Town Council Special meeting
· recording 1 hr 35 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
193 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:00 Adjourned meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Town Council to order. Wendy, would you lead us in the flights of it, please? Sure, if everyone would please rise and join me. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you, Wendy.
0:34 Okay, this is an adjourned meeting of last week's regular meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Town Council, and the first item on the agenda is a discussion of an ordinance repealing the Utility Users Tax Sunset Clause. Rob? Thank you very much, Mayor and members of the Town Council. I think one thing we all learned from the recent survey,
1:00 of the town regarding the utility users tax is that it's going to take a very vigorous group of supporters in order to make this work with our voters in June and I think we do in fact have that. I've held a series of meetings since the last council meeting with this group and they've come forward with the recommendation that's in front of you tonight as an alternative to what we had presented earlier and just to
1:28 Briefly summarize what they're recommending. They are recommending that we put the extension of the utility users tax on the ballot. The tax would become a special tax for the purposes of planning, construction, operation, maintenance, programming, and administration of facilities and projects for mobility, recreation, arts, and culture. As a special tax, it requires two-thirds approval by the voters.
1:56 It would be placed on the June 8th ballot. The tax rate is recommended to stay at the current rate of 2.5%. There's a process whereby either the Tourism and Recreation Commission or an alternate commission or committee appointed by the council from time to time would make recommendations prior to the expenditure of money from the measure if it's passed.
2:24 There's also a mandatory annual audit by an independent auditor and a review, again, by either the Tourism and Recreation Commission or an alternate commission or committee designated by the council sitting as an audit committee. There's also a clause that allows the funds to be used for bonded indebtedness and supplanting of current funds with these funds is prohibited.
2:53 So those were the various points that they've agreed to and that we have built into the ordinance and the two resolutions, which also include the ballot question. I would like to note that this was put together fairly rapidly, and since the time we issued the ordinance to the Town Council, we found a couple minor mistakes, and Pete Tracy would like to go through those with you just to make a clear record that we have made a few changes.
3:24 In the ordinance refers to mobility, recreation, and arts and culture. If you look at Rob's memo. Pete, can I interrupt you one quick second? I didn't open the public hearing. Oh, I'm sorry. I'm opening the public hearing, and we've had a presentation by staff. Thank you. I'm sorry, Pete. The ordinance refers to mobility, recreation, and arts and culture, but Rob's memo reverses recreation and mobility.
3:50 And so if you look at the actual motion language, it talks about recreation mobility. When the motion is made, it should be mobility recreation. The other changes are extremely minor, and in the title of the ordinance, originally it referred to the Mammoth Lakes Mobility, Recreation, and Arts and Culture Initiative. This is not technically an initiative because it was not...
4:19 Commence with an initiative petition. It is put on the ballot under Elections Code, Section 92-22. So the word initiative comes out there and also comes out in Section 4. It has no material change. It's a technical change. And in Section 4, after where the word initiative was, added in would say utility users tax because that makes it consistent with the title.
4:48 In Section 1. Other than that, I think we're fine. Thank you, Pete. Questions from Council? Yeah, I'm not clear on the changes. You said in the, I'm sorry, Peter, the first one where you said the words need to be reversed, I think, on the, is it in the recommendation by the town? Yes, in Rob's memo, if you look at the recommendation under A,
5:20 The next to the last line, it describes the ordinance as projects for recreation comma mobility, whereas the ordinance itself says mobility comma recreation. Those two words are just reversed. That's the only change. But it's right and it never does.
5:39 It's right in the ordinance. The ordinance is right. I'm looking, yeah, I'm looking, mine says mobility of recreation. His number was corrected. I gave them all corrected. Oh. I was going to say, I think ours is corrected. That's why I'm not saying. Oh, you are so good. Okay. I wanted to make it less complicated. So noted. Any other questions? I had a question, Rob. On the audit, can that be done by the town's independent auditor annually? Yes, it can.
6:08 Thank you. Okay. Actually, I did have a question. Is there an intention here to kind of do something like with Measure R where there are applications made for this money for projects and things like that? No decision has been made on that. That's not something that would be put in the ordinance because anything you put in the ordinance can only be changed by a vote of the people. And so we discussed that a little bit at one of our committee meetings and it was agreed that that's the kind of thing that should be flexible so that you can adjust it from time to time as deemed necessary.
6:38 Thank you. Okay. Testimony from the public for those people that are in favor of the ordinance. Anybody wishing to speak in favor? Anybody wishing to... John just walked in. John, are you going to testify in favor of the ordinance or... Yes. Well, okay, if you ask. I think it's a good idea.
7:13 Have you been skiing today, John? Have you been skiing the sure ones today? Thank you. Testimony from those in opposition to the proposed ordinance. Okay, then. General testimony. Kirk. I'm the resident. I've been looking at this tack for a long time. I appreciate all the work that the committee has put into this, as well as the council and everything else.
7:55 I listened to my wife that received the phone call on the survey, and I listened to this on the other phone to hear what was going on. And I've also talked to just a couple of people, so I didn't talk to 200 people, so I don't have a 7% error factor. From talking to different people in the community and from that interaction, I believe that
8:23 The proposal is too general. And what I mean by that is when you start talking about a special tax, 2.5% mobility, arts, that is so general. I support the tax, by the way, the continuation. I'm not opposed to it. It's how to craft it in such a manner that the voters will actually support it. When I talked to John about this several months ago, as well as the TAN manager, I suggested that they...
8:50 Identify specific projects that would push the community forward. I would recommend that to the council as well as to the committee. Things like the track down at Whitmore, that's $1.6 million. Things like the ice rink, finish it out here, Trails End Park, that would be three projects. The cost of those three projects would be about $3.5 million. $3.5 million if you, you know,
9:16 Leverage your COPs or your adopted COPs, that would be about $7 million. You can have all three of those projects done within 18 months. The value of the track at Whitmore is for marketing. I mean, the Olympians have been, you know, really after this particular project for a long time. It would also have a value to our kids and to those people that are exercising and the people that utilize the park.
9:46 The ice rink, our kids again, again our tourism, and again marketing. All of a sudden we now have an ice rink that is viable year round. And Trails End Park is just a project that has been hanging out there and it looks like it's not going to be addressed for a number of years. This would give security to the voters that look, these are the three projects, they're going to...
10:10 Leverage the revenue source, which is about, if you're at 2.5%, about $800,000, $850,000 a year, and you could get these. Then it would go back to the voters again for another list. Yeah, it takes time, which is the reason I think a 51% vote. Let the council prove that they can get this done and let those projects be completed, and then you would have a cap on top of the initiative.
10:40 If it is a $3.5 million worth of three projects, then you're looking at probably about an eight-year cap. And you can calculate that out very easily. You can do it right here. The point that I'm trying to do is, or the point I'm trying to make is that with the recession, with the attitude towards government, especially the federal government, and the state government, what they have done with their budgets,
11:09 There's really a very strong negative feeling about the reliability of government as well as local criticism in the local papers, especially one paper every week. So I would consider identifying three specific projects or four, whatever, using a 51% vote and then putting a cap on it.
