TransparentMammoth

Topics / Budget

Capital project

Mammoth Creek Park West Improvements (CIP PR14)

The FY25-26 Final Budget document filed with the June 18, 2025 meeting lists a Total Budget FY25-26 of $850,000 for Mammoth Creek Park West Improvements (PR14) [1] FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf, p. 34. The FY24-25 budget text for the same project listed $500,000, so by our calculation the figure rose by $350,000 (+70.0%) [2] Agenda (PDF), p. 287[1] FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf, p. 34. The FY25-26 Final Budget also says $350,000 in Measure R funding was set aside in April 2025 and that MLR provided funding for the climbing boulder [3] FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf, p. 38. The same text says the park area would be constructed over the summer of 2025 [1] FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf, p. 34. The records reviewed do not show whether that construction took place [1] FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf, p. 34.

Updated

Findings

7 findings

  1. 1 The FY25-26 Final Budget lists $850,000 for PR14, up from $500,000 in the FY24-25 budget text

    Updated

    The FY25-26 Final Budget document filed with the June 18, 2025 meeting ends its Mammoth Creek Park West Improvements (PR14) entry with "Total Budget FY25-26 $850,000" [1] FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf, p. 34[2] FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf, p. 38. The same entry appears in the June 18, 2025 agenda packet and in the Restricted Revenue capital and Housing fy25-26 document filed with the May 21, 2025 meeting [3] Agenda (PDF), p. 109[4] Restricted Revenue capital and Housing fy25-26.pdf, p. 7. The 25/26 5 year CIP table in the September 3, 2025 agenda packet lists PR14 Mammoth Creek West Park Improvements at $850,000 [5] Agenda (PDF), p. 114.

    The FY24-25 Final Budget pages filed with the June 19, 2024 meeting list "Total Budget FY24-25: $500,000" for Mammoth Creek Park West Improvements [6] Agenda (PDF), p. 287[7] Final Budget Adoption FY24-25.pdf, p. 45.1. The 2024-2025 Budget Book and a copy of the text in the December 4, 2024 agenda packet show the same $500,000 [8] 2024-2025 Budget Book, p. 163.1[9] Agenda (PDF), p. 201. The 24/25 5 year CIP table in the August 7, 2024 agenda packet lists PR14 at $500,000 [10] Agenda (PDF), p. 68. By our calculation, the budget figure rose by $350,000 (+70.0%) between FY2024-25 and FY2025-26 [6] Agenda (PDF), p. 287[1] FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf, p. 34.

    Why it matters

    They are budget figures, not spending [1] FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf, p. 34[6] Agenda (PDF), p. 287.

    Sources

    1. FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 34

    2. FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 38

    3. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 109

    4. Restricted Revenue capital and Housing fy25-26.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 7

    5. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 114

    6. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 287

    7. Final Budget Adoption FY24-25.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 45.1

    8. 2024-2025 Budget Book

      financialfiscal year from document title Document date (fiscal year from document title) p. 163.1

    9. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 201

    10. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 68

  2. 2 $350,000 in Measure R funding was set aside in April 2025; a September 2025 table splits $850,000 into $500,000 General Fund and $350,000 M-R

    Updated

    The FY25-26 Final Budget entry states: "In April 2025 $350,000 in Measure R funding was set aside for this project" [1] FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf, p. 34[2] FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf, p. 38. The same sentence appears in the June 18, 2025 agenda packet and in the Restricted Revenue capital and Housing fy25-26 document filed with the May 21, 2025 meeting [3] Agenda (PDF), p. 109[4] Restricted Revenue capital and Housing fy25-26.pdf, p. 7.

    The Table 1 - CIP Budget Outlook for 24-25 Carry Over lists PR14 Mammoth Creek West Park Improvements (phase CON) with Totals of $850,000: $500,000 under "TOML - GF Committed" and $350,000 under "M - R" [5] Table 1 - CIP Budget Outlook for 24-25 Carry Over.pdf, p. 1[6] Agenda (PDF), p. 111.

