TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2021

Town Council

· recording 4 hr 25 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Notable from this meeting

3 findings

Transcript

561 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

1:42 Good afternoon, children. Good afternoon, Mr. Mayor. Good afternoon, Bill. Hola. Well, we're up to four of us. Now we're up to all five of us. With that being said, Jamie, if you're ready and everything's turned on, I'll start the meeting. Yeah, let's go. Thank you. Am I sending a bunch of noise out or something? My yellow box isn't going away. Okay, good. I hear a little bit of background noise, like maybe a TV.

3:47 Something going on in the background? No, just the fan on my heater. Maybe unmute yourself, Bill, and let's see if it goes away or not. Yeah, there's a little ambient noise coming out of your sight there, Bill, I think. Not too stressful. Let me see if I can fix that. Did that change things a little? Yeah, it's a little better. It's not terrible, it's just a little bit of ambient noise. Yeah, there's really no noise in here with me now, except that that I make myself.

4:42 Okay, I will open this Town Council meeting from Wednesday, February 3 at 4 o'clock. Roll call, please. Councilmember Rae? Yes, here. Councilmember Stapp? Here. Councilmember Wentworth? Here. Mayor Pro Tem, Salcido? Here. Mayor Souser? Present. We are all present and accounted for. Pledge of Allegiance.

5:16 Sandra, how would you like to lead us in the pledge today? We'd love to. Thank you. Rise and join me. I pledge of allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. I thank you for that. Public comments. Now is the time for any member of the public who wishes to speak on anything that is not otherwise on the agenda.

5:53 We received an email earlier today from Laura Heiner regarding Gray Eagle Homeowners Association concerns with their neighbors, and that's the only public comment we have received. Thank you, Jamie. Dan, do we have any emergency additions to the agenda? We do not, Mr. Mayor. Thank you very much. Reports from commission and or departments. Joel. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Just wanted to take a moment of your time.

6:28 To share a quick update report, just a snapshot of the last couple of weeks relative to the host program. So this is from January 21st until February 2nd. This graph shows a number of interactions we've been having for logging. And so when we had our snowstorm, you can see we did not deploy that. That's that bottoming out.

6:59 Saturday, we logged 440 interactions with the public at different locations, Lake Prairie Road Closure in the village at the bus stop, very busy there. We've been working extensively with the transportation system. As you might expect, since we're focused on helping with our system a lot, a lot of people have questions related to how they get to different places. And the latest recommendation is that we improve.

7:29 The maps and the schedule information at the bus stops a little bit just to make it easier to interpret. That was the latest feedback we got over the weekend. A lot of people have questions about the host program, outdoor recreation options outside the resort. We saw a lot of activity outside the permit area over the weekend. And then last, shopping and dining questions. We had hosts out at the Sherwins Trailhead clearing.

7:58 Thank you very much. I just wanted to create some awareness around what's going on out there. We did have a busy weekend out of the ground.

8:27 If you have any questions, I'd be happy to answer them. Any questions for Joel? Seeing no hands raised, I will move on. Thank you, Joel. Any other reports? Sandra? Thank you, Mayor Salzer. I just wanted to provide a brief update on the business assistance program. We completed round five of the program and issued checks this week. We provided checks to 31 businesses, totaling a little bit over $425,000.

9:00 Which brings the total amount that we put out to the community a little bit over $875,000. So it's been a very successful program. Every single applicant has said thank you and asked me to pass on and thanks to the town council. So I'll do that again. It's been very appreciated. And I think it's really made a difference for a lot of our small businesses in our community. So with that, I'm happy to answer any questions that I need to pass this program, but just a hearty thank you to all of the council members.

9:33 Again, any questions for Sandra? Seeing no hands. Any other reports? Hayes. Thank you, Mr. Mayor, and thank whoever was out in the public who made that appropriate sacrifice to ruler and that giant snowstorm. Appreciate that. Quick update on our snow removal activities. Just in general, I feel the crew did a great job. This was a pretty solid storm. We definitely were a little bit behind when it was beating us down, but...

10:04 By Friday morning, we turned the corner and had roads cleared, so really appreciate all the hard work from the entire crew. I asked all of the managers to put together just kind of their own personal synopsis of what they saw and what transpired, and I'll just kind of give you a couple excerpts from Todd Murphy. Again, he was reiterating how great his crew did. Everybody stepped up, working long hours. In advance of this, we made some changes. We pulled a member of the parks crew.

10:33 Onto the night crew for snow removal. We pulled a member off the airport crew to put them on the day crew for snow removal. And then I put out an email to the admin staff here as we moved our facility's janitor into a plow truck. So we basically threw everything we had in the storm and all of our equipment. And there was a lot of things around from all the managers working together to try to put the team together with all the resources that we had. So I really appreciated that. The report from Lon, we're a little bit dinged up on our fleet.

11:00 We had to turn around a number of vehicles with cracks, hydraulic hoses, little things. But at the end of the day, everything kept on running. We kept all the equipment working. And I got to shout out to all the mechanics because they're working side by side with these guys running plow trucks. They run fuel. I don't think people realize that when you get a piece of equipment, you're in that piece of equipment for 12 hours. We run water out to them. We run food out to them. And we run fuel out to them. So, you know, they deserve a serious amount of credit as well for being part of the team.

11:30 I did get a, I'll share with you guys this synopsis from Vince over at the airport. You should be seeing a picture of the airport, correct? No. Okay. So going into the storm, we put out a note on letting the pilots know that the runway was not going to be monitored for snow conditions.

11:52 The next morning, it was clear we're not going to be able to get open, so there was a NOTAM that went out. We closed the airport, which also allowed us to allocate resources to the snow removal crew here in the town for streets. They worked through the storm the next day, knocking down the burns, knocking down the snow, trying to keep up with it. We had to allocate crew to clear the airport roads to keep things open. I'm obviously paraphrasing kind of as I walk through this. This is a pretty detailed analysis.

12:21 By 1230 on Friday, they actually got the airport completely open. We had an aircraft landing an hour and a half later. So hats off to the crew down at the airport. They had a lot of snow down there. And we also allocated a year ago a backup blower and a loader that once we replaced them, we put them down at the airport. If we hadn't have done it, there's no way these guys would have been able to keep up with that amount of snow.

12:47 A couple photos. They have the ability to just side cast. They don't have to spot anything. So it's always exciting to watch these guys remove snow because it's always a huge plume. So with that, happy to answer any questions you have about our operations. We're all cleaned up and looking forward to the next storm. Thank you, Hayes. Any questions for Hayes? Hayes, I'll give your crew an attaboy. I thought for the type of storm it was, they did a good job. Thank you. We'll pass that along.

13:20 Yeah. Yeah, it was a significant storm, although I heard several people saying it was the biggest we ever had, and by no stretch of the imagination, was it the biggest we ever had, but memories are short, I suppose, when you haven't had big snow in a couple of years. Any other reports from commissions or departments? Come in, Bill. I'll call Grady first. Go ahead, Grady. Copy that. Just a very quick update.

13:51 We had a regular meeting with Inyo County and FAA last week on the progress down in Bishop. Inyo County reports that they do expect to be able to receive virtual air flights next winter in December. FAA is pushing them to finish all of their paperwork, all of their requirements, their park winter and everything by July 1st of the summer, according to the schedule. That's the schedule right now. We've actually had a discussion as early as this morning about

14:17 The impact to Mammoth Gosemite moving forward with TSA entitlements and everything else. And you can expect something to come to Town Council in March or April with an update on that. So thank you very much. Thank you, Grady. Any questions for Grady? Stuart. Thank you, Mayor. Members of Council, Public. I just want to, again, like Hayes and his crew, acknowledge our Parks Maintenance crew.

14:48 Pretty sure everybody on council, not too sure if everybody in our community knows what our parks maintenance crew does. So we take care of all the sidewalks, the multi-use paths. And then we also were assigned this year to clean our bus shelters. So I believe, I understand, I toured many of them. I don't think they've ever looked as good as they have before. We had Tito with his own snowblower from the barink out there.

15:16 Driving it around, cleaning it up, scraping it, making sure it's accessible for everybody that wanted to jump on one of our many free transit buses throughout town. And then the crew also were able to clean up Canyon Boulevard. I know we always have a lot of interest. It is kind of a public safety concern, so the crew went up there last night.

15:40 And cleared not only the bus shelters there, but Kenyon Boulevard. So essentially all our trails are back open again, which is great. I also want to point out that not only does our crew work, you know, around the clock, like Hayes' crew, but our crew actually get to produce coloured PDFs with photos that they can kind of upload to the website. And if you've seen our new 30-second video with music, you can log on to our Town of Mammoth Lakes Facebook page or our Parks and Rec page.

16:09 And you can kind of get a day in the life of our parks maintenance crew out and about on their machines. So again, full credit to Warren, Marco, Juan, Taito, and Hector for going above and beyond during our storm cycle. So thank you very much, man. Bill, you're muted. That's what happens when you're doing two things at once. Any questions for Stu? Just a quick shout out to Stu and the crew and all the snow removal folks.

16:46 The mops, the sidewalks were really in great shape. I was able to get around on feet on my bike, and it's a great alternative to being an automobile. So thanks a lot, sir, for that really excellent job on that stuff. Thank you. I really did. Thank you. I'll pass that along. Thank you. John, do you have chains for that e-bike? Studded tires. Studs are illegal in California. Okay. Not on my bike. Moving on then. Unless we have another report from someone.

17:18 Seeing none, staff presentations, Town of Mammoth Lakes 2020 year in review, Dan. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. I'm going to share a screen here and kind of whip through the things we look at each year as we go through and look at the last calendar year, the various things that we're able to accomplish and the work that gets done. We started this a few years back to kind of highlight the year's efforts and the work and also

17:52 It tends to help us work through as we get ready, looking at the next year's budget and the year we're in right now, the next few months and the programs. So we've got a full-blown report coming out. It's coming back from the design side now. I'm just going to kind of quickly try to walk through this and highlight the things we'll be touching on in the report. Then once we get the full document out, that'll be presented to you all as well and shared publicly. This year is more of a very...

18:19 Kind of a quick overview of the things that will be covered in that report. No surprise, emergency response has been a major element of the last year, starting with the COVID-19 pandemic and the response and the elements we've done there. Since last March 15th of 2020, we have been in an emergency management process, which is continuing.

18:43 We'll see how long that goes beyond another month or two or six. We'll see. But on top of that, you recall, we also had the creek fire next door to us and the impact of that and responding and prepping and preparing for that. Several months later, it was ultimately declared fully contained. And then we also dealt with the public safety power shutoff program.

19:13 If you remember that we put dollars into that for our generator program so we could have the proper backup power in different facilities. It has been tested several times, some successfully, some has not. So ongoing work there to make sure we're able to function without power as need be. Then the photo here, it's kind of rolling into this year. This is our vaccination set up at the high school.

19:42 We'll talk a lot more about that later this evening, but the importance of rolling this vaccination program out, and they're doing a great job with the system for that. Housing, obviously an ongoing topic for this last year and moving into this year with the parcel, a lot of discussion on that this evening, taking that 25-acre investment the town made and property here in town and ultimately transforming that into affordable workforce housing for our community.

20:11 We continue to work with the Chamber of Commerce on housing, on their matching program between people with additional space units or rooms with vetted workforce here in the community, reaching out to do that. Continued investment, our recreational amenities, hats off to the crew and to volunteers to get our golf, whoops, the shady rest, this golf course up and running.

20:37 I see a sign of it there. It's out there as we get back into the summer season again, be a popular element. With the passing of Tony Colisardo, we ended up establishing a fund in his honor, who is very, very committed to our recreational efforts here in the community and the department.

20:56 And just a really solid supporter of the town in these areas. And so we raised over $20,000 in donations. And that really goes for us to be able to do scholarship programs. We have a real strong commitment. We don't want to turn anybody away from our rec program based on their economic abilities. And so we really do want to bring people in and have them involved in our rec programs to be able to have that scholarship program in place for that.

21:23 A lot of work in the trail world, both in terms of construction and other activities out there, maintenance efforts that we're doing, shot here, some of the work up in the basin, but also some planning work going on in different areas as well as we look to the future. And as Joel mentioned at the beginning of the meeting, the trail host program, the community slash trail host effort out there, touching base with people on the ground.

21:50 A great program, very well received by locals and visitors alike as we reach into that space to really provide that extra support there. A lot of capital projects, infrastructure projects, deferred maintenance areas, partnerships out in the parks, example here of a drinking fountain, maybe through the Klonis, I believe, bringing those in to be able to provide water bottle fill stations.

22:17 Regular drinking fountain and several that are lower also have a pet component to it as well for watering as people are out playing and enjoying our great outdoors. Sidewalk projects, a lot of those at the last council meeting, there was an overview provided on the work around the village, getting a full connection of sidewalks, extending around that investment in the North Village area there.

22:45 The airport, several projects there as well. This is one of the taxi areas, repaving. Going through there, we have additional fence and gate coming up, work that's being done, and then also completing the environmental work at the airport for the next phase of projects, which would include storage area for equipment, as Hayes mentioned, the level of...

23:06 Snow removal equipment, fire protection equipment that's housed at the airport to have a place safely to be able to keep it stored and maintain it, work on it as need be at the airport, be an added value element in the projects we do. And of course, overall municipal surfaces, different things that we've stepped up there. Sorry, I had the text in here twice, but the...

23:30 20-year Solid Waste Franchise Agreement with Mammoth Disposal. We'll be able to bring that forward so we can plan for the future as we meet state mandates for recycling, for the reduction of greenhouse gases and other types of diversion programs out of landfills. Ultimately, building on this a number of different areas. One is looking at the biomass still and the element there. Tying that into a larger project here and around our community and in the county.

23:56 Ultimately dealing with the forest and biomass there and fuels reduction as well as safety throughout our community. Again, a master reminder, a major reminder this last summer with the Creek Fire, the amount of fuel loading and the negative impact that that type of catastrophic event can have in this region, in our community, even without the actual fire in our community, the impact of the smoke and other elements were definitely there.

24:23 Just enhancing the level of services we provide to the community. This last year, we were able to move our police department forward back to a 24-7 coverage throughout the week and throughout the year. Also, our building activity was pretty amazing, even with the COVID and activities there. The total activity was on par with 2019. We were within.

24:47 A few dozen permits or less in terms of having 10 fewer than one year to the next and total permits. We had a couple larger projects last year that created some extra value there, but the activity was quite high. A priority item for the council for a few years was how do we deal with some of the blighted buildings in the community? And here's the La Sierra building and it goes by other names depending on how long you've been in the community, Mayor Salzer.

25:14 Anyway, looking at this as this building taken down and that we have that vacant lot there that much more appealing and marketable for future investment in our community. All of this work, everything we do here is ultimately underpinned by our financial structure here, our financial planning, the operating budget, the process we've used in setting.

25:39 forward goals in ways in a very conservative approach to budgeting. It's provided us the resources and the ability to respond to the emergencies that you've seen that we've been dealing with for the last year. It has enabled us to continue to respond and make capital investments, both in deferred areas as well as in new project areas, as we also leverage other funding sources.

26:04 This is $21.1 million in our general fund this last year, the current fiscal year, down from the previous years with the COVID-managed budget. So definitely continuing to watch that, continuing to tighten our belt in a few different areas as we look at going forward. But I can't stress enough, I think the foundation that this has allowed us to do, as Sandra mentioned, we've put a little over $800,000 into our business community. We have put a similar amount of money.

26:34 into our assistance program for rent and other dollars invested through the emergency responses that we have had. I mentioned this is a brief overview of the overall presentation that we'll have out for the community and others as we look at kind of the last.

26:51 Calendar year and a lot of the major efforts and projects that we've undertaken through the last 12 months. It's always amazing to me if you walk back through these of how many things have been accomplished within the community and within the town and the efforts out there. And this just touches on some of the larger items. There's been a lot of other work going on while we've still managed a worldwide localized pandemic. With that, I'd be glad to answer any questions Council may have.

27:20 Regarding this and look forward to the final product coming out for your reading pleasure. Any questions or comments on Dan's presentation? I just have a comment, Mr. Mayor, if I may. Yep. And that is that it's nice to be reminded that something happened last year besides COVID-19. This is, you know, really gratifying to see that, you know.

27:50 The work continued. We had some projects that were completed and that this is sort of a documentation and letting us look at it in retrospect and for the future being able to look back and go, oh, that's right, that was that year and this is what else we got done beside that. So thank you for putting this together. I know we do it every year but I think it's particularly meaningful this year. I appreciate your work on it. Any other questions or comments? John?

28:18 Just an observation, Lynda, certainly to echo all your comments, all the great things the town has gotten accomplished this year. But I think it's also a not so subtle reminder, indicator to the council that despite COVID, despite the challenges of that pandemic, that the needs and the challenges of this community, they march on and they're marching on with a whole lot of energy.

28:40 And I know that Dan and Bill, I think you've been talking about trying to get us together for some strategic work and kind of a regroup of what's going to be in front of us. And we've got, we are working with an excellent team. And I think we just, given the opportunity to provide guidance and a little leadership and some direction, I think we can start dealing with the things coming our way. And certainly the summer of 2021 is going to be something that I'm already getting calls about. I'm sure you are as well, but I'm looking forward to engaging with that. But congratulations to Dan and the team for just...

29:09 Great work and to be carrying on and to face a lot of adversity. Thank you. Any other comments, Sarah or Kirk? Just echoing your comments, John and Linda. It's nice to know we can walk and chew gum at the same time. Thanks for the presentation. Thank you, Dan. I think everyone's covered pretty much my comments. The world goes on regardless what emergencies occur around us, and we need to remember that and plan for that. So keep moving forward.

29:46 Those things being said, we will move on to assessment and prioritization of mobility planning. And I will remind you, in reality, this is not a prioritization exercise tonight. This is a presentation by staff and an ask as to whether we want them to move forward or not. With that, I will turn it over to Hayes. Thank you, Mr. Mayor, and very well said.

30:12 Having an introduction to a potential planning process, I'm going to introduce you to a couple ideas and key issues and so forth. And I hope you can see my slideshow. Got it. Perfect. Now let's make sure I can actually operate it with all these screens open. So we're going to go over some of the issues related to town wind mobility. Again, this is just a presentation on kind of an introductory.

30:36 And I'll be looking for comments and direction related to the development of what I'm calling a Mobility Master Plan. So I want to go over some of our previous work. I want to identify some of the key issues, discuss why the Mobility Master Plan could provide solutions, share some opportunities and needs, and talk about budget and staffing.

31:02 I want to be clear that this isn't intended to prioritize or discuss all of the town's issues like storm drains or recreation or all these other items. This is really strictly focused on our mobility needs. So background, we have a lot of really good planning documents. And I think it's important to recognize that we have done a lot of really good work over the last decade, decade and a half. And this is a very truncated list, but it's...

31:29 Pretty comprehensive trail system planning, mobility element, walk, bike, ride, downtime revitalization, transit, mobility, it goes on and on. We've done some really good things in the planning sphere. And we've leveraged those planning documents. We've leveraged those planning documents to build infrastructure. Sidewalks around schools. In order to get Safe Routes funding, we had to have pet plans. To get ETA, EEMP, ATP funding, we had to have bicycle and trail plans. Main Street on sidewalks.

31:58 It can be said that that's a result of our downtown revitalization. That plan really put us over the edge. Work in transit stops, transit shelters, all the work we did for municipal signage and wayfinding led to a project. So we've done a good job of taking what we planned and implementing it. But we also have some issues with all these planning documents. And we have a need to better organize and consolidate these planning documents. And some of the key issues are really a lack of cohesive implementation strategy.

32:28 These documents are oftentimes quite siloed. There's a lack of project prioritization across these documents, and a lot of the documents really don't have a strong methodology to determine a priority or a metric to evaluate the success of a project. There are some conflicting goals and some changes that need to be made between the plans. There are a few gaps in some of our planning work.

32:52 A lot of these plans are really difficult to update. They've been adopted. They've gone through CEQA. And it's a very arduous process to update just one, let alone the battery of documents that we have. So they're diving in a little bit deeper. So the cohesive strategy, really the kind of, you know, why and how.

33:14 We believe that this MMP strategy really needs to span all of our existing documents, and it needs to incorporate the goals and objectives in a cohesive manner and really help us to focus on our priorities. A lot of our existing plans often focus on only one vote, and that those implementation measures held in those plans are only, you know, focused on that one vote, and that's not helpful when you're trying to prioritize against different documents.

33:41 We're also missing, you know, a strategy for ongoing monitoring and regular updates. We do a good job of collecting data. You saw Joel just a minute ago, post-program, we've got data on it. How are we leveraging that? And then we need to have a hierarchy of our goals. Prioritization, we went back through and cataloged all of the projects and all of our adopted and accepted mobility plans. And that list is over 250 projects long.

34:11 And those projects align with a lot of different strategies. And I can tell you that there's a number of projects we're discussing right now and that are on the books today that are not in any of these plans that are priorities. We need to have a methodology to look at those long lists of projects to determine which ones are the highest priorities. We need some kind of metrics, some way to address that, whether that's some type of cost benefit, looking at the value, how it's going to strategically advance our goals.

34:40 And then we need to sit there and look at how successful that was, if it's actually meeting our goals, and then learn from that. Take that information and apply it to future planning exercises to make sure that we're continuing to do the best work possible and putting our limited resources in the projects that will benefit the community the most. And then we need to really work on our commitment to follow through.

35:02 Projects take a long time to advance, and if we have a great idea, we need to be steadfast and work towards those goals, knowing that they're going to have the best impact for all of us. Quickly on conflicts and gaps I'm not going to dive into, I had a couple examples in the staff report, but we'd like to try to resolve some of these issues and try to build some of these conflicts and turn them into, you know, the hierarchy of goals and so forth and make sure it's very clear what we're trying to accomplish.

