Town Council Special meeting
at 16:00
On the Town's site: Agenda ↗Agenda PDF ↗Minutes ↗Video ↗
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
280 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
4:17 Good afternoon and welcome to this, I guess, is this a special meeting? It is. Special meeting, Mammoth Lakes Town Council for Wednesday, March 22nd. And Jamie, if you could call the roll, please. Councilmember Bubzer? Here. Councilmember Ray is absent. Councilmember Rice? Here. Mayor Pro Tem Souser? Here. Mayor Wentworth? Present. Thank you. We'll get started with the Pledge of Allegiance and Stacey Powell's here.
4:46 We're going to lead us in the pledge. Thank you. Lead us. Thank you, Stacey. Okay, so we will now move on to public comments. If anybody has comments for items that are not otherwise on this evening's agenda. Mayor, good afternoon. John Urdi from Mammoth Lakes Tourism. I just wanted to give you a brief update, conversations that we've had in the past talking about infrastructure priorities for the community. We had a special board meeting for Mammoth Lakes Tourism yesterday. I didn't erase it, so it's all right there. Oh, good.
5:36 But you'll be getting that formalized in a letter to you in the next couple of days here with ideas that very closely match what you have in your priorities document. I think the biggest thing that my board is looking at is more action steps and timelines and, you know, when can we start to see some of these things and how can we help? I think the biggest thing, again, Mammoth Lake Tourism is a partner. You can see at the top of the board over there, number one is resident focus. The way we kind of look at it is that anything that we can do,
6:06 That benefits the resident, ultimately benefits the visitor. And so we'll get you that as soon as possible. Excellent. Thank you very much. Thank you. Thank you. Stacey, good evening. Good afternoon. I'm sorry. What was that? Good afternoon. Good afternoon, Mayor. My name is Stacey Powell-Slicer. It is no secret that this winter has exhausted everybody.
6:31 Because the snow removal company we hired to do our driveway did not push the snow far back enough away from our home, our garage is now fully enveloped with snow, and my husband can no longer get his car out of the garage. There's at least 100 extra feet of snow storage space they could have used in our property, but they did not. At 119 Mill Street, where we live in Old Mammoth, right in front of us, the second homeowners have not dug out their propane tank, which is 20 feet from our house. It's right near where our tenants live above the garage.
7:00 According to Mammoth Lakes Community Fund, they will only help homeowners who live here full-time. If the tank is dug out, the only place they can put the snow is in our driveway. But Eastman, who does our plowing, will not plow the driveway if there is snow on the driveway that has not fallen from the sky. Because according to them, they do not have the right equipment to remove shoveled snow, only snow that comes from up there. Our property in Old Mammoth is right below the bluffs.
7:25 There's an avalanche run between our house and the bluffs. Right now there is a pretty large cornice hanging down above our house. We called the Mammoth Lakes Fire Department and they said Cal Fire would come out. Then they said that they passed it to the town and the town has said now maybe that Eastern Sierra Avalanche will come out to see if we are in danger because it is an avalanche run right behind our house. But of course everybody is overwhelmed right now.
7:51 Just yesterday, two snowboarders came onto our property. They skied from the bluffs or snowboarded down onto our property, and we are very concerned that they are going to release that big cornice that is right above our house, a possible avalanche. Snow walls are starting to avalanche and cave on Mill Street, and many properties are full-time, many properties are owned by full-time residents, and many of the residents on Mill Street are seniors, over 70 years old, and they need a lot of help. Least of all, Mill Street
8:19 Needs to become finally dedicated to their town roads of the town of Mammoth Lakes. We were told by Public Works that it would be possible, but very expensive. Something to do with right-of-way, 20 feet, 24 feet. I know that's California law, but it's something that can be done. It's just going to cost some money. We also own lot 139 on Mill Street that butts up against Lost Lane Road. We are more than willing to let the town use that lot for snow storage. It's pretty big.
8:45 There are plenty of places to store snow on Mill Street, and I know that was one of the issues that Public Works might have had. We also have two surgeons from Mammoth Hospital who live on Mill Street who had a very tough time getting out this winter, and they need to have clean access to the hospital, obviously. So I'm asking the Town Council to please agendize, however that works, a discussion to have Mill Street finally be part of the Town of Mammoth Lake's road system. Thank you. Thank you very much.
9:19 My name's Ann Gimple. I know at least one of you, sort of. You guys have a really tough job, and no one knows that better than me. I have almost 30 years of government service running mental health and alcohol drug programs in several different counties, including this one. With that preface, I'm here to talk about Mill Street. I'm well aware it's a private road, despite being dedicated to the town 100 years ago.
9:48 I believe it's long past time to incorporate every private road into the town's structure. We're all in this together. As it stands, Mill Street residents have turned into red-headed stepchildren. So far, the town's position has been we can basically find our own snow removal. My question is where? We need snow trucked out of Mill Street. The walls are high. They're inward-leaning. They avalanche frequently.
10:17 The only one who does that kind of work is Villar. Stacy got us on the list, but his list is long. I've lived here 23 years. I know what that means. It means he'll never get to us. And, you know, if he does by some miracle, the price tag will be exorbitant. John Eastman's assistant emailed me that they lack the equipment to adequately clear our road. She suggested we throw ourselves on the town's mercy. Eastman is the one who's contracted to clear Mill Street.
10:47 Mill Street in its current form is dangerous. The snow walls collapse from time to time. The road has huge divots, potholes, and other hazards. Backing out is a joke. I just cross my fingers and pray no one's coming since I can't go slow. If I do, my tires get caught in the holes Eastman failed to get rid of. And then I'm trapped and at the mercy of whoever's careening down the hill. Electrical wires, except I...
11:14 When I wrote this yesterday, I thought they were electrical wires. Turns out they belong to Optimum. So SCE's been out, and I have a call-in to Optimum. They're frozen in snow on both sides of my driveway, about six feet above the ground. Someone needs to clear them, but who? Every municipal entity seems to think it's someone else's problem. My house has its own set of difficulties. It's not the roof.
11:41 I've had it shoveled three times. It's the weight of snow pressing on the gambrel walls. So far, the primary casualty is my front door, which is really tough to open. I can't open it. My husband has to. Again, I desperately need snow trucked out of my property. I did fill out your emergency assistance form. Hopefully, it will yield something beyond a polite denial. You don't have to embrace Mill Street permanently, although I really wish you would.
12:08 If you could see your way clear to trucking snow out of our street and smoothing up our road, it would be hugely appreciated. And now might be a good time to point out that two of the hospital surgeons live on Upper Mill Street. Stacey told you that. If you or a loved one had an emergency requiring surgery, it'd be a shame if the surgeon couldn't get you in a timely manner. Thank you so much for your time and for considering Mill Street. Thank you very much. Thanks for coming forward. Yes, please. Good evening.
12:45 Hello, I am Bobby Tanner, owner and operator of Reds Meadow Resort and Pack Station. Upon learning of your recent discussion about the Reds Meadow Road Project, I went back and viewed the meeting, watched the meeting, and that's what I'm here to comment on, have some comments on that. I want to start off with, I know Councilman Rice and Raya and Bubser, you are new to this process. I ask you, I urge you to please familiarize yourself with this issue. There are many documents, many people you can talk to.
13:14 Please meet with me. I will show you all the paperwork. Meet with me not just to hear my side of the story, but I will show it all to you, and I want you to draw your own conclusions about this project. And there's two major issues. One is the road construction that was talked about at your previous meeting. It also is the overall stewardship of the valley that has been in place for 51 years now, since the Trans Sierra Highway decision and subsequent wilderness boundary adjustments were made.
13:44 That set the direction of the valley. And I want you to look through it and see if you believe that this direction, that this road matches that direction we've been under for 50 years. The direction we have been, we've been running our resort has been a very narrow focus of how that valley is to be managed. And just the summary, the real short story of that is the valley is to be a wilderness setting.
14:12 A wilderness experience without the overlay of a wilderness regulation. And I want you to see if this big fort, the two-lane road and all this build-out matches that. Because if we're going to go this way, it's a whole different thing. We've been investing money. We've been running it based on conservation and preservation for 50 years. And if we're going to go a different direction, I would like to know. I think that that's fair. Also, to Fred Wong's comments, I was glad to hear him say that there will be adjustments to that closure plan.
14:42 The closure plan was discussed in concept at one meeting. Nothing was agreed on. It was just, should there be closures? What would it look like? How would it affect things? What are all the issues that would surround that? There was no agreement on it. See, Councilmember Wentworth, you brought up the May 15th concern. Ski lift said no to May 15th at a previous meeting. They said yes to administrative access, but no to construction traffic through...
15:12 The administrative access route, which obviously this year at the snowpack, that's going to be different, but maybe next year will be a light year. I would recommend you learn all the fine print of that situation. The land trade plays into it. Some of that's private property at the ski lift. There's a bit to that that I would recommend you learn if you're going to take over that road, the whole thing. Let's see. What else? Councilmember...
15:43 Salzer, you brought up Madera County. After I listened to the meeting, I contacted Madera. There's been no contact whatsoever, no contact whatsoever to Madera from the town of Maryland, which to me, that brings up an interesting question being involved in the day-to-day operations and this whole process, that you brought up the concept of what's going on with Madera? What's Madera think about that? Mr. Madera, guys, told me to thank you for bringing that up. But the last meeting we had, the very last meeting we had,
16:13 It was a meeting Leslie Yen put together at a Zoom meeting. I don't think any of you were there. But Madera brought up the concept that they've always managed the value of their county issues with themselves or through MOUs with Mono, that kind of stuff. They felt it would be appropriate if you are coming into their county with a road there would be an MOU between Mono and Madera. And the town staff dismissed them and said, absolutely not. We will not do an MOU with you. You are not to be involved in this project whatsoever.
16:43 And so for me, I would like to know what is the official position of the town of Mammoth in regards to Madeira because I work with Madeira all the time. So that's a very brief summary. I hope you guys will take time. You'll meet with me. Meet with me where there's a photocopier. There's so many letters, so many documents. Devil's Postpile letters. Devil's Postpile offered to cost share the entire project. They were denied by town staff the opportunity to be involved.
17:12 So thank you for your time. Any questions? No, I think we're good. Thank you very much, Bobby. Thanks for coming down. Appreciate it. Okay, any additional public comment here in the room? I'm not seeing any Jamie in the virtual world. Roger, would you please unmute yourself and give your comments? I have none. I'm okay. Roger, can you hear us? His hand is right. Testing, testing. Can you hear me now? Roger, is that you there? Yes. Can you hear me? We can hear you. Yeah, please go ahead.
17:56 I have no comment for now. Thank you. Oh, okay. Good. Thank you. All right. So that's it for another one. Sarah, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Can you hear me? Yes. Loud and clear. Thank you. Testing, testing. Sarah, can you hear us? Can you hear me now? Yes, we can hear you. Thank you. Sorry about that. No problem. My name is Sarah Sundell. I am a general surgeon at the hospital and I also live on Mill Street and I wanted to...
18:44 Just echo the comments that my neighbors have made about the condition of our road and consideration being made to have it become a town managed road. It has been difficult at times, if not impossible, to get out of my house. And on occasion, I have had to ski to work multiple times a day because our road is not cleared. And I believe that represents... Oh, we just lost you, Sarah.
19:22 Sarah, if you want to try calling back, we just lost you. I think we kind of got the gist of what you're saying. If you want to try again, try again. Okay. All right. Well, Sarah, we're here. If you want to try give us a call back, that would be swell. Jamie, anybody else out there in the virtual world? Nope? Okay. Well, thank you all very much. Thanks to the Mill Street crew for coming down. Appreciate you guys coming down.
19:57 So then we will move on now to policy matters. Council action and management response to extreme weather declared emergency. Mr. Holler. Thank you. Last couple meetings since we've had the declaration, we want to provide an update at each meeting we do have. Originally this one was going to be a little more probably upbeat than it is today in terms of the work and the support we've had from Cal Fire, Cal OES. It's been great having them in the community and different elements that have.
