TransparentMammoth

Topics

Multi-Use Facility / Community Recreation Center

The EIR addendum says a previously approved 13,000-square-foot standalone community center was no longer proposed and would instead be a 2,500-square-foot mezzanine community center within an enclosed sprung structure. [1] Attachment C_Addendum to 2017 EIR, p. 13[2] Attachment C_Addendum to 2017 EIR, p. 18 Town annual planning reports say the project was re-scoped after construction bids came in significantly over budget, then rebid with six bids ranging from $8.8 million to $11.4 million. [3] Agenda (PDF), p. 285[4] 2020 Annual Planning Report.pdf, p. 15 A Town document filed with the March 1, 2023 meeting said construction had taken longer than planned and estimated a summer 2023 opening. [5] Agenda (PDF), p. 69

Updated

Findings

  1. 1 EIR addendum reduced the proposed community-center component from 13,000 to 2,500 square feet

    Updated

    The 2017 EIR-approved project included a 13,000-square-foot complementary community center. [1] Attachment C_Addendum to 2017 EIR, p. 13 The EIR addendum says that standalone center was no longer proposed and that a 2,500-square-foot community center would instead be located on a mezzanine within the sprung structure. [2] Attachment C_Addendum to 2017 EIR, p. 18 By our calculation, the proposed community-center area was 10,500 square feet smaller, an 80.8% reduction. [1] Attachment C_Addendum to 2017 EIR, p. 13[2] Attachment C_Addendum to 2017 EIR, p. 18

    The earlier proposed center was to include up to two large rooms of 1,500 to 3,000 square feet, a warming kitchen with concession space, offices, arts/crafts/play space, a meeting room, a multi-purpose room, two to four locker rooms, accessible restrooms, storage, and a mechanical room. [3] Attachment 1 - TC Resolution, p. 10 The addendum says the proposed mezzanine center would include a warming kitchen, accessible restrooms, storage rooms, and amenities for community events and meetings. [2] Attachment C_Addendum to 2017 EIR, p. 18

    The 2017 EIR background described an approximately 30,000-square-foot pitched roof over the ice rink/RecZone, while the addendum comparison table lists the approved pitched-roof structure at 43,000 square feet. [1] Attachment C_Addendum to 2017 EIR, p. 13[2] Attachment C_Addendum to 2017 EIR, p. 18 That table lists the proposed sprung structure at 40,320 square feet, entirely enclosed, 56 feet high, and 50 feet from existing residences to the west. [2] Attachment C_Addendum to 2017 EIR, p. 18 It lists the pitched-roof design as partially enclosed, 35 feet high, and 90 feet from those residences. [2] Attachment C_Addendum to 2017 EIR, p. 18

    Why it matters

    The records show that the project proposal changed both the amount and configuration of community-center space, as well as the enclosure, height, and west-side setback of the rink structure. [1] Attachment C_Addendum to 2017 EIR, p. 13[2] Attachment C_Addendum to 2017 EIR, p. 18

    Sources

    1. Attachment C_Addendum to 2017 EIR

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 13

    2. Attachment C_Addendum to 2017 EIR

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 18

    3. Attachment 1 - TC Resolution

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 10

  2. 2 Planning reports say bids exceeded budget before the Town awarded a construction contract

    Updated

    The 2020 annual planning report says the Multi-Use Facility project was re-scoped after bids for the approved project came in significantly over budget. [1] Agenda (PDF), p. 285 The report says the project was rebid in September and received six bids ranging from $8.8 million to $11.4 million. [2] 2020 Annual Planning Report.pdf, p. 15

    The 2019 annual planning report says that on June 5, 2019, Town Council voted 3-2 to authorize staff to proceed with the facility's design and development as a fabric tensile, or sprung, structure. [3] 2019 Annual Planning Report and Attachments, p. 11 The 2020 annual planning report says Town Council awarded Hamel Contracting Inc. a construction contract for the Community Recreation Center on February 20, 2021, with construction scheduled to begin in mid-2021. [1] Agenda (PDF), p. 285

    Why it matters

    The reports document a sequence from bids above budget, to a re-scoped design, to a later construction-contract award. [1] Agenda (PDF), p. 285[2] 2020 Annual Planning Report.pdf, p. 15[3] 2019 Annual Planning Report and Attachments, p. 11

    Sources

    1. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 285

    2. 2020 Annual Planning Report.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed date Document date (earliest date in cited text) p. 15

    3. 2019 Annual Planning Report and Attachments

      attachmentmeeting/filed date Document date (earliest date in cited text) p. 11

  3. 3 March 2023 Town document estimated a summer 2023 opening after construction took longer than planned

