TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2023

Town Council Special meeting

at 16:00

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

362 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:12 Thank you.

1:55 Good afternoon. Welcome, everybody, to this very special joint meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Town Council and the Monroe County Board of Supervisors. Welcome all. Great to see you.

2:49 You all here today, we haven't done this in a while, someone's going to tell us when the last time it was that we did this. But always good to get together. We have some special guests, but before we get to all that, Jamie, I guess if you can call the roll. Councilmember Bubzer? Here. Councilmember Ray is absent. Councilmember Rice? Here. Mayor Pro Tem, Sauser? Present. Mayor Wentworth? Here. Supervisor Garter? Here. Supervisor Salcido? Here.

3:17 Pro Tem Chair Kreitz is absent. Vice Chair Peters is absent. Chair Dugan, here. Excellent. Thank you very much. And to kick things off this afternoon, District Ranger Fred Wong has agreed once again to lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance. Of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

3:56 All right, so before we get started, any public comments for things that are not otherwise on today's agenda? Not seeing anything here in the room? Anything out there? Jamie? Okay, thank you. So with that, we're going to get started. We've got some very special guests. In light of the unprecedented winter we're still trying to digest. So I think, Dan, do I turn this over to you and to Mary? Yeah, I can kick it off real quick.

4:26 Myself and Mary and some others from the liaison committee kind of work together on the agenda, but we'll walk through a few items here as we have the first agenda item dealing with the extreme weather state of emergency that we've gone through and kind of looking at where we're at in the recovery process on that, looking at some of the response efforts and then ultimately in the after action planning process. So all of that will be coming to us. What I did want to be able to kick off was

4:56 We have the FEMA Disaster Recovery Center open here in Mammoth and I believe the one in Bridgeport is open this afternoon as well, right? So getting a good feel for the resources that are in town as part of the key recovery element I think is an issue for us that we need to get out to the community. Pass out some of the flyers that are just now coming out today, a lot of the media or social media work we're trying to do and just information-wise.

5:26 I just want to take a look at these, but ultimately these will have a Spanish version on the back of them as well, so, but hot off the press today and we'll be looking at some other outreach efforts we can talk about as we get down the road. But I think right now I'd like to introduce Maria Figueroa, if I said that correctly, with FEMA. She can give a good overview of the process with FEMA and the center and

5:56 I will say right before this meeting, we always had a chance to kind of tour the center where it's set up and looks pretty impressive and lots of resources in the community. So encouraging people to take advantage of that. So with that, Maria, if we could turn it over to you and have you walk through where you're at in the process and kind of what that center is all about in the recovery process. Thank you. Good afternoon. I am not there.

6:23 Physically, I am in Monterey County, but from what I know, and if the emergency manager is here, you can't correct me, you have our disaster survivor assistance teams going around, registering people door to door, and also you open the disaster recovery center, which we call the one-stop shop, because there people can go register for assistance with FEMA, with SBA.

6:52 Talk about mitigation and also get county resources and other state resources that you might have at the DRC. It is very convenient for people to register at the DRC because they can go come face to face with a person and, you know, help. They can get help through the process, what documents they need to upload, etc. Sorry for that. The process begins.

7:21 With the emergency declaration, there is money for the county to start the process of evacuating people and getting some emergency sheltering and relocation. Then you get the major declaration, which by that time will put IA, the declaration for individual assistance in place.

7:50 When you register for IA, when we tell the people to register, we also tell them that they have to file a claim with their insurance because sometimes their insurance takes too long and we don't want them to be without any, with unmet needs while they're waiting for their insurance to come. So the three major sources of funding for the disaster are your insurance, SBA, and then FEMA.

8:19 Insurance is your homeowner's insurance and also the NFIP National Flood Insurance Program. You start by getting your information to IA. What do you need to apply? First of all, you need a social security number. If you don't have a social security number, but one person in your household has a social security number, you can apply.

8:45 Through that person's social security number as a co-applicant. If the person is a minor, he will be the applicant. The rest of the family will be the co-applicant. Now, you can also apply if you have a green card or if you have a T or U visa. Once you have registered, you register for rental assistance, lodging rainbows, lodging reimbursement, and home repairs.

9:15 Why does that mean? That the money that FEMA will get you is enough to get your home in safe, sanitary and functional conditions. It's not like you're going to remodel the whole thing. It's for bare necessities, you know, your most important necessities that we give money for so that you have a roof over your head and a place that you can feel safe in.

9:45 Now, when you apply, they're going to ask you for your telephone number so that an inspector can call you and make an appointment to go visit your home. The inspector will try to get in touch with you three times. At the third time, if he hasn't been able to make an inspection, he will come back and say, this person, I haven't been able to contact them. The person will need to register again.

10:15 They just not get served if they don't get an inspection. Once you go into IA, there's money for individuals and household programs that I already talked about, rental assistance, reimbursement and lodging, and there's also other needs assistance. In between those, some people are going to be sent an SBA package, the Small Business Administration package, which is for a loan. Even if you don't want a loan,

10:44 If you get sent the package, you should apply and register with SBA because what happens is if you don't qualify for the loan, then you'll be sent back to FEMA for the Other Needs Assistance Program. The Other Needs Assistance Program is essentially money for your personal stuff like clothes, your appliances, what you lost inside your house.

11:11 Everything that is outside the house is not covered by FEMA. Now, some people do not qualify for SBA and do not qualify for FEMA assistance. So when we started with the emergency declaration, those who were helping the first responders and the nonprofits like Red Cross and United Way are the ones who are going to help those who FEMA could not help at that moment.

11:41 The NFIP program at this time has what we call the GFIP, the Group Flood Insurance Program. What that does is like when you are applying, FEMA will pay $2,400 for three years. That's the policy for three years. You don't have to pay it. It will come out of your awards. For example, if you get awarded $20,000,

12:09 The money has already been subtracted from that amount. The max ground amount is $41,000 for the individual and household programs, $41,000 for the other needs assistance program. Now we have a third program that's for the access and functional needs persons, and that program has no cap. What does that mean? That means that if

12:39 Before the disaster, you had all that you needed to have in your house, the electronic equipment, a wheelchair, bars, whatever you need to make your life functional, it will be replaced no matter the cost, okay? That's for access and functional needs. It's the only one that doesn't have a cap. Now, that's group flood insurance.

13:09 2,400, it will be paid for three years. What happens after those three years? You will have to pay it on your own because it's the policy states that you have to obtain and maintain the flood insurance policy while you are in that building. There is a separate insurance, which is the National Flood Insurance Program. That policy

13:36 It covers you up to $250,000. That is a different one. Any questions for now? Any questions? I had a question. Oh, yes, please go ahead. Hi, thank you so much for being here. Chris Bubser from the town of Mammoth Lakes. So it sounds like if no one has a social security number and no one has a green card, then there's no assistance. Is that correct?

14:05 Well, if they have a minor or another person in the household who has a social security number, yes. Okay. That person says social security number. But yes, you do need a social security number. If you have a worker's visa, it also works. Okay. Okay. And then also a question about, you said no damage outside the home. Does that include like external structures like people's decks and...

14:32 Roofs. The sheds, and yes. None of that is covered. That is not covered. Okay. It is your house. Your primary residence is what's covered. But not the outside of your primary residence, only the contents. Well, as far as I know, it is only your primary residence. It doesn't include the landscape. It doesn't include the sheds. It doesn't include the fences.

15:06 Okay, thanks. Okay, thank you. And also remember that each individual is different, their circumstances are different, and everything is case by case. I can give you a general overview here, but the person that goes to register, when they...

15:32 I mean, they're not going to tell us every single part of their life. So when we are discussing things, we are discussing them in general because that's privileged information. So you and your neighbor might think that you have exactly the same damages, but since your personal circumstances are different, you might not get the same amount. And when you don't know,

15:57 If you will qualify, you don't disqualify yourself. You call 1-800-621-3362 and you apply and you let FEMA tell you what you're eligible for. Maria, thank you very much. Anything else you want to add? We don't have any questions here for the moment. There may be some coming up a little bit. Thank you. Thank you very much. You're welcome. So now we're going to hear from Mr. George.

16:30 Castrico, is that right? Is George here? I haven't seen him online yet. He was going to try to join, I believe, on Zoom. So if he comes on, we'll bring him in to the conversation. Okay, good. I just want to add first, thanks obviously very much to the county for hosting the FEMA team. Dan and I were over there, took a quick tour. It's impressive. A lot of people there, a lot of resources, a lot of capacity, and nobody's busy. So if you've got constituents or folks who need some help.

17:01 So Dan, I guess, Dan, Mary, we'll move on to our next item. Oh, I had one other question. Sorry. Do you know how long that center will be stood up because people are asking how long they have to file their claim? The center, I believe, is scheduled to be open through the 8th. I don't know if there's a deadline on filing a couple of some of the paperwork said June 5th. So sooner the better, though, to get in and get your...

17:33 Application turned in. I believe that they work through that. So that's the process after that. What are the hours? At the moment, at the moment, the registration deadline is June 5. June 5. Yes. So that's why we tell them apply now as soon as possible. And Maria, what are the hours over there at the center? From 9 to 7, Monday through Saturday. Oh, I'm sorry. The emergency manager has that information. Where's the emergency manager?

18:03 Is he there? Chris, what are the hours over there at the county office building? It's going to be 9 to 6, Monday through Saturday. Okay. And this is at the Civic Center in Mammoth, as well as the Memorial Hall in Bridgeport. It opened up today. Oh, good. Thank you. All right. Well, good. I guess we'll move on now to response. Dan and Mary, who wants to go first? Yeah, we wanted to talk a little bit about the response that the town and county has done.

18:32 The different elements of how we're reaching out to the community and doing different things. And I'll punch the county first. Either Chris or Mary can jump into that, and then we'll have a couple of folks, myself, speak to some of the efforts we're doing in town here. Okay. Chris, why don't you want to kick it off? You know, as far as the response and, you know, on the county and the town's part, we work really seamlessly together with the response and each helping each other out when needed.

19:05 We started having informational meetings on a regular basis in Mono County and the town starting January 4th. We brought in the Cal Fire Incident Management Team to assist after the December-January storms and just prior to the March storm. So we received assistance from them. We were just getting exhausted and tired.

19:31 You know, it was, we were getting overwhelmed at that point. They came in and assisted and they were able to reach out and provide resources that we just couldn't, you know, and there was just a ton of support from them. Just to let you know, with Cal OES resources, whenever I request, they want to know, you know, what have you done to prepare for that or to purchase that ahead of time. And so...

20:01 A lot of times, you know, we have to search and maybe we couldn't get sandbags purchased on our own and receive them when we needed them. So then we would reach out to CalAES. Just kind of an overview of what we requested. And I know this is more on the response side and then I'll get into recovery. But we did request the National Guard three times, three different times. Some of those requests were denied because we were specific to National Guard and then...

20:30 Finally, at the end, it was, we need boots on the ground to help us shovel propane tanks and roofs and things like that. They were able to provide assistance with the Cal Fire hand crews that worked throughout the county in doing prep work. We provided 20 generators. We had pallets of MREs and water to Mono City that were brought in by helicopter.

20:58 We provided firewood to Mono City, Bridgeport, Walker, sump pumps for flooded basements, sandbags. Right now, I think our current inventory stands at $80,000. And we're always, you know, we're keeping a close eye on that to make sure we're prepared. OAS Fire and Rescue operations under the chief's guidance provided the Gulf teams, which were the hand crews, preposition fire apparatus.

21:28 We had USAR teams and Swift Water Rescue teams and dozens of pieces of heavy equipment, dump trucks, loaders, graders, blowers, you know, throughout the county and the town. So, I mean, they really stepped up in pretty much everything we asked for, they provided. We opened shelters in Mammoth and Bridgeport. I know in Bridgeport, we served over a thousand meals to the individuals that were trapped there and just couldn't get out for a period of time.

21:58 So now into the recovery phase. And we're still in a response phase because now we're waiting for the flooding or the runoff, which is weather dependent. And we're working with the experts to try to find out when and where and just preparing the best we can. We're doing prepositioning sandbags and working on all that right now. But right now,

22:27 We're just working to get the word out as far as the FEMA DRCs or Disaster Recovery Centers. They're also on the ground going door to door to assist. We're working with our PIOs to get the word out. And, you know, this weekend, it was really Saturday that we were finally authorized to open the Memorial Hall. So we were kind of holding back on the press releases and really getting the word out.

22:57 So we could say, okay, the center's going to be open on these days and these hours. We didn't want to cause confusion. So we wanted to make sure we had it for sure. So moving forward, we're going to continue to put out the messaging. I'm also, I've requested an extension beyond the June 5th. Whether that is approved or not, we're going to do that just to be sure. Because, I mean, by the time the DRC is here, we're putting the word out.

23:26 That window closed. So it's important that everybody has the opportunity to apply. We are also waiting for our public assistance declaration. And that's just a matter of any day now. Everything has gone through. Everything has been approved. We're just waiting for FEMA's final directive. So that's where we stand right now.

23:54 Good. Okay. I think what we'll do is we'll kind of go around from the agencies and Mary Town, and I know we've got some Forest Service folks here, and they want to add to this, and then we'll come back to all of us when we ask some questions. So, Mary, anything you want to add to all that? Hey, I want to thank the people in the town and in the county who worked tirelessly for weeks on end in response and continue to be ready and prepared as we're...

24:22 Looking at well above normal temperatures now for the next week or so that will result in. And as we look towards runoff planning, we have really different partners on both sides of the county and really two or three really distinct different watersheds that we're trying to be prepared for. So I appreciate all the help and information on the north end. We're working with Walker River Irrigation District. Down on the south end, we're working with L.A.

24:49 Department of Water and Power as well as Southern California Edison and just there's a lot of cooperation that has to happen and all of our staff have done a phenomenal job and I can't thank them enough. Dan? Thanks. Kind of echo that effort in terms of across the town and the county and the various agencies and the number of people engaged and we were fortunate here in Mammoth to really work closely with Cal OES on a number of things. There are SAR teams.

25:18 Search and Rescue Team, Fast Water Rescue Teams that were in town. And that was a key issue for us in terms of responding to buildings that were damaged, red tagged, et cetera. I was going to have Hayes touch briefly on kind of where we're at in that process, both in our response capability and then we're at in that recovery side. They're both kind of ongoing. We're still seeing damages coming out of snow banks. Joking about, you know, destroyed cars are now blooming, things of that nature. So a lot of different work going into that.

25:48 You can touch a little bit on it. We've done one emergency contract for road work. We have another one proposed to the council tomorrow to do a lot of other infrastructure and town facility work. So, Hayes, if you want to touch base on those elements, that'd be great. And I'll say hats off to the public work staff, both our admin staff and our road crews. I think they had five or six weeks of maybe a day off if they were lucky, but I know one gentleman, I think he had, give me how many hours.

