Town Council
at 16:00
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Minutes ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Notable from this meeting
3 findings- Town sets a November 3, 2026 election for three Council seats and asks the County to consolidate it Elections and Governance
- Council agenda lists FY25-26 budget amendments for approval; Council agreed with FY2024-25 revenue projections in 2024 Elections and Governance
- Resolutions list $208,750 for FY 23-24 and $181,325 for FY 24-25 in Measure U programming funding agreements Measure R and Measure U
Transcript
655 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
4:26 Okay, I will now call to order this meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Town Council for April the 3rd at 4.02 p.m. Roll call, please. Councilmember Rae? Here. Councilmember Rice? Here. Councilmember Wentworth? Here. Mayor Pro Tem, Bubzer? Here. Mayor Souser? Present. Rob, I'm going to ask to lead us in the pledge tonight. Thank you. Ms. Paul, after me, ready to begin?
4:59 I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America, to the republic, for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all for all. Thank you, Rob. Moving on now to public comments. This is the time for any member of the public wishing to comment on anything that does not otherwise fit on the agenda. Good afternoon.
5:26 Brianna Goyko, Assistant Director at the Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce. Just wanted to provide a brief update on a program that we have coming up at the Chamber. We are partnering with Mammoth High School and doing a program called the Chamber Career Compass, and we are bringing in business owners and people from the community to do some workshops in the classrooms, in the English classes to be specific, of all the high school students. We're going to be covering resume building, filling out applications, professional presentations.
5:56 So just really trying to educate our youth on how to enter the workforce and how to present. The main thing that we really wanted to impress upon our young people is just how to present yourself when going into a choir about a job or volunteer work or anything else. So that's happening at the end of the month, Monday, April 29th through Wednesday, May 1st. And then on May 2nd, we'll be doing our...
6:22 Student Job Fair with them. This will be our third year in the row doing it with the high school. So we're asking our businesses that are looking for entry-level position employees to come join us. And just wanted to educate council and the community on what we got going on at the chamber. Thank you. Thank you. Any other public comments? Seeing none, we will move on.
6:47 Additions to the agenda. Rob, do we have any additions or subtractions or movements? There are no adjustments to the agenda. Thank you. Council presentation 5.1, proclamation declaring April as Fair Housing Month. The last lines, now therefore it be resolved, the Town Council of the Town of Mammoth Lakes hereby proclaims the month of April 2024 as Fair Housing Month. The Town of Mammoth Lakes urges all citizens to wholeheartedly...
7:19 Recognize this commemoration of the Fair Housing Act throughout the year. Any discussion among Council? Mr. Mayor, I'm prepared to make a motion if you're ready to accept one. That would be fine. Do you want public comment first or do you want just to accept? The motion is pending. Yes, thank you. Okay, thank you, Mayor, Councilmembers. I'm Matthew Lehman and I'm here on behalf of the Mammoth Lakes Board of Realtors.
7:57 And also speaking on behalf of the Eastern Sierra Community Housing with regard to the Fair Housing Act. And I just want to thank you for the proclamation. For those that aren't aware, the Fair Housing Act is an act that was passed in 1968. And the purpose of the act was really to, it was in the wake of a lot of the civil rights movement that was taking place years earlier. And the purpose of it was really to address race.
8:26 Religion, national origin, sex, things of that nature in the housing market because the time is, many of us don't even really know anymore, there was a lot of discrimination taking place just against different groups of people for a variety of reasons. And a lot of those, since the passage of that, there's been even further efforts, ongoing efforts for the real estate community to
8:52 To take further efforts against things such as sexual orientation, gender identity, marital status, and even participation in the military service and even addressing people with varying sources of income. So I just wanted to bring it to everybody's attention, say it is Fair Housing Month, April, and I just wanted to thank the council for bringing it up and to the public's attention. So thank you. Thank you, Matthew. Any other public comments on this?
9:23 John? So, Mr. Mayor, I would move that the Town Council declare April as Fair Housing Month here in the Town of Mammoth Lakes. I'll second. I have a motion and a second. Any further deliberation? Seeing none. Jamie? Councilmember Rae? Yes. Councilmember Rice? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Bubzer? Yes. Mayor Souser? Yes. Mayor Souser? Yes. Passes 5-0. Matthew, if you want to come back up, I have this to present you with, sir. All right. Thank you.
10:03 Moving on now to item 6.1, joint workshop with Eastern Sierra Community Housing Board of Directors. If you give us a moment, we will all move to the
10:58 Lower tables. Why don't you move down a little and we can get somebody else at the end of that table there. We can all schmooch in a little. I can put someone on Andy's lap.
13:22 You've got to be below a certain age for training to do any good. That's right. Okay. Thank you all for coming. We have a regular agenda to follow on this one, so I'm going to start us off. Number one is the housing program's overview, starting off with the town of Mammoth Lakes presentation. Nolan. Great.
13:47 So I handed out to the town council and the MLH board the same presentation, just since it's hard to see the screens at this setup. So if anyone didn't get one. So let's jump in since we only have an hour and we have a lot to cover. Unfortunately, I don't have pretty photos like the MLH presentation, but we can just walk through the projects that we have in the works for the town. I think the most exciting thing, kind of update from last year, is that
14:35 All the projects that were really just in the pipeline for last year are really close to being delivered and providing housing for the community at this point. So the first one on here is the Sawyer. It's the first phase of the parcel. That project's going to be 81 units. It's under construction.
14:52 As we learned at the last meeting, the initial 15 units are expected to be delivered later towards the end of April or early in May. The property manager, Buckingham, did confirm that they have provided initial offerings or kind of outreach leases to 15 households to fill that building.
15:15 So they have income qualified people for that building and they're obviously awaiting just the final move-in date, but there are households ready to move in for that building, which is exciting. The building A, which is 66 units, is targeting a completion date of July of 2024. Due to that kind of delayed delivery date, they are holding off on extending or offering up leases yet for that.
15:37 The next phase, phase two, the Kingfisher, will be 148 units. That project was awarded tax credit funding at the end of 2023, and they are looking to begin construction on that project in June of 2024 on the initial 76 units. It will be approximately a two-year build. We've kind of seen how that goes, so we hope that we can stay on track, and the kind of learning curve is...
16:04 Over from the initial phase and that they can hit that target. Along with that, they are still continuing to apply for funding for the second phase of the Kingfisher, which will be 72 units. They just recently submitted for the most recent round of tax credits. If they don't get awarded in that, they'll keep applying. Part of that is their hope to free up some funding from phase one. That then will make the second phase of phase two more competitive.
16:33 So there's a lot of just moving parts there within the parcel. Phase three is currently in the planning phase. That is for an ownership phase. It's 47 units. For those units, they will be targeting higher income households, so 120 to 200 percent AMI, so really targeting the missing middle with the ownership units. They will range in bedroom sizes from two to four bedrooms. The critical kind of...
16:59 The first piece on that, on the ownership phase that the town and the developer are really working through is the funding for that project. Because it targets higher AMI households, it's not eligible for tax credits or other non-traditional sources of funding to build housing. So they are looking to the town and the...
17:19 So we're still working through on
17:48 And what is a feasible number that the town could commit to that project? And then really looking out to more of the community on how to fund that project to get it moving forward. The other piece that's been very successful in delivering units in the community is the bridge program. Highlighted here, we have 10 units acquired.
18:09 Currently, five of those have been sold and are currently owned and occupied by local households. And then we have one that's currently being used as a long-term rental that we intend to list for sale soon. Then four units are currently for sale through ESCH. So they have been working with clients from their wait list to try to identify households for those various units. But we have kind of a range of size.
18:36 Currently in the mix, which is exciting, so it's not all just one unit size. There's a two bedroom and a loft, a one bedroom and a loft, and two one bedroom units currently being actively marketed to households. The other piece that I think is important to highlight with the bridge program, when we set out, our goal was to
18:56 Maintain a subsidy of under $150,000 per unit into each unit. With five sales being completed, our current subsidy is $126,000. So it's not including the four that are currently for sale, but with those, I believe the subsidy is still right around $126,000 to $130,000. So we are still hitting the target that we set out to do with the program.
19:21 And again, similar to the kind of ownership phase of the parcel, the bridge is targeting those higher AMI households. A few other highlights are small site development concept. That's our four unit design build at 60 Joaquin. They did break ground in summer 2023 and they are going to plan to go vertical with the modular units starting in May or starting the foundations and then going vertical in June of this year.
19:48 The modulars are currently being manufactured off-site and will be arriving here in the next one to two months to then be placed on the site. They are still targeting a completion date of late winter 2024 with that project. We've also, the town has acquired two additional sites. We haven't determined what type of project we might build on those sites, but they are two contiguous sites that provide up to a half acre size, so it allows a lot of flexibility for development.
20:16 The other two highlights on here, down payment assistance, it's just that we have ongoing programs that can provide down payment assistance for a range of AMI households ranging from up to 120% AMI. So those programs are available for eligible households. We work through ESCH on facilitating providing those loans under the grant programs. Then the bottom one is one that we highlighted or talked about the last council meeting.
20:43 It's a concept the Town's working on with Mono County and with the ski area of setting up a van life parking or a safe parking overnight parking location in the community. We are looking at a site down off the 203 or 203 and 395 for this. It's the old dog sledding place.
21:04 The plan is to still house the dog sled operation on the site and then accommodate the van life piece there as well. It's still in the early concept. We're still working through it with Mono County, with the ski area, with the attorneys, with everyone else to hammer out all the kinks, but it is exciting to see it moving forward. And that is kind of it on the town's highlight. With that, I will pass it on to Patricia.
21:34 I can share my screen if you like, or you can share yours. Yeah, if you could share it, that'd be great. Thank you. Did you have the beginning? I was trying to shorten the presentation. I know, I know. But I'd just like to go real quick, just to make sure everyone knows who we are. I'm Patricia Robertson, the Executive Director of Eastern Sierra Community Housing. We just wanted to remind everybody that we are a 501c3.
22:31 Certified Community Housing Development Organization serving in Yomono and Alpine counties. In our presentation, you can see our nonprofit vision and mission, which is to support community housing for a viable economy and a sustainable community. As I mentioned, we're a nonprofit. We're also a community housing development organization, and we're also a real estate brokerage. And each one of those designations allows us to do a different component of our work.
23:06 I wanted to touch just briefly on our rebranding. This is a little bit out of order. But up front, we have rebranded from Mammoth Lakes Housing to Eastern Sierra Community Housing.
23:25 We've been working on this. There's a lot of components, but we do have a brand new website. And so I just provided some images from that website and a new logo that we have. And so we're still working through that process. And all of our contractors and partners will be receiving a letter, a formal letter explaining that our name has changed, but we're still the same great organization. We recently expanded our staff to four full-time staff members.
23:57 This is made possible through our partnerships with Mono County and Alpine County. And so here we are. We wanted to mention, you know, that we do pride ourselves on being the regional experts in affordable and workforce housing. We have a nine-member board of directors, which represents some of our elected bodies, but also small businesses.
24:23 And both private and affordable housing development experts. We are members of state and national housing organizations where we are able to learn from other experts across all different areas of affordable housing and take ongoing professional development through these networks.
24:48 And I also wanted to mention that our staff is very committed to our communities and volunteers and serves in our communities in a number of roles, including volunteering for other nonprofit organizations, as well as the fire department.
25:11 And then you see, here's the map of the Tri-County area. We serve in Yomono and Alpine counties. Our bylaws have had that incorporated since 2013. And our rebranding is just another way for us to remind everybody that housing is a regional issue and that we are committed to working on that on a regional level.
25:35 Some of the programs that we've had sort of ongoing that you're likely familiar with are our homeownership programs. We have added a new component of homelessness prevention, which we'll talk a little bit more about in the next couple of slides, as well as housing navigation. We continue to provide rehabilitation and ADU construction loans through various programs.
26:01 And then we also do rental management and development of new projects. And then I think I'll pass it to Isara for housing navigation. Yes, hi, good afternoon. So a little bit about what housing navigators do. Me and Olia are here today just to kind of give a brief update about what exactly we do in our office. We do a lot of client case management.
26:33 Up to date with what our clients are going through. Majority of our clients are either at risk of homelessness or are homeless or are in some way disabled that they cannot reach certain services in our regional Tri-County area. So we partnered with different organizations, different property management companies, along with organizations in Alpine County.
26:58 Mono County, Inyo County, just to see if we can find more individuals that are in need of services. We're also constantly looking for different funding sources, either state or national, that can help these individuals find permanent housing and stay in permanent housing. Just because we find permanent housing doesn't always mean that they would stay there, so it is our job as housing navigators to make sure that they have a permanent place to stay and that they are there long term.
27:27 Next slide. I'll just note that this is a really big expansion of the programs that we've previously been offering and that it is made possible through our additional contracts with the counties and also that if we didn't have these employees in our office,
27:49 We wouldn't be able to do the high level of service that we do on a day-to-day basis interacting with clients who are coming in the office looking for housing or in an emergency situation. But also that with our housing navigators we were able to deploy the emergency funding last winter when households were displaced for various red tags and other reasons. And so that was a great asset to have so that we could act
28:18 And with this slide, this also, I mean, it's a very big
28:29 Shout out to the Eastern Sierra Continuum of Care. Through them is another way that we are able to reach so many households and strengthen our partnerships with all three counties. So far, we've counted a total of 275 households in the Tricount area that are homeless or are experiencing homelessness. We always participate or we're trying to do our best to participate in the annual person and time count, which is a pick count that each county does individually.
28:57 Personally saw a very big skyrocket in the amount of people in the United States actually who are experiencing homelessness and that number seems to be on the rise every year. We use the coordinated entry system to count individuals. That system, again, is a tri-county.
29:15 The system that we use to link services to clients through that system is a way that Mono County, Alpine County, and Inyo County can help find these clients whether or not they're in that specific region or not. The next slide. Takeover. Yeah, I'll take over for projects. So Innsbruck Lodge, it's undergoing. We've been doing a lot of work with the GC on it. So just some big overview updates. So Artesio, which is our...
29:47 Temporary Certificate of Occupancy is scheduled to be is pulled on April this April sometime during this month and then for that we have six units so it's going to be five studio units that are going to be leased up and then a manager's unit which is a one bedroom and that the navigators are currently working to get people leased up on that. They are starting to call them this month and then we should be having them leased up at the end of this month.
30:16 That is the overview for Innsbruck. This is, or at least, the process for Innsbruck. I don't know if they want to speak on it or if they just want to look at it. You can read this later, but I just wanted everyone to know the amount of work that our team has been doing to, you know,
30:36 I would like to also add,
31:10 Just so it's clear, there's 16 units total. And so this will make it a little misleading. We have five that will be ready in April. And this was due to some issues with long leave times on electrical switchgear. So we were able to get six units up, get a temporary certificate occupancy. We'll get those occupied now. And then once the switchgear shows up later this summer, we'll get the rest of the units completed and get a sign-off on the whole building. So we'll have all 16 units complete here by...
31:40 September? Or I can't remember the date. October. October. Yeah. So just wanted to make sure you guys are clear on that because I know that was what we asked the money for assistance was for the full build out. Thank you. That makes sense. But yeah, just the usual hiccups here with material procurement issues that are still lingering from the pandemic. Thanks. Yeah. And that was just pictures. So access. Moving on to our other project. So this is our commercial conversion project to residential units.
32:15 Today it's going to be 13 studio apartments or one-bedroom studio apartments. So overview for this one, our start dates is in June 2024. Our GC versus general contractor is already under contract, so they should be starting work soon there. Our completion date is for December 2025. And for this, as you see on the board on the screen, it's going to be two units at 50% AMI, eight units at 80% AMI, and then three units at 120% AMI.
32:45 I would point out that when the town council committed additional money, we had worked with ESCH to try to identify some higher AMI households, so they were able to identify three households at the 120% AMI, which does help the town's regional housing needs allocation with the state. And these are rentals, correct? Yeah. Okay. I always get confused. Thanks.
33:14 And then we'll pass it to Olia to talk more about some of the work we're doing in the region. Thank you. Hopefully this is close enough. So here are some of the projects that we've been participating in regionally, sort of as highlighted earlier. So Valley Apartments is going to be a preservation project in Bishop designated for low-income and seniors.
33:38 Last week we were able to submit a PRP, which I actually don't know what the acronym stands for, but it's a grant at the state level, so that was great for acquisition and rehabilitation. As the Alpine County Housing Navigator, I have engaged in some relationship building with other housing nonprofits in El Dorado County and Douglas County.
34:01 And in some more exciting news, we've also been discussing housing opportunities in the region or in Alpine County that would benefit the region. Inyo County selected Eastern Sierra Community Housing to administer the Permanent Local Housing Authority funds for ADU or accessory dwelling unit construction and rehabilitation. And this is sort of similar to our program offerings in Mono County.
34:30 And our board of directors recently approved an ad hoc committee named the Partnership Discovery Committee to identify housing opportunities in the unincorporated areas of Mono County. And this committee is an extension of the Mono Basin Housing Work Group. So more on that to come. We have a lot that we're currently working on, but here were some highlights I wanted to make note of.
35:01 We are developing a credit building workshop to help our residents educate themselves around what credit is, credit worthiness, and in preparation for lease up at the parcel, as we know, credit is important for various reasons, and so we're working to develop a curriculum around credit building with some of our partners.
35:26 We'll also be holding a first-time homebuyers workshop to educate folks about the home buying process but also about the various different programs that we have to offer and recommending that folks get on the homeownership waiting list since, as we know, there are other opportunities coming up in the near future. We will be hosting a ribbon cutting for the Innsbruck Lodge and I think the intent is to wait for the project to be fully complete.
35:56 Are in the beginning stages of planning that in collaboration with the town. New income limits will be coming out shortly. I think that's kind of a highlight. Everyone's always wondering, what are the income limits and when do they change? So they should be out this spring or summer. April is Fair Housing Month. May is Affordable Housing Month.
36:20 And we are working towards becoming a HUD-certified housing counseling agency, which would make us the only HUD-certified counseling agency in the Tri-County region. So that is a work program that Eric and I are working on, so hopefully we can report back on the success of that in the near future. And then I always like to end with just some of our success to date.
36:49 We're constantly, you know, trying to do more. We have preserved the only transitional housing unit for those experiencing homelessness in the Tri-County region. We've taken on the management operations of that unit. We continue to look for development opportunities and grant funding. We've been able to leverage more than $60 million for housing in the region.
37:14 But just recently some of our staff were able to access resources we have never accessed before for rental subsidies at the Innsbruck Lodge specifically. And so being able to have additional staff and access additional resources is just another thing that we bring to our work together. And then we have expanded our fundraising efforts. And so here are just some of our local and
37:45 And national supporters who have contributed financially to our projects and programs. And that's it for us. Thank you. Any questions on any of that for anyone? Seeing none. For Nolan or for Eastern Sierra Community Housing? For both. Okay. That was, if I'm reading my agenda right, that was our number one. Yeah. Okay, great. So one question I have for town staff is,
38:25 That in the bridge program, the average subsidy is $126,000 and I don't know why I never asked this before if I haven't. For the parcel ownership phase, I realize that they're made to order units, they're larger, there are definitely benefits, but if the subsidy runs about $350,000 per unit, are we thinking about shifting some of our resources to trying to maybe
38:55 You know, concentrate on the bridge program where we can put twice as many people into home ownership. Is that something we can or should be discussing? That was my first question. Definitely. And we haven't said or discussed kind of at staff level or the developer that we agree with their subsidy and have committed to it. By no means. We do feel it's a bit.
39:22 Higher than any other program that we've seen. So it's definitely a discussion point that we will be having with the developer on that. Is that a realistic number for us to commit resources to? But, Nolan, does that include both the buy-down of the purchase price and down payment assistance? Because you could think of most of our clients have the town subsidy, which goes into the sales price, but also have down payment assistance from other various sources.
39:51 So when you look at the information provided by the developer on the parcel phase three, they split out the subsidies into a down payment assistance piece, a shared equity down payment assistance piece and more or less a buy down, but they are both going to it as loans, so they would both be coming, the town would recoup all the investment into that unit, so it's a little different than the bridge program where the bridge we are providing a subsidy that we are
40:19 Truly buying down the unit to an affordable price with the long-range deed restriction. So there are slightly different programs, but we agree the subsidy is high. Then my other question along those lines is I've forgotten. What is the expected per unit subsidy going to be at 60 Joaquin? Do you have that? And if not, you can tell me another time. But I'm just trying to keep in my head all the different...
40:45 Sure, we anticipate it's going to, with the new construction, depending on the AMI we target, if we're going with, say, 150% AMI household, it'd likely be around $150,000 to $200,000 subsidy. If we target 200% AMI households, then it would likely be a $125,000 to $150,000 subsidy. So it really depends which AMI initially, when we kind of...
41:10 Started on the project, we were hoping to target 120% AMI households, but with interest rates going up, construction costs going up, that would just create a much larger subsidy on those units to target 120% AMI households. Got it. And then for Eastern, thank you. For Eastern Sierra Community Housing, a couple of questions. You preempted my question, Eric, about the...
41:44 Tom, I'm looking at you and saying, yes, Tom, thank you. Sorry. Oh, my only question was about, for Alpine County, you were talking about some programs that are under consideration. Alpine County is such a tiny population that I was just curious what their needs are, really, and then what kinds of programs are you contemplating?
42:21 Yeah, I can touch on some of this. So we like kind of similar to our Innsbruck Lodge project. I think Alpine County is considering a permanent housing project as well for the population that's experiencing homelessness. I will say because it is similar to Mono County, really cold, at least on that side.
42:45 The households are typically more transient in that they're moving around. And so we see an increase of individuals experiencing homelessness in the summer, and then those households have to leave. They're forced to leave because of the weather. So permanent housing is one project. A second large project is home rehab, as well as potentially accessory dwelling unit construction.
43:14 The intent there would be to increase variety, like households available to a variety of incomes because I believe a lot of the homeowners there have been homeowners for a while and so they're looking to increase local workforce and so addressing sort of I'd say probably under the 80% area median income for the county.
43:43 Lastly, let me think. I think those are the two primary. And what about transitional or supportive? Yeah, permanent housing supportive services would be like the last type of housing. So I work pretty closely with the probation department there. And so we have been exploring transitional housing, a transitional housing project. And that kind of goes along with the permanent housing as well.
44:09 Also one of the key components, I think, to the navigation program for both Alpine and Mono County is linking residents to resources that counties have underutilized in the past. So there's all these different programs and acronyms. You know, we can pay your rent only if you have a disability and you're 65 plus, or we can pay your rent if you have an open family CPS case.
44:37 And so because those are so specific and obscure and inaccessible, one of the things that the navigators do is that they learn about these programs. They coordinate with staff at the county level to make sure that when clients come in our door, we can link them to the right folks. Thank you. Anything else from anyone for the town? Go ahead. Thank you, Mayor Souser. I have just a couple questions.
45:08 For you, Nolan, on the PLHA, the $360,000 that is for down payment assistance, is that multi-year or is that a one-year allocation? So that was our initial three-year allocation and then we initially were awarded for the initial three years and then we are eligible for a fourth and fifth year, but I'd have to get back to you on whether that was our five-year allocation or just the initial three-year.
45:39 Okay. Okay. But that can be used for up to $120, which it sounds like doesn't really help you out on the parcel because you're targeting $120 to $200. And it wouldn't, just the timing, that grant has a, it's about a three-year window to expand those funds. It's like we wouldn't see those units completed in that time frame. Okay.
46:07 Could have been used on the Joaquin site, but it sounds like that's going higher AMI now too. But still, if a 120% household was eligible, we could layer that with the subsidy and the down payment assistance to place them in that household. That's great. And you have guidelines already for that program? We do. The guidelines are currently being reviewed by the HCV legal team.
46:30 By ESCH staff as well. Okay, great. That's exciting. Mono County isn't doing that with theirs at this time, but we have the flexibility to do that. That's really great. And then could you just say are the modular units, are they being manufactured by the same folks at the parcel for the Joaquin property? I don't believe they are using the same manufacturer.
