Mammoth Lakes Recreation · 2022
Mammoth Lakes Recreation
at 16:30
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Minutes ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
301 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:45 Share it. Hello. All right. Welcome, everyone. I'd like to call this meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Recreation Board this Tuesday, November 1st. And what have we got? About 4.36 p.m. Call to order. Angie, could you have roll call of the MLR board, please? President Albright? Here. Board Member Schaubmeyer? Here. Board Member Bankson? Here via Zoom.
1:45 Board Member Fernie. Here. Board Member Wasserman. Board Member Ray. Thank you. All right. Thanks, Angie. Our first item of business, as we've been doing here for quite some time, is we need to approve, adopt the resolution for being able to meet via Zoom. That's Assembly Bill 361. And so do I have a motion to adopt a resolution to allow us
2:18 The Mammoth Lakes Recreation Board of Directors to meet virtually during COVID-19 pandemic declared emergency and beyond. I'll make a motion. I'll second. Moved by Schaubmeyer, seconded by Fernie, and Angie, can we have a roll call, please? President Albright? Yes. Treasurer Schaubmeyer? Here. Secretary Bankson? Yes. Board Member Fernie? Yes. Thank you.
2:51 Awesome. Order of business done. It's also on our agenda here. We also have the time in our meeting where we open up to public comment, particularly things that may not be on the MLR Board's agenda today. Angie, do we have anybody online or emailed in public comments? No public comments at this time. None at this time? We do have Mr. Lawson. Mr. Reef.
3:22 All right, hello, Lawson Reef, Office of Outdoor Recreation, Town of Mammoth Lakes. I have a few things I would like to alert you of, but first and foremost, I would like to introduce our new Outdoor Recreation Coordinator, Gretchen Hasselbauer. She has been in Mammoth for three years, previously worked for Mammoth Lakes Trails and Public Access, and loves to do all things outside.
3:50 Just wanted to introduce Gretchen. She'll be an awesome addition to our team. So just wanted to introduce you all. And then just a couple things for the good of the group.
4:06 Public comment is open currently for the ESCCRP or the Mammoth Donut. Obviously, very important timber project that is going on here adjacent immediately around the town of Mammoth Lakes. So that project is open for public comment as part of the NEPA process with the forest. As a matter of fact, in partnership with the Whitebark Institute, the INYO will be hosting two meetings.
4:31 One is actually tomorrow virtually on Zoom, and then the other one is Thursday, November 3rd from 6 to 8 p.m. in person at the Mono Community Center, Mono County Community Center. So if anybody is interested in going to that and providing public comment for this very important project, please do. With the snow, want you all to be aware as well, Lakes Basin closed today. Don't know if it's going to reopen.
4:56 But again, just wanted you to be aware as a result of all this as well, fire restrictions have been lifted and wood season actually has been extended to November 30th. And last but not least, as it relates to the donut again, there are a couple parcels within the town of Mammoth Lakes I wanted to alert you all about that the timber harvest plan is ready to be submitted to CAL FIRE for that project, which is the next step in getting that work done in bell-shaped parcel and Mammoth Creek.
5:26 Any questions? Thank you. Thanks. Thanks, Lawson. You bet. I don't have the booming voice like Lawson. So what I want to do is just update you on recent developments with the agreements that we signed yesterday with the LA Kings. Craig was very responsive and had it signed immediately. Thank you, Craig.
6:10 And I'll just kind of walk you through what it means and kind of what we're launching. If I go to full screen mode. Here we go. So what are we talking about? So this is obviously tied in with our Community Recreation Center. We all know a little bit about the CRC. We know it's going to operate. I know we know. I don't know if the public really knows. But we collectively will be running an Olympic-sized ice rink from typically October through April. And then we flip the building.
6:43 to turn it into kind of a three-court gymnasium, you know, multi-use rec zone. Really, and it kind of meets our mission to kind of deliver all recreation all the time, and as we all know, we'll be a game-changer for recreation in Mammoth Lakes. These were the goals that Parks and Recreation Commission put forward probably about three, four years ago, why we are developing a community recreation centre.
7:08 You can see there's quality of life, multi-purpose, year-round, indoor, which is kind of what we talked about today. Social interaction, place to stay, this recreation destination concept. And really kind of focusing on this enhanced and innovative programming. That's really kind of what we're trying to bring to the community. Partnership goals, why are we partnering with the LA Kings? Really want to ensure the long-term success of the CRC by partnering with the best of the best.
7:36 who share kind of our love of ice sports and commitment for success, deliver on the expectations of the community, council, commission, yourselves, for the building, and really looking at, you know, a franchise that can bring, you know, enormous influence and brand familiarity to Mammoth Lakes. This third one's really important. This is actually the consultant experience. So this is kind of partnering with the consultant that has that professional expertise, technical knowledge, and capabilities to really maximize operational programming efficiency.
8:06 And then to leverage the power and influence of, you know, the LA Kings. Who are the LA Kings? I think this is just that slide. Everybody's familiar with it right now. They're in the West Division. I think they're sitting about fourth, Colin. Kind of a so-so start. It's okay, I got you, buddy. Colin features at the end of this presentation, by the way, everybody. But pretty big organization, right? Part of the AAG group.
8:38 Eighth most valuable team in the NHL, current value of a billion, right? They play at crypto, 18,000 people there every game. A couple of, you know, normal guys here, Luke Robitaille, Wayne Gretzky. Bailey's been here, Bailey comes up again for a lot of watch parties at the mountains, been at our rink too, so it's pretty cool. Just under a million Facebook followers and some pretty big sponsors, so it's a good group. The partnership is comprised of three components.
9:06 I'll kind of walk through these in more detail in subsequent slides, but one is a corporate sponsorship agreement, the second is a facility branding and use agreement, and the third is a consultant agreement. So that's kind of comprising the partnership. So the first one is the Mammoth Lakes Tourism sponsorship agreement. It's a three-year deal. Mammoth Lakes Tourism receives certain sponsorship benefits. Right there is the big jumbotron.
9:30 And last night, last couple of games, if you've seen, Mammoth was kind of on center ice. They projected down on the ice. It was pretty cool. But this includes those elements there that you can see. They're an official partner of the LA Kings, and the value of that sponsorship is $100,000 a year over a three-year deal. LA Kings Facility Branding and Use Agreement. So the second part of this is the same. It's a three-year deal. As part of that, the Kings receive branding of just the ice rink.
10:00 So this is not a naming of the Community Recreation Center, this is an ice rink within the CIC. So that has just different values. So they are just the ice rink. So it's now the LA Kings Ice at Mammoth Lakes. So that's kind of that second bullet. Term of the agreement starts on March 1st, kind of when we are triggering the opening of the building, of the rink itself. And they donate $75,000 each year to Mammoth Lakes Recreation. The town then works with our wonderful partners.
10:30 We invoice MLR for those funds and then it becomes part of the operating budget at the Community Recreation Centre. The King's really wanted to work with a non-profit organisation so we applauded that. They also received just this Centre Ice logo. This is kind of under the ice. So that's the King's logo, King's mark on Centre Ice. And that's really it. So they just have some name recognition on the building. They have Centre Ice.
10:59 And then there's a whole host of other benefits that we'll talk about, but from a signage point of view, that's really kind of all that we're looking at. So you can see here they receive 20% off just ice time, so pretty nominal, and they'll use all their efforts to kind of help program the facility. Just talking about what that means, what does that partnership mean? Well, we get kind of connected with their hockey development program just for one.
11:27 I mean, element here, so a lot of learn-to-play programs, camps and clinics. They'll be up here on January 27th for a three-day development camp already. ICE and adult hockey leagues, skills and drills camps, you know, all of this type of stuff that talks about programming, that comes with this partnership, so that's kind of why it's so powerful. And this just gives you a representation of kind of those programs that they run. High school leagues, Little Kings programs, the LA Lions is the women's.
11:57 Hockey team, adult workshop, hockey development, King's Camp. So a lot of stuff that we talk about programming we're able to bring to the facility. The third component is the consulting agreement. So this is actually with American Sports Entertainment Company. Talk about more of them in the next slide. But that's really to provide technical operational consulting services. It's the same three-year term. It's actually started today. Well, actually, I think it started about seven years ago with Brad.
12:26 But that's okay. They've been phenomenal partners with us all the way in the development of the CIC. And you can see they have three phases of support. That's now, construction program development, the first partial year, and then the second and third year. For this, the town pays $50,000 each year. So what does that mean? If you're doing the math in the head, that means the town nets $25,000 of annual operating funds.
12:55 Just a little bit here, just some highlights of what are those deliverables, what is really this group going to do for the town and why do we need them? Well, they can bring a lot of expertise, capabilities, guest service plans, standards, help us with financial projections, recruitment and training of staff. For instance, at the outdoor ice rink, we've never actually put lines on the ice, right? So we've never done that. So again...
13:21 This is what this group can do for us. Logos on ice, we haven't done that. We haven't run an indoor facility. We've run an outdoor hobby, shoveling kind of practice, training. That's all we've really done over there. So a three-month rink is different to a six-month indoor ice arena, right? So we need to partner with the best of the best. It also includes programming, and particularly, you see here, LA Kings, but also LA Galaxy-branded programs, if you've been out in Torrance.
13:51 This group runs that facility down there. Colin and I were down there on the team. I mean, that's an amazing facility, right? That's got futsal courts, volleyball courts, table tennis table. They've got everything down there. So again, not just winter, really for kind of year-round programming, customer service contracts and agreements, but really just helping us kind of deliver the best of the best that we can for our facility.
14:15 It's great, they run basically the largest, they're the largest independent owner-operator of ice rink facilities in the United States, right? So, I mean, they're it, they're the player, they're it. These are some of the rinks in Southern California. Pickwick Ice, if you've been down there near Burbank, they do a lot of films around there. They also run a 24-lane bowling alley down there, pretty cool. Big conference center, Toyota Sports Center, that's big in El Segundo, that's where the Kings train.
14:45 If you've been to the Cube, I haven't been there yet, but that's actually owned by the town. And then ASEC are the management partners on that, so similar to kind of what we do. ISA Promenade in Pennsylvania, sorry, Pacific Palisades there, and Peninsula, and then the UCLA Health Training Centre, which is the home of the Lakers. So they're up there. So why are we doing this? This is kind of just that wrap-up slide. Working with tourism, MLR, leverage funding, partnering with the Kings.
15:17 Bringing that professional branded programming, working with the largest independent owner operator, really to ensure the future success of the kind of CRC. So that's why we're doing it. Had to pop this up there, Colin. This was kind of our first meeting back in March 17th. Doesn't seem that long ago. So if you all recognise Rich. Rich was the Executive Director at the time of MLR. Dan Holler, Luke Robitaille, Colin, myself, and then I think that's Brad. Can't remember his name.
15:47 He was the GM at Toyota Sports Centre. So we've been at this for a long time, so it's just great to see this finally come to fruition. And that's kind of a little rendering of kind of the signage that's going to be on the exterior of the building, just a little sign, LA Kings Ice, Mammoth Lakes. With that, I just want to provide that on a brief public comment. But it kind of just does set the tone of kind of what we've been working on, of the commission and the town.
16:14 In general, Hayes gave the commission an update today. We're still looking at around mid to late February commissioning for the CRC. So our goal is to get ice as soon as we can and operate ice for as long as we can, hopefully through the end of April. We'll flip it and get into summer programming and so forth. So that's kind of our schedule. Thank you for my public comment. Yes. NHL. Well, they wanted an NHL ring. They were pretty clear about that, right? Yeah. That's their preferred. That's what they practice and train on.
17:08 But they see this as just growing and supporting, you know, ice sports in general. I mean, it'll grow hockey, it'll grow figure skating, you know, skating. I mean, it's just ice sports in general, and that's kind of what that brand's about. And they really want to be in Mammoth. I mean, right from the start, you know, they partner with Mammoth Resorts, they partner with Mammoth Lakes Tourism, they really see this as a great place, you know? Exactly right. Right? So, they...
17:36 It didn't, yeah, they said, great, Olympic, that makes sense, you want to turn this into a rec zone, it's more than just an ice rink, great. I think that's the most changed any conversation. A lot of people are like, well, why do you need more is better, it's not always better, but it is in our circumstance because we cannot fit all of the sports courts on an important aspect of it. Yep.
