TransparentMammoth

Parks & Recreation Master Plan Committee · 2026

Parks & Recreation Master Plan Committee

at 17:30

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Notable from this meeting

1 finding

Transcript

210 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

3:03 I will, all right, we will call our meeting to order. This is a meeting of the Parks and Recreation Master Plan Advisory Committee. Roll call, please, Jamie. Committee member Agnich. Yes. Committee member Bourne. Yes. Committee member O'Neill. Here. Committee member Rondanella is absent. Committee member Schaubmeyer is absent. Committee member Vanderhurst is absent. Committee member Weisner. Here. Vice chair Truex. Here. Chair Rice. Here.

3:34 Okay, we will begin with public comment. If a member of the public wishes to address us for anything that's not on the agenda, please come on up to the podium or raise your hand in Zoom. Anyone in the room? No one online? Okay, we will move on to the consent agenda, item 3.1, approve the minutes of the regular meeting of July 27, 2026. I would entertain a motion. I'll move to approve the minutes. All right, roll call please, Jamie. Yes.

4:14 Okay, we are on to item four, discussion items 4.1, Parks and Recreation Services, Fiscal Analysis, Presentation and Workshop. Great. So let me share my screen, which I've done. Let me see if I can actually make it bigger. Next magic trick we can perform today. At least this is better than the other time I did it for council. While Farrell's coming along, as you know, I've been working with our consultants, KTUA.

4:47 on our master plan update, and part of that work has been with 110%, which is Farrell here today. So what you're seeing is a little bit of the follow-up from that original presentation that Farrell made about kind of our guest services, recreation services, community benefit discussion, when we started to kind of rank and rate our service categories.

5:12 We spent some time with that little model. So we've kind of taken that to the next step. So what we're really presenting today is kind of more focused on where we go from there. So we'll kind of revisit those service categories, where we ended up, because I think you're all interested to see how it went from categories one to 11, how the team and how we all kind of collated and came together to formulate a strategy. We'll all talk about a little bit of how that's kind of rolled out at the end. There's some questions at the end of the...

5:41 The presentation today, really looking for input and feedback from the advisory committee as this moves along. So from this point we have one more presentation to make with you and that's on November 30 and that'll be the last meeting of our advisory committee. I know, so sad. So this is kind of that last opportunity to really kind of lean in on our kind of service financial sustainability strategy and model, really how we move forward, right? So we'll kind of revisit where we've been.

6:10 And then really looking at how we want to move forward. So that's kind of where we end up. So really looking for the Advisory Committee to kind of give us some direction that we can work with the Commission and with Town Council. So with that, I'd like to introduce Farrell, who's made it all the way from Colorado today. Yay! Welcome. Thank you. Thanks for having me. Do you want to turn on your microphone so everyone online can hear you? In person versus only on a little box.

6:34 So I'm excited to share with you today, I guess, some of the results that you helped put together and that we've been working on and then talk through some recommendations. And then most importantly, we have a couple of, I would say, big key questions that we just want to get your input on and your thoughts. If you have questions along the way, you're welcome to ask. I've broken this up into kind of three sections. So again,

7:00 This is just what we're doing today. We're looking at fiscal analysis and I'm going to walk you through again just a quick reminder of what the process was that we looked at because I know this isn't the only thing you think about. I'll show you the results of the strategies. Talk through some of the recommendations that we're looking at putting in the long-range plan. We also just went through some of them with staff and then again kind of go through a couple big questions for this group.

7:26 So as a reminder, 110% the company I get to work with, basically we're talking about how do we manage finite resources, so we've coined that Parks and Recreation Center. We know that Parks and Recreation has allocated a certain amount of money, and so yes, we will at times go back and ask for more, but we really want to make sure we're utilizing it in the best manner for the community currently. We can't just...

7:51 Again, just get more and more and more. There's only so much money to go around, so we want to make sure we're really intelligent and really create a good, sustainable plan with that. We'll always be looking at this from a couple of different lenses. One is the fiscal reality of what's happening in the town, and so we're looking high-level, big picture.

8:10 Next one. As well as the policy and the expectations. So one of the questions we're going to ask you tonight is kind of more on this practice or actually like policy discussion a little bit. But we want to blend those so that

8:22 Things can get implemented and plans can come to fruition. We also know that there's this idea all the time of balancing kind of the social service heart and the business acumen brain. Social service heart is why a lot of us get into public service and parks and recreation. We want to make things happen for people in the community. We want to say yes to really everyone all the time and we just can't. The business acumen brain says how do we take...

8:46 care of the people that we have. We don't want to price people out of the market. Also, how do we provide the quality that's expected here? How well do you provide the quality that's expected here by Mammoth Lake? Why we do education sessions and why we teach financial resiliency, we believe that educating staff, members of the community, elected leaders, whomever we can, really helps everybody create a more cohesive plan going forward.

9:18 As a reminder, the process that we've worked on with Mammoth Lakes staff, you all participated in one of the legs of the stool. This process, although we've completed it, we completed it across the U.S. by over, I don't know, two, three hundred organizations. Although we use the same process, everybody's results are different because there's no two towns the same. There's no two municipalities that operate exactly the same, so.

9:40 We've broken that into the three legs of the stool is what we call it. And each leg gets a lot of attention, if you will, to make sure that a strategy that's created is unique to your organization. So those three legs, the first one is called service categories, the second is beneficiary of service, and the third is cost of service. So I'll just spend a couple minutes again just walking through each of those, although you participated in the beneficiary of service specifically. So as a reminder what service categories are.

10:10 Service categories are how every class course event program facility is bucketed.

10:18 in the town of Mammoth Lakes. And so these have been bucketed where the purpose is the principal consideration of cataloging the service. So what you will see here is like three pictures. There might be considered an intro to fitness. It might be an intro to baseball. It might be an intro to pottery. Those would be bucketed the same because they're all beginner level or intro level classes. Why do we use it?

10:43 Why do we use service categories? There's three main reasons. One is we want to eliminate arbitrary goal setting and price setting. If somebody came up and said, well, why are you charging $50 for this class? We don't want to be like, we don't know because we charged $50 last year or because our neighbor's 50 miles away charged $50. We want to know exactly intentionally why is something.

11:04 That price. Why is that chosen? So we would not eliminate arbitrary price sitting. We also want to discourage attempts of cost recovery based on special interest or social value. If I said what's more important like kids that can swim or adults that are able to socialize and play bingo, that would be a very bad debate.

11:26 Debate to have. We would say they're both really important. People should be able to swim, and kids should learn to swim, and older adults or adults should be able to gather and create community. So we don't want to pit our own people and population of people against each other. And the third is that really when we do this type of bucketing programs, it starts to create more equity-based decisions. So we're not basing prices based on someone's demographic.

11:51 Age, background, things like that. We're really saying like, hey, let's be equitable and let's look at the purpose and let's be really intentional on where we want to spend taxpayer dollars and where we want people to recover costs on their own. So that's why things are in service categories. I'll show you all yours again in one second. Beneficiary of service is the second leg of that stool and basically this is the workshop where we came together and said, hey, here's the service categories that Mammoth Lakes team have identified and staff.

12:21 Let's rank those based on who's benefiting. And we use two key definitions. One is the community benefiting more. There's maybe a social good. And the second one is an individual benefiting more than the community. So for this example, you can see these are both aquatics programs, aquatics service area. But the kiddo is in a learn to swim. And then for this example, that young lady is in a master's level swim.

12:48 And when you go to the next one, what you'll see is they'll end up in different categories, even though they're both about swimming. Is CR the cost recovery? Yep. Okay. And currently, likely cost recovery for everything swimming is in the same bucket. And so the idea is when things start to get categorized this way, the category has the same bucket, but different categories will have different cost recovery level goals. So we would say with this, the beginner level activity.

13:17 That would have a different cost recovery goal at the end of the day than competitive level activity. And the definition and how that comes to fruition is like this, that the individual in the beginning level swimming class, no matter

13:34 who they are, there's more of a common good or more of a community-wide benefit. Maybe it's considered a must-have for this department to offer. Maybe it's considered universal value, access for all, everybody can learn to swim. And the individual in the master's level or competitive level swimming, they're receiving more benefit than the community as a whole. There's more of an individualized benefit. It might be considered more exclusive in nature. Maybe there's a higher level mastery of skill necessary to participate.

