TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2021

Town Council Special meeting

· recording 3 hr 20 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

390 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:14 Testing, testing, testing, testing, testing. Great. I'm going to pause it. See if that swings over to here. Can everybody hear me? Okay. They all have their heads down. Andy, can you talk to us so I can make sure the audio is working, please? Happy belated birthday, Jamie. Thank you. Is that enough audio checking or do I need to soliloquize?

6:49 No, that's perfect. Thank you. Soliloquize. I'm having issues on my end. Good gosh. Good afternoon, everyone. Is your Sunlink working as well as mine is today? Mine's been fine today. Mine started messing up midday yesterday. And it is nowhere near up to what I'm paying for. We're not happy. I've been lucky. Mine's been pretty solid here.

7:44 Okay, we're missing Kirk, right? No, he's there with Dan. Well, he's in Sweet Z. There he is. Well, I can't see him. Half my screen just went away. I'm just doing so wonderful today. Okay. How about if I call to order this very special Town Council meeting Friday, April 16th, Rob? All right. Councilmember Rae? Councilmember Stapp? Here. Councilmember Wentworth? Present. Mayor Pro Temp-Salcido?

8:23 Yes. Mayor Sauser. Pledge allegiance. Who wants to pledge today? There you go, John. Thank you. Excuse me. While I rise, get on my feet, I can turn to my flag right here, my little unit. Ready? Begin. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America. Republic. Republic, which it stands, one patient, under God. Justice for all.

9:02 Thank you. I've heard first-grade classes stay more in sync than that. It's one of the most awkward things to do on Zoom, I think. Yes, it is. Public comment. This is the time any member of the public wishing to speak on anything that otherwise is not on the agenda. Do we have any public comments, Jamie? No, we do not. Thank you very much. Policy matters.

9:36 I haven't had a chance to look at the email, so I'm not sure what they say, but Dan, you want to jump in here? Yeah, thank you, Mr. Mayor. I believe we need to pull items one and two. We'll need to pull them off the agenda today. Either Andy Morris or Grady Dutton can speak to the need for that and which ones need to be re-agendized if both of them need to be re-agendized for your 21st meeting. So Bill and Sarah.

10:02 I think you can listen, but no participation just as we clean up the agenda, if that works, Andy. Okay, I will back out. I am now off video and off of voice, if I could. Okay, well, in our never-ending efforts to try to do the right thing and the state's apparent never-ending efforts to make doing the right thing more complicated, we did send HCD a copy of the draft resolution that would declare the property to be surplus.

10:37 And HCD got back to us and they say now that they think that we needed to have that resolution before we did the request for bids, which is interesting. That's not in the law anywhere. And I don't think it's consistent with the law. So first they said, yeah, you can't do this because you need to do this before you went out for bids. But then they said, but maybe you could make it work under this other law. So we took a look at that other law and talked to

11:07 And we think we can make it work under a different law that doesn't require us to declare the property surplus, doesn't require bidding, doesn't require much of anything. So we are going to pull that from the agenda for today while we kind of get our bearings because we've just got this late yesterday, this new curveball from HCD that doesn't appear to be based on the law. And we will have it back in front of you on Wednesday.

11:36 The nice thing about this new approach that we think we can make work is that it does not require us to give HCD 30 days notice before a resolution can be effective. So, although HCD is complicating things in some ways by appearing to kind of make stuff up as they go along, the nice thing about this is that we can actually have this wrapped up, have the DDA signed faster because we don't have to wait 30 days anymore.

12:05 Unless, I mean, I guess unless HCD jumps out from behind to Bush again and tells us that they've made up a new thing. But I don't think they will. Because the section of the law that we're going to use has been on the books since 1988, and it doesn't look like it's changing at all. So that's the idea. And Sheldon, if you care to comment on any of this, I mean, we're interested in what Pacific has to say, but my understanding is that Pacific can meet the specific affordability requirements of this other

12:36 Hi, thank you, Andy, for that explanation. And I just got the email with the five or six ways to meet that approach. And so at my first reading, I think yes, but I do want to take the time that I think this affords to really make sure I get my bearings as well. Right. With something this important, I think neither town staff nor Pacific want to be

13:05 Trying to improvise on the fly, which is why we would prefer that the council not take action on this today and give us till Wednesday. And I think by Wednesday we can have it all squared away. Thank you, Andy, for that explanation. I mean, this just seems like another case of the, you know, the goal is to expedite affordable housing at every turn. However, the state doesn't necessarily make that any easier. Always amazes me the way state can, state.

13:37 Can make things even more cumbersome than originally thought. So thanks for continuing on this and, you know, specific okay with this. I know there was some, you know, reasons to go ahead with this as quickly as possible. Is this going to throw a wrench in any of that? Sean, Andy? Well, I'll let Sean speak for Pacific, but to my way of thinking, since we will now not have to have this artificial 30-day period of time between

14:06 The Council approving the disposition of the land and actually being able to execute the DDA, even a four-day or five-day delay up front, but minus the 30-day delay means that I think we can get this done faster now than we would have been able to otherwise. Okay, thanks. I mean, it'd be very disappointing to miss our opportunity here this spring. So, okay, I mean, I guess any other comments, John? Just, I think,

14:36 Madam Mayor Pro Tem, a good lesson for us in a somewhat deliberative approach to this, recognizing that the state is on a lot of different strings, and I think our instincts at the last meeting, let's generate as few documents as possible, let's make decisions once and not have to go back and remake them and redo them, I think that's serving us pretty well, so I would encourage us to keep on that track, and just a reminder that it's not that far.

15:06 Just saying. Thank you. Okay. Kirk, comments? No, I have no comments. I didn't think it was going to be easy. Well, you were right. All right. Just for the heck of it, any public comment on this? No, there is not. Okay. Any other staff that wants to speak to this before we move on? No? Okay, everybody. Thank you very much. And let's ask...

15:38 Sarah Rea and our Mayor to come back with us. But it's so much more fun just listening from the wings. I'm sure. Okay, at this point we will move into the main focus of this meeting. One announcement first. I believe that John is going to have to take a 15-minute break or so at 2 o'clock and we will make that happen. We will all take that break. That being said, we will move on to Town Council Workshop.

16:13 on strategic priorities and key objectives. And I will go to Dan, who's going to give us a reboot of last Friday and move us on with today. Yes, thank you, Mr. Mayor. The workshop for today really does, we'll kick it off kind of reviewing what, at least from a staff perspective that we heard at your last meeting and confirming that up and making sure that

16:38 The information we have there is correct and that we're on the same page going forward. There's a write-up, I think it's the last attachment in your packet on that. And then as we move from that, the real issue today is we're talking about governance and the town organization and roles and responsibilities of council staff, different elements of that. A lot of that information, there's some write-up in the packet that we'll really be working through.

17:05 Some information that several or at least a few of you have gone through in the past with, which is now Cal City's, the League of California City's training program. But before we dive into that, we would like to take a look at the recap from the last meeting. It's at the end of the current packet, this last couple of pages there. If you're in your packet, it's page 97 and 98.

17:33 And the idea here is after the meetings as department heads met, we went through several pages of notes and tried to look at what were the themes or high-level items that came out of the discussion that we were hearing from town council. I think this helps us frame up some work as we get into strategic priorities, linking back into these as appropriate. And the key themes, there were...

18:01 Five of those kind of identified one being on the housing and kind of the idea of our community first or the community livability issues. Tourism and visitation were a major point of discussion. The idea of relationships across various agencies and partnerships that we need to develop and maintain, internal, external, a lot of different elements in that.

18:25 Our town revenue structure, different discussions on the tax structure and how we do financing and budgets. And then the transition really out of this pandemic into whatever the new paradigm might look like as we continue to move through hopefully into what will be a more normalized atmosphere. But we believe there are potential significant changes in terms of their whole relationships and how people view different elements, at least for the coming year or two.

18:53 And then we tried to hit on some common values or perspectives, and we have them listed out there. I won't read all this stuff to you, but you can take a look at that. But I think our real question, if you have questions for myself, the department heads, we're glad to respond to some of the elements here. But the real question is here is, did we capture, you know, from several pages of notes and a few hours of discussion, kind of the key elements, I think, that...

19:20 Council was talking about the things they were touching on. And again, trying to keep it at a higher level at this point. There are different elements in here that get into down in the weeds a little bit in terms of solutions. But really this here was to get commonality of focus from the council and agreement on kind of some of the major challenges you see long term and near term. And from this, the idea would be that helps us make potentially frame up kind of a short term vision statement as we get into the.

19:50 Goals and objectives setting in the next couple of meetings. So I really do want to just turn this back over to the council for a discussion on these items or if we need to clarify something or if there's a comment that you heard or made that you, you know, as we bring this back in part of a final report that you want to have incorporated into the statements here and that either today in the discussion level or if something pops up, please let us know and we can.

20:19 Incorporated. We did not just look at whatever, you know, commonality, everybody saying the same thing, but what were those key points by various council members and hopefully we captured the majority of that thought and concepts. So with that, I would turn it over to the town council for the same level of discussion. If you heard other things in that discussion that you want to touch on, please note those for us and we'll capture that. And as we did in the last meeting, I would encourage.

20:49 Everybody to jump in and ask questions as they see fit of each other and the staff, less structured than we would normally do. I'm not going to call you each by name. So as Dan said, you see the overview in front of you. Do you see anything that is missing from the points we all made? John, go. Unmute. I think that generally speaking, I think this captured things pretty well. I've got a couple notes for things to clarify that I think would be helpful.

21:23 The first thing is under housing and community first. When we did the housing summit a couple of years ago in the community housing action plan, it was very intentional to refer to housing in the community as community housing and not workforce housing. And I think it would be a good idea to just make a note of the semantics of this. When we're talking about housing, we're talking about community housing. So we don't polarize things. If that would be okay with everybody, I think I'd appreciate that clarification.

21:52 Under tourism and visitation, the second bullet, need for localized mobility structure. I'm assuming that's infrastructure. Is that correct? I think it's infrastructure as well as just the actual programming of how people flow. So let's call that need for localized mobility infrastructure and programming. That would cover that. The final bullet under tourism and visitation where it says enhancement of recreational amenities.

22:24 I'm thinking we need to clarify that a little bit. When I think of recreational amenities, I'm thinking of things like the CRC, but when we're thinking about the recreation, you know, experiences that compel people up here, we may want to do a little, you know, teasing out of those terms so that we don't, it's clear if we're talking about a municipal piece of municipal infrastructure or the larger things that draw the track people here. Under relationships, third bullet.

22:54 Regional engagement, I think we need to add ESCOG in there. The last time we did this, ESCOG is now a joint powers authority. It's got an identified program of work. I think we need to make sure we list that in there. Just a couple of final things on transition from pandemic. The experience of attracting new residents, visitors is new reality. I think we talked a lot about that, but I think we're mostly talking about new residents.

23:25 And if we mean to say new visitors, I don't quite know what that means. Or if that's the fact that there's a new recreation audience that's coming up here, that would make sense. Maybe we should go with that, a new recreation or new visitor audience, generational, new generation of visitors are coming. And the final thing that I wanted, I think is kind of important, is my last, when I picked up on Andy's statement about peer communities and

23:55 You know, Frankie's doing the same thing. I think it's really important that we now make the transition from the peer resort thing that we used to do, i.e., we want to be another veil, to peer communities. There's a very rich culture in mountain towns throughout the Western United States, the Mountain Ventures Summit. I think we all went to that. We heard a lot of, you know, what that's, the kinds of...

24:22 Thank you. Thank you.

24:47 Want to be failed type thing. We are a mountain town. We are a mountain community. And there's a culture out there that we can participate in will benefit us. So thank you, Bill. Everybody, those are a couple of comments I had. Thank you, John. Anyone next? I'm just talking to myself. Hold on. Okay. Yes, I think those were good suggestions, John. I read through this. Nothing really jumps out at me as being not included.

25:22 You know, we can say more about our workforce and relationships, but I think we've talked about other engagement. I think one thing I was looking for, and I think we've covered it a couple ways, is, you know, just the kind of visitors that are coming, I mean, I'm sorry, not visitors, but the kind of professionals that are looking to settle here have a deep need for good connectivity, you know, amenities that support a workforce at home.

25:52 And I don't know where exactly we put that, but I don't see. Is there anywhere on here that talks about our infrastructure and our broadband? Briefly, on the transition of the pandemic to new paradigm, we mentioned that work is no longer tied to a specific place and the idea of remote work. Okay. Yeah. Okay. I mean, maybe that's enough for now. But yeah, it's just super important that we have the caliber. And also, and I don't, you know, schools are kind of that, you know, we have.

26:21 A really robust educational system to also attract people who are very interested in that for their children and families. Where we would put that, I'm not sure, but that's all I have, thanks. To that one, Lynda, if you'd like, underneath some of the relationships and maybe partnerships, we could put an element in there that includes school systems, whether it's K-12 or Cerro Coso. Yes, yeah, and especially maybe call out Cerro Coso. For me, a few things.

26:58 I think this pretty much captures what we talked about. Going back to some of John's comments that we're building community housing, not workforce housing, and I certainly hope to get in the business of helping provide that at some point, but I'm not sure that what we are currently looking at that I don't get to comment on is not pretty much pure workforce housing. While they all will be in the community, I'm not sure I appreciate the differentiation there.

27:29 The first, I've never heard anyone in Mammoth say we wanted to be a valer in Aspen. We were looking more towards a working class kind of town. You know, we used to be called the JC Petty of the ski industry. To me, it's an important differentiation as to who our core visitors are, whether they're the high enders or whether they're the middle class. But one of the things we need to do is we need to keep

28:00 And I, we need a marketing department that can be quick enough to respond to changes in the market. While 100% doesn't equal success, we do need to attract new visitors as well as new residents. Maybe we need to attract them more in the off seasons. Maybe we need to attract them more in the midweek. But certainly new visitors are needed.

28:28 Over the course of an entire year. So I believe that that's an accurate statement. Not just new residents as this government actually runs on TOT. It is a huge important piece. I would hate to see our rates go up to the point where we create and veil the mammoth because the only people who can afford to come here are the same customers that go there. Because as that happens and our prices go up.

28:58 Our housing stock goes up too in price, and then we have less and less community housing inside. So there's a balancing act we have to do. We do need to continue to support marketing to continue at least with the visitors we have. Those who have tried previously to reduce their marketing budgets while it has worked for two or three years because they're living under the guise of their old marketing, five years out they have lost business and are scrambling to try and get it back.

29:28 We need to be mobile about that. Yeah, Bill, I'd like to maybe, I hear what you're saying, but I'm thinking what I've been hearing in the destination marketing universe, certainly over the last year, that that is one of those worlds that is fundamentally changing.

29:53 I think we need to have a conversation on that and what the ingredients and the components of that are. This also is going back to something which may not have been in here, Dan, which it may not have. I think we talked a fair amount about those forces that are beyond our control, that there are things that we are living in a society, in a world where there are things that are beyond our control. And I think, Bill, a little bit of the things you're talking about, marketing and audiences and all that kind of stuff, that maybe fits into that category a little bit.

30:22 And we can have a little conversation about that. Yeah, I'm just saying we need to be agile. Absolutely. Yeah. Yeah, I absolutely agree with that. But, yeah, the things we're being agile, too, we got a lot of new stuff coming our way. Yeah. Any more comments from Sarah or Kirk? Yes, I think that we need to have a discussion about our anchor, a lot of our discussions on our budget.

