TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2026

Town Council

at 16:00 · recording 3 hr 38 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Notable from this meeting

8 findings

Transcript

463 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

2:50 I haven't seen him in a long time. No. It's four o'clock. Let's start our meeting. Roll call, please, Jamie. Councilmember Sauser is absent. Councilmember Wentworth? Here. Mayor Pro Tem Truex? Here. Mayor Rice? Here. All right. And John Stewart is going to lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance tonight. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic.

4:19 For which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you. Okay, it's time for public comment. If any member of the public has a comment for anything that's not on the agenda, please come up to the podium, or if you're online, please raise your hand and Zoom and we'll get to you. Welcome. Mayor Amanda and city council members, and I notified the clerk before.

4:53 My name is Phillip Betancourt. We are longtime seasonal visitors this year in Snow Creek 5 from our home in La Quinta where it is 105 degrees right now. I wanted to extend the remarks that I also presented to the tourist board earlier today and put in two salutes. One to the limelight where we had the privilege of staying.

5:22 For three days to prepare ourselves for the wine walk, if you will. It's an extraordinary property. We also had an opportunity to tour the ski club and, of course, the few remaining luxury homes, if you will. I think maybe the food service is still a work in progress, but the buffet breakfast is extraordinary. We enjoyed every minute of it.

5:49 Secondly, for the Wine Walk, we want to salute Tom Bissell and the volunteers and their team in the Small World Department. Tom's father and I are actually office mates in Newport Beach and we were thrilled to hear that he has come to Mammoth Lakes, he and his wife. They are great community assets. We thought the Wine Walk

6:19 Was absolutely the best management of volunteers. The participation was just extraordinary. And I think you are very fortunate to have them as distinguished representatives of the Mammoth Mountain Community Foundation. And we want to salute everyone who participated Saturday and who knew that Schatz Bakery had a wine of their own.

6:45 With grapes in Bishop. Of course we had to buy some at the end of the day. Thank you, Madam Mayor. Thank you so much. And I'm glad to see that Tom Bissell's walking well again. All right. Any other public comments from anyone in the room? Hi, Kevin. How are you doing? Hi. Hi. Good evening, Mayor, members of the Council. I'm Kevin Leanne with the Mono County Office of Education.

7:13 And I'm here today to extend an invitation to our Mammoth Huskies mural celebration. It's taking place next Tuesday at Mammoth High School at 5 p.m. This was a collaboration led by Mono County Office of Education in partnership with the school district. We're here to celebrate the new mural. I'm sure you all have seen it. I'll leave some copies down here for you in public.

7:43 Thank you so much. I saw it. It's beautiful. And I think it's going to stay on there really well because it's in the shade. It's great. Awesome. Yeah. And we've also got the Mammoth High School's Culinary Arts Program serving the refreshments as well as some music from the music program from our student musicians. So it should be a lot of fun. Wonderful. Thank you so much. Okay. Thank you. Hi, Brianna.

8:12 Good afternoon, Council. Brianna Guayco, Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce. I just wanted to highlight a few things coming up in the business and outside of the business world. We'll be doing a ribbon cutting for a new business, Grooms by Axel. It's a mobile dog grooming business on National Dog Day, which is Wednesday, 20...

8:31 Sorry, Wednesday, August 26th. We'll be over at the dog park from four to five. If you're able to join us, always great to see council and community members there to celebrate a new business in town. So bring your four-legged friends and come join us. Next item, community coffee this month will be on Thursday, August 27th. As always, 830, 930 on Zoom. And this month's topic will be featured on...

8:58 Wildfires and all of the different mitigation efforts that we've been seeing go on around town. So obviously there's a lot of activity out there. So it'll be nice to have an update from Whitebark Institute, Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District and Cal Fire. So join us for that Thursday, August 27th, 830 on Zoom and our coffee shop this month is Looney Bean.

9:16 Speaking of the culinary program at the high school, they're doing really great things over there with Stacey Schlichta leading the students there. We're going to be doing a Restaurant Association mixer on Wednesday, September 9th over at the school so our local restaurateurs can see what's going on locally to prepare youth hopefully for careers in food and beverage. So we'll have that on Wednesday, September 9th, 3.30 to 5 over at the high school.

9:44 And then we will be hosting a candidate forum on September 29th. So I've been in touch with all eight.

9:56 I think that's correct. Eight candidates that are running for the three seats for town council. And so we're going to be hosting a forum. It won't just be us asking questions of the candidates the whole time as we've done in the past. Amanda, I know you've participated in those fun sessions. We'll also have some time for the participants to just get some face time, some round table with the different candidates, just a little less formal, a more casual setting for people just to get to know who is running for council.

10:25 So that'll be at Burgers, Tuesday, September 29th, noon to 1.30 p.m. Anyone from the community is welcome to join us. This is part of our new at-the-table lunch series that we're doing and really just trying to facilitate more conversation amongst the community. And then lastly, our...

10:44 Nominations are open for our 10th Annual Business Excellence Awards. So that'll be open through the end of the month. So anyone in the community can nominate any business, any person that they feel has gone above and beyond in our eight various categories. You can just go to our website, mammothlakeschamber.org for that. And we would love to hear from lots of different parts of our community on that.

11:08 And last thing, I don't know if I mentioned here, but the business guide is final, so we're working on getting that up on our website, and we've already started talking to some different prospective businesses, current businesses, expanding businesses about the business guide, and really hope that can serve as a resource for them for both the chamber, town, and the county to use. Thank you so much. Thank you.

11:39 Good evening, Madam Mayor, Council, Tom Hodges. I'm here before you this evening in my role as the President of the Board of Eastern Sierra Community Housing. And it's my sincere pleasure this evening to introduce you to our new Executive Director, John Stewart, who I'll let step up to the podium here in a minute. But I just want to acknowledge our, you know, recent actions of Eastern Sierra Community Housing that, you know, we, as you guys are all well aware, are...

12:04 A longtime executive director stepped away to accept a position with Mono County, Patricia Robertson, after 13 years of service to the organization, and we wish her very well in her new role there with Mono County. That was back in March, and we, in the process of recruiting a new executive director, we hired an interim executive director that...

12:25 I think some of you may have met, I know staff interacted with Dana Topman, who was a really well qualified individual with a lot of background in workforce affordable housing. It was fantastic to have him sort of fill the gap and assist us with recruiting a new executive director. And I just wanted to mention that we did go through a pretty extensive process. We had the position advertised and solicited and received about over 200 applications.

12:51 Narrowed the field down and went through other interview processes and settled on John. And I just mentioned, you know, some of the reasons we selected John for the role is really, you know, really exemplary past work history as a leader of other nonprofit organizations. And specifically, John worked for two fairly large, fairly guaranteed nonprofit healthcare organizations, both in Virginia and in Kansas.

13:21 We're organizations that had, you know, in excess of 100 employees and budgets in excess of $10 million, involved a lot of interaction with federal agencies and funding and so forth in the communities that they were serving. And that really stuck out to us as something that we were looking for in the role of our new leader for our organization, as just somebody with that real solid leadership experience. John also, and I don't want to still have a stunner, but he's got, you know, personal connections here in Mammoth, is it?

13:51 Specifically with his family. And I'll let him mention that maybe to you guys. And then I also wanted to mention just of interest. John probably wouldn't tell you this, but he's a University of Kansas graduate, actually has a graduate degree in architecture, which also we thought was very appealing to us in our organization as we do some development work. And then also of note, he was a Division I college football player for University of Kansas in defensive end.

14:20 Defense event. So, yeah. So, I always know to keep my conversations level with John. So, with that, I'll let John introduce himself here. Thank you, John. Mayor, council members, good evening. Good afternoon. Good evening. I appreciate the opportunity to introduce myself and, more importantly, to begin working with you all.

14:45 Whether in this official capacity or elsewhere in the community, as Tom said, my name is John Stewart. I just joined Eastern Sierra Community Housing as the Executive Director. And this is particularly meaningful for me. I've spent a lot of my career in mission-driven organizations. And my connection to the Eastern Sierra is personal, as Tom said. My three adult kids are settling here and setting down roots.

15:09 And I've spent enough time here in this community to know that Mammoth is a remarkable place, as I know you all know, and that it's also incredibly challenging to build a life here. Housing is obviously at the center of that, and housing isn't simply about putting a roof over someone's head. I believe it's a matter, a measure of our success will be whether the teacher, the restaurant worker, the young family, and people who keep this community running.

15:38 Can actually imagine a future here. I still very much am in listening mode. I'm getting to know our staff, our board. I'm understanding our properties still, our programs, and I'm digging into our operations. And I'm beginning conversations with community partners. But one thing's already really clear to me. There's no single entity that's going to solve this alone. This is going to be collaborative.

16:04 I've also learned over many years of leading community organization that partnership has to be earned. And I feel strongly that you earn it by doing what you said you'd do, by bringing bad news early, and by bringing solutions when you bring problems. And that's the kind of partner I want ESCH to become. At the same time, I'd like all of us to think ambitiously about what ESCH can become and what role we should be playing in helping this.

16:31 The people of this community not just find housing but put down roots. I know the composition of this council will be changing over the next several months, which makes this an especially important time for me to listen, for me to learn from those who have been doing this work for a while. And I hope you'll give me the opportunity to sit down individually with each of you and to understand what you've learned and help me understand what I need to know to make ESCH more successful and ultimately to make this a better community.

17:01 So I think our success, as I said, will be measured by how many, not just by how many people we help house, but by how many people we're helping put down roots. So I'll look forward to working with you and I want to thank you. Thank you so much. Any other comments from, public comments from anyone in the room? Anyone online, Jamie? No. Okay. We will move on to item four, additions to the agenda. Rob, are there any additions?

17:28 Madam Mayor, there's a modification to the agenda. We are removing item 7.1 for a future meeting, and that would be the presentation from Eastern Sierra Community Foundation. They will be prepared for a meeting in September. Okay, thank you so much. So we are on to item 5, introductions. 5.1, introduce new arts and culture manager, David Barron. Evening, Madam Mayor, Mayor Pro Tem, members of council, staff, community, big night tonight.

18:03 We're welcoming lots of people to our community. So I'm going to be as brief as I can. I'm missing a contact lens, so I have to bear with me too, right? So anyway. So it's my privilege today to introduce David Barron to you. And the community as our new arts and culture manager for the new Dave and Roma McCoy Arts and Cultural Centre. We're all very excited.

18:29 David brings an exceptional blend of leadership, strategic insight and experience in theatre, media to this position and we are immensely excited to welcome David in this new role. A little bit of background, David holds a degree in theatre from Yale University, he'll talk a little bit more about kind of that, with focused coursework in theatre management through the Yale School of Drama. His early career included production and theatre management roles with institutions such as the Manhattan Theatre Club and the Mayboo Mines.

18:59 Mabu. Mabu, got that right. He also co-founded and managed the Sacred Fools Theatre in Los Angeles, which is a company that continues to thrive to this day. David also has a long career at the intersection of media and technology, highlighted by a 14-year career as a founding executive at Hulu, as well as roles at Microsoft Paramount.

19:28 Fox and Disney. After three decade hiatus from performing, David returned to the stage this past year, appearing as Bully in Driving Miss Daisy, the Mammoth Lakes Repertory Theatre. I'm going as fast as I can. And more recently, taking on the title role as King Lear, if you saw that up at the Little Eagle Lodge Outdoors, which was amazing. David is married to Chris, previous mayor, and have been full-time residents for over five years.

19:56 And homeowners here since, for 20. They have two kids, Sam and Ellie, both of whom were on the Mammoth Ski Team and enjoyed Mammoth Summer Camps. Of course they did, thank you. Coached by Stu. I know, right? And hikes in the Eastern Sierra Backcountry. Apparently you've got a crazy dog called Linus, which I think we've all met. Some of you have met. Yep. And two senior cats, both at rescues. So the opening of the new 259-seat theatre,

20:25 Marks one of the most exciting developments, as we all know, in Mammoth Lake's short history, 40 years and young. Getting from here to opening days, we know we'll require deliberate planning, thoughtful strategic investment, and tremendous community engagement collaboration with our many arts and cultural organisations. David's major responsibilities, we didn't touch on these, we'll be back in a couple of weeks with more detail. In the coming months include coordinating with Public Works and Amy and that team and Hayes on the construction of the facility.

20:54 If you saw some of the photos today, we shared those. And the planned technical capabilities of the theatre space. David will also be hiring and training our technical and operational team and staff, developing a robust two-year performance calendar. So we're really looking at building out next year's and the following year's calendar in the next, you know, few months. We'll also be launching a new website, so it'll be kind of standalone to the town Civic Plus site, right? It's got its own look, brand, feel. So we're excited about that.

21:23 We'll also establish a strong social media presence and building a dynamic community engagement and region-wide outreach plan, right? We've got a great new shiny object, let's tell the world. One of the other items that we're working on, which is kind of a standalone system that's, well, yeah, standalone to Dash and our DaySmart system will be kind of a new ticketing system, right? So performing arts has a very narrow, specific kind of field based on ticketing.

21:51 It has to do a range of functionality such as subscriptions, we have to assign seating, right? We want to scan our many members and ticket holders into the facility, needs to manage donations, manage box office operations. So we're going to be digging into selecting a ticketing system over the next few months as well. So lots to do. So we're very excited about that. But all of these really leads us into kind of building an excitement.

22:17 And really that momentum, right, that we've been building for the last kind of decade and beyond as we move closer to opening the doors of our brand new performing arts centre. And when I say our, it's really ours in the community. So we're really excited about that. That's enough of me. Like I said, it's a privilege and honour to welcome David just to the microphone if you want to say a few words. It'd be wonderful. Thank you very much. Good afternoon, Mayor Rice, Councilmembers, friends.

22:48 First, I really want to thank all of you and Rob and Stu for this opportunity. This is a huge opportunity to expand on the great creative work that already occurs every day in this town and really create a truly wonderful and unique culture of the fine and performing arts in the town of Mammoth Lakes, anchored by the new Dave and Roma McCoy Arts and Cultural Center. And I'm really honored to have a chance to shepherd this project forward.

23:15 I would also be remiss if I did not thank Chris for helping facilitate this job. And thank you for coming today, too. I look forward to coming back to you in a couple weeks with an updated roadmap of what we need to accomplish over the next few months and the next year as we get to opening day for the new theater. We're going to continue to update you on our progress on a pretty regular basis.

23:42 And bring to fruition what I know has been a very long process in getting a performing arts center built and operating in this town. In the meantime, please don't hesitate to reach out if you have any pressing questions or things that we need to address. And I really look forward to working with all of you as we get to opening night. And thank you again. Thank you. Thank you.

24:22 Okay, we are on to item six, reports from commissions and or departments as needed. Stu, are you coming back up here? Reports from commissions and or departments as needed. Don't encourage him, please. Any opportunity to speak and promote our wonderful world of park recreation. So I just did want to highlight that the parks, future park amenities survey is now live. So hopefully everyone's had a chance at participating.

25:02 Kind of sharing their voice about kind of what they would like to see at the bell-shaped parcel as a future park. And then the opportunities that we have for expanding Whitmore Recreation Area. So please jump on and do that. I do want to say also that the clock is ticking on opportunities to play at the Mammoth Rec Zone. That'll close August 30th. Oh, August 30th. Coming up fast. Yep. We are going to start pulling some of that sports tile, the two volleyball courts.

25:32 We're going to move one of those volleyball courts over to the school that they would use for their invitational volleyball tournament. I think it's over Labor Day weekend. And then we'll be simultaneously making ice. So we hope to have ice by mid-September. And again, our opening for the public is October 1st. The Whitmore Pool is also scheduled to close for open swim and kind of public recreation swim also on August 30th. That is that Sunday, last Sunday in August.

25:59 And it'll stay open for the next couple of weeks for lap swim through September 11th. So that's how that looks through there. And I think that's kind of all I had on that world, unless you think that there's anything else. Summer camp's finished, which is very exciting. And we will be introducing, hopefully at our next council meeting on September 2nd, our fall program of enrichment and after school activities.

26:24 Wonderful. Do you plan to offer some availability for like Tuesdays for parents who have a hard time picking up their kids early for early release days or is that in the works also? Good. Great. We'll pass that on. Fabulous. Yes. Any questions for Stu?

26:40 Where can we find the link to that survey? Is that something you can, someone could send it to Council? Yeah, thank you. I appreciate that. So that link is available through our social media content. It's also available on the Town's website under Parks and Recreation. People can just click on Parks and Recreation Master Plan. It'll take them straight to that website. Okay. So if you want to find the Parks and Recreation Master Plan, Google. Jump on the Google tool. It'll take you straight to that website. Click on the survey. It's in both English and Spanish.

27:05 And so far we've received, I think, over 120 responses. So we're very fortunate and grateful for the community's kind of weighing in. And then we'll be, I think, coming back with our consultants later in September for some more community engagement. So I'll talk about that in the next meeting. But thank you for the opportunity. Fabulous. Thank you so much. Any other reports from departments? No?

27:32 Mayor Rice, I'd like to just make a couple of comments about the hiring process for which David was selected because that was fairly significant and robust in that. And I want to thank all the people that participated in that process. Obviously, we were thrilled with the outcome of landing on David as a selected status. But we did have a robust interest in that role. We had, you know, I think more than 60 people that originally applied for the role. Had several different iterations.

28:01 I'm sorry, different processes by which we interviewed folks for that role. And, you know, the first one being a staff sort of narrowing that down. And the staff went through, I think, 16 different interviews, narrowed that down to the three that I then interviewed with Stu and a consultant. And then we decided after that interview process to go through a community panel.

