TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2021

Town Council Special meeting

at 16:00

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Notable from this meeting

5 findings

Transcript

379 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:01 Let's see. Should someone chat to Lynda that it might be the audio on her end? No, I'm fine. I just was unmuted. I was muted. Yeah. We're all good. Come over here and play for a while. We'll take him to Sanders' office. I'll take him to Dan. We'll hang him out with Kirk for a while. We can show him around. Yeah. This is, yeah, our first meeting.

0:32 Not the last, we are sure. Hey. Hey. Hey. Then he can go play with Stu, too. There you go. Yeah. Council. We always have to start. Councilmember's young. That's great. Yeah, participate in your democracy early, right? If he doesn't run in about 30 years, he's going to be in trouble. We've got all the, like, A's for activist books.

1:06 Oh, there you go. We got a lot of, yeah, we got a lot of books about Ruth Bader Ginsburg. Yeah, good. So, yeah, so he's got good, good reading material to start with. Good job, Sarah, good job. Yay, all right. Congratulations, Sarah. Thanks, I thought I just, Dan was like, well, the most important thing is, is Miles going to attend the meeting, so we thought we'd put him on.

1:37 Real quick. And then I'll plop him back in his bouncer. Hey. She's here, happy mom. Alrighty. And there it is. In the back row. Good job. You've been promoted. I just, anything to get out of the house. I've been going for hikes about three times a day and same weather. Everybody's been vaccinated, so I don't get it. I mean, is it, is it still that contagious?

2:56 I mean, I don't get me wrong, it's spreading with people that refuse. No, Kirk, actually, there's quite a few reinfections with people who have already been vaccinated. More so than I would have thought. At any rate, it all appears as though we are all now present. Dan, you got all the staff there you want? Yeah, they're either here or they're on the Zoom. Perfect. With that, I will open this special town council meeting of Wednesday, October 27th.

3:33 At 4.02 p.m., roll call, please, Angie. Mayor Sauser. Present. Mayor Pro Tem Salcido. Here. Councilmember Stapp. Here. Councilmember Wentworth. Present. And welcome back, Councilmember Ray. Thank you. Very good. Stuart, I see you are on the call, so I'm going to ask you to lead us in the pledge, please, if he's listening. All right, Bill. It would be my pleasure. Here we go.

4:11 Follow me in the pledge. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible with liberty and justice for all. Thank you very much, Stu. Been waiting a while, Bill. Yeah. Public comments. This is the time anyone wishing to speak on any item that does not otherwise appear on the agenda.

4:42 Angie, do we have any public comments? No public comments at this time. Thank you very much. Moving on then to policy matters. Consider the town's participation in the California Housing Accelerator Program for the parcel. Because Sarah and myself are recused from the parcel, we have to be recused from this item as well. So I will turn the reins over to Linda. And we are...

5:11 We're accused because we live in too close of proximity to the parcel. So Linda, I will turn it over to you and I will mute. Okay, thanks everybody. Okay, this item number 4.1, consider the town's participation in California Housing Accelerator Program for the parcels, such as Bill already said. So who's going to kick this off for us here? Sandra? Yes, I will. Thank you so much.

5:39 So as you stated, this item is a request for the Town Council to adopt a resolution authorizing the Town's participation in the California Housing Accelerator Program. This program is a $1.6 billion program that was authorized by the Department of Housing and Community Development earlier this month.

6:01 The program is intended to be kind of a stopgap for projects that couldn't shovel-ready affordable housing projects that couldn't receive funding through low-income housing tax credits or other sources. The phase one of the parcel is an eligible tier one project for this program, meaning that if we apply for the program, we are...

6:22 Almost guaranteed to get funding through the program. So we have been working with Pacific West communities, our development partner, to identify funding. They alerted us to this funding opportunity. And so we're here before you today to ask you to adopt this resolution to allow us to apply for the program.

6:40 And also to allow the town manager to file all the required documentation for the program. So with that, we do have Caleb Rupp, who is with Pacific West Communities. And I don't know, Caleb, if you want to give a couple other comments on the program, provide a little bit more detail. Sure. Thanks, Sandra. And good to see everybody. I'm Caleb Rupp with the Pacific Companies.

7:07 This is a brand new program, never been done in California before. We'd be one of the very first ones to apply. So there's some newness to it. But I think the state's done a pretty good job of setting up the program to be pretty flexible and work with our existing financing that we do have approved, i.e. the funding from Mono County, the town's contribution of fees, the land, et cetera. So the IIG, the Inflip Instructure Grant Program.

7:36 So we're in great shape with this. We can get anywhere from about $35 to $42 million, which is really the balance of any of the financing needed for the phase one of the parcel. And as you guys might know, those listening out there, we have started construction already. And this is a great opportunity that allows the project to move forward fully funded and just without any contingencies left in terms of financing. So it's a great outcome.

8:06 We're looking forward to being one of the first ones through the gate. Okay, thank you, Caleb. All right, other staff members, any questions for Caleb? John? Council members? Yes. Oh, okay, sorry. Caleb, I don't, I mean, I'm going to profess my ignorance. This is your field. I'm not getting in the weeds with this stuff. One general observation and question. Some of us have been following a little bit what's going on in D.C. with the attempt by

8:37 I'd love to get your insights on that.

9:01 Yeah, this is a California program, so whatever's happening in D.C. doesn't have any effect on this program or phase one. However, what is going on in D.C. would certainly have an effect on future phases of the parcel. With more funding opportunities being produced in the tax credit program, also direct assistance funds, and so home funds, CDBG funds, things like that. So mostly, even though it's messy back there, there will be money for housing.

9:31 And I think that bodes well for future phases of the parcel. Okay, good. I'll leave it at that. Thank you, Madam Mayor. Those are all the questions I got. Thank you. Thank you very much. Kirk, do you have any further questions? No questions. Okay.

9:48 Hi, Caleb. I have a couple of questions, if I can. So in the resolution, we state that it's not to exceed $45 million. Is that a realistic number, or would you be happy with something less? Obviously, would that be expected, or would this a real number, a hard number for us asking? The range, I think, will be from $35 million to $42 million. It really comes down to an issue about

10:16 Prevailing wages. And, you know, as you know, some of our project costs are prevailing wage, some are not. And so the range, that's why there's a range right there. We're probably going to settle on that in the next day or so. And we'll know the application amount, but we figured on the resolution, just make it an up to amount. That way it was covered whichever way it happens. But my guess is probably going to end up about 42, if I had to guess.

10:42 Okay. And then as far as specificity of what we would be doing with this money, I read through the application, I mean, I read through the paperwork, there's nothing really in it, but what, could you just outline for us what that would look like? Yeah, so basically this funding covers all of the development costs associated with the project. So this is just, you know, round numbers, it's about a $50 million project for phase one.

11:09 Which includes a lot of the infrastructure that we're going to be building, the roads, you know, the curb gutter sidewalk, utilities, working in partnership with your public works folks and Hayes and everybody. But we're, you know, we're really, this is most of the construction dollars to actually build the units. It will also cover financing costs, you know, construction loan, et cetera, architecture, engineering, things like that.

11:34 This money basically replaces what otherwise would have been the tax credit equity coming from the private investors that buy tax credits for projects like this. That source alone was about a little over 60% of the project's total costs. And so this money from the state basically replaces all of that money.

11:57 And provides the replacement capital that would have come from that tax credit investor. And so really all project costs, but mainly like a focus probably would be on the construction costs, which total about 39 million of that 50. That's kind of what we're looking at it to cover for the most part. Okay. And then we talk about this being a forgivable loan in terms of 0% interest for 20 years. So explain to me how we would then.

12:26 Work with that loan. Well, I think it's TBD as to whether they're going to run the loans from the state directly or run them through the town or cities as the case may be. You'll remember like home funds, which we've been successful in years past getting those. Those were a grant from the state to the town. And then that town, the town would loan the money to the project. I believe these loans are going to be structured directly from the state to the project.

12:56 The reason why they want the joint application process is because a lot of these, why we're eligible for this money is because the town had been awarded the infill infrastructure grant funding and you're already a participant in the project. And so they want to have us both go in there together because you have money at stake already that's already committed to you.

13:18 That, you know, they want to make sure you're on board with this process and this approach to the financing. And so that's why there's a joint resolution and joint application. But I think the loan will come directly from the state. Again, it's a new program, but that's my interpretation of what's going to happen. And then maybe this is a Dan question, or maybe for you, Caleb, our payback mechanism is what then? Well, in that scenario, if the state funds directly to the project, there's no loan through the town, so there's no payback.

13:49 At all. Okay. If you think about it this way, the money that the state is providing was replacing equity from tax credit, so it was no loan in the first place, and they tried to structure it as similar to equity as possible. So the loan is forgivable, but there's also some hooks in there. For example, if your sponsor wasn't in compliance or the project was out of favor in some way, shape, or form, they'd actually have the ability to keep that loan in place and not forgive it.

14:17 And it's just, you know, it's another kind of hook they have to make sure the property performs well and is ran well and complying with all its conditions. Okay, thanks. Yeah, that's what I thought, but I just kind of wanted to talk about a little bit in open air here, so thanks for indulging that. Okay, and Andy, the last question is for you. Because the agenda doesn't list this as a resolution, is that an issue? Well,

14:48 Yes, but I think that Dan was the idea that the council was going to approve the resolution next Wednesday, next Wednesday being the last day that it could be approved. The intent was that the town council would adopt the resolution tonight. Yeah, if the item doesn't allow for that, we can do it both ways. We get direction tonight, we can actually file the resolution, I believe, without it being signed, and then we would actually then have it as basically a consent calendar item at the next meeting.

15:20 Okay, so in looking at the agenda, it's described as consider Town's participation, and then the action sheet, which was posted and available online, has the adoption of resolution as the recommended motion. The resolution was attached. I think we've gotten it close enough that the council could adopt the resolution tonight. Okay, then I would say we should just go ahead and do it then. Is that acceptable? Anybody have any comments on that?

15:51 Is there any public comment on this? Yeah, I was just going to ask Jamie that. Jamie, is there any public comment on this? Was it Angie or Jamie? Angie's working the meeting this evening. Oh, hi, Angie. Okay. Hi. Nope, there is no public comments on this item. All right. Great. Thanks, Angie. All right. Are there any further questions from anybody listening in here? All John, Kirk, staff, have any more comment? I'm prepared to make a motion, Madam Mayor, if that's where I'm at. Please do.

16:18 Yeah, I would move that the Town Council adopt a resolution authorizing the Town's participation in the California Housing Accelerator Program and authorize the Town Manager to file all require documentation. Okay, I'll second that. Okay, we have a motion and a second. Angie? Angie, call for the vote. I'm sorry, I was muted, Mayor Pro Tem Salcido. That's okay. My turn. Mayor Pro Tem Salcido, how do you vote? Yes. Councilmember Stapp? Yes.

16:59 Council Member Wentworth. Aye. And Mayor Sauser and Council Member Ray have both recused themselves. Okay. Hearing that, we have a 3-0 for the approval of the motion and the resolution. Caleb, thank you for joining us and hope to see you again soon. Will do. You guys take care. Thank you a lot. Bye-bye. Thank you. Thank you. All right. That being said, I will move aside and let Mayor Sauser return to us here. There he is.

17:35 No, I gave this item more time than that, Lynda, so you've got to do a song and dance for another five minutes. Sorry. Sorry about that. Okay, moving on then to item number five, staff presentations, workshop on allocation of TOT revenues and review of TBID and short-term rentals. Dan, you're going to start us off here. Yeah, let me, I'll kick into some of this and then we'll work through with the discussion. The item before you actually came out of a...

18:06 Presentation a few, maybe a month or two ago, we talked about setting up a number of workshops with the Town Council, both including, you know, one-on-one joint meetings with our various partners. And there was also a request to look at these items in particular as well, looking at the allocation of TOT more globally than with a particular agency, and also looking at the TBID as they begin to look into the future for renewal.

18:36 It's role in the marketing and other elements that it's utilized for. And then the question on short-term rentals, and there's been a back-and-forth discussion over the last couple of years is if any council action should be taken in that area in terms of managing that a little differently, looking at a number of different pieces there on quality of life ordinance update review on limiting numbers.

19:04 Kind of putting a hold on things to look at it or let it continue to run as is. So we want to bring those back. And the actions or the information tonight is not structured specifically for any formal action to be taken. So we're not asking for you to make any final decisions. But really, the idea would be that there's comment, if there's some direction, you want to see more information come back in a particular manner, you want to see it brought forward in a different way.

19:32 And individualized discussion, then we can gladly do that or maybe enough this evening and you're good to go. So kind of lay those out from that perspective. So not formal action, but definitely a good chance for the council to really have a discussion across yourselves as well as with a number of public members that are weighing in as attendees here at the meeting. A lot of the information presented in the staff report

20:01 You've seen before. I won't walk through all of that. But really, we come back, we begin to look at this, and it comes up through the budget process and other times. The nice part, at this point in time, we are not in the middle of a budget process, so the discussion is kind of outside of that element at this point that can provide direction moving into it in the future. But we really look at the allocation of transient occupancy tax, referred to as TOT.

20:29 And we currently do that a number of ways through the various agencies we support. We will touch on the TBID, and then we'll touch on status of short-term rentals. Each of these topics are relatively substantial in and of themselves, but we believe they are all related at different levels, so trying to at least have some of that relationship identified, I think, is beneficial for the discussion. You've received the information in the past on a lot of the ballot questions in the structure. There's an attachment to the report that walks through that.

20:59 At least one of you, Mr. Stapp, was here when I think all of these were passed. We talked several times about the ballot measures and the process they went through being approved as general taxes, but in the information and the gaining of support for the taxes definitely made political commitments to provide specific revenues in the three areas that we're looking at in terms of tourism and housing and transit.

21:30 And then for a number, for a portion of that time, there was also a commitment for a one and a half points of TOT to go to capital projects or community facilities in the town, and that was discontinued several years ago as well, I believe in FY89 that that was discontinued at that point. When you go back and review the ballot questions, a lot of different comments regarding

21:54 The structure of the tax is a general tax, which is important. It allows that flexibility in use and also only a 50 plus 1 percent vote to approve versus a two-thirds voter approval process. So I won't spend a lot of time walking through all the different changes that's in the attachment there, but really getting to where we're at today in terms of how we currently allocate out the revenues between basically four agencies, including the town in there.