30:59 You know, when we look at are we maintaining certain levels? Are we at service levels and response times and those kinds of things? So, you know, that's under our direct control. And I think that that is an important issue that we need to constantly look at. Are we actually providing them?

31:27 So when I look at that, you know, from housing, from response time to all the different elements, and can we, you know, continue to at least maintain the levels of service that we have now? Thank you. Thank you, Kirk. Okay. Hearing nothing else on this, Dan, I believe now we will move into role delineation. Is that where we want to go next? Yes.

32:07 It's kind of the role delineation, and that'll lead into a little bit of governance discussion. A couple of things there. There's some write-up in the packet, page is 1720. We won't spend a lot of time there, but we did provide out information from the lake. If you go into your packet, it's page 78, 79 of the packet. There's some kind of flow charts there, charts that kind of highlight a number of items.

32:34 And this is a training that's been developed over time that really looks at some of the foundations of exceptional councils that has been developed over the last several years of working with the League of Cities and other organizations and governance structures and different elements there. There's a number of things like a high level in these charts and stuff. We can touch on those as need be. But kind of the meat of it.

33:02 Kind of shifts into page 82 starting there. And there's a set of statements in each of those. There's six different statements. And we'd like to just highlight each of those and really just open each one up specifically for the council discussion. There's a statement. For example, the first one talks about exceptional councils develop a sense of a team, a partnership with city manager, to govern and manage the city. And then there's a number of key characteristics and other statements there.

33:30 I think we'd like to do is walk into those and say, you know, have a chance. This is a really good chance for us to evaluate how we're doing as, you know, you all as a council, but also the relationship with staff as well and those roles and responsibilities that go into that. And so walking through these six areas, kind of keeping the focus narrow, it's really your own self-evaluation, I guess, about these areas and do you find them important and how are we doing?

33:57 If there's specific things that we can do better at the staff level or better at the council level as we go through these elements, I think that's a good element. It sets a foundation for the work effort moving forward in terms of that relationship and expectations of each other and of the council as the new legislative body, relatively new, some of the membership, new as the legislative body for the town.

34:25 And how you work together becomes very important. And then that relationship from the council down through staff. So that's kind of the idea to spend the time walking through this and hopefully stimulate some discussions, things that have worked well, things that haven't, either council level, staff level, et cetera. Remember the department heads, I think all but one's here, one's out. But in terms of discussions that way too, if you have particular questions at our end, we can address those as well.

34:53 Or if there's some areas where you want staff feedback on how what our expectations might be of council or as we see our own roles, glad to step into that discussion as well. So there's kind of like I mentioned, a couple of pages of broad overview and then it really starts on page 82. So we can lead off and the idea there is there's any broad questions, that'd be great. Otherwise, just got to hit each of these statements. We go through those.

35:23 As we move out of that, then we move into some of the other last couple of pages in the document. The governance, culture, and stability, and then looking at goal setting and the process of setting priorities, kind of a purview, if you will, preview of as we look to the next meeting for the actual getting into setting some priorities and what that means and some of the key objectives and how the council.

35:54 Works through this in terms of setting those and working together to achieve common vision, common outcomes. I'm having fun here. I'm watching you guys in some kind of a stopgap motion picture thing. I'm hearing it all. It's just... So if that provides enough clarity for everybody, that's my first question, and we can kind of... So I want to add on to what Dan said. This comes from a piece that I picked up at one of the California City's conferences. It was made by the Institute for Local Government.

36:27 And frankly, this was one of the best breakout sessions I've ever been to. I thought this was well put together and well done. If you get the opportunity, if we ever come out of COVID and you get the opportunity to go to this particular session, I recommend it highly. It did me a whole lot of good. But then again, and I'm done. So I needed the extra training. So I'm done. What you will do is start off on page 82 and go through key characteristics, just as questions, view them as questions.

37:00 Successfully transitioned from candidate to a member of the council. Do we feel we have all accomplished that or any opinions on that? I can say a couple things about that and it's just not from this council but on other organizations and watching other people join boards or join groups of people and there's a lot to know about the town that you don't necessarily know when you are running or when you're first elected and it takes a while. I think that we

37:32 Don't have a very good process for that. I think that we sort of hand people a book and say, you know, knock yourself out. And I know, Dan, that, you know, you meet with people and Bill, I think you do too, but I would like to see that institutionalized a little bit better as far as what we provide for those people who are newly elected. I just think it takes a long time under the best of circumstances and longer when it's sort of hit and miss and not very.

38:01 So I think we could do better at that. And Linda, you're talking about the onboarding process, right? Correct. Yeah. I would add something to that, which is in the campaign season, right now the debate process is pretty hit or miss with at least one part of the debate process being potentially quite ugly and divisive and rude.

38:29 But I'm thinking that the town should find a way to be part of that process. And I'm not, just to follow on your comment, Lynda, about onboarding, to have a debate or something or something that's a session about the, you know, what is it, what are you going to find when you get there to help be as part of the election process and start helping to set those expectations? I think the town is an organization.

38:59 Because it's the leadership of the organization, I think we could extend that a little bit further. So not just the onboarded country elected, but into the campaign season itself do something that would help set the expectations and frame things a little bit better. I think that would be a really good idea too. Yeah, and I think perhaps it's up to the candidates at some point. I don't know how, but when a debate is offered and being set up and it's being facilitated by someone whose goal is to, you know, say rude and mean and...

39:27 Nasty things to candidates, that's not helpful. And so I think that we need to decide whether or not we want to do that. Like, you know what, no thanks, I don't think I want to participate in that one. And then, you know, encourage the ones that are more civil and really look for answers and look for positions as opposed to, you know, defense mode. It's not, you know, let's debate and, you know, let the candidates beat each other. That's not, that's not helpful. Yeah, but I think also even in a more civil forum.

39:54 To introduce those ideas of what the public understands, the kind of technical or institutional acuity that's going to be necessary to be a good council person. We could maybe get that as part of those forums. Yeah, it's a good goal. I would give a shout out to Mammoth Voices because I thought they put on a pretty good forum. I would agree, sir. Yeah, exactly. That's the kind of civil, yeah, you're absolutely right, sir. That's a great civics forum, I think.

40:29 You know, I think the idea that they debate ideas, not people, or we, you know, attack ideas, not people, is needed to keep in mind. Well, if I might make a comment, remember that during the campaign season, depending on the number of people running, it's a competitive process. So there's going to be some give and take and some acrimony, if you will.

40:57 During any campaign season. Yeah, and the campaigns that I've run locally, it has never been any of the candidate forums or candidates night where the negative occurs. It occurs outside of that more in the world of social media and how people take what happens in those forums and then purposes. And I don't know how or if we could ever gain any modicum of control over that. It's like trying to control any particular individual. We are all individuals.

41:31 And for me, it's very frustrating because the five of us, while we represent differing ideas and even differing generations in some cases, we're all putting ourselves out to be here. And then to be chastised by those who won't put themselves out is a hurtful thing that I certainly don't appreciate. I think to bring it back to Linda's original point, let's make sure we capture that onboarding step.

42:00 Right? That's really important. And then, look, campaigns are campaigns, and we're all adults, we can all handle it. But it's what is it going to be the best piece of the community in terms of saying, look, you're going to get on this body. This is what you're going to be dealing with. And to get some expectations from the community to understand what's involved in this. Look, it's an important responsibility. It's a big deal. And it's not good.

42:27 So to that end, John, would you suggest something like, once the candidates are known, a workshop with all the candidates and whoever the current council is, to try and educate them on what it means to be on council? Sure. I think, yeah, that would be great. And that could be almost non-partisan, non-electioneering. No, absolutely. Common shared facts kind of stuff, civics kind of stuff. Yeah, I think that'd be great.

42:55 Here's how to run our kids and here's why. Yeah. So the Mammoth Voices tried, sorry, I'll keep interrupting you. I said Mammoth Voices tried to do that within the leadership program that they were doing. I know Sarah was a participant in that with speakers and sort of that, but you know, not everybody who's running has had a chance to go through that kind of training and that kind of education. So I think people come from very different places as candidates and if you could get people to, you know, kind of.

43:23 As they're running, would that be useful? Maybe, yeah, it might be useful. If I might, what's the candidate's responsibility to come forward to talk to the town manager and the different, you know, to educate themselves rather than have, and I think both needs to happen, by the way, but rather than have staff. So if somebody wants to understand the budget, they can go talk to the finance director.

43:53 And I think they should, as a candidate, they should go and explore and understand, you know, what is the limits of our local government and, you know, some of the authority it has over land use and that sort of thing is staffing levels, et cetera. I don't know if I'm following what, you know, where this conversation is going. So those are my comments. Yeah.

44:22 Although I don't think there's anything you ever can do. Certainly when I got on council, I had been involved with town politics, if you will, for a long, long time. But still, those first few months on council were daunting. The feelings you have when you sit at that dais for the first time, it took even someone as outgoing as myself, it took me a few months to get my feet under me and find my voice.

44:49 Okay. I think we beat that up. Bill, if I can kind of bring that back into the, I think the key issue of the question here is actually it's that transition from the candidate to the council member. And I think what the question only gets to in some of the other elements versus, you know, each bullet point there, but how well do you feel that you've integrated into working as a team now as the legislative body?

45:14 And I think the idea there, we're going to have diversity in values, and that should be, you know, embraced, the valuing of that diversity in style and perspective and priorities that people bring. But there's a whole process, and that goes into that, is developing that on the town council, working together. Again, working together doesn't mean there's 100%, you know, 5-0 votes and agreement on everything, but there's definitely...

45:40 A willingness to do that in a way that's effective. And if you kind of look at the, to the page there, but each bullet point, but kind of work with those key characteristics that are on the page there. If you look at those, do you believe that we are succeeding in those areas as a legislative body with town staff and with the community for that matter as it looks at that? But really this is about the relationships across the five of the elected body members.

46:10 You know, I'd like to just chime in on the, I think one thing that's tough, right, is making decisions based on the needs and interests of the community at large, because I think everyone has a little bit of a different personal idea as to what the best interest is of the community at large. So, and I don't have the answers on how we come to Kumbaya on that, but everyone has their own motivations.

46:40 You know, believe that their constituents are or who they're trying to speak for. So I just think that's a, I don't know what the solution is there, but it's certainly something I've noticed. I think that that's when it becomes really essential that that kind of code of conduct is well ingrained and agreed upon mutually. Like, how do you disagree respectfully? How do you put your views forward, have your say, the vote is done, and then after the vote,

47:10 Then are we all willing to support the decision that the council made and go forward that as a, you know, three, three, two, four, one, whatever the vote was to do that. And I think, you know, again, I think it goes back to sort of that one point that the county was sort of having real issues with that on the board of supervisors and they put together kind of a code of conduct as a workshop in a way to bring people onto the same page with, okay, you disagree, you feel differently.

47:38 The vote is done. Now, how do you not only debate respectfully and share your opinions respectfully, but how do you then take the vote and then all move together forward in whatever that vote was? And sometimes I have a problem when I read this, so it's like you're all on the same page, you're doing this, and I'm like, okay, so you have a different opinion, okay, you're not going to feel, you're not going to agree with those other four people that voted about something else, but how do you, one, you know, do it respectfully and

48:08 How do you move forward from that? I don't know how you put a code of conduct. If it's a 3-2 vote, you know, and the two want to write a letter to the editor or whatever explaining their vote or even criticizing the rest of the council, how does that fit into a code of conduct? I don't know. Does it?

48:38 One thing that you could consider, I mean, because a code of conduct sounds like something that's almost meant to be binding. I mean, you could, if you can agree on things, you could establish something like norms or, you know, or you can call it aspirational best practices or something. And you can make it clear if you can agree on this set of things that these are not intended to be binding. There are no consequences for not meeting the standards, but that they're things that the council collectively thinks are good.

49:08 And people could choose to follow them or they could choose to not follow them, but you could at least say what you think those good things are, those things to be avoided, those things to be done. And that could at least give people a starting point. If candidates are looking for just some sense of what could we or should we be doing or not doing, you'd have it there in a non-binding way as a resource for people. And that was certainly the idea. I don't think the code as a general.

49:37 You know, the official definition of the code was implemented. I think it grew to be sort of this, we've agreed upon these principles of how we're going to behave. It was non-binding, it was non, and it couldn't be punished for, but it was kind of an agreement between the five that this would be our aspirations in conducting business. So I think to those lines, policy items for the council, it's contentious. I think that the council should ensure

50:07 That the debate, that the arguments, that the discussion happens at the dais. If council members want to write and start writing letters in the paper, that's fine, but understand the fellow council members can't respond to those because it's outside of the Brown Act. And then basically it's a statement that says, I don't think the council's credible. And I think it's a pretty big step to want to do something like that. And I think we want to make sure the mayor...

50:35 Whoever the mayor is at the time, make sure that the debate is exhausted, everybody's been heard, so when a vote happens, the vote happens, but it's based on the substance of the discussion in the dais, but otherwise we're getting into sort of weird end-run things, I think, sure, people can do it, I don't think it's in the community's interest to do stuff like that. I'd love to hear, sorry, Sharon, go ahead. Is that something that's happened in the past?

51:01 No, Kirk just brought it up as an example. I hadn't seen that happen, so I was curious. Let's have it out at the dais. Let's do our business at the dais. Yeah, there's a question whether letters to the editor, and we've gone through this before, violate the Brown Act and that you're informing all councilmen you're in essence having a serial meeting. So early on when I went to my first one of these leadership conferences, things that I took to heart.

51:32 from one of the sessions was that if you are on the losing end of a 3-2 or a 4-1 vote, once council has made the decision, that's a binding decision, and that is the town's decision. And I have several times gotten on board with things that I didn't particularly agree with because that was the decision of council. So I would love to hear from all of you how you feel about that. Personally, my opinion is that once council has done its job,

52:01 You don't keep trying to beat that horse to try and get some kind of a shift back to your own position. And I would love to hear the morality of that from each of you, just from my own perspective. Maybe I'm the one that's off base and I need to start fighting harder for the things I disagree with. I don't know. Well, I'll just say I'm a big believer in democracy, democratic process. And I frankly take a certain kind of a thrill, either if I'm the losing side of a vote or whatever.

52:32 But to have a representative body come to a decision and say, this is the aggregate direction of this body, I'm good with that. And that's democratic. That is democracy in action. So I tend to say, look, vote decisions made, let's move on. It's kind of a beautiful thing to watch that unfold. That's how I think about it personally. You ask for a personal reaction. Yeah, absolutely, John. That's what I was looking for. Thank you. Yeah, and I think it's okay to, you know.

53:02 Someone asked you about the decision, say, well, you know, it wasn't my vote, but the council voted as a majority in that process to support this, move this forward, agree to this, and, you know, we're in that vote now, and we're all going in the same direction. So I had my say, I had my vote, that's where we are. Yeah, that's how I responded. You know, I had people reach out.

53:27 Regarding like specifically the CRC and say, isn't there a way we can bring to the public or whatever? And I'm like, this, this is the public, this is the process. And, you know, this is what the council has decided. So it's, it's a good opportunity to remind people about the democratic process. And this is the way that it works. And we were elected to, to, you know, to represent people. I also have gone through the,

53:56 The same process as both Linda and Sarah have described. You know, you make your vote and then you move on. I mean, if it's a 3-2, it's a 3-2. And if you're approached by the public or the newspapers, you know, I mean, you just explain, hey, there's a rationale on both sides. I mean, there was a vote and this is the way we move forward.

