Town Council Special meeting
at 16:00
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Minutes ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Notable from this meeting
3 findings- Final FY26-27 document puts reserves $1,290,110 below the policy requirement Budget and Capital Improvements
- FY23-24 preliminary budget listed General Fund revenues of $30,103,400 and an almost $82,000 deficit Budget and Capital Improvements
- The FY26-27 final budget lists $23,000,000 in TOT revenue, up from $19,500,000 in FY25-26 Tourism and TOT
Transcript
378 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:24 Yeah, how was it being done? Okay, good evening. Ready? Okay, good evening, all. Whack. Calling to order this special meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Town Council for Wednesday, April 12th, 2023. Jamie, if you could call our roll, please. Councilmember Bubzer? Here. Councilmember Rae is absent. Councilmember Rice? Here. Mayor Pro Tem Salzer? Present. Mayor Wentworth.
1:05 Yes, present. Palace Chief, if you could lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance. Thank you very much. Dan, I'm going to turn to you. I think you may have some additions to the agenda and some flip-flopping as well. Yes. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Yes, we do have an urgency item we'd like to add to the agenda to do this. I'll touch on what it is, and it takes a four-fifth vote to add it to the agenda, then we'll take action on it under the appropriate place.
1:53 But this is an emergency. It's a resolution that allows us to, due to the emergency circumstances, that we can award a contract for street repair work. We just got the process and the resolution prepared just the other day, so it was not prepared in time to place it onto the agenda in the normal course of business. The need to be able to do the repair work in this emergency, if you've driven on the roads, other than
2:22 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
2:50 This would allow us to go out to bid without going through the competitive bidding process. We'd get a quote and then be able to move that forward. So that'd be the item. The first question we would have to the council would just be an action to add a resolution as an urgency item to the agenda and that we would address it specifically under the update and council direction in response to local extreme weather declared emergency.
3:19 And we would like to take that item in front of the budget item as well. Okay. So you'll advise us when we need a motion or if there's a document or something to... The very first motion at this point, we would need a motion. At this point, Mr. Mayor, I would like to make a motion to add the resolution on emergency actions to the agenda tonight. I'll second. Okay. And as always, that motion is based on the need to take immediate action.
3:46 And the fact that we realize we need to take this immediate action after the agenda was posted. So added. So amended. So amended. Good. Thank you. So we have a motion and a second. And I believe we need a unanimous vote to move this forward. Is that correct? Yes. Four fifths. Thank you. Four fifths. Is there any public comment on any of this?
4:11 Not seeing, hearing any, okay, Jamie, let's call the roll, please. Councilmember Bubser? Yes. Councilmember Rice? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Sauser? Yes. Mayor Wentworth? Yes. So, you agreed to it unanimously, and Dan will get to that item when we get to it. Thank you. We'll add it to the agenda and discussion under item 4.2, which we'll take in front of item 4.1. Sure. Okay, thank you for that. Any public comments on items not otherwise on the agenda? Yes, Patricia?
4:43 Hi, good afternoon. I just thought I would mention this. I thought of it as I was on my way over here, but I'm Patricia Robertson, the Executive Director of Mammoth Lakes Housing, and I wanted the community to know that Mammoth Lakes Housing does have a grant that can provide funds for rehabilitation of homes for health and safety repairs.
5:08 For households earning below 80% of the area median income, and we have reached out to the state to see if we can raise that income threshold up to 120% of the area median income because of the disaster declaration. So we haven't heard back yet, but we're waiting for that to come through, and once we know, I'll let the community know, but we do have that resource available. Excellent. Thank you. Please keep us posted. Yes, Mr. Urdi. Good afternoon. John Urdi, Mammoth Lakes Council.
5:40 Jesus. Wishful thinking. Trying to do your job already. Mammoth Lakes Tourism. Just a heads up that we have extended advanced air a little bit more in the season. We're going to fly on Friday and Sunday, the last two weekends of April. And so we've added those with some of the, we had some of the canceled flights that we were able to push forward to be able to extend that season through April 30th. So just Friday and Sunday, it'll fly Hawthorne and Carlsbad. And folks that have 10 packs, they're good through that April 30th and they'll be done for the year.
6:09 And we'll bring out the new product for next year. Excellent. Thank you. Anybody else? Anybody in the virtual world? Oh. I'm sorry, hang on. Just real quick. Is that a public comment? Okay. No virtual. Okay, go ahead. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. I have a very brief public comment. I'm just going to share my screen really quickly. Just want to bring to Town Council's attention and our community.
6:40 I know it's been a long-standing work item for quite some time, but we have a Town of Mammoth Lakes Instagram account. Good. Right? Thank you. Good. It's a bit sad it's taken this long, but we're going to get there. So you can see I've got two posts and four followers. So, you know, we're starting slowly, but we're going to get there. So please jump on and follow as best you can. We're going to meet next week with the new tourism rising star.
7:08 Dakota Snyder, is that right? Dakota was awarded a pretty prestigious honor. So we're actually going to meet with John's team next week, with Christina from the police department, Kat, and kind of our team that kind of manages social media, and we'll kind of just get a little bit of a discussion strategy, plans moving forward about how to best use these resources. So within the Twitter, sorry, Instagram page, we have...
7:38 This little link tree, which is kind of cool if you're familiar with it. And on that, you can actually go to our website. You can jump on Community E-News. Just a little bit of background there. We do that kind of community update every Friday. We're going to rebrand that and call it kind of Community E-News. A bit more trendy, right? And we'll kind of migrate away from the town E-News. We used to do that once a month, but I think...
8:04 I believe, I think a weekly update e-news is going to be, I think, more timely, more accurate for our community. So we're going to be posting that. If you follow that link, you'll get to a page that has the archived editions. So if you want to follow along, we started with last month's, last week's edition. So you can kind of follow there. And then it's really just kind of following and linking to just some of the quick links on the town website. So you can kind of get back to meetings, agendas, housing now and jobs and so forth.
8:33 With that, happy to answer any questions, and we'll be moving forward with the world of Instagram. Thank you. I'm just wondering if you would consider including the Office of Outdoor Recreation and Mammoth Lakes Recreation in that group as well. That'd be great. Thank you. I do have an email that we received for public comment. Yeah. Okay. Do you want to read that? Sure. Great. Thank you.
8:56 Town Council, staff, and members of the public. As a full-time Mammoth resident for over 20 years, I am strongly opposed to both MLT and the proposed 10-year T-bid renewal in their current forms. Although MLT has a valuable place in this community, I do not agree with the growth at any cost mentality, their one-sided spending plans, and an accountability to no one. At last week's joint council and MLT meeting, I was appalled by MLT's argumentative and defiant attitude towards town council and the public.
9:26 I listened to numerous positive and constructive spending suggestions get presented, all of which were seemingly shot down by condescending lectures and an unnecessary tone of defiance. There needs to be serious changes made before a renewal is considered. I'd like to see this board listen to and represent the wants and needs of everyone in this community. Unfortunately, last week it became apparent to me that they have other priorities.
9:52 $6.7 million estimated spending budget laid out for the next 10 years shows that nearly 93% of those dollars will be spent on airline subsidies and marketing, leaving the other 7% for administrative fees and reserves. What happened to the very community TBIT is supposed to benefit? The residents here deserve not to be ignored or disregarded. Mr. Urdi last week literally said everything we're doing is resident focused. I couldn't disagree more.
10:19 Please correct me if I'm wrong here. All current members on the MLT board are not voted in by the public, but instead are hand-selected and appointed at the sole discretion of the director. The director's current quarter-million dollar salary, including any past, present, or future raises, gets voted on and approved solely by those hand-selected members. In other words, there's zero input from council, town staff, or the public. How does that make sense? Tens of millions of our dollars are spent on whatever the members decide on.
10:46 That is the most undemocratic thing I've ever heard of. Council, please insist on or at least consider a more fair and community-inclusive process for TBID spending as well as for Council's current TBID renewal consideration. Ten years is too much. Please, no more new airline subsidies until they can prove that Denver and San Francisco can be profitable. Airline subsidies were never meant to be permanent when TBID was formed. Dallas and Chicago next, question mark.
11:12 Not until the two current airline routes are proven successful, let's consider adding year-round service in Bishop first so locals can fly somewhere on vacations during our shoulder seasons. That's one benefit a lot of us could use. Why is Bishop and Inyo County not contributing to the airline subsidies? They are direct beneficiary of MLT's marketing machine. Can we ensure that a tiny sliver of their budget gets allocated towards infrastructure, parking, road, and signage improvements, et cetera?
11:42 Can we please enforce the speed limits, chain requirements, and no parking signs in town? Let's not be afraid of hurting someone's feelings here at the sacrifice of safety. Our guests are quickly learning they can do whatever they want with virtually no consequences and at the detriment to public welfare. This town simply does not have the capacity, workforce, or infrastructure to accommodate the 75,000 daily employments they so dreamily would like to see. Thank you. CJ Sterling. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Sterling.
12:12 Okay. Anything else? Good, Jamie. And Andy, I believe Andy is a 530 presence in our Zoom. Is that correct? He was there. Okay. That's me. 530 is me. 530, Morris. Okay. Good to know. All right. Well, with that, Dan, if you're ready, item 4.2 out of order. We'll move on now to the updating council direction on response to local extreme weather declared emergencies.
12:43 And Dan, go ahead. Thank you. Yeah, we wanted to spend some time walking through a number of different issues related to this, and that'll include ultimately requests for some funding, including the emergency item added to this agenda. The element of our emergency, excuse me, the emergency here is quickly becoming much larger than just the town of Mammoth Lakes or Moto Inyo County. We are getting a fair amount of exposure at the state and national level.
13:13 In terms of our news reports, et cetera. So a lot of that information's out there and coming in, I know the mayor's done a couple different interviews on radio and TV and I've done one for the Digital Weather Channel and LA Times, et cetera. So a lot of exposure to the challenges going on in the Eastern Sierra and the town of Mammoth Lakes in particular.
13:38 I wanted to touch on some of that, and the staff report kind of walks through a lot of this, but I wanted to highlight some of the, I think, the key issues on this, where we went into this process with storms starting back in October, frankly, early opening of Mammoth Mountain, never excited about a great winter, and then it just never quit snowing until a week ago or so. So it's been quite a challenge for us. There definitely have been some significant impacts through this.
14:03 The next step in the disaster side of that, we've declared ours, the county has, state has. We had a federal proclamation of a disaster, and then the next level is a major disaster under FEMA. They're in the process of collecting information, and will be here, I believe, this week, tomorrow, to actually finalize that determination, if we get that major disaster designation, which we believe we will, for both Mono and Inyo counties, so the two counties are coming into that.
14:32 That really helps us on our reimbursements, the costs that we've incurred that are not fully already covered by the state. So we go from a 75% to a 94% potential cost recovery for eligible items. Through the disaster process, we end up creating an emergency operations center. The state actually stood up an emergency management team kind of to support our EOC, which was joint between the two counties.
14:57 When that gets stood up, all of the resource requests to the state then goes up through that process. So we put in what's called the 213 form. It's a request for resources. That goes through logistics or through operations and then up the chain of command to see if we can get those filled or not. We did a fair amount of that, the request of pushing through that.
15:19 The one request was not filled. We had done a request asking, I think it was 40 to 60 shovelers to come into the town and help clear, mainly private properties, which is a real challenge with state resources and also some uniqueness of the private town resources, even working on private properties. But that one was not filled, but we did get a lot of other support out of that process. The Fire Protection District here...
15:47 Chief is here, can speak to some of this later as need be. We had engines response coming in and backfilling and supporting Mammoth Lakes Fire. We had some ALS ambulance support coming in to do that. And a lot of that was because we were also bifurcated with the closure of Highway 395, bringing those additional resources in here because we were not able to reposition ambulances through the county as we'd normally do. That also supported the receipt of
16:16 Additional law enforcement resources coming. We had a couple of different rounds of the law enforcement here. Again, in part, if we had to respond to major incidents, they really were helpful also just in traffic management with trucking. But having them here, because we could not call in our normal partners. We couldn't get CHP out of Bridgeport, for example, in any timely fashion with the road closed.
16:40 We also ended up with the pre-positioning of an urban search and rescue team. We ended up ultimately with, I think it was four teams. One of those was a hazmat, heavy hazmat type team. Really aided us in being able to respond to incidents, and obviously the one explosion with the life safety rescue was key, having them in our community.
17:02 Scaling down and have scaled down. We'll be down just one use to our team between now and this weekend. They will be completely out, I think, as of Monday. And we'll retain a couple of Cal OES engine companies still supporting Alish's team as it relates to responding to propane calls or other emergency components. We had a number of hand crews come in that were able to help clear out a lot of hydrants, very task-oriented in terms of how we got that mission. It was interesting to watch them do that.
17:32 Digging out hydrants with chainsaws as they were going through ice. A great coordinated effort with some motor work as well to clear off and have that done. The other thing they were able to do was help us with sandbags. We currently have about 7,500 plus or minus sandbags stockpiled ready for the next event with flooding potentials here is the snowmelt. Those are available to the community for use as well as town use. And as need be, we can put together another
18:01 The other component coming in really was
18:31 This is Port of Town staff. We had a finance person embedded with the EOC. Stu was the alternate PIO in supporting that. We actually provided safety officer to support through the EOC as well. And so we worked through that. We also ended up working with the whole where do you dump the snow questions. As you're aware, we started the year with a snow pit on that Snow Creek 8 property, worked with the property owner to do that.
18:58 We ended up losing that pit due to heavy winds and the amount of snow just trying to keep the roadway open. And then the wet, heavy snows, it turned it into kind of a bog. And so we were able to work with the Forest Service. We opened that pit where we had before. The District Ranger was good in working with us through that to get that up and running and going. And so that allowed not just us but others to have a place to move snow out of town. And we have moved a lot.
19:26 Haze will spend more time, a lot of snow out of town, and yet some roads you drive and you go, man, these are still narrow and their banks are huge, but a lot of snow has moved out of town through that process. The other thing we did, we actually, in response to structures, failures and stuff like that, we'll talk a lot about that process, but hats off again to a lot of the town staff, coordination with the OES staff that were here to position, used our teams that had structural engineering teams with them, really added value.
19:55 A lot of training work on both sides of the house there and moving some stuff forward through that process. And then, of course, through this whole thing was the response side, whether we were showing up at a propane lake in the fire department, police department. We were in front of a number of structural concerns and issues, some collapses, obviously, that you're all aware of and those types of things. So that community support.
20:22 Town support back. I think it was huge overall, and I'm just giving you a very, very brief summary of the last what seems like 100 days of January update here. I'm going to have Hayes walk through a lot of the detail, and I want to come back and talk about our proposals of how we invest back in our community as well as we move to the recovery phase and continue to prep for the melting snow. So with that, let me turn it to Hayes, and he'll kind of walk through.
20:49 Some more detail here. They won't bring it back that way for some actions and considerations by Town Council. Thanks, Dan. I kind of think of this emergency as having three phases, and I've broken my presentation up into those three phases. First was the snow removal and the town-wide trucking operations, and then the response and recovery for the structural assessments and the propane issues. And I'll pause after each one of these sections and answer any questions.
