TransparentMammoth

Topics / Budget

Department

Snow Removal (Dept 452)

The FY2026-27 adopted budget for Dept 452 Snow Removal lists total expenses of $1,950,918, against $1,602,878 in the FY2023-24 adopted budget; by our calculation that is $348,040 (+21.7%) higher [1] Budget line item detail.pdf, p. 24[2] Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 20. A Town fund-balance document says state Gas Tax revenue covers approximately 50% of the Town's snow removal cost [3] Fund Balance FY23-24.pdf, p. 11. The records also show the FY26-27 snow storage load-fee schedule, staff-recommended contracts for outsourced snow work, and an airport snow removal equipment storage building scheduled to go out to bid on May 29, 2026 [4] Combined Schedule FY26-27.pdf, p. 5[5] Award Contracts for Snow Removal.pdf, p. 1[6] Agenda (PDF), p. 358[7] Final Budget Adoption FY26-27.pdf, p. 38.

Updated

Findings

12 findings

  1. 1 Dept 452 Snow Removal's adopted FY2026-27 budget lists total expenses of $1,950,918

    Updated

    The budget line item detail filed with the June 17, 2026 meeting lists total expenses of $1,950,918 for Dept 452 Snow Removal in the adopted FY2026-27 budget [1] Budget line item detail.pdf, p. 24. The same table lists $1,848,191 for the FY2025-26 approved budget [1] Budget line item detail.pdf, p. 24. The budget line item detail filed with the June 21, 2023 meeting lists $1,602,878 for the FY2023-24 adopted budget [2] Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 20. By our calculation, adopted total expenses are $348,040 (+21.7%) higher in FY2026-27 than in FY2023-24 [2] Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 20[1] Budget line item detail.pdf, p. 24.

    Within that total, Regular Salaries (account 210-452-40000) are $688,131 in the adopted FY2026-27 budget, compared with $682,457 in the adopted FY2025-26 budget [1] Budget line item detail.pdf, p. 24[3] Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 22. By our calculation that is a difference of +$5,674 (+0.8%) [3] Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 22[1] Budget line item detail.pdf, p. 24.

    Why it matters

    These are adopted and approved budget figures, not spending [1] Budget line item detail.pdf, p. 24[2] Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 20. By our comparison, the FY2026-27 total is above both the FY2025-26 approved total and the FY2023-24 adopted total [1] Budget line item detail.pdf, p. 24[2] Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf, p. 20.

    Sources

    1. Budget line item detail.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 24

    2. Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 20

    3. Budget - Line Item Detail.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 22

  2. 2 A Town document says Gas Tax revenue covers approximately 50% of the Town's snow removal cost

    Updated

    The Fund Balance FY23-24 document filed with the November 20, 2024 meeting says the Gas Tax fund is designed to capture the cost of road maintenance and snow removal [1] Fund Balance FY23-24.pdf, p. 11. It says the tax revenue covers approximately 50% of snow removal cost for the Town [1] Fund Balance FY23-24.pdf, p. 11. It says the snow removal reimbursement is delayed a year as reporting and reconciliation is provided by the State, and that the Town will continue to budget a normal year for snow and a normal year for snow removal gas tax [1] Fund Balance FY23-24.pdf, p. 11. It lists a current balance of $2,425,424, available for future road projects or up-front funding of a heavy snow year [1] Fund Balance FY23-24.pdf, p. 11.

    The Fourth Quarter FY21-22 Budget Review, filed with the September 7, 2022 meeting, says revenue for the Gas Tax fund comes from State Gas Tax reimbursements based on prior-year expenses, snow removal load charges, and the General Fund [2] Fourth Quarter Fiscal Year 21-22 Budget Review.pdf, p. 15. The FY26-27 final budget says the Gas Tax fund is in balance, with total revenue of $5,757,649 matching expenditures for FY26-27 [3] Final Budget Adoption FY26-27.pdf, p. 23. Dept 452's line items in the FY2026-27 document filed with the June 17, 2026 meeting carry account numbers beginning 210-452 [4] Budget line item detail.pdf, p. 24.

    Why it matters

    The documents describe how snow removal is funded: State Gas Tax reimbursement that arrives a year late, snow storage load charges, and General Fund support [1] Fund Balance FY23-24.pdf, p. 11[2] Fourth Quarter Fiscal Year 21-22 Budget Review.pdf, p. 15. The 50% and $2,425,424 figures come from the FY23-24 fund balance document, not from FY2026-27 [1] Fund Balance FY23-24.pdf, p. 11.

