TransparentMammoth

Eastern Sierra Council of Governments · 2026

Eastern Sierra Council of Governments

at 08:30

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Notable from this meeting

2 findings

Transcript

339 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

5:37 Good morning, everyone. Wow, that's loud. I am happy to call to order this regular meeting of the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments. So, Angie, could you please call the roll? Chair Bubzer? Can you guys hear? Was that me? I couldn't hear. I couldn't hear either. Angie, could you please repeat yourself? Chair Bubzer? Here. Vice Chair Oral? Supervisor Griffiths?

6:16 Supervisor Salcedo? Supervisor Salcedo? She couldn't hear. We have to keep these mics like right by our mouth. Yeah, here. Yeah, these are not sensitive. Council Member Wentworth? Here. Council Member Schwartz? Here. Supervisor McFarland? Here. Here. Council Member Kong? Here. And just to clarify, Supervisor Oral and Supervisor Griffiths are not

6:59 in the room at this time. Is that correct? That's correct. Supervisor Oral will be here, so we won't take any votes because we don't have a quorum until she arrives. All right. Thank you. We'll let you know when she arrives. Thank you very much. All right. Alan Pietrasantra, would you please lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance? Pledge of Allegiance. Yeah, don't stick your head up there. It's really hot. All right.

7:42 So at this time, we will take public comments for anything that's not otherwise on today's agenda. Hi, good morning, board. Kristen Feiler, the ESCOG Wildfire Coordinator. I wanted to take just a few minutes to introduce you to Jackie White, the environmental planner for Whitebark Institute. Jackie's been working with me on the riparian resilience projects that we've...

8:11 Your board has approved us moving forward with and Jackie's been leading all the environmental planning components to move those projects forward. Having Jackie as a teammate and colleague on these projects has been a huge capacity boost for me and I think it's a direct outcome of the pace and scale accelerator program basically which helped build a lot of capacity within the Whitebark Institute and we've been able to utilize

8:39 The regional forest and fire capacity funding through the Sierra Nevada Conservancy to leverage Jackie's time and expertise to move other projects forward across the region, including these riparian resilience projects. And so I just wanted to highlight this as an example of how we can effectively utilize our organizational strengths across the region and kind of give you a glimpse into the behind the scenes working of

9:06 You know, how we are redefining what collaboration looks like and moving projects forward. So mostly today I wanted to say thank you to Jackie for your exceptional leadership and to give her an introduction to you and just kind of say thank you because this is, I think, a really great success story that doesn't necessarily get a headline. So with that, Jackie White. Thank you, Kristen, and thank you for having me here this morning.

9:35 I started working with Whitebark Institute last July, and so I'm fairly new, but I just wanted to be here and introduce myself and give a little bit of background of where I come from, which is Mammoth Lakes. I grew up there and I was born and raised in Mammoth. I went off to college and studied environmental studies and biology, and then I had the opportunity to come back home and work for CDFW.

10:03 Doing the Sierra Nevada Bighorn Sheep Program. And then I had the opportunity to work for an environmental consulting firm down in the Mojave Desert, learning about desert tortoises. And from there, I was kind of shepherded into the environmental planning realm. And I got to work with whitebarks starting in July.

10:26 Now that I'm here, I learned really quickly that partnerships are a necessity to make any project move forward in our area because we're a rural town, rural location, and we need all the expertise we can get. These projects, like the riparian resilience projects, are complex and they require a multitude of expertise. And I realized really quickly that Kristen Feiler and ESCOG

10:56 is a necessary partner. You all have been willing to fill a need where there's been a gap. I have helped with the environmental planning portion of it, but ESCOG was willing to take the lead on these riparian projects, which if that weren't the case, we wouldn't have been able to move the projects forward. We've also worked really closely with Carol Snow from CAL FIRE, and she brings the fuels and fire

11:24 resiliency expertise to the partnership, and so I'm just really grateful that you all are here and have been willing to work with Whitebark and various other partners to move these wildfire resilience projects forward. As you all know, we are also working on the West Mono Basin project, which is a large landscape project, and it wouldn't be possible without all of you all and the various partners that are involved, and so

11:53 I just wanted to introduce myself and say I'm here for environmental planning. If anyone has any want or need to learn more about environmental planning, I'm here to support and I look forward to working with ESCOG more in the future. And so thank you. Thanks for having me. Thank you so much for being here. And I'm starting to sound like a broken record, but I can't say enough how much Whitebark.

12:20 and ESCOG is bringing to our region in terms of capacity and are addressing some of the challenges that we've all thought about for a long time and just haven't felt empowered to take action on. And I also just want to commend my colleagues from the town of Mammoth Lakes who saw the need.

12:41 to help whitebark over some of the early hurdles and, you know, now it's really paying off dividends. So, Jackie, I'm delighted you're here. I might take you up on that. We can never know enough about environmental planning and so just thanks to everybody that we're making this happen for ourselves and we're not waiting for, you know, the state or the federal government to come do it for us. So, thank you for being here. Keep going. Anybody else with public comment?

13:10 I don't see anyone online, but I might be missing. So, Angie, if you see anyone online that I'm missing, just please interrupt. Thank you. No hands raised at this time. Okay, terrific. So, with that then, we will go on to the consent. We can't vote on the consent agenda. We'll move that to later. Okay, great.

13:31 So now we're on to policy matters. Item 5.1, we're going to receive a presentation from Meryl Picard, Executive Director of Eastern Sierra Business Resource Center on the Sierra Jobs First Project implementation. Welcome, Meryl. So I, you should have all received.

13:54 our 2025 impact statement, and that's what I'm going to be presenting to you all on, but also just kind of give you an update on, you know, how things are going at the Business Resource Center. So again, thank you all for having me.

14:09 You know, so far we celebrated our first year of being open and we're really excited. Again, we wouldn't be able to do the work that we're doing without this wonderful partnership we have with ESCOG. So I'd like to thank Elaine, you know, for her work with me and the other team members like Alan that we have locally to help do this work. And again, without your guys' support, we wouldn't have been able to.

14:36 be as successful this first year as we were. So I really just want to commend you all and thank you all for taking that initiative to put in the grant through California Jobs First. So this past year, we were able to assist 75 unique businesses and entrepreneurs.

14:55 We do this in different ways, one-on-one consulting, helping people sign up through the SBDC to get them connected with an advisor. Maybe that advisor is then going to help them with a business plan or financing. So we're really excited that we could assist with that because I think before, without having a center or a place for people to go and someone for them to talk to locally, a lot of people didn't know that resource was available to them.

15:23 We also hosted 26 workshops. These were events and classes covered a wide range of topics such as financial planning, marketing, business planning, leadership development, and access to capital.

15:39 We did help two new businesses launch and help with their ventures. We leveraged 26 new partnerships by expanding regional network and forming new collaborations with local agencies, chamber of commerce, education institutes, and nonprofit organizations.

16:00 And then one thing that we're really excited about is the leadership development. So we did launch and elevate a leadership program with 27 participants graduating from that. And it was over a course of five months. So they're still...

16:18 gathering together as a cohort and meeting together to continue to mentor one another and continue what they started there with that collaboration. Again, some of the workshops we were able to deliver, you'll see there under the workshops and events.

16:34 And then another really exciting event we've been hosting is our Matriarch Mixer, and this is for women in business or leadership where they could come together and help support one another. This has been a very well attended event with at least 25 to 35 participants every single time. So I think that was a much needed kind of networking and an event for women here locally. Job creation, we were able to host two different

17:04 Companies, Marshalls, before they opened, they hosted an event to recruit people as well as Limelight Hotel and Mammoth. So those collaborations helped to bring people in locally to find jobs. So that was a great collaboration as well. And then, of course, our collaboration.

17:23 hosting the regional meetings like the California State Association and Counties Board Meeting. Many of you who sit on different boards and committees, your boards and committees might have used our space. And so we're really thankful for the space that this community or just even in the region, sometimes we lack, right, spaces for our nonprofit organizations or...

17:47 different groups to meet. And so we've had a number of different organizations use the space. And that is one of the ways we are bringing in some income. But of course, we do waive that fee depending on the need of the organization or the nonprofit. So we're happy to help assist in those ways as well. So looking ahead, you know, the BRC services,

18:14 You know, that are underserved communities across Eastern Sierra, we want to get to them. One of the things that we did during one of the biggest storms we had this year was we hosted six sessions of customer service. In Bridgeport, we had over 25 people signed up and they thought I wasn't going to get anyone.

18:33 So to me, that's a huge accomplishment. And of course, we had to shift very quickly to online, but I think we were still very successful overall with 97 participants. So unfortunately, we didn't get down to Bridgeport, June Lake or Lone Pine like we had hoped, but we still got the attendance virtually and we were really excited about that. So partnering, I just met even with Fort Independence Tribe yesterday and talked to them about

19:03 how we could assist them. The reason why we were so successful in Bridgeport is because the Bridgeport Indian Colony sent all their economic staff from their businesses to the customer service training. So again, those partnerships, even with the tribes that we are now forming. But we do want to grow our workshops to be more digital. We've been working really hard to make our center more

19:29 Digital friendly, you know, and accessible for people to join online no matter where they are. It's very easy for us to, I will say, favor Bishop because of the center being here, but we do get lots of people who will come from other areas and participate still or they'll still call the center and ask for services regardless of them coming in person. So I just want to make that clear that that's still happening.

19:55 And we do hope to bring on an assistant this coming year as well so that I can get out into the other communities and travel a little bit more while still having the center stay open. So aside from the highlights here from 2025, you know, we've been working also with people who want to buy businesses, existing businesses that are selling their businesses, which are great, right, because then we're going to keep businesses going in our community.

20:25 We've also been working, we just partnered with TMC Capital, so now we're offering microloans up to $5,000. That's really helpful for like really, really new small business owners who may be working out of their home, things like that, just to help get them started. Maybe they don't have good credit yet.

20:47 Starting small and then working them up to bigger. We've been also working with a business right now who's been in existence and is really growing their business in the area. And so he's looking to expand his services. So he's actually going to be going after a larger loan through TMC Capital for about $20,000. So really connecting our businesses to the resources that they need to continue them to grow and be successful here in our valley.

21:16 Any questions you have for me? Questions? No? I just have kind of a random question because, you know, we've been hearing a lot about yesterday about the tariff rebates or paybacks. Has that been an issue here? You know, I know that yesterday the site opened and there was just a lot of coverage on the news about how that would go. Have we had people who really struggled with that?

21:47 I think there was lots of talk in the beginning and I think people kind of were worried and scared and nervous and you know business owners amongst themselves were talking about ways to address those needs. We also have a mastermind group which is a group of

22:04 business owners that meet and mentor one another and talk about that. And that was a topic that has come up in the past. And unfortunately, I wasn't at the last meeting, but Alan was, and I don't know if those kind of comments came up. Okay. So, yeah. Do you want to come up? Yeah. Yeah. Please come to the podium and introduce yourself for those online.

22:28 Alan Pietrasanta, I am currently the Board Chair of Sierra Business Council, and Sierra Business Council is the nonprofit that operates the Business Resource Center here locally. So I have a couple comments about that, but to address your specific question, yes, the business owners have been affected that we've been meeting with since the tariff wars started a year ago. They have had confusion and

22:57 Difficulty in their supply chains. Karen might be able to comment on that as well. They've had pricing fluctuations making it hard for them to plan going forward. They've also had, because of the tariffs and other things, effects on, as we all have, of the visitors coming to the area. So business has been affected.

23:19 They're very resilient. The people that we have been working with at the Business Resource Center are very creative, resilient, and resourceful. And so they're going to survive, we hope. And then I just want to make another general comment about the Business Resource Center. It operates under the Economic Empowerment Program of Sierra Business Council, which is based in Truckee. I'm sure you're all aware of Sierra Business Council.

23:45 We have been operating the Economic Empowerment Program there for many years. We are also the SBDC in the Tahoe area. And so we have experience with economic development in the rural part of California, in the Sierra. And we have a lot of successes. And so we're just getting going here.

24:09 One of the things I just wanted to announce or say that we're very proud of that recently just happened, the USDA just awarded $115 million in grants across the country for timber production and forest management, okay? Of that $115 million, $88 million of that came to California.

24:36 Of that 88 million, 43 million of that came to two projects in the Sierra, one in Sierra Valley and one over in Calaveras County, a biomass facility that Sierra Business Council worked with from the ground up with those entities and those projects. So I use that as an example to talk about what we're doing.

