TransparentMammoth

Eastern Sierra Council of Governments · 2022

Eastern Sierra Council of Governments Special meeting

at 08:30

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

46 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 That's right. That's right. We're all in this together, Bob. Come on. That's right. It's numbers and inclusion. Yeah. I continue to be reminded of the items in the agreement, however specific they are and were and shall be. Don't forget the items in the agreement, Bob. No. Morning, Janet. Morning. Can you hear me okay? Yeah. Try that again.

0:31 Casting. One, two. That's good. It's a little, it's good, it's loud. Okay, I'll tone it down. There we go. Now we got Inyo County awake and just right on the edge. Right. On the edge of? Sanity. Good. Yeah, it's a big club these days.

0:58 Okay, well, I guess we're all good to go here. Elaine, are you all set? Grace, you're all ready? Angie, you're okay? We are ready to go. Good to go. Okay, well, let's call this meeting to order. This is a special meeting of the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments for Friday, May 6, 2022. Angie, let's call the roll, please. Chair Wentworth? Present. Vice Chair Totharo?

1:31 Council Member Schwartz? Present. Supervisor Corliss? Here. I hope you don't mind. I'm keeping my video off. I'm kind of on the road in Santa Rosa, and I don't think you need to see it. Great. Just let me know if you end up leaving. Thanks for spareness. All right. If you end up leaving, let me know since I won't see you. Supervisor Gardner? Here. Supervisor Griffiths? I'm here. Council Member Ellis? Here.

2:03 Council Member Salcedo? Here. And we'll try one more time. Supervisor Totharo. All right, thank you. Thank you very much. For the Pledge of Allegiance, Jim, I was going to call on you, but it'd be tough for you to stand and rise there in the vehicle. So, Bob Gardner, could you leave us in the pledge, please? Would you be okay with that? Absolutely. Thank you. Ready, begin.

2:36 I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you, Supervisor Gardner, and thanks to the appropriate emphases there with our pledge. All right, well, let's move on then to public comments. Angie, any public comments, either virtually or in person? No comments at this time.

3:08 Excellent. Getting, I just got a comment from somebody advising that the Zoom, let's see here, the Zoom link in the agenda goes to a page that says the host is not signed in to start the meeting. Is that something you can take care of on your end, Angie, or? It's the same, it's the same link that we use for every meeting. So anybody who is trying to log in,

3:40 If for some reason that isn't working for them, they can just go to the Zoom website to join a meeting and they can enter our meeting ID number that's listed on the agenda. If you want to forward that email to me, I can go ahead and respond if you'd like. Yeah, let me, hang on one second. So should I have this person email you directly? Yeah, and actually, yeah, they can do clerk.

4:18 at townofmammothlakes.ca.gov or the regular email you have for me. Either one of them would be fine. Okay. Thank you. Good. Thank you for that. So no public comments. So let's get started with some policy matters. Item 4.1, consideration of a resolution of the Board of Directors.

5:03 of the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments regarding the need for continued virtual meetings to protect public health. Elaine, this is a kind of a standing item for these regular meetings. Any special nuances or new things we should consider today? Is this pretty much a standard item at this point? Good morning, Chair Wentworth and Andrew Ward.

5:29 This is just a standing item that we've been holding under AB 361, making these findings every 30 days to continue virtual meetings. Right now, there continues to be different legislation proposed, either memorializing or making changes to AB 361. Staff is not entirely sure which direction that's going to go, though we are monitoring it. At this time,

5:57 I believe our council has advised that we will not need to have a special meeting to make the findings in June, since we are planning to hold our first in-person meeting June 10th at the Bishop City Council Chambers. And at that time, we'll have an update on AB 361, and we'll include an item to discuss how your board would like to proceed with holding the ESCOG meetings in the future.

6:26 If there are no other questions or discussions, staff would recommend that the board adopt the resolution regarding virtual meetings pursuant to AB 361. Thank you. Excellent. Thank you. Anybody have anything to add to this? Motion for approval from Supervisor Griffiths and a second from Supervisor Gardner. Any additional discussion? I think we're all good with this. Okay, Angie, let's call the roll on this one. Thank you. Chair Wentworth.

6:57 Aye. Council Member Schwartz? Yes. Supervisor Corliss? Yes. Supervisor Gardner? Yes. Supervisor Griffiths? Yes. Council Member Ellis? Yes. And Council Member Salcedo? Yes. Thank you. Thank you, Angie. That sounds pretty anonymous to me.

7:24 We'll move on now to item 4.2, award agreement between the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments and the Whitebark Institute of Interdisciplinary Environmental Sciences for the provision of National Environmental Policy Act services for the Eastern Sierra Payson Scale Accelerator. Elaine, tell us what we need to know about this one. Good morning.

