Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board · 2023
Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board Special meeting
at 13:00
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Minutes ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
290 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
8:04 Doing good? Yeah. All things considered. Unplowed. Good to go. All right. Call to order. Microphone's on. I'm good to call to order, Angie. And we're good to do roll call. Chair Goyko. Present. Vice Chair Foster. Here. Treasurer Morris. Here. Secretary Mendel. Board Member Clerk. Here. Board Member Radcliffe. Board Member Sauser.
8:51 Yo. And Board Member Magner. Sure. Thank you. All right. I have a very quick Board Member comment or reports. I want to thank Mammoth Mountain for hearing my hashtag keep Canyon open and extending Canyon Lodge for at least two more weekends in April. I think that's going to be very beneficial to the small business community. We've all been
9:22 struggling with some of these recent storms. We thought we were going to make up ground for New Year's, MLK, end of February, you know, the last weekend of presidents there that we lost. We thought we were going to make that ground up in March. We haven't been able to make up any ground in March because we've been dealing with Armageddon storms. So to extend...
9:46 Canyon Lodge, and the Village Gondola and make that accessible for another two weekends at the end of April is huge. So thank you, Mammoth Mountain. I think that's going to really have a very positive impact on the small business community. So that's my board member report. And Eric, I'll move to my right here. Yeah, Jeremy, I'll just add a little bit more detail to that in the sense that, as you all know, we're about reacting to Mother Nature and we'll open when she lets us.
10:15 and close when it's time. But when we look at Canyon this year, we would have made that announcement a long time ago, but we actually get the opportunity of replacing Chair 16. And Chair 16 will be a six-pack. It will be 25% faster than what we have now. So we'll be able to move that many more people up. And it will open earlier on days like this.
10:41 Because we'll have chair parking for it, it'll be out of an avalanche zone, there won't be nearly as much chipping, so it's really going to provide a great experience for our guests going forward, and we're really excited about that. It was planned to go in prior to COVID, but as the supply chains go and everything gets changed due to COVID, we're really excited to have that. So, 16 will not be open, 17 will be open.
11:10 And there will be access, you know, through the lodge and so forth. The village gondola will be open, parking will be there, and so forth. And then we'll, as we get closer to that time, you know, figure out other lifts that are there, but provide connectivity. We know we'll have a big Memorial Day weekend too, and we'll look at that as well.
11:32 They have no choice but to leave it open, Jeremy. They can't get to the main lodge. It seems like the whole year, yes. Any plans for Woolies to extend? There's been a lot of discussion about that. And nothing finalized yet, but we are absolutely looking at that. And I assume Tamarack has a drop-dead date when the snowmobile starts. Tamarack does have a drop-dead date with the permit that we have with the U.S. Water Service.
12:01 April 15th is somewhere in there. Yeah. 17th, I think. And when you bring that up, you know, to that point, I want to let you know, we currently don't have any occupancy up at Tamarack again. And, you know, we really fought a hard battle up there with Mother Nature, and we cried uncle. We don't know when the next time we'll be able to get there. I mean, this last week, it wasn't us digging down to the doors like what we were doing.
12:29 We just lost the cabins altogether. So we had the igloo effect like you were talking about, but I mean completely gone. So it's going to be a while before we get to have occupancy up there. But the lodge is doing good and we'll open lakefront when the road is accessible and same with cross country as well.
12:51 Yeah, and we do, we do still have the trails in the shady network that are, that are getting groomed when they can, so, we've been directing a lot of people to our offices and that shady rest. Good, thank you. Yeah, you're welcome. Awesome, thank you so much, Eric. Anything from you, Mr. Souser? It's white outside. It is. It is. I hold a family barbecue the 22nd of July each year, and I've told them to bring their gloves, we'll have a snowball fight.
13:20 Sounds good. Mr. Foster, how's everything going? You know what? We're dealing with the same snow challenges, revenue challenges, same thing everybody's dealing with. I don't have a lot to add. Mr. Morris? All right. Sounds good. We'll get right into it. We do have one public comment, correct, Angie? Are we ready for that public comment? Sandy Hogan, you can go ahead and unmute yourself. Okay. Can you hear me now? Yep. Yes. Oh, good. Yeah, it is.
13:56 A minute ago, it looked like a blizzard, but it's settling down here. I'm Sandy Hogan, and I want to speak today about YARTS, the Yosemite Area Regional Transit System. And I'm here to give you some history and show how you can offer some non-financial support this year. It's so important to the Eastern Sierra, our guests, and even some of our
14:25 International guests. And with, you know, John, Urdi, you helped bring here with your excellent marketing. And a little bit of history. It was formed officially about 23 years ago by three counties, Mono County and Merced and Mariposa. And they formed JPA, a Joint Powers Authority.
14:53 and with an annual contribution based on seasonal and year-round service. And, of course, each county has two supervisors on the board, and the National Park Service contributes the majority of the funding. Now, Tualamay County joined just a few years ago.
15:19 And Madeira just recently, I think with last year, years ago, Madeira was noted, as Bill probably knows, for opposing any kind of transit. But now they're happy about, you know, and so all those counties contribute funding and their two supervisors. And the funding is based on whether the service is seasonal or whether it's year-round.
15:49 For 22 years, the past 22 years, VIA has been our contractor for all drivers and buses. But we have been acquiring buses over the years. So only last year we changed. We got a new contractor that had Merced, the bus, you know, had worked with. And it's quite a bit cheaper. And we are on our way to acquiring.
16:19 All buses. But these new contracts were issued for both management and transit, and they reduce cost a lot. In Mono County, we have traditionally kind of served June, sometimes a Memorial Day, through end of September, and even I think we served a little bit into October, but I can't remember which years that was, because our
16:47 Writership has increased over the years, especially our fall writership. I served on the AAC for three terms, about 12 years, and I retired as vice chair in January, and I worked with several of our supervisors over those years. In October, we had a meeting in the Valley with all of the representatives, the supervisors, and most of the AAC, and we had two
17:18 Very sobering budget presentations. One was from the new, well, she's not new now, I guess this is her fourth year, Executive Director Stacey Guzman, and also from Gordon Shaw, LSC, and probably a lot of you are familiar with that name because he worked on ESTA. He's really a fabulous transit consultant and knows the Eastern Sierra well. Each came to the same conclusion, though, however.
17:49 If supplementary funding isn't found, yards will close, will cease to exist within, at the end of, well, the next five years. And that's really, you know, it's been so important to us in the Eastern Sierra, just in our seasonal. And the contributing factors were many. Of course, anybody that knows about transit knows that fare is never.
18:17 Cover the operating costs, and most grants are for capital and not for operating costs, but once in a while they come through. The county contributions are never enough, and even the National Park Service budget is not enough, but it seemed like, what it seemed like for a long time was that our reserves were adequate, and as we acquired YARDS buses, what's happened, of course, those grants needed matches.
18:47 And that caused our, even though our ridership was growing, our reserves were dwindling. And this was brought to our attention, you know, in the fall. So our ridership grew over time on the Eastern Sierra, wonderful. 90% of it comes out of Mammoth Lakes, if not more. We worked to make our service more efficient over those years.
19:16 We have two buses a day. And we now call both of them express because we cut out a few stops here and there because we reviewed the stops and was it worth five minutes? Probably not. And we dropped the June Lake loop. The ridership just wasn't there after a couple of years. We dropped that about three or four years ago. It's now on a on-demand service at the June Lake kiosk.
19:45 Most of the Levining stops, we've changed to on-demand, but not all, but almost. And now our season stops in mid-September, which is just really, I had hoped, my dreams were that we would go into mid-October or into the, you know, with transfer, say with a late year like this, that we could transfer some funding into the fiscal year for.
20:15 You know, late October service, if we had time and sunshine. The west side is similar. You know, they've been trying to save some. All the counties have raised their contributions. The new contracts save money bucked. So I'm here to ask for your, as I mentioned, non-financial support, because I understand that your budget is pretty well set this year.
20:44 But when Stacey Corliss, as her schedules permit, you know, she's former supervisor, and she was really active with yards. And if her schedule permits, and when she and I go to the town council, probably next month or so, to ask for excess TOT funds, just for supplementary contribution for yards this year.
21:14 We would love to have MLT's support, maybe written or maybe verbal or whatever, but just underlining how important YARTS is to us. And maybe for your board to consider over the next year, maybe in that year you can include some funds in next year's budget, or
21:42 Have a match with the town contribution because we're going to have to get this done. This valuable, it's been such a valuable service for the east side. It's something that, you know, we can really fly them in, get them on the bus, take them over there, have them see the valley and one day come back and spend a couple of nights here, which is what we want to do. And I know that's one of your goals, your strategies. Anyway.
22:11 That's really my pitch, and I just wanted to know if you have any questions about this. Sandy, we appreciate the feedback. I think, you know, today's special meeting is to talk about moving forward and what some of the challenges are as a community, and transportation is definitely going to be on the list. So I think it's good timing to talk about this. The value, obviously, our biggest opportunity time is the fall.
22:38 And we recognize that the park is a huge piece of it and the arts is a big piece of it and it's been a big message for us for years now. So we appreciate the info and more than happy to chat with you more about it or Stacey or as we move forward and see what we can do to assist as well. Thank you very much. Great service, Sandy. Thank you. Thank you. Okay. Thank you, Sandy. Moving into policy matters.
23:08 Let's do our TBID renewal update. Brief update on TBID renewal process and timeline from Mr. Urdi here. Yep. So I'm actually just handing out a couple of things for our board members that are in restaurant and retail side of things. These are hard copies of the management district plan, hard copies of the fact sheet, and hard copies of the petition. So we are getting petitions in via email right now.
23:37 We did have one get dropped off this morning by Mr. Morris, so that was our first in-person handoff. We do have a pretty tight deadline to get those in by next Wednesday so that we can submit the percentages to the town. And so I know that our different groups have reached out to restaurants, retail, and lodging to make sure that folks are on board. We have had some interesting feedback. I think that right now, obviously, everybody's a little stressed out with snow.
24:05 What it's affecting their businesses and how it's affecting their parking and all those different pieces. We've also had some feedback with concern about the fact that they're concerned about the TBID assessment rates being raised in the future. I'll go back to the steering committee meeting that we had with the community last, I don't even remember what it was, last spring maybe, where we talked about, we presented coming out of the gate with an increase. We heard loud and clear from the business community that it was not the time.
24:34 And so we went back to the drawing board and came out with the flat rates. If the board and the organization decide to do something with rates somewhere in the 10-year future of this TBID, it will have to be very, very well justified and approved by this board.
24:49 It's not something that would be done willy-nilly. It's not something that would be done, you know, there's no executive order to say that we're going to raise rates. It would have to be a fairly major discussion as to why and what we're doing. So we have talked about this in the past. The plan right now is not to raise rates while we're moving forward. And if something were to come up where we felt that we needed to, then it would be a bigger discussion than just an executive order.
25:12 You know, even it would be a bigger discussion with this board and the community. So, you know, not sure that that helps in the long run. But I think, you know, we were very clear that when we heard the business community that we heard the business community. Hey, John. Yep. Just a comment. So a lot of those have come through mine, as you saw in the email. And going back and looking, you know, like last summer, June, July, whatever it was.
25:40 And I went back and the only two things I found were both published by the sheet. One was TBID plans an increase, and then sometime in either June or July it was plans for an increase are canceled. And if that's the only communication, I think that we probably need to do a better job just making sure that the community, you know, that our constituents in particular, you know, we have the email addresses and stuff, and to the degree we can.
26:08 And I've assured them the same thing. And I said, you know, this is not something that's going to be taken lightly. We heard you last year. OK, well, we, you know, but it's still kind of rolling around. Memories are long, you know. And so I think that the taxation issue and everything else all just sort of builds up and sits there. So I will say that the people I've spoken with are supportive and cautiously optimistic that we will do the right thing and not
26:38 Do anything unilaterally without their input. And I appreciate that. And I've had feedback from the board members who have been out talking to the businesses. I think it's a great exercise for the board to be out talking to your constituents. I think it opens that door and it opens that dialogue. I know that Pat has dialogue.
26:57 pretty consistently with a number of businesses in town, and I think that's really our opportunity to continue that. So when we do an annual report, then we'll publish the annual report, but it may also be an opportunity for you to physically go and drop that off with people and talk to them and answer questions. So I think moving forward, that level of relationship will be key. On the positive side, I will say that that discussion has actually piqued some interest in, and I don't want to overstate here, forming a retail
27:26 Association. Association. Great. So I'm optimistic that now there is some interest in getting involved. I've had a couple people say, yeah, okay, yeah, I want to do it. And there are people who we would want, you know, I mean, they're... Well, that's great. I appreciate that. So we do have, you know, like I said, we need to get these petitions in by next Wednesday.