35:30 And then we should try to coordinate some of these changes with other town documents. And I'm speaking to like the municipal code or town standards, making sure that we have not only a strategy across all planning documents, but it's actually feeding into some of our other documents that are more codified and can actually influence different types of change. We need to be a little bit more dynamic in some of our gaps in our planning work. We need to look to new technologies.

35:58 A lot of things have changed since we've adopted a lot of these plans. There's a lot of new technology out there, a lot of intelligent transportation systems that we could be leveraging. We also need to be focused on new trends. When we wrote some of these plans, micromobility wasn't a thing. E-bikes were not on the radar. We need to make sure we're addressing that. We're planning for it. We're providing the infrastructure that's appropriate for our community and our visitors. And we also could do some additional work with our partners at the Forest Service. We have a lot of overlap.

36:28 And there's some gaps where we can work together to really solve some key issues on the fringe of our town. Also working with our partners at Caltrans, addressing some of the, you know, green sticker stuff, over snow vehicle staging, OHV. These things are very popular and they really don't fall into our mobility categories in a lot of these documents. We also have opportunities to advance our airport planning conversations. You know, a lot of the decisions regarding air service are not made by the owner and operator of our airport.

36:56 And maybe we want to talk about changing updates. And this is really, really important. This is really the key in this planning exercise is to develop a document that we can review and update regularly so that we can be nimble, we can assess priorities, and we can adapt to change. And then we need to use this MMP, like I said, to inform other documents. This will roll up. And I don't know where this document is ultimately going to live in the hierarchy of our existing town documents. This could replace the mobility element. It could be

37:28 An executive summary that's off to the side that's accepted. There's a lot of different ways we could use this, and I don't have those answers yet. I'm just introducing the concept right now. But there's a lot of value in doing this type of work. So development. If we decide to move forward, be right up front with you guys, this is going to take time, it's going to take staffing, and it's going to take resources. This is a pretty monumental, heavy lift to consolidate all of this really great work we've done and really focus our attention.

37:59 We are going to need a lot more direction from Town Council and probably our commissions and the public. And that hasn't been figured out yet, but we need, we're going to need a little bit more, we're going to work together to advance this. And then we'll need to understand that this is going to be dynamic. If it takes us a year and a half or two years to put this together, things will change in the interim. We need to continue doing the work we're doing and advancing additional projects. And I outlined in the staff report a number of projects that

38:29 Internally, as staff, we believe are pretty high priority looking at what we have kind of based on the success we've had with other projects. And the reason I put that in there is we're going to add these to our CIP and have a little bit more conversation about those projects. I don't want to focus on this tonight, but I just want to introduce this, that we need to add some projects to our CIP. We need to start advancing some of these things. We're moving into a stiff cycle. There's money out on the table. We need to make sure that we're working towards some common goals.

38:58 While we haven't gone through this holistic planning exercise to have all these great tools at our disposal, I think we can intuitively work together and identify some projects that will have great benefit to the community. And I'm speaking to some key maps, some gaps we know about, some sidewalk gaps that we know about, working to implement mobility hub opportunities. I think that this hub study is going to daylight a couple of obvious opportunities that we can leverage.

39:26 Transit system improvements, and this is going to sound like a sales pitch, but every time we put together a grant application or evaluate it, we're always looking for ways to improve the transit user experience. We really believe as staff, at least the public work staff, that improvements to transit and that providing information, better apps, information in transit stops about the real-time location and timing of the buses will really improve transit.

39:55 We're exploring micromobility. I don't want to get too far ahead, but we have a potential partner that could implement micromobility. We're talking scooters, scooter share system as soon as this summer. And we want to continue to work on high impact areas. I'm talking about the lake space and I'm talking about shady grass. I'm talking about these really well-known things. I do not want to show those in advance of working on a document. We need to continue to work on these key issues in parallel with this exercise.

40:24 And then again, finally, like I mentioned, we need to evaluate this as all as part of the CIP and we'll bring this back. Budget and staffing. I am proposing to leverage local transportation planning funds. The LTC manages through the town and the county regional planning assistance and program planning and monitoring funds. These dollars are strictly for planning. And we've used them for a lot of different things over the year, but I believe...

40:52 That this time, this is probably our best use of those funds. I have proposed for the LTC $100,000 allocation to kind of kick off this project. I believe if it's not going to hit on this Monday's agenda, it will definitely be on the following agenda to have that dialogue as Jerry and his team introduce the overall work program. And I'm also recommending hiring either a contract staff person, which would be the stronger of the two recommendations, or a consultant.

41:22 I think this project would really benefit from having someone embedded in staff, someone who's living mobility in this town that can help to really, you know, make good policy decisions or make good policy recommendations and really understand how the system works. I think there's some really great consultants out there, but they're going to be working as an outsider. So that's just my personal opinion. And I think working with Dan, there's a couple of ways we could do that on a contract basis so we don't have the long-term financial obligation.

41:53 So with that, I'm happy to field any questions, but before I do, I do just want to mention it's probably a little odd that the Public Works Director is giving a planning presentation. We had a lot on this agenda, so there was a little bit of a divide and conquer to cover all the bases. So moving forward, this will probably end up living with Sandra with really strong support from the Public Works Department. But I just want to point that out.

42:21 I'm happy to help out. I'm really passionate about this stuff, but ultimately it's probably going to move over to Planning Department. So with that, I'm happy to field any questions that you may have. Thank you, Hayes. So let's go to start with questions and I'll come back for comments. Sarah, let's start with you this time today. I don't have any questions. I feel like thank you so much, Hayes, for that.

42:50 Yeah, I'd just really like to hear what the rest of the council has to say. I feel a little too green at this to ask too many questions at this point. Perfect. Thank you, Sarah. Kirk. Unmute, Kirk. Keep moving forward. I think this is an excellent direction. It needs to be done. And the impacts, you know, the reduction of the traffic, the use of different modalities is just great.

43:26 Thank you. Thank you, Kirk. John? Hi, Hayes. Thanks for a really excellent presentation and something the council requested at our last meeting, and I think you really did a great job. Thank you very much. I don't have any questions at this point, Mr. Mayor. I have a number of comments and ideas and suggestions, but we'll get to those after your public comment. Thank you. Thank you. Linda? So, Hayes, thank you. This was really illuminating to see that we have eight distinct and separate

43:58 Plans that go back as far as I think it was 2009 with the trail system master plan. And the discussion we've been having lately, you know, that was, you know, coordinating these plans together. In other towns and cities, have they, I mean, have you experienced, you know, watching other entities go through the same thing? Like you have all these plans and all of a sudden, not all of a sudden, but, you know, the realization comes about that

44:27 These plans stand alone. They don't necessarily stand all together. We need to back up and put ourselves back in a command position over all these different documents. And is that, I mean, have we about reached the saturation point of plans before these just become really just not even possible to try to coordinate them? Yeah, a couple things.

44:55 One that's a truncated list. The actual list of plans is much longer. I just kind of was hitting the highlights. I did a fair amount of research looking at what other cities have done. And I think what has happened here is we are honestly still a pretty young city. And it's only been the last 15 years or so. We really have done some real advancement in our planning. We had a trail system planned back in 1991. When I started here, we had a sidewalk plan. I refer to it as the sidewalk master page because it was literally.

45:24 One page. And so we've done some, like I said, a lot of really great planning work, but we've been doing it in these, you know, hammering out all these kind of individual components. So we haven't really sat back to like, okay, how does this all work together? And I think we've kind of hit that threshold because we've done a lot of implementation in these silos and now it's kind of getting really difficult to prioritize across them. So I've seen a lot, you know, in my research looking at other cities, I've seen it done as standalone documents. I've seen it as part of the mobility element.

45:52 I've seen it done a number of different ways, and I think, like I said, there's probably a number of ways we could get there, but we'll be looking to advance that conversation and provide the pros and cons of each as we do a little bit more evaluation. I think we understand the issues, but there's probably a number of ways, a number of different solutions. Okay, thank you. No more further questions. Okay, for myself, I have a lot of comments, but I'm going to save my comments until after the public.

46:20 Do we have any public comments on this, Jamie? No, we do not. Thank you. So with that, I will go back. Sarah, would you like me to start at the bottom of the list instead of putting you first? You can hear everybody else's. Sure. Thanks, Bill. Okay. Let's then go comment-wise back with Linda. Oh, sure. Okay. Comments. Yes, I believe that this is something that is sort of coming.

46:52 More and more clear, especially as we've been discussing the parcel and how we coordinate and put these plans together to inform where we want to go with it. My other comment is this is obviously a staff intensive kind of work, whether it's staff or whether it's a consultant, and there is a cost associated with that. And so I'd like to sort of get a handle on that.

47:18 The comparison and the strategy around our other competing priorities. I think that's really important. What else has been on the burner for a while is cooking, and we want to finish that before we jump into this and how critical it is right now to do this as opposed to some of the other projects we have. There's certainly no hesitation on my part that this is a priority.

47:46 This master mobility plan is clearly needed and clearly an element going forward that's going to inform how we continue to build and how we continue to think about the way we move around town, the priority of trying to get cars off the roads and onto feet and onto, you know, two pedals or, you know, as you said, micro, what did you call that, micro mobility? Micro mobility. Yeah, all good things, but, you know, cost, staff time and coordination.

48:15 One more big project to take on, the pros and cons of that, and what else do we want to consider as far as big priorities? I think those are my main comments right now. So thank you. Thank you, Lynda. John. Thank you, Bill. Thank you, Hayes. Thank you, Sandra. So I got a couple more kind of specific requests. First off, I completely support this. I think this is a...

48:50 Enormously important initiative and Hayes, I very much appreciate your understanding and indication that this is probably going to live in planning. I think there's going to be a number of policy things that we're going to need to make sure we get into our regs, get into our adopted policy stuff so as more and future development projects come forward, we've got things we can point to for conditions of approval and other kinds of things we get that stuff kind of taken care of.

49:16 And I know that the Public Works Department is going to do an excellent job with all the implementation of all this stuff, but having that policy stuff right up front is going to be really important. So that when big, important projects come into town, they want to develop, we can say, look, this is how we're going to be moving people around in town. So I think it's going to be really important. A couple little favors to ask. On the LTC side, as you're no doubt aware, there's been a significant change in the membership of the LTC.

49:41 And I think it would be really helpful if we could get together. I'm now the vice chair. Bill is just getting on that commission. Jennifer Burroughs is getting on there. Dan's been there for a while to get together with you and just maybe have a little sort of an overview from the town's perspective, what the LTC is, how it functions.

49:58 When you make a mention that there's potentially $100,000 in the LTC, that's a completely reasonable amount of money given the kinds of dollars that the LTC traffics in. So I think it'd be really helpful to get the talent team together and let us all understand how it works and what to expect and what not to expect because it's an enormously important resource.

50:20 And another favor I think would be really helpful as we go forward as we get into planning documents and maps, either from the planning department or public works. Let's make sure we represent all of the mobility infrastructure on those maps. Get the mops on there, get the sidewalks in there. So it's just, it's an expectation of council that every time we see a map, the mobility infrastructure represented, because that's going to be very helpful for our decision making.

50:46 We've got something on the consent agenda coming up, just again to get to the council's attention. State requirements, ESTA, electric buses. We are in the state of California. The state of California is not messing around. Governor Newsom in his proposed budget has proposed about $1.5 billion year mark to help people and businesses purchase electric or hydrogen vehicles and equipment and to invest in construction and maintenance of charging and fueling infrastructure.

51:14 You know, General Motors has announced they will not be building any more carbon-based, you know, gasoline-powered automobiles by, what is it, 2035, I think. So this, it is so timely to be doing this because we're in California, and Sandra can speak to the leadership that Town of Mammoth Lakes has shown in terms of our safety element, our housing elements, our adoption of general plans. We're leading the state in many ways in this space. It's great for us to be an example of this stuff going forward.

51:43 Just real quick, John, I don't know if you're aware, but we're actually demoing an electric bus in less than two weeks. Oh, awesome. Can you please, I would, man, I would love to put my mask on and go out there and go for a ride. I want to see it and pick the tires. I want to see how this thing works. It's actually going to be running a route. We're actually, we're really putting it to the test. And then our crew is going to go kick the tires on it and poke into the hood and ask a bunch of questions.

52:09 I'll talk to those putting out on and see if there's an opportunity for council participation. That would be so helpful. And also for members of the LTC, because you know YARDS, the Yosemite Area Rapid Transit System, I think is what the acronym stands for. They're going to have requirements for electric buses. I mean, this is happening, folks. It's going to be great to get us all in with that. And, you know, I finally just want a particular...

52:34 Challenge we're going to have is that we're going to, this is being one of those build the plane while we fly it kind of things. And we're going to have to figure out a way to make sure that those policy things, as projects or individual things come forward, Sandra, you and Hayes, you guys can figure out how to bring things forward. They're going to be germane to the projects as they come forward. We would very much, you know, make these things conditions of approval, get those things involved in the development process. That's going to be challenging.

53:02 But we're not going to be able to wait two years to get this thing done. We're going to have to figure out how to build it as we fly. But I really appreciate your help, your work, Hayes and Sandra, both of you on this bringing this forward and how much I know and how much you guys believe this is truly, really, really important for the future of the community. So anything we can do to help move this forward. And again, that meeting with the LTC group, I think we can really give you some cover.

53:25 Provide some policy direction in that form to access those resources, those dollars, and then move all that stuff forward. So thank you. Really appreciate it. I'm very excited to move forward on this. Thank you. Thank you, John. Kirk. Thank you, Bill. I don't know when we need to have – I support this. I think it's important. But when you look at – you know, we need two extra bays down at the – at least the staff told me that.

53:55 A new blower, all these different things, all these different projects and everything else. Seems that we should have a master list of capital projects and purchases that we need to, you know, I think Hayes has it, but I don't think, you know, it's been presented to us partly so the community can understand that we're making choices. That's my confidence. Thank you, Kirk. So for me, let me drag out my 42.

54:25 Thank you for notes here. One, just because I'm me, micromobility. So is that like saying, beat me up, Scotty? That's like the line bikes or Uber bikes or bird scooters. It's more of the share programs that are available. And a lot of...

54:52 Larger cities and actually a lot of communities like ours that have high tourist rates. Yeah, and I have seen those things in those cities. And those cities without snow have huge problems with them getting left in places they don't belong. And so hopefully before we go down that road, we have made such a plan as to prevent. We have a whole set of issues there that Long Beach, as an example, doesn't have.

55:22 And I know Long Beach has had huge problems with their scooter and their bike sharing program. So just to start with, I want to start my comments off. When the town started, there were no multi-use trails and there were no sidewalks in reality because the county never required them. We have done a great job of building this system, not through prioritization as people thought we should.

55:51 But through availability of funds to build what we had planned for. If we would have stuck to the original list and prioritization process, we wouldn't have three quarters of the trails we have. So I reiterate every time we go through these exercises, the need for complete flexibility. If the meridian to Main Street on Minaret Road is a priority.

56:19 But there's no funding source for it, and we have funding source for something else, then that would become my priority. When we make these plans, an awful lot of people think they're written in stone and therefore come after us if we don't follow our prioritization schedule. So that's just, that's huge for me. We have to be careful as we sell this that it's not because this is our number one priority, this is absolutely what we're going to do first.

56:47 And we're not going to do anything else until we can get there. That's a huge fear of mine. I've seen it in the past. In any mobility study we do in Mammoth, first, I'm being negative here. Let me say I absolutely want this to move forward. If we can replace 14 other planning documents with one well-done planning document, man, I am in support of that every single time. But recreation is hugely important in any mobility plan we do.

57:18 We have motorized recreation, non-motorized recreation, equestrian. We have trailhead needs. We have mobility hub needs that can actually link with the trailheads. If you don't include recreation, you do a half-page plan. So incredibly important to me that access to our non-built environment is as critical as access to the built environment. Parking.

57:49 One of the original studies that goes back to the town's inception, the gentleman who was the presenter said something that is still in my brain today. A pedestrian, or for that matter, a bicycle, is nothing more than a driver who has found a parking spot. So because we create these great mobility, we've seen with North Village and everything else, mobility is not going to be the solution for parking. We still have to find places for these cars.

58:19 And I am deathly afraid that we're going to go back and say, we don't need this project to have parking because we're going to use the mobility and buses and transportation to get them there. So that is huge. I am in favor of doing the contract staff over a consultant because, Hayes, I agree with you, we need this to be somebody who knows the community and works with staff and knows staff.

58:48 To get something that is Mammoth-centric and not something that you can plunk down in El Segundo as well as Mammoth. We have our own very special and critical needs. Linda, you made reference to prioritizing all the different plans and things out there. Dan and I are in talks now for how we can bring forward, without hiring outside consultants and everything else, a workshop for the council.

59:16 To go over our prioritization and our little piece that we have for that because it's been since 18, I think, and it's time for us to update that. That being said, last thing, this may well live in planning, Hais, but this is critical that all the departments are involved, from park and recreation to...

59:44 Everybody has got to be involved in planning and implementing this thing or it just doesn't work. Planning by itself isn't going to know what the snowmobilers or off-highway vehicle people need for trails or what the cross-country skiing public is looking for or the dog-walking public or, you know, I can go on and on and on. So with that, I think I've covered my little notes here and I would move on to Sarah. Thanks, Bill.

1:00:15 Good points. You know, I just, a couple things come to mind. Mainly that, you know, Hayes' comment that we are a young city is important to note because, you know, Los Angeles is built on freeways, right? So everyone drives everywhere because that was the mode of transportation. So it's all drive-throughs. It's all totally, you know, taken for...

1:00:41 Granted that you're going to be spending 45 minutes in the car to get anywhere. I personally hate driving. When I go on vacation somewhere, I like to park my car and I like to walk. That being said, Mammoth historically doesn't have a... I remember like working in restaurants and people would say, where's the town? Where's the downtown? Where's the place where everything is? And it's like, well, we've kind of got the village and we've kind of got...

1:01:09 And so I think that this is important because if we use this as a basis for our future growth, we're thinking about how we develop based around mobility that's not by par. So yes, I think it's really important to have that base. That being said, I will also just add

1:01:39 When I hear the word consultant, my ears kind of prick up. So I would love to avoid that if possible. But I do realize this takes a lot of staff time. So that's really all I have to add to the conversation. Thank you, Sarah. John. Just one clarifying comment, Bill. I wanted to follow up on your comments about recreation. Hayes, this is really, this is not...

1:02:06 Actually, new planning. This is a roll-up of everything we already have. Is that fair to say? I think it could be whatever we need it to be. Just on that point, though, my assumption is that when we mention we've got all these planning documents that already exist, and we're trying to establish if there's overlap or they're duplicative, that we're going to be rolling up what we've already got.

1:02:30 So that's the assumption I'm making as I support this, but also, Bill, to your point on the recreation side of this and the recreation audience, between what's in the trail system master plan already, what's in the walk-bike-ride plan already, I'm very confident that the needs of the recreation users, those, they're articulated, they are in those plans. So I don't, there's no need to go out and redo that or rethink that. It's already in those plans.

1:02:58 Was very involved in both of them, actually, and I've been reading them again recently. I'm very confident that all the stuff we need to get this community connected to this recreation opportunities is in those plans. So, Hais, that goes back to this idea of assuming this is a roll-up, it's a cleanup, it's kind of sorting it out and figuring out if you've got 250 projects, how many unique projects do you have in that 250 that aren't actually the same thing that's said in two different documents, that kind of stuff.

1:03:26 That's the assumption I'm making going forward. But I think that, Bill, the recreation stuff is well covered between the trail system and the water pipe. Thank you, John. Any further comments from Council? Is there any staff which is to weigh in on this other than, as it's a very important thing, other than Hayes? And that would probably be Sarah or Sandra or Dan.

1:03:54 Yeah, just to follow up on that, just the last comment by Councilmember Wentworth, I think that as we go through all of these plans, as Hayes kind of alluded to, we may see plans where one plan says something and other plan says something a little bit different. So those are the types of times when we would kind of bring that forward and say, well, we've got these, I don't want to call them conflicts, but we've got these policies that are different. How should we move forward with those types of things?

1:04:23 But I don't have any other comments. Thank you. Andrew, thank you. This is Dan. I think the only other thing I would add to this is we look at this, we're rolling up plans, we're looking at the connection points into a lot of the comments made. This may fall into use of the LTC work. A lot of our transportation systems don't start or end in the town of Mammoth Lakes.

1:04:49 And so how do we look beyond into our federal partners? How do we look into the county side? How do our trail systems and staff fully aware of this? How do we end up connecting people in the environments we live and work and play and be able to move people around? And whether that's, again, to the recreational side, the OHV, OSVs, you know, they may stage in Mammoth Lakes, but they play in the county or beyond. I think it's vital that we look at our mobility element.

1:05:17 One, how do we serve our residents? How do we help them move through our community in an effective way? But also, how do we reach out to those residents who are playing, enjoying, and having a great time here? Again, keep your vehicle, but let's see how much you can not drive it and have a great time. And then with our visitors, as they come in, a majority driving up in the Southern California market, how do they park their car once and have access to all the things that we've been talking about? You know, whether it's a trail or a bike or a...

1:05:47 Gondola or it's sidewalk and they can get down to a different restaurant and all those different elements begin to feed together in a coordinated system. I think it's a lot of work. It's a great vision out there. And then it's really put on the ground one project at a time as we have dollars available as we tie to it. But it's building to that vision. It's not just kind of willy nilly going, but a lot of different moving parts there. And I think it was to Linda's point.