14:02 Why that's important is because programs and services that end up more towards common good and community good will have a higher subsidy level or a lower cost recovery level. Taxpayer dollars should be spent there. That's kind of the high-level expectation of community benefit. And the programs and services are more exclusive in nature, more individualized benefit. You'll see that those end up having a lower subsidy rate and a higher cost recovery, meaning if we had

14:30 Food and beverage and concessions at that end, you don't want to be spending your taxpayer dollars on my eating habits. You'd be like, you pay your own way. So that's the notion and that's kind of the strategy and the philosophy that we've been working with. The third leg of that stool is cost of service analysis and cost of service just analysis basically just says, what's the investment? How much does something cost, right? So we're not...

14:55 We're not judging it or putting a good or a bad label on it. When we do cost of service analysis, what we've done with staff and your team is we've looked at all direct costs, and those are costs that can be traced back directly to the provision of a service. So let's say there was no more summer camp being offered. That is not happening, but let's just pick that for a second.

15:20 You wouldn't have the cost of things like the supplies, part-time staff dollars, things like that, right? We also try to get our hands on all indirect costs. Indirect costs are things that that cost is going to be incurred with or without an exec program. So you're still paying Stu his full salary whether you offer summer camp or not, okay? And we take those indirect costs like...

15:43 A salary, we take that like facility cost, utility cost, anything we can get our hands on to say this is just the true cost of that service. And that's what we begin to analyze. Why it's kind of complicated in public parks and recreation is because departments offer hundreds, maybe even thousands of different programs. And so when you start to break apart direct costs, indirect costs, their shared costs, splicing and dicing, it just gets really complicated to understand.

16:13 What is the true investment of the playground versus a golf course versus a painting class, etc. So that's why we do cost of service analysis. We've created very specific tools to help identify how to show you and share with you and teach staff about what's happening. So moving forward and keeping with the trajectory of

16:41 Understanding all of those costs. We will look at the ranking and how you rank the programs and services, share out the costs and teach staff about how they might want to set cost recovery or subsidy level goals saying here's where you are, where do you need to get over two, three, five, ten years to have a financially resilient system and then staff have set cost recovery goals.

17:09 This is an example of a completed strategy. This is not yours, but I'll show you yours in a second. This is West University Place, Texas, and again, it's just an example to show you that their service categories are in that blue arrow. This is how they chose to rank them, and after working through their cost of service and cost recovery goals, these were the goals that they set for their organization. It has a strategy by it because this is a strategy that they believe is right for their organization.

17:39 So specifically in Mammoth Lakes, these are the results of some of that work. So service categories, these were the, I think there were 11. Yeah. So these are the service categories that Mammoth Lakes staff came up with. And so you'll see that there is a short title.

18:03 A brief definition, and then a handful of the classes that go into that category. In this order right here, they're simply in alphabetical order. Every single class that's offered is not meant to be listed, nor is it listed. The idea, though, is if I came on as a staff person and I was starting a new program, I would know exactly which category it should go into.

18:27 Specific to Beneficiary of Service. So once we did the workshop with you all, we also did the workshop with staff, and then we created a hybrid workshop. So there were three different models or tools created. This was the final model selected of how those programs and services were to be ranked from most common good or community-wide benefit to most exclusive or individualized in nature. And then third,

18:58 We did the cost of service analysis. And so in this example, I just pulled out this one graph. So if you're like, where'd that number come from? There's lots of tables. I know, I know. There's just this one image. But basically this is in the same order of that continuum that you just saw. So if you're like open access, essential life skills events, this is in that same order of continuum. So these are specifically just the current cost recovery.

19:29 percentages of what's happening in each category, and this was just from one fiscal year of data. So we call it like a snapshot in time, right? And it gives us a starting place of, okay, where might we want to go from here? So you can see the current cost recovery for each of these service categories in that column where it's around 23%, and then you can see what we've dropped in are the cost recovery goals for each category.

19:58 as a starting place and then you can see the variance from the goal based on this one year of data at the end of that continuum. I have a question for you. So I noticed in here I was a little surprised under the resale it has skate rentals which I guess I would have thought that that would have been in like the rentals and then just my other comment on this one is

20:25 Should our goal for resales be 100% cost recovery? Since, like you were saying, like, we shouldn't be paying for, you know, food and beverage that people consume? Sure. Right? Sure. Okay. Skate rental and skate aids. Yeah. Which would those both be under rentals? That's resale. Yeah.

20:51 Because aren't rentals more like facilities? So yeah, so for that specific, so it could be a titling thing, but rentals, we were really looking at facility rentals. And so they were like goods. Not like skate rental. Yeah, so goods and services. And so maybe it's like for purchase or use or something like that could be added to that. Yeah. And I think that's where a little bit of subsidy came in because if somebody really came ice skating and they really needed.

21:17 Would you allow for a little bit of subsidy for them to have a rental aid? Well, I think the cost of having skate rentals should mostly be covered by the rental fees throughout the year, but may not be, but the food concessions should definitely cover their costs. So that's where we started at 90%, and again, the idea is, and that's a good question, and where do we go from there? Yeah, philosophy, because you get to help pick that. All right, great. So yeah, thank you for paying attention. Not too far off that one, actually. That's about the highest limit we're so far at, right? 73 of 90.

21:47 Yeah. But you look at private lessons, I mean, you know, how do we want to address that? Yeah. Right? Classes, clinics, anyway, so there's lots of topics to talk about. And what we didn't show you, but what we do have access to is like inside of resale specifically, let's just pick like this skate aids, for example, that might already be at 100% cost recovery, right? So we know programs and services inside of each category are in a range. And so that might already be.

22:16 Or food and beverage might already be and the aids might be at 70%. So we might have picked like somewhere in the middle to be the goal. Okay. Yeah, the data tool will pick an exact point as a starting place. I have a question regarding the classes, clinics, workshops. Class recovery is 26%, but it's suggested to be 60%. So who's suggesting that?

22:45 The staff are. As well as some input from understanding how the tool works, understanding how you get somewhere over three to five years' time. So the following table is actually going to give you this little sliding benefit you saw up there, right? But Stu, do you find that fees for the programs are a deterrent for registration? Is price a deterrent? Is that what you're saying?

23:16 We haven't seen them because they're all selling out. You know, every workshop that we're doing is full, you know, all those products and services. So, definitely, you know, something that we're really interested to understand and that's kind of how we established, you know, this arbitrary cost recovery goal. Some have ranges, you know, you can certainly look at ranges and I think the strategy though is...

23:38 Okay, if this is kind of where your goal is, how do we think and what is kind of the strategy to get there? Is it, you know, one, two, three, five year, right? I mean, it's not something that we can just immediately go next year with a fee schedule. Double the price. Yeah, I ran some numbers on stuff and it's probably 500% to actually to get to a cost recovery goal. So what's realistic? For the community and Farrell's recommendations were great, did we just pick two or three and try to narrow in on those, you know, where we think we can kind of, you know, make some good gains?

24:07 I think the overall strategy and the philosophy is pretty broad. You know, we're currently at 23%, you know, of our cost recovery goal. So what do we think is realistic over the next, you know, two, three, five years? You know, is it 25, 30? And how do we get there? And what categories do we want to kind of tackle? And you're obviously, you know, looking at this, you're not going to tackle the ones on the lower end. You're really looking at tackling ones on the higher end, right? Which is more exclusive use, you know, more limited, you know, high cost of...

24:36 of providing that service so, you know, that the guests should pay more for that. So, but again, there's got to be a strategy. So you look at private lessons, that's a tough one. I mean, that's literally 500% increase to get to a full 100% cost recovery or actually just to 80%. And one of the things we haven't taught, well, I guess we've started to, but we're...

24:56 Kind of still in the middle of this part of the process is how do you get closer to a cost recovery goal with number one, not pricing everybody out of the market, right? And number two, continuing to offer the quality that's expected. And so there's about six or eight different strategies. So I'll just use a very simple one. Let's just say a class can take 20 people, but it's regularly operating at five people.