27:48 And so if people are out there listening to this and their businesses are out there, please send those in. You know, we are happy to go pick them up. You can scan them and email them to me at jairdi at visitmammoth.com. You can drop them off at the office. They can drop them off with any of the board members and I can come pick them up. But yeah, by next Wednesday, we want to be able to be prepared to submit the petitions to the town on Thursday for our meeting with town council on April 5th. So we'll have a workshop with town council on the 5th. Important for me.
28:17 We list the top 25 in each category to go after them and we can reach our 61% or whatever it is. But the guys that aren't on that top 25 list are hugely important. Well, absolutely. Because if they feel ignored, and I would love to see the feedback somehow, whether it's having them fill out a questionnaire or something as to how the town in general, because 61% is a small minority of the actual businesses in town.
28:45 So just as you're going out and collecting these, I would love to see some of those. Personally, it doesn't stop at that 25 list. It's just that those are sort of the priority. This is alphabetical or something else, right? And these conversations, like, I had two conversations. Each one of them was 45 minutes long. You know, these people have questions. They have concerns. They appreciate the phone call. They appreciate what it is we're doing.
29:15 But there's just a lot of, you know, there's some misinformation out there. And I, you know, I think a little confusion as well, you know, you know, we thought you were going to raise rates. Are you still going to do that? They haven't heard the conclusion of that conversation is kind of the sense I'm getting. A lot of questions about air service as well. What's going on there? How is it going? You know, so, you know, these are very in-depth conversations.
29:42 You know, and so when two people are split, you know, at 12 businesses a piece, you know, you can do the math. It's a lot of time. Welcome to the world. Very good exercise. Welcome to the world of a local politician. Yeah, absolutely. But I think to Jeremy's point, we ought not allow our communication to be done by a third party. It can't, people can't just read it in the newspaper, right? And regardless of what that paper is. Or I'm not a real fan of.
30:09 Well, it's on the website. You know, you can go to the town website and dig it out. I'm going to have to dig it out. Show me. You know, just tell me. So I'm a broken record on this, but no one ever died and said, you know, I wish I'd communicated less. Well, and hopefully going through this process will create those lines of communication that we've been talking about where in the future it's more often short 15-minute conversations and how things are going and there are more updates than, wait, tell me.
30:38 Bring me totally up to speed because we haven't talked in a long time. I think some CPR in sales, right, you're reaching out regularly. I think this will be helpful to getting that ball rolling. Anything else on the TBID renewal? Any questions or concerns from any of the businesses or constituents that you guys are talking to right now? All right, cool.
31:06 Thank you. Moving on to MLT infrastructure priorities discussion. You know, this is an in-depth discussion to inform town council on infrastructure to mitigate visitation impacts and enhance resident quality of life. So we're, you know, John's going to kind of take us through. We have, you know, a list of things that we've discussed, but what we need to do is come up with what are the top priorities, you know, so that when we...
31:35 Present this to town council, we can say, you know, this is everything on our list, but these are number one and two that really need to be tackled in, you know, in the first year, if possible, and then make a plan for the other items kind of moving forward for future endeavors. So you want to get us started on that, John?
31:57 Last year when we were in the budgeting process we talked about roles and responsibilities and what was Mammoth Lakes Tourism's role, what's the town's role, where does the planning come from, where does the money come from, where all these other pieces come from, and you know we had one one good meeting to talk about direction and then it kind of fell off so we were approached by town council and specifically Mayor Wentworth about having this board come up with our priority list to present to council. Council has a meeting next week on the
32:26 What's next week? 22nd? No. 27th? Yeah. 28th? 29th? 29th is Wednesday. We have a meeting coming up to talk about council priorities. Tomorrow. Actually, no, it's tomorrow, March 22. The 22nd. You did. You did. And so the staff report that's on the council website, if you take a look at it, it outlines...
32:51 You know, a lot of the things that we have discussed for years now, as well as some other things that are maybe more municipal than they are necessarily resident quality of life or visitor facing. And we've been meeting as a Mammoth Lakes Tourism staff and talking about the fact that everything that we're doing moving forward should be geared towards the resident experience with the idea that everything that we solve for the resident becomes a benefit to the visitor. There's really no differentiation if we figure out that we can get consistent bus service.
33:18 That benefits the front desk person at the village as much as it benefits the visitor who's staying at Sierra Nevada Resort. So if we know that we've got consistent service, then it helps our residents to be able to get to work or be able to get to where they need to go. And we know that as a byproduct default will help our visitors as well. We've also been really working hard on a community research project. And it's funny because once we start to peel off the onion, there are multiple companies out there that we found that can help us with these things.
33:47 And it helps determine, you know, really where we are with all of our stakeholders and where the touch points and the pinch points are with each of our different stakeholders because we've got residents, we've got business owners, we've got second homeowners, we've got visitors, and we've got the government. And so we need to figure out where all of those folks are having struggles or challenges or where the opportunities lie. And so we've got multiple different programs. We're working with Visit California. They're doing regional strategy plans.
34:16 With a company called JLL. You know, our region basically is from us up through Tahoe and down into Yosemite, so it's kind of a little candy cane. That's going to be helpful for the region because we all have similar challenges, but Tahoe has challenges with day visitors that we don't necessarily have, and Yosemite has challenges or opportunities to restrict, you know, the admission because they have gates. So we've discussed, do we hire them to do a more in-depth when they come to town to survey?
34:44 business owners and residents and second homeowners, etc. Do we work with them to expand the scope at that point and get us a lot more info about our specific destination? We've talked with Carl Roboto, who's done a lot of work in town here. Carl and his company, Travel Analytics Group, has some other thoughts on how to go forward. We've worked with Destination Next, which is an MMGY global company.
35:11 We've got a lot of different things out there as opportunities for us. SMARI, who we've done research with in the past. And so we're really kind of whittling that down right now to figure out who can help us understand all of those different aspects and how best to approach them. So that's one thing that we're definitely working on. And we want to give the perspective from each of those groups. Because while they may be slightly different, they're probably all going to start to focus on the same sort of core challenges.
35:41 Mountain has been nice enough to share some of their research with us as well. Their research is talking more about, you know, some of the pinch points and the challenges that we have, but it also talks about kind of what we're missing. You know, what are the guests that are coming, looking for, and it's the dining options that we don't have, and it's some of the activities that we don't have off the slopes, which really, not necessarily something that the town itself can influence, but it's something to keep looking at as we move forward. You know, something like Limelight fits a five-star.
36:11 Lodging opportunity for us. Maybe Vulcania in the village is a new higher dining opportunity for us, but that's really kind of free market stuff that we can try and attract, but there's not necessarily a whole lot that the town can do to make it better or go away or whatever it is like we can with some of the trains that are parking or trash or some of those things. Before we get into the conversation, we all recognize that housing is issue 1A.
36:38 We know that that's kind of the root of a few things. Staffing challenges are not because nobody wants to live here. It's not cool to live here anymore. They just can't live here. They can't find a place to live here. And so we know that the town has got a robust program with almost 500 units in the next three to five years, 81 of them coming online this summer. I pay attention to a lot of mountain towns around the country, and this is by far the most that's being done anywhere in the country.
37:08 Maybe a little comparable, but it's about 400, 450 units. I think we're actually ahead of where they are, which is amazing. So we know that housing is the number one problem and staffing is a byproduct of that. So I want to focus today on what are the infrastructure challenges or program challenges that we can affect? The housing thing is in the works, not saying that that's the solution when those 500 units are done, we're done. I think when we get 200 of those units done, we need to figure out where the next...
37:37 500 are going to come after that, probably. But I think for now, because housing has a plan, at least for the immediate future, I'd like for us to focus on some of the other challenges that we've talked about as a group and that have also been brought up throughout the community and throughout town council and a lot of the things that came up through the mountain surveys and what we assume we'll also see from these other research projects that we have going on.
38:06 Clean off our whiteboard over here if we want to start throwing out the big pieces, and then there are a lot of sub-factions underneath them. I think right now one of the biggest things that showed up in the mountains information as well as our information is transportation. And I think that there are a lot of layers under that transportation piece. You can't just say it's transportation.
38:25 Microtransit, it's YARCs, it's things like Sandy Hogan just talked to us about. And so I think that if we can go through what we all think are the larger pieces, you know, we've got top level, it's transportation, it's communications, it's cell service, it's Wi-Fi, it's all those different pieces, safety issue. You know, cell service right now when we have blizzards going on is critical and sometimes it's not very reliable.
38:52 But even when we don't have a blizzard, it's spotty throughout town. So that's got to be. And it's a safety issue, absolutely. And then the Wi-Fi, I think a lot of people think of that as being nice to have when you're at home and you're surfing the web. But it really comes down to there are a lot of businesses that run Square and other things that if they can't run it, they're out of business. This is my list, and we can expand it. But communications is the cell and the Wi-Fi connectivity. They are restrooms.
39:22 We've talked about it a lot. I had a conversation with Fred Wong from the Forest Service last year. Our Welcome Center, the bathroom at our Welcome Center is high school circa 1964. It really needs to be replaced. He and I talked about it. He's willing to work with us on helping fund that so that we can get the first impression when somebody actually comes to the Welcome Center not to be that they're at Ridgemont High.
39:47 But also things like the Lakes Basin, you know, the restrooms on Old Mammoth Road and Main Street. You know, if you look for a public restroom in town, you can go to Shady Rest, and they're probably, you know, a couple of them are fine, but some of them are also, you know, outdated out there. So trash, EV charging, and town beautification. I think we really need to take a look at our, how we show.
40:13 You know, when we have people turning into a town that we're trying to be a world-class destination and we're not necessarily always presenting as a world-class destination. So we can always expand the list. We can contract the list. We can say that this is important, but it's not really a main priority. Ultimately, what I'd like to do at the end of this is have a one through five priority that we can say these are the things we think are critical. These are the things that I think that need to get ticked off as we move forward. And then we can present this to town council.
40:40 And we can talk about how we can potentially assist with programming or funding or different programs as we move forward to say we want to be a partner in this. We're not just telling you these are the problems. We want to see an action plan. We want to see a timeline. And we want to know how we can help. Hey, John. Transportation is key, but it's pretty narrow. I'd really love us to think about this, if it's appropriate, as accessibility. Yep.
41:11 And so it's not only accessibility to town, but within town, accessibility to the mountain, the functions, movement around town. And I think under that air service, I think that two boxes. One is quality of life for residents and quality of experience for visitors. You know, like everybody else, I think everybody's mind now is thinking about...
41:39 Not when it's going to stop, when am I going to get out of here for a week to see something other than snow, you know. And that, you know, you can't drive to Reno now, right? Well, you can, but it's a two-day trek through Las Vegas. Pack a lunch. Pack a dinner. And so air service has to be, I think, thought of as a quality of life issue for residents and for our guests.
42:08 Because if we only look at it as the guest piece of it, I think we're going to short-sell ourselves. Well, and I think to your point, like I said, I highly doubt that we're going to put anything on this board that isn't going to affect both very positively. Because whenever we talk about air service, we talk about the people that can get to see family or family can come see you or get to your doctor's appointments or you can get out of here and go someplace warm. And so I think that I'd be very surprised if there's anything up here that's...
42:35 Completely resident-centric or completely visitor-centric. You know, there may be some that sway a little bit more towards one or the other, but I don't think, like air service, you're absolutely right. You know, we have seen a great increase in locals using air service because it's reliable. You know, we talked about this, the 12 years prior, if I needed to get back to Washington, D.C., I drove to Reno. Now, I'm pretty confident that I can get out of Bishop.
42:59 And I'm pretty confident that I can take scheduled charter out of Mammoth. When of course you can get to Bishop. When of course you can get to Bishop. Yeah, exactly. And so I think the other side is the scheduled charter being able to access Southern California makes a huge difference. But John, I think the point is extremely valid and we ought to communicate it in the sense that this is for residents as well as borders, especially when you're talking about air service.
43:27 Because the communication doesn't get out there that much. Talking to three of the four people who were really vocal on, you know, wanted to spend 45 minutes or an hour talking, which was great. There was a whole litany of different things, and air service was binned in all those conversations as a getting more people here. It wasn't about, I could actually go someplace, or if I need...
43:54 to connect to a flight at LAX or out of Denver or to see family. And so I do think we need to start thinking about that as a duality of purpose here and probably lean in more to the residential side and benefits of it, to your point, that says, yeah, we can go places now.
44:15 We're not a backwater anymore where we're subservient to Reno or LAX or somewhere else. And our objective is to give infrastructure ideas to the town council and the air service is an infrastructure idea for both residents and the town council. But what you're hearing, you may not be, what I am hearing from constituents is what is the right size for that air? Are we putting too much into the air now?
