Housing Board (MLH / ESCH) · 2021
Housing Board (MLH / ESCH)
· recording 1 hr 33 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
174 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:03 Hi, Patricia. Hi, everybody. So, I do know that Zariah will not be joining us this evening, and Tom is going to be late. Are you going to do the roll call? I can do it if you don't. It's up to you. Actually, it's Patricia. Okay, I think everybody that's going to attend is on Zoom.
1:17 Or in attendance. I'll call to order the Board of Directors for the regular meeting for Mammoth Lake Housing. You want to do roll call? Patricia, you want to do roll call, please? I got it. Or Angie? Lindsay Barksdale? Here. Mariah Cruz is absent. Tom Hodges at this point is absent. Jennifer Kreitz? Here. Kirk Stapp? Here. Agnes Vianzen?
1:50 I'm here. Richard Pleistad. Present. And Tony Perkins. Present. Thank you. Okay. We'll move to agenda item two is public comments. Are there any public comments? I have received no emails. No one in suite Z and there are no hands raised at this point. Thank you. We'll move to agenda item number three, which is board member reports.
2:22 Patricia, are there any board member reports? Would anybody like to make a board report? If there are no board reports, other than all the COVID-19, we'll move to agenda item four, approval of the minutes from the February 1, 2021, regular board meeting. This is an action item.
2:54 If I can have a motion to, unless there's any deletions or corrections, if I can have a motion to approve the minutes from February 1. Sure. Lindsay moves to approve the minutes. Lindsay is, I'll second the motion. It's been moved and seconded. I guess we're still using the hand signal. All those in favor, please indicate by raising your hand and saying, and saying.
3:28 Oh, this is a roll call. A correction. Lindsay Barksdale? Yes. Zariah Cruz is absent. Jennifer Greitz? Yes. Kirk Stapp? Here. Yes. Agnes Johnson? Yes. Richard Plastead? Abstain. Abstain. And Tony Perkins? Yes. Thank you.
3:56 We'll move to agenda item number five, which is review and approve the Mammoth Lake Housing and Sierra Housing Advocacy, LLC, fiscal year 2020, 21, second quarter draft financial statement. This is an action item. Patricia? Thank you. These are quarterly financial statements that we review every quarter. On the first page, you see Mammoth Lake's housing statement of financial position.
4:26 There are a couple things that I wanted to point out. Namely, number one is the line item due from Shaw, which was the loan that Mammoth Lakes Housing made to Sierra Housing Advocates, our sole member LLC, for the purchase of Meridian Court Unit B202. When that unit sold in October, that loan to Mammoth Lakes Housing was paid off. So you'll see in the second to last column,
4:55 That that balance of that loan is now zero. I guess, I feel like the rest of this page is pretty straightforward. I wanted to point out that the HBA Cal Home Loans line item is decreasing over time, and those are loans that we have made to community members to purchase manufactured homes that they've been paying off over time, so that line item decreases each quarter. We'll see our properties that we own, rental property.
5:30 And then you'll see some liabilities in the middle of the page. And our net assets and our reserves are at the bottom of the page. Are there any questions on this page? Question from the board? There are no questions. I will move to the second page, which is the statement of activities and shows our income and expenses for each budgeted line item for each quarter of the fiscal year.
6:05 So in quarter two, I wanted to point out that you'll see a large increase in contributions. Those are donations. I believe the reason why it looks like so much was received in this quarter is because we have our donation link on our website set up through PayPal, and a physical transfer has to be made of those funds into our checking account.
6:34 And so I probably made one or two large transfers during that period. And so it appears as if we received all those funds in that quarter, which is probably not the case. But yet now here they are. And so now we'll use them for rental assistance. I wanted to also point out, because I don't know if we spoke about it previously, but in quarter one under contributions in kind, you'll see $3,600. And that was a donation.
7:04 services for the environmental analysis that we had done on the 238 Sierra Manor Road project in preparation of the CDPG grant. And so the market rate value of those services was double this cost and so we paid a discounted rate for those services and we attributed that donation of services here under in-kind. Who did that?
7:33 Service for Maniflex Housing. Geode environmental services. Let's see, what else? I wanted to note under miscellaneous revenue, there's, this is where we've been allocating our real estate commissions, and so those are two real estate commissions that Maniflex Housing receive for providing those services to our clients. Under expenses,
8:15 I wanted to point out the deed restriction retention line item is substantially more than we had budgeted for at this point. The cost of sales for selling some of these units and then also the repairs that we had made at both Meridian Core units, B202 and H101. I also wanted to point out for the board that our insurance line item is
8:51 is not over budget yet, but it will be, and we have that outlined in the forecast in the next worksheet. Are there any questions on this page? I have one. Okay, great. On the HOA fees, maybe that's on the next page. Oh, sorry. No, that's insurance. I'm sorry, the print is kind of small.
9:25 I think, I was thinking the HOAs were over, but they're not. They seem to be running true to budget. I think I was just maybe looking at that erroneously, so I apologize. I looked at that the other day. Sorry. That's okay. Okay, so then on to the next page. We have some of our other, the properties that we operate.
9:57 And then also the restricted interest that we collect from those Cal loan manufactured home loans. So here under other income, we have the interest accrued on those loans, and then our rental income from our three rental properties. And then under expenses, you'll see each property has expenses associated with it. And I wanted to point out under
10:27 238 Sierra Manor Road expenses. You'll see that number is $17,850. We paid property taxes in this quarter, almost $8,000 in property taxes, and I think we had some snow removal, and then our insurance also went up, so that line item is larger than I would have liked, but certainly was anticipated considering the property taxes were due.
11:01 And then under that you'll see we have a rental unit at Meridian Court or a condo that we have that we rent and we have HOA fees associated with that. And then Star Apartments is the same. There are some expenses associated with that project as well. And then at the bottom you'll see the increased decrease in net assets. I have a question on this page whenever you're ready.
11:52 Okay, sure. I'll take your question. Okay, thanks. I noticed that the rental income on Star Apartments and Sierra Manor Road went down, assuming that's due to vacancies. I was wondering if you think those would be continued into this next quarter, the January to March quarter, quarter three, or do you think that those will stabilize? Thank you for asking that. So all the vacancies have been filled.
