Town Council
at 16:00
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Minutes ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Notable from this meeting
2 findings- FY22-23 preliminary budget had a $10,183 deficit that staff closed in the tentative budget at $27,630,890 Budget and Capital Improvements
- The FY2019-20 franchise renewal raised the fee from 5% to 9.5% Fund 205 - Solid Waste
Transcript
404 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
3:59 Yeah. Hey, John, I'm tired of those seats. Your mic's not on. Mayor Peckstown Council for May 18, 2022. All right, let's start with the call to order and the roll call. Jamie? Councilmember Rae? Here. Councilmember Souser? Yep. Councilmember Stapp? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Salcido? Here. Okay, I'll pledge allegiance on Andy.
6:37 Thank you. Next, we'll call for public comments. Is there anybody here that would like to make, or online, who would like to make a public comment on a topic that is not already on our agenda? Hello, everyone. It's been a long time since I've been in this room. Jo Bacon, Mammoth Lakes. I'm here this afternoon as a former Planning Commissioner, Town Council Member, and an appointee to the Mammoth Community Water District Board.
7:28 In my 20 years in Mammoth, I've read and analyzed most of the environmental impact reports concerning our community. I'm well familiar with what a good report is. The May 11th decision of the Planning Commission to approve the drilling of geothermal wells as a part of the Limelight Hotel project was made without adequate information.
7:50 First, the Mammoth Community Water District was not involved in the environmental review process and was not even aware of the geothermal wells until after the agenda packet was released the Friday before the meeting. Second, a decision was made to publish an environmental document that did not require community input or review. Third, any responsibility for the quality of our water
8:16 was deferred to a state agency without any understanding of that agency's processes. A public hearing without adequate information is not a public hearing. Because of these decisions, I'm letting the town council and the community know that an appeal has been filed concerning this project. Thank you. Thank you. Okay, any other public comment? My name is Ted Carlton. The reason I'm making public comment, I made a public records request.
8:54 I think that their transparency and lack thereof should be taken into consideration and as an MLT board member,
9:25 I think Councilmember Sauser should be particularly disappointed in that group. Thank you. Thank you, Jen. Okay, thank you. Okay, Jamie, is there any public comment online? No, there is not. Okay. Okay, seeing no other public comment, is there any additions to the agenda? No, Madam Mayor, nothing from staff. On to item five, reports from commissions and or departments as needed. And they're rushing the podium.
10:01 Thank you so much, Sandra Moberly, Community and Economic Development Director. A couple of updates. I wanted to update the council and the community to let you know that the town and Mammoth Lakes Housing have received home key funding for our project in the amount of $4.41 million. This is really exciting. It's for conversion of a hotel into 15 residential units. And so we will be putting out a press release. Mammoth Lakes Housing is working on
10:30 Securing the escrow for that property and then we'll be putting out a press release on it but I did want to let the council members in the community know that we have received that grant which is very exciting. Another update, just an update that the Planning and Economic Development Commission met last week.
10:46 They had a pretty full agenda. They did approve a new 33-unit residential development at 100 Callahan Way. That's the Villas 3 development. They did approve the new limelight project, which is 151-room, 15-residential-unit hotel. As Ms. Bacon noted, we have received an appeal on that. So that item will come forward to Council in probably the next couple weeks, probably in June. We're working on determining what...
11:13 You know what our response will be, putting that together, and then we'll let you know the date that it will counsel for consideration. They did also approve a tentative track map for 14 lots for affordable housing at the parcel. That was just a relatively quick item after those two long items. And then they did approve three different variances for various single-family home configurations at 182 Davison, 31 Mali Ulyse, and 751 Majestic Plains Drive.
11:42 And then just another note that we will be having a special joint council commission meeting next Wednesday. It'll be focused on the parcel, so our council members who are, and commissioners who are conflicted out of the parcel won't be attending, but it'll be next Wednesday, May 25th at 4 p.m. And that's all I have. Okay. Congratulations. Great news on the home key. Yeah. Thank you. It's very exciting. It must have felt good. Thank you. Thank you. Good afternoon, council. Laura Kaler.
12:16 Director of Communications, PR, Content at Mammoth Lakes Tourism. Just here to give you guys an update on what's going on with us right now. So basic winter 22-23 air service has been loaded through United. This is probably the earliest we've had winter flights loaded, which is fantastic. It'll help with booking ski clubs and groups. It'll just give them more advanced notice.
12:44 That they can book a ski trip to Mammoth Lakes. So we're pretty excited about that. Winter flights will start December 15th. And then of course we have our summer air service kicking off in June with Advanced Airlines and United. So book your flights on Advanced before May 30th to get your discount. MLT is traveling the next two weeks to promote the winter of 22-23 in Australia. Winter flight service into...
13:13 BIH is one of the major talking points, so it's nice, again, that we have those flights loaded. MLT is also in the final stages of producing an updated vacation planner. This is the aspirational piece of collateral that we use in our international audiences to promote Mammoth Lakes. So Brian, our Director of Marketing, is in Vail this week presenting on our stewardship efforts at the MMGY DMO Summit.
13:42 We also have Dakota and Emily are at the Tourism Cares Meaningful Travel Summit in Lake Tahoe this week. So everybody's kind of out and about. We hosted an open house last week, had a great attendance, probably the best attendance we have had at one of our open houses, which was really exciting. Connected with a lot of the community, just gave a really short presentation so we didn't bore anybody, but got to talk one-on-one with a lot of people.
14:08 Community Coffee is May 26th. We're going to be talking about defensible space, home hardening, fire education. It does have a new start time of 8.30, so if you're used to joining, we moved it back a little bit for people dropping off kids and getting around. We got some community feedback that that would be a better time. And then finally, I want to introduce our new digital content and social media coordinator, Patrick Grayley.
14:35 Patrick joined us last week. He's been in Mammoth Lakes for about four years, grew up in Southern California, visited Mammoth all his life. He does all the activities we have to offer, so he's really hit the ground running for us on social media and, you know, already knows a whole bunch about the area. So, welcome, Patrick. Nice to meet you guys. Nice to see you. And then, am I allowed to comment on what was mentioned in public comment or no?
15:02 Is that allowed? I just wanted to say I don't think we've been unresponsive. I've been CC'd on the emails. I just don't think we have the information available yet. My understanding is the requests are for 22, 23, and contracts have not been signed yet. So that would be my take. I'm sure Ted has a different take. But we haven't been unresponsive would be the main thing.
15:28 All right. Well, I would suggest MLT talk with Ashita. Yeah. Thank you guys so much. Thank you. Laura, you have one question. When you say loaded the winter, is that for both Bishop and Mammoth? Just Bishop. This is just Bishop. Correct. Just the United Flights. Okay. Yeah. Thank you. Okay. And we're working on advanced air. Absolutely. Yeah. Thank you guys. Thanks. All right. Good afternoon. Kim Anna Clario, Mammoth Lakes Recreation.
16:01 Very happy to have announced the awards to five local arts agencies through the National Endowment for the Arts Award grant, Chamber Music Unbound, Eastern Sierra Arts Alliance, Eastern Sierra Symphony, Mono Arts Council, Sierra Classic Theater all received awards totaling $79,300 and we'll happily be dispersing those funds to the recipients next week.
16:28 We also submitted a concept proposal to Sierra Nevada Conservancy through the Vibrant Recreation and Tourism Grant Program for the construction of the Sherwoods Area Trails and Trailhead, a requested grant amount of a million dollars. It's very limited funds and very competitive, but we'll do a site visit in early June. The concept proposal is recommended. Full application will be due in July and funds come in December.
16:57 Also, thanks to a sponsorship from LADWP, we'll be expanding the Tangle Free Waters program with upwards of 15 to 20 new stations to collect used fishing line for recycling. We've added a map of the station locations that can be found at TangleFreeWaters.org. We are starting to plan the next Mammoth Trails meeting for mid-summer, which will be focused on the Sherwin's Area Trails and Trailhead project.
17:26 And on May 3rd, the MLR Board held a public hearing for the recommendation of allocations of Measure R and Measure U, which are included in the tentative budget being presented to you this evening. Last is an update on the Regional Park Program Grant, which is the improvements at Whitmore working with Stu and team. Notifications for that won't be coming out until late July or August, so we just have to sit tight and wait on that one for a while. Thank you. Thank you, Kim.
17:58 Kim, what was the award from the LADWP for the Tangle Free Waters? The amount? $7,500. $7,500. Welcome, Stu. Evening. Afternoon. Council, community staff, just a brief update from Parks and Rec. Stuart Brown, Parks and Recreation Director. And then Hayes and I are just going to walk through a little bit of a bird scooter update. I have a brief COVID short presentation. So I've got some...
18:39 Pretty serious multitasking going on here soon. But anyway, lots of smiling happy faces this morning at the Whitmore Pool. Big day at 6.20am. Pool officially open for the morning and afternoon lap swim. Mammoth swim team practices. So that was great news. The team did an amazing job getting that ready for the public. And the maintenance finished this morning at about 10.30 as well. So really good timing. June 11 is when the pool actually opens for the public. That's when we get kind of a seven-day week schedule.
19:08 So we've got a few long weeks of lap, swim and swim team. I think everybody might have got their invitation to the official Shady Rest Disc Golf Park. Should be in the email box, hopefully, if you haven't. Check it out. Come and get your hot pink little putter disc next Tuesday at 3 o'clock. So we have those for everybody that comes along. It's also a recognition event for the many Adopter Holes sponsors as well. So that's 3 o'clock. But do reach out and let me know if you didn't receive an invitation.
19:38 We cleared the lakes basin path to Horseshoe Lake. Hayes might give a brief update on the roads, but pretty much dry as a bone. No official opening date. Recreation team, just quickly on our camps and programs. We've had a pretty successful hiring phase, so it looks like we'll be able to operate all our published camps, maybe a few more, and then we're just working on our wait list and enrolling a lot of the kids in some of the open spots we have in our camps.
20:09 Team's doing a great job getting everybody sorted and in camps. Parks and Recreation Commission meeting is June 7th and that's when they'll look at allocating the additional youth sports funding money. Just really briefly on, let me just get here to a screen that I can share for COVID. We just had a brief update from the county yesterday and I just grabbed a couple of their slides.
20:40 Just to kind of share with the public on kind of where we're at. Do that reasonably efficiently. There we go. Not as long as our normal slide presentation. But we just do want to kind of bring the community up to date graphically on how we're doing. This is kind of a two-month window. So right there, that's kind of mid-March, I believe, all the way through to, I think that's May 14 at the end on the right. So you can see we've had some...
21:13 Highs and lows. We had some peaks here at the end. Positivity rate is, you know, has been hovering around 8%. And you can see the case rate just kind of came down from 23 to 20. And you can see this graph kind of gives you the combo. So this is the adjusted case rate per 100,000. Gives you the historical case rate for the last month. And you can see the hospital status is still green.
21:39 Just a quick snapshot at our vaccination rate, still almost close, almost there at the 10,000 mark for our first dose and almost 5,000 for the booster. And then testing, I know we've been updating this frequently, testing is at Canyon Boulevard, sorry, Canyon Lodge, 1,000 Canyon Boulevard. OptumServe won't be testing on Memorial Day May 30, instead they'll test on Tuesday May 31.
22:07 And then Public Health still do their testing PCR and antigen at the Mernon County Civic Center. So that's kind of all I had. On COVID, Dan, did you have anything else to add? If there's something we needed to, if I forgot anything, all good. And then Bird Scooter, so we launched, well Bird launched I think around 20 scooters last week and we published that through our website. Hopefully everybody saw that Facebook post, it was on our website.
22:39 Hayes has a little bit of an update. So what we're trying to do now is just kind of catch up, get some additional information from Bird, trying to receive public input, how it went, if anybody's been writing on them. I know Brent and Betsy jumped on, so we've been kind of collecting a little bit of that. We're also publishing on our page, it'll be under, I was trying to think of where we would put it, but it's going to be under kind of local and regional transportation as a heading, kind of micro mobility. And then we're going to be able to publish that map.
23:07 So there's kind of a GIS map that shows where the scooters are geo-fenced. So basically if you pick up your scooter, this map will tell you where to go, where you have to go slow, where you can't go, where you can park, where you can pick up, those type of things. And any other information, please reach out to the town. I don't know if there's a contact case. You want to just cover the rest on that?
23:32 Thank you. Like Stu said, we're doing our part to try to collect information on this pilot program, so we're encouraging the public to contact us with their positive experiences and along with the negative and any constructive criticism they have of it. I think there's been a mixed bag of results on Facebook, and we'll share that data as we get it. But I want to remind the public, if you do see a conflict, you can respond directly to Bird. If you have the Bird app, you can...
23:59 If someone is calling, is there a local number?
24:30 To call to report an abandoned bird or one left in the middle of the road or something. So if you're, you know, walking around town and you see this, what is the action? Who do you call? So the process is to contact bird directly through one of those three methods I just went through. And they'll contact their people on the ground to have those bird's scooters moved or relocated or taken care of. So the process is to go through their bird channels at headquarters. Okay, so someone was...
25:00 If you're visiting town and they didn't know any of what we're talking about, what would they call the, you know, what if they, what happened if they called 911 and just said, you know, there's a bird in the middle of the street so I'm just going to run over it? Then we would respond, obviously, if we get something directly. We've received some stuff to Public Works and we've reacted to it. We're not going to say no, but we are notifying, you know, through the proper channels. But if there's something that's an emergency, obviously, you know, we're not going to just...
25:28 You know, blow it off. We will respond for something. Case, in conversations with the people from Berg, and I mentioned this when they made their presentation here, I find it, as an old guy, odd that they aren't giving any information to town or locals about who the local contractor is that's actually picking them up and charging them and maintaining them. Somehow the convoluted route through Berg and then back, and we all know.
25:57 They don't want you to say it, so I won't, but we know who it is. I'm finding that odd. Have we had that conversation with them and it would be much more convenient if they could call the local number or is this just how they're going to operate? This is how they propose to operate is everything to flow through their headquarters and they will distribute to their groups. I think they have multiple organizations working on this and I think they're coordinating with who's on at what times. We do have access to that information at the town.
26:26 So we can make those contacts if necessary, but that is how they have proposed to work with us, and I think we're inclined to work through that process now to see how that works. And if it doesn't work through this pilot program, maybe we have to have a different conversation with them. Sort of a who's on first and what's on second approach. So did you say that that number is going to be published online? We'll put it on our information. It is available on the scooters as well and through the app and through email. So we'll provide it on the channels that we have accessible to us.
26:58 And it's also, like I said, on the scooter. Okay, could you give it one more time in case everybody wanted to jump down? Yeah, it's hello at bird dot co. And then it's just the bird application through whatever app store you use. And then customer service is 1-866-205-2442. Is the local contractor keeping track of where, I don't know how the geofencing works, but is there an app that they use, they know where the scooters are? I found it a little odd and this isn't, we should probably bring it back at some point.
27:30 But a little odd that you're able to turn the scooter off and end your ride at somebody's private residence. I understand that so you don't keep getting charged. But if you can do that anywhere, then the problems that we foresaw become reality. So hopefully we're going to keep an eye on that. Yeah, that's exactly right. That's why we're looking for this feedback. So if there are issues, we want to hear about it so we can communicate with Burke. They have the ability to change things on the fly immediately.
28:00 If something needs to be blocked out, modified, private property changes, we have the ability and the flexibility to work with them to change that effectively instantaneously. But we'll need that feedback in order to have that conversation. You know, this is a pilot program. We are expecting growing pains. We don't really know what the result will be at the end. But we'd like to let this play out a little bit, and then maybe it'd be good to come back to council with some findings.
28:26 Have Burke participate. They have an algorithm. They have their internal processes that they could speak to on how they're redistributing things and how they're working in town. And I think it would be more appropriate for them to answer those questions because we don't have direct access to that data. So if it is the pleasure of the council for us to do that, I'll work with the town manager. We'll find the time and it's appropriate to bring them back. Could we do an update at the next regular town council meeting? A few weeks? Yeah, I'd probably give it a little more time than that.