25:01 I think in that part of the Sierra over the last year or so, we probably brought $120 million of capital into the region. We want to do that here.

25:11 As we expand and grow, we want the members of ESCOG to please tell us what your entities need, what we can do. Meryl is all ears about what we can do in Mono County, what we can do in the town of Mammoth, what we can do in the city of Bishop. So we want to hear from you what you need. We also will be looking for you to partner more closely going forward. I also want to make it clear to ESCOG that

25:41 Sierra Business Council is absolutely committed to keeping the Business Resource Center open and operating even after Sierra Jobs First money runs out. We're working very hard on that. So I just wanted to reiterate our commitment, echo what Meryl says about how important the relationship with ESCOG is, and I appreciate the time to be able to talk this morning. Thank you. Great. And I think...

26:07 Council Member Wentworth, you had a question? I just had a question along the lines of Jobs First, and maybe we'll talk about in the budget. I know that currently ESCOG has a relationship with the Business Resource Center related to Jobs First and that funding. I don't know if this is the appropriate time to talk about it, but I know that money is going to run out, and I just wanted to get some clarity. We can talk about it now. We can talk about it later. And I'm assuming you guys were a project, right? So that means it's over in September, right?

26:35 So at the appropriate time, it's just good to understand from the ESCOG's budget perspective and our relationship with the center, how that transition is going to work and what that's going to look like. We can do it now, we can do it later, whenever it's appropriate. What's your pleasure on that? We do have an item, we have two items. One regards updates on Sierra Jobs' first projects, and there's a second that is a little bit more budget focused. I think that it might be more appropriate to hold that conversation until we're discussing future programs and the budget.

27:04 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you very much for coming. Great. And Supervisor McFarlane has a question. Yeah, thank you both so much for the energy and optimism you continually bring to our place. It's appreciated. You know, one of the biggest challenges, and I'm wondering if you hear this from others, that I hear from folks in my district and other places that are trying to start a business is successfully navigating, even at the point of when they're working on their initial business plan, you know, the various and sundry regulatory hurdles that they have to get.

27:33 through everything from cottage food to small retail use permits. Has there been any talk about providing some kind of ombudsperson support or any kind of support to help people through those processes that really can make or break people at the early stage? Yeah, we actually just hosted an event in collaboration with a community member and it was a cottage. I'm trying to think of what he titled it, but they had about...

28:01 10 people participate in that. That was last Friday. But yeah, I mean, we could definitely help them through that process. One of the businesses that we mentioned here that we helped get started, we really helped work through those types of processes and hurdles. So again, putting them...

28:19 Connecting them with a one-on-one assistant who is going to help them. So yes, definitely. If you guys know people who are just getting started and need support, have them reach out to us and we'll help walk them through the processes for sure. That's what we're here for. Okay. That one-on-one support that makes a difference.

28:36 Absolutely. And sometimes those challenges stop people from continuing. So that's why we want to really make sure that we, you know, help them through. And then they'll be able to answer questions for the next business owner who wants to do the same thing, you know. And that's, again, the best thing about, like, bringing in local people that they are going to mentor them as well as, you know, each other. So, yeah. Well, thank you. Yeah, thank you for the comments. Sure, of course. So, Meryl, I was thinking about it.

29:07 on my drive home from Sacramento yesterday. And what about Spanish language and that population? Because they seem to really be very, you know, move forward with their ideas pretty quickly. And so how do we reach out to that population? Yeah, you'll actually see that that was one of the goals for this upcoming year, too, is try to offer

29:29 Even in our flyers, like a Spanish version of anything we're sending out. So we are currently working locally with someone who's, they're hosting Spanish classes actually at the center. It's part of their business and they're renting the facility. But we're looking to partner with her to help with that translation. Also met with Jobs Spot.

29:55 And they might have some technology like headsets that we could possibly purchase. I don't know how much those are going to cost, but that way that helps with translation too, so that we don't necessarily have to have someone who is a translator in the room sitting by those individuals, but they would have a headset to translate for them. So those are some of the technologies and the ideas we have moving into the next year that we would like to be able to accomplish those things. It's a great question.

30:25 That's a great idea. That sounds like a grant opportunity. Yeah. I think I want that for us in Mammoth, too. That's a great idea. I just wanted to add, it's more of a comment than a question, but I'm just delighted at how you're helping make our region a true region because, you know, I don't think it's, with the technology we have today, it is very easy to have a gathering from Lone Pine to Bridgeport, and I'm just glad that you've

30:54 You know, sometimes because of our weather and the challenges of where we live, we're forced to try things. So I'm happy to hear that. Any final questions? I'll make a comment. I mean, I've been able to participate in quite a few of your programs with the Spanish class and the leadership program, and it's just been a really welcoming space. And you guys have done a really good job making the space a place you want to be. You know, it's very welcoming, and I think it's an asset to the entire region.

31:23 And thank you for participating. Yeah. Enjoyed it. You've always been an avid person attending a lot of our events as well as our leadership class. So I want to congratulate you also. Yeah. Thank you. Great. Thank you so much. So next we are moving on to 5.2 to receive this year a jobs first project implementation update and provide direction on our engagement, the board's engagement. Good morning. Good morning, Chair Bobser. Good morning, ESCOG board.

32:26 Very nice to see all of you. I appreciate that you were all able to make it to Bishop safely with the inclement weather conditions. And I just also want to offer welcome to our new board member, Council Member Kong. Thank you for being here. I wanted to provide your board a presentation on our Sierra Jobs First projects.

32:51 and really provide an overview for new board members about the work we're doing, but also provide your board with an update of the project work that's happening. We have three Sierra Jobs First projects that are going.

33:05 Four, if you can consider that there's a subproject underneath one of them. And as Council Member Wentworth said earlier, there's a pretty fast turnaround on this grant opportunity expires in September 2026, which means that the amount of interface that your board will have in the project development, how these projects end up concluding, will be limited by our bi-monthly meeting schedule.

33:31 In addition to providing some regular updates, that's why I invited Ms. Picard today to talk about the Sierra Business Council implementation of that Sierra Jobs first grant. I also am hoping to get some direction from your board about how you'd like to engage with these projects over the next few meetings we will have before the conclusion of the grant term. So the first project I'd like to discuss with you is our Chipmunk Canyon Existing Conditions Analysis. It will go over these at a pretty high level.

34:04 But the goal of this project, if you're not familiar, Chipmunk Canyon is a recreation area located southwest of Bishop. It is a network of informally created trails on a mosaic of public lands.

34:22 The trail network spans DWP, Forest Service and BLM. And when we had kicked off the Towns to Trails project, those land management agencies approached me and asked if it would be possible for ESCOG to bring in funding to provide capacity to begin a planning process for the trails network that is...

34:45 out there in the future because there is a real need for formalization of that network, for determining where it is or is not appropriate for various cultural biological resources to have trails, but there is not capacity or clear lead agency direction among those three agencies to move forward. We were successful in getting a Sierra Jobs first grant to take that first step in doing just an existing conditions analysis to map what

35:14 trails are even out in that area because there is not very good data that even informs that. I apologize, I just want to pause for a moment and make note of Supervisor Oral coming in. Good morning. Angie, yeah, we wanted to make sure you knew Supervisor Oral's here so we have a quorum. Thank you. Thank you very much.

35:40 So the goals of the project are to develop a baseline of the trail conditions and the environmental resources, to support responsible, culturally respectful and sustainable recreation planning, to build a collaborative multi-agency framework for stewardship so that at the conclusion of this, there is a working group among those land management agencies and the users to be able to move the project forward as appropriate.

36:06 and to lay the groundwork for future funding opportunities. The project leadership team for this project, the project obviously is left by ESCOG. The project manager is Mr. Etzel, who's the recreation coordinator who's currently serving for that project. We're very grateful.

36:27 For his experience with trail systems in places across the US. We have awarded this contract to Alta Planning and Design. They are working with two subcontractors, Helix Environmental to do environmental analysis and MLTPA to provide some communications support. And then we're working with the Inyo National Forest, the Bureau of Land Management, the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power, Bishop Paiute Tribe.

36:54 We had a kickoff meeting with that leadership team a couple weeks ago to establish how it is we want to be communicating to the public around this project. There's some anxiety that government involvement might limit people's enjoyment of that resource, so we want to be sure that the public knows that this is intended to help formalize that as a trail network, and the goal is not to...

37:19 necessarily limit people's access to that place. We also had a discussion about the study area and what the appropriate boundaries are since it's a spaghetti bowl of trails. So we wanted to determine what would be within that study area. And I mention all that to say we do want to formalize also having a direct involvement with Inyo County since it is an area in which there's a lot of planning work that is happening with the county as well.

37:48 This is the study area.

37:51 That was proposed on the basis of the conversation I just mentioned a couple weeks ago. We will not be including the trailhead up to the Druid Stones, since that is already an in-system trail within the Inyo National Forest. But as you can see, this trail network, this data is all drawn from Strava Network. So it's pretty extensive, the amount of trail building that has gone on out there. So we will be working with Alta.

38:20 to go out and be ground truthing that. There's going to be trail counters to determine what the use is. We'll be doing some work with the public to see how people are using it, where they're coming from, what their desired conditions are. There's also an important emphasis in this project about consultation with the Bishop Paiute Tribe.

38:43 There are a couple of resources within this area, notably the Tribal Cemetery that we want to provide particular sensitivity to in recommendations moving forward.

38:59 This is probably hard to read, but this is our project schedule. As you can see, it is going to be a very quick turnaround to wrap up all the components of this project by the end of August, and a lot of that work is going to be happening over the summer. The project team is aware that this is a resource that is probably most heavily used in the shoulder seasons of Bishop when the weather is nice, so they are really expediting getting out and doing that.

39:28 Trail Analysis, that on the ground research right now, they have their first site visit scheduled for the first couple of weeks of May. They will be coming up and doing that work and shifting a lot of the desk analysis to summer months. The second project I wanted to provide an update on, which is a subcomponent of our collaborative grant, is the Eastern Sierra Agricultural Activation Study, similar to the Business Resource Center.

39:56 This is a Sierra Jobs first project that's a little outside of ESCOG's traditional scope, but certainly fits within ESCOG's core competency of incubating projects. So this was a project opportunity to help support and expand the agricultural economy of the Eastern Sierra, which was identified as one of the primary industry drivers of the Eastern Sierra economy.

40:23 But it needed a fiscal sponsor at the time. And so ESCOG has housed it within our Sierra Jobs first project. The full slide deck from this shareback session that was held on March 18th is included in your agenda packet. But I did want to just pull out some highlights to provide some context around this project and the next steps.

40:47 We are working with Plana Planning and Design as a contractor for overseeing this project. She's doing a wonderful job and I am very excited that we were able to work with a local consultant and be able to support local contractors through this project. Just a couple of highlights. The goal of this, there's a few goals of this project. One is to work with

41:14 the producers in the region to understand what some of the regulatory barriers are and where there are opportunities to strengthen an agriculture economy and in particular local food system in the Eastern Sierra. Part of that is also data driven by what consumers of the Eastern Sierra are interested in and what sort of price points they're willing to consider to expand their

41:39 Consumption of locally grown produce. And I think one of the things that is important context here that we've learned in these conversations with the producers, with UC ANR, and with the Inyo Mono Agricultural Commissioner, who's a very close partner to this project, is that we have a spectrum of agricultural producers across the Eastern Sierra from generational ranchers.

42:07 And agricultural producers who are working on largely DWP and other, you know, federal land leases to, you know, startup boutique agricultural producers who are the ones who are going to be stocking farmers markets in Bishop and Mammoth and throughout the Eastern Sierra and bringing food to market and really driving opportunities to, in some ways, reduce dependency on imported food.

42:36 And strengthen opportunities for us to get that. So one of the first phases of this project was engagement through surveys. As you can see, we had 251 people from across the region participate in that. Only a few of them were agricultural producers relative to the broader community. But Ms. Gecker, who is our consultant with planning.

43:02 has done really extensive on the ground, going out to ranches and farms, meeting with cattle ranchers in the field interviews to help inform this process as well. So she's conducted interviews with 30 ranchers throughout the region. And so I really want to focus on that producer input, which is I think most immediately relevant to where those opportunities are to reduce regulatory burdens and increase resource investment to support local food sovereignty.

