TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2023

Town Council Special meeting

at 17:00

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

222 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:39 Okay, so I think Angie, you're all set. And I see Sarah. So she's here. Hi, Sarah. How are you? I hope that's chicken soup. Yeah. Okay. All right. So I'm going to call to order this special meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Town Council for Wednesday, January 25th. And let's call the roll, shall we, Angie?

3:18 Mayor Wentworth. Present. Mayor Pro Tem Souser. Yo. Yo. Councilmember Bubzer. Councilmember Rae. Here. And Councilmember Rice. Here. Thank you. Thank you. Good. So we're all here. And I've been advised by Angie and others that we need to be very attentive to our voice modulations and our microphone etiquette. So, Chris, I see you're off. That's fine. If you need to speak, we need to make sure. Oh, I know you don't need any coaching.

3:51 Actually, lean into the mic a little bit. We're getting complaints that a lot of people aren't, we're not hearing all the information. First time in my life I've had anybody complain that they couldn't hear me. Everything comes around, you know. So with that, Daniel, would you mind leading us to the Pledge of Allegiance this evening? Thank you. Thank you very much. So we'll get started with any, is there any public comment this evening for things that are otherwise not on the agenda? Mr. John Urdi.

4:44 Thank you. You got me. Good afternoon. John Urdi from Mammoth Lakes Tourism. I wanted to talk about two things. So you council members have your copy of the new visitor guide. These are now widely available throughout town. This is the 2023 guide. I think most of you know, but in the last couple of years, we've scaled this down greatly, mainly from an environmental standpoint. And the idea is that we want to have people utilize the book to go to the website. So you'll see in there plenty of QR codes to get people

5:13 Thank you so much.

5:41 And I think there's been a little bit of a confusion out there as to what's going on. The state of California, in their infinite wisdom in the Taxes and Fees Administration, decided that those businesses that charge TBID need to charge sales tax on TBID. So it's a new thing where if you go into Footloose and you buy a $10 t-shirt, normally it would be $10.15 with TBID. Now it's $10.15 with TBID plus sales tax on the TBID portion.

6:12 7.75% on 15 cents, which is 0.665 cents. So it's not even a penny. I'm sure the state will make millions and millions and millions of dollars on this. Unfortunately, it's something new that the state has come down with. It has nothing to do with us. The money does not come to the town. The money does not come to Mammoth Lakes Tourism. The money goes to the state of California. And I don't know how you tax an assessment, but apparently that's what they're doing.

6:39 So there have been some questions, and obviously our board members are going to be going out here in the next three weeks working on the petitions for the renewal of the TBID, and I'm sure we'll get plenty of questions on that. We already have between our office and our board members, and so I just wanted to take the opportunity to explain that here. If people have questions about this or if they have concerns or comments, they can go right to the California Department of Fees and Administration, taxes and fees and administration.

7:06 Thank you very much. We all know, everybody knows where to find you, John Urdi. Hayes, good afternoon.

7:38 Thank you. Haislip Hayes, Public Works Director. The community continues to do battle with all of our snow. We celebrate it, and then we go to war with it. The town itself, we're finally getting a little bit of a break. The guys are getting some rest. We're off a shift, working days. We are splitting the crew up at night. We're still trucking with the goal of trucking Old Mammoth Road by the end of the night. And then over the weekend and into next week, we're planning on trucking out Canyon Boulevard, some of our safe routes to schools.

8:05 We've got our own truck out running, clearing cul-de-sacs and so forth. So we're going to continue working to move this snow well after the storm. I'm just going to ask the public to be patient, be kind to our drivers because there's a lot of heavy equipment out and about, a lot of trucks out and about. So please be careful around all the heavy equipment. Thank you. Thank you very much. Any conditions for that? I think we're good. I was up at 5 o'clock in the morning last week, drove down Old Mammoth Road, and it truly was a war zone.

8:35 And it's just remarkable the job that Hayes and his crew did. Okay, anybody else public comment? Anything in the virtual world there, Angie? We might have one more comment. Okay. Are you here for public comment? Yeah, I am. Please step forward and this is for something that's not on the agenda, I'm hoping. Sorry I'm a few minutes late. Sure. My name's Zach Mills. I've been living here since 2011.

9:05 Have mostly been here to snowboard and the last handful of years have been trying hard to find a place to live here and it's the last two years in particular have gotten overwhelmingly frustrating to see our town turn into an investment community where people are buying properties for the sole intent of Airbnb and it feels like everything in this town is catered to people who don't live here and I would just really like to encourage town council to do something about

9:35 Limiting, restricting, you know, it sounds extreme, but I don't think we should have Airbnb in this town. If we can, something towards that is something that I would like, and pretty much every other local that I talk to feels the same way. I just got a message from a friend who's a registered nurse, who was born and raised here. He's on a combined income of over $100,000 a year and doesn't feel like he can afford to live here. And I think that's just heartbreaking and wrong. So that's what I have to say. Let's get rid of Airbnb.

10:08 Well, thank you very much. We're going to be talking about some of our priorities this evening if you want to hang around and provide some comment on that. It'll take a little while to get to it, but we'll be here. Have you seen the Housing Now presentation or the paperwork on that that shows everybody what we are doing? No, I haven't. If we can hook him up with that, that would be absolutely great. Yeah, I'm aware of the parcel, and that's a great step for workforce housing, but what I'm really concerned about is people being able to find a place to buy and live here.

10:37 And we have programs for that as well. So I would encourage you to talk to Sandra or whoever, and she can give you a hard copy and talk to you. Thank you. Okay, great. Thank you, guys. Thank you. Pam Mitchell? Angie? Pam Mitchell, you can go ahead and unmute yourself and give your comment. Okay. This is Pam Mitchell. Can you hear me? Yes, we can hear you just fine. Can you hear us okay? I can. Thank you. Thank you. Along the housing lines,

11:08 There's a couple things that I want to bring up. I watched the Mammoth Main Lodge redevelopment project presentation update that was on, when was it? It was September 21st. And it's a wonderful project, but it also brought up some alarms to me. And part of the reason for me coming on tonight is to see if possibly

11:37 There could be scheduled a meeting, not waiting for Altura, but between Altura, the Town Council, and Mammoth Lake Housing. In watching the update, some of the questions at the end was, where's the housing? And Altura's response was, it's not in this plan. And then shortly after that, he qualified by saying it would be addressed later. That is not...

12:07 And I guess Continuum of Care who is

12:37 Housing Homeless did step up and, you know, contribute something. So there's a couple parts to this. I do not think that we should sit back and wait. Right now, the different EIRs, EISs, whatever they're called, are in process. And I believe that Altura should be bringing into that process their housing part.

13:07 You know, this is such a bitchin' project, but it is going to be bringing in a huge amount of people outside of the normal people that we bring in during the wintertime. And, you know, between Mammoth Lake Housing and their project, which has a huge waiting list, and I'm so glad to see that the parcel actually went to what's going to be workforce housing.

13:36 And housing that people can afford. And it's great, but it's insufficient with, especially with the plans that Altura has coming up. We need to have something designated for when hundreds of workers come in just to work on the construction and the development and the different things along that line, along with the fact that Altura stated in one of these.

14:04 I think in that presentation that all the employees at the Mountain now are being hired at at least $20 an hour. And I know that that could be untrue because I've talked with many employees over the years who were hired in this year who were not hired in $20 an hour. This isn't to bitch about that, but we're going to be basing decisions on things like that. And I think Altura should provide

14:34 employees, the classification, salaries that they do make, because that will show you what people can and cannot afford, and also impacts the importance of having some kind of workshops and meetings prior to waiting for Altura. It could mean that they would include housing on the project that was in that presentation.

15:04 Okay, thank you very much, Pam. Thanks for those comments. Very much appreciated. Thank you. Anybody else? No additional public comments. Okay, and I was looking, Angie, I was looking for your little lights there on the timer because the clock in my head doesn't work that well. Okay, so with that, we're going to move on to the consent agenda, and I will read these items. If anybody wants to pull anything, please let me know.

15:33 First one, item 4.1, is to adopt a resolution approving a grant application of up to $452,144.65 to the Regional Early Action Planning Grants Program of 2021, REAP 2.0, to support the acquisition of vacant land for the future development of affordable housing. The second item, 4.2, is to approve and adopt side letter 01-2023 between the Town of Mammoth Lakes,

16:02 The town and the Mammoth Lakes Police Officers Association, the MLPOA, establishing benefits for employees in the position of police recruit. Anybody wish to pull anything? Any further discussion? Good? Good. Okay. You okay there, Sarah? Blow on your nose. Anybody in the public want to pull anything? Okay. With that, I would entertain a motion. I move to approve the consent agenda. I'll second the motion.

16:30 Thank you very much. Motion and a second. Angie, please call the roll. Mayor Wentworth. Yes. Mayor Pro Tem. Yes. Councilmember Bubzer. Yes. Councilmember Ray. Yes. Councilmember Rice. Yes. Thank you. So we're good. Unanimously approved. Okay, so now we're going to move on to policy matters. This is item 5.1, Town Council Strategic Priorities and Key Objectives Review and Planning Process.