46:56 Quite a few manufacturers that have popped up in Idaho, and the developer of the Joaquin site, I believe, is using a different manufacturer that they were able to get in with, even though it's a small project. They're also the developer of the Villas 3 out at Obsidian, which they're doing that as modular, and so they're able to get into the plant, even though it's a small project, since they had a bigger project to kind of leverage.
47:22 And my last question, thank you, is around the Kingfisher, are those 4% as well, they're continually going after 4%? Correct. Okay, thanks. Further? Okay, Nolan, I think we've sort of gone off the schedule a little here because you've covered some things, so I am going to let you pick the next. For me, it would be the challenges, interest rates, affordability, HOAPs.
47:50 If you want to start us off on that. Agreed. So here on the slide, it's the back page of the smaller packet there has the same chart. It really highlights the challenges that we've seen with homeownership here in the community. I mean, every kind of factor affects the affordability and the purchasing power of households, such as HOAs going up, interest rates going up, incomes stayed flat for a number of years up until 2023.
48:20 And then sales prices just in the community for median sales price have continued to climb. I think this graph really illustrates it. From 2012 to about 2016, the median sales price for a two-bedroom condo in the RMF2 zone was affordable to 120% AMI households and up, and that's looking at a three-person household income or a three-person household size.
48:46 Then really about 2016, 2017 is when you saw the median sales price really skyrocket up until 2022. We saw a small dip in 2023. What's also interesting on this chart is seeing just how when the state with the most recent income or AMI limits released last year, they finally did see an increase. It was about a 20% increase in the income limits for the Mono County. So you did see the purchasing power of those households increase.
49:16 Finally in 2023. What you also see on the screen is that even at the 200% AMI household, they're still below the median two-bedroom sales price as far as being able to afford it here. So that's really where it's critical to have programs such as the PLHA and then other programs like we're talking about with the parcel and others that would be unrestricted funds coming in.
49:42 From various sources, whether it be the town or other entities to help those households that are above that 120% limit because there's currently no subsidies there. The bridge program does help to that because it reduces that price to an affordable level, but we can only do so many units with the limited funding that we have for that program. So that's really it kind of on the challenges. Patricia wants to chime in.
50:11 The other piece of the home ownership side is just looking at how, again, how the bridge program can assist the affordability and then with the parcel, like I said, the challenges there are really going to be coming up with the funding to provide that subsidy. I don't have any feedback specifically except for that. I really appreciate Nolan putting this data together. It's something that we talk about daily, it feels like, but it's nice to see it visually represented. I don't know if you...
50:42 Want to talk about that strange inverse gap between the affordability and the prices going up in 2022? Do you think that's the spike in interest rates and the increase in incomes the following year? It is. So also on the chart, underneath the year at the bottom, I provided the average interest rates for that calendar year.
51:07 And so what you see from 2021 to 2022 is about a 3.5% jump in interest rates, which really dramatically affected the purchasing power for households. So that's really where you saw that gap increase. And then it did right itself somewhat in 2023 with the increase in the AMI, even though interest rates continued to climb in 2023.
51:33 So we will see, like Patricia said, the state releases the AMI, the updated AMIs usually in April or May of each year, so we should be seeing those come out, but we have no idea if our income is going up or staying flat. Okay. Mr. Mayor, if I could... Yes, please, John. No, I think... Oh, sorry.
52:05 A lot of great expertise at this table. People know acronyms, know all the stuff we're dealing with. But you point out a really important point, which is the value to all of us in this community of the unrestricted dollars that come in primarily through TOT. And I think that we're all watching the onboarding into the parcel. I think we're all well aware of the constraints that when we take that kind of money from the state and the feds.
52:31 We have microinflation issues going on. We have wages going up. Those AMIs, those restrictions are never going to change. And so I'm making kind of a friendly pitch for the basics of our recreation tourism economy. And I think it's really important for all of us to really kind of recognize and buy into this how we do business here because that provides the unrestricted funds that we can use to help out.
52:59 Eastern Sierra Community Housing, other projects, things that we're all doing to really invest in housing for this community. If we keep, we're going to have to keep taking state and federal grants, that's going to keep happening, but we're going to start running into some bumpy stuff with that. And so love your economy, love how we do business, and let's keep bringing those unrestricted dollars because they're very important to this program. So thank you. John, any other questions on the challenge piece?
53:30 Bridge Program, you've touched on this some already, Nolan. You want to touch on it more? No, I would just encourage anyone who's out there who's listening, who's interested in learning more about what units are available or getting on the wait list to reach out to ESCH staff to learn what opportunities there are out there for ownership here in the community. Thank you. Patricia, anything you want to say on the Bridge Program? All right.
53:58 Ownership phase at parcel phase three. You've also touched on this sum. Anything else you want to add to that? No, just that it'll be an ongoing discussion on what the subsidies look like and what the town and other entities could realistically commit to the project. I'll ask a quick question about that. The parcel, the contractual relationship we have with Pacific, the developer.
54:25 I think when we put this together, there was the assumption that there could be some flexibility in that, and that we're not obligated to work with Pacific to do five phases, and as conditions on the ground may or may not change, that the Council has an opportunity to revisit that contract, to perhaps look at things in a slightly different way. Is that, could you confirm that that's true and maybe
54:50 Can you share with us all how that contract is structured and what kind of flexibility the community has to leverage those 25 acres over there? Sure. So we do have a disposition and development agreement with Pacific, which the agreement spells out that they're responsible for providing up to 450 units on the parcel.
55:15 As far as what flexibility there is to amend that agreement or look to work with other entities, we'd have to come back with you on that information on what that looks like. Yeah, I think the council, I mean, I'd really like to know what is in that. Andy, I know you're deeply involved in putting that thing together. We don't have to get into it now, but I mean, again, if we're looking at the kinds of constraints that come with state and federal funding to build those projects.
55:40 And the very specific, unique, idiosyncratic conditions we have here in Mammoth Lakes, I think we all want to be always be looking for opportunities and how we can maximize the value and put people into housing. So some later day we can maybe get an update. John, what I would add to that is from my remembrance, which of course is short, while we are sort of committed to Pacific for the project, we aren't specifically committed to the timing of any particular piece of it. So we would not have to go with the for sale units.
56:10 Remember, originally, they wanted to do that as number two, and we pushed them to hold off to number three, so we are not required to follow through with that, especially if the, correct me if I'm wrong, especially if the assist on it or the subsidy is over our ability to pay. Yeah, and there may be opportunities, again, it's a wild and crazy world we're living in these days, and there may be things that might come up down the road that we might find a better use for the land than...
56:38 Going with the type of business model the Pacific has in place and maybe other opportunities we want to look at. So I think at some point getting communication to all of us, what is the flexibility in that agreement? What are we bound to? What are we not bound to? So let's save that for a later date. I would second that. I think it'd be a really good conversation to have because we know that the affordable housing world has changed dramatically even in the past five to ten years.
57:07 So I can't imagine that there isn't flexibility for us to rethink that. On the next item. I thought you were going to, you know, endow us with some brilliance here. Okay, any other questions on that piece? So I am going to stop here real quick and ask if there are any questions from the audience on what we've gone over. This is between us and the board, but if there's something quick you wanted to come up with, no one's jumping, opportunity gone.
57:44 Short-term rental committee recommendations, starting with the rental subsidies, Rob? Yeah, so we just went through a process where we had a short-term rental advisory committee working on really administrative functions of our short-term rental projects in town, but there was a sort of directly connected to activity for housing, and so part of that committee, the subcommittee broke down and talked about
58:11 Different recommendations. Again, we talk about our Housing Now initiatives having multifaceted approach. In this particular case, we were adding to that, right? So it doesn't necessarily replace, but it's more additional tools in the toolbox. And so we had one recommendation about a rental subsidies program.
58:29 And that was put forth with a fairly robust degree of contribution for that ownership program. And again, it's going to target the higher AMIs, right, things that are not addressed by the parcel activity. Right now, those are kind of sitting in, I'm sorry, the rental subsidies program, we've put some funding out there. We've got placemates coming to talk to the council and give us a presentation on the May 1st meeting.
58:57 They've had a pretty good turnkey program. We as an organization have set aside the year one funding for that, our last second quarter adjustments for our budget. So we're really funded it, ready to go. It's just a matter of whether the council wants to execute on that particular program, that turnkey program. Down payment assistance was the one I was really talking about, and that was...
59:21 You know, brought forward to try to get home ownership out there and to give a little bit different process than we have for the bridge program. And not necessarily what we are acquiring and reselling and subsidized, but more how do we participate in the actual down payment. So we are a part owner in the home, we are a part owner in the equity of the home and what it appreciates to and in some degrees what it depreciates to if it does that.
59:47 That needs a little bit more work that was presented to council and the direction of staff was to take that back, do a little bit more analysis on that, try to get that program maybe right-sized a little bit and ready to go for us. So we look to bring that back to council probably in mid to late summer for the process. That one doesn't really have any funding sources and if we were to fund that it would probably take away dollars from our existing Housing Now initiatives.
1:00:15 But that could be a possibility if we think we have a good program and good utilization. And then finally, the TOT tax increase. We're working on a ballot initiative for November elections that would provide a 2% TOT increase. And that increase would be a general tax. So it would not be a special tax that's committed to housing. It would be a general tax.
1:00:43 So with that process, you know, we think we'll generate committed funds to housing.
1:01:12 And that would go on, you know, for at least 10 years, I think was council direction on that. And it would help us to still provide funding for housing in the event that we do have some sort of an economic downturn and, you know, our unallocated TOT that we've been so dutifully putting into housing for the most part would potentially not be available, right? We would still have continuous and ongoing funding. So that's the purpose of that. It's critical that we get that passed.
1:01:38 And that's coming to us in November. So those were the STR Advisory Committee recommendations for housing and if there's any questions. Thank you, Rob. Any questions or comments on those things, John? Just a couple observations. I think potentially the November ballot might be getting a little crowded. And I think that the council, I think we as a community, we need to have a discussion about that.
1:02:01 School bond didn't pass. That may be coming back. I know the fire district's got a very important measure coming forward. Housing is obviously a part of this. We need to really think as a community establishing priorities about, okay, what do we really got to get done? That's going to be an important discussion to have. And I think that's it. Thank you. Any other from the housing board? Go. Okay. Just a couple.
1:02:32 Is it possible or have you contemplated an overlap with the down payment assistance recommendation coming out of the STR committee and the implementation of that on the parcel? On the parcel ownership component? We have not considered that at this point in time. The way that the phase three of the parcel has been presented to us is that we would
1:03:00 Be contributing on the front end to the subsidy of that. You know, as again, as talked about earlier, the request was $350,000 per unit, 49 units. That's just a little bit over $16 million. We think this program, whatever we work through in the subsidy for that would probably be substantial. It hasn't been ruled out, but it was not considered at this point. It seems like maybe.
1:03:25 Two birds with one stone, not to be mean to birds, but that seems like a possibility. What does your 1% TOT generate? That's roughly $2 million. Okay. And then, you know, the county's contemplating an increase of 2% in their TOT. We're working with selecting a consultant to help us determine when's the best time, because as you noted.
1:03:54 There's a lot happening in November. I think there's also a constitutional amendment that we may see on the ACA 1 to reduce housing initiatives to 55% vote from the two-thirds that's currently required. But if you're thinking about 10 years and then it would sunset, what happens? Then you go back to your original TOT or you just stop investing in housing? What's that?
1:04:20 The discussion at council, it wasn't that we would have it solved in 10 years. It was the commitments that we were not wanting to go out into perpetuity. And so the concern was that 10 years was probably a good time to figure out what the next phase looks like because things will change across time. And so that was the intent. So in that period of time, we would generate roughly $40 million from that process.
1:04:49 And there's two other components in that. One is we've been hearing some advice from staff that we're getting in the relatively near future to an inflection point, at which point the cost of running the town is going to be bumping against the TOT revenue that we've been taking in over the last couple of years. And this, Rob, it's seven, five, seven, eight years out, but we're going to get to this point where the cost of running this organization is going to be bumping against about
1:05:18 The TOT numbers we've been taking in. So there may be a need to, you know, kind of recalibrate at some point. So that's, but I think we haven't had a discussion. We haven't had the discussion about the TOT increase. Love to hear your input and all that when we get to that. That's going to be coming up relatively soon. But that's a consideration in there. Yeah, I get that. I mean, I understand nothing, you know, cost of employees just continues to go up in operation.
1:05:46 But $40 million, I don't know. I feel like that could be potentially a solution for the ownership on the parcel from where I sit right now. So I encourage you to consider that. Thank you. So real quick, because I know we have a last-gen item that I want to just segue into on this discussion, if you don't mind, which is the update of the housing needs assessment. And, you know, I really feel like this discussion about the TOT tax increase is really, there's a nexus between
1:06:15 That discussion and updating the housing needs assessment and understanding. So what's the first thing if you're going to call out and be a developer is you create your business plan, do a market study. The housing needs assessment is your market study. And ours is outdated. I think it was updated in 2017. So it needs to be updated. And I would posit to you guys that you need that information now to make educated decisions about how much funding you need into the future.
1:06:44 That's going to identify the number of units, income levels of those units that are required, and then you can start to model that in terms of a development pro forma and a build out of what's required. So I think that would go a long ways towards potentially supporting the need for that and just that you guys are doing your job, you're doing your due diligence and have a business plan that's backed up by real data and numbers that can
1:07:13 You know, versus I feel like this is a number that works. I mean, I get it. It feels like it's an endless, endless issue that's never going to go away and we're always going to need money for it. But by the same token, you know, we got to do our homework and I do feel like that is the underwriting or that's the foundation of that whole plan of what you guys need. You know, the previous housing needs assessment in 2017, I'm going off of memory here, but I believe it identified maybe up to 1,200 units. It was like 800 to 1,200 units at the time.
1:07:42 And so we're, you know, obviously there's some units that have been coming on. We're making a dent and we'll see how things go once we start delivering these first phases of the parcel. But, you know, we anecdotally hear that the missing middle is underserved and we need to provide units for that. But, and, you know, in some ways you can't do anything wrong right now because there is so much demand, but we do need to back that up with some understanding of where the needs are today.
1:08:09 How long does it take to do a study like that? Housing assessment? Well, I think the fact that we did one previously, there's already
1:08:39 Sort of the framework of one, we know what to do. And my recollection was at the time that was, it was under a year process. It was probably more than six months, kind of somewhere around that range, six to eight months if I recall. But I, you know, I think we could certainly reach out to the people that we used before, I think. And actually I was going to mention in my employment with Altera Mountain Company, I wanted to mention that recently Altera Mountain Company
1:09:08 Hired Willa Williford as their Vice President of Workforce Housing for all Altera Resorts. Willa is actually a very well-respected and a long-time professional in the workforce housing, affordable housing. In fact, she even assisted, I believe, in our last effort on the housing needs assessment.
1:09:28 Here in our community. Is this an offer from Altura to maybe make a little available? Well, you know, so she was here last week. We toured around town. Did she introduce any council members? It was a very short, short visit, so we'll have her back. But she definitely is willing and able to bring her expertise to the table and collaborate with.
1:09:48 With the Town Council, with Eastern Sierra Community Housing, and help in any way she can to, you know, help create more units for the community. So I just want to mention that so you guys are aware and absolutely reach out to me and we can connect people and get that going. So those are my comments just about that last item. I think Jenna didn't mean to steal your thunder there, Nolan, but I do feel like that is sort of time critical in my view. We need to get that rolling. Thank you.
1:10:14 You know, Tommy reminded me of something I want to add to the discussion with regard to the TOT tax increase. The town is not looking at a tax initiative as replacing our efforts and investments into housing. We will still have the way we're budgeting, the way we're going through this process, provided we still have good, strong economic results, we will still have unallocated funding after that.
1:10:38 I think no one's going to address the timing by which the housing update needs assessment because Council did provide
1:11:08 You know, a good amount of discussion about the timing of that and how critical it is to understand the impacts of the things that we're actually doing in the parcel as they come online. Before we turn Nolan loose on the outcomes of that, I'd like to address a few things that Thomas said and that we looked over in that last section, rental subsidies. We haven't talked yet about whether we're better off putting into a non-permanent
1:11:35 Resource, if you will, or a permanent resource. Should that rental subsidy money maybe go into down payment assistance? One is permanent, one is temporary. How do you best spend that money? We have not had that conversation. So I don't want the people out there to think that this is all, everything we're going to do. We have not had that conversation.
1:11:54 TOT tax increase. We've got to look real long and hard on where that leaves us price-wise with all of our competition. If we raise 2% TOT, but it costs us 1% of the people coming to Mammoth because it's cheaper to go someplace else, we actually lose money in our unallocated funds that could have gone to housing rather than make money. I'm not saying we will or won't. We have not had that conversation. It sounds great, $4 million, but a slight decline in visitation.
1:12:21 It costs us that $4 million, so we have to look at that. Great effort on the housing needs study. However, it is my personal opinion that the last one was done so poorly, it did not give us any true numbers. We asked people, would you like to buy in Mammoth? We didn't say, could you afford it? Would you do it if this is what it costs? So we had a huge, yes, I want to buy in Mammoth. So that became a priority with X number of units.
1:12:47 We didn't ask the people that were living in Bishop whether they would like to stay there or whether they'd like to move to Mammoth. It was just assumed if they were Mammoth workforce that they would be here. I would love to see us do a housing study, but if we do one, let's do one with real-world parameters and real-world financials so that what we get out of it is a study that tells us what our real needs are. Are there a need really for 1,200 units? I didn't think so at the time. I still don't think so.
1:13:16 So how do we suss that out to such a point and do it in such a way that we aren't asking pie-in-the-sky questions, we are actually dealing with reality. And I have fears of that. So many things we've done as governments give governments a bad name for a reason. So I would like to see us, if we're going to do this, suss it out to the point so we get real-world values, not, yes, I want to live in a 3,000-square-foot home in Mammoth.
1:13:45 You know, that's great. We all do. Well, some of you do already and want to live in a 5,000, but that's beside the point. With that, I will give it back to Nolan. Great. It is a great segue, I think, into the last one on the housing needs assessment. I think Tom hit on a lot of the points. Luckily, our number is not 1,200. It's 595 needed. 1,200 would be a little daunting. And 595 is daunting as well, but it sounds a lot better now.
1:14:14 But with that, like I said, our needs assessment was done in 2017, and there wasn't really a strong need to update it from then to now because there has not been a delivery of any affordable units during that time either to really indicate are we, are we moving the needle at all on that need or is the need just increasing as far as how many units we need?
1:14:41 So the direction from council before was to wait for a short period of time until some of the current projects do come online to really start to see are they having an impact in it. With the projects kind of coming online, I'd say in the near term, which is end of 2024, that would provide approximately 100 units of 80% or below AMI households, followed up by the next phase of units, which is looking at
1:15:09 Phase two of the parcel and the access apartments. Those plus what's currently in the pipeline combined would provide approximately 260 units at 80% and below AMI. The needs assessment that we did before indicated we needed 230 affordable units. As far as for rental, that would be affordable. So those would directly cover what was indicated was our need for affordable rental.
1:15:39 Which is also part of why we're talking about the parcel and future phases and other projects really taking, I wouldn't say a pause, but kind of a step back to really look what is the needs in the community, where should we be focusing our efforts, should we be focusing more on ownership at all AMIs, should we be focusing on rentals at higher AMIs because there's also a need there. So I think that's really what an updated needs assessment could inform on is really giving
1:16:07 Good analytical data that we can target the programs to the appropriate needs because we don't obviously want to keep building 80% rentals if there's not a demand for it in the community because we don't want to have an excess because the way those are funded, even if you can't find households, it doesn't mean that you can then go and rent them to other AMI households. They're still restricted to those households. So we obviously don't want to get into that that position.
1:16:33 With the housing needs assessment, there's been some discussions between Patricia and I about looking at it possibly from a regional approach. As Patricia talked earlier, housing's not just, you know, the challenges aren't just isolated to Mammoth and our workers don't always want to live or even can live here. They live throughout the region. So is there desire from the two boards here to have us pursue and look into what a regional housing needs assessment might look like?
1:17:03 Obviously, Bill touched on it as well as the goal is to really get useful data that can really inform on the housing programs. Ideally, too, it'd be set up in a way where it can be not necessarily a full needs assessment done annually or biannually, but maybe it's a smaller needs assessment that can be done periodically as these other projects are coming online, again, to just really gauge are we addressing the appropriate demographics with what the housing programs we're putting in place.
1:17:33 That'll open up to Patricia or the boards for questions. Yeah, I just wanted to comment briefly on the regional component. I have had a few of our regional partners reach out and ask about what a possible needs assessment could look like and if there was possibly a way to partner. Some of our jurisdictions only receive small allocations of, you know, resources to hire consultants and maybe...
1:17:58 Maybe have less of a need for a robust study but would like to still be included in something with the funds that they do have available. But I also think that a partnership or a greater study could bolster political will in other parts of the region just through the idea of partnering together but also by having the data we have to act. You know I was recently looking at the employment
1:18:24 Development Department website and the Mono County STR study that just came out and it's just interesting to see the migration patterns and I think that that's a big component to the housing needs and I agree with what the mayor said about maybe folks don't want to necessarily live where they work but maybe they do and what does that look like?
1:18:50 What resources are there if we want to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, for example? And then lastly, I did want to say the 2017 study was a partnership effort between the town Mammoth Lakes Housing and Mammoth Mountain at the time who did allocate additional funding to contribute to that study. So I think there's precedent for partnership and I think a regional perspective could have a lot of benefits possibly.
1:19:20 Those are, I mean, this is a great conversation. I think some really good comments from everybody. But I would support the notion that we should do a regional study because I think we all know, right, we all, if you live here, that, Chief, I don't know how many of your officers are living down in Bishop. I know at one point I think the whole police force was living in Bishop. So we know that our, you know, there's numbers of our workforce that live down there for whatever reasons. But, you know, I think the fact is, do some even live in Minden? Yeah. So, you know, it...
1:19:50 You know, think of understanding those sort of metrics and trying to figure that out, whether it's, you know, by choice or by affordability or the desire to move back in the community. So we'd fall short in assessing sort of that needs if we didn't kind of address it regionally because, you know, I don't know about you guys, when I drive back home from down south, as soon as I...
1:20:10 Get down to a launch job. I'm back home in the Eastern Sierra, right, until I get across the state line. So, you know, this is our home, the three tri-counties, this is all of our homes, and I think it makes total sense to, you know, work. And we could, you know, I think maybe Eastern Sierra Housing could reach out to the other governmental entities and, you know, and Alpine counties and City of Bishop and so forth. I bet everybody would be on board with that. So, you know, I've made the suggestion at the board level, at the Mono County board level.
1:20:40 To my colleagues that serve on the SCOG, and I know there's some of you here that serve on the SCOG, the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments, I think if you look at what they're charged with, this really falls within their purview. And I've had some conversations, brief, but some with Elaine Kabbala, the staff of the SCOG, about looking into this. Last time a regional housing needs assessment was done was in 2003.
1:21:09 And it was done for all four jurisdictions. And that was a great asset that really sprung into the 2006 developments. We saw the tax credits here in the town and I think it informed everybody. You know, so much has changed since 2017 because of the pandemic and people working remotely. I just, as much as we haven't filled
1:21:37 Buckets yet, you know, with the 595 units and the parcel not being online yet and so on and so forth, I think it's a good time to at least start doing some legwork on RFQs, RFPs, what would it cost, who could have...
1:21:56 Come to the table. What's the timing? Not that we have to commit, but just start doing the background work to figure out what's involved, because I think it's time. You know, that was a five-year study, like you mentioned, Nolan. And I think that...
1:22:11 You know, I remember Rusty allocating up to $250,000 for that study and action plan and how grateful the community was and, you know, at the time MLH really put in a lot, and this town staff put in a lot of in-kind efforts to make that all come together for far less than what was considered to be available.
1:22:35 So just a long-winded way of saying I think that the county wants to do one. Ours was done in 2017 as well. We used CVG funding to do ours, but I think we know we need to go back to our communities, our little communities in the unincorporated county and see what are the needs. And, you know, I will just say that it wasn't just like, oh,
1:22:58 We just want to have X number of units in town. We said, it was, I thought a good study. I understand you don't think it was, but I thought it was well thought out.