21:17 So trucking operations began middle of March about the 16th and ran through April 7th. The trucks were provided by Cal OES, but the town did pick up the tab for the pit fees, which are going to be about $375,000. We targeted a number of areas around town, focusing initially on arterials and collectors. We worked in heavily populated areas like the ski area, the lodges. We focused on some constrained areas with limited snow storage like cul-de-sacs and some narrow.
21:46 Streets, the higher elevations. And we had to consider a lot of different variables. We never knew how much work was going to get done on a daily basis. We always set pretty lofty goals, and then we'd have to reel it back in the evening and come up with a new plan, working around the day of the week, parking, widths of the road. Sometimes we couldn't get certain equipment in certain places. So every night the team would get together and put together the plan for the next day, and we'd try to message that out through Facebook, through the town and the PD website.
22:15 The program was more or less managed by Public Works Engineering staff. Colin, Riley, Sean did an incredible job wrangling these trucks. They operated seven days a week, 12 hours a day, except during storms. They had up to 44 trucks running and three loaders every day. They cleared about 120 fire hydrants, and they moved 5,706 loads of snow. For comparison, in 16-17,
22:44 We did 6,000 loads for the entire community for the winter. So we did almost that much just with a single trucking operation. I think for the community we'll probably go two and a half to threefold on what we did in 16-17 with the community. That equates to about 57,000 cubic yards of snow, about 3 million pounds of snow, and about 4.6 million gallons of water that was trucked out. This is a map of all the locations. We kept pretty good track of where we were working.
23:15 I'm not going to go into this a lot of detail, but I'm happy to share it. All the little red dots, the fire hydrants, we worked closely with the fire department to strategically target certain fire hydrants so they could get the right hose pull. And then we worked a lot in the higher elevations and the higher density residential neighborhoods to make sure that we had good access to those streets for the fire department and EMS. And just a couple photos. Upper left-hand corner, we did use loaders to load trucks. Some of you may have seen the parade of trucks on...
23:45 203 as we tried to clear the highway. And then on the right-hand side, you can see how constrained it can be when you try to stick a Kodiak 966 split mount and trucks in a narrow street. But these guys were able to navigate these constraints and do a lot of good work. I'll pause here. Any questions about our trucking operation? Yeah. When you say $3.75 for pit fees, is that the pit fees at?
24:14 The original pit or at the Forest Service pit, do we have those together and do we know what the Forest Service expenses are going to be? Yeah, we've been, we use both pits for this operation. We transitioned to the Forest Service pit once the road to the Snow Creek pit effectively failed. We have the accounting on which one we were using at what time. The cost was the same for either pit and I believe we have a 5% surcharge that we owe the
24:43 Forest Service for the use of the land. But that's based on the value of the land, not the actual cost of our work. Is the Snow Creek pit still in operation, or are we losing that road due to spring? That pit is being, we're losing it to spring, but Snow Creek 5 has an access road to it, so they're still trekking out their operation so that, you know, it's the same organization using their land. But for our purposes, we've abandoned it.
25:16 Okay, Chris, yes, no, Amanda, anything? The Forest Service, if we are losing the Snow Creek pit, then will the Forest Service allow us to finish out this work on the Forest Service land since I know it's been a hard battle this year. Yes, we'll be doing some follow-up with them. We had at least a minimum of a 30-day window, which we're hitting into that. We'll do some little follow-up to make sure. I haven't heard anything to the contrary that...
25:42 If there's any concerns there, they definitely have gone out through the process and actually looked at the other roadway in the other pit area. So they're intimately familiar with the challenges that we have had. And so I think we'll be able to utilize it until we're done. The one thing we have to do there, we do make a distinction between snow coming off of the town roads and town property, our parking lots, for example, public snow versus private snow. So we've made that distinction. That's another issue that we've had to track with the Forest Service.
26:13 Hayes, do you anticipate updating this presentation? Like in a month or a couple weeks? Not so much the trucking. I think that's come to a close, but there's aspects that we'll get into next. I'm just thinking that if you could share this so when there are requests, numbers, data, this is a very efficient way to be able to kind of communicate with the people what's happening.
26:38 The staff wrote a pretty good write-up with some additional mapping and some tables and information that we shared with Dan earlier today, and we can share that with you, and I think Stu's got some messaging that press release on this same topic. Yeah, just we can have that at our fingertips if we get calls and things like that. And yeah, if you could add just a time frame of this, you reference like a specific trucking operation, like kind of when it started, when it ended, and then that goes very well for the largest statistics.
27:08 And we know how to get in touch with these trucking companies for the 4th of July parade, correct? Yeah, actually we do. Okay, good. We'll see if they're willing to come up here. We'll make it worth their while. Okay, any questions from the public on this? No, I think we're doing good, so please proceed. All right, now for something completely different.
27:33 So our structural assessment response and recovery. This is an ongoing and developing program. As I mentioned last week, we're still working on how we're going to manage this incident. Really ramped up after an evacuation warning for damaged structures was issued on March 16th. And we had a number of calls, DIY, Juniper Springs, that really started with the trigger points.
27:58 We geared up pretty quickly and brought in staff from Cal OES, the Structural Assessment Program, to assist town in going through critical infrastructure and evaluating certain buildings proactively and then responding to what we've crowdsourced as data and calls that came in from 911. We also leveraged the structural specialists embedded in the urban search and rescue teams that were in town. Those guys were great.
28:25 Wealth of knowledge and very helpful in making determinations on the safety of certain structures. As part of our crowdsourcing, if you will, we tipped up a, excuse me, I've been talking all day, my throat's dry, tipped up a damage assessment form and put that on our websites and pushed it down on social media. The survey is also an application that staff uses to report damage in the field. We also put together a call center.
28:56 And put that up on a CMS board and issued it on social media and our websites for individuals to call and get information and report structural damage. And then, as always, call 911 for collapse or unsafe situations or propane leaks. We collected all this data initially in a spreadsheet. And every party, the USAR teams, the SAP teams, and the town teams all used different databases. And we consolidated in the spreadsheet and later... Oh, thank you, sir.
29:26 Appreciate that. Yeah. Consolidated in a spreadsheet and then later into QuickBase databases, which we are currently using as our management tool. Today, over 440 structures in Mammoth alone have been reported and evaluated. I think it's 615 countywide. We currently have 65 red tags issued and 54 yellow tags issued. What do those mean? So a green tag.
30:00 Let me back up. So this program is based on ATC-20, which was developed in the late 80s, early 90s as a way to quickly evaluate structures for seismic response so that you could walk into a disaster and quickly evaluate whether things are safe to enter or not. I don't remember what ATC stands for. Yeah, it's an engineering term. It's a group, not a... I could look it up. Anyway...
30:32 Green tags are inspected as safe, but they could have damage, but it's still safe to enter, safe to stay there. The opposite side of the spectrum is a red tag, which is unsafe, clear damage, and some imminent threat. And then in the middle is a yellow tag, and a yellow tag can be a red tag, it can be a green tag, and everything in between. But on a yellow tag, you'll note what the damage is, limitations on entry.
30:59 Limitations on use and so forth and we try to clearly articulate the use of the structure on those tags. So the recovery process is going to be long. It's going to take time to work through all these structures. Like I mentioned, we're managing this database and trying to close the loop. Good information in, good information out, documenting every step along the way. We are providing information to the public on the next steps they need to take.
31:28 An email went out the other day to everything we had crowdsourced through our website. We are merging our database with the assessor's data and our business tax certificate data so we have good addresses to mail out to people we don't have email addresses on. We have created a couple of new communication tools. We have a tag status application and a reoccupation action requirement sheet so people can get good information on what they need to do.
31:55 And information on the status of their tag. And again, we're pushing out emails and mailers on the same line. I'm not going to go through this, but I'm just really proud of the work our team did tipping up this database in an incredibly short amount of time and how valuable this tool is. And this is not a one-time thing. This will have value for the future for dealing with propane issues and code enforcement tags. So it's going to be really helpful, too, in the future.
32:24 This is just a list of all the different tags we have. There's over a thousand records now for inspections that we're managing. And if you drill down into any one of those, you can get information on the actual inspections, like that down at the bottom. You see those little green and red blurs on the screen? Those generate those letters, those tag response, the reoccupation, so we can quickly create those and give them to the public.
32:50 I may real quick, we also coordinated this work with Mono County, so the records in there are reflected the town of Mammoth Lakes and the county information that's been collected as well. So we worked cooperating together and Olivia, sorry, I'm going to drop her last name, Hollinhurst was there, Hollinhurst, she did a great job in studying this and she's actually worked on disaster stuff around the world.
33:18 Was a great asset from the county that partnered in getting this pull together as well than our team helping manage it through that. I did want to know what we say, a thousand different things out there. I think that includes some of the, I think it does on the Mono County side as well as town of Memphis. Thanks, Dan. And you can drill down even further on those inspections. They're all geo-referenced. They have, you know, all the details on what was seen and you can see photos and so forth. And we can collect that in the field from our application and it goes directly to our database.
33:49 So the recovery, I can't say this enough, every situation is unique. Every residence we're dealing with has a unique set of circumstances. But general conditions to remove tags, if you have a red tag and you have structural damage, you're going to need to have a structural engineer or a civil engineer do an analysis of the structure and give us a report on what needs to be fixed. That will require building permits and inspections.
34:16 Generally, snow removal, a lot of the hazard is snow. Remove the hazard, can be in good shape. Some buildings require shoring. You've seen that at DIY where they've had to temporarily shore up a wall. Removal of snow from LPG infrastructure is something we've added to every response requirements. That way we know that the propane system is safe when we're working in those buildings and then clearly inspecting the work.
34:43 Got a few photographs. It's hard to imagine that we were actually in emergency when you drive around town. Yeah, it's a lot of snow, a lot of potholes. I know there's a lot of potholes. But you don't see this damage when you're just driving by. And any building could have something similar where we have on the right and left here roof rafters and headers completely cracked and failing. Imminent threat of collapse. This is an A-frame on the left-hand side. The lateral load broke that roof.
35:13 Right-hand side, snow shed, sheared off the whole front of a building. Some shoring, holding up a walkway. On the right-hand side, complete failure of any very large beams, very large timber completely failing. And then some creative shoring around a lot of entrances to residences. And then to demonstrate why you need a structural engineer or civil engineer, these roof rafters collapsed, the web members.
35:44 Buckled. But you can't see any other damage. There's blown-in insulation. So that all has to be removed and evaluated by somebody to make sure that whole system is safe. And then on the other side, you have complete failures, complete collapses. This is that on Minaret Road. Structures, a total loss. Before I move on to propane, any questions on what we're doing in relation to the structural assessments? My only question on this one is of all the red tags issued.
36:15 And I know they may not have been completely cleared at this point. How many have we allowed re-occupancy in? Whether it be business or 65 are issued. So how many of those have we allowed people to go back in? I don't have that exact figure, but not a lot. Probably about a handful. Good. Question? Does anybody else have one first? I guess what I want to understand is, so you said,
36:51 There's a tag status application, so like an actual app that you just can look and put in your address or? So a couple ways that can work, you can email the permit technician, they can generate a link so you can fill it out. Okay. We can generate it ourselves. There's a couple different ways that we can utilize the system to generate that information for that property owner. And then, so your red tag, the structural engineer comes in, they say what the,
37:21 Sure, yeah.
37:51 Set path forward. We'll work with the property owners on making sure that the structure is safe. We may allow people to get back into their units under a green tag with acknowledging that before next winter they have to make the repairs because once the snow load has been mitigated, the hazard has been mitigated to a certain degree. Okay. So all kinds of variables in there. But they need to reach out to us and we'll work with them. And then 65 red tags sounds like a lot, but it's also...
38:21 Manageable for a town of our size. Do we just have a sense of who these folks are and what they're doing? I mean, that's not that many that it seems like we can't come together to figure out how to help them. Yeah, we've spoken with a number of them and some of them, you know, there's second homeowners that may not even know that they have damage. So we're trying to reach out. That's why we're generating these mailing lists and so forth. It's just going to, it is manageable. We are going to need some resources, you know, we've kind of talked about.
38:49 The administrative side, there's going to be a lot of requests for information. There's going to be requests for plan sets. So we're working with town manager to bring in resources to help us with our immediate needs to manage that influx of building permits. We've also discussed bringing in some additional resources to help us with responding to those requests outside plan checkers and so forth and outside engineers to help us do those reviews. And then longer term in the recovery, we'll need assistance with inspections.
39:19 There will be a lot of inspections that need to occur. There's a lot of work already happening in town with the large development, so we'll bring in some contractual services, and we may pull some retired annuitants off the bench to help us out and keep this information and keep the people working on these job sites. Thanks. I have an extra room in my house. If there's a structural engineer that needs a place to stay for a couple nights, as long as they don't ski, let me know.
39:50 Okay, anything else? Nope. Okay, next. All right, so I'm going to move on to the third phase of this emergency, propane. And so you are probably well aware we are experienced higher than normal calls regarding propane leaks. Many of these leaks have been very serious and have caused significant damage and in some instances injuries. The fire department responds to propane calls and coordinates with the propane provider to turn off the system.
40:20 And there's been many broken lines and residents filled with propane. I'll invite Alice to speak to some of the response. This is kind of a chart of our activity since March, and you can see that trend line is not particularly good, averaging about five or six calls per day. So before I jump into recovery, Chief, did you have anything you want to say about the response side and what you guys are doing to manage this incident?
40:54 Now to have a coughing attack. I'll just remind you about the Fire Protection District. Excuse me, I'm a little tired. It's been a long two months. I'll cover a couple of those. So first on the red tags, I'd actually caution us to be – so we end up red tagging a lot of the 911 calls, essentially, and a lot of those happen at night, the 911 calls during the day. We take that initial call. 60, I'm guessing, is going to be a lot lower than what we're going to see.
41:23 Again, the data that we have right now is on the multifamily residences. If you take a look, that's about 80% of what we're seeing. If you drive through your neighborhoods, you'll clearly see the single-family residences are impacted as well. A lot of those will ultimately end up being yellow tags to a certain extent, but the damage on the community is significant. Again, I would say 10% of our structures will probably have something that will require a contractor, and that recovery effort is going to be large.
41:51 It's going to be a large impact on this community. The way that this works currently is USAR essentially fits under our fire department. So what ends up happening is these Cal OAS resources come in and they work under our incident management system. So they've been fantastic. They've been doing a lot of work supporting our engineers and that sort of thing.
42:11 We have one more company that's going to stay and has been extended through the weekend. After that, that's going to move back to local resources. So we're working with Hayes' team and USAR people that are still here to set up a response system after they're gone. And essentially, we're going to be very conservative on these in the sense that we show up on something. We're going to red tag it if there's any damage because I'm not an engineer. I'm not going to make that call. At some point, we'll get some engineers out to take a look at that.
42:40 Bring it to a level that's appropriate for the damage. That being said, there may be structures where there is still a life hazard in, like we saw in Valdez Air, and that's going to require some sort of response, and that's going to be a team comprised of the fire department, engineers helping us with the appropriate shorting levels, and trying to bring in resources to recognize that they're probably going to be about 8 to 10 hours out at a minimum. Otherwise, I think the red tagging process has been really good, both for the immediate...