11:33 By calculating out where a yearly cap, meaning that it dies in eight years, and eight years from now, the community can come forward with another set of projects. And I do appreciate all the work that you guys have done, but I think when it's too flexible that the community is going to lose some of the votes, or they just think it's going into the town's general fund, and it's going to disappear regardless.
12:00 Regardless of, you know, us using a special tax. Even, you know, recently there's been an issue that's been raised about supplanting money and everything else. That's all I have to say. I appreciate your time. Good luck in your deliberations. And again, thank you to the community that has worked so hard on this. Thank you, George. Is anybody else listening to testify in general? Yes. Greetings again. Alan Bloomer.
12:35 Figuratively, I'm literally throwing my hat in the ring for hopefully one of these seats here come mid-June. Along with what was just mentioned about picking items to work with, to bring to the public forefront as tourists, along with covering the ice rink, we have another emergency meeting coming up with the Board of Supervisors. It just seems atrocious to me that the Mammoth Dog people have been put out of town.
13:05 That's a complete total winter thing for the dog sled teams to not be in town because the way you get and attract people is you have to make it easy and you have to make it obvious. They should be a viable part of our winter festivities and sports here. Covering the ice rink, we'll also be able to bring in some professional ice shows. We can also use that as a venue for music.
13:32 One of my main platforms is running for Town Council is the Sierra Wildlife Sanctuary. It will help us deal with our problem with bears. It's a whole new revenue. One of our sayings is bears and coyotes and cougars, oh my. It's another family-oriented type of venue that would bring in revenue and recreation for our town, much like the addition of the Frosty's mini golf.
13:59 Along with the ice rink, this is the first year. I guess the ice rinks really stepped up and become actually viable. It's too bad the radiator hose blew out. Again, with the Whitmore track, that should be a focus for the council. And Joe Perino has just the great idea of opening Mammoth motocross more than once a year. That week that they were here, Shady Rest was packed.
14:28 Sherwin Campgrounds was packed. I watched those people. The gas they bought, the food they bought, that brought in so much money. We should also open it up to professional snowmobile races. ESPN would be here to cover that. It wouldn't damage the track one bit. It seems to me that that is a perfect venue that is way underutilized, way underappreciated. And I believe the utility tax.
14:56 I agree with Mayor McCarroll that there were some crucial points missing from that phone survey. I think we could have probably hired somebody locally that would have done just as well a job and addressed the issues on that. Thank you again for your time, and we'll be seeing each other. Thank you, Alan. Anybody else wishing to comment? John. Real quick.
15:30 There has been a committee of folks meeting that provided the substance of the recommendation to you all for this two-thirds proposition. Many of those folks are here this evening. I won't speak for them, but Kirk brought up some points that if you have questions in your deliberations, these points were considered very carefully. There are rationale and arguments that may be helpful.
15:55 To understanding why we put together what it is that we did. I don't want to get into all that right now, but if you have questions on that, please feel free to call on us to respond to that. Thank you, John. Anybody else wishing to speak? Matt. Matthew Lehman, citizen. I agree with the measure. I just would like to add that I think there should be a little more specificity in there. I personally would like to see more support go out towards the track as well.
16:26 And hopefully a lot more marketing dollars going towards our town, particularly when this DMO comes to fruition. That's about it. Thank you. Thank you. Anybody else wishing to speak? Lee. How much is this going to add on to our property taxes every year? How much? Nothing on property. It's utility. Utility? How much does it add on to that? It adds on to your utility bill.
17:01 It continues what you're currently paying, which is, I looked at my phone bill and it was about 47 cents a month. Okay, because the reason I was coming here this evening is I feel like the middle class people are being eliminated in this town. They're all moving like to Crowley and other places because they cannot afford to live here. John, you mentioned that if you go to the town offices, I did it one time, you go in, you look to the left.
17:26 There's a lot of foreclosures going on right now. And I don't think that's going to be the end of it. A few people I know have had to foreclose. And I understand we need help. I know second homeowners have told me they're fighting tooth and nails to hang on to what they have. So don't think that second homeowners have a lot of money either. They're fighting to keep what they have. How many things in the future are you going to continue to put onto bonds and bonds and bonds that you'd be eliminating the middle class completely in this town?
17:54 You know, will it ever stop or are we going to keep having to pay all these all the time and be eliminated? Do you want to be like Aspen where everybody lives out of town? This is something we need to think about because we all work very hard to stay here and it's getting tougher and tougher every day. Thanks. Thank you, Lee. Anybody else wishing to testify? Any rebuttal to previous testimony? I don't think so.
18:25 Well, I was going to ask John volunteer to be a source of information. I know your committee discussed the points that Kirk has brought up in depth, and I don't know whether you characterize it as a rebuttal, but could you go through the points and why you elected to do what you did? Yeah, I think we'll just offer a couple of examples. And again, anybody who's part of those conversations, I'm not...
18:54 Feel free to chime in. I think to the first point, I think Kirk's argument is a compelling one, but it has a profound limitation. If you say that you want to do three very specific projects, but then you say you want to do it in the context of a 51% vote, well, we all know and the committee certainly considered that a 51% vote is a commitment of counsel.
19:25 And Council has always lived up to its political commitments. Nobody doubts that. But in the context of a campaign, when you're trying to effectively get that message across the public, at some point you bump up against the fact that, well, is legally those three specific projects going to be exactly where the money goes? And at that point, at a 51% threshold, you can't say that. The campaign has to back off and say, well, it will go into the general fund and it will be a political commitment.
19:54 And excuse me, my forester's calling, sorry. So you can't, I think the committee felt that when we sort of deliberated this, the tactics of doing something like this, you can't, it's very difficult to say we're going to make it for a specific project, but be doing it at 51%, or 50 plus one vote. And I think that the way that the committee worked to structure the three project areas, mobility, recreation, and arts and culture,
20:23 with the hows of how you do that is consistent with what we were hearing from the diocese of the council last week, and I think it's consistent with what, how the committee feels is the most effective way to implement this. It doesn't, it's specific to areas of activity that are needs that are very easily to produce lists of such as and the important projects to go with that without necessarily restrictively binding the hands of decision makers in terms of how that money gets spent. So I think that
20:53 The opportunity to bring this thing forward has been considered in such a way that I think makes sense and is consistent with how the legislative bodies of the town will work with these funds. They will go to specific projects, specific project areas. It will include not just the capital cost of building something, but the maintenance, the operation, the programming of these facilities, which is a key issue. If you look at the ice rig, it's very nice to have...
21:19 That ice rink, but there's no money to maintain it. There's no money to operate. There's no money to administer, make sure the thing is successful. And I think that all the ingredients in the work that the committee did were very well reasoned and very well thought out and considered. And I just think that what Kirk was proposing, it sounds nice and it's a good way to kind of do things, but I think when you look at the reality of really implementing these things and making these happen, it doesn't work. And it's not a formula from which you can win a successful campaign.