44:43 Those are the questions that somehow have to be answered. Can you answer the question, do we have too much air? Right. And my question would be no. But I can tell you that the people coming to me on a daily basis that I have to represent as well, that is not what they're saying. You know, they're telling me, yes, we need to reduce air so that we can put it, and they don't have a good idea where to put it, and we're talking about that today. But from a political standpoint, the times they are changing, as Bob Dylan said.
45:13 We have to bear that in mind and go along, not go along with, but educate or do whatever is necessary if truly the level of service we're giving is the correct or if it needs to be increased because the end solution, whether we like it or not, is going to end up being a political one, what the people of Mammoth want. Well, and I think that we have been very cognizant of that. You know, I've been working on the air program for almost 13 years now and Eric's been with me for 10 or so of those.
45:41 And every year when we look at this, we look at the economic viability of this service. You know, for this summer, last summer we flew Hawthorne and Carlsbad with Advanced Airlines. We have looked at just flying Hawthorne this year. From a financial and viability standpoint, we looked at eliminating going from two markets to one. Our price is still double what it was last year because of the cost problem. We went from three flights last year with LAX San Francisco and Denver to two flights this year with San Francisco and Denver.
46:11 It's pretty much right-sized right now. Eric and I and our group have talked about is the next step. We've talked about going to Dallas with a new airline. It may not be the best economy of scale. It might be doubling the Denver flight because it's been productive and that redundancy in Denver could produce huge numbers having a morning and afternoon connectivity flight with all the flights that go through that hub. So I think that that's part of our discussion for planning. I think that access is a great way to put this versus transportation because I think that transit and all that falls into that mix.
46:41 I do think that we really want to talk about the, I guess, we do want to talk about programs like air, but we also want to talk about infrastructure. Thanks, John, for saying that, because while certainly you guys all know I'm a huge proponent of air, the problem is that even talking about how air benefits locals, there's still a very large percentage of our town that cannot afford to fly.
47:06 based on their wages. So we want to be careful when we're talking about these things. What I hear a lot from people that work for me and so forth is, yeah, that's great, and it's great that locals can fly out, but what they're looking, I mean, their rent is too high, their restaurants are too expensive, the bonds is too expensive, grocery outlet's too expensive, gas is too expensive. Everything about living in Mammoth is too expensive. Now, there's not a whole lot that this group can do about any of those things.
47:36 Granted, anybody that's listening, we don't fix the price of gas. That doesn't work that way. But I think it's important as we talk about these things to be looking at when we're talking about transportation. For me, yeah, I would really love it for all of my staff to be able to relatively easily be able to take a bus to get to work, even out at Snow Creek.
47:58 Wherever it might be. And those are the kinds of things that, you know, whether it's a free service or nominal charge or whatever it is, but those kinds of things that will affect our workforce more than anything else and give them a better quality of life in one way or another, you know, whether it's free transportation or subsidies of some kind or another or just better access to things around town, whatever that might be. That's hugely important because I think a lot of the workforce
48:27 looks at some of the things we talk about and said, yeah, but that's for the rich folks, and that's not for me. So I want to make sure. With the bus services, that reliability, because right now, your staff can't rely on the bus service. And I think that we have been asked, and we've got the whole walk, bike, ride, and we talk a lot about it, but it's really not a walkable, bikeable, rideable community right now, because you wait for 45 minutes for a bus, and then you end up walking an hour to wherever you're going. And so if we don't have it reliable, again, for the
48:56 For the resident. If the resident can't get to work, then the visitor's not going to take the bus either. But the problem becomes the same. So there's no way we're ever going to have reliable bus service when it looks like this outside. You can't go there. And I think that's where the next thing I want to write down here is microtransit. There are two other pieces of that. One, just like everybody else, ESTA cannot, like I said on that board, cannot find drivers.
49:23 For all the same reasons we talked about. It's too expensive to live here. I don't want to live in Mammoth. I can't afford to do the things I want to do. There's going to be another limiting factor that nobody is talking about yet, and that is the California law that is going to force the transition to electric buses. They cost twice as much, and you need twice as many of them to run the same routes, because you have to take them out of service to charge them. Electric fire service. Yeah.
49:52 So how is that going to affect the access we're trying to create already? I mean, we are at the edge of what we can afford with the free service we have, and it needs to be doubled. When it becomes double the price, now where do we cut to continue doing this? And that conversation hasn't started yet, and we're only, what is it, in another year or year and a half, we can no longer purchase anything but electric buses.
50:23 So that's a huge... Yeah, 20, 25, 50% of the emergency purchased have to be electric. By the way, they don't make an electric fire truck. And a lot of those vehicles idle for 25 to 30. It's impossible. Which doesn't work. Yeah, yeah. We do have an electric van that's in use now, and it's got a range of 90 miles. Well, that doesn't... Anyway, not what we're here for, but just down the road, that's going to be huge. Well, and I think one of your things, the driver challenges, this is something that we talked about at lunch, talking about the...
50:57 The idea that maybe if we go away from bigger buses down to Microtransit, you don't need CDLs, maybe you have more of a pool to choose from. Not true, you still got to have a chauffeur's license anytime you're doing a commercial service, so the extra license is still going to be required. It's going to be easier to get, I imagine. It's not a CDL, though, it's a chauffeur's license. A chauffeur's license, yeah. Yeah, still medical on everything.
51:20 Yeah, yeah. But again, I mean, it may be that we decide if transportation and getting people around and flow and reliability is the biggest thing, maybe we need to pay more for that position. Maybe there are certain positions that need to be paid more to be able to pull them. Man, we've raised that so much in the last 18 months. My head's swimming. Is our objective to identify the opportunities to improve the experience both for our residents and our guests? Not necessarily solve it right now.
51:50 Inform them as to what we're hearing from our guests and our employees, what the problems are, right? I think we need to keep doing that. And there's some really hard problems to solve up here, and there's even more coming. But I want to make sure we don't get stuck on trying to solve them. If we have enough time, we can go back and do that. John, I got a text from one of our council members who are having a hard time hearing you. Speak up, son.
52:17 They brought a microphone over here. I know. Okay. So, I mean, on transit, we've parking, traffic, this is all access, under access, and I like that. One of my, you know, one of my phone calls with the TBID renewal, one of our constituents was, we pretty much talked about access the whole time. His first concern was air service, that Bishop wasn't having a big enough impact.
52:51 After reminding, hey, we had two years off from COVID, this is only our second year of air service, we're up 50% in bookings, I think we're headed in the right direction, you know, he was very understanding of that. His other concern was that our local transportation companies, Mammoth Taxi, Mammoth All Weather Shuttle, because of the shuttle service down to Bishop, and that being their main focus now,
53:20 It's nearly impossible to get any sort of service around town. You know, we had a lot of people in town for the Mammoth Film Festival, you know, different parties going on, different events going on. The film festival did provide their own drivers and such, you know, for certain of their guests, but there were a lot of people that, you know, could not get a taxi, you know, and just having a really tough time, you know.
53:49 getting to where they wanted to go around town safely. And so, you know, kind of taxis, microtransit, you know, I think, you know, need to be up there and we need to think about those things moving forward for sure. So, Jeremy, just to kind of emphasize that point that you heard from, our survey information that we submitted to John was 8,500 surveys from November, and they said that point, hard.
54:27 Time, finding micro transportation, and that, you know, they talk about, there's 245 comments. It's a lot, and it is a lot of people talking about it, 155 people, traffic management, ESTA, 60, and all the general concepts that everybody has mentioned is really important to look at this and try and figure it out. It transfers over into the summer survey, too.
55:14 What about a transit hub, a parking structure? I mean, I know that we're talking that parking is the challenge, but do we want to come with some, you know, question marks? I think they're related, though, because if I could drive and there was a place to park, I'd do it myself. Right, right, right. Accessibility. That's right. And so this is a bigger, I mean, you solve one, if you can put this at a Pareto, if you have reliable public transport, Uber,
55:44 Taxi, something, then I don't need more parking. I'm parked at the village and I'm going to, we get it down at the distillery all the time. People are trying to, you know, is there some way I can get down there without driving, right? Mammoth Taxi, we refer them to everybody in town. Well, how come I can't get an Uber? That's not something we can fix, but one sort of begets the other. If I can't get public transport, then I need more parking. And, you know, one of the town's strategies that you
56:10 What you've been working on for a long time is Walk by Cride, right? And I think that this information gives the town, the council, just that, that that's still a really important initiative. Because it is all about accessibility. I mean, every single one of those things. It was hard to reach the mountain. It was hard to get back from the mountain. It was hard to go to dinner. It was hard to... I don't want to walk.
56:38 Let's say winter for a second. Forget summer. Yeah. A little bit different animal, right? Yeah. But right now, walk, bike, ride doesn't work. Well, ride does. But I can't find anybody to give me one. Yeah. Right. One of the things I'd like to see under parking, too, I mean, there's kind of two layers. With the question of what, if you build more parking, there's also the question of what do we do with available parking that's not being utilized right now? And I know there, I'm sure there are plenty of...
57:06 Government, political, whatever issues there are with various schools and the colleges and all that stuff. But I get asked every week by lodging people, are they going to allow parking at the school this weekend? When are we going to find out whether that's going to be available or not? Because so many of the condo projects have half the spaces that they've had before. And that's a difficult thing. So we have multiple, multiple parking lots that are...
57:29 Basically not used on the weekend when we have the most people here. And it seems like if we could work out a coordination a little bit better there of, okay, it's Wednesday, we're going to get dumped on, we're not going to have room, this parking lot's going to be open Friday night, Saturday, Sunday, you got to be out of there by Monday morning, whatever, or you're going to get a ticket or however that works. But these areas are available now, and then there will be a bus that will come by every 15 minutes to pick up at those locations as an extra blah, blah, blah.
57:57 There may be some ways of not necessarily having to build more infrastructure, but utilizing what we currently have. Because when we have opened up those school lots, it's been people have been really thankful, especially when, you know, it's been a Friday or Saturday and it's just nuking outside and they, you know, there's supposed to be a spot for them at their condo and it's, you know. They have seven cars for six people. Yeah, that's an issue too. I think that's a good temporary fix to it, but then, you know, I wrote up your transit hub.
58:26 You know, especially with the traffic that goes up the road every day to the mountain, does there need to be a transit hub at the community center that people can park in a structure there, hop a bus that goes up the hill, and hop a bus back down? So at least it minimizes the traffic up the hill. You know, it still creates maybe a little bit of a challenge of a transit hub. I don't know, but, you know, that's one of the options. Yeah, the problem, of course, even when we open them currently...
58:51 And this is a problem that I have said, it's a town we have to solve, but it goes with access, how many van lifers there are, not just living here, but coming and visiting here. So you open a 24-hour parking lot, and the amount of trash that has to be removed afterwards, and the fact that half of it gets filled with people who are actually camping and not, you know, day parking. And if you open it as a 24-hour lot, especially in a year like this, you guys all manage parking lots.
59:19 You don't all drive around in a big piece of equipment, but trying to clear a lot where the cars don't move is impossible, you know? So there's, I agree with everything that's been said, but how do we find a solution to the problems created by the solution? Well, and I think that's the next step. I think us defining the... This is a list of priorities, not why we can't do them. Absolutely. This is just ideas. Yeah, absolutely.
59:47 Let's keep moving on access. Are there other pieces that we feel that we want to add to this portion? Well, okay, so one of the things I have listed here, it really isn't access, but it has to do with the staging areas and other places outside of just normal parking. And the maps and the signage needed to disperse the groups we get, which is an access issue.
1:00:17 So one of the biggest complaints from locals is that the Lakes Basin in July is so, thank God it is, because we make a living doing it, but I'm not afraid to say it, but still, that's it. It's so busy, I can't go up there. And part of the problem for me is access to the other areas and the Forest Service allowing us to print those maps. Part of what this group can do incredibly well is research what those are.
1:00:46 and make the necessary brochures and maps and create the access points if necessary so that we can disperse those hikers to the Sherwin Lakes and the Laurel Lakes as well as the Lakes Basin and to Glass Creek Meadow and to, you know, there's unending opportunities. Amazon does it well if you're searching for something you might also like.
1:01:14 Yeah, that's right. No, these are three things. That's exactly right. Now, the problems with it, of course, are getting the Forest Service to allow you to print maps. Mammoth Creek has trails going down both sides of it, but in reality, those trails don't exist, so you're not allowed to put them on a map. So there are issues with it, but it seems to me that's one of the biggest access things that this group can do is help with the creation of those trailheads that the trails are there.
1:01:43 And then the necessary accompanying maps. Now, you know, I'm an old-fashioned guy with paper in my hand, but produce them for these so that you can go to the Mammoth Trails website or the Mammoth Recreation Wells website or the Mammoth Tourism website and look at, you also might, if you like, you know. And the Mammoth Trails website does that. It says if you like this hike, you might like this hike. And it gives you where the trailhead is, tells you you can get directions. Right.