54:23 I don't think anybody on council has written letters. I haven't or anything else after a council votes being critical of that. I think right now we have a process of moving forward, at least as from my perspective. And I don't think I've written any letters, you know, that have, you know, chastised. Yeah, moving forward, the number of houses on...

54:50 Shady rest is an issue before this council, and that needs to be debated and at the council level. Thank you. Thank you, Kirk. So on this first page, we have definitely gone through successful transitions and support policy goals and council decisions. Anybody want to weigh in on becoming for the city to make a decision based on the needs and interests of the community at large?

55:18 The greater good or just demonstrate a willingness to work collaboratively as a team and have a citywide perspective. Pretty much the same things there. We may have already covered that. If that's your opinion, we'll move on to the next page. Can we talk just a little bit about develop, communicate, and support policy goals and council directions or decisions? And this isn't just talk about council, it also talks about the town and that is this dialogue.

55:48 That happens in our local media. So the dialogue is controlled by the two publications, which is amazingly fortunate that we have two different newspapers, if you will, in our community because a lot of rural areas our size have no local media presence. But I would say that given that those are two opinions out there, I think the town

56:16 Continues to have a responsibility to communicate what it is we're doing. We talked about this over time. I think it kind of got swept up in COVID and we didn't really move into it, but that, you know, there'd be something like a weekly column or a bi-weekly or a bi-monthly or something column in both of those papers that say, you know, what's happening at the town, you know, edited and written by the town. That's basically our way to present how we feel about the decisions that have made and the directions that have been made.

56:43 The community can pick it apart if they want, the editorials can continue, but we've never really been able to step into that strongly. I think that it's important that we, to the part that we can, to control our own dialogue around actions that we feel are happening within the town. And that maybe kind of belongs here or not, but I just thought I'd throw it out there. I think it's critically important. Linda?

57:10 You'll recall a couple years ago we put together, we paid for a plan to coordinate the town's websites, right? Really good bunch of people, really good ideas. It did not happen. The institutional will of the town was not there to make it happen. To do the kind of communications you're talking about in the communications environment that we live in is going to require a real investment.

57:36 How ideas are communicated, how people are getting information. I think we're all aware of that. I couldn't agree with you more about that. And I think it's a good investment for the community to understand this is what the community, the town, this is what we're all doing together. It's going to be a lift and it's probably going to be expensive. Just saying. I love that idea. It makes me really excited, Linda, to hear you talk about that.

58:05 One of the things I campaigned on was like trying to bring people into civic engagement. And I'm pretty active, well, relatively active on Instagram and Facebook, which are two of the most used. I have a lot of younger people who follow my political page on Instagram and Facebook is a little easier to share events and stuff like that. But there is no repository for the town's business. The town has a Facebook page. I'm not sure that Instagram is very...

58:34 accessible, but there's no, like, I would love to be like, to share a post from the town and

58:41 Probably this is laziness on my part, but can I share a post from the town? This is what we're going to talk about this week. These are the big deals that are happening at this council meeting. And here, if you want to tune in, if you want to talk about the CRC, that's happening next week. And yeah, I can post that, but to have the town being actively posting that, and I know I'm offering up an employee that you don't have because, you know, I work at the hospital. We have an employee that's dedicated to pushing out news from the hospital.

59:10 And they're busy. So I often kind of joke, I'm like, we just need one person who can do like TikToks and Facebook posts. But it would really, I think, increase civic engagement if we just had an, I don't think it needs to be a well put together newsletter. It's just, I mean, Dan sends us an FYI every week. That's just for our consumption. But what about a public FYI? I mean, it could be easily tailored to.

59:37 What are people interested in? Why should you attend a council meeting? You can just tune right in. And I would love to see something that we could all just push out on our channels that's put together for us. Well, it's kind of like what the JIC has been able to do during the pandemic. They kind of were, like you said, the depository of all this information, and it got printed in the two names papers. It got printed, it got put up on Facebook, it got shared across all these media sites. And I think that that is the ideal, that we were able to do that. I mean, somebody, you know,

1:00:07 It processes what this written is, and then it just goes out in all those channels. And, you know, Stu has, you know, when, I mean, remember Stu's news? That was the genesis of the JEC, because that was the sharing site that we got stuff to Stu, you know, and it just went out from there. So I think we, I don't think it's as big a list as we think it is, but it just needs some attention, and we've never really boiled to the top, but maybe it's time. Stu is...

1:00:36 He's awesome at that. There's a way to take what Stu does and translate it into what Sarah's talking about. But remember, like with Facebook, Instagram, these kinds of platforms, they're ostensibly very easy. And, oh, look, I can just push a couple of buttons and it can work. But to do it on a sustained way and establish a credible presence, it's real money and it's real time. It's not, I mean, that's...

1:01:04 That's the thing they don't tell you about in high school. To do it well and to do it effectively, you've got to make a real commitment of, frankly, staff time of someone to actually sit there and do it. It's a real thing. Yeah. That's like what Sarah's saying. They have a person at the hospital. The hospital posts two to three times a week most of the time across those multiple things. They do a quarterly or every half year newsletter to every box holder.

1:01:31 In the district, in the county. And so, yeah, you're right. That's a real investment. That's real money. That's real time. And it's not just, oh, you can write a little article once in a while. It is a definite, you know, kind of work that you need to put together. And there's so many, like, NGOs and, you know, agencies and trying to hunt and peck, like, me with a full-time job, too.

1:01:55 Council in a board seat and then, you know, trying to like eat dinner every night and like find out what I should like push out to my followers is, I mean, again, it's probably laziness on my part to see, I would like to see it distilled so I could just share that from the town and be like, this is what we're doing this week. Yeah, so as we move forward, and occasion is key, as we move forward down this and we look at what are the next couple of meetings is giving the town manager

1:02:28 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

1:02:52 I think we've had those same discussions internally at different ways to do a better job in getting our story told and information out. To the JIC side of it, I think they had at one point 15 or 16 people engaged in that process. So that was a huge, huge lift in the environment there. So it's a great example, but that level of lift was huge. But definitely an area of conversation, how do we enhance how we communicate.

1:03:21 Unless there's something else on this item, I think we're approaching a break time here. I know before we dive into the next one. So if there's any other comments related to kind of that first question on that sense of a team and partnerships that get built with your town staff through myself, any other comments there? Or just kind of watching the time. I know John had a time certain commitment he needed to maintain. So I wanted to be mindful of that. Thank you.

1:03:49 So, John, we are at the 2 o'clock hour. If you guys want to keep yakking, I mean, this may not take me 15 minutes. I don't want to break everybody's groove. Well, I will tell you, if you guys are all okay with it, I would love to use this as a time to reboot all my computers and my internet software to see whether or not I can get my stopgap motion picture back to a regular one. So, if that is good with you, it is 2 o'clock. I will try to be back up by 2.15.

1:04:20 And we will continue at that point. We're all good with that. Thanks. Hello. Bill, it looks different. It does, doesn't it? It's a little crisper. Different camera, different computer. This is normally the screen I use to look at my agendas on while I'm down below on the meeting. Right. But the down below computer seems to be having issues.

1:07:46 Yeah, anything that's called the Down Below Computer, I would, I would, uh, yeah, all right, all right, uh, the, uh, oh, let's call it the Town Computer, because right now, you know, that's, yeah, that, we can kick that, you know, yeah, oh, that is, I hate it, I hate it when technology doesn't do what it's supposed to, John. I share your pain, you guys want to talk Dropbox a little bit or no? No.

1:08:18 Or Verizon. We could talk Verizon. Well, Verizon, I quit because the service was so terrible, and I'm now on Suddenlink, and we're public, so I won't go too far down that rabbit hole, but... I think there's some community support to that rabbit hole, though. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, but how do we find, you know, a solution? I just don't know. We can invent a new internet. It would be good, yeah.

1:08:51 I could have my buddy, John Wentworth, you know, put a few million dollars into a wireless system around town that we could all buy into. Yeah. And then John Wentworth can get on to some bigger and better things. That's right. Yeah. I've always wanted to be a public utility. It's been one of my goals. Yes. Okay. So, moving on to the next page, 83, if that's where we're going, and I'm assuming it is,

1:09:26 There are three bullet points in the key characteristics. Understand the role of local governments and their responsibilities, know their roles, set vision and policy, avoid micromanagement, and council members strive to be informed about the issues facing the city and be prepared to ask questions of staff and the job board, you know, either way. So are we doing this?

1:09:59 Well, first is, you know, ask questions of each other all in the Brown Act, or I hope that they mean within the context of a public meeting. Yeah, I believe they mean within the context of a public meeting. So do we, each of us, know our role, or do we tend to try and micromanage? You recall this one, we went on to about 45 minutes with this at the last workshop. I don't, I'm just thinking back to the COVID era.

1:10:32 I don't know. I don't even know how we're micromanaged. I think we've been doing what we're supposed to be doing, which is working with the town manager. I haven't seen it. I haven't been in my room in a year, so I guess I could call people on the phone and bug them and stuff, but I don't know. I don't think that's much of an issue, but I'm more than happy to talk about it, but I think we've been staying out of that. Yeah, well, you know, I think part of it comes down to a,

1:11:04 And as we discussed in our last...

1:11:34 I remember that. I think I have certainly had conversations with town staff over the last year. I try to make sure that I always, no matter how passionate and crazy I get in a conversation, look, I'm one-fifth of the decision.

1:12:03 And I appreciate that only one-fifth of the decision. And I hope the staff understands that any one of us is only one-fifth of the decision. I always try to predicate my remarks that way, and I think if we're all doing that the same way, that's probably appropriate. But I would, to your point, Bill, defer to Dan and staff. They think we're my advantage of getting out of our lanes. I'd love to know that. Yeah. Yeah, I think that would be interesting to know. I mean, I try really hard not to also. And I try, if I am planning on emailing a department head or talking to a department head, I try to include Dan in that.

1:12:34 Not necessarily to get his permission, but at least to let him know what I'm doing. I try to listen carefully when department heads are giving their updates and then maybe follow up questions on that. But again, we may think we're doing great at it, but I would love to know what staff thinks because that is the biggest pain in the neck of all is to have council people or board members reaching out without the knowledge of the town.

1:13:03 of the town manager or the CAO to suggest things or to ask, not questions so much, but to suggest things like, I think you should clean the bathrooms at the park three times a day, not once every other day. I mean, whatever it is, that's not appropriate. So I'd like, again, I said to know how the staff thinks for children. Yeah, so important. They're going in there when you talk to them because the constituent has talked to you, which is often what happens is when I deal with staff a lot.

1:13:32 If you say, in the given direction, do you think we're cleaning the bathrooms enough, is that being misperceived as telling them they need to clean the bathrooms more? I don't think about those little nuances, you know, when I go in and take my relationship with staff, and probably I should think more about that, how I say things to make sure it's misperceived. Intellectent manager knows.

1:14:00 I think we're just fortunate, Bill, when you walked in, everybody, it's kind of a quick little whisper change that, hey, Mr. Sauser's here, please intercept him. I think, I think of the,

1:14:35 The element here really comes down to the day-to-day operational issues. A lot of this in different cities handle it differently. I know there's some that are very, very strict in terms of council members not speaking with other staff unless they're, you know, invited to do so. Those elements. We're probably much more relaxed in that area, especially for reaching out for information. You know, the two employees you have, obviously you have direct access on a regular basis, be that to myself or to

1:15:04 The town attorney, Andy, in terms of reaching out and asking for things, and I know people do that as needed. I think that the discussions with staff, getting information is good. I think the caution comes into, as a council member, you have inherent authority that sometimes you don't even maybe recognize as you deal with staff, and it's like, oh, I've got a request to go do this from council member staff, so we jump to it and go get it done. Or there's a...

1:15:33 Expectation that those things will be addressed. So it's early in the career, one of the council members down south that made the comment that we actually spoiled them because he'd bring a complaint in or an issue forward. And it happened, it got addressed pretty quickly. And he goes, you're almost empowering me to bring those forward. And again, not just through the city manager at the time, but the staff directly.

1:15:56 And so there's a balancing act in that in the day-to-day operations. A lot of stuff that comes forward makes sense. You're out in the street. You see things. You're talking to the community. Members bring things often forward more to you than to us. So to the extent that we can be aware of that, then we can respond accordingly where we need to. I think there's a balancing act between that process and how we make that work effectively and to where staff isn't feeling that they're given a directive by a council member to act accordingly.

1:16:25 Two elements. One, it's not the role of the individual council member to do that, period, in terms of day-to-day operations. The other side of that is, as a single council member, the authority to do that doesn't really exist. Most of the vast majority of the authority of the council to make direction and stuff comes as you sit as a body, as you act as a legislative body going, here's where we're collectively going, or here's the direction we're providing.

1:16:54 But again, I think we have that now and again. It's sometimes a perception issue that people have felt like they're being directed, whether that's the intent or not. It's been there. And I think the other piece this falls into is how that happens in the meeting setting as council members take action and stuff. At times, it's the clarity of that action or one council member in a...

1:17:19 Related to an item or in a council report will make a statement to something and the rest of the council kind of, you know, listen. And the question is, is that then direction or is that just the opinion of one council member? I think at times that gets confusing where the person making the statement assumes that is now direction to staff and staff is kind of going, well, nobody else acknowledged it. So is it just.

1:17:43 A statement, not a direction. And balancing through some of that is probably more challenging at times in the actual adoption of an item or the moving forward. It's something of that nature. But I think the idea of, you know, the day-to-day, you know, running of the town and, you know, getting things done, I would say overall the council's pretty decent about that in terms of letting staff get their work done. Where do we pull council members into things, where we want input and discussion?

1:18:12 Again, often that can only be one or two of you just because of the nature of the legislative body, those types of elements. But having that clarity in terms of direction, I think it's pretty well understood, I would say from the overall that.

1:18:27 It's probably true. There's now and again, I think, perceptions of that being, hey, I want you to get X done differently if you're coming directly to me and making that choice to say, yes, we can do that or no, that needs to come back to the council or no, that's not an item that we can actually act on independently, being able to make those types of choices and have that conversation. But to that end of it,

1:18:50 Up to the department heads if they want to weigh in on this as well. But I think understanding that clarity of role there is very important on that and understanding the structure we have of, you know, the council and you're fully aware of it, of the two employees that you actually direct and work through. But again, it's also difficult at times if there's a simple question to ask, yeah, go ask the person who has the information versus at times versus trying to go, well, I'll work through another person and get through it and it's back up.

1:19:18 Always, if there's a question mark on that, you go through myself or Andy and we can coordinate that. A lot of times it's good to know what those questions are. When you do ask a department head something, the vast majority of the time, unless it's pretty simple, they do pass that along that, hey, you know, you know, Vice Mayor Lucido asked about X, Y, or Z. Great to know. Let's make sure we respond accordingly or provide the documents we need.

1:19:44 Or at times it's a direct referral, hey, great question, you need to contact, you know, Stu to get that information. So that, I don't think there should be a straight jacket in that chain of command and that communication, but definitely an understanding of what's either perceived and or given as direction needs to really be cautious, those, that area.

1:20:07 So, Andy, if you want to weigh in on any of that, that'd be great. If not, I'd open up the department heads if they have comments as well. We'll talk a little more about the roles and stuff here shortly when we get in some of the diagram of it. But, Andy? I don't have anything to add. I mean, you're right. I was going to echo you earlier when you said that individual council members don't really have any authority. It really is only when acting as a group from the dais that you officially do have authority. So, as you said, Dan, I mean, it's not.

