TransparentMammoth

Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2023

Planning & Economic Development Commission

at 09:00

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Notable from this meeting

5 findings

Transcript

221 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:12 Sounds good. Thanks. What's up? Hey. There's more holes out there. I think I need to, at some point, go out there. It's pretty clear now that we can just document everything and then coordinate with... Just a note to try... Okay. Well, good morning, everybody. I'd like to call the Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting for April 12th to order.

2:19 Jamie, may we have roll call, please? Commissioner Chang? Commissioner Eckert is absent. Commissioner Kennedy? Here. Vice Chair Burroughs? Present. Chair Vanderhurst? Present. Thank you. If everyone would please stand, we'll do the Pledge of Allegiance. Commissioner Kennedy, would you care to lead us? Thank you, Commissioner Kennedy. Jamie, you'll note I remembered roll call this morning. I'd like to open up public comment.

2:58 But I would ask if anybody has public comment they'd like to submit to the commission today in regards to a matter on our agenda, please wait until that agenda item has been opened before the commission. So is there any other public comment that is not associated with an agenda item? Jamie, did we have any through Zoom? All right. Then I'll close public comment, and we'll start with our first presentation, which is an update on the economic...

3:29 The Community Economic Resilience Fund. And I believe we have a couple members before us today. Good morning, Stacey. Good morning, commissioners. My name is Stacey Corliss, and I am here today representing Sierra Business Council. We are, if you're not familiar with Sierra Business Council, we're a Sierra Nevada-based nonprofit based in Truckee that focuses on strengthening communities.

3:58 Thank you so much for joining us.

4:26 That's going to be working and the acronym for this project is SURF, C-E-R-F. People get confused when they hear that, like talking about surfing, is it going to be in all the runoff that we're experiencing this spring? No, SURF is a project. So first I want to introduce a new addition to the Sierra Business Council team, Magnolia Barra, Mammoth Lakes resident, she is going to serve as our SURF project navigator for the Eastern Sierra.

4:54 Sure. I just started last week, so I'm just getting familiar with everything about the project and the next steps that are moving forward, and my colleague Erica is going to explain a little bit more of what's coming. She's here, right? She's on, yeah. But we wanted to come in person and just show you that we're the local faces of SURF. There'll be a lot of town involvement.

5:21 I know Sandra will be involved, also Mayor Wentworth, among others, and there'll be more opportunities for engagement and for the Commission's participation and feedback as this kind of year-plus-long process kicks off. But now I will turn it over to Erica Harvey, who is our Economic Empowerment Director at Sierra Business Council, and she is the Project Lead for CERF. So we'll hand it over to Erica. Congratulations. Thanks, Stacey.

5:52 So Sierra Business Council was chosen to be the regional convener and fiscal agent for the Eastern Sierra region for the SURF program. So the $600 million SURF program was set up to fund planning and projects that promote sustainability and economic development with a focus on disinvested communities. And there's three state agencies that are supporting this effort. So it's EDD, GOBiz and OPR.

6:24 So California broke up 13 regions that make up the SURF regional boundaries. Each region received $5 million for planning. And then the implementation phase includes the $460 million pot after all the carve-outs. And everyone is applying for that same pot of funding. So the phase two implementation phase will be

6:53 Very competitive. And then these are the seven counties that California defined as the Eastern Sierra Region. So Alpine, Almodor, Calaveras, Inyo, Tuolumne, Mariposa and Mono. So this is kind of our timeline where we currently stand right now. We originally were planning on a 24-month process and it's been shortened to 13, 14-ish month process.

7:28 We received our executed contract at the very end of February. March has been primarily working on hiring new staff, our HRTC outreach, ramping up our admin, and then drafting subcontractor MOUs. And then April has been full of just organizing the HRTC and subcommittees, filling those gaps.

7:54 And then beginning the research and data aggregation process for the first couple deliverables and then finalizing our subcontracts. May, we're hoping to have the entire HRTC and the subcommittees selected and all that information will be sent out then. It's also our first deliverable is due. And then for this summer, June and July, that'll be primarily, you know,

8:22 The subcommittees and the HRTC convening and then working on that first big deliverable, the 2.1 that's due at the end of August. So that's what kind of the process that we're currently looking at right now. So these are just foundational pillars that the program is designed around. They're also, these are things that SBC values. So equity, inclusion, transparency, sustainability.

8:54 and impact. So this process will be governed by a diverse collaborative, so the HRTC, and then a series of topical subcommittees resulting in a robust regional economic recovery and transition plan. So that first deliverable, it's a plan, it's a regional plan, will include a broad range of data, including stakeholder and asset mapping,

9:25 Identification of opportunities for alignment with existing regional economic planning processes and documents, and then a regional labor market and economic cluster analysis, and then identification of regional climate and public health trends. And then that second deliverable will be one regional plan with two interrelated subcomponents addressing

9:53 Region-wide strategies and a specific set of east side and west side strategies and implementation opportunities. And then this process will also evolve over time. Recently at the kickoff event in Sacramento, interestingly enough, the agencies described these deliverables as drafts or living documents. So as we start to dive into this, the state is well aware that we could be making changes.

10:25 You know, as new things start to come up. And they want people to start looking at this program as the start of something that will be sustainable, not like a start and then a finished product. So this is our proposed governance structure. However, as I said previously, as the process continues to evolve, we anticipate needing to make adjustments based on the stakeholders and the region's needs. So our HRTC.

10:55 is made up of 21 members and then one non-voting chair. We hope that to have three from each county and then five of those people will be chairs on subcommittees. And then the subcommittees, we have five subcommittees as you can see, one dedicated to equity, climate and labor, business and workforce, local government, data planning and drafting, and then a project committee.

11:24 So these subcommittees will be made up of seven voting members for each committee. So these are the list of required stakeholders that the state wants us to include. Highlighted are the stakeholders that we are still trying to engage in this process. And if you would like any additional information, here's just a couple links to the agencies.

12:00 Web pages, and then their announcement video. And then we also included our website, which includes kind of SBC's plan on how we're going to go about governing, helping govern the east side. Does anyone have any questions? Any questions for, was there any public comment on this presentation, Jamie? Any public comment from the audience? Questions that anybody might have? I just had a quick question, Chair. Please.

12:37 Erica, this is Sandra Moberly from the town. I'm just wondering if you noted that you're missing a number of different stakeholders for your committees. Is that something that you're looking for us to try to push out or reach out if we know people in those different groups? Yes. Yeah, we could reach out. I think on the east side, we're actually, we have a lot more of these stakeholders than we do on the west side. But yes, if...

13:07 If that's something that you guys are willing to do, Stacey can definitely follow up and fill you in on who we're currently trying to engage on the east side. I think that, you know, this commission and members of the public who are watching might know people in these different groups, so if we can identify those, at least we can say, hey, we might know this person or that person and forward that on to Sierra Business Council. Hey, Erica, just for the sake of the audience that may be watching online, would you just go back to the slide that had?

13:36 The stakeholders identify the different groups. Thank you. Maybe just leave it there for a sec. Sure. Stacey, did you have? Quick question, Stacey. The stakeholder positions, I'm assuming, are volunteer.

15:43 Not compensated. There is funding for per diem and travel. So the way we envision this working, obviously it is funny, I heard some kind of snickering, you know, the Eastern Sierra that we have west side counties in the Eastern Sierra region. I for one am glad the state recognized the Eastern Sierra exists and named the region Eastern Sierra. But what we envision with these meetings is

16:12 It'll be a hybrid format a lot of the times, but trying to alternate the HRTC meetings between the east and west side with virtual options for everything. So there will be some, there could be travel involved and the state does allow for compensation, per diem type compensation. But we're also, we'll be working really closely with the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments on

16:39 Convening meetings and outreach. And so, you know, we are compensating SCOG for that, for their staff time. So there is, the funding that SBC is getting is going out through the community in other ways. Got it. Yeah. And Sandra, did I hear you are representing the town of Mammoth Lakes? I've applied to be on the HRTC, but they're still, I think they're making decisions, so I don't know yet. But I know that a number of, I think John Urith has applied, some other, you know,

17:09 County Board of Supervisors members have applied, so I think that right now SBC is kind of going through their process to put together all of the different committees and the High Road Transition Council. That's right, and the Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce will also be involved. Jeff Simpson from our county, Mono County's Economic Development Director, will likely be involved. So a lot of familiar faces, but hopefully also some new faces and new voices in the conversation.