18:08 Festivals and events. You're exactly right. Dan and I go way back with soccer and stuff. I mean, that's something that a lot of soccer players are familiar to. You go to different, you know, fields and they're all different within certain parameters. Some are wider, some under, et cetera. And, you know, certain things couldn't be done, though. So, like, if, you know, as Stu mentioned, it's ideal for NHL training, but it doesn't preclude.
20:22 From summer to winter? Uh-huh. Okay. That's what I was wondering. Is it something that you could do? Well, you know what's interesting? It's a great question. Dakota and tourism brought that up too, right, with us. You know, can you cover the ice? Absolutely. You know, looked at the mats. I've got an estimate. It's probably about $150,000 to get some surfacing. So in the middle of winter, you could actually lay that out, much like they do at Staples. Yeah, they do it every night at Staples. Right? Come on. We got their money. Okay, fine.
20:51 But there's that opportunity, right? So if we wanted to, you know, look at some of those opportunities, yes, it can totally be done. Totally, you know, turns that facility into something, you know, far different. So just to follow up from this is the launch, the ribbon cutting, all of that, right? So, you know, we're going to be looking at kind of launching some outbound messaging. Bailey's up here, we've got development camps, they'll be here. And then Luke does assure me that he'll be here for ribbon cutting, so we'll see.
21:23 But there'll be, that's a lot of stuff. I mean, this is kind of. So we wanted to, yeah, get, we wanted to separate those two to have, yeah, I know we're dragging on, but we wanted to separate the two. We talked about having that first ice event, but we're just way behind that now. So I think what we'll do is double back and create kind of that next ice event, perhaps, after we kind of celebrate the opening and do the ribbon cutting and get going. But still all planned and it's all rolling out, just kind of different timelines. But I just wanted to bring that to everybody's attention.
21:59 It's going to be good. Congratulations. Yeah, thank you, everybody. Thank you. A lot of work for many in this room for going and going. Six and a half years. That's good. Angie, any other further public comment? No comment. Sorry, my mic was off. Pardon me. We'll move on to our joint workshop with the Parks and Recreation Commission. And just to review our...
22:32 Annual work plans, engagement, roles and responsibilities, and Kim, did you want to kind of start us off? I sense that you have a plan. Always, always, always. If I could interject, we've got a whole bunch of new commissioners, and maybe we should do some introductions. Do some introductions first, and I think that was kind of first on our agenda. I didn't have your agenda.
23:03 I apologize. Well, that's fine. Yeah, so let's start off with some introductions and review of the agenda. Yeah, introductions, and I know Stu wanted to go over the revision of Chapter 2.4. We'll kind of talk about the Parks and Recreation Commission annual work plan, some community programming stuff, talk about a little MLR, and then some discussion. I'm Stuart, Parks and Recreation Director.
23:35 And to my right is our new Vice Chair. Silver Chesick. My name is Scott Reef. In fact, that is my son. I don't know where that works, but that's it. Ben Wisner, new to the Commission. Sorry? From the Mountain. I am Director of the Free Ski and Snowboard Teams at the Mountain as well. And Dan O'Connell, the new Chair of the Red Commission. Heather Schotmeyer, a fan of that.
24:41 I'm still here. I'm Craig Albright. I'm the president of MLR and have been involved. Great to work with you guys. Colin Fernie. I've been on and off with MLR like a decade maybe, but I think this most... Hello, I'm Tamara Bankson by Zoom. Sorry, I can't be there in person. I have a sick kiddo at home. But I am the secretary for MLR and I've been, I think this is year three, Kim, if I'm correct. I can't keep track.
25:26 I'm three years, and I'm on the allocations committee with Heather, and I am the Executive Director of Mammoth Mountain Community Foundation. Just want to make sure you guys have one for this meeting. And I think I've met most of you by now, but Kim Manaclario, MLR Program Director, aka solo employee. Standing solo employee. But you want to be busy.
26:12 You want to be busy. Office of Outdoor Recreation here for the town of Mammoth Lakes. So what I would thought to do is, now that we're introductions out of the way, is that I know when I introduced this to my commission, because they're all so new, it's just a great outline of the powers and duties of the commission, i.e. their roles and responsibilities.
26:56 What they're really charged to do as the appointed advisory body to Council. So I've included just as a little handout here with you. It's called Chapter 2.40. If you didn't get one, I'm going to pull it up on screen. But I did want to just hit the highlights of it because it was recently amended by Council in April. And I'm not too sure if Mammoth Lakes Recreation have seen this in any great detail either. But it's just a good way to kind of kick off what we do.
27:26 And I'll kind of talk a little bit about, you know, some other outcomes after this meeting. But essentially, we've added and we revised the powers and duties, which is 2.40. And we added professional development reimbursement. But let me just hit the highlights here. You can see, you know, it's created. Composition. I think it's all pretty straightforward. Vacancies.
27:53 I'm going to just scroll down here to powers and duties because this is where really what the commission does. So I think it was a good kind of starting point for discussion amongst the commission and the board here for us to articulate what we do, right? I know certain board members have seen this. I know Heather, you've probably seen this. Craig, I think I've given it to you. Colin, I know you probably were part of this on council.
28:19 But it's essentially kind of outlines, you know, as an advisory body, what is the capacity. The commission establishes a schedule of regular meetings, makes recommendations to the department director on funding priorities related to the departmental budget, assist town staff in the advancement, coordination, delivery of community services and activities, right, as that liaison between the community and council, provide recommendations to council regarding rules, regulations, policies.
28:49 of our facilities. Reviews surveys provided by the department for recreation users. Reviews town's capital improvement program, which we just did today. I believe, have you guys, sorry, seen the town's CIP? Is that something that we want to kind of schedule or? Probably not. Yeah, I haven't seen it.
29:17 I think it's been about a year. Okay, so it's kind of an annual process, so that could be something we could do kind of jointly together. That sounds like a good idea. Hayes just did it, and it makes a lot of sense if we kind of see it together. That would be really helpful. And then we also just discussed today kind of our first go-around with our deferred maintenance program project, and we'll be doing that again. So, again, just really the purpose of this conversation to kind of just get these kind of topics front and centre.
29:46 Upon Town Council Direction, provide input recommendations for public hearings related to land acquisition, facility design, i.e. the CRC, that's why the commission was so involved there, and also kind of arts and recreation and cultural purposes as well. Provide input to town staff and or contracted professionals to assist in the design of facilities. And then this one here, so this was Jay, right, so if you remember the Parks and Recreation Commission or the Recreation Commission at the time,
30:17 was the advisory body for Measure R, Measure U funding, right? So this has been the biggest change, even though Mammoth Lakes Recreation has been performing that duty for several years, we've just revised it. So now hopefully it makes more sense and is more accurate to the function of the commission, and that's really to inform, provide funding recommendations to MLR or any other body or entity designated by Town Council for the use of Measure R, Measure U funds for town-owned or managed parks, recreation, arts and culture.
30:47 Prescribed by ordinance by town council action. So really, that's kind of why, you know, one of many reasons to have these two bodies connected. We really want to make sure that the commission understands your process and then what you as Mammoth Lakes Recreation does as you look to, you know, future investments in our facilities and amenities. So that's really the biggest change from the roles and responsibilities. And then we also have included professional development.
31:17 Really just ensuring that our commissioners have the opportunity to participate in professional development, industry kind of networking conferences and so forth. So just, you know, they are able to join CPRS conferences or any kind of educational activities that would feel that would further advance their role here as a commission. I'm just going to stop there and see if there's any questions from the chair, commission, or if there's any questions from MLR on that document.
31:50 Getting Jay aligned with how we've actually operated is always good to get aligned to try to provide clarity to, you know, and when I listened in on your guys' last meeting, this meeting was an agenda item. You know, there's, it's like, oh, why do we exist? Why does MLR exist? Which is ourselves many times as well. And in the community, you know,
32:28 With the many MLs out there, you know, there is this confusion, and we've had to work hard over the last few years to really, first and foremost, make sure that was clear with town council that we were on the same page of what our role is and how we can make those recommendations for RNU funding, allocations committee, heading up the trails committee, and what our lane is. And that's,
32:59 You know, had over MLR's history has had some very grandiose plans and a couple different executive directors and, you know, years or so into MLR, I think we finally found our lane a little bit more, but now it's time to, now that we kind of understand it better, it's time for us to town council, work with the Parks and Rec Commission and really engage with the community to help push things forward that, you know.
33:33 Recreation, mobility, arts and culture issues that those two tax initiatives were designed to help us get through. I kind of went through a little history lesson because I go, what did MLR, where was it born out of? And it was born out of a time, such a tumultuous time with the airport lawsuit. We had these great new funding mechanisms that the citizens had approved.
34:08 But not a lot of trust in town government to manage that. And so MLR was born out of that environment to provide more public input and collaboration with the Parks and Rec Commission. So it's only become clear over time what our role is. And I think it's just key that we can work together to
34:42 To further the things that we all have in common about work. It's always been a little unclear to me from the beginning, actually, when it was first being pushed along and then was finally formed. I never really understood at that time. We had a Parks and Recreation Department, recreation providers, mobiles, bowling, and so where was MLR going to fit in? That's always what I was confused about. And then as things moved along, I started understanding some aspects of
35:29 And that has changed. It's evolved. So what is your lane? A good example would be that having a non-profit set aside from the town allows us to do some things that the Red Commission, as viewed as part of the town, might not allow us to do. The King's deal is a great example that we just...
36:02 That they want to work with a local non-profit to do that and that relationship. Another would be, and that we find traction on, is Kim going out and getting grant funding for whether it's Buckeye Hot Springs or the stuff happening in Sherwin, come on Sierra Nevada Conservancy. Those are the opportunities that I think MLR was really one of the things that
36:34 was envisioned where MLR has a unique role to play in those regards. There was also, you know, certainly when I first got on the board, there was a big push that MLR was going to be this big fundraising organization, and I think those grandiose plans ran up against a lot of realities that relatively small town with lots of great programs, whether it's DSES or EMACA or HERP.
37:07 You know, Wild Iris, they're endless, and that we didn't have the fundraising opportunities that, you know, not that we've given up on that, but we've kind of refocused it to more programming, things like to trail, tangle-free water. It's like, okay, we can, let's get hit singles rather than swing for home. Probably the biggest lesson I feel like we've learned over Mammoth's or MLR's history is
37:41 I think we came out swinging for home runs and get on base. You even take a walk, you know, hit by pitch. I think we also have a very passionate community. I'm getting Kim. She's fabulous. And I kind of think you guys should pay Kim on how many feet are on the trails and maybe she too could make a quarter million dollars. I like where you're headed. And truly. Me too.
38:56 Who we've had, you know, at the helm is best. I mean, I think we all knew, and Greg, I shared many of your concerns. See, even on the MLR board, it's like, are we given the citizens good value? And that was really the heart of our struggle with the town is we had to provide them with value for them to get us through, you know, particularly, you know, the tough times of COVID, but that was just
39:30 What was heartening listening to your last meeting is Sandy's public, you know, which was someone
40:47 Who was adamantly against the NGO concept and was certainly a critic of MLR during our early years because of some of those value propositions. And now, you know, now that we've kind of got on track, one of our biggest orders. That's no small thing with Sandy. Having Sandy on your side is no small thing. And Sandy's really concerned about Kim's Health. We actually share that same opinion with somebody else to work with.
41:22 Prove ourselves. I think she was very sincere. I would jump in and say, I think you're selling yourself short because I think the home run to MLR is your Office of Outdoor Recreation. That's not a single. So I do want to say that's really a game changer for MLR. I mean, if you look at, you know, a lane, I mean, that clearly depicts and defines your lane. So I really applaud that evolution. Yeah, I was going to say, Stu, that as I went and, you know, and we talked with this, with the town council a bit, is that
42:02 You know, municipal recreation is kind of one lane, and I think as you guys said, there's certainly some overlap, but then outdoor recreation is a distinctly different lane. 100%. And that there's some overlap between the two for certain, but that's where absolutely the Office of Outdoor Recreation really is what we maybe as an organization needed to give us even more greater focus.