1:23:08 You know, there was 52% of the workforce living in town, and that's how we got to the number of how many, you know, job vacancies, people overcrowded, growth in jobs, and, you know, it was well thought, how do we get there? We knew what percentage of folks in town were renting versus ownership. Let's stick with that ratio when we say we need this many ownerships. It wasn't just a...
1:23:31 Like this, you know, it really was thought out. The people that worked on it, as you mentioned, Tom, were intelligent and experts in their field. So I have faith in them. I think they are guideposts and they help government try to do a better job and allocate funds. So I would be supportive of that. I think my colleagues at our county would be too. Any further questions or comments? It's a quick question.
1:23:58 The investment of the mountain, was that in the community housing action plan or was that in the needs assessment? It was both. It was both. If you may recall, we started with the needs assessment because we said, okay, well, we need to figure out what have we done, what do we need before we can do an action plan? We have to have a starting point. And so that was first and then the phase two was the action plan. Because I remember Russell Cumming very specifically saying he was investing in that community housing action plan.
1:24:27 Which was turned around pretty quickly. Thank you. And undoubtedly there were some good parts. I just thought a lot of the questions were just too open-ended. So, you know, we've done a lot of things with open-ended questions so you don't get the reality of what can and can't happen. I want to make sure that doesn't happen. Right. I don't think we've made any mistakes, though, based on that study. I feel like we're working in the right direction. I don't think we can be like, oh, we really screwed up right now.
1:24:58 Okay, with that, I will end this piece of the meeting, and we will take a five-minute break while we break all of this down. I just want to thank everybody. Thank you. Thanks very much for having us. Thank you.
1:25:29 Public hearing. I will say before I open the public hearing that with as many people as want to speak and with my bedtime being early, we're going to limit public comments to three minutes per person. And those in TV land couldn't hear that. Three minutes a person is what we're going to limit public comments to.
1:34:25 And if somebody has already said what you're going to say, feel free to get up and say, I agree with George, but we don't need to hear the same thing 43 times. Thank you. With that, I will open the public hearing for consideration of an appeal of the February 14, 2024 Planning and Economic Development Commission decision to approve use permit application 23-1574 Old Mammoth Road.
1:34:53 With that, I will go to Andy to start us off. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. My name is Andy Morris. I'm the town attorney for the town of Mammoth Lakes. I just want to start with a few introductory things for benefit of the council and the public. As the council knows, as a member of the public may not know, the council's job is not to decide whether this is a good project or a bad project. It's not to decide whether you like this project or you don't like this project.
1:35:21 Council's job, rather, is to decide whether the findings can be made to approve the project and deny the appeal, or rather whether the findings can be made to reject the project and grant the appeal. But it's not about emotion, it's not about is this good or is it bad, it's about findings. And I will say also that every project that comes before the council is governed generally by state laws.
1:35:45 And as with all telecommunications projects, this one is governed by a very complicated web of both state and federal laws. So we're in a realm that the town council does not often deal with. And because it's a complicated area of law, we have invited one of my former colleagues, Gail Karish, to make a presentation to the council and to the public.
1:36:09 To kind of explain where we are and provide some context. I think Gail is standing by up there on the screen and she has a PowerPoint she's going to run through. Gail's entire practice essentially is on telecommunications, mostly helping local governments navigate through the laws and she's probably dealt with more wireless facilities than I've had hot dinners.
1:36:29 We also have, from my former firm BBK, Shauna Inspector, who's here to help us through any CEQA issues that may arise. But with that, I'd like to turn it over to Gail, and she can help explain how federal and state law deal with wireless communications facilities applications. Thank you, Andy. Good to see you. Good evening, everyone. I have a PowerPoint I'm going to attempt to share, so let's see if that, first, if I can get that working.
1:37:06 Can everyone see the PowerPoint? Yes. Okay, great. So, as Andy said, my name is Gail Karish. I'm a partner at Best Best in Krieger. I advise local governments on telecommunications law, and I have with me my colleague, Shauna Inspector, who's going to discuss CEQA at the end of the presentation. And so my task this evening is to take...
1:37:34 to provide a brief but sort of broad overview of town authority on siting wireless facilities. And we start with the premise that or the starting point is really that the town has police power authority, zoning authority, to regulate development and uses within the town. And so my discussion of federal and state law is really to
1:38:01 I'll point out some of the limitations on your inherent police power authority that have been placed on you and other municipalities throughout the state and indeed in the country with respect to wireless sighting. So if I can get the screen to go to the next slide, which is the one thing I wanted. There.
1:38:28 Briefly, in terms of the federal legal framework, we're looking at laws that were mainly adopted at the very beginning of the rollout of wireless networks. So the Telecommunications Act of 1996 has two provisions that are relevant, one specifically with regard that applies to personal wireless facilities.
1:38:55 And it recognized that there is local authority that has been preserved, but it limited that authority in some ways, both procedurally and with respect to some substantive limitations that I refer to generally as sort of these national policies, and I'm going to get to those in a moment.
1:39:21 So there's what we call Section 332 of the Telecommunications Act that deals specifically with wireless facilities and personal wireless services. So those are the services provided by Verizon, AT&T, and others. And then there is another provision of the Telecommunications Act, that's Section 253, that's also relevant. It was broader in that it
1:39:48 It also preempted local or state regulations that would prohibit or have the effect of prohibiting the provision of telecommunication services, including wireless services. It also preserved some
1:40:18 Non-discriminatory right-of-way management. So this provision was a little bit more focused on regulating installations in the public rights of way. So those are the provisions that were in 1996. I'll talk about the national policies that they represent in a moment. The only federal law of any consequence that has been adopted in the period since 1996
1:40:48 is a law that was adopted by Congress in 2012 as part of a middle-class tax relief act, but it sometimes referred to, this portion of the law referred to as a spectrum act, and that was much more narrowly tailored.
1:41:06 to require the approval at the local level of certain modifications to existing wireless facilities. So the terminology used is eligible facilities requests, and if the town were presented with an eligible facilities request that met all of the criteria, you would have no discretion but to approve it. So the Telecommunications Act in 1996
1:41:34 Place some limits on your authority. This more recent law is one narrow area where you have been completely preempted from exercising any discretion. The last bit of the sort of federal legal framework is the Federal Communications Commission, which has responsibility for regulating communications, including wireless.
1:42:02 At the federal level, they adopt orders, rulings, regulations, they interpret the federal statutes, and those orders and regulations also carry the force of law. So that's the very brief overview of sort of the laws that are involved. So what is the policy behind these laws? So with respect to wireless in particular,
1:42:31 There are several national policies. One is a national deployment policy, and that is, the goal of it is to ensure that there are wireless services available throughout the nation. So that is reflected in the federal law that says no local decision or regulation can prohibit or have the effect of prohibiting the provision of personal wireless services.
1:43:00 Another national policy on wireless has to do with the safe levels of RF emissions exposure. So the federal government established that the Federal Communications Commission has the sole authority to set safe RF emissions exposure standards.
1:43:27 For localities, for any local governments, they cannot regulate the placement of wireless facilities based on a concern about the environmental or health effects of RF emissions, but they can ensure that an applicant has shown that it will comply with the FCC guidelines. Another national policy on wireless is that there would be timely action on applications.
1:43:57 And the Federal Communications Commission in a series of orders beginning early in 2009 has interpreted that federal requirement that there be timely action by actually creating what they call shot clocks for action on applications. And those are basically timelines that run between 60 and 150 days depending on the type of application.
1:44:26 Those are timelines for action on the application. And they also have adopted in some instances some remedies for the failure of a local government to timely act on an application. Another national policy is that if a local government denies an application, the denial must be in writing and it must be based on substantial evidence in the record.
1:44:55 Another national policy is that applicants are entitled to an expedited appeal of a final action of a local government. So the action you're taking today would be subject to an expedited appeal in the courts if that were the applicants choosing to challenge the decision. Finally, and this is just another
1:45:24 Kind of summary of what I mentioned earlier, that law that was adopted in 2012 created a situation where there was some mandatory approval. So you don't have an eligible facilities request before you today, but if a local government were to have an application to modify an existing wireless facility that qualified as an eligible facilities request,
1:45:52 Then there would be no discretion that application would have to be approved and there's actually a deemed granted remedy in federal law if the local jurisdiction does not act in a timely manner. So those are sort of the national policies on wireless. So I'm just going to highlight a few more details on some of these topics.
1:46:19 For example, to give you an example of some of the FCC orders that have come out, in 2018 the FCC adopted a moratoria ban, so that means that basically local governments cannot put a pause on the processing of applications for telecommunications facilities or wireless facilities.
1:46:46 You have to accept them. You have to process them within the timelines that are the FCC shot clocks that apply to wireless facilities. And you couldn't, like you can in some other areas of development, actually just say, you know, we need to rethink what we want to do on this topic. We're going to hold off taking any applications until we have the opportunity to, you know, update our policies. That's not allowed.
1:47:15 With respect to telecommunications facilities. I mentioned that the FCC has developed timelines for action on applications that they call shot clocks, wireless shot clocks. And this is just a chart that shows the different categories of applications and the applicable federal shot clock. And so they range from 60.
1:47:44 Days to 150 days, the application that you have the appeal, it would fall into that other category with 150-day shot clock. Excuse me, Mr. Mayor. And I just want to also note that I'll talk a little bit about state law. I need to ask you. Gail, could you pause for a second? Is there any way you could make your screen a little bigger? It's very difficult to read even while we're squinting into our laptops. Oh, I'm sorry. That's okay. Thank you.
1:48:14 There's a way it will let me, I may have to stop sharing for a moment and make it bigger. Thank you. Sorry about that. Where did the, that won't do it. I can share the PowerPoint as a full screen from here and you can just ask me to advance the next slide if that's easier. Oh, if you want to. Well, let me see if this is better. If this isn't better, then we can do that.
1:48:55 Let me go back to here, back to sharing screen, see if I made it any bigger. Is that better? Still not. A little bit. There's a zoom button. Yeah, go ahead, man. I think on the bottom right-hand corner of your screen, there is a magnifying glass with a plus and a minus. I think if you click the plus, it'll get bigger on the bottom right. Oh, yeah, there. Here we go.
1:49:40 There you go. One more of those. One more of those? There. Sorry about that. Okay, so this chart is just a summary chart of the FCC shot clock, so the timelines for action on different types of wireless applications and the remedies that are available.
1:50:14 A local government fails to act within the applicable shot clock. And I'm not getting into the details of how they start and stop and all that, but just as an overview that roughly these are the periods of time within which to act. What I wanted to point out was that for a brand new macro tower, like the discussion tonight is about that appeal, that's a 150-day shot clock.
1:50:42 In terms of deemed granted remedies, there is one federal deemed granted remedy, that's for the eligible facilities request. The California state legislatures actually adopted deemed granted remedies for all of the other shot clocks. There is an exception.
1:51:07 And I'll get to on the last slide with respect to the application of those deemed granted remedies. But generally, whatever timeline there is for action for a wireless application, there is a deemed granted remedy available if there is a failure to act, a timely act. This is probably not looking quite right. Let me see if I can. Oops, sorry.
1:51:37 I'm getting a weird thing here. There. I'm not sure. I don't think now you can see the whole screen. There. I'm going to talk a little bit. I mentioned that one of the limitations on local authority is to regulate with respect to RF emissions exposure. And that is because, as I mentioned, the FCC
1:52:06 And then for local governments, they cannot regulate, establish their own,
1:52:36 Another thing to
1:53:04 Sort of related to, again, the perceived health effects of RF emissions is there has been case law that says that you cannot, as a local government, kind of have proxies for what would be really a concern about RF emissions. So if you have a local government decision,
1:53:30 That they're denying a permit because they think that there are diminished property values, but really what's generating that concern about property values is the perceived effects of RF emissions, and that would not be an adequate or substantial evidence to support a denial of a wireless application.
1:53:57 One more on RF emissions because this is sometimes comes up in public hearings is what's the relationship between sort of the ADA, so the requirement to accommodate persons with disabilities and
1:54:17 Sensitivity that some persons have to RF emissions exposure. And there's one case in California that dealt with this specific issue and said that so where there are these competing interests of compliance with the ADA and compliance with these limitations on local authority to regulate based on RF emissions concerns that the court found
1:54:47 That it would be improper under the ADA to subject a defendant city to the threat of litigation for the purpose of accommodating a plaintiff individual under the ADA. In other words, where there is a sensitivity, the most important
1:55:16 The most important factor for the city to consider is that it cannot regulate based on RF emissions even in the face of a complaint or an accommodation request under the ADA. So long as the carrier is complying with the FCC standards, that sort of ends the
1:55:45 The exercise for the local government. The eligible facilities requests I mentioned already, I won't go through it in any more detail, but that's the type of application that requires local governments to approve if the criteria are met. The FTC has implemented.
1:56:06 Very detailed rules on what is an eligible facilities request, how much of a modification, how tall, how wide can a facility change, and these are set forth in several implementing orders. Finally, this is my last slide, just a brief mention of some of the state law limits on local authority. I already mentioned that there is a deemed approved remedy for the
1:56:36 Many of the FCC shot clocks, except for the eligible facilities request, which already had a deemed granted remedy at the federal level. I just want to note about this deemed granted remedy that this state level deemed granted remedy is not available for proposed placements on fire department facilities. However, an applicant could still pursue litigation.
1:57:04 And seek an approval of a court. They just could not invoke their rights to being granted remedy under the state law. Other state law limitations, wireless permits may not be less than 10 years unless there is a public safety or a land use reason for a shorter permit duration. You cannot require an escrow deposit for removal of a facility, but
1:57:34 You can require, as a condition of approval, a removal bond. You cannot, as a local government, require all facilities to be located on sites owned by particular parties. And what that means is you couldn't say, oh, we only want wireless facilities to be located on government property or only on utility property or something like that. And finally, state law.
1:58:02 And that recognizes the federal authority over RF emissions regulation and like federal law prohibits localities from taking into account RF emissions in evaluating proposed wireless facilities except to the extent allowed by federal law and as I mentioned that is just to ensure that the applicant is going to have a proposed facility that will comply with federal standards.
1:58:33 Okay, so I'm done with my part of the presentation. I'm going to turn the rest over to Shauna Inspector to talk a little bit about CEQA. Thank you, Gail. As Andy and Gail mentioned, I'm a CEQA attorney at BBK, and I'm going to go over some of the basics with respect to the town CEQA authority on this application. When we are conducting CEQA review,
1:59:05 We engage in a three-step process. Step one is to ask whether we have a project subject to CEQA. Step two is to ask whether the discretionary action is exempt from CEQA. And step three is to actually conduct environmental review on the proposal. Step one of the process here is to ask if we have a project that is subject to the act.
1:59:32 And here we do have a project that is subject to the act because the town is being asked to make a discretionary decision with respect to the cell tower and whether or not to approve it. And the cell tower has the potential to result in either a direct or reasonably foreseeable indirect impact to the environment. We could do the next slide, please, Gail. That would be great.
2:00:09 Step two of the process is to ask whether your discretionary action is exempt from CEQA. CEQA sets forth both statutory and categorical exemptions. Statutory exemptions are absolute and the categorical exemptions are qualified. So here staff had recommended and the planning commission adopted a categorical exemption.
2:00:36 Under State Sequel Guidelines Section 15303, and this is referred to as a Class 3 categorical exemption. This exemption is specifically outlined in the regulations to include construction and location of limited numbers of new facilities and structures.
2:00:57 For this cell tower project, we are focusing on the construction and location of limited numbers of new small facilities and structures, as well as the installation of small equipment and facilities in small structures. So if the town is able to identify evidence that demonstrates that the project fits within the four corners of this class three exemption, then the project is exempt.
2:01:26 No matter how significant the environmental impacts of the action are. Those environmental impacts could include aesthetic impacts. And you've probably read quite a bit in the appeal about aesthetic impacts that could occur as a result of the project. But like I said, if the project fits within the four corners of the class three categorical exemption, it doesn't matter how significant those impacts are.
2:01:56 CEQA exempts the project from environmental review. So as Andy said earlier, the council's goal today is not to state whether or not you think an aesthetic impact is good or bad, for example, but rather the goal is to decide whether the planning commission was correct in finding that the project fits within the class three exemption criteria.
2:02:23 So we need to focus on whether this proposal involves construction of a limited number of new small facilities or structures or involves the installation of small new equipment in facilities in small structures. In the appeal, you have heard concerns about whether the monopine itself is a small facility or structure.
2:02:48 The staff report contains information, and you will hear more today in the verbal presentations about why the Planning Commission found that the structure, which will stand at 80 feet tall, does qualify as a small facility. If you look at the language in section 15303 of the state CEQA guidelines,
2:03:10 You'll see that a commercial structure qualifies as small if it is 2,500 square feet in floor area or less. If the commercial structure is 2,500 square feet in floor area or less, then the project is presumed to fit within the four corners of the class three categorical exemption. So even though the monopine does stand at 80 feet tall,
2:03:38 It is only 680 square feet of total floor area. In addition to that, there is only one monopine structure that is proposed, so the number of facilities that is proposed is limited. It's limited to the fire district property and is focused alone to be installed in that area. In addition, staff will speak to the fact that the monopine standing at
2:04:09 At the 80-foot height would be similar, though not admittedly identical to the surrounding pine trees, which have an average approximate height of 55 to 65 feet. I also wanted to address the St. Ignatius case that the appellant has cited to. Unlike the light standard at issue in that case,
2:04:36 This facility will actually be camouflaged and aesthetically designed so as to blend in with the surrounding area. If that case does come up today, the council should be aware that St. Ignatius is not binding law in California. It is an unpublished case that we cannot cite in court and it is not binding precedent, but I do think it is important to note.
2:05:04 The differences between the facts of that case and our case as you make your decision. In the St. Ignatius case, there was a 90-foot light standard that was proposed at an athletic field, and there the court looked at the surrounding environment and area in which that
2:05:25 Light standard would have been erected and illuminated and found that the structure far exceeded the height of any of the improvements in the surrounding areas. So the court in that case found that the class three categorical exemption did not apply to the light standard. But like I said, that case is not binding on the town. It is distinguishable factually because there it was dealing with a light standard and
2:05:54 And here we are dealing with a telecom facility. So there's a different regulatory scheme. And with respect to the actual structure, it is also factually distinguishable because in our case, there will be this camouflaging and blending and treatment of the structure to try to harmonize it with the other pine trees in the surrounding area.
2:06:20 So if the council agrees with the commission's finding that the project fits within the class three categorical exemption, then there is an implied finding that none of the exceptions to the exemption in the state sequel guidelines applies. The reason that is important and the reason I bring it up is that you will see in your staff report that
2:06:44 Staff has taken the additional step to explain why it is that none of those exceptions to the exemption are triggered. And that is important information because if an exception had been triggered under CEQA, then that would mean that we would move out of step two and into step three of the three-step process.
2:07:09 Step three of the three-step process would be to actually conduct environmental review on the proposal by engaging in an initial study and then determining whether we need to prepare a mitigated negative declaration or an EIR.
2:07:26 But here, staff in the Planning Commission do not believe that going to Step 3 is necessary because we fit within the four corners of the Class 3 categorical exemption and none of the exceptions to the exemption applies. So you may hear today in the appellant's presentation about concerns on aesthetic impacts or impacts to views from private property owners.
2:07:53 So I just wanted to note that it is important to keep in mind that the town's code and CEQA do not protect private views to the extent that any consideration is given to views in an actual CEQA analysis. That analysis would be focused only on impacts to public views or scenic vistas or scenic resources from public vantage points.
2:08:22 So again, we're not getting to that level of detail because we are not in step three of the three-step process and we do not need to engage in an environmental impact report or an MND. But as you were thinking through the comments, I just wanted to have you keep in mind that if we were doing an environmental review, we would need to focus on impacts to views on public vantage points only.
2:08:52 So that is all I have. And now I think I'll be turning it over to either Andy or Nolan. Thank you. Great. And so next up, we do have a staff presentation from Michael Paterka to walk through the merits of the application and what is being proposed by the project.
2:09:22 Thanks, Nolan. I'm going to provide an overview of the project as well as staff's response to the topics that were raised in the appeal. An application for a use permit was submitted to the town on July 20th, 2023 for a proposed 80-foot-tall stealth monopine cell tower at fire station number two. The item was originally scheduled for a public hearing on November 8th, 2023 at the Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting. However, due to an error in public noticing,
2:09:49 That inadvertently resulted in a number of property owners not receiving public hearing notices. The item was continued to a future PEDC meeting. The future meeting took place on February 14th, 2024, where a notice public hearing took place. The Planning and Economic Development Commission approved the project by a vote of 5-0. On February 9th, 2024, the Snow Creek 7 Condo Owners Association submitted an appeal of the decision of the PEDC.
2:10:17 The appeal was timely filed within the 15-day appeal period following the project approval. The Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District, who's a landowner, is working with Yukon Group, the applicant and consultant for AT&T. They've submitted an application for a cell tower that will be located at fire station number two on Old Mammoth Road. The tower is intended to expand service in an area that currently has poor service and also improve public safety and emergency communications for the fire district and other first responders. The tower will initially be used by AT&T.
2:10:50 And there will be the option for other service providers to co-locate their equipment on the tower through the approval of a subsequent use permit. This can be done without increasing the height of the tower. Project parcel is shown here and is located at 1574 Old Mammoth Road. The parcel size is 0.91 acres and it's located in the resort zoning district. Project set is zoned resort and is part of the Snow Creek Master Plan area.
2:11:23 The resort zone is not just a residential zone as it allows for various uses including residential, professional and administrative offices, hotels, recreational facilities, and public or quasi-public uses. The zone also lists utilities as a permitted use which the cell tower is considered. The Snow Creek Master Plan does not contain development standards for telecommunications facilities and instead relies on the standards specified in the municipal code. The plan states
2:11:51 Where the master plan is silent on development standards or other regulations, other provisions of the town's municipal code apply. The municipal code includes development standards for telecommunications facilities. First is site selection, which is focused on the old Mammoth Road area due to a significant gap in acceptable coverage in the area. When considering the potential sites, the code specifies the following order of preference. One, on or within existing structures, including church steeples, rooftops,
2:12:23 Stairwells or equipment enclosures. Two, co-location of facilities such as locating equipment with another provider on a single facility. Both of these were not possible as there's no existing structures or towers that can accommodate the area's needs. Instead, the applicant worked to find a location that meets the third and fourth selection criteria. This includes a location that has existing topography, vegetation, or other structures to provide screening that will not require significant visual mitigation.
2:12:53 The proposed location is in the rear of the property and is screened from view from public or out of way, as it is important to note that the town zoning code does not protect views from private property. Also, the stealth monopon design was chosen to best blend in with the site. The code also requires that projects be located near existing utility poles, trees, or other similar objects and consists of colors and materials that best blend in with the background and also requires that it be located in the rear portion of the property.
2:13:22 Municipal Code does not establish a maximum height for cellular facilities and instead specifies that the maximum height is to be determined by a use permit, which is a height that is necessary to provide adequate coverage. For this project, a height of 80 feet was determined to be adequate, and the applicant provided analysis for different heights, which showed that 80 feet is needed to provide the necessary coverage. To note, the antennas will be located at approximately 74 feet, but a total height of 80 feet is needed to create the cone-shaped treetop.
2:13:53 As far as setbacks, the resort zone does not establish setbacks for cellular facilities, so the setbacks of 20 feet are based on the public and quasi-public zone, since it is a zone that most closely matches the use on the site. Also on this slide is a portion of the site plan that shows the location of the tower in the upper right corner, as well as the mechanical equipment that will be located next to the existing fire station. The appeal that was submitted by the Snow Creek Seven Condo Owners Association consisted of seven topic areas.
2:14:26 And I'm going to go over each topic and provide a brief staff response on the topic that's raised. And additional details can be found in the staff report. The first issue raised in the appeal is that the Class III CEQA exemption, which applies to the new construction of small structures, does not apply to the project because of its height and potential for its materials to be hazardous to the environment. And as Shauna spoke to earlier, in order to qualify for a Class III exemption, the commercial project must not exceed 2,500 square feet.