7:48 So your board will remember that the ESCOG was awarded a CDFW Proposition 1 grant last June in the amount of approximately $3.4 million for the Eastern Sierra Pace and Scale Accelerator Project.

8:05 The Eastern Sierra Pace and Scale Accelerator Project has sort of two goals and intents. The primary goal is to expand local capacity for environmental planning in the Eastern Sierra by investing in professionals to build a locally based workforce in the area of environmental planning. And the pilot project is the second component of that grant, and that is to complete the NEPA work.

8:31 for the Eastern Sierra Climate and Communities Resilience Project, specifically focusing in the initial areas of landscape restoration around Mammoth Lakes. On February 19th,

8:45 The ESCOG noticed a request for proposals for 30 days for the services. We received two proposals. The first was from the Whitebark Institute in partnership with Panorama Consulting and the Great Basin Institute, as well as other sub consultants. And the other was from Cardinal, now Stantec, in partnership with Ascent, the Sierra Business Council and other sub consultants. The ESCOG had formed a

9:10 consultant selection subcommittee, which consisted of members of your board, and then the Inyo National Force graciously offered three staff specialists with expertise pertinent to this project in particular to help score those proposals. The scoring found that both of the consultants were respondent and qualified both in their expertise and capacity to

9:39 provide the NEPA services. And so it was determined at our last meeting that we would have a, we would conduct interviews to further understand their proposals and their approach to the project to make a selection. Interviews were held also consisting of the ESCOG board subcommittee and the specialists on loan from the Inyo National Forest.

10:04 And following those interviews, it was unanimously determined by the subcommittee to award the contract to the White Bark Institute. The proposal from the White Bark Institute was for approximately $2,100,000. So the agreement in front of you is for the amount not to exceed that in their cost proposal. And the

10:29 budgeted amount under the CDFW grant is for approximately $2.5 million, so the cost proposal is within budget.

10:38 The decision of the selection subcommittee was based on Whitebark Institute's qualifications to provide the NEPA Environmental Planning Services, but moreover, their more comprehensive understanding of the original intent of the Eastern Sierra Payson Scale Accelerator, which is to build capacity in the Eastern Sierra to address long-standing capacity issues for third-party NEPA with the International Forest.

11:02 As stated, both of the consultants were deemed to have sufficient support and knowledge, particularly with the team of sub consultants that were brought in to support the project. But the intent of the grant, as specified in the proposal and the grant agreement, is to establish the Eastern Sierra Payson Scale Accelerator to build local environmental planning capacity.

11:29 The scoring subcommittee unanimously agreed that the Whitebark Institute demonstrated a greater commitment to building that long-term capacity. In particular, their approach was more integrated into working directly with the Inyo National Forest staff.

11:46 And in particular in this project that was deemed to be beneficial given the complexity of the train and the desire to have consultants who were very intimately familiar with the project area and moreover would be available to work in person hand on hand with the Forest Service and to be able to go to the project area for follow-up studies as needed by the Forest Service in very particular areas.

12:16 One concern of the subcommittee is that the Cardinal team, most of their consultants are largely outside of the Eastern Sierra region, and their proposal was to bring in specialists as needed, but not to have them based in the Eastern Sierra.

12:36 White Bark Institute proposal supports the capacity building and the local workforce development that is the intent not only of the Eastern Sierra Payson Scale Accelerator, but also the Sustainable Recreation and Ecosystem Management Program that's being championed by the ESCOG, as well as other business development and workforce development initiatives being championed by partners throughout the Eastern Sierra. At this time, I'm happy to take questions.

13:04 regarding the proposal and the agreement, but staff would request that the ESCOG Board approve and authorize staff to execute the agreement between the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments and the Whitebark Institute of Interdisciplinary Environmental Services for the provision of National Environmental Policy Act services for the Eastern Sierra Payson Scale Accelerator for an amount not to exceed $2,100,903.20. Excellent.

13:33 Elaine, thank you very much. Before we turn to questions from the ESCOG, are there any members of the advisory committee that may want to add to whatever Elaine has just said? I see, I think Nathan still was a part of that. Perhaps, Nathan, if you had anything to add, you don't have to, but perhaps there may be some thoughts you might have, or ESCOG members may have some questions for you. Elaine put it very well.

14:06 Okay, so I think any questions for Elaine or for Nathan or members of the committee? Okay, I'm not seeing any. Is there any public comment on this item? I have no public comments at this time. Excellent. Thank you very much, Angie. All right, well, it seems pretty straightforward to me. Excellent report, Elaine. Thank you very much for that. And your staff report as well was quite thorough. Thank you to you and to Grace for that. So with that, I'd entertain a motion.

