Town Council
· recording 4 hr 10 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
492 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:31 Thank you. You boys are all wearing vesties. I didn't get the call to put on my vest before the meeting. I'm sorry, what? I said you boys are all wearing vests. Well, the weather's a little cuspy today. Yeah, well, I didn't get my notice. I could have put one on. Well, just, yeah, keep your camera on. You can, you know, change out and do what you gotta do. Yeah.
1:50 Hi, Bill. I'm in the council chamber. I just wanted to get out of the house. Thank you, Kirk. Where is the lovely Linda? I got the club open finally. Yeah. Thank you, too. Yeah. So. Okay. We are all present and accounted for. So I will open this council meeting of Wednesday, April 21st. It is 4.01. Roll call, please. Councilmember Rae? Here. Councilmember Staff? Here.
2:39 Councilmember Whitworth. Present. Mayor Pro Tem, Salcido. Mayor Souser. Here. We are all present and accounted for. Pledge of Allegiance. Rob will lead us on the pledge tonight. Join me in the pledge. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
3:19 Public comment. This is the time any member of the public wishing to comment on anything that is not otherwise on the agenda. Also, if you are making comments on the mandatory part, now would be the time for that as it does not appear anywhere else on the agenda. Public comments, Jamie. Doug Gans, can you please unmute yourself and give your comments? Hello, how are you doing today? Can you guys hear me right now? Yeah. Great.
3:57 I want to thank you to the council members and the mayor for giving me just two minutes to introduce myself and really ask us a couple of basic questions. First of all, my name is Doug Gans and I'm one of the two owners of Mammoth Holistics on 101 Old Mammoth Road. It's one of the cannabis dispensaries that you guys, I worked with you guys to get approved and we opened, I guess, probably around five months ago and I want to thank you for that and also let you know how much I love Mammoth. I really enjoyed it.
4:27 Big part of your community. I bought a home here, and I'm part-time, back and forth here in San Diego, but I want to thank you guys for that. My question, and again, I really want to talk to Michael today and a couple other people in the town, and I wanted to know how to kind of get, or even if I could get something up on the agenda down the road, and really it's three things in regards to our cannabis dispensary, which I think would work for the other ones too. One of them, as you guys probably know,
4:55 The state hours for cannabis is 6 a.m. to 10 p.m. That's what the state approved. In Mammoth, it's 9 to 9. And my hope would be that the 9 o'clock at night, that's fine. My hope would be open a little earlier. We have so many people that come in, really skiers and, you know, it's really people that are going outside and want to get out early. And in a lot of cases, we're skiing, you know, with the CTA and products like that. So that's something I would love to be able to get an agenda to look at. That's one of them.
5:25 The other one, another one is in regards to the age limit. In California, it's 18, 19, to 20 if you have a medical recreation card. Mammoth, it's just 21 and up. And what I'm finding out the more that I've been here and talking to people is that there's a ton of 18, 19, 20-year-olds that use cannabis, whether it's for medicinal reasons or for pleasure. And what they're doing is they're buying it, quite honestly, illegally.
5:54 With products with our dispenser, everything has to be tested. You know, it's all this strict criteria of the state. And I worry that the 18, 19, 20-year-olds, what they're doing is they're buying illegal cannabis along with other products. It's not safe for them. It's not tested. And quite honestly, you know, the town of Mammoth loses out on taxes. And then the third item, and this is kind of more a long shot. This is something I'm starting to see a lot in California.
6:23 Is people are opening up, really in tourist areas, they're next to a dispenser, they're having lounges. And the lounges really, obviously for the main purpose for tourist areas, you can't smoke anything at all in a home, in a hotel, any place like that. So we have right across the 101 Mammoth, we have an unrented, one of our places we have rented. And that's where, if we are able to do it, that's where we would love to put something in there.
6:52 Again, I know that I still have to get permission from the state. That's a long process. It's really all those things are different. But I guess the one right away I'd love to get an agenda would be trying to open a little earlier. So again, I appreciate you guys' time. I don't know if there's any questions you have for me. Any questions? Making those changes in my estimation at this point would require that we actually change our ordinances. So it would be more than just putting it on the agenda.
7:25 So if I were you, I would talk to Sandra Moberly and or the Town Manager, Dan Holler, to see what it would take to start that process. Okay, that'd be great. I'll send Sandra and Dan, I'll send an email and just get the conversation going. I don't want to do anything, obviously, that Mammoth isn't for. So I just want to really, for the most part, introduce myself and really thank you for letting me be part of your communities. I'm loving it. Yeah, thank you.
7:55 Thank you. What's your comment? Kathy Cage, would you please unmute yourself and give your comments? Sure. Good evening, Council. I wanted to request a future agenda item for a discussion, a policy discussion of a particular item that has come to my attention and is an area of concern. And here's the public policy question. Should public employees be permitted to put political symbols or stickers on public vehicles?
8:26 So that's the public policy question. The reason this came up for me recently, it's something I've kind of been stewing about for a little bit, and it has to do with the thin blue line stickers on the police vehicles, frankly. I had some recent visitors from Arizona, you know, they kind of made a comment, said, oh, gee, you know, when do we get to Idaho here? And it had a very, you know, it had a very political effect on them.
8:52 Observing that sticker. And then the other kind of motivating factor was a really cool documentary this week on HBO called Our Towns. And it's about these kind of smaller towns that are doing some great stuff, you know, remaking themselves after economic downturns and that sort of thing. And I'm going to read a quote from one of the economic development directors. It's from a place called Columbus, Missouri.
9:14 Where they struggle with what to do with the Confederate flags, you know, something that's a combination of a heritage symbol, but also has some very politically charged connotations to it. Here's his quote. It says, I understand heritage, I understand culture, but if you may offend somebody that might want to invest here or create jobs here, why would you do that? So I'm just asking for an opportunity to present some arguments to the council.
9:42 To consider having those thin blue line stickers removed from the police vehicles. I'd like to be able to convince you they're political symbols. And frankly, I personally don't think they have any place on public vehicles, which should be apolitical. So that's my request. Thank you. Kathy? Any comments? Counsel? Yeah, I'd like to comment. Kathy's not the first one of our constituents that has brought that up, and I would love to see that item agendized.
10:13 Thank you, Sarah. Any other comments? I'd support that as well if support is needed. Thank you, John. Moving forward, Jamie, any further public comments? Tom Parker, would you please unmute yourself and give your comments? Thank you. I wanted to comment on the Community Recreation Center. I know that there's going to be a report on that early here in the meeting.
10:50 I've been a resident here for just over a couple of years, privileged to work here at Mammoth Hospital, and one of the things that I really look forward to is hosting family here, especially during the summer months, so I was very sad to see that the Mammoth Creek Park playground had been closed in order to accommodate construction of the CRC.
11:17 I'll just say I haven't tried Shady Rest again this year. We tried that last year. And of course, you know, there's new enforcement of ordinance with respect to cleaning up after dogs. But our experience with Shady Rest was that it was a one and done and we had no desire to go back there. The closure of this park certainly is disappointing. And I saw there was
11:46 Some explanation, there was a Mammoth Times post with respect to the need to provide for public safety and the construction being very close to the park, specifically the playground. I just wondered if folks working on that project had looked at means by which construction could have occurred adjacent to the playground.
12:16 In tighter municipal situations, you know, in urban areas where large glass and steel structures are put up right next to pedestrian walkways, and they accommodate that through, you know, a number of safety measures. I have no doubt that there's costs involved in that, but my...
12:36 Curiosity was whether or not there were options explored that would have allowed the playground to stay open through the summer. And I know this is public comment, it's not public discussion, so that is my comment, and I appreciate you listening today. Thank you. Thank you, Tom. Jamie? Sandy, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hello. Yeah, my name is Phil Aberle. I'm 81 years old.
13:18 Been around Mammoth for a little over 70 years. Observed a lot of things over the years. The first comment is regarding the gold mine potential drilling sites. I'm opposed to it. I think back over the years, the opposition presented by some prominent families and individuals in late 60s, early 70s, prevent the Trans-Sierra Highway. I imagine if that would have been completed.
13:52 Back, I remember a prominent businessman from Crowley Lake, well known to the community, along with others, and he was a county supervisor at the time, who put a halt to a casino being built on the Benton Highway, east of the Green Church. I've been around out in the area where those drilling sites are as a young boy with my dad fishing on parts of Hot Creek and as a young man hunting and fishing myself.
14:23 I'm opposed to it. I just wish the town, and particularly our mayor, whose family's been around this town for many years, would have cherished Mammoth Creek more. There was another location that put the CRC behind the bowling alley. We're so fortunate to have a stream run through that beautiful park in that area. My wife and I walk there all the time, and it's kind of disheartening to see the trees being ripped out, pavement going to go in.
14:57 And a huge white tent. I hope in the future, the younger people, I wish I would have been more involved over the years, but I guess as you age, I never consider myself lazy, but I never thought I'd see the day when someone would do something to that beautiful part of this community. That's my comment. Nothing can be done now. The screws have been turned. But in the future, the younger people in our community speak up. If it's wrong, say so. You know when it's wrong.
15:28 That's my comment. Thank you. Thank you. Jamie. There are no further public comments. Okay. Or there are in Sweet Z. No comment. No answer. My name is Tracy. I live in Old Mammoth. I've lived in Mammoth since 1995. I'm here for a couple different things. Heavily opposed to the gold mine proposed.
16:04 Whatever we can do to assist that in not happening. I have to agree with the last speaker that the location and tearing up Mammoth Creek Park appalling and the location behind the bowling alley way more ideal, a much better location. It's really heartbreaking to see such a continued.
16:31 The most beautiful areas of town completely destroyed with little thought to alternatives. Also, I was informed by my neighbor today that there was going to be a representative from Suddenlink participating in this meeting. I have to say that 20 years ago when I had dial up, my service was...
16:52 And I would really ask that we
17:21 Do something with the service in the community, not only for our guests, but for the businesses and people and schools that are here. Please know that our service is incredibly bad, incredibly bad, and it has not improved in the last two weeks or two months, in my opinion. Thank you. Thank you. Any further comments? One more.
17:57 Councilmembers, Mr. Mayor, Jeff Posey here, hopefully speaking for my very last time. I have heard of a few things going on about the CRC for social media. Everyone's up in arms about it. And there's a lot of misinformation out there, like why the spot was chosen. And the reason why I know about all this is because I attended hundreds of hours of meetings and was told.
18:25 The proper information from the powers that be. The bowling alley is not an option. As far as service land, they don't own it. They can't do it. So that's just not an option. And I also want to say that my kids played in that park growing up as every single one of them. It used to be the blue park before it became the ADA park, whatever it is now. And I'm sorry it's closed, but there are other options.
18:50 I mean, I just can't see anyone really complaining about giving a little to get a $15 million recreation facility that all the kids and all the community members are going to enjoy. So I think it's great. It's been a long time. Thank you very much for all your hard work. I know I'm over it, but you guys have been putting in all the time, and it's going to be an awesome facility. I'm pretty stoked. Thank you. Thank you, Jeff. Any further comments, Jim? Sophie, please unmute yourself and give your comments.
19:25 Hi. I'm a somewhat new resident to Mammoth, but I've been visiting the area for about seven years, and I am, as well, heavily opposed to this coal mine, especially if it's planning on continuing without a thorough environmental impact report, because it will absolutely heavily affect the environment that it's in, possibly poisoning the water in Hot Creek.
19:52 Continuing all the way to Crowley Lake, which is also where LA gets their water from. It would destroy the tourism in the area, the fishing, Hot Creek fish hajury, the ranch, just the wilderness in itself. And they're possibly going to create an open pit mine, which is one of the most destructive things on the planet, according to many, many environmental sources.
20:18 I've read that there's a possibility of this continuing without an environmental impact report, and I think that is absolutely absurd, especially considering the times that we're in and the awareness of how things affect the environment. And, yeah, I would just like to say that we absolutely need to have a thorough environmental impact report before anything can continue. Thank you. Thank you, Sophie. Any further public comments? Noreen, please unmute yourself and give your comments.
20:56 Good early evening, everybody. My name is Noreen Wilbur. I've lived in Mammoth since 1990, worked in the community, myself and my husband, and raised two daughters who have returned to the community as professionals to contribute to the community. I'm speaking on behalf of myself and my family.
21:23 Regarding the core exploratory gold exploration. Myself and my family are opposed to it. The potential for toxic substances close to town, destroying an area, or I shouldn't say destroying, but disturbing an area that
21:51 May have had some other things going on in the past, but it's basically been restored. And again, the biggest objection is it's so close to the community, which could have potential impacts on our health, our safety, visitation to the community, impacts to the water table, etc. They go on and on.
22:19 I know that it's something that happens in the mountains, but we want to keep our community as safe as we can. Thank you for your time. Virginia, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Good afternoon. I'm Virginia Chadwick. I'm a volunteer for the...
22:49 California Department of Fish and Wildlife and since 2013 I have worked with them every year in the spring to collar deer and the interruption of migratory pathways for these animals would be fatal. In 2017 on Bishop Pass the
23:14 Animals followed their instinct and they slid on an ice field and over a hundred of them died. So when we call her deer, we call her everywhere from Goodale Creek, out Round Valley, out to Yellow Jacket Road and on into Nevada. And so having this core mine in the area would absolutely upset the deer migration and could be the end of hunting.
23:44 in this area. Also in the area are sage-grouse, and they are slowly diminishing in populations and will probably soon have to be listed for endangered species because of not being able to keep the promises that were made during the early Obama administration. So I followed my other
24:14 Commenters on refusing to have the core mine and they must have an environmental impact statement before they start any procedures out there. Thank you. Chris, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hi, this is Chris Bubser, but before I go on, am I in the right place in the agenda to be commenting on Lynn Bolton from the Sierra Club's letter or should I wait?
24:49 No, this is the right place. We do not have that on the agenda tonight. Okay, got you. Thank you so much. So I just wanted to, again, propose the core mining exploration near Hot Creek. This has the potential to have major impacts on human health because of the drilling that could hit our geothermal water supply.
25:15 To wildlife, especially sage grouse and the other things that other people have already mentioned. And as importantly, our recreation economy. I know that there are many people who are in our fly fishing communities in particular who are terribly concerned. So I hope that the town council will oppose this as strongly as possible so we don't end up with years and years of fighting like we had in the past with royal gold. And I have a question.
25:45 Lynn Bolton wants to comment, but she had to dial in on a telephone, and I didn't know. There's no raised hand on the telephone. What does she press? I'll allow her to speak when it's her turn. Okay, but she doesn't know how to indicate that. Oh, you have her? You know who it is? Okay, thank you. I can see the number on there, yeah. Gotcha. Thank you very much. Thanks for your time. Thank you, Chris. Jamie? Claire, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hi.
26:19 Hi, I'm Claire. I don't live in Mammoth. I actually live in Lone Pine, but I wanted to make a comment anyway. Not sure if that's cool. Just to build on what everyone else is saying, I think the mining is just a really, really bad idea. Even with an environmental impact statement, I just can't support it. We've seen what mining has done to the environment.
26:47 We have also seen that despite reclamation bonds, a lot of the communities can't recoup or can't pay to restore that land or make that land better, make it do all the cleanup. So yeah, I just really can't support it. I just wanted to throw that out there. Thank you all for listening. Thank you, Claire. Jamie.
27:17 Wendy, will you please unmute yourself and give your comments? Yes, my name is Wendy Schneider. I am Executive Director of Friends of the Inyo, and I am also making comment to encourage this Town Council to engage regarding the proposal, the core mining exploration proposal, and oppose the approval of this proposal as strongly as possible for all of the reasons that have been given here tonight. Thanks so much. Thank you, Wendy. Jamie? Lynn?
27:49 Will you please unmute yourself and give your comments? Hi, I'm Lynn Bolton, the Chair of the Range of Light Group, Sierra Club, and on behalf of our 200-plus Mono County members and the thousands of Sierra Club members who come here, I urge you to oppose this project every step of the way, as you did in the 1990s when our bolt drilled in the same spot. Well, my use today means an opened his mind and sun-eyed heat bleaching. Mono County has an arm that's damning the use.
28:22 But it could be challenged. So while many exploratory drilling projects don't turn into gold mining operations, we never know which ones will. This project is in the middle of the sage grouse area. And just the drilling, the trucks would be cutting through a nesting brooding area. Eight of the drill sites are within yards of where sage grouse congregate. The night floodlight, the noise will stress and then disrupt the breeding. Drilling could easily tip the scales.
28:52 The population, which has been declining for less 17 years. So mining eventually would wipe them out in the area and would remove half of the research itself. So we really must. Thank you. I hope we have your support. Jamie? Malcolm Clark, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hi, I'm Malcolm Clark. I've lived in Mammoth since 2004. And I just want to, I send in a statement.
29:32 Because earlier today my Zoom camera wasn't working and so forth and I wasn't sure if I could be heard. So I will not repeat everything in the statement which I sent to the town clerk. I just wanted to especially emphasize how important it is for the town council not just to engage with the forest service but to take the leadership in cooperation with other community organizations and the business community.
30:01 to drum up opposition to this project. I think it can be as much the effect of strong community opposition, which also adds an effect upon investors in such a project that can stop a project as it can be regulatory action. Thank you. Thank you Malcolm. This is Jamie. That's the end of the public comments. Thank you very much.
30:33 Moving on then from the public comments, we did receive a letter from Lynn. I'm sure you all got that. It was our correspondent. And now we're going to move on to what I'm calling today changes to the agenda rather than additions because it could be deletions or additions. Any changes, Dan? Sorry to jump in. We had so many comments. I just wanted to ask if this is something that we can agendize for a future.
31:00 Council meeting. It's my understanding the Board of Supervisors is going to be doing that. If I may, thank you, Member Ray. The item is scheduled for your May 5th meeting, which is next regular meeting, and we'll have some comments that we'll draft up in looking at that meeting as they'll need to be submitted the following day to the Forest Service. Thank you so much. And I think it's just worth pointing out in case any members of the public aren't quite clear on.
31:29 Who would be the agency approving the mine or doing the environmental review is not the town. This project would not be within the town limits. It would be Mono County, probably the Forest Service, but the town would not be directly involved in anything. The town could certainly take a position about it, but the town would not be determining the level or type of environmental review. The town would not be issuing permits for the mine. The town doesn't have any direct role.
31:53 Thanks so much, Andy, for clarifying that. Thank you, Andy. Another question I would have before it comes back to us is to make a determination as to which agency is actually handling the environmental process. With the drill site for the steam plant behind the thermal plant, BLM, even though it was on forestry or planned, actually with the agency that did the environmental reviews and permissions. So before we bring it back, I would like to know who is.
32:24 Who are the responsible parties? Thank you. Dan. We have on the agenda that we left off the agenda. Item number 16. And that's no longer necessary related to the parcel that we pulled that item off the agenda. Also the two closed session items number 17.
33:04 We have no update on either item. Thank you, Dan. That being said, then the other change will be we will move Councilmember reports up to after item 14 as Sarah and myself have to recuse from item 15. That leaves us free to leave the meeting. Thank you. Okay, going on to...
33:40 Thank you, Mayor Sauser. I just wanted to let the council know that the town received an award from the American Planning Association for the parcel phase one. It was selected as the 2021 Excellence and Achievement in Planning Award Opportunity and Empowerment category. And that was from our central APA section. So just letting you all know that our work is recognized and it's recognized outside of our community.