28:54 I'd still like to hear kind of where we are. Yeah, I can always ask. Okay, thank you. There's an abandoned scooter in front of my condo in Snow Creek 4. I don't know if this isn't done doing enough, but it's been sitting there for two days. I can make a call for it. That's all I had. Okay, thank you very much. Oh, you're back? Okay. Real quick, just...
29:28 I did want to provide a quick update on the lakes basin. We did plow. We did clear snow. We have put out porta-potties, and we have unlocked the dumpsters, and so we are managing those facilities. I do not have an opening date that is managed by the Forest Service, but the basin is open for recreation for people who want to walk in or cycle in, and we have provided the facilities for those folks. That's the only update I have. Is the porta-potty on the other side of the tunnel at Mammoth Creek East? Is that open?
29:58 Yeah, the regular restroom, is that open? The regular restroom at Mammoth Creek East, it's due, step out. Mammoth Creek East restroom, is it open? They turn the water on? Okay, and if not, is the port-a-potty operating or? All right, just. Thank you. Okay, thanks. Anybody else? Dan? Yeah, two items. One is we're working with Mono County to kick off an update of our multi-jurisdictional hazardous mitigation plan. We did run a few years back. It came through a lot of work between the town and the county.
30:44 Wanting to make sure some of the districts get included this time, fire district being one, into that planning process. We have to make an early commitment to participate in order for funding from the process to make it more of a hazardous plan. We just did the one here a few years ago, and this will be a good update and lessons learned and some ways to beef that up. It is required for a variety of grants and stuff, mitigation grants in particular. Working through that, and as Stu noticed, some of the greedy, but I think Al walked the end or back out anyway.
31:16 Our police department did pick up, set a little sting up and picked up some juveniles doing graffiti in the tunnel between Mammoth Creek Park East and West, so we are watching that. Don't know if they're the same ones that tagged the restrooms or not in those types of areas, but if so, we'll be working through that. It's a little disappointing, but obviously it's good to get them caught and talked to and their parents, guardians spoken to as well. So they were caught in the process? They actually, well, yeah, they...
31:46 They confessed to doing it, too, as they had their pens with them, whatever. So, yeah. They were juveniles, though, so we don't say who and all those things. But, anyway. Frustratingly but glad we were able to do that. Okay. Nope, nothing else. All right. On to staff presentations. Amanda, waiting in the wings. Good afternoon, Madam Mayor and Councilmembers. Amanda Pelham, Human Resources Officer.
32:19 Today we're here to welcome Melissa Bell to her new position as the payroll and human resources specialist with the HR department. She should be a familiar face to everyone as she worked in our building division as the permit technician since November of last year.
32:35 She comes to us with 10-plus years of customer service experience, including working for private sector and Fortune 500 companies and office management positions, working in facilities coordination in Yosemite National Park, and working as a building permit technician and commission secretary for Mona County prior to working with us.
32:56 With a wealth of administrative experience, excellent analytical skills, and a passion for serving our local community, we're really excited to have her on our team, and we know she's going to continue to be a great asset. So welcome, Melissa. Welcome. Glad to have you here. Thanks and welcome. All right, next, Amy. Good afternoon, Madam Mayor, Councilmembers. Amy Callanan, Engineering Manager, here this afternoon to welcome...
33:40 And introduce to you Matthew Friedman, our new associate civil engineer. Matthew most recently joined us from the Concord area in the Bay Area of California and was working with a telecommunications company on telecommunications infrastructure for several years. He is a licensed California civil engineer, having graduated from Walla Walla University in 2013. And he has some previous land development experience as well.
34:10 He has visited Mammoth often, enjoys climbing, hiking, all the variety of activities that Mammoth has to offer. I have enjoyed working with him now for these past, well, three days. He just started with us on Monday, and he is getting right into the thick of things, and we can't wait to see how everything shakes out. So we're looking forward to a busy summer, and we are very thankful for the help. Thank you for having me. I came forward to all the work today. Were you able to find a place to live?
34:49 Currently I am in town housing. Great. Okay. Thank you. All right. Thank you. All right. Good afternoon again. So I would like to take this opportunity to not introduce but to at least acknowledge the employment of Hector Garcia, a.k.a. Teddo. Unfortunately he's not able to be with us this afternoon. I'm sure he'll make it back at another time.
35:38 Teddo joined the Parks Maintenance Department in summer 2019 as a temporary maintenance worker and, according to Warren, established himself as a hardworking, no-nonsense, get-the-job-done employee. After the peak of COVID, we rehired Teddo in late 2020. Warren offered the full-time position to Teddo and he joined the Parks team at the end of this April. Teddo was unable to attend this evening but is eager and looks forward to maintaining and enhancing how many parks, trails and facilities in Mammoth Lakes.
36:07 We'll try and get him back in another time. Okay. But thank you. Thanks. That's great. Okay. Now I think we're going to item number 6.4, update on public safety radio communications upgrade. Thank you, Madam Mayor. Yeah, we wanted to bring this in and do a quick update of where we're at and working on our radio system. Jeff Edelson of Elk Mountain Technology will be joining us on Zoom. Elish Duminer from the fire department is here. And Nate from Mona County is here as well, Greenberg.
36:38 The idea on this is we've been setting money aside and so wanted to keep the council updated on where we're headed and what we're working on. We have been looking at different means of upgrading a 30-plus-year-old radio system that definitely needs some TLC. Through the process of that, we've ended up moving forward with the state system. Chris, there's a write-up that in your packet. I won't read through that. So it'd be part of a statewide system. Elk Mountain's had some
37:08 We have experience with statewide systems in Colorado, so that's been a real good asset. We also began some working initially with Mammoth Mountain and upgrading their system, so they were familiar with the area, so bringing them on board made a lot of sense. The fire district in the town took the lead on that. Auto County has been engaged by Jeff as well, conversations, looking at different options. We know we have to deal with integration for communications, but for dispatch. And then ultimately, I know the county's made some funding requests to help support
37:38 Roll out in more of the county as well. The state system would roll out along the 395 corridor, and so we're looking then at being able to tie into that through the 203 corridor up to Mammoth Lakes, which was not part of the original state plan. And Jeff was going to share his screen there. Jeff, I saw it pop up, but nothing shared on it, so if you want to try that again, you may. And then I had Alice here can speak to the fire district and their needs and stuff, and also with
38:09 Nate's been just involved in this whole process. It's been really beneficial, frankly, throughout the whole discussion on this and maybe a brief update of where the county is and or also just some of the challenges I know we'll be looking at as we integrate systems. So we have a good team on the IT side, which has been very helpful. But Jeff, if you can share your screen, I want to walk through briefly the couple of slides you had there. You're not coming in very well. Yeah, Jeff, you're breaking up pretty badly.
38:57 So, you know, I was going to just take a minute, and Jeff really is the technical expert on this, so hopefully he can get his slides up and working, but really just provide a little bit of perspective and zoom back. 2019 is when the federal engineering study came around, I'm sure you're familiar with it, but just to kind of go back and take a look at that.
39:26 It really presented a little bit of a conundrum here. We're all aware of the status of the current system, but they came in with an estimate, and this is for the entire county, so it's not an exact apples to apples comparison, but clearly our two constituencies have important ties in this. $8 million on the front end for the cheapest system, $12 million on the high end. And if you actually looked at the reoccurring costs over the next 15 years, it was going to be another $6 million.
39:55 The system that we're currently looking at with Chris is probably closer to the high-end system, but it actually has, it's a trunk system. There's some opportunities in it that especially for law enforcement will be appreciated. So it is kind of a top-end system. So probably that 20 million 15-year system is kind of the best comparison to that. When you really look at, you know, when we saw that in 2019, that just seemed like something we weren't going to be able to conquer. The solution we have in front of us today is really speaks kind of
40:25 The collaboration of all these groups, really bringing in a good technical expert. The fire district is probably the most knowledgeable end user on communications just due to the nature of how wildland fires work and the fact that we have to work quite a bit with different agencies who have different types of radios. So while we know them well, this is completely past our scope of knowledge. So having Elk Mountain come in here, and these are ideas that have been vetted by the county, by ourselves, and by the town, but really kind of validate a lot of that.
40:54 Speaks to just where we've come in the last few years. So there's still a lot of hurdles to get crossed. We won't really know until we have the system up and running, but I'm fairly positive as far as where this is going. The district is obviously involved, and one of the sites is going to be over at our fire station. Just an update on the action sheet. It's actually over at Fire Station 1. One of the benefits of having a pre-existing tower there is it's significantly easier to build on something that exists than to put a new radio tower, as I'm sure you're aware.
41:24 And I'll probably leave it at that. I just kind of wanted to pull a reference in depending on if Jeff was able to get on. I'm back. Yeah, I'm back. Sorry about that. Internet in Colorado is terrible. You can hear me OK now? Yes. OK, let me share my screen real quick here. I'll pull this up. So sorry for the members there. I'm going to leave my video off just with.
41:51 Internet being poor. But the goal here is to give you all a short little update. Everybody can see the screen, correct? Yes. Okay, sorry. A short little update. So as both Dan and Alice mentioned, we went through an evaluation of the different types of systems, and we were looking at the pros and cons of cost, coverage, reliability, interoperability, and really...
42:14 Trying to meet the end user goals. And at the end of the day, we did select the Chris system, as they mentioned, which is the California interoperability system. It's currently a pretty large statewide system. It's continuously growing. I have a lot of experience working in a similar capacity consulting for other state systems, including Colorado, Utah, South Carolina, Nebraska. And in general, these systems, as long as they're well-funded, have a lot of opportunity involved.
42:42 So, you know, the big things that we looked at were the interoperability with the other state agencies, whether it be CHB, Caltrans, other municipalities. And one of the things that was really attractive about this opportunity was based upon the work that Mono County had already done with Chris, they were able to move up the build out of four sites planned for the summer. The equipment's been ordered, the sites are ready. And essentially,
43:08 Cal OES is driven to establish radio communication statewide along all the state roads and highways. So what we want to highlight with that is their goal is to provide coverage along really the major interstates and corridors, not getting in-building coverage in towns and municipalities where ultimately both the fire district, police, and your local users need it. So that allowed us to essentially build on the over a million dollars that they were already spending on the system.
43:38 To look at how we could really leverage that to build things out further. So they have this five-year phase map. You can see essentially here phase five was supposed to be Mono County, but like I mentioned, built up and moved up the building of the four sites in that drainage there. So that leads us to when we did our evaluation, we looked at a whole bunch of different sites, which I'll show you a few maps quickly here.
44:03 And we identified that Lincoln Mountain on the ski area and the station number one were ideal locations to provide adequate coverage while leveraging existing infrastructure. Because as was alluded to, the site equipment might be a few hundred thousand dollars, but if we had to build a new telecommunications site up at a mountaintop somewhere, pretty quickly you might be adding a half a million dollars to that cost. So we wanted to look at leveraging the existing sites, which is how we ended up with these two.
44:30 We looked at a whole bunch of different sites. I'm going to blow through these really quickly. I just wanted to put them in here so you could have them to reference. But Mammoth Mountain, looking at how that would do, which wasn't great. We looked at the 8050 building. We looked at what Mammoth Mountain and the fire station would look like. And in terms of portable coverage, it didn't cover town very well. We looked at the new limelight that's getting built. We looked at Lincoln Mountain, Westin, and ultimately,
44:56 We settled on the Mammoth Lakes Fire Station and Lincoln Mountain because as you can see here, this area where we're kind of showing the buildings, the majority of the in buildings, the majority of the buildings in your town and fire district area would be covered with in building coverage. And this is just some parameters that we use at the bottom. And then we looked at how some other sites in the future getting added in terms of covering.
45:24 The corridors around there. And the long and short, the total predicted coverage for the town and the fire district boundaries, as you can see, is pretty great utilizing those two sites. So we went through a big exercise. We spent many weeks on it. Like I said, those slides will be available for you to reference. But ultimately, the goal is to provide the public safety standard, which is 95% coverage in all of your buildings within the town, the town boundaries. So essentially, the law enforcement and other users will have.
45:54 So where does that leave us today? In June, we're hoping to do some site walkthroughs with the Cal OES team to come out, look at the existing site, see if we need to make any minor improvements or upgrades to either Lincoln Mountain or fire station number one. The goal is to have site equipment ordered sometime next month or quickly thereafter. And then also today I had a phone call with Nate from Mono County.
46:23 And we've had some emails that have gone around where we want to put together a stakeholder planning meeting to essentially look at, even though the county may not be ready today to move, but what does this look like in the future in terms of interoperability, sharing talk groups, sharing channels. So we're looking at trying to get together a meeting in June as well when I come out for my next site visit. Discussing interoperability, we're working on what the cutover plan looks like.
46:48 Ultimately, we're trying to get the equipment ordered in June or July for delivery over the winter for installation early next spring. My goal would be that we are ready to migrate to the new system at this time next year, which, believe it or not, is a pretty quick migration to a new radio system. Often these things take 18 to 24 months. That'll put us closer to the 18-month time frame. And looking back is when we started this project about six months ago.
47:17 And then one of the things that we had some preliminary conversations with Nate and the county about today was what integration with dispatch looks like. So they have the ability to provide the dispatch services that we rely on them for. And then one of the big steps will be evaluating and selecting the subscriber units and subscriber units are the actual radios that the police and fire and road and bridge and other users will actually have in their vehicles and in their hands. So going through an evaluation, getting that equipment over.
47:45 I know I blew through that really quick. I was told to try and keep it around five minutes. So I'll stop there and open it up to any questions with you all. Okay. Council, questions? I'm trying to figure out how much this is costing. Free? Because it's a state system? No, it's not free. I mean, it'll be, we're paying for stuff to build and equipment. They're doing some install for us for some savings there. Ultimately, then we'll have to do all the handhelds and in-car radios that we'll have to purchase.
48:16 And then depending on the investment side, there's an ongoing level of subscribing into the state system, but there's a discount depending on the amount of investment we make. And again, until everything's ordered and set up and what we know on the sites, it's kind of unknown. That's why we've been setting aside funding for it. And, you know, if we actually have extra funding on that, the other element would be to take a look at the Hemlock sites at Bada Ameth Mountain so you can actually get into Red's Meadow.
48:42 Some stuff of that nature, which would be a little longer outreach, but because we provide services into there and we're often, the folks down there, that's one area with very weak radio coverage at this point. I wish you could speak to that as well. However, Dan, important to note that part of the reason we're going with Chris, unless I misunderstand it, is because it's a $20 million system that is going to cost us significantly less, maybe 10% of that.
49:08 So that is built in, and Dan, I don't know if it's the appropriate time or not, but Dan and I did meet with our Assembly Member, Frank Bigelow's office. We met with Frank himself. We didn't expect that, but that was very nice. I had a coughing fit. I'm sure they all think I made them all sick by the time I left, but we also met with staff of State Senator Bigelow to ask if they couldn't move some money.
49:35 Towards this project for us in their earmarks because the state has this huge budget surplus. I don't know if anything will come of that, but hopefully it will so that we can put the site on Manfred Mountain. Yeah, I can say that something in Bigelow was very interested in that because his experience on Madera's site and the fact that that Reds and that whole area back there is just quite a challenge if you don't have good systems. So we get a lot of people down in our Reds Meadow area.
50:04 Borges' office, we just met with staff there and we did follow up with correspondence to them. Councilwoman, if I could just add and kind of clarify my earlier statement. So the original system, if we built it just as a county.
50:20 Would have been roughly 20 million, but that's also considering the ongoing cost. So there's a couple of considerations. It's really hard to put an exact number on this other than it really does seem to be a great bang for your buck, if I could call it that. What this system does by tying into Chris is it kind of creates that backbone going up the 395, and then we're just kind of filling in the communities. And so that's where you get that leverage to, you know, buy into it and really get something out of it. What I'd recommend, what I'd say the fire district should be doing is
50:49 We have to recognize that the reason we're in this room today is because we have 30 years of not making the proper capital expenditures. This is something that Nate's hit on quite a few times. And if we have additional funding left over due to things like the Assemblyman's funding coming in, we're going to be putting that towards capital expenditures. Because the reality is this is a system that has to be maintained. You have to keep it up. Otherwise, we're going to be seeing the exact same situation, not in five years, but certainly in 10. Kirk, did you have any questions?