28:26 And have members of the community also involved in that selection process. So through the three processes by which making a decision on that, it was overwhelming support for David in that role. Then I had the unfortunate role of contacting Chris and saying, well, Chris, we want to select your husband for this role.

28:48 You'll have to vacate your position with council. So I wanted to clarify a little bit of that and just let folks know that's the process by which we went through in that decision. And it was a really well thought out one. It was a long and delicate process that we had to work through. And I just want to appreciate the HR team, Stu and everyone else for getting through that effectively. So thank you. Thank you. And I mean, I guess his comment of Chris facilitating his

29:16 Position is her putting her political career on hold. Because when you first said that, David, I was like, what does he mean by that? And then I was like, yes. But yeah, you have a very supportive wife who's putting your career in front of her political ambitions at the moment. So it's a wonderful partnership. Thank you. OK. OK, so we have item 6.1, Town of Mammoth Lake social media report for July 2026. This is just a written report. Any questions on that? That's correct.

29:46 Okay, item 6.2, August 2026, Public Works Engineering CIP Update. That's a written report as well. Are there any questions? Are there any public comments on these two items? No one online either? No? Okay. So we are on to item 8, staff presentations. 8.1, informational presentation on mobile home park regulations in California.

30:11 Thank you. I am, uh, I'm not in the room, as you can see. I'm, I'm on vacation in Alaska. Um, but I have been working with Nolan, um, and with Mr. Rudin, who's there on your screen, uh, looking very professional, wearing a tie. I don't think I own a tie anymore, but, but, um, and this is a really complicated issue, as we've previously indicated to the council, um, whether and how to regulate mobile home park rents.

30:38 It's very, very complex. And so we thought that the best thing to do would be to bring in Sergio, a partner at my former firm, who has extensive experience in crafting and administering mobile home park rent control ordinances and is very, very familiar with kind of how this works statewide, has been part of some ordinances, and he has helped us come to a better understanding of

31:04 of the issues involved, and we're going to ask him to present this item to the council. Yeah, thank you for the introduction, Andy. Yeah, Sergio Rudin, a partner at Best Best in Krieger. I also serve as a city attorney to Sausalito and interim city attorney for South Lake Tahoe right now. You know, for reference, I primarily do land use zoning and building regulations as special counsel for various public entities, and I have

31:33 advised various public agencies on mobile home park rent control issues, including advising boards of appeal for mobile home park rent regulations. So I'm going to share my screen and hopefully we can get started on the presentation here. Can you guys see that okay? Not quite. It hasn't loaded yet. Ah, okay. There we can see it now. All right, let's start this slideshow.

32:05 So we're here to talk about mobile home park regulation and rent control. The regulatory framework is multi-layered. There's a lot of state law on the subject. When it comes to opening and operating a mobile home park, the State Mobile Home Parks Act and HCD's implementing regulations comprehensively govern

32:30 All construction issues related to mobile home parks, their use, their maintenance, occupancy, permits, utilities, the layout of parks, lot lines, inspections, and health and safety enforcement. Importantly, local agencies cannot do any of those things or regulate those things unless HCD provides approval for the local agency to become the local enforcement authority. And so there is state law on

32:57 How that happens, but you do have to petition and seek approval from HCD. When it comes to regulating occupancy and the relationship between landlord and tenant, the mobile home residency law sets a lot of regulations for what must be in rental agreements, how a landlord is supposed to give notice of rent increases.

33:26 Fees that can be imposed by a landlord, process regarding sale of mobile home parks, protections for tenancies and termination for tenants, and additionally a process that a landlord must follow to change any of the park rules, and additionally to convert park uses, so if you have a park that's dedicated to seniors specifically.

33:56 There's a process by which the landlord must follow before they can change that to an all-ages park. So what's the city's role? The city still has its land use role, so it can zone for where mobile home parks can go. It does retain some police powers, but for the most part, a lot of those are preempted by state law. The key one that the city does retain is control over rents.

34:23 You can adopt local rent control. There are certain prohibitions in state law and carve-outs, including you can't subject new parks and new spaces to rent control. And additionally, you have to abide by constitutional protections for landowners in terms of not having your rent control regulations so burdensome or so confiscatory that the property owner doesn't get a fair rate of return.

34:53 So again, the sort of roles and responsibilities, you know, HCD is responsible absent the city or the town assuming enforcement authority and getting their approval. It's responsible for all of the health and safety code provisions, regulation of common area, utilities inspections, permits for construction, registration of homes.

35:22 And it also has a complaint program with regards to all of those issues. Additionally, there is private rights of enforcement by tenants, so for violating any of the state law standards. Importantly, there is current legislation at the state level. AB 1128 would create a statewide rent cap beginning in 2027 if it passes.

35:53 Additionally, there is a exemption among various other exemptions from local rent control. If a space is not used as a principal residence, AB 768 is currently in process, which would narrow that exemption and create a presumption that a space is used as a principal residence. So again, just this is an outline of

36:24 The kind of roles that HCD plays versus the city. Importantly, local code enforcement can't treat any state-regulated park conditions as ordinary municipal code violations, and those things do need to be referred to HCD for enforcement unless the city gets approval to become a local enforcement agency.

36:53 Why are we here discussing this? I'm aware, and Andy and staff have made me aware, that the town council has received a number of complaints regarding one of the mobile home parks in town. The owner of the park provided a response to the council as well. There are a lot of concerns over rent increases. There are also concerns about what's in rental agreements.

37:20 There's concerns about snow removal, condition of pavement, lighting trees, retaining walls, fences, and maintenance issues. At present, for a lot of those issues, the town doesn't really have jurisdiction to address them. However, the town can take action on some of the rent issues, as we'll outline.

37:50 In this presentation. So again, HCD is going to be responsible for dealing with the kinds of complaints that have been raised related to roads, common areas, snow, tree, retaining walls. With regards to concerns about lease terms, those can be raised to HCD.

38:12 Additionally, landlord-tenant law and civil court is going to be the appropriate place to resolve a lot of those issues if there are disputes between the tenant and the landowner. Annual increases in terms of space rent can be subject to town rent control, subject to complying with the exceptions in state law. The main exception is obviously new construction, which isn't going to apply to the parks in Mammoth Lakes.

38:43 So, importantly, there is pending state law, as I mentioned previously. AB 1128 would impose a statewide rent control cap, which would be the lower of 5% rent increases or 3% plus CPI. So this is more restrictive than what's in place for Costa-Hawkins.

39:13 Legislation is based on an existing statute, which currently applies only in mobile home parks that are in two or more jurisdictions. So basically the state decided that for those parks that statewide rent control would control. Importantly, there was litigation over that statute. It remains pending. And so that may be a consideration for the legislature.

39:41 From all indications, this is proceeding towards adoption and we'll have more information as to whether or not it passes the Senate anticipated in the next couple of weeks. Importantly, stricter local rent control limits would remain ineffective if this bill passes, but I'm not aware of too many jurisdictions that have more restrictive rent control than this 5% or 3% plus CPI cap.

40:11 Again, as I mentioned earlier, AB 768 would revise one of the exemptions and create a rebuttable presumption in favor of the tenants that a space is used as permanent housing. Importantly, given the amount of time that it does take to draft and adopt a local ordinance for rent control, there is

40:37 A high likelihood that 1128, if it passes, would pass before the town can prepare such an ordinance, so that is something to consider. Additionally, the state is working to provide more resources to non-profit legal aid organizations that are in the business of representing mobile home park tenant interests in litigation against park owners.

41:06 This pending bill would require HCD to develop a grant process to distribute funds to these nonprofit legal services providers, and also it would require that the complaints that HCD receive be referred to them for enforcement action. So without rent control, what laws typically apply to both landlords and tenants in parks?

41:37 State mobile home residency law regulates a substantial amount of the tenancy issues by requiring specific terms and rental agreements which cannot be preempted by local ordinance. These include disclosure requirements, provisions regarding rent increases and the timing of rent increases. So there are notice requirements which tenants have to comply with.

42:05 The mobile home residency law also creates the process by which park rules may be amended. It does provide for some fees for HCD's complaint program, which are passed through tenants to tenants already. It does contain restrictions regarding sales, rentals and subleasing and provisions for that, as well as restrictions on park management terminating tenancies only for specific statutory grounds.

42:34 And then again, it does create the HCD's protection program for tenants, which is primarily complaint-driven and complaint-based. If the town does decide to go forward with rent control, one of the key issues is that any ordinance adopted by the town does have to provide for a fair rate of return. And typically,

43:05 Any ordinance needs to consider the landlord's operating income and expenses. Oftentimes they are based on allowing CPI increase over time to ensure that a landlord's rate of return is preserved or at least not depleted to the point where they can no longer account for maintenance costs. Oftentimes ordinances are drafted.

43:33 Considering comparable space rents in adjacent jurisdictions or adjacent parks. Additionally, any ordinance does need to provide for a mechanism to ensure that a landlord can undertake capital improvement for the park and do rehabilitation if necessary. So this is typically to ensure that utilities remain functional.

44:00 Address the common area maintenance requirements, et cetera. And then, of course, any fair rate of return has to allow for the landlord to pay their taxes, utility costs, et cetera. And oftentimes, fair rate of return requirements do take into account service reductions by the landlord in terms of allowing for adjustments downwards.

44:29 The most common methodologies in these ordinances, most of them are based on a maintenance of net operating income, meaning that if a landlord is getting a certain amount of operating income, they are allowed to maintain that level, taking into account depreciation and things like capital improvement requirements to make sure that the same standard of

44:55 Park Operations is maintained. Other ones are, of course, return on cash investment and return on value. So a lot of ordinances are also drafted with an assumption that they're based on a base rent date. So the ordinance assumes that

45:21 Existing rent prior to rent control was at their rate of return because it was sent by the landlord. And typically an ordinance will just allow that, you know, pick a date prior to the passage of rent control to be a base date and then they will allow, you know, limited increases based on CPI or some sort of formula. Additionally, most of these ordinances include a petition mechanism for the landlord.

45:49 to petition for a different rent amount to be considered their base rent if for some reason their rent on the base rent date was under market and they can demonstrate that. One of the things that has resulted significantly in litigation is that you cannot typically adopt moratoriums that are indefinite and we have seen this result in litigation during COVID over

46:21 Moratoriums adopted by public agencies because over time, while a temporary moratorium will not be illegal when adopted, over time it will eventually erode the opportunity for the property owner to obtain a fair rate of return that allows them to recoup their investments and pay for all of their operating costs. So mobile home rent control ordinances are

46:50 Frequently the subject of challenge. They're probably more subject to litigation than rent control ordinances of other jurisdictions dealing with residential real property. There's a lot of case law dealing with mobile home rent control ordinances. Typically, public agencies are successful in defending these.

47:19 A lot of the facial challenges are rejected because courts will recognize that public agencies do have the authority to adopt rent control as long as landlords are not entirely deprived of the economic value of their property. But typically the as applied claims, meaning a landlord is challenging whether or not

47:47 An ordinance provides them an adequate return in their particular circumstance result in very lengthy court cases, oftentimes going to the court of appeal, and they can be very costly for public agencies. Cities have spent hundreds of thousands of dollars, sometimes almost, sometimes in the low millions, you know, one to two million defending.

48:14 Their rent control ordinances. Carson Valley, I think, had years of litigation over theirs. Most agencies that have had them will have some sort of court case involving them at some point in time. Importantly, while most of the legal challenges are brought by landlords to

48:42 Over whether or not they're provided an adequate rate of return for their investment. Increasingly, we are seeing that sometimes they are brought by tenants, challenging city decisions to allow for increases by landlords. Beyond making decisions about how to structure the city's rent control regulations and what methodology you want to include in terms of ensuring you're providing a fair rate of return and

49:11 What sort of adjustment mechanisms you want to have? One of the big questions is whether you want to have vacancy control or decontrol. For residential real property, Costa Hawkins provides for vacancy decontrol, which means that every time a space or rental unit is vacant, the landlord gets to set the rent for themselves. Allowing that typically decreases the likelihood of legal challenges because

49:39 of the landlord allowing, having a mechanism to allow for them to set what they think is market rate. But a number of ordinances for local jurisdictions do include vacancy control, which ensures that rent doesn't significantly increase when a mobile home is sold or a tenancy changes.

50:06 It does allow for greater continuity and predictability in home values. This will typically result in more difficulty for administration of an ordinance because you're more likely to have landlord petitions to deal with. But it does typically result in more protections for tenants in terms of predictability for home values and for resale of homes.

50:36 Importantly, another big question is who do you want to have be responsible for hearing petitions for rent increases and adjustments to rental rates? Cities have a couple different models. You can have a board that considers these. You can have a staff-administered model where it's handled by a hearing officer.

51:04 In either case, they're both time-consuming for staff to administer. Certainly a staff-administer model is simpler. It requires fewer public hearings. It is typically faster in terms of routine administration. That being said, there is some benefits to having a hearing model in terms of it's a dedicated forum. You know, you will have more decision-makers involved.

51:36 Roaner Park, Fresno, Carson, Beaumont used boards and commissions for this purpose, but a number of the smaller cities, as well as Fremont, used a dedicated staff officer. Again, just going back to discuss sort of the cost of administration and the litigation risk, Thousand Oaks spent five years in litigation, spending three quarters of a

52:08 After repeal of that mobile home park rent control,

52:39 Capitola did, during COVID, re-adopt mobile home park rent control as an urgency measure. Additionally, rent control is being blamed by park operators as a primary reason for park closure. There is ongoing litigation, both Petaluma and Windsor, over the closure of parks in those jurisdictions and relocation obligations under the city's local ordinances for those tenants.

53:10 In terms of preparing an ordinance, there's a number of steps, as well as steps in terms of administering. Typically, the city has to make a decision on the big picture policy questions, draft its regulations. Additionally, administering these kinds of regulations is not cost-free, so it is appropriate for the...

53:37 Town to consider adopting a fee that is imposed onto landlords typically, who then may or may not, depending on your particular ordinance, impose that on the tenants. Typically you need to gather information about your existing tenants, base rent data, conduct outreach with landlords prior to implementation. Additionally,

54:07 You will need to, once the regulations are adopted, most jurisdictions have registration requirements, compliance review that is done annually, record keeping, and then a provision for annual adjustment of rents. In the instances where the city's or town's ordinance is not providing for a fair rate of return,

54:35 There will be a requirement that the ordinance include some sort of fair rate of return adjustment mechanism, usually done by petition of the landlord, and so there needs to be a mechanism to hear those, and obviously that is going to result in annual reviews. Usually you'll have at least

55:01 If you have a number of mobile home parks in your jurisdiction, you will usually have at least one or so of those kinds of petitions to decide per year. And then additionally, you may need to consider hiring either consultants or hearing officers to address those particular kinds of petitions. Program fees.

55:29 Most local ordinances have either a purse-based fee or administration fee that is used to fund the staff time, keep track of registration, pay for noticing hearing officers, mediation arbitration is sometimes included in local programs. The fee amount is usually set by resolution. Almost always, fee amounts are not sufficient to recover all of the legal costs that can come along.

55:58 with these kinds of regulations. Importantly, they're usually not set with the expectation of litigation, even though litigation is a significant risk. So with the fair rate of return requirements, most of the time any program fees that are imposed on a landlord are calculated as part of the landlord's operating cost and can be a basis for the landlord to petition for increases.

56:30 Oftentimes, if the local ordinance doesn't prohibit the pass-through of these fees, landlords will pass through the fees to the tenants. So if the council wants to move forward, there are a number of questions for the council's consideration, including what exactly the council wants to address in its ordinance, which formula it wants to use for rent control, including

56:59 Whether or not it wants to undertake vacancy control or allow for vacancy decontrol. The town does need a plan for the eventual administration of an ordinance, including deciding whether or not it's going to be administered by a dedicated board or hearing officer. And then additionally, a lot of local regulations include provisions governing park closure and relocation requirements for tenants if in case of park closure.

57:29 Again, based on the experience of Petaluma and Windsor, those may not be something the town wants to undertake at this point, but it is something to consider. And then, again, in terms of cost of administering the program, there will need to be an evaluation of the program cost, and additionally, the town will need to think about how much of a program it is willing to subsidize.

57:55 And then lastly, given the pending state legislation, that is another consideration for the town in terms of whether or not to move forward or see whether or not the state with its additional resources will be moving forward to enact statewide rent control for mobile home parks. And that is my presentation and I am happy to take any questions.

58:23 Okay. Thank you so much. John, do you have some questions? Yeah. Help us understand why this is so complicated. Is there a legislative history in California that's added up to something that just seems kind of impossible out of the box? I'm not trying to be glib about this, but can you give any background on why regulating these things is apparently seemingly so complicated, involves state agencies, all the rest of it?

58:55 Just any thoughts you might have on that. Before Sergio dives in, I'd just like to say that it's complicated because of the legal rights involved, and it's complicated because of a long, long history of litigation involving these issues. The law has changed over the years. The courts keep having to hear challenges brought largely by landlords.

59:20 What you get is you have a complicated set of rights, you have complicated laws, and you have an atmosphere that breeds litigation. And you put all that together and you get what we have, where drafting ordinances, in some areas of law, ordinances are pretty much cookie cutter. This is one area of law where they are not. There is no one true path, there is no one right way to do it, and every jurisdiction just does the best they can and makes choices they think,

59:50 Will serve the community. But Sergio can expand on that. Yeah, Andy, thank you for that. I agree with everything you've said. I think the main reason it is so complicated is that the fair rate of return standard for local rent control is so incredibly squishy. When you're asking a court to figure out what is fair for a landlord, it is always an adjudication of very fact-specific issues regarding the operations of a specific mobile home park.