42:31 Of how we can help with, you know, trails, but so much more than just trails. That was a segue for Lawson to jump in and talk a little bit about, because I think that was a miss when, you know, Kim and I chatted after your meeting with council, you know, and I think that was part of that we really wanted to make sure that came, you know, through to the public that the offers of outdoor rec is really that big part of MLR now, right? And I just, anyway, so I just wanted to make sure Lawson had that chance to get to the commission a little bit about
43:03 No, and I definitely echo Stu's comments and the interface with public land, the adjacent public land, town of Mammoth Lakes is an island effectively and what we are here for is to try to interface with adjacent public land to get work done within the town boundary, get work done within the regional area, whether that's trails, things of that nature to enhance the recreation experience for
43:30 Locals and visitors alike. And I think, honestly, too, another home run as it relates to MLR is a lot of the stewardship programs. I think there's been a huge transition in the town of Mammoth Lakes from, hey, everybody come here, this place is awesome, to, oh my God, we're getting trashed a little bit out there. And I think you guys will see, I think Kim's going to have a presentation, but you guys will see some of this stuff that has gone on out there.
43:58 Which is pretty remarkable that an army of one is able to coordinate all of that, get everybody together from operations like clean up the lake to adopt the trail. You guys will hear all about those and the influence they've had on the community. And also the nonprofit NGO, and we'll talk about some of this as well, angle of things as it relates to fundraising versus a municipality. We have hundreds of thousands of dollars in grants, hopefully.
44:27 Hopefully coming our way from the SNC to fund projects like the Sherwin's Trail System, also known as SHARP, to fund the new trailhead that you will hopefully be seeing here very soon out of the Sherwin tanks. And having that kind of NGO interface with groups like the Sierra Nevada Conservancy, I think has been huge. And, you know, just...
44:53 I think the fiduciary responsibility in general that MLR has in a small town like this where a lot of different elected officials touch a lot of different areas of this community, having kind of an independent NGO to help, non-profit NGO to help inform some of that decision-making I think can also keep some of that town leadership out of the mud. Yeah, and I think just to dovetail off of that, you know, working with Stu over a long period of time, Stu's a very capable
45:24 But there were a lot of things thrown at us. And so I think, you know, we're a community, we're a recreation-based economy, we're all recreation all the time. So I think there's a lot of different lanes that can be carved out that allows your group to be kind of streamlined and more narrow. And so I know there were some times over the years where things got taken off of Stu's play, refocus and redirect my efforts to things that are more my wheelhouse. And so I think there's just, you know,
45:55 When we talk about the guest experience, they certainly don't understand municipalities, right? They're up here in the area, and so I think MLR can have a larger purview in terms that we touch in our full region, whereas your organization is a little bit more. You guys are much more focused on programming facilities, whereas our organization experiences that you can. So I think, you know, like I said before, I've been kind of involved in MLR since the inception, and we talk and joke all the time at MLR. We've had a lot of different iterations of the organization.
46:42 I think that's why these conversations are important so that we're not duplicating roles. Yeah, I think that's a really good point too, just MLR's flexibility as it relates to working outside of the town boundary and being able to provide some of that regional support as well. Again, those boundaries are meaningless to a lot of our visitors and help providing that connectivity. I mean, there's some huge programs coming down the pipeline as it relates to recreation, connected community.
47:18 Through communities, through trails, multi-use bike trails, things of that nature, and I think that's another arena in the future, too, where MLR can have a really, really big... Agreed, especially on the working outside the town boundaries, that's huge. Yeah. And I look forward to hopefully me learning more and us being able to work together to help each other in our respective boundaries. And I think, you know, our role started out very grandiose.
47:47 It was very narrowly, you know, kind of shrunk way down based on circumstance. And we still have some aspirational goals like fundraising and those. I think we were broken down to a very basic function. What do we need to survive? Stabilizing the organization. And now we can start to slowly build from that. I think we tried to do too much. Shrunk all the way down and maybe we start to expand. Have you guys figured out what that is? Like, do you have a four-year plan or anything like that? You know, our...
48:38 Our strategic plan, you know, we just finished the last one in 2021. And what we've felt as the board, first of all, as Colin said, you know, we kind of went through, hunkered down and lived to fight another day. But in light of the Office of Outdoor Recreation coming on, we've decided to kind of, let's give it the winter and see what that's really about and how
49:08 How we can really assist that moving forward. And so we're kind of delaying on our strategic plan for our organization until we kind of understand the Office of Outdoor Rec and what they really need from us more so. But certainly the aspirations of finding new experiences and not limiting ourselves to the, we really feel like there's a regional.
49:40 Yeah, I don't know if you guys have seen the work that was done at Buckeye, but pretty awesome work, and I think that just highlights an example, I think, where MLR can fit into the grand scheme of things as it relates to the overlap either with municipal projects or adjacent public land projects.
50:12 And how an organization like MLR can support. I went on the website today. I was looking at a strategic plan. It was. Am I missing something in there? Yeah, it was the 2016 through 2021. So it was a five-year plan. Okay. And so that one has, you know, was the last one we did. We started working on a new one when the wheels were starting to fall off. And we were in the middle of COVID. And so we haven't restarted that. I didn't have a lot of time.
50:49 Yeah, yeah, no problem, but that is the most recent one was adopted in 2016, which was kind of a five-year plan. Stu, just for my own clarity, these are things that you're working on, but not necessarily that are looking to get completed in the next calendar year. So I'm sure there's all kinds of different timelines for each one of these. And they change. What's that? And they change.
52:24 It's very dynamic, which is what we were discussing today. A priority today may be a second priority tomorrow or next summer when we see something that's falling apart. Yeah, quite honestly, too, because we'll have the Office of Outdoor Recreation pretty new. We'll have a similar thing here very soon as well, and I think we will behave very similarly in terms of priorities. Obviously, a lot depends on public lands partners, what we can do, what they're willing to take on.
52:53 In their program of work, along with the variety of those different agencies, you know, whether it's BLM, Forest Service, you know, again, the Buckeye stuff was Humboldt-Toyabe, so all that interface. One example here, in the first one, there. A lot of other people put one in. But again, just a great one. So a lot of these projects that I think, you know, look pretty basic on a level, but to, you know, the point about the priorities and changes and where they are in the timing.
55:31 That's a good list for us to, you know, get our head in. What are you guys doing and how can we collaborate and help within our lane from a fundraising or, you know, public
56:05 Hearing standpoint, I mean, how can we, you know, how can we assist with any of these? You know, moving on to the, you know, the community programming, you know, you have an item here, Stu, that's the new funding timeline, and you talked about it briefly earlier. Yep, and I'm, again, a great collaborative process, and I'm going to actually turn it over to Kim. You've got a really good handle on it. I've talked too much already.
56:38 But again, it's the reason why we're working together and you've been all involved in that process. I just thought it'd be a good opportunity to talk about it. All my commission is aware of now is that we've pushed our youth sports funding to January. We're kind of moving it up. But that's to really coincide with all these other funding opportunities that we've been working with. Yeah, so essentially there's three buckets of community funding. The youth sports funding through the Rec Parks and Rec Commission, Measure U programming funding.
57:10 Through the MLR allocations committee and special events funding through Mammoth Lakes Tourism. So rather than having the applicants have to figure out which bucket they fall into and when that application period is, all of the applications are going to be due in January and that way nobody misses out on a funding opportunity because they applied to the wrong program. That way if I get an application I say no, no, no, this is special events.
57:39 Or you need to go to youth sports. So it's been great. We've been working with Dakota, Stu, myself, the rest of all of our teams. And I think we've really narrowed it down and made it quite simple. There'll be a landing page on the town website that will direct out to everybody's individual funding website. And opens January 4th, I think we decided. So simplified. Always working to simplify. Where's the easy button mark?
58:11 I think the allocations process of Measure R and U is such an incredibly important initiative for this community. And I just want to give kudos to Heather U, Tam.
58:56 The progress that's been made on me, it's a very daunting but also really incredibly important process. We've streamlined it and simplified it. We're putting real... That's been a huge lift for MLR over the last couple of years. That's something that we've been able to kind of carve. And then Kim, yeah. I do have a little presentation.
59:55 I've got some candy. We're all candied out. I think we've talked a lot about a lot of stuff, but we've got some good pictures, show and tell. We'll kind of show you what MLR has been doing. So yeah, we talked, last couple years we've been focusing a lot on putting grant money back into the community.
1:00:25 We're able to make new Eastern Sierra Winter Recreation maps and OSV network kiosks signs out there and a multitude of trail work through the town and county and got some funding for our arts community. This National Endowment for the Arts was a $150,000 grant as part of the American Rescue Plan that is directly for MLR to sub-grant out to arts organizations.
1:00:54 In Mammoth. And, yeah, and it's only, it's for operational expenses, you know, to get everybody through COVID with no ticket sales and whatnot. So, so far we've put out just about $80,000 in the first round and the second round will be going out in the spring to finish out that grant and we'll be getting performance reports for that first round in December. So, really looking forward to seeing all the great things that with that money.
1:01:26 And probably some more pictures to show you next time. And this is the Buckeye Hot Springs Improvement Grant. This was a $80,000 Sierra Nevada Conservancy Grant. As Lawson mentioned, got to work with several partners, Humboldt-Toyabe National Forest, Mono County, Eastern Sierra Sustainable Recreation Partnership, Town of Mammoth Lakes Trail Crew helped out here, installed a new single-vault toilet.
1:01:57 Made a single access trail down to the tubs so people weren't just walking all over the hillside. Created a picnic pad and delineated the picnic area, bought new picnic tables, put in interpretive panels about the natural history and geological aspects of this area. It's hard to say. Roll with me.
1:02:30 Lots of trail and restoration signage to help those user-created trails recover. Where is this approximately? It's up at north of Bridgeport, Buckeye Hot Springs. We should go check it out now. It was a mess up there. 1980 and I still feel like I'm finding new places. So much.
1:03:02 And I hope they continue it this winter. Last winter, Matt Perullo, when he was in his old position, started a pilot program of grooming the road up so you could ski in to the hot springs in the winter and then nice downhill ski out. That place was exhibit A, though, of something that was... I mean, just spur trails everywhere, lots of environmental impact. So these grant funds allow you to do many more things.
1:03:35 I mean, Measure R is limited. There's limited purposes. And you can't even maintain older projects with those funds, correct? It's supplanting. Well, and town owned or managed is the nexus. And being up in Bridgeport. Right. So, exciting towards doing those reachable things that you're talking about. The majority of your time. You'll, I think you'll see.
1:04:05 You know, MLR plays, this particular grant, we played a big administrative role, and Matt Perullo really helped with the on-the-ground management, and so it's definitely, again, this partnership. So as the non-profit, we get to be the applicant and work with partners to get this money on the ground.
1:04:31 And so, as was alluded to, we've also applied for two other grants to Sierra Nevada Conservancy for work out at the Sherwins. We'll find out in December if they're awarded or not. We have a $900,000 plus application in for construction of Sherwins Trailhead to add a restroom, a paved parking lot, bike parking, station access, and then also a $500,000 planning grant to complete
1:05:05 Environmental work for 20 miles? Proposed trails and an expanded trailhead area. So let's hope those come through. That would really turn those propane tanks into something real. Let's see, I think you guys know we do a lot of work with Mammoth Lakes Trail System in the Office of Outdoor Recreation. You know, in essence, we try to make these guys look. And so...
1:05:37 Mammoth Trails Committee is part of our purview, which is the funding and directional oversight for the Mammoth Lakes Trail System. Mammoth Trails, the consortium of user groups, which is, again, another Mammoth Trail something. But this is more of community meetings, getting all different users together, talk about what's going on with the trails. And just a week or so ago, we had the last meeting, I think it was the 20th.
1:06:09 at Mammoth Brewing Company. The meeting focused on the Sherwin's area projects and we also celebrated the 10th anniversary of the Mammoth Lakes Trail System. It's a nice little party and got to announce that Mammoth Brewing Company is going to brew a special 10th anniversary ale for us. Pilsner. Pilsner was the winner. We let everybody that was there vote on it that night. And Pilsner won, like it or not.
1:06:37 And so that's going to be released on June 3rd, which is National Trails Day. So we'll probably have an event of some sort up in the Lakes Basin, a stewardship thing, and then come down and have a nice party at the brewery that evening. We run webpages for Mammoth Lakes Trail Systems, such as the Lakes Basin Connector Trails, which again, we just helped organize and promote the ribbon cutting a couple weeks ago, I know some of you were at.