20:27 Come together, just a great group of people and just fun to get to know and very, very talented at what they do. It's great having that resource here. This morning, a little after 9, 9.20 or so, we did have an explosion in the unit. Having the teams here and the response there was invaluable. But the overall structure in town has been a great asset to the community too. I do want to give the incident commanders, I should say,
20:57 Division Commander and Office Manager that are working as team leads here in Mammoth. An opportunity to speak to the council, give an overview of that work, and then Fire Chief Alish Tamaris here as well. We'd like to also address the council and the support that he's received out of these teams. And a lot of small stuff in the community has also happened out of these teams, others in the resources, you know, shoveling areas and stuff like this. But we have been really...
21:25 Privilege, frankly, to have the caliber of overhead teams in the community. So I'm going to turn this over to Jeff and Captain Harris as you guys want to address the council a little bit about the teams and the work and your experience being in Mammoth in a snow environment. I would just add that we have representatives from Eastern Sierra Propane as well as Southern California Edison on the line. And there you are.
21:51 They'll be joining at some point as well. So welcome. Thank you very much for coming up. Thank you, Mr. Mayor, Town Council, staff. So my name is Jeff Adams. I'll introduce myself by title and then explain a little bit about what that means. I work for the Governor's Office of Emergency Services. My title is Assistant Chief or Coordinator, and I work in the Special Operations Division.
22:19 The special operations include the things that aren't the typical vehicles you see running up and down the road on a day-in and day-out basis, meaning they're not fire engines. The equipment and gear underneath my coordination are urban search and rescue teams, water rescue teams, regional task forces, and to some extent that we are engaged.
22:46 With the bigger teams who are the federal element in the urban search and rescue task forces. With that, we understood that your town and the whole Sierra Nevada is under an extreme weather event that seems to be unrelenting. And, you know, we're at the end of March now, and we're still in December, if you look out the windows. With that, we had our weather people letting us know that more of that snow was going to be coming.
23:16 And we decided to pre-position some resources up into your town. Those resources we pre-positioned were urban search and rescue, single resource heavy rescue units. There's four of them up here. There's six trained individuals on each of those. They've been up here for a fair bit now. Most of them are timing out in the next day or two of 14 days, and they've been very busy doing the work that they typically do. Fortunately, and as mentioned by the town manager,
23:46 We did have an event this morning, and we were ready for it. I will explain a little bit how that went down. I was having a conversation with your fire chief, and he was on this edge of the corner, and I was on this edge of the corner. And previous to the call, one individual who's working with us let us know that we have somebody on this team working up here in your town who has a personal need, and that person's home was on fire, and we need to get them home to their family.
24:15 And literally 30 seconds later, the chief got the call on his device that an explosion occurred. Fortunately, and I'm going to introduce one of the people we brought up here to do this work. He is Deputy Chief Robert Harris from Los Angeles County and has a very deep urban search and rescue history or wings or legend.
24:42 He was the right guy to bring up for this incident. He's been a tremendous asset to both me and to your town folk. With that, that's kind of an overview of what you've been doing. I'd like to bring Deputy Chief Harris up here, sir, if you'd like to just brief the council, if you wouldn't mind. And I know we don't have all night, but I just... These are obviously important things. And again, thank you guys very much for being up here. Thank you, council, for allowing me to speak this afternoon.
25:13 Just wanted to brief you on, right now we have approximately 32 members that are here serving your community. Throughout the course of this mission, we've seen highs and lows as far as our requests for assistance to your local community, and we had a glide path of looking at maybe demolding our resources this coming Saturday as a result of what happened today and some of the changing environment.
25:41 We see that it's necessary to maybe look at reconsidering that effort and working in conjunction with your local fire chief. I think that it's definitely a necessity that the council looks at just the overall.
25:55 Amount of resources that you just have up here. We have some definite concerns with just the safety of the community in light of some of the lingering effects that this storm is going to have on this community for the foreseeable future. Today's event was very alarming to us because we have really a high risk right now with just the gas emergencies in combination with
26:19 Just the collapse threat that we see. So me being here is really just to stress that, you know, this is an event that, you know, even though we may extend for a week or two, this is something that your community is going to be faced with for the foreseeable future, you know, with just the amount of snow that's on top of your structures, the collapse threat.
26:42 I know, obviously, what the climate's going to throw at us. We conceivably have more snow coming in the coming weeks. And then this gas emergency with the structures that are completely covered. And we not know if we have leaks out there. So I'll just tell you from my professional opinion, there's a lot of risk out there. And, you know, I'm just concerned. So I just thank you for just giving us the opportunity.
27:08 The team is really appreciative of the fact that we come up here. We do a lot of training for these type of emergencies. And to actually come up here and to be able to be of service to your community is really what we've trained for. So thank you for that opportunity. We thank you for your service. And I think you guys are going to be hanging around for a couple of minutes. I think we may have some questions from council members in a couple of minutes, if that's OK.
27:32 Mayor, would you like to stay up here for those questions? Oh, no, have a seat. We had a couple other people to bring in some local stuff. I know the fire chief wants to speak, but I'm sure there'll be questions from the council to the whole team. So, Alish, good evening. How are you? Good evening. I'm hanging in there. Good. Good evening, Alish Tamar, your fire chief. We have these moments within our community, and I think it's important that we take that moment, we deal with the situation at hand.
28:03 We're in good shape to do that. We have the best in the world. Chief Harris just came back from Turkey. I don't know if I got mentioned earlier. We have the best in the world. Some of the engineers that are walking through buildings are PhDs who teach at UCLA who graduated from Princeton and are out here taking care of our community, walking in with our firefighters into these buildings. So the team we have here today is the best. What I think I need to do is take a step back and...
28:32 Take a look at where we've been and ideally where we're going. And I started on this department about 20 years ago. We were running about 300 calls. We're at 400 and something, and I don't know what day it is because every day has been Monday for me. I'm working about 16-hour days. But it's not 20 years ago. The impact that the fire district has felt is tremendous. I've been feeling it, and I knew it was coming kind of since January. And the reality is,
29:03 Some of these events are, I'm not surprised by them. You know, these, they've been escalating. I reached a point where the community essentially, you know, I knew that we had to reach out for help. Reached out for CaliOS just in time and we got the Calvary in. And so, you know, some wise people say, what do we have today? What do we need? We need to get the snow off the roof. So the more you can, you know, work on that and make sure we're getting that messaging and the PIOs are doing a great job, we're going to get there. The sun will come out at some point.
29:32 What do we need? I mentioned that. What do we have? We have the best. We also have a local fire protection district, essentially a fire department. It's a separate district. It's stretched. At the same time as we had that explosion, I had another unit that was dealing with a choking child at the middle school. We are stretched. What I would ask is that we take this situation. I need to figure out what we do for the next few months.
30:03 Because there is a point when the best will leave. We've got some darn good people here, and we will mitigate the incidents. But I would ask for this group, as you work with the fire district, and we look at what are we going to do a year from now? What are we going to do three years? And what are we going to do five years? Because, again, I think that this is an important moment. It is going to snow again. There will be propane issues. And, again, what keeps me up at night? Sure, these things. Red's Meadow. I've got a list of them, and I'm working hard.
30:32 You have loving community members that serve you, but we need your help, so we just want to get that out there. Thank you very much. I'm sure that everything that's happening is being documented officially and for all kinds of different reasons. That's something to be thinking about as we go forward. There is very good documentation, yes. Okay, good. Thank you. I think at this point, to round out the group, I know we have Eastern Sierra Propane is on the line, and then, Jamie, that's the 374, sorry, 937-4464 number.
31:01 Hey, we could unmute. We could hear from Tom. Tom, you're unmuted if you'd like to give your comments. Unmute yourself. Hey, can you hear us now? Yes, sir. Oh, very good. Yeah, we tried Zoom. It didn't work out. So this will be the best we can do at this point. That's fine. We can hear you loud and clear. Thank you. So was there questions or you just wanted to make a statement? Yeah, we'd just like to get a little sense. As you know, we had some type of a propane emergency this morning.
31:41 And I think just to provide for the council and for the community the sense of where you're at in terms of Eastern Sierra propane, you know, access to propane tanks, what you'd like the community to know given the snow emergency we're dealing with right now. Just get some thoughts and advice to the community given our current situation.
32:03 You bet. My name is Tom Sigler. I'm the owner. I've got Jason Sigler here. He's our operations manager. We've got Adam Marsland here. He's our service manager. They have both been out there doing the work. So I'm going to turn it over and ask Jason what he can best think, because he's been there, what he can do to help and what we can do. By the way, we did send out a letter to all of our customers up there, June Lake, up to Levining, asking them to make sure there's snow removal.
32:30 He probably didn't read it, but this is back in November. We've done what we know to do. So here, I'm going to turn you over to Jason. I think our biggest problem, obviously, we all know the snow is a problem, but nobody seems to care until there's a problem with clearing the tanks or the meter banks or shutoffs or any of that sort. That would be our biggest problem. We've been up there trying to do what we can do, which obviously is just...
33:00 Sometimes not enough. Okay. So what we really need is the homeowners to get involved to either, if they're not, they don't live up here, then they need to contact a snow removal, whomever does their snow removal and remove it from the driveway and not put it from the driveway on top of our tanks. That's been the big challenge. And so they're digging that out. We're making deliveries in snow caves. True story. Not safe, but that's the only way we can make deliveries because it's so deep. Anybody else want me to comment? Yeah, the biggest thing is just...
33:34 I know years past, an ordinance or some kind of wording that homeowners were supposed to clear their tanks, you know, 24 hours after a storm, possibility of a fine. And I know that's unreasonable with, you know, you guys, you're resourcing into Jason today. They, two calls up in Mammoth where it's happened again. There was almost two other that exploded on Majestic Point where a lady's been smelling it for two days. They called the day and she had a broken mind.
34:28 You guys need to help out the propane companies, you know, trying to dig tanks out and make it help us out. It'd be awesome. Are there any other resources available from the states that can help us remove the snow from the tanks and or plumbing? Is that a question? That's a question. Do you know if there's any resources available from the states that could assist us to dig out tanks and remove snow from meter banks and plumbing?
35:05 Yeah, I'm going to defer to the town manager. I think we're working on that. I think there's some language we need to address in our emergency ordinance, and that's in the works, and we'll certainly let you know as that comes together. I mean, obviously, you know, we're all trying to work together here. Some of the biggest problems are the town themselves with the blowers. I mean, we all know it's a problem. I've talked to a few people from the town saying, hey, is there any way you guys can not blow snow here? We put bamboo sticks up, painted them.
35:36 They're packed back full of blower snow. Every mom and pop and little guy trying to run a snowblower in a driveway. I mean, that right there is probably one of the worst case scenarios. Okay. So they've dug out the tank and it could be, you know, several, several feet deep, as we all know. And when they come back, that hole's full of, packed full of snow and ice that's been blown into it, which makes it twice as hard to get to. And if you wanted to turn off an emergency, good luck.
36:04 Okay, good to know. Well, if you guys could just stay on the line, I think we may have some questions from council coming forward. Dan, did anybody from Amerigas respond to being here this evening or no? No, we were reaching out to the local manager here and he was frankly tied up this morning and a couple of other elements where he was not going to be able to brace. Okay, good. Hang on one second. Before I, I just want to get to one last person, which is Southern California Edison. Matt Perillo, are you with us?
36:36 Because I know there are concerns about high-voltage power lines that are now within, you know, reasonable expectation there could be human contact with those power lines. So I'm wondering if, Matt Pearl, if you could share some of your thoughts on that. Yeah, good afternoon, Mayor Wentworth, Town Council. Mr. Holler, can you hear me? Yeah, we can hear you just fine. Thank you. Okay, great. Hey, first, an update on the incident on Hillside. In order for search and rescue,
37:05 And emergency medical to safely work in that area. Our crews did de-energize approximately 184 customers in the surrounding neighborhoods, including Mammoth Knolls and portions of the village. I did just get word that we brought Mammoth Knolls back up and a portion of the village is still down to allow safe access in there. We have staggered crews to stand by at the Mammoth Service Center to provide additional coverage.