1:00:19 What may be fair for one park is not always there for another park. And because it is park-specific, tenant-specific, landlord-specific, it is very hard to predict, as you are drafting these kinds of regulations, where the weaknesses may be in them. Okay, that's great. I think we get the general idea. If the town were to wade into this,

1:00:46 Would the regulations apply to all parks within our jurisdiction? The second question being, how many parks do we have in Mammoth Lakes? You have two parks, at least according to staff. And yes, if you adopt mobile home park rent control, it would be my recommendation that you have it applied to all parks in your jurisdiction. And what are the two parks? That is the ski trails and the name of the other one escapes me.

1:01:17 Sierra Holiday. Okay, so not. It's over by Azimuth. But not the, you know, the mobile. The RV park? The RV park. That's not. That's a campground. I mean, that's a, I would think. It's a federal, it's a federal thing. That doesn't apply to this. That is outside of the town's jurisdiction, is my understanding. Okay. All right. Those are my questions for the moment. Thank you. Okay. Brent, do you have some questions? Yes. A couple questions, if I could, please.

1:01:41 Just to clarify, one of your statements that says that health and safety issues are responsibility of HCD on within the trailer park. So I just want to make sure I'm clear on this. So waste disposal issues, bears, crime rates, unsafe buildings, that's HCD and that town has no jurisdiction? That is correct. Unless the town petitions to become a local enforcement agency that typically all of the issues regarding

1:02:07 Construction Standards, Health and Safety Code Provisions, and utilities, all of the things that deal with the built environment are almost all entirely subject to regulation by HCD. And there are very few jurisdictions that have petitioned to become a local enforcement agency for mobile home parks. I don't know the exact number, but it's a small, small minority of the jurisdictions that have parks. The vast majority...

1:02:39 The jurisdictions with parks have relied on HCD to continue to do the enforcement. Just one clarifying point. Can you two explain to the audience and us what HCD is? This is the Department of Housing and Community Development. So this is the same agency that is responsible for housing element law, enforcement of ADU laws, and generally the state's housing agency. And where are they headquartered? I would assume Sacramento.

1:03:10 Okay, and they don't have, they have a branch office in our region or we would be dealing with, we and everybody in the community would be dealing with Sacramento, correct? I believe that would be the case. I do not know about whether they have branch offices. Okay, thank you. A couple more questions and it follows up to the previous question a little bit. So we have residents who are raising concerns regarding challenges, maintenance issues, rent issues.

1:03:38 What can we do right now through HCD to address any of these conditions without waiting for an ordinance or other action? Do we have any... Well, with regards to the existing complaints, the town can serve as a liaison. It can petition HCD to take action on, you know, existing issues. I do believe that having local agencies reach out to HCD has increased enforcement efforts in the past.

1:04:09 Does that require any particular action other than us taking action, or is there a petition for that? What's the process for that to happen? So HCD does have a complaint service, and certainly staff can encourage tenants to file complaints. I think that's important, but staff can also follow up on behalf of tenants to see whether HCD is taking action.

1:04:39 So you've put a number of different points out there, and I'm just trying to understand because there's not a financial component per se, but let's just say the town adopted a rent stabilization. In your opinion, what does that do to the actual rents? Because I'm concerned about cost being, okay, now we do it, now we charge an extra 10% fee, and then there's another fee that goes on this, and the landlord charges another fee. Does it actually reduce the rates? So local rent control does,

1:05:13 Slow down rent increases. It is very rare that local rent control results in rent rollbacks. Okay. And then the other one that I have is, so let's just say we ask staff to look at this and start to look at implementing something. What's the length of time would it take to get an ordinance in place? We've got state measures that are potentially going to impact this. Could be some overlap. But what's the realistic time frame to put something to place if we went down that road?

1:05:45 Realistically, I would probably say three to five months. Yeah, I concur with that. And the reason that it takes that long is because, as I said, the ordinances are not cookie-covered. There are no two that are alike. And I've looked at a couple dozen of them. They're all different. And they're all the result of a bunch of small, discrete, separate policy choices. As Sergio said, you have to decide how to calculate a fair rate of return.

1:06:15 You have to decide who's going to administer the ordinance. You just have to make a bunch of choices. And I think that in order to do this properly, we the staff, probably with Sergio's help, would need to bring to the council a bunch of options. And I don't think it would be as simple as, here's the staff recommendation, because the issues are complex. They need some time to unpack. And I think that it would require

1:06:42 Probably multiple council means. I'm not sure that the council would be able to do the subject justice and reach a decision the first time considering it. A lot of jurisdictions that enact these ordinances will want to do some outreach to the park owners and have them be part of the process so their voices are heard because that can be a way of reducing the likelihood of litigation. Some jurisdictions have sought to involve

1:07:09 Park residents in crafting the ordinances, which also adds time. So I really don't think it could be done in less than three months. I think five months could be done with a lot of focus and discipline and focused attention on the subject. Do you have any other questions? No. No. Okay. I have a few questions. Sergio, I'm hoping that you can clarify.

1:07:38 You said something about that there, I just didn't quite understand, you said something about like there's an exemption for two parks in different cities or it only applies to two parks in different cities. Yeah, so the statewide legislation which is being proposed is based on a statute which currently imposes that 5% or 3% plus inflation cap.

1:08:04 In mobile home parks that are in more than one jurisdiction. So that statute already exists and the proposed bill would expand the reach of it to all parks throughout the state. Okay. So. Okay, thank you. So that is, that is an effect and the, was it the AB 1128? That's, that is going to expand it to all parks? AB 1128 would take state rent control for mobile home parks, which only applies to a handful of parks and apply it everywhere. Okay.

1:08:33 Thank you. And then, let's see. Nolan, I think this is a question for you. How comparable are the rents at the two mobile home parks in town? The town does not have detailed information on what the actual rents are charged. Based on what I've heard, they're fairly comparable, though, or comparable to each other. Okay. They are about the same. Okay. And then, how is the land zoned? Can it only be used for...

1:09:07 A mobile home park? Correct. So within the town zoning ordinance, there's a mobile home park zoning designation. That designation only applies to the two existing parks. Then there outlines standards if we were to, what process and steps we'd have to take to create any new parcel zone mobile home park with size and specific details on that.

1:09:34 But then it also regulates the uses that it can only, only allows for mobile home parks or mobile homes to be placed within the park, does not allow nightly rentals within the mobile, the two mobile home parks. That's kind of the extent of what that zoning does. Okay. And then, I don't want to interrupt, but I, I'm just getting a hint of a question there that you might be wondering, well,

1:10:02 Something else happen on these sites. And Sergio can address this in more detail, but I will tell you, I do have some experience with the idea of wanting to close a park, and it's somewhat complicated, it's very expensive, and it's time consuming. Because the mobile home park law provides a number of rights to tenants, which are fantastic, but they make it very financially difficult for park owners to close a park, because they have to provide extensive relocation benefits.

1:10:31 To the tenants. Sergio, have you ever had a jurisdiction actually have a park close? I have only dealt with trying to have a public agency acquire a park. So I have not actually had to deal with park closure myself. Yeah, and I've only addressed it in a jurisdiction that was thinking about talking to the property owner about doing that. I have never actually seen a park close, to tell you the truth.

1:11:01 I'm sure it's happened, but it's very rare. That was kind of my line of questioning, is if they would be able to drive up the rent so much and then close the park and have it zoned for something else. But that sounds like that's not a possibility. It's possible, but it would not be easy, nor would it be cheap or quick. Okay. And then the AB-1128, you said that there's not really a timeline for that?

1:11:34 No, there is a timeline in order for it to pass this legislative session. I believe it has to, let me pull up the state legislative calendar. I think it needs to be signed by the governor in September. And it needs to, I believe, exit the, I think it needs to be passed out of the houses at the end of October. Yeah, September 30th is the last day for the governor to sign or veto bills.

1:12:09 October, August 31 is the last day for each house to pass bills. And then they go into final recess. So we'll probably know by the end of this month whether or not it's heading to the governor's desk. Okay. Okay. Are there any questions? One other quick question. Do the other HOA, other homeowner associations associated with parks, is that possible? And do the two parks at Mammoth have HOAs?

1:12:40 Typically parks will not have associations, although certainly tenant groups can band together and form an unincorporated association to represent their own interests with regards to the landlord. Often in, you know, condo developments are similar under David Sterling. A homeowner's association is responsible for managing of the park and it, you know, collects assessments, etc. Park management.

1:13:09 Usually contracted by the landowner is responsible for that. So there's not an HOA in the sense that you may be thinking of it. But there could be a tenants, some sort of organized tenants association for the parks. Yeah, and increasingly for some of these mobile home parks, these kinds of tenant associations banding together sometimes will buy out the park from the park owner. Okay, that's it. Thank you. Okay, just another question. Yes, Sergio, just one more question. You brought up an interesting thought in my head, but.

1:13:37 When you said you were involved with a public agency potentially acquiring a park, is that a difficult thing? I kind of got through your voice that's not necessarily a easy thing. Yes. The short answer is yes. It is difficult. Okay. That's it. Okay. And then I guess I had one kind of question. I don't know if you'll answer to this, but it's a mobile home park. How mobile are the homes?

1:14:01 Not mobile? I don't know. They're not. No, they're not. Okay. And that's the main reason, and that's why there are so many state law protections and comprehensive state regulation over what landlords can and can't do is because, as a practical matter, it's very hard to move any of these homes. It's essentially a homeless step there. Especially once they get to be over 20 or so years old, which a lot of coaches are. I don't know the ages of the units in either of our parks, but you essentially can't move an older coach without it falling apart.

1:14:31 Just can't be done. Okay. So we've done questions. Let's do public comment, and then we will do deliberation. So if you have a public comment, you can come up to the podium, and you have five minutes to tell us how you feel about this issue. Hi. Jennifer Kreitz. I'm on the County Board of Supervisors, and I also want to just not take away the thunder from anybody else, but I do want to recap on some of the legislation. So AB 1128.

1:15:01 It's actually been through a gotten amend and it's in the Senate right now and it was amended to only be a rent cap for the city of Torrance so it will not be a statewide rent cap on mobile home parks this year because once it's been amended in the other house it can't go back and be amended again in the Assembly because now it's in the Senate.

1:15:27 AB 768 is dead. It's not going to get hurt again. So those things are off the table. I think it's important for us to know that as a community when we think about next steps. I mean, many of these big cities, too, have lots of mobile home parks. We're kind of lucky we only have two in the sense that that's easier to work with the tenants and the landlords. And I think...

1:15:53 Being in this situation where the land is zoned only for mobile home parks is also favorable in my opinion. In the county, most of ours is zoned commercial, so therefore it could, you know, it would be controversial, but it could potentially become something other than a mobile home park. I personally think that the housing fund is a great place to fund the administration of a policy like this.

1:16:21 And that, you know, a lot of these bills that we've seen throughout decades, I would say, as long as I've been working in affordable housing, have been brought to the state. But the lobbyists on the park owner's side are just so strong that they just never pass. And it seems a shame to keep waiting for that for our residents. It is an organically affordable.

1:16:51 housing source here in our town. And I think folks deserve some stability. And that's really all this policy would do. It wouldn't reverse rents, but it would make them stable. And I can appreciate the desire for that. So that's all I wanted to share. Thank you so much for your time. Thank you, Jennifer. Welcome. My name is Jennifer Barrett. I actually am the other park representation for Sierra Holiday.

1:17:23 I actually manage the community with the support of some team members and we've owned the park for three years and I do consider us to be very good park owners. We're very involved with the community. We have homeowner meetings with them to understand what the needs of the community are. In that community we have 83 sites. Only 78 of them are occupied because we hold the others back for the snow removal every year and we don't plan on bringing homes into those sites.

1:17:52 I think some of the concerns that I have is I think that we all share the same goal. I share the same goal as the community does, which is really having stable housing for our homeowners. And I feel like we really do do a good job at that. We have MRL is in place to protect the residents and to protect park owners like ourselves. We also have measures. Sorry to interrupt. What is MRL? The mobile home residency law.

1:18:19 Okay. And when we talked about HCD, the HCD program that was mentioned by the gentleman, I love that program. If a resident has a concern about the way we maintain or don't maintain a community, they can call and file a complaint.

1:18:36 There are no satellite offices, by the way. It's either Sacramento or Riverside County, and they will come out to the community. We've had HCD out to our community twice since we've purchased the property because we've invited them, or we've had something done that requires permits that they come out and do that. Specifically for Sierra Holiday, one of my concerns is the percentage of residents in that community who own the homes that do not live there. They either rent it out.

1:19:05 For profit. So they have their subleasing the home, they have a rental agreement with us, but they're subleasing the home to an outsider, or they're using it strictly as a vacation rental. And I do think that if this is something that we look into, I don't believe second homeowners should be entitled to that, or people subleasing their home. Right now, we can only confirm because it's only

1:19:29 Three years, it takes a while to meet all of the residents. 15% of our community do not live in the homes. So I think that's an important thing to look at when we're doing that. The other thing that I would like people to look at is the pricing of the homes in the community, mobile homes or mobile homes. And right now there's a couple of mobile homes listed in the two mobile home parks. Two bedroom, two bath is listed at $175,000.

1:19:57 It's listed at $175,000 due to its location. That same mobile home in other cities, if you pull a NADA value, which is a Kelley Blue Book value on a mobile home, would most likely be listed at $50,000 because it's a mobile home. So if this is something that we plan to adopt, we would want to look at the fair return for the landowners.

1:20:22 Selling a mobile home that's worth $50,000 for $250,000 is something we should all be looking at. The other thing, I do understand hardships. By the way, I've been in the mobile home industry only in California for 19 years, and one of my biggest things is engagement with homeowners and getting to know the communities, which is why we have homeowner meetings.

1:20:46 We do offer a low-income assistance program. So if any homeowner came to us with an increase that they received, we have a program that they can apply where that rent increase would not go into place. We would freeze that rent increase because we do understand hardships and everything that the homeowners go through. I just feel very passionate that we are good park owners. We do what's right. I have some stats.

1:21:14 That our total operating expenses for last year was $985,000. We did road work. We brought in a brand new house. We did our tree trimming. Snow removal, thankfully, was not as bad as it was in 2023 when we first took over. I'll be the first one to say we were not prepared for that because we're in Sacramento. You picked the right year. We sure did. We plan for that now. But we are genuinely infested.

1:21:43 In making the Sierra Holiday a good mobile home park. So I just wanted to share that with you. Just a quick question. I don't think you can ask questions for public comments, but maybe afterwards we could. I would like to meet with the city council. Yeah, I would love to get your information. So I think we would love to hear from you more. Thank you so very much. We can't just ask your questions. Okay, any other public comments? Hi, my name's Hari. I'm an owner and resident at Ski Trail.

1:22:16 And I very much appreciate the other park owners speaking today. And it really exemplifies the contrast, the stark contrast between the two parks that we have in our town. I would very much like the owners of Ski Trail to be involved, to be caring, to be able to freeze rent if we express hardship. It is extremely different. And I'm very grateful for you to speak. Thank you very much. And thank you for doing what you're doing for your community. However, none of that, unfortunately, applies to Ski Trail.

1:22:44 So I just wanted to bring that to attention. Unless the owners of Ski Trail are here to speak? Mayor, do you have anything to listen? No, I mean the park owners themselves, I don't believe, are here to represent themselves. The park operator. The park operator, yes. And we have many residents at Ski Trail here, and that is what brought all of this to the attention of the town, is specifically the park of Ski Trail. So again, thank you for coming and sharing that, and I just want to make sure that everyone is aware it is a very, very different situation.

1:23:16 I would like to just ask one question to the lawyers if that's okay. I think what we should do is if there are questions we can take down the notes and then at the end our staff could respond. Sure. Yeah, this question refers to the ski trail is trying to get all of the owners and residents to sign new leases and inside that lease it...

1:23:42 States that any rent control ordinances will not apply. They're claiming that they're going digital. This is their argument. However, they're telling us we have to come in person and sign physical paper to go digital. So I just want to bring that to everyone's attention and ask if there's any legal grounds because I know some people have unknowingly signed that lease and if there's any legal standing in that should a rent control ordinance pass. Okay. Thank you so much. Any other public comments from anyone in the room? Come on to the podium.

1:24:14 Hi, my name's Will. I've lived in ski trails for almost seven years. My comment is about the fair return for the owner. The owners of ski trails have owned that park since the 70s. I don't know how long. I don't know if they give out 50-plus-year mortgages, but that park and that land has long been since paid off. I heard a rumor that their annual tax bill is $14,000.

1:24:43 I don't have my phone on me, but I did the math at $1,500 a month times 63 units. You're close to $1.2 million a year, even if our only amenities are snow removal and trash. So if trash was $1,000 a day, which it's not, you would still be left with close to $900,000 of pure profit.

1:25:11 Minus your $14,000 tax, you're at $886,000. I doubt they're paying the snowplow guy. We have the worst snow removal ever, and they constantly refer to that as a big expense. I don't think the snowplow guy is receiving $10,000 every day that he comes in. Does it even if he did, like he still doesn't come 20, we don't have 20 storm days with him doing that. So we talk about a fair return. How much?

1:25:41 How many hundreds of thousands of dollars is fair for the owners of this park to receive? And then back to their response, the owner's response to the accusations or whatever, they say that tree works, no removal and maintenance are ongoing, citing contractors, inspections and

1:26:10 HCD inspections. I've never seen anything repaired in our park the last seven years I've been there. There's no mention in here of the poor management that we received from Blizzard Property Management. I cannot stress how arrogant the owners of this park are, and that's why I like that the operators of the other park were here. That shows that they actually care. I'm very surprised that you even got an answer from the owners.