1:02:15 through to get the permission to add a lot more to that. And that's definitely something that the town has more power than anybody to do. John, is there a second category under a broad heading of sort of guidance? Because we talk about where to hike, but also how to act responsibly. Well, let's... I mean, I'm not trying to be particular on the words, but there's a sort of information guidance education thing.
1:02:46 Educating people about different trails or alternative hikes or things to do. So communications initially was kind of the cell service and Wi-Fi, but it can be education. And it can be education, stewardship, all those different things that we've been working on for four years, you know, asking people to respect the community and the environment and the town and their...
1:03:16 Peace talks about that. They use slightly different terminology to talk about the, it's like the natural setting and the urban setting or something, but it's the same exact thing of community and environment. And so I think it can easily fall under communications. I think communications in the context that I was thinking about with infrastructure was being able to use your phone, being able to use your square at a restaurant. But education and stewardship can definitely continue to fall in that. I don't think that that's necessarily
1:03:45 Anything I know the town has in here that it's support marketing and on-the-ground engagement to develop a culture of stewardship and responsible recreation that's under their strategic priority on environment. So I think that's probably a good place to put it. I'm not necessarily sure that that's a capital investment or a physical investment, but it's absolutely a place we can put that. John, one item that came through our summer feedback.
1:04:21 Incorporated both access and exactly that, the educational aspect, and that's the e-bikes. So the e-bikes, you know, the popularity of that, the ease of getting in and having that experience with multi-generational people, where you can go, the access that you have with those bikes versus other bikes.
1:04:46 and etiquette on how to do that. And so where some of the feedback came back was that people on e-bikes don't understand the etiquette of riding a bike because they don't have done it in a long time. So I think that e-bike access is great and it falls under the communication plan as well. And that was something that we worked very closely with MLR last year. We did the branded bells that they handed out to people to try and educate them to alert people when they're coming.
1:05:15 I think there's another piece of that, and I'll get this exactly wrong, but I know that throttle access bike can't be used on marked trails, but they're used all the time and nobody does anything about it. Speed limits aren't enforced. I mean, I got totally wiped out by somebody coming down who's a local, going to work.
1:05:39 On a modified e-bike, it's a thousand watt small bike, you know, I mean, it's just, you know, going 35 miles an hour down the trail. Right. So, there's probably an enforcement piece of that as well that says, there's education, by the way, if you've got a throttle, you know, don't use it. And have the right access, right? And have the right access. So, enforcement and education. E-bikes came up with a couple of conversations that I had last week.
1:06:07 And so I'm glad that you mentioned that and I was going to. But also staging areas for snowmobile access, off-road, side-by-side in the summertime, opening up more terrain, working with the Forest Service. In fact, a couple of the guys that I was talking to said, we almost need a full-time guide just to deal with the Forest Service. I mean, the fact that we don't have the snow pit this year of all years.
1:06:35 Some of the other issues that we were just talking about with access, I mean, that would help tremendously. Of course, my answer to that, because I've answered that same question many times, that we do now have a full-time guy to deal with the Forest Service. That's what I told him. I said, I sat on the panel when we brought on Lawson, and a lot of people just aren't aware of that. Right. It's like, hey, these are, and they were very pleased to hear that. But it's not, we don't have access to the snow pit.
1:07:02 There's not a lot of options for staging areas, for snowmobile riding, off-road, side-by-side, these types of things, and something that they were interested in. Or again, a lot of educational information on different rides and what you can do and what you can't do. Is there anything else under communications that you guys can think of? I mean, obviously, the two big things were literally the access to being able to communicate, whether it's getting your systems to work or...
1:07:34 You know, calling your kid when they're stuck in a snowbank. The problem I have with the communication piece, almost everything that happened this year in communications, it's true that our systems are overloaded during big weekends. But almost all the reasons that everything went down had to do with our storms this year. It had to do with generators running out of fuel because they couldn't be delivered. Batteries running out, you know, digital 395 in Bridgeport went down.
1:08:02 The first piece you mentioned, you know, the first piece you mentioned is just, I think, even when we don't have huge crowds in town or we don't have weather, we have issues. Yeah. You know, whether it's home Wi-Fi and, you know, digital 395 has not been the savior that everybody thought it was going to be and it was supposed to be. The cell service, when we are busy, you can't make a phone call. And I think that's, again, it comes down to a safety issue. It's not weather dependent. There's a safety. Absolutely. Fire department's dealing with that.
1:08:29 Now, there's parts of town where communication is just not existing. I want to move there. And that's a problem. It is. And that's why I think that. And I don't know the answers to it. I don't know if it's another cell tower. I don't know if it's beefing up the cell tower. I don't know if it's going to 5G. I don't know. Again, we're not here to necessarily solve the problem. We just know that both our residents and our visitors have problems with cell service. And have problems. And Wi-Fi. Yeah, and Wi-Fi. So I would add to both cell service and Wi-Fi, consistent, reliable.
1:09:00 Somebody's going to say, we have cell service, we have Wi-Fi. Well, the problem is, consistent, dependable something that says, you know, if you dial 911, you can actually get through, or you need to make an emergency call that you can get through. And we did not have that for a long period of time. Consistent, reliable is everything. Transit, the only way transit's successful, the only way to get people out of their cars is if you can guarantee that the 815 bus is going to show up at 815.
1:09:28 Maybe on a snow day it takes 25 minutes late, I might not die. Right, that's what I'm saying. But if it's 45 minutes late, you're never going to take the bus again. Honestly, it's like the problem we had with Mammoth Yosemite Airport. There were so many people that got canceled that decided to never fly again that that's what didn't help us build that business. Now we have people that know that it's reliable out of Bishop and they're using it more than once or twice a year.
1:09:51 And they're growing with that. I would just say that, I mean, I know we all felt that more this year, Bill, to your point, but it's been something that's been a problem for us for a long time. And one quote verbatim, still can't believe the Wi-Fi situation in the city of Mammoth Lakes is so awful year after year. That is, I mean, who knows what they're speaking of? Maybe it's Canyon Lodge, which, by the way, we just approved $70,000 to go beef up the Wi-Fi there in Canyon Lodge.
1:10:21 That is something that our guests are feeling, and we need to, with Digital 395, there's got to be opportunities. Well, and to your point, if we have five cell towers in town, and we can invest 70 grand a cell tower and get the cell service to work, that's a pretty cheap $350,000 investment for having something to call that loss. And we actually have a grant to look into what it takes to increase that service and to go down that road. Well, and again, I've mentioned it before. I have no idea how much a new cell tower is. I have no idea how, well, now I do have an idea of how much it is to beef it up. I don't know what the process is. I don't know what the...
1:10:50 The issues are, I don't, but again, we just need to talk about this. It's not a playing game, it's just really about what's about it all. Right, well, and what I'm saying is, the discovery comes from this opportunity. We say it's all service and Wi-Fi, so what's the solution? We're not solving it today, we're just saying these are the problems. And that is the broad, the whole broadband thing is being, is being looked at. And that's in here, yeah. Right, yeah.
1:11:14 But part of the problem, frankly, is digital 395 is living up to its promise. What isn't is the last mile provider. That's right. And how do we do that? The town can't just buy them, can't get somebody else to come in and buy them out. My understanding is everybody in Crowley Lake has the best Wi-Fi in the world. Yes, they do. But everybody in Mammoth has the worst Wi-Fi in the world. Yes. Why? I don't understand why. I don't get it.
1:11:40 For the same reason that Truckee does, and it's the same company, I won't say more than that. John, does experience come up here as a topic? I think it's kind of the overarching. We're talking about the resident and visitor experience, and it's how it's affected by all of these. So if there are pieces that tie up to a better experience for visitors or a better experience for residents, we can fit them in wherever it is. Well, I mean, I don't know whether this fits or not. But again, it's amazing what information you get from people over.
1:12:13 Most all of them guests talking about their experience. And by and large, in spite of the weather and everything else, their experiences have been great. You know, I mean, a great day on the slopes, thanks to Eric and his team, do wonders to an average experience someplace else, you know, that I waited for gas in line or had to shovel my car out or anything else. But it is interesting to hear people talk about different...
1:12:43 providers of lodging experiences. So, John, this will, you know, so, and I'm speaking particularly like Vacasa, VRBO, Airbnb, right? Vacasa and VRBO seem to be pretty consistently good. Airbnb, I have not heard a good thing. They check in, the place is dirty, they check in.
1:13:11 There's missing stuff, they can't get in the front door, they had to dig their front door out by themselves. Vacasa has people here, I mean, you know, right in the business park, somebody to manage. I can tell you for one thing, I know that Rob Patterson and his team, they're working on a newer program, which is basically a certified property manager situation, which I think will not solve those problems, but will help.
1:13:37 And then just making the requirements to get that short-term rental license a little bit higher. And I know Bill's mentioned it a million years ago that probably the best thing to do would be to have not allowed to make sure that you had to go through a actual local condo management program in order to be able to get a rental review, whatever. But frankly, if you can't, and you're not going to stop anybody necessarily from Airbnb or BRB or anything else, at least then try to control it.
1:14:07 Yeah, I mean, to the degree you can. And I realize those are sort of out of the place. But it has been interesting, you know, people self-triaging the experience they've had in different places. It has been very unfortunate that some of the providers in town, you know, whether it's somebody that owns a place down south and doesn't really have anybody here to help people, that some of those experiences have been not so great. And I realize Airbnb and everybody else is, you know,
1:14:35 Subject to the same workforce issues as everybody else. They can get people to clean or they can't. But it just seems like that is many times the first point of contact. People go check in their condo or the house that they rented. And it's... Thumbs down. Nice timing on that. What do you think? Should I answer it? Defibrillator. Yeah, go ahead. Tell them to start shoveling.
1:15:04 With access, I just recalled in my communication with two of our TBID constituents yesterday, and I am not picking on the mountain at all, but this came up. Takes a long time to get down from Main Lodge on busy weekends. We've talked about a roundabout at that intersection of Forest Trail and Minaret. You know, that...
1:15:34 was a concern that was voiced by both business owners I talked to yesterday, and the other one was lack of parking. Yeah, yeah. And the other one was lack of parking at Canyon was the one that was referenced, you know, specifically Lakeview Boulevard being a real problem this year. I love the fact that so they finally cut the burn on Lakeview.
1:16:01 And they've written, and it's the spray paint, no parking, so everybody parks on the other side under the no parking side. You know, you're driving, and it's like, I think this goes back to the idea that if you build, and I know that parking structures are expensive to build and whatever, but if you were able to build a parking structure or a transit station.
1:16:19 Whether it's at the community center or the park and ride lot or whatever it is, and the blue bus goes to Canyon and the green bus goes to Maine and this one goes to Eagle, and all of a sudden you've at least got, you've got all of those eliminated or at least, you know, maybe you take a thousand cars out of the mix and it makes it that much better experience for the people that actually did drive up the hill and then you don't have to. Or if you had reliable, consistent bus service and microtransit to support it.
1:16:44 Yeah. Well, and that's it. I mean, I think that if you can look at the fact that you know that, hey, I want to be on the lift at 8.30, I know if I catch the 8 a.m. bus, I'm going to be at Main Lodge at 8.15, if you know that that's going to happen, then you might be more inclined not to drive all the way up there. To me, that's a better experience, walking out my door at Snow Creek, getting on a bus versus getting in my car, going to park in a transit. And then walk a mile. Yeah, right.
1:17:11 No, and I think that, I think that's it. I mean, if you can get me to drop, if you can drop me off at my, the front door of the, uh, the lodge, as opposed to me parking, waiting for a shuttle, walking to the shuttle stop, and then still having to walk. Hey, Eric, do you guys still have the toaster around? Maybe you could extend that line? I went flying a while ago. You know what? It was just a time. Come back. Ahead of it signed, yeah. One of those at my, my ski area in New Hampshire, too. I had the, I had the monorail parked out in front of our ski area in the 60s, and there was.
1:17:39 It was well gone before I got there, but it was going to run to the top of the mountain in the restaurant and everything else, and it looked like Disney. Okay, we can always add things back here, but let's talk. The next one we had on the list was restrooms, mainly summer in Lakes Basin, but also Welcome Center and General. You have Main and OMR. Oh, okay.
1:18:04 Yeah, you know, speaking from the Chamber's perspective, putting on the 4th of July parade, nightmare situation with restrooms. Businesses get very frustrated that people are just coming in their shop all day long, you know, of the 4th of July parade. We did mitigate that this year by bringing in, you know, hundreds of porta-potties and kind of organizing these, you know,
1:18:32 Restroom areas with all the port-a-potties, I know that Blueza Palooza has to do the same thing. I was commenting to Urdi at lunchtime that, you know, shady restrooms are an absolute joke. You know, you go, you drive up to 395 and in Walker they have two or three beautiful heated year-round restrooms that are marked, you know, right off the 395.