51:21 I have a couple, Elish. So, everybody, we're talking about the town, okay? Do we know that the county is going to do this? So, yeah, I can speak to that and fill in a couple of points as well. I'll start by saying that I'm really excited and pleased to see the town arriving at the same conclusion that we arrived at a couple of years ago. This is a recommendation that my team came
51:53 Actually, Chris came to us as we were looking for solutions, and Alish said it very well. The federal engineering plan was used as a benchmark around what it would take to go this alone. So, excuse me, so Chris came after we did that study? Correct. They had plans in the works leading up to that, but as Jeff said, we were at the back end of that. And basically, through a number of conversations that my team had with OES,
52:21 They expedited the work on the sites in the Eastern Sierra in order to effectively meet our demands and our urgency. So things kind of slowed down for the county as a whole, and I think actually the county and the town at that point were working through governance and technical working groups to try to have an efficient path toward adopting and implementing Chris as our system of choice. Initially, the numbers that we were sort of coming up with
52:49 To build a couple of infill sites in Mammoth as well as I think four others throughout the rest of the county were about five million dollars and that included not just the site built but the need to buy radios for belts and vehicles. Over the last year plus the conversation has continued to evolve and I think the town rightly sort of
53:15 I don't want to say broke away from the county, but recognized an opportunity to move more efficiently than we were because money had been put aside and ultimately that money is being allocated for a couple of these infill site builds in town. So that's great and I think it's put additional pressure on the county as a whole. Our biggest problem is that we still probably need about three sites.
53:40 to get the coverage to the level that we have more or less today with our existing system and or meet the rough basic need that we have. And we also are trying to take the 11 unincorporated fire departments under our wing, essentially, because their capacity to self-fund largely the radio replacements that are needed to access the system is relatively nonexistent.
54:09 As we're kind of sharpening the pencil, so to speak, the number is kind of closing in around three and a half million without the town, with the town going after the two sites on their own and the radio replacements that are needed. We're trying to look a little more proactively at whether we can do some different things with sites, much like Jeff was saying, instead of building a...
54:31 Brand-new site, you know, from a Greenfield or Brownfield state, leveraging other locations, certainly bringing some of those costs down and increasing efficiency. And really what we're hoping is CA Lawton has put in a federal earmark request now two years in a row, and it sounds like Obernolte's office is favorable. We don't know yet as to whether or not that will come through, but if it does, we'll have roughly a 12-month window.
54:58 To do site construction and purchase subscriber units. And I'll say that we've been already purchasing radios that are Chris compliant and Chris ready. We've got about 130 in our fleet now of I think about a total of 600 radios that we need. So we're chipping away at that. And our intent, regardless of the site builds, is once those sites come online later this summer, we'll start testing and having a better understanding of coverage and things like that.
55:27 So the last thing that I'll say is in terms of the ongoing economics, and I think Alish was sort of referring to this, is, you know, we, you say a $20 million investment or a $15 million investment in capital that's going to have a 20-year life cycle, you know, you do the math on that and you're needing to put away capital in order to maintain that and replace that infrastructure over time. This is pennies on the dollar for us. I mean, our subscriber fees are a few hundred dollars per radio per year. It's a very, very low,
55:57 Price Point. It is a ongoing recurring cost, which gives us a flat budget. And our rough estimates are several hundred thousand dollars a year annually. I think with the town in, it was maybe like four hundred thousand dollars a year annually that was not only paying subscriber fees, but also putting money away for life cycle replacements on radios. So it's, you know, roughly 50 percent in terms of what we would be looking for.
56:24 From an operating cost standpoint, if we were to build it on our own. And it is far surpassing any of the functionality that we were seeing in any of the designs that we were putting out there. So it's a real, real good opportunity for us. And I think what we're trying to do at the county level is just to sort of overcome a few of those initial hurdles so that ideally we can all move onto the system at the same time. Some of the complexities that we're still working out is if the town is
56:53 Indeed, you know, six months to 12 months ahead of the county, there are some challenges that come in terms of operation with dispatch and things like that. All of it, you know, they're details, but ultimately we're trying hard to stay together and aligned on it, and I think this is really our goal as well. Okay. When you're talking, sometimes I get a little confused about is we the large we or is we the town or is we the county?
57:21 Yeah, and I think we're working that out.
57:49 I think there are ways that that can be overcome at the end radio, the subscriber unit level effectively where the town's primary use would be Chris, but the ability to access the county system would still be there. And it's very possible that this will be a bit of a transitional effort for all of the subscribers.
58:16 Mammoth Fire in the town may kind of make a hard cut to the Chris system. There is likely the need to leverage the county system for a while until we've fully transitioned everybody over. And so this is something that we're working through the details on. And the best case scenario is that everybody will move together. And in the case that the town is ahead of the county, then we'll come up with some plans to make sure interoperability still exists.
58:46 Mayor, if I could add to that, I would just be blatantly honest, there are no perfect solutions in this. We've spent three years working with agencies and end users that are fairly involved. I think having Jeff and Elk Mountain, who's done this in multiple locations, is really going to help us through that transition. One of the positives of this system is it ends up being P25 compliant, which essentially is kind of a communication standard for public safety.
59:14 Just to give some perspective, INYO was in a similar situation where this is an incredibly expensive thing to fund. They ended up going a different direction, which we explored as well, which is basically they're using a private subscriber model. And I've already spoken to end users that are having issues because these things don't talk to each other. I'll be blunt, we don't control the feds. They're going to stay on their system. It's not going to be perfect. It's not going to be as seamless as you get on your phone and you just hit up another phone number. There will be problems with it.
59:44 It's kind of the nature of just the decentralization of communications at this current state, and we are taking that very seriously, especially as end users, because everybody knows that whenever there's a critical incident, there's actually fatalities or anything like that. Communications always comes up at the top of the list as far as the problem. That being said, we do believe that long-term, this is the best system. There's some law enforcement, things such as encryption that are going to make it very good.
1:00:13 There's future technologies that this ties into where we can actually track individuals potentially and things like that that we really are setting ourselves up kind of for that next level system if that makes sense. And it will be good but your concerns are well warranted. So just one quick question. So for wildfire, are we better, worse, the same in terms of dealing with the feds?
1:00:42 Will be essentially the same because it's already complicated. I'll leave it at that. You know, there's obviously different jurisdictions and what ends up happening is you end up moving over to the channels that get used by the authority having jurisdiction. Usually for wildfire, that's going to be the Forest Service. Even if they're coming into our area, we're going to be on multiple channels. Fortunately, the nice thing about the way the Chris system is getting set up here is it's going to be on the VHF frequency. So there will be abilities to work on that.
1:01:12 What that looks like for the end users for switching radios is still needs to get worked out there. We really try to keep systems as simple as possible because we have these high impact events like wildfires and we have end users, we have a lot of volunteer districts or part-time districts like Mammoth Fire that don't deal with that on a regular basis. So when you add complexity to a high risk event, you're making things bad.
1:01:36 It is one of our main strategic priorities is making sure there's a system that's as easy to use as we can do within the budget and operational constraints and kind of the realities that we live in. So I think, Nate, I think Zone Haven, are you familiar with that? Yeah, we're working on implementing that currently. And will that, that will fit into this to the degree that it can or? It all fits, yeah. So, I mean, there is a lot of convergence that are happening at the state around them.
1:02:04 There's a variety of these different systems, and some of it's kind of esoteric, but, you know, what's happening with the state investment in broadband is a very top level. The commitment to NextGen 911, it's leveraging a lot of those same networks. This Chris system is leveraging a combination of those networks. There is a nexus that is sort of aligning around these things and leveraging, frankly, a lot of the technologies and investments that we've made.
1:02:33 And so from that standpoint, I feel very comfortable with the trajectory that it's on. I think Alish's comment about VHF is really germane. When Chris first approached us, basically their proposal was for us to move to a different band, to move to 800 megahertz, which is the same thing that CHP and Caltrans or others are using. And we flat out said no. It's a non-starter for us because of
1:03:00 And I think what we're seeing with that commitment to that, with the commitment to integrate with FirstNet and look at how all of these other technology pieces start to coalesce, the next handful of years are going to be really interesting and I think the
1:03:29 The technologies that we're embracing from dispatch all the way down to the people in the field are going to be able to leverage all of that stuff. Well, it's certainly more reliable than when the only person we had was Nielsen, remember? So this is a lot better. So we're getting there. Thanks for that. Thank you. Thank you.
1:03:54 Thank you. Really on this, thank you, Jeff, as well, for joining in. We really did, as this is a major expenditure item over time, and it is complicated, and it's multi-jurisdictional, so the goal on some of these is to keep the council updated and informed of how we're going and how we're moving through it, so you get it in bite pieces over time versus, hey, look, we got a new system. But anyway, I think it's really good, and yeah, pretty excited about it. I think that takes us to the consent agenda. Sorry? Oh, yes, thank you, Ted. Good idea.
1:04:35 Is there any public comment? Okay. John asked a question regarding finances and funding, and you didn't answer it. So I want you to answer it with real numbers, and then I also want to know if it's, is this budgeted for this year? Is the potential expense in that budget that Rob's going to present later, or how does it, how does that work? Yeah. I can't, yeah, thank you, Ted.
1:05:04 The bottom line actual total cost is not known yet because we're still going through the analysis. We're still looking at the equipment. We're still looking at subscriber units. The initial estimate for the town element was $1.5 million. We have currently put in the budget $1.25 million. $1,250,000 is in our capital program. And so we're moving through that. And as mentioned, we're out of ways in the final implementation if we need additional funding.
1:05:33 We'd come back with a request for that. But our goal was a target at 1.5, and that was based on a very rough estimate of cost. So if we can achieve that within that budget, then we're doing well. We've made the additional ask from the legislative side, which could actually enhance the overall system if we get that additional funding. Like I mentioned, if we could get something there, we could talk it in the Reds Meadow area better. It would be a great enhancement to our public safety side in those particular difficult mountainous areas.
1:06:02 For the main coverage element, yeah, 1.25 set aside, 1.5 is our goal to have that. I think the fire district could set aside $300,000 as well for funding on that, and then the county's working through its funding side. But so we're moving it forward on that and begin setting that money aside. When we first started this process, we were not sure what the ultimate outcome was going to be, but we knew it would be expensive.
1:06:29 And how much was he asked to the legislative representatives? We asked $750 to $1 million. And that's for additional? Ideally, that would help if we could get another site with the Hemlock site, if you will, with Mammoth Mountain. If not, it could offset the costs that we're incurring. And Madera County, are they? They don't have any radio communication or very little into there, I believe. But we're really doing this for protection of our first responders. And also, we do a lot of...
1:07:00 Responding with ski patrol and coordination that way and having that type of communication that would tie into their system as well in the mountainside would be helpful. Okay. Any other public comment on that? One comment I'd like to make, Linda. Sure. Ted, thanks for asking that question. Important because I push this all the time. Over the last six or seven years, we've changed the way the town runs its budget. And because of that, we have been able to foresee stuff like this and set the money aside in advance to have to do it.
1:07:32 While in an emergency it could be, you know, moved to other purposes as anything else. It's important for the public to understand that we have put ourselves in this position to get through a COVID and to have money for this type of, I mean, this is bordering on an emergency at this point. And if the county can't move forward, at least as a town, we can move forward on our own to see to it for the protection of our own people. All right, thank you, Bill. Now I'm off my soapbox. Thank you. Thank you. All right.
1:08:01 Moving on then to consent agenda. We have item 7.1, approve the minutes of the regular meeting of May 4, 2022. 7.2, authorize a professional service agreement with Michael Baker International for Environmental Consulting Services related to the Mammoth Lakes Foundation Development Project. And item number 7.3, accept payment approval report number 22-46 and accept payment approval number 22-46.
1:08:32 Madam Mayor, I would propose, I would move that we approve the consent agenda as presented. Second. All right. Councilmember Rae? Yes. Councilmember Salzer? Yep. Councilmember Staff? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Salcido? Yes. Thank you, everybody. All right. Policy matters. First item is 8.1, agreement between the Town of Mammoth Lakes and Mammoth Lakes Recreation.
1:09:00 Dan, I think you're going to... Yeah, thank you. I'll kick it off, and then there are representatives of Mammoth Lakes Recreation here who can speak to the item as well. You do have a proposed agreement that would be for the next fiscal year, July 1 through June 30. The financial structure of the agreement is the same as it was previously. There's no change in compensation from last year. It's, I think it's $90,500 was the number that's in there. What we did work on was, and it was presented to the council in some discussion,
1:09:30 Workshops. Looking at the scope of services and deliverables, very similar to last year. We've done a little bit of cleanup on it, added a couple little items in here. I think last year, actually, and I think we saw that in the review of the deliverables, the process and the program seem to work very well between the town and Mammoth Lakes Recreation. The location of their staff person, Kim, in the town offices providing space has really enhanced the communication with
1:09:59 Our trails group and with Parks and Recreation. And so the structure, again, pretty much follows previous years. We added in some work in assisting with some trailhead planning. We put that in here, if you remember, as part of the capital program. We wanted to take a look at what does it take to enhance our trailhead amenities. We didn't fund the amenity work, but we want to go out and look through planning work and say if you have these different nodes and different access points.
1:10:27 What's required there to really make them more user-friendly? Is it a bike rack? Is it a restroom? Is it a parking area? Is it signage? Is it dog waste receptacles? You can kind of fill in the blank on what that could look like, but having to go through and take a look at those areas. We're not looking at the capital side now, but having some assistance in just what is our user experience and what are people looking at? It could be a snowmobile staging area. It could be other things of that nature as well.
1:10:55 So our team will be taking the lead on this for assistance with MLR to be beneficial, especially in the outreach, like in the website work and the newsletter work and also just in talking with the user groups. Then we cleaned up some other elements in here in terms of some of the process stuff. They do a great job in terms of the advisory work with the committees for the programming expenditures. Kim mentioned that earlier in our presentation. A lot of work goes into that and I know the people that are funded through that program are...
1:11:24 Very much thankful for the additional support and work and then the additional grant this year that was received by MLR as well. That non-profit arm has allowed us to go after some of those types of grants. The arts one is that work as mentioned from LAWP and we've also had other funding come in through them for work on the trail system. Overall, I think it went pretty smooth this year compared to a year or two years ago.
1:11:49 I'll ask Craig Albright. He's the chair of the MLR board. He's joined us in the audience. If he wants to make any comments, Craig, come on up. And or Kim, if you want to speak as well, stand behind him and prop him up. But it's actually, I think it's been a pretty smooth process this year with Mammoth Lakes Recreation. And I can say the work accomplished last year and even into the last part of this year has been beneficial. Thank you, Dan. Craig Albright, Mammoth Lakes Recreation Board President.
1:12:19 As Dan highlighted, you know, we went all went through a pretty tumultuous couple of years. First of all, it's great to be in person and not see your faces on the screen. And but, you know, we've really built, you know, the work that we did a year ago with council members Wentworth and Sauser and a small group of the MLR board really got us back on track. And we were pretty far off track.
1:12:48 At that point, and for a variety of reasons. And so we really are looking forward to over the next year building upon, you know, the three big pillars of collaboration, providing value for the town and rebuilding the trust between our two organizations. And so looking forward to doing that, coming back before you, hopefully in a year's time, looking at a longer agreement.
1:13:13 You know, we really looked at this, taking these last year and this year as a time of, you know, kind of rebuilding our relationships and finding ourselves, if you will. And I think we're on the right track and looking forward to working with you and hear for any questions you may have regarding the item in front of you this evening. Any questions? Why don't you go ahead and do comments? I'm sorry. I was going to add one other item to this, as mentioned, especially this next year coming forward.