1:26:40 To respond to this, but I am begging this council to do something because the owners of our park are on par by 7% every year to displace over 60 families out of their homes as their final legacy. The owners of our park are in their 80s and late 70s. They are some of the most arrogant people you will ever meet. I'm sure at some point somebody that this town council has dealt with them.

1:27:07 But like I said, they are on par to kick out 60 plus people from their homes every year, making our homes worth less and less money by every rent increase. My home probably went down over $200 in value just in the afternoon being in this room. And I beg you guys, please take this seriously. I see that you guys have taken it seriously, but I'm begging you to use all the power that this town council has to help our residents here.

1:27:37 One of our residents drives the bus. The other resident runs the taxi company in this town. Hari is a nurse full-time at our hospital. One other resident is the head of Parks and Rec. These are not people on vacation. We are all hardworking people, and we are being taken advantage of every single day by the owners of this park and by Blizzard Property Management. And I just thank you for hearing us out, and I hope that...

1:28:05 You guys can do everything you can to help us. Thank you. Thank you for your comments. Thank you. Any other public comments from anyone in the room? Come on down. Hello. My name is Sofia Flores. I've been a local resident since 1997, and I am also a resident at the Mobile Home Park. And I grew up in the Sierra Mobile Home Park here in town. So I am very familiar with both of them now. And I just want to say that the residents were not naive.

1:28:44 of what it takes to have property value. We're not. And we're not asking to take away from profit. What we're asking is just for stability in housing. So we want to work with the park owners. We want to make sure that this is something that doesn't hurt the residents or doesn't have those kind of negative effects. But we do realize that the rent increases are just too much for the working families.

1:29:13 And that is what the mobile home parks are. We have maybe a few second homeowners. I didn't realize it was that high with us here at mobile home park, but in ours, we know our neighbors. And so, and they're all part of the workforce community here. And when we're talking about money, this town will lose more money losing those residents who can't afford to live here anymore. And you're talking about the places in town that are supposed to be the most economical places to live.

1:29:42 The cheapest places that you can buy. And yet families are being pushed out. And so that's where our concern is. And so we don't, like I said, we don't want to take away profit. We just want to make it fair housing because we own property too. And that's why we are such a sensitive, protected class because we own our homes, but we don't own the land. And so that's why this is such a complex cases. And so thank you for adding this in the agenda. And again, I just,

1:30:13 Push that we continue to have these conversations as a community because it's complex, but I think we're valuable people of our community and we are worth the time and the energy and the money that this will have. Thank you. Thank you so much. Any other public comments from anyone in the room? Do you guys want to start a line behind anybody else want to talk to? I have just one comment to add to all of that.

1:30:45 I think it's very important that the town supports our citizens here in trying to find a longer-term solution as it relates to rent control. But I like to pick out the low-hanging fruit here and just point out we have a dispensable space issue. Residents of the park have complained to me about how they're not allowed to trim the trees and that the park owner's not doing anything. So their places are in danger.

1:31:13 The greater community of Mammoth Lakes is in danger if we have an issue like that. So I would just like to encourage the council to direct staff to work with HCD to work on those issues because I think there's a lot more power with the town complaining to HCD besides just individual residents. That's all I have. Thank you. Any other public comments from anyone in the room? No? Anyone online? No.

1:31:44 Okay. So staff, would you be able to, or Sergio, would you be able to answer the question about is it legal or would it be held up in court with a mobile home owner signing a paper that said that future mobile home rent caps would not apply to them?

1:32:09 I'll address two comments that were made. One, I did pull up the legislation for AB 1128, and it does appear that that was gutted and substantially revised within the last few days since the agenda was published, so surprise. With regards to the rent control issue, historically,

1:32:36 State law had a provision that long-term leases of more than 12 months were exempt from local rent ordinances. However, AB 2782 basically narrowed that exemption and any lease of any length signed after 2020 is no longer exempt from local rent control. So to the extent that local leases have provisions.

1:33:03 Saying that they waive local rent control regulations, those portions of the leases are likely void. Okay. Thank you. Thank you so much for that. Okay. Well, would you like to tell me your thoughts? Brent? Well, I'll start with this way, and then it was going to be, I was curious when Jennifer was up here with the other trailer park, what their rates of increase have been over the several years, just in comparison to no overall, because we seem to have a...

1:33:28 We have a very focused audience here on not that trailer park, but the other one from that standpoint. My portion is that I think there's an opportunity for us here to engage HCD from staff, try to help see if we can help expedite some of the complaints that have been there. And I think we should be taking a look at what this really takes to implement an ordinance and make sure that we've evaluated the cost and make sure that it makes sense in that direction. But for me, I'm

1:33:58 Favoring that we ask the staff to come back with what's this take to put an ordinance into place and not just the presentation today, but what's the real nuts and bolts to make this happen. Okay. John? This is a very interesting situation. And this is, I think, the true value of living in a small town, living in a small community. We have powerful levers to use to try to address something like this.

1:34:27 I have questions for staff that I don't want to get into here. I very much thank the woman from the park who came forward and advise we have a civil situation in our park. We're conscientious and we care about people that live there. Some interesting idiosyncrasies around second homeowners and nightly rentals. We've spent a lot of time going through that in years past. And I'm sensing that there are opportunities there.

1:34:54 I would hesitate at this point to start bringing in sort of a government mandate to try to address this problem because it seems like we have an example of something that seems to be working pretty well and we have an example with perhaps some individuals, I don't know these people, I'm not casting any aspersions up here at the dais.

1:35:13 Perhaps there's some cultural problems going on over there. And I think it's worth exploring that and exploring the levers we would have with HCD as a town to look at what's kind of going on over there and to see if we could maybe try to get some of those things into compliance before getting into, I mean, this whole environment.

1:35:36 Litigation, all the rest of it. I don't know if that's going to make anybody happy. So I would want to explore other local options before getting into something like that. But that's my thought. But again, I've got some questions for staff and questions for residents, people living in these places. I'd like to do some fact finding here to see what's kind of what's going on. Okay. Thank you.

1:36:00 I agree that I think that we need to petition HCD to make sure that the complaints that have been hopefully filed, if not filed, like I think that, you know, we need to, there are a few things at play where it seems like there are issues with the living standards, but then there is a separate issue of affordability and so I would be in favor of modeling an ordinance on AB 1128, you know, capping the rent at

1:36:30 5% or 3% plus CPI, whatever is lower. So, I mean, I think that we need to take steps. I think that it's going to get less affordable. So I don't know if Jennifer, she's still in the room. I mean, I would love for our staff to talk with her and see, you know, just kind of see what is reasonable from her standpoint and, you know, and then also have staff.

1:37:03 Talk with the mobile home owners here tonight, you know, to see what's reasonable from their point of view. Because I do think, I mean, that's 60 community members that, you know, work in our hospitals, you know, their kids go to our schools, like, we have to keep their housing affordable and, you know, it's much, much more affordable to draft an ordinance.

1:37:30 And cap rent than it is to find housing for 60 families. And I would agree with completely what you're saying. I'm just looking at what is going to be the most effective and efficient solution. And I would hesitate. I mean, it's fine to explore an ordinance. We can start looking at those kinds of things. But I think it's going to be in the community's interest if we as a community can deal with these issues on a human community-based level.

1:37:58 I think once you start bringing in ordinances, you know, things like that, trust is going to go out the window right away, which maybe that's okay, but I'm not, based on the litigious history of this, the very complex nature of it is described by both attorneys, it gives me some pause to think that that is necessarily going to be the solution we're looking for. But there is, I mean, like,

1:38:26 Other renters in town are protected by, you know, what is it, like CPI, up to 10% annual increases in your rent, you know, and mobile homes are excluded from that. And so I think that it's very reasonable to, you know, we only have two mobile home parks, like I think that we could.

1:38:50 Figure out something that would be reasonable for the park operators and the mobile home owners and, you know, make sure that we keep that affordable housing for our community members. No, I absolutely agree with the goal that you're articulating. Absolutely agree with that. I'm just trying to think about what is going to be the most effective, efficient way to get there. It's government. It's not effective.

1:39:15 Well, that's what I'm saying. It's like, I would like to keep Sacramento out of this if we can, if we can find a way to do, because again, we're so, we're so remote, we're so far away. I mean, you know, the question about comps, like what's reasonable return, all the getting into all that kind of nonsense. If we can find some way to be investing in our culture, investing in our small community to achieve the goals you're talking about, I would lean that way for now, but I have no...

1:39:43 No issue with exploring ordinances or doing it. And because we're a government organization, I guess we can't suggest to Jennifer that maybe they should acquire another trailer park within the community. Well, yeah, I mean, maybe they, exactly. I mean, things like that, solutions like that, but I'm interested in exploring all solutions at this point. But again, I mean, this litigation legislative nightmare is something that just gives me pause.

1:40:14 What do you need from us tonight? I'm sorry, I was just texting Andy the question. He's in Alaska. What's that? Yeah. He looked like he was laying in bed. I am not going to say that. They are all recovering from a cold, so I understand. Yeah, so we've been talking a little bit here about, you know, options. I think, John, the directions you're going are having conversations locally with folks at either owners, management.

1:40:43 Or anything else from the town's perspective. You know, we've all heard and received, you know, notes, letters, and, you know, a public comment coming in from the operator. The one thing I ask Nolan is the opportunity to sit down with him face to face and have a conversation about what they're creating here and the hands that they're forcing into a space where all of the things that you're describing, which none of us want to partake in, are our only option. And so...

1:41:10 I think that would be step one. I know Nolan has been sharing information about HCD hotlines, both English and Spanish, with folks that have been interested in understanding that process. Interesting to hear that the town itself can have an influence on that if we're going on behalf of someone. That's never been something that, you know, had been communicated to me at least, and we're not.

1:41:33 We're not doing that right now. We're not reaching out to HCD. We don't have a lot of civil, a lot of community members believe that the town gets involved in everything that goes on civilly, and we just don't, right? We don't have any jurisdiction. But if there's effort that would produce results based on our involvement, I have no problem doing that, right? So we'll do a little exploration on that as well.

1:41:55 To understand that. So tonight, you know, I think we wanted to give the opportunity for our attorneys here to share the information that we had. I think

1:42:06 You know, what I've heard is there's some desire to kind of move forward with something quickly. There's a desire for us to maybe do some legwork internally here. Well, I'll disqualify that. I think doing things quickly is kind of imperative. But I think what you're saying, Rob, is you've heard that the town could actually be speaking on behalf of people, and we haven't done that yet. I think if there's some easy, maybe some easy short-term wins or things to explore, I think we should start doing that right away.

1:42:33 Yeah, and I think we can do that and obviously communicate with council on the outcome of that effort, not at a council meeting, but, you know, real time as it occurs to give folks an understanding of that. I'm very clear that there's an interest in getting something accomplished as quickly as possible. So, Nolan, is there anything else you have for tonight? No, I think we can definitely take out on those efforts, engage with

1:43:03 I think both park owners, their management, residents, summarize those efforts and then work with Andy to potentially agendize a future policy or discussion item because we would have to have that to receive any formal direction then from town council to move forward on something. So I think us reaching out, summarizing that effort, summarizing what we...

1:43:29 We've learned from those efforts and then bringing it back to a future meeting is really the extent we get here. Madam Mayor, I think it would be helpful if there's a way to include council members in these meetings of these discussions as appropriate. You know, one of the three or four of us is something to be, to hear these conversations. It's not a... Which meetings are you talking about? Well, if they're having meetings with the park owners, meeting with residents and things like that so we can...

1:43:54 It'd be more efficient so we can hear what folks are saying. Instead of just being brought in when it comes back to council. Exactly. Instead of just getting a report, hey, this is what we heard kind of a thing. I mean, we can do that on our own, I guess, but I think it would make sense to figure out a way to do that so we're listening as part of that conversation. Mixed reaction on that because sometimes when you're council members, staff, people, you're trying to get honest feedback, it could make people be cautious or not. I think these people, I think the residents of Mammoth Lakes are

1:44:22 Proud, strong people, and I would hope that, I mean, if it's an issue, fine, but tell us, that's what we're here for. Maybe you haven't, but I've already been engaging with a number of people, so I'm here tonight. I've already been having one-on-one because I want to make sure this has come as a pretty significant issue, and it's affecting the character of part of our community, and I think we have to address it sooner rather than later, so I've been pretty invested in having those conversations already.

1:44:47 Okay, well, I have not been, but I'm available if you want me to sit in and be part of these conversations. And then I guess, John, I just wanted to, you know, crunch some numbers, too, is, you know, like, I mean, Sergio shared how much different cities have paid on litigation costs, you know, with the most expensive one being $1.5 million. I mean, that sounds like a lot, but, you know, with our bridge program, finding housing for 60.

1:45:19 Families would be like $9 to $12 million that we would spend subsidizing purchasing units. So, you know, I think that any money that we would put into this would be well spent keeping that housing affordable for our community members. What kind of money are you talking about? I'm just saying like $1.5 million on litigation sounds like a lot, but if you're comparing that to... I've been on this council long enough to remember...

1:45:48 Litigation issues with the town. It's probably not something we want to say that that's a price we can be willing to pay. Well, but if we're modeling it on other ordinances that have been litigated. Well, I'm not convinced. I mean, I'm hearing the stressors that are coming in the ski trail community. I'm hearing that. But I'm not convinced yet that we don't have to pull out the ultimate legislative legal hammer that that's going to actually get us the solutions that we want.

1:46:18 I'm not convinced of that yet. And, you know, if there are property owners that are along the lines that the gentleman described, I think that it sounds to me that there are things that we could do within the rule book that currently exists to say, look, you're acting as a bad actor, and this council is extremely concerned about what you're doing and the risks that you're identifying. So I think until...

1:46:44 I hear something from those landlords, those park owners that say, we do not care. We are going to keep doing exactly what we're going to doing. And as Rob said, there is one tool we have left to play, which is going to be this. Then I'd be willing to go there. I'm not there yet. Okay. So do you have what you need for tonight? Okay. Yes, we do. Thank you. Okay. All right.

1:47:08 That is item 8.1. We're going to move on to item 8.2, update regarding electric vehicle EV charging stations. Just give it a minute for the room to clear out. All right, Hayes, is this one? That's me. All right. Working here? Yes. Okay, so the catalyst for this item tonight is requests from Tesla for expansion of electric vehicle charging stations in the town of Mammoth Lakes.

1:48:16 You guys are aware we get asked regularly for opportunities to provide charging stations. I suspect that you've heard from local residents about needs and desires for different types of opportunities. And as you'll hear later in this presentation, we don't really have good guidance on staff as to how to move these things forward or ignore them or whatever the case may be. But I thought it'd be a good opportunity to kind of talk a little bit about

1:48:43 The background of the town's participation in providing these services. What I've seen on public property, private property, a little bit about the current request and a little bit of discussion about a policy and plan. I am not looking for any specific outcome tonight. I'm not looking for any particular decision. Maybe a little bit of guidance on where we could go with this, what we could be doing. I have some ideas myself if you guys are looking for some input from staff. But we're going to just have a little bit of a dialogue.

1:49:13 So going back to 2015 is when we entered into the first agreement with Tesla. This is the site, the park and ride site. There are eight supercharger. My slide got messed up there. It says park and ride, eight superchargers. This is Tesla only. It's non-exclusive.

1:49:35 In our agreement, which I'll touch on this, I touched on this in the staff report, non-exclusive does not mean non-exclusive. There's state law that says you can't park in EV spaces. We just don't enforce it. It's in all of our agreements that they're non-exclusive so we don't have to take action, but state law says that only EVs can park in EV spaces. And we do not charge any lease to Tesla. When we put the site together,

1:50:00 There was pretty strong demand from visitors and residents to provide some type of EV charging. The second site came in 2022 with the Community Recreation Center. This was part of that whole mobility hub component. We brought EV charging, transit, parking, and then all the connectivity came with the multi-use paths and the sidewalk network into one mobility hub. Tesla brought 11 chargers.

1:50:31 Four universal and seven superchargers. And the universal, this is a point of contention, were originally J1772 universal. Part of the deal with Tesla was that they would provide free charging to non-Tesla vehicles. And at that time, it was our understanding that they could not charge for that service. That did not make it into the agreement. And later, they found a path forward to charge through those lower level chargers. And they currently charge for them, which is quite disappointing. Can I ask you one quick question?

1:51:00 When you say Tesla only is I have a small electric vehicle and there are some Tesla charging stations that anybody can charge at and there's some that they say for Tesla only. Correct. Could you clarify what? Yeah, I was going to touch on that a little bit later. Tesla is willing to make some adjustments to allow for other vehicles.

1:51:23 As part of their offer to us. These current chargers, all the Tesla stations right now are Tesla only unless they have very specific OEM, NACS type charging infrastructure. It's a very limited stock that can use these chargers other than Tesla. The universal chargers, universal, if you have the right adapters, any vehicle can use them. I have certain terminology because the EV world.

1:51:53 They use so many different terms. In the staff report, I try to make it clear that there's fast chargers, and then there's not fast chargers, and then there's Tesla, and then there's everybody else. And in that world, those spaces, there's a lot of sub-uses. Just trying to keep it simple for everyone so we can have kind of a baseline dialogue because you can get lost in the acronyms very, very quickly in this space.

1:52:21 The third site we authorized was in 2023. This is the Electrify America site. This is at the Hillside parking lot. These are six fast chargers. These are not exclusive to Tesla. These are universal, so anybody with an EV can use them that has the right adapters and infrastructure. They have an option to add two more on top of the six that they're installing right now. We are not taking a lease payment on these.

