TransparentMammoth

Housing Board (MLH / ESCH) · 2021

Housing Board (MLH / ESCH)

· recording 3 hr 2 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

369 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:35 President, staff, I believe you do have a quorum and everything is set to go here in Suite Z, so I'm ready when you are. Thank you. Thank you. Can you hear me? Yes. Yes. Okay. If we have a quorum, then we'll start the meeting of the Board of Directors, a regular meeting for Monday, April 5, 2021, of the Mammoth Lake Housing. Patricia, if you can do a call?

1:14 I'll go ahead and do that for you, Patricia. Thank you. Board Member Barksdale? Yes, here. Board Member Cruz? Board Member Hodges? Present. Vice President Kreutz? I think she's muted, but I see her. President Stapp? Here. Thank you. President Stapp? Here. Board Member Vianzen? Here. And Board Member Perkins? Present. Thank you. We'll move to agenda item.

1:50 So we have a quorum, we'll move to agenda item number two, which is public comment. Are there any public comments? If there are no public comments, we will move to agenda item three, which is approval of the minutes from the March 1, 2021 regular board meeting. This is an action item, so we'll vote on it. Are there any corrections, deletions? If I can have a motion. I'll make a motion to adopt.

2:24 The minutes of the March 1st, 2021, regular board meeting. Do I have a second? I'll second the motion. It's been moved and seconded. Patricia, roll call, please. I'll go ahead and do that for you. Board Member Barksdale? Yes. Board Member Hodges? Yes. Vice President Krites? Yes. President Stapp? Yes.

2:59 Board Member Vianzen? Yes. Board Member Perkins? Yes. And I believe Board Member Cruz has not logged in. Thank you. Okay, the minutes pass unanimously. We'll move to agenda item four, which is a parcel update. Patricia? Thank you. Here's our regular monthly parcel update staff report.

3:29 I wanted to go over a couple of new developments since we last spoke, but I included the background here. In 2019, Mammoth Lakes Housing spent approximately 300 staff hours on outreach and coordination on the plan the parcel process and supported town staff on all the outreach that they performed for that process.

4:00 And then after that, Mammoth Lakes Housing involvement sort of leveled off and ended in a way. In February of 2019, Mammoth Lakes Housing applied in response to the town's RFQ for a developer with a nonprofit developer called Meta Housing. And we participated in two interviews with the town in their interview panel. And then in 2020, MLH spent

4:29 At this point, approximately 25 hours on the parcel at the request of the town. Since that time and our staff involvement has sort of tapered off, Mammoth Lakes Housing has been requesting meetings with town staff in order to discuss a potential role for Mammoth Lakes Housing in the development of the parcel.

4:59 We sent them a letter in November requesting a meeting, and we had a committee of volunteers discuss from the board, discuss what role those board members believe that MLH should play in the development of the parcel, which is proposed to be almost or more than about 500 units. In February,

5:27 Myself and Tom Hodges met with town staff and representatives of the Pacific Companies to discuss a potential role. And we talked about the model that Pacific Company uses at some of their other projects in Truckee, for example, where most of the coordination with vacancies goes through the town of Truckee's housing coordinator position.

5:56 And then we discussed some other potential roles for Mammoth Lakes Housing, including a larger role in any potential ownership units at the site, performing the brokerage role to sell those units to qualified households. Last month, I did some research regarding the general nonprofit partner role at our current developments in town, including Aspen Village Apartments.

6:29 And Manzanita and Jeffries, as well as some other affordable housing projects in California. I had a call with Andrea to discuss specific companies providing a presentation to the board at this meeting, which I believe Shellen will present after my staff report. And then I provided some information to the board regarding the structure of a low-income housing tax credit partnership. And so this is the partnership structure that

7:03 Mammoth Lakes Housing used, along with Pacific Companies, to develop the Aspen Village Apartments and the Manzanita and Jeffrey's Apartments in the early 2000s. And so, in this structure, you have a couple of different roles. You have the limited partners who bring the financing and receive the tax credits. Then you have two general partners, an administrative partner,

7:32 who is often the developer, and the general nonprofit partner. The general partner can also be a nonprofit, and in that case, they wouldn't need an administrative partner, but in this case, the for-profit development firm needs a nonprofit managing general partner in order to get the welfare exemption for the low-income housing tax credits.

8:02 And the affordable housing project. Each of these partners plays some specific roles. So as I mentioned, the limited partners bring in the investment, and the general administrative or for-profit developer is the developer role, secures the site control, observes the necessary entitlements for the project, goes through design review, and does all that really specific work.

8:36 And then the managing nonprofit partner also has some specific roles, including being a nonprofit entity in order to secure the tax credits, is responsible for contracting with the property management firm, ensuring that the project complies with the low-income housing requirements of the project. In some cases, they're required to perform an annual physical inspection of the property.

9:07 Supervise and assist in other ways the property management company to make sure that the asset is being maintained. And then for those services, they collect a management fee. Mammoth Lakes Housing, when we did our first developments at Aspen Village and Mancini and Jeffries, utilized the Pacific companies to complete those developments and partnered with another nonprofit, Central Valley Coalition, in order to

9:45 Gain the experience and the points that we would need in order to become a nonprofit general partner in the future. And so currently we hold the required clearance certificate from the Board of Equalization, which allows us to perform that duty. As I've mentioned before, Mammoth Lakes Housing currently provides a lot of these duties to our current properties, including having a relationship with our clients.

10:16 Dispersing applications, walking the projects to make sure that they're being maintained, advocating for improvements, including painting, siding improvements. We've advocated historically to have playgrounds repaired. We coordinate very closely with the property manager. And I know as one of our board members would

10:46 Would advocate that we provide a lot of Spanish language support, whether or not that's a responsibility of the property manager. We are here for our clients and we provide that support to them. And a lot more. Those are just a few examples. These examples of services that we provide to our clients and our community members is

11:16 is an added benefit that we are here to provide, right? And so this is why Mammoth Lakes Housing was created and right, we are the local housing organization and we continue to provide those services despite not collecting a management fee from the current properties that we serve as a partner on. And so our conversations with the town and Pacific companies are ongoing regarding

11:50 Whether or not Mammoth Lakes Housing will be considered to provide the role of the managing general partner nonprofit. And so we'll hear from the Pacific companies regarding what role they believe is appropriate for Mammoth Lakes Housing to play this evening. But I wanted the board to know that as staff, I believe it's in the best interest of the community.

12:22 And the tenants and the town, as well as the project, to have a general managing partner that is a local nonprofit entity. I provided as an attachment to the staff report, the code of regulations, which describes the requirements of a general nonprofit partner in order to obtain the welfare exemption, which is a requirement.

12:53 And that's just a reference document for the board to review. And it's my opinion that Mammoth Lakes Housing is well equipped to provide the handful of requirements under this code for the parcel project. I would like to ask the board if they have any questions before we move on to the Pacific Company's presentation. Questions from the board?

13:35 Okay, great. I don't see any questions. Okay, great. I think Shelyn has a presentation. I just want to make sure she's able to share her screen. Hi, good evening. Thank you, Patricia. Let's see here. So are you able to see my screen? Yes, I am. Okay, so I had, well, first of all, thank you. Are you ready for me? Is now the right time for me to just jump in? Yeah, now would be great. Thank you.

14:23 Awesome. Okay, well, thank you for the introduction, Patricia. And I think most of you have probably looked through your packet and seen this presentation and nothing's changed from the PDF that I sent Patricia a couple weeks back. But I spent the first few slides kind of updating you on sort of where the parcel is today in the development and entitlement process. And as I look,

14:49 At the Zoom screen, I see there's so many familiar faces that are, you know, so acutely aware of the development. I'm happy to go through those first slides quickly if you'd like, or I can just skip ahead. I kind of wanted some feedback from you all if you wanted to, if you wanted me to kind of go through it and get you up to speed, or if you felt like you were already in a position to kind of skip through that. What do you guys think? Anyone that needs another review?

15:22 I'm not hearing anyone. So I think, you know, Kirk, I'll jump in. Sure, Shelly, if it doesn't take up too much time, it'd be great just to hear for the public, for us, I suppose, where we're at, in case people are watching a recording later, too, who aren't on now. Okay, yeah, that's great. Good thinking. I'll go quick, because I do see so many familiar faces. All right, so the parcel, you guys know it well. There we go.

15:55 You guys know it well. Now, which are you just seeing? I don't know which screen you're seeing, but that's okay. You know, where we are today, right? We're here in spring of 2021. We've gone through, I mean, you guys played a major role in the needs assessment through the public process. The town council accepted in 2019. Patricia spoke a lot about that, the RFQ award, and then again.

16:26 Another request for bids using due to the surplus land act accommodation, which happened this past January, December, January. At the same time, the town went forward with the master plan and the zoning revision. And then in early February, we got the first phases use permit and design review approval.

16:50 And then we immediately turned around literally within 24 hours and put our financing application in. So that's what that red star represents. We put in an application for 4% tax credits with which, like Patricia mentioned, you utilized all those things to get points on. And although we haven't gotten formal notice from the state, we're pretty certain that we were not successful, which isn't a huge surprise. It's how it goes. So we'll be submitting another application come

17:20 Come May. And I just want to say, in looking at this, and I promise I will go fast, Lindsay, but that, you know, having a needs assessment completed in 2017, and then getting a parcel, a 25-acre parcel in public ownership, going through a town-approved planning process, and then getting a developer on board within two.

17:43 to three years is extraordinarily, and a master plan approved is extraordinarily fast. And so I just commend, you know, this agency, the town of Mammoth Lakes to really, really have, you know, kind of setting themselves up for success. And I think that the Pacific Companies has done our part, but at the end of the day, I think it was the community that really did the heavy lift.

18:04 So with that said, just shows you, you know, master plan, the whole project's been entitled. We're going in front of the town of Mammoth Lakes later this week to hopefully get approval of the disposition and development agreement for just for phase one. And then hopefully go through with that financing in May.

18:23 And be able to start site grading as early as, you know, when the snow allows this spring. And that would be primarily for the public right-of-way, which the town will continue to own. So you're looking at the master plan, the whole 25 acres of the parcel. The different colors and the different numbers represent proposed phases. This will change. Master plans always change, but it's at a high level.

18:50 You know, what we're thinking. It includes each of these colors, represents a different phase, like I said, and they will each go back to the town of Mammoth Lakes and go through a public process. A minimum, this site will have 400 units and at a maximum 580 units. So there's quite a big difference and it really will depend on what each phase is entitled to have by way of density and height and all those other things. So the first phase, which is

19:22 You know, this teal colored is what we're talking about, what I'll kind of walk you through tonight. This is the primary. There's two buildings. They're both three stories of residential over tuck under parking. So what you're looking at is the podium parking of the two buildings. You'll come in off of Center Street, and this is the driveway, if you can see my mouse, into the surface lot, where you can come in under the building A or under building B.

19:47 We'll have a community center with some case management services from Mono County Health and Human Services, a lobby, property management sister, a property management office, community room, fitness room, restrooms, of course, as well as we're working with Amaka to have a daycare facility with an outdoor area as well. This community park is going to be owned by the public and will include not only the daycare, the required outdoor daycare.

20:15 Playground, but also some public public play area for children. We're showing extra bike storage in both buildings for these little gray boxes and in those bike storage areas we'll have dog washing and bike washing facilities just to kind of make this a really multimodal a place where we hope folks can really rely on bikes and pedestrian multimodal activities as well as having two bus stops in the in the first phase.

20:47 Affordability, the first phase is 81 units. It'll include one, two, and three bedroom units, up to 80% of the area meeting income, which based in 2020 was roughly $17,000 to $75,000 a year. I won't spend a lot of time on this. These are your clients. We were asked, I think, by Council Member.

21:06 A step here on the call or on the Zoom to look and compare what we were providing to what the households on the Mammoth Lakes Housing waitlist look like. And so this was back in December, but, you know, roughly 94% were below 80% of the area median income, meaning a lot of the waitlist would be theoretically eligible to live in this first phase.

21:33 Let's see. So I talked about the child care and the future park. We've got, I mentioned a diversity of unit types ranging from 400 square feet to the small one bedroom and studios up to just over a thousand feet for the three bedrooms. What we've also included is laundry on

21:51 Pretty much every floor, as well as little additional storage areas and sort of nooks for Zoom rooms, library areas, extra storage that people can use for bikes and boats and mountain living type of stuff that we know folks have. So we really strive to have these open floor plans that seem bigger than they are, but then also to include some amenities like that extra storage in these mountain communities. So these are just some views. This is...

22:19 Looking at that community space, coming down, you know, kind of on center street, looking into the community space in the public park. This is coming down center as well. This is the first smaller building, and this represents sort of the turn into the surface lot.

22:35 And this is the other side, looking at the daycare facility with the daycare playground and then the larger playground. These trees are to scale. There's two heritage trees in the park area that we're aiming to save. So you can really see how the trees tower over the height of the building. So the ownership structure, I'll turn it over to Caleb. Sorry, I didn't introduce you, but I kind of went fast and furious there. I hope, I'm certain that we'll have time for questions afterwards. And Caleb, you can just tell me to move the slides along when you're ready.

23:06 Well, we could just stop there, if everyone can hear me okay, and just see if you have any project-specific questions that they might have, you know, about what you just spoke. So let's just do that, just so we can talk about the project and process. Anything like that would be helpful, maybe, to ask first, if they're ready for that. Sure. Questions from the board? Yeah. It's Tom Hodges here. Hey, Caleb, how you doing? Good, Tom. Thanks. This is actually more of a question for our team, our Patricia. I mean,

23:38 How many people are on the current waiting list? Or, I guess, for rental property? I mean, I saw the percentages. I'm just curious, what portion of the demand are we serving with this first phase of this project, the 81 units? So, currently, there's over 100 families on the waiting list for low-income housing. Okay. So, I mean, it's 81. So, I mean, it's going to be a pretty good dent in the list, which is good.

24:07 In the list, yeah, but we don't really know exactly how many homes are overcrowded. Sure, I understand that. But I was just trying to get a feel for, you know, what the impact will be for this first phase. And obviously, I know there's subsequent phases. Hopefully, it'll be kind of following year after year after year. But, you know, I just, it's so apparent right now that our, you know, our rental housing is basically completely occupied in our community. There's just no availability right now.