1:19:01 They aren't so beautiful, but okay. Compared to Shady Rest. It's all relative. They're good, decent, comfortable options on the 395. It'd be nice to see something like that. I think we have a real opportunity at Shady Rest. We talked about OHV staging areas. Some people built some pipelines that are pretty frustrating.
1:19:26 impacting those recreation opportunities in Shady Rest, but I think we have a real opportunity at Shady Rest to make it a recreational OHV staging area, make it more comfortable with year-round restrooms, and really build up that area a little bit. I know we're limited because it's on Forest Service land, but that's a great opportunity. Is there, Bill, is there any...
1:19:54 You probably know what's townland and what isn't. Is there any opportunity along the downtown corridor, along Old Mammoth Road, along Main Street, between Mammoth Brewing Company and the stove in that area? Are there opportunities in the area to put restrooms anywhere? Park and ride. Restrooms. Restrooms, yeah, at the park and ride. We could put one there. Town owns very little land. You've got the easements on Old Mammoth Road, but they aren't very wide.
1:20:25 And no room like in any of the bus stops or anything like that. Which are all, except for the ones on Old Mammoth Road, are all Caltrans easements. But yeah, there is one of the things in Dan's list that I have here is additional restrooms placed. I mean, especially off the edge of the parcel, the street side of the parcel. It's not really close. But there is no street side of the parcel. No, no, no. Center Street. Like behind shots and all that kind of stuff. Yeah. Yeah, yeah. You had to walk 50 feet. We have one lot.
1:20:56 And this is all coming from a mine that's, you know, been looking at snow for the last several months. We have one lot for access to the parcel on Center Street. That's all the town has there. So is there some opportunity? Yeah. Is that the best spot for it? Probably not. I think one or two on Main Street in Caltrans easement, and I think that can probably be done. I guess my point would be that if we're really trying to, you know, other than, you know, the village is great.
1:21:22 The Village is wonderful for the way it's laid out and the bathroom accessibility and all that stuff that kind of takes care of itself during festivals and just in regular whatever. But if we're trying to make this downtown corridor as a walking pedestrian type of you can go to shops and restaurants and you don't need your car there, you need a bathroom. Even though, yes, every one of those businesses has a restroom and of course the ones in restaurants are all...
1:21:48 usable by the patrons and so forth. But, you know, if you're going to have people walk in all that space, I mean, there's got to have something in that area. And I have a list here of 20 things from Dan that he has that could be used in this. And restrooms, Old Mammoth Road and Main Street are on that list. And maybe it is tying it in with where the bus shelters are. The bus shelter at the post office, maybe there's one behind that. Or maybe it's on the Liberty side where the other thing is. And then Old Mammoth Road, I don't know.
1:22:15 And it could be while Motel 6 owns land that comes down to the Caltrans. It doesn't have to be on public land. It can be on private land. We just have to have the permission to build the thing. And that's, you know. That would be hugely helpful. You know, on the communication side, and I have this written down here because I don't know where it's gone or if we're still even doing it, the banner program. We used to provide the banners. I think that the park crew put them up. Are we still?
1:22:41 Big into that program? We're still big into that program. It got a little screwed up this year. They're supposed to come down in November. The new ones go up. The snowflakes go up for the winter and the snowflakes came down too early and they're supposed to stay up until April and then the banners go back up.
1:22:55 So there's some communication issue, but yes, we have that program. We expanded the snowflakes, so it was banners or snowflakes, not both. Because it's huge, it looks good. Can I pick a recommendation under trash, actually? John, instead of trash, do something broader like we did with access, do curb appeal or something, and then the banner program would go perfectly into that area. And again, you've heard me talk about in the past.
1:23:23 pounding on the local businesses to live up to what I believe is their responsibility for beautification of all the major corridors and stuff as well. But does the town, but that's, that's, and I agree with you, right? Yeah. But I think that if you surveyed everybody in that business community, there are broad differences in what they, and I think that, you know, perhaps a certain, during the spring and summer, let's try to theme it. I mean,
1:24:07 I know that the chamber encourages, you know, beautification and all that kind of stuff, but there ought to be, I don't know what it is, but some of the programs that used to exist that had people do it, outside of Joni, who did such a great job anyway, were competitions. You get recognition for doing certain things, and I think that while the overall mindset seems to be, why isn't government doing more for me?
1:24:41 to get them to think, gee, I can have recognition and this can help me in the long run if I put snowflakes on my own building or if I... So we actually had a couple years ago with the chamber, we talked about if we went out and bought a ton of Christmas lights, you know, just white lights, make them easy, and just made them available to businesses. We'll call them winter lights. Winter lights, she has holiday decoration. I'm up all year, who cares? But that's, you know, I think the idea is that it's...
1:25:12 And it's probably not the cost of a string of lights. It's probably more the hassle to put them up. But we've tried the, you know, the light contests and we've tried all those different things. And I think that... You give away the lights and you get complaints because they have to pay for the electricity. But it's true. It's always going to be that way. But I also think now that you've got people that are working 24 hours a day and there's no time to put up lights and there's no staff to put up lights. So I think that, you know, it's kind of like the snowflakes. We don't... We actually have Decralite put those up.
1:25:41 You know, it's not something that we burden the town with. It's not something that we do as a staff. We actually have a company that does that. Maybe that's something we look at and we say, okay, hey, we want to have these two roads completely decked out and maybe we hire a company that comes in or, you know, somebody starts a little cottage industry in town and we, you know, if you want your place decorated, just let us know and we'll get you decorated. And again, it goes to your curb appeal and it talks about that. And it's huge. You know, I have my parents in New Hampshire.
1:26:09 If I'm back there for any sort of holiday, Labor Day or Memorial Day or Veterans Day or something, the local rotary does a deal where they sell you a flag for $100. And for each of those holidays, they come by. You have a flagpole on your mailbox. They come by for those holidays. They put it out. They come by after that holiday. They pull it out. You don't put it out, but you're showing your support, and it supports the local rotary club, whatever it is.
1:26:34 And, you know, it's kind of a cool program. But, again, the same sort of thing. How do we get to that point where we say, hey, if you want to be part of this program, let us know. We figure out what it's going to cost to do it. And, yeah, I mean, it should be part of that curb appeal when you come into town. You know, having a Rotary member in the family, they're always looking for service projects, as I'm sure Lions is and everything else. You know, I think this public-private partnership leverage is not a – whether it's a flag program or whatever.
1:27:03 You know, maybe that's a way. I know that Rotary has done water bottle filling stations around town, you know, funded themselves in conjunction with the town. But they're looking for things to do and they're looking for projects. You know, maybe there's some way to leverage them in some fashion. And Lion's the same thing. They're all public service organizations. John, before the meeting's over.
1:27:34 One of the things we haven't talked about that I believe is going to be critical, locals and tourists alike, because it helps spread people out, is our events space. And that's something the town and this organization both definitely need to work on and come up with a consensus of how we're going to solve it, whether we're going to buy that land, whether we're going to look for other land. I know that Dan has shown me plans potentially to use the bell-shaped parcel for it.
1:28:03 Although I think that would be a huge legal fight. I think it would be, and I wish we had better communication on that, because, I mean, we've been working on our own path in this group, because we have money sitting in our event account that we had from the ill-fated wood site debacle. Right. But we have been working with, you know, I got here 13 years ago, and I'm sure that it was an argument 13 years before that as to where the event site should be, you know, it's too cold, it's too windy, it's too this, it's too that. There is no perfect place.
1:28:31 You know, we have really kind of settled on the opportunity at Canyon Lodge with the idea that Chair 16 moving, build a stage, back it up there, and have it project towards the gondola. You've got access, you've got parking, you've got all these other things. So Dakota and I have been working very closely with the mountain to try and move towards that. You've got a facility that can handle 20,000 people. You've got restrooms, you've got retail, you've got food, you've got storage, you've got lockers, you've got bars, you've got gondolas, you've got parking buses, you've got shelter if you get a lightning storm.
1:29:00 You know, I think that the idea that everybody wants to say, well, it's too windy, it's too cold. I had a bluegrass festival in Wyoming at 9,000 feet that got two feet of snow on it one year in August. There are risks. I have sat on the side of the hill at Canyon Lodge for many, many events because we used to do big events there. And I'm here to tell you even in August it is cold. Well, it is. And I think when the sun goes down, that's when you sell hoodies. Yeah.
1:29:28 Did it stop me? No. No. Even though there weren't no people selling whiskey in town at the time. It's the only place that could stay open right now because of Lincoln Mountain shades the whole thing. Yeah. You know? I don't know. Do we want to have that as a standalone category? Right.
1:29:48 Well, at first I thought you were talking about the CRC, but you're not. I'm not. No, I'm talking about an outdoor event, someplace where Bluesapalooza can go, someplace if someone wants to do a Jazz Jubilee again, someplace that Shakespeare in the Park can go, so it needs to be affordable overall as well. Well, and that has been the focus, is that working with the mountain to make sure that it's not something that's going to be unattainable by any event that wants to go up there.
1:30:13 You've got VIP access up the wazoo with different decks in different areas. You've got indoor area where you can move a performer off the stage into an acoustic set for the VIP area. You've got the roof deck. You've got the bar. You've got the outside patio. You've got just...
1:30:26 The whole beginner slope that runs up the other side, you can put all sorts of food and beverage and fun, whatever out there. So we have been working on that. That is something that we want to have the conversations with the moving of the lift because if we need to run power while they're digging up the ground and we need to say, okay, this is where we're going to go with it, then we should be doing that sooner than later. We do have funds in the account to help with that. We've got, I absolutely love the stage that Deer Valley uses. It's an absolutely gorgeous summer stage.
1:30:55 It's not a permanent structure, although they have like five permanent structures over there. Same with Deer Valley, or Sun Valley, they've got an outdoor amphitheater, an indoor amphitheater, and then a bigger outdoor amphitheater. It's kind of an embarrassment, but yeah. But I think that we have the opportunity with that, so. They have one. They do. Embarrassing or not? Well, it's an embarrassment of riches is what it is. It's an embarrassment of the fact that you were not having one. They have one that we complain about. I'll plug it over here as just a kind of standalone because it is a big piece.
1:31:24 It is something that we have been working towards for. I think it's a great point, Bill, and it probably does serve its own category. But another one that we talked about early on, A1, you said employee housing. I just want to bring that up again because I think it should continue to be on the list for time counsel, and I think we need a category. And here's the biggest reason that I'm bringing it up. It's because there's still the missing middle.
1:31:54 We're going to have these people that are only earning so much. A lot of our employees in the fountain aren't even going to be able to go into the affordable housing. So what about those that are really looking to be here and build a life and how does that program look? And I know that there's been discussions around that, but I think we need to tell the town that that's still a really big issue.
1:32:20 It's amazing how it comes back through our guest comments, where, you know, through those surveys, you know, there's verbatims coming back. People don't have a place to live. Look, our service workforce and the people who are struggling are talking to people, right? Yeah. It's not uncommon for...
1:32:43 You just strike up a conversation with your server or anything else. Yeah, you want to get the zone. And there's, you know, where do you live? I'm living out of my car. What? You know, yes. Look, I would be embarrassed if you knew how many of our firefighters are living in their cars. Yeah. Wow. And yet they won't qualify for housing because they make too much money. Well, and I think that... Well, but there are... And they need to be expanded. But in the Housing Now portfolio...
1:33:12 There are several helps for them. I mean, we are buying units as fast as we can afford to buy them, indeed restricting them, and then we've got a, you know, a down payment loan assistance program. And I understand that. All I'm saying is, and Eric's point, having been through this bitch a number of different times, there is that chunk in the middle. Yeah, absolutely there is. I can afford anything I want, and the chunk in the middle is I'm barely making it, but I'm making a little too much to go for good stuff, and yet I'm...
1:33:41 I can't really put it together on the other end. So that's good. I think we'll put that as, again, it's kind of like our, when we do our deliverables, we talk about the fact that we are still here to bring visitors. Even though we're going to talk about education, we're going to talk about other things, are still our main goal is that, and the main priority must be housing for the immediate future, because that is our biggest risk. Our biggest risk is if we have people coming up here who don't want to come here anymore because it's a two-hour wait.
1:34:08 And it's just too, you know, they're not getting the level of service. Or a restaurant can't stay in business because they can only see 10 tables instead of 30 because they don't have staff. So that is our biggest risk. Well, only in having lost, what, eight restaurants, 10 restaurants in the last two years, and having an equal or more number of people coming here, that just gets exacerbated. And you can't solve that problem without more people. Yeah, and one thing that we were talking about the other day that's interesting, when I came here, our population was 8,234 people. Now it's 6,970-something.