22:23 And I did do a little write-up in there, because you'll hear us talk about percent points or percentage of allocation. It gets confusing at times, but the idea there is in the tourism, for example, it's 2.35 points of the current 13 points of tax rate. Sometimes that's referred to as 2.35 percent, but it's referencing the share of the 13 percent, not a percentage of revenue.

22:51 Otherwise, that would be an 18.077% of budgeted revenue that's allocated. So just as we talk through this, please keep in mind as we reference those items that we use some different terminology for the same meaning. Try to keep the discussion to points, which is the points of the TOT that's allocated. The current last round of amendments to this happened 17-18.

23:19 And it was clear at that point we're allocating these elements by program area being tourism. The one item defined as 2.35 points, housing at 0.85 and transit at 0.85. The town, the remaining portion of 8.95. And there was a fair amount of work to go to those and I won't spend the time to rehash all that unless there's interest or questions about getting to those elements. I think the key issue on that, there was an adjustment made following the

23:48 Bankruptcy filings and the settlement of a lawsuit. The last adjustments dealt with those changes, trying to bring back additional funding, really focused on some additional money for the housing opportunities and activities undertaken by the town in partnership with MLH. And then the other structure on that was the allocation of those particular dollar amounts based on the town's budget versus total revenue generated out of TOT revenues.

24:17 And then we continue to track revenue, even if it comes in over and above the budget, it still gets allocated into reserves, if you will, and our general fund set aside for those three particular uses, be it tourism, housing, or transit. And then obviously the remainder is in the town side to work through that. The various adjustments in the past as I mentioned have been driven by other

24:43 Outside forces, if you will, legal actions, economics, and other elements that go through that. I did want to touch on briefly the town's budget strategy and the way it's been working the last several years. We've had questions come up in terms of kind of a low budget number for TOT revenues, and then obviously our allocation to those particular areas are tied to that budget number. Again, still restricting out.

25:11 Anything over and above that, but having greater authority over that at the council level. And we began that process for a number of reasons outlining the staff report. I'll touch on a couple of them. I think they're important as we went through that to really get a better establishment of the town and the town's financial health and its ability to address issues and look forward. And also really to be able to have an increased and better debt rating when we go out for borrowing of money.

25:41 Their priority was to get there. We're actually right now an A-plus with a negative outlook coming out of COVID, which has been really positive, frankly. We're surprised to keep us there. Following the legal settlement, we were down at a C rating or at one point maybe a little lower down in junk status basically as an agency. So one of the elements as we began to work through a lot of those things was how do we reestablish that bond rating. We've been able to do that.

26:09 One of the key elements that agencies look at is what is your reserve policy? First of all, do you have one? And secondly, if you do have one, do you actually follow it and fund it? And so we've been able to achieve that in the policy that's in place. And again, the staff report outlines that. We have a couple of different areas of reserves within the general fund. We also have reserves and other funds that are either restricted, i.e., gas tax is restricted and or special taxes, you know, measure R, measure...

26:40 You or LTC revenues and other things that have a legal restriction on them. We continue to do that. We have a good reserve in terms of vehicle replacement and other elements to shore up the town's financial structure. The other element on that does it really allows us to strategically focus on as we maintain core service levels, where do we actually need to see an increase? In the last year, for example, we made some shifts in part-time to full-time positions within our road department for

27:10 Snow removal purposes and general maintenance in the non-snow ones, if you will, in the summertime. And what we were seeing there is on the part-time staffing, I think at one point we were as high as six part-time snow removal operators. The ability to recruit those positions was getting more difficult. And we were seeing a greater demand on the workload pre and post winter for prepping for it and recovering afterwards.

27:37 Being able to work down through the summer in terms of our other road work. And so shifting in some full-time positions over time and reducing the number of part-time positions still has an additional cost, but the effectiveness of the department was enhanced very dramatically. So those types of issues were able to do that. It also has really allowed us to step back in and figure how do we deal with capital needs, deferred maintenance.

28:03 Other expenditures, one time unknowns. We've had the last several years, we've had two monster snow years. We have spent literally well over a million dollars on budgeted revenue on snow removal operations, things of that nature. It's allowed us to address substantial deferred maintenance in our parks department. It's allowed us to step forward in some major rehab work on streets and mubs and sidewalks and those types of elements.

28:32 Being able to have that capital that isn't pre-committed really allows us to either respond to emergencies, which we've done. It also allows us to really work with the council and the community in terms of some of the things and feedback we get on priorities to go fix things. For the last several years, there's a lot of push on our MUP system, which was developing substantial cracking in the pavement, and how do we go back in and rebuild that? I think it was at one point. I forget the number.

29:00 I would say 1.7. I could be off on that in terms of the funding that we put back into those months this last year. And again, the responses to that has been great because people definitely have something they see, they utilize, and they see that benefit coming back into that. Being able to have that flexibility and to have that discussion to set priorities and to move that through a capital program or deferred maintenance program has really dramatically, I think, changed the look and feel of the community.

29:28 And I know from a staffing side, the fact that we're taking care of those things, free staff up to work on other elements and other maintenance items, and they're not chasing the deferred maintenance side. And we still have some areas to work on. We get requests, for example, at our community center to beef up the landscaping. We get that down on Main Street. Old Mammoth Road, so just the look and feel of the town. And those are things that we actually are able to go back in down and program and do because we do have the resources.

29:57 To be able to choose those. The other side of the strategy on that is really dealing with that TOT revenue, which is 60% or so of our adopted revenue, and at the end of the year it's probably more like 70% of our revenue coming into the general fund. The capability to utilize that, though, given being in a tourism-based economy, the flexibility that could happen, the fluctuations in TOT, and we saw that this September, for example.

30:26 You know, revenues were actually pretty solid, a little over, was it $800,000? I'm looking at the finance director. But lower than last year, but we had a smoke impact. We had the forest shut down. And if we're budgeting everything we think we might get and those little types of hiccups, that really sets us back. And then we're looking, where do we not fund? Where do we cut? How do we respond to those types of adjustments that would have to be made?

30:52 So the budget process has worked very well. I mean, if there's desire by council to change that or look at modifications, we can definitely have those discussions. But it also, it's also allowed us to a lot of times do major projects, i.e. the purchase of the parcel or some of the investments we're making in housing would be another huge one in the last several council meetings, dollars going into that, both from the general fund, restricted funds from a political commitment side.

31:19 As well as being able to backfill some of our road and street work. One of the examples there, I know we look at our street budget, we do about $500,000 a year, 80 of that or better goes into regular maintenance work. Then we have a half a million for road work. Our goal is to spend a million or more a year in roads, and we've actually been able to do that as we leverage projects and we look at how we do that funding work with excess revenues and savings.

31:48 And one of the challenges in the general fund, we talk a lot about the TOT revenue. At the end of the year when we go through the budget process, there's a lot of other revenues and expenditure sides that fit into those dollars. So it's not just TOT revenue when we do these types of things. We're looking at property tax and sales tax and the other revenue sources. And so we don't bifurcate out TOT as its own separate entity, if you will. It is part of a larger budget structure that we work with.

32:19 And then in the TOT allocation, I'll jump back to that and come back to these items if you have particular questions, but the TOT allocations, really a couple policy items that has come out of the past allocations. One is there remains a commitment to fund the areas of tourism, housing, and transit and work related to those pieces. With the exception probably of tourism to some degree, the others have, don't really have a

32:47 Absolute allocation of a percentage of dollars. Housing has been funding through MLH, but it's been fixed at a lower amount, $336,000 this last year. ESTA, which is really kind of a different structure. It is a legally separate government. It is a joint powers authority. And so going into that, we have other partners in that from Mono Nino County and City of Bishop. But our transit funding is based on an hourly rate.

33:17 And then the number of hours of contracted service, it fits much easier into that model working that way. So we do look at a 1% allocation, but we also, or the 85 allocation, but then we look at other revenues and then work through that funding source. The other element to this is that all of these funds are part of the town's general fund based on the ballot measures and language there, subject to council action.

33:45 And then, at least historically, there have been changes to these allocations based on different needs and conditions that we've touched on. So as we go forward, we want to kind of keep in mind these policy elements. And I'll be honest, we're not looking for any changes in this that would put additional dollars generically into the town's general fund or into town operations. The amount we're committing into the particular areas we're talking about.

34:12 Strong recommendation that those be retained for those purposes. And we've seen success over time in our revenues as the TOT has grown. A little bit dated, but from FY 6-7 to 12-13, we had an average of about $10.5 million a year. That increased to $15.6 million from 13-14 through 19-20. And if you take the last year or so in there, that may have bumped up a little bit.

34:40 We did hit a record in 18-19 of over $20 million in revenue. Again, but as we went into the pandemic year, the process we put in place really allowed us to weather that fairly effectively. The impacts projected to be fairly dire did not come to fruition. We actually did better than anticipated, but definitely lower than what previous years had been. So we definitely want to look at those types of elements.

35:07 And then I want to touch on the three areas of tourism, housing, and transit. But maybe before I do that, just kind of in the preamble work, if there's anything there that council has questions on, I'd like to do a little highlight on those, talk about the framework for discussion, and then hand it away to council to get into some of that other dialogue and discussion on the use and allocation of TOT revenues. But questions kind of to the preamble side. Any questions for Dan on his presentation so far?

35:40 John? I don't have any questions. I think we're all, hopefully we're all pretty familiar with Dan as shared, so I don't have any questions at this point. Thank you. Sarah? Not at the moment, thank you. Thank you. Linda? No, I think I'll better ask later. Thank you. Thank you. Kirk? One comment, just to read into the record. The town retains 2% of the revenues collected to offset collection costs, processing, and enforcement.

36:10 It's just, you know, the town does spend staff time doing that. And I just wanted to make sure everybody understood that. Thank you. Thank you. And I have no questions on the first part either, Dan. So continue away or we can start with the first of your four points. Yeah, let me hit a couple items and then, yeah, then turn you loose on the policy discussion framework there.

36:40 You're all familiar with this, but a little bit overview just for those who may be listening. As we fund tourism, that has been an ongoing percentage of budgeted TOT at this point. It goes into that allocation. Anything over and above that is held in a tourism reserve. This last year through both consensus counseling with the MLT board, that excess dollars has been shifted into housing projects and programs this year.

37:06 There's about $2.67 million allocated this year. A portion of that funds the Chamber of Commerce, and it's approximately $2.3, a little more, that then goes to Mammoth Lakes Tourism. And then MLT also is funded out of TBID revenues and any other trade-outs and other elements they may get in terms of their operations for doing various ads and public relation campaigns and marketing, et cetera.

37:35 The TBID, we'll talk separate there, and as member staff noted, we do retain a 2% percentage of that to offset the cost of staff. All right, Sarah's introducing Miles. I love it. Sorry. Thank you. I'll have to do a formal introduction here later, Sarah. Sorry. Joy babies. They look too happy. So the element there, as that goes there, then Mammoth Lakes Housing probably took the most

38:08 Significant change with the legal lawsuit that was settled, the lawsuit with the airport issues, and they were actually cut back dramatically down to just a flat dollar amount that was retained for a number of years. They're still at that. It really isn't tied to a percentage or amount of TOT. There's still a full 0.85 that's allocated to housing work. Part of that does support town staff work and housing. We've taken a much more aggressive role.

38:37 The last few years in terms of a lot of the housing efforts, state programs, grant funding. And I will say with MLH, we have a great grant partnership. A lot of the grants even the town operates or goes for is in partnership with MLH and they do a lot of the administration and delivery elements on those grants. One of the newer programs in terms of buying a unit.

39:01 We actually utilize MLH as a non-profit to be the lead to buy that. We provide funding then to MLH accordingly to provide for the purchase of a unit. In this case, it's an open market unit that we're buying to de-restrict to 120% of AMI, average median income levels, in order to have a family that can afford it then to be in that home and a stronger part of our community. So a lot of partnership through those elements. We've also provided funding for the 238 Sermana.

39:31 Park Project, which is MLH Project, working as a CHOTO, Community Housing Development Organization, which longer discussion there if people have an interest doing that. And so we're actually utilizing a lot of that to move these projects forward. As I mentioned, transit funding with ESTA. It is a contractual relationship tied to the JPA, the town's a part of. It is a hourly rate, which right now is...

39:59 Just under $48 an hour that we contract for approximately $19,500 hours of service. There are other funds that go in to support that through fees here in the town, as well as other state and federal revenues. And outside of Mammoth Lakes, they have some fare box revenue that goes in as well. I think Mammoth is unique in a lot of areas here, not completely, but where we have truly tried to provide free transit services throughout the community.

40:30 A lot of the winter transit is free also, but that's through a contract between Eston, Mammoth Mountain Ski Area, where they pay for those services, similar to what the town does based on a negotiated hourly rate and the number of hours of service. And then they get a fair amount of revenue as well from their work with the National Park Service, Forest Service, as they deliver people safely and reducing congestion into the Devil's Postpile area.

40:57 A lot of work throughout the summer. There's also an additional fee that gets paid there that's set aside for future maintenance of a new roadway in that area as well. So partnerships in terms of how we make that work. And then the allocation discussion, as the mayor referred to, as we set up kind of a framework for this, I think it's very important that it's a little bit narrow in terms of the topic areas. And I think that I just want to read through these quickly. I think they're important is that

41:27 First, the recognition that there is a need to continue dedicated funding into these three areas of tourism. Each of these can be kind of broad. Tourism is more than just doing marketing, for example, but the tourism element, housing and transit services, that needs to continue. There's no desire from a staff perspective to not fund those areas. Second is that the allocation minimum right now would be 4.05 points of our 13.

41:57 Continue to go into those areas. We're not recommending any reduction in that amount. I think there could be some debate. Should it go up a little? But that would be a different policy direction issue. But definitely to maintain at a minimum level those dollars going into these particular areas. And then also that over time circumstances have changed. That has required the shift in the use of these revenues, how they've been committed into those areas. There are still commitments there, but outside factors drove us.

42:27 And then lastly, that those TOT revenues are part of a general fund, but they are definitely restricted to those areas, and we are not looking to increase general fund allocations for any town operational type activities. To the extent that they fund town projects like housing, it's still within that area, even though we may be the sponsor of an element.

42:56 Thank you, Dan. With that, we will...

43:31 Try to break this down. Now, some of these are interrelated, so our comments will go through them. But the first is the recognition of the need to continue to have a dedicated funding for transit, housing, and tourism. Melinda, let's start this off with you. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Yes, so the question around dedicated funding for those three items.

