Housing Board (MLH / ESCH) · 2021
Housing Board (MLH / ESCH)
at 18:00
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Minutes ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
207 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:01 We don't have a quorum yet. We need one more. Ah, there we go, Tom. I think we have everyone who's going to be here this evening. I'll give it one more minute, and then I'll call the meeting to order. Can you hear us, Kirk? Heidi. Hi, Heidi. I think everybody is connected now. Yep, I think everybody who's here is here. Okay, I'll call the...
0:47 I'll call to order the regular meeting of the Public Benefit Corporation 501C3, Mammoth Lake Housing, Inc., whose mission is to support affordable housing for a viable economy and sustainable community. Roll call, please. Kirkstapp? Here. Jennifer Kreitz? I can see her. I can't hear her. We'll mark her here. Lindsay Burks? Can you not hear me? Now I can. I can hear you now, Jennifer. All right.
1:19 Lindsay Barksdale? Yes, here. Soraya Cruz? Here. Hodges? Here. Agnes Fiansen? Tony Perkins? Present. Heidi Steenstra? Here. And Brian D'Andrea. Brian, you look like you're frozen, but we're going to mark you here because I can see you. Thank you.
1:52 Okay. We have a quorum, so we will continue with Mammoth Lake Housing, Board Meeting. Are there any public comments? There are no public comments at this time. We'll move to Agenda Item Number 3-1, which is approval of the minutes from the June 7, 2021, Regular Board Meeting. Are there any corrections or deletions? If not, can I have a motion, please? So moved. I need a second.
2:27 I'll second it. It's been moved and seconded. Thank you. Please roll call. Oops. Okay. My voting screen is not coming up for some reason. You want me to read the names? Nope. Here we go. Kirk Stapp? Yes. Jennifer Kreitz? Yes. Lindsay Barksdale? Yes. Zariah Cruz? Yes. Tom Hodges? Yes. Tony Perkins? Yes.
3:07 Heidi? Heidi Steenstra? Yes. Sorry, my machine is glitching up here. And Brian DeAndrea, I will mark as absent for this vote because it looks like he is frozen and cannot respond to us. There's a majority there. He may call in on a phone number. He seems to have an easier time with that connection. So if you see, if he joins, I'll let you know. Okay, I'll keep an eye also over there.
3:39 I can bump them up if we need to. Thank you. We'll move to, we have a quorum, so we will continue with the board meeting. Patricia, an introduction, introduction of the 21-22 California Coalition for Rural Housing, Rural West Interim, Rico Guzman-Rangel. Thank you, everybody.
4:12 Thank you for joining us for this board meeting. And this item is a formal introduction of our current year intern. His name is Eric Guzman Rangel. And a little background on the internship program. This will be our third intern through a partnership with California Coalition for Rural Housing, who helps pay for
4:39 Our intern who was part-time for 12 months. This program really encourages underrepresented students to participate in learning about the fields of community development and affordable housing. Let's see, the board approved the application to the grant program in December of 2020. We proceeded, we were awarded in January and proceeded with recruitment efforts.
5:10 We interviewed Eric and made an offer and he started working in the office at the beginning of June. Through this program, he's able to work a total of 1,320 hours over the course of the next 12 months. And currently, or most recently, his work program has included working very hard on our 4th of July, our first ever 4th of July float, as far as I know.
5:41 He's working very hard on entering all of our home ownership files into our new cloud-based database software. He's going to start working on annual occupancy monitoring of those home buyer files. He's going to help with some translation services, putting some of our applications into Spanish, as well as
6:08 Work items related to our project at 238 Sierra Manor Road, which may include additional grant applications, construction loan documents, and other assistance as necessary, and so much more. That's just what I can think of, you know, off the top of my head. He's very enthusiastic and excited to learn of all the ins and outs of policy and project development.
6:37 And so I'm really excited to introduce to the board this evening, Eric Guzman-Rangel, who's here and would like to introduce himself. Hi, it's nice to be here. I guess I'll just share a little bit by myself. So I grew up here in Mammoth, so I'm a local. And then I went to college, or I'm still in college. I'm in my last year. I'm studying animal science and management.
7:06 with the focus on policy and planning, and then also doing a minor in natural resource recreation. What else? I guess I'm a first generation college student, I don't know if I mentioned it, but, and then, so I hope to do with the career that I chose to go either into city or regional planning, either one, hopefully go city and then regional, get a feel for it first, and then
7:32 I guess with the program, like Patricia was mentioning, I'll be participating in a summer intensive training. It's going to be hosted by the University of California Davis. And then I'm also going to have the opportunity to go to the California, the CCRH Rural Statewide Summit. So that's where they all get together. And then I guess I'm just excited to be on the team. Welcome. Thank you.
8:04 Great, thank you so much, Eric. Does anybody else want to say anything to Eric before he signs off? Yeah, Eric, welcome to the team. Glad to have you here and super excited to see a local Mammoth, you know, born and raised here and going on to great success. So really glad to have you on with our team here at Mammoth Lakes Housing. Thank you. Further comments? If not...
8:35 Again, welcome. I would just echo Tom's comments and welcome and I'm glad that you stepped up to this role with Mammoth Lakes Housing. I hope you find that it's really fulfilling and complimentary to your studies. You didn't mention what school you're going to right now. I'm attending Humboldt State University. Okay, great. Wonderful. Well, I look forward to seeing you around and welcome.
9:07 Thank you. Again, welcome, Eric. If there are no other further comments, we'll move to policy matter 5.1, receive and discuss the Mono County Grand Jury Report of 2021. There are 12 recommendations. Patricia, do you want to take this? Yes, thank you, Kirk. This item comes before us this evening as a result of the Mono County Grand Jury Report.
9:37 which came out in June. This year's report really focused on workforce housing and what local entities are doing to help alleviate the crisis that we're in. The report specifically analyzed three entities, the town of Mammoth Lakes, Mono County, and Mammoth Lakes Housing. Each of those entities had
10:09 At least one finding and one recommendation. And for Mammoth Lakes Housing for the board to discuss is, or to at least receive an update on is one finding that was in the report detailing a potential conflict of interest between the town of Mammoth Lakes and having a designated representative on our board of directors.
10:40 from the town of Mammoth Lakes Town Council. The finding explained that the grand jury believed that there was a conflict of interest because at least one of our previous contracts with the town had been voted on and signed by a town council member and that the grand jury felt that this was a conflict of interest.
11:11 The recommendation is that Mammoth Lakes Housing devise some procedures or a policy to help prevent a conflict of interest in the future. The due date for responding to findings is 90 days, and so that brings us to the middle of September.
11:38 And our attorney is aware of the grand jury report and the finding relating to a perceived conflict of interest and is researching whether or not a conflict is present and what we should potentially do if there is one. I'll remind the board and the public that our governing bylaws of the nonprofit organization
12:08 Require that we have a town council member and a board of supervisor from Mono County on our board of directors. I guess with that, I know you've all reviewed the grand jury report. I can open it to any questions. Our attorney, like I said, has reviewed the report and is in the process of drafting a response to the grand jury. Patricia. Go ahead, Kirk. Yeah.
12:48 Obviously, they're recognizing my dual role being on council and being on Mammoth Lake Housing, so I'm not sure when and when I'm not supposed to participate other than when the contract is being discussed. Patricia, you have any insight into that? Well, I'll say briefly, like I mentioned, our attorney is reviewing the bylaws and the structure of Mammoth Lake Housing and our partnership with the town of Mammoth Lakes.
