Town Council
· recording 2 hr 23 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
307 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:31 Council to order, or in the immortal words of, I think it was Willie Brown or Willie Nelson, I can't remember which, but the rights and liberties of the people are now in jeopardy, the legislature's in session. We'll call, please. I've been aching to say that. Councilmember Harvey? Here. Councilmember Sugimura? Here. Councilmember Sugimura? Here. Mayor Pro Tem, Easton? Here. Mayor McFarrow? Here. John, would you leave us? I'd be happy to. Please join me. I pledge allegiance to the flag.
1:05 Thank you, John. Now's the time for public comment on matters not appearing on our agenda. Any public comment? Good evening, Mr. Mayor and council members in public. I'm here to advise that we're in a...
1:40 We're in a shutdown mode for the ice rink effective tonight, basically. A pipe broke yesterday, a four-inch pipe broke yesterday, and unfortunately it's in a location that's not going to allow us to repair it before we were scheduled to close next Sunday, March 14th. So the weather conditions tonight weren't going to allow anybody to be out there tonight. We will go back out and clear it in the morning based on the weather, and if it's...
2:08 If the ice is still holding up, we will still operate tomorrow, but we would anticipate that tomorrow is our last day for the ice skating rink. With that, though, I would like to advise you, we had 8,106 users, skater sessions, visits to the rink this year, which is an increase of almost 2,500 from last year.
2:32 We operated much longer this year. We did not have mechanical breakdowns as we did last year. So all in all, a successful event or a successful season for the ice rink. And we're sorry that the pipe broke and we're sorry that we have to end it a few days early. But we will make an official notice tomorrow, but just to advise that the ice rink will be shutting down. Thank you, Dana. Dana, quick question. I'm sorry. Just a curiosity question.
3:01 In the past we've had a number of hockey players, adult, are they still using the rink this year? They were. Their use is down about 30 over last year. And we did see an increase in our youth by about 30 over last year. So the youth offset the adults. But we had still significant, or...
3:25 231 counts as of this weekend of adult hockey, men's hockey. We had 76 youth hockey throughout the season, and we had 35 women's sessions of hockey. Women were down just a little bit. I think it's because we changed their schedule just a little bit as well. So you changed the men's schedule also? We went back to having men two nights a week, and women shared with the youth in the middle of the week. Thanks, Dana.
3:56 Any other public comment? Hearing none. Council reports. Wendy, you want to talk? I've just had a couple of meetings with Joe on the Mammoth Lakes Recreation, Mammoth Regional Recreation Council, whatever you want to call it, recreation reorganization issues. Both talking about the larger recreation reorganization that we're calling Mammoth Lakes Recreation and then
4:27 Also how we're going to approach the reconciliation process with figuring out how the recreation reorganization fits together with the DMO. John? I just had one item. I got an email about three weeks ago from Mark Davis, and he was concerned with the lack of opportunity for public comment as it relates to the Tioga Pass overlay and rehab project.
4:58 So I've been in communication with Mono County to see if they could get the Park Service to come over and take public comment from this side of the Sierras, and I was happy to report. I got an email yesterday from Larry Johnston. Larry is here. And I wanted to thank Larry publicly for getting on top and staying on top of this issue. Through the efforts of Mono County, the Park Service now has agreed to have a brief presentation.
5:27 On this rehab project, an overlay at the Mono Basin RPAC meeting, which is next Wednesday, a week from tonight, 6.30 in the Levining Community Center, if anyone's interested in attending. It's not technically a scoping meeting, but it will give an opportunity for the public to make comments on this important project on Tioga Road. So, thank you, Larry. Thank you, John. Did I skip? I have nothing.
5:57 Jo? Actually, I'd like to take this time to remind everyone that the census is coming up and that there are jobs available to be census takers. I put some cards in the back. Rebecca Garrett asked me to just give a little bit of information. They're looking to hire people working mid to late April. They need lots of census takers. It's $15 an hour with 50 cents a mile, so that's not bad in that shoulder season.
6:26 Giving tests at the library, there's an 800 number on those cards back there. It's also 866-861-2010. There's an application, an aptitude test, and a background check, and there's even a sample test online so you can practice up. And there are many more people needed, and especially bimingual applicants. Thank you, Jo. I just have one meeting to report. Actually, Skip and I attended the Public Arts Commission meeting.
6:57 I know that, you know, there's been some controversy in the paper concerning this monument sign at the entrance to town. And, you know, it's very difficult to do that sign justice by taking a picture and putting it in the paper. So staff, Sandra Moberly at the Community Development Department has the actual materials that the sign's going to be composed of.
7:23 In her office. So I would invite the public, anybody who has interest in that sign should stop by and take a look at the actual composition of it because it is quite unique. There isn't another sign like that anywhere in the world. It's not like an industrial park sign. It's not like the Irvine sign. And the more you learn about it, I think the better you'll like it, I would hope. But Sandra does have the materials.
7:53 Additions to the agenda? Anybody have an addition or pull anything from the consent agenda? Yes, I would like to pull items 12 and 13. 12 and 13. Anybody else? Okay. Consul presentation, 2010 Mammoth Lakes Community Priority Survey. Rob? Thank you, Mayor, members of the council. I'd like to introduce Brian Godby of Godby Research. Godby Research is one of the leading...
8:23 Polling companies in the state of California helping communities with their tax measures and also with their resident satisfaction surveys, among other things. We've budgeted about 45 minutes for Brian to go over the polling results. You have the slides in your packet, and he has the slideshow ready to go here. But in reviewing this, we found it to be very interesting and useful information, and so I hope you do too. Thank you. Brian, welcome.
8:51 Thank you, Rob. Thank you, Mr. Mayor, members of the council and the public. I'm happy to be here to present the results of the survey this evening. I hope you do find it interesting. I'm going to dive right in. There's no other further things to talk about. As Rob alluded to, the purpose of this was to look at both a community survey and in that context, we've got resident satisfaction, quality of life, satisfaction with town services, those sorts of things.
9:19 To look at some development. Excuse me, Brian. Can somebody turn the lights down, please, so we can see it better? So we can see it very? Yeah, see it very. Thank you. Not quite that far. Great. Thank you. Also looking at some various residential and commercial development directions and what people are looking for in that area. And then moving into the utility user.
9:55 Thank you. Thank you.
10:25 So that's the purpose of the survey. I'm going to talk a little bit more about the methodology than just the slide here might suggest. But overall, we did a telephone survey, which is still state-of-the-art, even in an Internet world. And there's a real simple explanation for that. We don't know all the email addresses of the voters. And if we were to just post an email or an Internet survey...
10:48 And part of what that rigor is, is looking at the population. And in this case, we did 200 completed interviews, and we split it into two parts. One was 157 responses, completed interviews that were from voters, and then the remainder were from
11:18 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
11:47 And, well, that's a good string of characteristics, represents a certain portion of the population. Let's say it's 10%. So what that means, if Republicans, 30 to 39 males, are 10% of the population, I'm just using this as an example because the math is using, that means that out of 157 completed interviews, we need to have 15 and a half or 16 interviews that match that.
12:13 String of demographic characteristics. What we do in the sampling is called stratification, and how we do that is we basically say we need 16 completed interviews from these type of people, and we create 16 buckets, if you will, and then we randomly sample the people like that into those buckets, so that when we're making calls, we start with the first person in the bucket, and we call that person, in this case him, a couple times, and we don't get him, then we go to the second person.
12:41 They've all been randomly selected, but the replacement for the first person is random based on the strata that the original person represented. So that makes sure that based on partisanship, ethnicity, age, gender, that we are representative of the voter population. And that's how we deal with the 157 voters. The other just short of 50 residents, that's from what's called a random digit dial sample.
13:08 And that's a different kind of sample. What that is is we look at the phone exchange and we randomly create phone numbers. But we take out the phone numbers we have from the voters because we know we're going to call them on the voter side. So we're looking for people who their phone number isn't registered to vote. And then we call those folks that are left and ask them if they're registered to vote. If they are, we take them out of the list because we know we'll talk to them on the other side of the sample.
13:33 And so we're drilling down to get just those non-registered residents in that last 47, 43 respondents. That sampling methodology is based on just a complete random replacement.
13:48 And then at the end of that, we look at the demographics of the population, we look at the demographics of the voter population, we make sure that we're correct based on our stratification approach, and then we come back and we wait it if we need to a little bit. And there's always some waiting because not everybody is available to take the call. So that's how the sampling works, and that's how we get 200 interviews that we can say, the voter portion, we have a plus or minus 8% error rate for the...
14:16 Non-voter portion, we have a plus or minus 7% error rate. We did complete the 157 and the additional items to get to the 200, and we did the interviews in both English and Spanish. It was 18 minutes long and we were in the field at the beginning of February. Any questions about the methodology? And that's always the hardest part. Okay, great. So, first, if you're allowed to ask questions or no. Okay, go ahead. Thank you, Mr. Allen.
14:51 Since I don't know anyone under 40 who has a home phone, I'm wondering, do you have a demographic survey of the average age of who you called, and then also the average income? Yes, we do have that information. The solution to that problem, the cell phone problem, and it is a growing problem throughout the country for telephone surveys, is in the voter registration file. The voter file asks people if they would provide their phone number.
15:20 And while most of us, like me, who are unlisted and can't convince my wife to get rid of our landlines and just use our cell phones, we don't put that phone number down. But the younger voters, who are cell phone-only households, do in fact put that number down.
15:39 And so it is reflected in the voter file, and it is stratified by age, and so we make sure we get those younger people, but the way we get many of them, not all of them, but many of them is because we are calling that cell phone. Now, the misnomer is that you can't call a cell phone for marketing or market research. That's actually not true. The federal law is you can't call a cell phone for marketing or market research from what's called a predictive dialer.
16:05 A computer dialer, for lack of a better term. But you can if you dial by hand. And because those people are, in fact, important to us, we do dial those numbers by hand. We dial all of the phone numbers by hand because we get a better response rate. We eliminate the problems of that robo-dialer by using the old-fashioned finger metal. So we do take into account the cell phone only household. And, Brian, just to add to that, Ted, I'm under 40 and I have a home phone.
16:34 I guarantee you I'm not. There are some and
16:41 It varies depending on the community. Nationwide, it's about 12% of the population, but in communities that are younger and communities that are more technology-oriented, the number is higher, but no one really knows what it actually is in reality because the only way we know it nationwide is because of the survey that's done nationwide among cell phone users and phone users by the mega research organizations. Okay, so...
17:10 I'm sorry. I don't have it here, but we do have it. Well, I mean, okay. The reason I think this is important. Hold on. We'll wait to get up here, Ted, because they can't hear you at home. Well, the reason I think the average income question is important is because we're talking about a tax, ultimately. And I want to know if the workforce in this community is being adequately represented in this survey or whether we're just surveying people who can afford whatever you put in front of them.
17:40 Brian, that's Ted Carlton from the local newspaper. Sure. Actually, I was incorrect. We did not ask income on this. It's not a routine question for us to ask in voter surveys because income actually is not a predictor of support for a tax measure, and that's based on over 160 tax measures successful in the last 10 years. What is a good predictor is age, and the age is representative. What is also a good predictor is partisanship, and the partisanship is representative here.
18:10 I am completely confident that this is representative of the population having done that number of surveys over the last 10 years, and that doesn't count the 100 or so plus in the previous 10 years. So I don't think income is a driver on political issues like this. At least it's not a driver that's not represented by those other demographics. Sorry, I didn't hear that, Brian. At least it's not a driver that does not co-vary with those other demographics. Age.