1:20:33 Not quite right for council members to be providing individual direction to staff. And as you said, even asking questions can kind of give staff, especially lower level staff, the impression that you're telling them to do something rather than simply asking a question. But yeah, I don't really have anything to add, Dan. I think you got it. Thank you. Anybody else want to weigh in from the department head side? Or did that cover it? I see heads nodding. It's okay. All right.

1:21:05 I'll ask another question. I did this last one, too. We have some good people since then. So, Andy, if as a private citizen and homeowner, something happens where if I was not a council member, I would go to a crew and say, hey, what are you thinking? Why are we doing it this way? Then how do I need to do that? How much of my homeowner authority and landowner authority here in Mammoth do I lose by the act of becoming a council member?

1:21:36 You don't lose any of it. But the thing is that just like you have those two capacities, staff can't tell the difference. You know, it's really hard for any town staff, especially when below the rank of apartment head, to be able to discern whether you're only talking to them as homeowner bill versus mayor bill. And so staff are going to tend to give you more deference and treat you differently simply because you're the mayor. And that's why.

1:22:05 Even though, of course, you could talk to staff, it's best if you really talk to Dan. Or me, if it's a legal issue, always. But if you have a question or a concern for the staff, the best thing to do is to talk to Dan, or if Dan's okay and you have a relationship with the department head, talk to your department head. But telling the guys out in the field, hey, the snowfall's in the wrong place, that could be a little weird for them because you can't stop being the mayor.

1:22:33 You know, you're always going to be the mayor or, you know, any of you, council member, when you're talking to them and they're aware of that. So try to talk to Dan as much as you can. Do you have any questions on this one? This is an important one. I like my interpersonal relationship. And we currently have a town manager who allows us that relay. We have had town managers in the past who forbade anyone who was in the public realm of talking to his staff without first getting permission.

1:23:10 Which didn't fit well for my personality. And it's a large personality bill, but remember it's just one-fifth. It's one-fifth. No, I believe that. I understand that. Not only do I understand that, I appreciate it. It means I don't have to take all the liability either. Okay. So we know our roles. We know not to micromanage. And we know to be informed. Actually, I think this council does a good job of being informed. I give you all a high mark for that.

1:23:45 Relationship with staff and each other. I thought that's what we just talked about. Councilmembers have the ability to disagree or agree. Leave it at the dais. Debate throughout policy, not personality. Exceptional councilmembers reflect positive decorum of model of leadership. Respectful thumbs up. Hey, Bill, as you look down and speak, we can barely hear you, at least here. I'm not sure about the other.

1:24:16 Members, so either speak louder or turn your volume up if that's the issue there or directly into the microphone. Thank you. It's what I love about these meetings, Dan, because it's the only time anybody ever says they're having a hard time hearing things. Sorry, personal joke. You've all read those four points. Do we agree, disagree? Are we doing this? I mean, I would like to see us.

1:24:42 You know, not only for this council, but for subsequent councils, that we sort of establish a set of behaviors ahead of time, which are, we don't have to sync them up, they're all over the place, you can find this on League of Cities documents, and just so that we can kind of point to that, and if someone is being sort of oriented into joining town council, you know, we can kind of review those, we can touch on them every year in strategic planning, and just say, just remember, this is how we've agreed to conduct ourselves with civility and respect.

1:25:11 I think it's just worth touching on on a yearly basis. Yeah, so you think it's worthwhile finding one of the documents that spells out council roles and responsibilities and changing the pursuit of our needs and passing it to the council? I do. Others? John? There are cans, and some cans have worms in them. On this particular topic,

1:25:43 We don't have to get into it now, but I would like, I think we need to start having a conversation about the council's role vis-a-vis the NGOs and the effectiveness of the NGOs, direction to the NGOs. We don't have to get into this now, but I think it gets a little bit into this relationship with the town manager and the staff to some degree, because

1:26:13 Given the certain program areas that the NGOs are working in, we could be giving direction to staff, but there's this other body out there that's doing all this work, and I don't know, I think that we need to have a discussion about that, how we monitor effectiveness, all that. That's a whole, as it can, and there's worms in it, but I just, this seemed the appropriate topic of discussion, maybe just make a note of that, we can get to that at some point.

1:26:42 So, John, if you're following along with the draft working agenda, it is not on your version, but on my version, between role of staff and effective meetings, it's a conversation on NGOs. Oh, okay. I'm sorry. I'm looking at these pages. It is part of what we're talking about, and we are going to roll that into the end if that works for you. Fine. Perfect. Thank you. Yeah. Yeah, that is a huge, important conversation. I agree with you. Yep.

1:27:13 If I may, I think one of the key elements in this one is that whole idea of the idea of respectfully agree to disagree in that process. Several councils I've worked with is one of their key elements in its statement they make at the front end of coming together as a body after elections and stuff, but kind of the Linda's note of kind of having these norms out there. It's the idea of respect.

1:27:39 And being civil and one group, I mean, that was their only norm is we have to respect each other. We have to respect the community and the public and we have to respect our staff and their follow up as if we can't do that, we've already failed. And so their goal was how do we respectfully work with each other? And even with a very strong disagreements on issues and items, they were very good about being able to leave it at the dais afterwards, you know, if they went out and

1:28:09 Had dinner or did a, you know, other community event and stuff. But I think that that takes a lot of thought in that and just in stuff from how we use our words and the information we bring forward and how we do that, that it doesn't.

1:28:22 Come across as being disrespectful in those three areas, you know, starting with the council, the community and the public that we interact with, and then with the staff and the relationships that we have in the working environment here. So I think as you look at those, I think that's a really key one in terms of just being able and however people define that idea of respect and civility in the process, especially when things are heated. Often that's when things get difficult, it's easy to...

1:28:51 It's back to the idea of you attack the person versus the ideas and deal with the concepts and deal with the policy discussion and debate. But that's a key element. That's something from a staff level that we talk about if we bring employees in. One of the elements is we'll look at the five chairs at the dais. And the idea is you need to respect that position regardless of who is sitting in that chair.

1:29:16 The individual there has ran, they've been elected, the community has set them up in that role as a leadership role, as a legislative body member. And we need to respect that regardless of who it is or whether we agree or disagree on an issue. That level of respect is key to being able to effectively run and manage a local government.

1:29:38 And so that's a real key issue, as I say, for me personally, in terms of looking at that. It's not a matter of agreeing or disagreeing at that respect, but doing whatever that is with respect and understanding that role of the elected official for the position that they are in and their responsibilities accordingly. Thank you. I think that that's, you know, that's certainly ideal. And personally, I've been party to boards who were rude and disrespectful to each other.

1:30:09 And particularly rude, disrespectful to department heads, to staff. And it was, I mean, you know, department heads would come forward with a report, agenda item, and would be attacked by the electeds. And I would never want to see that. And you don't think that you need sort of a little code of conduct until you do. And so that's why a little preemptive work and, you know, trying to get the council.

1:30:37 Or boards on the same page with an agreed upon way that they're going to be treating not only each other, but the public and staff, including the manager of the CAO, I think is really ideal. It's just not tolerated. We're not going to tolerate it. I'm going to call it recess. I'm going to hang the gavel down. I'm going to stop this where it is. And we're going to, you know, I mean, there is no room in that for electeds and boards. Other comments?

1:31:17 Okay. My comment, hi Bill. My comment is that, remember that the media does try to focus on conflict. Or create conflict. A little of both, I agree. We love our media, yes. Okay, I'm going to go on to number four then. Exceptional councils routinely present effective meetings. There are six bullet points. I am not going to read them.

1:31:51 One thing I've noticed as being, you know, a secretary to my own board and on another board and then as a council, I think our meetings are extremely effective and props to Jamie for keeping them running along. One thing that I notice again and again is the stating of a thing in a different way. I don't know what the...

1:32:21 What the technical term for that is, but I'm sure you all know, like, oh, you just said this, and I'm just going to go ahead and say it again. And I'm not really sure what the solution to that is. I've, like, even read, you know, how to just say I second that remark without kind of having to go on a second soliloquy about that. I know that these meetings can sometimes.

1:32:47 I would be saying yes.

1:33:18 Just because it's your turn to speak doesn't mean you have to. I guess so. Well, as someone who always never shies away from an opportunity to open his mouth, I think, Sarah, it's also important, though, in terms of constituents understanding where people stand. And sometimes if we just, if we don't say anything in the interest of brevity and being succinct, sometimes the public might start wondering if that person never says anything.

1:33:46 What do you believe? Or where do you stand on this? So maybe it's hopefully just cognitive of that. That's fair. Yeah. I mean, you can acknowledge a statement. I agree with that. That makes sense to me. And that could be it. But I think it's probably helpful to at least give an indicator to the public of where we all stand. And I would agree. One of the things that we have tried to do away with some, and our council has gotten better at it. There are some other organizations that haven't.

1:34:21 Thank you.

1:34:51 I would agree, Sarah, that gravity is good, but I also agree with what John said. If you don't speak up, sometimes there's a perception that you're not doing your work. So there's a fine line to be had there. And I hope that we all keep that gravity thing in line for the future so that we can have, you know, effective leadership. I have watched this council for 36 years or whatever it's been now, 37 years this year.

1:35:21 And there are a lot of councils that have gone on too long as I'm doing right now just to prove my point. You know, Bill, there's a little bit of one other spot in this, and that is the length of our meetings and how they're set up with the agenda. Sometimes the agenda is just too ambitious for a good length of time. I agree with you. After three hours, you might as well just call it. So I would rather consider adding an extra meeting in the calendar.

1:35:51 Then just trying to jam five hours or something into one. So I think that's kind of a staff working with the mayor, particularly on setting the agendas and how long is reasonable to how many items are reasonable.

1:36:03 Linda, I think that's a great point. In some of our meetings, Craig Burrows, who's our CMO, he always sets his alarm for an hour and he makes everyone stand up and stretch because he says that we, you know, you can't focus if you've been staring and especially with Zoom and you're on Zoom all day and then you come here and sit on Zoom. I would love to see like a 10-minute break.

1:36:28 I know that, again, it's tough because you have to cram in so much into these meetings, but I really do think it boohoo's everyone to just stretch and, you know, just take your eyes off the screen for a second so you can kind of come back with a little bit more fresh head. I remind everybody that they do have child labor laws in the state. Mine like I may qualify, but they probably not. That's an important distinction.

1:36:57 Every two hours, incidentally, Sarah, I try to call, I pull you all as to whether you want to take a break or not. I'm very cognizant of that. I don't set an alarm, so sometimes it goes over or under it. I do try to do that. Another thing that Dan and I have been talking a lot about lately, and I was glad to hear comments on it, is when an item, when we can't do justice to an item in a regular meeting because of the length of our agenda, to justice.

1:37:27 I mean, I would be in favor of that. John, Sarah? Yeah, it's, you know, it's always tough for me because I do have a job, so every one of these meetings I take paid time off for. However, I do think,

1:38:08 I am more useful if it is not five hours or if it's 10 o'clock and we're still hammering out the same issues. Yeah, I would sort of be okay with that. I tend to not suffer too badly from marathon efforts, but I do think putting brakes in there along the way. And certainly it's the determination of the mayor that we're all foggy-brained and nothing's happening.

1:38:37 We can put it off to the next meeting. I mean, do it. And to that effect, you know, from the staff side of that is one of just the work element of that, but it's not unusual to set up a study session or other things. And to Sarah's point, the timing of those, if you're going to do one item, you do it at 5.30 or 6 and you're only going to be there for an hour and a half. You're not going to be there from 6 till 10 or 11 or 12 o'clock at night.

1:39:01 One agency actually at midnight was an early meeting. So you can imagine the drain on people at that point. But the element there would be if there's something like that that's going to need that much focus and discussion and that can be done. We can look at, you know, whether it's the regular council meeting night or different night for a special meeting. You set that up. It's, you know, one item to 10.

1:39:25 You know, outside the normal stuff on the agenda or public comment, etc. But then you can focus on it. You can do that as an off hour, but you know you're going to be there for that one item. And it may go long depending on public engagement and conversation and discussion. That's why you would pull it off onto a different meeting schedule to be able to have that level of discussion on it, but focused on one issue, making that available from the council's perspective. And one of the discussions a while back with folks is it's

1:39:54 Daytime meetings, they're great unless you happen to have a full-time job and then they're really painful to try to make them work. So how do you make that transition and try to look at that evening or that off-hour element is, and Sarah, I fully agree with that with other, not just this body, but others who have had working council members that made it difficult in terms of taking time off and scheduling and those types of elements.

1:40:18 But if you could come in, I don't know your schedule, absolutely, but it's a 530 meeting that's going to go 530 to 7 and we'll be done. Then we're able to dive into something that's fairly weighty and work through it. That's the beauty of having a citizen legislature, right?

1:40:37 So, yeah, 530 absolutely works for me. I can hear in my heart Jamie probably groaning because as a board secretary myself, I know that it's a lot to schedule those extra meetings with the Brown Act and everything, so it is a lot of extra work. So, obviously, I'm not in favor of that unless it's, yeah, kind of the special occasion that you're referencing.

1:41:03 And when we get into those types of debates and those types of issues, though, having that focused time, the goal would be it leads to a better understanding and ultimately better decision making. So it's no different than these sessions. I mean, you could cram these into the first hour or last hour of a regular council meeting and the effectiveness of those would be dramatically diminished. And so I know you love spending your Friday afternoons with all of us, but it's...

1:41:31 Just one of those things of trying to get a time that works so you can actually have this type of dialogue that otherwise you normally would not be able to engage in. Yeah, absolutely. There's two, you know, there's a left and a right shoot every thought. And one of the things we have to remember is at the meeting, while it is hard for nine-to-fiveers to make daytime meetings, some of us that work, even that work a little more physically, by the time five or 5.30 comes along,

1:42:01 And I don't work as much as I used to, so I thought we're out at the end of the day. But you have to keep that in mind, you know, next council and next council and what that's going to look like. A lot of times, five or six o'clock at night, which accounts have been doing for a long time.

1:42:29 Yeah. It doesn't work just because you're wore out. Yeah. The four o'clock is, I think, is a good compromise. Yeah. Thank you. So do I. Okay. Anything else on that one?

1:42:44 Where am I at? Bill, if I may, the only other comment in there. It's one of the items I think we do pretty well on that, but I know from a staff level at times, it's making sure that agenda packets are read and that the information is there, people come prepared if they have questions. To the extent that we get them in advance, it's really beneficial. We try to do that. Past life experience, one of those we used to have as a council member.

1:43:10 Would show up and they would have their packet in a manila envelope. And at the dais as the meeting started, they're pulling it out and laying in front of them. They have not looked at it as they're breaking the seal. So coming in and being ready and having read stuff, I think that's really powerful. Some of this stuff is very complex and some of it's much more, you know, deep or thick or how you want to, you know, just technical reading of it. We don't expect council members to be experts in a lot of these areas.

1:43:38 But definitely coming in prepared really helps everybody. I think it tends to move the meetings along a little faster. We also try to maximize use of a consent calendar if something really is more routine in nature. I think utilizing that tool can help meetings move forward as well. But I think there's nothing that beats that really preparedness coming in and going, yeah, I've looked at this stuff. I've got questions. I'll raise them. I've asked some in advance.

