TransparentMammoth

Mammoth Lakes Recreation · 2021

Mammoth Lakes Recreation Special meeting

· recording 2 hr 59 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

364 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:30 Eric, did you see the email I just sent a minute ago? Thank you. We were on the same mind track. I didn't even see your text. Oh, I was like, wait, there's a, I know someone's going to want to know how we got here. Totally, yeah. Sorry for the last minute. No worries. Hey guys, how's it going? Good, Eric, how are you? Good, good. Hey, um.

1:10 Real quick, Ted Carlton just called me and said that there's no link on the town website to get on here, and he would like me to request that a link is sent out and that we don't start until he can get logged in. So the link is on the agenda that's posted on the town's website. I'm just relaying what I was just told a minute ago. Okay.

1:42 She went downstairs to turn things on. Yeah, if someone wants to shoot me an email with his phone number, I can text him, but there is a link, the agenda's up there, and there's a spot on the agenda that says MLR Board Meeting Public Zoom Information. And we've got a special meeting, May 26th, in progress agenda view event, so I'll email that to Ted.

2:09 Thanks, sir. I appreciate it. Hey, could you do me a favor of CCB? Because somebody else asked me to get on, too. Yep. So I can forward it to them, as well. No problem. Thanks, Stu. I appreciate that. You bet. Do you need my email? Uh, yep. Shoot it. What'd you got? Eric P. Wass, E-R-I-C-P-W-A-S-S, at N-P-G-Cable. Dot com. Yep. Got it. Perfect. Old school. Yeah, that's an old one. That is my old one.

2:43 I have others, but this is the one I use. That's like Hotmail. It is. This way, if this one gets out in public, I know where it's going. Actually, if you still have a QNet one, you really define yourself as a local. Yeah, I'm not local yet, Craig. I've only got 19 years. I'm almost there. That's awesome. QNet. Or Shot.net. Shot.net was the other one, yeah. Yep.

3:19 I predate both of those with an old Earthlink address I still use. Of course you do. From the eight days when we thought a 9600 baud modem was a Gucci thing. That's right. We've come a long way, haven't we? Thanks, Stu. I just received your email. Guys, I'm going to disappear for a minute, but I'll be back. Okay. Actually, I just got to...

5:11 text from Ted, he is on, so I'll assume others of the public are able to get that link that Stu talked about, so why don't, I think Angie sent me a text, we are ready to go, so let me call to order this special meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Recreation Board of Directors meeting, May 26, 2021.

5:39 I've got, what do we got? 5.36 PM. And Angie, can we do a roll call, please? Yes. Craig Albright. Here. Heather Schaubmeyer. Here. Tamara Bankson. Here. Bill Souser. Present. Catherine Taft, I believe, is absent. David Page, also absent, I believe. Colin Fernie. Here.

6:15 Eric Wasserman? He's here, but he said he's going to step out for just a second. Okay. Do you want to wait for him to come back, or what would you like to do on that? Because I can't mark him present right here yet. Is he the last on the roll call? Captain Weston. We know he's here. He's just stepped away, so we'll go ahead and mark him in. And is that the end of roll call there? Yes, thank you. Oh, okay. I'm sorry.

7:03 Let's see. So let's start off with next up is public comments. Do we have any public comments, Angie? They're at suite Z or chat rooms or email. Yes, I just got an email from let me just read it first to make sure it's for you guys. It says this item needs clarification.

7:38 As it appears that the MLTS website that has been developed and maintained by MLTPA under the TOML contract would be duplicative if taken over by MLR. Hosting is reasonable, however, so would MLTPA still develop and maintain the TRAILS website under its contract, serve as a subcontractor to MLR?

8:05 Or would MLR be expected to develop and maintain a similar website? I would assume that comment has to do with some of the webpages MLR hosts for Mammoth Lakes Trail System projects, such as the Shady Rest Inyo Craters Project or the Adopt-A-Trail Program, which are not the same as the mammothtrails.org website, which is a

8:38 resource for trails and experiences and activities in the area. Okay, actually, I'm now looking at the subject next to public comment. It says Appendix A Communications slash Outreach 3 website. And I can forward this to you, Kim, so you have everything in front of you. Yeah, why don't we do that and then Kim will address that since public comment is for items not on the agenda and that will...

9:10 We'll be addressing that later in the agenda. So let's, Kim, you can look that over and then we'll talk about it during that part of the meeting. Any other public comment, Angie? Not at this time. Thank you so much. Moving on to item four, president's report. I have...

9:39 two letters of resignation to kind of pass on to the board. I'll read each of them in their entirety. And then also, Kim, if we could have these entered into the public record and forwarded on to the board members, I think that would be appropriate as well. The first is from Catherine Tapp, dear Craig, an MLR board.

10:07 This note is to formally step down from my seat on the MLR Board. It has been incredibly rewarding to serve the organization and the Mammoth Lakes community as a board member since 2018. I remain committed to MLR's mission and good work, even as I must shift my focus towards new professional and life demands.

10:29 The board agrees, and if it's allowed, I would love to keep serving in an advisory capacity or as a committee member for allocations and cultural stewardship. I see so many opportunities for cultural growth, both for the town and MLR, and I would be honored to help when and however I can. Please do not hesitate to reach out if you'd like to speak more, and thank you for your understanding, and of course, for all the important work you continue.

10:57 continue to do as an organization with respect to Catherine. So that is from Catherine. And then also have a letter of resignation from David, David Page. And just pulling it up here. And I will read that for you. Dear Craig, with regret, I am

11:28 Ready to inform you of my decision to resign from my position of the Board of Directors of Mammoth Lakes Recreation, including my role as Chair of the Mammoth Trails Committee, effective immediately. My professional and personal commitments are such that I cannot continue to dedicate the significant amount of volunteer time required to help push the ball up the hill. I have served on the Board of Directors of this organization since its incorporation as a California

11:58 registered 501C3 nonprofit in 2014, including through the drafting of its first five-year strategic plan from 2016 through 2021. The negotiation of several contracts with the town of Mammoth Lakes and the hiring and subsequent separation from two full-time executive directors.

12:24 I am proud of MLR's many accomplishments over the last six years and I firmly believe that the value of the services and programs that MLR continues to provide this community including through extensive citizen volunteer time expertise as well as dedicated staff time far outweigh the meager financial investments that have been made year over year from

12:54 Municipal and philanthropic sources. However, as I have expressed on many occasions on the public record, I am deeply concerned that MLR in large part due to its convoluted and inefficient structural relationship with the town of Mammoth Lakes and its other contractors and commissions continues to be hampered in its capacity to deliver on its most basic foundational mission.

13:24 quote, to provide efficient public oversight and strategic recommendations for the leveraging and effective expenditure of municipal tax revenues derived from Measures R and Measure U and the broader enhancement of opportunities and infrastructure for recreation, arts, culture, and mobility in Mammoth Lakes, California, unquote.

13:51 There is clarity and broad agreement across the community regarding the work that needs to be done to better manage and protect a wide variety of recreational opportunities in the Eastern Sierra and to mitigate increasing impacts to this unique landscape they depend upon, the landscape we all cherish. Annual revenues from Measure R and U should provide a decent down payment on this project.

14:19 We will need to greatly improve our ability to think strategically as a community, to work collaboratively, to appropriately delegate responsibility, but also hold staff and contractors accountable for specific deliverables, to communicate effectively, and to get things done. Wishing you all the best for the board staff, the board and staff of MLR, its partners, and the community it serves.

14:48 Signed, David Page. And I'd just like to take a moment to publicly thank Catherine and David for their many years of service and work here with MLR. And also looking forward to, I know with both of them, they are engaged members of our community and no doubt we'll continue to hear their input as

15:18 Like I said, engaged citizens. But thank you very much for their service to our community in both their roles. And I believe, if I'm not mistaken, Angie, or let's see, where did I get that from? I may have a few things to say. We may have a public comment from Mr. Wentworth. While we're waiting for that, I'll just...

15:50 echo your sentiments, Craig. It's been a pleasure to work with both David and Catherine. Sad to see them go, but understand. I'll make a comment. I'm sorry, after public comment. Sorry, John. I don't see any hands raised at this time. Okay.

16:14 I'd like to make the same comment. I'd like to say thank you to Catherine for being part of the allocations committee. I'd like to have her as an advisor moving forward if she so does wishes like we kind of did with Rhonda at the beginning before Rhonda became a board member. And so moving forward, if she would like to participate with that, I think we'd love to have her input. She's got a valued contribution and understanding of our different partners. And so I've always enjoyed her company with that. So thank you, Catherine, for all that you've done and especially from

16:43 From distance and still being part of our community. And then also to David. He's one of the reasons that I came onto the board from the very beginning. I just wanted to tell him thank you for his commitment and his efforts and endless amount of time that he spent trying to steer MLR through its freshman, sophomore, and junior years. So I do appreciate that very much. And I'm sure it's not the last we'll hear from him when it comes to MLR. So I just want to tell him thank you.

17:11 Thank you, Heather. That's outstanding. Thank you. I do have a hand raise now, if this is appropriate. John Metworth, you can unmute yourself. Hello there. I just wanted to publicly thank both Catherine and David. My relationships and friendships with both of them predated all of this. They're great people, and they just work really, really hard. And the community is better for their efforts and their contributions.

17:44 So I just want to make sure that I acknowledge my friends and the great work that they did. And I will see them again in all kinds of different iterations. But they really both provide a great service to the community. Just want to make sure their contributions were acknowledged. So thank you. Thank you. Thank you, John. And no doubt we will be seeing them. Like you said, our friends out on the trails and in the outdoors.

18:14 And in the various art and cultural activities in our community. And we look forward to them being able to enjoy the fruits of some of their labors here with MLR Board. So moving on to the next item, policy matter 5A, discussion and possible action on FY21-22 Town of Mammoth Lakes contract. In your board packet, you had

18:42 2 slash 3 reference materials. 1A was review from the town manager on the contract and 1B was actually the draft agreement and scope of service and deliverables and then also Kim just before the meeting sent out kind of our worksheet that we were using when negotiating with the town.

19:11 kind of calculating some of the, you know, hours and rates and whatnot. And so I think I'd like to hand it over to, you know, I see we have Dan here and also Colin was a member of the negotiations committee. Maybe Colin I asked to start it off and give kind of a little overview of how we got to this point and take it away, Colin.

19:34 Sure. You know, Dan, Kim, if you guys want to kind of lead us in, that's totally fine by me. I'm more than happy to provide a little, you know, introduction from the negotiation committee, but if either one of you guys wants to lead in, I'm fine with that. Yeah, go ahead, Kim. No, I was just going to say, shortly after our last meeting, not our last meeting, last meeting, which was in March,

20:08 Negotiations committee started meeting together and meeting with the town manager and eventually a town negotiating team and just working through some of the deliverables outlining things and so we have been through a few iterations and what we have before us I think maybe Dan can speak to next. Yeah I can dive into this this came out of a couple different iterations of discussion I think the last meeting was

20:38 kind of a shift back into creating an agreement that continue to support MLR in terms of the town level of financial support versus maybe shifting it more to standalone nonprofit and working through that process and having potential contractual relationship town on certain items. I think it's a little, it's kind of a hybrid a little bit, it's still more narrowly focused in terms of funding structure, but I think it,

21:08 provides a balance there that minimum continues to cover the vast majority of Kim's cost as well as some additional there's other dollars that I know Kim has been working on coming into the organization. The other thing we attempted to do was kind of walk through building off of some work we had done at the town as well as what Kim had put together and trying to work through the deliverable sections or scope of services

21:39 I'll link it into the work that's ongoing, a couple of additional pieces there, but also trying to relate it back to the color of the money, if you will. There's a lot of good projects out there, and David, I think it was his letter you're reading, Craig, when I popped on some of that bigger picture stuff, which is a future projection project work for MLR to begin to look at.

22:07 I think what we're looking at on the town side, an agreement for services that we're requesting, if you will, hey, these are the services we need you to provide given this funding structure, the Measure R funding structure, which has limits in terms of what it can be used for and cannot be used for. And I think that's one of the key issues. I want to touch on that briefly because a lot of the structure through here was trying to highlight that piece in there. You know, for example, just

22:37 This is just fresh on my mind for sitting through the meeting as well as Kim did with like the whole debate and discussion over this first campaign, what's going on with that, how do we step into it, those types of things. I think that's a, that is an extremely valuable discussion. It's something from a broader picture for Mammoth Lakes Recreation to be engaged in, but that's not a legal use of Measure R money, if you will.

23:03 It is a program that is outside of the town boundaries. It is a program, for the most part, because we don't, it's illegal in the town to be dispersed camping already. It is a program that we don't control, we don't manage, we don't oversee it. Those types of elements are in the, you know, the legislation, if you will, that was approved by the voters. Long discussion, actually, with folks the other night on that, outside of MLR side. But anyway, so...

23:32 One of the elements is we're trying to lay this out and structuring it to the color of the money becomes very important as not just as we look at it, but if anybody from the outside or when we have our annual, you know, audit, if you will, look at it. As they do go through and look at those types of things, they'll ask questions at times, hey, is this legitimate expense and those types of issues if they have different things and they're called out that way versus just a direct payment component. And there's a lot of other programs in here that

24:02 A couple of them kind of are on the edge on that. I think there's other funding for it. I'll say like the Tangle Free Waters Program, I believe that had a grant program and those types of things set up. So trying to work through that and say, what is a reasonable workload? Also in one sense, providing enough funding to kind of cover the primary cost structure, but also hopefully putting it together at a level that there's some additional potential time.

24:32 in there to be able to do these other things that have other funding sources. I know there's been dollars brought in recently for some other work and stuff that Kim's been involved in, which I think really begins to help expand out MLR's influence and impact as well as some of the other programs that go on there. So without walking through a lot of the detail, but the idea here was kind of that, I'm going to call it almost a hybrid position from several meetings ago now and call it because we kind of have an ABC discussion.

25:01 And it moves back toward being more of a, you know, standard, here's the agreement to town, primary funding sources to town. I think there's that flexibility in there to continue to look, how do you go grow and work on dollars? At the same time, not happen to have staff do, well, you need to do 100% timekeeping, you have to track every hour where you're working, what you're working on, and billing accordingly to work through it. And then we would have to go through those and say, yeah, that's legitimate, measure our funding or not measure our funding.

25:31 And those types of things. So I think there's opportunities to grow what MLR is doing at the same time, providing their services kind of outlined back into the town and partnership with, you know, our Trails Group and those types of things. The other thing we've left in there is the use of office space for staff. I couldn't tell Kim if Rod and I would call today if that was you and the office students and stuff or somebody else. But anyway. And then the other

26:02 element to that is be able to keep that relationship like with Joel and work on the trail side. We're going to lose Matt Pruillo to the county full-time, but that's still a relationship. We'll keep in tact, obviously, as he'll just be a full-time county employee starting, I can't remember if it's September 1 or October, but they have fully funded that position on the budget there recently, so. But that's not really losing it, right, Dan? Wasn't that kind of the plan?