1:07:06 to open up those new trails in the Lakes Basin. And we also pay for a reporting platform where Adopt-A-Trail volunteers can report what they do each time they go out and work on the trails. They can do volunteer waivers, all sorts of different forms. And then, as you know, we do the Adopt-A-Trail program. It started in 2020 with 18 facilities, and now it's grown over to 40 in the town of Mammoth Lakes.
1:07:42 14 out in the county, over $56,000 has been raised thus far, which has eliminated the use of any Measure R tax dollars for the program, and also offsetting maintenance and equipment. Volunteer-wise, for this program, 450 visitor contacts, 1,500 pounds of trash pulled out of our areas, and
1:08:11 And 650 volunteer hours, so that's like another $19,000 that added bonus. So these pictures is the Parker Lake Trail Boardwalk rebuild, which was up in Mono County. MLR was able to use adopted trail funds to buy $4,000 worth of lumber to support this project. June Lake Trails Committee worked on it. Frontier Pack Station brought in all the materials free of charge.
1:08:41 And the Inyo National Forest was also. So we've been really pleased with how this program is working in Mammoth and throughout the whole county. So Lawson alluded to some comments we've been getting over the summer. You know, you can just read those. One person says it's the nicest she's seen the area in 30 years. So all this great stewardship work that, you know, I'm not an Army of one. There is a lot of people that make all of this happen.
1:09:18 This team here that you see today, there's all the trails crew, tons of volunteers out there. So everybody's work is certainly making it. Moving on to Tangle Free Waters, which is a monofilament fishing line collection program. We have these tubes throughout the county. Started with just a handful, now I think we're up to about 30 stations.
1:09:50 This summer, or spring, we created this interactive station locator map. So people can go and find out where the station is and they can discard their line there. We have over 400 views of the map now. So it's nice to see that it's getting used. And this summer had a very nice integration with the town of Mammoth Lakes water host program. And so they spent their days specifically
1:10:18 walking shorelines, picking up line and tackle, and definitely. So a couple other things we've been involved with, like space and cleanup. I know some of you were there, or your better half, Mrs. Reef was quite the litter collecting machine. There she is. And you know, we tied that into the Great Sierra River cleanup, which is a statewide cleanup day, and everybody submits.
1:10:51 Their data, and I believe the statewide stats are expected to be out in November sometime, so we can bring those back to you. But that was just a really great community event. Help plan, organize. One big lead. One big lead. Yeah, right. There's some, yeah. It's just remarkable. One lipstick. Why do you have computer stuff? Yeah. Reporting the data. One bullet casing, that's scary.
1:11:20 At least it was only one. We're dog bags. That's an empty dog bag. I know so much. I know. Okay, and if you remember our first summer after COVID, the whole Eastern Sierra Dispersed Camping Collaborative started, which really helped put temporary infrastructure out on the landscape when no public facilities were open, and it started the whole camp like a...
1:11:50 Crow Initiative and Mammoth Lakes Recreation has kept a few of those facilities going that aren't in the agreement between Mono County and Caltrans. So this summer we had toilets and dumpsters out at Navy Beach, Benton Crossing Road, and Parker Lake Trailhead. So that was successful to see. We won't go into details by. And then let's see, probably early
1:12:21 In 2022, we started talking with a company organization, Clean Up the Lake. They do underwater cleanup dives, and they had a dive already planned for June Lake. And so MLR was able to support them a little bit financially and also start the conversation about getting this under the lake spaces. And maybe you have or haven't seen it, there was just a news release that Mammoth Lakes Tourism is matching $25,000.
1:12:51 funding to bring this group to do dives in all of our lakes and the lakes basin. Much, much needed. Because as they said, June Lake so far is the dirtiest dive they've ever done. We haven't done lakes basin yet. Who knows? If they can finish. That's not pointing any fingers. Yeah, that's not pointing any fingers. Yeah, if June's the dirtiest thing. It's unreal. So pretty impressive operation. I'm excited to be joining the team. So we...
1:13:26 Touched on R and U, a big part of what MLR does, as you know, R is a one-half percent transaction tax, and Measure U is a two-and-a-half percent utility users tax for the purpose of planning, construction, operation, maintenance, programming, and administration of facilities and projects for mobility, recreation, and arts and culture. Do you know how that memory is? Really? No, no, no. I kind of do, but...
1:13:56 And the big difference between R and U, R has to be used for town-owned and managed properties. And U can go out to organizations within town and Mammoth Lakes limits. And so we recommend the expenditure of these funds to town council. It's twofold. As Heather mentioned, as the chair of allocations committee, they review and recommend programming funds as one line item in the greater Measure U budget, which involves public
1:14:31 Reviews, public hearings, and then it finally gets to town council. And this next slide is an excerpt from our annual report, which will be up on our website soon. It's also in this packet. But these are the full example of what MLR recommends to council as far as Measure R and Measure U expenditures. You can see the programming there at the very bottom of the page is that purple slice. And then, you know, there's
1:15:05 Money for the CRC, there's money for the MAC, there's office about the recreation funding, so there's a variety of things that the board looks at, examines, takes public input on, and then makes a recommendation to council. Is this online? It will be. The board's going to see it for the first time today. But yes, it will be up on our website. It's in this packet, you can pull it off the office. It's not.
1:15:40 It's probably hard to see on that screen, but it's actually coming out of Measure U. We have $75,000 for a recreation coordinator. Is the $1.2 million high, or do you save something in reserve? Or is that appropriate or allowed? There is a fraction, yeah.
1:16:15 I'll, uh, most of the pie is allocated. And that, these are based on, um, estimated revenues from Finance Department. Excuse me, if I can make a quick request. Um, members of the Commission and Board, when you're speaking, if you can move a microphone close to you or people who are out in Zoom land are having trouble hearing those of you that are not right in front of a microphone. Thank you. We don't, we will take those funds, like, we didn't allocate all of it this year. We put a portion of it to the reserves, hoping there can be more. There are some reserves in our programming. Any other?
1:17:01 Questions on that? Go over this quickly. Just, you know, we try to work on community building. You know, as MLR, we go out and try to speak to different groups and organizations about what's going on in the outdoor recreation world, events, programs that are coming up. Worked with the trail system to produce three etiquette on the MLTS videos that are available on our YouTube channel. This summer we did one.
1:17:33 Sharing a trail with equestrians. We've also done some on e-biking in town and controlling your speed on our pathways. We showed a free screening of a movie called Bike Town down at the U.S. Forest Service Auditorium, which is, you know, just how communities came together with land managers to build trails. That's a problem here. I'm just trying to keep the dream alive.
1:18:02 This big thing in the middle of Ride Like a Pro, thanks to Stu, he came to me with this great idea he found of these bike hang tags. Okay, made it happen. And so we produced these bike tags that we gave out to the rental shops, and also I reached out to a lot of the property managers and second homeowners and got these into condos so visitors can come. You know, so we had some great...
1:18:31 Partners, Black Tie, Footloose, Mountain, Wave Rave helped out. And so it was really successful. We've got plenty. We'll keep it going next year. Also worked on the idea of bike bells, you know, just making awareness, you know, trying to teach people etiquette. MLT got these branded, and we had the town trail host pass it to everybody like a horseshoe when they got off the bus. Here's a bike bell. Put it on your bike.
1:19:01 Let people know you're coming behind them. They'll be very helpful. And just to wrap it up, you know, high-level financials, you know, outside of our contract with the town, Mammoth Lakes Recreation brought in $196,000 and we put back into the community through various programs and really excited to see which money in action. So that's fantastic. How does this compare to previous years?
1:19:40 I can't remember the exact percentage, but it's astronomical, and a lot of that is due to the grants that we've gotten, because we're able to, yeah, it's in the annual report, I think it's like 131, 170 percent higher than years past. And I'd point out that I was looking through some of the early MLR, it was the MLR, not quite one sheet draft.
1:20:11 That the town council used when they first approved. And one of the last sentences was, while funds for MLR will come from Measure R, it is strongly stated goal of the organization to become revenue neutral in three to five years. Well, it took eight years to now we're finally, and I don't know if we were revenue neutral. Good work. Thank you. That's exciting. Hope it continues.
1:21:39 Probably some numbers on how many times the QR code got scanned. That'd be interesting to know. So this is why this is so important, you know, being here because, you know, I've never had an understanding of what's really going on. And with all the development that's occurred and your progress and the low-hanging fruit and the base hits, you know, it's really impressive.
1:22:07 But I'm not sure that, and I tell Stu this all the time and commission members that the public doesn't fully grasp or comprehend everything you do, you know. Well, that's really true. The parcel is just the same thing. A lot of people don't even know that the parcel is going on. Like, there's housing? Right. That includes the commissioners, not only.
1:22:28 Well, exactly. That's my point. But we always have a discussion about how do we communicate better with the public to get this word out. Now you're doing the CRC updates every week with new pictures, new information, just bombarding the communication. In all honesty, this is the best way to communicate with the general public because otherwise people don't. If you put it on social media, it's the best way to communicate because no one's sitting around and watching this meeting for three hours tonight.
1:23:01 Well, no, nobody's going to do that. Right. You know, and so what are the best ways to communicate? It's the same with... Yeah, and I think MLR's attacking it very similarly to the way Stu's attacking it. I mean, I know for me right now, as it relates to Office of Outdoor Recreation things, that there's things I want the community to know, I go to two people. I go to these two. And, you know, they have their various email blasts and stuff like that. I agree that social's kind of one of the quick, easy ways to get that accomplished. But...
1:23:32 I agree with you 100%. And it's just one of those interesting scenarios. We talk, the parcel's like a great old life. Hey, what's going on with housing? People are very complacent in this community. You know, they don't really, even though it's so small, and we have these major accomplishments that are being, you know, achieved, people don't always appreciate what is being done for them.
1:24:07 When I built the bowling alley, like two years later, I met locals that never even walked in to look at it. You know, so sometimes, you know, you've got to nudge things along a little bit. I certainly don't think conversation is with Lakes Housing and Mammoth Lakes Tourism and Town Council and, you know, Stu and, you know, town staff has those conversations. I mean, that's going to be kind of an omnipotent struggle is how do we communicate the work that's being done out to the community? And, you know, there's a...
1:24:44 A huge sect of our community that's very engaged and kind of actively seeks out that information and there's a lot of people that are pretty complacent and so it's tough to communicate that. I don't know that anybody's come up with the best answer for it. It's something we're all going to have to continually work on and try. It's a paradox. It's such a small community. Yeah. But with that too, you have so many second homeowners, you have such like a younger kind of transient population in and out. It's just, yeah, it's just...
1:25:13 It's such a small community, but there's so many different organizations throughout this whole area. I've lived in so many different places, and this is the one that has one for this and one for that and one for this and one for that. So this is really cool to understand what one of those entities be able to give that. Well, a lot of this stuff, too, and I think what's really cool about a lot of this stuff is, you know, a lot of it we sit here and we think, oh, like, that makes sense.
1:25:46 Right. But a lot of this stuff is cutting edge and Mammoth is kind of cutting edge as it relates to recreation with a lot of different communities. Again, I don't know if folks are aware, but like Aspen, I believe, Jackson, they both had affordable housing initiative. You know, whether it's something as small as adopted, well, I don't want to say small, but something like adopted trails, something like the bells, people are calling and asking like, oh, how are you guys handling this massive use in Mammoth? So I think it's pretty exciting to just be a paradigm.
1:26:20 For other communities and even our communities to just say, hey, we tried this, it didn't work, let's try to address a lot of these different uses. I've heard in Sun Valley the housing situation is a hundred times worse. It's exponential. I read in the Aspen News where they were putting a lot more of their resources into dealing with people that were coming, not so much anymore in advertising to get people to come. They were already inundated. ICS is pretty close to that same.
1:26:49 Yeah, I mean, Mammoth Lake Tourism turned to, you know, from, hey, everybody come to hug what you love, you know, the stewardship angle of things and just building that within a community, building it with the youth, you know, I think it's huge. This is a recreation-based economy, you know, if it's going to be sustainable in the future, building stuff like this from the ground. 7,000 people, or actually, he's like, no, it's more like a freedom. Oh, yeah. If you think about that, it's pretty, a little bit of workforces hosting that and serving that million.
1:27:30 If I could interject, I don't know what your agenda is for the evening. You have a formal meeting that you need to follow up on. I think we scheduled an hour, so we're past a half hour. And so if I could just suggest that maybe we close the workshop. And that's right where I was heading with one other item on here that I think will serve as a closing is that obviously we went long because
1:28:04 This was so needed to, you know, particularly with a largely new commission and kind of all of us coming out of our Zoom closets and being able to meet face to face. But the notion that I heard of, and I can't remember where I read it someplace, or maybe I heard it in your guys' meeting, is that, you know, a couple of our board members and a couple of your board members getting together for a beer. Yeah.