1:13:44 With the standing up of the Office of Outdoor Recreation. That relationship this next year I think will really help inform where we're looking at as we go into the future of that. And then also I was going to note the board discussed this at their May 3rd meeting. Remember Ray is our representative to the MLR board. She was at the meeting and stuff. So I was going to ask her if she had any comments related to the discussion at the board meeting that she wanted to bring back to the.
1:14:11 Town Council regarding the agreement structure and the elements there. So Sarah put you on the spot there a little bit, but I know you were part of the discussion. No, I don't think I have any additional comments at the moment. Thank you, though. Okay, thank you, Sarah. Oh, go ahead, Bill. Well, Dan stole my thunder. I am looking forward terribly to how we can even move beyond where we are today and really get back on track with the original expectations, having created the Office of Outdoor Rec and working together.
1:14:41 More closely, I have made no secret of the fact that I believe our NGOs have strayed far from the town path and looking for ways to bring them back in so we are working more collaboratively and working together harder. I think we are getting there with MLR. I think Kim is doing some great work. So thank you, as always, and the board for going along with all of this change and it has been pretty radical change over the last year.
1:15:09 But I think going forward, this can be a great relationship. Great. Thanks, Bill. John? Yeah, to echo a little bit what Bill's saying, and Dan, I guess my question is, when is the officer of outdoor recreation, when does that person report for you? The first day will be June 6th. June 6th. Okay, I'm assuming that, Dan, from your office, you're going to provide the type of support and coordination to get everybody...
1:15:37 Talking to each other, figuring out what the roles and responsibilities are going to look like, right? Yes. Okay. That's going to be important. Obviously, we have a new district ranger. There's a lot of stuff happening. So I think the leadership coming out of the administration is going to be really important to work with MLR, work with the trails program, work with the staff and everybody to get everything lined up so we can get to build the kinds of things you're talking about. It's needed more than ever, but again, we're going to be looking at you a little bit to make sure we get all this stuff lined up properly.
1:16:10 I know for the comments, I think it sounds like we're, like everyone said, right path, right way to go. A few new things added to the deliverables. Was there any other things on the deliverables we wanted to highlight beyond the assistant trailhead planning effort that's changed from last year's scope? There was nothing that jumped out, you know, outside the scope and responsibilities that, you know, we felt comfortable with. You know, the idea that
1:16:40 You know, there's the clause in there that as special projects or if something comes up that we can negotiate those things and, you know, I think puts us in a good position to, you know, be able to pivot and particularly in light of, as council members highlighted, you know, with New Forest Service Ranger, the Office of Outdoor Rec, you know.
1:17:05 All those things, you know, having the clause in there that, oh, we really need to go this direction and here's how MLR can help, you know, I think puts us in a good way. We had an agreement last year, but the example of that was the support on the Prop 68 grant for Whitmore Park, which required a non-profit to be the applicant. And so we worked closely with MLR in that application, waiting to hear on the outcome. But if something like that came up that we could not foresee, that would be a discussion point to go back and say, hey, how much help do we need?
1:17:37 Yeah, just one other point. We're using the word recreational a lot here, but the fire component of this is going to be huge. The S&C Board meeting, which I think
1:18:10 I'm sure you're aware of is happening June 1st and 2nd. The tour for that will be on June 1st. And the focus of that tour is going to be the integration of recreation, programming, infrastructure, and all the rest of that with fire management. And that's going to be a very big deal. There's a lot of money coming out of the state that's specific to wildfire. There's money in the state around recreation, but it's a little bit more sort of nebulous and amorphous at this point.
1:18:36 But what we're doing in Mammoth Lakes is a case study. It's a test case for that integration of recreation values, programming, infrastructure with fire, wildfire fuel treatments. There can be some people at that meeting. I think the lead staff person for the California Wildfire Resilience Task Force is going to be there. They're going to be looking what the S&C is doing with this. Also a guy named Steve Frisch from the Sierra Business Council, which is...
1:19:00 Probably going to be involved in the SURF program, where a lot of money's going to be flowing through that as well. So I know what your schedule's like. I think, Kim, I think we talked, you may be able to make it on the tour, but this is all these sectors coming together, which, frankly, I think we're doing in the town. We're taking a lead on that, is bringing multiple partners, institutionalizing that. So it's a great opportunity to start showcasing the things that we're doing. All right. On that note, if there's no other council comments, any public comment? I see none. So we have a recommended motion. Would anyone like to?
1:19:36 Thank you. Thank you.
1:20:12 Yes. Councilmember Salzer. Yes. Councilmember Stapp. Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Wentworth. Yes. Mayor Salcido. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes 5-0. All right. Item number 8.2, discussion of draft deliverables for the Mammoth Lakes housing contract. And Sandra. Yes. Thank you so much. So as you stated, this item is a discussion item to allow the council to discuss draft deliverables for the Mammoth Lakes housing contract.
1:20:41 As you recall, earlier this year, we had a joint meeting with the Mammoth Lakes Housing Board. Sandra, hold on a second. Is your microphone on? It is. It is. It's not. I don't think it works. It's not working. Try the next one. Can you hear me now? Yeah. Can you hear me, Sarah? I can hear you. Okay. That's better. I think it's. Okay. Yeah. Sorry. Closer the better. Okay.
1:21:05 Thank you. So as I stated, this is an opportunity for the Council to discuss the draft deliverables with Mammoth Lakes Housing. We had a joint meeting earlier this year. We came up with some priority areas that the Council had desired to include in the contract. And there was a recommendation from Council to really reduce the kind of, not the scope of the contract, but make it more brief, make it more summarized, get more bullet points, just have it be a really kind of
1:21:35 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
1:21:58 The priority items that were established by Council, we included those in there. And we did carry forward a couple things from the current contract with Mammoth X Housing. And so I'm happy to walk through all of these if you'd like. We were suggesting a one-year contract to start on this. However, I know Patricia from Mammoth X Housing is here and would like to speak on that and is looking for possibly a longer contract just due to the time that it takes.
1:22:23 Yes, thank you.
1:22:53 So you're referring to Exhibit A, correct, Sandra? Correct, yeah. Bill, what do you think? Do you need to walk through the whole thing or just questions? I don't think we need to walk through the whole thing. There's a few things. And as I said previously with MLR, I think that perhaps our MGOs and town are not working as closely together as they should or could in collaboration and a lot of other things. It is taxpayer money. Those of us sitting up here have the responsibility.
1:23:21 And I am looking over this deliverables from last year, as I did a couple years ago with MLR, and there are some things, deed restrictions that are town deed restrictions going over for the management that didn't happen, and there's a few things in here that didn't happen. So I always question that. The new, I was a little concerned, although I have had time, a lot of time with Dan and Sandra both, on the brevity,
1:23:51 If we didn't get done what was in this, the brevity of the current process are deliverables. So I would suggest at least a change in how the reporting comes back to us. So if there was a reason that the deed restriction part didn't happen, that should have come back to us and said, look, this doesn't work in our deliverables. We would like to change it to this. That's part of how we are not working together closely enough.
1:24:21 I don't, as a person spending that money, I don't really know what's going on or why things are changing. As we often see with a lot of our NGOs, I'm not asking for a dog and pony show where you come up with a PowerPoint presentation telling me how wonderful you are. I am looking for specifics of here's the money the town sent over. How is it being used and how is it being leveraged?
1:24:46 And are we getting the biggest bang for the buck? You've heard me say a lot. If I can bring something back in-house and I can do it for less money than what it takes an NGO to deliver it, then that's the direction I want to go. No, you know, this isn't a personal thing. It's not a vendetta. It's me trying to do the best I can with the tax dollars coming into the town. So my position would be to try and go for a one-year contract, see if we can do better.
1:25:15 On the coordination and on the report backs to the council and staff and see if we can't creatively have other ways. MLR being in the town offices has created much better continuity. I don't know that we can't do something like that with MLH. It would have to be looked at. I know they have their own offices and would appreciate staying there. But anything we can do to increase that collaboration.
1:25:42 And make us all part of the same team instead of the public thinking that we're working across points. We have a great Housing Now program the town has put together and a lot of other things. So that's where I'm coming from, my frustration in not being close enough to these organizations or lack of control over the spending or whatever. I'm not sure how to phrase it, but those are my comments moving forward with this.
1:26:12 So right now we're kind of talking about how we want to approach this, whether we want to walk through the new deliverables as opposed to the old ones because there's a loss of, what, three pages of dialogue, which is what we asked, is that it be simplified. A question I have is that in June of 22, this present contract is over. And at what point do we get a report back from MLH?
1:26:41 Sort of walking us through what they were able to deliver or perhaps not from the current years and then looking to the year forward, you know, that was a piece that we talked about, that there didn't seem to be an answer to a lot of things. I know that things have changed at MLH, new funding has been received, new staff is going to be hired, what does that say about these deliverables? I mean, I just, and you've been the person, you know, and that's the closest, Sandra, so.
1:27:09 I think it would be good to allow Mammoth Lakes Housing to kind of go through this, take this to their board, and then we could ask the board or Patricia to bring that back when you consider the contract. I mean, I think it's appropriate there to talk a little bit about the shift, talk about the previous contract, what they were able to complete within the contract scope, what they were able to complete on the town's behalf that wasn't in the contract scope that resulted in some of those things shifting. I think that would be a good opportunity.
1:27:38 To allow Patricia and her team to do that. As Councilmember Sauser mentioned, they did come before the council and kind of provided during the joint meeting a pretty broad summary of all of the work Mammoth Lakes Housing has done, but I think what you're looking for is a more focused report and here's the contract, you know, item one, here's what we did on this, item two, here's what we did on this, rather than kind of here's the broad things that Mammoth Lakes Housing is doing. And with the way that this
1:28:05 Current scope of deliverables is, that's pretty hard because it's so detailed. Looking at the one that we're anticipating for next fiscal year would be a lot easier to come back and report on that. So somewhere in there, you know, kind of knowing what's going on. The other thing that just personally I'm interested in is the accounting of not time so much as scope of what they're doing. If this is
1:28:35 The deliverables for next year, how many FTEs does it take to get that done? How many people are needed to do what is here as opposed to the whole scope of what MLH is doing? That would be an interesting discussion, I think, to bring back next time. And how is that time reported? Are there time studies, if you will, daily time accounting of how...
1:29:04 Today I did some work for Alpine, I did some work for Inyo, and I did this much for the town, because I know that there's, you know, several funding streams now going into MLH. And they do track their time. We used to, with their monthly invoices, get a copy of their timesheets, and we changed the contract last year to, those timesheets are available upon request, so if we wanted to pull the timesheets, we could pull them, take a look at that, or, you know, we could request that, maybe they put together a
1:29:33 You know, pie chart or just some sort of a summary of their time. I'm not sure how difficult that is, but they do track all of their time for all their projects, so I think it's not super difficult to pull that information together. I'm just saying that, you know, Mammoth Lake Housing, the doors open, people come through constantly asking questions and, you know, providing directions with the town, who to go to with the town or the county, you know.
1:30:04 It's really hard to try to, you know, put it into a time frame and, you know, a labor aspect, you know, how to do it. All I'm saying is that those doors are open, you guys, the council welcome, Ted's welcome to come in and sit through a day and see the volume of people that just simply come through that are looking for a place to live.
1:30:32 As well as what's available and what are the resources. So, I mean, it's a real information source as well as a place for people to find housing. And it's getting, it's becoming more acute. And I think the council is well aware of that. And especially with what we're doing on the parcel. I mean, you know, people are lining up for those 80 units.
1:31:01 I mean, they just, they'll be, as soon as they turn key, they're filled. I mean, that's the reality. I'm sorry for getting on my soapbox here a little bit, but this has been something I've worked on for a long time. Thank you, Kirk. So, I've got a couple thoughts here. Sandra, I would like, if you wouldn't mind, going through just the high-level numbered items here.
1:31:31 Don't have to go into detail what the town expectation is for these things. So when it comes back from the MLH board, you can give us a sense of is this working, flying, whatever. And I think to Bill's point, I think it's also really important that when we get reporting back from as a client and a contractor, that the reporting that comes back is to the things that are on this page here. And I think there was a pretty profound disconnect at the last meeting about
1:32:00 Those things are not being talked about. We need to get on the same page with that. And at some point I'd like to hear from MLH about, we have to do it today, but maybe this comes back, about how MLH is structuring itself to contract with other agencies, how they're anticipating their workload and their change throughout the region is going, and how that may or may not affect the services they're providing. So if you could just walk, just high level number one, number two, we're thinking this, we're thinking that. Okay.
1:32:31 So number one is continue to provide overall management and support for Mammoth Lakes housing services and providing information to community members. So this is really kind of the baseline service that Councilmember Stapp was referring to, keeping the doors open, maintaining an updated website, and providing information on housing-related resources.
1:32:53 Staff suggested that the Mammoth Lakes Housing could consider some training programs to train some of our community members to help provide those answers so that they could enhance their service with maybe some unpaid ombudsman, something along those lines. The next item was two homebuyer education classes or other training opportunities annually. That's a pretty easy one to measure.
1:33:20 The third item was creation and preservation of deed restricted units. This has been kind of the bread and butter of Mammoth Lakes Housing using a revolving loan fund to preserve, sorry, I'm sorry, am I not going through the item that you wanted, Councilmember? Okay, I'm sorry, no, I was looking at the wrong thing, sorry. Okay, so.
1:33:42 Preservation of deed restricted units. So that's using the artwork revolving loan fund, the bridge program to add new deed restricted units to our pool and looking at other funding sources to develop new programs and provide additional deed restricted unit. Item four is develop and maintain a wait list for both renters and owners and proactively matching households with the appropriate units. So really and then really getting out there and marketing that program.
1:34:12 To try to get people into homes across the community. Item five is looking for more grants, bringing more money to our community to produce more homes in Mammoth Lakes. So that's continuing to look at those traditional sources like CDBG and home, but exploring nontraditional sources.
1:34:35 And the Home Key Project is a good example of a non-traditional source that we've never received funding for. But just really kind of keeping their eyes peeled for different ways to bring more money to our community. And then really actively managing, reporting, tracking, and promoting that grant funding. So promoting the grant funding to our communities if we have grant funding for certain programs, really getting out there and letting the community know that it's available.
1:34:59 Item six is providing real estate services. This is buying and selling units for town affordable housing programs, including the bridge program and the RLF. And Mammoth Lakes Housing has been helping us with the bridge program units over the past year or so. And then item seven, providing formal updates, at least two per year to the town council on MLH activities, outlining.
1:35:25 With one outlining the coming year's work program. So really, here's what we've done and here's what we're doing next year. If I can comment on that one a little. Perhaps, as I've been encouraging a lot of our non-department department heads to do, a once every three council meetings or something, a staff coming forward from MLH and just giving a brief descriptor of what they're doing and how it's going and changes that need to be made in our...
1:35:53 Reports from Commission and our departments. I'm only one person. But I'm really pushing that for everyone. Hopefully we'll see PD in here doing it. Hopefully we'll see others so that we can stay informed as a council of everything that is going on. If that's appropriate, that is Andy and Dan's purview to, you know, talk to me later and tell me I'm an idiot. But I think that that...
1:36:19 More so than the formal presentations would be helpful for me anyway. I think also it's not in public comments so there can be a little bit of engagement with that which is important. I think what we want the formal was just back to the comment made earlier. Walking through the deliverables. Where are we? And it's more structured in the formal process. But yes, absolutely being able to come in and hey, it's an announcement tonight. I think Sandra did at MLH is doing some celebrations of the recent grants we received. The Homekey grant.
1:36:50 Additional CDBG grant, and additional home grant for the, between the access apartments and the project home key project. So having those types of updates and information, yeah, that can be done either it's in person here, Zoom in person, the hybrid stuff. But as part of that, department had updates that we heard tonight, MLT and MLR and stuff going. And I'm not encouraging them to have a 20-minute presentation during that. These are little, you know, two to five-minute excerpts of what's going on. No one likes a short meeting better than I.
1:37:28 Thank you. Noted. Item 8 is provide ongoing informal updates as appropriate to town council and town staff. That kind of hits on what you're talking about, these informal, you know, coming every third council meeting or so. We do have monthly meetings with Mammoth Lakes Housing and, you know, Nolan and I probably talk to Patricia on and off, you know, almost every day per week. We talk often. So we certainly are.