26:28 Yeah, it ends up shifting there. I mean, we lose him for our direct work, but definitely having him develop actually is a real compliment to him and the work he did. Now you're a full-time county piece that actually gives like him and Joel and, you know, MLR and others, here's that relationship that then built. It doesn't go away. It just focuses a little bit differently. And also raises those funds that we contribute to his salary. Right. Yeah, so those frees up some dollars on our side too, so.

26:57 But it was nice to see the county step up and actually fund a full-time position for recreation at this level of trails, because they have not done that, out of my knowledge, ever. So I think it's a real plus to have that asset here and working in the county. And frankly, Mammoth Lakes is part of the county, so it's not like they can't do stuff with us. So those types of elements that are pushing that together. So that's kind of where it came out of, but back and forth, independent completely, not quite.

27:27 Because of that linkage to the contract still retains all of the, you know, public agency requirements, you know, being a local government, you know, body still in terms of the three factors for being that public agency requirements is that primary funding source directly is from the town, the appointment of a town council member by the council to serve on the board and taking on a legislative

27:56 Duties of the town that we can delegate out to a body and that legislative process there. Then all of those things combined together, I think any one of them can put it into it, but that combined together all three points require MLR to continue to operate as a public legislative body. That's the Brown Act, et cetera, all those things. So that kind of hit a column from the last discussion, I think, kind of where we're at in those multiple paths and kind of narrowing it down.

28:28 Yeah, you know, thanks to both of you for kind of opening that up. You know, before I jump in, I just want to echo other sentiments with a huge thank you on behalf of the board to both David and Catherine. David's been there since the inception. We've been working on this since before MLR existed. And, you know, there's no one that has the institutional knowledge or history of continuity on this board that David does. So that's going to be, you know,

28:57 Missed and hard for us to replace. And a huge thanks to Catherine for her contributions to the board. I know it's not easy doing that from a distance. And we all have a lot of life and business commitments that we're juggling. And so huge thanks from all of us for both of those board members for their contributions. You guys will be missed. In terms of jumping into the contract stuff,

29:27 I've seen hundreds of these in my time on, you know, planning commission in town council. You know, a lot of it is kind of boilerplate legalese that I don't think is necessarily important for us to focus on unless, you know, anybody has any specific concerns. You know, I think in terms of our conversations, myself, Kim and Craig went through a number of discussions with Dan and council members Souser and Wentworth.

29:57 to kind of get us to the place where we're at today. I'd suggest that we maybe focus on kind of three things here in terms of our discussion. The first piece would just be the highlights from the contract. Those are obviously things that are called out for a reason to make sure that we discuss them and make sure that we're comfortable with them.

30:18 The second piece is obviously Exhibit A, where it really gets down into the details of the work program and what would be expected of MLR. So that's obviously something that I think we should have a pretty robust discussion on. And then the third piece, and Kim and I talked about this earlier today, is just kind of the notes that Kim had addressed based on that scope of work. I'd like to make sure that we kind of go through all that stuff individually.

30:47 Kim is really going to be the one that's handling this stuff, so I want to make sure that we're all on the same page and she's comfortable with the work program and the expectations. You know, to kind of take it back a little bit, you know, obviously we've been through a lot over the last year in terms of our relationship with the town and how that is going to look moving forward.

31:12 I think that's pretty understandable after going through a catastrophic event like COVID and the shutdown and what that would mean for budgets and relationships and work programs moving forward. So I'm glad that we're now at a place where we've come out the other side of that and are still being able to continue these discussions and work on having a continuing relationship moving forward.

31:38 I think we need to kind of keep in mind what is really in the best interest of the community and the taxpayers as well as just our own best interests as a respective board or council. And I think that it's been shown through this process and kind of the back and forth that there's a lot of very worthwhile projects that this organization has taken on and helps to implement on behalf of the citizens of this community.

32:07 I think there's a desire on both ends to continue that work that, you know, a lot of people, a lot of time and energy. You know, I think the last thing kind of we had, our last discussion was basically as Dan framed kind of an option A, option B, option C, if you will. You know, option A was really continuing kind of the old relationship that we had with the town, which was a very,

32:37 Tethered relationship, there was a higher degree of funding, and basically MLR was predominantly working on town work program initiatives. The option B was kind of the antithesis of that, which is a full separation from the town and go pursue other interests. And that option C, where I think most of our discussions landed, and that seemed to be most of the interest on everybody's behalf, was kind of that hybrid model of

33:06 You know, maybe continuing a relationship with the town, maybe not to the same degree and the same funding level as before, but continuing to work on implementing projects on kind of a contractual basis. You know, really the only thing that's changed in my estimation, Craig, Kim, Dan, you know, Bill, let me know if I'm off on this, but the only thing that's really different from our last set of conversations around this is

33:34 The town kind of expressed to us in a circle back some legal concerns and considerations around the legislative body language. And so where we had talked about before, there might be a way to kind of just work with the town on a contract basis, but maybe avoid some of the constraints of the Brown Act and the legislative body umbrella. We don't really think that that's a viable option moving forward.

33:59 So what that would mean is if we want to continue in this relationship, continue to receive funding for measures R and U, that we would fall under that umbrella of the legislative body and the constraints of the Brown Act and all that kind of stuff. Speaking for me personally as somebody that worked under those guidelines for multiple years as a planning commissioner and then multiple years as a town council member, that's never been a large concern for me.

34:28 I think that that still allows us the freedom and flexibility to do the things that we've discussed as a board, and that's not a make or break issue for me, but that is definitely something that we need to discuss as a group and make sure that everybody understands that and is comfortable with that. I think we're at a place where we have some great projects that both parties are interested in kind of continuing that contractual basis on.

34:57 But none of this, to me, precludes us from doing a lot of the things that we've talked about in terms of a potential name change, a larger regional focus, starting to build out some of those new initiatives, really kind of ramping up as an organization, as a fundraising entity. I mean, that's something that we've talked about since the inception of this organization that for whatever reason just hasn't happened to this point and I think does need to kick into high gear.

35:27 So I think we need to wrestle with that as a board moving forward is what that looks like to build out that infrastructure. But I don't think anything in this contract that we've laid out and discussed, including, you know, continuing to be a legislative body on behalf of the town and the constraints of the Brown Act hamstrings us from doing any of that stuff. So that is something that I think we want to highlight is just a discussion around that specific piece.

35:56 And then kind of going through what I discussed, the highlights in the contract, exhibit A in terms of the work program, and then Kim's notes. As a negotiating committee, we did not really get into brass tacks in terms of like numbers, billable hours, billable rate, contract basis. We really left that up to Dan and Kim to kind of work through those details. We were more focusing on the framework.

36:22 of this negotiation and the contract moving forward. So I think we've arrived at a pretty good place that I'm comfortable with personally, but this is definitely the time for us to discuss it as a board, clarify questions, that type of stuff. Hopefully that all made sense. And yeah, Colin, thanks. If I could step back into that too. I thought you'd wrapped up the thank yous earlier on. Sorry I missed that. Yeah, it's my thanks to David and his effort and time.

36:50 Service on MLR and the trails committee missing there just as much or more even than here in terms of his insights. And Catherine, if there's a way you can get her to stay on your allocation committee, Heather, I think that would be great. If she could have a narrow focus and she's willing to do something, that would be, she seemed to be very valuable in that discussion. Yes, we agreed that she should come on, kind of like how Rhonda did at the beginning, and yes, we would take her up for that. Thank you. Yeah, no, that's,

37:21 Very doable from that perspective. But anyway, yeah, it's just, yeah, she was, she was great. I appreciate her perception, perceptions and perspectives on a number of different elements within that whole dialogue. Yeah, so I think Colin touched on that. Yeah, and so I was just going to re-height, re-light, relay one other piece to that. He touched on it. We looked originally, look at, here's hours and time and billable rate in terms of work.

37:45 That was there and looking at that. That was really driving towards that more independence going, okay, if you want to be a true contractor, here's an hourly rate of X for services and that's where you're doing timekeeping and tracking and similar stuff that we do with other consultants and other nonprofits that we've worked with or certain things is, yeah, they have to track everything. It's an invoice. A lot of the projects have a not to exceed dollar amount without approval and it's much more of a

38:14 It's much tighter contractor slash service provider. And then ultimately you could bid that stuff out and do those things. And I think we kind of moved away from that, therefore not calling out a lot of the billable rate and timing and the agreement here back more the flat dollar amount. But it was actually kind of linked to and tied to from an hourly issue based off the original work that Kim did on those estimated hours through this stuff, trying to walk through and what would that look like.

38:44 I think the other, as Colin mentioned, I'll leave it up to Craig, if you guys want to run the meeting there, but try to go through the agreement, highlight areas that were important, I think, to make sure there was agreement or understanding or if there was questions on, we could deal with that stuff in that nature, and then actually the scope of services truly being one of the key factors. Is it doable, not doable, that we need to tweak it, whatever, through that stuff. So I'd be glad to...

39:13 Greg, I'll throw it back to you and however your board wants to work. If you have any other general comments, I'm glad to hear this as well. Yeah, Dan, I think, you know, doing just that and as Colin outlined, you know, going through the highlights from the contract that were all, you know, things that we definitely want to have dialogue and consensus on and

39:43 Make sure everybody's up to speed on that. So going through the contract first and then exhibit A, the deliverables and then Kim's notes. I think that'll lead us through it. So if you want to kind of guide us through that first part, which is the highlighted areas from the contract, that'd be perfect. Real quick, Tamara just said, sorry, my Wi-Fi went out. I'll be back as soon as I can.

40:14 Being sun-linked is going to become a verb. I can dive into some of these unless you want to give her a minute. Are you ready to go forward, Craig? Up to you all. Yeah, maybe just to give her a minute, you know, Craig, if there's anything you wanted to add in terms of our discussions or Kim, anything you want to add before we jump in? Because I do think it'd be helpful to kind of go through these one by one and definitely want Tamara to be here for that.

40:43 You know, I just think, you know, the point that Dan just made regarding, you know, how we've evolved through this discussion from, you know, our multiple options of, you know, wanting to be more free from the Brown Act and where we've ended up where we're more of a hybrid and that if we want to go out and fund other things outside of the scope of

41:13 of, you know, our contract with the town, we're free to do so, but that has affected that it's the contract amount is less the billable hours and more of that, you know, flat rate, which is in here, that $20,000 per quarter or $80,000 for the fiscal year, it will be a good discussion point for us is, you know, is that

41:44 amount, you know, the right amount for us considering the scope of work and that dialogue. But, you know, I think that nuance of we're not, we haven't went down the full contractor route and hence maybe the change of the context of the discussion less to the billable hours and not to exceed in some of that language. Kim, anything you'd add from our

42:14 from our conversations? You know, I don't think I do have anything to add. I think you all covered it very well. I think just the biggest turn since we all met together last as a board is we really did leave that meeting pursuing this hybrid option and that meaning not restricted by the Brown Act and that is

42:46 Probably the biggest and only change, I think, that we've experienced is that's just, it's back on the table. It's still part of the contract. So nothing, nothing really has changed. It just hasn't been removed. Yes. Yep. Great. So, you know, if you guys are good, I can kind of lead us through the contract discussion and the highlights and stuff. Perfect. Looks like we've got Tamara back. She's suddenly relived. Sorry, Wi-Fi cut out like, oh, now it's back on.

43:16 All right, cool. So let's jump into the contract. I'm going to gloss over things and you guys can kind of circle us back if we need to discuss anything. Does everybody have it in front of me so we can avoid screen shares and that kind of stuff? Okay. So...

43:41 The first highlighted item on page one, we obviously know parties and date, contractors, sources of funding, scope, terms of services. If we look down to term, this agreement would commence on July 1st and expire on June 30th of 2022.

44:03 And so, you know, basically it's a one-year agreement that may be extended by mutual agreement for up to two more one-year terms with the same conditions, and we would just do an annual update of the services and deliverables. So basically, you know, we'd be looking at a one-year contract here starting July 1st with the ability to extend for two more under the same structure.

44:31 I just want to get some feedback, make sure everybody's comfortable with that. And real quick, Colin, if I can, the purpose for structuring that, in that term, in the past, I think we've been like, well, we did like a three-year, you know, just called it out directly, then we also did the short one-term. The idea here was being, if there is ultimately a desire to do something different, it's kind of a built-in checkpoint to say, hey, are we all still happy? Let's keep it going.

44:59 Year to year there in a three-year deal is the way it was structured there. So it's kind of structured into that and we're not re-debating all the same issues again. The goal would be that we're able to move into things and I think this last year we had a lot of, on a very small budget, very difficult year, but we actually hit a lot of successes. I think this kind of built off of that, working into that and being able to have that discussion each year going, hey, are we still happy?

45:28 You know, it's, but it's built in automatically to go forward on that if we all go, yes, great, here's the update, the deliverables, the way we go. So it was a simple process, hopefully. Yeah, and I think, I think we can just kind of go through and discuss all these things and then, you know, before we have any formal action, we can. Yeah, yeah, absolutely. Just want to walk through and discuss. Yeah, I just want to give a background of a why for that. Yep.

45:54 The agreement being terminated as provided herein, I was looking for a continuation of an explanation of what that is, because it seems at any point there could be a termination without any agreement. I just, I didn't see anything past that. Yeah, there is a, yeah, I can find it for you. Cool, thank you. I just want to play devil's advocate. I understand, Dan, why the one year is a good check-in point.

46:25 However, I do recognize that a one-year contract is fairly short and it doesn't provide a lot of security for our organization or for Kim to know that the projects that she works on or the things that we start to work on have some longevity in them. So I would just throw that out there that it's a concern for sort of our long-term well-being as an organization. I can agree with that, Tamara.

46:57 It's kind of like when we go to event people, even our programmers, excuse me, and we get to give you one year and give you a chance, then we're going to give you a three year after proving yourself. And I feel like we're kind of past that point. Right. So I just have concerns about that. I would have liked to see a bit longer agreement. I'm fine with the check-in. I would have liked to see a two or three year agreement.

47:26 All right, I think that's a valid concern. Was, Craig? Yeah, I see the, you know, I kind of like the flexibility of it, though, you know, certainly the unknown, but right now, without a solid strategic plan really in place for our future, I'm

48:01 I feel like at least this first year, this is appropriate for where we're at as an organization during another one of our many transitions, kind of trying to, I like the analogy early of getting through our freshman, sophomore, junior year, but we just got to get through our senior year and decide what we want to be when we grow up. And so I'm okay with the one year as it stands.