13:18 It's his initial opinion that the conflict does not exist, that when you're on Mammoth X Housing Board of Directors, you serve in the role as a board member, and when you're on town council, you serve in the role as a town council member. So once we receive his formal written response, we can talk more about the details around that. Further discussion from the board?
13:47 Is our response limited to just that finding? I think it said there was two findings that we were supposed to respond to, but there was some additional language in the town findings that I kind of wanted to respond to, especially in regards to its applicability about our contract negotiation. Yeah, that's a great question, Tony. There was actually another
14:15 recommendation that did cite Mammoth Lakes Housing. The recommendation referred to a finding that had nothing to do with Mammoth Lakes Housing. And so I have asked the grand jury for clarity around which recommendation they were referring to. And unfortunately, that was probably 10 days ago, and I haven't heard back yet. So once I...
14:42 Find out specifically which recommendation they were referring to and that it wasn't a typo. We'll include that in the draft response for the board to review. Whether or not we can respond to other findings, I don't think we're legally precluded from doing that, but I would look for suggestions from the rest of the board. I think the other one it had us.
15:12 Slated to respond to was F11T, which is talking about Airbnb. And the other ones that I think would be good to respond to are F3 and 4T. Let's see, what was it? 2 and 3, 2 and 3T. And I think those are specifically talking about
15:45 how the town should be committing more funds toward housing, and one of them specifically says that we should be receiving more money, and we didn't go into any detail about that during our meeting last week, but I think that's direct support for our case for getting
16:16 better increase in funding for our contract and it'd be great if we could get something some kind of recommendation from the grand jury and maybe if we make a case for a recommendation for the five percent or maybe even a little more than that I think that would be great and if the grand jury could use that to
16:47 Include a specific amount that we should be included, upgraded into our contract. That'd be great. There was also some language about increasing the transient occupancy tax and having 1% of that used exclusively for housing. And I think it'd be great if we were guaranteed a certain percentage of that in addition to our contract as well. I don't know.
17:24 There's several ways we could approach that, but if we can have some language, a recommendation from the grand jury, that'd be great. So if we can include some of that discussion in our response to the finding, I think that would help in our future negotiations with the town. Further discussion? I'm just curious as a matter of how this is administered.
18:01 First time I've personally been involved in or have some association with a grand jury report, but isn't the report like it's done, right? There's not like they're gonna go back and go, okay, we'll add these amendments to the grand jury report or do they? And then MLH, I mean, do we have the liberty to submit comments on other findings for other entities? Or is it, I just don't know whether we're stepping out of our...
18:29 Out of bounds, so to speak, with what the protocols are for a grant jury report. It's a public document. Once it was submitted to us and the town, it's a public document. So yes, we have the responsibility and the authority to respond. But respond for the things that we were called out for or respond to anything we care to make comment on? Respond to the comments that were directed towards Mammoth Lake Housing. Which was just one.
19:00 So it's more of a conversation between Mammoth Lakes Housing and the grand jury. And what I was going to say was that the grand jury does follow up on items to see if they have been complied with, but I don't know ultimately how much teeth they have. I personally think it's appropriate for us to respond to anything in the entire document considering
19:34 That we were called out as a primary stakeholder in this. And like Patricia said, one of the findings involving the town that we were asked to respond to isn't as relevant as some of the other findings. So I think it's our responsibility to comment on the document as a whole and just to...
20:00 And a requirement that we respond to the specific things that they wanted us to. And if it was just written and done for, there'd be no reason for a response. And so along with our response, I think there would be some kind of conversation. Otherwise, if the conversation is done, then what's the use of a response?
20:31 Go ahead, Brian, please go ahead. Go ahead, Jennifer. No, really. I was just going to ask if the County Board of Supervisors is planning on receiving and filing this at an upcoming meeting and that might represent kind of a natural opportunity for Mammoth Lake Housing to provide some feedback to the document. Yeah, that's kind of where I was leaning and I wanted to provide an update that the board at our last meeting received the
21:02 And I'm requested that staff come back to us in August in advance of the deadline, well in advance of the deadline so that the board can participate in the response and some of the solutions and ideas and the response so that it's comprehensive and has input and plenty of time for a report back to us after we give some input
21:32 So that we can really fine tune it and have a thorough response to the grand jury. And so I do think that that's a good time for the public and Mammoth Lakes Housing to weigh in. You know, the town council will be doing the same thing. They have to respond as well. And that I think is where the dialogue for my standup point really belongs is that we, if we have thoughts and input.
21:59 to provide to the findings for the other organizations, jurisdictions that, you know, it's really about us helping inform their response to the grand jury. That's where I think we could do a better job advocating is directly to them to help shape their response. And then our response, I mean, if there's something we want to weigh in on, that's fine. But ultimately,
22:29 the requirements to address the findings don't fall on us, but they fall on those other jurisdictions, and we want to ensure that they're doing a thorough and comprehensive job addressing the concerns, and that's where I think we should place our energy. Further discussion? Thank you, Jennifer. I do have Tom? Yeah. Sorry, I thought you had a comment to make.
23:01 I do have Town Manager, Dan Holler, who would like to make a comment. You said Tom, or Dan? Dan Holler would like to make a comment. Please go forward. Yeah, if it's appropriate. We've taken initial review of it. Two different issues, and a lot of the comments are correct in terms, there's actually, technically, MLH doesn't have to respond to any of the items. Actually, you're...
23:32 They're not a governmental agency and actually not subject to the grand jury review to start with. So that's another issue to look at. The conflict of interest, we've actually had that same question raised before with the various advisory bodies and there is no inherent conflict. The only place there would be one of that be internal to MLH if it was a CHOTO-related action. But the actual action now that a council member take an action at the MLH and take a similar action at the council.
24:01 Or board level. There's nothing that requires them to act the same way in both bodies either. So it is too independent in the way the bodies are structured and the type of bodies. There is no conflict of office or conflict of element there. We've actually had this discussion before, brief discussions with the town attorney. That's definitely there. The response back is response to their recommendations. The recommendations are not binding.
24:29 They are just that, their recommendations. A year from now, whenever the next grand jury comes in, usually what they do, at least my experience has been, they start with the review of the past grand jury's reports and the activities and stuff of that nature. And so they will take a look at those and look at any type of consistency findings. There's a process for that. But as far as their recommendations and stuff, yes, both the town and the county will need to provide responses back.
24:57 MLH, as to Jennifer's point, can definitely weigh in on what they believe those responses should look like. But ultimately, there's a response element that the town will have to prepare and the county will have to prepare to those particular items that are directed at each of the various agencies. And we'll do that. And as mentioned, yeah, MLH could weigh into that public process, but there's really not a requirement or form for MLH to actually for me to respond back to the grand jury.
25:26 As my understanding in the brief discussion with the town attorney on those items, the conflict of interest one, we would address at the town level based on the council member item and address that accordingly. And at this point, based on the past review of these types of items, the simple finding would be there is no conflict for that particular item. Questions from the board? That's kind of more what I was thinking. And so as much as that's the,
25:59 The protocol, then I think it's more appropriate that we maybe, you know, whether we submit written comments, called up with, you know, public comment during the agenda item at both council and Mammoth County voter supervisors, just to weigh our opinion in on those findings, I guess, or recommendations might be the more appropriate path. What you were saying, Jennifer, basically.
26:28 Yes. And I guess one of my concerns a little bit here, you know, given what we know and the lack of real, I mean, we want to take the grand jury seriously and with respect. But I guess I'm a little concerned about staff time, spending a lot of staff time on letters responding to everything.
