TransparentMammoth

Housing Board (MLH / ESCH) · 2021

Housing Board (MLH / ESCH)

· recording 1 hr 34 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

181 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 Morning of. I don't believe I've been getting that. How do we double check what our email address is? I send it out personally to every one of you from the Clerk account, so you might want to look in your spam and see if it's in there. And again, it's just clerk at townofmammothlakes.ca.gov. Great. Thank you. I'll have a look. And if you're not getting it, maybe we need to check the email address. I think I have two different addresses for you.

0:30 Perfect. Thanks. Yeah, I'll have a look here. Great. So we're all here. Richard is absent this evening. Are we ready to start, Patricia? Oh, yes. Sorry. We're all here. Richard will be absent this evening, so we can start whenever everybody's ready. All right. I'll call to order the regular meeting of the Board of Directors for the Mammoth Lake Housing, Inc.

1:08 Patricia, roll call. I'll go ahead and get that for you. Lindsay Barksdale? Here. Zariah Cruz? Here. Tom Hodges? Here. Jennifer Kreitz? Here. Kirk Stapp? Here. Agnes Vianzen? Here. Richard Playstead is absent. And Tony Perkins? Present. Thank you. We'll move to

1:48 Agenda item number one is, well, agenda item number two is a time for any public comment or anything that is not on the agenda. I have no one in suite Z and I have no hands raised and no public comments have come in via email at this point. And if there are no public comments. Any public comments in advance. If there are no public comments, we'll move to board member reports. Patricia, you want to just.

2:23 Call off each name of our board members to see if they have any comments. We can't hear you. I don't know why. It looks like you're not unmuted, but you did go a little space-agey. Can't hear you now. What about now? Yes. Okay. With just the connection, I guess. So board member reports, Patricia, you want to, or is our, any, I guess it's best just to, you know, I've been writing myself notes. Raise your hand if you have a report.

3:00 Okay, Tom? Or am I supposed to use the hand on the icon? Sorry. Or the icon, either one. Yeah. Real quick, I was just going to report, I didn't attend live, but I listened on the recording, the Planning Commission hearing on the town's ADU zoning code policy.

3:27 I don't know if you guys get a chance, you can always go back and listen to that stuff. It's going to go, it's going to be heard by the town council. I don't know whether it'll be on consent agenda or not. I imagine it might be. Just with respect to, you know, sort of language specifics about the zoning code as it relates to accessory dwelling units, ADUs, or secondary units on a single family lot in particular, but it also includes multifamily.

3:56 Properties in Mammoth. And there really wasn't anything too earth shattering there. They did, the Planning Commission recommended to count, or in their approval recommendation to go to council, that an attached accessory dwelling unit, so that would be like a garage conversion or another unit that's, you know, part of the same building as the primary home.

4:26 That it should not have an interior connection. And their feeling was that that would sort of encourage misuse of the intent of the ADU code that people would just build extra space for an extra bedroom and not really use it as it would be intended for a secondary rental unit.

4:55 So anyway, it just, and there was some cleanup language just to try to update it to pair up with the state's codes and so forth. So, and I was surprised, actually, Nolan reported that there's been, he said almost like a dozen local permits either pulled or, you know, for permitting or discussed, you know, people have been discussing.

5:25 Interested in developing ADUs on their properties, which I thought was encouraging. I was surprised it was even, you know, that many. So anyway, that's, you know, I know we've been dabbling in that a little bit. We have been meeting with Noel in the past and, you know, our focus was going to be a little bit more on how could we advocate for some type of supplemental funding for ADUs or loan program or something like that to encourage homeowners to develop ADUs on their properties.

5:53 You know, with some sort of a financial incentive, although we would certainly tie some, you know, strings attached that would encourage that would be, you know, used for actual housing, rental housing. None of that was discussed. I've just mentioned that it's something that we had sort of tackled or talked about and potentially, you know, applied for some grant funding, as you guys know, in the past that we haven't been successful and so forth. But I think it's good to keep up on it. And, you know, it can be part of, you know.

6:22 Part of the solution, right? Might not, you know, might generate some units over time, which is a good thing. So that's it. Any other? Jennifer. Thank you. Thanks for that information too, Tom. I appreciate that. I think it's one of the more meaningful things the state has done recently since 2017 with their housing package was the ADU work that they did.

6:55 I just want to update the board on a few things that I attended a webinar today on SB 91. That's the state's housing act. I don't know the proper name of it, but it does have to do with the extension of what the state's calling the moratorium, although there was a lot of

7:19 disgruntled people about that expression because it's not technically a moratorium. People can be evicted during this time period for not filing the right paperwork. Mammoth Lakes Housing has that form that you have to file and give to your landlord. And then you also have to pay 25% of your rent. So if you don't do X, Y, or Z, there is no moratorium for you.

7:44 If you do those things, you don't stand to be evicted. If you pay 25% of your rent and you file the form declaring that you have hardship due to COVID, you have until the end of June, I think it is, June 31st, or 30th, excuse me, 2021, to only pay 25% of your rent and not be evicted.

8:11 But also part of that bill, which is exciting, is some rental assistance. And because Mono County is less than 200,000 people in population, it's exciting that we'll get some money for our residents, our tenants, and our landlords. It will be administered by LISC, which is a national corporation, nonprofit corporation. It's a CDFI.

8:39 And the Executive Director was on that webinar today. And they are working on building a portal for people to apply. That application on the portal should be up and running in March. And they're going to reach out to you and we can reach out to them since Mammoth Lakes Housing has been involved in this.

9:05 platform of rental assistance to be a local partner, basically to help get the word out. They have a toolkit, media toolkit, et cetera, in multiple languages to help inform people that this is available. They go to the website, they fill out the application. Again, it's in multiple languages. Landlords and tenants can do that, and that will provide 80% of their rent if the landlord agrees.

9:31 And if the landlord doesn't agree, then it provides the 25% of their rent. A couple other notes from that is that the primary focus is people earning 50% AMI or less, but it will serve up to 80% AMI. They also said on their website, they'll have, it's called housingiskey.com. Actually, this is the state's website, not LISC website, but housingiskey.com.

10:00 is where you can find an AMI calculator, geographic need, and there's also a COVID-19 call center as well for folks to call into, and there's multiple languages. So quite a bit of resources coming out. They're trying to get this going quickly in light of the deadline to spend the money from the feds and also the end of the moratorium on June 30th.