34:13 And a big thank you to our entire parcel team who worked on the project. Thank you. Thank you, Sam. Always nice to hear something positive. Any other reports? Stu. Thank you, Mayor. I just wanted to spend a little bit of time sharing with the public an update kind of on the Community Recreation Center construction update and the temporary park closure and just share some of the information that we're distributing throughout the community. I think it's an opportunistic time.
34:47 Thank you so much. Thank you. Thank you.
35:14 I just want to say that this presentation will be part of Recreation This Week that is distributed every Thursday from our department as well. And we'll share as much as we can on Facebook as well. So with that, Mayor, I'll just kind of keep this as brief as I can. And Amy Callahan from our Public Works team is here as well. Just a little introduction just to make sure that everybody... That would be Cal and Ann's, too. Cal and Ann's, sorry, Amy.
35:44 So if anybody that's joining us tonight is not up to speed on the project, this just gives you a brief summary. It was awarded in 2021, but as we know, it's been ongoing for several years. Most recently, I think 2014 is when we actually started the site analysis for the project. And I know we've always, we've had plans for Mammoth Creek Park up to about 20 years ago. So anyway, so this gives you a...
36:13 An overview of the CSC, what it's going to be functioning in the wintertime, and then in the summertime, it's our new home for our expanding parks and recreation, summer camps and programs. So it's really kind of positioned as a recreation destination. It is just one element of many. So as everybody enjoys our Mammoth Creek Park, and I just want to say, on one hand, I'm thrilled that a lot of our community members enjoy this park.
36:42 Enjoy the beautiful playground. But on the other hand, I completely understand why there's some frustration with the closure. Parks and Rec clearly is not in the closing business. Certainly during COVID, it's been a very difficult year when we were forced to close a lot of our amenities. I mean, that's just heartbreaking for all the work that we do as a department and the town and town council to provide a lot of the funds necessary to open and maintain and provide these wonderful amenities that we have. So again,
37:12 Just as deeply saddened that we have to close this park for this reason, but, you know, I look to public works and I look to contractors to provide, you know, what they believe is the right path forward to protect the safety and well-being of our community. So, again, this just speaks to kind of that broader recreation destination that we talk about. You know, all of these elements remain, and I just want to say in 2018, when we, you know, cut the ribbon for our beautiful, inclusive playground,
37:40 It was always planned to basically reorientate that playground. So when we talked about reorientating it from north, south to east, west, it was about planning for the future. So planning for these additional amenities, this park would be able to host for our community and kind of create this one-stop shop. So not only did we say, well, let's just not pull out the original playground and put it back. Let's see if we can kind of add to this park. So we went out and secured.
38:09 Grant funding through game times, $130,000, supplemented with, you know, general fund money. So we're able to kind of bring in and enhance this park, which as we know now is extremely well visited. So anyway, it deeply saddens me, but again, this is for the best interest is what I've been told for our community. Just a couple of facility renderings, you know, people can kind of get a sense of the scale and the size.
38:35 Where the groundbreaking was today, it was kind of right there on that top left-hand corner, right at that front entrance there. You can see it includes a 118, you know, space mobility hub. You can see the different sides in the back. And perhaps this aerial view kind of shows you right here, I kind of put, I don't know if you can see that, not too sure, but, you know, the playground's right in front of the structure of the new building. You can see the restrooms, the close proximity to the parking lot. So everything's just really, you know, so.
39:04 So contained within close proximity to that new structure. This is the temporary park closure that we're currently experiencing, and you can see with the fencing, you can see where the trailer was in orange, you can see where the other trailers are going to go. A lot of work's happening in and around the playground, utility lines, water lines, electrical lines, they have to redo a lot of the pathways, the entrance to the CIC facility, they're reorientating the parking lot, so just a tremendous amount of work.
39:34 In and around that playground. So essentially for the duration of the construction, you know, unfortunately that playground, the restrooms and the parking lot will be closed. But that green space is open. So if you do want to enjoy that green space, we have picnic tables there. It's a beautiful shaded area. We have trash rooms. And then we also have a restroom that will be open. And I'll show you kind of a map here. It's Mammoth Creek Park East restroom. It's just underneath the tunnel. I'll show you where that is.
40:03 And then we certainly, as we've talked about, a reference, Tom Parker, you know, thanks for joining us this evening, talking about some other parks as well, you know, Shady Rest Park. We also have a playground and community centre, and then we have one at our award-winning Trails End Park. So again, if you are in Mammoth Creek Park looking for the restroom, you can see down here, I've just highlighted in red, that closest restroom to Mammoth Creek Park. That's Mammoth Creek Park East. It's a beautiful stroll out towards the lookout.
40:33 And again, just some signage, just some images, you know, again, unfortunately, we have to put these clothes signs up, we have to put these fences up to protect our public. Just some proximity photos with the fence, you know, here it is coming into the park, and you can see we've got excavators right there behind it. Again, everybody's around it, you can see the containers, that's the edge of the parking lot. So again, just a lot happening on that site, you know, not only now, but, you know, for the next few months. And that's obviously the construction trailer.
41:03 And then we were just 50 feet on the right there for the groundbreaking ceremony. So, you know, just everything's in very close proximity to the construction site. I do want to reference Trails End Park. I know a lot of people don't head down there, or I just think it's kind of a Vulcan Brothers skate park. But we have an award-winning playground. In 2017, this facility received the Outstanding Facility Award from the California Parks Recreation Society, District 7.
41:32 You can see it's two large structures, flat. It's accessible. We've got picnic tables, benches. We've got a pavilion in the area as well. So if you haven't experienced Charleston Park, please do. You can see we've got some pavilions there on the left, restrooms, a great pavilion. And again, it's adjacent to our Walker Brothers Skate Park with plenty of parking on that side as well. Again, Shady Rest Park, a highly frequently visited park. So again, that's another playground site.
41:59 And again, our community centre playground. Perhaps a lot of people don't get to visit this park. They're just up there for the tennis. But there is a new playground there we installed not too long ago. And then we invite the community up there as well. So with that there, I will end my department report. But I do want to also just highlight our wonderful, let me just jump into another screen if I may.
42:28 Our defensible space and community cleanup event. Again, just want to remind our entire community that we encourage everybody to grab a bag, help clean up our town. It's May 21st and 22nd. So again, grab a bag, come out and help us clean up our town on Saturday, May 22nd. You can also grab your green waste around your home and take it down to the town yard. This is kind of where we are in the town yard, right there on 299 commas from 8 a.m.
42:57 To 4pm on both Friday and Saturday. You can see here we've got a little loop already set up with the chipper. So if you've got some green waste and some limbs to chip, we have that ready for you. Green waste bins, household waste, some metal waste, e-waste. So again, that's going to be 21st and 22nd. And we're looking to volunteer. So if you're able or willing to volunteer to help us on Community Cleanup Day, please visit our wonderful friends at Volunteer Eastern Sierra and sign up online.
43:26 So hopefully I didn't take up too much time this evening to Council, but I appreciate the opportunity. Thank you, Mayor. Thank you, Stuart. Any questions for Stu for your presentation? Yes, if I could. Stu, you talked about a green space being open. I didn't really understand where that would be, and then where would people park to access that? So the green space is, thank you, if you want me to comment, Mayor. Go ahead, Stu.
43:57 Okay, so just briefly, the green space is where it always is. So we invite everybody to either access it from our trail system. You can kind of walk there from the trails adjacent to Mammoth Creek Park. There's parking on Mammoth Creek Park East. So if you want to park on that side where the restroom is, walk underneath the tunnel, access that park and enjoy some green space and beautiful views of our mountain range. So hopefully that answers the question. Thank you, Steve.
44:28 Okay. I'd just like to comment, Stu. I really do appreciate you putting this together for us. I would have loved to see it a couple weeks ago when we could have communicated this, but I think it's a good, you know, good learning experience for us that communication is key and getting out ahead of things is key. I want to thank you for putting it together and we can share that with the community. Is it going to be posted somewhere where the public can access it?
44:58 Yes, I'm going to attach it to the homepage so people can kind of see the groundbreaking right there. So we'll kind of amend that newsflash item on the homepage, remember, and then we'll have that PowerPoint for them. And like I said, it will go out in recreation this week, tomorrow, and then we'll include it in some Facebook posts as well. So like COVID, we're playing a little bit of catch up here, but we'll get there. So thank you. Thank you. John, you had a question. Yes. Is Sandra on the call?
45:33 Sandra Moberly, yes. Yes. Hi, good afternoon, Sandra. I'm wondering, I've read in the paper and heard about some discussion at the PEDC about graphics and the white roof and those kinds of things. My understanding that is now going to the design review committee as part of PEDC. Can you give the council an update on what we should be expecting if there could be any changes in the rendering that Stuart just represented?
46:00 I noticed that the roof is now white. It doesn't have the Town Mammoth Lakes logo on it, but it would be very helpful to get an update on that if you've got some information to share. Certainly. Thank you. The item was considered by the Planning and Economic Development Commission last week at their meeting, and the commission couldn't come to consensus on the colors, the final colors of the building.
46:25 The commission has already approved the design and kind of all the other aspects and it was really kind of down to the final colors. So they did recommend that the item be considered by the design committee, which is two members of the commission, just for that final color of the white. I think that they were comfortable with the blue, the tan color. It's just really whether or not that white roof works. And so staff is going to bring that to a meeting of the design committee for their final decision.
46:52 And we'll report that back to Council and to the full Planning Commission. That would be much appreciated. I think that the renderings have played a large part, I think, in generating a fair amount of community support for the project. And I think certainly if there was going to be any kind of a substantial change to what we've seen and what the public's seen, I think the Council would...
47:14 I'd like to have an opportunity to weigh in on that. So I look forward to any kind of an update. And just to echo Sarah's comment, Stuart, great presentation, great information. It would have been great to have had it a couple of weeks ago. Just saying. Because these are predictable things. I can't imagine this stuff was all last minute stuff. So no harm, no foul, but for all of us to be learning so we can certainly the council members can be communicating with the public and help getting those messages out so we're not all.
47:42 Caught maybe a little bit flat-footed, but great presentation. Thank you all. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Thank you, John. Sandra, I'm assuming that Stuart will be asked to speak in front of that group of two to explain why the white group did not something else, if there are reasons besides this aesthetic going on here. Right. Yes, he will be. And then Amy Callanan will also be able to provide comments to the committee as well with some information about the rationale for the colors.
48:13 And we will also work to put together a memo that describes how the project colors meet our current design guidelines and color handbook. Thank you, Sandra. Thank you. Mayor Sauser, we have public comments on the department reports. Okay. Sandy, please unmute yourself and give your comments. No, if you fail, I believe. All right. Patricia, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hi, this is Patricia Robertson.
48:51 I wanted to just make a quick comment about the closure of Mammoth Creek Park. I apologize. I missed the initial comment period at the beginning of the meeting. But I was just wondering if there was a rendering of the new facility that included.
49:10 Images of the park, of the existing park that showed what it's all going to look like at the end of the construction project. I feel like I haven't seen one, but I also haven't been following extremely closely. And so I think there was just a little bit of extra excitement when we heard the park was closed and we weren't, you know, people maybe weren't sure if that was indefinitely or because I personally haven't seen the rendering of the
49:37 The total project completed with the existing park in place. Thank you, Commissioner. I'm sure you just send that out to her, because I know it does exist. Jamie? That's it. Thank you. Any other reports from the commission or departments? Seeing no hands, I will move us on then to public presentation, item number one, update on suddenly communication services.
50:18 Sandra, are you going to start us off on this, or am I going straight to Michael? I think Nate is probably going to start the discussion on this. Okay. Yeah, thank you, Mr. Mayor, Council Members, Nate Greenberg, IT Director for Mono County and the Town of Mammoth Lakes, and appreciate the interest in this item tonight. Certainly heard the public comment and recognize this is a hot, impressive topic, which has been...
50:48 On a lot of people's minds. And so I wanted to just provide a little bit of intro to our representative that's with us tonight, our representatives that are with us tonight from Sun Link. And just make sure that the council is aware and the public is generally aware of the position that the town is taking on this matter and, you know, to the extent appropriate the county is taking on this matter. You know, first and foremost, what I'll say is this has been a very long...
51:17 And certainly the issues that we are dealing with tonight did not arrive overnight. They're the product of a lot of different things. And this is not something that the town is a bystander in or we are just sort of turning a blind eye to. That said, I think there are some limits to the amount of leverage and control that we have over some of the matters.
51:47 We can talk some more about that this evening as questions come up. You know, as just a way of background, you know, I really want to remind people that we are in a position today which is the result of, you know, more than a decade of work, really, which began, I guess, in this sort of current situation with the completion of digital 385. That happened in 2013, and prior to that, the town
52:17 And the region as a whole was in a certainly a much worse position than we are today with regard to broadband. In Mammoth, you really couldn't sign up for service with NPG Cable at the time or with Verizon. All of those networks were oversold. And, you know, as the project was completed, as Digital 25 was completed, the town recognized fully that in order for us as a community, as a region to take advantage of it, we really needed to focus on
52:46 Last Mile on Internet Service Providers and really working with them, finding folks to come in in places that we didn't have providers to deliver service that really leveraged the value and the opportunity with Digital 385. And so, as some people may remember, kind of early 2014, suddenly adopted Digital 385.
53:15 And had a number of different problems with our network. And really that led us to have some very focused and I think in some ways challenging conversations with the company. And they actually ultimately invested heavily in Mammoth in June and upgraded the electronics and performed a tremendous amount of maintenance on the network, which brought
53:42 Mammoth to be one of the first gigabit communities that was under that company and one of the first gigabit communities, honestly, in the Western U.S. as a whole. You know, today, 95 percent, roughly, of households in Mono County have access to gigabit network, and that's really not something that any other region in the country can say. And I recognize that
54:09 That doesn't really do anything to assuade people's frustrations and challenges when service is poor, but I also want to say that, you know, I think that we have a lot of really valuable opportunities that we can leverage and work with, and that the situation that we are dealing with is vastly different than underserved and unserved communities throughout the U.S. in places that they don't even have infrastructure in place.
54:38 And so I am optimistic given that and some of the conversation that will be brought by Sunlink this evening. I also just want to say that we as a organization or as organizations, both county and town, have strategic priorities that are built around broadband. We recognize the value of it from an economic standpoint, from just the need to be connected to the outside world and compete, certainly from, you know, marketing.
55:08 Supporting the tourism-based economy that's here as well as the businesses and residents that are here. And so we really and I really see this as an ongoing commitment. You know, in 2013, when 395 was completed, when suddenly completed their network, you know, a year and a half later, we never felt like we were done. We knew that there were going to be challenges again in the future. And, you know, given the demands of technology and how things are evolving, this is going to be a conversation that we will.
55:37 Continue to have in some facet or another. And I think this is a chapter in that conversation, which I know is challenging and frustrating for a lot of us and myself included in that. Spent countless hours over the last decade working on getting broadband to communities and constituents and ultimately to have a provider not delivering a level of service, which is expected by a lot of us.
56:04 Is something that I think frustrates a lot of us, myself included. And so what I wanted to sort of have Sunlink talk to a little bit this evening, and certainly I know I don't control all of their conversation, but was sort of the types of challenges that we as a community are dealing with really fall into kind of two major categories, one being network and the actual service that people are getting or are not getting in some cases at their homes and businesses.
56:34 And then the other side being the customer service piece. And they're definitely connected to one another. And I think certainly that will be talked a little bit about in terms of the pain points that are realized by folks and where the efforts need to be placed in order to rectify both of those. There, I know, have been a lot of comments brought to council as well as to staff around the franchise agreement and myself for
57:04 Andrew Morris, I'm sure would be happy to speak on that. The quick and dirty that I'll offer is that it's not as simple as just revoking the franchise agreement. It's a much more complicated matter than that. Certainly, if we need to go there this evening, I think we can talk a little bit about that. But ultimately, what I've sort of asked and I wanted to kind of speak to was that I see there being a number of different time segments that are related to sort of the
57:34 The state of affairs that we're in. And I alluded to one of them at the beginning, which was, you know, before the network was upgraded to gigabit. I think that, you know, people were very frustrated. There were a lot of challenges. After the network was upgraded to gigabit, everybody wanted to be a Sunlink customer. That was the gold standard for broadband in the eastern Sierra. And Sunlink as a company was really shining and I think doing a tremendous job.
58:04 They were generally locally owned and much smaller than they are today. And then they were acquired. And Mike will talk a little bit about that. But the acquisition, I think, really created a lot of challenges for the company, the local market, and ultimately us who are customers. And so, you know, what I really wanted to have Mike talk about was sort of the state of affairs today.
58:29 And kind of hopefully where we're headed and some of the things that they're focusing on. And, you know, again, just recognize that this is an ongoing commitment. This is something that we're going to continue to be working on. I recognize there's a lot of people that would just like to scream and yell at Suddenlink and certainly can't keep you from doing that. But also recognize that there are some challenges that we have in regulation.
58:56 Broadband is not a regulated utility. It's not like electric or water or power. And as a result of that, there are limits to what can be done. And that creates some challenges for us as an organization and ultimately you as customers. And really, I think what we're focusing on, what I'm focusing on, is how to work in partnership with Sunlink to focus on some of these major issues that are
59:25 in existence today and try to improve the state of affairs for everybody in the community as a whole. So with that, I'd like to introduce Mike Horton and I'll actually let you introduce yourself, Mike, and not actually try to speak to you. Great, Nate, thank you very much. Good evening, Mayor and Council. My name is Mike Horton and I'm guessing you can all hear me okay, is that right? Good, thank you.
59:53 I'm the regional vice president of a group called Local Market Engagement. I live here in Flagstaff, Arizona, and I have regional responsibility for a group we call our West Pacific region, and that is the franchises we have in both Arizona and in California. We have some very small market footprints in the state of Idaho and a couple markets in Nevada. I'm also joined tonight by a colleague of mine, Brad Ayers. Brad is the senior director for our government affairs group.
1:00:22 Real quick question, Sandra. Are you going to put the slides up, or would you like me to drive that? If you could do that, that would be great, Mike. Okay, give me a second here. There we go. Share screen. So slides should be up. So I would like to open and just touch base on, you know, an issue that impacted all of us, both Suddenlink as a company and all of you in the community over a period of time, and that was the Creek Fire.
1:01:03 This is not an excuse, but this is simply an acknowledgment of one of the underpinnings of some of the challenges we had, certainly in the second half of 2020, in the age of COVID. Excuse the noise in the background, I have a little bit of a pot. Run as it's a Corvette. Sorry about that. But over a 45-day period, the Air Quality Index, as measured by either state or environmental groups, and the guidance that we receive from our corporate health
1:01:34 And safety team measures the AQI. And we basically support in the Eastern Sierras, the markets of Bishop, Mammoth Lakes, and June Lakes with the same field support team. And during that time period, all of our field technicians and then our outside plant repair technicians, which I'll allude to more in the presentation, their ability to work was directly impacted. And as you can see on the slide there, 33 of the 45 days,
1:02:03 Our teams were not able to either work the full day or a partial day. And the direct result of that became a very significant backlog in what we call days out. And days out for any of you would be as a customer if you called in today. Our corporate standard is same day or next day for an installation or repair visit. And that's what we would expect. And during this period and then really into, you know, the months of November and December.