    Updated

    A Town document filed with the March 1, 2023 meeting said Community Recreation Center construction had taken longer than planned and gave a current estimated opening of summer 2023. [1] Agenda (PDF), p. 69 The document said the Town planned to continue ice-related activities at the existing Mammoth Ice Rink Site through March 31, 2023, although operations could end earlier if ice conditions deteriorated. [1] Agenda (PDF), p. 69

    The same document said that, under an amended lease executed October 27, 2022, the Town would pay an additional $4,200 for March and that the total contract amount paid to the District for that fiscal year would be $37,800. [1] Agenda (PDF), p. 69 It also said the Town did not intend to continue operating the outdoor ice rink/RecZone at its current location once the CRC opened. [1] Agenda (PDF), p. 69

    Why it matters

    The delayed-opening estimate was accompanied by a one-month extension of use at the existing ice-rink site and an additional lease payment. [1] Agenda (PDF), p. 69

    Sources

    1. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 69

  4. 4 Town announcement described a 40,000-square-foot arena and LA Kings ice-rink partnership

    Updated

    A December 7, 2022 announcement in a January 2023 agenda packet said the Town, Mammoth Lakes Tourism, and Mammoth Lakes Recreation had launched a multiyear partnership with the LA Kings, brokered by AEG Global Partnerships. [1] Agenda (PDF), p. 40 The announcement said the Community Recreation Center at Mammoth Creek Park would be a 40,000-square-foot Sprung Performance Arena enclosing “LA Kings Ice at Mammoth Lakes.” [1] Agenda (PDF), p. 40

    The announcement said the facility was set to open to the public in 2023, with the ice rink operating each winter from October through April and the Olympic-sized rink becoming a multi-use RecZone during summer. [1] Agenda (PDF), p. 40 It also said the Town had contracted American Sports Entertainment Company, LLC to provide year-round technical and operational consulting services. [1] Agenda (PDF), p. 40

    Why it matters

    The announcement identifies the planned seasonal uses of the facility and the organizations named in its ice-rink partnership and operations consulting arrangement. [1] Agenda (PDF), p. 40

    Sources

    1. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 40

  5. 5 FY2025-26 fee schedule lists $17 adult ice admission and $250-per-hour RecZone facility rental

    Updated

    The FY2025-26 Parks and Recreation Department fee schedule lists Ice Rink adult admission for ages 18 through 64 at $17 per session, or $23 with rental. [1] 2025-26 Parks and Recreation Department Fee Schedule.pdf, p. 2 It lists youth admission for ages 5 through 17 at $13 per session, or $19 with rental. [1] 2025-26 Parks and Recreation Department Fee Schedule.pdf, p. 2

    The same schedule lists peak ice rental at $500 per hour between noon and 8 p.m. and non-peak rental at $350 per hour before noon and after 8 p.m., subject to availability. [2] 2025-26 Parks and Recreation Department Fee Schedule.pdf, p. 3 It lists RecZone facility rental at $250 per hour, including equipment, with a four-hour minimum, a 12-hour maximum, and a required 50% reservation deposit. [2] 2025-26 Parks and Recreation Department Fee Schedule.pdf, p. 3 The schedule lists RecZone adult admission at $7 per entry plus equipment. [2] 2025-26 Parks and Recreation Department Fee Schedule.pdf, p. 3

    The FY2022-23 master fee schedule listed RecZone facility rental at $200 per hour. [3] Exhibit B - Master Fee Schedule.pdf, p. 3 By our calculation, the listed RecZone facility-rental fee increased $50, or 25%, between FY2022-23 and FY2025-26. [3] Exhibit B - Master Fee Schedule.pdf, p. 3[2] 2025-26 Parks and Recreation Department Fee Schedule.pdf, p. 3

    Why it matters

    The fee schedules establish the listed public charges for admission and rentals and show a higher listed RecZone facility-rental rate in FY2025-26 than in FY2022-23. [3] Exhibit B - Master Fee Schedule.pdf, p. 3[1] 2025-26 Parks and Recreation Department Fee Schedule.pdf, p. 2[2] 2025-26 Parks and Recreation Department Fee Schedule.pdf, p. 3

    Sources

    1. 2025-26 Parks and Recreation Department Fee Schedule.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed date Document date (fiscal year from document) p. 2

    2. 2025-26 Parks and Recreation Department Fee Schedule.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed date Document date (fiscal year from document) p. 3

    3. Exhibit B - Master Fee Schedule.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 3

  6. n1 Planning reports say bids exceeded budget before the Town awarded a construction contract

    Updated

    The 2020 annual planning report says the Multi-Use Facility project was re-scoped after bids for construction of the approved project came in significantly over budget, and that a September rebid received six bids ranging from $8.8 million to $11.4 million. [1] Agenda (PDF), p. 285[2] 2020 Annual Planning Report.pdf, p. 15