1:52:46 Like I said, they're open to all EVs, and this is currently under construction. My understanding, I was out there just the other day, they're awaiting some inspections from SCE. That was the main challenge with this getting completed last year. My understanding is that will be done this week, and by the end of next week, they should have about half the site buttoned up and people can start using it again while they're getting their final inspections, setting their switch gears, setting their transformers, and so forth.

1:53:15 I know that has been a difficult thing to deal with this summer, not having this site available. But as you can see in this photo, there's a giant trench down the middle of the parking lot. And there's another trench you can't see that goes perpendicular. So it was not safe for the public to use. But that should be backfilled and slurried in and by the end of next week open at least the majority of the lot. And here's another photo.

1:53:46 The fourth site we authorized was with EV range. This was just last November. Also at the park and ride lot. They are proposing eight fast chargers similar to Electrify America that are open to any EV. With this one we took a little bit different tact. They didn't typically pay lease payments. All of these companies have different models. However...

1:54:11 We were willing to work a deal with them to get a $600 a month credit for town government vehicles if we ever move into that space. They have a building permit. They've applied for their building permit. They've received their building permit. But they have not given us a start date for construction. And I don't have any updates other than that. One quick question. Is this part of the EV range, the federal subsidy? Are they part of that federal subsidy program? I don't know how they're funding this aspect of their operation.

1:54:39 If you recall when we were going through the lease agreement, there was a whole bunch of subsidiaries under this mothership of EV Range, and they have different businesses underneath it. I can't speak to which component of the company this is under. This is something in the Jobs First Stuff regional thing. This came up that EV Range was going to put a bunch of charging stations up. So those are the four that we've offered town property.

1:55:07 To private entities to provide this service. The town itself is working on a couple of chargers. We have three chargers that will be at the town hall. These will be for government vehicles. We're working with ESTA and SCE on four chargers at the ESTA HQ, that's 210 Commerce, to support some electric vehicles and buses that they're purchasing. Our chargers will be up by, well, this year.

1:55:32 And ESTA should be sometime next year. It's about an 18-month process on that grant. I looked at what was available on private property. And I'll say that we can't control what happens on private property. So I just went off what's on the PlugShare website. PlugShare is used by most EV users, owners, to find chargers. I can't speak to the availability of these. That's for the private businesses to determine.

1:56:00 There are six Rivian chargers which are publicly available by Good Life. There's chargers at the Westin, the Village, Woolies, and one at the RV Park. I believe those are for people using those businesses. I haven't personally tried to co-use them myself. But they're on private property and they're for private use, but they are available to public or the patrons who use those services. Hayes, just a clarification on that.

1:56:28 Rock Springs going in, they're not required to put an EV station in? Yeah, the green building code requires a certain number of stations. That's what I thought they, so there is, so there is, town does mandate through code for certain things. Yeah, and they may not be publicly transparent on these sites, like PlugShare, because they may only be for the users. It may only be for people staying at Rock Spring or Limelight, you know, I'm sure they have chargers in their basement, they're not publicly available.

1:56:56 And I suspect and I know that there are other chargers in town that are under that. I just went off what was the information publicly available so we had some kind of baseline. So the request. John, to answer your question, the new Tesla V4 architecture allows for OEM manufacturers that use the NACS standard, which is the Tesla plug, to use those chargers. And I believe they've opened the architecture up to some other vehicles as well. I don't have the full list.

1:57:26 In front of me, but if you go to the Tesla website and look it up, it's got the list of all the manufacturers that can use those newer style chargers, which I have a photo of right there. With an adapter? Yeah, if you don't, well, the end, that architecture is OEM for a lot of these new manufacturers. Right. So, and I don't know how far back it's reverse compatible with like a Chevy Bolt or a Leaf or, I don't know. I don't have that detail, but the...

1:57:53 The Tesla website has that information. But I believe moving forward, the newer architecture, most vehicles will be able to use the Tesla stations. They desire to put blocks of eight. I think that just happens to work with their transformers in the way that their architecture. So if we offer two or three, they're really not interested and they're looking for blocks of eight. I mentioned the staff report, if we gave them 40 spaces, they would take it.

1:58:20 They see a lot of demand, a lot of increase in demand, and their company policy is not to be behind, they want to be in front, so they want to build out before they see long wait times. Their wait time is 10 minutes. If they see waiting more than 10 minutes, they don't believe they're providing adequate service. They have their models based on Easter Sunday scenarios, holiday weekends.

1:58:47 And I mentioned all this in the staff report, I'm not going to rehash all the details, but they see strong demand and they see a significant increase over the next five to ten years. They're offering to pay lease payments. This is different than what they've offered in the past. Up to $300 a space. And they mentioned that if they were able to get chargers that say hypothetically the park and ride lot,

1:59:17 But not the CRC, they would be willing to sign a new agreement at the CRC under the existing circumstances to pay lease there just to get more spaces at the park and ride lot. And so that's $300 per month? Per space per month. Per space per month. Yeah. So if we were to get the full $300 per space, that would be over $80,000 a year. So if you put in an ED spot, does that take just one parking spot? Or do you sacrifice other parking spots?

1:59:48 That's a great question. For the chargers at the park and ride lot, we did a very custom installation with Tesla to allow the plow blade to go through those spaces so they're wider than typical. At the CRC and what we see at Electrify America stations and what we'll see with EV range, they're designed and set up in such a way that the plow goes perpendicular so it doesn't have the same pass-through. The pass-through stations require

2:00:18 Yeah, and we'll get into the policy side of this thing. You were encumbering.

2:00:48 Public parking spaces with electric vehicle charging spaces. You're swapping them out. So that's the offer, and I can get into more details. I will say Tesla, they do what they say they're going to do, and they've been very accommodating for any issues we had. Anytime there's a problem out at the CRC or at the park and ride lot, we make a phone call, send an email, they send a technician, they deal with it. They've been a very good partner to work with.

2:01:15 But these requests put staff in a difficult spot. Every single one of these requests have been brought to council case by case, one at a time, not looking at some holistic, larger plan or policy or program. And we don't have a lot of guidance on how to have these dialogues and these conversations. And so that's why I'm bringing this forward to you guys, because we're also seeing the increase in demand.

2:01:44 The sales numbers in California, 20% electric vehicles, 5% of vehicles on the road are electric vehicles. We only see that increasing. What we're not seeing is the private side jumping in and building charging stations. Outside of Rivian and the chargers that really serve the private developments, we haven't seen a success story in Mammoth of a private, you know, Electrify America station or Tesla station.

2:02:11 So they continue to look to the town for opportunities to meet their demand. And so we're looking for guidance as to what the role of the town is in that space. We don't have good guidance on it. I looked at the Mono County Local Transportation Commission's, Mono County Alternative Fueling Corridor, doesn't really provide great guidance on what the town should be doing with its land.

2:02:39 Mono County has a policy in their general plan that says where there's good balance to allow for electric vehicle charging on county land. We don't have any similar or corollary in our general plan. So we didn't make any commitments to Tesla. We just said, hey, we'll bring this forward to council, see what the appetite is, what they're interested in doing, and then get back to them. But I'm really interested in your thoughts as...

2:03:08 What you think we should be doing, what you think we should be doing to prepare, or if anything. And that's really my presentation, and I'm hoping to engage in a dialogue on the subject. I have a quick question for you. Sure. So the charging stations at the CRC, is the electricity that's used for that separately metered and paid by Tesla, or is that in with the CRC? Yeah, so I should have mentioned this. With the CRC, Tesla,

2:03:38 Gave us $80,000 to bring that electrical service into the CRC. As part of that mobility hub component, we, the town, already had to bring in significant service to run the ice rink. They front-loaded that and paid for it for us, and so then they were able to use that infrastructure for their charging stations. But there's no monthly cost to the town to have those operating? There's no monthly cost. There was a one-time payment. Yep. Okay. And in all of these installations, every single one that we've authorized on town property,

2:04:06 They pay for the electricity. They have their own meters, their own transformers, their own architecture. We don't bear any cost there. Would Elon Musk put a parking structure at the park and ride? I don't think that's his business model, but I don't have a direct line of communication with him. I don't mind doing business with Tesla, but not maybe doing business with that guy. Okay.

2:04:34 Has anything like that been discussed or anything? Like maybe putting a, I mean, because for me looking at this, I feel like for every charging station we put in, we're losing a parking spot and parking is very tight, you know, especially during the winter months, but around the village, like it's tight all year round. I would be interested, you know, if it was increasing our parking capacity, you know, like putting a parking structure in at the park and ride or at the hillside.

2:05:03 Hillside Drive lot, turning that lot into a parking structure, you know, and having half of the spaces be EV spaces or, you know, something substantial like that. But I think that it's hard to, like you said, the county's policy, like when it is taking away parking from an already congested spot that has limited parking, I think that it's...

2:05:29 I think that the town does have limited public parking around town. Well, Brent,

2:06:02 You had a thought in mind. Oh, yeah. Well, I think that a couple of things. One is we had an interesting discussion as a council back in the basement of the brewery a couple of months ago, and we talked about a bunch of different things. But climate, our policy, our overall vision about how we're dealing with climate was an interesting one, and I'm looking forward to seeing that come forward. We can figure out how to navigate through that.

2:06:31 But one of the things I think we talked about is the fact that this may be the last winter sports recreation destination in the state. You know, that's, and Hayes is pointing out increasing demand for these kinds of things. That's kind of a unique position for us to be in. So I think it's something to be thinking about. How do we ensure that to our audience that we are in a leadership position in terms of climate mitigation doing what we can do?

2:06:58 I think your point about public space versus private spaces is a very good one. And I think that that's something that we should start figuring out how to have those discussions with, you know, with the large parking lots in town to say, look, we need to start talking with you all about it. We want to be in a leadership position with regards to climate doing what we can do. We have limited public facilities. We provide free public parking. We want to keep doing that.

2:07:27 I mean, one of the great building zoning challenges in the town is that we've got all these 1960s strip malls that, I mean, the whole downtown revitalization plan was about how do we start getting out of the parking lot business and start building housing and, you know, converting that real estate to something else. So I think this is, it's along those same kinds of lines that I think I agree with you. I think it's not ideal that we're using all of our public assets for this kind of stuff.

2:07:55 We need to bring other partners into this because we have very limited real estate, whether it's public or private. And I think we should find a way to start talking with those partners. The Rivian charters are right in front of Good Life. I don't know how they did that, but it's like the prime parking spaces in front of Good Life are Rivian EV charters. Okay, well, good on you. But I think there could be some ways that we could talk to people with more parking opportunities than they probably need.

2:08:25 Start figuring out a way. Let's start spreading the fun around a little bit. And what about the public parking down Main Street? You know, like in front of the businesses like WayRave and Stellar Brew and Napa. You know, there is public parking there that it wouldn't be an eight space. Well, I think you get into the technical realities of what they... But, I mean, I feel like in some of those things, if it were a charger or two, I would be open.

2:08:51 You know, like, away from the village, I feel like some of those businesses, it would be good for the businesses to have a single or two chargers, and maybe it's not with Tesla, maybe it's with Rivian or a different company. But, you know, the thing that they're asking for about, like, eight spaces, I don't know that we have the space for that. Yeah, and I think, I mean, if you look at what, like, what they're doing up at the mobile mart.

2:09:18 I mean, you know, these, how many is he putting in there? That's got to be more than eight. I don't know the number, but it's a large. It's a large. He's putting in a whole bunch up there. Up in Bridgeport, they just, you know, 15, 20 are going up there. So obviously demand is there. I think we want to be playing in that. But I think we should find a way to try to get more players into this to help us out with this. Well, and sort of similar from the standpoint of.

2:09:43 You can have people use EVs. We need, as a leading destination place, we should have places where people can charge their vehicles, et cetera. Maybe not just Tesla, but more universal charging stations. But to me, it's that we want to have a policy where we are anticipating and working not only businesses, whether it's our own properties, I'll come back to that in a second, but, you know, to encourage that we need to have more EV stations to a certain degree. What's the demand? Make sure we're not, like, building 500 and no one use those.

2:10:12 But I think it would be good at some point in time to we actually develop a policy on this, whether it's climate change or where we roll it into. It's like, okay, we're trying to be good stewards of this land, and it's a more efficient way to do things going down the road. But I'm not against looking at town property from time to time when we analyze the public benefit. There may be times, and I don't want to get into it.

2:10:37 Where those stations are or not because I think that staff is better equipped to judge based on power, location, whatever. But if there's a public benefit and we actually received enough return on that that it justifies public benefit. Maybe it's $10,000 a month. I don't know. I'm just saying if there's something that makes sense, I think we should be looking at that. But we should not be the only resource. And that's where I agree with what we're going is town owned because they're coming to town because we're the easy one player.

2:11:03 And it's easy to come to town and say, oh, we want to use this lot, this lot, and this lot. I mean, I originally thought the reason this is on agenda is because I'm wondering why is Hillside closed in the middle of summer and no one's told me about it. And I'm like, wow. Well, the other thing we could be doing is start thinking about how do we incentivize some of the private owners to say, look. And that's where I'm going as part of our policy is how can we incentivize or assist them to make movement in that direction so that we're working together to achieve a challenge. Yeah. I would point out also that

2:11:32 The ye olde walk, bike, ride plan, the mobility hub, the reason, I mean, there was a policy in place for why that, all that charging stuff happened, why that mobility hub happened at the CRC, because there's things in the walk, bike, ride plan that call out for things like that, and it happened to all come together in that one particular instance, but hopefully we can be looking for more opportunities like that. Yeah, I appreciate that. Some good comments there.

2:12:02 You brought up the idea of a study. This is one of the things I was going to suggest if I didn't hear it. We know we have strong parking demand. There's a lot of need in this town, seasonal need that changes. And the EV charging stations obviously impact that. But there's a benefit to it because there's a percentage of the people who are looking for it. Are they in the right locations? Are they in the right place? To be determined. Back of the envelope.

2:12:32 Town has about 950 spaces that we're responsible for in the summertime that are publicly maintained between our facilities or parks, the street parking that is formalized with signs. I'm not talking about the stuff around the ski area in the wintertime, just the formal stuff, about 950 spaces, so quite a bit. And we've got about 37 of those spaces encumbered right now. So it's a small percentage, but it does have an impact.

2:12:59 And where you place them obviously has an impact. You kind of almost mentioned economic development. I think it's a mix. People want them and then they don't want them. I think there's a desire because it drives traffic to business, but it also encumbers the parking so other people can't get it. So there's a balance there that I can't quantify. I think it would be worthwhile to talk to some experts about that and get some information from the public on how they feel about it.

2:13:28 If we're talking about studies, would it be possible to look at where the electrical infrastructure exists such that, okay, irregardless of whose property it is, this is a good opportunity, that would be a good opportunity, that might be a good place to kind of start. Yeah, where the circuitry is, yeah, because that's definitely an issue. They're looking for, it's very expensive to move that kind of architecture around. It's just a little bit of a challenge sometimes because, I mean, we do studies on lots of different things in this town.

2:13:57 What's going to take in this regard, in my opinion, is relationships with businesses to say, just like the bond shopping market and other locations, maybe this place, that you've got to work with them and say, okay, how can we make this happen? We can do a study that says we should have mall here, here, here, because these are hubs, but that may not be the location that they can be into because no one's willing to talk about it. Look at the downtown plan.

2:14:21 We put that out a couple years ago. No, I'm not talking about a planning study. It's a very, an inventory, perhaps, of where is the electrical infrastructure exists. Inventory different than a study. That's, because I heard study. That's why I'm. Maybe we, it's a decision-making tool, right? We're kind of in a vacuum right now. We've got some really good questions. We know that there's a need out there, but we're not in this position to really provide good recommendations or guidance from either side right now.

2:14:47 We're trying to do the best we can with what we understand is the demand and the need, but it's not quantifiable. I mean, we don't, haven't gone out to the community and talked to them about this stuff. Well, the only other, on a sort of a side note to that is that whatever chargers like Tesla is putting in, this whole, whatever the mystery is about Tesla only, they can't put in Tesla only chargers. And maybe because the technology's advanced to the point now where you,

2:15:14 Any Tesla charger, any vehicle with adapters or whatever will be able to use it. When I'm out there driving around, you run into Tesla lots that they say, oh no, only Tesla users can use this. And I don't know if that's a technological problem or if that's a Tesla corporate thing that they're saying they're reserving it for their vehicles. I think that that should be, if they're putting things in here, like if you've got the adapter, if you've got whatever, it's open to all vehicles. Because we can't afford to have like,

2:15:40 You know, charges for this kind of car and then charges for that kind of car. I know, we should be as universal as possible. Exactly. They made that commitment. Okay. When I talked to them, that was one of the issues we brought up because years ago when we were having these conversations about testing, we didn't have the Rivian or the Electrify America or the EV range opportunities that are coming online. This was a major issue. We didn't have fast DC charging for other vehicles. So they were willing to...

2:16:08 In the agreements, make the charters available to all OEM and ACS standard product on this new architecture. Is this a space that other municipalities are making agreements in? I guess I feel like I don't have an electric car, but I feel like I notice them mainly at businesses and not at public parks.

2:16:34 You know, town-owned parking lots. For example, like if you go to Las Vegas, like huge EV traffic going back and forth. Tesla goes and finds a place and they set up 50 chargers. It's the kind of thing that we're seeing. And think of us as a destination. And we're going to get these surges of people coming up here with those vehicles. And that's the demand I think you're talking about. We need to figure out a way to satisfy them. But when you say Tesla.

