TransparentMammoth

Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board · 2022

Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board

at 13:00

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Notable from this meeting

2 findings

Transcript

214 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

2:14 I'm Angie. We let everybody know when they're talking. All right, we're going to call the meeting to order, and Angie, if you can do roll call, please. Waiting for my system to open. Oh, sorry. I thought you said you were ready. I was ready, and then my roll call got jammed up. I didn't want to put you on the spot. No, we're good. Chair Goyko? Present. Vice Chair Foster? Here. Treasurer Morris? Here. Secretary Mendo? Here.

3:32 Board member Clark? Here. Board member Crabb? Here. Board member Radcliffe? Here. Board member Souser? Almost here. Board member Magner, I believe, is excused today. Yes. Thank you. Wonderful. Thank you, Angie. All right. We're going to go into some board member reports. I'm going to keep it. I'll get us started off here, but I'm going to keep it quick.

3:57 Besides the chilly weather, I thought Memorial Day weekend was fantastic. Great to see kind of, you know, the crowds of people come back to Mammoth and great weekend for us at Black Tie. The one thing that I want to make note of, we had some employees and customers recreating, especially on the scenic loop, you know, in the forest.

4:27 Coming across campfires left and right, just abandoned, still on fire, and they're wringing it with dry wood. What good does that do? You know, like, we're gonna burn the place down, guys. You know, like, take your water and put the fire out, okay? So, very concerning to see how much that was happening.

4:55 Multiple reports from multiple people that I got and some of my staff members taking photos, videos, happy to share that. But, you know, one suggestion I got from a local was to put together like a voluntary task force, you know, every Monday after the weekend to go around or something like that. I don't know if that's the answer. I thought maybe talking to Joel Rathje at MLTPA might be a good idea, but.

5:23 Very concerning to see how much feedback I got that we're seeing that in our forest. That's the Shady Rest, Inyo Craters area. That's right, that's our backyard there. So let's make sure that we are putting out our campfires. I don't know how much more information we can put out about this stuff. And then there's just complete lack of common sense at one point. But, you know, that was really the only really frustrating or concerning thing.

5:53 I spoke to multiple police officers. How did everybody behave? They said really the only issues were with locals in the last couple weeks. So, which I've heard some pretty unsavory stories about locals kind of with some issues there. Apparently there's a BB gun tick-tock that, you know, is getting out of control. And unfortunately that was one of my employees, so I heard about that one too.

6:20 So, you know, I think from a visitation standpoint in terms of, you know, people coming into down and enjoying themselves, great, but we need to make sure that we don't burn this place down. So those are my comments and I'm going to move to my left here to my vice chair. Pat, if you have any board comments. I don't have anything right now. All right, wonderful. Mr. Mendel. Yeah, so, you know, your comments are particularly, snap this, it'll give you a response. Yeah.

8:08 Mr. Larry Crabb, yeah, no, thank you, John, you know, I appreciate it. Comments, May, we saw May down quite a bit, 30% from last month. I don't know if that showed up in lodging or not. As you said, Memorial Day weekend, more visitors, but concerned with, echo your concerns with, a little concerned about not just this summer, but coming summers. Jamie Dimon from JPMorgan Chase came out preparing for an economic hurricane. Banks raising none up. Lending's going to be down by the big banks.

8:58 We may be heading into an economic downturn. Sorry for a lot of that. That could be as troubling. That's it. My comments. Thanks, Larry. Here, we'll just turn around this way. How are you doing, Deb? I'm great. How are you guys doing? Good. You know, to your point about the recession, that may be beneficial to us because instead of traveling, you know, to other cities and overseas, things like that, they may come back and start coming back to our local neighborhoods, you know, or...

9:43 Our community. So, I mean, there may be some upside to it, maybe some downside to it. It's so much more affordable to fly to Europe and Turkey than it is to go to Atlanta or New York. It's crazy. But from the village perspective and from, you know, the restaurants, we saw great traffic over the weekend because they moved the mountain event to the village because of the winds. I heard about that. So we love when there's high winds in the village because we get all the traffic.

10:12 It kind of caught us a little bit all off guard from a staffing perspective, but we made it work, and it was really exciting to see everyone just engaged and excited to be outside, and it was just a tremendous weekend, so I'm glad to see summer's kicking off with a rush, so excited to be part of that. No comments from me. Thanks, Eric. Mr. Souser?

10:39 I wasn't here for Memorial Day weekend. I cooked for 60 people at Topaz. It was great. But I do want to remark on your comments some. There are several miscommunications that we keep doing about these campers. Most of the people along the scenic loop were already camping illegally because you have to get more than X number of miles and so off the road to make it legal. That's what I thought. So they are also, we keep calling them dispersed campers. They are not. Anybody here that would like to,

11:09 Have me take them out in the woods in my truck and show them where the actual dispersed camping occurs and what those people are doing because it's two completely different groups and different things. I completely agree with you. Most of those campers out there are the locals who, because they can't find a place or because they want to save money, are camping in the woods. I saw it this winter on the second road that goes into the tubs. I had a gentleman locked out of his truck. I went out there into my surprise.

11:36 The one side of the road was lined with campers. I mean, we're talking 40, 50, I don't even know how many of people. They aren't our tourists. They aren't dispersed campers. They're not getting our message because we're not sending it to them. So the Forest Service talks about closures, and we talk about closures for dispersed camping. Let's just take out the pistol and shoot ourselves in the foot now. Let's talk about how we can control that segment.

12:03 Can we come up with an MOU with the Forest Service so that we can do a heavier enforcement presence? You know, Town of Mammoth Lakes, RPD is pretty much restricted here. Sheriff's Department has some sway, but on Forest Service land, not all that much. So I get worried when we start throwing around this, all the campers, because they're livers, not campers. I hear you. And just like the homeless population in every city.

12:32 They create huge issues. And that's it. Thank you. Awesome. Thanks, Bill. Mr. Morris. Sure. Just a couple comments regarding Memorial Day. I'd say it was average. It was about what we had budgeted. So I haven't heard from a lot of the other lodging folks yet, but everybody seemed to be okay. Nothing particularly special, but a decent weekend. Let's see. On the lodging side also, there's a presentation that Rob Patterson is doing tonight.

13:03 regarding certifying properties, business tax certificate potential change, and encourage especially anybody in lodging to be here or be on Zoom. He made a really nice presentation to the lodging steering committee a week or so ago, and it's an interesting angle on enforcement and potentially changing the way that short-term rentals work a little bit. Don't get it.

13:29 Don't get freaked out, anybody. We're not talking about a moratorium on short-term rentals, just some changes to the licensing and where the onus is put more on the owner than the manager of the property as far as the licensing. Anyway, I'm getting ahead of myself. That'll be tonight at tonight's meeting, and it's important for anybody who's interested in that to listen. There's some good points, and I'll be interested to see what the council thinks of it, too.

13:51 And then on the Snow Creek side, a lot of questions about the golf course. We are doing everything we can to get open before Fourth of July.

14:00 I don't know if it'll be much before that. Supply chain issues, equipment issues, same things that plague everybody. But golf course equipment is pretty specialized. And when you send out a piece of equipment and they tell you to get it back in November, that doesn't do us a lot of good. So we're doing the best we can. We're trying to locate different pieces of equipment to be able to manage the golf course the way that we need to and have a great product. So everybody just stay patient and we'll get open just as soon as we can. Driving range is open every single day.

14:31 Awesome. Thank you, Mr. Morris. Thank you for all the board member comments. Angie, do we have any public comments today? No comments at this time. Wonderful. Moving to the consent agenda, do I have a motion to approve? Wonderful. Any discussion on that? I'll second it. All right. I have a motion from Mr. Morris and a second from Mr. Souser. Roll call on that, Angie.

15:06 Chair Goico? Yes. Vice Chair Foster? Yes. Treasurer Morris? Yes. Secretary Mendel? Yes. Board Member Clark? Yes. Board Member Kraft? Yes. Board Member Radcliffe? Yes. Board Member Souser? Yes. Thank you. Sorry, guys. I can't help myself. It's good. I like it. All right. Moving on to policy matters 5.1, upcoming board seat elections.

15:36 received notice from John Mendel and Pat Foster of their interest in continuing on the Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board. Mr. Morris, if you would like to speak on behalf of lodging. Sure, thanks, Mr. Chair. We did receive a letter of interest from Darlene to continue on the board, and that was the only application that we had. F on the...

16:05 From the Lodging Steering Committee and the Lodging Association, we are extremely happy with Darlene and would like her to come. Absolutely. Yeah, we did not have any other interest from any other parties for the at-large seat that Pat Foster currently represents and then no other interest for the retail position that John Mandel currently represents.

16:33 I would like to make a motion to approve John Mendel, Pat Foster, and Darlene Magner. Three-year retail term for John Mendel, two-year at-large term for Pat Foster, and two-year lodging term for Darlene Magner. Do I have any discussion on that? I agree with you. I would love for that to happen. Our agenda item says upcoming is not an action item.