1:06:14 Ultimately, these priorities in this mobility site have to fit into the other priorities of town. How does that work in with our street maintenance or to Kirk's comment? How does that work in with our parks maintenance? How does that work in with our staging areas and our parking and our restrooms and all the other issues that we deal with day in and day out? How was that connection point with the airport that was mentioned?

1:06:35 And again, all those things ultimately feed in together. So I think it's a great opportunity to build off of that as we look to the future in this, but at the same time this next summer, what are going to be those top two, three, four items that, you know, the council prioritizes out and says, hey, we have funding for this, we have funding for this, let's make those things happen. And that they're happening in the context of the work that we're doing, so they're connected together. So thank you. Thank you, Jen.

1:07:03 We've already asked for public comments here, so I will move forward on the agenda. Let me just real quick on that. I believe we have pretty good consensus in terms of support to move this forward. We'll bring back, as we deal with the prioritization, how we pull it together and be able to figure out how we want to staff it, etc. Yeah, Dan, I took that sort of for granted. I probably should have asked.

1:07:31 I didn't see any of the councilmen say anything other than they supported moving this forward, so. Thank you. Yeah. So moving to consent. Approve the minutes of the regular meeting of January 20. Approve the resolution continuing the local emergency regarding COVID-19 declared on March 18, 2020. Approve subscription agreement with eScribe for streaming and agenda management service for the meeting. Way of the reading and adopt by title only the ordinance amending

1:08:03 Municipal Code Title VI, Animals. Approval resolution granting town manager signature authority for cow recycle payment programs. Resolution providing $50,000 in support to Inyo Mono for community action to support food distribution required under the public health pandemic. Approve the letter of support for Eastern Sierra Transit authorities grant regarding electric vehicles and accept payment approval reports.

1:08:33 Number 21-31 and 21-32. Does anyone wish to pull anything from consent? Seeing none, I would ask for a motion. Kirk? So moved. Proof the consent items. Consent agenda item 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, and 10. Mr. Mayor, I'd like to second that.

1:09:04 Just to point out that there's a very important item number five for the e-scribe, and I believe there's going to be a demonstration for the town council about that. Very much looking forward to that. Very important for our public engagement. And so happy to hear Hayes sharing that opportunity to ride on an electric bus. Very much looking forward to that. That's tied to that letter of support for item number nine. So I will second the consent agenda. Thank you.

1:09:30 Thank you, John. I have a motion from Kirk, a second from John. Any further deliberations? Jamie? Councilmember Rae? Councilmember Stapp? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Councilmember Wentworth? You're muted, John. You're muted. I'm muted. I'm sorry. Yes. My apologies. Mayor Pro Tem Salcido? Yes. Mayor Sauser? Yes. Passes 5-0. Moving on to policy matters.

1:10:04 Number 11, discussion update and possible action related to COVID-19, public health and economic emergency and the management and response. Dan. Yes, thank you, Mr. Mayor. We'll kind of do a quick walkthrough of an update of where we're at and the focus over the next several weeks as we look to the future. Highlight very quickly our Community First programs continuing, some of the local trends we're seeing out there in cases, some of the actions we're taking. We've got some additional guidance on schools.

1:10:35 Where we're at in testing. And then the primary focus as we're looking at the next several weeks is in the area of vaccination. So I'll try to go through this pretty quickly and then open up for comments and questions that the council may have. Our community first programs are continuing with rental assistance. Sandra mentioned the business assistance program earlier. Between the two of those, we have put close to $1.6, $1.8 million or more into the community.

1:11:10 I think it's been a great investment, and that includes Mono County, not just the town of Mammoth Lakes, as we make that investment. The coordination with IMACA has been great. I know they did a food distribution yesterday again. We do have funding helping them out in the work that they're doing there to be able to pick up that need in our community. And then the ongoing support through the R2R program for those who are in quarantine or isolation and encouraging them to serve that full.

1:11:39 Time there to make sure they're safe and healthy before they go back into the community. We're seeing the trends actually improving in Mono County for our percent positivity and our case rate. This is out of the information here from the state blueprint that they do each week. They do an update, but it's a backward look, a seven day back look with a seven day lag there. So this was for the week ending 123.

1:12:08 Our positivity rate of cases was at 9.1%. It's good to see it down in single digit. And our case rate was just a hair below 30 on terms of an average daily case rate. The hospital continues to function normally, being able to take on all sorts of needs and demands there as may come forward. The positive thing here is that trend line is moving down. You kind of see the flattening of the line here from our positive case rate.

1:12:38 If you go back to the 27th, we were at 896 and we're at 916 now. So we still have that uptick of cases, but not near the sharp decline we saw earlier in the month. The information here, the information in the chart showing the 916 cases.

1:12:57 The information going into here, there's actually a little note on the website now. This is pulled from a bunch of different data sources, different levels that we get at the county level that ultimately working with the state and CalReady, their program for pulling these numbers together. You will see some differences now and again through the process. And then some of this work here is also manually updated. So that depends on staff availability and time and priority.

1:13:23 If you look at the cases by area, it won't quite add up to the 916 at this point. Mainly that is actually due to a manual process to update that portion of this graphic that is on our website. But I wanted to show this in note because it gives some of the issues and reasons for what we're doing in the town of Mammoth Lakes versus Mono County. As you look at the number of cases there, that 710 cases in the town area.

1:13:50 It begins to represent between 75 to 80 percent of our total caseload coming into the town and obviously on a per capita basis that's a much higher rate than the whole county outside of the two different areas.

1:14:04 And the questions have come up regarding some of the efforts the town has made separately from the county. And some of that is from this exact issue here. We see a different dynamic in terms of the density of our population in the community in the town of Mammoth Lakes, the interactions, the closeness of people being together, all those elements that tend to highlight greater levels of transmission of disease.

1:14:27 So we have that there. We've looked at a lot of different elements. We're definitely watching that and watching our trend lines and those elements to see if we can't be more open in a lot of areas. The most recently enacted area that we've dealt with is in lodging. The guidelines were modified but effective February 1. We basically looked at a 70% daily occupancy level in our various.

1:14:53 Rental products that are out there, be it the hotel, motel, or an Airbnb, different rental platforms. And that applies across the board to the various lodging properties. The one differential is with smaller condo complexes at 10 units or under. The element there is a 21-day limit on a monthly basis.

1:15:16 With the caveat that that needs to include one vacant weekend as well. And all of these have a 24-hour gap requirement between occupancies that has been done to allow for cleaning, for the staffing that goes in and does that type of work for their safety, and also to spread out that impact of people coming in and out of the various lodging properties in the community and hopefully to limit what may or may not be that enhanced level of transmission in those processes.

1:15:46 The other components in the lodging areas follow state guidelines as that relates to hot tubs or saunas and those types of elements or fitness components that are provided in a number of our lodging communities. The guidelines are kind of identified there. Several those are remaining closed. Some outdoor areas are allowed to be opening. I must say as we transitioned out of the regional stay-at-home order,

1:16:12 A number of personal services in the town also open back up. Salons, you know, if you need to have your hair done, get your hair trimmed up. Those are open and going now along with other personal services like that that can be operationally up and going. A lot of emphasis by the state on school openings, school guidance kind of walks through the numbers here. For Mammoth Unified, the grades...

1:16:40 7 to 12 can only open if we get into the red tier. That means we need to get our case rate down to 8% or under and our per capita per 100,000 population, I should say, down to seven cases per 100,000 population, which is basically one a day or a hair less than the averaging out of that number.

1:17:02 There are some movement at the state level and through other rural communities looking at other options that we might go get a hard number versus that level of a tightness to get our schools open again. The case of six can open in the purple tier if the case rate itself drops below 25 cases, 100,000. And again, we're getting closer. As I mentioned, we're just under 30.

1:17:23 Cases for 100,000 at this point. And so those metrics are coming down where they need to be. Hopefully we'll be there in the near future, be able to do that. Ultimately, also a call by the school. They have some reports and filing they have to make to the state to be able to open. The Eastern Sierra Unified School District is able to open as they were open prior to.

1:17:46 The regional stay-at-home order and the other actions taken. And as they were open beforehand, they could reopen again and continue to operate in an open status as they go forward. They did go back into in-seat learning on 119. I know they had a couple of closure days from snow, I believe, in activity, but they are open in in-seat. The other side of that is we really want to continue, and it feeds right back into all of those numbers, is our testing.

1:18:15 Uh, component that's out there. Well, we've restructured that. Uh, it's a simple pre-registration process. Uh, if you have a smartphone or element that you can use the QR code there to pre-register, you can do it on site, uh, especially with the public health testing at the Mammoth Lakes Foundation parking area. Uh, drive through, you know, simple nasal swab, uh, component. Same thing, the Verily testing, you can go online, sign up for that in advance.

1:18:42 And again, the golf course, the different days here in the community that the testing is ongoing. But it's currently so much of that tier system is based on the level of testing we're doing, the number of positive cases versus negative cases, the positivity rate. And to encourage people to continue to work through that testing program is very critical as the measurements and the metrics that we're being held to at this point as we go forward.

1:19:08 A lot of information here on our website, so feel free to get there and take a look at it. The other real drivers vaccination, and I'm very proud of what Mono County is doing, the Public Health Department. We have received close to 5,600 vaccinations, vaccines. This was earlier today, pulling the website up here. It may have been updated later today, so the numbers may be off of here.

1:19:34 First doses administered there, the 3,386 and over 600 second doses been administered at this point. Again, a lot of coordination, a lot of work to set up the vaccination clinics, encouraging people to be informed, to get online, to get pre-register. A lot of information out there. We'll spend a lot more time on this tomorrow evening in a community conversation about the vaccination process and the safety elements of it, et cetera.

1:20:03 And to be able to move people into it. Also, the state has made a shift in its thought process and the prioritization, which actually really helps us. One of the key elements there is vaccinating people of any age with high-risk conditions. I'll speak to those here in a minute. But that rationale change really helps us focus on those that are more vulnerable, who are more likely to have a negative reaction from the COVID disease.

1:20:32 And so how do we not have severe disease or death resulting? There's a whole list of conditions. We'll take a look at that. So this actually has opened up the vaccination to more individuals in our community. So we really want to push that out. We have great collaboration with the hospital and identifying high-risk populations. We have great collaboration with volunteers and others as we bring people together for this.

1:21:02 High-risk conditions put out by the CDC, everything from cancer to smoking, maybe a little causal relationship there. But different elements, if there's kidney disease, I'll touch on some of these, but you can look at this. You know, heart conditions, if there's immune-compromised state, weakened systems from organ transplant, those types of elements, pregnancy, those diabetes, etc. All of these...

1:21:28 Conditions tend to have a worse outcome if somebody is diagnosed with COVID. So the goal there is to get that individuals in, get them vaccinated as we look at hurting our community, if you will, to this disease and the impact it can have here. As we're reminded in one of the public health discussions, smoking is a high category one there. So the best element to fix that would be to quit smoking right after you're vaccinated.

1:21:56 To be able to reduce that threat. And again, you can pre-register, you get in, get in the program. There's a lot of information to get on the website to do that. We are requesting proof of eligibility as people come in now to be tested. We've had folks show up from out of Mono County. They're just assuming they're in town. This is a faster way to get vaccinated the more they live. And we have other folks who are

1:22:23 Not as accurate as we would like them to be in terms of their status and where they work or their conditions in that. So we're looking for information here, again, a soft glove approach, but really trying to, yeah, are you a Mono County resident or employee in Mono County that's in one of our high-risk areas, such as our restaurant workers or medical service, public safety?

1:22:49 And looking for information, very broad types of outreach that we can do that way. But it would really help if we can narrow that down. Again, our focus is first and foremost on our community here in Mono County versus those who may be a second homeowner or transition through the community. So second homeowners are not eligible. We've had some show up at our vaccination clinics. I think some of them have probably been vaccinated, but also then.

1:23:17 Others just wanting to do it here because of the speed, the success that we have in the program. Some of the challenges with all of this, of course, if you're not a Mono County resident, the reminder is this is a two-shot process. So once you get your first shot, you have to be back in either three or four weeks, depending on the vaccination for that second shot to have that happen. Again, a lot more information on that on our website there.

1:23:42 And we really do appreciate people's willingness to comply and understanding our focus on our community. Real quick, just got a little conclusion in this element. A lot of serious conditions out there still. We're still very concerned in a number of areas. That is why we're pushing vaccination as a highest priority at this point. We have a great system set up with paid staff, volunteers, others.

1:24:10 Really getting that out there as a way of protecting people from the harm of COVID and what happens through that. Our biggest challenge may be supply in terms of actually getting vaccines in. Right now we're in good shape. We want to be able to demonstrate that we're utilizing and moving through vaccines as they're made available to us. And then it looks like the data, at least to date, the new strains are out there that adds some uncertainty, but it does appear that vaccinations do help.

1:24:39 Protect against the new strains of the virus that are making their way into the U.S. and different places. We also look forward to additional vaccines coming on the market. There's several of them that are close to being approved as well. So hopefully we're able to move through that. As I mentioned before, the testing continues to be an area of concern because we need to have those numbers in there and how we're being graded at this point for things we can move into.

1:25:06 And then the contact investigation and contact tracing, that work and following up on people of where did you have an exposure? Have you exposed other people? How do we continue that to sustain work in that effort and have people responsive and working through that? And then the ongoing, just the basic preventive measures, you know.

1:25:28 You know, the whole idea of distance, you know, stay home unless you don't, unless you have to be out for work, you've got to be out shopping and do certain things like that, but reduce that interaction with other people, working with your own households. And again, face coverings, washing, and again, just distance as you're in different elements. I believe LA announced today for Super Bowl weekend, they are opening the outdoor dining areas up and asking the restaurants to shut their televisions off so they don't have large groups gathering out.

1:25:57 Watching, if you will, through the windows or speakers, etc. That is a concern coming up. I would expect to have a lot of Super Bowl parties going on and activities and again, start to become the concern for those spiking in those types of areas. And I know a lot of people, there's just fatigue over the whole situation. But if we can look out over the next two, three, four months.

1:26:22 And really be able to move our vaccination program through to be able to continue to monitor and isolate the cases as we can and be vigilant in our activities. A lot more information to come on these areas tomorrow evening is our next community conversation at 530. Again, we provide this information regularly in terms of information that's out there. Check out the website. There's information here.

1:26:50 Other code compliance issues and those types of elements that come forward. Sign up for the newsletter. It comes out twice a week. Great information in there and a lot of detail and where to go for more information as well. The majority of this information we're putting out, if not all of it, is the idea is get out in English and Spanish as we reach out to our full community. With that, I'd be glad to answer any questions, provide additional data as necessary.

1:27:20 Stu Brown has been doing a heck of a job for us in our joint information system, putting information out. So he's well versed in a number of these things as well. Appreciate his assistance in putting these types of presentations together. Thank you, Stu. So with that. Thank you, Dan. Any questions or comments on Dan's presentation? We'll do questions and comments together for this. Sarah?

1:27:50 Just again, and I've said this before, huge props to the county public health for getting so many vaccines done. It's really hopeful and everyone I've talked to has said what a great process it was. So thanks to everyone who's led to hand with that. Thank you, Sarah. Kirk? No, you just remuted. Okay, sorry. I think we're doing a good job. I've gone down and got vaccination.

1:28:27 So I thank everybody that's done a lot of work. Thank you, Kirk. John? Mona County Health, our favorite injector, are doing a fabulous job. And it's our ace in the hole to be able to avoid hopefully the worst implications of this pandemic. I do want to, you know, shout out.

1:28:58 For the editorial page of the sheet last week, which provided a very insightful series of comments. I just quoted a couple of things to keep us all, keep everybody grounded with stay-at-home orders being lifted and all that kind of stuff. Inyo County Public Health Officer James Robertson told Inyo supervisors Tuesday that if one of these new, more infectious COVID strains takes hold, there's exponential impact.

1:29:24 If a strain is 50% more infectious, you said you'll have twice the number of cases in two weeks and a four to five fold increase in cases within a month. This courtesy of Harvard epidemiologist Mark Lipschitz, one of the experts, Richardson says he relies upon.

1:29:38 Richardson isn't the only one. Another public health official speaking on condition of anonymity said, you can learn a lot by looking around the globe by getting your heads up and looking down range once in a while. Germany, Sweden, Denmark, Israel, the UK, their numbers are down, but they are all extending strict public health orders. It looks like the water is receding, but don't be fooled. There's a big wave coming. And finally, infectious disease expert, Michael Osterholm, Director of the Center for Infectious Disease Research and Policy.

1:30:05 The University of Minnesota, I believe he's now working with the Biden administration, said Tuesday in an interview with Anderson Cooper, he fears the United States is about to enter its darkest weeks of the coronavirus pandemic yet, specifically the next six to 14 weeks. Richardson's best advice, staying away from people is 100% effective. So let's, we're doing great work. Let's not get involved. And at some point, Dan, as part of these COVID presentations, we'd be ready to start talking about what's going to happen in the summer of 2021.

1:30:35 I know that's all on our radar, but we've got some big work to do there. So those are my thoughts. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. And Bill, you're muted, just so you know. Someone rang my doorbell. So I'm going to now move on to Linda. But before I do, I want to thank her once again for her superhuman effort with the health department and being a council member in helping us to get these vaccines out there. She is the one that put the first dose in my arm. And Linda, thank you. And your comments and questions.

1:31:11 You're rather welcome. A couple comments. There's a few little rumors out there that I just wanted to hit on really quick. Number one is after you've had two vaccines and you've waited two weeks, you don't have to wear a mask anymore. That is not true. You are not 100% protected from anything, nor do we know for sure whether or not you can transmit that disease on, even if you're not ill. So if someone tells you they don't have to...

1:31:38 Wear a mask because they've had the vaccine, run away quickly and yell behind you, put your mask on. So that's what you need to do. The second thing is I heard in a meeting this morning, someone say that the employees that she knows got their second shot and they got sick. And so they were sick and they couldn't come to work. That's not true. The vaccine does not make you sick. What you feel is your body doing an amazing job of

1:32:07 Thank you so much.

1:32:36 I want to change that because I don't want that to discourage anyone from coming to get their vaccine. It's actually a colossal experience to think about as your body is fighting away and doing all these amazing things. So if you take a look at that, it's actually pretty cool. So anyway, that's all I got.

1:32:57 Thank you everyone in our community who has helped make these vaccines happen from the town and all their people, Stu and the JIC getting everything out with that group. John Urdi from MLT brought his volunteers who had been working at the food bank forward and have been staffing all over the county.

1:33:18 They were up in Walker last Saturday. It was a two and a half hour drive up there the day after on Saturday after the storms. Then have been at every clinic. We're getting help from Sandra DiMizio, who initially volunteered her time to help us put the vaccine clinics together. So a lot of the polish that you see at these clinics is due to those volunteers. I told someone it looked like.

1:33:41 Public Health had a great big box. We were stuffing in testing and contact tracing and now let's step in some immunization and there was like tissue paper flying out and there was duct tape and it was, you know, not, it was going to happen but it wasn't necessarily going to be pretty and now it's like all pretty with bows on it and really great signs and volunteers. It's amazing. So it was a community effort without a doubt and I'm really proud of our community and everybody that stepped up to help make this happen. So it's a great, great effort for our whole county. So thanks everybody.

1:34:12 Thank you, Linda. And again, my first comment is how well our little community of Mammoth and Mono County is doing getting shots in arms. Far better than any place else that I've talked to. In fact, if they can continue to get a great amount of serum by April, we will in all likelihood have reached some sort of herd immunity and we should see our numbers.

1:34:41 Really start to tank, which is what I'm looking for, for us to be able to go backwards in tears. While I'm not advocating you don't wear masks, yes, wear your mask still, I do, even though I hate the darn thing. But again, I am proud of what our people have been able to do in terms of the vaccination compared to other areas. I have siblings living all over the place.

1:35:10 Who are all in their 70s at this point. And they have not been able to get their first shot yet. So this is huge. I do want to say one thing. When you're looking at the numbers, I'm a junkie at looking at our numbers almost daily. You go to the county site and you look at those numbers. But if you want to know how the state is viewing us, you have to go to the state site and click on our county and their state map. And it will tell you what they perceive our numbers are.

1:35:38 Because it is wholly different from what the Mono County site says. Same thing, just different numbers because I'm assuming the way that they calculate it out. So if you want to see how the state is looking at us, I encourage you to go to that state site and it will be more informative from that standpoint. And that's all I have. A little late too, but we have a...

1:36:04 We have a clinic tomorrow, you know, 75, probably up in Antelope Valley, and then we have a clinic that will probably be over 800 people on Friday at Mammoth High School. And those will probably be reflected until next week, so it's hard to say. But it's just changing all the time, and they're not updating. Certainly the state, we're updating more locally on our portal Monday, Wednesday, Friday. I think that the state is, you know, behind us for sure. Do we have any public comments on this, Jamie? No, we do not. Okay.

1:36:38 Thank you all for that. And with that, we will move on to item number 12, consideration of concept review application, requesting town council feedback on a potential development agreement, an operating agreement with a revenue sharing component to facilitate the development of a limelight 151 room hotel with 23 residences on the 6.97 acre site within the North Village specific plan. Sandra.

1:37:08 Thank you. Thank you, Mayor Sauser. The item before you tonight, as you mentioned, is the concept review application for the limelight hotel. The intent of the item tonight is to gauge the council's willingness to have staff discuss entering into a development agreement for this potential limelight hotel. Just a little bit of background, a development agreement, it's a voluntary contract between the town and a property owner.

1:37:36 And it can include a variety of different items from vesting of development standards to revenue sharing. As the council is aware, the town has had questions from a variety of different property owners about development agreements over the past couple of years, but we haven't had any completed development agreements since the Snow Creek DA, which was about 10 years ago. And our staff report provides a description of what a DA is.

