TransparentMammoth

Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2011

Planning & Economic Development Commission

· recording 2 hr 52 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

357 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 In the meeting to order, our first item of business is the Pledge of Allegiance. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Roll call, please, Karen. Mr. Clark? Here. Mr. Dugan? Here.

0:40 Here. Here. Thank you. Next item, reports from the Commission. Yes, I have just passed out to all of you an article from the Wall Street Journal on other ski towns that are looking at TOT, so that will come up in a bit, okay? Second thing, as you know, one of my primary concerns is water resources and water availability.

1:10 And this week's Time Magazine had a whole article on the parched earth. And as it turns out, that's the lake I grew up on in Austin, Texas. And that's what's left. And it talks about how much water we lose in this country through leaky pipes, like 7 billion gallons every year of drinking water.

1:37 Same lines when I was at the Water District meeting last Thursday evening. They had a graph that shows how they have been working on leaky pipes for almost 10 years. And they call it unaccounted water because they can't trace it. But in June of 2002, we were losing 37 million gallons through leaky pipes. And now, this June, we have recorded less than 5 million. So that shows you how much progress we've made. And I think that's very...

2:07 Very encouraging. And that's it. Thank you. Okay. Sharon, can I borrow your glasses? Thank you. Following on your water, Greg Norby told me a few months ago that if everybody left town in the summer and there was not a soul in our four square miles,

2:29 We would use far more water than we use over the holidays at Christmas or President's Day weekend when town is packed. It's just amazing how much water. The irrigation? The irrigation that we use, yeah. I feel, I don't know what decade this song came from, but you know the one, Stop Children, What's That Sound? Everybody Look What's Going Around? That's how I feel about Mammoth right now. Something is happening this summer. It is just looking so much better. And I started making a list of some of the really cool things that have happened.

2:59 Well, just, for instance, for Public Works, Meridian, gets paid, bingo, it gets striped, bingo, it's just done, just like that. I just was very impressed with that. I'm really impressed with the, let's see, the Lutheran Church, what they're doing with their landscaping, the new sign for the Plaza Center, paint and polish, the deck on John's Pizza Works, bunting, it just looks terrific. It's been restained, it looks very good.

3:26 Century 21 has been painted, Sierra Manners, the condo complex on Old Mammoth Road has a new paint job that looks very good. Ocean Harvest is just, that's really looking uptown. I'm really amazed at how good that looks. That's right. Excuse me, the Red Lantern, and it's also going to be Jimmy's Taverna, I understand. It's going to be a Greek restaurant and a Chinese restaurant, so I can't wait.

3:51 Roberto's, of course, the flowers, and you know, you think about it, Old Mammoth Row, you know, me and the post office, and those flowers just make such a difference, and I'm seeing this all over town. Well, now we've got Roberto's, which started it, and then next to that we have the Eastern Sierra Community Bank, and then next to that we have Remax, and so we just have this band of gorgeous wildflowers going down Old Mammoth Road and more coming, I think more will be coming at the Lutheran Church.

4:15 What else is looking good? Oh, on the village, they put up banners on Minaret, which are looking very spiffy, and they're readable, and you go by. And what else have I seen? Did I get them all? But this whole idea of paint and polish, and, you know, we may be down, but we're not out, and people are really doing good stuff, and it's just, it's wonderful to see, and I just, all these things, just this summer, it just is a whole different feeling in town, and I feel great about that, so. And I didn't sing for you, I just quoted the lyrics, I didn't sing them.

4:43 Which I was tempted to do. Thank you. You ready? Yes. Thank you. Just a couple of things, just for clarity. It is two restaurants in the same building. The Chinese restaurant is the Red Lantern. It's downstairs and reopening in November. And Jimmy's will be upstairs opening in a year from now. So it's not Greek one day, Chinese the next.

5:09 But it's both in the same building. Both in the same building. Okay, so I was right. And the second, just for point of reference, that was called For What It's Worth by Stephen Stills, Prosby, Stills and Nash, and I believe it came out on the Deja Vu album in 1968, and I was not paying attention at that time. I was very too young, but I caught up with that in high school. Anyway. Very good. Moving on. I had no intention of doing that.