18:41 Gender, Ethnicity, and Partisanship. So the first part of the survey deals with the resident satisfaction portion, and we'll start with the quality of life. This again was asked of all 200, so this is not just the voters, this is the voters and the residents. And we ask them simply, are you satisfied or dissatisfied with the quality of life? We then sub-segment that into, are you very satisfied or somewhat satisfied?
19:12 The way we do that, it means that you can look at this in total, satisfied versus dissatisfied. In that case, it's 93 versus 4, which is a great number, by the way. Or you can look at it at the drill-down level, where you've got 66 is very satisfied and 27 somewhat satisfied. Those also are good numbers, too. We like to have that 2 to 1 ratio between the very satisfied and the somewhat satisfied. If it's reversed, the numbers are obviously substantially softer.
19:42 This is among the top quality of life that we've seen in the state. The highest we've had is 97% with air rates here at the same level. So that's probably a great thing and probably something you all already know. We next asked people if...
20:00 We've asked similar questions.
20:27 In a variety of different communities, it's either economic forecast or quality of life. And any time we're down at the 20% range in the last year, we've been happy with that. We've seen some communities where the things are getting worse, whether it can be economics or overall, and the two things co-vary is in the 40s and even low 50s. So this is actually encouraging, even though it may not seem like it.
20:53 We asked an open-ended question in this section of the survey where we simply said, you know, what's the most important issue in the city or in the town of Mammoth Lakes? And we took verbatim responses. We then coded them into categories together. Not surprisingly, at the top of that list is the economy and jobs. You can certainly add the two of those together because they're opposite sides of the same coin. So we've got 28% or a little over a quarter saying something to do with the economy.
21:21 At a much lower level then from that 25-28 percent is population growth and development at 9 percent. And then we have a variety of items at lower single digits, which with the margin of error could be zero. They could be a little higher, but they're really not very significant in this open-ended format question. That includes the town budget, the cost of living, education, town leadership and politics, and you can see down the rest of the list.
21:50 But it is very clear that economy is going to happen. Quick question, sir. Going back to, I think, the point that Ted's, one of the points that Ted might be trying to make is if you take those first two, and as you mentioned, economy and jobs together, they're 28 percent, and not surprised by those two, but if you look at those two, you say a quarter, 25 percent, I would say almost a third that that's important too.
22:21 The top two combined being 28%, the next four, which are places three, four, five, and six combined are equal to one and two. So it takes four all combined to be as important as the top two. So I just wanted to point out that I think that is extremely important as far as the ability of people to pay. Yeah, I certainly agree with that. Thank you. I certainly agree that the economy is a factor.
22:50 In all of the tax measures that we work on, what has been interesting of late, and maybe we're getting to the tax portions ahead of the schedule here, but I'll just comment on that, is that people understand there's a crisis, people understand that they're hurting, and that they can only afford so much, but we're still seeing very high levels of support for tax measures. This year we have 25 that are already going to be on the ballot.
23:19 Which is a huge number compared to what we've seen over time. Now part of that's the need, but we don't recommend things be on the ballot that can't be successful because it's just, it's not worth you spending the time to do that. Now there's some caveats, and we'll get to that when we get to yours. There's not a race forward. Real quick, and not to keep interrupting, but it's been on my mind, and I think it's an easy question for you to answer.
23:40 Have you done any work for any other municipalities or agencies in Mammoth Lakes like the fire department, hospital, water district, school? No, we haven't. No, I'm just curious. Yeah. Thank you. So to sum up a little bit this first section, and I'll try to make these brief, Mammoth Lakes residents are overwhelmingly satisfied with the quality of life, and that's something to be proud of and probably something that they want to protect.
24:09 They're reasonably optimistic about the future despite the economic climate that we're in and when asked to identify the most important issue it is the economy and jobs as we've been discussing. The next section drilled down more into the town job performance and satisfaction with that and not only at the overall level which is the first question that we have here.
24:35 But we drill down into the individual service level as well, which is fairly typical for our resident satisfaction surveys. What you see here is, again, a question where we say, are you satisfied or dissatisfied? So we can look at the totals on both sides of that equation. But then we drill down and ask them a subsequent question, which is, does that vary or somewhat on either side? So you can compare the 65 percent.
25:00 Total Satisfaction with the 29% dissatisfaction, and that's important to look at. You can also drill down and look at the very satisfied versus the somewhat satisfied. In this case, the 1748 is really the reverse of what I was saying earlier. We would rather see more people in the very satisfied for all the obvious reasons, and this indicates some weakness in people's overall satisfaction with the
25:30 The town services in aggregate. This is not among the highest. This is actually a substantial shift. Usually, when we've got something in the 90s on quality of life, we would expect to see something in the 80s with satisfaction with the overall town service. Obviously, you don't have that. You're probably in the 30 percentile, rather.
25:55 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
26:19 This next, actually the next two slides drill down into specific services and while the quality of life was quite high and the satisfaction was substantially lower, we've now, when we look at the individual services, we jump back up. This is asked the same way again, satisfied versus dissatisfied and then we drill down into the very versus somewhat satisfied and we, in this particular chart, we assign numeric values to make it easier just to compare the different items.
26:47 Assign a 2 to the very satisfied, a 1 to the somewhat satisfied, a minus 1 to the somewhat dissatisfied, which you don't see on this particular chart, but is there, and a minus 2 to the very dissatisfied. So it gives us an average respondent. So, for example, operating and maintaining trolley and bus services at 1.7 is a very high rating. And it says that the average resident is almost very satisfied.
27:17 With that particular service. In fact, the very satisfied category was 73% and the somewhat satisfied was 23% for 96% that are overall satisfied with the service, the trolley and the bus service. That's a very, very high number. We very rarely see services, individual services ranked that high. So great job there.
27:43 Providing access to the national forest land, also highly ranked, that's a 90% overall satisfied. Building and maintaining parks and trail facilities, another very highly satisfied at 1.4 or 89% overall satisfied. So that means that in those last two that the average voter is right in the middle between somewhat and very satisfied.
28:08 And that's an excellent place to be. Maintaining a low growth rate is 88% satisfied. And then we drop off from there to some of the other items like removing snow, 1.3. Still pretty good satisfaction. Support special events to encourage tourism, a 1.2. Anything on this chart that is a 1.0 and above is at least somewhat satisfied, and we think that's a good level to be at.
28:33 It's when you get things that are substantially below the 1.0 level that we become more concerned about those services as maybe things that need to be worked on. I think you said low growth rate. It's a low crime rate. I'm sorry. Did I say growth? Yes. Low crime rate. Thank you. Just to point out. Thank you. I apologize. This next chart shows the remainder of the services that we tested, and these are...
29:00 Below that 1.0 level, at the top portion of that, provide youth and recreation programs is not bad. It's 66% satisfied, but you can see you're starting to get a big chunk of people that either don't know or are less than satisfied, so there's some reason to think about those services that you're providing. The ice rink building and maintaining it was at 67% as well.
29:26 Then we're enforcing speed limits. We're at 69% there. The reason these rankings change is because the side of the equation with the higher percentage on here has an impact on that. Provide code enforcement to maintain business properties at 0.7. And so some of these things down at the bottom of this list from 0.7 down are areas probably that need some improvement or to the extent that resources are available. And I know that that's difficult in these times.
29:54 That would probably help benefit the overall perception of the city's job satisfaction at a high level by addressing those things that are at the lower end of this budget. I want to point out, too, that at the lower end of this, first-time homebuyer loans and rental workforce housing, 26% said that they didn't even have an opinion of that.
30:19 So that has an impact on how high that score can be. In fact, the positive side was very satisfied, 20, 30 percent, somewhat satisfied. At the bottom of this list is maintain a balanced budget, and to break that down, we've got 13 percent that don't know, so there's a good chunk of people that are saying we just don't have an opinion because we haven't...
30:41 Delved into it in that much detail. Then on the satisfied side, we have 11% very satisfied and 22% somewhat satisfied for 33% overall satisfaction. On the negative side, we have 26% somewhat dissatisfied and 28% very dissatisfied for a total of 54% dissatisfied. So there are obviously concerns associated with the budget. The next question that we addressed
31:11 Sort of drilled down on the police and public safety issue. And in fact, we asked Mammoth Lakes Police Department has two officers on duty per shift with three shifts per day. Do you think that two officers on duty is about the right number, too many or not enough?
31:29 And as you can see here, about two-thirds said that it was about the right number. 21% would actually like to see more on duty. And only 4% said that it was too many. So a very small percentage are actually suggesting that the police coverage be reduced. There were 5% that were mixed opinions, and those could be mixed between right number, not enough, not enough.
31:53 Unlikely to be not enough too many, but maybe about the right number too many, so it's hard to see where those mixed opinions were, but it's a very small number as well. Mr. Godby, quick question on that one. When I read this, knowing what I know, and that is that there's not actually two officers per shift, if you count the sergeant that's on duty for each shift, you've actually got three responding.
32:21 And not two. I question the relevance of this question because it doesn't reflect what actually happens, plus it doesn't incorporate the cost of a particular level of service. Is that a fair question on my part? Well, we work with staff to write the questionnaire, and we do not talk about the supervisor on duty.
32:50 Do I think it would change if we called it three people on duty? It might. If it was three people and a supervisor, whether it goes up or down, I don't know. I just question the relevancy of asking this particular question. Yeah, and that's the way that we work it out with the staff. Okay, thank you. So again, to sum up, residents are satisfied overall.
33:21 But there's some work that needs to be done. They are very satisfied with some individual services, and so you'd be commended in those areas. There are some areas where there are dissatisfaction, and we talked about those, and we need to think about addressing some of those challenges. The next portion of the resident part of the survey dealt with various growth and development directions, and we simply asked people...
33:52 Do you think, would you support or oppose each of these individual items that I'm going to read to you? And then we drill down again, is that strongly support, somewhat support, or the opposite on the negative side? We've created the same sort of scale here so you can see how they rank really quickly vis-a-vis each other. I want to make sure that I read the full description in the question because some of these are shortened because they need to fit in the chart.
34:20 So at the top of the list was more year-round businesses at 1.5 and the actual question was do you support or oppose development of more year-round businesses. So that 1.5 is comprised of 64% that are strongly supportive of that and 27% that are somewhat supportive for a total of 91%. The next item also at 1.5 overall was
34:48 Do you support or pose development of more recreation and visitor-oriented businesses? And that one was 55% strongly supportive and 39% somewhat supportive for a total of 94% supportive. Well, the total is a little higher than the other one. It's the intensity that varies, and that's why it comes in second place in this particular chart.
35:10 And then third on our list at 1.4 was do you support or pose prioritizing preservation of the environment over commercial and resort development? That was 68% strongly sport, 18% somewhat sport for 86%. Clearly there is some tension between these top three items. On one hand there is some development and on the other hand there is preservation. I think what that tells you is that
35:38 Both are important and that striving to find a balance is what the voters are really saying they want, is to figure that balance out and obviously that becomes the job of the town. We had some additional ones, I won't read you all the percentages here, but additional single family homes, 80% supportive of that. At .7,
36:04 We have, do supporter oppose restriction of condominium and hotel development projects to limit growth? 71% are supportive of that. Now that's the supporting restriction side of the equation, not supporting doing it. So again, you see that this is a complicated issue and people are looking for some sort of balance between the growth and development of the environment and the type of development. Down at the bottom of this chart is
36:34 At minus 0.2, and I call that out just because it's low, is the development, if you support or oppose the development of additional condominiums and hotels. And 42% supported that versus 52% that opposed it. So that's the one that they're pretty clear that there's a large chunk of people that are opposed to that type of development. This slide summarizes really what we've just been talking about, and I don't think I'm going to go through it point by point.
