TransparentMammoth

Mammoth Lakes Recreation · 2021

Mammoth Lakes Recreation

at 17:00

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

197 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 Good afternoon, everyone. Welcome to the August 3rd Mammoth Lakes Recreation Board of Directors Special Meeting. I've got 5.01 p.m. and Jamie, if we could do roll call, we'll get started. Sure. President Albright? Here. Treasurer Schaubmeyer? Here. Secretary Bankson? Here. Board Member Souser?

0:31 Present. Board Member Fernie? Here. And Board Member Wasserman is absent. All right. Thank you so much. And first up is public comments. Jamie, do we have anyone there in Suite Z? I know we also received a public comment via email. But how are we doing there? We do not have anyone in Suite Z. Okay.

0:59 And I received a public comment. And let me read that for you. Let me pull it up real quick. And this public comment is from Stacey Corliss. And it reads, Dear MLR Board President Albright and board members, I can't attend tonight's board meeting, so...

1:27 I'm emailing this quick note of appreciation for MLR's work towards sustainable recreation in Mammoth Lakes and Mono County. MLR's adopted trail and other programs give residents and visitors a way to contribute directly to the stewardship of our public lands at a time when these places need it most. Additionally, MLR's role in the Camp Like a Pro program,

1:56 or campaign has made it a success. I've heard from land managers and residents that this is that this collaborative effort is making a positive difference on the ground. It wouldn't work without a community nonprofit partner. Many thanks to you and all and to program director Kim and a solar. I always hack that. Anna Clario.

2:26 Anna Clario, Anna Clario, it's easy. For your commitment to sustainable recreation. Sincerely, Stacey Corliss. Good job, Kim. That is encouraging because that's what we're kind of all about. So it's nice to be recognized by Mono County Supervisor.

2:57 So great job, Kim. Thank you. And so we will go on to item three, consent agenda. Two items on the consent agenda. 3.1 is approved minutes from the May 11th, 2021 special board meeting. And there was an attachment in your packet with those minutes. And 3.2 approved the minutes of the May 26th.

3:26 2021 special meeting and again with an attachment in your packet. Any discussion on those items? And no. So I would entertain a motion to approve the consent agenda. Move to approve. I will second. Moved by board member Souser and seconded by Anxin.

4:01 And all those in favor. Aye. Oh, I have to do a roll call. That's right. Sorry. Different type of board meeting. I've been doing too many of these lately. Anyway, could I have a roll call on that? Sure. President Albright? Yes. Treasurer Schaubmeyer? Yes. Secretary Bankson? Yes. Board Member Souser? Yes. Board Member Fernie? Yes.

4:33 Passes 5-0. Thanks, team. And on to Section 4-1, reports. And we have Council Member John Wentworth with us, giving a report on the SRTI, which is the Sustainable Recreation and Tourism Initiative. Take it away, John. Thank you very much, Craig, and members of the board.

5:02 I'm going to share my screen and walk you what I hope through will be somewhat of an edifying presentation and more than happy to answer any questions when we get to the end as we proceed here. So this is an update on the Sustainable Recreation and Tourism Initiative that's been going on in the region here for almost a couple of years at this point. We start all of these

5:32 items off with a land acknowledgement, which I'll share with you this evening. Public lands in the United States hold the recreation stories, burial grounds, and ceremonies of indigenous people who were killed or are forcibly removed from their ancestral homes during territorial acquisition. Many tribes comprised of different bands live in the eastern Sierra region, caring for their native lands as they coexist with the ongoing impacts of colonization.

5:56 Past or present tribes and bands associated with the region that this effort is aware of include, but are not limited to, the Miwok, the Mono Lake Kizetika, the Monomanash, Numu, Paiot, the Newe, Shoshone, the Timbisha, Utu-Utu-Guatu-Paiot, and the Washoe. Two Numu terms describe the region and provide important context to ideas offered in this presentation. The first is Pemadu-Twayabi, the Western Mountains, and the other more widely known place name is Payanadu.

6:25 The place where water flows. This acknowledgement is an invitation to all organizations, residents, and visitors to recognize the way this history has shaped the present as all parties work together in anticipation of a better future. So thank you for that. This SRTI is a product of the Eastern Sierra Sustainable Recreation Partnership, of which some of you may be aware. This is an effort supported by the Washington Office of the Forest Service and the Sustainable Recreation Tourism Initiative.

6:55 is a grant from the Sierra Nevada Conservancy through Prop 68 to support the efforts of the ESSRP. The grant was awarded back in March of 2019, so about $620,000. As I mentioned, Prop 68 and the Sierra Nevada Conservancy are behind this. It was awarded to the town of Mammoth Lakes on behalf of the regional partners. This was because something called the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments, which is now a joint...

7:21 powers authority did not exist at the time. So just underline the need to get that joint powers authority established and set up, which it is now. And everybody in the region is very grateful to the town for being willing to administer the grant and work got started and all this on July 1st, 2019, which is, I guess, yeah, it's about two years ago. What do you know?

7:46 Here's a sense of the geography of this effort. It encompasses the entire Eastern Sierra region, three counties, five national park units, two national forests, BLM lands, LEDWP lands. So it really is the entire geography of the entire Eastern Sierra. A number of folks have been working on this, including High Bar Consulting, which is a guy named Michael Ward, who's been the lead facilitator for a lot of the public meetings.

8:12 PlaceWorks at ICF, worked on the Climate Adaptation Resilience Assessment. I'll give you some more details on them in a second. A guy named Carl Roboto, who some of you may be familiar with, was the lead facilitator for the Visitor Connection Track, and MLTPA has done a lot of the project management work and done the final grant supporting and has provided staff support for all the tracks. And Council, sorry, Craig Albright is correct. I am a member of the Mammoth Lakes Town Council, but I'm here this evening as a volunteer board president with MLTPA.

8:42 Just so we're all clear about which hats we do or do not have on. The SRTI has four tracks. The recreation stakeholders, climate, visitor audience, projects and funding. I'm going to keep a little bit of detail and walk you through all that. And here's the standard support for these various four tracks. You can see that three of them are completed. And we're in the final stretch on the final one, which is projects and funding. And a lot of very interesting, exciting developments are popping up daily, it seems.

9:10 This effort obviously started off in the analog environment. Two years ago, there was no COVID. We started off with kickoff meetings. This was down in Bishop.

9:20 The Talmud Pavilion was a great way to get things started, but we were able to successfully move this entire effort virtually. It's actually proved to be more, probably a bit more effective, a little bit more efficient. We gathered an enormous amount of public output. It made it a lot easier for people throughout the region to participate because people didn't have to drive all over the place. So that was actually a little bit of a blessing in disguise. The Recreation Stakeholder Track,

9:47 There was a series of efforts to reach out to stakeholders in the region to identify ideas for sustainable recreation projects. And this is entirely consistent with what Craig read from Supervisor Corliss.

9:59 Sustainable recreation. That's the mantra for all this work going forward. And we collected about 183 project ideas, which is way more than we thought. We originally thought we would be going to individual communities throughout the region, and we thought maybe we'd get 10 or 15 per meeting, but doing it virtually, it really upped the count in terms of how many ideas got submitted. And then all these ideas were scored. They weren't ranked, or what's the best one, or who's the prettiest one, and that kind of stuff. It was

10:27 Scoring them for their alignment with stewardship, access and equity, and benefits to local communities. This scoring was done internally because we're obviously getting ready to seek funding for all these projects, and it's a good way to kind of keep track of where things lie and where they stand. One of the projects, one of many, was something like the

10:50 Dispersed camping effort, the Camp Like a Pro effort, which we've all heard a lot about this summer. These are the types of ideas that came in through this effort. And the Camp Like a Pro, hats off to Monroe County for taking the leadership role in this and getting this thing up and running. It's been very successful this summer. There's been a lot of engagement, a lot of folks from the region throughout, really impressed by the program. And a lot of, we had an ESSRP meeting yesterday and all the public land management agencies were very impressed and very happy that such a thing exists.

