TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2023

Town Council

at 16:00

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Notable from this meeting

2 findings

Transcript

335 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:41 Good evening. Welcome all to this regular meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Town Council for Wednesday, August 16th, 2023. Jamie, let's go ahead and get started with the roll call. Councilmember Bubzer? Here. Councilmember Ray? Here. Councilmember Rice? Here. Mayor Pro Tem Salzer? Yep. Mayor Wentworth? Here. Thank you. Good to see you all. Welcome.

1:09 I've asked former Councilmember Matthew Lehman to lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance this evening. Matthew, please. Thank you, Matthew. Okay, we're going to now move on to public comment. Just a quick show of hands. How many folks here to make a comment on the Snow Creek? Just one? Okay. So with that being said, I'm wondering if we could just start with folks who are maybe not commenting on the Snow Creek item to go first.

1:58 And then public comments, three minutes for every comment you want to make. It'll be great. I think we all have your letters. I've got about 50 of them, so thank you all very much. And maybe not try to repeat things other folks have said, those kinds of things. So if anybody's got a comment other than Snow Creek, why don't you step on up, please. Yes, thank you. My name's Emily, and I'm here with Nohawk Creek Mine.

2:25 We are a small group of community members in Mammoth fighting core mining, which is an issue you guys have probably already heard about. I'm here to request that the town of Mammoth Lakes take a stronger position in opposition to this project. It will not only have detrimental impacts to our local environment, but to our tourist economy as well. Mammoth residents, such as myself, rely on the pristine beauty of the Sierra to generate income.

2:49 It is very important to understand that this fight against CORE is not a one-time issue. In the 90s, Royal Gold began exploratory drilling at the same site at Hawk Creek. Their claim was later sold to CORE, who will be showing up as soon as September 1st, which is just a few weeks away. Technology for extraction has improved and will continue to do so, granting mining companies the ability to extract smaller pieces of gold. If we look at the trajectory of mining in the U.S. right now, especially to our neighbors in Nevada,

3:17 It was clear that these projects are not stopping anytime soon. Mining is a direct assault on the earth, on indigenous land, on our small communities, and will reap no benefits. It is outrageous that mining companies, especially foreign mining companies, can with ease have access to minerals in the ground without considering the consequences to its land and its people. I'm here today to ask the town of Mammoth to take a stronger stand against core and utilize your platform of direct communication with this community to inform people about the project.

3:46 I understand that the town does not have the ability to stop the project, but I believe you have the power and the tools necessary to keep our community informed. The document starts with small groups and individuals such as those in Nohaw Creek Mine and myself. However, we need the allyship of our local political body. If the town reiterates your opposition to core mining, it would be a strong show of support for our grassroots efforts. It is imperative that we work together as a community, and we need leadership from the town to stop this project.

4:16 Even the exploratory phase will cause harm to this fragile ecosystem. Hawk Creek is one of the most important local areas for our fishing economy. Having treks with drills rolling across the White Bridge, 24 hours of lights, clouds of dust, and disruptive drilling noise will be harmful to our fishing enthusiasts, as well as many other visitors who enjoy the beauty of this geologic site. Thank you. Thank you very much. Okay, public comment on other issues not otherwise on the agenda. Please, sir, if you want to come forward. Thank you.

4:56 Thank you, Mr. Mayor and City Council members and staff. My name is Philip Bettencourt. My wife, Meredith, and I are proud to be a seasonal residence here at Solstice and are fans of the Sierra Star Golf Course and also of Snow Creek. And my wife's golf group was, I don't want to say decimated, wounded by the loss of Snow Creek and she asked me to put my...

5:25 Two cents in, and I appreciate the opportunity to do that. I'm a former Planning Commission Chair. I'm the Chair of the Restoration Advisory Board for the Navy in Seal Beach. I'm a Commissioner on the Coachella Valley Energy Commission, and we are Equity Country Club owners, so we have a good deal of experience with golf. I filed a letter, and without going into the details of the agreement and what you might do, fair to say that the Community Development Letter was...

5:55 Thank you very much. Thank you.

6:24 And the capital requirements may be to operate the golf course because it seems to me the developer may claim it's not uneconomic. Residents are going to say the opposite. You may want to be a participant in participating with that. And there will be residents that say, no, we shouldn't need to get into that. But I think if you'd reach out to the National Golf Foundation, I've worked with them before. They're glad to provide independent.

6:52 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you very much. Okay. Anybody else? It's warm and cozy up there, but yes, Mr. Landy. Good evening, Mayor and Councilmembers. You know, although I appreciate all the creative writing and gossip.

7:34 I thought it best to just come and put the facts on the table. We did not open this year. The main reason we didn't open Snow Creek is because we had running water on three of the nine fairways up until a couple weeks ago. You will see people out preparing the greens for winter next year in the next week or two, and we look forward to opening next year. So I hope that sets the record straight and be glad to answer any questions you have. I don't think we have any questions, but thank you very much.

8:04 Thank you. Thank you. Jamie, any public comment in the virtual universe? No? Okay. So with that, I don't see any additional requests for public comment. I hope I got that right. Yes, please come forward. Just for a click, I'm glad to hear that he's going to open the course for at least one more year. Request that Department of Tourism do an application. They probably have already done it because that's what...

8:40 Those departments do. A study of golf courses within a resort community such as ours and what the economic impact is and what the future of golf is relative to what is said. Like some people have said, well, golf is really not very popular anymore. I don't golf. I'm not old enough. But even though I may live at Snow Creek, my desires are not what's important, nor are Chuck's desires what's important. What's important is what is best for the public as a whole.

9:10 What's best for me as a NIMBY, what's best for the public as a whole. This should necessitate an in-depth study relative to what is required in the development agreement for 18 championship golf course, not a golf course that has to run into the ground by the current owner, seems to have some issues with caring about the people who sells units to and the course. Clearly down the road the course is going to go away if he's not making money on it. And that is something that perhaps the town should put perspective from a study plan like...

9:39 So for that to become a natural space,

10:07 Probably cost millions to convert it back. And it should be noted by public workers. I'm sure they realize that all the drainage from the Mammoth Road and all the Snow Creek goes into those ponds. Some will have to maintain that. And if it's not a golf course, some will have to maintain the waterway to make sure that's part of the so-called open space and walkway. If so, I believe it's probably best as a golf course, as much as I hate to say that for those of you who know my history.

10:32 But I think that's probably what is the best for the community at large. And that's what counts, not what I want. Certainly not what Landuans or anybody else. What's the best for the community? Department of Tourism, they do great studies. So did your actually amazing planning department. They could also do it. Anyway, thank you very much. Thank you. Thank you, Greg. Okay, anybody else? Going once, going twice. Okay, I think she's leaving. Maybe she's going. Going three times. So thank you all very much. Thanks for coming.

11:12 Okay, so let's move on then to Dan for the agenda. Any additions this evening? No additions to the agenda. Okay, thank you. Moving on now to reports from commissions and or departments as needed. And I think, Dan, do you want to kick that off? Yeah, if I could start with one, it's not listed there, but a couple of the reports. But I did want to let the council know that as you're all aware, Sandra Moberly stepped down as our community economic development director to take on the role of the...

11:40 County Administrator for Mono County. And for the town and the interim, appointed Nolan Bobroff to serve in that position as an acting director for the department. And so I think he's here this evening back there. So no one can wave. You'll hear from the meeting. But we've had a couple different conversations with kind of the key team there in the department. And they're supportive.

12:07 I'm stepping into that role in this acting capacity, so I wanted to make sure you're aware of that. So if there's questions related to the planning department, again, you can reach out to myself as always, but Nolan will be the primary contact where Sandra was before. Okay. So thank you. Good. Thank you. Congratulations, Nolan. I didn't say that. So Dan, the wildfire

12:34 Clearing process that's happening. Who's going to speak to that? I can speak to the item there that's in the packet for information there. We do have ongoing work with what we'll call the Donut Project, the idea of the Eastern Sierra Community Resiliency Project. I'm missing one of the season there. Looking at fire issues around the community. The two projects in town that are on town-owned properties, one is

13:06 Along Mammoth Creek, and there's information in the packet about that. We want to make sure people are aware of it. We've done some door drops and stuff like that of information in that process in advance of the work going on. So we want to make sure people aware of the clothes and movement impacts on trails to the area. Also, we'll be doing work at the bell-shaped property later in the middle of town there. Same thing, getting information out on that.

13:30 But I think more importantly is if we look at that whole idea of the Eastern Sierra Climate and Community Resiliencies Project and the amount of fire threat in our community, I think it's something we get inside of and we've had a horrific reminder of it recently in Hawaii. You look at what's happening in Maui and Lahaina, what's happening there, and you look at the amount of dry material, you look at the winds, you look at the potential of ignitions, but for that

13:59 Could be a portion in the Eastern Sierra, including Mammoth. What happens if those forests end up in that type of a situation? So while these are very small projects, I think they're indicative of what's needed on a much larger scale and also give us a feel for the type of threat that could be out there. We saw some of that close by with the Creek Fire. We've seen it in the Tahoe area, South Lake Tahoe, and the fires there. Others that have gone through, so it's not something that's, you know.

14:28 New to us, but I think we're continually reminded of the threat that is out there. And again, what's in your packet here tonight, the information there, this is one small step we're taking to begin to address some of those threats immediately in town, but there's also obviously a much larger threat that we look to the future. Okay, thank you for that. I think as I was driving over here this evening, I was listening to reports from the governor of Hawaii.

14:55 Chris and I have been involved somewhat with that process moving forward. And Dan and I spoke this afternoon about a statement of purpose document, which you can see. This is coming from a group called Blue Forest, which is something that I think Dan, you're providing some comments on. It's a very important finance meeting coming up September 14th that's going to start bringing the partners together to figure out how we're going to finance this project and move forward. Because the stars aligning for us in the right way.

15:25 The fate of that community could easily be ours. And we listen to the stories of over 1,000 people missing. They've identified remains for 135 people. They've only identified five of those. That's our story. And we can do things to be proactive and get ahead of that, but that's going to be a very important thing we're going to be doing in the next couple of months. So thank you for that. John, along those lines, a quick question. I've just been talking with some

15:52 Colleagues from other rural communities. And there's a designation called a Fire Safe Community that I've heard other people talk about, and I just didn't know if that was something we've contemplated or even already have. But as long as you're bringing up the rest of this, I was curious. We've worked with the Fire Safe Council here, and there's a whole process. Fire Safe Community hasn't gone that far yet, but that has been discussed at the time when the Fire Safe Council here was more active. It started with a lot of work up in Lakes Basin.

16:22 Provided some funding for that as well as work that they did on that. There is a process to get designated that that has been looked at at that level. I don't know if it's been pursued beyond that at this point. Okay, thanks. Okay, thank you. So, Stuart, are you here for the reports and commissions and or departments? Okay, please, go ahead. Thank you. Thank you. Mr. Mayor. For 10 members of council, staff, and I know Greg is definitely old enough for pickleball.

16:55 Part of a brief update, Stuart Brown, Parks and Recreation Director on Parks and Rec. So Camp Mammoth, running this week, will wrap up our summer camps. Our amazing recreation team hosted 49 age-appropriate summer camps, so just a wonderful offering for our many residents and visitors. We had, as you know, a pretty long wait list, but the team managed to kind of get people in and out of those camps appropriately.

17:22 So we'll spend the next couple of months digesting, debriefing and getting ready for 2024. How about that? Once the kids go back to school, our fall programming begins. So August 28th, fall programming, bike squad, skate squad, gymnastics, adventure squad and art class are those on the schedule. So if you've got any kids, get them signed up. They'll go August 28th. We'll get those flies in the school. Whitmore Pool is scheduled to close for public swimming. I know we just seem like we just opened.

17:52 But it'll close on Sunday, September 3rd, and we hope to extend lap swim for another week, just working out staffing. A lot of our lifeguards are departing, off to school, sadly. But we did start dropping water polo, if you manage to get down to the pool, try a bit of dropping water polo. And so far, two of our swimmers have reached the Whitmore 50-mile challenge, so good on them. Adult softball men's and co-ed leagues wrapped up this week on Tuesday. Fun but short season.

18:21 We now prep the fields for Mammoth AYSO full soccer, so that's busy. Tennis court rehab on courts five and six begins tomorrow. Very excited about that. If they'll make a mess up there, I'm sure they will. And then the crews will be back on August 30th to start the pickleball rehab. Okay, so we're getting a lot of comments about that. We're also working with Amy and her team over here. I know Hayes is away, but we've got the park at the parcel.

18:48 Kind of planning. We've got material turning up. We've got water fountains, picnic benches. We've got some playgrounds going to turn up here soon. Just working on coordinating the site work and then getting the installer in to install the playground hopefully later this fall. The dog park is out for bid, so that's moving forward. Hope to have that kind of on the schedule here, I think, on September 6th for award. And then again, I know we're looking at winter already, sadly.

19:17 A couple of things. We do have Dawn Johnson from the National Weather Service here in town on November 8th. I'll be sending out some information on that if you want to come and listen to what was summer and fall and what could be. So again, that'll be November 8th. That'll be here in Sweet Sea from 1.30, so we'll get that information to you. And then our team will be planning to reinstall those beautiful snowflakes once again up and down Main Street on Mammoth Road.