10:30 So I think I know I can get copies of the slides from that webinar. If anybody's interested, I'm happy to share them. Just reach out to me. So that was interesting today. I just wanted to make an announcement that I was, I don't think I'm announced this last time, but I was appointed to CSAC, the California State Association of Counties Housing, Land Use, and Transportation Policy Committee to be their vice chair.

10:59 And that's exciting. As such, I will be speaking along with CSAC staff and some other folks to Senator Scott Wiener on Thursday about housing and budget items and what's going to happen this year and what some of the needs are. I am also working with that group to submit a resolution to the NACO Housing... Oh, actually...

11:29 It's not housing, it is housing, but it's Community Economic Workforce Development Committee, Policy Committee at NACO, that would support reducing the bond cap from 50%, the private activity bond cap from 50% to 25% for 4% low-income housing tax credit developments. As you may know, Aspen Village, the Jefferies,

11:59 Manzanita and the proposed phase one of the parcel all use or will use 4% housing tax credits. And they've become competitive. They used not to be competitive. They'd be over the counter. But because 9% tax credits are so hard to get, 4% have a lot of pressure on them. And it's harder to now get 4%.

12:25 If we reduce the bond cap, we'll basically get double the amount of housing in California and the nation. It's an IRS, Internal Revenue Service tax code that requires this 50% bond cap. So I'm working to try to get NACO to support the reduction of that at the federal level.

12:49 I think it will have a direct impact here in Mono County. So that's exciting to be working there. I also, I don't know, we haven't talked about this, but that HCD has put a pause on their programs. And I think that's something that maybe we should consider writing a letter to HCD and our representatives from Mammoth Lakes Housing.

13:19 Pause there. A lot of their programs, MHP and others, I have a list of them here, because of an audit report that came out this year in November saying that the state was not coordinating and using their funds appropriately. They were wasting money. They have a lot of different agencies. I think there's four or six different agencies at the state level that are responsible for funding affordable housing. That's a lot to sync up.

13:48 As developers, we know and see that it's challenging to get projects done because there's so many different funding sources and revenues that you have to synchronize. And as a result of the audit report, HCD just put everything on pause, a lot of their programs on pause until they can figure out how to sync them up better. But at the CCRH ledge committee call today,

14:17 It was raised that MHP, which is primarily a rental program, rental subsidy for new development, won't have a NOFA until 2022. That's a long time deposit program when we're in a housing crisis as a state and we have the parcel. And I know that they're not looking to use MHP today for that project, but maybe another phase that we'll want to. And anyway, I just think it's a good thing for us to let them know from

14:44 A local, rural community. And, you know, we're trying to get funding for our own developments, that that's an issue. So it's something to think about and we can work, I can work with Patricia. It's the board's pleasure on that. The last thing I would just want to note, and this is just more of a board of supervisors thing, that the board of supervisors at their last meeting did decide that they would like to

15:12 undertake the redistricting process themselves with robust community outreach. So I just encourage everybody to stay tuned. That's due. We have to have our final map by November 15th. We're waiting on census data. That's late. And it's coming in even later. Some of the details about underserved populations won't be ready until July or

15:42 Sometime after then. So, we really have a small time frame, but we're going to do a lot of public outreach, and we want to hear from all people, and I hope that we'll get the input from Mammoth Lakes Housing, and you all, and our residents on that process. So, that's all I have. Thanks. Sounds like you've been busy. Further reports from the board? Just to

16:15 Give everybody a heads up. You know, we are working on the parcel, and it has been, or the shady rest, or whatever you want to call it, the parcel. Anyway, it's working through a process between 400 and 550 units there. Obviously, the issues are parking, snow storage, lot lines.

16:41 So those are all big issues that the Planning Commission and staff are working on. Let's see. That's the only thing I have. And Jennifer's report just triggered all the different things that are happening with the parcel. Any other board member reports? I forgot. I was going to mention one other thing.

17:08 You know, I read in a recent article here since the change in the administration federally, and it sounds like the Biden administration is supporting a tax credit for first-time homebuyers that is supposedly going to be around $15,000. So obviously that's something I'm not sure they're going to have to tack into some legislative package here, but it sounded like it was high on their agenda to support.

17:37 You know, affordable housing across the country, you know, at the federal level. And that was something that they are looking to implement sooner than later as a, you know, something to support affordability. And it sounds like, you know, maybe, who knows, maybe we'll see some other federal programs start to come along over time in the next year or two with the change in leadership at the federal level. Tom?

18:08 You haven't been watching the news lately. The battle going on in the Senate over a budget, $1.8 trillion, and all the things that people are talking about cutting out, so I wouldn't put too much on... Yeah, I saw that. Sounds like this isn't in that COVID package, so it must be something else, but we'll see how things play out. All right. Reports from the board members?

18:39 I'm not seeing anything, so we'll move to agenda item number four, which is approval of the minutes from the January 4, 2021 regular board meeting. Any correction, deletions? If not, can I have a motion? I'll make a motion to adopt the minutes from the regular January 4, 2021 meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Housing Board. I'll second. Lindsay?

19:12 It has been moved and seconded to adopt the January 4 board meeting minutes. All those in favor, if you just put your hand up. I'm going to actually go ahead and do a roll call. You have to read them off. Or Angie, Angela. Yes, please. Lindsay Barksdale? Yes. Zariah Cruz? Yes. Tom Hodges? Yes. Jennifer Kreitz? Yes. Kirk Stapp?

19:43 Yes. Agnes Fionzen. Yes. And Tony Perkins. Yes. Thank you. We'll move to agenda item number five, which is a Mammoth Lakes Housing Program update. Patricia? Thank you, everybody. Here's our monthly update on program activities that staff have been undertaking at Mammoth Lakes Housing.

20:14 I still have here on the first page a list of all of the deed restrictions that we transferred since the holiday season in 2019. And I have some updates on the Meridian Court H-101 unit. I wanted to share some photos from the property. So I went over to the property today and shoveled out the front door.