37:04 In deference to the Council's time, but it is in the slide deck. So that takes us out of the resident satisfaction section of the survey and moves us into the tax portion of the survey. And the way we have done this and the way this is done over the last 25 years by not only our firm but our competitors that specialize in this.
37:32 Sort of sub-segment of political polling is to do an initial ballot test at the beginning where you get an unaided perception of whether people support a measure or not. Then go through some features of the measure, some arguments for and some arguments against and prioritize all of those and then come back to a second test of the measure to see what happens and in that you can call it sort of a simulated campaign between the first unaided
38:00 Perception and aided perception at the end. So looking at then that first test, we get again, we ask yes, no, but just like all the other questions, we then drill down, is that definitely yes or probably yes? So you can in fact look at it as an aggregate, yes versus no, and in that case it's 58 versus 36. Or you can drill down and look at the definitely yes at 16% and the probably yes at 42.
38:27 58% overall for a simple majority measure is a good place to begin. And when we began this process and when we were working on the report, we were still thinking simple majority. Rob's told me about some meetings that have happened and that there's a constituency that supports the idea of making this two-thirds. Most cities that are doing UUTs or UUT renewals or UUT modernizations in the state are using the simple majority approach.
38:57 For all the obvious reasons. This is a good place to be for a simple majority on the first test. It's a little bit weak for a two-thirds measure. It means there's a lot of work that needs to be done. And particularly with an error rate of plus or minus 8%, this could be 50% on the low side. So there is no cushion on top of the error rate, even for a simple majority measure. Obviously for two-thirds, we don't even achieve that.
39:22 What's important to keep an eye on as we go through this is the probably yes category. And the probably yes is critical because without a campaign effort in this kind of measure and a substantial campaign effort in a community like this that's different than in bigger communities but it's still a substantial effort nonetheless, it's really easy to lose half of those probably yeses.
39:47 So put it on the ballot, no campaign, and you're looking at about 38, 40% on election day. Put it on the ballot, and there is a strong campaign. We can probably hold the 58, and then it becomes a question of whether we can get to the two-thirds. More about that as we get to the end of the survey. Now, the next question that we asked in here was a no tax rate increase, which the previous one,
40:19 Said that there would be. But in this case, if we assure them that there is no tax rate increase, then all of a sudden the support goes up. So that's a good indication. And now we're at 73% versus 24%. And if we're talking about a two-thirds measure, it becomes viable, but it won't be a tax increase. It will have to be a no tax rate.
40:42 And it may even have to be a slight reduction, which is very popular, particularly in Southern California, you've seen a lot of UET renewals at lower rates. Brian, did you make it clear that this tax sunsets? Not at this stage now. Okay.
41:01 And how are you getting the inference that a different question saying a reduced rate would have given you a better return? Well, that is an inference. I don't have a question like that. That's something that's come up since we came out of the field with the survey and the conversations that have been going on about whether it's a simple majority approach or a two-thirds dedicated tax. Having seen and done a wide variety of UETs where we've looked at that tax reduction, it has always been higher.
41:29 In the past, it is anecdotal to the town of Mammoth Lakes, there's no question about that, but there's no reason to believe that your community would be different than those other communities that have gone with that slight reduction in the tax rate. But 73 is not a bad place to be. There is an error rate, of course, on that, and that on the minus side takes you down to 65%, which means there's little cushion even here at the two-thirds level, and I think what I understand is...
41:58 Then the discussion from one of the conference calls I was on is that there is a group that wants to go out and take this on and feels that they can get to the two-thirds level and they're going to work really hard. If this were a bigger city, I would say that's unlikely to happen. But what I have seen in small towns is the ability to go out and campaign, and you can campaign to everybody. And if you've got a committee that's willing to do the work, you can literally reach everybody in town before you vote.
42:26 And that can have a dramatic impact, but it also is an undertaking. There's no question about that. The next set of questions, and this is again a set of questions that looks a lot like some of the others that we asked on the residence side were features of measures, and what we're talking about here is here's how we're going to spend the money. So we say if you knew that the money would be used to complete trails and the Mammoth Creek Park projects, would you be more or less likely to support it?
42:59 We again segment and drill down beyond that. You can see here that .6 is at the top of the list. For a simple majority, that's probably okay. For a two-thirds, that's a little weak because that's actually 30% much more likely and 37% somewhat more likely. For a total of 67% more likely to support the measure. So while that is something that you need to...
43:23 Prioritize. It's not what you would think of as a home run measure. It's sort of a solid double or maybe a triple depending on your baseball preferences. Completing various trails and track projects are at a similar level at 0.6, just slightly below that but not statistically different. Then we've got a second group which include improved public transportation service guaranteeing the commercial
43:50 Airline service year-round. Maintain various town services. That's part of a general tax because it has to go, of course, to the general fund. And then create partnership with local schools. Those are at a mid-level, which range from 65% more likely to 59% more likely. At the bottom of this, we have support special events that draw tourism, maintain the town's visitor in tourism.
44:15 Marketing Program and Build a Roof Over the Public Ice Rink. Those have much less increase in support or potential for increase in support. Now, after asking what we might spend the money on, we then turn to arguments for the measure, and these are, because I characterize them as arguments, they are a little more advocacy in orientation.
44:41 And we have three tiers here. This scale, while it looks the same, is actually different because the negative side is not on it. And it's simply a artifact of doing interviews on the phone. It's difficult to say, now I'd like to read you some arguments for the measure. Please tell me if you'd be more or less likely to support it. It just doesn't make sense. So we say, these are arguments for, would you be much more likely to support it or somewhat more likely? The same thing is true on the negative side.
45:07 So that changes the scale a little bit and usually pushes the numbers up slightly. But in any case, you have a couple items at the top of this list which are really pretty important. And they are really accountability in nature.
45:22 The first one is that there's a mandatory financial audit, which was called out in the ballot questions that we looked at earlier, but here we're being more specific. And that gets you 43% much more likely to support the measure and 28% somewhat more likely for a total of 71% more likely to support the measure based on just hearing that one piece of information. That there would be local control and none of the money would go to other communities or the state is at a similar level, just slightly below that but not statistically significant.
45:52 Then we have a second tier, which includes complete a variety of recreational facilities and trails, maintain $800,000 in the annual revenue to the town with no tax increase, guarantees year-round commercial airline service. Those run from 65 to 62, more likely to support the measure. And then at the bottom of the list we have...
46:16 Maintain events and marketing programs that encourage tourism exemptions for low-income lifeline users and Mammoth Mountain Ski Area sports measure. Those increase support between 36% and 58%. So those are somewhat lower and a different tier. So the takeaway here is that some form of accountability is critical in...
46:41 The measure is obviously more critical in a simple majority measure because the money goes to the general fund and is at the council's discretion every year. That's less critical for a two-thirds measure because you have to specify exactly what you're going to spend the money on. So by the nature of a two-thirds measure, you're building in the accountability. These are the only things that the money can be spent on.
47:04 So at that point in the survey, we switched back to doing the ballot test again. We've talked a little bit about the measure of some pros and cons and how we might spend the money. And we come back to that same initial ballot test that you can see in the little box on the right-hand side there. And the good news is we've gone up to 65%.
47:24 So knowing where the money's going to go and knowing about some of the accountability provisions helps people increase their support. And that's a substantial increase from the first to the second test of 7%. There's also a slight decrease in the overall opposition, and that is good as well. Particularly the 27% definitely opposed come down to 21%. I'm really encouraged by that because we almost never see that happen.
47:53 Usually the definitely opposed will oppose the measure no matter what we say. And so it is heartening, particularly if we're going to be doing a two-thirds measure, that there's some flexibility there that a campaign would actually have an impact on those people. But again, I think accountability is key in making sure that we can get to where we need to be. I think also that there is going to have to be an independent citizens committee that is separate of the city that goes out and campaigns for this.
48:23 At a simple majority, the purpose of that would be to make sure we keep the 43% and that doesn't get split off. For a two-thirds, obviously, we not only need to keep that, but we need to increase it slightly. So there is a challenge in front of that committee should it coalesce and should the council determine to put a two-thirds measure. So to sum up, there is adequate support for a simple majority measure.
48:56 Without a doubt. The 65%, though, is encouraging that there was a big jump, but again, we're still not quite there for two-thirds measure and there is no cushion, so there's a lot of hard work that needs to be done.
49:10 I think there does need to be a substantial communications effort and particularly we need to head off any misperceptions about how the money might be spent and what the accountability measures would be sort of drawn on and on about. The communications in most communities that are doing UUTs is two-part. One, it is public information that the city is allowed to do that says here's what the measure is and here's what we're going to spend the money on.
49:34 And then the other part is the independent campaign committee, which the city can't be involved in, using city resources, that is, and those resources have to come together separate of the staff and city resources. Again, as we saw before, trails and park projects are popular, so are the track projects, including public information, or public transportation, sorry.
50:05 is very important as well as guaranteeing the year-round commercial air service. This last slide just repeats some of the arguments that you need to make in favor of this and again the accountability and the financial audits is a very important component of that.
50:26 So that concludes the presentation for this evening. As I said, there are detailed cross-tabulations, and if you've got any questions related to that, I can answer some of those, and I'll try to answer some of those now. We are certainly in the process of completing the full written report, which will have the cross-tabulations as an appendix, plus they will have the significant differences. The cross-tabs do some statistical analysis, which highlight those tables where we see significant differences, and that will be in the full report.
50:55 Comments or questions from Council? I had one. Brian, when do you expect to have the full tabs? Well, I can actually give you the cross tabs tonight. Okay. But the full report, I think it's going to be more like the end of next week. Okay. Obviously, the committee that's working on this is pretty interested in that. Yeah, I'm certainly happy to give you these cross tabs tonight. They've got a couple of my little notes on it, but they're probably things that you'll want to look at anyway. Okay. Thank you.
51:22 And that will help them. I can also be available to them. In terms of a go-no-go decision, though, the crosstabs are useful for identifying target audiences and those sorts of things. That's less useful for deciding on a town-wide basis, is this something we should do or shouldn't. That's sort of the top-line analysis like you had in this presentation. Any questions or comments from the council?
51:48 Brian, I want to get back to this sunset issue because to me, the more I think about it, the more it troubles me. You do know that if we don't vote in favor of extending the UUT in June of this year, it sunsets June 30th of next year? Correct. June 30th, 2011. Well, why didn't you take that into account?
52:16 Well, we didn't put a sunset. Let me just play the devil's advocate here. I'm trying to get from you what likelihood there is that the vote will be positive. And if you didn't tell the electorate that it's scheduled to sunset in 2011, that seems to me to be kind of the omission of a very, very material fact that I would certainly want to know if I were a voter.
52:45 We get it sort of from a slightly different angle. We have an argument that was this measure will maintain $800,000 in annual revenue to the town and it will not increase taxes. So we are saying we're going to maintain it. We aren't saying the negative, which is it's going to go away. What we have found over the years when we've tested the positive and the negative of things like that is the positive always tests better than the negative. Voters don't like to be threatened.
53:12 They would rather be enticed with maintaining that revenue source and the services they pay. Whoa, whoa, whoa. The voter, when the voter goes into the booth or, you know, fills out their absentee ballot, they will know on June 8th that this tax sunsets. And they will know that the implication is that after 2011, they will save $100 a month. Month or year? Year. A year. $100 a year.