5:37 I've been privileged to be part of the Economic Stimulus Council and I think that we've had three meetings and they've been extremely productive meetings and what this is doing is bringing community leaders and people of varied interest in the community together to discuss some solutions to our economic challenges here in the community and not to wait and see what happens so much as to take

6:05 Take action on things that we can do today. Where we have a lot of focus on events and event spaces and business to business development and how we can actually get out there and affect our own future instead of waiting for something to affect us. We meet on a weekly basis. I think this week we're taking a break, but absolutely it is putting

6:30 Putting actions in place right away because there's a lot that we have to do. Winter is here. If you're not planning for it, it'll surprise you. It may surprise you tomorrow if it gets too cold and it rains. But proud to be part of this group. There's a lot of great ideas and a lot of great actions and people taking a lot of initiative to get information out that allows us to make good business decisions. So I'll be bringing

6:59 Some information forward to the commission and anyone else who has questions about it and what's going on. It uses, it's definitely a volunteer effort and there's a lot of work being done by a lot of volunteers. Thank you. Thank you. My version of what's happening in town, Elizabeth, involves the lakes basin. Noelle and I do the mine tour on Fridays up behind cold water.

7:27 And for the last three Fridays, we almost couldn't do it because we couldn't find a place to park. I've never seen those trailhead parking lots so full. Wow. But the place is just packed with people. So we're good at something. Well, the thing that makes me so happy is everybody I see in town is smiling. I mean, not just the locals, but people are so happy to be here. I've only encountered one person with attitude, and he was just stopped right in the middle of Old Mammoth Road while he...

7:55 You know, slowly unloaded his gear from his car and just sort of, he was on vacation, so, but that's one person. Everybody I see is smiling and happy and just so, it's wonderful. Well, along those lines, I was stunned. I was looking for one item and went to three different stores because at store one, they said, we don't have it, but go to this store, store two, you know, helping each other. That, I thought was rather very impressive, so.

8:22 Everybody is happy when they send you to a competitor. It's good. And one other thing I wanted to mention for my fellow commissioner, I think you recall that the town council now regularly has on their agenda a commission reports section, and the focus of that is for us as the planning commission whenever we have something significant that we think that the council ought to know about.

8:50 To show up and make a report. So I'd like to remind all of you to think about that each time we have a meeting. And during commissioning reports, if there's something that you think fits that category, let's discuss it. Why don't you tell them what we just talked about? I mean, that's a pretty big deal, I think. I don't know if they're aware of it, because they're thinking about the settlement and all that stuff. And, you know, they've got really heavy-duty problems. We did have four pretty good in... Yeah, that's really positive stuff. Four different things. Okay.

9:20 Thank you. All right. The next section of the meeting is our first comments from the public opportunity. This is a portion of the agenda that provides you, the public, with an opportunity to address us on matters that are not specifically listed on the agenda. Is there anybody who would like to make comments at this time? Bruce Woodward, architect. I just want to say that we had a really great meeting yesterday afternoon on signage for the town.

9:56 And I think everybody was really well put together, get together, and I think it's heading in the right direction. I just wanted to bring that up and so that the people on the commission know about that. But I think it was really a very positive move forward. That's all. Thank you. I should have reported on that. Do you have anything to add? No, it was a good meeting. It was all the stakeholders starting at the airport with Caltrans, and we stopped at various places and sort of stood in a circle and assessed.

10:26 What, you know, what it was in terms of giving people guidance. And there's also a concept which I hadn't thought about before called reassurance. When people turn off 395, they want to be reassured. They are, in fact, headed for Mammoth. So there are guidance signs, there's traffic signs, and there are reassurance signs. So it's very interesting. Maybe John, I don't know, maybe John has something to add. Because he was there. No, I think that we had a good cross-section of people involved. I think that there were a lot of...

10:58 A lot of good ideas that came out of it. We had the people that we needed to talk to about the decisions, again, Caltrans, and I think we learned a lot from them, but I think they also learned a lot from us. I think when we talked to Mark Reistetter and I said, when you get to the end of the airport road and you're at 395 and it says Bishop and Lee Vining, 90% of the people that are looking for Mammoth Lakes don't know which one to go towards. So even little things like that were...

