Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2011
Planning & Economic Development Commission
· recording 1 hr 55 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
251 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:02 Oh, I'm sitting down, it's chiming nigh. You're on the meeting of March 23rd, it's your order, and you all stand and join Vice Chair Behnken and the Pledge of Allegiance. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. And if we could have roll call, please.
0:42 Okay, Commissioner Dugan? Here. Commissioner Tenney? Here. Vice Chair Duncan? Here. Chair Barrett? Here. All right, at this time, we'll move on to the commission, Commissioner Tenney?
1:07 Do you want me to report on the Mammoth Gateway since that's a private project? Okay, I won't have anything. Okay, thank you. I don't have anything. No, thank you. Okay, I just have a few things. First, I just want to thank the Vice Chair for running the meetings while I've been ill this last month and everyone for keeping things together. Mark, I know Ray's not here, and this is something that would be with Ray, but...
1:37 And there's Commissioner Clark now. Why don't we hold up for one minute and we'll... That's okay. No problem. Let's get Commissioner Clark a few moments here to get herself sat down. So we're on reports from the commission. Do you have any? I attended the Water Board District last week meeting. All right, and then I'll continue then. Old Mammoth Road.
2:26 Out in Old Mammoth. And I'm a little embarrassed about this because after living here 20-odd years and being involved, one thing I never noticed that I just recently did is all along Old Mammoth Road, starting from the Snow Creek up, all of the development, the new development that we've put in, the development that's already there, when you try to come out at any of those apartment buildings homes on Old Mammoth Road, you've got to pull your car all the way out into the lane of traffic.
2:57 To even see if you can make a right-hand or left-hand turn. It is so dangerous. Yeah, under snow conditions. It is just incredible. I apologize to the people out there like Mammoth Lakes Housing and that. We go on these trips, we go around the town, we look at all this new development, but we've never taken a chance to look at what's already there and the problem with it.
3:21 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
3:50 I think it's 25 at the church, I think. Yeah, but it changes to 35 too, and there was supposed to be a left turn lane onto Ranch Road that we talked about, and so... Perhaps this could be an agenda placed on the agenda. If we could, if the rest of the commission is fine with that, I think it just really needs... I was, you know, I'm embarrassed because I just... A young woman out there watches my dogs for me, and I noticed it when I was, you know, leaving.
4:18 Actually, Wendy Seguimara lives in the same complex that I was pulling out of. And it's very dangerous. Also, the Ski Back Trail intersection, just past the athletic club, the Ski Back Trail, same problem. I'll ask Public Works Director Jarvis to report. I mean, it's a snow removal, it's a snow storage issue, so, I mean, it's not a little issue, it's huge. And I see Tom there, so I think you know what I'm talking about out there probably.
4:47 If you're concerned about old net, that's the tip of the iceberg to grassland. Okay. Every intersection encounter faces that same situation, but that's not every driver. All right, so maybe if we could just expand that and make it a... Yes. Okay, perfect. Because now we're looking at snow removal instead of snow storage in areas that we traditionally store. It's the practical ability to create a clear zone in the removal of the snow. Or it may not be possible.
5:16 And that just really struck me. There's a lot of families that live out there and children, and it's just, you know, not that the rest of the town isn't as needy, but thanks, John. No, it's very dense out there. You know, also we had our zoning code update on height and density, which I think went really well. I did my phone conference, but I want to bring up that.
5:38 Something that was brought up there that I actually brought forward and I want the commission to be aware of is while I was down in L.A., at UCLA, I talk a lot to a lot of people and the doctors and nurses and all that stuff and most of them, you know, they always say, oh, Mammoth, we love Mammoth, we go there, we ski, but they all had like a complaint or a concern, let's say, that we generalized, but they all had it and that was they know what they get from the mountain.
6:05 They know the service they get. They know the consistency they get there. But as for the rest of the town, even though they want to come and enjoy the town, because of the fact that we don't allow credit stores, credit-based stores, or that we've tried to stay away from them, that's a downfall for us, meaning Chipotle, some of the restaurants, the chains that we've always tried to stay away from.
6:32 And I just, you know, I've asked that this be brought forward. I think we need to have another discussion on it because those types of businesses, they provide certainty to our visitors, number one, because they know what they're going to get. Number two, it provides financing too when you're looking at that. So it's something I think we need to revisit. So we are going to do that under our development guidelines, I believe. I think we'll do it through the resort investment program in our development forecast and strategy.
7:02 But I'd just like all of you to kind of think about that. Talk to the visitors because, you know, we always seem to focus on our locals, which we should, and what we want to see our town be, but we forget that we have 35,000 visitors up here at a time, and they look for certainty. And if they're only staying on the mountain, that doesn't do the rest of the town any good. Tony, can I make a comment? Uh-huh.
7:27 That's a very good point. And when you look at what McDonald's looks like in Mammoth compared to McDonald's elsewhere, you know, just because it's a fast food chain or a chain restaurant of any kind doesn't mean it can't fit in with our community. So, good point. It's interesting you brought it up because one, well, four people said to me, well, you don't even have a McDonald's there. And they said, well, yes, we do. And it's because of the design that they're used to. They're used to the arches. They're used to specific building types.
7:53 That they identify with. Well, the sign is right there. Yeah, exactly. But it's something I think we just really need to take into consideration, you know, for the visitors and then in the future. All right. We'll move on now to comments from the public. And if there's anyone wishing to address the commission on anything not on the agenda. All right. We did receive a letter from Lee Gosch. And as I said, I was not at the last couple meetings, and I had a little conference with Vice Chair Denkin before this meeting started.
8:22 Thank you, Chair and Commissioners. Before I begin, I just wanted to quickly speak to
8:53 Lee Gosch's letter regarding the confusion over the start time of this meeting. And I do think it was just miscommunication between planning staff and Stu Brown, who does our kind of outreach in terms of advertising the meeting times to the paper and so on, just to not make it more clear to him to advertise that meeting as a different start time. So I apologize to anyone that was confused by the different meeting times that were published. We'll do our best.
9:22 In the future, not to allow that to happen. Well, it was on the town website, though. The correct time was on the website, too. And, you know, as for, and I guess we're kind of getting into this a little, but as for the newspapers, I mean, if they don't go in, you know, they have their standardized calendars they have, and if they don't go in and change them, there's not much we can do about that, so, except ask them to get it right. And Ellen, I presume for Sierra Valley Sites, NDP, like other matters, you have a list of
9:49 Interested people who get e-mail from you? Yeah, I e-mailed all of the folks that were at our, worked up on the 23rd to let them know about this meeting, and we've had ads in the paper and so on, but obviously it's not good to have different meeting times published, and we'll do our best not to let that happen in the future. Ellen, e-mail, but so many people, I don't know so many people, many people do not have
10:14 Internet connection. Do we, is there any way to know in town what percentage of our population does not have Internet connection? I couldn't say. I mean, most, there's, even for those that don't have email at home, there's always, you know, there's Internet access at the library and so on, but it's hard to know. And so, you know, that's why we do outreach in different ways to try and get people to come through as many channels as we can, the newspaper being the major.
10:41 I have almost 150 people on my email list of interested parties that receive this agenda every time there's a meeting, and in the body of that email, I did write in bold that note that the meeting will be at 9 a.m., and I bolded that 9 a.m., and I underlined it instead of 2.
10:59 So I know those people who received the agenda saw that, as well as me bolding the agenda. I suppose it would be a typical, we would be typical of any other community if I could get those. Maybe it's something that will come out with the census. I don't know. But it would be interesting to know how many people at home do not have access. Well, you could probably find out from MPG Cable would be one way. QNet, those are two of the bigger providers. And Verizon, so.
11:27 And then there's Gmail and there's Yahoo. Well, you're in our connection, but if you have the connection, that would be through Verizon. Our MPG. Yeah. Those two. Yeah. Thank you. That's a good idea. Thank you. In addition, this item was discussed at the last Planning Commission meeting regarding should the Planning Commission meet at 9 or should it meet at another time. It was the consensus of the Commission meeting at 9 because it had been already.
11:56 advertised at that period of time. So with that, she will proceed. And wasn't she in attendance? Yes. Yes. Okay. So the purpose of this agenda item is to have the Planning Commission consider and recommend acceptance of the framework for the Sierra Valley Sites Neighborhood District Plan. The framework is the
12:23 High level, really, the scope of work for the neighborhood district planning process consists of three major components, identification of the boundary, the study area boundary and sphere of influence for the project, the guiding principles that guide the issues, discussion, actions, recommendations of the plan, and finally, the list of key issues that will be studied through the planning process.
12:48 The Sierra Valley Sites is a unique neighborhood, very different from many of the other district plans that we've done. Sierra Valley Sites is a local's neighborhood, it's residential, it has unique issues and characteristics, and for that reason, we kicked off this process slightly differently from other NDPs by holding a public workshop on February 23rd to
13:12 Begin to gather as broad of a range of issues as we could so that we understood those up front going into this framework process. And we've tried to reflect the issues that we heard as well as input that we've had from other town departments, other agencies to fully define that framework as best we can. I won't go into a lot of detail in the background of district planning, but it was a process that began in 2007 following adoption of the general plan.
13:40 That directed more detailed planning for key areas of the town in more detail than could be addressed through the general plan. And so since 2007 we've done a number of studies. We're continuing to work on those through this fiscal year. And current work includes work on the South District's NDP. You see a lot of graphics up on the wall for a workshop that we held yesterday. And that process is moving along. And the second major...
14:08 District planning effort is for the Sierra Valley sites. So those are two very important processes that we hope to begin and we will begin and will conclude this fiscal year. As I mentioned, there's three major components of the framework. The first of those is the study area boundaries. That has two major parts. The study area, which is the focused area of interest for the project, and in this case includes all of the residential properties along Manzanita.
