Town Council Special meeting
at 17:30
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Minutes ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Notable from this meeting
2 findingsTranscript
295 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:04 Feels like we're getting the band back together again. I wish that's what we were doing. Maybe soon Bill will be back in person, huh? We can only hope. It was a big part of my social life hanging out in town council meetings. Well, now it's on the record. Is that a social life or a social disease? I'll leave that to you. Just so everyone knows, it looks like everyone from Mammoth Lakes Housing is here.
1:07 Well, except for, yeah, I guess my staff is probably in the audience, but we're not waiting for any additional board members. After hanging out in that previous meeting, I'm surprised Sandra hasn't ditched out for a cocktail. I'm still here. Good evening, everyone. Do we have, is Sandra's here? Okay, good. That was a quick one, Sandra. Good for you. Okay, let's go ahead and get started on this. Thank you, everyone, for waiting just at least a few minutes.
2:29 So this will be the convening of the Mammoth Lakes Town Council special meeting on Wednesday, February 9th. And why don't we start out with roll call. Council Member Wray? I'm here. Council Member Souser? Present. Council Member Staff? Here. Mayor Pro Tem Wentworth? Here. Mayor Salcido? Here. All right, Pleasure of Allegiance. Council Member Souser, would you lead us, please?
2:59 Certainly, if you'll stand and join me and begin. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you very much. And also I would like to welcome...
3:22 The members of the Mammoth Lakes Housing Court of Directors to join us this evening. The purpose of this meeting is a joint meeting with Mammoth Lakes Housing. Before we move on, let me ask if there's any public comments about items that are not on the agenda this evening. No, there are not. Thank you, Jamie. All right, why don't we move along then to policy matters 4.1.
3:49 Town Council joint meeting with Mammoth Lakes Housing to discuss key focus areas for fiscal year 22-23 contract. Yeah, and Mayor, as a joint meeting, if we could have a roll. Oh, yes, right, roll call for Mammoth Lakes Housing, thank you. Yes, Jamie, thank you. Sure, President Stapp? Yes. Vice President Kreitz? Board Member Barksdale? Yes. Board Member Hodges? Present. Board Member Vianzen?
4:23 Here. Board Member Perkins. Present. Board Member Steenstra. Board Member DeAndrea. Okay. Thank you, Jamie. Jamie, could I request that you promote our attorney, Raphael Yacchian from Goldfarb Lutman? Will do. Thank you. Okay. Good evening. Again, Sandra, would you like to begin on this for us? Thank you. I would like, yes, I can. So,
5:09 Let me just get the, let's get the slideshow up. We were having some slideshow issues with in planning commission and I have the same, ah, there we go, great. Okay, so this item before you tonight is the joint meeting with Mammoth Lakes Housing. Next slide. So just a little bit of background for the commission and for the board. The town approved the contract with Mammoth Lakes Housing on July 7th, 2021.
5:41 That was a one-year contract. We have included it in your packet, but it's really just for reference only. And at that meeting on July 7, 2021, the Town Council directed staff to seek out additional housing programs and possible items for collaboration with Mammoth Lakes Housing. So we did that. We worked with Mammoth Lakes Housing to look for new grant sources like the Home Key Grant, which we applied for about a week ago.
6:09 Also, the bridge program was the program where we buy market rate units, deed restrict them, and then sell them at the deed restricted price. And at that meeting in July and over the course of the past couple months, there's been a town council desire to identify some priority focus areas for the next contract that we have with Mammoth Lakes Housing. Next slide.
6:37 So just a quick run through on our agenda tonight, we're going to hit the town's housing program highlights, Mammoth Lakes housing program highlights, town council identified contract focus areas, our next steps for the contract, and then some other discussion items. And just a note, I think what we'll do is run through our presentation, and then I think Patricia has a separate presentation to kind of hit on her points, and that's probably easier to kind of have her vote after we finish ours.
7:05 And then, Sandra, I just wanted to ask, when will the MLH board be able to identify their contract focus area? They can, during, I guess, during the town council identified contract focus areas, that's the opportunity to, for the town to convey what we're looking for from Mammoth Lakes Housing as a part of our contract. And I think that's the opportunity for the Mammoth Lakes Housing Board to respond to our requests for the contract. If there's items that they would like to see the town council, the town focus on.
7:36 And they think it would be important to be in the town's contract. I think that would be an opportunity to provide those. Okay, great. Thank you. Thanks. Okay, next slide. So, Nolan, I think it would be great if you could walk through our housing program highlights. Great. Thank you. And one change I talked with Patricia before this started, after we walked through our program highlights, I was going to stop sharing and have Patricia share her screen. And then...
8:06 Switch back to ours to finish the presentation. Okay, thanks, Nolan. Appreciate that. So yeah, the Town Council or Towns Housing Program highlights one key point. We have come up with a name for our program. Currently, we're calling it the Housing Now Program. If anyone has a more catchy name, we're open to ideas, but now we're running with that. So highlight number one is the parcel. That's the 24th.
8:35 5-acre project that will provide up to 450 units of affordable housing. Phase 1 with 81 units is currently under construction. That will be 80 units of affordable with one manager's unit. And then we're working with Pacific, the developer, on the design for Phase 2, which we anticipate being submitted shortly. And that will accommodate somewhere in the mid-100 unit range.
9:02 Next highlight is the bridge program. This is a program that's been developed through a partnership with Mammoth Lakes Housing, allowing for the acquisition of market rate units to be resold at a deed restricted price. Our goal for this first year of the program is to have six to eight units. And then that also is being funded through a million dollars allocated by the town council.
9:31 The program works through providing a subsidy from that million dollars. So after we acquire the market rate unit, it's so that that reduced price subsidies coming out of the million dollars. We currently have four units in various stages of being entered a purchase agreement with the future buyer up to when we have one unit currently in escrow and we have two units that we're working on minor repairs too. Our next highlights, the small site housing developments. This is
10:01 We've acquired one 0.200 acre site with the goal of providing a four-unit planned unit development on that site. Those units will then be deed restricted and sold at an affordable price to qualified households. Also, with this program, we're currently looking at other smaller sites, multifamily sites as they come on the market to see the potential for development, whether it makes sense to pursue acquisition.
10:30 Next up is the Creative Housing Fund. This was $1.5 million allocated to housing programs. The program's intentionally vague and allows for flexibility to be responsive as new housing projects arise. So part of the funding from this program currently will be used to assist if we are awarded the Home Key Grant.
10:56 It also leaves some additional funding as other potential private-public partnerships may arise for acquiring or developing new affordable housing units. Some other highlights, we're working on in kind of a partnership with Mono County, they went through with their Senate Bill 2 funds to get pre-approved ADU plans.
11:19 Through our shared building official and talks with Monah County, at least one of their designs will meet all the town's snow load requirements. So we can then utilize those plans and adopt them as pre-approved ADU plans available for the community in Mammoth. This will save building costs through not having to do all the structural and engineering and building code plans for an ADU.
11:47 We also maintain a revolving loan fund that's currently funded with $600,000. This allows, again, through a partnership with MLH, the opportunity to buy back deed-restricted properties as they come on the market. This ensures that the units remain deed-restricted because it removes the hardship exemption or 30-day out clause if the seller cannot find another qualified household.
12:15 This program is also assisted by an additional $300,000 from Mono County. Town also employee housing program. The town maintains four condo units that can be used for temporary and term housing for new employees. We've also in the past extended this use to other local agencies and nonprofits. If the unit's not in use by a town employee and we don't have a potential employee that's looking to use it in the near term.
12:45 Recently, as in the end of 2021, we've identified all the town deed restrictions that the town is a party to. These are separate than the Mammoth Lakes Housing deed restrictions that they're a party to. We've identified 26 deed restrictions. Historically, the town's monitoring of these has not been...
13:08 Very diligent, and so we're looking to improve on that. This is the first year we've monitored. So far of those, I've received, I think, 10 responses. We've also identified one unit that is no longer deed restricted. The deed restriction was rescinded around 2011, and we did not have it in our files, so it's a good exercise to update all of our records. Going forward, this is a potential program that we have talked with Mammoth Fixed Housing. Once we...
13:36 Clean up and identify the status of all of our due restrictions that potentially could be handed off to them. Other programs, ongoing grant programs. So the town continues to look for and research and apply for state and federal grant programs. Oftentimes Mammoth Lakes Housing is a sub-recipient to those grant programs, such as the CDBG or home grants. And other times the town is the sole applicant on the grants.
14:06 We also work through any legislative updates, so we monitor all the state actions related to housing and then implement code changes or process updates here locally to implement those. Some recent ones that have earned more attention are the Senate Bill 9, allowing duplex and two-unit projects in residential zones and the ADU code updates.
14:30 And some process updates include the SB35 streamline approvals for qualified affordable projects. So we actually use that process on Mammoth Lakes Housing's 238 Sierra Manor Road project and are potentially looking at using that for the Home Key project if the grant's successful. We also provided...
14:53 Close to $650,000 in funding assistance to MLH to assist with community-wide rental assistance in response to COVID. Some of that was CDBG CARES Act funds and a large portion of that was general funds. Then lastly, we're a partner with MLH or Access Apartments partner. We've committed $1.5 million in support of their 11-unit apartment project.
15:20 So that's just a short summary of the town's housing program highlights. With that, I'm going to stop sharing and ask Patricia to share her slides. Thank you, Nolan. Yeah, thank you, Nolan. That was really great. I have two things I want to share. The first is I wanted to do a brief overview of our success infographic that was in your packet.
15:51 There was a couple things I wanted to highlight. And so can you see that infographic now? Yes. Let's see. So this is an infographic that I put together to highlight some of MLH's program success over the past two or so years. As you know, we are a staff of two full-time employees, and our average annual budget is approximately $530,000.
16:26 In the last two years, we've really ramped up our fundraising. It was a priority identified in our strategic plan, which I know was also in your packet. And so in the last two years, we've raised $200,000 in private donations. And so that's above and beyond any contributions by jurisdictions. And so that's almost $150,000 in private donations for our rent assistance program that we operated during the public health emergency.
16:55 And $37,000 towards Access Apartments. We currently have a goal of $100,000 in private donations for that project. And I released a press release today related to a donation by the Altera Mountain Company Community Foundation of $25,000 towards that project. So we've exceeded our five-year goal by 900%. And I'm really excited to say that
17:22 Where we anticipate continuing on this fundraising journey. In terms of grants, I did extend the timeline here to 2019 because we have some pending applications that we haven't received awards yet for. But in this time period, we've applied for almost $13 million in funding. We've received $2 million and we have pending $5 million in grant applications.
17:49 I wanted to note on that item that we have applied for some funding independently of the town, and that is included here in this infographic. And those grants include our 2019 home application for access apartments, as well as a couple of grant applications that we applied for to provide.
18:14 Loans to households to create ADUs on their properties. And so that really, our board felt like was in line with the town's ADU priority program and how could we assist and facilitate the construction of ADUs. And that was one way that we felt we could participate. Item number three is our home ownership program. And so in the past two...