1:02:32 We were as much as 20, 25 days out. And I know there were customers that I was receiving escalations either from Nate or from a member of the town or relationships that I have established that said, I got an appointment for December. And we would certainly work to escalate on that. But those were the challenges. And that was really what we would consider a force majeure event. That being said, the customer complaints that I want to
1:03:01 Really address the citizen who spoke up and thank you for all of you on the concerns. We have predominant customer complaints that have fallen into a few buckets. Nate alluded to those. The first was around customer care or our call center. And those were hold times, negative customer experience. Please excuse the acronym of CX. Difficulties with engagement, whether that's a language barrier, time of day, long hold times. And I will enumerate on each of these points in more detail.
1:03:31 Our field technician performance, the reliability of that performance or what we would consider a repeat visit where the technician came out, either did not correct the problem or that problem occurred and reoccurred in a very short period of time, again, causing a lot of frustration for any customer. Missed appointments. And then as I had spoken to on the last slide, the issue around days out. And I think the final point was in 2017 before either Brad Ayers or myself had.
1:04:01 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
1:04:31 Our Bishop retail store during COVID did close, and we closed almost all of our stores nationwide in the April timeframe of 2020, and we reopened Bishop January 4th of 2021. One of the challenges and the unintended consequences once we got to the latter part of the year towards the holidays, we wanted to reopen the stores, but all the employees that we had that were in region had departed the region or had taken another position.
1:05:00 So there's a lot of issues with regard to help as well as being able to staff and train the proper personnel to be able to get inventory back into the store, et cetera. We are monitoring our business indicators closely, and I will go into those to talk about the system metrics that we do measure, our root cause analysis for prescriptive improvement that our analytics teams have. We are hiring, and I will talk about that more.
1:05:29 We are spending money for our remediation and improvements, not only on the customer experience side, but also in the areas of customer service and network performance. And when I get to my last slide, we do have an opening or two right now in the region, and I would love for any support this forum could provide to offer some staffing suggestions. And as Nate has said, these solve actions here are not immediate.
1:06:01 But we are focused at the highest levels of the corporation to continue our process correction and really trying to drive trajectory in the improvement of our service levels across the board. When we look at our customer care and our call centers, we have a commitment to improve customer experience. We have a command center that does manage our contact rates, that's the number of phone calls we take, the ASA, which is an average speed to answer, and an AHT, which is what we consider an average handle time.
1:06:30 So that we can have then a performance insight team who can investigate any drivers and try to proactively correct any of the agent performance. I think most of you are aware, but any contact with our call center, we do advise customers that we record. We have the ability, if you had a negative experience, to pull that recording and identify either what the defect was, what the problem was from the employee side or the customer report.
1:06:59 And then take the appropriate action. I will also advise that one of the challenges as we go through this discussion and in an ongoing basis is, as Nate had alluded to, with digital 395, and that being the interconnecting network that gets the Suddenlink signal out of your community and up to Reno or over the LA Basin or on to Phoenix or somewhere, and that would be your long haul or your interconnect network. And then Suddenlink providing...
1:07:26 We can touch on more of that. My real message here is
1:07:53 If there's a problem with your sudden link service, if it's not reported and it's only a source of pain and consternation, if we don't know about it, we do not have the ability in the cable television industry to proactively go down, and I'll use Nate as an example, to the cable modem that sits at his home that provides data services and interrogate that that is offline. We have to have the responsibility of the individual customer to call us and open a ticket.
1:08:21 When we look at staffing, we have been trying to meet and improve staffing across all of our hours of operations, 7 by 24, 365, that includes training, technical aptitude, with a focus again on customer experience. I will tell you that in the latter part of 2020, we realigned our reporting structure in our call centers, and we moved the call centers from a work group that a senior leader had.
1:08:48 Into the Executive Vice President that I directly report into in our business to consumer organization. His name is Matt Marino, and Matt now has responsibility, and I have a direct line to any of the issues, problems that would be reported, and or support for corrective action in our call centers. In the application front, we have increased automation. We use a, everyone gets to this, and sometimes it's a frustration.
1:09:15 Even for myself as a consumer. But we have what's called an IVR, an integrated voice response system. It's a call tree. And it is with its intention, how do we direct calls? How can we front calls? If a customer does not need to speak to an agent, they could be moved to another source of care, which could be an IM chat or a different method to handle that call. Available in the fourth quarter of 2020, we upgraded our system to
1:09:44 So if I was the third person in queue, Nate opted into this on hold, the call director would take Nate's call as the second call in queue and ring his phone back and say, hello, this is Suddenlink, how may I help you?
1:10:11 Additionally, we have our information technology staff that is continually trying to work on the troubleshooting for the tools so that we can more prescriptively diagnose issues and recommend solutions to the customer. And that goes to the technology front. I've already discussed the upgrades, the $19.2 million investment we had in telephone technology. We're now using what we call a nuanced on-premise solution from Cisco. But we've also implemented a digital...
1:10:40 Artificial intelligence powered conversational cloud. And the intent there is if a customer called in and said, my internet speeds are terrible. We would punch in all of your customer information and then we would go in and try to run a line test and out of that line test would give the agent what a prescription would be for the customer. A frustration for a lot of cable television customers or cable data service customers is we would like you to power down your device and repower it.
1:11:09 Because a lot of times that device is communicating back to a server that basically has what we call a keep alive message. And as with many communications, same thing with cell phone, y'all live in the mountains, so you know you run out of signal. And if that signal was interrupted, a power cycle in many cases will restore that problem. If a customer does a power cycle and no problem is resolved, that is when we would then as an agent want to go ahead and place.
1:11:37 A technician field visit with the customer. That would move us to our field operations team. I will tell you that we have made sustained improvement from the period that I described around the Creek Fire to our on-time arrival performance, and we are now operating same day next day. There will be days when that rule will be broken or violated if we had more customers call in.
1:12:03 And we had available quota. And the quota would be we would have X number of technicians doing installation repair work. And once that quota would fill up, if it was not available for same day or next day, they would go to the next available date. And again, if that's an escalation point, that's something Nate and I can talk with you on at the end of this discussion. Our field teams are very focused on driving enhancements in our customer experience. And the foundation of that really is our...
1:12:32 Plant Stability. Our on-time arrival, if we make a commitment, we need to keep the commitment. And completing all work on the first trip, we are really hammering our field technicians and our field leadership with regard to the repeat rate and or missed appointments. It simply is not a sustainable play and it simply has to be corrected. On the 28th of February, we approved new incremental field headcount.
1:13:01 And I did skip over a December 15th notation where we had several senior leaders who were running our field operations team. We made some organizational decisions and we displaced several of the leaders that were running the field team. And we came back in with our man who was our chief technology officer and a couple of senior executives, which are at the level of executive vice president that now run our field operations. Today, we are fully staffed for field operations supporting Mammoth, June,
1:13:31 And the Bishop Markets. And that is both in the field service technician, those techs that would come to either your home or to your business, work inside the home or work out to what we call the drop wire, which would be at the edge of your property. And then secondly, our outside plant technicians, which are the ones that are the most senior technicians, they work out of our bucket trucks. A lot of the plants and a lot of the cable that we have in your community is aerial. It's on telephone poles. So they've got to be able to access that.
1:13:59 We have electronics, we have optical equipment, and all of that really has to be maintained. We are also very aggressively working to manage out any poor performers, especially contractors, when we would contract certain pieces of our labor force. We've established or reestablished our dedicated quality control organization, and by that, every month, we're expecting every technician that's in suddenly
1:14:29 To get a minimum of five QC visits by the quality control team. And then if they have any defects, those are reviewed not only with the manager and the area director, but then with the individual for corrective action. In the fourth quarter of 2020, we worked very aggressively on repairs in the market, and we have seen some positive results. We use a term called a node split. And a node is a piece of equipment that will serve a certain amount of homes.
1:14:59 Off of the local network, or the last mile network, as Nate had alluded to. We work on balancing the network and the electronics, and the whole intent is to drive that measurable service stability. I will tell you, since the fourth quarter, we have completed three node split projects in Mammoth Lakes. And a lot of the congestion that customers experience is because the node gets congested. Its analogy would be, you know, we'd sell 125 tickets for 100 passenger airplanes.
1:15:28 And if that node would become oversubscribed, or in the age of COVID, where you as a community saw a significant migration of second homeowners moved to your community and want to be there, stay there, work there. And what we would start doing is, based on how we had calculated the build of the network, we would start to see those networks saturated. And that's where we have to go in, partition the node, it increases the bandwidth, and it reduces the number of customers.
1:15:57 I'm on the Flagstaff Chamber of Commerce.
1:16:26 Again, supply chain related issues. And that is one of the issues and the challenges we have. Second would be the available either labor or permits that we would have to pull for certain projects. But that withstanding, there is certainly a very keen focus on nodes, on node performance. And that leads me into what we record as bandwidth utilization. And we have three conditions for bandwidth. Green is a zero to 70% bandwidth utilized. Orange is a 70 to 90.
1:16:56 And if you're in the red, you know what, we are in a position where we are really going to start seeing contention. We have a process we call node in distress. And we go down to that node level and anything that hits the red gets an immediate ticket. And that's where we get our maintenance teams to go out and split those. There are approximately 28 nodes in Mammoth Lakes, two in June Lake. And I pulled the report early this week and two nodes showed bandwidth utilization.
1:17:26 At or above 70%, the highest being at 74%, the other note was at 72%. So they were not in anywhere in a critical issue. As a customer, you would then say, but my internet is too slow. And again, as I had said earlier in the discussion, that is likely a process or a problem where we would need to dispatch a technician to your residence or your business, verify.
1:17:51 That the inside equipment and the signal levels are good at the side of the house or the building, that the drop wire that connects to the telephone pole and back to the local network is functioning as identified. If it goes beyond that, then it's a problem in that local area network, and that would be with our maintenance teams. The last point on the network side is the node health or the availability. And that's, you know, is your internet, what is, we measure our uptime.
1:18:18 And we had a very difficult six months in the second half of the year, up through really the October timeframe. A lot of that, as I had alleged or alluded to, excuse me, on my first slide with the Creek Fire, we weren't able to maintain the network because we weren't allowed or the employees were not allowed per guidance from our health and safety teams to be working in the community due to health and air quality standards. That said,
1:18:47 Over the past six months, we have seen significant improvement in the availability of the network, you know, really from November to year-to-date or month-to-date here in April. Now, one point I just want to touch on to give you, I don't want to make anyone an engineer here, but we have seen both measurable improvement in our downstream bandwidth and our upstream bandwidth. And I want you folks to know that I am a longtime Mountain Bell, U.S. West Quest telephone person.
1:19:15 And I know for many of you that lived in California for a long time, that would have been Pacific Bell or AT&T. And in the phone company, we would build networks that we considered symmetrical. I would build two or three lanes of bandwidth down to the home, and then I would have a concurrent two or three lanes of bandwidth upstream back to our office and out into the network. Cable television, and I've been in cable now for five years.
1:19:42 Cable television built what we called an asymmetrical network. And essentially what cable TV created, and this is Cox, this is Charter, this is Comcast, this is Suddenlink. We all use exactly the same technology. And the downstream bandwidth, and please excuse me, but I'm using kind of a roadway analogy, the downstream traffic would be two or three lanes from what we call our head end there in Mammoth Lakes, pushing the video or the internet signal to your home.
1:20:11 Correspondingly, the upstream bandwidth looks like a sidewalk. So it's an asymmetrical relationship because as a cable industry, the primary product was video. More and more, we have become a data-centric community. Many folks don't even watch television, or if they do, they use Netflix or Apple TV or something that we call streaming. And right now, we are all, this is a perfect example of upstream bandwidth. We are all broadcasting from either
1:20:40 City Hall or from our points of residence upstream into the network. And one of the challenges that we've all experienced in the age of COVID and the new normal is a significant bandwidth requirement for upstream, which has led television companies, labs, manufacturers to continue to work to push and improve upstream performance. And that is not a quick and that is not a cheap conversation.
1:21:08 But that withstanding, we are fully aware of those challenges. And we do have certain techniques where we can increase upstream bandwidth, but not appreciably. My last slide. We talked a lot in Mammoth Lakes. There are between 9,000 and 14,000 doors for MDU or multiple dwelling units, an apartment, a condo, Snow Creek, as an example, Aspen Creek.
1:21:35 And I certainly will report to you that we've had significant confusion across the community on our MDU property accounts, not only from installation repair support, from billing issues, and identified points of contact. I have a memorandum that I've been working on, well, with my sales teams over the last probably five or six weeks, and we have worked to provide dedicated staff support that will be positioned in Mammoth Lakes.
1:22:04 We work exclusively to support the MDU properties on a dedicated full-time basis. And I will be working with Nate, and I can certainly get to Mayor, to you or to Council, the job description and the job ads because we are looking to hire local if we could. And that would be someone that lives in the community. If there's a problem with one of the MDU properties, they have a single point of contact. And then they have an escalation point to myself, Regional Vice President, where I work across all of the organizations I've just described.
1:22:33 To be able to help push escalations to successful completion. A couple of things I want to touch on is that just from the memorandum today would be in establishing this single point of contact for escalations with what we call a bulk account manager. And that would handle building installation service. Suddenly we'll be performing on-site surveys property by property to understand what are the wiring limitations. What are the challenges in Flagstaff, in Mammoth Lakes?
1:23:03 We have aging wire in your residence, in your home, in your property. And some of that wiring actually does cause interference on your cable signal at your specific home. So when you say my internet's not very well, we may have what we call a leaking tap. And that leaking tap might be a jack in the kid's room or in the office that we no longer use in the building.
1:23:30 And yet it's leaking signal. And as a result, your internet bandwidth is taking a dive from a signal quality perspective. Additionally, we are pulling right now all of the properties in Mammoth Lakes on our account sales teams to look at the current accounts and are they set up properly. And one example I'll give you is if the account was set up is what we call a bulk account where everyone gets the same 100 megabits of bandwidth and the same 50 channels of
1:23:58 of Internet, or excuse me, of video, television, but the network was upgraded to a 200 megabit service. Your modem is only capable of cycling at 100 megabits, and there's what we call a modem speed mismatch. That also contributes to that, and will only be diagnosed if we get out there at the site, put a meter on your home and say, you've got a piece of equipment here, or if you purchase one from Best Buy that may or may not match the signal level.
1:24:27 So all I'll tell you in closing is that the sales teams are working very diligently as I speak, one, to establish their presence and notify all the communities, the HOA management and HOA boards within Mammoth Lakes of the new dedicated resource, and they will be looking to audit the equipment so that we can have a more sustainable go-forward position. So with that, I know we would go to questions, but I wanted to...
1:24:56 Mr. Mayor, if I could hand it back to Nate, because he has one piece that he would like to share that I think will be quite interesting with how we can more effectively support your community on executive escalations when someone is frustrated. And so, Nate, I'll turn it over to you, sir. Thanks, Mike. So, yeah, I just wanted to let council and the community know that just today,
1:25:27 We are working to launch a new public-facing portal that is designed to serve as an intake funnel effectively for folks who are having challenges with getting customer service engagement from something through the standard customer care center and calling their line or going online to actually submit the service request. I am working to get
1:25:57 This URL on the portal that I'll show you in a moment on both the town's website and the county's website for the time being, you can access this. It's live as of now via the URL that's on the screen, which is on.mono.ca.gov and sudden link escalation. So we'll push this out and get it on our website. Just to show folks really quick.
1:26:26 Basically, where you'll land is a dashboard that looks like this. It's just showing kind of the status of requests or issues that have been brought into this portal that are, you know, requested for escalation and the ability to click this nice button here at the top and add a new escalation request. So, you know, as Mike alluded to or spoke specifically about
1:26:55 We are working hard to meet the demands of customers, both businesses and residents in town and in June. We ask that you follow the standard channel of kind of engaging customer care at Sunlink by calling their customer service center and trying to open a ticket. If you're not getting resolution through that, you're not able to get through.
1:27:25 So, if you go to customer care, you know, or you're having issues with field tax, misappointments, things like that, we invite you to come and fill out this form, you know, basically asking for some simple information from you in terms of what contact information we can kind of reach you back on, you know, what issue you're actually dealing with in the description. This is going direct to Sunlink. It's being tracked by myself, and it will
1:27:52 Thank you, Nate.
1:28:21 Questions or comments from Councilor Linda? Yes. I appreciate the presentation and it sounds great, but, you know, having heard just over multiple years of just the continuing issues, my own experience has been, my main issue was with the call-in customer service.
1:28:44 Was just really impossible to access, really impossible to get through quickly, multiple layers of passwords and number codes, etc. I haven't had to call lately, so I don't know, but I would think that that certainly is something that would need to be improved, and I appreciate your speaking to that. I also appreciate that you're speaking to the issue in our community with old wire, old buildings.
1:29:11 I know you face that in every location, but, and then your explanation of the multinode work is probably long overdue. So I suppose the question is, this all sounds like a really good plan, Mike, and I appreciate you coming to talk about it, but I guess the proof will be over time if we actually see.
1:29:30 A decrease in issues here, a decrease of, you know, complaints about the service and why don't we go use somebody else and people not understanding that the Town Council has a limited ability to impact those changes or those improvements. So again, I'm hoping for the best and hoping that this will come to fruition and in a year from now we'll be able to say that, you know, the service has improved greatly and the work was well done. So thanks for being here this evening. Thank you, Linda. John?
1:30:03 Michael, thank you very much for the presentation. I did actually follow up most of everything in which you were saying. I don't have much to say. I think it's fair to say that the temperature of the community in some sectors in the community is pretty white hot on this issue. I certainly appreciate a lot of the challenges that have brought up by COVID. So I'm not going to share it personally. I think I'm hoping there will be some members of the community that want to chime in on this.
1:30:31 Mr. Mayor, before we leave this conversation, I want to make sure that the town attorney gives a little bit of an update of what regional jurisdictions are doing. We understand that the CPC is the only place we can go to get any real address on this. Michael, you need to be, I'm sure you're aware of this, that we are banding together as communities to go to the regulatory agency to get relief. So I'll leave it with that. And Mr. Mayor, and comments from the public, if Andy wants to chime in, I assume he's there. Thank you. Andy?
1:31:03 Yeah, so I participated in a call with Suddenlink representatives, including Mr. Horton, Mr. Ayers, and the California Public Utilities Commission, and Supervisor Corliss, and Supervisor Gustafson from Placer County, and representatives from Truckee as well, and I was there, obviously, and heard most of the same things from Mr. Horton, and, you know, I think we're still waiting to see action or improvements.
1:31:33 Still haven't gotten the customer service standards that Suddenlink was supposed to provide a year ago and that Suddenlink promised to give us again on that call three weeks ago. Haven't seen anything at all. But we're working on it. I mean, I think it helps to have the jurisdictions working together. We do seem to have gotten the CPUC's attention at least a little bit, although it's unclear exactly what they can do. I think it's worth observing about the franchising process that...
1:31:59 Back in 2006, the phone companies wanted to get into the cable business, and so they essentially wrote legislation that took franchising for video service away from cities and took it to the state at the Public Utilities Commission. So there is no franchise as such that the town can revoke or really do anything about. Suddenlink does not have a monopoly. No one selected Suddenlink in any kind of competitive process. Suddenlink just has the ability to operate.
