TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2010

Town Council

· recording 3 hr 6 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Notable from this meeting

1 finding

Transcript

380 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 Last year, Horizon, so we pushed it as a commission. We really believed in it. Horizon pushed it because it's better for them. And they actually got their team on it and worked not only with the people of Bishop, but everyone else that they could. And it keeps coming back to it. Man, it happened because of the community, the council, the...

0:25 Commission, all of the people that had the will to make it happen, and there's just not any kind of that product coming out right now. The answer right now is that they go back to where they started, or they, because we had it happen more than a few times this year, they get over Mammoth and they can't land, so then they go on to San Jose Arena, whichever their next destination was, then they fly the people back to their starting area.

0:51 John, if you remember back when we had that meeting with Andy Richards up at the village, we kind of came up with a new strategy. It was pretty well agreed by everybody that, you know, they pushed Mammoth the airport for these, you know, just regional zones that were up to eight flights a day type thing, and C-2 aircraft, and

1:22 Probably that guy, Danny Richards is not retired, but he sort of promised Madison and Eastern Sierra that someday there would be need for a bigger airport somewhere in Eastern Sierra. And that's probably the time that this is going to come up again. And I think our field will...

1:44 Take pretty much what you can throw at it now. I don't think that's going to be an issue until something comes along and the economy recovers and things like that. And they'll say to me, the Eastern Sierra needs an airport that's going to fly in from Detroit and Miami. And then there will be the...

2:04 Does anybody know how the sense in the community, I mean,

2:33 I haven't heard it until recently, but it sounds like that there is a certain segment or percentage of the community, you don't expect it to be 100%, but don't support air service at the airport. Are there any reasons why? I haven't heard any. I've asked people, everybody. I haven't been close to a lot of those folks. So it's really, really small.

2:56 They haven't been in our meetings. I've heard nothing negative. And I've heard the negative, too, to the point I was going through. And we've heard how great it is. And one year-round was a big one last year. There is some misinformation out there, though, with regards to position as the alternate. So I'm not surprised that you're hearing it. I hear it occasionally, too, where somebody said, well, whether it's that. And my daughter's coming in on that flight. She probably met with Bishop.

3:24 No, she won't. And the way the airlines have alternates, she might have that position. But preferred alternates for airlines, large airlines, are usually where they already have facilities. That's preferred, that's a big A alternate for them. A small A alternate is when you're on fire, any runway looks really good. And that really is what...

3:49 As a commission, we're really...

4:19 I'd say, if you look about, you are focused in supporting staff this year to get the regional jet service approval as council has approved and moving forward and getting that EA, I think that that progress is going very good. We're also,

4:48 Continually working with community input and then with town staff and the mountain on where do we go next. You know, this year's been very, very good for us, adding more flights than any of us anticipated if you looked at our record and our plan and how fast we exceeded it. Things are going extraordinarily well with that. And so where's next? San Jose is a good challenge for us. It's a bit that we're seeing.

5:17 Fast growth, really good growth out of there. So as a commission at that we hope to continue to be able to be very involved with the town staff and the Sierra and everybody else on that. That we want to work with the town staff and the mountain staff to make sure that we are doing the right support, marketing support, promotional support, any type of support we need to do in market to do that growth.

5:45 San Jose is a great example of that, and we have been able to throw some good promotions at that, but to support that, there is a need to officially change the official declared distance of the air runway at Mammoth.

6:09 In a nutshell, if the airplane takes off, if it has an inclination of, I forget the exact thing, say 3%, and it can travel so many thousands of feet at that angle. At that angle, essentially, if you're saying you have a declared distance, it will be 1,000 feet longer than the actual runway. So even though the runway is 7,000 feet, you can have a declared distance of 8,000 feet. That's a really big deal because it's essentially like hitting 1,000 feet of runway without having to put down any pavement.

6:38 And that allows you to take off with heavier weights and maybe leak, and you can explain this better than I could, but basically it's a big deal because particularly in the summer when you have your density altitude pretty high, you know, you'll be able to have a greater low on the airplane. In a nutshell, but just if you want the technical background, once an airplane is committed to take off at a certain speed, then performance is predicated on losing an engine.

7:08 And still climbing out and crossing the threshold at the other end of the runway at 35 feet. Okay, so once the crammer's going to meet that, then it's called a balanced field. They can trick it a little bit by making the virtual end of the runway another thousand feet down, further down. So the aircraft has another thousand feet to climb to that 35 feet.

7:33 Because there's nothing in line. There's no opposite. Okay. So it's clear. It is clear. We would never ask to do anything that's not really done. It's just basically passed it. It's a virtual runway out there that you really, there's nothing you have to do to actually make a runway there. It's just that there's a clear way. And the aircraft already, after you hit a speed of V1, you're committed to fly no matter what. Because you can't stop.

8:01 And you can't stop on the paved surface. But we're talking about a virtual, normally, pass the surface. Is that been run by the pilots? Yeah. Well, you're already airborne, so all you're worried now is about climbing and not hitting it. So then that where it is on number T-7? Well, it could be probably either direction as long as there's... Are they clear? That could be on both sides. On both sides.

8:31 Is that, now you've mentioned that's something in the summer, does the summer service help get us to that point of that declaration? Well, no, I believe there are some hurdles we have to jump through with the FAA, and I think there's a cost involved, so I don't have all the details in front of me, but what that does is we will have summer service regardless, but what that will allow them to do would be to take off with a heavier weight, and as we will tell you, if they go down to the pound.

9:00 Yeah, I found that out yesterday. I was in the cause of the bill of San Jose the day yesterday as they tried to figure out where to put the bags so I could sit in the cup. Because the plan was unbelievable. You could have seen a dinner in Salt Lake on the CR, the next one down. CR, yeah. It's very weight restricted. It's unbelievable. They made us, they realized there's a luggage in wrong.

9:27 So they took it all out, all these two out in the plane, and then they brought some insights. Well, to give you an idea how closely they are, he has his little computer, and I'm sitting, looking over your shoulder, and the captain was working the problem, and he was within four pounds, four pounds, which is...

9:42 Pretty stupid when you think about the fact we're estimating pastureweights. I was going to say, did you start waiting? We have a saying in the business saying it'll be measured with micrometer and a marker with a crayon. I think this is quite critical in getting marges on, you know, not just from San Francisco.

10:11 Potentially in other markets like Las Vegas and that, you know, it's not that big of a deal in the horizon, but it's pretty critical in getting good small jet services. It's a very important point, John. When we did our, when we got approval of our EIS, we,

10:35 We had to pick a specific, to work with the FAA appropriately, we had to pick a specific plane type, and we knew we were doing the K-400, and so that study was around that, and the EIS worked in every area for what we all remember, which was about eight flights a day, no larger than around 80 passengers. The problem is, is through all of that, and we tried, but it was a sticky point with the FAA,

11:04 We only were able to get it for planes with turboprops, not jets. So the beauty of this, while we're working with United to bring in their RJ700, when done, it will include all jets that fit that same profile, you know, smaller passenger, but now it doesn't mean every single time we have to go to a jet. So now it will be all turbo.

11:33 So this is a much clearer thing than this. And it's crucial to the plan of eight flights, different destinations, because not very many airlines are very popular. Not a lot of airlines that are flying the Q400 to do this. It also opens up a relationship with United, which allows us to look at a lot of these other plans.

12:01 As well as continue to grow with programs. Interesting, I don't know if you know this, you probably do, but you should talk to the rest, but they can their idea of getting rid of the records. Yeah. So they're going to keep the records because they basically can't get rid of them. So they have cue pointers on order, they still are taking a few orders, but they postpone the rest of them to keep these.

12:23 Which is a great opportunity for us in the future because some of the airports we were interested in before, they weren't going to service with the key part either. And now, as we talk about Vegas or other areas, I think that gives them a lot more flexibility than they had before. And even meeting the flights that we have, because we had two, not one, but two, that didn't get here because there was a plane, but his mission was over the way somewhere else.

12:51 What's the reality of, not the reality of the song, where do we still need, one of the goals is to bring Kurt's car loan, is that necessary? We all, I think, including Tom Caden, we all believe that

13:18 Having flagging. And he's seen that, right? He's doing great business down there, but on the slower days, the benefit that enterprise has by being on, you know, all of the distribution systems out there. Tom, I have to say, I tried to contact him for a more current update, but the last update I have is that's moving along well. They've had, there were a lot of issues in the air.

13:46 At the time, we didn't know what was taking so long as it turns out there were a lot of issues in the corporation, that they were getting new paperwork on how they work with licensees. I haven't spoken to them in two weeks, and if it's changed, I apologize, but the last time I spoke to them, they were very good about this, and they're still working with her. And if I may, do you all know what she's speaking about when she says distribution? It was better for Tom, because he...

14:15 He helped me with mountains and everything when we had one huge storm and he did take cars to San Jose and everything. He supplied an incredible level of service. That's a lot of work for him to do that. If he has a national flag behind him, they can help do all that. In my opinion, he's doing an incredible job.

14:40 One of your other goals is to lobby the FAA for additional funding opportunities. Considering the economy nationally, is it realistic that we can find additional funding opportunities? In fact, probably better now than that. The FAA has been in different areas and we're actually, right now,

15:10 We're working with the staff in looking at discretionary funds, funds on appointments, obviously, which is looking pretty good for this year. And then other, Chris Rob, we're asking. We have an airport layup plan, and there's what they call the ACFP program, which has funded runways and

15:40 This list is a list combined from staff and the commission and a lot of the stuff is

16:08 To try to talk to our senators

16:38 about now is the time when they are looking to funding. So we have Tim on the letter to go and say, okay, don't forget us. That's earmarks, isn't it? Well, that's, some of it's earmarks, yes. No, I hope not. Actually, no, you have to acknowledge it. But really, a lot of it's discretionary funds that they would, to rule our efforts. There's also a big funding push for the F&A to upgrade our air spaces. And part of that would include maybe an approach in the year that,

17:08 So one of the obvious funding sources that we all know about ad nauseum is the 10,000 appointments for a million dollars. I was going to ask this, what's the red circle day on the calendar? It won't be long, I'm just looking at the booking reports. The issue is, will we reach it? It's when we get the money from it.

17:39 And we do have to counsel.

18:04 Start drawing on June 1st. Yes. Start over. But it's reasonable that maybe sometime in March we'll reach 10,000. This year. Yeah. Yeah, we have summer. Yeah. And we have early next winter. We're fine. What we didn't, I think, John's point is, we didn't make it in, which, I don't think any of us have a thought we did, but we're on a calendar year now. Yes. Not the.

18:32 Yeah, exactly.

19:00 So now it's just really last winter, and then Thanksgiving, and of course Christmas, and so the bookings look fantastic, it's four flights, not one, and it's summer, so we will, I hope we will achieve it before next year.

19:30 I'm sorry we did it. AWOS, that's a completed project. We have a, probably two years old now, two year old, brand new AWOS. It's connected by satellite, so you can get it online. You can type in Navit AWOS on Google and it will bring up our weather station for you. You can dial it up by phone. It's fully operational.

20:00 But we did have a glitch with the AVOS where it has multiple problems at once. It did cause us to use perhaps two sites in the way we were lucky it happened during sort of bad weather so they could have impacted us more severely. But it had multiple problems. It had a loose coaxial cable on the aerial.

20:23 It also had a bad radio transceiver. The way it works is your AWOS is now in the field. You have a computer in the airport office. They communicate via radio. There's two whole VHF radios in each site. One of those radios turned out to be bad. And we had thought it was some EV chips, but in reality, it turned out to be radios and coax cables. So because it was intermittent,

20:50 And because there was multiple problems, it took a little bit of time to isolate it. It happened on a Friday afternoon. We don't have technical service over the weekend from the company we bought it from. I won't go into the whole story, but we worked very hard to get spare parts and to get our technician in so that he was there first thing on Monday. And it will troubleshoot the whole thing. And we did get it back up online eventually. And we have a secondary plan to get some...

21:19 Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

21:50 I'm not sure so many people as remote as we are.

22:16 They're going to try to have fantastic contacts within the industry. Cars were headed to Reno before we knew what we needed in Reno. We offered a charter plane, but the weather was bad. So that, as he said, some of his clients didn't come in anyway. So I would rate the response to it as excellent. We hope now that we know what we need and with these guys taking courses, we need to be officials and you can really manual them.

22:44 As long as there's clients. There were two flights. I think there were two flights. I think the other flights, honestly, the other was on the ground. It works great and it works, but when it went bad and it had been troubleshooting and turned out there were multiple components,

23:14 That were not working. That made it hard for the technicians. We were working over the call. They were telling us what to do. The whole story is kind of a story. But anyway, we did get it back. That was a great job by staff, Tim. So we have about minutes, I think, before you kick us out of here. So I just want to make sure that as you go through your list and that you're able to ask us

23:42 To correct this, I know there's a couple areas where we've had staff talk to us and we've felt strongly, I think, as a committee that we want to address. One is that we've heard talk of consolidating committees and we feel, I think I speak for everyone, that we are really just now where the work needs to be done. We feel we've had a very big impact.

24:08 There's concern from this commission about it being consolidated with other commissions. That was one thing that's on our list. I'd like to just make sure we get in in the last 20 minutes. From my standpoint, then anything else on here is open for anybody that has questions. Is there anything else in the commissioners that you want to make sure you address in a minute? Just to make sure that our goals are, if you've got any other 10 items, people have to stand to our goals.

24:37 Any questions or comments from the public?

25:04 You know, I've got one quick one. It's kind of repetitive, but I'm assuming that one of your high priorities currently and in the near future will be both the design and the funding for the new terminal building. It seems like we're going to need that. It's going to creep up to us real quick, it seems like. One of our largest focuses and probably because it's one of our main focus on this.