43:09 So while we're dealing with the
43:37 Immediate emergency. The system's going to be great as far as making sure because these aren't new, just the number of them is new. So this will help long-term make sure that we're keeping our building safe. Going back to the propane, we've had over 100 propane incidents since March. I didn't track it all the way to the beginning of the year. On a busy year before, if we had 40, that was I think 16, 17 was off 40. So this kind of gives you the magnitude on that. Also just...
44:04 For reference, the last large explosion we had prior to this was the 16-17 year. It was actually today. So a lot of times we start to think about kind of end of March, April as the end of the snow hazard. But that's kind of where our snow water equivalent is the highest and it's where our risk is the highest. I need to work on recovery, but I would again caution that we're not quite out of the woods on the response side. As you saw on the graph there, we had 10 calls on Saturday. Two of those were significant propane leaks.
44:33 It involved an area in the trails that had a pretty large leak that was difficult to mitigate. We had a house yesterday, just to give you some reference, that our engine company showed up on. I had a strong suspicion that it was full of propane. We've been forcing entry into these houses, which usually would be a tough call, but right now the crazy thing is more than half of the houses that we decided to break into, essentially, are full of propane. So the risk versus gain there has been really simple in my mind. Those present...
45:03 A difficult challenge because, again, because of the snow, we don't have a way to quickly shut off utilities. So we have a house that we now know is essentially a ticking time bomb and we don't have a way to get rid of the ignition sources. So those are honestly my biggest concern for our first responders right now in the sense that we try to ventilate them safely and mitigate the leak. So the one yesterday was actually not on a propane tank, not on the franchise line.
45:32 We were able to get it open and get it dug out. And then it ended up being actually people that live in town. So a lot of these have been second homeowners, but some of these have been roof shed now coming down and taking out lines right against the house. So it's hard to pick one certain scenario that we can say this is definitely X is the problem. The one commonality is the lines coming into the house that have been an issue. So again, kind of stressing like we had in our PIO videos. Keep that area safe and dug out.
46:01 The roof's not going to shed onto it. That's going to be the best for your safety. We do have the two Cal OES engines. They're going to be staying here. And I tend to try to be data-driven. So basically, when I see that propane chart going in the right direction, at that point, we're going to work on releasing those. Propane incidents take two to three engines at a minimum to conduct safely just because it's an involved operation.
46:27 CalAWS has been great to work with as far as supporting us with the resources that we need. I believe we are in a position that we are incrementally downsizing the USAR footprint. That's appropriate. But that extra agent coverage is going to be beneficial to the community for probably a few more weeks. Any other questions I can answer? On the whole thing, and probably for both you and Hayes, it just hit me when you said you were doing forced entrances. If you rent...
46:59 In town on a nightly basis, you're required to have a 24-7 presence with a key. I'm wondering if vacant second homes we shouldn't require, as we do on commercial building, Knox boxes that the fire department has the master key to get into so that we aren't, as someone who has been called out in the past after a forced entry to make the repairs, I'm just wondering if that wouldn't be, and this is just something that just, you know, hit me, that wouldn't be prudent for us to add.
47:29 Into our requirements so that there is a level of safety there that doesn't currently occur. Absolutely. So a couple of things. We're trying to force entry as gently as possible. So we're usually finding a window or however we can do that. But you're right. I think one of the lessons from this, there are some very low-hanging fruits that we should have tackled, honestly, years ago. And this needs to be a catalyst to make those happen. Knox boxes are one thing, but there are other things. Just, I mean, data. We need to be using it better to where...
47:57 You know, we should have a public safety repository. When you pay your taxes, have a little firm that says, hey, you want to add an Olivia with GIS is great. If you want to have your number and contact available so we can call you in an emergency, I mean, half the time we can open a garage door and open something. There's a risk there with propane. But to where those are things that, you know, it will be a real shame if we don't take advantage of things like potentially Knox boxes, databases.
48:24 Lecter is above your propane tank, just the low-hanging fruits to make our community safer. So I have a list of those. Our community members that have been here for a while have a list of those. Hayes is working on a list of those. I think that goes back to, you know, we had Chief John Adams here a while ago. You know, he was pretty, and this is going to be on me, you know, he said, what are you going to do in one year, what are you going to do in three, and what are you going to do in five? I'm still, unfortunately, in emergency mode. I'm still very concerned about the safety of my firefighters, so I haven't had a chance to.
48:51 Put together great PowerPoints or anything for that matter. But we do need to make sure that we have those steps moving forward. Because unfortunately, we are going to be busy in the spring and summer. And we have an October 1st date for people fixing a lot of these red tag issues. And that is going to be an incredible challenge. So at a minimum, we have to get to the low-hanging ones and have a plan to get to some of the harder ones, such as Knox boxes as well. Chris.
49:18 Just so I can sleep tonight, can you go back to the chart about the propane incidents? Because I think I misunderstood. So the USAR teams are leaving, but Cal OES is leaving two extra rigs to support you. Because this doesn't seem like we're ready to have everyone leave. So everyone is not leaving. What we are losing on the USAR branch, which they're a very technical group.
49:48 We've actually only used them on several instances. They've been great. They try to do as much community outreach and effort and work as they can while they're out here. They're very specialized in the sense that propane is actually an engine company hazard. And this is very strange even to firefighters because most people see it as a hazmat. But a hazmat team shows up with a really fancy rig, $4 million rig, and a whole bunch of equipment and suits that you usually see astronauts wearing. Propane.
50:17 Explodes and burns. So it really gets handled best by specially trained firefighters. It's interesting because on some of these fires, the Cal OES firefighters were letting our guys go first. They're like, yeah, you got this. And it's incredibly complicated work if you've never done it. I'll give you an example. On the tent we had at the trail. So this was a residence at the back of the trails where the snow had shed, broke the line, broke the line below the safety valve so there was no way to shut it off.
50:46 It also broke the window, so the house is filling up with propane. The people are in the house, so we're evacuating that house. We're also evacuating the neighboring houses. We don't have a good way to mitigate the ignition points on that because, again, all electrical is buried. So what we usually end up doing is trying to get into the house and shut off the panels, which is not ideal. It's not a 100% solution. And once we feel like we've created kind of our zones of red zone, yellow zone, green zone, got the public out, we try to dig to this valve, which is usually...
51:15 Buried in ice. So we're chipping away at it with brass tools that don't spark, which is an interesting tool that doesn't usually exist. Once we get to that, we have to make enough room to attempt to shut it off. And you shut it off and you go, oh, it's broken below. Dig some more ice and, you know, this isn't quick. You have to be on VA and in masks to be doing this work. And there's this next part, actually, I don't know of any fire department that trains on this, but Amerigas has essentially a crimping tool that they then give to us.
51:45 Cramp the line and try to pinch it without breaking it because there is no shutoff after that. You can see why the Calorius guys go, no, you guys, you're a little more experienced. You guys take the lead on this. So they're difficult situations. And that's why, again, we're not out of the woods. This just occurred on Saturday. We had a house yesterday that was having a potential explode. That being said, the right tool for that is engine companies.
52:12 Where the USAR team would come in very handy is if we had a collapse. It was not on fire like we saw in Valdez Air where we had victims inside. We do have a plan to keep moving forward because I hate to say it, but this could happen tomorrow. It could happen two months from now. So this is something that we have to have a local capacity to handle, unfortunately, because of where it is.
52:34 So we do have good plans on bringing people in. We're working with their team to stand up our team, but ultimately we'll be handling it. And for better, for worse, for propane emergencies, we're probably some of the best in the nation right now. The only thing is our people are tired. I mean, you know, a lot of times they're volunteers who you know who stay here, have two paid firefighters on at most at any given time. The rest are coming in who are just community members. So it is a...
53:04 Thanks. Yeah, that was my question. Just while that trend line isn't going down, that you have the support you need. I expected this, honestly, because of what the snow was doing. Sure.
53:31 Another factor in why that went up this weekend is we had that meltout. Bill was mentioning this last time we spoke where we all understand exactly what our snow is going to do. It starts to shift. The good news is it also starts to move away from the buildings. If you've been here for a while, you start to see that gap between the building and the snow bank. I've been checking mine at my house every day to see it because that's ultimately going to be a big factor in these lines not breaking. So there are a lot of things that are moving in our favor.
53:59 I am not going to be releasing calories rigs till I see that drop down significantly. But the reality is we expected a spike this weekend. Okay, thanks. We just want to keep you all safe. Appreciate it. Good. Good. Okay, please. All right, so we'll close this out. So if you do have your propane turned off, and we've had obviously a lot of instances where we've had to shut propane off.
54:26 That oftentimes does require a building permit. Broken lines, anything that's plumbing related does require a building permit. We are working with the propane providers to do emergency work and do the permitting process and the inspections after the fact to get the utility back on for the customers. It does require some tests and leaks and interior and exterior inspections to get the propane back on. It is a bit of a process.
54:52 This often has, there's a lot of people involved. You know, I've talked about my layered cake of property managers, HOAs, tenants, owners. So make sure you're speaking with the appropriate people who are responsible for making those decisions. The town's not going to assign that responsibility. We're going to work with the appropriate people that come forward. And then at the end of the day, the town and the fire department are responsible for the oversight and the permitting of the inspection process. Town does have a lot of good information out there on our website.
55:22 Stu has shared quite a bit of this on propane safety and what you should be doing. We do have a video that was put out, the star of the show, Gilbert's mustache, and the chief did a great job of putting out some great information on what we should be doing with our propane systems at our homes. That is the end of that long presentation. I can answer any questions that you may have. If not, I'll turn it back over to Dan.
55:50 Okay, so we'll do questions, public comment, then we'll get to the resolution after that. So any final questions, thoughts up here? I have a thought because my allergies are off the charts at the moment. Excuse me. But several people have said to me that we weren't ready for this because we're in a 15-year drought and we just haven't seen this in so long. And I would like to correct them. And Dan's time here at Mammoth, this is the third time we've had to have emergency responses because of snow.
56:20 It pays us. I'm sure that we will change some of the things we do and how we do them. But we need to stay prepared. And we can't do that for people as a government. They need to stay prepared themselves to a certain extent. Know where your propane lines are. Know where the shutoffs are. You know, shovel your roof. Do whatever is necessary. But to say we have forgot it because of this long drought is this continues to happen. It has always happened in my lifetime, once or twice a decade.
56:51 As another local told me in his 20 years of being here, he's gone through 900-year winters. Okay, anybody else? Chris, Amanda? A couple maybe idiotic questions. I don't know where to send people to get sandbags. Who do they get in touch with for that? 299 Commerce Drive. What, 9 to 5? They're sitting in the cinder shed. Okay, just go down to the yard and then get them. In terms of after-action stuff, I know...
57:26 Hayes, you've been with the LTC for a while, as I have been. 16, 17, there was a big push in the LTC, so we gotta debrief this, all these lessons learned, we've gotta, and I think this year, we started having that conversation in the LTC meeting this week, but I think we really need to start focusing on this. So, Alex, I'm sure that you're, at night, before you go to sleep or whatever, just start jotting down those notes of the things that we have to, we have to keep track of, because
57:53 I think that the town did a remarkable job with snow removal, managing our systems and all the rest of it. We had some challenges with some of our partners, state agencies, county, not to cast any aspersions, but we need to be able to document the things that have happened so that we can advocate to whoever will listen. I mean, we heard at the LTC meeting the great...
58:18 Climate Mitigation Adaptation Policy that's been adopted by the state for Caltrans and all the rest of it. Well, I think this region is on the front lines of that stuff. And I think we need to be able to advocate as electives and with our partners and our colleagues to be able to say to the state, look, you've got to get some resources out here. Because this isn't, it's not funny anymore. You get a Mona City cut off for how many weeks? Our main roads.
58:41 Avalanches, all the rest of it. So just encouraging everybody, keep your notes, take your photos, no matter how stupid or trivial they may be, but we have to do this efficiently. Gather all this information, get it to a nice, good, simple, clear document that we can use to try to bring resources back this way. All right, any public comments? Any thoughts? Horror stories to share? Anybody in the virtual? No? Okay. So Dan, please. Thank you.
59:11 Kind of the next step in this was really talking about how we want to propose and what we are doing to invest back in the community. As mentioned, we're very concerned of a lot of different areas here and a lot of different impacts. So the first thing we've done is we did...
59:26 They provide $200,000 to the Mammoth Mountain Community Foundation. It was a match for money they'd received from Mammoth Mountain Ski Area and the Altera Company. They have been utilizing that to help shovel roofs to clear out some of the propane, and they've also used it to haul some snow out of different areas as well. So they're stepping up in that, and we're helping the funding structure for that. The next couple of areas, as Hayes mentioned, authorizing staff for some emergency hires within the building department.
59:53 Some staff to help with inspections and permitting. And then we're looking at bringing an outside firm in that could actually provide inspection services, for example, at the Limelight Hotels Project. So we're not tying our staff up through that so they can be committed to doing the plan checks, little ones, big ones, be able to move that through very quickly, get permits issued, get inspections done. And then the challenge which we can't solve there will be do we have enough construction teams in town to actually do all the work?
1:00:22 That'll be a challenge that put out of our capabilities. But so that authority, then the three things this evening that we're asking for is one is two funding items noted in the staff report. One was $100,000 for working through Mammoth Lakes housing to be able to help people who are in need of emergency housing.
1:00:48 Temporary side, so we hopefully get some repair work done, get them back in their homes. Also, just some of the other necessity needs there. So that would be a $100,000 request. It'd be a similar agreement that we did with Mammoth Mountain Community Foundation. Secondly, we are looking at a small business grant program, very similar to what we did under COVID. Some restrictions there on size and capacity and stuff and putting that out there. We're very concerned, frankly, about the smaller businesses, the amount of cost.
1:01:18 So if there's a way to help kind of ease that cost issue, again, it's not going to offset a lot of it in some cases. We're hearing people talking about five or ten times more than normal.
1:01:43 So, but something that could go into that. We'll have a program set up for that. Sandra's team is working on that. She really took the lead on the COVID one. So looking at that, a little more simplification in the process. So she's got a good start through that. We'll finalize that up. Then the other item that we're requesting this evening.
1:02:07 Two I just mentioned, $100,000 from MLH and $500,000, small business, really concurrence for that. You can do that through an action item as you desire. But the other one really is this resolution that we added to the agenda. It's a resolution of the Town Council of the Town of Mammoth Lakes, State of California, finding in emergency circumstances to justify awarding a contract for street repair work without competitive bidding. It has some other requirements. We'll need to come back on a regular basis.
1:02:34 But we really do feel we need to get out in front of repair work on our streets. The number of potholes, the number of large sections of the street that have failed are definitely creating hazardous driving conditions. It's definitely impacting. You watch people, they'll swerve to miss something. Literally, I would not be surprised if we have car damage and stuff as people go through some of the size of the potholes that are in the community. We're looking at probably a $500,000 contract there.
1:03:04 We didn't specifically call out the number in the resolution at this point. We'll be working with the contractor, but that would be the framework that we're looking at committing. To do this emergency work, we'll have additional work down the road that we'll do through the normal process. But so those three actions of really investing back in our community, again, $100,000 through MLH, $500,000 small business grant program, and the approval of the resolution for the emergency.