18:44 Two years and a little more, we've assisted nine households become homebuyers within the town of Mammoth Lakes. Their average down payment assistance is almost $100,000. We've preserved six land trust homes, so deed restricted homes. And Mammoth Lakes Housing invested, I wanted to note this during Nolan's presentation, the bridge program, the town.
19:11 Invest some money into that program, but Mammoth Lakes Housing actually invests money into that program as well. We have carrying costs and costs associated with selling the properties. And so in the past two years, we've invested $100,000 towards the preservation of land trustee restricted homes. And then in partnership with the town, we have successfully closed escrow on three units. As you know, we
19:43 We were a COVID pandemic champion award recipient from the Chamber of Commerce in 2020 for our ability to pivot and provide emergency rent assistance to tenants in our community and also the landlords. And so we fundraised $1 million and that's inclusive of the town's contribution and Mono County as well, but also includes our private donations and other agency contributions to that program.
20:12 For example, First Five contributed $20,000 and Union Bank contributed $30,000. And so all of that work is encompassed in that 1 million number. We issued almost 2,000 partial rent payments, which helped more than 500 households maintain their homes during the pandemic and put money in the pockets of more than 200 landlords. I know you're well aware of our new projects. We have access apartments, 11 one bedrooms and five.
20:46 And then our Project Home Key application, which we submitted last Monday. It's been a whirlwind couple of weeks, but that'll hopefully be 15 studio apartments. And then we're actively, you know, pursuing and researching additional opportunities in the region. Number six is really important to me. In the past three years, we've really...
21:10 worked hard to strengthen our relationships and identify new sources of funding to grow our capacity at Mammoth Lakes Housing so that we can do more. And so far, we've successfully done that through a partnership with Mono County Behavioral Health, which funded a grant, a grant-funded position for a temporary amount of time. But that staff person was critical in operating the Emergency Rent Assistance Program, which we never would have been able to do as just two.
21:39 We also, in the last couple of years, had a program development contract with Inyo County to develop a rehabilitation loan program, and that was additional revenue, which we ended up not utilizing for capacity, but reinvested into our mission for affordable housing. And then we've also been able to host three part-time annual interns at Mammoth Lakes Housing, which
22:07 Is just excellent for growing local capacity in general and professional development, but also really helps us in the office with all the clients that we have coming in daily. We have a new, under this item, you know, we're working, we're having conversations with both Alpine County and Mono County to potentially fund a full-time benefited position to help grow capacity for all the services that we offer. And that's just another example of how,
22:39 We've been trying to grow our workload so that we can have more employees doing this great work. As I mentioned, number seven, our board of directors allocated net proceeds from our work into access apartments and then our rebranding effort, which I'll talk a little bit about later. The last item I wish I had added to this infographic, but that is not here, is that in the past two years, we did host a number of
23:10 Public workshops for the community. We held a Zoom meeting with the Mexican consulate to help inform the community about resources that were available to them during the pandemic. We also held two landlord tenant rights workshops so folks could understand what was legal and not legal during the chaos of the pandemic and the inability of tenants to pay their rent during closures.
23:39 And we also held two homebuyer education classes. And those classes helped to inform our homebuyer clients about the process of buying a home and the legal requirements, but also help attract new clients who might be interested in participating in our programs. And so that's another success, I would say, that didn't appear on this infographic. I'll have to add it next time. I'm just going to stop and share my PowerPoint quickly.
24:08 And I will go as quickly as possible. Everyone can see that? I think we're, Patricia, I think we're looking at the wrong screen. I think it's a, we're seeing your view and not the presenter view. I wonder how I, maybe. I had the same problem in the, in the PEDC meeting just recently. Do you know, Sandra, what the, what keys to click on? I didn't actually share that one. I don't know, Nolan, is there a secret? Oh.
25:26 I'm not sure. I got lucky that mine just worked. Okay, hold on. I think I might have it. Hold on. Sorry. Thanks for telling me. Okay, are you still seeing presenter? Presenter mode, but now you are. You weren't before. Okay, hold on. I'm just going to switch it now, I think. What about now? There you go. Yeah. Okay, great.
26:05 So this is just our program highlights. And then I tried to, you know, come up with some ways to address some of the comments that I heard at the Town Council meeting on February 2nd. And so here's just an overview of those folks working on housing in Mammoth Lakes. We have Mammoth Lakes Housing, IMACA, the Town of Mammoth Lakes, the Chamber, local businesses, including Mammoth Mountain.
26:33 And also private property owners and developers. And you can see we're all doing different things. And of course, there's some overlap, but it's pretty amazing to see how much capacity we have dedicated to this issue. So here's a little bit of background information about Mammoth Lakes Housing. We are a nonprofit 501c3 organization and our charitable purpose, according to the IRS.
27:01 is to acquire, develop, own, operate, lease and support the development of affordable housing in Alpine, Mono and Inyo counties. This allows us to do fundraising, partner with for-profit developers and leverage local resources and relationships for affordable housing. We're also a real estate brokerage firm.
27:25 And this allows us to provide direct client services, for example, the homeownership program, but also allows us to perform property management duties for the properties that we own and operate. We're also a community housing development organization, and this is a certification that we qualify for at the state level, which gives us a competitive advantage when we compete for some funding at the state level.
27:56 And so when we compete for CHOTO Set Aside Funds, we're competing only against 20 other entities and is part of the reason why we were successful in our 2019 application. And it also helps the state recognize who we are because we're one of 21 other organizations. It gives us the reputation at the state level.
28:27 It requires that we have one-third of our board of directors represent the low-income community, which helps build community trust and inform program design, which I think is really important. And then it does limit public officials' participation on our board to no more than one-third of our board of directors. Mammoth Lakes Housing is a nonprofit business.
28:54 And so our revenue comes from a variety of sources, contracts for services, grants, our real estate services can generate some revenue, and we provide property management services. Our infrastructure includes our bylaws, which are our governing documents. We have a board of directors and a strategic plan, which guides our programs and projects.
29:20 And then we obviously have office space and staff that are committed to our mission. The outcomes of this structure are public benefits of affordable housing, direct client services, and ultimately regional housing solutions. You all know our mission is to support community housing for a viable economy and sustainable community. And we're proud to be an official partner of the town of Mammoth Lakes, you know, to maintain a community within our town boundaries.
29:58 I wanted to touch briefly on the qualifications and experience of our staff because I think it's important to remember that we're not just a nebulous NGO, but we're actually real, dedicated, educated, and professional folks working on housing solutions. Starting with everyone but me, and I'll be last, but Diane Dunan is our Grant and Financial Associate. She has a degree in rural community development.
30:28 And 13 years of experience working for the Washoe Tribe. She has managed grants and construction oversight for rural community development projects like tribal health center and bridge infrastructure for when there was a flood. And so, you know, she's amazing at administering our grant programs, providing the
30:58 Procurement for our pre-development consultants for access apartments. And I just, I love working with Diane. She's just a wealth of knowledge and experience in our community. Eric Guzman Rangel is our Rural West intern this year. He's pursuing a degree in environmental science and management. And he's one of our bilingual staff members who speaks both English and Spanish.
31:29 He worked really hard on the budget and the pro forma for our project home key grant application for the acquisition of an existing site in the town of Mammoth Lakes. And he has a lot of experience, you know, pursuing his degree and working on public outreach, cost benefit analysis of rezoning public land.
31:58 And just lots of really great experience that we can harness and utilize for affordable housing in our community. And as you know, I'm Patricia Robertson. I'm the executive director. I have a master's degree in community and regional planning from the University of New Mexico. I'm a licensed real realtor and I have nine years of experience with Mammoth Lakes housing.
32:26 I am also bilingual in English and Spanish, which is really important in our community. I think for me, the current project highlights are the Project Home Key application we submitted. The emergency rent assistance obviously was a huge win for our community. I'm very excited about the bridge program and our partnership with the town to increase ownership opportunities for our middle management staff in our community. And obviously,
32:55 Our 2019 Home Award for Access Apartments, this is actually a picture of me working on that application with my son who's like five weeks old in this photo. So, you know, we're very dedicated and passionate and committed to affordable housing. This is just a visual representation of some of the work that we do. It's not numerically accurate, but it's one way to slice the pie, if you will.
33:24 We have a contract with the Town of Mammoth Lakes, which takes up approximately 85% of our staff time. If you say we have contracts with some other jurisdictions, those take up a smaller portion of that pie. But we also have other work items that we work on above and beyond, you know, oftentimes a 40-hour work week. We have administration of the nonprofit.
33:52 We provide property management for Star Apartments and also 238 Sierra Manor Road. We're working on the conversion of access apartments. Our board of directors has a development committee which adds capacity to Mammoth Lakes Housing and so they're very active doing new project research.
34:16 I do a lot of relationship building with our local partners, businesses, and other jurisdictions, including Mono County. We've expanded into a new fundraising role, which takes time and effort. Then we also administer grant agreements, like Nolan mentioned. We have outside contracts for CDBG administration or home administration, for example, and that also takes staff time. And then we do some advocacy.
34:45 While our work program may fluctuate at different times, there's always more work to do than time in the day, and I don't think that will ever go away. But for the past 10 years, Mammoth Lakes Housing has been to full-time staff people, and I think that we're trying to leverage the resources we do have to grow our capacity and do more for housing. Our relationship to the town is quite...
35:16 Straightforward, I think, right? We have an appointed official who serves on our board, and that is a requirement of our bylaws, which are governing documents. And then we contract for specific services, and that's why we're here this evening. And so I would expect there to be some overlap in what Mammoth X Housing in the town is working on. And that overlap is really memorialized in the contract by our common goals. And so I think we've heard that some of them are grants.
35:48 Expanding our de-restricted opportunities for ownership and providing direct client services. I think we'll probably hear about some more priorities this evening. I wanted to highlight briefly some of the really exciting things that we're doing that's different than what we've done in the past. And I've given a similar presentation to both the Chamber of Commerce and the Mammoth Lakes Board of Realtors, and they've all been very receptive and excited about.
36:16 This and I couldn't pass up the opportunity to share it with you. So I'll go as quickly as I can. These are the things I'm going to touch on. Our work in the region, our rebranding effort, fundraising we've talked about, the bridge program we've talked about, and our new projects you know about. So this will be quick. Mammoth Lakes Housing has been working in the region for quite a long time.
36:38 You know, for a long time as one of the only housing agencies in the region, jurisdictions would reach out to us for feedback on their housing elements and implementation programs. And so we've been providing that feedback for a very long time. Since 2013, our regional goals have been memorialized in our bylaws. And as you saw in our IRS tax exempt mission, which is to serve affordable housing in the region.
37:08 I think that we all know that we're better together. And so combining our capacity and our resources is only going to result in more solutions in the long term. And I know that our board and our strategic plan is very clear about that. Our 20th anniversary is coming up this summer. It's a very exciting time for Mammoth X Housing.
37:35 And we felt like a rebranding was extremely important if we wanted to attract outside funders and donors and also communicate to our partners that we don't just serve a small community in the Eastern Sierra, but that we're available and willing and able to work together outside of the town of Mammoth Lakes.