25:25 Like one strategy might be like put marketing efforts towards to get it to 20 people, right? So you haven't changed the price, but you get the class full. Instantly that adjusts the cost recovery. So we talk very specifically about some strategies once you identify, once we identify, but leaning on them first, where does it make sense to move the needle and what does it make sense to leave alone? The other things that are good for staff to know is

25:55 Again, costs will continue to increase. So if we're looking at adding something, are we adding something that's in private lessons and do we just price it where it needs to start if we're adding that versus trying to play catch up over time? Or maybe it's renting something different. Maybe there's a prime time and whatever. So it's just looking at those types of strategies. And I will also say there's always a huge caveat of continuing to

26:21 Support people financially that need financial support. There is a segment of the population of every population, but in your community as well. So this doesn't negate those types of practices or programs towards your current scholarshipping program or a reduced rate or some of those other types of amenities that, frankly, lots of people need these days at times. But I did want to make sure and share kind of like where we're at.

26:49 And then your current community benefit and investment strategy. This is specific to Mammoth Lakes with all that information pulled together is this is where we would identify as a possible starting place and working towards this strategy and these goals over about a three-year-ish time period. Some of the recommendations that we've come up with from

27:18 doing this financial analysis specific towards programs. I wanted to share with you all because these are still, I would say, in maybe a bit of a final draft form. We went through some staff today and we know there need to be some adjustments, which we're great with, but I also did want them to be a shock. So a couple of recommendations and things that we're looking at.

27:43 specific to this town are being mindful of the reliance on the general fund. We know the general fund will help support this department. It's meant to. But we want to make sure that that gap isn't increasing by this much. We want to be really mindful of what dollars are coming in, how the dollars are being utilized. Obviously, general fund dollars fund many departments in the town. Strategically implement some of the various funding strategies to reach those cost recovery goals. So I just talked about a couple of those.

28:12 And how do we do that intentionally and not just by picking and choosing and evaluating the recreation program menu and some operational practices. So we've been teaching staff some ideas around how do you evaluate current programs and new programs and what's being offered.

28:33 As the community shifts in expectation or some trends change, how do you move the ship and change with that? And then also, what are some operational practices internally that staff might want to consider that either create more efficiencies, help them do their jobs better, help tell actual qualitative and quantitative data sets together, so they'd even third-party partners or community residents that understand.

29:03 And then I went into an example of that recommendation so you could see what that might look like. So strategically implement various funding strategies to reach a desired cost recovery goal. And again, these are some of those examples, maximizing program participations, look at different pricing principles, and evaluate some of the partnership agreements. So it's like, if you're like, how would you get there? Here's some ways. It doesn't mean a price will never change on a program. But I think sometimes we see

29:31 a shift and we automatically assume there's only one answer to get there and we really want to make sure that we're clear that that isn't really the only option. Another thing that we've looked at specific to that recommendation of evaluating the recreation program menu, we've been teaching staff

29:53 This tool, it's called a Recreation Service Analysis Tool. This is an adapted version of the McMillan Matrix, and we've specifically adapted it for public parks and recreation systems or special recreation districts. We use it in some states. But the idea is that you would look at one program and you would say, does this align with the department's purpose, strong or weak, right? And it's like a big Plinko board if you...

30:19 Remember the prices, right? But stronger, weak, and you'd say, oh, that program is strong. Okay, what's its financial viability?

30:27 Is that strong or weak? Okay, it has good financial viability. What's its competitive position in the marketplace? Meaning, do we have the facilities? Do we have the staff? Do we have the quality? Do people want it? Is there a wait list? All those types of questions we teach staff to work through. Again, it goes one more layer. And then, are there alternative providers? And is that strong or weak? Meaning,

30:51 Are there private businesses that do this really well? If so, we don't want to compete with them and put them out of business? Or can somebody else support our efforts so we don't need to stand alone? That reduces duplication of service or duplication of resource? Or is this something the community is like, yes, please, and we needed to get whatever, and so you want to actually invest in it and really capture the marketplace?

31:17 I threw this in there because, like I said, there's three or four tools we've been working on teaching staff of how to utilize this from a philosophical standpoint. So I just think it's interesting to share sometimes. Really good because it gets down to the nitty-gritty bit, right? So we've got these recommendations and now what, right? How do we actually put these in place? And this was a really good tool. Farrell just introduced this to us about two, three weeks ago to our team and we did one exercise.

31:45 We did hockey, which was like, okay, straight down over to, you know, strong, strong, strong, strong, strong, but then he picked some other ones and noticed that there were some other competitive, you know, sets or other providers and, you know, it kind of changes your position. So how should we, you know, strategize that product and service? So really the goal we talked about today is doing a service analysis really on all our products and services, which is pretty daunting. Certainly for a new product. Just the first time. Yeah. Just kidding.

32:14 The first year is our work program is kind of done. But for any new product and service that we bring forward, just a great way to kind of, you know, work this filter through that product and service, right? So, you know, I think all these tools and tactics, I think, will really help our department, you know, move forward in a more thoughtful, intentional way, I think, is what we're trying to get to here. I like the objectivity of this because I think it helps me. Because I think that, you know, it's really easy to make sort of more emotional.

32:44 more subjective decisions around Parks and Rec programming, so it's so cool. That was one of the first comments the staff person made when we were going to say, I'm glad to have a way to evaluate stuff without all the emotion, like, because usually we each love our own programs, and that's a great start, but we also need to have a consistent way to look at it, and then make a really intentional decision, so.

33:08 I just kind of had a question with like the private lessons. I don't know if you want to keep going forward or is this can we start chatting about it? Okay. You don't have to go back on the slide. Okay. My personal experience, you know, like the private lessons, does that include semi-private lessons also? Because I know, you know, at Whitmore we do swim lessons, like semi-private lessons and then

33:37 From my experience, the very beginner learn to swim lessons are completely full. Group lessons. Group lessons, completely full. And then once your kid is, you know, a tiny bit water safe, and then they're doing like, you have like levels one, two, three, and four. You know, I guess I don't see those as it's competitive. It's still like kids learning how to swim. Water safety, right? Yeah. So like, I guess my question is,

34:05 Does that fall, like, things like that, where it's like, it's a private lesson or a semi-private lesson, learning how to ice skate or learning how to swim, you know, I, um... So if it's like one or two people, generally, that would fall into that private category. So saying like, this individual is fully benefiting right now at getting better at this, but the class grades, like one, two, three, like those, those would be in like classes, camps, whatever, because, um,

34:35 It's open to everyone. Anybody can technically get to one to two to three based on their movement. So the private lessons do not include like semi-private lessons where it's... If it's like two people, then yes. For them, they have private and semi-private in there.

34:50 It's a bit squishy at the pool because it's not a good example, right? Groups are small anyway, right? Small groups would kind of stay in the classes. But if it's semi-private, I feel like there are different names for it, but I'm just wondering, for me, it just kind of helps solidify how we're separating that. Do you mean like you're requesting with another family?

35:13 To have these four, only these four children in the event? Or are you going to a group lesson and there's only four kids there? That's open to everyone. Well, I don't know how we market it now. When my kids were little, it was semi-private lessons where it was three kids with a teacher or something like that. Which is a group kind of class. That's a group class. If you intentionally call up and say, I want just a private with my child. Right.

35:42 Just how they're labeled on there. Yes. So I just wanted to like clarify which one that would be. Pretty much all our swim products I think are all kind of class lessons. Unless it's like a one-on-one. Exactly. I'm trying to get better at the butterfly. I want to do it with just these people. With Leah or with that instructor that I had the other day. And it's almost the same for ice skating too with Brooke and she did a lot of privates after those lessons as well. So they're very narrow, right? Yeah. So it's the traditional, you know, ski instructor lesson, you know, private one-on-one.

36:11 You get a semi-private if no one turns up. Exactly. You get a semi-private. If it's a class, yeah. Then you still get the class cut. Yeah, you still get the class cut. It's offered as a class and you pay a class fee. I just wanted to kind of ask that question. Okay. However, to clarify, wouldn't those swim lessons at a young age or at a young, low ability

36:35 Needing a small group because they're not water safe, isn't that in the life skills category and not... Yes, for swimming, I mean, most of those are actually in essential life skills. Unlike for ice skating. Water safety. I mean, that's why we intentionally, you know, minimize the cost recovery goal on that, right? Because it's really... So swim lessons would be... Like, that's where I feel like it's not quite clear to me, like, where all of our products fall on this slide. I would probably put private lessons in the ice skating and you'd probably put swim lessons in essential life skills unless they were...

37:05 A direct private lesson where you called up and said, I want to have Ben for that one hour. Okay. And that's what they were saying is that one product or one service could go across many.

37:17 So how do we categorize that to like know where it falls? Or like adult swim, like a private adult, like stroke improvement versus basic skills would probably fall into them. That would be in a class clinic and workshop, right? That's Brian's. Yeah, but sometimes instructors do privates too. Exactly. Yeah, Brian would too.