37:32 I know that residents are working feverishly to clear snow from their roofs and
38:02 From their properties and snow storage is becoming increasingly limited. So I would like to remind customers and residents to never touch or even to approach a downed power line as it can cause serious injury or even death. Whether overhead or underground, residents should assume that all lines are energized and potentially dangerous. Although as one of the public commenters pointed out, there are numerous communication
38:29 Paul attachment feeds on many of our structures which belong to the communication utilities and are not within the purview of Southern California Edison. But again, please don't touch anyone or anything in contact with the downed power line, including debris, trees, cars, ladders. Don't try to use tools such as a branch or stick to move the line.
38:55 We've heard some questions come in throughout this activation since January with respect to that. Customers, I want to emphasize customers should call 911 immediately after vacating the area for downline or imminent contact with a downline. Customers should be extremely careful with ladders and shovels and any tool being used overhead and maintain 10 feet of clearance away from primary lines.
39:22 Chris Bounds, John Westbrook, Jr.: Transformers and electrical equipment, since I know folks are working overhead, visibility is minimal, snow depth is increasingly deep. Chris Bounds, John Westbrook, Jr.: Safety and reliability are part of the reason we invest so heavily in grid hardening and in our wildfire mitigation and vegetation management programs. So just as a reminder, this is why, you know, even pruning of trees near growing near power lines requires the expertise of a qualified
39:52 Line Clearance Arborist. To report in non-emergency power outages, customers should call 1-800-611-1911 for all outages. It's important that customers and residents do that because this ensures that a trouble ticket is generated and trouble men and line crews can then respond to that outage or issue. Just a reminder, during the storm activations, like every other agency,
40:21 SCE is triaging and prioritizing the protection of life, property, and the environment to safely restore power as quickly as possible. Right now, apart from the incident on the hillside, we're showing no outages. However, during storm activations, there are no estimated restoration times as we move from the frying pan into the fire, like Chief Tamai mentioned earlier. A primary concern for SCE throughout these events has been
40:50 To maintain access to its facilities on public roadways, crews did, and in our substations, crews made significant progress today clearing snow from its substations and infrastructure in Mammoth Lakes to minimize the potential for major outages, so we're not seeing any imminent threat to that degree currently. I will add that I'm extremely grateful.
41:15 For the coordination of town and county staff, including the town manager, public works department, the CAO, health and human services. This has been ongoing. It's the winter that never ends. And our crews are working through all kinds of conditions. So I'll provide some of this information to Stu so council can disseminate that through PIO, how they see fit, contact numbers, useful information, working around power lines.
41:43 And I'm available for any questions that council has. Okay, great. I think if all of you could just stand by, I'd like to get a report from the town manager, and then that'd be a good time to have some questions and dialogue. So, Dan, go ahead. A couple of things I wanted to note, and Alex may be able to help with this one too, but one of the things with the propane tanks, we do have people calling and asking about, you know, what's most critical in terms of clearing, you know, it's off the top of tanks for filling, how much of that is on where the pipes either come out of the tanks, where there's a...
42:13 The other element, and I may have Stu touched briefly on just the information we sent out on the explosion this morning.
42:41 A quick overview of that. We don't have all the details yet, so we're a little cautious on what we say. But we can have a little bit of that information. A couple requests already pop up via text and stuff. Are we going to give an update on that so we can do a brief update there? I know Alice's team has worked on a lot of different areas as they go out and work with people. A lot of requests coming in in terms of code changes and requirements in terms of propane issues because we've had other.
43:09 Outside of today, we've had other leaks and stuff. So ongoing work in that area, absolutely, and whether there's a code change. Usually that's usually forward-looking versus going backwards and making people do massive retrofits or movement of tanks and those types of elements. So a lot of different things that way. The last issue I wanted to touch on, we had a good conversation with a representative from Cal OES today regarding the potential of getting some support on digging out tanks. It's a very specific request. We just got it.
43:39 Five minutes before this meeting. So when you say digging, this is tanks on private property, correct? So modifying our declaration a little bit and touching on the need for that private property support to be able to go on there and so not to have the liability. This would be tanks only, likely not roofs due to the skills and OSHA requirements, the roof shoveling.
44:01 Versus the tank shoveling. So we'll follow up on that. If that's good, I would modify the one that I've issued, put that in there, then have the council ratify accordingly so we can move very quickly on that. With that, I wanted to just give a brief just from what we've put out to the community regarding the incident this morning, and then we can continue if there's other questions or comments. And also, Fire Chief had one more thing. And I do want to thank, again, our partners from the state here.
44:27 Thank you, Stuart. Thank you, Mayor. Members of the Council. Yeah, I mean, just a really difficult, devastating incident today. Condolences to the families and those affected.
44:57 As the Town PIO have been looped in with our Cal Fire PIO team, so we've been part of that collaboration for the past several weeks, which has been great, and they're providing tremendous resources and assets and help us amplify, you know, whatever messages we need to push out. I'm also connected with our Town PIO team, Eastern Sierra PIO team and so forth. So upon notification of the incident today, we convened over at the police department.
45:26 Christina and I kind of started to work on the incident, getting information from Acting Chief Casabian. We were able to publish a release here at 1 o'clock. I believe you probably saw all that. We're mainly, at this point, pushing everything on the Mammoth Lakes Police Department Facebook page, hashtag Valdezere incident. So we're going to keep that updated. We're able to post a statement here at 1 o'clock describing, just in general terms, kind of what happened. And then, as more information became available,
45:55 We posted another update just after 2 o'clock. You probably saw that one as well. And that one was a little bit more specific in regards to the number of people, the type of injuries and so forth. The injury, the incident is still under investigation, so we're not able to comment on that at this time. We're also able to list the number of responding agencies and then to really try and control the message and the narrative.
46:25 We were able to kind of post as much as we could, and then we supplemented that with kind of images, and we posted videos today as well, and we'll continue that as more information becomes available tomorrow. So again, all that information is available on the Mammoth Lakes Police Department page, and I've been in contact with, as you could imagine, several national EU's organizations, so they're picking up the story, so I certainly wouldn't be surprised if it's on kind of our national.
46:53 And regional news outlets tonight. So again, doing the best we can in the very, very difficult circumstances. Again, thanks for everybody's support that is here helping the town through this whole time. Thank you. Thank you all very much. I think we've got a good overview and I think I want to turn it now to council members for questions for any of the various folks gathered here today and who wants to start? Well, I just have one question. I don't know if there's really an answer, but I've heard from
47:20 You know, multiple people who are concerned who have absent neighbors with buried snow tank or buried propane tanks and the propane tanks are, you know, close to their property and their house. Is there anything that we can do for all of these buried propane tanks or, you know, people should just, you know, shovel their neighbor's propane tanks or what can we, how can we, you know, what's a proactive thing that we can do to stop this from happening again? Alice, you want to address that one?
47:52 So for better or worse, I am your subject matter expert on propane and downed power lines. We need to again kind of address this like I mentioned earlier. What do we need to do today and what do we need to do downed power lines? If there was a couple asks today, we're not going to solve this. This is incredibly complicated. Strategically, propane is one of my top three priorities. I have some thoughts on what we need to do. What we need to do today is we need to make sure that we have representatives,
48:27 From those organizations available to our community 24-7 while we are working through this crisis. And they need to be in town. Having them in Bishop when the roads are closed and I'm trying to shut down a propane line does not help me having somebody down in Bishop maybe showing up in four hours. Could you be specific? Are we talking about represents of the companies, of the propane providers? And a technician who can help us solve the problem.
48:53 Okay, and these technicians would be associated with the propane companies that are providing the services, correct? And Edison's actually very good. Right when we had this incident, they had people on scene. I worked with them. I said, look, we need to work on having a team that is supporting this incident. They have liaison. So we need to have that same mindset when we're working with our propane organizations, okay? In my opinion, propane is a higher hazard right now than the down parts. They're both dangerous, but today reflects that.
49:23 So that would be my number one ask. As far as digging things out, get to your tanks and get to your shutoffs at the house. Where we are seeing these failures are at the house, for the most part. You're seeing other places, but the majority. So if you have a tank, that's great. Please get to the tank. Get that shoveled off. That helps us mitigate it quicker. Some people don't have a tank. Their systems are set up different. I don't want to get into all the details on that today. But if you don't have a tank, you certainly have to have that one shut off.
49:54 At your house dugout. Again, for today, I think what we need to do is make sure that we have the technicians in town. We've asked Cal OES to support us for the next few weeks. We need to ask the same of these organizations that are providing those services. We need to continue this conversation. It is critical. So what I ask is we make it through this, but that we don't forget about it. We come back to this at an appropriate time.
50:23 I apologize that I'm texting during this. We have ongoing incidents. It's busy out there. Sure. Okay, maybe just to follow up on that, there's been some mention, Dan, about town ordinances with regards to requirements. Do you have any, I don't want to put you on the spot, but ordinance about requirements to have propane tanks dug out 24 hours after a storm? Are those on the books? I call that off the top of my head. I don't get unless staff is aware of it, but I'm not.
50:49 I thought it was the propane company said that they have an ordinance or they have a rule. They're a company. They don't have ordinances. Right, right. So I think it would be helpful. I think they're talking about some discussions they may have had with Chief Morrow. Ultimately, this has to be a prevention solution. And what I think we need to do right now is address the problem at hand, which is there's many things dug out. Again, if you have a tank, work on your tank. If you don't have a tank, work on the side of the house.
51:18 And getting those companies. We need to make it through the next two months. I have some thoughts, and I've had some multiple discussions on how we need to address this long-term. It is ultimately a prevention issue, but we need to do it appropriately. So we are not going to get an ordinance up today that's going to solve this problem. It's vital that we do that, but it won't help us today. Okay, I'm just looking for a little background, Dan. Maybe you have to do it now, but there's been representations that there is somehow an ordinance or requirement.
51:45 That homeowners have to do something. In 2009, there were changes made to the code. I'm not exact. I checked today. But basically, Mammoth Lakes is one of the most difficult environments for why it's occurring. Everybody understands. And it's new. In Lake Arrowhead, they had 11 houses that exploded. We've had some in our community, obviously. What's occurring is it's just the snow pushing against the house. We just have more snow. So even though we have some of the most stringent codes.
52:11 Compared to a lot of these other local communities, it's still not enough with what we're seeing with the snow loads. And in reality, what we need is valves. We need ways to shut this off. Those valves have to be in the right locations. And that takes good inspectors, good plan check. It's a very solvable problem. It's going to take time. But we need to deal with the emergency we have today and then have the willingness to come back and say, this is important. And we put it on our plates this spring.
52:41 Can I ask him one other quick question? Do you have any tips for digging out propane tanks or, you know, for people that haven't had to? If you have a propane tank, so the biggest thing is we struggle finding them. So we are working off, unfortunately, some partners have been willing to give us their GIS data, others have not. These are, again, long-term discussions I don't want to fix today. We need data, we need to have schematics, and we need shutoff valves. What I would say is even if you cannot get to your tank because you have, you know.
53:10 Somebody's elderly or something. If we can get to where that bamboo pole is, maybe extended with another bamboo pole, our crews will get there. It will at least get us digging in the right place. So that would be my first recommendation. Okay. Hang on a second. Any questions from council members? I'll get to you in a second. Thank you so much for all you're doing. So, you know, like you mentioned, propane comes in multiple ways. So I guess really...
53:37 So, then,
54:05 I guess really the question is how do we best message to the public exactly what needs to be done? I think you posted on social media weeks ago like how to get the part on your house dug out safely. Is that – am I remembering that correctly? Yeah, and I will tie it with the PAO. We've had pretty good messaging. I think we honestly have a – we have just gotten – and it's difficult. 16-hour days and my wife's up shoveling the roof with my 10-year-old kid. We are all stretched to our limits.