17:37 Any other questions or comments from anyone on the commission? I wish you nothing but the best of luck. I mean, it's an exciting proposition. It really is. And just looking at the timeline that Erica presented, I mean, you guys are hitting the ground running. Yeah, we were hoping to get started earlier this winter, although, you know, from the winter we had, it may have been so difficult to convene meetings anyway. But yeah, we're ready to go and excited about the process. Got it. And if anybody that is watching this online,

18:07 If somebody does have a suggested stakeholder, who should they contact? Magnolia? The easiest thing to do, Erica, put the slide up, go to sierrabusiness.org slash surf, and that is a page that has all the information. We have an email address dedicated to surf, so that's the best way to reach any of us that way. An email goes through there. It could be...

18:35 Routed to Magnolia or anyone on the team. So yeah, and there are application forms. There's sign up for an email list dedicated to serve to get all the news and engagement opportunities. Thank you. Thank you, Stacey. Appreciate it. And just to add one thing on the subcommittees and the HRTC, those meetings will be public. So even if someone's not on a subcommittee or can't make that full commitment or even they're not chosen to be on the HRTC.

19:06 Anyone will be able to join in and listen to those. So just want to make sure everyone knows that. Thank you. Thank you for the presentation, Erica, and best of luck. I'm going to move on to our second presentation, 4.2. It's the 2022 Annual Planning Report. And I believe Michael is our staff contact. Thank you. So yeah, I'll just do a brief introduction. The Annual Planning Report is a report that we are required to complete by the state every year.

19:38 We often bring it to commission just to give you an idea of what projects we've worked on over the year and just to kind of go through all of the different work that we've done as a town. So it's not just our department, it's throughout the entire town. And I think it's a really great opportunity just to check in and to see what we've done over the past year. So with that, I'll hand it over to Nolan and Michael who will go through a brief summary of the report. Thank you.

20:10 Good morning, commissioners. I'm here to just give a brief overview of the annual planning report and some of the projects that were highlighted in the report. The report was received by town council at their meeting last week and was submitted to the state ahead of their March 31st deadline. And like Sandra said, the annual planning report is a document that's required by the state with the purpose being to inform town council and the community about the status implementing the general plan.

20:41 Housing and Development taking place in Mammoth Lakes. First, we're going to start off with some of the larger planning projects from last year, all of which have come to the commission, you know, at some point, some of them last year, some of them years before. The big project, obviously, from last year is the parcel phase one. Here's some pictures from over the winter of work going on on the site. Free removal and rough grading began in the fall of 2021. In 2022, building permits were issued.

21:20 with construction beginning shortly after. Work culminated with the placement of approximately 100 modular units that were used to create the two buildings. The buildings were then weatherproofed to allow for ongoing interior construction throughout the winter. Further site work, including installation of dry utilities, roads and sidewalks, will begin later this spring.

21:47 Phase 1 will include a total of 81 units within two buildings with affordability levels ranging from 20 to 80 percent of AMI, as well as a variety of unit sizes from studio to three bedroom. The project also consists of a community space, child care facility, public park, and it's expected to be available for occupancy in the fall. Other projects in 2022 included

22:18 The Main Lodge Redevelopment Project, which is currently working through their required environmental documents. The Sierra Nevada Resort Redevelopment, which included the addition of 30 cabin units and a new mobile vendor that just received its mobile vending permit from the planning department a few weeks ago. That's a crepe stand. They're currently open as well. Construction also began on the 151-room Limelight Hotel at the corner of Canyon Boulevard and Lake Mary Road.

22:50 with snow removal already taking place this year to allow construction to begin again. The Residence Inn on Berner Street was approved by the Commission in 2022, and as of now, they've currently applied for their building permit. Public Works was busy in 2022 with a number of road projects. These included annual maintenance on Old Mammoth Road consisting of replacement of the curb and gutter.

23:21 Sidewalk panel replacement, and landscaping cleanup. Work on streets for the parcel included the creation of the entirely new Inyo Street, as well as the extension of Tavern Road. Road rehabilitation projects took place on Sherwin Street, Majestic Pines, Monterey Pine Road, Red Fur, and Mountain Boulevard. Picture of the work going on on, I believe it's Monterey Pines, is shown here.

23:54 And also Public Works awarded contracts for the Chaparral Road Extension into the Parcel, the Laurel Mountain Road Project, which will include new sidewalk, curb and gutter, storm drain, sewer, street lighting, and reconstruction of existing pavements, as well as the Bluffs-Lurry Seal Project, which was awarded in 2022 and also completed last year. Parks projects in 2022 included the ongoing construction of the Community Recreation Center,

24:23 As well as deferred maintenance projects at Whitmore Pool, Whitmore Ball Fields, Shady Rest Park, and the community tennis courts. Trails projects included construction of 1.5 new miles of trail in the lakes basin, rehabilitation of several miles of multi-use paths all around town, and the continuance of the trail host program, trail days events that took place throughout the summer, as well as the adopted trail.

24:50 Now I'm going to pass it off to Nolan to give a few of the housing highlights from last year. Sure. So amongst other things in the housing world, I think the big achievement in 2022 was our progress towards the regional housing needs allocation or the RENA. The RENA sets the target for how many units of the various income levels the town needs to plan and issue building permits for. It's intended to identify the number of...

25:16 Thank you so much.

25:46 Senate Bill 35, which requires ministerial streamlining of certain projects. If you haven't built enough low-income or issued permits for enough low-income units, then you're subject to SB 35 requirements for the preceding year. So here on the screen, on the green bars, just shows the RENA numbers set by the state for extremely low, very low, low, moderate, and above moderate income levels. Then the blue line shows what we achieved in 2022.

26:15 So the big jump there is on the low, very low and extremely low. That's all related to the parcel. We still need to do quite a bit of work on the moderate. That's your missing middle. That's your 81 to 120 percent AMI. That's the kind of the most difficult category to achieve because there's really no state or federal funding there. So that's some of the areas we're focused on is adding units to that category.

26:41 In the far right, you have your above moderate, which is your market rate, which seems to, you know, they're ahead of the schedule for what the state says we need, so we're still doing some catch-up on the affordable units. The red line shows what we expect to achieve for 2023. You know, there's a few additional units in the extremely low and very low, and then another jump in the low, and that includes the Innsbruck.

27:08 Lodge, Home Key Project, as well as the Access Apartments Project, both Mammoth Lakes Housing Projects. We anticipate those permits being issued this year. And then it would jump even higher if we issued the building permit for a parcel phase two. However, we don't know when that schedule is really dependent on funding. With that, that is complete the summary, and we're open to any questions the commission has.

27:38 Start down there with Commissioner Kennedy. Any questions for either Michael, Sandra, or Nolan? Commissioner Burroughs? I have a couple of really quick questions. So the red line, Nolan, does that represent just housing that is being constructed by the public sector or does it also represent the private sector? Both. So really, I mean, all the private units are the ones in the above moderate. Right.

28:10 The annual planning board, at least the housing element annual planning board, captures all housing construction. It's not just focused on affordable. Got it. Is there any process to incentivize the private sector to construct housing in the moderate category? That seems to be where we're really kind of falling behind a little bit. Yes, I think it really comes down to providing subsidies to close the gap between what they could get at market rate.

28:40 And then Michael, quick question on the parcel, and I apologize if this is not in your world, but has

29:10 The large amount of snow we've received this winter, has it slowed down the parcel build out at all? No. I'll just answer that one. No. They're doing all the work inside right now. Okay. And that was always the plan. And they have been removing snow off the roof, you know, throughout the winter, but they've continued work inside the building. And no structural damage to the parcel with that flat roof? No. Nothing? Okay. And then...

29:35 Again, apologies if it's not in any of your worlds, but has the winter slowed down the build-out of the CRC? That might be one. I don't know. Hayes, are you on? And can you respond to the question about the CRC? Short answer is yes. Thanks, Hayes. Jamie, do we have any public comment on this presentation? Any public comment from the audience? Last chance for questions for staff.

30:09 It was a very ambitious year, 2022, so congratulations on all the projects, guys. Look forward to seeing, you know, the residents in and the limelight come online here and are we thinking 12 months, 24 months? Like, either. Limelight should, I think they're anticipating completing construction at the end of next year or maybe early 2025.

30:33 But I don't know the construction timeline off the top of my head. Residents in were just working with them to get their building permits submitted. So I don't really know where they are in the process. If I had a crystal ball, I might say next year starting, but they could still possibly start this year. Thank you. Thank you very much. With that, I'll close that presentation. Thank you, everyone, for your time and attention to detail. And we'll move on to the business matters.

31:00 5.1, consideration of a request to amend resolution PC-2009-08 for TTM09-002, Snow Creek 8, to modify conditions of approval number 13 regarding the annexation of the project area into the Mammoth Lakes Mosquito Abatement District and to update reference lot. And I believe Nolan is our staff contact on this.