19:44 By Thanksgiving. That is all I had. Any questions? Happy to answer them. Thank you, sir. Any questions? What are our plans for celebrating the 72 hours of summer this year? Brief summer. I think we just kind of did. Kind of missed the opportunity, huh? Something's going to be big for Labor Day, maybe. Yeah, okay. But I do want to follow up on your comment on the town parcel fuels reduction work. That information is on the town website if people do want to jump on.

20:11 Again, the detours are in there, and then we'll start pushing that again as we get closer to the work on August 24th. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you very much. Rob. Yes, sir. Town Council Mayor Wentworth, Rob Patterson, Admin Services Finance Director. I just wanted to give a brief update on our work to our efforts to obtain some reimbursement from FEMA from our disaster recovery from this last winter.

20:42 That's a very long process, but we've definitely begun in earnest trying to receive as much as we can in reimbursement for our direct expenses. What that looks like is we basically go around and identify, certainly we've tracked the expenditures as we were responding to the emergency and the things that we spent money on as far as just actively working in the emergency. This does not include things like grant.

21:09 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

21:32 But just exactly what you anticipate the cost to be to recover from that. So our town expenses identified to date are just over $2.1 million. And so we're seeking that. We've had a couple of preliminary meetings with the entourage from FEMA. And one of the key things that we're focusing in on is the snow question. So with regard to damage.

21:58 If it's caused by snow-related activities, it doesn't really fit within the FEMA framework for reimbursement unless it meets some specific criteria. So we're working with the county on identifying just the details of that criteria and whether this storm meets it. So more to come on that, but that has a fairly significant ramifications to our ability to get reimbursement if it does not. Because not only just the cost of snow.

22:26 No questions. Rob, I think I've been talking with Dan about

22:51 The opportunity for our state senator, Senator Alvarado Gill, and our congressman, Kevin Kiley, who's going to be in town over the Labor Day weekend. I think you may be getting tasked with helping out with that a little bit. That might be a good opportunity to have a conversation with the congressman about FEMA's definition or understanding of the snow problem. This is not the first time we've been through this rodeo, and it's unfortunate that the Federal Emergency Management Agency

23:18 I cannot allow for the very particular natural types of disasters that we experience here. So let's maybe talk about that a little bit. Sure. Thank you. Yeah. Okay. Anybody else? No? Okay. So in the packet, we have the 2022 Town of Mammoth Lakes Union Review, which looks very nice. There's a slightly confusing section about the town council in there that perhaps the graphic artists and the text writers could take a look at.

23:48 Dan, I know you flagged that same section. Any thoughts on the capital improvement program updates, street digging? One thing, Dan, I wanted to maybe bring up is if there would be possible to get a range for a tour for council members, maybe some staff of what's going on in the parcel before things get too hectic. I don't know if that would be possible, but I think it would be a great thing for us to be able to talk to constituents and tell folks looking good, timelines are looking good, that kind of thing, that might be helpful.

24:17 And, okay, Mammoth Main Base Redevelopment Project Update, Mammoth Mountain Lodge Area. Who's sitting in the hot seat on this one? Let me speak to that real briefly. Two different things happening, a couple different things there, I guess. The update you have in your packet, there hasn't been anything real substantial from the last one in terms of the work that's ongoing. Again, but with Sandra Moberly taking the position with Mono County, a little bit of change just at the staff level.

24:47 Kim Cook, you'll see her on Zoom there. She is our senior planner, and she'll be kind of the lead town staff person liaison for that project. And then Jen Murillo, who worked at the town a few years back, knows us pretty well, but with Lisa's wife, Lisa Weiss Consulting Firm, is really the project lead for us working on that project through that. And so they're engaged throughout a lot of the different meetings or follow-up or things of that nature.

25:17 I'll let them speak to some of the details on it, and they can correct me if I'm wrong here, but we haven't received a formal application that's, you know, project description, et cetera, and that's come in recently. Some of that information that we'll need to ultimately dive in and really do additional outreach and work with the community. We do have a communications plan or engagement plan that I know Jen has been working on with Kim to put together that we want to roll out this fall starting to really do with some community engagement and including elected appointed officials.

25:47 In that process. But so that's in the works and that's starting to move forward there. But I'll let Kim, if you want to introduce yourself again, and you've been here before and other items, so if not new to the council, kind of your role with the project. And then also, Jen, if you want to add into some of the next steps and things we're looking at. Thank you. Sure. Thank you, Dan. So Sandra did bring me onto the project team around late June to kind of transition me into her role in the project.

26:17 And so I have been participating in the bi-weekly sort of standing meetings and some of the individual meetings with technical experts on the archaeological study and some of the fiscal analysis that will be taking place. So I am getting up to speed and I'm thankful to be working with Jen and her kind of organization made it easy to kind of review all of the files that we have so far.

26:45 But I'll be your staff contact and staff liaison. So I'll be on all the project meetings and emails. And if you have any questions, feel free to contact me. Thank you very much. Jen, hi. Hi. Hi, council members, Mayor Wentworth. Good to see you all. Yeah, I'll be working really closely with Kim and town staff and the other consultants that you have on this project.

27:14 We look forward to working with you and getting out to the community to talk about more details as they come forth. The applicant is planning on working with the community to refine and develop the project details. So we don't have any new information, as Dan mentioned, about like in terms of application materials.

27:39 But we look forward to getting in front of the community and you all to refine those details and get into the analysis and review. So I think keep an eye out for meetings as they come forth. We'll be coming back to you monthly for updates. There is also a page on the town's website for this project. The link is in the staff report. So we'll be posting updates there as well. So happy to be on board and look forward to working with you over the next couple of years on this project.

28:09 Great. Thank you. Any questions from council members? A couple quick questions. So, Jen, perhaps you would know the answer to this. How long has this sort of interdisciplinary team, the CEQA and NEPA team, been working and meeting with the applicant? How long has that been going on for? I think it's probably been for, I think I came on about a year and a half or so on this project.

28:38 It's been quite some time. I will mention that there is, it is a complicated project because we are working on a joint environmental document, both under CEQA, State Environmental Review, as well as NEPA, Federal Environmental Review. So working with both the Forest Service on this piece as well as the town on this piece, it is complicated and it does take time. Okay, I just think Councilmember Sauser and I both serve on the LTC and we got sort of an interesting

29:07 Update from Caltrans that there's legislation in the state assembly. I'm sure you're aware of this about the fate and the status of Highway 203, which came as a little bit of a surprise. I think there's, speaking for myself, not speaking for my other fellow council members, that in doing all the environmental work and kind of figuring out how things work, that that could maybe be precluding some of the desires and needs of the community. And I just hope that...

29:34 This effort doesn't get too far down the road. It sounds like you're coming forward with something publicly this fall. Is that correct? Is that what I'm hearing? Some public meetings this fall? That's correct. Okay. Because we're hearing sort of funny things about, well, the Forest Service perhaps is saying, well, there's not going to be any public trails or any public recreation access from the new site. Or I know there's been discussions about OSV about up there. There's not going to be any public OSV access. We're just hearing this stuff anecdotally.

30:02 But the fact that you guys have been working on these things for 18 months, obviously we're not sitting in those meetings. But I just think it's going to be really important to not let the environmental process be driving what ultimately the decisions are going to be made by the town, the town council, our planning department, the planning commission. So just a little maybe a cautionary note there on that. That's a great point, Mayor Wentworth. And we're actually, I had a conversation with our...

30:31 Sequa Nipah Consultants specifically on that. We're working really hard to make sure that the environmental review will allow for the flexibility that the town and the Forest Service needs to be able to deal with requested revisions or alternatives or options that could evolve as this review goes forward publicly. So we totally agree with you. Yeah, because there's been 18 months of discussions going on and

31:01 Fine, a formal submission hasn't happened, but the community is very interested in all this, and obviously this project will be part of the town, so all the town's adopted documents, policies, planning documents, all that stuff applies, and I think council members will be diligently reviewing all those documents to make sure that whatever comes forth out of this project is consistent with the adopted policies of the town. Yeah, Bill, please. Also hugely important, because maybe I miss...

31:28 Understood what you said, but the CEQA and NEPA so that the town and Forest Service could continue to plan. My hope would certainly be that the mountain would plan for access for all types of recreation outside of alpine skiing from their location. Their plan is going to alter that. So I believe they have a responsibility to reestablish and they even have the opportunity to improve. So I would hope to see that come forward in any plan that comes to us. Yeah.

31:59 Okay, anybody else? Good? All right, thank you. We look forward to seeing you this fall. And Jen or Kim, maybe you can make us, make sure you let us know when the meetings are happening. The fall is already getting very busy. So I look forward, we all look forward to knowing when the meetings are happening, where they're happening, how they're happening, and we look forward to participating. Not as a body, obviously, but as individual council members. Thank you. Thank you. All right, so moving on then to public presentation.

32:28 Some dear friends are going to come before us now. This is the Town of Mammoth Lakes PM10 Planning Area's second 10-year maintenance plan. And Dan, do you want to kick this off? Nolan? Sure, I can kick this off. So here with us is Morgan. She's the Deputy Director of the Great Basin Unified Air Pollution Control District. I got the name correct.

32:52 As lengthy as the title of the maintenance plan. Just a quick intro on this item. So this is the second 10-year plan. Our current plan runs from 2015 to 2025. That's what found us in attainment for PM10 standards. So this plan will be the second iteration of that. Again, that will remain in attainment, hopefully. Just a little bit before Ann kind of describes the purpose of the plan.

33:18 The town does monitor the air quality during the winter months from November through March annually for any potential impacts from usually wood fire smoke and then we would call potential no burn days if we thought there'd be an exceedance. We have not had to call any no burn days in the last 10 years, potentially longer than that. Then also during the summer months we kind of monitor any exceptional events and provide updates on our website.

33:47 The phone recording, if there's impacts on wildfire, smoke, or others, and direct people to those resources. That's just a little bit on what the town does for monitoring. With that, I'll hand it over to Anne. Thanks, Nolan. As Nolan said, I'm Anne Logan, and I'm the Deputy Air Pollution Control Officer with Great Basin. We are in Yomono and Alpine counties.

34:12 And the second 10-year maintenance plan is a requirement of the Clean Air Act. So areas that were previously designated non-attainment for criteria pollutants have to have plans to maintain that standard. PM10 is a particulate matter of 10 microns or less. The town of Mammoth Lakes PM10 planning area is an area that's a little bit larger than the town boundary. So it extends out to the airport, encompasses the lake's basin.

34:41 And the updated plan includes a missions inventory quantifying all the sources of PM10 in the area, a verification of continued attainment, like Nolan said. So we have, with the exception of wildfire smoke exceedances, continued to maintain the standard with the existing rules and regulations. We have a commitment to continue monitoring as part of the plan.

35:07 And then a detailed description of the existing rules and regulations that provide for the control strategy. The primary rule that accomplishes this was adopted by the Great Basin as District Rule 431, particulate emissions, and was also adopted by the town in your municipal code. It's 8.3. So this is what regulates installation of wood burning devices, prohibits

35:36 Installation of those in some commercial buildings, provides for street sweeping programs, and that, those regulations, which were initially adopted in 1990 when the area was designated as non-attainment, really dramatically improved air quality. They were strengthened in 2014 when the area was initially re-designated for attainment.

35:59 And then with this second 10-year maintenance plan, there's no proposed new regulations. So we're just carrying forward the existing regulations. But the last piece of the maintenance plan is a contingency measure. So if we are unable to maintain air quality with the existing rules and regulations in place, there is a plan outlined for how adoption of new regulations might occur. I don't think that it will come to that, but that's

36:28 The whole purpose of the maintenance plan is to have some steps so that if things are unable to be maintained that we can move forward and address air quality issues. The item on the agenda before me, the Maine Lodge Redevelopment Plan, that's a project, something that maybe isn't located in close proximity to our monitor, but big projects like that, we are going to be paying attention to the environmental review and making sure that

36:59 Air quality impacts from that are in alignment with the maintenance plan as well as the district and town code. And so the 30-day public comment period for this draft maintenance plan is underway. There's no action required by town council, but the public or other agencies are welcome to comment during this period. We did work closely with the town in drafting it.

37:26 Nolan and Michael and other staff have already provided comments. Mono County has also provided comments as well as California Air Resources Board and U.S. EPA. The Great Basin Governing Board will consider for approval and adoption this plan on September 7th at a district governing board meeting and then pending it's approved it will go to California Air Resources Board for approval and adoption.

37:54 And then on to the US EPA for federal adoption. That process could take as long as a year, but we don't expect any hiccups. In conjunction with the plan, we've also prepared an exceptional event demonstration document. This was a document that was needed to show that all of the wildfire exceedances that occurred in 2020 were what the US EPA defines as exceptional events. I know the wording is

38:24 Somewhat ironic given that those are no longer exceptional here, but that's the regulatory term for an exceedance that is not reasonably controllable or preventable. So we have an over 200-page document showing that those exceedances were not due to sources within the town or associated area that were under our control. And that document will be moving in conjunction through the Great Basin Board Carbon EPA.

38:53 And they kind of go together. And that is essential for showing that we continued attainment, excluding those exceedances from the consideration of meeting the federal PM10 standard. And with that, I'd be happy to go into any extra history or answer any questions on the plan. I think in the packet there was a link to the public notice as well as the draft of the second 10-year maintenance plan.