43:32 So the challenges that we've heard from producers largely center around land access and water management, but there's also things like regulatory constraints, workforce development needs, and market volatility. And some of the initial feedback that we're getting from that, again, these policies are outlined more thoroughly in your agenda packet, I think create and demonstrate some value for places for local government to be responsive to

44:00 those needs from producers, things including, you know, one-on-one mentorship for cottage food producers, to be able to navigate what feels like a bureaucratic process, or being able to, what was the other one I was thinking of, being able to facilitate cross-county relationships for some of those land constraints.

44:25 Because a lot of those producers are not producing in Inyo County or in Mono County, but are producing across county lines and across the region. As I was saying, some of the opportunities that were really identified by those agricultural producers included things like identifying opportunities to expand agritourism and working with things like our destination marketing organizations to help create itineraries for

44:53 our visitors to learn more about our ranching heritage in the Eastern Sierra and the relationship that we have between agriculture and land stewardship to be able to consolidate some of the things like infrastructure needs or educational opportunities between the agricultural producers so we can be supporting them as an industry.

45:23 And then looking for different things like zoning incentives or modifications that would help support things like agritourism or, you know, small farm producing. The next steps for this project, we've finished our stakeholder engagement. We are currently working on strategy development. And as I say we, I should also provide clarification that I am working very closely.

45:53 with Nate Reed from the Inyo Mono Agricultural Commissioner, with the UC ANR Office, with the Economic Development Department to help refine what that strategy development looks like. And then we'll be working on what some of the data is that really helps inform things like need assessments and education development. And then we'll be putting together a final plan that will be completed.

46:23 Before the end of the summer and consistent with the Sierra Jobs First Grant. And then the last project that I wanted to talk to you about, and this is really the place where I most want to focus board direction on getting on how you would like to engage with this project is our Eastern Sierra Collaborative Implementation Planning Project. And this is a project that is it's broad in its scope.

46:52 consistent with ESCOG scope. And the goal of the project, I'll get into in more detail, but generally it is to leverage this grant opportunity and to leverage capacity through that to be able to do outreach with our partners, not just our member agencies, but our recreation NGO partners.

47:13 Our land management partners, additional agriculture partners, and economic development partners to really be able to hear from them how ESCOG can play a strategic role in a partnership role in those four core areas. So in essence, not only is this an outreach opportunity, also will help refine ESCOG scope into something of a strategic plan at the conclusion of Sierra Jobs First to really lay something of a path.

47:43 for what happens when that funding concludes. A quick introduction to our project team there, this contract was awarded to Agnew Beck, so we are working primarily with Shawna Doherty, Christina Kind, they have also brought on Travis Nabahe to serve as a tribal liaison to make sure that we have opportunities to be engaging with the various tribes throughout the Eastern Sierra to help inform this project.

48:12 One of the value adds we have in working with the Agnew Beck team is that they have been engaged in the Sierra jobs for strategic development for years. So they are familiar with all of the quirks and nuances of that program. And they're also working with several of our partner agencies in strategic development as well, which is really helpful for just being able to leverage that institutional knowledge. So for instance, they're working with...

48:40 White Bark Institute on their strategic plan currently. So as I said, what is this project about? So what is the goal? In the Eastern Sierra, there's a lot of good work that is already happening. There are a lot of good organizations. There are a lot of different plans in place. I think one of the...

49:03 Hypotheses in founding the ESCOG was how can we bring those efforts together so that the sum is greater than its parts. How do we identify those opportunities to where there's intersects in those different projects where we can strengthen partnerships and be more competitive in state and federal funding at a regional scale rather than on an individual organization or a local scale.

49:33 As I said, the goal of this is to work with partners to help solidify ESCOG as a convener that can support these four core areas and ensure that there is collaboration among those different organizations. It also is an opportunity to understand how there is intersection between those four core areas. So I think a great example of that, which will come up again later in our agenda.

50:02 is something like wildfire resiliency. Wildfire resiliency is there's grants available for that planning work, and there's grants available for that implementation work. But certainly one that we've learned as a region, as we've embarked on trying to do that work is there's a whole body of work that needs to be done just for implementation. There's workforce development needs, there's choke points around biomass facilities.

50:29 And those are economic development opportunities. So how are we communicating across those silos to really broaden those opportunities to be effective and impactful? Some of the supporting data we're also looking forward to getting out of this project work is a ecosystem map of the different organizations that are working in these four core areas and what their capacity is. Who does implementation work on the ground?

50:56 who is a grantor organization, who's a grantee organization, who's working in planning versus implementation, with the goal of really being able to strengthen and find efficiencies in that collaboration. And then finally, one of the outcomes will also be identifying funding mechanisms for this ongoing work, not just looking at future grant opportunities, but also what are the funding models of other regional organizations.

51:24 from across the state or across the country and how are they funded to be effective. You can see on the right hand side of the screen in blue, these are some of the questions that we'll be going out to ask our partners.

51:42 Agnew Beck is going to be conducting up to 20 interviews with key partners in those four core areas that will include leadership with our member agencies as well as NGOs and agency partners that we work with to inform these projects and implement them.

52:01 There will be a literature review of existing regional plans that are relevant to these four core areas. There will be case studies of relevant and regional multi-county collaborative models to help inform what this collaborative would look like moving forward. And then there will be recommendations on a collaborative governance framework and an implementation roadmap coming out of this.

52:28 And then, as I said, exploration of key funding and investment to move it forward. We've also developed a steering committee to help inform this process. That includes, at the top, the subcommittee that your board directed that I could appoint to oversee this project, as well as leadership from key partner organizations, White Barth, BLM, federal land agencies, the Eastern Sierra Land Trust, so on and so forth.

53:00 We have kicked this project off. Right now, Agnew Beck is performing discovery and research, so we're, you know, getting relevant plans to them, identifying who is going to be on that stakeholder list for those key interviews. I should mention that in addition to that, Mr. Etzel will be doing...

53:24 Outreach beyond the 20 stakeholder interviews that Agnew Beck is going to be holding as well. And then we are planning to hold a summit this summer. It says here June 18th through the 20th. Unfortunately, the land management agencies were not available. So we have now shifted that to July 9th through the 11th. So please save the date. And that will be a summit that, among other things,

53:52 is intended to get community feedback, but in addition to a workshop, a traditional workshop, what we would like to do is make it an inspirational event around how some of these regional collaboratives work in other regions to really be able to implement multi-benefit projects at scale. And then we intend to conclude putting together this project. Again,

54:21 The project needs to conclude by the end of September. As you can see, we have steering committee, we have four steering committee meetings in that period of time to help inform the process. The question for your board is over that period of time, we have two more meetings before that project is concluded. We'll have a meeting in June and we'll have a meeting in August.

54:50 And what I don't want to do as staff is put together what's a pretty comprehensive outreach project that should provide strategic direction for this organization moving forward without some input and visibility from your board before bringing it to you in August.

55:14 So I would like to have some discussion, some direction from you today about how your board would like to participate in this project moving forward. One of the items is, this first item is direct the existing recreation subcommittee members to participate as part of that steering committee. That is an action that we've moved forward with as it seems appropriate within the role of them providing feedback on that.

55:43 The places I would like your board's input is on should we continue to bring back regular updates on these Sierra Jobs First projects at the next two meetings during the term of the grant? Does the board want to have dedicated workshops related to this project at any of the project milestones? And what process would you like for review and comment on draft work projects prior to finalization?

56:14 I'm happy to take questions on that. Thank you. Questions? He was, though. I saw it. So, subcommittee members, I think we would like to hear from you on these two items. So, in either order. Elaine, can you repeat the first one? I want to make sure I had it right. I have the second one. Your two questions. Oh, three questions. Regular updates at board?

56:50 Meetings. Okay. Would you like to have any dedicated workshops to focus on these deliverables at milestones? And would you like to have a review and comment period on draft work products prior to their finalization? So maybe take the first one. So I think, does anyone object to having regular updates at board meetings? That seems really like a very logical thing. I think the question that to me, the one I really made sure I wrote down was,

57:18 Do we want dedicated workshops in the process? If we have a subcommittee, do we want to really delegate that to the subcommittee? Or do you all want to be more involved as an entire board? The only thing I would point out with this is that this is all part of Jobs First. There's an enormous amount of, there's an enormous need and calls and requests.

57:47 For everybody across the region to be involved in a whole litany of different projects. So I think how this aligns with the ESCOG meeting schedule is something to be figured out. I think we all want to show up and play our part in this, but it's getting very, very crowded. And I think it's going to be very tricky with this schedule because the project's all going to be ending at the end of September, and I know that the ESCOG is going to need to be getting invoicing and accounting and all that kind of stuff.

58:16 into the Sierra Business Council with plenty of time to make sure that there's a record that all the financial stuff has been submitted. So there's going to be some scheduling juggling going on. But I would leave it to the rest of the board if you want to give them what our meeting schedule looks like to review comments or something that may not fit. It may not be possible. You know, the third option and yes, Mr. Pietrasanta, please approach the podium. The review and comment seems very logical to me because regardless of

58:47 What's happening, that would give us the opportunity to weigh in, even if we haven't been in all the meetings. Does anyone have an objection to being asked to review and comment? Obviously, if it doesn't work with the crammed schedule, it doesn't work, but at least we'd have the chance. And I see we have a public comment, so I thought I would just take it now. Thank you for allowing me to speak. I would like to throw a very positive cog into ESCOG about this subject.

59:17 And that cog is that the state has extended the September 30th deadline to June 30th, 2027. So that I wanted to get up here before you got too deep into the discussion because it affects everything that Elaine is talking about. And it's going to give a little bit more breathing room to accomplish this. If I could on that point, I think that that's something that we would.

59:47 I mean, projects are generally aware of this, but if this means having to go back to the SBC, renegotiating contracts, renegotiating financial stuff, and I don't want to get into that discussion now, but that is a very important point of concern. Again, I don't want to get into it. I'm not debating. No, no, no. I'm just advising the board that this is, even though this deadline is out there, that may not be appropriate for the ESCOG to get into that because there will be some financial implications.

1:00:15 I think we can maybe table that for another time. Sure. I would also just want to make clear to ESCOG that, as you know, the state's divided into 13 jobs-first regions and we're one of the 13. 11 of the...

1:00:34 Current conveners applied to the state to continue on as conveners, of which Sierra Business Council is one of those. And we got notice two days ago from the state that we are approved to continue as the convener fiscal agent for our region. And so we are working on the contract for that. But John's making a good... Councilman John is making... Councilman John... I'm going to keep that one. JW here.

1:01:03 It's actually making a good point. This is an extension. This has no funding with it. This does change. This could throw a negative cog in things, so that's something to be aware of. But I just felt it important to bring to your board today the official extension of that and how that may play into your planning. Which is spelled differently. You're down there. It's all done.

1:01:33 Oh, and the last thing I'll say is all the participants in Sierra Jobs First will get an official notice of this. There's 38 projects in our seven-county region. We only got the notice from state, from EDD, two days ago. And so we're working on finalizing that contract. I'm giving you advance notice, which is just germane for some of this planning. But official notice will come out. Thank you. Appreciate that.

1:02:02 And I think for purposes of today, Elaine, are you more comfortable assuming that we're just going to stay on the timeline that you've established? Because as Council Member Wentworth pointed out, I was in that meeting on Monday where all the projects were talking about how they're getting to completion. So I understand there's two parts here. It's the actual projects on the ground and then it's how are we moving forward, correct? It is. And I appreciate that.

1:02:31 This is the first that I've heard that there has been an official extension, which could be very good news. And I would need to have conversations with each of the projects individually. Sure. More work for Elaine. Hooray. It could be beneficial. I mean, I think extending the timeline would be great. I don't know that we need to extend it to June 30th, but having more wiggle room than September 30th is probably beneficial. It's something I'll have a conversation with the project.

1:03:00 Okay, but to the task at hand today, you asked us to whether we'd be comfortable with regular updates at board meetings, whether we want dedicated workshops just with the board, and whether we want a review and comment. It seems to me, go ahead, I'd love to hear your... Well, and then there's the first one, which is direct existing Recreation subcommittee members to participate as part of the steering committee, and I would say at a minimum, one of us should try to participate.

1:03:28 At each one, if available. Looking forward to the proposed schedule from staff. Yeah, exactly. I think it's really important for all of us to be there and we'll be there. Yeah, and I would strongly encourage our colleagues on the subcommittee because we're counting on you to help us understand what's happening because, you know, just personally, I've tried to stay engaged with Sierra Jobs First as much as possible throughout the years and it's...