25:33 I would say next year. Now, I think we can. We found that during these four flights of days, we would have, if the San Francisco flight came in, it would have been bad. And I think we're finding that we could do that fifth.

25:56 Anything beyond that, there are some shorter term fixes that we're working on. The current EIS doesn't allow for a temporary moveable type holding facility that we could do. And so there would be some short term fixes. But reality is, in the length of time that it's going to take us to do an EAA, or I guess an EAS, an EAA.

26:20 And go through the process to get a terminal and we need to be working hard and fast right now. And then I think best case scenario would be breaking ground in two and a half years. We hit the schedule perfectly. So that's a very, very high priority. It would be, I'm not going to say impossible because we're actually doing more at night than we thought we could do.

26:46 If we were to do the service we did this year, we would have been able to do it with five. We would still be able to do that, and I think next year we could.

27:13 It's really the holding areas. It's not the runways. It's the security issues in the holding areas. So a short-term fix are some temporary facilities, but they're not ideal long-term fixes. And they have several restrictions from what they can be.

27:39 So we're not going to be able to just go put up, for example, a soft-sided structure, and we call people a lot, right? So that's why. A tent? Yeah, soft-sided structure. It has to, you know, they have to meet the terminology of portable in some way. So it's, you know, the way the demand is ordered, and also for our guests and facilities that are down there.

28:08 It's getting uncomfortable. It's especially an issue if you have a delay of a flight. That's what we really, you know, you could, if you knew there was never going to be a delay and the flight could come in, the flight could go out, you could do a flight an hour, but there are delays and that we're really starting to reach capacity. Have you been there in school? Have you been waiting for a flight? You can feel it. I'm headed off my head. The holding room only has room for, you know, has 66 seats.

28:37 So if you have two things on the ground, what are you going to do with 120, you know, 120 people? So that's why you need that temporary holding to the hold, and that's really where our limitation is. We could work around it with our, you know, the TSA could work with us, Horizon could work with us, the airport to handle it, but you need to replace all those people, and we have it. It wasn't just about delay. If we were interested in Las Vegas or Phoenix or San Diego or...

29:06 And right now, it's difficult, it's very limiting for us to work with the airlines on time, because we're controlling their time slot by when they're available here. Other airports, that's not so much an issue. They could put two Q400s on the ground at a time, but unfortunately our facilities don't be able to do that. That's a really good point. I mean, we might want to have two planes at 12 o'clock, but right now we can't do that.

29:35 If we all at one point were to say absolutely Las Vegas is our next market and we like it, the airlines will tell you we have good time slots and if we say doesn't work, doesn't work, doesn't work, by the way you can fit from 5 to 5.15 on Wednesdays your opportunity to go to those markets become more and more. It would be more complicated with the airlines. Yeah, exactly. Well, the United, that was really going to be

30:04 Meanwhile, we won't be coming

30:32 with staff, I think, in front of the council regarding at least one temporary for the holding structure. Any questions? Can you refresh my resolution of the ILS study with the results of that?

30:44 And we don't want to unless we can move Doe Ridge. It might actually raise our minimums and not mention it would cost somewhere over $30 million. It's an easy answer. It's a no. It's a no. Unfortunately, it's kind of in between. ILS is still state-of-the-art as far as getting into large airports.

31:14 Yeah. With big equipment, down to very low minimum smoke, and in fact, zero visibility. But in this particular situation, we've got so many terrain issues that ILS is not the perfect solution. In fact, it is, in our situation, out-loaded. There's new technology. I'm sure I know a lot of systems and a lot of local area systems that can allow GPS to do what ILS does.

31:41 And that's where funding is actually being concentrated in the FAA. They're kind of moving away from that. Yeah, that was a very important point when we were talking about being on this. They're using it when you have to still, but it is not the direction they're going in and trying to fund something that's used to be on that. It just, all the geography of the cost. Fairly took it. Question?

32:12 One thing that I think that struck me, you guys should be aware of, is that just operating the way we are today, there's probably around 20, between the rising of TSA, good full-time paychecks coming into town. That's a real stimulus. Some of it's what you guys are paying for.

32:43 A lot of those are government and horizon checks. And the benefits that came with EPA and Horizon, I mean, health benefits that you don't necessarily find in seasonal towns. I mean, they pay after 20 hours, and it's really been a side relation. And with the taxis, shuttle services, it's probably going to create some jobs here in the town, at least 20 staff between Horizon and TSA.

33:13 Maybe not the heart of the winter season and some of the shoulder seasons.

33:53 You know, we've talked about this at the commission of pilots that do tours of rural airports and those types of things that Mammoth become more and more known as an airport than it opens it up. I have a question about that. You know, are you thinking about how to... We've talked about it. We've talked towards making a plan and being more specific as to how... Because I recall that years and years ago, Mammoth was more popular.

34:24 I think the smaller economy is just clogging no matter where you are. I mean, we're just seeing, you know, the effects of that economy. Actually, too, when we were in Ontario, there was a bit of a false economy in, you know, mountains for a second. There was a lot of real estate for a second. There was a lot of talk of air services. So it greatly increased air traffic into Mammoth. That was fairly quickly replaced.

34:51 We talked with Dana and other people. We have legally lost some very good ideas with him on, you know, oh gosh, we've talked about there's going to the small aircraft, $100 hamburger kind of, that travel from airport to airport, finding their publications, telling them what we have to offer to him.

35:19 Work to with Pat and his team to do some of that. I mean, they do a little bit of it, but we think that they could do a lot more. And then what can we do in the way of, you know, the town doesn't necessarily have large, I guess some people are big, there's a large marketing budget.

35:34 So, but what are some public relations things we can do to get out there?

35:50 The trouble with the $100 amateurs, it's now more like a $300. I have a small plane, and I don't fly it. I haven't flown it in six months. Well, I don't fly it the other day. Six months prior to that. I got one, too. I fly it every three or four months, whether I enjoy it or not. Yeah. It hurts, though. I mean, it's very expensive. So we're having to pass it off. We're unfortunately seeing it. The last report that was...

36:16 It's interesting that the jets were holding up pretty well. It was the small plants that probably were on. Small plants that use a lot of fuel.

36:26 Michael, the plane hasn't used so much, so it didn't fit so bad. Okay, you pilots were missing. We have 10 minutes left. Let's make sure we get through this. We're not supposed to be leaving this. I apologize. Go ahead. But I guess I'm really concerned that we cover, I remember this session last time I felt like we left in maybe the questions.

36:49 I think one thing we're aware of, too, is trying to unload the staff. I guess kind of subject to cutbacks and things like that, and we want to try to do our share. So I think we've talked about the frequency of the meetings. We've talked about how to unload the staff. And one of the things about combining commissions that I guess is maybe.

37:20 Thank you.

37:49 And I think we're good at addressing what we need to have more meetings and less, because I don't think any of it has been this. And I think it's because we know when we need a second meeting and when we can let one go for a more focused on getting the job done. One question I did want to bring up year-round air service. The proposal right now is to continue

38:17 April through... It's actually done. We're doing through November... I'm sorry, through what? September. September. And then picking it back up on the 17th, 18th, 18th, October. So there's a five, six week... It's been out there so much. There's a five or six week time that this vehicle won't fly. It goes down to one flight a day.

38:44 What is the reason for shutting it down for five weeks? It's just really, at the time, it was a proposal we put in front of you guys to try to save money because it's a subsidy that we're splitting with the town.

39:13 And that's a time that just has shown that if there was a period that we were concerned about occupancy, that would be the time. Horizon has mentioned, and I don't want to speak for them because I think they're picking up and picking up flights, but they have mentioned that should we get into somewhere in occupancy?

39:39 You know, the load factor would be better than we thought, and therefore the subsidy would be better than we thought, or less than we thought, and potentially we could come back and talk to them about continuing. Okay, I was just going to say, is when they have the ability maybe to adjust that? The more that would be a while ago, you know, the closer we get, the more they commit points, but it's certainly still on the table, absolutely. I did have a comment about that.

40:03 Maybe the shoulder seats at the last few weeks. Yeah. It's a time when business people do a lot of business spent in preparing for whatever. Totally agree. It was already, and that seemed to be the threshold that the town was willing to take at the time when we were having public sessions. And so we were really trying to meet that threshold. But I absolutely, you know, I would say if you feel strong enough about it now that there's enough.

40:33 Yeah, we ought to pursue it more than sort of a general discussion with Hermison. We are more than happy to do that and bring back the potential risk out of risk. Yes. If you would like us to do that, then everybody else can put in working with the often staff who can do that. We also have the smaller community air services companies that still do not get out. Yeah, but we really need to be.

41:03 All we do know is if that goes through it. But for now, I think all of our time should be on that. We don't do that. Because that's how, right now, what we've done by a council was the highest risk without that grant and without that would be over that. Pam, what would you need to know? What would the lead time?

41:23 December 2009. December 2009. Well, no, no, let me talk to everyone. You know, I'll just tell them that this came up in our workshop and that maybe there's more interest than they thought. Certainly, I, you know, I think that we put together with staff a very conservative estimate on loan factor, so you could be doing a lot better. And then if that grant came through,

41:51 It would be a huge, because it would allow the town to use that money for a subsidy, which then would really be free of some stress on the budget. So the next step could be for me, I'll just talk about the town and talk about the horizon, find out if it's even a chance still, and then we'll break. What flight is the once a day?

42:14 Started in April, wasn't it? Well, it's the LA one, but there's a slight little change. Oh, you mean, I guess if you're going to go ahead and get time. It's kind of a big thing. It's LA and it's a... LA in the middle, back in LA? Yeah. Although there, they're still going to do the connectivity. I mean, there's an all-more advertising zone. And what's the time that we get?

42:41 Yeah, it's like mid-afternoon. Okay. It's mid-afternoon. It's not at 5.4. It's a little later than that. One comment I heard from the pilots was that the Horizon Act likes the fact that they fly through Mammoth. And we had a plane that just came off from Reno down to here. There were several people that just continued on that. It gave them flexibility of their moving aircraft around. So they...

43:09 They may be willing to... Well, we're talking with them about that. They're very aware that we were going to move to Reno. That's great. As of right now, they're not committing to that. They're saying L.A. Mammoth. But we're absolutely... It's better for us and men if they're willing to do that here. Unfortunately, the way they presented doing this was L.A. Mammoth. But if you want to go to L.A., you've got all the Mammoth, you went to Reno. And that is not leading direct. It's not stopping. And so...

43:38 They're looking at options, but they'll drive that. It's pretty separate, you know. I just can't remember the time in the minute. We've been out still in the rest of the week. Have you been doing it? A few months ago? Yeah, probably, yeah. Yeah, it's not really open for a lot. I just didn't bring it, because I should have. It was within our last room, and I guess it's been out for so long.

44:04 And again, for clarity, real quick, this, I'm sorry, Skip, last question. For clarity, you're saying that it's going to shut down, that air service shuts down at the end of September? Last September, when it restarts. It's in October. And then through? Mid-November. Thank you. And again, with, simply don't worry, so we'll find out what that is. Okay.

44:32 I just wanted to say that you've mentioned several times about the joining of commissions and things, and just as one council member, I can tell you that I see there are two very important elements of the guest's experience. The first one is getting them here, and that's a handful to itself. That's all you folks are finding out and doing a great job. Thank you. The second element is moving around once we get here, and that is a major feat within itself. So the idea of combining the two commissions probably

44:59 Would not be efficient to any of us. And I appreciate the fact, too, that you're trying to minimize staff time and be efficient through meetings and get work done and not having the experience in any way. So I think we're pretty, I don't think there will be a lot of concern for that. Any other questions? Well, thank you. Congratulations. No, that's work.

46:12 I've got to talk to you. Can we get together? I've got to talk to you about the theater this week. The theater? Yeah, I'm going to be here. It's a warm morning sometime.

46:42 Would,

47:06 Thank you.

47:36 I'm taping the Olympics. I'm taping the Olympics. Well, no, Stuart was giving out some back there. Unsolicited.

52:43 Well, I know, it had my name on it. It was definitely odd, yeah.

53:17 I'm not quite sure how this happened. We are not making purchasing decisions. I'll call to order the regular meeting of the Town Council of Mammoth Lakes, February 17, 2010. Roll call, please, Jamie. Here. Here. Here. Here. Here. Wendy, would you lead us into place, please? Yes. If everyone would please rise and join me.

54:16 I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you, Wendy. Public comment. Now is the time for public comments on matters not appearing on the agenda this evening. Any public comments? Michael Grossblatt, I'm pleased to announce that as we speak right now, we're...

54:54 Doing our first live webcasting on our website. And thanks to all the efforts of Dan Dennis and Jamie and just a whole host of people, we're really excited to offer this up for the community because, as we know, a lot of people in town have satellite dishes. So with the webcasting, this will allow everybody to watch our exciting meetings all the time. Tonight is a dry run. As Jamie's showing, it's actually working.

55:24 Cool. Ooh, there's a little Michael. Tonight is a dry run and we're working out the kinks. It is working, but currently it says planning commission and it's really the council meeting. So we're working through things like that. And then starting with the next meeting, we'll work with Stu and we'll do a full-on media blitz to the community to make sure that everybody knows that this is a good thing and we're moving forward on a technological basis.

55:53 Wonderful. And they're also available for later replay in an archive? That's right. The meetings are live on the webcast, but they're also archived. And so people will be able to go back and click on the meeting and click on a certain agenda. You don't have to sit and watch all four hours of the meeting to get to your favorite agenda item. And that will be on the town website? Did they get the link to that? Yeah, there's a link to it right now. Okay. Wonderful. Thank you, Mike. Anyone else wishing to speak?