39:25 Any questions for Ann? Yeah, I've got a couple, John. Oh, please. When the Forest Service is doing their pile burning, or what they call controlled burns, do they come to Great Basin in advance to find out what the levels are and to tell you that there may well be an exceedance because of their work, as it were? Yes. Prescribed burning is regulated by air districts in California. So we have a smoke management program where

39:55 Burns of a certain size require that the burner, whether it's a land management agency or a private individual, has to submit a plan detailing what methods they're going to take to minimize smoke, and then they have to request ignition for specific days, and so we make sure that the meteorology that day is suitable. That being said, you know,

40:18 The location of the burn has a very significant impact on the smoke impacts to communities and residents. And we are in a situation at the Air District where we are trying to facilitate as much burning as possible to help with fuels reduction and forest management while balancing that with protection of public health. So, yeah, if you have additional questions, I'd be happy to answer them. But we do have a role in that process.

40:49 The only other would be that it is controversial how the Forest Service handles forest fires. Whether we do a lead burn, even when we say we suppress, do you have any input on their preferred methods there? So when we have a big fire in our chimney coming up, the San Joaquin drainage is pumping smoke into us, whether they would put an all-out effort to put the fire out.

41:16 Or whether they're allowed to let burn because they would like more area to burn. We do have a role. I would say state law and federal interpretation can be a conflict. So when it's a naturally ignited fire managed for resource benefits under Title 17 of California state law, air districts have an ability to kind of intercept and deal with ignitions that, say, a land management agency is doing.

41:45 The federal land management agencies kind of disagree with that law, but we've been involved. I think the land management agencies can be receptive, especially when there's ignitions happening where they're actively putting fire on the ground. But with the Lions fire, I think that was, you know, we've had a steep learning curve the past couple years with those, but we do participate and can be an avenue for

42:13 Concerns about impacts. Lastly, do we have any ability to push the Forest Service in the direction, especially when they're doing pile burns, which are not prescribed burns, they're not clearing the underbrushes, of trying to push them into a biofuels plant that would create electricity, has scrubbers in it, doesn't put the amount of garbage in the air that just pile burning does, or is that just something that continues? I know that's not your bailing work, but Great Basin does have some powers here.

42:50 We do, but I would say for now in California we treat forest management, whether it's prescribed burning broadcast or pile burning as its own thing and stationary sources as their own thing. There hasn't been a move to push for burning to occur in other ways. And biofuels facilities can require permitting from the district. We've been involved in some of the discussions about potential for the one.

43:20 Thank you. You're welcome. Thank you. Anybody else? Nice to see you, Ann.

43:50 As you all know, I serve as our representative to this board. It's a very interesting board, a lot of very interesting things going on there. And Phil do a great job. It's really great staff and a great organization to sit in on. So good to see you. Thanks for coming. Thanks for having me. Just thanks for letting me update you on the plan. And I'll keep Nolan updated as this moves forward through the approval process. Thank you. OK.

44:16 Moving on then to staff presentations, 7.1, the quarterly presentation by airport core management team, summer 2023. It does. Yeah, I see it. Hi. Who's in charge? Okay. And then all four of us are going to be presenting through different sections of the presentation. So...

45:10 This is the Mammoth Yosemite Airport quarterly presentation. I think we missed one, so we might be slightly off. I'm getting back on track on our quarterly presentation. So I'm Sierra Schultz. I'm the Deputy Airport Manager for Mammoth Yosemite Airport. We have Sabine Spring. She is fairly recently our Operations Manager for the airport.

45:35 We have Pat Foster. He is with Hot Creek Aviation, who is the fixed base operator at Mammoth Yosemite Airport. And Rob Patterson, who works for the town as admin services and finance director, as well as part of our core management team for the airport.

45:56 So just kind of a recap on these quarterly presentations. We really want to just come to council and the public to kind of keep everyone informed on the happenings and current things going on at the airport as well as progress on any projects and things that we're working on.

46:18 We also want to hear back, get feedback from the public and you guys on goals, visioning, kind of priorities and work that back into what we're working on. So today we're really going to be focused on kind of the operational mission and operations that have been happening at the airport. We're also going to touch on the...

46:40 Some recent projects and events that have been going on, and then Hot Creek Aviation is going to talk a bit about GA and some of their services as well. So I'll talk a little bit about a meeting we recently had with Aviation Insights, which is one of our consultants with expertise in the aviation industry. We actually hired them in order to help our core management team understand not only

47:07 You know, some of the idiosyncrasies of running an airport, but what it takes to have good relationships with the FAA, as well as just having really operational excellence in leadership for an airport. We've been working with them for a little over a year and a half now, and so we had a meeting on site with all the representatives. There are three different branches of that group. So they were here to meet with us and really to help us prepare for a meeting with the FAA.

47:34 So our meeting with the FAA, it should occur very frequently. We do have phone conversations with them on a regular basis. But this is with the Western Region leadership team. So a very large area that they cover. But they're really responsible for what we receive for the airport, what we're able to achieve.

47:58 With our grant funding and that and so forth. The town is the airport sponsor, which means we are the responsible party for all the activity that goes on at the airport, as well as any grant assurances that we provide FAA for funding we receive and projects. This was a really good meeting. We had an opportunity to talk about everything that we're doing as far as our work plans, our capital projects, both current and future. And then we got to hear from them on on what.

48:27 FAA is focusing on now, what is important for them, for us to be aware of, so we're preparing to meet the needs they have for us. And as well as we had a few areas of discussion around our airport configuration. While it was a good conversation, we had some points that were made by both sides. I left with a whole lot better understanding about certain aspects of our airport, specifically on the design and planning.

48:57 And I think we all sort of understood a little bit more about that and got to a better place. So that was a great meeting. We look to have a lot more of those, but this one was long overdue. A few more updates. We started the automated weather observation system relocation and upgrade project on July 17th.

49:24 They've been working the last few weeks just to kind of do the underground utilities, and today they poured the concrete foundation, so we're moving through that, and we'll have a bit of downtime waiting for some equipment, but hope to get that project closed out in early November, so our new AWOS will get commissioned likely early November, and then decommission our existing system, so that is well underway.

49:51 And I also wanted to mention that we have town internally does these path to success academies where one department has staff present to the other departments within the town about kind of what's going on in that department.

50:09 What that department does essentially. So it's really great for new employees as well as others who might just not work as much in those other departments. So they did a facilities tour last week and the airport was one facility that they toured. So they came down in a trolley. We took them out on the runway and it was pretty great. Chris was there. So hopefully she enjoyed it. It was scary riding down the runway in the trolley. I was like, okay, can we go now?

50:37 Yeah, so we escorted them and yeah, so it went well. But thank you for, you guys worked really hard to make sure everyone knows what's going on. Thank you. Yeah, thanks. I'm glad you enjoyed it. So yeah, that was great. Kind of showed everyone our ARF and just gave employees a chance to come down and see the facilities, get inside the terminal, see the cafe and things that we are continually trying to tell everyone about. That was great.

51:03 And our last reminder is just on air service. Just a reminder that flights are happening to Hawthorne Airport right outside of LAX as well as Carlsbad Airport. And those occur on Fridays and Sundays every week going through Labor Day. So it will be on Monday, September 4th as well. And that'll be the final flight for the summer until we move into wintertime.

51:31 Yeah, and while we did talk about the air service a little bit, you know, this update is really about airport operations, as was our meeting with the FAA. We will have, you know, some regional air service discussions that's going on at the MIWAG level, and there will be some other, I think, broader discussions that go on with a regional focus on air service. So, but just a reminder, this particular point of the presentation is about airport operations.

52:00 If you will, for MMH. Okay, so operations is my department. My name is Sabian Spring, and I'm the operations manager. We have a very small crew. This year we have Tom Thomas, who's our maintenance lead. A new recruit, Shane Holti, which you guys met him recently. We have a future...

52:31 A teammate who has until August 20th to apply. We do bring on two seasonal workers, temporary airport maintenance workers in the wintertime. And then this winter, an exceptional winter in every way, we were able to bring in Hawk Creek Aviation as temporary employees as well.

53:03 Pat, Greg, and Jordan. Pat and Greg had history moving snow at the airport before the current configuration, and so they kind of fit right in as mature operators who knew the equipment in the airport and pretty much saved the day. And then, yeah, there's me. I did do some pronunciation there for you, Mayor Wentworth. Thank you. You're welcome.

53:31 Okay, so our mission in operations is safety, and the main tool that we use for that is our Part 139 certification. There we go. So Part 139 is a certification the FAA developed over years and years of compiling basically fatalities and trying to understand what caused them.

54:02 It was finalized in 2004, and it is a rubric of how to be exceptionally safe at a commercial airport. Here's a picture of our runway. Our runway is grooved, so it remains, it holds traction for many inches of snow, up to four inches of snow, but we start, typically we start moving at an eighth inch of snow.

54:30 We do repaint the pavement lines every season. Here you can see that the center line has wandered off of its plan. So this year, this is Eastern Sierra Land Surveys resurveying our center line so we can bring it back into true. So the components of Part 139 are all of the things that make an airport safe. We have lighting, signage, pavement.

54:55 Markings. We do have aircraft crash rescue and emergency medical response. We have movement area, movement and runway safety area requirements so that people just can't like drive or walk all over, ride their bikes or do drag races all over the airport. We do have security, discrepancy reporting, reporting notices to airmen, etc. are some of our components, but very

55:24 Very heavy on our plate is training. So there's annual trainings and all kinds of trainings. One that we did recently was the emergency medical responder training. It was the first time that we did it at the airport. Until recently, we've been staffed by volunteer firefighters. And most of us have had this training, EMR or EMT. But we found ourselves in a place where there was just one.

55:54 Me, and so I was the one who had to be there for all the flights, and we reached out to other town departments for that. We opened it up. We had two from the fleet. We had three from Public Works Engineering. That fellow in the yellow is Tom Thomas. We had one from Planning. And the three that you see in the upper right-hand corner, that is the

56:24 operations crew for Bishop Airport. So we were able to, because they have the same requirements of Part 139, they came up and trained with us and it was wonderful to have a nearby colleague and talk shop with. So that's something that we'll do every two years and possibly open it up to more of our town employees. Another big part of our

56:55 What we do there are inspections. So we do daily, weekly, monthly, on into infinity inspections. And we have a big one coming up next week. It's our annual FAA inspection for Part 139. And what they're going to see is that winter did a number on our airport. So I don't really need to tell anybody what winter was like here. But when you get to work and

57:23 You can't drive down the road. You have to snowshoe in across the fence. So this first slide is the doors snowshoeing over to there. And luckily, doors open inward on aircraft hangars. And to go inside and open up the hangar door, then you see that on the far right. That's kind of what it looks like. And a pickup truck won't drive out of that, but a big blower.

57:53 Well, even a blade won't push it very far, but we have our rotary snowplow. It would just cut paths out, and you can see in that second one on the right that it was just snow forever because we don't have night ops. All of that snow would accumulate overnight, and we'd face it every morning after morning after morning. So we all banded together, and we

58:22 We made it happen there. Here are some pictures of sometimes we would stay in communication with the FBO who does the ground service for Advanced Airlines and the Advanced Airlines team to make space for them a safe...

58:42 Runway is our first priority, and then part of the commercial ramp space for them to land and have passengers come and go. And those are those two top pictures. You can see that there are aircraft and snow removal equipment in the same frame. Those were exciting mornings. And some other pictures of our big blower, that's the one that we did take out, Benton Crossing Road, 14 miles.

59:09 Help to extricate those five souls out there. So yeah, winter was, we're still recovering from winter. We couldn't have done it without tons of help. HR was amazing in supporting us in getting Hawk Creek to be able to work with us. Hawk Creek Aviation is our partner in everything that we do.

59:36 And the roads department really chipped in. They actually took over from the county to keep airport road cleared once we got to that point. This is a picture of them doing our triple whites, which are our runway edge markers just a few weeks ago on the runway. And then also fleet maintenance, who kept all of our stuff running, including this unusual fire engine.

1:00:08 So every winter we scrape off all the markings, but this winter we scraped them off more than usual, and every summer we repaint them. So this is a big piece of what we are working on right now. We've also been repairing, there wasn't any, you know, piece of pavement, any system, piece of equipment, person, anything that wasn't touched by this winter. And so we're kind of putting all the pieces back together.

1:00:37 Getting it ready for next winter. You can see our little operations office down there in the right-hand corner. It's getting some new siding on there. This is what our every day is about right now. So the reason that we're there and that we're doing it or that we talk about and what makes us excited coming to work every day is really visitor and resident mobility.

1:01:09 We also love our local agency operation and events being a part of that and creating a safe space for that and our regional, state, and federal operations all in partnership with the FBO. But here you can kind of see that I just wanted to point out that one passenger there in the upper right-hand corner. That aircraft had a flat tire.

1:01:34 And this is one of the services we provide is this thing called a plane skate, which we can put under the landing gear. And then Hot Creek moves the aircraft safely off without any more damage to the aircraft. But you can't really see it in that picture. It's a tiny little pug dog who just made our day and cheering us on for that operation. OK, so now I'm going to hand it over to Pat to kind of explain what Hot Creek Aviation is doing.

1:02:03 These days. Good evening, everybody. Thank you for the opportunity to be here. I'm Pat Foster. I'm the president of Hot Creek Aviation. A little bit of review for some of you, although we do have some new council members since the last time we were here, and we still have some members of the public. So a little bit of review and then a little bit of an update. So Hot Creek Aviation has been in business for nearly 25 years, which sounds like it makes me...