37:37 Okay. Thank you for clarifying that. You have the option. But I guess that's the big lift is to go through every single product that we have or offer and go, okay, that one gets the 60% recovery, this one gets the 0%, this one gets that. Even though it's all swimming, we're going to go and tag that 60% on that because we believe it falls into this. And that, good luck.

38:04 Yeah. So one of the things, so staff have been the ones, you know, picking, and again, it's like a starting place to go, okay, let's analyze where it is. If we make some adjustments or we put effort towards these class, let's analyze again. We said regular, so it might be every two years, it might be every three years. The other tool that staff will have access to is actually a program pricing tool, if you will, where we'll pull

38:33 the category that they have chosen so they know where a class started because you have to doesn't mean it will never change but you have to know where you what you've started with when you've analyzed it to have the cleanest picture of data and then it will pull in the direct and indirect they'll put how many hours they'll put that and so basically the pricing tool will then work with staff to say if you want to be at 50% cost recovery you either need five people at ten dollars

38:59 Or you need 10 people at $5, right? And so it helps them start to get in range over that three years, as well as if they're creating new programs or shifting programs, how do we start in that market and make sure it's feasible for people to financially be able to participate in programs?

39:19 It's not very different than Ski School, which is Ben's bringing up his point. That's the class size. Well, it's the same as the ski and snowboard team. You've got to start with the ratio that gives you a yield that pays everyone that does this, but this product is...

39:34 Have a higher level of service, so there's more cost, it's the same. Going into, yeah. Can I steal your tool? Yeah. We'll analyze your data too. It would work though. You could probably adapt some of it or have some stuff. Yeah, yeah. No, I'm joking. No, I know. I'm just saying like even for places that end up needing to operate more on an enterprise fund matrix, at times there's a golf course or there's a water park or something like that. They're at least able to take the bones of it and you can do.

40:03 If you have time, you can do the work yourself. You know what I mean? And so it's like, then it's a way to help justify like, why is this program this and this? It's like, well, this is a feeder to that. We really want to be in the whatever business. So those are, that's kind of a starting place of where we are. And then a couple of questions that we wanted to put forward with your knowledge. And I know you've met with Marina and Jacob and you've looked at different pieces of,

40:34 of programming is just, this was the first question, this is the easy one, but the idea is the Parks and Recreation Department's current core services are listed as this, so youth and teen, which is camps and programs, adult programs, community recreation center programs, community events, facility operations and maintenance, and so we were talking about, and Stu was talking about this idea, is there a need to change or adjust these as?

41:02 The focal points for core services that the department is expected to operate as we move into the future, right? Nothing will change tomorrow. I guess my comment would be, do we need a separate category that's like active adults? That's what I was going to ask. What is the definition of adult programs? Is it like 18 to...

41:26 Currently, currently, yes, we just, we were talking about that earlier with staff. It's currently not segregated, it's just fully inclusive that people can come and participate at any age plus. I guess my question would be back to what we were talking about with the different labels. Yeah, service categories. Yeah, the service categories. Will there be...

41:53 A document created that will outline all those for us to review, to look at and go, okay, that makes sense, that kind of thing, because to your point is like, okay, where does the group lesson sit? Are you comfortable with that being that? Or where does the private sit? Where does an adult tennis lesson versus a youth tennis lesson? What percentage?

42:20 of recovery we'll be putting on each one of these topics so that everyone can review and go, well, that makes sense. I don't know, is that something, is that a part of the process obviously? I don't know. I would say the part of the process that we would like from this group is like, I think the first question in zooming out would be like, does the use of dollars make sense in this fashion where dollars spent more on the community as a whole?

42:52 Versus dollars so more as an individual. I would say, I would almost zoom out before we're like, exactly where did that program go because what's going to happen to it? I would almost zoom back out and be like, does that make sense philosophically that you were like, yes, I can bless or I can thumbs up that this is the direction that the town's Parks and Recreation Department needs to go because we don't have...

43:18 We want to live within our means. We also want to maybe improve quality in some things, right? Or we also want to see some things shift down the road. I think that's kind of the first high-level question. Yeah, it's good when I read forward before I can see the other two questions later on. Oh, yeah. Yeah, so I think that's kind of where it's going, but it's like...

43:42 We were asking this first, more of like zooming in, did these categories, did these core service areas make sense? Does there need to be something that's more specific to an age population, right? Or is this still working in Mammoth Lakes? I don't know that, we don't be the ones to say we know that answer. My question is, do we need like number three, community recreation center programs? Yeah.

44:11 That, I mean, I would feel like all of the programs that take place there, don't those either fall under, like, youth and teen camps and programs or adult programming or community events? Yeah, they all, there's a lot of, there's a lot of crossover. Yeah. Do we need a number three or?

44:27 Yeah, no, you go. Well, I would say that I think that if you are keeping the CRC programs there, I realize it's not online yet, but you probably either need to specifically call out the MAC or have something in there about arts and culture because arts and culture is going to become, is really a core service of your part now. I don't have an answer to this question either. Yeah, we don't preload it, but I think all three of those comments, four of those comments are very poignant. I don't think splitting.

44:55 these topics to then like drill into them more is beneficial but like adding the MAC or whatever else we do down the line would be you know another line item to add but splitting adult programs to be active adults or seniors or whatever I don't think really

45:19 helps the process. Do you think this community is looking for something that's more specific for not just 18 plus or 16 plus? I don't understand your question. Can you say it again? Like active adults or older adults or 50 plus or something that's really specific or keeping it open? I think adult programs is so general. Okay. And I think there is

45:50 Room for improvement in programming for an older program. Do you think it deters people from participating? Having it totally open? If it just says adult programs versus active adult or older adult? No. Or senior. Ooh. See, it did. That's her mom. She's like undeterred. It did, yeah. Currently it doesn't, but maybe there's more specialty. That's 80 plus right now. For all of us, 50 plus, I'll just say. Yeah. Okay.

46:22 I mean, I do think, I mean, I think there's a pretty big trend away from, you know, calling anything senior programs, because nobody wants, you know, people don't want to place them in that, but at the same time, I mean, Pat's probably not going to play in, like, the soccer league. I mean, I wouldn't play in that, right? It's pretty intense, so. But if there was a soccer league that said 65 plus, you might jump in under the adult programs. So, adult, click adult programs, because I'm an adult.

46:51 And then I go down, oh, soccer, oh, they have a 65 plus, I'm 65 plus, I might go and check that out. Sure. You know, does it, do we need the active adults or, you know, that's, to me, just, to the point, like, is it stopping anyone that you've heard clicking to find these activities and are these activities being used underneath that adult thing is the question. I haven't heard anything in my...

47:21 World that it's turning people off? Well, that's a very good point. Possibly, too, some of the programs that are being offered at that level, yeah, you're right, adult softball, for example, maybe if there was a league that was at a certain age level, it might be more enticing. Like hockey has an adult, an elderly, you know, 40-year-old.

47:49 Hockey programs sometimes, right? Or soccer, I know. My friends at home in Australia, they play in specific age groups, but they've got a really big demographic and a big community to use. I mean, we will struggle putting something like that together. I was just curious. We talked about that earlier today with the staff. That's why I was asking. I was like, oh, that's a comment to ask. We're kind of fascinated about this. It seems like a really innocuous question, but it's depth-y because, you know, should you now look at this from a service category point of view and say, well,

48:21 We've got 11 service categories. We've got this kind of, you know, hierarchy that we're prioritizing or, you know, cost recovery or, you know, however you want to play it. So how should these relate with kind of our core services? How should we structure the department to make sure that we're, you know, meeting the needs that we're kind of saying here? Should we all, you know, align with, you know, general to, you know, how do we, yeah, I'm just, it's a really open-ended question with all this coming forward.

48:48 I'm just fascinated because basically this right now is aligned with each of our supervisors, right? So each of these responsibility is a person, you know, delivering that program and service, so to speak, right? And community events is kind of blended. But that's how we've structured it. So I'm really just, you know, here we are at kind of a crossroads. But I guess I feel like the first part of your presentation, you're saying we're moving away from this, from categorizing it, and we're looking more at the other graph so that it's... This one?