53:42 Yeah, that's not terribly much, but to me, darn, that's a very significant fact. You say talk public, I'm stating it positively rather than negatively, but you didn't say, you just didn't say. No, we didn't. And part of that is because this survey. I'm troubled by that. This survey is doing two things, and it's doing resident satisfaction, which was one of the council's goals. It's also doing a revenue measure.
54:10 What we found when we have tested sunsets in terms of going forward with new sunsets, the shorter the better. The voters always want the choice to make decisions on how the funds have been spent. So if we're trying to figure out is this four years or is it eight years or is it ten years, it's always going to be shorter. And in this particular case, I would say, based on surveys where we've had more time to devote to the revenue portion,
54:39 That this should be four years, particularly if we're doing two-thirds. It's not in the data, it's not a question we asked, but we've seen it where we have asked it over and over again. If we're a simple majority measure, you probably don't need to do that. You can probably go longer as you did before. We did not ask, we did not tell them that it will be sunsetting and the money will go away. We did tell them that there is, that we will maintain that revenue to the city.
55:07 And I think that in terms of passing the measure, it's important to say how the money is going to be spent rather than you could save $100. Okay. Comments or questions from the public? Ted, come up to the podium before you start this time, will you? Mayor McCarroll, I think you hit it right on the head. It's not about telling people that the money is going away.
55:43 Well, where is it going away to? Oh, it's going back in my pocket. Wow. The issue I have is apparently Mr. Godby, who is very smart, and he's consulting with staff to come up with this survey. Well, it's in staff's incredible interest to get the $800,000 in revenue so they can support their pensions. What is this really about? Yes. I completely disagree with that. That is not what...
56:22 I just wanted to point out what I just had John hand over to you, that one of the questions, you know, Mr. Godby didn't go over the questions or the campaigning against the negative statements about the tax, and one of the questions is,
56:47 One of those statements is that the town says this measure won't increase local tax rates, but in reality the average household will continue to pay more than $100 a year on top of their utility charges. And I don't know, Mr. Godby, if you want to talk about that a little bit further. The mean score on that was 0.8. So clearly it is an influential statement. And clearly, actually all of the negative statements were influential statements, which is something to be aware of.
57:15 You know, that provides a little bit more information about that particular concern that, you know, if people realize that it is $100 a year, there is some influence on whether or not they would support this tax. And that is something to take into consideration. Yeah, the full item was that if you heard the argument against that the town says the measure won't increase local tax rates, but in reality the average household will continue to pay,
57:42 More than $100 per year on top of their utility charges, would you be much more likely or somewhat more likely to support it? It was 27% much more likely to oppose it, I'm sorry, and 25% somewhat more likely to oppose it for a total of 52% more likely to oppose it. You would have gotten me on board if that statement had been continue to pay rather than the thing sunsetting next year.
58:11 I just think it's a material thing to tell the public. There are several other arguments against which I can go through those. They're probably material as well. The town is responsible for the current budget problems. They can't be trusted to manage the funds raised by this measure. That doesn't mean that it's necessarily true, but it's certainly something that could be raised in a campaign. 30% are much more likely to oppose the measure based on that. 22% somewhat more likely.
58:37 Next one was with the current economy, falling home prices and rising unemployment now is not the right time to raise taxes. That was 30% much more likely to oppose the measure and 21% somewhat more likely. The next one is it's unfair for the town to tax telephone, propane, electricity as these are essential household services. 35% much more likely to oppose, 18% somewhat more likely to oppose. And finally, the town spends too much money on staff salaries and pensions.
59:05 32% much more likely to oppose and 29% someone more likely to oppose. So there are certain negatives. It's not the negatives that you're suggesting, but there are negatives. And they're all very, very, very popular. There's no question about that. But those are all asked before we ask that last question, which was the 65% yes. Again, that's not a two-thirds win. That's a simple majority win.
59:32 With a campaign, that's a two-thirds win with a substantial action. Could I just comment, Mr. Mayor, you know, in going out and selecting a firm to do this poll, I didn't go with any of the companies that have been polling in Mammoth Lakes before. Instead, I went and looked at the companies that other cities are using and asked them, who do you use and are they accurately predicting the outcome of your elections?
1:00:01 And so that was the criteria I used for choosing this company. And I think in the big, I mean, you can quibble with small questions, but the big picture is that these types of surveys have been very accurate for other communities. And so I think it gives you the best possible input you can have and the community can have to make the decisions that you have to make about whether to go forward or not. Yes, but Rob, I'm not quibbling about the form of the question. I'm quibbling about what I consider to be a...
1:00:31 The very material nondisclosure to the people that were questioned in this poll. And you know as well as I do that before the June 8th election, everybody in this town will know that this thing sunsets in 2011. And I'm just trying to figure out what this means. What do you think it means in your professional judgment? I guess my question is, do you think that's an argument against or is it an argument for the measure?
1:01:02 Well, it's potentially an argument against the measure, of course. It could also be an argument for the measure. In what way? Well, if I know that the money's, it's going to sunset and it goes away, then I'm going to lose services. And I may be interested in getting some of those services. So I think it cuts both ways. But in this case, I don't have an answer. Well, but that's why I'm asking you. You're the expert in this economy.
1:01:28 Does the fact that somebody can save money, is that a factor for or against? I mean, I understand what you're saying. I think, well, in this economy, yesterday we passed a tax measure for a school district in the Bay Area. It was a two-thirds measure, and it actually was just a simple renewal, and had they voted no, $180 a year tax would have went away.
1:01:51 They supported it. Two weeks before that, we passed another parcel tax measure, which was actually an increase, an extension and an increase by 90 some odd dollars. And the same thing was true then. Had they voted against that, not only would the increase never have been assessed, but the base of $180 would have gone away as well. But people are still willing to support tax measures in this environment. And while last year as a whole,
1:02:18 Was a much lower level of success than we've seen in previous years for all the obvious reasons. There were far fewer measures on the ballot. Statewide only about 70% of the taxes that were on the ballot were successful. Many of those were in fact committables, which if they weren't approved, the taxes would not have been collected. So the glass is half full or half empty. I think it's half full.
1:02:44 I think that the fact that the tax at sunset could be an argument for the measure and probably would be because you do see people in this survey that want to spend the money on trails and parks and keeping the commercial air service. So if you tell those people that want those things that those are going to go away, they're going to say, I want to keep them. That's the point, though, that
1:03:10 My understanding is that this tax currently is paying off a debt, which the debt will go away when the tax sunsets. So in effect, we're not telling people they're losing any services if they don't support this tax. They're saving the $100 a year.
1:03:30 And we will continue to fund services that we're currently getting the way we currently are funding it. You're absolutely right. Do they have an opportunity to increase that funding and get additional services might have been the question. And in all fairness to Mr. Godby, I would assume that you're from out of the area. You drew up this survey and ran it by staff before you put it out to the public. So the final...
1:03:57 Questions and how they were posed were approved by staff, not yourself. You are just doing the job you're being paid for. And also everyone needs to remember this survey represents less than 5% of the adults in this community and less than 10% of the voters. So it really does not, I can't feel like it represents our
1:04:23 Community as a whole or as a large group. It's only a very small, small sampling. Well, let's not get back to that stratification that you were talking about. I would argue that the statistics show that it is representative of the community. It is always a small portion.
1:04:42 I've done surveys in the city of Los Angeles of 600 people, and that's an even smaller portion, and they're accurate in that community as well. And it's just simply the stratification and sampling methodology and the statistics of why a survey research works. Okay, thank you. Any other comments or questions from the public? Yeah, one, Evan. Good evening. Evan Russell with the Mammoth Lakes Foundation. And tonight, the hat I'm wearing is in support of...
1:05:18 Thank you.
1:05:50 Cultural Center, Arts and Cultural Center. The project's been installed due to state operational funding, but there is bond money from the Measure C project in the bank right now that could be spent on this project if we had a way to be able to support some of the operating cost of the project. And I know that this is
1:06:21 There's been a lot of work done, and they're all great projects that are on the table. And what I'd like to ask you to consider is that whatever language that is used to take this to the voters includes cultural facilities and programs. Where we stand today is over the last year we've been working on resurrecting
1:06:51 A needs assessment that was done about six years ago for the cultural center and it was put together by a pretty significant group in the community of about 50 people. When state funding for operations at the community college level anyway started getting cut back, this thing went on the back burner and we just recently tried to bring it
1:07:20 We're in the process of working on it now. We formed a steering committee that had its first meeting. We hired Bill Taylor as a facilitator and a leader to bring this to some kind of a conclusion in the next three months. And our goal is to bring a business plan forward that would allow us to take this to the community
1:07:48 And to the current community college district, which would have to approve the use of those bond funds sometime by June of this year. So we're on a pretty aggressive timeline, but so much of the work in the past is still very valid that has been put into it that I think it's worthy of your consideration. Some of the benefits that
1:08:15 What we bring is there's approximately $10 million available in this bond package. We have more than adequate land to support this and related uses out on the college and the foundation site. And we have a $2.5 million art and literature collection, which is the largest collection of ski art history in the country.
1:08:43 When we first started looking at this project 10 years ago, it was an educational, cultural venue with a theater, with gallery space. We had culinary arts planned for it. And I think as this has gone along and it's gone through different gyrations, at one time it was proposed to move into the recreation facility that the town would like to build sometime in the future.
1:09:11 And recently, discussions we've had is to bring it back to where it's a core centerpiece of the campus as it was originally planned, but make it an attraction for the community as well. And we don't have anything specific tonight to be able to bring to the table. It's kind of last minute. But what I'd like you to consider is adding this
1:09:40 Knowing that it leaves the door open to be included. Considering in the future a public-private partnership as the college did with the library, and the library was able to be built because of $3.5 million that came out of the Measure C funds and working with the college, and we have some very good examples of that.
1:10:09 I haven't had a lot of time to really pull a specific proposal together for you, but I've got some information I'd like you to look at, and it's a program in Park City, Utah. And you know, when we look around, almost every resort community has a fine arts or cultural center, and you've toured a number of them when you've taken some of your
1:10:36 Trips away to look at other facilities. We've looked at quite a few. And there's a hundred examples in the state of how public-private partnerships work with government, with education, and with nonprofits. And there's one in Park City, Utah, which I think is a good example. It's called RAP, Recreation, Arts, and Parks.
1:11:04 And what I've brought is some background on that, language for the legislation that they passed, the tax program that they passed, and information as to how they award grants out of the tax fund that they have. And I'd like you guys all to take a look at this before you make your final decision. Evan, while you're passing that out, Evan, there's a...
1:11:31 There's a group of people called the Utility Users Tax Supporters, and one of the people is John Wentworth, who is seated right behind you there. So I think if you're going to contact anybody for a seat at the table, it would be John. Don't need to put any pressure on me, John. Evan, did you hear me? No, would it not be easier just to ask Rob to make sure that Evan is included in the next meeting? Either way is fine.
1:12:05 Yes, it's a bit of a tough situation coming to the table after this is pretty much a done deal, at least the way it appears. And we'd certainly, at minimum, just ask that language be included that would allow this to be eligible for funding if and when we bring a project or the arts community brings a project to the table. I don't think it's a done deal, Evan.
1:12:36 And I think that group is going to start. John, go ahead. It's not even close. It's not even close. They just got started. Thank you very much. Any questions? Thank you. Thank you. John Wentworth. I want to be brief because there is consensus from this group on this matter moving forward, but there is significant work to be done. I have made a personal commitment to the campaign for this effort.