44:00 I personally feel that, yeah, I mean, those need to continue. Those have been set aside. We have sort of stayed with that. I don't see any reason to break that now. We can talk about that more later, but, you know, we can reallocate what the percentages of those are, as much like what was done by the previous group that went from a 2.54 tourism to a 2.35.

44:25 We can take a look at that and see if we want to redirect any of those. But we can also remember that if we put that 2.35 aside specifically for tourism, that's not saying that all that money goes to our NGO. That is saying that we have a contractual agreement with MLT that says currently this is what the status of that is. Going forward, we could amend that.

44:50 We could use tourism dollars and, you know, being careful here to understand exactly what we would term tourism. Would that mean that you could pay for marketing and we could pay for outreach, we could pay for a little bit of the subsidy for airlines that we currently do? And would we be able to consider that tourism could be stretched into even supporting our workforce?

45:15 Does that mean workforce housing? Does that mean workforce augmentations in many ways? So I'm not convinced that that dedicated funding should be changed from what it is currently. I think these questions are further answered in the next bullet points, but that's sort of where I sit in that at the time. I have no, I personally, I have no desire to break that apart. Thank you. Thank you, Linda. Cheryl.

45:43 Yeah, I would say that my sentiments are in agreement with Lynda. If I were to, personally, if the world went my way, which it doesn't, but I do think that the T bid is sufficient to fund the NGO, but I agree that we may be able to take a more liberal approach to what does tourism actually mean? Could it be more liberally interpreted? Thanks. Thank you, Sarah. John?

46:16 Yeah, this is a great big conversation. So I'm trying to do my elephant one bit at a time piece here, Mr. Mayor. So, Linda, I think, I guess the first comment I would make is I would hope that we would leave out of our conversations just the mention of the contractors. I mean, it's appropriate at times to...

46:44 Bring that up. But I think the only conversation that happens at the council level is indeed policy. And I think that I very much support the allocations of Measure A and the political commitments that the council's made over many years. And Linda, as you mentioned,

47:04 Previous councils went in and made reallocations. That's certainly within the purview of the council to do. I think it's very important for the council to provide the rationale to the public for why those reallocations get made. So I see no reason to change. It would be a pretty drastic thing to be changing any of these things because these are political commitments that have been in place for many years. But certainly the council has the authority and the responsibility to make

47:32 Thank you, John. Kirk. Thank you, Bill.

48:03 I strongly support all the political commitments since I campaigned for all of them. So that's my comment. That's my personal history. Thank you. Thank you. As for myself, I absolutely believe we need to keep dedicated funding streams to these items. It has proven successful. We have altered in how those are determined.

48:34 Which has created changes in how some of our agencies are funded. But in terms of the importance to allocate for transit, tourism and housing, I still see the great need to keep those commitments in place. Thank you all. Next, we will move on to the second item, a recognition that the allocation of a minimum of 4.05 points.

49:03 of T.O.T. to the town's budgeted revenues to these specific areas to be continued. John, let's start with you. I guess, again, we're not taking any action tonight, but for discussion purposes, this is the status quo. Is that correct? That is correct. The status quo as it is today, not as the original political commitments. Yes.

49:31 Yeah, I'm okay with the status quo as it exists today. The adjustments were made, the rationale was provided, and I'm not at any point yet to make any changes to anything. We haven't had those discussions, so I'm good with the status quo as it is right now. Thank you, John. Linda? Thank you. I'm very open to a discussion as we go forward of an adjustment to those.

50:03 We have some other, I think, pieces of this to consider and information to be gathered on to whether or not a change of these would be warranted and wise. But I continue to be very open to a redistribution of the 4.05. Thank you, Linda. Sarah? Yes, I'm fine with keeping it at 4.05. Kirk?

50:34 I'm supportive of what's been presented, the history and everything. And if we're going to make a change, you know, I'd really, the question that would be posed is are you going to go out and frame it in a public vote? Thank you. As for me, in conversations I've had, I would consider a potential change if we increased that 4.05 to 4.35.

51:08 We could then take housing and transit, not to any specific organization, just for those funds, up to the original political commitment of one point apiece. And I would like to see us go there. Tourism, I'm happy with 2.35, but for those two, I think it may be something we want to consider in the future, going to that 4.35 of general fund

51:37 So that we can increase those commitments to one full point for each of the other two. Mr. Mayor, if I could add just one qualifying comment? Yep. I'm certainly open to the council exercising its discretion to make adjustments. I haven't heard any rationale yet for why.

51:59 Or any of that stuff. That's the discussion we need to have. I just want to make sure it's clear that my mind is open, but I haven't heard any discussion or rationale yet, so we've got a ways to go to get there. I think also, I think it's very, again, from my perspective, this is a very interrelated opportunity.

52:20 This is an opportunity for the council to start really optimizing the way we deliver services in this community. We have a lot of tools to use to do that, but I would anticipate a pretty weedy, maybe pretty wonky series of discussions. I think we need to do some work to really nail down the semantics of roles and responsibilities and who does what. And I want to make sure that my fellow council members are on the same page as to...

52:49 Who has what authority to do what and how relationships are set up. So I'm anticipating a fruitful conversation, but I just want to make sure that it's clear my mind is open, but I'm going to base whatever I would want to do based on the discussion we have and the rationale for doing things. Absolutely, John. I'm not sure, correct me if I'm wrong, Dan, that this wouldn't be the time if we were going to change, not change, we're not going to change anything tonight, but if we would like to bring that item back to a council meeting.

53:20 This would be the time to talk about that to give staff direction. If we're all comfortable with 4.05 and don't want to see an increase come back, then that's where we're at. If we'd like to see it increased, then I think this is probably the time to have that discussion. This is our workshop on these items. Linda. I just have a question. So I want to make sure that I'm understanding what we're saying here.

53:50 So while we may agree that the 4.05 is appropriate to those areas, the exact specific of what it is to each area is still what we're very open to. Yes. Well, yes, to each fund. Right. So an adjustment of the 4.05 around those three buckets, if you will.

54:16 Right. Is something that is also being still included in this conversation, is that correct? Yes, to me that's correct. Okay. Yes, then, yeah, I agree. Okay. With no further comment on that section then, or seeing none, we will move on to the recognition that over time circumstances change that requires a shift in the use of committed TOT revenues within the areas of housing, tourism, and transit.

54:50 to be considered. So here we're just considering the fact that change of political commitment can at times occur. I think that's what we just, what I was just trying to say is that. Okay. Okay. All right. Any other comment on that third bullet? Seeing none. Fourth, recognition that TOT revenues are part of the town's general fund and subject to allocation by action of the town council, but there is not a recommendation to increase the general allocations

55:25 for town operational purposes, which is pretty much going back to number one. Any comment on that, John? Again, absent discussion amongst the council of any rationale to do anything different. I don't have any comment at this point. Thank you. Sarah? Yeah, agreed with John. Linda? Yeah, so we're just saying that we're not going to, the town's goal in all this is not to keep any more money internally for the town.

56:02 It's helpful that it stays in those three categories, correct? Yes. Kirk? I agree. Thank you. And as for myself, I agree as well. At this point, I would ask if there was public comment on the four things we just discussed. Angie? We have two hands raised. Phil Morse, you may go ahead and unmute yourself. Good evening, Council. This is Phil from ESTA.

56:42 Yeah, thank you for your comments and your careful consideration. Obviously, these revenues are critical to transit, and I'm glad to hear that we still have that support. And I just wanted to ask, I guess, a couple of things I wanted to add to give Councilman Wentworth's comments some.

57:05 Time for discussion and for information as to why things should go up or why should there be an adjustment. We have a great relationship with the town in purchasing vehicles. Part of that transit fund is paying for the matching of the grants that ESTA is awarded when vehicles are purchased. It's about 20% of the total vehicle price.

57:34 is the matching amount. Sometimes they go a little more than that, and it gives us an advantage in the competition for replacement of vehicles with the grantors. And we have 13 heavy-duty transit buses. We're doing fairly well in the trolleys. We're making progress on that. The town has committed to buying a new trolley. We have successfully gotten grants for two more.

58:02 We still have three more that are from 2006 that are really giving lawn atoms over at the shop fits. So we're trying to get those replaced and we're applying for grants to do that now. And so, you know, the trolleys are moving forward, but we have 13 heavy duty transit buses used in the winter that need to be replaced. They're reaching their useful life in 2024. That's a couple of years. So I'll start applying for the replacement of those. Now, whether they're replaced with diesels,

58:32 Or electric buses is a significant difference in the cost of those. It's like it could cost about 6 million to replace them with diesels and about 12 million or about 11 million to replace them with electric. And 20% of those of those amounts would need to be saved.

58:53 And be ready so that when we file those grant applications in a couple of years, we have the funds available and they see that we are in a financial position to purchase those vehicles for the town. So that's one consideration. Also, we are entering driver negotiations if the ESTA board approves what I'm planning to bring to them in a closed session in November.

59:23 Then we'll open up the driver contract early and talk about making that position more attractive. We have two successive recruitment periods that we have failed to get the drivers that we need. And quite frankly, I just think we need to pay them some more. That number is up for negotiation, but I know that we need to be more competitive on that.

59:53 an amendment proposal. It's for a certain amount of increase for the hourly rate and the amount that costs for his consideration. And finally, we are looking to reduce, like Dan was talking about,

1:00:12 Reducing a dependency on seasonal workers, I think, is a really effective strategy. If we can do that successfully, then we have hired locals who already live in our community. We don't have to depend on people coming in from out of town and finding a place to live. And one of the solutions that we're working on right now is called job sharing. And I'm going to meet next week with Hayes and some of the department folks about can they

1:00:41 Give my drivers work in this older season. Can we create a full-time position that doesn't break in May and June and in September and October? And they work smoothly through the year and they have a career instead of a seasonal position. If we can get, you know, two or three or four of those rolling in partnership with the town, then we can stabilize our driver.

1:01:07 driver manpower and get some things done in the town while we're at it. And this could be a mutually beneficial idea. So I'm looking forward to those conversations. That's my comment. Thank you, Phil. Angie, any other public? Yes, Ron Cohen, you may go ahead and unmute yourself. Hi, everyone. Thanks for the opportunity to comment.

1:01:32 Coming to you from Mammoth Mountain Ski Area, where we'll be opening on Friday. Hope to see a bunch of you out here. Really excited to get the season going. You know, I think you all know the scope of the role that Mammoth plays in the community. You know, when we talk about revenue generation, you know, we're the biggest TOT generator in the community. We're the biggest

1:02:01 T-Bid Generator. We're going to pay $62 million in wages this year to employees of Mammoth Mountain Ski Area and June Mountain. That money gets spent almost entirely in the community. If you're a business owner here or a vendor, we're intimately, intricately linked to your success.

1:02:29 You know, we spend our own money in vendors and stores in the community, and we pay a lot for services. So, for example, that discussion of transit, that's about...

1:02:40 You know, when we think about

1:03:03 Allocations and TBID and TOT. And I think back over how we got here and, you know, really that existential threat that we faced in bankruptcy that was one of the key motivators for forming the TBID, for example, to ensure that

1:03:28 That we as a business community would have the resources we needed to pull ourselves out of the economic doldrums that we were in at the time and the threats that faced us. And, you know, I think that that TBID, we had to fight for it. It wasn't a unanimous vote to approve the creation of the TBID.

1:03:52 And there was a lot of controversy around it. And we pushed to do it anyways. And I think it's been incredibly successful. It's one of four TBIDs that I've been a part of forming. And all of them have paid off for the communities that have formed them. So I think of where we came from. And then I read the great staff report.

1:04:18 That was done and really laying out how we got where we are now. And what I read in that is that, you know, things have really changed. The job that town management has done in ensuring that we have a stable budget, that we have funded reserves, and that we are not creating structural cost increases in town government. Those are really...

1:04:47 And so when I when I

1:05:15 And to add all that up, I hear a really good news story. And it's hard to discern that when you get into public or private discussions. We have a lot of fighting over resources when we have this ever-increasing resource pool. And so when we talk about political commitments, political commitments go way back. They're not the Constitution. They're important.

1:05:45 They're not written in stone. And I would tell you from the perspective of leading a really big business here in town that we're open to discussion as well. And what we want is for the resources that are available to be put in the right places to have the greatest impact to achieve the goals that we all collectively have as a community.

1:06:15 And I think, you know, when we're getting into the discussion of this point here, that point there, we really need to step back and say, where do we want to go? I think if we can do that collectively, council and the residents and business owners of the community, if we can align on where we want to go, I think we can reach agreement on how we get there with the funds that we have.

1:06:43 And so I'm eager to be part of that conversation. I think others in the business community are as well. But let's have it. Let's get together and start talking about this stuff in a broad forum. And let's get to the why of why we want to do something, where we want to go. And then I think the what, the how.

1:07:07 will fall into place because I just see unlimited opportunity for us and I think the resources are going to line up for us to be there. So I look forward to being part of that with all of you and thank you for the time. Thank you, Ron. Any further public comment, Angie? None at this time. Okay. So at this point, we've gone through our four points there.

1:07:41 So are we all comfortable with where we're at with our TOT or do you want to discuss moving allocations? Mr. Mayor, I'll just say again, I'm open. But again, I think to Mr. Cohen's points about, you know, we've got some work to do to identify some whys and work with the priorities we've developed. We need to get some rationale to do any of those things. But I hope we're not going to be putting the...

1:08:13 Cart before the horse here, so we've got some work to do, I think, to figure out if any of that's needed. Okay, thank you, John. That being said, it appears we will move on and discuss the TBED at this point. Mr. Mayor, if I can ask a question or two. So, as we've alluded to, there's a lot more conversation about this topic that needs to happen.

1:08:44 Was this our goal for this evening was just to sort of preliminarily answer those first four questions and then we would have another meeting later? I mean, where, what is our direction now to get to the point of deciding those next questions? Yeah, if I can step into that, I think if the framework, it sounds like the framework we've kind of laid out is consistent and there's options to look at how we do allocations in there, one discussion about even increasing the allocation.

1:09:16 In total. I think the question there, we laid out different options and stuff you could look at. I guess I'm looking for, if we're all agreed we're good, then we don't need another discussion on this, which I don't think I'm hearing either. But the item there would be, if we bring something back, we need to probably narrow down that point of discussion. It can go to Mr. Connelly is talking about in terms of where do we want to go in a bigger picture and line the resources accordingly, or...