31:30 Great, thank you. Yes, yes. So Commissioner Chang is conflicted out of the next two items to ownership of residents within 500 feet of this project. Commissioner Chang, can he stay in the audience or does he have to leave the room? Technically he's supposed to leave the room. You can, if you want to sit, there's a room right over there if you want to sit in there. So this item is related to the Snow Creek 8 project.

32:08 The proposal is very minor. We did include some background history in the presentation to really bring everyone up to speed on the Snow Creek 8 project since it has quite a long history here. So just a brief summary of the Snow Creek 8 project. It's the final phase of the Snow Creek development that is currently envisioned. It's regulated by the 2007 Snow Creek Master Plan update. That master plan represents the zoning for the site. It covers the approximately 222 acre site.

32:39 The site's located kind of south of Old Mammoth Road, east of Snow Creek 5, and west of Sherwin Creek Road. So it's approximately 222 acres. The master plan allows on the site up to approximately 900 residential units that's comprised of private dwelling units, resort hotel rooms, and private residence club units.

33:10 75,000 square feet of non-residential uses, that'd be commercial uses, sports shops, outfitters club, uses like that, expansion of the existing nine-hole golf course into an 18-hole championship golf course, and various recreational amenities including multi-use paths, no-play areas, and winter trails. TTM 09002 was approved in 2009.

33:35 That tentative map was only intended to parcelize the 222-acre site. It does not allow any development to occur, so does not allow grading, utilities, or any of the buildings to be constructed. Also, that tentative map was approved with numerous conditions that were required to be satisfied prior to final map approval. So again, just showing the location of it.

34:00 Snow Creek 8 is the one in the yellow. It also shows the other seven phases of the Snow Creek project. So that kind of comprises the entire Snow Creek master plan area. As we said, it has quite a long history for this project. Snow Creek was originally envisioned in the 1974 and 1981 master plans. Those master plans regulated the development of 355 acres of snow.

34:27 property, allowed up to 2,300 total dwelling units throughout all the phases. So that includes all the phases of Snow Creek, the Catholic Church site, the athletic club, and the nine-hole golf course. In 2005, there was a land exchange between Snow Creek and the U.S. Forest Service that added the 94 acres to the development area that's proposed to be the expanded golf course area. That land exchange did come with the restriction that that land only be used for recreational purposes.

34:56 Such as the expanded golf course. 2007, they began the Snow Creek Master Plan update. It wasn't completed until 2009. So that was an update to the 1981 Master Plan to incorporate the 94-acre land exchange site and provide updated development standards for the remaining 143 acres of the Snow Creek property. That area is what is now called Snow Creek 8.

35:24 EIR was certified for the project and it also included a general plan amendment to adjust the urban growth boundary to align with the land exchange boundaries. Following the master plan update, TTM 09002 was approved in December of 2009 and that allowed for the parcelization of the site. It parcelized the site into 23 lots for future development purposes, 7 lots for

35:51 private roads, and one lettered lot for open space. So for a total of 31 lots were approved on that tentative map. And as noted before, it came with about 10 pages of conditions that they needed to satisfy before the final map could come forward. In 2010, the town and Snow Creek entered into a development agreement. This development agreement provided a vested right to the developer to develop the site in accordance with the master plan

36:21 It also vests the existing approvals that are in place for the entire term of the Snow Creek Development Agreement. If they start the golf course and hotel, then that development agreement is vested or in place until 2030. However, there's terms in the DA that say they lose a day for every day that the golf course and hotel aren't started. So there's potential that the DA could expire in 2025.

36:49 As a note here, we show the final tract map, 09-002. That's the subsequent item to this item on today's agenda. This final map would legally create the lots approved by tentative tract map 09-002, which then would allow them to come in for the future development phases. So as noted before, that tentative map or the final map don't actually allow for any development. This allows for those parcels to be created.

37:18 Then they have to come in for subsequent tentative maps, use permits, design reviews for the various phases. So the next step after the final map would be the development phase. They have phase one tentatively scheduled for commission consideration this spring, where there's still some items to work through, such as recording the final map, and future phases are to be determined. So the proposed amendments today, these are really considered minor amendments to the resolution.

37:49 As we've been working through the conditions and as the developer's been working through the conditions to satisfy them to get to the final map approval, they ran into an issue with the annexation into the Mammoth Lakes Mosquito Abatement District. This process is governed by the Mono County Local Agency Formation Commission, or LAFCO.

38:16 One of the conditions in the tentative map required that the entire project area be annexed into that mosquito abatement district prior to final map approval. There has been some delays working with the county to get this to LAFCO for consideration. So the developer asked us if there's any chance to amend that condition to delay annexation of the entire project area. When we started looking into it, we...

38:45 Consider the request since a portion of the area is already in the mosquito abatement district, and so we amended the condition to require annexation prior to any project consideration for an area outside the district. So on the map on the left, the area in orange shows the area, the project that's currently within that district, and that includes all of what's proposed for phase one of development. So when we looked into it,

39:11 We came to the conclusion that since that area is already within the district, holding up the final map and then the future consideration of phase one did not make much sense since the area is already subject to what is being required. However, the condition does require that prior to any future approval for a tentative map, a use permit or any other entitlement,

39:35 Any area subject to that development has to be annexed in. So we anticipate that they'll annex the entire rest of it in in one action. However, we don't have a timeline from Mono County Lafcoe as to when that will be completed. The other amendment included in this is really just a cleanup item. When they went from the tentative map to the final map, the total number of lots went from the 23 or 31 total, but 23 proposed for development to 18.

40:07 to 18 lots. And so throughout the conditions of approval, it makes reference to lot numbers from the tentative map for the timing as to when those conditions have to be satisfied, as well as to the location of those conditions. So this cleanup just adjusts the lot numbers to reflect what's on the final map. So as we're working through the conditions and working to implement the project, we ensure that the conditions are being satisfied, when they're supposed to be satisfied, and that they're

40:36 being put in place in the right location on the project. To approve the minor changes, municipal code outlines certain findings, such as that it's consistent with the applicable provisions of the zoning code, does not involve a feature of the project that was the basis of an environmental impact report, does not involve a feature that was specifically addressed or is a basis for conditions of approval, and lastly, that it does not result in an expansion

41:06 So, again, no changes to

41:35 I think I would just like a little clarification to make sure that we're approving the mosquito.

42:09 Abatement annexing. That's what we're looking at, right? Right. Two, kind of two different things. One is to push out the annexation into the Mosquito Abatement District. And then the other thing is to clean up all the lot numbers. So it's really, that's really kind of just two high-level things that you're looking at as a part of this. And then the next item is separate, but it's the final map that would incorporate these changes. So these two are really connected. So if you're not comfortable approving this, then we would likely...

42:38 Pull the next item off of the agenda. But we have communicated with the county about the annexation of LAFCO and it's just, it's really just the timing of this. Honestly, the applicant has been working on this for months and months trying to get this annexation complete and it's just really just been timing on the county's part and the Mosquito Abatement District Board's part of kind of going through this process. So I think the applicant is willing to do this. It's just...

43:03 Really just this timing, they would like to move forward with the next phases, the next steps in the process, but still annex into the district. Thank you. Quick question. Just in regards to the annexation of the Mammoth Mosquito Abatement District, are we superseding the county now with this action? No. It sounds like there's been a delay on the county side, but are we now...

43:35 No, we're not superseding the county. The condition of approval is still in place. The timing is going out a little bit. That's the change. We're just allowing them to annex into the district at a later date. Originally, the annexation was required to be done with the final map, which is on the agenda for today for consideration. This just allows the applicant to annex into the district at a later date.

43:59 And I don't, you know, we've pushed this information out to the county and, you know, it sounds like they're just, they're all trying to work on it, it's just taking longer than they thought. Apologies for this question, but any idea when this mosquito abatement district was formed? I don't, it's been a long time, I don't know when it was formed. It is a special district, so it's not actually under the county, it's a special district, and we have a couple of these, we're kind of...

44:25 I think the county's trying to go through a cleanup of all of the different districts, just really an understanding, so I don't know when it was formed, do you know? I'm going to Google it. Are there any other mosquito abatement districts within the town boundaries or within our... I don't know if there's any other ones in the county besides this one. I think it's relatively unique. You know, I think there's other areas where...

44:52 They provide mosquito abatement services. I actually think they do it in Crowley. I don't know if there's a separate district. I know in my neighborhood, people will come out and spray, but I don't know if that's a separate district or what that is. Got it. It was formed in 1969 to provide mosquito control to portions of Mammoth Lakes. Their boundaries include Old Mammoth, part of the Snow Creek development, Valentine Ecological Reserve, and adjacent condominium developments. Wow, okay.