21:48 And to Measure R was no more specific than Recreation, Trails, and Parks, as I recall. And the hows were spelled out, you know, the language that the hows in this Measure U proposal, I think, are the same language as it was in Measure R. So it's the same type of focused, concentrated investment without being specific to one single thing that, you know, the ice rink, as I understand it right now, has enormous problems with this infrastructure. So if you said specifically to that ice rink,
22:18 Well, if the pipes blow up next year, are your hands tied? You have to be investing in that ice rink. What if you have to pull all the infrastructure out and start over again? So I think we've been very mindful of not getting council or the town into a box. If it's too restrictive, you can't be targeted and strategic with your investments.
22:36 Don't go away, though. I had a question as it relates to, I hope the group discussed the fact that this could be considered a regressive tax and have an impact on some of our community more than others, but I also wonder if the group discussed
22:58 How you could help anyone apply for and get exemptions from it, which are offered by most of the utilities. Was that discussed? That was not discussed in any detail, but the group is mindful of the fact that those options exist. And that's something I think when we get into the reality of the campaign, these kinds of opportunities would come forward. As well as, I think, calling on or identifying the people who bear most of the burden of paying this tax law.
23:21 Larger businesses and folks in town who, if these investments are strategically made and well made, it will increase visitation, which will help them more with their bottom line, which I think is, that's an opportunity we're looking forward to exploring. Thank you. Skip. John, I guess in an earlier staff memo I saw something where they were discussing the possibility of using $400,000 of it to replace Measure A funds that are coming out for marketing to kind of help subsidize air service. That's almost 50% of...
23:51 What we project to be the annual amount, isn't that supplanting? How can we prevent, I think that's a little excessive, how can we prevent that from happening? Skip, you'll be relieved to know that I think three meetings ago that proposition came off the table. Okay. So that's no longer a part of this. Okay. John? I'm done with John.
24:20 Okay, thank you. You've become undone. General discussion, council discussion, if we're ready. If there's, well, yes, oh, Kirk. It wouldn't be fun if we didn't have a staff. No, come up. Just a, first staff.
24:41 Just a piece of historical information. Measure R is the only measure that has passed with a two-thirds vote. In 1986, we passed a 3%.
24:51 Increase in T.O.T., all that money was politically committed to marketing. There's never been, we've never been nicked on that. And we've had three other voters who have passed a 51% vote. Some of those, again, increased marketing dollars, 1% towards marketing, 1% towards housing, and there was also some money that was set aside for capital projects. And, of course, that money has been leveraged extensively because of the grants or the matching fund grants.
25:21 So John, I agree with you. There's an argument on both sides of this whole debate about how to approach this. And the 51% vote is something historically that the council has never reneged on. And it does make it a little bit easier to get out there. And again, if you put a cap on it.
25:44 You know, if the Council did remade on it, you're not going to have the opportunity, the future Council is not going to have the opportunity, again, to identify specific projects to move forward. I will support it regardless of what the Council does, but if the language gets too loose, then I'm going to have a difficult time arguing.
26:07 With somebody out there that this is where the dollar's here to go. Because I think that becomes the weak side of the approach or the language that was presented in the ordinance. And that's very difficult. I'll say, well, it's going to, and then we're going to have a committee or we might not have a committee. And so you have a problem both ways. Being very specific, you do, you know, those people that don't support those. And then when it's too general,
26:35 I mean, what do you tell somebody? Just go in and park for them all. Thank you. Terry. Terry Stelick, Tourism Rent Commission and Lodging Rental Company owner. You know, I don't mean to stand up here and point fingers or anything else, but the lodging community was very adamant that, and I think that kind of there's reasons why.
27:13 That this not be a general tax. Because with Measure A, there's great dissension out there as far as how it's been used, especially in the last few years. Thank you, Terry. Anybody else wishing to speak for or against in general? Okay, I'll go ahead and close the public hearing. Council of Liberation. Who wants to start? John? I had a number of the same concerns that you had, Kirk.
27:48 And presented those to the group discussing this and didn't get my way, so to speak, on any of them. But it showed me the level or the detail that the group went through in their analysis to come up with what they came up with in the end. And as a side note, I do trust that group with what they came up with and actually agree with it now after going through that process. There are, first of all,
28:18 I'm over the survey that the town did. I think we've been educated in the interim that there were faults in that survey. And so I'm over it. So in hindsight, Skip, if I knew what I know today at the time that I took the vote, I would not have supported spending the $16,000 to take the survey. Having said that,
28:47 There are five reasons, and please bear with me on the reasons if I take a little time, why I do support putting this particular issue on the ballot and letting the voters decide through the voting process whether this passes or not. The first reason that I support it is that this tax, as we all know today, it's not a general tax. It does not go into the general fund.
29:16 And so there will be no question as to how the money will be spent. It won't be spent on quote-unquote town services. The second reason is three weeks ago I challenged John Wentworth and Dina Castor and her group to come up with a proposal in a short time frame which ends up being about three weeks. Those individuals which is now the group
29:45 Took that challenge and I say that those people but the town staff as well and working with the town staff to get to the point to where you are tonight. So I support it because that group has brought forward this proposal this evening in a short time frame. Third, I have a tremendous admiration and respect for Andrew and Dina Castor and for John Wentworth.
30:16 I know that they have support in the community and having that support, I think there's at least a good chance that this will pass. John, of course, has previous experience of passing something on a two-thirds vote. Also, I think we would be remiss if we didn't remember Dave McCoy on this issue. Evan Russell, as a speaker for Dave McCoy, has brought forward the arts and culture.
30:46 As part of this proposal, as we all know, Dave McCoy has done a lot for this community, specifically at the foundation, at the college, contributed huge sums, multi-millions of dollars, to make that college successful, and the housing, and to bring students into that facility, and the arts and cultures will enhance that, and by doing so, will in the end satisfy
31:15 One of Dave McCoy's personal visions for the community of Mammoth Lakes. Finally, I think as been said earlier, a majority of the funding on this measure would come from the larger businesses, businesses like Vaughan's, businesses like Mammoth Mountain Ski Area that have the high utility fees and rates that they pay throughout the year.
31:45 And Mammoth Mountain Ski Area does fully support passing this proposal. So I think that's important to keep in mind as well. Thank you. Thank you, John. Anybody else? I was just going to thank the committee for bringing together what I believe was the consensus that we discussed at last week's meeting. And I fully support the idea of a special tax.
32:13 Times have changed, and I feel it is specific enough without tying the hands of the future of whatever comes next, as long as it falls into mobility, recreation, and arts and culture. Thank you. I would agree with Joe. The only thing that concerns me a little bit is the mobility section of it, the fact that this notion has even been put out, that we could be using up to 50% of this money.
32:42 to subsidize air service. I think it needs to, and I know the committee nixed it, however, that doesn't mean that the next council or the next tourism and rec group that we happen to have couldn't change their mind and decide that yes, air service falls under the mobility heading, and yes, we could, but...
33:02 I feel like our product is
33:32 Behind our marketing and the fact that we're probably 40% finished with what people should be seeing when they come here. And actually 30% of that is provided by Mother Nature. So the town has only really done about an extra 10% to help access and get to those amenities people are coming here for. So we've got our work cut out for us right here within the town limits to really use this money to accelerate programs.