1:03:33 Road work that we can continue to move that forward and get a contractor on board to start on that just as soon as possible. Okay, just for the council's edification, operating under our emergency declaration, this is theoretically within the authority of the town manager to do all this stuff? The $100,000 for MLH, the $500,000 small grant program could be done underneath that. The waiving of the competitive bidding process does require an action by the town council.
1:04:00 Okay. I just want to make sure we're clear how that's all working. Bring that forward as we're spending these size dollars so you're aware of what we're doing. Okay, good. So questions for Dan? We'll take some public comment and then we'll move to deliberation. I guess I just had a question. You know, $500,000 to small businesses. You know, what the, do we know what the parameters would be on that? Would that go to, like, nightly rental, Airbnb places, or what are you envisioning? This is truly our small retail and commercial businesses.
1:04:31 I'll use for example here, just because we're in this shopping center, it'd be like Faske, another T-shirt shop, one of those businesses. There'll be an application process, they'll have to file for it, maybe two tiers. We're working through the final. So no, it doesn't actually go to private residences, either like a private condo or a condo complex at this point. And then would that be available to landlords for retail?
1:05:01 I mean, I don't know how it's structured here, the payments, but you use FASCII. Yeah, it's usually through the CAM charges that businesses have to pay. So the idea is to get it in the hands of the businesses. They're the ones that will get charged by the landlord to make the payments accordingly out of their common area charges. We do have some restrictions, like, for example, here, bonds would probably not be eligible for that size of a business. Those types of elements, we do have some limits that way.
1:05:27 And then the idea is to get it into the businesses themselves. Those are the ones that we really want to say, hey, we're supporting you, whether they've already made a payment or they're waiting to be billed. So those things will be happening through that. So we'll get some additional information when we put that out that way. And that process will come back to council. Yeah, we'll definitely bring it back to you. We can get it started under this other authority, but we'll definitely let you see what the process looks like and what our recommendations are going forward with it. Okay, Chris, go ahead.
1:05:56 Yeah, less of a question, more of a comment, just to make it as transparent as possible, because, you know, in the absence of information, people fill in their own ideas, and that's how we end up with a lot of rumors that simply aren't true. So, just to get out ahead of that. And then the other thing is, I would say, my advice would be to make sure to let anyone who's going to apply, all apply at once, because, you know, the sort of opening and closing of applications that happened with...
1:06:26 The roof, the snow removal? Yeah, correct. They got overwhelmed. I understand. I totally understand. So that's just a lesson learned, you know, just so that the public feels more confident. I mean, there's been so much wonderful work done, and it's just a way of making sure that people- We'll have a time frame to get everything in. That also helps us manage the funding. Absolutely. That's great. I'm assuming then, Dan, you don't really need a motion on the housing and the small business grant because you are empowered to do that already.
1:06:57 Under the emergency declaration. Yeah, if you want to take an action off concurring with that action, that's always good, so we can lean back to that if we need to. You're right, it's not an absolute requirement, but it's nice to have that support. And Andy, I'm assuming that you are going to give us the proper motion for the emergency declaration on the non-bidding process? It'll be adopting the resolution that we handed out. Yeah, that's exactly it. The resolution that you have.
1:07:25 has the right recitals and findings, and so the motion could just be to adopt the resolution. Okay, good. Okay, good. Any public comment? Yes, Patricia. Yes, thank you. Hi, Patricia Robertson with Mammoth Lakes Housing. I know we've talked a lot about the physical structure side of this emergency, but I don't think I would be doing my job if I didn't speak to the human side. I think everyone's aware that one of our low-income housing...
1:07:59 Projects has been red-tagged and 10 households have been displaced and that includes 14 children. Since that happened on March 17th, those households have had to make really fast decisions regarding their daily lives while experiencing the trauma of being displaced. They have been staying in hotels, Airbnbs, their place of work.
1:08:30 Other unsafe situations and also commuting from Bishop to go to work and bring their children to school. Our staff have reached out to all of the households and we've been in contact with them but as of Monday we averaged their personal emergency expenses and each household has spent on average $3,500 in expenses for lodging, food, gas and other unexpected emergency.
1:09:01 Clothes, actually, clothes for their children and other things. That's three times their normal monthly rent. According to the CDC, you probably know being displaced is a form of trauma and causes feelings of isolation, feelings of being neglected by society and the government, disruptions to life, daily life routines, separation.
1:09:30 Worries about the conditions of their home, they have no idea. Loss of personal items like family pictures, they don't know, are they still there, or in some cases they're not, we know. And then difficulty getting to work for various reasons. In response to this, our staff have been in contact with all 10 of the households.
1:09:55 And we offered to make appointments with them to assist in completing the Altera Community Foundation Emergency Grant application through their program. All 10 households have submitted an application, and they used Mammoth Lakes Housing as a reference, and I supplied a cover letter for their application. We are also actively working with Mammoth Mountain and the town to secure temporary housing resources.
1:10:23 For those that are maybe commuting from Bishop or don't have resources available at the moment. And I'm also in contact with a couple of other private property management companies. I think those resources will be important, but it's good to note that a lot of them are temporary, and so these households will have to continue to move based on the occupancy of these units.
1:10:52 I'll also mention that we have been fielding calls from other people in the community. We get a lot of foot traffic in our office, but also a lot of calls from people who have been impacted by the emergency in different ways, not just displacement. We had a family referred by the school district that was displaced because their unit didn't have electricity for 10 days and they were living in a hotel and the school district referred them to us.
1:11:21 We've had another call from someone who has endured a head injury from falling snow and ice and is now not working at the moment due to their physical trauma experience. Then we've also had someone call who's been displaced because their landlord is going to do a cosmetic renovation.
1:11:52 Eviction moratorium. You know, I haven't heard anything about that, but, you know, terminating a lease for a cosmetic renovation isn't really the tenant's fault or, you know, a cause to evict somebody because they didn't pay their rent, for example. And so that's just something we've been asked about, but that obviously isn't, we're not talking about that tonight.
1:12:20 Our low-income residents are some of our most vulnerable community members. They often have a language barrier, technology barrier. They may have an organizational barrier and have likely not been keeping their receipts. And so the ability for them to be fully reimbursed by the landlord, who's ultimately responsible, is unlikely.
1:12:51 So I guess I just wanted to make that statement regarding the temporary housing program, and I think it would be beneficial to the community to expand the use of those resources to make some nominal contribution to acknowledge the stress that certain individuals have experienced due to this emergency, other than just paying for temporary housing.
1:13:17 But maybe to help cover the new clothing they had to buy for their children or other types of expenses. I don't think the point is to enrich, unduly enrich anybody, but to just acknowledge that they have gone through something traumatic and have already paid three times their monthly rent for a period of 23 days. I wanted to let you all know that
1:13:46 Mammoth Lakes Housing now has four full-time staff members, and we've actively been working on this situation and responding to folks who are coming to us, and we're fully equipped and ready to respond in whatever way the town and the community feel is appropriate. Thank you. Just one question. Are you in touch with Mono County?
1:14:11 I mean, all the whole variety of social services at the county. You didn't mention them. I'm just hoping you're in touch with them. So early on in, I think it was early around the Watch Out for Falling Buildings emergency declaration, which was March 16th or something, I reached out to Mono County and the town to ask if they needed us and let them know that we were available and let us know if they had resources that they would like us to help.
1:14:42 Refer people to. Nobody really responded at that time that there was anything available, but I do know from working closely with the county that a lot of their programs are very specific, so in some cases you have to be a senior and be disabled. In some other funds that they have, you have to have an active child welfare case and a case worker. Those are two examples, and our staff are well-
1:15:11 I'd like to put this into two motions if that's all right. One.
1:15:44 to approve the 100,000 housing and the 500,000 business improvement grant as presented. Okay, so is there a second for that? I'll second. Any additional discussion? Jamie, please. Councilmember Bubzer? Yes. Councilmember Rice? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Souser? Yes. Mayor Wentworth? Yes. John, secondly, I would like to make a motion to approve the emergency resolution as presented.
1:16:17 This is a resolution of the Town Council, Town of Mammoth Lakes, State of California, finding the emergency circumstances justify awarding a contract for street repair work without competitive bidding. Yes. I'll second. Great. Motion to second. Additional discussion. No. Jamie, please. Councilmember Bubzer. Yes. Councilmember Rice. Yes. Mayor Pro Temp Souser. Yes. Mayor Wentworth. Yes. Okay. Well, thank you all. More to come. And great work to all members of the Town, staff and team. You guys do a great job with us.
1:16:47 Okay, so because this is a- We'll get stuff set up for the budget? Sure. Okay. I was going to say it's a special meeting so we don't take breaks. But- We'll take a special break. We'll take a special break. 5.25, so seven minutes. Stretch and move around. Okay. Let's get some work done here. So we are now moving on to item 4.1. We're not going backwards. We're just going out of order.
1:27:25 This is the fiscal year 23-24 preliminary budget department requested. And Mr. Patterson, I believe this is your item. It is. Thank you very much. So this is part of our budget series. I will say it's a long process. We obviously start the budget long about February, looking at our revenues. And we work through this sort of methodically as we have information that
1:27:54 That comes to us or we are working through how we are changing maybe our core services. This particular presentation is called the preliminary budget because it's the first time the department head level review of budget has been put before council. So I'm going to work through this. I do have a series of policy questions for town council to address directly. I will stop at those points.
1:28:21 And just sort of allow for dialogue and finalization. The first thing I want to start with here is just kind of a reminder of projected revenues. We have been working either on an emergency or on department-level budgets and haven't really made any edits or updates to the presentation that you all received in the middle of March. So I'm not going to go through that whole process again.
1:28:47 But I did want to kind of put before council just exactly where we had decided to be at that particular time with our revenues. Now, as I said, work continues on this. I would expect to see some edits coming through for revenue and expenditures on each of these iterations that we review. The next full review will be at the end of May, and that will be almost 90% complete, and then we'll have the final adoption in June.
1:29:16 So there'll be edits and updates as we go through that entire process. As a reminder, on the revenue side, we had a total revenue of $30,103,400 as an estimate at that particular point in time. Some of the key items that we had was transit occupancy tax at $18 million or $2 million higher than prior, a little bit of an increase in sales tax and property tax, as well as building permits and business tax.
1:29:43 That building permits was prior to a lot of the emergency activity, so likely that will go up just a little bit, but in total, here's how that looks on a chart with regard to just the size of the pie, if you will. As I mentioned, I'll have a series of policy questions that come through this, and really what these help me do is really form what you want to include in the operating budget and what
1:30:14 Maybe can be funded in a quarterly or third party or third party. I'd love for third party to pay for some of these bills, but a quarter presentation. The first one of these is our funding of reserves for budget process. Now, we have in the past funded our reserves. Yes, sir. Before we get into all this, one question. You don't have to have an answer to this now.
1:30:40 One of the components of our budgeting discipline and the budgeting process that we're using, at some point, the lines are going to start to converge where the costs of doing business, just our base nut is going to start to converge with TOT, surpluses and all the rest of it. At some point, I think it would be helpful for council to understand where are we at. And Dan, in your and Rob's estimation, when do we think those things are going to start?
1:31:07 Getting to the point where there's some policy stuff may be necessary to address that. Yeah, certainly. That's something that we discuss quite often. We call it the inflection point, where we're going to end up with what we truly believe to be maximum achievable revenues crossing with our actual operating expenditure, which would have a couple of different...
1:31:30 Fairly significant impacts, number one being with reduced air available excess funding that we provide to a lot of programs, which we've been very lucky to have done, and the council has been good about that, but also really just requires, I think, more focus on the discipline that we already employ now about being very conservative in our expenditure growth. As you'll see as we walk through the salary, a little bit of that is out of our control.
1:31:59 And that's what's going to push up the number the fastest. The problem is determining where the revenues are. So I've done a lot of review of just exactly where we've gone in this revenue increase over the last couple of years. And I'm sorry, I don't have a chart on that to show how that.
1:32:29 And we started to climb up from that perspective. But first steps were in the $15 million range. The last couple of years, I believe, were going to be $26 to $27.5 million range. Where is that actual top? And is it slightly lower than what we've seen as a cap, for example? So that kind of dictates the revenue side of it. And I believe somewhere in the...
1:32:54 In the TOT at $22 million range, you know, is probably a realistic expectation, which would put this, you know, cap number here to be probably around $34.35 for total revenue. But with our wage increases, as we've seen over the last couple of years, that could come as soon as three years from now. And again, this is barring any major impacts. This would be within about three years, we could hit those inflection points.
1:33:23 So that's always something that keeps me up at night. But again, we don't, the way we do our budgeting process is to be cognizant of that always. We're adding bodies or we're adding different core services as we've done recently. We are also looking for ways of being coming more efficient because that is our most expensive item. So it's great that you brought that up. I didn't want to dive that much into that, but it's out there. It's on the horizon.
1:33:51 Okay, good. Just didn't want to distract you from what you're doing, but that's when there's going to be some policy choices and things we got to make. We want to make sure we're aware of that. So thank you. So I was talking a little bit about some of the policy questions, and actually, Mayor, this is a very good segue into that first item. As I said before, we were funding a lot of the reserves based upon available funds later in the year, and I'll walk through just for a second here what our reserve policy and adjustments are.
1:34:21 We have a fairly robust reserve policy. It's based upon setting a standard revenue target that we want to utilize as our percentage of coverage for reserves. We have four total components of our reserve policy. One is a reserve for economic uncertainty, and that one is if the bottom fell out of either business or there was some sort of a major disruption in our ability to produce revenue.
1:34:50 How do we keep the lights on? That is only used in emergencies. That reserve is 20%. In this particular case, it's going to be a total of $6 million. And so that's really sort of last-ditch effort to protect us from a major impact. The operating reserve is more of a cash flow opportunity. So if we needed funding for either an event or funding for not a...
1:35:18 And that really has helped our credit ratings as well as just looking at our overall
1:35:46 Reserve policy as being very robust. And so we added that, and that's about $1.1 million. And then the final element is our contingency fund, which is $100,000, and that's part of the budget. So when I talk about this, every year when I look at the total sort of revenue that we built, I will match that baseline revenue to what we are for the current fiscal year.
1:36:11 We generated that in a year when we were hitting the pandemic, and we actually reduced revenue expectations. We did not want to reduce the reserve expectations. In the past, I would make this increment and say, okay, here's the balance I have in each of these funds, and I have a gap. In this particular case, I have a gap of $514,000. I would fund that from one-time monies. Today, or what I'm asking you,
1:36:36 Do you want to take these questions?
1:37:07 Tell us how you want to do this. I think it would be helpful. I'm going to stop now, and I'd like to get this question. So what I have built into the budget so you know is that part of what I call expenditures as the operating budget is funding that $514,000. So that would take our total reserves up to $8.6 million, and we would be fully funded on that based upon the way we built this in the budget today. Okay, so questions for Rob?
1:37:34 So historically we funded reserves at the end of the year or from excess? Typically we will fund them in the fund balance presentation in October. Okay. Thank you. Right now we're just dealing with the debt reserve. Your mic's off. No, right now we're dealing with a gap that has occurred in the REU and the operating reserve. Yeah. And that's based upon increasing the limit expectation. I'm just making notes two items ahead of your crop, sorry. No problem.