17:07 So I don't care if we have action on it or not, it is just not there as an action item. MLT Board to approve reappointment of three incoming, do we need to, do we need to, I thought we needed to make a motion. Yeah. It does, yeah. MLT Board to approve, right? Mine says upcoming boards. Yeah, it's on the last line there, Bill, I'm sorry. Oh, okay. Just underneath. Oh, all right.

17:42 Yeah, because they expire June 30th, today's June 1st, and then our next meeting's in July. So we want to get them in. I need John, Pat, and Darlene at the July board meeting. I will second your motion. All right, thank you, Eric. Can we go roll call, Angie? Please. Chair Goico. Yes. Vice Chair Foster. Yes. Treasurer Morris. Yes. Secretary Mandel. Yes. Board Member Clark.

18:13 Yes. Board Member Crabb. Yes. Board Member Ratcliffe. Yes. Board Member Souser. Yes. Thank you. Wonderful. Thank you so much, everybody. And thank you, Pat, John, and, you know, Darlene's not here today, but we look forward to working with her moving forward into our next fiscal year, 22-23. Fantastic. On to 5.2. So final approval of MLT deliverables and goals. Board to...

18:42 Board vote to approve deliverables and goals as presented at the April 6th board meeting. Urdi, you want to take this one, my man? Yeah, I mean, nothing has changed since we presented those to both our board and 210. So on the full agenda packet for Mammoth Lakes Tourism, that falls on page 9. So we have that.

19:26 Page 9, 10, 11, 12. Those are the four pages of the deliverables. So we did rework those after, you know, our April 6th meeting. And so we are voting today to approve those deliverables. Do I have a motion to approve those? I'll move. All right. So moved by Mr. Mendel. Do we have any discussion on this?

19:55 Agenda item. I'll add a little discussion for it, Jeremy, in the sense that I'm willing to speak to item 3F, where we state coordinate with town of Mammoth Lakes, Mammoth Lakes Housing, MLR, MMSA, USFS, and other entities to begin developing a comprehensive sustainable destination management plan for future success.

20:23 We've been talking about that for a long time and we understand some of the infrastructure needs that we've had. For instance, not enough bathrooms, not enough trash cans, not enough of those items. And it's in conjunction with make sure that we're marketing and educating people on how to be good developers.

20:47 I think we really need to make sure before we spend too much money marketing on how to be great campers, even though the discussion we had earlier today, we have to make sure that we execute on these items. And it doesn't necessarily mean a destination plan. We can get the right people at the table together to come up and really make a difference this summer. If we waited for a destination plan, I don't think we'd make a difference this summer. So that's my only comment.

21:15 Like to see those entities get together and start talking about it, see if they can do something. Or maybe even next summer. Right? I mean, we've been talking about this, to your point, for a long time. Exactly. And everybody is waiting for us to take action. Yeah, make sure we get everybody together at the same table and talk about who does take that action. Right? Who's the people to execute on it? And then what does the plan become? Because more trash cans is great. Yeah.

21:59 So the town has already, you know, ponied up some in that direction, spring and fall in the basin, we provide bathrooms, but we do, because Joel and company and the host program gets all sorts of, of course, to do something, we have to go through the Forest Service, which, you know, is a game, but I think that it's already being worked on. And I think we can take that lead, because we've had one-off conversations with the town, we've had conversations with the mountain, you know, Forest Service, we need to get them all into a group, plan one, we need to make sure this is really something that we...

23:00 Yeah, we were able to discuss this particular topic with Ron Cohen at length during a meeting, and he made it very clear just how important, to your point, Eric, this is. And so I really feel that MLT's role is to really get us all together and facilitate the conversation, right? And then...

23:34 You know, give our feedback from the data we're getting, from the feedback we're getting, you know, just kind of anecdotally, I was made aware right before Memorial Day weekend that there was no running water in the Lakes Basin. So, like, no wells to, you know, pump your water for camping, and then no bathrooms, and we had to bring in all these porta-potties.

24:00 Definitely not ideal. Obviously, you know, it's the beginning of the season up there, and apparently, you know, the winter created some issues with the water system up there, but, you know, how do we avoid that situation in the future, right? That is not part of Town of Mammoth Lakes. It's Forest Service land, but it reflects on the Town of Mammoth Lakes, and it reflects on the visitor's experience in Mammoth.

24:29 Would love to do a land swap, but, you know, is that a possibility? Can we talk about that? That's a long process. That's a long process, I know. Can we hurry that up? But, you know, I think, to your point, Eric, I think it is, it's top of mind for me and John, especially hearing that coming down from Ron Cohen and hearing it from you as well.

24:58 I think it was also mentioned at our last meeting, I forget who it was, but said that's the most important thing on the list. You know, so I think we are very motivated to get that process started. Well, and I think Mr. Tannum does have quite a few things. What can you do is replace some bathrooms, fixed ones, which is great. So I think that's the discussion. And there's also a plan for international forest campgrounds. There probably should be forest service, you know.

25:45 I fought when they took out all the pit toilets, flush toilets, because the water system was inadequate for it back then. Now they want to take out the flush toilets and go back. The water system is inadequate now. But we need to understand what the four services plans are there. Plus, I think we need this group to tell us what everybody's plans are. I was talking to Eric a little bit earlier. Hays may have a map with the next 10 bathroom locations already X'd off. Great. Now we just need to figure out the funding, the timing. Or if we have 20 new trash cans, where are they going?

26:23 They may have that map already mapped out, and good for this whole room to say, okay, we approve. So I think that's the initial discussion point, the low-hanging fruit, and the longer-term fixes. If the roundabout needed at the minaret, that's not happening in the summer. But if that's the flow, a few more buses, or if there's that, then that's this discussion jump off to a system. If we even need one, we may be able to solve enough of the problems and have a working plan that says, in summer 2023, these six things are going to be

27:13 And then we just all need to look back at the plan and say, okay, December 23, are these things all in place or are they all? I think that's the working group. Agreed. And I think the hosts will be able to bring a lot of information back as to where we should put it. So that's a great program. And they have a lot of that already. I just don't know how they have it. Yeah. And like John, Hulis, Hayes could have that already too. So my main point was that I think the destination management plan is a really important step.

27:47 But I would love to see us tick off some of the low-hanging fruit this summer. Well, and I think that, I mean, we know, like you said. Yep, that's right. So other than that, we accept the deliverables as presented. Wonderful. So I have a motion from Mr. Mendel. I have a second from Eric Clark. I'm assuming no further discussion. All right. And so you can do roll call, Angie. Oh, I'm sorry. Go ahead. Just a question. Yeah, not a problem.

28:28 Good question. By when? Because otherwise we're just going to be talking about it next year and say, yeah, well, didn't we have somebody who was going to, Bill, you said the forest service, you know, by when? I would realistically say. So by August 1st? All right, I think we're ready for roll call, Andrew. Chair Goico? Yes. Vice Chair Foster? Yes. Treasurer Morris? Yes. Secretary Mendel? Yes. Board Member Clerk? Yes. Board Member Crabb? Yes. Board Member Radcliffe? Yes.

29:23 Board Member Souser. Yep. And if we can get, you know, May has been, you know, pretty busy for us with all the TBID stuff we've been doing. You know, I'm hoping we're coming to the end of that process. But, you know, June, for, you know, for you and me, John, it would be great to get a meeting in June if that's possible, you know. Well, Jeremy, let me just say, I think it's going to take more than a bill. The town is going to have to push.

29:54 Yeah. That we've got to have more constituents in them than just, well, MLT. Because one of my ongoing concerns is we're always ready to step up and take on new responsibility. Coordinating this meeting is, what can we do? Three months from now, we're going to hear about how MLT didn't get this or something else. Not our sole responsibility. It's going to take more people rolling. And, you know, if we can get help from the ski area as well, because I know you guys have a very good, obviously, your entire operation.

30:46 operates there on forest service lanes. And I know it's a major focus point. Yeah. Yeah. Pushing confident voices, not just MLT raising their hand. Absolutely. Please, won't you meet with us? We're trying to put it, you know, we're trying to coordinate things. Yeah. It's got to be a number of people. If it's a priority, then we all need. All right, wonderful. Urdi and I will take the lead on, you know, starting that conversation to get that meeting in place. You know, I think town council, ski resort, forest service.

31:24 You know, I think MLTPA with Joel Rathje, I mean, he is a wealth of knowledge. Getting him involved would be, you know, essential as well. Stop it. Not MLTPA. Joel Rathje is our trails coordinator. Sorry. Trails coordinator. What we paid for by the town of Mammoth Lakes, not MLTPA. Can I say Mammoth Lakes Trail System? System, yes. That's what it is. I apologize. MLTPA is the previous. Mammoth Lakes Trail System. No, thank you. I appreciate. I appreciate.

31:54 You know. All right. Moving on to 5.3. MLT Board Ad Hoc Compensation and Benefits Committee. Oh, yes, we did. We did. We did. Okay. Sorry. Yeah. We did. That's fine. Can we go out and come back in? I can't. You understand. Five minutes ago? Wow. Sorry, guys. Bye-bye. We're moving quick, you know. We had a lot to cover today.

32:26 It's all right. I got us off with a little extra discussion there. I felt it was an important point, so I appreciate, Eric Clark, your discussion point there. So, Ad Hoc Compensation and Benefits Committee, recommendations by three-member Ad Hoc Committee on proposed Mammoth Lakes Tourism staff compensation and benefits. This was presented to us by John Urdi at last month's board meeting during the budget overview.