20:48 And as you can see here in the kitchen, we have new paint. So the whole unit's been painted. Here's the living room and the closet, all new paint here. And then as you go upstairs, we have new paint and all new carpeting throughout the upstairs in the three bedrooms. We had the unit re-keyed so that

21:17 Because one of our contractors lost our key, and so we had it re-keyed, we have new keys, and the carpet and the paint is done, and the repair guy will be over there tomorrow, and then I'm meeting a contractor to repair some of the blinds in a few of the windows on Thursday. So hopefully, I'm hoping this week,

21:45 The majority of those repairs will be well underway and hopefully finished within the next two weeks. And then we can list that property for sale. I worked with Mono County staff to get an extension from the Mono County Board of Supervisors on our loan from their revolving loan fund since we exceeded the 12-month period for a variety of reasons. And so that was an excellent

22:13 process to work through, and I really appreciate everybody's partnership on that. Now that we have that extension, I think it goes through July, but we're already working to try to find qualified homebuyers, which we've been working on the whole time, but we haven't found any yet, so we'll start processing some new applications and seeing if we can get somebody, local households, in an affordable home.

22:42 Certainly well before July. That's my update on the Meridian Court H-101 unit. We also have some information on homebuyers assistance programs. We have funding available in all of our programs. We've had a lot of our homeowners pay off their loans, so there's loans available.

23:11 funding available to make loans to income eligible households in the town. And then the county program, we just got a new representative for the home program at HCD. And so we're working closely with them to get them to approve our setup checklist. So hopefully we'll meet the new rep.

23:39 This week and hopefully they have our file in their hands and we can get that going shortly. On the next page we have some details on the rental assistance program. I was thinking about it today and we have a weekly staff meeting on Mondays and we talked a lot about it at our meeting today as well. This rental assistance program is a service level that

24:12 I don't believe Mammoth Lakes Housing has undertaken previously the amount of clients we have coming into the office that need assistance filling out their applications that maybe can't read or write. You know, the level of assistance that we're providing to the community, I think, is

24:38 something that we probably weren't expecting and is obviously very much needed. So I invited Diane to say a few words about that. I don't know if you have any anecdotes that you wanted to share with the board on the rental assistance program this evening. Sure, I can do that. Like Patricia said, it is a whole new level of

25:10 of assistance required for people that are used to doing online applications, it seems pretty simple, and we're not trying to establish an income baseline, we just have to document their income, so that seems pretty simple to us, but obviously it is not that simple to someone who's not used to doing it, someone who doesn't necessarily have a computer at home, only is trying to work off of their phone,

25:41 Obviously, there's language issues. We have the information in both English and Spanish. But when they come into the office, if I'm the only one there and I'm not a Spanish speaker, it's a difficulty. Although we're getting pretty good on Google Translate. But people bring their, you know, their young children and you're not sure if what you're telling the young child to translate, if that's going, if that's coming across correctly.

26:10 For the most part, we're managing. I think it just takes a lot more time than we've anticipated. Last week, I had more than one person, you know, I was explaining what they needed to put on the self-declaration, for example, and the one gentleman looked at me and finally asked me to write it for him. And obviously, it's his self-declaration and he needs to write it, but I don't think he was comfortable doing that, whether it was a literacy issue or

26:43 Whether it just seemed terrifying, I don't know, but it's a new thing every day. It's really interesting that way. We did count up the number of Spanish speakers based on whether they chose a Spanish application or not, or whether they answered the questions in Spanish, and it looks like the total number we've got so far is 44% of the

27:13 recipients are more comfortable in the Spanish applications. So that's kind of interesting. I think it reflects the community as a whole. I think the actual number is higher because more people may not be as comfortable in English, but they can manage well enough to answer the English questions or get someone to help them. I think that's about all I have.

27:45 If anyone has any questions, though, I'm happy to answer them. Thanks, Anne. I think Judith made a comment also at our staff meeting this morning that I think a lot of the clients are getting frustrated because it's taking us time to process the hundreds of applications that we have. And, you know, our subsidy payments aren't always making it in time for the first of the month.

28:16 I think we just continue to say that we are doing it as fast as we can and we're following the process and we've made some efficiencies where we can and we're just trying to plug along and get through all the applications. It does raise some concerns for me around the state-operated LISP program.

28:43 How much support clients might need in order to access that funding. So that's something I'll have to follow up on. In terms of, well, does anybody have any questions up to this point? Just kind of what you said there about when rents or when is, at what point are you in contact with the landlords? Because I know the checks go directly to landlords. And are we, I suppose if you haven't even read applications yet, then.

29:14 You're not really in contact, but what are applicants able to say? Are they just telling landlords, I've applied, I'm waiting? Yeah, so I always remind everybody to be in close communication with their landlord, because if you don't communicate with your landlord, then it's just going to become a snowball of a problem.

29:39 And so to let your landlord know that you've applied for this program. And then part of our process is that we actually have to call for every application, we have to call the tenant and we have to call the landlord. So once we open an application to start a new application, we have to make those phone calls. And so at that point, the landlord also knows, okay, this application.

29:59 Been in, is in process now. And then usually we can give them an update like, okay, well, I'm processing the application now. I'll put it in queue for a check. And then I know Diane's going to write the checks on Friday. So it'll go into the mail on Friday and you'll get it at some point after that. But you're right. If we haven't processed the application yet, then the landlord's out there paying. We.

30:26 We tell the applicants if they're checking on it, you know, feel free to have the landlord call us if you want to have them confirm that you have an application in. That isn't always as smooth as you would think, but at least we make that offer. And then we spend a lot of time answering the phone.

30:50 People wondering where they are on the list and when their application is going, when we're going to get to their application. So instead of processing applications, we're answering people and telling them where their application is in process and that takes time. So I have a question. And do you have Jake supporting you in the office right now or is it just you and Diane and Judith?

31:19 Yeah, so we did, I did reach out to Jake after Eduardo left the internship program and Jake's been supporting us on a really limited basis. He took the lead on the town's CDBG CARES Act program since that rental assistance program had a lot more requirements and specific forms and paperwork that needed to be completed and so it was great having him kind of take.

31:47 Take the lead on that. So he has all of his files really organized. That process has come to a pause as we wait for some more funding for that program. But he is still available for us on a limited basis since he's still attending college. Okay. Now for the large amount of work that you're having supporting the people in the Spanish speaking,

32:17 Do you think it's helpful if I volunteer my time Saturdays and support you guys processing some of the applications or maybe taking phone calls? That could be really helpful. Zoraia, I appreciate your offer to help do that. Maybe we could have a call and think about some ways that you could help support us. Okay. Thank you. Thanks.