56:22 Public comments? Hearing none, we'll move on to Councilmember Reports, additions to the agenda. Skip, do you want to start? Thank you, Mr. Mayor. I just have a couple short things. I did attend the Wildlife Subcommittee meeting today, and we are continuing to work through our management plan. We expect to have a final draft on that at our next meeting, which the date is still to be determined in March.

56:49 And I think we've made a lot of great progress in that, in handling the issues that need to be done, and each year it's going to get better, and this coming year I look forward to having a program that we've ironed out some of the kinks. The other thing I would like to say is that this weekend, the holiday weekend, the President's Weekend, I think Mammoth...

57:11 Actually put on its best face possible. And I can tell you that from snow conditions to the traffic in town to the attitude of the people around, everybody had a smile. I spent a lot of time on the mountain and both in

57:27 Thank you.

57:52 19,000 plus people on the mountain, 16,000 some on Saturday, and with the full mountain being open, lift lines were manageable, people were moving through nicely, and I think the entire town, all the business owners, town staff, and everybody deserves big kudos for doing a great job and putting on a big show, a great show for the people that came to visit. So thank you to everyone. Thank you, Skip. Joe?

58:19 Yes, Mayor McCarroll and I attended the LTC Commission on the 8th. The good news is that there's a potential for additional federal funds through a second phase of ARA, maybe. Also that Main Street will get resurfaced this summer so that the scraped off parts will be fixed.

58:42 The bad news is that the Governor's budget has changes to the gas tax that are going to have significant impacts on public transit funds if it goes forward as it is suggested by the Governor. So that's something to watch very closely.

58:57 And the only other thing I'd like to mention is I'd like to thank Sierra Star for coming up with a creative way to get some wintertime use out of the golf course by adding the cross-country and snowshoeing out there. Everybody should go out and try it. And when you get to it, I have some consent agenda items to pull. Okay. Wendy? Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Joe and I attended some Mammoth Lakes Recreation meetings, continuing to pursue the...

59:25 Reorganization of the Tourism and Recreation Department. And so that process is moving along, and we're continuing to meet and make progress. I actually have an item that I want to report on that I attended as a county staff member, and that's a project that's called the Land Tenure Project, which is, it's a pretty ambitious project. It's a collaborative effort between Inyo and Mono counties and then federal land agencies.

59:52 Which includes U.S. Forest Service, the BLM, and then also the City of Los Angeles, LEDWP, as landholders in the Eastern Sierra. And I think as many people know, a lot of the lands in both Mono and Inyo counties are held by public landowner agencies, either the BLM, Forest Service, or LEDWP. And there's a checkerboard pattern to their landholdings so that their...

1:00:19 Their land holdings are kind of dispersed, as well as there's an issue of not having enough private land sometimes around communities who may want to expand, who need some critical masks for economic sustainability, economic growth. So the land tenure project is intended to address all of those issues, trying to help agencies consolidate their land so that they can manage their resources better.

1:00:42 If there are communities that want to grow, if that's what they choose to do, then there may be some opportunities to do some land exchanges to provide more private land around the communities for that purpose. So it's a pretty big-scale project, and Mammoth has not been involved in that project or in that conversation very much to date.

1:01:06 And Mammoth was actually brought up a couple times at the meetings, and I don't know if it was because I was there and people recognized me as a council member, even though I was there in my capacity as a county employee.

1:01:17 But I shared with that committee that Mammoth has a very strong commitment to our urban growth boundary, and I think that we are interested in supporting this idea, but that we probably don't need to have any direct involvement in it at all. So if that isn't the case, then I'd like to hear that from the council, and we can agendize it and talk about it. But otherwise, I'll just keep everybody apprised of it, and it is moving forward. I think it's a great project.

1:01:45 And it addresses a lot of issues and needs that are out there in the community, and it's a very cooperative project. But I don't know that there's any direct need for Mammoth to be engaged in that necessarily. And if anyone wants more information on it, feel free to contact me. I think it's very worthwhile.

1:02:04 It's a very exciting project. And then the only other thing I wanted to bring up, Skip reported on the Wildlife Committee meeting. The only other thing I wanted to bring up is that there was a letter from a property owner out in Old Mammoth where there has been some alleged feeding of wildlife going on. And in that letter, John, your name was mentioned as the property caretaker.

1:02:30 Yeah, and I just thought that, you know, not that anyone in this community draws judgments or conclusions based on incomplete information or anything like that, but I thought you might like an opportunity just to help clarify that since that information's out there, whatever your involvement may be on that property. I'd be happy to. Thank you, Wendy. Without mentioning names, this particular property in Old Mammoth is a property that I've caretaked for for years.

1:02:59 You know, probably more than 10 years. Steve, who's in the audience without mentioning names, identified this particular property as having, for lack of a better word, feeders, if you will, in the yard. And those feeders, whether it's bird feeders, raccoon feeders, doesn't really matter. It's my understanding, although I didn't observe it.

1:03:28 That these feeders had food in them that could be used by a variety of different types of wildlife. After I got the letter that Wendy referred to from this particular homeowner, I was instructed by her to go out to her property and remove what ended up being two feeders. One was what I would categorize as a bird or small animal feeder that was attached to the back of the fence.

1:03:58 In her yard at that time when I removed it, which I believe was on Sunday of this past weekend, maybe Monday, so just recently, no indication that there had been any food in that particular feeder. And then there was a second feeder that was strung up with a rope on the side yard.

1:04:23 Both of which I was not aware of these two feeders because we just entered the front door and checked the inside of the house and don't walk around the exterior as a general rule. But this was up at an elevation of six, eight feet. Large, large feeder, not quite the size of the podium here on a skinny spindle. That as well didn't show any indication of any recent food being in that.

1:04:52 Having said that, there were also feeders, what I would consider like a dog or a cat bowl in the entrance to the house, and those didn't have any food in it at the time, but all were removed, the front door closed. This particular homeowner does not like publicity and wanted to make sure that if there had been previously, that from now on there will be no feeding at that property.

1:05:21 I'd like to thank Steve Searles here tonight for essentially taking care of this issue and making sure that it didn't continue. So good job, Steve. Thank you, John. Yeah, thank you, Wendy. Having said that, I've got three reports that I'd like to give real quick. The council met from 5 to 6 this evening for a full hour with our, it was a joint meeting with our airport commission.

1:05:51 And the five commissioners as well as their staff. Three things that I wanted to share with the public that may not have been in attendance at that meeting or may not otherwise hear about it. Number one is by having air service in Mammoth Lakes at the airport, and John Walters pointed this out at the meeting, that air service generates a number of jobs for local

1:06:21 People in the area. Whether it's Horizon Airline or Airline Carrier, jobs that they need at the airport for their air service, or whether it's the TSA, Transportation Safety Agency, or whether it's taxi service to pick up passengers and to take passengers at the airport. There's

1:06:45 Something in excess of 20 jobs that are created for our local economy. So in that sense, it's very worthwhile. Second item of importance, and we beat it to death, but it's really important. If we get 10,000 employments at the airport in a year, and that's from January 1st through December 31st, in any given year, if we get 10,000, we get a million dollars from the FAA to put back into the airport.

1:07:14 It's reasonable to speculate that we will reach that 10,000 employment number possibly sometime in March of this year. And again, it just started in January, so January, February, and March. In the first three months of a 12-month year, we should be able to reach that 10,000 employment and be eligible for the $1 million FAA distribution of money.

1:07:39 The downside of that is that that distribution, as my understanding, does not occur and does not come to the town until that one-year, 12-month cycle has completed and they have up to a year after that's been completed to give us the money. So we're still a couple of years down the road before we're going to receive that first million dollars. But still a very positive situation in that we should

1:08:07 Unless something unforeseen happens, we should be in line to receive that million dollar FAA distribution of money each year from now on. Third and final from the commission, and these are not specific dates, but it gives people a general idea. We have currently four flights a day. Those four flights a day will end on the week after Easter this spring, so April.

1:08:36 11th through the 13th sometime in there. And the four flights will lower to a single flight. And that single flight for the rest of April, May, June, so forth, will be a single flight out of LA to Mammoth and then back to LA as it stands now. So the one flight. We will have, as it stands now, no flight to Mammoth during the time frame from essentially October 1st to the middle.

1:09:02 Or the third week of November. So there's about a six or seven week time frame there in the late fall, early winter that we won't have air service at all. That brings updated on that. I want to mention a couple of just FYI items. I got an email today from a local realtor that there was a story in the Los Angeles Times. I'm not sure the date of that article. Actually, I think it was the 16th, which would have been yesterday maybe.

1:09:32 But that article in the Los Angeles Times indicated that as of now, currently there are 4 million United States homeowners, so this is 4 million single family homes, that are 90 days or longer delinquent on their mortgage payments for their homes. So still serious economic indications throughout the United States as it relates to

1:10:02 People's Homes. The other item that I think is really relevant, you can debate, anybody can debate whether the town of Mammoth Lakes responsibly passed our budget for this year or not, but I would rather be in the town of Mammoth Lakes budget shoes than Reno, Las Vegas, State of California.

1:10:32 Or now we're hearing from the city of Los Angeles. The mayor of Los Angeles spoke a week ago to his council, and again, the article was in the Los Angeles Times, and they have a lot of council members in the city of Los Angeles, obviously, to represent the different people, but the mayor had to go before the council and say, you know, look guys, we're almost a $500 million shortfall.

1:11:01 For the city of Los Angeles for this year. And because of their inaction, you know, they're getting deeper and deeper in the financial hole. So good for the mayor of Los Angeles to bring this to the fore and to put pressure on his city council to take action to address their budget problems in Los Angeles. The last item is two parts, and I'll say the first one, or the second one first.

1:11:28 I had an opportunity to meet with the executive recruiter for the director's position of the destination marketing organization. This is a new position. This gentleman's name is Mike Gamble, and he was here from Minnesota gathering information from many locals as to what we expect this individual for the executive position to be hired by their DMO recruitment team.

1:11:53 Mr. Gamble is a high, what I would consider to be a high-powered nationwide recruiter, and I felt good that we would receive some very specific input as to candidates for that position. Had a, just a wonderful, every once in a while you have just a great, great opportunity. I see Diane in the audience, Ted Carlton, a number of people here in the room had an opportunity.

1:12:23 On the February 4th to go to the Mammoth Mountain Ski Area. Ted, I think Ted, yeah, Ted, weren't you, were you there on the 4th for the Wounded Warriors luncheon? I was. Yeah, okay. I was thinking Ted Shady did. I'm sorry. No, okay. Anyway, Mammoth Mountain Ski Area and Kathy Copeland, Kathy Copeland, of course, representing the Wounded Warriors, had a luncheon. Let me back up. First of all, they sponsored, I believe it was 26,

1:12:53 Wounded Warriors from Balboa Hospital. Most of these, if not all of them were Marines, Marine Soldiers from the San Diego area. The Mammoth sponsored them for about five days. They had an opportunity to ski, to snowboard, and on their final day they went snowmobiling. These, for the most part, were individuals who had

1:13:22 Limbs missing. I was fortunate to sit at a table with four men. Two of the four lost one leg and the other two had lost both legs. The two gentlemen had lost both legs. One of them lost his legs in October and the other in November of 2009, so recently. These 26 individuals are recovering for an extended period of time in San Diego and in Kathy Copeland, Disabled Sports and Mammoth Mountain Ski Area.

1:13:51 Brought them to Mammoth to give them a winter break, and these guys were so appreciative. The last thing on that, first of all, just Kathy Copeland and the job that she does at the mountain is wonderful, and we all really appreciate what Kathy does. Dina Castor was, I would refer to her as the keynote speaker.

1:14:15 The table, each table had ten people and again I had four wounded warriors at my table and also the four honor guard members that were there that came down from above Bridgeport. When Dina Castor started speaking and telling her story, this was during lunch, the people at my table stopped eating and turned their chairs and looked directly at Dina Castor and

1:14:44 She made a huge impact on them and really related to these individuals and the struggles that they're going through. So again, congratulations and thank you to Dina Castor as well. Thank you. Thank you, John. As far as the meeting that I attended with Joe, the LTC meeting, I had reported last year that before summer, during last summer, that pavement on Main Street would be replaced. And what happened was there was

1:15:14 Some sort of a legal dispute. First of all, we shoot all the lawyers. But that's been settled. And that has been settled now. So I think we actually can expect that payment to appear this summer. So the second thing was on February 8th, I attended a board meeting of Mammoth Lakes Housing. And I'm very pleased to report that, you know, we adopted interim

1:15:43 And basically what the board has approved is that Pam Henry, the executive director, is going to do

1:16:09 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

1:16:31 And I would like to poll 9 and 9A. 9 and 9A. Anybody else? Okay.

1:17:02 This evening we're very pleased to have with us Ted Shady from the Great Basin Unified Air Pollution Control District. He's going to give us a public presentation. It's an update on the use of solar panels for dust control at Owens Lake. Thank you for coming up tonight, Ted. I appreciate it.

1:17:26 A little update on air quality in Mammoth, and we can talk about that if you'd like when I'm done.

1:17:34 I briefed my board in January, in our January meeting, about solar, the proposed solar power project and the state of dust control at Owens Lake. There's been a lot of information in the press lately. Mr. David Freeman, the general manager, the intern general manager of the GOP, is very good at getting publicity, and he's also a big thinker, and one of his big ideas that he's recently come up with is that he wants to make the eastern Sierra the largest.