32:55 The group was supposed to be me, John Mendel, and Pat Foster. I was out of town, so I asked John Morris to step in in my stead. John, can you report on your discussion? Yeah, thanks. Sure, thank you, Mr. Chair. So basically, the request was two-part, was two-fold. The request number one was for a 5% July 1 increase for all staff except for

33:25 our Executive Director, as well as continuing the normal review date and a 0 to 4% increase, which is part of the normal review process. That was number one. Number two was to cover 100% of staff-dependent insurance premiums, health insurance premiums. So what we asked Mr. Urdi to do was to basically

33:52 Give to us a pretty comprehensive list of other DMOs in the state. I think there were 18, John, all together? 12. 12, okay, 12, sorry. 12 different DMOs and what the salary ranges were, what the different benefit packages were, and these were all similar, so we're not talking about San Francisco, San Diego, Los Angeles. These are DMOs that are more like us. So we analyzed all that data, had a really good discussion, and basically came up with a couple different solutions.

34:22 One, the group felt unanimously that giving a 5% increase in July 1st and also approving up to a 4% increase in performance reviews this next year was going to be too much of a heavy lift for one year. We just felt that given the current environment that that full amount could potentially be too much. And also looking at the health insurance premium situations.

34:51 Most DMOs do not cover dependence. Some do, to some degree. And some companies within the town, private businesses here, do cover dependence. Some of them cover dependence at 50%. There's a kind of a wide range of things that are done. So we basically came up with a two-part solution. One was that we would split the difference. Also, one other piece. We wanted to sort of bring back the...

35:20 Reviewed the review dates or the reviews for all the staff to July 1st so that we weren't doing a review every couple of months just to make it easier for John and make it more consistent. So to push for all staff to be reviewed in July of 23 and then consistently on July 1st every year. So basically what we came up with was that first part of the changing the review date to July 1st.

35:48 Really giving two different options to staff. One was to have a 7% July 1st increase to help offset inflation, and that was one option. The other option was a 5% increase, and if staff wished to have their dependents covered, that they could do so at 50% of the cost.

36:16 MLT would pick up 50% of the cost of the dependents' health insurance premiums, and that staff would cover the rest. So it was an either-or option. Either a 7% increase and not picking up any of the insurance, or a 5% increase and the option to go 50%. And in analyzing the cost to the company, basically it breaks out to be about the same. So those were the two options that the committee came up with. We felt that that was fair.

36:46 And that's what we're recommending to the board. John, that's in lieu of any further increases. Correct, thank you. Yeah, so that would cover any, so there would not be any increases or performance reviews until July 2020. So nothing on top of that. So that's what we came up with. Any questions, discussion, feel free to, or Pat, if you want to jump in, or John, if you want to jump in. I understand the logic and have a question as it's related to making sure that we're tweaking people.

37:21 Is there any concern that you have two different packages of 5% and insurance, 7% no insurance? We discussed that. We didn't feel that it was at that time that was necessary for attorney review. We felt that it was a fair compensation between the two. So I guess the short answer is no. I think what Eric is saying is employees that don't have insured, that's not giving them the option of the extra 50% of the health care.

38:01 So would we then offer 7% to those who don't choose to use them? Yes. I'm sorry if that wasn't clear. That would be their option. So they would either get a 7% increase or they would get a 5% increase and they'd be able to do 50%. Two options for the whole organization. I'm sorry. No. I mean, and then decide in August. Like an annual renewal. Yeah, it would have to be a July 1st decision.

38:44 A follow-up question to that is that I'm assuming because those two options exist that there are several staff members that would pick either option, correct? So this is the recommendation from the ad hoc committee. We don't need to vote on this right now. This is just a discussion. We're going to vote on it when we vote on the budget. Yeah, I put it on here as a vote. Oh, you did?

39:32 Recommendations, proposed. It would be covered under the, that's what I was assuming. So to be clear on that, the built into the budget that John had done for 23, so this is not, this is not in any way what that budget, in fact, it made. Any further questions or discussions on this topic before we move on? Wonderful. So moving on to 5.4, presentation of draft, MLT fiscal year 22-23, plans and budgets.

40:39 So board discussion on the final plan and budgets. Yeah, so I'm going to just go over one document here. Okay. And I'm not expecting you to read this. I think everybody has it in front of us. So basically this is the year-over-year document. What you're showing us, John, it's in the agenda, right? It is. That's what I'm bringing it up. For those of us that are following along a particular page or something. It's the year-over-year comparison. Budget comparison. Oh, it's the very last page, Angie. So as I said, there's...

42:07 Just for the board, if you're following along on the agenda, it's page 125 of 130 that John is covering right now. Okay.

43:21 It's okay. It's close to the end. So the second line employee benefits, that's exactly what you spoke about. I had full coverage for all on the overhead side. We did go up $3,500. We're going to be taking on this winter. United Airlines came back to us and they required a $10 million insurance. We were able to get them down to $5 million, a $5 million policy on top of the current $1 million policy.

44:08 We need to go out and buy another $4 million, which is about that $3,500 mark. And that's really the only major hurdle that we had with working with United was to increase that insurance from where we currently had a general liability of $1 million in occurrence to $5 million. So that's a $3,500 change there. On the marketing side, this is a sizable change. So in the fiscal year 21-22 budget,

44:34 I had added $100,000 for advanced airlines prepaying for this summer. Our accountant came back to us since we weren't flying the entire month of June. They came back and pro-rated and said you can't charge all that in this fiscal year. And so what we can charge in this fiscal year is $51,000, which means that the carryover for the remaining $100,000 will come into this year, but that brought the 2022-23 budget up by $49,000. And we'll talk similarly with United on the

45:04 So that's the current change there. Then the other thing that I did was I didn't have a prepay for summer 23, so I had to add another 51,000, which is roughly what we had with the service for advance this year into the June of 2023. So we had a $51,000 underage to the fiscal year last year budget? Yes. Yep. Yep.

45:31 And then, like I said, we'll talk about United. It's kind of a similar story on the lower side here. So no changes to sales, communications, or special events. And again, the MLT, Measure A Reserves, not the joint reserves for the town. The Measure A Reserves were used to balance that. As we go down into the TBID, the exact same. Can I ask some questions back on Measure A? Yeah.

46:01 In the Measure A and not in this, but in the all the little stuff that gave me a headache that I had to put these on for, John? Sorry. In the air subsidy, $25,000 back in whatever month it was. Right. Which is a holdover from last year. Correct. But there's another $175,000 in there total coming from the town that is not in the town budget. Correct. So there was a conversation I started with Rob Patterson a month or so ago.

46:42 But we are looking for the expenses fully budgeted if the revenue doesn't come in. Okay, the other issue I was having in looking at it is there seemed to be a yo-yo with what the reserves was and maybe I want to leave on you, what do you want? Sorry. We go from an $800,000 reserve that we're using $361,000 out of to a $1.4 million reserve that we're using $722,000 out of and it's kind of a yo-yo.

47:26 I'm trying to get my fingers around all of that. So there are two different accounts. So the 800,000 is the MLT measure. These are the ones that we had before the reunion in 2017. The other 625 is from the settlement. So that's where the one point is. And that's why when you look at it, so that's where that one point is. I tried to find it and I didn't. And I'm pretty good at going over these things, as you know. So you may want to explain that in your presentation tonight on the budget so that we don't...

48:14 Go sideways, and I'm not here until 10. Well, and it's not necessarily part of the presentation tonight, so if you want to ask them, we can do the presentation. My wine supply is much lower for me going through that. No outstanding receipt. There's no payback. I missed that. I assumed it was right off. Yeah, I think we reported that at one of the meetings, but they actually paid us months early. And that is where, so when we talk about the fact this year, for this summer, but for next year, we're budgeting the $300,000.

49:33 The original investment that we had on the wood site was $300,000. The proceeds from the settlement were $300,000 plus interest and penalties, so that was about $322,000. And so we'll take that $322,000, which is above and beyond the original investment, and use that for event funding for 2023. The other question I think you're probably going to get tonight is on the funding of advanced area repair.

50:00 On a knee-jerk that all the advanced air is either coming from the town's budget or from the Measure A budget without anything coming from the TBID budget. And so have we decided as a TBID group that we are abandoning the L.A. market? So there is $200,000 in the TBID budget. When I sent the Excel files, there are notes on there. And there's a prepayment. So we have a $200,000 prepayment in TBID for the prepayment for the winter season 2023 with advanced.

50:32 So there's $200,000 of the $625,000 coming in from TBID. So there is, I heard you loud and clear when I presented the last time, I wanted to make sure that there was some scheme from TBID as well. And so there's $200,000, which is the initial payment, because we do pay up front, and then when that runs down, we equal the money. Any other questions on the Measure A side? Just to go back to the events, for this year that we're in,

51:03 The $300,000, it's an increase from what we had done this year. What were we worried? It was like one for this year? Well, no, for the events that are budgeted for this summer, it was $220,000. Oh, $220,000. Yeah, so we're putting about an extra $70,000. I'm rolling back down here. The TBID, so again, the wages are split. There's no change in the overhead. The only overhead in TBID. The marketing line, this is again where we had Sunday. It's basically just take that same $120,000.