48:30 And then as we have a better feel strategically where we're heading and what that may look like, this balance between contracting with the town, but also stretching out into some other areas with a more regional focus and getting our funding strategy underway for that, that that will be more

48:59 telling of our long-term health and financial future is us cracking that nut as opposed to it necessarily being tied to the TAM. Yeah, I think, you know, Tamara, that's a very valid concern to bring up. I think, Craig, that's very well articulated how I feel. I think I'm pretty comfortable with moving forward with a one-year agreement with the option to extend just based on...

49:26 Kind of the interim nature that we're in and where we're evolving. You know, I'm pretty comfortable with it, but I think it's a valid discussion for us to have for sure. How about Eric, your thoughts? You know, I'll echo all of that. I get what Tamara and Heather are saying that is a shorter term we have proven ourselves, but I think things will come up in this conversation that will show why we're going to want to have to talk about this in a year.

49:58 And the economics of this contract, I think, needs to change a little bit, and I'll save my comments on that for later in the meeting. How about you, Bill? What's your take on this? I think it's a great opportunity for both sides, a year-to-year with an almost automatic update unless we want to change it. I think it works really well. Let's put a pin in that. I've got a note on that. We can set that off to the side and kind of circle back and discuss that as we go into more deliberations on this stuff.

50:32 Yeah, hey, call real quick. Heather's already a question. If you look at page eight, there's a termination section on page eight. I forget the section number there. It talks about how the parties could do something and getting notice or defaults, et cetera. I'll just kind of move us along and we'll circle back to that. You know, it's not highlighted, but I do think it's important to call out 3.1.3.

51:01 No limitation on other activities. Nothing in this agreement should be deemed to prevent contractors from engaging in other worker activities beyond those set forth herein, either on its own initiative or at the behest of other parties, provided that the town should not be required to fund any such worker activities. I mean, obviously, there's mechanisms in here for us to continue to build on this relationship and add additional things in for compensation, but...

51:26 You know, what this basically states is like we've discussed in the past. You know, if MLR has other initiatives that we would like to move forward with, this doesn't preclude us from doing that. And I know that that was a strong desire of the board. So I think that's something that's important to call out. Yeah, call out. I'm sorry, that was highlighted on mine for that exact reason. Okay, cool. So yeah, it's definitely want to make sure that there's nothing that constrains what you can go do on your own.

51:56 Okay. Anybody have any thoughts, questions around any of that? Okay. Bunch of boring stuff about insurance and endorsements. Just kind of scrolling down here. The next highlighted item is 3.3 compensation and accounting. You know, as Dan kind of circled back and helped to articulate, you know, where we're at at this point is we've kind of agreed or

52:34 We're driven towards this place based on billable rate and perceived hours to handle these projects. But this is really based upon trying to take a step back from that and having it be so drilled down to that line item basis and just say, hey, we're going to work in a contractual relationship on a quarterly compensation.

52:59 The Town should compensate a contractor in the amount of $80,000 to be paid at a rate of $20,000 per quarter with a payment in July, October, January, and April of the Town's fiscal year. The compensation is provided for the delivery of the scope of services and specified deliverables as provided for in Exhibit A, which we will definitely spend some time discussing. Town may provide contractor with office space.

53:28 At no charge, the contractor to assist in providing the services and specified deliverables and to enhance coordination with town employees. I suspect that we may have a good deal of discussion around this specifically. This is obviously kind of getting down to the meat and potatoes of the agreement. So, you know, compensation of $80,000 for the work program.

53:57 Paid out quarterly. So I don't know, Craig, I don't want to kind of step on toes here in terms of how you want to handle this. Do we want to wait to discuss this piece specifically until we get into the deliverables or what do you think is best there? I think you're right, Colin, that, you know, let's put a placeholder on that. It gives us context in which to discuss the scope of service and deliverables and then

54:27 I have no doubt as we get into the depth of that, then we can see whether, you know, we feel, whether the board feels this is fair compensation in light of what those deliverables are. Yep. I think that it's obviously pretty clear in terms of what is proposed, and then we can discuss, you know, based on the deliverables, how we feel about that. So if everybody's okay, I'll kind of move on to the next section.

55:00 And Colin, it wasn't highlighted in mind, but make section 3.3.4 extra work. Got to take a look at that one too, where if we're assigning something, requesting something, there's compensation for those types of pieces. So I wanted to highlight that one. So just FYI for that. Yep. I actually do have it highlighted in mind. Just kind of that last section that basically says,

55:26 As we kind of already discussed, the extra work may be agreed upon by the parties as provided for the scope of services. So if we do kind of mutually come to an agreement that there's a new project or initiative that comes up, you know, that MLR wants to jump on top of and the town wants to support that through a funding resource, then we can do that. And then again, just below that, 3.3.5 other work.

55:54 Nothing in this agreement prevents the contractor from pursuing other work with separate funding sources. So, you know, it gives us the ability and the freedom to go out and, you know, expand our work program outside of the town and also if we mutually agree to pursue additional work with our, you know, contract relationship with the town, we can, there's a mechanism to do that as well. Also important, I think on the 3.3.5,

56:27 As the clerking support continues. So that's sort of extra on top of the funding, right? Yep. Good point, Bill. Thanks. So moving down, the next highlighted section on page nine is regarding the Brown Act. You know, I don't think we need to go over that ad nauseum. We kind of already discussed that in the intro, but...

56:55 You know, that is definitely something that has kind of changed or been adjusted since we last met as a board and something that we need to discuss and grapple with. But, you know, essentially under this contract, if we move forward, MLR would be subject to the Brown Act as a legislative body. And so that's just something that, again, I think

57:21 May just want to put a pin in and kind of discuss as we circle back at the end, but, you know, up to other people as well. Hey, Colin, I just had a question. We skipped over 3.5.3 on page 8. Looking at this, it looks like everything we do, the town has ownership of our intellectual property. I'm not an attorney, but I didn't see any language that would say that we do our own separate property.

57:52 When we do our own separate projects, that's our intellectual property, and it's only contractual for the town that I could see being their intellectual property. Dan, do you have any thoughts or response to that? Yeah, it ties back to that work for the town. If you're actually something out of your own, clarify that. But it's prepared by the contractor under the agreement, right? So the agreement says, yeah, you can go do whatever, great.

58:21 But if you're doing it on behalf of the town, basically, it basically is saying we're paying for whatever that is. So that becomes property potentially of the town as well as MLRs. You don't have an independent right to it. We're not paying you to develop something for MLR to go off and then sell it or you that are doing another fashion from that element. It's similar language in every agreement we have with contractors where we're not paying you to go rich yourself on behalf of the public.

58:51 investment in something. It also keeps it all as kind of a, unless there's a proprietary element that comes into play specifically, it all becomes a public document records. And so you can't say, hey, we really worked on this, but we don't want anybody else to see it. Well, sorry, you don't have that opportunity. Or if you develop something that the town asks you to develop and you work through it, it can't be a proprietary program of MLR. That's a joint type of things that we're paying for. So if you did something for

59:21 City of Bishop, for example, and you want to offer, not even city, for a private contractor, even out there, the fishing ranch or something, really did a great program, great, that would be yours to hold on to. No, that's great, dude. That all sounds very fair. I just want to make sure legalese represents that. Yeah. So, thank you. Uh-huh.

59:45 So that's all I've got really that drives us to Exhibit A, which I think is going to be the lion's share of our discussion. So I want to open it up a little bit more at this point, but I've got in terms of notes from our discussion so far that we may want to have a little more discussion on the one-year agreement part of things and just kind of drive to some sort of consensus there.

1:00:10 You know, we should maybe just kind of take a quick look at that language to address Eric's concern around the intellectual property. And then really, I think the most of our discussion is going to be around, you know, the work program and the proposed compensation for the work program laid out in front of us. And that's where I think we kind of go back a little bit towards some of Kim's notes, which was super helpful. Thank you, Kim.

1:00:39 You know, as the person that's going to be going out and implementing this stuff on a day-in, day-out basis, you know, what you're comfortable with, what you're used to, what's new, and whether you think it's a reasonable workload based on the compensation. So, you know, those are the things that I kind of have for us to circle back with as we move towards, you know, approving or not with the contract.

1:01:10 Yeah, I think if there's no other further discussion on that first part of the contract, then really diving into the scope of service and deliverables of Exhibit A, I think will really help us get to the meat and potatoes. Dan or Colin, do you have a preference of

1:01:46 Kind of, which one of you would kind of work through, lead us through that? I feel like I've been talking too much already, so I'm happy to take a step back. Dan, go for it. Yeah, I can dive into this stuff. It's, take it by a bigger section, if you will, and we, say we, but I built this to come in. I tried to take the initial write-up, I think that Kim had done, and she had hours and stuff assigned to it, so a lot of that stuff got pulled over.

1:02:17 In a very similar formatting, if you will, but trying to highlight it. A little bit different in part of that area. And so, and there's a few things in here that I've highlighted that I did on purpose for discussion that may get yanked out of the actual scope here. But that whole first section on the outdoor recreation element, the stewardship stuff, really deals in how you interface with our existing staff at the time.

1:02:47 Primarily Joel Raschee at this point, the trails program. I referenced the Eastern Sierra Sustainable Rec Coordinator Project. I believe you are the administrator off of that grant that they're doing on Buckeye, the Buckeye Creek, Kim, I'm forgetting so. And I highlighted that there. Normally that isn't something we put in our scope. I wanted to be very clear that one, it's already an existing program so we could do a letter of approval, no problem. Hey, go do that work or something.

1:03:17 That is the way to work and have dollars come in. But I also want to recognize that that is a time commitment. But it's really not something worth funding because there's a funding source for it and it's not part of major art programs. That's why that was listed out in there specifically on that number, that 3A and stuff. The other element on that is the actual support for that position will be dramatically different at this point because it's going to be 100% county position.

1:03:46 Unless there's something the county's doing in the town that relates to the major artwork, that element potentially could just get struck out of there as, again, that got changed just recently. So that was after this was already drafted as an example of things that happened quickly here. The other side is just the level of activity engaging in the process, the meetings and stuff with our staff and the other work we do. We laid out a number of agencies that are coming together.

1:04:14 I think, Kim, you attend the majority of the weekly coordination meetings already, those types of elements. We also wanted to highlight a lot of the work that's already going on. That's the adopted trail program, Tangle Free Waters, the elements there that have been going in our existing programs. Some of those have funding outside, some do not. Others did grow elsewhere if they have their own funding. The adopted trail program is a good example.

1:04:42 We have that working within the town, as long as we set up as a town program, we can fund it. If there's donations coming in, again, that provides another funding source for those types of programs. And then that would be another one, potentially, this goes back to this hybrid thing, where that program, I wouldn't be a bit surprised if MLRs asked, hey, how do we extend that into trails in the county? Again, that's not something we can pay for today, but that would be a very good extension in natural taking.

1:05:11 Work that you have in place, program you have in place and replicating it in other locations. And then the trail facility enhancement program that came out of some of the other discussion on that. How do we take a look at doing those types of elements there? Again, this would be focused on those within the town boundaries again for that type of work. And we have to make some of that is getting some agreements with the board service if we need them. The other one that was here that was specifically called out.

1:05:40 Stu can speak to more of this. We do have a, you know, a bench program. You know, we probably got 30 or 40 people out there going, hey, we want to put a bench out here with our loved one's name on it. It's a memorial to them or a memorial for people who love to come to Mammoth Lakes. A lot of that is, you know, as far as buying them and doing stuff, they actually do a donation for that and installing would be on the town.

1:06:08 Where it'd be really nice, I think, to have a non-profit and to establish relationships with them would be work with those donors. It can be a couple hours to four or five hours depending on what the donors are looking for. But a lot of that that we go through and identify where can we put them on the trails and that's a full service process as well where we actually have enough space out there where we want to put things and where people want them to go. People actually have their favorite trail or favorite location.

1:06:35 Those types of things to work through that. And again, if this is a program that becomes replicable, again, elsewhere in the county, great, especially if the donors are funding and paying for it, that just becomes a workload component. Then obviously the Measure U and Measure R grant awards, that's been the ongoing process. I think that one's probably a little more self-explanatory there. And then, you know, the follow-up stuff that happens.

1:07:03 The stewardship one was really trying to focus in on those key elements where we're actually working on the ground in partnership. We left off anything to do with construction because of the bidding processes. We can't just do a service contract and have you do contract construction on the groundwork. So that creates a public works code conflict. So those things are there. So there's a couple of things in there highlighted on purpose to show that outside work and others, how do we build something?

1:07:32 The town that can go outside if it has its own, if it has a separate, which some of these are designed to do. And Stu, if you want to touch base on the bench program and that other, just how we deal with donors and stuff, that's, or unless that covered it well. Yeah. Yeah, covered it well. Keep going, Colin. We'll follow you, bud. Sorry, Stu. Just real quick, you know, I think Kim's notes on this section are important, you know, basically.

1:07:58 We're already, or she is already doing everything in items one, two, three, and five from this first section. And that section four would be a new program to be developed and could take some extensive time and resources on behalf of staff. So I think a trail facility enhancement program is very valuable and something that we would want to consider, but it would be new for MLR taking that on.

1:08:27 Kim, although she is superwoman, is only one person, and there's only so many hours in the day and so many hours to be allocated, so it's just something we've got to keep an eye on. Thanks. Yeah, the donor program we looked at, because we did have the funding source, and originally played with some time on that, and it's probably anywhere from that two to four, maybe five hours with a challenging donor. But again, that would be working in partnership with the town staff as well. We had actually ordered and installed, we'd do all that type of it, so put that front end.

1:08:58 And the goal of it, as I mentioned, if you actually establish a relationship with some of these buildings, does that become a funding partner in the future? It's like you saw with the bridge at Horseshoe Lake or those types of things. Yeah, just to add some context too, as Kim knows, we've been working on this for probably a couple of years. Started with the town, went to MLR, came back to the town, and now we're kind of looking to provide some, have MLR provide some additional capacity. So we've actually built the GIS platform.

1:09:27 that we want to use to administer this program. That would essentially be everything's, every asset or potential asset is on a GIS map. So any potential donor can just jump in to the interactive page, much like the camping map and the dog map we did. That's how it's kind of set up right now. So we kind of have that, we're just identifying locations. So once we hand that over to MLR, it's really just administering that program.

1:09:56 So, you know, as I said, town staff, we've worked with Kim. We have a list right now, Kim, right? I think it's a growing list, 20 to 30 people that want to get on this program, throwing money at us, really. And we just have to figure out the best way to make this work for the best interest of the town, MLR, and the donors. And it's above and beyond just kind of benches as well, right? We're really looking at enhancing our parks and recreation facilities, amenities, trails.

1:10:25 You name it, pavilions, electric barbecues, right? So now with the stewardship of open flames and fire, having kind of electric barbecues in our parks versus charcoal and these open barbecue flames, that could become a priority here, right? Clearly with what we're experiencing now with the restriction on open flame in our community. So anyway, that's just a little bit of context, but yeah, thank you. Any questions?