1:32:27 So it's not as simple as saying, well, the town should just kick them out and find another provider. We don't actually have the ability to do that. And the state, as far as I know, has never revoked a state video franchise. The law, I think, was set up to make it very difficult to do that. So we have Suddenlink and we're going to have Suddenlink unless they get bought again. There's not really a way to kick them out. So we look forward to working with them. And we hope that the things that Mr. Horton and his Suddenlink colleagues are saying.
1:32:56 Are all accurate and the service issues will be addressed and we will continue to work together with other jurisdictions to see if we can speak more loudly with a unified voice. Thank you, Andy. Moving on to Kirk. Questions or comments? My comments are, I have no complaints. I've actually had good service from Sudden Lake, so thank you. Kirk, Sarah? Thanks.
1:33:31 So, I have two questions. The first is, Nate, very cool idea to have this escalation page on the Mono County page. I'm curious as to who's, like, is Mono County paying you to do that and how much of your time do you think that's going to take up? Is that something we can ask suddenly for reimbursement for? Because I imagine if you're...
1:33:55 So the beautiful thing about the portal is that it doesn't actually require hands-on
1:34:27 By myself, it's actually just forwarding information on to the necessary individuals within Suddenlink. What Mike and I have been coordinating around is sort of closing the feedback loop, so to speak, so that we as a local agency are made aware of requests for escalation that are coming into us and generally whether those have been acted on and or resolved based on action taken from the company.
1:34:56 And so my hands-on in time is really just around occasional review and analysis of that, not actually forwarding. And part of why I did that, quite honestly, is I literally get a couple of these requests via email a week at this point or phone calls. I'm on the phone with Mike or emailing Mike several times a week currently. And so we're looking for ways to sort of streamline that both for him and myself.
1:35:27 Great, thanks, that's helpful. Hi, Sarah, thank you for the question. So, first and foremost, with not connecting to new construction, we have a new build team. We are always looking to, one, you know, expand and grow our network footprint. One of the challenges becomes the, and I know we've got certain developments right now where the splicing has been completed. There's one developer, I'll leave the developer nameless.
1:35:56 We've got the splicing work done. The problem for the customers on an order placement is that it's still not identified in our back office that says these addresses are serviceable. It's in how we identify. If you lived at, you know, 123 Mammoth Parkway, we would show serviceable or not serviceable. It's a new address. It has been populated. The problem now is just to make sure we get that toggle to serviceability. This week I have taken...
1:36:24 Two or three escalations, one in conversation with Nate and myself from members of the community or elected officials on that very issue back into our process to say, where the heck are we? The physical work is done. Now it's a matter of turning that up. So now, and I will address some additional challenges in expanding the network. One of the difficulties that we do encounter is not only permits, but then when we want to go to what an estimate would be to get
1:36:54 To a location, if it was like a half mile off, or somewhere up or down Canyon in June, as an example, only because I know Mammoth in June pretty well, but June's smaller, so I had a pretty good understanding of its topography. And some of those, it gets into a process we have, and I'm an old Bell System person, the aid to construction. But I certainly tell you assuredly that we are always looking to respond and address requests for new service, or as we would call it, network extension.
1:37:27 Okay, thank you. Of course. And I'll just add that I know that this has been a challenge, had been a challenge in the past because I think that there was a position empty, Mike, that was responsible for some new build in the local area and I think that that position did get refilled but I guess I would just go back to the comments on the escalation process and say that if people are
1:37:55 Feeling like they're not able to sort of get the right individual on the phone through customer care around new construction and actually getting connectivity that they go back to that same portal and escalate it and then can run it down through something. Nate, can I just a quick follow-up? How long did it take you to set that up on the Mono County webpage? 20 minutes. Great. Thanks, Sarah. Moving on to myself.
1:38:29 Michael, I won't go over what my issues suddenly have been. There have been some, but others have already expressed that as a public person and manager, as a council member, if you will. There are two companies that continually get brought to my attention that are not serving the public well, but I get complaints about. And yours is one of those. I am certain that your upper-level management...
1:38:56 I would like to see that somehow go away. So I'm hoping the presentation you made today will lead to that. I may be a bit skeptical, but for the moment, I'm willing to give you the benefit of the doubt that we will see some of these things come to fruition. With that, thank you. Any further comments or questions? There's public comment, Mayor Sauser. Thank you. Public comment, please. Ryan Jackson, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hi, I have a couple comments.
1:39:34 Ryan, we lost Ryan. Unmute. Can you hear me now? There you go, Ryan. Go ahead. All right. I have a couple comments. One is that several of our neighbors, when Southern California Edison came through and cut down the trees, they left the cable lines. And when some of our neighbors had called in asking suddenly to move those lines, the customer service has basically said, we don't attach to trees. It's not our problem. So that's one. Another one is, is one of our neighbors, I'm
1:40:17 Near the person who had public comment earlier, we constantly lose internet. So one of our neighbors recently, within the last two months, has had a missed appointment. They had another technician come out, said basically your connection is poor, your wires are old, they need to be replaced. No one came out to replace them. He didn't get a date. He called back for an update. There's no updates. Another one of our neighbors at the end of the street basically called with the exact same complaint.
1:40:46 Same issue, poor connection. They came out, they looked at it, they said, we think we have it okay, but we don't have a new modem to test it, so you're going to have to deal with it. When they called customer service and said, we're not back for two months, what can you do? You guys aren't dropping a new wire. They were basically told there's nothing we can do, so they canceled their service. It's a problem that at least four of us have had that is poor connectivity.
1:41:13 Probably related to the fact that the wires are old and there's no timeline. So I understand there has to be permits and everything else, but people that drive up from LA that have this as a second home or this has become their primary home, you need timelines. And to say that you have 38 days where we didn't have service because of the creek fire, there are people up here that are essential workers for major corporations that patients' lives are on the matter or public lives are.
1:41:43 So I think there has to be something to be able to deal with that. That's it. Ryan, further public comment. Forrest, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hello, my name is Forrest Cross. I'm a resident here in Mammoth. I live up in the Slopes area. And Mike, I want to say thank you for the presentation. You know, it's good to hear that some of the issues are being looked at and addressed. My frustration stems from several years of really poor
1:42:20 Customer service as well as technical service from Suddenlink. And, you know, as an example, I was one of the people that was sold faster service. It took four technicians to come out to realize that the modem I had wouldn't even support that. I don't understand how when I rent a modem from Suddenlink, they don't have the information somewhere that says, oh, well, that service isn't going to work with you, so we can't sell it to you if they were happy to take my money.
1:42:48 But did not provide me for what I'm paying for. And then for the last two and a half years now, I've had a temporary line ran from the drop point of the street to the house. I finally got a technician after six or eight tries, figured out that the actual wiring from there that was in the ground over the house was bad. They put a temporary line above ground. I was told that that would be buried within four to six weeks. Two and a half years later, it's still sitting there above the ground.
1:43:18 Been through three winter cycles now. Like, I get horrible service off and on. Like, I'll be down. I pay for 400 megabyte service. There's some days I get one and a half megabytes. I stopped calling customer service because every time I would call, they didn't even have it on record that I even had a temporary line. My next door neighbor had problems with theirs last fall. Technician came out, ran an above ground line over on his temporary one, said it was going to be buried shortly.
1:43:46 Looked at mine and was like, oh, wow, we had no idea this was even here. Hasn't been buried yet. Neither of them have. So having issues like that that aren't addressed for months and months and months, that's not just a creek fire issue. This has been going on for a lot longer than just that. And it's pretty frustrating for the amount of money we pay. So I really hope that these things can be addressed and fixed in the future.
1:44:15 Forrest, as soon as Nate can get this website up, if you could put an escalation in, and again, the drop, Barry, you're absolutely correct, that's just, there's no excuse. But getting that specific information, and folks, I didn't advise earlier, but I will have visibility of every escalated complaint that will come through this website. We do have a dedicated team.
1:44:41 That provides the what we consider executive escalation desk. And it is, you know, a move to the front of the line, but it is to be able to resolve these issues. And then for my role systemically to understand why we've simply not performed on the temporary drop wire that Forrest just described, and it needs to be buried, you know, now as soon as we can get to mud season and get snow out of the way so we can go get that put underground.
1:45:10 And certainly can do that. And the vehicle that Nate has described is a short-term but an immediate remedy to be able to correct some of these issues. And of course, I would also include any of the service speed issues that you were describing if it's, you know, more than one subject item that needs to be put into that request. So thank you. Michael? Jamie? Patricia, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hi, this is Todd Robertson.
1:45:42 From Mammoth. And I just actually coincidentally today was on with Sublink customer service for the second time in less than a year. And I just wanted to talk about the annual increases that keep happening over and over again. And, you know, the prices keep going up. And I was told today that there was going to be, that Sublink always puts a $20 annual increase, you know, per month.
1:46:10 But that's just something that they do. And I was like, you know, we're not making 25% more income. So the value really isn't there. And the cost of living here is, you know, always such a hot topic that I just feel like, you know, that alongside of the service issues, it's just really compounding things. And I did have a question specifically about there's on the bill a network enhancement fee that seems like we've been paying forever. And I wasn't sure what that was.
1:46:39 You guys can answer that. I'll just finish my comment first. But I asked specifically today when I was with customer service for a department that could offer like service alternatives or take my feedback. And there was really, there was nothing available. So my suggestion would be that, you know, Sunilake needs to offer plans that appeal to our community, obviously have better customer service. And then ideally, I think it's just kind of imperative that we have offices here in town. Thank you. Thank you.
1:47:13 John Blackburn, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hi, this is John Blackburn calling in. I've been working with IT or in IT for the last, I don't know, 12, 14 years. And I deal with the internet services on a pretty much daily basis. So I've had, you know, the experience over the last 12 to 14 years of every different level of network.
1:47:42 In town. And I do want to thank the local Suddenlink workers. They are awesome. They do a great job. And they do help us out where they can. They obviously have to take their orders from the bus. So, you know, they've been extremely helpful on that front. And I'm thankful for the service that they do have when it does work, because otherwise we wouldn't have anything here in the first place. So that aside.
1:48:10 You guys have been talking about upgrading your networks for years and years and years, and they have been, you know, slowly being brought up to par as more and more people get online. But that brings up the node overloading issue, and I feel like that's going to be a constant problem, you know, being a cable network. Why are we not looking at providing fiber to the home instead of doing a band-aid fix on old copper infrastructure?
1:48:38 I just want to understand, like, why can't we move to fiber to the home if they're going to spend all this money on upgrading the network? I feel like that would be a better option than band-aiding, you know, cable copper infrastructure. I do realize that something has fiber in different parts of their network. I just don't know which ones and, you know, if they're ever going to bring it here. It'd be awesome if they did. That should probably fix a lot of different issues going on in town.
1:49:07 And reliability. So that was one thing. I did have to deal with the FCC a long time ago when I did have Suddenlink at my house. I don't have Suddenlink anymore. I live in Crowley and I have fiber now. I've never had an issue ever since I've found fiber. It's always been consistent. Never had downtime. If we've had downtime, they've let us know about it weeks in advance and it's just been good.
1:49:32 The call center issues, as everybody has talked about, that's a brutal one, especially when I have to call in and I'm billing somebody as an IT worker on hold times, because that doesn't look good on me and it doesn't look good on anybody involved. On top of that, I've been on hold for, I don't know, hours at a time, so that one's been pretty brutal.
1:50:00 Let me see some of the other stuff I have here. Are you guys going to be rolling out any fiber, I guess, is the big question. I don't know if that's going to be in the plans, and that's kind of where I was heading. I'm hoping for the best on that, and that's kind of all I have to say. Thank you, John. That's the end of the public comments. Thank you. Michael, any final comments? Yes. Just, John, thank you for your comments.
1:50:37 With regard to a fiber to the home, you know, we are a fiber-based company. If you look at our interconnections with digital 395, that is all fiber optics, and obviously, you know, we're able to facilitate very high bit rate speeds. When you look at the last mile, as I had alluded to in our presentation, we are fundamentally a hybrid coax network with coaxial cable. And the implications for a fiber to the home,
1:51:06 Basically underpin that every drop wire, every what we call distribution cable that would be in the alley behind your home or running down Main Street, then has to be upgraded, one, to a fiber optic cable, and then secondly, that drop wire has to be extended to the home as a strand or two strands of fiber, and then you have to put the optics or the electronics in the home so that you can take the on-off blinking pulse of light, make it into an electrical signal that can then be consumed or used within the home.
1:51:36 One of the challenges that any company is going to have, and I make no excuses on this, but just to tell you the return on investment in my community here in Flagstaff or in Mammoth Lakes is with the extensive rock and topography that we have. The estimates for any construction job become really prohibitive. I don't know where Crowley is, but I'm going to surmise it might be a flatter parcel of land, much like a bishop.
1:52:06 That comes easier to facilitate. Again, not an excuse, just an explanation of where fiber to the home comes in, and it does provide much faster services. But I certainly want to thank you, Mayor and Council, for this opportunity. I certainly, as soon as we're kind of pulling back from our travel restrictions, I have told Nate that as soon as I can, I want to make sure I can get back to the community. I've been to Mammoth Lakes three times in the last, well.
1:52:35 Thank you very much, Mike. Yes, sir. So, moving on.
1:53:07 To agenda item number two, staff presentation, update on Mammoth-Josemite Airport Air Service and regional airport matters. Grady. Thank you. This is a fairly lengthy staff report. I'm certainly not going to read all of it, but I will go hit some highlights. I mentioned to the town manager earlier today that with all the transition things we have going on with air service and the Bishop, with the increase in what we're looking for for scheduled charters,
1:53:37 My recommendation is that this be scheduled for a workshop format for a couple of hours. We can really drill down into detail a lot of these issues. You'll see as we go through, we have their service issues, airport issues, other things we want to serve at Yosemite Airport, and certainly funding issues with the fact that 10,000 employments, while certainly we think they're within reach, is not going to be as easy as it has been in the last few years. So with that, I'm just going to run through.
1:54:03 The staff report, I do have a few notes here I'll want to bring in specific context too and we'll go from there. Real quickly on Bishop, we do have our regular monthly FAA meeting on Bishop tomorrow morning. I'll report back to the town manager if anything substantial comes out of that. But to this point, they're still commenting that they're on track to finish their paperwork with FAA.
1:54:28 By the end of June, by July 1st, that's the target that Mark McCarty from FAA Regional has set. And that air service should begin in Bishop in mid-December. And I'll get to air service in a minute. John Urdi, I know it's on the line. He's going to comment on that. They did, down in Indio County, circulate their EA, their environmental assessment, and their initial study and negative declaration for the initiation of air service in Bishop.
1:54:54 They got five written comments and one verbal comment out of the whole package. They did have a public workshop on April 1st and a public hearing as well. We did provide a comment on that, just clarifying some facts, but they got five comments on that. And they are working right now to respond to those comments so they can wrap up the environmental documentation, I believe, sometime in May. I also know that Ashley Helm from Inno is going to listen in at least tonight.
1:55:23 And I comment on that. One thing, not necessarily a comment here, but she's going to work on their comments. One thing I mentioned at the end of my comments about Bishop is that the projection is that 70 to 80 percent of the passengers that will go to and from Bishop Airport will have Mammoth as a final destination or they'll be residents of Mammoth going somewhere else. And it's certainly been a regional issue for a number of years. We had the Miwok, which I won't go into the...
1:55:52 Mammoth Inyo Air Working Group, I got that right, surprised me, but we had several working groups that worked with Inyo County to come to a consensus that we worked together to improve regional air service. It's a regional issue, and I, for one, would like to recommend to the town manager, the town council, is that we frankly ask Inyo County, hey, why don't you either come to one of our meetings, or if you're going to have one at your board of supervisors, let us know to explain to the traveling public, okay, precisely how this is going to work.
1:56:20 Because the traveling public will have a lot of questions about, okay, how do I get to Mammoth? How do I, you know, how do I do transportation? What's the schedule going to be like? What kind of planes are going to be? And while they're covered in small part in a lot of different meetings, there hasn't been one single presentation, I don't think, to at least to town council. And again, I don't know if they've done it to the board of supervisors to explain a lot of the ins and outs. Where's the money coming from? Where's the subsidies happening? All those types of things. So I'm just going to offer that to town council.
1:56:50 And ask if you have any specific questions you'd like answered about Bishop, get them to me, send them to Ashley, and if you'd like your presentation, we can do that in the future. I'll come back to that at the end to ask the actual question if you'd like to have me to do a presentation or not. Number two in the staff report is air service. I know John's on and available. I'd like him to go ahead and jump in with a focus on Mammoth Yosemite Airport and what we're looking at for
1:57:17 Scheduled charter and increases. I know there's a lot of discussion MLT support very recently on that. And, John, just a brief update on Bishop as well. But if you could focus on Amethyst Yosemite. So thanks, John. Yeah, on the air service side, thanks, Grady. We are looking at going into winter 21-22, so this December, working with advanced airplanes. We had started to work with them this past winter. Unfortunately, literally never went off the ground with them. But we plan on...
1:57:45 Providing the services that we had originally planned for winter 2021 for next year. So we would be flying seven days a week for Berlin, seven days a week for Carlin, and also having flights out of Hawthorne, which is another LA airport. You know, with working with advanced airlines, they have 30 passenger Dornier jet, so very similar to what we flew with JSX over the years. So there's no TSA when folks come in. They can really arrive at the airport 20 minutes before their flight.
1:58:15 And as we've had in the past, if the weather in Mammoth isn't conducive, they can divert to Bishop. And so that's still an option there. You know, we think that this is a great opportunity not only for our visitors to get in and out of here, but also for our locals. I think it's going to be a premium service. I think it's really a great opportunity for us to become an executive airport up here with multiple scheduled charter companies. We are looking at a few others that we've talked to in the past. And so as we get the opportunity to expand into new markets.
1:58:44 We've looked at places like Santa Barbara, places like Oakland, potentially places like Las Vegas with carriers like this. Basically, the threshold is that 30 passengers, anything above 30 passengers needs TSA, and so that would be something that would go into Bishop Airport. Ultimately, our goal will be to get to that 10,000 employment number. Our goal for winter of 21-22 is going to be 4,500 visits in planements because I think at this point,
1:59:12 I think we have roughly 6,800 available seats. We figure 65% load factor, 65% of the plane's full, that we should be able to get to that 4,500 number. I do anticipate that in year two or year three, we can potentially get to that 10,000 claimants. The convenience of having the flight land 10 minutes from town versus Bishop, where the commercial area will land, should be a big premium for folks to take advantage of. Briefly, on the Bishop side,
1:59:42 We have been working with United Airlines. They've been a phenomenal partner over the years, and we are working with them to consider the markets that will be flying into Bishop. Right now, we are looking at the same markets that we've had in the past for next year, seven days a week from Denver, San Francisco, and then the question mark is Los Angeles. You know, we've had a number of conversations of whether Los Angeles makes much sense.
2:00:08 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
2:00:37 Dallas, Fort Worth, Phoenix, Seattle, Salt Lake City. So, you know, we've got some new options coming up. I think we need to walk before we run on both of the airports. I think with the scheduled charter service, I anticipate that we will have a good increased demand with advanced airlines and with the scheduled charter service because of the proximity to town. So hopefully we can get that to the point where these subsidies get minimized and we can start to add new markets.