52:47 for June of 23 to prepare for summer service of 23. So we got a little bit of a double hit there, so that's why we're up about a couple hundred. And those are really the only changes to the budget since we presented it last month. I think, as I mentioned, there are a couple of things out there that are still somewhat wild cards. The contract, I'm working with Inyo County on potentially partnering in on air subsidy, and so that's going to be something that won't come out probably until

53:25 I think their process is June, July, August. I'm presenting to the ESCOG on June 10th. I'm presenting to the Board of Supervisors on June 14th. And I'm requesting that the county participates at $500,000 towards air subsidy in general. That may get us to year-round air service, or it may just contribute towards helping us get a longer summer season, fall season. Very similar to what we did with the Mammoth County Supervisors way back in 2010.

53:52 Mammoth County Supervisors wanted to see us fly in the fall, and that's where they started to contribute to the cost. So, you know, depending on what comes in there, that's a possible change. And then the other piece that becomes a factor that we haven't settled yet is the subsidy for air transportation from Bishop Airport to town. This year that was $300,000, but talking with them, we're looking at potentially having that become maybe a $200,000 cap next year.

54:22 Right now, I just got the invoices this morning. This year we came in at about $210,000. There is still, the contract runs through September 6th. So even though it's currently short of the $300,000 commitment, it depends on what happens with the summer service. So there's still about $90,000 roughly available if needed for that summer service. But again, next year I think that we can drive that number down and hopefully.

54:49 with increased exposure and passengers that we can get that number non-existent. And then I think that the idea is to continue to lean that off, whether it's one more year or two more years, but that is the goal. So we budgeted $300,000 for the fiscal year we're in now.

55:07 And we're coming in right now at 210. Correct. And that might go up slightly because we still have a couple months left with that. Well, there's still the summer service. September to September, right? Correct. So we'll have a final accounting for last fiscal year, even though it's both of our, runs through two of our fiscal years until September. Correct. Is there any way to get it on our fiscal year or you kind of have to keep it on this September? I think it'll be something that we work on for next year.

55:36 So what I'll probably do when we work on it. So September negotiations. And so those are really the only changes. For the 22-23 fiscal year, are we going down to $200,000 for this next fiscal year, or do you still have? Oh, okay. Yeah, I had it budgeted in there. So once we get to September, we're going to kind of. Well, the plan is to work on that. Those are the changes.

57:21 to the budget moving forward for 22-23 fiscal year. Seems pretty straightforward to me. Yeah, and again, to Mr. Sauser's point, the town has us capped a 2 million in this, which is part of our new compensation of the scope or the 2 million cap and then potentially the deliverables if they're... Anything to add from the town side on that? No. That all sounds good. We will need to start the discussion with the town of, you know...

58:13 We want to line up the renewal of the TBID that 10-year, which there seems to be plenty of support for that. We need to figure out some rate things, which we'll discuss a little later. But, you know, we would like to see with the town, you know, a 10-year contract that kind of mirrors that TBID contract that we're in. Your executive committee or whoever it is that's working this point, it would really... Okay. Well, thank you for that. That's good to know. Well, and I do think that we, you know, the contract, we have a...

58:53 A year and nine days on our contract starting contract as we have done in the past. So to your point, counsel, in the past we've had two council members and board members, town staff and me, and I do think that there will be when we settle where we're going with TBID. To talk to Rob about the contract process? Yeah, about the contract process. Yeah, he and I have talked about it and we both... It's on his radar too. Correct, yep. Yeah, Rob and I still meet pretty regularly. Yeah, because he's kind of our liaison with this whole process. Can't busy right now. He's a busy man.

1:00:30 Let me come back to my... Do we have any further... Do we need to take action here? Vote if needed. So, any further discussion, questions on these changes? I think we're all on the same page there. All right. Do I have a motion to approve the marketing plan and budgets as presented for fiscal year 22-23? So moved. Mr. Morris? I'll second.

1:01:12 All right. Second from Mr. Mendel. Any further discussion? All right. Angie, roll call. Certainly. I just have one question. On the budget, did it need to be amended for the compensation items that were talked about earlier or no? I believe those are all included. They're incorporated there to this. Okay. Thank you. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Chair Goyko? Yes. Vice Chair Foster? Yes.

1:01:50 Treasurer Morris? Yes. Secretary Mendel? Yes. Board Member Clark? Yes. Board Member Crabb? Yes. Board Member Radcliffe? Yes. And Board Member Souser? Yo. Thank you. I want to make sure that was a yo as in yes from Mr. Souser, not a yo as in no. Yes, dear. Thank you, Bill. All right.

1:02:16 Moving on to our Tourism Business Improvement District TBID Renewal Update. I'm going to share the document. Oh, okay. Do you want me to give a little introduction on this, John? Yeah, if you want to go kind of through the process that we've had and then... Yeah, so we have our current TBID steering committee. That is myself, John Morris, John Mendel, Eric Clark, and Mr. Urdi.

1:02:50 And we have been in touch with our Civitas about the process of, you know, putting together the formal contract and everything. We are looking at a 10-year TBID renewal here. The steering committee put together some recommendations that we presented to an advisory panel. We had about...

1:03:16 20 people in attendance from the community. We received feedback. We met again as a steering committee. From the advisory panel, the biggest pushback that we kind of received was on the proposed or recommended rate increase. The rate increase was a half point or 0.5 percent.

1:03:42 across the board for all industries, retail, lodging, restaurant, and ski area. After hearing that feedback and that concern from the community, our steering committee met again. What we have arrived at is a tiered introduction into that rate increase.

1:04:08 We are going to be in our current TBID for one more fiscal year, the one upcoming, and then it would be for the 23-24 fiscal year that we're looking at the start of the new TBID. We would have two years at the same rate. After that two years, we would bump up a quarter percent, go three years with that quarter percent bump, and then, you know, basically in year five of the 10-year TBID renewal,

1:04:38 We would do another quarter point bump to get us to that half point that we had originally recommended. So that's kind of where our steering committee stands right now. We wanted to bring that to the attention of the board and get feedback from our board members. And we have started to...

1:05:03 Put that out to some of the individual members of the advisory panel to get feedback on that. And I believe, you know, John Mundell, John Urdi have been able to have a couple conversations and they can kind of report on their individual discussions. But why don't you take it with your... Yeah, the only thing I'll correct on you is that when we go to the .25, it's a four year at the .25 and then four years at the .25. So it would be two years flat, four years at a .25 increase.

1:05:33 But in fairness, sure, the first thing is TB's decisions aren't stated. So, yeah, so I just don't want to, if we get approval, actually signing up for, or else I think we're going to, one size fits all, that that is our process. This is our idea. This is the idea right now. Right, but it's not, if we renew TBID, then this is absolutely what we're going to do. Yeah, so this is the recommendation.

1:07:06 from the steering committee. And the reason we're recommending an increase, which this is what we presented to the advisory panel, is the two main reasons are first, we have an accessibility issue. Mammoth is hard to get to. So BIH, the move to Bishop, we have

1:07:35 You know, in our first year, data showing that Denver was a very good success. So, we want to expand to markets that are east of us. The top three that we're looking at are Phoenix, Salt Lake City, and Dallas. In no particular order there. You know, but we want to increase, you know, our goal is 75,000 employments between BIH and MMH.

1:08:02 Advanced Air is off to a great start at MMH. There is, you know, some room for improvement there and some further, you know, maybe we can get a San Jose or an Oakland or something like that in there. You know, obviously that's more of our regional, you know, California, you know, flight options into Mammoth, right? But, you know, how are we going to get those folks coming from New York, Florida, Chicago?

1:08:32 Texas, internationally, you know, how are we going to get those folks to Mammoth in a more accessible, easier fashion, right? This has been our long-term air service goals, you know, that we had this big speed bump with COVID that kind of derailed, you know, our, you know, and we just kind of had to put the pause button there for a little while, but this is, you know, before COVID, this was our plan, you know, and now we're finally able to realize it.

1:09:02 And I think that's, not to interrupt you, I think that's hugely important because, you know, we're now competing on a much broader playing field than everything else. People get to shop now. Yep. They get to choose whether they're going to fly to Deer Valley, Steamboat, wherever. Big Sky, Jacksonville. And we're going to be compared and say, gee, you know, that was really easy. I flew into Salt Lake an hour later, I was skiing versus, gee, you know, I had to drive from L.A. or, you know, whatever it is. So that accessibility piece is huge.

1:09:40 And frankly, if we don't get that right, the town no longer has a housing problem, Bill. You know what? Affordable or otherwise. Because without the jobs and the tourists, you know, we're just fine the way we are. And if that's where we want to stay, I don't. I'd like to compete with the best of them. And so that accessibility piece, I think, is hugely important. We've been able to dodge under the radar because we were sort of that unique sort of, we're mammoth, you know.