1:44:05 And then whatever happens at the meeting, whether it's public or other council members, you get that dialogue going. Yeah, there's going to be things come up that, hey, I hadn't thought about that. Hey, that's a great question. Thank you for raising that. Helps my understanding of that here. And so we want it to be a very good dialogue in that way. But, you know, can't emphasize enough at times really coming in, having read the information. And again, not here we haven't done this, but again, previous perspective on that.

1:44:33 Department head would like to remind, like, okay, yes, Mr. Mayor, if you look at page three of the staff report, that question is highlighted on the second paragraph. And almost in an embarrassing sense, that had to, like, get nipped real quick. Not an appropriate way to respect people, as we talked about earlier. But having that opportunity to read through stuff, and that means it's well prepared, it's well written, there is adequate time to review it, this council and others here.

1:45:03 If I'm going to hand out a four-page document or longer at the beginning of a meeting and you have three minutes to look at it, that frankly doesn't work well. And so on both sides of that, I guess one of my questions to that is on the information you're getting and receiving from staff, do you feel, you know, I'll say the vast majority of the time that you're prepared to discuss or make an action on the items there?

1:45:34 Because sometimes these packets are hard to read for those of us that are lay people. We don't speak government needs. But you also, as councilmen, all of us have the ability to meet with Dan and ask our questions and even meet with department heads if he allows us to do that if we have questions of other specific things. So that a lot of our questions can be answered in advance. If they are questions we are asking,

1:46:03 to educate the public, then that makes sense for the meeting. But if there are questions we can have answered prior, I recommend it. It helps us keep the meeting griefer and more pointed, if you will. Comments, questions?

1:46:21 Again, just want to shout out to Jamie for always having that packet promptly done so that I can take the weekend to read it. You know, I always just sit down with my tea on Saturday or Sunday and go through it. And it's great to have that, knowing that it's always going to be there, setting time aside for myself to read it, and then being able to meet with Dan before the council meeting to get any clarifications or questions I have. I feel like it's a really tight program.

1:46:49 Yeah, I appreciate the shout-out for Jamie. I will give her a shout-out as well. I would miss not being there in person because I can't look over Jamie and have her keep me straight and moving in the right direction. So she would appreciate the call. Other comments? Okay. Okay. The next one on the hit parade is exceptional councils, both themselves and the city accountable.

1:47:23 Let me dive in a little bit, Bill. I think overall, yes, I think at times, you know, the follow-up and how we make sure we're coming back with information to Council is it can be stronger and we're putting some things in place to do that. I think as the Council works through things, I think, you know,

1:48:01 Being ethical and integrity in those really are critical. It's something we see as councils do that. Asking honest questions and issues at the front end and in the meetings and really trying to understand stuff I think happens with that. I think the areas where, you know, the celebrating success at times I think it's, okay, that's done, we set it aside, we jump into the next thing and maybe we don't quote unquote pat ourselves on the back sometimes as we should, both as a council.

1:48:29 For the elements that are getting done. And it's always interesting dialogue with council members who we get a lot of work done and they're going, yeah, but, you know, the staff really put out and did a great job and made that happen. But that happens because of the direction we get, because of the resource allocation, because of the priority set. So I encourage council members to, you know, step into that success along with the staff that are engaged in the process and the work through it.

1:48:56 And then I think that accountability comes back to how are we reporting back on items if there's questions that come up? Are we getting back in timely fashion and making sure that we're following through on some of the goals and priorities? Or if we're not, everybody's understanding why. This last year, there was a pretty good excuse for a lot of things not happening given the level of COVID activity. But yet one of the elements we'll want to point to is in the staff report, we added a lot of the

1:49:25 Background information on how, with things we have accomplished, the successes that have been done, and to have the council really be mindful of that success level, but also understanding the accountability that's needed there. I think John had a question. I think one thing we could do with that is, in terms of the priorities, when I came on council, there were no council priorities. I think there were three. It was like three little bullet-pointed sense kinds of things.

1:49:56 into this effort to get priorities set up. I think as part of the onboarding process, I think the first council meeting with a new council should be to review the priorities with the understanding that we're not going to, we'll address changing and redoing them down the road, but at least kick the thing off with, this is what this council, this is what the priorities are. Bill, I think I remember the first time you came on up and you were going, well, look, I just got elected here. I'm going to...

1:50:23 I want to weigh in on these priorities. I want to do something with them, which is entirely appropriate. But we didn't do anything at all. We just said, well, we're working off of this. Let's just get going. But I think to have as part of that onboarding process, this is what we got. This is what we're working on right now. So we're all sort of on the same page to start with. And then set the expectation as to when the priorities, when we'll do this kind of stuff, when that will happen. And I know Dan's been a tough year, obviously, going something to deal with.

1:50:51 I would like to see that integrated into the onboarding process. That would be helpful. Not make new council members feel left out or like, you know, well, we'll get to you guys later. That's my only note on this section. I would like to talk a little bit about annual evaluations of both the council and the town manager. I think that asking a council or board to evaluate themselves is really powerful.

1:51:22 Yeah, I really agree with that.

1:51:54 I'm sorry, I keep bringing it back to my work, but because I do work with the board, it does intersect. You know, we've hired a consultant to come and kind of facilitate that. People kind of do that. And I think that has been really helpful for our board. And I also, I know that the evaluation of the town manager for me this year, I was kind of just a little bit lost.

1:52:21 And this is my first time, so I, and I've experienced that in other governance areas as well. I think there wasn't, I didn't feel like there was, like I didn't know enough about the criteria maybe, and that may just speak to my being new. I think every organization knows about performance evaluations differently. I wish there was a chance that worked for all. I don't know, how many?

1:52:57 How do I judge him on those things if I don't know?

1:53:27 You know, are 360 evaluations best? Some organizations think they are, some organizations don't. We have never evaluated ourselves to counsel. Probably not a bad idea. Do I really want to know anything about me? Well, I don't know. It could affect my emotional stability. So those are things, you know, tell me about it. Should we be doing counsel evaluations? Should we be asking for 360?

1:53:58 I think 360s are a really great way to understand how you're, because we don't speak to the town staff, right? I mean, well, Bill, maybe you do, but, you know, I don't go in there and see how everyone's liking their jobs. Do they feel supported or do they feel their culture is good? And I think an anonymous 360 is a great way for the staff to express what

1:54:26 You know, are they burned out? These are things that it's really hard for us as a council to know. And that's why I do think that those anonymous evaluations are extremely helpful in my experience. I think anything to do with the council, these types of conversations are really valuable. I mean, this kind of just for us being able to talk with each other is really, really important. And to take on exercises involving trust, evaluations and all the rest of it, I would hope.

1:54:53 Any council has a chance to get a foundation under its feet before we start doing that kind of stuff. I would agree with that. Okay. Exceptional councils have members who practice continuous personal learning and development. Stay informed on key issues, gain key insights on knowledge, learn to listen. What? Again, I think this one is in terms of the ongoing personal learning and development from a...

1:55:46 The organizational perspective or, you know, legislative body perspective this last year has been difficult. A lot of the processes that have been there before through a conference or traveling or other elements have just obviously been difficult this last year. I think there's a number of resources out there, similar to what we're walking through here, that is good for council members to go through. And also, as department heads engage in similar activity and work, I think that's really important.

1:56:13 To continuing to do that and how you engage and learn and just general understanding a lot of the legislative processes. One of the main things I think we learn in a lot of the conference sides is talking to other counterparts for myself, either managers or council members having a conversation. All of a sudden it's like, oh, well, we're actually doing really well or.

1:56:41 Man, you guys are actually succeeding at X. And it's just that whole interaction tends to really help and move through a lot of those things. But understanding that, that we're not acting in a vacuum just in Mono County, the town of Mammoth Lakes, that we are involved in a much larger clinical spectrum, both in our region and to the state beyond in that element. And learning those things and able to work through that has been, I think, very powerful for

1:57:09 Other council members here as well as in other settings that that understanding and talking to what other elected officials are learning and going through or challenges before them has been very powerful. We're actually fortunate with Andy here. He can bring some of the experiences from the town of Truckee. Very similar in a lot of the issues we deal with. They deal with some similarities there. And it's great to have that experience of going, hey, how are you addressing X?

1:57:38 In another community. And at times that can be, it's interesting that either you're out there on the leading edge or falling behind or you're just uniquely different, however that may fall out. But Andy? I don't really have anything to add to that. Okay. But I agree. I mean, and I will say it works both ways. It's really interesting and helpful to me as I sit here in Truckee to have a constant comparison of what another...

1:58:07 Peer community, not peer resort, but peer community is doing to handle some of these common issues. And I talk to my counterpart in South Lake Tahoe pretty regularly and hear about what they're doing. And I do think, as I've said before, that we can all learn from what our counterparts are doing and no one has a monopoly on good ideas. Bill, you were muted there if you were speaking. I just said I'm listening, trying to encourage you. Sorry, what's the topic at hand? I got distracted by some incoming. Exceptional councils and members.

1:58:56 You practice continuous personal learning and development. So I will say on this how important I feel continually learning new things is, not as a council member, but as a human being. To stay fresh, there are several things I believe you need to do. One of them is you need to keep learning new things every day and new positions and perspectives every day to learn what other people are doing. That is hugely important.

1:59:25 As a human being, just like a city, if you stop growing, you start dying. So I think that this is a hugely important thing. I look to all of you in town to do that. The other thing, of course, that I believe is hugely important is socialization. And this Zoom is not my idea of appropriate socialization. I hope we get back to public meetings. I think it's really important. I think also, too,

1:59:54 Have confidence in whatever experience and learn things that fellow council members bring to discussion. It's a perfect question and ask questions. I think the degree to which we have a certain amount of trust in each other with areas of expertise makes the council stronger and makes the community stronger. So, yeah, I was mirroring every word you're saying there, Bill, especially in being part of it. Thank you.

2:00:24 I think as we forward articles back and forth to each other through Dan, you read this really interesting article about another resort community and you say, oh, I'd really like to give this to everybody, you know, send it to Dan or he forwards it out to everybody. Really, I really do like that. I also appreciate getting, you know, educational opportunities or seminars sent to us. I know we get a lot of them from League of Cities, but we also get them from a lot of other places that one or the other of us would see. So I would like that to continue.

2:00:54 We'll be, you know, kind of share information with each other. And, you know, we run across a lot of agenda items that I read, and I'm like, I have no idea. You know, like we brought someone in, like, pre-COVID now, which all seems very long ago about financing opportunities for housing. And I think, you know, we learned a lot of that, and I'd like to see more of that, where things are brought to the council, where the community can also learn a lot with us, because we certainly cannot be expected to know everything.

2:01:24 So are we clear about how that works routing-wise? Like if we find an article for the council, we send it to Dan, Dan, you send it to everybody, is that how we're doing this? That's what I do. Yeah, because we had some discussions on that a while back. That's the way it should be done to avoid any Brown Act. Yeah, I've got a, there's a whole bunch of stuff happening in the state right now. I've got a little list, I'll share some things out with folks.

2:01:54 You know, this, to me, the learning and communication, well before I got on council, the town manager at that point thought it was very important, and the council thought it was very important to do peer resort tours. And I looked at them both in a positive, negative way, because when you go to another resort, staff sets up these meetings for those folks, you get, you know, what I would call a dog and pony show.

2:02:21 But it was also very important for me to see other peer communities that I would not otherwise pay attention to and how they are doing things and how they are solving the same issues we have. I don't know if any of you were on those, John, I think you were on some of those here as to what the benefit or if you think that they are not cheap for the town to do.

2:02:47 And then, you know, there's a certain newspaper man in town who will say that we are taking pleasure junkets and not going out to learn. But in visiting several of those communities, I learned a lot. One of the things I learned was how well we do things here. But it's still an important lesson. Yeah, I think that's, I was talking about being in the meeting and having the last week. That whole, there are networks now for us as a, as a,

2:03:17 Mount Town that are easy. It's not anything like what we've done in the past. We can tap into those resources, use those resources much more efficiently, much easier, much less expensively than those things in the past. So I won't go on about that, but we've got, there are enormous resources we can avail ourselves of, and I would encourage us to do that. When we go into the post-Zoom world, fine, we'll be meeting a person.

2:03:47 You know, saying how to do and all that kind of good stuff. A lot of that stuff, though, we may come back to this environment because we can do a lot of that kind of stuff in this environment. Much less cost, much more efficient, and the information, the intellectual resources are about for sure. Yeah, I just can't ask, you know, the bartender in Aspen, what do you think about their public health? You have no business asking a bartender in Aspen anything anyway. Okay, John, I can't ask the mayor.

2:04:16 What she thinks about the workforce housing solutions they have there versus what we have here. All right, we'll do some of that. Code market research, John, come on. Yeah, but we'll just arrive in Aspen briefed, ready to go. We know we want to talk to, but she's with our mates, and then we'll leave town. No dog and bonies, no insufferable. We do things perfectly in August. Any other comments on that?

2:04:47 I just remember John the other week was like, you've got to go to Europe. And I was like, who's going to pay for that? And that's sort of my point. I am not going to go and visit Aspen's Vale to see what they're doing on my own. I have no desire to go. But I learned a lot from that trip. Yeah. And a lot of this is not, it's just personal experience. And bringing those kinds of things to the table is just really important. Yeah.

2:05:20 Okay. Wait a minute. Just so you all know that I can take recommendations well. Everybody stand up. It's been an hour. Touch the ceiling. Well, okay, the rest of you can't do that part. Touch your toes. You're all rock stars. Perfect. John's got to be able to have fun doing this stuff, brother. It's the way it is. I'm having a great time. Yeah. Okay. I am not going to go on further into this.

2:06:20 Well, I'm sorry, Bill. The last piece was what? Yeah, we're good with that element. I think the next few pages are summaries of the things we've talked about. As you look at culture and civility, you look at teamwork. Unless there's something on those pages that jump out, we would like to spend a little bit of time on...

2:06:47 It's kind of a summary of it. It's on page 95. 94-95 is the same little chart that really talks about the dimensions of the governmental process and the different levels of activity from really setting that vision and mission down to the actual management and implementation side. And I wanted to touch on this and really where a lot of the work goes on. And this kind of leans into a comment Bill made earlier. This is really...

2:07:15 Dealing with the elected official sphere and how that feeds into the staff's level. But the other side of this is that unique position here. Maybe it's not that unique, but how we utilize other non-governmental organizations. We use other elements to achieve town mission, town goals that maybe doesn't quite fall into this type of a graphic. But the graphic really...

2:07:44 Looks at the mission of the town, really, you know, that's the council doing that. What's the purpose? Where are we going? Setting that high level of policy direction. As we get into that, the particular ones of new policy, whether that's done by resolution, by ordinance, by council action, you know, it's working through the budget. A lot of the budget is pretty well fixed in terms of costs that work through that.

2:08:10 And then the ability to, you know, make those adjustments as necessary to make policy on that. Within those two upper areas of mission and policy, staff is really your professional recommendation authorities, if you will, to be able to bring items forward, to be able to provide detailed analysis where we are requested to, looking at audit times, what actually we can do, what we actually can achieve.

2:08:40 I think that's back to the reality on some issues we're dealing with early on made the comment. These are things that the town actually can control. These are areas where we can have substantial influence versus, you know, tackling something that we just have no ability to influence. And how do we make those recommendations forward? And then in terms of actually implementing those decisions, you know, it's...

2:09:07 Really, a lot of the complaints and, you know, day-to-day operational issues falls to the staff. But there's a certain level of input or complaint or positive things that come to the town council that can help in the administration, help in our practices, our procedures and things that we're doing about how to implement those decisions. But you start to fall through that down to the day-to-day management. Really, that's an area that the council kind of steps back out of. Definitely.