26:55 In the reports, it's just one of those things that I know our staff is really busy. So I don't know if that's a concern of any of my colleagues on the board, but it is one of mine and we can certainly all participate as public members in any of those public items as well at the town council and the county grand jury. Just some thoughts as we discuss this. Further discussion?
27:26 I will just say that our attorney does recommend a formal response to the finding of the grand jury from Mammoth Lakes Housing since we were analyzed specifically and separate from the town and Mono County and we are well on our way to prepare that and have the board of directors review that at our August meeting. Further discussion?
28:00 I don't want to waste Patricia's time, but I think the response could be valuable in building a case for needing additional support if we are to address the report as a whole rather than just the two specific findings we were asked to respond to. My comments are, you know, we have a contract that the board, or that the...
28:36 Town Council approved, I can recuse myself from approving that, and I don't know if that would resolve the conflict or not, but I'm willing to step back wherever appropriate, but I'm not sure after being on Mammoth Lake Housing for all these years that that is going to suffice.
29:00 Anyway, those are just my comments and thoughts. I'm trying to figure out a resolution to this, addressing the grand jury's concerns. Yeah, I guess, Kirk, in light of the next item, which is the draft contract between the Town of Mammoth Lakes and Mammoth Lakes Housing, I would recommend that you do whatever you're most comfortable with, but it's...
29:34 Our attorney's initial opinion that there is no conflict, as Dan Holler mentioned, the town attorney also agrees with. So I think I'll just follow the town attorney's advice and maybe that will resolve the issue. Further discussion? If not, Patricia, any other comments? If not, we'll move to...
30:08 Agenda Item 5.2, consider the contract between Mammoth Lake Housing and the Town of Mammoth Lakes. Patricia? Thank you, just one second, so I can pull up my document. Okay, this item is Item 5.2, like Kirk mentioned, consider the draft contract between the Town of Mammoth Lakes and Mammoth Lakes Housing.
30:49 In 2017, the Community Housing Action Plan called for a renewed contract between MLH and the town, which we entered into and is going to in 2018 and that expires in July 2021. The contract for the last 10 or so years has been 330,000. Mammoth Lakes Housing had set up an ad hoc negotiations committee
31:19 which was comprised of Jennifer Kreitz, Tom Hodges, Tony Perkins, and myself. And we met with town staff and representatives from the town council to discuss the deliverables and the compensation. On July 7th, Mammoth Lakes Housing and the town council held a joint meeting. Our initial ask in the draft contract was for
31:51 Modest 5% increase over the same amount that we've received over the last 10 years. And town staff recommended a 1.8% increase. At that time, board member Tom Hodges had brought an offer to the table to help fill the gap between the 1.8% that the town was offering and the 5% that Mammoth Lakes Housing had asked for. The town council felt
32:23 As though they wanted to go forward with a 12-month contract. During that time, Mammoth Lakes Housing would work with town staff to refine and I presume grow the deliverables to support an increased contract amount. The current contract in your packet
32:55 is the contract that was proposed and accepted by the town council on June 7th and includes the 1.8% that was proposed by town staff. Our attorney has reviewed the contract and hasn't proposed any changes and so I'm happy to take any questions from the board at this time. Question from the board.
33:37 I'm not seeing any hands. Tom? I mean, the contract, I guess, I mean, the town council accepted it or approved it, so it's gonna come back to us then for our board to ratify or we just, it is what it is at this point, right? This would be the board's opportunity to approve and accept the contract so that we can move forward with a 12-month contract. Right. I mean, I think the...
34:08 I guess hypothetically the board could come back with some suggestions if they really felt that it needed to be amended. Right, I mean, I think just to expand a little bit on the, you know, how least I interpreted the discussions was that, you know, I mean, there was an initial discussion like, oh, maybe it'll just be a three-month extension and we'll help redefine the scope of work for our deliverables for MLH. And then it was like, everybody's like, no, let's just do it for a year and then we have more time. But that,
34:41 There was specific direction from council to their staff to facilitate an effort in the next, I would say less than six months to really for the town to create a more comprehensive housing strategy that would potentially redefine roles of the different entities that are involved, including MLH. And then maybe at that point, not necessarily that the contract could be
35:11 renegotiated and re-executed at some point prior to the expiration of 12 months. It wasn't like, okay, we're just going to live with this for 12 months and then renegotiate again. I think it was, let's get our act together as a community. Let's come up with an updated strategy of priorities for how we're going to tackle this issue as a community and then divvy up.
35:40 The resources and responsibilities to tackle, you know, what's identified in this update of strategy. So, you know, I, you know, my, you know, my sense is that, that it isn't that we're acquiescing, so to speak, and just saying, okay, it's the same thing for the next year, but that we're going to participate in this process and, and that'll be our opportunity to bring to the table.
36:07 What we feel what we're able to offer as an organization, whether it's an expanded role in actual development, you know, housing development or, you know, whatever it may be identified. So, so anyway, I just was trying to clarify, I mean, you know, I felt comfortable with those comments during the course of our joint workshop and, but it was based upon the narrative of the discussion that went on during.
36:35 During that workshop that there was going to be this concerted effort to really do this sooner than later. And quite frankly, called out in the grand jury report, they have to, you know, they're kind of being asked to step up the program, you know, and they're going to have to do that and respond in the next three months anyway. So I think it all kind of plays together, I guess, in my view, and that at that point, you know, hopefully we can rework the contract. Because nothing's necessarily cast in stone, right?
37:06 My fellow board members feel differently. I feel like we can come back and say, hey, okay, now we've done the hard work. We've revetted the strategy as a community, updated the community housing action plan, reset the priorities, reset the assignments and tasks and responsibilities and resources. And okay, now this is our new list of deliverables. Our role is expanding and therefore we need to be compensated accordingly. Further comments?
37:37 Tom, I agree with a lot that you're pointing out, but with the parcel coming forward and with a lot of our workforce moving to Bishop and community, you know, I think that we need to put together, you know, recommendations to the town council because I think the issue of workforce housing, you know, what
38:06 What level is Altera going to play? So it's more than just, you know, Mammoth Lake Housing as a single entity. I mean, we're part of a much larger program that needs to be put together. And I'm not seeing it right now at the Town Council. Well, yeah, and I think that's, you know, to the numerous points made of everybody working in a vacuum or, you know, working in their own ivory tower and not collaborating.
38:34 So I think the point was, what I heard was like, okay, let's break down the, you know, people working in silos and then we all get back together as a community and it's, you know, it's everybody that was part of the chat before, you know, the town, MLH, the mountain. Well, the town is, you know.
38:58 They can work with the Planning Commission, everybody else as to zoning and, you know, all the different elements. But until
39:07 The issue is spelled out as to, you know, 88 people on the, or 88 families on the wait list and, you know, what's, you know, 2023 before we get 81 units on the parcel. So we've got some heavy issues that I think needs to be very clearly spelled out and, you know, how are we going to pick away or prioritize?
39:34 You know, how do we move forward? And then there's the issue of history. One point of TOT is supposed to, or 0.85 after the airport litigation, 0.85 of one point of TOT is supposed to be for housing. Now, some of that money is obviously being used on the parcel. So there's a history here. And, you know, based on that, how do we move forward? I'm sorry if I'm preaching.
40:04 But, you know, I just think that we need to meet with the council and have a discussion about this, as well as the planning commission, as well as the council. I think that was the point of the discussion with the council members, like, hey, let's reconvene this task force again, God forbid, but, you know, we need to, because we're working off a four-year-old plan that's dated, doesn't reflect current circumstances. You know, things have changed.