1:38:03 And also describes the findings that are required for a development agreement. So just to note that unlike a traditional entitlement process where we can't impose requirements on a developer without showing a nexus, this process allows us to negotiate items that are mutually agreeable between the town and the applicant. And so for the subject property in the limelight, this could include public parking, a pedestrian bridge.

1:38:29 Some of the items that are noted in the applicant's narrative and our staff report. I'm not going to walk through the details on the project as we have the applicant team here to provide information on the hotel. And I also wanted to note that we do have Will Soholt from Cosmon Companies. He did provide us with a summary of his findings after reviewing the pro forma for the hotel. I did email that out to the council today and it's uploaded to Granicus as well.

1:38:59 And just kind of in summary, his letter basically states that he believes that there is room for the town to consider a public-private partnership to facilitate this development. So in order to help frame the council's discussion and provide staff direction, we did provide a discussion question for you on page five of your staff report. I'll go ahead and read it just for the benefit of the public.

1:39:24 The discussion question states, based on the information provided at this concept review meeting and understanding that this is not a formal commitment by the Town Council to any agreement, is the Council willing to authorize staff to begin working with the applicant to negotiate a development agreement and operating covenant with a revenue sharing component in support of the proposed hotel project? So we will come back to that question after the presentation.

1:39:51 But I'm happy to answer any questions about the development agreement process if you have any before the applicant provides their presentation. So that completes my part of the presentation and I'm happy to answer the questions. Okay. Do we have any questions for Sandra? Just raise your hand and I'll call on you. What about the DA? John? Yeah, Sandra, just a little bit of background perhaps on the council's involvement with COSMOTE, and I believe that right before the pandemic hit, we had a similar

1:40:24 Council meeting with a proponent in the North Village. Maybe just give us a little bit of background and all that. Sure, yeah. So we have had a relationship with COSMON for a couple of years now. We did do an RFQ process two years ago, I think, three years ago now. And we have five financial consultants that are on our short list for this type of work. COSMON is one of them. So we did ask COSMON to come in and I think wait.

1:40:51 And then they did, I think they came back in March as a part of the request for the Beacon Project, which is also known as the East Village Project. That was kind of a very similar request as you're seeing tonight.

1:41:17 And the council did direct staff to move forward with discussions with that applicant at the time, but with the pandemic, that project I think is on hold at this point as far as we know. So this is something that the council has discussed in the past, and we have provided information about development agreements through the previously as well. It does, and for any revenue sharing.

1:41:46 Should that town want to go forward, that Cosmo, we have our own independent sources of analysis to analyze anything that will go into an agreement like that. So we're not, the council specifically retains the services of folks. We're not flying blind to these types of agreements. I just want to make sure the council knows that. We have resources to draw upon should we need that, and also for the community to make sure that the council and the town will be well advised should we determine to move forward with any kind of discussions.

1:42:16 Yes, it would be our intent to engage COSMOT to help us negotiate the development agreement, review all of kind of the numbers and kind of be a part of the bus. And just to clarify, the contract is with the town, so COSMOT works with the town. Good. It's just great to see, no, we've got two Ken Ishiguro's on the call and two Mark Carney's. Maybe that's a nightmare, maybe that's not. I don't know. We'll have to see. Thank you, Sandra. You're welcome.

1:42:48 Thank you, John. Council, any other questions for Sandra before we move on to the presentation? Okay, take it away, Sandra. Sure, I'd like to turn it over to Amy Reed to introduce the applicant team and to go through this presentation. Actually, if I may, Sandra, I'm going to start first. This is Mark Carney. Good afternoon, Mayor Sauser and members of the council. As many of you know, I was an attorney, a partner in a law firm in Mammoth.

1:43:19 I want to thank the council for

1:43:49 Adding us to the agenda today, we know it's really busy times and there's very important matters before you on a regular basis and we understand that you made a concession to get us in, the staff made a concession as well to get us in in these times. So thank you very much for adding us to the agenda tonight. We're here to discuss Aspen and Little.

1:44:17 Nell Hotel Group's desire to introduce the Limelight Hotel brand of Mammoth Lakes. And for the purposes of efficiency, it's my pleasure to introduce you to the Limelight Mammoth team. And, John, mercifully, it is the case that there's only one Mark Carney here. There's not more than one. I will introduce you to a couple of members of the team to whom I forwarded my invite.

1:44:45 And that's how they got their names underneath their, my name underneath their pictures. So we'll clear that up in a sec. And I will introduce them to you and then in turn they will introduce to you their concept for the Limelight Mammoth Hotel, but first and foremost to introduce you to the Aspen Skiing Company and to the Little Nell Hotel Group.

1:45:15 And first and foremost, I'd like to introduce you to Andy Reid, who is the Vice President of Development for Little Nell Hotel Group. Andy authored the letter that appears in your package attached to the agenda, and he will address you momentarily. We're also joined by Kenny Shigeru, who is the Vice President for Project Advancement for the Little Nell Hotel Group.

1:45:45 And Ken is actually named correctly there over on the right of my screen anyway. And then we have Craig Backus, who is a name, who is Mark Carney over there on the left. Craig is the founding principal of the Blackline Group Development Services, which is a development consulting firm. Craig is a founding principal and manages the Santa Ana office.

1:46:13 Craig was trained as an architect, but has developed a particular expertise in the development and management of hotel products, so he is acting on behalf of the team as well. And then we have a couple of gentlemen from the architectural firm, WATG, a renowned kind of global firm. Little Nell is working with the

1:46:41 Los Angeles and Irvine offices who are represented by Brian Elgeo who is over there with Ken's name attached to him. And I think we also have Greg Villegas online, but I don't see him showing up in a picture here. So in any event, I will turn it over to Andy Reid and he'll tell you more about the Aspen Scheme Corporation in a little.

1:47:11 Thank you very much, Mark, and to echo your comments, thank you very much to everyone on the line tonight. I really appreciate the opportunity to speak with you and appreciate your time and looking forward to introducing our concept and touching on some of what we're about here at Aspen Ski Company and the Little Malt Hotel Group.

1:47:39 I do have a fair amount of material that I'd like to share, but I'm going to do it very quickly. But I think there's a lot that's important to know about us as an organization, about me as an individual even, and about what we're trying to accomplish with the Limelight brand and what we're trying to accomplish in Mammoth. So pardon me while I share my screen here.

1:48:13 Let me change the screen. I'm working from a new office and there's three screens somehow. So one moment. All right. Could everybody see my screen? Yes. Perfect. So I will go through relatively quickly. But I did want to introduce myself first of all. That's me and my wife Erin. We really...

1:48:50 I do have a passion for the mountains and the outdoors. I've lived in Colorado for about 12 years. I love skiing, hiking, hiking, camping, fishing. Not so much into motorized outdoor activities yet, but looking forward to trying that at some point soon. I thought that was a good picture to throw in. I do enjoy traveling a lot.

1:49:14 Iceland, so a little reminiscent of Devil's Postpile, but not quite. And then I think there's no better way to get to know an individual than looking at their phones. You can see here the apps that are important to me. It's the Aspen app, the Vino, which is a wine app, mountain bike project, AllTrails. Again, I just love getting out and being active. So thank you for...

1:49:41 For Barry, with you, I'll introduce myself. Now to the Little Nell Hotel Group. We are a privately held real estate investment management group based in Aspen. We own, develop, and manage Limelight and Little Nell branded hotels. We've got to focus on hospitality assets that meet our strict quality standards. But our real end goal is to create long-term value. In our portfolio, it's the Little Nell in Aspen. The residences at Little Nell.

1:50:11 Three limelight hotels, one in Aspen, one in Ketchum, one in Snowmass, one in Boulder, Colorado that's in pre-development, and then we are actively designing the limelight and Mammoth that we would like to build. We also own and operate the Aspen Mountain Club and the Snowmass Mountain Club. I have gotten questions from time to time as we go into Mammoth about the Aspen relationship relative to Altera, so I did want to touch on that briefly.

1:50:41 So that's how that structure would work. I also think it's important as a company to touch on,

1:51:12 You know, our guiding principles because it really is what we stand for as an organization. So when it comes to humanity, we treat people the way they'd like to be treated. We model authenticity, transparency, courtesy, respect, and humility regarding excellence in business, quality craftsmanship, guest services, and athletic achievement. Sustainability to us is...

1:51:39 It's more than the environment, but it is inclusive of the environment. It's part of a function of wanting to be in business forever. And lastly, when it comes to passion, we do live our core values. We're a values-based organization. And I did want to share this video. Hopefully it comes through. But Aspen Scheme Company was recently awarded the State of Colorado Governor's Citizenship Medal. It's awarded to

1:52:09 entities that are recognized as remarkable leaders for their impact in their communities. So let's see if this goes. Again, I'll be relatively quick here, but I do want to share a little bit. We are as an organization. Perfect. So the video doesn't want to work, but in the spirit of being quick and efficient,

1:52:53 I would encourage you, if you do have time, to check out the Corporate Citizenship Award.

1:53:23 With respect to humanity, you know, we're active when it comes to philanthropy. We have a caring for the community fund at all of our hotels that supports health care, food aid, relocation services, legal assistance. We also have an environment foundation. It's a nonprofit that was founded and is operated by Aspen Skiing Company and employees of Aspen Skiing Company. Given that the last video didn't...

1:53:51 Want to work, I'll skip this, but over the last 20 years through the Environment Foundation we have donated over three and a half million to hundreds of projects. I will continue. So regarding excellence, this is just a survey that shows the network for a variety of different mountains. The survey is done by the National Ski Area Association and Aspen Skiing Company has four of the top five net promoter scores.

1:54:20 Limelight Hotels also have a very high customer satisfaction rate, over 90%. When it comes to sustainability, we could talk about this for quite a long time, but it's core to what Aspen, Skiing Company, the Little Nail Hotel Group are all about. You can poke around our website, but our goal is to stay in business forever. We want to do business.

1:54:47 Over the long haul, we want to take the law review. In that vein, sustainability, again, not just with respect to the environment, but of course, including the environment is important to us. So we're very active when it comes to political action. We're unapologetically lobbying elected officials. We've been involved in just about every climate bill that's come through Colorado since 2004. Our electric utility runs on 100% renewable power.

1:55:17 We've got a three megawatt waste methane to electricity power plant that emits three times Aspen scheme to waste carbon emissions annually. So this is something that we could really talk about forever, but I do want to respect your time and get through it. I think it's interesting to think about how we're doing innovative things with respect to new developments.

1:55:44 One of our latest projects that we're invested in is Electric Pass Lodge, 100% renewable. And again, you know, regarding sustainability, not just being an environmental issue, but a community issue, we are building 130 employee housing beds for Aspen ski co-workers, and that building will also be 100% electric. A couple partners of ours are ACES, Protect Our Winters, City of Aspen,

1:56:14 Again, we could talk about this for a while, but I think important to this project is how we're going to think about sustainability in Mammoth and what we can accomplish and how that would translate to Mammoth. So the walk, bike, ride program I think is an important element of that and potentially providing a village mobility hub and incorporating ourselves into the transit system. Bike Share, if that gets off the ground, and we'd love to consider being

1:56:44 On the forefront of some of those programs. Our culture, again, I think speaks to our desire for a sustainable community beyond environmental concerns. And in that vein, we sit on 111 nonprofit boards as a skiing company. We're going to provide jobs. We're going to provide about 80 full-time employees after opening. And we will be contributing to some of the town initiatives that are in place, whether it's the parcel.

1:57:13 Through development fees or over time considering how it can be impactful with respect to affordable housing, which is something that we deal with on a pretty regular basis in Aspen and we're in small communities, which we'll get into a little bit later. And passion is our last guiding principle. We've been effective when it comes to creating a new center of gravity in a town core and other hotels that we've built, whether it's the limelight and ketchup.

1:57:43 It was the first hotel built in Ketchum in approximately 20 years and helped establish a little bit more of a town core and some density. But specifically with respect to passion, our core purpose is to inspire journeys within to advance possibilities for all. That can mean a lot of things. But at the end of the day, we do want to be an agent for positive change in the world. We're not just trying to be a business. There's more than that.

1:58:13 That we are passionate about. Now, specifically with respect to limelight and the project that we would propose, our position is home base in the places that you want to explore. So we've been very successful in accomplishing that in other limelight hotels. We want to be a stop and a home base and a hug of sorts. But we do encourage our guests to get out in the community and participate.

1:58:43 And everything that is offered and experience the local destination. And again, I just want to give you an overview of what Limelight is. So the Limelight and Snowmass opened in 2018. Snowmass has a population of 2,900. We feel that the catalyst for high-quality investment in and around the hotel, and we're contributing to the Environment Foundation. We've got an adventure concierge that promotes everybody to get

1:59:13 We have positive feedback from the community.

1:59:45 One Light Aspen was our first property. It sort of was our catalyst to building the brand and around building the brand around being the living room. We have meeting space in the hotel that gets used on a regular basis by nonprofits. It was the headquarters for a COVID response team back in March and we feel is critical to being a fabric part of the world.

2:00:17 White White Aspen's donated a good amount of money to the Carroll for the Community Fund, and we program everything at the hotel to get our guests out and about, oftentimes with staff, whether it's biking, so it's just a snapshot from our website that shows some biking starts. The project in Boulder that we're working on now, it's in pre-development. It is a product of...

2:00:42 About a 10-year endeavor between some public entities in Boulder. So interesting public private partnership that we're working on. Again, I want to be respectful of your time, and I understand it's very challenging with COVID going on now especially, but I wanted to take the opportunity to introduce ourselves and our project. We're not assuming anything, but we would seek...

2:01:11 Council to direct staff to allow staff and town's advisor, which we understand to be cause not to study the opportunity and advise the development agreement would be a proposed project. Again, I think speaking maybe to some of the items Sandra touched on, it would be subject to mutually agreeable and beneficial items. So nothing.

2:01:40 That wouldn't necessarily, that wouldn't benefit town as well. And why here now we want to understand if there's additional community benefits that are desired. We feel first of all that the hotel in this location will further the walk, bike, ride initiative among others. But there's an opportunity based on where we are in our planning process to understand if the town would like additional public benefits, whether it's a pedestrian bridge.

2:02:08 Over Canyon or additional parking to really anchor the hotel into that mobility hub element. And I just wanted to show a little bit of, I'm sure you're familiar with the walk, bike, ride program, but if there's calls for a mobility hub in the village, this rendering to me felt like it could actually be from our site. It was very representative of some of the design that WATG can speak to shortly.

2:02:38 When we read the walk, bike, ride, we felt like we accomplished virtually all of the mobility of opponents and recommendations. So felt like, again, a good candidate for that. And according to that plan, it does suggest identifying potential development partners. Mobility hub to get to gold level would be inclusive of 100 moving spaces. We also, again, have an adventure concierge at our hotels.

2:03:11 So we could be that focal point for the long distance hiking hub, which is also included in that. And I don't want to get into too much about what COSMOT has presented in the past, but in our mind it was relevant to some degree to be asked today in the material that we're sharing. COSMOT suggested that tax sharing agreements may be appropriate to bridge financial feasibility gaps for projects that are expected to be significant revenue generators.

2:03:42 That may drive additional private investment and then further public policy goals. Understanding that more than half of the TOT is generated. From December to March, we felt like a hotel with meeting space and amenities that are new to Mammoth would fill a void and help balance out some of that TOT and reduce the reliance on just winter business to contribute TOT to the town's general plan.

2:04:10 The conclusion from COSMA was that the town may want to consider a revenue sharing agreement. Now specifically to the limelight in Mammoth, again, trying to go as fast as I can to be respectful of everybody's time, but our goal really is to entitle it now and start building as soon as we can when the economics makes sense. Core to the limelight brand and very much what we're looking to accomplish in limelight Mammoth is be a community hub and a living room for the community. We feel like we can be that.

2:04:39 Anchor Location, not only Mobility Hub, but also I guess within that context of Mobility Hub. I think we're strategically located in a geographic location that would allow somebody, whether it's a guest of ours or somebody to drive, park their car once and then not necessarily have to get their car out again until we've got

2:05:10 We contemplated 150 true hotel rooms, so we're not looking to build just another condo hotel, sell the real estate and move on. We want to own the hotel forever, moving forever. I think that's very different than a lot of other developers that have come through town in the past and had projects proposed that were condo hotel. So we've got 5,000 square feet of indoor meeting space, which I think fills a gap in the market. There's not a lot of high quality indoor.

2:05:41 Meeting space, and I think that would attract some visitation during off-season and shoulder season and 10,000 square feet of outdoor event space for functions, again, to really push the off-season and shoulder season visitation. We're not a chain hotel. We don't have a Marriott or a Hilton or Hyatt system, so we've got to sell our experiences and programming, and in that vein, it's also meeting space.

2:06:12 Proposing to build meeting space to help us accomplish that. I think that's different and unique than other projects that have come through and different and unique than what's in there in the market today. Structured parking, again, we think you can park your car once and not have to get it out again. Bikes and bike storage. This is just a shot of the Port Cocher. The architects can touch on that briefly later.

2:06:39 But we've contemplated two levels of structured parking to meet the needs of the hotel, and a third level can be included if town council would like us to consider that. In total, we've got close to 400 parking spaces, 250 of which would be hotel use. Again, we want to provide something new and different for Mammoth. We're not going to succeed if we do more of the same. I think part of the reason that

2:07:09 Rings true is the Westin was the last large-scale project to open and that didn't open for that. Nothing has really occurred of substance since 2007. We want hotbeds. We don't want to just build condos and sell them. It would be probably easier, but that's not our goal. Our goal is to create long-term value. And we've programmed the hotel to fill gaps in the market. We want to add to the depth of Mammoth.

2:07:40 Again, with meeting space, event space, hotel rooms, new experiences, we think the hotel's an opportunity to expand the source markets for Mammoth beyond just being Southern California the primary market to draw from. So we felt like that was important to enhance the TOT and diversify to some degree. Our plan for Mammoth, again, we

2:08:13 We're building hotel rooms that we're going to hope forever. We're going to build something of a very high quality that's going to withstand the test of time. And we take the long view, which if that video is able to play, I think you may appreciate a little bit more. So again, if you have time, please do take a look at the Corporate Citizenship Award for the state of Colorado. And we want to be mindful, which is part of the reason that we're here right now, is to get the sense from town council about what we can do.

2:08:41 Specifically to help the town of Mammoth accomplish some of its public initiatives. I think there's two elements to this. One is what can we do on the front end? And then almost more importantly, what can we do on an ongoing basis? If we're going to be in business forever, we're going to be in Mammoth, we're going to be part of the community. It's not just about sort of a small token up front and then leaving.

2:09:10 But again, what we can do on an ongoing basis. And I think part of what we've accomplished in Aspen does speak to that. Over time, we've developed employee housing. It did not come at once. But now we've got about 800 beds. Our last latest project under construction now is fully electric 200 bed project.

2:09:33 With that, I'll turn it over to WATG and Brian so he can run you through our plans, but again, appreciate your time and thanks for bearing with me. Thank you, Andy. Hello, everybody. Hello, Mayor Sauser and Councilmembers. My name is Brian Algeo and I am Senior Vice President at WATG. WATG is an architectural landscape and interior design firm that was founded 75 years ago.

2:10:01 I've been with the firm for 22 of those years, and we focus on hospitality, entertainment, leisure projects. So we really are a niche-focused firm. This is what we do. The Limelight, the Little Fennell Hotel Group is an amazing client for all the things Andy just stated, and they really align well with Mammoth. I've been going to Mammoth as a little boy, and I take my children, and now as an empty nester, I go frequently.

2:10:29 Know Mammoth. I love Mammoth. And this project is close to my heart. And to be honest, it makes me a little nervous. I want to make sure we do the right thing. And Andy and his team are really focused on doing the right thing. We looked at the site carefully. During the early stages, late last year, we walked the site. I was familiar with the site. We were staying close by. Walked the site and saw the topography and the challenges. It's a challenging site.

2:10:57 Canyon Boulevard sloping down towards Lake Mary. Lake Mary has a fair amount of traffic. It's that corner, Canyon and Lake Mary. And then it has the great opportunity of the village connection. So we quickly realized the layout of the hotel wants to focus on Canyon, focus on that pedestrian connection to the village. And that's what you're seeing here in site plan. We've got the pool area and a lot of the outdoor function areas facing south along the corner of Canyon.

2:11:28 As a site plan and a floor plan, we have all the public spaces, the lobbies, the restaurants, the meeting space, the children's areas, all the lounges are all on one level, creating a great community town square concept, which is one of Little Nell's and LiveLite's core brand promises, is to create an asset for the community, which this design is really geared towards doing that. We designed a strong pedestrian connection up along the village edge,

2:11:58 We created a public plaza that can receive all the visitors coming via tram as those tram stops located right there and also the pedestrian traffic coming from the village to our property, either staying at the hotel or dining at the hotel. We have pedestrian connections throughout that will connect this hotel well to the fabric of the town. The portico share and the vehicular drop-off is off of Lake Mary to try to get the vehicular traffic off of Canyon and really get them

2:12:28 Situated, parked below the building, and then it's really a pedestrian experience from there. You can go to the next end. This is a view from the Lake Mary Canyon intersection looking up towards the hotel. We've created a building that is designed in segments. It's three segments that meander along the canyon to break up the massing of the building. Use strong, rustic materiality with wood and concrete and some stone to really

2:12:57 Anchor into the Alpine, but have a contemporary aesthetic. The roof forms are really designed, they're inspired by the valleys and the lakes and the hillsides and the mountains coming down into the valley areas. Really, we're geared towards pedestrian orientation, the sidewalks, the landscape can really give a great front door to the property. This is a view at the hotel arrival. If you come for the first time or come in your car, you'll pull into this courtyard. You'll drive up through the pine trees and then

2:13:28 We come into this lobby area where all the activity is in a single floor, as I discussed earlier. And the inspiration for the motor court is really the rings of a tree, the age and the aging of a tree you can see on the ground plane. And the sculpture in the center were inspired by the great sort of geological events that have happened in the region with the devil's post pile and the hot springs. And again, creating a warm material palette, really geared for the pedestrian level experience.