1:38:04 Yeah, I have no questions. I think it's great taking it out of the regular budget up front. I agree that's a much more responsible method of doing it. And as we get further into that inflection point. I guess I had a question. Saying that it's fully funded at $7.5 million. Does that number change each year? Or, you know, what's our savings goal? Yeah, so...
1:38:34 It does change each year, and it's based upon the growth of our budget. So when we are saying that our reserve policy is a percentage of budgeted revenue, we set that based upon our analysis in determining that top. So last year it was $27.5 million, and that's sort of where we were in the overall budget. Expectations this year, it's $30 million, and that, again, matching closely to where we were.
1:39:06 Town Council has set the rates of 20% for our REU and 5% for operating reserve. So it's just me bringing up, you know, hey, we've got about $30 million as our new target. That requires, that's where the gap usually comes from. We do have interest that we earn on this that is applied to direct funds. So, and their interest rates are fairly substantial now, so we probably will have less in a few years at least. But that's exactly how that's generated. The only thing that doesn't change is the debt reserve, which is the other 1.1.
1:39:37 That takes that 7.5 you see on the top and takes it to 8.6 million. Okay, thanks. Okay, I don't have any questions with this. It's pretty straightforward. Do you need a motion or is consensus okay? We're just looking for consensus on that and if it tweaks around a little bit as we bring the budget back, we'll note that. But this is more policy. If there's a big difference to say, no, don't fund it now, that changes what we do in the budget. Leave it in, then we know what we're working with as we move forward in the next phase of the budget.
1:40:11 I don't anticipate any public thoughts on this. My only final comment on this, if I could, John, is that we are currently in both together at 25% of our annual operating budget, which gives us X number of months to operate if everything falls through tomorrow. And personally, when we did this, I was pushing for 30%, so I'm happy with 25%, but that may be something in the future that we may want to look at. Okay, so I think we're good. Perfect, thank you. Yep.
1:40:40 The next item, and I'm going to say these two bullet points are related to a degree. We typically talk about MLT contract funding a little bit earlier in the year. Last year, anyway, we talked about it in January when we sort of set some focus points for the MLT board as well as we talked about the funding. And this is an integral part of their development of budget.
1:41:08 For 23 and 24, but also where the town's budgets are outlined. So I'm going to pause when I get to, I'm calling it a reconciliation, but it's just really a detailed list of what we're doing for tourism. And I'll pause there for that response. The second one is on the excess budget to measure A allocations going to housing now for housing and tourism.
1:41:37 That's something that prior counsel has directed us to do. And so we have built that into the budget, and I just wanted to highlight that and just confirm that current counsel would like to see that to continue. So again, when I get to that point in the presentation, I'll pause and then seek input on that. Okay, because I think it would make sense to talk about this excess budget measure A to housing now first. And there's a little bit of exposition missing here, which is...
1:42:07 Correct me if I'm wrong, but Measure A, the political commitment was transit, housing, and marketing. That's correct. And there's a reserve fund for each one of those categories set up for that. So I think when you get to this, I think it would be helpful to really, you know, go by each one of those political commitments, where it's all going so we don't talk about Measure A as an aggregate. I think that would be helpful. And then if we get that figured out, and then we'll, yeah, okay, there it is. Perfect. Thank you. You're like magic, John. You've got it right in front of you.
1:42:37 And away we go. There it is. So as Mayor Wentworth was talking about the Measure A allocations, in the staff report itself, I did give quite a bit more detail that talked about the timing of when we had increments to transit and occupancy tax, and then how those initiatives, their various initiatives, there was Measure A and Measure T at different times, and how they were committed to tourism, transit, and housing.
1:43:04 Across those, that time period. I also gave some of the updates that occurred, I believe it was 2017-18, when council members took on a re-evaluation of that allocation and just sort of set it a little bit differently than it had been before, providing more funding for housing, but at the same time building reserve accounts specific to each one of those three. And these reserve accounts are there because
1:43:32 We allocate based upon the budget, but then as you know, there are excess TOT revenues that come in later in the year, and so the excess doesn't automatically just go into these categories, it goes into a reserve. And so we'll talk a little bit about how that looks here in subsequent slides, but those reserves are what really come before council. They have the opportunity to engage those in really, frankly, anything that would help the community.
1:44:01 As it is today, but the same ratios are here. So, for example, the rate of allocation for transient occupancy tax revenue line item only is 18.07 percent of that goes to tourism. And when I say to tourism, it goes to a department called tourism within the general fund, within the town's revenue and town's expenditures. And that total pot of money is for tourism and promotional activities.
1:44:31 Again, I'll walk through that just shortly here in a second. There's also one of those departments for transit and one for housing. Both of the allocation rates for those two elements are 6.53 percent, and in this case about 11.6. The total left over at the end would be what is available for town general fund. And again, these are not voter initiatives that require these. These were general tax.
1:45:00 Elements, so they're just allocated by town council action. And so that's something that we've established and we can kind of continue on with that. I did put at the bottom of the slide here really what non-government organization or agency typically is involved in utilizing those funds. And I'll again dive into that just shortly. The first of these, and this is the look that you'll see for the other three elements as well.
1:45:32 It's just how the budget is allocated for housing. So again, this is within the general fund. You'll see it as a department in the general fund, very similar to like finance, for example, as it being its own department. I talk about how the allocations are atop the $1,176,000 total revenue for housing from a budgetary standpoint. Then we have the components that are listed in there as expenditures. So these are historical. These are what are currently built into the budget.
1:46:00 And I will say that some of them are not yet set. So, for example, Mammoth Lakes Housing Contract is set in here at $336,000. That was last year's contract amount. I believe it's still in negotiation. There may be a possibility for slight adjustments to that. The town staff, we do an allocation of all of our labor costs, and we'll go into a lot of detail on labor a little bit later.
1:46:25 And just where they're charged to. So we have specific people that are housing only that are in these numbers. And we also have a number of other departments that have a lot of activity that go on with housing. And so they're also a percentage of their time is charged to that. And so that's where that $233,000 expenditure comes up. We have some ancillary expenses like deed restriction monitoring to make sure that we don't lose any deed restricted housing, clerk servicing for the town.
1:46:53 And just ancillary advertising and legal notices. So total expenditures that we have in this particular department are $592,000. That leaves an excess revenue over expenditures of $584,000. I am recommending, as prior town council had suggested, those excess funds on a budgetary standpoint be transferred into our Housing Now program.
1:47:19 Any thoughts on this? You are going to go over.
1:47:48 So that the public out there understands as well as us that this allocation to housing is only a very small portion of what we're actually putting into housing. Yes. Because it's important that people understand that. This isn't our housing allocation. This is just a housing allocation that comes out of this specific commitment. That's correct. That's a good point, Bill. So with the political commitments and how they take the TOT revenue and separate it into these three elements,
1:48:19 This is simply just taking how we are going to allocate those items alone. I would say in the last fiscal year, when we look at excess revenues or we even look at available fund balances that have occurred either within tourism revenue or reserves, housing reserves, or general fund for the town, we've allocated more than $10 million.
1:48:42 Can we call them instead?
1:49:12 You know, XSTOT comes with so many different connotations. Would anyone be offended if we called it uncommitted revenues or something like that? Because I just think it creates this whole impression. I don't know. When I hear XSTOT, I find it confusing, and I also think it just creates an impression of not what we're trying to do, which is we're trying to budget.
1:49:40 As conservatively as possible for the basic services we have to provide. And then, but I also question, I mean, I understand why we do it, but it just begs a lot of questions. I think it really, because if you're a member of the public, I mean, it took me like a solid year to really understand all of this. Is there any, am I the only one? I think, no, I think wordsmithing is an important.
1:50:09 Thing that the council does. This may not be the time to do it. But I think we should put that in the parking lot somewhere and let's come back to make it more easily cognizable to the public. I could real quick. Often we've referred to it as either larger than anticipated or larger than budgeted versus excess. Excess sounds like it is. Hey, it's leftover money. But if it's actually larger than anticipated budget, that tends to look at it. Because that goes across several revenues.
1:50:39 Not just TOT. And it gets misrepresented a lot, and it behooves us as council members to explain it to our constituents as well as we can. How many times do we hear someone say, with all the excess TOT, why the heck haven't you guys fixed all the problems in town? Well, it is over what we anticipate, and we are busily fixing the things in town that we can possibly fix.
1:51:05 Under those constraints. But also if, like John so aptly pointed out at the beginning, if we're three years away from it sort of converging and there's not going to be that, I think it's really time for us to start finding terms that will help people understand. That's all. And I will. No, it's good. Point well taken. Amanda, you're good, right? Okay, so I think, yeah, I'm certainly good with this. And Bill, your point about.
1:51:34 You know, this is a contribution. This is one of many places where we're making contributions, and we'll hear more about these contributions on these other items. Since we're expounding on this, it's really important that it came up a little bit earlier. There is going to be a time, which is really only about three or four years out, where these overages will no longer exist, and those extra millions of dollars will not be there to put into some of these programs, and we have to think about that now. No matter how we deal with it in the budget,
1:52:04 The additional cost of labor, the additional cost of everything we do is going to slowly choke that out. Yep. Okay. So I think there's a consensus up here. Any thoughts from out there in the public or in the online world? No. Okay. Rob, thanks. Tourism, very similar process, same exact format. As I mentioned in the previous slides, the allocation to tourism is slightly higher at 18.07%.
1:52:34 So that provides about $3.2 million available for that fund. The expenditures I have listed here, again, Mammoth Lakes tourism contract set at $2 million for the year. That is what's built into the budget today. That was the prior year's dollars available. We also have a Chamber of Commerce contract. It's about $300,000 a year. It comes out of the same pot of funds, as well as some LA Kings, which is a...
1:53:04 We have an advertising contract with our Community Recreation Center, and that's $100,000. I believe there's another $150,000. This is a five- or six-year commitment, so we've been whittling down that fund on an annual basis. We have recommendations for $100,000 in litigation support, and that would be covering any sort of lawsuit that may come about with regard to redoing of TBID.
1:53:33 Or anything else, DOT-wise, that we may have, or tourism-based. The host program, there's contribution from the tourism to fund that program. And so that is actually a transfer that feeds other departments within the town's general fund in order to cover the cost of that program. We have, again, fish stocking for $50,000 and then clerk servicing for $10,000. So total...
1:53:59 Identified expenses that are appropriate for tourism-based is $2.66 million, which leaving about $593,000 in available funds for tourism that, again, based on prior council action, we're recommending to go to Fund 245 Housing Now programs. A little bit more than $1.178,000, I believe, in these two elements, contributing to housing alone. Okay. Any questions for any of these items or any of the...
1:54:29 Expenditures, recommended expenditures. So the one thing I would like to pause here too as well, John, is to get council thoughts around the $2 million allocation to Mammoth Lakes Tourism. Okay, let's park that for the moment. Anything other than the $2 million contribution to Mammoth Lakes Tourism? The one thing I keep hearing that our townsfolk talk about is they're concerned about certain things like
1:54:59 When our visitors come, making things better for visitors so that it'll also be better for the public. So for example, when people arrive in town, they don't know where to use a public bathroom so they end up in our businesses. Or those kinds of things that we keep kind of just hearing about a lot. And is this the fun from which we would, because it sort of just keeps coming up, like where are the bathrooms? Where are the extra bathrooms at the lakes basin? Where is this and that?
1:55:29 You know, I sort of wonder, is this where we pay for it? Because I don't see, you know, I'm all for funding housing as much as humanly possible, but I also feel like that question just never goes away. So I think the kinds of things you're mentioning are capital infrastructure type projects. And I think the best place for those, and correct me if I'm wrong, is to get them into the CIP and have them identified in the CIP. And I think the TBIT discussions which we have, which I think have been very good.
1:55:57 I think when we get into those discussions, there's going to be a way to start helping the MLT board and the MLT organization help us identify what things, what are the capital needs for those specific projects, and then to what degree the TBID may be able to help in partnership with the town fund those kinds of things. And, I mean, these capital expenses are going to be pretty significant. So this is not, I mean, there's not, you know, this is not the place I would suggest to be taking that kind of stuff from.
1:56:27 I agree. I just wanted to bring it up, you know, because it has to come up at some point. Absolutely. And I, Dan and I, we had a long conversation about that today. And I think I'm going to go back to that TBID discussion a little bit. I think there's going to be some real opportunity there to start framing that up and how that's going to work. And there's a lot of, you know, when you start talking about bathrooms at the Lakes Basin, while the Forest Service is building a whole bunch of new bathrooms up there, get into the...
1:56:54 Doing infrastructure on federal public lands, it gets... I totally get it. It's just, you know, I do feel like that's something that just never stops coming up. So, thanks. No, no, noted. So, I do want to address, and a good segue as well, is the Capital Improvement Program is slated for discussion on May 3rd. Okay, good. This presentation that we bring forward. And that's a very comprehensive list of projects as well as funding sources for that.
1:57:22 I will say as a town and as an organization, we have not, we can't solely be a one-trick pony when it comes to just putting anything we ever get into housing. While it's the most important thing that we have out there, I think, as a community, a lot of times we will bring forward suggestions or requests of counsel to look at excess TOT for projects where it makes the most sense. So that would be an opportunity, I think, to make sure that's addressed as you think. Okay, good. Bill, Amanda?
1:57:55 Okay, so let's talk about the $2 million expenditure to the Mammoth Lakes Tourism Contract. Yeah, so again, I think in prior years, this is less than we've provided to Mammoth Lakes Tourism in prior years, and what we've asked them to do is sort of reduce a little bit of dependency on Measure A allocations in their operational expenditures.
1:58:25 I will say that it is definitely an integral part of the funding structure of that organization as well as the relationship between the town and Mammoth Lakes Tourism as far as input into the overall marketing effort. So we contract with them and the contract with Mammoth Lakes Tourism is based upon us paying them to perform these marketing services and that's where the $2 million payment from the town is directed.
1:58:54 And it gives us that voice, an opportunity to sort of direct those work plans or at least give focus points to those work plans. So the $2 million, again, is something that we landed on last year, and that was a reduction, I believe it was 2.3 or maybe even 2.33 prior year to that. So there has been a slight decline in that number, but would like to get some consensus from Council. Okay, who's got a thought? I'm more than willing to go first, if you like.
1:59:24 Okay. Go ahead. I wholly encourage us to keep that $2 million. This is what makes us partners. We are probably not working together as closely as we should now. If we lose this and they are funded completely by TBID, then we really lose the opportunity to be partners with them. And this is a hugely important thing. If we go back to the original...
1:59:50 Measure A commitments as they were made as 86 and 96 and everything moved forward. The actual amount of DOT that MLT would currently be getting is somewhere in the $5 million range. So we have taken 60% plus of that away and are using it for other purposes. I think we've cut probably of this as far as we should go. I agree.
2:00:18 With this, we worked hard when we made these changes so that we could fund housing to a higher degree. And I think this is, it is the right amount for us for now. Okay. Anybody else? Amanda? Well, I'd just like to say, Bill, since you bring up the 1980s and, you know, how Measure A funds were initially meant to be spent, that was pre-TBID.