38:02 Actually, we're going to be releasing a community survey probably this week, maybe on Friday, asking for community feedback about our rebranding. And so look for that. It'll be in our newsletter. We're seeking community feedback. And then we're going to move into the design phase. We've done some marketing research and development with a consultant.
38:31 To help us frame and do better outreach and communication to our constituents and potential funders. And so we'll be moving into design phase and hope to relaunch this summer. We touched on fundraising. I mentioned this already. We've raised nearly $200,000 in the past two years. We just received a contribution from the Altera Mountain Company Community Foundation of $25,000.
39:01 We received $30,000 from Union Bank last year, and we have other donors that are participating, and so we'll continue to foster those relationships and harness outside funding for housing. We've also been communicating and advertising our ability to receive asset and land donations.
39:23 Mammoth Lakes Housing did receive a partial land donation for access apartments, and so that is something that we are communicating more about and letting folks know that that's a possibility if they'd like to give back to the community. This was just some of our sort of, you know, rebranding, thinking about a new image for Mammoth Lakes Housing. We want to support our community and obviously continue with fundraising efforts.
39:54 As you know, we're partnering with the Town of Mammoth Lakes on the bridge program to buy down market rate homes and sell them at affordable prices. Thank you to the Town of Mammoth Lakes for providing that subsidy to make homeownership achievable for our community members. I think currently we've actively purchased and closed escrow on three homes. One is already in escrow for sale to a local family. And there's about nine households waiting for homeownership opportunities.
40:29 This we didn't talk about yet. So this is an example of how we fund the bridge program. I guess I'll run through it real quick. So let's say that we purchase a unit for $500,000 and the town loans that money to Mammoth Lakes Housing, who then becomes the owner. As the representing broker in the transaction, MLH earns a commission of 2.5%. And then Mammoth Lakes Housing...
40:59 It coordinates with contractors to make sure that if there's any repairs that are needed. In one unit, we did do carpet, paint and some broken windows. And so we front the money for all those repairs. And then Mammoth X Housing is the owner and we're carrying the property. So there's costs associated with that, including the monthly HOA fees, property taxes, utilities, et cetera. We pay for those. And then
41:29 Let's see. So then we're ready to sell it to the next owner and we sell it for $400,000. And we have fees associated with the sale. So we have to pay the title insurance and the escrow fees. And if the buyer uses Mammoth Lakes Housing as their broker, we don't have to pay an outside broker's commission. But in some cases we do.
41:54 So I would say maybe $4,000 in closing costs unless there's an outside broker and then it could be upwards of $14,000 in closing costs. We sell to a local household and the town absorbs the subsidy of $100,000 in the price and the $10,000 for the rehab and Mammoth Lakes Housing is paid for the carrying costs and the seller's fees. In this example, I...
42:23 You'll see that there's a small amount of net proceeds to Mammoth Lakes Housing of $2,500. But I will say in our last transaction when we paid an outside broker, we would actually be in the red as well. And so this is just one example. And as I mentioned, over the last three years, we have invested over $100,000 in deed restriction retention. We do annually budget for that line item in our budget. And so that's where those funds come out of our budget and support that program.
42:58 I don't think we need to talk about this. I think you're all well aware that we have some projects in the pipeline. Here's the old country glass building and then our vision for a revitalized community. I did give a lengthy presentation on access apartments during the Mammoth Lakes Tourism Community Coffee in August. That's available on our website for viewing.
43:28 And then I think I'm coming to the end, so I wanted to share a few testimonials from some of our clients about the work that we do. This testimonial is from an emergency rent assistance client who said, thank you for the assistance from the bottom of our hearts. We were very uncertain on when we would have our normal income flow. Though it has not recovered fully and we only needed two months of assistance, we couldn't be more appreciative of the help when we needed it. Thank you for keeping us afloat.
43:58 And keeping our family here in our beloved community. This is from an ownership client. Thank you, MLH. We are very excited to be homeowners. Thank you for all your help throughout the last several months. Working with Mammoth Lakes Housing was an enjoyable experience. Now, instead of paying rent every month, my wife and I are homeowners. I recommend Mammoth Lakes Housing to other first-time homebuyers in our area. Thank you for everything you did, Patricia and staff.
44:31 You know that Mammoth Lakes Housing has been making an impact in our community for over 20 years. We've leveraged $48 million in dollars for our community and helped tens of thousands of locals with housing solutions. Thank you. That's my presentation. And so I'll turn it back over to Nolan and Sandra to finish up the PowerPoint and move to discussion. Thanks for your time. All right. Thank you very much, Patricia.
45:05 All right, Sandra, would you like to come back in here? Yes, thanks. So I think it probably would be easier for me to run through all the focus areas as discussed by the council last week, and then we can maybe come back to them after I run through them if that works for you, Mayor Salcido. Yes, thank you. Thanks. So the first focus area that the town council discussed was the creation and preservation of deed restricted units.
45:34 This would involve using the revolving loan fund to preserve those deed-restricted units, using our bridge funding to add new units, and looking for funding programs to add affordable deed-restricted units, a variety of different programs for that. Developing and maintaining a proactive wait list for renters and owners, so that's matching households with the appropriate housing units, looking at affordability level, family size, rental ownership, etc.
46:04 The third focus area was to seek out and apply for grants to bring more money to produce new housing units in Mammoth Lakes. Looking at both traditional sources like CDBG and home, but then also non-traditional sources that we might not have accessed in the past or accessed only on a limited basis like the Community Reinvestment Act. And then really looking at ways to maximize the federal, state and other funding sources.
46:31 And actively manage, report, track and promote grant funding. The fourth focus area was real estate housing services. Again, the bridge program using the real estate license to buy and sell units to the bridge program. And in housing services is to provide office hours, website and consider training housing ambassadors or ombudsmen to increase capacity. Next slide.
46:57 And then the next steps for the contract, we would be looking to bring a draft Mammoth Lakes Housing Contract back to the Town Council by May 7th with a final contract on June 1st and options for other meetings as needed. And that's maybe something that the council can discuss through this meeting. And then other items, the staff report has a summary about the kind of current organization of Mammoth Lakes Housing and the way it's organized.
47:27 They do operate as a legislative body due to the appointments of council members and board of supervisors. And, you know, town staff has, we've heard kind of comments across over the past couple of years about maybe some desire from the Mammoth Lakes Housing Board's part, maybe just some discussions about the potential for a Mammoth Lakes Housing to transition to a standalone nonprofit, if that was desirable. So we wanted to kind of...
47:53 Add this in here to have a discussion about that to take the temperature kind of of both the council and the board just to see if there was any interest in that. And if directed by the council, at least the town staff would put together some information to analyze that change. So this is really just an opportunity for the two groups to discuss that item. Sandra, can you clarify what you mean by a standalone nonprofit? Because Netflix housing is a nonprofit and we contract directly with the town.
48:22 Sure. I mean, not an NGO. So not an NGO of the town. I think that was the intent. It's clearly not a technical term, but a nonprofit that is not just an NGO of the town. So a nonprofit that doesn't contract with the town for services. Well, I think the thought is that it could be, there could be more distance in the relationship if that's what the MLH board of the town council want to have. Right now, it's a fairly close relationship.
48:50 With, you know, a council member on the MLH board and the town providing significant funding. But if everyone thinks that there should be a little more distance and a less close relationship, if that would benefit both MLH and the town, I think that's what Sandra is referring to. Thanks, Andy. Really, like, number two is just an elaboration on number one. I think that could be one aspect of it. I mean, certainly, if there were no longer a council member on the MLH board, that might...
49:23 I mean, the MLH would no longer be subject to the Brown Act, but there could be other aspects too. And again, this is not something necessarily that staff is recommending. It's just, you know, something that could be considered if everybody wanted to. Yeah, I just want to make sure that my board understands the terminology because I think it's a little confusing. Right, and clearly, as indicated kind of at the bottom there, we need to analyze those changes. I think, you know, there's a lot of different aspects to it and we would want to analyze that if there was a desire from.
49:52 You know, from the groups to talk about that. So definitely more analysis needed. Last slide, Nolan. Our next slide. So the discussion items, kind of what we're looking for here tonight is to hear some feedback and some consensus on the focus areas. If there are higher or lower priority areas, are there any areas that we missed? And then feedback on that current...
50:22 contractual relationship as we just discussed with Mammoth Lakes Housing. Next slide. And so that concludes our presentation and we're happy to come back to any of the slides if you'd like. All of the information on the focus areas is in the staff report so we can take the slideshow down if that's easier to have the groups just kind of be able to see each other that might be preferred. Okay. Let's do that. Perfect.
50:49 Well, that concludes our presentation. We're happy to answer questions. Thank you. Okay. Thank you, everyone. So we were able to hear the town's housing program highlights. We heard the MLH housing program highlights. And then we touched on the contract focus areas. So as we proceed, perhaps we can stop and take the...
51:18 questions and comments up to and through the third point Town Council identified contract focus areas. I think that, you know, if there's any, you know, the highlights were both organizations highlight of what they feel. So maybe some, not so many questions there, but I know that we really wanted to kind of dig in that the purpose of this is to help to frame the contract going forward. And so if we can talk a little bit about the contract.
51:45 Focus areas, I think that would be useful. So I'll go ahead and ask for questions and comments from our council members, and then we'll go ahead and ask the same Patricia of your board, and then perhaps we can go from there. So I'm going to ask that council member Sauser? Oh, there he is. That council member Sauser start out this conversation kind of focusing on the identified contract focus areas.
52:16 And if you had any questions on either presentation. I have no real questions. And the focus areas that the staff has come up with are legitimate. My questions are mainly in the expense of running those. And I'm not sure when and how we're going to get to that point. But my concerns are the expense of the nonprofit.
52:46 And what that would look like if it was in-house and not nonprofit. And mostly that's, you know, where I'm coming from. I've got so many notes all over my desk. But in terms of the focus areas, you know, they're fine. I understand those. But what would it cost us to provide those versus what we're paying somebody else to provide those? I have always wanted our NGOs to be closer to the town than they currently are.
53:18 Having offices within the town offices instead of paying extra for extra offices is interesting to me, but that is not part of our contract discussion, so I am not sure how to deal with that. But having them in-house so that we are more bonded, if you will, and working together as a cohesive group instead of going down separate paths. Or the other side of the coin is what has been talked about earlier. Do they want to be standalone with no council member on there?
53:48 Okay, Bill, thank you. That's helpful. John, why don't you go ahead here.
54:18 Questions, comments? Thank you. So I'm looking forward to hearing from the MLH board on these five focus areas. As I'm sure you all know, the town council had a preliminary meeting last week where we dove into these things and helped staff to kind of refine them. So these are the things that we're thinking about. And I think that...
54:43 I'm also interested, along with Bill, in potentially kind of restructuring how we do business. Because I think if you look at these five focus areas and the contracts we've had with MLH over the last couple of years, the last iteration of it had, you know, four, three or four or five pages of very, very, very, very specific detailed deliverables, which was an attempt by the town, I think, to really make it, you know,
55:12 Really, really clear with MLH and the town who's doing what and who's or what's responsibilities and what's billable and all the rest of it. And my sense is that even doing something in that super detailed way, even that wasn't really satisfactory to everybody. It didn't really work out that well. And so I'm interested in hearing about the focus areas, but I think also, Andy, I have a question to follow up on Patricia's line of questioning, which has to do with
55:41 I guess I'll just ask it now. The town has not delegated any authorities to MLH in the way that we have with MLR, correct?
