TransparentMammoth

Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2011

Planning & Economic Development Commission

· recording 3 hr 50 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

496 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:08 Would you please join me in the Pledge of Allegiance? I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Roll call, Karen? Here. Here. Here. Here. Here. Here.

0:45 Next, reports from the Commission. Sharon? None. Rhonda? Yes, I had the pleasure of last week of attending the Mountain Travel Symposium in Beaver Creek last week, and this is a major trade show where trade industry professionals get together that sell

1:08 So wintertime and mountain travel experiences and Mammoth was quite well represented here. Everyone knew about the amount of snow that we had and we tried not to rub it in when they only had about 400 inches there and thought that was amazing. And just the air service extremely well received and I've also had the pleasure this year to fly on every flight more than once.

1:37 This season, and it's so great to see full flights and very few locals. Not that I don't want to know friends on the flight. It is great to see a lot of guests, families, and people using it from all areas, especially San Jose and San Francisco. Very well received. Thank you. Thank you. Elizabeth.

1:58 I've got a couple things. I just wanted to report an interesting factoid in my project as a private citizen, you know, with the gateway to the entrance to town. I was telling somebody where it was, and I said, it's Thompson's Way. And I said, Thompson's is plural. It's not with an apostrophe. And it's after Glenn Thompson, our much respected and loved former town manager, and Helen Thompson, who was planning commissioner for many years, also much loved and respected.

2:25 And someone else said, well, if it's plural, what about snowshoe Thompson? So I thought we've got three Thompson's for Thompson's way. I would also like to, I've been thinking about this for some time. I'm just sort of in awe of how staff's pace has accelerated and what they're able to turn out, the quality, the caliber of the work.

2:47 the comprehensiveness of the work and they're just working like crazy and doing a great job but I would also like to pat us collectively on the back because since the layoffs and the budget constraints we have been trying to help as much as we can and I think our work products been pretty good and I feel I feel proud of our efforts because we're recommending policy based on considerable input from the community

3:15 input from staff, and we're deliberating in a really deliberative way, which I think is really good, and I think we've done a good job there, and I just wanted to say go planning commission. Okay, then my third thing is yesterday we had a focus group meeting with two commissioners from every one of the commissions, and also

3:38 Some people were in the focus group originally, a developer and some people from the Mammoth Lakes Housing Foundation and Jim Smith from the Mountain, and we're knitting together all these district plans, and it just makes so much sense. It just all comes together. It just, all we've been working on is really...

3:59 Just becoming very clear on what our next steps and our direction should be. Rhonda was there as well because this, of course, is, we're the resort investment subcommittee and it was all about investing in our community and our economic sustainability. So maybe Rhonda has something to add about yesterday's meeting. No, it was good that we were able to bring all the information together, form consensus, yes, we, and put certain issues to bed.

4:29 And move on to implementing these things. And so there's not a lot of debate because all of this came from the community. And so they're ready to see us. They don't have to be asked that same question again. Let's move forward on these particular issues, and that was great. It's been a very productive process. I've never felt like it was, you know, one step forward, two steps back. We just kept moving forward, got lots of input, and it's just, it's been really successful. Wouldn't you agree, Mark?

4:56 I hope so. I think it's been a good process. That's all I have to say. Thank you. Thank you. I have just one thing. A week or so ago, Lee Gosch called me and had a concern about something I hadn't even thought about that seemed to me something worth considering. She mentioned the trash containers that typically sit out front of a business that are for the convenience of customers of the business as opposed to

5:26 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

5:55 I think it's worth making a note of that and considering what can be done. I talked to Sandra about it and as she noted there are animal resistant versions of those as well. I know I've seen some, there's a lot around Lake Tahoe and I think we have some over in Mammoth Creek Park for example where you've got a lid which has to stick your fingers in and open.

6:21 Maybe there's, at some point, there should be an effort to adopt some of those for the ones that are in front of businesses, which typically I don't think are not very animal proof at all. And as Sandra mentioned, perhaps the town could work with Mammoth Disposal, maybe there's some grant money or something available for that. We'll follow up. That also increases the bear aware, the whole bear awareness kind of thing, so that's good. Plus it would solve a problem.

6:51 Okay, the next segment is our first opportunity for comments from the public. This portion of the agenda is an opportunity for the public to address issues that they would like to mention to us that are not on the agenda. Do we have anybody in the member of the public that would like to speak? Lee? I want to speak a little bit about what you just spoke about on the trash cans. It's something that Michael Grossblot was very passionate about and

7:24 He couldn't give out any fines or anything until it was brought into the zoning code update. He said we had to wait until this happens so if we can include it into the zoning code update that, you know, we need to be part of the process and not part of the problem. And it's not just for bears. There's raccoons that get into it and crows and coyotes and all kinds of animals. So if you go by Union Bank, they just replace bears. I know that Militar 6 replaced all bears. Did they have an animal proof?

7:53 Container? Is it? It does, yes. And Motel 6 has replaced theirs, but I'd like to be included into anybody who has a business because when you have a business, you should know what you're getting into when you come here and you need to be part of the process. Thanks. Thank you, Lee. Anyone else from the public? Okay, I see no other hands. Jay, excuse me, just to follow up on that, is it too late to incorporate that suggestion into our code update?

8:23 I'm not sure it goes into the zoning code update. It might go into our nuisances requirements or it might go into our street specifications. We'll look into it. If it's going to be part of the zoning code update versus the kind of equipment you put on the sidewalk and the street, we can sort it out and figure out where it goes. Great. Thanks.

8:45 Can I make a comment? Sure. I was just thinking, wouldn't it be nice when we get our new brand, which will be happening pretty soon, if we could have a sticker, a consistent sticker that went on all these containers, you know, about bears and Mammoth and the brand and the whole thing, which is sort of, it would be nice. And thinking of that, I know on my bumper sticker, I have, don't feed our bears. And so when we go to other locales, people want to know what that sticker means on our bumper, which I think is...

9:15 Interesting, because they don't understand in many, many, well, in most places. Well, that's true. People and bears do not inhabit the same four acres. And how many communities feel so proprietary about their bears? So, that's true. Thank you. I just see somebody, Mr. Cage, is just arriving. We're just ending up the public comment period. Did you have any comments?

9:46 Thank you very much, Tom Cage, property owner of one of the parsers. So this project is an experiment and we hope it will work. It is born of...

10:19 Skip here, so I have some reservations about it, but I think it's worth a try. I think it's worth an experiment. I think it might even answer and shed some light on other ideas that the town has had about possibly making the frontage road one way. And the only thing I can tell you is that I have some hesitation to it, and I want you to know that I'm considering it strictly.

10:48 A summertime experiment that we put into place for what's the current period? Mid-June until the end of September. Tom, that's on the agenda. I'm sorry. I didn't realize what, but if you want to elaborate on that when we get to that. So those were my only points. Okay. Yeah, I'm sorry I got in late. I was in the middle of the project. But otherwise, we'll have other chances to speak. Yeah. Okay. Thank you.

11:17 Okay, next segment is presentations, and our agenda item one is the Main Street Summer Circulation and Animation Project, and Ray, you're up. Thank you, Commissioner, Vice Chair, and Commissioners, and thank you for that introduction, Tom. You know, the title of this staff report, Circulation and Animation Project, it's really two things that in this proposal sort of go hand in blood.

11:46 You may recall, summer before last, two summers ago, we took a stab at this during the 4th of July weekend, and that experiment included events for 4th of July and included the idea of one-way vehicle circulation, a pedestrian corridor, which are all very attractive ideas, I think, and they're consistent with the downtown neighborhood district planning process.

12:14 That experiment, I think, was somewhat successful. It gave us an idea of what could be possible. Of course, you know, the million orange cones weren't really conducive to a real pleasing look and environment, but they served us for that weekend and helped us, you know, gain some insight into what we could do. You know, the idea of the circulation and animation project and

12:41 Expanding this out for a summer long or maybe two and a half months or so concept gives us a chance to further analyze and experience some of the ideas that are contained in the downtown neighborhood district plan. Obviously the ideas in the downtown plan of creating an attractive, distinctive, revitalized, and energetic area.

13:09 Those are sort of key components of the plan, and this again gives us a chance to look at that and really experience it firsthand, sort of try it on for size. In this situation, what we would propose to do is better delineate the vehicle corridor, the pedestrian corridor without cones. There may be more or two of them, but mostly what we're thinking we're going to do is

13:38 Use logs and planters and benches and some color. Let me just get to the next slide. This is the same map that we have in front of you. I just wanted to put it up there. The color's not quite as good, but to give everybody a sense of what we're talking about. So we would delineate or propose to delineate the pedestrian corridor.

14:09 By putting logs in cradles, you break that up with potentially using, I think we were thinking about watering troughs maybe as planters, put seasonal colors in there, periodically put a bench in there. These are some of the details that remain to be worked out, but these are generally the ideas of how we could create a more attractive place for people to sort of congregate.

14:37 Walk, ride their bike adjacent to Main Street businesses on the south side of Main Street. And then also include one-way vehicle circulation. And in this case, we're proposing to try it to the east. When we did the 4th of July a couple seasons ago, it was a westbound vehicle pattern. If you have vehicles going to the east, it gives the people that are coming into town an opportunity to drive up Main Street.

15:05 Get a sense of what's going on over there. If they see something that attracts them, they can then turn in, you know, potentially by parries and come back down, find where they want to go. And the other option, or the other idea, excuse me, that we're thinking about here is directing people to the backside of the businesses that are on Center Street and start implementing the idea of parking in back of businesses rather than in front of.

15:35 Because ultimately, you know, the plan is, in terms of the cross-section that we've been talking about recently, is to move businesses up closer to Main Street and maybe even get rid of the frontage road in the future and extend the pedestrian bike promenade up further. So the ideas that we're talking about here sort of help us advance those ideas of reconfiguring Main Street. And again, we have a cross-section back here that we've been talking about.

16:05 Which is an idea for phasing this in over time. And again, trying to implement some of these ideas that have been considered in the downtown concept plan for Main Street. You know, all of these ideas, one-way traffic, street park, on-street parking, ped-bike corridor, and the other things I've just mentioned are consistent with that plan.

16:33 And again, as an engineer and in public works, we're very interested in testing these ideas out as it relates to circulation. So if we're given the opportunity to do this, we'll be out there doing traffic studies, counting cars, watching pedestrians, see how things are actually flowing out there, how does it work. And this will give us some intelligence going forward on how we move forward with permanent.

17:02 Redesign of Main Street. The other part of this, the animation part of this is the Main Street Marketplace. Skip Harvey is here to talk about those ideas and that's really sort of ideas on how do we program this area to create that activity, that attraction, not only for our residents but certainly for our visitors during the summertime. Give them interesting and fun things to do along Main Street that can

17:30 Also benefit our businesses. So with that, I'm going to ask Skip to come up and sort of move into that part of the project. Ray, before you leave, could I ask a quick question? Yeah. Will there be parallel parking on 203? Ultimately, what? I mean, this summer? No, not this summer. So I'm glad you mentioned that because the parking part of this is interesting.

18:00 Commissioner Clark and I were just briefly talking about the idea of testing back-end diagonal parking, which is something I'm really interested in looking at. Personally, it's easier for me to back-end diagonal park than head-end park, especially when weather's bad, than try to back out into traffic. So this could be an opportunity to see how that works, how people react to it. So we're interested in doing that. But the cross-section that we've been looking at ultimately would include,

18:30 Parallel parking on the frontage road as sort of an initial step, one-way traffic, pedestrian corridor, parallel parking, then you'd have essentially the grass median that's there to be slightly in a different location. But then in the future, when we get to a point where we get rid of the frontage road and we begin moving businesses up, and this is the phasing part of it, yes, we would promote.

18:57 On-street parallel parking, again adjacent to those businesses, and a pedestrian corridor. Isn't there room on 203 now for parallel parking? Pretty much, yeah. Why can't we do it this summer? Well, what we were going to do this summer when Caltrans comes in and resurfaces the road again, we're providing them with a striping plan that they're going to use as a change order for their contractor. We're going to put a biplane out there.

19:25 So we'll have, you know, we'll put the little guys on bikes down on the street and signage and so it'll be a bike lane each direction. So that would be a problem for the bikes if there were cars, of course. Yeah. Yeah, I see what you're saying. We'll try out the bike lane and see how that goes. Good afternoon. Skip Harvey, citizen, business owner, and council member. I don't know which hat I'm wearing today because, to be honest with you,

19:56 Thank you very much for allowing us this time to bring this before you and provide your input hopefully on any questions or concerns you might have regarding this project. As Ray stated, this began with

20:23 About five years ago when we quickly, because of the lack of fireworks, threw together the block party on Main Street and we had such a great response from the community with that event and how it felt really local and how it really gave the center of town some synergy that we continued that program for a couple of years, two more years after that.

20:46 And then last year we kind of took the next step forward in bringing the farmer's market over there and creating a regular weekly event in that area. And once again, it was well received by locals and the farmers particularly have already sent an email out and they're anxious to come back to Main Street again this year. So part of what I'm trying to do is get all my ducks in a row here and when I go down to their first meeting in May,

21:14 April 26th, this month, and Bishop, I will introduce to them the idea that we're not going to move them over in front of the outlet mall as opposed to being in the parking lot where they were last year.

21:28 We're doing this because it became quite a burden on the businesses that were in the mall at the P3 Center, the Main Street Center, for us to close off the parking lot early in the day and not allow our customers to park there so that we could be prepared for the farmer's market. So we had to rethink our location and move it out to Main Street.

21:51 Hopefully, they will find this location suitable and they will want to go there. Otherwise, I'm afraid their only other option is to go back out to Mammoth Creek Park if they so choose. And that's going to be kind of up to them. But I think we're presenting them. If we do this properly, they're going to see the value in being on Main Street. And we're actually going to be able to produce a nicer market with them in the area that we have.

22:17 One of the things that is going to be key to this whole project is flexibility. There's three areas that we need just a lot of flexibility on because sometimes as much as you do your best to look at a diagram, lay out the signage, try and think about plans on how you might do easy-ups or how you might want to do a marketplace and create synergy in an area.

22:41 Until you actually get into it, you really don't know what's going to happen. And a good example of that is the 4th of July when we tried to do the cones. Our thought, and it seemed much for the time, was to connect the bike path up by Matsu with a nice walking lane and bike path all the way down the bike path at Bank of America and create this nice flow of pedestrian-oriented traffic.

23:05 Needless to say, by the second morning of our experiment on that, I had just tons of phone calls of people north of Perry's telling me this isn't working. This just isn't working. We can't get into our houses. It's affecting our business. Up by John's Pizza.

23:24 Turner Gas couldn't get their trucks in, so we immediately went out and just made a quick change. We pulled all the cones on that upper area and were able to continue it through the lower part. The businesses luckily to the east of Center Street were gracious enough to...

23:43 Follow through with the weekend and let us continue on running it that way during that time. But after the event, they too commented that for some of their customers and the type of businesses they were running, it wasn't really conducive the way we had it set up at that time. So, you know, we kind of came back and focused on the area where it worked really well. The outlet malls felt that it worked well.

24:08 I think Tom saw that there was some benefit to it in front of our area, and Shea Shot also felt that having that pedestrian thing would work. So when we do something like this, we are doing our best to look at the signage that we need to direct people first, to let them know how to get onto Main Street and where additional parking is. But once we get into it, we may find out that after a week of it or within a couple of days, people are going to go.

24:36 I don't know how to get back to the back street parking. I don't know where to go once I get on Center Street. How do I do this? And we're hoping that we can do some signage through the use of some banners or small, tasteful things on the backs of our buildings that would let people know that they can come through a driveway from the back side of Center Street or that they can park in that back area if we so desire to put them in the back. But until we begin to get into seeing how the traffic flows,

25:05 I don't think we're going to know what type of signage we're going to need to do that. There's also going to need to be some additional signage for the businesses in this area. As I noted in here, this is a risk. Every business that is in this location is really kind of rolling the dice that changing the traffic pattern isn't going to dissuade people from coming into that area and doing their shopping or from stopping there that they won't just drive by and go, it's too much of a hassle, I'm not going to be bothered with it.

25:34 So we need to get things out in front of our business that would let people know that they have an opportunity to come in and maybe get something, get a special on a product or that there is something inside of the store that's there or we need to be able to set up an easy up on the outside, maybe in our parking lots and create little pods of easy ups that would create little market, like an outdoor marketplace feel.

26:03 But when you're trying to do something like that, it's really difficult to know, should I do it one day a week? Should I do it seven days a week? Should I do it just on weekends? And until you begin to get a feel for it, you just really don't know how much you can afford to invest on setting up, putting a staff member out there, observing what goes on and finding out if it's worth your time.

26:28 My thought is that our goal would be to first get the traffic pattern set up and get the traffic flow and the pedestrian-oriented walkway set up so that it is operating smoothly. That would be step number one. Step number two would be to get the farmer's market set up and get them comfortable in their new location and begin to find out where they need to be situated and how that would work. And step number three probably would be to encourage maybe the businesses in the area

26:57 To look at that Wednesday afternoon when the farmer's market is there already drawing people in to say, you know what, maybe I will try to put something out here in front of my store and do a little easy up and put a small sign on it that it would advertise something that the people might not normally know that is available here and try and get them to move.