1:18:03 Solar Power Project in the world, the largest solar park in the world. The city of Los Angeles has made some serious commitments, some significant commitments for renewable energy, and they feel that solar is really the way for them to go right now. So they also own a lot of land here in the eastern Sierra, and David asked his staff to find some place to put an enormous solar project. They looked at their lands and came up with some places.

1:18:30 Mainly the east side of the Owens River south of Independence, so from like the Lone Pine area up to Independence east of the river, they identified as number one an area that the city owns, number two it has really good sun, and number three not a lot of obvious environmental impediments like they have on a lot of their properties. So they start looking at that for solar.

1:18:53 But they also identified the bed of Owens Lake, the dried bed of Owens Lake. As you know, the city is working on a project there. They are about $500 to $600 million into the project. We've been working on it for about 10 years. And next month they'll have about 40 square miles of dust controls on the lake, but that's over 20,000 acres of dust controls on the lake bed. Their idea, and when I first heard it, I...

1:19:18 Thought it might not be a very good idea, but the more I thought about it, the smarter it sounded. Their idea is to replace areas on the lake bed that are being controlled with dust now or new areas on the lake bed that might need controls with solar panels. And if the solar panels can be oriented such that they break the wind, then they would do two things. They would generate power, solar power, obviously. They would control dust.

1:19:43 What may be most important for them is they would save water. We could put those solar panels in areas now where they're putting aqueduct water onto the lake bed. This year the city estimates that they're going to put about 95,000 acre feet of clean aqueduct water onto the lake bed. That's all the water that Long Beach and all the water that Glendale uses every year. It's a huge amount of water.

1:20:04 And that's coming right straight out of the aqueduct through two big five-foot diameter pipes put right into the side of the aqueduct. They're meeting their dust control commitments, but now they're asking themselves at what cost to our water supply. So with the situation that we have statewide with water and the situation that the city of Los Angeles currently finds itself in, limiting people to watering two days a week, they are using less water now.

1:20:30 Even with population growth than they used 15 years ago. So they've done a really good job at cutting their water use back, but there's still a lot of people down there, and those people need a lot of water, and they find themselves putting a lot of that valuable fresh water onto the lake bed. So the push really now is, for many years, I've been working on the Owens Lake Project for 20 years, and for much of that time, their attitude is,

1:20:53 What problem make us fix it? And I have to say that that attitude has really changed over the last few years, and now it's how can we fix it as efficiently as possible? And I think we realize now that some of the decisions they made back in 2000, which were...

1:21:08 Maybe for expediency's sake, to get out there and get going and get the lake fixed. They committed their water because they're in the water business and they get their water pretty cheap. It's essentially free. Where we could have gone with other things like gravel or vegetation and now in this case soil panels, you know, that's not going to be free. It's going to be very expensive. But now they're sort of weighing the need to

1:21:31 Continue to provide water for the people of Los Angeles versus the cost of dust control. And, you know, I think we're going to see a real kind of a switch in their priorities. So back to the solar project. You know, Dave Freeman is a big thinker. You know, he's – what I characterize him as a guy that looks at a problem for 20,000 feet.

1:21:54 You have a big view from up there, but you miss a lot of the details. And so, you know, thankfully Dave's got people that look at things from 2,000 feet and 200 feet, and in some cases 2 feet. And, you know, when you get down to 2 feet above the surface, there's lots of issues to deal with regarding solar panels out there. You know, it's not a – it's a very in-hospital environment. The soils are awful. The access is horrible.

1:22:16 But they are sort of committed at this point. They originally thought that they were going to go ahead with about a 300-acre or about a half-square-mile pilot project that was going to cost $300 million. The lake bed itself is owned by the state of California. The state said, wait a minute, you're not going to – and they were going to do that with a notice of exemption from CEQA.

1:22:35 All the attorneys laughed at that, including state lands, like I said, who owns the lake bed. So they've scaled that back, and now it looks like it's going to be about an 80-acre project, so it's scaled back significantly, but it's still going to be big enough for their power engineers to determine, you know, how do we get stuff built out there on the lake bed, and it's going to be big enough for us at their pollution control district to make sure that the configuration that we pick is going to control dust. We've been working with their wind engineers since the beginning of last summer coming up with

1:23:05 Thank you.

1:23:06 The configurations of panels, the size, the shape, the way they're mounted above the surface. We come up with some ideas. We run those ideas through a computer model. The promising ones then, they've actually built models of, scale models of, and we put them in a wind tunnel in Colorado Springs. It's an enormous wind tunnel. And we can blow 60 mile an hour winds through this tunnel and then see how the wind at the surface is being affected. And we're pretty sure that a combination of, you know, a smart combination of solar panels along with probably some gravel

1:23:36 Thank you. Thank you.

1:24:03 Mr. Freeman sees ultimately up to four gigawatts of solar power in the eastern Sierra. That's something on the order of six billion dollars. Nobody really has six billion dollars laying around now for a project like that. So, you know, it's going to be a little bit of time. One of the things that the city is doing is they're trying to recruit partners from other utilities in the west.

1:24:23 You know, because you can only use so much solar power because the sun generally doesn't shine at night. And so you've got to have, you know, what you really want to do is you want to spread that power over as many people during the day, during the peak hours, as you possibly can. So they're talking to Pacific Gas and Electric, San Diego Gas and Electric, Las Vegas, trying to really generate some, you know, Western enthusiasm about this large project. But it looks as though, you know, they're pretty committed. And these guys, when they get an idea in their head like this, you know, often it comes to fruition.

1:24:53 That's where that stands. Great. Thank you, Ted. You're welcome. Questions? Questions? Yeah. Well, I think it's a very exciting project, and I'm glad to hear your point of view on it, and I wish you guys the best of luck in seeing whether or not the panels will actually control the air pollution and the dust mitigation, and I think, like you said, there's a lot of

1:25:16 Technical issues that still need to be worked out. Has there been any discussion about the transmission infrastructure, about how all of this is going to get to place? I'm glad you mentioned that. I mean, the city looked at…

1:25:28 You know, they looked far and wide for a place to put a big solar project. And originally, they were going to put it down in Imperial County, down south of Salton Sea. The problem there is that they didn't have wires to get up to Los Angeles. And so they embarked on what they called the Green Line. And a lot of you probably read about the Green Line in the LA Times. And, you know, it was going to go through, what's the park down there, the Yucca Park? Oh, there's a state park down there that was going to go through. Joshua Tree. Joshua Tree. Joshua Tree. It was going to go through Joshua Tree.

1:25:57 And, you know, there just were all kinds of issues. And so they realized that, you know, maybe the hardest part of any solar project is not putting solar panels out, but it's the wires. And the thing about the eastern Sierra is they've got the wires. They've got enough existing capacity for a very large project. And then with some improvements within their existing right-of-way or maybe even on their existing towers, they can up that amount.

1:26:19 The sun in the Southern Owens Valley is 20% more efficient than the sun in Los Angeles for generating solar power. And the losses, the electrical losses between the Owens Valley and Los Angeles are about 10%. And so by putting the project in the Owens Valley, it's actually 10% more efficient than it would be down in Southern California. Not as efficient as in Imperial County, but if you don't have wires, there's no sense in even having a project. So this really sort of fits in.

1:26:45 The missing link, which is the wires, is already in place here and that really makes the project a lot more feasible. Any other questions, comments or questions from the public for Ted? Ted, thank you very much for coming up. I'd love to talk about that. Thanks for asking.

1:27:10 Mammoth has done a fabulous job improving its air quality. When I first came to the district in 1980, you were in federal non-attainment status, which means that you had days over 150 micrograms per cubic meter. That is really, really dusty and really smoky. And the town council at that point was the first governmental body in the country to adopt wood stove regulations. And a lot of people at that point, a lot of the...

1:27:36 You know, the real estate and developer people said, you know, if you make us change wood stoves out when we sell houses, we're not going to be able to sell houses. And, you know, the council at that point says, you know, we don't believe that. And so, you know, over the years we estimate that we've replaced about 90% of the non-compliant wood stoves in Mammoth. And, you know, and I don't think that it ever prevented anybody from either selling or buying a house. So it's been pretty painless.

1:28:01 We had a number of federal violations, which is 150 in 1990. By 1992 or 1993, we had no federal violations, but we still continue to have state violations. The state standard is 50 micrograms, so it's three times less than the federal standard. And, you know, in 2004, we had as many as 90 days in Mammoth where we exceeded the state standard. That dropped pretty precipitously over the last few years.

1:28:27 And, you know, we're down to a handful. Those eight and three might be a little bit low because we had some equipment issues in those years, but it was something on the order of a dozen or so, certainly less than 20. Now, over the last couple of years, we're seeing those creep back up. I don't really know why, but I can speculate that the economy has caused people to stop burning propane and possibly start burning wood, and we're seeing a little more – we're seeing more smoky days in Mammoth than we've seen in the past few years. In fact, on the very right there, you'll see so far in –

1:28:57 2010, you know, just in the, how many weeks do we have, seven weeks in 2010, we've had 11 violations of the state standard. So we're not there yet. I mean, someday, I hope that we have no exceedance of the state standard and we can say that Mammoth, you know, really is a truly a clean air community. But we do have a little ways to go and I just wanted to make you aware of that. But we're moving in the right direction.

1:29:20 Ted, do we have to be concerned that I understand you're saying the equipment flare so it may be not so much a dip in the curve but the fact that it is going up a little bit, do we need to

1:29:31 Like I said, it might be the economy. You know, there certainly hasn't been any more wood stoves put in. You know, the town was great about, you know, keeping an eye on the wood smoke levels and calling the no burn days if they have to. You know, I really don't know what kind of compliance we have on no burn days. The town's also been great about getting out and, you know, the PM10, the dust problem and the particulate matter problem in Mammoth is part wood stoves and part road cinders and, you know, and getting out with those sweepers and cleaning those road cinders up.

1:29:59 Sooner rather than later is a big deal also. But the town, you know, for many years has been very good about that. And, you know, I don't know that there's anything obvious at this point that we can do. You know, outreach, education, enforcing those no-burn days, getting better at calling the no-burn days, you know, really kind of knowing when we're going to have those quiet, you know, evenings when everybody comes back from the ski, from skiing and they fire up their wood stoves. And, you know, by the next morning we're, you know, choking on the smoke here.

1:30:27 It's not nearly as bad as it used to be. We don't have as many, but we're not quite where we need to be in order to claim success. Just a comment and a thought here is that part of the fact that our Main Street is constantly disintegrating, and there's a lot, it is, it's just constantly dissolving, and I think a lot of those holes are even probably collecting more cinders rather than letting them disperse off to the side of the road may have a play in some of the increased numbers over the last couple years.

1:30:58 Yeah, I would agree. I would agree that it tends to trap the fine particulates. And, you know, even if you come over with the sweeper, you're not going to get all that stuff. And the more they drive on it, the more they kick it up and, you know, and it gets spread around. So, yeah, I mean, I'm very proud of the fact that we were the first and really sort of still the leader. And we've been doing this for two decades now. You know, and a lot of communities are just sort of finally.

1:31:20 Finally facing up to the fact that they need to control their wood burning. You know, Bay Area has just recently done it. Sacramento has just recently done it. We've been doing it for many, many years. So I'll always be proud of that. Wendy? Ted, so the chart says that we have 11 exceedances so far this year. In 2008, 2009, we had 18 and 23. Is that 11 sort of on track with that still? It might be a little.

1:31:43 A little higher? Yeah, because, I mean, that was, February 10th was not President's Weekend. You know, it was a pretty nice weekend. There wasn't a lot of wind. It's been a very non-windy winter so far. I mean, we see that at Owens Lake. We see it really all up and down the valley. So we just haven't had a lot of wind yet. You know, so some of that is just going to be a year-to-year, you know, climatic variations. But, yeah, 11 in the first six weeks of the year was quite a lot. You know, that's almost a couple of weeks. Thank you. Any other questions?

1:32:13 Thanks again, Ted. Oh, I'm sorry, you had somebody... Robert, can you come up for the podium, please? Regarding the street sweepers... Tell us your name for the record. My name's Robert Calvert. You know, many mornings I come down Main Street and I see, as we all do, quite a bit of dust and the street sweepers blowing the dust into the air. Is that pretty standard for the street sweeper or is this something up with the filters or who could help me out with that?

1:32:43 I mean, that thing is, I don't know if it's helping us or probably more of a problem. Thank you, Robert. They're not just the regular street sweepers where you've got to broom and just sort of push that stuff over to the side. I mean, these are supposed to be sort of state-of-the-art. At least they were years ago. I mean, I don't know. They're probably better ones out now. But, you know, they really are supposed to minimize the amount of dust they create.

1:33:09 You know, sweeping streets is a dusty endeavor, and, you know, it's not perfect. But so, you know, I think manless street sweepers are better than normal street sweepers, but they still, I mean, there is a certain amount of dust that is generated by the act of actually sweeping the street. Well, you know, when you watch them, there is some dust that appears to be coming out of the tops of them. There's a lot less dust coming out of the top than there would be if some of it wasn't being filtered out. You know, they don't capture everything, they capture most of it. But, yeah, I mean, cinders make a lot of dust.

1:33:39 And there's a huge volume of cinders that are put down. So it's a big undertaking to get that stuff picked up as dust-free as possible. Thanks again, Ted. Okay, we have two public hearings this evening. Public hearing number one is, it's actually item two on the agenda, is Zoning Code Amendment 10-01, which proposes to make amendments to the zoning ordinance of the Town of Mammoth.

1:34:06 To allow permitting a limited number of medical marijuana cooperatives as not prohibited by state law. The ordinance will permit medical marijuana cooperatives within the commercial, general, and industrial zoning designation subject to the use permit process. I'll go ahead and open the public hearing statement and presentation by staff. Sandra? Thank you.