1:02:38 I'm pretty old. We opened in the late 1900s. And we are an FBO. And whenever I say that, people say, OK, well, what does that mean? And I say, oh, it's a fixed base operation. And they go, well, somehow that's worse. What does that mean? So a little bit of history for you might find interesting. In the very early days of aviation, there weren't very many airports.

1:03:04 And so pilots would fly around from town to town landing in grass fields and they would put on little air shows and they would do flight lessons and these types of things. It was very transient in nature and they'd move from town to town trying to generate some money to keep flying. And then in 1926 the government passed the Air Commerce Act which created regulations on pilot licensing and maintenance protocols and these types of things and it basically took some of the transient nature out of

1:03:34 The aviation, it kind of forced people to set up permanent bases, or in other words, fixed base operation. So that's what we do. And in simple terms, we are the service provider for the airport. Just went through a long list of things that the town is responsible for. The town owns the airport. I have a contract with the airport to provide the services. Frankly, I've said it many times over the years, it takes at least a dozen people to run our airport effectively.

1:04:03 And it just so happens that about half of them work for you and about half of them work for me. But we all need each other. We work very well together. And it ends up being a great partnership. So some of the services that we provide, overnight tie-downs, overnight hangar rentals. We do jump starts, preheats, de-ices. We do some catering. Amanda helps us with some catering. Basically,

1:04:32 Anything that the pilots want, we try to take care of. Our motto, it doesn't matter if it's a Gulfstream or if it's a little single-engine plane or if it's advanced air, is, hey, you land the plane, we'll take care of everything else. You go enjoy Mammoth. We make our money selling fuel, which is a very difficult environment. Fuel sales account for about 70% of our revenue. And, frankly,

1:05:02 Like I said, it's very difficult to do. About 99% of our traffic comes from L.A. or the Bay Area. Everybody can round trip. Nobody needs the fuel. Everybody gets a better deal at home. We're talking about FBOs that sell millions of gallons a year. We sell 200,000 to 300,000 gallons a year. We can't pay anymore for trucking. It's a very difficult environment. Plus, we're at 7,100 feet of elevation, and the planes don't perform as well at elevation, so they really don't want the weight.

1:05:31 So it's about akin to me setting up a snow cone shack out front here with no flavors in the middle of winter. Right? Who wants that? But over the years, we've historically sold fuel to about 80% of the planes that fly in. And I really attribute that to our staff. We've got an amazing staff that...

1:05:57 It really loves on our customers. We offer a high level of hospitality, which is what these folks are expecting. And they understand that we need to sell some fuel to stay in business, and they work with us. And of course, I work with them. We have to make it make sense. So we really enjoy what we do. A little bit of an update. Last year, calendar year 2022, we did about 6,800 operations.

1:06:25 And operations is a takeoff and a landing. And that's a pretty good year for us. We've had better, we've had worse. But that's a pretty good year for us. Year to date through July, we're down about 12%. Very rough year for flying in the wintertime. A lot of challenging days. Now we're having kind of an odd summer. So that's hurt us a little bit. Conversely, our fuel volume is down about 12%, as you'd expect.

1:06:55 On the other hand, as I mentioned, we handle advanced air. We do all of the ticketing and baggage and ground handling and everything for them. We love that service. It's kind of interesting. Our flights are down almost 10% with advanced air this year. We kind of softened the summer schedule. Last year we were flying four days a week. This year we're flying two days a week. So even though our flights are down about 10%,

1:07:25 Our emplanements are up almost 32%. So year to date. And last year we did just under 3,600 emplanements. So we're up about 32%. We're going to surpass last year's numbers here pretty soon. So that's been really encouraging. And like I said, we really enjoy that service. If you haven't come down, the town staff did an amazing job converting the old, somewhat sterile.

1:07:51 So I'd love to have you come down and see that.

1:08:18 Although we still have our 139 certification and we still have to follow a lot of TSA rules, things have been softened a little bit. TSA works with us on some things. So we're able to do things that we used to do prior to air service in 2008. For instance, tomorrow we've got a photo shoot with Bloomingdale's. They're going to come down and spend about 12 hours with us. So that's going to be really fun. We're renting them a portion of the ramp.

1:08:46 We've got several staff members coming in. We're escorting folks and keeping an eye on everything. But it's really fun to be able to do those types of things. And frankly, if we had airline service coming in, it would just be a no, especially where they want to shoot. So it kind of creates opportunities for those types of things. We did do a commercial shoot not too long ago. That was really fun. But as you can see in the pictures, you just can't beat the views at the airport. It's a beautiful place to be. We really enjoy it. So with that,

1:09:17 Any questions for me? Any questions? Okay. Okay, I'm going to just kind of show you guys a couple more pictures here. So aside from helping passengers and people come and go, we do really go out of our way to make a safe space and do anything we can for

1:09:43 Our local agencies. So we have in the upper left-hand corner, we have a recent search and rescue training, which was also, you saw a couple slides ago, somebody dangling from a helicopter. That was, they went up one by one, up in the air, a miracle helicopter, and then came back down, and probably the best day of, it sounded like, they were pretty excited. Okay.

1:10:08 So we also have Medivac. It comes and goes frequently. The center photo is of our EMR class training with the Medivac crew and learning about how we can assist them, how we can help load their aircraft and all their different capabilities. We've got CalSTAR there on the left. And then on the right, we have every 15 minutes.

1:10:35 You guys are probably familiar with the program that happens at the high school. That center person there with the white shoes has Moulage. She was one of the passengers who was then airlifted to the airport. That was a pretty neat thing to be a part of for the first time with CareFlight. And we also are pretty excited about, you know, the airport was built

1:11:07 In the 40s as an airport, like an alternate airport by the military, but it was really used as a high altitude crosswind training ground, and it still is today. So that's when you see C-130s off in the distance or fighter jets, they're still using our airport for that. But we do have many fire suppression aircraft come through in the summer. Up until a few days ago, we had the only...

1:11:36 Helicopter on the east side was staged at our airport and then on Saturday night there was tons of lightning and it had to go work on keeping those fires down. We do have CHP in Southern California Edison. Edison was here today. I think CHP dropped off a hiker with like a broken leg two days ago.

1:12:01 We have the Airborne Snow Observatory aircraft are stationed at the airport. They are in Mammoth Lakes and Boulder, Colorado, but they spend a lot of their time at our airport. CalDART, which is the California Disaster Airlift Response Team, has just this season, after our incredible winter, they were responsible for airlifting water, fuel, food into Crestline when they were...

1:12:29 When the roads were all closed. And so they wanted to come, they reached out to Sierra, and they wanted to come and visit our airport. And they delivered a virtual package, which is a piece of paper. But it represented that their volunteer network of pilots could access us should we be, should 395 be completely closed. And then, yeah, I mean, we have like every kind of...

1:12:56 I know that hasn't always been the case in the past, so I am very excited to see that.

1:13:27 And having been care-flighted out myself, I'm glad the airport's there. Well, thank you very much, Sabine, for that really nice presentation. Great to see the team. And Rob, to your point, I know we've got an ESCOG meeting coming up tomorrow, this whole MiWOG discussion, and looking forward to figuring out how to put that conversation in the context of this conversation as we go forward, because that's, I think with the TBID renewal, we've got four years, four or five years to get that all figured out.

1:13:58 That group's got to get to work on all that stuff. Thank you. Yeah, thank you all. Okay. All right, so we're going to move on now. I'm going to read the consent agenda. Maybe take a quick break after that. So forgive me as I recite. Item 8.1, approve the minutes of the special meeting of July 27, 2023. 8.2, approve the minutes of the regular meeting of August 2, 2023.

1:14:27 Item 8.3, approve the resolution authorizing the temporary closure of town roads for special events. Item 8.4, adopt a resolution authorizing the subrecipient agreement with Mammoth Lakes Housing, Inc., to administer the Town of Mammoth Lakes 2022 CDBG Home Buyer Assistance Program. Item 8.5, adopt a resolution rejecting the bid for the ARF snow removal equipment building site work at Mammoth Yosemite Airport. Item 8.6, approve side letter number

1:15:01 01-2023 between the Town of Mammoth Lakes and Mammoth Lakes Police Supervisory Association amending the current Memorandum of Understanding and authorize the Town Manager to sign. Item 8.7, approve side letter number 02-2023 amending the Memorandum of Understanding between the Town and the Mammoth Lakes Police Officer Association regarding the canine program. Item 8.8, waive the reading and dot by title only the ordinance.

1:15:29 Authorizing the levy of special taxes in Community Facilities District Number 2013-3, Transit Services, including certain annexation territories, on Item 8.9, accept check register from July 27, 2023 in the amount of $85,296.65, and accept check register from August 9, 2023 in the amount of $334,295.48. Anybody wish to pull anything?

1:16:01 Anybody in the public want to pull anything? Not seeing any desire for that, Jamie, if you could, sorry, I need a motion first. Okay? Second. Okay, motion and a second, any additional discussion? Jamie, please. Councilmember Bubzer? Yes. Councilmember Ray? Yes. Councilmember Rice? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Souser? Yes. Mayor Wentworth? Yes. Thank you. Let's take just a quick break. I'll be right back, and then we'll keep going. Are you sure it's the...

1:24:12 Okay, we're back. So now we're going to move on to policy matters. Item 9.1, approve agreement with Peckham and McKinney to assist the town council in the recruitment and selection of a new town manager. Dan Holler, Councilmember Rice, Mayor Pro Tem. Thank you very much. Dan, you want to kick it off? Yeah, I can real quickly. Yeah, the process here was we sent out.

1:24:47 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

1:25:17 Great house. She is on Zoom here. Speak to that. There's a lot of information in the packet on the agreement. We will want to speak a little bit about the process and then also kind of about the schedule coming up in that process. With that, if Sauser or Rice want to speak up and how the selection process went. Great. The process, as always, is fascinating. They were two for Peckham. So, yeah, proceed from here.

1:26:08 I thought that Roberta would be a good fit for working with our town council members, and she seemed very professional, and we're expecting her to get us someone as good or better than Dan, which will be hard to do. Roberta, we haven't met yet, but your trees, what's wrong with your trees? I don't know. It's Parker Lake. Maybe it's just the way that the path was, that they're kind of, that one tree is a little sideways. No, they're beautiful. They're just yellow. We're just, we're...

1:26:40 Trying to convince ourselves that we're still enjoying summer, but so it goes. So, Dan, should we just hear from Roberta? What's your pleasure here? Yeah, if I may, I'll introduce it. Yeah, then I'll have Roberta give a little bit of background on herself and the firm. And then for the council, the real discussion, one is approving the agreement, obviously, that's before you, that we did want to be able to walk through. It's the last page in the packet, which is kind of the time frames and the proposed search schedule, making sure council is comfortable with that and look at some of the dates.

1:27:10 Key dates in that process to make sure they get on your calendar for setting those days aside. So with that, Roberta, I'll let you talk briefly about yourself and the firm and then don't do anything else, but really want to look at that time frame and the process to make sure everybody's on board with that. And then the action this evening would be to approve the agreement accordingly to move all this forward. Excellent. Thank you. Roberta, good evening. Welcome.

1:27:34 Good evening, Mayor and Councilmembers. Thank you so much for having me tonight. I'm very excited about this opportunity to help you with a new town manager. So let me start with talking to you about Peckham & McKinney. So Peckham & McKinney is a boutique recruitment firm, and we specialize in executive searches only for small and medium-sized public agencies.

1:27:55 We think that we probably are the only firm that is owned and operated and comprised solely of individuals who came from the public sector. All of us are retired executive managers, either city managers, human resources, we have police chiefs, we have fire chiefs. You know, what makes us different, I think, in addition to the fact that we are all public employees is that passion that we have for the government.

1:28:24 And, you know, we keep our recruitment load very small so that we can make sure that we have very hands-on commitment to the agency as well as the candidates. You know, we really focus about fit. We're not here to come in and, you know, just jam a bunch of candidates at you. We're really looking for people. We're looking to hear from you what you're looking for in your next town manager. And then I'm out there searching for people that fit that profile.

1:28:53 So then really quickly, I'll tell you about myself. I spent 34 years in the public sector, spent 18 years with the city of Monterey, 16 years with the city of Seaside. And when I retired from the city of Seaside, I was their HR director and risk manager. So I have lots and lots of experience with recruitments. And I served a year as their acting city manager. So I also understand, you know, what goes into being a city manager, particularly in a small and under-resourced agency.

1:29:25 Okay, that sounds good. Any questions at this point? Do we want to start talking schedule? Okay, well, we're all about the fit. And, Roberta, I would just add that some of us are on the council. Some of us just ran for election just not too long ago. And I know that a top priority for us was this transition from our current town manager to a new one. And so we're very much looking forward to working with you. We're very excited to meet you.

1:29:55 Thank you. And to start embarking on this process, which is going to be of critical importance to our future going forward. Absolutely. Yeah, thank you. So do you want to, who wants to start walking us through getting the calendars out and starting to figure out how we're going to do this? May I? The calendar looks great. One of the things I have said to Dan, and I'm only one, is my preference is to have as many in-person as possible. I just believe in these circumstances they work better.

1:30:25 So I will be there on site.

1:30:53 October the 4th at your council meeting. And this is the time that we will review all of the feedback that I've received from the council and look at the brochure to make sure we're all on the same page. And at that meeting, we'll also talk about all of the other key points in the recruitment to get the council's input on what you would like to do with the testing process. We have one virtual meeting December 13th. That is when I would bring you your list of candidates.