26:15 The one went in, but it was like three weeks worth of time in a week or two weeks, whatever it was. It was crazy. But a lot of hours, a lot of work, thanks. Yeah, I think the record was 184 hours in one pay period. So again, I also want to echo, I appreciate working with the county. It was pretty seamless getting the resources into our community. Worked on two major operations that I want to talk about. Working with Cal OES, we brought in 44 trucks. We trucked out 5,700 loads of snow.

26:44 5,700 cubic yards of snow was moved out of this community over the course of three weeks. We dedicated three staff members full-time seven days a week to that operation, and it was instrumental in getting our streets opened up so that emergency services could navigate our community. As the kind of situation transitioned to more of a structural kind of response, we tipped up a database to manage the oncoming calls. We had a call center. We staffed that. And currently, we have 18 red tags outstanding.

27:14 We were up to almost 70 at one point. We have 131 yellow tags. I'm assuming you guys know what these tags are. I've probably heard this spiel before. But currently we have 131 that we're managing and a couple hundred green tags. So this response will take a long time to get through. But the community is starting to get back into their residences. Things are getting fixed. Repairs are being made. And part of our response to...

27:41 The damage that we're seeing is dances that is blooming all over town. We currently have a $500,000 contract for emergency road work repair doing potholes, trying to pick up the work that our crews couldn't do themselves, working on Meridian, Minaret, Old Mammoth, Canyon Boulevard, a lot of arterials and collectors. And then our crews will continue to pothole the lower volume streets in our residential neighborhoods.

28:07 And then tomorrow we're hoping, with Town Council's approval, to authorize a contract for $400,000 to take care of our fencing, our ADA ramps. We have a lot of drainage work that needs to be done, concrete sidewalk repair and so forth. So this will be kind of our catch-all to fix the damage to our parks and our roadway streetscape infrastructure that our crews are just not going to have time to get to. And as Hayes was talking about the snow removal operations,

28:40 We want to recognize Fred Wong from the National Forest Service here, the Inyo Mammoth District. I think that's the best district in the whole forest. They're here. Wait, we have Bill here from Bridgeport as well. But actually getting the snow pit open in the Forest Service. We've gone back and around to some stuff, and Fred had reached out knowing some of the challenges that we had. We were working on a private one that we lost the road on and different elements that way.

29:10 Thank you for that coordination. That really helped when you look at the amount of snow we moved was greater than we've done in any one season for some time. So very challenging from that perspective. And then the other thing would just be the impact related to the national force and some of the challenges they saw. I was going to kind of go north to south, but I'll leave it up to the Forest Service folks. I see Bill is on for up in the...

29:40 An HT area there for Bridgeport, I believe, Bill. If you want to touch base just on the impact of the weather, the snow, and then the planning you're doing right now for being flooded out here in the near future. Sure, yeah, thank you. Good afternoon. I'm Bill Dunkelberger, the Forest Supervisor for the Humboldt-Toyabe National Forest. Coming to you from Reno today, where it's a balmy 85 degrees, and yes, the snow is, the Truckee River is extremely high today. So we're concerned about flooding pretty much all over this.

30:10 So, yeah, I want to thank the county and Cal OES and folks for their work around the Bridgeport area. As you know, we have a ranger station compound housing in Bridgeport. And we had our own road crew engaged up there pretty much full time for about 35 days trying to keep our folks plowed out. But as you know, it was Snowmageddon.

30:38 It's one to go down in the history books. And then I think we did have some need for some firewood. I think I worked with Mary and Supervisor Peters on that, and I think we got that solved. So yeah, currently we do not have a permanent district ranger. I think you all know Megan Maloney, who was our permanent ranger there for the past year, was forced to relocate to Montana.

31:07 She and her husband had some family ties up there that they needed to be closer to. We hated to see her go. She did just a fantastic job for us. But she is now working back in Montana on the Beaverhead Deer Lodge National Forest outside of Dillon. So we currently have our district ranger, Matt Zumstein in Carson City, is overseeing the Bridgeport District as well, short-term. And then we'll have an acting district ranger.

31:35 Starting June 4th for 120 days while we fill the permanent position. And that gentleman is David Risley, who actually used to work on the Bridgeport District as their geologist. So he's familiar with the area. And I do have a map I can share with you. I was asked to talk about any hazardous fuels reduction projects coming up this summer. Let me see if I can share my screen here. It's always different with Zoom.

32:05 Teams. There we go. Can you see the map? You can see the map, Bill, and I want you to give us maybe kind of a quick overview of this because we're going to come back and have a more focused discussion around this stuff a little later in the agenda, but it's good to get it. Oh, okay. Well, yeah, to set the stage, the Humboldtoyabe was very fortunate this year. We were actually selected as one of the 27 wildfire crisis strategy landscapes in the West, and so we are receiving

32:41 Special funding from the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law and Inflation Reduction Act to the tune of $50-plus million for fuels reduction on two of our landscapes on the HT, one of which is the Sierra Front, so that includes the Bridgeport District, the other of which is the Elko-Ruby Mountains area, so our Mountain City-Ruby Mountains-Jarbridge district over there. So we have a significant workload planned. We're actually...

33:10 We've obligated almost $40 million in terms of agreements and contracts so far, the work in both landscapes. Coming up just briefly, I'll go into detail later on, but three main areas for Mono County this year, the Mountain Warfare Training Center will be doing quite a bit of work over the next few years with a signed decision to reduce fuels using a variety of methods, anything from target grazing, sheep grazing to

33:39 So with that, I'll pause and we want to come back later to more

34:09 Bill's reduction, but in the interim, in terms of flooding, let me just give you my cell phone number. I know that I think your sheriff has it, but if something comes up, especially this weekend, feel free to give me a call, 775-720-9963. I've got that on all the time, and we'll make sure that we get our local folks to respond and or evacuate as needed.

34:39 Yeah, we are seeing some road damage. You know, a lot of the forest is still inaccessible, but I heard yesterday we've got some damage on the Buckeye Road, for example. I'm sure we've got lots of potential, you know, down trees and damage coming up as the snowpack melts. Yeah, thanks for that, Bill. We're going to finish digesting the glacier here, and then we'll get right back and talk about the fire. And we're just dealing with the inevitable whiplash of climate change. So we'll digest all this stuff first and get right back.

35:10 So, Fred, anything you want to update on this winter? Yeah. First of all, Leslie couldn't make it up here, so she asked me to cover for her. But, you know, just to give you a little context, when you folks kind of stood up your CAL FIRE incident team, the Nino National Force also set up a similar incident management organization, which helped us bring in resources, crews from the Angeles.

35:39 And other for us to help us shovel our roofs, our federal roofs, our compound with our government buildings, as well as our district office and other places up at Lee Binding. And so that was really helpful. It also brought us some resources as far as funding to hire contractors to help us shovel roofs and heavy equipment to clear some of our areas too. You know, we had minor damage to some of our buildings, walls kind of, the facade kind of peeling off because those,

36:08 You know, snow kind of pushing and ice dams pushing on it, broken windows, that sort of stuff. Right now in the process of trying to hire some contractors, it's very tough, as you folks probably know, finding people, local people to help fix these minor problems here and there. But really the main issue that we had is accessibility to some of our work sites. For example, at Crestview, it's covered with snow, so our and our fire crews and some fire barracks are located back there, so they couldn't get

36:38 As far as transitioning, very similar to you folks. Our incident management organization is kind of slimmed down now to a skeleton crew. However, as soon as the flooding starts picking up, we will...

37:06 Re-staff them to deal with some of the flood stuff. We're also staging sandbags. We're closing some of the roads down south that have a huge amount of damage and safety issues. And so we're preparing for that as well. I should note that the snow is impacting also recreation, as you folks know, accessibility to Reds Meadow as well as Lakes Basin area. It's impacting our concessions. So we're actually...

37:35 Kind of pushing back our reservations in those areas so that you can't reserve anything sooner than certain dates because there's no way that snow is melting out in those areas. So I think really that's all I had. Thank you. Thank you, Fred. Any other agencies? I know I was going to ask Fire Chief Tamir if he would speak just briefly to the USAR teams in the propane challenge.

38:03 Where we're at in that process a little bit. That was a real key issue, I know, for us and other places in the county as well. Austin Meyer, Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District, Fire Chief. Thanks for giving me a minute on this. So I have to kind of point out, I think we're all on the same boat. We actually had my own board meetings and hadn't had one since February. We just pivoted to emergency operations, just getting caught up on admin and our first board meeting.

38:34 About a week ago. It was certainly a topic of importance and our, my board stressed, you know, working with the town and the county obviously on moving forward so that we're not in a similar situation. Just to again kind of reiterate, we had about 140 propane calls that Mammoth Fire responded on. I know we also provided some assistance before our service and June and I obviously had some calls as well. I don't have the numbers on those. Just in about that 45-day period.

39:02 Of those, we had about a dozen homes that were completely full of propane that we had no way to shut off. We had two significant explosions. I would say we did a lot of things right, but I'd also say we were very lucky and fortunate. So while I haven't had enough time to be dealing with this matter because I have been pivoting as quickly as possible to deal with flooding and setting up a wildland program, we do need to take another look at it. I appreciate the town or the county moving forward on making sure that we have a...

39:30 Joint plan with a consultant actually coming in and supporting us through this because we're all short-staffed, but it is important that we learn the lessons from this so we don't, you know, there's a couple of little hanging foods that we need to make sure we pick at least those moving forward. Any questions? No, thank you very much. Okay, so, Dan, any other folks? I don't know if George has joined. I don't see him on the Zoom there. No, okay. So, obviously, we're just, we're just...

40:00 Scratching the surface of something that still isn't over yet. So I'm going to, Rhonda, turn it over to you and your colleagues over here and see any observations or things you want to add to this general sense of what's happened and we'll come back to the council and I think we'll start getting ready for what comes next. Thank you and thank you for everybody coming forward and giving us perspective throughout this because as we know from and I would

40:29 Glad you had that date of January 4th. Happy New Year, right? And which it doesn't cover countless avalanches is cutting off this and I have a date that my snow blower broke on January, excuse me, December 28th. So that was an omen that we all need to heed. And I want to really just thank everyone on staff.

40:59 Everywhere and that just to continue to persevere because we were extremely fortunate of what could have happened and also what is still happening and just that we're still continuing to be in this. The flooding is intense in a lot of areas and it's going to be more intense but I just

41:25 I had the opportunity to see Cal OES and work with them and they told me they know how to put out fires, they don't know how to shovel snow and we appreciate how quickly they learned and we were able to show them but this is an ongoing effort and many of us are affected directly and everyone knows somebody there and really have had

41:55 A lot of public outreach and want to express how important it is that we take the public comment and give an opportunity for them to express how they experienced it because they are our eyes and ears out there where we can't be and what we know is very different from what they experienced.

42:24 So many of us have this information. I've shared way more than I ever thought I would with Chris, and thank you again there. But they're all wanting to have a debrief, but basically they want to make sure that we're hearing them where it is because a lot of people have experienced something similar, and some believe that they've experienced something worse than it is here.

42:55 But what I can say in my 35 years here is we've never all experienced it at the same time. And it's still coming. And that we really can't challenge. So continue to, those of you that are listening, continue to give us your perspectives because they change daily. And we really need this to put together a plan on what to do when something.

43:22 That we didn't plan for happens again. And that's the only way that we will learn from this because we have a tendency to forget the pain and move on. But remember the pain right now. Send that information to us because that's going to help us build that plan. I guess I had some kind of basic questions. You know, I've gotten a lot of questions. After I turn the microphone on, I've got those questions too. About the propane tanks, and I appreciate the comments.

43:57 The one thing we heard the most was dig out your tank. And that's good if you can remember to do that. But the problem was a lot of people didn't do that. Is there a longer-term solution in terms of covering certain parts of it, the lines or something that would give you a permanent answer if you didn't dig out your tank? Because I got a lot of those questions of people saying, yeah, I didn't dig out my tank, but should I put a cover over pieces of it? Or what's the best practice in terms of really...

44:27 Taking care of your tank and these types of big storms. So thank you for the question. Appreciate it. There's actually quite a bit that goes into that issue. There's also quite a bit of confusion as well. This was interesting because if you recall, there was similar storms that were happening down in the L.A. area that were unique to them. And I was receiving phone calls from fire chiefs out there in Crestline, Arrowhead, Big Bear, where they were seeing significant explosions and significant problems. I believe there was a day that one of the skier

44:57 Well, down there had 100 inches in 48 hours. That's more than we usually see. So we've been dealing this for a longer period of time. We actually had some explosions in the 90s where we had some fatalities in the town of Mammoth Lakes. There's been some up in the Walker area as well down by the base down there. So fortunately what's happened up here is we've had some code changes that have led because of those residual things we saw. And those are significant.

45:23 What those ended up doing is we now see more snow that you see down in Big Bear, Arrowhead, and we don't generally have those types of explosions as they do. What happened here is we just had significantly more snow, plus we had the problem of people shoveling their snow off their roofs. And where you actually see your points of failure is not the tanks. The tanks are actually your solution a lot of ways. They're your safety valve. So it's great to have that dug out.

45:46 If you don't have that dugout, eventually the fire department can go. Ideally, they can still find it. It's, again, a whole other discussion of low-hanging boots for what we need to do to make this easier. And they can shut off the tank. The biggest problem is when we're trying to shut something off at the building and we have no way to do that, what we were finding is that these lines were breaking where they come from the tank or from the franchise line up into the house against the house. The toughest situations were the ones where they were breaking below the shutoff valve.

46:13 And then you potentially have no way to shut them off, especially if they're on the franchise line or the tank is completely buried. So what the local code does, and I can't speak to the county code as well, Tom's here, he actually probably can, is we have some codes that have been protecting those meters and equipment coming into the house. It's time to take another look at those because our future looks a little different than our last 20 years. My neighbor's house, if this is a significant, you know,

46:42 4x12 header that's sitting on top of the thing snapped completely. Unfortunately, we're losing some opportunities. He's already had somebody out there fixing it, and guess what? They're putting it back exactly the way that it was prior to this. So we do have a need to move quickly on some things. It's tough. We are still, like Chris McCrassick mentioned, in the middle of the emergency while we're working on recovery efforts and also getting ready for the next emergency. But if the one thing that we could stress is this needs to be a...

47:09 Regulation fix in the sense that we need to protect that equipment coming in. We'll probably make sure that on some systems we have no valves to be able to shut off portions of it as we move forward. Okay, I remember several years ago a guy in our tracks was coming around trying to sell us a little cover he would build over the meter where it goes into the house. I remember thinking, what is this guy talking about? You know, the stuff doesn't fall off the roof and hit that. Well, obviously it does. It is impressive. I mean, I've been here 20 years and when you...

47:39 We're digging our way down 15 feet to these, especially when you have the ice when it's on the snow shedding side. It is impressive the amount of damage that we're seeing on these. So, again, I am not an engineer. I will not put the fabrication specifications on that, but that is the most reasonable part of the solution. Thank you. Linda, anything else you want to add to that? Okay. So I'll just turn to council at this point and just say, oh, Tom, do you want to come up and talk about that? Sure.