17:02 And Dan, I believe this is to you. Yes. I'll kick this off. I want to walk a little bit through the staff report and information before you and then what we're looking for from the town council this evening. On the front end of this, looking for some consensus and direction, but we're not looking for hard decisions tonight. We're not trying to solve our objectives and key objectives and strategic priorities tonight, but trying to get input and process through that.

17:30 So let me touch on some items here. I want to give a little high-level overview of what's before you, then we'll come back and start the discussion points. We will be looking at three levels of discussion this evening. It's kind of looking at our past, how we've done these strategic priorities and key objectives in the past. A few of you have been involved in this, some more than others, but I want everybody to have an understanding of what we were doing and why. And then also some direction regarding

17:56 Either setting new or modified or just updated priorities and key objectives through the past process or different. That's up to the council to decide. And then kind of a high-level discussion on areas that council is looking at. This is not a time. It's a little bit of brainstorming from you all a little bit or just areas that you'd like to see us look at. Not an exhaustive time this evening.

18:20 But a good chance for you to just kind of give a flavor for each other and to staff of what are some things that are definitely out there that you would like to see us begin to look at as we go forward. Not looking for a bunch of debate on those. You all have your right to your opinions and statements, and that would be healthy for us to hear that as we look forward. The use of strategic priorities and key objectives really came out of some work with previous councils and some past work I've done in other places.

18:49 Or how do we define near-term council priorities and really what we can call an achievable work program? And that really helps us direct staff resources and financial resources going forward. It's not designed to be a full-blown strategic plan. It's not looking at multiple years out. Several items do carry over from year to year. But it really is.

19:13 As a council, can you come together with a solid consensus of, yeah, as we look forward, these are some key areas we really want to get some work done in. I'll say as council has new programs and projects and ideas from a staff level, we probably got 10 or 15 percent of capacity to really put into this. Everything else is committed to core services, the thing we do day in and day out, and there is some overlap in these areas, but just a highlight of that.

19:40 I think where some other areas have failed in the past in other places and stuff is spend a lot of time on the strategic planning, but the resources aren't there to achieve it, but nobody says that on the front end. And so then there's frustration that builds out of that. So our goal is not to have that happen, but we can take work and direction from council as they desire through that.

20:02 And this isn't designed to reflect the full work program of the town either. There's a lot of things that are ongoing, things that are priorities for council, et cetera, that we're working through. But it does give us an area to focus on. This really began back in 2014, the first round of that facilitation. Then we've updated it since then in 2016, 18, 21, 22. You have attachments in the staff report. It kind of gives the one page

20:30 You also get requests for additional

21:00 Funding for housing, which has been a priority as examples that will come forward. One unknown, unforeseen, really not a priority, but definitely a core service. The other tied to what has been a directive and a priority for the council and work through those. The other thing that we did starting in 2018 was looking at a vision statement from a long-term issue of just incorporating that out of a general plan. It is getting dated. It's 2007. It's there.

21:29 I think that provides a large picture vision for us to keep in mind. And then annually, or as we update this process, we take a look at a short-term vision. What is it that's really driving your desires and your priorities over the next 12 or 18 months? And that's a chance to really focus that. And then our objectives and our priorities should relate back to that. And so it gives us a sense of direction. It gives the community a sense of direction as we move forward.

21:58 And you will see things that they extend over different time periods, and I'll touch on a few of those. But the other key element that makes this work has actually been the town's financial structure and management, our budget process. We are fairly conservative how we do our budget the last several years, and it's built into that. It has allowed us to have resources to invest in priorities. Our goal is to invest what we have, not what we think we'll have, which is really critical.

22:25 So we don't fall behind, if you will, or end up going the other direction. This has allowed us to be very responsive. Through the pandemic, for example, we were able to do things and put investments back into our communities. To be able to put, I think it's been over $14 million into housing projects in the last three or four years. It's allowed us to do those types of things. And I like to look at it.

22:50 And it's broader, but we are investing in families. We're investing in youth. We're improving mobility. We're investing in capital programs, be it trails, paths, road work, et cetera, recreation, different services and our maintaining our equipment and those types of things. So I think it really has allowed us to do a lot of things and how we improve our service delivery with technology. So having those resources and be able to work with the council with that and with staff with that.

23:17 We're not limited, if you will, by a budget that is, you know, over allocated in some cases and historically in some other places and stuff and other experiences, which really creates challenges mid-year, like, okay, where do we reduce versus where do we invest additional dollars? I think that's a key issue for us to do that. So as we look at priorities, one of them has consistently been is to manage our finances accordingly.

23:46 And again, that's one that's carried over from a few different years. But that's really allowed us to do the level of investment in areas that have been priorities. Without that, there's a lot of things that we would not be doing today. And the other thing that this allows you to do is to review it on a semi-regular basis. Ideally, it's an 18 to 12-month program. If we start now, some of it could be updated. We hear things. We do work. Something would be adopted in the near term. And then going into the next fiscal year again,

24:16 We start to look at those elements and where do we have resources to apply to be able to do those things. The other thing is in that process, if something comes up that we're not foreseen, COVID-19, nobody really budgeted for that. But we were able to react very quickly and put, I think it was close to $2 million back into our community to help through that pandemic. And we did that without having to take a lot of hits within our organization.

24:44 We had a very tight budget, but we were able to work through that. The other thing you'll see multiple years, we had a number of different years with Solid Waste Services, getting that addressed. We knew the landfill was closing, and you see that coming to fruition finally. The Housing Now initiative that has multiple programs in it, that was built over time with a lot of different pieces and building consensus of how do we move that forward. More recently, being able to partner with Mammoth Lakes Foundation.

25:13 Building a childcare facility. Not running one, but building that. To be able to actually meet that need of family and youth, and that fell right out of the whole workforce housing discussion. That's great. Where do I put my children where I feel that they're safe and have a good environment and receiving some educational background? And really, people are struggling. And I'll look at Sarah. She's just recently been experiencing this, as well as sharing different things from childcare that...

25:43 Like strep throat or something. Keep smiling, Sarah. But that need there, and we see that in the community and building back into that. And the same thing, the ongoing work with the Performing Arts Facility. It's been on the books for a long time. It's almost off, back on, and we've stepped in and said, how do we make this work together and be able to put the time and effort into that? The last thing I want to touch on is we've had a lot of discussion over the last few years on broadband, and we were excited to be a gigabit community and stuff.

26:12 We still hear a lot of issues on my broadband just isn't that great. And so through that, because it really was an area focused by the council at the staff level, we had an opportunity to jump on a LADA grant through the CPUC. Sorry about all the acronyms. California Public Utility Commission. And we said, yeah, we want it. Boom, let's go for that. And then we came into council after the fact. But we knew it was a priority. The staff was very comfortable in saying, yes, let's go after those dollars.

26:41 To make that happen. So it has that built-in flexibility in the current process. And we can retain that. Or if there wants to be a stronger structure by council, you could do that as well. And I know for a lot of this, for two new members, there's a whole lot of stuff to look at in a hurry. But I really do want to have a discussion with the council a little bit in terms of the use of how we've structured this over time. And it has morphed over the last several years.

27:11 From existing council members who have worked with it, do you feel it's effective? Is it working? And then looking at it from a new eyes and new perspective, the idea of setting a very limited number of priorities and that, I'd say, achievable work program becomes real critical for staff. But does that process that's in there in the outline, does that make sense to you as a group and whoever can kick it off, maybe some of the past council members who have worked with it and seen other things?

27:39 But we want to make sure that we're going in the right direction as we set this. And the other primary goal of this is to have consensus by the full council on the process and how we're setting this. You may disagree now and again on some of the actual items that get in there, but ultimately it needs to be consensus of the council as a whole so we're confident we're moving in the right direction and not worrying about, well, no, this week we're changing our minds, but to have a consensus of the whole is really...

28:08 I know I've had a couple of discussions with folks asking questions.

28:35 Does this make sense as a process for this council as a way to narrow down and focus the work that we want to get done over the next 12 to 18 months priority-wise and then some key ways to measure that through an effective work program? Okay, and we're going to do this, but a couple sort of maybe high-level process questions to you just for edification of the council. So we're going to have this meeting tonight.

29:00 We're going to keep it kind of high level. We're going to maybe rotate through the topics and we'll take some public comment as we go. But there will be some follow-up meetings to this. If you could maybe let the council know, follow-up meeting and then when you want to start picking some decisions. Right. So that's really going to be based on the process you want for setting these. If the past processes works pretty well, we would come back in a workshop format, really get down, have some discussion. Staff would take the comments from tonight and other comments.

29:30 So we'd come back in that workshop format.

29:58 Take all the comments out of that. Bring that back to Council in a more narrowed-down focus. Work through that again. If the goal is to get down to one page with a limited number of items, begin to work through that as probably, I'll say, a two-meeting process outside the workshop. So we would actually have these in place, I would say, April or May at the latest. So you would actually have an updated list of goals and objectives as defined in those priorities and key objectives to move forward.

30:25 And we can shorten out a little bit or extend a little bit depending on the level of input, the dialogue the council wants to have. Okay, so I'm going to try to set up a predictable rotation as we go through the council members so you kind of know when you're going to have an opportunity to speak and then we can debate as we need to. But the first question is really, as Dan pointed out, is around the process. What do we think is going to be necessary, effective to be able to get to something in a timely manner that can inform budget and things like that?