14:38 Mono, Lupin, Joaquin, Callahan, and Dorrance Drive, the neighborhood that we think of as the Sierra Valley sites, as well as a couple of other properties that are zoned sort of on the periphery of the Sierra Valley sites itself, but which are multifamily affordable housing projects that we feel felt shared some issues with the Sierra Valley sites and so should therefore be included in this study. The second boundary is the sphere of influence, and that's a much more broad
15:07 It looks at the properties, the areas around the main study area that have a relationship to, that have issues that are common to or affect the main study area. And so in general we don't look at that sphere in as much detail, but we do consider issues of connectivity and influence that that broad area has on the Sierra Valley sites.
15:33 In this case, we've drawn the boundary to encompass properties south to follow Minerat Road across the Sierra Star Golf Course to include the denser multifamily projects along Arrowhead, Chaparral, Azimuth Drive, the Shady Rest Site, and then also properties north of Main Street. And again, these are the
16:04 The area that we thought had the greatest relationship and sort of interest in terms of direct physical connection but also of issues as well. The second major piece is the guiding principles and generally speaking for district planning we've drawn these directly from the general plan.
16:26 The general plan lists neighborhood characteristics for a variety of districts in town. In reviewing the general plan, however, there's not a substantial amount of guidance in terms of guiding principles for this district, and so the guiding principles that are included in your attachment does list the references that are made to the Sierra Valley sites, but also takes as additional guiding principles some of those that were developed for the shady rest site, which is adjacent.
16:53 has a lot of characteristics in common with Sierra Valley sites in terms of being a livable, in-town, workforce neighborhood, a desire to have quality housing, good connectivity, and those sorts of things. And so we really borrowed some of those guiding principles and adjusted them a little bit and have listed them here as guiding principles for Sierra Valley sites as well because we felt they were relevant to this area.
17:23 Third item is the list of key issues. And in this staff report, we provided a little bit more detail on some of the issues that came out and were discussed in some depth at the February 23rd meeting.
17:36 As I mentioned, the framework is really sort of the high-level scope, and so the goal here is to really kind of list and have, make sure all of the major issues are brought out in front of the project so we know what we're going to be studying. We will be looking at all of these, some of the additional background information and detail on things like, you know, what is the storm drain system? Where are those pipes? Where are those culverts?
17:59 And some of the results of previous studies that have been done as well. There has been a number of other previous studies for traffic, for storm drainage. We've looked at housing issues in the Sierra Valley sites. So at our meeting coming up in April, we will provide additional background on some of those things. This meeting is really to present those key issues, but not necessarily to go into extensive detail on them at this point. But we do want to know whether or not we captured.
18:27 The right set of issues if anything is missing or other things that were discussed that we missed and that are listed and should be included among those key issues. So just briefly on the issues that are addressed in the staff report, what we heard very clearly was that
18:43 The residents of Sierra Valley sites really like the Sierra Valley sites the way that it is to a large extent. They like the rural character. They like the fact there's not a ton of street lighting, that the streets are windy, that there are trees, that there's a mix of housing types, there's a mix of people, and people really appreciate those characteristics and don't want to see a lot of land use change. But at the same time, there are obviously issues that the neighborhood faces.
19:11 What we heard most strongly was concerns about traffic safety, pedestrian speeding and cut-through traffic as major issues. And it's clear that this is a concern, but also that solutions are going to be complicated, that you don't want to come up with a solution that's going to inadvertently or affect another situation, push traffic onto another street, for example, create an unintended pedestrian safety issue. And that also needs to be balanced with things like
19:40 Maintaining character that residents want to see in terms of sidewalks or street lighting as well. Stormwater was another major issue. There's documented incidents of flooding that have been significant to Sierra Valley sites over the years. Again, this is a fairly technical issue, one that we'll certainly need to have an engineering.
20:02 perspective on to understand what the causes are and what the solutions might be, but certainly as an issue to be explored, it's very important to residents and to staff as well, to the town. The third major category was issues I would describe as sort of nuisance and public safety, things like noise, trash, aesthetics, how does the neighborhood feel, is it safe, is it a safe place to be, is it an attractive neighborhood, and a number of issues were listed in that category.
20:33 And then finally, housing. And as I suggest in the staff report, this is a very complicated issue, and it's certainly true that a number of affordable housing projects have been approved in the Sierra Valley sites in recent years. Those projects, because of density bonuses and a strong desire to facilitate that type of housing, have been approved at higher densities. And I think there's a perception that those...
21:01 Though some of the higher density projects have caused neighborhood issues of traffic and various other things. And it's, as I say, a complex issue, one that we need to think about carefully through this process and consider balancing those community needs of providing affordable housing for our local families and also maintaining the quality of life and a livable.
21:26 Truly livable neighborhood in Sierra Valley sites because this is really where our working families live and those working families need a place to live that are safe, that are affordable. The Mammoth Lakes Housing Project certainly provide that type of housing. So finally, just quickly on process, we will be following the outline format in terms of the content of the plan, although it's important to recognize that we will tailor
22:46 Spanish language meeting as well because there's significant Spanish speaking populations in Sierra Valley sites and we'd like to get their perspective on this process as well. Just in terms of timing on this, we'll be following this meeting assuming that you conclude on your discussion of the framework today, taking this to the town council for approval of the framework at their first meeting in April.
23:11 Holding our Spanish language meeting in mid-April and then our follow-up, our next district planning meeting in late April with the goal of presenting and then accepting the final report in May and June, sorry, June and July. With that, I would invite any questions or discussion. Thank you. Okay. Just for the public, what we're going to be doing is I'll have questions for, it's not a public hearing, but.
23:41 I have questions of the commission for Ellen, a little discussion, and then we do want to hear from you also. So with that, Commissioner Clark, do you have any questions for Ellen regarding the staff report? I guess they could be that. I want to talk about the guiding principles.
24:02 The map, a couple of things like that. So is that where you want to go? Yeah, how about if there's any questions about the stack? Because I do have questions about the map as well, and I'm sure others, and maybe we can go back and take each item separately. Okay. I thought, and thank you, Alan, for spending so much time with me on Monday on the phone. Elizabeth? Yes, I had three questions on page five. The top bullet point, lack of mid-block pedestrian routes that lead to cutting across private property. There was nothing in here about,
24:34 Exploring the ideas of obtaining easements so that you don't have to walk all the way to Main Street or all the way to Meridian to get to Old Mammoth Road. And I don't know what an easement takes, but I certainly think the idea should be explored. So is that complicated, exploring easements? I mean, is an easement, I don't know too much about it. I think that the scope will speak specifically to trails.
25:01 Implementation of trails than require easements and sometimes property acquisition. Okay. And one would think that the trails should be connected. Then my second question on page five was the second bullet point near the bottom about ensuring the new development provides for adequate parking and snow storage. Does the town have any authority over garages that were part of a new construction use permit?
25:31 to provide adequate parking and then those garages are rented out and people are parking in the snow storage areas? Generally, the town does not deal with private parking issues. Those will be regulated for a condo project through the HOA if there's a particular issue. However, to the extent that that then causes a parking problem on the public streets, then the town would want to look into that as a code. Only if it's on the street, though, as long as it's on the private property.
25:59 Enforcement issue because the intent of a use permit, for example, to provide a garage is meant to provide a place for parking. And so if it starts to look like a code compliance issue, it can't be enforced. I remember Roy Sari used to insist with those permits that all those garages have automatic door openers just to make it easier not to leave the car outside. I thought that was very astute of him. And then the third bullet point near the bottom.
26:28 What authority does the town have beyond code compliance over improving exterior property conditions? I mean, if a place is, you know, badly in need of paint and falling apart, does the town have any authority as long as they're in compliance with the code? Well, the nuisance section of the code speaks to property and building conditions. And so if the building is falling into disrepair, it can go through a nuisance abatement procedure. Disrepair is a nuisance.
26:58 Yes. Oh, okay, good. But it has to be, obviously, you know, the common man opinion of Mr. Perry's. Right, right. Okay. Thank you. I've got a discussion item for later. Thank you. Commissioner Greedy? No questions at this time. Yeah, no questions. I think everything I have would be in the comment section. Ellen, I didn't notice. It's my understanding that Sierra Valley sites has CC&Rs.
27:25 And have those been reviewed? Were they reviewed in the context of what we're doing here? I have also heard that and I have not reviewed those. I think it would be important that we do that as we move through this process. Just a comment on the Spanish language workshop. I think that's great we're doing that. I would have really liked to have seen it before it went to council. I think it was important to have him on, but I'm happy at least that we've got it there for him as we move through.
27:56 And then just a question regarding, and I'm glad that Tom is here because it's something maybe Tom during comments we can discuss, but Sierra Holiday Mobile Home Park, that's guided under the Department of Housing, and it's my understanding that I think they may have given the Fire Department the lead way on code enforcement, but it's not our town codes, it's under the Department of Housing, I believe.
28:24 Maybe, Tom, when we get to that, you can address that for me. I'm a little concerned about it being involved and then we have a kind of a misstep with Commission not being able to enforce town codes.
28:36 Okay. I think what I'd like to do is hear from the public.
29:05 Is there anyone wishing to address the commission before we go into our discussion? So the podium is open. Gary, please state your name. My name is Gary Small. Just a couple other little things that I think we may have missed at the first meeting. Heavy equipment storage on properties, which is fairly common, and also some RV storage.