1:03:55 Just like you're hanging on the end of a kite, just getting flopped around out there. But, you know, I know Council Member Warren has been deeply involved and has kept me abreast of it. So I just think that at this crucial juncture, it's really important that ESCOG stays as engaged as possible. So we'll count on you. And by the way, if a subcommittee member is unavailable, could there be a substitute from ESCOG just so somebody's there to hear it real time? How many subcommittee members? I think there's three of you, right?

1:04:24 There's four. Oh, so, all right, so, all right, we're looking at you, kids, like, you guys are going to make it, okay, good. How many of these have there been? There's been one? There's been one. Yeah, just the one. Okay, great, good, yeah, I think as long as, you know, one of, at least one of us is able to participate, we can bring that report back, you know, regular updates, of course, the dedicated board workshops, I think that kind of remains to be seen.

1:04:51 That's the part that actually concerns me. I'm concerned about that. Not that I don't want them or I don't see value, but to me, all that is is extra work for an already stretched staff because if you have four of us in there, we should have a fairly strong knowledge base of this project. I agree. And be able to support the regular updates with any information and I think that when we go to the review and comment,

1:05:21 That's when we need a really in-depth, fully formed workshop for this board. And I'm just thinking about that from a workload. I also believe that getting, I don't know if we'd have to have a quorum, but even getting a critical mass of this board together on short notice is so challenging that I don't see it coming to fruition. I just don't see it. Yeah, at least a minimum of one.

1:05:51 Or a maximum of one, potentially, as we get near the end. Yeah, just one. And on the deadline extension, at some point, I think a deadline is good. We need to move beyond the perpetual planning phase of having to go to a billion meetings and talking about collaborating and actually start doing. And so, you know, and then you also tie in the financial ramifications of all these different bodies having to completely change.

1:06:18 How they have designed their glide path of spending towards the end of this, which is a known date. And it seems better for us as a region to stick with the date that we've had, you know, and recognize that we need to move on to the next phase because we have a lot of implementation pieces that we could be doing now, but we're still planning. So am I hearing that we want one board workshop? Probably towards the end. That's what I'm hearing. Yeah, with the whole board. Yeah.

1:06:49 Okay. Elaine, can you go back a couple slides for me real quick? This one is fine. Yeah, I think the interesting piece about the collaborative one that we're talking about here specifically is the idea that it really seems to be more of an us decision than a them decision, right? And so a steering committee is great, but if you look at the steering committee list, there are really more of them than us.

1:07:24 And so before anything is decided, it seems like it needs to come back to us and have a big discussion about, okay, so this is what they're saying, how do we feel about what they're saying, right? All of those things need to be fleshed out by this body as opposed to by the steering committee itself. Because again, if you look at that steering committee list, one more back, Elaine, right? Those are all of our partners, but it, you know,

1:07:55 When push comes to shove, none of those people there are footing the bill or any of those other things, right? And so what they want from ESCOG might not be something that's actually possible from ESCOG. And I think it's a very important thing that you're saying in terms of setting the expectation for the steering committee of what this thing is going to be. We've looked at our budget. We don't have any money to implement this. We understand that. That's fine. This is, as you mentioned, part of a sort of a...

1:08:23 A foundation for a strategic discussion for the ESCOG of what we might do in the future, but we're not going to, we want to get a good document out of this, some good suggestions, but this is not going to get implemented because there is no money to it. That's fine, that's cool, but let's not set any expectations that some of this is going to lead into some great regional nirvana, which we all live in anyway, but we'll get to that. I mean, and is the ultimate goal, back to both of your points, for the roadmap, for this board to adopt that as an official?

1:08:52 You know, guiding documents. Could be. It could be. Could be. Yeah. I guess that's a question for... Yes. Great. And if so, then that's the time to really bring back that workshop after, you know, the cake has been baked halfway. Yeah. And then be like, okay, well, here's what this group has identified. Does this jive with what all of the jurisdictional partners foresee going forward as doable? And it seems to me like that needs to be...

1:09:24 Almost a meeting in and of itself, as opposed to trying to cram it into an already long meeting that it needs to be something that we just dedicate a time to, to talk about. And that's what I think you're asking, right? The one request I would make, if it's appropriate, to please prioritize the schedules of the ESCOG collaboration in terms of this meeting. If other people on the list, if they can't make it, they can't make it. But I think it makes sense for us to be there and be involved in that.

1:09:53 Otherwise, you're trying to schedule for 20 people and it's never going to happen. Given the time frame, let's see if we can do that. But I defer if that's in line or in politics, whatever. That makes perfect sense. And that would be in the August-September time frame on the current timeline? Yeah, that's correct. Okay. To your point, John, I agree because to Karen's point.

1:10:20 The four of us sitting on the subcommittee represent the decision makers. And so, yeah, I encourage that scheduling as well. You're the deciders. That's super helpful. Any other public comment, either online or in the room? Because this isn't really, you don't need a motion or anything, but we did give feedback, but I just want to make sure there's no other public comment before we, before I ask you, Elaine, if, are you comfortable with the,

1:10:50 Discussion as it's taken place and you're good to go? Yes. Thank you. Okay. Just one quick question. On the study area for Chipmunk Canyon, is that, has that been accepted by the jurisdictions and the agencies as the official facility? Yes. That is. I apologize. No. The map I showed you is outdated. I apologize. They have adopted a study area. It's consistent with the map I showed with the exception of the Druid Stones Trail. That's fine. But they have accepted the study.

1:11:21 Just a really quick, and I know this is an unnecessary detail, but it seems important. Why exclude what's already legal? You know why? I apologize. I don't know why. What they provided is that it's in system, and so the study is not necessary. Can you speak to that? Great. Because it seems when you're building a system, you build off what's already legal. So that would be a critical place to start.

1:11:54 Hi, Ken Etzel, the Program Manager for the Chipmunk Canyon Current Conditions Analysis. And I think we included the Druid Stones Trail, Historic Trail, because it was in need of some maintenance and communication. There were some communication breakdowns where we were able to bridge those gaps.

1:12:21 That concern about it being part of the study area came from the Forest Service. It was already included in the systems trails. So that maintenance work will be continued forward. And also the scope of the project, it was focused on user-built, non-sanctioned trails within the area. So we decided to exclude it to, because of our shortened timeline, shortened resources, just to kind of...

1:12:50 Expedite the process. Thanks. Any other questions for me while I'm up here? Okay. Thank you. All right. So if it's all right now, Angie, I'd like to go back to item 4.1, the consent agenda. And so this would be to approve the minutes of the special meeting of March 13, 2026. I will accept a motion. Second. And the motion was by Supervisor Oral.

1:13:26 I'll say M. Okay, second by Council Member Schwartz. These are tongue twisters. So Angie, could you please call the roll? Chair Bubzer? Yes. Vice Chair Oral? Yes. Board Member Salcedo? Yes. Board Member Wentworth? Yes. Board Member Schwartz? Yes. Board Member McFarland? Yes. And Board Member Kong? I abstain.

1:13:56 Thank you. All right. So moving along, we are on 5.3. This is the board workshop on strategic priorities and capacity needs for the fiscal year of 2627. This is in our package, but I can't view it. There was a resend yesterday from... About 1.30? It's in here. I also can't see this because this table's in the way. Yeah. Yeah.

1:15:07 Linda, there's one thing you could do. If you sign into the webinar, then you can watch this on your website. It was also emailed on the regular website. It was emailed about 1.30 yesterday. It's also uploaded to the meeting website as well. It's also top of the agenda. There's a Zoom link. Anyway, okay. Thank you. Good morning once again.

1:15:39 This item is intended to build off of the conversation we had at our last board meeting where we got some pretty clear strategic direction regarding broad programmatic areas that ESCOG should be pursuing, including continuing to invest in regional economic development opportunities.

1:16:10 What I wanted to have a conversation with your board about today to get additional direction on as we're planning for our budget next year is some direction on staffing and how with the staff we have and the funding we have, we can meet the board's priorities in the scope of work that has been put in front of us.

1:16:37 And in particular, one of the areas that I've received feedback from your board is a desire to see the Executive Director role work less on day-to-day administration and things like grant management and more on external communications, strategic leadership, program building, relationship building across the region.

1:17:03 I'd like to have a conversation about the role, the expectation of the Executive Director role, you know, with some, with discussion about, you know, what the limitations are relative to the funding we have. Your slides are not advancing, they're advancing here, but not on the Zoom, so. Correct. Same. Yep. Yep. Just as a. Thank you for that. Give me just a moment. That's how it goes.

1:17:39 I want you to get too far to go on a discussion. I appreciate it. Thank you. Wait, wait, wait. I see what's happening. Sorry. I'm sorry. It's, um, I don't know why it's not sharing my screen. That's really weird. Well, it's important. Thank you. Stop me. I have no idea what to do. I literally have no idea how to fix this. I know. Where is Councilman Mohovey with all his Zoom skills?

1:19:32 Believe me, I probably. It was not, it was not, I did not take on that responsibility. IT skills. Oh my gosh. Is that going to do it? Let's try one more thing. Did that change on the Zoom? No. Okay, there we go. Is that doing it now? Yeah, no, it's still. Oh, I'm sorry. On Zoom, it's now, you can't even see it now on Zoom. I have a copy. Deeply frustrating. Oh yeah, so it's advanced.

1:20:49 Do at least the second slide now. There you go. It's moving. It's not showing it as a full slide. It's showing it like you're working on it. That's really weird. That's not what's on my screen at all. John and I have different things going on our screen. Yeah, it's not in presenter view. Yeah, it's not in presenter view. That's what I meant. Yeah. It's not in... That's the word that I was trying to pull out of my head. It's not in presenter view. That's not ideal, right? I see what's happening. Okay, hold on just a sec.

1:21:29 If we have to change it, we'll go ahead and change it. I think it's picking up that I'm connected to a second monitor, which I'm not only knows how to fix that now. Ken's coming to help. Thanks, Ken. No, Ken's not. Ken's running away. I did not be fixed. IT is not my world. I thought he was coming. No, I do not want multiple displays. Currently, I am showing what you have on the screen. Not a great sign, because whatever's going up there is not actually syncing to what I'm doing.

1:22:31 Well, the room itself is very... Yeah, I have two, but it's definitely... But if you look at us, you and I are not talking right now. It is? Oh, yeah. No, it's totally five minutes. Oh, my God. I don't know why it's like not responding to anything. Oh, my goodness. It's okay. I apologize for the delay for everybody's time. So, just to make matters more worse, Elaine, John and I up here have different things. I can see that.

1:23:27 Yeah, we're not even... We're not even together, trade-wise. Are you in a different... Log in. Yeah, just log in. Log in. I... Did you know about this? But see, you... But I'm really delayed. Because if you look, I'm not leaning over talking to you. See? Yeah. Yeah. How long did it take? One month ago? Minutes. Minutes, yeah. Yeah. Isn't that weird? Okay.

1:24:02 Let's try it one more time. If we can't fix it, we're just going to move forward. Okay, great. That's the consensus up here, but we didn't know if we were allowed. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Thank you. Because among other things, with the update from Mr. Pietrasanta, most of the budget information has suddenly become kind of irrelevant anyway. Yeah. Yeah. Because you know what? We want to do going forward. Yeah.

1:24:33 The fiscal cliff is coming anyway. It's just a question of when, so we might as well have the conversation. So let's do this. All right. Give me a committed to trying one more time. Okay. Please. Bear with me. Thank you. Thank you all for your patience. Oh. Counselor. Counselor. Counselor. Counselor. John. Yes, because since it's in the packet, anyone who's following along can see it in the packet. So it's not like that.

1:25:03 The presentation has to be synced. Allow us to, I understand. Here we go. A miracle has happened. We can see it. Is everyone good? Can we move on? Yeah. Great. Thank you. Thank you. We like that. Can I just ask one thing? I'm so sorry. Please go ahead. You're going to want me, you're going to be like, you're going to call Elaine after this meeting and be like, can you make Karen go away?