1:31:21 And then I'm back in person January 11th and 12th. And we also, just to back up a little step, I will be having individual meetings with each of you to get your feedback on what you're looking for in the town manager, as well as anybody else that you'd like me to meet with. Sometimes it's department heads, community members, whatever the council likes. And I was planning to do that virtually between September 18th and 29th.

1:31:58 With Roberta, yeah. So, Roberta, my question would be the virtual meetings with individuals. Would you then on the 4th meet with us as individuals and then at the town council meeting or as a group only? So my thought was to meet with the entire council on the 4th. But if some of you would like me to meet with you in person on the 4th, I can do that as well. I'll be there on the 3rd. And so that's not a problem at all. I wouldn't think that's a problem.

1:32:33 I think, Roberta, I'm very much looking forward to meeting you in person and virtually, but I think we're all interested in meeting the candidates in person and virtually in all kinds of different configurations. And especially, I think Dan's probably mentioned this to you, the various ebbs and flows of our audience, the types of seasonal challenges we get, so I think that's a discussion for a later time. But I think that's going to be really interesting.

1:33:04 I think it's aggressive. I think it's aggressive. And fingers crossed, Roberta. So yeah, let's go ahead and I think we're good with the calendar.

1:33:41 And I think with that, if there's any additional comments or questions, I would see if there's any public comment on this item. I'm not seeing any, so then at this point I would entertain a motion with the action item in front of us. I'll move to approve the agreement with Peckham and McKinney to assist the town council in the recruitment and selection of a new town manager. Thank you. We have a motion to second any additional discussion. Not hearing any, Jamie, please. Councilmember Bubzer? Yes. Councilmember Rae?

1:34:14 Yes. Councilmember Rice. Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Salzer. Yes. Mayor Wentworth. Yes. Great to meet you, Roberta. Looking forward to working with you. Thank you. Me too. Talk to you guys soon. See you soon. Bye. Okay. This next item is the determination that emergency work authorized by resolutions 23-29 and 23-54 continues to be necessary for public welfare and safety.

1:34:40 We've done this at the last meeting. This, I think, is something we just need to keep moving forward with. I don't think we need a staff presentation. So at this point, unless there's any public comment, not hearing anybody, seeing anybody, I would entertain a motion to move this resolution forward. I'll make a motion to find that the determination that the emergency work authorized by resolutions 23-29 and 23-54 continues to be necessary for public welfare and safety. Second. Second.

1:35:10 Any additional discussion? Not hearing any. Jamie, please. Councilmember Bubzer? Yes. Councilmember Rae? Yes. Councilmember Rice? Yes. Mayor Pro Temp Souser? Yes. Mayor Wentworth? Yes. Thank you. Item 9.3, we're going to get an update on the Housing Solutions Workup, sorry, Housing Solutions Workshop follow-up. Nolan. Thank you. Council, as well as the public, we had the Housing Workshop on July 27th.

1:35:43 I thought it was really well attended by the public. We counted approximately 65 people. It seemed like a diverse group in the crowd. We also did a great job of mixing up the tables so that everyone wasn't necessarily sitting with all their friends or those who would have the same thoughts. So I think it did really well having the mix up at the tables. In the packet, we did include all the group response sheets as well as the individual response sheets as attachments. And we went through the group response sheets and

1:36:15 We tried our best to kind of identify the overarching themes that we were hearing from the various tables and then consolidate that into something that makes sense for people to kind of inform on future work programs. Some of the themes that I thought, you know, that I saw in the group sheets, you know, some of which we kind of expected, some of which was surprising. For example, on the what did you learn, I think, you know, six out of the eight tables key.

1:36:44 Mentioned that they were surprised by the needs or learned about the needs and that we actually hadn't produced any affordable units in the near term. But at the same time, we have a number of units coming online in the next few months to help starting to address that needs as well as ongoing projects which will deliver additional units. Also a kind of popular theme on what you learn as well as what you like with responses on the van life.

1:37:13 That's something that going forward we can look into how to implement that. Also on the other part of that kind of question one that I found most useful was what is missing. There wasn't necessarily an overarching theme on what is missing, but at the same time some of the comments were, you know, items that we're already doing, which is looking at, you know, land in the county and outside the town or within the town and outside the town for potential developments.

1:37:41 As well as the need for additional data, not so much to a full in-depth update of our needs assessment or the community housing action plan, but just some different data as to are we targeting the correct AMIs? Do we know what kind of groups are out there and what their needs are, such as the workforce at the schools or the workforce at the hospitals and are our current programs addressing those needs? And then...

1:38:09 Going to exercise two, which was kind of looking at future housing projects and opportunity sites. What we also heard was nobody at least another group responses said any of the sites were not appropriate for housing. And also surprising, all the groups said that all three sites were appropriate for medium to high density on the sites. Nobody felt that any of the sites should be low or excluded as housing sites. Then on just the amenity sides,

1:38:38 Thank you so much.

1:39:05 For my work on the housing side, exercise three was obviously informing more on the short-term rental side, which is obviously the finances kind of department. But again, on that one, I think it was good to hear feedback from the community there that they supported their strongest support for the management strategies was to continue with the current short-term rental management plan and implementation of that. There's also medium support for

1:39:33 Implementing some sort of restrictions or reductions as well as facilitating the conversion of long-term rentals to ownership. Obviously, any of those work programs would have to be more defined as to what those mean. We also, within the questions, or at least in the follow-up, I combined questions two and three, which was adjustments to work plans as well as alternatives to work plans, and just put really the high-level themes as to what the comments were in this follow-up.

1:40:04 With that, I can open up to the council on any questions they have, at least on the kind of summary of what we heard and what was presented there before we go to the next steps. Yeah, then we'll talk about next steps, but really interested to see from the council perspective if there's elements and themes or ideas that you heard that came out of the discussion that you want to make sure that we're aware of or maybe they just hit you as being interesting or an area that we should look at or whatever from that perspective.

1:40:34 And also general thoughts on the format. Did that work well in terms of maybe utilizing this for some other topical type discussions where we can have the full count in that process, although your engagement's a little bit limited due to different meetings? Okay, so I have just a quick comment. I think that one thing that we could have just done a little bit better is included a zoning map and kind of talked about the different zoning.

1:41:06 In the town, I feel that listening to everyone's, I think it was maybe question number four or something, when asked about the resort zoned, only limiting STRs to resort zoned areas only, I feel that the general public didn't have a good grasp of what that meant exactly. I felt like the issue that we were trying to get at the heart at, which is what, you know,

1:41:38 What are people feeling about short-term rentals? Having a discussion about short-term rentals was really kind of shoehorned in to the last part of that meeting when everyone was kind of itching to get out. I feel like the discussion about future housing plans and what we'd like to see and where we'd like to see them was maybe a little bit over our skis.

1:42:00 We want to have a discussion about what's going on with short-term rentals. So we put that at the very end when everyone's kind of like stirring in their seats. And we had a really lengthy discussion about what our dream, you know, future housing plans should be. So I really feel like we kind of mixed those up. I would have really liked to have. I had to go, you know, like I had childcare. I had to go. So I feel like people were kind of over it. It was, you know, by the end of the two hours.

1:42:29 I felt disappointed when I left that we spent so long talking about future housing projects and where we'd like to see them or what we'd like to see as opposed to the issue that's actually in front of us, which is short-term rentals. I agree. I would have really liked to have seen some more visuals because not everybody has the knowledge that we do as insiders. I think those are my two things I wish we had done a little better. Chris?

1:43:01 Bill, do you want to go before me? I'm collecting my thoughts. I was incredibly pleased that we got a group other than the normal suspects. That is huge for me. The number of respondents that were already homeowners in Mammoth versus people that actually may have the need for housing I thought was a little skewed. I don't know how we would fix that.

1:43:32 Our Hispanic community, except for one or two people, was absent almost entirely. I don't know that there is a way to bring them in any better. Some of the questions and how they were answered, I was not surprised, but saw that a lot of people talked about the necessity of being close to transit, but at the same time talked about the necessity for having better parking planning.

1:44:02 It's something for us to take into consideration. As one of our consultants in the past said, a pedestrian is a driver who's found a parking spot. So I still think that's important for us to look at in our plans. Other than that, I don't think there are any real surprises for me here. Again, it was a good exercise. I'd like to see us do it again, maybe.

1:44:33 Six months or a year after we open at least the first phase of the parcel because that's going to change the dynamics somewhat, I think, into what our needs are and to what actually transpires with 80% and below housing. Other than that, I was pleased with it. Yeah. Make one more comment. Under adjustments to work plans, I didn't see...

1:45:06 The suggestion to have a waiting period between purchase of a home and obtaining a short-term rental permit. I don't know if I missed that. Good. Chris? So I am really pleased that we're starting to engage the public more. And I think that, and I was really happy with the turnout. I was pleasantly surprised because, you know, it's always challenging to get people to show up. I feel that

1:45:40 I don't want to reiterate, I sort of agree with everything that's been said, so I don't want to go on for too long. And I do feel that, Bill, while it's important to have follow-up once we have people housed, because I think it's important to show success, I also think that there's a lot of community discussion around what we do in the immediate term.

1:46:03 To get more housing available for people. So I would like to see us continue to follow up on the short-term rental question, potentially even have another workshop. But I don't think that we, you know, have addressed that in the way that the community has been clamoring for. But again, I'm thrilled that people are willing to show up and they're willing to lend their voices. And we should take and build on that, you know, success.

1:46:37 I did not see the community clamoring, and I read every one of these for something big on short-term housing. The majority were in favor of us keeping as we're going. I know we're going to have the discussion, but that's not, in my perception, what I saw coming out of this meeting. The majority of the people in that room were realtors. Not the majority of them. There were some realtors. Of the people who showed up, I think, you know, you made the point that

1:47:05 It wasn't truly representative. We know that. And the other thing is, it wasn't representative of our community who struggles with finding housing because they were at one of their several jobs. So I do think we need to find a way to get those voices into the conversation. And look, I'm not criticizing the staff or the program. I'm just reflecting a reality that

1:47:34 None of us believes that was representative of everybody in town who's struggling with this problem. So I think we have to keep trying. That's what I was saying. And I am hearing from lots and lots of people who weren't in that room. But let's be honest, they couldn't be there. I think, Chris, I agree with you. I feel like, you know, it was a good start to the conversation. And, you know, we need to continue this conversation, especially.

1:48:05 You know, about STRs and, you know, figuring out what we are willing to do as a community to, you know, increase livability and affordability here with regards to short-term rental management. Well, I'll throw in, I think that the, from just as a council perspective, that type of setting, that type of format, I think, is incredibly valuable. It's never going to be.

1:48:36 It's not perfect, but to have us sitting there basically listening, it comes in, it's not perfect, but we hear it, we know the things we have to do from a policy perspective. I think that format is an incredibly useful tool. I think I would love to see a similar conversation with the business community. I mean, all the things that are, when people say, well, where's your retail? Well, you know, look what's happening in the world. It's online, John. What's that? It's online.

1:49:02 Well, exactly. So in terms of the things I think that we need to hear as unscientifically as possible, those types of settings are going to be really good. I think, to your point about the night of the rentals, that was obviously not a policy setting session. That's sort of a listening session. So I would not want us to say, well, we've got to do more listening to figure out what we've got to do with policy. I think you're right. We have policy things we've got to get into right away, so we've got to keep that going. I heard a lot of great information.

1:49:31 One takeaway I really heard from this is the urgency of housing. We've got to do something about it. I really think we need to figure out some basic vision of where we're going with all this so that we don't just start saying, OK, go build a bunch of stuff and go do a bunch of stuff over here like this. And we don't really know where we're going because we're going to need to have some idea because it is finite. We've only got so much land. We've only got so many resources to have some sense of how to prioritize what we're doing to make sure we get there.

1:50:01 The Grocery Outlet Project came forward. And, you know, Sandra was saying, oh, no, we got enough room for parking and turnouts and all that kind of stuff. And, you know, I ride down Old Mammoth Road all the time, and that doesn't really work that well. So we start talking about issues of density, the things that maybe we hear from the public, they're okay with it. We've got to be really smart about how we do that. Because a lot of communities, this is happening statewide.

1:50:28 You know, no single family residential stuff. Let's put four plexes, do all that kind of stuff. Okay, great. More housing for more people. But the infrastructure that supports all that isn't being modified to accommodate that kind of stuff. And so these are the kinds of things we've got to be thinking about in terms of what our real holding capacity, what our carrying capacity is, and how we can move forward. So I think it'd be real helpful for all of us to get kind of the same page of what does this build out look like? It'll change. It'll be different.

1:50:54 What are our values to be making some decisions as we go forward? Yes, Bill? Another thing that I think we could have done better is to put sideboards on the conversation. It is obvious from reading through all of these that most of the people there don't understand that we don't get to set AMI because a whole bunch of the comments were, change the AMI so it works for our people. We don't get to go there.

1:51:22 The fact that we cannot produce 450 units in the next 70 years with what we can finance it as, no matter where we go with short-term rentals or anything else, it takes the tax money, the grant money, it takes someone like our current partners to achieve that. And I think that somehow when I'm reading this, maybe between the lines, that was lost. So an informational piece to get out prior saying, look.