11:18 So this track, again, it's done, completed back in February. The next one is the Climate Adaptation and Resilience Assessment, which again, this is a...

11:31 deep dive and a hard look at climate change mitigation and responses in our region. And again, it's the same study area, three counties, five national parks, two national forests, BLM, all the rest of it. And one of the key differentiating things about this was a valuation of ecosystem services in the region. This was done by a group called ICF, a team of very...

11:55 Very skilled economists, and they estimate that the ecosystem services coming out of the Eastern Sierra averages about $100 billion a year. Now, that's not bad for a landscape that's mostly rocks and bushes with some trees and some other things, but $100 billion a year in ecosystem services is a pretty impressive number. Most of that's coming from water and from carbon sequestration, but I think for all the elected folks in the region to be able to take that to Sacramento and say, look,

12:24 These kinds of numbers are coming out of this region. Let's really talk about long-term investments. And the climate work itself was done by a group called PlaceWorks. PlaceWorks was responsible for the California Adaptation Planning Guide. So they really are the leading professional capacity to work on these types of things. And we're very pleased with the results and what came out of all that.

12:45 So that work is done. It's up on the MLTPA website, and you can see the URLs there. And Kim, if we want to share out some of these links later, we can certainly do that later on. People can take a look at all this stuff. The visitor audience track, this was completed again back in February. This was a gathering of all those organizations that have frontline engagement with the visitor audience that comes up here.

13:07 And they put together a series of components of an outreach and connection program that's rooted in sustainable recreation and stewardship. And how do we really work with this multi-million person audience comes up here every year to start to inculcate and make them stewards of this region as much as we all want to be stewards of this region. So they identified some themes to the messaging, memory, tradition, connection, escape, adventure, surprise.

13:34 And then did a lot of work to align how those themes align with the imagery and the iconic images that come out of this place every day. Am I still here? Did I freeze? Am I still with you guys? You're all good. Yep, okay, good, sorry. To align these themes with the images and how we, certainly things like Instagram and social media, this region is being messaged hourly. And how do we start working on doing that in a way that's going to emphasize sustainable recreation and stewardship?

14:03 And all of this is framed by a series of guiding principles. And it's wrapped up in a package called the Visitor Connection Package. And again, if you've been interested in taking a look at that, we'll get you the links to that. You can take a look at this stuff. And this is the group. So it's DMOs, NGOs, tribes, folks from all over the region, north to south, that made up this working group. It was a very exciting effort. And we all had a really good time working on this thing.

14:32 So this visitor connection package is now ready and it's available. And again, if you want to take a look at it, that's ready. So we're now moving into the final effort, which is to aggregate these project ideas and to look at what funding is currently out there and figure out how we can start lining this up with funding opportunities to get some of these ideas implemented on the ground.

14:55 There's a very basic process for how this is going to work, which is to fundamentally take the ideas that came in either through the various tracks or through the recreation stakeholders, roll these up, align them with funding opportunities, looking for the best available funding opportunities in this moment, and then this will roll up into eight different projects that are going to be submitted for funding opportunities, again, based on what is the best available funding in the moment that we're in right now. So again, we start with the ideas.

15:22 go through these filters, go from desirability to feasibility, line it up with the funding opportunities in front of us, and these become what will be final, these final eight projects of the SRTEI portfolio of projects. And you can see, again, these are the sources of the project ideas. It goes through these various filters, ends up in these various project ideas.

15:45 And then what we're really focusing on now is identifying where is the best funding that's out there. There's enormous, enormous amounts of money in the state of California budget, in the federal budget. I know you're all tracking what's going on with the bipartisan infrastructure bill and the reconciliation bill. I mean, this is trillions of dollars. Not all that's going to be available for our work, but a couple hundred million trickles down. It's going to be a very big deal for all of us in this region. And take these eight project summaries.

16:14 align them with the identified funding applicants, and then prepare these and work with the funding applicants to prepare their grant applications for submission. This is all being guided by a prospectus that the partnership that ESSRP has put together that will inform a 10-year investment horizon for investment for sustainable recreation infrastructure programs, mitigation.

16:38 efforts for climate change that guide, that will guide that partnership for the next decade at least, if not longer. So there's a long-term view and then there's this immediate short-term view of getting, identifying funding applications, getting grants written for the things we can do in the present moment. So again, all these different project ideas, they get rolled up through these filters to identify those final eight projects for the portfolio. Those become one of eight SRTI projects.

17:03 They're then submitted through one of the sponsoring agencies for funding. And I just threw this in because this is an example of what's happening. We just, in the last couple of weeks, the National Fish and Wildlife Foundation worked with LADWP, put out an RFP for a grant for a million dollars for funding through a partnership with LADWP, the Indian National Forest and NIFWF to get some work done down in the buttermilk region.

17:28 Very quick turnaround. The grant's actually due on Thursday, but between the SCOG and the SRTI team, it was identified this is something we needed to move on because it's money that's specifically targeted at opportunities, recreation opportunities in the Eastern Sierra. And so you can see this is a rough map, rough map of the project area. This sort of kidney-shaped thing in red is the buttermilk boulding area, but the grant application is focused on

17:53 All this area in black, where you've got all kinds of recreation happening up in Pine Creek, the Happy and the Sads, the Tungsten Hills, all of it, there's no sense of who's doing what, where, and the idea is to do some conceptual recreation planning out there to figure out what infrastructure is needed, how can it be organized to benefit the key watershed, which is that outline in blue, that's part of the watershed of LEDWP, and they obviously have an interest in keeping that watershed healthy.

18:21 A lot of the money that was put up for this grant opportunity has to do with fire and fuels work. And I'm sure you're also aware that the ESCOG was awarded about almost a $3.5 million grant to set up a NEPA team to start doing environmental work for all the fire and fuel work as well as the recreation work. So that's exciting. That's something that's been keeping us all on our toes the last couple of weeks.

18:46 The entire project is on budget. It's about $70,000 worth of volunteer hours. I think it's probably getting closer to 80, 90 at this point, plus cash donations to help out with some of the environmental work and the climate work. And you guys, you can see the very august list of other agencies have gotten this presentation.

19:06 You are not last, and you certainly are least. You're just, you're on that list. So it's been good to get this out to everybody, just to make sure everybody in the region is generally on the same page, a general understanding of what's going on here as things move forward. A couple other things on the side that should be of interest to all of us.

19:24 The ESCOG, Eastern Sierra Council of Governments, which is a joint powers of authority, the next meeting for that group is coming up August 13th. As I mentioned, they received a pretty interesting grant from the California Department of Fish and Wildlife to establish this. Now, this looks kind of crazy, but those of you who can navigate org charts can get this. This is to establish this Eastern Sierra Pace and Scale Accelerator. This is to do NEPA work for ecosystem health. This is all about fire and fuels.

19:52 and to do sustainable recreation work. The Inyo National Forest, you've heard this time and time again, we don't have the capacity to do any environmental work. We can't do any NEPA. We can't make anything happen. Leslie Yen, the new forest supervisor, is committed to doing third-party NEPA.