1:09:45 It can get down in some other little areas here as noted. If we're not down in the weeds too far, it's helpful. But to just say we're good to move forward, then frankly, I hate to say it, we really don't know what to bring back to you for a future discussion other than a much broader general discussion again on the use of TOT revenues. If you're looking at the status quo, we continue to just do it that way, great. If you really want to come back and focus on

1:10:14 Additional discussions on that alignment of resources with purpose. Glad to do that. I'll be honest, is that focused more on what we're doing in the MLH and MLT area versus ESTA? Are all three of them still together? There is some distinctives in their structure, so I call it out that way. Or we can continue as we have in the past, which, frankly, I'm not recommending at this point. We just individually hash out with contracts and we kind of...

1:10:42 Get more adversarial than cooperative at the end of the day under that process. So I do like the idea of, you know, what are those priorities and where we want to go together and how do we align the resources to get there? That type of a discussion I think would be extremely valuable. And seeing how well we are aligned where we want to go from a council, from previous political commitment to the needs of today or tomorrow, if you will, in terms of being able to...

1:11:09 Yeah, I mean, you know, I don't feel like we've gotten even off the first

1:11:40 Top of the blade of grass, let alone into the weeds here. So, I mean, I think we need to, you know, really, I guess the direction, you know, might be something along, you know, bring this back with some decision points backed by information and data around how we can, you know, ideally and most reasonably allocate these TOT points that we all came to agreement was still a good.

1:12:06 Number of points. No change to that. I feel like that's the only real decision we've made tonight, and I'm really curious about what, when you make these kind of broad statements we need to do, you know, what would that look like? You know, what would that look like at the next meeting? What would be some decision points and some decisions, you know, in the next meeting or two or three backed again by information and decision points along the way? So I'm not quite ready to leave this conversation about TOT.

1:12:35 Thank you for that, Linda. This is our chance as a council to discuss what we're each thinking individually so that staff can then put together a piece of work to come back to us. This is not about making a decision. So when I said we could take point three point and bring a couple of things up to one point, I think we're going to spend on housing. Whatever is necessary.

1:13:07 I probably don't need to allocate anything new there. I was just trying to stimulate some conversation. On transit, however, because the cost legislatively in the next few years is going to go through the roof. You just heard Phil say that the cost of buses as the state mandates electric is going to double or more, not to mention the infrastructure. So I can see the need because of the type of relationship that is.

1:13:35 To add that .15 back to that, because we're going to need those funds. Housing, we're going to allocate. That's a priority of council, and we're allocating way beyond what percentage or what point of TOT would be doing. In terms of tourism, personally, I like the way we do it. We have taken MLT from 2.5.

1:14:03 Plus all of business tax receipts to not just 2.35, but actually we've altered how we figure it. So they only get 2.35 of what we allocate budget wise. Anything over that and we build an overage in goes straight into a pot of money that as council, technically we can use for anything we want. So I'm very comfortable with that allocation going to tourism as a whole. If you want to talk about.

1:14:32 You know, individual organizations or something. I'm open to that as well. So, Linda, what I'm answering you with is I would love to hear what the individual council members' ideas are on if we need to shift TOT so staff isn't wasting their time on something that we aren't going to want to go to. John, I see your hand up. Thank you. Yeah, thank you, Mr. Mayor. So, I'd like to throw out a number of points here. I'm going to be succinct, I hope.

1:15:03 But I would very much like to see these as topics of discussion for first future meetings. This is in no particular order. The first one is I would like to get some recommendations from the town's administration, Dan and your lieutenants, for revisions for the process by which the town contracts for these measure A services.

1:15:30 Right now, I believe we contract with an organization for housing, housing focus. We contract with an organization for tourism. We also contract with an organization for transit. I think I'm not going to be harsh, but I believe that we as an organization have failed to create an efficient, effective culture of how we do this contracting such that we saw this just last July.

1:15:58 Where contracts arrive in front of the council the day before the contracts do to expire. And it's just not an efficient way of doing business. It also has the ancillary effect of creating a culture of real animosity and frustration and difficulty. So it makes it difficult for the council to have really good policy conversations and tracking conversations about deliverables and things like that that's necessary.

1:16:26 One thing I would love to see come back from the town about how we can do that in a completely different way so that we can do that. The second thing is that I believe we're here tonight because of a conversation we had around something to do with the contract and amount of money going to one of our contractors having to do with tourism. It was kind of a difficult conversation for the council to have.

1:16:56 The position that I was coming from was we need to have a truly strategic and tactical conversation about how we're going to do this. And we have not had that. And I think that we need to...

1:17:10 We need to have that conversation. I have concerns about the contractor we use for housing. I brought this up at the last council meeting because the town, we as the council have said, yep, housing, that's our number one priority. We're putting a lot of money into that program. And frankly, we are able to do that because the marketing and the revenue coming into the TOT makes it possible for us to do that. So we have a really important opportunity in front of us.

1:17:37 To acknowledge for ourselves and to the community that the TOT money that is generated through a variety of different reasons is going to make it possible for us to put a dent in the housing for things like the missing middle so that we can actually have a community and we're not just going to build a labor camp up here. And we need to have a very specific policy level discussion with amongst the council to figure out how are we going to realize that opportunity.

1:18:06 Of being this enormously successful destination, which as Mr. Cohen pointed out, we're doing pretty well by this. How can we make sure that the community benefits from that success by investing in our primary goal, which is housing and not just housing that is a labor camp or workforce housing, it's community housing as we've identified from the beginning. So I really want to have a conversation with them.

1:18:30 With all of us about how we can really do that. At the last council meeting, we talked about the town's program and all the stuff that we're doing. And the question was raised, well, who's going to manage this? What's going to be the front-facing program for that? We need to figure all that kind of stuff out. And then finally, I think we need to have a good conversation about the TBID. I don't have enough information about the relationship of the town as an authority.

1:18:58 with the TBID. And I don't think any of us do. And I think we need to schedule a session some time with our legal counsel. And I really very much appreciate Ron's comments. I think all of us could benefit by not using pejorative pronouns. So rather than saying,

1:19:16 Making the town, making you successful, or making the mountain, making you successful. Let's really start talking in terms of collective pronouns to make us successful, to make all of us together as a community successful. I think that's going to be really helpful. But I think we all need to have an understanding of how a T bid is going to work so that if we start thinking about making allocations of Measure A money, going to different programs, we as a council need to be able to answer our constituents.

1:19:42 If we make a 10-year commitment to renewal of the T-Bid and someone comes to us in four or five years, we won't be here anymore, most likely. And someone says, you're over-marketing this place. We're not in a position of saying, well, that's a T-Bid. We don't have anything to do with that. We no longer have any measure A or general fund in the marketing of this town. So sorry, you just got to go talk to somebody else. I just don't, that's not a responsible position. I don't think we should be in. So we need to have a conversation about the relationship of the T-Bid, the reallocation of the T-Bid and the rest of it.

1:20:11 I'll leave it there. I hope there's three pretty specific points. The contracting, the relationship, to really identify housing as a north store and leveraging the resources we get through being a successful destination to build a community and not just a labor camp. And finally, to have a really good discussion about what a TBIT is, what the relationship of the community is to that. So those three things, I'll just start with those. So thank you for that. Thank you, John.

1:20:41 I mean, certainly, I can discuss the town's role vis-a-vis the T-bid anytime. I mean, we can talk about that now, if you like. We can have a workshop later. With all due respect, I don't want to talk about it now. I'd like, Andy, if you've got some relevant documents, not 600 pages of them, but this is the stuff that we need to know. These are the authorities that we have, the ones that we don't have. If they're things, authorities that we have not exercised that we maybe didn't even know about.

1:21:09 A good primer, a good sort of general but specific overview. Council, this is what you need to know of what you've got now and what is going to be asked of you for a 10-year renewal. That would be very helpful. Okay. And I think I'll just add doing that in a public setting so that the community hears it, our partners hear it. We're all looking at the same pool of information so we can make decisions from that. Thank you. That would be really helpful. Thank you, John. Further discussion on this?

1:21:44 Linda? I mean, I think John spoke well in the things we need to move into, the things we need more information about. I would like to add one to that, and that is the vehicle that we use, the tool that we use to fund our NGO partners, in particular, Mammoth Lakes Tourism. So currently, we take points of, you know, 0.0255, and we...

1:22:16 Take a percentage of our budgeted TOT and that's what the award that year is to our contractor MLT. I find that hard to defend in that I don't know, it has very little to do with performance, it has very little to do with the scope of work and measurable successes. So that I think is no longer a valid way to fund an NGO.

1:22:45 We've been thinking kind of we've had a few kind of small meetings about what what that would look like. It's really hard, I understand, to quantify tourism success as it's tied to the amount of money spent on tourism success. But if we continue to just use this sort of blind formulation to give to an NGO that we have asked to do our.

1:23:14 Marketing and Tourism Outreach, then we have nothing to measure that against. So I really want to take a look at not continuing with that formulation of how to award a tourism group. I think we can do better. I think we can be more responsible to ourselves and to our community in what we're asking of a marketing entity. I think MLT has performed well. They have done what we asked them to do.

1:23:43 But whether the number is 1.5 million or 2 million or 3 million, we have no idea. We are throwing a dart in the dark at a target. So I would like staff and whomever the brightest people are out there to try to help us quantify what we pay for in marketing and tourism, how we can measure success, how we can work with our NGO to come up with a way that is more responsible because the money that we don't

1:24:12 Put in to marketing and tourism is money that would be available to housing and other priorities. I don't think I'm in no place to say I know the number. You know, this is the number. This is what we want for that number. I am in no position to prescribe that. But we I believe we need to get there. So that to me would be the added item on that list that John spelled out rather well.

1:24:43 My problem with that is there is no reasonable way. I don't like judging tourism on how many dollars come in a month because inflation all by itself alters that. It's impossible to judge. By how many people come to Mammoth, maybe that would be a better judge. But the way we have handled it, the amount we have cut from their budget, I think is adequate.

1:25:13 Of our budgeted amount, plus TBED, I think has worked really well. If we go back to the original commitment, in this past year, we took about a million dollars of what Measure A would have paid for out of their pocket, and I have no problem with that. We have used that money for housing and for other purposes. The points or percentage of TOT builds in your COLA, your cost of living adjustment. We know that advertising costs more every year.

1:25:42 We know that if we're in a drought, we have to advertise more for this. And MLT has been very good at segueing and changing their marketing message based on feedback from council. I think that relationship has worked well. And John, I'll agree with you. In the process of coming up with a contract, we became adversarial instead of partners. And we certainly should be partners. That's what we should be striving for with any of our...

1:26:11 I think since the initiation of TBID and half of those funds going towards marketing, the other half goes towards their service.

1:26:38 And 20%, of course, of what we give them in Measure A goes to air service. I think it's working really well. And just because it's working, we can ask them, you know, stop advertising Christmas week. We're full. Stop advertising so much for August. We're full. And they have done that. They have moved their campaign to shoulder seasons and to slower times.

1:27:07 And I think the relationship just works well. I think it works well as we've certainly laid it out in 17 and 18. I'm very happy with it. If I may, Mr. Mayor, I think that we have had good success. I don't know how that success is measured meant in regards to dollars. I don't know what that same success wouldn't have been achieved with 1.5 million. And I dare say I don't think anybody else does either.

1:27:37 I agree. So how do we then get better at that? There are better ways to do it. If you add the TBIT and the TOT together, what is MLT currently, like $8 million or something in total? And that includes airport subsidies and all kinds of things. So I don't believe we should settle for, well, it's sort of working now and everybody's doing well. There's a lot of TOT. I don't know if that's the right number.

1:28:03 And I would be really hesitant to continue a relationship, which you are very right. We have been not good contract managers in any way. We have basically said, here's some money, do stuff, come back and tell us what you do. We'll applaud and everybody will be really happy. That is terrible contract management. So we own that. The town owns that. If we have this money to give out and we want something done.

1:28:29 We develop a contract with deliverables and goals. And, you know, last year and the year before, before we got a little bit derailed by COVID, we had stepped into that pretty strongly. And I think we can continue that. I think we're on the right path of that, but it's not there now. So, you know, I would respectfully say that I think we need to do better than to just say, okay, 2.35 looks like it's working and we should just continue that. I think it has worked and I think we've been lucky, but I think we can do better because when none of us are on council anymore.

1:28:58 And nobody in the town is there anymore. I would like to think that we came upon a model that was sustainable into the future for funding with these points of TOT. So that's just kind of my take on it. Thanks. John, your hands up. Thank you. Linda, I want to support what you said.

1:29:26 With regards to tourism, I want to just remind us and get us up to a slightly higher altitude. Let's not start going in there yet because we don't have a lot of information from this. I want to make sure that when we do that type of analysis of how we are generating public value from the measure of money through these three program areas, I want to make sure we're looking at all three of them. We absolutely have to be looking at housing.

1:29:49 We have absolutely, as Phil just pointed out, we absolutely have to be looking at transit. And we just have to look at real change that's happening quite quickly and quite radically. And I want to make sure we apply this same discipline and the same lens to all three of these areas. I hope we're all committed to that. This is not, we're not just string off into the tourism and marketing side.

1:30:16 I think also I would anticipate that we should be able to get some very good, well-informed and interesting feedback from the people that we presently contract with to be part of what it is that we need to do. So I support it. It's got to be, again, at our, the only.

1:30:35 People that are at the altitude that we're at is council at policy looking at these things from this position. And we've got to remember that that's our obligation to the community is to try to do that well. And let's stay up there, but let's look at all three of these different areas and give them equal scrutiny, given the environments that each one of these endeavors is now trying to exist and be effective in. Thank you, John. Sarah?

1:31:06 Yeah, I agree with John on that point. I think ESTA is probably the only one of these NGOs that has a quantifiable, like that has a formula where we can see sort of what our money is getting. I just, I can't.

1:31:23 I can't forget the embarrassment of like having this discussion about MLT's contract. And then the next week, I think it was the Don't Be a Bleep Hole campaign came out and I get to be in the position of trying to defend, you know, this carte blanche that this organization has that a bunch of people were embarrassed about. Like, and I still don't know how much that cost.

1:31:50 And where that money came from. So, I mean, I guess what I would love to see is, okay, so that, you know, 2.671, what exactly did that go to? And what's the return on investment on all of those points, on all of those items that that went to? I mean, is that something that would be satisfactory to the council if we have a...

1:32:21 You know, a line item by line item like we see in the town budget where this money is going to? Frankly, I don't understand what purpose that would serve. Again, I mean, I guess I'm not interested in doing that until we really establish the strategic and the leadership direction of what it is that we're trying to do.