12:20 And so we won't have those vacancies in the next quarter. We actually filled all six of the garage units at 238 Sierra Manor Road, so we'll be getting income from those, as well as the old Country Glass office space and the warehouse there, as well as one of the downstairs commercial rental spaces as well. So there's only two vacant commercial spaces there right now, which is pretty incredible.
12:48 And then the Star Apartments unit has been filled. Great, that's what I was hoping. Thanks. Yeah, thank you. So we've been working really hard on getting those filled and it's good they're filled now so we can move on and keep paying for our expenses. That's all I have on this page. Are there any questions? Any further questions from the board? I want to jump to the forecast really quickly. Here you'll see what we're projecting for
13:28 Our income and expenses. Lynn and I spent some time going through this, trying to get an accurate understanding of where the budget was headed this year. I think I've mentioned some of the places where I already suspect the budget will not be in alignment, including deed restriction retention and insurance. But at the end of the year, we're projecting
14:06 revenue of approximately $60,000, and we had budgeted for a deficit of $10,000, so I think with our real estate commissions, some of those additional contracts that we received with Mono County and Inyo County is really keeping us afloat this year, so all those work items are obviously underway and in progress, and we're just keeping
14:38 Keep an eye on the budget for the next quarter. Are there any questions on the forecast? Okay, on the last page of this one, it's just the statement of cash flow and the reviews for financing and things like that. So you'll see depreciation, accounts receivable, rent deposits are on here, and then the loan from Shaw. And then it explains the change in cash from the last quarter and how much cash we have on hand.
15:37 And then the next documents are related to Sierra Housing Advocates, which we use to buy and sell real estate, mostly for our deed restricted properties. And on this one, you'll see there's about $40,000 in this account. We still own the Meridian Court Unit H-101, so that's still on the books here, but the unit B-202 has dropped off.
16:13 After we sold it in October. And then we have a loan with Mono County of $196,000 that will pay off when we sell H-101. Oh no, that one was for B-202. $40,000 for H-101. That under 550 Mono Street H-101. And then we owe the Town of Mammoth Lakes $300,000. And I'll just note that that unit is in escrow and should close before the end of the month.
16:54 So that's good. We can pay off those loans. This account doesn't have a lot of activity. You'll see the statement of activities. There were some expenses associated with selling the B202 unit. And then we pay some fees to do our taxes. And that's about it. I'm happy to answer any questions there might be. Questions from the board? Does that conclude? Patricia, does that conclude your report?
17:40 Thank you. Oh, I guess I'd like for the board to adopt the financial statements if possible. Action item. So I can have a motion. I'll make a motion to approve the Mammoth Lake Housing, Sierra Housing Advocacy, LLC, Fiscal Year 2020-21, Second Quarter Draft Financial Statement. If I can have a second. I can second. And I just want to thank staff for it.
18:12 There are efforts to put this together and go through the forecasting. It takes some brain power to do that. And then I also think that it's worth acknowledging that, you know, investing extra money this year to maintain those deed restricted units and bring them up to saleable conditions.
18:39 Is important. And, you know, next time those transfer now with the new deed restriction, it seems like, Patricia, correct me if I'm wrong, that, you know, there'd be less, if any, funding from MLH or the town to go into those units because it's now built into the new agreement. Is that correct? Yes, that's correct. So the new agreement requires that the owners maintain the home or at least if they have an intent to sell.
19:07 That they would prepare the home in saleable condition and not have any deferred maintenance. Yeah. And so with all the transfers this year, you know, it's just inevitable. It's hard to know when people are going to sell. So I think it's a good use of resources. So thanks for managing that too. Thanks. There's a motion on the floor. We can have a second. I second that, Kirk. It's been moved and seconded.
19:40 Roll call. Lindsay Barksdale? Yes. Jennifer Kreitz? Yes. Yes. Agnes Vianzen? Yes. Richard Playstead? Yes. And Tony Perkins? Yes. Thank you. We'll move to agenda item number six, which is Mammoth Lake Housing Program update information item. Great. Thanks. It's my favorite time.
20:15 So this is our monthly programs update where I get to update the board about all the exciting opportunities and success stories that we've accomplished in the past 30 or so days. Under deed restriction retention, as I mentioned, Rory Court H101 is an escrow with a household earning below 120% of the area median income.
20:43 That's really exciting. They're going to utilize begin down payment assistance, which can loan up to 20% of the purchase price through the town of Mammoth Lakes. And so that'll be great. And then also we're working with some applicants to purchase directly from the owner an Aspen Village unit that had an intent to transfer. And so we're trying to get a client to work with them and buy direct from them.
21:15 Then under Homebuyers Assistance Programs, I just provided some more information in a little table showing what funds we have available, the AMI levels that they assist with, and then the approximate amount of funding available, and then also when they expire, because some will be expiring soon. So we have townhome funds.
21:45 For 80% AMI and below, which expires in September, so we're going to try to get one more home buyer to utilize those funds. And then we have Town CDBG, which is also 80% AMI and below, and that expires at the end of July. In reuse, POT, which helps households earning up to 120% AMI, has quite a bit of money in it. We had a lot of
22:13 Homeowners refinance and pay off their down payment assistance loans. And so you'll be using some of that for the client at age 101. And then those funds are still available to purchase any home in Aspen Village townhomes, San Marquino Villas, and Meridian Court. So even if it's a market rate unit, you can still use this down payment assistance program as long as you income qualify and meet some other requirements aligned in the
22:46 50 page guidelines. I've been working with the town staff to get the general fund town program for up to 120% AMI, which would require that the home buyer enter into a deed restriction with Mammoth Lakes Housing. And so hopefully those funds will be available this spring and we're going to operate that program on a lottery because there's only two
23:16 opportunities for two households to utilize those funds as a pilot program. And then we had an exciting meeting with HCD Home Program staff today where they promised to help us set up the Mono County Home Program, hopefully by the end of this week, they said. So we're accepting complete applications now so we can get some folks lined up and ready to go to use those funds.
23:48 Um, because if they're, unless they're granted an extension, that program expires at the end of July. Um, are there any questions yet? The, the, the HCD seem to indicate they might allow an exception since they've been dragging their feet. Now it expires in less than four months. 2022, it expires. Oh, the year extension already on it. Yeah. Oh, we have the extension. Okay. Oh, good. I'm sorry.