55:49 Like MLR is involved with Measure R, Measure U recommendations and things like this. But I'm just thinking when I serve the MLH board, the burden of the Brown Act, the burden of all that stuff, I don't know how that's actually doing anybody any good at this point. So I just wanted to ask, it's kind of an inventory question. Yeah, I don't think the town has delegated things to MLH quite as formally. I think when MLH was formed, there was an idea that some responsibilities that the town
56:17 had been carrying out would kind of shift to MLH. So there's maybe kind of like a structural maybe delegation of some responsibilities, but it's not formal in the same way that it is with MLR. So I think that there are lots of ways that the relationship could be structured. And I guess the challenge for the MLH board and for the town council is just to figure out what works best for everybody. Yeah, because I'm just not, I'm not, at this point, I'm not seeing any value in
56:45 Having a council member appointed to the board, I don't know, I just, I see that puts an enormous burden on MLH and it doesn't have any relationship to the contract for services for the services we would want.
56:58 From MLH, I think there's enormous value in having a nonprofit that's helping, that's working with the town as a partner through a contracted relationship to deliver services. And I don't, so I think that's really valuable. I'm just looking to see if we can lower the burden on having to have that relationship. So I'm interested in hearing about from the board about these five, these five focus areas and then exploring a way to, you know, just have a more efficient.
57:23 Less overhead, more nimble relationship, especially as MLH starts going out into the region and taking on a regional life. And I think it's something we should really talk about. Those are my two and three cents. Thank you. Okay. Thank you, John. Appreciate that. Let's go to Kirk. Kirk is our council member on Mammoth Lakes Housing, so I'm very anxious to hear what he has to say. Kirk? I don't know if I have that much to say. I think the five focus areas are fine.
57:53 I don't, you know, and the relationship, the existing relationship has been working for quite some time. So, you know, I am, I'm comfortable with, again, the existing relationship. All right, Kirk, thank you. Sarah? I'm also interested in kind of talking with the MLH board and Patricia and the council about
58:19 The possibility of MLH being a standalone nonprofit. I think that would be, I think coming out of this meeting, I would really like to get everyone's temperature on that. I said that at the last meeting. But yeah, that's pretty much all I have to add to the discussion at the moment.
58:39 Okay. Thanks, Sarah. As for myself, I agree with what we've talked about here in regards to the focus areas. We looked at them hard last week. It seemed to be sort of a compilation of those things that we really look to MLH to help us with would be most beneficial. And so I'm very pleased with those two. I did look over the current scope and deliverables, and I was puzzled at the...
59:06 Enormous amount of details and points in this contract. It seems like it would be really hard to, you know, provide an evaluation. But we were thinking that perhaps in April, Patricia, you could come back with a point by point sort of summary. I know the summary you did just now was helpful. But if we put something in a contract, it would seem that each one of these kind of deserved a look and a response to.
59:33 Why was put in the contract and what was done to deliver those specific services. That being said, I'm very pleased with, I think, boiling this down, if you will, to a number of focus areas that seem to have made it a little easier to work through it for the year. In regards to the question about being a standalone, not an NGO, I think about the regionality of housing.
1:00:03 And, you know, I think MLH has already done strong work in reaching out to other areas. And I think this would give some further ability to do that, to take the talent and the experience of MLH and use it more in a regional way than just, you know, sort of primarily to the town and then a little bit to other areas. So I'd like to explore that more and see how your board would feel. So, Patricia, being the...
1:00:31 The person there, would you like to walk through your board and get some comments and questions answered? Yeah, sure. Thank you. Let's see. Let's start with Lindsay Barksdale. Hi, good evening, everybody. Thanks for your time. So I think what I wanted to touch on in the focus areas were some I saw right at the end of Sandra's presentation about priorities.
1:01:02 And I just wanted to touch on things that I think are important to me that MLH is doing. So looking at number three on the focus areas list there, seeking out, applying for grants, I see that as fundraising. And I think Mammoth Lakes Housing as a nonprofit with the ability to diversify fundraising. So on that list is...
1:01:25 Not many private donations or I don't see any private donations. So the ability as a nonprofit to raise private funds, I think is very important. Doesn't have as much to do in the contract per se, because that's not something that we might do at the town, but in the future, being creative with our fundraising and figuring out how we can continue to partner with the town and reach out and diversify fundraising.
1:01:52 I think is a really important one. So that number three, bringing in more money to produce new housing units is very important. And then the other one looking down at number five, providing housing services and information. I think this is a really key thing.
1:02:07 That Mammoth Lakes Housing is doing for our community, being an in-person community resource, Patricia, the staff members always are talking at our board meetings about the number of people coming and walking physically through their door, calling on the phone to get information. And one of the things that's not listed in there that I think could be is that I would imagine that Mammoth Lakes Housing
1:02:31 Staff members in the office will see an influx of people and phone calls asking, inquiring about the parcel. And while Mammoth Lakes Housing does not have a formal relationship or a formal role in the parcel development, my guess is when people think parcel housing, they're going to go to the Mammoth Lakes Housing Office. So my guess is that they're really going to ramp up. I think they already have been seeing an increase in.
1:02:57 People inquiring about the parcel. And then also with that, just being Mammoth Lakes Housing, being an advocate for housing and a policy advisor. We by no means create any policy, but I think when Mammoth Lakes Housing was formed, being an advisor to the town council, so separate from the council, being able to really be
1:03:21 Just embedded in housing issues and then being able to help town council create policy is really important. I don't know where that one might fit, but being a policy advisor I think is a big thing for the housing office. And then a little bit aside, because we got off a little bit on talking about our board structure, I think that just for me thinking about Mammoth Lakes Housing, I think our housing board, we can talk about our structure and what's going to benefit.
1:03:51 Our board to have actual designated town council member and a designated board of supervisors or not. We'll kind of figure that out in our future meetings. But having a nonprofit separate because we already are separate from the town. We have no affiliation. We already contract with the town for services. Everything is written up and done. So I think we do want to be really clear in our language at our board meeting on Monday.
1:04:19 Dan Holler chimed in because we were talking about this term NGO. And NGO is not a formal, and please correct me if I'm wrong, but the NGO is just something that how we use, that we use that term locally to talk about what we call our NGOs, but it's not a binding terminology for anybody. So we are a standalone.
1:04:41 Already standalone nonprofit. And I think that gives Mammoth Lakes Housing a nimbleness and an ability to react to housing issues separate from what I see if all of housing sat within the town. We saw that with the emergency rental assistance program. The need arose with the pandemic. People came together to donate money and Mammoth Lakes Housing was able to get that program rolling and really.
1:05:07 Initiate that program and help so many households and landlords. So I think those are probably my things. I think having the ability to diversify fundraising for housing is important. Advising on housing policy, being an in-person community resource and having people walk in the door and being nimble and able to react to the needs and really get things done quickly. Thank you.
1:05:36 Thank you. I'm sorry to interrupt, but Andy, I'm wondering if we could, I just want to make sure that we're clear on these semantics of this terminology around NGO and nonprofit, because it is a specific legal thing when the town council appoints someone to serve on a board. And so, Lindsay, I just want to make sure we're very clear about that. It is a very specific thing, even though the term NGO, I appreciate it's being used kind of loosely, but Andy, could you please just make sure we understand what the differences are?
1:06:03 Sure. The significance of having a council member appointed to the MLH board as a voting member is that it brings MLH under the aegis of the Brown Act. That's really the significance there. And then it has maybe some symbolic value in saying that the town and MLH have an ongoing relationship. But other than that, I mean, as people have said, NGO is not really a term of art. It doesn't mean anything in particular.
1:06:27 MLH is a nonprofit, of course, and MLH will continue to be a nonprofit regardless of the exact structure of the relationship with the town. And I guess I think that in Mammoth, the term NGO is used to connote a very, very close relationship between the town and in particular nonprofit. There's a term that's used a lot in the United Kingdom, quango, a quasi-NGO. And so that could be a...
1:06:57 A convenient shorthand for describing a slightly different kind of relationship if you wanted to have a different kind of relationship. But anyway, to answer the specific question, just having a council member appointed to the MLH board just has Brown Act implications and maybe symbolic implications, but that's about the extent of it. Okay, that's good explanation, Andy. Thank you, because that is always a question that I get.
1:07:18 An NGO just means it's a non-government organization, but it's within the bylaws where it states that there will be people appointed from the council makes it a whole different world then. So, and yeah. Okay, thank you. Yeah, thank you for that, Andy. I think that's helpful. And I'll just turn next to our attorney, Raphael Yakian from Goldfarb-Lipman to weigh in on that as well. Good evening and pleasure to be here.
1:07:48 I just wanted to clarify that the fact that the bylaws of the organization require two members of one member from the Board of Supervisors of Mono County and one member of the Town Council to be members was a decision that was made when the nonprofit Public Benefit Corporation was formed.
1:08:18 The fact that two elected officials sit on the board does not require the organization to follow the Brown Act. It was a insistence at the creation, at the time of creation of the nonprofit that folks, whoever came up with the bylaws thought it would be wise to require the
1:08:48 Brown Act procedures to be followed. That in and of itself is not a requirement of the nonprofit law that governs MLH. And the fact that there are two elected officials does not necessitate the need to follow the Brown Act. That was a decision that was made at the onset by the incorporators of the organization.
1:09:15 At any time, the board of MLH can elect to amend the bylaws to remove that requirement, but I think historically it's not been amended or removed because of a...
1:09:36 Thank you so much.
1:10:05 Well, it's not, I would clarify what Raphael is saying. And by the way, I like Raphael and we've had a good working relationship on various things. So I'm not disputing Raphael at all. But what the Brown Act says is that it will apply to a private entity if it receives funds from a local agency and the membership of the governing body of the nonprofit includes a member of the legislative body of the local agency that's appointed.
1:10:32 As a full voting member by the legislative body. So Raphael's right that it's not having a council member on the MLH board that triggers Brown Act compliance. It is that the council has the ability to appoint a council member to the MLH board as a full voting member that triggers Brown Act compliance. So Raphael's right if the bylaws were to be amended such that there was no longer a reserved seat for a council member or a member of the board of supervisors.
1:11:00 Who was appointed by the council or the board of supervisors, that would bring MLH out from underneath the Brown Act. It's not simply having an elected official on board. It's the manner of appointment that matters. And I, Raphael's nodding. And I think we're all in agreement there. Yeah. Yeah. And so in terms, elected officials can serve on the board of directors of nonprofit organizations. They, it's the appointment that is making a little bit of the problem.
1:11:28 Right. It's the appointment by the council and by the board of supervisors that triggers the Brown Act. Okay, perfect. Thank you, Raphael and Andy. If that's it on that, I'm going to move to Tom Hodges. Yeah, I was just going to layer on there that it is actually a term of our current contract with the town that we...