30:55 Can I ask a clarifying question? So this contemplates that the budget has to be approved in June, correct? Yes. So you really need this by April to give you those May and June timeframe to finish the budget? Yeah, if we have a good discussion on it, we can get to May with it, but just the last meeting historically has been, I'll say, just some wordsmithing.

31:19 Hasn't really changed the intent of it. But that allows us to build. But now the budget side, some of this is built in and some of this is going to be tied to future resources versus budgetary ones. But there will be a portion of that that we build into it. And staff builds it into work programs. Okay. Thank you. Dan made an important point there for me and for the new people on council. An awful lot of what's in our vision here is paid for by the excess over what we have budgeted into our income stream.

31:48 So we are not spending what we hope to get. We spend it after it's in the bank. And that is huge. So we've put $14-plus million in the last three or four years into housing. That's because our TOT certs have been so good. But we haven't built it into the budget and inflated our budget numbers. This comes after the fact. When we say, okay, end of the first quarter, we've got $2 million over what we budgeted. Here are the projects on our list.

32:18 That it can go to, and Dan and staff have been incredibly good about following this priority list at that point. So that's critical. It's not as necessary for budget, because most of what we budget is day-to-day activities from staff and town. These projects don't come out of that. They come out of that excess that we build into the budget every year. Unless we have a huge issue, we know we are going to have those funds.

32:46 Yeah, a good point. I mean, that's kind of how the whole process kind of works. So, Sarah, what I'd like to do is to go Sarah, Chris, Bill, Amanda, and then back to myself. We'll kind of go in that kind of an order. So, Sarah, do you have any thoughts? You've been through this kind of process before. Just talking about the process, how we do this to get to the priorities that have been documented over the last couple of years.

33:14 Yeah, thanks for choosing me to go first. I'll do my best to be a value add to this discussion tonight. You know, I think you kind of led it last year, right, John? Yeah. So, yeah, I feel like it's a little bit organic. You know, John kind of led the discussion and I think we kind of went through.

33:44 I wish I had thoughts, so. Okay.

34:08 So I guess, Bill, what you were saying, if I'm interpreting this correctly, is, you know, we have our general fund revenue and our general fund expenditures. They have to match. That's our blocking and tackling, if you will. That's making sure that we have snow removal equipment, unlike Caltrans, that is working and available when we need it. So there's an awful lot that as a town we have to do that isn't negotiable. And so, you know, but the...

34:37 Sustainable recreation economy with partnership and investment and investment in infrastructure and maintenance and municipal services, like three of these strategic priorities are blocking and tackling, they have add-ons. I guess for me, when you articulated that, it was helpful because

34:56 What I would like to see is in an early meeting a chance for us to have a true brainstorm where we just talk about the challenges that we're hearing about from our community members so that it's a pure, we aren't always working off what we always did. That's not to say, I really don't expect things to change, but there might be something that bubbles up that we're not thinking about.

35:26 It's expensive and hard, but boy, wouldn't it have been great if we had a parking lot somewhere in town that's either underground or covered or both where we could put a lot of cars in these crisis situations where nobody has place to put them. So that's just an example that only came up because we just had this crisis. And it may, you know, it may be impossible. It may be impractical financially.

35:53 But I think that we aren't hearing new ideas unless we have a chance. And, you know, again, we'll do with it what we will. But I do love to start a process like this with a very open mind. I think that's an excellent point, obviously. I think that, as Dan mentioned, we will have a second meeting, perhaps in a workshop format. It sounds like kind of what you're talking about. And we could schedule that, promote it, reach out to constituents in the public and say, look.

36:20 Council's got a, we got sort of a draft, we're looking for things, we're looking for new ideas, this is the opportunity to bring it forward. So I think maybe that sounds like what you're talking about. Yes, but I'm talking about the five of us as the council doing it because we are out talking to people in our community all the time.

36:39 You know, sometimes it's really hard to get the public to come to workshops. That would be ideal if we could get a real representation of the community. But if we don't have a real representation, then I think it's incumbent on us to make sure that we are looking to represent those voices that may not get heard. And then the second thing I'd say is that the town staff I know is contemplating a survey, and I think it would be really important for us to have access to that as well sooner rather than later to see what

37:08 You know, people are talking about. Can you talk about the survey? That's kind of annoying. Yeah, just real quick. Yeah, we put out just in concept. We start to do it at the staff level, look at some of the get feedback on services and quality and things that people use the town for. And they're really looking at that more operational level. You know, how, you know, public safety, how safe do you feel in your community? You know, those types of questions and things like that. And something that we can build.

37:36 That you could actually put out like annually and then see how things move. Kind of came out of some of the work Parks and Recreation does on their recreation services. Every year there's a survey that goes out and do we see incremental improvement or not or areas that. So we'll have something drafted up we'll bring back to council to look at here shortly. But we think that'd be a good thing to reach out with people and it's about their expectations of services and stuff in the town and something that you can measure over time.

38:04 Like a tracking, almost like a tracking study. That's great, and I do think there's always a chance there to leave, you know, one or two open-ended questions at the end where just allowing our community to have their voices heard. So that's great. Thank you. I've built in a couple of those in there for the general comment. Okay, good. So good thoughts. Bill? Well, several things. You guys keep saying things that make me want to talk more, so be prepared. This is what we're here for.

38:34 Surveys. Surveys are great, but especially in the town of Mammoth Lakes, we get a lot of responses from the same very, very small minority of people. You said something incredibly important. That is that we have constituencies that we need to go out and talk to because we're going to get more information having lunch with the guys than we're going to get out of a survey. Important to remember that we represent.

39:03 Everybody out there, that's second homeowners, that's our working force, that's the tourists, we are the voices for all of them. And somehow we have to find ways, and it's not easy, believe me, but somehow we have to find ways to do that. Initially, I would love to see us have a straight council workshop. Everybody else can be there, but muted. So that we can openly talk and have the time to discuss.

39:35 When we get into some of the situations we've gotten into in the past, where everybody's been invited to the table and to have their comments, by the time we get down to serious discussion, we're all tired and the work is not what it should be. So I caution us against that. The process that we have developed here over the last eight years, and two of those years I wasn't on council, but when I first got on council, we had a facilitated process, and in my mind it failed miserably.

40:03 We had a facilitator from out of the area that doesn't know the area, doesn't know the issues, when we brought that in-house and tried to do a one-page piece, which I dearly love. This format and how we've achieved this, to me, is second to none. I am fairly active in the league, as you guys all know. Everybody else does their vision statements, and it's 152 pages long. It's pie in the sky. It's dreams.

40:31 What we have produced here are reality-based objectives. And that's what I'm hoping we can continue to do. That's why I'm hoping we keep this process. Deviate some from what we've done in the past, add, subtract in our workshop format. I think that's great. But I think the process we have here is second to none of the other cities that I work with.

40:59 Can I ask a clarifying question? Because I think we're all agreeing with you, Bill, like nobody's thinking about facilitators or anything. But I think the question may be for

41:30 And Amanda, you may share the same question. When we say, like, this is the outcome, right? But how did we get to that? Maybe we need a little bit more color around that because I wasn't there. You will be. Hang on. So Amanda, go ahead. So I'm open to the process that we have laid out to come up with our strategic priorities. And then I do have, you know, a few general ideas that we'll be sharing those tonight. Of course, yeah. We'll just talk about kind of how we do it. Yeah.

42:00 That's fine with me. And Sarah, I'm going to come back to you because you've heard everybody except for me say our bit. Anything you want to add at this point? No, but I am intrigued by Chris's suggestions. You know, I do think that we could really benefit from kind of that, like things coming up.

42:26 In the wake of a huge snowstorm that we don't think about 90% of the time. So I just wanted to echo that. So I'm going to do a little bit of maybe aggregating and just make sure we're kind of on. I think I'm hearing that there's general support for the process, the deliverable of the process, which is a one sheet, kind of a one simple document consistent with the desires and wishes and staff. But I am hearing.

42:53 From Chris and from others, I think from all of us, the desire to make the, you know, bring as much as we can into this process so that we're not just, you know, cutting and pasting and rinsing and repeating and we're making sure that everything in here is valid, that we all think it's something good that we have to do. The only thing I'm going to add to that is that looking what we have to do this year, we have to hire, we have to recruit and hire a new town manager and we have a budget process that we're going to go into.

43:22 And I just want to make sure that we can align the work that we're going to do, if we can do it, with those kinds of needs. We're in a very kind of particular situation, so I just want to make sure that we can hit those marks as we go forward. Is that a fair summation of things for the moment? Okay, and we are going to go through sort of, we're going to go chunk by chunk and bring in some new chunks if you want it. Yeah, so hang on real quick. So any public comment on this discussion so far?

43:51 Okay, yeah, Dan, sorry. So, based on that, it's looking at, like, process stuff. It sounds like if we do come back in a workshop format, we can do some of the brainstorming work. I think that's a good idea. It's not judging stuff. It's just getting everything out. And then begin to work from that of what kind of sticks. And that's, again, council. Focused on a council discussion, but bringing whoever wants to show up and make public comment, they're welcome to do so.