49:19 Yeah, that we're moving towards that graph and we're moving away from this. Yeah, so that's kind of my question. Should we start to structure our core services on this? Well, I guess that's what I was asking. More than that, right? Yeah, I was asking, like, well, what are the... What's the relevance of this now versus what we're doing? Oh, yeah. I don't know, does the core services, these five things, in the end, become... I can't read it from there, but...

49:46 So it becomes that line, you know, and whatever the titles are in there is events, camps, all of these things. So within those for, well, if I look at camps, you could have camps as youth and teens. You can have adult camps. You could have camps at the CRC. Community events could happen.

50:12 No, you wouldn't do a camp on that, but facilities and operations, those two kind of stay away, but these three seem to me to go in all, in a lot of different spots of open play, dropping reg, you know, all this now, so like you're saying, like, do we now look at it that these are our categories that we focus on and within them, they have subgroups that service those three groups that we

50:41 They're at the top of that list. But you're saying these are your department, you like have Doug is in charge of youth team camps and programs, you have someone else for adult programs, you have someone else for the CRC. And staff would keep those responsibilities. So we would say these are like service areas. So a service area is typically like a sport of this or this. These are the service areas that we would say Mammoth Lakes has continued to focus on as a priority, those five.

51:10 So staff would still have those responsibilities. It's like, but is there any service area that should receive more focus or breakout? And then a second question in this thing is like, and then getting your thoughts and opinions on moving towards the next, we would call it the next layer down of depth into the categorization of how dollars are allocated. Yeah, so arts and culture need to be added to this list? Yeah, I would think so, absolutely. And I think possibly, yeah.

51:37 50 plus or I don't know whatever we came up for names or something. Active adults? Active adults, yeah. Something like that. I kind of agree with Amanda what she was saying though for the Community Rec Center programs. Those kind of fall into these other categories. So do you still need that as a call out? It's not clear cut by any means, is it? Because you've got a supervisor that's managing hockey programs that happens in LA Kings and you've got Doug overseeing kind of their camps in that facility as well.

52:07 Yeah, there's always going to be that crossover, so that's the question, you know, posed to the group. How do we really align those service areas, which I kind of like, with the categories, with our kind of priority and with the responsibilities? It's not clear-cut and it's hard to be clear-cut, but... Am I missing it that we're trying to more... We're more talking about cost recovery at this time, more than putting someone in charge of...

52:35 Yeah, one specific. Service delivery, maybe you just start there. So, yeah. So, delivering those services, you know, does this still make sense? And then we can kind of weigh into cost recovery because they'll own that cost recovery because it's a product. Oh, but see, that's, to me, it seems like a funny way, like, I wouldn't, sorry, I'd take that, but the way when I work at Mammoth, I'm running the teams, but I'm also working.

53:02 And executing camps and competitions, which is with another department with another team. And so I don't have any cost. I don't make any money off that. But I'm a big part of that. It's like my thing. But the money all rolls up into one area. And it's like, OK, there's three different departments working together in multiple different areas to then roll up to the good of the business. But, you know, it's the little thing.

53:31 Does it have to be so vertical? Does everyone have to own a vertical and that vertical then can't cross pollinate? I'm getting a little confused on it. Just on how you describe that, what comes to mind, which may not be totally spot on, but is like you're already doing the grid. If you did this for just, you would do that. But when you add like,

54:02 So many different types of programs and services, right? Not just, I'm not saying just ski, but one, more intentionally, and you have like 12 to 15, and then you have 25 different staff doing them. It's making sure that there's some framework so that staff understand we are all doing this for the greater of the good.

54:27 I can't only grow this area where everything is 100% subsidized, like we talked about that today. We might not only be able to grow essential life skills if we don't grow at all competitive level, right? Like there might have to be a balance at some point of striking of where we're investing some time and resource because otherwise we can't only grow all the items that are subsidized 60 to 80% or we won't be able to help.

54:55 Right? We'll need too much from the general fund. So I think it's like taking that and maximizing it if you had... And you're saying, Stu, that you want someone in charge of that revenue recovery and labeled to that specific... Like everybody having buy-in of parts of it, no matter which area they oversee. For the sake of specifics, like the aquatics, the pool stuff.

55:25 is probably the one that spans them up. So right now I'd imagine that Whitmore is under facility operations maintenance in this core service? It's an adult person. It would be under four of them. It would be under youth, adult programs, community events, and number five. Is there like a person? Oh, is there a person that oversees facility ops and maintenance? Because like you have CRC up there. And so like if it like

55:52 Probably there's a person for Whitmore and they're going to have general access across the street from the pool. They're going to have essential life skills, events, camps, open play, drop-in, like every single one of these is going to be represented. But I like the idea of offering it as core services and having a philosophy behind it, even though it's getting managed by multiple people. Yeah, multiple people are managing those, which would be more common.

56:19 And you can see why things are costing, what they're costing, and where you can develop even within like one facility, for example. Interesting. I see it more as like an accountability, like you're saying, I see it more as like an accountability framework because, for example, like the guys who are doing parks maintenance, like they're going to maintain the facilities.

56:42 Regardless, I mean, maybe they'll, you know, try to do it in a cost-effective manner, but to some extent, they're not going to have much control on the cost recovery side compared to programming staff. Sure, absolutely. Yeah, because three and five, you know, someone's running a community recreation center, they're doing programming and they're doing the operations of it, right? So there's kind of that split there too, and aquatics, right? So someone's operating it.

57:06 As well as programming it, and they've got adult, they've got youth, and they've also got facility operations and community events, like you said. So there's, you know. So I kind of like, yeah, core services above, like, the service areas, right? I think this is kind of our general philosophical statement about how the Parks and Recreation Department's, you know, working through these core services, and then you're drilling down into the service areas, service categories, and then you just kind of keep drilling down like the Planko model, right? You just keep going down and down and down, but there's got to be some.

57:35 And that's where you decide. Some other side. Which on the graph they, sorry. Turn it off because we've got two microphones. You can get reverb. Don't turn your mic on. Eventually you have to go, blinko, blinko. Here's my product. That's right. 60% is what I want to take back on that and zero is back on that. And so these things adding the, this is more like your, what are we?

58:03 What do we care about and what do we want to do in a big, big, big what? I'm not seeing anybody jump in and be like, oh my god, what are you doing? Why should you change? It seems like we're just going to add arts and culture. I think so, possibly active adults. And maybe that's just like adult programs or just a subcategory. I also think too, because...

58:26 Your department is so community-facing and, you know, when Pat and I were on the Rec Commission, you know, we were having to be such strong advocates for the Parks and Rec Department. I think the community understands what these core services are. I don't know that the community will really understand. Right, the next layer down? Yeah. Yeah, I agree. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Once you get into the service category and those definitions. I will say, like, you know, the core services, as I'm hearing everyone talking, it's also...

58:53 How do our core services find synergy in helping one another, minimizing cost, having other areas of expansion of growth? So, I mean, like, for, like, the swimming pool, right, the lane lines, you know, they're purchased for both, you know, youth and teen and adult programs and community events and they're part of the field city of these operations, hockey, right, the net systems that we put into place. We're using them on multiple levels, so.

59:20 Taking our core services and seeing how we can basically double, triple dip. And to me, it seems like the facilities operations maintenance is really kind of like in so many capacities, right? They're like maintaining everything to keep it at a high level and they're constantly going back to those people. Is this of high enough value or quality so that we can grow the programs, right? So they kind of all put, I'm seeing this all as like pushing and pulling, you know, all at the same time constantly.

59:50 Not so much more of, you know, I don't know if it makes sense, like one, two, three, four, five. I mean, it seems very linear. More of, you know, like Stu is doing like the circle, you know, and like this is all supporting each other. You can't really have one of these without the other. And I think kind of going one through five kind of, it might limit people's ability to see this as youth and teen camps and programs do support adults and the adult programs do.

1:00:19 You know, support the teen and youth. And all of these things, they all engage one another. And if you lose one component, I think overall, the whole system feels the stress. It's not just, oh, I lost my pinky. It's, no, you're going to feel that, you know, for a while. So it's, it behooves our community to have all of these components that are then, you know, working together. Okay, brilliant. All right, here's the next.

1:00:54 Here's your next question. I know there's a lot of words on here. I know, but... Well, I just wanted to give it all to you so you could read it, but... So the department currently relies heavily on the town's general fund, which provides approximately 77% of its funding. So that's all direct and indirect. Looking ahead, does this advisory committee believe the department should become more financially self-re...