1:32:48 I think we need to do that first. We do that first. For me, what I would like to see is we're not just throwing this money into a void, but we have an accurate accounting of what we're getting for it. I think the same with Mammoth Lakes Housing. I would like to see, you know, what that money is going to, what our TOT is going to, because right now it seems to me like it's just, it's thrown in this pot.

1:33:13 Again, there's like no, I've heard since I moved to town, we can't quantify what we spend on tourism. You know, we can't quantify it. We can't quantify it. And I just, I think that's lazy and I just don't buy it. Well, let me make a suggestion. Why don't we get our act together in terms of what our expectation should be for each of those three areas. And then when we go down into the weeds to say, okay,

1:33:43 We need to be doing this. This is what the council wants to be doing in these three program areas. Look at what's in the budgets or what's in the kind of detailed accounting you're saying and saying, okay, well, that is, and this has to go back to the scope of work with the agreements that we have with these organizations and say, you know what? We don't need that one so much anymore. We want to go over here.

1:34:03 With the scope of agreement. So we, when we're looking and doing an analysis as you're describing, Sarah, we're doing it with a lens of where it is we want to go. It's a yes and proposition. We want to be going in these directions. Now let's start taking a look at the scopes of works and say what is consistent or not consistent with where it is we want to go. And that I could support. Go ahead, Sarah. No, please, after you. As long as in that where to go.

1:34:37 We continue the conversation about how it is we fund to get there because that is critical. If we make decisions today that somehow, and we're not making any decisions today, but if we make decisions in the near term that changes how we fund something that has been successful and then we start losing our market share, which we have done in the past, then the money that we're using for these other programs goes away faster.

1:35:06 I don't think anyone's talking about cutting out tourism.

1:35:36 Every year we come up with a wish list of items and we bring that to the funder and we say, this is what we want to do this year. Can we have X, Y, Z? Can we have 13,000? Can we have 20,000? Can we have 2.67 million? And we come to that funder and we say, this is what we want to do. Can we have this money? And they say, you can have this, this, and this, or you can have all of it. I mean, what about that?

1:36:03 Doesn't that seem like a reasonable? Then we have our NGOs coming to us saying, you know, this year, MLH, we want to retrofit these apartments. Can we have this money? And out of the 4.05%, we can allocate that. MLT comes, we want to do this ad buy, this ad buy. We want to get into this market. We want to fund this. Can we have it? And then we get to all sit down and make the decision. That way we know.

1:36:31 What does it cost, right? That's what we keep asking. What does it cost? And so the onus is on them to say, this is what it costs. Can we have this? Is that a radical idea? No, Chair, that is actually what I'm looking for from all of us from this meeting. What you're saying is you would like to see MLT, as an example, come forward with a proposal that costs us X amount of money. I would love that. And then approve it or not approve it. That is.

1:37:03 Dare I say it, I don't want your head to get too big, that is leadership. That is not, bring me just more information. Mr. Mayor, if I could, I think that is, I think that is fundamentally bass-ackwards. I think that's a fundamental application of our responsibility. We have to, the council has to say, this is where we want to go. And if they want to bring us proposals that align with council articulated policy, fine.

1:37:32 But this is not the North Pole and we're not all playing Santa Claus here. We have to set the direction of what we think is in the best interest of the community. Am I wrong? I mean, isn't that what we're supposed to be doing here? If I may. I think what we're talking about is that it is our job to administer or to set policy. You know, we're still talking about Wheaties stuff a little bit. We're getting down into it. But the policy of a council would be.

1:38:03 That the money that we receive through TOT will be spent in a certain way, you know, and spell it out, you know, considering successes, you know, working closely on a scope of work with achievable and measurable goals.

1:38:22 That that is where we start with establishing our policy, that these contracts will be managed well, that they will hit a timeline, that they will, I mean, all these things that we have not done in the administration of this money to date. So we can do better at that. And if it is about, you know, that maybe, you know, we need to talk to the, well, we would, we would need to talk to the angels around what their specific plan might be and work.

1:38:49 You know, collaboratively believe them to come up with something that makes sense. It's not them to tell us what they're going to do. It's not us to tell them exactly what to do. It's a collaboration between the town and these NGOs in a way that is productive. And that's our policy. The policy is what we need to really think about. And we don't have enough information at this point.

1:39:10 To get into decision making, but yet the policy, I think we can work on doing that first. And I think other things will come out of that because I think that's where, I think that's the kind of the missing linchpin here that we haven't well established what that policy would be. So then the question that we need to come up with is eventually is, are we saying the NGO model no longer works for us? We don't want to fund a nonprofit to do our work. We want to more designate.

1:39:42 I think that model is not broken, necessarily, but it's certainly in the administration of it from

1:40:12 Our level has been a bit broken than the way we crafted relationships with those NGOs. There were reasons to put those NGOs in place when we did, and I'm not sure that I am convinced that that's no longer valid, but that's another conversation also. Mr. Mayor, if I might jump into this conversation. Yes, please, Kirk. When we look at the different expenditures, it's very difficult when we look at

1:40:44 The town are core service levels and we can, you know, police response time, we measure a lot of those different things. When somebody comes to the counter, somebody, you know, greets them as well as a turnaround on a developer proposal. Transit is ridership, you know, the amount of ridership that we actually have.

1:41:07 Housing, we have 11 units that will be coming forward hopefully in a year or 10 months on the Alpers property as well as the parcel, 80 units in two years. When it comes to tourism, it's incredibly difficult to measure. Right now, I think the fact that going through a pandemic and everything else and our budget is three and a half million dollars over what was projected.

1:41:37 Then, you know, the tourism can, could, you know, ask credit for that. So I'm not in, I'm not, I'm not worried, or I think tourism is the hardest thing to measure, you know, if you put a billboard down in Huntington Beach, I mean, is that going to bring people in and how do you measure it? So tourism is very difficult and this conversation has happened over and over again and again.

1:42:06 I support Mammoth Lake Tourism. I support the previous councils and the votes that people have voted on to provide those funding. I'd hate to see us begin to not compete against some of our competition up in Colorado and everything else. So, you know, I have a very difficult time to start manipulating the tourism budget.

1:42:35 Based on the political commitments, as well as, you know, I would have to say success. Thank you. Thank you, Kirk. Still on TOT. Any comments on how we get to where you want to go? Other than somebody providing us with information that really isn't available to help us make decisions. Well, Mr. Mayor, if I could, the requests I made for further discussion, are those, are we still moving?

1:43:09 I'd just like to know before we wrap this up, where are we going here? We don't have to define it. We don't have to stop now, but I just want to, are we generally, those three points I laid out, do we have a consensus to have further discussion on those items? So, John, if I go through your three points, and I'm going to jump in here quick because otherwise my mind won't work. You know, one of your recommendations is a revision with how we contract. So what I would be looking for from you is how do you see that revision?

1:43:40 Okay, so very specifically, I would like to have a recommendation back from the administration of the timeline for contracting such that agreements are in place in May or April or they are completely divorced from

1:44:01 The budgeting process and approvals having to do with fiscal years. So completely revisiting of the timing of that. I would also like to understand the administration, the specific workshop meetings that we need to have with those folks that we contract with. I believe with the tourism folks, we were supposed to have had a quarterly meeting already and we're six months into the year. The protocols we've put into those contracts to have good collaborative discussions with our NGOs,

1:44:31 None of that stuff has happened. So it's not about whether we contract, Bill, to be clear. I'm not talking about that. I'm talking about how do we actually manage and engage with the people we're contracting with. That's the first point. That's what I'm asking for. And I'm assuming that Dan and his team could come back with some suggestions for that. That's the first point. Thank you. And I'm assuming we can do that. Having a timeline.

1:45:01 For when we deal with each one of these people we contract with is probably an important thing. From a meeting standpoint and timeline, I'm not sure we can have long enough meetings on a quarterly basis to meet a quarterly meeting thing, but that's something we need to decide as a council. Yeah, because we can't, I mean, to Linda's point, we're not going to have any kind of effective, you know, our role in these agreements.

1:45:29 Once we establish...

1:45:31 Look, these are our expectations. These are the things that we want to be doing. We're not going to micromanage stuff. It's going to be something that we can deal with in an hour, maybe a 90-minute workshop with our contractors to say, look, how are we doing on these points that are in your deliverables? And again, the deliverables have to be written in such a way, not just for the agreement's purpose, but also for the ability of the counsel, the person we're contracting with, to be able to engage with these things.

1:46:00 So we can, as Linda's saying, we can set relative expectations that are, how are we doing? Doing good this way? Doing good that way? You know, we have to be able to do that, or then I would say the NGO model is not as solid as maybe we thought.

1:46:15 If we can't manage, if we can't do at least that level of management and hold up our end of the bargain, I mean, the meeting I think that Sarah brought up when we had that discussion about with MOT turned to the discussion about housing, that was supposed to be a meeting we were looking at the very specific deliverables in the agreement. So come on, we got to do a better job with this. That's point number one. That's what's in point number one. For me, as someone who manages grants in my day job, I have to report to my funder.

1:46:47 What I'm spending, exactly what I'm spending the money on. So what our relationship looks like to me is we're the funder of these NGOs. And I just, I don't see why it's so radical to want to get a report of where our money is, like what exactly we're spending our money on. If I could add to you, there's one kind of point of qualification. We're not, these are not grants.

1:47:18 These are contracts. We are a client and they're a contractor. So I think there's a nuance in there, Sarah. I deal with grants myself all the time. I think that there's a difference with this type of relationship. Sorry, Linda, I interrupted. My apologies. Oh, no. The only thing I was going to say is being on the MLT board, they are very much in a position to be able to do that. At our monthly board meetings, the...

1:47:46 The expenditures, the budget, everything is very clearly presented. If we were asking them to bring that, I think they would very easily be able to report to us and say, this is what we spent this quarter, this is what it was spent on, these were the deliverables, these were the products that we produced. I don't think that that would be a stretch, but it is upon us to stick to the schedule that we set with them and expect them to come to us. I think it is us who have not

1:48:15 Asked and presented opportunities to do that. I think that is on the town management of these contracts rather than on that particular NGO. So between Sarah and Linda, what I'm hearing here is that what would be helpful with that one particular NGO is as they give their financial updates and reports to their own board, that we be CC'd on those things so that we have that information in front of us.

1:48:43 I don't necessarily think we just have to ask for it, I think. Yeah, I don't need to have a meeting with them unless something comes up in their budget that I don't like. But to have that automatically sent to me would be a plus. I get it because I called John and I asked for it. Yeah, and I get it. And I believe we used to have it. It seems to me when I was first on town council, there was much more.

1:49:08 Many more times that MLT came to council and reported off to us on what their activities and things were. I'm not sure what happened there exactly. Because like when we discussed potentially, you know, cutting their budget by 300K, like what does that look like to them? Is that a full-time employee? Is that an ad buy? Is that, you know, what does that look like? And how much does that hurt? And what?

1:49:37 Yeah, what percent, you know, what, how much does that hurt? And, and I think, you know, it goes back to Linda's question from July is, or from even prior to that, what, what does it cost to do what you're doing? Because I, I agree, I think I'm not a, I don't have experience as a contract manager, so this is obviously new to me and I don't think doing a fantastic job at it, but I certainly.

1:50:07 I certainly have trouble. We still have not answered that question. What does it cost? And it's been 11 years that I've been hearing, you know, we have no way to quantify what these people do, 11 years that I've been here. And I just, again, I have to say, I don't buy it. I think that there's got to be some way, at least so we can see, you know, what exactly this money is. What does this buy?

1:50:38 So if you guys used to see that, great. I would love to have that in front of me. I would say that that is sort of in process. I think trying to determine that is in process. I certainly realize that it's very hard to quantify it in an industry like that, but I don't think it's impossible. And it may not be as...

1:50:59 You know, widget-driven as some, you know, industries can certainly provide. I think that there's, you know, achievable outcomes and deliverables, and I think you can get a better handle on it. You know, going back to June, I can say that in spite of the fact that I did support that, it would have been, you know, difficult for MLT to say, okay, this...

1:51:17 You know, we've already probed our budget. You guys didn't, you know, get to us to help us work this out earlier. Now you're saying you want to take this money away. They would have had to scramble and cut here, cut there, and maybe break some, you know, pre-existing contract. I mean, it would not have been ideal, granted, possible, but not fair, really, at the end of the day, but in some ways. But, you know, that's why we're going to do better now, and we're going to move ahead and try to fill in some of these blanks, I hope, which will be another one of these points, I hope, Bill, for subsequent meetings.

1:51:48 I'm curious what other peer organizations do to, you know, let their shareholders know what, like, what their return on investment is. I don't know if John already could speak to that or, like, what your counterparts are doing in similar industries because there's plenty of, you know, tourism entities around the country and the world.

1:52:15 They can't all be saying we have literally no idea how to show you what your return on investment is. But as a business person, and I've been in business both in nonprofits and my own business and manage other people's businesses for the last 50 years, it has been impossible for me to say when I do an ad buy or when I do anything to promote my business what the effect of that specific ad is. You hope that your overall approach brings you more customers.

1:52:44 Of course, now I'm advertising for people to stay away. But that's just a change in my perspective. But it's just as a businessman, and maybe there are others that can answer it, to try and determine what one specific piece you're doing, what your return on that particular investment is. We can get John Urdi to come in here and say, well, for every dollar we spend, look at what our TOT is, here's your return. But that doesn't take into account the...

1:53:12 The word of mouth, the, you know, the other organic things that go on to bring people here. It's just, I have a hard time asking someone to quantify something that I've never been able to get a hand on. Maybe it's my own thick headedness. Well, I mean, I think we're spending a lot of time on something that could probably be more easily explained and or discussed with MLT who have, I'm sure, lots of studies and lots of return on investment.

1:53:42 That are out there that we would not have a reason to be aware of what that is. So I think we're probably, you know, getting a little bit down into it when we could push this up a little further. Lynn, I just want to raise my hand, Bill, just to reiterate that. I think that we do not belong down in there. Information's available. We can find it out. We don't have a whole lot of time. We have important policy and things like that to set. We need to be working over in the space that is...

1:54:13 The space that we need to be working in. Okay. Anyone from council want to comment anymore on TOT before I open it for public comment? So next steps here, we're going to put together some meetings with these points we've been talking about here and continue the conversation. Is that where we are here? I believe that's where we are at. Dan? Yeah, we'll follow up with that layout of some of the topics and items identified there. And also just to the scheduling of the items, the next...