24:28 That's good. At least, yeah, thank you. So what happened was they gave an automatic extension because they took a year to issue the contract. So that's right. It expires in 2022 now. Sorry for the scare. We're scared every day. Okay, I'll move to rental assistance. So as of the 23rd of February.
24:58 We received an additional 1600 in private donations. I have received some communication from Union Bank indicating that our request has been approved and that they're going to put the money directly into our bank account. They haven't let me know how much it's going to be, but my initial ask was for $30,000. And then you'll see that we've spent
25:32 To date, more than $600,000 to help folks pay their rent. That's almost 500 households and 1,200 rent payments and 175 different landlords. Fundraising for this program is ongoing but hasn't been as active, I would say. I tried a Facebook fundraiser at the end of the year.
26:07 Did get a lot of traction. I think maybe because I'm new to it, I wasn't really sure how it worked. We're still receiving donations via our website in small amounts from individuals. And then the union bank donation is the most recent. Under grants, I wanted to let you know that I have been in close communication with the home program on our website.
26:49 Grant for 238 Sierra Manor Road, and they indicated that they were, that their staff was recommending to their loan committee to loan to our project the funds that we requested. I don't know when that will go to the loan committee. They had initially said it would go in February, but I just talked to them last week, so hopefully soon we'll hear more. I'm optimistic, so I think that's good news.
27:22 For the CDBG grant that we submitted in September, we were told the earliest we would hear is September of this coming year. And Diane attended the CDBG webinar on the NOFA that was just released. And she noted that they may not accept over-the-counter project applications in this round. So we were really lucky to get it in in the last round because
27:51 They'll be going down the list of everybody who submitted their application before the deadline and hopefully funding all of those that meet the project ready requirements. And then they anticipate not having funding for projects to apply in this round because they'll be funding the projects from the last round. And then we anticipate talking with our partner jurisdictions to see if they're interested in applying for more.
28:22 Mortgage Assistance under the CDBG program. And then I added on here the LISC Partnership for Rental Assistance. As you know from our last meeting, the state is partnering with LISC, which is a national organization, to implement the state's rental assistance program. And LISC held a webinar for partner agencies to
28:54 Apply to be a partner and help with outreach and then also maybe help with technical assistance helping clients fill out the online application. And so I attended a meeting with IMACA to talk about a strategy for regional coordination and we each submitted an application to
29:20 Support outreach and education around the program. Hoping to coordinate with them and whatever staff capacity we have to help each other. But it was really unclear from the resources that LISC provided how much funding they were allocating to our region to support.
29:49 needs to pay staff to help people fill out this application, which as we know from our program is very labor intensive. So we submitted a proposal with a budget that included staff time and we're just waiting to hear. That program is anticipated to start taking applications from clients.
30:14 As early as March 15th. So I'm just waiting every day to see whether or not we were selected to be a partner agency. And if not, what can we do to help? Or what is that going to look like so we can start educating people? There's a lot that I don't know yet. So I just wanted to keep the board in the loop. Question? Yeah. So
30:46 I looked at their information. They created some new information. They have some FAQs, LISC does. And I looked at that because one of my fellow board members at CCRH is an employee at LISC, and he shared it with the board. And it looked like they were encouraging not more than 5% to 8% for admin. But do we know what that's of?
31:16 No, and that's what was confusing about the application. So my understanding is that the admin ask was supposed to be not more than 7% of your total ask. So if we were asking for, you know, 10 iPads or I'm, but it was confusing because it was like, well, really, we just need the support.
31:49 to pay the people who are going to help the people. So I submitted something. I don't know if they're going to come back with questions or... Well, then today at the CCRH Ledge Committee meeting, and also from Michael Carroll, who works with LISC, it sounds like the response from rural community has been less than desirable. They're really hoping more people will apply to participate. I think there's some concern about
32:21 That getting out. And then some people from CCRH just don't want to participate for various reasons. Some are concerned about conflict of interest since they actually own and property manage property there or, you know, that would be. So, I mean, we don't have those issues so much, but I think it's going to be a challenge. So I'm glad you're at least in the loop on that.
32:52 Kind of along the same lines of this topic, it was brought up today that HCD has requested that jurisdictions that receive CDBG funding for the CARES Act for rental assistance, and I know the town received some of that, that they had asked the recipients of that tranche of funding not to
33:20 Not to use it for rental assistance now and to focus on mortgage assistance. Is that something that's trickling down to Mammoth as well or Mono County or no? Yeah, so that is true. I apologize that I didn't have it in my update. So the town of Mammoth Lakes received CARES CBG-CV1 funds for rental assistance and we implemented that program.
33:47 That had an application window. And when the application window closed, I think we had maybe 22 or so applications that we processed. And I think maybe one or two of those was ineligible. And so we paid up to three months or $1,500 a maximum each for each one of those applications in accordance with the HUD guidelines.
34:17 And then the application window was closed. And so we were working with town staff to reopen the application window once they received their second round of funding. And then news came from HCD that they wanted everybody to stop rental assistance with that funding.
34:36 Because they were concerned that there would be duplication of benefits and that people would be receiving rental assistance from CARES, but then they'd also be receiving rental assistance from SB91 and that would cause a problem. And so the state said you can still do subsistence payments. You can do it for mortgage for 80% AMI and below households.
35:04 And or utility payments. And so the town is considering doing that. And otherwise, what would they do, give them that? I think that they could also do business assistance, but I think with the low mod income restriction, they felt like it was maybe more burdensome than administratively burdensome than a program that we sort of already have going. Okay.
35:37 You're just keeping communications open with the town to try to solve for that. Okay. Thank you. And so, under the LISP Rental Assistance Program, you know, I had a really good conversation with Mammoth and we, you know, to be honest, it was very intimidating thinking about doing the outreach for this program considering we know what it takes to make it happen. I mean, it's good that we have that experience.
36:12 But it wasn't something that either one of us wanted to jump on very excitedly, but we talked about how if we don't do it, who else is going to do it? And if we aren't the resource for people to figure out how to access this state funding, then people are going to get left behind. And so we really felt a responsibility to apply. We said that under each of our applications, we would say that we're partnering with each other.