2:14:00 This is a view from the village looking back towards the hotel. And you can see at the lower area where we created a pedestrian plaza that will actually function as a gathering place, enough space for pop-up, retail or food, beverage, a great place to wait for the tram, and also a great access and front door to our hotel. So it's really a community front door of the project is facing the village and really up along that edge.

2:14:30 You can see the materiality of the guest rooms with the residential on the upper floors. This is a close-up view of that plaza, something that we envisioned from day one when we walked the site and how important this intersection is of our site. That covers the plans that we wanted to share with you. I think they're all obviously subject to town approval and will be refined as we go based on feedback from the ADP and other organizations, but did want to share.

2:15:07 The early renderings of what we're contemplating. And again, in closing, we do feel like we would be accreted to the community in a lot of ways. There's some opportunity based on where we are designed now where we're able to incorporate elements of public benefit should it be desired. And what comes to mind in that vein from our perspective was the pedestrian bridge over canyon.

2:15:36 And really adding parking so that we could really bolster ourselves as a hub, mobility hub, and we could provide parking for non-hotel guests. I think, you know, with respect to the next steps, we would like town council, we're asking town council hopefully to direct staff to work with its financial advisors, negotiate a development agreement if it's deemed appropriate. It could include some revenue sharing.

2:16:05 And if town is interested, other elements of public benefit that we're certainly open to providing. You know, I think I do want to address one of the elephants in the room, which is we're not the first group to come to town council with the proposed hotel and ask for some type of revenue sharing agreement. But I do think we're unique. And it was mentioned earlier that the pandemic really pushed pause on

2:16:34 Another project in Mammoth that had been sort of approved to negotiate a development agreement, bring that back in front. I think we're uniquely qualified to actually complete development during the pandemic. We've got a unique source of access to capital with our ownership entity, and we can do exactly what we say we're able to do. So again, I think we're unique. We're not coming to town to build a conda hotel and leave.

2:17:04 Coming to town to be part of the community, build a hotel that we plan to own forever. And just the last, we touched on Cosmo, so I won't go through it again. And here's my contact information if anybody would like to reach out, make myself available at your convenience anytime. Please do, if there's questions, comments, concerns that we don't get to tonight, happy to be a sounding board for anything and everything.

2:17:33 So that is the material. And I will stop my screen share. Great. So again, thank you for your time. I do appreciate it very much. Thank you, Andrew, or Andy, what we were calling each other on the phone, I think, when we talked. Moving on, I will go to questions from council for staff or the little Nell group. And John, I'm going to start with you.

2:18:13 Bill, thank you very much. Andy and the team, thank you very much for the presentation. Super informative. Great to see the visualizations. I don't, I don't, Mr. Mayor, are you going to do questions and then public comment and then deliver? Right, John, thank you. Yeah, no, I think I'm good. I have a pretty good sense of what's going on here and I don't have any specific questions, so I look forward to

2:18:42 Hearing any other thoughts from council members, any public comments, I'll have a couple of comments as we get into our deliberation, so thank you. Thank you. Linda? No, I don't think I have any questions right now. I think I'd like to hear the next steps, and also, as John said, if we have any public comments on this. Thank you. Kirk? Yes. My only concern is when I read the words revenue sharing in the agenda bill,

2:19:13 Partly because I've been on council for a long time and the revenue sharing part of it is the way we incorporate it. We've relied heavily on TOT and sales tax. So I'm just sharing, you know, one of my concerns. I think the project, I've been to Aspen, I think the project looks great. Your product looks great and everything.

2:19:37 But again, I'm just raising my concern, which is the idea of revenue sharing because of the way the town incorporated. We rely so heavily on TOT and on sales tax. Thank you. Sarah. No questions. Thank you. I'll probably have some comments later. Okay. Thank you. So the only question I have for the proponents here, we always talk about feet first and we talk about bicycles.

2:20:08 But especially a product like yours is going to draw a lot of the, shall we say, better healed and older crowd who isn't going to want to do a lot of walking and that kind of stuff. I'm assuming in your plans you have made plans for them as well that, you know, it's not going to be a 500-foot walk from their car to the room or whatever.

2:20:33 Correct. Absolutely, Mr. Mayor. So a good portion of our customers are active. We intentionally seek active customers, but you're correct as well that a good portion of our customers prefer alternative means of leisure and recreation. And we do, we've incorporated not only obviously ADA, but other elements to make for an easy experience for everybody. And I think

2:21:03 You probably see that, which is an additional cost to us, an additional cost to the project, but we've pushed the hotel down to Canyon. It costs us probably about a million dollars every five feet we get closer to Canyon, but we've decided to do that because, again, we want to be connected to the community. I think the West End is an example of a condo hotel that's sold out but sort of left.

2:21:30 A lot to be desired in terms of the owners that now own that product and the town's experience and the town's connectivity to that hotel. It's very challenging from a connection standpoint. And we've taken the financial burden to push our hotel to Canyon in a pretty meaningful and costly manner to accomplish exactly that by Mr. Mayor, which is better connection for everybody. Thank you.

2:21:57 Andy, you and I have already had a conversation, but I want to give you the opportunity to tell our public that's out there what you're going to do to promote midweek and shoulder season and summer season while everybody wants to rely just on the mountain in the winter. That's a fairly large group already. So if you could accommodate me and answer those as well. Absolutely. Thank you for the opportunity. So meeting spaces is often

2:22:25 Not built, or we'll call it value engineered out of a hotel. Once the cost budget comes back, because it tends to be the guest groups that make the most money. And for us, we're unique in that we don't have, again, a Hilton Hyatt Marriott system that we rely on, which in Mammoth, I think you probably get a lot of point redemption business in the winter and then not that much outside of the winter. So our

2:22:54 Capital is going towards meeting space and event space and function space to help us drive business that is new and different and wouldn't cannibalize the existing hotels and the demand that they're getting but would attract different elements from Southern California and beyond from groups that want to have meetings and events at our space and hopefully there's

2:23:19 A ripple effect throughout the community from those guests that are staying or meeting at our hotel and the retailers in and around the village that would get the additional foot traffic, especially out of winter, which is so critical. But I think the meeting space for us is our big, one of the big pushes and big components of our project that is different and should allow for more spread out, less seasonal business.

2:23:49 Thank you, Andy. And I'm assuming with your record of working with nonprofits that you would also be willing to work with some of our nonprofits on events and things, you know, the Shakespeare in the Woods and Balooza Palooza and other events such as that to drive those seasonal businesses. Absolutely. The meeting space in our hotels is often, you know, sometimes donated, sometimes significantly discounted.

2:24:18 Just support the community in any way that we can and would love to host nonprofits throughout the community and give them the opportunity to use our space. Thank you. Last one. I know that we have had trouble in the past with, and I know there's been some changes in the laws, and Andy Morris could help us out with that at some point down the road. Accepting tax dollars or our rebates can often kick in a...

2:24:48 Yes, we're very mindful of the impact that a potential revenue sharing agreement or development agreement would have on the cost of the project.

2:25:17 The reason that we've hired SierraCon as our general contractor is their experience in Mammoth and their experience specifically with what that prevailing wage impact could be on a construction project. And we would also look to the town's financial advisor, Cosma, to make a recommendation that that works most appropriately for the town. Thank you. I think that ends my question, so I would now go to public comment if you have any.

2:25:47 We do not have any public comment. Thank you, Jamie. So I will now bring this back unless proponents or town staff have something they want to add before I go to council for comments. Mr. Mayor, if I may provide a few comments as well as the conversation with the little nail group that started several weeks ago or even longer than that, but as they look at the limelight brand coming forward.

2:26:20 Some of the initial review work was looking at the quality of the team that they're bringing to the table, the owner, and that long view or that forward thinking in terms of projects in Mammoth and this reflects that in their core values as they've walked through what that begins to look like. And the nice part, I think, on the front end of the willingness to look at a partnership for opportunities that can benefit both of us. We look at the gaps in the North Village.

2:26:49 Some of that being in the mobility element. As we look at the gap in parking, we know we're short somewhere in the neighborhood of 300 plus spaces as the village sits today and builds out. We know that we have some gaps in our transportation, just the flow of vehicles, et cetera, within that area and the pedestrian movement across streets. Great ski day. You go up there on a Saturday.

2:27:17 In front of the village where the bus stop is and the crosswalk and just the challenges we have of navigating that between people and vehicles. Same thing on the canyon side with the steps coming down from the west end, two different directional buses, bus stops, the gondola component. Again, a lot of potential for a conflict in there and the types of activities are going on. And this is summer and winter, as you see with the bike activities and others.

2:27:46 As we look at that is how do we help kind of close those gaps in our systems up there for our visitors, for our locals, and especially for the workforce up at the village as they get there via either transit or they get there their own vehicles or walking or biking, et cetera, utilizing. Going back to the beginning of the meeting here, we're talking about the mobility components up there and enhancing that safety element just as people interact as we bring the

2:28:13 Needed mass of people, visitors and locals into the village area for the success of that core element of our community. And it goes to Councilmember Stapp's comments that we are a community that is highly reliant on a visitor base that generates transient occupancy tax revenues. It is a huge portion of our budget. It dwarfs property tax, which we get very little from. And then the other one, obviously, driving the sales tax component.

2:28:43 Which is another smaller but significant piece of our budget as that looks at the activity of retail sales, restaurants, et cetera, driven again by that interaction of people in these areas. So we want to be able to see how do we enhance those areas. Again, connecting.

2:29:03 All of those areas together has been an ongoing discussion with the town council the last several years. Some priorities were set of how do we enhance parking in the village area. The town has invested several thousands of dollars, some on-street parking, a small parking lot, other improvements in stepping in and doing that. We know that ultimately there's an obligation there. We look at how do we provide that, where do we step up and fund those elements.

2:29:31 The physical connection across the streets become an important element of safety, as well as that idea of moving public back and forth between core areas. In this case, looking at that Canyon Boulevard and being able to move people, not just from the hotel properties, but from the parking areas up there, having lived up above that area in the past. Walking down to the village, if you had that opportunity to kind of...

2:29:58 Bypass Canyon Boulevard, frankly, down in there, you would take that option on a regular basis. If you could walk across, you know, above the busyness of the street and drop into the gondola area and down into the village plaza area. And so as we move forward in a partner discussion on this, cautious in terms of, I believe we have a lot of investment in the village that the town has looked at over time of making, whether it's our own dollars generated out of the project or in this case.

2:30:26 Through a partnership with a developer, utilizing our dollars, if you will, but utilizing their money on the front end to be able to achieve some benefit sooner than later. I think that's one of the key elements as we look at the development agreement side. It's the value of a great product coming in, but on top of that is how do we meet these other needs and desires we have from our community and for that public benefit side? We know we have parking challenges. We know we have just the pedestrian crossing issues in there.

2:30:56 The ability to connect people there and look at that, and not just a parking solution really, but a connection solution as we look at our transit component that runs through there in multiple directions, getting people up to the lake space and transit versus a vehicle. As we look at people connecting to the paths there, the Lake Mary bike path, the other hubs there that we can go either direction and back into the community.

2:31:22 The connection to the gondola itself as people move up both in the summer and winter into the one of the main portals for Mammoth Mountain. And as we look at all those connection points, even if we were to look at some opportunities, maybe it's not parking in the project, maybe it's somewhere else, but we work together to partner to make that work from the financial standpoint. We know we have those needs in the area and they're coming forward. And the real challenge for us has been how do we ultimately

2:31:50 Fund, finance, work through some of those elements. And to have a partner in this, again, I think is a very critical element to the town as we look at this going forward. And as mentioned earlier, the commitment at this point isn't to provide a pure financial incentive just for the sake of that, but there's a lot of elements coming with it. And the commitment at this point being requested, if I'm understanding the request correctly and working through this, is really do we have an opportunity to work together and say,

2:32:19 What makes sense from a public benefit? What makes sense from public investment of public dollars? How do we take the elements of the project that's presented? Again, going through the final review processes and everything else with the town and say, how do we bring that together? And again, not looking at as a single product or a single hotel project even, but how does it integrate with the rest of the planning work that's been done for the North Village? And I'll go back to Councilmember Staff who's been

2:32:49 Here on the council recently in previous years, a number of years on town council and have seen some very good decisions, maybe not so good decisions in some of the planning work and development that we've had in the community, but does this provide an opportunity to address some critical needs that we have, but also in a new method almost based on the discussion earlier in the meeting, again, the mobility component of bringing people into town.

2:33:16 Ideally, they park their car, let it charge up, whatever the needs are there, and let them get through our community other means, be it transit, be it walking, be it on a bike, be it a ride share, et cetera. You can kind of let your imagination run there. But how do we work together meeting those objectives and not necessarily...

2:33:37 Significantly impact the financial capabilities of the Town of Mammoth Lakes, but add to that, but also a way of creating added benefit by investing dollars over time and working through that. So we end up in a very much of a win-win-win situation. It's a win for the town. It's a win for the project developer.

2:33:57 And it's a win for our community, both our locals and our visitors. And I think we've really got to be able to package that together to bring that forward and make a lot of sense to it. I like to think of it, if it's giving away dollars, it doesn't make a lot of sense. But if it's truly a partnership and investment to solve issues, to address concerns, and to offset future investment the town may have to make on its own, now dealing with a partner, is there some real value in that step moving forward?

2:34:25 The key element here is not sure exactly what all that looks like. That's why we're here before council at this point going, is it worth having the time and effort sitting down, walking through this, relying on some outside expertise in the whole development agreement world, tax sharing world, but also just looking at these other needs that we have as a community and how do we bring those together and balance that off.

2:34:51 Ultimately, we go through a whole legal structure, and that's why we have Andy Morris on the call as well, to be able to help us walk through some of that, as well as Will Schott from the Cosmon Company and looking at a lot of those different agreements, and to make sure that it truly does have that win-win-win component to it. This isn't something that we're stepping into lightly or blindly. We want to be well-informed. We want to make sure the council and our community is very well-informed as we take this forward.

2:35:19 And again, you know, here's our first, you know, full meeting of looking at who our partners are. I think there's a comfort level with the Aspen Ski Company, the primary owners in that, and the Little Nail Hotel Group and the focus they bring to this. And it is good to see it's a hotbed hotel versus a necessarily a condo hotel and the different values and different things that come with that. So I wanted to lay that out there. We started discussions a while back with a key issue being how can the project help us meet?

2:35:48 Community needs and community benefit. And the two that really came out of the discussion was on the parking elements and on that pedestrian connection element that can bring together to address some significant needs we have in our North Village and the area there as we look to the future. Again, long term future vision, not just the near term as well.

2:36:12 Again, staff can answer additional questions or the team can from the council as they begin to look at this and whether or not we want to pursue this level of discussion and concept moving forward. And I'm going to ask Andy Horst if he wants to weigh in at all and give him a chance to speak to some of this and just from the legal side of the things we're working with and or other comments as well. Thanks, Andy. Well, sure. Thanks, Dan. I mean, a development agreement certainly is not something that's foreign to the town. It's not foreign to me.

2:36:42 The Town has negotiated a bunch of these over the years. I've negotiated a bunch of these over the years. And I've worked with Mark Carney over many, many years. And I'm sure that if the Council directs us to talk to a little group about a development agreement, I'm sure that Mark and I will have very productive discussions. I think it will require some thought on the Town's end about what we'd like to prioritize and what our asks are. And I'd like to hear the details of what the applicant is proposing. So if you tell us to move ahead,

2:37:12 We can do it. I'm not worried about it. It's going to be terrific, and I'll look forward to working with Mark and the team. Thank you, Andy. With that, I believe I will take my privilege and start off the comments. A few things that I want to get off first. We're talking about the Westin being the last project like this that was built. The fact is there is no other project in Mammoth that is similar or compares to what they are telling us they're going to offer us.

2:37:44 We're not seeing their specific plans, but this is a hotbed resort with resort amenities that we don't have in any of our condo hotels. I can't even remember when the last hotbed property was built here in Mammoth. So for me, that's absolutely huge. Also for staff, I believe this is a good chance for us to go back and look at potentially an EIFD or something like that.

2:38:12 With an incremental tax structure for the town to help us build some of these things such as parking and mobility hubs and things that we need. This is a perfect project for that for the value of the land is going to do. My only negative piece that I have, Andy, you talked about an end date or a building date when it becomes financially viable. One of the problems I've had in the past with DAs that the town has done.

2:38:42 Is things have been given up on the town side to encourage the development. And then development doesn't happen for so many years that we gave away the, you know, the baby with the bathwater. So for a development agreement for me that is going to include a sharing program, it needs to be very well written as to exactly what it's going to be, but it needs to have an end date because from my standpoint, we're going to give up.

2:39:10 We should not give up. There are no taxes coming into the town if it's not built. So this is going to be a positive regardless of what we come out with. But I don't want to potentially give up money for something that is not going to happen for X number of years. So I would like to see an end date where you would have to have sticks in the ground for the development agreement to be solid to move forward.

2:39:39 That being said, I believe that this is a good potential partnership. I like the idea of a hotbed project in Mammoth. We have not seen that before. If you take the Westin as an example, several and a growing number of units within the Westin no longer rent through the Westin because they're individually owned. So you have varying levels of quality of product throughout that.

2:40:07 Hotbed, everything is going to be managed the same. So I am very much in favor of moving this forward. Remember, we aren't committing to anything other than moving the process forward. With that, Linda, I will go to you. Yes, thank you, Mr. Mayor. Again, thank you for this presentation. It was very beautiful and nice and looks great and all of the background information about the Little Nell Group and the

2:40:39 Aspen Ski Group is, you know, a good fit for our community, and I'm not going to, you know, reiterate everything Bill said, but I have no, you know, disagreement with any of the comments that Bill made, so consider those also moved forward. But I did want to just, you know, again, point to our housing issues here in town.

2:40:59 We have a critical housing shortage at the moment. We're pushing hard in the next two items on our agenda tonight have to do with, you know, those pieces needed to continue that as quickly as possible. And there wouldn't be possible residency in that project until 23, summer, you know, spring, summer of 19 or 2023 at best.

2:41:27 So we're talking about bringing people in to build. We're talking about finishing this, having, I think you referred to 80, you know, full-time employment. And right now we don't have any place to put them. And so wouldn't want to bring in additional employees, additional work people without some real thought about how we would mitigate those housing concerns. So I would ask that as we move forward with this, if that is indeed the...

2:41:53 The decision of the council that that be kept on the table with, you know, the negotiations and talking about how we would accommodate this. It's an exciting project. I agree with Bill that it sounds like a good fit for our community. And I'd like to, you know, also in favor of moving this forward, but not without also keeping in mind the impacts to our housing supply. So other than that, I think I have nothing right now. Thank you.

2:42:23 Very much. Thanks. Thank you, Linda. John? Yeah, so the question in front of us, I believe, is do we want to talk with each other? I think it would be a fundamental dereliction of the council's duty if we did not say yes to that. So I am strongly in favor of this proposal. Let's start talking. I think that...

2:42:47 As long as I've been in the town, I've been in some pretty dark places with the development community, and I won't share some of those war stories with you right now, but I think we have all long looked for this type of a partner, a partner with the means to invest, a partner with an internationally recognized track record of environmental stewardship, of proactive leadership on things that matter to communities.

2:43:12 Was unfortunately been associated with the billionaire class, was known as one of the bright lights of the progressive community in the United States. And those values are real. They're still with this community. I believe and trust in what they do and what they say. So should we talk? We would be remiss in our responsibilities if we did not say enthusiastically yes. So that's my thoughts. Thank you. Thank you, John. Kirk. Yes.

2:43:43 You know, I've been to Aspen quite a while ago, and I would love to see this project go forward. And again, it goes back to, you know, the economics, you know, when it talks about revenue sharing, we're not just talking about revenue sharing. I mean, if you look at our workforce housing requirement, it's been reduced 80%. And those kinds of issues, it's not just the sales tax and the TOT.

2:44:12 Thank you, Kirk. Sarah?

2:44:41 Yeah, both Linda and Kirk, you know, covered some of what I'm going to say. I had Dan, and thank you, Dan and Sandra, pulling the housing fee numbers, and it looks like it's about $740,000 would be the housing impact fees that this would pay us for 151 hotel rooms and 23 residences. And I will go ahead and apologize because I'm obviously...

2:45:08 The newbie here. Dan, I didn't ask you this, but would entering into this agreement give us wiggle room to change those housing fees at all, or are those set set now forever? I think, and Annie can speak to this too, as you get into a development agreement, pretty much everything can be on the table. It may not be a fee at that point. It may be a commitment to build housing. It may be a commitment to partner.

2:45:38 Some of the projects the town has going, as we'll be talking about shortly. There's a number of things that can go on the table as it relates to that agreement. It is just that. It is a negotiated back and forth agreement. And that can relate to dollars. It can relate to actual other elements on the ground. There's a timing element you can look at. So all of that can be on the table as part of that discussion. And if I just open there, Andy, I'll kick it to you, Morris.