54:38 And that's where we cannot, you know, we will be in this position again, make no mistake. And that's where we have to put systems in place. So we're not depending on grandma or my 10-year-old to be shoveling something because it will happen again. So we need to build systems and approach this. And it's going to take time. What I'd like to see us do is Bill Norton's working with the building department that addresses things moving forward. I can't fix everything that happened in 1985. But we need to stop, you know, recognize that today's date.
55:08 We have to do better. And then start working backwards from there to start retrofitting some of these systems. So what I do not want to do is put more lines into the ground that don't have the proper safety mechanisms built into them. Sure. So just trying to understand how we help the community with the problem today. So I guess the question is, would it make sense? Can we consider shutting off the valves at the house for any house that's empty? How hard is it to shut off?
55:38 You have to get to it. So if you can get to it, you can shut it off. And if you can shut it off, you don't have, you know, we can mitigate the problem. So right now, Chief Adams, he nailed our, he showed up in town and he nailed our problem. If we get the snow off stuff, problem solved, right? It's really, us firefighters, it's not too complicated. I mean, it's just how we work. There's really a lot of truth in that. We are in a situation where we are resource scarce. We've reached out to the National Guard. I know that.
56:06 Your town manager is doing everything we can to get those additional resources. What I ask is, we are dealing with the problem today, and we have to make it a priority, not tomorrow, but two months from now, strategically. Sure. And, you know, I'm not trying to beat it at horse. I'm just trying to really understand, like, for example, do we, you know, Amerigas and Eastern Sierra Propane have lists of customers. They know who's got gas.
56:31 You know, either in a tank or coming into their home. And if they're absentee, then can we use those lists to contact people and say, you've got to take care of this, you know? We can, but it's a tough situation. I mean, and again, if we shut off gas, you're going to break water lines. So the reality is that we are in a situation where there are no good answers. But the people that can and have the ability to, they should dig out their tank if they have one because that's the easiest way for us to shut off an emergency and to shut off at their house.
57:01 For the people that can't, the town's working on some systems where you can reach out and the town manager can correct me on leaving messaging as these systems get put up as we get that support from the state. So we're doing everything that I believe is appropriate. I believe the messaging coming from the PIOs is appropriate. It's a tough situation. My ask is that we make it through the next two months. We have the best of the best here. I just don't want us to say, hey, we had the best of the best. It takes them a while to get up here.
57:31 In Afghanistan, next time, take care of things. So we were fortunate to get the team that's up here. We take those additional measures. But yes, absolutely. If we can get the tank and the regulator right at the house, dug off, that is ideal. And, you know, this is a community that cares about each other. You know, take care of your neighbors. You know, I was driving through, I was tired, and I saw Eric Sigimura, the United Hydrant. I had to pull over and thank him. You know, and the crews working out here.
57:59 The Cal Fire crews, you know, you have the crews that are through the corrections department working out there. Their Cal Fire captains are standing right next to them digging in that trench. So everyone's putting an effort. This is a hard endeavor. We're going to get through it, and we need to learn from it forward in a way that's different from how we've done things in the past. Thank you. And then I do have a question for Matt Perillo. Okay, go ahead. Matt, thanks again for all you're doing. You talked about the high...
58:31 Yeah, thanks. Like Alex mentioned, it's difficult to get into technical details with how some of these systems are configured, but I'll take my best
59:02 I'll take my best steps to answering that. So our high voltage or primary lines are carried much higher than the communication lines, which you typically see as a bundled insulated package. We've had numerous, numerous calls about down calm lines. So that's not us. That's not the high voltage stuff. To your question, the secondary line or the service drop, which comes off of either transform or off of the primary.
59:30 Greg Stapp, John Eastman, Jr.: So when clearing snow around those it's I would imagine really difficult when you're talking feats and feats of snow to even know where that is at to work around it generally, and I want to provide the best information customers should steer clear of that entirely and push snow away from the panel away from the service weather drop.
59:55 And avoid it, right? And then call our number if we have an outage. You flip your breaker, the lights don't come back on. Calls, we'll get a troubleman out there. Avoid it is the best advice I can give. In terms of specific clearance recommendations from the state, I don't want to cite those. I don't have them on hand. It's not 10 feet like it is for our primary lines. It's like three feet, something to that effect.
1:00:20 The best advice I can give is push snow away from those things. Know where that service drop comes in. Avoid it and be careful of any overhead motion or tools that are within distance of primary conductor. And then I would just add to Alicia's comment about prevention, this is the world we live in as SCE. We invest billions of dollars in grid hardening. We pre-deploy crews to respond to these type of things. We're not perfect.
1:00:51 But I do ask the council's support to help us move those initiatives forward, invest in modernizing and strengthening our grid. This is why we have so much activity and impacts to customers. We have crews out there constantly. We're placing thousands of poles. It's an aggravation. Having somebody in your yard clearing trees, maintaining secondary lines, pole attachments, new poles, it's an impact. But ultimately,
1:01:20 Prevention is the best tack that we have. I got a lot of questions from customers asking about generators during outages. We have services which can provide backup batteries and generators for customers living in high fire risk areas. It only works if customers enroll in those programs prior to taking the outage. So we're doing everything in our power. I know that doesn't fully answer your question. I'll try to follow up with specific.
1:01:46 State recommendations on clearance from secondary lines. But again, just stay away. If power goes down, call. If there's a down line, 911. Thank you, Councilmember. Just to reiterate, we are trying to work on a program to dig out magicians. There's also, in the questions I've been getting from some people, there is some confusion about whose responsibility some of this is. Where is it the propane company's responsibility? Up to what point?
1:02:28 And after that, what point is it the owner? I dealt with a leak earlier on a commercial building where we were told that it's not the propane company's responsibility because it's after the meter and it goes along the building in. So I would love to see, as our fire chief has said, some collaboration there and something going out prior to each winter from the companies explaining what your responsibility is versus theirs. And if you don't like it, you can change companies.
1:02:57 But that's where it goes. Most of the lines, and I'm doing snow removal, so I'm out there looking at this stuff, that I see that are in big danger that could be a problem, I believe belong to Frontier, the landline phone company. I don't see them here, but there are several locations in and around Sierra Valley where their lines are in the snow, and you can see they are being pulled down by several feet.
1:03:25 And if somebody only has a landline and that goes, then access to 911 and emergency services and everything else are gone. So I would love to get Frontier's take on that and how they're going to deal with that because I don't imagine we want people with steel shovels out there even though there's no electricity in it trying to hack out a phone line out of the snow pile. I have had questions from Home Owner Service who is completely at loss for what to do.
1:03:55 with all the homes that he manages because the tanks are completely gone. There's no, you know, he can't even find them. The bamboo pole at my house, probably about the third or fourth storm of January, it was really wet, got enough snow on it, the wind blew, it broke, it's not there anymore. So, I mean, thankfully we know where it is and we dig it out, but they're missing. I also want to say we get a lot of complaints about
1:04:25 The town blowers and my propane tank's been hit as well. But if you've never driven that piece of equipment, you can't see, folks. They don't know where that snow is going. And we have to cut them a break. Our streets are open in this winter in a way that I find absolutely amazing. Our crews deserve a huge attaboy, including our PD, if you read the police beat. We have done a phenomenal job with this.
1:04:53 Trying to tell people not to come up doesn't work. People are very independent. And they come anyway. I know the homeowner services I deal with have sent letters to their owners and gotten very nasty replies about it's my house, I'm coming. So we do what we can. But those are my questions. Somebody looking at their tank saying that, you know, I pay thousands of dollars a year for propane.
1:05:19 They charge me rent on the tank. Shouldn't this be their responsibility? This needs to be clearly defined. And one of the problems is I think it isn't. So by the time the homeowner knows there's a problem, he has no way of responding to it. Digging down 20 feet in the kind of snow we've got this year is just not a doable thing for most people. Other than that, that's about it. Thank you for being here and helping us, of course. Steve, you want to?
1:05:47 Yeah, if there's some public comments, I know, Stacey, you wanted to go, you had your hand up. Do you want to say something? Yeah, please come forward. Yeah, I got it. I'm going to piggyback on what Amanda said. So, like I said earlier, about 20 feet away from our house, right where our apartment is that we rent to a couple locals, is our second homeowner neighbor's tank. It's under 30 feet of snow. They have not removed the snow. Now, because we have all, you know, we're in a tunnel.
1:06:16 If somebody was to shovel their tank out, and I think, Sarah, I think your husband, right, about a month and a half ago, I saw him on top looking for it. He was totally in the wrong place. And I said, no, it's like 30 feet over this way. He was working for, I think, Amerigas. He was, wasn't that your husband? Somebody else's husband. Sorry. Anyway, so if he shoveled the snow into our driveway, which is the only place they can shovel the snow, Eastman will not clear it. They said, we will not come. We do not have the equipment. Our equipment will get broken.
1:06:46 To clear the snow. There's nowhere to put it anyways. So let's say they have somebody come shovel the tank off, all that 30 feet of snow. Who's going to come clear it so we can get out of our driveway? Because already we have a three-car garage. Already my husband cannot get out of his garage because the snow is just right there. So that's the question. Who's going to come and take that snow away when they shovel that tank? And that tank needs to be shoveled. And our tenants are terrified because of what happened today. If his tank goes.
1:07:15 You know, our tenant's apartment is going to get it first. So it's a danger. It's a big danger. But the question is, who is going to clear that snow out of our driveway if they clear that tank out? So that's a huge problem, not just for our house on Mill Street, but for a lot of people as well. And I've spoken to the second homeowner. We're friends with him. And he's trying to get people to come over there. You can't even tell. I mean, I have it on my phone. You can't even tell where his house is, the roof and the snow. It's all one big pile.
1:07:45 So what do we do? You know, help. I mean, how do we do? We want to get that tank shoveled out. I have a list of snow shovelers that I've been keeping, and I've been passing it around to a bunch of people, and they've been great. But like I said, who's going to take the snow out of our driveway so we can actually get out of our driveway? Great, thank you. Steve? My phone's blowing up right now. The mics aren't working on the dice, and the people are texting. They're very interested in what you're saying.
1:08:32 Okay, if we could, I mean, I think they're on. Just let us know, because I've got mine right in front of me, so if they can't hear me, maybe there is a technical problem, just let me know. As a 45-year resident and past employee of the town, I get a lot of calls that maybe you don't, but you have the same neighbors I do, you're seeing the same things. I'm well aware and so grateful.
1:08:57 For the outreach and the people that are here in our community. I talked to a man today plowing on my street from Idaho. He said, I won't leave until your streets open. That's great. And we all, you know, it's a struggle. Our streets have been one lane where I live by bill for months. So there's a lot of name calling, a lot of accusations directed at the town manager. And that's common. We do that on a good day.
1:09:28 If you've lived here as long as Bill has or I have, we've seen countless buildings blow up. We've seen floods and famine, locusts. We've seen it all. This is different. We're in a fight that the resources are piling in here. Again, I have radios 24 hours a day, comms in my house. I have a different background to the Mammoth Lakes Police Department in serving my community for decades. And so I have a different understanding of how a lot things take.
1:10:00 Again, and I'm so grateful for the resources that are here. I have a legal pad of notes that I wanted to share with you today. I'm not going to share those thoughts of my neighbors and what I'm seeing, but I think the best advice I could give you and encourage you is there's an army of people out there. We live here. We're all...
1:10:31 Square pegs in a round hole. But we're all very independent. We all own a shovel. We all own a chainsaw. I get that you're having Mammoth Lakes Police Department's social media spearhead the information that you are putting out. No disrespect to the police department and their outreach. It's not working. The animosity on the streets, the them and us attitude.
1:11:03 If you guys, I think you should put out maybe
1:11:36 A word of encouragement or thoughtfulness or what our timelines are. We know by fact how many roads, how many miles of roads have been opened. We can extrapolate those numbers to see generally how long it's going to be. If we're just screwed and we need to run or this is doable, let's get in the game. I see communities that do Boston Strong or different things to prep people up.
1:12:06 That are hurting. We're not just hurting, we're completely beaten. My, as an unemployed, older person in the community, my snow shoveling bill last week was $6,500. I'm grateful to pay it, and I'm so grateful that I have the money in my bank account. A lot of people don't. To her point, we're sharing and trying to work on, we're storing snow on our roofs. Incredible.