20:07 And now there's a three and a half million dollar grant to establish an independent ID team to start getting that NEPA work done so we can get projects done on the ground. This is obviously going to be very helpful for the fire and fuels work, but for projects in and around Mammoth Lakes, while the work that Joel's working on, he's going to have access maybe to this team, but while the regular Forest Service staff is working on the fire and fuel stuff, Joel can maybe finally get access to the regular staff of archaeologists and all just to get NEPA work done, to get things approved so we can get infrastructure built up here in Mammoth Lakes.

20:36 And again, it was about a $3.4 million grant. It was a pretty big deal. The ESCOG has only been in joint powers, I think, for less of a year. So it's pretty interesting to see this type of funding starting to roll in. And the first project for that grant is going to be something called Mammoth Donut Project. Are you guys all aware of this? I think Kim, Greg, you guys are aware. This is a 50,000 acre fuels treatment project that's going to happen all around the town of Mammoth Lakes.

21:04 And not only do they have money to do the NEPA work, they've got a $5 million directed grant from CAL FIRE to start doing some of the work on the ground. There's going to be a lot of work, a lot of interest having to do with biomass, what's going to happen, all the materials are going to be cleared up to save us from catastrophic wildfire. But from MLR's perspective, well, what happens to the recreation values while they're over here cutting all the trees down and clearing all the brush? What happens to the trails? Where are the opportunities for new trailheads?

21:34 Things like the biathlon that's been studied as part of this. How are all these things going to blend and work together? It's not just about fire and fuels for communities like ours. It's about blending all this stuff together and really defining what success looks like on the ground. Another interesting program is the Innovative Finance for National Forest Grant Program. This is a grant that MLTPA got.

21:54 And this is one of 10 grants awarded nationally that will produce a business plan to leverage outside resources to do campground improvements on the Indian National Forest. And this is, I spoke earlier about those recreation stakeholder project ideas. Improving campgrounds was consistently a big concern of a lot of people. And this is about putting together a business plan to figure out how to bring in funding and resources from downstream beneficiaries to make improvements in the campgrounds.

22:23 Because the Forest Service just doesn't have the resources to make this happen. And one of the things that's been very interesting out of that, they've done a lot of work. It's a group called Quantified Ventures. They've done a lot of work in Ohio and Colorado and other states. We've learned a lot from them. They've learned a lot from us. This is basically sort of our org chart here in the Eastern Sierras. We've got...

22:41 Eastern Sierra Partnership, the SCOG in the middle of it, the SCOG with that JPA can seek federal grants, it can go after state and federal funding, and we can bring all these things together to deliver real resources to this region to make some things, get some real projects, important things done on the ground. And Quantified Ventures just a couple weeks ago announced, I got about $3 million out of the governor's office to invest in the trail system in a sort of impoverished and hard hit.

23:06 Former coal town in rural Ohio. So they've got experience with this. We're working together. They've applied for a second round of funding. It's going to be announced in the next couple of weeks. We'll certainly keep you guys posted to see where that goes. And what's happening with the state of California? Well, the governor's established a new Forest Resilience Task Force. Our good friend, Stacey Corliss, who was all coincidental, she serves as part of the leading members of this task force. The task force...

23:36 Used to have a guy named Randy Moore, who I think you all know is now, used to be the head of Region 5. He's now the head of the entire U.S. Forest Service. He's someone that all of us have worked together very closely the last couple of years. He's now the head of the Forest Service. And Stacy is on this Forest Management Task Force in her role as the head of the RCRC. So there's a lot of interesting things happening in our region, in and around Mammoth Lakes.

23:59 All this is made possible by a shared stewardship agreement between the state of California and the federal government. This was just signed back about a year ago, August of last year, that provides a policy framework for the state and the federal government to work together. And the governor has been all in on biodiversity, 30 by 30, nature-based solutions for climate change.

24:19 There have been a number of very interesting regional workshops. I'm not sure if any of you guys attended these things. The last one, there was one on April 28th, and there was one just recently on July 27th. The state is being very ambitious, reaching out to rural areas such as ours, wanting to understand what kind of natural resources exist in these regions that are going to help be the solution to climate change.

24:40 It's taken a long time for the state of California to discover rural California, but they finally have articulated real interest and need to be out where we live and to really engage with us and to be able to say to the state, yeah, we have $100 billion a year in ecosystem services coming out of the eastern Sierra. That's going to get somebody's attention somewhere. This is going to be very important for all of us going forward. The state is also updating their climate adaptation strategy.

25:05 As we all know, California is leading the planet in the climate change program. And they're looking to nest existing efforts. Certainly the work that the SRTI has done is a great candidate to nest as part of the larger efforts going on throughout the state. It could be a replicable model for other rural regions. There's established a list of priorities. I won't go too deep into this, but there were two that kind of caught my eye, which is helping nature to adapt to climate change and accelerate nature-based solutions.

25:35 And to leverage resources for climate action through partnership and collaboration. I know they've updated these a little bit in the last month or so, but certainly leveraging resources through partnership and collaboration is what the Eastern Sierra is all about. Again, it's another one of these things that really primes us for success going forward. And this is kind of a trick question for you guys, because this was in the slide deck from the state, and I was in an audience of about 125 people, and I raised my hand and said,

26:01 Hey, just checking out, who of you folks here in Sacramento know what lake that is? And nobody had a clue. I know the MLR Board knows what lake that is. Back in the drought, there was really good ice skating on that lake. Yes, Craig, that is Lake Tanaya over in Yosemite National Park. Tamara, you're muted. You were going to say the same thing, right? Unmute yourself. I can't hear you.

26:31 Sorry, I said I was going to guess the same, but I wasn't sure. So thank you for clarifying. You're the people that talked about this stuff. And the point to the Sacramento folks was, look, it's okay to put pretty pictures of federal landscapes in your presentations on climate change. Where's your partnership? Where are you working with rural places and the gateway communities to make this place possible? We need to connect these dots. We need resources over here in the Eastern Sierra to help unlock all the amazing.

27:01 tools and solutions we've got through nature-based solutions. And again, on the financial side, the Great American Outdoors Act is signed. State of California has put together a budget. They've allocated billions and billions of dollars to climate change, to nature-based solutions, and all the rest of it. They still have not figured out exactly what they're going to spend the money on. This has been a source of ongoing frustration. But hopefully it happens through a process called trailer bills.

27:30 And hopefully they get that figured out in the coming weeks. And then, of course, there's this guy, President Joe Biden. It's one word. Remember, it's one word, Joe Biden. And he produced his American Rescue Plan, which was, that was almost a trillion dollars back to deal with COVID. That was analyzed by the National Association of Counties. And it was determined there's about $65 billion in flexible aid to every county in America. That includes Mono, Inyo, Alpine, the town of Mammoth Lakes.

27:58 And over 1.5 billion is going into over two years to those public land counties. Mammoth County is 90% public lands. Mammoth County is the same way. There's a lot of money in the machine that MLR should be able to access. We should all be able to access. And this is before we even get to the bipartisan infrastructure bill, which is being debated this week, which hopefully will pass, and the reconciliation bill, which is...

28:22 That's another two or three trillion dollars. There's an enormous amount of resources out there. A little bit of a cautionary note, we as Americans are not so good doing the infrastructure these days. In New York City, they tried to expand a subway line, like one more stop. It ended up being the most expensive public works project in the history of subway lines. Why is Italy building subway lines cheaper and more efficiently than we are?

28:48 Of course, we all know what's happening with the high-speed rail in California. So there's a lot of money being invested in this stuff, but can we as Americans really turn that into good infrastructure and good programs on the ground? Something we've got to be smart about. Finally, I mentioned earlier, Tom Vilsack announced the new chief of the U.S. Forest Service.