32:52 I'm going to move into the fundraising component. So I wanted to point out a few new sources for this program. First Five allocated an additional $10,000 for this fiscal year, so their total contribution comes to $20,000. Those funds have to be utilized to assist households in Mono County with children under six years old. Yeah.

33:27 And then for private donations, we received $2,500 from Oak Valley Community Bank, and then some more private donations, adding up to almost $4,000 since the last time we spoke. We've spent almost $560,000 assisting 437 households with more than 1,000 partial rent payments. We did receive some contributions from some local

34:04 Organizations, including Format, Mammoth Mountain, Oak Valley Community Bank, like I said, and the Vons Foundation. I'm waiting to hear back from Union Bank. They seemed excited about it three or four months ago, but keep following up and haven't heard anything, so we'll see what they say. Under grants, we have our home application is in at HCD. We submitted that, I believe.

34:38 in about February of last year, and I just had some communication with our contact at HCD that said they intend to submit our application to the Loan Review Committee in February, but they've been having a lot of construction closings, so hopefully that's still the timeline.

35:04 They said they are still interested in setting a follow-up call. I answered all their questions in an email, but they still want to chat, and so I'm hoping that all of that is very good news. For CDBG application, we submitted in September, and I'm expecting to hear back at the earliest in September, perhaps later. And so I'm working to list some of our vacant commercial space for rent under a short-term lease.

35:35 So that we can get some revenue on that property and pay for some of the ongoing operating expenses there. And then we spoke about CalHOME at the last meeting. Awards have not been made on the CalHOME applications we submitted, but our applications did not score very well, so I'm not expecting anything there. Let's see. I did want to let the board know that I heard from...

36:11 The California Coalition for Rural Housing that our application to host an intern was awarded again for the next year. So we'll be beginning recruitment probably soon, probably March to try to get a head start on recruiting a new intern for the next year, which hopefully will be really exciting for them because we'll be working on 238. So congratulations to everybody on that.

36:44 And then I did want to announce that the state's eviction protections had been extended through the end of June. So thank you, Jennifer, for that really great update. We'll be continuing to communicate with the community on where they can get resources. We have the blank affidavits that they need to give to their landlords explaining their financial hardship.

37:10 We have those here in the office and in the lobby. So if we're not here, you can always pick up a blank form in the lobby. And so we'll just try to continue to get the word out on that because that's really important. I think those are the highlights for me this evening. I'm happy to answer any other questions you may have. Questions from the board? I just have a couple of questions. First would be the Union Bank.

37:50 Are you working with somebody outside of the area? Are you working with the local branch? Could we possibly help advocate? I'm just curious. So I had originally went through the local bank, but the local bank said that they were not able to contribute at this time. So I went directly to the corporate foundation website where they have an application and submitted a formal application to the corporate office.

38:21 I believe that application got funneled down to the local branch, and then that's when I received a response from the local branch saying, oh, we're trying to get this through, yeah, we're working on this, and then that's kind of where it stalled at this point. Okay, well, I banked there, so I'm happy to stop in and talk with Angela Teller about it. Just encourage her to do what she could to support the local organization. I know that Mammoth Lakes Housing has banked there for years.

38:51 And then would it be possible to list the H-101 unit now and just put in the listing that repairs are being made? Yes. Or is that too much pressure on Mammoth Lakes Housing staff to process more applications? I know you're really busy with rental applications and there's not that many of you. I was thinking a lot about it today. I mean, I want the unit to look in the best condition possible, but

39:19 I mean, it looks pretty good from the pictures. The repairs are pretty minor. We have the contractors lined up. We could certainly list it. Yeah, it might be good. And then, yeah. Anyway, let's talk if you'd like to list it. And then I just want to say thank you to those that have donated to the program.

39:50 The people you highlighted tonight, MMSA, which we have somebody on our board from there. So if Tommy could extend our gratitude, my gratitude to Mark and whoever else at Mammoth Mountain who made that contribution and also thank you so much to the staff and Zariah for helping out or volunteering to help out. Appreciate it. You guys are doing a Herculean task here and you're right, I don't think anybody understands.

40:16 the amount of handholding that's necessary. And so thanks for being there for our community. Thank you. Are you finished, Patricia? All right, we'll move to the parcel update. Patricia, do you have anything to add to the parcel update? Yeah, so I provided this item on the agenda this evening.

40:57 to give the board an update on where the parcel project is today. A lot happened in the last couple of months. I know it was the holidays. I know it was COVID and everyone's stressed out. And so I just wanted to kind of recap where we're at with the parcel. So in December, the planning commission recommended to the town council to approve the master plan.

41:26 And then at the end of December, the Town Council and the Planning Commission met to discuss the Surplus Land Act. And this meeting was the result of some discussions on whether or not the town had been compliant with the state's law regarding surplus land.

41:59 It was to inform the Planning Commission and the Council and the public that despite the RFP process that the town had undergone, requesting proposals from developers, that Mammoth Lakes Housing participated on the Meta Housing team and Pacific companies applied, and ultimately the town chose to work with Pacific companies. Despite that process,

42:28 The town had to release the parcel publicly for a bid publicly because this is surplus land and it needs to be available for affordable housing developers in the state. And so they went through that process and then received bids I think for 30 days and

42:56 received their bids and they're going to review or accept the highest bid on Wednesday. So I wanted the board to be aware of that. There were two bids, the Pacific Companies and Chelsea Investment. And so the town council will approve the highest bid on Wednesday. And then on January 6th, the town council approved the master plan, which allows up to 580.

43:26 units and replaces the affordable housing overlay for the site as the new planning and zoning standards for that area of our community. As a further update, I know that the board had instructed staff to send a letter requesting a meeting with town staff to

43:55 discuss the benefits of having Mammoth Lakes Housing involved in the ongoing stewardship of this really important community asset. And that letter was sent to the town at the end of November. And then there were some volunteers from the board who met to discuss the benefits of having a local entity involved in

44:23 The ongoing stewardship and also the community relations, you know, helping folks fill out their applications and providing language access. And so that group met and continued to underscore the importance of that role and how it's different from property management and why it's important.