24:36 It's going to be interesting here as we get kind of ramping back up as a resort community after, or, you know, somewhat return to normal, however long that's going to take, but it feels like, you know, we are going to start coming out of the other side of this whole thing. And, you know, I know there's a lot of concern in the community and the business owners about needing more employees potentially. And it's just always so difficult to bring anybody into our community from out of the area.

25:06 To expect that they're going to be able to find housing out of the gate. So, anyway, I'm just trying to get a sense of, you know, sort of demand and timing because, you know, we're going to, we're still behind, obviously, in the overall time frame of this. That's a good question, but I was wondering that if we don't have a significant role as a non-profit partner, are those 100 houses on the wait list going to be the first one served once this is developed?

25:40 Yeah, I can certainly speak to that. Just to say that the management company and our team are really trained to go first to Mammoth Lakes Housing for the waiting list to determine residency for the project. So that's part of the action that the management company will be in and continues to be in. In fact, that should be happening on an ongoing basis for the existing properties we have in the town of Mammoth Lakes. First direction is pulled from.

26:10 The waiting list, the Mammoth Lakes Housing maintains, and so that's the protocol. If it's not happening, we don't want to hear about that, you know, at any time, but that should be the procedure that's in place already. Yeah. Any other questions? While you guys are thinking about questions, I'll just give you a couple of important updates or additions to what Sheldon spoke about the project. As you guys might remember, the town and us jointly received the $20 million award.

26:43 for infill infrastructure from the state. And we are actively working with the team of the town to move forward this season with construction of the roads and major utilities on the parcel. So that is in process now. We're actively doing the working drawings for that. And, you know, as you know, in Mammoth, you got...

27:05 You know, kind of a limited shot each year to build anything. And so we're trying to take advantage of the construction season, regardless of the financing condition of our affordable housing applications. So we're kind of jumping the gun at risk there to deliver the infrastructure and kind of get that out of the way, given the limited building season. Another action that you'll anticipate seeing relatively soon would be, you know, a future application for, call it the next.

27:34 or phases of the project. We'll be kind of working on that, get that ready, even though that phase wouldn't start this year, maybe not even next year. We kind of need to stay ahead of it. And so that will be something coming your way. And then, you know, just one comment on the phasing itself. You know, it's a plan, but it may not end up exactly like that as far as the phases and how they work together.

28:01 So just know that, you know, that that phasing plan that you guys have, that can be modified, you know, all this, of course, is subject to the town's approval and the various boards, but I mean, ultimately, I just want to point those things out for you guys, just so, you know, hey, what's going on on the parcel? They're already building, potentially, and, you know, the answer to that will probably be that we're out there on the infrastructure, and, of course, this is all subject to the town's approval and permitting, et cetera, but just know those things are coming, so.

28:29 So maybe I'll also just pause for any other questions you guys might have had about the project itself and so we can finish those up. If you think of something later, no problem, but for now I just want to give you the chance. Hey Kelp, Tom here again. Quick question on the $20 million grant award. Is it specifically limited though to just sort of that civil site improvements or can portions of that be used towards the actual construction of the first phase building?

28:57 Yeah, it's mostly limited to public infrastructure. There's one exception, and that is that the funding can be used to construct our parking structures. So the podium that you see for both buildings, that understructure element there, that all can be used with those funds. And in fact, we do have a meaningful portion of those dollars budgeted for structured parking. So that's the one exception. But yes, everything else is public infrastructure.

29:27 And then just a quick follow-up. So that's great to hear because that helps. I'm sure at a high level, have you guys done an estimate of the whole build out of the site? And is the $20 million going to kind of cover the lion's share of the infrastructure that's necessary for the project?

29:46 Yeah, near as we can tell. And, you know, again, we've got a phase one infrastructure plan that's, you know, pretty biddable at this point that we can really get some good numbers on. And we've been working with town staff to kind of get some comparable information about their bid and what they've been doing. But yes, short answer is yes. And in fact, I'd say that my bet right now is at least half of the money can be available for

30:15 Parking infrastructure. And that, you know, the public infrastructure roads, et cetera, probably is less than 10 million as we estimate right now. So the money we have awarded, the 20 million, more than covers any public infrastructure needs for the whole parcel, as near as we can tell, you know, by a meaningful amount. So I think we're in good shape and can afford now to do a lot of structured parking, which honestly I wasn't quite sure.

30:42 You know, how much we can do structured parking and have paid for with that funding source. But it looks like, you know, in addition to this first phase, we've got meaningful dollars to be set aside for that, which is actually, you know, a benefit to the residents to have that covered parking and no snow removal and, you know, get greater density where we want to concentrate it. Is there a condition of the grant that you have to spend that money within a certain time frame?

31:09 How open-ended is that on getting it spent? There is. There's basically about a five-year window that we have to spend all of the money. And so, you know, we've kind of mapped out a plan to do that over the multiple phases. You know, a big chunk of the infrastructure, if you look at the infrastructure plan right now, you would see a substantial amount of improvement being done all around, you know, connecting.

31:38 Center and Tavern, and then even on over, getting to where Chaparral is, not all the way down. I don't know if Shellen has a screen for that, but, you know, basically, we have a huge chunk of it. You know, you can see kind of everything pretty much other than that purple area. So that center, tavern, and that mill crossing road would stop at the ditch at this time, but all that is considered phase one infrastructure. So a big chunk of it would be done now.

32:08 Utilities, you know, curb better sidewalks, streets, everything. And, you know, we're plan checking that right now with the town, as well as any park improvements, you know, we'd all be looking at it on a quote phase one infrastructure. And then after that, you know, the public infrastructure is not that significant anymore at this time. There could be some off-site infrastructure elements that town comes up with.

32:32 You know, i.e., is there a need for a traffic light, you know, up on the main road? Is there some connectivity that has to happen with a bike pedestrian slash connectivity? You know, things like that that could come up later. But for now, you know, this infrastructure plan is kind of what our on-site system looks like, and it's good. And so we'll only end up with maybe that milled crossing area and then the Chaparral Road extension, and that'll pretty much be it on-site. Is this going to be public?

33:01 So we're going to have, you know, we're going to have probably tackle that next season or the season after, but we'll be done with the public infrastructure well inside of the deadline. The question will be, can we get the affordable housing project financed quickly enough to use the rest of the money for structured parking? That's probably our bigger contingency.

33:26 And so, you know, one of the conditions in the grant is that, you know, we have to deliver a certain number of units. We kind of have to earn our way forward with the units we deliver or promise to deliver with the dollars that we're going to spend. And so right now we have a plan that kind of goes over five years to spend $20 million but also deliver a sufficient number of units to qualify for the infrastructure. And then the last thing that I'll say about that is that it's kind of a...

33:56 A flexible and fungible way to earn our way toward the $20 million. And what I mean by that is that if we do deeper targeted units, let's say units at 30% AMI versus 80% AMI, well that gets you more earned infrastructure money than does units that are at higher income level. Units that are bigger in size, so a three-bedding unit gets more infrastructure credit than a studio unit, as another example.

34:24 Homeownership units get different credits than rental units. And so there's a whole formula, which, you know, we put a whole spreadsheet together to kind of manage this. It sort of just tells us, you know, how do we earn our way to the 20 million? And so, for example, just as a, you know, like general rule, by doing the first phase, we probably earn our way to about, you know, three to four million worth of the infrastructure, just to give you a benchmark.

34:52 Unit production is really how we earn that money. And so over five years, you know, we basically have to earn our way towards the 20 million is kind of the way to think about it. There's also another provision for an extension to it if we run into trouble, but, you know, earning our way there. And so ATD will work with us at that time. But right now we're kind of working off of a five-year plan to get there. Questions? Tom? Thanks for the explanation, Clay. Yeah.

35:28 Appreciate it. Yep, you're welcome. Okay, well, if there's no other questions, you know, what I wanted to do, I mean, you guys, Patricia did a pretty good job of sharing some basic information with you. You know, the purpose of the meeting really today was to kind of talk about, you know, the structure of the project ownership, individual phases as they may be, and then kind of what happens at each phase. And so this little chart here is really just meant to sort of tell you.

35:55 As it's currently constituted, every phase is done with a separate special purpose limited partnership that's specific to that phase. So every time we go out, we form a new partnership for each phase of the project, and the members of the partnership in each phase are what's specified on the screen, with the limited partner kind of dependent upon

36:21 Who ultimately comes in and what investor we choose to buy the tax credit. That's really what that comes down to. So at first we come in as a limited partner just to have a placeholder name, but it really doesn't mean anything because at the end of the day we bring in an investor like a bank or an insurance company and they come in and buy the tax credit and take a 99.99% interest in the partnership.

36:44 And get the tax benefits that they really why they're investing, you know, in affordable housing. Federal government created this program to incentivize private sector to invest in affordable housing. And that's what the structure basically represents. You know, it's pretty straightforward. The administrative general partner, that's us. And we effectively kind of, you know.

37:06 Do all the day-to-day administration of the partnership. We take care of the tax planning issues. We take care of, you know, who hires the property management company and work with the managing general partner to do that. We pretty much, you know, think of the operations of a business are kind of what we're doing. And then the managing general partner, really, their role, and we can probably move to the next slide if you want, Sheldon, is really just to kind of, in this case, you know, really just be the, you know,

37:35 The kind of party that signs off on all of the different elements of the application, you know, they include their experience, they basically provide financials, they do all the things that the State Board of Equalization requires them to do to qualify as an official managing general partner that causes the project to be eligible for the property tax exemption that the project enjoys. So freedom from real estate taxes, basically.

38:04 And so, you know, nothing really at this point they need to do. In this case, although it doesn't have to be this, the management general partner has provided a supportive services plan, which basically specifies, you know, what services are going to be provided to the residents on site. This is kind of a new feature to Mammoth. The project that we did in the recent past, as well as the one that was done before our time there,

38:34 All were done in an era where supportive services were not required in the project. And so now, under California's rules, supportive services are a requirement or a point scoring category that has to be done in order to qualify for the maximum points to even get funded. So it's really a requirement of the project basically by default. And so what are supportive services? Generally, those are things like, you know, computer education, English as a second language, job.

39:03 Training skills, resume writing, credit counseling, you know, pathway to ownership, you know, things of that nature basically that are designed to improve the economic status of the residents when they take the classes, etc. So that can be provided by, there's nonprofits that provide that just as a business model, and then there's nonprofit housing providers that also provide those services kind of quote in-house.

39:33 And that's what Central Valley Coalition is doing in this case, is they provide all of the services as well as the maintenance of the property tax exemption and all the paperwork requirements for that. So they kind of bring both of those requirements to the table. You know, they generally at the closing,

39:54 They're underwritten, like both us as an administrative general partner and the nonprofit as a managing general partner are underwritten by the investors and lenders. They're looking at their financial condition. They're looking at their history to make sure they don't have any defaults or problems with other real estate projects. So there's a requirement to have a decent history, to not be, you know, at odds with anybody out there. And that'll get picked up in sort of litigation searches, et cetera.

40:23 On the other side of the equation, they don't have to provide any guarantees, any financial guarantees to the investors and lenders. They're not signing up for that. They're not signing up for a lot of day-to-day activity either. It's really mainly that property tax exemption feature that they bring to the table. And really, their attorney, who they also bring with them, is mainly there just to make sure that all the paperwork's done in a way that...

40:50 That reflects the requirements of the state, as well as make sure that the nonprofit's not getting in any kind of trouble or using their tax exemption for something that's not appropriate to their charter, et cetera. So, you know, when the project's built, they're not really involved heavily in this particular case. And by the way, the structure that I'm telling you is just sort of how this is working out in a situation where a developer like us is really driving the bus, so to speak.

41:20 And pushing the project along. There's other situations where a nonprofit might be actively involved in the project. They might have sourced local money, for example. They might be financially strong and able to put up guarantees. They might have a very strategic relationship with a local funder that causes money to come our way to build the project. Those are examples of situations where a nonprofit managing general partner might be very engaged in the project.

41:50 They could have found the property, you know, all kinds of different examples of that. But on an annual basis, basically, when the, you know, after the project is built, effectively what they're doing is they're making sure that that property tax exemption is maintained with the Board of Equalization and the county, and they are also being very diligent with the support of services that are required as part of the project. And that's actually an issue where, you know, if you're not doing your job, you can get in a lot of trouble.

42:16 The state will send out auditors, you know, basically every three years to do a field audit, and they come, they look at the services that have been provided. Are they appropriate for the residents? Are the number of hours being provided that are supposed to be? They're kind of checking into all of that. And then, of course, the county assessor's office and the tax collectors are looking at the tax exemption process for the Board of Equalization and making sure all that paperwork is filed. So that's what they have to do.

42:44 And ultimately, you know, what they're doing is they're getting in there and they're looking at all the tenant files. They're making sure that the residents that are there income qualify and meet the requirements of the state law that allows for the tax exemption. And that becomes basically their main job is to make sure those files are in really good order and that there's no issues with our tax exemption. And a tax exemption mistake can be very expensive. You know, if you assess this property at market value, that might be a $2,000 or $3,000 bill that shows up if a resident.

43:14 Has failed to qualify for the tax exemption. So it's something that has to be paid attention to. So I'm going to stop there because I gave you a lot. And, you know, I think I'll just say one last thing is that, you know, what is the main general partner typically get paid for on, you know, for providing all these services? And the answer is, is that the tax exemption itself is about $100 per unit per year.

43:41 So call it $8,000 on this particular project that they get paid on an annual basis. Usually at the start of construction, closing of the financing, we tend to pay them between $25,000 and $35,000 kind of one-time payment as a small piece of the development earnings that kind of covers their startup costs and just gets them situated. And we also pay their legal bill.

44:07 Which tends to be about $15,000 to $20,000 is kind of the average for that. And then, you know, for services, they will tend to get paid anywhere from like, you know, $10,000 per year to $15,000 per year, probably depending on the size of the project. And I'm just, you know, kind of giving you guys a data dump so you know the metrics that, you know, we play with and that we work with. So I'll stop there for some questions before we hit the last relevant slide on property management and services.

44:37 Which a lot of it I've already covered, but anyways, I'll stop there, Kurt, for some questions if needed. The only thing I could add real quick, thanks, Caleb, that was really thorough, is that we'll go into the property management portion in the next slide, but I think one of the really misleading portions of the managing general partner is the managing part of the name, because it really has nothing to do with management of the property.