1:54:45 Formalized schedule with MLT is actually set for November, and they will be presenting on November 17th, kind of a look at where they've been last year, and a little bit of, I think, kind of looking into the winter, hopefully. But that is the next scheduled presentation with them. We've talked about, from the council setting, other workshops with each of our NGOs, so that'll also be coming forward. We gave you a schedule a couple months ago to lay that out. To do that.

1:55:14 And a lot of the questions you've raised, yeah, we'll worm those up and structure that into you can have that type of discussion touching on the, I'll say, needs and desires of each of that we've heard. There's overlap and then there's some individuals. So if there's something you don't want to talk about, we can take that off the table down the road if we need to. But at this point, I think we have a pretty good list of items that you need to have a more policy discussion on.

1:55:42 Mr. Mayor, I'm wondering if Dan could just read back. Dan, what do you have on that list exactly? Well, John, the point that you had walking through that in terms of the contracting for services, the program, how do we actually go through that process, having them done in a timely fashion, relate the timeliness of those contracts, the ongoing meetings and follow-up throughout the years, scheduling that out, the, excuse me.

1:56:17 Ultimately, as we deal with tourism and stuff and the TV and the relationships of a lot of these elements to each other, we need to talk about how do they work together? How do they complement? How are they different? The request of the town attorney, for example, to provide some of that relationship there as well to work through that. A point to discuss, I don't know if there's a particular hard question in that, but that whole idea, I think Bill and John both referenced.

1:56:45 The idea of the amount of the TOT generation, the work that MLT puts into that, but really the resulting of that is the revenues and the resources we have to do other things, such as housing, that are basically our economic structure. Definitely Linda wanted to work in that and deal with the vehicle that we use to fund our NGOs to have that discussion.

1:57:12 I think it's the contract issue, but also to question the automatic amount of dollars tied to a percentage or a number of points just automatically going into an organization. So looking at how do we structure that into an agreement and what does that look like, if that needs to be changed or not. And for that and leading into Sarah's comments, how do we quantify some level of that success?

1:57:42 You know, if we have a great snow year, we didn't need to do marketing. If we have a lousy snow year, we didn't market enough. So there's some elements in that we need to work through in terms of just what does that look like? And if we take that to the higher level, I think a couple of folks have mentioned this, is where are we really going with our tourism investment? And I think that helps feed into Sarah's comment then, what is that ROI? What is that return on that investment? And how do we begin to measure that?

1:58:10 Not just in dollars and cents probably, but also is it taking us as a community and you as a council where you want to go? Asking that question. The other element, I think in that relationship of the funder and fundee is important, the grantee. We have a contract, but we don't really treat them as contractors in the terms of here's a deliverable, here's an hourly schedule, send us an invoice.

1:58:41 Explain exactly where the dollars went, then we pay an invoice. It's a little different relationship between the town and those contractors. We do set out deliverables. We do set out expectations. We can do a better job of that. And then how does that meet certain goals, I think, that we've been weak on establishing and measuring back against and begin to do that. And then

1:59:07 Bottom line, we will get some information to you, and the agencies can provide that as well, and just in terms of their funding, their sources of revenue, and their budgets, and those types of elements. That may or may not give the level of detail that's being asked for to look at or review, but that information is definitely available. So that kind of frames up, I think, the discussion. We'll have to spend more time in laying those items out in terms of framing them up in questions and policy discussions. Thank you, Dan.

1:59:37 John, your hand is up again, or it just isn't down yet. No, thank you. Just one thing I think that'll be helpful, Dan, is that each one of those three program areas are really different. Correct. We talked about transit. It's easily measurable. There's a lot of very, you know, it's easy to deal with data. Marketing is much more amorphous and ethereal. And housing is probably somewhere in between. So I think it would be helpful.

2:00:06 As you bring these things back, this kind of set the stage a little bit for council, okay, you're talking about transit. This is the kind of program you're talking about. Pretty easily measurable. We've got this need probably coming off the buses, as Phil has talked about. This is the nature of the kinds of conversation that would be helpful for staff to hear as we start figuring out what to do. And marketing, we've had a lot of discussion about that tonight, so that's...

2:00:34 That's what that is. But I think on the housing thing, I think that that's, again, it's somewhere in between. But I think if you could be sort of setting the table that's specific to the idiosyncratic nature of these endeavors, I think that would be helpful. Kind of looking for head nods if there's agreement on that. Yeah, we can definitely walk. Because they are different types of services and functions that they provide, as you mentioned. And then there's different relationships of how much of that the town supports and doesn't get heavily engaged in on some of those areas.

2:01:05 Yeah, Dan, and I would, a timeline coming back of when we're going to start our conversation on dealing with each of these entities is big, and we all have diverse opinions. I think at some point the conversation of what we view Mammoth as in 20 years, because that lends itself into the discussion of how we're going to fund or if we're going to fund these organizations. Linda.

2:01:37 Yeah, just one more point before I forget about this, and that was that when we're, you know, preserving the percentage to the pot, like 2.35 goes to the tourism pot, if you will. What are some of the menu of things that can be that, you know, considered to be tourism besides, you know, funding our NGO? So, Dan, you had, I know, talked about that a little bit and, you know,

2:02:07 How can you use tourism and still help me out here? Okay. If we wanted to say, okay, part of our tourism expenditure is helping to clean the restrooms in the lakes basin because that improves the experience of our guests. So that would be tourism. Could that also be something along, okay, because to have a quality experience as a tourist, you want to have service, you know, staff.

2:02:33 In facilities, in restaurants, in hotels that can help also improve and augment an experience that a guest has here. Is that then an expenditure of tourism dollars also? So to have places for people to live. So maybe we could brush through that a little bit too and help to understand what that tourism money set aside can be actually used for. And of course, the short answer is it can be used for anything that council decides.

2:03:05 Tourism. And honoring what the tourism, you know, dollars were. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. If I could just build on that a little bit, which I think is in the spirit of this discussion. Dan, I think it would be helpful to start having conversations about roles and responsibilities. So, Linda, to your point, if, okay, we're going to contract with somebody, say, MLT to do marketing to do this stuff, but the definition of tourism is broad.

2:03:35 And there's some other things that are going to need to get done. Okay, good. A, council, identify what those other things are. Let's say that it's housing, for example. Let's say that it's having a sustainable recreation destination. Okay, well, then who is going to own making sure that those things get done? Because this is really important, because this gets into authorities. Someone like Mammoth Lakes Housing doesn't have any authorities, except as it showed up.

2:04:04 Kirk can speak to what those are. The town has authority. So if we're going to say we want this out of a contract relationship, great, but we still need to take care of this. We have to say who's going to pick up the slack and who's going to own those things that are in the gaps because we have to be.

2:04:24 Delegating a, you know, the delivery of a comprehensive program, which I don't have any problem with. I think that's a good conversation to have. We just need to say, okay, well, this isn't going to live over here with this contractor, this entity. Who's going to own it? Who's going to pick up the slack to ensure that it's going to get done? So, Dan, I think that'd be really, for all of us to be helpful to understand how are we going to use a variety of different tools to deliver these things that we're talking about.

2:04:53 And one other thing I would add is semantics, terms of art. You know, so we, Dan and I talked today about infrastructure. Well, infrastructure means very something very different when you're talking about prevailing wage and you're talking about putting things in the ground versus infrastructure that may be stuff that's involved with a marketing campaign or a housing program or something. We just need to be very clear about exactly what we're talking about, who's going to own it, who's going to do it. Thank you. Okay.

2:05:24 Wrapping this up some, I will open this for public comments on the TOT section. Phil Moores, you can go ahead and unmute yourself. Thanks, everyone. Just a final comment in the spirit of quantifying and measuring performance of the NGOs. I am going to get Dan a vehicle replacement plan that will give us the cost out both diesel and electric.

2:05:54 What that cost and what that transit fund needs to look like in a few years to cover that so that he can consider that for his recommendation on the TOT percentage for us. I'll get that to him in the next week or two. Oh, one more thing too. We work on a fiscal year. I don't remember if Mammoth does the same, but we are June to July. So contract discussions in February, you know, in finalizing.

2:06:23 Our contract so that I can bring a preliminary budget to my board in March, April timeframe. And so kind of the beginning of the new year is a good cycle for ESTA. So if we can calendarize that, I'd be happy with that. Thank you, Phil. Thanks, Phil. I just want to say I think ESTA is the way that that is a great example. And I think the way that ESTA is operating and I understand that tourism and housing aren't.

2:06:52 Exactly the same and able to do it in the exact same way. But I think that the way that we're funding ESTA is sort of what we should be looking to do with the other two NGOs. Thank you. We do have the same challenge in determining how ridership

2:07:11 Grows and shrinks. You know, you can never really put your finger on it exactly why ridership is increasing or decreasing. Call it gas prices, call it the fare, call it recession. You know, there's so many nebulous things about it, but we do agree and feel comfortable on a level of marketing or a level of funds spent that we feel is effective.

2:07:37 And that, and not more and not less, really. What's effective? And what do we believe is effective? And it maybe comes down to a faith thing, like, you know, do we believe that we're spending an effective amount? And if we spent less, our ridership would go down. Or if we spent more, it would go up, you know, and what am I comfortable with? And that's just kind of my approach. Thanks, Bill. If I can just piggyback on that real quick, because I think it leads into a lot of the discussion you have on that is...

2:08:04 We have a transit system that's been very effective, I think, in terms of moving people on those routes and how do we structure that to make that happen, the partnerships that we do. And it's easy to say we're going to contract for X number of hours of service, X dollars per hour. But it may raise a bigger question down the road to say, is this the most effective way actually to move people around Sam's Lakes? Maybe you don't buy any large buses anymore. Do you use a different mechanism for moving people? And think through how's the best way?

2:08:34 Not just to provide our bus service that we currently do, but do we look at systems and say, how do we move people reliably and effectively between point A and point B, how they want to move and where they want to go? And maybe the current model isn't quite the best either, or should we take a look at that? Again, I think it was Sarah that made the comment earlier, what are some of our other peer resorts doing? Are they moving people?

2:09:03 Differently, and our goal, I think it's a good goal, and I would support it, is how do we continue to do that on a free basis? How do we move people around so when they do get here, we see a reduction in their use of their personal vehicle. If you can bring your car here, great, park it, unless you want to go out to Bodie or something, you know, great, go do that, but maybe not in the winter. But how do we end up moving people maybe even more effectively? In different times, I've had requests from people who...

2:09:31 They've got to be at work at 3 in the morning or 4 in the morning. There is no transit available. And once they get there, they're great parking for a few hours. And once they're there, come 7, 8, 9 o'clock, now they get a ticket because they're parked illegally. Is there a way we could actually meet that transit need? These are more broader, definitely higher level questions and stuff. But do we look at how do we provide some of the services? We've done that a little bit with the housing side, just given the role the town's played.

2:09:59 Same questions could go back to MLT. How do we provide marketing and everything else? Are we staffed appropriately versus contracting out more or bringing more in? You could look at those types of elements as well. And as you get to effective use of why right now we have a fairly good source of resources, but not necessarily all the case all the time. And how do we effectively utilize it? And then you go back to the earlier question.

2:10:28 Where do you want to go? Where do you want to be at X point in the future? And how do all these things, again, at least in this narrower area, how do all these things move you in that direction? And I'd like to say that I definitely think that Mammoth has a successful model in moving that large number of people. We move about 48 passengers per hour.

2:10:51 Microtransit, for example, can never do better than about eight or nine people per hour. I don't care if you have a thousand cars, you can only move about eight or nine people per hour. So, I mean, the big buses we have that are filling and moving people is a good model. In fact, Big Bear Resorts have just contracted with Mountain Area Transit to do the exact same thing we're doing. They're offering free transit. They've partnered with Alira, you know, and they're...

2:11:18 And they're looking to do the exact same thing we're doing because it works. Now, if you want to have night owl service and you want to have service in early mornings or late nights, you're really, you're donating that service in a sense because you'll never get the ridership.

2:11:33 You know, to really say, yeah, this is worth it. There's just not enough people in the middle of the night. You know, I've done that in Orange County. We did a night owl service. And there are people that get off work after we finish or need to get work before we start. And there's a need there. And then we'll just have to balance the cost in relation to the number of constituents you'd be serving with that service. And I'm not saying it doesn't work, though. I'm just saying, do we take a look at these areas of how do we provide services as we look at growing costs and demands and changes in that?

2:12:03 I kind of wanted to say that because there are people that think it doesn't work. I've heard recently some people in pretty important positions say they want to revolutionize or change the way transit's done in Mammoth. And from my perspective and my experience, the model that we have is a good model and it works. And I'm not pointing that at you, Dan. I just wanted to throw it out there. I want to cut this one short because now we're getting down into the nitty-gritty of running a service. That's me.

2:12:31 Thank you. Sorry. I'm going to move it along to more public comments. Yeah, Linda, go ahead. No, no, I was just going to say, do we have any public comments? Yeah. Yes. John Urdi, you may go ahead and unmute yourself. Thank you. I appreciate the conversation tonight, and I think the biggest thing that I want to put out there is that while, you know, there's been a lot of talk about the tracking of our budgets or the nebulous nature of marketing,

2:12:58 You know, none of those are insurmountable. We have incredible tracking. Our budgets are probably more line item than detail than anyone else in town. You know, we have every single dollar spent every month, every department, every line item drilled down probably more than my staff would care to do, but that's what we do. You know, there's no just marketing line. It's marketing with about 600 different codes and lines to it.

2:13:23 I do too, and I think that we have a lot of new council members, and actually even having Linda join our board, you know, the last time we were able to do our ROI and add effectiveness studies was back in fiscal year 2018-19, and so we do have that information, and I've got the presentation on November 17th, and while that information is not as current as we'd like to see, obviously COVID through a wrench in the works for our, you know, every two-year study on that,

2:13:52 We do have a tremendous amount of information as far as our cost effectiveness on ad buys, how much money we spend, how many households we reach, all of those different pieces. So the information is there and we can present, you know, again, the information that I'll show you on the 17th is more of an example of what we can do. And we will do that again next fall once we get through another winter and hopefully have a fairly normalized situation.