27:19 Back down to the other side of Main Street, down toward Shop's Bakery and away from that, or to come further up into the outlet mall. Maybe they want to do a little shopping pod back in the middle. They have to realize they're giving up parking spaces to do some of these things.

27:35 There's going to be a trade-off. What's it worth? Is it worth it to do a shopping pod, you know, do a little outdoor shopping area and give up some of those parking places? Or is it better just to try to get people to draw them into your store? It's a challenge, and it's a challenge that you can't really gauge until you actually get into it and give it a try. I think we can get some credit for the fact that when we've done our Main Street, when we did our block parties,

28:04 And when we did the farmer's market last year, we were very tasteful with what we did. We weren't gaudy or anything. We simply put enough information out there that people knew that there was a market going on there. They could see the easy-ups and all that. And the one problem from the farmers that attended the market is...

28:23 We have never had so many different languages at the farmer's market, which tells you it wasn't just locals going to shop for their groceries. The tourists, our guests, actually saw this, and they make a real effort when they see something, some activity in animation, they make some real effort to come over and check it out and see what's going on.

28:44 So we need some flexibility on how we can use easy-ups, and I think I would be happy to come back to you about mid-July and not only give you a report on what we're finding out up until that time, but get some feedback from you folks as to what you like and what you don't like and see if there's any kind of adjustments that we might need to make to kind of clean it up a little bit or something we could do to make it a little bit better.

29:08 We're going to need some relaxation of our parking requirements because if you look over into, let's see, I borrowed my cat's laser light here. I don't know if they used up the battery or not. I think they did. Did you say your cat's? Yeah. I borrowed my cat's laser light here. I think your cat wasn't operating. I think you are.

29:33 Well, anyways, in the P3 parking lot, one of the things that you have to do to create this pedestrian corridor, Mark, you see the arrow coming in and out, there's an in arrow right there where traffic comes in, and you go down all the way to Coldwell Banker and you see where the traffic goes out.

29:47 We can't have traffic crossing this pedestrian walkway in a lot of areas. So in order to accomplish this, we need traffic to try to enter by P3 and be able to move across from our parking lot into the shop parking lot and around and either go back out onto the...

30:05 Driveway down here by Coldwell Banker or use the driveway in between P3 and Schatzes to exit out through Center Street to come back out that way. But in order to do that, we're going to have to remove probably four parking places, two from the P3 lot and two from the Schatz parking lot because that will create the driveway that will connect our two parking lots.

30:29 If we do the easy-ups on Wednesday, that will take a few additional parking spots, but that would probably be for an afternoon, you know, so it would simply be an afternoon event on Wednesday, and I've talked with Mark and Ray about trying to get some kind of a blanket permit so that every Wednesday we could do some kind of an event.

30:48 The only other thing that we would like to possibly have the option of doing is if this is successful and we're drawing people in there is on the holidays such as Fourth of July or Memorial, Labor Day.

31:04 If it's successful, on those two holidays, we probably would want to also maybe do some kind of animation on those holidays to bring more festivity into our town and give more animation to what's going on here. I think one of the best things we heard last 4th of July and even the previous one, particularly when we had the block party, was

31:24 That there were so many things to do in town, people didn't know which one they really wanted to go to next, and that's a good problem to have, I think, is to give people a lot. So we're really, really going to need to be flexible. One of the things that you need to realize here, too, is that if we're successful with this, we're going to have some kind of memorandum of understanding with each of the property owners along here about what it is we're doing.

31:49 And the costs involved to them because the property owners do need to pick up the cost to set this all up and tear it down. It's only fair. Old Mammoth Road has their assessment district. The village has their assessment district. They all pay for improvements and maintenance and upkeep in their areas. And it's only fair that the business owners through here share some of the expense. We're going to try and keep it low. Approximately $12,000 is the maximum cost.

32:18 For this first year, and if it's successful, it should be less than next year, because this year it's going to include some of the purchase of the benches or the galvanized planters that we're thinking about using, constructing the cradles for the logs to do the separation in, and that is one of the original costs, but the cost next year, if it's successful this year, would be simply set up and tear down.

32:46 So we need to get all of the property owners on board with this. So that's one of the documents we do. In doing that, what we have done, though, is we have created a system or a plan so that if we're successful this year and next year we get maybe the next block down is going to say, we want to play this year. Or the people across the street might say,

33:09 You know, we want to do this too, or if you look out here at this south section of Old Mammoth Road, and they want to make some changes, but they're not really sure what they want to do.

33:19 We will have a template set up that if they want to try something, we can apply that template to their area. We can then expand it out and we can do, I like your term, Elizabeth, the paint and polish type of projects for the next couple of years where we don't have a lot of money, but we can make some pretty significant changes and at the same time, as Ray pointed out, we can learn from these changes of what's really going to work best before we make any major investments and find out, oh,

33:49 A parking ride that nobody parks in? Ooh, okay, maybe we need to do something different. So I think it's a great experiment. Flexibility is the key, and I agree with HOM that the time frame is important that we adhere to it this year that we set up, try to be up and running by about mid-June prior to motocross, so it kind of helps kick off our summer season.

34:14 And that we tear down at the end of September, just to make sure we're not out there in the snow in early October. It could be snowing in September, knowing, looking outside right now, you never know. But that we get it torn down in time so that we're cleaned up and ready for our winter season. You know, if it's successful this year, we may want to adjust that the following year. But for this first year, I think it would be important that we adhere to those time frames and for set up and tear down when we run it through that time period.

34:45 Does anyone have any questions? I got lots. Go ahead. I got some questions and some comments, but let me do the questions first. Why aren't you doing this on weekends? It's going to be set up all year long. The setup, once it's set up, the traffic pattern will operate from or straight through every day, seven days a week from mid-June until... Three and a half months it's going to be there.

35:14 For three, yes. Okay. Correct. Have you considered having the trolley come down the frontage road on the one way instead of being out on 203 because the trolley is very festive and, you know, fun? I would think that would, well,

35:29 That would be something we would have to run through ESTA, and since they're the governing board, and they set the trolley routes, and they set the maps. Now, the map wouldn't vary that much, but we do have stops on the outside, on Main Street already set. So, and on Wednesday, it might get confusing for the people, because we're going to close this section where the farmer's market is. That will be completely closed off to traffic on Wednesday, so there won't be, in order for traffic to get...

35:57 Down the service road, they would have to either go through the outlet mall parking lot or they'll have to go back out on the main street and come back in again. So there would be a day a week where that trolley route would then have to deviate from its normal route. But I kind of think that with the stops out on main street, especially with the restriping of main street and the extra room or the bike path and all, we might be better off keeping the trolleys on the outside. Okay.

36:24 I don't know if the logs are still buried.

36:52 In the yard, they're opened up. I think it has to do with the time it takes to make sure that all of our snow is melted, that all of our grass and the landscaping out front has had time to be cleaned up and prepped for the summer season and get that all done first and then get ready. Again, this is just June for the first year. We could change it the following year if we care to.

37:18 I've been out of town for three weeks. Is this the first time the public has seen this map? Yes. And, yes, go ahead. And I would like to see maybe you, Mr. Jarvis, or Skip either one, go over and point out what and how that's going to work, what is where, and you've mentioned several times, access from Center Street. Can you show, that map doesn't show any kind of access.

37:44 I don't know if we need a pointer or what, but is the public seeing this at home? Does anybody know? And if they're not, then it doesn't matter. Is that on? The camera is focused on that. So it is on, the public can see that map? Okay. Then it would be a benefit. This is a very new concept, and I think the sooner the public sees it, the better. And I think that once we are sure that we've got the approval and we've got the MOUs all signed through the property owners, and that's going to be the key.

38:13 Is make sure that everybody's on board. If one person decides this isn't in their best interest, we have to scrap the whole thing. So once we get those MOUs signed, I would say we then have a plan. We can move forward. So once that's done, I think this should actually be published probably for a couple of weeks in both newspapers to let the public, the locals know particularly that a change of traffic pattern is coming in this area. But Center Street is here coming in this way. And as you come through here,

38:42 You would see that there's a driveway here that goes in between Coldwell Banker and Schatz Bakery that you can drive through. There's a driveway over here in between P3 and Schatz Bakery that you can drive through. And there's another driveway right over here that you can access the outlet mall parking from. So each one of these parking lots has alternate access points off of the back. And with the exception of Schatz,

39:11 There is quite a bit of parking in the back. We encourage employees to park back there, so some of that is taken up with employee parking, but we also, I find the majority of my employees bicycle or walk to work in the summertime anyway, so that amount of parking stays down. It gets busy on the holidays, but that's wherever you go. Go to the beach on the holidays, you can't find a parking place, so it's always easier up here.

39:37 So we have all this parking in the back. As far as the traffic pattern goes, during the normal weekday, with the exception of the farmer's market day, pedestrians will begin to take over this southbound lane of the service road. This will all be pedestrian only, separated by some of these log rails.

39:58 Planners and open some benches along the way here, possibly some kind of cover over the benches, maybe an easy up over a bench here and there so people can sit in the shade and all this would be totally pedestrian oriented so they can walk up and down here freely without having to worry about cars and stuff coming up behind them. Traffic coming down Main Street can either turn in here and go down through on the North Lane, come down through here. They can access all of these shops.

40:28 By turning into the parking lot here or using the far east entrance and exit down here. So this is still easily accessed from either this entrance or this entrance. If you were to come down Main Street and you want to get down here, you can turn in here. One of the problems we found when we went the other direction was people would turn in here and want to come this way. They would see this as blocked off and it just confused them.

40:54 Very much so. They didn't know what to do from that point. So with this, they can still come down this way and come in. People turning left will have a little bit of an issue because they can't come up this way, but they can at least go straight ahead and still get back up to where they want to go, my parents, if they so desire to go through this parking lot. During farmer's market, like I said, there's one entrance also to this parking lot here, and we need to be able to move people.

41:23 The property line here is right about here for P3. These are all parking places right now. So we need to just maintain this opening right here in front of Mammoth Reservation so that people can move between our two parking lots. And this really becomes a parking area for this whole center. This sort of brings these two areas together almost so everybody can kind of come in here.

41:54 Thank you. I just think, you know, it helps to have a little explanation with that so that maybe they understood. Yeah, a little more explanation. I'm still a little confused about the pedestrian versus vehicular flow through the area next on the access road next to the farmer's market, both on days when you have the farmer's market and on days when you don't. Okay, so if

42:24 This, I guess this blue arrow indicates the Farmer's Market Day. So this whole area is blocked out. There is no traffic moving along here on Farmer's Market Day whatsoever. On non-Farmers Market Day, it looks just like this side where there is vehicular traffic moving to the east and there is pedestrian traffic moving on the inside of the southbound lane. So that whole thing is open. So this will be blocked off right here.

42:53 And the way we have to do this is that there will be traffic coming this way, so we will have to jog these people over as they come down onto this one way on this side, and then they'll be in the right lane, the correct lane, I should say, all the way down to this Coldwell Bank, and then we're going to have to jog them back over. At this point, these people can only come up to the Shell Station, really, because we still want to allow access to...

43:22 So I gather then the feeling was that

43:46 I'm sorry to say that again.

44:07 Ideally, from a pedestrian point of view, it would be nice to every day, whether it's farmer's market or not, have that, yes, as pedestrian flow, but then you'd have to route the traffic down through the parking lot. They would come in here, you know, and, you know, we still have some traffic issues right in this area. You know, just to kind of, as an experiment, I think Tom has already commented on this, Paul Rudder commented on this.

44:33 If this works and is successful, the next step, one of the possibilities of the next step would be to block this off completely right here, block this, possibly block this off completely right here and simply put an entrance into the outlet mall parking lot right here in the middle of Main Street so you access this from this parking lot, turn all this into a green bell, you've got the parking lot entrance, green bell all the way down here.

45:02 You put another entrance off of Main Street right here into this big parking area and then you have Greenbelt all the way down here to the Shell Station. And this is kind of the direction we're going in. If we can prove that this is successful and work with it and prove that you can still generate the interest from the public to come into your businesses.

45:22 Going to this next step, I think, will be even easier for us. It will be more about, yes, let's do this, only do it better, rather than, I don't know if it's going to work to make that big of a change all at once. So it's a nice next step to where we could go in the future. The one-way sign on Main Street is just to direct traffic to know that they can only go east when they turn in there? Yes, the CYAC is attached to this.

45:52 This sign is, these two signs sit right here. So that as you turn in, you know that this is one. Thank you. Thank you. Yeah. Okay. The sign is, when you're looking at that map, it is a little confusing. That's actually laid out for Caltrans encroachment permit. Caltrans, we will work with Caltrans on this as we did when we did the 4th of July. But they're, you know, as far as the frontage road is concerned, they're not that interested.

46:22 What they're interested in is how do people get onto and get off of Main Street State Route 203. So the signage that's proposed is consistent with what we had done before, although we'll be reversing some of it because vehicle traffic would now be going east instead of west. And again, as far as Caltrans is concerned, they are, you know, originally they thought, you know, if this was a weekend deal, they don't really care. But because we're, you know, proposing that we do a longer

46:51 Term project, then they're a little bit more interested because they're going to want to make sure that the signage is maintained, etc. So we are working with them on the permit for this. Is there any signage currently on Center Street to tell people that they can get into these parking lots? No, no. And, you know, it's not shown on here at this point because I think that...

47:13 As far as the idea of parking behind these businesses, we need to work with the business owners on that. There's no striping or anything back there, so if it's something that we can work out, and I would encourage, we can potentially lay out how parking might work, and then for the summer we can just chalk it or they can chalk it. But we would definitely want to put some signage up that directs people to parking at the rear of the buildings, you know, from Main Street or from the frontage road.

47:41 So a little bit of wayfinding is going to be important. More questions? Okay. Thank you. Oh, she had comments. Are we going to make some comments? Yeah, well, yeah. Oh, it was just questions. Oh, okay. We got a question. Don't go away, Skip. Don't we want to hear from the public before we start making more comments? Oh, that's a good question. Thank you, Rhonda. That's a good idea. Comments from the public? Thank you. Hi, Tom Cage again.

48:19 In regards to parking in the back, the majority of parking in the back is taken up by staff. There really isn't any behind Schatz Bakery, and Schatz Bakery's staff parks actually on the Main Street Center's property along the back. So, although it's a great idea, and chalking it out, we might find a few extra spots and maybe even some for bigger vehicles behind the outlet malls.

48:49 To direct, because there is a little bit of room in their parking lot. But the rest of it, for all intents and purposes, is staff parking. And in the winter, it's either temporary snow storage until we remove it, and staff parking. The parking spaces in the front that Skip talks about for the circulation of parking, there's approximately 26 between P3, between Main Street Center and Schatz Bakery, and we'd probably lose six.

49:16 I'm sorry, there's 26, we probably lose six spots for this circulation, which would put us about too short of what code would require based on the businesses that are in those locations. So it's not a huge parking effect as far as that goes. I don't know whether we've, have you talked to the fire department about this? Being there doesn't matter.

49:45 Tom's been involved in this, and you came by talking to me a little bit, and their main concern is that they have a wide enough vehicle file so that they can get there. So really, as laid out, as presented, you get what you get. We're not, just to be clear on something that Dr. J said, we're not parallel parking, we're leaving those parking spaces as they are.

50:15 Experimenting since you're traveling east, experimenting with backing in as they are. Parallel parking on Main Street would eliminate the ability to have a bike path. Bike path on Main Street is more conducive to what we're trying to all achieve than additional parking spaces and also probably safety issues that Caltrans would have a problem with. I think that's about it.

50:45 Tom, is there any room on Center Street for parallel parking, or does everything have a vehicle pulled in on property that wouldn't be able to back out? The problem with parallel parking on Center Street, A, it's not wide enough, so it would have to be slightly off, and then that would disrupt the parking behind the businesses. Okay, that's what I thought. Where you need more spots having staff park back there. Okay. And Ray might be right, we could possibly look at it and see if there's a different way to lay it all out.

51:13 Behind all of our businesses to pick up a space or two. Or we figure out a way to reposition trash cans so Main Street Center shares with shops and that takes up a few less parking spaces here and there if we reduce the amount of trash receptacles. Are you planning on striping behind the businesses this summer? No. Since it's staff that parks back there, it's...

51:42 I plan to do my trash can thing that I've been trying to get done for a while. I think I've got the money to do it, so that's the first priority. And then there's some Edison wires that go behind Base Camp's building to straight down, and I'd like to get those underground. So those are electrical overheads, and that's not cheap, but it would be nice to get that done.

52:11 But you wouldn't have objection to chalking and striping once they get everything worked out? Absolutely. Absolutely. We're going to have to restripe the front. Right. But if we want to incur the cost to do that in the back to experiment to see if there's a better layout, if we can come up with a better layout, then we'd have to retrain employees so then striping wouldn't make sense. But if there isn't a better layout, then staff knows how to work.

52:40 A real layout has never been done for that area, has it? I would doubt it if it has. Not to my knowledge, and I've been involved in the Main Street Center area since 1980. Thank you, Tom. It'd be interesting, Mark, Sandra, as the new parking part of the zoning code is developed for you to comment for us when we know more about that.

53:08 How this 26 to 20 reduction would fit in with that. It might comply for all we know. Okay. Other comments from the public? Okay. I just wanted to say that, you know, thank you again for the time. We really were just looking for comments and feedback. We'll take your comments and your ideas as we go forward with this refining.