2:14:56 And the area proposed for the monopine and the equipment is 640 square feet. Also, the exemption does not take into account the height of a structure, only floor area. Additionally, the argument that the monopine may be hazardous to the local environment is not supported by legal authority, and there's no evidence to support this argument. The second topic in the appeal argues that the proposed cell tower will have a limited improvement on public safety because it will only benefit AT&T customers.
2:15:27 This appeal topic is not germane to any requirement for telecommunication facilities in the Municipal Code and it does not relate to any required findings for approval. Third, the appeal argues that the proposed cell tower will have a negative impact on the aesthetics of the community. As stated earlier in my presentation, the project meets all applicable standards in the zoning code, including locating the facility in the rear of the property and screening to blend in the structure to the surroundings.
2:15:55 Furthermore, the Town Zoning Code does not protect views from private property, including the views from the entirety of the Snow Creek 7 development and the private streets within the development. The fourth topic in the appeal argues that the visual assessment prepared by the applicant is defective and misleading for failing detailized images taken from nearby private residences that may be impacted by the proposed facility. Staff's response is that the code requirement for visual assessment
2:16:24 Does not require a wireless applicant to generate photo simulations of a proposed facility from the perspective of private properties, but rather from public perspectives. Additionally, an independent contractor who produced the photo simulations provided a statement confirming their accuracy. Topic 5 argues that the cell tower will have a negative impact on property values of nearby homes. Staff's response is that the purpose of the code's wireless standards is to preserve the unique visual character of the town.
2:16:54 Promote the aesthetic appearance of the town and ensure public safety and welfare. The town's standards and requirements do not include an evaluation of the effect of any particular development project on property values. Sixth, the appeal argues that the applicant is required to prove there is a significant gap in wireless service and that the proposed location will remedy those gaps. The appellant incorrectly attempts to convert the town's application requirement into a required finding.
2:17:22 Applicants are required to provide a map showing planned or anticipated future needs of wireless communication facilities within and throughout the town, including discussion of the existing local facilities and service gaps. The applicant has met this application requirement through the submission of their site justification coverage maps and their technical siting analysis. The final topic that the applicant is that the applicant did not in good faith consider alternative sites.
2:17:54 The submitted documents and the applicant statements at the February 14th meeting demonstrate that AT&T and their consultant, UConn Group, formed a thorough site analysis and determined Fire Station No. 2 to be the best site for the Monopine Cell Tower. Other sites that were considered include the St. Joseph's Catholic Church, located at 58 Ranch Road, and Snow Creek Athletic Club, located at 51 Club Drive. The church site is not a viable location because it's zoned residential multifamily 2.
2:18:22 And telecommunications facilities are not permitted in residential zones. The Snow Creek Athletic Club was not pursued due to lack of landlord interest at the time AT&T was conducting their alternative site analysis. With that being said, the staff recommendation before you is that the Town Council deny the appeal of the Planning and Economic Development Commission decision and affirm the approval of use permit application 23-002.
2:18:57 With that, that concludes staff's presentation. So we will ask town council if they have any questions for staff or the BBK attorneys. And then after that, we will have the appellant, opportunity for the appellant to address the town council and then opportunity for the applicant to address the town council. And I will also note one correction on Michael's. The appeal was filed February 29th, not February 9th, just to have that on the record. It wasn't before the Planning Commission approval. Thank you, Nolan. Any questions?
2:19:28 For staff. Yeah, go ahead. I just, I had a question for Gail Karish. I noticed in your presentation there was an exception for if it's on a fire department property. Could you just go over that one exception? I just want to make sure that I'm clear on what that meant.
2:19:53 Yeah, thank you. Great question. That is often a topic of some confusion. So when the state adopted the law that implemented a deemed granted or deemed approved remedy for any applicant that does not get their application process within the timelines that the FCC set for action, they carved out
2:20:21 Fire Station Facilities from that remedy only. So what that means is, and they made that determination, the state law says, because of the sort of unique circumstances of fire station facilities, that they didn't want to impose a deemed granted remedy.
2:20:43 ...or didn't want to make a deemed granted remedy available to applicants, but it doesn't mean that wireless facilities cannot go on fire station facilities. It's really just about not making that deemed granted remedy available to applicants. So it means an applicant would have to go to court to get a remedy for a failure to timely act rather than
2:21:12 Thank you. Thank you.
2:21:40 That starts a 30-day timeline for the local government to decide whether they're going to go to court to challenge the application of that being granted remedy to the project. Thank you. Any other questions for staff? We will move on then to the Pellant, who is Snow Creek 7HOA, for whoever is speaking on their behalf. Good evening, Mayor and Council.
2:22:18 I'm Chuck Landy from Snow Creek. I kind of came in with a series of thoughts, and then listening to this presentation, it brings up a lot of things. You know, about five years ago, I got a call from cell tower people asking if we would accommodate a tower on the Snow Creek site, and I said no. It wasn't appropriate. It didn't belong there. And as I found out, they called the church at the same time, and church was amenable. They liked the income.
2:22:47 And we chatted with the Athletic Club ownership. They, too, heard from the Cell Tower people five or six years ago. So none of us were contacted here in the last couple of years. We've heard many times tonight about proper notice and due process. We developed Snow Creek 7. Unfortunately, there was a recession in the middle, so we've been developing it probably for 12 years.
2:23:16 And about the time of this application, we probably had, I don't know, 20 units yet to close, 30 units yet to close, which meant that any notice that came would come to me or my office. We did not receive a notice. And actually, the first I became aware of this cell tower on the fire station site right outside our front door was receiving the Planning Commission hearing email from Jamie. And I happened to look at the agenda, and there it was. And I started.
2:23:45 Dialing the phone. So there wasn't a process. If there was a process, that was proper. I know the fire district some months ago, Nolan, you could tell everybody when it was. I don't know if it was 12, 18 months ago, had a public workshop. You know, what does a public think about having a cell tower? If I would have known about it, I would have been there because it doesn't belong where it's being proposed. I didn't get the notice. It happened to go to an old address. I understand it wasn't staff's fault.
2:24:14 They got the address from a third-party agency who had an old one. So here we sit today in a mess, and it's unfortunate. The fire department, fire chief, stood up and said, you know, for life safety reasons, we need a tower. I get it, right? Life safety, you have to appease them. You have to accommodate them, excuse me. It does belong in the region. There are gaps out there, but does it belong here? Should the process have been followed?
2:24:44 This is really ridiculous. And there are over 100 homeowners out there right now that all of a sudden have this slammed in their face. So there is an alternate site. Nobody's saying, not in my backyard. Somebody's saying, put it in the appropriate place. And I think you'll hear tonight from someone that said he would like to have this tower. It is close geographically. I talk to staff. I don't want to put words in staff's mouth. But to switch sites does.
2:25:14 Take a delay of a couple months, but isn't it better to have a couple month delay, put it at a recipient site that wants to have it, then sit in a courtroom with a bunch of attorneys, it's going to get delayed longer than that. I appealed you, please turn down this application and let's deal with this properly for everybody's sake. Thank you. Good evening, council members and mayor. David Jordan, I'm a homeowner at Creek House, Snow Creek 7.
2:25:48 I think is the proper terminology. I've been asked to speak and represent the HOA primarily because of my work experience. I've been in the commercial real estate business for the last 30 years. I've been a developer for most of that, and I've had my own company for 19 years. I've been in front of planning commissions and town councils many times, some with very controversial projects.
2:26:14 Get a virtually unanimous, if not a straight unanimous approval of both Planning Commission and Town Council because I firmly believe in a consensus-driven process and that's a protection for both the developer or project applicant as well as the neighbors or stakeholders as well as the town and city. In my 30 years, I've never seen anything further from a consensus-driven process than what has gone on with this cell tower.
2:26:40 I got to tell you, and I'll get into some of the details here, I'll try and be concise, but I speak, at this point in my career, in my life, I speak all the time in front of people, meetings, conferences, town councils, like I said, planning commissions, etc. I have never struggled more with getting prepared for planning commission or town council because, and I was asking myself, what's wrong with me? Maybe I'm losing my fastballs, I'm getting older and doing this.
2:27:07 But I really realized it's not me. There are so many things wrong with this whole process and the cell tower that it's very hard to provide in a limited amount of time a concise and coherent package for you guys to understand and discuss. So again, I'll try and stay at a high level. We did provide a memo that's very comprehensive. I hope you've had the opportunity to read that carefully. So why are we here?
2:27:31 Chuck just touched on it. I want to be very clear that the Creek House homeowners are not opposed to a cell tower or cell towers. We're opposed to the irresponsible placement of a cell tower that is causing severe, legitimate, material adverse impacts, not just to the Creek House, but to the Town of Mammoth Lakes, and they're largely unnecessary. Chuck touched on the process. I want to continue because if anybody thinks that the
2:27:59 We were given 60 days, of which almost immediately 30 to 40 percent of that disappeared because of the holidays. We asked
2:28:29 Basically three things. Can we understand what the alternate locations are, what the challenges that were to those, and what were potential mitigations? We asked for the drive maps.
2:28:40 Very technical term, I probably will butcher it, but basically understanding what are the true gap coverage problems that are perceived to be here, because we'd only seen these computer projections. We also asked for better photo simulations, because frankly the photo sims that we'd seen were just disingenuous and deceptive. They were not true reflections of what this proposed cell tower will do to impact the neighborhood and the surrounding community. So we waited, we waited, we waited. What did we get?
2:29:09 Frankly, we got dishonesty. As to the locations, we were told that the landlords were not interested and that the elevations were lower and so that they were, I think, towards suboptimal from the RF engineer's objectives. We asked about the model, instead of the drive maps, we said those were proprietary. We got the model projections again. And then we got the same photo sims. So what did we do?
2:29:37 Well, we tried to step up and try to be a positive force on this. So we actually called the site owners, as Chuck mentioned. We called the Catholic Church. They're interested. I know there's some challenges with that. We called the Snow Creek Athletic Club, and I believe Ralph's here tonight, and he's going to speak on that. He said he was interested. We actually flew a drone over the Snow Creek Athletic Club to understand the elevation changes. Surprisingly, the drone is saying that the Snow Creek Athletic Club is actually higher than the fire district site.
2:30:06 Now, it sounds like a bit of an optical illusion, but if you think of the topography, it does make sense because we're rising towards the Mammoth Lakes Basin. And we looked at Aspen Village, and that's even higher as well. I do want to touch on there are other locations we're just going to focus on for brevity on a couple of these. And then we went ahead, we looked up the AT&T website because we weren't getting the actual drive maps, and the AT&T website, which we...
2:30:32 Put in the exhibit. Says that the cell tower, the cell coverage here is excellent. You should use AT&T. I even found a couple of websites that do, like a consumer report type thing, which I'll show you. So if you're looking for what cell carrier to use in a specific location. And all of those said that AT&T is one of the best, if not the best. I can provide those. I'd have to look on my computer.
2:30:59 And then we actually went ahead and did some photo sims that I think were better accurate reflections. Those are also put into the package. And they really show what the true impact is of this tower as it is currently proposed. So we took all that and we spoke with Sonal at UConn, Chuck and I, and we said, look, we're finding a lot of discrepancies and contradictions in what we have so far.
2:31:25 We think that we need it. We ask for more time. We think we need some more time. Can we get together and talk about this and look at some of these alternatives? We got nothing. In fact, what we did get at Planning Commission was a very derogatory term that we were NIMBYs, okay? We're not NIMBYs. We're NIMPHIs. I don't want to confuse that with NIMPHIs. That's a personal issue. We're NIMPHIs, not in my front yard, okay? This became a front yard for many homeowners. When town,
2:31:54 Staff and Planning Commission approved these homes right next to this fire station. Whether that was good planning or not, sort of irrelevant at this time, the homes are there and this is an effective front yard for everyone. The process alone is enough to uphold or grant or appeal. So moving on to Planning Commission. I'm going to be a bit critical Planning Commissioners because bluntly they did not do their job. I know
2:32:26 They're good people. I've worked with a lot of planning commissions. I know it's a very difficult job, but in this case, they just simply did not do their job. As best we can tell, they based basically everything on fire life safety without any balanced consideration of any of the other impacts that are going on with the cell tower. The fire chief gave a very detailed, frankly, I think it was an informative and good description of the evolution of emergency preparedness and his future needs.
2:32:55 I liked it. I enjoyed it. But there's a real problem here. And that is that we are still not seeing a connection between this fire life safety consideration and what the cell tower will provide. And that's because we don't have actual data. And that actually creates quite a risk for the town because everything is based off of these computer model projections.
2:33:17 It's easily, and it's a hypothetical, but it's very conceivable that AT&T can build this and then say, you know what? Topography doesn't work. We didn't get quite the saturation that we thought. We've got to put another cell tower up a mile away because we weren't looking at the hard data that is needed for people to make this correct decision. I believe FirstNet, which was discussed, and again, it's more in the memo, gets over my pay grade on some of this, but I believe it's already in place. I mean, there's articles about
2:33:47 It being in place several years ago. IPOS was brought up, but that's a multimodal communication system that's frankly independent of cell towers. There's a couple other comments I think we need to touch on at Planning Commission. A number of the Planning Commissioners said this thing was ugly and that they wouldn't want it in their backyard. One Planning Commissioner brought up a heart attack and said that I would put it in my backyard if it would prevent my neighbor from dying from a heart attack. It's very emotional.
2:34:17 We understand. I don't think anybody would disagree with it, but again, I just point out that the connection has not been made between this cell tower and preventing a heart attack. Some of the visuals that were presented at Planning Commission by UConn, AT&T, were quite deceptive, too. They didn't even show the homes actually built. I don't know if they're going to show those again tonight, but they showed a brown dirt area. They didn't show what was actually there.
2:34:42 And touching on home sales, the planning commissioner said that that was due to higher interest rates. I think nobody will question that higher interest rates have slowed down home sales everywhere. But when you look at what's gone on at the Creek House, they've come to an absolute stop. And we have real estate agents, direct testimony and letters in our exhibit to you that are saying that this is being prevented. Now, I keep hearing that if somehow, I mean, so Orwellian, it just...
2:35:08 Defy his description. But if somebody does that because they're worried about health, then that doesn't matter. So we're now talking about people that have bought a home in the last couple years that may have a home that's essentially valueless, but that doesn't matter because it's due to radio frequency concerns. I don't think it really matters. The point is this proposed cell tower is having a massive impact on home values already in Creek House. And this is unnecessary.
2:35:37 Planning Commissioners did touch on the height appropriately, and they didn't understand why it would work at 55, 60 feet for Verizon, but that doesn't work for AT&T. And this is something that really needs to be explained further or really explored further to understand this. The thing that we kept hearing at Planning Commission
2:35:58 Was the radio frequency engineer's objectives, RF engineer's objectives. Let's be really clear about what AT&T's RF engineer's objectives are. The cheapest location, biggest tower, make it easy for them. So, as I said, just that alone, the decision was flawed by planning commission, and that alone should allow, should have us grant this appeal that we've put into the town. Moving on to CEQA.
2:36:29 It's another favorite. Been dealing with Sequa for 25 years. This is Sequa exempt. I just can't think of anything more absurd that I continue to hear that this is a small structure. Let's be really clear about this. This is an 80-foot tall man-made structure. There is nothing natural about it. You can put whatever euphemism you want on it. Stealth monopine. It's not stealth. It's not a pine tree. It's a man-made structure that is 80.
2:36:55 Feet tall. That's eight stories. It's the biggest thing in that area by far. It's the biggest thing, I think, frankly, in Mammoth Lakes until you get up to the village. And when you look at the village, they didn't look at the, I guarantee you, because nobody does this in California, nobody does this in the United States when they talk about floor area.
2:37:14 They don't look at it 625 feet. We didn't look at the hotels up there and say, oh, they're only 5,000 feet because that's what the footprint is. Man-made structures, you look at the whole volume. It's called floor area ratio. If we go to 10th grade geometry or 9th grade for those that were smart, I was in 10th grade geometry. You take the volume of a cylinder because this thing is 22 to 25 feet wide and 80 feet tall. It's more like 5,000 or 6,000 feet of true volume.
2:37:43 It is not a small structure. There's also major material and adverse impacts, and they need to be addressed and mitigated, and that's exactly what CEQA is here for. Those that are most affected need to be listened to the most. Very clear in California. I'm going to put some names to these people because we're just talking about Creek House, but the Brodericks, the Lees, the Pallies, these people bought right next to this, and they're now facing terrible aesthetic impacts.
2:38:15 Directly out their front doors, in from their living rooms, from their dining rooms, and a major value decrease, if not valueless. This ties directly into violating really the intent and spirit of the town council, and this is why we're here, because this is not a good location for the cell tower. The general plan and the Snow Creek Master Plan talk about the aesthetic, the importance of aesthetics. We all know how pretty.
2:38:43 The Eastern Sierras and trying to preserve that. And also the actual cell tower code. We've had a few attorneys look at the cell tower code. They actually think it's very well written. It's good. It protects. It has all the steps that are necessary. It just needs to be utilized in this case. There is no screening. That's what our photo streams show. We're talking about pine trees. There's like two or three pine trees. There's no pine trees even near the stealth monopine. Stealth monopine.
2:39:13 This is not a backyard, as I've touched on. This is a front yard. We get into this public right-of-way issue. I understand that we want to call these private streets. From the town of Mammoth Lakes perspective, you don't want to be shoveling snow, taking care of these streets. We don't have the budget for it. It is much better held at an HOA level.
2:39:32 And we totally understand that for that definition. But these are public right-of-ways in all practical terms. Anybody can hike on them. Anybody can ride their bike. Anybody can run on them. Anybody can drive a car on them. There's a street right in front of the cell tower that is proposed. It's directly contradictory to the cell tower code.
2:39:56 And I'll use the example of the Snow Creek Athletic Club to show how much better of a location that is. That is truly in the backyard of the athletic club. Yes, there are a few homes that are back there, but the homes are some distance away. It's heavily vegetated already because there's a seasonal or a perennial creek back there. You could certainly screen it even further because there's good, adequate water. And there's also 70-foot pine trees all around that area. This is the intent of the code.
2:40:24 For regarding cell towers. And that's just a much better location than what is currently being proposed to us. I do want to say because I did miss, look, I've gotten to know Aless, the fire, our fire chief, personally, I'm a fan of his. I think the town is a net better with him. We don't want to hold back tools that he needs to fight natural disasters or fires. We don't want to be a part of that. I think my point is,
2:40:52 That every item that I've touched on is enough to uphold or grant or appeal. Taken together, it's overwhelming, and this needs to be stopped. We are not here to oppose cell towers. We are here to oppose the irresponsible placement of them that are creating these severe adverse impacts. You're going to hear from many homeowners tonight about that. And there's ways to do better. And we've been trying to do better.
2:41:18 And we'd like to be better. We don't want to be opposition. We'd like to be part of a consensus-driven process to get to a better result for the town. I'm here for any questions, but thank you. Before I move on to public testimony, I would like to ask counsel if there are any questions of the appellant. Okay. Prior to public testimony, we do have a response from the appellant online. Okay. Or not from the appellant, from the applicant, sorry.
2:42:04 So, Mr. Attorney, do I go with public comment first or with the public? It would be typical to allow the applicant to speak before public comment. Okay. So we will move forward with the applicant's rebuttal. Great. And so I will ask Sonal to unmute herself and speak on behalf of UConn Group.
2:42:28 Members of the Town Council, my name is Sonal Takwar. I'm here with UConn Group on behalf of AT&T. Please give me a minute to share my screen. Okay, can you see my screen? Okay? Yes. Okay. The slide before you shows what the existing coverage in the proposed area is, the project area.
2:43:39 The pink and the yellow shows that the coverage that currently exists is marginal and poor. Excuse me, ma'am, I don't think we're seeing the slide that you're referencing. We're seeing a text slide with two bullets on it, two numbered bullets on it. Let me try that again. Can you see this? Yes. Yes, thank you. Okay, thank you. And you see a coverage map now? Yes. Okay, great.
2:44:10 So the slide shows what the coverage in the existing area along Old Mammoth Road currently is. The target, red target, shows the fire station area, center of the search ring. The pink and the yellow shows that the current coverage that is in the area is marginal and poor. Later in the presentation, we have Scott Heffernan.
2:44:38 This slide shows the general search ring area that the AT&T RF engineers are looking to cover and it
2:45:11 Shows their coverage objectives of where they're trying to improve signal and coverage for this challenging terrain in Mammoth. This yellow road is Old Mammoth Road. Where the shallow pin is, is the location of the fire station. AT&T consulted with Yukon Group in order to try to find a property that would be able to accommodate a facility that would help them
2:45:43 Provide the signal and coverage needed for this area in Mammoth and to improve the AT&T network. When UConn is looking for properties that will be able to meet those coverage objectives for AT&T's engineers, there's five criteria that we look for. One, whether or not that candidate and that candidate location will meet the criteria or rather the development standards of the local zoning code.
2:46:13 Whether or not this site can result in a successful, fully executed lease that has terms that are acceptable both to the underlying landlord and that will also be accepted by AT&T's management team. The third criteria is that it does in fact meet the criteria
2:46:37 Objectives, rather, of the RF engineers and that they will be able to provide the coverage to the area, to the boundaries and the various land uses that they're looking to improve indoor coverage, vehicle coverage, as well as outdoor coverage, which again, the RF engineer, Scott with Fox Hill, will go into more detail about those nuances.
2:47:07 We also have to make sure that the project that is proposed can result in being construction viable. And at the end of the day, does the site also meet regulatory requirements at a local, state, and federal level? Additionally, we want to make sure that the proposed and designed facility does address the gap in coverage and does consider aesthetics.
2:47:38 This is a snip of the town's zoning map with the various land uses. Here is Old Mammoth Road and this rectangle shows where the fire department property is located. The pink is designated as a resort zone. This surrounding area in pink to the north and to the east also is where the Snow Creek Lodges are located. To the south of Mammoth Road,
2:48:07 This slide here is depicting the various alternatives that were considered when looking for a property to locate the proposed project. This teal balloon
2:48:41 is where the project monopine is currently proposed, which is at the northeast rear location of the fire department station. These blue pins show three other alternatives on the fire department property that were considered. This yellow pin here shows a church property. The red balloons simply show
2:49:14 The zoning properties are excuse me, the parcels that are single family residential or multifamily residential, which ultimately were not viable locations based upon the town zoning code. The proposed property, as I mentioned, is accommodating our monopine, which is an 80 foot tall stealth tower. The top five feet of the tower
2:49:47 Will be made up of faux pine needles or faux pine branches. However, the top of the antennas and the pole for the wireless equipment will be at 75 feet. The height of the 80 feet, 80 foot tower would also accommodate a future carrier that would be situated below AT&T. The fire department fire chief has actually shown the plans.
2:50:18 That have been proposed to the city to Verizon Wireless and Verizon Wireless has expressed interest in co-locating below AT&T. With the tower there's a 200 square foot equipment enclosure that's adjacent to the west elevation of the existing fire station and south of an existing pad mounted transformer. The monopine at the rear portion of the property
2:50:50 is consistent with the requirements of the town's code. It does not encroach into any required parking loading areas or pedestrian circulation areas. And it also is situated such that it is out of the way of area needed for the fire station to operations. The tower and equipment enclosure for AT&T's facility are also easily accessible.
2:51:18 And provide a short and clear path of travel for AT&T network operators to access whenever they need to visit the property. Locating on the Fire Station 2 property also adds an additional layer of security and surveillance of AT&T's equipment. And there's the additional comfort where
2:51:46 Because it is on the fire station property, there's going to be more visibility and communication that if there's any issues with the faux branches or aesthetics that AT&T network operations can address the acute concerns in a timely manner. The co-locatable cellular facility is also a compatible use with the current operations of the fire station.