2:46:06 Yeah, that's right. I mean, basically the way the development agreement works is that the developer gets certainty that it would not otherwise have. It locks in certain development standards and requirements, and in exchange, the public entity can negotiate for whatever it can negotiate for, which could be money, it could be housing, it could be all kinds of goodies and benefits. I think that in this case, the interesting discussion that we're going to have to have on the town end is thinking about the things that are most important to the town, to the community, and figure out

2:46:35 How to pare down a potentially enormous list of asks into something that might be doable because we're not going to get everything that we ask for and we need to kind of focus on whatever the priorities are. So I think that we'll have further discussions probably as we go along. And again, I'd like to see what the applicant team comes up with. We can use that as a starting point and we'll figure out how to do this in a way that works for them and works for the community.

2:47:00 Great. Thank you so much. I did just have one more question about parking. So with the, I think Andrew, not Morris, but sorry, Andrew Reed, with the parking, I think you said 140 excess spots potentially. Obviously we're in dire need of more parking in the village.

2:47:28 I'm assuming the parking spots dedicated to the hotel, would those cover parking spots for employees of the hotel? Yes, so inclusive of the, I think it's approximately 250 parking spaces that we've contemplated for the hotel parking, we do meet the needs of the employee parking within those numbers. Okay, good to know. Thank you so much. That was my only other question. Yeah, the crunchy hippie in me.

2:47:57 Loves the presentation. It looks beautiful. I absolutely think it would be an amazing thing and a great precedent for us to set for future development is, you know, this is what we're aiming for. We're looking for mobility. We're looking for green projects. And I agree with John Wentworth that we should absolutely talk. But, of course, the housing advocate in me is extremely concerned about.

2:48:25 The impact of that project on housing, which, you know, our parcel that we're developing is wonderful. It's amazing we're moving forward with it, but in no way is it even going to start solving the housing issue in town. So thank you for your presentation. It was really beautiful. And I'm, of course, in favor of moving forward with discussions. Thank you. I appreciate everyone's time.

2:48:50 Is now an appropriate time just to add a couple other comments before I sign off? Okay, thank you. I appreciate it. Yeah, I think, you know, it will be, I get a little nervous, I guess, when I start hearing about the litany of asks that the town may have. But obviously, looking forward to those discussions. I think the hotel project on its own.

2:49:21 is strained with respect to what a commercial developer would expect. And I don't want to sort of share my thoughts, but Cosmont and Will could. But at the end of the day, whenever we agree to or potentially agree to or negotiate in and around, I think it's appropriate at this time to say that the economics of the hotel would be

2:49:52 It would be challenged significantly if we start adding a lot more in terms of workforce housing, impact fees, etc. I think our position would be over time we can make a significant impact, to Kirk's point about a significant portion of the town of Mammoth Lakes budget being TOT generated.

2:50:15 We're looking forward to contributing to that in a pretty meaningful way. I think we're going to have one of the most substantial contributors to that TOT fund out of anybody, especially a hotbed hotel or a lodging facility, period. And I want to be mindful of everybody's time and effort. I think what would be worst case scenario is if we do continue having a conversation and negotiate a development agreement and then we don't.

2:50:45 Get to that mutually agreeable, mutually beneficial place. So if there's, I'm looking forward to talking, but I'm looking forward to negotiating and coming back with something that's mutually agreeable for everybody. I just wanted to say that before we continue. Thank you, Andy. I would like to ask one more question of Andrew Morris. Andy, turn your little screen back on here. Hello.

2:51:14 So in my mind, and I have not looked into it at all, this would be a perfect project to go to the county and ask to create an EIFD, which has nothing to do with them, but has to do with us and something we would have to work on our end. What's your thought on that? It could be. There have been very, very, very few EIFDs formed in California since the law was passed a few years ago because they require the acquiescence of a number of public agencies to make them work.

2:51:41 So we can certainly talk to the county. I think we should talk to the county. And we'll have to see what the county's appetite would be for participating. Yeah, because I believe, you know, the county's, if the project moves forward, the county's income is going to increase regardless, depending on how you lay out the EIFD. So I think that there'd be a good case here to move something like that forward. And this is Sarah's and Linda's positions that could be used to...

2:52:10 Go to affordable housing or workforce housing as well. Could be, and it's something that we will definitely take a look at and talk to the county about. Yeah. Thank you. Sarah, did I cut you off there? Did you have more? Okay. Any council member have anything else they'd like to speak to, John? Just thank you all very much. Please give our best to your reminders. And we very much look forward to these conversations. And I think...

2:52:42 I can speak. I'm not going to speak on behalf of the council, but our interests are focused. They'll be specific, and we look forward to those negotiations and to the report back to the council with what you guys come up with. So please go forth and speak and talk and come back with something. That's it for me. Thank you. Thank you, John. Dan, this is for you. If we just do a simple motion here.

2:53:10 To direct staff to work with Limelight Mammoth on a potential development agreement, that should be adequate? Yes, that would be adequate. So that would be the motion, if somebody would like to make it? So moved. I'll second the motion. Okay, I have a motion from John and a second from Kirk. Any further deliberation? Seeing none, Jamie? Councilmember Rae? Councilmember Stapp? Yes. Councilmember Whitworth? Yes.

2:53:47 Mayor Pro Tem, Salcido. Yes. Mayor Salzer. Yes. Passes 5-0. I look forward to future discussions. Thank you very much. Andy Reid, I expect you to call and ask me what all of my wishes are so I can pile them on you. Looking forward to it. I appreciate it. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. With that, we are going to now move on to agenda item.

2:54:17 So we will have to recuse. Sarah, would you like to say anything?

2:54:47 Thank John Kirk and Linda for handling that. And I, again, apologize to my Ray Culpa, as Ted would say. But, yeah, thanks. All apologies needed. You've got a place to let me down. Which was a big lift. So, thank you all so much. If I can also, Mr. Mayor, for Member Ray.

2:55:16 That the same conflict item will apply to items. The rest of the three additional items there that will be involved, 13, 14, and 15. All three items you'll be conflicted out on. So at that point, we'll be ending the meeting after those items as well. So what I will do, Sarah, for you and I, do you have a council member report you would like to give?

2:55:42 Yeah, I actually, I did attend the collaborative planning team, and that was on, I believe, last Friday, the 29th. And I'm the alternate, I believe Linda's the primary, but I attended, that was my first committee meeting, and it was very cool to see, you know, we just got a big overview from, oh, I can't even go into all the acronyms that were represented there, but it was really.

2:56:11 Wonderful to see. We had Lahontan and County and Toyabi. And so everyone kind of gave an update on their COVID protocols. It was right after the storm broke. So we got a lot of updates, just a lot of snow stuff. And yeah, it was really interesting. And I look forward to being the alternate on that. I will do my best to attend those meetings as much as possible. So that's my report. Thank you, Sarah.

2:56:41 For myself, I've had meetings with several people from the police chief on down, but nothing really reportable back. I didn't need to ask counsel on, so I will keep mine short. Great snowstorm. I plan to go out this weekend and recreate in it. That being said, I will now shut myself up and turn the meeting over to our Mayor Pro Tem, Lynda. Thank you. Thank you. Sorry you have to leave. Thank you.

2:57:11 Okay, so that brings us then to item number 13, which is awarding the contract for the sale of real property and construction of affordable housing for the parcel. And I think that Grady, Sandra, which one of you is going to lead us in this? That's correct. I'll take this item.

2:57:38 For the sale of the parcel, Sandra has the next one with her staff of public hearing, and I'll be back for the third item on the agenda. There are, as you said, three items tonight for the parcel itself. This is probably the shortest of the three, and I know we have a long meeting. I won't read the whole staff report, but suffice it to say that staff and the town went through an arduous request for qualifications process to select a developer for the parcel.

2:58:03 Well, over a year ago. It started in late 2019 and went into 2020. At that time, the process we used was correct and appropriate and legal. Subsequent to that, some changes were made in the Surplus Lands Act that the town attorney has already actually described in detail, so he's available to ask some questions, of course. We found that we needed to go through another process. We sent a request for bids out to over 250.

2:58:31 Potential partners on the HDC list, the state of California's housing list. We did get two responses. The high bidder, which we were looking for the high bidder on this one because it was for sale of property, was Pacific West Community, South of Eagle, Idaho. It happened to be the same company that we had worked with about a year ago. We did get a second bid from Chelsea Investments Corporation. That's a very qualified firm, well-qualified financial firm.

2:59:00 San Diego County, I'm very familiar with them and some of their people. But Pacific was the high bidder, and we are recommending award to Pacific on this item. If this one, if the council does choose to make this award, the second and third item, especially the third, we'll explain a little bit more about how the sale itself will proceed. And that's it, unless you have any questions whatsoever. Okay, let's, thank you, Grady, I appreciate that.

2:59:26 So let's go through the three of us and any questions. I'll start with you, Kirk. Any questions for staff? I have no questions. We've only been working on this for 40 years. Andrea knows the project very well. And she's still with us. Okay. Thank you, Kirk. John? Andy, a question for you. Are you satisfied with the...

2:59:57 With the process that was undertaken by staff, results of the process, do you have any concerns from a legal perspective on the item in front of us? I am satisfied. I do not have any concerns. I worked hand-in-hand with Grady and Sandra to make sure the process fits the somewhat weird requirements of the law in its current state. I think the process was done correctly, and I think that Grady's recommendation of...

3:00:23 I think I see Grady's hand up there, too. Thank you.

3:00:53 I just want to add one thing. We did get a letter in public comment from Chelsea Investment Corporation, and they basically offered that they're still very interested in the parcel, and it is certainly up to Pacific to propose, but they're welcome to talk to them if they want to, and maybe in a year, two years, ten years, or ever, they can come to some agreement that helps us all. So it's not out of the boat. We appreciate Chelsea's involvement, and we are by no minds encouraging or discouraging anything Pacific does, but I did want to recognize we got that letter.

3:01:22 We recognize it and we did our due diligence. So thank you. Okay. Thank you very much, Grady. All right. Is there any public comment on this at all, Jamie? It's not. Did you say no, Jamie? Sorry. Nope. No public comment. Okay. Thank you. All right. Any further comments from either Councilmember Stapp or Councilmember Wentworth? I'm prepared to make a motion, Madam. All right. Please.

3:01:51 So I would move that the council award the sale of real property for the construction of affordable housing in the parcel to the highest responsive bidder, Pacific West Communities Incorporated, the amount of $6,604,000 to further waive any minor irregularity in the bid, and finally to authorize the town manager to execute necessary agreements upon preparation, review, and approval by the town attorney. All right, thank you. Do we have a second? I second the motion. Okay, we have a motion by?

3:02:23 Council Member Wentworth and a second by Council Member Stapp. Jamie, can you call for the vote, please? Council Member Stapp? Yes. Council Member Wentworth? Aye. Mayor Pro Tem, Salcido? Yes. All right. We have a motion that has been voted on and carried. And is there anything else anybody needs on that one? Dan? I think we're good to go, Mayor Pro Tem. And the next thing we have here is a...

3:02:55 Public hearing. So I'm going to open a public hearing. And the topic is to consider approval. And I apologize because this was asked to me to read completely. So to consider approval of use permit, UPA 20-003, requesting a 100% density bonus through the town's density bonus program to allow for up to 580 affordable housing units to be constructed in phases on the 25-acre parcel site.

3:03:25 Thank you so much.

3:03:55 Facility, Community Center, and Public Park. All right. Based on that, then, would staff like to walk us through this, please? So as we've done in the past, we're going to do kind of a joint presentation with the applicant. So for tonight, we're going to ask the applicant to start the presentation. So with that, I'll turn it over to Andrea Clark. Thank you, Sandra. Thank you, Mayor Salcido. I'm waiting for Shellen.

3:04:29 Thank you, Kirk. We have been working on this for a long time. I haven't been working on it for 40 years, but maybe 20. I'm not quite that old, but close. But this is, I just want to start by acknowledging this is kind of a landmark day.

3:04:53 I think that it is something that the leadership should be proud of, that the community should be proud of, and the staff should be proud of, that we are here today to approve the first phase of development on the parcel, which has always been intended for testing. And tomorrow we are submitting for financing, which we are incredibly hopeful will go forward for this first phase of the project. There is no guarantee.

3:05:23 Just to submit for financing is a huge endeavor. It requires permitting. It requires staff cooperation. It requires leadership to take action. It requires site control. It requires so many things to basically say, yes, come spring, we're ready to put a shovel in the ground and start this housing should we be awarded. And so for so many years,

3:05:49 For Council's insight to buy the property, for the community process, to plan the parcel, and then to be able to be honored, to be selected, to help implement your vision. I think that you should all be really proud of your leadership. Staff should be proud of their work.

3:06:05 And the community should be really proud of their participation and holding leadership accountable. So I don't want that to go unsaid as we get into the nitty-gritty of this approval because it's remarkable to be here and it's been really a privilege to work with all of you and the staff and the community to be able to get to where we are. So thank you very much for being able to be here. So Shellen, on the next slide, you'll see our team.

3:06:33 Caleb and I and Shellen are your leadership and project management team of our in-house team, which consists of development, finance, construction, and asset management people in our in-house for us. We're about 50 or some employees in Idaho. And then we have our architecture and engineering team, which are based in Tahoe. They've worked in Mammoth. They know snow country. Jordan Knighton has worked in Mammoth for years.

3:07:02 We feel very comfortable with our team and feel like we can just deliver a really great product. So forward to showing what we have. So you all, the most recent action that you took prior to this meeting was approving the master plan for the parcel. And that basically created its own zoning for the parcel, including density and just an overall setbacks.

3:07:31 Design guidelines, how we will come forward in the process. And the one, I think the most important thing to touch on with regard to the master plan is that every phase that to be developed will come back to PEDC for review and approval. So the public will have an opportunity to comment every time we propose to develop more units.

3:07:55 So this particular approval is coming to council for 81 units and future approvals will go to PEDC for design review. So the public will have an opportunity to participate in this process as the parcel is developed. We understand how important it is to the community. We understand that every action is critical in regard to design and parking and number of units and all of those details who we're going to serve are really important to the community. So we will come back.

3:08:24 Every time. And so as you look at this timeline, here we are at looking at the use permit for the phase one and kind of oddly the use permit that permits the density and we can talk about that shortly. Next slide, Joellen. So here we are. We've completed the master plan. We got the zoning code amendment that repealed the affordable housing overlay. I have to tell you personally, given my history in Mammoth,

3:08:54 That affordable housing overlay was critical to preserving the affordable housing and the workforce housing potential of this property for years and years and years. And when staff first said, oh, we're going to repeal this affordable housing overlay, I kind of hyperventilated. And I said, no, no, no, you can't do that. Like, that's what makes this special. And Andy and the staff worked, Andy Morris and the staff worked to say, no, no, we're going to do this as a use permit to be able to preserve the density.

3:09:22 The master plan preserves the affordability. The zoning code amendment that was repealed takes off that affordable housing overlay. And what we're here today is this use permit allows for the density that you already approved in the master plan. So it's sort of a formality. And then Shailen will walk you through the design review approval for phase one. Next slide. So this was the master plan that you approved previously.

3:09:54 Every application will come for a major design review. You'll have public comment. Everything will come back for public review. Right now, we're looking at that turquoise area for phase one, and that is what's before you tonight as the major design review application.

3:10:14 Thanks, we'll go back to EDC and then we'll have an opportunity for public comment. Everything that we're presenting with you tonight is consistent with what you approved through the master plan process when you adopted that master plan for the parcel. So this is kind of a strange slide because all of the area is shaded there, but basically it's intended to tell you that the use permit in particular, which covers the entire parcel site,

3:10:43 And it is going to provide for the density allowed on the site. And I know that there's been a lot of conversation. We heard a lot of public comment and also comments from you, Councilmembers, about concerns about the density. But the master plan that you approved allowed for a minimum of 400 units and a maximum of 580 units. This can be changed by you really at any time.

3:11:12 And all of that is part of the community conversation.

3:11:42 Sets the table for maximum density for the entire site only. So it doesn't say that that is what shall be there. It just says this is what is allowed. And every time we go for approvals, the PEDC will have the opportunity to consider up to a total of 580 units based on this use permit. And this goes hand in hand with repealing the affordable housing overlay. So the two go together.

3:12:11 Basically says we don't have the affordable housing overlay anymore, but now we have this density and the master plan dictates the affordability levels and how many rental and ownership units happen on this site. So it's kind of a formality, but it is something that's necessary for us to take action in order to be able to go forward in the next phase. So next, I'm going to turn it over to Shellyn to talk about the

3:12:38 Major design review application for phase one, which is very specific for our initial development that we hope to start construction on in the spring. Thank you. Can everybody hear me? Right now, yes. Yes, okay. Thank you, Andrea. I just wanted to add one thing to this slide that you're looking at is just to confirm and just remind that

3:13:06 One of the various reasons, in addition to what Andrea spoke about, that we're doing it in this manner with this use permit and the density and the master plan is really to meet some of the preferred plan requirements of maintaining the open space, maintaining ample rights of way for these connections to existing.

3:13:30 Road Frameworks, creating the public space in the park, and then making sure that we can maintain density and height in the center of the site, as you'll see tonight, but also along the edges that are least impactful, along the edges that are closest to commercial, you know, shorter buildings, closest to single family. So I just wanted to remind you of...

3:13:54 Of that, sorry. Okay, so diving into phase one and the design review of this plan. And I think you recall it's two buildings coming down from Center Street. We call this building B and building A is the larger building. It's three floors of residential units over podium parking. So most of the parking, most of it will be under cover, right, as a podium.

3:14:23 There are studios, ones, twos, and three bedrooms. And in total, what you're looking at is 93 spaces for the 81 units, which does not include the what I'm calling off-sites, which are on Center Street and Tavern. I'll dive into parking because, again, we know it's a big issue. So I'll spend a few slides on that later. But for now, you know, this particular phase has...

3:14:47 Two trees that are of interest in the tree survey. One is a heritage tree and the other is considered a unique tree. And we revised that, you know, we showed the master plan around kind of where we could include the park to make sure that those two trees, which are located right where my mouse is in this community park, could be preserved.

3:15:09 You can see here on the first floor these beige areas. This is a community center which will be primarily for residents but of course can serve the greater community, about 5,000 square feet, which is larger than our requirements but is certainly, we're certainly excited about. The daycare, the proposed daycare center is over here also adjacent to their outdoor fenced playground area, about 2,500 square feet.

3:15:36 Those might be revised. We've been working with Amaka and Mono County to try to make sure that we're adequately meeting their needs and creating this building envelope for what we hope will be a joint venture with them as a daycare provider. We've got bike storage at each building covered and secure. It also includes, for aiming to include a dog washing and bike washing station, right, just a place for residents to wash their muddy bikes or their muddy dogs.

3:16:05 And in these, in addition to the common space that is associated with the daycare area, there's also a playground that, you know, we believe would be associated with the entire park. And then this version doesn't have it, but we're showing a picnic area as well as additional sort of recreational outdoor amenities kind of tucked back here in between Building B and the mill ditch. So I told you I would talk about parking and I'm just going to, I don't want to.

3:16:35 Belabor it, but I do want, I do think it's really important. And so this image you've all seen before, it was, it actually came directly from the preferred plan that was accepted just over a year ago. And I've revised it a little bit because I just want to point out that, you know, we all talk about affordable housing and the affordable housing overlay that's been on this site for, as Kirk, as Councilmember Kirk said.

3:17:01 Almost 40 years. And so that was done for a variety of reasons, obviously. But I think it's important to note that the location of this site lends itself as an infill site lends itself to being able to

3:17:16 Depend on alternative transportation modes by the location itself. And so we in the business, the affordable housing business, we're always talking about how to make sure that our rents are meeting the needs of the members of the communities that we work in. And what we oftentimes, what we're constantly reminding ourselves of is that our rents are the number one thing that a family has to pay for, right?

3:17:42 As a family household, the number one expense we have is housing, and the number two is transportation. So by default, when you create an infill development that has access to services and doesn't require multiple cars, you are enabling a family to hopefully spend money in different ways in the local economy for health care, et cetera. So this site, every black dot is a representative of a bus stop.

3:18:10 Including the ones that are proposed, you know, in the master plan. All the purple dashes represent, you know, a safe route to these services. Within a half mile, you have the pharmacy, grocery outlet, the bakery, post office. And then within a mile, you have some larger, you know, the hospital, the schools.

3:18:29 Library, ice rink, those kinds of things. So it really is an amazing opportunity to provide truly affordable housing and affordable transportation where a family can easily have one car to live in this development. Excuse me, Madam Mayor Pro Tem, Sean, would it be okay if I share my screen just for a second? Sure. So I stop sharing, you start sharing. Thank you. So, Sean, can you all see this?

3:19:02 So just to add to what you're just saying, I want to make sure, this is a comment we made in our mobility discussion earlier this evening, to make sure that we're including infrastructure that... John, you lost your sound. I can't hear you. Can you hear me now? Yes. Okay, sorry. This red line represents the town loop, right? This green line is a shady rest path. This is another MUP connector.

3:19:37 Obviously, we are a recreation-centric community. People want to live here because all of the things you're talking about, Shaolin, but I want to make sure that going forward that we're providing maps and doing this kind of stuff. You work with the town staff, the GIS department to make sure we're representing all the recreation amenities as well. One of the many things we're working through with the scenarios, how is someone going to get from the parcel to Shady Rest Park without getting into a car?

3:20:03 Whether it's wintertime to go cross-country skiing or the summertime to walk their dogs or to go mountain biking or whatever, please make sure we're including these types of representations going forward. So that's it. Madam Mayor Pro Tem, thank you for indulging me that opportunity to share graphics that I made all by myself. Thank you. Good job. Okay. Go ahead, Sean. Okay.