1:10:54 If I could just give my two cents on that, as far as the programs and dealing with donors for items like benches and things like that, I think it is very appropriate for it to be handled by a nonprofit rather than the town, so I would be very supportive of that. Coming from a nonprofit standpoint where we do deal with, I do deal with donors quite often, it's taxing and takes a lot of time. So my biggest concern is how much time it's going to take of Kim's, not just

1:11:24 The execution of it, which is going to take time in order to, you know, require all the assets to put these, actually put them into place. But there's a lot that goes into when somebody wants to put a memorial bench up or things like that. It's emotional and it's taxing on your time. So I just want to make sure that MLR is compensated appropriately for the work that she's going to be required to put in.

1:11:49 And I'm fully supportive of it being an MLR project. I just want to recognize and make sure that that time is compensated. Well stated, I'd say. And keep in mind, too, as we deal with those, we can limit the number of donors, frankly. I mean, if we have to, you're going, great, yes, you're in line, but we'll get to you when we get to you, if you will, in one sense. So it's not a matter of, you know, stepping in and be overwhelmed day one. Here's, you know, 30 people to go spend hours and hours with. I agree, it's a good program. It can be overwhelming.

1:12:21 Right now, we're putting a lot of people on hold depending on how we're going to do it. It's our own staffing issue. You never, I'm sorry, but I'm in sales. When someone wants to give you money, you don't say no. So you need to find a way to execute those funds ASAP, and if that means that eventually that Kim's going to have to have somebody to either be underneath her or if she's going to need somebody above her one way or the other, as this starts to roll forward, this position needs to be able to develop because you never want to say no to somebody when they want to give you money. Sorry. I hear that, but yeah, it's, we...

1:12:50 Tell people no at this point. Or put them on hold at this point. And the town would buy the benches. So we would buy them out of our budget. We would install them. And then just do the invoicing back and forth between MLR once the donation is made with MLR. We would just invoice MLR for the cost of the bench and the install. And away we go. So it's a good partnership. Let me just say that.

1:13:18 It'll be a very valuable partnership for the community. Looking forward to working with Kim on the program. Thank you. It'd be great. As long as she gets support, Stu, I think it's fantastic. Oh, yeah. Good. Maybe on to the next section, potentially, unless anybody else has anything else you want to discuss at the moment right here. Yeah, Dan, you want to dive into communications and outreach?

1:13:53 Yeah, again, the goal here was to try to reflect what MLR is already working on. This one starts to get into a couple of gray areas for funding structure. I'll speak personally for a second. I like the information that's coming out. I enjoy the trailhead, those types of issues coming forward. There's a lot of information there that is, you know, dramatically beyond what the town and Measure R is looking at. It's great information on recreation.

1:14:22 And Kim does it. Whoever's pulling the research together with the camera, if you're doing that, or it reaches out and touches in other places, other areas across the country in some cases. And so I think there's a real big value there of what that brings in in terms of creativity and thought. It's on the edge of being a town managed program or a town element for the funding. But I think the relationship, we can make that probably work. I'd love to see other people go, hey, we like your newsletter. How do we subscribe to it?

1:14:51 So that was that one. The other one, you know, the stakeholder meetings, that's been an ongoing element there, convening those and working with a couple of those. Again, that's in partnership, I think, with Joel and the work that he does with that as well. And I think the website and Clara work has been an ongoing program already. The question on some of that becomes of where does some of this stuff live? Is it on an MLTS website?

1:15:19 or an NLR website, how do we make sure that the sense of authority information is clearly articulated that, those types of things, and being able to put information out on the programs we have, and I think, been a while since I went into the website, but I think a lot of that has been built and is there, and correct me if I'm wrong there, so, and then obviously with the major use stuff and the elements there, however that's.

1:15:48 Information that's been rolling out consistently. So I'm not sure in that one how much is new and different, but I'll leave that to Kim to make some notes or comments related to that. But I think some of this work has been ongoing. I know the last Trails meeting we had after the wind got blown up with the internet, but it was a great turnout. There was a great group of people on there. I think a very effective outreach to some of the work that's going on. I think that was focused a lot of that on the shrimp work at a dual shop.

1:16:18 I thought it was a very well done. I forget who helped kind of run it. Carolyn. Thank you. Yes. From the event director for MLR, MLT. Yeah, she did a great job out of the trails committee side. So anyway, yeah, so you can kind of walk through that in the same way. I think it's good to say what's currently on the plate being done and what's additive and then if we need to tweak stuff around accordingly.

1:16:50 Or how much is really measure versus not. I think there's some good information going out, which is positive and a good step forward to do that. Yeah, I mean, I think it's critically important that we're, you know, communicating and getting public outreach going. And so I think those are all, you know, valuable things for us to continue. I mean, seeing as Kim is going to be the one doing the work, you know, her comment that the commitment of weekly coming out for the trailhead is not realistic. I think we need to.

1:17:19 that advice. And, you know, we could maybe move it to, you know, periodic or monthly or, you know, frequently or whatever you're most comfortable with, Kim, but I could see, you know, weekly constraint being maybe too much. Other than that, I don't have a lot to say personally about this section except for, you know, we should probably adjust that word weekly under item one. Yeah, that sounds good to me.

1:17:51 Weekly's awesome. I think it's a little ambitious. I also wonder if the content loses some value every week, you know, people just get every week in their inbox and kind of skip over. So it's something I'd like to play with. It's not saying it won't go out weekly, but I don't want to be restricted. I don't mind if we just say regular communications and you figure out what it works. Yeah, I think it's great.

1:18:19 Great tool and great asset. And yeah, I enjoyed it. My perspective that way, if you had regular community, and I can see the newsletter going out, but the other regular communications could be a very focused to the same group. And they're doing a trail days cleanup. And that's the only piece that goes out. It's not a full newsletter. Some of that kind of gets picked in their things, but that regular communication, I think coming out from MLR is important to the organization as well.

1:18:49 weekly to regular communication solves that issue. Works for me. Yeah, and just to answer your question earlier, Dan, the community stakeholder meetings are new this year. MLR has always helped with the Mammoth Trails meeting, but when the Shady Resigno Craters project came online, we really wanted to do a community-based meeting.

1:19:19 And so that's above and beyond that was initiated this past year separately from the Mammoth Trails. Right, okay. Yeah, that was a great meeting. And again, I think our staff was a partnership that helped set it up. Hey, Kim, in this section is, you know, in 3A, it talks about some of the web pages and maybe that public comment earlier about, you know,

1:19:53 Yeah. Change to review that and maybe provide us some insight to that public comment. Yeah. Do we want to reread the public comment or should I just explain how mammothrails.org is different from item three? Let's reread the public comment just to make sure, you know, we're doing our due diligence and understanding, you know, what the concern is, but then also...

1:20:23 you know, the board understanding where this may be different or not. Angela, could you? Yes. And this was regarding Appendix A. This, excuse me, this item needs clarification as it appears that the MLTS website that has been developed and maintained by MLTPA under the TOML contract would be duplicative if taken over by MLR.

1:20:53 Hosting is reasonable, however. So would MLTPA still develop and maintain the Trails website under its contract, serve as a subcontractor to MLR, or would MLR be expected to develop and maintain a similar website? And so to answer that, these are discrete web pages that MLR will host based on specific projects and programs.

1:21:23 that the trail system is currently involved with. Like the adopted trail page, which has facilities and is able to accept the donations, like the shady rest in your craters page, which has all the resources, past meetings, at work, et cetera. So an additional resource to the trail system, not duplicative in any aspect to the mammothtrails.org website.

1:21:54 Thank you, Kim, and it covers, from the looks of it, both Lake Basin connector trails. I think that's just a typo. I was excited. We got an extra trail in there. We're trying to build as much as we can, right? Awesome. Okay, thank you for that. Any other questions, comments, clarity needed by the board before moving on to

1:22:27 The next section. Let me just ask Kim, I think a lot of these web pages have been built as updating them or they're somewhat duplicated. I know as new stuff comes on, you put on a new page, it's very project-specific and fundraising-related to some degree in terms of that donation button and stuff, which I believe then goes through MLR, correct? Yeah, so Sherwin's Meadows Trail, Sherwin's Trailhead, Poo Ferry, and Host.

1:22:59 Have not been developed yet. Lakes Basin Connector Trails is in draft form, ready to go. Shady Racineal Craters, Adopted Trail Tangle-Free Waters are up and running. And the Measure R and Measure U pages. And I'm sorry, I'm thinking, this one here was trying to get down to a very discreet deliverables on there. It may be talking about develop, host, and maintain web pages for following. It might be similar to the following because if one of these drops off.

1:23:29 We can't go, well, we never did do it. Yeah, well, why didn't you do a webpage on something that never happened? Don't want to get into those types of discussions. So if we need a little clarification there, let me know. All right, hearing nothing else, let's move on to management of advisory committees and funding recommendations. You know, I'll just interject of all the things that I see in this contract deliverable, I think this is...

1:24:02 You know, kind of the area that MLR has excelled up to this point. I think it's obviously a really important service on behalf of the community and legally we're obligated under R&U to follow these procedures. And I think, you know, a tremendous amount of work from a lot of board members has gone into developing and honing this. And, you know, Kim's only comment here was on item six that, you know, it's probably a good idea in my estimation to continue to

1:24:31 to review and update the allocation process, but that, you know, probably about 40 hours of work estimated would be required to do that. So there's something for us to be aware of in terms of hours necessary to, you know, perform on all these deliverables. But, you know, I think this is an area where we excel and is all really good stuff for us to continue doing. I think that number six was really, the review could be very, very short. Hey, it all worked great.

1:25:02 We're happy, but I know at times when the committee has met and done things, they'll have a comment, hey, we really should look at it. It's like the change going from here's a one-time period, here's a three-type, here's a three-year allocation. I think changes that have come out of the process is really what this is focused on, not a sit down and review it, soup to nuts, if you will. But I think in the whole process, people have gone through it. I'd say at least in my experience, the last few years.

1:25:28 It seemed almost like every year something's been tweaked a little bit to actually improve the process. I think that's, you know, kudos to the group working on that, Heather and her team and Kim looking at it as processes come in. So ideally not to sit down and just do an independent, complete review, but in that whole process, that seemed to happen organically, pretty powerful. But that was a thought process. It's a lot of work in this whole program here, absolutely. And I agree with you, Colin. I think it's an area that

1:26:00 MLR has excelled in the last few years. It's definitely a real plus. Any other comments, questions, clarifications from the board on this area? Any of these committees and funding recommendations? Awesome. Then let's move on down to council updates. Dan, do you want to talk a little bit about why you feel the

1:26:44 Need for this area and just, you know. Yeah, absolutely. I think this is one of those things of we usually put it in a lot of our contracts and it tends to lose its importance as we talk about regular updates and stuff. We put it here quarterly. Part of that is so we keep the connection between MLR and the town council. We don't want to see that drop off or not be there. I think that helps the relationship stay solid.

1:27:12 The other side of that, in doing so, the idea is that hopefully I can see regular updates like this that don't require a massive amount of time. We're not looking for an eight-page PowerPoint. It, frankly, could be a verbal update with two lists of bullet points of successes. So not looking at this to be something that's overwhelming timing-wise, but that it's a regular process of the council members and, frankly, the public as well.

1:27:42 Dial into this stuff. Start seeing what we're achieving, what we're doing. Yes, we're meeting these deliverables. And not to make it overwhelming, it's not like taking a list of every single thing in here and having to spend three minutes on every item, you know, doing a half hour, 45 minute hour presentation. I think it's that get in, successes, here's where we're at, or if something is not working, you need to identify it. And really kind of, but it's that connection with your,

1:28:12 You know, client, contractor, you know, relationship there is just a good way to keep that connection going. And frankly, I could see some of this, I mean, board members, frankly, can take a role in that presentation and go, yeah, bump, bump, bump, look, we've done A, B, C, and D, we've done this. If you have questions, Kim's here, she can give you all the details, but, you know, Craig walks through five things, takes 10 minutes. At that point, and Bill can speak to some of this too, I think, just in terms of that,

1:28:42 ongoing regular communications with the council, I think, keeps the relationship tighter and that's the main goal of this from that element. So, and yeah, here's what we're doing and here's what we're succeeding. You know, it's my opinion that this is a great addition to the deliverables in that maybe we've struggled in that area in the past and maybe it's been unspoken or

1:29:11 You know, oh yeah, we do once a year and then it's too much or whatnot. So, you know, having this articulated within the contract and, you know, I think that quarterly basis of a quick update, you know, kind of aligns also nicely with kind of how the funding is proposed on a quarterly basis. It's a good reminder to check in with your client.

1:29:41 A lot of times I think we just assume people know what's happening and as you talk to them you find out that that didn't work. Again, the idea for this one is not to make it overwhelming in the type of report also. I think that getting it down, if you can do a two-page or a one-page report can have as much or more impact than a 30-minute.

1:30:07 Nice done PowerPoint slide deck. After the first two slides, people kind of lost it. So anyway, just kind of, we can kind of work through what that looks like. And again, I would encourage board members to kind of step into some of that role as well. So the council sees and hears and understands that. I can defer to Bill and Colin was in this council planning commission type stuff. That type of an update, I think, can be really powerful and supportive of the organization from that.

1:30:36 elected leader position. Excellent. Bill, anything to add on that? Yeah, I think that communication is always important. And this is a great communication tool. Not a dog and pony show, as we may have sometimes seen in the past, but just an update of what's going on in communication between the two, I think, is critical for us to move together smoothly. So, yeah, I think that it's an important feature.

1:31:07 Thanks, Bill. Any other comments on that section on council updates? Seeing none, why don't we... If I make... Sorry, Craig. Yeah, although it's... Yeah, thank you. Although it's not spelled out in the deliverables, I think there's a good discussion here for the board of MLR, you know, when it does reference municipal recreation, and that's really kind of the level of engagement with the Recreation Commission, right? So perhaps it's not spelled out here specifically, but I think it's a good discussion.

1:31:36 that we have on the Recreation Commission side, you know, and I think it's probably important to have your discussion from MLR and your kind of level of engagement with the Recreation Commission. I mean, just case in point, in the strategic plan of the Recreation Commission right now is, you know, the CRC, Whitmore Recreation Area Planning, you know, this dog park, you know, the bike park, and some other projects too, right? So, I mean, that advisory body to town council is also perhaps working on similar...

1:32:06 projects that might come in front of MLR at some point. So we've had, you know, good engagement in the past. You know, there's always been kind of a scheduled annual meeting. Perhaps there's opportunities for MLR and Recreation Commission to, you know, keep that level of communication open as well. I think it'd be very valuable for both advisory bodies and certainly for the community as well. I appreciate you bringing that up and I don't know how other board members feel, but

1:32:35 I think we might want to consider adding something about that into the contract just because when MLR was formed, that was a general concern from the public is how we were going to kind of define and delineate roles and responsibilities among MLR and municipal rec. And I think that's an important thing that we're not continually having those discussions and conversations and understanding where we collaborate and where our differences are.