29:07 Randy Moore, who I think is a familiar name to all of us, is now the head of the U.S. Forest Service. Rumor is he's going to poach a lot of people out of Region 5, hopefully he doesn't start poaching them out of Indian National Forest. We've got great leadership here now with Leslie Ann, I don't think she's going anywhere. And finally, just to close on an observation from last spring, one of the...

29:28 Treat, there's many treats in the Eastern Sierra, but one of my favorites was going, I like to go backcountry skiing from time to time. This is a place of Twin Lakes out of Bridgeport, and I always loved going there. I still love going there, but one of the things I used to love about it was there's never anybody up there. I would go up there and wouldn't see a soul. Well, I went up there with my room back in the spring and counted, I think, nine Sprinter vans and 35 cars. And I checked in with some of my colleagues, and this was not an aberrant.

29:57 This has been happening every weekend this spring, 35, 40, 50 vehicles up there. And when you get up there, this is up at the Matterhorn, this is actually eight, nine miles back. There's 50 people skiing up there. I've never seen anybody up there before. And I did my best to ask politely and well, gee, where are you from? Oh, I'm from Gardnerville, Reno, South Lake Tahoe, Atlanta, Atlanta.

30:25 Yeah, I'm remote working. I live in Atlanta, but I'm remote working in South Lake Tahoe. This is the most beautiful place in the world. I'm going to figure out a way to keep living in South Lake Tahoe so I keep driving down and doing this. And this is just part of this national and global trend we're seeing around people coming to places like this. And we can't blame them because this is where it's at. So that concludes my presentation. Hopefully that was edifying and useful. I'm more than happy to take any...

30:52 questions, Mr. Chairman, if there are any, Mr. President, if there are any questions. Yeah, thank you, John, and exactly that. Any questions from the MLR Board for John? No, just to say that's a lot to digest. Thank you, John. It's a lot. I know, I apologize for that. No, it's okay. I'll dig in a little bit more, but, and I might have questions to follow up, just so you know, but thank you for your work on that, and it's just a tremendous amount, so thank you.

31:26 Yeah, if there's questions anybody thinks about that they percolate a little bit, just find me, find Christy Williams as the project manager. Kim certainly is aware of a lot of the stuff she's been going to those partner meetings. Craig Albright has been going to the SSRP partner meetings, so there have been regular updates every month to the entire region. If any of you guys want to come to those meetings, just let me know. We'll get you on the list. Other questions out there? Heather? I was going to say thank you, John, and I wish we had more time.

31:56 If I could have 50 hours a day, I'd have more time to get more to that meeting, but thank you. It's very educational. Appreciate it. Sure. Thank you. Yeah, I'll just, you know, follow up with that, that, you know, having went through that presentation numerous times now as it's built momentum, you know, the couple things that come to mind for me as a summary of it, it really sets the framework for the collaboration and partnership

32:25 action that MLR wants to focus on. And, you know, I think of us as another one of those gears on that one graphic that to fit in there and, you know, address some of the things that are the needs in our local community when it comes to recreation. And so, John, I really think it's amazing how much work has been completed and really

32:53 You know, relatively short period of time. And I think that the linchpin is really that, you know, the work of the ESCOG to get the resources for our partners at the Forest Service to get the environmental stuff done. Because that always seems to be where the brakes get pumped on almost everything. So, you know, to me, that's the central piece that hopefully is going to help our partners at the Forest Service.

33:21 Be able to move more nimbly and the rest of us to take our role in that process of getting good projects done. So thanks, John. For sure. I think, Stacey, I mean, obviously it's a very sincere message to you guys and the work you're doing with the Adopter Trail Program and things like that. There's so much that you're doing that it's just build, build, build, build. We've got so many things in line to make that work. It's a great time to be doing this. Awesome. Awesome.

33:51 Okay. Thank you, John. All right. My mom's calling and I got to ride my bike. I'll see you guys later. See you, John. Bye. Bye. Thank you. Bye. Bye. Bye. All right. Great. All right. Moving on to policy matters 5.1, discussion and possible action on fiscal year 2021 and 22, Tana Mammoth Lakes.

34:20 contract within your packet was that contract. We've been working through it with a little back and forth over the last few months. I believe all of us were on a joint meeting with the town council and the MLR board. And so now I think it's just a matter of us

34:47 coming back and voting and approving on that, but I'll open it up for discussion and then like to entertain a motion, but on approving that contract. So anybody want to open us up with comments or thoughts on that? If seeing none, does someone want to move to approve that item?

35:14 Greg, what page are we on on the agenda? I'm just trying to get in front of me right now. We're at Policy Matters 5.1. No, but what page is it on? Sorry, the agenda. Oh, 95. Thank you. Oh, okay. There you go. And that has the contract with, you know, kind of all the boilerplate in it. And then, you know, the two items that I had jotted down as kind of the most important, as you'll remember.

35:46 In that joint meeting, the town council had approved an amount of $90,500 yearly to be paid at a quarterly basis to MLR. And so that was the amount of the contract. And then Exhibit A at the end of that has the scope of services and deliverables for FY21-22 that we've been working through and had approved as a board.

36:15 Yeah, a while back, and it was just a matter of the amount of the agreement. So, but open it up to any questions. I just want to comment that, again, going through the figures and the budget, I think the $90,000 is at the very bottom of what I was willing to acquiesce to.

36:41 But I think it's acceptable, especially for a one-year contract. So I'd like to move forward with it, and I would be willing to put forth a motion to approve the contract. Okay, so I have a motion from Tamara to approve the contract as presented in your packet. I'll second that.

37:09 You know, I think obviously a lot of work went into this and, you know, I appreciate all the time and energy you put in, Kim. And I think, you know, I would echo those sentiments that I think, you know, we would have maybe hoped for a little bit more or a little bit smoother negotiation around the funding, but I don't think we should trip up at the 99-yard line over a few grand here and there. So I'm good to move forward with where we're at.

37:37 Okay, so I have a motion from board member Bankson and a second from board member Fernie. Any further discussion? Heather? I just wanted to see if Kim had any comment before we made any motions. Okay, Kim? No, we've discussed this a lot. I will echo sentiments of the board as well.

38:05 You know, everybody just kept talking about how much work it is, but it's hard to pay for it all. We're worried about you, Kim. You know, it's that catch-22 right there. But as you said, it's the bottom. We'll move up from here. We know you're up for it, Kim. Yeah. I think we can move forward, Craig. Yeah. Bill, any comments from you? I know, you know, that was...

38:35 higher than you wanted to go, but I think we found someplace that hopefully we can all live with and build upon. Any comments from your side, Bill? No, I think I made them all at council, so I voted affirmative there, and if this goes forward, I will again here. All right. Awesome. Okay.

39:00 Oh, it's not Angie, it's Jamie, I gotta write that at the top of my agenda here. Jamie, any public comment coming in on this item? No, there is not. Okay, thank you. No other discussions, then we'll call the, let's do a roll call on this then. President Albright? Yes. Treasurer Schaubmeyer? Yes. Secretary Bankson? Yes.

39:29 Board Member Souser? Yes. Board Member Fernie? Yep. Awesome. Passes 5-0. Thank you. And, you know, as was stated, a lot of work on all sides. You know, Dan, I know you, you know, put a lot into this. Kim, the negotiations committee. So good work, everyone. You know, it's been a wild, you know, year and a half.