45:06 So we'll talk about property management next, but this really has, the role of the managing general partner, it has nothing to do with managing the property. So I just wanted to be clear on that. Yep. Good point. Yeah, the name is a little bit of a, you know, the only reason it's called a managing general partner is it's state, it's state nomenclature in a limited partnership agreement. I mean, this exemption really is for

45:30 You know, non-profit organizations. And so the exception that they make for this property tax exemption, it's called the welfare exemption officially, is that the non-profit organization has to, quote, be the managing general partner when it's a limited partnership. And all these projects are structured as a limited partnership so that there's room for that investor to come in. And this is the provision under state law that, you know, has them be, quote, a managing general partner, even though, and what they do under the agreement, just so there's clarity from a legal point of view.

45:58 Is there allowed to delegate the duties of a managing general partner to us as the administrative general partner? So the state said, hey, you got to do these 20 things as part of your process to be the official nonprofit to get the tax exemption, but you're allowed to then delegate those to folks that perform the services, and that typically is us. It could be the developer, Pacific West Communities, which is us. It could be us as the administrative general partner, but they're allowed to delegate a certain number of those duties to us.

46:27 And that's what they do. And, you know, to the extent you guys ever want to see a partnership agreement, that's in the partnership agreement, actually, each time. So, okay, well, that's all good. So let's just move on to the next slide and talk about property management. So I think this is important to know is that, you know, it's not plug and play property management. It's got to be an experienced property manager that under California's programs now have to have 11 projects over three years.

46:57 of which some have to be California tax credit projects. So there's that kind of fundamental requirement. They've got to be in good standing with the state. They can't have any big compliance issues, meaning like if they're having a bunch of findings from the state, meaning the California Tax Credit Allocation Committee that allocates these credits to us or any of the other agencies, funders, et cetera, you know, they have problems. They have to disclose those defaults and problems.

47:23 It often can lead to not getting funded. So experienced property management is very important to this level to qualify for the points to get funded in the first place. And what do they do? You know, day-to-day marketing and lease up of the assets. This is what's typical. They got to income qualify all the residents and make sure all that paperwork, which is probably a huge, that's at least the 40% of the work is really, you know, working with the residents.

47:50 Getting their third-party verifications to make sure they make the right amount of money to qualify. Just dealing with that paperwork because anything that's out of compliance results in a loss of our tax credits. And that's really a fatal blow to the project in the sense that you lose credits on a unit, you not only have a bad reputation, but the investors that suffered that loss of credits, you potentially can put the project in jeopardy financially.

48:16 And we have to guarantee that loss of credits, by the way, if it ever happens, you know, we have to step up and guarantee that. We also make the property management company guarantee that too. So that's the big issue there. They hire the property managers, I mean the on-site staff. So like that's the person that lives on site, works on site, you know, the office folks, as well as the maintenance team. And they obviously oversee and supervise all of those employees of theirs to make sure the assets look good.

48:43 The residents are taken care of. You know, of course, they deal with, you know, any issues that residents have. And I'm speaking to what's normal and what should be happening at all times. And, you know, they'll often, you know, have to work with, you know, a local government agency or, you know, this case, Atlantic Housing to administer a waiting list. So when they talk about who's coming into the property, then they got to go work with those teams. They report to our asset management team. They also report to other

49:12 Funders of the project, lenders, investors, etc. And, you know, basically a whole host of duties that are really operational in nature and are required for, you know, being compliant with the program requirements as well as what we say is important as an owner of these properties to make sure we stay in good standing. If they fail, if there's problems with them, it blows back on us. That's the bottom line.

49:39 So we often, you know, we want to hear about issues and be involved in dealing with anything, and our asset management staff, you know, here really works with them directly to make sure everything's in order. But that's what they do, and, you know, it's possible, I think, with you guys and Mammoth Lake Housing, at least over the years when we've been working together, you know, I think some of the things that Patricia has mentioned were really accurate is that you guys have been a great local partner in this way.

50:08 You've gotten involved, as I understand it, in various, you know, issues or helping residents with different things if they've got a management company issue. Now, those, I would just say, are extraordinary. They're not the normal thing. We normally don't have a Mammoth Lakes housing or another partner at the local level to help us with any of that. Mostly what happens is, you know, the management companies deal with that or, you know, if it's really not getting handled, what often happens is they're going to complain to a council member.

50:35 Or, you know, some other government official about, you know, the dissatisfaction they have. I'm talking about a resident. And then, you know, that makes its way to us generally. And we don't like it when that happens because that's not okay. You know, that residents' issues should be resolved. And if they're not resolved, then we should be hearing about them first and foremost and dealing with performance of the property management company specifically. But from time to time, it is very true.

51:00 That we find ourselves, you know, engaged with property management or resident directly on an issue where they're not satisfied. That's just part of the part of business. So that's on property management. Do you guys have any questions on any of that before I go on to services, just to finish up? Yeah, I got a couple of quick questions, Cale. On the, so you got the.

51:26 The managing general partner, so speaking specifically to this project, that's a different entity from the property, who you would anticipate to be the property manager? Was it Buckingham or somebody I think is the name? Yeah, Buckingham. Yeah, Buckingham Property Management. They're who we've proposed, I think, so far, in that they have a base of operations there. I mean, Mammoth being remote like it is.

51:55 It's not like, you know, everyone's looking to come to Mammoth to do one project. And so that's one of the challenges of being so remote. So we have Buckingham Property Management slated, I believe, for the first phase of the project at the parcel. We have another good property management company that we work with up in Truckee, which I'm sure, you know, would be interested in coming down. I think it's about critical mass.

52:20 You know, when you talk about anyone coming down to Mammoth, and so we have what we have there. We also have a property in Bishop. And I think we'd probably, if we brought in another management agent, we'd probably be giving them those properties too, more than likely. And so, you know, we try not to take properties from our management agents too often. You know, we try to be respectful of their business and, you know, make sure that we're not just flipping properties here and there. But yeah, that's right. Buckingham Property Management for the on-site management we're talking about on this slide.

52:50 And then Central Valley Coalition as the managing general partner, which, you know, like Andrea kind of pointed out, nothing to do with managing property per se. Go ahead, Tony. So the property manager is basically a consultant and not a partner? Right. Yeah, they're an agent. So they're like a hired agent to run the asset and they're not a partner in the project. That's not to say there are some companies that self-manage, that they're like us, let's say that they both develop.

53:19 And own and manage. That is not how our company works. We are too diverse. Our portfolio is too big, too spread out. So we don't manage any of our assets. We hire property management agents to do that. We have about 25 different ones we work with as our portfolio over the western U.S. So that's the program. They're an agent that we hire. And incidentally, they've got, you know, the limited partner can demand their firing.

53:45 Like, if they're not satisfied with the performance of the management agent, they can demand they be fired. Sometimes the town or city government will have a provision under the loan agreements that they have to remove the property management agent if they're not satisfied. It's a 30-day, terminable kind of deal. And, you know, we don't exercise that willy-nilly, but the truth of it is, is if we're dissatisfied, it's not a long-term marriage for sure. And they can be, you know, they can be terminated and the new agent can be brought in.

54:14 It's very disruptive to the property when that happens, but we have had to do it before. And it's the administrative general partner who pays for the project management? The project operations pay for the management agent's fees. And so the rental income that's generated from the building, right, pays all the bills, pays the utilities, pays the maintenance, pays snow removal, pays everything. And inside of those expenses is a fee to the property management agent.

54:42 And so it's part of the operations of the project. That's how they get paid. Also, their staff is paid for. So the on-site property manager, that's also paid for out of the project budget each year, as well as benefits, whatever benefits they might have. If there's compliance fees, those are paid. So pretty much full operations of the property get covered out of that budget that's constituted each year. Great, thanks. Yeah.

55:10 Caleb, so on the managing general partner in this ownership structure, are they paid some sort of a fee for their participation? Yeah, they are. That's that $100 a unit per year that I mentioned earlier, $8,000 in this example, $8,100 actually for 81 units. They are paid that fee. And, you know, usually it's kind of like, I mean, $8,100.

55:40 is not a lot of money in my view, right? It's just not. But if you do it at scale, I mean, Central Valley Coalition, for example, has over 15,000 units of ownership where they are mainly internal partner. And so at scale, they have all the systems in place, all the, you know, the forms and the processes. They know every county processor pretty much and, you know, have a very efficient system. And so they're able to keep their per unit cost pretty low.

56:07 For managing, for providing those property tax exemption services. But that is what they get paid. And then there's, you know, usually like a $25,000 to $35,000 upfront fee that we pay them at the start of construction as well, plus cover their legal. That's kind of the compensation that they earn for this service of the managing general partner tax exemption. And that doesn't include supportive services. Services are a separate bucket.

56:31 And that's that kind of $10,000 to $15,000 range, you know, per property that they typically will get paid. And so if I may jump in, sorry, I just wanted to point out two things because there's a lot of terminology like Andrea mentioned that doesn't, it's not what we would all think, right?

56:54 This piece, the managing general partner at closing doesn't seem like that big of a deal, right? They go through and they're scrutinized by the lenders. They go through the underwriting process. But to be clear for, you know, anyone on the call, I mean, Tom, you've probably closed deals before. It gets a little bit hectic and there's a couple attorneys on the line that are just going through their underwriting issues. These deals generally have 10 to 20.

57:20 Attorneys on the calls during those closings. And I say that because I work a lot with market rate as well as affordable developers. And some of those who do cross over, I mean, Caleb's been doing this and he does 20 deals a year, but some of those market rate developers who cross over and do an affordable deal, this piece makes them crazy, right? I mean, this piece causes them

57:43 Enormous. They get very uncomfortable with the amount of scrutiny that is on these affordable deals, mostly from the limited partner, but also when there's so many public agencies involved. So although this seems pretty much standard and sort of status quo, I just want to be really clear that it's a drill and there's a lot of risk that all parties take on as they're being scrutinized and having to meet deadlines to close.

58:12 So I wanted to point that out. And then the other thing, just to clarify on the property management piece, I think Buckingham and Andrea Caleb could certainly confirm, came into Mammoth Lakes initially with a tax credit project prior to the Pacific companies. And so when the Pacific companies came in back in 03 and 04, we had to figure out who was able to come to this rural community that had the experience TCAC required. And so that's how

58:41 That's how kind of Buckingham came to the table, you know, going back into history. Yeah, that's right. I would just add a couple things. One is, you know, Kayla talked about the fees that are paid to managing general partner, and Mammoth Lakes Housing in the previous two projects did not receive those fees either for doing the annual property tax exemption. Mammoth Lakes Housing was never intended to be able to serve that role.

59:11 on those previous deals and were not with the comps. And for that, nor were they paid any other fees for being managing general partner. The goal was to be able to get the experience as managing general partner to be able to do tax credit projects as in the nonprofit set aside and to serve as the sole managing general partner in the future. So the things that Kayla mentioned that have been

59:38 The compensation that goes to managing general partner in the previous two deals has now been paid to Mammoth Lakes Housing. Now, Mammoth Lakes Housing previously in those deals, because they were a co-developer, had negotiated a portion of the developer fee, which is much different and outside of this managing general partner role or the property management role or supportive services. Mammoth Lakes Housing truly served in a development partnership role and then negotiated a portion of the developer fee.

1:00:07 As a result of that. So that's very different than what we're looking at on the parcel unless Mammoth Lakes Housing wanted to come in as a development partner, which Patricia and I was talking just briefly that that was not the role. And then as far as property management goes, and Caleb can speak to this if you want, but we recently learned the role that Mammoth Lakes Housing has played in the

1:00:36 In property management, facilitating and helping Buckingham property management, and Martin in particular as the on-site property manager, we were, we did not know that Patricia was helping facilitate painting of units and, you know, really serving a much different role than what we would ever have expected. From our perspective, we thought that we were just looking for Mammoth Lakes Housing to help us fill the waiting list.

1:01:06 Go for the waiting list to the property manager. The property manager does the actual certification, which is required to make sure that we meet all the tax credit requirements, and then we move on. And we were completely unfamiliar with the additional work that Mammoth Lakes Housing was providing. So we're trying to figure out exactly where the breakdown is. Why isn't Buckingham providing that? If Mammoth Lakes Housing is providing it, should they be providing it as a factor to the property manager?

1:01:35 Or a co-property manager. And I think that for the existing properties and as we look forward, like we want to make sure that the community is served and that the units are filled and that everyone is being compensated accordingly. So to me, I see a breakdown that it's disturbing to like, I want to know, are we serving our community? And what I've learned over the past six months is that

1:02:03 No, we haven't been serving the community, and Mammoth Lakes Housing has been filling in the gap, and that bothers them to me. Like, we want to know where their breakdown is, and we want to make sure that we're serving the needs of residents and the needs of our property, and that we're being a good community partner. And I just say, though, with all that, it's like, I mean, the property management company is probably very grateful for the help. You know, whatever you guys have been doing, you know.

1:02:31 Unbeknownst to us, that we're learning about. I mean, I'm sure they're quite happy. Like, great. Mammoth Lakes is willing to do that? Awesome. Why? I mean, like, that's wonderful. There's a partner. I mean, it would be the same as if we decided to help them do it. So, you know, and you know how it is, right? If you take on something and you take care of somebody that way and they like it and they're going to keep letting you do it. And so, you know, I think if that's going to continue, to me, that's either, well, that's either one, shall not continue.

1:02:59 Or if it's going to continue, you know, MLH needs to be compensated for it, in my view. And that's a conversation to have with our management agent about that very subject. Because maybe, you know, maybe with a remote location and the local presence, you know, it's better that Mammoth Lakes Housing do that work and maintain that interface with the residents in a way that is better for them in a more extensive way than is a typical sort of waiting list management provider.

1:03:28 Which is really basic and more just taking care of, you know, making referrals come to the property. So we're, you know, we're very open to not only this going forward, but also to the historical projects that have been done. And, you know, that's where I think Patricia's help would come into, like, understanding that. And then, you know, that would spur that conversation with our management agents there on the ground. Because it's not easy to, you know, keep...