48:13 John Perry, building official, Town of Mammoth Lakes and Mono County. We've had, as Alish alluded to, we had some pretty serious accidents in the early to mid-90s. We actually had people die here in the town because of propane explosions. Since then, my predecessor, maybe some of you remember, Byron Pullman, put in fire-safe regs for LPG facilities. It was based on a model code from NFPA 58.

48:39 It's been added to quite a bit, and I did some additions just this last code cycle this last fall. But he's right. The weak link in the whole LPG system is typically where that underground line comes up out of the ground because it has to be plastic in the ground, but it comes up. It's called a riser, and then it goes from plastic to metal. And that point right there when you have a gap between the pipe and the house, when you get that accumulation of snow and ice as it melts and refreezes,

49:08 It expands, and it'll cause that pipe to break, especially at that joint where the metal and the plastic are connected. And that gas will always usually find its way into a building. So we do have pretty, I would say pretty good regulations on the books, but I think there's two things that come to mind. One is, dare I say, a little stricter enforcement of some of the stuff we already have on the books. And I think, as Alex said, there are some changes I think that we should think about.

49:37 The one thing I would share with you is that one of the explosions we had in town was the Valdez Air condominiums, and one of those, it was the manager's building. I haven't seen the report yet because that was done by the state, but I feel very confident there was no propane detector or sensor in there. So having these multifamily buildings with a lot of units, with a lot of people where the hazard level is very high is critical.

50:03 Tom, you're saying that it's required to have plastic in the ground? Yes.

50:33 Code requires, because your black iron is not corrosion resistive, so it's not designed to be resistive to corrosion when it's in the ground when it can get wet, so it's prohibited by code to put steel black iron pipe in the ground, so it's always going to be yellow polyethylene pipe, but I think that, you know, the pipe in the ground's okay, but it's when it comes out of the ground close to the house, and that gap again, like I said, between the pipe and the house is a big deal.

51:03 Yes. They were about eight inches below grade, which is pretty shallow. I had the pleasure of hitting one at my own home at Shady Rescue Road years ago in Mammoth. There's supposed to be 18 minimum now below grade. But yeah. And then so in the early 90s when we got the new codes, or the codes at the time,

51:33 It's one of those enclosures, those wood ones, you see them all over town. Those have been engineered. Now, they're not infallible. They still are capable of failure, like Aleish mentioned, when you have extreme loading. But the wood enclosure, and we also have a metal enclosure. That's a welded metal enclosure. Those were engineered back in the day for our snow loads. So most of those that I've seen, I saw one fail this year myself, failed because it came off. The question is, no, you can't, so it leads to me.

52:11 Yes. Yes. Yeah. Those are allowed. So I wanted to make that comment to you that these enclosures over a propane tank are allowed by code. You could do it. But it has to be, one side has to be open so you could remove the tank if you had to, pretty obvious. But you could have an open-faced enclosure over your propane tank. And if it was Bear Valley, I drove through Bear Valley not too long ago, and they were all over the place. So that's something that people could do. And maybe we...

52:50 Promote that a little bit more. Maybe we have a prescribed design for that. These are all things that I'm considering right now. Yeah. Yeah. It'd be a good summer for some carpenters to be able to do that. But that's a lot by code. And perhaps Alice has something more to say about that. And if I could just touch in on that again, we did not have a, there were minor problems with tanks, but tanks are not honestly a problem. So if somebody wants to do it for aesthetic reasons, great. But I think we need to be very critical in our messaging.

53:21 I would say that the engineering was done well 10 years ago. Again, we're in a different world. I saw multiple of these systems failed. I have pictures of them. So if we're going to put efforts into solving this problem, again, we need to concentrate on where the lines come in, and additionally on valves, especially in the town of Mammoth Lakes. I believe Bridgeport is a similar situation where...

53:48 We're getting to the point of where we have to shut off whole neighborhoods. Juniper is actually a great example of that, where we ended up shutting off that neighborhood and it took about two, three weeks before we could get heat back to that community. There is not a single water distribution system that works like this. There is a valve on every single lateral. Really think about what we have here. It's unique because it's so unique. There's only two of these, as far as I know, across the United States. So as we work on technical solutions, I ask that we really work with the...

54:16 Technical people that deal with this. The plastic pipe's actually not an issue. It's better because we can pinch it off and solve the emergencies. The metal pipes are the problem. So again, I think we spend a lot of time trying to solve the problems here. Let's put together a committee and work on kind of doing that, what I believe is kind of the right way. Thank you very much. All right, so I'll come back to our fellow council members. Just any kind of general observations of what we saw this winter. I think we're heading towards a discussion about an after-action report.

54:47 Can I let Bill or Chris go first? Sure, of course. Bill, go ahead. I forgot to turn that on during the propane conversation. It was missed for prosperity. Everybody call Tom. He'll explain what I said. Other than that, you know, we've all worked very hard through this. I'm anxious to see an after report.

55:19 What do we build this to? What is reasonable?

55:49 Because extreme events are extreme events. You're always going to have issues with it. So that's where I'm at. Hey, Chris. I think it'll be really important to just make sure that we take all of the citizen input that we had on things like streets that weren't plowed but they're private roads and these one-off things that, you know, there were a lot of reasons why we can't plow private roads and just to make sure we're super clear so that people's expectations for the future are just...

56:18 We live in a place where it's very clear. And by the way, you know,

56:48 Now we think it's El Nino next year. It's looking pretty clear. So we could have back-to-back winters and we just have to be ready. So how do we make sure while FEMA's in town that we find out whether there's any federal and state assistance for a community like ours to get ahead of climate change instead of us always running to catch up? Because I don't want to see our fire chief and his team go through like what they went through this year ever again. So that's what I heard.

57:20 I like what you said, Chris. My brain is a little discombobulated. But I think that getting messaging out also that we can't shovel private roofs. I think a lot of people feel that, oh, you need to come and help me shovel my roof. And then other people feel like, well, these are taxpayer dollars. Why are my tax dollars going to shovel Susie's roof? You know, just kind of defining.

58:00 And, you know, we can just learn from what happened and, you know, try to do better.

58:20 I have just one more quick thing to add. I was really impressed that FEMA sent a press, and there's a press release, so it's all over the town social media. I think it's on Ready Mono. There is help for people who are struggling and need some support post this crisis. Like, I would talk to people and say, are you okay?

58:43 All you have to do is ask people if they're okay. And, you know, people aren't really all that okay. So please use that resource. You know, we've been through a really hard thing. And I just want to make sure that everyone realizes that that's available and we should take use of it. And I'd love to hear from people. If they do use it, it'd be perfectly, obviously, confidential. But how it goes, like, this is what we need to do. You know, our staff, I mean.

59:11 Our firefighters, all of our emergency responders, our sheriff, like, you're all here, like, you know, make sure your teams are okay. This was rough. And I just had to offer a couple of observations. I think we're all in the middle of this, and I don't think any of us can really look beyond the circumstances that we're presently in to really understand what it is we're dealing with. And so this is kind of a teeing up for the after-action report conversation, which we should have.

59:41 We've tried this in the past and it hasn't worked. We tried it in 16, 17, nothing came out of that. That was going to the local transportation commission and it never happened, which is fine. Because I think we're really dealing with exceptional circumstances. And Bill, I know you've got this great, wonderful historical perspective, but from my seat, I see exceptional things happening. Hang on, hang on. So just hang on. So we're going to be talking about fire and communities like this that are on the front lines of climate change.

1:00:11 We all know that, but there's also hundreds of millions and billions of dollars out there for communities like ours that can help us mitigate this and invest in our resilience going forward. And I think that that's critical. I don't have a whole lot more to add other than this has been an exceptionally rough winter for this community, for this county, for this region. And I think you just look at the reports coming out from everybody, and it's all just anecdotal at this point. This is an exceptional set of circumstances. And I don't think we can even begin to articulate that.

1:00:41 Today, this afternoon, in this meeting. However, Madam Chair, I think we really need to be focusing on this after-action report. And I think for our friends at FEMA to really understand that I know that perhaps there are usually things with disasters that happen over a day or two or a seismic event, a hurricane, a tornado, something like that. This is something that started back in December. Here we are in May. It's going to go on probably all the way through the summer into the fall.

1:01:08 And this is obviously very trying and very difficult for our citizens in our community to deal with this. Not to mention the effects of the compromising of our economy, Fred, as you mentioned, with the recreation assets that our Forest Service doesn't even know what's been compromised out there. So I think maybe it's a good time to sort of think about what it is we need to be seeing that after-action report, what the expectations are. I think, for one, I would just throw that wherever a consultant gets hired.

1:01:31 That the recommendations coming out of this are aligned with state policy, they're aligned with federal policy and the funding that's available for those things. So we can be telling our story as a region and align those things with the funding opportunities that may be available so we can really invest in our resilience going forward. Yes, Mary. I want to clarify, there's two different reports. The after-action report comes post-incident. There is also a five-year...

1:01:59 Hazard mitigation plan that we have applied for funding to update. Having an updated hazard mitigation plan will qualify, and we're looking at an all agency plan, not separate plans, that will qualify us to apply for hazard mitigation grant funding, which comes out from FEMA every year, but we will have higher priority in the year following a disaster in our counties. That's where you can start talking about how do we build the resilient communities.

1:02:29 And you talk about trying to do away with propane, but we had two communities without power for seven days in weather that never got above freezing. And so if we're going to go towards electricity, we need a grid that's reliable. And so it's larger than just propane. And that hazard mitigation plan is a critical piece for us to be eligible, both jurisdictions.

1:02:56 To be eligible for funding for projects then going forward. Okay, but the second, the after action report, it perhaps is not tied to that hazard mitigation plan. Maybe you guys could talk a little about what you might be cooking up or something like that. So, and I'll turn it over to Chris, but that is really an internal focused document that says this is what we need to train on or what resources we need or

1:03:23 You know, what do we need to do better in the next event? Okay, so I would just, again, to Madam Chair, we both serve in the LTC. We've had several conversations with Caltrans and all of our agency partners. Edison's not here today. You know, other agencies aren't here. But I think that that internal document has got to be something that can be routed to all of us who serve in all these committees, whether it's the SCOG, the LTC, whatever, so that we can be advocating on behalf of our communities to state agencies.

1:03:52 And I would hope that the scope, I don't know, is the county doing that document? How is that document? The county is responsible as the operational area to do that document. The town is certainly free to join in that or do their own document. The state will have their own document, which will incorporate Caltrans. And so there'll be potentially multiple after-action reports as a result of this event. Okay, I'm a little concerned about that. I see.

1:04:19 Silos, silos, silos. So I'm hoping we can really put something together that tells the collective narrative of this region that can be useful. Again, the money coming out of the federal government, the money coming out of the state government is perhaps framed around things like climate change, resilience, all these other kinds of things that can be useful for all of us to use as we advocate to bring resources back to all of us. I certainly would hope that, you know, that...

1:04:45 Town's not going to do one document, the county's going to do its own, someone else is going to do their own document, and we just end up with a bunch of documents. It's not something that can really be useful, so I don't know, I'd advocate for something that's a little bit more. And I don't know if Chris has more to add to that. Okay. We definitely need to do one. I know that we were planning and scheduling an after-action meeting for the COVID response in December, and we had to cancel it because the storms came in.

1:05:16 And we've never picked it back up because we haven't been able to catch our breath yet. So it's a matter of capacity. But I think as we all join on Zoom meetings with our cooperators and everyone, I definitely think we can all join together and put out a quality document of what we've learned. What I would like to see is we put out the...

1:05:46 The damage assessment forms on Ready Mono and the town website. I would like to see us do the same thing as far as receiving comments from the public while it's still fresh in their minds and they can name address and their information and then what they feel we did right and what we could have done better. So I think that's something that we should, even while we're still in response to the flooding, we still want to capture that information while the

1:06:15 The winter event is still fresh in everyone's mind. And we can do that easily. Amanda touched on something real quick that I think is really important that we can't forget in all of this. We're looking at this as government agencies. How do we do better? How do we protect? How do we do these things? One of the things we have failed at as a government is to manage the expectations of our citizens. We live in a out-of-touch, incredibly rural area.

1:06:45 We had citizens out of power for how long in Mono City? Yeah. These things happen. They will continue to happen. How many times was the power out at my house for 12 to 24 hours? Somehow we have to put the message out there and part of our planning has to be your power can go out for three or four days. You need to be able to manage it. Do you have food? Do you have water? Do you have heat? If we go all electric.

1:07:14 You have a camp stove that you can use to cook your food on. Or if you're an old codger like me, are you going to keep your antique gas stove? But these things are important. Right now, the way we've managed this is an appropriate stove for how I think government has gone. We are telling people we're going to be your savior. We cannot be that. So managing public expectation and putting that out there and getting them involved somehow to me, and Amanda, thank you for bringing that up, is critical.

1:07:44 Hugely important. Okay, so we're going to, we've got some fire stuff to get to, so I just wanted to check with you, Madam Chair, in terms of whatever direction or consensus we need to provide to staff, so these after-action reports are something that are going to be useful, so I. Let's go ahead. You make a good point, Bill. There's a reason it's called ready mono, it's not react mono. Right. And I think that was brilliant, and there is the piece of it, while we do all the, what we should, we have done better.

1:08:13 I hear you loud and clear saying, you know, let's talk about generators. Let's talk about protecting our propane lines. You know, be in a better shape. Be ready. Prepare. Because we talk about that, but that seems to be the flyer that comes out once a year from whoever, and it's like, oh yeah, I need to do that. But it's like, you know, don't be caught again. And really put a full-court press on preparation and prevention and expectations in terms of don't be caught. There's so many places where all I had to do is put a 4x4 up.

1:08:41 And it would have supported something that collapsed and broke things. And I didn't think of doing that. And I've had plenty of years to think of doing that. So I really think there's a piece of the whole after action that gets into public, you know, preparation, prevention, and hitting that really hard in terms of just this is where we live. Be ready mono. Okay, good. A couple comments. I wanted to just kind of look for a second at the...

1:09:09 coordination between town and county and how that came about and how we came to it because I believe that we were well prepared partly because of COVID. During COVID, we put together an incident management team. We put together a kind of a joint EOC, if you will, which worked well. Agencies were working together. Everybody got to know each other. And now suddenly now we're have a snow event. And everyone kind of almost by memory.

1:09:38 Started to work together much more easily than in the past. That was my observation. You know, you went along for a while and then it's like, okay, we need an incident management team to come in. That team came in, they went to Bishop, they were trying to do things. I think it was all almost like muscle memory, how we pulled together initially.

1:10:00 So time goes on, time goes on, and now we're to the part of, you know, we need to do an action after action report, but that is embedded in the ICS management system, which is something that we haven't had a chance to go back and actually train on. So when this COVID started, the few people in the community who were trained with ICS kind of stepped up and said, okay, let's get these people together.