29:39 It's probably true all over town, but I think in our neighborhood a bit, where people clear the whole frontage of their property along the street so that other properties nearby are impacted when the town blower comes through. They leave basically no place on their property for the town to blow snow. So adjacent properties are impacted quite a bit, especially during big storms, obviously, by snow. And then there was one other thing,
30:09 I don't know. The whole town has the workforce lives everywhere in town. So, you know, to say, you know, we're the workforce neighborhood, I think locals neighborhood may be more accurate or whatever, but we don't want all the workforce housing in our neighborhood per se. We've talked about that before. So, you know, maybe get away from saying we're the workforce neighborhood, you know, so that we don't end up with more workforce housing or at least some gets spread out. So just those remarks.
30:39 Thanks. Thank you, Gary. Gary, I have a question. You said some property owners clear their entire frontage. Is that so they can park cars there? Is that why they do it? Your property melts out a lot quicker in the spring. Oh, they're just doing it just, hmm, okay. So I don't think it's a huge issue a lot of places, but I've seen it all over town. I mean, you know, you'll see somebody with a driveway and that's all they have and then there's huge snow banks and then you've got the guy next door that's cleared, you know.
31:08 Property line to property line along the street. And where does he put the snow? Well, he might blow his own snow onto his property, but when the town comes down and clears the street, typically they're blowing a lot of snow out of the street onto the properties. And they'll blow it on the opposite side of the street, or they'll blow it back on the property before his, and they'll shoot it on the ground and then shoot it up on the property after his. So basically the properties on adjacent sides and or across the street are being impacted.
31:35 So your objection is that the person who clears their frontage is not sharing the burden of snow storage? Correct. Got it. Okay. But in fact, his property does have snow storage specifically indicated, and that's where it's supposed to be, is what you're saying. I think you're really only supposed to clear your own driveway. I don't think you're supposed to clear extra frontage so you have extra properties. Well, that's what I mean. At least at my driveway, on both sides, there's another.
32:05 12 feet that's designated snow storage. It's supposed to be town storage. Yes. Yeah. The town does have a snow storage easement in general, Mr. Peter was here, in the front of properties that allows for that, but I think Gary's point, it probably doesn't have a wide driveway or are clearing the whole front of the town. The plows come by and they don't want to blow it into those cleared areas because they know they'll get in trouble for it. I think what Gary's getting to, help me up here if I'm not correct, it's...
32:33 You know, you pick your driveway area, then you have non-driveway area that people will either use their blowers or whoever moves the snow will clear out the area in front so they have additional parking. Then when the town comes by because it's cleared, they won't blow into that area so they blow it into the other areas. But in fact, it's designated snow storage so they should be filling that area. It's everywhere in town.
33:01 It happens. It happens in the trails. Yeah. So Ray Jarvis is in the audience. I don't know if you had any. I've got a question for Ray then perhaps. If a neighbor has a problem like that and it looks like that is a designated snow storage area, if they complain to the town, will the town investigate that? And if it is snow storage, then have the equipment operators.
33:29 Put the snow from the street on that cleared area. My response is that, and particularly when we have a lot of snow, our guys are going to put snow wherever they can. So if they see, and I'm not quite sure I understand what Gary's getting at, I thought what he was saying was that a property owner may go out into the street with their own blower and move snow beyond the sides of their property, and that way when the blower comes by,
33:57 They're not actually picking it up in front of that property. They're getting it, you know, to the next property. Is that what you're getting at? But anyway, the point is, is that if there's open area to put snow, we're going to put it there. We're not going to put it on someone's driveway. Hopefully not. We do occasionally, but, you know, we want to correct that. But, you know, we're looking for every nook and cranny we can to get snow off the street.
34:24 I think the issue you brought up, but we already have an ordinance, you're not allowed to put your snow out on the street anyway from your private property, but going back to Gary, I think if you have a cleared area and you've got two cars there, your guys are not going to blow snow on top of the cars. No. So that's getting back to what Gary is bringing forward. So instead of just doing your driveway, I've got 100 feet on the street. I do my driveway and I could do another 30 feet on one side.
34:51 And that would give me some extra room for parking and this and that. But it wouldn't be that easy for me to do it because I'm not that flat. But I've seen other places. I've seen spots behind the post office. I don't want to need my neighborhood. But where people, again, include the whole frontage of their property, from one property line, their property line on one side to their property line on the other side, as opposed to just their driveway. And they've got extra parking on the left, extra parking on the right, extra parking on the driveway. And those are the issues, I think, where that's done. Well noted. Thank you, Gary.
35:20 The podium is still open for anyone wishing to make comments. Hi, Jennifer Halfordy. I know I can attest that they will put snow anywhere because they do blow it over my fence, right into my backyard, so they won't find any open space they can, which is fine. But I think part of the exacerbation of that problem is the dumpsters that sit in the public right away, all up and down.
35:51 The streets prevents them from being able to store snow and blow snow in the public right away. All those dumpsters, they're all along Mono Street, I know for sure where I live because I walk the street. In addition, there's a lot of vehicles, not a lot, but some vehicles that are parked right there on the public right away as well, you know, just right along.
36:17 Right next to the snow stakes in their park, they're all winter. It's like where they keep them and that too, you know, keeps you from being able to blow snow there. So I think those are two big issues as well as, you know, people clearing too much of their land. Although it's not really, you know, I'm not sure what the setbacks are off of the street, but I'm guessing it's 20 feet, 15. So there's a lot of...
36:45 Usage of that space that could be used for snow storage, which would help. So if there's any way to enforce, you know, the code that would encourage people not to keep their dumpsters right on the street, you know, right off the street, that would be helpful. Jennifer, oh, excuse me. Are these privately rented dumpsters, one per parcel? Or are they neighborhood dumps, like we used to have when we had neighborhood dumpsters?
37:12 They're not neighborhood dumpsters? No, we don't have any neighborhood dumpsters in the Sierra Valley sites. They're all private. Okay. Yeah. Thank you. Thank you. Good morning. Larry Johnston, resident sort of. This past winter did a lot of walking through the Sierra Valley sites on several occasions. And just a couple of observations for you. It's a great, great mixed neighborhood.
37:48 of different kinds of uses of people and so on and kind of very interesting talking to the different people. One of the things that they kind of told us, especially the single family owners, were they felt there was enough multifamily. They didn't like the idea so much of adding more affordable housing, that sort of thing. Although the affordable housing that's been added has been nice.
38:20 So they thought they were kind of like maxing out what would be good for the neighborhood. And that comes back to what the zoning is and what's allowed. And then some observations on the, it's an unsafe neighborhood to walk around in, in the winter especially. A lot of the, and you may not be able to do anything about this, a lot of the older complexes especially.
38:48 Snow removal was a real problem and it wasn't done very effectively from my observation. A lot of the stairways, a lot of the access points to the houses were ice covered. There's icicle problems, overhanging icicles in a lot of the overrooms. The newer ones not so much, you know, they had covered walkways and appropriate overhangs and so on, but I'm not sure there's anything you could do with that. Maybe some housing rehab kind of thing that would help.
39:18 And then the access issues, as you probably know about this, just the trail, the trailer and connection and so on. They have a good, apparently the bus system was fairly good for them. They like that. It goes down in the neighborhood and serves it pretty well. And then drainage was another issue that they spoke of. We've had some flooding issues out there from time to time. So that would be my thoughts and what we observed when we were walking out there.
39:48 Larry, so just to be clear, are you here as supervisor of the district or a private citizen? Oh. Because you're out that district, so it's fine for you to be here. I was just stopping by today to learn more about it, but I thought I'd share with what we learned when we were out there. Okay. Yeah. And then so are you suggesting down zoning for properties that are zoned multifamily but only have a single-family home on them? I'm not. I'm just suggesting that that's what people told us, that we're in single-family homes. They thought there was enough.
40:18 Multifamily zoning in the neighborhood already, and they wouldn't like to see too much more emphasis on that, but it's a zoning issue. Thanks. Along that line, I wish that had come up during the general plan update because one of the questions I asked Ellen was initially, originally, I believe these were half-acre lots in Sierra Valley sites, one unit per lot, and the zoning got changed, I don't know when.
40:51 Was it 84, 85 when town took it over from county? Was it in some other update or, you know, I don't know. So that is when I think we should have considered down zoning, should have been in our general plan update. I could be wrong, but that's currently our general plan says multifamily. Yeah, I think the higher levels of, you know.
41:19 Zoning were the issue that we heard. Single-family duplex, that wasn't so much of an issue. So it was more towards the workforce housing. Yeah. Yes. Thank you. Thanks. Sure. Go ahead, Elizabeth. Alan, what does the code say about dangerous overhanging ice? We've had several tragedies in this town in the 20 years I've lived here. I'm not sure that it speaks to it. And what Larry points out is really important. Yeah, I don't think the code speaks to it.
41:53 Directly other than, as Mark was suggesting, sort of the health safety and welfare type of issues. So I don't think there's any direct, I mean, it's a property maintenance issue, really, and I suppose it could be enforced or code enforcement. It's probably more of a civil issue for an individual property owner to not maintain their property in a way that's safe to the public.
42:21 Right. It's generally, you know, the difference between public access and private access to that property. Well, I'm just thinking about the little girl at the nursery school who was killed, you know, when the ice came. Well, that's different, though, because that was not, that was a, wasn't a residential property, so. Right, that's principally affected through the building code. Okay. That's why it's no rails. But for these older properties, we have no recourse? I do not think you do. This is a private property.
42:51 Okay. So it would be considered trespassing, actually, if you wanted a property and were injured without being invited onto the property. So if you lived there, if you were renting and the ice comes off the roof because the landlord hasn't taken care of it, that's a civil suit. That's not anything to do with town code because it's a private property. Right, because it's a private property. Okay, that's good to know. All right, the podium is still open. And folks, you know, as we move through and are having our discussion, there'll be other times for you to come forward, too, as we're discussing the sphere of influence.