44:50 And instructed staff to continue to schedule the meeting with the town and participate in that meeting. That meeting is scheduled for February 11th. And it seems like there'll be two members of town staff, two representatives from Pacific Company, myself, and asked Tom Hodges to join in on the meeting with me.

45:20 So that I'm not the only Mammoth Lakes Housing Representative. That meeting will be on the 11th and we'll discuss the importance of the ongoing stewardship and having a local partner involved and see what the group would like to, how the group would like to move forward. Do you have a question? Yes. No. No, I have a comment. But I'll wait. Are you still have more?

45:51 I think that's it for my update. We have this meeting on the 11th. We'll be represented. And we all know the importance. I think we've talked about it quite a bit. And so I think we're prepared to relay that to the rest of the team. So I just have a few comments. I think that it's really important that the development have a local partner. I think it's

46:22 It's actually critically important. I mean, typically, and I think you pointed this out at our last meeting, typically, there would be a local nonprofit in a lot of developments. Now, I know Pacific Companies always worked with a Central Valley Coalition. That's their go-to nonprofit partner in all their developments, unless probably a community pushes hard to have a local representative, which we did back in

46:51 The first developments with Pacific Companies at the Aspen Village and at Manzanita and Jefferies, which is just a scattered site. But anyway, regardless of the details of those developments, Central Valley was the nonprofit partner, but there was a local partner in those, and that was Mammoth Lakes Housing. And it's always a good idea to have a local partner because the local partner is on the ground. They can

47:19 Do input on design. They can asset management from a local level with oversight on the physical property, which Central Valley is not going to see, especially about nine months out of the year. And it should be paid for from the development and the operation sources and not by the town.

47:44 I strongly encourage Mammoth Lakes Housing, Pacific Companies, and the town of Mammoth Lakes, which I see they're here. We have one council member on the call tonight, but she can't participate, but I see we have staff here from the town. Strongly encourage. I said this before, I don't think it can be said lightly enough.

48:07 Or strongly, excuse me, I think it could be overlooked too easily how important it is to have a local partner for those reasons. And there's probably more, but those are the ones, the high level that come to mind. I think I've talked with developers in affordable housing from other regions and rural regions in California, and they advised me that this would be very beneficial to the community and the property and the residents.

48:37 The last thing I want to say is that tomorrow at the Board of Supervisors meeting, we will be considering an MOU, Memorandum of Understanding, a contract with Pacific companies for $1.8 million and no place like home funding to secure eight assisted living units and five floating units and an ongoing subsidy with wraparound services on site, all kinds of services.

49:07 Mental health services, job services, just a slew of different options available right there on site, ongoing for 20 years. So we'll be taking that up tomorrow. So that's exciting. I think that there's enough community support. This isn't just the Pacific West coming in and state subsidy that, you know, there's

49:35 There's local subsidy. The town used taxpayer funding, $6.5 million to buy this property. We've got Mono County coming in to help. We've done a lot of community outreach. Let's not drop the ball now and leave the community, nonprofit, community eye off this once it gets built. I think that would be a real disservice. So that's my two cents. And thank you for working on this, Patricia and Tom. Thank you.

50:04 I guess to sum up my comment or to elaborate a little bit more, I did a little bit of research on how much time staff spends providing stewardship for these units, which are currently paid for under the town contract, and it's about 2.5 hours per unit annually. So it's not a small amount of resources, and it doesn't make sense to me why

50:34 The town would continue to further discount the land, essentially, by investing into a project annually, you know, to have local eyes and ears on the ground, or why the community should have to continue to pay for that when the development will generate revenue. And it's the responsibility of the development to provide those services to the community as a community benefit.

51:05 So, we'll be prepared for that meeting, and I think we'll see what happens, and we'll keep the board updated. Discussion? Patricia, are you finished? Yes, thank you. I was just going to mention in the staff report there, it had February 5th. It's actually council meetings on Wednesday, February 3rd, starting at 4 p.m. It's after a consent agenda, so it'll be an hour or so when it'll be.

51:43 Thanks, Tom. This housekeeping. Someone's got to do it. Patricia, do we finish with the parcel update or any questions from the board? I do have a couple of comments to make about it. I do worry about parking 1.3 per unit spaces and snow stories and I brought these to the council and to town staff. So it is going to be in four phases.

52:25 And so, you know, we can, the first phase is going to be, you know, under the, under what has been adopted, but we will be able to evaluate that after it's, you know, occupied. And so, I think it will have impacts on the further phases. Just to comment, I'm doing, because of Aspen Village and some of our, Manzanita and some of our other projects,

52:55 These are concerns that have been raised. You know, is there going to be snow storage? And, you know, how close are they going to build to the lot lines? All of these issues will be discussed by the Planning Commission and town staff. So it's a process. And the product hopefully will come out that addresses these issues. Any further discussion on the parcel update?

53:26 I'm not seeing any hands raised, Tom. Remind me, Kirk, I mean, you know, one of the comments that I had made, I think in one of the workshops prior to the formalization of the adoption with town council was just, you know, integrating with the downtown plan and I know there's still some stuff up in the air with respect to public parking or, you know, the mobility initiative with town.

53:56 And I think it's, similarly, it's getting punted or kicked down the can down the road a little bit as much as, I mean, it was mentioned during deliberations with council that, oh, we'll make sure we look at that on the next phase. I think Linda said that, and maybe John, but, you know, it's, I think it is really important that ultimately the development does integrate with downtown. I think it's a great opportunity, particularly along the Center Street.

54:26 Is that Laurel Mountain side of the property where it could create better connectivity than just having the back of the development back up to the back of the lots? I think that would be kind of a bit of a loss, you know, given the fact that we're all at the plate here trying to make the best of this thing. So I'm going to be watching that closely as we get into subsequent phases to have that discussion about let's try to make this.

54:54 integrate better with the downtown. Hopefully by now we'll have a better idea where these potential mobility hubs might be located. And, you know, I really think, I mean, obviously you're building a development that's going to house well over a thousand local residents right there. And, you know, that's definitely going to create critical mass that can help to start other follow along redevelopment in the downtown, which.

55:22 You know, we really need as a community ultimately that our downtown areas are so underdeveloped in terms of their potential and what they can be in both, you know, improving local economic activity as well as having opportunities for other housing. Something else I've always been on the soapbox about, you know, opportunities to try to develop some of the commercial properties is mixed use development with.