1:10:10 But now we're getting, we're at the big kids table with a lot of very professional, easier to get to resorts. So why here versus somewhere else that's a lot easier? Precisely. And I would say for a certain percentage of our visitors, while I have always agreed, but not because it brings in enough people to justify what we spend on it, travel air service, Sierra Pacific, Wings, Alpha Air, it goes on and on and on. Don't say reliable. The drive market has actually increased because of the perception.

1:10:46 Accessibility. Accessibility. It's not how many people come in. But the problem is, for the same pass now, I can go to all those and try them. Before, you had to pick your mountain, right? You got a Mammoth pass, you skied Mammoth, regardless of, you know, who would give you the day. If you're skiing, we still entertain some 4 million visitors annually. That's right. Even 100,000, which is more than we're hoping to get, is a small drop in the bucket to our total visitor population. While I support the accessibility. Right.

1:11:17 The idea that we have to have it to bring the people in. Well, then maybe we shouldn't do it. Yeah, well, that's an argument. It's only 100,000 people. It's an argument that you're not going to get from me, but it is an argument. I'm just saying, but you said it. It's only 100,000 people. If we're willing to write them off and say, go to Salt Lake, go to Deer Valley, whatever. I'm not. No, I'm not. I want every one of them. It is a piece of the overall puzzle.

1:11:43 Sure. Absolutely. Absolutely. But we got the easy stuff. Now we're more and more difficult increments of who we want to get, whether it's international markets or whatever. Those people tend to spend more. They tend to be a little bit more discretionary income than others. And that's who I want. And they're usually here long. I want coming to Footloose, and I want them coming to the mountain, I want them coming to the distillery, because they're going to spend money. Yeah. I think that's, you know, what do we...

1:12:12 You know, it may only be 100,000 people, you know, coming on the flight, but, you know, what are we getting for that? You know, I think that's, you know, the quality of that visitor is kind of what we're after here. Listen to the idiocy of that comment, not your comments. But it's only, no, no, no. I mean, the fact that we can say it's only 100,000 people.

1:12:37 You know, I'm not saying that was idiotic, but I'm just saying, to even have this discussion about, yeah, well, you know, it's only 100,000 people, I mean, it's a small portion of what, we either want them or we don't. Let's make that decision. I want them. Let's say that. I want to make that clear. I do too. I want them. I do too. But I'm just saying, the fact that we can even say that. Yeah. We made that commitment a long time ago. In today's environment talking about looming recessions and everything else, is stupid. Yeah. I hear it. I hear you.

1:13:05 We made the commitment to get that type of visitor here a long time ago, and we need to stay with it. It is a long-term strategy, and it's something that we're executing on, and it's important to do so. And Jeremy, you started off by explaining why we need to increase the TBID in order to have the appropriate funding to go after that marketplace. And it's not something we're going to be able to be pivot on a dime like what we've been able to do a lot in the past. But back to your procedure question, John, I completely agree with you that

1:13:35 This is a recommendation. And in fact, it was different when we took it to the steering committee. They gave us feedback. We adjusted it. And we even have more adjustments now. And we're understanding, to Bill, your comment, that there's some other rumblings about the years. In the steering committee, there was no comment about the length of time for the TBID, by the way. Everybody understood it. And they really said, we really do want the TBID.

1:14:02 It's benefited our business. That's been their feedback. So back to your very first question, should we renew the TBID? All the feedback we got on that was yes. Yeah, and I think that's why we just need to be clear that there are two separate issues. Exactly. And then as we look at this and know that we're going to have a need for more funding with these other flights that we want to invest in. But...

1:14:28 Hearing our constituents and saying, okay, we're not going to increase it right now. And in fact, we're not even going to increase it for sure. We'll vote on it in 2025 when we have to vote on it. So this is what we expect the increase to be, but we still, as a board, need to vote on that increase. So it's not a for sure thing that this is the way we're going if we renew the TBID.

1:14:54 And so that's what we've been talking about, and we understand that there is some concern with timing, so we thought, okay, let's not vote on this here today. Maybe we take it back and make sure we're communicating exactly what you were suggesting. I want to bring up one more point that we haven't brought up yet that was part of our discussion, and that's locals. And one of the things we talked about was the current status of things in town. It's been a tough haul the last few years.

1:15:23 We're kind of coming out of this. We don't know exactly what we're looking at for the next couple of years. And we do recognize the fact that locals do pay into the TBID when they go to restaurants and when they go to retail. That is a fact. And it may not be a lot, but everything that a local has to pay is something. And we all here, regardless of our economic status, all pay into that. Some of it's easier for some of us and some of it's harder for others.

1:15:49 So that was also, I want to make it clear to the public that that was part of the discussion. One of the reasons why we're recommending not to increase the TBID two years after we renew is precisely for that reason because we don't want it to be a negative effect. That's very important. Even though it's a smaller sector of the TBID that locals pay into, obviously locals don't participate in lodging and to some degree in the ski area. It's mostly restaurant retail. But we want everybody to understand that. That was absolutely part of our discussion with the steering committee.

1:16:20 So we don't want to be tone deaf to that because we understand that we've heard that from locals. Locals do pay into TBID to some extent and so we're really careful with that. So we'll make sure that's clear. Yeah, good point. Thank you for bringing that up. And I wasn't calling you an idiot. You're just for Bill. I mean, coming from a non-government funded private sector, we kill every single customer. To say, well, 100,000 people pales in comparison to what our total.

1:17:00 It's okay, John. People call me an idiot on a day long. See, he's just warming me up here. Larry. I agree with the effort to get the extra 100,000 people. I agree with everything John just said. But to John Morris' point, how are you funding that additional? And, John, what you just brought up is you're funding it through a very regressive tax.

1:17:33 It falls heavily on the locals and it falls heavily on the drive to customer. So you're asking people to fund the attraction of 100,000 people who, by definition, are pretty well-to-do. That's the challenge that you're going to have in selling the increase, that it's a progressive tax. So my question is, is there any other way to fund the attraction? You know, I think, I don't want to make it,

1:18:13 There was part of your comment there that I just, I want to clarify. We're not, you know, we're not subsidizing like somebody's personal flight out to, but we're subsidizing the program. We got to get the program up and running, right? You know, it was decided before Mammoth Lakes Tourism was even formed that MMH was going to be the commercial airport to bring in those flights, and then we experienced.

1:18:42 25% to 30% cancellation rate, which is not sustainable. Even locals were like, I think most people sitting around this room were like, I'm not flying anymore. It's not worth it. It was just such a poor experience. Hence the process to move commercial air down to Bishop. And now, you know,

1:19:06 We've had success with Denver. San Francisco is coming along nicely. We didn't think L.A. was going to work. That's moving off the table. The whole regional is moving to Mammoth and the advanced air. We found a nice balance with Bishop and Mammoth to get people.

1:19:38 So that is, you know, to get this airport to Bishop to where, you know, our goal is, 75,000 employments between the two, you know, we're going to need more funding. So the other, you know, part of it, you know, it's going to cost money for us to go in to somewhere like Boston, New York, Newark, you know, Chicago, Florida.

1:20:04 Dallas, and market to these people that we have a flight that will get them here. We need to let them know that that's available, right? So not only is there the air subsidy to bring that on, but there's also going to be the marketing to let people know that that flight is there. So, you know, those are the discussions that Urdi and I have had. And so, you know, where do we need our budget to be in two, three years once those flights

1:20:34 You know, once Ernie has the time to bring those flights on board coming into Bishop. You know, and that is, you know, that is why we are proposing and recommending a rate increase to the current rate. I think the other way to look in any of those endeavors is to get it up and down. Exactly. There is, if we were sitting here saying, yeah, we're just going to need to subsidize an extra, that's a completely, that's the, to get them over the heart.

1:21:26 or anything else, is to get them over the hump. We're talking about now taking the ground transport, the air subsidies reduced, and we're flying. That's my vision. At some point, we're not going to be subsidizing. We're subsidizing a lot less than we are to get them up. That's a tougher sell because every time you're subsidizing. So you're saying the increases are popular. The point that subsidy works is that we always want to move to the middle. It's not that it's necessarily a... I think the idea is to get a market, the opportunity to keep that just allows us to...

1:22:25 But success will also breed success. If an American sees that it's positive from Dallas or whoever, from Phoenix and everything else, then suddenly you've got a positive momentum going on. We don't need to go out and say, well, we'll give you a half a million dollars if you start. That's in their best interest to do. It will present other opportunities. And it's one important piece which ties into where we are. Just our cap on... The cap is the max. I think the other piece that...

1:23:18 We're waiting on the potential cap for San Francisco and Denver or whether we're flying San Francisco and Denver with doubled-up days in Denver or doubled-up days in San Francisco or whether we're just going to be able to afford two flights this year. So everything's gone up. You know, one of the things that when you look at the United Contract, a one-cent increase in gas means an $8 increase in cost. So a one-cent increase in gas is an $8 increase in cost. So, you know, we've got margins. What's that? It's been more than one cent.

1:23:52 It's been more than one set. It's been a lot more than one set. So just as devil's advocate for a minute, and I will preface this by saying that I have been trying to get more people to Mammoth for years and years and years, and I still believe that that is an important goal of this organization and the town. It is how we survive. Great. However, when we talk about new markets and bringing new people in, I'll introduce you to my world, the number of people I'm going to hear about saying there's already too damn many people in town. Why are we going out seeking new people? So we have to make sure.