    Sources

    1. Fund Balance FY23-24.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 11

    2. Fourth Quarter Fiscal Year 21-22 Budget Review.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 15

    3. Final Budget Adoption FY26-27.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 23

    4. Budget line item detail.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 24

  3. 3 Assessment district funds 850, 853, 856 and 857 carry Dept 452 snow removal budgets of $50,000 to $70,000 each for FY2026-27

    Updated

    The budget line item detail filed with the June 17, 2026 meeting shows adopted FY2026-27 total expenses for Dept 452 Snow Removal of $70,000 in Fund 850 and $70,000 in Fund 853 [1] Budget line item detail.pdf, p. 48[2] Budget line item detail.pdf, p. 49. Both funds also show $70,000 in the FY2025-26 approved budget [1] Budget line item detail.pdf, p. 48[2] Budget line item detail.pdf, p. 49. Fund 856 shows $50,000 in the adopted FY2026-27 budget, down from $70,000 in the FY2025-26 approved budget [3] Budget line item detail.pdf, p. 51. Fund 857 shows $50,000 in both the FY2025-26 approved budget and the adopted FY2026-27 budget [4] Budget line item detail.pdf, p. 52.

    The FY26-27 final budget says the Gas Tax fund has only minor edits from the tentative budget, related to modifications in the transfer to Assessment Districts for snow removal costs [5] Final Budget Adoption FY26-27.pdf, p. 23. The adopted budget for Snow Removal (Dept 452) total expenses in Fund 856 for FY2026-27 was $50,000, and the adopted budget for Snow Removal (Dept 452) total expenses in Fund 857 for FY2026-27 was $50,000 [3] Budget line item detail.pdf, p. 51[4] Budget line item detail.pdf, p. 52.

    Sources

    1. Budget line item detail.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 48

    2. Budget line item detail.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 49

    3. Budget line item detail.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 51

    4. Budget line item detail.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 52

    5. Final Budget Adoption FY26-27.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 23

  4. 4 The FY26-27 fee schedule lists snow storage lot load fees of $55, $75 and $85 per load plus a 5% USFS Surcharge

    Updated

    The Combined Schedule FY26-27, filed with the June 17, 2026 meeting, lists a Snow Storage Lot load fee of $55 per load plus a 5% USFS Surcharge for a dump truck or trailer of 20 cubic yards or less [1] Combined Schedule FY26-27.pdf, p. 5. It lists $75 per load plus the surcharge for 20 to 40 cubic yards, and $85 per load plus the surcharge for 40 cubic yards or more [1] Combined Schedule FY26-27.pdf, p. 5. The schedule says these fees are for sites where the Town collects the fee, and that charges may be different where a private contractor collects the fee [1] Combined Schedule FY26-27.pdf, p. 5.

    The schedule also lists an annual land lease for Town-owned property, priced by snowfall of less than or greater than 200 inches [1] Combined Schedule FY26-27.pdf, p. 5. It lists the Snow Removal Equipment Use and Snow Storage, Off-Site annual permits among fees currently being waived per Council Policy [1] Combined Schedule FY26-27.pdf, p. 5.

    The same $55, $75 and $85 load fees plus the 5% surcharge appear in the General Fee Schedule filed with the June 21, 2023 meeting, the General Fee Schedule filed with the June 19, 2024 meeting, and the Combined Schedule FY25-26 filed with the June 18, 2025 meeting [2] General Fee Schedule.pdf, p. 7[3] General Fee Schedule.pdf, p. 4[4] Combined Schedule - FY25-26.pdf, p. 5.

    Why it matters

    The schedule sets what is charged per load at Town-collected snow storage sites, by vehicle capacity [1] Combined Schedule FY26-27.pdf, p. 5.

    Sources

    1. Combined Schedule FY26-27.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 5

    2. General Fee Schedule.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 7

    3. General Fee Schedule.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 4

    4. Combined Schedule - FY25-26.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 5

  5. 5 The FY26-27 fee schedule lists a $220 parking citation for obstructing snow removal

    Updated

    The Combined Schedule FY26-27, filed with the June 17, 2026 meeting, lists a $220 parking citation for MC 10.12.106 Obstructing Snow Removal [1] Combined Schedule FY26-27.pdf, p. 7. It lists $110 for MC 10.12.100 No Street Parking Nov 1-April 30 [1] Combined Schedule FY26-27.pdf, p. 7.