40:34 Gotten worse. And there's things that have been accomplished that were on the CHAP originally. But I think a reprioritization, a revisit of the strategies and tasks is probably very, very timely. And then that's opportunity for MLH to, you know, make a case for what we feel we're most adept to take on, you know, whatever that is. You know, I don't know what's all going to come out of the conversation with everybody.
41:03 So what I'm kind of waiting to hear is staff coming back to town council saying, yeah, we're going to reconvene this process, get all the players back in the room, probably should include the county board of supervisor of the county as well. You know, it's a regional problem. And I think the point was that we can't all work in a vacuum of one another. We have to work collaboratively. There's not, you know, you know, it just makes sense for there to be effectively a regional strategy.
41:31 Mono County, Town of Mammoth Lakes, I think at a minimum, maybe even possibly in your county and city of Bishop, but, you know, but we got to all understand what we're all doing and we all agree, yeah, those are your priorities, you should work on those things. Otherwise, we're, we can't afford to duplicate effort, that's for darn sure. And so, any event.
41:54 All right, I just want to say that I support approving this contract. I think we've met with the board or the council and had a good discussion, learned where they want to go and what they want to do, at least at the initial phase to figure out what they actually want to do and how they want to move the ship forward from their perspective. And this is...
42:19 A contract that's going to get us through that process. And I was glad that it wasn't just a three-month contract, although that would put a lot of pressure on council to come up with what their strategy is going forward since the CHAP seems to have been now exhausted, at least in some ways.
42:44 You know, I think we'll be participating, all of us, I hope, in that process as an organization and individually as it rolls out through the public process, because it will be a public process, it has to be. So I'm happy to make a motion to approve, Chair, staff, if you're ready for that. Is there a second to the motion? I can second that. Patricia, can you clarify the motion? My motion is to approve and accept the contract.
43:23 Is that second? I second it. It's been moved and seconded. Further discussion? Roll call? Kirkstapp? Yes. Jennifer Kreitz? I'm sorry, I think Tony has comments under deliberation, Chair Stapp. Tony? Sorry, so I just wanted to make sure that we're just approving the one-year contract, and we're going to have further discussion about how we want to move forward with the contract negotiation.
43:58 In the future? Angela? Is that correct? My understanding, Tony, yes. Because, you know, the scope of work will change as the town develops their strategy to move forward for everyone. And so then, you know, obviously we'll be part of that conversation in developing that strategy and then also what that means for our scope of work. That's my understanding and expectation.
44:32 Great. Well, I'll go ahead and participate in the vote on this, and then if we want to continue discussion of that after, we can continue discussion next month, but I think it's something that should be on the top of Patricia's head if we want to continue a little bit of dialogue on this today. So it's been moved and seconded. Any further discussion? Roll call. Okay, and I had a yes from...
45:08 President Staff, a yes from Vice President Kreitz, Board Member Marksdale? Yes. Board Member Cruz? Yes. Board Member Hodges? Yes. Board Member Perkins? Yes. Board Member Steenstra? Yes. Board Member DeAndrea? Yes. Thank you.
45:38 The next agenda item is 5.3, the 238 Sierra Manor Road update. Patricia? Thank you. This is our update on our project at 238 Sierra Manor Road. We're calling it Access Apartments. And as you all know, we purchased this property in 2017. It's a commercial property with the intention to convert it into 11 one-bedroom apartments.
46:10 In 2019, we held two public design workshops that were bilingual and family friendly, as well as we had the architects and design team present at a public meeting of the board of directors. I have a few update points that I wanted to make sure the board was aware of. In 2019, the total project cost was about $6 million.
46:40 And we recently had new cost estimates provided, but coming around $2 million more than that. There's a lot going on, you know, the time that it takes to create housing partly plays a role in the increased costs. The site is partially constrained to, you know, some setbacks and things that make it difficult to include additional units on the site.
47:12 And then obviously there's been inflated costs through the supply chain during the public health crisis that we just endured. So there's a lot that plays into that. We do have $4.5 million pending in state grant applications that we should hear about imminently. And so staff has been having
47:40 Very involved conversations, actively communicating with HCD on making sure they have all the information that they need to make us the awards. In light of the urgency around securing this $4.5 million, I have been actively thinking about how we're going to do some fundraising, what are some
48:10 Additional sources of grant funding and what are some other asks in the community that we might be able to find some money to help fill the gap and make this project a reality. You'll notice in the staff report that under item three, we have other funding commitments. Those are funding sources that have been committed previously under the 2019 cost estimate.
48:44 Then as the board knows, we've been actively seeking fee waivers from all jurisdictions that collect fees. And so we asked the town for a fee waiver in May that was rejected in July. But with the caveat that we may be able to ask for some additional sources of funds to go towards the total development costs. I have a
49:12 Scheduled public meeting with the water district on August 19th to talk about the water connection fees. I initiated discussions with the fire district in June. I have had a meeting with the county library director and we're waiting for a follow-up from Mono County Office of Ed who is there overseeing jurisdiction. So those conversations are all ongoing.
49:42 Like I mentioned, we've initiated a private donation fundraising campaign, and we had a graphic designer work on a flyer for us. We passed out 200 flyers at the 4th of July parade, sort of as a kickoff to our fundraising initiative. I have a union bank grant application that I need to finish. Certainly, we could...
50:11 I will be asking Eastern Sierra Community Bank. And then some other asks that I mentioned, the Town of Mammoth Lakes, potentially Mono County, and maybe some other partners that may want to contribute to this project. Lastly, I think I wanted to mention, you know, I'm really focusing on this other funding opportunities.
50:36 I do have some technical assistance approved with the California Coalition for Rural Housing to talk again about the affordable housing and sustainable communities program. We had an interesting conversation today about potentially maybe including a rideshare program at the property that maybe could generate some revenue to help the project pencil. So those would be things that potentially
51:06 might get points in an AHC application. I'll also be working on an affordable housing program grant application, which we'll be due in March. For that, we'll need a bank partner, and I'll be working to secure one of those. You may all be aware that I'm in communications with IMACA and Stanislaus County Housing Authority to talk about
51:36 Section 8 vouchers and how we might be able to utilize those at this project. Not sure if that's a viable source at this point, but it's certainly an ongoing conversation. And then I've been having some really active conversations with the Kern Regional Center, who has access to some funding from the Department of Developmental Services. And so they're interested in maybe contributing to the project to secure
52:06 a unit for their clients. Because our project is so central to all of our amenities and services, it's a great location for those who may have a developmental disability. And so those conversations are ongoing. I'm not sure how much they might be able to allocate, but certainly a great partner to have engaged. Oh, I guess one thing that's not on here is that
52:38 We are having conversations with the architects to try to bring down costs, obviously, and we think there may be some savings of around five to 10% there, and so those conversations are ongoing as well. I know I had a very engaging call with the town manager this afternoon, and I know that he would like to share some information with the board around a potential additional town contribution. Thank you, Patricia, this is Dan.
53:18 Yeah, as part of kind of the earlier discussion, just talking about the town's housing strategy and looking at different ways, really making a shift from staff level, we think from what we're hearing from town council is how do we get people into housing, getting new units on the ground and people in those units. And so in looking at that and walking through some of the resources that are out there in the current fiscal year, the idea there was hearing from the last, might've been two board meetings ago even,
53:49 In terms of the gap that needs to be closed in order to secure the state funding, I think those are both total loans, I could be wrong, or total grants. At least one of them was for sure, but Patricia can clarify that later. Anyway, the idea there was how do we get the gap closed or show the state enough support for the project where we actually continue to see those grants process. So the concept on this would be coming back to council for discussion on the 20th.