1:28:33 And outside of the bottom line, sorry. They don't have to be mutually exclusive. No, they don't. Either or. An adult beverage of your choice. Say yes and. Is doing that on some sort of regular basis so that we know what's on each other's, you know, what's in each other's lanes and how we can help each other. And I think is a strive to do going twice a year.
1:29:08 I think, and then once a year we get together and have a workshop like this, you know, my head was that? Twice a year. Twice a year? I think so. Two, two, two. And then ad hoc stuff. Ad hoc stuff with a couple people from, you know, so that we don't get into Brown. Angie's laughing at me over there. That was me. I said, you know, I never know what to get out of something like this. Sometimes it's just a meet and greet.
1:29:47 People kind of struggling, kind of like in the beginning of MLR. What are we? What are we doing here? What tangible can we take away from this? Actually, something very tangible did come out of this. It's a very dynamic sort of getting to understand what you're doing and appreciate it. And so, yeah. I certainly thank you guys for the extra time. It felt like it was something that was needed. And if we went a little long, I can hammer out our agenda pretty quick, I bet.
1:30:18 Okay. So do we have to formally adjourn something here? No? Okay. Well, thank you for your time. Thank you guys. Thank you. Very educational. Thank you. We'll do a five-minute break until we come back and hit our agenda. Thank you. Okay. Almost ready here.
1:39:11 Disco. And we are ready to go. Boom. We'll reconvene here. And first item on our agenda where we left off is consent agenda approved minutes from the June 28, 2022 regular board meeting. Do I have a motion for? I would be happy to make a motion that MLR board approves the minutes of the June 28 regular board meeting. I will second that.
1:39:48 Second, Schaubmeyer. Any discussion? Seeing none. Angie, could you do roll call for us? President Albright? Yes. Treasurer Schaubmeyer? Yes. Secretary Bankson? Sorry, I was muted. Here. Board Member Fernie? Yes. And Board Member Wasserman did join us during the workshop. Board Member Wasserman, how do you vote? Yes. Thank you. Hi, Eric. Hi, WF. Hey, guys. How's it going?
1:40:24 Good to have you with us. Good to be here. Yeah, next up, 6.1, Program Director Update. Kim, what do you got for us? Okay, this will be quite brief today. We went over a lot of stuff already, but just wanted to touch on a few things. As you heard, the NEA grant is still in process. We have the SNC grant applications in.
1:40:52 Speaking to Mammoth Lakes Trail System, we recently had a ribbon cutting. I'm going to share my screen here, show you a couple fun pictures. So yes, on October 1st, we got to open a little over three miles of new trail in the lakes basin. Nice to celebrate some wins here with trails. And so you see...
1:41:24 Mayor and Joel cutting the ribbon there and then a nice group photo. There was a good turnout. It was really fun. So lots of celebration around that. And again, we just touched on this in the workshop, but also on October 20th, we celebrated the 10th anniversary of the Mammoth Lakes Trail System at a Mammoth Trails meeting at the brewery. Had a great turnout, had a great dessert table.
1:41:53 By Deserted, it was delicious. Sorry you missed it, more for us. And we told you Mammoth Brewing Company is going to brew a special 10th anniversary beer and we let everybody vote on it. You see in the bottom left there our town manager putting in his vote. The Pilsner won. And so on June 3rd, National Trails Day, we'll be having a fun party. 10th anniversary Pilsner.
1:42:25 Let's see, other sustainable recreation stuff. Lawson and I have been attending a pre-scoping, pre-pre-pre-pre-scoping process for the over-snow vehicle, over-snow travel planning with the Inyo National Forest, the sub-part C, which is a mandated process the Inyo National Forest goes through.
1:42:51 A group of users that have been identified or representatives of user groups trying to get everybody to come to a collaborative decision implementation plan that can be presented to the Inyo National Forest as one option in hopes to keep this process to about three years instead of lots of collaboration. There's been some good stuff.
1:43:19 Organizations haven't really been part of the process, such as like Friends of the Inyo, so there's a little concern that maybe this shortened timeline won't be met, but you never know. Anything else to add? No, I think she covered it pretty well. I think the end result of this is hopefully a recommendation, right, to the forest supervisor for this process. Obviously, the forest is going to go through their own review. That does not mean at all.
1:43:48 that that recommendation will be taken forward, but this has been extremely contentious on other forests, extremely contentious. So the U.S. Forest Service hired a professional mediator, and that mediator is basically running these pre-scoping meetings. Then this process will have to go through public scoping and all of that, all of what that entails as well. But the end results of kind of these
1:44:15 pre-scoping meetings are to try to provide a recommendation or maybe several recommendations to the forest supervisor as the forest moves into formal scoping for this project, if that makes sense. Yeah, so I've been, you know, attending just to listen, absorb, and be able to report back to you as a board, to the Mammoth Trails Committee, you know, in the event that along the way there is a formal position that you'd like to take and submit a comment during the official comment period.
1:44:46 As you heard, we've been continuing to support dispersed camping efforts. That's all getting pulled this week. So we had a good, successful summer. Measure R and U allocations applications will be January this year, 4th through 27th. We'll be reviewing them in February. And I think we have everybody nailed down to February 8th and 9th in the morning for our review meetings, which will be great. Then we can take them to the
1:45:16 We do have a new committee member, Danielle Torrance. She's the superintendent for Round Valley Schools and lives here in Mammoth. She'll be replacing Catherine Taft. Catherine had to step down. Just too much going on in her real world.
1:45:44 Love to have her on the allocations committee. She'll be missed, but I think Danielle will be a great fit. As far as funding, this year we'll have 186 plus the $31,500 we did not allocate last year, so applicants will have $217,500 to apply. That's a good amount. We've been working with Pinion Ranch Consulting, so if you follow our social media, you've maybe noticed it's
1:46:17 Stepped up a notch, or 10. Certainly not my forte, so it's been really wonderful working with Matt. He's helped me catch up on a very backlogged part of our deliverable for Adopt-A-Trail and Tangle-Free Waters, which is recognition to our sponsors and volunteers on social media. So he's been posting those twice weekly, and he's very good at it. Tamara recommended him to me, and he's great.
1:46:45 Love working with them. Super good. I've definitely spent most of the budget I've allotted, probably about half for the year already. I'm not really worried about it because I think it's worth it, and I think a lot of money we've spent on the front end dialing in our systems and creating templates and whatnot, so our workflow is going to get a lot more efficient. You know, I think we'll look at the budget numbers tonight, but I think in
1:47:15 The next financials maybe. We'll see how they are and if we need to make any adjustments. But it's been really great working with him and I do think those costs will go down. Quick couple administrative things. We're moving to Heartland Payroll Services. Sarah, our accountant, she's been doing payroll for MLR since the beginning and she's migrated away from it from all her clients. We're one of the last ones. She recommended Heartland. She works with them.
1:47:43 Costs are going to be about the same, and it's been a seamless transition so far. Would like to get everybody's opinion and possibly reschedule our next meeting, January 3rd, maybe push it a week to January 10th, right after the new year, if we want to just decide that now, or at least decide we're going to reschedule, unless you want to meet January 3rd. I feel Tuesday after New Year's might be a little tricky.
1:48:18 I concur with that. I just, it's such a busy time of year. Yeah. That week, and schools are not back in session, so I'd prefer the week after. Yeah. Yeah. LA Unified doesn't go back now, so. Okay. Our early indication of the mountain is it's going to be one of those three-week holidays, and so that's why. Yeah, so I definitely suggest that. Tamara, Eric, does the January 10th work for you for our next meeting? January 10th, I'm actually an outdoor retailer. Okay.
1:48:49 Big convention. Is there any way we could do it on the 9th, which isn't one day? Otherwise, I can zoom in again, but I can be there in person if it's on the 9th. Okay, well, we'll look at Sweet Z availability. Let's just know that we're going to push the January 3rd to hopefully one day that next week. I could do the 3rd, but I know the mountain is slammed. Yeah, I think that's kind of asking too much for, like, especially getting packets in and whatnot.
1:49:22 We'll definitely push the January 3rd and we'll announce the date once we figure one out. Yeah, I might be out. I have a tentative trip that I'm planning. I'd be leaving the 7th and not coming back for at least 10 days. So I might be out either way. The 3rd works for me, but I'm the opposite of everybody else. Okay, thanks, Eric. The week of the 17th, I'm wide open, if that helps.
1:49:53 I know that's pushing it a couple more weeks, but that might be better for Craig to recover also. And you know what? Also, we'll look at what agenda items we have. We'll just see how robust the meeting is and how far we can push it. So I'll be in touch with everyone on that. But know that the third will be rescheduled. Okay. Well, do we want to keep the third? No, we were saying it's better to not keep on the third, I think.
1:50:31 And just last, a quick FYI, Governor Newsom announced that the COVID-19 state of emergency will be lifted in California effective February 28, 2023. So if all goes as planned as of now, we will be required to be meeting in person. And that is the update I have. Angie, maybe you're the best to answer this question. So if that gets pulled and Zoom kind of comes off the table.
1:51:04 You know, there's always been an ability for people to call in as long as your public location is noticed, et cetera. Would that go the Zoom route or is it back to a call-in or in person? There's a couple different weird things with this. For starters, we will continue to offer Zoom meetings for members of the public or outside vendors that can't come to me. There will be the option to go back like pre-COVID. And so, yes.
1:51:36 As long as we know before we publish the agenda that somebody will be zooming in, we'll be able to do that. There is also, and I sent it to Kim, it's rather complicated, there is another assembly bill that was put in place to sort of replace the AB 361 we're doing now, which looked like it was going to be great, but then a bunch of people got their hands in it, and it's a little convoluted. I did send Kim some information on it.
1:52:06 There is a way, if it's like an emergency last minute, Heather's got a sick kid or something, and last minute she can't come, it can be voted on during the meeting. So there's some limitations to that. It is an option, but it's very limited as to how many times that can be. I gave Kim some stuff, and she can forward that out for you guys to take a look at. But your original question, yes, we can do what we did pre-COVID.
1:52:37 Thank you. So next item, thanks Kim for that update. And item 6.2, fiscal year 21-22 annual report. Okay, so I put together our second ever annual report. Did a little different format this year. I got some feedback last year that people had trouble printing it. And so I made it more...
1:53:11 Page PDF style rather than digital scrolling. Kept it to the basics in our vision, mission, income expenses, funds generated, funds dispersed, talked about Measure R and U, some of the advisory stuff we do, our grant projects, stewardship programs, our community awareness, and what I'd like is for you all to peruse it and offer any feedback that you have.
1:53:47 Make it public on our website. I think we had a really successful year. I like doing these annual reports because it does give us a good snapshot year over year. For example, when we talked about, you know, our funds generated was a 19% increase over last year. Last year, I think it was like 150% increase, which is good that we're not having that much. It means we're stabilizing. I think that, you know, the...
1:54:17 A more stable, steady income that we can count on for funds generated, but then our funds dispersed was greatly increased because I don't know if we did anything the prior year. You know what I'm saying? So we're really starting to find, see these patterns, which is something I really like about that. We're able to see how much money we've allocated in Measure U. You know, it's over the lifetime of MLR, it's over a million dollars that has been put out in the community.
1:54:46 So it's really nice to see those figures and, yeah, just looking for any feedback, comments, and then let's see. I don't need it tonight, but take, you know, a couple days and look it over and let me know what you think. Sound good? No, that looks great, Kim, and we'll all do this a little bit more, but I think it is really important to get it out on our website and, you know, and maybe as working with our social media person,
1:55:25 You know, kind of let the community know, hey, here's where to go to look at what MLR has been up to, you know, and maybe a couple of those big numbers, you know, find out more about the X million that we've, you know, that we're benefiting the community with might really be helpful. Yeah, definitely. I'd love to task out more social media. It's just finding that budget. All right.
1:55:56 Moving on to Policy Matter 7.1, Review and Consider Approval of Mammoth Lakes Trail System Budget Modification for Sherwin's Area Environmental Analysis. Hello, Lawson Reef, Office of Outdoor Recreation. I wanted to bring forward to you
1:56:21 A request for basically an additional $20,000 to be allocated out of Measure R trails to help fund archaeological analysis for the Sherwin's Area Trails or SHARP project.