1:12:45 Opposed today, get on your roofs and shovel your roofs. 10-year-old kid shoveling his roof. My next-door neighbor is a first responder and his wife shoveled the roof. So, situation, COVID, by what we're seeing now, one of the assets, we have huge liability, we have liabilities, and see where our shortfall is. Down and said odd or even addresses or north or south, if you gave them any 25-30.
1:14:09 And be here within an hour. If they could help insurance clauses and OES and all the different agencies that responded to the call today, all with different radio handles, channels, it's a mess. I believe animosity is distrust. You guys know where we got to today of your lifetime to sign it yourselves and say we're coming for you. It'll be Thursday. It'll be 10 days.
1:15:15 People in the trails, it's going to be three weeks. Nobody will like that, but they could set a goal. We're all goal-oriented. And it might be a year from now. Much of what has happened to our town will be years. We all know that. Our roads are destroyed. Yeah. And I think, Steve, that this is very good sage wisdom and sage words. We're going to get through this, and we're going to start talking about our priorities for next year.
1:15:43 Maybe if you want to hang around, we're going to start addressing those things very specifically as we go forward. Question, if you look at the real estate map of the town, times the amount of snow, public safety over and above the amount of roads. Question, I probably have 60 trucks in my driveway. Impossible for me to manage. Feds in OES, Cal Fire, though, all the combination of efforts go on private property after the roads are open.
1:16:26 We're going to be talking about that shortly. Hang around. Hang around. Have a seat. Hang around. Yeah. Okay. Any other public comments? Okay. Well, thanks for all the agencies for being here today. Dan, you got something? Jeff, any other comments from Cal Fire's side? I know you've got other stuff to be jumping on, but as long as you want, but I just wanted to give you an opportunity if you had anything else. The state agency side, I appreciate the work that's going on and the outreach we've had. Cal OES side, sorry. If you could do us a big favor.
1:17:10 If you could step up here and just speak into that microphone. We're having people saying the microphones don't work. Nothing else will get a mic test out of you. Again, Mr. Mayor, Council and staff, I'm happy to be here. I appreciate the invite to come and speak with you all today. I don't disagree with your fire chief and the rest of your staff in town. They've done a terrific job. It's unprecedented terms.
1:17:36 We have a lot to deal with. You have a lot to deal with. We're going to be sticking around. It's in my hopes that we are anyway. We're devising a plan to extend what looked like our exit this coming Saturday. I think we're going to be here for one more week. And I think that's a prudent decision. So I'm supportive of that. But if there's no questions of me for the people out and about listening and on the devices, I'm going to get back to work. It's OK. I'll just add one thought.
1:18:05 Which is, this is a slow motion natural disaster. And so this has been, what, four or five months in the making? You've arrived when we're seeing, finally it's getting to that point where structure failures, explosions, things like that. This is going to be with us for another four, five, six months, maybe even longer. So I think that we've had struggles with Cal OES in the past, understanding the nature of snow emergencies.
1:18:33 Rain on snow emergencies. We've broken every record. We've broken 50-year records with this event. And I think that as part of a debrief, getting back to the state and having them understand the realities of snow and what we deal with in these types of situations. We're a small community, but it's a conversation we'd love to have at an appropriate time down the road a little bit. I don't disagree, sir. I have made myself and my agency available personally to your fire chief.
1:19:03 I am the guy for special operations that is connected to your town and your fire chief, and I'll be available all the time. If we had not met up until now, we have forged a very strong relationship, same with your police chief. And so it's interesting. It occurs to me as I hear your words that all we've really heard for the last 15 or so years is winter is getting ready to be a thing of the past.
1:19:32 I think we all need to caution ourselves when we use that type of language. Mother Nature gets to do what she wants. Well, again, as a representative of the state, the state of California is investing billions of dollars into climate resilience, climate adaptation. I think I'm encouraging all of our council members here and our leadership here to be really framing what we're seeing within the framework of climate change and manic events. Six months ago, if you come up here, we...
1:19:59 You would have been talking about we're all scared of being incinerated. Sure. Now we're worried about drowning. So this manic reality is something that we want. We're on the front lines of it. But I think to work with the state, get the policies and the funding and the capacity lined up with these types of events, it's an opportunity not to be lost. I think we look forward to working with you on that. Likewise. Yep. Thank you. OK, you have more important things to do. Please, thank you very much for being here. Really appreciate you being here today. Thank you.
1:20:27 One last thing I want to note, too, is when the teams came in, we set them up a partnership with the county. We have them in the county civic center. They were looking for some better space, and we reached out to the Mammoth Lakes Foundation and coordinated through Betsy and her staff and actually got them set up in that facility. I think it's worked very well for them. They can have a larger briefing room than some breakout areas. And so just the need for those types of facilities, it's not a huge need every day, but when you do need them.
1:20:58 If you can't get a hold of them, it's pretty critical. So it was very good for being able to transition in and set up that space for them to utilize, and I think it's worked very well for them. Good. Upon us, it would not work at all if it wasn't done in the manner, and it was, all of you. It's been a terrific relationship under difficult circumstances, but the hospitality is unprecedented, and we don't get it every day, so thank you so, so much. You're welcome. Okay, so obviously more to come on this. Yeah, Dan. Yeah, any...
1:21:39 Dan, my question of you is, we keep hearing the thing of, can we get the emergency service people on private property? And I know we've worked on that. You and I have had those conversations. But for the edification of the people out there, where are we on that? Yeah. Continuing to work through it. We've made different requests to the state. Let's come back and even some conversations a couple of hours ago regarding the use of certain resources on private property is very difficult for the state because it's okay.
1:22:13 We're taking statewide taxpayer funds. That is often seen as something that they should be doing. So as we work through that and those discussions, there's also the roof side of it gets challenging because if they put their resources on there, there's certain limited areas they can work on. Otherwise, they're not trained to do that. They don't meet OSHA standards. Most of us aren't going to buy that liability, those types of things. And they're not going to put their crews in those situations where people, you know, kind of that respond to safety first. So they don't meet. Discussions just today, though, on part of that, looking at.
1:22:55 I think also, I think, Dan,
1:23:45 In addition to state resources, I think that as a council, I think we are all very concerned about the immediate needs of our community. And I think if there's any issue, I think we'd like to see a proposal coming back from staff that says, how can we take our resources and go to Bill's question, getting it in the interest of private property? Because these bureaucratic lines, we're dealing with potentially very serious emergencies. We have some of those same restrictions. I'll speak to those, but one of the first items we did do already, we reached out with Mammoth Mountain to me.
1:24:21 The foundation, they reached out, they set up a fund. They had put requests out, applications out. I believe they have over 100 right now, and they have temporarily stopped taking applications because they can't process them. They don't want to give people a false sense of, hey, thank you for your application. We'll get back to you in a month. They're working through that. They do have licensed, bonded contractors they're working with. Different things, the roof clearing and some of the other digging. It's mainly been focused on roofs just because of the important nature of that.
1:24:57 The other thing that they've been doing, though, is a broader community benefit. If they're working with the family who needs a hotel for the night, other necessities because they're out of their homes or other needs of that nature, they've been able to step into some of those areas. So in providing fundings and matching funds to this, it's not just about one piece here, but it really is about benefiting the people who are hurting and not all of them are just for snow. So they're helping holistically as they deal with it.
1:25:29 Let me ask you a quick question. Are we agendized this evening for the council to authorize or to vote to approve a $200,000 match to that fund? Yeah, under the emergency, give me the direction to get it done. It'll happen. We'll bring back the DB, but it's part of the emergency powers. We have that declaration for us to do things and make expenditures. I believe it's structured enough. We're asking for approved recommended staff actions in response to this. One of those would be to $200,000 matching grant.
1:26:03 So if it's
1:26:39 If it's $400,000 because $200,000 from the foundation and $200,000 from, and it's probably $5,000 to do a property effectively, that's 80 homes and they've got 100 people on the list. So are we doing enough? I don't know. It varies from us. So my commitment to them was we'll match what you have. Again, we're going to figure out how do we fund it. So it'll be on us. If we come back and there's additional, we can come back and look at that.
1:27:09 Right now they've taken what they can handle. Sure. So I guess my next question then is if the biggest problem is propane lines and propane tanks, I understand roofs are an issue too, but how are we sort of balancing? Because it seems to me like in terms of like loss of life, the biggest concern to me is the propane access. I'll say we're balancing both of those. If you have your roof cave in, propane doesn't matter.
1:27:39 We've had more people displaced out of their homes because of structural failures, frankly, and so we're balancing that in terms of that collapse, what that would mean, which also could result in propane ruptures. So, and again, this is what they can do. We're looking at the propane side. That's a whole other ask and need of how we get into there. And again, that's probably a little more dangerous for, you know, I'd like to have people know what they're doing shoveling. It's a reminder.
1:28:07 You're digging through ice and stuff, so you need the equipment to do it, but you normally don't want to dig out propane with metal shovels, for example, which is, so there's just a skill set there. We'll be looking at some different ways to help in that. Like I say, if we can get the state resources in, that'll help a lot. And we should know on that pretty quickly. We've given us a lot of thought of how do we do this. Falling right behind that has just been the overall, we're broke in terms of moving snow. You're going to have a lot of HOAs that are upside down.
1:28:41 The other piece that we're looking at there would be what we're doing right now. We believe we'll be able to retain the resources for a period of time is the amount of trucking we're doing of snow off the roads, which ultimately we help. What do you do with the snow and getting things there?
1:29:11 Dave's team in Public Works. We have a whole lot of our admin work that is not getting done because we have people out there running this emergency. So heads up for that as other things slip. They are, we have people signed down to the EOC and Bishop. They're actually down there a couple days a week and not working on other elements. And the trucking program has been very good. We've done three, I don't know, three, four hundred, five hundred truckloads of snow out of town.
1:29:40 And again, that's running $25,000, $30,000 a day that currently the state is picking up. So if we have to continue that through our own resources, you can look at that cost, how quickly that adds up. We have some streets that are very, very tricky of how to move the snow out, just in terms of as you pull out some snow, you end up with little micro avalanches potentials. So we're looking at a lot of those different areas and some stuff that we haven't had to really deal with at that level in the past either.
1:30:09 The amount of snow over time that we've gotten is a challenge, to say the least. And the type of snow. I think everybody needs to be reminded it is not just inches. We have seen inches of snow before. But the kind of snow, the heavy, the rain, freeze up, soft snow on top, that makes a huge difference. And while I have the mic for my mayor, you know, shuts me up, I want to say something to one of Steve's comments earlier.
1:30:39 That the local snow removal companies are putting snow in the street because they're angry at the town. And I don't think that's true. They're putting snow in the street because they have no place else to put it. And that's when you hear me talk about partnerships, you know. We're coming around and we're bucketing that and putting it in trucks. And Dorrance is a great example of that right down from Steve and my places. It was widened, almost widened up for two cars. Absolutely amazing.
1:31:05 And this morning it was stuffed to the point where I don't know that a fire truck could have gone through. And I understand it. There just is. I imagine Steve's yard looks like mine. There's just no place left to put the snow. The little blowers can't get it to the top. The things that we needed to look at. Maybe one of the things we need to look at down the road. You heard one of our people talk about the fact that the snow was never pushed back as far as it could have been.
1:31:35 It happened to my neighbors, too. Everybody talks about the lack of winter and snow going away. We've had five years without a major winter. So they aren't taken care of. So maybe that's a campaign we need to do at the start of every winter. Remember, this could be a kick-tail winter. What I'd like to do, though, is bring it back. I think we have a question in front of us about doing matching funds to the Mammoth nomination. So I want to, if there's any other, do you guys have any questions for Dan on that? OK, go ahead.