1:51:51 We have a very finite budget. It costs us between a half million and three quarters of a million dollars to build a unit. How then give them realistic expectations of what we can do? Because now I'm going to hear from people, you get that AMI is wrong. You got to change it. I can't go there. So that's in the future when we do these, a better educational piece or upfront.

1:52:21 Well, I think that, I mean, there was, I was, you know, encouraged that the folks seem to have it, you know, they have their own sense of it.

1:52:52 And I think it's important that the conversation has begun because all those people showed up left with more knowledge than they had when they came in the room. But to Bill's point, I think we have to be less.

1:53:20 Or more willing not to shy away from help. And I realize when someone gives public comment, we can't as a body comment on that. But in that setting, if I think staff should feel really comfortable with dispelling myths, because it's a perfect example. Like people don't understand that the only funds that the town of Mammoth Lakes can leverage for housing from the state or federal government is

1:53:48 So, I just think these are

1:54:18 Pretty complicated. It's taken me forever to start to understand how it all works. But to Bill's point, like having people leave with that information, you know, that belief, we should really try hard to help them understand we have policies set elsewhere that we have to try to work around. Okay, so, I mean, the conversation's not over yet, but do you guys have any, do you want to tell us what are we going to do with this? One point is, Noah, I need to follow up.

1:54:53 What was reported? I'd like to touch on a little bit just comments and stuff and take them to note. I think I did want to touch on the next steps elements because I think it's a multi-pronged approach. The first one being obviously continuing doing some of the other small projects. We have initiated some conversation with that. Again, ongoing work with ADU. We're expecting to have several new housing bills to further restrict what you can say no to.

1:55:46 Housing and how that goes forward. I think the other two elements, so that's kind of the near-term continue doing, you have that longer-term one. Looking at that, people have asked, okay, after the parcel, then what? It's got a lot of work to go. And so those kind of three larger sites continue. And then the other one that really deals with more of the, I'll say it's still, it's a, that is something we can, definitely looking at some elements there as we can bring stuff forward, but being able to have the time to work on that.

1:56:26 And address the types of issues. We'll take effort, and as we know, kind of there is, to give us the time to do this. A lot of the options are out there. There's a half a dozen, dozen trucking, and they address through that. So I think there's, you know, part of that, I think people were surprised at the level of enforcement. And then the question really comes up with managing as team. That's, there's a number of things to do there that we didn't really want to spend. To be able to bring that back and say, what does it take that, you know, look at. And part of that is we've had some discussions with the economic side of having mixed.

1:57:41 Does short-term rental. Pro and con. In neighboring counties, several studies this way, and they've also then been able to analyze a number of policies. Let me just interrupt you real quick on that. I think on the short-term rental thing, I think that for a variety of reasons, the winner, whatever, we're not really engaged. And it just comes back to a point that was made at the meeting, which is we have a really effective enforcement program. We still don't know the effect of that sector, the short-term rental sector.

1:58:34 What effect that is actually having on housing? So we've kind of isolated, we've got our hands around it, but we don't know exactly how it's affecting our housing. However you look at this, I just want you to know that I'm strongly in support of others are as well, but we don't want policy. Is there a policy question in front of us? No, really, we're looking for that general direction, for moving the right steps, hitting those priorities. We should also, as we look to the future, my real question on the first... We're sitting here in an empty room.

2:00:02 Talking to ourselves. And I think it's an enormous relief to be sitting in a room with a bunch of people. We can not just hear individual comments, but that kind of a dynamic thing. I think one other just idea if we did a meeting like that in the future would be to maybe have it on a Monday or Tuesday night because I feel like more service industry people, more restaurants are closed on Tuesday nights compared to Thursday nights. So maybe we'd be able to get a better turnout or.

2:00:32 Did we start it at, I can't remember what time, was it 5.30 or 5? We hope it was at 4.30. Okay. And, you know, maybe like starting it just a little bit later so people can get off work and go there. But I think maybe, I don't know. Yeah, we can kick ideas around. Timing is always, as Sarah said, by the end, even earlier, it's just, it's a tough. And then also on that note, too, is I don't know how we would be able to engage.

2:01:24 Thank you.

2:02:11 I thought it was a great, really, really good. I'm glad, Amanda, you brought up trying like a Tuesday evening, but also for issues of equity, it's really important, I think, to do it twice at a completely different time of day so that, and I know that costs more and it's more time, but you know what? Like we're trying to engage our community and if we really want to engage our community, we got to meet them where they are. So I'll leave it at that. Good, let's do some more of those. Okay, so.

2:02:58 Item 9.4, Consideration and Direction on Increase of Parking Citation Fees from the Sublime to the Ridiculous. Chief, thank you. Complaints have gone up quite a bit. I want the community to know that we hear them. We hear them and... Speaking of which... We hear you. Yeah, does the community hear me? Yes. Our complaints have gone up significantly and what we're trying to do is mitigate the issue. We're trying to gain complaints because right now we don't have complaints during the winter times.

2:04:38 In the summertime. What we're seeing is our ingress, egress, slowly narrowing, especially on those roads. Our parking citations are $45. What we're seeing, and I've seen it personally, is how much is the ticket? $45. They say, well, okay, I've already spent thousands, so what's another $45? And they use it basically as a parking pass. And we have issues with towing.

2:05:08 We have one tow company in here. Winter times are very busy. We need to do something about the parking issue to gain complaints. And my thought is to increase our parking fees. Primarily, if you look at the schedule, we're at $45, I would say. The majority of our tickets are at $45. We have a few that are, you know, $110, which is obstructing snow removal, $330 for handicapped parking, which is below the state average.

2:05:37 Usually the state average is around 450 or so. We're requesting it to bump up to 550. And the reason for that is we have limited parking, limited handicapped parking stalls within the town. And a good example of that is going to be in front of the village. We've got one handicapped parker in front of the village. People are in and out of it all day. And when we do have the opportunity to actually catch somebody in there and they're sitting in the car, the explanation is we're just running in to get some.

2:06:07 And it's just kind of like an in and out all day long. So the request is going to be to up everything. And what I did was I looked at some other resort destinations to see where they're at. And Big Bear being one of them, funny enough, they were at $50, I think, and they just upped their parking citations to $100. I looked at Vail. Vail does a progressive parking citation program where they go $50, $100, $100 for like the third violation.

2:06:39 And I reached out to some others, and before I can get this in, they hadn't gotten back to me, but South Lake Tahoe got a hold of me yesterday and explained what they do. So theirs was about $75. They're having the same issues we are, the ingress-egress issues, the using the parking citations for parking passes. They just went to council and got it approved, $100. So what we're looking for here is just some direction.

2:07:12 Council, we're looking at 110 for the majority of our parkers. We're looking at doubling our 110 to a few others as well as handicapped. I understand that the literature and the information needs to get out to the public. A way that we plan to do that is through social media. We can get this approved and through by the October-ish. That would give us October to start issuing warning sites that actually have the, with that, have to answer any questions from council.

2:07:57 So just to clarify, it's currently, like for regular, parked wrong, $45. The increase is $110, so it'll be $155. No, it would go $110. Okay. Because you said $550 for parking in a handicap zone, but it's actually $410. I'm with you. You can't charge people enough for that. The handicap one is one of ours, and a lot of the community, and you go there, I'm waiting for my wife to come out of the store.

2:08:45 The other balancing through this we're looking at is we also have a lot of locals who deserve balancing that off too. And some of that is, well, where else do I go? What else do I do? We do want to have a balance between, as Dan mentioned, looking at probably like a start date to let people know what's coming so they're aware of it. And again, I'll say a lot of people, I think, have gotten to the point hoping it's over 100. That starts the attention a little better, not just for those elements. So I think the two issues tonight was if you're comfortable with increases or forward.

2:09:45 I do have another question then. Just in the law of unintended consequences, we've all heard the stories of someone who, you know, gets a pile of parking tickets and literally ends up incarcerated because they can't afford to pay them. That's not, I think, something that probably happens in the mammoths of the world, but it happens in big cities.

2:10:25 What do we do to locals who have accumulated a certain number of parking tickets? Because that's not our intent here if it's somebody who, you know, is just having a rough time. So what usually happens with that with the parking citations doesn't, I've never seen it in Mammoth go to an arrest warrant to arrest that person for parking citations. It goes to DMV and then they get fined through DMV for not the parking citations. They suspend their registration.

2:10:54 That type of stuff. You know, another thing to look at as well is what South Lake Tahoe did is they have resident parking passes. And what that means is they can park out in front of their house if they need to move their car to clear the snow and stuff like that and not get a citation for it as long as they have a pass in there. That's something I think to look at at another time, but something that would probably be a good idea. But as far as what you state, there's no, I've never seen that here.

2:11:23 You know, they do have consequences through DMV for unpaid parking citations, but I've never seen a warrant go out for arrest for unpaid parking citations. Well, and the reality is the PD would control whether a warrant is sought for the arrest, so that wouldn't happen without me wanting it to happen, and I think that would represent a significant enough shift in the town's enforcement strategy that I imagine the town manager of the day would come to the council and ask us, do you want to start arresting people for tickets? I think that'll happen without me. Interesting conversation on that point. Something like that is what is needed.

2:12:11 I've talked to Dan about this. I haven't talked to our attorney about it. I was a drunk driver that lived in Mammoth that got a citation, came to me for public service because that's what they were ordered to pay. I'm wondering if we couldn't work initially for our locals. So if they can't afford the ticket, we'll do it again. But to end up in public service, I have to do eight hours instead of paying my 110. Works. I know it's hard to find, you know, that I think we could find that work for them. But still the end, if we have to arrest.

2:12:54 Through everything you're saying, when I did the pier with the town to Aspen, and I actually talked to some of their customers, city staff in Aspen told me program works, this is the trolley. I talked to five different skiers who just took their $207 ticket as the cost of parking, so somehow we have to find that issue. Prices, I don't think, are out of sight at all, especially if we can work. I will say I would like to see us ticket a violator every day. If they're parked in a spot, no overnight parking, and they continue.

2:13:38 Which is a really good idea, and we can look at the progressiveness of the citations similar to Vail, and we can, that's one of the biggest concerns.

2:14:34 Plants is from our local business owners. When vehicles are parking in front of their businesses, which hampers their business, they don't have any parking out there. And these people, a lot of times, are just leaving the cars out there for days on end because they don't have any place to park. What we're currently doing is we do go back and we recite on a daily basis if that vehicle is still there. If it's there, then we tag it as 72 hours and end up towing it as an abandoned vehicle that's been there for over 72 hours.

2:15:01 So there are multiple tickets that are getting put on the windshield, but you're looking at multiple tickets in the amount of $45 apiece. Another interesting thing that you've explained to me is the fact that if someone's parked illegally, we can't just go in and tow them in California. That's correct. And I don't know that everybody up here knows that, so if you'd like to explain that to us, that would be... So we have tow authorities in the vehicle code that we can follow, and one of them isn't if you're parked illegally.

2:15:29 One of the only times we can tow an unintended vehicle is if it's blocking snow removal. We can tow at that point and we can tow for abandoned vehicles, which are in a place, in a position for 72 hours and has not moved. Fire hydrants, yes, fire hydrants you can tow for. So the vehicle code is really prescriptive and restrictive on everything relating to vehicle regulation, parking and towing. And so there's no room for jurisdictions to be creative at all because we only have the authority that the vehicle code says we have.

2:16:06 Yeah, the only one that gives me pause is the $110 for no camping on town roads. And I don't want people to be able to camp on town roads, but I think that that will affect our locals who live in their cars the most. And in turn, that will affect local businesses, you know, because a lot of people who are locally employed live in their cars. So that's the only one that...

2:16:36 I could see that, you know, hurting local people, and I don't think that that's what raising these fees is intended to do. Absolutely not. It's not intended for that, and to be honest with you, I don't remember the last time we've written a citation for that. We usually move them along if they're in an area where we're getting complaints and stuff like that. Citing them doesn't happen very often. It would be the direction that we're looking at going. So this is more geared towards eerie.

2:17:12 You know, ingress, egress, that kind of stuff, blocking snow removal. You know, the issues, the major issues that we're having throughout town during the wintertime, and not necessarily for no camping on town roads. Okay, thank you. I'm good with everything I've heard. I really, the progressive nature of this, I'd like to see it, I'd like to do surge parking tickets, but that's probably a good topic for another day. But I certainly am good with everything I'm hearing here.

2:17:45 When do you think we can bring this back and when do you think we can start having a vote on this so that we can start getting the information to the public? I'm thinking also about the folks who came down and talked to us, the Rainbow Lane folks, where, you know, talking about taking some really exceptional measures to make sure the public knows that we're serious and we're doing this. Talking with MLT, putting signs up, look, welcome to Mammoth, don't park like a fool because it's going to cost you. So I think you've got some good.

2:18:14 I think getting it back in front of the council would be pretty quick. You know, these two to get a resolution done. I think you need to adopt it by resolution to make sure it's well documented for as a fee, a citation fee. And then within the resolution, you'd put that, yeah, these new rates would be effective X date. In the meantime, we push information out. We let people know it's coming. If you've got a citation that's $45, can we put a note there that says in November this would be $110, especially

2:18:43 Again, to our local residents and visitors, it's a little tougher to do that outreach to. But getting that information out there and also then for local businesses and stuff that they know it's coming as they inform their staff as well as their customers, those types of elements. One more thing, Dan. Even in the next year or so, when we implement these new, if we could reach a deal with the county or some other space to provide parking,

2:19:13 And a minimal, we're talking about van life, but for the people who frankly don't have parking, it's just something else for us to look at. Okay, so I think you've got some thoughts from the council here. Is there any public comment on this? Sure.