1:13:12 And I think it's important for the public to understand my motivations and that my motivations are discrete from MLTPA's. MLTPA's position relative to this from the board was represented in the letter to the sheet, I think it was last week. My personal interest and commitment in this is that in the kind of economic world we're living in right now, with the federal situation being what it is, the state of California being what it is,
1:13:38 That it is more important than ever for a community like ours to be self-reliant and to be able to have the opportunity to engage resources that could be specifically addressed to things that matter to the people who live in this place. And I think that unfortunately with the general tax proposition, the problem with that is you can't run a campaign that tells people what it's going to be for.
1:14:04 I want to make sure that everybody understands that I don't have any problem at all with councils as an institution's political commitments. They've been honored. There may be some issues with some transitions, but that's not the issue. The issue is being able to run an effective campaign where you can tell a voter with the opportunity as a small committee like this, here's the proposition, here's the question to you. If you vote and you support this, there is a legal liability that that's where the money's going to go.
1:14:33 And in this climate, in these times that we're living in, that's important. And I think that the consensus of the group that met on Monday, that was the consensus of the group. And that's the beginning and the end of the question. And I think the Measure R, there was no poll taken before we did Measure R. I think there's very good and useful information in this poll. I think that it was a fine effort. I think we should all put it behind us and glean whatever information there is in there to use. The Campaign Committee will certainly use it.
1:15:03 But there's a lot of work to be done. We look forward to coming back to the council with some thoughts and some suggestions. But Evan, nothing has been decided other than that there's a consensus of trying to do this as a two-thirds proposition with appropriate accountability of the public. Are you going to stick around for the next item, are you? I don't even know what the next item is, but Neil. It's the UUT. Oh, yeah. I'll stick around. Thank you, John. Mr. Mayor, I have a question of Mr. Godby, if I could. Yeah, sure.
1:15:32 When we originally undertook considering putting this on the ballot on June 8th, and that's what we've been gearing towards up until now, because we wanted, if you pass by a simple majority, 50 plus, it has to be on an election where candidates are running for town council. That's correct. And that happens once every two years. So it's either now or wait two years. There is one other.
1:16:05 Caveat in the law, and that says that the council unanimously can declare a fiscal emergency and place a measure on any ballot and do it, but most cities do it the way you've described it. Okay. Having said that, during the process that leads up to tonight with the group of people that have been meeting, there is a feeling amongst that group, and I agree with it, that it's unlikely that the community would support the 50.
1:16:35 I think that's understood at this point. So as John Wentworth had mentioned, the direction now is to a two-thirds. If the direction now is to a two-thirds vote, does it make sense to forget about the June 8th election and put it on the November election? Well, I think that's an excellent question, and it's one of campaign resources and bandwidth and commitment in reality. And in fact, when we heard about the
1:17:05 Not decision, because it's obviously the council's decision, but the supporters wanting to do the two-thirds, that was one of the things I thought of, is to give them more time, you could put it on the November ballot. There's no reason that you have to be on in June. Better education. More time for education, and maybe Rob can speak to that, or maybe the committee can speak to what their view of that was, but it's also a different voter universe, too. This is a gubernatorial primary.
1:17:33 And there will be a lower turnout in June than there will be in November. So that's just a simple fact. There's also the reality that the two primaries for governor are substantially different. There's a contested, very well-contested Republican primary, which is going to make that a Donnybrook. The Democratic primary is over.
1:17:59 I think it was over yesterday morning. Okay. The former governor announced he was running. Last, last question. I'm sorry. As a follow-up. Does this go to this item or number two? Well, I just want to take advantage of Mr. Gottfried and his experience. If, okay, if you think November of 2008 is going to be a more people voting,
1:18:26 Does it make sense if you're going to go for two-thirds to have a special election just for the one item? A special election meaning separate from November origin? Yes. Probably not because it's going to cost you money to put that on the ballot. Okay, thank you. So most cities have not answered that from a political perspective, but just simply from a budget perspective. We would rather be on an already scheduled election and consolidated. Thank you. Okay, any other questions for Mr. Godby? No, thank you very much for coming.
1:18:58 My pleasure. Very interesting. And the next item is UUT also, so I can stay around with any other questions. Thank you very much. That would be helpful. That would be helpful. Okay, the next item on our agenda is a public hearing adoption of an ordinance repealing the utilities users tax sunset clause in setting the tax rate subject to ratification by the voters and approved resolutions putting the measure on the ballot directing the preparation of an impartial analysis
1:19:27 And providing for ballot arguments. I'll go ahead and open the public hearing. Statement and presentation by staff. Rob. Thank you very much. Last fall, when we were beginning to look at the possibility of this election, you referred the utility users tax discussion to a series of different groups, including the TNR Commission, the Airport Commission, the Planning Commission, the DMO Board.
1:19:56 The Chamber of Commerce, and I'm probably forgetting some others. Since that time, it was also suggested that we consult with MLTPA and with the Striders, who were two groups that were interested in this. And so this Monday, we pulled that group together, and we got Mr. Godby on the conference phone to review the results of the survey as it related to the utility users tax with that group.
1:20:26 described after a pretty vigorous discussion the group came to a unanimous consensus that they would like to ask you for more time and that you not act on this matter tonight but instead that you continue it to an adjourned regular meeting and we're suggesting next Wednesday so that they have a little bit more time to meet and talk about the possibility of a special tax
1:20:55 Which would require two-thirds vote and also in particular what that special tax would be dedicated to. So they're organizing themselves without any activity on the part of the town between now and the weekend and then we're going to reconvene next Monday and hear what their recommendations may be in this and then bring that to you at the adjourned regular meeting.
1:21:23 Robert, how about, are there any questions about that? Yeah, hold on. I was going to ask a question of John Wentworth in regards to this idea that whether or not we put it on the June or the November ballot. Okay, well, if that's the case, let's do this. There are no other questions from council. I do have a question, and it's actually of council members, is I still think we, even if we
1:21:50 Delay it. I think it's very important that we give our opinions and things in some direction on it today so that we're not into a marathon meeting on the 10th. I have no problem with sending it over, but I think we need to have some discussion, and it may include items like that as we go through the process today. Okay, we're going to have the discussion, and of course the next thing I was going to do is just call for public testimony for and against because the people showed up tonight to testify.
1:22:19 Before we continue the public hearing, they should have a chance to testify to this evening. Did you open the public hearing? Yes, it did. Thank you. Did you anybody? Yep, I did. It was just a soft gaveler. Just a soft gaveler. Anybody wishing to speak in favor? Anybody wishing to speak in opposition? Okay, discussion. I guess, well, I think we have to label this preliminary discussion. Right, right. Because there may be more public testimony.
1:22:51 Next Wednesday. I would want to know when it comes back to us on Skip's question of what that committee feels about which date. I would also like to know if that means we incur other costs because we would normally not have a ballot in November, whereas we will have one in June. Just on that one issue. I have some other comments to make. Should I just go over? John wanted to speak. John? Yeah, go ahead, John.
1:23:22 And anybody who was in the room on Monday, correct me if I'm wrong, I think the sense of why June is significant, it's a local election, these are local issues, there are going to be candidates running, this is a significant question in front of the public, and I think it's the hope and desire coming out of our efforts that we would like to know where candidates stand on something like this. I think it's an opportunity, if it's a well-framed, well-written, well-thought-through effort, it's a good opportunity to focus
1:23:51 on what this means and to galvanize more support for it. I think that waiting to November, fine, but I think to Mr. Gobby's point, it's going to be about a whole bunch of other issues that it would be even harder to get the community discussion focused on what this is about. So the short fuse doesn't scare you? No, not me again. Thank you, Austin. Ted. This is what I think your issue is. It has to be a special tax.
1:24:23 I'll give you a preview of the paper.
1:24:47 Staffers who would probably eat up the entire utility tax that you propose in terms of revenue. There's going to be a connection between your staffing levels and this revenue that you want. And if a correlation can be made, this thing is done. Fortunately, you have people like the casters and John Wentworth out here who, as yet I haven't had a chance to sully their reputations. But I'm just saying, in other words, you have great
1:25:17 People out here for a special tax that you could probably sell. But the furloughed worker issue and your budget issues and your staffing issues are going to be tied right into this. And they need to be separated. So you guys are going to have to rely on our continued fiscal responsibility, aren't you? Couldn't resist. Well, it's nice to know up front that there's going to be that misinformation put out there so that the campaign committee can deal with that.
1:25:50 That's a question. Are we in discussion at this point? Well, just a preliminary discussion if you have any concern for my voice. Yes. And actually, knowing that we had the memo earlier about the special tax and having been involved in the Measure R tax, I totally agree with that. I went a step further and started thinking about what it might be spent on.
1:26:23 First of all, I think it was very clear, even if it was a small survey, but I think I know our community and that recreation needs to be part of it. I think that instead of saying transportation or continuing to subsidize air service, if we were to say mobility projects, we're giving ourselves the opportunity to consider those, and future councils as well, or things like clearing sidewalks in the winter, etc.
1:26:49 You know, I'd hate to see us put in there something as specific as saying subsidizing air service because how many years would you subsidize it? How much more money would you throw down a hole? But if you say something like mobility, it is transit, transportation, sidewalks, etc.
1:27:05 I also support Evan in his request to have cultural considered. You know, we have an element in the general plan that's all about arts, culture, heritage, and natural history, and I do believe there is support to go through with the policy that says encourage development of arts, culture, and heritage facilities and venues. I do believe that's out there, and I'm glad to hear that. You know, for years, constituents have been asking, so where is this cultural center?
1:27:32 I also have some other technical options I'd like the committee to look on and suggest that it be spent on construction, operation, and maintenance. I'd also like to suggest that it be within the town's municipal boundary or facilities owned or operated by the town of Mammoth Lakes. I'd like to see a no supplanting issue.
1:27:56 I'd like to see that there is some kind of an oversight. I don't know if it's a joint commission depending on what's in it or whatever would be the appropriate commission, but I think there does still need to be an oversight that is giving part of that accountability back. I don't have any idea about length of time. That's something I would want that group to look at. And then the final thing was that in the mobility commission,
1:28:27 In the study session we had, there was a recommendation that certain percentages be parsed into certain areas, and I think that would be tying the hands of future councils. I think that if we identify areas and the types, we don't want to get so specific. And the reason I'm saying that is in Riverside County,
1:28:49 There was a similar vote that went to the people to have spay and neuter clinics back before they actually had them, and they still, today, have to have them just because it was voted on as specifically as you must have a spay and neuter clinic, and it's not efficient cost-wise for them. Neil? Yes. John? Mr. Godby, from your experience, can you give us any insight as to the jeopardy on either side of having
1:29:21 Two or three specific items on the ballot versus 10 to 12, more of a grab bag of things that this tax measure would support? You mean two or three in the actual ballot, in a single ballot question? Yeah, two or three specific items that this would support. No, I think the more specificity you have in a ballot question, the better you are. I realize that you need to have some flexibility and you can't be so specific that you...
1:29:51 You run into the spay and neuter clinic problem. But the more specificity you can get, the better. And if the list gets longer than the one we have here, that's fine too. What really constrains you is the 75 words for the ballot question, but you're not constrained in the resolution. So actually working on a community college parcel tax measure where we're going back and forth today on the ballot question.