55:49 You know, live work units above or other housing above redeveloped commercial areas because there's so much flora ratio available in those areas. So, in any event, I just don't want us as an advocating housing more to lose sight of some of these other opportunities that really are synergistic with the development of the parcel. So, that's it. I agree, Tom. It would be really good for some of the businesses along Main Street.

56:19 Thank you, Tom, for bringing that up. I think that we have to think about it in a holistic manner and I think it's easy to get focused on segments and not the whole pie, if you will, the community and how to capitalize on this investment in our community that it's more than just housing, really. I mean, like you said, it has the opportunity to put a lot of

56:50 People in our downtown and activate that like it's never been activated before. And I think that we need to keep in mind commercial real estate and where it's headed. You know, there's a mall that just sold in Las Vegas that was appraised at $28 million and it just sold for like $1.5 or something.

57:14 Or billion maybe, but I mean, you can see it was like 28 versus one because commercial real estate is just plummeting. Now we're different, right? This isn't a big mall, but I think it can be felt here. We need to keep an eye on that too. And maybe there's a need for more opportunities for housing in our commercial zone, not less. And how do we expand that opportunity?

57:40 Maybe we need to look at eliminating the requirement for commercial on our commercial zones and some of it, some ratio to encourage more housing because there's such a demand for housing. So, especially now that people are working from home. So, thanks. Further discussion? If not, we'll move from that parcel update to discuss strategic planning priorities and work program overview.

58:12 The 2021 Strategic Plan and Priorities. Patricia? Thanks. I'm bringing this item back to the board this evening after we discussed strategic plan priorities at our January board meeting. I would share my screen here for a second. These are the top 16 priorities that were identified by the board members who

58:50 Responded in advance of the January 4th meeting. At our January meeting, the board asked me to consolidate these 16 items into groups and like tasks so that it was a little more compartmentalized. In this view, you'll see the weighted votes for each item. So the top items had four votes. The middle items had three votes.

59:20 And the bottom yellow items had two votes each. In the image that I prepared for this evening, I didn't include the weighted votes. I included them all as the same priority level or importance. I just combined them into groups. So we have enhanced communications and diversify funding, build and facilitate housing.

59:51 And grow housing programs, organizational capacity, and foster collaboration. And that represents all six of our focus areas from our strategic plan. And the white items are new or additive to the work program, whereas the black items are ongoing. And so this visual was included in your packet.

1:00:26 If it meets the needs of the board and the organization, the board can approve this as the priorities for 2021. And then we would work on different priorities as capacity or funding allowed for each priority. Patricia, are you asking us to adopt this? Well, I guess... Or just to provide feedback?

1:01:09 At this point, I guess I'll take any questions or any feedback, and then we can amend this, or if the board is happy with it, we can adopt it as the priorities for this year, and then we can briefly take a look at the work program. Questions from the board? I'm not seeing any. If there are no questions from the board, again, I'm not seeing any.

1:01:50 So do we have a direction or do you want a motion? I think that last year we adopted the priorities. They looked at this and I'll make a motion to adopt the board, November 2019, the board prioritized 26 items in 12 months and so I'll make a motion to adopt the

1:02:27 The, let's see, the current prioritization. Do I hear a second? I'll second. It's been moved and seconded. Further discussion from the board? Just real quick, just trying to reconcile where assisting with the ongoing development of the parcel. Does that fold into one of these? Oh, am I on mute? Oh, no. I am looking. Sorry.

1:03:04 I guess I had, well, I guess if you look at the work program, I believe that it falls under the town contract at this point. You know, when we were doing a lot of the public outreach for the parcel, all of that was wrapped up under the town contract, which is an ongoing work program item, maybe not a strategic plan priority, but could be wrapped into the

1:03:37 Build a list of developers interested in community housing. I don't think we had a task or a priority in the strategic plan specifically about working on the parcel. That's more so located, I think, in our contract with the town at this point. It's an ongoing work program item because it's our contract with the town. Okay.

1:04:12 Community Stewardship and Community Relations, I suppose it falls in that slot. So, okay. Tom, just to clarify a little bit, the town staff, Brie and Sandra are pretty much taking the lead on this. Yeah, I know that. I understand. Yeah, I just wanted to recognize it. Our prior discussion about us trying to also be involved.

1:04:43 Yeah, and I did have that in my notes, and you're absolutely right. We did talk about that at the last meeting. I guess for me, that's more of an ongoing work program item, like how we worked with meta housing on the RFP, and I've been in discussions with other nonprofit developers regarding LLC structures.

1:05:16 To learn more about what's the best way for Mammoth Lakes Housing to be involved in the parcel. And so I guess because it, I guess for me, because it's not a specific task called out in the strategic plan, it didn't materialize in the strategic plan priorities. Okay. Yeah, I just, that's fine. I guess, you know, there's definitely ways you can say it's part of the work program.

1:05:51 We don't really have, I guess it actually have their grants and loans ongoing support and parcel. I'm looking at the actual work program now. So, okay, I'm good. Any other board members have any comments? If not, So, if we're going to vote on this for being the priorities, was there,

1:06:23 It's this document that she showed? Did we have that document already? Or is it just the work program that you sent? I think it's in the agenda packet. Yeah, this document here is the synthesis of the 16 tasks that were prioritized from the last meeting. And this is in the board packet.

1:06:58 That was attached to the email that I sent out last week. And if you don't, you can send it to you now. Further questions or discussion? Is somebody trying to get in? Further discussion? Raise your hand if you have any comments or questions. I'm not seeing any hands. Patricia, do we need to, on this, it's just simply your work program.

1:08:05 Do we need to adopt the work program? Well, no. I'm happy to go through the work program now if that makes it more clear for everybody. I also have an additional item that I forgot to include in the work program that I'd like to point out. Go ahead. I think I will share my screen again if that's okay. It's just a little awkward. So this is the Envoy Work Program from Amplix Housing.

1:08:47 Under the first box here is the Town of Mammoth Lakes contract. It's our largest contract for services. We have some items here under the foundational structure of the housing action plan, which include expand staff capacity and renew the town contract. We'll be recruiting for the CCRH intern again this year, and then we will also be renewing our town contract.

1:09:14 Which is up, I believe, in June of this year as well. Right now, we are operating an emergency rental assistance program, which is a new item here. Here are some other community housing action plan items. Partner with the chamber on their program, work on this home buyer assistance program, and support for the parcel development. We have some reporting that we assist the town with.