2:09:36 Watching, it's the idea of eyes in, hands out, seeing what's happening, here's some suggestions, here's elements, here's what I'm hearing in the community, but really then management controlling those resources, be it people, be it financial, be it equipment, et cetera, to really make those things work. I think the majority of the interaction...

2:09:57 Is in that policy and administrative boxes there where that line kind of waves in and out of the role of staff versus the role of town council. And I think it's a good issue there because that also allows us at staff level, there are expectations that we hold when we deal with town council. I think there should be the opposite in the town council expectations from staff. And also from the staff role, how do we see ourselves as well as

2:10:26 The council role with different elements with that that we deal with. And so I think it's a good item to look at and say, what is that expectation and how far up and down, if you will, these different areas? Again, this is a broad statement thing. We work through that. When you walk into a non-governmental organization or one we've created that now has a separate legal board who has authority over their activities, they can almost have this same level of a role.

2:10:54 Yes, they're linked back to the town. I think a lot of times that I know times there's like kind of a role identity confusion almost going. I know they're an independent body, but we've actually asked them to achieve certain things on our behalf, but we really don't have any authority to go make them do that from a staff level at least. Or there's no consequences if you don't perform it. So if we have a true contract, for example, with a

2:11:24 We're working on a mobility hub study. If we don't like the output, we terminate the agreement. We get somebody else who has a skill set to do that, not to touch on something that's real. But those issues of that, how do we navigate some of that? And really, that starts to roll into that council policy level going, here's our expectations and roles for these other support agencies.

2:11:50 And then the staff is kind of often one foot in, one foot out of saying, well, what's our relationship there and how do we have that work as well? So it's both from that outside, but to the inside with the town staff and the council members, that roles and expectations in this matrix or in this continuum of activity becomes really critical, I think, in terms of what that expectation level is on both sides of the table to really make us come together.

2:12:18 Kind of the very first item is how do we become effective as a team achieving common goals and mission and a benefit to our communities in those areas, how we work through that. So one, a little bit of discussion from the council in this area and also if staff is willing to talk about a little bit their expectations of town council as we bring things forward or as we work through policy development, some of the expectations there and vice versa from the council as well would be really

2:12:48 I think a healthy little discussion here as we kind of move into the last hour at 45 minutes or so of discussion here. So I'll turn it back over to you all. One is just if that makes sense. And I like this dimensions of government. I've used it in the past and seen it several times, sometimes a little different terminology in the boxes. But it's that gray area in the middle where the vast majority of the work gets done from a council slash manager slash staff level work program.

2:13:20 And John, as you were speaking to earlier, where does the NGO model fit in this line with how we, you know, provide services? So you all have the draft ahead of you and in front of you. I guess the other question is just does the flow of activity make sense? Bill, are you asking, let's take Mammoth Lake Tourism, how it fits with this model? What are you asking? Well, first,

2:13:59 The conversation is, do we understand what this is saying about the mission of council versus the mission of staff, and are we good with that? Do we think that's where we are, or do we need to change that line for our way of governance? Do we understand the delineation of roles and responsibilities? Well, policy turns into budget, and so I think staff, you know, administration is following, you know.

2:14:28 The adopted budget, but also the policies that Council and the direction that Council has set. I mean, I look at this squiggly line and I see us in here. I mean, I could, you know, okay, there's a steep mission, policy, accelerates, a vote happens, direction's given, and then it becomes, well, it's a burden on administration.

2:15:02 Implement it to make it happen. Things hopefully calm down a little bit and it gets done and it's implemented. So I certainly see us in there. But for a topic of conversation, how NGOs, and I think that we should not talk about any specific NGO, but just in terms of a service delivery tool or model that we're using as a town, understanding where that type of delivery mechanism fits.

2:15:29 And start thinking about what kinds of criteria we're going to bring to these things to say, is it efficient? Is it nimble? Is it, you know, is it a value-added thing to the mission of the town? Is it helping the town deliver its mission? Did it help deliver policy? Is it helping to implement? We need to start figuring out how we're going to evaluate those kinds of things because to be

2:15:57 Someone blunt about it, Dan's analogy about, look, if we have a contract with a consultant or something and it's not working and we don't like it, we say, look, okay, we're going to go find a better way to do this. And I think we need to be looking at that NGO model with a little bit of that same kind of a lens on. If we give direction and we say, look, we need to go over here and from an NGO or a contractor, we start getting all kinds of pushback. Well, we don't want to do that. We want to do something else. It's like, well, wait, wait, wait, hang on a second here.

2:16:26 We start getting into Goofyville, and I think it's something unique about how the town does stuff, and I think we need to start thinking about how we're going to evaluate the effectiveness of providing services in these ways, and what are the criteria we want to use to say, okay, this is effective, actually, this is not effective, this is working, this is not working, all that kind of stuff. It's a big thing, but I think we've got to sort of look at it. Yeah. Before we get completely into the NGO discussion, because I have a lot of things as well.

2:16:56 Are we comfortable with where we separate the staff in terms of partway through policy, where administration's primary staff and policy is sort of a combination of staff and council? Just looking at it, it kind of makes sense to me as a graphic representation of what goes on in that space. Yeah, that looks about right. There's an accelerant in there.

2:17:30 Do you have any more comments on that? A comment, you know, the council is setting policy, and again, the administration is carrying it out. And that is predicated on a 3-2 vote or a 4-0 vote, 5-0 vote. And so, you know, I'm not sure, you know, are we following this? Yes. You know, is this applicable?

2:17:59 Do we need to adjust our approach to issues? I don't think so. Thank you. Thanks, Kirk. With that, Dan, I am pretty comfortable that we've covered role delineation, challenge of governance, role of counsel, and role of staff in that draft, unless you want to go further into that. I would just...

2:18:33 Just want to make sure in some of that and the expectations in there. For example, let me do go a little deeper and a little bit of that from a staff perspective. We've touched on a lot of this, that expectation that council comes prepared, that they respect the professional opinion of the staff that's coming forward. I think unintentionally or intentionally at times people walk out feeling a little condescent, being, I'm going to say this properly, condescended to is like the action is like,

2:19:06 Hey, you know, it's not like it's sorry, I don't understand this or a question of it. It's like it feels a little more pushback. I'm just, you know, there's a frustration level or whatever pops out of that. And I want to make sure those are his expectation. It goes back to kind of that respecting or agreeing to disagree agreeably. The staff doesn't know all the answers and stuff, but they do come in hopefully as your professionals and the technical skill sets that they bring to the table of being able to bring things forward.

2:19:34 And as Kirk mentioned, we trust it's following a policy level direction from council. If it's not, that's a great discussion to have. Well, wait a minute, are we going down a certain road or not? And that there's commonality across the council for those policy statements. And the same side of that, I want to be cautious that the staff is not the one saying, council, here's your policy, please do this. You know, that we're not the ones driving that at a level that's not.

2:20:01 Appropriate or uncomfortable at the council level, be able to have those types of discussions. I don't think this happens often, but now and again that we get into those kind of unique little spots at times going, wait a minute, that really came across very, you know, non-genuine or it felt, you know, directed at versus beneficial. So those issues, and I think at times we got to be cautious of not doing that at the council.

2:20:27 Either if I can't believe council doesn't understand what we're telling them or something of that nature that can come across at times. And I want to be cautious of that way. Kind of goes back to respect and stuff, but also the willingness on both sides to raise those issues as they do come forward. And often that's, I'll be blunt, it's outside of a formalized meeting if you're dealing with a particular issue or a particular person at the staff level or council level. But I think overall that the spectrum works pretty well.

2:20:56 Again, in those middle two areas, that policy administration, I do think there's give and take through that process. And I think overall it works well. Now and again, you know, we feel at times at the staff level there's probably a little more micromanagement and direction than necessary, or that maybe at times it's the other way where staff feels or are driving a policy question that really should be asking the question versus trying to make a decision.

2:21:25 If that makes sense in that. I'll open up the staff if they want to say anything or elaborate on any items there. But I do think it overall works pretty well and there's always that gray area there that we work through. So I'll stop there. It's important to remember that staff does have a role in policy and that on a lot of these things from payment to policing, they are the experts we are not. So there is a role for them in policy setting in terms of...

2:21:58 I don't understand. What's the question?

2:22:32 Looking for comments, John, not really a hard question there. It sounds like earlier a comment. Yeah, we're working in that space pretty well. It's up and down. So, I mean, in terms of administration to policy, not trying to drive questions there, just understanding that role and that expectations as we go into these elements. Yeah, I think we're good. It's always going to be a tense space. A lot of the stuff that staff develops can be complicated and complex.

2:23:00 And if the complexity may not actually have policy implications, it just may be complicated to try to figure out what's being said. But then that's the council's role is to extract from a lot of technical language ideas. Okay, how does this align with a policy thing that we want to engage with and to adopt? So it's going to always be kind of a tent space. And I think we do pretty well with give and take back and forth.

2:23:27 From what I've seen, I don't, I haven't seen, I haven't had any problems with that so far. I very much appreciate, Dan, as you described, the professional technical staff, and Bill, if you mentioned the same thing, I really, I enjoy being able to engage with a group of smart people who are focused in and working issues and opportunities, and that's what makes, frankly, makes this, this opportunity to serve so rewarding in many ways. You're talking about my bartender again? Bill, we're not in Aspen.

2:24:02 And at this point, I think you're right, if staff has any comments you would like to make on this as well, I would love to hear their opinion. This is Sandra Moberly, sorry. So just a note, I do appreciate Mayor Sauser, you bringing up the fact that staff is, you know, it's our responsibility to bring information to you and, you know, recommendations.

2:24:29 And just a note to keep in mind, I guess, when we bring things forward to the council is that we make recommendations based on kind of our existing legal and policy framework. So we're really kind of looking at the existing general plan and all of our existing requirements as we make those recommendations to council. So if items are coming forward and the council has concerns or

2:24:53 Feels like it just is not in line with how the town is now. I think that's the time to step back and talk about do we need to change some of those recommendations, you know, the general plan or any of our other policies is does this just not meet our needs right now? And I think that's certainly a good spot for the council to kind of to say stop and let's talk more about this. So but I do appreciate being able to bring items to the council with our professional recommendations. Thanks, Sandra.

2:25:24 Thank you. I'll just add maybe one thing to that. The quality of life ordinance is a really good example, could be a very good example of that. Because it's policy, Sandra, correct me if I'm wrong, but that's policy that you guys are working under. But that space and that environment is changing so quickly that council might say, okay, well, this is consistent with the policy. Our role as council is to not go after the staff recommendation and say, whoops, we got to look at this policy. We got to review this thing and see where we're at.

2:25:52 Is that sound about right? So you guys are working consistent with the policies as directed? Right, right. The quality of life ordinances is an ordinance. And yeah, certainly that's an opportunity for the council to say, hey, this just doesn't kind of meet our needs anymore. And staff can you step back and look at that and bring something back to us. Yeah, okay, good. And I think just kind of to tag onto that, when we do get those comments or concerns about ordinances or policies, it's really helpful to really...

2:26:18 Get some good feedback from Council about what the issues are. Where are the problems? Where are the disconnects? And is there consensus on those disconnects? I mean, I think that's really helpful for us because then we can kind of go back and say, you know, there's consensus that this part of the policy or ordinance isn't working. We're going to bring that back to the Council. So, thank you. You know, so much of what a town does is prescribed.

2:26:45 There are things that just happen every year. There are certain benchmarks that have to be hit. So the space for innovation and brand new things is sometimes limited. And I would not expect anyone on Town Council to know what those things are that a town needs to do. Like every few years we do this, and then we have to do this, and it's required to the state, it's required to the feds. So I completely depend on the staff to do that.

2:27:14 There's no way that any of us would know that and they're left to us. It would, you know, be a dismal failure. So I think that, you know, a lot of that, but when we do a strategic plan and we identify some new initiatives and things and that, then I think that it's a shared piece. You know, we come up here and we do mission, you know, mission and we come up with all these great ideas and then the, you know, the administrator can sign and say, well, you really can't do that. Oh, you really can do that.

2:27:41 You know, that goes back and forth. You know, the mission is what we set, but then the actual implementation of it goes back to the other side. So, oh, excuse me, I'm just joking here. So, that's kind of, you know, this makes sense to me. Hopefully, we're doing close to this now. Well, I would also add, Sandra, while you gave good accounting, I would also hope that staff, the person experiencing, as well as adherence to the general plan or the quality of life,

2:28:13 And in the presentation brings that experience to that as well. Yeah, absolutely. I'd just like to make a couple of comments with regard to this. I mean, we all, when we're talking about roles and responsibilities and positions, it's helpful for me to consider the challenges that the council is facing in the position they have and the decisions that they have to make.

2:28:46 You know, satisfying constituents as well as listening to staff and that being that middle ground. So, you know, kind of understand then what challenges they face. And I guess I would ask that the same kind of process be used for staff and understanding, you know, the challenges we may have through our process of delivering what you guys need from us at these meetings and the most efficient way to do that. Those staff reports, you know, they're

2:29:15 They're difficult sometimes to put together, but how can we streamline that? How can we make that more efficient for you? But then just that level of understanding, it's always been helpful for me through that process. I certainly don't feel like there's a challenge among who's doing what in the process. I think it's just really understanding the challenges that each of those entities face will be beneficial. Very much so. Well said, Bob. Okay.

2:29:51 If I'm seeing nothing else on this, John. Mr. Mayor, just real quick, just, we're going to be having a new document public meeting platform, correct? For replacing Granicus? Yeah. Yeah, and I'm thinking, Sarah, back to your point about being able to link out agenda items and link out ideas and things like that. I think that, Rob, your point, that can start to kind of close the gap a little bit in terms of...

2:30:19 The staff report, how to make it more efficient. Because ultimately, if we can take things like that and send a link or get it to someone in the public to say, do you understand what this is and what's going on with this? That's a toolkit that I think we're all very much looking forward to getting our introduction to. And there may be some opportunities there to help with the kinds of things you're talking about to close that gap from understanding efficiency. Sorry to interrupt, Mr. Mayor. John, if I could just piggyback on that. I mean, it's, you know,

2:30:49 Staff is already doing that, right? They're giving us these agenda items and they're like giving a synopsis of what it is that's, you know, sort of idiot-proofed. And so I think, yeah, it's not a far leap to put it into a digestible format. Thank you. And I think when we first got Granicus, the search tool was amazing. You could find an agenda item.

2:31:16 It was a really great tool. It was relatively easy to send a link to a constituent for a staff agenda and say, here, take a look at this. Whatever's happened with Granicus, none of that capacity works anymore. I know. Right? But hopefully we go into this new thing, we can reuse that again, and that'll be great. Okay. So the second part of this conversation is the role of our NGOs.

2:31:53 And, John, you started this off there once. One of the questions that I would love to ask everybody is the frustration that I'm having with our NGOs is that they all want to be completely independent bodies working off the tax balance. And the fiduciary responsibilities that we have, I feel it's inappropriate just to give and say, here, go make housing. We don't know how they're doing it, but if they aren't tied to it, they aren't in our offices.

2:32:25 So for me, I would like to see sort of change in our NGOs and how we interact with them. And I would love to hear everyone's take on this. I think that MLT is certainly been successful with bringing customers here. But I think we caught them unawares when Dan had a meeting with them saying that it looked like council may want to institute some change. And I know some members of their board have reached out to you.