34:01 I want to make sure that these funds are kept within
34:24 I guess the town limits or the four square miles of the town, something to that effect, so that it doesn't at some time in the future get pushed over into subsidizing our air service or doing something. I guess I can't limit the four square miles because that puts the track out, so we've got to pull that corner in. Sorry. I'll take that back. But I do think there needs to be some terminology in here that while we don't want to tie the hands,
34:53 of the town, and we do want to be specific. I think we need to make sure it doesn't get sidetracked in the future. And actually, in what I presented last week, I did try to identify a geographical area, so I don't know if someone from the group wants to speak to why this does not get specific as to the geography of where it could be spent. Oh, Mr. Wentworth in the back row.
35:26 I think that there was discussion about that, and I think that it was the type of discussion that came back to not putting in artificial language that would limit the ability to expend these funds to the purposes for which they're intended. And I think that there's a specific language in there about having a citizens committee and or the TNR commission to start with that's reviewing this process. It doesn't come to council raw. It comes to council.
35:56 Having gone through some sort of a process identifying what the best strategic opportunities are. And I think the track is an excellent example. And I think that the way to leverage these funds, it's bound legally. Rob gave advice as to how physically it has to be, how it is bound legally. But I think it was felt that it would limit the ability to potentially really leverage these funds most effectively. But I think having the oversight provisions in there, the TNR Commission and the Oversight Committee.
36:24 I think is a critical part of this so that things don't come to council just raw and unfiltered and unshaped, but citizens looking at this thing who've invested in bringing this thing forward will continue to bring it forward to you in such a way that it's consistent with your saying scope. But so how are you going to guarantee, I'm a citizen, I'm concerned that this money may get sidetracked and used to subsidize their service. Well, I would say the best way to do it is to get involved.
36:52 And to be part of the process. If you care about it, show up. I think that's the best way to make sure those things don't happen. I mean, that was one of the first things that came up in one of the first meetings we had. And, you know, Rusty said this isn't appropriate for this. And everybody said, look, this cannot be part of this. But I think, I don't know, I trust the citizens. I'm sorry, but with all due respect, John, I'm seeing other issues in town where people do show up and people do voice their concerns.
37:21 They're ignored. Well, I don't know. I think that the committee feels that this was, that the geographic constrictions would be kind of arbitrary. What if we put a cap on a specific item like air service? What if we say no more than 10 percent could go towards subsidizing air service? I think by the time that we go through the election in June and by the time we get a process together for what this looks like, those issues, there'll be plenty of opportunity to address those kinds of things.
37:50 And I think that if you start putting things, you put restrictive language into what it is that gets passed, that could have a whole set of other unintended consequences. You know, at some point you're just at that point of like you have to frame it so it's specific as it needs to be, but it's not constrictive and you have to trust that communities know, you know, will get together and make good decisions. Wendy?
38:14 Yeah, I have some other comments, but I guess in response to what you're saying, Skip, you know, I know that air services may be the issue today for you and maybe some other folks, but it may be something else tomorrow. So, you know, I think that we need to do our best to frame what the values are that we're trying to support in this community, and we can't be constantly defending against the individual issues that we don't want to see happen or the individual items and allow that to derail us, because in the future it'll be something else.
38:44 And then what do we do about that? We can't constantly be attacking those things piece by piece. I think it's our responsibility to try and understand what is a meaningful question to ask of the public about whether or not these are things they value in their community and want to invest in. And so I really appreciate the work of the committee and staff's assistance to them for
39:06 For going through a very rigorous process and very rigorous discussions to try and figure that out. I think Kirk said it very well when he said there are good arguments on both sides of the 50% vote, of what it is that should actually be on the ballot. There are good arguments on both sides. There are a lot of different options that could be pursued.
39:26 But I think that kind of along the lines of what John said, we have a very credible group of people who have stepped forward and are willing to take this on, know what it means to take on a campaign for a specific tax and how much, I mean, the huge amount of work that that's going to be. And I have to respect that and support that and be appreciative of that. And at the end of the day, this is a vote of the people for what it is that they find of value in this town. And so I have to support that as well and support the people who...
39:55 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
40:21 And we have much more unity now amongst the groups that are seeking to support this funding, and I think that's a huge step forward in terms of building community for us. And so I'm very happy to see that too, and I think that that's a great sign for our community of, you know, building community, being healthy, and moving towards making those investments that will make us a better place to live. Thank you. We're in deliberation now, Tony.
40:50 I also support the group's recommendations wholeheartedly and thank the group and staff for all the hard work that has been put into this measure and all the hard work that will be put in between now and June 8th. When I first heard about the special tax, I kind of bristled a little bit because we've shown a 25-year history of being committed to what the will of the people is.
41:17 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
41:46 is a reversion to what Karen, I think, precisely talked about today is local control, the return to local control. And all over California, municipalities, groups of people are coming together and actually taxing themselves because they realize the value of a tax if it's directed to a very specific purpose. In other words, people are beginning to take care of themselves, which is really what
42:15 The whole point should have been all along. And it isn't really a vote of no confidence in this council or previous councils. It is, more importantly, an exercise in the most basic form of government, local control. The people saying, okay, we'll tax ourselves, but we want to control where those monies go.
42:41 And that's the theme with all these taxes that have been successful. And they're springing up all over the state. So I think I finally got the point, if I did. But the other thing that I would like to say is that, you know, after Measure R was passed, I think that the tourism in Iraq has done an excellent job of identifying what the needs of the people are relative to Measure R.
43:12 I see no reason to believe that that won't continue on into the future. I agree with Skip. I think that putting half of the proceeds of the extension toward air service would be a classic case of supplanting. And I think that those arguments will be made, and I trust that tourism and RAC will filter out those kinds of things. So I support it. Any other deliberation?
43:42 If not, I'll call for a motion. Mr. Mayor, I'll make a motion that council approve option as recommended as written by staff. I'll read the whole thing. I guess I probably should. A, wait. A, wait first reading and introduced by title only an ordinance of the town council and people of the town of Mammoth Lakes, state of California, repealing municipal code section 3.4 4.180.
44:09 Land Extending the Utility Users Tax at the rate of 2.5% for the purpose of planning, construction, operation, maintenance, programming, and administration of facilities and projects for mobility, recreation, and arts and culture, and pass to second reading. Do we need to adopt these one at a time, Peter, or do we do it all at once? Okay.
44:35 B. Adopt the resolution putting the major on the June ballot and C. Adopt the resolution providing for an impartial analysis and arguments for and against the major. Thank you. Second. And there's a motion in the second. Jamie, roll call vote, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Thank you. Okay. I'll now adjourn the regular meeting of the town council.
45:05 To Wednesday, March 17th at 6 o'clock in Sweet Z. And we'll take about a two or three minute break so anybody who wants to leave can leave. Our next item on the agenda is the Destination Marketing Organization. Thank you all for coming.
46:08 Is he? Skipped out. ...and call the special meeting of the Council... ...and the Destination Marketing Organization Formation Board... Oh, there you go. I see. There you go. ...to present the Destination Marketing Organization Strategic Direction Report. There you go.