1:10:28 They're going to run this management team. And now we've done almost the same thing for snow. We need to get to, as far as preparedness, to the training part, to the training part so that people have gone through ICS training. They know what position is what. Like, you tell somebody, OK, you're in charge of logistics. What is that? What do I do with that? I mean, there really is a need, and Chris, I know this kind of falls on you after we get a breath, to bring that training to the county and the town, not only as partners, but as...

1:10:58 Just responders. So that's my little add for that. Comment on that, Chris, because I know you're smiling like, yeah, that's kind of what we did. All right, great. I know that moving forward, Mike. We do need to breathe life back into the town and county incident management team. We do have some upcoming trainings that have kind of been working with Callaway as behind the scenes.

1:11:28 We'll be bringing an ICS 300 and 400 class. That's the one that needs to be done in person. So we're bringing that back and try to recruit individuals into that class so that they can be part of the management team. We saw such a huge turnover, you know, since the initial training and then after COVID, you know, these emergencies aren't supposed to last three years or six months or, you know, that long. Next week, we're doing mitigation for emergency managers.

1:11:57 In Crowley, and they'll be emergency managed from all over the state. For that training, we're doing an emergency operation center management class in October, as well as an ICS EOC interface class. And then we will be updating our emergency operating plan. So, I mean, it's kind of in the works behind the scenes, and we'll be definitely promoting that moving forward and trying to draw more interested individuals into the team, because it's very important that we have that established.

1:12:26 I hope that we have the class on what should elected official do in the case of this kind of emergency. And it's a really short class because it's just one sentence. Stay out of the way. Sit down. Be quiet. I mean, you know, because you don't want electors to think they need to go to the EOC center. They need to, you know, participate in all this. You know, we field the calls. We push them up. And that's pretty much where we should be involved, at least in my opinion. Dan, I'd love to hear you.

1:12:56 I'll kind of echo a lot of that that's happened that way in the training effort. We actually work with the fire district and the town and the county to actually build that system in place. And we note here, really, to have a type three incident management team that we can pull together from staff, a lot of that is how do you survive the first 96 hours, 120 hours, as you need to as a stand-alone community, especially in our location. So, yeah, we had real-life training for way too long there for a while under COVID.

1:13:26 A lot of different activity there and worked that way. And some of the training from that actually did really step in. I know some of our own staff stepped back up right into things they'd done before. They knew the forms, they knew the activity, and that really was a benefit, being able to step into some of that. We've also looked at some expansion potential of that. We bring in part of Inyo County, some discussions there at a broader level. A lot of that is to give us depth in the organization. If you're going to do this for a period of time, then they'll be able to run.

1:13:54 24-7 for a period of time. The staffing gets quite demanding. So from that. And that's something, too, I think we look at the after-action plan. How does that work into that? What went well there? What didn't? Where that kind of internal process? Where do things fall? Those types of elements. And so it builds off of itself to go into that. And being able to step in and do those in that training, both, you know, I'll say the ice.

1:14:21 I see that training that we have here and then having gone through a joint two-agency training actually through FEMA back in Emmitsburg and to be invest in a real situation, if you will, for a week and having to go through all this stuff, eight hours a day, nine hours a day, plus homework, it really does give you a feel for the impact and when you actually go through it in real life, it's like, yeah, that training was real. It doesn't go away.

1:14:51 So I think we did a lot of stuff well. There's a lot of things that we can definitely do better.

1:15:18 And then as you train on that, learn on that, you also begin building the relationships across organizations. And that becomes almost as valuable as the actual, you know, I'll say paperwork training is who do you pick up the phone and call becomes critical. And how do you bring in federal partners and some of the other agencies that we have in the area in those discussions? It's really an all hands-on deck thing, especially in any rural community of this nature. One of the things in talking with CalOAS, they were very clear.

1:15:48 Yeah, if you guys can't stand on your own for 72 to 96 hours, you're in trouble from a big picture of stuff. How do you get immediate resources in? We had some discussions that way, too, but a very powerful thing. And so we want to do a couple things that have been noted. We want to get a good after-action plan that we can look at. Here, after that, one of the recommendations would be, however we go forward, we do it jointly for that after-action plan in terms of...

1:16:15 Using an outside consulting service to help too. And I think if we need to branch off a little bit in individual areas and go, hey, how can we do X better or information need to go out, we can lean into some of those areas. And then coming back with that, really a training program focused on that type three incident management team. We've used that a little bit here on a couple other things. We actually shadowed some of the fire ones that were in town when they brought in, I think they were type two teams, maybe a type three team.

1:16:45 Where you could actually stand up and watch some of that operation go through and understand what was happening in those fields. And then once you've done the training, then you go through an incident, it makes it more real. I think Mary has the experience on some of that where get that training while boom, the incident happens and people start to show up. They actually know where to go, they know what to do, and it becomes built into the organization and that would be the goal here on this type of team. I think, Dan, I think the thing that you're saying, I think the critical thing is this be a joint plan. Yeah.

1:17:14 And I think that we've got to do this together. I'm a little leery of saying one plan over here, one plan over there. That's going to work against the kind of things you're talking about, Lynda. I mean, we really need to be coordinating and working together. We have to just reemphasize that and redo that. And I think I'm seeing some nodding heads over there and some nodding heads, I think, on this side. So I think if that's – I don't know what direction you're looking for at this point, but I think if that's –

1:17:55 Okay. Well, especially the public education piece. Let's speak with one voice and one message on all that advice so that, you know, people aren't looking at, well, wait a minute, they're telling me to do this, they're telling me to do this, and are that the same? Let's speak with one voice and have a clear message that

1:18:28 You know, it really is consistent. That's huge. I think the ReadyMondo platform is really awesome. The number one thing that changed quickly is our ability to communicate quickly because we can't reset expectations for everyone affected if we don't know what to say. Us as officials, we are the conduit. You know, we don't want to. We can't send people to the people.

1:18:57 For asking questions to the people who are doing the work. That's what we're here for, is to help assure everyone what is happening, what is a timeliness, because it's different. That is completely different. And when they don't hear anything from us, they make it up on their own. People were scared, and they had every reason to be. The people that were involved and communicating weren't.

1:19:27 Because they were knowing what was happening. And whatever it takes to make sure we have that level of communication is just as important because that allows you to do your job. And that has changed from the last time. We have dozens of sources where people can get information, but when we speak with one voice and funnel it through...

1:19:55 These areas, they're able to get 90% of their questions answered. And then we're actually able to support all of our staffs by being liaisons for them. Okay, good. So I think the Ready Monro certainly is a really good platform. I think the Ready Inyo platform, they've done some really good work down there with Inyo County, LADWP. They put a really important meeting together. Again, these are opportunities for synergies within the region.

1:20:25 That we can start combining these efforts and to be more efficient with this communication and all the rest of itself. I'll turn to Mary and Dan. Do you guys have what you need from us? Is there anything else? And I think if there is any bifurcation in this, again, we're looking for a comment after action report, but to make sure that whatever you're saying tomorrow to the board of supervisors, you know, we're saying the same thing to both bodies so that we're all sort of kept in the loop of where these things are going so we can all be on the same page.

1:20:53 All right. Well, I think in the interest of time, unless anybody wants a break, I think we've got to move on to the other side of the climate equation. The one we thought we would be talking about. Yes, exactly. Exactly. So with that, we're going to move on to the wildfire-related programs, prevention and preparedness programs. And Mary, Danielle, I'll throw over to you guys who set us forward here. Actually, I want to start by introducing Wendy Grashechi, who's our wild...

1:21:22 Fire Prevention Coordinator, and she can give you an update on those efforts. Okay, great. Thank you. Wendy, please come forward. Thank you. So hopefully that'll work. How long do I have? Five minutes? Three minutes? A reasonable amount of time. We've had other partners who are going to want to speak, so do whatever you think. Until I throw my phone at you. Can you guys hear me? I'm not sure if this is... You have to get really close to it. All right. I'm more familiar with asking questions than answering, so just give me a minute here.

1:22:01 Okay, so what my understanding was is I was going to give you guys kind of an update of what we've been working on, what I've been working on for the last couple of months. I'm the wildfire mitigation coordinator, as you know, and I'm just going to go through the basics of what we've been working on. The first thing that I had intended to do when I took the job was reach out to every single person in the communities that I could think about that might have any

1:22:29 Background or any interest in wildfire mitigation all the way from fire safe councils to the fire departments, everything else. I started that process and then we started getting storms and almost all of them were so swamped. We quickly changed gears and started working on some grants and I wanted to tell you about the grants real quick because there's two of them that are I think are pretty interesting and we have a good chance of getting both of them. I'll pick up on the communication outreach here in a few minutes.

1:22:58 The first one was a Cal Fire Wildfire Prevention Grant. This was a big grant that we applied for. It's $1.5 million. And the reason it's so big is because we are asking Cal Fire, who seems very supportive of this idea, to fund a series of wildfire mitigation toolkits. Their mobile traveling toolkits would go up and down the eastern Sierra being pulled by a trailer. They would have a chipper with them. They'd have a small mill with them. They'd have...

1:23:27 Everything you needed to do, landscape level and community and residential level, wildfire mitigation, fuel mitigation projects, you could do those in a community or we could downscale that if we get the chippers that we're looking for down to each individual residences and communities. We put out the grant. We've gone through three levels with CAL FIRE who has been mentoring and supporting us because they like this idea.

1:23:56 They think it could be used across the state, so they've given us a lot of support. It is on its way to Sacramento right now, and that's the last level we've got to get through. But people have said they've never seen Cal Fire spend so much time trying to get something to go through. The San Bernardino Cal Fire unit worked really well with us, and we're feeling pretty good about it. It also comes with a...

1:24:24 Let's say this is written into our budget for the grant includes large land scale wood chippers, all this stuff. The other half of the grant will cover robust wildfire mitigation education and training program through a series of workshops for community members focusing on home hardening techniques, tool training, tool use training, some more. The program will be run, this is a non-profit that we're working with, American Wildfire Experience, which will be responsible for maintaining, repairing the kits, keeping the kits in working condition, et cetera.

1:24:53 Because you know how chippers break down. So this is supposed to be a sustainable, long-term, 10, 20-year kind of thing that keeps getting renewed, right? Comes with the truck, the trailers, everything. Whatever doesn't get funded this year, they thought we would probably, as long as we demonstrate we can manage this, they thought we could probably keep picking up chippers and as many as we need and trucks and trailers.

1:25:20 The other thing is this is in cooperation with Inyo County. The two counties have done this together. So that was one of the grants. I said the reason I bring this up is this format today is even if for some reason we do not get this grant, we have increasingly come to believe this is the right route for a sustainable long-term and self-sufficient wildfire mitigation program that will allow both counties to have much more control over the fuels and wildfire mitigation projects.

1:25:49 Are absolutely critical to protecting our communities and landscapes from catastrophic wildfires. As such, we will pursue this kind of project through other means until we have success. So if we don't make it this time, we're going to keep trying because as federal and state agencies have been kind of increasingly difficult to access as they experience serious hiring challenges and the difficulty in getting skilled contractors here to do this work is legendary. These are some of the reasons we really reached this point of just saying we need to get our own stuff.

1:26:18 We need to have it here in the Eastern Sierra. We need to take care of it. We need to own it, not rent, you know, whatever lease. The other grant that's out there right now is a bioenergy facility grant. This was Whitebark Institute has been a partner in all of this work that we're doing, although not necessarily with the first grant, but almost everything else helped us put together this grant. Mono County is the lead on this grant, but this is...

1:26:45 A large grant that will support the planning and engineering for a bioenergy facility with a full support and formal letter of commitment for our technologies and others. This is called the Missing Link, Solving Biomass Utilization Needs in the Eastern Sierra. The reason we thought this was such a high priority is because if we do not have a place to put all this wood and all this biomass materials from all this work that we're going to do and that the

1:27:13 This is the white bark, the donut project, which you guys all know about, right? I don't need to explain this. So it's 90 square miles of fuels treatment, and there's got to be some place to put that. So that was as high of a priority to us, to me, in this job as I could think of. And so that grant went out, was put out in March, and I think we should know about it in the next few weeks. That's what Janet said.

1:27:42 We're going to be trying to fund at least the pre-engineering and pre-development and permit process with that with a $600,000 grant with a $300,000 match, which we matched. How much? Should I still have a few minutes? Second priority, connecting, interviewing community fire safe councils, local community leaders, regional planning advisory committees, local fire officials, county and town leaders. As to their and your...

1:28:10 Wildfire mitigation questions and unmet needs. As I mentioned before, I expected to be done with that by the end of February. I'm not done. And I'm just picking that up. I'm setting myself a goal to probably finish by the end of the month. And then at the end of this month, I'm hoping to come up with a really comprehensive report that I could give to the town and the county, either in separate board meetings or town council meetings as to what I'm finding is out there, what's unmet needs, what people, you know, where we're at with that.

1:28:39 I had really intended to do that, like I said, in February, and that was kind of put on the back burner. Excuse me. My third priority was assessing the relative efficiency and appropriateness of establishing regional and or county-wide fire-safe councils and or fireways communities. Long sentence, but the reason I'm bringing this up right now because I believe we're starting to almost go into a, not a policy-making process, but just a way to think about things differently.

1:29:07 And this is why I said, during my time in this job, I've come to understand there are more ways to create fire resilient communities and more ways to fund projects and more organizational options other than just community-based fire safe councils. Increasingly, the state of California, CAL FIRE, and other possible funders and collaborators for local projects are leaning toward a model that emphasizes regional solutions.

1:29:31 And larger Fire Safe Councils that are staffed by professionals who can manage the grants and funding proposals coming from community-based Fire Safe Councils. This means, and this is a change that's happened in the last couple of years in particular, this means that there is an opportunity to create a new model for perhaps a Mono County-wide Fire Safe Council or even an Eastern Sierra Fire Safe Council, which will take on the burden of finding, applying for and funding grants, not funding, finding, applying for

1:30:00 Grants for local projects that are defined by our local communities and or our fire safe councils. This is a subject I will be bringing before both the town council and the county board of supervisors in more depth for your input. Another option is communities may be better served by becoming fire wise communities instead of either fire safe councils or only fire safe councils because fire wise communities can access fire insurance deductions. Again, I plan to bring this subject up.

1:30:26 This is kind of the beginning of this process for me and for getting information out. So as soon as I feel more competent in the details, I'd like to bring that up at a meeting or at least talk to you all privately. Fourth priority, attending state and regional meetings with potential partners and collaborators in order to assess new ways to collaborate, find new partners to collaborate with. So for example, am I okay for timing?

1:30:50 We have a list of collaborators, Inyo County, Whitebark Institute, ESCA, Cal Fire, SCE, LADWP, Mammoth Community Water District, Department of Fish and Wildfire, Fire Safe Councils, Office of Emergency Services in both counties, Master of Gardeners, Chamber of Commerce, FOI, Friends of the Inyo Fire Districts, Tribal Communities.