1:30:17 We have about six bullets in that ballot question. The resolution has about ten. So the resolution has other things that are included in it, but we just can't get them all into the ballot question. I'm sorry. What I meant was if this specific tax, if it passed, if it represented putting a roof on the ice rink, creating a track at Whitmore,
1:30:45 Provided money for mobility. Mobility might be pretty general and not be supported where if you had just two or three items that this money would go towards. I think there was some support for the transit and I guess I'd want to define the mobility a little more carefully than that. I think that might be just slightly too broad. I don't want to be too specific on the other hand.
1:31:12 But I think that level of specificity would be a good thing. I'm going to try once more. I'm sorry. And it's my fault. My question is, does it make sense to have this on the ballot and say it supports two things? Let's say it supports a continuation of trails development. Let's say it says let's support the construction of a...
1:31:40 Great track facility at Whitmore. Let's just say it says those two things. Would that be better off, more likely to pass than if we had transportation, mobility, fine arts? How many things can you put on the ballot before people start getting blurred and say, you know, I don't understand it? I think that, I'm just trying to look at the features list here again real quick.
1:32:10 Actually, John, you know, Measure R Parks saying it was going for recreation, trails, and parks, period. Well, no, that's... Recreation and trails, I got them in the wrong order. I mean, that was as specific as Measure R was. Right, and it was limited to that. Right. I'm just saying... But it never said how much to parks, how much to... No, no, but I'm just saying if we get too many things in the... I think a parks measure would do fine. Those are, in fact, the top two features.
1:32:37 I think the transportation, public transit, or public transportation, the way we're in here, services, are also high enough on the list that you could include them in it, and it wouldn't be a problem, particularly given the fact that people in this community give you very high marks for the public transit in the trolley system. So I don't think, while they may not be the same things, I don't think there's a problem putting them together, first of all, because they're both fairly highly thought of.
1:33:06 If one was much lower down the list, then I'd say separate them. But I don't think you have a problem putting them together, but I also don't think you have a problem just doing parks either, because clearly recreation is a very important component from the results here. Something to consider is that if you get too specific, then you may suddenly discover that you've completed those projects altogether, and then the tax, of course, continues. So I think you have to strike some sort of a balance between
1:33:35 Specific enough, but not too specific. Now you certainly could put a specific or two specific things in there if you wanted to. All right, well, Wendy. I would support the committee considering Joe's comments as well as Evan's request and I would encourage the committee to just take Peter's comments into consideration as well that I know we have immediate projects on the horizon that are
1:34:02 Needing some funding, but we need to have a longer term view than that as well. And so we should be looking to ongoing projects, maintenance, you know, issues, items, projects that require a continuing revenue stream as opposed to a capital facilities type of project that will end at some point. Not that those can't be included, but there needs to be more to it than that as well to continue to put that money to work for our community in ongoing projects and maintenance.
1:34:33 Rob, special meeting is 6 o'clock suite Z next Wednesday? Yes. Okay. Well, then I'll go ahead and did you want to? Yeah, just one more comment on this. I agree with both Wendy and Joe on this and I just also want to point out and I have some concern about how this is all drawn up and this is for the committee to consider but in our agenda bill it talks about replenishing major A marketing funds with this money to the tune of almost $400,000 a year.
1:35:02 That's half of what we're talking about. So I just want to make sure that this is an opportunity for us to accelerate our efforts to improve the product we give to our people, which is our town, our parks, our trails, our recreation facilities, our tracks, our multi-use centers slash ice rink type of thing. And I would hate to see it be divided up in this way. So for the folks on the committee, I just want to put that out there. And I do support the two-thirds.
1:35:32 Thank you, Skip. Sorry, just one information item coming out of the committee's work on Monday. Rusty Gregory spoke to the issue of the airline subsidy, and I think it was his representation that that was appropriate to take that off the table as far as this measure was considered. So the airline subsidy is not going to be part of the committee's discussion. It's kind of off the table as far as this is concerned.
1:35:59 That having been said, I'll continue the public hearing to... So, the tell attorney advised me that we can't introduce an ordinance at a special meeting. It has to be an adjourned regular meeting. So we'll have a separate agenda for an adjourned regular meeting, which we can also call at 6 o'clock if you want. I'll continue the public hearing to the adjourned regular meeting. Next Wednesday, 6 o'clock, Sweet Z. And at that time, we'll continue to take...
1:36:28 Public testimony for those wishing to speak in support or opposition. Okay, next item is policy item number three, draft 2007-14 housing element update. Ellen? Thank you. Thank you very much. The agenda item before you today is an introductory workshop to review the first draft of the 2007-2014 housing element. As you know, the
1:37:00 State requires us to update and adopt a new housing element approximately every five to seven years. We are in that cycle right now and are pleased to have, after some delay, the draft for you to consider. The approval of the housing element requires both adoption by the town as well as certification by the Department of Housing and Community Development who take a great interest in housing elements.
1:37:26 Have very specific requirements about their contents and scrutinize them closely for compliance with state law. We were able to submit our draft to HCD on February 11th. However, although it's not a requirement of HCD, it is common practice for the jurisdiction to have its council also recommend submittal of that element.
1:37:52 We're requesting tonight that you do provide that authorization for us to submit the element. And if you desire to provide comments to us that we can include in the next round of the draft, which will be ultimately brought back to you at public hearings for adoption. So there will be additional opportunities to comment and review the draft element once we have incorporated HCDs, comments.
1:38:22 That will be brought back to you. We have taken this to the Planning Commission on the 24th of February, and on Monday we took it to the Mammoth Lakes Housing Board for their review, and both bodies had very minor technical questions and comments on the element. Councilmember Bacon also submitted a series of informational clarifications, which I followed up with her by email.
1:38:50 I won't go into the detail of the housing element. It's really summarized in the staff report. There are several new policy directions in there, particularly focusing on adoption of a revised housing ordinance that reflects the interim housing policy that was recently adopted by the town.
1:39:14 Incorporation of the idea of livability, livability concepts throughout the element, as well as some specific updates and corrections to our zoning code, primarily related to meet state law requirements and ensure our code is consistent with what the law requires as far as our regulations concerning housing.
1:39:36 And finally, an important aspect of the housing element as an action item is to complete the community housing strategy in partnership with Mammoth Lakes Housing, which will really set the stage for a directed implementation plan to be carried out by Mammoth Lakes Housing towards achieving the desired profile of housing for the community. With that, it's Steph's recommendation that the Town Council authorize
1:40:04 Thank you, Ellen. Questions? I'm confused. Ellen, I thought you said you had already submitted it.
1:40:26 As you know, we're somewhat behind schedule on submitting this to HCD. We were due to have our housing element fully adopted by August of last year due to staffing constraints. We didn't meet that deadline, so we're quite far behind schedule. Ideally, I think this would have come, the process would have been to bring the draft element to you, have you recommend, and then submit to HCD.
1:40:52 In order to expedite the process, we submitted preliminarily a draft to them and are hopeful that you don't find issues so significant with this draft that we would want to withdraw that submittal and make corrections and resubmit that draft to HCD for their review. So it really was a time-saving measure on our part. Because there's money on the line. It's grant money. Okay.
1:41:14 Now when HCD is looking at it, are they looking at those required portions like the needs assessment and the regional amount? Are they, you know, my concern is there are some things in the policy here that I think deserve discussion. What happens if it comes back and it goes back to them and policy has, you know, the housing program section has been changed? That's,
1:41:35 Not typically an issue. HCD is interested in working with us in a cooperative manner to work through corrections and changes. What they really want to see is that we are making our best effort in our housing element to address the housing needs, the constraints and the items that are identified in the analysis that's in the housing element. So to the extent that those policy changes continue to represent the towns,
1:42:01 Best effort to fulfill those obligations of state law with regard to housing, it shouldn't be an issue, although we can certainly discuss those sorts of changes with them. I don't think they're as interested in necessarily the detail as in the intent and the direction of those policies to facilitate housing production. I have a second question, and it comes from my days as a planning commissioner, so, Neil, you can put your planning commissioner hat on as well.
1:42:31 Actions under H-4E where it's talking about updating the ordinances, specifically updating Amanda Town's parking standards to allow for reduced parking requirements. I understand that the state law allows the concessions and then the Planning Commission reviews and determines their balances, livability versus reduced parking spaces, etc. Is this recommending that we change that, that it not go to a Planning Commission review?
1:42:59 Any changes to our parking standards, just like any change to the zoning ordinance, would, of course, be reviewed very carefully. Both would be studied. I'm not talking about the standards. I'm talking about when an individual use permit would come forward on affordable housing. I would want to make sure that Planning Commission still has that ability to balance it at that time and determine if reduced parking is the best way to still...
1:43:21 Have livability on a piece. So I'm concerned that if you change, if you're suggesting changing the code, does that take something out of the hands of the Planning Commission? If the parking, existing parking ordinance, parking requirements were changed to reduce standards or make certain provisions that allow certain types of projects to have less parking and a project complied with that, then to that extent there wouldn't be the same.
1:43:46 Sort of discretionary discussion about whether or not that parking should be allowed. Now if the project proposed further revisions to those parking standards and, you know, to some extent, I mean, the state actually dictates certain parking ratios for affordable housing projects where we have no choice about complying with. So it would depend on how and the extent to which the parking standards were modified. And as I was trying to say is that obviously that
1:44:16 Process to reconsider those parking standards, if it's appropriate, would go before the Planning Commission, would be considered carefully. Okay, and would this then come back, would there be the opportunity for Council to discuss those kinds of items as well? A zoning code amendment would come back to the Council for their obedience. Yeah. Neil mentioned there is money on the line, this is why we're rushing through, and have we already lost some money because of the delay in this? I believe there's been one
1:44:47 Fairly small fund grant notice that we have missed. There's another much larger one, as I understand it, from Pam, that's due. The deadline will be in July. So we certainly want to try and make us eligible for that much larger grant. What's the dollar amount on those grants, the ones we've lost and the ones coming up? Good evening, Pam Hennerty. Sam Flakes Housing.
1:45:21 The first grant that we missed is a community development block grant planning and technical assistance. It's worth $70,000 to the jurisdiction. The next one is the community development block grant general allocation application. Last year, we applied for $800,000. I anticipate that we'll be applying for about the same amount this year, depending on if we go forward with home buyer assistance and rehab, which is what we applied for in the last round.
1:45:50 I just want to sort of clarify, it's not, you know, Ellen and I and we've been working on this thing for a long time and so we really wanted to get it into the hands of HCD quickly because they have 60 days to review it. So it's not as if there's a, you know, we have time to go for you guys to review it, we have time for the community to review it.
1:46:13 I read it to my kids for bed almost every night. And so, you know, it's really was, the rush was to get it to them because they've been taking 60 days. You know, they have to post on their website when jurisdictions submitted and how long they took to respond. And so their comments could take 60 days and then we have to.
1:46:39 Address those. So really the hurry was to get their clock started. And in order for us to be eligible for grants, we have to adopt the housing element prior to the grant application due date. So we've got time still to go through any concerns that may come forward as a result of this document. Okay. And this is what – didn't we hire a consultant originally to do this for us?
1:47:06 EDAW. Yes, we did. We had an extensive contract with EDAW, and in response to our budget shortfall, we took some of the scope of work back so that we, instead of outsourcing, we insourced it back. EDAW has provided some services under that original scope, but this was one of our budget approval actions. Questions? I just had a general question. I've heard that the number
1:47:39 We need 1,000 units of affordable housing. These numbers come up again and again and again. I couldn't find it specifically anywhere in here. And do either one of you know where that number came from and how it was determined? I believe it was just a proportion of future growth that was seen to be the workforce housing, affordable housing need.