1:25:32 Can you give us a little brief overview? Because you couched it by saying that per what we said last meeting, can you give me a little synopsis of per what was said last meeting as far as what they want you to do? Yes. Thank you. I will include an overview of that discussion. You're very welcome. In sum, the basis of the last meeting is that a lot of the

1:26:02 Funding that supports the executive director position right now is through Sierra Jobs First Grants. And the funding that supports regional economic development through ESCOG is through Sierra Jobs First Grants. And at the time, we believed that the Sierra Jobs First Grants would expire in September. Looks like we have some flexibility there, but we don't know exactly what that landscape looks like. And so the nature of the discussion was, how do we want to continue supporting these different roles, given that

1:26:31 The funding is going to shift largely to forestry projects. And what is the role of ESCOG in the region in supporting things? Got it. Welcome. Okay. Thank you. And thank you, everyone, for your patience. Technology has never made my life easier. All a fallacy. Okay. So as I was saying, this is the current capacity landscape we have. So our wildfire coordinator.

1:26:59 who supports ESCOG in a part-time capacity, was successful in bringing in a community wildfire defense grant. By way of update, we have heard that the Forest Service is processing that grant agreement, and we expect to see that in May, but there is still a delay in kicking off that program because we do not have agreement, so we are not going to be able to invoice off of any of that work until we have a agreement in hand.

1:27:29 Notably, that grant provides for funding for two full-time positions over five years, as well as a 20% administrative overhead, which totals about $400,000 over five years, or approximately $80,000 a year. We have several Sierra Jobs First projects we've discussed, those expire in September. We might have an extension that provides wiggle room on that.

1:27:59 We have submitted a grant to the California Advanced Services Fund to continue to provide capacity for staff to focus on broadband expansion. That is, I expect an award probably in May or June. That's generally viewed as an allocation rather than a competitive grant. So I anticipate that we will get that and that provides $200,000 a year for that capacity.

1:28:26 We also have some residual funding in our Inyo National Forest Service liaison funding that we'll roll into next year. And then we've had discussions for approximately a year about establishing an economic development district that would be housed within ESCOG for the Eastern Sierra. It would provide about $70,000 a year of annual capacity funding. So that is our funding landscape for what we're

1:28:56 looking at in the coming year. One of the things that I also want to bring into this conversation which we discussed at our last meeting is that the member agency contributions have been held at $25,000 a year since ESCOG was established in 2020. That $100,000

1:29:24 Primarily covers basic operational costs of the organization, as you can see there under member agencies. Approximately $30,000 of that funding is allocated towards the executive director position when the actual budget for doing the executive director role is $147,000. And so there's a pretty big gap between the secured

1:29:52 Discretionary funding for the Executive Director role and the actual cost of the Executive Director role. One of the things that we have discussed to help maintain a $25,000 member agency contribution is the option of the various support services that are provided by member agencies being provided in kind. So currently

1:30:19 We receive $25,000 from a member agency and we have contracts that pays for support services for clerking, legal and finance from other member agencies. So that draws down on that $100,000. There's also an administrative fee to Inyo County to pay for the executive director role for that contract. If those member agency services were provided in kind, that closes the deficit.

1:30:48 Between $25,000 and $47,000, depending on the member agency's willingness to negotiate with us on those items. I've also included in here, this is from our last presentation, that we anticipate there will be about $80,000 of Community Wildfire Defense Grant administrative revenue, which also helps close that deficit. So I put this together for this discussion. I apologize, since it's very small.

1:31:18 But this is a very rough, round numbers budget looking forward into next year, looking at our anticipated revenues across our grant programs and looking at our anticipated expenditures. A lot of the grants are pass-through items. So we have approximately a million dollars.

1:31:41 in revenue anticipated under the CDFW, and that will go directly to contractors to support that work. I think what is important in looking at this budget is that question, going back to the question, what role do we want the Executive Director to serve, and what is the funding that is required, potentially in addition to our grant revenue, to support that body of work?

1:32:09 There are some assumptions that are included in these budget estimates, such as I anticipate that there will be a carryover balance in the Inyo National Forest liaison funding. We can use that to extend a runway in having dedicated recreation support, or we can shift the executive director focus and roles to be billable against that time. Similarly, and this is a point of conversation for today,

1:32:39 We have two positions that can be funded under the CWDG role. We have some options. The Executive Director can bill against that and provide the administrative support on the grant. Or we have an opportunity to leverage that grant to provide capacity in other areas that I've heard your board request, including fiscal management, grant management, day-to-day administration, and better communications on our programs. But that does

1:33:09 Depending on how we choose to allocate that funding to fulfill the obligations of the grants over the capacity we have, that also potentially puts obligations on providing additional discretionary funding to support the executive director role to not be working against those billable grant hours. There are some assumptions that are rolled up there. So what we're looking at here is,

1:33:39 What the actual costs will be under the required budget line item versus what the anticipated revenues are to support those expenses in the next year. So there's some items that are rolled up into that executive director role, which includes member agency contributions, assuming that the administrative overhead from CWDG can support that exclusively.

1:34:08 And that there will continue to be administrative billable time against the California Department of Fish and Wildlife grant, which expires in 2027. So we're looking roughly at approximately $100,000 to $120,000 of anticipated revenue to support that role, but it does still leave a funding gap for the funding that is required in that role.

1:34:36 This budget also assumes that there is no change to those member agency in kind services. So that continues to be a place that if the member agencies are willing to provide those services in kind, that will help us to close this anticipated gap that currently I'm estimating at about $27,000. Before you move on, sorry, back to that slide real quick. For the California Advanced Services Fund, there was no...

1:35:07 admin built into that award as submitted. It's basically a 100% pass-through. Is there any way to capture any of that funding internally? Thank you. That's an excellent point. As it was submitted, there was no administrative overhead that was built into that. When it was submitted, there was still some...

1:35:26 There's still details we need to figure out about how we want to staff it, for instance, with Mr. Armstrong retiring. So I think there will be an opportunity to renegotiate some of that budget before signing an agreement. And I believe the allowable administrative overhead is 10%. I think at a minimum we have to. And then if there are any other creative ways to support the contractor position that could help ESCOG's capacity, I think we should be building that in too.

1:35:55 That funding is good for how many years? Three? Yes. So that's $200,000 over three years, $200 each year. Yes. Yeah, anything we can do to capture more of that to sustain ESCOG, I think, would be, if it's possible. Yeah, thank you for that reminder. One other item in this budget estimate is, for your information, I do not know what the carryover balance will be for this year.

1:36:28 When I come with a budget in June, we'll have a better sense of that. A lot of that is dependent on how much of my time I can bill against the Sierra Jobs first capacity funding we have to offset the amount that I'm drawing down on member agency contributions for the executive director capacity. Okay, so the direction that I have received from your board is that

1:37:00 We need to see the Executive Director role move into something that's more strategic, less day-to-day fiscal administration and grant compliance. And so given that right now a large balance of the Executive Director salary has to be billable against grants.

1:37:25 The question for your board today is what is the desired balance between administrative management and strategic leadership for that executive director role and how that will really, I think, help inform to some degree how we are planning our budget for the next year and the conversations we'll have with the member agencies regarding that. I can pause here and we can focus on that.

1:37:53 Or if you want, I can keep going through my presentation. We can talk about some of the other staffing projections that we have for the coming year. Does anybody have a strong opinion? I do. I think we're in a really ominous place because on one hand, we've grown and we've accomplished some of our goals.

1:38:21 And we're on the precipice of how much further can we go, but we can't do it with Elaine only, because she is one person, very capable, and I think she would try, but I think we would, you know, just burn her out. And so we, I feel like we need at least a two-person staff at this point, but the reality is, how do we pay for it? That's the question I think that

1:38:53 I think that that's kind of the basis, the base question, because that's just the reality of where we're at with this body. Yeah, I think that's, yeah, that's obvious. And I think I'm a little, I think it'd be helpful to get a recommendation from staff rather than putting this whole thing in front of us and asking us to figure out how to allocate your time. I think from a higher level, we can certainly say,

1:39:21 We want to get to a point where the executive director is free to act in an executive capacity, acting in executive capacity, and start telling, letting us know, to your point, what support staff do you need to be able to get there, and then we can crunch it hard at the numbers to figure out what we can do to live with it. Because I feel like... We don't... Sorry. I've been told to speak into the microphone. We don't work at ESCOG. We don't know what's going on.

1:39:51 And I think it's a little tricky for us to be able to get in there and start to kind of micromanage, we'll do this or do that. I think if we can get a recommendation to you to get to where we want to get to, and then you tell us, okay, look, that's where we want to get to, this is what we can afford to do, and then we can kind of take it from there. You know, because the other side of my statement is that as a board, we often do give direction to a lane that is.

1:40:19 We want her to be strategic. We want her to be looking for these opportunities. We want to expand our regional footprint, but that support isn't there. And I've been, and I've said this before, and the further we go without addressing it, the more concerned I become of that capacity and that support for her. Well, I agree that we should not be the problem, you know, kind of solvers.

1:40:53 I know the Community Welfare Defense Grant has two FDEs in 2020. My question is, does that give you any relief in all the other scope of your work within ESCOG? Excuse me. So I appreciate the comment, Councilman Wentworth. I do have additional information. There is some flexibility.

1:41:20 We believe in the CWDG grant that can provide more of that administrative backbone that would free up more time that I wouldn't need to be doing fiscal management, grant management, that we could do more communications work. But there is a question there of how do we want to proceed with staffing the CWDG grant and what the right capacity is. And I do have a recommendation for that later in the presentation. Just to, so,

1:41:49 I had been meeting with Elaine to prepare for this meeting, and we've had some conversations. And while I totally hear you, Council Member Wentworth, that we don't want to be too directive. On the other hand, I think it would be important for us to understand that there's a gap. So when we give the direction to Elaine, like we want you to be strategic, we want you to be outward focused, I asked her the simple question, what percent of your time is inwardly focused towards ESCOG?

1:42:19 And 1% of the time is outwardly focused towards coming to our different boards, to going to statewide meetings, to being able to lift her head up and understand where the wind's blowing, because these kinds of JPAs are very much driven by where funding is available. While we wanted to, you know, we want to have some direction on that, we also have to live in the real world. So could you talk a little bit about, you know, where you see it today? Because I think it would be reasonable to ask this board,

1:42:49 How we would want that to shift, I think it will inform then the kinds of questions she comes to us with. Because right now it's like we just keep hitting the tennis ball back and forth. Like, so Elaine, what do you need? And then she's like, well, what do you want? And, you know, it's our job to say what we want. And I think we need to be a little more specific at this point. Anyone have a problem with that? So could you talk a little bit about where things are today? Because we need to understand what that is so we can...

1:43:18 envision what's possible in the future. Yeah, I would be happy to. And I think, you know, ESCOG was established and not, you know, really fully empowered with funding to have that runway at the beginning to do that strategic work. And so it's been very funding-driven, it's been very project-driven.

1:43:45 Very, you know, nimble and responsive to incubating these different opportunities. But I think the question now is, yeah, we have a little, we have a little bit of runway. What is the strategic role that we all see ESCOG playing moving forward? So to your question, you know, a lot of the core work of the executive director, 80%, has been project management.

1:44:12 Very hands-on project management. That is particularly true under Sierra Jobs First, where as a very attenuated case study, there was not a lot of organizations in the Eastern Sierra that were well-positioned to capture that funding. And so right now we carry like four grants under Sierra Jobs First. Those are very administratively burdensome. So between now and the conclusion of the grant, I think my time will almost...

1:44:41 you know, increase in day to day project management and grant management for those funds. The balance of that 20% is, you know, just day to day management of the organization, putting together agendas, scheduling meetings, trying as I can to have conversations with you or with member agency leadership. So if there is a, and I do think that there is a need and an opportunity for ESCOG to, you know, help elevate the region in those relationships with

1:45:10 Federal Partners with the State of California. And that is going to require more discretionary funding that is not directly billable to a grant opportunity. So I guess my question is this. You guys had a discussion last time about wanting Elaine to be more forward-thinking as far as

1:45:36 Not that you're not forward-thinking. I didn't mean it that way. I just meant that you want her to be out there gathering information and letting ourselves be known. So my question is, is there at some point the idea that this discussion is really part of the discussion you guys are going to have as part of the Sierra Jobs first thing we just talked about? Yes. Okay. And so is...

1:46:05 Is it then, is this part of the conversation then a little extra? Not necessary right now because of the idea that between now and September when the money runs out for Sierra Jobs first, we will have that roadmap of what we want ESCOG to do. I would say that that's exactly right. But given the fact that ESCOG is essentially a startup and we're in those various stages of a startup,

1:46:38 Trying to migrate into being a grown-up, we're looking down the road and seeing what the landscape looks like. Without any expectations, we can do everything we want to do, but the work that's coming out of the project you just mentioned is going to provide perhaps a very solid kind of a strategic foundation that can align with the authorities the ESCOG's already got, and then based on this discussion, we figure out how do we get leadership for the organization.