53:37 I think we probably will want to look at the area behind, and Tom may be right that, you know, it's employee parking, there's a certain number of spaces, but I think because it really hasn't been looked at, there may be a way to better utilize that space and get some more parking in there. And again, I think that that idea is consistent with ultimately where we'd want to be, so we'll take a look at that and see how it might lay out.

54:02 I think there's very little time and expense to do that because we probably wouldn't pay if we'd probably just chalk it. So again, thank you for your time. Comments? Well, I think it's exciting. I'm really looking forward to the June 15th, end of September. Okay. Since we've talked about this last year, Skip,

54:28 You know, we're talking about the downtown district plan and you and Tony and Paul and I met and talked about it. I'm just so excited. I love the name Main Street Marketplace. I think it's wonderful. I think it's really important that you make a big splash this year. This winter, because of the snow we've had and then that long, you know, icy January and all the rest of it, with a few exceptions, town has looked really cheesy. And I think that you should pay particular attention.

54:56 To your signage and how you set it up. I mean, when you think about shopping for produce, it can be all the way from buying oranges off the back of a pickup truck, you know, with a cardboard sign to Whole Foods. But what's even better than shopping at Whole Foods is shopping on vacation. You know, when you're just, you're on vacation, you're having fun, and being able to go to a farmer's market, it's really special. So I would hope that you would think about the font for Main Street Marketplace, a theme that you want, a color that you want.

55:26 And have that consistent. I don't know if the easy ups permit penance. Can you put penance on the top? You know, kind of flag kind of thing on the top? But what I hope it won't be, just because it's so, I mean, our sign code is coming, you know, and in June I think it'll probably be adopted. But I hope it just won't be a lot of banners. They're just all droopy drawers. If you're doing something with flowers, is it possible to make a few standards? You know, knocking together some.

55:55 Well, of course, in our wind, I don't know. So you can have a sign saying Main Street Marketplace and beside it may be a hanging basket of flowers that the adjacent shopkeeper would keep watered. I really think a color theme, a font theme, something sort of whimsical, it would just make a huge splash. And it doesn't have to be a monster banner like, you know, everybody tries. Because, you know, it's hard being in business and the economy's really tough and people think the bigger the banner, the better. But that's not how you get the attention. But if it was just sort of...

56:24 A splash with, you know, these attractive signs and the pennants fluttering and the people and all the rest of it and really think about that because that's an investment that you will then be able to store away and use again the next year. So I'm very, very pleased that you're doing this. But I think it's important to set the highest standard for how it appears, you know, because it's going to be up all summer, which I just think is great. That was very good news. So I'm just super excited about it. It's great. Thank you.

56:56 I don't know how you're going to advertise it. You can have individual signs with arrows, you know, directional arrows, which you can point whatever direction depending on where the sign is located. I don't know if you're making a sign that says Main Street Marketplace. I don't know how you're going to do that or what the plan is, but I think it should be really...

57:26 Not high-end, expensive design, but it should be well-thought-out design, so you make a really good impression and make a big splash with this, because you're going to a lot of trouble, you know, to try it out, but you want to just, you know, best first impression, that's what I'm recommending. I think what the town has got for the log treatments and not cones, you know, we have to have directional signs, obviously, to direct traffic.

57:54 And I hope, I mean, I'll put up our flower pots that hang on things up around the building there, and then Schatz puts up tables with umbrellas in front of their place, and Pumbo Banker always looks nice. It'll be very festive. You know, so hopefully it'll be festive, and then if we add, as Skip discusses, if we add some animation with either easy-ups or other activities, if we do a...

58:23 A chili cook-off, or if we do something else, then that will add to it. But keep in mind, the farmer's market, although it's neat and unique, it's one day a week. Oh, I know. They don't pay rent unless you've got to deal with them. You know, they generate probably $500, $600 between them. I mean, it's not a money producer for property owners there, but it's not.

58:51 And we hope that it draws people in. And the reason why we've moved in is because in blocking our parking area, it was illuminating traffic coming into P3 and Base Camp because they were there for the farmer's market. Hopefully now if we have their own area in the blue shaded park, they go to the farmer's market and then they see there's still easy access. And the people that have that easy access see there's a farmer's market and they go over there.

59:20 So we're hoping that it creates a two-way. I think, Tom, you're thinking I'm talking about something bigger, i.e., more money than I really am. I don't see any reason for a big banner that says Main Street Marketplace, but every place you had a directional arrow or, you know, no left turn or whatever, you just had a Main Street Marketplace sign with it, you're setting that theme and, you know, people will know. It'll be very nice. That's a great one. Yeah. Rodney?

59:49 Just a couple of things. I really applaud you trying to think outside of Mammoth's Box, which is pretty closed and has very thick walls. But I think there were, excuse me, the key to this will be the circulation. That will be the success to this. And, you know, people can be guided to what you want them to do a lot easier than you think.

1:00:16 Because I just, like I said, spent some time at other resorts the last couple of weeks on business. And that's a very different outlook than if you're there on holiday because you have, with business, you have to try to get around and do your business. And I came back with some different impressions of places I'd seen a lot. But some of the things that make it work, and I will...

1:00:45 Never noticed it before as many times I've been there, but the flow around Vail. And I immediately thought it was horrible. After day two, I got it. And what that was is they had taken a lot of two-way streets and turned them into one-way streets, but they had taken half the street that they closed down for pedestrian, had turned that into pavers. It became, there was no sign telling.

1:01:14 Anybody to walk on one side and drive on the other, you got it really quick. When you saw people strolling on the pavers, which happened to be heated, by the way, and then driving on the pavement. The pavement was close to the entrances of buildings. The people were walking on the other side. It's kind of the reverse of what you have here. So just take a look at that. One-way streets made loops, so you weren't having big expanses.

1:01:44 to go around there. And the second part, the cars were restricted to the perimeters, were able to get into other areas. The shuttle buses could drive anywhere. If you want people to ride a shuttle, have it go to a place you can't drive to. That's what gets people on that. So they could drive through the middle of Vail Village on the pavers.

1:02:09 You very quickly learned to not walk on the pavers if there was a sidewalk because the bus will come up and honk at you, get out of the way, but that's why I figured it out there. And you will walk miles in Vail that you would never dream of walking here because they're guided around there. And then the second the pedestrian access allows you to meander through areas that you would not normally do.

1:02:39 So, and then the last is, wherever they had places blocked off, and this was in a lot of places, and it's at several resorts, because we've all been there, but we've had like two hours to absorb it. When you live the experience, then you go, okay, I get it. But with your, what you do with the locks,

1:03:00 They have higher profile things. So it's large planters that have maybe juniper trees because they're tall there. But what that does is you do not approach it driving up to it and realize it's blocked off. You see from a distance that there's something else there. So maybe look at a mix of higher profiles with trees and movable planters and things around because then it created a sense of place instead of, oh, this road is blocked off, now what do I do?

1:03:28 And let me see the last one because when you're looking at this, I think this is exactly what we have to start trying. But maybe, but even be a little bolder in some areas of say, oh, they're not going to like it. You know, I, you get it, you know. And anything that will improve flow that would allow us to, you know, to bring this into a little center that you turn in and out there.

1:03:59 It doesn't hamper the shopping at all. And just looking at this from a different light and having this go down on, my only comment is I would reverse your pedestrian, put your road closer to that and put the pedestrian on the outside as long as they feel safe. But definitely look at having the trolley drive in there because if the trolley drives in there, it's...

1:04:29 And it says, well, now it's convenient the trolley drops me off in the middle of stuff. And maybe that is part of the key to how we can get bigger ridership on our buses and things is bring them closer into the building off of the main street in a lot of these areas because that's what they do. They go to an area that you can't drive anymore. That's what people will use them.

1:04:57 You know, good luck. And then I think that you can get a lot more parking out of this where, you know, where you, it's hard to vision it with what we have. But when you look at that, you can get a lot more parking behind the buildings. Absolutely used to it. And I didn't know there was that many driveways behind. Which is, hmm, you know, how do we do that? And some of them become pathways. And, you know, as looking as we become there with the pavers, you know.

1:05:24 You've got to tell somebody you can't drive on this anymore. That was exactly the way I figured out you weren't supposed to be driving on it. And parking that close to the building, if you have the transportation, people will carry their bags, a small, you know, you're changing a mentality here of, and the farmer's market is a different mentality. It's go to buy what you need for today, not what you're going to go for the week. And we're trying to set up shopping.

1:05:53 To where I have to carry out my 15 bags from Vons and I have to park close. These other areas are doing, this is my daily shopping because it's my routine to go to town. That's a little bit more of a vacation experience. It may not work as well for us as a local, but I would, you know, I'd love to be able to adapt a little bit more and try that. So I applaud you trying to do it. And I would, looking at that,

1:06:21 Sure, you need to start shutting off these roads in certain areas. It doesn't shut off business if you think it through completely. So good luck on that. Just one thing I'll add. I think the incremental approach you're taking is good. So instead of taking a big step that may fail in a big way, take little steps, figure out what your successes are and incrementally improve it each year. I think that's a good approach. Go more mentally. Yeah.

1:06:52 Now, let me just give a couple things I missed, and that's one of the things, Elizabeth, as far as how we set the thing up in the signage and being tasteful and all that. One of the things, working with Sandra DiDomisio, with the other vendors as part of the farmer's market, that has been something that we, that myself and Sandra handle, is bringing these other vendors in. In the farmer's market, you cannot mix and match farmers with other vendors. I don't know if you do that or not, but you have to keep...

1:07:19 The two completely separate. The state law actually says you have to have farmers on one side and other veterans on the other side and somehow eliminate the separation between the two.

1:07:30 We have set up some guidelines for the other vendors to keep them in check, making sure that they use it easier, they have it properly weighted, to make sure that they have banners, they don't interfere with other people's businesses or anything like that. And what we hope to do is maybe encourage the farmers to take on some of the next step to make our farmers market a little more upscale and bring it up. Maybe they don't work out the back of their car, maybe they unload their car and park it somewhere else and work out it easier.

1:08:00 I love the farmers, but making change is not always easy. So, you know, we'll see how that flies. But we're going to keep working with them to get them up to the next level. As far as additional scientists, I mean, it's required to sign or something of that nature. My first goal was just to get this approved and get everybody on board, which is the place and the traffic pattern. Once we've got everybody there, then Tom and Paul and Shea Shot, and that's going to all sit down.

1:08:28 And I'll be the intermediary if necessary, run between everybody and carry messages. But we will decide, you know, can we do another banner to add Main Street Market out? Elizabeth, I love your idea of just maybe burning out. It's a very simple brand, you know, where there's a little logo or something on every sign that doesn't know it's part of the Main Street Market. That's great. Ray has talked about poppy coloring and concrete on the walkable area, too. I think it's your test pattern.

1:08:56 I like that idea of being taller and bigger. And what we hope to accomplish with this is to spark enough interest when a sea is going instead of us as a town.

1:09:21 For individuals or businesses trying to sell other people on why they should do it, we have them coming to us saying we want to play, we want to be part of this, how can we do this in our area or in our block or whatever, so that's kind of one of the goals, to take this and do it as a test program and then have it spread like a little good virus throughout town and everybody wants to be part of it.

1:09:47 Skip, I don't think Tasteful exactly summarizes what I was talking about. I was talking about having a theme and an identity. It was more of that, and that was like the consistency in the signage and really having a high level of design for the signage so it's distinctive and gives you a real identity. This will be a destination. I'm going to go to the Main Street Marketplace, you know. All signs are the same size. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. And distinctive. Yeah.

1:10:13 Thank you. This is great. Thank you, Skip. Thank you, Ray. Okay. Agenda item number two is snow removal operations. Ray? I think that this particular item on the agenda is really in response to the Chair's

1:10:45 comments or concerns or questions regarding site distances, particularly on Old Mammoth Road and access to Old Mammoth Road from driveways, which I have experienced firsthand in picking my daughter up and taking her to an appointment on Old Mammoth Road right across from Aspen Springs Department or Aspen Village Department. And there is no doubt that we have had quite a bit of snow this year.

1:11:15 And this is an issue all over town. In fact, yesterday, as I was pulling out of the driveway from where I was, I'm inching out, inching out, inching out, trying to see down the road, and here comes Mammoth Police Department, you know, and he had to kind of go out a little bit further than he probably would have liked to. So we recognize that this is an issue. Not real certain.

1:11:41 What we can do about it. I have some ideas. And it's a particular problem on Old Mammoth Road, I think, just because of the proximity of everything. Old Mammoth Road is fairly narrow. And if you're in a big vehicle like I was, trying to get out is a challenge. But some of the things that I thought about, you know, we could potentially...

1:12:03 Not that we love signs everywhere, but the right signs in the right places can be helpful and effective, but it's possible that we could consider putting a warning sign out so that vehicles, you know, warning, watch for driveway traffic or something to that effect, just so they've got a heads up or thinking about it. Maybe they already are, but it's still a challenge. The other idea, and I'm not sure how this could potentially be implemented, but

1:12:30 You know, our challenge when we're doing snow removal is we're working inside the snow poles. And we've got a narrow area and some places in town very little area in which to throw snow and destroy it. In general, we have about a 10-foot easement from the edge of the right-of-way, which is not always the same line as the edge of the pavement. But we have about 10 feet that we can work with.

1:12:58 Clearly, there is not an invisible barrier at 10 feet that stops the snow and drops it right there. So sometimes we're working, you know, in areas that are outside that 10 feet, you know, and that's a problem sometimes also. But one idea or thought that I have is maybe it's possible to provide some kind of a paved taper into and out of as you're going down Old Mammoth Road.

1:13:24 Next to either side of the driveway where you could move the snow stakes, snow poles back a little bit. That way you maybe give yourself three feet of extra depth into the driveway where you don't have to go out so far into the roadway to see if there's traffic coming down the road. You know, maybe you set it back, set the snow pole back three to four feet, you taper it out.

1:13:50 You know, even 25 feet would be helpful just to knock the edge off of that corner so you can see a little bit better. You know, how we go about doing that, I'm not sure. Obviously, that's a cost issue and asphalt and all that. And then the other thing, you know, potentially we can work with private property owners to try to knock some of that stuff down as well. You know, this year it was especially challenging because there's so much snow and everybody's struggling with where to put it.

1:14:20 Part of where we live. We deal with it. We do the best we can. When it comes to safety and traffic safety especially, those are some of the things that I was thinking about. I'm certainly open to ideas that you may have. I'm not sure what else you guys were looking for, but those are just a couple of ideas that I had.

1:14:43 Speaking of that stretch of Old Mammoth Road, it's helped greatly to have the sidewalk in front of the Aspen Village, you know, townhomes, but people are still, if they live on the other side of the street, they'll often walk on that side of the street, and so many of them wear iPods now, and it's just, you know, with this much snow and the road's so narrow, it really is dangerous. I wonder if it would be possible to put up a sign at the athletic club.

1:15:10 Going up to Waterford, you know, both directions, pedestrians, please use sidewalk. I just, you know, or just like no parking November to April, no walking in the street when there's snow. It's a huge, it's a huge problem and it's, you know, you can't see and people are pulling out and there's no room to swerve because you got the runner or the pedestrian, you know, just jogging along, listening to their music and. Right.

1:15:33 Every day. I know it so well because every day it's back and forth, back and forth. It could just be something that a directive, you know, pedestrian access north side of Old Mammoth only or something. Yeah. You know, and like I said, signage, the right signage in the right place can be helpful. We certainly can't, you know, make people do things that are safer and protect themselves, but we can try.

1:16:04 My position on putting a sign up saying watch for driveway, I mean, it's going to get covered with snow. I do like the idea of an angle somehow. Yeah, that's a good idea. And I do think it's up to the homeowner. I mean, backing out of my driveway coming today, I almost got hit. But it's up to me to go and shave that off so I can see better.

1:16:30 Before I get out. And you're way up there. Right. Right. But that's my problem. I know what it's like up there right now. It's not the town's problem. But I've also noticed on Main Street, people have to get their nose so far out. And we've got two lanes of traffic there, which is helpful because you can have a place then to move over so you don't hit that person.

1:16:55 I don't know how in the world your plow drivers could do any more than they've done. I mean, this whole year I've wondered when they sleep. But anyway, how they could do those angles. I mean, it would seem to me it would have to be a people person with shovels. Well, if you set the snow poles back and you have, you know, just an angle point next to the room like where it normally would be, you set a pole right here.

1:17:20 And then they would know, you know, see the next pole and just go to the next pole and so they could potentially cut that angle off. Would you have that ability legally for right-of-way? It's more likely it's within the right-of-way. Yeah, that's why I'm saying the right-of-way generally is not coincident with the edge of the pavement. It goes further back. So maybe on Main Street, that would be a real big help. Well, except for that's Caltrans. But it's the same idea. I mean, we could work with Caltrans. And, you know, honestly, we've been...

1:17:48 Working with Caltrans for what seems to be a long time, but keep hope alive. We're getting there. That's a segue. Could you just talk for a second about context-sensitive design, what exactly that means? I'm all for it. Well, I am too, but what does that mean in Caltrans' world? Well, I have to be careful. But clearly there is a state mandate. It's a state law that we...