1:34:38 It's gone down. Our population when I got here was 8,234. Our population that we Googled the other day is 6,900 and something in the latest census. So that's 1,300 people that have left. Well, I think, I mean, I'm sure people know that there was a monstrous portion of our workforce that left during COVID because
1:35:03 for whatever reason, whether they couldn't qualify for benefits or whatever the situation was, went to look for work elsewhere, and wherever they were living, those places are no longer available for them to move back to. They have either been converted to... Well, our chances are... When that big decrease, I mean, was it a steady decrease over time, or how big a dip did it take? Well, interesting for me is...
1:35:25 Is it a true decrease? Yes, there has been some. But at 8,200, it was my belief at the time that Mammoth did not actually have that many people living here. When was the last census taken? It was taken during COVID. Well, sorry, they didn't go around to the houses as they normally do and knock on doors and say who's living here. They did. They were still alive. They did some. Maybe not at the same level as they did before. Yeah, not even close. It would be surprising you missed 1,300 people. Yeah.
1:35:52 And there are also. Our businesses are failing it. Well, yeah, that's the. It's not like we're sitting, you know, same old, same old. It's definitely failing. Exactly, because I can tell you from, you know, and I don't have to tell all the rest of you guys, you know, trying to, you know, I've exhausted every possible way I can advertise to try to get somebody to come work for me. And I'm simply, my ethics are I'm not going to steal people from other businesses. I'm just not going to do it because it's not right. And it doesn't help anything. Yeah, and arguing is not. The solution is not arguing a number.
1:36:22 Well, it's a 16% decrease. So, I mean, are you 16% down in staff? Yeah. Easy. I mean, I think that's, you know, I think it's not something that you look at and say, oh, yeah, that number's not right. It's probably right, if not higher, that we've lost 16% of the workforce. Yeah, so the question becomes, why have we lost them? Looking at the, which is impossible, incidentally, looking at the number of monthly rentals available, it would appear that they have not actually gone down. There have been some come on and some go off, but.
1:36:52 That number is out there. So multifamily situations has decreased incredibly throughout our population where you get two or three families to convert to private owners. Well, that's exactly what I was just going to say. One of the things that we're doing with AirDNA is to work on the past three years. Yeah, so probably the last three or four years as to what happened with the inventory on Airbnb and VRBO and what happened to our population.
1:37:18 There's probably a direct correlation to going that way. So, I mean, that would be a great thing for us to look at, Brian. Okay. We have, I think, one of the things that I brought up here, because I know it's been brought up with council, is, you know, EV charging stations. I was talking with Carl up in Tahoe the other day, and he was talking about the fact that Southlake has, you know, 37-some-odd universal charging stations. I'm like, wow, I'd love to have 37. He's like, we're woefully short here.
1:37:48 And I think that even some of the stuff that we've talked about adding with the CRC is probably a tenth of what we actually need. And so I think that that's something that we definitely have to have. I know that it's in the council priorities. I would put that under access. Yeah. How many are planned at the CRC? Do you know? I should. I don't remember what the number is. But I know we're also looking at putting more on the park and ride lot. So Tesla has those now.
1:38:18 Other companies are coming forward with the desire to put some in. Well, the piece, which is really critical. Yeah, right. So I think people aren't, I mean, they're carrying adapters with them. That's a crap sheet, right? That's one plug adapter. I think to your point, and Emily probably knows the numbers, but if you look at what is happening at the CRC, Tesla is paying to put 12 in, and then Universal is like four. Four Universals is not. Yeah, come on up.
1:38:57 Our resident electric car driver at MLT. Hello. Best choice I ever made, by the way, is to buy a plug-in hybrid. I just want everybody to know that. The Tesla adapter piece that you talk of does not work on the superchargers that we have here.
1:39:15 So you could, with the superchargers that are installed at the Westin and the Village in Juniper Springs, you can get an adapter for those. But that is actually like another step up that you cannot get an adapter for universal. They're commercially available, but they're not. Right, exactly. And Emily can speak to the fact that when she was working as an admin, the amount of calls we get where people are planning their trip.
1:39:39 And if we didn't have chargers for them, they weren't coming. We definitely have people turning away. You have a plug-in hybrid, so you have an option. I do. And we chose that option because of the unavailability of the chargers. Even the chargers in Bishop, the one that's in the Vons parking lot, doesn't work on my style of vehicle. I don't know how many Rivians you all see in town. Tons. Yeah, like a ton. They have a completely different problem.
1:40:09 They, yeah, and they actually, so in Bishop, they work to install the Rivian chargers at the, um, El Pollo Loco. Thank you, El Pollo Loco, which is very specific to Rivian, but actually in Inyo Kern, they installed, uh, universal chargers, and there are three universal chargers that I can use for free, and I just sit there and eat my classic burger in the parking lot. I'm always looking forward to a classic burger, and, looking at that, at the distillery as well. Yeah, yeah, exactly, so I think,
1:40:38 You know, I mean, we made that choice because we knew we wouldn't be able to find chargers. We have a plug on the outside of our house that we installed for our diesel truck. Not to go on and on, but I, you know, so I just charge at home. The best charger in Mono County is at the Guy Hess Park up in Lee Bining. So, and that's all off of the solar panels that are on top of the plaza there. So, and we definitely...
1:41:03 Have visitors who are saying, you guys just don't have them, so we're not going to come there. We had one gentleman end up actually down in Red's Meadow with no availability to charge his car. So, you know, they're definitely looking to come, but now he's not coming ever again. I mean, he wrote us an email. He's not going to come ever again. Bill, what? I'm thinking about the CRC, and that's, I mean, I know it's not necessary.
1:41:30 Maybe up there somewhere. I don't see it. But the CRC, I think, is going to be a, it's a, obviously, it's a very expensive community asset that will come online, hopefully, by the end of this year. And, yeah, fingers crossed, I know. We could never stop snowing. But just the, I think, I keep looking at that, and I keep thinking about the programming of that facility. And when we talk about benefit to the community,
1:41:58 You know, and believe me, I have absolutely nothing against hockey whatsoever. You know, exactly, I know. But I just want to see that, I would love to see that facility be programmed to its hilt to benefit the most number of both guests and locals in varieties of different ways. And Stu's got that. Stu's definitely putting on it being booked, and then Dakota has definitely been working with him. In fact, we talked about the yoga festival.
1:42:27 moving from June because of snow into the fall, and they want to be housed out of them. Well, I know when we went through our process, we had actually a request for a concert in early December, and it's like, maybe a little too early. We can't quite program that yet. But just, it's a great resource. I think it's going to be a really cool building. Yeah, and it's being looked at, of course, for a multiple of reasons, and the questions become,
1:42:49 So when you say program it to the hilt, in my mind, because I come off the park and rec commission, is immediately program it for our local youth and adults and all the things you do. If you program it fully out for that, then where is the time? And Stu can answer these questions far better than I at this point, but how do you free the time so if somebody wants to do a concert there, they can do a concert there? What does it cost to do it over? I mean, we all know the big basketball stadiums for...
1:43:16 For the NBA, have ice under the floors and things like that. What does it take to have ice and what do we have to have to throw over the top of it? So those are all things that will be ferreted out. But yes, it needs to be programmed to the hilt, I completely agree. Yeah, it's going to be a great asset. And I think that hopefully for people who do choose to live here and stay here and raise their kids and so forth, that that's going to be a sense of pride, I hope. Because I think it's going to be a really cool thing. And I don't think that people really understand right now. They kind of look at it and go, yeah, whatever. They don't get it.
1:43:46 And so not necessarily our, well, part of our job is to get people to do that. Because if we allow it to be just a hockey rink, it's just going to be obvious. Yeah. But there's all, first it's ice, it's not hockey, it's ice for all sorts of things. It will be a great spot for the kids I find in the hall here before every council meeting to have a place to actually go to and hang out together without feeling like, you know, they've got an oppressive hand on them.
1:44:16 So, yeah, I'm really looking forward to it. My understanding is it's also going to be a big transportation hub, correct? Yeah. You're going to have the chargers out there. However, at all the spots where the town are building chargers, those are not just for charging. If they are needed for parking, they're open for parking as well because we don't have the space to do it for both. So, I find the EV thing...
1:44:44 A weird duck for an old guy. If you are going to put gas in your car, you go to a gas station, which is owned by a private company that makes the profit off of it. Now, if you buy an electric car, you're going to a charging station that the government has given space to put in, and the company that makes the chargers are making the profit without having to do any infrastructure. This is the same problem. You have this whole strategy.
1:45:15 Or you have this demand strategy, public vehicles. So the concept is no one makes an electric fire truck today, but in the state of California by 2025, 50% of all emergency vehicle purchases have to be fired. So the hope is that somebody's going to get off their seat, out of their seat, and develop an electric fire truck that the people in California can buy by 2025. It's at any cost, because they know they have to do it. Same with...
1:45:48 You know, every other vehicle that's got to be purchased publicly. And this is part of the problem you have, is they're saying, we want to encourage people, right, even to the point where they'll provide the power for free and subsidize the electric company to provide it. It doesn't make economic, it's sort of like air service, I digress. You know, you're investing today to make it standalone tomorrow where you can actually make money on it and not have to subsidize so much.
1:46:16 But there's seed money that has to go in this. Whether you agree with the strategy or not is a whole different discussion. I was just going to bring up one other thing. Under communications, what about our reader board? What about public? I mean, is that happening or is that not happening? We have the corner sign that we've been talking about at Footloose. We have been told, Dakota can give you an update, but we've been told there's not a lot of love for it.
1:46:44 I would just like to, as long as we have some town council in the room and maybe on the call, we were told from town that town council has no interest in it and they're not putting it forward in front of the council because they have no interest in seeing it in town. And that's where that stops. Very disappointing response, I think. You can put it on there as a comment? I think it's just, it's an odd response given that the fact that...
1:47:13 We'll just go continue to print banners and let them rip up in the wind and get bungee corded and everything else. I don't have a better solution, but it's just... Well, the better solution is an LED board, and it comes down to being able to put safety messages... Welcome to town. Yeah, right. I mean, if it's the most basic thing. Anyway, okay. What about... We didn't put trails up there, and I know that we're kind of looking at the infrastructure improvements that...
1:47:41 are really necessary, but trails is a great benefit to our whole community. Is that, does it belong on this? I think, I think they do. I think the one thing I will say, and I didn't see it in your survey either, I don't think I've ever heard anybody complain that we don't have enough trails. I mean, I think it's fine because the trail network is definitely important and maybe, maybe if we, maybe if we have a larger trail network that it draws people. So I'm going to disagree with you a little.
1:48:09 No, people are not saying we don't have enough trails. What they're saying is the trails we have are overused and overcrowded, which is the same as saying we don't have enough trails. I agree with you, and you heard me say it earlier, so I'm repeating myself. There are enough trails. People just don't know about them and don't know where to go and don't know how to find them. And the Forest Service doesn't acknowledge the fact that they exist. So we're not allowed legally as a sub-government agency to...
1:48:37 Put them on our maps. We have to rely on private to do that. We have to encourage, you know. We can't put out a map showing the hot tubs. But a private person can do that, and that's legal, and that's fine. There are books in the Welcome Center that show the hot tubs. Yes. And the trails are the same way. There are books, but nobody's going. Our customers are not coming up and going to the ESEA and buying books to find out where to cook. Well, and I think it also brings up a big thing. Like, when we started talking about over-tourism back in, you know, five years ago.
1:49:07 The question that I still question is whether the overtourism is an effect on the visitor or is an effect on the local because the visitors are coming from the city. I had this conversation with somebody that I can't remember who it was that they were in L.A. and they were talking about, you know, we were talking about bonds being busy and they're like, my Rite Aid or my Albertsons is busy like that every day. So it's not, they're not having an issue standing seven in line. No, that's right. They're used to standing seven in line. Yeah, locals. Oh yeah, and one of my answers to them is I take regular
1:49:36 weekly trips around the lake basin, and yes, sometimes it's crowded, and I'm not seeing people with frowns on their faces, I'm seeing family with big old smiles. And that's the differentiation, and that's why I think when we talk about community, we need to talk about the residents and the visitors, because there could be two different experiences going on there, where the visitor has zero problem with 80% of the things that locals have problems with.
1:49:58 You know, there are too many people here, there are too many people there, everybody else is thrilled to be out of the city. Where do they overlap? Where do they overlap and how much of it is that issue? So I think that that's a big part of this community perspective research that we need to do is finding out really where those disconnects are because I think that, you know, something that we think is a problem, people are maybe they're used to it because they deal with it every day. It's no different from, you know, when I go down to LA for a volleyball tournament, I...