1:33:06 You know, can lead to confusion for the public at least. So I'd be supportive of adding something in there. I know it's not, you know, necessarily directly between the town council and MLR, but all falls under the town's umbrella. And I think that'd be valuable.

1:33:21 And I'd like to add to that, there's also going to be a point right now where municipal and recreational are going to kind of cross over if you look at what's happening with having the CRC and hopefully the MAC one day. So I think there's a lot of crossovers that are going to occur and we need to be able to justify and differentiate with the town and with the public. Good point. Maybe we just change that from council updates to update the town, which can be inclusive of all the different groups that need to work together.

1:33:56 If you put advice to town and take out council or you put including, you know, council, commission, staff, the whole idea of having staff working close together is actually so you could work through this stuff and I could see Kim and Steve going, hey, we really should go make sure that the rec commission is up to date on what you're doing here, what we're doing here with you, or frankly, what needs to be presented to Mammoth Lakes Recreation as well from the town side coming back and having the staff be able to juggle through that when we need things.

1:34:25 I think having some level of the contractor to the client to the owner, if you will, is good to have that discussion. But yeah, if you had to advise the town in a more generic statement, we could do that as well. Yeah, maybe we could change the language to advise the town and then in parentheses including town council staff and recreation commission, et cetera. You know, that might

1:34:56 Calling out those three entities specifically in the parentheses might work. I'm hoping at some point if Kim takes advantage of an office the town may give her when we all go back to some sort of normalcy, it will create a better line of communication between MLR staff, which is Kim, and town staff, which is Stu, so that these communications happen even outside of official updates. Do you all provide child care?

1:35:31 We have employees who do bring kids into work now again. Absolutely. Come on in. I just wanted to make sure she's getting covered. Fox and Rec. That's what we do. Thank you for that point. I appreciate the discussion and the acknowledgement of the benefit for that enhanced collaboration and engagement. And I think Bill nailed it. It starts at the staff level and then the different, you know,

1:36:01 volunteer groups can then engage as, because you are the ones who are going to know that engagement is needed. Well, and I'll say in some of the other experiences and stuff, if the staff's having that discussion, all of a sudden Stu's doing an update, his regular update to the rec commission. By the way, we're working with Mammoth Lakes Recreation on X because he's aware of it. He doesn't have to wait, you know, to a formal park to have somebody come in and say it. It's that,

1:36:31 That immediate, be able to do that, and then you do the formal updates that you need to, and or even at the council level, if we have that relationship working, same thing, we're in some of the own reporting out, and same thing going back to Mammoth Lakes Recreation, I can see Kim saying, yeah, we're meeting with Stu and Joel on this project to move this piece forward, or, and I think that just the communication structure there, when you're not every, you know, five days a week in the building together, but when you have a lot more interaction like that.

1:37:02 That organic communication just becomes much stronger than that allows you. Hey, let's really bring this project. And it might be going direct commission. It's not a general update on every deliverable. We need to talk about the new XYZ project or program that we're implementing. You know, let's give an update on the Adopt-A-Trail program. All of a sudden, we're doing really successful outreach on. And you just know that you can bring a particular item forward versus waiting to...

1:37:32 particular time frame to have a broad discussion that might not be as impactful. Just my final comment. I think we use the term kind of community recreation. So if you want to flip those back and forth, but that's kind of our mission here for Parks and Recreation. All right. Thank you, Stu. You're welcome. And we can call out that. We say quarterly in here. We're going to call it out broader. I would probably change that back to a regular reports at scheduled meetings.

1:38:06 Yeah. Take out the term counselor again as well. Okay. I'm looking for head nods or something for editing and stuff, so. Yeah. Thumbs up. Thanks, Colin. And then moving on to grant support. Yeah, and Stu can speak to this one. This would be a new kind of a one-time front end, and then if we actually get the grant, there's admin that has to go, that gets built into it. Stu, do you want to walk through?

1:38:38 The Prop 68 grant that we're looking at here. It would be my pleasure. So we've investigated several grants through the Proposition 68 program. And our analysis is kind of indicating in discussions with the grant team from California State Parks is that the regional park program is probably the one with the best fit for an opportunity for our region to

1:39:06 be awarded or at least be considered for grants. The original park program is really focused on areas above 50 acres and really the delineation for us is that it has to be submitted by either a county, a park district, open space authority, joint powers authority or a non-profit. So we really believe that this is probably the best partnership that we can kind of engage in.

1:39:36 to pursue upwards of $3 million for Whitmore Recreation Area and that expansion down there. We have already committed, as we all know, funds and we have an outstanding nine lane running track. But in that phase two project, there's other amenities that have been identified and actually have plans for. We actually have already our environmental work completed.

1:40:02 So what we're looking forward is to conduct some public meetings, which is a requirement of the grant. It needs to be submitted by November 5th. And we're really looking to partner with MLR on submitting that grant for the benefit of the community. And that would be a $3 million grant that we'd apply for. So we've got a lot of work to do to get this submitted, but looking forward to working with MLR on that project. And I think a lot of the heavy lifting would be on the town staff side.

1:40:33 coordination with MLR, but you do need that nonprofit to put the grant forward with the name on it and stuff. And then obviously you build into that, I forget the percentages there, you build in admin costs and coverage for going forward. So it becomes a funding source for MLR as well. Hopefully not a ton of admin work as we go forward on it, but that would be a joint service, if you will, to town supporting that as well. Yep.

1:41:01 You know, at the risk of being a broken record, I will say again that I think this is an incredibly valuable project for us to be involved in and would be a huge benefit for the community. And I just want to heed Kim's notes again that, you know, it may require significant resources and time to get through that. So I think that's going to be the lion's share of our discussion coming back through here is, you know, what can Kim manage? What is reasonable, you know, given?

1:41:29 The constraints of only having a one member staff. So, you know, I think that's super exciting and I think it's the exact type of stuff that we should be involved in and helping drive to the finish line, but cognizant of Kim's time and available resources.

1:41:48 I'm just wondering how it's a lot right now that we're talking about for deliverables. I just want to know if Kim has an opinion here on is all of this realistic. I see this being one and a half people's jobs right now as we continue to grow. So I just want us to be very upfront about this. I don't want to disappoint anybody. Are you asking me? Yeah, please. Comments. Dive in, Kim. Comments. So, yeah, it's a lot of work. And it's...

1:42:22 It primarily lines up with everything that I had sketched out, making DraftScope works as well, you know, with hours and commitments. The one thing that wasn't in my estimates was the grant support. I think it's a great addition. The only thing that worries me is, you know, I had come up with estimated hours of, you know, 1,274.

1:42:52 to be exact. And in talks with the town prior, this grant is probably another 250 hours, which is great. However, I just think on the compensation side, we need to revisit how the amounts are calculated. And, you know, there'll be some things removed, support for the Eastern Sierra Sustainable Rec Coordinator, right? You know, I budgeted two hours a week for that.

1:43:21 There's some things that'll come off, but the biggest difference in what I had calculated and this exhibit is just the grant support being part of the scope of work rather than an additional contracted service. That's not saying I don't think I can handle it. I think we can, but I just think it being included should be revisited. Exactly.

1:43:49 An addition, right? So then a rate that you said, an hourly rate in addition to, so it should be not being filled into the exact deliverable scope of what you're being paid for now. Yeah, or if it is, perhaps, you know, as we get into more of the budget talks, there's an increase in the budget. Thank you. And then let's go over this last little bit of additional contracted services, a couple items there.

1:44:20 And this is highlighting the extra work outside the scope of services provided where herein will require the following, just the process for that. And so kind of ties right into the conversation we were just having. If this grant support team, if I'm understanding this correctly, an opportunity like

1:44:52 The Prop 68 came during the middle of our contract. This is the process we would follow in which to do additional work for the town. Correct. And I do again want to call out Kim's notes on here that I think locking in a specific billable rate for one to three years is not prudent and that compensation for extra work should be paid out.

1:45:23 Current billable rate makes more sense than allocating a specific dollar. I would agree. I agree, because there's different scales of work. Yeah, I do too, and I appreciate the amount that was put in. That's what we were sort of working off this past year. I do think it's a good idea moving forward to just put whatever the current rate will or is. Yeah, because that would be something if we agreed to. If the rate's gone up a lot, we don't want to pay it. Great, we'll go get somebody else to do the work. That's easy enough.

1:45:57 Yeah, that's what I was going to say. If you leave it open, then it allows each item to be negotiated based on its merit and cost. Because of that, if you put that in there, I just have one question. Does that mean that you have to then shop it out because of public funds to multiple people before you present it to MLR? No, if it's a professional service level contract and we have it in here, we can do that. Obviously, if the rate's too much or we think it's going to be

1:46:27 We can definitely, we can go out and ask for other quotes. You know, you could ask some cases, you know, the Chamber of Commerce has a nonprofit. Will they be, if it fits their mechanism, would they be willing to do it? If MLTPA obviously would be one we could talk to. Some items, broader issues here, Friends of the Inyo's out there. We actually looked a little bit on the Prop 68 one. I don't recall if it actually covers the...

1:46:56 Park, if it would fit quite right, but the CSA one is the Crowley Lakes organization or the county, the community services. I don't know if that fits the park district definition, but that would be another group we'd go to, okay, hey, can you be the applicant? And some of that we're asking because we need to have that applicant. We're not necessarily handing off and saying, here, go do all the work on this. It's more about how do we make sure that we're...

1:47:22 Walking hand in hand to get a lot of, my guess is the town would be the vast majority of the actual grant work, but you do need that non-profit application component going into it, and then there's ongoing reporting requirements naturally where that admin dollar comes in too to support, you know, paying for that time as we go forward, obviously, if we get grant dollars in. Reimburse time, I think that makes those grant dollars in kind of a more of a less restricted type of revenue coming back in. That's one of the ways you need to build that revenue back in preparation.

1:47:52 And Dan, Dan, I've got one last question. Sorry, as I'm sitting here and we're talking about this and shopping out and different nonprofits, it just came to my head. So a lot of times when you have an ED position and they're going out and they're looking to raise funds for a nonprofit, sometimes there's a percentage, if I'm correct, that the ED would receive out of those funds for the scope of work that it takes to go out and find funds for

1:48:19 Different projects. Is that something that Kim could ever do in the future? Just talking in the future, nothing specific? It could be potentially that way. The question here, of course, if it's grant work and some grant people will write grants based on being able to write in their own cost to it. It depends on what the grants allow that as one example. The other side is going out to donors and saying, hey, I want to raise $100,000. If I can do that, I keep $10,000 back to the organization or to the EV.

1:48:46 From a public agency standpoint, that gets a little bit more dicey, just in terms of perspective or, you know, the viewpoint from a public standpoint on that. Other standalone nonprofits, it's different. A lot of them, you know, a lot of them come at the ED side and say, great, glad you're here. Now go raise your salary. Work with some chamber execs who's been basically had to go do that. Those types of elements.

1:49:15 Down the road, I mean, I think some of that could happen, but it'd probably be more outside of the scope of the town services. You know, if you're going out and working with another, especially a private or other non-profit or maybe even another public agency, but kind of outside of the town itself. Otherwise, I can see people going, so why are you continuing to pay X if you're having them go do this to bring dollars back in? So anyway, it just gets a little, the...

1:49:42 The details of that gets a little dicey. Great. Thank you. Kim, were there any other notes as we've worked through all of this? Just, you know, I think, you know, more than anything, we want to hear that you're comfortable with the workload before we start going in, getting into the, having a further discussion on the compensation part.

1:50:13 And particularly maybe more pointedly, you know, do we need to be thinking as a board about bringing on additional part-time staff to Heather's point? Pardon me. Yeah, I mean, I guess to start, I think the scope of work is great. It's good work. A lot of it is what we're doing. Most of my comments were truly

1:50:45 We're doing this. We're doing this already. We're doing this well. There were just a couple of the additions, which I think are positive and line up with MLR's mission and what we can be doing. And I think it's a lot of work. I don't know how much additional time, if any, we'll be able to be spent like exploring additional opportunities.

1:51:13 You know, so if it's very important to the board to explore more regional opportunities, you know, we might have to cut some of this stuff out. And as far as having additional staff, I honestly haven't even thought of it. Of course, I would love it. It would be great. But it just, you know, hasn't been an option this past year. And so I haven't even

1:51:43 thought of it, but you know, like part-time staff for specific tasks will be great, you know, but if and when that happens, it'll be, but yeah, I don't think it's enough work for like two full-time people for sure. Yeah, to Kim's point, I think I, when I was playing with this, I think I had it running 1,300 to 1,400 hours of staff time, assuming, you know, you're going to work

1:52:17 I'll say 1900 hours, you know, time off, et cetera, call it whatever, so it's not 2080, but you roll that back into that, what does that mean for doing other work? And again, the challenge that we'll run into a little bit is, yes, go do this other work and outreach and exact things we're talking about, but by the way, the Measure R money really shouldn't be funding that work of going out.

1:52:47 Doing work for Inyo County, for example. So there's some balancing in that. I think there's some ways in this for other money to come in, and that's part of the whole grant thing too. That actually frees up more time from a funding mechanism to say, yeah, it's good to use that money to pay because they can go do X work out there outside of what the town scope is tied to the major R funding structure. Again, I hate to bring that back, but the color of the money becomes really important in how we utilize it and make sure we're legal in our uses.

1:53:16 of those types of things. You know, the grant work, I mean, that's something, you know, if we went out to somebody else, yeah, we'd be bidding it out, if you will, or looking at getting quotes or getting support for somebody else to work on that type of a thing or something which we could do. Or Stu's still on, okay, I thought maybe he left and I could make the comment a little stronger. Just tell staff, hey, guys, figure out how to make this work and crank it out. But in this case, you know, you have to have a nonprofit partner or other type of partner to be the applicant along.

1:53:46 with or support of. So, but anyway, I think there's time where ideally it was trying to build in, not something that, and the rough estimate of the dollars was going, yeah, this is the majority of Kim's cost, I believe, not 100% of it on purpose. Otherwise, she would not be able, we're going to do, truly say, we're funding 100% of Kim from Measure R, then you only work on Measure R projects, which I don't think that's where MLR should be or wants to be.

1:54:17 Exactly. Can you remind us just for this discussion? I appreciate kind of breaking it down into specifics. What was the exact funding level from the town to MLR in the past fiscal year? It was like 289 or somewhere around 300? 192, I think, is what we had in older contracts. We were funding ED and the support staff. And we set that up.

1:54:44 Again, this goes back when Burst brought an add-on. We did the general fund allocation to help support that and where it was with the whole idea being there is here, go do fundraising, here, go do these other things. And obviously that never supported itself going forward. But we had about 192 sticks in my head or 196, if you remember, 192 sticks in my head is what the contract was to support that. Then we had a general fund component.