47:00 Um, we can, uh, if we would like to go around the table and just, uh, so everybody can identify who's here, and for the public, you know who's on the Tourism and Rec Commission, who's on the DMO Board, I think you know your council members, so, anyways, we have, uh, Peter Spencer, Tourism and Rec Commission, Shields Richardson, Tourism and Rec Commission, Sean Turner, Tourism and Rec, Eric Walshman, DMO Board, Howard Pickett, DMO Board, John Morris, DMO Board, Wendy Sugimura, Town Council,
47:29 So I just like to take this opportunity to welcome the council members and my fellow commissioners and DMO board members and, you know, thank
47:57 My fellow board members and commissioners for the time and effort that they've put into getting to this point and the energy and time it's going to take moving forward. So, anyways, this is, tonight's intended to provide the council and the public a perspective of a model and the presentation is focused on the goals, strategies, and action steps as a foundation to move forward. And we'd like to hear any
48:28 Concerns or points that she'd like to see addressed as the transition moves forward. And as we go through this presentation, I am going to ask if everybody could hold their comments and questions until the end of the presentation. And so with that, if everybody's OK with that, we'll move forward. Dan, are you over there? OK. So starting with the basic, what is the theme on? Destination marketing organizations often called Convention and Visitors Bureau.
49:02 Are not-for-profit organizations charged with representing a specific destination and welcoming the long-term development of communities through a travel and tourism strategy. DMO serves as an official point of contact. Whoops. That's okay. I didn't read that. I guess our pointer wasn't. Our automatic forwarding wasn't. So DMO serves as an official point of contact.
49:45 And this comes from the DMI, which is the Destination Marketing Association International. And there's going to be a lot of reference to that organization. It's well respected with lots of information. Tourism equals the Mammoth Lakes economy. And approximately 233 million travel spending generated in Mammoth Lakes. Most jobs in Mammoth Lakes are dependent upon travel. Approximately 3,500 jobs directly related to travel.
50:16 Other sectors such as construction, financial, real estate, and the public sector also rely on tourism. Most of the town's operating budget is generated by transient occupancy tax known as TOT and sales tax. Tourism promotion is vital to the community's economic interests. Non-governmental DMO is the industry standard. Almost all managed care resorts utilize a non-governmental DMO for marketing.
50:48 Majority of worldwide DMOs are independent, not-for-profit organizations. 64% versus 19% government agencies. Slightly more than half, 52% are membership organizations. 61% of DMOs have a contract with their primary funding scores. Primary roles of a DMO spend almost 50% of their budget on sales and marketing efforts. Segments represented in sales and marketing efforts include consumer, leisure,
51:20 Convention and Conference Sales, Travel Trade, Communications and Public Relations, Visitor Services and Information, including Welcome Centers. Existing Maniflates Model. Currently, the sales and marketing efforts for the destination are handled by the Tourism and Recreation Department, which is a department within the Townsby Municipal Government. And why should that change? To leverage government funding with private sector funds,
51:48 Engage entire business community's knowledge and energy through cooperative efforts. Strengthen the advocacy voice for the local tourism and travel industry. And develop a non-governmental entity that is more flexible and entrepreneurial. Behavioral goals. Four goals. Just to let you know that these goals are expanded in your full strategic document. The economic growth.
52:19 Promote tourism in a way that generates increased travel spending. Number two, engage the local community and build support for tourism. Build a public-private partnership that works for the benefit of the community. Three, give the tourism and travel industry a strong voice. The DMO will speak to issues with tourism and economic development. Four, emphasize a year-round and shared approach to marketing. Work to increase year-round tourism to grow the local economy.
52:50 The strategy focus, one, position and differentiate the destination, two, utilize the internet and technology to the fullest, three, focus on air service and ease of access, four, cohesive promotional strategy for special events, five, build community support for the organization and the industry, the DMS strategic actions, advertising and branding, continually focus on the Mammoth Lakes brand,
53:29 Website development, online promotion, continue to upgrade and enhance its website and expand online marketing strategies. Sales, develop and implement sales programs in targeted markets. For public relations, comprehensive programs designed to reach target settings, visitor information, content development and on-site experience of the Welcome Center. Special events,
53:59 Develop an integrated plan for promoting events collectively instead of individually. Seven, research and measurements. Develop ongoing research and intelligence to make informed marketing decisions. Community industry support. Focus efforts on initiatives that bring the industry together. The structure of the DMO. The DMO will be incorporated as Mammoth Lakes Tourism, so that will be how you hear
54:29 The D.O. referred to from now on. Amanda Place Tourism shall have the status of a 501c6, a non-profit mutual benefit corporation. It will be a membership organization designed to maximize participation by its constituents. The board of directors will be comprised of seven members, two representatives of the Lodging Association, one representative of the Chamber of Commerce,
55:01 One representative of Mammoth Mountain Ski Area, one representative of the Cultural Arts Special Events category, that membership category or at-large, as there's not an official group that's organized right now, and one representative of the retail restaurant membership category or an at-large seat, as well as one Mammoth Lakes Town Council designee. The status of the Mammoth Lakes Tourism?
55:30 A DMO transition board established, which is referred to as the DTB. Legal services have been retained. Accounting and financial services have been retained. Bylaws have been drafted and approved. Articles of incorporation have been filed. Strategic directions report has been completed. Recruiting firm has been retained to search for the executive director, which will be referred to as ED.
56:02 Anticipate hiring the ED by mid-May. Oh, sorry. Status of Mammoth Lakes Tourism. Operational transition begins once the executive director's in place. Sorry, I got lost. How will Mammoth Lakes Tourism be funded? Measure A funds through a contract with the town of Mammoth Lakes. Membership dues, business development and corporate sponsorships,
56:40 Co-op marketing and advertising programs. Examples, website, booking commissions, collateral. Peer resort DMO budgets. These are many of the western state ski areas. And as you can see, Mammoth is fairly low on that list. Transition to Mammoth West Tourism. The current tourism department team will fulfill current responsibilities and commitments through the DMO transition.
57:17 Staffing and marketing responsibilities will transition from Town of Mammoth Lakes to Mammoth Lakes Tourism after the Executive Director is in place. The Transition Board recommends that all Measure A funds go to Mammoth Lakes Tourism. What's next? Funding levels to be determined from the Town of Mammoth Lakes Measure A, reconciliation of the two departments in the demo, contract negotiations,
57:51 And then transition. Very exciting. So basically, we, you know, as I said before, entertain questions because there's a lot of work still to be done moving forward. So I know that the DMO board is committed to taking whatever time it's going to take. This month along, we have quite a few days and have a couple of that set up. So I entertain questions. No questions, but just a quick comment.
58:36 On your deal, it said full measure aid funding, and I can only speak for myself, but you have my support, that I support full 100% funding. It's obvious, but I know it's a question mark, so. Thank you. That's awesome. I just have a question. I just want to thank all of you guys for all of you. It's so exciting. I know that we were hoping, we had been hoping to
59:17 You know, we're still looking at, you know, the transition, we've been informed that there's money within the current budget to keep
59:49 I think that we're pretty confident that it should be a fairly smooth transition, but it's going to take a lot of commitment on everybody's part to make that happen.