1:56:34 that will be occurring at the base of the Sherwins. We are working with a firm called Cardno, now Stantec, and a lead archaeologist named Crystal West, who was a former Inyo National Forest archaeologist. They have all local resources, so extremely savvy with this area, which, if you are not aware, is one giant archaeological site.
1:57:00 So having an experienced team is absolutely huge. We received a proposal from them outlining those costs, which will be roughly $117,000 with an additional, what we are requesting, $2,856.50 for some additional staff time that may be needed. Now, for some background on this,
1:57:30 The archaeology, I think, is what has stalled this in the past. The rest of the environmental analysis, wildlife, hydrology, botany, that is all being done in-house by the Inyo National Forest.
1:57:46 Many of their staff has been already out there to analyze coming up with a proposed action, which will subsequently come out of this analysis is on the Inyo National Forest Program of Work, meaning they are working collaboratively with us. They simply do not have the capacity to do the archaeological analysis. So $100,000 had already been allocated effectively for this archaeological work, but we
1:58:16 Received an NTE quote from Cardinal of $117,000 plus that additional $2,856.50 to make it an even $20,000 for some additional town staff and contingency. Now this is an NTE number. It is entirely possible the $100,000 that was already allocated will be sufficient, but the goal is to not spend any of that money due to hopefully getting
1:58:45 S&C planning grants for this project. But either way, the Cardinal staff is available if we can execute this, which I will present to Town Council tomorrow, to start working this fall, assuming that this snow does not completely shut us down.
1:59:07 So really what's going to happen with a lot of this is they will conduct archival research and obtain archaeological survey permits from the Inyo National Forest. They will conduct an inventory field survey out in the field at the Sherwin Meadow. They will analyze that data and prepare a draft site record and phase one cultural resources inventory report. They will then provide that report to the Inyo for their review and to provide comments.
1:59:37 And then address those comments and submit the final cultural resources inventory report to the forest. Now, this is step one in the process. They are going to find stuff out there. And then the next part of the process is putting shovels in the ground, looking at mitigation measures, all of those different things. We are hoping to work with the Inyo National Forest to try to have them do that work in-house. But if not, we are
2:00:06 Hoping that SNC grant goes through to complete the second phase of the project. But currently we're at the part of developing a good proposed action and then sussing out if that proposed action will have negative impacts on the condition out there. And if they do, how do we mitigate those?
2:00:28 If we run into an archaeological site here, can we just shimmy our trail over here and avoid it? Or are there other mitigation measures? Is it possible that maybe that trail alignment is not good, right? That there's too many problems with it and that we might have to abandon it completely or find a suitable alternative.
2:00:45 So what we are asking for is that allocation from Measure R Trails Fund 215 of an additional $20,000 to support this archaeological work, again with the hope that that SNC grant comes through and spend that money. Awesome. Thank you, Lawson. Any questions from the board? If you don't need to use those funds, will those funds be returned?
2:01:19 That would be the goal, yes, yes. They're basically being moved from the trial system capital project budget to operating, and then if they're not used, they just go back to the fund balance. Yeah, just because it wasn't a line item budget. Would you two dare to speculate the likelihood of receiving that planning grant? I mean, do you feel like we've got a viable... We're not going to jinx anything.
2:01:51 Do you feel like we fit well within the constraints of the ground? Yes. So then essentially you need, I'm sorry, does anybody have any questions, Tamara or Eric or Craig? Hi, are there any other organizations such as MLTPA that are participating in this? In what aspect? Funding. No, this would be funding that would go straight to the archaeological survey contractor. Okay.
2:02:28 You may have answered this. It's just a little hard for me to hear, but you're asking for us to move $28,000 from the MLTS reserves. What is the likelihood that you're going to need to come back and ask for additional funds? For this phase of the project, I do not anticipate this. The $117 was an NTE amount as well. There was already $100 budgeted.
2:02:51 It is entirely possible that they don't even reach that 117 mark. So I do not anticipate being that that was an NTE quote we got from them going over that dollar amount and having to come back. Okay, I'm just concerned with everything and the inflation rates these days that they come back and say, okay, we're not at 117, we're at 137 now.
2:03:15 That being just a consideration, but you don't anticipate that to happen? No, I do not. And the NTE quote that they provided was kept it at that 117 number. Yep. And then we are requesting that additional $2,856.50 for town staff time and just general contingency there. Okay. Thanks for answering. No problem. Lawson, this seems to me like this is a good example of where
2:03:45 where MLR can partner with the Office of Outdoor Rec when we run into these situations, if I heard it correctly, where the Inyo can't move on something and it's the opportunity we could sit and wait until they do have the resources to do something or jump in and, you know, jump, keep the process moving forward. I mean, this
2:04:15 Sounds like exactly where, you know, the Office of Outdoor Rec, MLR, and the INEO can keep things moving together and avoid some of the delays we've experienced in the past. Yeah, and I think some of that overlap is also evident with, you know, what we are hopeful for, those S&C grants, and how would that whole overlap with MLR and us working collaboratively to accomplish what I would hope are our shared goals. No other...
2:04:47 Comments or questions, then I'd entertain a motion on this matter. But then I guess I could start with, please correct me here with the language, to make a motion to approve $20,000 to be moved from Mammoth Trails, please give me clarification of it. Measure R Trails Reserves. Measure R Trails Reserve used to be held in a fund essentially for the name of the company.
2:05:27 Cardinal Stantec. Cardinal Stantec. Yep. Does that work? Can we read the agenda item? Sure. I know, versus me, like, pulling that one out. Thank you. So I'll make a recommendation that the MLR approve the budget amendment of moving $20,000 from the MLTS reserves to the Sherwin Area Environmental Analyst Project budget. I'll second that.
2:06:06 I have a motion from Schabmeyer and a second, Fernie. Further discussion? Angie, could you help us with a roll call, please? Yes. President Albright? Yes. Treasurer Schabmeyer? Yes. Secretary Bankson? Yes. Board Member Fernie? Yes. And Board Member Wasserman? Yes. Thank you. Excellent. Passes 5-0. Thanks, team.
2:06:45 Good job. On to our next item, 7.2 review, financial report, fiscal year 22-23 through September. Take it away, Kim. All right. I'll put it up on the screen as big as I can. Okay, so I'll just kind of go over some highlights of the budget. Feel free to ask questions whenever. Currently, we are tracking about...
2:07:32 $9,600 over budget in our direct public support, which is always a good thing. I definitely budget conservatively, so happy with that figure. Moving down into our government grants, we are under budget, but I wish there was a large donor. Yeah, definitely lots of small.
2:08:12 contributions. Probably the most common is our $1,500 adopted trail. Agreed. Just an FYI, we can't hear. I think it's Colin talking on Zoom. If someone could talk to my mic, it would be great. Sorry, I got the mic on now. Is that better? Yes, thank you. Thank you. Yeah, so Eric, just to reiterate, my question was,
2:08:44 Under individual contributions, we have a total of 11,950. And I was curious whether that was comprised predominantly of like one larger donor or if that was a large group of smaller donors. And Kim clarified that that was a larger number of people with smaller contributions, which I think in general is a positive thing. It's more people supporting the organization. Agreed. Thank you. Now we can't find that large donor on top of all these other people though. We'd like to have both.
2:09:21 Yes, and. Yes, and. I'm learning that. To mention here in our government grants, which is our grant funding, things like such as the SNC grant that we have already done, the NEA grant, and also our contract with the town of Mammoth Lakes, we're tracking a little under, and that's only because we haven't received our final closeout payment from...
2:09:48 SNC for the Buckeye. So by the time we see the next financials, that should be leveled out. Overall on income, we're right on target. So I think that's, we're tracking very good right there. Moving into our expenses. You know, for now we continue to operate at a bare minimum, well under budget for our business expenses. We're at 2% of budget right now.
2:10:19 Contract services, as I mentioned here, down here, the creative agency were well over budget at the moment. Alarming, not alarming. Like I said, I think our monthly costs will go down, and I did budget over the course of the year, so the $1,500 budgeted is only for these first three months. I think we will go over budget on the year and might have to look at it, but let's see how we are tracking. Do we have an ROI on that? I mean, obviously, we know you originally set these things up.
2:10:51 There's an investment that you have to make. I see it constantly when I'm going through Instagram and through Facebook and stuff constantly up. And so I notice it. Therefore, I know other people are, which is great. But it's something I think we definitely need to budget in for next year to find out what that number is and find out what we're getting in return, how many punch-throughs are we getting, et cetera, for clicking on MLR and then hopefully then turning it into a donation. Definitely. He's also helping with the newsletter, which is nice. We can track donations that come directly.
2:11:21 from the newsletter. I feed the content. He makes it look pretty. It's great. It looks great. But yeah, so I definitely think, I do hope it pays for itself eventually. It's building that base again, building it up, continuity. So yes, don't have anything right now. Though I would add to that, that more than necessarily just the financial payoff, it's
2:11:51 Kind of what we talked about with the Rec Commission is awareness of what we're doing and engagement with the community, even though that may not have a direct dollar amount to it right away. You know, if we were measuring amount of engagement with our Instagram post, I don't know what the measures are in that, likes or...
2:12:14 Impressions. Whatever that metric is, impressions, you know, that if that's increasing over time and we can really see, wow, we are much better engaged with the community and it cost us X number of dollars to get there, that, even though it may not directly have a dollar for dollar connection, you know, engagement with the community is one of the hurdles we've been trying to get over for a while and it may be worthwhile even in that.
2:12:43 Exactly, yeah. Who we are, what we do, getting our name out there, and it takes a lot of stress off of me. It was something that I'm so thankful for. We are competing with the world for their attention. I understand. Well, that has, the fact that you just said that, Kim, it takes a huge amount of stress off you, has huge value to us. So we know that you're a one-man show, one-woman show, and...
2:13:12 For you to have somebody to back you up that you can say, hey, can you just do this? That's huge for us. That's worth it. And he's good at it. And it's certainly not my specialty. I'd rather focus somewhere else. But it's a deliverable. So you're getting it done. Exactly. That's important. Thank you. Let's see. What else did I want to say? Oh, consulting services here. This is a new item. Was it in our original budget? That is.
2:13:43 What the company that filed our employee retention tax credit charged. Gotcha. So that's where that $5,400 was filed. And I think we got $21,000 back. Have those funds landed yet? Yeah, I think we filed in February and got them in August or something. Quite a process. Let's see. Office, you know, overall.
2:14:18 Some way under, some way over. I think overall we're tracking good. Our bank service charges here at the bottom are above budget, which is a good and bad because that's where we show the processing fees for us accepting donations. So I did budget that high. We are over budget on contributions, so those go hand in hand. Any questions thus far? Okay, insurance, we're...
2:14:52 Under, but I just made a couple big payments, so those will level. Payroll, we are right on. Keep scrolling up. Organizational growth, nothing has come through that I thought was of great interest right now, so no need to spend in that category, but it's nice to have the budget if something does come up. Same thing with travel, and moving into fundraising.
2:15:27 It's kind of hard because, you know, we know we need to have a fundraising event to make some funds, but you need to have funds to make some funds. So still searching for that magical event to get us there. You know, and I know we have a great board we can work together to try to find something. So that's just a conversation that's continuing, have a little bit of money budgeted, and then...
2:15:56 Looking towards our program service expenses, this is where we get invoice for all of the adopted trail work and the Tingle Free Waters and all of the dispersed camping and any type of specific donation that comes in. We show it here in these program service expenses and I know that about $15,000 of invoices are coming from the trail system soon for work completed here at the end of the season. So we're under budget but I think
2:16:24 We're actually right on with some anticipated expenses coming up. So overall looking good through... Can I have a question? Just to read that correctly, the contract labor there, we budgeted to get $15,000 in, but we've only gotten $483.50, but there's invoices that are out? That's correct. The trail crew is going to bill us for time working up in the Lakes Basin on some of the connector trails.
2:16:56 And there is some equipment that is going to be purchased through adopt-a-trail funding. Gotcha. Okay. Yep. And just before we talk about bottom line, if we need to, I want to show you the next page, which I've been showing you a few times now. These are just balances that we carry for very specific projects and programs. Looking at the...