2:01:04 And that would be the ultimate goal. And again, the ultimate goal is to get to that 10,000 plus employments, which helps the airport from an entitlement money standpoint. Yeah, just to clarify that, John, in case everybody doesn't understand, if an airport in the system reaches 10,000 employments, they basically earn without injection $1 billion from FAA for improvements on that airport.
2:01:29 I think that's just something I think everybody knows, but just to make sure that's why we keep talking about $10,000. If we can reach that goal, that means $1 million towards capital projects at the airport. So any questions for John before we move on? Yes, John, one question. So the 21-22 service, is that just through like Easter? Is there no summer charter service? You know, so good question, Ted. So we are looking at, we're currently exploring
2:02:01 Summer service, summer 22. So no summer service this year. We are exploring summer service for 2022, both with commercial and charter. And so we potentially could see to service with the charter into Mammoth. But right now the main schedule, the winter schedule is typically mid-December till end of March.
2:02:25 Thank you, John. Any council questions? Just a general observation. Obviously, the private sector
2:02:55 The Elterra Mountain Company has been a very significant drive for all of this. And, Grady, while I appreciate its support for the town, the county, for us to be talking, figuring out how things are going to work, I'm concerned that without the Elterra Mountain Company available for questions at the table, involved in this, that those are not going to be fruitful conversations.
2:03:21 So I'm putting that out there as a general observation. The Altera Mountain Company's been thriving. And I think council has been, you know, we're obviously supporting air service in all its various iterations, but I think we are a little bit leery of getting too close and too getting involved. We can be a very chaotic sector, which is the sector that we're talking about right now, especially in the age of COVID, especially with international travel.
2:03:46 Situations that's, you know, two, three, four years to recover from what we've been going through. Those are the estimates that people are talking about. So I think in the interest of time for the council of all the regional jurisdictions, that Calterra needs to be identified. The person needs to be there. Somebody can speak and tell you this and answer some of the tough questions. So I just, I just throw that out there as we look forward. Yeah, they are, John. They're involved heavily. And I think that the one thing that I would caution is that the
2:04:13 The purpose of this is to create reliable, consistent service for the Eastern Sierra. In a normal year, we are seeing probably a 12% cancellation rate. In a blizzard year, where we had, I think it was 2017-18, we were upwards of 30% cancellation rate, including 11 straight days out of San Francisco that couldn't get in. We anticipate that that probably goes down to about a 2% cancellation rate in Bishop.
2:04:38 You know, I think for the Eastern Sierra, for the town, not only for Altera, that that's the big opportunity right here is to get that reliable, consistent service, because I've been saying it for 10 years, that with the cancellation rate the way that it's been, you know, we've had to put new flyers into the funnel every single year versus getting loyal visitors who trust it and will fly it. So we're really looking forward to the consistency of Bishop Airport, but also the fact that we can expand on the regional or the interstate flying with
2:05:08 The scheduled charter that can still divert to mission. Yeah, and I've been a long time supporter of the regional solution, but I think we start getting into the implementation of this program, to Grady's point, how are people going to get from mission to, and I think the private sector at some point wants to kind of step out and say, well, ESTA's going to figure that out, you guys can figure all this stuff out. That's just not real, and I think that they need to be.
2:05:35 At the table, I mean, we've supported this, and I certainly support this transition, but they need to be at the table to be helping to figure out how the solution is going to work. Absolutely correct. In fact, when I mentioned it to the town manager earlier today, I said there needs to be three parties given this presentation. It's Inyo County, MLT, and Altera slash MSA there in that session. So absolutely correct. I just didn't mention them earlier, but they'd absolutely be requested.
2:06:01 And, John, I'll fill you in a little bit on the transportation side. I've been working on that for well over a year here, not only with local providers, but other providers that provide this service for places like Gunnison and Crescent Butte, Montrose, with Telluride, Steamboat, and Hayden. So, you know, working with a number of different people to make sure that we do have that solution, working with Enterprise and National Rental Car, who we've had at the airport here for a decade, and making sure that we have multiple options for people to be able to link up and down the hill.
2:06:32 Great, thank you very much. Thank you, John. Other council members, questions or comments? Seeing none, John, my issues are pretty much the same to Mr. Wentworth. I have not seen anything on the logistics yet that puts me at ease in any way, shape, or form. Is the bus service going to stop at all the various condos? Are we going to have our well-heeled passengers who can afford air service come up and get dumped off at the post office or at the so-so?
2:07:06 I am looking for answers. The fact that we have all studied it for a year or two does be no good. The other issues are, you know, currently we subsidize about, I think it's 20 or 25 percent out of general fund dollars because the next study shows that they are not directly benefiting customers. If it is 70 percent in Bishop, and I think it will be actually less than that to directly affect Mammoth.
2:07:34 Who is going to pay that subsidy piece? How is that going to be done? Is the mountain going to step up to that plate? Is the town of Bishop? Is the county of Vigneault? These also are questions that I have not heard answers to my satisfaction on yet. So I am still very concerned about this transition. Would you like some answers? If you want to give them. So the way that the transportation is being looked at is that
2:08:03 You know, very similar to those models that I mentioned in Colorado is that if you fly into Montrose, which is the reliable airport for Telluride, you know, you'll get off the plane, you'll go in, you'll say, I'm staying at Mountain Village, you'll go in this van, there are five stops that come off, you might be the fifth stop and you get dropped off right at your door. And so that is really the model that we're looking at versus a motor coach that would drop you off in a park and ride and have, you know, hotel shuttles come and pick you up.
2:08:31 And so, again, we are working with local transportation companies, but also working with the gentleman that runs those and owns those services in Colorado because he has the services, he has the system, he has the equipment, he has the insurance, he has the know-how and the experience. So that is the transportation plan. We are still working to finalize it, but that is the plan anyway. As far as subsidy goes, I think you're referring basically to the fact that with the current subsidies, we have blocked out 18 to 20 percent.
2:09:01 For local traffic, meaning that there are residents that are flying in and out of the airport that we don't pay for with the T-BID funds. Because the idea behind the T-BID with Prop 26 is that the expenditure of T-BID funds have to benefit people to pay into it. So if you or I are flying in and out, we're not tourists, we're not definitely benefiting 1849 condos or the Westin or whatever.
2:09:26 And so that's always been the case with Mammoth, and we've always had the Measure A funds that have backed up those TBIT funds for that 20%. Moving into Bishop, we are going to be doing intercept surveys to figure out exactly how many people are coming up the hill, and then of those people, how many of them are locals versus coming to vacation and spend money. And so we also know that people are going to fly into Bishop and stay in Bishop. We know that people are going to go to Death Valley. We know that people are going to go to Lone Pine. You know, there are multiple other places.
2:09:56 And INYAL has, we have talked to them about subsidy on their side. They don't have a ton of money set aside for it. And the discussions have been there with Altera on commitments to other pieces of subsidy. And so that's all I can speak to right now. I don't have the answer for you for Altera. I think Councilmember Wentworth saying that we need to have them at the presentation as well is accurate. I can't speak for them, won't speak for them.
2:10:22 I can speak for what we're looking at. All of our subsidy dollars down in Bishop will be coming from TBIT funds. Here in Mammoth, it could be a combination of TBIT and Measure A, because obviously they're right here in town and coming to town to spend money. But those are the two plans. Okay, thank you, John. Grady, anything further? Yes, the next subject really, though, is just not on that subject anymore, except that you can see that there's a lot of complexity to every part of this, and that's why I'm going to recommend a workshop again.
2:10:54 The regional planning issue, FAA has commented that they will provide us with a planning grant. It probably won't be until early 2023, however, or 22, excuse me, about a year from now. In advance of that, we're meeting with Nino County, we've talked to Bono County, and we've talked to Caltrans now about the possibility of starting that study earlier on our own dime where it would then be reimbursed later with that planning grant.
2:11:19 Caltrans was able to give me a draft scope of work that they've used for a California Aviation System plan. I'm working through that right now to prepare a draft scope so we can get a cost estimate on that and get it back to F.A. and all the parties and see if we can move forward. But we're really excited about that as well, the ability to work with everybody else in the region on all the airports, all the airstrips, and have one document that can guide us moving forward.
2:11:45 Next, number four, and again, this is another reason why your workshop's appropriate. There are three capital improvement program projects, three grants that are underway. One is the environmental assessment. We actually got comments back from FAA. It's actually letter C on your staff report. On that, they were not a lot of comments. We think we're going to be able to wrap those up in a couple of weeks, get our environmental assessment out for public review in May and wrap that up.
2:12:13 It does have projects in there which we do not expect, frankly, to build within the next 10 or 20 years. It actually has, if you recall, a terminal building. The idea is there we didn't do any design on it, but we wanted to cover it from an environmental standpoint should conditions change in the next 10 to 15 years. But it does include an ARF vehicle, not ARF vehicle, excuse me, an ARF maintenance facility and snow management facility, things like that. So that's moving forward.
2:12:40 Two construction projects that are happening this summer. One is our security fencing and gates project on the north side to put an actual eight-foot fence on the north side of the airport and better security gates for access in the airport. The other is an East General Aviation grant project, which will come back to you in May for award, both, again, 90% plus funded by FAA monies on that. The other two grants that aren't on here, and I'll mention them later, but they are actual grants.
2:13:10 Last year in May, in March, excuse me, we got $1,096,000 CARES funding from FAA to support the airport. Most of that was actually used to support the general fund to reduce our general fund contribution to the airport, which is typically about $700,000 a year and will be going up in the future. The only reason I mention it here is that we today executed the second grant, which was $1,500,000, which we can use over the next three years for similar things.
2:13:40 I mentioned it before, whatever monies we're getting from the feds to help with local government, we've gotten $2 million out of them that directly support the general fund that is coming through the airport because we don't have to subsidize the airport so much. Other projects that are in our airport capital improvement program, we have long talked about a wildlife perimeter fence that would go along the south side of the airport and the rest of the perimeter.
2:14:06 Thanks to 395. That's still on hold. We still will be working with the Forest Service NFA to get that released. There's some discussion between the biologists about what the deers actually do when they run into a fence. Do they go around? Do they go back on 395? I don't want to give in more detail on that, but we're still working with the county and Couch and NFA on that. The next and probably most critical is our snow removal equipment and our vehicles sit out in the weather a lot of the year.
2:14:34 And it makes it very difficult during the winter as well, and it deteriorates more quickly. We put in a project to FAA for a $5 million, 8,000 square foot facility to house that equipment. FAA has said that they are going to support our request for funds for that. That doesn't mean we have a lock on discretionary funds, but they have said many times that they support us on this and they'll do what they can.
2:15:02 And just very recently, we also submitted that particular project to Congressman Obernolte's office. He did a call for projects. That was one that the town put in for that. And I actually spent about two hours today answering some questions on that that were due by 5 p.m. today to hopefully move that forward. So there's various opportunities for that. I'm not sure how much of the money that comes through Congress will get to us during the next budget, but it's in.
2:15:29 Other projects, I don't want to go into a lot of detail. Again, this is a long meeting, but in our ACIP, we have rehabilitate our T-hanger taxi lanes. We have board general aviation apron, widening taxiways. In addition, there's other projects that we're looking at. Again, good reason to look at our airport layout program in a workshop. Our existing ramp space by our existing terminal. I will tell you that immediately...
2:15:55 We're going to get rid of that red stripe and open that up for more GA and more of the scheduled charter facility. If it doesn't have a red stripe on it, it's not TSA controlled, it's not the same level of security, and we can be much more flexible in how we use that. I will say that we've already started talking about our existing terminal building and the sprung structure. We have no intention of doing any major TIs by any means in that existing terminal building or the sprung structure at this time. I think...
2:16:24 Bishop expects to operate in December. We wish them well. We hope it works. We expect it to work. But if something slows it down or anything, we need to be ready to have that terminal provide services. And we're not going to spend money on rehabbing something that might have to go backwards. So that's on hold for now. Also in that airport layout program is helicopter parking and a taxiway to the north side.
2:16:49 There was one time last summer we had seven helicopters on the ground at the same time, all firefighting. It's a great base of operation for fires even as far over on the west side, 70 miles from here by air. Also in there we've talked about land acquisition for LADWP. You don't know it, about a third of our runway is on LADWP land and they'd like to dispose of that and we'd like to have it in ownership rather than a long-term base.
2:17:17 The last one I'll talk about really is our Forest Service land. We have a vision that from Airport Road South should be in the airport someday. And right now only a small portion of that is. There's a big section between Airport Road, which is north of the airport, at the airport. It's still owned by the Forest Service. We've started discussions with that. We haven't picked them up again due to COVID and everything else in the Forest Service being as busy as they are. But that's our future.
2:17:45 One thing under financial considerations, and I'll leave this alone, but we'll get into more detail later. Right now, we transfer approximately $700,000 a year from the general fund to support airport operations. That's going to go up. If we don't have the $200,000 in revenue that we get out of our regular scheduled commercial service, that contribution will go up to $900,000 or $1 million. We need to talk about that for future years, okay?
2:18:13 So that's something. Also the entitlement money, we have $2.8 million available right now in entitlement funds. We're using that up on the East GAA. It's an important project. It's a big project that we need to do. So those will be gone. And in the future, currently, we don't have any other entitlement funds earned because last year we didn't get anywhere near 10,000 employments. I think we got around 8,000 and we'll work to try to see if we can get some relief from FAA on that.
2:18:43 And then certainly in 2021, we don't see 10,000 in playments. John described very well our goal is to get back to that 10,000 in the future through scheduled charges. Also, passenger facilities charges. When we were at 20,000 to 30,000 in playments, those are bringing in about $100,000 a year, which we use for our matching funds for projects. Without commercial flights, you can't charge passenger facility charges. So we're going to have to look at a way to replace those funds.
2:19:11 That really does it. What I'd like to do is turn over to any questions you have at this time. We can certainly come back for a workshop. And I do have a question if you'd like us to contact Inyo County and ask them along with MLT and Altera to make a presentation about the approach for the future. So thank you. Thank you, Grady. Any further questions, comments from Council? Starting with Linda? Nothing? Okay. No, I don't think so. Grady,
2:19:45 How much was the first CARES grant? $1,096,000 from March of last year. Oh, okay. I was missing a zero in there. I thought it was close to two. I was like, okay. Yeah, that's all I got. Thank you. John? My sense is that the environment out there is extremely chaotic, with chaotic subsidies, air service being hammered all over the place. But I, again, just to emphasize, I think that it needs to be,
2:20:19 Regional discussion with all the interested parties. And I hope it's not formatted in such a way that everybody's just talking at everybody else, but we're starting to understand how this is going to work. And, John Erdi, I've used those services out of Montrose. I know all this stuff works. It can work effectively. But I think we need to be talking with each other and working together to make all this successful. So those are my only thoughts. Thank you.
2:20:48 Thank you, John. Current questions or comments? No comments. Thank you. Sarah? Nothing from me. Thank you. Thank you. The budget feeds, Grady, is very critical on this because we lose our 10,000 employment. I have talked to several people involved who believe we can get there with the charter service. It was my impression that we couldn't use charter.
2:21:18 Thank you very much. Thank you, Grady, as always. Moving on to consent. I will try to do this in such a way that you can hear me.
2:21:52 Approve the minutes of the regular meeting of April 7. Approve the minutes of the special meeting of April 9. Approve the resolution continuing the local emergency regarding COVID. Waive the reading and adopt by title only the ordinance making required CEQA and municipal code findings and approving zoning code amendment 20-001 to update municipal code chapter 17.44 parking and loading standards.
2:22:19 Award a contract with transit shelters to space construction. Approve side letters between the Town of Mammoth Lakes and General Employees Association, Management Employees Association and Public Works Employees Association. Modify Article 11 of the MOUs as it relates to deferred compensation. Community recreation center subcontractor substitutions. And accept payment approval reports number 21-43, 21-44.
2:22:50 Does anyone wish to pull anything from consent? Seeing nothing, I would then entertain a motion. Mr. Mayor, I would move that the Town Council approve the consent agenda items as you have so eloquently presented. Thank you. Second that. Who was my second from? Is that Kirk? Linda. Okay, I have a motion from John, a second from Linda. Any further deliberations, please? Seeing none, Jamie. Councilmember Ray?
2:23:28 Yes. Councilmember Stapp. Yes. Councilmember Wentworth. Yes. Mayor Tim Salcido. Mayor Salzer. Aye. Okay, that was my best hiring. I failed completely. Public hearing. I will, this Community Belt and Block Grant 2021 NOFA public hearing authorizing the middle of grant application, I will open the public hearing officially. Nolan.
2:24:03 All right, thank you. Let me share my screen. All right, so this is the public hearing for the application for the 2021 CDBG NOFA. Quick, if anyone wants to provide any comments, here's the information, and it will be on all subsequent screens as well. Just a quick recap of the program. The HCD manages the...
2:24:38 Funding that comes from the federal level and allocates those funds to local jurisdictions. In January of 2021, HCD announced $30 million in federal funds for the 2021 CDBG program. The town held a public hearing on April 7, 2021, and two activities were proposed for consideration. Those two activities were a home buyer assistance program that was proposed by the town and MLH.
2:25:07 And a child care site feasibility study as proposed by First Five Mono County. We have discussed both programs further with the appropriate entities and are recommending submittal of applications for both programs. First one is the Home Buyer Assistance Program. It's for single family units up to $500,000 being requested from the state.
2:25:36 That program will benefit low to moderate income households by providing homebuyer assistance to income eligible households to assist with the purchase of a home. Income eligible households are defined as those earning 80% or below of the area median income. And the second proposed activity is a planning study. So we're requesting up to $250,000. The actual amount will get
2:26:03 Finalized through discussions with First Five, Mona County and the ultimate Brianna consultant to prepare the study. The purpose of the study will be a child care site feasibility studies. This will be looking throughout the town to identify potential sites. And then if a site is selected to develop shovel ready plans.
2:26:26 So we're in position to apply for future capital CDBG funds on a future NOFA to actually construct a facility. That facility would be required to provide child care for income eligible households. I believe it's a minimum of 70% of the
2:26:51 Attendees at the child care facility must come from income eligible households in order to use CDBG funds for that facility. So this will benefit low to moderate income households by identifying potential sites for a future child care facility that will provide subsidized child care services. So that is the conclusion of my presentation and a summary of the two activities that we're looking to apply for.
2:27:19 So I'll kind of skip over the recommendation, just touch on next steps. The state did extend the application deadline to June 14th, 2021. Originally it was April 30th. So prior to that June 14th deadline, but hopefully sooner since we have everything in place almost for that April 30th deadline, we'll be submitting soon. We're also going to bring the updated Homebuyer Program Guidelines to Town Council for adoption.
2:27:47 That is a requirement from HCD, HCD to have those at the time you apply. And then after that, we will await notification from HCD on an award. With that, I'll stop sharing my screen and turn it back over to Town Council for discussion. Thank you, Nolan. Questions for Town Council? You're muted. We're always muted. Yeah, give me a second. I was looking for some of my notes. Come back to me, okay?