40:00 for us all, so congratulations. I'm looking forward to us building a strong partnership in the future, so good work, everyone. Next item on policy matters 5.2, review the draft fiscal year 21-22 Mammoth Lakes Recreation budget. Kim had some budget numbers in there for us to

40:30 Look at and give her some feedback on. But this is, Kim, I'll let you take it away from there and the show's yours. Okay, let's see. I have shared my screen. Can you all see that? If you don't have it in front of you. Yeah, we can see it. Perfect. So, yeah, so let's pass a budget this year. That'll be a step up.

41:02 I think we'll just take a few minutes and walk through this line by line and just stop me if you have questions or comments. So we'll start with income and corporate contributions. I'm hoping that we can secure two at least corporate sponsors primarily for

41:29 Tangle Free Waters Program and the Fly Fishing Film Tour, you choose to do that again. Business contributions, I've set a goal of getting one adopted trail and one Tangle Free Waters Station adopted per month over the course of the year. I don't think it'll pan out to be one per month, but you know, fluctuation seasonally.

41:57 Individual contributions, starting some targeted appeals, some monthly giving donation campaigns, moving down to government grants. Here we have the Town of Mammoth Lakes contract, and then I anticipate writing a proposal to Mono County for some support on the Tangle Free Waters Program as they

42:25 originally funded the program for startup costs, so looking to continue that partnership in any other areas they are interested in. And as you'll notice, the column on the right is our last fiscal year actual, so just for a comparison. Moving down to fundraising, we have these great cross-country ski signs and some trail sign memorabilia, hoping to pull all those.

42:55 Fundraising efforts together this year. Last winter didn't really pan out to get excited about the snow, and I was a little overwhelmed as well. So we have some needs, possibly a new grooming machine for the trowel system, looking towards that. Fundraising events, raising some money, hopefully at our film festival, recruit some more help, rally a bigger attendance.

43:26 And that's what we have for income. Any questions on that? And Kim, you've mentioned that a couple times now. Let's lock down a date next year now in May. That sounds great. And it was very difficult this year because we did, and then the tour pulled back because of COVID restrictions and weren't allowing any in-person events until June and, you know, chalk it up to a crazy.

43:55 COVID year, but yes. Jen's just a really hard month, as you know. Yeah, I will take your word for it. But yeah, I think it's a great thing that we can keep bringing to the community with a little more planning. We could have really success. Okay, expenses. Let's see. Filing fees. Those are just taxes.

44:26 Other business expenses, that's where we count our Mono County property tax. We used to have annual credit card fees and Shopify, both of those have been canceled. Business meals, just in case. Advertising, just budgeted $1,000. This past year, I had some evergreen graphics created for some of our programs. We'll run targeted ads throughout the year.

44:56 Trying to drum up some interest, any other additional advertising like when Measure U application period is open or we are doing events or fundraisers. Counting fees, we have our accountant, you know, payroll, taxes, that is what it is. We've never budgeted for any legal fees or at least not in the last several years I've been around.

45:27 That would be something great to look into retaining some pro bono services if needed. Anyone ever has a line on that? Let's see, website development, budgeted $1,200. We were dropped by the company that built our site. They were just too small for them. So I got a recommendation, have a new company. They've been great providing services for $100 a month. It's working well.

45:57 Only been a couple months, but they're very responsive, almost too responsive. I feel bad that I can't get back to them fast enough. So we're doing well on that. It'll be a big help to me to have a responsive need on the back end of our website. Graphic design, minimal needs, but I'm sure something will come up. And move down to office. Let me move this up here. Office supplies.

46:37 You know, bare necessities, pretty much printer ink posted. End up mailing a lot of checks for some reason and thank you letters to donors. Promotional materials, you know, hopefully we can participate in some events and have some promotional materials for those. Down to printing, essentially that boils down to posters for events.

47:05 Rent and utilities. Obviously, we don't have an office, but we do have storage unit. And that actually just went up about $7 a month. So this figure will be adjusted slightly. Telecommunications is a MLR cell phone. We used to have a cloud-based system, which you'll see was about $4,500 a year. For multiple employees, that made sense, but with just me.

47:36 I canceled that. It's working fine and we're saving quite a bit of money. Computer hardware, just in case items, software is, you know, the basics, Adobe, Formsite, the software that we do surveys with and Measure U applications, adopted trail, volunteer reports, etc.

48:02 And every action, which is the software that we accept donations through, that's the biggest expense, that's about $2,200 a year. Bank service charges, that is the fees that we pay for processing the donations. Insurances, you know, that's what we have to carry and rates continue to rise. So I think I've, you know, increased the budget slightly on these.

48:34 We have the Fidelity Bond. This one may increase. I have to look into it. As part of the Prop 68 Whitmore grant, MLR needs to carry a Fidelity Bond, which I'm assuming is going to be greater than the one we carry. But the expense is reimbursable for the grant. Something we will be incurring. Payroll.

49:01 So all this will be finalized at our next meeting in September. Our next agenda item, President Albright will run through the staff evaluation and contract proposal process. And here are some figures to base off of. Professional memberships, Chamber of Commerce, and we do a National Wilderness Stewardship Alliance.

49:31 We have a grant with them, and so we need to state members, plus it's a great organization. Staff training, I just budgeted a small amount, hopefully participate in a webinar here or there or something educational to better the organization. Move this screen up. For travel expenses, I put in some money for gas.

50:04 That's just when I need to go out and install tangle-free waters tubes or adopt the trail signs or disperse camping things, you know, up in Highway Summit, just paying for gas for that. Last year we had the Eastern Sierra Sustainable Recreation Coordinators travel in there, but that is not part of our budget anymore, so we down. Our vehicle maintenance, we have nothing, we sold the vehicle.

50:33 If you recall, I think we sold it for $3,000. Fundraising expenses, hoping to buy some merchandise, as I mentioned before, initiate some campaigns or events. We're hoping to at least raise about $7,000 through a couple fundraising events, so see what we can do there. The next line you'll see under program service expenses is allocated income.

51:05 And essentially, I just added this line to show money that up top has come in currently, but is already allocated to a program such as Adopt-A-Trail or Tangle-Free Waters or Disperse Camping or another Sierra Trash Eliminators. So just showing that expense in our budget so it's not looking like a profit.

51:35 You know, I didn't line out each program there underneath it, but currently it's about $43,000 that we have in the bank that we're just waiting to be invoiced for. Moving between two screens here, not very good at it. We will not have any ESSRC program expenses this year. So our total expenses are

52:20 Down about $100,000. It's primarily salary. We are still short $24,000. We did have our first PPP loan forgiven. I've applied for forgiveness for the second loan. And just another side note, currently, you know, we have in the bank approximately $110,000.

52:48 But also about $40,000 has been paid out for our grants that we're administering that we are waiting for reimbursement for. So just to add that line coming up on our monthly financials, that'll be called out more clearly. And that's where we are. So Kim, with the grant stuff, that'll be added into our cash reserves. So those will go up to $150,000? Correct.

53:23 And so in this- And then do we need- 125, that's accounted for. I'm sorry, can you repeat that? Yes, in the cash balance down at the bottom, that 40 is accounted for already. Okay. And we don't need to net out the program service expenses out of the cash balance because that's already been on both sides, income and expense. Correct. That's why I added the-

53:56 Just the general 43 amount. Okay. Can you clarify the second PPP loan? If that is forgiven, does it add into our cash balance? It won't because it's already in the bank. It'll just be forgiven on the books. Okay. So that does not adjust our net balance at all. Okay. Thank you. And what was that amount again on the second one?