1:24:21 As we develop these plans, that we have an answer for that argument. So that's hugely important, because that's what I'm going to hear. That's a great segue. So when we're talking about the destination, we're talking about the other piece of it is during the need period, a lot of this is to get... Bottom line, it's who we are. It's who Mono County is. We are supported by the tourists. We need to find a way. My answer is generally, we don't have too many people. We have too little planning on how to handle the people. That's my answer. Absolutely.

1:25:38 We have a lakes basin that gets overcrowded, but we don't tell them about Glass Creek Meadow, we don't tell them about Sherwin Lakes, we don't tell them about, so my answer is always, let's get the trails crew out there, let's get the Forest Service to work with us, so that instead of continually closing, we did a travel management plan on the Indian National Forest several years ago that I worked on and was very frustrated with. We closed one-third of the dirt roads in the Indian National Forest.

1:26:07 Now we have complaints that the dirt roads are too busy. Okay, so we're planning backwards as our population increases, as our tourism increases. We are reducing the number of miles in the areas for them to operate in and we're artificially creating this closure. So my eye has been working for decades, way before the town became a town, to do the opposite. Let's make more trails. Let's allow more roads open.

1:26:34 Let's go to a larger group of people. Let's get motorcycle clubs in here in May and June. If you've seen the number of bikers on the road, and I have because I'm one of them, it's huge. It's a market force to go to. Do you think the council is? I will tell you the fact. I can't speak for council. I agree with you. I believe I'm a minority. To some degree, then, I think we have. Yes. Because if we're continuing to push a rope uphill, the council is not in support of that.

1:27:22 Which is why I keep playing devil's advocate a little bit, why I keep saying the new piece of local outreach becomes hugely important. We have restaurant workers that don't want to see more people in town, yet they have to work two jobs. I've heard from owners of different businesses that say, look, I want to take my month off in the spring. So let's increase your business to the point where you can afford to do that because you've got a manager you're paying. Okay, sorry to digress. No, no, it's a great conversation for this group to have.

1:27:59 Well, I think it all comes back to this. I think it also goes back to the very first lines of our deliverables that we just approved. The town of Mammoth Lake continues to thrive as a tourism-based destination from the revenues associated with visitation. Mammoth Lake's tourism will continue to work to maximize revenues for our businesses in the town while taking the lead role in education stewardship. So the town council...

1:28:44 It does support us going out to get more. It tacitly improves the fact that that statement is true. Yeah. Again, it's this, well, publicly, but privately, you know, and I think that's the issue. That's where it is. Yeah. Publicly, I said yes, but privately, I mean. I think at this point it would, the plan was to try and get it all figured out. I also wanted to make sure that the rest of the board that's, you know, not on the steering committee, Bill, Deb, that, that, that, understand, you know.

1:29:54 Why we're making this recommendation of the rate increase. And I also want to make sure that we have your support for it, you know, so that, you know, when, you know, local business owners come to you guys and ask why, you know, Mammoth Lakes Tourism is recommending this rate increase to the TBID, that will have somewhat of effect on locals in these two areas specifically. And we are getting some pushback on the retail side.

1:30:22 But also, you know, restaurant there. We haven't heard the pushback from the restaurants quite yet. And we're hoping we don't. We hope we have their support on this. You know, why are we making that recommendation? And so I wanted you guys to understand that and be part of the process there.

1:30:40 I think you're not making changes until 2025, after 2025, right? And so that gives us an opportunity to prove exactly what we can do and how that could benefit the community and the businesses. And if it turns out that we do such a great job that we don't need to increase it, then we'll figure it out at that point. So I think it's really smart to leave it flat until 25. I think it's palatable for the businesses.

1:31:04 Like you said, you know, the locals, it's a little bit challenging, you know, considering, you know, inflation and everything that else is happening, but it's, I think it's minimal at this point. They're used to paying it, so I agree with the approach. All right, wonderful, wonderful, thank you. So, you know, as John mentioned, we're going back to the advisory panel. We want to make sure we have support for this. Again, with the renewal process, our goal is 66%, correct?

1:31:34 61 and 63 in the past. So we want to see that bump up to 66. We want, you know, really good support for this TBID renewal. And so that's a priority as well in this process. Okay, so let's wrap up that discussion. Let's move to financial reports. Yeah, the financial report, well ahead of budget. TBID similarly came in about 10% ahead of budget. To date, we're at 5.9 million on a budget of 4.4.

1:32:52 So that gives us a $1.44 million overage right now, about 32%. Of that $1.44, we've spent about $500,000 of that from the things that we talked about back in the fall, the brand refresh, some of the other things that we needed to do out there, some research. So my guess is that we'll carry over, when it's all said and done after May and June come in, we'll carry over about $1 million, which will cover some of the shortfall from the budget we just approved. So that's still good news. We'll carry that money over.

1:33:22 and put it to good use next year and not have to dig as much into the reserves. You can see the bank balances there. We do have some larger bills that are coming due soon, so those bank balances will shrink a bit. And then the CDARs, as we had mentioned, Bill, right there, the Measure A CDAR is $800,000. Those are our unrestricted Measure A funds in reserve that we have from when we recalibrated back in 2017.

1:33:51 is $4.5 million in the TBID CDARS, and then the special event fund is $617,000, and so that's where the $300,000 for event funding will come from for next year. And then currently the tourist reserve for the fiscal year through the month of April sits at just over $2 million, and so those funds are there for the town to utilize. We've again recommended that they can utilize towards housing.

1:34:18 But again, they're general fund dollars, but $2 million that will remain in town in that aspect. So, questions on the financials? Are we good there? Can we move to department updates? All right, Mr. Vanderhurst, International Sales, good to see you, sir. Thank you. Good to see you all this afternoon. I'm just going to briefly recap May and talk about what we've got coming up in June. A couple of busy months in the books, no doubt about it.

1:34:52 We finished our updated vacation planner. It's at the printers now, so it should be in-house in the next two weeks. You guys remember the vacation planner is the more aspirational piece that we use on the international side. It's not the little booklet piece you'll see outside of ONS. That's a different piece. We just returned from a two-week sales mission in Australia. We were down there with the Altera team, Nico and his whole squad. We did two-week sales trainings in the three major cities in eastern Australia, that being Melbourne, Sydney, and Brisbane.

1:35:22 We also did about 10 days of media visits with the Australian media to talk about our flights for the upcoming winter, the winter 2022-23. Talk about our fantastic snow quality that we had this last year, excuse me. And then we were part of the team that represented Mammoth and the Altera Resorts at the Sydney Ski Show and the Melbourne Ski Show. So very, very active. A couple of weeks down there.

1:35:49 We had three media visits in May into Mammoth Lakes to talk about our winter spring skiing, one from Canada, two from Mexico. Visit California's got a GoPro influencer coming in the next 10 days that we're going to hook up with Pat, our new team member, to do some mountain biking on the mountain. He's actually going to go mountain biking with Gabe Taylor as well. And then on Friday, Brian...

1:36:14 Dakota and myself are leaving for IPW. It's one of the bigger shows in the United States. It's three days of speed dating. Our main talking points will obviously be the opening of Tioga Pass and our new flight service into BIH. So it'll be a busy, busy June. Any questions? Where was that this year? Orlando. Who doesn't want to go to Orlando, right? There's a hurricane coming in. Oh, God. Stay safe, Michael. Wonderful. Communications.

1:36:44 Mark Hayler, hello. Hello, hello. Good afternoon. Busy as well in the communications content and PR department. First, we had a really successful open house earlier in May. Thank you to the board members that were able to attend. We were able to collect 50 surveys during that that we're reviewing right now. Basically, the questions were asked how the community wants us to communicate with them.

1:37:11 So we can get a better understanding of where to put our information. So that was great. Community coffee last week was a success. I was actually on vacation. So Emily Bryant and Brianna from the chamber led the charge on that one. And we changed the time to 8.30. And I think that's really successful. Gives people time to drop off their kids and kind of get back to their computers. So I think Emily said,

1:37:37 Everybody showed up right on time rather than trickling in between 8 and 8.30, so that was great. What else? We worked with Visit California to host an influencer this last month, and basically she was promoting spring here. Going back to Chair Goiko's comments at the last meeting, it was great. She talked about spring skiing, eating, drinking, all of the good spring...

1:38:01 things going on, so she was on a road trip and was only here for two days, but got some really great coverage there. The crib has been really busy. We hosted some athletes from Moment Skis last month, and so they were doing some spring backcountry skiing, produced a great video with them, so we've got that up on our YouTube channel right now. We're also planning for this

1:38:29 Writers Conference in October. Things are starting to get hot and heavy with that. If any of you planned a big event, you know it starts months in advance. So we're building the registration landing page, sorting out the activities, getting all that dialed. Registration will open on August 1st. So a couple months to get that all set up. And then finally, we're working on switching our web content over to summer at this point, getting everything.