1:31:10 Eastern Sierra Land Trust, Eastern Sierra Wildfire Alliance, BLM, Inyo National Forest, Alpine Wildfire Mitigation Coordinator, Clint Celio, and MMSA. These are the ones we've kind of been interacting with or having communications with. I said it's an income list because I'd like to do more outreach to contractors, insurance providers, realtors, and more in the coming weeks to get their input just to kind of understand where things are.

1:31:38 Insurance and fire insurance and, you know, what would be best for us here in the Eastern Sierra in terms of whether we go to fire-wise communities, which you can get a 10% deduction on your insurance. You know, you can't do that in a fire-safe council, you know, all that. We are also working to restore a functioning resource conservation district if, indeed, the county and the town think is a good idea. Most likely a Mono and Inyo County resource conservation district.

1:32:06 The reason this is important comes back to the idea that such an entity is being effectively used in many other counties to apply for and administer the kinds of grants I'm talking about. It might be a good way to carry these grants on this landscape level that we're talking about. And again, I'm just learning that process. I think we had a resource conservation district at one time in Mono County.

1:32:30 I know INYO has one, and they're interested in forming a regional one, so I'd like to think about that a little bit. And then the last, there's a lot more, the fifth priority, and these are not in order. Okay, I'm just saying the priorities, they're not in order. Community education events, workshops, et cetera. This is just starting to kick up right now because we're finally getting out of the snow. So what we've got going is White Bark is doing a lot of event planning with us. We're just trying to make sure we don't.

1:32:59 Underplan and overplan on top of each other with them. There's a big week of wildfire mitigation education events starting June 11th. It's going to be in three different Mono County communities, June, Mammoth, and Crowley. We're going to get to North County at the next one, I think, in July. And these will include home hardening talks by professional forest or guest speaker, field trips to home demo sites, and many other events. We'll start publicizing this in the next few days. And we're also planning some events that will go with the town cleanup.

1:33:29 The thing I forgot to say is we actually got one of the tool trailers from the State Fire Safe Council. We were one of three counties in the entire state to get such a trailer. I think they knew we were interested and they had to get rid of three trailers. So Northern California, Southern and Central California, one trailer went out to each county. We have one. We will have one sometime this summer. So that will be something great that we can take around to communities to start showing that there's...

1:33:59 There's actually something we can do. And you guys probably want to make me shut up now. So that was the end of my... That was the end. Excellent. Thank you very much. Stand by. I'm sure there'll be questions as we go through the rest of the speakers. Want me to sit here and just... Sit whatever you want. Thanks a lot. Thank you. Good. Thank you very much for that, Wendy. Elish, I think you're up next. Sit wherever you want.

1:35:01 I'm not sure if you can all see that, but I'm going to take the liberty to go a little wider than just defensible space. In my defense, I'll be a little shorter than Chief Casabian was the other week, so I'll try to balance that out. So, you know, it's interesting because we're speaking on probably the most important topics for this region. That's why emergency and wildlife got picked. And when you speak in front of the groups of people that ultimately make the decisions,

1:35:30 Sometimes the underrepresented parts of your community are here. And I would argue that we think about communities for one reason or another. They don't have the financial means or whatever that is. But in this situation, your fire districts really represent that. And it's ironic when you think about the fact that they are a key player in all these issues that we're talking about today. So I'm going to speak from the point of view of Mammoth Lakes Fire, which is a fire protection district, but I think it's important. A lot of the things I speak about are important for all the other fire districts.

1:36:00 A lot of those issues are actually amplified for them. So just a couple things. I'm going to give you the seasonal outlook, really kind of touch on the fire problem, speak on Mammoth Fire's current capabilities, what we're doing to expand them, how I believe we as a community should be working to mitigate that fire problem, and then just touching on collaborative efforts. It's kind of interesting because I work for a small fire district, so I believe I'm reasonably good at collaborative efforts, and it's just by fault of I have no resources of my own, so I have to solve problems collaboratively.

1:36:33 Sometimes I think we've worked on problems and we've gotten so good at solving them that we've created these silos on things we do. The reality is these are problems that are becoming so large that I don't see ways that we solve them because we have all these people sitting around the table, probably some that aren't here today. So season outlook. That's the creek fire. I try not to be too much of like a fear monger, but if you go backwards, it's a very similar looking environment. I'm sure most of you are aware. Mammoth, not mammoth.

1:37:10 The outlook for this season actually doesn't look that bad. So I do have to be honest, if you look at it, so this comes from South Ops, it's the southern portion of the state, and the general belief is that from a forecast perspective, due to what we had from what we saw over the last few months, we're actually going to have a more mild than normal season. So that's a positive. I do think it's important that we have a realistic discussion on all these things.

1:37:39 That being said, I think as a community, we also have to recognize the fact that there's forecasts and there's things we see such as quite a few significant fires in this community, but the one that combined on this subject is the one in Wheeler Crest Paradise. We lost 40 homes. I believe that was in February. So again, take all these forecasts with a grain of salt. I really think that we need to take some time and really think about the fire problem and what it means to us. And in some ways, I think we have to talk about the cost.

1:38:10 I think I have a little bit of responsibility to convince people that it is a little different than it was maybe 40 years ago. It's tough because I'm a new fire chief for you, so sometimes having Chief Adams when you spoke on our resources here, that carries some weight. So I'll start with, you might recognize that guy. He's now the director of the Cal Polymui Fire Institute. We are experiencing the leading edge of a perfect storm created by unsustainable vegetative fuel loading, climate change,

1:38:40 I didn't hear him ask to use the word climate change too much when he was up here. Times are changing. Expanded development of the wildland urban interface. Failure to prepare for what is approaching will at best result in avoidable loss of life and avoidable financial ramifications for property and utility loss that will devastate insurance, reach, reinsurance, municipal bond, mortgage. Of course, we face an existential threat through irreparable.

1:39:08 Damage to ecosystems in the western U.S. Returning beneficial fire to these ecosystems is essential and will remain politically unacceptable as we concurrently and confidently fire resilience into our woe-wee communities. Chief Freebolt. So I don't have a full-time attorney, but I'm sure he would probably advise me against this slide. What I'm doing here is trying to put people to have some perspective of cost for them, right? And it's hard for me to explain this to my community. We went out for a...

1:39:40 The tax measure of years ago, it was about $78 per parcel. And at that time, that's quite a bit of money. I recognize that. But what is the cost of our fire profit? For me, the obvious ones are my cost on my insurance. I'm not saying this isn't in any way reflective of anybody's in this town or in this community or in this county, but mine has doubled in the last two years. I think that that's kind of a familiar theme that we're hearing.

1:40:09 We're talking about thousands of dollars at this point. So when you really start talking about the scale and scope of this, it's larger than these small problems in trying to solve this. And what I think we need to recognize is, as John has alluded to multiple meetings and earlier in this meeting, there are ways for us to be leveraging our resources here because there is this belief that this is different. And we've got good organizations that are now taking new paths. And we have funding.

1:40:39 Mammoth Fire, Mammoth Lakes, Monroe County.

1:41:08 It's special. It holds a place in people's hearts. There's a reason we have half of L.A. County up here helping us with USAR because people do care. So we do have some opportunities that I believe we have to leverage. Again, looking at it, this report that was just done by the Sierra Business Council, so not looking at it from a fire perspective, looking at it from an economic perspective, looking at it from a tourism perspective, you know, there is the cost of a single home for a wildfire average is about $29,000. If we look at just the smoke that we had in the Eastern Sears in 2018,

1:41:38 We had about 10% of visitors cancel their trips. What does that mean for this community? About $20 million. So again, not solving this problem isn't just the impacts immediately from the wildfire. It has significant economic and tourist impacts for us and our ability to continue doing what we do. So again, I'll speak a little bit on Mammoth Fire, where our current capabilities are. So we are a fire district. We have about eight full-time staff.

1:42:09 And that's significantly more than the other fire districts. So again, in some ways, unfortunate. In other ways, it's difficult. I don't have the admin support that most other organizations have here. And what that means is most of the work that's done is done by volunteer part-time staff, which is true of all the fire districts, essentially. I used to have two inspectors. We lost one who got a job in the Bay Area. So on the defensible space, we're actually looking to try to refill that again.

1:42:38 The way that these communities work is you've got a whole bunch of volunteers that come in and put in their time and they fill your engines and get the job done when you have your emergencies. Again, just to kind of create what that value is for you. When we had the Valdezera explosion, we probably had about three or four local engines that were on that along with USAR companies. There was also a child that was choking at the middle school that the fire department sent an ambulance to because the county ambulance was tied up.

1:43:08 So, again, we are, as a community, pretty dependent on these resources. If you put that together for what Mammoth Fire can provide, it's basically the equivalent of four or five engines. And in the fire service, that's considered a strike team. Five engines of one type, that's a strike team. Just to give you a little bit of perspective, the Rainbow Fire had 34 strike teams and about 170 engines that were on scene. So, there's a couple of takeaways from that. One is, we're always going to be reliant on the outside.

1:43:41 We have to have good relationships with our local partners, our state partners. We also can't solve this just through response. I think response is a big component of that, but the prevention part is critical. How we're trying to expand our capabilities. For Mammoth Fire, I had three strategic priorities when I started. First one was retention and recruitment. If you don't have people, you can't solve any of these problems. My second one was wildland. My third one was ironically propane before any of this started.

1:44:13 Pivoting off propane and getting back to wildland. Fortunately, we had a retired annuitant who helped us salvage a grant that we almost lost in the middle of this, and we were able to put together a wildland program this summer. So, in the fall, what I did is go up to Tahoe. There's a lot of ways that Mammoth is different from the Tahoe area, and I'm not even getting into all the reasons why, but the reality is there's a couple things we can learn from them as well. One unique one that I looked at was North Lake Tahoe, the Fire Protection District.

1:44:43 They started a wildland program with just six individuals in 1999. They now have about 60 or 70 on there. And it's about 90% funded through going out on incidents across the state and doing fuels mitigation work within the community. So as far as local impact, again, it goes to that leveraging of the larger system that I believe we have to do here at Mammoth Lakes. That provides multiple things for that community.

1:45:11 What it does is it creates 60 people now that can fight a fire. Also, when they're not fighting fires, working on the fuels mitigation projects that need to get done to when that fire does come through to keep those communities from burning down. And they're also working collaboratively. The Tahoe Program is an example. They just picked up three engine companies, and those are actually being funded by Nevada Energy. And Nevada Energy is essentially paying them to do work around the poles in those communities.

1:45:42 So really thinking about these collaborative solutions that seem a little crazy on the front end, but that's where you need to go if you really want to mitigate these at the level that we need to. It took me a while to really understand just the scope of this problem. We've done projects throughout this community, both on the Forest Service side as well as locally. We've had quite a few. And Jen will be speaking from Whitebark a little bit, but you really start looking at, we're talking about thousands of acres that have to be mitigated.

1:46:11 An acre is essentially a football field, and that's every year. So you do need to scale this up. It's doable, but it's going to take a little bit of work, and none of us can do it by ourselves again. Working together, it will take some work. So Mammoth Fire was able to work off what we learned up in Tahoe. We did put in for a Cal Fire investment grant that will cover three years of fuels mitigation staffing costs. It will also provide us with equipment.

1:46:42 Also, CEQA and NEPA. We're all firefighters, so we're not great at the CEQA and NEPA stuff, so we're getting some consultants to help us with that. We're primarily working on chipping and defensible space within our community. We're also narrowing that up with a program that we're working through, Cal OES. Cal OES has signed an agreement with us to where they're going to provide us with a Type 6 engine. The one thing that I have at Mammoth Fire and I honestly don't need is engines and fancy fire stations.

1:47:10 We look very fancy. The reality is what we need is people. What this provides is an opportunity for us to get across the state and start picking up that experience and get that engine out so that over time we'll start to rebuild that capacity to fight fires here in the eastern Sierra. Again, while speaking with these departments in Tahoe, they really said don't start too big, so they started with six. We're starting with six. My goal is to work that up over the next three to five years and build a project here.

1:47:39 Working closely with our partners, both with the county and NGOs, such as White Park, cautiously optimistic about where it's going. I will warn you, they're doing training these first couple weeks. This week, they're doing driver operator training. So if you see any Mammoth Fire Engines driving around town, I give them a little bit of space because most likely they're brand new drivers. So again, on mitigations for the fire problem, I've really hit on kind of sufficient public safety response. And I do have to stress that, in my opinion,

1:48:11 Your fire districts here need more support from the communities. There's a whole bunch of ways to do that. I don't see this region going to a larger full-time-based fire service anytime soon, but there are multiple ways that we can support those organizations, and I think we need to do that. Wendy was hitting on that. Fire State Council is another great example. It's just hard to build up that long-term capacity to do a lot of these administrative things.

1:48:39 Those are the organizations that are in the unique positions to solve the problem, but they need the support of all these organizations. There's clearly individual ownership of these problems. We need to make sure that we're doing everything we can as individuals, and I'll touch on that a little bit. And some of these are just community solutions in the sense that they are now becoming a little big, and the only way they want to solve is working together with everybody in this room and some people that aren't here.

1:49:05 Ultimately, at the core of wildfire mitigation, an effort to save the structure, right? We don't own most of those structures, and again, it goes back to that fact that everybody has to have some piece of ownership in this. We work on helping them out with that. There's quite a few resources that have been mentioned in this room. There's quite a few in our website. If I could stress just a couple real quickly, at a minimum, every resident in this county needs to make sure that they clear those

1:49:34 First, five feet adjacent to their properties and they clean off their decks and the materials below them. Those are just, again, kind of that low-hanging fruit that everybody should take care of within the next month. There's obviously more than that, but most people haven't gotten that far, so I really urge you to start there. I'm not going to go into any details on why, but those are kind of your highest risk factors. If you want to look into a little bit more for defensible space, if you go to our website, it has quite a few links there. And then, you know, again, looking back, this is a community.

1:50:04 Are we committing the resources to the needs that we have? This, again, what I would argue is an existential threat for this community in the sense that not just from the fire side, but from an economic perspective for our tourist-based economy. Tough to get everybody up here if everything looks the way it does. Again, our solutions need to be collaborative. Your fire district can't do this alone. The county can't do it alone. That being said,

1:50:39 There are some opportunities for us to start leveraging some larger resources. There's quite a few logos added in place up there that probably need to be a part of this as well. But this is a solution that needs everybody at the table working on this. That's all I have. Do you have any questions? Thank you. We're going to save the questions once we get through the rest of the speakers. I'm sure there's going to be an aggregated bunch of questions. So thank you very much for that. Okay, so next.

1:51:11 We're going to hear from the seasonal staffing, local Forest Service. I don't know how you guys want to handle that. I think the Forest Service can speak to this again. We have both Bill on the Zoom call and Fred here in the office, in the room, can speak to that. A little bit just in terms of the projects and programs that are being planned out there for the summer, assuming the snow gets out of the way to some level.