44:18 And in the past, we've had public meetings, and we've done tweaks and changes based on that input, so it's a good thing. And again, I think that's an element there. And then out of that is to build that consensus to move. And then the only caution, usually on the brainstorming, is ultimately getting the list down back to where we can actually do it, and it's achievable, and we don't get unreal expectations. That would be the only caution there. I like the idea of the workshop and having that open discussion.

44:45 We'll engage some of the department heads in some of that work as well and have some of those ideas come forward for that. I think this evening would be helpful back to the third point and however you want to walk it through and have that dialogue or what are ideas that either that are there that are good and what's missing maybe and what are other areas. And I know there's some different comments that have come up on some things that we'll probably move forward relatively quickly based on

45:13 So I took the first strategic priority and I looked at the things that are in there and I looked at this and I said, what would I like to see? What I think is important things that I ran on?

45:42 Chris, Amanda, and I were just re-elected. We put our proposals to the community, so we need to be echoing that, obviously. So the first point about complete construction on Phase 1, the 81 units of the parcel, update that, carry it forward. So that's, yeah, we've got to keep doing that, so I think that's important. The next one, implementing the Housing Now initiative, and you've got to copy that back there, to deliver diverse housing solutions, working with the private sector and other agencies locally and regionally, update it.

46:11 We just have to look where we at. Get rid of the stuff we've already done, but move that forward. Pursuing the implementation of sustainable funding sources for community housing, including the potential EIFD and in-low housing increases. For me, I think that EIFD is a real timely opportunity. I think we need to prioritize that. Other than just sort of generic funding opportunities, we got to really get, I think we need to focus on that. And I want to also just share that Dan has asked that

46:40 We throw ideas out. They can be whatever level they're at, but just the things they want to, Dan and staff want to hear what we're thinking. So that's an important one. The data piece, the collect and analyze data on short-term rental compliance, we talked about at the last meeting. That's been in the works for a long time. We need that, and we need that sooner rather than later. And I think the issues that were brought up about nightly rentals and all those kinds of things, the council needs to have data.

47:10 And we need to all be really deeply informed in how the town is zoned, what we can do legally, what we can't do, what Measure Z means, all the rest of it. This is an increasingly, you know, sort of a crux point that we need to be able to articulate that, make sure the community knows what we're dealing with. So that's something to talk about. The other thing is I would recommend that we consider doing an update to the Community Housing Action Plan, the CHAP, which we've talked about.

47:38 I think it's time to do that. There may be some other statewide things we need to update. So I'm just throwing those kinds of things out there. I have a global comment, but we'll get to that later. So that's just an example. And just make a note if you think those things are stupid or crazy or you want to add to it, let's just do that. We'll go around the road. Just keep it positive. Keep it positive. Keep it positive, please. So Amanda, go ahead. So just speaking about strategic priority.

48:06 The first one, the housing. Yeah, we're going to go around. Okay. Yeah, I definitely agree with the EIFD that I feel like, you know, if people are happy to build here, I think that they need to help out with the employee housing and we're short already. So I think that's, for me, that's a really quick way to, you know, help address our housing shortage. You know, I, the collect and analyze data on the short-term rental.

48:34 I would like to take that a step further and kind of try to make a choice about short-term rentals and how they're affecting our town and what we can do to help our constituents that can't find housing. I would also be interested in looking at subsidizing some housing until the parcel units are available just to help people now. Let's see.

49:04 Yeah, so for housing, I would just like to add to, you know, those things. Yeah, okay, thank you. Sarah, anything on this first priority you want to add, cut, delete? I want to emphasize we need to do this data-driven discussion sooner than later. I kind of feel like that's getting pushed by the wayside a little bit. I think that's fairly common on that. Okay.

49:38 Chris? I agree. I think it's really hard for us to make any decisions until we understand, you know, there's just a lot of zoning issues. There's just a lot of issues that until we have all the facts in front of us, it feels to me like we're kind of feeling in the dark. And then the second thing is, I do think as a community, we need to accept and address that

50:03 You know, the world is moving on and housing looks different to different people. You know, Bill and I had a sidebar conversation about this. There are people who choose van life and we want to make sure that we support them as important members of our community and I think that's something we're going to have to just tackle head on. Bill, housing as a priority is very important. How we go about it to me is sort of getting in the weeds a little bit tonight.

50:37 There are a lot of potential solutions. Short-term rental and how it affects the town. When I moved here, there were 300 people. Short-term rentals made the town. So I have a bias to a certain extent there. If we're going to provide funding for housing as we have for the last three or four years, we have to maintain a short-term rental base that is at least as big as what we have today or there will be no excess. We have to look at our budgets.

51:04 And remember that just, you know, staff costs alone add about a half a million a year through the contracts to our budget that we have to pay for. So if we're going to continue doing these things, we have to be really careful about the cause and effect. Rental subsidies, and I would love to sit and have that conversation with you. The chaos that that can create, everybody all of a sudden dumps their rentals and goes back into the pool so they can all achieve the subsidies. It has pretty much failed another.

51:34 And then in the workshop format I would go through line by line and see what we need to change, see what staff brings forth to us and then add our own and hash out.

52:02 What the bullet points need to be. Yeah. And I think, I mean, certainly if there's any thought about an additional priority, I mean, we're just kind of giving Dan and staff a sense. If you've got another priority, someone's got... Okay, one second. Sarah, you got your hand up out there? Yeah, I don't... I just wanted to make sure my thought didn't get lost. I can... I'm happy to wait. Okay. Okay, you heard that? Yeah, Amanda, you've got a priority. Okay, Amanda would like you to go first, Sarah.

52:34 Another thing that I feel is really important is I really want to hold Altera and the new developers that are wanting to build, you know, hotels, their feet to the fire. Like, I think for too long, like, town has been, the town government has been in the business of solving the problems that are created by this overabundance of

53:04 And we are solving for these people who are making all the money. And I feel like that needs to be part of our strategic priority moving forward while we're looking at this main launch redevelopment. And, you know, I was gone when the Limelight project was approved, but I just, yeah, that's really important to me.

53:32 to the public comment earlier, you know, we're kind of hearing them say like, oh yeah, we'll do the minimum that we have to, you know, and I just don't think that's good enough anymore. Great, thank you. So just a strategic priority on here that I see that's missing is things for our environment.

53:55 You know, I feel like Brandon was here last week. He spoke about the to-go containers and the waste from that. I feel that, you know, with our current situation with the landfill that we're going to be trucking out all this trash. I think that we need to figure out a way to cut back on our trash and especially on our plastic consumption here. So I would really like to see, you know, something.

54:24 Environmentally sound on here also is that, you know, it's, yeah. Yeah, so let me, I'd like to follow up on that because I have the global, I was looking at the priorities thinking, is there anything that's missing here? These are all kind of, but I think that we need to integrate the issues and the needs for resilience mitigation and adaptation to climate into that, into a priority that way. I think for a lot of reasons, Bill and I, you've talked about it a little bit, but.

54:56 A, there's an enormous amount of money in the state, in the federal government that is pointing at resilience. I mean, they're giving us the framework to engage with these opportunities. And I think that it would be in our interest, socially, economically, environmentally, to be proactive. All the things the town does, the decisions we make, and what we do to have that frame on top of that. Because if we frame it that way and we kind of draft it that way, then we can be looking at the...

55:24 Funding opportunities coming out to say, well, yeah, this aligns with resilience. This aligns with adaptation. This aligns with mitigation. And I think commingling the environmental stuff along with the climate change stuff is probably a pretty good idea, so I definitely support that. And I think one of the just, you know, an observation in this last storm I was looking was, gee, is this bigger than 17? I looked out at my front yard, yeah, this is bigger than 17. But the thing in the back of my mind is

55:55 This is not a record we're going to kind of set and it's going to get more. And I think if we just, we don't have to get into it now, but all the things we've experienced over the last month in terms of Caltrans trucks breaking down, not finding housing for the workforce, systems like Digital 395 going down, these are issues of resilience. And I think we can track these to a manic, an increasingly manic climate environment, wildfires, all this other kind of stuff, huge things happening with snow.

56:27 I would support that. I think that's something we should look at and consider that as a priority. Two other things I want to add, I forgot to add, is the van life, that van life strategy, I think that needs to be part of our housing discussion. Because it's been discussed, the county will come back and say, we've got to talk about homelessness. Okay, homelessness, I get it, you know, it's a serious problem, certainly in urban California. We don't have, I don't think we have those degrees of those challenges up here.

56:56 But we do have a recreation audience or an audience that is here for the recreation pursuits. They like living in a lifestyle they choose to live and that's great. But we have to navigate what is truly people living in a van or living out in the woods because they want to have a job and they want to be part of this community and really kind of sort out, okay, what are the people here because they want to have a good time, they can do for a couple of years. It's basically the latest iteration of the dirtbag culture.

57:22 And that's a real thing. And we need to factor that in, you know, dirt bag, ski bond, whatever you want to call it. I mean, that's where that's all gone. And I think we need to be conscious about that, figure out how to do it. The other thing is the Altera housing piece. I absolutely agree with that. And I think we need to be extremely proactive about that. I mean, that project, as we all know, is coming into the town. It will be approved ultimately by the town. But we need to be proactive about that.