2:14:17 You know, we do have the ROI numbers for every dollar you spend with MLT, what it brings back to the community. We have it by business segment. We know how many people are coming to town, what they're spending in restaurants, retail, ski area, activities, lodging, transportation, et cetera. And so as nebulous as marketing might be sometimes, we do have quite a bit of detail into the ad effectiveness. You know, we compare to Councilmember Ray's comment, we compare our

2:14:46 So we can see how we are comparing to whether it's Lake Tahoe or Indianapolis or Orlando or New York City or Chicago, we can actually see how our dollars are being spent. And for the most part, the study that I'll show you on the 17th will show

2:15:14 That we tend to outlast the national averages. So we are very effective with the dollars. You know, I think if you start to look at whether they're dollars well spent, I don't think there's any question that they're dollars well spent. And so we can show that. And as I mentioned, we will continue to do that research. We spend a tremendous amount of money on research because we don't work off of opinion. We don't work off of our own ideas. Doesn't matter what I think.

2:15:41 It really depends on what the market thinks we should be doing and what the things that are going to be responding to are. So that's all I wanted to say. But the budgets are always available. Again, they're lined up and out from overhead to marketing, sales, PR, events, all the way down through. And like Linda said, in our P&Ls, we have our board meeting next Wednesday. We will be doing our Q1 budget variance report.

2:16:09 The $7.3 million budget, any line item within that budget that is over or under budget by more than $5,000 will be explained. And that may sound like an undaunting task, but it's about 15 items, and a lot of them are actually positive. So I think that I'd encourage the council members to watch our board meetings, because I think there's a lot of information that they can glean from that. But I do look forward to the November 17th opportunity to speak with the board.

2:16:41 Thank you, John. Any further public comments? None at this time. Thank you very much. Moving on, then, we should have next a brief conversation on TBED and short-term rentals. Yes, Mr. Mayor, given the robustness of that last discussion, these can probably be a little more narrow. They definitely are key items as we're looking forward. The TBED itself is really a powerful tool that's...

2:17:12 Business community brought forward, and I think it was following the economic downturn and the litigation issues here facing the town. It was initiated through that process. Other folks here were involved more in that creation than myself. It was put into effect September 2013. I believe we started actually collecting TBD revenues. It was renewed again for another five-year term and then could be renewed for a five- or a ten-year.

2:17:41 Thank you.

2:18:11 You know, the Town Council has a fair amount of say, I think, and influence in that process, and obviously, if you engage in the discussions with businesses, it's probably one of the best things to do, and how people see the value and the benefit, as well as the other elements that TBID goes into. A TBID can fund a whole lot of things legally. The current one is more narrowly tailored in terms of the air subsidy and the marketing and promotional work.

2:18:38 There's a lot of other things that can be done. If that would be a priority, how does that get discussed? But the other side for the TBID, too, is when you do that, there's a couple requirements. One of those, it comes forward. The council has a process to go through. You can make changes to that. Generally, you like reducing the size or modifying a rate downward versus increasing things. The legal structure gives you some levels of work through that. And as I requested earlier,

2:19:08 Andy Stelan, he could walk through a number of those types of elements. The other side of that is ultimately because it's an assessment being collected by the town. There is a contract required between the town and the owner's association that actually runs the TBID. In this case, that's Mammoth Lakes Tourism. If that's the agency called out in the business plan or the...

2:19:31 Management District plans, and that's who we contract with to do the work. If it was silent, you would contract, you could create one or a contract with another non-profit to actually be that manager and that implementation of the TBID. I think the key issue there is the TBID provides a lot, a substantial amount of funding, that four and a half plus million dollars, or it can be as high as five or so, and how that works and how it's utilized, and there's different elements.

2:19:58 Legally, it goes through, but also ultimately that district management plan, which comes to the council for review and comment on. And there's elements in that that we can definitely have those discussions with. I think the other side of that is, what's the expectations for the implementation when you have a contract with the owners association for the implementation? There is a legal requirement for an annual report to come back, and it calls out a number of things it needs to be.

2:20:26 Reported back to the town council or filed in with the clerk's office. And I think we, again, I think we get that. It's often blended in with Mammoth Lakes Tourism as the destination marketing organization created by the town versus the owner's association board that actually runs the TBID. And while they're the same, there is distinctives, I think, between those two organizations and what their purposes are, what their goals are, and then the legal structure.

2:20:55 Around the funding. One of the elements there with TBID, it does have more legal requirements on it. And where the TOT allocation comes in is it actually does provide some more flexibility in that area than what the TBID does. I think the other key area to the TBID is similar to what some of our other assessment districts are, our benefit assessment districts, etc.

2:21:22 It has to provide a benefit back to those who have been assessed the fees for those services. So there's a special benefit conferred back to the payers of the assessments. And that's one of the key issues when you look at the assessment districts. It's the same thing when you look at, say, Old Mammoth Road. There's an assessment district. Those funds have to provide benefit back to those people who pay.

2:21:49 There can be some level of general benefit. If you do this right, everybody's property taxes go up because of value of property going up, and that's a general benefit. But the special benefits have to be conferred back into the businesses that pay. The other key example that was referenced earlier, subsidy of the airport and air services versus the airport, the air services. There is a study done talking to people of where they're coming from, where are they going.

2:22:19 And to the extent that those are tourism-related visits and they're actually benefiting the businesses in Mammoth Lakes, that's where that subsidy comes from, to the extent that you or I, who were not tourists but were using those air services, we would not be eligible to count against that subsidy. And if it runs, John could give me a better number at this point, probably Ernie, but it's probably, you know, 17 to 20 percent of the passenger load is non-tourism related in terms of either

2:22:47 Destination in Mammoth and or it's from local people utilizing it who don't qualify for that. So I think as the council engages with the TVA, it's something that has definitely benefited the community. It's definitely a fixed revenue source. It's one that you don't really have a lot of authority of how it gets used throughout the year, but the front end of the management of it. And in the creation of an update to a management district plan, you can definitely have influence and input in those types of...

2:23:16 And it does, you know, complement and...

2:23:45 Overlap to some degree with what we do from our destination management organization or the MLT funded by the town dollars versus the owner's association, same board, but the owner's association that is tasked with managing and implementing the district management plan under the TBID. Andy, please correct or add in. Yeah, just a couple things to add.

2:24:11 So the council's role in oversight of the TBID is a little bit limited. I'm not saying there's no role. They have to prepare that report every year that the council then needs to bless. But the council doesn't really have the ability to unilaterally amend the plan of services that are going to be provided, what's called a management district plan. The council has the most leverage when it's time to form or renew a TBID because, of course, the council can say, we're not going to form this or we're not going to renew this.

2:24:39 If the management district plan doesn't contain things in it that we think are of value. So you don't have any obligation at all to renew one or to extend one. And that's when you can say, we're just really not seeing the point of what you're trying to do. About the benefit, as Dan said, it is like an assessment district in that it has to benefit the payors. And it gets a little bit tricky when the payors are all the people in the tourism industry.

2:25:07 Townwide, because then it is mostly marketing. That's what most of the ones around the state do. I can tell you, because I don't think this is confidential, that the truckie one has talked about, is there a way to use some of this money for housing? And I've told them, you know, I don't represent them, so I can't give them legal advice. I've told them, maybe, but you're going to have to be real careful, because it has to, again, benefit only the people who are paying. And up here, it's the lodging community. In Mammoth, of course, it's broader than that.

2:25:37 So your creativity and your imagination about how to use these funds is a little bit limited in that it all comes back to benefiting the people that pay. There can't be a kind of general benefit that might accrue to other members of the public. It really is benefiting the lodging community. And so there are different TBIDs around the state that have kind of different ideas about what to do, but it's not like an assessment district where the council...

2:26:06 Might have a little bit more control over it. Thank you, Andy. Opening it for council questions or comments. John? Andy, thank you very much. I hope that we all heard what Andy just said, because our opportunity is going to be with the renewal. And correct me if I'm wrong, Andy, but...

2:26:35 We need to be factoring that renewal in with our discussions around, you know, allocations of TOT. And we have to be strategic and smart about it. Again, I'll just bring up the example of a constituent coming to a council member after the future TPA has been approved and says, you know, what the hell is going on with this thing? And I just, I don't think we want to put future councils in a position of saying, well,

2:27:02 We don't have anything to do with that. You got to go talk to somebody else about that. We have to design this and we have to work with our partners to design this in such a way that it is truly, it's going to be additive. It's going to cover some of the gaps we've talked about tonight and it's going to fit into what we're doing with our TOT Measure A programs. We got to start fitting all this stuff together. So that's what I'm hearing. I'm really glad, Andy, this was succinct. This was great. And I think as we have future discussions,

2:27:32 To help us understand what we can and what we can't do and how do we work with the folks that are going to be setting it up to really make this thing work and make it just super effective going forward. Thank you. Thank you, John. Sarah? Any comments at this time? Thank you. Linda? Thank you very much. And thanks for this presentation on the TBIT. I think we all, myself, certainly have sort of, you know, put TBIT on, you know, in my mind on autopilot.

2:28:05 And didn't need much input from the council on any of that. So it's nice to kind of be reminded that we can indeed, you know, use that as a consideration in our other funding decisions and that the cumulative us of that is what's really important because I think that, you know, we have not sort of, I guess you could say, bothered our little heads about that. It got passed. That was great. And, you know, but I think that it's really good to know it.

2:28:34 What our position is. So Andy, thank you. And Dan, thank you for going to a little review, a little update session on this. I appreciate it. Thanks. Thank you, Linda. Kirk? I think the question is, does it benefit the people who pay? Is the benefits worth the financial investment? And that's something that the business community is going to have to answer. I think it's a good tool.

2:29:06 I think there are benefits, and those are my comments. Thank you, Kirk. My only comments here are to reiterate something that both Dan and Andy said. In the language of the law, and I hate reading this dry stuff, but in the language of the law, it says that it has to have a specific benefit to the businesses that pay in. So if we are going to try and tweak it in any way, we have to remember we have to be able to create that nexus.

2:29:36 Yeah, I'll very quickly

2:30:07 This here came up in part of the strategic planning discussions and others in looking at short-term rentals, questions of how many long-term rentals are converted to short-term and the impact it has on housing. The overall management, though, is from a town standpoint. We do a lot of enforcement work. We do a lot of elements that tie into those. A few years back, a lot of discussion on this resulted in the adoption of a quality-of-life ordinance. How do we manage the impact of short-term rentals on?

2:30:38 Neighborhoods and those types of elements that came forward. More recently, not so much here at this point, but other agencies, Andy can weigh on this shortly, there are agencies out there looking at putting stricter limits on the number of STRs, short-term rentals, in their community. There's others looking at, there's been restrictions in the past on you can do it for X number of days out of the year, a lot of different ways to manage it.

2:31:06 Generally directed back to a quality of life component of what that means for a neighborhood or will these types of limits impact our housing supply and those things. The other side of that is the STRs have been a piece of our growth in terms of opportunities for rental activity and bringing additional dollars in from that activity going on in the rental market, giving people greater choice with some of the questions. Well, if I can't do that with a

2:31:34 Short-term rental, like a VRBO or an Airbnb, I would look to go elsewhere where I can do that. It's just a choice in terms of how people like to vacation, travel, et cetera. But we have a lot of them in the town. I'm trying to remember, I think we're one of the highest in the state, if I remember correctly. Rob's shaking his head, yes, I think San Francisco is right up there with us, for example. Just a number of units out there, a little bit of stats in the staff report that I won't walk through.

2:32:03 So there is a push out there. Remember, Measure Z was in response to some of those efforts to say we're not going to allow it in certain areas in the town based on zoning. There may be other things we want to look at, and that's what we got, the quality of life ordinance. So there are limits you can do. You can have a lot of authority and control over those. And I'll ask Andy to pop back on to add to that and maybe give a little bit of an overview of what trucking is even looking at here recently, if you don't mind, Andy. Thank you.

2:32:30 Yeah, so the starting point for thinking about how to regulate STRs is that for at least 30 years now, it's been really clear from court cases that cities can completely ban STRs if they choose. And the corollary to that is that since cities can completely ban them, they can do just about anything that they like short of a full ban as well. So some cities still have a full ban. Carmel by the Sea is a good example of that.

2:32:56 Some cities are completely hands-off about it, which is what Truckee has been up until now. And then there are just a million different ways of regulating. South Lake Tahoe was moving too slow for some of the residents, and so there was a voter initiative that now bans all STRs outside the tourist core. Some cities do caps. Some cities do a combination of caps and locational constraints. Some only do locational constraints.

2:33:24 Because Truckee is in the process of evaluating how to regulate STRs and councils adopted a moratorium on the issuance and new permits, Truckee staff have been doing a bunch of research and collecting examples from other cities, which of course I'm happy to share the fruits of all that research if anyone would like to see them. In Truckee, the number is something like 8% of all housing units are registered as STRs. Mammoth, I dare say it's quite a bit higher.

2:33:51 And obviously, hardly even needs to be said, but because TOT provides, you know, by far the biggest source of income to the town, you might take into consideration, you know, how do you want to regulate these things and how does that affect kind of visitation and revenue? But like I said, I will provide the research that Truckee staff have done. You can look at some of the different models that are out there and just kind of be thinking about whether any of that

2:34:21 Could be adapted to serve the town. Thank you, Andy. Going now for comments, starting with John. Andy, a couple questions. Given where the town is now with our program, if we were to make changes, can you talk a little bit about the legal implications or things that we should consider from the perspective of what's called takings?

2:34:57 Given the program we've already established. Sure, happy to. So if anyone isn't really up on constitutional stuff, a taking occurs when the government kind of takes away all economic use of the property. And as long as the government leaves a property owner some use they can put their property to, the government has not made a taking. So sometimes people will say, well, you've hurt my property values and that.

2:35:25 Is a taking that you have to pay me for. And that's not the test. That's not how it works. The Supreme Court, that's the U.S. Supreme Court, reiterated back in the the TRPA temporary takings case in about 2003 that property ownership is thought of as a bundle of rights. You can use your property. You can sell your property. You can let other people use your property. And all those are kind of it's the analogy is those are sticks in the bundle. And the Supreme Court said again.

2:35:53 Taking away some of the sticks doesn't mean that you've committed to taking. As long as the property owner has some sticks, you're fine. The government is not committed to taking. And with regulating short-term rentals, the thing is that even if a property owner can't rent out the property, they always have the option to just use the property. A property owner can always stay in their property. They can allow their friends to stay in their property. They can visit it. So taking away the right to rent it out on a short-term basis

2:36:22 is not a taking. It doesn't create vested rights. Cities can do that. The interesting part comes in figuring out how to transition away from a less restrictive system to transitioning to a restrictive system. And there are different ways to do it. So some cities have chosen to go with, OK, everybody's grandfathered for a few years, and then we're going to have a lottery. And maybe the first year of the lottery is for 80% of the number of SQR permits that they have up until that point. And then maybe the year after that,

2:36:52 Okay, so.