1:03:53 Keep people employed in a town like this. And I think it's very relevant. So, you know, your leverage there might be really good. So, that's all that. And then I think the services, just real quick touch on that. You know, you see them on the screen there. There's nothing, you know, really magic that I can say in addition to what I've already said. This is a requirement of the state now. One of the things that often is done, and this could be an area, by the way, where

1:04:22 You know, Mammoth Lakes Housing could potentially have a role, as an example. You know, would it be possible for, you know, you're not, you know, I don't think MLH can be, quote, a qualified service provider, per se, at this point, but there's nothing that says that some of these services could be subcontracted from Central Valley to Mammoth Lakes Housing. You know, maybe there are things you're doing in the community, like homeownership counseling would be one of them. I could think of, you know, off the top of my head, just real quickly.

1:04:49 Mammoth Lakes Housing has had a goal placing people in homes and working outside of the housing sector. Okay, that might be a great thing to come in once or twice a year and okay, time for another homeownership counseling session and here's a class on it and here's the things to pay attention to as you renters want to maybe move to that. Okay, so that's an example of an idea, you know, that's connected to the services component. But these are the hours that have to be delivered.

1:05:18 This is basically the budget. And, you know, we try to design the services, you know, working with the resident community to figure out what they care about and what they need. Sometimes they don't care about different things that we think they ought to care about, and they've got a whole agenda of their own. And so we try to survey the residents, not us, but the managing general partner service provider will survey the residents and sort of figure that out. So that kind of completes, I think, like,

1:05:47 Everything on our end of it, as far as, you know, what's going on, the property management, the roles, the services, and then the last really section was to kind of, you know, we thought we just kind of put a list together of, you know, this is just our limited perspective of what, you know, how we see Mammoth Lake housing, possible roles that could be played. You know, this isn't meant to be an, you know, exclusive list. I mean, if there's other ideas here, we're very open to them.

1:06:15 Ultimately, we see Mammoth Lakes Housing as a partner in the effort to deliver housing to the community, and we want to help support that. We want to do whatever we need to do to be a great partner to the town, to MLH and others, to see that the housing gets delivered and the people get served. That's the bottom line.

1:06:34 I don't know if we want to go through these individually, Sheldon or Andrea, if you had anything specific you wanted to call out, but, you know, really we're just here to kind of start the dialogue with you guys and find out what it is, what your ambitions are, what you want to do, and how you want to move forward. And then that's really, I think, the key to this meeting tonight. So, do you guys have anything, ladies, you want to bring up in addition to what I'm saying? So, just really quick, just because I see Supervisor Kreitz obviously is on the call, and just to jump back to supportive services.

1:07:02 You know, this project does have a source of funds called No Place Like Home, we call it NPLH, and what that means is there'll be a high-needs population that are either suffering mental health or formerly homeless that'll be housed about eight units on site, and so there's a set of supportive services that go along with those units that is separate from the required tax credit supportive services. So there's two sets of services that'll be offered on site, and there'll be a lot of eyes on the prize.

1:07:32 with the Health and Human Services offices there. And then additionally, you know, this piece here, phase one, on-site child care may qualify for a portion of the services. In addition to having these adult education and kind of financial fitness classes, that sort of stuff, you can also get your supportive services points by having on-site child care if it serves.

1:07:55 The community in a certain way. We have not gone there yet. It could occur here, but we're really trying to let Amanga and the county get their service program for daycare. And then if it happens to fit through, you know, fit the requirements of supportive services, then that's what we'll use. And if it doesn't, we'll go back to the typical TCAC. I just wanted to clarify that because there's kind of, you know, a little bit of a moving part there, but we're excited that we have the option.

1:08:22 This one, you know, this affordable homeownership and advocacy for funding and the master plan that I spoke about at the beginning, you know, the project, the 25 acres is primarily rental housing, but there's a lot of room for ownership opportunity and opportunities to serve families that are over the 80% income mark. And so that is an incredibly difficult gap.

1:08:47 to fill for those units, those units that aren't qualified for low income housing tax credits, but yet the market, you know, you can't build them and rent or sell them for a price that families at say 100 or 120% of AMI can afford. So there has been some talk and, you know, local leadership, I'm sure knows way more about this than me, but there's certainly been some talk in the needs assessment of ways to fundraise throughout the community to sort of help.

1:09:12 Help solve that puzzle and help fill that gap for affordable homeownership. And we certainly, we certainly feel that's a huge need. I don't know if that's in, you know, as a desire or anything of Mammoth Lakes Housing, that's just something that we see is, has a lot of, you know, there's a good opportunity there for somebody who wants to sort of leave that charge. So that's all I wanted to add. Yeah, thanks. Sheldon, I was actually, that's an area that I think we're very focused on.

1:09:47 You know, that missing middle funding. And just to be clear to everybody, you know, there's this, at present, state and federal level, there's no, you know, programs out there for that. So it's really got to be locally funded to fill that gap. And, you know, that's where the rubber's going to meet the road. And I think, you know, there's a big segment, you know, significant segment of our community of our year-round residents.

1:10:16 Who, you know, have that desire to have ownership, but are going to need to be subsidized. And it's something that we need to start making movement on sooner than later to get the funding built up to have those funds available in a timely fashion such that specific companies can be assured that they can move forward with a project to fulfill that need.

1:10:45 You know, well in advance, right? That that money's there to support it and to fund that. But, you know, I guess, and correct me if I'm wrong, Caleb, but I think, you know, as you guys go through this, you're going to go through this as efficiently and as quickly as possible as far as building out the parcel, right? So, you know, if, and I understand that, you know, likely like this idea of the homeownership phase might be the last phase to go in or it'll be a later phase, but, you know, the fund's got to be.

1:11:13 The money needs to be set aside and a significant amount, right, to come up to those, whatever that gap's going to be. So, you know, I think it might be helpful for, you know, to whatever level you guys could provide some modeling of that and say, okay, hey, if we were going to do 28 townhomes, duplex townhomes for home ownership in phase five, this is what you're looking at in today's dollars. You would have to come up with this amount of money. I think that would be helpful just so that

1:11:43 And, you know, we're definitely, you know, I think this is definitely a role for Mammoth Lakes Housing to play as far as advocacy goes on the political side with our community that we've got to get serious about putting money away for this if we want to do it. Otherwise, you guys aren't going to wait for us and you'll go ahead and finish it out on the LIHTC level. But, you know, it's a missed opportunity and we don't have a lot of other, you know, at least at present, we don't have any other.

1:12:11 You know, near-term opportunities to create this type of a product. So, in any event, I just, you know, it's a long, long conversation, but it's going to take a lot of political will on our community side to start to figure this out. We are actually going to start those discussions here. In fact, there's some calls scheduled later in the week to talk about a little bit. So, but I think it would be maybe helpful, you know, to the extent that you could say, hey, you know what, you figure, you know, for

1:12:41 Whatever, let's, like I said, the example of the 28 three-bedroom townhouse, duplex townhouses, you know, I just think of a product that would probably fill that need. What would that look like? What would that be? How much would we need to actually come up with as a community to help subsidize that from a development perspective? So that's good, Tom. And also just add that there's, we've at least heard some preliminary expressions of interest of not waiting till the end to do the homeownership. And one of the benefits of the, you know, there's a chance,

1:13:11 Just to kind of maybe launch a little bit earlier on that, one of the nice things about the homeownership units, even though they're harder to finance, we also don't have to wait for the funding rounds that, you know, typically with tax credits, you know, you don't get funded, you got to wait, miss a building season. So, you know, and the infrastructure that we are going to do, even as part of phase one, would be sufficient to start the low density construction, let's say, kind of on the east side of the parcel.

1:13:39 near the Shady Rest subdivision, as an example. We could be able to do some of the, you know, some of that lower density stuff up against that existing subdivision. So we are actually contemplating working on this sooner than we originally proposed. And we'd love to, you know, work with you guys and figure that out and start putting some models together to anticipate what's needed for gap financing and how we could go about solving for it.

1:14:09 Yeah, that's great. That's great. And, you know, the brokerage side of it, there's an opportunity there for some commissions. And, you know, I think that's, that would definitely be a good area for us to focus on. I mean, one thing that would be very helpful just to complete this conversation about that is, you know, where do you guys see the need? You know, where is it that you see the biggest, the gap in what the market's providing versus what, you know, you are?

1:14:37 Obviously, the rental side kind of cuts everybody out. But then, you know, I think with your company in particular, you know, you guys have a real good pulse about your employment base and what's happening with them and where are they living and where's their housing solutions being found currently. And that would kind of help us in establishing price points for what truly is affordable workforce housing for the community. And, you know, I'm thinking in particular, you know, folks that work in the mountains.

1:15:04 You know, any kind of feedback like that would be helpful because we are going to show up with, you know, theoretically free land, theoretically free infrastructure, right? So, you know, we have a chance to have kind of a, you know, base and base out of the way of major costs that typically as development would need to incur. And, you know, we're probably still not there yet, but then throw in some fees and, you know, what other subsidies would be needed potentially to get home? You know, so I just, I see it as an opportunity. So as soon as you guys feel like you can start helping us work on that as MLH.

1:15:34 Or the amount, you know, great with us. We'll tee it up and start programming. That's great. So that gives us something to chew on, for sure. And just an aside, I mean, we conduct an employee engagement survey annually, you know, with our employees. We just finished that. And there were a lot of anecdotal comments by our year-round employees that, hey, you know, we want an opportunity to have homeownership, but we don't see where that's coming from. How's that going to be solved?

1:16:06 And I think it's something I can dig into the data and mine that up a little bit and get some more pragmatic results to that to define those income levels and those needs to speak to that more specifically, at least from the standpoint of the ski area. Yeah, that'd be great. Yeah, so that's great. It's great to hear that feedback and direction. I think that's very helpful. Thanks for all the info. I just had a couple questions for the supportive services.

1:16:37 That would be conducted by Central Valley Coalition. Is that primarily online since it's not a local agency that would be providing these services? No, it is. It is actually on site and they haven't, you know, kind of in the era of COVID, I think there's the state's probably opening up some more flexible ideas there.

1:17:06 for online opportunities, but traditionally, pre-COVID, it's on-site meetings that happen on the property or a community center nearby, and it's a combination of their staff that will come in and actually do the classes or do the education or whatever the service is, but it's also working with a network of providers where they are, where these providers do exist.

1:17:33 And bringing them in. So, for example, if there is somebody, you know, in job training that is locally there that can be brought in to do a class, do an education seminar, whatever, maybe a series, then they will coordinate that and facilitate that. Sometimes they don't have to come to the site. Sometimes it'll be like, work with the management company. Hey, you know, the college is going to show up on this day to do a two-hour class about what do you got to do to prepare for college.

1:18:00 You know, like that would be an example, you know, of a sort of an adult education type class. So, you know, it's not, it's not, there really isn't a lot of rigidity to it. And I think online options are now more available and maybe will be available in the future, but there's a lot of variety and flexibility with this. It just has to be for the hours specified. That's kind of the key. Great. I just, I appreciate all the information. It helps me understand the,

1:18:30 The structure of the partnership better, but I still really don't understand why we weren't being chosen as the managing general partner. It seems like there's a lot of overlap between the managing general partner's role and the supportive services and even the project management role. We can coordinate a lot of that stuff and we did.

1:18:57 Essentially an internship with you guys to be qualified to do it. So I think we should reopen the discussion about bringing us in as managing general partner. And if not, we really need to tie down, we need to negotiate maybe a contract or something and talk specifically about what our role is going to be and how we would be compensated for it because

1:19:28 We're a community advocacy organization and we're eager to jump in and help the community as needed, but it's not sustainable for us to just jump in wherever it's needed and it's not sustainable for the community and it's not sustainable for the town. Everyone's going to end up waiting longer and paying more. So, like I said, I think we should reopen that dialogue and see.

1:19:57 what our role could be. I think one of the slides on the structure said that it could be a shared, the managing general partner could be a shared position. So maybe that could be partially the Central Valley Coalition and partially us and we divide the roles and responsibilities between the two organizations or otherwise really define.

1:20:25 What we're going to be doing and how we're going to be compensated for it before the time comes that we're just jumping into it. Yeah, I think that's all good, Tony. And, you know, that's kind of, I think, what we hope the purpose of this conversation would be, was to sort of figure out what you guys were interested in, what you wanted to do. You know, kind of like, we haven't, of course, had any detailed conversations with Central Valley on any of this, but...

1:20:52 Given the location of the town of Mammoth Lakes in their world, it's pretty remote. And obviously, any kind of local support like that, I'm sure would be a welcome conversation. We'll certainly have it together with you and also on the property management side. So I accept all that and look forward to the continued conversation about it for sure. Great. Thanks a lot. Yeah. Hi, this is Lindsay. Thank you guys again for your time.

1:21:24 And the information, like Tony said, I also, like Tony, have some questions about the nonprofit general managing partner. And having, for our community, having people who are more on site, more familiar with our community, like you said, Caleb, we're remote, we're, you know, unique in our base here.

1:21:50 And I guess, yeah, I would love to, while we have you, talk a little bit more about the decision that you came to. It sounds like you've come to the decision to have the Central Valley Coalition to not have Mammoth Lakes Housing be that nonprofit managing general partner. And like Tony said, is that something we can continue to talk about and have Mammoth Lakes Housing be that managing partner? Yeah, so no, I think just the thing to know at this point is,

1:22:20 It's still way early in terms of like what we can do. So I mean, you know, as far as like what we can do going forward, I mean, really the key role for the managing general partner really lives at completion of the project. So ideally, you know, you'd like your managing general partner or partners to be specified prior to the start of construction and close the financing, let's say. And usually, you know, if we got a financing award, it's usually four to six months before we have a closing. So there is an opportunity now.

1:22:49 To, like, kind of have those discussions and figure out if this is something you guys want to do. I mean, we pretty much, you know, we were really in a pretty big rush to try to get the Parcel's first application tried in the door, right? We were just like, okay, hey, you know, we didn't have any conversations with MLH. We didn't really know, like, could you guys even do the managing general partner duties? You know, we certainly knew you're a local great partner. We just didn't know.

1:23:16 You know, do you have the qualified exemption status? Do you have the criteria met with the state, the county? You know, all those things we were unaware of, and, you know, we're moving at such a torrid pace to kind of catch the building season. You know, we know that there's plug-and-play opportunities to happen later post, you know, post-award of funding. And so, you know, I'm sorry to take a long...