1:37:54 Communicating well on that. And then the final item is just submitting all documents related to the contract, related to all of our grants, just on a timely basis. And so that's our brief deliverables that we've put together. And as I stated earlier, Mammoth Lakes Housing still needs to take these, take a look at them, have their board review them, and then provide some feedback back to us.
1:38:20 My hope that is since that these are very similar to what we discussed earlier this year, it'll hopefully be an easy process for them and we can get through this before the end of June. I mean, I think it's nice to know that in a couple years, the next group of Town Council members will want more detail. And then you can just keep the prior one ready so you can, you know, flip in a little bit more of it. But another question I have, were we to get, is the job finished where we wanted the listing of all the deed restricted units?
1:38:51 In the inventory. Did we complete that? Like, we know exactly which units are there, which are not, you know, because that was always a question that we didn't quite know that. Yes, we have all of the town deed restricted units, and Mammoth Lakes Housing has all of Mammoth Lakes Housing's deed restricted units. We're working to...
1:39:13 We sent out a bunch of letters. Some of the deed-restricted units, we don't have all of the information on, so we're working to pull information from those. We sent out a bunch of letters to the property owners to just get an update on, we're supposed to be monitoring them annually, so we're trying to kind of pull all that information together. So that is in process, and we expect to have it completed here in the next couple months or so, but it is a project that we are working on. So that would be nice when that's completed to bring that to Council.
1:39:41 Yes. So we can actually see those numbers because it's always been a little bit not clear exactly how many units. The mornings, right? Yes. Yeah. Not losing any, but adding two, rather. Correct. So, Madam Mayor, just one quick follow-up on that. Sandra, when this comes back to us as part of the contract, would it be possible for you and staff to be able to advise Council which components of these integrate and are supporting with the Housing Now program?
1:40:11 So we can really be focused on how we're weaving all this together so it's clear who's playing what kinds of roles. I have a particular interest in the communications piece. The town's done a good job on the town's website. The Housing Now program is listed there. But we still have this, while MLH is over here and the town's over here, we need to really get to one point of context where saying someone's got a housing need, you should go here. It's not, they don't have to go to two different places and try to figure it out. I think that's a particular interest to try to get that.
1:40:41 Not cracked. So that would be helpful if you could do that when it comes back. All right. Is there any public comments on this? Good afternoon, Mayor Salcido and council members. I almost zoomed in and then I remembered that we're in person. So I'm here. Thank you for having this item. I wanted to address some of the council's concerns about our contract last year and some of the, well, number one, some of the deliverables that weren't met.
1:41:18 There were some additional deliverables added to our contract for that time period that we knew we wouldn't be able to accomplish because we've been under the same contract amount for 10 years. We're two full-time staff people. And so when those deliverables were added to the contract, there was an understanding that...
1:41:40 The work could ebb and flow, but there was a likelihood that all of those new items that were added, we might not get to those. So that's an ongoing concern of mine. Last year, the council approved a small increase to our contract, which barely covers the inflation of our costs, including insurance, HOA fees on the properties that we own and manage, and just ongoing staff costs that increase annually.
1:42:10 In terms of staff time, we are two full-time employees at the moment, and the town contract takes up about approximately 85% of their time. And so we are contracting with Mono County and Alpine County to hire two additional full-time staff people. Those staff will be 80% dedicated to those counties and the work that's needed in those counties around housing. But 20% of their time will go towards other projects. That could go towards
1:42:40 Assisting with town contract deliverables. It could go towards some of our new projects that we'll be implementing, Access Apartments and our Project Home Key properties. We're acquiring some additional properties in Mono County and Inyo County, so maybe some of their time will go towards asset management. Client relations will obviously be a big part of the work that they do.
1:43:07 But that's an example of how we can leverage the town contract to grow our staff and actually have more staff time to dedicate to other housing projects. In terms of collaboration, I have to say Nolan and I are a team and we work really well together. We talk daily, I think, approximately. If not, we email daily. So we're in constant communication and I think that we work
1:43:37 The best together than any other staff that's been in charge of the MLH contract. So I think just in terms of efficiency and communication, we're in sync. We also have a monthly meeting with Sandra as well. And so Sandra's well aware of what priority projects we're working on together as a team. And so I think our communication is better than ever from my perspective. Just in terms of a couple of...
1:44:06 Successes that we've recently had that I just wanted to mention to demonstrate the entrepreneurial spirit of Mammoth Lakes Housing, but also how we can leverage the town contract to do more, which we're always doing. We're always doing more. As you know, we spearheaded the bridge program in partnership with the town. That program really evolved from
1:44:33 The moderate income down payment assistance program guidelines that I brought to town council many moons ago when there was some housing reserve funds available for creative solutions. So that program evolved from that and we've worked closely with the town to create more deed restricted ownership opportunities through that program. And that's a new program just, you know, in the past six to 12 months.
1:45:02 During COVID, we fundraised a million dollars for emergency rent assistance, and we were recognized by the Chamber of Commerce as a pandemic champion. And in the last three months, we've received $12 million in grants. Two of those grants are in partnership with the Town of Mammoth Lakes, but not all of them. And so that's another example of how our contract is leveraged to achieve additional funding for our community. My comments on the
1:45:34 Draft contract that you have in your packet I think are on the term. Mammoth Lakes Housing is reaching its 20th anniversary. We are a trusted community partner. Like Councilmember Stapp said, our office is very busy. The phone is ringing off the hook. Clients are coming in constantly, it feels like. And so I think that a one-year term
1:45:58 is really unnecessary, and I would advocate for a four-year term, which is similar to what the Chamber of Commerce received in 2021. I think that it's not a good use of our time or the town staff time or legal counsel's time to have to review a contract on an annual basis when we have such a good track record. And then in terms of a pared-down scope, I know that this council has requested a pared-down scope.
1:46:29 It's not a preference of mine. I think that the issue I have with the pared-down scope is that when it's vague and short, there's always room for you to ask for more. And we're always already doing more. And so I'm a fan of having the scope fleshed out so that we know exactly what we're responsible to do. And there's no gray area for people to ask for more. I think those are all in my comments.
1:46:59 But I'm happy that you are reviewing this tonight and we will have comments from our board and then we can move to approval. Any questions, comments to Patricia? No. Okay. Thank you, Patricia. Thank you. All right. So our, I have another public comment. Oh, good. Okay. Thank you. Sandy Hogan, please unmute yourself and give your comments. I'm unmuted. Okay. Thanks for, Jamie, for all the emails back and forth. My comments, I've been,
1:47:40 You know, watching Mammoth Lakes Housing since it was created. And, you know, the track record is stellar. And yet, I keep hearing comments like, oh, let's do it in-house. Well, you know, the communication is going on, it sounds like, with Nolan every day. And Nolan briefs Sandra if there are questions, I'm sure. But, you know,
1:48:10 What I've seen over these years is we didn't even have a contract for many years. You just let the NGOs do what they do best. And I mean, that's when the time was not taken up with the minutia that you are talking about. I know from my own experience, actually, over many years in the Forest Service, when I went from a field job to an office job,
1:48:39 The time spent on the phone is utterly amazing. And I always tracked it, even when I was a district ranger, just because I wanted to know who I talked to and for how long and what it was about. And it's amazing that I think some of you ought to go sit in there, you know, for one day and see, and especially now with the parcel.
1:49:06 I mean, this is so awkward having them have to feel questions about the parcel when they're not contracted to do so. You know, when I had staff, I took a goals and objectives approach. Now, that's an old-fashioned way, but we had usually quarterly meetings. And so, you know,
1:49:36 The goals are what you want to do. The objectives are how you plan to get there. And that quarterly meeting gave me a chance to go over, you know, and hear why staff couldn't do something. And sometimes it's things beyond their control. And that's the kind of thing I think it sounds like there's communication between Mammoth Lakes Housing and Nolan.
1:50:05 And good communication, I assume, between Nolan and Sandra. And so maybe what you want to do is take that approach, you know, a little more general goals and then objectives, you know, you spell those out. And then if you can't do them, you understand why. And it doesn't have to be the council understanding all of this.
1:50:33 If Patricia is talking to Nolan and obviously to Sandra once in a while, I mean, the council should not be trying to manage real estate. That's a whole different field. And believe it or not, I did that for two years. And it taught me how complicated the land things are. And like the monitoring, they're trying to get the information so they can monitor.
1:51:03 These deed restrictions, you know, and they took them over from the town, a lot of those. So I would say, oh gosh, this tracking time and timesheets, I mean, oh my gosh, talk about distrust of the organization that has brought you millions and millions and millions of dollars. Anyway, I get frustrated because when I hear this, I did listen to the chamber.
1:51:32 And I know that they have an agreement. It's not called a contract, I don't think. It's called an agreement, at least the meeting I listened into. And exactly, it's three or four years. So I mean, this idea of an annual, if you have any idea of how much time they spend on trying to break down the costs and whatever, I mean, that is absolutely time-wasting.
1:52:02 When you're short, you just have two people. Anyway, if I sound frustrated, I am because it's been, what, 20 years since we've had MLH and they've got a stellar track record. And I mean, you cannot imagine how many people just drop in because I do from time to time. And, you know, I mean, there are always people at the door and calling and if they're Spanish speakers.
1:52:30 You know, you need Spanish speakers, and Patricia's one. I don't know that Diane is. Anyway, just my comments, and thank you for listening, and I'm sorry I'm frustrated, but I think when you have such a great track record, it should be honored and not, you know, not ask for such minutia that takes time. Thank you. Any other questions? So, a question for staff, then.
1:53:06 Does this give you what you need to proceed? I think, yes, it does. It sounds like the council doesn't have any changes to the contract. There's some discussion items, things that we'd like to see when we bring the contract back, but we can bring back these deliverables for you for consideration. So I think what will happen is we'll...
1:53:28 Patricia will take it to her board. We'll come back to you with a recommended contract, and we can include, if there are changes from the MLH board, we can include those at that meeting, so you can decide to include those in the contract if you desire. All right. Can we make good of that? All right. Thank you, staff. Thanks, council. Thank you, Patricia. All right. Let's move on here. All right. Now we have the 8.3, waive the first reading and introduce by title only.
1:53:58 Thank you. So you'll recall that we brought this to you at the last meeting just as an informational item so as to give us time to have the policy up on the police department website for 30 days as the law requires.
1:54:24 At the last meeting, the council seemed generally supportive of the policy. There was a request from Councilmember Rae, and I think Mayor Salcido joined in, to add one thing to the policy, which was a requirement that the police department obtain specific authorization from the town council before buying any new kinds of things that would be on the list of military equipment under the state law.
1:54:50 Chief Davis and I talked about it, and we weren't sure that there was a consensus of a majority of the council. We just, we, not sure that there wasn't, but we weren't quite sure. So we put it in the policy. It's in section 706.4. If that's something the council wants to include in the policy, great. If you don't want to include it, that's fine too. But other than that, the policy is the same as what you saw a couple weeks ago. Okay, I, my memory serves a bit differently.
1:55:22 My memory was that we would be notified, you know, and aware that this was happening as opposed to a specific authorization. I guess I'd be back and listen to it, but I don't remember that piece of it like that. Perhaps Councilmember Rae remembers it differently. When I read the policy, I was happy with it. I guess I don't remember exactly what I...
1:55:50 I think, Linda, you said future council people
1:56:19 You know, may have different opinions about it. Right, so maybe I misunderstood, but the sentence that I added in the draft in section 706.4 was intended to capture Councilmember Rae's request that there be something more than just, oh, well, of course they won't buy those things. So that's what this does. It's that if you want to buy something new, something we've never had before, come talk to the council. If you want to tweak that, if you want it to be something different, no problem at all.
1:56:50 Chief, do you have any thoughts on that? Actually, I would like to have that removed because as Councilmember Sauser pointed out, probably 98% of the things on here I'd have to come to council for because my piggy bank is not that big. And I don't want a hamstring future chief that might want to maybe join the Inyo Mono special enforcement team or develop a team here. And the two items I'm just looking at is according to state.
1:57:16 The state law says flashbang grenades. I'm a flashbang instructor. They're not grenades. They're a noise flash diversionary device. There's no fragmentation, nothing like that. And interior gas is a standard use to, you know, hopefully get people out of a house and not so much crowd control. So that's kind of where I'm at. Anything other than that, I'd have to come to you for, you know, $450,000 to buy a bear cat or something like that. And I don't see that any time in the future. So, Andy, what would be one kind of degree less than what that?
1:57:46 I guess something in between would be maybe the department would have to come to the council before buying armored cars. If there are certain things that would be on the list that you don't need the chief to come back to you for, fine, we can take that out. We could just have it be limited to the police department won't buy.
1:58:06 You know, armored drones or armed drones. Yeah, I mean, if there are specific things, Councilmember Rae or anybody else on the dais, that you want to be really clear that not just budgeting approval but specific approval, then we could narrow this down and say, okay, fine, you have to come back to Council and ask really nicely if you can buy these specific things. That would be kind of the compromise between having nothing and having this broad requirement.
1:58:34 Okay, let's hear the council members or how they feel. Sarah or Bill? Sarah, go. Go ahead, Bill. Bill, go. Sarah? Yeah, go ahead. I'm sorry, Al. When you say my piggy bank's not that big, like we're going to go over the budget after this. It's like your piggy bank's pretty big. I just, I just, I take some umbrage at that statement. I don't because most of that is personnel.
1:59:03 You know what, I'm good one way or the other. Frankly, even when we had leaders of our police department that I disapproved of completely,
1:59:37 They weren't so dumb as not to come to council when they wanted to buy something that they knew might cause a stir. I trust that our current chief and any replacement down the road would do the same thing. I have never seen in Mammoth, town-wise, somebody dumb enough to go out and buy an armored drone, as an example, without going to council first because it would cost a job.
2:00:06 I mean, as soon as we got wind of it, we have the ability to go to the town manager and say, this guy's got to go. So we have options. We have many arrows in our quill. So if it is the pleasure of the majority of council to keep that in, it's not a deal breaker for me, but I don't see it personally as being a necessary add-on to the contract, to this item. I don't have any...
2:00:38 I think the one thing we are aware of is that in this universe things are changing and I think, I'm sort of with Bill on this, that if something starts to come up in terms of equipment or hardware or software or computer stuff that's part of the job that the department is doing that is new, that is unusual, that is something
2:01:12 That you think, hey, Council, I think you need to know about this. I would have an expectation that that would come. Because if we were to get a new situation where some new piece of equipment or something was being used, and the first time the Council found out about it was when it was being used, none of us wants to be in that kind of situation. So I guess I'm kind of with you in this. I could go either way with it. But I think we're living in this incredibly rapidly changing environment. And we need to be just...
2:01:44 The favoris of state government. I've read over that whole list, and there are things on that list that frankly just are not military equipment. So if they decide all of a sudden that the pistols that the police department are using because they are not six-shot revolvers are military-style equipment, I don't want them to have to come back to me and ask for that. So I am comfortable with it as it was originally. Not this, but the original. The original, yeah, without the line in it. How do you feel?
2:02:20 Andy, is there a way to kind of speak to the council will be informed as these things are so that we were aware when things were
2:02:29 Sure. I mean, it could either be in the policy that says, you know, the chief shall notify the council, or you could simply give direction to the chief and to the town manager, which I'm sure would be completely faithfully carried out, that you want to know what's going on and that you don't want the PD buying new things that are radically different from what we've got. Or just, you know, as we utilize this policy to buy things, the council would be simultaneously informed as they were ordered. So if it was any, you know, thing.
2:02:58 That was like, oh, wait, wait, we need to talk about that. That would happen. Sure. As opposed to waiting until it was used before we knew it. Yeah, so you can make that standing direction to these two people, or you could put it in the policy either way, whatever your preference is. Okay, what's staff's preference on that? In the policy or direction? I think if there's language in the policy that requires a, we've done that in some of the other resolutions we've done where there is a regular reporting or a requirement to come to council.