2:28:27 I certainly will. John. Thank you. Thank you very much, Nolan and staff, for bringing these ideas, these project ideas forward. A little concerned about the Mono County piece, but let's see. Let's go in here and see how this works out. But no comments, no questions. Thank you. Thank you, John. Sarah? Yeah, I see Molly's on the call with her hand raised, so I guess I would like to hear a little more.
2:28:57 More about the plan for that. I know I had said the other week I didn't want to see this spent on studies, but yeah, I'm just curious what Molly has to add to that. Thank you, Sarah. Yes, I think we need to submit for the grant. Thank you. Thank you, Kirk. I would concur that I would support moving this forward at this point. Did you find your notes, Linda?
2:29:32 Yes, it had to do with the first five. It just seems to me that there have been former child care site feasibility studies. And is it necessary to repeat this again? I know that that information, I think, was held within first five and the Office of Education. And I guess I just would like to kind of more of an update on.
2:30:01 Thank you, Linda. Nolan, do you want to answer that question or can you? No, I would think, I know Molly is available to answer what other studies and a little more detail on the proposed study. I would, if right now is the proper time, have Jamie unmute Molly. Yeah. Molly? Good evening, council members, honorable mayor.
2:30:38 Thank you for the questions already and any that might come up after I say any words. I also want to say thank you to Sandra and Glenn for spending some time talking to me this week and making sure that our visions were aligned and we shared some common purpose in the potential for applying for a CDBG planning grant for a child care facility in Mammoth Lakes. And I'll start…
2:31:07 With Councilmember Salcido's question, I think it was the most pointed, that an answer that yes, there have been feasibility studies done in the past. They're over 10 years old. And in order to apply for CDBG construction funding, a proposal has to be shovel ready.
2:31:27 And all of the financial assumptions from 10 years ago, as well as the site control are no longer valid. So it is in some ways a repeat of things that have been done in the past. But in order to get to a building phase, it needs to be done again. Okay. So the question I have then, I know that from the first five funding streams that go into the first five commission,
2:32:00 So I have not seen the budget this year for First Five Commission. And so within the budget this year, the proposed budget for next year, Molly, is there any money being put aside for the study of feasibility of child care development or developing child care, et cetera? How is the First Five budget playing into this?
2:32:31 The Child Care Commission, what is their current scope of work around child care development? Yeah, good questions. Sharing the lay of the land for all of us that have our hats in that ring of creating child care availability in Mono County. First five, Mono County's budget does not include any money for planning. In the past, I have been able to allocate some of my time.
2:32:59 As far as the Child Care Council is concerned, their funds are primarily utilized with materials.
2:33:29 To support providers. And it's time for the coordinator to hold meetings, convene planning. And they do not, to my knowledge, which I am a council member, have a specific allocation this year or next year dedicated to planning for child care slots. Although that is the overarching goal of the council.
2:33:59 There's just not a staff time allocation associated directly, especially not the funding source for any of the council members, really. And I guess that brings me back to thinking about this whole endeavor to develop child care within the county and the town. And that would be that this is a multi-partner endeavor.
2:34:26 We really need to bring everybody back to the table that were there, you know, those years ago when we were really working hard on this together. And that includes the county, the town, Mountain Major Employers, First Life Commission, you know, and so have we made any strides in reestablishing that partnership group to work on child care as opposed to just...
2:34:51 You know, the town getting money and doing a feasibility study, because once that is done, then where does that go to? And that, you know, either the office vet or to reconvene that child care endeavor as a partnership once again. Yeah, again, great question. And I think that, gosh, there's so many things I think.
2:35:17 That it is absolutely imperative to have multiple partners. And of course, that's why I'm coming to the town, because the town is the only entity eligible to draw down these funds. In terms of the parties that were at the table 10 years ago, there's somewhat of a bifurcation of need along the income lines. So many of the partners that you mentioned are seeking to provide care for
2:35:47 Employees for staff. And the hospital has always been one of those big entities that have child care that wants staff to have access to child care. I would put the school district in the same boat. The issue with bringing those partners in, and I think in planning phases, they absolutely will be included. I mean, that would be the purpose of the planning grant, is that we have some funds to allocate staff time to spend a lengthy
2:36:16 Time period, making sure that, you know, all the community stakeholders, and I'm preaching to the choir here, you know, you guys just went through this long process with the parcel, and I would see this being somewhat similar, but that when push comes to shove, as Nolan mentioned, there is a financial requirement when using community development block grant funds to offer those slots primarily to folks that are low and moderate income.
2:36:44 Which is at somewhat odds with some of the partners that would have been at the table 10 years ago. But I don't think that it would be possible to do a complete planning process without consulting with county office events, school district, hospital, the mountain, you know, all of the parties that have an interest in childcare. I just wanted to give a little bit of a line of sight to that bifurcation of income level.
2:37:15 Okay. Thank you, Molly. More to come. Thank you. Yeah, and I would jump in and say that, you know, if there were more child care for even people, any more child care is going to ease the strain on the child care that's already completely overwhelmed. So I think that's important to keep in mind in terms of the low and moderate income child care needs. I just wanted to...
2:37:47 Jump in because that's something we've been talking about where I'm at. So I had a question, but it slipped my mind. Sorry. No, I hope it comes back. And I completely agree, Councilwoman Rhea, that if there's slots open for some people, then there's going to be slots that open in other places, right? There's a lot of family-funded neighbors in Mammoth. There are some private sector.
2:38:18 Thank you. Jamie, public comments on this. Patricia, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Thank you, Jamie. Good evening, Town Council. This is Patricia Robertson. I'm coming to you this evening as a First Five commissioner. I've served on the commission for three-plus years now, I believe.
2:38:54 And during our last strategic planning process, we determined that finding ways to create additional child care slots was a priority of first five. And that, you know, the need is so great. I think Molly mentioned that the last public hearing, there's a need of 400 or so slots. I believe just in Mammoth. And I think that need.
2:39:23 It's been made even greater because of COVID. I think some in-home providers closed last year. And every day I'm talking to somebody who's struggling because they don't have care for their child. And I think that the commission sees CDBG funding as an opportunity for our community to really push forward.
2:39:52 And so I just wanted the town council to know that
2:40:20 The First Five Commission is aware of this and we're excited for the opportunity to explore actual opportunities to provide child care and I implore the Town Council to support this application so that we can move this conversation forward. Thank you. Thank you, Patricia. Any further public comments? That is all the public comments. Thank you. With that, I will close the public hearing.
2:40:52 And bring it back for deliberation to council and our motion. John? Mr. Mayor, unless there's any other further discussion, I would move that we adopt the application as presented by staff. Thank you. I'll second the motion. I have a motion for John, a second for Kirk. Any further deliberations? Seeing none, I will call for the item. Jamie? Councilmember Ray? Yes. Councilmember Stapp? Yes.
2:41:31 Council Member Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Salcido? Yes. Mayor Souser? Yes. Council Member 5-0, thank you all very much. Mayor, I would request we have a short break at this time, please. Yes, that will be my next question of Council. It is now 640. We will reconvene at 645. Thank you all. Okay. Sarah and Linda, are you with us? Hello.
2:48:06 I see Linda. I'm here. Just waiting for Sarah. Sarah, if you can hear me, turn your picture on so I know you're here. Sorry. There we are. Now we're all back together. The group is here. Moving on to item number 12, discussion, update, and possible action related to declared COVID-19 public health and economic emergency. Dan.
2:50:37 Trust, you can see my screen there. We'll work through some information regarding to COVID where we're at in the orange tier now that we've now been placed into that tier effective today. Give it a little update on the framework that's been updated. And then as we're ongoing with vaccinations, testing, and some next steps as we continue through the management of the pandemic. First and foremost, we touched on this last time, but as far as we know, we're still on target.
2:51:06 For the potential full reopening of the state, for the most part, June 15th, assuming we meet the two standards of the vaccine availability to anybody who desires one at 16 years and older, and that we have a consistently low burden of disease, so we're not impacting our ICUs or our hospitalization rates are low, so the hospitals are not impacted. So ongoing through that, there is likely to be some level of ongoing
2:51:34 Modifications required, discussion on that off and on with the state on what that might look like. But for Mono County, we have moved into that orange tier effective today. We'll be in that tier for a minimum of three weeks. We would then need to hit the requirements for a yellow tier two weeks in a row. But this last measurement week, utilized to move us in the orange tier, we had a very good...
2:52:00 Outcome with a less than 1% test positivity rate, 0.8, and also a case rate with 100,000 level of 3.1, so well within the case rate numbers, 2 to 5.9, and the positivity rate between 2 and 4. So we actually had hit that well this last measurement period. Some of the key changes for the orange tier.
2:52:25 One for restaurants, indoors modification still, but they have a 50% capacity of 200 people, whichever is the less. Wineries, bars, and distilleries, 25% capacity or 100 people. All retail is now open indoors without a occupancy limit with modifications. Again, that's looking at face coverings and hand cleaning and those types of elements that are in there. Movie theaters, the same at that 50% with a 200 person limit. And then.
2:52:55 Hotels and lodging, their fitness centers can be open at 25% capacity. Indoor pools can open providing they can have physical distancing between non-household members. However, the indoor hot tubs and saunas and steam rooms and those elements are still to remain closed. Outdoor spas can be open with certain modifications. Similar for gyms and fitness centers.
2:53:19 Again, that 25% capacity, the same element with the indoor pool. That'll help Snow Creek as it can open its indoor pool up at this point. They need to maintain that separation element there. Also, again, the indoor, if there's any hot tubs and saunas, they would remain closed as well.
2:53:35 And then the family entertainment centers, this impacts our bowling alley here locally. They have a 25% capacity limit or 50% if they can show that all guests are either having a recent test of negativity and or approve full vaccination in place. And then there's some modifications related there still with face coverings unless it's in the food and dining area, which are identified as separate areas versus.
2:54:04 At the bowling lanes, for example. And so there is some restrictions there. And if they have alcohol service, that has to be outdoors only if it's not being served with a meal being provided. So it'll give a lot of different businesses in town that opportunity to expand out. The state has also, they've talked about this the last couple of weeks, provided an updated small county framework.
2:54:27 If I recall several months ago, we worked with that to be able to have a much higher standard before we'd have to move backwards through the tiers. The request that was made by several small counties was to make that modification effective so we could actually move forward in the tiers. So as you note here, tier three, that moderate orange.
2:54:49 The updated framework would put us between 7 and 13 cases, so very highly unlikely it's going backwards into the red tier given the past several weeks. And they would be looking at both the case adjusted rate, but then if that is over, they'll look at the just hard case rate, which moves us down a couple percentage points potentially. And then also look at other factors should there be a concern. And then the
2:55:17 Yellow tier, tier four there, you would actually only have to have to have less than seven cases. So that there element really helps us be able to look at potentially moving into that yellow tier at the end of the three-week period, assuming our current efforts are continued. The positivity rate would be probably the tightest element there, needing to be below 2%.
2:55:44 Well, we did hit that this last week, so it is doable here in Mammoth and Mono County, provided we continue to be vigilant in our efforts to manage the disease and spread of it.
2:55:58 Part of that is ongoing testing work that is still being provided through OptumServe. The information is here. You can go on the website, confirm that up. You can sign up for testing or you can walk in and get signed up there at the Mammoth Lakes Foundation Building, the Edison Theater. They are still providing the testing services through there. And then you can check and see where they're at throughout the county in different locations as well.
2:56:25 On the vaccine side of the house, this was updated later today, I haven't checked it recently, but we're pushing 7,000 fully vaccinated individuals in Mono County. That includes workers and people who are living here. At this point, too, in all of the testing facilities and the vaccine facilities, we are vaccinating everybody 16 years of age or older.
2:56:51 Provided we have the adequate vaccines in place and either live or work in Mono County. And at this point, living in Mono County has been extended to include second homeowners. So if you're here and you're going in, again, availability of those who have signed up coming through first and then walk-ins are being accepted. This is a list of the various clinics out there. I won't read through all those. This is on the website, but the next couple, the 17th and Bridgeport.
2:57:20 The 19th here in Mammoth Lakes, 24th in Colville, and then end of the month in Benton. So they are spreading out throughout the county. We encourage people, if you're listening throughout the county, take advantage of these. Some of them have a very, very low turnout rate, and they're really pushing that to try to make sure that we're providing that opportunity that people are taking advantage of that. Ultimately,
2:57:43 As we look at some other tiers and look at some options, if we happen to have a higher rate, is looking at the vaccination level in our community. And right now, Mono County is doing very well. We will be shortly, I think, pushing close to that 70 or 80 percent of the eligible population in the county, as well as a lot of the people who work in Mono County, but don't.
2:58:05 Necessarily live in the county, whether they're coming in from Nevada or Inyo County or other places to work here in Mara County. As we continue this, as we go forward, we really are continuing to focus on that testing and vaccination program. Our clinics have been running extremely smooth and we've been very pleased with that activity.
2:58:28 As we continue to look out into that June timeframe or thereabouts, we're still looking at a staged demobilization of our EOC. That is in the process. We've been stepping down frequency of meetings and some of the high-level activity and the amount of activity, for example, in our public outreach and the JIC activity as people are slowly stepping back into their regular work programs as that site is picking up demands and requirements of employees.
2:58:58 We continue to update information. There are press releases that are going out or on the website. That continues to happen as we get information. We push that out. And then also a key issue is kind of that transition to recovery and disease management. We want to make sure that we're hitting areas of concern that are out there that we can still provide support where needed. And also, again, not forgetting to do those key elements of just
2:59:26 You know, where required, have your face covering, where required social distancing, and always looking at some good hygiene, especially in the hand washing area and sanitation areas. We are also monitoring changes in state guidance. For example, just 415, there was a change in the gathering guidance. They had put out some documents earlier, effective on the 15th of April. So trying to make sure that information is current. We're able to push that out.
2:59:56 There's recent changes in religious gatherings that they have requirements there, but they're non-mandatory. It's strongly recommended issues. That was updated 4-12, I believe, as a result of Supreme Court action. So we want to continue to be diligent in the things that we're doing as the disease is still in our community. It's not over yet.
3:00:18 We've talked a lot about transitioning out of this pandemic, but also understanding the impact that it's had and how do we do so successfully. The last thing we want to see is a big uptick in cases. There are continuing concerns with variants and other activities that you see throughout the country and around the world. And so that's an ongoing challenge, but the extent that we can truly make our own locale.
3:00:43 As much as we can virus-proof to protect our residents and workers, that is a huge effort, a huge push over the next several weeks. With that, that's a quick overview. Be glad to take any questions that the council may have or additional comments. Thank you. Thank you, Dan. Questions or comments for Dan? I will let you raise your hands this time instead of calling you out. No comments.
3:01:19 Most of this, Dan, is very good news. I am glad we're finally moving forward from this thing. As I said at the park today, I'm waiting for the day when, like, graduates from school, we can all throw our masks in the air and celebrate. So thank you. Any public comments on this, Jamie? No, there are not. Thank you. Moving on to item number 13. Mr. Mayor, I'm sorry, but I didn't have any comment on Dan's update, but...
3:01:50 We will need to be thinking a little bit about the emergency order, rescindings, you know, that kind of stuff. Maybe even start talking about if we want to start doing in-person meetings. I'd like to have a discussion about that just because I think that the public engagement in a virtual platform has been perhaps a little bit better than it is in the analog platforms, but we can talk about that. But just for future discussion, I know, Dan, you're aware of this stuff. How do we really...
3:02:18 Ultimately transition out of this and that's what we're going to be able to do. You know, if I could, Dan, one of the things on this, on the gatherings that we're seeing some guidelines from the state, like on bowling alleys, I saw some language today that indicated that they were going to be adjusting capacity based on vaccine status of those people coming in and or if people had a negative test in their hand to show you. So that's why we're kind of waiting for this gathering.
3:02:46 These gathering things to say. So does that mean we might be able to meet, you know, sitting on the floor six feet apart, with or without masks, and who comes in to talk to us? I mean, these are not worked out well, so I don't know that we're quite there. I don't believe we are. Someone asked me about that at the shovel event today, and my best guess was the closest I could see is the first meeting of July, possibly.
3:03:16 For going back to in person, but I don't see anything prior to that. We have to wait and see what the state's order is going to be and what the rules are going to be at that point. Right. And there's this whole conversation now about sort of these vaccine passports or your verification of passports, the cottage industry now that started around, you know, multiplying vaccine cards and, you know, it's the state's trying to figure it out. I mean, they have.
3:03:46 They definitely have a database of who all is vaccinated and who's not. And so I don't know how accessible that's going to be. So we're waiting to see how they're going to. I was on a state call the other day and they're still struggling with that. I also would like to chime in that someone brought up last meeting about the fact that we are a public meeting where the public is welcome to come. And although we may all be vaccinated, there is, that's the fact that we are.
3:04:15 Having the public in a room is fraught with, you know, scary stuff. And I'm not sure who read that article about the nursing home where one, you know, unvaccinated staff member spread it and someone who was vaccinated passed away. And it's still pretty spooky to think about having a bunch of people in a big room since we see. And I also think it's important that we set an example of being safe.
3:04:47 Okay, any further comments on that one? Moving on then to item number 13, approve the 2021 youth sports funding recommendation. Stu. Thank you, Mayor, members of Town Council and many community members watching us this evening. I have the wonderful pleasure of presenting the annual youth sports funding recommendation. So hopefully you can see that. I will make it a little bit...
3:05:16 And I'm almost lost now that I don't get to speak every couple of weeks in front of the community with our COVID conversation. So here we go. But just a wonderful program that the Recreation Commission has been managing for several years. I have the privilege and honor to provide additional funding to our many youth sports organizations, not only here in town, but across Mono County. We have a sum of 36,800.
3:05:44 8,000 of that is contributed from Mono County. So for the past five years, the county has provided the $8,000 match to benefit those other programs in Mono County, such as Little League, AYSO, Mammoth Lake Swim Team, that operate with a large portion of county residents as well as town residents. So again, just a wonderful program, truly, you know, regional wide. Again, just want to applaud.
3:06:14 Acknowledge Supervisor Corliss for working with us to pull this program together and to the County Board of Supervisors for their ongoing support of this wonderful program. So we open up applications each and every year around this time. This year we had nine applications. We published the funding applications online and then the Recreation Commission not only reviews but they also...
3:06:39 Go over the funding form, the application, the questions that they need to ask, all those details just to make sure it's a very transparent and open process. And then the commission met on April 13th and they unanimously approved the funding recommendations as presented in table one. Before I get to those, again, just a wonderful program. You know, I just want to acknowledge Andrea Colisado and the whole Colisado family.
3:07:09 For putting together and working with staff on the Tony Colisato Scholarship Fund. I mean, just a tremendous program to really reach into the community and provide, you know, parks and recreation programs for each and every person, regardless of their income. So what we want to do here is that as part of this program, we want to allocate each of these youth supporting organizations to full scholarships, and then they'll be awarded the discretion of each organization. So again, just a wonderful way to promote inclusivity.
3:07:39 So the funding recommendations in your packet and all this information I'm presenting with you this evening is in your packet. I just kind of pulled out the highlights. You can see here we're looking at this first column here, 2021 recommendation. And you can see across the board it's about a 4% increase from the 2020 recommendation. That is essentially due to the Eastern Sierra Soccer Club not submitting an application this year. So we just divided.