1:34:31 As you stated, the adding before you is a zoning code amendment to permit medical marijuana cooperatives within the commercial general and industrial zoning designations, which is subject to voter approval. The commercial general and industrial zoning designations are outlined in black on the map behind me. And this ordinance will be placed on the June 8th ballot to allow voters to determine if medical marijuana should be permitted within the county of Mammoth Lakes.

1:34:56 And because the ordinance before you tonight may be approved by a vote of the people, staff included only basic requirements in this ordinance as any changes to this ordinance or to a ordinance enacted by a vote of the people may only be changed by a vote of the people.

1:35:10 For this reason, we are preparing a second ordinance that contains regulations for medical marijuana cooperatives, which will be enacted if the voters approve the use on June 8th. And staff anticipates that this ordinance will be before the Planning Commission in March and the Town Council in April. And the Planning Commission considered this item at their January 27th meeting. The Commission recommended approval of the zoning code amendment, but recommended that the Town Council make two changes to staff's recommendation.

1:35:40 Staff had suggested that no more than three medical marijuana cooperatives be permitted within town, and the Planning Commission recommended that the Town Council only allow two medical marijuana cooperatives within town. And the second change was that the Planning Commission recommended that medical marijuana cooperatives be at least 500 feet apart rather than 1,000 feet apart, as staff had suggested.

1:36:04 And staff is recommending that the Town Council choose Option 1 as outlined in Page 2 of your Agenda Bill. And that concludes my staff report, and I'm available for any questions that you may have. Okay, any questions, staff? Yeah. The question that I had was, what was the Commission's reasoning on Number 2 to reduce it from 1,000 feet to 500? The Commission was...

1:36:32 Concerned that when the second ordinance came forward, the second ordinance is going to have a distance from schools, a minimum distance from schools. They were concerned that that might cut into some area where there might not be enough room in the commercial general or industrial area once that is overlaid to allow for them to be located in appropriate locations. So that was their reasoning to reduce the distance between medical marijuana. And what was the vote? It was 5-0. It was 5-0? Thank you.

1:37:03 Wendy. I had a similar question just on the first change that they made. Why did they feel that two cooperatives was appropriate as opposed to three or even one or some other number? They felt that three seemed like too many but two seemed like a good number and I believe Vice Chair Barrett is here and he may be able to provide more detail to that. You know, normally there's a

1:37:32 Provision for statements from the applicant, but there really, there's some real parties in interest here that might wish to speak. Steve, Tony, are you? Tony Barrett. I'll just be here as a citizen, I guess, not as a planning commissioner, so we have no issues there. You know, it's something that you're putting it before the people, and I just, you know, want to say the language that's in there, I think we're comfortable with. I'd like you to leave it that way. Having two, no more than two.

1:38:09 It allows, if you want to use the word competition, but it allows the marketplace to dictate how many there should be really. And I think for us to allow two, we know that we can't put a number on the number of uses of medicinal users that we're going to have within the town or our visitors. So I think that the language you have is broad enough for the community to vote. You'll have regulations coming forward.

1:38:36 And I want to be clear that we've got regulations that would be 750 feet from the schools, and a lot of regulations are very strict as to how the operations will be conducted. So I would just encourage you to go forward with this, let it go before the people, and let the people decide as you had decided last month. Thank you, Tony. Any questions to Tony? Not of Tony, but if...

1:38:59 If the recommendation I've understood was 750 feet from the schools, Sandra, can you kind of give us an idea of how that would cut into the commercial general? I presume it would not affect the industrial. It's too far away from the schools. I can actually tell you too, Jo, if you'd like. Sure. So it would not affect industrial. It would take this center out. So this center would not be allowed, which works with the regulations because we placed about where children congregate like the movie theater.

1:39:27 It would take this whole side of Old Mammoth Road out all the way down to the Century 21 building. Okay. And what's interesting is 750 feet doesn't include the McDonald's. So what we're discussing is maybe doing it without the barrier of 750 feet but to include the McDonald's area because the kids do walk there in there during lunch. So we're saying 750 now. I anticipate it's going to come out with a...

1:39:53 More of a, you know, a border going around that area that defines it more than just 750. And all of that information would be part of what's available to the public so they can check and see where that is in relation to their personal service. Exactly. And that's why our group, the chief and Steve that we've been meeting working on this ordinance, it was important to get it to staff, which we've done now, so they could go through it, get it ready for the public so the public knows in June.

1:40:20 What are the regulations are? I mean, for instance, no signage with cannabis or marijuana on the postings. The windows blacked out. Hours of operation. Full-time security during hours of operation. California-accredited security. No more than $200 at any time on the premises. No one under 21. You know, the list goes on with the regulations surrounding it. I'm sorry, I missed the part about the staff report says.

1:40:49 500 feet. Well, you said 750. 500 feet between each of the cooperatives. 750 feet is what we're saying about the schools. Thank you. In a subsequent ordinance. In a subsequent ordinance, correct. Yeah, thank you. Okay. Any other questions for Tony? If not, I'll call for testimony from those persons wishing to speak in favor of the ordinance. Anybody wishing to speak? Steve? Robert Calvert again.

1:41:29 I would just, reading through this, and I did read everything that was posted on the internet today with regards to this ordinance, but I would urge council to at least approve no less than two, as this does talk about multiple ones. Two, creates a sense of competition, and one obviously doesn't, so I would urge council to approve two. Thank you. Thank you, Robert. Steve?

1:41:58 Hi, I'm Steve Klassen, owner of Wave Rave. There's just a couple of things that I want to say, and they seem a little scattered to you guys, but there's just some things that I just want to have let known. First off, I think the solar project is awesome. I do have the largest residential solar system in Mono County, so anyone that wants to talk to me about that, please feel free. I think that we need a minimum of two.

1:42:32 Cooperatives in town because if you only had one there would be issues of quality if the person who has the permit didn't really care about that. There could be price issues and I think that it would cause more problems than it would help if you only had one. The next thing I'm going to say is that one of the things that I think is very important with this ordinance is that we need to be able to protect the safety of

1:43:03 So, I just think that whatever we can do to protect the safety of the police officers and the safety of the growers is

1:43:33 Very, of a very high concern and very important part of this process. And Randy and I have been talking about that a bit and we'll see where we can go with that. The next thing is I just, I want really everybody in this town since I came out publicly about myself being a medical marijuana patient to know a couple things. Both Tony Barrett and myself were the

1:44:03 Two of the main people that were involved with the fluoride vote that happened about five years ago. We successfully kept synthetic fluoride out of the water in Mammoth. In the last five years, there's been quite a few reports that have been published by the American Medical Association and the ADA, American Dental Association, calling to get fluoride out of the water to no longer give it to any infant.

1:44:30 So you can thank myself, Tony Barrett, Deb, and several other people, John Backer, who's no longer with us, for making that happen. And these are the same people.

1:44:58 So it's not like we're just a bunch of stoners that want to have the best weed that we can possibly get. We have a track record of showing that these health-related issues are important to us and important to our community.

1:45:23 And here we are once again going to a public vote on a health-related issue. And what is the similar thread between these two things, the fluoride issue and the cannabis issue? Well, the similar thread is the deception that has been given to us by the large corporations, large industries that make huge amounts of money off these things happening the way that they do. The fertilizer industry for the fluoride.

1:45:54 And the pharmaceutical industry specifically in the cannabis side. So I know there's a lot of older people in this community that would just rather shut their ears and not know the truth about the medicinal benefits of cannabis. But hopefully through this election process we will be able to educate people in this town and then, hey, everybody can make up their own mind on the issue. So once again I'm going to say that I am a solution for this town.

1:46:25 And in conclusion, I just want people to know that

1:46:57 You know, we're looking out for, we're really looking out for the good here. We, we do not like deception from large corporations. That is the group of people here that you're dealing with. All right, thank you. Thank you, Steve. Questions for Steve? Steve? Steve, hold on. I'm going to start, skip over here. I'm going to start with,

1:47:24 Asking you this question, it's also kind of going to come back around to staff again, but I fully agree with you on the deceptions of the pharmaceutical companies and all that. But I also have some concern and want to kind of get your thoughts on how do we address situations where we have the physicians that find it a lot easier and a lot more profitable to just simply sit behind a desk and write prescriptions to people than to actually take the time.

1:47:52 You know, to do it kind of in the proper way to run the tests or do whatever they need to do to get this out because I have already seen a situation with a doctor in this town, a gentleman I believe who worked for the doctor giving a 21-year-old girl a card and making it quite clear that he kind of had this.

1:48:10 And was trying to sort of get her to go along with him on this. So how do we address, I mean, the other side of this, because we do have the responsible doctors that do it. Sure. Have you heard anything about how the AMA or how communities address this issue? Well, I think you have to realize that we're all individual people. I'm not the person that is giving those prescriptions via Skype to local patients.

1:48:37 You know, that's not my choice of how I want to be involved with this industry. So we each have to be treated as individual people. And if he is doing something illegal, then I think it's up to the local police department to enforce that. Okay. So then I'll come back around in discussion and discuss how we may want to address that issue. I want to do everything 100% legally. I mean, when I first stood up here.

1:49:02 What was it, four months ago, three months ago? That's what my intention's been the whole time. I understand that and I respect that and I agree with what you're doing, you know, but I just want to make sure that we, I think, and I also think in moving forward to put this on the bow, the community will feel more comfortable if we have something in place to address situations that may arise once this passes, I assume it will. Yeah, I think that we should have as many things in the ordinance as we can as long as they're legal.

1:49:32 Correct. You know, there's some things that you might want to put in there that aren't, so you can't put those in. Of course. So, but as far as the guy who is writing the local scripts, I don't know what to say about that, because I just don't know that much about that side of the industry. Okay. I just thought you might have heard something, but that's fine. Thank you. Any other questions? Testimony in general. Hearing none. Anybody, there's no rebuttal.

1:50:03 So I'll close the public hearing and Thank you. Council deliberation. Want to start? Well, I'll just pick up and direct my question to staff as to finding out. You know, I support the change in what we're doing here on this agenda bill, but I think we need to have a parallel track to be prepared for issues coming up so we're not kind of faced with something and having to take months to figure out how to handle it. Does anyone have any?

1:50:33 suggestions Peter or Rob is to does the AMA or anyone else have then you know routes that we can take to file complaints or concerns you know I think that's something we have yet to research and then the other line of research is to find out how other communities are handling these issues because I think all across the state of California all the communities are struggling with the same issues the doctors

1:51:03 Answer to the Board of Medical Quality Assurance in California, the licensing agency, similar to the state bar for lawyers, and they usually act on complaints, and so if we have some reason to believe that there are violations, complaints can be made by virtually anyone, and then the board would have to decide whether or not to commence an investigation, and if so, how to proceed after that. Okay.

1:51:33 Before you continue, I have a similar concern. I was just wondering, you know, a doctor or a lawyer needs a business license to function in the town of Mammoth Lakes. What if we felt that the person was abusing this prescription privilege? Do we yank their business license or are we preempted? Well, I think our business license ordinance is non-regulatory.

1:52:00 It's a revenue ordinance, not a regulatory ordinance, and you get into an entirely different world if you get into regulatory ordinances. I think the answer to that is as things stand, if there were violations of law and you could prove them, sure, but then, of course, you probably can get a verification of a medical license, too. Yeah. I'd sure like to hear more about that. I'm sorry. Okay. Yeah, slightly different line of questioning.

1:52:29 So if this passes and we allow for two cooperatives, what if we get five permits? How do we handle determining who actually gets the permits and can operate the cooperative? We don't know yet. When we start, we're very well progressed in the development of the next more development standards ordinance. It could be that there's a lottery or, you know, some mechanism, but there has to be a fair...

1:52:58 Equitable way to deal with that. So maybe if I could just ask that that's included in the development of the next ordinance or at some, wherever the appropriate place is to address that so that we have some criteria or standards. Mr. Mayor, may I know? Yes. So when the in the ordinance, thus far which one, the one that's two that will be developed, thank you. There are such things that the applicant

1:53:24 We'll have to go through a background check, as will their employees. And the employees are actually volunteers. They're considered volunteers of the cooperative. Produce business plans. You know, there's all these checklists they're going to have to go through in order to make it to the use permit base. The planning commission, then, we're just going to have to go through all of the applicants and see who is best qualified by what they've turned in. That's how we're looking at it right now. So there will be a set of criteria for qualifying. Exactly.

1:53:53 As a cooperative. And I think the good thing to remember also is this is only a one-year permit. So the applicant, the operator of the cooperative is going to have to go through the entire process each and every year. So there's also language in there that states they must start that process at least 60 days before expiration of their current use permit to get through the process. I think the background checks are important. And also with the employees, they're having background checks. There's also going to be language in there that

1:54:22 If there is a violation committed, either by distribution to somebody without a card or, you know, something that is illegal and the chief of police or the police department, you know, acknowledges that by way of fine or arresting them, we can revoke that instrument. So, as I said, very strict language is going into it to protect the community. You know, our first priority was protecting the children in the community along with our whole community. So I think all of the questions you have, you'll see,

1:54:54 Having covered when the ordinance is released to you. Thank you. John? Joe? Well, under deliberation, I didn't until this afternoon, I didn't see the necessity for having more than one because I'm looking at this as compassionate treatment of a group of people that feel that they need to do a certain thing that's not prohibited by state law. And so I didn't see the necessity for having two.