2:00:43 You know, that was when MLT had no funding and we all got to see John in his 10 cup go around asking for money. That was pre-TBID. So, you know, I feel like they're kind of double dipping in that they have their own revenue source and, you know, they're working for the businesses. Mammoth Mountain wants airport subsidies. They're giving them airport subsidies. You know, I feel like...
2:01:12 I don't know if there's more wiggle room with cutting that back more. So I would be interested to hear those options. The one thing that I would say that I find that the rationale for our doing it is that that creates a partnership that the $2 million that the Town of Mammoth Lakes puts in makes it a partnership. But I don't see the partnership. And I'm not...
2:01:45 Placing blame on any individual. I just don't see a partnership. So I would really want to see the plan for how that work comes together. And again, I'm not placing blame on either the town or Mammoth Lakes Tourism. I just want us to have a much more clear reason.
2:02:13 That the town needs to contribute that. When we all know that, as Amanda pointed out, when the political commitment was made, I mean, it was in 86 and 96 in 2002 and 2006. So the cheap, it didn't come in until 2012. So it's just, it seems like we're, I'll give you an example. There's an old story about
2:02:42 Making a brisket for Passover. So, okay. So the daughter comes to the mom and says, okay, how do I do it? She's like, cut the end off, then put in pot. So grandma's in the other room. And they're like, grandma, why do we cut the end off? And they say, because the pot was too small. But now, you know, so it's kind of like we're doing this because we always did is what I'm hearing. And with a little bit added in of, and we need to have a seat at the table.
2:03:12 And I would just say I would like to see more results that really come back to the town. Yeah. And if I could, I'd just follow up on that. I think so last June, we had a discussion where we capped it at $2 million, no more percentage. And there was all kinds of representations made about how we would partner and how we would work together. None of that came to fruition.
2:03:42 So the blame lies with the town and the blame lies with MLT. If we're going to be throwing blame, it's not blame, but we failed to make that partnership work. So I am, I'm with Bill, I'm fully supportive of the $2 million for now. And I think I want to be, I want to make sure we're very clear about the legal restrictions on TBID and how it can be used. If we were to say we're not going to give any measuring money to Mammoth Lakes Tourism,
2:04:12 The council has one shot, which is the approval of the district plan. Once that's done, they're off and running. And we don't have, so when the constituents come to us and say, oh my God, what's going on with all this marketing? We say, well, we don't have any skin in the game. It's, you know, we gave that, we let that horse run from the barn. So I'm very much looking forward to your point. When we get into the contract negotiation with MLT.
2:04:40 In combination with the discussion around the TBID, that we do this exactly the work that you're talking about and we bring this together. Because it's not just a partnership. I mean, this is much more profound. This has got to be a functioning working relationship. If we have to provide technical capacity to the MLT board to understand what kinds of projects the town can actually build, what we can do as part of the public works process, we're going to do that.
2:05:07 We're going to give you guys whatever you need so when you can start making recommendations, these are things that we can practically consider and actually build. I think the CIP process is going to be a big part to play in this. Again, it goes back to what you were talking about before. We need public bathrooms. We need these kinds of things that are connected to tourism. Okay, let's bring the TBID money and some of this general fund money. We cannot afford to fail. So I'm supportive of $2 million. I think it's a good place to start, to start having these conversations.
2:05:39 It's going to come down to what's in that contract. And there's a relationship between the DB and the contract with MOT. We've got to bring all this. Yes, go ahead. One more important thing that you said, John, you didn't emphasize it enough. I'm sorry. Please, emphasize it for me. Thank you. Is the fact that TBID is far more restricted in how it can be used than the $2 million in DOT revenue that goes money? This can be used to subsidize part of the airlines that cannot be paid for with TBID because it's not tourists coming to our business.
2:06:12 Thank you very much. Thank you.
2:06:47 And I think the Measure A money could facilitate that, help to expedite relationships, building the kinds of issues we talked about. Eastern Sierra Airlines, this working group, staff's been going on, there's a lot of opportunities. And having the Measure A money available as part of that is going to, as you say, facilitate that process. It's got to benefit the people. Just add one more thing, like an observation. So, and, you know, when you look at, so, you know, part of the thing is,
2:07:25 When the tourists come, we want to tell them to recreate responsibly. So there's different messaging we've put out. And that's valid. But I also just question
2:07:37 The wisdom of the town saying, OK, MLT, then you have to do that, because MLT has invested a lot of time and money in an advertising campaign, and now we have this mixed messaging, because if you go to the splash page of the website, it's talking about regulating responsibly, not real, unreal. And so I just want to make sure, like, you know, we have all of these professionals doing their different pieces of these very important tasks, and that we just set
2:08:06 More clarity and we aren't, you know, saying MLT first do this, no go do that. And so that we're, we're having a bit of whiplash. And I just think clarity of roles and responsibilities in a contract, who's doing what is so essential. So if that's necessary for the town of Mammoth Lakes to have a say in how some of this marketing and messages are going out, then that's fine.
2:08:35 I just can't state strongly enough that just to have a seat at the table by not using that seat well, I think this is an admonishment to town more than... I mean, that's exactly where I would go with that. Okay, we're going to have a seat. We're working with them. We have to... We didn't... Something happened. We didn't show up. We didn't get... A lot of this stuff was said in that meeting. Well, sure, but first, I want to make sure that we heard the consensus from the council. What's that? I didn't hear consensus.
2:09:24 Okay, I'll state what I thought, and I'll go to public comment in a second. Hang on, just one second. That, what's that? Well, okay, I'm trying to figure out where we're at, so that's what I'm trying to hear. So I think you heard from Bill and I, and I won't speak for Chris, that there's support for the $2 million, at least at this point. We're not in the budget. We haven't approved that. We haven't approved the contract. Chris, do you want to speak for yourself? So I think for the next year, it's worth...
2:09:59 Making the conservative effort to make this work. But I also think just making an assumption going forward is just not a wise path. Well, I would like to add to your comment about, oh, well, you know, if we give them this $2 million, we can have a voice in what they do with it. And I just wanted to reiterate that, you know, if TPIT gets approved for five or 10 years, you can't tell them what to do with a dime.
2:10:29 Yeah, but we just have to have...
2:10:55 But I feel like the way that you stated it, that, oh, you know, your constituents are worried about TBID and that doing this, then we'll have a say with TBID funds as well. I feel like I heard you mention something like that. I'm not sure, let me say that again. That you said that your constituents are worried about how TBID is being spent, and if we give MLT $2 million, then we have more direction with them. Well, I'm just, I don't think it's what I, I'll, let me.
2:11:27 Try to say what maybe you thought I said. The point I was trying to make is that the TBID funds are very restricted in how they can be used. Right. Because the TBID funds have to benefit from being assessed, right? Which are the businesses, yes. Yeah, we're just saying that that has to directly. I understand that. That's the loop on that. With the Measure A money, that's general fund money. And I'm proposing that the allocation of the $2 million be very specifically defined.
2:11:58 Yeah, I would just like to say my last comment is I don't think that we have a visitation problem here. I think that we have more than enough people coming to Mammoth.
2:12:28 You know, MLT has really spread the word, and there are more than enough visitors here, and that's not the current problem that we have. When TBID was put in place 10 years ago, we were in a recession, our numbers were down, we put this in place to drive visitation, and I feel that we no longer have a visitation problem. So do they still need that extra $2 million? I don't know. Well, would it be fair to say that we could...
2:12:58 I think move forward with the preparation of the contract with MLT and scope, you know, deliverables and all that kind of stuff. I think what I'm here to see, how is that $2 million, how is the seat of the table, what value is that bringing to the community, unless you want to say something else. To talk about it next month. To have staff start drafting up the scope of work that would be in our contract, how that fits into the T-Bid and for the council. Are we getting...
2:13:40 Sufficient value from a contract with a very specific and then form what investment we've been kind of saying. Okay, so does that, do you guys have what you need? Yeah, I was just going to make some comments and John, you sort of made some of these. The amount listed on here pays for that contract. That, where staff may have failed this year, in January of last year when we talked about funding, we also talked about this council giving direction exactly to MLT. Chris, you mentioned, you know, a variety of different things we asked them to do and we do ask them to do.
2:14:28 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
2:14:58 Overarching list of things that we want them to accomplish. The third item, and this is what we discuss annually, are the set of deliverables, which can be from 1 to 20 or 30, that are specific to achieving those overarching items. And again, this is all within the Measure A allocation dollars. This isn't in how you're going to spend TBID, because you're right, there's no direction on where TBID is spent. It's defined.
2:15:26 The third element to that is the compensation. That's an element. And the fourth and final is a list of times when we will come together and discuss things. So it's an annual planning calendar for that. That's the content of that contract that we will have before you. That's what the money is paid for. So a couple of thoughts on that, though. Last year, and it happens every year, we were dealing with a contract that had to be approved in one meeting.
2:15:56 At the end of, you know, we were right up against it. I think we had the same problem with MLH. So I would really encourage staff, let's start working on that in advance. And I think that the frame is, again, how if, you know, with this money and the reality of the TBID funds, how do we really bring this together in such a way that it's going to provide the kind of value that I think council's looking for? The other piece is, in terms of the quarterly meetings, which I think is a very
2:16:25 Good and useful thing to be doing. But I think we should be looking at that set of deliverables as basically agenda items for those meetings. It's really about, you know, are we, is the contract performing? Is the town doing its share? Is the MOT doing its share? And really use that as, that's what we're talking about, those quarterly meetings. Are we making progress? Are we getting things done? Rather than just, well, we just got to get together and talk with each other. It's good to get together and talk, but I think we need to
2:16:55 Use those deliverables in a way that can be the agendas for those meetings. So I have a bit of a problem with how we keep talking about deliverables and how we want to bring the scope down for the town and MLT to some very specific points. We complain and I complain that the town and MLT have not been as closely aligned as they should be. The partnership isn't there. That may be personalities, that may be differences between the business community and us, whatever it is.
2:17:24 But one thing I do know is that in the past three or four years, when we have asked them to change from bring more people here to wait a minute, you shouldn't come now, or we have smoke in the air, or camper programs, or whatever it's been, they have been willing and able and have made the segue. If you define the deliverables down to, and I've seen this.
2:17:51 Play out in businesses before. If you bring them down too strict, here is what you're going to do. And here is a point by point, instead of working with them through the year, this is what we need in coming to agreement. Now you get to a point where when we need to segue from marketing to something else, like don't bring people here, they can point to us and say, you know what, that's not my job. That is not a deliverable. The more we constrict by defining deliverables, and I'm not saying we shouldn't have some,
2:18:21 But the more we constrict it to smaller and smaller terms, the less mobility they can have as a business and we can have as a business. So you need to keep them broad enough so that when we need to segue from marketing to whatever it is, that can be made and no one is going to point the finger at each other and say, no, no, that's your job, not my job. Because we're all in this together. I mean, we are a town after all.
2:18:50 And while we get complaints from the citizens about not spending enough on X, Y, or Z, the fact is we have worked together very closely and collaboratively to bring things that the people in town need. The business people represented here are just as much part of the local construct as the other side of that coin. And we need to realize that and treat them as such. I'm not going to treat them beyond the guy down the street from me.
2:19:21 You know, as a maid, I don't give them any more power than that, but I am going to listen to them as a very important part of the community. And I think, but I think if we could go just take our cues from the TBIT discussion we had, where members of the public are saying amenities and infrastructure, amenities and infrastructure. We had a good conversation about that. That's a really good place to start in terms of looking at defining what those things are. The TBIT term we talked about.
2:19:49 And the air service piece. And I think if you go back to the Miwag meeting, there are a whole number of things in there that are tangible, that are identifiable, that are things that we can start putting into this agreement so that, Rob, you know, in this agreement, it's very clear what these things are. This has got to start to work. We can't be sitting here saying, we all know we are absolutely dependent on tourism for our fiscal health. We have this looming three- or four-year thing coming up.
2:20:17 We have to have a functional relationship and we have to memorialize that in agreements. I'll add one other aside, Mr. Holler, who's been provided wonderful leadership for this community by example and through his actions for many years will not be here in how many months? Eight months? We're not counting the days, but so we have to memorialize this in a way that whoever comes in here next, we can all look at this and say, this is what we are doing. We can't be guessing anymore. We can't be
2:20:46 You know, we got to get this stuff written down in a way that gives us a good, yeah. Okay, so you guys digest that for a second. Any public comments on this? Hello, Council. Can you hear me? We can hear you, yeah. Is the green light on? Okay, good. You're all good to go. Pat Foster, Mammoth Lakes Tourism. You know, I just, I want to kind of change the tone of the conversation. Clearly, our meeting last week, as evidenced by Jamie reading the email,
2:21:31 Folks that were watching, you know, we've got a negative tone, and we don't want that, right? We do need to be partners. I've met with each of you guys individually over the last couple weeks, and one of my leading questions was, what can we do as an organization to be a better partner? And that question was asked to Dan and to Rob and actually the business owners that I've been meeting with in regards to the TBID. And that's important to us. We need to get on the same page.
2:22:01 I do want to clarify a couple of things because clearly people are listening and there is information that's not correct out there. John Ernie doesn't appoint anybody to the board. Our board creates an ad hoc committee. That ad hoc committee interviews panelists, goes back to the board with a recommendation. The board brings people on. John doesn't have anything to do with it. To Ron's point the other day,
2:22:31 John is very, very good at what he does, and I appreciate tourists. Public comment. Yeah. Bring him in. I appreciate Ron making the point that he made, because John is very good at what he does, and he is very well respected in the marketing community, as is his team, as evidenced by Dakota's recent award. This is a team that's really good at what they do. However, John does work for the board.
2:23:06 The way we're set up, anything over $500 needs two signatures. John can't decide anything. The board, everything goes through the board. So Amanda, when you made your comment the other day that you don't trust John Urdi, the whole board took that to heart because we have to approve everything that's done. And John does speak on behalf of the board, but that's because he knows his stuff. He knows his stuff really well. And I will say that
2:23:35 I call him several times a week. He always answers or responds immediately, and he's never said, I don't know. He knows his stuff. That being said, as Bill pointed out, MLT has the opportunity to be nimble, and this is an opportunity for us to be nimble. We have been tasked with generating TOT. We've talked about, hey, the town's budget is X. We've been bringing in...
2:24:08 I've been meeting with several business owners lately. None of them have said they're too busy, but one of our goals is to
2:24:38 I just can't stress enough, we're going to have a lot of opportunity to work together.
2:25:08 That we've been doing. It just hasn't worked. So we need to be strict about our quarterly meetings. I know we've got meetings scheduled. But just wanted to clarify a few things. And yeah, I think we can accomplish some great things. Infrastructure improvements. I'm hearing this from business owners. There are things under the TBIT umbrella that we can do that would be good for locals, that would benefit the business owners, which is what we need to do.
2:25:39 We've enhanced the guest experience. It's all good things that we can do. But we're going to need to work together. Chris, when I asked you the question, you said exactly the same thing, roles and responsibilities. We just need to have clear delineation. If you add up all the bathrooms that I've built and Deb has built, it's zero. We're going to be in Hayes' way. Happy to participate. We'd love the opportunity to work with you. But we need to decide who's doing what. I think that would be a good start. Yeah.