1:09:50 Grants and things that we have to submit reports to the state. We have lots of outreach and marketing that we do. This includes homebuyer education and tenants' rights education that we've been doing, being available in the office, etc. Providing fair housing information, deed restriction stewardship, which has been a huge item over the last 12 months. Hopefully those units don't turn over again for a long time.

1:10:26 Stewardship of the Revolving Loan Fund, making sure that we are compliant, utilizing those funds for the buyback of deed restricted housing. Here, grants and loans, programs, real estate services, annual monitoring of 68 homeowners, their first-time homebuyer loans, and their deed restricted homes.

1:11:05 Here we have an item which we haven't been able to work on yet, which is the transfer of the town's deed restrictions into our monitoring program, which will be great when it's complete, but obviously it hasn't been done yet. Here's where we provide community stewardship and relations for the existing LIHTC properties that we are a partner of, which, as I said, is about 2.5 hours per unit.

1:11:41 Annually. And then some miscellaneous items we provide for the town, including apartment vacancy, complying with the Brown Act, and some reporting and things that the town asks us to do. We also hold our meetings on Granicus as requested by the town and have an audit annually. Here are the two grants that we currently have.

1:12:19 with the Town of Mammoth Lakes for homebuyer assistance. Those have funding available, but will be closing out this, is it 2022? This summer, actually. Then we have some contracts with Mono County. Here's their homebuyer, their grant for homebuyer's assistance that we're working with HCD on. And then we are operating the Latino Housing Coalition.

1:12:54 We're also doing rental assistance for the county, utilizing two separate pots of money. And then we also have that master services agreement for monitoring of Birch Peak Condo and Davidson Road Project. So that's a new contract that we entered into this past year. We also provide services to the city of Bishop, including some reporting for some grants they've received in the past.

1:13:28 Monitoring of some of their loan portfolio. Oh, and the annual monitoring of their LIHTC project at Willow Plaza. So here is where I would add a new box for Inyo County because we did enter into a contract with Inyo County to develop a rehabilitation program. And so that is missing from the document that you received from me. Despite working on this

1:14:03 With a fine tooth comb, slipped my mind, but I am working on it and it should be on here. And then we have some Mammoth Lakes Housing admin that we do, personnel management, staff evaluations, trainings, making sure we stay up to date with the work program. We do property management for the properties that we own. Here we have 238 Project, obviously I'm working on that.

1:14:38 We have a Calum grant that we received in 2014 that we can reuse the loan payoffs to help folks buy main fraction housing. So we have to monitor that and prepare reports for that. And then here's where I added some of our strategic plan priorities that we wanted to add. We have governance trainings, which is really an ongoing item.

1:15:08 Pursue development opportunities, engage the developer community, expand collaboration in the region. Here's the annual fund development plan, so fundraising, diversify income, and bolster internal systems. So then, if the board would like to approve the strategic priorities for 2021, I'll probably update this section to better reflect, to make sure that all those

1:15:41 Those 16 priorities are in this section here. I think they all are, but I guess I would just want to make sure. That's the work program in a nutshell. I'm happy to answer any questions. Question from the board? Jennifer, or Patricia, you're just looking for the board to approve the strategic plan and priorities? Yes, just to approve the 2021 strategic priorities.

1:16:26 You think you had a motion and a second on, so it's, I think we're ready to go. Patricia, you want to do a roll call so that we, on approving? I'll go ahead and get that. And Kirk, your motion earlier was to approve the 2021 strategic plan and priorities as presented. Is that correct? Correct. And that was second by Jennifer Gratz.

1:17:04 I'm sorry. Did I second it? I think, I thought Tom did it, but maybe. I think you did. I did? Okay. It's been a while. Okay. Just want to make sure we have it right here. Okay. And we'll do a roll call. Lindsay Barksdale? Yes. Zariah Cruz? Yes. Tom Hodges? Yes. Jennifer Kreitz? Yes. Kirk Stapp? Yes. Agnes Viansen? Yes.

1:17:35 And Tony Perkins. Yes. Thank you. We can now move to, let's see, where are we? The Marketing Committee date on marketing and rebranding strategy, priorities, progress, and discussion. Great. Thank you. So this item is a result of the priorities identified in 2020.

1:18:11 In the previous prioritization that we did, marketing and outreach really was one of the bigger priorities. And so as a result of that, I did some research to try to get some quotes and get a sense of what marketing professionals offered in terms of services for this type of scope of work. And so I received three quotes.

1:18:41 And I reached out after we reorganized the committees, I reached out to the new marketing committee members and asked them to meet with me to identify goals of that committee and to do an overview of the proposals that I have received. Those proposals ranged from the bare minimum of just

1:19:12 A new name and a new logo and some help with the website for $3,000 all the way to an extensive iterative process with multiple phases for between $50,000 and $80,000. After reviewing those proposals, the committee felt like

1:19:36 We needed to sit down and hone in on the deliverables that really would meet the needs of Mammoth Lakes Housing. And so the marketing committee met twice in the beginning of January and decided that we needed, at a minimum, a rebranding strategy with a new name and a logo.

1:20:04 Some messaging strategies, specifically to help with fundraising, a marketing plan, which is specifically identified in the strategic plan as a priority, as a task, some website upgrades to include ongoing support as needed, and then meetings with the committee to help refine that process, and then some public meetings with the full board.

1:20:34 To make sure that the process is public and transparent. The committee, and I'll let some of the members of the committee speak as well, but really, I think, believes that the importance of this marketing plan and this rebranding strategy comes at a really important time for Mammoth Lakes Housing. In this

1:21:06 in that, you know, we really want to diversify our funding, we really want to collaborate with our regional partners more, and we're coming up on our 20th anniversary, and so it seems like the time is ripe for a really robust marketing plan with a new and exciting personality for Mammoth Lakes Housing to participate in

1:21:39 Workforce and affordable housing creation in the region. And so as the committee was going through the deliverables, the committee felt it was really important to bring this concept to the full board to ensure that there was buy-in and that the board identified this as a priority before we move forward with additional staff work releasing.

1:22:08 A request for proposals with the refined scope of work before we ask consultants to put time into responding to an RFP if the board isn't really committed to moving in this direction. So I just provided a brief snapshot of some financial resources that could be available to support a project.