1:55:28 Tony, and then just now Steve, I think presented some pretty good arguments as to why there should be two. I haven't heard any arguments at all as to why it needs to be in commercial general. To me, it should be in the industrial zone only, and I don't think the commercial general is really suited to our vision statement for this kind of an occupation occurring in that zone.

1:55:56 So just something to think about. Comment? You know, we had that discussion at Planning Commission, so maybe I don't want to speak from that point. But, you know, the industrial park, if you think about it, there's right now there are two available spaces in the industrial park, both of which are not 500 feet apart. So, you know, we have to keep in mind that whoever is going to be the operator is going to either have to lease or purchase a space.

1:56:29 You know, the two available units down there, there's actually three, but one is a storage unit. So right there, you're going to limit it to one. We changed the feed from 1,000 feet to 500 so that we could allow both of them to be in the industrial park. And that came about because Ted Carlton stood up and said, well, wait a minute. If somebody in the industrial park is, like, right in the middle of the park,

1:56:54 You could stop people on either side from going forward. We changed it to the 500. For a commercial general, we don't want it in our neighborhoods. It shouldn't be in the village. It shouldn't be in commercial lodging. So we're limited to Old Mammoth Road, 203, the back of Center Street. You know, if Steve is one of the applicants, which we think he would be, he may, adjacent to his building of Waveraib on the back of Center Street, have something there. So I think we have to allow for that.

1:57:23 And that was the point of putting it in. You know, we have to remember, too, when an applicant goes forward to Planning Commission, even though we say Commercial General and Industrial, the Planning Commission has the ability to say, let's say, for instance, somebody wants to go in at Mammoth Mall next to a Good Life restaurant. The Planning Commission has the ability to say, we don't believe that's an appropriate location. So we still have a lot of checks and balances to take care of it.

1:57:51 Yeah, and for that reason, Neil, I don't have any problem with the Commercial General because I think you're talking about a very small storefront or even second floor or whatever. I thought that Tony's response was very practical. I'll never question the wisdom of the Planning Commission again, Tony. Until I do. Until you do.

1:58:13 You and all people should feel better. Yeah. I thought it was a good point, though, Mr. Mayor, and I had actually thought about it, too, and from the standpoint of, you know, it is going to have blacked out windows and things like that. Is that what we...

1:58:25 You know, want to have on our street front retail and things like that. But I think you make a good point, Tony, that the Planning Commission has the discretion to determine whether or not the location is appropriate. And it sounds like that will be taken very seriously. And also, Wendy, too, just about the blacked out. When I say blacked out, it can end up being a painted mural. It could be like you have in the village where you've got the designs on it. It could be something like that, too. I think the Planning Commission will have that ability to state what it should be also.

1:58:50 Sure. Yeah. And my only point is that it doesn't necessarily contribute to an active or animated streetscape. And I agree with that. I've got the same concerns. Yeah. So, but I think it sounds like that can be handled. Okay. Any other further deliberation by council? If not, Mr. Mayor, I would make a motion that we choose option one, waive the reading, introduced by title only, attach ordinance, adopting zoning code amendment 2010-01.

1:59:18 To Metamunicipal Code, Section 17.20.030.C and 17.24.030.D and add Chapter 17.84 as recommended by the Planning Commission. Second. We have a motion and a second. Jamie, roll call, please. Oh, any further discussion? Roll call, please. Councilmember Bacon? Yes. Councilmember Harvey? Yes. Councilmember Sugimara? Yes. Mayor Coltan-Eason? Yes. Mayor McCarrick? Yes. Mayor McCarrick? Yes. Mayor McCarrick? Yes. Mayor McCarrick? Yes. Mayor McCarrick? Yes. Mayor McCarrick? Yes.

1:59:46 Thank you. Our second public hearing is introduction of an ordinance repealing the utility users tax sunset clause and setting the tax rate subject to ratification by the voters. And I'll go ahead and open the public hearing and ask for a presentation by staff. Thank you, Mayor, members of the Town Council.

2:00:07 At the next Town Council meeting on March 3rd, we're planning to bring forward proposed language to you to put the utility users tax on the ballot, and that language would indicate that the voters are being asked to approve an ordinance which extends the utility users tax or, alternatively, extends the utility users tax and lowers the rate.

2:00:33 In order to have an ordinance like that in place when you approve the ballot language, you can introduce either one or both of those ordinances this evening and then decide at the next meeting whether or not you want to adopt either one or the other or neither of them. I would like to say that this is not a mandatory legal requirement, but from a timing perspective, it seems to make more sense to have an ordinance adopted on the 3rd.

2:01:01 If you're going to add language to the ballot. And introducing either one or both of these ordinances tonight doesn't bind you to adopting either one of them if you choose not to on March 3rd. So unless you have any questions, that's the staff report. Okay, any questions from staff? Okay. Testimony for those people wishing to speak in support, wishing to speak in opposition, wishing to speak.

2:01:35 Would you like to stand up and walk around for a while? Carlton. I'm looking at the preliminary poll results, this memo that came before the meeting. How many people did they actually survey? They surveyed a total of 200 people, and I think 50 of those were voters, so there's a separate voter sample and resident sample. Okay, and there was 16 grand, right?

2:02:12 Oh, for the price, yes. Yeah. Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Ted. As a follow-up question with Ted, do we know this evening how the question or questions were stated, the wording? I do, but I don't recall exactly right off the top of my head. But the nature of the first question was whether or not the voter supported

2:02:42 Strongly supported, opposed, or had no opinion on the measure. They then asked a series of questions about arguments in favor and arguments opposed, and then they asked the question again and got two different results based on that input. In other words, once the people that responded recognized what benefit the money would be used for, it swayed their answer.

2:03:13 Yeah, it was interesting. Some of the questions, and this will be, there will be an extensive presentation of this by Godview Research at the next meeting, but some of the questions were those kinds of questions, and others were questions that related to the kinds of arguments people would make against extending it. So they heard both sides of the story, at least from some perspectives. Were they asked the question about what percentage? About? About 2% or 2.5? No, they weren't. Okay. Okay.

2:03:48 So actually, I have a follow-up question to that then. So was the implicit assumption in the questions that were asked that it would remain at 2.5%? Yeah, one of the questions was would you be more likely to vote for this if you knew that it was no increase in the current tax? And I think they had previously said that it was 2.5%. So yeah, it was sort of implicit that there would not be a decrease. Having said that, we provided two options here, and you can introduce both tonight if you like.

2:04:16 But the last time when we extended the utility users tax and put it to the voters, we also gave them a lower rate, which I think was appreciated. So I think that's something you'll need to sort out at the next meeting. Great. I just asked, Rob, what are the consequences if we were to select option three? Does it change timing or anything that... No. Introducing both ordinances really gives you...

2:04:49 It preserves two options for you at the next meeting, so that might be the best alternative. Yeah, I was just going to say that is if we don't really have the details yet. My feeling on this, though, is we're still kind of going at it backwards is I would presume that we would have an idea of how we were going to spend the money and how much it would generate and then decide on the rate. And we haven't had that discussion yet.

2:05:14 So in that case, I would be in favor at this point of looking at option number three. Well, let me, before you, I'll go ahead and close the public hearing. Oh, I'm sorry, I thought you already did. No, no. Okay, now. Okay. You know, it's kind of like putting the cart before the horse is presuming that a certain percentage rather than saying this is what we would intend to spend it on and that's going to cost so much and therefore it would take X to fund it. I would rather see us going in that direction.

2:05:43 Since we don't have that, that's why I would be in favor of option three that gives us more flexibility, and I would ask that the presentation that we see at the next meeting really focuses not just on what came back from the survey, and I'm a little concerned if it's only 50 voters, or I guess they call them people who are expected to vote, but I think we need to be focusing first at the next meeting on

2:06:11 What it might be used for. Yeah, I agree with that. I mean, it feels a little...

2:06:19 I understand why we're doing it this way. It's just a timing issue, and we have the opportunity to not take any action at the next meeting. But the crux of the issue really is what is going to be funded. And then that's the question that's put before the voters as to whether or not that's important enough to the community that the community wants to support this tax. And so that question isn't the question that we're asking tonight. So it seems a little bit strange. So I agree with you, Jo. I think it would be wise to preserve both options, and then we can make that determination at the next meeting.

2:06:46 And move forward that way with the appropriate information in hand. John? I had a couple things I wanted to say. One is that I've done my own limited survey and have yet to find a local voter who would support an extension of this tax if it went towards funding of municipal services. That has...

2:07:12 directed me to asking questions of a couple of people about because it seems like there might be some level of support in the community. What level? I don't know if the money were directed towards some form of recreational capital project. There's a couple of worthy potential recreational capital projects.

2:07:42 That might fall into that category. So I would like to see staff sometime during the balance of this month to meet with a minimum of two individuals or their representatives to see if there's any possibility that they might have a capital project, recreational capital project that might fall and be receptive to this type of funding.

2:08:11 So I would suggest that town staff meet with either John Wentworth or a representative of his or both and Dina Castor or a representative of her organization and any other recreational organizations or individuals that we can think of within the next balance of this month to vet

2:08:39 them as possible uses for the funding if the tax were extended. And I also favor auction number three to give us the most flexibility and I go along with what John's concerns are because I've had calls from people along the same line. We know that we are deficient in infrastructure.

2:09:08 As far as our guests are concerned vis-a-vis our peer resorts. And so to give up any kind of an income stream that would help us along with that is just doesn't, it sets us back as far as competition is concerned with other peer resorts. So I think that makes a good point, John. So just to make sure I'm clear on this,

2:09:35 You guys were able to determine the kind of pulse of the community and people's feelings before the $16,000 survey results have even come in? What I'm saying, to answer your question, what I'm saying is that we're under a short fuse, obviously. We've talked about the date that we have to have this if we're going to have it on the ballot in June. So I'm saying that rather than going down one track,

2:10:03 That we need to find out if there is another potential track and get that vetted beforehand. I also want to clarify, Skip, because it's relevant. I personally do not, today, tonight, I personally do not support the extension of the utility users tax at any level for any time period.

2:10:33 Under any circumstances, because it is my personal opinion that the people in this community, the people like myself and other people in the community, you know, I heard today that there is likely somewhere between 20 and 30 homeowners just in Mammoth Lakes who currently are 90 days or longer overdue in making their house payments.

2:11:02 So we're going to have an influx of additional foreclosures this summer in Mammoth Lakes. That's one example. The people that I know and the people that I associate with are struggling, whether it's struggling to make house payments, apartment rent payment, utility payments, buying food, whatever it is. Our economy for the workers in this community is not good. And if they can save two and a half,

2:11:32 Percent on their utility payments each month. That's a big thing to them. So to restate right now, I don't support this tax, extension of this tax under any circumstances. But I'm open-minded enough to be able to see what happens by the 1st of March. I, for one, skip and interested in hearing what the statistically valid survey has to say about what our community thinks.

2:12:03 I'm also interested in getting the information from the group of the commissions and some of the other people who have some recommendations to provide to us, and I'm just sorry that we don't have those yet to think on. The sooner the better. We'll have those by the next meeting. We'll make a motion that we approve option three. A motion? A second.

2:12:27 We have two seconds. Take your choice. I think we need to clarify the record on that one. As I understand it, the motion is to waive the first rating and introduce by title only of both ordinances which appear in the agenda bill. Ordinance listed as Exhibit A, and I'm going to read the title.

2:12:54 And introduced by title only, an ordinance of the Town Council and the people of the Town of Mammoth Lake State of California, repealing Municipal Code Section 3.44.180, extending the utility users tax and reducing the rate to 2% and also introducing by title only, Exhibit B, which is also Measure U, an ordinance of the Town Council and the people of the Town of Mammoth Lake State of California.

2:13:18 Repealing Municipal Code Section 3.44.180, extending the utility user tax of 2.5%. Is that correct? Is that acceptable to the motion maker? That clarification? That's what you're... You clarify, yes. The wording in option number three is a little bit too general. The problem is that by using the language of number three, it doesn't use the magic language that's required by law to introduce an ordinance. I'll amend my motion to what Peter said. Okay. I'll amend my second. Okay, Wendy. Okay.

2:13:47 We have a motion and a second. Roll call. Councilmember Bacon? Yes. Councilmember Harvey? Yes. Councilmember Sugimura? Yes. Mayor Patendista? Yes. Mayor McCarroll? Yes. Okay, we have several policy matters. I'd like to take the five-minute break before we get to them. Okay. Whether the Wildlife Committee has discussed this or has any comment.

2:23:13 Um, we, it was, it was not an agendized item. There was a brief question about it, um, this morning, um, just because Dan Dawson hadn't had a chance to read the agenda item and wanted to know about it. But, um, because it wasn't agendized, the Wildlife Committee did not actually have a formal discussion and come to a consensus on it. Any, uh, questions, uh, questions by members of the public, comments? Deliberation? Mr. John? Excuse me. Um,

2:23:51 My reaction was that this seems to be, to me anyway, a clear-cut, simple and beneficial change in our ordinance to both town residents and visitors as well. And it seems as well to be consistent with what has actually worked in prior previous seasons.

2:24:20 Historically, our animal control officer did not go through formalized officer's training, but he did go through a limited amount of training and also the animal control officer carried a weapon and issued citations as well. So it seems to me that it would be reasonable to have the same level of training as our

2:24:51 Animal Control Officer had, who was, I believe, a non-sworn position in animal control, which this would be a non-sworn as well, for a wildlife position for the town of Mammoth Lakes to provide the same level of authority. Is that a motion? I have a couple of more questions. I need a clarification on John's comment.

2:25:16 Is this inferring that the contract wildlife management officer would get PC 832 training? I was presuming it was not. Well, if I may under state law, it's required. Okay. But if we're going to deputize them, I don't know what that means, to be quite honest with you. I don't know if that waives the requirement.