3:08:09 Those additional funds, you can see the $1,112.50 fairly across those eight organizations. As in the past, and we have historically done, Mammoth Lakes, sorry, Mammoth Unified School District Husky Club receives their $6,000. So that's kind of their set allocation. And then we move up and down those recommendations of those other sporting groups based on the number of applications that we get.
3:08:39 Sorry, what is interesting here, you can see here on the 2021 request and 2020 request, you know, it's obviously a lot more requests than the money we have, but each of the organizations provide a report each and every year, and we can clearly see where the money goes, and the commission is satisfied that that money is being well spent, you know, across the entire community. So the recommendation in your packet is to 123, approve.
3:09:08 The youth sports funding recommendations as listed under column A in table one. Allocate each youth sports organization the two full scholarships funded by the Tony Colisado Scholarship Fund. And number three, we put this in only because we still have some doubt, there's some uncertainty. We believe we're confident enough as in most groups can operate this spring, summer and fall. But we do want to kind of
3:09:36 Highlight that this funding application is really pending compliance with the CDPH, or California Department of Public Health, outdoor, indoor youth and recreational sports guidelines as they do change. And we know this is a very dynamic pandemic. So in the event the current pandemic prevents any youth sports organizations from undertaking their season, funds will not be awarded to that organization. Essentially, we just hold those funds.
3:10:03 So, with that, Mayor, I'm happy to want to answer any questions, but again, just a wonderful program, and thank you for the opportunity to present it to you this evening. Thank you. Questions or comments from Council? Just that it makes me really happy to know that we're focusing on helping kids who maybe the families otherwise wouldn't prioritize this or be able to prioritize this, and that is the goal of this.
3:10:39 Happy with the Colisado Fund. It's just, it's all really good news. It's really good to see this too, so thank you. You're very welcome. Thank you. Thumbs up. Thank you. All around. Yep. Do we have any public comment on this? No, we do not. Thank you very much. That being said, John? Mr. Mayor, I would move that the Town Council...
3:11:09 Approve the allocations as recommended by staff. Seconded that. I have a motion from John, a second from Linda. Any proof of deliberation? Jamie? Councilmember Rae? Yes. Councilmember Stapp? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Temp-Salcido? Yes. Mayor Souser? Yes. Passed appropriately so, 5-0. Thank you. Thank you, everyone. Moving on to item 14, fiscal year 21-22.
3:11:41 preliminary budget. Rob. Yes, thank you, Mayor, Councilmembers. Tonight, I'm presenting to you the department requested, which is our first sort of larger portion of the budget. Remember, the last one we did was our revenues. So we'll touch a little bit on some updates to those revenues, but kind of walk through the preliminary budget, mainly focusing tonight on staff costs. That's kind of a high portion of our budget.
3:12:11 It's around 51% of our total expenditures for general fund anyway. And we'll talk through a little bit of that. And we'll also cover gas tax and our airport fund. So this is sort of a miniature introduction to the budget. We'll get into a lot more in the tentative where I add a lot of the restricted revenue accounts as well as assessment districts and different accounts.
3:12:39 That's kind of the complete budget once we get to that point. But tonight, I'll share my screen. Hopefully you guys can see that. And I can progress. Yeah. So the general fund rejected revenue. There's not been much changed in this since you've last seen it, since we presented this on April 7th. We do get updates to this fairly frequently. We are working through
3:13:18 Some updated property tax information, some updated sales tax information, and then we did some refinements to the program revenue expected from the Parks and Recs program. That's the minor adjustments that you see between the $24,399,000 that we're projecting tonight and what we showed you last time. So not a significant adjustment. We'll kind of talk on the point of, you know,
3:13:46 We went really low last year in our presentation for TOT, or our projection for TOT, because we were just uncertain about how the pandemic was going to flow, how the visitation was going to respond. I'm kind of happy to say that it was stronger than our 11.2 million. Looking at the collections for March, which was due yesterday, we're...
3:14:14 We're around $12.2 million through March. So I'm really looking for that number to exceed budget expectations for the current fiscal year by about $3.5 to $4 million. And so that's exciting, but that's a tough one to project. And this year, you know, we put that number at $14.5. We've never been that high in a budget in my years here anyway. And I think it's appropriate, though.
3:14:43 We do anticipate, I'll probably get, we'll probably get close to that within this current fiscal year, so next year. That's a good conservative number to start with. We talked quite a bit about property tax and its performance. The minor adjustments to that are really reflective of, you know, continuing to get more refined data on that revenue stream as well as sales tax. I'm not really probably going to adjust sales tax that much because it is quite volatile, but we'll go and roll through.
3:15:16 Yeah, kind of throwing the general fund, the key components, just give people a sense of where the bulk of the revenue comes from, the percentages on the right-hand side. We start out budgeting somewhere around 60% of TOT of our general fund revenue, but it's gone as high as 75% of the actuals towards the end of the year. So that's, like I said, a conservative number that we're pretty comfortable with.
3:15:45 And this is just a little bit of a breakdown. There's quite a bit more detail in the staff report, but not a lot of adjustments. I think it was around $5,000 that we adjusted the revenue so far. Jumping into labor costs. Now, labor costs is a lot of moving parts to it. The first and foremost is if we add any new positions, you know, those positions come into the budget. They were not present last year, so they can make a fairly large impact.
3:16:17 There are six full-time positions, new positions in this budget, and around three, 2.8 full-time equivalents of part-time employees added. So a fairly large addition this year. That variance you see on the screen there of $943,000. That's an overall complete
3:16:43 You know, salary and benefit comparison to last year, that's the increase, so 7.6%. And I, you know, kind of give you the breakdown of where that's really coming from, from salary, health premiums and so forth. Health premiums is a little bit volatile in the sense that we have an increase of around 3 to 5% annually in that, depending upon what county you live in and where, you know, you're.
3:17:10 So if you have people moving through that,
3:17:36 It can be fairly significant. We also have of those six full-time positions added for conservative approach, I always add them in at the highest cost to be a family for Mono County. That way, because we don't really know, you know, if you have an approved position, you know, what the circumstances of that employee are going to be. So we want to make sure that we're kind of fully capturing like the worst case scenario of adding the bodies in anything that we're doing.
3:18:07 The first retirement, that was kind of a nice flattening of that, I'll say. It really is not reflective of, you know, any sort of predicament or change. It's of significance for the future, but there is a little bit of an evident flow, and sometimes with positions that may come off, if you're adding, you know, a new position, they are all PEPRA, which is quite a bit cheaper.
3:18:32 And the classic HERS members. And so in some instances, there's some savings there. Comprehensive leave, if you remember on that particular line, we did make, that's essentially a way of capturing the cost associated with hours that are provided for comprehensive leave, but not used. So they would be at hours that are banked by employees. And so it's really
3:18:59 Capturing the cost of employment, but not necessarily a hard expenditure that we would anticipate in the year. That we elected last year to cut that down by 50% as a balancing or a cost reduction measure for fiscal year 2021's budget in trying to save resources. So that 44% increase is really more reflective of that decision than it is anything else. And then workers comp, you know, we get,
3:19:30 These allocations coming from CGPA based on, you know, the performance of the prior year and they'll make some estimates on expenditures and costs. So that did increase fairly significantly over last year at 19.3. So like I said, there are six additional full-time positions and also like just under three full-time equivalents of part-time. That's kind of listed down below.
3:19:59 And the statistics of how we have our full-time employees. You see it's 82.3. One of our full-times, one of the six, does not start until April of next year. So that's a portion of their time. And as I went through this year's budget, I've been really taking and dissecting a lot of the reports and processes and spreadsheets that we utilize.
3:20:28 In the development of the budget. And so I've spent a lot of time refining these processes. So the salary and benefits worksheet, which is very complex and large, directly feeds into the budget process. So adjustments that are made are really seamless to the budget. And I think there's a higher degree of accuracy from separate reports that are then hand-keyed and so forth to the new ones. So just trying to do some refinements within our overall process.
3:20:58 To give you a sense of how that $13,356,000 distributes between salary, wages, health insurance, retirement, just showing it graphically. Some folks have liked to see that in the past. I will put boxes on that to tell you what the actual totals are in the future. I'm also giving some details here on the full-time equivalents.
3:21:26 Within each of the departments, because we are really allocating staff time to different departments. We don't end up with full bodies, so to speak, like the town manager position. That's two employees, but their time is split between this and I think the solid waste fund. But we really, that level of refinement going down to what percentage of time is each employee spending in the fund expenditures portion of our budget.
3:21:56 So that the right sort of people or the right funds can pay for the cost of the employee. And so that's kind of a little bit of an adjustment for this year, how we're displaying that information and how we're showing it. So the total for staff for full-time for general fund is just under $5 million at $4.9 for salary, but $9 million total in benefits. You can see the breakdown across that. It's $54.1.
3:22:25 Full-time equivalents for employees. This is sort of the same chart but showing other funds and how they're distributed. Basically the same layout and format. This is all part of one spreadsheet that wouldn't fit on one page. But it just shows you the distribution of where things are being allocated and charged to, how many people, so to speak, it takes to fund or run each of these departments.
3:22:56 I won't dwell too much time on that unless there's any questions, but in total, this worksheet total of $12,592,185, that represents the cost of our full-time employees. The part-time will be added on top of that for that total paper. Part-time employees, we break them down in their individual sort of breakdown costs. They really have just
3:23:28 Health insurance, PARs as benefits, and then, you know, the salary that's associated with that. Not a lot listed right now for capital projects. Expecting more for that to come forward, but that is the distribution of what we've received from the engineering team, and they don't really have a lot of part-time people that work in that. We really should have one or two interns that spend time on the job sites watching.
3:23:58 The folks worked through that process, but Community Recreation Center had school added this year, and overall, Town Center, Irvine, on the Finance Department, we added a position, and so forth. So total part-time staff is $764,000 in cost. This chart looks like it has an arrow on it, but it doesn't. I just flugged up on something, which I'll just tell you about here in a second.
3:24:31 The departments that are broken off, you see the Department 410, that's how our general fund is separated out. Each of these departments have their own budget. They would have certainly labor costs, any training costs, any contractual services that we run through that. And that's what would be generating the one item expenditure for that department. So some of them can be quite large based upon the activity they perform and how they...
3:24:59 May contract with other entities to perform services for the town on their behalf. So they go above and beyond just labor expenditures. But this is the total expenditures for those line items of those departments. Like I said earlier in the conversation, 52% of the general fund expenditures is labor. So that other 48% would be associated with these other types of expenditures, whether they be
3:25:29 You know, vehicle costs or contractual services without going training, miscellaneous expenditures and so forth. The, so it gives you kind of a breakdown, you know, really of what the, where the highest level of spend occurs within that department. I also, you can kind of link the two together when you look back at like the full-time equivalents and other things, you understand the number of employees that are involved that may help you understand.
3:25:58 Down at the bottom, you'll see transfers out listed twice. It's only in the calculations one time, but when I view the charts, which are on the next page, the chart feeds directly from this, the pie graph feeds directly from this chart, so both the departments and amounts needed to be within the same range in order for that to show up, and I didn't pick up that I was showing it twice.
3:26:28 The $24,633,250 is a good number. That represents both the top portion and the transfers out added into it, and there's no duplication on those. So the $24,633,000 is a little bit higher than the revenue that we have projected at this time, but as we go through this process, there are a few things in the budget this year, meaning
3:26:57 The one I'm projecting to you tonight that may be able to be paid for by one-time funding from the current fiscal year. There would be purchases of equipment and other items that I know we are going to need and had to get into the budget. But third quarter and fourth quarter presentations, which will be coming up in the next couple of months, we'll probably address those and that would reduce some of the expenditures out of here. I also talk about
3:27:25 The reserve policy quite often. And there's some updates to the reserve policy that you may have seen in the staff report that's going to require us to fund that in order to stay within the policy. And so I do have those expenditures captured, you know, transfers out in the budget. So just to make sure that we stay on policy. But those are decisions that will be brought forward to you if we get into a situation on balancing challenges.
3:27:53 Just know that that's kind of where we are right now. There's a slight deficit in revenue to expenditures, but I don't anticipate any problems being able to address and correct those. Taking a look at the pie chart for the general fund, and again, this feeds directly off of that previous chart, so those amounts and titles come from there. Just giving you a graphical representation of really what departments cost us how much.
3:28:25 If you ever have questions about what's included in one of those, in probably the manager recommended, which will be the tentative budget presented at the end of May, I will provide line item detail, or maybe in the final budget, but I think line item detail is important. That would then show you every single line item of all of the budgets. It's fairly arduous, but it gives folks a chance to look through there and see, you know, by line item, how
3:28:55 Each expenditure line item was in comparison to prior year's budget and then also two years prior of actual expenditure. So you kind of see changes, trends, and flows if you care to look to that level. And I know there's a number of people that do. So that will be provided in the next budget presentation. Switching away from general fund to gas tax. Gas tax is our second largest and probably more complex.
3:29:27 As it has, you know, a number of revenue streams, some of them coming from actual gas tax where, you know, gallons of fuel are sold and tax collected and distributed. There's that for general maintenance of roadways, but also for our snow removal costs. We receive 50% of our prior year's snow removal expenditure as a revenue in the subsequent year. So it's off a little bit.
3:29:56 Requires us to carry some fund balance in there in order to weather these stronger years and higher snowfall years. But it also has a strong component of support from the general fund. Last year, you can see right on this top item here, we have a transfer exam general fund and garage services. It's $570,000 more than last year. Partly is...
3:30:24 It's because we decided last year to utilize some fund balance. The term called planned use of fund balance means that I plan on spending some savings that I have within this fund to support my general operations. And we did that last year to reduce the load on general fund with our reduced revenues. And so taking that out this year and putting it back in fully does show a fairly significant impact.
3:30:53 That's the bulk of what that change is. But we also have, you know, you'll see up above that, the $500,000, an additional snow removal. That just represents a little bit stronger than we had for the prior year. So that'll be helpful. You know, within our expenditures, we capture the cost of the snow pit operation under street maintenance because we cannot capture that as a
3:31:23 Reimbursable Gas Tax Expenditure. It's been designated as outside of actual snow removal because it's a service that we're having to provide to the community. And so that $480,000 is about $450,000 of that is the cost of operations for snow pit. If you remember last year, I did not budget that because there was some confusion about that, between that and the jungle, the main.
3:31:51 Main Street snow clearing costs and whether or not we had enough captured in that, but we did not include the snow pit operation. So that's the significant increase for that process. The snow removal, $107,000, that's, you know, that's fairly consistent and a lot of that will be staff costs that are increasing there as they've seen some increases.
3:32:21 We are adding a full-time position in public works as a maintenance worker and reducing some part-time employee costs for snow removal. So kind of getting a full-time position in place of one part-time position. So that's a little bit of some of that offset. The vehicle replacement program, I'm still working through that. I've been working through that the last couple of days, so there's been no updates to that. But as we go through...
3:32:49 Manager recommended at the end of May. I'll have some updates to those numbers and you'll see recognize some differences in each one of those. But in total for gas tax expenditures going up about $602,000 and we're expecting revenues to be more by $1.70. So that's not a bad offset.
3:33:17 We do have a fairly sizable fund balance in gas tax that we can utilize for either road projects or other larger projects, and there's some things coming forward where we're getting some stiff funds to do some construction and revitalization of our boat bay. So we'll talk more about that during our capital improvement presentations that are in the upcoming meeting. A little bit of a graphical representation for gas tax.
3:33:51 And now airport, as Grady mentioned earlier, the airport is suffering a little bit of an impact from not having commercial air service. You can see the deficits in the right-hand column there. This is the top box is revenue, where we just don't anticipate receiving funding because we don't have commercial air service.
3:34:20 The middle one there were the ACIP grant entitlements. That last year we had three projects that were slated for construction at the airport. And when those projects are slated for construction, the grant dollars associated with those, which is about 92.8% of the total project cost, comes to us as revenue in the form of these grants.
3:34:48 This is a big significant difference in there. We don't have anything scheduled for this current fiscal year, so there's nothing listed as of yet as either grant revenue or expenditures down below. So you'll see sort of offsetting expenditure reduction as well, which is helpful. There is some things that we can do with the CARES Act funding, and Dan and I have been talking a little bit about this, actually his recommendation. We mentioned earlier that we had the million,
3:35:18 The $1.096 from last fiscal year has really been carrying our revenue shortfalls and supporting our general fund to reducing the general fund support required for the airport. And that should be fully utilized or fully expended by the end of this current fiscal year. So 2021, we will get through that $1.096. The $1.5 million that we have slated out there
3:35:46 We have a couple of options. I have it currently listed as a million dollars in there just to give a flat number, but we could utilize a little bit less of that in this fiscal year and sort of spread that impact across multiple fiscal years. And because we have that funding, it's available for approximately four years. But if we did that and reduce the CARES Act financial revenues, we would have to then support that from the general fund.
3:36:16 As we refine that and kind of work through the process, Dan and I will come to you with a recommendation on whether we want to either spend that money all at once in the front end or if we want to spread it out across a couple of years and let the general fund support more of it dampen the impact across time. The costs at the bottom, again, there's really small labor cost increases.
3:36:44 And vehicle maintenance and actually loading in a vehicle replacement program for the airport this year. We did not, we have not had that in the past. Most of the vehicles that come from, or that operate at the airport have been hand-me-down from the public works or bought by grant funding. And so now we're setting up, we purchased some vehicles last year, if you remember, that were for the airport. So you're setting up a vehicle replacement similar to what we do in all other.
3:37:13 And we're also setting up a program where if they acquire a vehicle from another department, then they'll pay them for that vehicle. So that $22,000 is really vehicle replacement updates. Then down below, you'll see, you know, a little bit of a reduction for the, well, a lot of reduction for the capital projects cost of around $2 million. That is the difference between the $9 million.
3:37:41 $1,935,000 up above and the $2,000,000 down below is the difference in what the FAA does not cover. And some of that is handled by airport passenger facility fees. But that, in general, it looks like a big impact and adjustment for expenditures, but it's just really capital falling. The operations of the airport remains fairly consistent. Graphical for that, labor cost is the highest one that comes through.
3:38:17 And finally, we'll talk a little bit about the debt service for the town. So these are annual debt payments. The debt schedule I update every year. There's minor adjustments to the actual payment that's required for the year. But those are all updated. I'm showing you what the initial debt amount is. And this is part of an overall program where I show debt across all of the years.
3:38:46 And really when we expect to see, you know, a reduction of our annual expenditures, but also, you know, when each item will be paid off. So it's a pretty comprehensive schedule. I'd also break this one down to show you that the bottom two items are really supported by something outside of the town's funding. North Village Development is funded by an assessment district as well as the Bluffs Development.
3:39:13 And those are listed below. So at a general fund, it's about $2.1 million. Measure R debt, about $612,000 for this year. And that's the CRC funding at $5.5 million in the assessment districts. We did request of council last fiscal year when we presented the budget that we withhold payment of the vehicle replacement reimbursement at $340,000 a year for two full years.
3:39:41 This budget, we're recommending that roll back in, and that $340,000 is included in the expenditures for the year as I'm presenting it to you tonight. So that's kind of getting back to fully funding our obligations because we do anticipate having enough revenue to do so. And that sort of mitigates long-term impacts. Instead of eight years, we're going to be down to seven years of repayment.