1:00:15 So because of the delay, does anybody else have any? Yeah, I would just say, you know, obviously, we all hope to have had the executive director chosen by February, March, that didn't happen. We tried to do it on our own. We didn't get the types of resumes and the types of people who were expressing their interest in that we thought position. So when we had the executive recruiter, that kind of slows down a little bit. But right now, the recruiter is in the market looking for people.
1:00:43 I think there are probably three or four pretty good candidates that he's identified at this point. He's not ready to have us expose any of those names yet. But the plan is right now that he'll produce four to five candidates that the board will be able to interview the first or second week of April. Once that process is done, hopefully we'll find one or two lead candidates and then bring those candidates back for kind of a broader group of stakeholders. So I think we're on track to potentially be able to have the person in place by May.
1:01:14 Hopefully up their money. I'm just a little concerned about us feeling constrained by artificial planning for ourselves. Certainly. I think that's why you thought it's so important that the current organization could continue to do their jobs. So just act like this is no change in things. Once the executive director gets in place and you transition the staff and the responsibilities, then that person makes better decisions they wouldn't make about the staff and the strategies and the plans.
1:01:47 Just like you would in any other kind of organization when you were in the leader. My comment was kind of along the same lines as I believe most of you know that Lynda and the two council members have been deeply involved in the reorganization because of reading new drafts and all of that kind of thing. The only thing I would say is that when we go into the reconciliation process, we're going to work this all out. I'm looking forward to that.
1:02:20 I'm hoping that we're not constrained by any kind of an artificial time limit. But I do want to suggest to you that, kind of jokingly, but not totally, is on your slide number five where it says you spend almost 50% of your budget on sales and marketing efforts, you might want to tell people what else it's being spent on because the presumption would be, oh, staffs, staffs, staffs. Just that, you know, it says you're going to spend that, but it didn't really say the other primary rules of how you're
1:02:49 I think what that was trying to point out was other DMOs are spending at least 50%.
1:03:18 Okay. It's just the way it got written. Right. Well, right now, we're not. And the idea is for us to get closer to that. Right. And I presume that it was just to make sure the community understands that it's not necessary to say there's only specificity. It's on the DMO's strategic access, number five. Business information, two, 12, page 12.
1:03:56 Yeah, well I think that that would speak to all the businesses that are involved with
1:04:26 The DMO as a membership, that there's going to be some direction as to what each of those businesses have to offer. I know the lobbying community right now, if somebody calls and it's something that we've just done amongst ourselves as businesses, that if I don't have something that is going to work for somebody, then I know what other people do. So that is something that, you know, through, that, you know, that's one of the hopes, is that this brings the business community together and that, you know, we can have some of those dialogues and know what each of us does.
1:04:55 So that we can better serve our guests and our community members. But what you mean, you don't really have to spell it out, right? Yeah. And what I would say, that's a role in the chamber, is actually has tried to see in the past, and we're really into the world by the community. We did a program last year called Nanocro E1, where we asked business owners to send employees to a training program, so that each business could have our employees to realize, hey, if I'm not getting
1:05:25 I just want to make sure a couple things. One, one of the things I get so much is
1:05:57 Is there a place I can go to get information for what is going on in town, what is available, where I can get lodging, all this kind of place? So am I correct in saying, telling people that this DMO is kind of headed in that direction, that you're going to be organizing all of that, and once we get up and running, you will have the resources to wear the one-stop shopping? Is that a good way to describe it? That would be something that, yes,
1:06:26 We could do, we already have Travelocity on our website right now. And so that's kind of, it has a lot of the people as far as the lodging part goes. And so, you know, we'll keep moving forward with our website and the development of what the rest of the community has. I know there's a special events coalition and we're looking at consolidating calendars. So all those things are going to be, you know, worked out and worked through once we, you know,
1:06:52 But that is the standard practice of most DMOs, is to be the sort of the central point for all restaurants, retail, all visitor information that might need to take place. It's part of the direction. I think we're all on board that there will be a welcome center, visitor center support. There will be special event support. I mean, there will be a broad array of responsibilities that the DMO will have. I mean, and it's spelled out very thoroughly within the plan.
1:07:22 So I think exactly what you're asking is exactly what the DMO is going to be delivering, which is representing all the business, tourism, and visitor interest that might potentially be asked about would be presented by the DMO. Either through the visitor center, through the website, through the clutter that they produce, through by calling the DMO specifically, there's a brighter way to get that information. I think it's expected and anticipated that the DMO would be the repository of all that information. The other thing is that people are asking me is the position of
1:07:54 The Executive Director. What are some of the criteria that we're looking at? I think some of the big criteria that we're looking for is extensive marketing and sales experience in the tourism sector. Somebody who's preferably run a private, you know, DMO type of organization. Those would probably be the two biggest things. And just the level of experience and maturity for somebody to come in and head off an organization like this and get it started in
1:08:26 Stood up in the organization or in the community so that people really look at it immediately as having great impact on the ability to market. So we didn't want to be, and we talked about it a lot, didn't want to be kind of penny wise and kind of foolish and say, you know, abnormally low budget for what the executive director needs to make the organization a success. And I think it's going to be important, one of the key factors for me is to find somebody who's going to be able to pull the community together.
1:09:06 The various different entities and businesses, because one of the beauties of a DMO is the private money that goes into it. The more that that pile grows, the more power it is out of the market. And there has to be somebody who's dynamic, who can come in and understand the community, understand the concerns in various different fashions, and bring everybody together and say, this is, we're going in a positive direction, it's going to be good for everybody. And that leadership quality has definitely been in the background.
1:09:32 I think that's a key issue, and that's one of the things people who respect me about, is the person to understand, man, what they know. I don't care what you say, we're a unique animal up here. I know people think it's easy to live here, it's fun, and all that. And they do everything they did somewhere else up here, just give us a little bit of time. And it doesn't always work out. I think people are a little bit concerned that if someone doesn't really understand our community, that we could be a long time down the road before we realize any benefits tomorrow.
1:10:02 Well, and I think that's part of the role of the board, too, representing all the different parts of the community. We need to get that personal guidance on how to be a success and how to make the right decisions without, you know, basically making all the decisions for the person. Yeah, I will say that that was actually expressed with interviews with the recruiter when, you know, we all spoke to him prior to the season being put together. So, anyways, I think that that was pretty well spelled out to him. Gary, I just want to say I'm very excited that we have all the work.
1:10:34 Unqualified support right after E&A.
1:10:36 So
1:10:36 We'd be all around the hope until July 7th, you know.
1:10:47 How do you plan to fund the
1:11:02 how we plan to fund it was it well right yeah
1:11:10 finally agreed to match the town's money
1:11:19 To basically pay the salary to pay the recruiter for the first year so that they go out and they don't have somebody coming in and say, wait a minute, I'm not sure if I'm going to get paid three months from now. So, you know, we would really do that and it obviously becomes a part of the operating budget for the DMO on their basis once they get passed the first year. Quick question. The $2.2 million that we have as a budget for marketing, is that the total sum of our measure eight dollars or is that what we did for the measure eight dollars?