45:23 So it definitely predates the town's incorporation by a long way. Yes. Okay. Any idea if there will be mosquito abatement measures taken outside of this district within the town? With all this snow melt, we are definitely going to have a lot of standing water within the town of Mammoth Lakes outside of this district. That's a good question. I don't know the answer to that. I can follow up on it, though.

45:51 And I don't know if in 2017 if we did anything. Sometimes county, like the county environmental health will, in other counties, and I don't know about Mono County, but we'll provide some sort of a service, but we can follow up on that because it's a good question. All right, before I open it up to public comment, would the applicant care to make a statement? Chuck Landy with Snow Creek. I don't have anything to say. I'd be glad to answer any questions. Any questions for the applicant? Thank you, Chuck. Appreciate it.

46:27 I'll open it up now to public comment on this item. Does anybody have public comment from within the room? Sweet Z? Jamie, do we have any public comment via Zoom? All right, I'll close public comment and bring it back to the commission. Would anybody care to have express opinions or comments, or would somebody care to put a motion forth? I'll make a motion to adopt the attached PEDC resolution, making the municipal code findings and approving the minor...

47:00 Amendments to Resolution, PC 2009-08, tentative tract map, 09-002, Snow Creek 8, as recommended by staff. I'll second that. We have a second. Any further conversation? Jamie, may we have a vote, please? Commissioner Kennedy? Yes. Vice Chair Burroughs? Yes. Chair Vanderhurst? Yes. Matter passes 3-0.

47:28 We'll move on to business matter number 2, 5.2, consider approval of the final tract map 09-002 for the 26-lot subdivision of Snow Creek 8, located at 145 and 7 Fairway Drive and 942 and 1110 Old Mammoth Road. And is, Nolan, I'm sorry, are you our staff contact again? I think it's Hayes.

47:55 As we can see on the big screen here. A's. Good morning, sir. Good morning, commissioners. Yeah, we're here to consider the final track map for Snow Creek 8-09-002. We're asking that the commission find that that map is in accordance with the approved tentative map and approve the track map and all the applicable conditions of approval and tentative track map have been satisfied and authorize recordation of that map.

48:24 Typically, these items are on consent, but given the request to make a modification to the condition of approval, we felt it was appropriate to put this item after, you know, changing that condition and not have it on consent just made sense. No one already went through all the details of the project. I'm not going to belabor those points, but I can answer any questions specific to the recordation of the final map. Do we have any questions for Hayes?

48:55 On this matter, 5.2. Just clarifying what we're voting on. Thank you, Hayes, by the way. We are looking, we are approving the tract map, the changes from the 23 lots to the 18 or whatever the number, what number it was? Is that correct? So we just basically approved that with the change in the condition. What we're approving now is

49:22 The final map and approving that for recordation. So this creates the subdivision of land. We're basically confirming that the conditions have been satisfied and will be satisfied prior to the recordation of the map. And this basically allows Snow Creek 8 to create those parcels and allows them to move forward with a forthcoming tentative map for development.

49:46 As Noah stated in his presentation, this final map doesn't allow for any development. This is just creating parcels. Thank you. Any other questions for staff? Would the applicant care to make a statement? Be glad to answer any questions. We're looking forward to getting this finalized so we can pull a grading permit and get to work here in the next 60 days or so. Any questions for the applicant? All right, then I'll open it up to public comment. Do we have any public comment from within suite Z?

50:27 Jamie, do we have any public comment via Zoom? Yes. Please just identify yourself when Jamie unmutes you. Patrick, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Thank you. I'm unmuted. Thank you, Commissioner. I'm Patrick Ellingsworth. I'm the president of Snow Creek 5 Homeowners Association, Fairway Homes 2. And I'd like to make a comment about items. First of all, let me say, the association support

51:00 The adoption of this final map. It is a significant event. It's a positive event in the development of our neighborhood. We think it's good for Mammoth Lakes. We think it's good for the two Snow Creek Five associations. But I do want to alert you to one factor that's in the resolution from 2009, a couple of factors that are unresolved. I'm not here to debate them, just to alert you.

51:29 to our concerns about this. Snow Creek 5 is remote from the main road. It's 7 tenths of a mile away from the public road, Mammoth, Old Mammoth Road. There are two associations in there. They were built between 1995 and 2004, 300 units. We're very proud of our organizations and the like. We were the last

51:59 Dempsey Project before Tom passed away. The items that I'd like to bring to your attention relate to access. As I say, we're seven-tenths of a mile away from the road. The history of the temporary road that's there now is, to say the least, checkered.

52:27 It was constructed as a temporary road in 1985 and has been partially resurfaced once but not actually maintained. And we've accommodated ourselves to that. And in fact, Chuck's in the room. He was very helpful when we identified what our issues were within the last 10 years to determine.

52:54 What our approach would be relative to the access road. And Chuck was very helpful in terms of organizing the thoughts, providing a formal documented easement and the like. The issues that we're now concerned about relate to the fact that we are remote and this is going to be a shared road if it were part of the community development.

53:23 District, whatever the current name is of the Benefit Assessment District, we would have a different approach. But as a private road, every one of our vehicles needs to go over that road. So we're very concerned about it. And we're concerned about one thing in particular right now, and that's snow removal. Fairway Homes 2 has spent $500,000 in snow removal this winter.

53:53 We have a premier removal plan, and we need to maintain that for our owners in the future. And we're in the process of discussing this with Chuck in terms of what are the terms for snow removal. And I had sent an email, not even knowing that this was an issue on the

54:19 Commission's schedule today. I just sent a haze, an update the other day that we had not yet resolved the issues. Not to debate it now, not to go through the details, just to alert you that it's not done as of this point. I'm confident we can work it out. To everyone's satisfaction, there are plenty of

54:48 plenty of ways to do it. We would prefer a consultation methodology or a separate homeowners association for the road. But if not, we want to put in writing in a long-term easement agreement terms that are satisfactory to make sure we can accomplish what we need to do in snow removal on our property. Thank you. Thank you, Patrick. I can take questions.

55:19 Thank you, Patrick. Jamie, any other public comment? That was it. Okay. Last chance. Sweet Z, public comment? None? All right. I'll close public comment now. Chuck, would you care to answer any of the questions that were brought up by Patrick? Yeah. First of all, it's a private matter. It doesn't really involve the town. There is an agreement in place currently, and we are working on a more, what should I say?

55:52 More defined agreement. So it will occur here shortly. But again, it's not something that involves the town of Mammoth Lakes. It's a private agreement between two private parties. I'll bring it back to the commission now. Any questions for either the applicant or staff on this? No? Would anybody care to make a motion? We'll make a motion to...

56:20 Find final tract map 09-002 to be in accordance with the conditionally approved tentative tract map and approve the final tract map. Find that all applicable conditions of approval of the tentative tract map have been satisfied and authorize recordation of final tract map 0, map 09-002. I read the next part to the one and two. After payment of outstanding fees and two, no less than 10 calendar days.

56:47 After the approval of the final tract map by the Planning and Economic Development Commission, provided no appeal has been filed, the 10th day of appeals shall be a regular business day. The map may then record the next business day, provided no appeal has been filed. I'll second that. We have a second. Any further conversation? Jamie, may we have a vote, please? Commissioner Kennedy? Yes. Vice Chair Burroughs? Yes. Chair Vanderhurst? Yes. Matter passes 3-0. Congratulations. Pull Commissioner Chang out of deep isolation.

57:43 Welcome back, Commissioner Chang. Our next matter is the consent agenda. Unless there's any questions or conversation, does anyone want to make a motion to approve? I'll make a motion to approve the consent agenda. Do I have a second? I'll second. Jamie, may we have a vote, please? Commissioner Chang? Yes. Commissioner Kennedy? Yes. Vice Chair Burroughs? Yes. Chair Vanderhurst? Yes. Consent agenda passes 4-0. Thank you.

58:14 On to Commissioner Reports, and hot out of the back room, I'll throw it over to Commissioner Chang. Sure. I participated, and it was a housing project for four units, pretty simple design, and seeking some simple modifications. We're just seeking some simple modifications to the project. Other than that, I think it was an easy project to review. Got it.

59:03 Commissioner Burroughs, any report that you'd like to submit? I don't have anything except for to ditto what Paul said, or Commissioner Chang said that we reviewed a new housing development building structure. Commissioner Kennedy. Nothing to report, thank you. Yeah, mine's pretty brief as well. Just kind of remind the...

59:29 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

59:59 I think the pond skim is this Sunday as well. So Sandra, if you have a costume, you want to get out there and... But yeah, the conditions on the mountain, if you haven't been out, are fabulous, unbelievably good. So if you can play hooky, get out there and enjoy it. So with that, I'll close the commissioner reports and we'll jump into the director's report.