57:50 I was reminded a little bit by, I remember we approved the grocery outlet market down on Old Mammoth Road, and I was concerned at the time, access, you know, going in and out of the parking lot, and how's all this traffic flow going to work, and what we've seen over the last couple weeks is it doesn't work very well, and I think that what we have on the books for projects like that, it doesn't work, and the traffic and the weird almost collisions and things happening down there, so I'm not, I don't know,

58:20 My level of confidence of dealing with these kinds of projects and the kinds of things we're seeing, eh, I'm a little concerned about that. So I think we need to be smart and proactive about that. Okay, so, yeah, go ahead. A quick comment on your comment. Sure. I don't know that I can call a 20-something-year-old driving around in a $200,000 Mercedes van, a dirtbag. Whatever, whatever, whatever you want to call it. Yes, it's a ski bum, but not the same kind of ski bum from my, you know, past life and experience.

58:51 The van life is very important, so I wanted to add that in there, especially, so, throughout history, in the town of Mammoth Lakes, every X number of years, we have a record year. This is one of those. It's not new. It'll happen again. Good chance before it happens again, we'll have another two years, three years of drought. But what does happen in a year like this, when those people who have been living out on the Tubbs Road, last year there were

59:20 Hundreds of them out there. When they can't access those ports, how do we deal with that influx in town? The police blotter every week has multiple tales of illegal camping in the Vons parking lot. So it is something I would like to see us to address somehow at some point. I would also like to caution us again. You don't build the church for Easter Sunday service. We cannot build the town.

59:51 For a winter of 16, 17 or a winter of, what is this, 22, 23, because we just don't have the capacity to go there. I just want to caution us not to get too far ahead of that because we can't. Totally hear you, but I think it's a conversation and then we explain to people why, you know, if we can't do it, at least we've addressed it and it's not something we didn't try. You know what I mean? Yeah. And also, we're just in such a unique... I don't know, I'd have to ask the police. Sorry, John. Yeah, yeah.

1:00:31 Yeah, but I think- By altitude, we are, yes. Somewhere. I mean, the unique position that we're in, we're on the front lines of all this stuff, and there is, we have a story to tell. Okay. John, there's just one more that, because I agree with Bill, like, I don't want to get too in the weeds, but there's sort of this thing that I don't see it in here, but we are a-

1:00:59 Town that is surrounded by wilderness and federal lands. We are landlocked. There's only so much land left. And it's sort of how do we make sure that we use every inch of the land the best way possible because one day there won't be any more. So we can't sprawl. This is it. And I just want to make sure that as we think toward the future that that's being addressed. Sure. And it is huge.

1:01:35 It's huge if the mountain brings their project forward in my lifetime. The EIFD thing is absolutely immense. To be able to use a tax increment to finance housing or some of the other things that we desperately need and wildfire. But that is critical. And somehow we have to get the county on board to move these things forward. Moving them forward after development is counterproductive. It does us no good.

1:02:04 As much as it wouldn't be that big incrementally, we should have done this with the parcel itself because the value is certainly going to be higher with buildings on it than it was before. Dan's shaking his head. We've had this conversation. I'm allowed to disagree with him from time to time. It's actually tax exempt for the most part. Yeah. Okay.

1:02:23 Can I have one other little priority? I would also like to see a little more support for our families, you know, maybe expanding the rec department, the summer programs. In my experience, you know, your child gets one program for a week, you know, and the summer is like 12 to 16 weeks. And, you know, I know there are some kids that can't afford it. There's the scholarship to help, you know, make it reasonable or free for low-income people. But I would really love to see

1:02:54 The rec department have an expansion. Okay, we'll get to that. That's coming up. That's noted. Okay, any public comment on this? I think it's a good discussion. Anybody anything to add? Yes, please come forward. Can you please come forward? You need to come forward. Thank you. I'm just curious what EFID is. What's it stand for? Can I say real quick, I think in my mind, the way that I think of it is, you know, Mammoth Mountain with if they do a re...

1:04:33 Redevelopment there, then they have to build X amount of units for workforce housing. So it's just a way to have developers contribute to our housing by holding them accountable to build a certain level of housing for the workforce and not just vacation rentals. Dan probably already put it, you probably already understand, but it's a tax increment. So as the value of that property increases.

1:05:02 Over what the current evaluation is, a certain percentage of that increase goes back into a district for specific things like housing or fire. Otherwise, what happens, the mountain builds and takes what was public land with no value or very little, I don't know what we get in our, what do we call that program where they pay us in lieu. Otherwise, it just all goes to the county and the county general fund. This is a way of getting that increase based on the buildings going on and using it to offset

1:05:33 The potential ills that that project creates outside of just development impact. It's a source of funding for things like housing and wildfire mitigation. Understood. Thank you. Okay, thank you. Dan, I got a text that they can't hear you out there in the virtual universe. Okay, thanks. Testing, testing. Yeah, I'll make sure I'm leaning in and have the mic on. Yeah, perfect. Okay. All right, thank you. So now let's go to the next.

1:06:03 The next priority, and this one has to do with enhancing a sustainable recreational economy with partnerships and investment. If it's okay with you guys, I can just go first and throw out some ideas. Is that okay? Okay, then we'll just go around the room. So for the Office of Outdoor Recreation to coordinate with federal land managers and recreational investments, experiences, and planning related to federal lands. Obviously, I think we need to move this thing forward.

1:06:28 I think that we need to formalize the engagement process for the Mammoth Ranger District and Inyo National Forest. We've got this office set up. It's in good shape, but we need to have a formal and predictable process for the council and the town to understand how we are engaging with the Forest Service and the local ranger district. That's something good to do going forward. And we also need to share this work plan with the council and the community so that everybody kind of knows what this office is doing.

1:06:57 And again, I go back to this climate change piece, resilience adaptation and mitigation, that's obviously going to affect all the recreation work we do on all kinds of different levels. Enhancing public recreational community experience through focused destination management strategies for parking, transit, trailheads, and user services. Where's the walk-bike ride? We were doing, we were, I understand, but I'm just, it's kind of gone under the radar. You may not be familiar, it's a very interesting.

1:07:24 Plan that the town has to really work on enhancing how we move everybody around in this town. Love to bring that back up again and get it some more visibility. And I think that we need, in terms of the wildfire piece, which is mentioned with the word, I think that we need to, the town needs to be actively involved, actively involved with the ESCCRP, which is the process for this wildfire thing around the town.

1:07:53 And I think we need to prioritize that. That's being spearheaded by a nonprofit. They're doing great work, but man, it's a huge multimillion dollar project. I've been hearing things where the Forest Service is maybe not playing as nice with us as they should be or they could be. And I think that we as the town, we need to get more actively involved in that. And I certainly bring the county into this. I mean, if the town of Mammoth Lakes burns down, the county no longer has a tax base. I mean, they go out of business. So I think that we need to, I think we need to,

1:08:22 That's ripening, so that's something to think about. And additionally, I think that we need to, now is the time to really be thinking about proactive engagement with this TBIT. I know we're talking about it, and it's kind of being kicked around, but I'm really interested in the possibility of separating out the air subsidies from the marketing that goes for the local businesses. It's a little, it feels like black magic to a lot of people, and I think it really needs to be a regional.

1:08:50 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

1:09:18 National, sort of international phenomenon at this point. I don't know if we're factoring that into our decision making. I think that's something as part of the data piece to think about. Proactive engagement with the main lodge redevelopment, as we've talked about. I mean, this is, it's a recreation, you know, driver. It's going to drive, compel people from all over the world to come here. I think we really need to be proactive about on the recreation side, but also all the other sides. Services, housing, all the rest of it.

1:09:46 And I think we need to talk about proactive engagement, but engagement with the Forest Service subpart C planning process for motorized over snow vehicle winter recreation. We've had, you know, there's been sort of an initial kind of a sampling effort, but I think that the council needs to be involved, and I think we need to speak as a voice from the council of what we want to see coming out of that plan and designate someone from the town with some policy direction that the council's all seen and reviewed and we're on the same page with.

1:10:16 And recruitment and hiring of a new trails manager is in there somewhere. So that's a little of a list. Again, it's kind of all over the place, but hopefully you guys got some ideas as well. Amanda? I kind of shared my ideas, and I like your points. Okay, good. Sarah, anything to add to that? Okay, Chris? No, I think you raised a lot of really good points. Okay, they're just ideas, and they're out there, and we'll shape them.

1:10:51 And I'm not sure how many of those don't automatically fit under some of the things we already have. Calling them out to be reported back is a great thing. The subpart C thing fits in two of the bullet points that are already there. Really important. We do need to be engaged with that. We also need to think about snow management for recreation, something that I have harped on for a long time. We have a great...

1:11:20 Cross-Country, dog-walking, non-motorized trail experience that we're trying to provide with wholly inadequate equipment. So these are some of the things that fit in these bullet points. And if we want to suss them out, but not as part of the document. I don't want to create this wish list document, but the high points, engage with partners on amenity improvement on federal lands, that's subpart C.