54:16 1st of July, then depending on that action, they're coming back in August to formalize it. But the recommendation was really is how do we leverage some town funds against those grant funds and other money that's coming in at this point and so it doesn't get lost. So the idea there would be is looking at a state perspective, able to come back in and go, the town's committed $300,000 to the project, we want to up that, but we come back in with another.
54:41 Again, don't have a hard number at this point, but come back in with another 1.1, 1.2 million to push that up to about a more and a half million dollar total town contribution to the project. Does that give us more leverage? I'll say us, but really give MLH more leverage with the state going, hey, we're closing that gap down. We have some other donations we're pursuing. We have other things coming in. Do we have some potential cost modifications there to be able to hold the cost down, et cetera?
55:11 And the idea there is to get that tight enough so the state would be comfortable in moving forward with the approximately $4.5 million in grant funding. I think that becomes really critical in terms of being able to get 11 units on the ground, hopefully in the next two-year window or depending on the construction schedule, obviously. But being able to push staff forward and we can step in and say this is one option. It's no different than the parcels to some degree. Hey, how do we get 80 units on the ground early 2023?
55:38 Does this project follow on before or after that? Here's another 11 units on the ground. We've bought property. What does that look like for timing? A couple other options out there for securing additional units. With the goal being, how do we get units on the ground? Especially, you know, we'll say we're already behind the curb in the next 18 to 36 months. How do we get another 100 plus or minus units on the ground out there? And we can actually put people in that isn't just recycling existing units.
56:07 Oh, that's one of the elements too, do we look at acquiring things, we want to continue the deed restrictions and protections and those types of elements. But I think for the emphasis here would be going back to town council, looking at another 111.2 million or something in that neighborhood of coming back into this project, say, hey, does this help secure that grant funding? We'd hate to see that lost, if you will, because of the gap is growing in terms of the cost of the project.
56:35 I'd like to answer any questions there if need be. Thank you, Dan. Questions of the town manager? Not so much question, but just comment. I mean, that's great, Dan. It's great news. And I, you know, having participated in a couple of calls here recently with the state, it sounds too like we have a little bit of a window once we get a loan approval, so to speak, or grant approval from their committee, you know, that these other...
57:07 Funding sources, you know, still have time to come to fruition. That's a period of time. I think, if I understood correctly, it was about a year. So, so in any event, you know, I think it's great because I think it'll really make, you know, move the needle with them, which was fairly time critical because they needed, they needed hard feedback from us by, in a couple of weeks, basically, so that they can firm up their, their package for review by their committee, their approval committee by the end of the month. So,
57:37 So yeah, so it's great to hear. And I think even though I know the project costs, I think anybody's involved in development or construction right now understands that costs are challenging. And it's maybe, right now they're probably as crazy as they've ever been, but maybe they'll settle down a little bit by the time you actually get to build this thing in a year or so.
58:05 I know lumber keeps coming down, back down again to reality, little by little here. So that's good news on that end. But yeah, you know, it's generally speaking, it's development's risky business and costs don't seem to usually go in your direction. So anyway, great to hear that you guys are supporting it. And hopefully, again, you can get the council to back you up on that, Dan. And I think that'll make a huge difference to the state. Yeah, thanks.
58:38 Hi, Dennis. This is Brian DeAndre. I just want to echo Tom's sentiment. It's great to hear the city's openness and interest in supporting this with additional capital. Obviously, these dollars will be leveraged multiple times over with external resources from both the private sector and the state.
58:55 And, you know, what the city is buying here is long-term affordability. There's going to be, obviously, construction activity and fees and taxes and other revenues associated with all this. So there's an economic impact element to all of this that will continue, I think, to pay its way forward. So definitely great news to hear from you this evening. Thank you. Further discussion? Thank you, Dan, for that information.
59:29 Certain items are supposed to be complete or when are they going to be addressed? And finally, when is the turnkey? When do people can actually move into the units? I know that's requesting a lot of work, but in the same respect, the community is asking those questions. Further discussion? I just want to echo and express my gratitude for that. Thank you, Dan.
1:00:06 If there's no further discussion on this agenda item, we'll move to agenda item 5.5, consider adoption of the Mammoth Lake Housing Inc. Resolution 2102, a resolution of the Board of Directors of Mammoth Lake Housing Inc. approving the creation of the following ad hoc committee, annual performance evaluation of Executive Director. The committee, if I can have a report.
1:00:36 You skipped 5.4. I skipped 5.4. Then we'll move back to 5.4 by Mammoth Lake Housing Program Update. I apologize. That's okay. Thank you. Just that this is my favorite item, so. This is our monthly update on all of the activities that Mammoth Lakes Housing staff has been undertaking in the last month to help our community members find resources.
1:01:07 Related to housing. And so on our first item, you'll see we had, we haven't had any turnover in our rental properties since March. And that was that last unit that turned over was a 50% AMI unit. It was a two bedroom filled by a single parent with two children who works in housekeeping.
1:01:33 And currently our property manager is working to fill a vacancy right now. So that will be filled under the next staff report. For deed restricted ownership properties, all of our properties are currently occupied and we don't have any imminent requests to transfer those properties as of this time. For down payment assistance,
1:02:01 The town CDBG down payment assistance is going to expire at the end of this month and I'll be working with town staff on the closeout report, which is a public hearing before the town council for that grant. The home program expires at the end of September and both of those programs help households earning below 80% of the area median income.
1:02:27 We have some begin reuse funds, which assist households earning up to 120% AMI, and we do have some households interested in that funding, so we've been pre-qualifying households, and then there's a few waiting for their turn to use the funds. Those funds can only be used at three condominium complexes, Aspen Village Townhomes, Meridian Court, and San Joaquin Villas.
1:02:58 And then the town of Mammoth Lakes did approve two pilot program loans for households earning 120% AMI. That program was the final guidelines were approved by the town council and we need to launch that program. I think it's going to have an application period and then we're going to do a lottery to we'll pre-approve the applications and then put them into a lottery to see who
1:03:28 Who's selected to participate in that pilot program. One of the terms of utilizing that program is that you agree to a deed restriction, which would limit the resale value of the home when you decided to sell it. And then Mono County has an active home grant for homebuyers assistance. And so we're advertising and processing applications for that program as well.
1:03:59 On the second page, you'll see the median sales prices year to date, and I don't know what happened to my fancy tables that I had previously with the colors, but I need to spend some time if we want that back to figure out what's going on. In the town, the median condo price, I believe this is as of the end of June.
1:04:29 is 585. A median single family home is 1.5 million. And in Mono County, a median condo price is 400 and a median single family home price is 495. For rental assistance, we talked today at our staff meeting, I think we'll really be wrapping up this program. Maybe we'll put together a nice final report.
1:04:59 for all of our participants to be able to view on our website and all of our partners. These are the statistics as of July 7th, but we've essentially run out of money for this program. Altogether, we raised approximately almost a million dollars and we were able to assist 530 households.
1:05:27 with 1,736 partial rent payments, and that encompassed approximately 200 different landlords. We're no longer fundraising for this program. The need has really wound down, and so I think we're excited to chalk this up as a great accomplishment for Mammoth Lakes Housing, and I'm happy we can help the community.
1:05:54 But rent assistance will be ending unless the need, unless further need becomes identified. We are still continuing to operate the state rental assistance program as a local partner, and that just means that we're here to assist clients with their application, but we really don't have any control or management of their application or the funding or when they get funded.