43:21 And the rest of it. Good morning. I'm Tom Heller of the Fire Department. And hopefully I'll address a couple of the issues that have been brought forward thus far. That's a good ringtone. That's a good ringtone. Propane tanks. Larry brought this up. One of the issues we definitely have in many parts of town, but certainly in Sierra Valley Estates because of the age of a lot of the facilities that are out there.
43:52 There are numerous tanks that do not comply with the setback requirements as far as property tank setback from property lines, both on the roadside as well as on side yard setbacks. And for obvious reasons, tanks were never placed in the old days in the back of a lot. They were always placed front or side. So as permits get pulled, we are requiring...
44:19 Along with the town, that that situation be corrected. If a permit isn't pulled, there's something we can do as far as forcing that issue. But at this point, we're slowly but surely working on trying to correct a little bit of that. This is not an issue that pertains to Sierra Valley states probably at all. But I guess I understand there was some discussion about color of propane tanks at a meeting yesterday or the day before. We have a requirement that tanks cannot be dark colors.
44:48 For obvious reasons. We've had the first year that it was changed here in town, we ended up with numerous calls as a result of tanks heating up and off-gassing, primarily in the summertime, but surprisingly we even had a few in the wintertime. So dark colors on propane tanks do not work. Basically tan and white-green and or white are the approved colors. That's in our code, so it would take a code change in order to make that happen.
45:18 And in fact, it actually even shows up to a partially, it's addressed in the building code as well, but not as detailed as we chose to be so that we had specific colors. I'll hit the trailer parts last since that's really not part of Sierra Valley Estates. Accidents went back, since the last meeting went back and took a look at our records. I only went back five years, but we've had seven responses to accidents that occurred. Now, I can't exactly
45:48 Differentiate between pedestrian versus vehicle, but in Sierra Valley states at night, we've had, there were seven incidents where, and I did not include the daytime incidents, just the nighttime incidents, where it appears that the darkness of the neighborhood may have played a role in the fact that there were, we were called to an incident. In two cases, it was definitely a pedestrian, it was definitely on the
46:15 North end of Sierra Valley states in the weaving section of the road, and based on the notes that were provided, it appears that the driver just wasn't aware that there was a pedestrian walking in the road. And I'm sure that's a combination of things. It's not only the element of darkness, it's also the narrowness of that section, those four sections, all four roads. And so as we work through this, hopefully we can at least address that issue.
46:45 Whether it's lighting, whether it's just trying to move the snow, it's primarily a winter time issue, but there was one incident that was in the summer. And whether speed was an issue as it relates to that, I don't know. But just so that we can provide a little safer buffer margin for numerous pedestrians. Now, as Mark pointed out, if trails become part of our solution for this, it may be less of an issue.
47:14 Alternatives for people as far as being able to get around in Sierra Valley Estates off of the roads network. Snow removal. We've been called now this winter twice to two different complexes in Sierra Valley Estates where the owner has chosen not to haul snow. And so what they've done is they've basically pushed snow off to the side and forced their tenants to park initially in
47:43 They were parking in the designated parking spots. That area got filled with snow. They had pushed snow as far back as they could. At this point, then they started taking a couple of the parking spots and created snow storage out of those. So the residents were forced to park in the access route that gets you back to where the parking spots are. Well, that started filling in with snow as well, the far end, and it forced a couple of people in that complex to park out on the road.
48:13 They got ticketed, they got hauled away, and so it's probably a long-term issue as far as there are designated spots identified when projects first proposed and built, but then it becomes an enforcement issue as far as trying to maintain those designated parking spots so that the residents at those locations have some place to park other than
48:44 Either forcing themselves to have to pull out in order to let the person who's parked in front of them being able to be able to get out in some kind of a sequential fashion. What they were doing, there were four cars stacked in front of each other in a line. All three of them would have to move if the person who was at the front wanted to get out. And that occurred in two different complexes in Sierra Valley Estates.
49:13 In conjunction with the town, code compliance, we think we've resolved that issue, or at least we've put the individual owner on notice that that's an unacceptable arrangement. Now, is that also like a health and safety issue for you of getting access if there was an emergency to those properties to where you would be able to notice the owner of the property?
49:35 Besides our code enforcement? And that's why we got involved. Okay, go ahead. Two reasons, parking out on the road and secondly, parking in that access route in order to be able to get into the building, get access to the building itself. Tom, why would the fire department be called as opposed to the police department? Police department was called. They did what they needed to do and that was ticket and haul away the vehicle. And they also talked to the owner because the owner admitted that, but he didn't really do anything as far as the parking.
50:04 Arrangement goes for, in particular, for this one condo project, or one apartment building. It's an apartment building, not a condo. Other issue pertaining to snow removal, a lot of the buildings, because they are older, when we get a winter such as this, people are shoveling roofs in order to be able to lighten the load on the roof. That ends up blocking all of the secondary egress for windows on the first story, and in some cases, actually, on the second story.
50:38 And so, again, that's a life safety issue. We go around and notify all of the owners and, for that matter, the tenants because we actually get better compliance from the tenants to either keep their own windows open or to continue to put pressure on the owners to shovel those areas out or to keep contacting us so that we can go back and continue to remind the owners that they've got a responsibility to maintain those windows open. In some cases, the owners have chosen to put up plywood.
51:08 Go in and physically block the windows so that as snow sheds off the roof, if they have a shedding roof or as snow gets shoveled off the roof, it doesn't come down and break windows. Well, again, that's contrary to code and that's something that the owner needs to take care of. It's just an ongoing maintenance issue. Trails, we're going to work as hard as we can with the town if we do create a trail network. That trail works double as a fire lane.
51:39 So that we actually are able to have some kind of a mechanism with which to move around in Sierra Valley Estates, especially if we're able to work something on the east end of Dorrance that will work out onto Chaparral or Arrowhead or, you know, the complexes to the east. That is definitely an area where we've got some pretty marginal transportation problems and we have very limited access into that.
52:08 Sierra Valley Estates. Ice buildup was brought up and we do go around and the handicap that the town has is unless a building permit is pulled, it makes it very difficult for the building department to get into a facility. And yes, there are hazards that develop, but it's very difficult to address those hazards.
52:35 Through the building side of things, but on the fire side of things, it actually works out very easily for us to go in and tell owners that they need to provide for a safe environment for their tenants or for their family for that matter. Most cases, individual single-family homes aren't nearly as big of an issue as the multifamily residential ones. And then to the trailer parts, and I don't know to much of a degree.
53:06 How Housing and Community Development deals with municipalities. But fire districts, it's filled out in the code. Fire districts have the ability to go in and request that we enforce life safety codes in trailer parks. And so we've done that. We're in the process of finalizing that process with all the trailer parks in town. So that'll be not only Sarah Holiday, it'll also be ski trails. And it actually also will be the RV park on Forest Service land because that's also under.
53:35 a state license, even though it's on federal land. What that does is it allows us to go in and enforce our codes. We can enforce those codes for construction as well as for ongoing maintenance and life safety requirements. So I'm almost positive, in fact, I am positive that building codes are not something that housing and community development
54:04 Want to give that jurisdiction to the local municipalities or to the counties for that matter. They see that as a responsibility that they need to keep. But we're going to use this, and we've had extensive conversations with a couple different inspectors. We're going to use this to improve the propane and electrical hookups that exist at both parks. There's an extensive list of responses that we've had.
54:35 Dealing with propane, and we've had, as those of you who've been here for a while, we've had a couple of explosions, we've had some near fatalities, and so we're going to go forward with enforcing the life safety issues that are necessary in mountainous terrain in the wintertime, which it's not that housing and community development do not recognize that and do not acknowledge that it's a problem.
55:03 They just don't have the staff that comes here during the winter months to deal with the problems. Will that be, let's say, snowshed-type structures in the mobile home park that are being used for wood storage? It's going to be a combination of things. It will probably be an improvement of the actual structure. The state has a designated design, which works fine in areas where you only have a couple feet of snow, but once you've buried those things, they require a flex tube that goes from
55:31 The propane pedestal into the trailer, and it's for seismic purposes, which makes sense. The problem is that when you get ice surrounding that flex tube, it just stretches it to the point that it's the weak link in the design. Thank you for that, Tom. Ellen, could we make sure that's where Tom brought up his trap. Tom, and then Elizabeth's going to have a question for you also.
56:00 About the accident reports, could we also have that included for council, not only the accident reports, but any kind of citations, moving violations from the police department? Yeah, I believe we can obtain that data. Because, and I think it's important to know if they're speeding related and, or if they're alcohol related accidents, but more for the speeding related citations and that to really build the case for what, like, Gary and others have spoke about.
56:26 Elizabeth? Thank you. Tom, you really got my attention with second floor egress because we're so buried in old Mammoth. I have the lights on all day, every day. We can get out the first floor but can't get out the second floor so I have to deal with that. You mentioned about the color of the propane tanks. The three tanks, the storage, I don't know what you call them, that, what's the name of the company down in Bishop? It's Kenny Lloyd. I can't think what the name of this company is. Low Gas. Low Gas, that's right. They're painted medium green and there's a,
56:55 A community tank or a neighborhood tank at Red Fur and Old Mammoth Road. It's also painted medium green. Now, does the fire department have the authority to cite the owner of that tank because of the color it's painted? How did that happen, I wonder? I mean, up on Red Fur, up on Red Fur. We don't cite anybody if we don't have to. What we're trying to do is get it through the appliance. And the propane companies, they're obviously in it for a profit.
57:24 A tank gets too warm and it begins to off-gas, there are profits going out of the tank and into the air. Sure. Let alone the safety issues associated with it. So we've been very successful in having propane companies go in and lighten the colors for those tanks that were painted dark colors because they don't want to lose their gas. Okay. Makes sense. Thank you. Thank you, Tom. The podium is still open. My name is Mary Shore.