3:20:30 Your graphics are good compared to some of the ones that I think I make, so thank you for sharing that, and I think noted on these kinds of slides, it's not just about services, it's about recreation opportunities, right, and really how are folks that are, you know, that are living here going to access those, so we have it high on our radar, and I was just going to kind of get into that a little bit with talking about sort of the

3:20:54 The specifics of our parking plan. So when we were looking at the preferred plan, we thought, gosh, this is quite a reduction in parking, right, that the preferred plan was suggesting, and does this work for us? And so when, you know, when we looked through the preferred plan, we saw that map that I just showed you, we started thinking, yeah, I think maybe this could work, especially if these are covered.

3:21:16 We were asked, I think it was during the workshop, to sort of look at the Pacific Company's assets in snow country. And we have over 400 units, apartments, in nine different developments that are in high elevation snow country. That's, you know, Tahoe, Truckee, but also Jackson Hole, Wyoming, and in Idaho. So those units and those developments that are not surface parked,

3:21:42 So the ones in Mammoth are surface parked, right? Jefferies, the Aspens, those are surface parked. But those projects that we own that are not surface parked have a ratio of parking per unit much very similar to this at about the same as this, which is between 1.2 and 1.3. So I just wanted to remind you that you had asked that question that we had kind of done our homework on that end. And that also helped us get really comfortable with this.

3:22:10 What you're seeing here, right, is the 70 spots that are under Building B and A, along with an additional 20 some, 23 spots that are in this area, surface parked, along with 20 on-street parking spaces that, you know, are along Center Street and the proposed Tavern Road. The condition of approval, I believe it's 82.

3:22:34 Requires these spaces to not be angled but to be perpendicular. So in doing initial studies and revisions to that, you know, we will gain roughly 10 spots overall by going perpendicular. So just to put it in perspective of parking, what your existing code says and what we know we're going to get on site, including on street, we're about 13 spots short.

3:23:02 Compared to code, if we were just standard code. So I just wanted to keep that in mind. It's about 13 spots, which is about, this is nine spots here, so it's about that many spots. So what are we going to do to try to alleviate that? You know, one of the things that Andrea and I are intending on doing and that we would do regardless of this conversation is work with our neighbors. We know there's a lot of unused or underutilized surface spots in the area.

3:23:31 Work with our neighbors to see if there's a way to get some night parking. Maybe for a fee or for some maintenance or whatever the issue is. E-bike sharing. We have some plans to look at how we can do that.

3:23:47 You know, whether we can have some e-bikes that are available for rent or that we partner. I mean, when I heard the gentleman speak from the limelight, I was like, oh, well, they're going to be doing shuttles to the airport and shuttles to Bishop and, you know, some of the, you know, the West End, they're doing those things. And is there a way for us to partner with them? We also, I think I've told you in the past about our resident rewards program, which is really a way for us to

3:24:12 Maintain good relationships with our residents and we use the rewards program to incentivize residents for everything from, you know, paying rent on time to learning about how to be safe in the event of a fire or how to help put out a grease fire. But we can also do things like incentivize them to not drive or incentivize them to utilize transit instead of having to move their car around.

3:24:35 So those are some ideas that we've been entertaining. And when we looked at the conditions of approval, there's some new options in there that are really trying to get at the heart of this parking issue. And to be frank, you know, we are your partner. We will do whatever you need us to do, right, in regards to these options A and options B that are in your staff report. Neither one of them are great.

3:25:04 Neither one of them feel great to us, and I can go over that, but, you know, I think the important thing to remember is that when we looked at our site plan, we knew that we were going to be scrutinized for parking, and we knew that the preferred plan was low on parking, and we chose to go that route because we think it could work.

3:25:25 And we also know that every future phase is going to come before you and you can require us to add additional parking or create some shared parking opportunities. So when we did this, we realized that if we wanted to add more parking, we were going to have to decrease our units. Or if we wanted to add more parking, we were going to have to decrease the park area or affect the heritage trees or the unique trees. There's just simply no other way.

3:25:52 So that's just where our head was, and it's not to say that your head should be there, but that's just what our thinking was. So option A, right, prior to CFO, and these are paraphrasing, but the developer shall provide parking management plan for consideration that demonstrates how alternative transportation will reduce the needs for the project. We can do that, but there's certainly some level of discomfort.

3:26:20 That we have with that because we just don't really know exactly what PEDC or the Town Council would want to see there. And then option B is similar in that it says prior to C of O, the project shall be required to meet the requirements set forth in code, which is, you know, the delta again is that 13 spaces unless a reduction in parking is approved by Town Council. Theoretically, that makes a lot of sense to us.

3:26:48 What I show here in bold is that it's incredibly difficult, and I think it will be ultimately incredibly difficult to our lenders to see this condition, knowing that we will have had a lot line created, we will have had a lot created, we will have buildings drawn and hopefully being constructed, and there's no more room on this site for additional parking. The buildings are what they are because they're podium.

3:27:15 It doesn't show it well in this image, but there's a flood line from the milled edge. This is the wetland delineation line, and there's a milled edge flood line that comes right about in here. So we have really squeezed this development into where the existing connection is to Center Street, because this site, if there was a parcel here, there is a parcel here that the town owns.

3:27:38 And it's really squeezed between a good connection to center and this flood line. So it's difficult for us in a worst case scenario, which is my job to think through, it would be very difficult for us to achieve this given we would not be owning the land that additional parking could be put on. We've always been good partners. You guys have been good partners. We don't think we're going to get to that. But just in theory, it is a little disappointing.

3:28:08 So anyway, we talked to staff a lot about it. I think that they've got a third option, an option C, if you will, that I don't even think I've seen the final of, but I do think it marries option A and option B in a way that is very agreeable to us. So I just wanted to let you kind of know where we were coming from. And again, we're...

3:28:34 I'm extraordinarily excited for this project and to be your partners on it, so we'll take what we can get, but I just wanted to be really upfront with you on some of the challenges that we were looking at when we saw those options out there. Michelle, if I could just interject real quick, I do think that the Chandler's presentation will talk a little bit more about the specifics of a condition to help manage this parking, and we really are your partner, and

3:29:03 You know, if we were a conventional developer doing resort development, so it's a foreign action in parking because then they can get more units and it's a better use of land and they make more money. Well, that's not really the case here. You know, we are your partners and our ability to make money is governed by the state and federal government and our partnership with you, which you have complete control of. So this is not a...

3:29:30 This is not a financial gain or lose from us as a developer. And we would just really see it as, you know, we took in all of the things that we read in the preferred plan and walk, bike, ride, and looking at the future vision and not just looking at town code. And our job was, where is Mammoth Lakes going in the future? And what is that vision? And what is our role in implementing that vision?

3:30:00 And, of course, I have Elizabeth Tenney in the back of my head saying, you know, we are a village in the trees. And this site, you know, has so much history, has so many trees, is so beautiful, serves as a dog-walking park and a place that people treasure in so many ways, and yet we're building housing there.

3:30:20 In looking at the site, you know, Sheldon and I have been around and around like, oh my gosh, why don't we have more parking? And we go back to, oh right, we looked at the, we started with the preferred plan. We started with these vision documents. We looked to where the town said they wanted to go and we worked to try to implement that vision. And so then I started thinking, well, how do we get more parking on this site? And with the exception of digging underground.

3:30:47 Which is ridiculously expensive. That comes at the cost of a per unit contribution to house people. How is it that we do this? And truly the only alternative I see is for more parking is to dig underground, which then costs the town more money, which is then less money to provide housing for more people. So it's not that we don't recognize that people have cars and lives and everything else.

3:31:13 We just feel like we're implementing the town's vision and that housing is the priority on this site. So we know that through the planning process for the preferred plan, you talked about putting a parking garage on the site and that's not in the preferred plan. It's just not. So we're not putting a parking garage here. And so how is it that we like come to some reconciliation of providing quality housing, enough parking for functionality?

3:31:42 Circulation, encourage alternative modes, try to work with the town on alternate parking strategies, remote parking facilities, implement those visions. And we think that this first phase is a step in the right direction. And we look forward to working with staff and council on, you know, continuing to implement that vision. And honestly, it's my hope that we're back here having this conversation for a second and third phase before the first phase is even occupied.

3:32:10 And we're talking again about mobility and parking and people and where the town is going and all the things that Hayes spoke about earlier in the meeting. Like, how do we get there? And we're here to help you get there. And we just want to be able to get this going and know that, like, there is a solution. And we will work with the community to make it workable. Madam Mayor, if I could, I just want to make, I want to point out another very important moment that we're at right here.

3:32:40 In terms of changing the culture of the town and the council and staff of how we address these problems. We are not kicking this problem down the road. We are having a proactive discussion and it's so beautiful that you've identified, hey, we're 13 spaces short. Cool. Let's know that now. Let's identify that problem now. This council does not want to be in a position of dealing with a bunch of irate residents saying,

3:33:09 You screw this up. And so we're not only dealing with an IRA resident population, we're trying to fix the problem at the same time. This is exactly how we have to be addressing these problems. So I want to commend staff for listening to council and hearing our concerns and into your team for bringing this information forward in front of us. This is how we have to manage all of this stuff going forward. We are in Ireland. We have a limited land base.

3:33:35 We must be proactive in how we make these decisions. And Kirk, I know your concerns about density and parking. This is how we're going to address these things, by being proactive, by being ahead of it, and coming up with solutions before we're dealing with problems. So I just want to point that out. Thank you. Okay. Any other comment on that? Or should we continue? Andrea, go ahead. I can take it. Andrea, were you finished? I think Kirk's got his hand up there, Linda. I'm sorry, I can't see him. Yes, Kirk, please go ahead.

3:34:09 Andrea, how many parking spaces per unit? Did you hear me? I can answer that. And I'm sorry, I have one screen, so I can't see everybody and share my screen at the same time. Or I probably can, I just don't know how. But we are at about one, and Chandler probably knows off the top of his head now, but I think it's about 1.2. If you include Bob Street parking, we're at 1.39 spaces per unit.

3:34:43 And that's before they incorporate the parallel parking. Once they add an additional 10 spaces, it would be at, sorry, I'm using my phone calculator here, would be at 1.51 spaces per unit. So one and a half spaces per unit, basically. So really that's, in terms of just required parking for residential units, we're actually above the code there.

3:35:16 The code would just require additional spaces for guest parking. So basically we're missing the delta. What we're missing is basically what the code would require for guest parking. Interestingly, Shailen and I were talking today about your most recent storm, and I woke up in the middle of the night having, you know, been in many big mammoth storms. I woke up in the middle of the night and I thought, well, gosh, if I was living in that development, I would probably...

3:35:44 Knowing the storm was coming, I would rally all the residents and get them all in one place and say, okay, how can we get as many cars as possible under this structure, under the podium so that everyone has their car and we can plow most efficiently? And I know that sounds a little bit crazy for 81 households, but when you do the math between the two buildings and the surface parking, we decided that if we put...

3:36:09 Sort of the critical workers, let's say we had a snow plow driver that had to get out, that was at the front of the line that had to get out of the podium garage. There would really only be 11 households that we had to sort of work with and say, how do we protect your car in this storm and make sure no one's sleeping in their car, that everybody has a way to get to work when the roads are plowed. And it seemed like a pretty...

3:36:31 It's a reasonable, safe outcome to think that way when you're looking at, okay, how does this actually play out from a realistic standpoint? You're talking about residents, everybody lives here, everybody works, not everyone's gonna be friends, but will everyone work together? Should there be an emergency like this where you're like, oh my gosh, we're in a place where people might not get to work and their car could be buried for the rest of the season? How do we work on this as a community?

3:36:57 It was kind of an interesting exercise for us to talk through. And, you know, we are talking about real people who really live here and who really need their car when the roads are clouded and when they have to get to work. So it was just an interesting thought process of, like, what does it really mean for this parking ratio that we have under these buildings to protect people's cars so that they can not have to shovel their car and be exhausted by the time they get to work and then have to go shovel a lift out.

3:37:27 Or help someone to their car with their groceries, right? Yes, that is interesting, Andrew. Thank you. All right, Shelly, did you want to continue here or did you want to stay on the parking for a little while? You know, I'm happy to continue. I suspect we'll get back to it. So just really quick, you guys have seen this slide before, but, you know, like Andrea mentioned, it's a great segue. You know, it is, these are real folks, right? These are real folks who live.

3:37:58 And Mammoth and probably some folks that want to live in Mammoth that can't right now and they're out farther, farther out and having to utilize more cars. But, you know, these are folks that are teaching in our preschools that are working in our restaurants and, you know, other things, but their households are earning up to 80% of the area median income. And so I have those numbers here, $17,000 to $75,000 a year.

3:38:24 And that equals a rent from just over $400 to just under $1,700 a month. And these are permanent deed restricted units, right? No short-term rentals, year-long leases, and they're folks that are living and working in the region, like I mentioned. In addition to the parking homework that we did, we were also asked to sort of look and make sure that what we were proposing in this first phase really was addressing the need.

3:38:52 In the community. And so our first stop was Mammoth Lakes Housing late December. We worked with them to determine what their waitlist was and if they had a sense of the incomes of the folks on the waitlist.

3:39:06 There's 95 households back in December. This is the breakup of the unit size, the household size, but about most of them, 94% were below 80% of the AMI. So 94% of the folks on the wait list would be eligible, in theory, to live on this site. So I think it's a great...

3:39:30 It really, it's a testament to that this phase, this first phase is meeting the existing need in the community. In addition, you know, we recently got awarded or committed the county, Mono County committed up to $2.3 million in No Place Like Home funds. That's an acronym here. You know, and that's to serve those eight units of

3:39:55 Folks that are facing homelessness or mental health have mental health issues. So we really are reaching down to the deeply affordable units up to the very much working core at the 80% of the AMI. So going back to phase one and talking about those community amenities, which will also in this community area, which in the previous image was right.

3:40:23 It's right here facing this sort of promenade area and then facing the park. That will serve as a place to gather. It'll be an opportunity for residents to have family events, retirement parties, quinceaneras, you know, whatever, as well as opportunities to have social services provisions and residence classes. A lot of the times we do a variety of social services, whether it's

3:40:50 The financial, you know, how to plan for your financial future, you know, ESL opportunities or other, you know, other kind of class oriented things. This is the public park. Again, I'm trying to show the childcare area is here. And then it looks out onto the promenade and also the play facilities.

3:41:18 I won't spend a ton of time on the floor plans. I know you've seen these, but they meet your minimum requirements. It's about 25% three bedrooms, 25% one bedrooms, and then, you know.

3:41:30 50% studios and ones. We really strive for an open floor plan. These gray areas that you see represent sort of common areas. There's some stairs and the elevators in addition to these gray boxes represent additional storage areas and common laundry rooms as well as little nooks to do like Zoom rooms or library spots. We really focus on common

3:41:56 This is a view from the southeast, right? This is looking at the park, community space here coming down Center Street. This is sort of the buildings and elevations. We're proposing

3:42:25 Materials that are very durable and they meet all the requirements of our financing institutions. But we have an articulated elevation here with a variety of materials and a variety of textures, including fiber cement panels and lap siding, as well as some accents with corrugated metal and wood accents, as well as like textured cord. Let's see. So this is an image. This is the daycare facility and this kind of shows the

3:42:57 Area that will be that natural playscape along with the park. And these are kind of representative of existing trees. Some of the trees are over 200 feet high. And this one here is one of those heritage trees that we're saving. This is an image or view from the northeast coming down center. This is where you would pull into the development. You know, these don't have complete streets in the renderings. We were in...

3:43:24 When we were getting these renderings together, we were quite crunched for time, so forgive us for not including the sidewalks and mumps in the image. This is one that you saw earlier with the materials, but you see the play area, the existing trees, and the roof lines that really do sort of ground the development so that it gives it a nice pedestrian feel, human-scaled.

3:43:49 So for next steps, you know, here we are in February. Financing will be submitted tomorrow. A huge kudos to everyone, including the, you know, the town and leadership, staff and leadership to really help make this happen. We've got that, you know, the commitment from Mono County. We're hoping for the commitment from the town. We've got in March, we would solidify and execute the

3:44:17 Disposition and Development Agreement for the master plan area and then start working on our CDs or construction design drawings to get the infrastructure in as early as this summer or spring when the snow melts. At that time, we would also have the lot line adjustment completed. We are hoping to start on tree removal as early as possible.

3:44:39 And then just pull those permits and get moving, at least on the site work, and hopefully with funding, we'd be able to start vertically. So that's just a synopsis of some of the things that are on our plate for the coming months. But that's the end of my presentation, the end of our presentation, I should say. And I think it's going to be time to turn it over to Chandler. I just, I do want to just take one minute and...

3:45:06 You know, express my gratitude to the town and leadership to get us to where we are today. And it is really been a tremendous lift. And I think that Andrea and I have had the easy part. Our team is at the easy part in a sense. And I'd say the town and creating a needs assessment, identifying a parcel to purchase, purchasing it, putting out a request for qualifications and being able to award it is.

3:45:32 Really a tremendous thing to do in two and a half years and having a line to creating financing and getting a financing application in in that amount of time is tremendous. And so thank you. Thank you. Great. Sorry. Thank you, Sean. Appreciate that. Okay, staff. Who's going to leave here? Chandler? Yeah, I will give staff's presentation. Thankfully.

3:45:58 Shellyn made my job fairly easy. That was a pretty comprehensive and awesome presentation. Thank you, Shellyn. I will share my screen here. Okay, can everyone see that? Yes, now we can see that. Thank you. Looks good. Okay, maybe I should go to the start. All right. So, you guys are all very familiar right now with what we're here to review, the use permit and phase one design review for the parcel.

3:46:39 You've already heard the applicant presentations. I'll give this presentation and you can hold a public hearing and then Town Council action or discussion and action to adopt the attached resolution, making the required CEQA use permit and design review findings and approving UPA 2003 and DR2005 with conditions as recommended by staff, adopt the resolution with modifications or deny the resolution. Background, which I feel like we've kind of already been over to an extent, but I'll just quickly

3:47:09 Go back over the approval background anyways. December 9th, PEDC voted unanimously to adopt Resolution 2007 and recommended that Town Council adopt the district zoning amendment, zoning code amendment, use permit, and design review. January 6th was first reading of the ordinance approving district zoning amendment and zoning code amendment. January 20th, Town Council approved the second reading of the ordinance with a motion that also directed staff to review.

3:47:38 And come back with a synopsis of the town's adopted mobility planning documents, which Hayes did earlier tonight. So just again, the use permit that we are bringing to tonight is requesting 100% density bonus through the town density bonus program to allow for up to 580 affordable housing units. We construct it on the 25-acre parcel site, where 300 units is the maximum number allowed by the previously underlying RM of one zoning district.

3:48:09 The approved master plan requires a minimum of 400 units and allows a maximum of 580 units. I think Chellen did a really good job, or Andrea did a really good job explaining that this is not requiring 580 units, it just allows up to that, subject to approval by PEDC, phase by phase. So the phase one design review, which Chellen and Andrea just gave a really excellent overview of, just for the first phase of the parcel development.

3:48:38 Infrastructure improvements, 81 units, including 80 affordable multifamily units and one caretaker unit, along with the daycare facility, community center and public park. 93 on-street parking spaces and 25 plus on-street parking spaces provided consistent with the master plan requirements. So the CEQA findings, which these are the same CEQA findings that we brought to you for the district zoning amendment and the zoning code amendment.

3:49:07 And so we are, we reviewed the project pursuant to CEQA guidelines section 15183.3 streamlining for infill projects. An environmental checklist has been prepared, has evaluated the potential direct, indirect, and cumulative environmental effects associated with the project and demonstrated that such effects have been previously adequately analyzed in the final program EIR general plan update and Town of Mammoth Lakes general plan land use element and zoning code amendments and mobility element update draft EIR.

3:49:37 And or the impacts would be less than significant. Therefore, we found that pursuant to Public Resources Code Section 21094.5, CEQA does not apply to such effects. No additional environmental review is necessary for the project. So key issues, and these are really just kind of formalities on our end to show that the project has met the findings for these approvals. I think that, you know, Sean really got into the details of the project and how it meets the findings.

3:50:07 Luckily, I won't have to dive super deep into those. But key issue number one is just the use permit and density bonus findings. Does it meet them? Yes. The answer is yes. The request is consistent with general plan, including policy L2D, which allows for up to 24 units per acre for need-restricted workforce housing, which this project is. The DDA, which you guys will get to. Sorry, mini DDA tonight.

3:50:37 And then the full DDA later will ensure the operation is not detrimental to the public health, safety, or welfare. The project greatly exceeds the sufficient number of eligibility points per the town's density bonus program to be awarded the requested density. All units will be indeed restricted affordable and workforce housing. And it's compatible with the surrounding neighborhood with regards to building form, scale, materials, and street orientation. Key issue number two is the design review findings.

3:51:08 So as Sheldon and Andrea's presentation I think just demonstrated very well, the site building design elements are attractive and visually cohesive, they're compatible with the character of the area and community, encourage increased pedestrian activity and promote compatibility among neighboring hand uses. Complete street design is consistent with town goals and policies and with the desired character of the area.

3:51:35 118 parking spaces and that this number is kind of bouncing around again just because of the condition of approval and the fact that the developer has been working to accommodate additional on-street parking. So with the parallel parking, really that number will be 123 parking spaces total. It will be arranged in a safe, harmonious, and efficient manner and will minimize visibility and impervious area. Lighting will meet all municipal code standards.

3:52:03 Landscaping preserves heritage trees and incorporates native and adaptive materials. And the design standards that are included in the approved master plan are consistent with the Town of Mammoth Lakes design guidelines. And this project is consistent with master plan design guidelines. So just to go back over two kind of important conditions of approval, you know, we've received some feedback just about parking connectivity in general.