1:06:23 Judith is still available to assist clients with that program. So we have that as a resource. That's the state rental assistance program, which can now pay up to 100% of back rent and utilities. I think under grants, I'll just mention item number three. Diane and Nolan worked really hard.
1:06:54 On submitting the town, Mammoth Lakes Housing, Joint Application, CDBG Application for Mortgage Assistance, so that we can continue to offer that program to the community. That was due on June 15th. And Diane also worked really hard on the Mono County Application. So both of those were submitted. I haven't heard anything, but we'll let you know as soon as we do. I guess I should mention to the board and the community that
1:07:28 The state eviction moratorium has been extended through September 30th. So we're still receiving calls from clients about what they need to do to prevent eviction, and that is to pay 25% of the rent that you owe and then apply with us for state rental assistance. I think that's all I wanted to say that's in the staff report, but I did want to share a presentation.
1:08:10 that Judith Jimenez put together regarding our participation in the 4th of July parade with automatic transitions. So, well, here's a slideshow about our float in the parade and all of our volunteers and board members who participated. It was extremely fun and we can't wait to do it again. Like I said, we passed out.
1:09:31 Lots of information and candy. And we can't wait for next year. It's the gist of it. They produced that ADU for cheaper than anybody in town. Yeah, and very fast. In the slideshow it says they only had a couple of days. We're going to have to open up a shop here pretty quick. That's all I have for my staff report, but I'm happy to take questions. Questions from the board?
1:10:12 Lindsay? Thank you very much, Patricia, and thank you to Judith for the presentation from the parade. Thank you to the board members for participating and staff as well. Thank you to Carlos. I actually live next door to Carlos who drove the rig and pulled the ADU, so thank you to him too. I had a question about some of those, the grants that are expiring soon.
1:10:39 And kind of what's our push to make sure people know about those before the expiration? I am on the marketing committee. I feel like I should know the answer to this. But we haven't really sort of launched like our big way to get information out yet. So are those going out in newsletters? Are we having meetings, going on the radio? Kind of what's the plan? So I do try to send out the monthly newsletter.
1:11:09 I believe I'm due to do one of those soon. But really, we've been relying on word of mouth for these programs. You know, last year we saw a 60% increase in the use of our home buyer programs, but certainly that's quieted down a little bit, I think, with the prices appearing to be so far out of reach for folks. I think we're starting to see that
1:11:38 The amount of subsidy that we can provide doesn't actually cover the full amount that they need. But I will certainly send out the newsletter to make sure folks are aware of that. It means that basically the problem is that the program in our market just doesn't bridge the gap. It's too big. And so that it's just not even an achievable program, even though there's money there. We can't.
1:12:10 We can't use it. Well, I was looking at some previous statistics from our last CDBG award with the town and an interesting fact is that all four of the loans we made under the previous allocation all went to homebuyers who also utilized the deed restricted ownership option. And so I think that does illustrate that there's a need for more subsidy, but at least in the last year,
1:12:40 We were able to use the program. I think it just fluctuates a lot and it's hard to say. So if it was used in combination with a deed restricted unit coming back on the market, then it could be used, but certainly not at market rate. Right. There's just no way it would cover. I did have just one comment. I did like your fancy graph that you had on the last report. I actually find that very useful. So I would ask if we could.
1:13:12 Have that included in next month's report. I think it's just a quick snapshot of here's the gap. This is where it's at for, you know, yours used 120% AMI, kind of the missing middle numbers and just showed what, you know, what that is. And I think it's a worthwhile thing for all of us as board members to be cognizant of to, you know, as we're going to get into pretty deep discussions about housing and how to solve this. And when you start to recognize that
1:13:42 You know, even 120% AMI wage earner in this community can only afford half of what a single family home costs. It's a huge issue. I mean, it's a huge, huge gap and, you know, there's, there's, it starts to, your solutions start to get narrowed down because, you know, any types, you know, ways to try to take advantage of market rate housing are just kind of getting out of sight, you know, programs that work on that.
1:14:13 I have a question about the eviction moratorium, Patricia. At NACO today, there was a suggestion that we all work with the local judges to ensure that they are checking in as they come, as, you know, as RITs become before them.
1:14:43 They're asking these tenants, have you taken advantage of the rental subsidy program, the rental assistance program through the state and the federal government before the eviction would be granted? And I don't know if anybody's done that kind of outreach to our local judges or even how many evictions we have going through, but
1:15:10 I wonder if that's something that Judith could do in her capacity to reach out to Judge Maget and the other guy was escaping me, his name. Patricia? Yes, yeah, absolutely. We'll look into communicating with the court and see if we can get some outreach material to the judges and maybe set up an informational call with
1:15:46 California Indian Legal Aid Services and myself and maybe the judges and Judith or, you know, maybe we can just have a conversation and make sure we're on the same page. Right, because I know that Mike knows about the program, obviously.
1:16:05 But I saw a staggering statistic recently, I think from Western Center that, you know, roughly 70, I'm just gonna throw that number out there, it was a majority of people that are evicted have no representation. And I'll just emphasize when I, this is the P for protection of the three P's. Questions from the board? Thank you, Jennifer.
1:16:43 Any Mammoth Lake Housing Program updates? Patricia, any further updates? I think that's it. Thank you, everybody. We'll move to Agenda Item 5.5, which is the resolution, a resolution of the Board of Directors of Mammoth Lake Housing, Inc., approving the creation of the following ad hoc committee. Patricia? Thank you. I added this item to the agenda this evening.
1:17:11 Because my employment contract as the Executive Director of Mammoth Lakes Housing will expire at the end of September. It's October 1st or so. And so I wanted to make sure we had the right infrastructure in place as we move through my periodic performance evaluation, which has been every six months since I started in September of 2018.
1:17:41 And so part of this process is for the board to establish an ad hoc committee of representatives to perform contract negotiations on behalf of the board of directors. And then also I'm hoping would participate in the annual performance evaluation to proceed.
1:18:13 The contract negotiations. Therefore, I recommend that the board create an ad hoc committee, which will comprise of no more than four board members to help steward the annual performance evaluation process forward and also serve as the board's designated representatives in contract negotiations. Question from the board? Patricia was up to four people.
1:18:53 Yeah, and I believe it says that in the resolution, so you just need to approve, if interested, the board just needs to approve the resolution, and then we can go from there. So moved. Moved. Do I hear a second? It's been seconded by Lindsay. Moved by Jennifer. All the roll call, please. President Stapp? Yes. Vice President Kreitz? Yes. Board Member Barksdale? Yes. Board Member Cruz?
1:19:25 Yes. Board Member Hodges. Yes. Board Member Perkins. Yes. Board Member Steenstra. Yes. And Board Member DeAndrea. Yes. Thank you. Okay. We'll move to agenda item 5.6. The Board will appoint board members to the ad hoc committee annual performance evaluation and designated representative for the negotiations regarding employee matter pursuant to government post section.
1:19:58 54-95-7.6. Okay, so this is the part of the process where the board identifies their representatives that they would like to serve on the ad hoc committee that was just approved in resolution 21-02. And that would be less than, or no more than four board members. I can serve on that committee. Other volunteers? I would be willing to serve and to learn.
1:20:36 I'm sorry, who was that? It's Heidi. Okay, thank you, Heidi. Is that Lindsay? I think I was scratching my ear, Kirk, but yes. Okay, thank you. One more volunteer? I can volunteer, yes. Okay, so that's three. I can volunteer too, Kirk. This is Soraya. Okay, so that's four. Thank you. Thank you.