36:41 That we really want to make it happen. But I wasn't shy about putting the cost in the application. And so I'm just curious to see what this will say. Yeah, it sounded like from the FAQs that they wanted one regional entity and then you could subcontract with others. So they may award it to you or a mock-in and ask that you subcontract with each other and collaborate. I think something to bear in mind.
37:10 Just so that it doesn't feel quite so overwhelming is that you don't write any checks. There'll be no check writing and Kirk's clock can get a break from signing checks. So there's that and that they have creative marketing, you know, they have a toolkit and so hopefully it's less of undertaking than the local program.
37:39 Yeah, so I'm excited to hear what they have to say and I look forward to working with our regional partners to figure out the best way to roll that out. Under additional work program items, I mostly wanted to talk about 238 Sierra Manor Road and a couple of things that I've been working on to move that project forward.
38:12 Obviously, I mentioned we rented the vacant spaces and we coordinated with the relocation expert to make sure that we were in compliance with relocation for those leases that we entered. And then we're just finalizing our environmental coordination with HCD. And then we had to get, so normally what would happen is that you would apply to the state for all of your grant funds.
38:43 They would approve them, and then you would go and get your architectural drawings done and apply for your building permit. But because when they did this CDBG revise of the whole program, they wanted shovel-ready projects, we had to invest resources up front and get the architectural plans completed and apply for a building permit. So now our building permit
39:10 is sort of in process and our application timeline was running out so we had to ask for an extension of our building permit application. So we did that and our building permit application has been extended through August and then in order to pull the building permit we'll need to pay all of our fees so our water permit fees, fire permit fees, and town permit fees.
39:39 So that's something that I've been trying to think about strategically about how that's all going to roll out. And then another big component that I've been working on is figuring out the construction loan timeline and thinking about having some conversations with some lenders. So we will be securing both a construction loan and a permanent loan for this project.
40:10 And so we'll be looking for a lender that can carry both of those loans for us. And so I'll be starting to reach out to our local banks first and then, you know, any banks we might have relationships with already and then kind of reaching out from there to see what's going to be the best avenue for that part of this project.
40:40 to look forward to in our meetings to come on that. Yeah, sure. CRA is still a thing, right? I know there was some talk about weakening that program under the Trump administration, but I don't know that ever happened. Hopefully local banks would be interested in there. What is that the something? Credit Reinvestment Act. So.
41:11 It's always something to remind them that they're on the hook for that and if they should participate. Yeah, absolutely. And so I've been making a couple of connections at local banks, which is great, and just trying to be prepared at a moment's notice for when we hear from the state. Other things that we've been working on are the annual occupancy monitoring, which is almost complete, which is great.
41:50 utilizing our new database to help keep track of deep restricted units and our home buyer portfolio, which is time consuming. It's a whole new database system and I don't think we've spent as much time in it as we want to, but we certainly are entering all of our new clients in and so just trying to work through learning how that works, you know, it's just more difficult than you like it to be at first, right? And then once you get over the home.
42:24 It'll be great. And then I've been meeting with Inyo County about the rehab program that we're designing and also their housing element update. So those are good meetings. We have a lot of other things happening. So we also have an open board seat that we've been advertising. We ask that applications be submitted by March 15th, but we haven't received any yet.
42:56 I think that was about a four-week application period or maybe a little more. And that's being advertised in the Times, the Sheet, and the Radio. It's on our website. And I did a post on it. And we're also recruiting for our internship for next year. And those applications are due April 9th. And we've received one interested person so far.
43:31 I implored her to submit a complete application. Then we released our marketing request for proposals, and we're asking firms to submit by March 19th. I've received one complete proposal, but I'm definitely expecting at least a handful more, so I'm sure folks are working on those. Those are all the exciting things that I have. Question, Jennifer?
44:09 I just have one more question, and thank you for all your work. You guys are doing a ton of stuff. It's so diverse, you know, and there's not a ton of staff. So I wonder if you had a chance to do the vacancy report calculation for the town or not yet. And if so, did you have that figure that you could share with us or maybe at the next meeting? I know I'm putting you on the spot.
44:37 No, that's okay. We have all of the data, but I haven't drawn up the report yet. So I will have it, I will have it for the next meeting. Further discussion? Then if there are no further discussions, this was a information item, we'll move to, and I'm not sure if we got, we covered some of it, agenda item number seven, Mammoth Lake Housing Annual Report 2020. This is an information item. Patricia?
45:12 Thank you. So last year we published our annual report in March and this year I had grand plans to change the format and delve a little deeper into the realm of report design. However, after thinking about limited time and the fact that we are
45:39 Trying to procure a firm to help us with those things in the future. I thought it was the best that I just roll with what we have and implement all the great work that we did this past year despite all of what seemed to be insurmountable challenges. So here we have the report, annual report for 2020. It covers the 12-month period of that year. It's a little complicated to
46:10 To put the data in, it just doesn't follow the fiscal year, which normally my brain operates in. So it's always fun to go through and make sure everything fell within the calendar year. Some highlights I wanted to note for the board was that despite, you know, scheduling people to work in the office one at a time, trying to work from home with screaming children,
46:44 Taking on the Emergency Rent Assistance Program. I still don't know how we're doing that, but our homeownership programs were up 55% over last year. So last year, I think we did two or three homebuyer loans. This year, in 2020, we did six homebuyer loans. That's a lot of work. I remember walking
47:14 You know, walking the bike path with my kids on Saturday, on the phone, trying to close a real estate deal because this homebuyer, right, was going to be homeless because their landlord was selling their condo and they were buying, trying to buy this other condo using our programs and it just was totally crazy. And so the fact that we helped six households buy homes in 2020 is phenomenal. And then on top of that,
47:45 We preserved and maintained 5D restricted units. I know the boards are very familiar with the rent assistance program, but we took that on. We raised almost a million dollars just through all the organizations that participated. And it's just been so great to be able to offer this service to our community during this crazy, terrible time.
48:17 And then on top of that, we held three separate community zooms, one for landlord-tenant's rights, which was really important when all of these eviction moratoriums were being put in place and all the landlord-tenant rights laws were becoming even more confusing. We provided that live in both English and Spanish, and those recordings are still on our website.