    The earlier "CIP Budget Outlook for 23/24 Carry Over to 24/25" table, filed with the August 7, 2024 meeting, lists PR14 at $500,000, all under "TOML - GF Committed" [7] Table 1 - CIP Budget Outlook for 23-24 Carry Over .pdf, p. 1. The 2024-2025 Budget Book also lists PR14 at $500,000 [8] 2024-2025 Budget Book, p. 161. A "2024/25 & 2025/26 Carry-Over CIP Projects" list in the December 18, 2024 agenda packet shows PR14 (CON) at $500,000 [9] Agenda (PDF), p. 145. A "2025 Summer Carry-over Capital Projects" slide filed with the January 6, 2025 meeting shows the same $500,000 [10] Attachment 5.1.1 - CRC Update_MLT Board Presentation_1-6-2025.pdf, p. 30.

    The $350,000 gap between the $500,000 and $850,000 figures equals the Measure R amount [1] FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf, p. 34[5] Table 1 - CIP Budget Outlook for 24-25 Carry Over.pdf, p. 1. This is consistent with the Measure R set-aside accounting for the increase, though the pages do not say so directly [1] FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf, p. 34[5] Table 1 - CIP Budget Outlook for 24-25 Carry Over.pdf, p. 1.

    Why it matters

    The records show the project's carry-over funding going from $500,000 in one funding category to $850,000 across two categories [7] Table 1 - CIP Budget Outlook for 23-24 Carry Over .pdf, p. 1[5] Table 1 - CIP Budget Outlook for 24-25 Carry Over.pdf, p. 1. The second category is labeled "M - R" in the Town's table [7] Table 1 - CIP Budget Outlook for 23-24 Carry Over .pdf, p. 1[5] Table 1 - CIP Budget Outlook for 24-25 Carry Over.pdf, p. 1.

    Sources

    1. FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 34

    2. FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 38

    3. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 109

    4. Restricted Revenue capital and Housing fy25-26.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 7

    5. Table 1 - CIP Budget Outlook for 24-25 Carry Over.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 1

    6. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 111

    7. Table 1 - CIP Budget Outlook for 23-24 Carry Over .pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 1

    8. 2024-2025 Budget Book

      financialfiscal year from document title Document date (fiscal year from document title) p. 161

    9. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 145

    10. Attachment 5.1.1 - CRC Update_MLT Board Presentation_1-6-2025.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 30

  3. 3 For 2025 the budget text lists shade structures and a bouldering park with fall protection, with construction planned for summer 2025

    Updated

    The FY25-26 Final Budget entry says: "Improvements for 2025 include shade structures and bouldering park with fall protection [1] FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf, p. 38[2] FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf, p. 34. The park area will be constructed over the summer of 2025" [1] FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf, p. 38[2] FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf, p. 34. The same text appears in the June 18, 2025 agenda packet and in the Restricted Revenue capital and Housing fy25-26 document [3] Agenda (PDF), p. 109[4] Restricted Revenue capital and Housing fy25-26.pdf, p. 7. Under the heading "2025 Streetscape and Infrastructure Repair Project (SS5)", the FY25-26 Final Budget lists "Concrete foundations at Mammoth Creek Park for the new climbing boulder and shade structures" [2] FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf, p. 34. The FY25-26 entry for PR14 does not mention the pavilion, grass replacement or screening landscaping that the FY24-25 text listed [2] FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf, p. 34[5] Agenda (PDF), p. 287.

    The entry gives the purpose as follows: "To complement all the improvements made at the Community Recreation Center (CRC) the Town Council allocated funding to improve the park space east of the playground" [1] FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf, p. 38.

    Why it matters

    The budget text states a plan for summer 2025, and the records reviewed do not show whether the work was completed [2] FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf, p. 34.

    Sources

    1. FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 38

    2. FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 34

    3. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 109

    4. Restricted Revenue capital and Housing fy25-26.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 7

    5. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 287

  4. 4 The FY25-26 budget text says MLR provided funding to construct the climbing boulder

    Updated

    The FY25-26 Final Budget entry states: "MLR provided funding to construct the climbing boulder" [1] FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf, p. 38. The same sentence appears in the June 18, 2025 agenda packet and in the Restricted Revenue capital and Housing fy25-26 document [2] Agenda (PDF), p. 109[3] Restricted Revenue capital and Housing fy25-26.pdf, p. 7. The cited pages do not give an MLR dollar amount and do not spell out "MLR" [1] FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf, p. 38.

    Why it matters

    The cited pages also do not say whether the boulder was built [1] FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf, p. 38.

