TransparentMammoth

Topics / Budget

Account

Garage-ESTA (910-000-31922)

The Town's FY2026-27 adopted budget for the Garage-ESTA revenue account (910-000-31922) is $1,000,000, which by our calculation is $100,000 (+11.1%) above the FY2025-26 adopted budget of $900,000 [1] Budget line item detail.pdf, p. 58[2] Agenda (PDF), p. 306[3] Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 56. The approved budget was $810,000 in FY2022-23, FY2023-24 and FY2024-25 [4] Final Budget Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 56[5] Agenda (PDF), p. 388[3] Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 56. Town payment approval reports from 2018 to 2022 list invoice lines from state tax agencies posted to this account, and the ESTA Garage expense budget was $225,000 in FY2017-18 through FY2021-22 [6] Payment Approval Report 19-22, p. 4[7] Payment Approval Report No. 23-04.pdf, p. 8[8] Full Budget - FY2017-18, p. 68[9] 2021-2022 Budget Book, p. 193.

Updated

Findings

6 findings

  1. 1 The FY2026-27 adopted budget for Garage-ESTA revenue is $1,000,000, up from $900,000

    Updated

    The budget line item detail filed with the June 17, 2026 meeting lists Garage-ESTA revenue at $1,000,000 under "Adopted Budget 26-27" and $900,000 under both "Approved Budget 25-26" and "Modified Budget 25-26" [1] Budget line item detail.pdf, p. 58. The 2026 agenda packet worksheet in the same meeting packet lists account 910-000-31922 Garage-ESTA with the same three figures [2] Agenda (PDF), p. 306. By our calculation, the FY2026-27 adopted budget is $100,000 (+11.1%) above the FY2025-26 adopted budget of $900,000 [3] Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 56[1] Budget line item detail.pdf, p. 58.

    The June 2025 line item detail lists Garage-ESTA at $810,000 for both the approved and modified FY2024-25 budgets and $900,000 for the adopted FY2025-26 budget [3] Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 56[4] Agenda (PDF), p. 235. By our calculation, that is a change of +$90,000 (+11.1%) [3] Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 56.

    The FY2022-23 council approved budget was $810,000 [5] Final Budget Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 56. The FY2023-24 approved budget was $810,000 [6] Agenda (PDF), p. 388[7] 2023-2024 Budget Book, p. 194.

    Why it matters

    The Town's budget documents show the Garage-ESTA revenue budget at $810,000 for three straight fiscal years (FY2022-23 to FY2024-25), then $900,000, then $1,000,000 [5] Final Budget Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 56[6] Agenda (PDF), p. 388[3] Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 56[1] Budget line item detail.pdf, p. 58.

    Sources

    1. Budget line item detail.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 58

    2. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 306

    3. Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 56

    4. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 235

    5. Final Budget Line Item Detail.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 56

    6. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 388

    7. 2023-2024 Budget Book

      financialfiscal year from document title Document date (fiscal year from document title) p. 194

  2. 2 The approved Garage-ESTA revenue budget rose from $507,476 in FY2021-22 to $810,000 in FY2022-23

    Updated

    A current-year budget column in a document filed with the March 2, 2016 meeting lists Garage-ESTA at $483,788 for FY2015-16 [1] Attachment to Agenda Item 10, p. 31. The approved budget for FY2017-18 was $535,184 [2] Tentative Budget - Fund 910 - Garage Services.pdf, p. 1. The approved budgets for FY2018-19 and FY2019-20 were each $544,835 [3] 2019-20 Budget, p. 115. The council approved budget for FY2020-21 was $507,476 [4] 2020-2021 Council Adopted Budget, p. 95. The approved FY2021-22 budget was $507,476 [5] Final Budget Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 56. The council approved budget for FY2022-23 was $810,000 [5] Final Budget Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 56.

    By our calculation, the approved budget changed by +$9,651 (+1.8%) from FY2017-18 to FY2018-19 [2] Tentative Budget - Fund 910 - Garage Services.pdf, p. 1[3] 2019-20 Budget, p. 115. It changed by -$37,359 (-6.9%) from FY2019-20 to FY2020-21 [3] 2019-20 Budget, p. 115[4] 2020-2021 Council Adopted Budget, p. 95. It was unchanged from FY2020-21 to FY2021-22 [4] 2020-2021 Council Adopted Budget, p. 95[5] Final Budget Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 56. It changed by +$302,524 (+59.6%) from FY2021-22 to FY2022-23 [5] Final Budget Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 56.