2:52:13 It would allow for clear communication, coverage and signal and it would have the capacity or ability to provide for FirstNet operations and the community that served. It should be noted that this project has a fully negotiated lease that has been accepted both by the fire board, fire station and AT&T management and this lease took years to
2:52:45 These three blue pins show alternative locations on the fire department property that were previously considered. This first alternative A was in the front landscape planter, but the code does not allow any wireless facilities to be located in the property frontage. These two other alternatives
2:53:18 B and C were actually proposed by the Snow Creek HOA and in response to those alternatives, Yukon Group and AT&T did in fact look at whether or not they were viable. Snow Creek HOA also asked Yukon Group to consider a monopole, a non-stealth monopole to which we also provided photo sims to the
2:53:46 Planning Department to present to the HOA. Unfortunately, when we provided those photo sims and these alternative responses, no input was provided. For alternative B, this is adjacent to the fire training tower and the fire station garage doors. Unfortunately, that is not a viable location for AT&T due to the risk of damage to their equipment.
2:54:18 There are also several manholes around this area which would be associated with underground utilities. Alternative C was also not viable because it does not comply with the town's code. This location, again, is close to the frontage and closest to Old Mammoth Road, so the proposed facility at the rear of the property is still more optimal than these.
2:54:45 Another alternative that was considered was St. Joseph's Catholic Church. It is zoned residential multifamily, which the town zoning code prohibits wireless facilities to locate on. For that reason, this is not a viable alternative. Another alternative that was considered was the Snow Creek Athletic Club.
2:55:22 If the site was to be situated here, it would need to be in the rear of the property and would not be able to be in any required parking, loading, vehicular pedestrian circulation areas. AT&T's RF engineers did look at this location and rejected it. They did say that the elevation was lower. Additionally, if the site was
2:55:56 to be located at the Snow Creek Athletic Club. It results in this tower being closer and move closer to other townhomes. I believe this is Snow Creek Phase 4, and additionally that tower would be situated closer to the Aspen Village Apartments. I will note that on March 5th,
2:56:25 Of 2024, in the afternoon, we did receive a cold call from Ralph Lockhart, who is the property owner for Snow Creek Athletic Lodge. This was the first time that we had received any kind of communication or correspondence from him. He simply advised that he had gotten my information from David Jordan and members of the HOA.
2:56:53 And was just reaching out to advise that in the future, if AT&T had any interest in locating here, he was available. However, we had already received approval from Planning Commission, and we still feel that the proposed candidate is the most optimal and makes the most sense. Another alternative was Aspen Village Apartments. Again, this is
2:57:23 In the resort field, but it is too far from the center of the coverage objective area, and locating here does not result in providing a less intrusive means of providing coverage than the current proposed location at Fire Station 2. Moving here, just like moving to the Snow Creek Athletic Lodge, would just move the tower and equipment closer to Snow Creek for townhomes.
2:57:53 And apartments in the resort zone. We also looked at another alternative, which is the water district. Same situation here. Moving Monopine here would simply just move the tower closer to other townhomes and apartments, as well as single-family residential homes. The proposed fire station, again, we believe that
2:58:31 This allows AT&T's RF engineers to meet their coverage objectives and provide the coverage and the signal that the town desperately needs. The terrain in this area is challenging and as heard in the testimony from the fire chief at the planning commission, this coverage needs to be improved as soon as possible so that they have the means to respond to emergencies and the needs of their community.
2:59:01 This project is feasible from both a zoning and a leasing standpoint, and having this tower at this location will ultimately serve the general welfare of the entire community and protect the life safety of the public. These are photo sims showing this is the existing view. This is a photo sim of what
2:59:34 The fire, what the model pine would look like when installed. I'd like to mention these are the exact same photo sims that were not only provided to the Creek House HOA, but these are the same photo sims that were presented at the Planning Commission, and they were prepared by independent third party. Existing view, proposed view. Additionally,
3:00:05 On February 12th of 2024, the fire department had put up a fire truck ladder. That ladder is 75 feet tall and let residents as well as members of the public know that to get a better perspective of what 75 feet looks like, which is the top of where the equipment and pole would be, they would have this up.
3:00:31 I'm going to show you different views from the community of Creek House. In some views you can see the ladder, in others you can barely notice it. This is to address any comments about photosims so that you can see this ladder that was there for everyone to see. We'll show you views of where the tower would be.
3:01:06 That red square below is where the ladder is from Minaret and Meadow. Just to conclude, our proposed facility, again, complies with the town's code and the development standards. We believe that the monopine is designed in a way that is concealed, conceals the equipment. We believe that it's designed in a manner that is responsible and minimizes the visual impacts.
3:01:41 But also addresses the community concerns of coverage and safety. And again, the entire objective of this proposed facility is in fact to provide the strengthened signal and coverage to residents, businesses, and tourists in this area. Fire Chief Alex Tonner had mentioned that it is of even more concern that tourists have
3:02:09 I would like to note that this facility would also have the presence of FirstNet, which again was commented on by the fire chief and I believe the forestry ranger at the planning commission hearing that
3:02:40 The presence of FirstNet improves their ability to communicate with one another, have a plan, and mobilize to emergency situations, and it works in conjunction with having improved coverage. Again, this 80-foot tall tower would allow for the co-location in the future of a second carrier, and Verizon has, in fact, expressed interest that they would like to co-locate below AT&T.
3:03:10 This would minimize any delays in having coverage on air, and additionally it would minimize impacts to the fire station and additional time to construct a tower that would need to be extended were this not designed in such a manner to accommodate two major wireless carriers. The opposition has conceded that there is in fact a need for connectivity and coverage in this area.
3:03:40 And having that improved coverage, I would argue that that alone increases property values, especially with the volume of residents, or rather tourists and visitors that come to this area. AT&T, we believe, has demonstrated that this proposed facility will in fact comply with the FCC's RF exposure standards, and this application cannot be rejected through health concerns.
3:04:11 or raised explicitly or indirectly through some proxy such as property values. Scott Heffernan, the professional engineer with Foxville Telecom, will provide a presentation that goes into the coverage provided by this facility as well as address admissions and compliance with FCC. And this concludes my presentation. I'm available for questions that the Commission may have. Questions?
3:04:45 Oh, I guess I have a quick question. When did this application start? Like, when did you start looking at sites for cell towers? Are you there? Yes, sorry about that. We, well, AT&T started looking at cell towers, I would say, more than almost a decade ago. At that time, the property was, or the location was proposed at the front of the
3:05:18 Property, which was not compliant with the code, but I believe it was also a different design. As far as the specific monopine before you, that would be, I want to say at least five years ago. Thanks. And then looking at alternative sites, when did that occur? Like when were you considering alternative sites? Was that five years ago or ten years ago?
3:05:49 Three out the process. Okay, and recently as well? Five years, more recently. More recently than five years ago? Correct. And then it looks like there are currently like four cell towers, like three within the town limits and one on Mammoth Mountain. Is that correct? Let me look at the coverage maps. Correct. Those are existing sites that have been constructed.
3:06:22 Okay. In the AT&T network. And are there other cell towers from other networks or is that all of it? This map is just showing where the other existing AT&T towers are. I do not have information showing where all of the other towers for other networks may be located. Okay. Thank you. Other questions? Nope. Let's move this on then. Good evening.
3:07:03 My name is Scott Heffernan. I'm an RF engineer with Fox Hill Telecom. Fox Hill Telecom was hired by AT&T to really work on three separate points. The first was to ensure that the proposed facility designed by AT&T would comply with all federal standards regarding radio frequency emissions. That is something that we conducted numerous studies on.
3:07:33 We ran several calculations for the site in many configurations. The results were that the site as it is designed is well within all federal regulations with regard to emissions compliance. I know that we have submitted an RF emissions report regarding those calculations, but I'm happy to go over those at any time. The second point that we were brought on to analyze was
3:08:02 So we were given several channels.
3:08:31 And again, I believe that report was made available to the board.
3:09:01 Lastly, we were brought on to analyze the existing and proposed coverage maps and objectives for AT&T. So the first thing we do when we get a project like this is we try to identify where exactly is AT&T trying to cover with this ring? And I know that's a question that everybody has when looking at the application.
3:09:32 Bear with me a second. I'm going to share my screen. Can everyone see that screen? Yes. Yes. Okay. So what we're looking at here is a map, and I'm sure everybody here knows exactly what that is, a map of Mammoth Lakes. Just south of the center of this map, circled with a red circle, is the location of the proposed AT&T facility at the fire station property.
3:10:24 And just to orient everybody, where my cursor is dragging along, this is Old Mammoth Road, just kind of running southwest to northeast, heading up towards Meridian and the 203 corridor. It was just asked a few minutes ago whether there were existing facilities in the area. The three that were referenced is a tower referenced here as CSL 01050, just south.
3:10:52 East of the intersection of Old Mammoth and Meridian. And then there are two more facilities located to the north along 203. We have a rooftop up here where the cursor is, and then there's an existing tower just to the east of that rooftop. There are two existing facilities over by Mammoth Mountain and a little beyond.
3:11:22 That are just off of the map shown here. They will show up on other maps that I'll be showing. But just to be able to zoom in and give some granularity to the roads and the area that falls under the coverage objective, we had to, you know, we had to zoom in to this as a minimum. So once I show you the coverage maps, and I know that you've already seen the heat maps that Sonal had.
3:11:51 In her presentation. But you'll notice that there is existing coverage in the east of the proposed facility at the fire station, as well as north along the 203 corridor, again, heading east and west. And if you're on there heading west, you're going to be heading over towards Mammoth Mountain in the sites over there. So there is adequate coverage for AT&T along this 203 corridor.
3:12:17 And that coverage does extend down Old Mammoth Road roughly until you get to the intersection with Minaret. AT&T does have reliable coverage approximately a quarter of a mile west past the intersection at Minaret Road. But after that, just due to terrain and distance from the existing sites, reliable coverage dives up very quickly. And again, we'll show that in the coverage maps.
3:12:47 So the way that we define an RF coverage objective in an area like this is to look at, okay, where does our existing footprint of reliable on-air coverage end? So we've established that with the provided heat maps, and later on we will go over some drive test results. I know that's been a hot button, and we're happy to address that.
3:13:15 Really defining the bounds of where the coverage objective is for this AT&T ring. The RF design team at AT&T, it was looking to extend coverage west along Old Mammoth Road, roughly from the intersection of Minaret over towards the Woodman and Tamarack Street. I guess you would call it intersection with Old Mammoth Road. It's a very defined, very...
3:13:42 I would say small coverage area in comparison to very large 150, 200-foot towers that they may have in other parts of the network. But it's a coverage objective that needs to be very targeted because in addition to having a lot of traffic and a lot of visitors that come through the area along Old Mammoth Road, there are a lot of residential structures in this area. So AT&T customers, either existing or potential, that live in this area,
3:14:12 Really need good robust coverage to provide that level of reliable coverage inside, whether it's, again, a residence or even a small business, like an office building, corrugated metal building for a shop, anything that might exist in this area. So once we've identified what that objective is, the search ring is established, and then that's when site acquisition goes out and looks for viable candidates in that area to provide
3:14:42 And I do have other types of maps, terrain maps that we can go over if there are other questions. So just to quickly review the heat maps that were in Sonal's presentation, what we see here is, and to orient everyone, my cursor is going along the 203 corridor, heading south from 203. We have the existing tower at the just southeast of the intersection of Old Mammoth.
3:15:11 Meridian Boulevard. But you can see as you travel west along Old Mammoth Road, once you get past that identified terrain, just maybe a quarter mile past the intersection with Minaret Road, the footprint from the reliable coverage that's on air currently for AT&T dies off pretty quickly. It's not that there's an exaggerated cell edge here where you might have some usable coverage for maybe outdoor
3:15:40 What exactly is this telling us? It's telling us that
3:16:07 Coverage exists in the area that we clearly identified, and then the area where the proposed facility is now into that area where reliable on-air coverage does not exist anymore. Clearly an area where this site and maybe other sites in the future are probably going to be needed because there is a pretty vast area that remains uncovered. But the next logical step...
3:16:33 And putting the puzzle together on providing good coverage for AT&T in this area is roughly in this area along Old Mammoth Road. So the best viable candidate that came over to the IRS team at AT&T, and I just need to make a distinction. I did not personally design the site. We were brought in to review the information and the coverage maps that were
3:17:03 So we can clearly see that even at 70 feet and regardless of what everybody thinks of.
3:17:31 You know, 70 feet. 70 feet is a pretty modest type for a tower facility in wireless networks, especially in an area like this where you're, you know, you're not in a flat plain area like in the middle of Kansas. There's a little bit of terrain that you have to contend with, and I'm sure everybody driving through here knows that. So the ability to provide a fairly sizable footprint and the diameter on this footprint from the proposed facility
3:18:00 Is approximately a mile across. So that's a mile of coverage that doesn't exist right now, a level of coverage that doesn't exist right now. So it does provide that comfort of knowing that you have reliable service if you are an AT&T customer, emergency services in the area, with the fire station being right there and really trying to push that footprint for first net coverage.
3:18:30 Clearly there's a big expansion on the footprint heading west in this area. And really any folks in this area that need the E-911 services, if there's a car accident, an emergency in their home, they can reliably use those services inside their residences or businesses within this area. So anywhere that you see the green segueing into the yellow does denote areas of fairly reliable coverage. And that's really what
3:18:59 AT&T designs down to for a minimum signal level threshold. So now talking about the drive test, anytime that I do review coverage maps or if we want to call them heat maps or propagation maps, I always like to have either current drive data that was done by the carrier or we go out and conduct our own. For this case here,
3:19:30 Fox Hill Telecom did go out, and we did our own network drive of the on-air AT&T server. This was done on March 19th, so it's a very current study, and that's what we wanted. We wanted it to be in current seasonal conditions. There is a difference for our propagation between summer foliage, the wintertime where maybe a lot of leaves are off the trees.
3:19:59 Simple things like that. So we wanted it to be in a, as we're discussing it in the spring, it should be done in that time frame. So as we can see here, it does back up what the prediction maps do show, that there is a level of reliable coverage along the two or three corridor as we head down Old Mammoth past Meridian, past, and you can see it gets very robust heading down into this area. And I should probably stop here and just,
3:20:29 Bring everybody up to speed with regard to what these colors mean. Each of these colors are a thematic representation of a signal level range. So when any carrier designs a network, they have a minimum design threshold where they can reliably bill service or promote service to their customers. For ET&T and for most carriers that design these types of networks,
3:20:58 Minus 95 dBm is the minimum design threshold for reliable coverage where you'll be able to use that phone, you know, in your business, in your home, in your car, outdoors. Excuse me, Scott, Mr. Mayor. Anything below that you said to get into college? Scott, if I can pause you one moment, please. We could just make that a little bit bigger now that we're talking about colors and numbers. It's just not visible here. If you can make your screen presentation slightly larger.
3:21:26 Thank you. There you go. Thank you. Is that better? Much better. Thank you. Okay. And I'm sorry if that makes anything on there blurry. There's a lot of points in there, and they might get tickled if I try to blow it up too much. But I'll do my best. So on this map here, like I said, minus 95 dBm, and that's a value used when referencing received signal strength values.
3:21:56 For these types of networks. So minus 95. So when I say minus 95 dBm or better, because it's a negative number, better means getting closer to zero. So minus 95, minus 85, minus 75, minus 65 and onward. Those values are increasing in signal strength and typically signal quality. That's really what we go for is signal quality. But where most carriers can provide coverage,
3:22:26 And in this area, AT&T specifically can provide reliable coverage, you know, with regard to good signal quality, is at that minus 95 dBm range or better. So you can see there are several colors that show signal strengths that are better than minus 95. And this helps us out because really what's lower than minus 95 are three different ranges. We have the orange.
3:22:53 We have red, which is minus 100 down to minus 105. And then we have the black dots that are anything below minus 105. Minus 105, that's an area that chances are you can't use a device in that area. So because there are only three colors that are below the minimum design threshold, it makes it easy to look at this map. And now what that tells us is that
3:23:24 The large, what I would consider to be a significant gap in coverage is in that area that was represented on the heat maps. So what that tells us is this drive test, again, a very current drive test, backs up the propagation or the heat maps that were provided in the application for the site. And I apologize if I'm going long on this. I can talk about this stuff all night. But if there are any questions regarding
3:23:53 The emissions compliance, anything to do with the interference study or anything with regard to coverage, whether it be heat map or drive test related, I'm happy to take the follow-up questions. Hi, Scott. Two quick questions which may or may not be within your purview of expertise. There's been a representation that an analysis has determined that the site
3:24:27 Over at the Snow Creek Athletic Club is actually at a higher altitude than the proposed site. Can you speak to that or not? I don't have the parameters of that location. I would have to run my own personal study. I know that the internal team at AT&T has looked at these candidates and for one reason or another either deemed them unacceptable from an RF coverage standpoint. Just having it be a little bit higher in elevation.
3:24:58 Doesn't always mean that it's a better candidate. You know, that increase in elevation might be pulling it closer to terrain features like ridge lines or hills where that terrain can get very constrictive on the ability to provide coverage in certain directions. But I don't want to say that that is happening or isn't happening without having done a full study on that. Okay. And then would there be any material?
3:25:25 I would have to, that location pinpointed on a map and I apologize that that wasn't part of the scope of the review for this for us. It's mostly about compliance and confirmation of
3:25:56 That what was provided by AT&T does in fact hold water. But if we have a map, I don't know if you have a map showing where that is? That's fine. So AT&T, they asked you to specifically analyze one site, is that correct? Well, it's not so much that they're asking me to analyze it. What they're doing is they're saying based upon the...
3:26:24 The analysis that they've done on all of the candidates that were brought in, and those candidates were summarized by Sonal in her presentation, AT&T along the way would have done an analysis to determine whether or not they were viable from a purely RF standpoint, would they provide coverage or not? So when it gets down to us, when we get called in to run the compliance, you know, the emissions compliance, the interference compliance, but also to review
3:26:52 The coverage data for the primary facility, that means that a site has already been applied for. Okay. I get it. I understand. What we're reviewing is the application. I understand. So your analysis was on one site, the preferred site is recommended by AT&T. Is that fair to say? That is, but also the existing coverage that would apply to any site. So this side map that I'm showing on the screen, that doesn't just apply to the proposed facility.
3:27:21 That's the existing footprint for any of those candidates. So that is something that is universal. Okay. All right. Thank you. So with that, it is now an opportunity for you to invite the public to provide any comments on the project. We will be taking notes on the comments and then providing responses at the end of public comments to keep it moving along. Good evening.
3:28:16 Mayor and Councilmembers, Ralph Lockhart, owner of Snow Creek Athletic Club. We've owned it since 2007. We have a desire to be a good neighbor to all the people around us, Snow Creek 4, Aspen Village, Snow Creek 7, the fire department, you name it. Our site is further west, and where the red and the black is on the map,
3:28:47 It would be a little closer to those areas, I would believe. I received, I would have guessed a call somewhere in the seven or eight years ago, maybe it could have been five years ago, and I did express an interest, so I have a concern about the process. Yes, we had an interest in locating a facility. Our property is five and a half acres. It's roughly eight times the size of the fire department.
3:29:14 The building on the site has got a footprint of about 33,000 square feet, and it's 35 feet high in certain areas, and could probably provide some screening and some coverage. We have stands of trees, we have a creek between us and Snow Creek 4. Seems like there could have been other analysis done on our site. I think it's roughly the same elevation.
3:29:45 The fire department is closer to where the golf course
3:30:15 Coverage. So it sounds, I've heard things like almost a decade ago and throughout the process and best viable candidate, that doesn't even ring a bell with me. I don't even think Snow Creek was notified of the cell phone tower until David Jordan let me know about it. So we typically have about 2,000 members of the town who are members of the athletic club and we receive
3:30:43 Scott, could you please stop sharing your screen?
3:31:18 Good evening. My name is Ron Homer. I live at 1371 Timber Creek, and unfortunately I live right across the street from this site. In fact, my seven-year-old will easily be able to throw a baseball into this tower. The shadow of this is over my house. There's been no discussion about ice, debris, rain, things like that that may fall onto my home.
3:31:42 There's no discussion of all the noise from all of the equipment that's going to be located there, the generators. What about the pollution? What about the noise in that? I certainly would have never bought in this location had I known. We're told that this has been in the works for 10 years, yet we were barely notified, as we've talked about. The process was not valid. It wasn't. We didn't have time to get our ducks in order to fight this. We're told we're not allowed to talk about the RF effects in health.
3:32:12 I'm a physician for 25 years. Those studies stopped in 1996 because guess who paid for the Telecommunications Act? AT&T. So believe me, nobody in this room wants their little kids getting blasted with 10 to the 12th, as God will tell you, radiation. So unfortunately, if this is built, the decades we save for this, we have to sell and move somewhere else. I don't want to have...
3:32:41 Debris coming out on my kids when there's ice and snow. I don't want unknown health effects on them. Sono called me and my neighbors NIMBYs and fools for objecting to this. I don't think anyone here would want this. I know none of you do. And I think there are other options with the athletic club or with the smaller tower. Anyone wants to come to my house.
3:33:11 And look, you can see these pictures, this giant thing, there's like two other trees right there. You guys all know this town as well as I do better. It's not a good site. It's not like this is in a forest of trees and it's going to not stand out. So I think we may have a lot better alternatives to this. And it's just hard to hear about that we need to protect AT&T's profitability and Yukon and their equipment.
3:33:42 Yet, we're not even allowed to talk about the health of my family. I mean, it's crazy, right? I mean, we need to actually use common sense, guys. At the beginning of this meeting, I'm told, you guys can't, you're my elected representatives, but you can't represent me. Somebody said that. It's just not how it's supposed to work. I'm educated in science, and none of this makes any sense. And I think this is an engineering and a political problem, and I think we can find a solution maybe that's better for everyone.
3:34:13 Our job here is not to make sure the people at UConn get big bonuses. It's not to make sure AT&T's RF profiles are 99% instead of 97%. We need to protect our community, and I urge you to do that. Hello, my name is Lucia Homer. I'm 12 years old, and I'm in the sixth grade. Hi, my name is Kai Homer. I am seven years old, and I am in second grade.
3:34:45 We live at 1371 Timber Creek and we are devastated that AT&T are planning to build a cell phone tower right next to our home. We really enjoy going to Mammoth because of the beauty of the mountains and building a cell phone tower next to our home will ruin it. It will be the tallest structure in our area. Another issue of the cell phone tower is the radio waves passing through our bodies 24-7. We're not quite sure what the effects of these radio waves are, but we are positive they are not good.
3:35:13 These are the reasons we don't want an eight-story cell phone tower next to our house. Thank you for listening. Thank you. Eric Larson, I live at 1465 Boulder Creek. I could probably say that once the tower's in, it's going to be about seven, eight feet further than that map on the wall right there from my house. I would urge, I've heard nothing but what you can't do to get this location moved. Nobody's, all of this presentation is about whether you want to have a cell tower or not. We're not arguing about having a cell tower.
3:35:49 What we're saying is that there was never due process to find out is there a better location that fits both the town and UConn. I see nothing that UConn's provided that says the cell tower doesn't perform just as well over at the Snow Creek Athletic Club as it does at the fire station. I guarantee you it'll cost them more or it's more difficult. They invested money in signing a lease without public scrutiny because the fire department didn't have proper disclosure to the town in order for us to show up and protest it.
3:36:18 So they've invested stuff already. They're very committed to trying to keep it at that location despite the town. They said the elevation is lower. It's not. I took two altimeters out there and it was actually higher. They called us NIMBYs. There are a lot of reasons. And I provided drone footage that will show you how much more screened and how few people will be impacted by that cell tower at the athletic club versus the fire station. At the fire station location, most of the town will be able to see it.