1:11:55 I'll read it verbatim, provide regular public meeting materials and compliance with the Brown Act using Town Council Chambers and Escribe. So in addition to all the points described or discussed, it is also a material term of our current contract with the town. So if we do decide that we're going to not do that moving forward, obviously we'll need to look at that in addition to our bylaws and so forth. But I think in terms of transparency to the public, it's not such a bad thing.
1:12:24 You know, we're going to go 90% of the way there anyway, as far as we're going to hold normal board meetings and maintain minutes and so on and so forth. So, anyway, we'll see where that goes. I did have a few comments. You know, I just want to add the conversation a bit. I wanted to point out that the five focus areas that are described in the agenda here, you know, really are, by and large,
1:12:54 You know, what we already are covered in our contract, our present contract. They're not materially different. In fact, some of these things are combined, were broken out as two items in our current contract are combined as one. And, you know, there's obviously a lot more subtask detail to sort of these larger headings, if you will, that are describing our current contract. I think council may have a copy of that in their packets. But point being is I'm just trying to point out that
1:13:22 What's being asked as far as focus areas isn't material or different than what we're already doing. And then also that the town's funding of 330K a year under the present contract, MLH, you know, is about two-thirds of our budget, which honestly, it's really largely covering our employee costs. And, you know, so it's, again, it's two-thirds of our budget.
1:13:52 You know, I just, I wanted to kind of highlight or bring this to a point because I know there's a lot of discussion around the edges here of, you know, how do we proceed with MLH and, you know, moving ahead? Do we just pay for contracted services, which I'm reading as we'll just ask for, provide us this service and we'll pay you on a per item basis, T&M, if you will. And, you know, I just, I think that will be very challenging for MLH in our current state because we don't have
1:14:22 Readily, readily available other revenue to supplement our budget to sustain our employees in our, you know, so, you know, I just, I think if that was something that you guys are considering doing, I would honestly say, give us another year, kind of maintain the same contract and we can work where, you know, we have started making some moves towards trying to entertain some other
1:14:50 And, you know.
1:15:16 You know, I think the other thing too, I mean, again, as I look at the staff report and a lot of the things were pointed out as the, you know, the town's highlights of their, their housing programs. I mean, if you kind of read that stuff, a lot of that stuff's in partnership with MLH, you know, MLH is doing a lot of the heavy lifting on a lot of those things. You guys are obviously providing the money, but, you know, then, you know, in large part, the bridge program is, is, you know, all, well, I'm gonna say Nolan's doing a great job for sure.
1:15:42 But patrician staff are doing a lot of work with the transactional side of that, refurbishing the units, getting them turned over and so forth. So just recognize there's a lot of other work going on there that's material. It's real hours. It takes a lot of time and effort to do that stuff. And it's making a huge difference, right? It's providing these currently three units. I think that's a great program. We should continue that for sure. So I wanted to bring that up.
1:16:11 I think the other thing, too, that is important to note and hasn't really been brought up yet. I mean, we do have up to a nine-member board. Currently, we're at eight. We're one short. But, you know, one of the other things we committed to in our update of our strategic plan last year was that we were, you know, going to form working committees that worked. And we're not just coming to a board meeting once a month and weighing in on opinions and decisions. We're actually doing work.
1:16:37 I'm on the development committee and there's four of us on there and we're meeting weekly for a couple hours. We have another number of initiatives where we're doing other work to pursue due diligence on potential development opportunities and talking to outside.
1:17:00 The contractors to assist us possibly with some of these projects. And so there's a lot of legwork going on behind the scenes that I don't know that you guys are aware of. But, you know, that's the benefit, I guess, of this organization is that you are bringing, you know, the expertise of board members to the table as well as our staff. In fact, one of our most recent board members that joined us, Brian D'Andre, is unfortunately not here with us tonight. He's a senior vice president of Century Housing in L.A.
1:17:27 He's got a tremendous amount of expertise and experience and exposure and knowledge. And he's bringing that to the table for Mammoth Lakes. So, you know, I think that's huge. You know, that's a huge resource that's free. That's not costing you guys a dime. So don't lose sight of that. And I think we can build our, we got one more available board seat. I think we can hopefully bring some other expertise to the board as well, you know. So wanted to bring that to light.
1:17:55 Let's see. You know, and I think, I guess that one of the other, you know, questions, operative questions was, you know, what does MLH do that the town can't do in-house on its own? And, or, you know, bring staff inside and do it themselves? I mean, we are CHOTO, we're, you know, community housing development organization that does provide us sort of special status to apply for certain grants that the town can't apply for otherwise. And in many cases, that really reduces the competitive,
1:18:25 Field dramatically in that. And I don't know, maybe, Patricia, afterwards, you can point out what we've applied for and what potential money we might get as a chodo. And then I know the town and during the, I watched the town council meeting last week and in your guys' discussion of this and there was, I think, John, you brought it up and said, wanted to make the point, we're not hiring Mammoth Lakes Housing to do development. And okay, we're not doing, I mean, we are doing some stuff on our own, but not for the town. And I get it.
1:18:52 But I think, you know, we're starting to try to grow our abilities and do that. I mean, obviously, we're working on the access apartments. This other home key project was really something that was brought to us and we brought it, we ran with it very, very fast. And yeah, we're certainly asking the town for contributions, but we also went to the county and Patricia presented to the...
1:19:11 The supervisors and they, you know, got a commitment from them. So there's a lot of legwork going on there with, you know, I really commend Patricia really did a lot of work to pull that together in a very, very short period of time. I mean, literally down to the wire to get our application in on that. So, you know, I think that speaks to our ability to react to an opportunity and be nimble and productive and do something fast. You know, we're on board, you know, housing now. We hear you. That's why that project got our full attention of our development committee. We met.
1:19:40 I don't know, four or five times on that. I spent time walking the property. We've, you know, came up with budgets and pro formas and did a lot of work to make that happen, just so you guys know. So, so yeah, so I, you know, I think, honestly, my opinion, I mean, I've been on the board for several years now. And I don't know, you know, the issue of whether we're a nonprofit, not accountable to Brown Act or.
1:20:06 I mean, I think it's good having representation of council and supervisors on there because it just keeps everybody informed. And, you know, it's certainly, I know that, you know, town funds are spent, you know, to produce units within the town boundaries. But, you know, a lot of employees that work here live out of town, live in Crowley. I've lived in Crowley. I've lived in Swalle Meadows. I've lived in Mammoth. And, you know.
1:20:32 I don't know. I mean, I feel like I'm just a member of the Eastern Sierra community and starts at Lone Pine when I'm driving up the highway and ends when I get up to Carson City. But, you know, it is a regional issue and I get that part and maybe we can start pushing some of the other governmental entities that we're, you know, serving to contribute, you know, that is something I think we can certainly work on and it's probably an area we should work on. Because, you know, at the end of the day,
1:21:01 There is limited private property. There's, you know, the town doesn't have very many empty parcels left to develop. You know, the last one was, the big one was the parcel. So we are, you know, we have to, you know, and we don't want to sprawl, but by the same token, we got to look at all opportunities within the county. And let's be honest, people commute from Bishop to Mammoth to work. So, you know, again, I think in that respect, we are, you know, we do need to be very regional in our view of housing and how we're going to deal with this in the coming.
1:21:30 Uh, months and years here as we face these issues. So, let me make sure I didn't miss anything else here I hadn't made note of.
1:21:39 Um, yeah, uh, one last point. Um, I did want to say just in terms of, you know, there was some frustration, concern about roles and responsibilities. And, you know, we always kind of go back to what was our, you know, document we want to work from, from strategic standpoint, being the Community Housing Action Plan, the CHAP.
1:21:59 you know that was prepared in 2017 so that thing's pretty long in the tooth
1:22:04 And, you know, it's my recommendation that we reconvene and update to the CHAP jointly and refresh it, re-vet it and refine it, add more detail. There's a lot more things we know now we didn't know then. And then just do, you know, do another new matrix of responsibilities, who's taking the lead and so forth. And so anyways, you know, I'm blathering on here, but I, you know, I do think that MLH is...
1:22:33 Does have, you know, some very good expertise that is supplements the town's expertise and is an overall benefit to the community. And honestly, you know, in my view, 330 current funding rate is a pretty low spend for what you're getting for the dollars. And I don't know, maybe, Patricia, I'll shut up here and maybe you could chime in a little bit on.
1:22:59 How the Choto, our Choto status does give us some priority access to some grants that the town would otherwise have access to. And that's it for me. Sorry, I got so long winded there. Oh, that's perfect, Tom. Thank you. I think I mentioned this a little bit earlier, but our Choto status, there's only 21 Chotos in the state. And so when the state sets aside funding for a Choto set aside.
1:23:25 Those 21 entities can compete for funding. Now, not all 21 entities will compete in the same cycles because they may or may not have a project that's ready for funding. And so that reduces the pool even more. And I'll say that our 2019 CHOTO application for home funds, we got verbal confirmation that it was funded for access apartments. And that's partially because in that round, not a lot of other CHOTOs applied.
1:23:54 While we may not have had the most competitive application, we only had to compete against a certain number of competitors in order to secure an award. And I'll say, as another example, we did partner with the town on a first-time homebuyer grant that we were not awarded, partially due to competitiveness, but partially also because the predetermined scoring put us at a disadvantage.
1:24:23 And so because every jurisdiction in the state applied, the town obviously didn't make the cut. And so that's an example of when it's hard to compete against everybody versus if you're a CHOTO competing against a smaller section of the population, you have a competitive advantage. I'm going to jump to Agnes Vianzen, and then we have Tony Perkins, and then I think that's all of our board that's present.
1:24:54 Okay. Hi, everyone. I also have a pile of notes here that I'll try and make sense of. So, looks like you're ready for it after, Tom. Okay. So, I guess, in terms of the focus areas, for me, it all makes sense. I mean, I've now, I think I'm coming up on my fourth year as serving on the MLH board. I think they're pretty clear. I think MLH is...
1:25:24 Delivering, at least in part, to most of it, most all of this. And as Patricia highlighted, there's simply the existing expertise and that through Patricia and Diane and the staff and as well as the board, part of how Tom lined out there.
1:25:49 And I want to go back. We don't have to bring it up, but Patricia had a great slide about all the stakeholders and lots of different entities that are all working towards housing. We all know how big of an issue it is locally. And whether we want to or not, MLH becomes a place where folks go to ask questions or look for guidance.
1:26:17 And it's not even, you know, it's not necessarily in all the things that fall under MLH, but with an organization that's called Mammoth Lakes Housing, it'll come up on Google or whatever, not necessarily the parcel wait list or something like that. And so I think, you know, a unified goal for all of us could just be how to help those find that information easier.
1:26:44 However, that might be. And again, there's a lot of stakeholders who are all working on housing together. Yeah. And so, you know, and that also just would help the public with other things that are important. So how to get how, you know, folks are looking for housing, they're, you know, choosing maybe to sleep in their vehicles or they have to. The tenants write workshops that Patricia provides.
1:27:15 There's just a lot of things. And I was a longtime seasonal person before I moved to Mammoth full-time where I was very lucky to be able to get a place under a short sale a long time ago, and there's no way I'd be able to do it now.