1:18:19 Design our right-of-way and roads so that they're complete streets which provide vehicle, pedestrian, bike, access, share the road for everybody. You know, Caltrans promotes context-sensitive solutions and in particular when you're talking about designs for main streets, these are the kinds of things that, you know, the state talks about and they've published and I think the published word is a little bit different than what

1:18:49 Is actually in place in many places, not just Mammoth, but those are in fact the kinds of ideas that we're talking with them about. You know, they've got a group of engineers, you know, in District 9 that have been doing things a certain way for a long period of time and it's difficult to change. Having said that, it's required that they change and do things differently.

1:19:16 You know, we continue to work with them on these ideas and, you know, I'm confident that we'll get where we want to be in terms of what Main Street looks like. You know, the idea of painting a bike lane on Main Street, that's one of those things that's an easy thing to do that maybe it helps change perception, you know, when people are coming into town and there's enough room there to do it.

1:19:40 Thankfully, so that it's just really us providing them with the documentation that they can give their contractor to do it. But that fits right in with, you know, the whole idea of complete streets. Okay. Anything else? You know, I don't know if you're interested in any follow-up on this idea, you know, of tapers or other ideas about how we handle that problem, because it is a problem, so I think we'll look at that.

1:20:10 Sometime between now and maybe the end of summer we'll come back and, you know, suggest some things that we can possibly move forward with. Oh, I would like to hear. Sure. Great. Okay. Thank you. Great. Thanks, Frank. Okay, we have no consent agenda items, nor do we have public hearing items. The next segment is business matters. Our agenda item three on zoning code update for parking, we are...

1:20:39 Going to reschedule until 2 p.m. tomorrow. The consultant that is presenting had problems getting a flight up here, so they will be up here tomorrow. So we will move on then to... Can I ask a question about parking? Yeah. Okay, I know that's been postponed until tomorrow afternoon and I'm going on vacation tomorrow. I just wanted to ask one question. Is it possible if we change our parking standards and therefore parking that's already been...

1:21:06 Let's see, parking numbers that have already been approved with development plan, you know, specific plans or whatever. Is it possible for them to reduce the parking and then substitute for that savings more sidewalk? Or does there have to be a nexus? Can it only be the sidewalk in front of the development? How can we get more sidewalk out of reduced parking?

1:21:29 Are you prepared to answer that one right now? That's what I'd like you to talk about tomorrow. And even before we get there, I'm concerned about how legally we can take something off today's agenda and just simply postpone it until tomorrow. Well, the people can't get here. But because there's no... There's no circumstance exception, I believe, isn't there? There's no opportunity for public notice. I guess my question is, why are we not just...

1:22:02 Postponing this until our next regularly scheduled plan commission meeting. Well, first, legally you can do it because you're simply continuing your meeting to tomorrow. Okay. So legally that's how you do it. Yeah. And then the reason we're doing this is the consultant has flown in from Boston and we have a finite budget. And so you'll either have this presentation or perhaps none because we have a finite budget for this work.

1:22:32 Our intent was to present this workshop with you, so we'll adjust the schedule because his flights were cancelled and he wasn't able to arrive here for this meeting. While still, so he's flown to Los Angeles, and while there he is able to come up for a meeting tomorrow. And the purpose of this workshop was to present the findings of Mr. Schreiber.

1:22:54 Explain these ideas, hearing input, and then we would go back and then draft an ordinance based on this workshop, and you would review that draft section of the code like you are all the others. And parking is a very important issue. It's very expensive, and you certainly want to make sure you have the right amount of parking on site. Okay. Thank you.

1:23:22 That being said, agenda item four is the zoning code update for chapter 17.116, which is the general plan, zoning map, and zoning code amendments. Are you presenting that, Sandra? I am. Thank you. So this chapter is, as you stated, focused on amendments to the general plan, the zoning map, and the zoning code.

1:23:46 We looked at our six comparison codes and also a list of issues that we had generated for the zoning code and we found two issues regarding this section. The first one was that the state law provisions are not incorporated into our current code.

1:24:06 And our amendment findings are the same for all different types of amendments, but the findings don't apply in all types of circumstances. So in order to solve this, we incorporated the state law provisions into the code, and we did update the findings so that they're case specific. And the zoning code users group reviewed this chapter last Wednesday and didn't have any suggestions or edits to the chapter.

1:24:35 And since there were only minor changes made to this chapter, we didn't have any questions for the Planning Commission, but I'm happy to discuss the chapter and answer any questions you have on this. Questions? I have a question on a page. I hope I'm in the right one. 43, is that still part of this one? Yes. Wait a minute. That's the next one. 43 is the next chapter. 42 is the last page of this.

1:25:07 For this agenda item. You're right. Sorry. No questions. Nope. No questions. So we have consensus on this chapter? Mm-hmm. Consensus? Yes. I mean, I didn't have any questions. Thank you. So we will move to agenda item 5, which is again zoning code update, and this time for chapter 17.120, which is specific plans, and chapter 17.124, which is master plans. Yes.

1:25:38 And so we took a look at these chapters. We looked at our comparison codes and our lists of issues. We had several issues that are noted on page 44. We have five issues. The zoning code doesn't include specific plan requirements. The zoning code refers to master plans as development plans. In fact, in our current zoning code, the word master plan is not even in there, so it's a little confusing for the reader.

1:26:06 And the content of a development plan isn't up to date with our current standards. The current zoning code is unclear regarding the procedures for filing a master plan. And currently in the code it's a little unclear, but it appears that master plans are only allowed in the resort zone. However, we already have a master plan for the shady res tract, which is in the RMF 1 affordable housing overlay zone.

1:26:31 So we did bring this to the zoning code users group on April 6th. They didn't have any edits or revisions to these chapters. So we did incorporate all of those issues into the code. We updated the code to comply with all of that. And the only question that we had for the Planning Commission was, is it appropriate to allow master plans in the resort public and quasi-public open space and affordable housing overlay zones?

1:26:59 And the zoning code users group did recommend that that be the case. And that's the, that's all the questions that we have for you on this chapter. I know you have a question. Yes, I was just going to be curious. Specific plans are allowed in all zones? Yes. State law. And that's state law. Got it. Thank you. Sandra is really pleased to see this section because I know we had a development a couple years ago.

1:27:29 Where terms are being used interchangeably, plot, parcel, property, and it was just total confusion, and it was just casual, and it's just an oversight, and I think it's so important to get this nailed down, and I was very, very glad to see this chapter. Anything else, Rhonda? No. Consensus? Do we have consensus? Yes. Well, did we answer the question about whether or not it was appropriate to? Yes.

1:28:00 And other zones. Do we have consensus on that? Well, I'm not sure. I kind of wanted to discuss it. I even can't find the question. It's on page 46, handwritten 46 at the top. So this would allow a master plan in a variety of zones. It would allow it in the resort zone where it's currently allowed.

1:28:19 It would allow it in the affordable housing overlay zone where we currently have a master plan for shady rest, but then it would open it up to public and quasi-public and open space. So, for example, the new, if we had a new municipal facility, that's public, quasi-public, and so it might be good to have a master plan for that facility, possibly the bell-shaped parcel that's open space or any other open space. It just allows someone to apply for that. Maybe you could just outline what are the reasons for having a master plan, just briefly.

1:28:48 It allows for a unified development, different development standards than are outlined in the code. It also creates development standards. The open space zone doesn't have setback standards and requirements, and so it allows you to look at the project, project by project, master plan by master plan, and create those development standards. So it just allows for more unified development. And to me, those sorts of things, if you look at the different zones, obviously...

1:29:17 That sort of need could apply to developments in any of those zones. Sure. Thank you. That's basically what I wanted. I guess I was curious. You're saying because the Shady Rest Track is already had. It's the only area in town that's with affordable housing overlay, too, so there's no other areas in town that would allow a master plan. And there's already a master plan there, because it's a little unclear in our current code where you can have them.

1:29:46 I don't know how old the shady rest semester plan is, though. No? You have another question? Yeah, Sandra, I just saw a question I looked at a couple days ago, page 57, B, minor amendment. Can you just give an example of what a minor amendment to a master plan would be that would be approved administratively? I couldn't come up with any in my head. I think about it.

1:30:13 I think we have consensus on the...

1:30:43 Application and Master Plan to Resort, Public, Quasi, Public, Open Space, Affordable Housing, Overlay Zones. Do we also have consensus as to these two draft, the language in the two draft code sections? Okay. You have a comment from the public? Lee? Can you come up to the microphone? Okay.

1:31:12 Parking isn't on the agenda today, it's on the agenda for tomorrow. But you can take your, we'll have your comments at the second public comment section, okay? Okay. Okay, so, where are we here? Agenda item six, zoning code update, chapter 17.84, administrative permits, and chapter 17.88, design review. Thank you.

1:31:42 As you stated, this is the administrative permits and design review chapter. We looked through our comparison codes and our existing issues. We didn't have any issues on the administrative permits chapter, just had a couple of major, more major changes in the design review chapter, which I noted on page 63. Basically, we changed, currently we have a very long list of

1:32:07 requirements for design review. We just eliminated that list and said all information specified by the department, which is what we're doing for use permits and all other types of applications. Our current design review section has a wide variety of items that require design review, including removal of trees, grading, signs.

1:32:30 And that's not current, that doesn't reflect our current practices, we don't require design review for those items. So we did update that section to reflect what we currently require. And we did change the level of design review for residential projects. Currently, if you have a project of two or more units, you are required design review. With a new code, it would be three units or less would not require design review, so you could build up to three units with no design review.

1:32:59 So those are the changes for that chapter. And then, as I stated, there was no major changes to the administrative permits chapter, and we just asked the commission whether or not it would be appropriate to combine the administrative permits chapter with the use permits chapter, which some of our comparison codes do. It would only be a minor change. It wouldn't majorly affect anything. So that concludes my report. I'm available for any questions that you have on this. Questions?

1:33:29 Sandra, on page 63, this thing about tree removal not being related to design review, I'm not sure I agree with that because that affects community character and it may also affect how a structure looks on the site. I mean, if a tree is dead, that's a different story, but if it's just arbitrary tree removal, I think that's too important in our village and the trees in four square miles to have that just be something you just go in for a permit and that's that.

1:33:59 So I question that one. And my other question on 63 is why did you change to three units or less from two units or less? The first question about trees, we currently require tree removal permits, so we don't require design review to remove trees currently. So we were going to continue with our current practices. If we were going to change and go and require design review for all tree removal, it would certainly change the way we're processing permits now.

1:34:29 At tree removal, we're looking at all items, not just whether the tree is dead or not, but, you know, creating sunshade. There's certain provisions that you can only remove trees for certain provisions. You can't create views, that kind of thing. So that's why we removed it from this section, because it's kind of already captured in our other tree removal permit requirements. And we would not allow a wholesale removal of trees on a lot without a permit. So a tree removal permit would...

1:34:59 is really there to make sure that there is not destruction in the forest for no reason, which is very different than the use permit and design review process associated with the project. So the criteria for removing a tree, you're saying are really pretty judicious. I mean, you just have to give good reasons. How many, what percentage of the population, there's no way to answer this, knows that you have to have a permit to remove a tree?

1:35:26 We get a lot of tree removal permits every year. I mean... Oh, people do know about that. Oh, yes. Because I've never seen anything, you know, in the papers about tree removal. The majority of people... Other than for the fire hazard. The majority of people who want to remove a tree are aware that trees are very large, and if you're not careful, they're going to fall in your neighbor's house. And so then they generally work with some of the local tree removal companies, some of which include arborists. And so those people are very aware.

1:35:56 We do have, on occasion, code compliance issues where a tree is removed without a permit, which can result in fines or significant remediation. Okay. What are the fines for removal without a permit? Does anybody know? Is it significant enough, is my question. Typically it's $500 a tree. Which is? Not very significant. Not very significant. For a business owner, I'd say it's quite significant. Yeah, I would think so.

1:36:26 You don't do it more than once. The majority of our tree removal permits are from single family condominium type projects. There's been over a hundred per year because I'm the one who ends up putting them in the system and giving it to a planner to go out and look at the tree before they even remove it. But I know the last few years, it's been over a hundred a year. You'd be surprised. It's the end of the year how many people are getting their permits.

1:36:52 But the fact that you do it through the arborist and the tree removal people, you know, that covers it much better than putting something in the paper. And then the second item that you asked about, we changed it. We've been trying to make the code more user-friendly, streamlined permits, and we've heard people complain about the requirement for

1:37:15 Design review for duplexes and triplexes. And so that's why we changed it. It's the, you know, the commission can decide whether that's appropriate or not. This is just a suggestion for you. I was a little surprised that it was that low. Knowing the extent to which design review usually, what's involved, I was a little surprised. So my impression was that that's a good change. But you've had more design review experience than I have, Elizabeth.

1:37:45 Oh, I just keep thinking, you know, as we get more and more built out and there's more and more infill and we've only got so much space to work with and you want to be sure that every project is, as we say on Planning Commission, the best possible outcome. And so I was a little uncomfortable with that myself. You have to balance that with the cost of the...

1:38:05 The person doing the development. Exactly. You have to be realistic. When you talk about a single family resident, you probably immediately agree that's going to be for us. Yeah, exactly. It gets into discouraging development and growth because of that. You know, it's something that you have to balance. But I'm satisfied that the permitting process addresses the real issues that we need as far as health, safety, and aesthetics enough there. And it's not something that...

1:38:34 It's taken lightly. And putting in one more level of bureaucracy in it is what ends up really repressing the good growth that we have in redevelopment. But just to clarify, Rhonda, does built without design review mean a planner doesn't see it?

1:38:53 It just goes straight to a building permit? A planner would still look, a planner looks, we look at all the building permits, you know, except for minor like kitchen interior stuff. Right. Planners look at all the building permits, so we would definitely plan check this. And so would you be making recommendations, you know, if it's just a flat face, flat roof, you know, ugly box, would you be making recommendations and say it's not consistent with our design guidelines and do that administratively or is that more discretion than a staff person?

1:39:22 is allowed to have. Typically if there's no design review required, we don't, we don't require any, make any changes to their permits. If it's just a ministerial permit, meaning you can pull the permit, if it meets building code, you can get the permit, then we don't go through and create, do any design review. So like in the Knolls or any, any place, any single family home except for really the Bluffs, you can just build whatever you want. I mean, so that's kind of the, that's how we do our plan checks for building permits.

1:39:50 So a box would meet the criteria, provided it was structurally sound. If it needs the heights and the setbacks and... So let me kind of frame this in a different way. We get a lot of single-family homes building permit applications, and the planners look at that, and they determine zoning conformance, so they're not conducting a design review. And on some single-family homes, which can be quite large, we don't, which can be much larger than a duplex even.

1:40:21 We're still not conducting a design review. And so the policy is, from that particular project scale and its location, which is in a single-family zone and not extensively obvious. It's not on a commercial corridor. Our policy is building permit for safety, planning for zoning conformance. This is...

1:40:47 Allowing a duplex to meet that same qualification. And generally, the duplexes we see are in similar to different zones. So they're not made generally on a major commercial boulevard. And it would be the same kind of approach. You could, say, follow this recommendation. You could keep it as a design review item for planning commission.

1:41:14 Or you can make it an administrative design review where we look, where we're actually doing design review at the staff level. So, you know, there's three ways to do it. Trust and expedite. Allow an administrative review. And what we're reacting to, of course, is many of the comments we have about the time it takes, the costs involved.

1:41:42 And it's quite different if you're doing just a single-family home and you're submitting your plans versus you're coming to either the Planning Commission or staff in a design review with the color boards, the more complex elevations. And so those are the things for you to weigh in this discussion. Do you recall in the comparison codes what they do, what their limit is? I don't recall. I could look into that, though. Some do not conduct a design review on anything.

1:42:12 Say that again, Mark. A lot of communities do not conduct a design review. Period. Period. Well, I guess what bothered me a bit is residential projects, which I tend to be more concerned about than in a more lenient zone. So, but if the rest of you were...

1:42:38 Okay with it. I did not want to see it moved either, Elizabeth. I am really torn on this because I can think of three neighborhoods in Mammoth, each of which has what would be probably commonly agreed a particularly hideous single-family residence. I mean, just, you know, it's the owner's specific taste. But this wouldn't change that. No, no, no, just a second, let me follow my argument.

1:43:00 But then we're talking about, you know, freedom of expression and its private property and, you know, how could we control that? And so how can I say, well, if it's two or more units, we should be able to have some, you know, design review discretion over the outcome. We have design guidelines for the town. We know we're very limited in our space. We want things to turn out well. But if you let the single-family residence owner...

1:43:28 Build whatever they want as long as it's consistent with the code, then how can you apply that to this? So I think I'm just going to have to suck it up. Well, I guess my concern became number of parking places. You increase the number of people in that lot or plaque and you're going to increase other concerns. Well, I think that's done administratively though. So that's okay again? That's not what design review is. Right. Okay. Right. Let me, one thing that

1:43:57 I don't know if you'll remember this, but we do. The large homes subject. We were tripping along. Oh, yes. And the subject was kind of at the fore nationwide, mansionization, large homes. And so we went through the analysis of procedures, requirements, and brought it to the Planning Commission. I think it was a workshop. And I think a lot of the local designers and...

1:44:27 Builders were surprised that the Planning Commission wanted to go the route of conducting design review and a different type of permit for all of those single-family homes, regardless of their size. And so we're mindful of that and not thinking that that's a good process to return to. And I'm also thinking of people who've come here from out of town, you know, looking to make a buck in the boom and came up with...