    By our calculation, the FY2025-26 adopted budget of $900,000 is $416,212 (+86.0%) above the $483,788 FY2015-16 budget figure [6] Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 56[1] Attachment to Agenda Item 10, p. 31.

    Why it matters

    The largest single-year change in the approved budget shown in these records is the +$302,524 (+59.6%, by our calculation) between FY2021-22 and FY2022-23 [5] Final Budget Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 56.

    Sources

    1. Attachment to Agenda Item 10

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 31

    2. Tentative Budget - Fund 910 - Garage Services.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 1

    3. 2019-20 Budget

      financialfiscal year from document title Document date (fiscal year from document title) p. 115

    4. 2020-2021 Council Adopted Budget

      financialfiscal year from document title Document date (fiscal year from document title) p. 95

    5. Final Budget Line Item Detail.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 56

    6. Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 56

  3. 3 Garage-ESTA actual revenue was $897,854 in FY2022-23, after falling to $364,301 in FY2020-21

    Updated

    Budget documents list actual Garage-ESTA revenue of $408,890 for FY2015-16 [1] Tentative Budget - Fund 910 - Garage Services.pdf, p. 1.

    The approved budget for FY2022-23 was $810,000, so by our calculation FY2022-23 actual revenue was $87,854 (+10.8%) above it [2] Final Budget Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 56[3] 2023-2024 Budget Book, p. 194.

    Why it matters

    These are the actual revenue figures the Town's budget documents report for the account, set beside the approved budgets above [4] 2020-2021 Council Adopted Budget, p. 95[2] Final Budget Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 56[3] 2023-2024 Budget Book, p. 194.

    Sources

    1. Tentative Budget - Fund 910 - Garage Services.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 1

    2. Final Budget Line Item Detail.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 56

    3. 2023-2024 Budget Book

      financialfiscal year from document title Document date (fiscal year from document title) p. 194

    4. 2020-2021 Council Adopted Budget

      financialfiscal year from document title Document date (fiscal year from document title) p. 95

  4. 4 Budget packets filed in June 2025 and June 2026 give different actual figures for FY2023-24 and FY2024-25

    Updated

    The June 18, 2025 agenda packet lists Garage-ESTA at $897,854, $577,098 and $495,672 under those headings [1] Agenda (PDF), p. 235. The same columns appear in the June 2025 line item detail without year labels [2] Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 56.

    The June 2026 line item detail shows the same three figures [3] Budget line item detail.pdf, p. 58.

    The records do not say why, and we have not reconciled them [1] Agenda (PDF), p. 235[4] Agenda (PDF), p. 306.

    Why it matters

    A reader comparing FY2024-25 actual revenue for this account will find different figures depending on which packet is used [1] Agenda (PDF), p. 235[4] Agenda (PDF), p. 306.

    Sources

    1. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 235

    2. Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 56

    3. Budget line item detail.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 58

    4. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 306

  5. 5 Town payment approval reports list tax-agency invoice lines posted to the Garage-ESTA account, from $85.32 to $1,349.35

    Updated

    Report 19-22: $129.70, invoice date 10/25/2018, description "JULY-SEPT" [1] Payment Approval Report 19-22, p. 4. Report 19-32: $104.75, invoice date 01/17/2019, description "OCT-DEC 2018" [2] Payment Approval Report 19-32, p. 8. Report 19-45: $177.79, invoice date 04/16/2019, description "JAN-MARCH" [3] Payment Approval Report 19-45, p. 2. Report 19-64: $85.32, invoice date 06/30/2019, description "APRIL-JUNE" [4] Payment Approval Report 19-64, p. 1. Report 20-19: $111.84, invoice date 10/14/2020, description "JULY-SEPT" [5] Payment Approval Report No. 20-19, p. 2. Report 21-32: $118.23, invoice date 12/01/2020, description "OCT-DEC 2020" [6] Payment Approval Report No. 21-32, p. 2. Report 21-58: $97.34, invoice date 06/30/2021, description "APRIL-JUNE" [7] Payment Approval Report No. 21-58.pdf, p. 1.