2:17:01 Finds this space. Like they purchase land and put in their own chargers or are they, you know, getting, talking to the city of Nevada and putting it on the city's property and not paying them anything and saying that we're going to let everybody charge there, charge for free and then we'll start charging people. There is a private sector incentive for this and the question is scale and volume and I think we're getting into that neighborhood where I think we can start to say,

2:17:29 Hi, you've got a demand for your users? Great. We're not going to just give you public property over and over again to do that. We need to start refining away, even if it's we're incentivizing, taking public money and incentivizing to put it on non-public infrastructure, start thinking about doing those in those kinds of ways. Yeah, because like I was approached by an EV several years ago and their deal was we won't put any property, but we're going to pay you per kilowatt usage of the device as our rent. Yeah. So they were paying for the...

2:17:59 Pay for it, and it became an income source for a private enterprise. Yeah, so I think the market is opening up in such a way that we don't have to be incentivizing just nakedly with our public assets. We can try to find a way to have a conversation on these things. And I'll add, and I mentioned this in the staff report, that there are some state law that require streamlining and processing for these types of applications for electric vehicle charging on private property. But what I've been told is that the maintenance costs,

2:18:29 The snow removal costs and those obligations outweigh the value of the rent. So maybe out in the deserts, you know, in between Las Vegas, it's cheap to buy land and it's easy to encumber it. The land here is extremely valuable and to encumber it for a small lease payment for an EV charger is not as exciting. But we don't really know what it would take to incentivize, to turn, to make that difference for a private business or a bond or a larger parking lot. We don't know.

2:18:58 Well, it'd be interesting to start talking to the private landscape, the Vons or the, you know, but the good look, you know, look, talk to those parking lot people and say, look, what do you, how can we, how did good life, I mean, was it good life to put the Rivian charges there or was it the landlord? No, it's the landlord. Okay. So that new owner. What deal did they make? Great question. Yeah. So I'm hearing there's some consensus on probably trying to put something together to understand this better, call it a

2:19:27 I just feel like I definitely

2:19:57 If you mean doing a study like you're going to put some things together, I would be supportive of that. But if you mean like doing a study like hiring a consultant and getting their expert advice, I would not be interested in that. I would say I think that kind of like each electric vehicle charging station potential idea would need to come before the council and it would be decided on a case-by-case basis. That would be my preference. I'm here a little bit different.

2:20:26 Hey, as you're saying, do an inventory of what we have. Come up with some recommendations of where it goes. But I'm looking, for me personally, the policy is not where they actually go. It's like we want to encourage that we're going to work with local businesses. We want to encourage that we keep up with having the appropriate number of EV stations that are multi-universal so we aren't stuck in one area and place them where appropriate that makes sense for the community or try to encourage them where it makes sense for the community. And that may not be on.

2:20:55 Our property. Correct. Or maybe on property. But we can't always fulfill the demand using what we have. Yeah. When I'm talking about this document, whatever it is, I am looking at hiring a consultant because it's not something that I believe I have the expertise to put together. The reason for it is because I can't make a good recommendation. I'm not in a position to tell you if this is a good deal or a bad deal, if this is the best thing for the community or the worst thing for the community.

2:21:25 I don't have the information. I don't know. I can't quantify the impact. I can't tell you the economic benefit. I can't tell you the value of loss of land that's being encumbered. I'm just not in a good spot to make a recommendation. I think the first four, the first couple were really easy, but the last one was really challenging. I felt like we really kind of struggled to get to a decision on that. And when they approached me this last time, I told them flat out, I'm like, I don't know.

2:21:55 I can't tell you if this is a good idea or a bad idea. I just don't really have a background. So when we're talking about putting a study together, I'm looking at someone who's going to look at the economics, who's going to look at the impact of parking. Some really interesting stuff that may be coming out from the state on climate that I heard about related to the value of each EV charging stations versus mobility hubs, that there's a higher priority on them. I've heard some interesting things that...

2:22:22 I would want someone to dig into and put a document together so that the next time this comes forward, I can say, hey, based on this, here's some better data to make a decision. I think what we need, I think what we all need is a basic decision matrix to figure out how to, you know, when an operating comes forward, okay, is it this, is it that, and be able to prioritize things. And it's a rapidly changing environment. And just one last thought is I've heard, you know, the...

2:22:47 Becerra, you know, is likely the next governor. Oh, we're going to make our meet our electric vehicle mandates by 2040 or whatever it is. I mean, the state is still actively in pursuit of these goals, which means subsidies, which means opportunities and things like that. But, Rob, I'm sorry. Yeah, no, I was just going to make a couple of comments. I think this is good dialogue. Essentially,

2:23:07 You know, we're always unique, right? The town has limitations that don't exist in a lot of places. When you start talking about availability of land, you know, we don't have a space where they can put in, you know, 50 spaces or go acquire some land to do that. So it's sort of put it on us to do that. We've got snow, right? Much snow, snow removal issues. So I don't think there's anything outside of the town that

2:23:32 Supports what we should do when you talk about policy. We're not going to find it anywhere. We're going to have to create the model that works for us. And I think what Hayes is struggling to figure out is just what are the parameters around that. And I think we're going to have to probably invest in studies that talk about our unique situations.

2:23:55 Gives us those guidelines because that's exactly what we're looking for. When an opportunity arises, what are the questions we need to ask? What are our marching orders that we need to put it into? So I think we're going to need that in order to really come up with something unique for the town. I'd also like to encourage, you know, I think there's a great opportunity for individual business owners to make investments that make

2:24:22 them more attractive to people that have those types of vehicles and set themselves up for the future, but they also run into the limitations of what they have in their own parking lot, grappling with the question of whether they should dedicate or not, and then going back to the cost of snow removal. I think in that space there's going to be a decision that has to be made around what is the price point for that.

2:24:45 particular spot because you've got to cover the cost operationally as well as provide for a little bit more. So in all aspects things are going to have to move and we have the answers to none of it. Can the funding for this come out of the LTC? Yes. Okay. Yeah, I guess I just feel like is a consultant going to...

2:25:10 Understand that we're on an island in the forest and that there's no parking. I mean, 950 spaces for 9,000 residents, that's not a lot of spaces. Yeah, I feel that we'll be able to find somebody who is knowledgeable in this space and can help us put something together. There's a number of consultants we work with that really understand Mammoth and the challenges here that I would be comfortable in.

2:25:38 Talking to about something like this and starting to work on a scope. Again, it's not going to happen tomorrow. This is something that's going to have to get programmed into the overall work program at the LTC and won't happen tomorrow. But I think it would be valuable to get some of this information because I don't think this will be the last time a request is before us.

2:26:00 And hopefully the market demand is going to start to increase and then we've got something in place that can help us navigate that. But would future requests still come before the council? If you hire a consultant and come with, like, get us a great playbook and this is what you should do and this is what it's worth, like, those questions of should we put an EV station here, that would still come before the council or would then staff just decide? No, staff doesn't have the unit.

2:26:27 Lateral Authority to make those decisions on the use of public land, our private, our town property. So any decision would have to come before council before any agreements are executed. I think we'd just be in a better position to say these are good spots for these, these are bad spots for these, we have good public support, this is good economic development. They can frame it up and know what they're doing. I'm fine doing the consultant as long as like the ultimate.

2:26:56 Approval comes before Council before we do any more EV parking stations. So thank you. That is actually very helpful to have some support and a little bit of guidance in that space. That's something that we'll start framing up. I do need to deal with the request in front of me, in front of us from Tesla, and we don't have to make any decisions today.

2:27:21 But I will ultimately have to get them an answer on whether or not we're going to work with them on expansion, change, leases, payments, and all that kind of fun stuff. Okay, but at this point you don't have a proposal. Do you have a site? Yes, they would expand at either location right now if we would allow them to. My personal opinion is that the CRC is too encumbered to allow for any expansion.

2:27:48 If we did anything there, I would say convert the universal chargers to fast DC chargers that were accessible by all vehicles. That would be a recommendation. I think the park and ride lot continues to be underutilized. I said this in the staff report. We've gone through an exercise of trying to make it more interesting mobility hub, but for whatever reason, it does not get utilized. I think pushing the EV traffic there rather than in the village or other locations.

2:28:15 To me, makes sense. That's just anecdotal. I don't have the data to really... So if I could, just as an example, I think it would make sense to, at the CRC, not add anything new, but update your infrastructure. Okay, good. No net loss there. The park and ride lot, I, you know, spend time, I used to get...

2:28:39 My acupuncturist was over there and I spent a lot of time in that lot. So I'd see what was happening in the park and ride lot, which is analogous to that thing that was being that Las Vegas example before. Sunday afternoons, people leaving the destination, they're in that lot charging their vehicles to drive to LA. So if that's a place that's underutilized and there's not a lot of competing interests, that might be a place to consider to add some more chargers. But I guess one thing that I'd like to bring up is with the town offices moving and there is limited parking,

2:29:08 At that Civic Center area, don't we expect to be using the park and ride lot for staff parking more in the future? I think some. I can't remember the number right off the top of my head. I think there's like 50 or 60 spaces in there. And we'll have 16, 20, 24 of them would be, if we were to expand, could be encumbered by EV chargers. So that would bring it down to how many spaces for non-EV cars?

2:29:36 Don't quote me on the number around 30, 35, not including the street parking. So the proposal though right now is for eight charging? They would do 40 if you would let them. But I think a block of eight is a reasonable, if I were to make a recommendation in a vacuum, I think eight is reasonable. I think getting the architecture upgraded to allow for other vehicles makes sense and the ability for us to renegotiate our leases to get payment.

2:30:05 If we were to expand, it could be a little over $90,000 a year, which we could potentially use for incentives or other things in a program or offset maintenance costs or whatever you guys decide, but it's opportunity that we don't have right now. Because I drive by that a fair amount, and what I see, though, is cars will park in those charging stations, and they're there for like two days. They're not getting charged or charged. They're just sitting there, and no one else can pull in. So I don't know if that...

2:30:34 It's a good or bad thing, but they're sucking parking spots. The rest of the lot seems like there's some availability that's not. It's probably impacted from the neighborhood. Yeah. Not enough parking. We have a large portion of that lot carved out for the hospital and the town hall contractors to park off-site. So we've given them a permit to use a nice chunk of that just to mitigate the impact to the surrounding, to Mono County and the courts while that construction activity is going on. But that'll be over. That'll be over next year.

2:31:05 So I don't know. I think that if you were to bring back a proposal along those lines, I'd like to see something like that. For the park and ride? No. Well, starting with CRC, just no net loss of spaces, update your equipment, renegotiate leases, bring some money in off of that. If that could be in the deal, that sounds interesting. And then park and ride, I think.

2:31:28 If there's, I mean, you heard the concerns here, but there's a way to put something in there that's going to be consistent with the use, we could, something to talk about, we could figure out if we want to do that or not. Yeah, I'm not, I guess, looking at that, and I'm not sure that's quite enough money from where I've.

2:31:45 We're thinking, but I think that if we could get the money from the four non-charging station universals at the CRC, may not be a bad exchange for- Well, then we start getting in, if we can start generating some revenue and use that for incentives to get it on non-public places, then maybe we're getting into something that we can develop down the road. But for me, I'm more interested in like eight slots there, not 40 in the park ride.

2:32:08 Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. I feel like I don't have a good visual of what they're asking at the parking lot and what we've already said. I think I've got enough here. I'm hearing we'll work on some scope for study later date. Let me go talk to our rep at Tesla, see if we can get some deal points together, and I'll bring it back with some mapping and some more information, and then you guys can chew on it at that time. There's no need to make a decision tonight. Okay.

2:32:36 Do you have what you need? This has been very helpful. Yeah, this has been very helpful. Thank you very much. Do you guys want to take a break or should we do the next? Can we do a quick break? A break. Okay, let's do a five-minute break. Okay, great. Thank you. Richard, it's our team. Oh, you made it. Yeah. I was looking for you online. I didn't know if it was appropriate for me to raise my hand or not, so. Yes, you should have. Okay. I didn't know if it could be public comment on it, so I was waiting for that.

2:33:26 Cookies? Oh, okay, good, thank you. Oh, okay.

2:33:51 We can get back.

2:34:08 So, John, I didn't see this gentleman in the room. I was looking for him online. I recognize your t-shirt and your logo there. So, we did have reps in the audience. Oh, okay. If you had any technical questions for him. I drive a Bolt and I arrive at some of your charging stations for Tesla only. Correct. Now, is that a technical thing or is that a corporate decision that we just want to make these for Tesla vehicles? That's old technology.

2:34:36 So it's not compatible. Okay, good. Which is why we're coming to the city, the town. Right. To upgrade the parking lot. So that's exactly what we want to do. Because, and you've heard in the discussion, very limited real estate. And so we don't want to have, you've got to go to five different places. If we can do that, I would support upgrading that. So my bolt, my little adapter, I can plug in and I'm happy. Right. And I appreciate that.

2:35:00 Tesla's first choice is to try to work with cities, and now that we're paying. Originally, these were zero-zero deals, and now we're providing, because we're making money, right? Well, if we can figure out a way to take the money that we're, you heard the discussion, if we can take the money that we're working, say, on a little bit of public infrastructure, and we can start going out to, you guys can figure out where's the infrastructure already at, put it here, put it there.

2:35:28 Then we're in business. That's where we're going to get to. We're moving more sustainable model, which is part of the reason to do this study. Hey, Brent. Yeah. Nice to meet you. I didn't see him in the audience. I was looking for a comment. I didn't have a comment. I just wanted to say that I appreciate his approach and the way the CDC came at it.

2:35:54 We, when we say non-exclusive, we mean that we're open to all EV providers. A lot of EV providers write non-exclusivity and releases, which prohibit us from going there. We're like the modern era that we want to.

2:36:10 Cell Electricity. Cell Electricity, but also...

2:36:35 Well, it means if you go to come here and say we want to have a new brand on the desktop and say no. We use .exclusive in all of our payments for all these purposes so that we'll have different options.

2:36:54 How was your break? Summer? No, for your five-minute break. Did you get a summer break? Well, we went backpacking and we had a great summer. Well, that's great. School starts tomorrow. That means for you it starts tomorrow, right? I start meeting on Monday. Man. Good luck. No. Okay. Okay.

2:38:11 Okay. We are back. And we are on to item 8.3, Understanding Credit Rating, Standard & Poor's Rating Review with Lauren Warren. My first presentation is about technology. Don't say anything because some other people take like 20 minutes, so you're doing great. Well, as long as we don't mind that talking up there. It's not up there. No, that's not true. It's just for you. Oh, okay. Just wanted to distract you while you were doing that.

2:38:59 So thank you, Mayor and council members. I will walk you through our credit rating review with Standard & Poor's, also known as S&P, one of the nation's leading independent credit rating agencies. This review is an essential part of maintaining the town's financial credibility and ensuring continued access to low-cost borrowing. S&P evaluates the ability of public and private organizations to repay debt. There you go.

2:39:28 Agencies typically complete a credit review when issuing new debt to assist with bond sales on the open market and through ongoing annual updates for secondary market trading. In many ways the rating functions as an objective financial report card to the community.

2:39:53 S&P assesses the town's overall creditworthiness. A strong rating signals fiscal responsibility to both rating. I'm not sure if that went forward. Sorry, I should have numbered my slides. So start over on that. A strong rating signals fiscal responsibility to both residents and investors, influencing investor confidence and ultimately affecting our borrowing cost.

2:40:27 Because the rating agency directly impacts the interest rate that we do pay on bonds, it influences the cost of major capital projects, such as infrastructure, public safety facilities, and community improvements. A higher rating reduces long-term taxpayer cost and can also remove the need for bond insurance or debt service reserve requirements.

2:40:52 The review process begins with a written request for financial documents and information. An S&P analyst review these materials, then conduct a follow-up meeting with staff to clarify details and gather additional context. Staff can provide further information to support the town's strongest possible rating. The S&P analyst then presents our full profile to an internal S&P committee.

2:41:19 Which votes on whether to upgrade, downgrade, or maintain the rating. The final rating and written rationale are published, and an S&P analyst continues to monitor the town with annual updates. We provided information on several key areas. Local economic conditions, including employment, tax-based stability, tourism trends, and tax-based diversity.

2:41:45 Management and government's practices, including financial policy, short-term planning, transparency, and council oversight. Budgetary performance, such as revenue and expenditure trends, forecasting, structural balance, and compliance with our reserve policy. Budgetary and reserve flexibility, including liquidity, fund balances, and our ability to respond to economic changes over the long term.

2:42:12 Long-term liabilities, including bonds, pension obligations, and other commitments. And the institutional framework for California local governments. This year, S&P upgraded the town's COPs rating to A-plus from single A with a stable outlook. So great news there. The published report highlighted several strengths of the town. A stable, diverse local economy supported by both residents and visitors.

2:42:43 Strong and consistent TOT performance and conservative budgeting, a small and manageable debt burden, robust financial policies and internal management, healthy reserve levels, and active wildfire mitigation and prevention efforts. S&P also noted opportunities for potential future upgrades, including adopting long-term financial planning and forecasting tools, strengthening internal controls, and financial processes.

2:43:13 They also mentioned the town's reliance on tourism-driven revenues, which can fluctuate based on weather, travel patterns, and economic conditions. They pointed out that a broader base of year-round residents generally creates more stable revenue trends over time. To be clear, this is not a recommendation for locals to pay more on taxes. It's simply an observation that communities with a larger resident tax base tend to see less volatility overall.

2:43:44 And as Town Council, your oversight is vital to sustaining long-term financial stability. And this includes adopting responsible short and long-term plans and policies, approving a balanced fiscally sustainable budget that meets community needs over time and help moderate tourism-related volatility, maintaining adequate reserve levels, exercising prudent debt approval,

2:44:13 Supporting responsible economic development and ensuring transparency in financial reporting. So thank you for your time tonight and I welcome any questions or comments. Any questions? A couple different ones. So, well, we got upgraded. What does that mean economically? What kind of rate reduction would we potentially see like on bond, et cetera? For each rate we go up, how much better are we in getting rates? So we do have fixed rate bonds, so it won't.