58:04 And I've been talking to some of the neighbors around, and they had some input, and I'll pass that along. One was in regards to the underground utilities that was mentioned, I think, on the 23rd or last meeting. The person has lived in the neighborhood a lot longer than I have, and she could recall a tree falling on the lines.
58:33 causing outage for a considerable period of time and also with the clumps of snow falling on the utility. So not only for the aesthetic reasons but perhaps doing the utilities underground helps with the safety and service. And my other neighbor had some comments about the pedestrian traffic which we all love.
59:03 to walk in the neighborhood, and not only just for fun, but to get here and there too. And she was concerned about the Sierra Valley sites, one, where the twisty roads are, and she, walking in the wintertime is especially hazardous with, she was siting one area, I think it was on Lupin Street, where there was a tree and
59:33 Dumpster and getting out into the road and really making the Kirby Road more narrow. So those are two considerations. And Chairman Barrett, you were talking about height and we never did talk on the last meeting about the height and I hope that the height limit.
1:00:00 It's going to remain at 35 feet? Yeah, what I was referring to is we do have our zoning code update group that's been working on the zoning code updates to work with our new general plan. So that area we haven't had any discussion about anything higher in residential. It's been more about Old Mammoth Road and Main Street areas for commercial and lodging.
1:00:28 I don't see myself personally residential being, you know, any given any more height than what you already have. Thank you. Thank you. All right, is there anyone else? Okay. Yeah, my name is Mike Shore. We live at 390 Lupin. And there are just a few things that have occurred to me since the last meeting. And first of all, of course, you've got to realize that
1:01:08 The area is really nice as it is, and everybody does like it, but there are some things that could be improved, and one is the 35-foot height limit. That's important, I think, to everyone. Something that I have a feeling about is the concept of building a sidewalk along the north side of Meridian.
1:01:32 And that would, because people do enjoy walking, but there are no sidewalks and there's no real designated area, so if that meridian north side, meridian sidewalk to be there, I mean it's been talked about and there are portions of it, but if that could be there, that would be great. There's one, this is something that is important to me and that's the fact that we do have an area of blight,
1:02:03 And that's the palace development that's where I think there are five units completed and five units that have been under construction since we came along in 2008. And then there are just another group of sites where all the building materials just sit and the whole thing just sits. And I don't know what can be done about that, but it blights our area.
1:02:31 And then on the utilities, this is something we've, Mary mentioned it, but another idea, if those utilities were to be placed underground, if you've got the aesthetics, and then the winter breakage and disruption that you get from the snow, and then also undergrounding those utilities, that takes away the poles and provides more space possibly for walking paths and areas. And then the last item,
1:03:01 Okay, thank you. And just to address the Talis issue for you.
1:03:31 That project did go back to the lender, and the lender has been working with the staff. I think after the winter is over in spring, you'll start seeing some work there. They are looking at completing that project, and they are working with staff on that. So you will see that whole Talus project move forward. I understand what you're saying about that also. And, you know, just kind of a generalization for folks on underground utilities.
1:03:59 The town has done many studies on undergrounding all of the utilities in town over the years, and new development now has to put in underground utilities for their projects, so that's why you see the gaps. But if I'm not mistaken, I want to say it was somewhere between like $45,000 and $50 million to actually do underground utilities for the entire town, so that's been the big...
1:04:26 Elephant in the room is where do we come up with $45 to $50 million to do that. But it's something that, and that's why you've heard a lot about it over the years, is that it's something that I think everyone wants to see. It's just the cost factor. But we do have, as I said, when new development is done, they must put in underground utilities, including no housing. Good morning. I'm Hennity with Mammoth Lakes Housing. I just wanted to talk a little bit about the workforce housing in this neighborhood. You know, we've built three projects.
1:04:56 The mountain has several complexes in there as well. And, you know, we are concerned and want to make sure that this is, when we think about housing our community, whether you call it workforce housing or affordable housing, this neighborhood really represents a large population of homes where people who live and work in our community call home. And that's really what we're striving to achieve, no matter what really label you put on it.
1:05:22 The goal is to provide safe and decent homes for people who want to live and work here. And we have no plans for new development at any time in this neighborhood or any others, but as we've talked about a couple of weeks ago, we are excited about the opportunities available to rehabilitate existing complexes. And while there are a lot of very nice, well-kept
1:05:44 Multifamily complexes in the Sierra Valley sites. There are some who are in desperate need of some love and attention. So we want to just sort of make that known. You know, we have a variety of tools to be able to provide housing, whether it be down payment assistance, we can help to continue to stabilize the neighborhood by getting people who work in town into homeownership situations with our down payment assistance in this neighborhood.
1:06:09 And there are a lot of opportunities to be able to go in and help rehabilitate, whether they're owner-occupied homes, there's funding out there available for that, so if we start seeing a need for owner-occupied rehabilitation loans, we can start getting involved in that, or as we're doing on Old Mammoth Road, buying an existing complex from somebody who maybe hasn't kept it up as well as they should have, and making those improvements to the community.
1:06:37 Just want to keep that in mind as we move forward. Pam, it might be worth noting that the property you're talking about in Old Mammoth is going to be four units, correct? Yes. And out of the existing, are there three tenants there now?
1:06:53 Well, there's only two tenants that live there now. Okay, but those two are going to stay there after it's correct? Right, they're going to come. So it may well be that if we explore the reasons that the residents of Sierra Valley sites are opposed to new housing like this, that kind of a situation, if you do that, they may not have any objection to. Right, I mean, because we're going into that complex and really improving.
1:07:19 The building for the people who already do live there. So we'd be excited and would like to explore those opportunities because there are a lot of complexes in the Sierra Valley sites that could use some improvement where people are living now and they're living in substandard conditions and we can help improve their lives and quality of life. Again, I'll just give you props because some of the photos that we've had regarding the three projects in the Sierra Valley sites over the years have come to the other side and actually now support what...
1:07:49 You've put there and how they're being operated, so I commend you for that. Thank you. All right, then. We will move into our discussion. So, Ellen, would you like to take each section from the commission and move through as we go through? Well, you know, I'd like to discuss the study areas. Yeah, I think we move through the three framework components and deal with the boundaries first. So do you want to go ahead and take that and we'll, so it keeps you.
1:08:19 Organized? Otherwise, I'm going to bounce around a little bit. So if you have questions on boundaries first, we'll take those. Commissioner Clark? No questions about boundaries. Commissioner Tenney? No, I don't. Actually, I do have a question. I'm confused. What is this complex right here inside that rectangle? That's a Stonegate project. Oh, Stonegate, of course it is. Okay.
1:08:50 Thank you. No, I don't have any questions on boundaries. I do have a question on the map, though. I do, too. Yeah, well, I have a question on the boundary about extending it, so maybe once we get through it. Okay, why don't we do map next? Yeah. Or do you want me to ask my question now? Let's do map next. Okay. Commissioner Bacon? No boundary question, no. So my question on the boundary is, and we've heard it a couple times today regarding chaparral and arrowhead drive.
1:09:15 And we've had the discussion, it's in the past meetings, it's in our agenda here, we talked about the shady rest track there, and that's kind of sitting off to the side, but it's going to be addressed. But the area of Chaparral and Arrowhead Drive, you have Mammoth, you've got the mountain housing at the end of Chaparral, it curves around, there's a piece of property there that's vacant, that's also owned by the mountain, that's been discussed about for employee housing.
1:09:44 You have some arrowhead complex, and you have some other complexes there, duplexes, fourplexes, along chaparral, and those are going to be directly affected by anything that happens within Sierra Valley sites and or shady rest. And I noticed where we put the old Cunningham property into the boundary, and I'm curious why we could not add that section of chaparral and arrowhead into the boundary and not the sphere of influence because
1:10:11 It's going to really, you know, drainage issues. Everything is going to affect that little pocket of properties there. And that's a lot of locals that live there. Can you and Ellen point out exactly where you are? Yeah, Ellen. It's right here. Yeah, it's right here. It's a section right there. No, it's right here. It's a section right there.
1:10:34 Yeah, if you just, if you come down from Arrowhead, so not Sierra, not Sierra Park, but if you, let me do it for you. Okay. Probably should have done this earlier, I apologize. Which street is Arrowhead? Okay, this is Chaparral and this is Arrowhead. Yeah, and that encompasses the Wildrose condos.
1:11:08 That's the mountain lot, that's the mountain lot that's, right, bacon, right. Okay, Mark, you want to? I'll show this to you. Okay, and Chaparral is? This is Chaparral. Got it. Okay, thank you. And part of that, too, is that Chaparral and all the plans for Shady Rest is going to connect into the Shady Rest tract as a connector road.
1:11:35 And then it will connect somehow to Sierra Valley sites as well. So I just think if we don't include that, it's going to create problems down the road. And my recollection from walking in that area is that those properties within what you, on those two streets, are, have much more in common with the character and so on with the Sierra Valley sites than they do with the things abutting them on the others. Yeah. Yeah, the only thing that you could say possibly doesn't is the wild rows and the other.
1:12:04 Well, even that's a small property.
1:12:06 What's the one across from that, Tom?
1:12:09 Timber Valley.
1:12:11 So, right here, this is Arrowhead Condos, and then Timberline here, and then you've got these over here.
1:12:21 Was there some reason you left the land out?
1:12:24 This land?
1:12:25 This one, because it's the mill?
1:12:27 Well, it's, I've...
1:12:29 So it doesn't.
1:12:29 Yeah, it's, it's...
1:12:31 The Mountain, and I mean it could be added in, but that's already the Mountain purchased that in 98, 97 for employee housing. You know, it could be included. I was going to say that would certainly make sense. And I would be fine with including that in there. It's not an issue if you wanted to include that. The east west line there is the southern boundary of the area. Yes. You're talking about that parking. Yeah, there you go. Yeah, just like that. Yes, that makes more sense. Is there a consensus for that?