1:55:12 That was backfilling that up to $75,000 a year, $225,000. So that was at the $192 plus? I think that $75,000 might have been in that $192 number, but I think it was like $130,000 give or take for the ED and $50,000, $60,000 for support components. I'd have to go back and look at that stuff. And Kim, I don't know if you have a better recollection of what was on top or what was supportive.

1:55:44 Yeah, I think I recollect, was it MLR was front loaded with some general fund money for the fundraising and then it was a annual contract of 192. Yeah, yeah, I think the front, I think we did front, we did the 225 up front of the one-time payment and the idea, because we couldn't really, we didn't know what more would be spent in the first six months of the last six months of doing things, so. Right, and that was the understanding of them.

1:56:12 Yeah. This past year to spend down those reserves that were front-loaded. Correct. Which then allowed a little more flexibility to do those things to be able to build some of the programs that would actually bring dollars in itself. So at this point, let me check in with Angie on have we had, now that we've kind of went through both of the documents with this and had a bit of a discussion, do we have...

1:56:42 Any public comment? And I know last week or last meeting we received a public comment specifically about our town contract. Angie, do we have any of those? Yes, we do have another comment from Sandy Hogan. Sandy says, will the town provide a list of current benches slash donors?

1:57:06 Purchase the benches. This type of program involves extensive record keeping due to the large numbers of donors to keep track of. I think I may recall that there are a number of donors for existing benches out there that the town may have lost track of. Will Kim have to research this in addition to managing the new slash revived program? She is only one person and having a multitude of duties without an assistant to delegate to makes her job much more difficult.

1:57:35 Also, on another note, does the compensation also cover the required insurance, including vehicle, or is that a separate item covered by the town similar to the office? Has this been calculated in the negotiations? Thank you, Sandy Hogan. And that's our only comment? At this time, yes. Thank you so much.

1:58:16 Payroll tax, insurance, your full package, though I don't believe it has auto or mileage baked into those numbers. Is that correct? Right. I think our current billable rate is set, but it's something I think we need to revisit starting this new fiscal year. And...

1:58:44 So as we went through this, it sounded like, you know, we had a number of different, you know, small tweaks, but no big, you know, deletions or edits. Most of it was all pretty small. Colin, were you kind of keeping up on those on the way? I've got some of them, but I'm not sure I have enough to

1:59:15 List them all in one go. Yeah, you know, I saw kind of Dan taking some notes on more of just kind of the language updates, which I think we were all kind of a consensus around. The notes that I took down to circle back on and I think we should first discuss would be how the board feels about a one-year agreement with two single-year options on top of that and just kind of hash that out.

1:59:40 And then I think, you know, most of the discussion is circling around, you know, Kim has kind of politely articulated that, you know, she feels like it's a lot of work for one person. So to me, I think it's either we need to think about kind of reducing the scope of the work or expanding the compensation or expanding the available resources to implement the work.

2:00:07 I think that that would be the majority of our conversation in terms of the negotiation. So let's start with the talk on the length of the contract, the one year with extensions. We had a little bit of a conversation about it earlier, but I want to see if we can get some consensus here and then move on to the

2:00:36 scope slash compensation discussion. As stated earlier, I'm very comfortable with the one year as articulated in this contract and the opportunity at this time next year to kind of see where we're at and then kind of take it from there. And I'm okay with maybe the little

2:01:06 Uncertainty that that gives a break. We have a lot of strategic items to cover in the next year to really have a clear focus on where we want to go and then a longer term contract may be more appealing this time next year. I'll support that as well. I'm comfortable moving forward with one year agreement.

2:01:34 An option to extend on a year-by-year basis. I was the one that brought it up and listening to the entirety of the conversation and the scope of work, I think it's actually appropriate to do a one-year contract now that I've heard what we're going to look at. It gives us the opportunity to review Kim's scope of work and see where we're at and then what's billable, what maybe needs to be modified in the future. So it wasn't a deal breaker to have a one-year contract in the first place and it certainly isn't now. So I'd be supportive of a one-year contract.

2:02:05 Thank you, Tamara. Eric, your thoughts on the matter? Yeah, I'm very comfortable with the one year based on the conversation. All right, great. Thank you. Heather? I'll do the one year, but I'm a little apprehensive just because we have everything that's happened for the last year for the record. I don't have 100% trust on where this contract's going to go in one year from now, but I'll have to put my eggs in and see what happens. All right. Thank you for your candidacy. And Bill, I believe you...

2:02:37 Yeah, I am more than comfortable with the one year. I think it gives an opportunity if we hit it out of the park as MLR to ask for a much larger or modified contract with us being able to show what we can and can't do. I think it's opportunity. Okay, excellent. Thank you, Bill. And so, you know, it sounds like we are all in agreement there.

2:03:05 Yeah, I think that just leaves it exactly as it was, you know, drafted here in the document. And so then going on to, you know, scope and compensation. And as I forgot who, maybe it was Colin who just outlined it, it's either reduce the scope and start, you know, taking out a couple of the line items there or, you know.

2:03:33 Right-size that with compensation. Thoughts from the board on either side of that equation? You know, and to be fair, I really feel like that conversation has been and needs to be driven by Kim. I mean, I don't think it's fair for board members that really don't have a sense of, you know, her day-in, day-out workload and responsibilities to be micromanaging that aspect. I mean, I'm really...

2:04:02 Coming to that conclusion based on my conversations with Kim, I mean, there's really, it's a difficult board member to be in to just look at those hours and say, well, it's lighter, it's heavy. And so I'm really taking that from your guidance. I think Dan and Kim have done a lot of work to kind of drill down to hours and billable rate and those type of things that we can look at. And that's where my comments are coming from.

2:04:30 And if I may, I mean, if you need that, I mean, take a look at this. Yeah, we're, you know, negotiating a contract, but there are things in here that the town actually, you know, we want to, if we're putting this out in general and say, here are the key things that we want to be done. You know, if you don't want to do those, then we'll go find somebody else to do them type of an issue or look at that. So I could walk back through this pretty quickly and just go, okay, from a priority standpoint.

2:04:59 Kind of putting a different hat on here for a moment. Truly going from a very solid town perspective, MLR, I could walk through here and say, yes, on the first, let me just do a real quick on this and don't take this as any final, but kind of discussions here. You could talk about the stewardship implementation after a rec. You talk about weekly coordination meetings. I would put that down. Coordination meetings as requested by the trail manager.

2:05:28 To be at a meeting every week, I don't know if that's, I think it's beneficial, but if I'm looking at that, if I'm paying people to sit at meetings, do they need to be there? I don't know that either, but I would go to Joel and say, if you don't need them, don't have them there, free the time up for them to work on other things. The item number three there with the Eastern Sierra Sustainable Rec Coordinator, I would just take that out. You know, I would have that relation, MLR should keep that relationship for other work and also then.

2:05:59 If we need that, then I rely on Joel to have that conversation with Matt. If we deal with the item four, we talk about that enhanced trailhead facilities, I would just take that item A out of there. Being, I think that was something, I thought I pulled that from some of Kim's work, there's other elements there, but really the key element for us there is that working with the current donor program that we have.

2:06:26 in place to some degree. That's the real value that the town needs support in. If we wish to further develop that program, then throw that on as an additional work element to do that. And then C was just highlighting that if there's things beyond the town, so we don't actually have to have that in the green language. That would fall out. If I look at the Trailhead newsletter, as I mentioned,

2:06:52 Take the comment newsletter off of there completely and just we want regular communications to the public. However you choose to do that now, in this case, we're saying whether that's a full-blown newsletter or whether that's an email blast, you know, if that takes pressure and time off. Now, again, I think it's been a good tool, but I don't necessarily need to pay for that in that sense, if you will, if I'm just looking through ways of narrowing the scope down.

2:07:20 As far as the website collateral, I would just cut that out. They maintain the current projects that you're working on only. If we want new ones, either we pay for those or we do them or we go to MLTPA and ask them to do that work. I think the advisory committee work is a real key element. It represents a good chunk of the time and probably is...

2:07:44 One of the most key elements for us, because that is a delegated town of 42 MLR, so that one stays in there as a real key element on our side to make that happen. We've modified the updating process with council. The grant support is something that we are definitely looking for to make it part of the agreement for this one. It's just the one grant. If there's anything else out there, we'd have to pay for that. I would give up some of the other support work in order to...

2:08:13 To have the nonprofit. Again, I do think MLR is the right nonprofit to go do this. So that would be a high one if I'm negotiating for what projects we want to pay for. That would be a key one. And then obviously the other service stuff, we can deal with that accordingly. I don't mind having current billable rate, whatever that rate structure is. Ideally, we would set that. We do this with other agencies. We would actually set that at the beginning of the year so we know what it is.

2:08:40 Or we set a base rate and a lot to go up by CPI. Two different ways to handle that. So if I'm going to put my hat on and say, if I want to keep the dollar amount where it's at, here's how I would reduce the services we're paying for down accordingly in order to get that to align up with what we believe. And again, it's going to be a little bit on Kim there, what she believes she can deliver then within that scope of hours and still have some time left.

2:09:07 Other funding source, but time left to continue to expand out in some other areas. And the last piece I need to touch on with this, and again, this is still a little bit fluid, but if we end up going forward, working with town council on this, you're aware of a rec officer level position, another position in here, that type of programming coming in, one could either, you could offload some of this work and or could really turn around and go, hey, we need to redo this.

2:09:35 We have a real value here. We want to be able to do and here's other funding mechanisms. I think that's kind of a one-year picture too, thinking about it. What does that begin to look like from the town? If we staff up and work through the outdoor, Office of Outdoor Recreation, how does MLR become that nonprofit support arm for that type of work, which may change a lot of us, frankly, as we look to the future of that. I think that'll take time to develop and obviously move that forward as well.

2:10:04 in those areas. So from a pure standpoint of putting a contract out, we haven't really done that this way, so that's fine. But if we wanted to start to trim back and say, here are the top priorities of town, I can easily call those out and say, if you want to do the other stuff, okay, that's great, but here's the things that we really need to have done. Okay. I'm getting confused here, kids. I'm looking at the piece Kim sent us.

2:10:33 And it looks like the estimated hours for the contract are 1,726. So Kim, is that your estimate of how many hours it would take to fulfill this? Yeah, Bill. So that's what I'm saying. This is the worksheet I created. Dan and I went back and forth, worked with the committees. And I put hours to all of these deliverables. The only thing that we're far off on is I did not allocate any hours for grant services.

2:11:04 And the bench program. And so if you, and I don't know if I'm pulling this number out, but I thought, you know, somewhere around 250 hours to work on the Prop 68 grant was estimated. And so then, you know, then we're almost up near 2000 hours. And so, like I said, I don't think that the scope of work is far off. It's just a couple things.

2:11:30 Mainly the grant and a little more definition on the bench program. Right. And if we need to, as I could say, I would cut out initially, I would recommend we cut other things out versus those or we take those. And I guess here will be the struggle. We can pay more to have those done, but Kim doesn't have any more hours. So either we're not doing something already or we're paying to have additional work done that is, I'm just making the assumption we're still working off of.

2:12:01 2,000 hours or less. So if there's too much work here, then we need to go back. What do we take off? And those would be things, I think, from a town perspective, we would take the first cut at saying, great, then don't do these things from a value standpoint. And so you can remove two hours a week from my sheet bill for the Eastern Sierra Rec coordinator. I would hesitate taking away any web pages.

2:12:33 Because I feel like that has been asked of MLR over and over again. And we're doing it now. Being that single source of communication for these projects. But if that's something that isn't a high priority, then that's fine. I just think it should be made clear. Yeah. I guess I'm saying, if I have to choose between that and going after a $3 million grant, I'd probably give up the website. Just about. Oh, and I'm thinking that for two things. I think they have a certain amount of time there.

2:13:03 And so even if we paid you extra for the grant work, it doesn't free any time up unless you hire somebody else to go do this work or something. You know what I'm saying that way? Well, there are a couple of services, like you mentioned, the web services that could be outside contracted. So if we just monitor, so if we were able to increase, maybe make one of these programs, either the grant program or

2:13:34 The bench program billable that allows us some flexibility to pay a contractor to pick up some of the other work. Does that make sense? So maybe that's a compromise is to make one of those programs a billable service. We take that income as a billable service and we utilize it. Right. Yeah. Yeah. We could do something like that. We take a look at that and say, could we do that as well in a lower different cost structure? Right.

2:14:03 We'd have to have the same analysis insight. So, you know, I'd go to Stu and say, who could we reach out to to do that work on behalf of the bench program? Kim, can you clarify for us on the spread you sent through right before the meeting? You know, the bill was just looking at, because this is really what I'm hinting at too. You have 1726 for staff hours allocated. Does that include the volunteer hours that you're putting in, or does that not include volunteer hours?

2:14:33 The volunteer hours are you guys. And the lion's share allocations committee. Yeah, the 1726 is just staff hours. You know, and based on conversations tonight, I would probably cut Trailhead newsletter hours in half if we want to keep it more regional. You know, because...

2:14:58 We'll be spending some Measure R dollars on that. Sounds like council updates don't need to be as intense. So, you know, there's some tweaks in those hours for sure. Yeah. Kim, is that the old one that you'd worked on? I don't have it right in front of me. Yeah, it's one of the earlier ones they pass back and forth. Yeah. Okay. So what I'm hearing from Kim is that this is probably very doable as it is.

2:15:31 You know, I view, as a council member, everything we do as being pretty fluid. I know a contract can be litigated and everything else, but if Kim finds partway through the year that the hours are going way beyond what she expected or way less than she expected, then that can be dealt with by Dan and then on down to council. So I really have no trepidation.

2:15:58 about what's in front of us. I think it works really well, and if we find it doesn't, then we change it, you know, through the year. It's easy to do. I just wanted to comment here. I just wanted to comment. I think we're all in the same place on this, is that the scope of work here at that price is way out of whack, and I don't disagree with the scope of work. Dan, I think it's great. I look forward to the opportunity to do work for the town.

2:16:28 I think these things need to be done, but let's, I'm just going to say it how it is because we're two hours in and I'm getting tired and want to get this moving. It's going to cost three to five times that amount to get this stuff done. And we are also talking about a quality of work. You know, they need to get this done in-house. It costs, with benefits, a town employee way more money than this. So here's what I'm proposing.