2:03:28 It's not so much, if you will, for the two sitting here, but if it sits down the road, I think it starts to say, I bought it, now I'm telling you we bought it, and you're going to go, well, don't use it, well, then we just wasted cash. Well, then why don't we put it in that? So you could have it weigh something, maybe a little softer, but you could definitely have something. I don't think, because just as everybody said, if we're going to inform you of these items before we do it, regardless,
2:04:00 Policy says, yes, you have to come in. Maybe it's informed versus get approval, but prior to doing it, council is informed of it. Maybe that's a little softer term, but then you could also go, thank you, no, we don't want to see that happen. Do you want to, I guess my question is, do you want to veto power over something as we come with it? That would give you more of that versus just telling you, hey, well, that's implied, you know, that's implied that we are informed simultaneously. Well, if we've already ordered it, though, then you're not.
2:04:30 I mean, you're not detail-wise. So what we want to do is then prior to information. I think the prior to thing, and also think, Bill, the point that Bill makes is this is a state policy, and there's some goofy stuff in there. And I think it would be helpful for us, I think, also to understand from the police department's perspective, these things are crazy. We don't want anything to do with this stuff. It helps us understand what state we live in and what kinds of things to expect. I think if we look at services and programs, I think the
2:05:00 The Chief's comment on the, like a SWAT type team going in, so a team going in somewhere and you're going to use other tools and stuff. If we're going to be a part of that, that should come to Council and say, by the way, this team will use this type of equipment. We're letting you know we need to acquire those things in advance, otherwise we're not part of that team. And I think that then we're getting your buy-in on the front end before we actually go do it. And I guess my question to Councilmember Ray, if that addresses
2:05:30 That upfront discussion information. So you'd still have a veto power at that point going, no, I don't think we should go down this road. And I think that's what I was hearing before is that not just informing, but the right, at some point there you could say, no, we don't agree moving that direction versus telling you after the fact, hey, we bought these things. And Dan, forgive me my stupidity here. They are a town department. Yes. So in our purchasing
2:05:58 Rules already, anything over, what, $5,000, we have to... No, if it's budgeted, you can go up to $50,000, so it's a pretty wide range, depending what's in their budget, obviously, and stuff, but it's not, other stuff like that will not come to Council. My other point here is if we get the PD on board with our occasional reporting at Council meetings, I have three minutes or less, Chief, that then they're going to be bringing this stuff forward to us.
2:06:24 Hopefully, anyway. I mean, as I said, they aren't stupid completely. I have to put the caveat in there. So that we are better informed of the tactics that they're looking at and what the changes are. I want to know what the changes are. I mean, I talk to a couple of our officers on a regular basis, but I don't know that everybody does that. So from the graffiti in the tunnel to I would like to know about this stuff, you know, going on. What are the changes and what they're seeing and what they need for enforcement?
2:06:54 But also keeping in mind that this will outlive any of us. And so we want to make sure this policy is not just because we know Dan and I work well together and they talk to you and it's all great. But this needs to be in place beyond that. So I would look at Andy and say, Andy, if you can read back to us what we maybe have babbled up here.
2:07:17 It might be something like the department shall inform the town council prior to acquiring any item on the attached list, which is not a direct replacement for equipment the department already has. Thank you. So moved. Yep. I have a motion. Second. Discussion. Kirk? I'm happy with that. Thank you. Sarah? That's great. Thanks, Andy. You're welcome. So that would be a replacement for...
2:07:47 The sentence that's in the 706.4 of the policy that was distributed to the council. Okay. Any other comments? We have a motion and a second. Jimmy? Oh, public comment. Seeing none. Councilmember Rae? Yes. Councilmember Sauser? Yes. Councilmember Staab? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Salcido? Yes. And thank you, staff. Thank you, Andy. All right. Move along. And thank you, Al.
2:08:20 All right. We're back to fiscal year 22-23, tentative budget. We have now a manager who's recommended budget. Can we ask for a quick break before this? Yes, it is 6 o'clock. Let's do that.
2:09:25 We'll see. Now that we've got Russell, we may even have a chance. That's it. That's it.
2:10:11 That'll be tent-lating.
2:11:07 I am the public.
2:12:35 Thank you.
2:13:07 Thank you.
2:13:30 Thank you.
2:13:58 Thank you.
2:14:29 John, how are you? Me? I'm good. You're keeping everybody calm today. Keep everybody calm. I believe in calm. I believe in calm.
2:15:01 Thank you.
2:15:39 Thank you.
2:16:06 Thank you.
2:16:47 Yeah, he just rejected and signed it down.
2:17:16 Thank you.
2:17:30 Thank you.
2:17:52 I make a motion. We continue with the budget presentation.
2:18:24 I'm getting tired of doing daily COVID tests because I have this too. Just the home tests? Yeah. Anything showing up? No. Good. Okay. Let's proceed then with item 8.4, fiscal year 22-23, tentative budget, manager recommended. And I think Rob.
2:20:09 Thank you, Mayor Salcido, Town Council. This evening we are going to talk about the tentative budget, which is our second to last budget presentation prior to adoption. And this is where we start to fine-tune some elements. But we're pretty much there. If you notice, remember on preliminary, sort of the beginning of things, we're still doing a bit of analysis. We're still trying to figure out some components that are late to come in to us.
2:20:38 And by this stage of the game, that's all been completed. So what I have before you today is a balanced budget. There are not a lot of changes to that, not a lot of updates, much either in here. So I'm going to spend some time on some important aspects. I've gotten some feedback since the last presentation that I'm going to, if you will, take some liberties on adding. I added a slide to the deck, so you guys are going to have one extra one that you don't have in front of you there. But hopefully it's the best slide of the evening.
2:21:07 The fact of the matter is this is sort of our budget for the year. I'm going to say this is really close to where we are. We will be back in the middle of June for final adoption. And during that process, the staff report will contain the rest of the funds that are not present as well as the capital improvement plan that was discussed at our April 27th meeting, the CIP stuff. So all that will be baked into the budget.
2:21:34 And it'll be finalized and put together. So tonight, just a few updates and we'll kind of walk through them. This very first slide is the one that I added that was not there. And it's really based on, you know, sort of comments I've heard or questions that I've had from folks about where, when we talk about the labor and the changes that we have in there, I want to just kind of walk through it in detail because it is, it's in the staff report, but maybe a little bit harder to pick out.
2:22:04 When we look at the budget counts that we have here on the left-hand side where it says full-time employees of 88 this time and 84.3 last time. So what that means is basically from budget to budget, those are the changes. So that 3.7 staff members, one of which was added last year. And so I'll kind of walk through that.
2:22:28 The 3.7 is broken down in the following. So rec supervisor for CRC, that was a new position that we created last or our current budget, 21-22. And we tagged that to start in April of this current year. And that was based upon the CRC being open and available or close to being open. So this person would have a little bit of input in that final stages. We've moved that back now to September, but this position is fully baked into the budget. So for an entire year.
2:22:58 Three that was in there last year was just the fact they were started in April. The point seven is the fact that the increment is that they're in there for there are actually one FTE at this point. So that is that change. The second one is the Office of Outdoor Recreation, that rec coordinator position. So we had last year.
2:23:16 Court of created the department and identified the management team, the rec officer. But this coordinator position came about when the joint position with the county, the Eastern Sierra Recreation Coordinator position, Matt Perillos, that was a county employee that the town participated in funding for. When that shifted and he went back to the county full-time, this position is to backfill those components.
2:23:44 And many of the funding mechanisms we use to provide funding for the county have also been rolled into the funding of this position as well. But that is a, you know, one increment to our staff. And it's really sort of a net, the way it's called is a little different because Matt was not a town employee. The third one there on the list, the engineering technician, this is Riley Griesbeck.
2:24:09 Was added in January of this year. And he's sort of a GIS expert. He's really our technical expert in putting together either maps or systems, things like that that support our construction projects and the administration of that. He's been a tremendous benefit to our team. You've seen some of the stuff that has come out recently. And it's very impactful. But that is a full-time position that was not budgeted last year, but it was incremented this current fiscal year.
2:24:37 And then finally, Public Works Maintenance Worker, we did add a full-time position. And partly is because it's very difficult to find part-time help, especially in this particular category. And so we switched it to a full-time position. We cut a part-time role out of the town as well. And so that's the 3.7 when we talk about our full-time staff growth from this year's budget to last year.
2:25:07 In part-time, there's a lot of fine-tuning and meeting back and forth on hours because this full-time equivalency is measured in 2,080 hours in a year. So, you know, with a part-time, we try to keep them under 1,000. So, you know, that would be a couple of part-time physicians working all year to get to one. But that's how it's calculated. So not going through the immense detail of...
2:25:31 The different part-time pieces, I wanted to focus on the program. So recreation programs, which would include the CRC opening. So that change is 1.8 full-time equivalencies, and that was new programs, some administrative help in that process in keeping that facility. You know, there's just so much more opportunity to run those programs, and that facility being able to open year-round and operating, it's...
2:25:57 Providing more benefit, more staff to support more programs. So it is an increment in programs. The arts and cultures, we talked about that. That 1.7 is actually three positions. There are two facility maintenance, facility coordinator positions, and one site coordinator position. And that's really what we'll be there to clean and staff that facility for being open to our
2:26:27 Plays and other performances that are there. And so those those hours typically of operation are going to be Wednesday, Thursday through Sunday. So these are part time positions. Those three part time positions would support that. And then finally, planning and building counter help. That's that's one part time position for the year. And that's really going to be at the counter to support.
2:26:50 Primarily planning questions, but they can handle building as well. And so it's just better service at the counter for our folks coming in for service. So it says that's an increment of four. There's other some things, some negative items, but I just kind of want to macro, here's the changes in our part-time. And it's really to support, for the most part, some increment with the arts and cultural area, some growth with the CRC, as was expected.
2:27:17 And then on the planning side, just some better service, frankly. So any questions on the labor cost? I mean, labor is by far the most expensive thing for us, topping $15 million this year all in. And so I just wanted to make sure there was real clarity around the changes that have occurred and why they're there. So that's close to seven FTEs against last year.
2:27:42 Yeah, so we went, total FTEs went from 98.2 to 105.7, yeah. Good, great question. Yeah. The arts and culture and those kinds of pieces, I don't believe we've committed to those facilities yet. Is that true? Yeah, that'll be coming up with the agreements to the council here in June for the, this is looking at the Edison Theater primarily on that to bring them into that. So assuming those agreements are in place and we haven't hired anybody yet, so.
2:28:14 I would move forward that way. I'll note on that, too, like Rob mentioned, the two facility-type positions. If we don't have activities going there, one, either they wouldn't be working or we definitely have other work in the town offices. We have work within the CRC and other buildings for maintenance-level, cleaning-level activities. That could definitely be utilized, so it's not a matter of they're there, they're funded there, but the actual usage of them may flux a little bit depending on.
2:28:43 So, Rob, the part-time positions then are non-benefit? That's correct.
2:29:17 Yeah, there's a small 2% PARS contribution which goes into like a retirement plan for them, but it's very small. The rest of it's full salary. And this does not include employees that are paid for like out of Measure R, the trails group? Are they included in this number? No, they're included in this. This would be all labor in all aspects of our budget. So you'll see that Measure R trails section down there, 1.5 to 1.7. No, it's not in my slide deck. Oh, yeah, you're not. Look up here. It's up there. Yeah, thank you.
2:29:49 My reading glasses don't work at that distance. So, yeah, and just on the oxygen culture, you know, good call out on that. It is built into the budget, and it is a general fund department, so it does have the flexibility that Dan was just talking about for funding. So now we're back to where you guys are picking up our previously scheduled time.
2:30:14 What I'd like to do and show just changes what's changed since the last time I presented something to you, and really, frankly, not a lot in this particular one. I try to keep the revenue typically consistent because we've had two bites at that process. The first one we met back in the first part of March talked about revenue projections, and in the preliminary budget we had our revenue with minor adjustments, and typically it's something larger like
2:30:44 And also, as we've
2:31:12 The business tax collection process takes time, you know, to accumulate. And we had, we were lagging behind a little bit when we were talking about this back in February and March, and we've sort of made up that distance. And I had drawn down that revenue stream a little bit in our presentation just to be a bit more conservative. But it's come back, and so I'm adding a few dollars to that. So really, all told, $35,000 in additional revenue, and for those reasons.
2:31:39 That will take our total tentative budgeted revenue up to $27,630,890. And that will match. We balance that to our expenditures for general fund. So that's why I say we're really almost entirely complete with the budget. Just, you know, there's the little elements of adjustment in here, you know, would be in the interest and miscellaneous or building, I'm sorry, business tax components. Everything else has remained the same. We're still at 16.
2:32:09 There are really no adjustments to TOT revenue for penalties and interest, although those have strongly overperformed. It's something that really depends upon the activity. So not a lot to discuss in here. We did receive our property tax notes, and they were in line with our original projections, so I made no changes to that. And again, just to remain a little bit conservative. So there are some elements of this that
2:32:39 I think are warranted for a bit of conservative process. We're looking at some of the real-time data for current year. We're looking down 19% to 20% coming into the next fiscal year as far as reservations and things like that with our lodging community. So there is a little bit of a drawdown. And from where we are at the high this year, going to be close to $26 million. You know, budgeting at $16 million is still well conservative, even with a bit of a slowdown we may see.
2:33:08 What is that slowdown? Based on bookings. And part of the things that we're hearing, two things that we're hearing on that is bookings are happening closer to the stays versus being out further. And they are trailing where they were last year for June by roughly 15 to 20 percent.
2:33:40 The other element, again, this is just a different way of looking at the same numbers. We talked about folks like to be able to quote to me often enough what percentage of, you know, our budget associated with what type. So we go ahead and put this slide in here, but it's still the same $27,630,000,000. And there's visual representation of that. On the expenditure side. Real quick before we, if you could, Madam Mayor. Yes, of course. So I'm sure that we're all aware, we'll watch the governor's press office.
2:34:17 The state of California now has generated the largest budget surplus of any state in the history of the state. And Dan, you and I, we've talked about bringing in some capacity to be able to write grants, to be able to access some of these excesses coming out of the state. And I'm wondering if you could just talk a little bit about that. I think also the issue, Bill, you and Dan were talking to Mr. Bigelow and Senator Borges and people like that. I think we need to make sure that we have the capacity to be equally engaged in talking with those people.
2:34:48 There is so much money. I can't imagine it's going to be spent efficiently, but there's going to be a lot of political pressure to get it out and do something with it. And perhaps you could speak a little bit of that because maybe we could bring some more revenue. We could bring some revenue from the state to help us to cover some of our costs, but perhaps you could speak that way.
2:35:08 So if I may, I'm going to go through the slide, the next slide, which is the expenditure adjustment, which we've addressed that in there. And then Dan can add some components if there's anything necessary on that grant writing side of it. But we have allocated funding specifically for that. So this is the same sort of reconciliation of adjustments to general fund expenditures since our last presentation.
2:35:31 And I will drop down to the third item on there, which is general services grant writing support. So we're allocating $50,000 basically to augment services that we don't have today. And while we have department heads certainly viewing and having visibility to that process, having someone that we have hired to perform those functions is what we've kind of teed up for this. And there's a multitude of ways those are funded. This particular one is basically full-time monthly charges of
2:36:01 I may on that real quick. Yeah, we're looking, we'll get a presentation tomorrow to our department heads, California Consulting. They work with a number of cities. They work with the city bishop, I know. I've been engaged with them in the past in just different, not grant writing, but different work through the League of Cities and other financing seminars and stuff dealing with their work. They're pretty, they're well respected. I know the agencies that utilize them.