3:36:47 The old Mammoth Road, you'll be able to see from the drone footage. There are all kinds of cars coming and going on the road that will be able to see it. If you can see it from the drone, it can be seen from wherever that location is in town. So I would urge that somebody, that I guess would be the question, can somebody in the legal inform the council what powers they do have to prevent this from happening or to force a fair
3:37:17 Bilateral investigation into the Snow Creek Athletic Club. Because so far, all the information about whether it's acceptable or not has come from one source only, and that would be UConn and AT&T, and they are not necessarily not looking out for their best interests, you know, call it me jaded on that. So I would really encourage digging around and seeing if there is a way to force to use some of the town's powers in zoning to say, look,
3:37:45 No, thousands of people are going to see it in this location. Hardly anybody is going to see it over here. And as for property values and using as a proxy, RF emissions as a proxy for property values, my house is on the market. People that have looked at it have said, well, we want to find out what happens with the cell tower first. You look out my window, it is literally going to be looking up and up and then a huge tower shadowing my house. It is ugly. Even the planning commission people said,
3:38:14 Ugly as hell were the exact words. I wouldn't want it in my backyard. My values go down. Everybody's values go down in that complex. It's not like, oh, hey, you're so close and we're so far, so we're only going to hitch your house for the value. It's decimating us. It will decimate us. And it's not because of RF irradiation. It's because it is ugly. And by the way, I've never heard of cell tower, a cell reception being a boost to values and properties, as was mentioned.
3:38:49 Any others? Good evening. My name is Suzanne Homer, and just like my husband spoke and my two children spoke, I live at 1371 Timber Creek. I'm here to also talk about the impact on our family as well. We moved here with the intent of introducing our children to a different way of living from the city. Our primary home is in Palos Verdes, and we bring our kids
3:39:21 Up here as much as possible to get them out into nature to see what it's like to live in the mountains. And the last thing I want is an 80-foot man-made structure in front of our home when we could have it placed in a slightly different location. We've heard tonight that the Snow Creek owner is open to having this 80-foot cell-foot tower.
3:39:50 on his property. Why don't we take a look and see if we can provide the adequate cell coverage to our community in a location that is more appropriate? I feel like the speakers before me that due process in this procedure was in this whole mess was not really followed. There's a lot of people involved that will be affected adversely and I urge
3:40:19 I really do urge you to really consider that before just rubber stamping it. I know AT&T and Yukon just want to railroad this through. They have the lease signed. It's all good. Whatever. I don't think that's the case. There are other people involved. It's not just AT&T. And we're all here tonight to speak passionately about why we don't want it in this particular location. It's not that we don't...
3:40:46 We agree that it may be needed, but it doesn't have to be in this location. So I please urge you to consider the kids, consider the families that are here for the right reasons, and please put it in a place that will serve the community without destroying our personal lives. Thank you. I'm not going to add a ton because a lot's been said already, and I basically agree with everything that's been said. I'm in the other house that's right next to the thing, and it's...
3:41:25 Directly across the street from me. Not quite as impacted as the homers. They're, I think, 15 steps from this tree. And I'm 30, you know, but pretty much really affected. I think that the, to me, the biggest problem is just site selection. If there's a better site, we should be exploring it. And when you're talking about screening, like, if you look from our homes and the other trees it's supposed to fit in with, we won't even see the trees. We're going to see an 80-foot tower.
3:41:54 We're going to see, it's going to block the trees. It's that big and they're right behind it. They're towards the road. So there is no screening for us. It's just a tower. So when I think about it and I think about it like showing my home to somebody or something like that, they're just going to see a big old fake tree, 80 feet tall in front of it. I mean, like I wouldn't buy that home for anywhere near what someone paid for it. If that wasn't there when they bought it and it's there now, I mean, how is there any way that an 80 foot tower?
3:42:24 With nothing around it sticking out like a sore thumb does not affect your value. There's no way it doesn't. It does. And I think you guys have the ability to help us be constructive and try to find a better spot. And I would hope that, like I said, as our elected officials, you would help us and help find the right place for this because it's just the wrong place. It sticks up in the middle of a community. It's not in its own section, neighbored by trees.
3:42:52 A little cutout in the middle of our homes. The picture that AT&C showed didn't even show the homer's home. It was taken before it was there. And so it doesn't show the proximity's 15 steps from their front door. It's just wrong. So I'm going to leave it at that. But to me, it's please consider it. Thank you. All right. Good evening, Halish to my Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District. My bedtime is almost about the same as yours, Mayor, so I'm going to keep this really brief unless you have any questions.
3:43:31 You know, so obviously AT&T's vested interest is to look out for AT&T. Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District is to look out for the community. I certainly have empathy for everybody in this room and all the considerations. As John Eastman mentioned at the planning and economic development meeting, you know, you have the tough job to look out for the entire community. It's very difficult sometimes. Yeah, absolutely.
3:43:59 So I've been chief for about two years. It started long before I got here. Kind of a big point that I think really was kind of a benchmark in this process was the Mono County Grand Jury investigation of 2019-2020. If you're familiar with that, it basically spoke to the communication issues that we have within the communities abroad. There's some other areas I think were pivotal if you ever drove through Crowley. You're aware that there used to be a gap there that's now covered, and those are really important.
3:44:29 I'm not going to speak on this whole topic unless you have questions on it. Again, it's incredibly hard. I think, you know, no matter where you put this due to our zoning, it's going to be difficult if we moved it to another location. Guess what? There's another phase of Snow Creek and you're going to have the residents that live around that that are going to be in here. So unfortunately, there are no perfect places to put this. We're trying to work with the best options. The district worked hard to provide a tower that would meet communication needs.
3:44:56 Not for Verizon, not for AT&T, but ultimately for the public. It's been specifically designed for that. That's where that height is. There's no intent to increase that height because it provides for the two providers that are interested in supporting our community. That statement was supported by our board at our last meeting, and it's in our letter that we provided. Ultimately, this just comes down to communications. There's nothing more ubiquitous than cell phones. Raise your hand if you don't have a cell phone with you today.
3:45:28 He doesn't have a cell phone. That's a good parent right there because I didn't do that with my first kid. My second two kids don't have cell phones. That being said, you know, we have some challenges in Old Mammoth and ultimately we need to provide for our public out there. There's a...
3:45:44 Basically two fundamental reasons. One is the public safety side for first responders. There are some questions on this. I'm not going to get into the details, but yes, there's different bandwidths, all sorts of things. This is a modern radio. It's made by Harris. It works on our VHF channel with the new CRIS system that's coming in. It also works on FirstNet. So it provides redundancy and more capability in the system using FirstNet, which is a federal program. Our iPads. These are in our rigs. I also work off of FirstNet.
3:46:12 Important component, as Chief Jeff Hinton mentioned when he was at the planning economic development meeting, first night essentially shows up when you're at an incident. They provide the communications for those first responders. So that's the component. Ultimately, I think the larger one is, sorry, is the community. You know, this is our way to reach the community when we have a wildfire and notify everybody, get them out of there safely.
3:46:42 Old Mammoth House has some unique challenges. We need to leverage what we have in our favor. Any questions? Any more public comments from in the house? Good evening. I'm an owner in the Creek House Development. My family is proud to be part of this amazing community, and we've saved for years to have an opportunity to call Mammoth Home. That being said, I want to make sure my voice is heard with respect to the proposed cell phone tower. The massing and scale is wildly inappropriate for this area. It'll be the largest structural, natural, or man-made by a large margin.
3:47:24 And there's been nothing presented that will mask it or mitigate the impacts from this tower. I find it hard to believe that the town is comfortable calling, and we're saying 80 feet, but it could be 100 feet tower exempt from Sequa as a small facility. The tower will affect or negatively affect a large group of Mammoth homeowners from views and home values. I believe we have an opportunity tonight at this council meeting to set a precedent in Mammoth that anyone that wants to develop in this area
3:47:52 to be held to a very high standard and to protect the natural beauty of this town. I'd like to see the town challenge AT&T UConn to go back to the drawing board, find a solution that can be a win-win for the community, safety, and the telecom group. I'm not asking that the council prohibit a cell phone tower, just exercise solid planning. Thank you. Good evening. I'm Wendy Blades. We're on Clear Creek Road.
3:48:24 First of all, I want to say I am so disappointed. We've been so impressed with this town and the smart decisions that have been made over the past number of years. But the fact that we're all gathered here tonight with this issue is just incredibly disappointing. I never in a million years thought I would be in opposition to anything that the fire department, the fire district was doing. You know, I'm appalled by that, first of all.
3:48:54 As I said, we're on Clear Creek Road. We love the Clear Creek Townhomes. We love the neighborhood. We love the meadow, the ponds, the stream. We love the views. On October 30th, 2023, we were shocked to learn for the first time that an 80-foot cell tower in clear view, no screening whatsoever, 30 feet from Timber Creek Road, was going to planning in November.
3:49:22 Wait, what? We were sitting in an airport at the time we discovered this. From the fire district minutes, on two separate occasions, this all began in 2021, on two separate occasions, the question of public notification was raised. Once it was deferred, once the question wasn't answered, this lack of transparency comes across as a purposeful sleight of hand.
3:49:49 Increased data speeds and public safety have been emphasized by AT&T at the behest of the fire district. As a tactic to sell this to the city, don't take my word for it, go back in the fire department minutes and check it out. AT&T's lobbyists clearly know what the hot button triggers are that convince municipalities to sign off on unpopular locations. In November of 2021, when the cell tower was first proposed,
3:50:19 One of the inducements offered by AT&T was help funding a generator for which a grant had just been denied to the fire district. What else has been offered that we don't know about? AT&T initially contacted the fire district because, as it said in the minutes, they were having problems with the ski area site and wanted to pivot back to station two.
3:50:42 It didn't quite seem as important at that point. So what happened with the ski area site? Is that filling in or where are we with that? I've got to ask, have you all gone crazy? Does anyone actually think this is a good location? We're not against the cell phone tower. We just think it's a horrendous location.
3:51:03 The thing is frankly but ugly. Excuse my French. You will be creating urban blight in a brand new neighborhood. How can you let this happen? It will become a landmark. People will say, oh yeah, we're just to the right of the cell phone tower. Do you really want that in this beautiful town? So before you vote, please ask yourselves, would you want to live by this tower? To have this in your neighborhood?
3:51:33 If the answer is no, then you're morally obligated to vote no, finding the correct rationale to do so and look for a different location. Snow Creek Athletic Site. Thank you. Good evening. I'll be brief. My name is Mark Young. I'm a resident at 1321 Timber Creek, approximately 300 yards from the proposed site. I just want to echo something that Mr. Jordan said.
3:52:04 We've had AT&T service for 20 years on our cell phones, and we have better service here than we do at home in San Diego. So the point that I'd like to make is that my personal experience is that the data that are presented in terms of coverage are misleading, possibly untruthful, and that this is a case where the
3:52:34 Data are being made to fit the hypothesis that we need this tower here as opposed to the hypothesis meeting the data that I'm experiencing and probably many other people are also experiencing. I would urge the council to put pragmatism over textualism, in the words of Stephen Breyer, and maybe go back to the basics and check the coverage.
3:53:04 I'm not saying we don't need it, but certainly a four or five hundred yard shift to the Snow Creek Athletic Club site would not hurt. Wouldn't change my signal at all, probably. Thank you. I'm a homeowner also at Creek House, 1442 Boulder Creek Road, and we've been coming to Mammoth for over 40 years, and one of our dreams in retirement was to have a place up here that we could...
3:53:39 So we could spend large amounts of time. And it would be really hard at this point in the evening to say something that you haven't already heard. But just a couple things stand out to me. I mean, at the Planning Commission meeting, I was understanding for the first time that, you know, this tower could not only accommodate AT&T, but it was large enough to accommodate another carrier. So, sorry. So there's still a lot of questions that haven't really been answered. I mean, first of all, does
3:54:08 I don't think anyone, I haven't heard anyone say that we don't, that there isn't a need for better cell service, and certainly the fire department has made compelling, you know, explanation of why we need this in the community. It's clear that there's more than one option. I know that AT&T has invested time and money, and they're pretty far down the road, and, you know, we heard all the reasons why this is good for AT&T, but one of those reasons is that they've already spent all this money, and they don't want to start from scratch.
3:54:37 It's not the best solution to be where it is, and certainly for the homeowners that have just recently purchased in Creek House and then discovered for the first time that this thing is going to be, you know, just steps from their front door, you know, I'd be infuriated. I mean, we've been in the development for two and a half years, and I mean, the views are absolutely the reason why we're there. Anyway, I know you've heard all this. We just really hope that you'll give this some consideration, and we appreciate your time. Thank you.
3:55:13 Good evening, Council, Mr. Mayor. Nice to see you, staff, homeowners. My name is Betsy Truax. I, as many of you know, I'm the vice chair of the Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District.
3:55:26 Board, and I just wanted to speak in support of Chief Tamire. You know, I understand these are difficult decisions, you know, before the Planning Commission, before you, and also decisions that are very constrained by federal and state law. But I would just like to reiterate that when the Fire Board reviewed the lease and approved it, our consideration is simply for public safety. We just, we support our chief, as you all know, Mammoth.
3:55:54 While a beautiful natural environment also has a lot of natural hazards and we just, we really need to do right by the firefighters who serve our community and make sure that they have the tools and equipment at their disposal to serve and protect life and property here in Mammoth. So again, Chief Temeier, I think, covered, you know, everything that, everything that needed to be said. But again, I just wanted to reiterate that the Fire District Board of Commissioners does unanimously support the tower. Thank you.
3:56:33 Good evening, Council. Dan Casabian, Chief of Police for the Mammoth Lakes Police Department. Also in support of Chief Tomeyer, I've been here for 22 years. Old Mammoth Service, whether it's Verizon or AT&T, is horrible. And just to make a quick correction on IPAWS, IPAWS is like our emergency alert system, and that is used through cellular data. So when we had our emergencies last year, homes exploding and stuff, and we were sending messages out,
3:57:02 I don't know for sure on how those messages were getting out into Old Mammoth. I know some people that were out there at Old Mammoth said they never got them. So that's just one of the issues that we're seeing with the emergency alert system. It's not a standalone system. So just wanted to make that correction. And also just let you know that out there in Old Mammoth, the cellular data is horrible. It's really bad, and I believe this would help. I know the homeowners also say, hey, we need a cell tower, but not there.
3:57:33 I can't really speak to that, but we do need a cell teller out there. So that's all I have. Thanks. Hello, Council. I'm an owner of 1373 Timber Creek Road. Bought about two and a half years ago. Used most of the money saved for our life. And this is really going to affect the people there. We're all in agreement that we're for public safety. We need the cell tower.
3:58:11 This was just absolutely not on anybody's radar that bought there in the last, you know, few years. So just please consider alternate location. This is, you know, a tragedy, the location where it's picked. I mean, it just doesn't look like a big deal from the photos. But again, if you're in the community on what are essentially public streets, I mean, it is all you're going to see.
3:58:40 Thanks for your consideration. Anyone else in the room wishing to speak before I go to online? Go ahead. Can I just make one point of clarification that Councilman Wentworth brought up? The site that AT&T looked at, at the Snow Creek Athletic Club, was on the east or the west side of the building itself in the middle of the property, which does put it right next to Aspen Village, does put it right next to Snow Creek 4 units.
3:59:13 But the site that we're talking about as the alternative site is actually in the northeast corner, not over on the west side. So it's in the middle of the trees, and it's away from Snow Creek four units, away from seven units. If you know the building, it's backed by the loading dock in that forest of trees right there. Thank you. Thank you, Council. I also live in Snow Creek. You know, I'm a builder, and most of the homes I build in San Diego, we have to story pole them.
3:59:47 The entire house, you know, roof lines, everything, and I have to certify them. And, you know, I went into Eshko in October, waited six months to buy this gem, to own it for four months to find out there was a cell tower. And I'm just wondering, like, why there was nothing posted, you know, like saying, hey, you know, so that we can make good decisions for ourselves. You know, how could I be up here?
4:00:16 And spend all this money, you know, my girlfriend of seven years, you know, has cancer, you know, she can't come back here, you know, so she, we discovered it when we bought the place, you know, and she's, you know, triple negative breast cancer. You know, it's not your problem, I don't mean to get emotional, but, you know, if they worked on this for five years, or all these years, how could we not know?
4:00:48 That's the question here. It's not us pitting us against the fire department, the police. Well, I don't want to be here pitting against anybody. All we want is to be able to know so we can make a good decision. How could I buy that and not know? That's the question. Not the shot clock. The shot clock started afterwards. That's what they want to talk about. The shot clock. There's nothing we can do now. What if it was five years in the planning and they've done all these sites and all these studies?
4:01:17 How could we not know? You know? I want somebody to just buy my house back. You know, I don't want it. Not if it gets approved. You know, what am I supposed to do now? But, anyway. Hi, my name is Lee Gosch. I live at 69 Lupin. I'm going to go in a totally different direction. I watched this three times on the Planning Commission, and they wish that somebody from outside the area would speak, so here I am. I was saddened.
4:01:57 It saddens me greatly the lack of communication and collaboration with the Creek House as to where to put the towers on. The tower is so close to the buildings, this will create bad blood neighborhood wars and our town is already divided enough and we're going to have to hire more policemen eventually. I'm going to put this to the company proposing this. Is this what you want for our town?
4:02:28 The choice is yours. You can make things change if you want to. You will be willing to move the tower away from so close to the buildings or look at the athletic club. Last year there was a developer behind Loco Frijoles who worked with the people around it and the project went through and I have a great deal of respect for that developer. Roy Sarri taught me four things that are needed. You need proof before you go forward. Yes, we need help with...
4:02:57 You have to listen to the people. And not everything is a given.
4:03:26 When you make your decisions. I ask the company who is putting in the towers to think very hard, bad blood, neighborhood wars, is that what you really want for our town? It's an easy fix. The choice is on your shoulders of what you want to do with our town. I have one last thing to say is I was advised to call somebody at the town. I put the person's name in and I never got a call back. That is why people never get involved with this town.
4:03:56 They don't get involved because nobody ever calls back so you can ask questions. And I had a question about the lights because this guy was talking about the lights. We have nightlight ordinance. But what about the federal and stuff like that, the lights that have to be on it? Is it going to be going into the people's buildings or anything? It has to have shields that go completely down. I'm concerned about the lights. Thanks. Anyone else in the room wishing to speak?
4:04:27 Seeing none, we will go to the online hands, please, Jamie. Emily, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hi, can you hear me? Yes. Yes. Okay. Hi, my name is Emily Schoen. Thank you for allowing me to voice my concerns. I'm speaking for myself and my son and Gary Morgan, who's co-owner of our property at Creek House. I'm the mother of a young son and I've been a full-time resident of Mammoth for 10 years. The Town Planning Commission based their decision to approve the tower.
4:05:02 On the testimony by the fire chief regarding public safety. But what about the public safety and health of all the people that live around this location, as well as the fire chief's own employees who work at the station? In LA County, at fire stations with towers, many firefighters were getting sick. They fought with their union and won. Now there are no cell towers allowed at fire stations in LA County.
4:05:27 Human exposure guidelines for RF radiation used by the FCC are more than 25 years old and only address the thermal effects, which is the heating of tissues, not other biological effects at non-thermal levels, which have now been firmly established. Over the last 20 years, a robust body of independent science has emerged, showing significant biological impacts, including cancer, neurological and cognitive harm, heart abnormalities.
4:05:55 Negative reproductive effects and microwave sickness, among other serious health problems. Freedom of choice is a fundamental American value. The FCC and the telecom industry and the town of Mammoth Lakes should not force citizens to endure involuntary exposure to powerful RF radiation 24-7 in their own homes. Even major insurance companies have refused to insure telecoms against losses from personal liability claims.
4:06:24 Related to exposure to RF radiation. Swiss Re, the second largest reinsurance company in the world, has classified 5G as a high impact liability risk due to potential adverse health impacts. The notion that exposure to radio frequency radiation is not harmful to humans has now been proven false. There are more than a thousand scientific studies conducted by independent researchers from around the world concerning the biological effects of RF radiation.
4:06:53 The FCC has not conducted any long-term testing of new 5G wireless technologies and has failed to update its human RF microwave radiation exposure guidelines since 1996, despite being advised to do so by the U.S. General Accounting Office, the American Academy of Pediatrics, and hundreds of medical and scientific experts from around the world. Thank you for listening. Sonia, please unmute yourself and give your comments.
4:07:32 Hi, thank you. Can you hear me? Yes. This is Sonia Bush, and thank you for hearing what I have to say, Mayor and Town Council and staff. Most of you know me, but as a means of introduction because it will give some context to my questions. I am a full-time local and a full-time residence in Snow Creek 7. I am also the owner of Destination Real Estate, and I also spent 28 years before moving to Mammoth Lakes in the cellular industry.
4:08:01 My first question is directed towards Ms. Thacker, I think I'm pronouncing it right, and Mr. Huffington. I want to know if they have actually stood in the place where this tower is located. Are they available to answer that question, or should that be tabled? Questions will be answered at the end of the public comment period by town staff. Thank you. I would like to know the answer to that question. I also encourage...
4:08:24 All the members of town staff and the council actually stand in that location instead of just reviewing the hypotheses and the photos of a fire ladder, which in no way replicates what the site will look like. My second comment or question is as a realtor. So as a realtor, these properties were flying off the shelf. I couldn't sell them fast enough. People wanted to see them. Now, just to confirm what others have said, I can't even get people to look at them.
4:08:52 As it relates to my experience in the telecom industry for 28 years, I have been to dozens of these hearings. And I have found most often the carrier is not willing to change directions, even when there is a viable alternative, because they don't want to take the time or admit there could be an option. I really seriously doubt Mr. Heffenden's maps would move at all the cellular footprint or coverage if it was moved to the athletic club.
4:09:21 I also respect both chiefs that spoke this evening, but I also think that if this tower was moved to the athletic club, it would not impact FirstNet or I think he called it IPAWS. Thank you. Oh, one last thing. When Betsy spoke, I have great respect for Betsy on the fireboard, but I think they're getting $4,000 a month for this tower. So I don't know what else they're getting.
4:09:48 But there is money involved, and that should also always follow the money, right? Thank you. Sabing Lee, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hi, everybody. I'm a homeowner, and I live at 1380 Timber Creek. I am in the second home over from the fire station. And so when I bought my home, one of the main attractions was the views, without question. And the view from my bedroom window looks directly over to Mammoth Mountain.
4:10:26 If this 80-foot tower goes up, then that is going to be directly obstructing my view without any sort of camouflage. And one thing I wanted to point out is when you look at the town code and you look at site selection, it talks about the site selection has to be based on where existing topography provides the greatest amount of screening when you're comparing this site to another site.
4:10:50 Camouflage, the fake leaves and all of the fake branches on the monopole do not count as existing structure. And so we've seen, Sonal went very quickly through some of the photos, but when you look closely at the photos, and even from the public right-of-way, if we say Old Mammoth Road as the public right-of-way, it is not screened. This thing stands by itself, and you've heard many, many times, it's ugly. And so, to me, the aesthetic concerns...
4:11:17 I don't want you to believe that you cannot deny AT&T's application. My understanding is that if there's substantial evidence in the record, and there's tons of evidence already established in the written record that's been presented to the town council, there is enough here for you to deny the application. So please do not feel like you have no choice but to approve their application.
4:11:47 You can deny this. Thank you. Paula, please unmute yourself and give your comments. This is Paula in Brooks from 1451 Boulder Creek. We bought our unit in October of 2022. If we had known that this 80-foot cell tower would be built across the street from our front yard, we would not have bought it. We could not sell it today for what we paid for it. All of the
4:12:31 The homes in Snow Creek 7 are two stories high. This monopine will be eight stories high, and without approval, it can be extended to 100 feet or 10 stories high. As others have pointed out, there is no screening whatsoever. This will devastate the aesthetics of our neighborhood.
4:13:01 Our property values are already suffering. When AT&T says that this is the optimal site, what they mean is they can construct their cell tower here at the lowest cost to them. It is not the only site that will work. We are not opposed to the construction of a cell tower, but we are adamantly opposed to constructing it at fire station two.
4:13:29 Snow Creek Athletic Club is a viable alternative that will have much less impact on the neighborhood and it will be screened by existing trees. And as Sabine said, the town council can deny this application. Don't be misled. Thank you. Also, I'm a photographer.
4:13:56 We have a nine-year-old.
4:14:25 We bought up there because we also wanted to show him what it was like to be away from the city, away from the hubbub. We look out our window and we will see this monstrosity. It is going to be ugly. I see them going down the 405 freeway in Los Angeles. And there is no way to camouflage this thing. There's what? Three pine trees right there.