54:29 Just over $34,000. $34,000. Okay, I knew it wasn't the $50,000, but I couldn't remember what it was. So if that's not forgiven, then it could ding us potentially $34,000 more. Am I doing that math right? Correct. Okay. Yeah, I would think for finalizing, you know, for

54:59 For our budget, we would want to under program service expenses. You know, I would like to see, and I'm channeling my inner Eric Wasserman, is probably want to have that all broken down by program, that 43.6 of just approximately how much in each of those. I know it's rather dynamic on whether, you know, we're adding new tinkle-free water.

55:29 stations. But, you know, I would think we'd want to have that, you know, itemized out a little bit more. And actually, yeah, we do. I have a whole separate program budget for each program. Got it. That's what I thought. Every, you know, income where it's allocated, expenses, you know, especially programs like.

55:56 adopt a trail where the income is split between town and county. It's all separated and pulled out. So those are available and we certainly can pop into this. Excellent. I think just overall feedback, Kim, like, you know, this is...

56:19 Well done, easy to digest. I think the income side of things is very conservative and very reasonable. Looks very doable. And I think you're obviously running a lean and mean organization. Expenses are kind of trimmed down to the level that we can, pretty bare bones. So that is commendable. And we appreciate you keeping such a keen eye on that stuff.

56:48 You know, it looks pretty good overall to me. I know we'll get into this, but it looks like you've got two proposed budgets here. One would be with just you and one would be with a part-time staff member. And that would fundamentally be the only difference between the first budget we just went through and the second budget we've got upcoming. Fundamentally, yes. It's my hope that with that other person, we will be able to generate additional income.

57:18 Definitely want to stay conservative on that part. Okay. Well, I certainly have some thoughts and questions on that budget, but I will wait until we get there for that stuff. Any other questions regarding, and kind of to Colin's point, maybe on the expense side, outside of staff? And seeing none, why don't you lead us through your thoughts on

57:52 Adding a part-time staff person and what that would look like. Yeah, so, you know, very conceptual in thought, thinking, you know, start with a very part-time person. I think I budgeted for about 10 hours a week. And, you know, I haven't written a job description. There's no specific.

58:24 task, per se, that they would solely be given to, but it would be certain things that I could task out. And, you know, in hiring a person, I would want to make sure that they are well-versed at social media and would also want to go and check a tingle-free waters tube and clean it out for a station we don't have a volunteer for. This task that over the past year, I have come up with.

58:52 You know, the workflow and gotten everything dialed in and now we can hand it off and let someone help me out. Questions for Kim on that from the board? When are you hoping to bring this person on by Kim? No, I don't know. You know, I think I wanted, this is the first time you all are hearing about it. I wanted to get some feedback. I would say sooner than later.

59:27 But definitely need to flesh it out more. Is there enough interest in volunteers to put up some kind of sign-up genius for some of the things like the tangled waters and stuff that you can assign people to do that aren't going to have to be funded positions? That's very possible. Yeah, try that as a first avenue. And what can we give them in return? I mean, listen, I know volunteers should be out of the goodness of your heart, but these days I think people are also looking for something in return, so that's something I think we should consider.

1:00:02 Just a thought, with any of our grant recipients, I don't know if this is possible, so it could be something that we can't do because it's a different type of funding, but do we require any volunteer hours if we allocate a grant to anyone, or can we hope for some volunteer hours? We don't have anything like that set up. You know, it's interesting with our

1:00:35 Tangle Free Waters Program and like say adopt the trail and, you know, there's options for people to adopt, you know, if they want to go volunteer and work. So I feel like that's already in place. And, you know, other things like the dispersed campaign people don't have the time to volunteer, but, or it's not the right program to volunteer, but they have some money to support it. So we're sort of, we already offer one or the other.

1:01:06 And, yeah. Hey, Kim, when we spoke last week, we were also, under this category, we're talking about, you know, potentially, would a summer intern be of help? Have you any further thoughts on that? Yeah, I think it would be great. And honestly, we, you know, we just passed the contract tonight with the town.

1:01:37 We haven't been in a place to even have this conversation for a while. So I think that interns, I think volunteers, I think there's lots of options. I do think there are some specific tasks that, you know, I know I drop off first that should be done because they're not a have to to make, you know.

1:02:04 the show go on, but it certainly would help our organization if it got done, that paid staff would be the person to task it with. I would also ask the question you had kind of mentioned, you know, and was highlighted that your income was seemed reasonable and kind of conservative, but you made the comment that

1:02:34 With a little help, you might be able to redirect some of your attention and boost that up a little bit. Any color on that? Areas you think there's opportunity that, like you said, with just being a one-woman show that we're missing out on? Give us a little color on that. It looks so weird. What happened?

1:03:05 Yeah, I think let's just look at fly fishing film tour, for example. You know, if I had a second person to help with marketing, advertising, hitting the pavement, getting posters out there, you know, possibly we could have generated more ticket sales and therefore made more money. Other questions from the board? So we're looking at about 10 grand difference in cost.

1:03:43 for your estimating about 10 hours a week. I'm assuming this will come back as an action item at some point as to whether we're going to go there because tonight is just a review of budget. I think it's just a conceptualization. Yeah, it is. This is just overall first size on the budget and then first pitching of a second staff to the board.

1:04:19 And then next in September, I hope we will be able to pass a budget and with or without a part-time person. And that's something we can always add later as well. Yeah, exactly, Bill. That's how I kind of had it planned out, give Kim the opportunity to kind of share where she's at with a draft budget, with a couple of options.

1:04:46 And so that we can start a little discussion as the board, but then in our September meeting, finalizing a budget and either accepting one of these or some iteration of that. So any other feedback for Kim on those? Where I'm at is, I would love to give Kim a little

1:05:20 A little help and see if we can slowly build ourselves back up and not get ahead of ourselves. And, you know, that seems reasonable to me and particularly if we can, you know, make a good case that this person will not only cover their costs but help us, you know, kind of eventually bring more income in. And I think this is...

1:05:47 not out of the realm of possibility, and so that's kind of where I'm at, but I look forward to, you know, the board, you know, thinking about this over the next month, and feel free to reach out to Kim and get more details on that, and then we'll have an action item for the September meeting. Well, we have a little bit more of like a job description written out. Yeah, I can.

1:06:19 We definitely can. And a great point, Heather, that was in my notes from Kim and I's earlier conversation that, you know, a job description and really filling that out a little bit more in depth will help the board be more comfortable with that idea. So, you know, doing that between now and September would be great. So, you know.

1:06:45 Just as you said, how are we covering, if we see it as a person that's going to help generate revenue, can we add a little more to that so that we have a little more to digest? How are we going to be able to contribute to offsetting their own pay and, you know, taking some things off your plate? So besides a job description, more sort of a task orientation?

1:07:10 Thank you. Good expectations. It's a lot of liability, even if it's someone who's only 10 hours a week, you're sloping yourself up a lot. Good feedback. Thank you. Okay, any further discussion on this item? But, Kim, I think you got, you know, a little bit of a feel for where the board's at with this and what they need to see a little bit more of. And I'm sure, speaking for XCOMM, we can, you know, happily, you know,

1:07:42 help you with that a little bit and so that you've got a nice solid presentation for our next packet. Sounds great. Thank you. Awesome. No other discussion on that item. We will move on to 5.3 and discuss the procedure and timeline for staff evaluation and contract renewal for our program director. And

1:08:13 you know, kind of where my head was at, and I'd love the board's feedback, is go through a similar process that we did with our Executive Director, what, a year plus ago, where, you know, we send out a, gather feedback from board members and from our partners at the town and some of our partners within the,

1:08:43 Trails committee and Measure U fundees and whatnot and be able to provide Kim with a good evaluation. I know we all very much appreciate the work she's done over the last year, but really formalize that and give her some solid feedback to build upon. And then that would lead into having a proposed contract renewal that again would be an action item.