1:22:42 Like this, including some excess revenue from our last fiscal year. That's a conservative estimate. I think at our next meeting we'll have our second quarter financials and we'll have a little bit better sense of where we're at this year. In the current budget, the board allocated $12,000 for consulting. Last year we didn't spend much in this line item so I don't foresee

1:23:13 Meeting to dip into that pot for anything else. So that's potentially available. And then annually we do allocate some funding for marketing specifically. We usually spend what we allocate in the marketing line item. It's usually used for print advertising for board vacancies or staff positions, some Facebook advertising that we do, maybe some print color.

1:23:43 Flyers, sometimes we print, but we usually spend around $3,000 on that line item. I guess that's my overview of this item. I think that the committee is just looking for direction, and I'll turn it over to the committee to add anything that I may have missed. And our committee members are Lindsey, Agnes, and Tony. I just wanted to

1:24:22 Bring it to the board before we move forward with it because it's going to be a big financial commitment. Really, we're probably looking at all of our marketing funds and all of our consulting funds and so it's going to be a big deal and the proposal, the request for proposals we're going through is I think we got it fairly well refined that we're looking for something real specific and

1:24:52 Maybe bid alternates that we can kind of take out line items or phase it along the way, but I just wanted to make sure everyone's on the same page and if everybody's content with that, then we can move forward and see more specifically what it's going to cost and outline a good approach to move forward with it. Questions from the board? I'll jump in as well, Kirk.

1:25:26 I think as well, the feeling was in the new priorities that we just voted on. Well, I guess that there's definitely in there the create marketing plan, identify our message, you know, refine our audience or define our audience. There's also fundraising and creating a fundraising development plan. So we think that maybe with some of this,

1:25:56 Marketing, rebranding could also lead us down the road to streamlining what we want to do for fundraising and getting some new donors and a new process. So I think that is part of this RFP plan. I'm just looking at the strategy to see if I missed any of the other bits on there.

1:26:25 And I think, you know, we've been talking about it for a long time since the 2019 strategic planning process that is our name too restrictive being Mammoth Lakes Housing. We, you know, we really do service three different counties. How do we make sure people know that? So this, like Patricia said, this is really a great time to do a whole bunch of things at once, potentially, if we can find the right, the right people to help us. So, and I think,

1:26:55 Some of it is specific that we're probably not, we don't have it enough in-house within staff to do the design work for rebranding, to maybe have the expertise on ways for us to market in the way that will work for us. And then also whether we can figure out some kind of fundraising strategy in there as part of the marketing strategy. So I think these do probably take

1:27:24 Services or expertise that we don't have within staff. We did talk about that in our meetings of what can we do in-house and what do we need to bring other people in. And as we all know, we're tapped pretty thin right now with staff capacity. So I think that's everything from what I've been feeling about this right now. The discussion? I was just going to mention, Tony hit the nail on the head, that definitely

1:27:57 Try to have as many, whether it's alternatives or just a breakdown of the bid, the bid schedule so that you have the ability to either, you know, prioritize those areas that we need most and if we have to phase it in over a year or two, a couple years, we have that ability. We're just making clear in the RFP, you know, that it's just have a breakdown of bid schedule, if you will, and it's, and we reserve the right to, you know,

1:28:29 award individual bid items, not necessarily all of it at once. Anything further time? That was all. Any other comments from the board? Patricia, do you have a direction? You're muted. I'm not sure I heard from everybody. You want to hear each board member make some comments? Well, I just want to make sure there's consensus so that we get good direction on moving.

1:29:18 forward with this process or not? My comments, Patricia, are that Mammoth Lake Housing has evolved and there's new relationships with, you know, the town and the contract and everything else. So when we look at marketing and I think it all comes from some of the changes that have taken place. I mean, Mammoth Lake Housing at one time was a developer.

1:29:49 The town has accepted that. So I think rebranding based on our contract is an important item. Questions from the board? Comments from the board? Jennifer? I don't think I have any questions. I guess what comes to mind to me is just being careful about the money we spend, but obviously you're going out.

1:30:29 And we don't know what that's going to look like. And yeah, and you've identified a few funding sources, which Patricia and I talked about today. And that's just an idea of places to consider. But I'm always thinking about how we could spend the money to have the most useful impact. You know, I think about the name.

1:30:53 Okay, I can see where the name's kind of limiting. Since we're working in so many different areas, it doesn't really describe the breadth of the work that MLH does. But is an acronym sufficient? I don't know. You know, these are the things, but I know we'll get into it. And how do we spend our money to get the most bang for our buck that actually allows us to reach more people?

1:31:20 And just have a greater impact, positive impact on the communities we serve. And so what that brings me back to is really the second bullet, messaging strategies, especially in relationship to fundraising. And how to, you know, that's where I would be most interested in expanding so that we can have a greater impact.

1:31:49 You know, other upgrades to the website are always good. I know we've only done two upgrades to our website in almost, you know, 20 years, as you pointed out. So I think that's always necessary. Technology changed so quickly. And then, so those are just some of the things that pop out to me as some specific scope of work at minimum to include a marketing plan.

1:32:19 I mean, I think that's something that's in the strategic plan. So obviously that was important and I don't know what all that's going to include, but I look forward to seeing what that proposes. So those are just some of my thoughts off the top of my, well, I read the agenda packet, but yeah, thanks. Patricia, are you writing notes? Yeah, I'm taking notes. Some great comments. So I think if the board

1:32:54 is obviously marketing was a priority that we just approved for 2021 and so I think if we're serious about moving forward with that priority I think the committee has a good sense of where we want to go to find out if this is a path we want to take or which components of this path we want to incorporate.

1:33:20 Maybe we don't do all of it. Maybe we just do some of it. And so I think the committee's prepared to dive into that. And so I will meet with them to refine and release an RFP for these services. Thank you. Thank you, Patricia. Thank you, committee. It's pretty awesome that these committees are working. I love this. Yeah, it's great. Thank you. That was agenda item eight. We'll move to

1:33:59 Agenda Item 9, which is adjourned to the regular board meeting scheduled for March 1, 2021. Further discussion before we close the meeting? Any other comments? If not, we are adjourned. Great meeting, everybody. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, everyone. Thank you. Thank you. Have a good night.