2:19:50 Okay, so any public comment anywhere?

2:20:18 I think you've got what you need. You can ask on that one. I mean, I hear Chris on that, but I mean, I'm not, the rest of the council wants to see that bump up. We can do that, but I'd like to have that more of a consensus. I'm fine with that. I'm okay with that. I'm not, I'm a little concerned about the signage part of it, but I'm not concerned about that. Yeah, if we can sign it appropriately, I don't have a problem with increasing that as a blue card holder. It is sometimes important. Yeah, getting people to respect that is...

2:20:51 What do you mean by sign it appropriately? Just make sure the handicap signs are out there? What's going to happen? For me, it comes down to what I truly needed in here. One day was a van from Bishop, the handicap, to go and tell people, because that really does exist. My car's running. I'm not parked. Ladies and gentlemen, I think we're good. I've got to run. We'll take a break for five minutes. Mayor Pro Tem, Sauser. Yes, well, I haven't banged the gavel in a while. Is that exciting for you? You're supposed to for opening and closing public hearings.

2:23:24 Okie doke. Let's continue on item 9.5. Update and direction to proceed with work program for new town office facility. Dan. Thank you. I'll walk through a little bit of a PowerPoint and kind of walk through some of the items here and some of the information in the staff report.

2:25:39 Finally, more detail on the financial plan here as well. Just a brief overview. We're kind of in this spot of trying to move this forward. Last time we brought the council, there was a direction to continue to move forward, but not at light speed, if you will. So we've done kind of a measured process in terms of getting a project pulled together. The outstanding element for us is we put in a grant for $12.6 million for

2:26:08 Community Resiliency Center, or we'll refer to as a Resiliency Center here in RC, element that would add to what our building does and how it services the community and other elements. We'll speak more detail on that. But the other side of that, because the grant originally was supposed to be done in June and it wasn't, and so we still don't know if we're going to get it or not, so we kind of have a two-path project that we're looking at.

2:26:36 We didn't want to over-design on the front end, but we're also getting to a point, still targeting our current lease expires September of 2025, and we have two one-year options. This is designed to exercise one of those one-year options for a move-in of September 2026. But again, timing and moving forward, we want to give ample time so we're not crowded. And also, because we're looking at two different options and also some longer-term planning,

2:27:06 We've been pretty liberal, if you will, in the cost of the project, pushing that up, not wanting to lowball it, make it look better or not, or have a challenge down the road. So start with that. I'm going to walk through some of this kind of quickly in the layout and touch on a couple of key elements. First one, I think you're all familiar with the site. It's next to the current county admin building along Sierra Nevada Road and the police station, the courts, and what would be the new town.

2:27:34 Town office area that was looked at before. We have some concept renderings. This would be a front look from the parking area there. The challenge on these at this point is we haven't spent a lot of time on the outside of the buildings just yet because we haven't gotten to that level of design. So what does that look like and how do we make sure? It kind of mirrors the other buildings around us as well as a little bit of some uniquenesses for the town. As you'll notice, like, on the entryway, it doesn't say town office here anywhere, so stuff like that.

2:28:03 But again, concept drawings in terms of what it could look like. It's kind of a two-level building, one being a larger single-story and then a two-story element to it. You can kind of get that feel from the back look. And the brown part there being primarily the office area, two floors, and then the community resiliency center and the council chambers, that larger one-story element. So not a lot of, I just want to give you a feel for the layout on here and the massing.

2:28:32 Don't get hung up on looking like a jail. That was my initial perspective. The words right out of my mouth. So anyway, we'll work through that. Then on the inside of the building, we'll look for a couple different things here, as I mentioned. This here is kind of where the council chambers would look. You can see we're trying to design it so it seats approximately 80 people. But it's also a multi-use room for the Resiliency Center.

2:29:00 The blue area there would be the new office side. We haven't gotten to the point where we're laying all the offices out. A little bit in part because we know we're looking at two different sizes potentially as we look at funding. And then just a second story, which would be the office component with kind of looking out in the open to the bottom where the council chambers in the lobby area would be. The other element to this is we look at the grant we put in for the resource center.

2:29:29 Is it different configurations that can happen? And this here shows you the council chambers. If you were to set up tables in there and some of this would be like a, whether it's a event type activity we're doing and or if it's from the operational center for an emergency, this type of facility would have came in really nice in the location here this last winter. So you could actually set up and respond to an emergency element. A lot of the white space and stuff, a lot of things in here related to requirements for your

2:29:58 You know, fire, heating and electrical and all the different back of house stuff you have to have. Here's kind of the concept looking at, you know, if you had a bunch of setup for an operations center. We saw this challenge when we went through COVID and some other emergencies. We don't have a good setup. This last winter, again, we started in the county building and migrated to the Edison Theater with our Cal OES partners having the right facility to run that. The other element of their resource centers here, the...

2:30:28 Resiliency Centers that can be utilized for other purposes. You actually set them up like at the kitchen. There's some elements for that. There's ongoing community services that come out. If you remember a while back, we were working with Inyo County on a Eastern Sierra Small Business Resource Center that they had grant funding to set up in Bishop. They were asking, do we have a location in Mammoth? At the time, the answer was no. It currently still is that we have phase-wise.

2:30:53 Having something like that that could fit into this type of area and actually being a resource and a shared space and that nature, we believe would be a real asset as well, looking at the space and the concepts. This will be a little tough to see, but it's kind of a summary of the information that's in the staff report. Really trying to look at the financial picture. The big issue here is we're making some assumptions on debt and timing on that. These numbers, I will guarantee you, will change.

2:31:22 As interest rates are flexing around a little bit. But the biggest issue on this one, at the end of the day, looking, if we get the grant and look at the funding, it's pretty minimal impacts the general fund operating-wise. It's averaging about $3,500 a year in a 10-year time frame. The 10-year window is really tied to the payoff of the judgment bonds, which are just under $2 million a year.

2:31:49 Once that goes away, you actually cash flow fairly well, and there's additional cash available for other projects. Remind me what year the Judgment Fund has paid off. That was the agreement to pay off the airport. Oh, no, I know. What's the year? It's paid off in 35-36 as the last payment date. It's the debt structure to have two and a half years of capitalized interest because you have no asset to borrow against until it's built.

2:32:15 And so you would start making debt payments in 26, 27. And then for a 10-year period is where you're really subsidizing that out of current, where you're using current general fund revenue to meet the debt payment. Again, if you're doing it with the grant, it's fairly minimal. Without the grant, about $300,000 average over a year. It also assumes wrapping debt around. By that, what I mean, for example,

2:32:46 We have debt on the police station. It'll be paid off in 29, yeah, 2930. It's no longer there. So that debt service would roll into the bonds for this facility, into that debt. And the bond structure, it starts with the lower amount and ratchets up over time in order to accommodate cash flow of existing debt. So the goal here was not to have a significant impact on current operating revenues.

2:33:14 We achieved that, I think, even doing it on our own. That reduces down the size of the building a little bit and those types of elements. But you're looking, I said, on average over that 10-year, paid about $300,000. It would be out of current operating revenue that we'd need to accommodate. There's about $1.1 million in other revenue. Otherwise, over time, we should come into that. And once you pay off the judgment bonds in the next several years, depending on the length of the debt.

2:33:42 Are covered actually by that existing payment. So trying to roll existing debt into new debt and not have much of an impact on operations was the goal here, structuring the debt structure. The other element to it, again, a little bit unknown in the design work, but we need to kind of start moving some of that forward for a timing issue to get into development and design details. And so still trying to walk.

2:34:11 Both realms of that with the resource center as well as the overall facility. We have built in some options. How do we reduce it down should we not have the grant? So it makes the building a little tighter. It's still functional, still works, but it does get a little less convenient, if you will, and a little less expansion. We're also looking at it. Let me stop sharing here. One of the key elements in the discussion before on this was taking a look at

2:34:38 What other agencies have done and some lessons learned. One is don't make it too small. Like some of the office spaces and stuff, talking to other employees and stuff, that's really problematic. Don't engineer out your soundproofing. Especially if you're having confidential conversations, it makes it really difficult. Plan for a beefed up AV IT system. Make sure that's there.

2:35:05 And also just the collaborative space and the number of like conference rooms and spaces where you have teams coming together and working, making sure that's adequate and that you have a very good front-facing element when somebody comes into the facility. There's some high-level takeaways that we've had from other facilities and talking to other agencies that recently built things. And we think we address all those and also the area around the council chamber is kind of a lobby area that is also can be utilized.

2:35:35 Almost like the event we did at the Westin, you could actually do that in this type of facility and actually make it inviting so it doesn't quite feel like suite Z elements that way. So working through that, we have kind of those two different paths at working down the road at the same time. I think it does get us there in a financially, I'll say, conservative approach. The current cost estimates are high on purpose, as I noted. The infrastructure costs.

2:36:04 Plug $4 million in for off-sites and on-site clearing, grubbing, moving massive rocks. We're assuming that. There's a power line that goes to the site. We don't know if we'll have to pay to fully underground the whole thing or not. That can be anywhere from $300,000 to $1 million, depending on how much we have to do. Looking at do we add some additional parking, bus stops, shelters, those types of elements. So that design level still is not here yet. But we do want to continue to move it forward. We're hoping to hear on the grant this month.

2:36:34 Update was summer. So we're hoping to hear from that. But beginning that design to continue to move it forward, starting to look at some of the office layout and how that works. Again, kind of with a two-option element. Here's what, if we can do a 15,000 square foot building, here we go. If we have to shrink it down, here's what it looks like. And the total space is similar to what we've been leasing here. Figured differently. It works better, frankly. But it's not.

2:37:02 About the same space that we're in today in terms of square footage, but it actually lays out for the expansion and alternative working styles and stuff that we can work into that as well. So a lot of different elements there. Again, wanted to come back, give the update before we go spend more money on design. Are we on the right track? And see where that falls into. So glad to answer any questions, any other discussion from the staff report and where we're headed with this at this point in time and if we're still on the right course from Council's perspective.

2:37:31 Okay, any questions? No questions. Okay. The lessons learned, you know, it sounds a lot, an awful lot of what I'm hearing from some of the folks over at Mammoth County. And I think it would be useful at some point to really summarize those in kind of a written form. Yeah, we've listed a few of those out in the staff before, but we're also looking at snow management, those types of issues as well at the outside.

2:38:05 Don't put some of your infrastructure where there's no sheds on it. Basic things. Backup power is important. Just go ahead. So just so I'm clear, because the restructuring the debt, I just want to make sure I really get this. So you're going to restructure the police department debt, restructure the judgment debt, and then you'll have some funds from those debts, Rob's listening intently, that you will use to finance this. And then when those are retired, that

2:38:38 Funding, does that go back into the general fund, or is that necessary to use to finance this project? Yeah, so ultimately you have a 10-year window there where you still have to pay off the PD debt. When that's paid off, that freed up dollars, $315,000, then we go to pay this debt for another period of time. At the end of the 10-year financing period, you would end up between the judgment bonds, which call that $2 million, plus our lease payment here.

2:39:09 And if you want to pay a little less on an annual basis, more interest, but payment down a little bit.

2:39:43 All of the existing revenue we have in that other debt structure, the internal loan we've had, the PD debt, the judgment bond, all rolled into funding. And then the judgment bond, when that's paid off in 30 to 36, would continue to fund this payment for another period of time, another six or seven years, years to actually fully pay off the building. And we also built in some savings that would be coming out of our CAM charges for this facility. We set those aside and said we need to continue.

2:40:19 Thank you. The only thing I wanted to point out is in Dan's breakdown, what we're currently paying in rent is shown as $3.75 all the way through, and actually that is likely to increase by about 5% a year. So if you want to do your own more true look at what it would cost to stay here. Yeah, definitely it would cost more to stay here from that. That would ratchet up over time. Based on the last...

2:40:59 The discussion direction was to look at moving. So I just kept that flat on purpose as a debt service payment and then instead of having more general fund money going into operations necessarily. In my opinion is we need to keep moving this thing forward. The owners here and the way we are set up here is just an untenable situation into the future. So we have to be looking at a solution. I guess my only question is

2:41:32 Bill, I know, I agree with you that we, I think that it's a good plan to build these, build a property for the town. I think that, you know, I think this is the only town that I've been to whose offices are, you know, not in a building that the town owns. I don't know, that the town owns. My only thought is, I feel like there are two different designs going on. You know, is it beneficial to wait a month until we hear, did we get the,

2:42:03 12.5 million dollar grant, or is it, I mean, do you want to keep proceeding with two separate plans, or that, just to me, that seems a little confusing, and I don't know if that's, if it's going to cost us more in the end, or if we'll get everything done more timely if we start now. The time factors we're looking at, we can continue some of the design work, and we know we can build in some factors and say, if you don't get it, we want to reduce the footprint, that, to actually have them design accordingly to do that, we know which pieces would come out.

2:42:33 We would probably do a little less design work on the addition that the grant would be funding fully. We have the conceptual design there so we know what the footprint looks like. The recommendation would be if we don't get the grant, we would still want to design the building so in the future that expansion could be done, but not funded at this point in time. So you'd actually have an expansion plan for the same issues that are here or for other needs of the town.