2:17:25 Capital projects, the Horseshoe Lake Bridge, you know, that was a few years ago now, and we've kept a balance in there just in case a piece of it broke or it needed minor repairs and good job, Joel and crew, nothing has needed, but we still have that funding available should they need it. The other two line items, the NEA and SNC grant, are money that will roll into MLR unrestricted funds once the grants are closed out.
2:17:55 So NEA, we're probably looking at at least a year from now until that money will be realized, but SNC, I imagine by the next board meeting, that should be closed. And then the sustainable recreation, all of those funds are available for invoice at any time by each organization, and so wouldn't really be counted as anything towards MLR funding, if that makes sense.
2:18:24 I'm just curious. I can't keep up on all the abbreviations. I'm not sure what AAT, KLVG, all those. Is it possible that they can rename and type them out so that we don't have to keep track of every little acronym? Absolutely. Great call. Thanks. Just so you know, I will type it out next time, but it's adopted trail for the Mammoth Lakes Trail System and adopted trail for Mono County because it's...
2:18:54 Different funding pots on the back end. Public facing, it's all the same. Disperse Camping, Keep Long Valley Green, Mammoth Lakes Trail System, donations that have come in specifically for the trail system. Then Sierra Trash Eliminators, we act as a pass-through for that grassroots organization so they can go do good work on the ground. And then the Tangle Free Waters Program and then donations tagged specifically for winter recreation.
2:19:24 Nice, thanks. Now it all makes sense. Thank you. My pleasure. Yeah, so plus or minus $80,000 of our fund balance is, in other sense, accounted for. Questions? Seeing none, thanks, Kim. Thank you. Pardon me. Kim, I think it'd be hard to argue at this stage that there's a lot of fluff in this budget. So, you know, well done running lean and mean and running the organization super efficiently. Good job, thank you.
2:20:10 The lean, mean, one-woman machine. Loved it. Moving on to 7.3, review and consider approval of website rebuild proposal. Okay, let's spend some of that lean, mean machine. Nice segue, right? Speaking of it. Okay, so again, working with Pinion Ranch Consulting, we've talked about a website redesign.
2:20:41 I think hopefully you've all read through the quote. It really, he's really lined it out well. Gets right down to the specifics that the MLR website is terrible to navigate. It's very hard to find the information you need, what you're looking at. I have trouble sometimes. I've gotten emails from people. I want to adopt a trail, but I can't find the page. Where is it? Or how do I find this? And so, you know,
2:21:10 I've worked with Matt to Matt is Pinion Ranch Consulting. There's so many Matts in the MLR world. To really figure out what this website needs to be effective and what our users are going to be looking for. And so we've come up with, I think, a really good plan. Drilled it down. And, you know, I mean, I think you guys know how I work. We try out something a little bit. Like I've worked with Matt on the social media and doing the newsletter.
2:21:41 Worked really well together. And I've seen his style. I've seen how he works. Tamarkin has tested this. He's fast. He's good. He's smart. And I think he can do a really good job making our website more user-friendly and getting our information out there to the people that need it. And so it's through this proposal. It's a full site rebuild with different navigations. If you turn to the costs page, I asked him to try to go bare minimum.
2:22:13 Full site rebuild came in at $7,800, which is extremely reasonable for a website. And then if, you know, we're feeling that's a little too iffy with our numbers, we can take it down a notch and leave out a few sections and bring that down to $6,500. And so I'd like to hear some thoughts, concerns, if you're excited about this, if you agree. I will jump in first because I was the one that referred you to Matt.
2:22:51 So Matt Ullery that has provided the scope of work. I can tell you just from working with him for several years now, he's excellent and efficient. He's not going to overbill you or us for any of the work that's done. And you are going to get a much better, using square space, a much better layout and really easy to navigate. And it's going to save you time in the long run.
2:23:17 The downfall is he's not cheap. So if you break that down to hourly, it's $120 an hour. And that's just his going rate. So he's not going to overbill you. You're going to get what you pay for. And still an entire rebuild of your website for $7,800, I personally feel is very worth it. However, we have to look at our budget. You only have a $7,500 contingency that we built in for the entire year.
2:23:42 So this is going to put us over budget and that's something we need to discuss as a board. So I'll just give you those as my two cents so far. Thank you, Tamara. Other comments or questions? I'm just trying to figure out where do we pull the money from. There's no money tree to pull from, so where's it going to come from? Ask somebody for those. What's it going to cost for our ads on an annual basis also? You know, like this is for the rebuild, but what's it going to cost monthly?
2:24:17 In addition. Because I don't think we're not looking for just $7,800. We're looking for $7,800 plus whatever it's going to cost per month. In maintenance. In maintenance. Yeah. Right now we're paying $100 a month for web hosting mates. So essentially throw on another $1,200 onto this for an annual budget aspect? That's in our current budget. That would be eliminated through this. We could get rid of this third-party company that is charging us $100 to do what Matt would do.
2:24:47 Got it. So can we that be included in this quote or that it's additional? No, that would be, you know, I think, I can't say exactly, but it would be close to one for one on a monthly basis. The 78 is definitely something we did not budget for. And yeah, it's a big chunk of money to take from our small budget. I have to think that it would really help just based on the public feedback I've gotten. Again, there's no...
2:25:21 ROI number to associate with it at this point. You know, I think... And then... Oh, go ahead. No, go ahead, Wasp. And then, is there anything in the contract that would hold him to these hours and quotes? Is he going to start this and then all of a sudden be like, you know, it said 19 hours, but it took 26. I know Tamara just vouched that he works quickly and he's good, and I'm sure he's very honest and reputable, but sometimes you lift the hood.
2:25:53 It's a little worse than you thought. Sure, and yeah, we did talk about that, and the original quote he gave me was a low-end hours and a high-end hours, and I just thought the high-end was too much for what we have available, and so I asked him to pare it down, and we discussed that, you know, as we move through, there'll be lots of check-ins with this is where we are on hours right now. This seems to be taking longer. Do we proceed? Do we change course?
2:26:25 So I feel like there's a good line of communication. There's nothing contractual, but I feel like that there's some, you know, relationship obligations that have been set up. Is there a way that we can ask for a not to exceed amount? For completion of the project with a not to exceed this amount, that that's the only budget that can be approved? So we can't be billed later? I assume, yeah.
2:26:58 And I think that's what this board can approve, you know, a not-to-exceed amount. I think the 7,800 or the 6,480 is the lowest not-to-exceed amount that we can do. I think, you know, more of like an 8,000 or 8,500 not-to-exceed is good, but we can also... And then I would honestly say, I mean, I'm very loyal to Matt. I've worked with him.
2:27:30 for quite some time now. But it's probably in our best interest to get a competitive quote. Is there, can we, is there another consultant or another company that can provide the same service and give us something competitive to look at so that we know we're getting the value? I know this is a reasonable number because when we did for an event that we do for Rock and Rye, we used a company, a marketing company that does
2:28:02 All of our website and our Facebook and our Instagram and everything. And I've seen these numbers before, so to me this is a very reasonable number based on, and ours is a once-a-year organization, once-a-year event that we put on, but we spent that money, the same kind of money, to get this stuff started. So I understand that this is, to me, a very reasonable cost. And I think if you want me to share that as a budget example, I could. But I think if you've already got an established relationship, is that something that you need to waste your time on right now?
2:28:31 I mean, all I can compare it to is since I've been with MLR, the three webpages that were built cost upwards of $10,000 for three. And then do we want to consider as a board just to kind of get this thing paid for selling advertising on any communications or anywhere on the website or we want to keep our clean look with no advertising? I don't know. Can we sell advertising being an NGO?
2:29:04 Or sponsor. Sponsorship. You can always take a sponsorship. Yeah, sponsorship would be a better word. And just some food for thought. I mean, if we need this and it's expensive, but it's good quality and a good value and it's just a budget issue, that's a way to solve it. Maybe not in perpetuity, but for a year until we get it paid off. And I'm pretty sure if we go back and look at our budget from four years ago when we rebuilt the website page that we have now, I think we spent about 10 grand.
2:29:35 I think it was four years ago? Yeah. Five years ago? That's what I kind of remember, right? You know, I know we're all just kind of discussing and brainstorming here. I mean, my thoughts are when I first saw the agenda item, I didn't know if there was a necessity there. I think our website aesthetically looks good, but I don't have the day-to-day interaction with it that you do, and I also take the feedback of
2:30:05 of the public seriously in the sense that if people are coming to the site, they're confused, they're having issues navigating it, I think we need to take heed to that because obviously it's not doing its job. You know, I'm sure Craig could dwarf the numbers that I look at in terms of, you know, website rebuilds and such, but when I originally saw the item, I thought the cost was going to be exponentially higher than this just in my world and working on website rebuilds.
2:30:33 We do have a great contact that I can share with you if you just want to get a secondary quote. He's done a wonderful job on work for our new Black Tie Adventure rental site and that kind of stuff. So if you just want to see a comparison point, I'm happy to do that. To me, you know, $6,000, $7,000 for an entire website rebuild is pretty affordable. So I'm not sure that we're going to do better than that necessarily.
2:30:58 Between option one and option two, at least from my personal opinion, I'd like to take option two off the table. I think if we're going to do it, we do the full Monty and I don't see the sense in kind of holding back a couple of sections for coming soon in the future. You know, I would be comfortable with moving forward if the board thinks that this is something we need to do at kind of a not to exceed of like 8,000 or 8,500. I think we need to give a little bit of wiggle room there.
2:31:27 But I think that's smart suggestion for us to put into the contract. So those are some of my thoughts. And I think it really comes back to the feedback we're getting from the community. If they're having issues navigating the website, we probably have something that we need to address. We can pull some of this out of reserves, correct? Yeah, absolutely. And we can also look at, you know, we were just talking about the SNC grant is almost closed out.
2:31:56 That's going to be about $9,000 that is just coming back into our unrestricted funds. Yeah. Yeah, that's exactly where I was thinking is, you know, that S&C, there's a big chunk of it, you know, you had, if I recall correctly, you had like $3,000 in office equipment that we haven't spent or for a computer. Don't upset it.
2:32:24 Try not to spend it. But, you know, I think there, it felt like there was some wiggle room in there, and I would agree with Colin, you know, I'm, these numbers seem very reasonable to me, and I'm comfortable with giving you not to exceed in 8,500 range, and particularly when you said, you know, if you can work with him through the process, and if what,
2:32:54 Eric was mentioning all of a sudden it's like, well then, maybe the couple items that they took off in option two, maybe we end up adjusting midstream, but I'd prefer not to do that, so giving you a little extra and moving forward seems reasonable. I think it comes back to, you know, do we think this is necessary? Because I think the 8,000 or 8,500 doesn't scare me. I know we've got the funds to do.
2:33:25 Do that if this is a necessity. So I think that's really the conversation for the board. So what's the feedback that you are getting? It's navigability. Don't make me say it. Navigability. Navigation. Navigation of the site. It is beautiful. It's aesthetically a nice-looking site. Gorgeous-looking site. But there's a lot below the fold, which is a terminology that they use and a practice that is now
2:33:55 You know, frowned upon. You know, the amount of scrolling you have to do to get down and see things is problematic. And there's a lot of data here below the fold, which is now considered a bad practice. So I see that for sure. And, you know, in lieu of that, you go to the, you know, the mega menu at the top and it's like,
2:34:17 I understand why the site was constructed the way it is. It was really to follow kind of a lot of the directives from council and those type of things, but is that really what people are looking for necessarily? And it sounds like no. So I could see navigating the site being challenging for people. It's like, well, I'm not necessarily looking for community building. You know, how do I search for what I'm looking for? What is that? You know, instead it's going to be volunteer programs, projects. Yeah. You know, grants.
2:34:47 It's going to be across the top, very specific categories, drop-down menus. Boom, this is where I want to go. Right. And just following up with what Colin's saying, do we need a full rebuild to do that? I mean, could they redesign where the buttons are and the navigation at substantially less than eight grand? I wish, yeah. So the past couple of years, I've taught myself how to make do with this website because it was built by,
2:35:18 Web developers with code. It's very hard to make any edits. So if I need to do something, I pretty much just build a whole new page. And so then we have this maze of pages. And so that's the other frustrating part is I can't go in. I cannot edit the homepage. I can't change things. You know, I got to say, I hear this every business that builds a website. It seems like, you know, every four or five years we all go through this.