1:13:02 Agreed. Thank you. Yeah. Okay, anything else on the study area? This is a map question. Anyone in the public wishing to make a comment on what we've just done there by that addition? All right. So next would be the guiding principles, which are listed now. Move into the map issue, please. Oh, I'm sorry. Okay. Elizabeth. Thank you. I'm trying to remember.
1:13:38 Refresh my memory about these streets that go through. I know where Tavern Ends in a cul-de-sac, and it's the southeast corner of the, what was the name of that project? Shady Rest Road? Shady Rest Track. Project was Hidden Creek. Hidden Creek Crossing. Hidden Creek, yeah, Hidden Creek Crossing or something. And then, yeah, that's Tavern, and there's a cul-de-sac there. So then the bottom boundary of the Hidden Creek Crossing or Shady Rest Site is not a road, correct?
1:14:08 Correct. That's just a line. Yes. Is that the road when we were discussing Hidden Creek years ago that we thought should be a connector, a future road that should be a connector with the Sierra Valley site? We have, as you recall... I can't remember how that came out. If you recall in the Main Street program that we just completed, we're showing a connection of Chaparral through the Hidden Creek crossing area so that it...
1:14:38 Generally heads northeast and connects to Center Street. Yes, I remember. Okay, I remember that. And then also extends a roadway to the east so that it ultimately connects up with Tavern Road. So there's a street network in there, and that's in your downtown. Okay, and does it connect with Dorrance? Was there any plan to do that, try and do that? No, that's not part of that project. There is a pedestrian connection from Manzanita.
1:15:04 That would connect to the Shady Rest site. And as you know, there's that wetland area in there that makes, you know, putting a road in there would be, you know, other than right-of-way issues would be. Yeah, the two properties there on Doran, so let's put that, are I think six plexes or it has the creek that runs through that floods over almost every year that runs into the wetlands.
1:15:25 Shady Rest, so we've always looked away from doing any kind of a road there. That's where Chaparral, though, coming back in, connects with Center Street and up to Tavern and the Shady Rest Track. Okay. Mark's got a map here. He's got a map here. Oh, this is going to help. Yeah, because that was years ago, and I can't remember how we planned to do it. Yeah. This is Center Street, the extension to Chaparral, and cross connections to...
1:15:58 Tavern and Laurel. Aha, okay, I see. But that connection looks like it goes through to Dorrance and Tony just said there were three issues there. He's going to send her to where? Oh, wow, great.
1:16:19 Just where that road went through and now you have clarified it, so I understand now. Okay. Thank you. Any other questions on the map? Any other questions on the map? Yes. Okay. Commissioner Clark? Ellen and I talked about this when we've heard so much about connectivity and trails.
1:16:49 I was hoping we could get a map that would illustrate. And Ellen thinks we can do this so that we actually know where there is an easement, where there is a possible easement. Yes. And plans for that so that we can see that on our map. At the next meeting we'll have a lot more additional background information including mapping of planned and proposed trails, storm drain and town easements. And the other thing we talked about was the drainage.
1:17:19 If we could see the drainage on the map. Please. Yes. So is that going to be before it goes to Council on April 7th? Probably not. Well, we could. Well, you said next meeting. The difference is that in identifying the scope of work and issues, we all know that we want to see trails that are connected, so we're not trying to present to you all the planning work that has already been done. So, you know, we have the mobility plan, we have the trail system master plan,
1:17:50 And we have a stormwater management plan, too. So through this process, we'll bring those existing studies forward so we can actually see where we don't have complete connections or where we do have inadequacies and issues that should be addressed. So that's really the body of work. So we're not trying to re-show that to you right now. So are you saying then that you don't think that everything that's been brought up so far and that's going to continue isn't going to affect?
1:18:20 Going to Council on the 6th, do you think it should come back to this body first, then go to Council the second meeting? I think we all understand that we want to see trails, and so that's what the body of planning work would accomplish. This is the scope of work. We have the right boundaries. Do we all agree that we want to study trail connections and everybody's saying yes? Do we all agree that we need to study traffic flow and everybody's saying yes? Storm drain? Yes.
1:18:50 And so that's the work that needs to be done. So you're comfortable with that, Commissioner? Just so long as we can see it. I'm much better with pictures. And one question about drainage. When you talk about showing drainage, can that include, is it impossible to include the historical stream flow? There was some discussion at the workshop a month ago about some streams that used to be in there. I think our storm drain study would illustrate that information. Good.
1:19:18 Ray is shaking. I'm looking at Ray. Nodding. Nodding. Nodding. This is nodding. This is shaking. Do we still have the ducks to put out there? The ducks. Ducks. Ducks. Ducks. Any other mapping issues? In terms of the subject area that we're studying, so I think that sounds like we're done. Yes.
1:19:45 Okay, so next would be the guiding principles that are included in attachment two, which as I mentioned are drawn from the general plan, and also we have a number of principles for livable, just generally speaking to this as a livable workforce neighborhood. Questions, concerns, additions? Attachment. Commissioner Clark? Yes, under B, number six.
1:20:15 I was wondering if we could include with parking, B, at number 6 under B, parking on property, off street. Now that, I don't know what the other commissioners think, but I mean, I just think for public safety issue, we simply have to consider. I would have assumed all that was included. Oh, you thought parking meant on the property and not in the street? Both.
1:20:44 Yeah. Well, I'd like to, could we put it in writing? Yes. Yeah, because we have, yeah, there's no on-street parking in the winter, but it's fine to have it still put in there. And I was hoping to, that we might consider under B, adding a number nine, that the dumpsters would be off-road in the summertime. We understand it's difficult in the wintertime because the trucks can't get back.
1:21:13 But surely in the summertime, we can get the dumpsters in the back of the properties.
1:21:19 There's something, if I may add on to what Commissioner Clark has brought up and Commissioner Tenney alluded to earlier, and that is neighborhood dumpsters, if there could be a discussion regarding that, because with the direction that Mammoth Disposal was gone recently, that the council went about curbside service, you know, perhaps there's areas within
1:21:43 then.
1:21:43 You know, walking distance on each road that community dumpsters can be put in that have, you know, coverings with them, that have barriers around them, that then the whole district would take part in for, you know, access and then also payment. Something has to be done about that as a district. But it might be something to look at and that alleviates all the dumpsters on all the properties in all different areas.
1:22:07 And that would even take care of the wintertime. Exactly. Especially for the winter and then the bears in the summer too. And it improves the aesthetics. And it improves the aesthetics of the area too. And a lot of communities use the community dumpsters not only for condo complexes but for housing and planned communities. Anything else? Well, I guess after hearing Tom Heller speak, when did we change from Sierra Valley Estates?
1:22:36 To Sierra Valley sites. It's always been Sierra Valley sites. I do know that. If you're interested, you've raised a couple of questions about the history of the airwood, so perhaps that's one of the subjects you'd like us to do some amount of research on, the history of how it was established. You've asked us to look at CCNRs and its evolution of zoning.
1:23:02 I think the original, during the county's years, and that it was Sierra Valley Estates, and that's why the quarter acre lots. And then it became Sierra Valley Sites, and, well, the ghetto. Which I still think is a great word. It's where I moved my family to when we first moved here. We loved it, so. Sierra Valley Estates actually shows up as a recording. I'm sorry, Tom? Yeah, that's how it's recorded from what it was originally done. Well, good heavens, we ought to be appropriate and proper.
1:23:31 And call it how it's recorded, if it's Sierra Valley Estates. A lot of people don't even know it's called Sierra Valley Estates. I'm sorry, Ellen. So a lot of people don't even know it's called Sierra Valley Estates when you say that. I'd like to call it Sierra Valley. I mean, you know. And to bring up, not to bring up the R word again, but that's part of the lawsuit with redevelopment is because it was called Estates and how could Estates need redevelopment? Well, thank you for my history lesson. Tony, I have something. Sure. On guiding principles, number four on the first page.
1:24:01 I think we should indicate, since we're talking about trail connections and access roads for the fire trucks, linear parks as well, along with pocket parks, because there may be opportunities there. It's amazing how little space it takes to have a linear park. So pocket and linear, is that what you're saying, Elizabeth? Yeah, just adding linear parks to the list. We didn't address anywhere, specifically, again, Mr. Heller's comment about
1:24:42 Utilizing paths and trails for emergency vehicles are certainly fire trucks. I don't know if we could write that in somewhere. We'll add that to A3 under trail and pedestrian emphasis with emergency access. Thank you. Anything else? Anything from the public? So the final piece would be the issues list, passion 3.
1:25:23 Are there any additional issues that you would add here? Anything that's missing or should be deleted? We'll move on to that. Commissioner Tenney? Yes. Number 8 on page 16 of the handwritten. I think it's really important to express this that safety versus dark skies is not a trade-off. What the whole outdoor lighting, and I wish Gary were still here because he would support this 300%.
1:25:55 What the whole outdoor lighting ordinance is about is no glare and putting the light where it's needed. And if you need an example, and I've mentioned this in some Planning Commission meetings before, of how light where it's needed still enables you to see the sky at night, is drive to Lancaster at the Auto Mall, which I think the parking lot for the new cars requires its own power plant. There is so much wattage down there. And yet because the lights are full cut off and shining down,
1:26:22 You can look above those fixtures and in Lancaster you can see the night sky. So rather than say how can the potential addition of safety oriented lighting be balanced, that sounds like a tradeoff and that bothers me because if there's no glare and no light trespass and we have more lights, you know, for pedestrian safety, then you won't have
1:26:45 The problem, the neighborhood can still enjoy the dark skies. The drivers will not have light shining in their eyes, which prevent them from seeing the pedestrians. The pedestrians can see the ground where they're walking so they aren't injured. I don't like the phrasing of issue number eight. How should it be designed to maintain or, you know, designed and placed? Or, you know, adding more lighting, adding more no-glare lighting without light trespass.