1:23:38 The answer to your question, but that is the answer is like there's still opportunity to have the conversation to you guys participate if that's the will of the board and you know the town's fine with it and all that. That's good news. That's great to hear. Thank you. Because I think for us, you know, what I've heard from staff speaking to their interest to be involved in this role and just as our community to have somebody

1:24:08 here in Mammoth, super knowledgeable about the project, but also about our people and what they need and being able to help in that way seems like it would make a lot of sense. So, yeah, I don't know what else we can answer for you tonight while we have you.

1:24:40 The cost and the burden of being a managing general partner or a co-managing general partner does not preclude MLTPA housing from, like, actively participating in the project. So, for example, you know, are you, from a property management perspective, providing services that a property management company would normally do? And should Buckingham say, like, yes, MLTPA housing is doing these things for us and the three of us, you know, as an owner?

1:25:10 Buckingham and Mammoth Lakes Housing say, look, this Mammoth Lakes Housing is doing services, are they a co-property manager? Should we be paying them for translation services? What is that role? Like, you can do that without being a managing general partner. It's a 0.05% owner, like, and could you provide supportive services without being a managing general partner and going through the regular role of closing and having an attorney and going through all of that?

1:25:39 Yes, you can. Like, I would argue that, and, you know, and Patricia expressed to me that you all feel like as having that ownership role, there's a certain community responsibility, but I would say that you can, as an organization, continue to serve the community and continue to do the things that you're doing and more without actually being a managing general partner.

1:26:08 That role, that ownership role, particularly because at least I would argue that for this first phase and probably future phase, we would just have a, we would put you in as a co-managing general partner until we really felt secure that we weren't at risk with that, you know, income qualification and annual certification for the Board of Equalization, and I apologize for my children in the background, but

1:26:38 That, like, you can do all of those things without being a managing general partner. And, I mean, it will take Patricia's time. It will take an attorney. It will take an investment. And I guess the question I would ask is, we're happy to have you along for the ride in that co-MGP role for this first phase. But I would ask you as an organization to discuss the pros and cons of why.

1:27:05 And what is it that you want to achieve? What role do you want to play? And then how do you achieve that role? Is it supportive services? Is it, you know, the co-property management role that you've been playing? Is it, you know, the community waiting list? What is that role? And how do we best achieve it with the least amount of brain damage and expense to Mammoth Lakes Housing? Yeah.

1:27:37 Thank you. We do, as an organization, need to be able to answer those questions. I think from my end, we talk a lot in our organization about adding more to our staff without being able to add additional staff members because we don't have enough funding coming in. And so while the $8,100 for this position

1:28:06 Doesn't seem like a huge number. When we add that up with other funding sources that we can have, that becomes an additional staff member. So I think, yeah, while there is some brain damage, headache, things that go along with that role, I think being able to pull in some of that income from the role could help us. But I also think, well, and I guess if you guys could answer well about the Central Valley Coalition,

1:28:34 And Buckingham, who is actually in Mammoth physically on a regular basis with a door that's open for people to walk in? I think some of the tenants, people that we work with already who are not tech savvy, maybe don't have internet, maybe don't have computers, prefer to have face-to-face interactions. How is that role filled currently in the setup that you are looking at? So Caleb, if you want to jump in or you want me to take it?

1:29:06 You can take it. It's fine. I mean, you know, I think, I guess, I guess how I look at things is to kind of go towards what's best for your organization, you know, to do and to perform at and not get jammed up on, right? Like, whatever commitments you guys sign up for, I think it's just important that you feel confident with your staff that you're committed to that you can perform them and not put them in a spot where they're uncomfortable. I mean, you know.

1:29:35 Honestly, the organization back when we did our first project back in the day was really more of a development organization than it was, you know, the services you guys provide now. It's a completely different set of commitments that you guys are in. So I think with anything, and you can take a challenge, but I just think with anything, it's really just like you guys feel comfortable with the commitments. Usually we look at things as kind of like long term.

1:29:59 You know, it's not like kind of in and out. It doesn't mean it has to always be that way, but I think, you know, from your guys' perspective, long-range planning, it should be like, this is the organization we are, this is what we're committed to, this is what we're going to do for the community, you know. Go ahead, Sheldon, sorry. Yeah, no, it's a good point, but I think to answer your question, Lindsay, the property manager is not the managing general partner, the property manager is required to hire and fire.

1:30:24 Any of the on-site maintenance and on-site resident manager. So, and Caleb spoke to this earlier, but, you know, just to kind of reiterate, you know, in the event that either the property management company isn't working based on our, you know, TPC's asset management or limited partner's desires, or in the event the property

1:30:46 Manager individual, right? And in an 81 unit development, it's just one required unit to be an onsite resident manager. Isn't meeting their needs, you know, we as the owner, if we as the owner hear about it, we have an ability to talk to the property manager to try to make changes. Now, again, as Caleb mentioned, that's not something that we ever like to get involved with, but it certainly happens. And so at the end of the day, the property manager is

1:31:15 Charged with hiring the resident manager and any of the additional maintenance type of stuff. So, you know, like in the existing properties, I know Patricia knows staff very well and they're hired, they work for Buckingham Property Management. So that's who you walk in the doors to, if you will. Perfect. Thank you. And then for as far as that nonprofit general managing partner role, do they, is there a need for

1:31:45 Residents to contact them, or is that really taken care of by that local property manager? The latter. I mean, I would say, you know, to Andrew's point and to Caleb's point, this managing general partner is a legal entity that helps us get our tax, you know, helps all, it's not just the Pacific companies. This is a structure that you're looking at on your screen that, you know, all tax credit developments throughout the country pretty much followed to some.

1:32:14 To some extent. So this role in California is primarily to be at the table at closing, to ensure that we get the exemption, the land exemption status. Very rarely does this managing general partner have a lot, I mean, Caleb, you can correct me if I'm wrong, but have a lot of interface with residents or interface with, you know, the lease-up process, unless it happens to also be the property manager, which there are situations where that occurs, but not always. Yeah, that's not right.

1:32:45 And then with the managing general partner, how much follow-up is there? Like you said, they need to be on board to be able to access the tax credits. How much role then do they play on an everyday basis going forward after the project has been completed and closed? Just they basically, and we're going to speak in the context of where you have a sponsor like us that knows the

1:33:16 You know, the industry very well and knows how to do everything. They're going to have pretty minimal interaction, honestly. I mean, they're going to, like, the MDP, Central Valley will visit the site once a quarter, you know, so they'll come out, they'll do those visits, and I'm keeping the services out of the equation for the moment when they also provide that because it's not necessarily typical with all MDPs, but they'll visit the site once a quarter and they'll...

1:33:44 Kind of audit the files in a big way once a year. They'll kind of spot check the files once a quarter when they do their site visits. And that's pretty much it. Of course, if there's an issue that comes up, they'll get involved in an issue. Let's say there's some kind of major complaint. Let's say there's litigation or whatever.

1:34:07 You know, going to be served as a defendant in a lawsuit, let's say, that's a possibility. They're the registered agent for service process, right, as an example. So they'll say, I mean, how that goes is like, hey, there's a lawsuit, here you go, Caleb, take it, is pretty much the way it's always gone. So, you know, slip and fall from a resident, I mean, who knows, right, anything that could come up.

1:34:31 So it's really not a heavy-duty role. It's really just the annual visit, quarterly visits, the annual audit that happens, and that's pretty much it. That's all they really got to do. It's a technical role, though. Yeah, a technical role, for sure. They got to technically know what they're doing. It is critical, and there's a whole legal opinion that their attorney has to write that says they're qualified, they're in good standing, they know what they're doing.

1:35:00 It's a reliance, you know, an opinion that the lenders and investors rely upon. Like, this is an organization that knows how to do this and will properly audit the files in a way that, you know, the partnership and the stakeholders can feel secure. Thank you. That's a clear explanation. I appreciate it. If, so kind of the three roles with the supportive services, the MGP and the property manager, if Mammoth Lakes Housing,

1:35:33 Wanted really to move forward and say, gosh, we feel very confident that we could fulfill one, all some of these roles. What's your timeline needing to hear back from us on that? You know, you really have time. So I think we'll continue to sort of move down our financing path just the way we are with the parties specified as they are. But like if you needed, you know, a month or two months to get back to us.

1:36:03 Then that would be okay. I mean, if that's too fast. I mean, I think that it would be nice to know going in what you're thinking so that we could at least start the conversation with Central Valley, with Buckingham, with investors and lenders, because obviously as we move toward a funding award and startup construction, let's say, you know, we would want to

1:36:28 Mammoth Lakes Housing is a fairly inexperienced organization, the investors and lenders would say, from an affordable housing ownership perspective and doing the services. So I think it would just be critical that we, one, get the property management and the nonprofit on board, Central Valley on board, like, yeah, we're going to take these services or we're going to join the team or whatever. And then it's an investor-lender conversation, really, just to go, all right, you guys are comfortable. And they're not selected yet. Investors and lenders aren't selected yet for the project and won't be for some time.

1:36:56 So if you guys need it, I mean, what do you guys, you know, maybe let you guys can talk offline, but I would just say if you could get back to us within, you know, no later than 60 days with what you think you could do, then we can, you know, we can spin that into future conversations with the stakeholders. And really, you know, in all honesty, it'd be nice to have you in if you're going to be in at the close of the financing, which could be as early as July.

1:37:23 If we get funded, you know, or anticipate we're getting funded, but likely won't be that quick. So, you know, the worst case scenario, by the end of the project, the construction, that would be nice to have you in. We'll continue to have Central Valley as managing our partners, so it's not like we'll have a vacancy in our team that everyone will be worried about. Everybody's going to be fine, you know. And then also, I think the conversation applies to existing properties that are on the deck already.

1:37:50 That have been there for a while that you've been taken care of in whatever way you have. So there's kind of like two buckets, right? It's the existing properties on the ground versus, you know, what we're going to be doing going forward on the parcel. I have a question. Oops, sorry. Go ahead. I didn't mean to interrupt. And Lindsay, did you have any other questions? I'm sorry. Okay. So.

1:38:16 I sit on the California Coalition for Rural Housing Board, and we've been talking a lot about, we had a legislative committee meeting today, talking a lot about the proposal of $3 billion in HCD right now. They're looking at a possible $3 billion fund to kind of flush out all of the people waiting for 4% bonds and 9% that are shovel ready.

1:38:46 And just to kind of clean the slate there. And I wonder if you anticipate this project being, you know, possibly available for that funding. It sounds like that will be in the governor's May revise probably. Just your thoughts on that. Yeah, no, thanks for bringing that up. And that is the potential to unstick a lot of projects across.

1:39:08 That are really, you know, in that log dam. So yeah, absolutely. And we will be the shovelest ready as you can be. I mean, we're jumping the gun on plan, just, you know, kind of for the reason that hits the building season. We're going to be way ahead of all those projects in terms of readiness. So you bet, because we have that infill infrastructure grant money and the no place like home money, you know, thanks to you guys, those two funding mechanisms generate the possibility that we'd be eligible.

1:39:35 So we're really hopeful that they pull the trigger on that. So then that would make the project not a bond, a SIDLAC project, right? That would be a different kind of funding. And how does that impact this conversation we're having? I think, you know, obviously they'd have to roll out that program and, you know, tell us the rules, right? But basically, as I understand the proposal at the moment, it's essentially replaced tax credit equity.

1:40:03 Okay. That's what that fund would do. That's really what you need. Even when you're going for the bonds, you're really going for the bonds to get to the tax credit equity. And so it would replace that tax credit equity. And my guess is that would kind of mirror kind of what HDD has typically done with their programs, like MHP programs or whatever. So I think there could be some changes to our...

1:40:26 Our financing structure a little bit because we'd probably be looking at some of the state HCD rules that would now apply to this project. I don't think they changed our income targeting. I don't think they would, you know, do any of that. But I could see some of their overlay requirements kicking in, i.e., would prevailing wages apply to the entire project now, for example, where they do not necessarily apply to the whole project. Now, that could be one overlay requirement that kicks in.

1:40:52 But my guess is they might, you know, they might, okay, that kicked in, here's some more money to pay for that. You know, they might have a, you know, ability to be flexible in the amount of money that you, that you get for the project. So, you know, I hope it happens. I really do. I mean, it'd be a great win to see a lot of these projects happening, including this one. Okay, great. Yeah, there was discussion about it impacting developer fee potentially too, since that's tied to the ZIDLAC. And I mean, there's a lot of potential impacts. And so I just,

1:41:21 I'm sure you're thinking about those, should this be one of the ones that gets funded? And hopefully you'll keep us in the loop on that, because I think that could be pretty critical to this conversation. Yeah, it definitely takes off the table a lot of those experience requirements, you know, that we're talking about, potentially for at least the bonds and the credits and stuff. And it takes away a limited partner, too, quite frankly, is the other big change. And, you know, without limited partner gone, all of a sudden the...

1:41:47 You know, the game really changes. We do have a number of projects, by the way, that are financed without tax credits and bonds or 9% credits. And so it's, you know, it has been done before. We have a number of them. It actually works quite well, you know, and it would be a welcome change to this project if it happens. Thanks. Yeah, you're welcome. Thanks for bringing that up. That was great. Other questions? No, I just think it's going to be an interactive process to define.

1:42:25 Mammoth Lakes Housing's role in this, regardless of how we move forward. So hopefully we can schedule a meeting outside of this board meeting and work to really clearly define our role in this project and, like you said, in some of the other projects that we're already working on and get that sorted out interactively because you have a

1:42:51 Better understanding of what it takes and we have a better understanding of what we can do. So if we can schedule a meeting or something to get that figured out, then I'd be appreciated. That's great. Well, that's fine with us and we're ready to go whenever you guys are. So take your time you need to figure out your objectives and what you think you can be most helpful with and then get a list established, right, of commitments and duties and things that you feel comfortable executing on.

1:43:21 That'll serve as a basis to go the next steps. Thanks. The only thing I would add is that, you know, every phase can be different and it doesn't have to be the first one. It can be in the future and it can evolve and there's nothing that has to be hard for the first phase or for the future. It can change and funding will change, supportive services will change, requirements will change.