1:00:20 Thank you. For the director's report, I'd like to give a little bit of our time, my time over to Haislip Hayes to provide an update on emergency response. I think he has a brief presentation for the commission. You're up, Hayes. All righty. I don't know how brief it's going to be. I'd like to thank you in advance, Hayes. I know this kind of was a request at the last minute.

1:00:49 Yeah, I was about to throw you under the bus. You got a lot of balls in the air at the moment, so I really appreciate it. I'm going to start with the obligatory. Can you see my screen? Yep. All right, great. Yeah, so Chair Vanderhurst asked that I give an update on the emergency response and recovery related to snow removal and some of the ongoing structural propane issues. I was planning to give a...

1:01:16 presentation tonight at town council, so I had to get my presentation together a little early, so there may be some gaps in here, but you're kind of my guinea pigs here, so let me know how this looks. I'm going to go over some of the town-wide trucking operations, kind of where we're at with the structural assessment and response recovery and the propane issues, response and recovery. Town-wide trucking operations, these were...

1:01:44 Happened through the later part of March through the beginning of April. The trucks were provided by California operations, Ocala OES. The town is paying for the pit fees that cost about $375,000. Operations, like I said, started beginning of March, about the 16th, and they ended on the 7th of February, not February, April, sorry. Areas that were they targeted?

1:02:13 We're arterials and collectors providing better access to heavily populated areas like Canyon Lodge, worked on constrained areas with limited snow storage, cul-de-sacs, some of the streets at higher elevations. There are a lot of variables when we were considering where to work. You know, we had to do a lot of work coordinating parking the day of the week to try not to get in where the tourists were working in residential areas during weekends.

1:02:43 The width of the road, trying to make sure we had access for two-way traffic on some of the constrained areas. We did a lot of messaging through Facebook, through the town of Mammoth Lakes and Petey. They were pretty much building the program on a nightly basis. It was managed by public works engineering staff, Sean Troy, Colin, Riley, working 12, 14 hours a day managing these trucks, seven days a week.

1:03:10 12 hours a day the trucks ran, except during the storms. They were wrangling up to 44 trucks a day and three loaders that were provided by Cal OES. In total, they did 5,706 loads of snow, which is about 57,000 cubic yards. And doing a little bit of math, that's about 30 million pounds of snow or 4,625,000 gallons of water.

1:03:36 That got trucked out to the Forest Service snow pit. Down in the right-hand corner, you can see a photo of what that looked like. The map of the areas, we kept pretty good track of where we were and where we were working. Green areas where we widened things with a blower and trucks. Some of these locations we hit multiple times. There was a two-foot storm in the middle of our operations. We had to go back into some of the areas in the slopes and widen roads again.

1:04:03 I tried to get into all the neighborhoods at least once. Some were in way better shape than others, but we were able to spread the love around and make a pretty good dent in some of these constrained streets. Here's a couple photos of the work that was being done. Upper left is just our contract operator just using a bucket to dump snow in the back of the truck.

1:04:27 A bigger photo on the right is we were able to, in some of the streets, sneak a snowblower in, a Kodiak, and then blow right into the back of the truck. So they could load a truck in 25 seconds with that snowblower, so that was significantly more efficient. When we were doing those blower operations, we really had a lot more success and did a lot more loads out to the pit. And then bottom left is just a line of cars you may have seen on Main Street when we were trucking out.

1:04:57 for Caltrans. I'll stop here. Any questions on the trucking operations? Any questions for Hayes? I would just love to say congratulations, Hayes. I know that was an unbelievable endeavor to organize that and make it happen. And as a member of the community, it was pretty impressive to see what is nothing less than an armada of dump trucks moving around town.

1:05:26 As far as I know, there were no incidents with crashes or people getting run over, anything along those lines, correct, Hayes? I think there were two really minor fender benders. And I think it was a car slid into a dump truck on a, it wasn't our truck sitting anybody. I think there may have been one truck that dinged a dump truck, but that was the extent. And for considering the number of operations, I think it went.

1:05:56 Pretty well. Definitely some cowboy traffic control, considering the limited number of services. We did have a couple PD folks from out of area help us out in a couple of days, but definitely did this on a shoestring with resources. So appreciate the kind words. Yeah, and my street that I live on was one of the ones that you did the blower directly into the dump trucks and it made a significant...

1:06:22 difference, major improvement on the accessibility of the street, so kudos on that. And also congratulations on regaining access to the Forest Service snow pit. My understanding is the snow pit out at Snow Creek was becoming a liability just in terms of access and amount of snow storage available. Is that correct?

1:06:45 We had plenty of storage out at the Snow Creek pit. The problem was the road. As soon as we got into March and the sun got a little higher, the road started melting out. And typically in the winter, we're driving over effectively like permafrost. And as soon as we got some heat in the ground, that road just got sloppy. And we were putting an incredible amount of effort just trying to keep that road open when we could.

1:07:10 And it got to a point where we would have probably had to haul in an incredible amount of material to reconstruct it just to keep it open. And it just wasn't reasonable. And Forest Service recognized that and allowed us to open up the old pit, which really allowed for more efficient operations. You know, we're incredibly grateful to Chuck and his team for allowing us to use that facility at Snow Creek Gate. We definitely needed it in a pinch and we definitely needed it this winter.

1:07:40 We never imagined we'd be trucking well into April. That is unprecedented. In 16-17, we did 6,000 loads total for the entire community. And just this operation was almost 6,000. I think we'll probably do break the record by two and a half to three times for the number of trucks total for the community. So we definitely needed both sites throughout the winter. And hopefully we'll be able to keep the Forest Service site

1:08:10 for this foreseeable future. Fingers crossed on that partnership. Thank you, Hayes, if you want to continue your presentation. Yep, I've only got a couple hours left. So structural assessment, response and recovery. So as you know, we've had, we transitioned from what was like a winter storm event and an incredible amount of snow on the streets to a lot of structural failures and that came on very rapidly.

1:08:36 And our program is still ongoing. It's still developing. We're still finding, you know, things to work on and ways to make it better. But effectively, it really kicked off with an evacuation warning in the middle of March for damaged structures. And we tipped up a call center, brought in some support from Cal OES, the SAP team, we call them. It's a structural assessment program.

1:09:02 We had some deployments from Urban Search and Rescue USAR teams, and they have structural specialists, civil engineers and structural engineers embedded in those teams that we leveraged to help to do assessments around town. We tipped up an online survey that we pushed out through social media and our websites to crowdsource effectively winter storm damage and alert people to indeed to involve us when they find structural damage on there.

1:09:32 in their homes or their Airbnbs, if you will. We put a call center together and then we put it out on social media and we tipped up a CMS board on 203 to let people know coming into town that we had this hotline available if they checked into their unit and found damage, which did happen.

1:09:55 And then obviously call 911 if you have a collapse or you find an unsafe situation or a propane leak. This is not to supplant those efforts. If it's something serious, definitely call 911 first. We collected all the data from all these sources, Cal OES, the USAR teams and the town all use different platforms to collect information. We consolidated that initially into a spreadsheet and later into QuickBase.

1:10:26 There's over 440 structures that have been reported in Mammoth. I think it's 650 total countywide. Currently, there's 65 red tags out there and 54 yellow tags. That number fluctuates as we move people or residences in and out of these conditions, depending on what work they're doing. In general, what these tags mean, this is based on basically guidance ATC-20.

1:10:57 We put together back in the late 80s, early 90s for evaluating structures rapidly in earthquake conditions. And it's kind of become the standard for all kind of disaster situations for rapidly evaluating the condition of a structure. Green tag means that it's been inspected as safe, but it could have damage. It could have issues that need to be resolved. Red tag is the opposite side of the spectrum where it is unsafe.

1:11:25 There is significant damage and there's an imminent threat. And then a yellow tag can really be all of the above, everything in between and could be a green tag or a red tag. It's basically limiting entry. There's some risk in all or part of the structure, but it doesn't warrant completely making it unsafe and unhabitable. They can limit occupancy.

1:11:52 And duration or who can go in it with that placard. And we'll write up on the placard when we post on the door what needs to be done or what the issues are and who made those decisions. In order to get rid of those tags, it's going to take time. There's a pretty long path to recovery. There's a significant amount of damage out there in the community. We're managing that database to ensure that we're closing the loop on our tags.

1:12:22 Making sure we're contacting residents and tenants and HOAs to let them know of the situation and providing good information to the public on next steps using email, letter campaign. We got some web and social media components that we're going to be pushing out little pieces on what you can do. We've developed a couple of communication tools, a tag status application, a reoccupation action requirement form.