2:26:10 Thank you. Thank you. Can I reply to it? No. No? No. It's just public comments. Okay. Hi, good evening. Ron Cohen, Mammoth Mountain, June Mountain Ski Areas. I just want to follow Pat's comments on a little bit of a perspective shift because some of the discussion, I think, sometimes takes us in the wrong direction. And so I look back to when I moved to Mammoth in April of 1999.
2:26:41 I think at that time we were in the midst of a town manager who was having an inappropriate relationship with a town employee and we were paying a settlement which then I think I may have the details not quite right they left together to go off and have their very life together and then we proceeded to have a succession of
2:27:07 Really difficult times with the succession of town managers and ultimately we made some big mistakes that cost us dearly and which hit us at just about the same time that economic conditions hit us as well and that mixture was really punishing for the town and since that time a few things have happened. We had a new town manager who's remade
2:27:37 How the town works as a professional organization. We've worked our way out of a huge litigation settlement. Still paying on it, but it's something we can manage now. We put the TBID in place 10 years ago and created a stable source of funding to build upon the start we made at the ski area with air service funding and to make sure we had...
2:28:05 So I know it's not.
2:28:34 How you meant it when you said it, Mayor Wentworth, but I just want to be clear, we haven't failed. We're like remarkably successful. When we think about the position we're in, we just are still in the middle of a local, state, and federal slash presidential emergency. And our community, our town staff, our extended community.
2:29:01 We've come together to address those issues. You just made a commitment for hundreds of thousands of dollars for the community. You didn't have to dip into the REU for that. The discussion we're having is putting more money into the REU. That's for times of economic uncertainty and emergency. I think that's now. And we don't even have to take a dime out of that. We can put more money in.
2:29:29 That's how successful we are. That's how not a failure we are. And I think our tone of our conversation doesn't reflect that. We have to reset and when we talk, stand on that foundation that so many people have built. And I think it takes our conversation in the wrong way. So we've built our budget and our funding on a conservative expenditure policy.
2:29:59 And so the town finances are very strong. And so now we're at this spot where we're thinking about, okay, five more years, 10 more years on the TBID. What do we do with MLT? And where I think about that question, the discussion of deliverables, and I hear it from Councilmember Sauser, don't get too prescriptive. My suggestion to you is...
2:30:27 Let marketers do marketing. That's what I do. I have a professional marketing staff. I read their business plan. I ask questions. But I don't tell them what to do. I have a marketing staff for them. And if they don't perform, if they don't deliver on what I'm asking, well, they're accountable for that. But I oversee them. I don't do their work for them.
2:30:54 And I'd suggest, because I've already said it, and I know I don't have complete agreement in the group of TBID or in the MLT staff necessarily, but I think you could take that $2 million down to $1 million. I think the question I would ask in that circumstance is if I'm worried about having a seat at the table and I'm not asking for a specific
2:31:24 Item-by-item deliverables. Am I going to get a whole lot more for $2 million than I would for $1 million? And I think we are in a different world where we've continued to grow the funding. And I think we could make our way with that amount of funding. I think we need that $1 million to deal with the specific restrictions of TBIT funding that we need unrestricted funding to handle.
2:31:54 I think we could find a way to that. And because of the way we budget, because of the way the town budgets conservatively, $18 million is this budget, and I think the projection for this year is $24 or $25. I'd consider that should MLT run into issues where they need more, there's probably going to be more.
2:32:22 And then come back and ask for more based on that ask. And it'll probably be a good ask that you might want to fund. But I think what we want to do is turn to all the rest of that stuff. And when I look at that board, I want to make sure everybody's framed correctly on what that was. That wasn't a list of things that the TBIT should pay for. That was a response to...
2:32:51 A request from the Town Council to MLT, hey, you guys are the guest experts. Tell us what the guests and the community want. That's what that was. And so there it is. And I think that if we take the funds that we're growing every year, if we maybe cut that two to one.
2:33:16 And then we take all of that freed up TOT. That's what I've heard it called, freed up TOT. When we built a TBID in Placer County, we got the Board of Supervisors to commit to, when the money that they used out of TOT got supplanted by TBID funds going to the Resort Marketing Association, they committed to spending those freed up TOT dollars.
2:33:46 On housing and transit, because that was the community's priority. And I think that when we look at freed up TOT, there's a lot available. 1.084 million is the amount of money above that 593 that $24 million of TOT that revenue this year will generate. So it's not the 593, it's plus 1 million more.
2:34:13 If there's $24 million of DOT, which there will be. And so I think there's a lot of money out there to attack and address all of those issues. And I think that we can do it in a way that's really productive instead of a way where we're shooting at each other. And so I appreciate the chance to address you on that and look forward to more discussion. Excellent. Thank you very much, Ron.
2:34:44 Anybody else? Ted? Oh, it brings up an excellent point. These do seem to be uncertain times. I know we have two new board members. Could you give a little philosophy why we have this $7.5 million reserve war chest that we are very religious about keeping in this moment? Thank you. Jeremy Goiko, MLT board chair, chamber of commerce.
2:35:24 Representative on the MLT Board. You know, it just got brought up that, you know, MLT was formed during a recession. I turn on the news these days. That's all I hear about. You know, so we need to be prepared here in case we do come into a recession. You know, saying that there's plenty of visitation right now, I just had the worst march.
2:35:51 I have to go back nine years to a time I had a worse March. Now, I know weather was a big impact of that, but I still have to deal with that financial reality. I still have employees that I need to pay. I just got, you know, a cam fee for $10,000 because it was $50,000 just in the month of January to clear our roof.
2:36:22 Saying that we have plenty of visitation, you know, we look at what other communities have done, and you can look at Sedona, Arizona, they completely cut their marketing budget. Within six months, 25% of their visitation evaporated. So, you know, when we get to these points where, you know, the public comment that Jamie read, this
2:36:49 Gentlemen is saying that it's, you know, maximum tourism at all costs. That is completely incorrect. That is not what our organization is striving to do. We are managing. We are managing. During COVID, we saw this blitz of people coming up here, so we changed our messaging. And we also started a food drive, you know, like,
2:37:18 We were able to do different things to help the community during that time. So, you know, we've proven to be a very fiscally responsible organization. You know, we've been able to, I mean, if you just go to our TOT numbers here over the past eight years, it's nothing but budget surpluses that give, you know, town government and our community.
2:37:47 The opportunity to address these issues that are happening, like workforce housing, so on and so forth. We're going to be presenting the strongest TBID renewal petition that we have ever had since we started TBID. There is a tremendous amount of support for this program in the community. So we have more petitions.
2:38:15 We were just on a call this morning with Andrea from the bowling alley.
2:38:45 We had a very productive conversation. So we're doing this. This is a very time-consuming process. So when we're looking at the 10-year T-bid, what it gives us, it lines us up for success. The last 10 years, it's been nothing. You look at our TOT numbers, it's nothing but success in terms of revenue generation for the town.
2:39:15 There are a lot of question marks out there. We very well could find ourselves in another recession coming up here where we're going to be competing with all of these other tourism industry markets for visitors to our area. That very well could happen. So what we're hearing at the, we go to California Outlook Forum, California Visitation,
2:39:44 We're involved with all these different forums. And what we're hearing is that across the state, people are upping their marketing budgets. So we're going to have to compete with that. Also, our prices, as inflation goes, it affects us as well. Cost of airline flights have gone up tremendously. So we're navigating all of that stuff.
2:40:15 You know, compromise is really challenging and concerning for our organization. You know, we want to maintain a level of, you know, what we're achieving right now. You know, we're looking at potentially $28 million in TOT revenues coming in for this year, which is going to put us at $12 to $14 million over budget. You know, that gives us resources and opportunity.
2:40:45 to better our community. So, Jeremy, I get the sense you're advocating in favor of $2 million going forward. Is that fair to say? That would be fantastic. Okay, good. Thank you. I certainly support that. Thank you very much. You know, just wanted to share those thoughts. You know, I know that we've had a lot of success, but we are still facing challenges. There's going to be some macroeconomic challenges.
2:41:14 Potentially coming down the pipe, you know, so we just need to be prepared for that. And, you know, this is our lifeblood as a community. And, you know, we take... Yeah, I just, I need, we need to kind of wrap this up. We just kind of... Yeah, thank you. Okay, appreciate it. Thank you very much. Okay, any other public comments? Anything out there in the... Nope. Okay, so, I think you've heard what council has said.
2:41:42 And I think you can divine, Dan and Rob, I think whatever consensus you need to take from that. But I do think that council is at least tentatively, we want to move forward with some funding for MLT. I think the exact amount is going to be tied to the perceived value that can be articulated in a contract.
2:42:04 And a scope of deliverables. To Mr. Cohen's point, I mean, if I think the council will be looking at that to say, look, is this worth $2 million? Is it worth less? And I think that will be something for the council to weigh in and deliberate and decide down the line a little bit. I think there is a consensus to move forward and let's figure out how we can assign the rules and responsibilities that are going to give value to the community and to all parties concerned. Thank you.
2:42:31 Thank you very much. Thank you for the input. So let's move on to transit allocation. Is that correct? It is very correct. And that is the end of my policy questions for the evening. So hopefully we'll move a little quicker. So speaking of quicker, now it's going to... Even the computer went to sleep. OK, good. And just kind of remind folks where we were. We were discussing the measure A allocations to transit tours and housing.
2:43:04 Transit is slightly different than the other two that we provided in a couple of ways. Number one is, while the allocation percentage is the same as it is for housing, that's 6.53% of TOT budgeted. They also have a transit fee, which is for certain community sections within the community, a collective fee associated with their particular housing units. And that...
2:43:31 That is additional revenue that we put directly into transit to cover those expenditures. So slightly higher revenue of $1.3 million. As far as expenditures, the main one is contract with ESTA. We don't yet have that contract finalized as far as the cost per hour, but we have a typical hours of roughly $19,000 we do on an annual basis. So there's a little bit of wiggle room in this as well. We also have some expenditures for staff cleaning bus stops and store removal for bus stops.
2:43:59 As well as public utilities, sign replacements, so forth. Total expenditures are by $1,068,000. This particular one, we do not allocate that automatically to housing. We retain that in a reserve specifically for transit. That covers a lot of grant matching funds required for acquisition of trolleys and other things like that. So we build that up in order to be able to buy new equipment.
2:44:30 That sort of rounds out the discussion on Measure A allocations. Okay, let's have a little quick discussion on the consensus around transit. So, any thoughts from anybody on transit? My only thoughts on transit is that we're going to reach that same point shortly where the Measure A allocations we're putting in may not be adequate for the transit needs we have as a town, and that's going to be something for us to look at budgetarily moving forward for the next year. I think it's fine.
2:44:59 Sure. Chris, any thoughts?
2:45:29 I agree with Bill. I just think, you know, Bill and I are the representatives on the ESTA board. And like what's happening with the town, we're just going to see this convergence of pricing, you know, costs increasing. And then additionally, you know, there's been a not insignificant number of people who have asked questions about microtransit and experimenting with other kinds of transit.
2:45:56 I've talked in the past about walk, bike, ride. What would it really look like to have this community have the kinds of transit that people really could park their cars? Because if we could get people out of their cars in Snowmageddon years, we would have a lot fewer problems. So how do we have a visionary idea of what this town can be? And so I would say we're going to be looking for more money for transit in the very near future, I believe.
2:46:24 Yeah, and I agree, and I think that this is, I mean, we're dealing with these relatively small sort of reserve funds and allocations, but I think it's a nice opportunity for some policy, getting a sense of policy stuff as all these things roll up, and I certainly agree that I think transit's going to be a real, it's going to be a real need going forward. Anything you want to add to that? Okay. And I think the only thing I'd also add is Bill and I serve on the LTC, and Cal Transit's had a lot of challenges this winter, but
2:46:53 The overall challenge has been we can't house our workforce. We can't get people to drive the equipment. I mean, we'll start advocating to get them the equipment they need to do the job. But these are things that I think we're all watching and paying attention to, not to mention all the issues with the red taggings, contractors, permitting. I mean, are we going to have the workforce here to be able to process and do all this kind of stuff? So these are interesting things. So, Rob, sorry, do you want to go on to the next item?
2:47:22 Yeah, I'm ready when you are. Yeah, I think we're ready. So next we're going to dive into labor statistics, and this is probably the bulk of the discussion tonight because that's really the bulk of our expenditures as a town organization. I'll give you a comparison on this chart here. It just shows you the number of full-time employees and the number of part-time employees. And these are in full-time equivalencies, so they're based upon a 2,080-hour annual labor.
2:47:50 And so when you see a percentage of that for the part-time folks, that's precisely what it reflects. So for full-time employees with this budget, and again, these items were not necessarily added as part of the budget. They were added from last year's budget to this year's budget. So during the year, we had four positions added. That was one recreation supervisor.
2:48:14 Two police recruits and one police officer. Those are the incremental four that you see in that top-line item of full-time employees. We also have some part-time allocation of additional staff, and that was picking up a reserve officer about half the time, as well as some recreation programs. And the way we design that is we build the programs based on the needs of the community and the requests that come from the community. Sometimes, though, we have
2:48:44 Things that we can't fill. It is built as we want to build the programs, and if we can get instructors for each of those, then we would actually be an increment of 0.6 FTE on our recreation programs. And then finally down at the bottom, the hosts, 0.9, that's reflective of the host used to be on an outside organization. They went internally mid-year last year, so we did not have them as our...
2:49:13 We're part-time staff last year, but they are now this year, and the funding structures are the same, but it's simply just an increment. So in total, about six total full-time equivalents of increase for this budget over last year. When I talk about the breakdown of where this comes from, our total salary and wage is about $16.8 million for the organization. When you look at a total...
2:49:44 Budget of around $30 million. It's fairly significant. You can see where that is our most important asset and our most costly one, if you will. What I try to do is break down just the changes that you see here so that the variance from this year's budget to last year was $1,835,000, or roughly 12%. And this year I broke it down into what's really contributing to those changes.
2:50:10 I mentioned the equivalent of six full-time equivalent staff increment. That's about $658,000 of that number. We're working through labor negotiations right now with three of our unions. We completed two of them in the prior year and three of those. We have an anticipated cost of that negotiation of about $390,000. We have what's called merit increases, which when an employee starts with a town.
2:50:38 They'll usually start at the A-step or the lower range of a salary. As they gain experience, they progress through that process. And so we have a lot of folks still working through that. We have a fairly, I would say young workforce, but it means new to the town workforce. And not everyone is capped out. So that increment is about $345,000. Health insurance, that's one of the ones that's been really a challenge. We are...
2:51:05 On a health insurance cost perspective, going up, I think we went up 12% last year in our overall cost for producing that. We have three tiers. It is a single employee, employee plus one, or a family. And so we will increment that based upon what we are provided on an annual basis by the providers. That is one, when I look at the cost increases that we face as a community, as a town, that may require us to make some adjustments.
2:51:35 In the future on how we fund that and how we provide that because it is getting very, very difficult to afford. Finally, workers' comp, that really is based upon the activity of, you know, how we go about as far as accidents and covering that from the prior year, that's an allocation. And then comprehensive leave, we're still sort of working on this number. That would be the difference between the accrual of hours of leave and what is used. And I think...