1:01:20 So that's the question, but then before you answer, we'd like you to kind of know what you would be saying. So if the advisory committee supports greater financial self-reliance, the department will strategically develop and implement the new pricing strategy aligned with the beneficiary of service model. So that's this.

1:01:46 This will require policy direction and support from both the commission and the town council, including a thoughtful implementation timeline and clearly defined cost recovery objectives. If the advisory committee prefers to maintain the current approach to general fund support and does not support increased reliance on the department generated revenue, the department should anticipate increasing limitations on the number and level of programs and services it can provide.

1:02:14 As operating costs will continue to rise against relatively flat revenues, so maintaining the current service portfolio and service levels will become increasingly difficult. So just like take a deep breath. Well I guess the question is obviously what's the town's general fund going to look like in the next five to ten years and if you really want to have something that's going to last forever it has to support itself.

1:02:45 Is my thought. So, you know, my, and that's going down to the nets and the thing and then the plinker of the program and okay, this program's not doing what it should be doing. We should get rid of that and support this one a little bit more or create a new one to replace it. Like it has to be, in the end, there has to be a goal of it supporting itself, right? Right.

1:03:10 Yeah, my thoughts on this is that direct costs should absolutely be covered, but indirect costs, I think that the general fund should pick up some of those indirect costs, like Stu's salary, you know, and some maintenance, and I mean, I feel like it's the town's job to provide parks, free parks, and, you know, so some of those, I believe that some of those indirect costs should not be

1:03:39 You know, kind of passed along to different programming. Okay. But, you know, like the direct cost of having the swim instructor there should be passed along to someone in a private lesson. Okay. Yeah. It's kind of interesting, I mean, the facilities, you know, the certain staffing that you have, right, those are kind of sunk costs in like an economic sense, right?

1:04:07 Reading this a couple days ago, the first thing that popped in my head is like really what's the opportunity cost of going one way or the other? What are we giving up by staying at around 77? Also in the past, has it been traditionally 77%? Have we kind of been on an uptick, downtick? Has it been flat? But the biggest question for me is if we did devise a plan to

1:04:29 Increase or decrease, like what is the community really getting for that? So if there's continued subsidy and it goes up to 78, 79, what are we missing out on from the town that we either can't develop or we have to push those development plans out, right, to kind of save more money in the long run and then vice versa. If we...

1:04:52 Use less of our general fund dollars. What could the town do with that in the short and the long term, right? So that opportunity cost is one thing that would be very interesting to help at least myself answer this question as to which way it goes. But with the facilities and some of those sunk costs, I agree with Amanda, right? Those, in a way, are mostly built by, sustained by the town.

1:05:20 But then some of those other aspects, right? Just have to kind of figure out how you guys are categorizing everything as you guys move forward. So do you view the strategy, so when you say sum direct and indirect, do you view this strategy as a solution to that? So if we're at 20%, we're subsidizing 80%, so essentially that would likely be a lot of the indirect.

1:05:43 Yeah. Or does that not quite fit your model? Like, I guess my question is, you know, like for swim lessons. Sure. You know, I don't think that we should, for basic life-saving swim lessons, I don't think that we should be putting any of those dollars that the member of the public is paying into maintaining the swim facility. Like, I feel like, I think that, I mean, and I think it makes more sense like with parks, like Shady Rest Park. If we had absolutely no programming going on there,

1:06:12 The town would still be responsible for maintaining and operating the park. So I don't think that those indirect costs should be passed along to the programming per se. But, you know, if the town is doing a soccer camp, you know, the direct costs of the coach and the insurance for that, you know, that should be passed along to the program participants, but we shouldn't be passing along.

1:06:36 Like, that's where I kind of feel like I'm not exactly sure of your indirect costs, how much of that is getting passed along. Like, Stu's salary should not be passed along to the, you know, soccer participants. But, you know, like, the cost of their uniforms should be passed along. Those are kind of my thoughts, is that we have a general responsibility in providing parks to residents.

1:07:00 Those should not factor in. We would agree. Yeah. Okay, good. But, I mean, you're currently subsidizing parks essentially, right, about just over a million dollars, right? Which this philosophy or we would say that is exactly... Parks aren't supposed to make money. Yeah, exactly what general fund dollars should be doing is subsidizing, right? That's a quality of life thing. We would put that in, like, that's a quality of life expectation.

1:07:33 Nobody else is going to come in and run that business. No private business is going to be like, hey, I want to be in the playground business, right? Like, that's not going to happen. So that is an expectation that does enhance the quality of life and thus supports some of the other reasons why people live here, have their business here, want to play here. So, okay, that's good. I think your guys' comments were great, and I'm back to what you're saying. It's just like more information would be...

1:08:01 It'd make it easier to go with the direction of where we're at, you know what I mean? Like what is being subsidized? I guess we see it in our meetings and things like that, but it might help to make everyone have more info. It's not adding that information, that data, right? Yeah, like programming should support itself. We should be able to pay all the coaches and all the people who turn up to it and all that, but the CRC should...

1:08:28 Pay for some of it through its programming, but what is the percentage? Yeah, what is the percentage of that? Well, to piggyback on Casey's, it would be nice to see the trend of the Parks and Rec budget and then what percentage of the general fund are we eating at this point, you know, like if it's significant or not, right?

1:08:56 Yeah, I mean, looking at your cost of service, is that page 26, the slide? You know, it's hard for me, you know, the prices and things on there is the essential life skills. I mean, my kids did swim lessons. There's like five kids or six kids in a swim lesson, and it's 30 minutes. And, you know, the price that you pay, I feel like there's, it's surprising to me that it's saying only a 14% cost recovery. Like, I feel like.

1:09:27 The actual direct cost is the person that I'm paying to be in the pool with my kid. And I think that this chart would look different if it were only direct costs on there. So I feel like it's a little hard. You know, I think that there's some things on here that we could all agree, like resales should be covered 100%. But, you know, I don't know. I feel like I want everything. I don't want to.

1:09:56 I don't want to skimp on, you know, it's like I don't want to charge more and then price people out and, you know, I don't know, like the two choices on this last thing, I feel like I don't ever expect the Parks and Recreation Department to be 100% self-reliant, you know, there's, and some of those things should be self-reliant, like a private ice skating lesson should cover the cost of

1:10:25 Whoever's providing the lesson, but it shouldn't, it shouldn't, you know, have a very large facility use fee that's collected that's going to pay off the electricity for the month. Yeah, yeah. So just so you know how the tool works, I know you haven't seen it, but so let's take that. That's a great example. So basically what happens is it's like, okay, what's the total facility cost for the ice rink? Let's just say it's $100,000. And so it's like, okay, how many programs are in there? Let's say there's 100.

1:10:52 And then how many hours does each program get, right? And then which ones are to which category? So it subdivides based on total percent use of time based on the number of hours something is used or rented. Is it 100%, 100% accurate? No, it's as good as the data that we have. So if we have great data.

1:11:15 We're probably at 90 to 95%, right? Because staff are making some of these decisions. Stu, exactly how do you spend 100% of your time? And he's like, well, I spend 60% in parks, hypothetically. So 60% of the dollars goes to that. Then there's only 40% left to go to 400 programs, hypothetically. So what's really great about this whole conversation is understanding that it's like, how do we look at

1:11:46 I think total general fund, what's coming in and what actually is going towards Parks and Recreation, which is easy to grasp and to pull in part of this conversation because then we're looking at programs, but we also start to then zoom out and look at like, okay, what if a new facility comes online and now we're trying to operate, let's just say hypothetically, a new pool, right? Because that's been brought up by the community. It's like, okay, well, a new pool is 30 million to build.

1:12:16 Do residents want to pay that? And are they also then willing to adopt, it's going to cost $1.5 million to operate? So that would be added to it. So will people be willing to say yes to that? So we try to like, this is micro, but then we try to zoom out and zoom out and zoom out to be, is this realistic for Mammoth Lakes and are people willing to pay X amount to build it and maintain and operate it for 50 years, right? Or is there any deferred maintenance in this town?

1:12:45 in anywhere in Parks and Recreation that you wish the quality was better, right, from a, not that they're not doing a good job, but just the quality of what's offered, because if we keep adding more to programs and services only, then how do we close that gap between maintenance, frankly, right? So that's where we like, yes, we take this and we ask you all really hard questions because these are really hard decisions. It's not meant to be an easy answer.