1:27:33 You know, that struggle is still very clear to me when I would come out of a seasonal job. And, you know, there was no Facebook, there was no, not even the bulletin board at the post office. And I would call the first out on Mammoth Times and just sight unseen, like, I have the deposit, will you please pick me? And, you know, the amount that that now has.
1:27:59 Thank you so much.
1:28:31 No, per se, like how much of the deliverables has increased or not. You know, I do know that the revenue and the programming that Mammoth Lakes Housing is managing has gone up. You know, we, Patricia showed that it, you know, currently it's at $530,000. There are a couple very exciting things on the horizon and Mammoth Lakes Housing could potentially be
1:29:01 Growing, you know, to a much larger revenue, you know, we're diversifying those revenue streams. Let's call it five years that maybe Mammoth Lakes Housing is managing over $1 million in programs. I mean, we've got the Project Home Key, we've got other, you know, there's just other big things that I think that's the direction that I'm sort of hearing that the...
1:29:29 You know, the 85% that's coming from the town in some ways is not going to take up the biggest chunk of Mammoth Lakes housing, but right now it is. You know, but as a fellow director of a nonprofit, there's definitely no way that I am clocking in and working eight hours a day and that's it. And I definitely know that Patricia and her staff are not doing that as well.
1:29:58 Legal reasons that maybe telling people can't do that, but I'll move on before I get in trouble. Another highlight, it's been mentioned, it was very brief, but Mammoth Lakes Housing is working on their own to get additional staffing, trying to take advantage of this opportunity through Alpine and Mono County Social Services.
1:30:22 That would provide another staff member, and I think that's pretty huge. The workload that our current staff has, like we said, as a board, we're very dedicated, we're very participatory in trying to help out where we can to, you know, help out with some of that overhead, help out with some of that capacity. The fundraising is a big deal, raising over $200,000.
1:30:50 As a nonprofit. And then, you know, simply that that investment as a nonprofit, like that is going right back into our community. It isn't, you know, it's governed by a board. Let me just check my notes. I know that was a lot and a little bit all over the place, but those were the big things that I had for now. Thank you. Thank you, Agnes. I feel so bad I didn't have a slide.
1:31:25 Commending our board and all the time that they put into dedicating towards Mammoth Lakes Housing and the work that we do, but I know Tom and Agnes both mentioned it, so thank you. We just have one last board member, Tony Perkins, if you have comments. Thanks, everybody. Most of what I wanted to say has already been said, so I'll try not to reiterate too much.
1:31:52 If the town wanted to...
1:32:21 changed that relationship, that we were still independent but structured tighter under the town, then that would create more details and red tape that would be hard to overcome. And if the town wanted to terminate our relationship, that would pretty much be the end of Mammoth Lakes housing, which would cause a whole other world of complications.
1:32:48 If that's something the town is seriously considering, I would recommend some kind of maybe five, six years to transition out of that. And we could try to change our business structure and change the model of the business so we could maintain. But at this point in time, we wouldn't last.
1:33:13 And with all due respect, if the town did try to pursue what we're doing in-house, it wouldn't happen. It wouldn't be as efficient. You wouldn't have the community support. You wouldn't have the donations. You wouldn't have the volunteer time. You wouldn't have the grant funding. There's a lot of stuff that Mammoth Lakes Housing offers that wouldn't be able to.
1:33:41 Be done in-house by the town, even with the most expertise that you could possibly get from in-town staff. So I think our relationship is good as it is. I think Patricia did a great job exemplifying everything that we've done for the town. I think the bridge program shows that the...
1:34:06 Town is kind of understanding the deed restricted housing program and the value of that. And we're doing a great amount to overcome that. And I think Mammoth Lakes housing is really the face of the community for Mammoth Lakes. And when anybody thinks of housing and affordable housing, this is the first place they go. I personally live in Bishop because I can't afford to live in Mammoth.
1:34:36 I work continually in Manage sometimes, and I work for minimum wage, and it costs 25 bucks in gas to get up there and back, or it takes three or four hours to take the bus up there and back, but that's the sacrifice I'm going to have to make, although the Mammoth Lakes housing is expanding our reach into the region.
1:35:04 I think that's something that the town should be appreciative of rather than thinking, well, they're not focusing as much of our attention on the town. But if we were to focus our priorities outside of the town and let the town handle what needs to be done in the town, we would just be picking up after the mess created by Mammoth with all due respect because Bishop wouldn't be so expensive.
1:35:35 If there weren't a resort community just 40 miles away and the regional housing wouldn't cost as much as it currently does. So the best thing we can do is focus on Mammoth Lakes and provide our services everywhere else we can in the region. Thank you, Tony. I think that's everyone from our board that's present this evening. We do have...
1:36:07 I believe three board members who weren't able to attend this evening. And so hopefully if we have another meeting, we could get everybody at the table. Okay. Thank you, Patricia. That was, I think that was really helpful. And now to Sandra, is there a direction that you would like to go at this time? Do you have what you need for staff to, you know, pursue along with MLH a contract for next year? I mean, I think we would like to hear from the, sorry, from the council members if
1:36:42 A number of the different board members raised some items that they think would be appropriate to be in the contract, and I think we would want to hear some feedback from the council members on those items. But before we do that, I think I'll stop and ask for public comment. Jamie, is there anyone waiting to give public comment on this? No, there is not. Okay. All right. So, okay. Let's circle back around then.
1:37:12 If there's any council member that would like to have anything else to comment on here, if you'd just raise your hand or indicate you'd like to speak. Sarah, thank you. Just a couple of things, Linda. Okay. Yes, Mammoth Lakes Housing may do a wonderful job. I am having a problem with the NGO model in the town of Mammoth Lakes, and it's a model I once supported. When we started the NGO program, it was because nonprofits at that point in time,
1:37:42 Could operate not just more efficiently, but for far less money than government organizations. There are two sets of people that I really have to answer to. One of them are the taxpayers, which I hear from on a regular basis. And the other is our town staff. We've created a town staff that is great. But when our NGOs start raising the pay of their employees, and I'm not picking on their employees for not doing a good job here.
1:38:11 Above and beyond what the town pay scale is, with pay and with bonuses and everything else, then I get the hit from both staff and taxpayers. We can do this for less. We can do this better. It is like the NGOs have lost sight of where the money is coming from and how close a guard we need to keep on it. And I'm really having a problem with that. All three of our main NGOs have staff.
1:38:41 They're making more than what the rate for that similar job would be in the town of Mammoth Lakes. If I'm incorrect, somebody can tell me so. I don't have an exact breakdown of what the salaries are at MLH, but I do have their budget numbers for how much they spend on their two employees or two and a half employees or even three employees. And it comes out to more than what a light job at the town would be.
1:39:09 Tony, you know you're working for minimum wage, and I have done that for many years in Mammoth, and I appreciate it, but somehow we have lost track of being fiscally conservative with the NGOs, and I don't know how to get around that. I don't know how to reel that back in at this point without making changes. Our five points are great points. The things Mammoth Lakes Housing does are important things, but somehow if...
1:39:37 We hire an outside consultant or somebody else and the cost can go way down and I'm not getting calls from people saying, hey, gee, man, what's going on over there? Then I'd be much more comfortable. So that's just sort of where I'm coming from. That's where the idea of paying, you know, hourly rates to NGOs like we do to MLTPA as an example versus just giving the money out there.
1:40:04 And there are things that tax money cannot be used for. And we have to very carefully watch that, you know, when staff time is spent outside of what the Mammoth Lakes tax dollars can be used for, we have to be reticent of that. We have to make sure that in your budget, it appears differently. So that's my rant. And I'm not picking on anybody specifically here. It's just a problem for me. Okay, thank you. Thank you, Bill, for being clear about how you're feeling. Thank you. I think Sarah?
1:40:34 Want to go ahead? Yeah, I actually am glad, Bill, that you jumped in because I do have to say, you know, I met with, I'm now serving on the board of MLR and I met with Kim and Craig and I was like, I got to be honest, guys, I'm not a huge fan of the NGO structure the way we have it now. So I do relate to what Bill's saying. I also think that I'm not ready to
1:41:03 And I also have to say, like, I do notice that no one really talks about MLT in the same way that we talk about MLR and MLH. Like, we're not like, okay, you guys need to be on your own now. You know, I just really need to remind us all that, like, if we're talking about the NGO's relationship with the town as a whole, as a philosophy.
1:41:32 We don't treat MLT the same, and I need us to be cognizant of that. I think that if we are going to re-examine these structures in a year from now, we need to lump MLT in the same boat, because they are the same. So that being said, I hear what the board members for MLH are saying. I don't feel, I'm absolutely,
1:42:02 Interested in entertaining the idea of having these entities be standalone, but I don't know if I'm not ready to do that this year with this contract, but I think that this should be a discussion that we, I think that this is the direction I would like to move in, sort of along the lines of what Bill is suggesting, so, but if we do move in that direction, MLT does not get to be exempt from that.
1:42:32 And also, regarding, I thought Agnes brought up a great point, or actually, I think it was Lindsay, the parcel, it's true, people are going to be coming to MLH asking, how do I get on the list for the parcel? I think that's something we kind of missed in our...
1:42:56 In our focus points, I think that we should explore how we can utilize MLH to put people in the pipeline to that project, even though they didn't have a hand in developing it. So I think that's all I have right now. All right, thank you. Thank you, Sarah. John, you had your hand up a while back. Yeah, and I think this is going to be a real challenge for you, Madam Mayor, and for the town managers to try to reconcile this stuff, because there's a lot of...
1:43:25 There's a direction that's emerging here. I don't know if we're there yet, but there's some very important things that we need to talk about. So the first thing is I strongly support the town, the refinement of this NGO model, which is what we're talking about. And Bill, being our historian, some of us don't call ourselves historians, but we were around when a lot of this stuff got started. We understand.
1:43:54 The context of the time and why all this happened at the time, but we need to be evolutionary with this. And the bottom line has got to be that we're delivering value to the public funds that pay for these things and we're delivering value for the community. And so I want to emphasize that the value is the thing that has to be measured. And the dollars may be one thing, the value may grossly exceed what the dollars are being invested in these things.
1:44:21 So to that end, I think it's very important that the town have a contractual relationship with an outside vendor that is providing a variety of services that can be described in these, say, these five points we've talked about that can act nimbly, quickly on behalf of the interests of their mission, which in this point happens to be Mammoth Lakes Housing. I think that's extremely important. However, I do not, I have not
1:44:50 As a council member, I have not gleaned any value from having a council member being appointed to the MLH board over the last couple of years. I just, I don't see what the value is. And I think it's important to, it's a high administrative burden for an organization to have to be conforming with the Brown Act. And I don't know why, I think it's a great opportunity to say,
1:45:17 We don't have to do that anymore. Great. We're still going to be a transparent organization. Those are our values. But we don't have to go through all the administrative burden of having to do that because I honestly don't think that's bringing any value to anybody. Someone can correct me if I'm wrong, but I just don't see it. So I think that could be an enormous administrative savings.