1:12:50 These are forms we can, you know, have filled out and give to the owners and residents and tenants and so forth. I'm not going to go through, but I wanted to kind of show what this database looks like. This, I'm really proud of the team that put this together and they tipped this thing up in a matter of a couple of weeks and it is incredibly valuable, not only now for the work we're trying to do, but in the future of managing red tags and propane calls and kind of these

1:13:19 Types of incidents. It was put together by a couple of town members and Mono County IT. And this is just a snapshot of, you know, all of the structures that have been reported. There's over a thousand records now, and it's showing on the snapshot 615 structures that we're managing. You can drill down from there into any unit. At the bottom, it shows all of the various inspections that have occurred.

1:13:48 Thank you so much for joining us today.

1:14:18 Robust tool that's going to allow us to effectively manage the recovery of this incident. General kind of conditions to remove tags. I'm sure this is probably the number one question people are asking out there, what they need to do. Units with structural damage will require a structural analysis from a California licensed engineer. The rapid assessments we do are just, we identify damage. We say it needs to be

1:14:47 Remediated, but we don't start tearing down drywall and looking for the totality of the damage. An engineer will need to do that and figure out how to fix all of those structural systems. And then they'll need to get building permits for those repairs. Snow removal. A lot of these tags are, all of them, are related to snow issues. So removing the hazard, removing the snow is probably step one in moving towards getting back into these units.

1:15:15 Sometimes shoring is necessary. You've probably seen the shoring out at DIY or Juniper Springs or a couple other places in town to kind of make buildings safe on a temporary basis. We are requiring that as part of any permit, they have to remove snow from their LPG infrastructure. We've had a huge increase in propane calls and to support the fire department. We're requiring this as part of any process to get back into the unit.

1:15:43 And then obviously inspections, working with the building department to take a look at these units. A couple pictures, what we see, and it's really hard to capture what we're seeing out there. Taking a picture of cracked drywall really doesn't tell the story. So I teased out a few photos that can show, you know, what we see in some of these structural members. You drive around town and it's hard to imagine that we're in a disaster type situation. You know, this isn't.

1:16:13 Wichita, Kansas, where a tornado went through and everything's destroyed. You drive by units and you really have no idea that they're damaged and they're in pretty bad shape. These two photos here are cracked roof members. These had significant snow loads, 10, 12 feet of snow on them. The one on the left, it cracked all the way through. The one on the right, that's a 23-foot span that cracked.

1:16:40 Where there used to be a structural support, that's an illegal remodel, and they took out the structural support and the beam cracked, and that roof is at risk of collapsing. On the left-hand side, that's an A-frame, that you can see how much lateral force was in that to crack that structural member. On the right-hand side, you see snowshed ripped off the whole front end of a home. A couple walkways, one with some temporary shoring, you can see the yellow placard on the left-hand side.

1:17:13 Right-hand side, I mean, just total failure of a structural member holding up an eve. And these are just kind of a couple of things that we've seen out there. On the left-hand side here, some additional shoring on some architectural members above a number of entrances to a complex. On the right-hand side, these are roof trusses that buckled and failed. There were seven of them in a row.

1:17:41 This kind of shows you can't see all the damage. There's a ton of blown-in insulation in this photo. Our rapid assessment, we just see that this roof truss has failed, but someone will need to go in there and pull out of the insulation to make sure that all the other members are secure or provide the remediation if necessary. And there was a good six to eight inches of deflection in that structure still, even after they had removed the snow. So a lot of work needs to be done to make that right, and only an engineer is really qualified.

1:18:10 to prescribe that type of work. Stop here before I go on to propane. Any questions about what we're doing on our structural response and recovery? Any questions for Hayes on the tags? I have a question, Hayes. You mentioned the red and yellow tags that they have to have an engineer or someone to come out before the tag can be removed. What about the green tags? Yeah, it's interesting. You can have a red tag go to a green tag.

1:18:39 If an engineer goes into the building and says, hey, if you do these things, shore it up, then you can use it until there's another snow loading condition. So we'll see tags move from red to green. You can use it, but you have to make all the fixes by, you know, next winter, pick a date. Some of these green tags are really simple. Remove the snow, clear up an entry, and then we'll close the loop on that and close out the tags, the red and yellow.

1:19:08 There's a lot of variability. The reds are where we've seen significant structural failure and there's an imminent threat. Those are the ones that are requiring an engineer. The yellows, again, a lot of variability in what we've seen. Some of them will just need basic fixes come in for a building permit. Some will need significant engineering. It's consistently inconsistent, but pretty significant in the amount of damage that's out there.

1:19:36 So when the tags have, or when the identified work that the tag describes has been completed, do the homeowners contact the town? What is the process on that? So again, it's all different for every situation. Basically, if you have structural damage, an engineer will need to go in there, do an assessment and prescribe the fixes.

1:20:03 And then design the fixes. And then you'll have to get building permits to do the fixes. Once those building permits have been closed out, then the tags can be removed. There can be a lot of different ways that gets done. Some of the yellow tags, they'll just need to come in and get a building permit for the fix or just prove that they've removed the snow and the hazard's been abated. Again, that's why we have these communication tools. Any owner can get a hold of the building department.

1:20:33 Ask for a status and kind of the next steps that they need to take for their particular situation. There is no single answer that covers all of our situations. Thank you. Commissioner Chang, any questions on the tags? A couple of questions, Hayes. So to be clear, people don't contact public works. They contact building department for these building structural assessment or recovery related issues.

1:21:04 That is correct. Public Works is involved because we have engineers on the Public Works side that are supporting the building department and the assessment and the ongoing kind of management. This is an all hands on deck type situation and we needed to pull resources from multiple departments to help support this effort. But building is the lead on the remediation side. Got it. Okay. You know, the photos that you have shown here.

1:21:35 with your presentation. Are they on our Facebook, Town's Facebook, that we can sort of kind of alert the communities that, hey, you know, these are the signs that you need to look for. Don't just sit in your living room and wait for it to come down. No, these are not public facing. These are private residencies are from our own stash of photos when we were doing assessments.

1:22:08 I think we could push out some, maybe use some of these photos in our social media campaign to say, hey, if you see things like this, that's bad. Yeah, I think that would be a great idea, just in case. Yeah. I don't want to turn this into story time, but we've definitely seen people who were oblivious to the structural failures above their head with cracking beams and failing structure and not really taking it seriously. Right.

1:22:38 But it's a step-by-step, you know, where there's a lot to be done and we're kind of working through it systematically. You know, given the fact that you have 440 structural issues or tags, how do you have enough staff to handle all this between building and public works? So a lot of those assessments were done early on when we had a team of SAP engineers. Those are...

1:23:11 Those Cal OES structural analysis folks, their engineers and state workers that came to support us. A lot of that work was done early on to assess critical infrastructure and the kind of initial push to evaluate buildings. Right now we're kind of in a, it's a slow burn, if you will, where we're getting a few a day. There's, you know, we'll get up to, you know, a handful.

1:23:40 that we need to go assess. We can manage that with our existing team of people who are qualified. There's only the 440 is what's been done in total. We're really focusing on the tags. The red and yellow are really most concerned. The green tags are kind of in a better state and we've been pushing out communication on the status of those by email just recently. But the management's going to require additional resources we're talking about.

1:24:09 How we're going to staff the administrative side to manage the request for information on tag status, pulling historic plan sets and previous permits to help engineers make good decisions and assessments. We're looking at pulling in resources to help with the plan check side. We do have a lot of contract plan check, but we'll need some assistance at looking at some of these engineering documents that we're anticipating.

1:24:36 We've had a couple conversations with some of our previous inspectors and asking them to come back as retired annuitants. We're looking at contract inspection for some of the larger sites. We will have to staff up for all three components. So right now we're managing, we're triaging the situation and I think we're covering it pretty well, but the recovery is going to require additional resources. Thank you, Hayes. Two really quick questions, Hayes.

1:25:05 Appreciate the presentation. The status website you showed us a little bit earlier, a couple of slides back, is that public facing so people can see what the status is of their home or their neighbor's home or, yeah, is that a link that can be shared with the public or is that more internal? No, this is all internal. This is our management system that was put together. This is what we transitioned the spreadsheet to a database and this is what the team is using to manage.

1:25:35 The status of the tags, the communication process, any information that we collect, photos, some of these have multiple inspections on them from multiple parties. This is where we're keeping all that data kind of in one spot so we can help give good information to public and make good decisions. Got it. So that's internal information. It's all internal. Yeah, we don't have anything forward-facing to kind of see what your neighbors are up to. Got it.

1:26:05 And then the second question I have, and I'm sure this is not the norm, but in the rare occurrence where somebody's second home has been red tagged because of obvious structural damage, how is that homeowner contacted? Great question. Right now we are merging our database with

1:26:31 tax assessor database and our business tax certificate database where we keep our TOT type certs and that it's allowing us to tease out addresses and contact information where we've crowdsourced it through our web portals and by phone we have email addresses and we've already pushed out communication just yesterday on that.