2:25:42 My feeling is the requirement still exists to attend 832 training. Okay. Let me ask Randy, was that required of the animal control officer? Yes. Okay. All right. Okay. All right. Yeah. Yeah. And then the second thing is in that second paragraph of 6.08.010, in the second to last line, it says contract wildlife services officer, but it says management officer in the top. Does that need to be amended?

2:26:11 I'm sorry. Okay. On the second paragraph of the ordinance under the 6.08.010, it says deputage of service contract wildlife services officer, but the title says wildlife management officer. Should they not be consistent? They should be consistent. Okay. We'll make that change. Okay. I would prefer services officer because management is kind of the prerogative of fish and game, isn't it? But it's our wildlife management policy.

2:26:48 And who knows what it is. I just wanted it to be consistent. Why don't we just take that word out completely and just call it a wildlife officer? Sure. Sure. As long as the contract's in front of it, yeah. Minor detail. So to clarify on Joe's point, Peter, is the language in here sufficient to clarify that the level of training that's required for this particular contractor to meet the standards that... Right, but PC832, but...

2:27:19 The language in here is sufficient to make that. Okay. Okay. Can I? Yes. One of the things that I'm looking at here is that in light of our current budget and financial situation, the last paragraph on page two where it talks about the council desire to provide a badge and a uniform, I'm wondering if we should.

2:27:41 I think since we're using a subcontractor, and he may have his preference of what type of clothing he actually wants to wear, but that we do require some type of identification on him, that we would provide a badge and clothing identification at this time, such as patchwork, the patchwork and all that. And it's also important to understand that as far as a badge goes,

2:28:11 Only the chief of police in a department can order badges when you go to a company. So we can't expect our contractor to be able to go out and provide his own badge. That does have to be ordered through the town. That's just the law, and that's the way these companies work. So I think that at this time, if we just simply provide the identification patchwork for, you know,

2:28:36 A number of different options of clothing that he can put onto whatever clothing he wants, maybe four or five sets of it for winter, spring, summer clothing, that that would probably be sufficient for this time. In the future, and as we look at next year's budget, we may also want to look at actually making this a position of the town once again. But for now, with the contractor, I think we should maybe just start with the badge and the clothing identification pieces.

2:29:03 Don't people on Animal Planet have, like, makeup artists and all that stuff? Never mind. Mr. Mayor? Yes. You know, when I first read this agenda bill, my first reaction was that since it doesn't change the authority of, you know, the position,

2:29:25 That's where we've had most of our conflicts is over the authority of the position. So I'd like to see that resolved someday, but that's not what this agenda item is about. So if the questions are, you know, is it reasonable for the town to provide identification for the wildlife contractor, that seems fine for me. We'll have to amend, I think, the contract because I think the contract currently says that he has to provide his own. And maybe the way to do that is just for council to refer amendments to the contract back to the wildlife subcommittee because we have some

2:29:54 Changes that we need to make anyway based on our review of the last season. So maybe we could just incorporate that into there. And then the only real change in authority is citations, the ability to issue citations, and it doesn't change the authority on private property or U.S. Forest Service. So those are the questions before us. I think they're pretty simple. Yeah. And I think you're right, Skip, because for one thing, we know Steve wears tennis shoes, and I don't know if that fits with a uniform. Still. Mr. Mayor, I would make a motion that

2:30:24 We accept option one, waive the first reading and introduce by title only the attached ordinance, which creates the positions of wildlife officer and wildlife, I'm sorry, wildlife officer. Contract wildlife officer. And contract wildlife officer and pass to second reading. Have a motion, is there a second? Second. A motion and a second. Discussion, Joe? Discussion. Did that motion need...

2:30:53 Mr. Mayor, if I may, just a quick note, and I apologize.

2:31:22 I had a schedule, but yesterday I was in Reno to visit my brother who's in the hospital up there, and his nurse was a lady by the name of Kathy, and my brother had communicated to his nurse that he was, that my brother was a friend of Steve Searles in Mammoth Lakes, and the nurse, Kathy, apparently had seen the film, I don't know, is it Bear Whisperer or whatever? Yeah, and she asked my brother,

2:31:52 If she could have his autograph. That was important to this nurse in Reno. Did you give her yours? No. But I got instructions from my brother to come back to Mammoth to get Steve's autograph for his nurse. Matt? I got a similar situation. A friend of mine in Florida asked me to do the same thing. And I actually got it from Steve. It was some of the stickers with his autograph on it.

2:32:22 So, I mean. Pretty amazing. Yeah, it's, I think, I said it in the paper a little earlier, it's just really amazing how much rain I think Steve has made for us in this town and for us not to really embrace what he's doing. I mean, it's great from a wildlife standpoint, but also from an economic and marketing standpoint, I think we really need to embrace it and it's nice to hear that. We'll make the patches really big, Mammoth Lakes.

2:32:52 Okay, item number five, zoning code update status report on chapter 17.38, water efficient landscape regulations. Mayor, Council, at your February 3rd meeting, you asked for a report on the status of our updates to water efficient landscape regulations, primarily in response to some concerns that were expressed by Mr. Earl Henderson. After your meeting, I met with Mr. Henderson.

2:33:21 I listened to his concerns, and we've devised a program to address some of those. In addition to the state requirements that we have a water efficient landscape ordinance and actions specified in the general plan, we're also, as you know, working on our zoning code update. In our zoning code update program, we're doing a rigorous analysis of each

2:33:48 Important chapter of the code. And as we identify issues and conduct our research, we have a discussion with our zoning code users group to make sure that we've captured the bulk of issues known by the key users of the code and that the work that we're bringing forward is indeed customer-friendly, simple, clear, and ambiguous. Unambiguous. We don't want to be ambiguous.

2:34:13 And in this particular chapter, Mr. Greg Norby, the Executive Director of the Water District, and Mr. Henderson have agreed to sit with that group as we go through our water-efficient landscape requirements. With that, I'll answer any questions. Any questions? Just to thank you. Mr. Mayor, I have a question. It says that the State of California requires cities and counties to adopt landscape water conservation ordinances by January 1, 2010.

2:34:42 What happens, we didn't adopt one, so what happens? We do have one. Oh, we do. We have an existing section, it is your section 1738, and we wrote specifically to the Department of Water and notified then that that is in on the books and we think it implements that state requirement. We've received no comment from them. So this is an update, progressive update to those standards. Gotcha, thank you.

2:35:10 Any other comments or questions? Questions, comments from members of the public? I'm Earl Henderson. Number one, thank you, Council, for indulging me at the last meeting. Since June of 2007, I've been attending the town-sponsored workshops concerning this ordinance, and I was a little bit anxious to see that something moved ahead.

2:35:43 Really appreciate the fact that the board moved or the council moved so quick to get it ahead and Mr. Wardlaw for stepping up immediately to soothe my feathers a little bit that I had allowed to get ruffled and I apologize for that. But it's good to see it moving forward. But I do want to point out again out of the analysis here that I came forward representing the feelings of the Contractors Association in town.

2:36:12 Not as a board member for the water district. And as always, when I've come forward, it's been in representing my fellow contractors and how these things are affecting us. Again, thank you. And I'm glad to see this group before. Thank you, Earl. So, Earl, you'll be wearing two hats when you're in here. You'll be a water board member and you'll be representing the contractors? No.

2:36:36 Mr. Norley has things quite in hand. I'm just pulling your leg. I'm given the privilege of sitting on the liaison meeting with the water district in town and at that point in time trying to forward things from the water district's perspective. But my comments and questions and issues I raised were directly what I carried from the contractors' meetings.

2:37:01 For the two previous meetings that we had had prior to your council meetings. And you're willing to continue to do that in this group? I will do my best to try and maintain my enthusiasm. All right. Thank you very much. Thank you, Earl. Many other comments or questions? Yes. I wanted to thank Mr. Norby, first of all, for attending tonight, I think. Is this your first meeting? No. Is it your first council meeting? No.

2:37:28 No, he's been here before. Okay. Well, thank you, and also congratulations on being named the Director of the Water District. General Manager, thank you. Not over a year. Yeah. Really? Yeah. Okay. Having said that, Mr. Mayor, I'd like to move that the Town Council adopt option number one. Is there a second? I'll second.

2:37:59 Motion and a second. All those in favor? Aye. Unanimous. Item number six, general fund revenue update. Thank you, Mayor and Council. In Brad's absence, I'd just like to indicate that the town council adopted a balanced budget. The general fund is tracking, at this point, about $250,000 ahead of where we would expect at this time of year.

2:38:28 Also, our expenditures are tracking somewhat behind where we would expect to be this year, 54 versus 58 percent. And we have $7.8 million invested in the local agency investment fund. And if the council has any questions, I'd be glad to answer them. Any questions? Do we have any indications about January at all yet? Do we know?

2:38:55 Just anecdotal, the returns for the month of January come in at the end of February, and so we won't be seeing returns until pretty close to March 1st, and we really won't know until a week or so into March. So anecdotally, what have you heard? Well, things have looked good for January in the Mammoth Mountain Ski Area reports that we get, and also in the M-TRIP.

2:39:22 Tracking reports that we get. So it appears that we'll at least make budget in January. Thank you. Just as a point of clarification, when you say general fund revenues are tracking $250,000 ahead of what we would expect this time of year, we would expect a lot better. I mean, we budgeted for a recessionary year, so, I mean, you're $250,000 ahead of a

2:39:51 What, you budgeted 83% of TOT? So, I mean, come on, let's be realistic. Secondly, I noticed in the Register of Demands a $95,000 payment to Morrison Forrester and wanted some update as to the airport litigation. Yeah, do it now. That's fine. The airport litigation, the appeal continues to be pending in the Third District Court of Appeal.

2:40:21 The town has completed its briefing schedule. The parties have completed their briefing schedule. The town has filed its opening brief. The Hot Creek parties have filed their respondents' brief. The town then has the opportunity to file a reply brief. And that brief has been filed. The briefing is now completed. The court will now assign a three-judge panel. We will not know who that panel is.

2:40:48 The panel will then look at the record, look at the briefs, and in due course we'll schedule oral argument in Sacramento in the Court of Appeal courtroom. Peter, is it appropriate this evening to share the fact that we got the... Yeah, I can if you want. One thing that has happened is on last Wednesday,

2:41:19 There was a filing in the Court of Appeal in support of the town's position by the League of California Cities, which represents 474 California cities, and also by the California State Association of Counties, which represents all 58 counties in California. The League and CSAC filed an application to file a friend of the court brief, what's called an amicus curiae brief.

2:41:49 With the court, the application has been filed, the brief is attached to the application. The court has not acted on the application yet, but I have every reason to believe that the court will accept the brief for filing. It's extremely important. I've never heard of a league brief not being accepted, and to date there's no opposition to the filing of the brief, and I don't expect any. Normally the court of appeal would act on Wednesdays, but of course this Wednesday,

2:42:19 It is a furlough day for the Court of Appeals, so they're not there. So it may be later this week or it may be next week. And then Hot Creek would be given an opportunity to reply to the amicus brief. Basically what the amicus brief says is this is not just a gunfight between a city and a developer. This is something that has statewide importance and affects cities and counties throughout California.

2:42:48 And that the trial court has totally misinterpreted what the development agreement statute is and specifically asked the court of appeal to reverse the judgment of the trial court and rule in favor of the town. Thank you, Peter. Could I just add one more word? You know, I think this report is very important because what it's telling the council and the community is that we're spending less money than we're bringing in.

2:43:15 And as Brad had indicated in one of our last meetings, as far as the general fund goes, which is our operating fund that pays for ongoing costs like snow removal and street repair and police officers, for nine out of the last ten years, we've spent less than we've brought in. And the only exception to that was the draw that we made on the REU for the Hot Creek case a couple of years back. It's also true that during the course of the recession, we have spent more.

2:43:44 And so we've done about $42 million of capital improvements, not counting the Scenic Way, which is going to be coming up, and received $36 million in grants. And so as we came into the recession, the Council made a very conscious decision to stop some capital improvement projects because we couldn't afford to do them, but to keep others going forward by

2:44:12 Borrowing money internally and spending money that we had saved. So I think, you know, a statement that Brad made the last time he made this report that in nine out of the ten years in the past we received more money than we spent is accurate because it relates to the general fund and our ongoing expenditures. And I think it's also true that the council made the wise decision

2:44:36 To keep grant money alive in this town and to keep capital projects like the Lake Mary Road project going, even though that meant spending some money that was borrowed internally or saved up in past years. Yes, Wendy. I just kind of wanted to add on to what Rob said, because, you know, the purpose of a budget is not to try and achieve the amount of revenue that you've achieved in the past. It's to monitor responsible fiscal expenditures. And, you know, so to the extent that we're doing that in a

2:45:07 In a poor economic year is a good thing. And to say that we're not achieving revenues from the last economic boom, that's really kind of skewing what a budget is for and how it's to be used. So I think that Rob makes some good points in that paying attention to the realities of the economic situation and where we are at the moment really is a good way to handle this going forward. Yeah, Matt. When you say the revenues are,

2:45:44 Exceeding our expenditures, does that include the sale of real estate, our assets? No, it doesn't include any sale of real estate. Does it? No. Did we, in our last year's budget, we had budgeted for some income to come in off the sale of real estate. Did we end up selling that real estate? We actually, we proposed doing that, but the council did not approve that, and no, we have not sold that real estate. Okay. The real estate that we're most likely to sell,

2:46:11 Is that we purchased a piece of land for the hospital at the Civic Center. And they have an option to purchase that back. And that was done to help the hospital. We actually in that year had more general fund money than we needed. And so we took some of it and bought the parcel that the hospital couldn't afford and then gave them the option to buy it back within five years. So we're talking to the hospital right now.