48:47 We also hosted the Mexican Consulate to speak with the Spanish-speaking community about services that they provide free, free legal services that we became aware of. And so that was a great opportunity for our community to learn more about their rights and services that are available to them. And then we also held a homebuyer education class, our first virtual homebuyer education class.
49:16 We hosted in April, right when the pandemic started. So there's been no lack of work that was put in front of us, but we accomplished so much. And I'm just really proud of all of our staff, Diane and Jake and Judith and Eduardo. Everyone's just been really committed to all the projects and programs that we've been offering.
49:47 throughout 2020. And I also wanted to mention that it wasn't included in this report, but we submitted something like at least five grant applications. And we don't know the outcome of all of those, but that's a lot of work of copying documents, of preparing zip drives, and mailing 500-pound binders to the state.
50:18 You know, we didn't put that in the annual report, mostly because a lot of the outcomes we don't know yet, but we did a lot of that. And so, you'll see, I put a picture of Owen, who's like four weeks old, helping complete the home application for 238 Sierra Manor Road. So, you know, we recruited some volunteers for that also, but it wasn't easy.
50:47 And so at the end of the report, I just have a few things that we're looking forward to, including our rebranding and hopefully our rehab program in Inyo County and our higher income down payment assistance program. And we just have a lot to do. And so it's always good to keep your eye on the future and try to stay on track. So I'm really proud of everything we've accomplished and I couldn't do it with Diane.
51:19 And Judith and everybody who's helped us. The board, I know many of you have signed checks or volunteered your time to check voice messages and Zariah is helping with rental assistance applications and it's just been a lot and just grateful for everybody who's helped out. So thank you. Thank you, Patricia.
51:52 Patricia, anything else on the annual report that you want to add? Okay, she turned the sound off. I don't think so. Thank you. This is great. I really enjoyed reading your letter. I thought it was written excellently, if that's the right way to say this, but it was just a great job on that. It was very heartfelt and, of course, all the work.
52:25 That you all did. And I hope that Owen will consider applying for the internship program. Any other comments? If not, we'll move on to agenda item eight, the parcel update. Patricia? I need to just grab my plug for my computer. I'm sorry, if you could just hold on one second. We're on agenda item eight, a parcel update. Okay. I think we just lost Patricia. Huh?
53:08 Oh, okay. As a general information item, the council has dealt with the parcel and it's broken down into four different parcels. So it looks like if everything...
53:37 works out the grants and everything that we will actually be breaking ground this year on one of the sections of the four sections that will be developed. So the infrastructure, the roads and the underground infrastructure will happen this year and perhaps I think they're a little optimistic that they'll be breaking ground and starting the building of
54:06 The first phase, which will be close to Center Street. Patricia? Thank you. Sorry. Yes, thanks. I just needed to plug in my computer. This update is before you this evening to give you basically an update on our meeting that we had with town staff and representatives from the Pacific companies regarding a potential role for Mammoth Lakes housing in the parcel.
54:37 And so for the background of this item, I just wanted to demonstrate the involvement that Mammoth Lakes Housing had in 2019 during the plan the parcel process. And Mammoth Lakes Housing really became involved at this level due to community input and the desire from the community that Mammoth Lakes Housing have a role in the parcel. And so we spent
55:07 something like 300 hours doing outreach, participating on the town staff team during their sessions with Lisa Wise Consulting and helping to come up with the guiding principles for the parcel development. After the conceptual land use planning outreach efforts were completed,
55:36 Mammoth Lakes Housing applied to the RFQ with Meta Housing, a non-profit developer, responded to be considered for the development of the parcel. And we participated in two interviews with town staff and their interview team, and ultimately we weren't selected during that process.
56:13 In 2020, Mammoth Lakes Housing's participation in the parcel process really dwindled, and we spent less than 20 hours of staff time at the town's request, participating in any planning for the parcel or conversations with the developer that they selected. In November,
56:51 The Mammoth Lakes Housing Board asked me to submit a letter in writing asking for a meeting to discuss MLH's role in the development. And I think that was the right thing to do. I think some people have said, well, you didn't need to submit a letter. It's not that formal. But I think that the Mammoth Lakes Housing Board and myself have been adamant about having this conversation about
57:23 a role for Mammoth Lakes Housing in the parcel, and there hasn't been a lot of response from the other side. And so now that we have this letter, this was the letter where we asked for a meeting. And then in January, we had some volunteers from the MLH board who wanted to discuss this a little more in depth. And so we had a meeting of those volunteers to talk about what role those volunteers from the board believe that MLH should play.
57:55 And some of those roles included continuing the role that we play at the current developments and as the community nonprofit housing organization where people can go for applications and resources, providing Spanish language opportunities and asset management on behalf of the community. So ensuring that the project is
58:25 in compliance with its requirements and coordinating with the property manager and any monitoring entities on the viability of the project in the future to make sure that there's eyes and ears on the ground. So in early February, I met with representatives from the Pacific Company in the town of Mammoth Lakes along with Tom Hodges, our board member, to
58:58 Bring those recommendations from the MLH Board and our committee about what we perceive to be the best role for MLH to play in the parcel development. That conversation, so during that conversation, the Pacific companies explained the model that they use in some of their projects in Truckee, which includes an out-of-the-area nonprofit organization.
59:32 And out of the area, property management firm, and coordination with the town of Truckee's housing coordinator. So that's the model that they like to use, that they like in Truckee that seems to be working fine. So they explained that to us. And then there was some discussion about why Mammoth Lakes Housing is a partner in the existing developments that are already in the town.
1:00:02 And one of the reasons why somebody thought that was, was so that Mammoth Lakes Housing could gain points to become a nonprofit partner in future developments. And so I posed the question, well, if that was one of the ultimate goals, then why are we still not pursuing that avenue? There's certainly, nobody's proposed that to Mammoth Lakes Housing to date.
1:00:31 And so why can't we continue to have that conversation? The group agreed that they would do some research around that, but I believe that it's too late for phase one since they've already submitted their application for their tax credits. Other possible roles that the developer and the town mentioned during this meeting included just being a clearinghouse for information, sort of like a community advocacy organization.