    Why it matters

    By our reading of the schedule, the $220 snow-removal obstruction citation is twice the $110 listed for no street parking from November 1 to April 30 [1] Combined Schedule FY26-27.pdf, p. 7.

    Sources

    1. Combined Schedule FY26-27.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 7

  6. 6 Airport snow removal equipment storage building was scheduled to go out to bid May 29, 2026, with $1.5 million expected

    Updated

    The FY26-27 final budget adoption document, filed with the June 17, 2026 meeting, says Phase 2 of the Multi-Purpose Building at Mammoth Yosemite Airport was intended as the total building, including snow removal equipment bays, ARFF storage and maintenance bays, administrative offices and a small public-facing lobby [1] Final Budget Adoption FY26-27.pdf, p. 36. It says the FAA warned that without sufficient enplanements it could take years to build up enough discretionary funding [1] Final Budget Adoption FY26-27.pdf, p. 36. It says that at the beginning of 2026 the airport's FAA planning group made it aware of Airport Resiliency funding and flagged it as a worthy recipient [2] Final Budget Adoption FY26-27.pdf, p. 37. The document says 'We are on track to be awarded $1.5 million toward a building' [2] Final Budget Adoption FY26-27.pdf, p. 37[3] Final Budget Adoption FY26-27.pdf, p. 38.

    The Final Budget Adoption FY26-27 says this project will go out to bid on May 29, 2026 [3] Final Budget Adoption FY26-27.pdf, p. 38.

    The FY25-26 final budget, filed with the June 18, 2025 meeting, lists the Multipurpose Building to Include ARFF and Snow Removal Equipment - Redesign (AP2a) at a total budget of $350,000 for design in FY25-26 [4] FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf, p. 34. It says the project was originally designed in 2023, bids were not received on the structure portion, and the FAA revised its eligibility for the facility [4] FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf, p. 34. It says the project was being redesigned [4] FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf, p. 34.

    Why it matters

    The records show the airport's equipment building was redesigned after no bids were received on its structure portion, and was then repackaged into a smaller unit because the expected $1.5 million does not cover the whole project [4] FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf, p. 34[3] Final Budget Adoption FY26-27.pdf, p. 38.

    Sources

    1. Final Budget Adoption FY26-27.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 36

    2. Final Budget Adoption FY26-27.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 37

    3. Final Budget Adoption FY26-27.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 38

    4. FY25-26 Final Budget.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 34

  7. 7 Staff recommended a Frontage Road snow trucking contract of up to $100,000 per year, saying the Road Crew lacks trucks and time

    Updated

    A December 4, 2024 Town Council staff report in the agenda packet says the Town provides snow removal services along both South and North Main Street (SR 203) Frontage Roads [1] Agenda (PDF), p. 358. It says Caltrans Right-of-Way abuts the Frontage Road, providing little to no snow storage, and that the lack of snow storage was exacerbated by the construction of the Main Street Sidewalks in 2017-2019 [1] Agenda (PDF), p. 358. It says the sidewalks and parking stalls should not be abandoned seasonally to create snow storage, so it is necessary to truck the snow, and that the Town Road Crew has neither the trucks required nor the time available to consistently truck snow as required [1] Agenda (PDF), p. 358.

    Staff recommended awarding the contract for Frontage Road Snow Trucking to Chuck Villar Construction, Inc. in an amount not to exceed $100,000 per year without written authorization [1] Agenda (PDF), p. 358. Staff also recommended authorizing the Public Works Director to approve contract revisions up to an additional 25% of the awarded annual not-to-exceed amount [1] Agenda (PDF), p. 358.

    The report says the scope of work is not considered a 'public work' under the Public Contract Code of California and therefore does not require a formal bidding process [1] Agenda (PDF), p. 358. It says an informal bid was solicited from four local contractors, and the Town received three responses: one contractor chose not to provide a bid and two submitted competitive bids [1] Agenda (PDF), p. 358.