2:36:27 They do do a good job of identifying grant areas and different opportunities. And then on our side is also identifying those priorities of the town areas so they can focus. And they do do two different options. It's $4,000 to $4,500 a month, just a flat fee for grant services. Or you can do it on a per grant and an hourly rate. And so we'll walk through that as we bring something back to council for approval. But the idea there would be
2:36:55 If they can do the full-blown, it's taking information from us, but actually write it, administer it, do all the reporting out of it. They do a lot of that support services. And knowing a number of cities, and some of them actually in our division of the league and stuff, where they've actually done a very good job with them in identifying different sources, different qualifying agencies and cities, but it looks like there's stuff in there that we likely could qualify for, having somebody put that time and effort in, and being able to write the grant accordingly.
2:37:25 And their tracking was coming out of the state specifically? Yes, primary to the state, but they also look at some federal stuff. We're now getting, I think it's a weekly update from them, interim-wise, of, hey, here's the different grant services coming out. Here's the different areas that you need to be looking at. And they have more of that if you're contracting with them or some additional services. So this is a group that Inyo County has used?
2:37:50 Bishop has, I don't know if Inu County was using a group that they had hired as a lobbyist and grant working at the federal level, a little bit with the state, I think, but more of the federal focus than theirs was. Actually, I think I met with those folks a couple years ago. We'll get a presentation tomorrow and kind of that field for that. There's some other firms that do this. Again, working with a couple of them in the past and different, these guys are right. Good, thank you.
2:38:32 Looking at the expenditures here that were identified, there really are two incremental, the $50,000 that we talked about for the grant writing support. And then the other one was within the police department utilities. That has climbed up. And so we had about $35,000 in that budget, so it's going to increase to $50,000. And that's really based on current trends. That's where we're going to end up this current fiscal year. Rob? Yes, sir? Can we just buy them coats and turn off the heat? Absolutely.
2:39:03 Although the codes would probably be very expensive. The other things, though, we've done in here, you know, I talked about wanting to leave revenue alone, is really where are we going to cut things out of the budget? If we, you know, if we're going to increment things for any reason, how are we going to afford that? And so, in some instances, we've cut areas down. So when you see budget balancing on there, which, I'm sorry, Andy, we reduced legal fees by 10,000. But that's...
2:39:33 Yeah. In all honesty, that rate in total was $200,000 for the year. That had been increased about $15,000 from prior year. And we have not come near actually expending that much. Not really any close to that maybe a couple of years ago. Yeah, my buildings in the town average about $100,000, $105,000 a year. And so the rest is just...
2:39:56 Specialty stuff that I'm not doing. I was going to note that because we do use that. It's Andy's bill, but really there's a whole other chunk in there, especially in the HR world where we use specialty. There's some other elements like that where we need specialty counsel. The other thing is that buffer in there basically for at least the front end work of one lawsuit. If you had to spend $30,000 or $40,000, I mean, that's not going to cover the suit usually, but it gives you some front end work in there that you can actually figure out what you're going to have to do.
2:40:24 If you remember a year ago, we had the lawsuit with the MLT, and we actually had money through that. I can't remember how much we spent at the end of the day, but we actually set aside, I think, $50,000 to go through that. Main street taxpayer's deal was ultimately thrown out by the courts in terms of element. But that's like, so if we had something at the town level, we want to be able to step into something like that, ultimately come to account of that. But having that cushion in there for that specialty type of work is kind of a safe place to be in terms of meeting.
2:40:57 So good comments on that. The other items for budget balancing, really trying to get to an exactly balanced budget is part of that. I took some money out of the uniforms associated for that. But then the other item on police overtime, we've made some really good strides in the last couple of years on curbing the overtime and bringing that down.
2:41:23 This last year, there was an increase in that. We've seen it kind of going back up. We're bringing this number down a little bit. I think it's going to require some additional work and effort to actually fit within that, especially we do have some injuries and things like that that require folks to be out for extended periods of time, and we'll have to pay overtime for that. The PD is one of those departments, it's not like if I get injured and I can't come to work, someone else may do the work.
2:41:52 When you're talking about shifts and patrols and those types of things, it gets very, very difficult not to incur that overtime. So that's where that comes about. And the same thing comes on for training. But reducing that number down will require the chief and the crew to really focus on how they're going to address some of those issues that do come up. So it is one to have in there. And then the firearms, we sent some increases in that. And we basically backed those out during this.
2:42:21 But this budget process and basically to fund some other items. I don't think it's going to impact the program that was intended, but it will, because this is another item we don't really spend all the way to what we have budgeted in there. So we'll have a total now budget in there of $15,000, and we come in usually around $10,000 or less. And that's, it's not just guns, it's ammunition, it's bear deterrent, it's all kinds of other items that are included in that.
2:42:46 Again, minor adjustments, but to bring the general fund into balance. And this is the updated list of departments and see the overall impact. Gas tax, not a lot of moving parts in there. The good news is that this year, even in the preliminary stages, we had quite a bit of the work done. And in this particular one with gas tax, you're talking about
2:43:14 Estimating how the snow removal costs are going to be for the coming year. Estimating what the paybacks for revenue from this current year are going to be. So it's really a bit of an estimation. So I did not make any adjustments from this in this particular fund between preliminary and this tentative that we have here. And I likely will not make any further for our final budget. We had not presented Measure R before. We had just taken
2:43:44 This actually to Mammoth Lakes Recreation. They're the recommending body. So we did give a presentation to them on May 2nd. And they talked about a few things, but did ultimately approve what we had presented to them as a plan. And so I'm going to walk through the one on the right a little bit. And Dan, if you want to hop in on any things, please feel free on that. On the sales tax side, the revenue for that, so measure R, that half percent use tax, that
2:44:13 That 1.5 million is representative of a conservative number. I mean, we think we can get to that, even if we do see a little less visitation in the coming year, because we are exceeding that now, and we think that that should remain fairly consistent.
2:44:32 Under the, and so that would, yes, you could give us the funds to spend, but we also have fund balance, and you'll see that we are allocating more expenditures than we have revenue, so that's a planned use of fund balance for this year, and it's for specific one-time items, so we'll kind of walk through those in a minute, but the one thing to note that's different this year than last, it does not have a net effect.
2:44:54 Providing the same funding for trails construction as we have done in prior years, it just looks a little bit differently. So in prior years, we would transfer $350,000 to measure our trails, and then we would allocate $100,000 of that to support our trails manager, Joel Rathje, his salary, which covers about 48% of that, total benefited salary. And that came out of then the funds that we transferred over.
2:45:24 We decided this year that we're just going to transfer that directly out of Fund 216, which is Measure R sales tax, to cover that expenditure. Then under the trail side, we're transferring $250,000, which will be for construction. So it's a net exactly the same as prior year, but it will look and feel a little bit different.
2:45:45 Yeah, if I may on that, there's a couple other items for that, but that'll be transferred over to the general fund and then built into that office of outdoor rec, so that would be support from measure R for Joel's position, then any cost above that we're budgeting into the general fund. The goal on that would be to try to cap that and hold that flat, and so the general fund continues to pick up a little more of those costs versus having to increase the measure R allocation for that staff or idea with the measure R, and you'll see some below there.
2:46:12 Is how do we leverage that stronger into the planning work and the capital work and the actual investment on the ground versus into our full-time staffing? Some dollars going into part-time work and the trail work and the actual, again, on-the-ground improvements versus the management side of that. We do have some dollars in there going into the other positions as well, the trail manager and Courtney. If we, if that whole situation with ORMAT out in Shady Rest, I'm assuming we
2:46:44 We have to do some political work with the gentleman who was here because it's a mess. It's getting worse. I'm assuming that would go through the Trails Committee and MLR and everybody else, but if they give us an opportunity to the Forest Service and Hermat, we would have some resources to be able to match with that or do something to make sense. Yeah, if we need to step into that, absolutely. There's resources in here. There's some in the Trails budget as well that would come back if it's a larger item. There's funding available.
2:47:15 Supervisor Corliss and I, I think, Bill, you might have gone, we went to a series of meetings with the new district. He's not having those meetings anymore, but it's, it's. I think the new gentleman will. I think he will. And just to call attention to the third line item down there, the transfer fund 100 trails manager, that's where the other 100,000 I was just talking about briefly and Dan elaborated on where that supports it. Under the community recreation support, the 112,000, that's made up of two components. In prior years,
2:47:54 For a prior year, we had $75,000 allocated to support CRC program and funding for operations. We also had $37,000 that came out of Measure R to support Trails End Park and Whitmore Park maintenance and those types of efforts that the town was working on. So that $37,000 has been in there for several years, and that's just been construction support.
2:48:19 What we've decided to do this year is we're actually taking that 37, adding it to the 75, and that's what you see there in the 112. So we've combined those two into one. So the same impact on Measure R, but we're providing the benefit to the Community Recreation Center. The cost of maintenance on those trails are now going to be absorbed by General Fund. So we will take the brunt of all those costs instead of having some of it carried.
2:48:46 Forward from Measure R. And that was always the plan. I think this is just a time where we're going to sort of wean off of that a little bit. And that, again, since I've been here, that's been the discussion that we will either hold that static and then we will somehow decrease it. In this particular case, shifting to another point. There's also a color of money question with this because there's more we're dealing with federal lands and things like that. Measure R constraints. It gives staff and the team more flexibility.
2:49:17 Actually, it does, yeah. So the work that the general fund is supporting in those areas, if that's utilized on federal or other areas, if you will, it's not as constrained under the measure are of town owned and managed. The CRC is very clearly that type of program and that type of, so it does open that up. As Rob had mentioned the last few years, several years, we'd kept that dollar amount flat, so we were actually slowly absorbing more of that admin or the administrative work and the actual maintenance work on the park and the north track area.
2:49:49 By making that part of the general fund, that it also reduces a little bit of what we're just doing from time tracking, because you're not asking employees, you're still looking at how much time are you spending so we know things, but not a time card going, oh, you need four hours in Measure R, then you need six hours, and it probably reduces some of our paperwork, and it's easy for our staff to move across. MLR, Town Agreement, Administration, the $90,500, that is, I think, a carryover from prior years, and just approved tonight as well.
2:50:25 The special projects, last year we had 50,000 in there. Prior years to that we had 25. The 50,000 was, we had kind of requested the rec officer position support that you see below there, that 25 of MLR, it was not approved because it had, did not have a job description essentially designed for that. And so they...
2:50:47 Wanted to see that process come forward, and that's been completed. So there is the $25,000 support for that rec officer position in this current year's budget, and we've reduced special projects back down to $25,000. The other three items, the audit services, equipment replacement, and equipment maintenance, those are part of standard annual costs that were agreed upon by MLR.
2:51:07 Quite a few years ago, and we just keep that sort of ongoing support for recreation programs in that. So the $610,750 represents really the annual operating expense from Measure R to cover all of those aspects. One of the things we've added this year, and this plan used to fund balance, these are one-time allocations, and they were requests made to MLR, and that was for $350,000.
2:51:35 For CRC Capital Project interior improvements. If you remember back in the fall, we allocated some general fund dollars to that project to support development of the interior. And so this will augment that additionally. And so there's a request in there, and MLR agreed to that with no issue. The other item.
2:52:00 Sharp's planning for NEPA work out at the Sherwin Trailhead. That's sort of getting on to the, I think, the work program for the federal, for the Forest Service. So the $100,000 really helped support us being able to fund that work and some work on our own to further that project.
2:52:21 So a total of one-time funding, $450,000. That, frankly, is what has brought our total negative balance of $176 for the year in that plan, like I said, plan to use of fund balance. The CRC financing, the 615, 747, that fluctuates a few thousand dollars here and there each year, and that's based upon the bond repayment schedule, and so that will change every year.
2:52:45 It doesn't change drastically. So that 615 is roughly in line. I think it was 612 last year or something along those lines. How many years are left on that? I think five? Five, six in line. Yeah. Yeah, there's a chart at the end. We'll answer that question. So four measure are a total of 176, 497, reducing fund balance based upon everything that we see at the budgeting standpoint.
2:53:10 On the left side of the screen, we have Measure Our Trails. This is a different fund, Fund 215, and that's where we're transferring the money into for the project work. We do have...
2:53:21 The $250,000 is pretty much expended or planned to be expended on trails to construction. We have staff and labor in there of around $91,000. That, for the most part, is part-time staff. And then we have an allocation of a full-time employee that we have in our public works department who's a hybrid position and they spend a certain number of hours.
2:53:43 Overworking on the trail systems have been very beneficial. So there's a little bit of full-time staff cost in there, but the bulk of it is the same sort of part-time labor force that is over there. But that's the extent of the labor. Everything else is now in the Office of Outdoor Recreation over in General Fund. Contractual services, that represents really the bulk of other funding that would be necessary to pay an outside agency to work on the trails with us or to perform services that would support that.
2:54:12 And so that's really a plug number to get to $250,000, but that's the available funds that we would have to allocate through construction of the projects. And then the miscellaneous expenses of $16,600, which would be just maintenance supplies, those types of construction supplies, and annual contracts, if you will, for if they have GIS or internet or other things that they're utilizing on those charges. So that's Fund 215's budget as planned.
2:54:42 On to 17, Measure U. Similar to what we just walked through with Measure R, we sort of forecast what the user utility taxes are going to be, and they do fluctuate with visitation. We've seen that during the pandemic years, but we think 880,000, which is fairly consistent with what we've done in prior years, to be something we can achieve.
2:55:05 And then we've got the programming of $186,000 there. I put more detail in the staff report on exactly who received those funds and how we had some increment. And there is still some available funding, I think, to be allocated to that. The Office of Outdoor Recreation, the coordinator position, that's $75,000. I made mention when I was talking about the labor where the joint position with the county, Matt Perillo.
2:55:31 Who was the Eastern Sierra Sustainable Recreation Coordinator. That received $75,000 in funding on an annual basis from Measure U. And that will continue. But in this particular case, it's transferred to General Fund and funding a portion of that rec coordinator position, as Dan talked about earlier, in the Office of Outdoor Recreation.
2:55:53 Budget also contains an element of support for the rec manager, that $25,000, and that was consistent with prior year's expectations that these two funds would shoulder in a little bit of revenue to support or offset the cost of that position. Special projects, same $25,000 as we have in Measure R, and that's just for incidental items that may come up. You provide funding for people to act fairly quickly, and that would be basically an MLR.
2:56:22 Recommendation for both of those. Transit services, so our special project, our special events that we have and securing busing and transit to support those events. We did increment that a little bit. We had that around 18,000 in prior years, so we've increased that to 25. And then we've added the Edison Hall operations of 15,000. So again, that's associated with, you know, presuming that we get to that point and that we need some
2:56:50 Funding for the, for arts and culture for that particular event, or that particular facility if you will, I'm sorry. And then the other three, the, the contract processing, the audit services, equipment replacement, those are the boilerplate items that we, we have in there on an annual basis to, you know, further those, those programs. We had one request for funding here for, for, for the year and that was some,
2:57:18 The concept, revision, and update on the MAC. As we've talked a little bit about working through a process with that facility and in that general area, we are kind of reintroducing that. Dan, I don't know if you have more to add to that, but just some of the design and construction are a little bit changed. Yeah, real quick on that. As the council is aware from previous discussions, the original MAC was being designed. It ended up being a project that was unaffordable. I think it was pushing $30 million in estimated cost.
2:57:47 We did a redesign initially, provided some funding for that, what I call a performing arts auditorium, not necessarily a full-blown theater with the fly top, everything else. And it would also then build off of the Edison Theater, so it's actually physically connected, and so we're utilizing existing other space. We did that design work. We've gone out from with a contractor, AMS, the company who was here before.
2:58:19 They've gone out and met with a lot of the user groups, sitting down and, you know, here's what we're looking at. Do we have any fatal flaws in here? Is there something that would, the majority of the folks that would, and we've also taken a look at the Edison Hall remodel concept that was there. We're looking, potentially requesting some changes there. Reduced cost, the goal would be to keep the Edison Theater, the small one there, the 75 plus room theater, works for rehearsal and other small events.
2:58:51 But so we do need to go back and look at the design element of that, looking at an update, get a revised cost estimate, and really trying to take the input from the users and say, yes, we can make these types of changes to address needs. No, we can't make maybe some other changes to keep the project. And so that additional work is something that needs to be done. That would end up being an agreement again with the foundation who's actually running that contract with HMC, the architect firm doing it.