1:47:06 That can act as leadership and is not just checking invoices, if that makes sense. That makes sense. I just, I guess my idea is, it seems a little premature, at least from, and again, this is my first meeting, so I could be totally wrong, to talk about how, you know, what we're going to do funding-wise, you know, to fill that gap if we don't know what the road...

1:47:36 I would suggest that we know enough about the roadmap to start anticipating, and I'm not going to see you again until July, probably. So it's, we only meet, you know, so it's going to be here before we know it. But just to clarify, John, Sierra Jobs first may take care of some of this, but it's not solving the ESCOG problem overall, so... No, I didn't mean that it was. I just meant that she introduced this as saying, you know, that the...

1:48:06 That the Sierra Jobs' first money is what's sustaining this right now and it will be done in September, you know, barring Alan's whole thing about continuing on. And so if our timeline for figuring out the roadmap is also September, then it seems like it could be a discussion that we... I think this is like an age-old ESCOG challenge that sort of is agnostic of all of the potential things right now because we're trying to...

1:48:34 Get ESCOG's future set, regardless of how the winds blow. Does that make sense? Okay. You know, in looking at this question, to me, it comes down to, like, how does it best serve our constituent? And what do we want for our own, you know, specific bodies, like City of Bishop for me, and then how that also translates? Because we know that people...

1:49:01 who live in Eastern Sierra aren't confined to just a boundary, right? Like what happens up in Mono County directly impacts us in the city of Bishop as well. And from watching ESCOG be very small into the projects that we've accomplished that have impacted the city of Bishop in tremendous ways, like the Buttermilk Infrastructure Project and the Sierra Business Resource Center, you know, we don't really have much money that we dedicate towards economic development in the city of Bishop, and that was a direct

1:49:30 Benefit through the ESCOG. So I think personally having our Executive Director be in more of a leadership role because the administrative role can be handled on, you know, we can work in kind or we can find, we can figure that component out somehow. But for direction, I think leveraging these relationships, seeing the grants that are out there in the state of California directly benefits the constituents of the City of Bishop and regionally.

1:49:59 Madam Chair, if I could, I think that once we get to a sense of the number to get to executive pass that we need, Council Member Bobson and I have certainly discussed about bringing an ask back to the town of Mammoth Lakes to support that. But we need to get to a number. It fits in with all the other things that are flying around. But if it's going to take something like that to do the kinds of things, I'm very happy to hear that the benefits this is showing to the City of Bishop.

1:50:28 We need to get to that point to be able to have that discussion. Yes, and... If I may. Yes, and then, so, our town manager, Rob Patterson, is going to come to the podium because I think he has something to add, but I want to get you first. If I may. Yes. I think that we actually need to take a pretty significant step back as a board and as participating agencies because we haven't asked ourselves this question in...

1:50:59 And that is just, and I think we need to do that.

1:51:28 Before we even come up with numbers, before we even decide on a roadmap, to make sure that all four member agencies have the appetite and the resources for it, because we're going into some really sketchy financial days, both federal and state, and I don't want to see ESCOG be, you know, for lack of a better term, the sacrificial lamb.

1:51:56 when those impacts start to hit. So are we going to really dedicate to that capacity growth and support because that's what we need and that's what's going to sustain us on balance of those revenue impacts? Or are we going to stay steady where we're at for the next few years? Can I comment? Yeah, of course. It's going to happen either way. The community is demanding it. They are

1:52:25 They, you know, we have what's going on at Mill Creek and there's, you know, looking for more music happening there. They're demanding a toilet at Pine Creek. They are looking for, their mountain biking is going crazy at Chetmont Canyon. So whether we aren't here to support these organizations, it's going to happen regardless. And so we can at least help leverage the funding that comes from the state to get it out there because these community members, they're on fire and they're going to make it happen. And I agree, there is a demand, but there's also a reality.

1:52:55 That sometimes those funds from the state is very real possibility that they're going to stop. And who's going to pay when those stop? Yes, there is demand, but there's also going to be demand for health care. There is demand for support services. And, you know, and that's something that in Yon-Mono County, we really have to consider.

1:53:22 When we're looking at this, I mean, I wish I had all the money in the world to give to ESCOG because I truly believe in what they're doing and how it really contributes to our region. But I also have to be realistic. But also, well, no, you go ahead. I'm just going to add to that that yes, we do need to be really realistic, but to Karen's point too, one of the benefits of our investment individually in ESCOG is

1:53:53 A massive capacity multiplier to do these things, to pull these efforts together that if we didn't have ESCOG, I feel would be spiraling individually and working perhaps across purposes. And I just look to things like the work from the EPP. We would not have been able to take advantage of that across the region without ESCOG. I think one of the things that ESCOG does is it's a great equalizer to ensure that regional capacity is leveraged regionally.

1:54:23 Rather than in individual places. And I totally get you. I'm worried looking at the future. I see the small, relatively small investments we make in ESCOG paying back multiple times over. And not just in dollars brought into the region, but in capacity leveraged to do very real things.

1:54:45 Yeah, I don't disagree. I just, I want us to be cautious because even talking about like the in-kind, not each member agency has the resources for in-kind. I'm not going to go down that road right now, but again, that is a resource from member organizations that's being taxed and as these impacts from federal and state funding deficits come in, member organizations

1:55:16 In kind may not be even a possibility. It just, it really depends. I just, I think I'm just asking for some caution and just some really realistic foundational decisions of what do we actually want to see? Where do we want to go? How are we going to get there in a sustainable way that isn't dependent on something else so that it doesn't go away? Go ahead.

1:55:45 Yeah, I mean, and I think this is just going to be a somewhat fluid discussion because, you know, your points are well taken, but, you know, there's just two things to keep in mind. You know, if we're talking about what's the gap and if, you know, it could be $100,000, which is just the doubling of each organization, I'm just saying, like, we're not talking about

1:56:13 Budget Busters here, and yet, if we tried to quantify, and I'm not suggesting we do this because it will become a morass, but the benefit that we have seen as a region, all of us, like in each entity has gotten something different out of this, but every entity has benefited, you know, substantially. And imagine if we had gotten the CalTrans grant for the Main Street project, right? Like, can you imagine? So, I think our...

1:56:40 If we really explain this to our constituencies, they'd all say, why aren't you doing more of this? So, I just want to keep it in perspective because it's, you know. Before Mr. Patterson goes. He's there. I appreciate that. I think there was a risk in pausing this presentation in the middle to have that discussion because there is, as I said in our last board meeting, there's not a cliff.

1:57:11 We have some runway to think about it, but I think those questions are important. And there aren't questions that I can come back with a number. I could come back with a number, but it's, there's a demand to increase capacity, and there's also a question of, to what end? And I can't answer those questions by myself. So with Mr. Patterson's comments, I'd also like to be able to move forward to get some direction on a couple other items related to staffing and funding. Thank you.

1:57:38 Thank you, Rob Patterson, Town Manager, Town of Mammoth Lakes. I wanted to get up and talk at this point because, you know, we've been working through connections directly with Elaine in our area managers meetings and having conversations about just how do we as administrators integrate ESCOG into our work plans. And I use the term integrate into our work plans very specifically because the work that's being performed by ESCOG is not work that I have my staff working on right now.

1:58:08 So this is incremental to the work that I'm sort of funding myself through my organization. And we've seen the value of the collaboration across the region. It's more attractive to grants and other things that are going on. So I think there's a lot of value in that space. When you look at the efforts of ESCOG prior to today,

1:58:32 It was really around where are the sources of money and that defines the projects we go after. As an organization, I can't hang my hat on that because it doesn't give me a consistency in what I'm seeking, right? So I think we do need to come to a point where the organization is funded such that it performs the work that we need to be done. I have, you know, being very, very thoughtful and I...

1:58:56 of everyone's different impacts to that, and I do appreciate the conversations that you guys just engaged in here because this is a tough conversation. I am fully supportive of when we talk about in-kind, it's, you know, the original intent was each agency puts in $25,000 and then some agencies were doing some aspect of work to support the organization and they drew back funds. The town of Mammoth Lakes, we used to charge $20,000 for clerking.

1:59:23 A couple of years ago, I reduced that to 10. I'm happy to reduce that to zero. When I talk about in kind, it's simply saying that we don't draw back from the money we put back into it. If we can get to that point, I think, as Elaine has illustrated in her notes, that's very supportive of that. Another comment that was made earlier about, you know, $25,000 has been the original amount and has been in place for a very long time. A lot of times, and, you know, budget is my background. I'm finance director at heart.

1:59:51 If you start to slightly increment things, they're not as impactful. So if you said, for example, that instead of $25,000, the agencies contribute $30,000 to that, it's an additional $5,000 a year out of everyone's budget, you know, and that can be difficult perhaps, but it might not be. And then that just becomes a norm for a little bit of time. So you take the two together, and I think that provides a fairly significant amount of additional funding that would support the work that we need to get done.

2:00:20 I also want to kind of make a comment about, you know, organizational growth. I keep, we keep, we, not I, we keep the town of Mammoth Lakes sort of lean and mean by really not going too crazy on the funding opportunities. And I think Elaine and ESCOG has demonstrated that through, you know, tight economics, you can actually get a lot done with a little bit.

2:00:44 Right? And so I think that's the strength of not having an organization that's going to try to grow to be something much, much larger. It's simply getting the funding it needs to survive. So I think that small increment and that other adjustment makes a lot of sense to me, both from a fiscal responsibility standpoint, but also from a support standpoint. So thank you for that. Thank you. Rob, before you leave, does anyone have any questions, clarification points?

2:01:10 Thank you for saying that. I know that the area managers do meet together and talk about this, so I'm grateful that you represented those conversations. Elaine, do you want to continue on and thank you? Yeah, thank you. Just the same word to pick up. In our last meeting, we looked a little bit at the existing organizational chart. I will move through these quickly because we do have other items to cover. So currently,

2:01:44 Executive Director, Wildfire Coordinator funded through our CDFW funding and shared with Inyo County. We have a Recreation Coordinator funded by Sierra Jobs First and the Inyo National Forest Service Grant. We had a Broadband Coordinator is currently unfilled and that program is dormant for the time being. And then we have some PMO support through a contract with Inyo County to support Sierra Jobs First administration. With a shift in our funding next year,

2:02:14 You know, we'll lose the administrative support through Inyo County. We are hoping to backfill that coordinator position through CS, through California Advanced Services Funds. There is that big shift over to forestry through the CWDG grant. And that is a place that I want to...

2:02:36 Have a conversation with your board about how it is we plan to staff that and how we might be able to leverage that funding to also help close that gap and provide some more of that day-to-day administration. So I think one of the things that's important in the context of this conversation about the community defense, wildfire defense grant, is that when that grant was originally scoped, it was

2:03:05 anticipated that the two county coordinator positions that are funded through a CAL FIRE grant would expire. That was a term limited grant. CAL FIRE has since extended that and has extended it again and we anticipate that it will be extended another time. What that means is that the two positions that we've proposed to fund in that community wildfire defense grant are redundant to those county coordinator positions.

2:03:35 which provides an opportunity for ESCOG to be able to potentially pivot one of those positions away from really working directly in the communities for implementation projects to be able to provide more administrative support. And in the conversations we've had with the U.S. Forest Service, who's the grantor on this project, there can be flexibility in that second position.

2:04:01 to provide more administrative support and more administrative backbone, not just supporting the CWDG grant, but also supporting some of their other forestry work and things like communications for ESCOG more broadly. So with that, I do have some options that I would like to get your board direction on. I've had conversations with Mono County. I've had some conversations with Inyo County on regards to how we are going to staff this program.

2:04:28 As you may remember, one of the complexities of ESCOG is that it doesn't, as a JPA, actually have direct staff. We have contracts with member agencies and we have contractors that we work with. Which means that depending on how we choose to staff this, there is going to need to be agreement with the Inyo County Board and the Mono County Board in how we're going to interface with those county coordinator positions.

2:04:57 And how we're going and how we plan to staff, whether we choose to use member agency staff or contractors for some of these roles. So the first option that I'd like to discuss with you, the thing that is consistent across all of these options, I should start there, is my recommendation that Ms. Filer, who works in a part-time capacity supporting ESCOG grant work, be

2:05:25 empowered to be the program manager for the community wildfire defense grant implementation. She's largely the architect of that. I think she has the capability for that. I do not think that we can, I certainly am not going to be the right person to project manage that. And I think it would be difficult for us to find someone.