1:44:58 Multifamily, you know, duplexes and triplexes, and they weren't the best possible outcome, but they met the code, so there we were, and that's frustrating. And as Jay says, it's not a perfect world, so there we are. Thank you, Jay. More discussion, or do we have consensus? Currently, the administrative is a separate chapter.

1:45:25 That's how I read it. It is a separate chapter. And I definitely agree with that. Okay. I have one more question. Did we have consensus on the change to the, I'm sorry, I missed design review. I think we did. Okay. Reluctantly. Okay. Reluctant consensus. Okay. But I do have a question on page 70. B1. Exempted, let's see. The following uses are exempted from the provisions unless it's a developer.

1:45:57 Constructing homes on five or more adjoining lots, where did five come from? Is this related to my previous concern? This is our existing code, and I think the intent is to capture a tract, like if the developer's coming in and building a large tract, it's not just like maybe John Hooper building a couple homes right next to each other, but a big development. I think that's the point of that. So staff is okay with five? You think that's... This is the existing code, so we didn't modify that. Okay.

1:46:24 And we do not have issues, we have not experienced issues with this so we left it. Okay. Okay, just one real quick other thing on page 70. Single family resident raised in RR below 8250 elevation. Why is, why, why does that need to be there? Because above 8250 is the bluffs and we do require design review there. Okay, well my house is above 8250 so. Your neighborhood needs it too. Anything above 8250.

1:46:54 That's when the whole Bluffs development happened. It was very controversial. And so that's when the town instituted design guidelines for homes in the viewshed. I think that Sharon's neighborhood is zoned RSF, though, so it would be exempted. Oh, are you sure? Not RR. What did you say? Your zoning is residential single family? Single family, yeah. Not rural residential.

1:47:19 So it's rural residential structures. Got it. I'm in R2. And you're RSF. Yes, thank you. Oh. That's the difference. So we don't do design review for John here. Okay. I really think it should have been, though, because the house next door has the light reflection. I was brand new to Mammoth when the whole bluff thing came up. But there are two more lots up there. And somehow I wish they did get a little more scrutiny.

1:47:47 Well, that's where the 8250 came from. But I didn't realize it was rural residential, so I just learned something. I just noticed one thing, Sandra, that I meant to mention and forgot about, but on page 69, subparagraph B, it looks like something maybe was left out. It says, to regulate the design, coloration, materials, elimination, and landscaping of new construction, renovations, and, and it looks like something's missing there, then, within the town. Okay. Thank you.

1:48:18 I'll correct that. Any more comments, questions? Nope. Okay, so we, let's see, where are we at? We had consensus on design review. Did we get consensus on 1784 as well? Sure. I think so. We are, yes. Okay. Okay. Okay. So, that is our agenda item six.

1:48:59 In item 7, again, zoning code update, chapter 17.28, special purpose zones. Okay, so the last zoning code chapter of today is the special purpose zones. This is an existing chapter in our zoning code. We made a number of changes to the chapter. We reorganized it so it was alphabetical, converted text to tables, corrected spelling, grammar, cross-reference errors.

1:49:28 And we also renumbered the chapter to be consistent with all of our other zoning code chapters. We did have two issues that we found when we looked into our lists of issues raised by the staff planning commission and the general plan. Their issues are outlined on page 76. One of the issues was that a question was raised that the current

1:49:54 Code includes a zone titled Planned Residential Development Zone and that's never been used in town and it was suggested that this zone be deleted from the special purpose chapter. Staff reviewed it and felt that that zone does provide flexibility from the zoning regulations to establish new residential developments and although it hasn't been used in the past, there's maybe a possibility it could be used in the future and it didn't seem

1:50:21 appropriate just to delete it in case there was a case in which it could be used. Would Talos be an example of that? They did not, no. Okay. That was just a condo development, townhome development. So the zoning code users group had consensus to keep the planned residential zone as part of the chapter. And then the second issue or question that came up was,

1:50:46 The special purpose zones chapter includes overlay zones, which might be appropriate to be in a separate chapter, and it's just an organizational matter that wouldn't affect the standards. The zoning code users group thought we should just group the overlay zones together within this chapter, just separately from the other zones. So either way would be fine.

1:51:09 And then I went through each section and identified all the changes that we made. I'm not going to go through all those unless there's any questions on those. The only one that I did want to point out was in the last section, which is on the staff reports, page 78, in the snow deposition design overlay zone, there's a provision that requires the town to conduct a study.

1:51:35 of the overall SDD zone to develop standards that could be applied to the entire zone. Since we adopted that, we haven't conducted that study. I don't think there's any intent to go ahead and conduct that study. We look at each lot on a case-by-case basis, and it just seemed appropriate to remove that section. So I highlighted it in the actual zoning code section, and it's on page 99. So that was the only question I had for you on that section.

1:52:05 And I'm available for any questions you have. Do you want questions on the attachments, on any of it? Anything, yes. Go ahead. Okay, page 85. I remember the renovation of the airport terminal coming to us, and yet for airport terminals, et cetera, by the way, hangars is AR, it's not ER.

1:52:35 It says P, permitted use, and it doesn't say UP, meaning use permit required, so that means there's no design review by Planning Commission for airport terminal? This wouldn't call out design review required. That would have been in that design review chapter. I don't know what the provision requirement was at the time to bring that forward. I think that might have just been a courtesy review. It was.

1:53:02 It was a courtesy that they did not go through design review. Yeah, we didn't make any changes to this, other than putting this text in, you know, kind of cleaning it up a little bit, we didn't make any change to the airport zone. So that's a, I guess we could call that municipal, because the town owns the airport. That's a municipal structure, and just like we, you know, did design review for the, you know, potential if we can ever get the money police station and the fire station, we would, it wouldn't be appropriate for us to do design review for this.

1:53:32 I think that the airport is a little bit different than the police station and the fire station. I could go back and look at the design review chapter and see. It may be exempted, but I think that we would always bring those types of developments to the Planning Commission for design review as a courtesy. We wouldn't want to move forward with a project without having input from the Planning Commission. Plus, I think the

1:54:01 Police station required a use permit as well. So in the design review chapter, design review is required for public and quasi-public uses. So it would be required for the police station for any type of a public use. But an airport terminal is not a public use? You know, I'd have to go back and look at what you did. I think that's an omission. Not by intent, but just unintentional omission. There may have been something.

1:54:29 In the airport, there's an airport land use plan, so there may be something in there that exempts them from that, but I think it was a courtesy that they brought it for you, but I'd have to go back and look at the files and see. Because I remember so well on the peer resort tour landing in Jackson and going through that arch of antlers, you know, it was part of their community character, and our airport is part of our community character, and so it seems like if they're going to do some major thing, that design review would be required, not just a courtesy.

1:54:57 Add a couple more questions. 87, this has to do with the equestrian overlay. It says on number 2, C2, one additional horse may be kept for each additional 10,000 square feet of lot area. Is there a limit on the number of horses? I know there's a limit on the number of dogs before you're considered a kennel. Can you just have more and more horses if you have a piece of property within the town? Within the equestrian zone.

1:55:25 Within the equestrian zone. Okay. And actually, just back on the design review for the airport, I'm just kind of scanning through the section at the bottom of page 85, the very last sentence that starts, it says, all facilities shall be subject to design review. So they were subject to design review. I missed that. Thank you. Thank you. Okay, back to the horses. Yes. In C3, in no event can a horse be closer than 25 feet to any property line.

1:55:54 I guess if you have property in the equestrian zone, you accept that you have horses within 25 feet of your back door or whatever just because you're in an equestrian overlay, right? I'm sorry? This applies to the equestrian overlay. Right. It shouldn't be an issue because if you're in an area that has an equestrian overlay, then that just comes with the territory. It's like buying property. You still get 25 feet. Yeah, okay, like buying property in the country. And C6?

1:56:22 How do you define accumulation with respect to waste? We use an accumulator to measure. I would like to know, how do you define accumulation? Because you could get people arguing about that. I mean, is it three cubic feet? Is it, you know? Do you feel that that's a necessary definition for the zoning code?

1:56:48 No, I'm thinking about, you know, I'm being scoffed at here, but I'm just thinking if we're in the equestrian zone. I think if we had a complaint and there was, you know, I think we'd have to take it on a case-by-case basis. Case-by-case, that's what I wanted to hear. Okay, case-by-case. Okay, case-by-case. We would use the accumulator to measure the accumulation. Case-by-case basis. No, I think it's useful to have.

1:57:14 Teeth in this code so that it can be enforced. So that's good. Let's see if I have anything else to surround this amusement today. Oh, yeah, page 92 on the bottom. Five. If you're talking about planned residential development, which of course is all hypothetical, we haven't seen one, but it talks about recreation areas have to be at least 40%

1:57:46 Required open space and recreation areas have to be 40% of the total land area. And so when you say open space and recreation areas, just lumping them together, I'm not sure how much space is left open and unbuilt on when the next sentence says, land occupied by recreational buildings and structures can be counted as required open space. Now because of our snow, a lot of the recreation is indoors unless you're skiing or whatever.

1:58:16 But that would end up being any building to the setbacks. You know, there'd be no open space at all the way that's written. I don't understand. It doesn't require you to cover that with land or that with buildings. It just says that the part of it that's structures that are devoted to recreational buildings can be counted. It doesn't say it all has to be structured. No, no, I understand that. But what I'm saying is you could build to the setbacks. You could cover...

1:58:46 The lot, it isn't like 40% of the, you know, the footprint could be 40% of the lot. You know, I remember that number. I can't remember which zone that is. It doesn't say that. It says you could build the setbacks is how I understand it. The idea of a planned residential development zone is it is meant to be an overlay zone that somebody can apply to a more substantial property. So it's got a single family home. And the idea is to have built a tool.

1:59:16 to change and vary from some of the standards so that you can see projects that are more traditionally known as perhaps a clustered development project. And so it gives you some ability through a process that would go through review to have different lot standards and a different type of grouping of buildings and roadway design.

1:59:42 So if you could imagine in your mind a more substantial piece of property and you wanted to vary, not from the intent, because you have to meet generally the standards of the underlying zone, but you place it on the site and you say, we're going to do something a little different. And it's meant to deal specifically with the siting of buildings and the organization of land versus a typical subdivision that might get plopped down in a very rote way.

2:00:12 Okay, the way I read number five, I thought we were digging ourselves a hole. Are you reading that to say that a recreational building or structure, that that requirement overrides any setback requirement in a separate part? No, it may be counted as required open space, which means you can cover your whole parcel. There's still lot coverage requirements as well.

2:00:36 So you can't exceed the minimum lot. If you look right above that H, item 4H, the site coverage is still the same as the required. So maybe, you know, the lot coverage is only 60% or... That addresses my concern right there. Okay, I was reading number 5 and actually I had missed note H, so I'm sorry about that. At number 8 on page 93, I have a note here, snow storage, and about how close...

2:01:06 A building can be to a vehicular lot or other surface area reserved for public use or for use in common. Is that unrelated to snow storage or that's not an issue for snow storage because that's all we've heard this winter is we don't have enough room for snow storage? This is a minimum standard. Minimum? Yeah, if you go back to the idea that this is something that lets you have a different kind of development pattern, you still have to have a functional site.

2:01:34 Okay, I have my eye out for snow storage, so I was thinking of that. Okay, those are all my questions, and I have a comment when we have discussion. Other questions? Yes, I want to go back to wherever, where were you, Elizabeth, when you? Oh, I'm on so many pages. Aircraft, what is the name of Mammoth Lakes Airport? Mammoth Yosemite Airport. And we're going to continue to call it Mammoth Lakes Airport here?

2:02:07 I think it's referring to the Mammoth Lakes Airport Layout Plan, which is what that title of the document is. Okay, I thought it was Mammoth Yosemite. There is a land use plan, though, and I think it's the Mammoth Lakes Airport Layout Plan. Well, I think that should be added, don't you think? At the time the plan was made, that was the name of the plan.

2:02:33 If you're arguing that we should go back and change the plan just to change the name. No, no, no, no, I'm saying this references a specific document. Right. It's what Sandra just said. That's the point. And that's the name of the document. It was named that before the airport was named. Right, right. It was. But it isn't clear that that, I mean, you know, Sharon makes a good point. That's not the name of the airport. This is referencing a document. And so it seems like the fact it's a document should be referred to.

2:03:01 We'll cite as a document. Yeah. Okay. I didn't even know if we should put it in parens, you know, Mammoth Yosemite Airport after it's made. No, it refers to a document. Because of that. Okay. That was my only concern. Okay. You said you had a comment, Elizabeth? Oh, yes. I don't favor removing the snow deposition design overlay zone. I'm surprised that...

2:03:30 We weren't proposing to remove the whole zone, just that one section that was cited, which is item D on page 99 of the packet. So just, I highlighted it, and I said, should we delete this section? So not the whole snow deposition design zone, just this one section that requires the town to develop guidelines applicable to the entire zone.

2:03:58 Which we haven't done in the past and probably won't do in the future because we do it on a case-by-case basis. And the reason we haven't done it is that a case-by-case basis is generally required because of the uniqueness of each site. Right, right. I don't see how that's going to change in the future. You actually get a better result, I think. Exactly, I agree. Okay, I retract that.

2:04:21 Okay, I was concerned there as well, but it's the entire zone. Correct. And we do it on a case-by-case with each. Thank you. For a good reason. Yes. Because as you say, the uniqueness of each site. Okay. Let me see if we, I want to ask if we have consensus on these individual issues that were raised.

2:04:44 The first one was the whether to keep the planned residential development zone as part of the chapter. I did. Okay. The next one is to split. The overlay zones, the users group suggested keeping them within the draft chapter, but

2:05:06 Grouping them together as overlay zones. Now, the way you've got it currently drafted, you just have them all alphabetical. Right. I didn't make the change yet until the commission. But it's called special purpose zone, so it seems perfect. So we would just group the overlay into, like, maybe the beginning or the end or something like that. If you turn to page... 102. Page 81. You see 17.28.010B. The special purpose zones are listed there, 1 through 10.

2:05:38 What this would do is group with, those are all alphabetized, but it would take them into two alphabetized groups, and one being the overlays, those would all be grouped separately. It's just a matter of organizing it. And it makes it more user-friendly, which is what we're trying to do. Rhonda? I agree. Okay. Absolutely. Sharon? You're going to leave it the way it is. No. You see...

2:06:01 Number one is affordable housing overlay zone. Right, okay. If you put the overlay zones first, number two would be equestrian overlay zone. Number three would be snow definition. Okay, so you're grouping overlays together. It just makes more logical. Okay, that's... And then the others would be grouped in their own group. It's not a big change. Okay, I thought you were on page 102.

2:06:25 Special purpose zoning. No, the discussion of individual zones after that would presumably be reorganized like that too. Okay. But it's all the same materials, just organized a little more logically. Got it. I think that's good. Do we have consensus? Yes. So I think the consensus is the two groups. Okay. Okay? Okay. Thank you. I appreciate it. And we didn't, well, I guess formally we should say then, do we have consensus on the whole

2:06:54 Draft 1728 with the one change I guess we discussed on the way it's listed here. I think so. Yes. I'm satisfied with the answers. Okay. That's good. Good. That brings us to agenda item 8, which is the zoning code update workshop on height and mix. Would you like me to wait or begin? I think you can probably begin Elizabeth. Oh, heck. I didn't know he was gone. I was going to ask for a break. And she's gone.

2:08:05 Do you need to take a break, Jen? Let's see. You might want to take your break. Why don't you go ahead, since she's out, a little overlap breaks. It went 400 slides. So I'll begin, because I see that you're all back. This is a global planning and mass workshop with the Planning Commission, and the purpose of this workshop is to help.

2:08:48 So today we're going to walk through some extensive information with you and we're leaving with you the extensive PowerPoint presentation that has some actionable items in it and we would like to follow up

2:09:12 at your next commission meeting. What we want to hear today from you, we want to present this information, and we want to see if we've missed anything that you're concerned with, then we'll help you and the council conclude this discussion. This has been a very controversial subject, of course. And also then, we want to be able to follow up with a kit of parts for the zoning code that you can conclude and...

2:09:40 Receive direction from the Council so that then in June you'll be reviewing the draft zoning code regarding building height. There are some related items with this. Incentive zoning may perhaps relate, but we're not discussing that today, so we want to get the box built, if you will, before we move on. What we think we've gathered through now the years of experience on this subject

2:10:06 And most recently, Commissioner Dugan put a very good point to this. What, why, and where first. What are you trying to achieve where and why are you trying to achieve it? Our questions that I think we need to focus on are what areas have appropriate standards now? Because if they're appropriate now, we don't have to study them. Which areas should be discussed and why? What in particular should change and what's driving that change?

2:10:35 And which standards should be refined and why? And then another large question, which I think we've given you good information already on, is what is the most effective content and format to describe these standards? In your package, we gave you a brief introduction about this subject, but we also gave you your Planning Commission workshop report of February 9th, where we already discussed a bundle of these subjects.

2:11:04 And we also provided a few sections from a draft transect-based code that was prepared for Flagstaff, Arizona. Flagstaff is not unlike Mammoth Lakes. It's relatively high altitude. I think it's about 6,000, 7,000 feet. So we have snow. But they also are old. It's an old log in the mining community. And so they have a main street pattern. But they've also experienced extensive growth. And Sandra came across this.