4:14:55 It's not in our backyard. It's right in front of us. We're going to drive down Boulder Creek. We're going to drive up Timber Creek. And it's right there. I ask, would any of you guys want to see this when you're driving to your home or walk a couple feet and it's right there? Please, please reconsider. There are definitely other viable options, including Snow Creek Athletic Club. So please keep this in mind when you're making your decision. Thank you.
4:15:27 Jennifer, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hi, I'm Jennifer Bradbury. I'm a homeowner at 1325 Timber Creek. Ladies and gentlemen, esteemed mayor and council members and staff, I speak before you today with a fervent plea, a plea born out of concern, out of care, out of deep-rooted love for our community of Mammoth Lakes.
4:15:53 We find ourselves at a crossroads faced with a decision that will decide the fabric of our neighborhood. You know this beautiful picture so well. A serene, picturesque community where children play freely in the streets, where families gather in our communal green space and where the tranquility of nature intertwines seamlessly with the warmth of human connection. Now imagine this idyllic scene overshadowed by the looming presence of an ugly,
4:16:22 Man-made 80-foot cell phone tower thrust upon us without regard for our well-being. I am fully supportive of adding a nearby cell phone tower, but stand firmly against the construction of this tower in our neighborhood. It's not merely about aesthetics or property values, though those are very valid concerns. It's about safeguarding our health, our safety, and our way of life.
4:16:49 Our small community deserves better than to serve as an unwitting experiment in the name of technological progress. Placing a cell phone tower among our homes will disrupt the peaceful sanctity we've all cultivated and we seek to preserve. The incessant hum of machinery, the unsightly structure marring our skyline, these are intrusions we should not have to endure. Is this truly the legacy we wish to leave for future generations?
4:17:19 I was struck by Sonia Leclerc's earlier comments, and it appears she's a fellow UC Irvine anteater. We both received our master's degrees there. She is, according to her public LinkedIn profile, a resident of Irvine, California, meaning she has the luxury of living in a meticulously laid out master plan community.
4:17:43 As a longtime former resident of Irvine, I know it is a community that would never even consider putting an 80-foot piece of electrical telecommunications equipment in her front yard. She is doing her corporate job and such has no personal recourse in the decision that will be made here. Why does she have the authority to influence such a monumental decision in our community? We must not allow short-term gains to blind us from the long-term consequences.
4:18:11 Let us not sacrifice our well-being, our harmony, our very essence on the altar of progress. Together, Creek House community members are raising our voices in unity, in defiance and in defense of what matters most, our community, our home. I urge each and every one of you to join me in staunch opposition to the construction of this cell phone tower in our beloved Creek House neighborhood. Let our voices be heard loud and clear.
4:18:40 Let our passion fuel our resolve and let us stand firm in our commitment to preserve the sanctity of Mammoth Lakes. The time is back now and our future depends on it. Thank you. Josh, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Yes. Can you hear me okay? Yes. Okay, great. Josh Bravery, homeowner, 1325 Timber Creek. I'm also a board member of the Creek House community.
4:19:10 I speak today as a homeowner and as a board member who has the best interest of our community in mind. As a homeowner, my view will now directly be threatened by a hideous cell phone tower rising 80 feet above our community. My view was the primary reason why I bought this home with my wife and two small children almost four years ago.
4:19:34 As a board member, I'm greatly concerned about the values of our entire community. You've heard reference to this from Sonia, who's directly in the real estate business earlier. This is simple as far as I'm concerned. Even though the science has not proven the health impacts from cell phone towers, I'll tell you right now that any buyer with children will avoid buying in our community because of the perception of that fear. That is a fact and it will severely impact.
4:20:03 Our housing values. Lastly, I do want to acknowledge that every owner in our community recognizes the problem of providing reliable communication for fire, police, and any and all first responders who we graciously appreciate that help ensure the health and safety of everyone in our community. No one is going to deny that requirement and we all support it, but for God's sake, don't put an 80-foot tower right in the middle of a 100-home community.
4:20:30 When you have an option that's 200 yards away, you know, I heard earlier today that there was proaction to reach out to the landlord of the athletic center, but apparently that was not the case, and you heard directly from the horse's mouth tonight that there's strong interest there. So the last comment I'll make is that it's important to note that if our appeal today is not successful,
4:20:58 Then our board is committed to fighting this issue to the full legal extent, which unfortunately is going to cost the homeowners, the city, and AT&T significantly more time and money. And as a result, I certainly hope it doesn't come down to that scenario because the only one that wins in that scenario are the lawyers. Thank you. Jeff, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Jeff? Sorry about that. My name is Jeff Rossino. I live at 1455 Boulder Creek.
4:21:39 This is also my front door. Literally, I just finally started getting used to the existing structure that's, I guess, as soon as we use it as drying their hoses. And I also echo a lot of the comments from the other residents that we bought this area here such as gorgeous views and been up here in Mammoth for, you know, 50 years. Not that I'm saying what my age is.
4:22:07 I said there's other locations that would be suiting better for this. And I don't know if you, I'm sure you guys have been out the site. That's the only structure that's going to be really prevalent. Like if we wanted a monument, this will be it and we'll be staring at a cell site. Also, they're talking about doubling up on the, or they call it co-locate, you know, to
4:22:35 The number with the 408 area code, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hi. Hi, this is Helen. Can you hear me okay? Yes.
4:23:14 Great. Thank you. Thank you, Town Council, for providing an opportunity to talk today. My husband and I bought our place in 2020 in Creek House and fell absolutely hopelessly in love with our beautiful community. We, like all the others here today, want to keep our community safe and understand there may be a need for a tower to help in emergencies. But I have to say I'm completely baffled by the decision to locate the tower in its present location.
4:23:41 If I heard correctly earlier today, AT&T has been looking for a site for at least five years, yet we just learned about the tower. The lease was signed before any of us knew about this. There's been no effort by AT&T to work with the community. Unbelievable. This is not a case of nimbyism. This is a case of concerned citizens worried about how the tower will impact our entire community, not just our neighborhood.
4:24:10 I frankly find the presentations, the photos, and the discussions from the experts speaking today and at the planning commission about the impact completely disingenuous. We keep hearing about how the tower is going to be located in the back of the fire station, implying it will be hidden from view. The back of the fire station is the front yard of many of our homes. Even the photos Sonal flashed up ever so quickly, more quickly than you could actually see.
4:24:39 Showed how conspicuous the tower will be. And as much as they want to pretend that the tower would be dressed up to look like a pine tree, let's not kid ourselves. This is an eight-story man-made monstrosity in an area with no vegetation or camouflage. It's completely unacceptable to locate the tower just steps away from somebody's front yard. I'm heartbroken. To date,
4:25:05 Our concerned citizens have no voice in a significant decision that will forever impact the place we love. I expect more from our planning commission. I find what is happening shameful, and I hope you all do too. Thank you for your consideration. Todd, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Can you hear me? Yes. Okay, thank you, Mayor and Town Council, and I also appreciate everyone who has spoken here. I know it's getting late.
4:25:39 And I think the first thing, I went to 1394 Timber Creek, which has probably the exciting award of being literally the closest location to where this tower would go up. You will be able to see this from every single window in our house.
4:26:04 We were just up there last weekend. My seven-year-old daughter was sledding with some of her friends on the hill right by where the tower will be. We bought this place and we received
4:26:30 We heard from one of our neighbors that there was a meeting three days after we had closed. I just want that to sink in because I know someone who works for the town had mentioned earlier, oh, oops, we sent out some notices, but I guess not everyone got them. We literally closed and you guys had a meeting, not you guys, but I guess the Planning Commission had a meeting planned three days after we closed. So I think we've heard a lot of great, you know, themes tonight.
4:27:02 Which I support all of them. But I think one of the things that jumps out the most for me is the lack of due process, which I think just put your mammoth hat aside, put your California hat aside, maybe put your American hat aside. And one of the core principles of living in the United States is about giving decent respect to your fellow citizens, allowing people to voice their opinions. And wouldn't you want to have the best
4:27:31 Ideas out there. Everything that I've heard tonight would have been great for, I think, the town council to hear before someone signed the deal that is now going to be, let's be honest, difficult to get out of without litigation. And no one wants that. I think the frustration and the disappointment.
4:27:55 And the anger that you've heard from so many of your fellow Mammoth Lake citizens and neighbors tonight is about the lack of process. It's not about whether we need a cell towel. I think 99 or 100% of the people who have spoken tonight, that's the fire chief and the police chief and the fire district and many other people. That's unequivocable. But why wouldn't we have, why wouldn't you, not the vendor, not ATG,
4:28:23 Why wouldn't the town do its diligence and look at what can form the code? What would be the best for home values? There's always going to be people who are going to be disappointed, but what would be the least disappointed? So I think, I don't think, I think, you know, I'm very unconvinced that this is going to avoid a CEQA lawsuit. I definitely think it's going to result in... Okay, I need you to wrap this up, please. Your time is up.
4:28:53 Okay, I would just encourage the town council to go back and please give the Snow Creek Athletic Club a shot and don't let AT&T push you guys around. Would the person with the 805 area code please unmute yourself and give your comments? Can you hear me? Yes. Hi, my name is John Eidelman, 1585 Clear Creek Road. At the Planning Commission meeting,
4:29:31 I tried to make a number of proactive observations about the planning division's conditions that are part of the agreement with AT&T and all the deficiencies in that. And it just reflected in itself and really the staff did the best they could, but really they didn't know what they were dealing with here. And I made a number of suggestions and it's just appalling to me that the lack of penalties for AT&T for all these items that they're required to do that they may or may not do.
4:29:59 There really is no incentive for them to behave. So I work with big vendors in the world in global business, and this is just an amazing statement of work. The rest of what I'd like to say is some inconsistencies about what AT&T has said tonight. First of all, yeah, 10 years ago, and there was an article that you can look up in the sheet dated August 13, 2013. It talks about the then AT&T application at the same site for a...
4:30:27 I want you to think about this number, 40 foot, 45 foot tall in September, 45 foot tall on the other side of the building, right at station number two. So at that point, the requirement to improve service was 45 feet tall. Now we have 80 feet. Think about that. The other inconsistency, and I know the time is short here, so I'll be quick. The Yukon group,
4:30:54 That spoke tonight in their drawing A5 shows that the 80-foot tall pine and how it's going to be allocated. The upper 31 feet of that up to 74 feet is reserved for AT&T hardware. Below that, at between 43 feet and 35 feet, they've allocated 8 feet for a future event.
4:31:23 So, you know, I pointed out to them at that meeting, this is, would AT&T want to trade places with Verizon and get 85 feet instead of the 31 feet that they've allocated for themselves? So thinking that this thing is going to in any way, shape, or form affect anything good for Verizon at the levels from 43 feet to 35 feet, the 8 feet are being allocated, doesn't really make any sense.
4:31:51 It's just another inconsistency and unexplained. Just exactly like they're saying, say, 10 years ago, they would be happy with 45 feet, and today, magically, they need 80 feet or 75 feet of the antenna with all that extra hardware hanging on it. The other thing that kind of struck me is that the fire board had no public hearings.
4:32:18 Was talking to the AT&T and negotiating with them. And six months before their hearing, I know it was a public hearing like this one, they actually hired AT&T to write the statement of work and to write the permits for the town, for the construction that's going to go on. Sir, sir, your time's up. Thank you. Would the person with the 310 area code please unmute yourself and give your comments?
4:33:04 Don, would you please unmute yourself and give your comments? Hi, my name is Don Herman. I live at 1450 Boulder Creek Road. I've been coming to Mammoth since 1963. We've owned four properties in the town since 1969. We've seen lots of changes in Mammoth, a lot of good changes. And we're just shocked to find that this tower would be located some 10 to 15 steps from one of Snow Creek's front doors. Not to mention the hideous impact on the environment.
4:33:35 We attended the Planning Commission meeting on February 14th, and the town staff actually pointed out with maps and the photo sims how this project does not meet code. Code state site selection is to be based on three locations where existing topography, vegetation, other structures provided screening, and four parcels that will not require significant visual mitigations. The location must be in the rear of the property, not visible from public rights of way.
4:34:02 Well, the presentations with the photo sims by the staff and AT&T contractors both showed that there was no existing screening and no screening of the tower from the public right-of-way of Old Mammoth Road and the bike path. So there's absolutely nothing screening around this area and nothing, even half as tall as the tower. There's nothing for it to blend into. The commission said that the public safety trumps aesthetics.
4:34:27 Refusing to consider aesthetics in the cell tower location sets a very bad precedent for this town. Yes, public safety can trump aesthetics, but you can do both. These objectives are not mutually exclusive. Four commissioners went on to say that the tower is hideous and they would not want it near their homes, as you heard before. It's been said that the tower is critical for public safety and IPOS. There are many ways to get emergency messages other than an AT&T account.
4:34:55 We doubt that there's been any increased damage or increased loss of life in Mammoth due to a non-existent AT&T wireless signal or tower. Past incidents have always been managed excellence in this town. Everybody always seems to get the message being such a small town. I was on chair three and found out 10 minutes after the condo's propane tank exploded last year. It was 10 minutes and I already knew about it.
4:35:19 Emergency responders have plenty of existing communication equipment through their incident command systems and mutual aid. Sonal didn't show you tonight, but the planning commission, she presented AT&T's two top goals. Number one, improved AT&T commercial coverage, and two, additional cellular capacity. That was the top of her list. That doesn't sound like public safety to me. What is AT&T's contribution to our community anyways, other than this commercial profit?
4:35:49 They stated that they have installed these towers in Irvine, we heard that she's from Irvine, and they have no complaints in Irvine. Really? Mammoth is the same as Irvine? Many of us come to Mammoth to enjoy the small town and the Eastern Sierra environment. Our top priority is not always the wireless signal. This tower at the proposed location does not fit or meet the town of Mammoth code. We ask you to deny this permit as it's currently planned. Thank you. Darren, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Darren Murray?
4:36:29 Hi, yeah, thank you. This is Darren Murray. I recently purchased 1571 Clear Creek. We closed last summer. And then recently, after that, found out that there was a cell tower going to be built about 100 feet from our driveway. We sold a home that was a lifelong investment for us to make an investment for us and our kids and would never have made that decision to sell our home.
4:36:58 I do have some experience in building cell towers, and I think everyone that has mentioned the health ramifications, whether they are proven or not, and whether we're supposed to talk to that or not, but all of my employees that have to build or work in an active environment.
4:37:24 Have to take special training to make sure they're not standing in front of any of the dishes or the equipment to have the added RF exposures from that equipment. So it's hard for me to say that I'm willing and accepting the fact of having my children in that neighborhood with a cell tower built so close when I have to keep my employees safe of the equipment that they're working around. It is a tough part in dealing with the loss of revenue.
4:37:55 Jeffrey, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hello.
4:38:26 I'm not going to make the mayor very happy. I'm just going to say that people have been much more eloquent than I could be. I agree with everybody. I've been a homeowner. I live at 1425 Balder Creek. I've owned a property there for 25 years. I think Sonia's point is have these people from AT&T seen this? And I find their presentation very cynical.
4:38:55 To call it a monopine, I think is very cynical. I wake up and I look at Mammoth Rock and I look at the few pine trees that are protruding and I think it is for the city council to look at the community and look at the history of it and hopefully that we're not going to let, if there is an alternative place, if there is
4:39:24 A lack of process just to take the time to make the right decision and hopefully not let a big place. I mean, yes, the town has grown so fast and I understand that sometimes you don't get cell phone service and sometimes I pride myself of being a resident of Mammoth when people cannot reach me, when I can make a phone call. I know that's not a good...
4:39:51 Selling point. But I just hope that we don't let this big corporation and this lack of process affect us and that we just, if we have an alternative place, let's just look at it and take the time and do the proper due process. Thank you. Barbara, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hi, I'm Barbara Taylor. I'm a realtor with the Snow Creek Property Company and my heart is really breaking for
4:40:29 All of my clients and everyone in Creek House that is going through this. I mean, I know we needed more cell, another cell tower, but please, this is really the worst possible place to put it. My heart's breaking for these families, so please put this tower someplace else. Thank you. Claire, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hi, my name is Claire Martin.
4:40:59 I am an owner at 1394 Timber Creek and my husband spoke earlier. We are literally feet away from the proposed site and we closed on our condo three days before finding out this was all happening and absolutely would not have bought this condo knowing all this or completely flabbergasted that there was no
4:41:27 Communication and the lack of due process in all of this and frankly might try to sell it if we possibly could without losing too much money. It was our dream. It's been our dream for 20 years that we've been coming to Mammoth to be able to have a place there with our family and we're just devastated.
4:41:57 Really implore the Council to look at other options, including the Snow Creek Athletic Club. Thank you. Kevin, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Good afternoon, or good evening. My name is Kevin Neida. I'm a Senior Public Safety Advisor with the U.S. Department of Commerce. First on authority. And I'm here to speak on behalf, in support of coverage in the vicinity that's been outlined tonight.
4:42:36 In 2012, Congress established the First Responder Network Authority, also known as FirstNet Authority, and directed it to ensure the building deployment and ongoing operation on the nationwide public safety broadband network, the first nationwide high-speed broadband network dedicated for public safety. The FirstNet Authority's mission is to provide and maintain a single interoperable platform that consistently satisfies the demanding communication needs for the public safety community in California and across the country.
4:43:04 New sites are needed and are essential to the success of the program in delivering the mission, critical coverage, public safety needs to communicate and save lives. The network has been on top priority for first responders and public safety agencies in California throughout the country and has been designed based on their specific express needs with coverage and capacity being paramount. Simply put, coverage enables the first responder to send and receive data.
4:43:31 And capacity ensures speed and quality of those communications. The new sites and infrastructure connected to FirstNet will improve communications for first responders where that infrastructure has been currently lacking. The FirstNet Authority and our private sector partner, AT&T, have worked with California Public Safety Community to identify coverage needs throughout the state to improve emergency communications and everyday use, as well as for large-scale emergencies.
4:44:00 In December 2017, the Governor signed the FirstNet Authority Plan for Radio Access Network Deployment in California and thus authorizing construction of the FirstNet Network in areas of the state where public safety needs coverage and capacity. By opting in, the Governor enabled public safety to rapidly access broadband services in California while also allowing the prompt build-out of the deployment of the network, which began in March of 2018. His decision also directed FirstNet Authority
4:44:28 to take all the risk, costs, and responsibilities associated with deploying the network for the next 25 years. Thank you. Good evening. That's it. Okay, that ends the public comment portion of the hearing. Now I suppose we need to go back to rebuttal to comments if staff or questions. We can provide brief response to some of the public comments.
4:45:12 And then on some of them, I will defer to Andy to weigh in as well. On the notes, regarding the view simulations, photo simulations are accepted form to depict the visualizations for projects. Also, again, these photo sims were, the requirements for the photo sims to be from the public vantage point, public right-of-ways, and so that's the primary photos from Old Mammoth Road looking at the site.
4:45:42 As well as a third-party vendor who certified the accuracy of those photosims as far as the height and the scale and the size of the structure. Regarding lights on the tower, there are no lights required for the tower as it is only 80 feet. There was a Planning Commission approval required that if there were lighting, they would have to only lighting that's required by federal or state requirements. However, again, there's no lighting proposed for the tower.
4:46:10 Then regarding the timeline and noticing, an initial application was submitted in April of 2022. That application was incomplete, primarily as proposed for the front of the fire station. A completeness letter was provided to the applicant at that time, which then paused the shot clock. No further updates from the applicant were received until June of 2023, when the fire district indicated they were...
4:46:39 Going to be hosting a public meeting to discuss the tower. Our encouragement to them was to send out public notices for that meeting, although noticing is not required. They did notice it to those within 300 feet around that site. Then a new submittal was submitted to the town in July of 2023 with the location
4:47:04 In response to the April 2022 application moving to the rear of the site as required by our code that did start up a new shot clock as the 150-day shot clock discussed earlier. Noticing was provided for the November 2023 planning economic development commission meeting ever due to an error and noticing where not all neighbors were notified. That meeting was continued to a future date because we wanted to ensure that all neighbors were notified.
4:47:33 After that meeting, AT&T did agree to toll the shot clock for a period until April 19th was the deadline they extended it out to to allow time to discuss other alternatives with the HOA group. And then the meeting, the February 2024 meeting was the next notice that went out to the public. Notices were also placed in the newspaper for
4:47:58 The Town Planning Commission meetings and then the Fire District also talked about the tower at a June Town Council meeting. Chair Greg Musil, Nolan, can I ask you a question? Was the notice for the original November where we did not notify all the homeowners directly put in the newspaper? Mr. Yes. Chair Greg Musil, Thank you. Chair Greg Musil, And then I will ask Andy to address the legal authority on alternative site selection. Mr. Well, sure.
4:48:24 A couple commenters asked if the Council, you know, couldn't you just do this? And other people said, you absolutely must do this. And the thing that they're asking about and saying you can do is to say no to this application because there's another possible site. And I can tell you that is not within the Council's purview tonight. The Council has to evaluate this decision, or sorry, this application on its own merits. You can grant the appeal, you can deny the appeal, but...
4:48:51 Thank you. That being said, I believe
4:49:21 Unless you tell me I'm wrong, Andy, it's getting late, that this concludes the public hearing and I will close it. You're correct. We will now close the public hearing and bring it back for deliberation, debate, and or motion here at council. Can we ask questions? You can ask questions. You can make comments. The floor is now yours. Okay. I have a quick question. Nolan, when was the neighborhood?
4:49:48 Constructed? Like, do you know when the first house was built and sold there? The first permit, I believe, was around 2008, North Creek 7, and so it's been in development since then. There was a pretty lengthy pause from about 2010 to 2015 where no new homes were built, and then they really started up again in 2015. Okay, thank you. Other questions? A couple questions. So,
4:50:17 Andy, thanks for the clarification and thanks to two attorneys here because it's been my understanding that we have a very narrow lane in which we can make a decision. I think that the council is more constrained by the law than you usually are in making decisions. Yes, that's my understanding. So the AT&T site selection process, we have no authority or purview over that, correct?
4:50:49 Our wireless siting ordinance expresses a series of preferences, not requirements, but preferences for site selection. But beyond that, no, we cannot tell AT and beyond that and the zoning, I should say, we cannot tell AT&T where to look or not to look. So this is not like a secret, if we're looking at a secret decision where there are alternatives, we're not, we cannot weigh in on an alternative at this point. You have to make a decision on this application. And if you're going, if you are inclined to
4:51:19 Grant the appeal and deny the application. That decision has to be supported by substantial evidence. That's a specific term of art that the project doesn't meet the requirements of our code or doesn't meet the requirements of federal or state law. Okay. So we're not serving here in a fact-finding capacity. Well, you're serving in a...
4:51:41 It's kind of an adjudicatory capacity. You're applying the standards of the law and of our code to a specific set of facts, to this application. So you are making findings of fact in that way, but you're not selecting among various alternatives, really. Okay. And issues around process and noticing and all that kind of stuff, we're not serving in a fact-finding.
4:52:07 Well, I would suggest that a question that is relevant might be, was the notice inadequate in some way? Did the notice meet the town's standards? Did the notice meet any standards that are in the law, of which I'm not sure there are any? That, I think, is the question. Was the notice legally inadequate, rather than is there a feeling that more notice could have been provided? Can you, is it appropriate to ask you and ask Nolan, was the noticing
4:52:34 Process that accompanied this whole effort. Was it consistent with town regulation and the law? Yeah, so public noticing for public hearings requires that all property owners within 300 feet of the subject site receive a mailed notice and additionally that a notice is placed in the newspaper for 10 days prior to the hearing. So we placed in the newspaper for the prior two weeks to a hearing prior to the November 2023 public hearing.
4:53:03 Notices were mailed out. We actually extended the radius to 400 feet to capture more owners within the radius to be notified and placed the ad in the newspaper. As we noted prior to the meeting, it was discovered that not all of the properties within the Snow Creek development received a notice due to an addressing error within the APN data at the county level. The addresses are provided and based on the county tax rules. The most recent county tax rule is what addresses are used for the mailing list.