1:38:56 Winter out and just, you know, all the camping and activities. Emily's been doing a great job keeping all the blogs updated with the road openings and all those great things. So, any questions? Thank you. Wonderful. Thank you, Laura. All right, marketing, Brian Wright. Good afternoon. All right, quick updates here. The Bishop Summer Research programming is happening right now as far as the survey itself.

1:39:25 John likes to prove that today. We had a little bit of an issue over the wintertime just getting an actual researcher. We have a great guy who's down at Bishop right now, so he's going to start next week. We should have him running the entire way through, so excited to get that rolling.

1:39:37 Summer Creative is up and running right now, and on recommendation of the board, we did move from a kind of a heavier come up and visit message than kind of the hug and be responsible. I say that, you know, even the come up and visit message does have and recreate responsibly tagging, so everything we do is saying please responsibly recreate while you're here. We started, we tend to, with our marketing, we tend to be kind of higher in the funnel on the inspirational side of things.

1:40:03 With the flight service, we decided to go a little bit tactical, like right now, so we'd send out like a travel zoo, we spent, you know, 10 grand on travel zoo, working with Expedia right now. Travel zoo launched on Friday of last week, and I got a report from Barb on Monday that she sold 100 tickets over the weekend, so we spent 10 to make 20, 250, or whatever, yeah, so it's like, we're, so it's working, so it's like, kind of tactical things are working, we're going to do more of that, as we kind of move forward. And then,

1:40:28 Planning's underway. Oh, man, there's one more going up first. That was specifically for United. I mean, sorry, specifically for Advanced Air. And then one goes out next week for United. And then we have an expedient program that's launching also in two weeks. And then we are well underway for our photo shoots. So we have two photo shoots that we had for this new campaign that's launching in October. The first photo shoot went down wonderfully. The second photo shoot's happening on the 15th and 16th of this month. We run into a little bit of a pickle.

1:40:58 The agency that we're using now, Shipyard, when they've got where Merring got bought off, so it was Merring first, they got bought off by Shipyard, they moved to a pre-bill situation, so typically we would just do the shoot, then they would bill us on the back end, and it's all good and set, all done. Now we have to kind of pay up front. So we're on the hook right now for about $178,000 in order to make this shoot happen in two weeks. I have found, I know where I can pull the money from, but I'm going to need to move money from a couple different light items, so that's when I asked, just to kind of show you what I'm doing right now, and that would be from research,

1:41:28 55,000 from research, 30,000 from our media, and then 9,000 from our hosting line up into that. Now, it doesn't take away from the research that we're doing. We're just able to do that next year, just in a month. So we're just kind of moving things for a month. So that'd be about, so we're looking at, you know, take those 55 from research, 30 from media, 9 from hosting, and then I found another 84,000 in production that we're able to do there, too. So that'll get us to that number, but I'm just wanting to say, do I have your blessing to make that happen?

1:42:03 Totally. So, you know, negotiation, I understand that they need an outlet. So, the original number was $250,000. Yes. So, okay, well, good for that. So, if we should be able to come down. Yes, sir. Yes, sir. Totally. Yeah. And that's, John and I have been talking about that. And we're moving, and these are the hard costs. So, what we were able to negotiate with them was the hard costs. So, the bill was $250,000, $275,000, and we pull it down to $178,000. But these are the hard costs for the collection of the $20,000. And I'm with you. I don't even know what it should. Yeah. It's, we're going to see. Yeah.

1:43:02 They're based in, well, the new company's based out of Ohio. But where all of our, the agencies, it's all, it's the same, our crew stayed the same. So we're very happy with, I mean, don't get me wrong, we're happy with the agency and the creative, like, very happy. It's just from the, is this just a, yeah, we're not, so it's not like we're paying more. It's just that we, normally this would have gone, because when I initially asked for this, like, when we talked about this initially, it was going to be, you know, the 200 this year and then another next year. This is just that.

1:43:43 Next year's money coming into a month early. Right. This is a month early. So I'm able to kind of make some modifications in those line items to where like the research, we can just pay for it. We're not losing anything at this point. Do we need to do anything procedural for that? I don't believe so because it's not a change. He's not asking for a variance. He's just informing us. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I think you have the consensus.

1:44:18 Blessing from the board, Brian, thank you for communicating with that change. With the request of exurbia. Yeah. Hands down. With the request of a, just mention that. But also, oh no. Tell them the board is not happy with this billing change. But you know what? Well, especially because it changed ownership. Yeah. That's. Ohio. Even though it is the same team. It's the same team, but just now there's a little bit.

1:44:58 It just feels, yeah. But again, I want to be very, I mean, we're very happy with this thing. It's always good to see what else is out there. Thank you, Brian. Appreciate that. All right. Dakota, special events and social media. All right. We can drop that part. I'd like you guys to meet Patrick. I don't know if you guys have met Patrick yet. He's not going to be presenting today, but he will be presenting at our next. He was brought on. He's our new digital content coordinator.

1:45:43 We are so excited to have him on board. He's been doing an awesome job, actually so much so that in the last month that we've seen him on board, we've seen a 32.5% increase in our engagement.

1:45:54 Over the last three months than what we've had on there. We finally have someone dedicated to that being their job. So if you guys have content needs or things like that, please absolutely link Pat into those emails. Like I said, we're super stoked to have him on board. With that, come June 1st, we are fully switching over to the responsible recreation messaging going out on our social platforms, right? The hug what you love information going out and all messaging moving forward, whether it's come mountain bike or go golfing, we'll have that like stewardship message.

1:46:23 messaging tied into it. So there's nowhere to escape it on our digital footprint at this point. And I'll be linking back into the different webpages that we have that are already set up for that. On that note, we also will be pushing emphasis with fire updates and information on just...

1:46:38 Keeping Your Campfires. We actually filmed a spot with our Hug What You Love campaign last year about how to properly put campfires out, and I'll be circling back and making sure that we have that up front and center. Maybe we can get something out on social where that plays as a really big reminder out for those individuals as well.

1:46:55 On that note, our website is actually looking pretty good right now. We have a 59.8% increase in unique sessions month over month, so we're starting to see things going back up. We had just over 100,000 unique viewers on our website last month, 106,000. Once again, 73,000 of those were on mobile, so we are really catering toward that direction. The time on site is a little bit lower than we still want. We're slowly working our way back up to where we were pre-pandemic levels for that.

1:47:25 Thanks to the lovely help of our team, our bounce rate has actually fallen 9%. So we're actually figuring out where to put that good content on the website to make sure that when people are clicking, they're being engaged and they're getting the good content directly forward and purposeful content for what's happening for their vacation. So we're super stoked on that. In the events world, we are getting ready to launch the summer event season. It is cranking. The Mammoth Lakes Film Festival last weekend was super successful. We are getting...

1:47:54 Getting ready to go into the end of June, right? This is when everything pretty much takes off around town. We'll be starting our weekly emails for events. The first one will be coming out the end of this week for you folks. Also, we have a new summer event poster that's going to print literally as we speak right now, as well as new event brochures that will be here by next Wednesday in the mail. So be on the lookout. All these bits of content for you guys to be able to go out will be hopefully in your guys' businesses here within the next week to really make sure

1:48:23 That we're geared for what's happening this summer through the fall, event brochure, what's going on year-round here in Mammoth, and really be able to get some more literature out to you folks. On that note, I also launched the brand new camp host program that I've been working on. So I met last week with all 64 of our campground hosts from all the campgrounds in our region. Over half of them had never, ever heard of the resource Visit Mammoth before. This is the problem that I recognized existed, and I could see the writing on the wall, our largest lodging property in the summer, and over half of the campgrounds.

1:48:52 The ones who are disseminating this information to the campers didn't even know that we were a resource. So I met face to face with them. They got to know myself. They know that Emily's a resource. They know how to get a hold of us. I'm also going to be sending them out weekly emails out to these campground hosts.

1:49:06 Letting them know what's going on around town. Letting them know what trails are open. And more importantly, just creating a conversation with them so that if we have information about recreating responsibly and this and that that we're trying to get out to them and to our campers, they actually know where to go and where to look and how that information can be received. I'm super excited about that. Also attended the Tourism Cares Conference with Emily this last month. Learned a whole bunch of stuff about stewardship that I'd like to bring to these conversations that you guys started having earlier. On that note,

1:49:35 Trashy Thursday starts tomorrow, every Thursday through October 1st. October 1st will officially be Mammoth Lakes Facelift, Act Local, the largest stewardship project that ever happened in the Eastern Sierra. We're bringing it back bigger and better than ever this year. We have a bunch of organizations on board, including one Clean Up the Lake from the Lake Tahoe area. They're actually coming down this next Monday, Tuesday. They're scoping out all of the lakes for our lakes basin, Convict Lake and the June Lake Loop to do underwater trash cleanups in them as well.

1:50:04 So getting the ball moving, got some cool stuff coming forward, I'm super fired up about it, we out. I don't have a question, I just have a comment. We have two of my favorite events coming up, Mammoth Motocross and July 4th Parade, so I'm excited. Thank you for all the event information. Dakota. Okay, Emily Bryan, I am the office manager and marketing assistant for Mammoth Lake Tourism.