    Why it matters

    The staff report gives the Town's stated reason for contracting out Frontage Road snow trucking and for not using a formal bidding process [1] Agenda (PDF), p. 358.

    Sources

    1. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 358

  8. 8 In 2022, staff said the snow storage facility contract cost the Town more than $800,000 for the 2021/22 winter

    Updated

    An October 19, 2022 Town Council staff report titled 'Approve leases and award contract for operation of the Town's Snow Storage facility' says that for decades the Town has contracted out operations of the snow storage facility for onsite management [1] Authorize Town Manager to finalize negotiations and execute contract for management of snow storage facility.pdf, p. 1. It lists duties such as locking and unlocking the gate, maintaining dump records, enforcing rules, managing site layout and spring cleanup [1] Authorize Town Manager to finalize negotiations and execute contract for management of snow storage facility.pdf, p. 1. Staff recommended that the Council authorize the Town Manager to finalize contract scope and fee negotiations and finalize a contract for operation of the facility [1] Authorize Town Manager to finalize negotiations and execute contract for management of snow storage facility.pdf, p. 1.

    The report says negotiations with the USFS had become stagnant, and that recent agreements with the USFS had placed a significant financial strain on the Town [1] Authorize Town Manager to finalize negotiations and execute contract for management of snow storage facility.pdf, p. 1. It says staff was in negotiations to lease private land for three years, from the Mammoth Lakes Foundation and from Snowcreek Investment Company [2] Authorize Town Manager to finalize negotiations and execute contract for management of snow storage facility.pdf, p. 2.

    Under 'Financial Considerations', the report says the snow pit contract for the winter of 2021/22 cost the Town in excess of $800,000, which it describes as the cost of a mild winter under the USFS contract [2] Authorize Town Manager to finalize negotiations and execute contract for management of snow storage facility.pdf, p. 2. It says a heavy snow year could easily triple this cost [2] Authorize Town Manager to finalize negotiations and execute contract for management of snow storage facility.pdf, p. 2. It says the proposed contract places the burden of operations, management and administration on the contractor [2] Authorize Town Manager to finalize negotiations and execute contract for management of snow storage facility.pdf, p. 2.

    Separately, the Fourth Quarter FY21-22 Budget Review, filed with the September 7, 2022 meeting, says the Town incurred operational costs for snow storage of $832,000 for FY21-22 [3] Fourth Quarter Fiscal Year 21-22 Budget Review.pdf, p. 15. It says these fees could have easily exceeded $2M in a larger winter [3] Fourth Quarter Fiscal Year 21-22 Budget Review.pdf, p. 15.

    Why it matters

    Two 2022 Town documents put the cost of snow storage at more than $800,000 for the 2021/22 winter and $832,000 for FY21-22 [2] Authorize Town Manager to finalize negotiations and execute contract for management of snow storage facility.pdf, p. 2[3] Fourth Quarter Fiscal Year 21-22 Budget Review.pdf, p. 15.

    Sources

    1. Authorize Town Manager to finalize negotiations and execute contract for management of snow storage facility.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 1

    2. Authorize Town Manager to finalize negotiations and execute contract for management of snow storage facility.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 2

    3. Fourth Quarter Fiscal Year 21-22 Budget Review.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 15

  9. 9 Staff recommended capped annual contracts for outsourced snow removal in 2022 and snow shoveling in 2023

    Updated

    An October 19, 2022 staff report, 'Award Contracts for Snow Removal', says the Town provides snow removal services for a variety of roads and parking lots and has historically contracted out many locations so Public Works staff can focus on public roads [1] Award Contracts for Snow Removal.pdf, p. 1. Staff recommended awarding the Community Recreation Center, Edison Theater, Library and Ice Rink parking lots contract to BG Mountain Enterprises, Inc. in an amount not to exceed $80,000 per year without written authorization [1] Award Contracts for Snow Removal.pdf, p. 1. Staff recommended awarding a second contract to Chuck Villar Construction, Inc. for a list of locations including the Bluffs Maintenance District and the Juniper Ridge Assessment District, not to exceed $600,000 per year without written authorization [1] Award Contracts for Snow Removal.pdf, p. 1. Staff also recommended authorizing the Public Works Director to approve contract revisions up to an additional 25% of the awarded annual not-to-exceed amount [1] Award Contracts for Snow Removal.pdf, p. 1.