1:11:49 That's what we get from the measuring dollars. Is that the total amount? Yeah. If I could, it's not. 2.2 includes some additional revenues that are generated by the department currently through fees, through advertising, co-op opportunities, any what we call refunds and rebates that people pay to participate in some programs that we have ongoing. Last year, we received about 1.9 out of measuring was the formula.
1:12:17 The forecast going into this coming fiscal year is about 1.8, remembering that the formula is 2.5 points of the 13 points of TOT that are collected. So you guys haven't put together much again as to what, if you get the business community involved, part of that question might be. That's our next step, actually, is our funding. That's our next step. Actually, that raises a question. You guys have a briefing.
1:12:58 You know, good strategic direction to plan about how, you know, working with the principal operating principles and the key areas of focus. And the next step really is to start getting creative talking. Are you guys planning on doing much of that before doing that? I think what we thought our role was, and Terry, you can jump in here if you think of it. I think we thought our role was to set that strategic direction because we were trying not to get it so far in front of that and the ED here that the person felt like we were handing him an organization, him or her an organization that was already preconceived.
1:13:31 So I think we felt like the strategic direction was where we can stop. Once the person gets replaced who's going to be held accountable for all of this, then that person could take the plan and create the actual operations plan that he or she thinks they need to make the thing work. Anybody from the public want a comment or have a question? I have a comment and question. One, I like the world moments a lot. It's kind of exciting, very exciting.
1:14:05 And I've also liked, I like looking at what Mammoth Mountain's done over the last year or two with their marketing. It seems like it's been really effective, you know, they've branded themselves a little bit differently, and I like seeing that we're going to be doing that too. If you look at Vail, a lot of other areas, they actually have a logo or a brand for their community, which we don't have. You can go up and see Vail, they have a flag flying above, you know, a lot of their stores and communities and whatnot. So that's exciting.
1:14:34 But the question I have with regard to $2.2 million, assuming that other funds, for example, this utilities user tax or something like this and part of these funds can go in there, are you going to be trying to hold on to the existing funds you have and make sure that you keep those or even increase them? Because this seems to me that this is such a vital part of our community and it compounds itself. The more marketing we get out, the more people we come, the more TOT we have.
1:15:05 More sales tax, we have more funds. So I just think it's really critical to hold on to that if at all possible. And I don't know if there are any other sources you're planning on trying to drive money from, et cetera. I was going to say, our intent is that's the base of our funding. Everybody wants to leverage those funds to increase our budget. So if we were to receive a bigger fund, . Well, and that's part of the idea here is that as a private organization, we should
1:15:38 Sid, look at what the situation is to decide what we need to spend, be competitive in the market, and then figure out as a business organization how we're going to fund it with the major funds and any other funds that we need to put together to make sure we're better in playing. And I would point out that when we look on page 17 of the presentation, our nearest competitor, South Bay Donald, spends exactly done it, 14 or 14. So I think it's really important that we do quite a bit of the money to us. Yeah, it's just, it's really interesting to me because you can, I just mentioned this hour,
1:16:09 If you can walk into, you know, Costco, you see Mammoth, Mount Scurie, and you turn on KTLA, you see Mammoth, Mount Scurie. And I think we need to see Mammoth as a community on there as well, or work in conjunction with them. I don't know if there'll be a discussion on that later too. But it seems that over the years, a lot of marketing dollars of individuals to kind of go on different directions. And this is great because it looks like they're starting to pull this process. Right in the town, but the town now plays the queue. It was very, very important. Yeah, I agree. Very important.
1:16:38 And, you know, branding was, we were in that process as well at the same time as the mountain. And so the town, actually, as a community, has some pretty good groundwork going forward for the branding. And so then we actually anticipate on finishing that process and actually coming up with branding and moving forward. So that would be the intent. I have a quick question for Gary. How do you leverage your 2.4 more funding? What do we need by that?
1:17:07 We still have a membership organization, so the private businesses, we're going through the process where there could be membership fees for different things that go in. And the advertising that the DMO might do, if we have a website, things like that, we could generate revenue. And really like a private sector business and come up with revenue ideas just like another private sector business. Yeah, I mean, if they have cooperative advertising, cooperative trade shows, I mean, we already do that to a certain extent with the town.
1:17:35 There's projects that we're co-funding currently as far as representation firms in Australia and the UK. Those types of activities would continue. We would hope that more of our business partners in town would join in on that and become a part of those co-ops and further leverage and developers that were already spent. Yeah, I mean, it sounds to me more of a cooperative effort than a leverage effort. I think with leveraging, when you get $2 million to go to the bank, you get $6 million.
1:18:10 One of the things important, Eric being on, is the difference between, you know, we look at sort of the DMO as more of a gay people here as what people do when they're here. Not that they're exclusive to each other, but that's what they do when
1:18:51 I would suggest that you financially decide to make the decisions about financing the rest of the
1:19:33 And then be very robust in the outreach very soon and very transparent. Because I'm privy to it and I'm very lucky, but I get a lot of questions because there are a lot of people who aren't privy to what's going on. And I think you can make or break the resources as the group participated in. And other than that, I can point out that we are severely underfunded. It's a very similar structure.
1:20:08 The other important thing to remember about those funding members when you look at those are the Colorado resorts who are outspending us for the most part. The Utah resorts who are outspending us for the most part are supported by a very aggressive state tourism organization that spends almost all of the money on skiing and tourism. So in all those ads that we see down in Los Angeles right now coming from Utah and from Colorado,
1:20:40 Those are funded over and above what the resorts are spending and over and above what the towns are spending. So we're absolutely getting killed. And the other thing in American Society of Tahoe, too, is that Tahoe is actually Nevada, you can buy it. So the casinos support the funding of the South Bay Tahoe DMO as well as the California side. So it's both. So I mean that $4.44 million is a combination of most states. It's a bi-state organization. Is one of your potential leveraging
1:21:09 And truly leveraging, but not at the bank of the time. Is that there is some that limited California Department of Tourism in Canada. We're already a participant in what's called the SNOW Committee with the California Travel and Tourism Commission. And we, there are about four or five resorts, Mammoth being one of them, that fund that special effort. And for that, they basically create advertising and talks about skiing in California.
1:21:39 But unfortunately, California is a state that's blessed with a variety of things that they can talk about. But in Colorado, Utah, where it's a little bit more one-dimensional. So while we have, I think that that campaign is probably worth close to $2 million, $2 million a year. It's spent out of the destination markets to draw people to come to California to ski. It's nowhere near what Colorado and Utah are spending. That $4.19 order that was in Park City, that's just
1:22:10 I know that the ski areas, I think in basically all of our resorts, there's not a consolidation of the DMO in the ski area. They usually have their core marketing. Why is that? I don't know that for a fact. I think that's true. I've seen anybody who's been in the ski business a lot longer than me. Next question. There are partnerships out there. And there are co-funding meetings.
1:22:38 But I would venture to guess that the number's been Terry out of the board or just DLO. Some of those companies were 10 million dollars. But it's traditional to have marketing for the mountains separate and apart from the DLO. And then the best case is that that's very integrated and, you know, it works together. It doesn't work kind of at cross purposes. It is exactly what we're talking about here. You know, we as the mountains.