2:05:47 with her qualifications to support that role. Moreover, I think Kristen has demonstrated excellent leadership in being able to mentor other coordinators in doing their community work and could continue to do that. So the first option would be, given that we have funding for two

2:06:10 full-time staff to support this. We would have a project manager for implementation who would oversee implementation for the program. If you're not familiar with the scope of it, it is a $4.6 million grant that does direct wildfire resiliency work within communities. So working with private property owners, bringing in funding to support public works to be able to

2:06:39 Manage all the biomass that's coming off of the projects, some support for landfills, green waste vouchers, infrastructure to support doing that work. So that's the scope of the project. So my recommendation would be bringing in a program manager for that. And then if we need

2:07:06 There is some opportunity that we might be able to find additional funds to cover the Executive Director role, but if not, that could fund, the Executive Director role could continue to do day-to-day grant management and administration of that program, and we would not need any additional funding to cover that Executive Director role for five years. The second option would be to have a program manager

2:07:33 served by one of the wildfire coordinators from Inyo County, and then a redundant position to that served by one of the wildfire coordinators from Mono County. Again, between the CAL FIRE funding and the CWDG funding, we have enough funding for two positions in each county. That would result in the anticipated deficit for the Executive Director funding and, you know, a drawback.

2:08:02 in the capacity to support economic development and sustainable recreation programming. And then the third option, and this is my recommendation to the board, is that Ms. Feiler would serve as the program manager on this project, that we would be able to bring in another county coordinator to Inyo County under her mentorship, be able to expand capacity in Inyo County.

2:08:29 And that the other full-time position provided for in the CWDG grant could be administrative support to provide grant management, communications, and all the day-to-day administration for this project and potentially some of the other ESCOG projects as well. My recommendation there would also be, given some of the concerns that we have heard in the past about ESCOG revenues coming in,

2:08:54 and being directed to one member agency over another to support revenue that we would identify administrative support opportunities in one of the other member agencies to be able to have a similar PMO style contract to what we have with Inyo County to provide that administrative support. We could alternatively make it a standalone contract that would support ESCOG as administrative support as well.

2:09:21 So those are the three options in staffing the Community Wildfire Defense Grant. As you can see, the third option both addresses some of our needs for day-to-day management and administrative for ESCOG, potentially across a number of programs, while also providing for capacity in both of the counties in the Wildfire Resilience Program to grow. Happy to take additional questions on this item, but I'm looking forward to the discussion. Thank you.

2:09:51 Can you push out options a little bit better as far as what would be provided in each county for a wildfire coordinator? Yes. So the CWDG role would be, the actual staffing would be to staff for wildfire resiliency in Inyo County, essentially, as far as serving as an Inyo County employee.

2:10:20 And then there being another Cal Fire funded position for the county. And all of this we have to go back to the various boards for. So looking just for direction and then we will continue to have these conversations at an administrative level. In Mono County, there would be the Cal Fire funded coordinator.

2:10:40 Both of those CAL FIRE funded coordinator positions would work directly with Kristen in implementation and community coordination on the ground and benefit for that program leadership in that role. And then the funding for the executive director would then continue to be the constitution, whatever we have in kind, and the most. Overhead. Yeah. Yeah. I just wanted to say a couple words about these organizations, you know, an organization such as us, in general.

2:11:10 is that you have your strategic plan, you have your goals, you have your things that you want to do. It's tempered by what may be available, what you can find to be available to fund those activities, including salaries for executive director, etc. So, you know, trying to predetermine what you're going to do, absolutely, given the lack of knowledge about what funding might be available, is always a little bit of a give and take. You never can exactly...

2:11:37 Do your strategic plan and expect to find money. You may sometimes drive the other way. But in this case, with the Wildfire Defense Grant, what we're saying is we would have an employee in Mono County employee here that would both kind of up through and coordinate with and be overseen by an employee such as Kristen. And whether, you know, this works for one county or the other, the money's coming from the same place.

2:12:04 So if, for example, in six months, another grant associated with or similar to, say, wildfire work becomes available, then the landscape can change rapidly because you may say, oh, we could add this on to what we're already doing. We have some things in place. We could take that money. So I think we have to understand that that's always a possibility that things change that quickly.

2:12:34 So for right now, this is your, you know, idea, and so all the talk we had before about what to do whenever, we sort of have, as you put out here, I think you should stop in the middle of a presentation and let everybody talk, you should get through the end first. Because these are good solutions, these are good ideas, these are good ways to do it.

2:12:56 We have, perhaps, especially given that that grant's going to be pushed, or the California Department is going to be pushed out a little bit further, we may be fined for the next fiscal year. Well, a couple points on that related to the ED position. One, we will run out of capacity funding through Sierra Jobs First for the ED role and its support roles by September.

2:13:26 If possibly before September. Yeah, because that is a set $200,000 and we've been billing against that with the expectation that it will expire in September. The Sierra Business Council did not award any funding for personnel for project management on those other grants, which also obviously some wiggle room on the back end might be beneficial, but we don't have the funding to provide support and grant management on that. The best case scenario was still going to be the $27,000 short.

2:13:55 That's my estimate at this time. The other thing that I just want to caveat there, which we can't bank on, is that we have done a preliminary submission of the Economic Development District application to the EDA. And if that's awarded, it does provide $70,000 of capacity funding.

2:14:21 Which could help, you know, provide some sustainability in that ED role in the future. That is at the discretion of the federal government, and so until it's awarded, it's not money. So I guess the point I'm trying to make is this landscape is never going to change. This landscape is what it is when you run a business like ESCOG, I think. You're always going to have, you know, a certain amount of money that you know about, a certain amount of money you hope you get. Some years it may look a little lean, and then something pops up.

2:14:52 This is not to be unexpected. So I don't know how much reality there is in the surety of making sure that we can always fund our executive director because our goals and our objectives may also change with the availability. It's a hard thing because you don't want the money to drive what you do. You want to stay with your goals and objectives. On the other hand, you have to be flexible. So I don't know. That's all I have to think.

2:15:22 Thanks, Madam Chair, if I could, I'm going to have to leave it. Sure, sure, please. I don't have any questions. Is there an action item on this? There's not an action item on this. I'm looking only for direction, particularly in the CWDG position, so that I can have conversations with Inyo County and Mono County, but how we're planning staff for that. So if that, then if we want to move to like more deliberation, should I take public comment and then we'll...

2:15:53 Elaine, is this the end of your presentation? Okay. So is there any public comment either in the room or online on this item? Then I think, you know, I think it's fair for you to start and talk about your thoughts and we'll just get it from the rest of the board and then this will be completed because it doesn't need a vote. So I'd be brief if it matters. Two things I would add. One, in

2:16:25 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

2:17:06 The second thing, I think I would like at some point to be clear about this, perhaps an opportunity that's coming to state to extend a vote on that. Anybody else, or else we can just go down the line. Does anyone have a... Go ahead, Paul, I saw you unmuting. Let's do it. I mean, option C is the only one that really gets us, I think, to where we need to go, because the Community Wildfire Defense Grant is something that is...

2:18:12 Basically making the desires that many of us have heard from our community and we have to do it well. And that's the only one in my mind that sets it up for success by ensuring that there's meaningful regional project management and consistency as well as that administrative support. And also by providing that administrative support, we support you, Elaine, and ESCOG to continue forward. I mean, you know, going back to something that Supervisor Oral said,

2:18:42 As we look at a potential pullback from the state and the feds, I think that encourages us to invest ever more in our own resiliency to address problems, issues, and things that people want to see here. And some of that can be achieved through investments in ensuring that ESCOG is not constantly chasing the next big grant, but is able to.

2:19:12 Meet the community where they're at and be more sustainable going forward. But the biggest thing we have on our plate right now is CWDG. Option C gets us there and means that it will be effectively across the region is critical to all of our little community. Yeah, I agree with Paul and Option C. Does anyone disagree with Option C? Because I agree with Option C. Can I butt in for just a minute? I realize that I'm not, you know,

2:19:50 This won't be coming back to the City of Bishop as a discussion item, right? These positions. I think if I was on one of those boards, the idea of having staff that's hired that I realize will be funded for several years puts you in a place where, you know, you will be chasing more grants because you don't want this person to come and work here for...

2:20:16 Three or four or five years and then be like, goodbye, you have to go. But I also realize that I'm not going to be put in that situation to make that decision. So I think if I was, I would vote for option A. I will say that I'm not going to express an opinion at this time because to Councilmember Kong's point, we're talking about employees for Inyo County.

2:20:51 And for Inyo County, that comes with a little bit more liability when you're talking about employing. So I think that's a conversation that Elaine needs to go back and have with our administrative and budget teams and our legal teams. And we as a board need to discuss that. And then the two representatives from the member agency will bring that recommendation back at a later time. All right. Can I throw one more thing in there really quickly?

2:21:23 Timeline-wise, your budget stuff is happening now, May? We're going into third quarter next month, I believe. Our fiscal year ends July 1st, and we're in budget through September. It's right here, so it's a timely discussion. Noted, thank you. All right, any other?

2:21:54 comments on this item? All right, we'll move along to item 5.4. Thank you. Yes, thank you. You know what, we keep moving it forward a little bit every time, so this is, at least we're moving forward, we're having the conversations, so thank you. Item 5.4, this is to provide direction to submit a letter of interest for the Governor's Office of Land Use and Climate Innovation, Prop 4 Regional Biomass Accelerator Pilot. Thank you.

2:22:26 Yeah, it's a shifting landscape all the time. We're about to move it again. Thank you again for the discussion and the direction. I appreciate it. I think it's very helpful. This item is in, you may recall,

2:22:41 that California Law Empowering Renewable Energy, Ms. Darlington and Ms. Corliss came to your board in August. They had pilot funding to do some regional coordination in biomass. We know that biomass has become a pinch point for implementation of various wildfire resiliency projects and also a potential opportunity.

2:23:06 for communities throughout the Eastern Sierra to be able to leverage new businesses and economic opportunities. One of the limitations of being able to move that work forward, though, has been capacity, an assessment of different site locations and the entitlement processes and support for businesses to be able to navigate

2:23:34 the entitlement pathways and contracting needs, particularly with the Forest Service and some of the larger wildfire resiliency projects happening on forest lands. In response to that, the Governor's Office of Land Use and Climate Innovation has made an opportunity available to build on that pilot project and has invited the Eastern Sierra to submit a letter of interest for funding.

2:24:00 That would provide approximately $1.5 million over three years to fund capacity, to focus on regional biomass coordination, to provide technical assessment of biomass passways, markets, and contracting needs, to do a broad regional site analysis for biomass-related businesses and facilities for both Inyo and Mono counties, which has not been completed before.

2:24:27 And to develop an Eastern Sierra Biomass Entity Plan in order to improve collaboration and coordination between all of the entities in a biomass landscape. I'm looking for direction from your board today to submit this letter to the Governor's Office of Land Use and Climate Innovation to be eligible for this project opportunity. Thank you. Questions?

2:25:05 I would love to offer more information about the grant. It is, and you may recall this from the presentation in August, there's not a grant application, and there's not a grant definition, and there's not a proposed scope within grant guidelines. It's a very atypical funding opportunity. Can we just stand here with our first opening? That's as it's been described to me, yes.

2:25:34 There is an opportunity to provide a letter of interest under this biomass pilot program up to $1.5 million. And the scope is, as I've described, first capacity to be able to project manage this as a discrete program under ESCOG to do technical assessment of like what

2:26:00 The technological opportunities in biomass might even be in the Eastern Sierra, what those markets look like, what type of agreements need to be in place for contracting things like feedstock, which is a capacity gap that the Forest Service had mentioned to us about a year ago, is some need to help broker those agreements for feedstock.

2:26:24 To do regional site analysis for biomass related facilities. To date, there's been some site analysis done in association with the Donut Project around Mammoth, but it was limited to what's very proximate to that project and doesn't meet the regional need of biomass creation through different wildfire resiliency projects. And then that entity action plan that would basically be a strategic plan for biomass utilization.

2:26:53 It is based on the feedback that we have received from their offices about what they might want, as well as the work that Stacey Corliss and Christiana Darlington did over the summer to do outreach to those partners in the Eastern Sierra. So basically... Any other questions? Well, I'll take public comment, but first I want to... So again...