3:52:31 So just wanted to bring to the council's attention and just remind the council that there are currently two conditions of approval, or I guess one with two subparts that requires connectivity from inside the parcel site to outside of the parcel site. So as part of phase one, which is what these conditions of approval apply to.

3:52:53 The applicant will be responsible and required to provide multimodal connectivity from inside the master plan area through existing infrastructure outside the master plan area. Public Works Department reserves the right to modify these conditions to meet the intent of providing connectivity while managing the unknown constraints associated with the described improvements. So really what that's just getting at is that the Public Works Department kind of has the final say on the design of these connections.

3:53:21 We can modify them slightly if there are construction constraints that arise. So the first one is at a minimum a six-foot sidewalk with curb and gutter shall be constructed to town standards on the southerly side of Center Street from the intersection of Center Place heading easterly towards Main Street. So that means there will be a connection extending north along Center Street from inside the parcel to Main Street.

3:53:51 Remove some of the language from these conditions to keep them shorter, but the full condition specifies that they'll have to accommodate parking and pedestrian crosswalks and provide street lighting, etc. Part B says that a sidewalk or multi-use path connection to the existing sidewalk on Tavern Road will be constructed. That condition also includes requirements to provide safe pedestrian crossing and

3:54:19 Streetlights because as you know the existing sidewalk on Tavern Road where it meets Laurel Mountain Road is on the south side of Tavern Road and the multi-use path or sidewalk both on the within the parcel project or on the north side of Tavern Road so there will have to be some sort of cross over that intersection to get to the south side and we haven't determined exactly what that will be yet but this condition ensures that it will be done.

3:54:51 So Sheldon did a really good job of going over these existing options. I had some slides about this, but I'm not going to go back over these in depth. I think she did a really good job of pointing out the issues with these. You know, essentially, both of these conditions, these optional conditions, rely on what we call transportation demand management, right? So the first condition.

3:55:21 Basically, the first option says that staff and the developer would provide the transportation demand management plan for consideration by PEDC, and if it doesn't work, we'll provide parking. Option B basically says that that plan would have to be approved before the certificate of occupancy is issued, or else parking would have to be provided at that time. After communicating with...

3:55:48 Council was receiving feedback from the public and in discussions with the developer, which also just to remind council, we haven't been allowed to have discussions with the developer because we hadn't officially chosen the developer until about a week ago because of the Surplus Lands Act stuff. So at the time that the staff report was published, we actually hadn't had an opportunity to really sit down with Pacific and talk about these conditions. So we wrote them hoping.

3:56:17 You know, to achieve the goals and hoping that they would be okay after speaking with the developer and really thinking about it more. We essentially realized that option A is a bit too loose and option B is a bit too tight. That's putting it in the absolute simplest of terms. So in working with everyone, we have come up with option C. I'm just going to read this now because there's no way for me to clearly explain the difference.

3:56:47 Without reading it. So option C is as follows. Prior to the issuance of the first certificate of occupancy for a housing unit, the developer shall provide a parking management plan for final approval by the town council that demonstrates how alternative modes of transportation will reduce the parking needs for the project with consideration for the entire master planned area.

3:57:13 Identified solutions shall be primarily derived from the Town's mobility planning efforts, including both accepted and adopted documents, and should be in place prior to the issuance of the first certificate of occupancy. The parking management plan that will be developed in coordination with the Town should include clear metrics and triggers that allow additional parking to be provided for the project, with consideration for the master planned area.

3:57:40 If the management plan does not achieve its goal. Now I know that's quite a mouthful, but what essentially this does is it kind of marries the two previous conditions as Sean mentioned. So it allows the developer in the town to work together to create a parking management plan. This plan will have to be ready before the first certificate of occupancy is issued.

3:58:09 But this gives us the ability to create within that plan a clear timeline for when we want the goals of the plan to be achieved, right? And it also allows us to monitor and evaluate the plan and to tweak the plan over a period of time to really address the specific needs of residents of the parcel.

3:58:37 When we agree upon the timeframe that the plan has to prove that it's working, so whether that's a year, whether that is prior to submittal for phase two, you know, those are two kind of timelines that make sense in our mind, but again, we will bring this plan to council and council will have the final say on, you know, the timelines and the goals that we're providing and the metrics and how we're going to monitor it. Within that timeframe,

3:59:05 We'll have the ability to really modify the plan as needed. So an example of that is we conduct a survey. Once the project is full, we ask residents about their transportation needs. We ask them where they work. And if we find that 50% of residents all work night shifts, let's say in locations that are served by two specific bus routes, we can...

3:59:33 Work with ESTA to immediately expand the hours of operation for those two bus routes to provide late night service. So that's just one example of an easy fix. Or if we survey residents and they say, you know, we would like more guest parking, but really it's just on weekends and holidays that we have guests. Rest of the time parking is fine. That would tell us that, hey, maybe we don't have to pay a neighboring property owner.

4:00:00 for parking spaces 365 days of the year. Maybe we can enter into a shared parking agreement for weekends and holidays. So in any case, this option basically provides that kind of timeline to allow us to make really, you know, specific additions to the plan to achieve the goals. And in the end, if we determine after a set period of time that the goals of the management plan are not being met,

4:00:27 It will include a provision that allows us or requires us to provide the additional parking, make up the delta, provide the 13 spaces or more, because this option also includes consideration of the entire master plan area. So I think this option, you know, really, it better ties the TDM strategies that we're hoping to use to the project as a whole, as opposed to just this phase. So this option, staff feels like if the council is going to

4:00:57 Request to add an additional condition of approval to the project. We feel that this option really is the best and the most comprehensive in terms of achieving the council's goals and addressing parking concerns. And we have discussed it with the developer and they're okay with it as well. So just jumping to key issue number three, CEQA consistency. I don't need to read through all of this. We have the infill environmental checklist. We have made the findings that no additional CEQA review is required.

4:01:28 These are the same findings that were included and used as the basis for approval of the master claim zoning code amendment. So, staff findings and recommendation. This is another mouthful. Staff finds that the proposed project meets the applicable requirements and recommends that the Town Council adopt the attached resolution approving use permit 20003 for a 100% density bonus and design review 20005.

4:01:57 To allow for development of Phase 1 of the Parcel Affordable Housing Project located at 1699 Tavern Road and 33 Center Street, consistent with District Zoning Amendment 20001, the 2021 Parcel Master Plan, and making findings under the California Environmental Quality Act pursuant to State CEQA Guidelines Section 15183.3. That is it for my presentation.

4:02:23 I will stop sharing now unless you want me to keep sharing if anyone wants to refer to any of these large paragraphs. Why don't you leave it up for a moment and let's move to the council where they can ask technical questions, clarification questions. So let's go ahead and do that. So, John, I'm going to start with you on this for any kind of technical questions, clarifications that we're doing here.

4:02:54 Thank you, everybody. I have reviewed all the materials to the point where I'm going to have to check in with the eyeglass people. I want to thank staff for their diligence and persistence. I want to thank the developer for their nimble, their ability to accommodate a variety of very challenging circumstances.

4:03:21 Chandler, I'm very pleased with the option C, as you read it aloud, if you're reading of that option C. That fits all my criteria needs. The only minor thing I would add is Chandler, in your quotation from the motion at the last council meeting, the word proactive didn't make it onto your slide, probably because of length concerns, but that idea that this is a proactive effort.

4:03:49 When we start getting into the stuff, we need to be ahead of the curve at all times. But with that being said, Madam Mayor, I'm prepared to make a motion once you and Kirk have had a chance to weigh in. So thank you. Okay, let's go ahead. And any questions you have at this point? There you go. I'm worried about the density. I'll be honest about it. That's my biggest concern and the parking issues. And I've expressed these concerns several times.

4:04:25 And so I'm hoping that through the process, after we do the first phase, that we have the flexibility, and I'm sure we will, the flexibility to adjust. And so, yes, let's move forward with the first parcel and then analyze that as we go forward. Because I think there are some issues there that we're going to have to put it on the ground before we really...

4:04:53 Know the impacts. That's my comments. So yes, let's move forward. All right, thank you. This is a really big thing we're about to do here. This is really notable. And I couldn't thank the staff enough for preparing this for us and for Pacific for...

4:05:14 Bring this forward. I think that we have as much information like John and I'm sure Kirk too feels that we have been studying this and studying this and trying to come to the right decisions. So on that note, I'm going to stop a second because this is a public hearing and take any comments from the public. Jamie, is there any public comments here? Yes. Jennifer Kreitz, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hi.

4:05:43 Thank you. And thank you to everyone, staff, the applicant, council, everyone for this. And, you know, we've been kind of staying up to date on this at the Mono County side, but I have a few observations and questions. It sounds like there's 13 spaces short of the code, and I'm assuming that includes parking spaces on the street? Maybe just a nod. Yes.

4:06:13 The difference is when you incorporate the on-street parking spaces. So no guest parking, though, are in that consideration? The 13 doesn't include guest parking. That's just 13 shy for the residents. No, that includes guests. So the municipal code overall would require 133 spaces for this development. And that includes parking for the residents and guest parking spaces.

4:06:43 There would be 20 guest parking spaces required, and that's included in that 133 number. And right now, as it stands, the project is showing 118 spaces, and that number will go up to 123 spaces, I think, once the additional parking is required. So, or I'm sorry, 120 spaces. So, really, we're talking about, yes, 13 spaces all in.

4:07:09 That's the difference. All right. Thank you, Chandler. And I'm assuming those, they can park overnight on the street parking. Yes. Okay. Okay. Thank you. And then, I know it's not supposed to be a Q&A. I understand, but I do appreciate that. Hold on. Chandler, can you take down the screen sharing now so the public can see more of this dialogue? Thank you. Absolutely. Yep. All right. There you go. Okay. Yeah, I do apologize. I know this isn't Q&A, and I do apologize. I just want to make sure before I go into my...

4:07:38 So this is really like a question or an ask. This is an ask. Going forward in the next phases, could the council please build in something that requires this to come back to you in all the phases, not just the Planning and Economic Development Commission. I really think this is community housing. We elect you. We would really, I think, the public would like to know that we can hold you accountable.

4:08:06 to this and not the people you appoint to the Planning Commission. That would be my ask. At the Board of Supervisors, when there's big things like this, they tend to come to us.

4:08:16 For example, the Tioga Inn. So I ask that you somehow build this in if it's at all possible. And if not, then could you require more planning and economic development commissions meetings rather than just one include evening meetings, extra meetings, because this is a big deal. This is community housing. So that's an ask. And then I just want to point out that

4:08:47 We're rural. We're not urban and we're not suburban. And yeah, when you're in the town, you can ride bikes and you can ride the bus. And I do those things. I get that. But we have to go to urban areas to get our life's needs met, to go to medical, to do Costco runs, to get to the airport.

4:09:10 So cars are essential. And, you know, we often say to people at the state and federal, you know, we need to have local control. And so I just want to remember that, keep that in mind when we talk about mobility. And I heard one of our

4:09:28 Our other council members say tonight, mobility is not the solution to parking. And I just want to reemphasize that because I think that was a really good point. And then I also want to mention that yesterday we had Dr. Cameron Wedding come and do an equity training with the county.

4:09:46 Board of Supervisors. And I brought up my neighborhood that I live in, which is called the Sierra Valley Sites, but unfortunately is mostly known as the ghetto and in a really derogative name and way. And that...

4:10:00 And those kinds of stereotypes and things, it's easy to put people off and to say that we're going to implement this really strict parking and mobility policy here with our poorest, because really this is income-driven housing, but the rest of our policies we're not going to look at. And I think that's an equity issue. And I brought this up.

4:10:29 Way back when, when we were, before we were here, equity, and that I think the parking issue isn't so much that, you know, 13 paces isn't huge, but...

4:10:42 Is the town ever going to look at equity across their policies for parking, including from the bluffs all the way down to this neighborhood that I live in? Is there going to be parity or no, we're going to just make mobility be a priority for the poor people? Everybody else, we're going to keep requiring multiple cars. And I would just encourage you to really reflect on that because I think it's 2021, it's time to think about those things.

4:11:11 And then in option C, I didn't see anything about the tenants. It's all about the plans and management plans and the town, but where did the tenants come in? Where did they get to participate in saying this isn't working for us? That would be a question. And I would encourage you to think about putting that in the language that they have a role in determining that the parking plan isn't working, the parking management plan.

4:11:39 And then the other idea I had is Mammoth requires really large parking spaces. They're huge. Maybe you could add some more spaces by having some compact area.

4:11:51 Could you allow the developer to add 13 spaces by shrinking some of them and making them compact? I drive a small car. It's all-wheel drive. A lot of people in my complex do. I actually live in Meridian Court. And we have quite a few small cars here that are all-wheel drive that could probably fit in smaller spaces. I would encourage you to consider that. I'm sorry. I'm just bringing that to the table right now.

4:12:14 And the last thing I want to say is that I really would request that you require this development have a local general partner. In the past, there has been a local general partner, a nonprofit, and it's been Mammoth Lakes Housing in these developments at Aspen Village at...

4:12:33 At the Jefferies and at Manzanita, I know that Pacific Companies works with Central Valley Coalition, their nonprofit partner, but they're on the other side of the hill. And it's really imperative that we have a local general partner because they can do on-the-ground asset management from a local perspective, oversight on the physical characteristics and maintenance of the property from a local perspective. I would encourage you to require it.

4:13:02 Paid by the development and not the town. I mean, that would be my last ask. And I'm super excited about this. These are some tweaks that I think that would benefit the community and the people that we're here to serve. So thank you for all your hard work and taking my long-winded comments. All right. Thank you. Any other public comments? In addition, we received an email today.

4:13:30 From Madeline Brown, she says, tonight's public hearing regarding the parcel is a milestone for our town. The approval of this resolution will mean we can request funding from the state and start building desperately needed affordable housing this spring.

4:13:42 While I know the design review isn't perfect, I am asking you to have the confidence in our town staff that they will work out the details. The price of delaying construction a year until the next funding cycle will be a tremendous burden on the entire community. It is time to make the dream reality. As always, I am most appreciative of your dedication and the hard work. And that is the end of the public comments. Thank you. Thank you very much. Any other comments? Yes, John.

4:14:12 Hi, Madam Mayor Pro Tem, I'm prepared to read and make the motion. I have to close the public hearing first. Thank you. No other comments, staff, Pacific, none. All right, we're going to close the public hearing. And now, public, John. Yes, ready? Let's do it. Okay, folks, here we go. Good luck. Madam Mayor Pro Tem, I would move that the town council.

4:14:45 Approve a resolution of the Town Council of the Town of Mammoth Lakes, State of California, approving use permit 20-003 for a 100% density bonus and design review, 20-005 to allow for development of phase one of the parcel affordable housing project located at 1699 Tavern Road and 33 Center Street, consistent with district zoning amendment 20-001,

4:15:14 Paren, the 2021 Parcel Master Plan, N-Paren, and making findings under the California Environmental Quality Act pursuant to state secret guidelines sections 15183.3 and to further include a language consistent with parking identified as option C as presented by town staff. I think that is well done.

4:15:44 Question for Andy, before we do a second on this, Andy? We did not have to read out that option C. It's not- No, you just referred to it by reference, and I think it's clear to everybody what it says, because it was on the screen, and you all have a common understanding of what it was. Okay, thank you. I wanted to make sure that looks in. All right, do we have a second for this? Councilmember Stapp? Okay, yes. All right, that being said, Jamie, could we call for the vote, please? Councilmember Stapp?

4:16:23 Yes. Councilmember Wentworth. Aye. Mayor Pro Tem, Salcido. Aye. All right, motion is passed, 3-0. We are done, I believe, with that item. Thank you, everybody, for your endurance through this, not just tonight, but in the past, and just take a moment to understand what we've done. Thank you, everybody, so much. Great. A big night. Thank you all very much. Great team effort. For sure.

4:16:54 All right. We have one more thing to do here, and it's not a short one. So does anybody need to take a little break or we just want to jam through here? Brady's saying, I'm sorry, Brady, I missed the hand signals. I don't think the staff report will take very long, if you'd like. Okay, let's do that. All right. Therefore, we are on. Okay. Go ahead.

4:17:22 Number 15, authorize the execution of documents related to the sale of real property and construction of affordable housing on the parcel. Thank you. This item was alluded to in the previous two items, actually. When you awarded the project to Pacific, it talks about documents that would have to come later. During the presentation, Shel and Andrea both alluded to various agreements that were absolutely necessary to be submitted to Sacramento tomorrow for the taxes and financing.

4:17:51 The staff report references three items that need to be submitted. I want to mention a couple that aren't on there first, just to get those out of the way. We've also mentioned a DDA, a disposition and development agreement. The plan, and the town attorney has been heavily involved in all the documents, is to come back to you in about a month with a DDA for phase one, kind of like we said, a mini disposition and development agreement, which would cover...

4:18:18 Phase 1, which you just approved. About a month after that, we would come back with a full DDA that will cover the rest of the parcel and talk about various options and things that we've spoken about briefly in the past. So those aren't before you tonight, but there is a schedule and a requirement in these documents to come back in 30 and 60 days. You'll see those in the future. The three before you tonight, thank you, one.

4:18:47 For that, the option to purchase is the first one for phase one. The developer has done an appraisal and they need to have an option to purchase in order to submit four taxes and financing for phase one. The second is a letter of commitment for a loan. And that's probably the one that if you have any questions, we can get the developer involved with that or Andy as well. The idea is that we set a price for phase one.

4:19:13 What the developer is asked that we basically take back a loan, if you will, for that purchase price, and that we also take back a loan for the development impact fees that are controlled by the town. It says in the staff report very clearly there are some that are not controlled by the town, child care, library, and others that we cannot touch. But the ones that are under control for the town, the developer is asked that we basically take back a loan and they pay back.

4:19:40 Those monies over the term of the project itself. The third one is a fairly straightforward zoning letter. Basically something that is required again by the financing people that's already been reviewed by town staff, both Sandra and Andy as well. I do want to note that these three documents were prepared earlier this week and they were actually signed by the town manager and by Sandra on Monday or Tuesday earlier of this week.

4:20:07 With a heavy caveat that if this is not approved, they are null and void. The reason for that is there used to be a portal for the taxes and financing that you can just submit in online. This had to come from all over the world down to Carlsbad, California, and now back up to Sacramento. So we did everything we could to help facilitate that and make sure that happened.

4:20:29 Well, I'm really just ready to ask for any questions. It's been a long meeting already. We have a staff report. We have the developers still online and the town attorney as well to answer any more questions. Thank you. Okay. So I will ask the council. Let's put our questions and comments together, please. John, go ahead. Yeah. Are we paying mileage to this person, Grady, who's delivering the documents tomorrow? Go left. I kind of think they've already worked that out, but I doubt it.

4:20:58 Okay, because we, you know, we're watching every dime up here. Madam Mayor Pro Tem, I'm good. I don't have any questions at this point. Thank you. Thank you. No questions. Okay, that being said, is there any public comment on this, Jamie? No, there is not. All right. I have no further questions or comment myself. I think it's quite clear. I would ask for a motion.

4:21:23 Madam Mayor Pro Tem, I would move that the Town Council authorize the execution of documents related to sale of real property, construction of affordable housing on the parcel. Okay, second? I second the motion. Okay, very good. We have an initial proposal by Mr. Wentworth and a second by Mr. Staff. Jamie, unless there's any, I'm sorry, we didn't ask for any. Yeah, we did. We did ask for a comment. Okay, on that note, Jamie, can we get roll call, please?

4:21:53 Councilmember Stapp? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Aye. Mayor Pro Tem, Salcido? Aye. Motion passes 3-0. Okay. I think we are there with that. Anything else on that item? Nope. We're good. Okay. Therefore, everybody can be excused unless you want to stay around and listen to council members' reports. Thank you, everyone. Let's go ahead and do that then. Councilmember reports. Kirk.

4:22:25 I have nothing to report. Okay. John. Thank you, Madam Mayor Pro Tem. I'm just pulling up my documents a couple pages long, so just give me a second to get it. Right. Okay. First off, I want, on behalf of all of us as Americans, to give our condolences to the family and our thanks to Officer Brian Sicknick, who died in the mob attack at the United States Capitol.

4:23:05 I believe it was four weeks ago. So I want to make sure we, I'm sure we all agree with the need to extend those condolences. Thank you. Ongoing efforts ESCOG is supporting, is submitting a very important grant proposal to the California Department of Fish and Wildlife. This will have to do with a project called the Mammoth Donut to do NEPA work. It's a very important effort going, coming forward. I attended the Lodging Meeting on January 26th. I think, I know, Linda, we've all been doing our share on...

4:23:33 All various different aspects of COVID, but that certainly was one of them. On January 27th, I had a very interesting conversation with the leadership in Yosemite National Park about the reconfiguration of management of the Devil's Postpile National Monument. And I'm sure those details will be forthcoming. This is going to be a very important series of considerations for the town as we process the development application for the...

4:23:59 Base Lodge, I'm not sure what they're calling it, but that whole land exchange up there, it's going to be a very important thing for us to be paying attention to. There's a special meeting of the Eastern Sierra Sustainable Recreation Partnership last Thursday, establishing a framework to identify a portfolio of sustainable recreation projects here in the Eastern Sierra. There's a regular meeting of the SSRB on Monday, and it snowed. And I lost a beloved member of my family, and I got to spend three days with him.

4:24:28 Who passed in 99 years out of the beautiful Eastern Sierra that he loved. That's my report. Thank you. Thank you very much. And I have no reports to see me. So, that being said, I'm going to be adjourning this meeting right now. And thank you, everyone, for your longevity on this and the good results for the evening. So, thank you all. Thank you all. Thank you.