1:48:01 The numbers in the housing element are the numbers that we receive from the state that tell us how much housing they think we need to provide over the next five to seven years. So the two aren't necessarily correlated at all. They kind of don't care what we think we need. They tell us what they think we need. But we do have an opportunity through the housing strategy to define that number much more precisely and also to tailor
1:48:27 Our efforts in terms of our programs to meet the gaps in our portable housing supply. So the housing is not necessarily the best form for that because it is so strictly regimented and they want to see their numbers reflected and set as targets. Further questions from Congress? Yes. So the public hearings and everything to adopt this element have to be finished by June.
1:48:53 That would be ideal in order to... In order to not lose the chance to apply for the $800,000 or whatever. Then the housing strategy comes after that? The housing strategy is effectively an action of this housing element. So we adopt a housing element. That's really what the state cares about for these grant funds. And the housing strategy is an implementation document that describes in greater detail and in different dimensions, I think, really how we plan to meet our community housing need.
1:49:22 Any other questions? Discussion? Uh, comments, questions from the public. Uh, through the discussion? If not, uh, is there a motion? Ms. Schmerer, I'll move that the council adopt option number one. Oh, I'm sorry, yeah. I'll second. Motion and second. Uh, any other discussion? Roll call, roll, please, Jamie. Council Member Bacon? Yes. Council Member Sigimura? Yes. Council Member Sigimura? Yes. Council Member Sigimura? Yes.
1:49:57 Thank you very much, Ellen. Good job. Item number four, waive reading and adopt by title only an ordinance adopting a zoning code amendment regarding marijuana cooperatives. So we were not planning an extensive staff report on this because it's the second reading, but I would point out that in addition to adopting the ordinance, you need to adopt three resolutions that call the election
1:50:28 Provide for the impartial analysis and for arguments and rebuttal arguments. Thank you. Questions from Council? Comments or questions from the public? Discussion? Does the whole motion need to be read? The title of the ordinance does. Go for it, Wendy. Mr. Mayor.
1:50:57 A move that we seek voter approval to allow medical marijuana cooperatives by A, waiving further reading and adopting the ordinance which allows medical marijuana cooperatives within the commercial general and industrial zoning designation subject to voter approval, B, adopting the resolution calling and giving notice of the submission to the voters a question relating to marijuana cooperatives, putting the measure on the June 8, 2010 ballot, C, adopting the resolution setting priorities for filing a written argument regarding town measure M,
1:51:26 And directing the town attorney to prepare an impartial analysis, providing for an impartial analysis and arguments in favor of the measure. And D, adopting the resolution, providing for the filing of rebuttal arguments regarding Measure M to be submitted at the general municipal election to be held on Tuesday, June 8, 2010, providing for rebuttal arguments. Second. Motion and the second. Any further discussion? If not, roll call, please. Council Member Bacon? Yes. Council Member Harvey? Yes.
1:51:55 Council Member Sigmar? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Houston? Yes. Mayor Carroll? Yes. Item number five, a resolution authorizing the joint filing with Mono County of a grant application under the Southern California Edison Company Local Government Strategy Solicitation Program. Mr. Mayor, I am going to recuse myself on this item and the next. As Mono County staff, I'd like to avoid any perceived or real conflicts of interest. Thank you, Wendy. Who's going to take this one? Karen.
1:52:27 Thank you, Mr. Mayor. The town has the opportunity to apply for a grant that's available from the Southern California Edison Company in partnership with the county and High Sierra Energy Foundation to address energy seeing policies and carbon. Being a leader in environmental sustainability is one of our strategic initiatives and addressing climate change and energy savings are goals highlighted in the general plan. The county will take the lead on this application with the town being the co-applicant.
1:52:53 The grant will cover staff time, some of the high Sierra energy work, some consultant work that will be needed to prepare the monitoring inventory component of the work. The product of the work effort will be to have a collaborative and regional look at energy policies. For the town, we hope this will ultimately lead to preparing a climate action plan, but that is not the ultimate product within this grant opportunity. For the county, it will lead to a sustainable communities element of their general plan.
1:53:21 It is important to note that the state is adopting more stringent requirements related to climate change and energy savings, whether that be stricter Title 24 standards or reducing greenhouse gas emissions. The town has been very forward-thinking in this regard, and it has acted several progressive programs, including the wood stove replacement requirements to address air quality issues or standing up a transit system to reduce overall vehicle emissions.
1:53:46 But to meet the new statewide requirements, we need to take additional steps to bring these great ideas into a comprehensive approach to reducing our common footprint and monitoring its success. The amount of money that we will be requesting is still being developed. The grant is due by March 22nd. If we are awarded the grant, it will not be funded until the fall of this year, and we must spend the grant funds by the fall of 2012. If awarded, we would have to...
1:54:11 Thank you, Karen. Yes, Karen.
1:54:32 With whom do we compete for these grants? Because I understand it's not an allocation, it is a competitive grant? It is a competitive grant. It's only available to entities that have a strategic partnership similar to the one that we have with High Sierra Energy Foundation. My understanding is there are 102 communities that meet that definition, and there's $27 million available with the maximum amount being $1 million per entity filing.
1:54:59 We have a reasonable chance. Our application would likely not be nearly a million dollars, but given that, we should be able to have some level of priority if they are reviewing our application and weighing it against others. Mr. Mayor, I'd make a motion. Oh, I'm sorry, I did have a question. I was just asking you guys first. Is this the time to ask for something specific on solar energy and wind?
1:55:32 Because at some point the rubber's got to meet the road instead of this lift service. I mean, when are we going to actually enact the Kyoto Treaty? So this particular grant opportunity is not available for implementation of policy. I thought I heard you say that. So this is setting policy and setting in place monitoring strategies so that we can weigh whether we're successful or not. However, having said that, there is a grant application that may be coming forward.
1:56:02 I think it's due in March. No, not that one. May. And it is more oriented toward implementation type strategies. We initially tried to go the direction you're speaking of, and SE said that is not something that they're willing to fund with this particular grant opportunity. So it's something we need to keep working on, and other grant opportunities may allow us to get there better than this one. David Freeman is from LADWP, is on the agenda for the Great Basin Air Pollution Control District.
1:56:32 And, you know, he's very serious about this, and he's appearing not this coming Monday, but a week from Monday before Great Basin to explain how he wants to put the solar into the ground, boots on the ground before sunset. Actually, I do have another question. Neil, I do have another question. Is there a possibility within this, since it is for renewing and updating energy policies,
1:57:00 To look at our air quality management plan, to have that be included as part of the, you know, kind of in the updating of things? It's not an implementation, it's a plan. Yeah, I think we could include air quality policies within the final product that we're putting together. I wouldn't necessarily call it an update of that particular plan, but I think we could certainly update our policies related to air quality.
1:57:29 Okay, because I'm also, I'm thinking back to what Ted Shady spoke to us about recently and that maybe we need to be looking at that a little more closely and if this is an opportunity to get a grant for it, I'd ask that that be included as well. I'll take that forward. Skip, you were in the process as I recall. Mr. Mayor, I make a motion to adopt a resolution authorizing joint filing with Mono County of a grant application under the Southern California Edison Company local government.
1:58:00 Strategic Plan Strategies Solicitation Program. Second. Motion to second. Any further discussion? Any comments from members of the public? If not, roll call please. Council Member Bacon? Yes. Council Member Herbie? Yes. Mayor Paterson Eastman? Yes. Mayor McCarroll? Yes. Thank you. Item number six, Mammoth Crack Project at Whitmore Park. Ray? Peter?
1:58:28 Well, Ray went on vacation, so I don't know how I got on bat so often tonight. So, many members of the... Nice catch, dude. At the beginning of the current year, we put together what I would consider to be a very ambitious work plan with some very high-priority projects that the Town Council wanted us to work on. And we've been working on those.
1:59:09 I think that my assessment of where we are is that we're not quite on schedule with the initial projects that were assigned to us. And then, of course, as time goes on, additional assignments have come forward. Like, we did spend quite a bit of time on the marijuana ordinance, and that is something that we hadn't really built into our thinking when we put together our work plan. So we have another project that's coming forward. It's the Mammoth Track Project at Whitmore Park.
1:59:36 And the council has been on record supporting that in a variety of different ways over time. And more importantly, we have a very ambitious group of local people, the Striders, who are pulling together private donations at a very significant level to support this project. We've spent some time over the last month or so trying to assess what's necessary in order to keep that project going forward. And Mr. Jarvis has outlined in the agenda bill
2:00:06 His assessment of the amount of hours that various things will take. And so we're coming to you asking for direction to go forward and to dedicate those hours, if not during the current fiscal year, maybe over the rest of this fiscal year and the following fiscal year. But I think we have to be honest in indicating to you that it's quite a balancing act.
2:00:32 And that there are impacts on existing projects depending on how much time we devote to this, or impacts on our ability to perform this depending on how much time we dedicate to the other projects. And so that's the question that we're putting before you now, and we've tried to put before you in a variety of other ways over time. Part of it's just an awareness that we are really stretched thin, but an acknowledgement that we have a number of high-priority projects that we have to balance. Thank you. Questions of Rob?
2:01:02 Actually, my questions are going to be of the High Sierra Striders Board, or the Mammoth Track Club, however many names you wear. All of the above. All of the above. Okay, any questions of Rob? Comments from members of the public? People wishing to speak on this matter? Okay. Does somebody want to stand up and answer questions? Jim Smith, ICR Striders. At all.
2:01:31 Yeah, the one piece that was missing for me in the staff report was the input from the board that is trying to put this together. So I have a number, so I'll just kind of knock them off and then everybody else can ask for them. As you were going into this project, first of all, I understand that there is a certain amount of money that's pledged towards the construction? Correct. And can you tell us how much that is?
2:02:00 Well, we have close to a million dollars that's been committed to that. So, you know, we're still working through that. It's very contingent upon getting the work done, getting the project essentially shoveled ready. So that's where we're at. So I think you saw that there's a million six in total in the first phase. So of that, a million we've been working towards to get. And that essentially gets the track and some appurtenances to go along with that.
2:02:29 Then what we submitted to Measure R at the last funding request was $600,000 for the artificial turf, and we asked their support to help with that. Now, obviously, that was a pretty big number. They allocated $140,000 to that, but didn't quite get us there, so we're still trying to figure out, you know, this $400,000, $500,000 all around. And one of the things we actually discussed with the TNR Commission as well as staff was maybe an opportunity to
2:02:59 Loan against the Measure R funds and use the Measure R funds as a repayment source for that additional amount. So we would actually go out and get a source of funds in the form of a loan and then have that be paid back through Measure R. But it's something we've been discussing and there's a lot of issues with it that's been communicated to us through Rob and other staff members. So we're still working out some of those details. Okay. And of the amounts that are,
2:03:29 The pre-construction cost estimates that Peter's provided, are some of those in that 1.6? I see CEQA, but that's the only one that popped out. I think all those amounts are staff time. Right. But in year 1.6, I see that there was also $10,000 for CEQA. Yeah, that was to pay a third-party consultant. In our 1.6, there was no staff time. Okay.