2:35:48 Is there a way to ask, or I'm sure the technology exists, but the industry just doesn't like to do it, is can it be something that you can be built upon so that in four more years when there's a newer technology, we're not spending 10 grand again and this thing is scalable? I mean, theoretically, that's what you're proposing by moving to a platform like Squarespace, better editability. And I think, Eric, to your point,
2:36:18 That's a change that's occurred in like the last short number of years. You know, five, ten years ago, you really had to go to a web developer to do all that kind of stuff. There's this whole new industry that's been born out of kind of Squarespace and all the likes of, you know, allowing the user to have some sort of tweaking and capabilities. And if you feel like it's over your head,
2:36:43 You can go to somebody that has some acumen in that space for a relatively cheap cost for like a short overhaul. We've done that. And it was very expensive, you know, very inexpensive kind of little cost to say, hey, these are the few things that we want to change. And it's just over my head. But yeah, I think moving to a platform, I mean, I think, Eric, your point's valid that like this stuff changes so frequently that are we going to be hearing this again in five years?
2:37:11 I think there has been somewhat of a fundamental shift in the industry in that respect in the last five years, let's say. Yeah, I'm all in favor for that because if it's shifted that way and now we're good for a while, I could justify the expense we've seen it. Yeah. Yeah, I'm excited to get this feedback because it is, you know, let's say a scary thing to do a website rebuild. And at first I was like, really, that's an interesting idea.
2:37:45 And the more I think about it, then all these feedback, you know, comments come to me and what people say and I really think as we move forward and we are getting more social media presence and people see our name and then they're going to go to our website and good experience there instead of getting frustrated and then forgetting about us again. Is it pretty frequent that you're getting this feedback? Is it like a one-off somebody from the early bird special that just can't navigate a site or is it pretty frequent?
2:38:17 It's frequent. Okay. And actually, the feedback is consistent. It's a beautiful site, but I can't... I think that's fair feedback. Yeah. Just looking over Colin's shoulder, I'm like, oh yeah, because I was on there a little bit today. Yeah, me too. And I was like, wow, our website looks great. But I was just skimming a few things. I wasn't looking for anything. And I can...
2:38:50 So, how would, how would, do we want to entertain a motion, or are we going to let this sit on it for a while? I will say that I think, usually when Kim presents something like this, she's pretty frugal with her spending, and so I have a lot of trust in you saying if you spent the time and energy to get to this point, that I think it's something you deem necessary to do sooner than later.
2:39:28 And I think it's something that should be done before the CRC is completed, because I think it'll be a great opportunity for us to push a lot of people in that direction of our website, if that's something that could be done in that time frame. So I would say forward 85 years. Good point. Yes, personally. Would you like to craft a motion? My favorite thing to do, college.
2:40:02 My Achilles. Yeah. Mmm. So I'd like to make a motion to approve $8,500 from our general fund budget to be used to craft a new website. Not to exceed $8,500. Not to exceed $8,500. Correct. I will second. See, I got double seconds on that. Bam. Double seconds. They just don't want to propose a motion. Give it to Tamara. So we have...
2:40:35 Motion by Schapmeyer and second by Bankson. Any further discussion? I just really want to push that February deadline. That's all, if possible. Yeah, that's a good point. So we've got a motion approved $8,500 from our general fund not to exceed to pursue a website rebuild and give Kim that.
2:41:02 And just I want to say, just like what Heather was saying, what is his expectation for completion of the project? They said February today. And Kim, like... No, I mean the website. Yeah, I will confer and make sure that February is a reasonable deadline, and if there's any problems, I'll come back to the board and we'll reevaluate. Do you have the content? I mean, that's the biggest, that's the most... And that's, we have all the content, we just need to organize it.
2:41:31 And obviously in the motion we're not tying into a specific provider, so I'll forward you over a second one to look at, and obviously we know we've got a good viable option here, and we'll just, the funds would be there regardless of the provider, assuming approval. Thank you. And if you need feedback on anything, just reach out to us via email. Awesome. Okay. Angie, could you help us with the roll call?
2:41:59 Yeah, I just wanted to confirm, so we're not necessarily approving option one with the agreement because we're not necessarily approving this quote. We're approving a rebuild of the entire website with an agreement not to exceed 8,500. Thank you very much. President Albright? Yes. Treasurer Schaubmeyer? Yes. Secretary Bankson? Yes. Board Member Ferney? Yes. And Board Member Wasserman?
2:42:31 Yes. Thank you. This is 5-0. Go get them, Kim. Go team. All right. Next up, 7.4 debriefing from our joint meeting with Parks and Rec Commission. Way back on November 1st. Way back. When was that? I'm like. Yes, I thought we just have this item here to give us any chance, thoughts. I thought the meeting went really good.
2:43:04 It was so productive sitting around, sitting with the new commissioners, talking about what each other did. And, you know, we're not going to meet again for two months. So any final thoughts, excitements? I just have one thought and it's for Angie. Actually, I had trouble hearing and didn't know who all the, couldn't identify everybody. And I know I'm out in Zoom land. So if she could just help me with that, with the notes, that would be great.
2:43:33 Yes, all of the names of the commissioners will be added in this section of the minutes that talk about the workshop. Perfect. Thank you. You're welcome. Tamara, you were not alone on that. I was struggling as well. Okay. And I want to think of others very productive. I think the last time we had a meeting like that, honestly,
2:43:52 Maybe four years ago, maybe three, I know Sean was on the board, Betsy was on the board, like it was a long time we were having ad hocs, we were talking about the CRC and who was going to be responsible for programming, it's been a while since we've had to sit down and touch base with everybody. Yeah, and I think it was especially necessary because so many new faces on the recognition, so, you know, I think...
2:44:15 There are a lot of valid concerns out there when you have Mammoth Lakes Recreation, the Town Recreation Commission, you have Office of Outdoor Rec, you've got Kim, you know, so there's a lot of cooks in the kitchen, if you will, focused on recreation initiatives, and I personally, I think that's appropriate because we are a recreation-based community and economy, and I think, you know, making sure that
2:44:42 The inner circle, if you will, understands where everyone's lane is and how we work together to get initiatives across the finish line and making sure that we're working towards the same goal but not overlapping and duplicating work. I think that's really critical for us as board members to know that and obviously there was a lot of that discussion today and I think some people from that meeting came out of it with a much better understanding.
2:45:11 If we don't have that foundational understanding, we certainly can't communicate it to the public. Do you think on our website we should house something that's a page of, well, what's the difference between this? And actually give a link to our partners' websites? I mean, for clarity? Or do you think that would just junk things up? I'm just throwing it out there. You know, I've been thinking, as we've moved through this with the town council over the last couple years, one point is, since we last met, we've went through.
2:45:41 Quite a transition, to say the least. Right, a rebirth. But this idea of these lanes and where there might be overlap, maybe it's the ski instructor in me, but I've got this Venn diagram. Oh, yes, the circles where they overlap each other. Where do we overlap and who's responsible for what? I don't know if it's not going to fix all of our problems, but it...
2:46:08 I'm a visual learner, I guess. And so giving me something that helps me see where am I at in relationship to our partners would, I think, be helpful. There's that content. Awesome. Yeah. I thought it was super productive. Certainly a necessary thing for us to do as we start to, you know, re-engage with what does our role look like moving forward, you know, as we integrate all these different entities together.
2:46:45 We've talked about how MLR really kind of shrunk down to very bare bones, like, you know, keep the organization alive, and we're starting to come out of that, and as we start to think back to some of those aspirational goals that we had, some of them may fall off the plate, but some of them are probably still in our scope of work in the long run. You know, I think we all have visions of this organization, really, you know, how do we become a better fundraising and grow.
2:47:20 You know, raising organizations. So like as we start to think about those things moving forward, we just, you know, it's good to have that. And I think between the town council joint session that we had last time and this, it seemed very obvious that our rebirth has commanded a new respect for our organization and it feels really good to be on it. And Kim, just a very special thank you to you because quite frankly, you're running the things, we're doing a lot and
2:47:54 You've articulated it well to the community so that they realize what we're doing. And both comments from Bill on council last time, and again, I don't know who the players were today, but, oh, actually, Dan from the bowling alley. He seemed pretty impressed, so it's great to see this, and I think that was a good benefit. We got some good PR. Just from my perspective, I don't know, I don't think you guys needed it so much, but we did for the commission.
2:48:25 Because I don't think many of us, certainly not me, were that aware of exactly what MLR did. I obviously was not aware. The staff report, I read every word of the whole, all of the, and I think with the staff you've got, you're going to go far. I mean, you're probably underfunded, especially reaching out to the boundaries of beyond Mammoth Lakes. There's so much need and potential in that arena. So I think you guys are, I think you're on the way. Well, thank you. We appreciate that. Thank you.
2:48:58 And to that point, I think one of the things that as we move forward, we really need to consider changing our name. Yeah. You know, to reflect that broader regional aspiration and to maybe get, there's too many MLs. Agreed. In my humble opinion. Yeah. You know, and that. Great. Do you just go Mammoth Lakes in order to change the initials?
2:49:28 Thanks, Eric. Anyway, awesome. Eric had surgery today. The drugs are still in effect. Anyway, thanks you guys. That was, I did think, even though we went long, totally worth every moment. Board member reports, we'll go around real quick. You want to start us off head? Sure.
2:49:57 Holy heck, where's the time gone? Phenomenal fall. You and I were talking about when we walked in. Hands down, the nicest fall in the 20 years that I've lived here. I don't know. I'm very thankful that it was a phenomenal summer, an even better fall, which I'm hoping will then translate to an even better winter. I'm very hopeful for the white, flowy stuff to come through and having a big winter. So that's where I'm at right now. I'm just right now in the world of planning for the winter, this upcoming season, the snow flying. I'm ready. That's where I'm at.
2:50:27 Boom. Colin? Yeah, I mean, I certainly don't have anything monumental to report. I spent a little time out of town on the East Coast with my family, and so that was nice and rejuvenating and kind of hit the ground running. We are making the flip from summer to winter right now and starting orientation with our management team. So, you know, coming in here while it's snowing outside was super exciting, and it definitely feels like winter is...
2:50:55 Coming at the right time and starting to build some good momentum for a good winter. So, yeah, I don't think I have anything crazy to report, just plugging along, normal. Awesome. Thanks, Colin. Tamara? Nothing monumental on this end. All of Mammoth Community Foundation events are done and we're just doing a lot of close-up and button-up from last year, but otherwise looking forward to winter.
2:51:23 Like now, because it's outside, and otherwise, all is well. Thanks. Mr. Wasserman. Thanks, Mr. Albright. You know, I've pretty much had my head down with work. We did a major undertaking. We changed our back office from Wells Fargo to LPL, and that has taken 100% of my time the last five, six weeks. So I will say the fall was awesome, like Heather said.
2:51:57 It's great. I've been watching on a webcam during this to see the snow flying in Mammoth right now, and I'm hoping to do plenty of recreation shortly. Awesome. Thanks, Eric. And for myself, as you might imagine, we're doing a big transition, trying to get everything closed up on the hill, all of our huge summer projects, and they're out paving.
2:52:24 Right up until the snow flies, and so that is the Mammoth way, if there ever was. You know, just a really good place at the ski area right now. You know, Ron Cohen's really doing a great job. You know, it's great to be able to go back to the senior leadership team at Mammoth and report on what MLR's doing. You know, when Brownlee first.
2:52:52 Kind of said, yeah, yeah, you should, we need someone involved with that, you know, from our senior leadership team. And there wasn't a lot to report aside from, well, we're trying to not get, you know, blown away, you know, out of here. And anyway, you know, stuff like our, the funding we've had, it's great to be able to, you know, along with Eric Clark, who's
2:53:20 really involved with Mammoth Lakes Tourism and Tom Hodges with housing, you know, that, you know, we take our role at the mountain as being, you know, leaders in the broader community and so it's, you know, I'm very proud of what we've accomplished together and, you know, as some red-headed guy with a black t-shirt used to always say, the best is yet to come and, you know.
2:53:49 Now that he's retired and just a citizen in the community, maybe that's going to happen. And so with that, and I've lost my agenda. I don't think I have anything else. We are going to adjourn until our next meeting in January, date to be determined, and out to the public. Thanks, everyone. And as always, thank you, Angie, for your...
2:54:20 Guidance here. Yeah. Thank you all. Appreciate your support so much. Good night. Thank you.