1:21:12 Do we need a motion on that? Yes, that would be great. Can you please frame the motion? I move that we appoint Lindsay Barksdale, Tony Perkins, Heidi Strinsa, sorry, and Zaria Cruz to serve on the ad hoc committee for the annual performance evaluation of the executive director and the negotiations committee for the employee.
1:21:41 Matters, according to Government Code, Section 54957.6. Do I hear a second? I'll second the motion. It's been moved and seconded. Roll call, please. President Stapp? Yes. Vice President Kreitz? Yes. Board Member Berksdell? Yes. Board Member Cruz? Yes. Board Member Hodges? Yes. Board Member Perkins?
1:22:11 Yes. Board Member Steenstra. Yes. And Board Member DeAndrea. Yes. Motion passes unanimously. We'll move to agenda item 5.7, consider adoption of the Mammoth Lake Housing, Inc. Resolution 2103, a resolution of the Board of Directors of Mammoth Lake Housing, Inc., approving the creation of the following ad hoc committee, fundraising for access apartments.
1:22:45 Patricia? Thank you. Thank you. You know, I think we talked a lot about 238 Sierra Manor Road, our Access Apartments project already this evening, and the imminent need for fundraising, and it's come to the forefront of my attention as well as I know at least one other board member.
1:23:08 As well as a volunteer that we have who participated in the 4th of July who's very interested in helping do some fundraising on behalf of Mammoth Lakes Housing. And so I think that this is a work program item that is above and beyond the capacity of myself alone. And so it seems appropriate for the board to establish an ad hoc committee so that the committee could work on potential
1:23:37 events, hypothetically, or other marketing or outreach, you know, just talking to folks about the project, you know, communicating the story and soliciting capital donations to help make this project a reality. And so, really the reason, I think, you know, that is the reason for the Abhoc Committee and I think it helps support.
1:24:06 Already the staff work that I'm doing, but really would add some capacity in that regard to have a specific committee to talk about imminent fundraising for 238 Sierra Manor Road. Jennifer? Yeah. Is the marketing budget available for this use? Are you asking on the town's budget?
1:24:38 No, the Mammoth Lakes Housing, is the Mammoth Lakes Housing Marketing Budget, which we just approved the budget, is there funds available within that for this endeavor? Right, so capital to spend up front to produce, to leverage and hopefully produce some private donations.
1:25:08 So the board approved a consulting line item, which is in excess of what we approved for the marketing rebranding initiative. So there's probably some flexibility there. It just seems like if we're gonna do something like this, we're gonna need some funding to move that forward. And I guess the committee could always come back and ask,
1:25:39 the board to allocate additional resources if necessary. I'm happy to volunteer, but if I'm going to volunteer, I'd like to know if there's some money available. Yeah, that's a great question. I hadn't thought of any capital outlays that would need to be performed up front, but that's certainly a conversation we should have with the committee, and I think there's some flexibility, so yeah, we can work within that.
1:26:07 Yeah, I'm thinking you've already used a professional for the brochure that you had included. Those kinds of things happen, right? And then mailers and advertise, you know, there's costs associated with fundraising. But I'm happy to volunteer. Further discussion from the board? I think we're looking for a resolution to pass first. And so I would make that motion to pass the resolution as presented in the package. I'm happy to second that. That's Lindsay.
1:26:42 So we have a motion and a second. Roll call. President Stapp. Yes. Vice President Kreitz. Yes. Board Member Barksdale. Yes. Board Member Cruz. Yes. Board Member Hodges. Yes. Board Member Perkins. Yes. Board Member Steenstra. Yes. And Board Member DeAndrea. Yes. Thank you. All right.
1:27:17 We'll move to agenda item 5.8, the board will appoint board members to the ad hoc committee fundraising for access apartments. Patricia? Great, thank you. So now we just need to appoint no more than four board members. And our volunteer who is very excited and has a lot of energy around fundraising is here this evening. So if the board would like, I'd like to introduce her.
1:27:47 for a possible appointment as well? Yeah, yes, please. Okay, great. Angie, are you able to promote Michelle Welting? Done. She should show up momentarily. Okay, great. So I'll just say a little bit about Michelle. Michelle is a very passionate community member. She's...
1:28:21 She came to Mammoth Lakes Housing, just of the, you know, goodwill and energy that she has to contribute back to our community. And she's just been a ray of sunshine, you know, coming into our office with all her great ideas and really her passion. And we've been trying to find different ways for her to participate with our organization.
1:28:47 And it seems like fundraising for 238 Sierra Manor Road is really going to be an excellent fit for her. And I forgot to mention that she enthusiastically participated in the 4th of July parade and really had firsthand experience with how personal and political housing can be when she was handing out our flyers. And so I just...
1:29:17 She's a very good sport and I'm just really excited to have her participate in some of our activities. Michelle, would you like to say anything to the board? Thank you for allowing me to be part of the team. I'm really looking forward to what's to come. I'm learning a lot. Great. Thank you so much for volunteering. Absolutely. I'm happy to. Lindsay, you had your hand up.
1:29:56 Yeah, if I just may add about Michelle, Michelle and I met last week to kind of just start talking about fundraising. I have been a proponent of having a fundraising committee on the Mammoth Lakes Housing Board since we did our strategic planning. And so I'm really excited for this step. I think it's a great thing that Mammoth Lakes Housing really puts on its non-profit hat and fundraising hat.
1:30:24 to just diversify the revenue streams that we have. And so Michelle and I had a great, great conversation last week, just with some ideas for 238 Sierra Manor Road, that she could start asking some questions around town and seeing what we could get going sooner than later. So yeah, I'm a big advocate of having Michelle. I'm also very interested in being on this ad hoc committee. Further discussion from the board?
1:30:51 Thank you, Lindsay. And so our bylaws allow for no more than four board members to serve on the committee. And that we may also have outside community members. And so if that is the will of the board, I'd recommend that we include any community members who have volunteered to serve on that board in the motion. Patricia, you need a motion? Once we identify volunteers, we'll approve them with a motion.
1:31:23 And so it'll be brought back to the next meeting? Or do we want to conclude it here? Yeah, under this item, we'll have a motion to approve those who want to serve on the fundraising committee. We have two board members, so there could be two more. Is that what you're saying, Patricia? If there were two more board members interested? Yes, then we should identify them and make a motion. Patricia, I'd be happy to volunteer on the fundraising.
1:31:54 committee for the apartments. I've worked on a couple of capital campaigns for housing and shelter projects and I'd be happy to lend my time and energy to that. Great, thank you. Anybody else? We can have one more or we can go with three board members and potentially one community member. Not seeing any volunteers. Hello, it's Heidi. I'd be willing to...
1:32:29 assist again and learn as to kind of how what options are out there and what we can do locally and through other larger commitments for fundraising. That's great. Thank you so much, Heidi. Thank you. Does this need a motion? Motion to approve the ad hoc committee for fundraising for access apartments, including Lindsay Barksdale.
1:33:04 Do I hear a second? I'll second the motion. It's been moved and seconded. Roll call, please. President Stapp? Yes. Vice President Kreitz? Yes. Board Member Barksdale? Yes. Board Member Cruz?
1:33:36 Yes. Board Member Hodges. Yes. Board Member Perkins. Yes. Dean Stroke. Yes. Board Member DeAndrea. Yes. Motion passes. Agenda item 5.9, the board will discuss current committee appointments and reorganize as necessary. Patricia. Thank you.