2:46:35 I'm about the schedule for them making that payment. But at this point in time, no, that's not built into the budget, and no, we have not sold that yet. Okay. Thanks, Matt. Ted? I think one of the most important items when you look at your revenue is sales tax revenue, because that's really the health of your business community. We had an anemic year last year, and we're below that this year. So instead of all...

2:47:14 The hyperbole over the fact that you guys might be a little bit ahead. Others are behind. I probably should comment just a little bit on the sales tax. The way the state allocates sales tax is based on their estimate of what we're going to collect. And they estimate that, you know, we get several quarters of estimates before we get a true up. And so we believe that the amount of money that the sales tax is providing to us, which is quite a bit below, as Ted observed,

2:47:44 Is very, very conservative compared to what we'll actually get. And we will eventually get a true up, which we think will bring in more money. So our belief at this point in time, and that's not just our belief internally, it's also the belief of our sales tax consultant, HDL, is that we're seeing a lower amount come in through the state advances, and that when we receive the true up, we'll actually look a little bit better.

2:48:12 But I do think that Ted's general comment is correct, which is that sales tax has been hit harder, and that does indicate that there are businesses that are closed and businesses that are hurting in the community. Well, and I don't think there's any assumption by anyone on the council or any of the staff that, you know, the economic pain is over by any means. I think we all recognize that the economy is still sluggish and that it's going to be still a bit of a haul out.

2:48:39 You know, to make the assumption that we think that because we are meeting our budget isn't really fair. I'm concerned about sales tax. Absolutely. Well, we were concerned about it. We went to Bathroom Village one day, if you recall, and hopefully that will generate some sales tax. But there are a lot of vacant storefronts, and that's a real problem. Okay, any other comments or questions? Rob, help me if you would on the sales tax issue. The way I read...

2:49:09 Brad's report, and I may have misread it, on page two. The sales tax for the last quarter of 2009, which will be October, November, and December, is below $135,000, and it's almost impossible to know what that is going to be because it's been estimated by the state.

2:49:37 But isn't it also true that we will receive that payment by the end of March, by the end of this quarter from the state? Yeah, we get a monthly payment and then a quarterly reconciliation that's offset by one month, so you're exactly right. We'll get a true-up in March for the December. Yes. And is it possible that the amount of money, that might be about $130,000? It's pretty hard to tell. It may not be the whole...

2:50:07 $130,000, but I think it will be somewhere between $0 and $130,000. It's really going to depend on activity. The state, when they do their estimates, they're looking at a statewide basis. And the makeup of the statewide sales tax base includes a lot of automobile sales and things like that that aren't true here. So the mix is a little bit different. So when our consultants look at sales tax in Mammoth, they're looking at a little bit different makeup than what you would see statewide.

2:50:35 We end up having a funny outcome. Okay. Thank you. I just wanted to make one more comment, and that is that, you know, last year, and correct me if I'm wrong, Rob, but last year, we took the biggest financial hit in this quarter coming up, January, February, March. It's our biggest quarter for TOT revenues, and so, you know, just, you know, we have a good, reasonable picture right now. You know, these are the facts, the numbers.

2:51:02 But, you know, I, for one, am not making any assumptions about what the fiscal year turns out to be. And that's why I was asking if there was any information about January, even if it was anecdotal, because we still need to keep responsibly monitoring our budget and paying attention to what's going on. Well, as was said, though, the figures we get from Mammoth Mountain, they show that Mammoth Mountain's year is on budget. And those are pretty close to real time. That's pretty terrific, because they were way under budget last year at this time. That's true.

2:51:32 And that kind of, it's kind of the canary in the mine because that hits us three months later, their court figures, so that's why it's so helpful. All I'm saying is that we're continuing to be prudent. Yeah. Mr. Mayor, I had one more comment, if I could, on the amicus curiae brief, the friend of the court brief, that I should have said, and that is that I did request the brief from the League of California Cities and from the State Association of Counties.

2:52:00 However, the town did not pay for that brief, did not write the brief, and it was prepared and filed at no cost to the town. Thank you, Peter. And thank you for doing that, Peter. I think that's going to be a huge benefit to us. Any chance we can get the oral argument over in Mammoth like we did on the...

2:52:24 I think I'll ask them for one in favor at a time. We were thinking if we had a hotel at the airport that would work great. Okay. Okay. Okay. Consent agenda. Do I have a motion to approve item number eight? So moved. Second. Motion and a second. All those in favor. Oh, wait a minute. This is a roll call. What is it? Yeah, it's a roll call. Yeah.

2:52:49 Please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Unanimous. Item number seven. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. I did ask that this be pulled. I had some concern over this because since the last meeting I was able to watch the

2:53:10 Video of the meeting and it clearly there isn't anything in the motion and I'm on page six of the minutes item 410-30 where it is the motion and there wasn't anything in the motion that referred to amending the town's story poll policy plus as I heard the motion that night there were terms such as rename the policy to something

2:53:38 That more accurately reflects. Clarify that the policy applies. Revise and clarify the methods. And add a section that addresses. And when I hear terms like that, I expect that changes are going to be made and that the final rendition of the policy will be brought back before council. And that is what I expected. And to have the term amended in there.

2:54:06 Kind of says that somebody's going to go out and just make changes and we would never know what those changes actually were, but yet we would be responsible for upholding that policy and that's something I would not be comfortable with and I certainly would not have seconded that motion if I thought that was the intention of it. Do you want to work with staff between now and our next meeting and go over the tape and find out what...

2:54:32 What wording is appropriate? Well, I think what we could do is if we want to go to the tape, we could have the tape just done. It's not a long motion, but to make this motion correct, it could be taken verbatim off of the tape. I don't think that would be that difficult to do. Just do that. And I also want to, though, be sure that this policy is brought back before council for final approval. Comments or discussion?

2:55:03 It was also my understanding, and I had not listened to it, but I thought we discussed seeing a red line version. So as the motion maker, perhaps I can clarify, I used some of the words that Skip mentioned in the motion because I didn't want a wordsmith from the dais. I don't feel that that is often very beneficial. And I think there was a discussion during council deliberation about whether or not the policy should be brought back to us.

2:55:32 And there wasn't, there wasn't, we didn't, okay, well, in either case, that wasn't part of the motion that I made, and it wasn't necessarily my intention for that, but if there's a desire on behalf of the council, then I think that that's council's prerogative to ask that it be appropriate. Can always bring it back. Yeah, as a red line version, but there wasn't any intention in the motion to necessarily state that as an objective of the motion, and I feel that.

2:55:58 You know, my motion, it may not have been captured verbatim, but that the essential spirit of it was captured properly. So if you want to, you know, request that it be put in there verbatim, you know, that's accurate as well. And then if council members want to bring back the policy to take a look at it, then that's council's prerogative to ask to take a look at the amended policy. That's kind of my feeling on it. Does that make sense?

2:56:25 That makes sense. And if we're going to bring it back, then we'll change the motion and pass the minutes, and then we will see on a future agenda that final policy coming back to Council for discussion. But the onus is on you or one of the other four of us to agendize that.

2:56:43 I'll do it on a future agenda. So Skip, if you ask me, I'll put it on. I'd like to have it on a future agenda. Skip, is it okay with you to leave the language like it is? I mean, I feel like it reflects what I said, even though it's not verbatim, or just to eliminate any sense of controversy, should we just go back and write it in verbatim? I think your bullet points are accurate, so if we take out the – if we somehow just rephrase, take out that word to amend the story pool policy, because I just –

2:57:13 That sounds like it's a final done deal. So to review and change the town story pool policy to include the following, that would be fine. Okay. Review and what? Change. Just review the town story pool policy to include the following changes, as it says there. Yeah. Yeah. Okay.

2:57:41 We now have a motion to approve the minutes as amended. And so we have a motion to approve the minutes as amended. Is there a second? Second. Motion and a second. All those in favor? Aye. Okay. Item number nine. Yes, I asked this to be pulled because I think it's an important issue that I did not want to see buried on the consent agenda. And then I also understand that Dana had some additional information.

2:58:08 About this pay first ruling and online travel agencies. I just wanted to comment that at the federal level this type of legislation was trying to be pushed through Congress very similar to what was being done here at the state level. The U.S. Travel Association came out against it the same way that we're asking you this evening to voice your opposition to this at the state level. And the reason that the U.S. Travel Association came out against this, and if you think about it,

2:58:38 They're speaking out against their OTAs, which is a significant part of our travel industry, but their reason for coming out against it is because of the need for local municipalities and governments to access these funds through the collection of the TOT and realizing that this type of a legislation done at the federal level could have damaging effects to city budgets across the country.

2:59:03 So I just wanted you to know that at the federal level, U.S. Travel Association is opposing this, and we would encourage you to obviously oppose it here at the state level. This has also been brought forward and discussed and provided information to you with the local lodging association as well, so that they're aware of this opposition too. Thank you, Dana. For the benefit of the public, could you give us a real short synopsis of this? Sure.

2:59:32 What's been happening across the country is that online travel services such as Expedia and Orbitz and that nature of travel company charge an individual for a room and collect hotel tax based on the amount that they charge the person for the room. Then when they come to our local hotel operator,

2:59:58 They take their cut first and give the local hotel operator a smaller amount. So they might charge $150 for a room and give our local operator $100. They collect the 13% TOT on the $150, but they only give the hotel operator enough to pay on the $100, and the hotel operator pays on $100. This is happening throughout the country, and so there's a class action suit, which we actually are a party to, where we're trying to collect that.

3:00:29 And if they win, they can get a refund. This legislation is trying to

3:00:58 Take that right away from the municipalities and say, no, if you dispute a tax bill, you don't have to pay the disputed amount until after the thing's resolved. And for us, that's not a huge amount, but for many other cities, it is a huge amount, especially in a budget time. So as Dan has said, there's pretty strong opposition to this kind of legislation. On the other hand, the legislation is being funded by the online companies, and so the League has asked for cities to weigh in.

3:01:27 In opposition to it. Thank you. I think, Dana, did you have something to provide one clarification on that relative to the relationship between the OTAs and the lodging properties? The lodging properties provide a negotiated rate to the OTAs, so what Rob was explaining where the hotel provides a rate to OTA, then OTA turns around and marks up their share, their margin that gets marked up, and they

3:01:55 are not collecting the TOT on that, or they're retaining that TOT on their markup. I just want to verify or confirm or clarify that the hotels have an agreement with the OTAs on the rates that they're paying. And that's due to a volume that the OTAs generate, which is why many properties go with an OTA is to get that type of exposure. But they're not, the OTAs are not

3:02:19 If you will, taking money away from the lodging property based on the rate the property has negotiated with OTA. So I just wanted to make sure we were clarifying that. Okay. Okay. Then in that case, I will move approval of option one. Seconds up. Motion and a second. All those in favor? Aye. Opposed? Unanimous?

3:02:42 I also asked for 9A to be... Joe, sorry, before you start, I'm going to recuse myself for appearances purposes as potential funding comes through the local transportation funds and sometimes my county funding comes from 9A. All right. I asked how this pulled because the agenda bill speaks to a meeting which Tourism and Rec Commission apparently had yesterday and wanted to get a little more information on that first so that we may know that...

3:03:13 Do we have a project? We do have a project and I believe you have an updated resolution. Okay. This item was discussed at the Tourism Commission, Tourism Recreation Commission early in December and then the early meeting in February was canceled which is why the meeting occurred yesterday. Yesterday we did provide the commission at that meeting additional information they requested with a matrix to look at several different options for the grant application.

3:03:42 It included an amphitheater project, maybe at Mammoth Creek or Civic Center site. It also discussed maybe the bell-shaped parcel. It also included discussion of additional tennis courts up at the community center park and then completion of the ice rink cover at the ice rink facility. With that, there's cost estimates and kind of where staff thought it might weigh in on where the points might be for this particular application. The application.

3:04:11 Is really set up for urban city, which we're not, and an urban city which has a low income element, extremely low income element, which we're on the high end of having a low income population. So, you know, from a rating standpoint, we have a lower probability of getting the grant application. So, but the tourism commission did...

3:04:37 Select the completing the ice rink cover, and so we're calling that the Mammoth Lakes Multi-use Activity Center. Okay, so it is the, used as an ice rink in the winter. Right. Okay. All right. And, you know, we've been working with the state on re-scoping the existing grant we have for $500,000 that was really for the multi-use facility, which was a significantly bigger project. They're in agreement.

3:05:04 We don't actually have the contract signed yet, but the agreement that reducing the scope to include the slab would be appropriate, and they will support that, and they also indicated that they would support an application, an ongoing application for what they call another project, which would in this case be a cover. The grant application would also include sufficient funds to acquire the land, so if the school district wanted to sell it to us. Oh, okay. So it's about $3 million.

3:05:31 I know, you know, I'm not holding you up for the Olympics any longer, John, but that's, I think that's really important, and I'm glad that the DNR Commission chose that as one of our unfinished projects. So with that, I will move that we adopt option one. Let's second that.

3:05:55 Motion in a second. Further discussion. Roll call. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Any questions on the Register of Demands? I had one, Mr. Mayor. Yes. It was brought up earlier this evening on the town's payment to Morrison and Forster for the $95,000. Is that within budget?

3:06:19 Yes, the flow of money was very high because they were preparing the briefs during this period. So there are times when they're very active and times when they're not active. And this falls within the budget that we have for that. It does. Yeah. Okay. Thank you. Okay. Any other questions? Okay. Is there a closed session? That's why you need a DVR.