    The 2019 annual planning report says Town Council voted 3-2 on June 5, 2019, to authorize design and development of a fabric tensile, or sprung, structure; the 2020 EIR addendum describes the 2017 EIR roof as approximately 30,000 square feet in its narrative but lists the pitched-roof structure as 43,000 square feet in its comparison table. [3] 2019 Annual Planning Report and Attachments, p. 11[4] Attachment C_Addendum to 2017 EIR, p. 13[5] Attachment C_Addendum to 2017 EIR, p. 18

    Sources

    1. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 285

    2. 2020 Annual Planning Report.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 15

    3. 2019 Annual Planning Report and Attachments

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 11

    4. Attachment C_Addendum to 2017 EIR

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 13

    5. Attachment C_Addendum to 2017 EIR

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 18

  7. n2 Timeline of routine actions

    Updated

    January 8, 2020: A 2020 EIR addendum said the previously proposed 13,000-square-foot standalone community center was no longer proposed and would be replaced by a 2,500-square-foot community center on a mezzanine within the sprung structure. [1] Attachment C_Addendum to 2017 EIR, p. 13[2] Attachment C_Addendum to 2017 EIR, p. 18

    January 8, 2020: The 2020 EIR addendum described the sprung structure as entirely enclosed, 56 feet high, and 40,320 square feet; its comparison table lists the earlier pitched-roof structure at 43,000 square feet, while the addendum's project-background narrative describes the 2017 EIR roof structure as approximately 30,000 square feet. [2] Attachment C_Addendum to 2017 EIR, p. 18[1] Attachment C_Addendum to 2017 EIR, p. 13

    January 8, 2020: A 2020 staff report described a project component with a 36-space surface parking lot and playground improvements with accessible, inclusive components. [3] Attachment D_2017 PEDC Staff Report, p. 6

    April 14, 2021: An April 2021 Planning and Economic Development Commission staff report identified the Community Recreation Center site as 686 Old Mammoth Road at Mammoth Creek Park West, on approximately five acres zoned Public and Quasi-Public with an Open Space General Plan designation. [4] PEDC Staff Report MUF_CRC colors_logo 4-14-21.docx, p. 1

    August 2, 2022: A 2022 agenda packet said the Town had leased two acres adjacent to the District offices from the Mammoth Unified School District and Mono County Office of Education since 2007, and that the resulting concrete-slab ice rink/RecZone had operated since 2011. [5] Agenda (PDF), p. 28

    December 7, 2022: A December 2022 announcement filed with a January 2023 agenda packet said the Town, Mammoth Lakes Tourism, and Mammoth Lakes Recreation launched a multiyear LA Kings partnership brokered by AEG Global Partnerships, and described a planned 40,000-square-foot Sprung Performance Arena at Mammoth Creek Park. [6] Agenda (PDF), p. 40

    March 1, 2023: A Town document filed with the March 1, 2023 meeting said Community Recreation Center construction had taken longer than planned and estimated an opening in summer 2023; it also said the Town planned to use the existing ice rink site for ice-related activities through March 31, 2023. [7] Agenda (PDF), p. 69

    February 19, 2025: The FY2025-26 Parks and Recreation Department fee schedule lists Ice Rink adult admission at $17 per session, or $23 with rental, and RecZone facility rental at $250 per hour including equipment, with a four-hour minimum and 50% deposit. [8] 2025-26 Parks and Recreation Department Fee Schedule.pdf, p. 2[9] 2025-26 Parks and Recreation Department Fee Schedule.pdf, p. 3

    February 19, 2025: By our calculation, the RecZone facility-rental fee rose $50, or 25%, from $200 per hour in the FY2022-23 master fee schedule to $250 per hour in the FY2025-26 fee schedule. [10] Exhibit B - Master Fee Schedule.pdf, p. 3[9] 2025-26 Parks and Recreation Department Fee Schedule.pdf, p. 3

    June 17, 2026: The adopted FY2026-27 budget says the Town acquired $5.5 million in Measure R-secured debt in October 2017 for construction of a multi-use facility and includes a $615,126 transfer for the fiscal year's debt payment. [11] Final Budget Adoption FY26-27.pdf, p. 27

    Sources

    1. Attachment C_Addendum to 2017 EIR

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 13

    2. Attachment C_Addendum to 2017 EIR

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 18

    3. Attachment D_2017 PEDC Staff Report

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 6

    4. PEDC Staff Report MUF_CRC colors_logo 4-14-21.docx

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 1

    5. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 28

    6. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 40

    7. Agenda (PDF)

      agenda_pdfmeeting/filed datep. 69

    8. 2025-26 Parks and Recreation Department Fee Schedule.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 2

    9. 2025-26 Parks and Recreation Department Fee Schedule.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 3

    10. Exhibit B - Master Fee Schedule.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 3

    11. Final Budget Adoption FY26-27.pdf

      attachmentmeeting/filed datep. 27