2:52:02 There may be some movement in this particular number in future presentations that we provide, so I think I can bring that number down just a little bit. But essentially the $1.8 million breaks down by those components, and I thought it would be important to share that with you just to sort of see where it comes from and how it comes about. In the notes on the side I put really what is affected in those particular areas. Obviously adding someone new covers all the different components of salary and benefits.
2:52:30 Whereas labor negotiations where you're talking about increases in salary, just salary and the PERS impact, the retirement impact associated with that, and then narrowing down insurance costs, workers' comp, and leave hours. So I'll pause there to see if there's any questions about that. Questions? Not seeing any. Giving you a graphical representation of really the components of labor. So just the salary benefits.
2:53:00 And that's, you know, on a macro level, obviously across our entire workforce. Sometimes our benefit package does exceed the cost of the salary in our lower-level positions or entry-level positions within the town. But collectively, that's the way it looks. And this was a last-minute ask, so it's not online, if anyone's following along online. The ask came to Dan was, we wanted to see the distribution of labor, and this would be total salary and benefit.
2:53:29 Based upon the departments of the town. And so I put that together just a few minutes before the council meeting and just to show how that distributes out in a graphical form. A lot of this, and I'm not going to cover this in great detail, I would recommend going to the staff report to review this probably in greater detail. But what I will walk through is just the components that are on the graph itself.
2:53:58 And I'll remind folks, these are departments and they are not specific to a person. So when it says town manager, that's not Dan's salary. That's Dan's department. Yeah, sorry, Dan. That's made up of folks more than just Dan. But essentially we have, you know, how many people or what full-time equivalence is in that particular department. The total salary, again, the comps leave, health insurance, 457.
2:54:25 All those individual elements we talked about before, when I say total health insurance, that's a combination of the health and the 457 contribution. So that total is that one line item. They're not duplicative, if you will, reading across the line. But that's how that breakdown shows. I have it for every department on full-time staff in this particular one. This is a continuation of that graph.
2:54:55 Labor that is town employees that are charged in other funds, so outside of the general fund. In this particular case, you've got solid waste, you've got gas tax, which is where our road crews exist, some measure R funding, airport, capital projects, and so forth. So we do break it down fairly granularly just based upon the activities and the functions that are performed. Then we have the part-time staff. Very similarly, we'll have...
2:55:24 The salary amount, the cost for part-time, it's a little bit interesting as the benefit package obviously doesn't exist for part-time. There's simply a little bit of sick leave and then a PARS, which is a sort of a retirement component that they contribute to and the town as well contributes to. But the bulk of it is salary. And so what you'll see is usually the salary rates are a little bit higher on the part-time staff because there's higher competition.
2:55:53 For those individuals within the community. So that naturally has driven up the cost a little bit on that over and above what we have for full-time wage in a comparable position on typical perspective. But total part-time, about $1,148,000. And that's built all into the total cost that I was describing in this $16,881,000. So that's the major component of our costs.
2:56:23 What we do as a department is we will break down incremental either other activities. So a particular thing in a department would be certainly the labor cost of employees, but you may have training that's associated with that. You may have using subscriptions, miscellaneous supplies. You may have contract labor, which augments our own staff in performing functions for the town that are included in that.
2:56:49 So each director who's responsible for these areas will go through this in detail and make decisions on where we are. For the most part, we're not incrementing it too much on an annual basis. You can see the difference between 2022-23 and 2023-24 to be about $2.6 million. I just discussed the labor component of that being $1.8 million, so we're really around $800,000 at other expenditures.
2:57:16 And you can see sort of where they are broken out. I will highlight the three departments I gave a detailed look on earlier, which was Department 445, Housing, Department 475, Transit, and 480, Tourism and Business Development. Each of those items, the full amount of the Measure A allocation, as I showed in the charts earlier, is allocated specifically to those departments. So in that case,
2:57:44 When you see the increments that are existing in there, it's because we need to utilize that full Measure A allocation for those. As I described earlier, we're taking a lot of that and putting it into the Housing Now programs. But that shows you a little bit about that. So I wanted to kind of walk through that just a little bit. But in total, expenditure increases about 9.7. And graphical representation of that for folks to be able to see just where
2:58:13 The expenses are, and again, this would be labor and total expense across the different departments within the general fund. Any questions on general fund before I move on? Questions? I've got a... You're giving me a headache. I'm sorry. I've got a couple questions. This is being somewhat prepared in a vacuum because all of the... what we're going to have to do to mitigate the effects of this winter
2:58:50 None of that's in here yet. Is that fair to say? Yeah, actually, the way that we approach that is this is the operating budget of the town, so it would be sort of sterile from those sort of inputs. And that gives you really the growth of the organization taking that aside. With what we have in the quarterly presentations where we will be bringing forth additional expenditures like the ones that were discussed earlier, funding those through
2:59:19 Whatever term we come up with with the excess revenues that we produce in a year, but that's a lot of the allocations will come from those revenues on a quarterly presentation. So we have one of those. When is that going to happen? It's May 3rd, and that's the third quarter presentation, which all the things Dan had mentioned earlier will be included in that among others, and there'll be adequate funds, adequate revenue to address those. And so what we like to do is keep them a little bit separate. Okay, that makes sense. I know that we've got.
2:59:48 We talked at the LTC. We sort of tabled the discussion around federal or state, any kind of relief, any kind of funds that might be coming from that, keeping that as a separate, as a whole separate lane, because that's stuff we'll have to consider and have to address as we get into those. Thank you for reminding me about that, John. I'll tell folks a little bit about how we account for that. So I have departments specific to functions that exist within the general fund.
3:00:14 What we like to do with these types of disasters is we segregate those expenditures into another area where we have clarity on exactly what that is. So we did that for COVID. We had an entire fund dedicated to COVID where we were able to take revenues and place them in there. Based upon the fact that we've had a few emergencies we've had to deal with, we created a department called Emergency Response within the general fund. So all the expenditures that we're accumulating for that are landing in that particular area.
3:00:43 We are going after whatever funds that are available for reimbursement for the activities we've incurred, but we will know the full extent of what it cost us to address these issues, and we keep that separate. Okay. We'll get into May 3rd. I think it would be a good preview of that. The other thing is I think the graphic representations are very helpful. I know council members have been asking those because it tells that story pretty well. But I think it may be a little bit of a challenge, but I think we need to start.
3:01:12 Thinking about, you know, from a consumer side, from a citizen side, from a public side, this much came in, this is where it went, a very simple, straightforward way. And it has to be consistent with the budgeting process that we use, such that we bring in, you know, surpluses over what we budget, then the council allocates that money. And I think that to help...
3:01:44 Close the loop. We don't leave, there's no money left standing at the end of our process. We take what comes in, we put it to programs. It's an enormous advantage this community, this town has to be able to do that. And I think Mr. Cohen's comments earlier about, yeah, we have been pretty successful in that way. But I think as we start getting into these crux points, which may be looming, we're going to need to be able to tell the story. Because if we have to start making choices about what we're going to fund, what we can't fund,
3:02:13 We're going to need to start setting the table to have a way to be able to share with our constituents what the challenges are, what they look like, where the pinch points are coming from, and as we make decisions about what we can fund and what we can't fund, we need to take the great work you've been doing over the years, Rob, and start translating that into a way to be able to tell that story efficiently and quickly and effectively. And that's Chris's point about the semantics of excess revenue and all that kind of stuff. We need to start really thinking about how we're going to be addressing those challenges.
3:02:41 Thank you. I did receive a request today to provide that sort of talking points, if you will, on exactly where that went. And we've provided a reconciliation across time that shows, you know, the excess TOT, just exactly how much that has been and then where it's been allocated to. But that's a good representation. You're actually taking that a step further and saying we'd like to see really forecasting the changes we expect.
3:03:06 To come forward and maybe what the impacts may be from that in addition to what we've done with excess. Yeah, to frame that up, I mean, housing being an island, I mean, it's an existential problem. It's not solvable. It can be mitigated, which is what we're doing. We're doing the best we can to do that. But we're going to get to these points of, look, this is what this looks like. And then council's going to be making choices and decisions. So getting ready for that and anticipating that will be helpful.
3:03:34 All right, any questions from the council on any of this? I'm going to get some public comment here in a second unless there's any questions. Okay, any public comment on any of this? Yes, Ted. Do you have any sort of realistic budgeting regarding road rehabilitation and street maintenance? Because your numbers here are not even close to realistic. Town Manager Holler said that that budget would likely double for three or four years. Is that correct?
3:04:12 The demand we have on the streets out there could definitely see instead of a million dollar a year, so much improvement. It could be in that two million dollar range or better over the next few years in order for us to get caught up on total street rehab and needs out there. So we'll be looking at some options that way with other funding as well as some emergency funding we proved this evening. But yes, as we get into our street rehab and our capital side of the budget, we have definitely have some challenges.
3:04:42 Road repair that has been made worse here in the last three months. And I'll also address that a little further. So, yeah, we have an allocated annual for road rehabilitation of $580,000. That is in this particular fund that I have before you here. That's the standard allocation from the budget process. We also have excess that we have sometimes in this fund that we retain there called fund balance.
3:05:13 We have about $2.7 million at the end of last year. And so we utilize those on those capital projects. So I think reserving those sort of critiques until you see the volume of which we've got the projects built and how the funding is there. So this is really more of a, again, operating budget standard versus how much we're committing to that. So May 3rd, again, is probably the time where we can start seeing some of those needs.
3:05:42 And staff's recommendations on how to fund those things. Right. Okay. Okay, Rob, anything else? Yeah, a couple more departments if you want to talk about. Okay, well. I'll move on through here fairly quickly, but just really gas tax is the one that, you know, the comments we just received are specific to this one. And you see the road to rehabilitation in there. This one's a little bit more challenging. So, for example, we receive, obviously, gas tax revenue.
3:06:11 From collection of taxes at the pump. And they come to us in a number of forms. Some of them are just general street maintenance and other activities. And then others are specific to the snow removal efforts. What we receive on the snow removal side is 50% of the cost in the prior year. So like, for example, this year, we're having to fund all the expenses. However, next year, we will receive an excess revenue to support that. So it's almost a...
3:06:39 A little bit out of whack, but it addresses maybe some of the question that was just raised. So we have excess revenues up there expected for next year, and I can't see that far away, but it's around $680,000 maybe. That will go to the bottom line and additional revenues for gas tax or for snow removal or for road rehabilitation and those types of maintenance expenses. So it's a little bit off as far as the timing.
3:07:08 All of our staff associated with the road work, snow removal activities all reside in here. So even though we were just looking at their staff costs, they're the bulk of what we have for these different departments within gas tax. But that just shows you the overall expense of what it takes to basically do a little bit of general road maintenance, I will say, along with expected level of snow removal expense.
3:07:38 Again, just slightly increasing over last year. The general fund does support this on an annual basis, so there's no reflective change in fund balance or anything added because we simply transfer over what is needed by the general fund. And in this particular case, a slight reduction in what we did in prior years, again, based upon the volume of revenue that's come up from gas tax. So that one we have a graphical representation of.
3:08:07 It shows you the bulk of it is really snow removal and street maintenance and rehabilitation. And finally- Quick question, Rob, about the gas tax. So the state will, whatever we spend on snow removal, the state will give us a commensurate amount for the next year. So what's that? 50% of that. Well, 50%. Thanks, Dan. But so even if our snow removal this year was double, they'll, I mean, presumably-
3:08:38 It'll still be 50%, but it'll be twice as much. That's correct. So what they do is they have, they will send an auditor here, they will review all of our expenditures associated with that, and they will come up with a number that they agree to as our reasonable expense, and then that will be funded, half of that cost will be funded. And then one other quick question. I mean, based on the new EPA standards, and the fact that, what is it?
3:09:06 Contemplating 66% of cars are going to be electric cars by 2030. Like, when do the gas taxes, when do we have to contemplate we just won't be seeing those? Well, the state of California will not lend ways, and they are currently working on ways of allocating that expense to the operators of vehicles that don't utilize fuel. And those could be in the forms of cost of registration and other things. But that is how the roadway systems are funded. So the state of California is actively working on a way that works.
3:09:37 I'm going to say right-size that based upon utilization of the roads and taking into account some of the vehicles don't use fuel. There's a program. I can share that. There's a program. Your mic's off. I just turned it off. Good. Okay. So last but not least, debt service, debt schedule. I wanted to kind of show just this is the total debt schedule for the town. Some of it is funded by assessment districts. One of them is funded.
3:10:08 By the multi-use facility payment funded by Measure R. And the rest of them are funded by the general fund. And so that's basically the extent of the term of those loans is already defined. The payment schedule is already defined. On an annual basis, I will review what that is, update that, make sure that we transfer enough general fund to cover that process. We have had a process in previous years where we
3:10:36 While we reduce the cost of the settlement payment on an annual basis of about $135,000, we continue to transfer the full $2 million over there, and that difference between the two is allocated to future capital projects. So it's just a way of generating some funds. In a year, perhaps, when we wouldn't have excess revenue, we still have a mechanism by which we generate funds for projects. And that is the end of the presentation for the night.
3:11:07 And again, I had some elements necessary for my ability to continue with preparing the document, and you guys gave me all the information I need. I really appreciate that. The next presentation we'll have on May 3rd is focused on the capital improvement program, and that whole process is fairly complex. And then subsequent to that, we will have a folding in, I guess, of more funds that are within the towns.
3:11:36 Accounting System. And so that will have items like restricted revenue funds like Measure R, Measure U, and a little bit more about airport and those types of things. So we'll start to build this whole package. And then by June, you will have everything in front of you and be able to take a look at that. Thank you for your time and let me know the questions. Yeah, thank you very much, Rob. And again, we didn't make any decisions tonight. We just provided direction, I think, which is helpful. I would again request that any contracts
3:12:07 MLH, MLT, MLR, whatever. Let's please try to get ahead of those so that we're not making those kinds of decisions at the last minute. I think certainly with the MLT contract, there's a lot of policy stuff that's going to go into that agreement. So I think it'd be helpful to try to get ahead of that. OK, so I guess we're done with this. We're now going to go into closed session. Any final thoughts from the public? Packing your bags and putting your shoes on. OK, well, thank you all very much.
3:12:36 If you want to read the item before we go into closed session, we'll take a break as we get the room set up for you. Yeah, we'll take a quick break and then we'll go into closed session and then we'll report out his name. Closed session is with labor negotiations. Yes. Do you want me to read the item, Dan? Would that be helpful? Yeah, you can do that just so we're covering it. Hold on a second, Bill. So while we're milling around here, I'm just going to read the closed session item, which is pursuant to government code section 54957.6A.
3:13:03 Conference with Labor Negotiators, the Council will meet with its representatives, Town Manager Daniel C. Holler, Administrative Services Finance Director, Rob Patterson, Community and Economic Director, Sandra Moberly, and HR Manager, Amanda Pelham, with respect to the following employee organizations, Mammoth Lakes General Employees Association, Mammoth Lakes Management Employees Association, and the Mammoth Lakes Public Works Employees Association. So we'll break for a couple of minutes, and then we'll go into closed session and report any results after that. Thank you. Thank you.