1:11:49 That's trailheads. That's, you know, Nordic skiing. That's how do we expand and improve so that we aren't clustering everybody on an ever smaller piece of property, which then creates issues, which we have seen with forest plans in the past. So I encourage us to be involved in those, but I believe they already fit in some of our bullet points. How much more we need to call them out, I don't know. And that's an excellent point. I think we need to all be thinking about the pros of this document.

1:12:19 Because there may be some ideas coming up that we may need to shift some things around to make sure we're accommodating and to make sure we're not losing anything. One thing I would add, and I'm glad you brought it up, you know, you talked about wildfire, and it's here under enhancing a sustainable recreation economy, and, you know, I do, I would like to have the conversation that that is our number, okay, housing aside, it's the biggest threat to our community.

1:12:50 I would like to make sure that it is loud and clear and up front that this is something we as an entire town need to think about and work toward, you know, finding a solution that we don't end up. Yeah, because there are, and that's kind of the point is these things out there. We'll leave it to the wordsmithers over there to figure out, to bring that back in such a way that we make sure that it's clear. I read the same thing. It seems like we've got this enormous project going on.

1:13:24 That's already raised $17 million, that has statewide visibility that is critical to the survival of this community. Yeah, and to sort of, you know, add to one thing you said was, you know, Mono County loses its tax base if the Town of Mammoth Lakes burns down, while LADWP loses its water. So there's a lot of people who should care deeply about what happens to our communities in the Eastern Sierra, both in you and Mono counties and Town of Mammoth Lakes and Bishop.

1:13:59 Getting our fair share to, you know, we're protecting this precious resource for much of the state. What are they doing to protect us? Okay. You could almost add other bullet points in there. The resort community, small community, I don't believe we get our fair share back from the state or the federal government when you look at the millions of people we serve every year. So we don't get the funding for our housing projects because our housing costs more than some people. It has to.

1:14:33 That's not a fair assumption. We get forest plans that don't look at fire and don't spend the necessary money to mitigate these concerns because we're a small rural community. We don't have a lot of voters, you know, almost a congressperson, but not quite. So we have to look at how we can enhance that relationship through the League of Cities, through, you know, some of the things that John is doing.

1:15:02 These things are hugely important. How they fit into this document, I don't know, but maybe we need a government bullet point on there so that we are looking at the legislation coming through both parts, and Dan is doing a great job of that, and I'll bring it forward to it. Okay, good. Public comment on discussion so far. Yes, please. John Urdi again. So I understood this priority as enhanced recreation economy, and I guess can you expand on how the TBID and the air subsidy

1:15:36 Can you fit into that? And then can you also define black magic? Black magic, I can define. The T-Bid, I mean, we are a recreation-based tourist economy. And the T-Bid plays a role in that. And the air subsidy, the air service plays a role in that. People are coming here, I would assume, with the subsidy.

1:16:03 That we're paying with the TBID is consistent with driving visitation for recreation pursuits. So I think that one council member's perspective, that when you look at the TBID, and we were in a meeting with the Chamber of Commerce, and the Chamber of Commerce, all the businesses support that marketing. That marketing means a lot to them, and it's tangible, it makes a lot of sense. But the air subsidies,

1:16:33 A, I think there's a difficulty in making that transparent as to what that is and what that supports, A. B, I think that the air service is a regional question, in my mind. It is a regional question. And I think it's important to establish a table at which all of the partners, all the people that are participating in the benefits of reliable regional air service are there.

1:17:04 And they can talk with each other and they can figure out who wants to make what commitment, who wants to put what into it in a manner that is transparent and specific to that conversation. Now, the T-bid with its air subsidy could be a partner, have a seat at that table, but I'm concerned that all of the burden right now is on MLT, it's on the T-bid, and it's not clear to the public and all, I think, to the council, who else is participating in this? What role are they playing?

1:17:34 And there needs to be a specific, isolated, identifiable, I use the word authority loosely, but a table or an organization or whatever that can speak to the council, can speak to the public. This is what's happening with air service. I think when it's locked into the TBID like that, I think it's confusing to the public, and I think it inhibits the ability for the TBID to be successful and for air service to be successful. You asked.

1:18:07 Yeah, and I think just on the transparency side, I mean, we've had this conversation multiple times. We have at least three partners in right now on the air subsidy side. That's been explained as far as Mammoth Lakes Tourism in your county and Mammoth Mountain ski area. Obviously, we'd love to have more partners involved. I think we should have the town of Mammoth Lakes involved for our locals that utilize the service. But I think just it just seemed a little confusing when we're talking about, you know, walk, bike, ride and parking and trailheads and wildfire mitigation that we...

1:18:34 Then have the T-Bid kind of stuck in there. Okay, but the T-Bid drives the marketing, the excellent marketing that happens with that. It drives the visitation. Not all of it, but it drives visitation. So I think we want to be successful. I think I want to be successful. I think we want to make sure that it doesn't get caught up in some, you know, we've got a history with this, I think.

1:19:03 I think we can get there. I think we can achieve this, but I think we've got to work on it and make it happen. Okay. And I do think, you know, you referenced it as a burden on MLT, and it's definitely not a burden. It's an opportunity. No, I understand. But I think we want it to be successful. I think we need to take the necessary steps to ensure that it's going to be successful. Yep. Thanks. Yep. Okay. Yes, Betsy, go ahead. Good evening, Council. Betsy Truax. I'm the Executive Director of the Mammoth Lakes Foundation. And I know you're trying to keep this very high level this evening, but...

1:19:35 Part of this second strategic priority does speak to partnerships, specifically the partnership with the foundation. I just wanted to say that from our perspective, we feel this partnership is really successful so far. We really look forward to moving it forward. And I just want to put in a word to not only move forward with the land use planning that we are working on, but also the Mammoth Arts and Cultural Center.

1:19:58 Just want to keep, you know, kind of keep arts and culture as, you know, a reminder that that's also recreation and so also probably belongs in this, in this priority. So happy to talk to any of you about that offline, but just kind of wanted to say how appreciative we are of this partnership. Thanks. Thank you. Good point. So Dan, how are we doing so far? Is this providing you, do we need to change our tone and tenor, our focus?

1:20:21 We're going to get a list we can't accomplish, but we'll start with that and narrow it down. Good, well, that's where we want to start. Good, it's, no, I think there's a lot of elements in here that will, yeah, it's a good input, and you do have a virtual person. Oh, I do? Okay, who's out there? Pam Mitchell, you can go ahead and unmute yourself and give your comment. Hi, Pam. Pam Mitchell, you can unmute yourself. I might have been left over, because I didn't, she didn't lower her hand after the public comments.

1:21:15 Oh, you had? OK. OK. OK, good. Well, let's move on then to our next priority, which is the strategic priority to investment in infrastructure improvements and maintenance. Once again, I'll just throw out some ideas. You can shoot them down, think of your own, and we'll riff on this a little bit. So invest in community infrastructure, planning, maintenance, replacement, improvements, roads, mops, parks, town offices, and equipment. Again, incorporating the considerations for climate change.

1:21:47 And all these things just as an overall kind of a lens for this stuff. I think it's going to open us up for funding opportunities. I think it's a good thing to do in a bunch of different ways. Participate in the regional airport plan with partners to set strategic vision for Mammoth Yosemite Airport. John, to your point, this kind of covers both of these things. But what I was saying before, to establish with regional partners this table, this forum, Eastern Sierra Air Alliance, whatever you want to call it.

1:22:15 Where these issues around air service, airports and things like that are addressed in a discreet and known place. Good for the public, good for us. The ongoing update, the priorities, five-year capital improvement plan, the CIP, and defined funding, great program. Glad to see it in work. Let's just carry that forward, updating it. Define and initiate mobility program, including micromobility solutions, enhance EV capacity and transit improvements. Again, I go back to walk, bike, ride.

1:22:46 I think there's a particular moment, next 12, 18 months, there's still that surplus flowing through.

1:23:23 So my first cut of ideas. Anything to add? This is a good starting point. All right, Sarah? No, nothing to add on this one. Chris? I have more of a question. So I would just be curious about when the last time Walk, Bike, Ride was updated and how we can, you know, push even farther because in an ideal world, and it's possible in the town of Mammoth Lakes.

1:24:02 I think there's a lot of movement in the state of California for

1:24:32 You know, things like biking. Like, maybe Andreas won't be the only one riding his bike to work. Shout out to Andreas. No, I am not riding a bicycle to work in Mammoth. But we would pay for the honor to watch that. I'm sure you would. In the summer, you'll see me on my version of a bike. Yes. A couple of things. We are, as a town, doing a great job on transit and moving people around and walk, bike, ride, whatever you want to call it.

1:25:03 But there's always unintended consequences. So if you drive around Mammoth today and you go into any condo project, you'll find that their snow removal is abysmal. Not because there are not loaders there, but because we've created a situation where people don't have to move their cars, so they don't, and then you can't do snow removal. So we always have to keep these things in mind when we're looking. You know, when we use our park and ride lot.

1:25:31 As a 24-hour parking lot and it snows four or five feet, people can't get out and we've created our own issue. So as we're dealing with those things, we really need to look hard at the unintended consequences, not just the rainbow vision of what they can and can't do. When we look at grants, John, for your comments, grants are a great thing and I have encouraged this town and this town has been great at getting grants. We have a trail to the lakes basin because of our ability to get grants.