1:09:13 for our September meeting. I had asked Tamara if maybe she could, as secretary, could head up the sending out the evaluation forms and getting some feedback. And then I'll plan on, you know, XCOM can kind of gather that together. And then whether the timeline

1:09:43 That's a good question. Gather that together and whether the whole board needs in closed session needs to review that before I sit down and do the evaluation with Kim. Is that kind of the normal flow of things? I'll refer to Colin and Bill. Yeah, I mean, I've always felt it's helpful to have a meeting where we start

1:10:15 with the Executive Director and kind of get their take and feedback on everything. And then we have a time where we just sit as a board and discuss that feedback. So I can send out, I still have the format that we use with Matt. So I can send that out tomorrow or the next day with a turnaround of, you know, four or five days.

1:10:43 including a self-evaluation from Kim. And then I can compile that by the following week, which we put us at, so if I gave it, if I asked for it back from everybody by the 10th and I compiled it and got it to everybody by the 15th, that would give us that whole week to then take a look at it. And I think that gives us then a couple weeks to formalize something, put it in writing before our September meeting.

1:11:13 I thought the format of the last one we did was great. Yeah. And yeah, it'd be great to get, you know, Kim's self-evaluation and give us an opportunity to kind of hear from her and ask any questions we might have, and then we can let her go and kind of just discuss amongst ourselves as a board. I would say that the idea of a 360 evaluation is great. I would be careful about how broad you made it because you want it to be filled out primarily by people who have worked with Kim.

1:11:43 Yep. Or our employee. I probably shouldn't use names. The other thing I would question at this point, whether the timing is correct right now to do the evaluation and the contract. I don't know what our contract with her looks like, but I'd like to see it sort of tied into just prior to our town negotiations because they sort of go hand in hand. I'm not sure when her dates are. Craig, do you know that?

1:12:13 It expired June 30th. Okay. So we're overdue. And we get to get on this right away. All right. So if that time frame works, I'll send it out to everybody. We'll just use the same format. If anybody has anybody else they'd like to be included, but I'm assuming I'm going to include Dan and John. And anybody else I should include on that for 360 feedback?

1:12:50 I mean, to Bill's point, Kim, who are some of the members of, I don't know, the trails committee or Joel jumped out at me. Matt be involved in that, Bruno? Yeah. Stu Brown. Yep. Okay. I think that's plenty. Yeah. I don't want too many. And then all of us?

1:13:17 And I'll put a return date no later than the 10th, and I will compile by the 15th and get it to you guys, hopefully, fingers crossed. I do have a huge event coming up, so I'm kind of busy. Yes, you do. Yeah. With a little added pressure to it. Yeah, no added pressure. Giant events and people's weddings, but that's okay.

1:13:48 Crazy. Bill, question for you. From a procedural standpoint, am I biting off too much to think that in September we could do the staff evaluation in closed session and also discuss the contract renewal during that? Or is it best to keep those really separate?

1:14:20 The contract renewal itself we can't do in closed session. Oh, that's right. The evaluation should be closed session. But if you have them on the same night, then you would need to do the evaluation prior to the meeting. So your closed session would be before the meeting instead of after the meeting. Okay. Dan is almost nodding, but not quite. Yeah, just in the evaluation process, the closed session, you cannot talk about salary.

1:14:47 Okay, got it. Yeah, talk about paying benefits in the evaluation process. It has to be an open session item. All right. And can I clarify, can Executive Committee, once I've compiled it all, have a discussion offline to compile all of the thoughts once we have them back? Yeah, as long as it's not a formalized, yeah, because even if, I guess.

1:15:14 It's a formalized subcommittee appointed by the board. It has to be noticed, but that could probably be a closed session item. But I mean, if the board created it and set all that up, then you'd have to follow all that process. Depending, I mean, if you're talking really about the evaluation, that's what you're focused on. Executive committee could end up doing that. But as a standing committee, it would have to be noticed even going into closed session item. Okay. Yeah, the executive committee could only meet like that.

1:15:48 Otherwise, because we're a Brown Act, they would have to be a non- Mad hoc, yeah. So it has to be, it still has to be a notice meeting. Just open the meeting, any public comment, closed session item, and go into closed session. So it's not an offline, just, you know, discussion. It needs to be a notice process. Okay. So we can look at that as we get a little later in the month.

1:16:14 as to how we want to do that between us. Yeah, yeah. You can likely do it as a special meeting, which is only a 24-hour notice. 24-hour, yeah. I'm assuming you have it. Yeah. Cool. Thank you, Dan. And of course, you can meet as long as you aren't a majority of the board. And that would be the sitting members as I read our bylaws. Yeah, no, and the...

1:16:45 Executive committee is a Brown Act committee because it's appointed by the board and is a standing committee. So it doesn't matter if it's one, two, or three people. Yeah, I think once we have everything, once I have everything compiled, we'd probably notice a meeting and the three of us meet so that whatever I've compiled as an evaluation, we can agree upon and then present it to the rest of our board. So, okay. That sounds reasonable. Thank you, Tamara. You're welcome. Thank you.

1:17:11 All right, so that's helpful. Any other discussion on that item? Excellent. And so then moving to 5.4, which is, you know, again, just kind of getting our feet wet with the idea of, in light of being down three board members, two board members? Two, three? Three. Three.

1:17:43 if there's any appetite for the board to amend our bylaws to have a smaller board. And the couple things that Kim and I have kind of talked through is, you know, do we go through, go down to a board of seven and look to fill that one vacancy and

1:18:09 not something we're going to act on tonight, but something we can bring before the board in our next meeting. Obviously, with the bylaw change, I'd like to have everyone there. In fact, probably necessitates having everyone here so that we have a full board meeting on this. But anyway,

1:18:38 Thoughts on number of board members, bylaw change in that regard? I mean, you know, I can certainly understand how we arrived at the place we are with nine board members. I know that was a desire of Matt to, you know, kind of build capacity of the organization and not put too much work on any one of the board members, considering we all have a lot going on. You know, personally, I find nine to be a little unwieldy.

1:19:10 So I think scaling it back would be beneficial, whether we go down to seven or five or however we want to handle that and discuss that. I think those are really the things that we need to weigh. The more board members we have, the more we can kind of spread out the workload. But it can become a little unwieldy with a lot of differing opinions. Obviously, the situation we're in right now,

1:19:40 With never having filled that ninth board member seat and then having two people resign has put us in a tough situation with quorum. So I think this is something we need to get resolved sooner rather than later. Anytime we have one board member that can't attend, we're in danger of not having a quorum for the meeting. And I'm not sure that's going to work for very long moving forward. So I think it's something that we need to address fairly shortly and just kind of weigh the value of.

1:20:09 number of bodies on the board, I suppose. Yeah, so I would concur that I would rather go to seven than try to go back to nine because nine is unwieldy. However, in reading our bylaws again, a quorum constitutes a majority of the authorized number of sitting directors. So that is sitting, not number of positions. So right now we are a group of six.

1:20:37 So four is the quorum instead of five for nine. So, and I find it interesting. It is something in all the nonprofits I've run, I've had written into the bylaws. So when you lose a number of sitting board members, you can still make a quorum. Good nuance to the bylaws there, Bill.

1:21:03 Kind of makes the quorum issue a little less tenuous, but still the idea that we're maybe a little unwieldy at nine. Yeah, I will agree with that. I think nine was a little cumbersome to manage, and it made for extremely long meetings. So I'm, I, but I do think we're a little shy, and I like the seven number, because as I would echo that with Colin, it's difficult to miss a meeting.