2:11:34 We also provided some information new from Napa, who is conducting a downtown specific plan. And we thought that in particular, the subject matters that have been discussed are important, and Napa's format, graphics, diagrams, and mapping is also very helpful. The methodology that we have taken to kind of facilitate this discussion is to note those important

2:12:04 Factors that relate to building height. This is really kind of a Lego block exercise for us. The what, why, and where relates to the place and what it's intended to be and what its form and character is resultant from that place. Community character and environment is very, very important to us. It's the idea of the trees, the natural setting and how development complements rather than takes away from that environment.

2:12:33 The specific design setting that we're dealing with, which is looking more detailed perspective of the siting of buildings and the characteristics and their adjoining uses. Building systems, the economics of construction, and then finally we'll review with you the best practices and case studies that we've seen. Let me take a moment and stop before I go through this PowerPoint.

2:13:01 And wave my hands at the wall so our viewers at home can't see this. But we have done some extensive work on all of these subjects. These sketch graphics represent, in plan view and in section, the implementation of Old Mammoth Road design plans that resulted from our neighborhood district planning efforts. And this section is the progress that we've made on Main Street.

2:13:29 Showing a reconfigured street centered around the travel lanes, and then the phasing plan, which is very similar to what Citizen Harvey presented to you, which shows the existing buildings, and then the evolution and phasing of buildings coming up to the edge that was described in our Main Street strategies. So we've done a lot of work and plan to understand scale, section, and character of these areas.

2:13:58 These diagrams, as you can see a little bit, represent our taking apart buildings. Buildings work in a certain way. They all have floors to them. They're a certain dimension. Ground floor retail is a different dimension than residential. And all buildings have roofs. A flat roof is not really flat. It has to shed water. And it's about perhaps a 1 inch in 12 pitch slope up to...

2:14:28 A pointed roof, which you might see at Sierra Nevada Lodge, which might be a 12-12 pitch roof. And then stacking these up from the ground up and understanding how parking works either inside a building, so floors above it but at grade, and also below grade and partially below grade. So we've really taken apart buildings. We've worked with our building officials. We know how they work.

2:14:56 And then finally,

2:15:23 We've also studied how standards are applied not only to blocks but to parcels. Let me just pass this on out as we speak. There's nothing more unfortunate to go through a zoning code process and then at the end have a series of property owners coming to you in your public hearings saying that these standards won't work on my property. My property is small and when you apply a certain standard to it you have precluded.

2:15:59 My ability to develop it. So our work has been above-ground character, but also we'll talk to you about how it is applied really here, boots on the ground in the town. So with that, I'm going to move into what, why, and where and move at a brisk pace. We think there are stable areas and there are areas that we need to study, which are principally those district planning areas.

2:16:28 The stable areas are the single family zones, the multifamily zones, the public and quasi-public zones, industrial zones, and then the master and specific plan areas that are largely complete. Snow Creek, Sierra Star, North Village, Shady Rest, and Clearwater. I put Shady Rest into this category as well because we've completed the district planning effort for that work, but we're not intending to initiate

2:16:55 A change to those current development standards. It has an affordable housing overlay zone to it which could remain, be removed, be changed, but we don't have that as a specific zone change to initiate through this process. We want to focus first on what we think we do need to change. Should the 200 or so property owners who are now on shady rest wish to come forward?

2:17:23 They can do so, and you'll have the tools in the toolbox to go through a rezoning for them. This represents our progress to complete district planning. You'll see that there's relatively no white space left. We focused on the village, understanding all of the mainstream shady rest areas, and as I've already said, the south districts are now nearing the public process through Planning Commission and Town Council.

2:17:52 The areas that we do think we need to focus on are Main Street West, that area between, let's say, Manzanita and Minaret that's not part of the village, North Old Mammoth Road, and the downtown area. And through the district planning process, I'll back up for a moment, it looks like we're forming up the concepts of the key significant places that are generally walkable as North Village.

2:18:20 The idea of downtown, which is North Old Mammoth Road and Main Street, and then South Mammoth, which is that portion of South Old Mammoth Road that we're in right now. In that context, we have just a few height zones, and as we progress through this, you'll see that Napa, for example, has a much more varied pattern of building heights related to the different uses.

2:18:50 We have in the darkest color building heights that are 70 feet or above. Those include the village, Sierra Star, and the small portion of the hotel area of Snow Creek. The next gradient is the zone that's generally from 55 to 75 feet and then 45 to 55. And then the bulk of the area ranges from 35 to 45 feet. And that includes

2:19:17 All of the commercial area of the C1, C2 zone, as well as the RMF1 and RMF2 zones. And that is an obvious image to me to say that we've treated everything the same where they're not really truly the same, which is certainly worthy of discussion. Out of the downtown concept for Main Street, we focused on three principal parts. The western area of Main Street, which is...

2:19:47 noted for infill and polish, and perhaps limited areas of change in that particular zone. The area around the outlet malls and then the rest of the downtown, which was characterized as truly being a main street. In the South Old Mammoth Road area, South Mammoth, very similar concepts have been suggested, that the area become walkable.

2:20:15 That the street walls of new development and infill development be moved to the street edge, and that Old Mammoth Road itself becomes a complete street with both traveled lanes, bicycle lanes, parking on street, and a generous sidewalk area. So downtown and Old Mammoth Road include this basic pattern shown on the wall. And Tom Cage is now gone.

2:20:44 In the Main Street Program, the center image, the line drawing that's black and white, he literally looked at that drawing and said, that's exactly what I was thinking. And what he's pointing to is the fact that there's two to three stories, but there's also mass taken out of the center and pushed behind.

2:21:06 Almost in a block U shape of a building so that those folks who might be behind actually have a view through the site. And so this has become to us a meaningful discussion about what happens on the street edge next to the sidewalk. Also, this image you'll recall from the North Old Mammoth Road study related to what, why, and where is the idea of the Main Street pattern.

2:21:34 This image, which then Clearwater and Old Mammoth Place evolved from, is noting that successful commercial districts have a much, much finer grain of accessibility. The blocks are smaller. They're 300 by 300 versus 1,000 by 600. And this image represents the idea of alleys and mid-block connectors.

2:22:00 Creating the means to access across and also creating frontage for retail and open space. It also points out that there are primary retail streets that actually become designated and become part of the code and along those streets there are street wall and retail requirements. If you don't require retail it is unlikely that it will happen. That study also showed us the concept of

2:22:28 Changing our now building height, which is generally 35 feet, but with an exception, it can go up to 45 feet. This process identified a minimum street wall of 25 feet and a maximum of 35 and shifting away building mass towards the center where it's out of view and it doesn't affect Old Mammoth Road itself. This happened to be based on a 45 degree angle.

2:22:56 Which results in a one-to-one setback. So for every one foot, you can go up one foot. And in the case of a building, we only plan around stories or floors. So generally you'd see a ten foot rise and a ten foot setback. Those standards, this is an important concept that we'll weave through this. The standards, it makes a difference how you apply them. If you apply them to the block,

2:23:23 Then you are very focused on the street edge. But you can also apply them to property lines in addition to the block. And for whatever reason, this thing has no color differentiation. The block pattern you see on the left, that's the sketch that I just passed around. And you'll see in the bottom slide,

2:23:47 The largest piece of property, that's on the order of magnitude of the Clearwater site. There are not many of those sites around. That happens to be about, I think it's 600 by 400 feet. And then we work our way down to the uppermost corner on the left, which is 100 by 150. And it makes a difference if you have two public frontages or one, you're in an interior lot. On the left hand,

2:24:15 We've applied that very simple 45-degree setback dimension to the perimeter of the block. On the right-hand image, we've applied it to the perimeter as well to the interior property lines. And you can see that we start shaping the areas where building can occur and where it can't occur. This is what that slide should look like. It's green. I don't know why it's green there, but it's supposed to be three different colors.

2:24:50 So, the next idea is that Main Street West area, where we see infill development, and it's not necessarily oriented to a particular pattern, like a Main Street pattern. And what we would expect to see in that area, then, are just incremental infill projects that might range from generally low scale, two to three stories, up to what you...

2:25:19 Processed with the Holiday House Project, which is a four and three floor and five floor building. In this image you can see that it's generally four floors above parking. The building is stepped to the terrain and building height is within the tree canopy. The palette of boards down here are kind of the history of what you've processed in the past as a refresher.

2:25:47 And a more important concept for us as we progress is parking. Typically, form follows parking. And the 64-foot bay dimension of head-end parking with a drive aisle two-way and head-end parking equals 64 feet. And two bays of those happens to match the dimension of residential. A typical double-loaded unit, such as what all of these are.

2:26:16 Have about a 30, 35-foot unit with an interior hallway with another 35-foot unit, which coincides with that 64-foot bay dimension. And so understanding that structure is important because that's how buildings are put together. With each subject that we present, we've extracted what we think the big ideas are, what principles should be applied to the zoning code, and how you figure out what your policy recommendations are.

2:26:46 In this case, big idea, tailored standards are needed to achieve the desired district planning outcomes. The downtown concepts won't happen unless they're implemented through the zoning code. You should not expect retail, for example. It's risky, it costs more, and you might not be fully rented all the time. It's more difficult. Mark, how are you using tailored there? You mean like customized? Yes. Okay.

2:27:16 As we've completed the district planning process, what we've seen is a difference in thinking as to what the zoning code should actually do. In the past, I think it's been difficult to understand. It's been somewhat obstructive. And it's not precisely related to construction or what we're trying to achieve. And perhaps it should shift to one that is actually encouraging the desired program.

2:27:46 that you want to see, making very clear standards and becoming responsive. And if you think that the change that the community needs to become truly a destination resort, most of that change is implemented by new development. The town is generally not going to sweep through an area and redo the sidewalks. You want the private sector investment to repair sidewalks, provide parking.

2:28:14 And provide the retail space if that's what you want in those places. And so the code should be not penalizing but encouraging what it is you truly want to achieve. It should be very focused on complete streets that form this public room. A couple of meetings ago I gave you an excerpt from Great Streets by Mr. Alan Jacobs. That's the public room. And that's where most of us experience.

2:28:43 We certainly have the natural environment that is absolutely unmatched, but our urban environment, this built environment, is sorely lacking. And so focusing not only on the components of building, but the spaces it shapes is important to us. Building height should relate to street width.

2:29:10 and the sections of those streets. There's a comfortable scale. Perhaps you picked that up in that excerpt I gave you. So having that sense of comfort that's appropriate to your environment here, that's your job to figure out. Main street features, again, should be required where appropriate. So that, for us, is our sense of what, why, and where. Community character and environment is most affected.

2:29:37 By tree canopy, views, vistas, and some sun shadow issues. We have a lot of knowledge about tree canopies. We've done surveys with every project we've done. We didn't have to do a lot of work in Snow Creek, though. But we've mapped, studied, and quantified and qualified our tree canopy. So I think we've got extensive information, and now we just need to make decisions. You've seen these before.

2:30:07 These are photos where we're able to look outside of our window and measure trees. Tree canopy and tree top height are two different things. Tree top height, it ranges from, in some places, 57 feet 85 to plus 107. And there are always lower trees and there are always taller trees. And I think what the biggest point has been is where the branches of those trees begin to interlace.

2:30:35 That's where we start forming the canopy. And typically, we're finding it's around 55 feet. Some places a little lower, some places a little higher. The zoning has to think about that, but think about these other factors as well. The principles we can take away from tree canopy is that the canopy is not completely uniform. It's punctuated by trees of different heights.

2:31:01 Generally, the canopy height is 55 to 65 feet. Tree top height is from 65 upward. In some places, some of the trees at Sierra Star are taller than that. In some places, we have unique topography. But in general, this is what we actually see when we measure them. Building heights, five stories and 55 feet fit within the tree canopy.

2:31:30 At 65 feet, a maximum, roof elements and equipment fit within treetops. And I want to point out something about roofs. Roofs generally tend to recede from view. If a roof is in this shape to you from one perspective, but is in this shape that big, that's a different kind of roof condition. So when we talk about roofs, we want to think about them

2:32:00 In diminishing form and not as just a piece of the building. So with those two points, I think what we can take away is above 45 feet in general, upper story step backs, a setback occurs at the ground plane, step backs occur above the ground plane. So 45 feet upper story step backs, massing, articulation and area limitations are more important to us. Views.

2:32:31 In vista, overall context of the town, following just on what we spoke of, in general, your vista from any point in town is generally obstructed by the canopy of the trees. You can only see over them. In a few places, on certain streets, you can look down the street and see some significant view feature, like the Sherwins. From upper elevations of the town,

2:33:01 And here's a view from Lake Mary. This is looking out at the Snow Creek area, and you can see in the distance, especially off to the left, some forms of human settlement. From this perspective, which... Do you recall where this is taken from, Sandra?

2:33:32 Okay, Mammoth. Oh, yes, I think it is from Mammoth Rock. It's from the Sherwin's, and this is pointing out how difficult it is to mask development from a view, because I'm at such a high elevation, I can really look down on top of it, which relates back to that hype discussion you just had about the 8250. So this is very similar. At 8250, I can start to see you, and then from 8250, you can start to see everybody down here.

2:34:03 So, this is a view, you'll remember that some time ago we have an extensive catalog of all the views on major streets. This is a sheet from that, and we have a series of them, but the view up Main Street actually terminates in tree canopy. So, I don't have, in this case, a significant broad vista that's...

2:34:26 Different from what's covered up by the existing trees. So if there are buildings within that tree canopy, they're not affecting overall the sense of vista. However, Old Mammoth Road is different. There are a series of points along Old Mammoth Road where we have a very defined view scape of the Sherwins. And we can also go back and look at the width of Main Street, very broad. This is in a sense that

2:34:55 This is a little less, but it's the 200 to 200 foot dimension from building to building. And those trees on the right hand side change and reduce that view, but you can still see that it's much wider than Old Mammoth Road. And so the width of the street makes a difference, as does the canopy and the framing along it. And I think we can give you these principles to work from.

2:35:20 View corridors provide important public views of a special scenic feature. So that's a definition of a view corridor. Some streets provide views of vistas framed by tree canopy and protected by maximum building heights. And then to protect a view corridor, minimum and maximum street wall heights are usually established and upper story step backs are established to protect that view corridor. So it's the frame of the building.

2:35:49 And how it starts adding to that sense of enclosure that starts to affect it. On Old Mammoth Road, it's more narrow and it has significant views. Upper story step backs above 35 feet may be appropriate. That was the action that you took on the Clearwater Project. On Main Street, it's wider now and also in the future. It's less sensitive because it doesn't have a specific view corridor feature to it.

2:36:18 And the topography and orientation is different. Upper story step backs above 45 feet may be appropriate. On sun shadow analysis, we typically evaluate a project not uniquely on a case-by-case basis, but the best practice is to really understand that all structures cast a shadow.

2:36:45 Design analysis is typically on a design day, and it's not usually the worst day of the year. So typically it's 10, 3, and at noon. The shadow is the same at 10 and 3. And it's typically done on the equinox, not on the winter solstice. So the equinox is when the sun is at its midpoint in the sky. The greatest shadows obviously are cast during the winter months on the north side of a building.

2:37:15 And when we go back to the images, the top right, you can't do much about that shadow. It's a significant shadow. What are the foot dimensions on shadows? It's 1.8 foot of shadow to each foot of the building. So it's considered. So at principle. Is that at noon? At the worst case. Yeah.

2:37:42 So a general thought that can be implemented through zoning is to shift taller building elements to the center of a site so it's casting on itself and not the edge of the public room. And so we're concerned about daylight on our public walks and our roads. And you can also shift building height to the south side of a site. Design setting.

2:38:06 In this context, we're going to talk about block and parcel size, street edge proportion, mass and articulation, and adjacent zones and uses. You've seen this before, and it's still true. Our blocks are mammoth, no pun intended. Aspen is pretty typical. It's showing a 200 by 200, 300 by 300 kind of grid. And in the variety of...

2:38:32 The experience that happens on that grid, the break and the traffic pattern is important, as well as the different modes of access and the accessibility it provides to all forms of transportation. That's why, that's the principle that was established in acknowledging alleys and mid-block connectors to break up our large blocks. The map on the left is the mapped building heights from the Napa-specific plan.

2:39:03 And we overlay that one in this one because it's showing that grid of streets with the alley connections. And what typically happens in alleys is some form of pedestrian access, but it's also service delivery. And again, these principles were applied to the Clearwater project. When we take Clearwater as an example, and we...

2:39:28 Transcribe that into a pattern of zoning. So we're always going to show you the same kind of format here so it's comparable to you about this one as well. The first one I showed you was the idea of establishing upper story step backs based on a 45 degree angle, one for one. In this case, we mapped the key principles of Clearwater to show you what it might look like in terms of zoning.

2:40:01 And this is to be thoughtful that the Clearwater project was a designed project. In this case, the first step back is mapped at 60 feet, which is a significant setback. And then the second one is an additional 30 feet. Their project was designed based on unit design, so that effectively on the edges of the street they had either a double loaded or a single loaded.

2:40:30 Unit, and then they step back above it. When we apply this in our street section, you can imagine if you had a 50-foot parcel, you're not going to have anything above 35 feet. So this is a very dramatic and significant setback. Principles from the block and parcel size, blockable districts.