2:16:59 Is I think the town should come back to us with a realistic number of what they're willing to pay for us to contract to do this work. It needs to get done. Anyone they contract it out to is going to charge more. So let's just put it at that. And I'm really looking forward to doing this work for the town, but to be compensated fairly. And I will say this, it is invaluable the work that our allocations committee has done. This is high level work with

2:17:28 Tons of hours that are not on here that I don't think you're going to get having somebody else do it. So that's my comments. I'd like to see what the rest of the board says, and I'm willing to make a motion, you know, once I see that there's some discussion to support it. So, Eric, let me get this straight. You think that the scope of work, that Kim is off by three to five times, 1,726 hours to get this work done? No. I think the cost to the town,

2:18:00 to shop this out and get people to do it, if you piece this all out, counting labor, counting benefits, counting everything else, is that much off? Yes. That's what I'm saying. Other comments from the board? Heather, your take on things? I haven't heard from you in a bit. I appreciate Eric's POV, I know where he's coming from, you think about what it would cost somebody who was a town employee to do these same jobs because of...

2:18:36 Benefits and all the other stuff that comes along with great office town jobs. But with Kim, I think we're asking a lot of her. I don't quite understand the $20,000 on a quarter. I think that the compensation that we're offering her needs to be thought of giving her a raise at what percentage I think it needs to be considered and then come back to a reevaluation. I understand that.

2:19:05 The pot of money is not bottomless and we need to be held accountable and we have to meet in the middle. I know that it's been a rough road the last year. So I think that if Kim is comfortable with the scope of work, I think that she's done a very good job of not knowing if she's got a job tomorrow, holding it together and has been very thorough with everything that she's done. I think we should consider a raise and then I would like an understanding of

2:19:33 Why we're doing quarterly $20,000 increments instead of annually if we're going to do a year contract? Yeah, I'll address the quarterly payment. I think before we were doing it monthly, we were just doing monthly payments as it went through. So again, it's cash flow on this side and that side for how it goes through. So the idea here was it's still an upfront starting with July. It was just a simpler process because ideally we would still have an invoice that would come in and say, yeah, hey, here's the workflow.

2:20:03 of dollars and not having that done on a monthly basis. We do have to be able to track that request for payment. And so historically, some of the other agencies have done that on a monthly basis and we've tried to move those to different, a couple other places like that where we do a quarterly based on a month timeframe. And also if something blows up, Kim leaves and nothing's getting done, then we're not paying out another quarter, if you will, if something like that was to happen.

2:20:31 Limited now. We wouldn't do it, we wouldn't write a check in July for 80 grand, for example. So is that quarterly, is that quarterly money put in prior or after? So it's the beginning of the quarter, so it's July. Got it. And did that on purpose, because we know there's cash flow for MLR, too, but, you know, so July, August, September is paid, so it's in the front end of each quarter. That was just done manually to simplify what we've done historically versus having a monthly payment.

2:20:59 My comment to that is it shows a lack of faith in our organization. We either have a deal or we don't. I mean, I see an escape clause for you guys, but nothing for us, from what I'm hearing on that. It's not like we're going to go off and spend the money, being that it's public funds, on somebody that's not there to not do a job. But I don't understand if there's a reason beyond that. I say we don't do contracts, any of them that way, and keeping us still as a contractual relationship, we wouldn't pay that amount up front, period.

2:21:29 And that's consistent with other things that you have with other contracted entities. Right. We do quarterly, we do monthly. What would be a more traditional contract would be, you are going to send us actually, I'll say, like the MLTPA contract, they actually send us invoices every month. We go through them and then we actually pay off those. And there is no upfront money. There is no guaranteed money. It's based on that invoice and review of it.

2:21:56 And accepting the invoice, which we can challenge back, but we don't think it's correct. Most of you are business people. How many of you pay your contractors prior to work done? Paying a contractor prior to the work being performed on a quarterly basis. I don't see how that is extraordinary in any way, shape, or form, or saying it's a distrust. You all hire contractors on a regular basis, I'm assuming, and have been through that process.

2:22:24 Do you really pay them before they commit to doing, before they do the work? No, and I'm just trying to understand that the strategy, the reasoning behind it. Is it something that's customary? It's understanding the process. We do that, for example, agreement we have with the chamber is based on quarterly process. MLH, we're having that discussion. We're looking at going through a quarterly payment for them versus monthly. MLT is also quarterly already based on

2:22:53 their agreement. So it's not unique at all even with the NGOs and stuff. The one different, I think we still do it monthly with ESTA. Theirs is based on actual hours of service ran and then billed accordingly. And I'll just chime in here. It's one less trip to the bank also. Yeah. Yeah. Thank you. I will say I think the town's good for it and we're going to do the work so I'm not worried about the quarterly payment. What I am worried about is that we have a spreadsheet that's showing

2:23:22 The hours, Kim was very detailed about what she plans on with the deliverables, with the total cost of close to $99,000. I realize that includes volunteer hours, that's our time as well, but the cost that it is to do this work, for MLR to do this work, is $99,000, which doesn't include the grants, the one-time grant that you're talking about, and doesn't include the administration.

2:23:51 of the bench program at $99,000, yet you're offering us a contract of $80,000 before those programs. So from a business standpoint, you're not paying for your scope of work. And I would say the volunteer hours, we would not pay for those to any organization, Perry. So that's kind of an off the table from a public payment standpoint. I wouldn't expect to go to...

2:24:18 Anybody else who serves on a nonprofit with the board and say, hey, we'll pay you next $100,000 or $10,000 for your board members who are volunteers just to put more money into your bank account, if you will. Understood. So even at that rate, we have, even at that, we have an 84, nearly $84,000 scope of work before the two new programs. Yeah, I don't think anybody's suggesting that volunteer hours should be compensated.

2:24:47 What people are suggesting is that the work that the town is receiving from their contractor includes a lot of hours for contractors that if you were to move that service to another contractor, you would have to pay for. And so that's what people are articulating is that there's a lot of free labor and free hours going into the implementation of these services. And the number that's been provided on the spreadsheet is prior to the two new programs.

2:25:17 Correct. And we can cut out a lot of those hours in a heartbeat if we need to. Again, I'm going back to these are the services we want to bid out. If I need to reduce services down to make that work, I don't mind doing that. And take another stuff off of here and say, again, I'm looking at it as a, if you went out and said, I want to hire somebody to come work for me, and they came to you and said, well, that's great, but I'm not going to do that work, so I'm going to do this work over here. You'd say, no, I hired you to do X. So we're in that same,

2:25:46 Again, it's a negotiation here. It's different than a true build-out project, so don't get me wrong there. But it does have that relationship. I was looking at initially, you know, if you did the $80,000, what was $80,000, you know, $50 an hour type thing, that's $1,600 of work. We can trim this down to fit that, and that still frees up a little bit of time to do other things. And again, I trust Kim. I think our numbers are probably pretty close to accurate.

2:26:15 Some of that stuff we can print back pretty easily and say we don't need that level of service in this particular. And I don't want to undermine any work that's been done because I know you guys have done a lot of work to this point. A lot. Can I ask a fair question? What kind of raise annually do you all do within the town for your salaried employees? It all depends on negotiation and funding capability.

2:26:44 Last year was zero with COVID. Right. And the current standpoint is at 2.5% salary adjustment. Okay. I think it's something that in our negotiations, if we could consider something comparable, because if you think that Kim at this point has delivered what you've expected MLR to do, and I think she's done a very good job personally, I think that's something that we might want to consider. And then I'd like to be able to say in six months from now,

2:27:13 You know, where do we feel things are at? And maybe it's the negotiation guys that we have to be a little bit higher with next year with the understanding of having a year contract. Again, I don't want to undermine a lot of the work that's already been done because I know the negotiation team has gone through a lot already. But to be fair, this is really the first time anybody including, you know, the negotiations committee is having a discussion on brass tax and numbers.

2:27:42 This is not something that's been presented to us until... Ah, okay. Thank you for the explanation. Yeah, no, I mean, don't get me wrong. I think the conversation, the discussion has been really helpful. Okay, good, good, good. I just didn't want to undermine any work calling that you guys had already done, but if you hadn't talked about the nitty-gritty, then now's the time. Yeah, and I think that's what we're here to do. I mean, this is where the road and, you know, I think...

2:28:06 You know, I'm a numbers person, so I'm trying to put some numbers behind this stuff, which is a little bit difficult to do because they seem to be a moving target. You know, let's say, you know, we're working off of 1900-ish hours in a calendar year would be a work output. You know, by Kim's estimations, and, you know, we can make some shaves to that, right? But, you know, 1726 is her estimate for her work hours to implement this program, and that...

2:28:35 As Tamara said, doesn't include volunteer hours, doesn't include some of the additions. You know, that's 90% of her work on an 1800 work hour year would be allocated to this work program. If, you know, the estimate that you threw out, Dan, was more like 1400 hours, which is kind of where you landed. So realistically, we're probably somewhere in that ballpark between 1400 and 1700.

2:29:02 But that would still be 73% of an annual output. So what I'm looking at is for $80,000, we're looking at allocating somewhere between 75% and 90% of Kim's time. It doesn't really leave her much time to go out and work on some of these other programs that we want to implement and get off the ground.

2:29:28 75 to 90 percent of our time is going to be allocated to the town's scope of services. And they're getting all of that for $80,000, which, you know, again, to kind of backdate to the prior contract, you know, my recollection of that is it was more in that high 200s range. If it was the 192 plus the $75,000 a year that was allocated up front from the general fund.

2:29:55 That's more like $270,000 a year, which at a 73% rate would be 195 grand. So whether the numbers are exactly on, I think we're all kind of drilling down to the spot that we feel like there's kind of a large disparity between the hours required to implement this program and the compensation that's being offered.

2:30:23 That leaves us with basically two options. I think most of the board, and it sounds like Kim, is up for the additional workload. What we're trying to articulate is we don't necessarily think that maybe $80,000 is fair and just compensation for the workload that's being asked to be done. So either we increase the compensation or we have to reduce the work program.

2:30:48 You know, I'm kind of hearing from you that maybe that $80,000, you know, number is a hard line that the town is towing, and we might need to be able to hear that, in which case we need to think about reducing some of the scope of the work. What I'm more hearing from the board and from Kim is that we would like to take on these additional things, but it feels like there might need to be additional compensation for that. So I feel like that's kind of the place we're arriving at here.

2:31:14 Yeah, it doesn't sound like Kim's afraid of work, and I think she's beyond capable. We just need to make sure we compensate her for it. Yeah, no, she hasn't been afraid of work. And, you know, I don't want 90% of Kim's time to necessarily be allocated to this project because we've got other initiatives that we need to work on as we move towards some semblance of autonomy and regional focus and fundraising capability. I mean, if 70-plus percent of Kim's time is focused on this work program,

2:31:42 When is there going to be time with her as a one-person staff to go out and raise funds? So, you know, I think it's got to be one or the other. And if compensation is increased, then maybe that allows us the ability to go out and hire somebody else that can help Kim and take some of those hours off of her plate. Yeah, yeah. And Colin, I agree with that. I was going to earlier on this would be...

2:32:09 It's back, and I'm going to go back to the color of the money. So we could provide $120,000 of support. That can still only be spent on town programs because it's town money. Sure. So, and I don't want to just, you know, I understand contracting back out with it. Yes, I could bring extra hope, time in. But if we're funding, and I'm going to make up numbers here, so please don't take these. We're going to fund 100% of Kim's.

2:32:36 Salary, sorry, Kim, I don't remember the exact dollar amount, $85,000. Great. That means ideally we're buying 100% of Kim. Sure. But she doesn't have excess time in one sense. Again, that's how, again, how do you bring the other dollar side in and do some of that already there? And I understand that's a little bit of a chicken and egg thing. Yeah. But I don't want to come in and say, I will provide all this funding so you can go do other work that isn't, but that we shouldn't be paying for.

2:33:04 Regardless of the dollar amount of time, whether it's $100 or $200,000, that was the whole goal behind the original extra funding with Matt was, here's your fundraising dollars, which technically Measure R and you cannot pay for it. Right. So we want you to go raise money, but I can't pay you out of the current funding structure to go do that. Yeah. I can free a lot of your time up, but I can't pay you for that free that time. Yeah, and I think that's totally a fair statement and something that...

2:33:34 We all need to be, you know, cognizant of. I'm more saying if it's going to take, you know, 120,000 views that, you know, the number that you want to implement this work program, maybe that, you know, it's bringing on another junior level employee to take some of Kim's time and still implement the work program. And, you know, we're saying that there needs to be a higher dollar amount to implement this work program.

2:34:00 Then it maybe frees up more of Kim's time to go out and do some of these other initiatives. Yeah, as long as the 120 isn't paying for her other work that she's out doing. Right, sure. Absolutely. It's staying within the scope of what you're saying. This is like a degree on scope, right? We're saying this is like one and a half people's worth of work. Right, right. So let's say, Heather, let's say it's one and a half people's worth of work and we pay for that. But if I don't get that full one and a half people, then I'm subsidizing work that I'm not legally able to pay for.

2:34:29 This is where we have the accountability that we're discussing working in our negotiations and deliverables right now, right? Right, correct. So I'm saying like for Kim, I agree the scope of work is close to a full-time position, right? Which means, no, she doesn't have a lot of free time to go work on other things because we have bought that many hours of service. But it doesn't necessarily have to be buying Kim's hours of service. Well, but I'm buying somebody else's hours then. We can do that, but if I'm paying them.

2:34:58 If I'm paying a premium to get those hours, then I'm still subsidizing other work that, you know, I could argue. I'm saying more like, let's say there's $120,000 worth of work to get done, but we want to do $160,000 worth of work. We can get that done with one and a half people, but we can spend our other time doing this. Does that make sense? It's just a different way of looking at the pie. In a sense, but if we're fully covering those costs, then no. I guess I would try and, you know,

2:35:27 reiterate it in a different way is that, you know, buying this level of service for $80,000 is what people are saying is maybe not reasonable. Yeah, no, no, and I hear that. So that's a fair point. So if $80,000 is what the town's willing to pay and MLR's billable rate is $49 an hour, then we should cut the work program we're giving you.

2:35:53 Down to 1,633 hours. And I think that's probably doable. With some of the things that Kim said, that's probably doable. Then we're paying the full billable rate for the amount of hours of work of Kim's time we're expecting. That frees up time, but then it's got to come from all the funding to go do the other work and stuff. Yeah, it covers that rate. I wasn't on the negotiating committee, but where did we come up with this $48 an hour billable rate? I don't remember voting on that.

2:36:25 And I'd be curious to know, I think that rate represents our cost on a good day. I'd like to know where that money came from. And if it is our cost, why are we not putting any margin in that? Yeah, because you're a nonprofit. So we're not paying you a profit to go do this work for one. So I think that came out of the work that we both did looking at total hours and dollar amounts and you start to do the math on it.

2:36:54 It came out a little below 40. Yeah, Eric, it's an estimated billable rate that we put together to start this conversation. And as I mentioned earlier, I think that it's something that needs to be revisited for this coming fiscal year and calculated by our accountant. That being said, I don't think we're very far off on hours here. I think what needs to be looked at is the actual billable rate. Yeah.