1:21:33 You know, we all have lives and this is volunteer work. So I think we need to recognize that we're, we need another person on our board. Heather, your thoughts on the matter? I think that we need another person just because of like, you know, Tamara said, and I agree with it, what everybody else has said, just because the time aspect of things, we all are very busy people with only limited capacity that we can take on. And I know Kim needs support. And I also think with just Kim being a one-woman shop.

1:22:02 And it makes it difficult to manage nine people. That's not what she needs. And I think until we had another person that'd be part of the crew and if MLR grew on the executive aspect of things, then it'd be one thing. But right now with our position, I think one more person would be plenty. Okay. Well, from that discussion, then it looks like we will put together

1:22:29 something for our next meeting agenda item with an action of, you know, addressing our bylaws and particularly the number of board seats. And, you know, I can tackle that with Kim on specifics of what we want to change in the bylaws without messing up bills that nuanced.

1:22:52 phrasing there so that we don't, if we do lose a couple members, we're not struggling with the quorum, but, you know, something that we can put together and then have for our next meeting. One other thing, Craig, just looking through again, section 4.8, sub-item E.

1:23:18 You know, in the existing bylaws, it says at least five directors at any one time shall be permanent residents of the greater Mammoth Lakes area. I think that was put in based on nine directors, not saying we need to change that, but just another specific number bylaw that we may want to consider. Okay, good heads up. I'll kind of go through that with more of a fine-tooth comb. Any other items that are in the bylaws that have been?

1:23:48 Nagging at anyone that we should, while we're looking at bylaws need to address. And if not now, you know, reach out to me and I can, you know, take a look at that and see if we can include that in any proposed changes. Awesome. All right. Thanks, team. On to board member reports.

1:24:17 Tamara, you had a 6.30 engagement, so why don't I let you go first, if you have anything to report on? You're muted. Sorry, thank you, Bill. Nothing huge to report, other than I have a huge MMCF event coming up August 21st called Wine Walk, and everybody should go. That's it. Awesome, thanks, Tamara. Thank you.

1:24:53 How about your world? Is that me? I'm sorry? Yes, yes, Colin, how about you? Sorry. You know, nothing major to report. I guess since we are an outdoor recreation board, I will report. Jeremy and myself finally launched a summer business. And so that is up and running as of mid-July.

1:25:20 The name of the company is Play Big Outdoors, and we're doing kind of outdoor adventure rentals, so e-bikes, inflatable sups, motorcycles and dirt bikes, and off-road vehicles is kind of the suite of offerings that we're doing. You know, one of our major goals was to provide some year-round employment for our Black Tie seasonal staff, so that's been a really nice thing to bring a number of our key employees over for the summer business.

1:25:49 You know, we're utilizing our real estate assets both on Old Mammoth Road and our warehouse space between the two businesses. And yeah, we're pretty excited. We got that up and running. We kind of did a soft opening and just making sure that we had our processes figured out. But we are up and running and ready to kind of turn up the dial. So I wanted to let everybody know that that is a new thing for us personally. And that's all I got. Awesome. And how's the baby?

1:26:18 Baby is awesome, getting more adorable every day and definitely keeping us on our toes. So yeah, things are good. Awesome. And I like how your guys offering in the summertime covered all of our board members. You're an equal opportunity toy peddler. Well, you know, I think we've...

1:26:42 We've got quite a broad scope of things to do up here in the summer, so we're trying to kind of cover a bunch of different options depending on what your speed is and what your interest is. There you go. And at what decibel level you like your recreation. Yes. Exactly. Yep. Or what adrenaline level. Colin, as I recommend people to go to you, that on your motorized, they have to have a way of picking it up at your site because you don't have a service permit that I know of.

1:27:11 Yeah, so that's a great question. We are offering our black tie concierge service for most of those items. So we are offering delivery and pickup to people's homes or hotel rooms or wherever they're staying. So that is a component that I forgot to mention. But yeah, it depends on the item in terms of that stuff, but you can certainly direct people to our website or to give us a call with any questions on that stuff.

1:27:39 You know, obviously, if people are taking out, you know, renting a motorcycle or dirt bike, there are certain restrictions, you know, they've got to be 21 years old, they've got to have a Class M1 license, motorcycle endorsement, those type of things. So, you know, rather than getting super specific on everything, because it depends on what category you're in, just send them our way and we'll walk them through the details. Awesome. Good on you. 6.30 guests have arrived, so I got to go.

1:28:09 Thank you guys, bye. Yeah. Heather, how about your world? I'm just busy, thank you. It's been, July was fantastic. I feel like in the sense of outdoor recreation and people, I feel like it's a little bit tamer this year than last season. I don't feel like there's people coming out of every orifice. I feel like it feels a little bit more natural. So that's been kind of nice to not be so stressed out like last summer has been. It's still a different client than we're used to. So it's just,

1:28:41 It's just different. But no, busy, busy. And every weekend of my life is pretty much occupied until the end of September. So, but I signed up for it. I'm excited for it. And I'm excited and thankful for the blue skies that we have outside right now. And I did drive to Carson City last week and got to see some of the devastation there off the 395. And it just kind of puts you into reality check and be very thankful for what we have. Indeed. Yeah, I know.

1:29:11 I know California likes to make media headlines, but it's been interesting talking to friends around the country anecdotally lately. I have a friend in Minnesota that has been smoked out for weeks. They can't leave their house. They've got AQI, PMI levels up into the 160. And they've been dealing with smoke impacts in Wisconsin. I talked to a friend in Big Sky, Montana the other day that's dealing with it.

1:29:38 It seems like the jet stream is kind of flowing kind of towards the northern half of the United States and then across east. So knocking on wood for sure. It's been great that we haven't had a ton of impact so far this summer here locally. Mr. Souser. Yes, please knock on wood. Remember our smoke didn't start until Labor Day last year and it restricted me to my house. Because of what has been going on with me recently,

1:30:08 I will announce that I no longer have a brace on my arm and that I am now allowed to lift up to three pounds with it. Whoa. Same as before. Yeah, exactly right. Yeah, nothing has changed. I can't ride my motorcycle and I can't rent one of yours, Colin, so that is kind of... Soon enough. Yeah, yeah, after September 3rd or so, I will get the next release. But other than that, for me, it has just been a beautiful summer.

1:30:39 A lot of company, a lot of action, yeah. Awesome. And for me, same thing, knock on wood, for the beautiful summer we've had. I mean, just some of the most stunning days in a row here. Just enough rain and not too much lightning, so I've been stoked with that. Super busy on the mountain. Just been, Heather, I would agree.

1:31:06 As busy, if not maybe a little busier in some of our businesses, but more tame and a little less frenetic. And though, yeah, it'll be interesting going back into mask zone on Friday. We're trying not to freak out too much about that. And hopefully it'll be short-lived. And, but, you know.

1:31:36 like Heather said, super thankful for the good both winter and summer we've had and all sites look towards it's going to be a good winter and the community certainly has their challenges on the staffing and housing front and I know Bill's neck deep in that and actually every

1:32:05 Every business person in town is. And so if there's one thing coming out of COVID for us to all circle around, that would seem to be the issue is addressing workforce housing. So looking forward to working on that with everyone. And so anyway, aside from that, any requests for future agenda items?

1:32:33 And seeing none, we will adjourn. And I've got 633. Thank you all. Thanks, everyone. Enjoy the rest of your summers. Thanks, Ken. You rock. Oh, yeah.