1:26:01 We're rebuilding the Reds Meadows Road because of our ability to get grants. But we have to be careful on what we apply for and how we spend those, and it needs to be built into this. Sustainability. Grants are one-time dollars. You cannot get O&M for your program out of a grant. We now have a great trail system that we now have to come up with general fund dollars for every year to seal cracks, to resurface them, to do whatever is necessary.

1:26:31 So again, just a cautionary tale. Grants and how we run our budget, that excess, those are one-time dollars. They don't sustain long-term O&M on the projects we're looking for. And somehow I would like to sort of see that language built into this so that future councils understand and that we understand if we can get a $40 million grant tomorrow to create another 300 miles of trails.

1:26:59 Can we sustain and maintain those trails? Hugely important. I'll qualify that in the next round. Okay. Any additions on any of that? Good. Any public comment or thoughts? Sarah? Sorry, what were you pointing at the end? Oh, I'm sorry. I was going to... Sarah, you don't mind if I speak on behalf of your... for a moment. We've had a lot of discussion on some of the transit stuff and looking at some of the challenges in particular areas of the community, the old Mammoth Road and stuff. Yeah.

1:27:32 And the idea, not so much it has to be called out specifically, look at that particular area, but as we look like at transit, for example, and how do we look at improvements, that would be an area to be analyzed, and we're looking at that as well as we talk about the new housing developments and stuff going on in the parcel. All of that's going to have to be kind of redesigned so our transit system works accordingly to where we're putting people. So that's one of the elements, and we talk about a capital improvement program and things, and that would be something that...

1:28:00 We continue to look at it. We build into some of our own work program. But as we look at different areas, we want to make sure as we come back into that, does it fit and is it go spending dollars and time to do those things? But we know in some areas where we have conflict and or where we know we're going to need service into the future, are we planning that now as we look at funding sources as well? So kind of to that practical, whether that's at this level for sure or not, but definitely we look at our transit system.

1:28:30 That has grown over time. We've had a lot of discussion on, you know, the micro-mobility. What does that look like, micro-transit? How do we fold that into a fixed-base, you know, type transit system? There's a lot of different areas in that one particular one. So I brought that up, kind of, Sarah and I talked about it a couple times. Good questions, by the way, at the time, Sarah, asking about, hey, I drive by and see these transit stops that really need some loving, so to speak. How do we move that up? And that's some stuff that, you know,

1:29:00 Moving in quickly on the capital side as we look at funding and doing things as we get into the spring, Public Works has already got a pretty long list. It's going to be tough to implement, but there's some pieces in there that I think we really need to take a hard look at is because of the importance. And we see it in this winter season, some of the challenges just given snow and buses and transit. And we do really do a lot of work to keep the transit system working in the winter because people will utilize that.

1:29:30 Mayor Pro Tem mentioned, yeah, in some places it gets to be a problem because cars don't move and then you help dig them out later. Sarah, you've been, I hope you've been successfully channeled by Mr. Holler, but go ahead. Thanks, Dan. I appreciate it. My brain's like not functioning at the, he's reminded me of, yeah, this priority that, yeah, so my son goes to daycare in the ski trails and

1:29:59 This old mammoth transit situation is just heartbreaking. I just am watching, I go there four days a week and I am just watching people like navigate this treacherous road down to this stop and it's just, we're just really not doing right by our community over there. So I think we may have to make some decisions that are like for the good of the community in terms of.

1:30:29 Transit to Old Mammoth. And I also wanted to spur another reminder that, and I don't know if this is too granular for this discussion, but I mentioned this the other week, a big priority of mine is the business district of Old Mammoth Road. Obviously, we can't see what it looks like right now, but I just, I feel like it's about time that we look into some

1:30:58 Solutions for landscaping. I know nobody bid on that this year, but I feel like we could really come up with some, speaking of, you know, kind of leading the pack on sustainability, I think we could really come up with some creative solutions for native plants or pavers or whatever. So that's just, that's a priority for me as well. Great, thank you. I know that, I'm glad you, that old mammoth.

1:31:27 I can't see how, I'm just wondering, like, if the people who have protested the, you know, solution that we came up with are seeing this, and I just, I don't know how their hearts are feeling seeing that twice a day, but my heart is feeling like I'm feeling really, like we did a huge disservice to that community that doesn't really have the time.

1:31:55 Or maybe the wherewithal to speak up for themselves. So we really need to put that front and center. We can't have another winner like with this solution. Sure. Good points. Thank you very much. Okay. Any public comment on this one? No comments at this time. He's considering. Okay. So let's move on then to our final strategic priority.

1:32:27 Implementation of enhanced and required municipal services. Again, just throwing out some ideas. Implement plans for child care facilities, pursue funding for community fiber network planning, and implement operating lease with Mammoth Lakes Foundation for the Edison Theater. Just update all that. Let's keep it going forward. These are programs that are in process. Finalize plans and agreements to complete the CRISP-based radio communication system. Update that. I don't know where we're at with that, but let's look at that.

1:32:56 Move that forward. Enhance the town's public outreach, engagement, information strategies and tactics and enhance customer-facing technology services. We're trying, we're trying, but I think Sarah, channeling my inner Sarah, development of social media toolkits. I think a social media toolkit should go with every kind of press release. I know the state's doing that now, so you send it out to people, they can easily Facebook it and social, do that kind of stuff with it. I think that little people could add to that, there'll be help.

1:33:26 Maintain long-term financial stability to support strategic investments in infrastructure and services, creating flexibility to respond to opportunities. That sounds like Mr. Sauser's admonition to all of us to stick with our budget discipline and how we do things because it really gives us unique opportunities. Maybe we add opportunities in emergencies. Okay, we can add that in there too. A couple of additions to this. Council, we've got to keep this top of mind.

1:33:54 I think that's something that...

1:34:25 We need to prioritize. I think we need to do some education with all of us. You know, EIFD, what's a surf, what's a SEDS. I think it's going to be helpful to get some knowledge up here at the dais so we can describe to people the value of this stuff that we're doing. Also, the hiring and engagement of an advocate for Mammoth Lake in Sacramento. We talked about that. I think that would be very important, and you've seen certainly the value of this kind of stuff. And as we go into this transition with the town manager, I think it's going to give us some continuity. It'll give us some, at least we'll be getting a...

1:34:54 Steady diet of what's coming out of Sacramento and opportunities like that. And finally, the successful recruitment and hiring of those people. I know it's on the list. We're already working on that, but we don't get to talk about it. Okay. So that's my blabber. Go ahead. Yeah. Good? Sounds good. Yeah. Okay, good. Sarah, anything to add? And we'll come back to you. I just want to reiterate.

1:35:24 So just for, you know, I've been talking to Dan about the social media thing. I don't know what the solution is, right? Because like Stu wears so many hats and he does a bang up job, obviously for like the bandwidth that he has. But like, what are we going to do? We keep talking like last week, talking about how really we're doing.

1:35:49 An amazing job with our housing initiatives, and sure, there's more we can do, and there's more we will do, but we just don't toot our own horn enough, or if we are, like, I know that I was the one who requested these community updates, and they're great, but like, it's a page of text, you know, nobody's reading them. I don't, like, it's...

1:36:12 We need to figure out how to market ourselves better. And I have said multiple times that we have a zillion dollar marketing arm that are professionals at this and they don't want to give up a quarter of an employee to send out Instagram posts for us. I guess I get it.

1:36:34 We got to get better at this. Like the town of Truckee is a great example. They do a great job with social media and they're like, oh, were you wondering like why this trail was plowed before and like the sidewalk was plowed? Here's our rationale. I mean, you know, during some of the early big storms.

1:36:53 I'm talking to Hayes and he's like, well, we had a blower go down and then this happened. And I'm like, this would be great for the public to know so at least we can manage people's expectations. Because then you get the peanut gallery on Facebook who's like, why? Oh, I guess, you know, I guess maybe the trails gets plowed because so-and-so lives there, you know? And it's just like, can we manage the public's expectations? Because when you don't get out in front of something,

1:37:20 The rumor mill just goes crazy. And I get it. A winner like this, everyone's twitchy and wanting to complain. But if we manage people's expectations via social media and meeting them where they are. I mean, when I campaigned for this job, I said, I'm going to get the town to communicate on Instagram because that's where younger people are. And we're still not doing it. And it's frustrating because

1:37:49 It's not easy for me as a council person to share. The content is not easily shareable. So what are we going to do? We have MLT who specialize in creating viral content. They're very good at it. We're paying them a lot of money. I don't know. It's not my job to come up with the answer, but I've been making the ask for over two years now. So we got to get there. Okay, good. Good points.

1:38:19 Yes, Chris. This is a little more granular as well, but I think it bears saying, you know, when we have big storms, we're moving in this direction, but we need messaging alignment from the mountain, the town, and MLT so that people are clear about, you know, what we're asking of them. I'm talking about our visitors, of course. So just something to think about and worth mentioning. Okay, good. More about the local, and I will take, you know.