1:43:53 We can have this be evolutionary and it can change and we're open to the conversation always and should jump into development or whatever. It's all good. We're here to participate and have it include you to the extent that you want to be included in the way that you feel like you can add value.

1:44:17 I think that's great, and I think that that's the kind of spirit that we should all be embracing. Appreciate that. Further discussion? Kirk. Kirk, it's Patricia. I think I just want to reiterate some of the comments that were made, and then if there's no other questions or comments, we can move on to the next item, if that's okay? Yes. Okay, great. Thank you.

1:45:02 That was a really great presentation, and I just want to thank the Pacific companies for coming to our board meeting and participating in the conversation and trying to determine what the best role for our Mammoth Lakes Housing to play in the parcel is. And it's true, I think we heard that it's remarkable that we have Mammoth Lakes Housing in our remote rural community.

1:45:31 Here to support affordable housing developments and programs for homeownership among many of the other programs that we provide. And it's true that in such a remote rural location, we face a lot of unique challenges. Some of those challenges result in gaps. And Mammoth Lakes Housing has been filling some gaps.

1:46:02 And it'll be interesting to see how maybe another nonprofit general partner will be able to provide services in our remote location. And I guess I'll mention, you know, the property management gap. I think that you could ask any business or jurisdiction in Mono County how difficult it is to hire and retain good staff.

1:46:36 And so I know the daily struggles that our property management company faces in hiring and retaining staff to maintain the properties and to deal with our tenants and the problems that they may have. And that is the support that Mammoth Lakes Housing has been providing to help fill that gap. I would just say that

1:47:07 Maybe despite not having a large management role, the nonprofit partner really does have an asset management responsibility. And I think that when they visit the properties annually to check the files, I'm sure that they're checking the condition of the property and making sure that everything is in tip-top shape. And it's certainly a role that Mammoth Lakes Housing is equipped to provide.

1:47:36 The current service that we provide regarding the waiting list referrals is a service that the properties has been utilizing since they were constructed and occupied. And that service is not paid for by the development, but actually paid for through our contract with the town of Mammoth Lakes. And so, you know,

1:48:00 It's these types of services that we continue to provide to the community and a question of who is responsible and who is going to pay for the ongoing services that the community deserves. I think that if the managing general nonprofit role isn't a big role, then certainly we're well equipped to play a small role as the managing general nonprofit partner that our community deserves.

1:48:31 And I think especially if the land is going to be sold to the development, I mean, that's just another reason to have a local partner involved in the ownership to ensure the ongoing, you know, the ongoing stewardship of this really important community asset. I heard from the board and from Pacific companies that will try to convene

1:49:00 Staff level meeting regarding potential roles and responsibilities for Mammoth Lakes Housing in the next 60 days. And so I will work with, I will work to define some potential roles that we think that we can play and have the board take a look at those and then we can continue the conversation. Thank you Patricia. Do you have anything further?

1:49:33 No, that's all I have. I don't know if there's any other questions or comments, but that's it. I'm not seeing any raised hands or hearing any voices. It looks like Agnes. Hi. Thanks, everyone, for all of that. Just all really good points and notes. One thing I just want to quickly add is that there's all the things that Mammoth Access Housing has done.

1:50:05 And already does and can do. There's also the perception, there's also what the public in our community knows, and also what the community thinks, and some of those are different. And so I just want to point that out in all of this, because that's a factor that many people will come to Mammoth Lake Southern for things that aren't necessarily

1:50:34 And that's also what we're trying to match up. Thank you. Further discussion? Not hearing anything. I'll just say thanks for having us, you guys, and being a part of the meeting and everything, and good luck with all the thinking you're going to do, and we're available to help and get in there with you whenever you're ready, so. Thanks, you guys. Thank you, Caleb. Thank you, Shailen. Thank you, Andrea. It was great having you, and thanks for providing the presentation.

1:51:25 In time to publish the packet and being so thorough with the background is really informative, so I appreciate it. All right. Well, thank you. Sorry to take more than 15 minutes. Thanks so much. Thank you, guys. Bye-bye. Do we need to, as a board, kind of just formalize that direction? I think, Patricia, you kind of summarized it, but I'm just thinking whether...

1:52:06 It's something we would accomplish in the normal course of our board meetings. So it's April, so maybe in our May board meeting, you would come back and present sort of your first draft of the responsibilities that we could take on for board consideration and then defer to the committee who would then have the... You muted yourself, Tom.

1:52:37 Am I going to mute it that whole time? No, we heard you about staff direction and the committee to bring back, and then you went. I was just trying to get the time frame down as we conclude this agenda item. So, Patricia, you put together this draft list of the responsibilities you think we could take on, both as a non-profit managing general partner and or some level of property management responsibility.

1:53:07 Bring it back to the board at our May board meeting for the board to, on an agenda item for the board to consider, and then authorize the committee, which I think is, I think this was under the development committee, if I recall, at least previously Earl, we had talked about that, right? Didn't have the meeting with,

1:53:35 Pacific Company staff to have that further discussion that wouldn't be at a board meeting. Is that correct? Would that be the right approach? I think I would direct staff to work with Pacific companies and then come back to us with some recommendations maybe. Like maybe like three options or something or a few options. But I'd hate for staff to work on that outside of working with Pacific companies on what those things would be because it may...

1:54:04 Just to make sure that it's mutually kosher. I don't know what the right word is. Right, right. You know what I mean? I'm comfortable with that. So I just could, it sounds like, you know, it's a little bit time urgent. We don't want to waste any time here. So I think we need to kind of cut to the chasing. Well, yeah. Okay. It would be good to maybe get some, I mean, I guess.

1:54:36 I think generally the board is comfortable with all of the roles, it seems. The ones we already provide was, you know, general partner roles, which they explained were not very much to add on, but to us, obviously have a lot of value. So I guess, yes, if the board is in, has consensus around that, then I am certainly happy to work with specific companies too.

1:55:09 Figure out what is viable. That would be my preference. I think so. I think it sounded like the only thing that I would be skeptical of is the legal responsibilities of the managing general partner. So maybe if you can take some notes from what you gained out of this and start writing down some tasks, what you see our role from.

1:55:39 Managing general partner, property management, and other, the community outreach, they have the slide, what they saw as for community service, and define all those roles and what you'd like to see us doing, and I think it's gonna go beyond just managing general partner, and so once you get that defined, what you wanna do, I would be open to you.

1:56:10 Talking with them, with the developer about it, and coming back to the board, or if you need advice or want to talk about it with the committee, I'm not sure exactly if we have the committee formed, but if you need support from the board, then we can help you out with that as well. And I will just say on the attorney or the legal side, we have a great

1:56:40 Some of the best representation in the state with Goldfarb Lipman. And maybe you could get a price estimate from Raphael, our attorney there, on something of this nature, just so you have some information there to put into consideration. Yeah, and I'm not exactly sure which legal responsibilities we're talking about, but I have had conversations with our attorney about general managing nonprofit partner.

1:57:11 And as I know from looking at the pro forma for phase one, all of the legal fees are paid out of the development financing. And so even the fees of the nonprofit partner are paid out of the development. And so that's not an out-of-pocket expense for Mammoth Lakes Housing. I think it would be good to consider the fact that I think there's a high probability. I mean,

1:57:40 I don't know how great, but it seems pretty great that the governor is going to propose $3 billion in his May revise to fund, to clear the backlog of tax credit projects, including all the 4%, which this one's going after, has already applied for, because of, you know, just trying to, like I said, clear the backlog and get projects that are shoveled ready off.

1:58:07 And that really changes the conversation and maybe just start having a conversation too with them about, you know, if there's no LLC in that same, you know, that same tax credit investor structure, then what could we structure potentially? How could we structure a partnership outside of the tax credit scenario? Okay, excellent. Thank you for reminding me about that. Very good point. It sounded like

1:58:39 In the conventional structure that they were saying in this first phase at least that they really were just would consider us as a co-managed general partner and that they weren't really willing to put us in a full role of that because that's what I took away. That's partially my takeaway but that is essentially the role we currently play and it's not a role I would be interested in continuing if it means taking on responsibilities without being compensated.

1:59:13 Yeah, certainly. Yeah, I mean, I think it's, you know, some portion of the property management seems like we're kind of doing anyway. So to the level that we, you know, get those specific tasks identified and then obviously we want to be compensated to the level that we're participating in that. I don't think we're looking to take on the full responsibility of property management, right?

1:59:45 No, we're not capable of providing that service. Right, okay, okay. All right, good. That's what I was gathering, so I think we're geared up for that, but okay. Sounds good to me. Okay, great. Well, I have direction, so thank you very much. Okay, are we finished, Patricia, are we finished with the parcel discussion and you have a direction? Yes. Then we'll move to agenda item number five.

2:00:21 Yes, I'm just trying to find out why it's so dark in here. Okay. Okay, sorry. I was so black. This item is item number five. President Richard Playstead with a certificate of appreciation for his service on our board of directors. I wanted to make the board aware that our board member, Richard Playstead, resigned from the board of directors on March 14th.

2:01:15 Which was effective immediately. I invited him to the meeting this evening, but I don't see him present. But I wanted to note that he served on the board since November of 2018. And I actually met Richard at a Chamber of Commerce event. And he was very excited about volunteering for a local housing nonprofit.

2:01:49 He had a great entrepreneurial spirit. He also had some knowledge of nonprofit administration, which I thought would be great on our board. He also served on the Programs and Development Committee and, you know, gave feedback on 238 Sierra Manor Road, as well as the moderate income down payment assistance program.

2:02:15 He also was very excited to start thinking about what our next development project would be. So I really appreciated his enthusiasm for housing in our community. So Kirk and I are presenting Richard with a certificate and I guess for the next steps we will have another vacancy on our nine-member board. And at this moment that vacancy

2:02:46 Does not need to be a low-income representative, but it cannot be a public official or a public employee. And the ad hoc nominations committee, which includes Lindsay and Tom, is aware of this vacancy and we will start a recruitment plan as soon as we nominate our next board member. So thank you, Richard, for serving on our board and we wish you all the best in the future.

2:03:16 I'd like to make a motion to approve this certificate of appreciation for Richard's place. I'll second. It's been moved and seconded further discussion. All those in favor, please signify by raising your verbally or raising your hand. Aye. And president and staff, I'm going to go ahead and take a roll call vote, please. Okay. Board member Barksdale? Yes. Board member Hodges? Yes.

2:03:49 Vice President Kreitz? Yes. President Stapp? Yes. Board Member Vianzen? Yes. Board Member Perkins? Yes. Thank you. Okay. Thank you, everyone. We'll move to agenda item number six, which is a Mammoth Lake Housing program update. Patricia? Thanks. This is our monthly programs update.

2:04:31 And our first item is deed restriction retention. I wanted to make the board aware that our property at Meridian Court that we purchased at the end of 2019 closed escrow at the end of March and it was sold to a household that earns 120% of the area median income and works in the real estate industry.

2:04:58 And the price for that unit was $365,000. We paid off our loan to Mono County, which included $3,000 in interest. And we also paid off the town loan, the revolving loan fund loan that we had with the town. And I'm in the process of providing a detailed spreadsheet of the additional subsidy that was put into that unit. Since we bought it for, I think,

2:05:29 A little over $400,000, and then sold it so that it would be affordable to 120% AMI, which was lower than what we paid for it. Currently, there's a deed restricted unit at Aspen Village in escrow with an eligible household, and they will use the BEGIN program as well for up to 20% down towards the purchase price on that home.

2:06:01 Are there any questions on deed restrictions? Yeah, I have a quick question, Patricia. So on the revolving loan fund, is that now replenished with both the county and town, or where do we stand on those? Yes, so Mono County, so we don't have any loans out currently for properties, so the town's revolving loan fund.

2:06:28 is full, essentially, minus the subsidy that was put into the unit that we just sold at the end of March. But the town has had a couple of help loans, down payment assistance loans paid off recently, and so there's some discussion about where those loan funds will be allocated in the budget. So what's the, at this point, the total available funding in the revolving loan?

2:06:59 Well, so the town has allocated $600,000 minus approximately $30,000 for the subsidy, and then Mono County has $300,000. Okay, so we have a good cushion at this point if two units come up at once, we're more than covered, potentially even cover three. Yeah, yeah, it was a really excellent partnership when the town increased their revolving loan fund.

2:07:29 And doubled it. Great. Okay. Great. Thank you. Yeah. Thank you. Just kind of dovetailing, if I could ask a question off of Tom's question. So would that normally get replenished back up to the full $600,000 on a new fiscal year to make a full $600,000 available? Or is that not very well articulated in the policy?

2:07:59 I don't believe it's well articulated. I believe that there's essentially supposed to be the full amount available at any time, but I believe that the town staff had been looking at making some revisions to that policy, but I haven't seen any revisions to date. And that's a resolution, so it would go before the town council, I believe, so we would see that in advance. Okay, thanks. Further questions?

2:08:33 Okay, so I will just move on to homebuyers assistance programs. We have lots of homebuyers assistance funding available. Some expires at the end of the summer, but we'll also be applying for more, so that's good. And then I wanted to make a note that the town's moderate income program will be going to town council, I believe, this week, on Wednesday.

2:09:02 on the consent agenda, and so that program will be, have final approval, and we will work to market that program and then open up a lottery for the two loans up to $50,000, which require adding a deed restriction to the home. And then my other announcement is that the Mono County Home Program setup has been approved, and so we'll be taking applications for homeownership in Mono County.

2:09:36 And I think it's good to point out that the, excuse me, the town moderate income program, it's really just a trial program or a prototype that potentially could be expanded, right? So just don't want people to think, oh, that's it. That's how we get. It's like, no, no, no, no. This is the start of a much bigger discussion about how we're going to do this. So. Yeah, and with the market.

2:10:04 Yeah, Tom, that's a great point. It's a pilot program to test out, you know, how homebuyers will feel about this type of loan and added with a deed restriction. And in the current market, I am already thinking about some modifications we might like to make in the future. So we'll see how it goes and hopefully some homebuyers will be able to utilize it. And then we can kind of go from there on additional funding sources and any

2:10:34 changes you might want to make to it. Right, right. Of course, one of the biggest challenges is to ever change the real estate market, which is kind of going crazy at the moment. So it may not be able to make a difference. Unfortunately, things are at the moment. I don't know. So we'll see how that goes. Yeah. The next item is emergency rental assistance.