    Sources

    1. FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 38

    2. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 109

    3. Restricted Revenue capital and Housing fy25-26.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 7

  5. 5 The FY24-25 plan for the park listed a pavilion, new grass with irrigation, screening landscaping and a bouldering park, with construction in summer 2024

    Updated

    At the November 7, 2023 Parks and Recreation Commission meeting, a speaker said that "we'll be able to kind of get that project up and running in spring" [1] Parks and Recreation Commission — 2023-11-07 14:30:00, 1:18:37. At 1:24:59 the same speaker asked whether a smaller artificial bouldering piece could be brought into the park, saying designs would come back to the commission [1] Parks and Recreation Commission — 2023-11-07 14:30:00, 1:18:37.

    The FY24-25 Final Budget pages in the June 19, 2024 agenda packet describe the project this way: "Improvements will include a new pavilion for smaller events, replacement of grass areas with irrigation, additional landscaping for screening, and bouldering park with fall protection [2] Agenda (PDF), p. 287. The park area will be constructed over the summer of 2024 [2] Agenda (PDF), p. 287. Total Budget FY24-25: $500,000" [2] Agenda (PDF), p. 287. The 2024-2025 Budget Book, the Final Budget Adoption FY24-25 document and a copy of the text in the December 4, 2024 agenda packet carry the same wording [3] 2024-2025 Budget Book, p. 163.1[4] Final Budget Adoption FY24-25.pdf, p. 45.1[5] Agenda (PDF), p. 201. The June 2024 project list shows the project with status "Construction" and funding source "General Fund" [6] Agenda (PDF), p. 269. The Final Budget Adoption FY24-25 table lists $500,000 in its "Previous Funding" column [7] Final Budget Adoption FY24-25.pdf, p. 44.

    Why it matters

    The planned construction season moved from summer 2024 to summer 2025 [2] Agenda (PDF), p. 287[8] FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf, p. 38.

    Sources

    1. Parks and Recreation Commission — 2023-11-07 14:30:00

      transcriptmeeting/filed date

    2. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 287

    3. 2024-2025 Budget Book

      financialfiscal year from document title Document date (fiscal year from document title) p. 163.1

    4. Final Budget Adoption FY24-25.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 45.1

    5. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 201

    6. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 269

    7. Final Budget Adoption FY24-25.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 44

    8. FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 38

  6. 6 A December 2024 Parks and Recreation Commission staff report lists shade structures, food truck infrastructure, railing art, a seat wall and a trash enclosure under the project

    Updated

    A Parks and Recreation Commission staff report filed with the December 3, 2024 meeting lists these items under "Mammoth Creek Park West Improvements": shade structures; food truck infrastructure; railing art installation; bouldering area seat wall, curbing, Engineered Wood Fiber (EWF) and foundation; and trash enclosure and year-round storage [1] Staff Report(3).pdf, p. 3. The December 3, 2024 agenda packet page shows the same list [2] Agenda (PDF), p. 13. The same staff report page lists PR14 Mammoth Creek West Park Improvements (CON) at $500,000 in a carry-over table [1] Staff Report(3).pdf, p. 3.

    Why it matters

    Examples are food truck infrastructure, railing art and a trash enclosure with year-round storage [1] Staff Report(3).pdf, p. 3[3] Agenda (PDF), p. 287[4] FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf, p. 38.

    Sources

    1. Staff Report(3).pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 3

    2. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 13

    3. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 287

    4. FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 38

  7. 7 Other FY24-25 and FY25-26 budget entries mention Mammoth Creek Park West work

    Updated

    The FY24-25 entry for the "2024 Street and MUP Rehabilitation Project (ST2)" lists treatments for the "Mammoth Creek Park West MUP" among its scope [1] Final Budget Adoption FY24-25.pdf, p. 45.1. The FY25-26 Final Budget entry for Park Signage (PR16) says three new park monument signs will be located at Mammoth Creek Park West, the Dog Park and Shady Rest Park [2] FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf, p. 34.

    Why it matters

    These entries are separate projects with their own budgets, listed in the same budget documents as PR14 [1] Final Budget Adoption FY24-25.pdf, p. 45.1[2] FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf, p. 34.

    Sources

    1. Final Budget Adoption FY24-25.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 45.1

    2. FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 34