1:39:05 Comments again, because I've said something about our precious locals, but your Sacramento comment, you know, I think that a couple of times in the last year or two, we have partnered extremely well with Truckee and other counties to identify more of those where we can regionally, as you were talking about with the airport, to me, even more important politically, to align ourselves with the other like areas so that we can carry something to Sacramento with.

1:39:39 Let's face it, even our own legislators don't look much at Mammoth unless they want to come skiing because there's 8,000 people and, you know, a couple thousand voters. So we need a way to increase that, if you will, to hit them over the head so that we can get the things we need, including fire, tourism, all of that. Yeah, and I think it's, I think, because Truckee's been very successful, and Andy's talked about that. Look into that a little bit. It's the only way we're going to get something. If somebody go and speak for us isn't going to...

1:40:17 It's not a big enough bat to get it done. We also talked a bunch in this session about the snow removal in town and what we need to do and all of that. And I will tell you that I'm very pleased that our Public Works Department has actually changed tactics in how they deal with some things this year that have opened a lot of roads in storms like this that would not have been open. In 16, 17, they weren't. The only way to get in and out of my road was to get in the bucket of the loader I was driving and drive out with me.

1:40:47 So I want to give them kudos for that and for the snow patrol thing. That has been huge. Along with it, we need to issue a few more citations for no chains, but that goes to PD. And I understand, and Dan already knows as the chief before him, that I don't like giving tickets, don't like giving them to tourists because we need to treat them well.

1:41:13 Sometimes in times like this, it is just an important thing, which has nothing to do with our priorities. But you gave me a microphone, John. I didn't give you the microphone. It's there. I think, yeah, we've talked about the Colorado Association of Ski Towns, and I think that that, I mean, our advocacy for us is unique. It touches a lot of sort of idiosyncratic geographies, but I think that's something we can certainly include and continue to learn from that.

1:41:42 Okay, any additional thoughts on any of this? Public comment on Mr. Erty Rises. Like the Sphinx. No, I couldn't sit down longer. Actually, when you're talking about the enhanced required municipal services, I think one of the, well, two of the things that we're greatly lacking, and from a safety standpoint, are incredibly important, are phone and internet. Yeah.

1:42:08 You know, with those storms, with two kids working and not being able to reach out and find out that they need to be picked up or that they're stuck in a snowbank, it's a problem. And I know that there's discussion about a new cell tower somewhere in town, but I think that it just needs to be, it needs to be a priority because I think we're, you know, there are businesses that can't run their business because they're running an internet based POS. Right. And there are other people like myself that are worried that my son who's working in the village.

1:42:36 Am I supposed to go pick him up? Is he going to take a bus home? Is he stuck in a snowbank? Are you talking about cell phone service? Or are you talking about when digital 395 went down? Or both? Probably both. I mean, I think the cell phone service, because of the congestion in town during holidays and during peak periods, I don't know how much of it had to do with weather itself. I don't know how that affects things.

1:42:58 But the same thing with the internet, because I think that the digital 395, like you and I have talked about, it's great for your municipalities and the hospital and all those different places and the government buildings, but I think the mainstream America is not getting that level of service to the house because of the cost. So I just think that the phone service to me from a resident standpoint as well as a visitor standpoint, not being able to make those phone calls is pretty scary.

1:43:24 Agreed. And the town's phone system went down because they're on a VoIP system. That was digital 395 related, but that goes to resilience. I mean, that was specifically about these storms, highways being closed. I mean, there's a case being made to get some help with that. I think the issues around the internet and the cell phone stuff is something we need to look into a little bit, but there's definitely something we need to look at. And it is really hard to look at because those are privately run businesses. Unless as a government, we're going to do multi-million dollar.

1:43:52 But other than that, I don't know that we have much

1:44:21 Oh, it's a private business. But we have a grant. We have a grant. But that grant is to look at what we possibly can do not to actually create the infrastructure. Well, actually, yeah, let me – I think both of those things are critical. We have a – we've had a couple applications come in, like, for additional cell towers. They're great to have in the community as long as they're not next to anybody. I hate to say that, but it's – there's real concerns, like, where do you put one because I don't want it in my backyard.

1:44:47 Type of an issue. But anyway, as that comes forward, that'll go through the processes accordingly. The internet element is twofold. Digital 395 did go down and had some challenges. Some of that was to do with their equipment. Some was the backup generator ran out of propane. In Bridgeport, there were some connection issues there that we still haven't resolved that we're working through. But definitely making sure that that thing has the resiliency built into that backbone that it needs.

1:45:14 We thought it would go south as well as come north, but it had to go north first to go south. And so anyway, it was so that that's going to take some reengineering on a couple of elements, I believe. The other element that we're looking at, I mentioned earlier with the push on broadband. So we have the half a million dollar grant to really look at a design level. What would it take to put fiber basically to every address? So it starts with that.

1:45:40 Initial design. That'll be done in the next, it's about a 12-month process. That comes back in, and then there's an analysis, and there's a number of counties and cities looking at this. They will take a look at that and take the next level out to an engineering-level design, and do they have a, and they be in a Golden State Connect Authority, which is a JPA under the rural county representative group.

1:46:08 They're looking at that and say, okay, now we have somebody who's willing to come in and they'll have to look at the funding. It's probably a $25 to $35 million project to put fiber in the town of Mammoth Lakes, rough estimate at this point. They're looking to be able to do that. There's two different elements that come to that. It becomes an open system. So they go out and say, great, we'll build this. Do you, Mr. Provider, want to come in and pay accordingly and do elements on that? The build-out also has, there's another portion of the funding at the state level.

1:46:38 That actually provides some loan guarantees behind that construction. So if they can line that up and they believe they have a market of businesses and residents at certain rates that will buy into the system, they have a formula they'll go through. It's time consuming by the time you get it approved, designed, and then actually the construction built.

1:47:02 That's all in place and funding is in place to help support those elements. Now, how well do we compete in that marketplace ultimately for the construction? That's going to be a little more of an up-in-the-air question. But to the extent that the funding is there to help backstop the financing for that construction, that was a huge lift from the CPUC as well as they've allocated money into that type of a fund. So we get the design done in one year. At that point, then you start to make the decision.

1:47:31 Do we have the wherewithal to truly go forward and put a project on the ground? Again, processing, permitting, a couple of years in the process there. The goal there is to utilize primarily existing right-of-ways, so it's easier to do. But for us, the question is, how much do we allow to go overhead versus through rock, just from a cost standpoint? And our goal has been, how much of that do we get underground? If the issue is, it all has to be underground.

1:47:58 That just adds a whole other level of cost to the project. And so those types of issues will come back forward and be before you in terms of some of those levels of discussion, as well as simply what does it take to get a cell tower expansion or a new tower put in the community is difficult at best. Okay, good. Well, thank you for that. If I may? Yes, sir. Go ahead. Dan, on cell towers, I think we would not get so many complaints. Most towns like ours and even desert communities require them to be...

1:48:29 Shielded. They look like trees. Most of you don't know that one of the towers north of Bridgeport exists out there, and it just looks like a big tree. I promise you, you don't see it. If you really know where it is and you look at it, you see it. But I think that as a council, I would love to see something come forward so that we could lay that into the rules. Cell companies obviously are willing to do it. I don't think people are just worried about the appearance of it, but they're actually worried about this.

1:48:56 It being near their house because it's putting up. The other thing at the last convention in September, there were two different companies that represented exactly what Dan was talking about. They come in and they do the infrastructure. And one of them that I talked with, one of their higher-ups, his comment was, not exactly, but basically what he told me was, come to us when you grow up. We don't have anywhere near the numbers.

1:49:24 For him to come in, even with the grants, they get to do this and make it work at this point. Okay. That's something we certainly can look at. But if we're looking at that and we're digging everything up to put it all underground anyway, we should look at the electrical lines as well because, I mean, you know, that would solve a lot of problems. You have to really grow up to be able to do that? No, but you know what? If we're laying fiber, shame on us if we don't try to do. Oh, sure.

1:49:54 Okay, so I think we've had a pretty good discussion. Dan, have you got something to work with, I'm assuming? I've got a list. Okay, good. When do we anticipate that we would sort of get together in some kind of a format? Probably in March. In March, we'll be able to come back. We're going to need a few weeks to work through this and outline it. Okay. We're missing one meeting in February, so. Okay.

1:50:22 And we'll look at it, whether it'll reach out to you all. We'll have a meeting in terms of if you want a separate, especially for the next workshop, whether you want to tack it on with the council meeting or have a separate night that you actually do it. Kind of like tonight, this was kind of a special meeting night. So you can actually spend the time diving into this and not have a stacked up agenda on top of it. So we'll look at a timeline that works that way. Okay. Is everybody happy? Council seems to be happy. Public?

1:50:51 We hope the public's happy. We trust that they are. Okay, so let's move on then. We will now go into a closed session apparently, is that correct? It'll take us a few minutes to get it set up and we have a separate Zoom for both Sarah and for Andy Morris to join in. So give us a couple minutes, we'll get that set up and also let the room clear out. Okay, so 7 o'clock, does that sound okay? About 10 minutes.

1:51:19 Yeah, that's fine. If you want to take a quick break and use the facilities. So what do I, the Zoom that's on my computer, what do I do with it? Thanks, guys. See you in a few.