2:44:41 Impact us right away. However, if the market does change and say rates come down, that would allow some opportunities to potentially refinance at a savings. And the higher rate you have, the more investor confidence. And so that would be basically realized savings in terms of we should get a lower rate based on our higher credit rating. Right. So if we're out with a new bond right now, we would, in theory, get a better rate than what we were.

2:45:09 Before, because we've got a slightly better rating from that standpoint. Even though the existing rating as what we're now is really not what I call excellent, but it's very good. There was a time when we didn't have as good a rating in this community. This is a strong rating, and you are absolutely correct that there's two ways it could benefit us. If the market moves, you know, far enough that we can realize savings or for any new debt issuance if we contemplate issuing any new debt.

2:45:38 And I'm not sure with municipalities, but like private businesses, it's not yearly review, it's multiple year. Is that the same way with like SAP? Would we get reviewed next year at the same time or is it five years or 10 years? What would be the next logical time frame or do we request that? So what I'm typically used to is getting evaluated on an annual basis and then also any new debt issuances. It sounds like our past history is every other year, but we also issued the new 2024 COPs.

2:46:07 It may be an annual review. Yes, so the monitoring, as Lauren indicated, the monitoring is an annual process, but that's more of an analyst at S&P that's focused on, you know, what's going on and making sure they have situational awareness. I think that can trigger, you know, if there's some drastic changes that go on, that can trigger some other opportunities to review us. But they're all things considered every two years is what we've had and then, you know, with any issuances.

2:46:35 And my last one is just, you know, it's not always directly related, but it is. If we were to have a large incendiary event within a close proximity, could that potentially impact our rating? Just from a, I call it sort of disaster, or I don't want to say disaster, a significant impact. If we had a forest fire that was there, does that have, is it strictly just economic driven?

2:47:04 What I'm used to, in private industry, it's all economic and now it's kind of changed. I didn't know if they incorporate into climate adaptation things that happen that might impact that effective rating. That's specifically why we mentioned the wildfire mitigation efforts that we're using, because when we're assessing risk to our ability to continue to perform our revenue generating functions, which...

2:47:31 Is having people come visit the town, right? So I would say that a fire in a near proximity probably not have an impact on that. If some of the infrastructure or landscape right around the town in our playground, if you will, were to burn up, then that would have an impact directly on our ability to generate that or something, anything on the ski resort. So I think when we started talking about the wildfire mitigation efforts, to protect us from that.

2:47:59 The potential, that's where, you know, as Lauren adequately noted, it helped to buoy our rating. Yeah, and where I was going subtly on that is efforts like Whitebark and other organizations actually help our credit rating down the road. It has other impacts versus just safety itself. 100%. Yeah, sure. No, I just make... Any other questions for Lauren? Where are we at with the judgment payoff?

2:48:29 I'm assuming that's factored in, you guys are representing that to the credit books, and that it's stable laying down, and it's on the books. You can plug the higher upgrade. We got upgraded on the judgment as well. Yeah, so there are actually two rating increases on that particular one. I think it's a double A minus, so it's even higher.

2:48:52 And absolutely, yeah, we make the debt service payment on an annual basis. There's no opportunity to pay anything down early. There's a call that comes usually at 10 years. That debt itself will be satisfied, I think, in 35, 36. And so it's, you know, 10 years out, but doing well. It's saving us $130,000 a year from what the original was. So really a good...

2:49:16 Program and excellent effort that Dan put together, you know, when he was Town Manager here. So that's all, that's all factoring in. And then things like paying off the CRC would measure our, like the things, does that, does that help our debt rating? If we issue debt, pay it off, everything's good, we do it again, that's, it's like getting, like a school, it's like getting your, you know. Similar to your personal. Yeah, okay. Yeah, you're demonstrating the ability to manage your debt, right? And then, and as Lauren mentioned, you know, our debt is very, very small.

2:49:45 Frankly, in comparison to any municipality. And when you demonstrate active management of that, where you're paying it off and then seeking to re-engage, like when we talked to Marty, our bond consultant, he expects to hear from us when this is paid off for looking at other opportunities and where we can engage and leverage the funds. But yeah, Measure R will pay off, I think it's next year that the CRC debt pays off.

2:50:14 No need to get into this now, but if we, what's going on with the bond market, if you guys, if we have any big capital thing we want to start thinking about, then maybe it's too late already. It's never too late to always be looking for potential market opportunities for savings. So, you know, that is something that we should be working with our financial advisor on an ongoing basis for just any sort of market changes. I mean, the feds have been pretty stable recently. You know, they're not down or, you know, reducing.

2:50:46 The rates right now. But if we start to see them dropping 25 basis, you know, that's when it's time to reach out and say, are there any opportunities that would produce something worth savings of actually going through for refining? It depends what I'm seeing. It's going in the other direction. It's not going where we want to go. But it'd be good when you guys get updates on that to share with us. Sure. Okay. Any other questions?

2:51:13 Any public comments on this issue online or in the room? Come on, credit rating. All right. Thank you for your presentation. Well, thank you for your questions. Okay. So we are on to item nine, consent agenda. 9.1, approve the minutes of the regular meeting of August 5th, 2026. 9.2, I like your screensaver there.

2:51:37 That's not mine. That's Microsoft. Approve the resolution authorizing the purchase and sale of real property located at 550 Mono Street, Unit C-201 in the Meridian Court Condominium Complex under the Town's Housing Now Revolving Loan Fund Program and Bridge Program. 9.3. Waive the reading and adopt by title only the ordinance amending Section 2.04.040 of the Town of Mammoth Lakes Municipal Code related to Town Council Compensation.

2:52:07 9.4. Update and request continuing approval for airport emergency contract work. 9.5. Authorize a professional services agreement with Lisa Weiss Consulting, Inc. for Mammoth Crossing project management support. 9.6. Approve agreement with Mammoth Lakes Recreation, MLR, to provide services related to management of Measure R and U funding for recreation, arts and culture, and mobility.

2:52:32 9.7. Reject all bids received for the 2026 fencing and railing project and rebid. 9.8. Accept check register 730.26 in the amount of $598,235.63. Accept check register 8626 in the amount of $481,995.21. Accept check register...

2:52:59 8-13-26 in the amount of $879,405.54. Would anyone like to pull anything? Yes, I'd like to pull item 9.5, please. Okay. Brent, are you pulling anything? No, I'm not. Okay. I'd like to make a motion to approve all the 9.5 that was pulled. Would you like to second that motion, John? Yes, I will. Second. Roll call, please. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Truex? Yes. Mayor Rice? Yes.

2:53:30 Okay, on to item 9.5, authorize a professional services agreement with Lisa Wise Consulting incorporated for Mammoth Crossing project management support. Thank you for this opportunity. I just wanted to give staff an opportunity to share with us and the public rationale the reason for this contract and what the scope is and what you hope to accomplish with us. Sure, so this specific process,

2:53:58 Agreement would be for project management support specifically dedicated to the Mammoth Crossing project. With larger projects, they can, such as this, or such as the Maine Lodge redevelopment project, they can inundate a single staff member where it, and that staff member is pulled and basically only working on that project. And that creates a problem within our department, being a fairly small department.

2:54:26 We don't have staffing to commit someone fully to, you know, a project that potentially could take, you know, a year plus in the review process. So in these cases, we often do look to contract out. The nice thing of working with Lisa Wise Consulting is their, one of their key employees was a previous employee of the town, so she's very familiar with the town.

2:54:52 She actually worked on the Mammoth Crossing District Zoning Amendment, and so is very familiar obviously with the North Village Plan, so it's not bringing someone in that has to not only get up to speed, it's someone who's already up to speed and can jump right in and provide that level of support for the town so that we're not inundated. They also have additional resources that obviously they can pull in, so additional staffers and others to assist with the work.

2:55:19 Different, some of the other type projects, like with the development agreement, things like that, where we're paying for it, right? The developer's not paying for this. No, the developer is responsible, just as any, whether it's staff managing the process or a contract planner managing the process, they do compensate for that effort. So it's the same as any entitlement application, they're responsible to pay for the services. Okay, so this, but it sounds like it'd be a little bit of a blend, like there'll be time.

2:55:49 Help me out. Is it going to be all to the proponent or is it going to be a mix, some yes, some no? No, they're responsible for 100% of cost, time and materials for processing their applications. Okay. And this is directly related to the processing of the application? Correct. So we would take a deposit. That deposit would then be used to fund any invoices we get, whether it be from Lisa Weiss Consulting or...

2:56:18 Attorneys who are assisting or providing legal advice on the project, all that is repaid by the applicant. And they obviously know that this is happening? Correct. Okay. All right, those are my questions. I'd just like to accentuate a couple of comments too as well. So, you know, the first and foremost is Nolan indicated this is capacity for the town, right? But that's great. It helps us with

2:56:44 Highly professional services that they can provide. They do this much more frequently than we do. But it also just is excess capacity. But the point I wanted to make is that the hiring of this consultant, while it is fully funded by the applicant in the process, is in support of the town, right? It is supporting our work, our efforts, both to be responsive to them and to make sure everything is accurate and complete. And it's really for us.

2:57:14 Essentially. It's for the public interest. Yeah, it's definitely in the public interest that this has accomplished. So thanks for letting me make that point. Yeah, sure. Those are all my questions. Okay. Are there any public comments? No? Would you like to make a motion? Yes, Madam Mayor. I would move that the Town Council authorize the Professional Services Agreement with Lisa Weiss Consulting, Inc., subject to the Town Attorney's approval and finalization of the agreement for Mammoth Crossing project management support. I will second that.

2:57:45 Roll call, please. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Truax? Yes. Mayor Rice? Yes. Okay. So we are on to item 10, policy matters. Item 10.1, consider the option agreement with the Mammoth Unified School District, MUSD for the MUSD Parcel Housing Project. And Andy, are you still with us? Still awake? Andy? Oh, we need a lawyer. He might be.

2:58:14 I bet he's getting the room service coming in. What time is it in Alaska? Yes, I am. I know I've double-checked with you before, but I am an MUSD employee. What? What did you say? You are an MUSD employee. Can you hear me? Yeah, I can hear you. I'm an MUSD employee. I believe I don't have to recuse on this. Can you hear me?

2:58:49 Yes, I can hear you. Can you hear us? Andy, can you hear us? I can hear you. Yes, you are. That's right. You don't have a conflict because government income is not considered for purposes of the conflict rules. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. No conflict. I'll text Rob. Okay. Thank you, Andy. Thanks. All right. Nolan. Great. So, yes, this item.

2:59:23 I believe we had an item a few months ago to talk about what at that point was a letter of intent to enter into future agreements with MUSD. So the purposes of those agreements is to

2:59:38 Complete a land exchange between MUSD and the town. They have interest in acquiring land to build workforce housing for MUSD staff, so that includes teachers, support staff, and others within the district. And the town has an interest in securing the recreation facility that's currently the pickleball complex that's on MUSD land. So through those efforts, we come to at least agreement amongst staff.

3:00:08 As to that this is a makes sense, we have land at the parcel that they could build on and they have the pickleball complex. So through further discussions and meeting weekly with their development team and then on our side, it's been Hayes, myself and Marcus.

3:00:28 And really trying to identify and all come to an agreement on land within the parcel for where they could build their housing project. To further this agreement, we had a multi-day design charrette two weeks ago where HMC architects came here and participated.

3:00:52 Really to identify land that worked both for the school district and also then worked for the town's desire to build additional workforce and affordable housing within the parcel development site. So what we landed on working with them is to, for them, for the school district to acquire sites 9 and 10 within the parcel master plan. So that's the area I kind of highlighted in the red box on the screen.

3:01:19 It's border Chaparral Road and Tavern Road, kind of adjacent to phase one, the Sawyer and the park facility. And then to the north, it's bordered by the open space kind of wetlands parcel that goes through the site. The benefits to identifying this site is that it has clearly defined boundaries with the edges of the site.

3:01:45 the wetlands and the roads and so it kind of it creates an area for them to focus and work on their project and then of key interest to the town is that it preserves all the area that's south of Chaparral or in the interior of the site where and where we could then build our future workforce housing projects so working with HMC the town did what we call a space test on that site of really just looking

3:02:14 Can we fit, say, 130 rental apartments on that site and 40 ownership units on that site, along with the roads, parking, and mops? And their preliminary test, which is shown on the screen in the lower boxes, indicated it can fit. There's obviously, it's not a final design for the town, but it gave us the confidence to then kind of give, at least at a staff level, a thumbs up to MUSD for sites 9 and 10.

3:02:44 So on the screen there, what the architects drew and mocked up for the school and the preliminary site plan is the area closest to Tavern Road. This shows up or not, yep.

3:03:02 The pointer in this area here, that would be the phase one of the school project, which would be 24 units. These would all be rental units. The school does not have a desire to build ownership units because they want to maintain control of the units and ensure that they remain available for their workforce. Also within the site, then, it would provide some additional land that could be for future phases of development.

3:03:27 They at least space planned it where they could fit approximately 35 units in that remainder of the site. Not that they're going to build 35 additional units, but they just wanted to keep their flexibility open and have that option should they find more funding. For the initial phase, the funding is in place through the Measure J. That was the school bond that passed a few years ago. That bond was intended to develop the TK building.

3:03:56 Recreate or a kind of field house facility on the school and then workforce housing. So this obviously is directly related to the workforce housing component. They are working through the agreements and other items to hopefully break ground this coming spring should we approve all the different agreements necessary for it. So this site is an approximately two and a half acre site that we would be looking to transfer to the district.

3:04:24 The item tonight related to the option agreement is necessary for the school to enter into a contract for pre-construction services and then what's called a lease-back agreement with that contractor, which is the way they'll be developing the site.

3:04:48 Uniqueness under the education code for how they have to enter into that agreement, but this is the kind of initial step for that. So before I go to the pickleball complex, is there any questions on the parcel housing site? Just one, just to clarify, when we talk about trade-off, but when they do the building, they would be paying 100% of their construction cost for that parcel? That's correct. So no town funding would go into this project.

3:05:17 The only real contribution from the town would be us exchanging the land. And you might have answered this already. Sorry if you did. What is the black arrow and the black line for on the map? So this was all drawn up during the design charrette so it didn't get fully refined. The black line is the current boundary of lot 9 and 10. And then beyond that is the open space site.

3:05:43 So they were looking if there's any option to do a lot line adjustment where they would own part of that open space area, but not for development, but more to provide for setbacks with future buildings. Okay. And then these potentially 60 units, that affects our ability to, like, does it change the AMI levels that we can build out in the future? Or like how, like the...

3:06:16 The zoning of the land, does it have to be zoned a certain, you know, like with the AMI levels and things like that, like does that come into play with how the whole parcel is zoned? Sure, so the parcel master plan allows for, I want to say it's 550 units in the master plan. Within that, 15% of the units can be for AMIs from 100.

3:06:39 And so should they build out all 60, that would then leave 22 that we could build on those higher AMIs. But it's within that 82 number not.

3:07:09 It doesn't change the overall number or reduce our kind of site planning that we've done puts us right around 480 or so units could fit on the parcel. We don't believe that we could actually get to 550 just with all the other requirements that go into place. And so it doesn't put us up against that number by any means. Okay, thank you. Question? Yeah, following up on your question, are there AMI?

3:07:37 Restrictions on the stuff that they're going to build? Sure. So our proposal with them was that we have to have an affordable housing covenant because that's part of the parcel master plan. They wanted the greatest flexibility with kind of where their staffing's at. And so our proposal, because kind of anything above 120 as long as below 200 doesn't, you don't get credit from HTD for providing 150% units or 180. So our suggestion to them with these.

3:08:05 Our restriction would be at 200% AMI, just so they have the greatest flexibility in how they're managing the units and working with their workforce. Okay, but then following up on your question, that's not going to affect, if they build everything out at 200, that's not going to affect our ability to make decisions and choices for the land that remains out there. I don't believe so. Our goal for the rental project would be that those would be at, we de-restricted at 120%.

3:08:34 So that's the 130 units there. And then any ownership ones as well, you know, we imagine a portion would be deed restricted around 150, but a portion would be restricted around 120. We don't have a, at least in our analysis, that anything really above 150 makes sense for a restriction, just because you're starting to inch towards market where you could afford market rate. But it is going to factor in. If they build everything at 200, it does factor into?

3:09:04 Into what we can do. Of that 82, yes. Okay. Are there any other, you mentioned some, you know, Department of Education or regulations that they have to deal with when they do this. Can you talk a little bit about what kinds of obligations, legal obligations they have coming over, given that school, that it's a school project? Sure, I'd look to Andy. He's obviously a little more versed in legal matters outside. But Andy's in Alaska. I know.

3:09:34 But the mayor, well, if you can hear me, I have thoughts. So the school district's attorneys have told us that the provisions of the education code, I've looked at them just a little bit. They are unique to school districts. They have no comparison to what we have to do. And we've been told that they have to do a two-step process because they have to get what you might call land tenure. They have to lock up the right to acquire the land.

3:10:04 And that's why we're doing it this way. But it has no bearing, no similarity to anything that the town does. Anything in the education code is going to be a little foreign to us, and this certainly is that. But it's their thing. It's not going to affect us. It's their problem. Okay. And who... So pickleball. The end of the world and pickleball is still there, right?