1:01:04 And then also playing a larger role in some of the ownership opportunities on the site. So in later developments, possibly operating as the broker for those units. And, you know, ultimately, I would hope that we could set up maybe like a land trust model for some of those units in the future. And so that was mentioned as well.
1:01:34 The Pacific Companies is really very interested in proposing or presenting to the MLH Board at our April meeting regarding what their timeline is for the development, where they're at for phase one, and supposedly discussing a potential role for Mammoth Lakes Housing in the Parcel with the full board. And so that is my update, and I'm happy to answer any questions that anybody has about this project.
1:02:05 Questions from the board? I wonder if Tom could speak to this since he was the board designate on that meeting at that meeting. Yeah, I mean, it was a little discouraging to say the least that they didn't have a lot of opportunities, at least as Patricia said, I mean, this first phase, you know, it seems like the boats kind of sailed, but they did mention like, you know, we could potentially pursue
1:02:40 You know, some sort of partnership with the nonprofit property manager, but that would be really to them directly and not through Pacific companies. So I think that's a possibility, but again, they've got an established track record with this path and they seem pretty comfortable with what they're doing. So it certainly didn't seem on the property management side, there was much opportunity, to be honest. One area they did say that
1:03:09 That also was potential in the future would be for sale product. And as much as we could possibly take a bit of a lead role maybe in qualifying and managing the applicants to buy to purchase units, because we're, you know, kind of doing that now with our master list. And that may seem to have some interest in that, but that might be a useful role for us in future phases. But, you know, the way things are right now, you know,
1:03:40 A lot of that product is earmarked to be rental, right? So, you know, it's hard to say when there'll be a phase coming that will be for sale. So I think that's something maybe we can quiz them on a bit when they come talk to us in April, what their expectations are on that. But, you know, I think it's just, I think a large part is because they ended up having, you know, through the whole arrangement of financing and so forth, having to acquire the parcel, their ownership of the parcel.
1:04:10 So it is a little bit different than past projects where MLH was the landowner and clearly a partner in that way. But as Patricia said, there was this, you know, where we could potentially become the nonprofit partner in the future. So that would help them to apply for the tax credits and stuff. I think that's worth pursuing and chasing that down. Yeah, so that's really the gist of it.
1:04:42 It wasn't as fruitful as I thought it could, as I was hoping for, but I have to be honest, you know, the whole affordable housing development business is very complicated, clearly, and a little bit over my head. I'm just not familiar with all the particulars of, particularly all the financing requirements in these programs and so forth. So, you know, it sounded like, you know, a lot of the stuff was just...
1:05:11 This is the way it has to go in order to get the financing together, and there wasn't a lot of room for our direct involvement, at least at this point. So were they going to be maintaining their own list of applicants to get into those units? Well, that, yeah, I mean, in terms of the rental, it really has to run through their system. So for now, that appears to be the case. But like I said, I think in the
1:05:44 Future potential phases of for sale product, they did sort of entertain the idea that maybe we could facilitate, you know, the for sale product and qualifying and prioritizing the applicants. And then I would assume that would also, you know, apply to future turnover in that product, just as much as we're doing now with the deed restricted units that come back onto the market.
1:06:10 And if we were to do that, what would finance our costs? So I think some of that is still to be determined and hoping that after they present to us in April, perhaps we can have a follow-up meeting with the town. Right.
1:06:30 The Pacific Companies, but I think that at some level there's some desire for our Mammoth Lakes Housing to play a clearinghouse role, whether or not that includes applications and a waiting list, I'm not sure. So, but I think from the developer's perspective that they, that the property manager should just be able to do that and that's a requirement of the tax credits and so there's really no need to have Mammoth Lakes Housing involved.
1:06:59 Is it the best for the community? I think there's a lot of unanswered questions, and I haven't heard a lot of ideas on how the town would like to see that structure. We just really haven't gotten into the nitty-gritty of it. Yeah. There was one other thing they did mention, that if we were, again, this is the for sale product, but there might be an opportunity for us to play the broker role on that, and we could be paying a commission.
1:07:30 For, you know, performing brokerage duties. So, in any event, I know, Patricia, I don't want any pressure on you because I know it's on your list of things you want to pursue is to get your brokerage license and, you know, but it does sound like there'll be a little bit of time before these things get teed up, you know, like, I'm just kind of guessing here, but I'm thinking it's a couple years out at least until they're going to be even starting for sale product in the best case scenario.
1:08:02 I think the first few phases will be focused on, well, because we know the first phase is all rental. Likely the next couple phases will be, I would think are going to be rental products. So maybe by the third or probably, you know, somewhere in the fourth phase or so, they would be looking at some of the for sale stuff. But they're part of that, as we've, you've probably heard off and on in different public forums of, you know, discussion about the parcel is, you know, putting together.
1:08:33 The financing for the for sale product, particularly the, well, really any of those income levels is challenging because there's no programs out there to support it. So, you know, it really is going to be up to the local community to put together some sort of gap financing for the for sale product. And so I think that alone is going to make it a bit of a struggle to get to a point where that those.
1:09:02 That type of phasing will get scheduled because we've got to have that financing there to support it. Well, you know, SB5 is in the state legislature and it's got ownership component to it and ownership tends to rest with CalHFA and they have financing mechanisms to finance ownership developments and such.
1:09:37 I think part of the challenge will be is for specific companies to figure that out because it's not something they do. But I think that there's an emphasis at the state level and I think it's going to grow between now and then to create more tools to finance homeownership because of the wealth building mechanisms that ownership creates that rental doesn't.
1:10:03 But I also think it's an opportunity for the town council, the board of supervisors, and this board and others to advocate and work on our representatives and through our pathways for the creation of ownership tools, more ownership tools. But anytime you talk about affordable housing ownership subsidies, it's through CalHFA.
1:10:32 And so, so I think there's some there and I think it's just, we're going to have to keep, you know, keep working on it. Yeah. Further, further discussion? My comments are, I still have concerns over the AMI if we are developing product that
1:11:02 That is available to people, average, medium income of 120 and above. I mean, we're missing a big gap of people that are making 80 or 100 percent of AMI. So I think that the product and what we're doing does meet a need, but there is a substantial need below the 120 AMI.