    A November 1, 2023 staff report, 'Award Contract for Snow Shoveling Services', recommended awarding Snow Shoveling at Various Locations Throughout the Town of Mammoth Lakes (SNW 23-001) in an amount not to exceed $100,000 per year without written authorization [2] Agenda (PDF), p. 114. It says the Town provides snow shoveling for sidewalks, fire hydrants, Town-owned and operated facilities and bus stops, and that the Town advertised one bid from September 29, 2023 until October 20, 2023 [2] Agenda (PDF), p. 114.

    Why it matters

    These staff reports show the annual dollar caps staff proposed for contracted snow removal and shoveling; the largest was $600,000 per year in 2022 [1] Award Contracts for Snow Removal.pdf, p. 1[2] Agenda (PDF), p. 114.

    Sources

    1. Award Contracts for Snow Removal.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 1

    2. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 114

  10. 10 A draft Town–Mono County Whitmore Agreement makes the Town solely responsible for snow removal at the Park Facilities

    Updated

    Section 8 of the 'TOML and Mono County Whitmore Agreement 021224dh', marked 'DRAFT v3 – DH' and filed with the February 21, 2024 meeting, says the Town is solely responsible for arranging and paying for utility service and snow removal service on the leased site provided to the Park Facilities and any additional facilities constructed under Section 4 [1] TOML and Mono County Whitmore Agreement 021224dh.pdf, p. 3. It says the County is solely responsible for arranging and paying for snow removal service on the leased site provided to the Animal Control Shelter and any additional facilities constructed under Section 5 [1] TOML and Mono County Whitmore Agreement 021224dh.pdf, p. 3. It adds that the parties may agree to cooperatively arrange and pay for snow removal services on a case-by-case basis [1] TOML and Mono County Whitmore Agreement 021224dh.pdf, p. 3.

    Why it matters

    The draft agreement says which party arranges and pays for snow removal at each of the two named facilities [1] TOML and Mono County Whitmore Agreement 021224dh.pdf, p. 3.

    Sources

    1. TOML and Mono County Whitmore Agreement 021224dh.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 3

  11. 11 A 2024 food truck letter agreement at the Community Recreation Center splits snow removal at a four-foot boundary

    Updated

    The 2024 Letter Agreement between the Town and Ms. Luna Tello for Food Truck operations at the Community Recreation Center, filed with the March 6, 2024 meeting, says the Contractor will be responsible for removing snow from the top of the Food Truck and within four feet surrounding the truck [1] Letter of Agreement with Ms. Luna Tello for food and beverage services at the CRC_3-6-2024.pdf, p. 3. It lists, among the items the Town will provide, snow removal services beyond four feet from the Food Truck [1] Letter of Agreement with Ms. Luna Tello for food and beverage services at the CRC_3-6-2024.pdf, p. 3.

    Why it matters

    The letter agreement sets a four-foot boundary between the Contractor's and the Town's snow removal responsibilities at the food truck [1] Letter of Agreement with Ms. Luna Tello for food and beverage services at the CRC_3-6-2024.pdf, p. 3.

    Sources

    1. Letter of Agreement with Ms. Luna Tello for food and beverage services at the CRC_3-6-2024.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 3

  12. 12 Earlier budgets: Gas Tax Fund snow removal rose from $839,711 in FY2005-06 to $1,045,387 in FY2007-08

    Updated

    Table 7-4 in the 2011 Town of Mammoth Lakes Trail System Master Plan, filed with the January 14, 2021 meeting, lists Public Works final budgets for Snow Removal (Gas Tax Fund) of $839,711 for FY2005-06, $992,800 for FY2006-07 and $1,045,387 for FY2007-08 [1] 2011 Town of Mammoth Lakes Trail System Master Plan, p. 273. By our calculation, that is an increase of $153,089 (+18.2%) from FY2005-06 to FY2006-07, and $52,587 (+5.3%) from FY2006-07 to FY2007-08 [1] 2011 Town of Mammoth Lakes Trail System Master Plan, p. 273.

    Why it matters

    These are historical final budget figures from a 2011 planning document, listed under Public Works expenditures [1] 2011 Town of Mammoth Lakes Trail System Master Plan, p. 273.

    Sources

    1. 2011 Town of Mammoth Lakes Trail System Master Plan

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 273