1:32:07 My question for Dan is, I'm so used to people complaining that I talk too loud that it's different for me to have to even. With the emergency powers granted to you in the emergency declaration, this is something you could do on your own without us moving. It is good that we are involved and we are going to make this motion and pass this if that's what we're going to do. But just so everybody understands, if an emergency comes up like this,
1:32:35 And you see the need to spend that money. We have already authorized you to do that, have we not? Yeah, there's a lot of powers granted through that authority because of the timing. My preference is to have the council. Okay, I think with that, no other questions. Is there any public comment on this? Mayor Wentworth, after we closed public comment last time, there's another one online. There's another what online? Public comment. For this item? Yes. Okay, good. Well, let's go ahead. Karen, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hi, I'm sorry.
1:33:12 Hi, Karen O'Kelly, and I'm just listening from Zoom today to see what's going on. Again, I appreciate everything that everybody's been doing. You may have answered my question. My question is, do we have, does the Town of Mammoth Lakes, do we have no place anymore to put to truck snow, whether it's
1:33:40 Private contractors, or if we have the capability to get the National Guard here, is there a place to take the snow either in Old Mammoth or to the Forest Service like we used to do? Okay, thank you, Karen. The question that you're asking is not quite germane to the motion that's in front of us right now, so we'll come back to that in a second. Dan, could you do me a favor and turn on your microphone?
1:34:09 Good. I'm getting some text saying that folks maybe can't hear you. Okay, so we've had public comment on the item, and at this point I'd entertain a motion to provide matching funds. Chris? I move that the Town of Mammoth Lakes provides $200,000 of matching funds to match what the Mammoth Community Foundation has done. Mammoth Mountain Community Foundation has done. Is there a second? I'll second. So a second, yeah.
1:34:38 Thank you very much from Sarah. Any additional discussion? Okay, Jamie, please. Councilmember Bubzer? Yes. Councilmember Ray? Yes. Councilmember Rice? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Souser? Yes. Mayor Wentworth? Yes. Okay, well, Dan, yeah, go ahead. I can address the question on snow storage. Yes, we begin the year we lease property from Snow Creek Gate to development for a private property-driven snow pit. We begin to utilize that.
1:35:06 With the really heavy wet snow, we basically lost the road access to that. We worked with the Forest Service to reestablish the Forest Service pit. The initial discussion with the Forest Service was really to assist with the trucking that the town was doing off of public roads, not private. Given what happened then with the pit, they opened it up to private. We had been back and forth trying to keep the Snow Creek pit open as well. The roadway, we get it open, we lose it. It's difficult.
1:35:36 So to the extent that they're both open, the U.S. Forest Service permit pit will take only public snow. We're just hauling our snow, if you will, to that. Private snow going to the other one. If the other one is lost due to access, we can haul both to the Forest Service, but we are tracking the number of truckloads from the various sources, be it public or private type of snow. Thank you for that update. Yeah, Chris, you have a question? I just wanted to...
1:36:05 I just want to point out that I've heard from people and seen on social media from the public that people are really upset and complaining about the charges per truckload to the snow pits. And I think it's really important, you know, Dan, if you could just briefly talk about how expensive it is to run these operations. I just think it's worth mentioning because people think that it's just a pit. It's not. Really, it's...
1:36:34 Snow storage and management. It's one, just the access to it. You are actually, and others could speak to this more eloquently than I can, of building snow ramps. What that takes from skill, ability, you're running, as long as you're trucking, you're managing the snow, you're moving it, you're stacking it, you're packing it, you're doing whatever it takes in terms of ramping out and how you actually manage that snow. It can get soft, you can't have equipment stuck if you're not careful.
1:37:03 There's a number of different areas that can happen. So multiple pieces of big equipment, you're paying for those operators. They will run it. Once they close it down, they actually still have to manage it, make sure everything is in its proper place, if you will. And I'll defer to Mr. Sauer to speak about the technicalities of building good snow ramps. Over 10 to 15 acres of land. So this isn't just a little bit of storage area. And so we do have a fair amount of cost just in that process alone, and we are paying.
1:37:32 Specialized skill.
1:38:01 There are ramps all over town. I actually took our town manager off on one so he could see it in person the other day. But these things are expensive. You know, the loaders they're using go for $200 or $300 an hour with a driver. Add that up, it's out there. In a year like this when they're, you know, maybe collecting more, maybe there's something we can do, but it's not cheap. How much can we afford to subsidize, which we already do, the service?
1:38:30 I'm assuming that Rob will give us a report at the end of the season of what it cost us to get that new pit up and running, and we had no choice. The road issues, so it's just, it is not an inexpensive task to get it done. Yep, okay. All right, so I think we're done. Thanks to all the folks who showed up either virtually or in person. They're all doing much more important things than hanging around a council meeting.
1:38:59 We can move on now to the next item if you want to take a quick break or we can just go right in the next item. If we could take a quick staff break. Yeah, let's do that. So let's come back in, was it 535? Let's say 545. We'll come back then to get into our priorities. Okay, everybody, break time is over. Let's reconvene. Thank you all. Okay.
1:51:31 We are now going to move on to, this is policy matter number 4.2, discussion and direction on Town Council's strategic priorities and key objectives for fiscal year 23-24. And Mr. Holler. Yes, thank you, Mr. Mayor. The staff report kind of went through an exercise of taking what we heard in the last discussion and priorities, trying to capture those things. Not every single comment, obviously, trying to look and see how many people were, if you will, nodding or...
1:52:01 Commenting in terms of the various elements for some level of consensus just on a list of ideas and then trying to take those ideas and categorize them so we can actually talk about them in a topical area. And that was the idea of coming back up and looking at things in terms of community or economy. And that ultimately a statement or some other, you know, a little bit more description there. But that was kind of the themes that tended to come out of the discussions. If I missed one, my apology, throw it out.
1:52:31 And some of those kind of fall under a couple different areas, so you can pick one that way too if you want. But it seemed to me like there's a lot of discussion, a lot of very, some stuff much broader, some more very specific, and so we can play through that a little bit. The couple things I want to remind council as we do this, this is not to capture every single thing that you have an interest in.
1:52:54 These are major strategic priorities that if we do these things, we begin to move the town forward in those particular areas. 90%, 85%, 95% of what the town does is already captured in our day-to-day work programs. We highlight some of that in the report. Just that understanding, a couple of you have been through this before. If we list everything we're doing, then you have a four or five-page, six-page document that becomes unwieldy.
1:53:21 And if it gets too broad, it doesn't really have any specifics, so then it's a little tougher. Actually, it's easier to succeed because you say whatever you've done fits. So we kind of have that balance in the strategic priority discussion, the concept there. These are those four or five areas that are really important. Looking at a 12- to 18-month window, most of these things carry on beyond that. We get programs in place. One good example is the housing. We talk about implementation of the Housing Now program.
1:53:51 Versus listing out every single program that we're working on. There may be other areas of emphasis in there, and that's okay. To be able to make those things that way and work it through, it does provide staff direction of where do we put resources as they become available, and limited staff time is actually available to really put into these areas. Again, that daily workload absorbs the vast majority of the daily activity of staff.
1:54:19 Financial Resources throughout the year. And then, of course, we have those little things that get in the way, like a snow emergency, where all hands on deck, additional funding going places, and just, again, kind of impacts that daily work program fairly significantly. So today, I kind of outlined five different areas for council to look at, looking at did we kind of capture the key ideas out of that January 5th discussion.
1:54:46 Then kind of refining some of those priorities, adding things, walking through that. And then each time we try to have a, we call it an updated statement of priorities. So it's just a one-page document. The goal is to try to keep it that way and not get it there by doing eight-point font. Well, that's one option for a one-pager, but it's hard to read. And then what other things are we missing in here? Don't need to necessarily wordsmith every statement tonight.
1:55:16 Trying to pull that together. We'll work through that again. You'll have another bite at the apple, so to speak. And then as we've done these in the past, we do try to come up with what we call a short-term vision statement. Do a little bit of that on the front end, but then really truthing it at the back end. Once you go, here's what we want to achieve. What's that vision statement that ties it together? And so there's a concept one in here. Edit it. Write your own. No pride in authorship at this point on these things.
1:55:47 So I think as we work through that, though, it helps tie it together. Then as we're coming back in with if we have additional funding down the road and it's not going to go to mitigation of new streets and roads and some other things of that nature, how do we put those resources to work as we look at staffing levels? How do they fit into what your priorities are from that area? And again, this is...
1:56:09 Short-term on nature, because it tends to look at that 12- to 18-month window, the stuff we're doing now as we set money aside, and then for the fiscal year. Obviously, some of these items are carryover, and they do have a longer shelf life. But again, if we want to measure success, I think we need to have that focus. And the other key issue on this, and we're really looking at it from the dialogue at the council on consensus, we don't just five different disparate ideas individually.
1:56:40 Doesn't allow staff direction to go work on things. We're looking for that consensus of the council that, yes, we all see this as a priority for you to work on. That becomes a very important element as well. And so we tried to capture a lot of that in the short staff report. Thank you, Jamie, for proofreading after I typed it. So if there's mistakes in here, they're mine. So apologize for that in advance. A couple in the last report.
1:57:07 The element here, though, is trying to spend some time walking through this, have we captured, where do you want to go, then how can we help you take you there, some specific edits and ideas, and again, we'll work through it, bring it back again, work through that one more time, then hopefully bring it back after that for adoption. Okay, so, council members, I'm assuming you've all read this, and I think this is kind of a roll-up exercise.
1:57:33 So what I would propose to do is we'll go with the lettered strategic priorities that's on page three. And we'll just, something's missing, something's not written properly, we'll just kind of go one at a time. And we'll just go down the dice and see what thoughts people have. We'll go to public comment after each one of these things and see if we're missing anything. And we'll do some public comment at the end in case we're missing anything in aggregate. So.
1:57:59 Let's start with Strategic Priority Community Letter A. Does anybody want to lead off? I think I'm just going to throw out one thing, which I think is that we need to establish the Disaster Recovery 2023, snowpack, runoff and related challenges, along with proactive and opportunistic identification of state and federal funding resources to help us mitigate that. So I would propose we just put that in there as a...
1:58:30 None of us know what that looks like yet, but I think we need to put them as a top priority. So I'll go, Amanda, I can start with you. Can we kind of, are we doing like just one at a time or can we have to be a little less formal or? No, I think let's try to go one block at a time because we're trying to get, if there's things that are missing or things that aren't in any of them, we can add those. We're trying to do this in such a way to get it to staff so they can roll it up. Okay. Well, I guess my initial comment, you know,
1:59:01 Housing's on there. Completing the community facilities and enhanced programs and services. I think that it would be really great if we added more community activities to enhance our community here. You know, I feel like it's kind of on there, but, you know, like, I feel like we need to strengthen our community for the people in Mammoth. Okay, do you have any specific, again? No, it's abroad, just.
1:59:30 A broad suggestion. Does the language in here cover that? With the understanding that there'll be specifics that get added to the activities? Okay. I think that was, if I heard you right, Amanda, that would be something that was specifically not. Yeah, activities is not on there. You know, and I feel like a lot of our activities in town are geared towards tourists and are centered around drinking. And I feel that the locals that live here could really benefit from
2:00:01 Activities that are different than that. Okay. It's a long under community. I think as I discussed this as we, you know, have been covering this evening and as Steve Searles noted, the communication is a big part of community and I guess I think that that the communication belongs under it. Okay. As opposed to municipal services and programs.
2:00:46 Okay, I think, I mean, I could certainly see the logic in that. I think, Dan, you'll have to figure out how to kind of move that around to make it work in two places at the same time. Okay, Amanda, anything else for you on A? Not this time. Okay, Sarah, anything from you on A? Okay, Chris, I'll go to you for A. Sure, so I agree that these kinds of community activities are essential, and I sort of feel like
2:01:22 There is a community culture, and Amanda, I totally hear what you're saying, and I feel like particularly when it's not, when we're not buried under snow, but in the summer, there are opportunities for us to come together. So we have Town Cleanup Day. There's different things that happen, but for example, just to put some like meat on the bones, we are going to have
2:01:47 Maybe I'm getting ahead of myself, but there's going to be some major tree work happening in this little area that's very near my home, like near the meadow and near the multi-use path that goes towards Valentine. Like that's happening this summer. And so one of the things that I've been doing is talking to Linda Salcido and others.