1:11:30 And so, and that's obviously trying to find the funding to be able to do that is very difficult. Historically, the town voted on an advisory vote that got over 60%, that 1% of TOT would be available for workforce housing.
1:11:53 And that, because of the litigation and everything else down at the airport, that money had been shifted. And so maybe the council, and this is just me talking off the top of my head, maybe the town council needs to go back and revisit the budget. Thank you. Yeah, and Kirk, I would just add, or I guess sort of a common question to you, but I mean, at this point, the funds that had been raised through that, that had been set aside in the
1:12:25 And the housing fund have largely been spent between the acquisition of the parcel, right, and then the rental assistance programs of late. So there's not a whole lot left in that. But moving forward, I would assume that there's potential for that to be replenished at that 1% of TOT level, or the one point of the 13 points of TOT. So it could grow back again. And just a question of the political commitment of the council, right?
1:12:55 Correct. Yeah. So, you know, I mean, that's real money. And then we had, one of the other things that had come out of the, you know, the community housing initiative was that we should look at, you know, another source of sustainable revenue for housing. And there was discussion about either tapping on another, you know, 1% TOT specifically.
1:13:27 To your mark for that. You know, that kind of lost its legs there with the pandemic and everything else going on and we missed the election cycle, but I thought it was taking something actually to the voters and getting it committed without question. So, you know, I don't know. I think it's something that we probably as a community need to reconsider as we move forward into the next election cycle to get that thing teed up again and have that out there because it...
1:13:55 There's not a lot of other obvious sources of funds, you know, I mean, you know, to really make a difference from a local perspective, raising money for that. Further discussion? I keep bringing that 1% up because I still want to adjust the town's budget again. If there is no further discussion, we'll move on to agenda number 9.
1:14:34 Did we do the parcel update? Patricia, do you have anything to add on the parcel update? No. Then we'll move on to agenda item number nine. Consider adoption of the Mammoth Lake Housing Resolution 2101, a resolution of the Board of Directors of Mammoth Lake Housing, Inc., approving the creation of the following ad hoc committee, Town of Mammoth Lake Contract Negotiation Committee. This is an action item. Patricia?
1:15:04 Thank you. I brought this item to the board this evening because our contract with the Town of Mammoth Lakes expires in June, and so we'd like to start working on it early so that we have plenty of time to adopt it before then, hopefully. Our last contract that we adopted was a two-year contract. I think this year we'll be looking for a three-year contract. Creating an ad hoc committee will help.
1:15:33 Further our discussions with the town and help us advocate for whatever is best for the organization and staff and the work program moving forward and what's best for the town as well. We had an ad hoc committee the last time and so I'm recommending that we create an ad hoc committee of no more than three board members and the executive director.
1:16:05 And the committee will meet as a committee and then may or may not meet with the town staff or potentially legal counsel we met with last time. So it's a little bit more of a commitment than some of our other committees. But once the contract is finalized, then the committee will disband.
1:16:28 And so I'm recommending that the board adopt Resolution 21-01 to establish an ad hoc contract negotiations committee. So moved. I'll second the motion. It's been moved and seconded. Further discussion, Tom? Okay. Roll call vote. So we're just saying that the committee is going to be foreign. We're not deciding who's going to be in it or anything.
1:17:05 That's the next one. That's right. That'll be next. Okay. Lindsay Barksdale? Yes. Tom Hodges? Yes. Jennifer Kreitz? Yes. Yes. Agnes Fiansen? Yes. Richard Blaisted? Yes. And Tony Perkins? Yes. Thank you. Motion passes 7-0. We'll move to the point.
1:17:38 Agenda Item Number 10, appoint board members to serve on the Town of Mammoth Lakes Contract Negotiation Committee formed in Resolution 21-01. This is an action item. Patricia? Thank you. So now that we have an ad hoc committee established, we'll need no more than three board volunteers and the Executive Director to serve on the committee.
1:18:14 The last one, I'm certainly willing to do so again, but I don't want to deny any of my other board members of the opportunity to participate in this if they so choose. So I'm available if needed and certainly willing to participate. What is the time commitment, William? The time commitment is, well, I'm not exactly sure exactly how much it will be. I think that last year we spent a lot of time hammering out the details of the contract and so I
1:18:50 I think it's, you know, our hope that the details are, or the frame is there, and that there's just maybe a few details we need to discuss. So I would think that the committee would meet at least once as a committee, and then maybe, maybe four committee meetings total, maybe? Yeah. I was going to say that, you know, last time there was a little negotiation of the legal terms and conditions that we,
1:19:23 You know, utilized our council for and got through all that. So I think the template's pretty solid at this point. It's really just the material, you know, business items. So it shouldn't be nearly as, you know, exhaustive as it was last time. It should be fairly straightforward, I think. Do I have a motion? Do we need a motion on this one? This is an action item as to who the official members of the
1:19:56 Contract Negotiation Committee? I think we only have one volunteer at this point, Kirk. We're still looking for two other volunteers. Everybody else stepped backwards and I just did. It's all good. Trying to be official. So we'd be putting that time in right away or is that going to go over the next couple months or what? I'm having a preliminary meeting on the deliverables with town staff.
1:20:29 In the next couple of weeks. So I would think after that meeting, we wouldn't have a committee meeting. And then, you know, our hope would be to adopt the contract either before June 30th or shortly after. I can put in a little time in, but my availability will open up a little more on the second half of April. So this month I'm pretty busy, so I can...
1:21:03 Do a meeting or two, but not a whole lot of time in this month, but in about six weeks or so, my availability should open up more. Lindsay, were you going to say something? No. I said thank you. I was on the contract committee last time, so I'm going to give it a miss this time. So thank you guys. Thank you to everyone who volunteered. Okay, I'll put
1:21:41 We're looking at Tom, Tony, Jennifer, and myself. And then if we could have a motion, that would be great. I move that we have an ad hoc committee comprised of Tom Hodges, Tony Perkins, and Jennifer Kreitz, along with the Executive Director. I'll second. It's been moved and seconded. Further discussion? All those in favor?