1:27:14 You know, the balanced is the word that bothers me because balanced to me implies trade-off and this is something I'm fighting all the time trying to get people to realize it's the glare that's the problem. What about if you just say how can, you know, how... Compatible, compatible's good. Or how about just how to, you know, safety orientated lighting that complies with the Dark Skies ordinance.
1:27:40 Yeah, because that is no glare and no light is best. Because your whole issue is no glare, overheads, things like that, and so you've got the ordinance, so you just have to apply the ordinance to whatever you're doing. I don't think you need to create anything else. And it's that classic thing, somebody shines a flashlight in your eyes, you can't see. If they shine it at the ground, you can see where you're walking. That was my only thing on the issues. I thought otherwise it was a good compendium. Commissioner Clark? I have problems with both 12 and 13.
1:28:12 I've heard time and again that we have enough workforce housing, so I don't, and Ellen and I spent quite a bit of time and she was helping me with this because apparently workforce housing gets automatic, doesn't automatically, but can go up to double density, which means 24 units per lot, and there's no way.
1:28:41 It seems to me that we can do 24 units and 24 cars. I just don't know if we can do it. Perhaps the question should be what is the appropriate density and then mix of housing, including workforce housing. You posed the question of what is the density and what's the appropriate mix. Okay, I just think we need to address that. That's what we've heard so many times.
1:29:13 So we've heard and we've documented the issues about a sense of density. It may in some cases be too high, and there is perhaps a concentration of workforce housing. So we understand that issue. So the question is, what is the mix and what's the density? Well, I think as Pam brought up also, and as we know, with the economic times we're in now and that we're going to be in for a number of years in the future, that we're looking more at rehabs.
1:29:42 Then actually acquiring property and, you know, there was a time there, Commissioner Clark, when the property that was vacant, like for Manzanita properties and that, that was available property, there was nothing there. So that's why we had the larger complexes, let's say, of employee housing, workforce housing. When you go through that whole site today, there's very little land left that...
1:30:10 Would be developed into that manner that we've already done. So I think the available densities that are there, you know, if somebody puts in, takes a home down and they can put in a fourplex, then the requirement of the town provides for a unit to be workforce housing. And that's where that density comes in at. So I guess what I'm trying to say is I don't think we're going to see measurable development of what Mammoth Lakes Housing has already done in the past.
1:30:40 At Sierra Valley Science, it's going to be more infill of already existing units. Well, and that'll certainly enable the neighborhood to improve in terms of what they have done with rehabs. But it is an issue, and I think maybe the way Mark phrased it would speak to the point. Yeah, thank you. We understand your issue. And then on 13, you said you had an issue also? Well, I think they were...
1:31:12 They both pretty much say the same thing. And of course the other issue is parking and what the number of units require in terms of parking. Can those be addressed in our zoning code user group updates, Mark, with the zoning code? Yes. Because that might be an appropriate place for them as we move through the zoning code to readdress them. Okay. And the only other thing is just I want to...
1:31:42 Comma between Main Street and Sierra Star on number 16. Thank you. Please. Thank you. I forgot to mention that on Monday afternoon. Elizabeth. One more on 28. I remember in the workshop we had that they specifically talked about they wanted to be in the forest. They really liked being in the forest. And so I think we should add to fuel tree reduction and or limbing.
1:32:17 Because sometimes for the fire department, limbing is enough. So you don't have fire ladders. What number is she? 28. 28. Okay, I'm sorry, Elizabeth, what did you want to? She had the limbing instead. Fuel tree reduction and or limbing. Oh, okay. You know, limbing. Yeah, so laddering on the trees. Yeah, so you don't, eliminating fire ladders. Okay. Anything else? Okay. Okay, I guess very quickly, I'm just looking here at mine.
1:33:01 Number 22, how can adequate and convenient parking best be provided? And, Tony, that goes back to your zoning code update, don't you think? Right. Yes. Okay. Thank you. That would. Ron? No, I think the questions are left, so the questions we should be working on. Okay. One general area that I wonder if we need to make a little more effort to capture, what about issues
1:33:31 that may be expressed by owners or residents of adjacent areas within the sphere of influence. I don't think there was anyone at the workshop a month ago or here that represented any of those areas. The one area of our discussion I recall at the workshop that touched on that was when we were talking about the issues with traffic and ways to
1:33:57 Calm the traffic and that there was someone mentioned that some of the business owners on Main Street were concerned about how this would impact their business. But I wonder if there needs to be a little effort made to see if there are some issues we haven't captured from, not from residents within Sierra Valley estates, but the surrounding areas. Just a general comment for all of the issues. And following up on that too, Sierra Influence with Sierra Star added into that, purpose of that.
1:34:29 I mean, it's gotten us into trouble in the past with the golf course being involved in things. The reason that we have the sphere covering that particular area is the stormwater runoff. The sheet flow has suggested that there's a sheet flow issue that relates specifically to the golf course. We also have some, you know, trail connectivity issues that have been raised. And then we also have...
1:34:56 Just south of Main Street, the idea of the mid-block mobility diagram showing some connection. And again, the focus of the sphere is to realize and acknowledge that there are issues outside of the study area that affect the study area. And it is not our focus in Sierra Star, for example, that we're looking at land use issues. That's covered through the south district process.
1:35:30 So could the bell-shaped parcel be included in that sphere of influence, means it's open space, now considered it could be used for recreation? It could be, but it's specifically included in the south districts. It's a piece of cake to change the line, but its focus is being discussed as we speak. Okay, that's fine. All right, anything else? Anything from the public on our...
1:35:57 Anything that we've missed? Anything you think should be added in, taken out? We still have more time, too, to do this written in stone at this point. It does go to council, and you can readdress issues there if they come up. All right. Ellen? Could we go back to the idea of what we're going to call this? I like to hear what you said, Elizabeth, about Sierra Valley. But if, in fact, if it's recorded as Sierra Valley Estates, I...
1:36:30 Would like for the Commission to start, and everybody else, start calling it Sierra Valley Estates. Maybe we need to know a little bit more about the history before we understand what really is the... And I think that's what we asked about. We asked for the... The evolution. Yeah. Okay, thank you. This is a topic for future discussion.
1:36:53 Would it be helpful to take out Sierra Valley right now and take out sites? Don't worry about the states. The district is listed as the Sierra Valley district. Yeah. That's the name. So I think we would ask you the historical content. I know Bill Souser has the historical value of two of what he calls it and others that have lived there for many, many, many years. Good, good. Thank you. Just wanted to get back to that. Okay, Ellen.
1:37:23 With that, I would recommend that the Planning Commission approve the Sierra Valley Neighborhood District Planning Framework consisting of the boundary, guiding, sphere of influence, guiding principles and preliminary issues as modified by the Planning Commission, recommending approval of that with those modifications suggested today. Any further discussion? Motion?
1:37:51 I move that we recommend to Town Council approval of the Sierra Valley Neighborhood District Planning Framework with the modifications and amendments that we have made in the discussion today. Second. Okay, we have a motion and a second. Is there any further discussion? Okay. We don't need a roll call on this, so all in favor? Aye. Aye. Okay, motion passes 5-0. Thank you folks for being here today and participating, and we look forward to the future of you doing so as well.
1:38:23 This is really moving forward. It's good. And it's very, very exciting because I think there has been some concern in that area. I mean, it really looks positive, I think. All right, we'll move on to briefing matters or none, director's report. Briefly, on our work program status, we have about 10 chapters. Thank you, Ellen. We have about 10 chapters left to go on the zoning code update.
1:38:54 And at your April 13th meeting, the focus of the agenda will be on the zoning code update. You'll be considering six draft chapters, as well as holding two workshop items. One on the parking ordinance. We're targeting Nelson Nygaard to come and give a presentation on the approach to establishing a more timely set of parking requirements for the town.
1:39:23 And we'll also hold a workshop on Heighton, Mass. This will be a workshop for the Planning Commission to prepare for an early May joint meeting with the Town Council. And that's what Chair Barrett mentioned with the zoning code committee having a review of the methodology of our parking. So after the 13th, we'll have four chapters left.
1:39:50 to go to complete the zoning code update. So it's moving again quickly and on time and on our scope of work. The South District's neighborhood district planning effort is also moving along quickly. We just completed our second focus group meeting yesterday morning. The group met from 9 to about 11 and established
1:40:20 I think considerable consensus about the focus of the south districts. As you'll recall, it includes the Sierra Star area. It includes the bell-shaped parcel. It includes Mammoth Creek as well as the south area of Old Mammoth Road. There is a public workshop for that district plan. The graphics and information are on the wall. That is scheduled for tomorrow at 5 p.m.
1:40:46 And we think that with that workshop, we will then substantially stop and start writing a report. And I think we'll target a May presentation to the Planning Commission for that particular district planning effort. As you see, this one is moving forward, and we're on schedule to complete district planning this fiscal year as well. April 27th.
1:41:12 We have that targeted for two very important items. This is a big one. One will be tentative parcel map and use permit application, Terry Plum's project. And we expect that to be fairly controversial. I think you know it to be that way. Director Jarvis and I have been holding individual meetings with some of the key people that are in groups that are concerned with the project.
1:41:42 issues associated with the overall project proposal. They range from trails, access, the scale and scope of the staging area for the trails, and the parcel map itself and associated issues which we shouldn't discuss. I'm just letting you know that it's coming forward on the 27th. Also on the 27th, we have scheduled the public hearing for the adoption of the sign code.