1:34:13 I just brought this item before the board this evening. I know just a lot of folks just volunteered for two additional committees, but I wanted to just remind everybody of the committees that they are already on and then allow an opportunity for any new board members to assign themselves to a committee if they haven't already had the chance to. We currently have
1:34:42 Six, we had some six committees and then we just added two more. I'll briefly describe each one of them just to give a little overview. We have the governance committee, which is a standing committee and follows the Brown Act noticing requirements. We have the diversity, equity and inclusion committee, which is also, oh no, which is an ad hoc committee. Oh no, no, that's also a standing committee.
1:35:17 Sorry. Then we have Programs and Housing Development, which is an ad hoc committee. We have Marketing and Communications, which is currently working on the 20th anniversary rebranding, and that's an ad hoc committee. We have the Chamber Steering Committee, which is a committee made up of different community members with a workforce housing experience that helped the Chamber launch their workforce housing matching program.
1:35:52 Then we have the Town Contract Negotiations Committee, which now with the approval of the contract, we're likely no longer need to meet. And then we have the designated representatives for the Executive Director's Annual Performance, Ad Hoc Committee, which we just formed, and the Fundraising for Access Apartments Committee, which we just formed. This is really an informational item. It may be the first time some
1:36:24 of our new board members have seen these committees, but it is also an opportunity to reorganize your committee appointment if you so choose. Discussion from the board? Are people comfortable with the committee assignments? I'm not hearing anybody saying that they need to switch committees or step off of a committee. Patricia, can you hear me?
1:37:13 Yes, I can. I'm just thinking. It sounds like at the moment we would need a motion to continue the committees as they are currently assigned, unless there's some change that somebody wants to make. I just, if I could, this is Jennifer, that I feel like, I know that Brian isn't on the Programs and Housing Development Committee, but
1:37:44 Tom and I are, and we have been meeting several times this month on the Access Apartments, and I feel like that's been covered really well by Patricia and her staff report, so I'm not gonna expound upon that, but just to say that we are working on housing development within that committee, and that there's been nothing governance-wise at this time, but
1:38:14 So we haven't been meeting. And obviously the Town Contract Negotiations Committee, as Patricia already mentioned, has met and probably will be unwinding now that that objective's been met. So that's all I have for the committees I serve on. And I'm happy to keep serving on those. Any other comments from the board as to assignments? If I'm not hearing any, then I assume
1:38:49 And do we need a motion to continue the assignments? Go ahead, Brian. I was just going to say, I feel like I'm still kind of getting my sea legs here and figuring out where I can be of value. I have been involved in a couple of conversations about the housing development piece, and I'd be happy to kind of become an official committee member of that subcommittee, if that makes sense, and the board would have it.
1:39:22 I think that might be a nice connection between the actual development activity with the fundraising efforts. I fully support that, Brian. I think it'd be a great addition and you've already helped participate in some of these things. So clearly you have the expertise to bring valuable to us. That's great. Thank you. I think if that's the only change the board could move to a point.
1:39:55 Board member Brian DeAndrea to the Programs and Housing Development Committee. So moved. I'll second. It's been moved and seconded. Further discussion. Thank you, Brian. Thank you, Brian. Appreciate it. I think you'll be a huge asset. Thank you. Good working with you all. Roll call. President Stapp. Yes. Vice President Kreitz. Yes. Board member Barksdale. Yes. Board member Cruz. Yes.
1:40:27 Board member Hodges? Yes. Board member Perkins? Yes. Board member Steenstra? Yes. Board member DeAndrea? Yes. Thank you. Thank you, everyone. We move to agenda item number six, board member reports. Jennifer? I don't have much support for, but I just want to say that
1:41:02 You know, I've received some public response from the board's action at our last meeting, the board of supervisors to change our parking policy, overnight parking policy and county properties. And basically we updated the ordinance to not allow parking in our county parks. And we already had a policy, but we really expanded it to include
1:41:32 All of our county parks and facilities that no one can park there between the hours of 10 p.m. and 6 a.m. and you know, given the amount of people that live in their cars and work in our communities across the county, I found that to be unfortunate. I could understand doing it if we had a solution, an alternative solution, but we didn't and we don't.
1:42:01 Obviously we can make changes in the future, but I think it's one of those things where I think we need to think regionally and act as good regional partners. And so I did receive some feedback from constituents that they weren't happy that that change was made. And anyway, it's just me just expressing some changes that have happened that I think will have unintended consequences. That's it. Thanks. Thank you, Jennifer. Further discussion?
1:42:32 It's Tom here. Yeah, it's sort of coincidence, right? Maybe you guys have been following it in national news. Ketchum, Idaho, has been in the national news with their challenges. And I think they just recently, their council, town council, passed an interim ordinance to allow employees to locate their RVs at private homes.
1:43:01 whether they're driveways or side yards or whatever as a means to try to accommodate you know at least an immediate solution for some of their problems and you know you may have also heard that they had considered an ordinance to allow people to camp in their park which they didn't approve but this was sort of their follow-up was to allow people to have RVs parked in you know with the permission of the of the owner of the homes residence you know so so I you know it's it's clearly this is a
1:43:31 A national crisis, right? It's gotten just exasperated by the whole phenomenon of the pandemic and people working remotely and driving prices up even higher and pushing, you know, working folks, local folks out. So, you know, we're certainly not alone in our struggles. And, yeah, you know, it's funny because there are people who like or don't mind having to live cheaper and live in an RV or van or whatever it is.
1:44:01 You know, it does seem unfortunate that we can't find as a community or Mono County, Town of Mammoth of, you know, ways to accommodate that that are creative. And so, I don't know, maybe that's something we can discuss when we reconvene this sort of housing summit on the CHAP and so forth. But I think it's part of the solution. You know, it does fit a certain demographic of employees and why not? Why shouldn't we accommodate that as an event? I'm trying to get on my soapbox.
1:44:28 The other thing I would like to report is that my role at the ski area, we are looking very seriously at developing our acre at Arrowhead lot adjacent to the parcel in town. We can develop up to 22 units there, and that's what we're intending to do. And we've even begun some preliminary sort of conceptual design work on that. We've been in discussions with a
1:44:57 Modular housing manufacturer that we think has some pretty good product and can provide a really good solution for us on that site. So still pretty early, but the intent would be to push that along where we could actually implement it next year as far as construction is concerned. And in that, you know, it would be again, mountain money, mountains property for the intent of housing mountain employees, which there's plenty of them.
1:45:26 So anyway, you know, I think it's will be a part of the puzzle, you know, and certainly maybe that'll alleviate some pressure on other at-large housing as well. But I think we're, you know, looking at it as more of a year-round type housing is sort of what we're targeting at the moment. Haven't fully baked the program just yet, but that is something we're working on actively. That's all I got. Thank you, Tom. Any other board reports?
1:45:57 If not, we'll go into closed session. So, Patricia, you want to lead us through this? Yes, so, Kirk, I think you need to relocate to the Mammoth Lakes Housing Office so that we can go into closed session. So, it'll take, what, a couple minutes, five minutes, 10? Run fast. Every minute.
1:46:22 I'm just going to announce that I won't be able to participate in closed session. I have a commitment, but I trust all of you to help us, lead us through this. And I would also say that I'm not sure that I should participate in this particular one because I vote on the town budget. Patricia, you have any comments?
1:46:51 Yeah, our attorney doesn't believe that there's a conflict of interest, and so as the board president, I think it would be good if we could participate in the closed session. Okay. Further discussion? And Patricia, you want to get us into a closed session? Yeah, I'll meet you here in about five minutes. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, everyone. Thank you. I'm not sure that I can. Whoops.