    Report 22-17: $1,087.28, invoice date 10/13/2021, description "JULY-SEPT" [8] Payment Approval Report No. 22-17.pdf, p. 3. Report 22-30: $889.42, invoice date 01/20/2022, description "OCT-DEC 2021" [9] Payment Approval Report No. 22-30.pdf, p. 2. Report 22-44: $1,349.35, invoice date 04/25/2022, description "JAN-MARCH" [10] Payment Approval Report No. 22-44.pdf, p. 2. Report 23-04: $1,029.63, invoice date 06/30/2022, description "APRIL-JUNE" [11] Payment Approval Report No. 23-04.pdf, p. 8.

    The criteria on reports 19-64 and 21-58 state that only unpaid invoices are included [4] Payment Approval Report 19-64, p. 1[7] Payment Approval Report No. 21-58.pdf, p. 1. The pages shown for the other reports do not display that criterion, so their paid status is not established here [1] Payment Approval Report 19-22, p. 4[2] Payment Approval Report 19-32, p. 8[3] Payment Approval Report 19-45, p. 2[5] Payment Approval Report No. 20-19, p. 2[6] Payment Approval Report No. 21-32, p. 2[8] Payment Approval Report No. 22-17.pdf, p. 3[9] Payment Approval Report No. 22-30.pdf, p. 2[10] Payment Approval Report No. 22-44.pdf, p. 2[11] Payment Approval Report No. 23-04.pdf, p. 8.

    Why it matters

    These reports show the Town's own payment records tying state tax-agency invoices to the Garage-ESTA account over several years, with the listed amounts rising from under $200 in 2018-2021 to over $800 in the 2021-22 reports [1] Payment Approval Report 19-22, p. 4[7] Payment Approval Report No. 21-58.pdf, p. 1[8] Payment Approval Report No. 22-17.pdf, p. 3[9] Payment Approval Report No. 22-30.pdf, p. 2[10] Payment Approval Report No. 22-44.pdf, p. 2.

    Sources

    1. Payment Approval Report 19-22

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 4

    2. Payment Approval Report 19-32

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 8

    3. Payment Approval Report 19-45

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 2

    4. Payment Approval Report 19-64

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 1

    5. Payment Approval Report No. 20-19

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 2

    6. Payment Approval Report No. 21-32

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 2

    7. Payment Approval Report No. 21-58.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 1

    8. Payment Approval Report No. 22-17.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 3

    9. Payment Approval Report No. 22-30.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 2

    10. Payment Approval Report No. 22-44.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 2

    11. Payment Approval Report No. 23-04.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 8

  6. 6 The ESTA Garage expense budget was $225,000 in each year from FY2017-18 to FY2021-22

    Updated

    The FY2017-18 budget for Total ESTA Garage was $225,000, made up of $150,000 and $75,000 for Vehicle Maintenance Parts [1] Full Budget - FY2017-18, p. 68. The FY2020-21 adopted budget lists $225,000 in total and $75,000 for Vehicle Maintenance Parts [2] 2020-2021 Budget Book, p. 200. The FY2021-22 adopted budget lists $225,000 [3] 2021-2022 Budget Book, p. 193.

    The first line's label does not appear on the page, and no total row appears there [4] 2024-2025 Budget Book, p. 215.

    Why it matters

    These records show the ESTA Garage expense budget at $225,000 for five fiscal years, with actual FY2018-19 expenses above that figure [1] Full Budget - FY2017-18, p. 68[5] 2019-2020 Council Adopted Budget, p. 193[2] 2020-2021 Budget Book, p. 200[3] 2021-2022 Budget Book, p. 193[6] 2019-2020 Budget Book, p. 193.

    Sources

    1. Full Budget - FY2017-18

      financialfiscal year from document title Document date (fiscal year from document title) p. 68

    2. 2020-2021 Budget Book

      financialfiscal year from document title Document date (fiscal year from document title) p. 200

    3. 2021-2022 Budget Book

      financialfiscal year from document title Document date (fiscal year from document title) p. 193

    4. 2024-2025 Budget Book

      financialfiscal year from document title Document date (fiscal year from document title) p. 215

    5. 2019-2020 Council Adopted Budget

      financialfiscal year from document title Document date (fiscal year from document title) p. 193

    6. 2019-2020 Budget Book

      financialfiscal year from document title Document date (fiscal year from document title) p. 193