1:50:25 I'm very well aware of the fact that I have to plan my trip differently because there's traffic down there and I don't want to get stuck sitting in traffic for five hours and that's just a fact of life. I'm just going to say it personally, I feel like a lot of the people I talk to who lived here a long time and who are locals, I feel like sometimes are not...
1:50:44 Making that extra effort to go to a place at a different time frame or a different day or whatever it might be to have a great experience because, yeah, I am not going to Lake Mary at noon in July to go paddle boarding. I go at 8 o'clock in the morning and there's nobody there. Or Vons at 6 o'clock before I go to work. So, you know, I want to be a little careful about that because, you know, I do acknowledge that there are a lot of challenges for workforce and for locals and we need to work on it.
1:51:13 That's a point I make a lot in my conversations. If you're a local and you can't figure out where to go on a busy Saturday in the summertime where you're not going to hit a bunch of people, maybe you need to rethink your status. Well, and it's like if you're a skier, you don't go in for lunch at noon. And if you're local and you're a skier, you're not skiing on the weekend.
1:51:42 Unless you have to. Unless you're a Jew. Or you're like us. Or you're like us who ski from 830 to 10 and leave. 830 to 10, get 15 runs in and leave. Or if you're a Jew skier, you've got a motor between them. Which we have to. What about sidewalks? Do we need to put sidewalks up there? Is there a need? I think we can put it on here. I think part of this is to have the town.
1:52:11 Maybe address what are the plans? Because I know there are plans for the sidewalk to go up the west side of Main Street, but I don't know when that is or what the thought process is. And there are plans being developed now to the third stage or whatever it is of going from Minaret and Main to Old Mammoth. Right, which is much needed. And if we're looking for places where there can be partnerships and funding partnerships, that's one of those.
1:52:41 places to get that done. And having, you know, having more, um, sidewalk access is, is really great. I mean, I, you know, there's, there are the sidewalks that connect right out in front of where my, where my cabin office is at, uh, Timber Creek in Old Mammoth. And, you know, I see the, the town, the little mini blowers out there blowing that path all the time. And I always see people on there. I mean, there's people walking their dogs and jogging and riding bikes and stuff. I mean, I think it seems like crazy. I mean,
1:53:08 This year it's been kept amazingly well clear. I think the sidewalks are the first thing that get done every day. That's awesome. It's great. So that's great. All right, we've got like five minutes left. I just want to make sure we haven't missed anything. What I'm going to do is I'm going to take a picture of this. I'll put it all together. I'm sure we have. I'm sure we have, no question. I think there's always more discussion. I actually did think about that. Where would that curb appeal? Where would that go? Locals, infrastructure. More Locals than anything else.
1:53:35 We'll just put it under here for now. Put it under fecal disposer. Well, and I saw that. It's definitely for trash and, you know, pet stations you should put in a code of appeal. I had this conversation earlier that, you know, you get on to Huntington Beach. That's a local and a tourist. Yeah, absolutely. But again, I think you solve it for everyone. I think when you go to Huntington Beach, every 100 yards on the beach, there's a trash can. And they're emptied regularly and they're, you can't, you have no excuse for dropping something because.
1:54:09 You're standing in the middle, there's one 150 feet on either side of you. We're talking about the dog problem. No, I understand, but even on the sidewalks in Huntington Beach, every 100 yards there's a trash can. So, you know, here, half the time you're out and it's like there's not expecting to put trash cans up in the cloud, but, you know, if we go out throughout town, whether it's dog stations or trash cans for them, you know, that's another piece that I think is huge. And you have to continue to try. I know that everybody will tell you the stories of I went on the hike to rock wherever and I saw five dog poop.
1:54:38 Full bags, somebody left on the side of the trail, and they said they were going to, quote, pick them up on the way back, and they didn't. We can't let that deter us, because people are going to do goofy things, and we all know that, but you can't let that say, well, why do it, because it's still, it's this percentage that caused that problem. At the beginning of our conversation, we said we wanted to prioritize these. Now, I know we've gotten them all down, you know, but, you know, can we, can we, you know,
1:55:07 With our group that's here right now, say this is number one and this is number two, or do we not need to do that, John? I'm just... You know, I think we need to, I think we can present this whole list, because I think they are all priorities. Now the town can come back and say, this one's easy, we can do this in two weeks. Access, communications, curb appeal, restrooms, housing, those are our priorities. And I think that's fine. But do they have to be prioritized in themselves?
1:55:35 I don't know. I think that this just lets the town know, because I mean, we're in agreement with, I would say, 90% of what we have on that board is part of the council priorities. I just don't know, you know, the Wi-Fi and cell service, is that more important because it's a safety issue? Is it more parking? And, you know, that I guess is the question. Of those two, I would say cell service is probably a priority, primarily because it is a safety issue. Wi-Fi is...
1:56:04 So one of the things we've been very careful of as a council over the last several years, and I can't speak for how this year is going to go because it's a completely different council. When we put out our priority list, there is a list of things. Usually there's four or five main topics and then four or five things under each topic. If you haven't seen it, you can. There it is right there.
1:56:31 It looks like. That's in the docket package. That's in the docket. That's exactly right. However, in the past, and again, I can't speak for this year, we have been very careful not to call out anything in terms of priority. These aren't priorities. This is a work plan for the next 12 to 18 months. Keep it short. Keep it simple. What most people don't understand, I think, is that 90% of the town's budget,
1:57:02 is already consumed by what we have to do on a daily basis. There is not a lot of, you know, we can't put millions of dollars into new programs because we have to maintain streets, we have to have police, we have to have snow removal, we have to have, you know, the list goes on and on and on. And people need that as an understanding. That's why partnerships have to be formed in order to make these things move forward. But I would encourage us.
1:57:30 Put this together the same way as that sheet is put together. We have four or five things here with a few bullets under each, and don't call them as this is our top priority. We all know that housing is huge, but it can't be the only thing we work on. We have to be able to walk and chew gum at the same time, although I'm losing that ability. That's just an important thing, that there are things that need to be worked on.
1:57:59 Bill, my one comment, and I know this is the dead horse that I kick every year, is if there are things that need to be done, I personally love to get a tax return at the end of the year and then be able to buy something with it, but if I know that I'm getting money throughout the year, I should use that money to buy the things that I needed instead of waiting until April. A $16 million budget going to an $18 million budget gives you a lot of room to accomplish a lot of these without putting you at risk of being
1:58:29 in the hole at the end of the year. I think that not hiring staff, but doing one-time projects or signing up for annual maintenance on things is, I think you have that ability. I think we've proven that we have that ability. You know, we've been at $18 million for four years now and well over that in some. And so I think that's, I'm not going to, again, I'm not going to belabor it, but I think that we have an opportunity to budget for these things because they need to happen. I think that
1:58:59 Even if you do come at the end of the year and say, okay, we've got $10, $12 million over budget this year, what can get ticked off this list that enhances the experience for the resident and the visitor so that we're not, you know, I understand that potholes, filling potholes enhances the experience for all of us, but how do we fix some of these challenges that come from visitation with the money that comes from visitation that helps the resident? Which is exactly how the monies have been spent. If you go and look at the...
1:59:27 What people love to call the excess TOT every year. None of it has been just thrown into stupid things. I get to vote on it, so I can tell you they're not stupid. However, they have gone to very important things. They've gone to housing. They've gone to trailheads. They've gone to the Office of Outdoor Recreation. We've expanded the town budget to bring some of these things in. And that is how they are used. But I think the format, by not...
1:59:55 By saying we know that unless something major happens, we're going to have a surplus. We don't build beyond our capacity. Then we have all of this money for the one-time projects that, you know, the CIP, the trails, the however it goes. I think it has worked beyond my expectations because I'm not smart enough to come up with this stuff. But we see the town after COVID.
2:00:20 Even at the end of this year, we're going to have to pull funds from some of the things we wanted to spend on for everything that we're going to have to take care of. But we have the ability to do that because of how we run the budget. This year will not break us. We won't be digging deep into reserves, where if we go back eight or ten years, we would be. If you think we're in trouble today, imagine what it would have been like under the old budgeting system.
2:00:48 Yeah, I'm happy with how it moves forward. Yes, input on how the money should be spent is critical. Right there. Yeah, I've seen lists like this before. I know, and I guess that's where I go back to it, Bill. Yeah. I think the challenge is that, you know, I remember John Wentworth and I talking in my office seven years ago. We replaced a bunch last year, which...
2:01:12 It was a net zero gain of restrooms, but we had newer restrooms. That's great, but what's the plan to, and I guess that's where I look at when we proposed the management, the destination management plan a few years ago, the idea was we're going to replace two restrooms, or we're going to build two restrooms a year for the next 10 years, and it's going to cost X, Y, Z, and it's going to happen by this date, or we're going to build, you know, this parking lot or that parking lot. It's going to be a five-year process because of the Forest Service. I guess that's the piece that I think that
2:01:38 I would love to see as a community member to say that we are on this path to solve those problems. We've got the housing plan out five years that's going to make a big dent in the problem, but then we're going to have to figure out what the next step is for it. So I think if we can get that to a point where we can say, yeah, these are important, and yes, a new cell tower, an upgrade to 5G, or this is going to happen in September, and this is going to happen here, and this is going to happen there, and we want to do this here, and it's going to take us two years to get a permit to do that there, that gives us that roadmap.
2:02:07 for the next five years, ten years to say these are the things that have to happen in order for us to keep the visitation coming without impacting the quality of life for residents or the quality of life or the quality of experience for the visitor so that we can go out to people and say, hey, listen, we heard you. We are building, you know, we're going to be able to build a new restroom on Old Mammoth Road this year and we're going to put one on Main Street next year so that people can say, oh, okay, cool. So at least we have that.
2:02:33 That something to look forward to piece that people can say, okay, here's the plan. And then people can also come back and hold you to the fire and say, hey, you said you were going to build a restroom on Main Street. Where is it? And you can say, we didn't do it because of X, Y, and Z. Or you can say, well, it got delayed because of this, but at least we have a roadmap. And this is one of my political problems that I deal with that I have. If we put anything down, here's what we would like to do. And everybody believes that that's in stone. Good.
2:03:00 It's not good because you have to deviate sometimes. I mean, I've heard you say this before, but what's wrong with that? That it's a priority for you and therefore it's an expectation of me that that's a priority for me too? Over a five-year period of time, what the needs are changes and they change drastically up here because of years like this, because of legislation coming in, because of what we can do and can't do with housing.
2:03:30 To say that we're going to have a white bike ride, and this is what we're going to do, and then all of a sudden another need arises that is more critical, if you pull from that, now you've got a large percentage. Isn't that a little bit of the, you know, the best laid plans never withstand the pinprick of reality on the battlefield, right? Right. But, you know, wouldn't in year two then say, whoops, something happened, we're going to have to push it out in another year, but I just, I struggle with the fact that
2:04:01 We aren't holding ourselves accountable to what we think is important today. But I think if you read this, you will find that we are. But I don't see dates or times on these things. I mean, I think that I'll use the example again of talking about, you know, Wentworth before he was, I think it was before he was even a council member, talking in my office about the fact that we need restrooms in the Lakes Basin. There are no new restrooms in the Lakes Basin. There are new restrooms, but not additional restrooms. And I think that's what I'm asking is because seven years ago we talked about restrooms.
2:04:30 We've done, I guess it's good that we've replaced failing ones, but we haven't added any to mitigate the additional people or need or whatever. And so I appreciate, but if we have something that says in every two years we're going to put in four restrooms, make it realistic, make it something that's not. And again, I have no idea whether a restroom is $100,000 or a million dollars. I have no idea what it's going to cost to do that stuff or what the red tape is with the Forest Service, but the town does.
2:04:57 You know, Hayes could probably tell me that the forest service is going to tell us it's a two-year this and a five-year that and a four-year this and a six-year that. You know, I guess that's where I'm just looking at it saying, even if it's tentative schedules, to John's point, that you come up and all of a sudden after a year like this, you've got to fix every bus shelter that we own because they all got trashed. Okay, people probably will understand that, but I think if we don't have the...
2:05:22 It goes back to when we talk about deliverables. If they're not measurable... If I never sign up for anything, I can never be held accountable. I mean, that's the flip side of it. I know that's not what you're saying, but on the back side of that, I mean, let's just take self-service for a second. If that process, if that's a safety concern, because people in a certain part of town, then to me, that would be a priority that says in the next three to five years, we want to make sure that we have...
2:05:50 You know, cell service available in 99% of the town on a consistent, reliable basis. I mean, I don't think anybody's going to pillory anybody if it's, you know, three years and two months or four years, but at least we're addressing a critical safety issue as opposed to, well, we don't really want to commit to any of those because then people are going to expect we do them. Well, then what do you do? I mean, what do we do? So we are doing the things you're talking about for cell service and everything else as much as a government entity can.