1:45:38 For MLH. And I think it could really help you guys to do the things that you really focus on doing the great work that you're doing without having to worry about that burden. Because I'm not, as a council member, I'm not getting any value out of it. I'm just one person, just to say that. The other thing is, I think it's going to be a real challenge in this rebranding thing. And it's not something to be taken lightly. Because, you know, as people have said, it's a branded thing, Mammoth Lakes Housing. I go there to get my information. How it's going to be a tricky,
1:46:08 It's going to be a tricky needle to thread. But this region is in desperate need of the kinds of services and the kind of work that you guys can do. And when I was on the MLH board, that was a key part of the strategic plan that we talked about. And I think it's, we need to, it's not our job to encourage you guys to do what you want to do, but it's a huge venue and it's going to be a need that's only going to become more so.
1:46:35 So those are my two points. I think I don't I don't think I don't need unless someone has a kind of compelling argument for keeping a council member on the board.
1:46:44 I don't think it's worth the administrative burden. I don't see it. And I think moving to a model where the town contracts with MLH for specific services, as we do now, based on the needs of the town, I think we can make that transition. I don't think it's going to make an enormous, it shouldn't make an enormous hit to your budget. And I think, again, the frustrations with the budgets are,
1:47:05 Five pages of attachments. And to Linda's point, Patricia, I mean, it's like we've got these deliverables that we contract with, and we're not getting reporting on those deliverables that we contract with. And it's frankly frustrating. And I think let's just let you guys contract with you guys for services, do what you're doing. You can raise money for your...
1:47:27 Things that you're doing has got nothing to do with the town. It may have things to do with the mission, but I think we can get to a leaner, more efficient, and frankly, a relationship is going to benefit all parties in a much better way. So those are my thoughts. Thank you. Okay. Thank you, John. Kurt, let's talk a little bit here. Thank you. When I look at the agenda bill, I look at the...
1:47:54 The focus areas, and I agree with them. And then I look at the scope of the work with the deliverables in the eight areas. And, you know, with the parcel coming up, there's going to be a larger workload. So I agree with the relationship that we currently have. And I support the relationship that we currently have. Thank you.
1:48:26 All right. Thank you. I have just a few comments to make. I appreciate everybody speaking frankly here. It's a good place for that. When I first became aware and studied and looked into the whole NGO relationship that we had created back when, it became clear that that was created for very good reasons. It served us well. And I saw us also beginning to sort of transit from those immediate
1:48:56 Structure that we had put together. I also, Sarah and John and Bill, have heard the community talk about the salaries and the prices that we were paying. And my question to staff was, when we put these together, why didn't we put a guardrail on that? When you are the person with the money contracting with another entity, you can put guardrails on all sorts of things to keep from what happened because
1:49:24 Those were actions taken by those boards, not by the town of Mammoth Lakes, but they were taken by the boards to, you know, compensation-wise. All right, what's done is done. We can't go back and fix that now, but certainly going forward, we can be more cognizant of that. A contract with an entity such as Mammoth Lakes Housing that prescribes sort of, this is the things we would like you to do.
1:49:47 And figuring out the payment scale around that is something that I think is very doable. But it also puts a bigger responsibility on the board of these entities to oversee and to carefully look after the mission of the organization and the compensation and the money piece of it.
1:50:11 So I'm in favor of that, but I'm not in favor of just, you know, pulling rugs out from under people. MLH has done a good job in good faith with us. And I think that we would, you know, certainly want to be a party, the party working with MLH or any other of our NGOs to establish themselves if the decision is made by the board that they're interested in pursuing the nonprofit model.
1:50:37 If I were in MLH's position, I would like to have that sort of freedom, if you were. I'm a nonprofit. I can go out and do all kinds of different things. I'm not completely beholding to one entity for everything. You know, we are the one entity primarily that's doing this. And on the other hand, though, I want this to be the partnership that leaves them in a stronger position even than they are now. Because I think that could be accomplished. They have a lot of experience. The two employees there are very, very talented.
1:51:06 Wonderful experience. I think it would be exciting for them to be able to look in other directions and look for expanding, you know, and using their influence and their role. And like I said, for the entire region, I think they bring a lot of expertise and the board too. The board is very, very talented too. I was very impressed to hear all the board members speak on this tonight. It was nice to do that. So that's what I have to say about that.
1:51:33 Okay, so we have sort of accomplished the steps in the agenda. Sandra, would you like to talk about where else we can go now with this? Linda, just real quick, I see Lindsay's got her hand up. I don't know if you can see that. Oh, no, I can't. No, I can't. Yes, please, go ahead. Thank you. I don't know if we're able to have a bit of dialogue, but I wanted to clarify what I hear is kind of two concerns of town council, just so that we as board members are clear.
1:52:03 Thinking about this, I hear the council talking about moving toward a contract model with Mammoth Lakes Housing. But I guess in my mind, that's what we already have. So what I heard that might be different in the council's version of a contract model, because what I heard earlier is, Linda, you spoke about already our...
1:52:25 So I guess I would ask the council what we already have a contract. So what needs to be different to
1:52:55 Make the council feel more comfortable. So, Lindsay, if I could just speak to the point I made. I think it's my specific change would be that there's no longer a council appointment to the board of MLH. I think it's unnecessary and I think it's an unnecessary burden to MLH. So I would just remove that piece of it and then just focus on the contract for services that we currently have with you and continue to refine that as the needs of the towns change. And I think.
1:53:24 I think, you know, one of the things I think I really want to come back to Tom Hodges' point about the CHAP. Pre-COVID, we were in one housing situation. Whatever we're in now is something that the CHAP couldn't even have dreamed in their worst nightmares.
1:53:42 So we have a lot of work to do to get into this new iteration of housing that we're dealing with. So we need to get onto that. And I think anything that we can do to lessen the administrative burden on MLH, to focus on a very clearly defined set of deliverables and a contractual relationship, I think that's the way to go. So I just wanted to make that clear.
1:54:05 Yeah, thank you, John. And, Lindsay, let me try to clarify a little bit what I meant. I meant that the contract, as I read it now, is very, very, you know, detailed. I mean, like, kiddingly, I said, you know, to myself, okay, so where's sharpen your pencils? And, you know, it was just, it really seemed laborious because in a good contract relationship, the fundee gives a point by point description of what each one of those things was and how it was performed. Or we didn't do that this year, or we, you know.
1:54:35 And that would be so difficult to do because there's so many, many points. What I meant was a detailed contract in that if we wanted a specific thing done by MLH, we would be able to say that. But these five points that I know staff worked really hard on to try to kind of condense the relationship between Mammoth Lakes Housing and the town, I think captures that really well. And as Tom said, a lot of those points are sort of repeated in the present contract.
1:55:04 And in different ways and sort of condensing those down into this, I think would be the best explanation for this. So I hope that helped clarify a little bit. Yes, thank you. And I think that's, it's good for our board and for us giving staff direction as well. I do have one more question and John, it's kind of to your point. Lindsay, can I just clarify on that item? I think it would be great to have a summary sheet with some buckets of focus areas, but.
1:55:31 The intent of having a detailed contract like that is because oftentimes we're asked to do more work outside of the scope of our contract, and that puts a burden on staff who's already performing 100%, more than at 100% capacity. And so...
1:55:46 Having a detailed contract like that really came from the process we went through with MLT, you know, really defining their deliverables and then having a similar contract for MLH and making sure that we weren't asking MLH to do things outside of the scope of the contract without additional compensation. And I think, Patricia, that's a great point, but I think to Linda's point again, if we have and if MLH desires to have a detailed contract like that, it would be very helpful to get reporting on that detailed contract, which
1:56:16 We don't get. So it's, I mean, it's how do we kind of evolve this to get something that's going to be helpful for all parties. Yeah, and Patricia, I mean, I trust that our staff and, you know, yourself and your board can kind of boil that down to be the larger points. And if the pay, you know, for services is a little bit different than it is now, eventually, maybe that would work fine. You know, we could kind of,
1:56:46 Somewhere between those two things I think would be more beneficial and easier to manage for MLH and more clarity and what is being done with the money that we're funding, what is being done actually. So I think it's just an improvement of a model that maybe we've just sort of outgrown at this point. I think that we can do things better than we used to and we can just continue to refine it as we go and maintain the partnership relationship with MLH.
1:57:17 Okay, so back to, oh, yeah, I cut, sorry, I cut Lindsay off, so I didn't know she had another time. Oh, okay, sorry, go ahead. Well, I did just want to talk about our board makeup again, because I wanted to, so John asked, you know, what is the value of having a council member on our board? He said he doesn't see the value. And I guess for me as.
1:57:40 And I guess so that's maybe where
1:58:10 This disconnect is happening because what I really appreciate having a council member on our board, as I do with our board of supervisor, is the information that we get. We get information in the board member report directly from what's going on with the council to having to do with housing. And then we're able to talk about it and figure it out. So I guess for me, it was that efficient pass of information. So my question would be, can we get that going? Is it necessary? Is it needed?
1:58:38 If it's not needed, then certainly let's change our model. Yeah, let's take a look at that. Okay, thank you. Is there anybody else from either board? Tom's got his hand. Hi, Tom. Hi. Real quick, I just wanted to try to get clarification on paid for services idea. I'm having a little confusion here about how that would actually be executed. And just in terms of...
1:59:06 Paying for services. So, I mean, the current contract has a very detailed list and task of services. And then it's just 330 grand a year paid monthly or whatever it is. And I understand the, you know, disillusionment about not getting details back on did I get, you know, did you do all that stuff? So how would that be structured? Because I'm just trying to understand how are we going to, you know,
1:59:36 Put structure that into a new contract where it's you're going to say, well, these are things we'll pay for, but we're going to pay by the hour at this rate for doing that. You do that task and provide the deliverables one by one and without a long term commitment. How's that work? What are your guys thoughts? Well, I see our town manager has raised his hand, so we're going to we're going to let Dan have a minute here. Thank you, Linda.
2:00:05 Let me address a couple of issues that have come up in this. And with the appointment of a council member or a board member, and Andy can correct me if I'm wrong here, but that creates MLH that operate as a legislative body. And that's where the Brown Act comes in because they have to follow those rules. For example, the committee structure that you utilize fairly effectively is probably on the edge of violating the Brown Act in terms of what a standing committee is.
2:00:35 It's not just how you create it, but it's actually the functioning work. And as Tom mentioned, it's great. They've got a development committee that's out there looking at this stuff. It's an ongoing area. Normally you would assign it, go look at this project, bring us back a recommendation, and then it's dissolved. So you run into those definitions of art that govern a legislative body. And I'll say a lot of the nonprofit model, the NGO model, I might use the words interchangeably here for a minute.
2:01:04 The whole idea was that flexibility to do exactly the lot of things that you were just speaking about. And if we could create that flexibility, I think that adds value. So you can go do those things. And ideally, if that committee is meeting and going to walk on a property, frankly, that should be an agendized item and everybody should know what they're doing, which, again, I think would limit some of the functions that are happening there. So that would be one of the things there. And also, having an elected official to the...