2:02:11 Actually, Matt from Southern California Edison about the fact that we have to educate people. Like, why do we have to do this? What's going to happen? And we thought of making it like a little community fair where we maybe brought an ice cream truck down to the Waterford Bridge and really got people together to say, like, we need to do this as a community. So I love what you said. And just if that helps people to understand, I've been thinking something similar. So how do we...
2:02:38 You know, create a culture of resiliency in this town so that when we get to times like this, you know, what Steve said is, you know, we're whatever it is. What's the theme of our community? Because we're out here really far from everything. And it's felt particularly poignant this last month. So I think maybe to kind of connect a couple dots there, it sounds like really investing in the outreach.
2:03:09 That's associated with significant major initiatives that we're doing. I mean, the ESECCRP is a huge, but rather than just doing the formal press release and this and that and the other, but to do some things to really make it human, community-centric and get the community really involved, a fair summary of that. Sure, yeah. Amanda? I kind of capture that and say, really, it's a creative engagement process. Right. I think what Amanda was getting at is more as a family-focused and kids' activities.
2:03:48 I feel like that's what Chris is talking about, is having local events to get messages across, but I'm talking about, you know.
2:04:21 Let's say like the CRC is having, you know, like family night once a month and, you know, setting up carnival games and families can go to an event that is not centered around drinking where you can make friends and, you know, there are different, there are different activities in our community like peapods for new families, meeting other people, but I just, and I know there's like seniors, donuts for seniors on.
2:04:49 Certain Sundays of the month. But I just feel that our town could use some more activities to, you know, support each other and build relationships. I think that's different than that directed engagement related to an action. Absolutely. Totally agree. Yes, and. But they have a different tone. And can I piggyback on that and say the idea of an ice cream?
2:05:15 And Trek is, like, so great. Like, we have these workshops, and they're here, and they're dry, and there's nothing drawing anybody here. Like, if we had, like, remember when the vaccination clinic had, like, tacos, you know? Like, this brings people to an event, and we're really bad at trying to draw people into being engaged in our initiatives because they're all, I mean, sorry, like, I'm sweet tea, but I'm kind of dry in here.
2:05:44 So a less formal council outreach. Yeah. Yeah, it's the council formal. The council gets into their problem. Well, we won't all go. Just Chris and Sarah can go have ice cream. We could all just stand 15 feet apart and then, you know, be all right, right? Okay, well, you've got, Dan, I think you're hearing. Okay, Bill, do you have anything else? Do you have anything on A at all? Yeah, John, I agree with you completely. The one note that I wrote before we started this meeting was recovery from winter.
2:06:20 John, one thing I'd say is
2:06:55 I see that fitting under more under environment and municipal services and programs. Which? Your point about, you know, how are we going to recover from? Well, I think I'm looking at, I think it's going to transcend everything. It kind of goes under everything, so maybe it's... Well, I just, I mean, community is, I mean, theme about touching community. I mean, we can put it where we want to put it. I think we all know it's going to...
2:07:28 It's going to affect everything. It's going to be a part of everything. I don't care where it goes. Okay, the only thing I would add in addition to that, wherever that ends up going, is to review and amend the quality of life ordinance and the business tax certificate program for nightly rentals, including the van life program. And again, Dan, there's another place to put that, but I think we need to make sure that that's listed here somewhere. Is that okay? Yeah, definitely. It may be specific.
2:08:08 I don't know. I'll leave it. Does it already fit under one? I'd like it on there. I think that it's kind of its own point. The Housing Now initiative is there, but this is something that is not necessarily included in that. I mean, we can assume that it's in there, but I'm not comfortable saying that we should. I think we've got some real issues with that. Say about assumptions, so I agree. We should be very clear that that needs to be addressed. Okay. So I think there's consensus.
2:08:43 And I would also ask, if there's something on here that really isn't a priority, take it off. We're okay with that. We try to narrow this down. There's only one other question on this, Dan, which is for the enhanced transit opportunities. I'm just concerned that the walk-bike-ride plan is, we don't need to do another planning initiative for this. We have a plan, so let's not read this up. I'm trying to capture that with the walking-biking community of how we bring this. We know we have specific issues in the community.
2:09:20 We got a plan. We don't need a plan. We just have a plan. Okay. Okay, good. All right. I don't know that that couldn't just enhance transit opportunity safety and can cut it off. The city of all the others because part of that program. Yeah, we could do that. If you just want to mention walk, bike, ride is, you know, that covers the whole thing. So we saved you some words. We saved some ink. Okay. Is there any public comment on item A, strategic priority community? Let's move on then to strategic priority B, economy. And Amanda, I'm sorry to put you.
2:10:07 Okay. Well, I guess the thing that I see that's missing on here for me is, you know, requiring a percentage of new builds to have a certain percentage of affordable housing with them, you know, or raising the fees to make it more in line with the cost of building those units. Like the fair share requirement for new development. Is it on here somewhere else?
2:10:42 I guess I thought it'd be under the economy for like new developments. Do you have that listed somewhere, Dan? I think it's up above still. Yeah, that could drop into there. Did I put it? Is it somewhere else? I missed it. It's under investing in community, under housing, that aren't privatized. That could drop into there. I see it on page two, under economic development, the economy, fair share requirement for new development. Yeah, as I know that prior to 2015, didn't we require like 10%?
2:11:28 of a bill to have affordable units? There was an inclusionary housing requirement to the extent that we had and it didn't build projects to do that. So the challenge on those has always been you can acquire, which is fine, if you're not getting the bills out of it, you're not really benefiting either. But we can definitely, I think that idea of the fair share issue is very valid to look at. How is development paying for its fair share of the impact? I think that's a very valid. Okay. Well, good. Just since these are our priorities, this wouldn't really...
2:12:23 And would that come forward as part of a diff discussion? Part of it isn't a diff, definitely, but I think there's some other elements as being in zoning.
2:13:23 There may be some other pieces to look at. All right. There's one definitely. That's just an impact fee study. There's other things we look at. Classic one would be, do we need to review snow storage capacity on development? Okay, again, we're getting complaints that people cannot hear. But this is coming from the live stream. This may be a technical thing. I don't know if the live stream is different from watching it on Zoom. I've heard that Zoom is fine, so maybe it's the live stream. Maybe it's the live stream. So, Dan, maybe whoever's in charge of...
2:13:58 Technical issues with the live stream. Maybe we could look into that. I mean, we'll talk loud and talk into this thing, but maybe there's something going on with the live stream. Online with the live stream, but not Zoom. I think your microphone just has to be close to you. Okay, well, I'll try to get some details on people who are, we'll see what's going on there. Okay, so, Amanda, you're good then for B? I think so. I'll look over my notes again and see. Do you guys think it warrants a bullet point on here to talk about?
2:14:42 Measure A and TBID. I'm going to get to TBID in a second, but be a little more specific. I think that we need to have a conversation about Measure A allocations, TBID, and whether or not MLT is going to be able to live on one or the other or continue to get both. Yeah, and I think I've got a note about that. I've noticed that TBID is missing on here. So I think a discussion around TBID and TBID approval.
2:15:12 In different days of when that's coming up, I think we could roll that up into that. Is that on just the agenda, though, and not like our strategic priority? Because I agree with you. Well, in order for us to enact something, it's a policy. It's got to be on here? Well, it's a policy question. It's a policy question. So we would have to debate that. Something would need to come forward to us. My understanding is that the TBID renewal will come to us as part of our budget process this year. So I think if that's something that we need to be taught, that needs to be part of that policy discussion.
2:15:42 I think that that needs to be part of our strategic priorities because it comes forward and we're going to have time to talk about it and give our opinions on all of it. So I don't know that it needs to be added with any specificity, goals, just a natural occurrence. Okay, but I want to just follow up a little bit with what Amanda and Sarah are talking about. There's been a lot of discussion about when that actually is going to come in front of council. Dan and I talked about this this morning. I was a little surprised here it's going to be coming forward in March.
2:16:20 I don't know, April? So, again, we don't need to get into this now, but there are questions raised in conversations with the chamber about, is the air subsidy going to be in the T-bid? Is it not going to be in the T-bid? There's not been any follow-up on this, so I think it doesn't have to be necessarily a strategic priority, but I want to point out to everybody that this is a very big question. We've got at least three members of the council here are very interested in having that policy discussion. So, Dan, as you bring this thing forward,
2:16:51 I think it's important to be council members have an interest in this. And there may be some unresolved questions that need to be. And I know you're already in the process of gathering the votes and doing all that. But again, there are some outstanding questions that I think it will be good if we need to have that meeting like we had before with the chamber, with you, that we did that. Well, remember, we had a meeting over in the Mono County offices. There was a point in the T-Bit, there were questions from council that are still outstanding. We can talk about this offline.
2:17:25 I think we need to, we cannot overlook the importance of this item in this discussion, whether it doesn't have to be a strategic priority, but it's going to be a couple of items. Yeah. All right. So is there anything else for you on that one? We're good there. Chris B. Yeah, under economy. And, you know, the thing that I was most interested in was the, not the most interested, but I wanted to make sure the regional and local air service was in there. It was originally.
2:18:00 Under environmental. So there's two parts to it, really, right? It's just what's the right size, and then how do we pay for it? There's two parts to that question. Right, and we've got developed regional partnerships to define service levels and funding for regional local air service, and progress, you know, there's things happening with the Miwog and other things, but there's a relationship between that. Right. They all kind of come together, so I think if we keep it high level enough to say to Dan, Dan, we've got to get in, we've got to figure all this out. Yeah.
2:18:30 Fair enough. I just want to make sure when you see B2 that that to you communicates MWOG, T-BID, all of it. Absolutely. That's why I made a note about the T-BID just to make sure that it's all going to be part of a policy discussion. A question I have about engage with partners on amenity improvements on federal lands. We hear about this a lot and I heard John Urdi talking about when are there going to be more bathrooms in the Lakes Basin.
2:19:04 I really think that we need to have that, you know, sort of conversation of, you know, how much does the town of Mammoth Lakes have to, you know, take care of things that are on federal lands? I mean, I think that conversation needs to happen and we need to push a little bit harder on our federal partners because we can't do everything. We're this small town and, you know, we have crises and urgent situations.
2:19:34 I just feel like that, you know, I'm glad it's there, and I think it's an urgent need for this town. Okay, good. Well, it's right there, so that's good. Okay. Okay. Any public comment on B or any discussion related to B? Okay. Oh, one, sorry. One last one on, I don't know where it goes. Cell service improvements. I didn't see it on there anywhere. Yeah, it is. Okay. Broadband, small business development, infrastructure, project, and back.
2:20:26 So we're assuming cell falls under there? Yeah. Okay. I mean, the cell tower stuff is we actually don't control that. So we can't say thou shalt build one or something of that nature. Where we do get into it, and it's important to bring forward because we've had that challenge just recently with Verizon. Often when we bring, actually we don't, but when the companies bring those forward, you always end up in a very significant neighborhood discussion about the location or not locating.
2:20:58 So just a heads up for that one, because we don't force that. We do allow for approval process, but it is a community approval process, if you will, that we go through. And so we do have at least two areas where preliminary requests have been looking at potential cell tower locations. One of them in the Sierra Business Park and one of them. So as those come forward, we can work them through the process.
2:21:29 As a priority, you know, to hear them and listen, yes, but you have a, you don't want their quasi-judicial decisions and planning, so you want to be understanding, you're going to look at everything that comes forward to you and take it through that process. Dan, and it doesn't belong on strategic priorities, but since we've gone down this hole already, I would love to see at some point in the future for us to get Verizon and AT&T in here, a representative, to talk to us about their redundancy.
2:21:59 I would love to see that.
2:22:34 And I appreciate, Bill, yeah, it doesn't have to be like a strategic priority, and yet, it's the number one thing I hear from people. They call me, my cell phone's not working, I'm like, well, it's a long conversation, but I think we need to educate the community also. Because it's a black eye for us, you know, people are just tired of it. Sorry. For sure, but that's why having the companies come in, that's the right solution, for sure. Okay.