2:40:55 Have smaller block patterns with alleys and connectors. Street edge and internal conditions should be considered when you establish zoning standards. Those applied to the block address scale, mass, and views. Those applied to parcel lines add interior light and air and establishing views through and over a site.

2:41:21 Another idea through this is that taller buildings require larger upper story setbacks to protect scale and view. So the taller the building is, the more step back you're trying to achieve. Larger step backs and parcel line applications impact smaller lots. Small lots may not be able to achieve the heights of 45 feet and 55 feet.

2:41:45 This is a scan of one of our sketches. This is the complete street that's approved for the Mammoth Crossings project. So it has a center lane, two traveled lanes, bike lane, those are very small bicyclists, and then on-street parking. And it's very important, again, to get this sense of edge and proportion scale. So this ratio principle, there's no one automatic number to apply.

2:42:14 The width should generally be about 1 to 2 to 1 to 4. At a scale of 1 to 1, the ratio feels urban. So in downtown San Diego, I might have a 1 to 1 relationship, and you're going to feel like you're in a dense urban area. We've seen this applied in a lot of places. These two images are befores and afters of Alpine, California and Barrio Logan, California.

2:42:46 And a common thing that we're all looking at is how do we achieve that desirable streetscape scale and proportion. And these are showing you the concept of the pedestrian-friendly environment and complete street. And noting that the taller buildings are located in intersections because the intersection is the doubling, it's where two streets meet, and so the open space on the diagonal is bigger. So if you do have taller elements,

2:43:15 That's probably an appropriate place to cite them. The images you see are generally three and four stories with a street wall and the relationship of landscaping. Principles, probably the takeaways, street walls are cited at the edge of the sidewalk to help create a sense of pedestrian scale and a feeling of spatial enclosure.

2:43:42 Wider streets and intersections require taller street walls. So if your street right-of-way is 200 feet, you won't even see a one-story building. It's almost out of your field of vision. Achieving the public room is important. And when you're thinking about building height, the comfort range is somewhere for an 80-foot right-of-way, 20 to 45 feet. 100 foot is probably 25 to 55.

2:44:10 And then height also has to think about the other factors that we'll talk about shortly. Mass and articulation is the idea that the fixed volume affects how you perceive it. So a big blocky structure seems larger than one that has complexity and setbacks and openings.

2:44:35 This happens to be your analysis of the Mammoth Crossings project, and we can show you that there's a lot of moving in and out of that building. It's not a solid plane, and there are three levels of dimension, so it's pushed back, pushed back again. And then it's also complex. That was only zoning, but the drawings that you saw during that project had ins and outs and dormers.

2:45:08 And ledger lines and shadow cast. So it's important for the code to acknowledge those features so that you're achieving the design that you want. Mark, what's a built course? A built course is either a change in material pattern that's going along a building, either at the base or some other feature, but it's differentiated from the rest of the wall plane.

2:45:38 So, complex facades with entrances, canopies and awnings, belt courses, cornice lines, eaves and parapets, detailed windows and balconies, all those together with shape and form dramatically affect your thinking of a building. Zones should also relate to specific uses in adjoining zones. In this case, we have a larger

2:46:07 Perhaps commercial zone on the right, and then an appropriate relationship to a smaller residential zone. This is the idea of the transecta zone, again. Standards allow for transitions between zones and uses, and in Napa you can see it mapped out fairly discreetly, so in just a block or even a block and a half, they're moving from 50 feet to 35 feet to 30 feet, and that's related obviously to the use and to the different.

2:46:37 Types of buildings allowed. The principles from mass and articulation. Building articulation adds interest to pedestrian realm, improves the sense of scale, visually reduces that sense of mass. Articulation is needed both vertically and horizontally. Appropriate flexibility and standards can encourage creative building massing and more attractive facades and roof forms. And then consideration should be given to the adjacent.

2:47:07 Zones to any district. Building systems and economics of construction. This drives much of what you actually have to review and react to. Structure and floor-to-floor heights. That's what we're in right now. This is a building and it has a floor and it has a ceiling. That ceiling has a joist structure and it has to carry ducts.

2:47:37 Vents, electrical, water, and so these things add up and stack up to define building height. Parking and access, form follows parking. Roofs and mechanical equipment, and then other considerations. This is a diagram from Flagstaff, and what we like about this is that it simply shows you the key pieces of a building that we should consider when we're setting height limits, whatever those height limits are.

2:48:05 In the single family to the left, the building has a crawl space. Here we have a lot of crawl spaces. We might also have basements. We have a floor with a floor above. And then in most buildings, there's some form of a crawl space, an attic, which may be also some portions suitable to be finished. And then there's a roof. The diagram on the right shows a typical

2:48:35 Commercial construction, it might have a different form, but it's the same thing. We're going to have a form of perhaps basement, underground parking, a foundation, floor-to-floor heights, and then there's some kind of roof. And we want to be able to understand them and then also clearly describe them. In roof forms, all buildings have roofs, or else you don't think it's really a building. I've already mentioned what a flat roof is.

2:49:04 We're starting to see more applications that have a shed roof on them, so the bottom center image, and the shed roof is doing a couple of things. It's holding the snow, but it's in a little more slope, so there's good drainage and runoff from it, and the edge of the flat roof, the edge is now being used to create necessarily or just a larger sense of volume in some of your projects.

2:49:40 When we set building height and we've accommodated the floors, which become rentable space, we still have to put a roof on it. So we're hopeful that we can have a document that describes and defines them all. Also in this, on the top left, the gable roof form, if you're viewing that building from the more narrow end, the visual impact of that roof form is less than if you were looking at its broad side.

2:50:10 Because from a distance, you'll only see the silhouette of that roof structure. So understanding how much roof you want to allow within your height standards is very important. The mansard roof and the hip roof tend to be more diminishing towards the center from any perspective. Building roofs. So these are projects that you've seen around you if you know what they all look like.

2:50:37 The bottom left image is Vista Point, and you can see the use of the shed roof to create a particular roof form. It intersects with generally a flat roof. On building equipment, you all know that it's there, whether it's an elevator, chimneys, vents, or HVAC, or even solar now.

2:51:06 We need to think about this and how we choose to allow it, screen it, and accommodate it. Parking is very important to us. Under structure configurations, generally it's some 64-foot bay dimension that relates to the building design. And then spread out through a site, it becomes more and more efficient and effective to have it become continuously laid out together and grouped.

2:51:36 Billings that are built over a parking structure are following that 64-foot bay dimension, and it's very efficient. We usually often see the number of three floors over one floor of parking as a particularly efficient unit. Parking surface is least expensive, but the long-term operating costs of parking, in fact, look at this lot out here, for how many years has it

2:52:06 Gone through snow removal. How much of that has required a loss of spaces because the snow is being piled someplace? And one of the things to consider in your zoning code is changing that dynamic so you're encouraging more covered parking and it's more efficient and then the people that are the visitors and guests are not as impacted by the inconvenience of the parking lot being closed. So one would think that

2:52:36 It might be a greener system to have covered parking that doesn't require forever snow removal operations. Understructure parking, if it's not underground, it's understructure. It's occupying that habitable floor. And so ultimately out of this, whatever our envelope is, we want the envelope fixed so that when people come to us at the counter and say we want to build this building, we hand them the zoning code. That's the height.

2:53:07 Whatever you do in it, that's the height. Parking can be partially underground, and what you saw with Vista Point and also in the Clearwater Project is there's ramping to a garage, there's access to it, and it's not always perfectly aligned with existing grade. So we tend to want to measure it from the finished floor dimension, which was quite a debate with the Clearwater Project, and absolutely not debated in the Vista Point Project.

2:53:37 Fully underground parking is incredibly expensive. In Los Angeles, it might start now at about $20,000 a space, and then for every level I go down, it's going to jump by maybe 50%, maybe even 100% per space per level. And so the cost impact is huge. Hence our desire to get with...

2:54:05 Nelson Nygaard to make sure that we've got the best knowledge to not overpark or underpark. Other considerations are the California Building Code. It limits construction type, so you can only build so many things and meet code. Typically, wood frame is only allowed up to four stories above a fire-protected structure, so a sprinkler garage or the ground.

2:54:35 We have fire district requirements that limit building height by how tall their ladder truck actually can reach. Some of the principles for us, floor plates differ for varying uses. Ground floor retail is going to be about 15 feet high from floor to structure, and residential and hotel will typically be 8 foot 6. Roofs add interest to buildings.

2:55:04 Articulation of the roof is important to us, but so is a flat roof. We can see a big difference between a commercial district where flat roofs are appropriate and they actually add to the continuity versus having a series of flat roofs or parapets and then some significantly tall building that's in a completely different character and form. So the village seems to have roofs. I think what's...

2:55:33 Trending in this Main Street area is more flat and shed type roofs. Parking is, we certainly have to think about mechanical equipment and accommodating that in height. Parking is dictating frequently our building dimensions as well as site form. And then underground parking, under structure parking, should be encouraged, I think, for a lot of different reasons. One thing I'll say in addition about parking is from the

2:56:03 The design perspective, our streetscape and what we tend to see in the community, once I'm not seeing it, whether it's behind a building on the back, it's under structure, but we still have that desirable design in front, which may be retail, it may not, I don't know that we really care. The visual aspect of parking is one of screening. The economic aspect is a different issue. Best practices and case studies and some applications.

2:56:33 I'm going to go through these very quickly, and then I'm going to stop, and I'm going to ask you to come down to the table so we can talk. We looked at Flagstaff, NAPA, and then some of the things that we've done recently here in Mammoth Lakes' case studies. Flagstaff is really interesting to us because it's clear, it's unambiguous, I can see it and understand it in text and in diagrams and maps.

2:57:03 Thinking about what they're trying to achieve. So it's transect-based. For us, that's like district planning. They're looking at the number of stories, number of floors, as well as maximum building height. And you've heard Bruce Woodward talk to you about building height. If you limit building height so much by a particular dimension, people will try to navigate around that and have odd floor dimensions.

2:57:31 That may not be the desirable form that you want to see. Understanding how construction really works, I think they've captured that in their dimensions. Their first overview, and we're only giving you excerpts now of what we gave you, is how they measure height. It's simply a plane to the site. We don't do that. We're using the average of three points on the site, and it's probably difficult for us.

2:58:01 It's difficult for a lot of our applicants. And by the way, we've walked through this, an early presentation of this with the zoning code users group, and they felt that we were moving in the right direction and that this type of approach was very useful. You can also see in this map that they've acknowledged a variation for a different roof pitch. So you see a little dashed line.

2:58:28 And the idea is that I think, again, the diminishing amount of roof that is in that height limit is an important consideration. And then they have some specific language where they'll state that I think the number was only 25% of a given area of roof or equipment can exceed a particular height.

2:58:52 They've mapped out, which I've already talked to you about, how they measure overall height, and whether you're measuring the parapet or the extension of a shed roof or the eave of a roof, we want to capture that idea. The finished floor height shown on the left for an attic or perhaps an answered roof, I think that's important for us to capture because so many people are using

2:59:20 The zoning code, they're going all the way up to the maximum height to try to get the rentable space. And I think that in many places we want to acknowledge the value of rentable space. They've taken these standards in both sections so you can see them vertically, and then they map their other important considerations. So if you want to have a street wall, you want to map where it is and what the dimensions need to be to the property line or to the back of the sidewalk.

2:59:48 Napa is very clear to us, and I think what I want to point out, that if we choose to apply setback dimensions, like, you know, 45 degree angle, those don't work well in that type of a map. And so we might map the overall heights, because now when I open the zoning code as a user, I don't have to read pages and pages and paragraphs, I can see it.

3:00:16 And it might be refined by whatever setback dimensions we actually use. So it's very clear. Also in Napa, they've spent a lot of time doing what we're doing now. And they're talking about place-based standards, dimensioning floors, and identifying the scale of the room. This is a photo of a project in Napa. That happens to be a ground floor retail space.

3:00:45 I think there are two stories above it with another one floor at least at setback. But you can see how, in a real building, how it starts to recede from your plane a view with the upper story stepbacks. On the far right, this is the idea of articulation and massing, a big blue box compared to a building that has movement and mass is chipped away from the facade.

3:01:14 or added to certain portions, street scale issues, and useful diagrams. A few case studies, Vista Point on the north of the site, much higher elevation, so there was a drop-off on the south of the site, that became the garage, and this is the 64-foot dimension double-loaded corridor.

3:01:38 It's based on the parking. This happens to be four floors above parking, but they're not just pure flats. The space is grouped so that there are multiple floors for individual units. Old Mammoth Place, this was a range of product, three, four, and five floors above retail or parking. Also, in addition to retail, the interior court...

3:02:06 Portions of the hotel were an extra height because it was in a conference space. And so acknowledging the higher ground floor requirements for retail and conference and meeting and restaurant space is important. Trees were preserved on site. There was vertical and horizontal variation and articulation. The roof is holding the snow. It's quite a challenge if you have a

3:02:34 Dense project like this, and the snow shedding on the property itself. Double loaded parking allows, 64, but it took the entire site, so the deck was designed around that bay unit. This image shows you just what is above a particular height plane as a roof and mechanical area, so we always have to have stairwells and elevator shafts and vent structure.

3:03:05 So again, regardless of what the heights are, we still need to accommodate those. Our applications, I think we want to test our conditions. We want to really understand the street edge, the street wall condition. Is it 35 feet, 45 feet, some other dimension? Step backs, what we have now showed you through this is a couple of approaches, one mapping it to clear water, another of...

3:03:35 45 degrees, and we're going to show you some numbers that relate to 30 degrees. We all always need to think about the unique floor-to-floor ceiling requirements of all the different uses. So this is, these are now our graphics, so we're taking the approach of trying to be very clear with definitions. So we have a ground floor dimension of 15 feet, two upper floors at 10 feet, so that's 35 feet for total story height.

3:04:04 We still have to accommodate a parapet or a shed roof or an eave as well as elevators and mechanical equipment. So if the height dimension was in the zoning code at 35 feet but we didn't define that mechanical equipment, you'd really only have a T-story building. This is the same thing with a variation of either a very steep...

3:04:30 Angle of setback or a mansard roof. But the idea is to show you what happens when we put on a fourth floor. Same dimension, but we end up hitting 45 feet plus the roof structure above. Back to our diagrams. This is the mapping of the Clearwater Project, which is at the first edge, a building height of, a street wall height of 35 feet.

3:05:02 And then the next plane for 10 feet of 45 with a tremendous setback of 60 feet. And then above that up to 55 with another 30 foot dimension. On the image to the left, it's a little difficult to see for you, maybe in your handling it's more accurate. The color shown in the red, kind of coral color.

3:05:28 You can see that there's not much of it there, so you could not practically achieve that height when it's applied to the parcel and block. The idea is that if a unit is looking like it's about 30 feet, you need to achieve about 30 feet in those upper planes for it to be applied. So in this concept, in parcel versus block, you can compare how much area of a property

3:05:58 And how much the smaller lots will be affected by that particular application. And again, that's the super setback. This is the same concept at a 45 degree angle that's showing a three story, 35 foot street edge with two setbacks with a maximum height of 55. Same concept, but less impactful to the smaller lots.

3:06:27 And then this is what I don't think I showed you yet. This is taking, if you recall some of the ideas that we analyzed with Mammoth Crossings and with the Clearwater Project were the visual impact of upper stories. At what angle across the street and on the street is important to us from a view perspective. And we studied their documents and we felt that 30 degrees.

3:06:54 Represented an interesting line of sight and pushing the buildings back. So we used that to come up with a mapped upper story step back of about 17 and a half feet. I think we'd round up or down, but the idea is you can start to see the more significant setback between one for one and about 17 feet. And the goal is to move the building height out of more.

3:07:23 Public View Plane. And in this case, you can see that it still has some impact, but nothing compared to the mapped dimensions of the Clearwater application. So with that, I'd like to close and remind of what we're trying to do, what areas have the appropriate standards, which areas should be discussed, and so forth and so on. So the reason I would like you to

3:07:59 Come from the dais. We have all our stuff up here on the wall. And we actually want to talk to you about these dimensions and see where we're running.

3:09:01 Thank you.

3:09:34 Do they turn the heat off at 5? I never know if they can heat off. And I don't know who they are either. They. There is some heating in here. Do you know what the airport heat is? Yeah, it's 6. What I would like to do for the commission is only to help you guys get the closure on this.

3:10:06 There's no new special knowledge to share with you.

3:10:39 I think the projects we're dealing with, this is the issue, and it really is the density. I think people are most concerned about their feeling of changing environment, their limits are too high, or there's a sense of fear of that issue. And there's really a lot more that we can give you.

3:11:07 All of the analyses that you brought to your project, you've studied, perspective views, you've seen a photo of my colleges, and I wanted to ask you first, let's see, should you follow the script, are we right about the areas that we should study, which were, you know, what do you say, the residential zones?

3:11:41 As far as areas that are stable, we agree that they are stable or that we have come to a conclusion that this is what where it's going forward is the right direction for us. Those boxes have been clearly defined.

3:12:15 We do for a choice. Right. I'd have to agree with those that worked on that. You mean this is, that you have to find the areas to focus on. I guess I do have a question on stability study. Why are we moving the forest service line? I guess this is on page one of our agenda.