2:37:23 And then how many hours can the town cover using that valuable rate? Yeah, you know, I want to be clear, like, I'm trying to drive us to getting into a place where everybody feels good about this contract, but I just think there's trepidation on the board for the compensation being offered versus the hours required to do the work. So, you know, Kim, you know, Dan, you guys have done a lot of work to kind of sponge this stuff, but it's like...

2:37:51 As Kim said, I don't think we're super far off on these things, but maybe we just need to rein some things in or increase some compensation so that everybody feels a little bit more comfortable with where we're landing. Bill, I got the impression from you, and as town council person and mayor, as you're going into your guys' budget cycle,

2:38:28 you know, and probably well into that already, is you made it sound like the 80,000 is a pretty hard and fast number, or, you know? I can, within the budget structure we have, there's a little bit of flexibility in there in terms of the Measure R budget overall. It's not a lot, but there is some, again, we're facing out, I think we're going to have a pretty solid year of activity economically, so.

2:38:58 It does seem like the crux here is that where what I'm hearing from the board is the value of the billable hours. It seems to be out of whack and it's all driven down to like Eric indicated that $48 is what's getting us to that point and maybe that's where, you know.

2:39:25 For whatever reason, we're kind of at a bit of an impact here. Yeah, well, I mean, oh, sorry, Craig. I was just going to suggest, I mean, we can walk through and trim back some of the hours. And again, I'm looking at this from, I'm putting out a request that I need to have done. If I can't get done, then I need to take that piece off and go give it to somebody else and see what they can do it for, obviously, and or not, or not have it done. A couple of things there we could just not worry about, but just.

2:39:56 Basic math, if you go back and say, if you trim this to 1,600 hours, and I just bumped it to $55 an hour, would that be $88,000 for that, keeping it kind of divisible by four for a payment thing, but that would be something that we could achieve within the current framework. We've trimmed back some of the workload or the hours there and look at other options for a couple of the pieces there, or not have some things done. And again, I don't think...

2:40:24 A little bit of reduction to some of the work is going to blow up the value that MLR is bringing to the Senate. Obviously, I've been in support of MLR. We probably wouldn't still be here. However, the first thing I would ask my town manager, if we're going to come in with a $120,000 contract for MLR, is what would it cost me to put a town employee in place at whatever pay rate would be necessary to perform these 1,600 hours worth of work?

2:40:54 Because as someone who has to watch after the tax dollars, what is the best way for the community, I can spend their dollars to get the job done. If I can get it done for less in-house, which I'm having a problem with most of our nonprofits because we could do it less in-house, then that's where I would ask for it to be moved. I can't even understand where that would even come from.

2:41:22 I mean, I threw 120 out there just as a number. So, I know, I agree, I'd ask the same question, okay, how does it, how the work get done? But just in looking at what we had here, I'd come back and go, I know there's some things we can tweak on hours and stuff, I don't mind doing some of that, but I would come back on a, I'll just say, it's a kind of a group negotiation back and forth. So, if I came back into that, I'd come back and go, okay, let's look at 1,600 hours worth of work.

2:41:51 And then it's a matter of managing what our expectations is on time to live within those hours contracted. That's on us for that. I think as Kim said, we're fairly close as far as if we trim back the scope of work, add in the two new programs, increase the billable rate, we're gonna come up with

2:42:22 And hit that number of hours that works for her, we're going to come to a pretty close dollar amount that would be acceptable to the town. It's probably going to be a bit of an increase from the 80, but it's not going to be 120. As I was just saying, I think we could do an 88,000. I'm trying to remember the park budget out there, but that would be a viable number. So I know, I think we can all agree that it's time to rework the spreadsheet and to look at...

2:42:49 where we can trim back as far as scope of work, add in new programs, available hours, and then revisit it and see if that's going to be an acceptable amount. If given a target number from, like Dan's saying, it's got an increase, 88 is likely possible.

2:43:11 If we've got a target number to reach, we can trim back those with Kim and come up with an acceptable scope of work and an acceptable billable rate. And the grant work sounds like it's something that's very important also. And how would that benefit MLR? And Bill, I agree with what you're saying. I'd love to see the data on that. If you think the town employees could get that done at a cheaper rate.

2:43:37 Don't forget their PERS and their benefits and every last cent that goes into that calculation. And let's also not forget all of our, you know, the quality of work and volunteer hours. You're talking about short staff with a lot of extra hours. If you guys could do it cheaper, do it. I mean, I really think that that's not the case. I also think Dan's pointed out.

2:44:00 That there's a couple of pieces of scope of work here that require a nonprofit. Now you go to a different nonprofit, but we are the appropriate one for you to utilize. So they agree as well. Yeah. And on the ground, on to Heather's question, there's two pieces of value to MLR on that. One is going through that because there's going to be additional Prop 68 type funding coming out there that isn't just town related. It's going to be.

2:44:25 If you look at the state budget and the amount of climate change type stuff coming out, looking at regional stuff, I think there's an opportunity to grow that skill to be able to know what people are looking for, to be able to do those types of projects and put in that grant work. The other side of that was ideally, again, if we're successful in the grant, that admin, ongoing admin services, any type of cost related, that all gets built back in. So that does bring back funding.

2:44:55 Non-restricted, if you will, back into Mammoth Lakes Recreation that brings up dollars that way in terms of, for example, if you did that and you had $10,000 or $15,000 a year of admin time that you're paying for, whatever that, I don't know what the number would look like, but all of a sudden those are dollars rolling back in that go to the benefit of the organization.

2:45:17 That was when I wanted to hear about it. Like, is it a long-term thing, a one-time thing? And if it's something that the scope of work needs to be underneath our organization and it's going to benefit in it in the long term, then I think that it's definitely something that needs to be added into the scope of work and then reworked from the other items. I feel like we're very close and I just don't want to lose sight of that. I mean, I think a little bit of massaging around the edges. We're just trying to be protective of our one employee and make sure that, you know, we're, you know, not overburdening her and that we're, you know,

2:45:46 She's being justly compensated for the work she's being asked to do. Indeed. Colin just took the words out of my mouth. Is that the other part of this is if we need to take care of our employee and make sure we all get the benefit of the good work she has done. And I think getting Kim and Dan together to

2:46:16 Aim for scope of work that's 1,600 hours and increase that billable rate to 55. Seems like that gets us maybe not where we'd all like to be, but someplace where we can probably all live with for this first year. And based off of our success this next year, we'll see where it goes. And with that same idea that

2:46:46 You know, we need to have a billable rate that allows us to take care of the quality employee we have while still providing this service to the town at a better rate than what they could do at in-house. I think that's the sweet spot where I think we all want. You know, none of us as citizens of Mammoth want us to overpay for work done, but we don't want to lose our good people either.

2:47:17 And she is one person. And Kim, I know that you're an awesome person, but we all have to realize, like, God forbid, what if something happens to your situation? Personal also, you know, we have to make sure that we're protecting you. Yeah. So, Craig, what are our next steps? Sounds like, you know, that Dan and Kim working on how do we get that 1,600 hours as a top end?

2:47:50 And what do we have to do in the scope of work? And we talked about a lot of those items, priorities for the town and what's eaten up Kim's time so that we can find that balance and then bring that back to the board. I guess timeline is what I'm less clear on because Bill, when...

2:48:18 When does this go before the board? It was like your June, first meeting in June, right? Yeah, let me walk through the timeline real quick because it's moved around a little bit. Originally, we were looking at trying to come in on June 2nd with some stuff, knowing that we were meeting tonight. The assumption was we wouldn't be ready, which sounds like that's true. June 16th is where we'll have our final budget hearings and stuff.

2:48:45 There's some, we can make some adjustments within the Measure R budget that would accommodate this. I would like to bring the contract forward though, but in conjunction with the whole board, at least the majority of the MLR board being able to have a joint meeting with the town council to talk about it with the whole group versus just taking a contract in with Kim and I and Bill, if you will, to kind of carry the water on it. I think having that broader discussion with the council, so.

2:49:14 They're all bought into it. I mean, once we agree to it, our job is, mine in particular, is to take that forward and say this represents a solid proposal for the town to get these services done that we feel we need. So I don't mind doing that a bit. I think it's extremely beneficial. I think other people besides, you know, John, know what all is happening. Exactly. So yeah, I'm saying so if I would look at this being a

2:49:42 If we could do it, again, it's going to be up to your whole calendar. I'd like to do it in July, because we'd make it effective still July 1, so that's our problem that way. That's the 7th through the 21st. Ideally, we'd be doing maybe an hour discussion with the board and the council just over almost the stuff we were talking about, maybe not quite as granular, but expectations, working together, et cetera, what does that look like moving forward? And then being able to have the contract as a action item.

2:50:11 Council at that point, and the MLR Board. Ultimately, the board has to approve it as well. And generally, we'd ask you to do it first, then us. But having that joint meeting and dialogue, I think, would be very beneficial for the board and the council. And for you to hear the other council members, too, if they have other concerns or comments, you all need to hear that as well. I think that would be really super helpful, Dan. And if I heard you correctly there,

2:50:37 Reversing the typical order of us approving and then sending it to the town council, reversing that in this timeline, I don't see as problematic, right? Yeah, if we need to, we could do that or we could act, it'd be a little funky on agenda-wise, but you could actually structure it for MLR to approve it the same day if we had to, but we can work. I don't think that's as problematic. I mean, if we're doing a joint meeting and...

2:51:06 The council hears, hey, we want to approve this contract in a majority of mail, our board will go, great, we're not going to sign it, well, then we're kind of done, so. Yeah, exactly. And I think just given the time now that we're in, looking at one of those two dates in July. Or the dates in July what? The Wednesday, first and third Wednesday, so the 7th and the 21st would be the two dates that we have regular scheduled council meetings to plug into. And again, if we had it.

2:51:35 Draft deal done, you guys could actually meet the week before and say, yeah, in concept, yeah, we approve this or, you know, again, obviously subject to the, accepted by the council or something. All right. And the next MLR regularly scheduled meeting is July 6th, so we can certainly push it one day, meet on the 7th. Yeah, or if you met on the 6th, we'd meet on the 7th with the council, except for you all, you could actually have it approved that night.

2:52:03 Or we could start our meeting a half hour early or something. Yeah. Getting everybody together is the... Yeah. Yeah, you could do something that way too if that works or just do it after the fact. Okay. I think at that point, you know, if something else blows up, it's not going to matter on meeting dates. Since we're... Since this is us, is there...

2:52:33 The 7th or 21, is either of those dates problematic? I'm okay on both of them. They're not problematic. The 7th is better, but they're not problematic. I just want to clarify, are we talking June or July? July. July. Okay, gotcha. I'm good on both. I'm good on both. The 7th is better. Bill? I'm good on both also. Bill doesn't have any choice. I was gonna say.

2:53:08 We don't even have to ask Bill. So it sounds like the 7th is a better date for them. It does. Or works for everybody. Yep. So why don't we shoot for the 7th? Getting it done sooner, in my perspective, is a good thing. So then I don't really need to drag it out. So if we can, Kim and I can set a time to get together or zoom through some of this stuff. So we can make that work and then have it ready to go. And then we would structure probably toward the front of the meeting.

2:53:40 Maybe started early or not, it'd be a 3.30 or 4 o'clock time to do a, I'd call it joint meeting between the town and MLR, and then we'd have to contract in that for discussion point or an action item later on the council agenda for final approval. Okay. Just structurally process-wise. All right. Sounds good. All right, team. Thanks for hashing through that. That was, that was- Thank you. Yeah, thanks. It's always hard for a large group, but this was actually-

2:54:11 conversation. Yeah. No, I think it helped us all kind of, you know, get up to speed, and I really like the idea of getting the rest of the council because, you know, ultimately, you know, it does take those, take three votes, and, and Bill doesn't, you know, can't carry all the water. Yeah. Yeah, no, having everybody there be good, so. Yeah. Excellent. Awesome.

2:54:40 And so no action then. And I'm looking for my agenda page because all we have is President Albright, if it's appropriate, I do have an additional public comment. Yes, please. I'm sorry. I forgot to. That's quite all right. This one comes from Sandy Hogan.

2:55:05 She says, Angie, here's one more. I spent a year worrying about the MLH's ED's health when the TOML's contract didn't allow for an assistant. Does the board want to do the same worrying about what would happen if? This contract is a lot of work, and so don't let this happen. Sandy. Okay. I hear you, Sandy. Awesome. Thank you.

2:55:31 And Dan, you were kind of staying on top of just those small track changes in terms of the language and stuff, right? Yeah, and I would work through that. I'll ship it to Kim and she can take a look at it as that reflective discussion. And just to go back to what Sandy's saying, that's kind of the comment I was trying to make earlier without saying it out loud, but it's good to have somebody else help Kim because God forbid something happens in her life where she needs someone to pick up the slack if something happens. I just want to acknowledge that. Yes.

2:56:02 Thank you, Heather. And was our consensus on this item for Mr. Holler and Ms. Anna-Clario to meet again to adjust the numbers and rate of pay and then to afterward have a joint meeting between the town council and MLR? Thanks, Angie. So moved. Thank you. You can have a motion on that. I'll make the motion. Were we making a motion or was it just consensus? You can do it either way there. It's agendized for discussion of possible action.

2:56:33 The direction is to have Kim and I work through it as a proposal to come back to the joint bodies. I'd like to have a discussion there. I think a board member should be present in that conversation as well. I'd be happy to volunteer. Volunteered yourself, my man. I did. Great. Awesome. If you guys are okay with consensus, that's fine. Otherwise, I'm fine to make a motion on it.

2:57:10 All right, let's roll with consensus. Yep. All right, that's fine, yeah, thanks. Yep, that'll be fine. Thank you, Angie, on that. And board member reports, anybody have anything to report? Seeing none. To the team that's been putting this together, negotiations team, and Kim and Dan, I know it's a lot of work. Thank you. Yeah, yeah. Thanks, everyone.

2:57:33 Lively discussion and we'll adjourn here at... Craig, I just want to say I wanted to personally thank David and Catherine for all their time on the board while they did a lot of work and it doesn't go unappreciated. Thank you both. Yes. I second that. Amen. We still have to throw a party one of these days once we can all get together. I think we've got three weeks.

2:58:02 And then June 15th. Party Central. I know someone who can bring wine. Uh-huh. Didn't I just hear if Clocktower Cellar was going to donate the evening for us? That's my husband. He would tell you you can't come there. Why much time you're taking away from my wife? No. We're bringing you to the party also.

2:58:29 It's tough to fit 8,200 people in the clock tower. We might need to look at, you know, Shady Rest or something. We're also waiting for some town guidance on what we can do. So we're looking forward to hearing that here in a couple of weeks. Thank you. Yes. Thank you, guys. 29. All the best. Thank you all. All right. Thanks, guys. Thanks, Kim. Appreciate it.

2:58:58 Thank you.