2:32:55 But I wonder if them and our other NGOs, John, you're asking, I'm trying not to work hard, were more tied to the council and the town and the staff, if that would have been foreseen earlier on. I have frustration with two of our NGOs in that I think they want to do things that are outside of what they were formed for, and the town wants to form them. And how do we get there?

2:33:24 Before I go on, I would love to hear from the rest of you on whether you think the end of your roles are still appropriate, whether we need to change them, or how you see us moving on. So let me, I'll kick this off a little bit. What I'm interested in as a council member on behalf of the council is to be able to, when council makes a policy decision,

2:33:50 That we may have an NGO or a contractor that's working in that space. That the council can have a reasonable level of confidence that when we look, we're changing a policy or this is what we have to do, that that gets articulated, obviously goes to our staff at the town, but it gets communicated and articulated to the NGO with an expectation that, hey, we're going over here now.

2:34:18 And we need to go over here, and this is why we need to go over here. And right now, that is so inefficient that I don't even know if the council can rely on that, which starts bringing up problems. Because then we start going to, well, if said, if NGO or capacity is not going to be aligned with council policy, it's not going to do the things we need it to do based on...

2:34:44 The council direction, the direction set by the council, then it comes down to, okay, we're going to cut your budget. And then it starts getting into this, well, okay, let's start fighting about money and turf and, you know, I hate you and you smell bad and all that kind of stuff. It just, it gets into a space that's just not, it's not productive. So we need to have at the high level, again, at this policy level, this understanding of

2:35:13 Hey, we need to go over here. The council's identified a policy objective. We need to get this done. And we need to understand with what level of efficiency, if we've got an NGO that's working in that space, that they're going to adapt, they're going to change, and they're going to be working as a team to achieve these types of objectives. And right now, it's beaucoup foggy at this point.

2:35:42 You know, I might add that there's a difference of perception, I think, between what the town has had in mind vis-a-vis its relationship with the NGOs and how some of them at least view their role vis-a-vis the town. I think that the town's perception has been, we're going to pay you to do certain things for us. It's a transactional relationship. We'll give you this many dollars. You do these things for us. And I think that's the right way to look at it. But I think that some of the NGOs...

2:36:11 are looking at it more as their mere existence benefits the town, so that the town should give them money just so they can continue to exist. And that's a fundamentally different way of looking at the relationship. And I think that that has led to some of the confusion about what it is that we're giving the money for, how much should we be giving them. And that's, I'm not sure how to reconcile that other than continuing to try to be clear with the NGOs.

2:36:38 What our view of their role is. And maybe I'm wrong. Maybe we do see it as, yes, their existence is good for the community, therefore we're going to pay them just so they can function. But I think that the council has previously said, no, we will contract with you to do certain things. We'll give you this many dollars to do those things. And other than that, you can do other things if you want to, but you need to find your own money for those things. Yeah, Andy, that's entirely consistent. I think that's a very good place to start.

2:37:07 I think, as you all know, I've run and managed an NGO, a nonprofit foundation in town, not a formal town NGO, but a nonprofit. And as we worked on our mission, the work that we were doing, there was a chorus in the town that would come up and say, we are not going to expend public money to support your organization. We will pay you for services, but we are not here to support your organization. And that was a consistent...

2:37:35 Refrain that I, the organization I work with heard for many, many years. That was fine. Everything we've done with the town is a contract for services. And I don't know, I hope it's worked out okay for everybody, but I think, Andy, the lines, I think in recent years, the expectation, at least for me as a council member, has been, okay, if it's foggy, where's the contract? Where's the scope of work? Where are the specific services that we're paying for? How much are we paying for it? And it's come back to that.

2:38:05 And I think that's fine. That's what contracts are for. I certainly defer to my fellow council members on this, but that's kind of where I'm at at this point. You know, when I first joined council, I didn't really understand how the NGOs worked. A lot of people came to me to tell me why a certain NGO had been created and what their purpose was and what their job was and seemed to feel that these entities

2:38:32 were rightfully situated to do this and it was the town's responsibility just to give them the money and that it wasn't really the town's responsibility to have that contractual relationship as Andy referred to where, yeah, I was used to, for example, so for Red Cross, I was on a Red Cross board and, you know, we needed certain things done and so we would then put an RFP out, people would answer back.

2:39:00 We would do a set of, you know, conditions of, you know, scope of work, you know, deliverables, and then write that contract. That's what I thought the NGOs were like, that they seemed to have a whole different thing like, well, we are set up to oversee R&U. Okay, you know, for example, which is just a very small example. And so I've had a hard time getting my head around our relationship ongoing with these NGOs.

2:39:29 And if we need to go back and sort of, you know, I mean, and then you get into the funding. So, you know, these things were voted into place with these stipulations in place. Therefore, the town just gives them money and they figure out what they're going to do with it. So it seems like these just need to be cleaned up. And, you know, I would like to understand better before we, how do I put this? In order to fix what is kind of a,

2:39:59 And Linda, I think you're hitting on a fundamental thing, which is we need to be reassessing the value of these things and be able to do it on a continual basis.

2:40:30 Because we need to go back to the taxpayers and say, look, we're doing this system in this way. It's bringing value. It's helping the town implement and get things done. And also, one final thing is, I think we have to, Linda, the council's got to, we have to do some work on our end. And rather than saying, well, we're going to start looking at the NGOs, we have to look at it from our side to say, what is it that we need, you know, from a delivery perspective.

2:41:00 So that we can be clear from where we're sitting at so that when we're engaging with services that we need, we know what we want. You know what I mean? So we're not going after an NGO. We're like, okay, maybe we have some problems here. We as the council of the town got to go back and say, what do we need out of these service delivery programs first? And then what is it that we want? And then it starts going back to an RFQ and RFP situation. Like, okay, we need these services. We've got this money. Let's see who can provide them.

2:41:31 For me, recently, it's come down to looking at them as you were talking sort of as businesses. But when you look at a business, what you're looking at is your return on investment. So, okay, we have an NGO that now does the allocations for R&U. Is it costing us more to do the allocations through an NGO than it would cost if we did it in-house? And once these things have been created, we have never gone back, as government tends not to do, to look at the effectiveness of these organizations.

2:42:01 In terms of what they deliver for the price they deliver it. That is one issue. When they were created, it was thought that, one, their staff would be less expensive than town staff because they don't have to go through all the same things that government employees have to go through. And frankly, that is not proven to be true. So one of the things that we need to look back on, they're going to be more nimble. They're going to be able to segue at the drop of a hat, which town can't do.

2:42:31 When we create a department, we fund that department in perpetuity, the money never goes back to its original purpose and we lose the ability to go there. So NGOs are really attractive in that sense for me as well. The other problem I have is that we created these NGOs and they each have their own individual boards that we have no say over except that we get a seat at each board and that they have to operate under the Brown Act and all of the rest of that.

2:43:00 But they become completely independent. And we say, you know, we want you to enhance recreation on all levels. And then they get to set how to do that and how to spend the town money. And they aren't tied to us or our priorities or our mission or our policies. So for me, it's how do we – because I like the nimble aspect. You know, MLT can spend money on a host program and if all of a sudden we're in the middle of some –

2:43:31 The thing that needs extra marketing, they can pull back some money from that and they can move it over much differently and quickly than a town can. That was probably a bad example. It's what came to my head. So for me, it's if we're going to continue to use the NGOs, one, are we getting our money's worth or can we do it better in-house? And two, how do we tie them to us? How do we create an umbilical cord so that our

2:44:00 Our mission and our policy is what they are driving and not their own goals and objectives because that's what we have the responsibility as council members to use taxpayer money in that way. It is not a nonprofit. I've run two nonprofits. I know how they exist and how they run. For me, and we sort of tried this with MLR. I'm going back to using specifics again, John, sorry.

2:44:29 If we could hire someone in the town that could be sort of a de facto executive director for that organization, now we've got an umbilical court. They're tied. And maybe we can get some use out of it. But one of the things we've never done, and I'll end with this, is with anything we've done, whether it's with our own staff or not, is taking that annual look to see if they're producing what it was our intentions were.

2:44:55 And if not, then how do we, as you said already, John, how do we move them into that direction? And with the NGOs, it proved to be not just problematic, but almost impossible. So I will end my diatribe at that for now. Bill, we have contracts, you know, and holding accountability, you know, that is...

2:45:20 That's the foundation of the relationship. So, and don't get me wrong, I recognize that historically we've had people vote, you know, to increase TOT or sales tax, whatever it happens to be, to fund these organizations. But those were not two-thirds votes. But I think council has been diligent in making sure that they follow through with, I will call them political commitments.

2:45:47 Maybe we need to go back, visit those again and look at, you know, the contractual relationship as to what, you know, are we getting what the voters voted for? Well, I want to clarify that because, correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't think any of the initiatives, whether they were 50 plus one initiatives or the two-thirds initiatives, identified funding of any particular organization, right? I mean, there were only

2:46:16 It was funding for specific goals and objectives and sort of higher level policy things, but I don't recall that any of those things were a vote by the public to fund an organization. I mean, correct me if I'm wrong. Yeah, that's what I thought too, John. And what I also have heard, and I think we just need to, you know, turn this rock over and be honest about it, is that the way those were set up was also an expression of distrust.

2:46:44 That the town had the ability to handle those funds appropriately. And that was, I heard that very strongly as, you know, as I've been on council that, well, you know, the town should be over, decide on RU, you know, they should do this and that. And so that's an artifact of how these NGOs came to be that really, Bill maybe is the only one that, you know, has, was involved in any of that. And Kirk, well, Kirk certainly, yes.

2:47:12 I had done. You know, I listened to these stories, and I check them out, and I talk about that, the political commitments that were made for certain amounts of money and put into these certain pots. So that's all, you know, wrapped up in this, too. Yeah, and I was sitting around, though, the Measure A stuff for the establishment of MLT. I mean, it was a pretty toxic, there was some, there was absolutely some distrust about the town and the town's intent. Right. Whether the town as an organization was prioritizing its interests over some larger

2:47:40 Interests of the community. That's a significant ingredient of how we got here, but perhaps there's a way to honor both things, to honor, to making sure that these things that the community, the town needs as being important get honored, but let's maybe get to a different system, a different way of delivering things so we can actually make true on those promises. And are those same reasons still here today?

2:48:10 Certainly, you know, recently we've had our press, once again, throw us under the bus so that citizens are distrusting what we do. And it's unfortunate. I think actually we've responded to that here as well. But I think it's time for us to go back and look at that. It is a funny thing. For me right now, it is not a trust issue. I think that this town has...

2:48:37 Come out of those years, and anybody who's paying attention should have much more trust for what STEM is doing. But frankly, I don't want to keep throwing good money on bad to hold up organizations that are not tied to us as well as I think they should be. I can't put it any plainer than that. Yeah, but I think also, I mean, there are a number of advocates or folks on this council that started out as advocates for something.

2:49:07 Absolutely. And we need to remind ourselves that just because we're here on this nice little Zoom webinar that, you know, we've been on the other side of a lot of those discussions. And with those kinds of things in mind, perhaps we can proceed. But I think that there's an enormous inefficiency going on right now that we need to figure out how to address.

2:49:30 I will at the risk of ignoring my own advice, I will not repeat any of the things that you all have said, but it sounds like everyone kind of has the same temperature on this. I was under the same impression that these NGOs were created, you know, because they would be cheaper and more efficient and more able to pivot. And it's really hard for me to see.

2:49:54 The town or the chamber hiring a position that one of the NGOs is supposed to be filling. When I started to watch that starting to happen, I think that was kind of my moment where I was like, we need to examine all this. So at the risk of, again, what you all said, I think I'm in agreement and clearly.

2:50:24 Seems like everyone else is. Yeah, no, we need to hear your voice. We need to hear everybody's voice on these things. Hopefully we're not just grandstanding, but we need to, it's part of understanding consensus and where people are at. So thanks a lot, sir. And it's an important conversation. It doesn't get solved here. Right. This is just a, John, as you said earlier, this is a chance for us to speak as individuals and not be voting on something as a council. If we can, real quick, kind of bring it back to what we're looking at there. As we look at the,

2:51:01 Structure that, you know, we work under with the council and town staff, the NGO model kind of falls into this gray area. There is some mission and policy related from the council. It's expressed in the contractual relationship. But we don't have any authority over the actual administrative staff other than what the various existing boards provide. And again, ideally, you know, we should have a say in that because we do have individual council members sitting on those boards.

2:51:31 And how we either provide direction or get input back, an area that can probably be strengthened in how we do those things. But that direction then goes that way. The staff is often kind of that one foot in, one foot out of looking at their contract. Hey, we'd really like you to do this. Here's our expectations. But really no authority to go back in and say, hey, you haven't accomplished these areas. And at this point, there's not a lot of...

2:51:58 You know, consequences in those areas. So it kind of breaks the model. I think we counseled previously and did that on purpose. They wanted a different model for service delivery. And so it kind of falls out of this mission policy administration management model here, and it shifts over to a hybrid element. So I know at times there's a sense of frustration on both sides of the table, frankly, on.

2:52:24 That control or authority or who do I report to from either a board standpoint or an employee standpoint. You know, if that employee is reporting to that. I'll just interrupt real quick. I mean, the only default mechanism the council has is money. Yeah. There's got to be something in between, hey, look, we're not on the same page or two, we're going to cancel your contract. We got to, there's got to be something in between. Maybe there's not.

2:52:53 But it's a sort of Damocles situation. I think we can do a lot better than that. Sorry to interrupt. No, that's great. No, I think you're exactly right. It's that element. And in some cases, if the NGO boards really want to do something different and they want to be, I guess, more separate from the town, they have the option to go do that. But then the contractual relationship and dollars don't necessarily follow that movement. Those types of issues. And there's a lot of pushback on.

2:53:22 You know, we don't like following the Brown Act. We don't like having proper agendas. It's painful or it's a little overwhelming. Well, to do that means there's a bifurcation in that process that needs to happen. And there's another element here that I became aware of a few years ago, and that's the effect of having wholly independent NGOs on our own town's staff and their vision of it and the morale.

2:53:52 Issues that it may or may not cause. I don't want to get too far down that rabbit hole, but I have had some discussions with some people, and it's something that I don't think was considered up front, and we have developed an excellent staff at this point, in my mind, to make this degree, and I would like to keep them and keep us all moving forward. That's why I say it's the NCO that needs to be moving forward with us as a whole, not as completely separate, which I've already said.

2:54:22 Sorry, Cheryl. It's not avoidable sometimes. There's another piece of this, too, and I think that is the failure of the town to have controlled by contractual methods the behavior of the NGOs. You know, I think we were naive perhaps when we walked into this and when we wrote these contracts, you know, we pretty much didn't look at the power that the town really had to control that funding and the behavior.

2:54:55 of the NGO. And so as a result of that, we have, you know, perhaps some NGOs who have lost sight of their relationship with the town and have moved into another sphere. And I think it's time to kind of re-establish what the relationship is. And as we said, that that one piece is pretty much in the contract. If you don't like what the NGO is doing, then

2:55:23 The next contract renewal, that's where you have a chance then to redefine the role of the town to that NGO and that it is a contractual relationship. If I could chime in here, what's really tough is once you've given something, once you've created something, organizations have a great way of making sure that they

2:55:49 Build themselves and if they keep themselves fed. And so once you've built something, it's hard to take it away, right? So like we talked about the child tax credit and all these people are going to get this child tax credit and it's going to be really hard to say, no, you can't have that anymore. And I think we're absolutely going to run into if we say, no, you can't have that anymore.