2:11:02 On this program, I just wanted to highlight that we received $30,000 from Union Bank as a contribution to this program, and it's just an amazing contribution that they made to the community, and it did take about 60 or more days to get approved, but we finally have the money in the bank, and we have about 100.

2:11:30 or more applications pending still, so we just keep processing those applications. A lot of people haven't really gone back to work yet, and so I'm hoping that this summer people will get busy, but I'm thinking we should be able to help everybody through this summer, I'm thinking July, August. I think we should have enough funding to help folks through that amount of time. Oh, and I should also announce that

2:11:59 We did also receive a small pot of funding from Inyo County to use for rental assistance in Inyo County in the unincorporated area and I think there's only enough to help maybe 15 households or 15 payments and so we've been trying to advertise that through service providers and I think we've had one application so far so that's just a great example.

2:12:29 You know, another partnership that we were able to create. How is, oh, I'm sorry. Well, how does that work? The Mammoth Lakes Housing has funding still available in that pop, but yet the state has funding. I mean, are we trying not to supplant the state funding, I hope, because there's, you know, so that we can use, I'm just curious how you're strategizing. So we've had a lot of conversations about this at the staff level.

2:13:00 Because the state is prioritizing back rent and a lot of our clients don't owe back rent, we've been referring clients who owe back rent and back utilities to the state program. And then we talked about it actually this morning at our staff meeting. If, you know, because we talk to the landlords every time we process an application and we say how much do they owe or are they behind.

2:13:31 And historically, our program has been helping people stay up to date. So if they were up to date, we were paying for that current month, towards that current month. So it seems like we may need to make some modifications to the program if we don't want to help people stay current. The state program says that it will help towards future rent.

2:14:01 But I know that they're prioritizing back rent and back utilities, and it's really unclear about how they're going to, or what they're going to allow in terms of paying forward rent. I don't know if that part of the program hasn't really been hashed out yet. So we still have some questions about that. Jennifer, you have any other questions? No. Questions from the board?

2:14:43 And I think, you know, we have a couple of other questions about the state program, and we're meeting weekly with them, and so that's another question I can ask them about folks who need help paying current rent and maybe don't have any back rent, and I can certainly prioritize that as a question. Yeah. To help figure out how we want to make sure that we're implementing the local program in a way that meets everybody's needs.

2:15:07 Yeah, and utilizes the funding. I mean, Mono County has a million dollars to help people. But if we're keeping everybody current, which is great, but I'm not sure it's really working for us if, because maybe we've done too good of a job. I mean, that's kind of how it feels. I don't know. It absolutely does. And, you know, I think it's, I guess, a double-edged sword in a way because our tenants,

2:15:38 A lot of our clients are so proud and they won't go in arrears. And so they'll borrow money from friends, they'll go without food and, you know, in order to not have back rent due. And we've been telling clients like, look, you only have to pay 25%, but they just won't. And so, you know, we're trying to line up the programs with the folks, you know, that makes the most sense for them.

2:16:07 I haven't really figured out a way yet. I mean, we talked about it at our staff meeting a lot this morning to figure out how to utilize the local money most efficiently and also make sure people are utilizing the state program in a way, right, so we can get that money into the community. And I will say there's a lot of people hiring. It's just overwhelming. I mean, there's a workforce shortage, so.

2:16:35 I think anybody who would like to work, there seems to be, I mean, I'm just, every time I turn on Facebook, that's almost all I see is somebody's hiring. So hopefully things turn around for people soon. Thank you, Jennifer. Patricia, further updates? Yeah, I am. So I just wanted to mention that Kirk made a great point to me this morning that reminded me we need to

2:17:09 Put an advertisement in the paper or do a flyer or do some promotion around thanking our donors who helped get our community through this tough time in the last 12 or more months. And so I'll be working on that in the next couple of weeks as well. We had a lot of contributions from the private business community and the jurisdictions, and so we want to make sure we thank everybody. Especially with such a generous contribution from Union Bank.

2:17:41 Yeah, absolutely. I have some updates on grants. We're still HCD on the home grant. HCD keeps asking me some follow-up questions and I keep answering them. So we'll just wait to hear what their loan committee says. The CDBG grant for 238, we should hear about hopefully in September. They said that was the earliest we would hear, but I'm hoping for September.

2:18:14 Oh, and then number three is the Eastern Sierra Sustainable Recreation Grant that I had worked with Agnes on to submit an application for 238s here on Manor Road. And I think I may have updated the board about this previously, but I wanted to make sure I let you know where we scored on that grant application. And in that application, we really were trying to focus on how housing, recreation, and tourism, and sustainability all kind of

2:18:43 Play equally important roles in our community and how they're all intertwined and how housing can play a role in sustainable recreation. And that application scored 150 out of 183 projects, which was the bottom 25th percent, which I thought was really good because I thought maybe I just wanted the board to know about that. And then we had a meeting

2:19:19 Today as well, Diane and I talked with Mono County staff about applying for CDBG funding, which is due at the end of the month for mortgage assistance, and the town is also interested in applying for that as well. So we'll be working with those jurisdictions on those applications. And then, so Mammoth Lakes Housing and IMACA both applied.

2:19:50 to help the state get the word out about the state's rental assistance program. They're calling it California COVID-19 Rent Relief. And, you know, I had a meeting with IMACA and we talked about limited capacity and not really sure how we wanted to get involved, but ultimately we decided that it was our responsibility to apply for this program.

2:20:19 So that we can help get the word out about all this money that's available to help California residents pay back rent, back utilities, and potentially future rent. Both IMACA and Memphis Housing were awarded grants, which are mostly outreach grants, but also include meeting one-on-one with clients to help them fill out the very lengthy online-only application.

2:20:48 So we were both awarded for that, and I would expect that I would be able to bring the contract accepting the grant funds to the board at our May meeting. I think I asked for, I think, approximately $100,000 to support Judith, who has been really spearheading our emergency rental assistance program, and then potentially another

2:21:18 Part-time person to just help in the office answering phones and meeting with clients. But I think ultimately we'll be awarded about I think between $50,000 and $70,000 to help support that program. And I provided outreach materials in the packet for your reference. Are there any questions on grants? That's great news on that program for sure. Yeah, yeah, it's great. The applications.

2:21:50 Quite complicated, but we've been scheduling office, or we can meet people at their doorstep to help them with the application, and so we've been scheduling office hours in North County the last two weeks, so we have staff available. If clients make an appointment on the appointment hotline, then we can drive up there and meet them to help them with their appointment.

2:22:17 And we'll be working more on trying to schedule maybe some open office hours in community centers or libraries around the region so that we can make sure everybody has access to this program. Especially because you need an email address and you need to be able to know how to use the internet. A lot of our clients have limited digital literacy and so...

2:22:43 Being able to have someone meet face-to-face and help them with the application is extremely important. I think, you know, I added some additional work items that we're working on. I think I just wanted to highlight, I have a preliminary number on the apartment vacancy rate in the town of Mammoth Lakes. I'm just waiting on the final number of total apartments, which will come from town staff.

2:23:20 Probably next week or in two weeks or so. But with the numbers that we currently have, the January rate was 0.72, which is still less than 1%, and the three-year average is 0.41. If the apartment vacancy rate, if the three-year average is below 5%, then multifamily property owners cannot condominiumize their apartments and turn them into

2:23:51 Condos for ownership. So that's a way to try to preserve workforce housing. Let's see. Oh, I wanted to also highlight that our annual occupancy monitoring, which Diane and Diane's been working on, is almost complete. I think there's maybe only two outstanding clients. And so I know she's going to try to wrap that up since usually we start doing it again in the spring or summer. So that'll be great.

2:24:33 And then I've been having a lot of meetings. We have a lot of committee meetings. The programs committee is meeting. The nominations committee is meeting. And the marketing committee is meeting. And they'll all have updates, hopefully, in the committee meeting updates. But lots of meetings. And then I wanted to make the board aware that I'll be completing my continuing education for my real estate license.

2:25:03 This year in the next 12 months, which is nine courses and it's 45 hours of training. And so that's just an added workload to my plate that I'll be trying to wrap up before the due date. So I've registered for that and hopefully can get rolling sooner rather than later so I can get it all done. And then staff has also been attending a lot of trainings.

2:25:30 We have some homekeeper database trainings that I know I want to bring a presentation to the board about the database system that we signed up for for deed restriction stewardship. We've been attending a bunch of trainings to try to wrap our heads around how to enter the data and then trying to think about how we're going to allocate time so we can get all the data uploaded.

2:25:55 The database is great. It's going to help us show all the subsidies that we put into units, all the rehabilitation that's been done on different homes, and all the different down payment assistance programs, and so we've attended quite a few trainings on that, and actually we will have another one so that we can really get a hold on it, and then I'm actually going to be attending a home ownership stewardship training, and

2:26:26 And affordable housing finance training, which Tom reminded me about, so I'm registered for that as well. So we just have a lot going on. And, oh, I wanted to make an announcement that Mammoth Lakes Housing was nominated for an award from the Chamber of Commerce for a pandemic champion or something like that. Pandemic champion.

2:26:57 From the Chamber of Commerce for the work that we did around the Emergency Rent Assistance Program. And I think it's a great opportunity just to, you know, get Mammoth Lakes Housing out in the public some more. And, you know, we're not doing coffee talks and road shows, but I think just trying to do small, small little things. And it's great to be recognized for all the hard work that we've been putting in.

2:27:26 I forwarded the invitation to all the board members, so if you'd like to attend the Zoom gala, you have the link, and hopefully maybe I'll see some of you there. And I think that's all I have on my update. Thank you, Patricia. That was quite a workload. Yeah, thanks. If you're finished with that, then we'll move to agenda item number seven, which is committee updates.

2:28:02 Great. So I provided a list of all the committees. If we want to go one by one, we have, well, I guess I can say governance committee has not been meeting. We've just got a lot of other things going on and governance committee will have to be a priority after we wrap some of this other stuff up. Oh, and then diversity committee hasn't been meeting either, but I'm

2:28:39 I've been attending some free trainings, which has been great, because I think it will really help me formalize some of my vocabulary and concepts so that we can kind of have some better conversations about diversity, equity, and inclusion. So we haven't been meeting, but Zariah and I have talked a couple times about it, and I think we're just focused on learning, and hopefully we'll be able to get that committee rolling again soon.

2:29:08 And then we have Programs and Development Committee. Yeah, which we've met a couple of times, I think. And we have, as Tom alluded to earlier, we have a meeting scheduled, I think, this week or next. I'm not sure it's on my schedule, I know. With Kirk and Council Member Ray, as well as Dan Holler and Sandra Moberly from the town to discuss middle income.

2:29:42 Funding mechanisms, just since Tom mentioned the program that's going before the town council on their consent agenda is really a pilot program and one-time funding of $100,000 and we know there's a need there and just a preliminary discussion about what are some possible options, how we can just get this, keep this on the burner and not let it slide far off. And then Patricia put this beautiful rubric together, so colorful.

2:30:11 I love it. We talked about it, but it did not look this pretty. So, way to go, Patricia. I had to fix it. It was terrible. I know. So, I'll let you. You did all the work on the rubric, Patricia. Sure. So, the committee met a couple of times. We looked at a really bad Excel spreadsheet, which was fine in the moment.

2:30:39 The committee really wanted to prioritize and cross off some of the items on their task list that had already been completed or maybe no longer were a priority because, you know, changes just, you know, since we've done our strategic plan. And so this rubric is an attempt to illustrate the tasks of the program development committee and their priority.

2:31:09 So, we have a description of each priority, an estimate of company number of units we think each priority will accomplish, progress notes here, if it's in the chat, and the status. And this is really, I will just remind in video, work in progress. You know, I didn't go through and add the number of units to every single priority.

2:31:39 I may have missed some that are in the chat, but I have to go back and double check. But this was a second attempt at trying to put everything on a piece of paper for us to look at. And so these are the top five priorities of the program committee from what I gathered from our two meetings that we had. One was to pursue development, which I think

2:32:07 Really highlights the board's commitment to the 238 Sierra Mariner Road project ultimately. And then there's a sub rubric which shows some other potential development projects that we may be able to play a role in. Number two is the parcel involvement and what potential role Mammoth Lakes Housing might be able to play. Conversations ongoing.

2:32:38 So orange is some progress, and green is full speed ahead, and yellow is stalled, and red is either complete or no longer a priority. Three is to collaborate regionally, you know, secure partners and find funding, try to grow capacity and also serve our partners with their housing needs, and I think that's full speed ahead.

2:33:08 We have our Latino Coalition Program and then an Inyo County Rehab Program. Four is identify capital sources, which is really always ongoing, but I put here full speed ahead because of 238 Sierra Manor Road, the Affordable Housing Finance Conference coming up, fundraising success that we had in the last year. So I think that's really full speed ahead and ongoing thought in my mind.

2:33:40 And then Community Housing Action Plan Analysis to show progress that we've made in the CHAP for MLH responsibilities. We've had this previously at a meeting, but it's probably been at least a year. So that is on my list for future board meetings. And I had thought maybe we would have it at this meeting, but I knew the parcel was going to take a lot of time. So it'll be in the next

2:34:10 One or two meetings hopefully we'll see that again. Here we have six through ten long-term rental inspection program, which is a program outlined in the chat and is a program that would implement an inspection program for apartment units that rent to long-term tenants, similar to an inspection program that currently exists.

2:34:43 for short-term rental units. I just put stalled here because I haven't had any recent conversations with the town about this program, but I know it's a priority of some board members, and so I think yellow is a good place for it right now, and we'll just have to keep it on the list as we move forward. And I'll just point out it's in the chat. Yes, absolutely. Which has a timeline. Yes.

2:35:19 Number seven is to create a strategy to engage the development community, which I think largely stalled out in some respects because of COVID and, you know, we weren't doing roadshows and coffee talks and we weren't meeting with people, but we did talk about it at the committee level about ways we can think of to try to discuss partnerships, create opportunities for board advocacy.