2:23:11 Well, thank you all for that. My only concern on this one was these questions about the T-bid renewal. We talked about that. Okay, so let's move on to C. And Amanda, anything you got for C? I guess possibly adding, you know, like focusing on sustainable development. And, you know, I know Mammoth Water Department was pushing for artificial or synthetic grass to replace lawns to cut back on water.
2:23:43 And we did receive a letter from someone kind of bringing up the negative things about artificial grass. So, you know, maybe focusing on water-wise things, ways to do new developments and things and, you know, incentivizing people to put the environment, you know, higher on the list when working on developments. Okay. Sarah, anything you want to add?
2:24:21 I don't think I have really anything. I just want to talk about something that's a little amorphous, but in this town, we need to create a culture of preparedness. So whether it's wildfire, you know, there's much you can do to harden your home. And there's been a great series of, you know, fire town halls that Stacey Corliss and I think Alice was there, you know, many summers ago.
2:25:01 The Mono County had a great series that was on Monday nights. I don't know how well attended it was, but I think we need people here to understand that we have to be responsible for our own properties and do the maintenance, whether that's limbing or taking down trees. I mean, we all love trees, but sometimes that can be a great hazard. I think Matt expressed his challenges that he faces with the community.
2:25:31 Matt Perlow from SCE about why sometimes you have to take out a tree or limit back substantially for safety in terms of fire. So I was just going to talk about wildfire and now here we are with weather preparation. So the same thing is going to happen to go for us in the winter. But I think that's something that we as a community need.
2:25:57 And I think we have to name it so that we can have programs. So I'm seeing number two and number four. What's number four? Engage in long-term forest health projects such as ESCC. That says three. And that's different because ESCCFP is where we're going to fund a program. Hang on one second. I'll make sure I'm not losing my mind. I'm looking at number C. Letter C? Yeah. Two and three. Oh, I see what's happening. And four is blank. Never mind. I noted four on sustainable development.
2:26:29 I think part of that whole process of that development can definitely be how do you take, especially new development coming forward as well as existing with the idea of you're building in that. We have codes adopted for that element of CPOS. So a lot of that's in the codes. I think how do you push that, especially after existing versus maybe some of that goes together. I think it does tie into sustainability. It ties into resiliency for how do we get that, yes, requiring us of new, but existing.
2:27:11 Now, how do we do that? The fire department has some programs and others on the interface to really enhance induction of fire. Some of that's built in, again, at a stronger times. I think, Dan, that we can build in a lot of what she's talking about by changing three to, say, engage in long-term forest health and fire-safe projects and dumping such as ESCCRP because that takes people down a specific path and direction. This would allow us, then, to do partnerships with the...
2:27:49 With the fire department and everybody else on local fire safe. And that is drowning at the moment. That is a critical need for us. So I think that that change may well rise out that statement, right? Yeah, and just there's a subtlety here. One thing that we're doing is we're doing the things, right? But the other is how do we bring our community along on this journey so that...
2:28:18 We aren't seeing, you know, on social media. Like, why isn't Town doing something? You know, there's a certain amount of personal responsibility as well, and we want to... And that's an interesting statement. In the break, I was talking with some of the others in the room. Stu does a great job of putting everything we do on social media, yet on my feed I don't see it because I don't go and look at it specifically. People aren't sharing it. So why is it when somebody else says...
2:28:50 My God, we got to fire this person or we got to do this or that. The negative things, it gets shared a million times and it keeps showing on my feet over. How do we get people, when they look at the stuff that we put out as a town, to then share it and appreciate it? Because that's, to me, that's the way social media works. That's how everybody ends up. Just putting it on there doesn't seem to have the effect we need. I don't know what the solution is to that. But again, we were having a conversation. How do you then put it out so that people...
2:29:22 The solution is to have a social media professional, Stu, no offense, you know, like we have a zillion dollar social media arm for this community who are social media professionals. We do not have someone who is a social media professional working for the town of Mammoth Lakes. So they, Stu doesn't know how to game the algorithm so that our
2:29:50 Message gets shared. We're not doing it right. Well, I would also say that unfortunately we are all depending on social media. People click on negative things. They don't want to engage with positive things. So if that's the case, then what I'm saying is we need to get outside and get into the community and talk to people and have events and, you know.
2:30:14 Maybe we have a model home. I think ESC CRP is working on this where we say, okay, like my house was a disaster last summer and I finally had a tree company come and really do a good job getting everything away and now we have snowmageddon. But so the point is that we can't rely on just one thing and we as a community meet and it starts with us and the staff that we need to tell people like,
2:30:44 You know, when you explain to people why things are the way they are, they understand, but they're not going to come here and they're not going to look at our good announcements. So we have to find a way to get people engaged. And I think we're getting a little off topic here, but I think we're also getting into the question of culture versus policy. And there's an old adage, you know, culture eats policy for breakfast every morning and every day.
2:31:14 And I think that's something for all of us to be mindful of. I mean, we're sort of in the policy business up here, and we're making policy. Issues about culture and community, extremely important, extremely powerful. Governments, it's a larger question. It's a question that perhaps is not.
2:31:33 You can say that culture eats policy for breakfast, but the truth of the matter is, like, what good is your policy if the culture is fighting you every step of the way? So I'll leave it at that, but I feel strongly about this. Okay. All right, well, let's move on then to, actually, Bill, why don't you go ahead for number C? No, C. Strategic Priority Climate Environment. You're good? Okay, so my thought on this is, I would like to change the title of this, or include in your statement, Dan, to be Climate Change and Environment.
2:32:08 I think that there's a number of tactical reasons to be doing that. We talked about resilience, all the money that's coming out of the state and the feds. And I think that that has a nice, big, broader net for all that. And I would like to propose that we really use this as a way to really start integrating issues of climate change, resilience, mitigation, adaptation into everything that we do. It's a high-level thing, but it's a way to start to cascade and permeate that through all the different activities.
2:32:52 Okay. I'll bring you a couple drinks. I mean, I think, again, in talking, looking at what we're dealing with here, going well. Okay, so let's move on then to strategic propriety D, municipal services and programs. I don't think I have anything to add at this moment. Okay. Sarah? Under this, or are we moving it to community? Well, that's, let me, what do you think, I mean, if,
2:33:38 We're talking about the town doing it. So if the town is going to do it with some ideas you're bringing to it, I think maybe it belongs here because town, do it, do it right. Does that make a sense? Because then we own it. Chris? I don't have anything to add to this section. Okay, Bill? No, John, for now I'm fine with it. Okay, my only thoughts are for number one.
2:34:15 Is rather than plan for leadership transitions to complete staff leadership transitions. John, you're right. However, instead of saying leadership transitions, the town should have a policy for how we go from one to the other, not just. There it is. Secession planning. I think that that is our way to call it out. It is now to create. Let's do kind of a yes and, you know, a policy for secession planning to be implemented as part of immediate needs.
2:35:06 I think your balance on that is a lot of succession planning. If the staff's leveled down succession planning, it should be a priority for we're going to push it a little different. But I hear what you're saying, Bill. How do we get the knowledge from the plan? That's a three-month overlap. Yeah, I think that's because we don't have it. We're going to be kind of next year. And it should be ongoing because that's just something that should always be in our priorities, that we're thinking about the future.
2:36:08 Sometimes people leave abruptly. So you, you know, it's just something that I think should be in our culture that most boards have. So I agree. Yeah, but sometimes it's just more. Okay. So I think we've gone through all four of these. My last, I had a sort of a question, Dan, generally speaking about the major projects engagements that are going on. Main Lodge redevelopment, the Resmetter Road.
2:36:41 Things like that. Should we assume that those are just in the regular staff work? Most of those will have a legal process and a planning process where they have to come forward in certain ways. So the fact that you want to talk about them is fine, but I don't think the priority of those are driven differently by the legal process as much as they are for a desire to see those ideas.
2:37:14 Elements that way. So I'd be a little cautious how you set those in there because it's something that will come to you that you don't have overall control over on the front end of it. I just wanted to bring it up as something to make sure because we have some major projects coming up here. So, okay. All right. Is there any public comment? Anything we missed? Yes? No? Okay. Anything you want to delete? Missed? This is going off to the presses. There's nothing out in the public, I'm assuming, Jamie. Okay.
2:37:43 So let's move on then to the final item with this, which is the short-term vision statement. And I had a thought on this. Does anybody have any thoughts on this one? I just think it would make sense to add, rather than just investing for the items listed, but investing for recovery and resilience, colon, because that gets recovery up to that high-level thing, and also bringing in the idea of resilience and all this, because that's something I think informs everything we're going to be doing.
2:38:16 Yeah, I think that that's probably a good idea, John. If I have to choose between the two examples, given I'm going with number two and adding that in. But with those comments, see what staff brings back to us. Which two examples? You mean? There are two examples in here. One is investing in the sustainability and resilience of the greater Mammoth Lakes community, and the other is investing for community prosperity, vibrancy, and stewardship. Right. The first one was last year's.
2:38:44 Correct. Yeah, what I'm proposing, Bill, is in the second one in the middle of the page is to add. It says investing for and then add recovery and resilience colon and then list those things. I think it's very important that we put recovery from this event in next year's plan. Absolutely. Okay. The way to capture recovery then that actually permeates through every one of these versus calling out it.
2:39:13 And there has been some tweaks, and this other one was divine.
2:39:43 Thank you. Thank you.
2:40:10 But I do like the idea of that recovery of resiliency because I think that's going to have to guide us through this, though, not a one and done, if you will, because it's something that we have to build into our community. So I kind of like the thoughts. We can play with that. Please think about it as well as we come back. This really should ultimately then kind of go through all this and all that should point to, hey, if all this is achieved, so is that vision. And ultimately this ties back into the broader general plan vision as well. Okay. So, Dan, do you have what you need from us?
2:40:40 Yeah, I think we can craft up another, as we come back, more of a draft document, but again, still draft. You can wordsmith it. You can change it. You can add to it. Our goal is try to get it back down to a page without using an eight-point font. If we can't, that's fine. We'll go to two or do something else. But I find it very beneficial to have that one document that you can look at and go, yeah, this stuff ties to this. Yes, that was a comment made. That's why we're going out and having ice cream.
2:41:11 I'm going to hold you to that one. Not that, you know, we overdo suites. Okay, well, so I think we're good. Everybody's happy? We stay with the general plan vision statement from 07. That is part, that's in our adopted general plan. We've been leaving it on there as an overall broad long-term vision statement. We don't have to. We didn't have it on. No, we should. I think we should. I just wanted to see because it could, you could fit more if you could. Thanks.
2:41:43 Okay, well, good. Thank you all very much. Jamie, I did get from folks in the audience who think they can't hear things. It is the live stream that's difficult to hear. That's one that they can't hear, but it sounds like the Zoom and everything else is okay. So, yep. All right, so now we are going to move into closed session. If I may have the closed session, the one relating to the conference on the town manager, we can remove that item. Okay.
2:42:13 We had some items coming back from the past one that are not ready, so we'd like to go into the one with the conference just with the labor negotiations. Okay, so this is item 5.2, pursuant to government code 54957.6.a. Conference with labor negotiators, the council will meet with its representatives, Town Manager Daniel C. Holler, Administrative Services Finance Director Rob Patterson, and HR Manager Amanda Pelham. With respect to the following employee organizations,
2:42:39 Mammoth Lakes General Employees Association, Mammoth Lakes Management Employees Association, and the Mammoth Lakes Public Works Employees Association. And I'd like to add Sandra Boberly to the negotiation. She's been at the meetings. Have you told her, does she know that you're making this request? Yeah, okay. She's saying yes. Okay, good. All right, well, thank you. So we're going to stay here? Yeah, we can stay here. Andy had another commitment tonight that way. He was on for a little bit this evening, but he had another commitment in trucking, so he will not be joining us. Okay, great.
2:43:10 Thank you. It's been a long day.