2:01:34 Board can actually be a benefit and the board can always appoint them. Then it's a matter of not the council appointing, but the board asking, hey, council member staff, you've got a great history on MLH. Do you want to stay on this board? And then you can do that versus the town council going, well, we want to change members or we want to move people around. There's some value in that potentially that way. So think of that in terms of acting as a legislative body that really does create
2:02:04 operational things that are not as nimble as maybe you would like or as it's been utilized even in some cases that may or may not be quite on the edge, put it that way. When we talk about, and Andy could weigh in on the legislative body structure and how you do ad hoc committees, which is not actually in the language of the act.
2:02:28 It's short-term, very focused type committees. It's not really an ad hoc term. Let me pause there. I saw Andy pop his head on or face up. I was just going to say, I mean, I don't think that this is the setting for the town to try to give MLH advice on how to follow the Brown Act. I'm sure that Raphael can certainly give you advice on how to follow the Brown Act. I mean, a lot of committees are subject to the Brown Act, but I don't think we want to get into that there. But I wanted to answer one question that Tom posed.
2:02:58 You know, a way that a fee-for-service structure could work would be for the town to say during budget planning, here are the things we'd like you to do. Can you please give us a price quote for doing these things? And it could be per hour, could be, or it could be we want you to do X activity. Please tell us how much you need to do that for the upcoming fiscal year. And so a way to do it would be to say we want you to do these five things.
2:03:24 How much will it cost to do each of those five things, add those numbers together, maybe there's some haggling, and then that's the amount that the town provides to MLH. That's a way to do it, or it could be an hourly rate, could be a hybrid of the two, could be an hourly rate with a not to exceed, but I think that something like that could be the general idea, and just kind of conceptually, and this is a discussion that the town's had with other NGOs in town, it's sort of one model is
2:03:52 We want you to continue operating. And so we will pay for your operations kind of broadly. And here are some things we'd like you to do versus getting a little bit more granular and saying, we want you to do these specific things and we will pay you to do these specific things. That latter one is kind of the essence of the fee for service model. And I was going to mention the same thing. We actually have those structures out there. We have some that are very much on an hourly rate basis. For example, we do have a contract with the Chamber of Commerce.
2:04:21 Which is a non-profit. They're not a legislative body. And we have a kind of a general support to the business community model and then a particular piece on housing that we have in their agreement. And that can be reviewed annually. But it's a set dollar amount for those services, knowing it takes that to manage it, as it was just mentioned there. We kind of do that with MLH already. We have a flat amount of $336,000 a year we're currently paying. And then if we do a grant,
2:04:50 So the actual payments from the town in some of those areas are more service-based type.
2:05:18 Payments already. And then there's a dollar amount that we have the broader categories, et cetera, through. And so I think that's kind of the model. It's a hybrid model that we already utilize and how we fund MLH. We talk about this contract here mainly in terms of the one dollar amount, but we have two other ways at this point of how dollars does pass from the town to MLH and help support.
2:05:42 The organization. It's not like it's hiring another person or in that nature. It's going back in to help the organization function. The other item I wanted to touch on was like the parcel work. I think one of the disconnects there is actually the Pacific Company has not said that we need MLH to do anything at this point. They don't need to hire MLH to provide a service. If we have an interest list or a wait list and you're building that,
2:06:11 There's nothing that prevents MLH from passing that off to the Pacific Company and say, by the way, we have, I think it's 130 people who qualify for low-income housing here. Take a look at these. Can you do that? You already gathered this wait list. It far exceeds, I think, any product that we have out there, whether it's the Aspen Village or...
2:06:37 The Star Apartments or the Jefferies or fill in the blank of the other projects out there. And so there's, I think, kind of a misconception there going, you can create a wait list or an interest list and pass that to Pacific companies anytime you like. I think the request has come up, we will do that, but we want you to pay us to collect that information. To some degree, in our agreement with the contract, you already correct that wait list. You have...
2:07:04 I think the other night it was 130 people on there, so it's definitely grown as people are looking for housing. So I don't think anybody disagrees on the need for expanded housing opportunities. I think we get hung up on that side of it saying we'll do that, but we want to be paid or we want to have a different agreement or we want something else to come into that. But it's work that's already being done. I think that's a great point, Dan, about the Pacific companies not needing Mammoth Lakes housing.
2:07:31 And the reason why they don't need Mammoth Lakes Housing is because they're contracting with a nonprofit from outside of the area who will collect a fee from the parcel and invest that fee from the parcel into their work in other communities. And I think that's why our board would argue that the parcel does need Mammoth Lakes Housing. And, you know, that fee could go to support our work, you know, working with clients directly on the ground in the community. And that fee from the parcel.
2:08:01 Development could go to fund our staff to do that. And so I think- If you hire additional staff. Yeah, talking about funding of nonprofits and nonprofit salaries, we're funding an entity that's outside of our community. Right. And that's their model as the developer of that project. We don't control that.
2:08:22 But to the extent that we can benefit people in the community. Oh, well, yeah, the town could certainly advocate to have a local nonprofit partner. That's actually the model that's preferred in most developments across the country. Ultimately, it's not our choice. Well, you could require it. We could advocate, yes, but working through that. But at this point, we're off topic there. But the idea being, well, I want to get back with the idea if someone's asking to be on a list of an interest in affordable housing, we're doing that.
2:08:53 The question is, what do we do with that list and how do we get it out to where we have housing? And that's the bridge, that's the partnership with the bridge program. You have a list of X number of people who are potentially qualified to be going into that program and then work with them, et cetera, and it passes through. And we're not like, our current contract allows that to happen. The only other differential in the pay would be if there's a commission on the brokerage activity.
2:09:21 So anyway, a little more detail there, but I think we could work through a lot of this pretty quickly sitting down and coming up with a couple of different options. It probably benefits both sides of the contractual relationship. Okay, so next steps here. Sandra, you're running this item. What would you like to see happen next here? I think, as I kind of mentioned previously, I think if there are any focus areas that the...
2:09:52 Or I guess any comments from the Mammoth Lexington Board on additional focus areas, additional work tasks. There was a handful mentioned that the town council would like to see incorporated into the contract. I think we'd probably like to hear that tonight. If there was something that kind of resonated with any of the council members, like, yes, we need to add that. That's really important. We'd like to hear that. And I think then the next steps is, like Dan mentioned,
2:10:17 For the town and Mammoth Lakes Housing to work together to come back with a draft contract. And so, I mean, I think that's kind of for the contract piece, I'd like to hear that. I think I heard, I, in a correct way I'm wrong, but I think I heard pretty clearly that the town council would like staff to do some analysis on the possibility of removing a town council member, that appointment, you know, removing that kind of relationship.
2:10:44 So we can do some additional analysis on that and bring that back to the council. Like I said earlier, we don't have all the answers on that, but we can do that. So I think for me, those are the two items I'm looking for. And I don't know, Dan, if there's other, no, Dan, shake his head no. So I think that would be a good kind of close of this discussion. Linda, if I may? Yes, sir. As one councilman, sorry, John, I jumped on you. You got your yellow hand up. I just spoke. Sorry.
2:11:14 I think a lot of information has been given to staff, and staff and Patricia are the ones that are going to have to hash this out. Personally, I don't care if we have an appointed town council member or not. I think it's not a bad thing to keep them tied that way so we at least have some modicum of control over tax dollars. But at this point, what I'd like to see, I think we're beating a dead horse here, is for Sandra and Nolan to...
2:11:43 Okay, thank you, Bill. John?
2:12:15 The detail that's within establishing a relationship where it's clear who is doing what, that's well beyond what any council member individually or as a body should get anywhere near. So I definitely support what Bill's saying. Staff needs to get in there, figure this thing out, who's going to be doing what. But again, I have a problem with the appointment of a council member. I think that the town's obligation to the taxpayer is through the contract. It's through the contract and it's through the agreement.
2:12:45 And I think it creates a false expectation that just because you have a council member on the board of a nonprofit, you necessarily, as an appointment, you're necessarily getting any higher level of accountability. I just don't see it. And I've seen that from a, I've been on the MLH board, I've been on different boards, I just don't see it. So those are, Sandra, those are my two cents on that topic. Thank you. Yeah, and I just wanted to- I'm sorry, Raphael has his hand up. Yeah, perfect. Thank you.
2:13:14 Sure. Thank you. I just want to be clear that going forward, if the town has a recommendation about the composition of the board, that it be offered as a recommendation ultimately as the governing board of the nonprofit has the discretion.
2:13:38 to act accordingly. And so, you know, the difficulty here is, of course, as one of the major funders of MLH, MLH doesn't want to do anything that will create strife between the town and MLH. So if there is a recommendation for
2:14:03 There to be a change in structure, it would be helpful to MLH's board so that they can then consider it. But I think that is a consideration and something that ultimately is at the discretion of the MLH board. And frankly, some of the problems that I think Andy pointed out is it would take...
2:14:30 Thank you so much.
2:15:00 Overcome the hurdle that has been identified, we would also need to approach the county to take a similar action. And so just wanted to be clear that amending the bylaws, changing the board composition would be a multi-step process and just wanted to put that out there. So thank you. Thanks for the clarification. Thank you. Thank you.
2:15:27 Okay, so we were asked tonight to discuss these items. I think we've done that quite well. I think the next steps then is for the town of Sandra and her team to meet with Mammoth Lakes Housing and begin this discussion around the finer points of the contract, the finer points of where a new contract that goes into effect July 1.
2:15:52 Right. Is that they're on the same fiscal year? Yeah, that'll be the same. Yeah, same. So I think that another way to keep the board informed for Mammoth Lakes Housing is to, you know, exercise the ability to come and do a quick little update to the council at any time. New things that come up. I mean, I think that, you know, if we didn't have
2:16:18 Representative, appointed representative of Athletics Housing, who would be responsible for bringing those comments and updates back to the council. There's other ways to do that to make sure that everyone stays in close step because it's important, I think, that we understand what each other is doing and that communication. And Sandra, I think you and Patricia communicate on a regular basis as far as I know. Yeah, so if we have those actions to take and
2:16:48 We did talk about would it be useful to come back in April with sort of an update staged against the contracts as it is now. And that I think would also facilitate eliminating points that were not necessary. And as we do the new contract outline, I think that would be helpful. So I'll let you, I think you guys can talk about that in your meetings and bring us back some comments on that. Sure. Okay.
2:17:17 All right, that being said, is there anything else that we want to cover tonight? Are we content to move forward on these points? No? You know, one more thing, Linda, and I say this to all our commissions, and I'm sure I've said it to this board before, I don't have an unlisted phone number and I don't have an unlisted address. Anytime any member of Mammoth Lakes Housing Board would like to converse with me to get my feelings on something, I am always more than happy to set up a meeting with them to do that.
2:17:47 Yeah, I think it becomes almost more efficient that way, as long as we're not creating serial meetings with other council members and things. Okay. Patricia can speak to each of us at any time, as can any of her board members. Thank you. Thanks for that. All right. Well, that being said, it's been a good working meeting, and I think that we're going to agenda or to, what's it called?
2:18:14 Yeah, we're done for tonight. That's it. All right, everybody. Thanks for being here. It was good to talk to everybody. Thank you so much. Thank y'all. Bye. Good night.