2:06:20 We get no credit for it, whether we put it on a list or not, but it is being done on a regular basis. We've gone together with Truckee to go to the state saying that this provider isn't doing what he's supposed to be doing. They are being dealt with, whether they are on that specific list in a specific way or not. And again, for me...
2:06:44 In the 30 whatever it is years that Mammoth has been in existence as an incorporated town, this is the best it's ever functioned. So I'm reticent to change that and go back to something that more closely resembles how business used to be done. Because they did used to make five-year lists that weren't followed. Well, we still have a five-year CIP, we just don't. We do. But I think that the... We just don't show the specific funding for it and it's variable.
2:07:13 Well, and the variable funding, but I think it's more of a timeline within the five years because, again, the bathrooms have been talked about for seven years and, you know, I just, I think that that's what I would like to see because we have everyone, not everyone, there's a large group of people that complain about the amount of visitors that come here and the impacts by them. We need to mitigate those impacts or we're going to lose those visitors and we're going to lose the money that comes with them.
2:07:37 And I think that housing is number one because if you can't get a meal and you can't get a table, then you're not going to come back. But we need to look at the money that comes in, all that, you know, you talked about the commitment of the budget. The $10 million over budget last year should be used to solve the problems that are being caused by visitation, which are causing issues for the residents. And so we can continue that money coming in versus the option of, well, let's stop inviting people.
2:08:06 That's my take on it, is that if we have a problem that we can solve, whether it's transit or restrooms or trash or parking or whatever it is, if we can solve that problem with the money that comes in and be able to maintain that money coming in, Mayor Wentworth is very clear about saying we live on tourism. The money that comes in allows us to build the parcel, it allows us to build the CRC, it allows us to do all these other pieces. So that's, I guess, the piece that I'm looking at. The only thing I would push back on.
2:08:34 that comment, John, is that I think that the percentage of people who
2:08:38 Plain that there are too many tourists here is smaller and that we spend a lot of time catering to that group. And that is a huge source of frustration for me personally because there are a certain number of people that, like Tom Dempsey told me back in the day, if you go out and stand in the corner with $100 bills, someone's going to complain, why are you giving out $100 bills? So I always want to be careful about that because everyone has a different interest in this town. And some people that are in this town have an interest.
2:09:08 because they don't feel it benefits them for it to be busier. But the vast majority of our workforce, if you say, would you rather have a smaller paycheck, I don't think that they're going to say yes. I'd rather hear that we don't need tourists from people whose life depends upon tourism than the person who has been here for 35 years and just likes it the old way when it was just a ski bum town. You know, before IntraWest came in, and I've heard that story so many times, you know,
2:09:37 Dave ruined the mountain. He, you know, it's from a half a dozen people. They sold the Interwest and then Starwood bought them and now look at, you know, the whole place has gone to hell. I just wanted to live here and be by myself and ski. Well, you need to move. That's why it's in June Mountain down. That's why it's there, right? I mean, am I wrong? I have little time for that. The problem with that attitude is the place they remember never existed.
2:10:03 I know. From 64 when tourism took off. High school athletics. Yeah. A lot better than what I remember. Not to get too broad about it, but you have to realize also, also realize that 35 years ago there were probably five and a half billion people on this planet and now we have eight.
2:10:26 That's a reality, and there are more people that are, 2 billion are coming here, people that want to go and do things and so forth, so the fact that it's not the same way that it was 35 years ago, no, it's not, anywhere, you know, and.
2:10:39 That's life. I mean, if you want to crawl in a hole and say, you know, yay, okay, well, that's great, but I'm sorry, it's not like that. So we're all adjusting to that. And, you know, again, it's, I mean, I know there's some people who obscure me for saying this, but I'm sorry, that's just the reality of the world. So, you know, to say that we shouldn't be adjusting to that reality is just, I mean, that's not what we do here. What we do here is try to make it better for us, for art.
2:11:08 People that live here or our guests that are coming to visit and how do we make all that work well without just putting their head in the sand and saying, I wish it was different. And that's your last point there. So let me retract what I said about the people. You were wrong. But the people that think there are too many people coming here, let's take them off the table. We still need to fix the challenges that come from visitation. Because we know that there's parking. Regardless of any feedback from locals or visitors or second homeowners or business owners or anything else, if we have parking problems, we have parking problems.
2:11:37 Doesn't matter who it's affecting, doesn't matter whose reaction. You asked me in a meeting when I first got on this group about what I would do different. I said just what you've all just said, the population continues to grow. We are one of the last places left where they can interface with this kind of nature. Our responsibility is to enlarge that system to the point that it can meet the needs of the expanding population.
2:12:05 And that is just not a consensus in town anymore. I wish it was. It can be done. But it can be done with partnerships with the Forest Service, which we don't have. If we can't get permission for a snow pit without a congressman calling in and other things going on, if we can't get that permission, how do we build four new bathrooms in the lakes basin in a year? Because they don't want them there. But I think the part of it is you have to talk to the Forest Service on terms that they understand, and it's degradation of the forest.
2:12:32 You know, if you don't build these facilities, people are just going to go wherever they want to go, and it's going to ruin the environment. So I think, and again, it goes back to the idea that we're talking about cell towers are not because we can't make a phone call. It's because you can't make a phone call when you need to have an emergency. And you know what, John? We miss 100% of the pitches we never swing at. And so, you know, as long as we take that attitude, it's never going to happen. And so, you know, swing at 100 and hit one, we're one better than we were before.
2:13:01 So I guess what I would ask is, if we don't fully prioritize this, that we present this as the headers and some of the subs for the council to consider. I have one question about this list that occurred to me during this conversation. I know we want to wrap it up and get out of here, but one thing we don't have up there is industrial and commercial space. And that's becoming tight. You know, does that have an impact on what all is going on here?
2:13:30 in town, you know, at the industrial park, it's right at the front of town there across from the water district, it's kind of removed from town, you know, but, you know, I was calling Pat the other day, I was like, you know, can I get commercial space down at the airport? They don't offer commercial space down at the airport, you know, the Sierra Center is booked up, everything over here is booked up. Is that a concern from, you know, is that something that we want to consider adding to this list?
2:13:58 I think it's a concern because I think if we don't have homes for the trades that fix everything that breaks, we're in trouble. I think it kind of falls under we need more restaurants. I'm not sure that we can influence more restaurants. And I don't know what we or the town can do unless they can, again, get the Forest Service to commit a piece of land that they probably are never going to ever commit. Yeah, I don't know. It's a good question.
2:14:28 Just wondering if that's kind of a sector that we need to be aware of, you know, because kind of our current industrial park is having a hard time keeping up with the expansion of the town. You know, perhaps something that belongs on the list is just that, land acquisition. How do we bring on the things we need, including housing, if we can't get ownership to some land to put it on?
2:14:59 So the only way to build another industrial park or to increase it is to find property to put it on. The only property available is U.S. government property. So how do we affect those land trades? Is it the, there's a name for it, the Town Act? Yeah, it is the Town Act, 1957. Yeah, so are there things we can do?
2:15:26 And can we afford to go down those roads? I think that's an important question. And is the citizenry wanting us to go down those questions? The map is changing. And to Bill's point, so the Town Act of 1957 allows a town, a municipality, to buy land directly from the local forest rangers at market value. So it allows the local district to actually make a deal versus having to go to D.C. and deal with all that. Because we talked about it with the former snow pit.
2:15:52 We had talked about, well, we had talked about that so that the town could buy the snow pit and have the, and the biggest concern from the district ranger at that point was the helicopters were there in the summertime. We liked having the helicopters close when there was discussion at the airport building a whole new heliport. And that was, again, another piece of the Townside Act was to take over some land down at the airport to build a heliport to move it out of here, you know, and kind of, it was a big chess match, but it would have worked fine. But there was just no interest from the local district to make that.
2:16:22 That deal. And even when I talked to the new district ranger about the snow pit as an event site, there was no interest in talking about it. So I think that it's just, it's an uphill battle. But again, I think if we focus on environmental impacts and we focus on safety, you know, there's got to be somebody out there that's going to listen along the way. This has been a really exciting discussion. Thank you for making the time today, especially with the current conditions outside. But, you know, I like when we have this opportunity to kind of speak openly.
2:16:54 and just get ideas out, you know, and have kind of more, you know, loose conversation. Yeah, so I think this was really beneficial. I'm looking forward to seeing you kind of organize all of our discussion there, John, and so that's being presented tomorrow. Is it on council? It could be. I hadn't planned on it, but tomorrow is like our first.
2:17:25 meeting to start hashing out what the priorities are. Okay. I would have to look it up in my calendar when the next one is going to be. Okay. But that may be the one to bring it forward in. I don't know. If nothing else, I'll show up and talk public comment that we have a list for the council. Okay. And let them know that we'll get it. I don't want to rush it into tomorrow's conversation. Thankfully, a lot of it's already in the board packet for conversation, but I think that if we can...
2:17:49 I can at least show up for public comment, let them know that we have this meeting. Hopefully a few of them have watched and we can say that we'll have a complete list for them. And it is a new council. Yep. So paying attention to this meeting and then meeting with your council representatives, you all get to see me once a month, but there are four others that need input and conversation so you understand where they're coming from as well. And there needs to be a real focus, not only from this board, but back from council, that this is a partnership.
2:18:20 This is a symbiotic partnership. This is not a parasitic relationship. We are not just feeding off of the revenue from the town. We are the marketing agency for the town. We feel that these are the things that we need to feel are being addressed in order for us to continue to be successful because the town recognizes where the money comes from, and we recognize what our job is and how it can affect the guest experience and, most importantly, the resident quality of life. Which is one other comment I'll make.
2:18:52 One of the comments I got back is why the council is not more supportive of what MLT does. The comment was that sometimes they are, sometimes they are, but not everybody's on board. They don't, you know, there's this sort of schizophrenia about we love you, we hate you. Well, we don't know what they do. We, you know, yes, we do support this. We don't support that. If that's the, if that's...
2:19:22 A broader feeling than just one person, I suspect it has to be, then we have a bigger problem. And so maybe you can help it. Well, you know, it is, but to the degree that we're trying to be joint priorities, and, you know, we talk about partnership, and we can only get this done with partnership and everything else, but I really hate these people, you know, or I don't trust them, or whatever it is. That's a problem.
2:19:50 Well, I think even little things, and I know this wasn't meant maliciously, but in the board packet talking about economic development, it goes down through and it talks about the TBID, it says marketing and air subsidy, and then in parentheses it says regional issue. It's a regional opportunity, it's not an issue. It could be challenging, but it's not an issue. It's an opportunity, and I just want to get our vernacular going towards partnership, going towards working together, going towards, we all have the same goal here.
2:20:18 is to make this place successful. We will live up to whatever we say. I would hope we do. No, I would say that we all do. I don't know that, I would not say that all the constituents within Mammoth Lakes have that same. Well, but I think, I think if that, if we're talking about towards the positive, not worry about the small group. We can all agree that that's something we want.
2:20:40 I don't think anybody's going to say that we can't. Whether there are people in town that don't want to see another business grow or another visitor come, yeah, there are always going to be those people. Close the door behind me, I'm here. But, you know, to your point, I've never heard a business owner complain about overture. I've never heard anybody say, my God, we're too busy, stop. In fact, the people are too busy. They're not paying bills. But you're dealing with the political reality. Yep.
2:21:10 You know, I have had a story that I tell people for years when they complain about tourism and over-tourism. If you don't want to live in a tourism town, how about moving to Markleyville? Because it's the same elevation, it gets the same kind of snow, it is spectacularly beautiful, but it is not a tourist town, you won't have to deal with this. But the tourists supply Vons, the ghost store, the Rite Aid, the hospital, without them we have none of those things that are the reason you moved here.
2:21:39 And the trails. All my employees are saying, where is everybody? You know, and I'm like explaining, guys, it's kind of tough to get people in town right now. They're like, when's it going to be busy? When's it going to be busy? And I'm like, yeah, me too. That's why I'm, you know, hashtag keep canyon open. You know? So, again, thank you for that. I do want a roll call vote to move forward with this list for council. So if we can make a motion in a second and I'm roll calling. I make a motion. I'll second it.
2:22:10 You have the motion. You have it here, Angie. Motion to approve. Motion to approve. The list of infrastructure opportunities. Sure. What Eric said. You have the first from me, the second from John, and if you can. John Mendel. Chair Goico. Yes. Vice Chair Foster. Yes. Treasurer Morris. Yes. Secretary Mendel. Yes.
2:22:46 Board Member Clark. Yes. Board Member Souser. Yes. And Board Member Magner. Yes. Thank you. Thanks, Darlene. Thank you, Darlene. Have the best day ever. Thank you. I did that when I came in the room. Thank you, everybody. Eric, the only other question I had for you, Eric, was can you, would you be willing.