1:26:56 Hopefully by week's end, we'll have merged all the database and we'll have another letter campaign that goes out to those residents. And if we find gaps and we'll have to work through that and find other means to locate these individuals. And it could be, you know, it could be tagging things on people's doors and are going through their HOAs or contacting neighbors to identify them. It's going to take some work to locate some of these individuals, I believe. And we've definitely tagged some vacant homes.

1:27:26 And these residents may not be aware that their structure has been significantly damaged. Thank you, Hayes. If you want to continue, I think. Oh, I'm sorry. I didn't until I thought of it now. But Hayes, can you, I guess I'm curious how long the building permit process takes and is that going quickly for when people have a structural engineer, contractor, whatever, who's willing to help them? Is that the building permit process is pretty streamlined?

1:27:54 It's the typical process. I think the turnaround time is no more than 10 days if it's an outside plan check. We're hoping to shore up our services so we can do some of these smaller fixes in-house and turn those around quickly. But some of these are going to be significant and we'll need to send out the structural assessment report for review and then some of the more complicated engineering will probably need to get sent out. So it could take time.

1:28:23 Obviously, we're going to try to find the most efficient path forward to help out our residents, but it's really difficult to commit to a timeline when every situation is so unique. Makes sense. Thank you. Any other questions on the tags? No? Thank you, Hayes. You can proceed. All right. So we went from a snow emergency to a structural emergency, and we're currently in the propane emergency. I don't know what the next emergency is, but I'm hoping this is the end of it. Locus, Hayes, Locus.

1:28:53 Locus' Department of Agriculture, as far as I'm concerned, I think that gets public works out of it. So I think I'm okay with that. So propane issues, and this is really taking a lot of coordination with the fire department. They're the lead on managing those types of emergencies. But you've probably heard we are experiencing significantly higher normal call volume regarding propane leaks and breaks.

1:29:22 And some of these have been really serious and caused significant damage. You've heard of the two buildings that exploded. Fortunately, no one's been killed, but we have had some injuries. The fire department responds to propane calls and coordinates with the propane provider. And there have been a significant number of broken lines that have filled residences with propane. And fortunately, there weren't any significant explosions other than the ones we know have been.

1:29:52 This is a chart that the fire department's been tracking on propane incidents. I think the average is right around five or six a day. And that trend line has been growing over time starting, this is basically March through yesterday. And talk a little bit about the process to reinstate service. Typically, any type of plumbing connections and lines requires a permit.

1:30:22 from the building department. And we provide information on red, yellow and green tags. So the fire department has been using a very similar process to tag buildings and communicate with us. They're using the same database and the same collection tools to provide information to the town on what propane calls they've been on.

1:30:46 We've made some tweaks to it and I think I've skipped over it, but we actually have an application on all of our cell phones that allows us to do assessments remotely and to do inspections on facilities remotely and the fire department has that. They have their own drop down for propane calls so that we can isolate them and then we can help to

1:31:08 Provide the appropriate information to get service back on. And sometimes they find structural issues and they'll tag it for a structural issue and a propane issue. So we have the ability to kind of communicate back and forth through our applications and our database. Inspection of all systems, lines, tanks, regulators, and safety valves is required before we get service back on. And we are requiring that all this be cleared of snow. And that can be a monumental task when you're talking about apartment complexes that have been turned off. We understand that.

1:31:37 That's what it requires to be safe. Propane pressure tests and leak tests are required. And then sometimes interior and exterior inspections are required to turn on the propane, depending on what kind of appliances and so forth are in the residences or commercial buildings. There are a lot of parties involved with this process. I keep talking about a layered cake of property managers, HOAs, owners, tenants.

1:32:07 And sometimes even property managers in between that handle like Airbnbs and such. So a lot of people involved. And so we were asking that everybody kind of work together, work with your tenants, your owners, your HOA to make sure all the appropriate people are involved. The town is not going to determine who's responsible. We're not going to point the finger at so-and-so has to do this. That is for the private sector to determine. You have to work within your contracts and your...

1:32:36 CCNRs and so forth. But the town and the fire department will provide oversight of the permitting and inspection process. And I will mention that sometimes these things happen as an emergency basis and we get our permitting after the fact. Generally, the propane provider or their agents or contractors will secure the permits and then the owners need to contact and work with the town.

1:33:04 to make sure that everything's getting inspected and turned back on appropriately. We have pushed out a fair amount of information on propane. There's a link to our website with a whole bunch of like propane safe information about cleaning out your regulators, making sure that it's accessible, putting up a reflector above the assemblies of the fire department can find it. The chief put out a YouTube video.

1:33:32 on, you know, how to mitigate, you know, exposure for propane issues and what to do to keep your home safe. That's the end of my presentation. I'm happy to answer any more questions. And tonight I'll actually have the fire department for the propane portion. So if it seemed a little light, it's because I'll be leaning on Alex to really get into some of the details, but he's not available. He wasn't available for this presentation.

1:34:02 Any questions for Hayes on propane? No question from me, but Hayes, thank you for that presentation. And I appreciated the chief, the fire chief did that video on Facebook, on YouTube, shortly after they visited my home because I experienced a similar situation and it was...

1:34:33 I was naive enough to think that I didn't blow up the building so I could enter the building. But unfortunately, I woke up the next morning. But I think it is a homeowner's responsibility. You need to call 911. You need to make these inspections and consult experts on these things. And if you're not sure, you need to call 911 immediately.

1:34:59 I made the mistake of not calling 911 right away. I called Marigas first. And Marigas then said to me, you should have called 911 first. So I think that's really important. That's, you know, that's a good lesson that I've learned. Hey, I've got a quick question and you are 100% entitled to say, I do not know as the answer.

1:35:25 Last week, we had a pretty interesting situation where the MLT offices actually got red-tagged by the fire department because of a propane leak in the complex and the Forest Service Administrative Building was shut down, our offices were shut down and the Welcome Center were shut down. Fortunately, Marigas came right out because we were considered essential between us and the Forest Service and fixed the problem within hours.

1:35:53 But the Amerigas staff that was there was saying that they're significantly backlogged. Do you have any idea how long the backlog is for them to get out and inspect? I do not. I'd have to check in with Amerigas and find out where they're at with the status. We've been sending them all the information on all the calls. So all the propane information we're collecting from the fire department does get sent to them. So they're aware of what's out there.

1:36:24 I do know that Amerigas brought in 15 technicians from out of area to help support this incident. I don't know what that means in terms of response time. I know they've been working with us and working with the fire department to try to mitigate this situation best they can, but I would have to reach out and get more information if it's something you're really interested in. Got it. No, might be something for your presentation tonight, though.

1:36:50 Yeah, the two guys that came out to our offices were both from Virginia, the Amerigas guys, so they were on it very, very quick. And Hayes, now that you've pretty much got your presentation buttoned up, take a long lunch, buddy. No, I'm going to go talk about potholes now. That's the next emergency is fixing roads. I actually had a question on that. You got him. Any thoughts on Sierra Nevada Road, how that's, if that's...

1:37:18 Are there any plans in the works? Yes. So tonight, a town council will be asking council to approve a resolution to forego bidding procedures and award a contract for emergency work for roads around town to the tune of about a half a million dollars. Meeting with the contractor here shortly to figure out that work program. Sierra Nevada is definitely on the list. It is beyond our ability to repair with our cold mix and

1:37:48 Hothole repair mixes. It's completely destroyed. So we need an emergency contract to repair that section of road. And there's a few others in town that are really bad that we need a higher level of support on. Cool. Great to hear. So we're working on it. Awesome. And then I just wanted to say that the Facebook posts from Town of Mammoth Lakes and Police Department have been really good. I've seen a ton of them and it feels like you guys are really getting info out to the right people. So thank you for everything.

1:38:18 Hey, can these fixes be permanent or is it just super temporary with the contractors that are coming in? For the pothole stuff? Oh, little column A, little column B. Something like Sierra Nevada, we can't patch. That's going to have to be completely cut out and reconstructed. There'll be patches where we just hot mix them in, we'll grind them out and they'll be temporarily permanent.

1:38:46 And then there'll be everything in between. The goal will be to get as many sections of road smoothed out as quickly as possible, knowing that we'll have to do a larger assessment later in the summer, and that will definitely influence our paving program for 2024. We're already pretty booked for 2023. We don't have the capacity to add a giant road project. Our road projects are Laurel Mountain in the stuff in the parcels, so we already had plans to work on roads.