14:37 I would make a motion to approve the award agreement as stated in the agenda. I'll second that. Thank you. We have a motion from Supervisor Gardner and a second from Mayor Salcedo. Any additional discussion? Not seeing any. Okay, Angie, let's call the roll, please. Thank you. Certainly. And I do see a phone number logged in as a panelist. And if that's Dan Totharo, can you please let me know? That's me. All right. Thank you. We will add you to our roll call. Thanks so much.

15:09 Thank you, Dan. Chair Wentworth? Yes. Vice Chair Totharo? Council Member Schwartz? Yes. Supervisor Corliss? Yes. Supervisor Gardner? Yes. Supervisor Griffiths? Yes. Council Member Ellis? Yes. And Council Member Salcedo? Yes. Thank you. Excellent. Sounds unanimous once again.

15:40 Let's move on then to item 4.3. This is consideration of an agreement with the National Fish and Wildlife Foundation for the Buttermilk Infrastructure and Recreation Planning Initiative. Elaine. Thank you. We've had discussion that

16:04 Last summer, the ESCOG submitted an application to the National Fish and Wildlife Foundation for the Buttermilk Recreation Planning and Infrastructure Initiative. And I think that there's been an update as well that that grant was conditionally awarded, I believe, in November. And we've been working with the National Fish and Wildlife Foundation, or NIFWF.

16:26 to go through the necessary paperwork to bring us to this point today with the agreement in front of you. The grant is in the amount of $247,000 and it also is a two-phase project. The first phase is to the existing toilet facilities in the Buttermilk Recreation Area.

16:53 And the second is approximately $148,000 for conceptual recreation planning. I can certainly elaborate. The grant award was supported by multiple recreation groups, including the Access, what are they called? The Access Fund, which is a climbing nonprofit.

17:27 The Bishop Climbers Coalition and the Adventure Trails. The project will be based on stakeholder input and looking forward to kicking that off. So with your board's approval, I would request that the ESCOG board approve the agreement with the National Fish and Wildlife Foundation for the implementation of the Buttermilk Infrastructure and Recreation Planning Initiative. I'm happy to take additional questions on the proposal. Thank you.

17:55 Thanks, Elaine. And this is a project developed, I believe, that the Sustainable Recreation and Tourism Initiative with a fair amount of input from the Eastern Sierra Sustainable Recreation Partnership, correct? That's true. This is one of the projects, eight projects that was identified in the Sustainable Recreation and Tourism Initiative, which obviously represents a much broader regional support. Okay, thank you. Any questions for Elaine on this one?

18:22 I'm not seeing any. Is there any public comment on this item? Oh, I'm sorry, Linda, you had your hand up. That's fine. What is the proposed start date on this project? My goal would be, and it's a little bit contingent on my ability to finalize all the agreement paperwork with NAFWF. If your board approves this agreement, I would like to develop a request for proposals that I would bring back.

18:48 to the board in June, working with closely with the Forest Service first on implementation of the toilet infrastructure, which they've indicated is their highest priority. And they already have the environmental assessment in place for that, as well as they're going to assist us with putting together the big package for that work. And then we would also develop an RFP for the consultant that would be doing the recreation planning. And so my goal

19:15 would be to bring those RFPs to the board in June so we could kick off the project this summer. Okay, thank you. Thank you, Linda. Any additional questions for staff here? Okay, Angie, any public comment? I am seeing no comments at this time. Excellent, thank you. All right, with that, I guess we'll entertain a motion. Move to approve the agreement as stated in the agenda. Again. Motion.

19:48 I think, Jeff, I think he just, it's Kentucky Derby week or something. I think the nose goes to you on this one, Jeff. So we have a motion from Supervisor Gardner and a second from Supervisor Griffiths. Angie, let's please call the roll on this question. Thank you. Chair Wentworth? Yes. Vice Chair Totoro? Aye. Council Member Schwartz? Yes. Supervisor Corliss? Yes. Supervisor Gardner?

20:17 Yes. Supervisor Griffiths. Yes. Council Member Ellis. Yes. And Council Member Salcido. Yes. Thank you. Excellent. Sounds anonymous once again. I think that concludes our business for the morning, Elaine, if I'm correct. And we would then adjourn to our next meeting on June 10th. Do I have that right? That's correct.

20:45 Thank you. Do we need a motion to adjourn or just all say goodbye and wish each other good luck? You have the power. Goodbye and good luck. Bye, con dia. Ciao. See you all later. Thank you. Thank you all. Bye.