3:10:33 I would also add on this site before we go on that, you know, our goal of providing workforce housing is achieved by this. It's just somebody else building the workforce housing here. So it's still achieving the goal of the parcel completely. It's just not the town doing it. Yeah, it's good. So yeah, onto the pickleball complex. So obviously the town currently has developed that site previously with an ice rink, now turned six pickleball courts as well as parking.

3:11:05 On that site. So the minimum area that the town would be looking to acquire would be the two and a half acre that's outlined in the blue. So this would secure the access into that upper or that I guess more lower parking lot geographically. Parking lot, the pickleball courts, and then the land between the pickleball courts out to Meridian Boulevard. Looking when you walk the site, the intent for that land.

3:11:33 Between the Pickleball and Meridian is it's relatively flat. And so it could provide option for additional expansion of what we would call the racket complex, meaning we could potentially add additional pickleball courts in that area should the demand or additional or build tennis courts in that area. The area in red there would be approximately the size of two tennis courts with all the additional space around the courts and it's I think they need 60 by 120 feet.

3:12:03 And so we've kind of mapped it out that that could, you know, in the future should there be a desire there. There's not obviously an immediate plan to build more there. We did look at what it could look like if land out kind of in this area. That area does get very steep so it has some topographic challenges. There may be some desire from the district though that they don't have a need for this land.

3:12:31 Here, and so that's really the option to grow to six acres. So ongoing discussions there, whether there is interest from the town to acquire that. We don't have a use for it necessarily, but if there's desire from the school, then it may be beneficial. But at minimum, it would be acquiring the pickleball courts, the parking, and that land. But if we were to acquire that, all the mandates from an education perspective, they don't apply.

3:13:01 Like in this land exchange, this is our land, free and clear, there's no mandates, no legal, you know, things that are attached to the land once the exchange is complete. Correct. So it would be town-owned, it would then become a town-owned recreation facility. And we're just clear of all the school district and all that stuff. Correct. Okay. Yes, that's right. And just to clarify on that one, so what's the zoning on that right now? Public and quasi-public. Yeah, or state.

3:13:27 Public, quasi-public, even with, it just, there's only stays, just land would change ownership. Correct. So a new boundary would get drawn carving out the town parcel from the MUSD parcel. And I'm sorry, Nolan, what's the little box to the left there that looks like a... That was a graphic design error. Okay. That was me trying to overlay...

3:13:50 Trying to overlay a tennis court rather than just a red box onto the graphic. I was like, that's going to be a weird piece of property to own right there in the corner. Yeah, that's what happens when you try to do graphic design and PowerPoint. Canva. Are you done with your presentation? Are you ready for questions? The last one, just a few of the bullet points on what is called the option agreements. This is the agreement that's actually necessary for...

3:14:19 At least the school district to move forward with their pre-construction services because it gives them the exclusive option to acquire the housing sites. That's what they need to move that forward prior to the actual exchange of the property. So to give them exclusive option to acquire it, it would require them then to convey the pickleball complex to the town in the same transaction. We put a deadline of completing this by August of 2027.

3:14:49 The exchange agreement is what would follow the option agreements that would actually establish the terms of the transfer, include the exact legal descriptions for both sites. Again, we talked about the requirement for the affordable housing covenant. That's a requirement of the parcel master plan.

3:15:04 And then the last two bullet points are ones we added. One, that we would have the option to purchase back any undeveloped land. In the option agreement, we put if it remains undeveloped after 10 years from the exchange. We'll see if the school district comes back with requesting a different timeline, but we thought 10 years was reasonable for them to build the initial phase and then figure out if...

3:15:30 There is a need or a desire to build any subsequent phases on that land. Then the last one is that the town would have the first right of refusal to purchase any developed housing or undeveloped land should MUSD ever choose to sell. So should they say they build the housing and then feel they don't want to be in the housing market, the town would have the first option of refusal on that. And that's not setting like a deed restricted.

3:15:57 Sale price. That's just saying that you get the first option to purchase. Yeah, and Andy, correct me if I'm wrong, but I think that the language there is it's reasonable market value. Okay. He's not going to correct you. Okay. Are you ready for questions now? Yes. Questions? I ask my questions, though. I'm good. Thank you. Just one more question. So we've made some adjustments with our

3:16:24 So we have an option agreement with Pacific to exit the DDA that gives the town the unilateral option to exit that. And so we prior to

3:16:52 Executing any agreements, we will have to act on that agreement. We were intentionally waiting until we were under construction on Kingfisher II and some of those other items were in place that it didn't, you know, unintentionally impact any of those agreements or those funding or other items. So we're now in a position to act on that option agreement. Okay. But that wouldn't happen immediately. That would happen at the next stage when we move forward. Correct. Okay.

3:17:22 Okay. Are there any public comments from anyone in the room or online? No. Okay. I would entertain a motion or let's, shall we discuss further? I'm very supportive of this. Okay. I would entertain a motion. I will make a motion. I move to authorize the town manager to sign the option agreement with MUSD for the MUSD parcel housing project and containing the deal points identified in the staff report subject to the town attorney's approval.

3:17:52 And finalization of the agreement. I will second. Roll call, please, Jamie. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem 2X? Yes. Mayor Rice? Yes. Okay, and we are moving on to item 10.2, approve and adopt resolutions modifying the compensation plan and reclassification of specified full-time permanent management employees association, MEA, and executive positions and salary schedules. Thank you, Madam Mayor.

3:18:23 So the item before you tonight is something that we don't do very frequently. It is not a part of any negotiation strategy or any consultation with our associations. This is more fulfilling the requirement of the town manager to produce what's called both a classification plan and a compensation plan, which outlines the structure and

3:18:51 Staff levels that the town puts forth in, you know, performing our functions. The classification plan in part reads the town manager shall prepare a classification plan which sets forth all the classes of positions in the town service. Classification plan shall be so developed and maintained that all positions substantially similar with respect to duties, responsibilities, authorities, and character of work are included within the same class and that the same class schedules

3:19:19 of compensation may be made to apply with equity under the under working positions for all employees. The compensation plan is also will provide salary schedule, salary rates, salary ranges and steps. Each class in the classification plan shall be assigned a salary range or rate established in the compensation plan. All persons employed by the town shall be compensated in accordance with this plan. So I'm required as a town manager to provide modifications to these plans from time to time.

3:19:48 We have, meaning we, the executive team, have been reviewing required modifications and discussed sort of a structure by which we could pull something together that makes a lot of sense with regard to shared responsibility or similar responsibility for each of the staff level.

3:20:10 Things happen across time when you think about a compensation plan. You're adding positions. You're sometimes sunsetting positions. Things are changing. And so you have to put them in place with regard to where they were at the time, what made the most sense. But you never step back and take a holistic look at that and do all the positions make sense with where they're located and the level of compensation they receive. Typically, when you think of...

3:20:38 Our general employees, our public works employees, the hourly staff, those all connect directly with a lot of changes that happen statewide with regard to the part-time employment minimum wage activities and all those things that sort of adjust that. And in the last several years, the town has made modifications to our general employees and public works employees.

3:21:00 But we did not make those same or similar changes all the way up through management level and executive level employees. The difference between those different employee classifications are very significant in the fact that management level and executive level are salaried, so they're not able to earn any overtime for the work that they perform.

3:21:23 And therefore, the salary structure, if you will, sort of encompasses all the activity that they could incur and just basically work to get the job done instead of working on an hourly basis. Some of the things that we did in this effort is reduce the number of potential classifications for wage in the MEA category.

3:21:48 We had in the original from an M-102 all the way up through an M-113 as an optional pay structure. In this recommendations that we're making tonight, we condensed that down to five different areas or categories or groupings, if you will, of employees.

3:22:08 The first one being M201, this entry-level management employee may or may not have supervisor responsibility of limited-term employees, typically does not have supervisor responsibility for full-time employees. So that just sort of defines their level of responsibility. M202, this category is usually a higher level of responsibility with newer developing areas within our organization. We thought this was a new category we should add because we are making modifications to

3:22:37 How we have employees in this particular category. They may or may not have supervisor responsibilities, but they can be charged with significantly complex functions within the organization, and a lot of times they're developmental. So it means there's no roadmap for how those are performed. They're working through that process. M203, this category is high volume supervision of many employees.

3:23:05 Large-scale operations with the organizations, but they typically coordinate closely with other management or executive level staff. So they have a lot of people they're responsible for, but they do get support in that effort. M204, this category, typically responsible for the entire department and will receive support from higher management, but they have requirements for increasing levels of education within this category and perform the role for the organization.

3:23:33 And then finally M205, that's the highest level in the Management Employee Association. They require the highest level of education, responsibility, and often are responsible for an entire division, and they can be considered at a deputy director level within our organization. So that's how we comprised the management level staffs within this particular compensation agreement.

3:23:59 MEA classifications, the M201 through M205 I just described, have a range of 30% from the very bottom of the range to the top. And that range, size of that range is determined by how much growth is expected from someone starting new in a leadership role until they are a seasoned leadership aspect. You are going to have steps that you go across time where you gain experience.

3:24:26 ...able to earn additional wage based on that experience because your contribution to the organization climbs with that. In this particular modifications that we're suggesting tonight, there are some changes that will be immediate for a few employees if they are not at the lowest or minimum level that was set.

3:24:48 For that range, there will be a bump to get them to that minimum level. And there are a couple of people that are affected by that change in this process. So there will be some immediate changes to wage based upon these new salary ranges, but only in the MEA category. I took this a little bit further and sort of tied the executive employee classifications.

3:25:15 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

3:25:42 Um, situation, which means they are, they're not represented by an employee association. Uh, they can be terminated at any time, with or without cause. Uh, and they basically are, are involved in leadership level discussions and often have responsibilities that cross all departments within the organization and all of those, uh, positions report directly to the town manager. That particular classification is 10 percent higher than.

3:26:12 Those in the highest level of the MEA. The next classification item is Director 1. That's positioned as a responsibility for an entire division within the organization. They're expected to lead that division without direct supervision. They all report to the town manager, but they really are autonomous in their function and basically

3:26:35 Are responsible for not only the operation of that division, but the coordination between other divisions within the organization. But they're responsible for one department, if you will. Director Level 2, that position is the same responsibility as Director 1, however, they have multiple divisions of responsibility within the organization. So there's a little bit more to that, and there's like a 7.5% pay bump for those additional collectively as a whole.

3:27:04 The additions of multiple departments. And then finally, the town manager. So as the town manager level, highest level employee within the organization and responsible for literally all aspects of the organization and the delivery of the core services to the community. And then that has a classification that is a certain percentage higher, 20% higher than the Director 2 level.

3:27:26 In all classifications in the executive range, it's a range from top to bottom of 25 percent. And this really is reflective of the fact that the employees that are in the executive status typically don't require

3:27:42 Additional, they don't gain a lot of experience over time. They come with that experience. It's what got them into that role. But there are things that they learn about their particular job across time, and there is an opportunity to grow that. There are no steps in these salary ranges, but there is an opportunity to earn a merit increase on an annual basis. So while there are no modifications to salary specific to the executive team based on this,

3:28:06 In all considerations, the salary has increased in each of these ranges. So across time, the financial considerations are that this will have a higher cost to the organization, but it's a way of structuring the sort of management to leadership team in a way that makes sense based upon responsibilities. So I wanted to kind of emphasize that point that

3:28:31 You know, it does have financial implications in the long run as people gain more experience and their merit increases will get them into the upper echelons, but it's not a significant modification to what we had. It's just wanting to draw that point to everyone's attention. Happy to answer any questions before you. There are two resolutions that talk about the actual language around the requirement to make these.

3:28:57 I don't have any questions. It sounds like Rob's.

3:29:27 You know, taking care of the house. You know, questions I had, Rob already answered when I met with him, so I'm good. Okay. Is there any public comment from anyone in the room? Or online? No. Okay. Are you all ready to make a motion? If you're... All right. I would entertain a motion. I will move to approve the resolution. If this current... Make sure it says two resolutions as opposed to...

3:29:51 Exhibit A and B covers it. Approve the resolution modifying the compensation plan and reclassification of specified MEA and executive positions as well as accompanying salary schedules as outlined in Exhibit A and Exhibit B. Does that cover it for both of them? Yes. I'll second the motion. Roll call, please. Council Member Wentworth. We're really answering emails there, John. Sorry. Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Truex. Yes. Mayor Rice. Yes.

3:30:24 All right. Thank you, Rob. We are on to council member reports. Brent, would you like to go first? Sure. Go ahead. Go back up here. Had an LTC meeting. There will be a hydrogen bus that's here on the 27th and 28th. I believe it's 28th that's taken from trip from Mammoth Mountain down to Reds Meadow will be available if you want to ride the hydrogen bus down.

3:30:49 Is that like a demonstration? Of August. Demonstration as we're exploring the possibility of hydrogen down the road if it makes any feasibility for public transportation usage. Interesting. So a lot of things to work out there with everything else in the world. Like, for instance, fuel for hydrogen is like 200 miles away is the closest possible fuel. And when you have a range of 300 miles, it makes it a little tough to fuel up.

3:31:15 Has some interesting prospects there. We also, at the LTC, had a good discussion about unmet transportation needs and trying to make sure people have the availability not only within town, but within the county to have transportation they need to get to and from the various aspects of their lives. Interesting that session two was that, and this is old data now, but there's already 11,000 people that had taken the shuttle to Reds Meadow, even on the limited shuttle schedule that we have right now. So it's been very popular and it's increased transportation.

3:31:42 I attended the Wine Walk. I thought it was a great job done by everybody else there. I went to King Lear, and David did an excellent job as King Lear, and it's over now, but it should exemplify what we can do in this community to do with the right resources, and maybe we can do even more. Great. That's all I got. Thank you. John? Yes, so August 7th, I attended a meeting of something called the ICARP Tech.

3:32:11 This is that climate group that I serve on. It's in the Governor's Office of Land Use and Climate Innovation. Really, you know, the high value of these meetings is the presentations we get from outside parties, outside groups. And we had a really interesting presentation from the Department of Conservation.

3:32:33 Which is getting an enormous amount of Prop 4 money that's separate from like what SNC and other state agencies are getting. And there may be opportunities for us to access some of that, especially around the wildfire work that we're doing, because that is a climate resilience play. And there may be a way to get funds from that for our recreation assets. It's just tied into the work we're doing with the ESCCRP. So that was interesting. Interesting discussion about climate resilience districts. There's something in the state of California you can establish a climate resilient district.

3:33:02 It doesn't come with anything other than the local jurisdictions got to come up with the money and come up with everything else, but you can have a climate district. So that was kind of interesting, but also very interesting presentation from the North Coast Resource Partnership, which if you're familiar with that is a sort of the gold standard for regional collaborative partnerships on the North Coast. So that was very interesting. Then today I

3:33:29 Had the privilege of attending the Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board Meeting. Some pretty interesting updates today. First, on global tourism, MLT is making a decision to cut back significantly their presence in global markets. A lot of it has to do with the perception of the United States around the world in our global markets, so they're going to be cutting resources back there and focusing on domestic.

3:33:52 And again, the team they have over there.

3:34:18 Just incredibly, it's an incredibly rich asset that I know we're working on how we can leverage those capacities, the technological capacities that they have where there's really interesting. On the air service update, it sounds like the city of Bishop might be wanting to get into the game.

3:34:32 And I don't know if it's been mentioned this evening, but we set

3:35:01 We, all of us, set a TOT record for 25-26. Best year ever. So thanks to Mammoth Lake Tourism. Thanks to the town for all that. But it brings me back a little bit, and Rob and I talked about this, that nice discussion we had over the end of the basement of the brewery. You take a very kind of ambitious destination management plan. We're doing well financially. Where are we going?

3:35:25 And I think it would be great to have that whenever Rob is ready to bring that back a little bit. So we as a council, when we're having these discussions with the Destination Management Plan, what are the council's goals around things like climate, some of the things we've talked about? It's going to be important to have those things help to frame that thing up for its final deliverable for something that we can work with. But interesting meeting. That's it. So thank you. Great. And I feel like we have to add thank you to our community for welcoming all those visitors.

3:35:54 And having the best T.O.T. here on record, right? Yeah, and I said it's all of us. It's all of everyone, yes. We're all working as a team. The whole thing is working really well. Okay, so Stu told you about the Parks and Recreation Master Plan Survey. Yes, I found the link. Okay. We have that going on. I attended the County and Town Liaison Committee meeting, and we did discuss mobile home, just kind of,

3:36:24 Kind of the environment and what's happening at the county level versus the town. And then I also attended August 13th this year, Summer Nights, which was a little chilly for August, but I had a great time and I would love to see more next summer. I don't know if it would be feasible or not, but I think that it's a wonderful night for our community.

3:36:46 It's lovely to see so many local families and just local community members just out there enjoying themselves. And then my kids also got to attend the skateboarding camp and they had a fabulous time and well, their scraped knees have still not healed, but they loved it and thank you to our staff for doing such a great job with our summer camps. Yeah, so that's all I have to report.

3:37:12 So we will move on to item 12, requests for future agenda items. I don't know. John, do you have any requests? A bunch of ideas, but no, I think no requests other than Hayes is going to bring us something back, right? Coming out of this, anything else, Rob, that you heard that's coming back?

3:37:33 But we have those on the agenda. So this request is just what do we not know that you guys want? Well, I would start. I would say I would love to discuss inclusionary housing and diff fees. Yeah, for sure. Is there anything else that you'd like to request? No, that's sort of a hot ticket at this point. Okay. Yeah. All right.

3:37:54 We are ready to adjourn. So the Town Council will adjourn to a regular meeting being held on Wednesday, September 2nd, 2026 at 4 p.m. We hope to fill all the seats. Thanks for coming. Have a good night. Have a good night. Thank you very much.