1:50:33 And I'll keep this very brief. Along the stewardship messaging lines, we started four different radio ads that are running on KMMT, KHRV, and Eastern Sierra Now, which is on Spotify. These four radio ads talk about specifically the ways to properly behave in town, around water, while you're camping, and in the mountains on our trails.

1:51:00 We are producing some physical posters to match these messaging you.

1:51:04 Probably saw these during the 2020 season. The posters also were living in our bus stops and whatnot through the last summer season. We're revamping them to make some of that message a little bit stronger. And so you'll see a lot of those coming out in the next couple of months, but you'll already see the radio or hear the radio ads. If you for some reason are not listening to one of those channels and you want to hear those four ads, send me an email and I will send the ads directly to you because I can do that.

1:51:32 We also, because it's June 1st and we're switching over completely to our summer messaging and our Hug What You Love, we have a new welcome banner that went up today at the corner at Footloose. I'm very proud of it, so please everybody go take a look at it.

1:51:49 We also will be doing a banner for the 4th of July that will just share all of the activities in one. So this is so that we don't have different events fighting over the event space. And we have a blog on our website that all of you can direct visitors to. Visit Mammoth.com forward slash July 4.

1:52:09 VisitMammoth.com forward slash July 4. You can find that live on our blog right now. It has all of the events. If you are hosting an event over that weekend and you don't have your information in there, send me an email at ebryant at VisitMammoth.com and I'll get all your information up. Stickers and maps. We went out and delivered stickers and maps across the town last week before Memorial Day. If you didn't get those or you all of a sudden already need more in your business, please let me know and I can bring you more.

1:52:36 Quick call out, the map has a QR code on the bottom of it that directs back to mammothtrails.org and has a full list of all the trails that are available. The rules for e-bikes are also available there on their summer recreation handout. So that is a really great QR code to point all your visitors to if they're looking for trails or where they can take their bikes. Okay.

1:52:58 And then, yeah, we're working with MLR on lake cleanups, a doctor trail, tangle-free waters, and bike tags for educational purposes. We're also working on a new local air discount mailer. As of this morning, we've given away about 405 unique codes to United. Those have not all been redeemed. So if you do still have a code, go ahead and use that still. It's still good through the summer season, but we'll be putting out another mailer to make sure that everybody knows where they can get their codes from.

1:53:27 And that's flylocal at visitmammoth.com. So, any questions? The bike tags are a great idea. MLR got in touch with us about that, and we are very thankful. So, great. And we appreciate that you are willing to sign on. We're looking forward to all of the shops signing on, and we're looking at making that message, you know, really clear for people to understand where they can take their bikes. Very helpful. Yeah. Very helpful. Thank you. Wonderful. Thank you for all of the department updates, guys.

1:53:56 Let's get into other updates. Mammoth Resorts, Eric, what do you have for us? Yeah, well, I'm happy to say but also sorry to say that this Sunday is going to be our last day up the mountain. So it comes with mixed emotions, of course.

1:54:15 And it was a great season. I mean, you think back to opening in October, and here we are now. But we had a great Memorial Day weekend. We got the golf course open. We had great participation out there. We had a great participation in the bike park as well. So the weather, even though it was blowing some of our events down to the village, we were still able to see a lot of fun out there.

1:54:44 And if you missed Yacht-Li crew, you know, I'm sorry about that, but I heard it was a good time. It was great. I too was out. You guys did an incredible job. It's still going. You put the last piece on there. I mean, it was spectacular. Right. No, it was a...

1:55:09 Amazing year when you think about how it all transpired and it's different every year, right? How the snow comes, but all coming at the beginning of December and keeping it thanks to the nice cold temperatures. Yeah, essentially. And so now we focus on motocross, right? And all our summer events and motocross starts on the 17th, goes through the 26th. So that's a great event.

1:55:35 We have a lot of participating events where you have qualifiers, where the racers qualified to come to Mammoth, and those are going great. So we have a lot of people participating and so forth, so we're really excited about that event as usual. And then move into all our other summer events. We have more weddings this year than we've ever had, and we see that as a trend due to kind of a COVID blip, if you will, where there's...

1:56:03 Been a lot building up, but it is almost double, so our catering crews are extremely busy. Other than that, it was a great year. Wonderful. How could it not be great? No snow, no snow removal costs. Great snow to ski on, I mean. You forgot December, but. Plenty of snow removal costs in December. Very brief, but very expensive.

1:56:34 It was expensive, yes. I have one comment. Mammoth Motocross, in my estimation, aside from when we get the Olympic qualifiers for the Grand Prix up at Main Lodge, I think annually the two best events that we have in town are Mammoth Motocross and Blueza Palooza. And, you know, just...

1:57:00 I know for whatever reason this is kind of like a, you know, sticky situation with the motocross track, but, you know, Dave McCoy built that track. We have water out there. That is an asset for this town, and if there's any way for that track to be open more than 10 days a year, I would really like to take a look at that. Like, I don't understand why that thing needs to be closed.

1:57:28 Other than the 10 days of the motocross event. I don't want to get into a whole discussion right now. You know, I'm sure we could. But, you know, that is a major asset for this community that we could expand on. And I just want to communicate that. The event itself is absolutely fantastic. I'm a huge supporter of it and would just like to see it be more available.

1:57:55 I can tell you right now there's a local community that would love to be able to ride that track more than just the 10 days that it's open for the event. So my comment there. Makes sense. I will get into a quick chamber update here real quick.

1:58:14 Back on Tuesday, May 17th, we did have a candidate forum at the eatery. Thank you to all of the candidates from Mono County that came and had the opportunity to introduce themselves to the community. June 7th, your last day to vote at this, what is it, the primaries, right, that we're doing, June 7th?

1:58:44 The big thing moving forward to be aware of at the chamber is our 4th of July parade. I know there were a couple business owners all confused as to why for Memorial Day we were putting out 4th of July parade posters at the chamber. It's because we knew the town would be filled and we wanted everybody to come back for the 4th of July parade, okay? That's why. All right?

1:59:07 So hopefully everybody saw the posters around town and will be back to visit us again for the parade. A couple things to be aware of that we're doing a little differently this year. We have responsible waste zones for the parade. Restrooms, trash, recycling, all right? We're hearing it from the business community on Old Mammoth in Maine that people are just inundating their bathrooms and using their trash cans. We want to help.

1:59:33 you know, offset that issue and we will have designated, um,

1:59:39 responsible waste zones, so be aware of those. More information on where those are at along the parade route. We have a marching band, Air National Guard Band of the West Coast that will be participating in the parade. We're really excited about that. And there is also a float competition with a $500 cash prize sponsored by Mammoth All-Weather Shuttle. So I wanted to make mention of that and

2:00:07 That's the big thing. If you are interested in sponsorship opportunities for the 4th of July parade, if you're interested in putting in for a float, please get in touch with us. We have had very, you know, we've had great response for both floats and sponsorships so far. So there might be a few.

2:00:30 Spots left available, but make sure to get in touch with us at the chamber for those things. That's my chamber update. Mr. Souser, do you have a town council update for us? All right, let's start here. No. From the town council side, about the only thing I really want to report is that we are having some issues, but they've been pretty much solved, I am told, out at the CRC. So in about another week, we should start seeing that construction site become very active again.

2:01:02 There's an SNC tour going on right now with most of the council members. And what am I doing? I'm sitting here in a meeting. I am glad to hear that we are meeting with the folks from Tangle Free Waters and all of that. That is excellent. I'm glad to see we're communicating. But as I've been pushing both at the town in our updates from departments, I would push here as well that perhaps sometimes in our department updates in these meetings, we bring Joel down.

2:01:31 Or we bring somebody else down to give a report because, frankly, the new Office of Outdoor Rec that we're creating and this group should be tied together at the hip. Really important. So that kind of thing. And maybe once in a while have Rob come in and do a quick update for this group so that the communication is going both ways. Motocross track. I won't go into it now. If you want to sit with me, we thought we had a deal made to keep that track open years and years ago.

2:02:01 And when we all gathered to make the announcement at the track, what the Forest Service announces what we have today. I can give you the reasons, I can give you the history, if you want to start down that track again, all the more power to you. I would love to hear any take on the current status of our bird scooter program, because I'm trying to keep my ear to the ground on that, and what issues it is creating or what problems it is solving. So if any of you have comments or have experience, I would love to hear it.

2:02:34 I know one of them already has been found in parts. Tour hit got disassembled somehow in a parking lot, but we love those things. Other than that, unless there are questions specific, that's it. Let's reach out to Bill and give him any feedback on some of those items that he brought up. I'm running three minutes behind schedule. I apologize, everybody. So unless we have anything else, I'm going to make a motion to adjourn. And, oh, I'm sorry, I have one last thing.

2:03:08 Wednesday, July 6th is our next board meeting. That is two days after July 4th. How's the board feeling? Are we going to be able to meet on Wednesday, July 6th or do we want to look at moving that? We're going to be okay? We're going to be okay? Everybody okay with that? I'll be back from the lake. Alright, cool. It's because John is out of town the next week so we'd like to keep it at July 6th but would look at that. Okay, we're good for July 6th. Alright.

2:03:39 Now I am officially motioning to adjourn. Thank you, Angie. And I'm still only three minutes late.