1:51:34 Piles of Burn, et cetera. But also just the staffing level, they've been noted a little bit, just that seasonal staffing has been a challenge at times in the area. So getting a feel for how we're looking from that perspective as we kind of look forward to hopefully a wildfire season. So I think Fred's going to kick it off and then we'll come back to Bill up in the humble. Yeah, so from a Forest Service regional, California regional perspective.

1:52:02 Hiring was pretty bleak this season. We were only able to hire 50% of what we wanted to fill in our positions in California. However, on Inyo National Forest, it was not as bleak. You know, there are some engine modules that we were not able to staff. Sorry, Bob, it was from Mono Lake Ranger District. We have two engines that weren't staffed. We have...

1:52:29 Water tender in the Mammoth that wasn't staffed simply because of a lack of people either applying or being qualified for some of those jobs. However, we do definitely have enough for initial attack. And so we're not too worried about that. We're still trying to figure out what are some of the reasons. And of course, the common reasons of this lack of workers is probably across the country and across all sorts.

1:53:00 Different fields. However, I know for sure some of the job offers we made to some of our firefighters and engine drivers, they would not have accepted the job unless we provided government housing. And so fortunate for us, we had some vacancies in our government housing. And so I think we would have been a worse situation if it wasn't for the fact that we did not have government housing.

1:53:25 However, it's not a lack of trying from the Forest Service perspective. We have just been approved for standing up most of our fuels modules. So there's a lot of vacant positions that we're going to probably try to advertise simply for doing fuels reduction. So these people aren't going to be for suppression. These are going to be exclusively 100% of the time fuels reduction. But that's not...

1:53:54 Saying that we're going to hire that many people because there's still a lack of workers and probably a lot of the suppression people will probably move over to the fuels area and so it's just robbing Peter to pay Paul. But hopefully it's just a start. I think it's a commitment from the Forest Service that they're able to provide the funding to do this. Also some other things that we're trying is we're trying to mimic some of the attractive kind of hiring.

1:54:21 We're offering full-time employment for some of our permanent seasonal employees for year-round. A lot of people don't want that, but we are offering it because they want to have that break or maybe they have other jobs in the wintertime as well, but we are offering it really to focus on some of the field's work in the winter.

1:54:50 Thank you very much, Fred.

1:55:18 Which, correct me if I'm wrong, is the largest national forest in the country, is that correct? Yes, sir, it is. 6.3 million acres in the state of Nevada and 700,000 acres in Eastern California and primarily Mono County, Mono and Alpine counties. Well, we thank you very much for being here. I know you've been a friend of these communities in this region for a long time. Well, thanks. Yeah, and if you didn't know, I was the BLM manager in Bishop back in 2002 to 2008. Thank you.

1:55:54 A little bit older and wiser, hopefully, and grayer. Anyway, I would echo what Fred said. We experience the same thing, challenges in seasonal hiring. The good thing is, like Fred said, we are converting more and more of our seasonal firefighters to at least permanent part-time. So they either 18 and 8 pay periods off or 13 and 13.

1:56:19 So that's been successful. The increase in pay that we were able to provide because of the infrastructure laws definitely helped. The president's budget this year would make that permanent. So we'll have to see if Congress approves that. But that would definitely help us. And like Fred said, especially in the eastern Sierra, we compete heavily with CAL FIRE and their portal to portal reimbursement pay, which is...

1:56:48 We just can't keep up with that. In terms of staffing this year, we will be fully staffed either through details or moving engines around. For example, in Bridgeport, if we don't have enough staff for the engines, we'll get folks from Carson or Elko or Las Vegas or somewhere where the fire danger is not as high at the moment. Just looking at the prevention side, which I think we're really trying to focus more and more of.

1:57:18 If I look at the window this evening in Reno, we're actually burning 600 acres of broadcast fire, actually in California, my office here in Reno, though, over in the Dog Valley, Bird Eye, California area. We are really, as your fire chief said there, good fire. Preventive fire is really what we need to focus on. The Forest Service had some starts.

1:57:45 The misfires in New Mexico last year with prescribed fire, we went through an incredible review of the entire agency. We've tightened up our procedures. But here on the Humboldt-Toyabe, we're really looking at expanding the use of prescribed fire dramatically. I think that's the only way we're going to get ahead of preventing these catastrophic large fires. Along with other techniques, mechanical tending, targeted grazing, we're actually using, we've got a,

1:58:14 A band of 400 sheep out behind Reno and Carson City right now, eating up all the sheep grass, which helps immensely in reducing that fine fuel load early in the season. We're going to continue to do that and increase that across our forest. And then, like I mentioned, we actually were very successful because of entering into a shared stewardship agreement with the state of Nevada. We actually prioritized

1:58:44 Firescapes, what we call firesheds across the state, which included the Sierra Front, which does include, you know, you guys in California there. But because we had done this prioritization, we were rewarded with quite a bit of funding, like I mentioned, over $40 million that we'll be implementing both in the Elko, Ruby Mountains landscape in the Sierra Front. For example, we just,

1:59:13 Led a contract for $17 million for mechanical fuels treatments with a couple Native American tribes in Eastern California. We're actually working with the National Forest Foundation, with the Nature Conservancy, with the California Department of Fish and Wildlife, Nevada Department of Wildlife, Nevada Department of Forestry, CAL FIRE. And so we're trying to spread the money because obviously we...

1:59:40 The HT do not have the capacity to implement all these good treatments. So we're looking at partnerships to get the work done on the ground over the next few years. All right, Bill, stand by. We're going to move on to a couple more speakers and then we'll do round robin questions and answers. Unless you've got something else for us, Bill. No, I'm good. Thanks. I'll stand by. Okay, good. Thank you very much. Please come forward. I don't know you. What's your name? What do you work for? Hello. Hi. My name is Jennifer Martin.

2:00:14 I'm a fuels planner for the Inyo National Forest. So I just wanted to come in and update you on some of our main project areas. I'll start with Red's Meadow. We have a couple of units that were completed this past fall there, mechanical thinning, which leaves us around 260 acres of piles to burn. So that'll be one of our next areas we'll be going into for pile burning. And then we've got quite a bit more work planned there for this next coming year after 23.

2:00:48 In the Lakes Basin area, there's another about 65 acres of mechanical thinning, conifers, it's pretty small diameter, definitely under 24 inch DBH, mechanical thinning in that area, which will also be piled and burned for the most part. I'm sure you've seen there's plenty of piles in the area close and around Mammoth Lakes, consider that the Sherwin, the scenic loop area, and we've got a new

2:01:20 Pile Burn Plan that's also bringing that area, which will be ready soon, so getting into there and take care of those that you're seeing in there. When it comes to the areas a little further up in Mono County, we have about 540 acres of mechanical thinning in the Dry Creek area by Dedman, and quite a bit of work that's been going on around June Mountain, some aspen and meadow restoration, which can be...

2:01:57 Removal of snags and also getting that hazardous fuels out of there. So there's been some work going on in that area in conjunction with White Park. We've got some more of that plans coming here as well. To talk about broadcast burning in the area, we are also soon going to have a new burn plan under the Jeffrey Pine Environmental Assessment.

2:02:26 Which covers about 1,300 acres of potential burning there. It has several different units north and east of the town of Mammoth, such as just south of Smokey Bear Flat, Antelope Valley, just south of Deadman Road, and in the Sherwin Creek area. And I want to say it's very important to remember with any of these broadcast or other burns, it's all very weather window dependent.

2:02:55 When it comes to the number of acres that we were talking about. So we have to definitely wait for the correct window when conditions are ideal to be able to pull us off with the effects that we want and also to make sure it's during a day when we have good smoke dispersal and we'll have minimal impact on the smoke side. And then a recurring project that will still be continuing on. It'll probably be the next place that you see smoke.

2:03:25 Is in our Casa Diablo area, which is just east of sunny slopes. And that's an area that we've been maintaining for a while. It's been an ongoing project to maintain the fire return interval in that area to a more natural level. As far as some of the other work that you may have seen this past fall, I'd like to mention Inu craters, which is some hazard tree and roadside fuels reduction.

2:04:03 And then, yeah, there's been a little bit of work along Highway 203 and the other Red's Meadow that was mentioned there. Are there any questions? There are going to be questions, so have a seat and hang tight. Okay, that works. Yep. Thank you very much. Okay, so I think we've heard a lot about something called Whitebark. Okay. So I think maybe, is there anybody here from Whitebark who'd like to come forward and maybe fill us in on a couple things? Yeah, presenter.

2:04:38 Here we go. Wrong color. I was looking for the wrong color.

2:05:46 I first want to thank you guys for having a joint meeting because it makes some of our lives a fair bit easier. So for those of you who it made harder, I apologize. But thanks for giving us an opportunity to feature fire after what has been a real butt kicking of a winter. So appreciate that. And it's nice to see some of your faces that I've emailed a lot and never met. So my name is Janet Hatfielden with the Whitebark Institute. You've heard a little bit about this project. Alice referred to it.

2:06:15 My job is to keep Alice not so busy and Jen a lot busier and all of you from needing to become incident command management team experts. So that's what we're aiming to do. I'm going to talk a little bit real high level over what we set out to do early on, what we accomplished last year, what's in the queue for this year and what's coming in 2024. A little bit about what I call our cash flow crux.

2:06:43 And how all of you can play a role in that. So photos at the bottom, this is our new norm, right? Climate chaos. So here we are. How do we get out of this very reactive mode into a preventative proactive mode? So we avoid the slide on the very far right, which was the creek fire with the day. I think it's maybe second or third day of it starting.

2:07:07 So really quickly, here's the current boundary of the Mammoth Donut. We can't really call it that anymore because it now looks like I don't know what. But as a result of the public scoping process, it grew a little bit. I think the color denotation of that blue or green to the north and east shows you those adjustments based off basically a lot of public comment to the effect of can't you bring it all the way to June so this boundary hits up against prior

2:07:35 NEPA documents from the Forest Service around the June Lake Loop, and it omits the Owens Headwater Wilderness. So we're still outside of wilderness. There's some weird gaps in there. That's a long story, but basically we removed some of the acres out of the NEPA work that we're doing. And just a point of clarifications for some of you that maybe haven't heard about this project ad nauseum from me is because it's so large, there's two different phases going. There's a planning phase.

2:08:02 Doing all the environmental work at a 58,000 acre scale. But then, surprise, we're also implementing on some previous projects that the Forest Service got completed on the order of about 10,000 acres. So two pieces are happening simultaneously, which causes a little bit of confusion. But really, the purpose and need behind the planning effort is, number one, community resilience. We've talked a lot about that.

2:08:27 This project will help Alish do his job safer, similar to the Forest Service folks. The reason that fires are getting worse is because the fuel problem is getting worse. So it makes it much more difficult to be successful. Obviously, forest health and resilience is a massive driver, and then really preparing this landscape for the reintroduction of beneficial fire when it's safe and appropriate to do that. And really quick...

2:08:55 Way back. This is early project goals, so I just want to highlight number one was to protect this town and to really build a fire understanding of a fire culture and a consciousness in this community because the next 30 years are going to be, if we had anything to learn from the last three, it's buckle up. So it's a huge opportunity to be ready and these are some of our guiding principles that

2:09:20 Help in our work as well as our collaborative work with the Forest Service and other partners. In a project this big, it really was helpful to have some planning time to really figure out how to organize ourselves. So we have seven different sort of priority planning areas. Right now, much of our work is based at those foundational building blocks. So how do we figure out how we're going to fund this thing?

2:09:48 Where do we take the material and who's going to do the work? Without one of those three things, we're done. It's not going to happen. It's a great idea. Nothing's going to work. Simultaneously, because of the importance of outreach and education, we talked a lot about that, is an early outreach effort in recognition that this is not a standard Forest Service unit. This has never been an industrial timber forest, so people are not accustomed.

2:10:14 to seeing this type of work at the levels that they're going to see it, and that is a huge education opportunity and really responsibility for all of us involved. So you'll see I'm really focused on the activities on the implementation and planning side. I'm not going to go into the outreach. There's just a lot to talk about there. So this is a snapshot of last year. So just want to highlight we near approached 1,000 acres. That's combined work between

2:10:43 Inyo National Forest, Whitebark Lead, and our partners at the National Forest Foundation. So there's three implementing partners right now working on this. So this is the work that was accomplished last year. That's where you're going to see Jen's crews doing some focused pile burning. We all know that the risk is not reduced considerably until that fuel is off the forest. It doesn't matter if it's in a nice little pile or not. It helps, but it doesn't solve the problem.

2:11:09 If you haven't hiked around and looked at the work pre and post, here's a good snapshot. This is along Mammoth Creek just next to the Sherwin Creek Campground. This is just a little bit of an idea of what's like out there if you don't hike off trail too often. A tremendous amount of fuel. This is what we have planned for this summer. So roughly 500 acres of thinning, another 200 to 500 acres of prescribed fire. It'll highly be dependent on where those prescribed fire windows occur.

2:11:37 But if you want details, this map gives you an idea of where the work will be happening on the thinning front and what all those parcels are named. And of note, we have two town-owned properties as well as a city of LA-owned property under Mammoth Mountain Lease, which were all three identified in the Monroe County Multi-Jurisdictional Hazard Mitigation Plan. So those are all funded from this CAL FIRE award to move forward this summer.

2:12:05 A big deciding factor is on Mammoth Creek if it's going to dry out enough to do that. So hang on. I'll be coordinating close with Lawson, Hayes, what that looks like. But we're looking late, late summer at best. So those are some of the challenges of this coming summer. And we'll provide an update in the fall on what actually happened versus what was planned.

2:12:30 And then looking way forward, so this is what's planned for 2024, and why I only include these three years is the environmental work that we're doing will open up a whole other set of acreage come 2025. So we're really focused on checking off the low-hanging fruit, getting as much done with the state funding that's flowing as possible. 2024 is focused highly on Red's Meadow.

2:12:55 A thousand acres in reds that's going to go down. We're going to try to do it in one fell swoop. We'll see what happens. But that is a humongous step far above. That's just Whitebark's contract. So there's additional acres happening up in the north part of the project in Dry Creek. And there's a small workforce development opportunity out in Sherman Creek, about 54 acres, that will be inviting new local business entrepreneurs that want to get involved, an opportunity to sort of get their feet wet.

2:13:24 Build a relationship with the agency as part of this incentivization of people getting involved in this type of work, which is a new and evolving economic development opportunity that's one of the things we're looking at through the SEDS process, right? Did I get the right acronym? I get the two confused, SURF and SEDS. Anyway, that's the work happening in 2024, fully funded. Sierra Nevada Conservancy funded this piece. So we are about, let's see, I think I skipped that.

2:13:54 We're about $12.5 million in state funds, and I just got our first federal funding that we're hoping the agreement is signed in June for $900,000 from the INYO that got last minute allocated to the region, and we're here to prove that we can use it quick. So sort of the cash flow conundrum is what I call it. So all of this work is incredibly expensive, and luckily the state agencies have passed some legislation so that they allow for cash advances.