1:22:21 We're going to do roll call. Lindsay Barksdale? Yes. Tom Hodges? Yes. Jennifer Kreitz? Yes. Kirk Stepp? Yes. Agnes Vianzen? Yes. Richard Playstead? Yes. And Tony Perkins? Yes. Thank you. Motion passes unanimously. We'll move to agenda item number 11, committee updates.
1:22:51 This is an information item. Patricia? Thanks. So I meant to put this item next to board member reports, but I forgot, so it ended up at the bottom of the agenda. But if representatives of each committee would just like to give a brief update, I think that would be helpful. You said you got one response from the marketing for the RFP?
1:23:26 Was that from one of the people who we had a response from already? No. So the deadline for the marketing RFP is March 19th and we received one proposal so far and it was not from one that we previously looked at. Great, thanks. Just as the governance committee, one of the members of that committee, I just mentioned that we haven't met and I don't think we've had
1:24:00 business, but maybe we do, and I just don't know what that business is, so I apologize that I'm being a bad committee member. Perhaps we should meet or send an email and confer. If there are no more committee updates? Well, I think we have some more. That was just the first one I was just reporting out. Lindsay? Yeah, Tom, are you going to talk board nominations, or were you going to different?
1:24:35 Well, yeah, I was going to say that we met, and we came up, went over our marketing program for promoting the solicitation for a new board member, and we kind of divvied up some responsibilities, and I think, Patricia, you've got an ad running here in the local papers, and Lindsay and I were making some calls. I made a comment during town council, public comment about the
1:25:05 The opening, and I think we were going to hit up a few other different groups in town. Yeah, it was going to go out to the Lodging Association newsletter. I wasn't able to present at their meeting, but yeah, so we were trying to get a few different organizations getting the word out, but I think board members, if you have people, people you think might be good for it, there's, it's very clear on the homepage of the website.
1:25:32 Where to go to apply to get the application. So direct people there. Or if you have organizations you belong to, double check that it's in those newsletters. Or if there are things that you think it should go to, we can get it out to further the word. And it's just a board member at large. It has no, we just have some restrictions on government, employment, involvement, things like that.
1:26:04 I believe, but not an income requirement. Right. And then we, in the programs and housing development committee, Jennifer and I and Patricia got together and started a discussion. So we're going to have a follow-up discussion, try to help prioritize what we're going to focus on and have a more solid report next month on what those priorities will be. Further discussion?
1:26:45 Thank you, everybody. Any other updates? If not? Well, I was going to say, I'm sorry, I didn't, I had doodling meetings there, and a surprise Jennifer wasn't there, a little of the counselor meeting for getting our kids enrolled in high school next year, so I apologize, I missed the opening hour here. But I did want to, just a couple things I wanted to report, I thought they were of interest, because I missed my board report, real quick, if you don't mind.
1:27:15 There's been a number of articles here of late that construction material costs have gone up exorbitantly, like in particular lumber, softwood framing lumber has gone up 100% in the past year, and like 50% in the last two months. It's been kind of crazy. I mean, the normal sales price per 1,000 bore feet is like $450, and it's like $1,000.
1:27:44 So it has doubled the cost of framing for any residential unit for that framing cost. So it's a significant impact on construction costs overall, as well as steel. Steel's gone up about 50% year over year. So there are some struggles on some of these commodity type construction materials right now. And some of these things are related to
1:28:11 Some of the hangover of tariffs from the Trump administration on the lumber, in particular with Canada. So there's been some contracting groups that have been lobbying the Biden administration to try to address these specifically to get these prices under control and facilitate the greater supply of these materials to hopefully bring these costs back down. So anyway, it's concerning. It's apparently slowing down new residential starts across the country, just even at market rate.
1:28:41 Much less affordable. It's going to have a pretty big impact on things at the moment. And then I saw an interesting article about people developing projects for rent for co-living. And I thought that was interesting as much as I could really see the need for that in our community with the units in the parcel.
1:29:13 It just kind of occurred to me, it's like, well, it seems like everything's focused obviously towards a family unit to a large part, but I don't know whether or not it's something that's worth looking into about, you know, creating opportunities for, you know, unrelated adults to, you know, work to get into a two-bedroom apartment, for example, or a three-bedroom apartment. You know, it's tougher, right, if they're just a single adult. And if there's people who are willing to
1:29:43 Co-live. You know, it might help address the needs of more people in our community sooner. So I just bring it up as something, you know, a little unique, but it's something that's going on in other communities in the country that people are looking at it. And it's like just trying to get more creative of how to get more people into housing. And so I don't think it would be abundantly obvious necessarily to people that there would be opportunity to cohabitate in a
1:30:13 So anyway, just wanted to bring that up to everybody's attention. Well, Tom, I just wanted to follow up with that, your co-living comment. We do have folks apply as roommates to live in our affordable housing units, but oftentimes they don't fall under the income limit because they each make $20,000 or $40,000 a year, and so then they're over the income limit.
1:30:44 So they get combined as if they were a family? Yeah, because it's household income. It's whoever's in the household. You don't have to be related. Right, right, right, right. So I could see that being an issue with other projects financed using low-income housing tax credits where, in a lot of cases, roommates who are both working each two jobs, say, may not qualify because they don't have a larger household.
1:31:15 As if they were married with children, they might be a family of five and the income limit would be higher. Well, maybe it becomes an opportunity for the missing middle group, or at least for purchase possibly, I don't know. Yeah, or for market rate rentals that are above 80% AMI. Right, right. I would imagine there's people out there who'd be interested in that. Absolutely. Yeah.
1:31:43 I made that suggestion during the workshops that we should have some type of co-living arrangement, whether it's dorm-style living or what, to make it easier. That's how I first moved to Mammoth back in 2002 was just an employee housing, sharing a room with somebody. And I know that that makes it easier for young adults and single people without the families.
1:32:10 Maybe, Patricia, we should add it to the Programs and Housing Development Committee task list. Might be some low-hanging fruit. Sure. Further discussion? If not, we'll adjourn to the regular board meeting scheduled for April 5, 2021. Thank you, everyone, for doing all the work. Thank you. Thank you, Patricia and Diane. Thank you, guys. Thank you, everybody. Have a good night.
1:32:52 Good night. Thanks. We are off the air.