3:12:53 Of course, we've got shady rest in here. Shady rest shouldn't be good. I couldn't shave that in the other time. And I think specifically on the missile, and what the stable there is, and very fast when it's there. And then that page is in general. All right. So where are we? Do you think what there is? Okay.

3:13:23 So, single family zones, I'm going to call it H6, page 6. It says, what, why, where, state matters, because it's single family zones, multi-parison zones, quasi-parison, and these massive specific values.

3:13:52 So, Snow Creek's done, that's approved. Sierra's done, that's approved. And we don't have that legislative change in France, and we've completed this whole Southwest Explorative effort, and it has census from that, and even though it's a big way it is, North Village is done, although we will come back later on that specific, whether it has the rest of the history-born kind of issues.

3:14:20 There is no support for that. So that home square goes out? Yeah.

3:14:52 And that's going to turn the next page, that's showing up there. So scratch that out? Scratch actually, yes. Can I please a little bit of a little bit of water? Yeah. And that's not necessarily generated to us. And the other reason, we'll look to do self-enforcers, because that's through the process of showing up there.

3:15:28 So for this effort, for example, using that, and then also, I say, take out the stuff that's a piece of secret, but we're not going to use that.

3:15:42 So let's say, we're going to pull out for a service just for this.

3:15:49 You look at, this will take your path.

3:15:55 This will, thank you.

3:15:56 Well, but it's too much to duplicate all the stuff that loves them.

3:16:01 Right. I mean, it's pretty much the same step. And what's the need for you? Okay, so consensus that you're on the right geographic areas. Yeah, can you cross out the same step? Next, I want to ask you about the overall methodology. Do you think that you cut the nature of the same place? That's what you do. Well, my employer, community character in America, design a step.

3:16:48 And that's not, you know, the developer coming in telling me, you know, because he's going to this, it's more expensive marketplace.

3:17:32 Can that be part of maybe the part of looking at the parcel applications? Because, you know, economically, I think that question has to be answered. Blocked application, obviously, is the least expensive for the issue for us, we believe, is the least desirable.

3:18:04 product, but in some applications they've been worked just on, and is the parcel application economic enough to achieve that? And maybe that's how the answer is, yes, you can have a volume of design, but that is still making it affordable, not in the parcel. Yeah. One of the reasons, I believe, we're getting the work block in parcel, one of the issues that I can do is.

3:18:33 Another issue is that through all the projects that we've taken through the process, people are talking about the sense of the law of development. And then there's not just one issue. And so the rehearsal application tends to give you more separation above that certain development. And so it is by default a performance because in these cases in here, we have

3:19:02 So, you have to, if you might scale it to the size of like this block that you're covering, you know, there's only four. And maybe that can be done with the seven. And so I think the results is set up on average.

3:19:28 So that's what we're doing. Okay, any of the big additions just to the methodology? Did they add economic emphasis? I wish you could give more examples of two-foot height ratio. We gave a ratio of the tissue, given some pictures to demonstrate that. And in these specific

3:19:59 Steve, I mean, you referenced it, just, you know, comments to the PowerPoint, where he wants to say, I'm not. So, I think what we, what we intended to do is, for you guys, when you sit down with Kelso, um, really, we need to come up with a recognition. We can't have this conversation with Kelso. Absolutely. We need to be clear, saying, we're going to go over with what you've been doing, I think, through the memories, because otherwise,

3:20:34 It would be a policy model that would struggle with this session, and when you were saying, you may have done, because Jim was coming, and down to the plate, right?

3:20:44 There's nothing else that you need to do, you just have to pay for those.

3:20:47 Okay, what else?

3:20:50 Listen, you said you liked the examples.

3:20:55 Student, student, student, student, student.

3:21:01 It's about a little past the middle. It's 38. I think you do need more pictures of examples and pictures. I am so sorry I am not here that Wednesday. I'm not here either.

3:21:30 Well, I'll be here after the 9th for the duration. May 4th.

3:22:01 Well, and this was the rendering that they did, like this before and after, because, and maybe that's what you need to do. You know, I think why this is so powerful is when this is all you see, it takes, there before, it's very difficult to imagine this for most.

3:22:31 So, what this is, is taking it, or what you have to do is imagine beyond this, and I think this is probably the best example, because you can put yourself, you are this guy, and however you want to do that, or taking some place.

3:22:59 ...especially in a controversial area where we're going to have to say this level of height is okay here, over here it is not, and because you're achieving these things. Now, these are high and you definitely don't have this vista, but we're going to argue that that vista and beyond is you're not hiding anything except in the sky. But that's what people are not seeing.

3:23:25 Where you look at a situation, you have a few pictures in here tell the product, you know, it's flat roof with a little bit of variation, it actually mirrors the landscape, aren't it? It is, it's a box canyon with a very flat, you know, very flat landmass above it, so everything there changes, you know, that's what it's mirroring.

3:23:50 And if you put your pitched roofs in there in a certain setting, it wouldn't have the same dramatic effect. So now we have a very large mountain behind us with a certain level of tree canopy. How do we enhance that?

3:24:17 Um, if you've got, if you've got anything, just, I think it's better. Well, just more examples, you know, public rooms. Okay. That's right. This is, this is comprehensive, what you've done. You really need the executive summary with a lot more pictures. Okay. Um, in terms of format, you know, when you go to the council, where you have a agenda, and you know, this habit that doesn't happen, and everybody has a chance, um, it's really difficult to talk to everyone.

3:24:46 Summary versus what you do in the summary form, the fact that the copy of the presentation can fill in a lot of details, so they can follow along with that quickly.

3:25:17 So page 4 is important. I would say it's an important slide because what this is telling me is not just that all of these things in here will determine what is the appropriate height for

3:25:45 These areas that we have determined that you still have the ability to do something like that. And so this is, that's what's very important about that. And these give you two. And it's important to understand you don't go here and say, you know, so maybe it's in the reverse of this. Yeah. It's over here. Then you get to the building hub there because

3:26:12 What we're trying to do is exactly what you say. We're trying to determine this without determining that. And that will only be one conclusion is it's X number of feet and all where you are. And what your presentation is just showing is that's not exactly true. Is you can achieve much better impact when you study all these things.

3:26:39 So, just reverse it, and then that, you can get to that. And one part of that is, when you have someone that says, I have this fun idea about living, I have to say to them, wait a minute, let's think about what you mean, and convince them that what they have a fun idea about, has to do with a lot of factors, other than just some linear dimension. Because, yeah, that is, that is, this is the old way to thinking this.

3:27:08 What's the number? It's like P-A-O-T. Oh, it's the number? You don't get to the right number if you don't do that. And I think you've got the examples.

3:27:42 And so, although we can look at that map, I think, at least after telling youth, is an old head of growth, it's different than a mainstream. And the discussion of that street match is important. And I think that this is a valid analysis that resulted in three or four hours. And because of the existing zoning.

3:28:12 Right now, unless you go up here. And that's what came to you long and long ago. Right? And that was decided from this different approach. And when you take this square building model and put it over here, and you can't see it. If you can see it, you can see it. That's telling us that, you know, between a minimum of two floors and a maximum of three floors, you have set this part of the world. You have framed this convention.

3:28:43 This is three-fourths, and you can see the trees, and it's starting to feel about that. And if that's got some truth to it, then what we have to decide is, if you don't only use the downside of it, there's some economics in this. Nobody's going to tear down this building because of this building.

3:29:15 And this is the place where one people are very interested, because it's wheat versus water. So what we've done is, because Clearwater started the idea of being 45 degrees, and there was some negative perception to it, we've applied a 30-degree nail, but we don't need to use an according nail, because we're going to have facts and arguments about giving the price of the nail. We only have a nail.

3:29:46 So it's very clear, well, it's 17.5. It's not 17. It's not 18. It's 17.5. So that even, you know, we can keep our clients paying attention. So from community to self, evaluation of all those factors, we felt that this looked about right from what we can have. You could still level 4.5, and you could extend it.

3:30:14 At some point in time, when you map it, you can start to see that this project is not going to build at that high level. That dimension is about 30 feet. So I guess you can maybe have 30 feet above what's going to be 40, I don't know. So you could get a 64-foot piece in here. So you're still getting some

3:30:43 The other side of that code is you from an absent scale perspective, saying should a property that's under 50 by 100 feet, is the appropriate scale really a 50 foot building? Because once you've said that this edge condition is important, you really can't say, well, you're a small watch, so I don't know what you do. You could, but there's a very awkward, and you'll be kneeled.

3:31:16 So we felt this is an appropriate for me to say, you need to think about this one, and then it's a less, like, we're going to let go. And the less, and the more, and you still have to be reasonable. I've never seen the 60-foot understory center. And the reason that worked for the order,

3:31:44 Because they actually built three projects on site. They built residential, they built flats, and then they built hotel. And I think they're not going to talk to us back there. Mark, Paul, I know. Am I broken? Yeah. Paul, I know a lot, sir. For the purposes of objective discussion, this shouldn't even be title building mass. It should be the public room.

3:32:13 And talk about the public room and what makes... No, no, it's not intentional. It's not intentional. Because, well, let me just finish. Because these pictures that we just put right here on whatever page this is, if you have examples of what it takes to make a...

3:32:40 A mixed-use retail commercial area look like something where you want to get out of your car and spend money. And here we've got a boulevard in the media and down the middle of what we're talking about for Man Street. And if you had several examples of that, and then you started talking in your methodology about what, why, and where, in the character design and setting, et cetera, following on that, then that would lead you to, okay, how do you make a public room? And then you talk about...

3:33:08 The height in proportion with the width of the street. You talk about the massing. You lead into that. You start out with what are we trying to accomplish. Do you follow my reasoning? Oh, I don't agree with it. Well, why do you agree with it? Well, they've asked us to talk about height mass. But it will come out of that discussion. You really are so serious. I think it was working.

3:33:39 So, what I just showed you, I think that this is reasonably appropriate, move from one side or another, and move from another place, that seems to make sense. On May Street, I have a different picture. May Street is wider, it's a lot better. And the whole picture that we just saw is about achieving an exception, changing the place,

3:34:10 And whether it's in this configuration or the

3:34:38 And so it's not affecting those issues of viewportals. It's not dramatically affecting all the issues of sun and access. And so the proportion study is telling me there can be support of the environment. And I think that when you try to arbitrarily display it,

3:35:06 These steps are difficult. Every time we change the construction here,

3:35:36 There's going to be a column that's talking about this law. And for us, there's going to be a discussion of the universe, universe core, or some form of capability, et cetera. So for us, on paper, it's just a special appeal. For a builder, that's a different thing. And so this is a discussion here about scale, about color.

3:36:07 And about fighting back a fear-based approach that has been expressed. Oh my God, that's too hard. So this seems to be something for me to chew more at the next beginning. And I think what we'll do with this is start to find out a little bit more. There's a tendency of how it's easy for me to use, which is color. And when we put those in part, this text.

3:36:39 I don't like it. I don't like it. I don't like it. But nevertheless, you know, we want to get to this information. And with all the information we have, everybody knows how it comes up. And so is how it comes up to the rest of their information. I say that we've been presenting this concept of look at other places, see how they're doing it.

3:37:11 for years, so they've seen, and now it's time to say, what works best for us, and what you're talking about, is the distance between there, and it's the proportion that you see, and when you have a narrower street, your setback is going, you're going to have to have that level setback, your first 35 feet, when you have a narrow two-lane street, or maybe a bike path, is all you miss.

3:37:37 You can stand when you have the four or five lanes or six lanes, it's going to be even higher. This is the difference between Fifth Avenue in New York and Michigan Avenue in Chicago. They both have very large buildings, but the setbacks in Chicago don't give you that feeling of the walls closing on. And that's what wherever you are, you don't feel like you're being closed in on. That's the number one thing.

3:38:06 And you wouldn't be able to appreciate what, if something's an improved landscape around there, a building scape, you wouldn't be able to appreciate it. And you can't do that unless you have a certain amount of distance. So, I've got a few comments to add to this. Some more pictures, some more. What do you mean that you're next one? Will you find your recognition? You need to study this more. We're not the only person who thinks a reminder about it.

3:38:37 The reason for a public room in downtown is important. Say yes. Well, that's different than what you said. Well, that's what I meant. You know, starting out, we're talking about the public room and what it is we're trying, what our objective is. A public room is one of the factors that's a manager. It's important to be considered when you decide what's in order. Right. That's part of it. But the end of all isn't dividing the public rooms. It's finding something else.

3:39:06 That isn't the way I see it in my head, but I understand your position, but that isn't how I see it or how I would present it. I'm just one person. I'm getting this feeling of what I would like to see us have to present to them. Number one is a presentation like this summarized, so it's faster. And then from that, so based on, there are the factors.

3:39:38 Here's the process we propose to you that we go through to come up with a recommendation. I think we're already here. We're there. We're there. We're there, but not in the solution. Only the way we can sit down and go through and come up with a conclusion. The reason I brought this to you is for this to action is very key action.

3:40:13 Thank you.

3:40:49 Thank you.

3:41:19 But that's not right. And in the camp, we need some very small portion of that. Now, you can think it never happened, right? You just get to, you end up taking about 10 feet of time to, the cashier. So, you gotta have, you gotta, you gotta step back, a step back, I'm sorry. You, you also probably need to put something in about reform.

3:41:44 Yeah, it's qualified, so you're saying the overall height is 55, and the street is a maximum of 35 because of this within, if you go up there, so that's the recommendation. That's the most important information.

3:42:10 That was right there. That agreed. Because what you wanted to find is I'm not going, we're not going to entertain 55 feet on the street at a box of 55 feet. In that configuration, we're going to wrap, we're going to take this thing, which is this area, and it's 55 too, and then over the meeting is talking about it. Because we're not having the same pressures over here,

3:42:44 I think this one stays at 40 o'clock. So that this, and that we define in greater detail as an entry, a relationship, a commercial relationship to residential. And we can do that as we go. But for you and the council to get to a point where you're talking about that is huge. Because everything in town is a little proportion, no matter where you walk.

3:43:20 Right, and if somebody, let's pick on this one, if somebody has that really significant roof floor, if you would agree that the end result of looking at that really big roof really absolutely still looks big, then I'm going to say, no, sorry, only that little bit can be above 55, that's still only 55 foot up, which is that principle of real mass reduction. We were talking elevator tower.

3:43:56 We were talking, scared about, we were talking, the whole whole roof. Or as we saw in Aspen, where they pushed the building right up to the height limit, and then stick on a couple of them, and just stick them on, and make it look like it's articulated, and it's not, just get the maximum density, and the building makes it is. In fact, one of the buildings is an example of our packet, not even here, is a really bad example, in Lifestaff, which is a monster building, with, um,

3:44:23 What will happen then is if everything is in the right proportion, it's going to look like everything is the same height, but it still won't be boring.

3:44:55 And maybe the thing we have to do, in addition to this, is preface it with each set of proportions, there's going to be a set of qualitative words, as you can say, although others come up with a higher mass that meets the requirements of the proportional for its location, plus ESC to the uniform.

3:45:26 When we did that, we used it. So, we need to close. So, I've got some information. If you had a video session earlier, I would suggest that we do some more video prep, which has synthesized this. The good material for that prep is a lot of time.

3:45:53 I'll have this stuff put in. And I think we need to give some consensus. You're not voting on the right. And again, I don't know. You need to decide.

3:46:23 I can bring your voice to Walter. So, you guys, you know, isn't that the appropriate thing if you have some different people to give up? There's so many people who give us all this and kill us. So that man, he's never going to have a talk. I'm in jail. I'm in jail. I'm in jail. I'm in jail.

3:46:49 Do you want any more reaction to this comprehensive lower place? Not now, but sending emails. That would be very useful. Okay. I'll number the pages. I was concerned about 55 foot limits. If you then have an incentive situation, what? Are you going to get 10 lower feet? Nope. Incentive lifts that was an accident. This is the accident.

3:47:18 So you don't need to worry about these cities. Well, we have them both in, for example, if you look at the roof homes, a simpler roof home is going to put a greater, effectively, a greater mass to go higher up. You're going to be incentivized to use a more interesting roof home. You can, in fact, have more volume in your building when you do that. For example, if you do that.

3:47:44 I forget the name of it, but one of those other rooms she could have a name for that kind of story. Which one? The one that's got a gift wall, is that it? Is that the right term? Heart wall? The knee wall? Knee wall. Knee wall. So if you pick a more interesting roof form that is visually more appealing, and you get more usable space inside your room, that's the kind of incentive you get.

3:48:13 You know, when I go through, after going through all of this stuff, you're still thinking about the set of standards. The set of standards should be really high. Once you figure out what your maps are going to do, you should be prepared with them. And what incentives should be, it's programmed, it's programmed. If you do this, you can do this density. And so I think it's possible. We can still keep the set of standards to your height.

3:48:43 Like, you can't get to 55 unless you do this, this, this, this. It might be, if someone's clear in the end, to say, that's the hype. You know, even if you put it, if you're going to trade off half of the space for your apartment, because of what it was so expensive, you might say, no, that's okay. But the basic idea of it,

3:49:03 And that's something for us to figure out. And then what I think I heard you say is that this presentation is going to be very much thinner. Yeah, yeah. And this is the ability for us to give you this clarification. Excellent. Are we done? No director's report today. I have a comment.

3:49:39 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.