2:14:25 Unfortunately, the cash advance policy isn't really working on the ground, and I think that's not unusual for some of these sort of policy decisions to not really get what it is like on the ground. So what happens is we're required to spend down any advance to the penny before you're eligible for the next. So it means you have to have a crystal ball to know what the weather's going to be like six months out. So you can imagine the challenges that that presents.

2:14:54 I was off $100,000 last year, which means I'm not eligible until I write a check to a timber operator spending down that $100,000. Then I can submit the paperwork to CAL FIRE and I wait 8 to 12 weeks until it arrives. Meanwhile, we have small timber operators working. They've got employees to pay, families to feed, mortgages, etc. You get the idea. So the cash flow pinch is a real concern and something that I'm

2:15:24 Reaching out to the members of the financial advisory team that we've put together for this project to help solve. And the reason that it's important that we solve now at the smaller scale is in three years from now, we're going to be working at four times so that the dollar amount is going to rise significantly. So it's a great opportunity and a bit of a primer to solve for a bigger problem around how do you actually support, how does the money move to support a project of this size and scale?

2:15:53 Roughly speaking, if I had a crystal ball, $150 to $200 million. We can bring that price down with the application of more prescribed fire, but it's going to be weather dependent. So the good news in that is about three minutes before I walked into this office, I have asked to both town council and Mammoth Mountain for help on the cash flow front.

2:16:18 Tom Hodges just reported back to me that Denver approved a $500,000 advance from Altera at 0% interest for us paperwork in short order. So that's step one. I'm looking to match that for a full million. That'll help us be able to weather the storm and spend those funds down and get the other Cal Fire money rolling. So this is, we're working at a policy level to change the policy, but in the short term, it's a real need to, and I need your help in solving.

2:16:48 A bit more of how we've funded this project to date. These are all the different partners that have participated in one way, shape, or form. I don't want to jinx us and put the Mono County biomass proposal on there yet, but I'm hopeful that that's successful. But it takes a bit of a village, and how we can share these grants across ESCOG and Whitebark and Inyo and other partners is going to be really, really critical.

2:17:16 And then the big piece of the puzzle for this project in particular is how do we explore the payment for ecosystem services market? This is not new. This is huge. It has everything from the water supply, which is big here, to the recreation value and all of the other good things that come with healthy forests. But in particular, we have Dr. Rick Cattleman, a colleague of mine at Whitebark, to thank for his early work on...

2:17:43 Applying the hydrologic models that demonstrate the water benefits of this work. And what this graph is saying is if we remove the basal area, which is basically the density of trees by 40 percent, so we take out all those little pesky trees that don't do a lot of good for us across less than half of this project.

2:18:06 That equates to 8,000 to 10,000 acre feet of water into the Owens River, which is a 6% to 7% increase for LA. So that is what they, that's talking their language. So that's going to be a big piece of the puzzle, but that in and of itself, and even if we do really well and we are able to pull all the political strings to get the bipartisan, you know, some of that big federal funding that you heard the HT has been a recipient of, we're still not going to be totally there.

2:18:36 So this is really where part of the financial advisory team, this is like the first introductory slide that we used a year ago with that group is who really pays for these wildfires? And really it's a combined approach, but the large sum of long-term fire impacts are paid for by local governments through lost revenue, lost taxes, all of the things that you...

2:19:04 It's far more than just the suppression cost, which is what this. And so this report details it really beautifully. And it's why it's like, well, we have a choice. We can prioritize it now and figure out how we're going to collectively solve, or we can wait and be in response mode. And I just feel like this winter, this last cycle, I guess, of about two years has been really eye-opening at just the battering that we...

2:19:30 Are going to continue to have if we can't figure out how do we stay focused on the preventative side of things? And yes, maybe have an emergency triage team, but the more we lose focus of the preventative side, we're further exacerbating that cycle. So that's the one benefit of whitebark, and you hear lots of praises, is I have the luxury of being able to stay focused on one thing. I don't get sidetracked into

2:19:57 Response and things like that. I have a 16-year federal fire background, so I get that piece, but that is really the recipe behind our success is really being able to focus and make this work a priority. So this is something we can only do together, and I welcome you all. And our June 8th financial advisory team meeting is a special one. It's going to be in person.

2:20:22 So if there's any way you can make it, it's at the Forest Service. It's at your office. Surprise. But we're going to have in-person guest speakers, the folks at Blue Forest. We've asked them to do a real deep dive into the nuts and bolts of this whole innovative financing mechanism that they are proposing to use here. And I need your help vetting that as a solution here. Does it work for us? It's not my call. I need you collectively to come.

2:20:50 With your strong, economic-savvy minds to ask tough questions, and we're going to have a break in that meeting and have sort of a closed session where we can have a real frank conversation about next steps. So that's all I have for you. Thanks. Excellent, Jen. Thank you very much. Okay, so I think, Dan and Mary, I think the next steps are yours, and then we'll get into our questions and conversations. One more, we have Justin Alder from the County Solid Waste Program who's going to give a brief overview of some of the

2:21:21 Opportunities through the solid waste program for residents doing cleanup and how they can dispose of that waste. Doing biomass and those kinds of things. Okay, great. Thank you. Welcome. Yes, thank you. Justin Nalder with Mono County staff today before you as a solid waste superintendent. We've been looking at some pretty high-level stuff right now as far as mitigation, recovery, and prevention. Mono County remains open to the potential collaboration for some of these projects, particularly at Pumice Valley Landfill.

2:21:49 Where we have existing permits, which will speed up potentially some of these projects, looking at wood vault storage, looking at the potential for biomass facilities, that remains open and we'll continue to try to participate as we can. Looking more on an individual level, what can we do right now as spring hits us, as some of these floodwaters move through, you have residences and small businesses that are going to be looking to clean up.

2:22:16 We've been working diligently to try to provide opportunities for waived dump fees. And through the Clean California Act, Caltrans has stepped up to sponsor some events at some of the county waste facilities. So far, we've had Benton and Chalfont transfer stations sponsor an event earlier in the year. We are next looking at having a green waste amnesty event. It'll run for two weeks. It starts tomorrow. This was by special request.

2:22:46 And so all of the county facilities, excepting the typical waste materials, will waive green waste fees. Green waste primarily being focused on organics and clean wood waste. So if you separate those, bring them in, and Caltrans will cover the bill, take it to any of the county facilities. That'll run for two weeks. Then we're looking at two months worth of big stuff amnesty month. This is like vehicles, trailers, appliances.

2:23:15 Big stuff that typically costs quite a bit more money to dispose of, and that'll be focused at Pumice Valley Landfill. Folks can take their stuff there. We've got other smaller events that we do periodically throughout the year. For example, coming up on a Saturday, we've got a Lee Vining Household Hazardous Waste Collection event, and then we're working together to provide the Town of Mammoth Lakes.

2:23:40 Annual Community Cleanup Event where the fees are waived again. That's looking like it's going to be at the end of June, potentially the 23rd and 24th. We also have an active program, which is the Wood Waste Voucher Program, and this is for defensible space, and it's supposed to be for property owners to create defensible space around their structures. You can go and pick up wood vouchers from the local fire districts.

2:24:08 The fire chiefs are responsible for running these programs and assigning someone to hand out the vouchers. They're good for 580 pounds of voucher or a cubic yard, depending on where you go, and you're not limited to just one. So really the focus is to help people help themselves in that area. That's about it for now. Thank you. Excellent. Thank you very much. Okay, so now you guys.

2:24:35 We've got Zone Haven, Upgraded Communication System, Education, the update on the joint hazard mitigation plan. Yeah, we're going to touch just briefly on these items that came up in some other discussions. As you may be aware, we rolled out the Zone Haven program a while back. Chris was involved in that, others, Fire District, et cetera. A lot of that was to be able to actually have an evacuation plan in place that we could do notification and kind of direct it.

2:25:02 We did one training in the trails area. It worked fairly well in terms of being able to identify an area and move people out of that. Ongoing issue there is if we look at fire season and the potential for evacuations, what does that look like in the planning and notifications? So that tool's out there. It also has a little bit of an emergency notification that can go out on the mapping and then we supplement that with an iPods or other type of broadcast warnings and those types of pieces that come together.

2:25:30 Go through this kind of quick and then Chris can add to this. The other thing the council's aware of and the board has upgraded communication system. We've been working through that quite heavily to get some additional sites up, go into a partnership with the state and the Chris system, the California Interoperability, Interoperable Communication System. It's California Reliable Interoperable System. It's a trunked.

2:25:57 System throughout the county. The state's put in, I think it's five sites or six sites, and we'll have five additional sites going in, two here in Mammoth and three out in the county in different places. A lot of the funding for that's coming actually out of some earmarked money that the county received out of the Senate last year, so $3 million going into that. That will include an upgrade of the radios themselves as well as the system, working through a lot of different elements there and looking at best pricing on radios, that type of work.

2:26:26 Ongoing education efforts, a lot of that's been touched on. We don't spend a lot of time there, but like the camp like the pro and a lot of different elements of be responsible when you're out there. A lot of that, you know, most of our fires are probably human-started versus natural. So one of those things to be watching for as we're out and about. And then as you mentioned earlier, updating the joint hazard mitigation plan. We've already touched on that, so we won't spend a lot of time with that one.

2:26:50 But as we do that, as noted earlier, some of the grant work and stuff requires that plan to be in place in order to be eligible for a lot of the funding sources to come into play. With that, Chris, if you want to add any of the other work related to those items, feel free. I know we did use the Zone Haven software this winter for avalanche warnings and evacuations. Right now, we're utilizing it. Pretty much all of Mono County is under a flood advisory.

2:27:19 At this time, and then we'll be upgrading specific areas that are, you know, at higher risk, and then using our emergency notification system to start notifying those areas to get ready and to prepare. And so we're definitely working on that. And then as far as the radio communication system upgrade,

2:27:46 We were very fortunate to work with the fire districts and come to a consensus on the type of radio and the brand. It's good. Yes, it was very good. It's one of those Ford versus Chevy owner situations, and so we were very happy to be able to get that pushed through. So that is moving forward, and we should be able to hopefully, depending on getting the infrastructure put into place, something this fall.

2:28:14 Something that will be operational, but then we will also continue to train on interoperability and to work on the coverage because we want to make sure that it works and everybody can communicate with each other and alleviate any concerns that this is going to impact that negatively. So we're moving forward and so it's real positive. All right. Well, a lot of incredibly enlightening and education and informing presentations.

2:28:43 Madam Chair, you are a guest here today. How would you, do you want to, any suggestions on how to take a bite at these, all these various apples? I know I've got a council here that's kind of chomping at the bit, but if you guys want to go first or? Well, I have a few comments, but I'll defer to my colleagues here and we'll be brief. She said. Okay, very quickly, I guess one question or I guess one response. Collaboration.

2:29:11 Everybody's mentioning collaboration. Fire districts. What grade would we give the fire districts in terms of collaboration right now? You just mentioned the radios. We've got to work on that. I guess I just feel like that's something we've got to work on. A lot of things, I get a lot of, you know, just in terms of June and Levining, a lot of comments and concerns, resources, equipment, training, staffing. What's going on with the fire districts? Good conversation about the fire safe councils.

2:29:37 What's going on with the fire districts? Again, in the Mammoth side of things, I think we've been having conversations with the fire district to make sure should they want to put another measure back in front of the voters, that they're going to get 100% support. We've had good success in Mammoth Lakes. We've had good success in Mammoth Lakes putting revenue-specific measures in front of the voters where it's not a general...

2:30:01 Tax, it's not a general fund type of initiative. I think we're very much looking forward to looking with the leadership, with your board, to come forward to start working very specifically with town council members who've had good success with these things. So it's a Mammoth Lakes, we're looking forward for that. If I'm wrong, 10 other, 9 or 10 other fire districts in the county? Yeah. And I'm just saying all of that's got to come together. I hear you saying loud and clear, collaboration, we've got to work together, we've got to get more bang for the buck. And so I just feel like we're, and I'm not saying it isn't there, I'm just saying where is it?

2:30:28 And how are we doing? Because I hear you loud and clear saying that's one of the keys to success. Wendy talked about regional efforts. You know, it is still a region, damn it. And so we've got to do that. And so I'm concerned that the fire districts be on board and that we spend some time working on that. Josh Tamir, Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District. I'll speak a little bit on the general subject. I think it's very important for the region.

2:30:53 It's difficult. I work with fire districts quite a bit. I'm the one-eyed leading the blind in the sense that I have very few resources and they think that I have a significant amount of resources. They don't have a lot of my problems, so it's different. My advice to this group would be that we will be depending on these fire districts in one sense or another for a very long period of time, so we need to figure out a way to work together and also we should all do what we're best at in the sense that I don't expect

2:31:23 Thank you.

2:31:50 Carrying a lot of weight for a long period of time, and they're just tired at this point. I think we have a responsibility to support them, but also we benefit if we support them and can keep them going in the sense that, you know, Janet and I can speak on the Mammoth Lakes Fire Safety Council. They did some great work in the first few years. They are a great organization. We burned them out, frankly, to the point where the project that they are taking on up in the Lakes Basin.

2:32:18 It was a little bit more than they could chew off with the amount of staff time that they had. The solution to that is I'm helping them out, Janet's helping them out, and we are taking the advantage of having a FireSafe Council, what that can bring in grant opportunities and tying it to our staff capacity to make that move forward. So, you know, my advice would be on projects like the radio project has been frustrating. I've been working on it for about 10 years now. I have to have those side conversations with...

2:32:48 The fire districts all the time. And I also recognize that they have a point. It is not the perfect system. I'd have to remind everybody we had a federal engineering study here about six or seven. It's probably been eight, nine years now. It came in with about an $18 million solution. So unless somebody has $18 million that they want to bring to the table, this is a pretty darn good solution for a county of our size working on.

2:33:12 Leveraging some state systems. So again, I get it. It's a little bit more than Ford than Chevy, but there's a little bit of that. But I think, again, as frustrated as we can be with the fire districts, imagine if you didn't have any fire districts today in the situation we'd be in today. So I do not advocate for you to try to put out fires or go extricate people out of vehicles. But when we can support them in administrative things, things like that, and then remind them of that support that we're providing them.

2:33:41 The radio system is actually a great example of that. The county and the town have supported that push so they can work on being firefighters because that's frankly what they're good at. They're not good at riding grass. Hopefully that answers a little bit of your question. Thank you. The second thing is really Fred and Bill, locality pay. Locality pay, I guess my question is would that make a difference in your recruitment ability and retention for federal employees, obviously? Can I answer that?

2:34:15 You have to be careful how you respond. Well, actually, we've had some success here locally. Reno is actually slated to get a locality pay starting in 2024. We've been working with our local congressional folks and other federal agencies for quite a while on that. I actually did work with the Marine Corps Mountain Warfare Training Center a few years back. We actually went to D.C. and made a presentation to the president's pay agent.