1:13:15 So then as we zoom out, zoom out, zoom out and start to put together a 10-year plan, what is the direction that you all think is good for the town? Yeah, and I guess I had a really small way, I guess I was thinking of it completely in the wrong way, I guess, because I would just assume that Stu and his team is part of the general fund, like as a given.

1:13:39 Like, I would just assume that that's how most towns operate, is that town staff is paid by town general fund. But then when we start to go down into facilities, then facilities and services should start to somewhat support themselves.

1:14:00 What is the plan for the general fund? What is earmarked every year? Will that increase? Or like you're saying, does it go up and down? Historically, has it always been that percentage? Can we rely on that percentage of the general fund for the future? And if that general fund is going to grow, then does our percentage go down? Is it just a dollar amount? Or is there a percentage each year? Because if you're going to do a 10-year business plan, you have to...

1:14:27 Figure all those numbers out, right? So that's where I was thinking about wrong. I don't think you're looking at it wrong. I don't think you're looking at it wrong at all. But it was just like, I was achieving a lot of things and then you brought it up and you're like, oh no, this should be paid for. And then, well, if we're going to support, it's like, no, no, I don't think Parks and Rec.

1:14:48 Yeah. As Parks and Rec should ever be a business that's, I think it's, it won't be, I promise this department will never make money. I promise this department will never make money. I'm just giving my opinion is that it's a community service, it's part of government, whatever it is, but like when we start to look at what we're doing right now, and again, I'm giving my two cents and everyone gets to this, but it's like, well, look at CRC.

1:15:14 the camps that we do, and then if we bring another place online, I think the strategy should be that it covers whatever the general fund

1:15:25 We need to know what the general fund is going to be. We don't know what it's going to be, but we know on average what it could be, and we can make an estimation of what we're going to get, and that would be a really good place to start to look at, and then I was drilling way too deep into the 60% recovery, the 0% recovery, because that's where I'm like, oh, where's that sheet? I want to see what we're doing now and what we're trying to recover, and I'm seeing these numbers here, but like...

1:15:53 What does that mean? And then, like, okay, how do we adjust to make things work better to, you know, I'm sorry. I'm getting a little bit too far ahead. It seems to me that staff is already heading in the direction of making changes to minimize that gap. And years ago when I was on the commission, I just remember some of the fees for classes were just

1:16:21 You know, so nominal. Right. That you've really made huge strides in that area. And it looks like with some of these recommendations for cost recovery, you're going to even increase that more. Yeah, some are already there too, right? Yeah. I'm a little concerned though about the MAC and then how, I mean, that could just throw everything out of whack. Or it might just make your budget look, you know, so much greater.

1:16:49 And maybe the fees or revenues not as much. For the direct and indirect, are we including any sort of life cycle analysis on these facilities? Are we having any of that going into this? Or is this purely year in, year out operational? Because just trying to think of what the goal could be, right? That we don't necessarily always have to go out to the community or find some other bonding.

1:17:19 to do something or say replace the hockey arena in 50 years, right? Because everything at some point is going to have to get replaced. Is there any pricing or cost analysis that's been going into this? So like we know like, hey, every year we're trying to capture quarter to 1% of the value just to like squirrel it away for the future or something. Or are we kind of just going, hey, we're trying to minimize cost, increase

1:17:49 Participation in our community, and when it comes up, we'll just have to be really aggressive with grant funding, you know, going out grant hunting, I should say. I just didn't know if any of that was built into this, or if this is purely kind of like operational. We didn't, but that's a great awareness. We don't do that in the specific cost of service analysis. However, what we do start to say is, yeah, what is that life cycle, and what are additional other funding strategies?

1:18:20 Hypothetically, if several of these were above 100%, which we've seen in other communities, the idea is that those programs and services start to reinvest into themselves, and then if there's any dollars captured that goes into capital, it might be a sinking fund, right? Or it might be a match fund or things like that. We know in the state of California, your ability to actually make money is illegal, so don't worry, you won't be. But...

1:18:47 I think there's a real awareness of like how do we take care of it to the quality that this community expects for 50 years. It's a more sustainable asset management plan right now ad hoc. All of the deferred maintenance, all that planned maintenance that we've been putting in over the last 10 years is just from our budget, what's available.

1:19:08 Is there overage in TOT? What makes the most sense gets kind of put through that CIP process and we start to allocate funds like the latest CIP. Right. It's got funds in there over the next five years, but it's not kind of assigned to anything. Yeah. You know, one of those projects is going to be the Whitmore Track, right? That was built in 212.

1:19:28 You know, we know that surface and that track is going to need to be replaced. So, you know, how are we going to slot that into the future, right? And what is that commitment? And how are we going to fund that, right? So, yeah, all of these are constantly being played out. But I think Farrell answered your question straight away. We're not including any of that in any of this direct-indirect cost analysis, right? It's just the program and the service. Perfect. Thank you. Stu, do you know what percentage of enrollment in programs is?

1:19:55 Resident versus non-resident? For camps, we do. Yeah. Don't have the top of mind. Because maybe that's more of an argument that some of those monies that are servicing, you know, people outside of the community. Yeah. We'll know that information in October when we present to the commission again, so we kind of have those statistics. We kind of pull them up every year. Doug just runs that on zip code, right? So we just, that's it. That's all we can really use, but we haven't dug into it. And that's such a tough one, too, and to turn now.

1:20:26 So resident versus non-resident and how you determine that it's really and also when you consider how much I mean that general fund money is primary I mean most of the town's general fund comes from visitors so that's why I'm really struggling with this question for two reasons and one I think you know from this conversation it's pretty clear that it's not really just going to be black and white and maybe you know

1:20:50 In terms of the cost recovery, you know, what is the, you know, what is the town's general fund obliged to pay for? But there's two issues. One, our general fund, because it is so, you know, it's not static, it's not like it's just from property tax, and so it's really hard to project what it's going to look like. And maybe, since Rob is here, he can speak a little bit to this. The issue that is, you know, unfortunately, or fortunately, depending on how you look at it.

1:21:16 The labor costs in the state of California are just outpace, well, and they're going to outpace, right, our ability to generate an FTOT to pay for all the people that you need, and Rob could be way more eloquent about that than I can, so I don't know if you want to chime in. We're at a pace that, you know, expenses could overrun revenue here, not too distant future, right, so that's why these questions there about, you know, the general funds are very competitive dollars, right, they're funding, you know.

1:21:46 Some big departments, public safety, and then we're going to get into the same service category discussion again internally with each department and who gets the most amount and who gets the less, right? So it's a very difficult conversation. It's not something you can really rely on. No. And so that's probably not the best model to create it on, but there needs to be some level of it, and that's where it's like, what's that number that you're going to create to...

1:22:15 to determine that and then how can you move these numbers around to help you see your services cover the cost of at least yeah at least the service itself plus a little bit of the building and I just think this I think that looking at you know this model I think you don't want to say it is greater financial self-reliance but I think

1:22:39 In terms of a decision-making tool, in terms of, well, are you going to add this program? Where are you going to grow? Where are you going to put those labor resources? I think it's really valuable for that, but I don't think you're ever going to get away from, you know.

1:22:52 a significant reliance on the general fund, because like you said, you know, nobody's going to be like, I'm going to get in the park business. I want to run that pool. I want to run that public pool. Well, and that's why a lot of municipalities have had to close pools. No one's stepping up and trying to run a public pool. Or an ice cream for that matter, right? We're forming out soon. We're forming out soon. It's going to be great. Thank you. My daughter's very excited.

1:23:21 I think you're right on time. 6.51. How about we take public comments? Yeah, there we go. Thoughts and questions, right? That was the... Yeah. Any public comment from anyone in the room? Anyone online? No. Okay. Are we meant to have made a decision on those last two things? No. No. I mean, it was more important to just hear a rich discussion. Yeah. Copy. Much more important to hear just like a rich discussion around them.

1:23:54 And it's good and hard, right? It's why you all are getting the big bucks. We often have to see things in a snapshot, and that's what we gifted you, and so we just wanted to have some really good dialogue around it to see where people are at to help us learn more about Mammoth Lakes as well. And I guess I would say, like what Pat said, with kind of...

1:24:21 And in your presentation it did mention dynamic pricing is, you know, a lot of parks and recreations in the state, they do offer like priority registration or a lower price for residents. And I understand, you know, like it's hard to say, is it, you have to be in Mammoth, does it include Crowley, does it include...