4:53:33 Because of that era, the meeting was then continued to a future date, not a date certain because it was not yet determined when it would be coming back to the Planning Commission. So then prior to the February 2024 meeting, the meeting was re-noticed, again, to all property owners within 400 feet. And so that includes if it touches a common area of a condo, it does then notice all property owners within that condo complex. Since they're all owners, the ad was also placed in the newspaper.
4:54:02 Yes, it was done to the legal requirements of the code. Excuse me, sir. Sorry. I'm not the fire. They already signed the contract. So the shot clock started. The law starts. What does it matter? The town did not sign a contract with anyone. Sorry, Mr. Mayor. Could you speak? There's a question about the CEQA analysis about the volume of the structure. Could you speak to that question?
4:54:29 I will refer to Shauna, who can speak to the volume one as far as how that relates to the CEQA exemption. Okay. Sure. Under the class three categorical exemption, if the floor area square feet is less than 2,500, then it fits within the structure, will fit within the four corners of the class three categorical exemption.
4:54:58 And my understanding is that this structure is, I think it's 640 or 680 square feet in floor area. And just to add to what Sean is saying, at least one member of the public said, well, it should be floor area ratio, which is a volumetric measure. It takes into account how tall something is as well as its footprint.
4:55:20 Class III categorical exemption doesn't work that way. It's not floor area ratio as in our development code. It really is floor area. And there is a case in 2018 from San Diego that upheld the use of this categorical exemption for a cell tower based on having a very small footprint. The height was irrelevant, essentially. And I should also point out one other thing. A question that I have heard previously, I think at the PEDC meeting, there have been
4:55:47 Some people saying, well, if the town's standards allow this, then the town has bad standards and the town should change them. And can't you just change the standards and then use the change standards as a way to evaluate the project? And you can't for a couple of reasons. Once an application of any kind comes in, the town is required to evaluate it based on the rules that are in effect at the time we receive the application. You can't change the rules midstream. Even if you could, you'd run into a shot clock problem because rewriting the town's wireless ordinance would take a while.
4:56:15 And that might be a good exercise to do. It's something that we've talked about. But getting it through the PEDC and then getting it back before council is going to take time that the 150-day shot clock simply doesn't give you, even if you could change the rules midstream, which you can't. So one last question. It seems like a lot of the property owners had bought some of these properties relatively recently. And it sounds like an application had been submitted. And I'm just wondering if this is sort of a...
4:56:43 anecdotal type of a question, but what obligation does a realtor have to advise potent people buying properties that, oh, by the way, an application has been submitted to put a cell tower in your neighborhood? I am not familiar enough with the obligations of realtors to even weigh in on that. Okay. All right. Thank you. Go ahead, Chris. Go. My question is, like, going to be the last question because it's simple. Okay. Super simple.
4:57:13 Andy, are we allowed to weigh in on aesthetic impacts at all? Yes. We are. So having it blended in or camouflaged or, you know, being a just standing by itself or can you clarify, please? I will defer to Nolan on what our ordinance says about aesthetics. Okay. So our ordinance encourages telecommunication facilities shall have a non-reflective finish and shall be painted and treated to blend with the primary background and minimize visual impacts.
4:58:00 It also again encourages it to be in the rear of the property and then the visual mitigations provided or screening in this case the visual mitigations proposed is for the monopine structure to blend in as a tree. Okay, thank you. And it says encourages it to be at the back of the property or do we require it to be at the back of the property? The rear of the property is a requirement. Okay, thanks. I'm not going to say a whole lot here because we've been here too long.
4:58:36 But John made a great point. The people who have bought in the last 6, 8, 10, 12 months should have known that this was going in. The realtors should have told them. The homeowners association certainly should have known. I can read lips too. Thank you. And I'm more than happy to have this conversation with anybody outside of this. You should have been notified by someone and been able to call me and talk to me about this or talk to others and somehow that hasn't done.
4:59:04 Legal notifications were made. Due diligence was put out and even exceeded because we found that some homeowners, not all, didn't receive the notifications. And what we can do is fairly limited. If we stop the process now and AT&T agrees to move it, are you going to accept it back at your lot when we get the same group of people here from Snow Creek 4 or Aspen Village saying they don't want it in their backyard?
4:59:33 This is problematic for me. I'm not taking questions. Thank you. Chris. Okay. So my question is maybe for Gail, maybe for Andy. You know, in our staff report, it said that if a local government fails to act within the time required, the applicant may pursue a deemed appropriate, or excuse me, deemed approval. I'm sorry. I'm so tired.
5:00:05 of its application by providing notice to the local government, et cetera. So that's one thing is that we're sort of compelled to act on this. And then the second thing says this remedy is not available to applications for wireless telecommunication facility where the project is proposed for placement of fire department facilities. Let me try to answer that one and then Gail can augment what I'm saying.
5:00:34 So that deemed approved remedy is something that the legislature gave to wireless facility projects in lots of places but not fire stations. But what that means is it just doesn't mean that it's automatically deemed approved. It doesn't change the criteria that have to be used in evaluating the application. It doesn't change the timing. It doesn't change the need for substantial evidence to say no. It doesn't change federal law. It doesn't change state law.
5:01:00 All it means is that rather than an applicant whose application takes too long to process, being able to say, ha ha, you took too long, you lose, I'm just going to go build this thing. Instead, they have to go to court to sue and get a writ or a court order saying, we failed to process this. So you have to process it. And if you say no, you have to follow all the same standards. That's the only thing. So the absence of a deemed approved remedy doesn't change any of the underlying standards or requirements. But Gail, do you have anything to add to that?
5:01:29 No, that's exactly right. That's exactly right. It's an additional remedy that is available for the applicant, just not available on fire station properties, but it doesn't change anything else. It just means that you would have to go to court. And sorry, I was in that paragraph, but my real question is what
5:02:05 What recourse does the applicant, not the appellant, have if we don't go forward? I mean, effectively, I don't want to even put the words out there, but tell me what would be likely to happen. I will defer to Gail on that one because she's seen this play out.
5:02:29 Just a point of clarification, are you asking if you don't take any action or if you were to deny the application? Well, I guess really we have to take some action, we have to vote, so I guess it's if we were to deny the application. Okay, so if you were to deny the application, then typically what happens if an applicant believes that you...
5:02:59 If you wrongly applied your code, but didn't comply with the law, either your local law or also federal law, then they would file an action. They have 30 days of an expedited period to file an action. Typically, they would file an action in federal court.
5:03:24 And they would lay out their claims for why they think that your denial was unlawful. So the typical claims would be that the denial was not based on substantial evidence. And that would be they would be looking at the court would be looking at whether there is evidence in your code to support evidence in the public in the record to support a denial under your local law. They wouldn't be considering
5:03:53 They would have the burden to prove that
5:04:22 That your denial is effectively prohibiting them from providing personal wireless services. Now there are standards in case law that have developed to interpret like what does that federal law mean and there are actually two competing standards or two possible standards that that
5:04:49 That issue might be reviewed on. I don't know if you want to go into that. No, no. I just want to understand, like, would they take us to court? And my real question is, would they take us to court? Because we don't have substantial... We don't know whether they would take us to court. That would be, I think, the most likely remedy. But whether they would actually exercise it, who can say? Right. But that's the concern. And we don't have...
5:05:19 Based on our own code, I don't see any evidence of what's the term of art, the legal term, substantial? Substantive. Yes, in order to grant the appeal and deny the application, you need to come up with substantial evidence based on our own code that the application is not consistent with our code. So my last question for you, Andy, do you see any substantial evidence?
5:05:43 That this application is not based on our vote. I'm certainly not telling the council how to vote or what to think, but I can tell you that as I sit here, I am not seeing it. I have not heard anything from any member of the public tonight, impassioned and genuine though their comments are, I've not heard anything that to me sounds like substantial evidence. If Gail or Shauna have heard anything that sounds like substantial evidence, they can certainly chime in, but I have not heard it. Thank you.
5:06:13 So, Mr. Mayor? Yes, sir. I am prepared to make a motion, and I would just offer a little bit of context. We are a community that lives on the front lines of climate change. We had a particularly aggressive winter last year in which fire department communications was a key part of emergency response. We're dealing with something called the Mammoth Donut Project. We're trying to mitigate...
5:06:42 Potential effects of a catastrophic wildfire. The neighborhood in Old Mammoth has, you know, egregious egress issues over there. It's an unfortunate context, but that's where we are. So, and I think, Chris, thanks for your questioning. That was very helpful, I think, for all of us. I would move that the Town Council deny the appeal of the Planning and Economic Development Commission decision and affirm the approval of use permit application 23-002. I have a motion. I'll second.
5:07:16 I have a motion and a second. Any further deliberation? Jamie. Councilmember Rae. Yes. Councilmember Rice. Yes. Councilmember Wentworth. Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Bubzer. Yes. Mayor Souser. Yes. The denial is 5-0. Thank you all. We will take a three-minute quick break. Are they below the table? You are hiding it. So we are now...
5:17:46 That reports from commissions and our departments as needed. 8.1, did you know short-term rental moratorium is just a written piece unless you have questions? No questions. 8.2, April 2024, Engineering CIP, you've got to write up unless you have any questions? No questions. 2024, Office of Outdoor Recreation update, I wrote ditto. So that means unless you have questions, we're just moving on.
5:18:18 Now I want to know if there is any commission and or department who feels it necessary to give us a report. That's a good one. Thank you, Mayor. Had I known, I maybe would have written it up. But I'm just going to give you a really brief update. Sierra Life Flight reached out to me recently with the desire to have a second base for their operation. So they will be...
5:18:49 Likely adding a base at Mammoth Yosemite Airport in addition to what they have going on in Bishop already. So I've been working with them on a lease agreement for our sprung structure. So this would be crew quarters for them during their night and day shifts for their flight crew to support their air ambulance operations. And then they'll have their Pilatus housed most of the time at the airport as well. So we're really excited about it.
5:19:18 We're still kind of working through the lease and everything, but it really fits in with our vision for the airport, focusing on emergency services, transportation, and aviation. So we're excited about that. And my second update was just to let you guys know that we got bids on the 20th for the parking lot reconstruction project. So they came in kind of just under our engineer's estimate.
5:19:43 In our budget. So we have submitted an application to the FAA and we will return to you guys with a recommendation to award that project once we have the grant in hand. Thank you. Any questions? That is good news. Thank you. Thank you. I guess a quick question. So currently with the Sierra Life Flight in Bishop, do they fly up to Mammoth to pick up patients and then fly them out or do they do an ambulance ride down to Bishop?
5:20:09 They, um, I think that there may be some circumstances where they might drive down, but they fly up. Okay, thanks. So they're flying up very often to do these operations, so it's going to be great to just have them. Chris, you flew out of Mammoth. Okay. Thank you. But you have to wait for the plane to get here, so this is better to have one here. Yeah. Yeah. For sure. Although I don't know of a circumstance where the plane wasn't here by the time the patient got to the airport. That's awesome.
5:20:35 Consent agenda? Mr. Mayor, I have an update. I've got an update. I'm not standing up there. So just a real quick update on the certified properties and the lifting of the moratorium. As you know, that that process was approved at the previous council meetings, finally adopted on the 20th, and will come to fruition on April 22nd.
5:21:03 That is the time when the moratorium will be lifted. That is a time when certified properties regulations will be in effect. I want to thank Sean Troy and Stephanie Trujillo working with the revenue team on developing the electronic software that will be managing this process. They've been working on that for several months and making tremendous strides. It will be ready to go in time for that process, and it will be significant improvement over the collection, tax collection that we've done with previously.
5:21:33 Looking forward to that being in place and starting off. So I wanted to give that brief update. Thank you. I am not going to read all of the consent. I am just going to ask you if you want to pull anything from consent. With that, I would entertain a motion. I move that we approve the consent agenda as presented. Second. I have a motion and a second. Any further deliberation?
5:22:04 Jamie? Councilmember Rae? Yes. Councilmember Rice? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Bubzer? Yes. Mayor Souser? Yes, please. Moving on to policy matters, fiscal year 24-25, budget general fund revenue projections. Thank you, Mayor. So the revenue, and I do have a little bit of a brief, if I may share my screen, to...
5:22:55 So just really briefly, honestly, you guys are exhausted, I know. We start off our budget process annually by reviewing our budget revenue projections. These are revenue projections. They will adjust throughout the process as we get more information. What you have in the staff report sort of walks you through and outlines my thought processes in what we think we're going to bring forward or collect as revenue.
5:23:24 We kind of be, as we talked about before, extremely conservative on the TOT side that controls the growth of our organization because it's the dependency upon that. This is the one I wanted to just talk about briefly and then certified properties revenue is the other. But we're being really conservative on this. I'm going up just $500,000 mainly because I believe we can keep it constrained to that level.
5:23:53 I do share, you know, this year is probably going to end somewhere in the $25-$26 million range, but we have an $18 million budget we started with. Next year I'm going to cap it at $18.5. And again, this helps to inform, again, with our staff adjustments and cost of operations, what we can actually do. The other ones really quickly, I kind of showed you through this process what
5:24:23 The actuals are in each one of these categories versus what I'm recommending. And you can see the strength of the last couple of years. I've got three-year averages there. For property tax, I'm coming in right about that number, right? That's a controlled growth for Prop 13. There's not a lot of wild swings in that, if you will. Certainly not global swings to the negative. But that's a pretty conservative number, and I think that's easy to come in to.
5:24:58 The other one is sales tax. This one's conservative, so you can see that sales tax, which is really based upon visitation for the most part, and a little bit of inflation, right? So as the cost of goods goes up, so does the sales tax associated with that. The $3,250,000 that we have in there, you know, last year on to date through just a little bit more than half the year, we're at $2 million.
5:25:23 Getting close to the 3.7 or exceeding that that we had last year is probably going to be a fact this year. And so that 3.2 is fairly conservative. And then no adjustments to the franchise fees because that's, again, based on visitation, but it's fairly flat. Tried to present, you know, the change here. We've got an 8.8% increase in that, but that's primarily driven by the certified properties fee. You see that there in the middle about $1,350,000.
5:25:53 That's based upon the recommendations from the advisory committee, which was adopted by council, to establish a $250 per unit fee for certified properties or all rental properties. And there's roughly 3,600 units in our inventory, some 3,500 to 3,600, which on an annual basis should produce around $900,000. With this year, we will have...
5:26:21 Certified Properties Launching in April. We're going to prorate the calendar 2024 for half of that, right? So we're going to charge half that fee for this year, and then we will have a renewal that occurs in January that would be for a full year, and so that would be where our $1,350,000 revenue comes from. And that's general fund? That's general fund revenue, correct. Correct.
5:26:50 And then so we just depict that $32,824,000, how that fleshes out. You can see the largest portion of that being transient occupancy taxes. We're all clear on that. Now this will inform this number here, this $32,824. It's going to move around a little bit, but it also informs the policy discussion on our reserves, right? We do that as a fraction of or a percentage of the total.
5:27:20 I think it would be helpful
5:27:52 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
5:28:21 Averaging over the last, say, the last decade since the T-bid really went into effect. Is there a plateau? Is there a number there that's sort of an averaging these kinds of things out? You don't have to do that now, but I think in terms of us looking at this saying, well, we think we can, this, we're generating about this, and as the costs of running the town start going like this to help us give some sense of, okay, where are we headed and when are things going to start getting goofy so we can be proactive about that a little bit.
5:28:50 So we can maybe not just stumble into that blindly. But what do you mean by plateau? Can you? Yeah, so the TOT numbers, I mean, they've. Yeah, so I can address that really quick. So if you look actually in the charts in the staff report and what was on the screen here just briefly, it does show you what the total TOT has been by year for the last 10 years. Yeah. And you'll see in there some, I don't want to say seasonality, but you'll see.
5:29:18 Some events that were impactful. So you can see when TBID came to fruition, and so we started investing more heavily in the marketing side of things around 2014-15, 15-16, you'll see a dramatic change, right? We were at a plateau throughout prior to that, right? We were just sort of achieving what we achieved. Then as that growth kind of came up in the economy, it was also an element that
5:29:47 drove visitation, right? You had people who had money to spend on vacations, and so you'll see that climbing up. And then there's a bit of typical market economics where you've got, you know, a lot of people wanting to come up here, and so you have a driving up of the average daily rates. That has sort of pushed up, if you will, in step increments that are noticeable on those charts.
5:30:13 But you'll also see, obviously, the impacts of COVID, you know, that impact that had very significant impact to us. But there is a little bit of a walking up a ladder, if you will, from the way the TOT revenue has grown. And again, we haven't seen, other than the COVID aspects, significant...
5:30:34 And so that's where we're looking for maybe this is going to plateau in the mid-20s now, right? And then we'll have some solid years that push it up in the low 30s. I think that's kind of the progression that I would expect in growth. And for people who may be watching edification about the inflection point we talk about, the growth of our organization, the cost of operations is going to climb, right? It doesn't have the same fluctuation as revenue does.
5:31:03 It has the potential, if we don't control it properly, to climb at a faster rate, right? And then we're going to get to a point where, hey, we don't have the resources necessary to run our operation, and we have to figure out how to either constrict in size or adjust the cost of our operations, okay? That's the concern that we have. So as staff, and certainly we talk about it every single day, how do we become more efficient?
5:31:32 Invest the right way in staffing, which you'll see in the upcoming budget. We are going to invest a little bit in some staffing areas that have been, I'm going to say, dormant or non-existent. But then from that point, we should be set, right? We've done some investments. How do we get more efficient? How do we get more diverse in our core service delivery?
5:31:53 And that's ongoing conversations. I just put together the agenda for tomorrow's department head, and it has an entire strategic discussion on this very point. So we're working on it quite diligently and aware of it, but that's coming in our future. Okay, because that's that. Yeah, my question on the plateau of the TOT revenue is really just because, you know, you had the big jump once TBID came online.
5:32:21 And then there was kind of steady growth. And then we had the pandemic and we don't have enough. So there were always externalities that I just think it's a big ask to ask Rob, like how that might play out when from. I'm thinking just back of envelope kind of stuff. Okay. Just very generally, we're kind of going in this direction because remember the housing money, all those things we're putting is coming out of the TOT. We want to.
5:32:46 Keep generating that to keep putting that into that. I totally understand your question about the inflection point. I just think trying to figure out when we're going to plateau. No, no, no. Forecasting, you know, five-year budgets, it's for one or two years you can get close to it and then you start to get very, very wild. Noisy. Yes, yeah. That's standard. And the inflection point, frankly, is determined by those of us sitting in these chairs. Exactly.
5:33:12 How we hold the line on employee costs, how we hold the line on structural costs, that we don't overinvest so that we have the unallocated funds each year to spend on the necessities. Yep. I'll just real briefly, and I apologize for extending this, but it was kind of an important point we've been doing with analysis of staff, and Hayes and team have led this because a lot of it is in public works.
5:33:39 The one-times monies that we're spending on capital projects obviously have those core costs. They're creeping our core services or an expansion of that. And not all of them are like the CRC, which has grown costs significantly, but it also has grown revenue significantly, right? Not all of our projects are ROI projects like that one to where we have to be cognizant of these spending money to grow infrastructure.
5:34:08 Does have a creep in our annual costs that need to be addressed. And so by looking at that, we're planning to come to council with not only the cost of producing the project, but the cost of operating that project for the next five to 10 years, right? Forecasting that out a little bit because we need to start making decisions broader than, you know, we've got money, what can we do with it? To how do we control our growth? Because that's another part of it that's kind of sneaking up from the side on us. Thank you.
5:34:40 So on this item, Rob, did you get from us what you needed? You don't need... It was just a presentation to you all, and I think what I was hoping to hear is consensus that for the most part what has been presented is not offending anybody, and we would like to proceed that. Again, no adoption of this budget occurs until June. Yeah, and I like what you presented. I think it's spot on. Thank you. Any other comments or questions? I think it's conservative.
5:35:10 And I feel like that's how we budget. Thank you. Okay. Moving on then to Councilmember Reports. John, we'll start with you. Thank you very much. Did you want to go first? I want to go first. I have nothing to report. We had the meeting today with MLA, I'm sorry, Eastern Sierra Community Housing, and I have nothing more to report. John. Sorry, John. No, no, no, no. MLA, let me start back here.
5:35:43 So, I attended the White Bark Raft meeting. Rob was there. This is the ESCCRP meeting. Talked about the biomass grants. The EDA grant, Rob advised, got cut from $10 million down to $1 million that's coming to us. But there's a significant amount of money going to a group called West Biofuels. We have some, we need to show us a new kind of love, apparently, to our friends in Mono County. There's some, there's some.
5:36:13 Grant stuff that's got to get done, some contracts that got to get finished. It's not moving over there, so we need to start getting things going over there to move this stuff forward. The MOU signing for this wildfire stuff, Rob, we have signed the MOU, we just hadn't delivered it, correct? Okay. It has been signed, for sure. So this is an MOU that has to do with the larger funding of this whole donut project. It's not binding in any way, but...
5:36:46 Got to get that side. So that's moving along very aggressively, and that's great. I had a meeting with Rob on March 26th with the Sierra Business Council leadership. This had to do with some concerns being expressed by California Jobs First. You guys have all seen the letter. The SBC got wind of the letter. They all came piling down here. We got to talk. Okay, let's talk. And we had a good, I would say, direct conversation with them.
5:37:15 Seemed to have hurt us, and we'll see where that goes. I attended the ICARP TAC meeting in Sacramento on Friday. This is something I do as OPR as part of the climate program with OPR. Interesting, if anybody wants the details that I could share. OPR is going through kind of a transition. The letter for California Jobs First, you've all seen that. If you have any questions, I'm more than happy to answer that. In the ESSRP meeting, it's going to happen on Monday.
5:37:40 It's an opportunity for SBC to kind of lay out, okay, this is the big pivot. This is what we're going to do. You could all attend. It's not a Brown Act thing. You can just listen to what's happening. But if anybody wants to attend, just let me know and make sure you're invited. I think that'll be interesting. Then the MLT meeting, they all went down to a big Visit California meeting. And, you know, our team is respected in the state of California. They say, wow, you're from Mammoth. You guys do great work. You know, it's...
5:38:10 We're well thought of and well perceived. Winter Air Service is doing sort of about the same as last year, a little bit behind. We are going to be seeing some draft deliverables coming from MLT, and that meeting has to be scheduled, Rob, I think sometime later in May. One thing that's really kind of interesting, you hear MLT talk a lot about, oh, we got to get more people here midweek, midweek.
5:38:36 Well, the discussion with the MLT board is between blackout dates, remote work, that's already kind of happening. You know, a lot of people, they're trying to get that midweek experience, so they're all showing up here to get the midweek experience. So that's kind of leveling things out a little bit, and I asked them to bring us some numbers, because that could affect policy decisions we make. If that's actually starting to happen, that could be interesting for us to know that stuff. John Urdi was talking about a sustainable destination management plan.
5:39:06 Rob, that's something he thinks he's getting financed by JLL, but I think that's something that might come in front of us, but I think we need to do some good groundwork in advance of that to figure out what's happening. And some, I guess, bittersweet news, Laura Kaler is leaving MLT. She'll be leaving in the next couple of weeks. More time with family. Social media, all that stuff that they're doing, all the numbers going off the charts, all kinds of people are engaging, which is great. They are really, truly,
5:39:35 The whole TBID renewal thing, they got beat up pretty bad by all that. And they're really, they're really, they got whatever message we were sending, they got it, and they want to be working very, very closely with us. I said, that's great, we want to work closely with you. When they come back together with these plans, communication plans and things like that, we really need to be thinking, okay, who are you, what department are you working with, and what exactly is it that you're doing so they can be tangible things so the community can...
5:40:03 More deeper invested so we can love our economy because our economy helps us build housing. So I'll leave it at that. Thank you very much. Chris? I have nothing to report. Sarah? Nothing to report. My most important reports I shared with you all prior to the meeting. So I have nothing to report. Amanda already said she had nothing to report. She reported her report. She reported nothing to report. So I will adjourn this town council meeting to
5:40:34 The next meeting, which will not be held until Wednesday, May 1, 2024, at 4 p.m. And I promise you, I will do everything in my power to get...