2:27:30 Assuming that this funding is what you're saying you think it possibly might be, because that's all we know, this is money to figure out if there's anything that we can do biomass-wise locally. Correct. With not necessarily people attached to it. I mean, as far as...

2:28:00 If we could figure out some biomass thing to do locally, there's not anyone who's going to then jump in and do it. I guess yes and no. Are you asking specifically like if there was a biomass facility recommendation for a particular technology like we don't have anyone who's going to come do that work? Correct. Okay. That is both true and untrue. So there have been there are a few business enterprises who are looking at

2:28:30 Interest in biomass facilities in the Eastern Sierra. It's a pretty significant area of technological innovation investment in California right now because of all the wildfire resiliency work. So there is that opportunity. And we've had some conversations with businesses around that. One of those limitations has been things like a site assessment to figure out where those businesses might go. There's lots of other barriers in working with those partners as well. But part of that would be helping to facilitate those entrepreneurial opportunities.

2:28:59 Okay, so that's my question, is that in the more immediate future, this could actually help people who are already wanting to do this work? Yes. Okay. That's the hope. Okay, that's the piece I was missing. Yeah, I did have a question. Thanks for the letter. It's really well put together. There's a lot of quotable lines in this letter. I think one of the best ones.

2:29:26 It's in number three on the third page. It's not just one county, not just one facility type. I think this gets us out of that kind of myopic hole that we were in for a while, focused on one solution in one place for all biomass all the time. And that's definitely not how we're going to succeed. As opposed to saying... Yeah. So thanks. I think my one question is, in looking at the three or the four broad pathways that are...

2:29:57 outlined here for what this money could be used for. Which one of these, sort of to Karen's point, can get us directly to investment? You know, rather than a planning process, an identification process, a feasibility process, are any of these four able to directly invest in people that actually want to solve this problem?

2:30:25 So there's components within this scope that address that. One is the site assessment and things like entitlement. So some of these biomass companies that are potentially interested in investment in the Eastern Sierra, we don't even know what the pathway is for entitling some of those technologies in our region yet. So it's kind of technical assistance to get through that process. I also think things like looking at markets and contracting needs also provides things like

2:30:53 you know data for financing for financing those things and being able to facilitate those contracts with the feedstock producers like the Forest Service. So all of those things would directly go to benefiting entrepreneurial opportunities. One of the things that we could investigate is if there's opportunities to also identify

2:31:18 If there's a specific technology that is most appropriate or feasible for the Eastern Sierra investing in a pilot program. Okay. Yeah, and again, I think it won't be one. It will be multiple small investments spread across the region because of as diverse as our place. And yeah, thanks for putting this together. It's a great opportunity. It's one of those like you've been invited to ask and so let's ask and then we'll...

2:31:46 Hopefully figure out details as we go. And I think that's just going to be one of the things that I'm going to keep asking is how can we take this money and get it directly on the ground to solutions rather than more problem identification, like get it right there and get things rolling. Okay. I do want to keep us moving because ESSA folks are going to be arriving soon. But is there any public comment on this? Please approach the podium and state your name.

2:32:20 Thank you, Chair, and Council. My name is Steve Nelson. I'm a resident of Bishop. I have been for many, many years. Worked for the BLM for 36 years and a lot of partnerships and building things and doing things. I'm probably the only person in this room now with the possible exception of John and certainly all will be aware that's actually worked through some sort of energy.

2:32:49 Producing Project in the Eastern Sierra. So this is my comment. I support, especially now that I hear some of the sideboards, I thought it was a pre-prenup, right, for a more detailed application. So since it seems so broad and open to ideas, I'm in that vein of some immediate on-the-ground activities.

2:33:20 Potentially, right? Because I think there's options now. But I fully support the project going forward as a proposal to the state. Why wouldn't you? And then, you know, if you could find a paragraph or words to add to one of those that you have already for existing opportunities that may already be there to use biomass in the community.

2:33:50 And to find an applicant for the energy producing type possibility, right? Because that's what it needs. That's what we need. And I think there's a small group of them out there. And maybe just some time to go have conversations and see if there's interest. And anyway, that's all. And go for it. And best of luck. Thank you. Hi, Kristen Feiler.

2:34:22 Wildfire Coordinator for the ESCOG. I do just want to say I'll be making a few edits to the letter because I wrote it really quickly and I'm in working with Christiana to get more details that she's providing her expertise being in these meetings helping us position ourselves the best that we can and so a few of those things are adding some more details around.

2:34:49 Potential pilot projects that we want to see implementation happen to get us started. And then more information about the Inyo National Forest and how to kind of work with that big partner and aggregate a lot of those contracts and feedstock analysis there. So just want to let you know there will be some slight changes, but the core of the letter is what you have in front of you. I was wondering, would it be beneficial to put a range?

2:35:20 A request? 1.525? You might get something in there. You can do more. Or is that counterproductive to... I will investigate that. Okay. I mean, I don't want to, you know, like... I did originally put two on what Christiana said, but she is like, the state's really telling us 1.5 is what they're looking for. Okay. Then disregard my anything. Thank you. Can I have one more question?

2:35:50 Sure. This is really a question for when this came about and you were thinking about doing this letter of interest, did you go out and talk to those other folks that already have like Steve and people who have things on the ground already and see would this be helpful to you or are we just sort of flying blind assuming it's going to be helpful? No, the collaborations and conversations have been happening for quite some time.

2:36:16 And we did pull together a small group of folks to help inform this letter, too, before it came to your board. Fabulous. Thank you. Thank you. I just wanted to make one quick comment. I'm assuming this money is Prop 4 money. Is that correct? We believe so. So this is Germaine, too, just to give you a legislative update about what went on in Sacramento on Monday afternoon.

2:36:43 I guess within Prop 4, they really have not decided how to use money for biomass utilization. So there was testimony Monday afternoon in Sacramento, 30 people testified about how to put $50 million aside, and this is now why this is so nebulous, because the Prop 4 money hasn't been set aside yet. So the proposal there was to put $50 million aside for biomass utilization parks across the whole state of California, and they would produce energy,

2:37:12 Biochar, Biomass, Smallwood Products, they would do all of that. It did pass the committee hearing 9 to 1, and then it will go now to the Appropriations Committee. And then the question is whether the governor approves that. But in the proposition for funding, the legislature never really, or the governor's office, never really defined how to use the money for biomass facilities.

2:37:37 This hearing on Monday was to come together to address what I see now is all this questioning about how do we get this done. So that's an update from this week in Sacramento. All right. Thank you. So the two projects you referred to earlier that have been awarded.

2:38:02 Were these in regards to, did they have anything to do with this or that was a whole different thing? These two projects were federal funding from USDA Rural Development Funds. One of them is a biomass facility in Calaveras County and the other is a small timber mill in North of, in Sierra Valley, between Truckee and Sierra Valley. Okay, we really do need to move along. So, Elaine, does this require a vote or is this just direction?

2:38:30 I believe the request was for direction. Okay. So then with that, I think you have the direction. Thank you. Let's move along to 5.5. This is a consideration of the Eastern Sierra Wildfire Alliance Memorandum of Understanding. Okay. Thank you. The Eastern Sierra Wildfire Alliance has been meeting for the course of the last year in order to

2:38:57 convene around wildfire issues. There are multiple agencies, Federal Land Management Agency, Cal Fire, local fire departments, the counties, etc., who comprise the Wildfire Alliance. We have worked together to put together an MOU. It is very high level. It only formalizes that relationship that we are working together.

2:39:22 Collaboratively to prioritize wildfire resiliency needs and work in a coordinated fashion to bring in funding. As it relates to ESCOG, it does not...

2:39:35 commit any of the members to funding contributions, project implementation, or administrative support, though currently ESCOG does provide administrative support to convene those meetings through the Eastern Sierra Pace and Scale Accelerator funding, and we will continue to do that until that funding expires in 2027.

2:39:56 I am asking your board today to please approve the Eastern Sierra Wildfire Alliance Memorandum of Understanding, formalizing ESCOG's relationship to that organization and our, yeah, in support of the wildfire alliance. Happy to take questions. Thank you. Two, four, six. And I'm here for 10, we have a quorum. Okay. One second. Questions from the board.

2:40:27 This is the one we're all taking around everybody, right? The same. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, absolutely. No questions? Okay. Is there any public comment? Please come and introduce yourself. We have to do it every time. Steve Nelson, Bishop President. I've been attending the meetings for this, and as a resident who's interested and has long history and fire and have stood in the community communities.

2:40:59 In the east side that have been hardest hit. It's a tragedy every time. But, you know, I stood in Walker when 60% of the town went down. It's still not back. I stood in Swal when that happened recently. And I've seen it happen elsewhere in the west. This is a huge opportunity. The MOU is not perfect, but it's time.

2:41:27 It's time to move on and same thing, try to get things happening on the ground. And so, you know, I'm recommending support for it. I'm also on the Board of Commissioners for the Bishop Fire Protection District, as well as the Inyo Mono RCD as an associate director. And I am going to those boards as a board member to ask for the same thing, basically, those entities.

2:41:57 Sign on to the MOU. So full support from this individual anyway. And it's past two and it's time. And partnerships matter. And what I heard while I was trying to get back from Long Valley from counting grass before this started, I think there's some champions in this room for partnerships based on what I've seen.

2:42:26 at those meetings, right? And these are things that an entity like this needs. So White Bart came up, right? And they know how to share, right? And we can all learn from that, right? Like powerful partnerships require sharing. And it gets to a lot of those conversations you've had about these other things, right? I came for a specific thing and then listened to you like, wow.

2:42:57 There's so much overlap, right? So partners help you when you're down. And these questions about where funding is going to come from in the future and things like that, you know, doing what I did for, you know, pushing 40 years, we relied on partners a lot because budgets and everything else go crazy. But anyway, there's that. And then I also think on just the working with people.

2:43:28 Kristen is amazing, right? She's in that group. She's the one who will always reach out to see if somebody wants to be a part of it or has ideas and take it from there. So that's where I'll leave it. I'll do, like I say, oh, the key part of, like, me going to my boards is

2:43:55 So I do think this is a young partnership, right, with a lot of enthusiasm and people that have passion and care about communities and all those things, care about the bigger resource base that makes this an important place that drives our economy. I would implore all of you to go back. It's good to have the ESCOG on.

2:44:25 for all the reasons you've talked about here, but it would also be important to have your individual councils and boards take it up and find who's the signatory for those entities, because that higher level support, it permeates the rest of your organization, right? So ESCOG's not out there alone, but other departments know that.

2:44:54 This is a priority for the county or the town or the city. Thank you. Thank you so much. So with that, did you need us to formally approve this? Yes. Okay. I'll make a motion to adopt. Paul, can you speak up a little bit? Oh, sorry. Yeah. I'll make a motion to adopt the Memorandum of Understanding for the Eastern Sierra Wildfire Alliance as presented. I'll second.

2:45:19 Okay, so we have a motion from Supervisor McFarland and a second from Council Member Schwartz and Angie, could you please call the roll? Chair Bubzer? Yes. Vice Chair Oral? Board Member Salcedo? Yes. Board Member Schwartz? Yes. Board Member McFarland? Yes. And Board Member Kong? Yes. Thank you.

2:45:46 All right. Thank you so much. So with that, we're on to our item 5.6, which is ESCOG staff update reports. I have provided, I and our staff have provided a written report in your agenda packet. We're happy to take questions on the sake of time if you have anything specific. Any questions on the staff reports? Just the timing you expect to hear back on the EDD application.

2:46:13 Yeah, thank you. So that's a preliminary review. So I expect to have a conversation with our representative in the next couple of weeks. And then following the feedback that we get from that, I will start having conversations with our partners, member agencies, Chambers of Commerce, other economic development partners, tribes, to be able to get the support for a formal application. Thank you for keeping it moving. And a special thanks to

2:46:41 Aaron Wilcher, who's no longer with us, for his tremendous support to putting that together. He is alive. He just left the room for the room today. All right. Terrific. Then with that, we will move on to board member agency reports. So do you want to start? Anything from Mono County? Anything from Inyo? City of Bishop? Nothing from the town of Mammoth Lakes. So then with that,

2:47:11 The request for future agenda items. Does anyone have any? Obviously an update on this. Yes, the update on what we just approved. All right, terrific. Well, with that, we will adjourn to our next regular meeting scheduled to be held June 24th, 2026. Thank you, everyone. Thank you.