2:35:46 Or perhaps hold some sort of quarterly Zoom call. So that's on the list here is number seven. Number eight is the development rubric, which we have attached here. And we can certainly flesh out some more and explore some additional partnerships potentially. So I put that as full speed ahead. The chamber program and subsides property management, because we serve on the committee,

2:36:21 And it's in the chat. I put that at full speed ahead and essentially ongoing. And then additionally, I guess I should also put red on this item because the subsidized property management research that we did didn't materialize anything that was scalable at this time to take on with the current staff capacity that we have. And so that component of this item is

2:36:51 No longer a priority. And then the middle income down payment assistance program is 10 here on the list because it's really full speed ahead and we'll be working on that really shortly. And that is in the chat as well. Oh boy, that's a lot of program items. Number 11 here is to streamline referrals, which I believe is full speed ahead. We've actually really strengthened our relationships a lot with Mono County Social Services and behavioral health.

2:37:30 As well as IMACA and other service providers in the region, including the continuum of care, to really try to figure out how we can streamline our referrals all together as a network of providers. And so I think that's full speed ahead and we'll just continue to work on that. Annual outreach to existing properties was an item that

2:38:04 The Board thought we should have in the strategic plan to strengthen our relationship with clients. And I think, you know, through COVID and the Emergency Rent Assistance Program, we have made some progress with, you know, building those relationships with clients. We don't have a specific outreach event planned.

2:38:32 But those relationships are certainly strong right now. Fee for service program is number 13. We currently provide services for fees. We don't have a menu necessarily of services, but all of our contracts that we have are negotiable. And so I would say this is full speed ahead and something we could certainly refine.

2:39:05 We definitely do provide services for fees to jurisdictions and possibly even developers. Expand real estate services is number 14. This item was included in the strategic plan as a way to grow income streams and provide more comprehensive real estate services to first-time homebuyer clients, which we already serve.

2:39:39 It hasn't been a priority in the last 12 months as we've been focused on rent assistance, but it's stalled, but certainly could always be revamped at another time. Legal clinic hours is number 15, and the goal is to either provide or partner to provide legal aid services in Mammoth Lakes and Mono County, and I would say some progress has been made on this. We have been working much more.

2:40:09 More closely with California Indian Legal Aid Services, their offices in Bishop, but they certainly serve our region and we've been trying to communicate with them on availability, their availability to provide legal aid to our clients and partnering with them as well on grant applications to bring funding to our region to provide this service as well. So some progress. I'd like to see more about it.

2:40:39 That's where that's at. Small business loan program research was another avenue that in our strategic plan we had thought that might be a way to provide some needed services to the community and also bring in some additional income and that priority is red so it's no longer a priority because you know a lot of

2:41:05 Changes have happened, especially during COVID, and a lot of small business lending became available, and so it doesn't seem like there's really much need or really a role for us to play on a program like that at this time. And then we have, this is the developments rubric, so this is really just a first stab at this one, actually. So the committee thought it would be good to have sort of a list of some potential projects.

2:41:39 That we know about that are ongoing in the community that we might be able to play a role in. And these are prioritized, well, I mean, the first two are prioritized and then the last three are just on there. But we have Sierra Manor Road, which is full speed ahead and 11 units. We have the parcel, which we talked about, 500 units, and that's also full speed ahead.

2:42:07 And then I put Mammoth Mall as number three because we have previously had a relationship with the owner of the Mammoth Mall and had discussions and completed a grant application with them in 2018. And so I put that as number three. I don't really know the status of that project, but since we had a previous relationship, that made the most sense for me to put it next. That was 13 units, but I think it could potentially be more.

2:42:40 It might actually be 26 units, but 13, I think, were, they said that they could do affordable RANSAT for the CDBG application. And then we added the Wounded Warrior Center because we weren't sure if there would be long-term housing at that project. We didn't know a lot about it, but we wanted to put it on there as a potential partnership. And then this should be number five, other sites.

2:43:14 Mammoth Lakes Housing, you know, we've been contacted by a couple of different property owners, actually in Mammoth and Bishop, regarding potential partnerships on, actually potential properties and potential partnerships. So, you know, I put stalled here, but I mean, really maybe some progress there. It's always good when you have open communication with folks and folks willing to explore different ideas and possibilities.

2:43:44 Probably number five is some progress, I would say. And that is the priorities of the programs and development committee. Question from the board? Does the committee have any comments or, yeah, are there any questions? No, I think the next time we meet, we'll be meeting soon and we'll report back in May how that goes and happy to take a look at, make sure that.

2:44:25 The chat is yes or no, and, you know, just help flesh that out. Thanks for putting it together so thoroughly. Appreciate that, Patricia. And thanks, Tom, for organizing our meetings. I think I did the easy part. Thank you, everyone. Okay, so then we have the Marketing and Communications Ad-Hoc Committee. I can start, and then my fellow committee members can jump in. We met twice this week.

2:45:05 Had put out an RFP for proposals for a rebranding of Mammoth Lakes Housing and some guidance on the future of our marketing. And so we've just been reviewing, we've had seven proposals come in and we've been reviewing them all and figuring out who we would like to interview and how we're going to move forward and really streamlining what it is we think that the organization needs.

2:45:34 In the future. And it's very exciting. We have a lot of people, a lot of organizations, businesses excited to work with us who are all bringing some really exciting proposals to the table. Thank you. Further discussion? Is anybody else from marketing committee? I think Lindsay pretty much summarized it.

2:46:07 In the process of going through, we kind of crossed off a couple of the proposals for not really interested and we're looking into what questions we want to ask some of the other firms we're more interested in to maybe speak with for an interview. Personally, I think we kind of get different interests from different firms and didn't really get something.

2:46:36 That was all around that fit us great. So we might try to source the services from several different companies. Thank you, Tony. Further discussion? Okay, then we have workforce housing committee. Tom, I don't know if there's been any meetings. I haven't seen any. No, there weren't any held this last month. Okay. I understand. I talked to Ken at the chamber actually the other day.

2:47:19 Sounds like Curtis is going to be leaving in June. So anyway, I mean, they didn't say they weren't going to continue with the program, but they'll probably have to reassign some responsibility there once they make some adjustments. Okay, that's good to know. And then, I don't know, Tom, do you want to take for nominations? Sure. So we've had three applicants, and we just actually...

2:47:52 Prior to the board meeting, completed our third interview. So we'll reconvene a committee meeting here, I think, either later this week or next, and just sort of coalesce our assessment of everybody and see if we're in a position to make a recommendation that we would bring to the board at the May board meeting is sort of the schedule. So yeah, three individuals.

2:48:22 who are very, you know, passionate and interested in Mammoth Lakes Housing, and so we'll see where we go. And then we'll also need to talk about recruitment for the second open position, which we'll do at that meeting or another meeting. We have to have at least seven members, so I just, you know, if we

2:48:53 We don't have to rush, but, I mean, obviously, we should do some recruitment, so. Yeah. I mean, to that end, I did actually get, when I talked to Ken, I was sort of soliciting, you know, just sort of the chamber in general to see if we get the word out amongst their membership as well. Great. Just a quick question on that. I can't remember the makeup, but with the three folks who have applied, is there potential to nominate you? You know, I think,

2:49:43 I think, you know, I guess we'll have to see. I mean, yeah, we could, but, you know, I would like to try to make a little more outreach and see if we can reach some more, you know, different areas of the community. And, you know, like I think with Patricia's point, if, you know, we can function, like, you know, I don't necessarily want to rush to.

2:50:13 I mean, at the end of the day, I think, you know, it's, it's, it's,

2:50:44 Word of mouth, more than anything, or the ability to really interact with people to kind of impress or, you know, solicit the interest, I guess, you know, it's tough. I don't know that we felt pretty disappointed. I think we ran a couple ads in the paper, and I don't know that really generated any leaks necessarily. So, anyway, you know, I guess void being is.

2:51:09 I think it's worth doing some additional outreach as well in the coming month or so to see where we can get. Yeah. Yeah, it was more so a question. Further discussion? Just that we have a town contract negotiations committee, and I wanted to let the board know that I have taken a first quick stab at the town contract.

2:51:46 for the committee to review, and that committee will be meeting on Friday. So, after the committee makes any additional suggested changes to the town contract, I'll be meeting with town staff to, well, I guess I will send that to probably just town staff for them to review, and then they can provide any changes that they'd like to see, and then I'll bring it back to the committee for another look.

2:52:14 But that process is moving forward, so that's great. I think our current contract expires June 30th, so I think we're well on our way to hopefully executing a new contract with the town. Thank you, Patricia. Further committee reports? If there are no further committee reports, we'll move to board member reports. Any board member reports? My comment is that it's been a productive meeting.

2:52:57 So I thank everybody for, especially in these times with the COVID-19 and everything else, this has been difficult and very difficult. So I appreciate everything everybody has done. I just have a few board report, thanks, if you don't mind. I want to just let the board know that

2:53:25 The National Association of Counties did support the resolution I proposed for them to support changing congressional legislation that would amend the Internal Revenue Code for private equity bonds, which are used with 4% tax credits, which were applied for and have been for the parcel and have been used in other projects in Mammoth.

2:53:55 They currently require a 50% match between tax credits and bonds. And if we reduce it to 25% match, then we can double the amount of bonds, or excuse me, tax credits of 4% that could be used in the nation. So it basically doubles the amount of affordable housing available. So NACO supported that.

2:54:20 And I'm going to meet with our new representative, Obernolte, Jay Obernolte, Obernolte, I've got to get his name right, his staff this week, to see if he would potentially co-sponsor Affordable Housing Act legislation, Congress, that would include this, hopefully.

2:54:48 I keep working on that because I think it has potential to do a lot of good, not just in California or in the nation, but right here on the parcel. And in the other developments in Mono County or the region. Let's see. And then I did meet with the CSAC, or not, I'm sorry, not CSAC, but

2:55:11 Actually, I did meet with CSAC and Senator Mark McGuire. He's the senator for California. And I told him about the success that we had had with our infrastructure and infill grant here in Mammoth Lakes in a rural community and really encouraged him to make sure that the next IIG, that's the acronym for the infrastructure grant program.

2:55:40 That is done through the governor's budget has the same kind of language that that one had, that that program had, because it made it really accessible to small rural jurisdictions, which is partially why Mammoth was so successful, because we changed program guidelines. I worked with CSAC on that and others to get the language to be amenable.

2:56:06 And so I hope that their future rounds will also continue to have that accessibility for rural areas. But the CCRH legislative committee met today and we reviewed a bunch of different policy or bills and the committee supported a slew of them. Some of them are about to

2:56:35 disaster recovery, which, you know, fortunately, Mono County hasn't had any major disaster. I mean, I think that while we think of the Mountain View fire as a major disaster, it didn't actually trigger FEMA. It wasn't that big, you know, on the scale of some of the big fires we've seen across the state, as devastating as those are where FEMA comes in, and it's a major devastation.

2:57:04 But should we encounter something like that, this Bill 880 will allow gap funding between when FEMA actually funds and CDBGR, DR, Disaster Recovery Funds are available with the state backfilling those because there are people who, like in Butte County, for example, who received 2017 funds and haven't gotten them yet.

2:57:32 to rebuild their communities. I mean, that's crazy, especially on the affordable housing side. So that's one of the bills that CCRH is working on and CSAC is going to support and RCRC and Mono County and just want to make you all aware of that. And I think that's it. Just some things. And I just think it's important that we think about the bills because

2:58:02 Oh, the last thing I want to mention is I actually, because I think this gets back to the middle income. I attended Missing Middle Income Housing Webinar. It was hosted by ILG and the California Statewide Communities Development Authority. And it was really fascinating. So there is this middle income solution for housing. And it's being used like in Long Beach and other places. And it uses

2:58:32 What does it use? It uses bonds. It uses tax-exempt bonds to finance the acquisition of existing multifamily housing and turn it into middle-income housing. And this group, their acronym is the California Statewide Communities Development Authority. They actually hold the bonds. So the jurisdiction doesn't own the property.

2:59:00 And banks back it, but the minimum size of the acquisition is like 150 to 200 units, which really stinks for rural communities. And I was like, when are we going to get something that works for rural?

2:59:15 They're aware of it. So this is pretty green. This is a pretty new program, but they are doing it. So I think, you know, maybe someday there'll be something. It's just hard to gather enough equity to get banks interested in smaller projects. And that's why they looked at 150 to 200 units. And then I asked about new construction, thinking that, well, maybe we could come up with something here in Mammoth for new construction. But they said that can be tricky.

2:59:43 So they can be done, but it's trickier because it triggers prevailing wage when you use private activity bonds because they are done through the jurisdiction, from what I understand, I think. It was a little complicated, and as soon as they said that you had to have, it would work best with existing market rate investment, you know, market rate already built product that you would go in and buy and deed to restrict. But basically, it's a long, impressive program.

3:00:15 But unfortunately, I don't think it works here right now, but I'll keep my eye on it. That's all I have. Thanks. Thank you, Jennifer. Any further reports? I was just going to make a mention, I don't know, in some recent news piece on the infrastructure federal bill that's being considered by the Biden administration, I'd heard that some fairly significant amount of that might be set up for

3:00:46 Affordable housing, you know, support across the country. I think 300 million. I thought it was in the billions. Oh, maybe, oh, maybe it's 300 billion. When we start getting to the trillions. Yeah, it's a one, what is it, a trillion dollar proposal or something like that? I think it's, I think it's three, I know it's 300 something, so it must be billion. It must be 300 billion. Yeah, impressive number. So, you know, that might filter down, right? So, anyway, just.

3:01:15 It's just interesting because, you know, the ebb and flow of these things changes as the political winds change. And, you know, maybe there will be an opportunity here that, you know, a significant federal program will get underway that'll filter down to little Melano County and we'll have a chance to apply for some stuff. So, you know, if they're going to get that bill done, it's probably going to happen in the next six months, it sounds like.

3:01:42 Yeah, so I mean, maybe by the end of the year, there might be actually something tangible there. And there'll be another source of money out there for us to go after. So anyway, we'll just be positive. I think Mitch McConnell wants to whittle it down. We'll see where we go. Yeah. It's going to take longer. They're going to go through reconciliation, and it'll be six months. But anyways, we'll see what happens. Further reports?

3:02:16 If not, then we will adjourn to the board meeting scheduled for May 3. Thank you, everyone. Thank you for all your hard work. Thank you. Stay safe. Stay safe. Have a good night. Thanks for everything. See you next time. Bye-bye.