1:24:44 How far does it go out? We had that discussion at the Rec Commission because I'm on that as well. It came up and it's very much the same as something with the mountain teams. Who's local? If I bought a property here, am I now local? It's just so much in there and it's a tough one. I think

1:25:13 When you can find that pricing that makes sense for any person in the community, because if you own a second home, maybe you're not local, but you're still a member of the community. If you come up here all the time and you visit, you're still a member of the community because you support the community with your dollars when you go buy a coffee or you go do whatever you're doing, you know. What's the right price and strategy for recreation?

1:25:40 Like to get a kid to go to a first-time swim lesson, like maybe it's better for them to come up here. I don't know, like it's such a, it was such a hard one and yeah, I don't, when you start going local versus out of town, you're now.

1:25:58 You're now putting it on a gatekeeper who's going to pay 20 bucks an hour to go, hey, prove you're out of town, like, oh, here's my power bill, and they're like, sweet, you're in. Well, you don't live here. How many days do I have to live here until I'm local? You know, how many years do you have to live here until you're a local? I'm an immigrant, like, am I a local yet? Infinite. Never a local, right? Unless you're Bill Souser.

1:26:25 The question about resident versus non-resident was that if you're saying that it's a broader community than just residents, then you can justify some of those additional costs that you have. Different pricing. Yeah. Because you're, you know, it's the broader community. Right, right. Yeah. But you could offer, you know, priority registration. Yeah. I do like that. Well, no, a lot of things are getting captured in the membership, right? Yep.

1:26:51 Yeah, the membership. That was that product specifically for that. And that's why it's in person. Yeah. It's in person, so if you're here. Shoulder season. Yeah. If you're here, that was the strategy, right? The timing. Let's take it off online, same with registering for camps. It's not precluding anybody from buying the product. No, but you're here. Anybody can buy a product. That means you're here, you've made the effort. You live here, you know, it's like without that label, right, of

1:27:21 No, I thought that was creative, and I, but same thing, like, so we go ice skating with friends from out of town, and they were still like, I don't know, 20 bucks, that's a deal. And I was like, I'll, something at some point. Leave a donation. Tip well. I had a question about where we go from here. The current survey is ending at the end of this month, right?

1:27:49 The Future Park Humanity Survey? Yes, and then we have a community outreach event Wednesday. Yep, on Thursday. And then, like, how specific are we getting? Where does it go after that? We have one more meeting, right, in October? The public can still provide any comments. I'm just reading an email from Marina. But we're going to keep the...

1:28:15 Draft comments available online all the way up to, I think, September, October. I'm just trying to find the right email. So even though we're kind of, you know, wrapping up the outreach in person this Wednesday, we'll still have the opportunity online to provide that comment, right? Because I think that's... How do people know that? That's only right. We'll start messaging out again like we just did for this one.

1:28:40 Did you say we have a meeting in October? We have the November 30 meeting. Yes, that's our next meeting. That's our next meeting. So that's going to be the whole draft recommendation from the consultant from K2A. And that's as specific as put this X number of dollars here? No, it won't be that specific. What is it going to look like? Our side will be more of, I think, this conversation as well as the rest of the public input will decide exactly what goes into the...

1:29:08 recommendations in the long run, in the tenure plan, in the master plan. And prioritizing or? And likely prioritizing and then the final piece is like a strategic plan. So it's like here's the five pillars overarching of the plan and then here's actions or goals inside of each of those of where to put focus and then prioritization is like.

1:29:34 One to three years, three to five years, five to ten year projects. And then identifying some financial resources needed to make those happen, some staff resource and time to make those happen. So all that is like one package that I believe will be coming back to this committee at the end of November. One of the specifics are up to us, I guess. And we spent a little bit of that today actually trying to dig into all the recommendations and put them in. We've got to rank them and rate them, right? So it's going to be pretty intriguing. So we're going to be certainly pushing all that information out for some feedback as well.

1:30:04 Cool. Yeah. You're almost there. You're almost there. I have one other question. Yeah. Is the Tony Colosardo Scholarship available for adults? It's just youth right now. It's just youth. You know, I feel like if we are increasing our costs, I think that it would be prudent, especially if we're not interested in giving residents.

1:30:26 Different pricing. I think that it would be nice to expand the Tony Colosardo Scholarship to adults, like to everybody, and I think that it's important to kind of publish income guidelines because then people can decide quickly if they should apply or not. Can we get a seniors discount? It might be in front of the commission too, right? It's not called seniors, you can't help. Are you going to come to the commission meeting and suggest that?

1:30:57 When is it? When's your meeting? When is our next meeting? October. October, yeah. It's too much going on. October 20th. What time? Sweet Z? Sweet Z, right here.

1:31:10 No, but I can take that. I can take that to commission. 2.30? I can take that for you. You were here. You already heard it. I can take it for you. It's a tough time. But you can always send an email, comment. Yeah, I'll take it. I'll take it to you. Okay. Or maybe there's a separate scholarship fund specific to adults. Yeah. I mean, there are some reasons why the Tony Colasardo is youth specific. Yeah. Yeah. You know, and I think you'd have to talk.

1:31:35 But I think if we're talking about increasing prices to cover costs, we need to make it accessible to everyone. Yeah, I don't disagree with you that that is something that should be looked at, I just, I think, in general, yeah, yeah. Call Betsy Truax from Costa College. There can be discounted pricing as well based on certain things, like I got a seniors discount the other day and I was very chuffed. I was very happy.

1:32:02 No, I was playing golf and they're like, senior, right, right? And I was like, yeah, thanks. They didn't even need your ID? No, no, no, I just showed the gray hair, I guess. I was like, I'm here, I'll take this every day. So, Stu, one other question, kind of following up on what Sierra was saying. So, with the meeting at the end of November, are we looking at the next town council to be looking at this master plan update as opposed to the current council?

1:32:32 Based on the schedule that we talked about with the consultant, it looks like it's kind of February, March time frame. Okay. Yep. To bring that forward to the commission and then the council. I know we're looking at it. Won't be me. Hopefully be my husband, but it won't be me. Yeah, yeah. So it's got a little bit of time, right? Because we've got to collate all those draft recommendations and then package it up and get it to. So that's kind of February, March. And we hope to have a kind of a workshop format with council and the commission prior to the action being taken that night.

1:33:02 For the master plan, so yeah, quite a bit of work to do. I mean, Farrell just gave us a lot of the work to do. Because that's really the strategic action plan, right? So you'll have the master plan, but that strategic action plan is going to dictate your short, medium, long-term tasks right over time, you know, measurable, smart objectives, right? So that's really the challenge trying to get those sorted out. So what we as a department are going to focus on for the next three and then five and then 10 years, right? And then really revisiting that, you know, to Farrell's point, you know,

1:33:31 Getting back into the service analogy to get the baseline. So we're at 77% general fund subsidy now. When do we run that again? And what are the tactics and strategies we're going to put in place to achieve those goals? If we really want to get after, let's capture trying the direct cost first. What does that look like? Do we just take some service categories? Do we take them all? I mean, just great questions. But I think that's an important question because I think that's going to come up from our public on Wednesday. They're going to want to know, okay, well, what's the timing and how does this all?

1:34:01 Yes, just to let you know, I won't be there. I'm flying to Australia tomorrow night. So, my team is there, Beryl's there. So, Stu's dropping the pen. K2-8. I'm going to get on the plane tomorrow, I'm going to leave the countries. Thank you. Thank you all for your attendance. If you can make it on Wednesday, that'd be great. All right. I'll be there. We will adjourn. Are there any other comments or anything? May we adjourn? Okay. Oh, sorry.

1:34:27 This is Marina from KTUA. I just wanted to add one thing. Looking ahead to our November 30th Advisory Committee meeting, we'll be sharing the draft plan with you all in mid-November, so you'll have a couple of weeks to review the full draft master plan before our meeting, and then you'll have a couple of weeks after to email additional comments to us.

1:34:52 And at the same time, we'll release that draft master plan to the general public online as well. So after our in-person activities next week, or sorry, this week, we'll also be releasing the full draft master plan online for community input in November through mid-November through mid-December. So that's where folks will get to see how all of this came together in the master plan before it goes to town council.

1:35:22 All right. Well, thank you so much, Marina. So we are on to item five, adjournment. We will adjourn until our regularly held meeting on Monday, November 30th at 5.30 p.m. Thank you all for coming.