2:03:56 All right. And part of that was just there was no commitment, but when we were working through the project and kind of planning it and talking with Dana and staff and, you know, the TNR Commission, what we were hoping for is that we could work together with the town. It's going to be a town public facilities command, town public land down at the Whitmore Center. So we were trying to balance working together and say, look, we'll take on the task of fundraising, planning it, using our resources to do that. And if we do that,
2:04:26 Town, would you be willing to provide staff and time and support on that side through processing and planning and working with us on the construction of it? So there was no commitment, but at least that's what we were working towards, and that's why we're here. Okay. Then what was your concept of how ongoing maintenance and all of that would be handled? Okay, so two things there. So one is with Measure R,
2:04:53 The understanding is that moving forward we could take some allocation measure our funds to help pay for maintenance. That was one thing. Second thing was that we as the High Sierra Striders, as a club, we're going to commit to providing, you know, however many hours or even unlimited hours on a weekly basis to help provide maintenance of the track. And those are pretty much it in, you know, in a general sense without really getting into the details, which we really haven't taken the time to do. Okay.
2:05:23 Couple more. Within this whole, is there any kind of a reserve built in that I presume someday the track or pieces of it have to be replaced? So there's none of that in those numbers. Okay. And the useful life of this, do you have any idea? Yeah, we do. It's probably 10 to 12 years, but given that we have it covered by snow a portion of the year, we can probably extend the life to about 15.
2:05:54 Okay. Of the track. And our maintenance staff did talk to South Lake Tahoe. They've got a track similar to this, and they confirmed that lifespan and actually expect there to last longer than that. Okay. Any other questions? Jim, did you have one? I guess, Jim, I'm kind of looking at the list of staffing considerations. Is there anything we're looking at
2:06:23 Complete the CEQA, Complete Town Approvals, Complete County Permit Process, and Annual Operations, and Maintenance. Is there any of that that your group could help out with? I'm not really sure how we could maybe reduce this somehow. Certainly on the maintenance side, but on the essentially the
2:06:47 Track has been submitted as a typical project, right? So for town staff to go through their project analysis as if it was a use permit or something similar to that, going through that process plus the building permit process, obviously we can't help with that. And that's pretty much the bulk of this. Now, that being said, there's obviously, you know, one part of that is LADWP. They have a request to have a certain amount of things done. That really needs to be done by Ray.
2:07:17 And staff. Obviously we wanted to help out wherever we can and provide information, but because it's a lease agreement between the town and county and LADWP, we can only assist in providing information and not negotiate, obviously. Which brings my question, if I may. It says that things needed are review and approval of the project by LADWP.
2:07:44 Do we know what their time frame is? And does that approval have to come before we start CEQA? Well, that's already been submitted. But I don't know. Have we heard back from them, Peter? No, initially they said it would be four to six weeks for actually the first review comments. They did give, you know, raise some comments within about a week, which are the four main things that they were concerned with right off the bat. But they really said it's going to be a six to 12 month process. And with that,
2:08:14 They would basically suggest that we extend the lease at the same time we're doing the project update. We've got about 10 years left, and they would suggest that we increase the lease life. The project in and of itself, as defined as a project, the secret that's already started, we've already done some of that work. Town staff had some secret consultants already in town, and they've done some work out there already. So the project in and of itself will define the secret process.
2:08:42 And that brings back my question, before the town puts too many hours into establishing an agreement between the two of us, shouldn't we get the approval of LADWP first? Well, I mean, staff may have to answer that. I would say this, though, is that the track is consistent with what the use...
2:09:08 What the agreed use was between the town and the LADWP. It is? Recreation. Okay. So it's kind of like a formality? I would say. Okay. And the track was actually in the original concept for the park itself. There was a track facility included. Okay. Thank you. You know, they had main concerns as water use and that we stay within the lease area. What would the water usage be for that? Restrooms?
2:09:33 So we have two major sources. So one is part of the track is actually an unofficial turf inside the track. So there's a water source there, obviously not to water it, but at least to actually keep some heat off of it at certain times. If someone's going to play on it, and if it's warm down there, you may turn on a sprinkler system for a few minutes to kind of cool that surface down. Then the second part of it is in phase two,
2:10:02 Which I believe is in your packet. We're suggesting that we actually build a kind of a commissary locker room that obviously has some water implications with showers and bathrooms and even a concession stand and those kinds of things. But those are optional and something we'll look at depending on how the water tests come up. Good.
2:10:23 Just for the benefit of people who may not have the attachment, phase one covers which pieces? So phase one is the track itself and then the infield, which is the artificial turf. And then a pertinence go along with that. So that's bleachers, fencing, trails going around it. Those are essentially the big elements.
2:10:45 And presumably some kind of facilities, restroom facilities? Well, the restrooms are already there, so we won't expand that until the phase two. All right. I guess this one's a question for staff. A mitigated negative declaration, 150 to 200 hours? Mark, would you like to comment on that? We don't know yet what we're going to go through for CEQA, so we're estimating it's a mitigated negative deck, so we'll have to do...
2:11:25 The initial study checklist. We've already got some work done on biology and I think archaeological studies. So we're going to have to correlate that. So it's going to take some time. We have to prepare the document and it has to be available for public review. So we're just generally estimating that kind of time. And, you know, that's about what it takes for us to do that kind of document over the period of time it gets to completing.
2:11:54 The mitigated deck circulating the document, doing all of the public notices that are required. Would that include the approval process? Yeah. Okay. That goes through the program. And the two critical path items are the DWP lease and our CEQA because we hope that we'll have a mitigated deck, but we don't know. Any other questions? If the LADWP time frame is six months to a year,
2:12:25 Obviously, the importance of that. Then we have six months to a year to spread out some of these hours. So some of these hours could be in the next year's budget. Yeah, I think when we get into deliberation, we need to talk about that. Any other questions of Jim? Okay, any other comments from members of the public? Hearing none, deliberation?
2:12:57 I'll start. I am fully in support of this project. I think it is something that's going to have all kinds of benefits for us. I think the real decision that we have to talk about is how we're going to decide which items get delayed if this work gets done. And I'm also a little concerned about, I think we can say it's a priority now, but can this council actually commit to a priority for the next council in the next budget year?
2:13:28 I have a suggestion. Okay. And that is that Rob said a little bit earlier, and I think it's, and Jim just reiterated that this is more than likely to fall into next fiscal year. And my question really, Rob, is it says delay work on the housing element, neighborhood district plan, zoning code update, arts plan, mobility plan. If this were to take the course over this fiscal year and next fiscal year,
2:13:57 Would it be safe to say that the staffing for the four elements that are discussed in the staff report, if it's carried out over two fiscal years, that you can do it in such a way that it won't materially slow down any of the projects that I just mentioned?
2:14:23 Well, there may be other staff members that want to comment on that. I think that spreading the time out over the two fiscal years is very helpful. I also think that there's certain key things that need to happen this fiscal year and may also have an impact on some of these projects. So it's going to be a balancing act. There's just no question it's going to be a balancing act. And knowing what your priorities are would be helpful.
2:14:50 I think that one of the things that we need to just be aware of is I think the support of this council has a lot to do with the ability to fundraise and get the additional monies they need to keep this project on track and keep it moving forward.
2:15:10 You devil, you devil. We need to show our commitment to this project. Do you support the project? I support the project 100%. Yes. Fully. So do I. Fully. Mayor and Council, if I could, the reason we place these particular items as something that will be delayed is we're going to, you know, our staffing team on this is going to include Peter, Ray, Jessica, and Ellen, and to some degree Steve.
2:15:40 As we move forward on this. And so there's just some hours that we take out of all of those other projects. And we're not suggesting that those projects listed will be substantially delayed. We're just cutting into the pie a little bit. And some of the work that we're doing now is the startup work that we actually have to get moving so that this thing plays out over its six-month to a year, two-year process.
2:16:07 Mark, is there a way to say that X amount of work would be done before you know what the CEQA impact would be and the DWP lease to say to get it going to a point because if it turns out that CEQA is going to be $200,000, I would hope.
2:16:27 It would be coming back to us. Yes, you know, what you should think of this as a public works project. And it has donations and almost grant funds that come with it. And so to us, this is a very new project that we're staffing up very quickly because of the time expectation that the clients had for this. And so we would be able to come to you in milestones and report our progress and keep you posted on.
2:16:57 Lease, CEQA, Planning Design, Budget Implications, and we can regularly do that if you would like the information. I think this is a big enough project that, yes, we would want to know that. Definitely. And, I mean, it just, what was that, half an hour ago we talked about getting the housing element done because of the monetary things there, so I would not be in favor of anything that delays the housing element past that June date.
2:17:24 Because it doesn't help us any to get money on one side and lose it on the other. And we're on track for that. Do you feel that you've had enough input from us policy-wise? Yeah, I think kind of the result is that we just need to keep coming back to you and reporting where we are on these projects with the understanding that we are doing this balancing act and we may need further guidance. Well, and I think...
2:17:50 I'm probably channeling John, but I think that we really need to know what those drop deads are and that if you're not hearing back from DWP and it's a drop dead that you don't just, you know, that you only work on the pieces that are necessary rather than working on all of it. Okay. So do we. Joe, if you want to make a motion. Do I have to read the whole motion, Peter?
2:18:21 I think that that's why I asked whether you've gotten enough information. I think we were just looking for a sense of the council and I feel comfortable. Okay. Moving right along. Thank you very much for coming. Oh, Wendy. Monthly economic forecast. Rob? I really love all these statistics and charts, so this has been a good meeting. Interestingly, the
2:18:53 The monthly economic forecast has been pretty consistent month to month as you see. The unemployment figures have been softened a little bit. And sort of the tone of the report seems a little bit more confident and not as tense as some of the past reports. But the reality is the unemployment situation is here today and it will be here next winter too. And so, you know, we're not out of the woods yet. Okay, any questions on item number seven?
2:19:22 Moving to the consent agenda, is there a motion to approve items 8, 9, 10, and 11? So moved. Motion and a second. All those in favor? Aye. Aye. Mr. Mayor, I'm sorry, I need to abstain from item number 9 as I wasn't present at that meeting. Oh, okay, with one abstention, unanimous. Item number 12? Yes, I asked to have this pulled because there's one correction in the amended by Joes that did not get amended.
2:19:54 On the ordinance, which is on page 4, at the end of the second paragraph in 6.08.010, it should read, any person deputized to serve as contract wildlife officer. We took all of the services and the managements out, but that one still got left in. So the word, it should read, serve as contract wildlife officer to match the other changes.
2:20:22 Contract by a lab office. So services would be stricken. I mean, not that services won't happen, but the word services will be stricken. Okay, thank you. Mr. Mayor, I'll move for adoption of Consent Agenda, Item Number 12. Second. As amended. Motion and a second. We need a roll call or roll call? Council Member Bacon? Yes. Council Member Huggie? Yes. Council Member Sigmore? Yes. Mayor Pro Temeson? Yes. Mayor Pro Temeson? Yes. Mayor Pro Temeson? Yes. Mayor Pro Temeson? Yes. Mayor Pro Temeson?
2:20:51 Item number 13, Jo? I asked this to be polled because it is a significant financial thing. To me, it's a policy decision, not just something to put on the consent agenda. And I'd like to have more information. So I'd ask that if you continue to the next meeting so that we can understand some certain items is that
2:21:18 And I believe that we found that
2:21:46 By using a private company, we could, I think, gain about 2% more return on our investment. And my only request is that you talk to Ted Shady, who can give you the particulars on that. I didn't have a chance to call in today, and I apologize for that. Any other? I support Joe's request. I do too. Can we continue that to myself? I can give a few answers if you would like.
2:22:19 I want to see the figures and things in front of us. That's why I'm just asking it to be continued to the next meeting. And I want to see that discussion that we had before Great Basin. Okay. Any comments on item 14, register of demands? Hearing no comment, closed session? Okay, we have a closed session.