1:42:10 So this will be the first public hearing. We're on track so far. Our research about some of the legal issues with signs, we're getting some very good information, and you, the Planning Commission and the Town Council, will have to weigh some meaty subjects about what's going to be allowable and what isn't. So those are the highlights of the work program right now. Of course, we're working on budget.
1:42:39 And so we, the collective staff, are very, very busy. I just want to make a mention to the public because we've received phone calls regarding the Plum Project and I just want to be clear, you know, I have to recuse on that. So direct your phone calls to Vice Chair Duncan so I don't have to tell you that on the phone.
1:43:02 I agree with you. It's going to be very controversial. I've had many calls, and I keep directing them back to Mark. So hopefully out there in the public, if you want to contact, please contact Vice Chair Duncan. Thanks. You're welcome. Well, it's hard. I mean, they call, and then I try to tell them I can't discuss this, and it's, yeah. Hello out there. Don't call me on it. Are we still on director's report? Yes, we are. A question? Okay.
1:43:31 Mark, you said previously with the zoning code update and the sign code and the rest of it that we're going to, in the next fiscal year, really up the code compliance efforts. Does that mean that the town would be considering in the next fiscal year's budget hiring a full-time officer? No. We will maintain our, what we'll suggest to the town council is that with the completion, substantial completion of district planning and zoning code,
1:43:58 We will have planning resources that we can shift from program and project work to code compliance. And so the staff member will just dedicate about 30% of their time or so to code compliance, joining the inspection services work group and focus on the zoning aspects, which are signs, not lights, that's somebody else, but signs, zoning issues.
1:44:27 And the sign code, you can imagine that with a new code, we will be rolling out public information first. Right. And we'll have, it's not our intent to run around with citations and penalize people. Our intent is to educate them about what's changed and what's permitted now. And that takes a lot of time to talk to businesses, walk in, responding to people who are putting up.
1:44:56 Banners and flags in the public right-of-way, for example. So it's not meant to be a heavy-handed approach. It's meant to be assistance. So by June 2011, we'll have a zoning code that is indeed consistent with our general plan. Yes, in a draft form. This June, so it was completed. We're going to then assemble a document, and we have to do CEQA, as you know, and we expect it to be a mitigated negative declaration.
1:45:25 We would expect formal adoption to occur somewhere around December of 2011. We're not doing any CEQA work until we have a project. So we need to complete the text itself and then integrate it all. Yeah, I forgot CEQA, of course, would apply to this. Thank you. Anything else, Mark? No, thank you. All right, that will no announcement of future meetings.
1:45:51 We will move into additional public comment. Seeing the one in the audience, Elizabeth, I apologize to you earlier, you asked about your sign project, and that's something you can do at public comment. Would you like to go down to the podium and just address the commission on that? Would you like me to? I'd be happy to. If you'd like to, because you asked about that earlier. I don't have to, but I'd be happy to. Well, that's kind of an appropriate place for it, and I have a couple comments for you. Well, thank you. And I apologize, I should have suggested that earlier at the first time. No, that's a good idea. In fact, I should do that regularly, so I'll see you.
1:46:24 The response is Elizabeth Tenney, private citizen for the Mammoth Community Gateway. No, the Mammoth Gateway Community Project. There we go. This is the project that I've taken on. It was suggested as something that would really benefit the town, but knowing the town has no financial capability to do it, I took it on because I really need a project.
1:46:48 Anyways, it's been, the response has been overwhelming. There is so much enthusiasm and so much support for it, and people are just stepping in and saying, well, I can do that, I can help you with this, I can help you with that. I went to the County Board of Supervisors last Tuesday, and they had had some issues, Supervisor Hazard in particular, when I went February 8th. We worked out those issues in a meeting with Supervisor Hazard.
1:47:15 John Urdi, Peter Berlusconi, Ryan, is it Ryan McDermody, is that his name, from Caltrans, worked out those issues that went back on March 15th, and it was 5.0, they were very much in favor of it. They raised a really interesting point, we're just talking about signs. They say we have too many signs coming in on 203, we really got a lot of clutter, and if you think about it, we've got old Forest Service things, we've got the Adopt-A-Highway signs, we've got the...
1:47:41 Just off 395, here's Mammoth's sign. I think there might be three Forest Service signs. And that's really something that would be interesting to discuss with John Urdi when we get into the branding, you know, start talking about the brand and stuff, how we could sort of update that entrance to town. Then on Wednesday, I made a presentation with town council. I think it was before town council, it was an hour and a half. And there was a little confusion about whether or not this was a town project. Not all of them were totally clear on that, but then they got clear on it.
1:48:11 And I was asking for in kind support, and we didn't have any figures for what it would cost in terms of value to have them waive the permits. I need a sign permit, I need a building permit, and what else do I need? The building permit includes grading. Does building include grading? It'll be combined. Yeah, okay, so that's what I would need, and I asked them to waive that, but we didn't have any numbers for them. So what they did, in order not to hold me up, because I want to get this done by November, it's just...
1:48:41 It's critical that we put a place forward for our visitors next winter and say we're still here for surviving and thriving. That's my mantra. They agreed that staff could go ahead with the engineering, which is quite complicated for this, that for just the monument portion, whether or not it will include a mammoth statue, some other kind of sculpture, no sculpture, whatever.
1:49:06 We'll wait and see. I'm going to go back on April 6th and ask for that additional approval. But I had a list of like eight things I wanted them to provide in-service, in-kind support. And, you know, Chuck Landy stepped out and said, well, I've got, you know, some dirt and I've got equipment and I've got labor. And I mean, people just stepping forward is wonderful. I mean, with Rusty next week to see Ralph the Mountain will participate. So people are really getting jazzed about it and I haven't even gone out.
1:49:30 You know, put out a press release and say I need money. I did get an email, though, somebody pledged $1,000 after seeing my presentation to town council, so I thought I did something right, so that was good. Anyway, we're doing fine, and I will continue to keep you updated as things develop. I have a suggestion for you. Yes, please. It's going to be very controversial, but I have not been controversial. So, you talked about the number of signs.
1:49:55 And how we have so many signs coming up the highway. I'm hearing this from people. That's what I've been hearing in emails and talking to folks. So I'm going to go out on a limb here, and this is no disrespect to the Public Art Commission whatsoever and their choice of a sign that they selected for down at the base of 203 by 395. But that was an allocation, I think, of $125,000, $150,000 maybe that was made.
1:50:23 I would like to see you propose to the council and have spoke to some council members about it, too, just so you know. But we really don't need that sign there. And your project is welcomed by everyone. It's a great sign. And I actually, like I said before, I think we should have two, one on each side of the road. And if you have that out in Utah, I read where you were talking about, you know, something with public art. So, I mean...
1:50:51 It's not an insult to the Public Art Commission, it's just that if something else comes along that actually would have a better use of their funds, perhaps you could go to them about incorporating and getting counsel to redirect those funds from that sign that was proposed that is pretty much disliked by many, many people in town, the cement mammoth sign.
1:51:11 And you combine those funds with what you have, and that would give you quite a bit of money to get this thing done immediately. And you would include the Public Art Commission, and perhaps you do put some, you know, they talked about wind spires of public art. Maybe that's something that can be incorporated in it, but you have this allocation of public money, that was public art money, $150,000, let's say $1,000, for a sign that really is not going to be consistent with anything else in town.
1:51:37 And if we want consistency in our signs throughout the town and up to the mountain, this may be the opportunity to do it. And so I'm going to throw that out there. I know it's the elephant in the room, but there it is, and what you do with it is up to you. I haven't gotten involved in any of that at all, but I will tell you, Tony, my goal is to get this done by November because there's so much enthusiasm and momentum, and I want to capitalize on that. And Mark has explained to me that if I go to the Public Art Commission,
1:52:07 Everything has to go out to bid, and there's no way it'll get done by November, whereas this way I have people stepping up and saying, I'll help, I'll do this, I'll do that, and we're just sort of like, you know, let's put on a play, you know, we're like a big gang, and it's working out well. So putting out to bid would really slow it down. Well, what's a 45-day period, isn't it? I think the RFP has to be out of 45 days, so. My suggestion to you, though, is a redirection of funds by the council, which the council has the authority to do that.
1:52:38 You know, I think, in fact, this was one of the discussion items at yesterday's South District's program. A series of graphics around the wall, of course you can't see, so there, they talk about community graphics, and it speaks to, first, the idea of a gateway and a hierarchy, which is consistent with Ms. Tenney's application.
1:53:05 The idea of community messaging, which is more of a public message program to identify events and festivals, 4th of July, and it's a big thing. Something that might be a banner program crossing the street, not little banners, but street-spanning banners. And then the idea of identifying some of the key public districts, you know, the shopping districts, the village, Old Mammoth Road, Snow Creek.
1:53:34 And then the final element is the idea of wayfinding. So that was discussed by the group. I think they felt that that was an important form of art and graphic communication for the town itself. So the options that you've, or the idea that you've suggested, public art funds, once determined to be art, can certainly be used for construction in the facility.
1:54:02 They can also be used for the design and permitting of the facility. So there's a couple of options to consider the use of public funds and the decision makers of the town council on that. I'll tell you, council did ask me, Mayor Harvey in particular, to go back to the Public Art Commission and then continue a communication with John Urdi at Mammoth Lakes Tourism. But when I go back, I'm going to talk about this idea that's been raised about something we wanted for years, a monument to all the Mammoth Olympians.
1:54:33 And what, you know, combining that somehow with the monument design, something that it would be a public art opportunity, it would be something the communities wanted for a long time. And that's another, you know, option to consider. So, that's it. Thank you. Thank you. All right, seeing no other public comment, we will adjourn our meeting to the next minute of April 13th at 2 p.m. Good to have you back, Sandra.