1:39:15 So this is really just stopgap measures to smooth things out and then we'll have to reassess and we may have to go back and reconstruct in a year from now. Hayes, the half a million dollars that you're asking for tonight towards potholes and road rehabilitation, is there any chance that the state or federal partners can backfill that? We're hopeful. I'm meeting with FEMA tomorrow.

1:39:43 And we'll give them a tour of damaged areas around town. I think we'll hit the thresholds to get additional support. How that funding works is really for the finance team and how that reimbursement occurs is not something I have a lot of familiarity with. I know that the town manager is recommending to do this work regardless. It needs to be done.

1:40:10 But it would be great if we got reimbursed so we could put that money towards other fun stuff. Any other questions for Hayes? Hayes, we appreciate it. Again, thank you for putting this together on the fly. Good luck tonight and huge kudos to you and your team for everything you guys are doing out there. Like I said, the armada of dump trucks that took snow out of this town last week was incredible. So congratulations on that.

1:40:39 Appreciate that. I'll pass along the kind words. I'm just a reflection of all the people doing the hard work, so I'll make sure they know that you appreciate them. Thank you, Hayes. Take care. Sandra, was there anything else on the director's report? Just a couple of other items. During this meeting, I did email Mono County Environmental Health about the mosquito abatement, and Louis Molina, who's the head of Environmental Health, said that the county doesn't have any mosquito abatement or vector control services.

1:41:06 And that Mammoth Lakes Mosquito Abatement District is really limited to Old Mammoth. So outside of Old Mammoth, there isn't any mosquito abatement. So we will work on a town from, I guess, from code enforcement, just to put out information about this, but I don't think it would be something that the town would be funding, but just information about ways you can, what you can do to prevent mosquitoes kind of around your home and that type of thing. So I sent an email to Jenna Carter, our code compliance officer, just to ask her to...

1:41:36 Find something, I'm sure plenty of other communities talk about this and then we can push that out. Sure, thank you. And then just two other items. One is that I attended the Planning Commissioner's Academy last month in Garden Grove and spoke to the commissioners about, it was just kind of a Q&A type session, just about how we talked about housing, our housing program, prescribed ADUs, the general plan, housing elements.

1:42:00 Talked a little bit about ways, you know, good ways to run Planning Commission meetings, those types of things. So it was a really fun session and they put this on every year about that time, about the end of March. So maybe think about it for commissioners that haven't attended. Commissioner Chang and Vice Chair Burroughs attended in 2020. So if it's something that you would like to attend, keep it in mind for March of 2024, which I would assume would be in Sacramento again. I think they go.

1:42:29 Back and forth, kind of Northern California and Southern California. And then the other item is on the Mammoth Creek Inn, the town has started the process of the receivership and has started citing the property owner for not complying with our agreement. We have looped in attorneys as well to participate in this. It isn't a quick process, receivership, but we have started it. And the property owner has responded and has asked for additional time.

1:42:59 But we're communicating with them that we're going to continue moving forward with this process. So we'll keep you updated, but it does take some time. It requires town council to authorize us to move forward with that, and it also requires us to go to court, and the court has to appoint a receiver. So the judge would have to listen to our case, listen to the property owner's case, and make a decision to appoint a receiver. So it's not just a done deal, but that process is moving forward. So receivership is basically...

1:43:29 And we've done this in the past. So if a property owner has nuisances and can't abate those or won't abate those, the town for residential properties only, any property that has a residential component, you can go to court and have a receiver appointed. The receiver is a third party that comes in and basically owns your property during this process. So you don't have any ownership of that property during the process.

1:43:53 And so the receiver would then come in, hire a contractor, come in and finish all the work, either whatever it is, either demolish the work or rehab the project. At the end of the process, the receiver would then sell the property back to the property owner or someone else. They'll put it up on the market. And the receiver will then pay themselves, pay the town, and then any residual money coming out of the sale, let's say the property owner didn't bid on it, any residual money after the receiver pays themselves and the town.

1:44:21 And any legal costs would then go back to the property owner. So they would get their money back. They would get some money back out of it. But that's basically the process. It is not desirable for a property owner. No property owners want their property to go into receivership because you lose control of the property during that time. And you obviously could lose money, right? The receiver costs money. It's not cheap. And then all of the legal bills, all the town's bills would get paid. So yes.

1:44:52 It's residential. It's not 100% residential, but it has a residential component. Those units in the back are residential, which can be rented on a short-term basis. And that's the process that we used. So we also threatened this process with La Sierra. And La Sierra, which ultimately the property owner decided to remove it on their own. We didn't have to go through the receivership process. But La Sierra, I think back in the 60s, had a residential component.

1:45:22 We were able to prove that, and that was the only way we were able to go through that process was because it had a residential component. At any time in its past has it been used for residential, and that could be a manager's unit, those types of things. So if someone's living on the site, you're able to do that. There's probably other ways. We've never dealt with that here, but we've dealt with a couple. We did have a receiver for a property up on Lakeview.

1:45:50 It had a significant retaining wall that was failing. The property hadn't been maintained, and it was an older person who owned it who didn't live in town. And we went through that process, and a receiver was appointed, and they fixed that retaining wall and completely remodeled that home. And then they ended up selling it back to the property owner. He wanted to buy it back. But that property was at risk of falling down into the street, the retaining wall. It's a significant retaining wall that was failing.

1:46:17 So we've only done it a couple of times, but we have Best Best Krieger that we use for code compliance issues, and so we loop them in on anything like this so that they can help us go through this process. Please. Why is having such a gift this thing? I'm not sure what the holdup is, and Jenna Carter. I think they just need more. I think they just need more. My guess is that it's related to funding, is just the funding to do the construction, but.

1:46:57 I don't know. Jenna Carter is pulling together the summary of when the building permit was issued. I don't know when it was issued, but it's years that the building permit has been issued. It's just taking a long time. It's an eyesore, and that is a nuisance under our code. We've already established that it's a nuisance. We've sent them a notice, and we're...

1:47:24 Working with a property owner, we certainly want to work with a property owner, and last year, a year ago in March, we entered into a compliance agreement with them where they agreed to complete the project within a year. And so they were, I mean, the buildings were already basically built last year, so it's, you know, there's a lot of work to do, but they were, they had made significant progress last year, so they had a year, and basically in March, I think it was sometime mid to late March when the compliance agreement expired.

1:47:52 That's when we started this process. So, I mean, obviously, our goal is to work with property owners to gain voluntary compliance. It's expensive, time-consuming to go through these processes. We don't want to do that. We want to get them to comply on their own. But if we can't get voluntary compliance, sometimes we have to use these measures. All right. Any other questions? So currently, there is no work being done on those two structures? As far as I know, nothing has been done in the last...

1:48:21 Couple months. I know they've been out there here and there. So they have been out. I think they installed some windows. They've been doing kind of little things here and there. But no significant work. In the fall, they were doing some work. And we were hopeful that they might be able to meet this deadline. But then it kind of dropped off. And understandably, the weather has been an issue. And that's kind of what the property is saying. The weather's been an issue. And we understand that. But it has been a full year that they've had to do all of this work. So that's why we're continuing.

1:48:49 Got it. So once the legal process has been completed and the receiver is in control, that is the person who restarts the remodeling or the build-out? They would hire a contractor to finish all of the work. Got it. It's a completely separate person from who's been doing the work out there now. So the property owner is basically done. They don't have the ability to do any more work there. The receiver would then be in complete control of that project.

1:49:17 Would hire a contractor, whatever needs to be done. They would hire someone to do it all and they move quickly. It's in their best interest to get that project done as fast as possible so that they can turn it back around and move on to other projects. And they're very efficient receivers. Is there any outcome where the town takes control? No. There is no outcome, okay. No. It would always be private. Yeah, it would be a receiver. And that's what most cities do because the town doesn't, we don't have the capacity to hire a contractor to do that work.

1:49:46 And that's the process that most cities use. I mean, I guess if there was a point at which the property was for sale for a reasonable price and maybe we wanted to purchase it for a housing program, that might be something to consider, but that's not the intent right now. It's intended to be kind of an annex to Mammoth Creek Inn, right, so that they would have additional transient rental there. So, and that's not on our radar at this point. Got it. Thank you, Sandra. Any questions on Mammoth Creek Inn?

1:50:15 You said Annex. I thought it's the same ownership. It is, but it's a separate building. Separate building. So it's not, it's not, Annex is just kind of separation. All right. No other questions? Then I appreciate that, Sandra. Thank you for the update. And I'm going to adjourn today's meeting until our next meeting, which is on the 10th of May, 9 a.m., Suite Z, 2023.

1:50:45 So with that, thank you for your time, guys. I appreciate it. Have a great day. Of course. I was in Northern Europe for...