1:23:05 You know, it's really important. We'd be a part of the organization and we participate as an active member. Sure. But why, why, why is that? Well, usually the Mountain's private business. Private and it's being, you know, you're representing support. So they would be a part of your game co-op just as any other business would. They're just a larger business. Okay. Any other questions? Yeah, I, um, I want to thank you for the skill set that this person should have. But I also want to say that I think this is,
1:23:49 Tremendously important initiative down in that place for the area in order to be able to grow amethystics. It's critical to the less than success, so there's some self-interest for me in saying that, but for the lighting industry as a whole, for the less than to be successful, the lighting industry has to grow, and for the lighting industry to grow, the town has to grow. And I think this is an important step forward for that.
1:24:23 I just urge, I offer my support and everyone's support. But as a question, in terms of a reservation system, some of the funds that you normally see generated at in this kind of organization are through the commission, the commission commissions. Will you be planning on establishing the reservations program and generating some of those? Well, we do receive some commissions right now through the Tradelosity.
1:24:55 That's on the website. We do receive a commission from that. As well as there's advertising opportunities on the website. And there's several businesses within the community or some larger opportunities for larger sponsorships outside the community to advertise on the website as well. We're receiving those funds as well. So, you know, that discussion can come up as far as, you know, do we, how do we grow Crablocity? Is there another option that we can, you know,
1:25:23 Work with on our website. So, you know, let's think those questions will definitely come forward. But to your point, it's not uncommon, Stephen, for DMOs to have a call center and a reservation center. Oftentimes that's outsourced to a private 24-hour service that's out there. It doesn't have to be part of the organization specifically, but it is a service that a lot of DMOs do provide. So just like a central reservation for the destination. It's pretty common.
1:25:50 And it is another way to generate funds. There's usually a commission involved. But you also have to pay for the service too. So it's kind of, sometimes it doesn't always pay for itself. So it's kind of a balancing act. And there is a bit of a history in Mammoth with the attempt to go down the central reservation path. And it got to a threshold and it didn't go much farther. Which doesn't mean that the new organization wouldn't want to perhaps consider that.
1:26:19 It's just that the history didn't make it a priority in this first effort. I think we're looking at getting the organization moving forward, and then we start looking at those opportunities. Peter? Can I have one more time to look in the future for this community? I have the executive, some of them in my hands. First point says we're going to be the world's renowned destination, community. We need to do it a year round.
1:26:58 So, we have a great scheme here and there, we have a great summer, all kinds of fails and everything else. But in town, we need more to offer for the market. That's why I'm looking in the future. We have to, you know, we have to build not only a recreation center, what I'm proposing for years and years, but we need a big hall like a convention center. And that would take care of the shortages.
1:27:33 I've been around a million results, believe me, not only in this country, Canada, Europe, all over the place. And that's what we are lacking here. So that's infrastructure. So we'll be looking at people and influence that in any manner at will, but we'll be marketing, you know. Conventions, not for 50 people. You're looking at 300, 400 people. Do you know what kind of money that brings you to?
1:28:01 I'd probably go on five or six of those inventions a year just in my line of work. And yeah, it brings in a lot of money, and I agree. I think what our rule is going to be that once that's built, we're just asking more. I think you're pretty smart. Help! Help! So we have quite an extensive
1:28:35 Any other questions? I speak to something with regard to special events, because special events, you draw so many people to town, as John pointed out, overarching roles, really bring people in, especially if you look at the travel reports that we get, the spikes in the summer for those weekends where we have so many different events that draw people to town. And I'd like to speak a little bit to how special events would
1:29:10 I think the focus has been that the DMO, MLT, will really be more oriented towards the marketing of those, again, trying to draw people, but there will still need to be support from the town, to coordinate town services, as well as, as somebody mentioned earlier, with regard to the chamber, coordinating more of the consolidation of the county.
1:29:40 And that's more business to business. But the DMO is really focused on marketing all of our events. Right now in the summer, but hopefully year-round, and the strategic actions and goals of the DMO really is to try and unify us. As you all know, together, currently loosely organized events coalition, with this task as well, trying to coordinate our calendars so that we can have a more live voice in
1:30:13 We're promoting our events, and I look forward to the DMO doing much better, really marketing all of our events, so that hopefully they can flow one right into the other for the entire year. We said we do it, but only for non-alcohol events. Yes, transparency and Indian word out, as Deb said that, I think that is definitely going to be important, so otherwise,
1:30:57 I remember at one point first, and that's that the Tourism and Recreation Commission also was very, very supportive that all the Measure A dollars go to the DMO at the point of transition. So they said that they aren't retained by the Town of Mammoth Lakes, that they do go forward and they do go into the DMO. It wasn't just the transition board, but it was also the TMR Commission were both unanimous on that point. And I think it's really important, mainly because of the skill set. You really feel that the DMO is going to have
1:31:27 Thank you very much. Thank you.
1:31:56 So I just want to make sure that that plan was clear as well. It wasn't just a transition plan, but it was also the TNR Commission that was very supportive of all Measure A funds going to the DMO immediately. That was one comment I was going to make. I was going to thank John for his opening comment, and I was wondering if we're going to get any more commitment from anyone to see me dedicating those Measure A dollars towards the DMO. I guess I just have a question about that. Since it's not going to a Tourism and Recreation Commission, are any of those funds, they're not, they're still, they're currently just
1:32:27 Is it dedicated to the tourism side of marketing, or do they go through recreation? Partially to Parks and Rec. So what's the plan of Parks and Rec is going to be funded with all this money going through? I guess what we're asking is that if those are eight dollars, do you go eventually? And when you put a time frame on it as to 18 months or whatever the case may be, you can do that. Day one. I mean, I'm not going to speak to that more, but
1:32:58 I think us as a commission are very concerned that the measure of dollars do get to do and that we transition some of the dollars that are being spent for parks and rec rather than the general fund be expended from the general fund eventually. Was that the intention of measure A to begin with? To go to marketing? Yes. The most comments I've heard from my constituents are, well, measure A's for marketing. Why wouldn't you get them?
1:33:31 The reconciliation process is trying to figure out what that transition is so that it's something else off the foot in working out the how and the when. Or where else in the general fund, will you fund recreation in Parks and Rec? So, I mean, there's other tough decisions that have to be made with your budget for next year that don't include Measure A. So we want to make sure that that's part of your discussion processes. But what are the other departments that can potentially be
1:34:05 And for those of you in the community that don't know, the Mammoth Lakes Welcome Center is now a California Welcome Center. And so with that, kind of exciting, we're going to get some additional signing down, 395, and some good stuff. So anyways. You too, thank you.
1:34:44 With additional funding? No, it doesn't give us any funding. We actually get to pay for that on it. But, you know, with that signing, that that's pretty important. Because right now, we haven't been able to actually get that out on it. And then it's also advertised through the state of California. So there's a lot that goes with that that's very beneficial. You're right, Terry. You're not going to be ordering since 207 numbers on these signs out there? Yep.
1:35:13 All right. Well, you know, I appreciate everybody coming. If we don't have any other questions or comments or any direction you'd like to give us, then I would ask for, we need a motion better. Our special meeting was to hear it.