3:40:10 That's kind of the right thing to do in my opinion. And, you know, we'll be recommending that. That's going to require council action as we've gone through a resolution before to make that adjustment for two years from extending out that contract or that payment. So kind of a quick run through on that. Like I said, there was more information, more details in the staff report. And I'm just wondering if there are any questions.
3:40:47 Here I am talking away and muted and with my picture turned off. Any questions for Rob? I don't have any. I'm sorry. Excuse me, Mr. Mayor. Can I speak? Yes. You're first. Go. Thank you. Rob, I don't have any particular questions right now. So this is just a very preliminary look at what we'll be doing. What's your target for finalizing the budget this year? We will be back to you with capital projects.
3:41:19 Next council meeting, we will be manager recommended at the second meeting in May. And currently nothing's slated for the first meeting in June because we're sort of leaving that as overflow for potential impacts, but we will be with a final budget by second meeting of June. Okay, good. All right, thank you. Thank you, Linda. John? Rob, that's a lot of stuff. Thanks for all your work.
3:41:52 Always good to know there's a Master of the Excel somewhere in town. I may have some extracurricular work for you, but we can talk later. I'm just thinking about the budget. I'm thinking about our priority settings sessions, and I'm just hoping that those are all going to line up, and I'm assuming that you and Dan are on top of all that. So keep those facts and figures coming, and we'll be looking forward to the next rounds and aligning what we want to do with what we've got to do with.
3:42:23 Thank you, John. Thank you, John. Kirk? I have no questions. I was able to follow the budget. I've done a few of these. Thank you, Kirk. Sarah? Yeah, this is my first one, so I was following along as best I can, but thank you, Rob, for making it so digestible, relatively. I don't have any questions. Thank you, Sarah. You know, Rob, I'm going to go along with that. You guys, over the last few years,
3:42:57 Okay. Yeah, I can provide that both in the staff report and in the subsequent presentation.
3:43:28 Yeah, that was the only thing. I can follow the rest of it very nicely, so I appreciate that. Thank you. Do we have any public comments on this, James? No, we do not. I'll see you at home scratching your heads. Someday, someone's going to comment. Someday. That being said, unless staff has something else to bring us on that matter.
3:43:59 And seeing nobody jumping up, I will move on to Councilmember Reports. Linda. Okay. Well, you know, there were the two strategic planning sessions on the 9th and the 16th, and, you know, still doing a lot of COVID-related meetings, and we had a couple of good-sized clinics up in Bridgeport last weekend, the weekend before there was some locals, so that's about it for me. Thank you, Linda. John?
3:44:35 Mr. Mayor, you'll be shocked here I have no report this evening. Thank you. Wow. Thank you, Tom. That's not a trend, but thank you. Okay. Kurt? Nothing to report on the committees, but a comment that globally pollution is down because people are traveling less, which is good for us in snow. Thank you, Kurt. Sarah?
3:45:08 Yeah, nothing to report. I have my first LAFCO and Collaborative Planning Team meetings coming up soon, so looking forward to attending those, but nothing in the past. Thank you. Thank you, Sarah. So let me get out my notebook here. Since John didn't do this tonight, I think I'll, you know, ramble on. I attended an ESCA meeting where we talked about several things that we already talked about here, the late states and approval.
3:45:38 I attended an LTC meeting where actually we talked about more STA stuff than I think we did at the STA meeting with John as well. A couple of quick things. They're working on all the passes to open. A fee increase to rent, because a lot of people are interested in that, are going to go from $10 an adult to $5 a child, $15 an adult, and $7 a child.
3:46:08 The Extra Lakes Basin Trolley we talked about. YARTS is going to have to still limit its bus passengers at 30, so we're not sure how that's going to affect their things. And some grants and some money coming to us that will help us with a lot of our projects here that I'm sure Hayes will be telling us about at some point in time. As all of you, I attended the...
3:46:36 Thank you all for being there. I thought the first two meetings went exceptionally well. I am proud of us all for how we handle ourselves in those meetings. Thank you for that as well. With that, I think that it's time for Sarah and I to back out because we have to recuse. I have to recuse on the next item because I live within 500 feet.
3:47:07 And Sharon needs to recuse for pretty much the same issue, although she lives a lot farther away than I do, and it's somewhat confusing, these rules. That's the way it is for today. So, Lynda, I will hand the reins over to you, and I will leave this meeting. Thank you. Okay, thank you, guys. We'll see you later. Have a good night. Okay, so that leaves Sean.
3:47:41 And that brings us to item number 15, approve the resolution, authorize the town manager to execute the DDA. So who wants to talk to us first about this? Grady, is that you? I'll just go real briefly and say that we've already presented most of this information, if not all of it, a couple of times before, and due to the fact you've all been at it for almost four hours.
3:48:10 I'm not going to go through the staff report. The EPA has been distributed. And I'll turn to Andy to describe why we dropped the second agenda item and why we think we're in good shape with this and ready to go forward. So, Andy. Okay. Hi, Andy. Hello. So, you'll recall that we've previously brought this to you. And at the time, we were proceeding with a sale under something called the Surplus Lands Act. And we...
3:48:37 Sent notice of what we were going to do to HCD as their brand new guidelines adopted just this month say that we need to. And then they seem to have invented a procedural requirement that's not in the law that was going to kind of delay us a bit, maybe make us go and do another bidding cycle, which nobody wanted to do. But HCD did say, well, there's this other route that you can take, which is a sale under a different section of state law, Government Code Section 364.
3:49:06 Which we looked at and it has somewhat different requirements as to the affordability levels. They're a little bit more aggressive than the ones under the Surplus Lands Act. But the nice thing about that approach is it doesn't have any real procedural requirements. There's no notice to HCD. There's none of these kind of cumbersome and tedious things that we were having to do on the other path. So since HCD recommended it and we thought we can make this work, we talked to our good friends at Pacific about whether
3:49:35 They could deal with the slightly more aggressive affordability levels. And as always, Pacific is there when we need them. And Caleb and Shallon have said, yes, we can absolutely do that. I put together a slightly revised version of the DDA that stripped out references to the other way that we were going to sell the property and added in the specific affordability requirements of the path that we're taking now. And I understand that Pacific is okay with the...
3:50:02 The small edits that I made and sent to them today. So we are here hoping that the council will see fit to adopt the resolution authorizing the town manager to sign the DDA. I think Pacific's okay with the DDA. Hopefully Shelling can weigh in. We as staff are happy with it. We're using an approach that HCD staff recommended to us. And because there's no 30-day requirement between the adoption of the resolution and being able to sign the DDA,
3:50:32 This might actually speed the process up ever so slightly because we can sign the DDA pretty much immediately. So if anyone has any questions, I think all of us would be happy to answer them and hopefully Shellen can weigh in and confirm for us all our understanding that Pacific is okay with this approach and with the slightly revised version of the DDA. Okay. Thank you, Andy. Questions? John, do you want to ask any questions? On the…
3:51:02 Affordability limits, Andy, can you just give a quick summation or maybe Sean kind of what the difference is? Yeah, so I'm moving around this window so I can look at the actual text. So this approach says that not less than 40% of the number of units developed on the property have to be affordable to households whose incomes are equal to or less than 75% of the max income to be lower income households.
3:51:31 Now the max income for lower income households is 80% of AMI. So you've probably heard us talk about the units, a lot of them on the parcel we thought would be lower income, so 80% of AMI. But the way the statute is worded, at least 40% of the units have to be affordable to people who are 75% of the 80%. So essentially 40% have to be affordable to people making no more than 60% of the AMI, which is pretty aggressive. That's very aggressive. And then separately within the statute, it says,
3:52:01 But of the 40%, half of those have to be affordable to very low-income households, and the cap for that is 50% of AMI. So we're going to get 40% being either very low-income affordable or kind of slightly lower than low affordable. The other 60% would be other affordable, probably mostly 80% units, although the DDA still has the language saying that we can have them do some moderate units, up to 120% of AMI if we can
3:52:30 Find the funding to make that happen. So it's just a slightly quirky set of requirements, but it's just taken straight from the statute. And I've essentially cut and pasted the language of the statute right into the DDA and then sent that over to Pacific along with some notes about, hey, this is what this means. Are you guys sure you can do this? And the answer appears to be yes. So this approach does not change the overall vision for the parcel as being for affordable housing.
3:52:59 It'll still be affordable housing and we'll have some particularly affordable units in there, even more so than we had originally anticipated. Okay, so does this apply to phase one or to the entire person? This is the whole thing in the aggregate. Okay, so what does this do to missing middle opportunities? I want to make sure that we're clear that this is about community housing, this is not about workforce housing. What is this going to do to opportunities for missing middle housing, 120 AMI and above?
3:53:29 Yeah, so the interesting thing about this statute that we're using is it says at least 80% of the land area that is conveyed has to be used for housing. Fine, no problem there. And other than that, really all it says is that 40% has to be this kind of super low and very low units. So the other 60% of the units could be at whatever affordability level we can work out with Pacific. Okay. You know, whatever we can kind of subsidize them to build.
3:53:57 You know, there's certainly opportunities here for missing middle units. We're not precluded. We're, I mean, 60% of the units are just whatever we can work out with Pacific. Only 40% are restricted to the extreme affordability. Okay, good. Thank you. Kirk, any comments? Questions? Well, when I read the agenda, thank you, Linda. When I read the agenda packet and I looked at
3:54:25 When it says the parcel concept plan provides up to 580 units. And when you take out the wetlands and the roads and everything else, and if we put a childcare center in there, the density could be up to 28, 29, 30 per acre. And then you have 1.3 parking spaces per unit, two bedroom.
3:54:54 You know, it seems like we are setting ourselves up to create a housing project that is going to have some real problems in the future. Fair point. The 580 unit figure is not guaranteed. I think that this has been set up both in the master plan and in the DDA. So the minimum number is 400 and the maximum number is 580. And the way this will work is that every time Pacific is ready to take down another.
3:55:25 And so we will pin down the number of units to be developed at the time we sell the property. So if, as things unfold, the collective wisdom of the council is that we don't think 580 units is the right number, that's a little bit too dense, I think we can make that work.
3:55:53 Within the boundaries of the DDA and the master plan. Okay. Thank you, Andy. Any questions about Andy's comments at all? So the, Madam Mayor. Yes, of course. So the 580 stays there and we just are going to try to, well, Pacific is going to come forward with as many units as possible because that's how they make their living. So, you know, I'm still somewhat.
3:56:29 Somewhat hesitant with that particular number. We're saying, oh yeah, no, we're just going to do 400 units. When you look at 580s, you're looking at 29, 30 units an acre. It seems that if we approve this and the developers trying to maximize the density as well as their profit, then it seems that
3:56:59 We might be creating something in the middle of the town that has some real long-term issues, impacts on the area around it. Okay, Kirk, Grady, did you have a comment? Yeah, thanks. If I could just add to what Andy says in response, Councilmember, the way the DDA is written is we really have very strong controls on that, and our experience so far with the Pacific has been they have basically said to us,
3:57:30 Look, whatever you guys want. If you want 400 units, we're going to build 400 units. If you want 580, we'll work on that. But it's really up to this council and subsequent councils as each development parcel is moved to Pacific to do it just as any sense to decide. If they come forward and they say, well, we've got 120, and we say, that's just too dense, we can say no. We absolutely have that control in the DDA. That's the beauty of it. I think we worked very hard on the DDA to make sure that it provided.
3:57:59 The protections that the town needs in a lot of different ways, legal, otherwise, density-wise, parking, everything, we have those protections built into the DDA, but still gives us the flexibility to respond to the future because we don't know what the future brings in terms of funding availability and other requirements. So we are very confident as staff and with Pacific that we have the control necessary. If we want to limit the density to, say, 450 units total, that's what it's going to be.
3:58:29 And I mean, that's just it. That's allowed the DDA. Certainly, you're giving a certain amount of that decision-making off to future councils. That's the way it goes. But on the other hand, if you were one of those future councils, you'd want the flexibility to respond to conditions as they change. And I'll say that, you know, the flexibility and the protection that we wrote into the DDA, we did that because the three of you had the wisdom and the foresight.
3:58:56 To tell us that that was really important to you and to the community. And so we took that to heart. I mean, that was one of the, that was my first and biggest note when I went to start drafting this thing is preserve flexibility but have protection. You told us you didn't want the town to be obligated to continue dealing with Pacific if there were problems in earlier phases. We wrote that in. You told us that you wanted a lot of control over each future phase. We wrote that in.
3:59:26 So I think that that was, as I said, that was wise and foresighted, and we have done our level best to stitch in language that meets your direction. And Pacific, I mean, to their enduring credit, Pacific has been willing to accommodate that. I mean, I've worked with a lot of developers who would have wanted a great deal more control because this is such a big project and a big investment. And Pacific has said, whatever the town wants, we will do. And they didn't balk at all.
3:59:56 At having these DDA provisions that provide protection, but also provide flexibility. Thank you, Andy. All right. Any more questions, either of you, John, or Kirk on this? No? I mean, I think that I'm comfortable with that. It would be very difficult for me to relate back to you, Andy, those percentages of affordabilities that you recited off, but I do...
4:00:28 I understand what the point of that is, and I also understand that the, I feel comfortable with the fact that we do have a point at which each parcel becomes available for development to make decisions and to correct whatever we felt was not perhaps exactly the way we wanted in the former phase, which I think gives us some guarantee rather than just committed the entire
4:00:55 Anchorage, you know, right now. So I think that that was a good, good thing to do. Sheldon, I see you got here with us. Is there something you'd like to add? Thank you for the opportunity. I would say, yeah, I've been listening this this whole time and I think I don't really have anything to add besides, you know, quite simply the way that your council described it is true and it meets this DDA meets our needs. It is.
4:01:27 I wouldn't worry too much about it being more affordable than we originally thought. The infill infrastructure grant also guides affordability coupled with the master plan, coupled with any other financing that we have. So we feel just really confident that as we take this off one bite at a time and we work together in partnership, we'll get the affordability that both the DDA requires along with all those other financing sources. So I think it was represented accurately and we're just ready to move it forward.
4:01:57 Okay, yes, it'd be nice to put a period at the end of this and get this going for sure. Thank you, Andy, for shepherding this along. It's kind of remarkable how HCD has pivoted around, but we are comfortable that this is their suggestion for facilitating this now in a timely manner, and that if we were to do this, there will be no repercussions later with them coming back to say, well, you did do the way we wanted it to, so we have documented all this, I'm sure, too.
4:02:26 Yeah, they sent us an email suggesting this approach, and I believe that Sandra emailed them back saying, okay, thank you for that suggestion. That's exactly what we're going to do. Okay, so we got that all in permanent ink somewhere. Okay. All right. If there's no other questions, I would entertain a motion on this. Yeah, and I'd like to suggest one small tweak to the motion. Because the statutory scheme that we're proceeding under
4:02:56 Okay.
4:03:26 Madam Mayor Pro Temp, do you want any public comment on this or no? Yes. If I can make a comment? Yes, of course. I would like to continue this at least to the next meeting, partly because I have not, my agenda packet was not complete.
4:03:45 As to having a copy of the Disposition and Development Agreement, I didn't have a copy on that. I just now was a copy was just shared with me. And I'd like to appreciate to be able to at least read that so that I can make an intelligent vote. Andy, was that the same DDA we had in our last two weeks ago packet? No.
4:04:12 Because we had to make some technical edits and they really were just technical in nature to reflect this different path that we're using rather than proceeding under the Surplus Lands Act. So no, not entirely the same. I would say that it's 97% the same and the substance is all the same. It's just a few minor tweaks. But I will point out that it does take three council votes to approve a resolution. So if Councilmember Stapp is not...
4:04:40 Comfortable proceeding tonight would not be inclined to vote in favor of the resolution. A 2-1 would not approve the resolution tonight. So, Shellen, how would it affect Pacific, if at all, to postpone this until the May 5th council meeting? Thank you for the question. Let's see. I'm kind of playing through it in my mind. You know, we have our next round of funding, and we need to have this document or something similar.
4:05:13 Ready for that next round of funding. I would not, I don't know if you recall in February, we all worked very hard and I would say it was pretty high cost for town staff because we, the town council was literally less than 24 hours ahead of the due date. I don't know if, you know, you recall, but it was, it was incredibly stressful. I don't know how else to say it.
4:05:41 With runners going up between Sacramento and our bond office. And I just really hate to be in that situation again in here in a few weeks. So I would, you know, I would urge you to consider trying to get this or something very similar passed beforehand. Yes, we do have time if it were to be passed on the 5th. Is that the date you said? Another option would be April 30th.
4:06:09 Michelle, which buys you at least a few days, and the council has a special meeting already scheduled for then, and this could simply be added to the agenda if Councilmember Stapp believes that the next nine days would be enough time for him to be able to review the documents and feel comfortable with them. I do have another suggestion that we could also convene a special meeting Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, or Thursday next week to facilitate that even by a few more days.
4:06:38 If Councilmember Stapp, Kirk, if you would feel comfortable as early as Monday, being able to convene a special meeting on Zoom to approve this, and that would give us time to notice it and hopefully give you time to review the DDA, would that be acceptable? That would be acceptable to me. Okay. Could we then, I'd rather get this done on Monday, get it done, get it put away. For me, it would have to be late in the day on Monday.
4:07:10 Say 6 p.m. on Monday. Dan, would that work for your staff? I'm looking at Grady and Sandra. We'd have to put the reports together. And then for just getting the special meeting notice out, then we'd get that out on Friday. So we need to have that within the next day or so. We'd have to have everything ready to go out for a Monday meeting. Special meeting requires at least 24 hours, but we'd want to have it out on a minimum Friday, if not on Thursday. We could do it Tuesday. I mean, you know, it's...
4:07:45 Well, I think the staff report would be exactly the same. I just can't. The DDA is already... Information. I mean, if this... I don't know how many pages this is. It's only five or six pages, but I'd certainly like to be able to peruse it before I vote on it. Understood. No problem, Kirk. That's absolutely very acceptable. If we could do it on Monday, is that agreeable with you, though? Is that enough time?
4:08:12 We could do it Monday back at 6 is what you suggested? Yes. Airport team. I'm looking over at the clerks and see if they have any conflicts or if they have a conflict with the Zoom room at all. Yeah. So, okay. So, yeah, we could do a Zoom meeting here in Suite Z that evening if that works. Does that feel a little bit better than having to wait all the way through the whole week? You know, I appreciate you guys.
4:08:38 Doing what you can. So that would work. Honestly, the 30th would work too, but either one works great for us. And I just appreciate you guys making it happen. I know it's always work. Okay. All right. Then why don't we get it done on Monday, get that checked off and move along, if that's agreeable to everyone. Okay. So we will then, being that there is no really action to be taken right now, we will kind of
4:09:08 Continue this, not continue officially, but we will visit this again on Monday and hopefully be able to have a vote then. Okay. John, thank you. Thank you, everybody. All right. That being done, I understand that we have no closed items to discuss tonight. Is that correct? That's correct. There's no new information in either of the pending litigation cases, so we felt that there's no reason to have the closed sessions tonight. Okay.
4:09:35 All right. That being said, unless there's any other comments, questions, concerns here this evening, seeing none, we'll go ahead and adjourn this meeting. Thank you, everyone. And I'll see us again on Monday then. Okay. Thank you, everyone. Good night.