2:43:05 But we wouldn't spend as much money on the details in that. And so we would back down a little bit. And again, it'll take time to ratchet up and get the architects going again and doing some internal work in terms of the space allocations and those types of elements. And again, we should hear it could be any time. We just, it's been a little frustrating. June deadline got moved to summer and it hasn't changed. I don't know if the state agents are actual. So it sounds like we are all waiting to hear.

2:43:41 Yeah, that's a concern, but some of this work, if we can continue some of it going, it helps us refine some cost projections out, though. Yeah, and then I guess my only other last thought was, I know you mentioned some things that the county wishes that they did differently, or any other people building? Others, too. Yes, others, too. One thing that I've noticed about new buildings in town, you know, if they have a big open room with a...

2:44:10 Very high ceiling is you kind of lost some potential extra floor space in having that high ceiling. So I don't know. Yeah, we looked at that on the council side of not wanting, we don't need that whole building. And so we did look at the council, but we did have that and we wouldn't recommend a space, I'll say at least today and looking forward. We had a pretty good discussion over what that was. I think it'd be helpful also to look at the lessons learned that were positive. Yeah. I've heard good things about the Inyo County building.

2:45:17 I mean, it may not look very good, but people seem to think it works. But I think it would be really helpful for all of us to get, if we get to a point where we're moving forward, it's a pretty definitive sense of a checklist of things we should do. Yeah, because there was some positive. And even some of the county stuff, some of that, there's some elements in there that are just, and part of that, I think, is that I think both of them ended up building to a budget that was artificially low on the front end. Do you have what you need? I'm hearing the general consensus is to continue to move forward. We'll refine some of this back out as well.

2:46:04 There's a lot of things moving around. I want to give you an update, though, and that's funded at this point. Again, it's still a measured approach. All right, well, let's move on then to the approval of local agency collaboration agreement for implementation of the California radio interoperable system, the CRIS system, trunk radio service of monocamera. Again, this has been a several-year process working in updating the radio system here, the public safety radio systems. We do have a path forward working with the various agencies.

2:47:06 Joining into the trunk system with the state. The original plan we looked at starting with this about three or four years ago was about a $14 million plus project funded primarily by the town in Monroe County. It's turning into a much lower cost component. And we earmark, frankly, the county is able to secure to help do sites, to build updates, help. And mainly for us, what we'd be purchasing at this, the radios and some additional support service areas.

2:47:43 Their dollars would be building out the sites. They're structured to be the lead agency with the state. We have a proposed agreement that has come through the county, putting it together to have a paying for our fair share of radios. And I think it's a good path forward in terms of getting a system that actually the county. Also the maintenance of the radios on us, but the system is on the state. There is a subscriber fee that's reduced over several years because the recommendations and the staff report.

2:48:40 Also making sure we have a replacement set up for the radio going forward so we're not. The request tonight would be to the agreement as presented. Any questions for Dan? Any public comment on this? Okay. The comment is compared to what would. Yeah, I would just add, you know, thank you, Dan, for your persistence in chasing down the various options but eventually getting to something. Okay, with that, I would entertain a motion. I would make a motion to California Radio Interoperable System, Chris, Radio Service in Monaco County and Authority.

2:50:25 The Mayor to sign the agreement. I'll second. Authorize. Second. Thank you. Amanda? Jamie? Councilmember Bubzer? Yes. Councilmember Rae? Councilmember Rice? Yes. Mayor Pro Temp Souser? Yes. Mayor Wentworth? Yes. Thank you. Thank you, Dan. Again, that was a long, long effort, but thank you very much. Okay, moving on now to our final policy matter, TOT Enforcement Update, Quarter 3 and Form, Fiscal Year 22, 23, Mr. Patterson.

2:50:58 Thank you, Mayor Wentworth. Trying to get this stood up here the right way. Hold just one second. So yeah, so I wanted to give you guys an update on our enforcement activities for third and fourth quarter. We're kind of stretching these out a little bit and having them, instead of quarterly, we're starting to have them twice a year. The bulk of it, as you know, we've got a pretty well-developed program with regard to managing

2:51:29 You know, the enforcement of short-term rentals. I heard some comments earlier tonight. We've got more work to do with regard to bringing forward policy items for certain. I'm clear on that. But we have a pretty well-defined enforcement process. So the updates are not too much more changing in this realm, if you will. Right now, we're focused on

2:51:56 Getting our certified properties functionality developed. That's sort of a scratch bill program. So Rentalscape or Decker Technologies, their product is called Rentalscape. Decker Technologies is our partner in this process. They're building it from the ground up. It's taking a whole heck of a lot longer than I anticipated. But the team's working on that pretty, pretty closely, almost on a daily basis with what we need.

2:52:24 Our expectations versus what's capable of being performed, but the team is doing a good job of providing feedback to them on the work efforts that they're putting together. This certified properties program will be a fairly significant change for our short-term rental activity within the town. It will provide us with a direct sort of relationship with the owner of the property versus maybe a property management company.

2:52:52 But it'll also give us quite a bit more teeth in the process here. We are working on collecting, part of that process will be collecting data electronically from our remitters and a much more robust data set as far as activity. So we do like data and it provides us with what's happening in this particular business space. So this process will enhance that quite a bit. So we're still developing.

2:53:20 And building those processes. With regard to our assessment process, we did make an adjustment this year, and it's based on technology. In the past, when we've had to do an assessment on a particular individual, we utilize an algorithm of nightly rental activity that sort of mimics what goes on at a busy hotel.

2:53:44 We use the nightly rate for the particular advertisement, and that's what we utilize for a three-year process. We do that to determine an assessment. Now with the Rentalscape product, we're able to, if we go deeper into a particular case, we can change that to look at specifically what Rentalscape has recorded as the activity for that unit and get that narrowed down to a more

2:54:13 I'll say a more accurate assessment of the activity when we get to the point at the end where we're sort of assigning someone either a certification of judgment, which is a lien, or if we're getting close to a town council hearing. We had one recently, and that's the adjustments that we've made between the time we first assessed it and then what we narrowed it down to what we believe was actual activity.

2:54:40 So that's kind of a cool enhancement for the product, and I think it helps, at least it helps me stand on something I feel is more accurate to the activity that has occurred. Audit refinements that we worked on, we talked a little bit about this, and some of this may be an update that you guys have heard before because we talked about it at the housing meeting that we had recently. But with the audit refinements, you know, we really have the ability to compare what

2:55:08 Rentalscape has estimated for a particular remitter versus what they put on their tax return. And so that comparison allows us to say who may be underreporting their information. And then that will get you a quick audit. So we're turning the corner on that fairly quickly so we can start more audits. And we do really a quick audit. It's a look out there and saying, hey, show me the last two months of your activity, your actual activity.

2:55:36 And the reporting that you utilize to provide that. And then we will determine if anything's happening in there that shouldn't be, meaning they're underreporting or they're making some mistakes. A lot of our audit processes are around educational elements where people are just not calculating it correctly or they're excluding some data that they shouldn't be. But if we've determined that they're doing something that they shouldn't be.

2:56:00 We will do a larger three-year audit. So it's really trying to get as many people with a quick look as possible, but that's the audit program enhancements. But we also have recently, at least in this last period of updates, has made those adjustments allowed by the state of California to our citation program. Our citation program is a very robust approach to solving a problem when someone's doing...

2:56:30 And then we've been reaching out and kind of working with several HOAs regarding

2:57:00 You know, problems that they may be having specific to their complexes. And we've gone out, sat down with them, talked about, you know, the town's processes, what can be done, what cannot be done. A lot of it is dependent upon them, and some HOAs are doing an excellent job of managing the activities of their area, but we're providing that service to help them understand at least the rules.

2:57:28 With regard to the activity, I kind of show this on a regular basis. We're trying to edit it just a little bit to make it more relevant, but we are showing the activity for the last half of the year as well as the fiscal year and just how we open our enforcement cases. We had a total of 58 cases for the year, and those would be full-blown open the case.

2:57:57 And again, it translates to longer-term elements. As we catch someone, especially if they are a revenue enforcement case where they could be legally renting and they decide to go out and rent legally, we do see increased TOT across years as we

2:58:27 Are now collecting those revenues as well. You'll see the certifications of judgment. That's a fancy term for liens. So those would be out there as liens on the property waiting for collection to occur. Give you a sense, and again, you saw this at the housing summit, the enforcement cases per year. This is fairly an average year as far as the number of cases opened.

2:58:51 And the activity, that little downturn that you see back in 2021 really probably associated with how busy we were and our ability to, with regard to health orders and other things like that, our ability to go out and do enforcement. But revenue-wise, you know, second to only to 2018 as far as activity that we have going on. And I think there was a large judgment during that period of time.

2:59:19 The current focus, again, I talked about implementation of the certified properties. That's most critical to us. We've got some deadlines approaching us as we get towards the winter months where the activity does increase. We don't like to be changing processes, especially when we're talking about something of the significance of certified properties. But we do want to get that done before we enter the winter of this year. The electronic tax return submittal process, which is...

2:59:47 What's turning out to be the most problematic of our updated processes will be in place by January, one way or the other. So we're just trying to make sure we get that done. We do have a significant amount of municipal code updates that we need to make in order to implement the certified properties. Everything now in our municipal code references TOT certificates, and those would need to change to certified property language. So we're working on that.

3:00:15 And then continuing our work with HOAs and trying to help them sort of address challenges they're having within their individual complexes and really educating them, but also helping them maybe develop some better processes for managing problematic people within their areas. So I'll take that off and ask for any questions. Okay, any questions for Rob?

3:00:47 Rob, the gentleman that was with us at our last meeting, how's the follow-up going with that? Yeah, so we submitted a series of questions to him just earlier this week, I think on Monday, we submitted those questions to him. We're looking for a lot of detail around some of the areas he was bringing up to you all for the defense, which would be...

3:01:14 His utility bills, things like that that may represent that. So we have a whole list of things we wanted from him. We have yet to hear a response from that. We did talk to the PD. The person that he spoke with was our records supervisor, and she has provided us a statement on that. We're collecting it all as evidence. It appears that it's a little bit different than he presented, but what I'm going to do is bring back to you a staff report that shows

3:01:44 An outline of all of the elements that they specifically requested or he specifically brought up and then how we've now gone out and got additional information on that. So nothing is showing that we're off point with having an enforcement case against this respondent, but we haven't got to the point where we have much information back from him. Oh, that's fine. Good. Thank you. Yeah. Any other questions? No, Rob. Just to follow up on your comment at the beginning, I think you're sort of hinting at the policy issues.

3:02:14 I just come back to the fact we've got a great enforcement program, we've got a quality of life ordinance, but now we've got to take that big leap into this program, how it relates to housing writ large, and what kinds of policy measures we need to put in place along the lines of the kinds of things that Truckee's been doing and others, and how do we move that thing forward. So looking forward to that. Thank you. Okay, so that concludes our regular policy matters for the evening.

3:02:43 And we're going to move on now to Councilmember Reports. Chris, let's start with you. I just want to thank Pam and Jamie for organizing the training trip. It's the Pathways to Success. They invited me to go along because they could use a trolley. And it was, I learned a lot. And I recommend if they do it again, even though we know what's happening in town and we know what all the facilities are, seeing it,

3:03:15 You know, with our staff and getting to spend more time with them. And then also seeing the results of the impacts of the things we vote on here, like real time was super helpful. Thanks. Awesome. Amanda? Yeah, I guess I don't really have anything to report. Sarah? No report. No? So I attended on Monday the LTC meeting. Almost missed it because I forgot I had it. I haven't talked about many things. Caltrans update on the road work.

3:03:54 In all the various areas, and of course you can go on their website and see exactly what that is. Talked about, Esther, Phil, in his report talked about how the numbers look skewed, but they look skewed like we went way down this year because last year we had June in reds and this year we didn't. So there's like 18,000 less riders because of that. Met with the Mammoth Trails Committee. A lot of our focus was on what the...

3:04:22 Office of Outdoor Recreation is doing, how we're moving forward or not with our Forest Service partners, a good meeting and how we are one committee member short and looking for someone else to join that group. Also on Saturday, I attended for 20 years in a row the Cancer Outreach Golf Tournament and I got to see our own Sarah Ray take her first ever golf shot. That's true.

3:04:54 And as per her bet with the local, she hid it from where she was past the red tees, so he paid off. It was an interesting watch. It was Grady. It was Grady, yeah. And I think that's about it, unless I missed something important on LTC or trails. I'm sorry, I missed the LTC meeting. I had some things going on. I attended the surf.

3:05:28 Project Recommendation Body High Road Transition Council Meeting. Interesting. Things are still quite chaotic. It's quite chaotic from the state. The state's moving money around, moving the goalposts around. We'll see what happens. I'll have something maybe more substantial to report down the road. But that's all I've got. We do have an ESCOG meeting coming up tomorrow. It should be interesting.

3:05:56 Okay, so with that, we are going to move into closed session. This is item 11.1, Conference with Legal Counsel, Anticipated Litigation, Significant Exposure to Litigation Pursuant to Paragraph 2 of Subdivision D of Section 54956.91 case, and then we will report out if there is any reportable action. And with that, thank you all for attending this evening.

3:06:25 And we'll let you know if anything comes out of the closed session. So, we're adjourned. Are we adjourned? We're not. We're not adjourned. We're recessed. Recessed. What are we? We're adjourning into closed session. Thank you. Okay. I'm assuming we're going to have the closed session right here.