2:59:23 We want them to continue to lead that versus having it's already started with them and not with them. And so that allows them to do that, respond to the needs of the users, take a look at what we're actually spending on remodeled work versus construction work, and be able to come up and revise plans. The capital funding that we committed to a long time ago, where is that in all this? That is currently sitting in the fund balance of Measure U. At the end of the year, I think it's fully funded at $2.5 million.
3:00:02 Yeah, we will have the full $2.5 million available in fund balance at the close of this fiscal year, plus a little bit. So we've got fine to allocate that and to be available. Again, I think we're all looking forward to whenever you guys come forward with whatever that package looks like. I think we're all keeping our eyes on the bond funding that's available to leverage this. Correct. We've had that. Yeah, and there's been some good discussions with the college, $7.5 million.
3:00:32 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
3:01:00 Then the MAC operating costs is set aside down to the $300,000. That's, you know, something we've been putting in the budget for the last few years, really just to illustrate the impact of when that facility is operational and expected funding that will be necessary for that. So we kind of keep sight of that as we may allocate this fund further through the years. So it's really just sitting there as a balance, a budget item, but not expended. So it sits in the fund balance, no changes.
3:01:30 But what I've illustrated here, this change in fund balance, that really would include the $300,000 as well as all the other expenditures listed above. Airport, similar to gas tax, not a lot of updates. I do, we are in the process now of submitting our request for grant funding from the FAA and we're in the process of, we'll hear back from that fairly quickly. That will determine some of our capital improvement project costs.
3:02:00 And that will change these categories, but there's nothing to report at this time, so we may have a slight adjustment, if you will, by the time we get to the final budget, if we've heard back on that. But for the most part, this operational side has remained the same. And what I show you on the graph here is really the operational budget, so that's the cost of operating the airport versus any capital improvement expenditures that would be associated with a project we were running on there. And the letters for our Mammoth Airport are MM, correct? Correct. And Bishop is BIH, correct? Correct.
3:02:32 It might be something to think about, just adding in the presentations or something so that, you know, someone, whatever report you're talking about, it's always this. Yeah, thank you. Vehicle Services, Fund 9, 10, 9, 15, really not a lot to report here. We've done a great job in the last couple of years of replacing our fleet, you know, since it's been, it's in pretty good condition. We are continuing with our replacement program. If you remember last year, we bifurcated
3:03:02 Fund 910, which is our garage service costs, and the vehicle replacement fund from each other. So we have now at 915, which is our vehicle replacement. I mean, that's really where the bulk of the dollars are sitting. I mean, that's where we've accumulated the funds to replace those vehicles. And, you know, it's close to $12 million as far as the fund balance with cash, you know, right under $11. So that's the big part of it. But what I want to illustrate here is just, you know,
3:03:31 The replacement charges that are refunded annually, so $966,000 in annual expense goes to fund those vehicle replacements and the bulk of it coming out of, you know, the gas tax and the heavy equipment that's responsible for snow removal or roads. So that's the bulk of the expenditure. But we also have other departments. Whomever utilized the vehicle is charged for the replacement cost as well as the garage services portion of that.
3:04:00 Garage services would be anything from fuel and parts and other items necessary to run that. We did increment that this year a little bit, as we anticipate, obviously, with fuel costs increasing. That's going to be a bit of a burden on us, but we didn't go too hard on that particular one. So really roughly, what, $1.45 for the year in vehicle costs. Again, I'm showing you the vehicle replacement.
3:04:30 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
3:04:52 As a major component of that, as well as the cost. So you build that into the system of, I have a piece of equipment that costs $800,000, for example, if you're talking about a blower, and it's going to last me X number of years. Prior to last year, we had those numbers set around 15-year replacement on a vehicle of that size, and we've extended that out based upon really common practice to 20 years.
3:05:17 And so that in itself made the vehicle replacement charges much more affordable on an annual basis. So in order to kind of keep this the annual charges similar to all of those departments, we've added a bit of a repayment program, an increment to that. So we are still charging roughly what we would have charged in prior years. That extended life is allowing us to take some dollars and put it towards paying off that loan balance.
3:05:45 So that loan balance is now $1.271 million, and we're paying it off roughly to the tune of $860,000 a year. So we'll have it one and a half years. So $25,26 is when it will be paid off. And that's really a good benefit for us.
3:06:09 We have to calculate and share all this information. This is just a screenshot of what we have in there, so our funded ratios. But the vehicle replacement program is strong, healthy, and getting kind of back to where it needed to be prior to the loan that was taken out. And then the debt reserve future capital fund 990. This is where all of our debt payments come through. Kind of showing a little bit different look on this. This is our repayment schedule. So there is five years remaining.
3:06:40 on after this year on on the repayment of that that second item down which is the installment sales agreement multi-use facility and so we'll have that paid off in fiscal year 27-28 and our current balance is $3,445,000 and we're paying $612,000 a year but so I kind of wanted to show you you know what the original debt was what our current balance is what our annual payments are the term
3:07:08 And the interest rates and so forth. And we did add the vehicle replacement internal loan in there. And I'm sorry, it's not 860, it's 820,000 a year that we accelerate that too. So yeah, so that is the presentation for the tentative budget. I did talk about the next budget presentation we have will be the final budget adoption. And I will have a number of other items included, which would be
3:07:37 The overall budget for capital improvement program, our assessment districts and our diff accounts, those will be also included in there. They're incremental to this. But that's about it. Everything else has already been included in either the preliminary or the tentative. I do not expect major adjustments, if any, in those. So we'll be focusing on discussions around the new departments in the next.
3:08:04 Item. As well as, if you remember, during that final budget adoption, we are required to adopt our policies and update those for the year, and we will have some edits on those for this year, so there's quite a bit of components to go through, but for the most part, this is our budget. No question? Yes. Our total budget, when you include gas tax, the whole nine yards, what is that? So 27 is general fund.
3:08:33 Yeah. When we add it all together, do we have a number for what that is? What our actual... So when I tell somebody what the town of Mammoth Lake budget is, I'm... Yeah, hold just one second, if I can get it to... I can tell you that. And it will adjust as we do the capital projects. That hasn't really been baked into this number yet, but we have this combined fund statement that currently has us sitting at total revenue...
3:09:11 And again, it's not complete. It's around $75 million with all of the adjustments. And the majority of that is capital improvement program. And that's the one that's not fully baked into that. But it's $24 million as of it sits now. And that's based on projects that we had working through. So it's going to be probably close to $75 million for a total combined, all funds included in that process.
3:09:55 All right. So I don't have anything else. Thank you very much. And this was just really informative to see where we are and if there's any concerns, I guess, about recommendations and adjustments that we've made. I don't hear any. I think we're doing the right things and kind of aligned with what you've asked us to do and are expecting. No, no. Thank you, Rob. Any other? Just one last stupid question. Maybe not so stupid. What is the cost of money now in the market if we ever go out for the CRC or some of these other things?
3:10:29 So when we were just doing some work on the funding for our potential Civic Center build, the cost of money in January was somewhere in the 2.5% range. And in, I think it was around April, mid-April, when we got that early April, it was right under 4%. And so those numbers, that 2.5% range, it's been there for,
3:11:00 I'm going to say years. And then just the rapid increase over the last couple of months. We have not pulled anything to understand what's going on now. We're doing a lot of legwork with regard to figuring out the cost of such facility as well as to get an understanding of this rough order of magnitude of cost, which will help us then go back to our bond agents to discuss further what it will look like at that point. And we are sort of
3:11:29 Testing all the different scenarios as far as, you know, we have to have the funding if we were to move forward with that in the spring of next year, but we're looking at just the cost of money if we pull the trigger earlier to maybe lock in a lower interest rate and what the cost will be. So there's a lot of analysis going on, but to answer your question specifically, you know, it's gone up from roughly two and a half to four. And finally, the state is working on some refunds for gas tax, gas price increase stuff.
3:11:59 Would the town benefit from that? Or is that only, like, for individuals? I'm not sure. The way it sounds like it's going to be per registered vehicle. And so if we have registered, whether it would apply to just across the board to every vehicle in the state that's registered, then they carve out government. I don't know if they would. It's actually two registered vehicles. There's some huge fleets out there from that. Let's see how that ultimately... That's the end of my stupid questions. Rob, thank you. This is...
3:12:44 Yeah, you brought it to us upside down, backwards, and inside out, and hopefully it's been brought to us and enough that we can understand it well enough to answer questions in the community, but well done. Thank you. Thank you very much. And if you ever have folks that have questions about the budget and the process, please send them to me. I really want to get people to understand exactly how it works.
3:13:18 And I have attended a lot of meetings recently, and there's been some confusion about in the community, the general community, about this process and maybe what we're funding. So I took the time to educate that process, but I really want to have the opportunity to talk to folks as we get that chance, because understanding what funds us and why and how we actually, what do we utilize those funds with is really critical for the community. I've had some questions on the, and so perhaps at some point in a few months or something we can have.
3:13:59 Many people are really interested in that. Of course, they always want to see their project. For sure. So we are, like I said before, we're going to have more of a presentation in the staff report for the capital improvement plan. And we do break it down to one tablet or one table that includes all the different funding sources for all the different projects. So it's really kind of well placed there. And it's in our budget book. So I look forward to more discussion on the CIP coming back next time.
3:14:28 I'm impressed that people know that much about it to ask questions. That's progress. Okay. Is there an action on this? Not really. Okay. Then we're on to Councilmember reports. If I remember right, the last meeting we kind of slipped past that. So if anybody can remember back a month, let alone two weeks, we'll try that. So, Kirk.
3:15:00 The only thing I have to report is that the wait list for housing continues to fluctuate at 130. Oh, that's the only thing I have to report. I was thinking of a question to actually ask you about that, and that out of that number, how many people have been placed in affordable housing units since the last report? So how many people have added to the list? I think probably four. Okay. Because some people have left the community and we've...
3:15:30 That's off the top of my head. Yeah, I'm always wondering, okay, so did anybody move in, did anybody else get into some of the housing? That's for next month. It's, housing issue is, again, going down valley. I mean, it is, they're eating up. And with the marketing and the purchase of units, I mean, it's becoming tighter and tighter. That's all I can see. You can see the trends. It's going to be difficult.
3:16:08 All right, Bill. I took a drink, sorry. So I already told you about meeting with our state representatives. I think very productive meetings just to, you know, let them know we are here. Was it in person or virtual? Frank Bigelow was in person. They were all in person. Okay. Borges' office was with staff. Frank was there, Bigelow was there. Okay, good. We got to meet with him, and I coughed worse than I am coughing today.
3:16:39 But that was also the, it was a combination event for the League of California Cities, and Dan and I went over to that. We went to several sessions. One of them in particular, and I won't get into particulars of it, showed me how, how do I put this delicately, how wacko some of our state representatives are. Sorry. I was astounded that there was point but no counterpoint presented at it. I think they will get...
3:17:07 And get better at this. This is a conference that was added, one that we used to go to that I really enjoyed today. Solid. But we met with our Desert Mountain folk and learned a few things. It's what's going on state budget-wise. And I had a sheet that I intended to bring. I will see to it that you get a copy of it, of what the league is recommending in terms of expenditures out of that surplus and what some of the...
3:17:36 You've probably all gotten some notices about oppose this, and we have our policy, and so I'm assuming we'll be writing some letters shortly on that. It was, as always, it was enjoyable and informative. LTC on Monday. Hayes, give my update. I can't stop coughing. Yeah, the one thing that was covered, our LTC had an MOU with several other counties where we moved funds to Kern.
3:18:22 To build some projects down there that are now not going to be finished because the funding stream is dried up. It's kind of complicated with how the state has changed their budget. And what was supposed to happen there was payback. So then they would, and it looks like that probably is not going to happen. So we did vote to ask for the money, but probably we will not get it and we will not go farther than that because you don't want to, you know, send good money after bad.
3:18:53 Did I get that right? That is correct. That was probably the highlight of the meeting. We also approved on unmet transit needs, provided quarterly reports from various groups, but that's the gist of the meeting. John. Thank you. I'm sorry I missed that meeting. I've got some familial obligations that's keeping me out of town a little bit. Great Basin Unified Air Pollution Control District. I hope you're all aware, I think you're all aware that
3:19:28 The issue of PM10 dust mitigation at Mono Lake is starting to pop up. So this is the kind of same kind of thing that the Air District got involved with, with the Illinois Dry Lake bed, and this could get quite contentious. Where is it again, John? Where is the dust on Mono Lake? Yeah, but I mean, where's the worst? Oh, I don't know. I think it's probably worst on the east side of the lake. Okay. Because the wind blows, but certainly no one wants to blow it that way.
3:20:01 It's because the water level is going down. It's exposing more of the sediment. The winds come up. And obviously with L.A. being in situations with water, I mean, we're all seeing what was predicted by many books and many things. And it actually gets a little more complicated than that because when the lake is low, just as with Owens Dry Lake, the lake bed gets up and moves. So even if Mono Lake refills, that's right, you're still going to have the massive amount of dust.
3:20:31 If you've ever been in a friend's house up on the shore of the lake or off of the Bodie Road, the whatever canyon road that is, and seen the, after a windstorm, the piles of dirt, it is a huge issue. But the work that the air district is doing is of a lot of interest. People in the Salton Sea and a lot of places around the world that are really interested in the work that remediation is very interesting. Then at the ESCOG meeting, and I've got the notes here.
3:21:02 Linda, so I can just kind of cover you for that. Go ahead, please. The SCOG, this was a special meeting to deal with the COVID. I mean, that's ostensibly what the purpose of it was, but there were a couple of contracts that came forward. One was the awarding of a $2 million contract to the Whitebark Institute to do NEPA work. This is third-party NEPA that we've talked about. The Indian National Forest and Leslie Yen is committed to doing this. And this is the NEPA work profoundly. This is going to be affecting the donut project, this whole big fuels reduction project.
3:21:33 That's it. Okay.
3:22:09 Other than that, the only thing I have to talk about is the Fire Academy was this week, the second installment of that. It was really well done. It was Malcolm North and another gentleman who's at the moment, but Craig. Oh, Craig Thomas. Yeah, Craig Thomas. Yeah, excellent. Craig Thomas. But really talking about the importance and the just importance of burning of, you know, treatment of forests to reduce the larger fires.
3:22:43 Basically, you know, there will be more smoke in smaller doses, hoping to avoid the large catastrophic doses. So it was well done. It's an excellent... It's hard to tell how many people are attending because it doesn't show participants. And so you just see sort of the four people on the screen, but then you don't know who else is there, which is nice kind of when they do list people. I always enjoy seeing kind of who's on there too. But I look forward to the next two ones of that, and I hope it's being... Other than that...
3:23:15 Which brings us to... Oh, Sarah, there you are. I got nothing. Thank you, though. Thanks, Sarah. Yeah, if I may, in June 1st and 2nd, we do have the SNC board meeting in Mammoth County. They'll be out. The request came up because of activity in that board meeting. The question was raised whether or not if we could move the start time of that...
3:23:45 It looks like a large agenda.
3:24:15 So we're juggling both needs there, so we'll take a look into if we need to move something around. Okay, and that works for staff, okay? All right, then let's go ahead and do we need, we don't need a vote on that. No, I just want to bring that up, consensus, we'll just agendize it that way then. All right, let's go ahead. I would just share that the tour, the SNC board is going on a tour that afternoon. That day. That afternoon, and so if you guys have any interest in just tagging along, there's going to be a lot of state, interesting state presence, and again, the work we're doing with the Donut Project, the recreation economy,
3:24:49 And Andy, can we do something that we need to do so all of us could attend? I will be speaking as part of that event. We're excited. I just killed anybody else wanting to come with this and see what's going on. But just fair warning. Okay. All right. That seems to conclude this business, but we will adjourn to...
3:25:25 A short closed session. A short closed session. Okay, which is conference with legal counsel, anticipated litigation, cross with legal counsel, anticipated litigation, significant exposure to litigation pursuant to paragraph 3 of subdivision D of section 54956.91 case. And we shall stay here and do that.