2:56:18 The Chia Pet is growing and has grown. And I think we're going to run into a lot of pushback because there are a lot of people in this community who serve on those boards, are really invested in making sure that those employees are going to stay paid at the same level, at the comforts that they're used to. And so I just want to be doom and gloom here and say that

2:56:48 I anticipate, depending on what kind of happens, a lot of pushback because these organizations are literally paying people's rent and feeding them, and it's a scary thought to think that that might be curtailed or taken away from anyone. That's an excellent observation. It's very important. But I think just saying to all of us, welcome to leadership. I mean, this is, you know, that's, this lands on our

2:57:17 Our dais, our desks, our Zoom meetings, but this is, yeah, that's the space for it. It's a responsibility. At some point, do we just look at what they're providing and send out an RFP to see what it would cost in another format? Without saying, we're going to go there. You know, putting out an RFP does cost a lot of staff time involved and everything else is. Our staff is already burnt, but at some point, we have to look at how we provide services.

2:57:47 And how do we best do that for the money we have in the office? Especially considering how many organizations can work remotely and are streamlined in doing exactly what a lot of these organizations are using office space to do and et cetera. It's a new world out there. Big time. And I'm an old man. That makes it tough. This is shaking your head at you.

2:58:20 Just keep learning. Just keep learning. We're all going to be fine. Just keep learning. All right. Yeah. Well, if I could kind of bring us back in. We've been at this a little after four now. So good discussion. I think it sounds like there's more others to do. We're working through deliverables and contracts with our NGOs at this point in time. So it's a good time to have that dialogue and discussion. You know, ultimately we need to do.

2:58:45 I'll say joint meetings with the various boards for the NGOs, and it's a good opportunity to have an honest, straightforward, open dialogue about expectations and roles and very similar discussion here today with the council. If there's not an additional discussion on that, I wanted to touch on one more item and kind of setting up for the next meeting, which is two weeks out to the 30th, and that's just kind of doing a brief review of

2:59:17 Really getting down more to the nuts and bolts in the next two sessions with our policy setting. But before we go there, if there's any other comments related to kind of the discussion here with the council that you wish to bring forward or comments that way. And again, I would open up the staff as well if there's comments prior to looking at kind of a little preview of where we need to go next. Bill, if I might make a comment, I mean...

2:59:45 When this process comes to an end and everything and it'll come back to budgeting and shifting perhaps budget and everything else, then perhaps we need to go back out and ask a public vote, 50 percent, on what's happened. I feel a little uncomfortable because I have adhered to

3:00:08 I'm not quite following you on that one, but we can talk about it later. Those are advisory votes. There's no two-thirds votes out there. So, you know, to go out with another advisory vote, if we wanted to shift money or keep it there, I mean, if the

3:00:40 If the council wants to shift money, you know, I still have a respect for what the people have voted for, you know, historically. And so putting together a package that shifts dollars one place or the other, I don't have a problem with that. But I would like to at least take it out to the community. If we have a 5-0 council that agrees that we need to reallocate budget funds.

3:01:08 You know, and not be locked into some historical commitments, then I think that would be appropriate. I would say that the NGOs were never an appropriate, were never a political commitment. And as it has been necessary, measure A certainly has been reallocated over what the original political commitment was. I think that as five council members, we represent the will of the town.

3:01:35 And for things like just moving these around, I don't think it's necessary to go to a boat and would be very nervous on allowing the public to weigh back in on whether or not we should be collecting those taxes at this point in time. Anyway, Dan, as you said, I would like to also, if staff would like to chime in on any of this, this would be the appropriate time. Grady, Sandra, Rob? I'm here.

3:02:12 No, I appreciate the conversation, particularly about the condition of the NGO model and how that goes out there. It's very challenging from a staff perspective at times. We do, you know, our responsibility on any contract is to, you know, be very fiscally responsible about those and sometimes that's a challenge. But I do like the dialogue that I've heard. It is a fundamentally difficult.

3:02:41 circumstance when you have these independent boards who they, you know, they're independent and the harder that the town pushes on direction, the harder that they establish their independence or want to talk about their independence. So it's a process that needs to be solved. I don't have the solutions for that, but I'm glad to hear the thoughts and comments of the council. Rob, any other staff who should chime in? Don't say we didn't give you an opportunity.

3:03:18 Thank you. If I can kind of highlight, I think a couple, as we look at the next couple of meetings, the focus will kind of shift to some degree. I think this dialogue has been helpful, hopefully to the council as well, but from the staff side, just understanding perspectives and where people are coming from, understanding the kind of the values and the key elements to look at. As we move forward, kind of look at pages 63 in your packet, 60.

3:03:48 62, 63, 64. As we talked about at the beginning, I think, and it seemed like there was somewhat of a consensus to really work and see how do we come back kind of with the one page. Maybe it ends up being a two-page document. But looking at those priorities in terms of, I'll say nearer term strategic priorities, we generally look at 18 months to two years, but often, you know, having that one-year checkup or a more regular checkup is always a healthy thing.

3:04:15 The elements we'd like to make sure we look at then as a format, but also to take a hard look, we'd encourage council to work through this prior to the next meeting, is looking at how this is laid out in the comments there, but also the information provided on the accomplishment side. If you look at the number of items that were identified, at some level, I believe every one of these have had actions taken to implement them. Some of them are broad enough that

3:04:45 And then looking at the other element we've added in here is a lot of stuff that

3:05:14 We're still working on in these areas. Take a look at that. Some of those areas that we identify, let's throw them out or no, that's a great one. Let's make sure that one continues to move forward, those types of issues. So some things are complete, other things are still underway. The other side of this is in the current document, the top of the page there, we have what we call a short-term vision.

3:05:40 Currently, that's focused on achieving sustainable economic security for the community. That really related back a couple of sessions ago and tied into a lot of the focus on the economic viability and focused in those areas. And the question is, from a shorter-term vision looking out those couple of years, does that capture where we're still heading or is it shifted somewhat in that statement, that type of discussion on the front end and then?

3:06:10 Once you walk through the strategic priorities, looking at those and going back and say, if all of those things happen, do we believe we're moving toward that short-term vision as well as the long-term vision as stated in the general plan statement that's been part of the document at this point in time. But if that process works, the idea would be to dive into that in the next meeting, start to work through this stuff.

3:06:35 Let it digest, come back again before final recommendations are put together, then ultimately back to a council and a formal council meeting for, again, consideration, additional modification and or approval, and that kind of sets us moving forward in that way. Unless there's particular questions in that, I'd be glad to address those or touch on items as we begin to look to that type of a process. If it doesn't work, say so now so we can adjust accordingly. John, go ahead.

3:07:08 Yeah, so I think, Dan, the first, all of us, first two sessions, great dialogue, good conversation, good to get a sense of kind of where we're at, what's going on. We're moving now into a couple of meetings that are going to require some document management. And I think we need, I'm looking at these documents and I'm getting a little nervous because I think we need to be very clear as to, you know, what is on the list,

3:07:37 What's, you know, what has been accomplished, what has not been accomplished, what's in play, what's got a question mark, what might be a new idea, and I want to make real sure that we don't go into these next two meetings to start tripping over our own process at this point, so I'm throwing out that caution. Dan, like, I don't know, like, this document I'm looking at, it's not dated, I don't know, do you want feedback on this, or how do you want to, how do we want to start?

3:08:04 I guess I looked at Bill a little bit on this as the mayor just to make sure we don't, you know, let's make sure we keep this good work going forward and we don't start tripping over ourselves so we get into the actual documents. We certainly don't want to plan, John. You're absolutely right. We are making good progress. Real quick, there's an animal in Lynda's house. Is that okay? Yeah. Okay. It's fine. As long as it's fair. It's very, it's very tame. It's fine.

3:08:35 You talking about Greg? I've never known him to be taped. Never, never. Yeah, a cleanup of some of these is good and probably start the next meeting off is going to be two weeks between meetings at this point for this type of meeting with an overview of the last. You're on mute, Bill. You muted yourself. I never touched it, I promise.

3:09:17 So, John, two weeks before the next meeting, I don't know how much you heard and what you didn't. We'll start off with this document, which is our last one, and what we've accomplished and how it's been accomplished to make sure we're all on the same page. And then go through point by point, are these still our priorities? Do we need to change them? Probably, and Dan and I talked about this earlier, we were going to deal with this some today. Our short-term vision last time...

3:09:45 Was achieving sustainable economic security for the community. So is that still our short-term vision? Or do we need to change that now to change the focus of what the next couple of meetings are going to be? Okay, one thing. And I would just point out also that, Dan, the color copier, the color copies we get, they're just not good. So maybe if we do need to have things that are in color that need to be legible, just, you know, things like that, just to make sure that we've all got the tools.

3:10:16 Yeah, there were some problems with the last documents as well. So we do need to look at that. So what do you think about that short-term vision? You want to talk about that now or no? Yeah, I would love to talk about it now because it helps us form the working agenda for moving forward. Unless you feel differently, Dan?

3:10:40 We can dive in a little bit of that as long as you still have enough energy at the council level. I've been at this for over three hours, so just want to be mindful of comments earlier on the length of meeting and ability to get a little bit of discussion on this. I wouldn't want to finalize it this evening. I just think we want to have questions, but some comments to that would be maybe helpful as we begin to look. So my thought on the short-term vision is our emergence from COVID and our...

3:11:08 Trying to, you know, that might take a while. I don't know how long it's going to take. I think our first priority is to come out of this and get back to some kind of a situation where I think the council feels like, okay, we've dealt with the traumas, we've filled the gaps, we've dealt with the holes, staff as whole communities, basically on some kind of terra firma. But for me, short term is getting out of that. I have no idea how long that's going to take. I guess maybe

3:11:37 A benchmark is the schools are all open next fall. Everybody's back in school. I don't know. I don't know what that is, but because I don't know what that is, that's an uncertainty that I think we would be well advised to make that a priority for a short term. Yeah, I would maybe, I mean, certainly that is, but, you know, the benchmarks of recovery include things like schools being open.

3:12:11 Events being able to be open, short-term rental is, I mean, the lodging industry, the restaurant industries have indicated that they're fully recovered. I mean, there's a lot of benchmarks we could develop or we could, you know, kind of do a global, you know, short-term vision, which is that, all the COVID recovery, but then some sort of measurements under that.

3:12:37 I don't think that's a bad idea because it is still informing what we do. It's informing how we're moving forward. It's still pivotal to business recovery. So I see that it's being woven into that for sure. I like, Lynda, those ideas on those benchmarks, like look at all our various sectors and saying, just check in with everybody. Yeah, keep in mind, I don't mind having you out there as...

3:13:06 That is something definitely that we're looking at as we walk through these issues. A lot of those things, it's back to that, that's great, but you're not in control of that necessarily. So if you're trying to get that into a council vision statement or a directional statement, we can definitely do some work on that. But is the elements that you're going to want us to work on, how are they going to achieve that?

3:13:33 A lot of those things, we have little or no control over school opening. So we can sit there and say, yes, we want that to happen, but it's not an action the town's going to take to open the school. So I understand the recognition. It's almost like is how do we come out of an effective recovery from the COVID-19 pandemic?

3:13:59 And that is a statement that we can look at, and we start to define that recovery in the key objectives of town controls. As we look at, you know, housing, we look at the workforce, we look at our health of our business community, we begin to look at all those things that would measure against that goal or that short-term perspective, vision that the council is looking to achieve. If it's too broad out there that we don't control, we can lay all that out there because I understand that's an underlying

3:14:29 Concern on all of this stuff. Are we out of it? Are we not out of it? I don't know, Dan, because while a lot of it is out of our control, there are certainly actions we can take to expedite that recovery or to support that recovery. And I don't think we can not include that because there are, like, for example, are we going to continue to let restaurants double up some parking to do outdoor dining? I mean,

3:14:59 That's certainly an action we can take to help recovery of restaurants. So there's a few, you know, I think might be worth some time to talk about that. Real quick, sorry, Bill, I like that, that could actually be one of our strategic priorities. And then underneath that you have those, but that's not the overall short-term vision. But it would be actions we take to help implement recovery out of COVID, if that's one of the priorities we want to set.

3:15:28 If you wanted to use those in your short-term vision, you would probably just say something more like focus on achieving sustainable social and economic stability. Because you're not defining, you define how you're doing that in your priority statement under that, right? That just drives our statement. Yeah, we can work that. But we can't skip this step. If we skip this exit from COVID,

3:15:57 You know, you can't, you can't, you can't do that. Right. So that becomes one of our four or five points under that one sentence short-term business. And here's what we're going to do. Yeah. Yeah. We have to have an exit plan. What happens to focus partially defines our budget process. Where does the money go and how to get there? I don't have anything else. I mean, this may be sort of a primer, but I think it'd be helpful to start getting the,

3:16:36 The toolkit, Dan, that you want us to work from so we can, like, look at it in advance and kind of come prepared and be ready to go. That'll be helpful. And who knows? In two weeks. Yeah. Hopefully I'll have a better chance. It'll be nice enough at the lake to sit out. It'll give us something to look forward to. Thank you, Bill. Great. We can all come down at this camp. Next week's opening day, so all right. Yeah, well, I think we can patch some of this up and kind of have it as a separate.

3:17:14 Section to look at and talk about some of those underlying pinnings that we have to keep in mind. I think how we exit out of COVID is definitely on people's mind and elements to do with that. And then what we've succeeded at where we haven't succeeded in some areas or we're still not there yet and a lot of things underway that gain success in some areas. And so, you know, these were adopted back in December of 2018. So it's been a bit.

3:17:44 And then we tried to look at the next couple of pages in the document. We were trying to highlight the key successes under each of those categories. And then there's kind of a staff work program that's been in place. A lot of that is ongoing. Some of it is completed. So getting a good handle on those things. We'll package that up a little more succinctly or so it's more focused and easier to read. And I think the notes, the cleanup of the notes from the first meeting.

3:18:12 You may, you can probably take the notes of this meeting and combine that in there maybe, but that's, here's our conversation, that's kind of what we did, let's check on that, make sure we're on the same page with that, and then, then start with our tools, let's launch fully into what's, what the short-term, medium, long-term, I'm really looking forward to doing that, but it's a big iceberg, there's just a little tip today, because it's Friday at 4.30, and, you know, just saying.

3:18:41 Is it really? Oh, yeah, it is. Just saying. Just saying. And what does Friday mean to you guys? For me and my job, the weekend has never been any different than the midweek. I'm right there with you, Bill. I'm looking forward to getting my weekend of work underway. Yeah. Yeah. I got to go. I got to go get vaccine tomorrow. We got to get more people. Right. Bridgeport tomorrow. So that's what I got to go do. So, yeah, I don't think we need to stay here until 5 if we all feel happy.

3:19:12 I think we're pretty much good. Yeah, thank you. I think it's been productive for at least more perspective and pulling items out and getting a better understanding of how council thinks and views and operates and their relationship building is a key element of this process. Great. Thanks, everyone. Andy, any closing remarks? He turned his video back on, so. Just turned my camera on so I could wave at people.

3:19:44 And we're going to wave back. You saw five fingers, Andy. It's important. All right. Children, we will see you later. Bye. Thank you. Bye, colleagues. Bye, everybody. Thank you. Thank you. Okay. Here we are.