2:37:21 Add to that Measure Z. Yeah, okay, so Measure Z, for people that may be new to this issue, was a voter initiative that the Mammoth Lakes voters adopted several years ago, and I don't want to speak for the voters, but I think it was in response to fears that I think were not well-founded, but there were fears that the council was maybe going to allow STRs to exist in single-family neighborhoods.

2:37:48 As you all know, I mean, condos can be STR in Mammoth Lakes, and single-family homes cannot, except in a couple of zones that don't have that many houses in them. So because Measure Z was approved by the voters, the council doesn't have the ability to override it. The council can't do anything, can't take any action that's inconsistent with Measure Z, only the voters can. And that means, and it was crafted very cleverly and very well. Can't make any, can't change the development code, can't

2:38:18 So essentially, because you can't expand the pool of things that can be short-term rented, really, if you're thinking about changing the size of the pool without voter approval, all you could do is shrink it because you're not allowed to read that. For example, you can't say, well, short-term rentals are allowed in this one zone, so we're going to rezone the trails, for example, and say it's now in that zone.

2:38:48 Measure Z says you can't do that. You can't change the rules that apply to a particular zone. You can't change the zones in a way that allows it. So that's kind of the effect of Measure Z. And if you were inclined to go out to the voters, I think that what cities that have had conversations with their voters about regulating short-term rentals have seen is that most of the people that own rental properties are not registered to vote in the cities where their rental properties are located.

2:39:17 I mean, some are, of course, but the majority are not. And so the people who are most affected by restrictions on short-term rentals are not actually able to vote. And it's the community as a whole that is able to vote. And they are the ones that kind of see the most effects. But that's kind of the overview. And this is a rich and complicated topic we can talk about more another time. OK, so real quick, what I heard was if we wanted to shrink the number of units for STRs,

2:39:46 That's something that could be considered without going to the voters. Does that sound about right? That's correct. And we received, at least I received a pretty interesting email from someone this afternoon about the potential to incentivize units that are zoned for short-term rentals to incentivize those things for long-term rentals. Is that something that we could think about and discuss? Yeah, absolutely. And that's not something you have to do.

2:40:14 In the context of changing how the town regulates short-term rentals. So there was a piece in the sheet two weeks ago that referred to some efforts underway in Breckenridge, but also some efforts underway in Truckee, where the town of Truckee has entered into a contract with a company called Landing Locals, and basically they go out and try to beat the bushes and find people who have STR units that are registered as STRs and offer them money to rent.

2:40:43 To take their unit out of the STR pool and rent it to somebody long-term. And I think the current amount is something like $3,000 the town will pay to get somebody to rent for a year. And now there are some restrictions on how much the rent amount can be, but it's been, this program's still relatively new. I think last I heard there were about 43 units that had been taken out of the STR pool and rented long-term that are now housing something like 68 local employees.

2:41:12 The people who are housed have to be, this has to be their primary residence. It can't, this doesn't work for a ski lease. I think there's some income qualifications, but it is a program that is kind of just starting to get underway, landing locals. I think Truckee was their second jurisdiction and now they're up to more than that. And of course, Nolan actually is really, really good about talking to his counterpart in Truckee. His name is Shawna. They talk pretty regularly and share ideas and I'm sure that Nolan can provide.

2:41:41 More details about the Truckee program. Yeah, I think that'd be an excellent one to follow up on. Thanks to the sheet and thanks for our good fortune to have you up there. And I think that this is something, you know, this is the kinds of things that we need to be talking about because the environment is constantly changing in those three spaces, housing, transit.

2:42:01 And marketing, I mean, it's super dynamic. So thanks to that. I think it's something I think we'd all be interested in trying to follow up on that. And especially with the chamber, with that program, Dan, we have with the chamber that they've worked on the last couple of years, maybe there's a compliment in there. Maybe there's a way we could do something with that program we've already got in place. Thank you. Sorry to take up so much time. Thank you, John. Sarah? I do want to comment that while I think that this is absolutely a good idea and it is like a tool in the toolbox.

2:42:31 I do want to just bring to the light the fact that this person's email is rentalarcher at gmail.com. So I feel like this is a program, while I would support perhaps thinking about using our creative housing fund to put some money towards that, I think we've had this discussion before where it does incentivize, I mean, it's essentially paying these landlords who have

2:43:00 Purchase their property to rent out, it's augmenting that market. Does that make sense? So we're, you know, we are, I think it's a good idea, but we are, it's probably paying people who...

2:43:17 I'm just gonna throw that out there. I think that it would give us an opportunity to

2:43:47 Kind of get our head around the issue to sort of staunch the bleeding as it were, and to be able to kind of come up with what we think it would be the best idea for our community. You know, Andy's right. We are one of the highest percentage of short-term rentals in our industry. And I think

2:44:12 It would buy us some time and it would be a huge move from the council perspective and from the town perspective and to the public to show them that we are serious about prioritizing housing for our community members. So I'm just going to throw that out there. Thank you, Sarah. Linda? Thank you, Bill.

2:44:42 When we first considered some of these ideas about how to encourage people who are doing short-term rental to transition to long-term rentals, we talked to a group from either Tahoe or Truckee, I can't remember, but they came down and they basically had an idea of how to do this. They had a platform they had set up. It was, you know, pretty, not complicated, but complex. And instead, we decided to build our own program within Chamber.

2:45:09 And so that's when we then helped fund that position to do that. So I'm not sure if those people were around. They had a great kind of way of doing it. And one of the big problems always is that a lot of people who have a short-term rental do that specifically because they want to continue to visit here in the season. Like they want to come up for Christmas. They want to come up for holidays. They want to come up when they want to. And they can absolutely easily do that. It's no surprise that we have as many short-term rentals as we do is that this place was built for that.

2:45:37 Every condo complex that was put in this town upon build, you know, from the 70s forward was built to be short-term rentals. So there is no surprise that this is what we have reaped from all that. So a couple of things on this. Andy, would you forward any articles you get or see or have access to about what other communities are doing here? Because I think it would help us all to just keep up on current ideas and what that would look like. On the staff report,

2:46:07 Sorry. I had a question here about the first paragraph at the end where we talk about business certificates for properties for long-term have increased. I believe that's an artifact of the pandemic.

2:46:20 And not being able to do short-term rental, but being able to do rentals of over 30 days, even if they weren't actually doing over 30 days. So I would think that that's not a very accurate number as far as how that actually looks as far as the market. I don't think that's a real lasting effect of that. So I would expect that now that rentals are opened back up, that many of those 161 units would probably flip back to a short-term rental as it's now much more monetarily attractive to do that than.

2:46:49 And in regards to, you know, talking about a moratorium, when we get more information, kind of figure out a way forward for us, I'm not prepared to sort of think that's a great idea tonight, but I really want to bring this back with more evidence and more discussion and more sort of contemplation that's at the serious

2:47:11 I think that's a very serious thing to do, and certainly there'd be a lot of reaction throughout community for that. But I do want to continue the discussion around the possibility for that. So thank you. That's all I got. Thank you, Linda Kirk. I would agree with most of what, almost everything that Linda just said. But there's also the question of the budget again. I mean, if we're going to commit dollars to this, what impact is that going to have?

2:47:42 So there needs to be some sort of looking at this. If we're going to take these units off the market and we're going to subsidize them to put people into them, what's the financial impact to the town? Thank you. Thank you, Kirk. As for myself, I will tell you that I do not believe our housing issue is tied to TOT certificates.

2:48:12 As someone whose second job is changing locks every time a renter leaves it, none of my customers that have been long-term renters over the years have switched to short-term rentals. The short-term rental increase has been, in my opinion only, I have no specificity on this specificity. It is tied more to people buying units that were being used by owners for their own purposes and altering them to short-term rentals because they can make a

2:48:42 Boatload of money. While if I could get rid of things like VRBO in Mammoth, I would because from a quality of life and on, they create far more problems than they've ever solved. But I don't know how we would deal with just that. In terms of incentivizing, giving $3,000 a year or whatever it is for somebody to rent their unit.

2:49:08 I think you're creating what in my mind is an unfair business practice for those people who are already renting by the month. To tell somebody, I'm going to pay you $3,000, but because you're already being a good guy, I'm going to give you nothing. So in my mind, unless we're prepared to give everybody who rents monthly in Mammoth a $3,000 stipend, I would be at this point unless someone can talk me into it, which has been done often enough.

2:49:37 I would be unwilling to go down that road. I say that's just an unfair practice. I have talked to Dan, and I will get a bunch of phone calls on this, is would it be possible, and Andy, you would be the one to answer it more, to alter some of our zoning. So some of the really old projects in town that you see advertisements on VRBO at $350 and $400 a night for you know what are substandard units, could we take the ability for them to nightly run away?

2:50:06 Without creating potential lawsuits. And Andy, I would also ask the changes and getting rid of short-term rentals in places that did have is fairly new. Have we had any actual lawsuits? Regardless of what the law says, we know lawsuits will be brought. Do we have any lawsuits that enforce that in the legal field? I'm not really aware of too many. There was one from 2018 in Buena Park.

2:50:37 That's the last one that I'm aware of. That case was brought in federal court and almost immediately got thrown out because the court said, hey, cities in California can do this. Could the town prohibit short-term rentals in certain zones? Yeah, absolutely. The trick in that would be trying to figure out if using a particular zone is granular enough to catch the areas that you want and not catch others because I don't think it would be

2:51:07 And I'm assuming with what you said earlier that besides their own

2:51:39 Use, they would have an economic use for it because they could rent on a monthly basis. Could rent on a monthly basis or use it themselves. And either of those is a perfectly fair economic use, as the courts say, such that I don't think property owners would have any sort of valid claim that there was a taking if they were simply deprived of the ability of short-term rent. Thank you. And that's all of mine. Unless other council members have something they want to speak at here, I will.

2:52:09 I apologize, Mark Sauser. I remembered there is the ongoing litigation in South Lake Tahoe. Everyone will recall that the voters passed the initiative that said no more short-term rentals outside the Tourist Corps, phased in over a couple years. A group led by realtors immediately sued. The city has won in the trial court. Now it's going up on appeal. But I have talked to my friend Heather, the city attorney, about that.

2:52:35 She thinks they're going to win on appeal. I think they're going to win on appeal, but I forgot that that one is still out there. Who's going to win on appeal, Andy? I think the city will win on appeal. The city, okay, thank you. Yeah, because it's just so clear in the law that cities can ban them completely and that cities can do almost anything up to, short of a complete ban if they want to. Thank you, Andy. I would just like to see a definitive piece of case law that's been determined.

2:53:04 To make me comfortable on moving forward with anything like that. Well, I can tell you that if the decision on appeal goes South Lake Tahoe's way, I happen to sit on the legal advocacy committee of the city attorney's department, the League of California Cities, and so I will be trying to get the committee to urge the court to publish the decision, which would make it officially precedential, because that would be an important precedent, I think, for cities all over the state.

2:53:32 So we'll be keeping an eye on that one. Thank you. And I would agree. That being said, then I will go to public comments on this item. And Mayor Pro Tem Salcido, is your hand raised? Did you need to speak? Yes, it is. Yes. Sorry, Linda, I missed it. That's okay. I did it late. Andy, I have a question. Is the financial underpinnings of Truckee similar to town in that they depend on the TOT for up to

2:54:03 You know, 70, 60, 70% of their town revenue. Not remotely similar. Truckee's TOT forms about 15% of its budget. That's all? How about South Lake Tahoe? How about South Lake Tahoe? I don't know the exact numbers for South Lake, but I think that their numbers are probably somewhere between Truckee's and Mammoth's. So we are in a very different position as far as our funding base to be contemplating any of this.

2:54:33 As far as I know, and Rob might have better data on this, but as far as I know, Mammoth Lakes has the highest percentage of its general fund budget coming from TOT in the state of California. Interesting. Thank you. I think it was with, I want to say, Yonkville, one of the Napa cities. We trade that number one spot now to get for percent of general funds from TOT, but last time I discussed with the manager there, I think we were beating them out.

2:55:02 We are, the percentage of TOT that Mammoth utilizes in general fund is extremely unique across the state. Nobody else outside of one or two. I think Avalon there on the island has a high percentage. But otherwise, yeah, it's, if you're over 20 or 30 percent from TOT, that's huge for most agencies and most of our culture are probably that 15, very few are. Okay, thank you. That's informative.

2:55:33 So for a history lesson, that goes back to the negotiations with the county when Mammoth Incorporated. And frankly, I would rather own the TOT than a larger portion of property tax because in reality, we get far more money than we would on the property tax side. So as much as I get irritated that we give Mono County as much as we do, sometimes it has been better for us in the long run. Any other public comments, Angie?

2:56:03 We did receive one public comment via email that was sent to the council members, which a few of you have referred to. It came from Jennifer Walker requesting the town implement incentive programs for homeowners to switch from short-term rentals to long-term and cited examples of programs doing that in South Lake Tahoe and Truckee. Yep, I've got it and read it. Thank you very much. That being said, I believe we've come to the end of the program.

2:56:34 I want to thank you all for jumping in finally and getting as involved as you did. I think this was a frank conversation and I think it does us good to have these from time to time without other entities on board and having joint meetings. At this point, what I would do is ask any of the town staff that might want to comment on anything they've heard to have a say as it affects all of us. Speak up if you want to.

2:57:08 Seeing, Rob, your picture came on. I'm assuming you are happy with where we are. Or unmute. Yeah, I'm sorry. I'm in Sweet Z, so it's a little hard to unmute. But yeah, no, there's a lot of input, and I hope to bring them back, especially on the discussions that were occurring earlier through what was requested of the staff to provide recommendations to council. Certainly want to bring that back.

2:57:39 And yeah, just good conversation. I'm glad we, they're pretty tough topics. I'm glad that we took some of those on. As regard to moratoriums and other things like that, I think there's a lot of things to discuss to understand how, you know, our business cycle works and how things are authorized and what that would, what kind of impacts that would have. So lots of, lots of discuss and I appreciate the effort and the conversation tonight. Thank you very much, Rob.

2:58:07 Any other staff wishing input? With that being said then, I will adjourn this meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Town Council to our next regular scheduled meeting of November 3rd. And remember at that, there will be a groundbreaking or a ribbon cutting or something going on, and I think it's 3 o'clock at the parcel, is that correct? Yes. So that meeting is going to start early at the parcel.

2:58:41 Thank you all and good night. Good night all. Thank you all very much. See y'all.