2:34:44 We were unsuccessful trying to get a locality pay for Mono County. But I think we did sort of lay a marker down. I think if collectively we put our resources together, we could make another run at it. I had a short conversation with Congressman Kiley about this. Didn't necessarily get a commitment as much as I would have liked, but at least got to be glad to work with you. So I know it is a matter of us working with you to get data, and I've talked with Leslie about that.

2:35:32 But Bill, to the extent we need to coordinate across the two floors, I'd be willing and have already done some work on it. We've got to keep moving on that. Frankly, it's the old thing of you hope they'll do the right thing for the right reason, but let's have them do the right thing because we irritate the hell out of them because it's the right thing in the long run. I'll just add to that with this, the comments made earlier about the after action report, you know, we are, the elected officials are the advocacy voice for this region. And I think we need things in that after action report.

2:36:01 Summaries, concise bullet points, financials, things like that that we can use, certainly the county supervisors and us as small town electeds, we can be advocating for this stuff. That's that kind of point I'm trying to make. Yeah. I don't want to reiterate everything that Bob said, because that was spot on, so thank you for that. But just a comment is that until we can continue to engage our community to be not only responsible for their own space, but...

2:36:35 Being able to support the community further, I think we're just, we need to not leave that part out. I drive through communities and I'm stunned and amazed at how people seem to love having a big tree grow right next to their deck and onto their deck and think that that's just swell. You know, wow, isn't that pretty? Second of Mars, maybe. I don't know, but it terrifies me. So until we can add that as a component of all this talk, I think we need to really focus on local.

2:37:04 Thank you. Let me just wind up, Russ, what you're saying along that line, and it struck me, and there's one thing that just rings out, especially for the south part of the county, and what happens there affects here just as much as...

2:37:31 Thank you so much.

2:38:01 That these people have to drive 150 miles to take it to Pumice Valley, okay? And I can tell you where it is right now. It's sitting in their front lawns or in their backyards. And we need to find some resources. They're not asking anyone to take it and clean it up for them. They just don't have an economical way to get rid of this stuff. And what's happening now is

2:38:29 So thank you to...

2:38:54 Justin, I admittedly make his life a burning hell. Asking for assistance on this in these green waste cleanup days, at least we can waive the fees on this, and we are going after everything that Caltrans will offer us on cleanup days. Many counties don't like this. We love it and we'll take them all. The other thing is the biomass opportunity.

2:39:23 And the Golden State Finance Authority to get one of these here.

2:39:53 There's a lot of opposition to these particular facilities throughout the state, and I understand in different areas why it doesn't make sense. Here, it's probably our only solution. And then the last thing that we have here is, along with Walker Fire a few years ago, and

2:40:17 What we experienced in Round Valley, the Wheeler Crest Fire Safe Council has an excellent toolkit that I will be sharing with anyone because they got a grant and said if you're going to get this area back in shape, you have a responsibility to fill out this. They have a toolkit that is applied to any of our areas. Happy to share this. Finally, I got the privilege to visit

2:40:47 And five years after catastrophic fire, that an area that looks a lot like and we don't want to look like, they have incredible resources, though they are up there, but they are experiencing their regrowth in the building to recover has changed the community and they have a lot of resources close. We don't have anything that happens to us wouldn't change our community.

2:41:26 You know, for just a short time, it may not recover. And that's what we're all working towards. So any of the resources that protect our community winter and summer are ones that we're continuously advocating for. They're worth our time and our dollars. Okay, good. All right, council members. Anybody? Go ahead. Nobody wants to go. I'm sort of scattered here because I've got stuff I can't read myself all over the page.

2:41:59 But there's a few things I want to point out. One, the thinning piles and the pile burning, nothing scares me worse than having to have a thousand piles in the forest for three years until the moisture in it goes down to the point that it will burn, but we have to have snow on top of it to safely burn it. A cigarette butt thrown into that at the wrong time and the whole place goes poop. Fire safe around our houses. My house is in the middle of Mammoth. I have too many trees on. I've only taken out 22 in the last.

2:42:32 Five or six years. I've got another 20 or 30 to go, which I can't do myself anymore as I used to be able to do. So where does the help come for us to drop those trees and get them off? But frankly, if a fire starts in reds and comes over the pass, and if you've ever gone to Google Earth or hiked it and looked at that path of dead and down and green trees, that is a natural path where it's going to suck over the top.

2:42:59 If that fire makes it to my house, what I have on my property is of no consequence because the town's gone already. So I'm really worried on the forest side to hear the biomass fuel plants. I think that's a great idea if we can get together and make it work on a regional level or if we have to tackle it locally. I've had many of these conversations because I would far rather see...

2:43:27 Even if the government has to pony up money to get it to the biomass plants, to me that it's a much better solution than leaving piles that are ready to burn. There's some questions in here, so if you want to try and answer them later, that's fine. When we do the thinning projects that the Forest Service does, and then we cut them up and we put them into piles, we fine people if they go up and take stuff out of the piles because it degradates the type and size of the pile.

2:43:57 So maybe to leave it on the ground a tad longer and leave it open to firewood gathering for those that use this as a fuel would make more sense than finding them for pulling something out of the pile later on. We keep talking about the overgrowth and we keep talking about how we have stopped fire in the past and we have let it grow to the point where it is unsustainable. Part of the problem with that is just how we run the forest.

2:44:30 The idea that mankind should not be a piece of managing the forest is unnatural to me. The condition our forests are in and have been for the last 30 or 40 years, the need for mechanical thinning prior to the reintroduction to fire, in my opinion, is huge. That's how we keep it from running away. If we get it back to a spot, a healthy spot, where then we can allow natural fires to occur and they don't.

2:44:58 Exceed 500 acres or 1,000 acres. Then we can reintroduce fire. Before that, we're just asking for conflagration, which we have seen in New Mexico, we've seen it happen in California. So these are my concerns when it comes to the fire. How we come up with the money to implement these things. You know, we've seen the state of California have multi-billion dollar surpluses that they haven't even seen fit to replace their snow plows that don't work. So how do we get that?

2:45:28 Yeah, I hope. It just...

2:45:57 Because of the lack of funding and the environmental process it has to go through, we are unnaturally risking, you know, the town of Mammoth Lakes. So that is sort of me politicizing and looking to the Forest Service. I don't know how we help. I don't know how we get the government to increase the budget so we can go back where it was. We've seen in the past there has been major logging in our forest. It occurred all of my childhood.

2:46:26 Then when the Forest Service replanted, they replanted in plantations that were 50 times too dense, and then the money went away for them to go out and thin it when they would normally have done it. So more than just Mother Nature, this is a man-made crisis that we should be able to somehow deal with. John, I'm going to go back to a question I have if someone has it on the original first part we went over, and that has to do with the propane tanks. I am told that one of our companies...

2:46:58 Has a GIS database of all their tags but are unwilling to share it. So we don't need to answer that question. But for those of you out there, if that's the truth, let me know so we can put some political pressure on that. Dan, maybe a note to follow up. Okay, Bill, thank you very much for that. And other council members? Yeah, Chris, go ahead. First of all, Wendy, I'm thrilled about the grant you're writing for the mitigation toolkits. And so...

2:47:26 How would those be staffed? Like, it goes around, and then does the community put the stuff in the chipper? How does it work? Wendy, come up here. Thank you. By the way, I had this idea last year, so I'm so glad it's happening. American wildfire ants. Okay, you mentioned them, yeah. ...experience doing such things, and they would take on the management, the repair, the training, making sure that the chipper's in, well, they're going to break down, so then you're going to have to get them fixed. And so that's written into the grant as well.

2:48:04 Otherwise, I think y'all might be having a tizzy fit because of the liability. That's what's written into the grant for that part. I'm not sure what we're going to do with the trailer work. We're getting an action that won't be connected. That's awesome. We'll figure it out. So another thing, you might as well stay up there because this is pretty much for everybody. So June 11th is Wildfire Week.

2:48:40 So, Alish, I remember last year, Chief Frank Freehold wrote a piece, and it ended up in this sheet, and it said, like, get to work, clear your stuff, and I actually did it. I went out and did all my pine needles, et cetera. So, I think it's a really good opportunity. Everybody's paying attention. They realize that, you know, we're under risk all the time now, and it's a really good chance for us to do as much as possible in the community to say, hey, here's how you do it. It's not that hard. We're going to do it together.

2:49:10 And so I just encourage everyone to, you know, as you're putting together programs, lean on us because we're happy to amplify it. The next thing was, oh, I'm just, this question's been burning at me forever. I don't know why I never asked you. If we do a biomass facility at ORMAT, is that just to take the biomass and turn it into biochar or is it creating electricity? I never asked that question. Okay.

2:49:41 Yay. Another question I have, as long as we're all here, you know, I know there's like maybe a mini mill that goes with this operation, but have we thought about, I know there's like a small mill out in the industrial park, but it seems to me like

2:50:14 Any of this wonderful lumber that we have has to be trucked so far that it becomes economically infeasible. So are we talking as a community about an economic development opportunity of a mill somewhere close enough that we could do something with all of this? Because that's another way to sequester carbon. And you don't have to answer it now, but I can't help myself. These are questions that maybe some technical follow-up will be appropriate, but it's good to get these questions out.

2:50:44 Right now, so there's a new mill in Carson City. They're just coming online. They're inundated with salvage material. They want us to pay them to take time. Yeah. Because there's so much wood available. Sure. The marketability of using that mill, something at a really small scale, possibly, but it's where there's just not that many things. Thank you. Fair enough. Just had to ask. Perhaps if there was enough material, how many, how long is that sustainable before we provide enough material?

2:52:15 I think we all know young people who, so I don't know how long they have to commit to, but it seems to me like. Unfortunately, I don't know the details of that, but I know that generally we require one or two seasons of fire in order to really be competitive for permanent work. And we do have an apprenticeship program where we

2:53:14 We kind of train them when they're lower level, and eventually we convert them to a permanent firefighter after the training program. What about for the thinning part, though, where they're not actually, you said there were two sides to the equation, and one is just, is that as highly skilled of a need? Yeah, because it also involves prescribed burning, so it's all kind of part and parcel qualifications. Gotcha, thanks. And then,

2:53:47 My last question answered Janet's question about the need for $5,000 of funding. And is that town and county? I just want to make sure we know next steps since she did such an awesome presentation. That'll follow up out of the finance group that's looking at those potential for the town. And Janet, you need that by July, right? It would be mid-July so that it's not this. I would.

2:54:21 You would all be horrified at how it went down last summer, and I'm not going to share that because I lost a fair bit of sleep. So we got the work done. That's all that matters. But yeah, mid-July is the target date. And then the payback is before the end of the year. So it's very short-term. We need Jenna to sleep because she's working so hard and she's, you know, doing this unbelievable thing for her town and county. So let's make sure Jenna gets to sleep. Super quickly, can I address one of...

2:54:51 Councilmember Sauser's comments. So I've talked to a little bird, an outside person that specializes in what is the rubric to getting some of these big federal funding allocations. And her answer was threefold. Local grassroots collaboration, which we have. The NEPA document, great. The workforce, which I was like, ooh, working on it. And maybe I said threefold, I meant four.

2:55:21 The other is the political advocacy, which is where you can all help. And I've already spoken to Supervisor Dugan and Councilwoman Busber to help on this piece so that we get elected folks here and we show them the work that we're doing and why we need to be eligible for that next bill funding because without that, we're not going to get it. So that's where you can help. Thank you. So Sarah, Amanda? Yeah, I would like to...

2:55:51 You know, I guess I feel like fire is on everyone's mind. You know, everyone in Mammoth, everyone in June, everyone in the whole county. I feel like we've all been affected by it, by the smoke. I think that, you know, the fire department would have a good chance of getting something passed if we did put it on the ballot, you know, for funds, if we need those funds to protect our town from fire. You know, Bill, you said a fire coming through Red's Meadow is scary to you. Honestly, to me,

2:56:19 People camping in the woods and living in the woods, you know, I feel like I'm pretty scared that, you know, like one of those fires are going to get out of control and, you know, how quickly that would be able to be stopped or, you know, so I'm very supportive of this donut project and, you know, the biomass facility would be amazing and I just feel like this is a problem for the whole county and we really need to work together to protect our homes.

2:56:50 All right, good. So I think we can take away from all this, I hope we all take away from this, is the enormous amount of capacity, a remarkable amount of capacity that's coming through the county, that's coming through some inspired leadership from NGOs, and this is aligning with funding opportunities coming out of the state. It was mentioned briefly around the idea that the state is moving to block grant programs and regional planning.

2:57:15 I don't know how many of you are tracking all this, but we are lining up in a perfect way to be able to take advantage of those things. I think on the communication things, Bob, Lynda and all of us have been on the ESCOG, worked on a regional voice. We're having a meeting tomorrow with Whitebark in Monroe County to start to align messaging around Camp Leca Pro, messaging around fire to feed that into the visitor connection program. This is something we need to start supporting.

2:57:40 To really establish and put in place that regional voice so these entrepreneurial NGOs get these grants, it goes into a common articulation of this region, who we are, what we do, and our expectations of our visitors. I have one request, Madam Chair. I believe that the Town of Mammoth Lakes, the Town Council, I hope the proposition will come in front of us to establish an EIFD for the Town of Mammoth Lakes. And what's so compelling about this now is that the EIFDs can include

2:58:10 Funding and resources to do the kind of fire and fuels work that we're talking about. And I think if we can come forward with the proposition, Mary, Madam Chair, we would love to solicit your participation, the county's participation in the IFD. There's obviously no ask for that right now. But obviously, you know, when the baby got split back in 1983, and the county gets all the property tax revenues, so all these buildings here, Amanda's house and her homes,

2:58:39 That's your tax base. We can do things through TOT and the money we get in through tourism to help support Janet, help deal with these cash flow issues. We're going to have a conversation tomorrow about how important it is for this community to have the type of general fund support that we have through this bargain that we made many years ago. But we look forward to bringing that proposition to you guys and having you participate in that. And that's a conversation for another day, but I want to make sure that that's on the table. And Dan, I know, will be working on that to bring that thing forward.

2:59:08 And Mary, thank you for your conversation the other day. It was very helpful. So with that, if there's been a nice, long, but very productive session, if there's any final thoughts or questions? Any public comment out there, Jamie? Sure. I think we all got it. We've all read it. I think we're good with that. Excuse me? For the joint meeting, as soon as possible. When can we pull this together? Go back and look. We actually set some potential dates with delays on committee. I don't remember the, I thought it was October.

2:59:45 Yeah, twice a year, basically. Okay, whatever you guys can pull together. There's a lot of things to follow up here. We're all working on a whole variety of different committees. But again, your elected leadership wants to be advocating and doing everything we can to bring resources back to this community. Thank you all very much. Thanks for coming. Bill, great to see you again. Thanks for coming. Say hi to Reno. We're not moving there anytime soon, just so you know. No. Thank you all very much. We are adjourned.

3:00:16 How are you doing? I'm doing all right. No, no, no, no. I'll be still. I'll be. I'll be chesty.