11:25 Kind of aha moments for people. So we learned a lot from them. They learned a lot from us. I think setbacks, things that we may not have considered or a lot of the regulatory signs and things that we have to have and distances and all that that are not allowing us to maybe reduce as many signs as we had hoped, but at least we have a better understanding. So it's a good process. And as soon as we showed Mark the Lee Vining to the right and Bishop to the left, he smiled and took a picture of the sign. So the man from Caltrans, that was good.

11:54 That was Mark from Caltrans. Yeah, Mark from Caltrans. I'm sorry. Thank you, John. Anyone else? Okay. Next item is our agenda, item one, under presentations, a presentation by the TOT committee. I'll introduce the item first. The town council, as you may know, at their last council meeting, accepted the overall work programs of the town. That includes our community development and joint public works programs.

12:26 The Council emphasized and created a new priority for us in community development to take on the enforcement of TOT issues. It is a form of code compliance, and to assist finance, we are internally going to treat this as a code compliance issue and begin tracking, informing, communicating, and enforcing the collection of TOT.

12:52 Substantially, there's been a tremendous amount of work that's been done, and Terry Stellick is going to brief you. This is a system that we'll use to implement GIS, our parcel map database, and our code compliance software, and our key person will be Pam Koblarz. So this is a fairly significant shift in our resources, and it speaks precisely to the article that Commissioner Clark has passed out.

13:21 In fact, today we just had a preview meeting of turning our now basic gov program into a system that can automate the collection of notification of business licenses and TOT activities. So this is going to be a high priority for community development. We'll organize a program. We already have a committee and a partner.

13:48 In this effort, who's done a tremendous amount of work, and you soon will see a lot of information. You'll be very aggressive in making sure people understand what is required, press releases. We have activated a webpage and created an anonymous hotline for tip reporting. And we're really building on and implementing what Ms. Stellinger will present.

14:18 Good afternoon, Planning Commission. As Mark just stated, the TOT committee has been in place for a while, and there's a lot of groundwork that was put together, was presented to the town council, kind of had a lull with everything that was going on with the town, and now we're working with Mark and his team, with Pam taking the lead on that, so working with the community development department, and so far it's been great.

14:48 Up and running again and moving forward with the plan that's been worked on for, well, actually, if I really wanted to talk about that, probably for the last 20 years. But anyways, it is actually moving forward and will come to fruition. So we're pretty excited about that. The TOT committee presented a PowerPoint back probably about a year ago to council, just kind of outlining

15:17 What potentially is being lost and why this is such an important endeavor that they need to move forward. So this is just an update to that as to where we are now. And so I'll just move through the PowerPoint. And so just the original proposal for the town covered the concerns, the TOT loss and experience, proposed immediate action, the education.

15:43 Ordinance changes that needed to happen, clarifying penalties and making sure those were all in line, and then the enforcement process. And so the letter that's going to be going now will be the first part of the education process. Well, actually, there was an education process with the reservation companies that was held with the finance department about a year ago, kind of what is TOT, so that we were all in the same.

16:12 Page, as far as what the town was expecting and what the lodging reservation companies were expecting. Then the next step is a letter that's going out to all property owners. That's been finalized. There's been a couple drafts that have gone out. So we have finalized the last draft that I'm assuming is going to council. Is that already gone to council? The letter. No, the letter hasn't gone to council. Okay. And so that'll be finalized.

16:41 Well, actually, it's been finalized. So we're waiting on all of the envelopes and everything so we can get that stuffed and out. Terry, do you have any idea what percentage of property owners who are affected by this are even aware of this? You know, it's been out there and just some media that's been coming forward. But I mean aware that there's an ordinance that applies to them.

17:09 Well, that's what this letter is going to go out to every single property owner. And basically, this letter is going to tell everybody, you know, this is what is expected of you. Are you in a legally zoned area? What you have to do to comply? How you can comply? Where you can get your tax forms? Where you can apply for all of that? So the letter will encompass all of that. So that is going out to every single property owner. And ordinance changes, there's been some ordinance changes that have already happened.

17:38 There's a couple others that need to move forward. One of them kind of moves right along with what Mark was talking about as far as going with basic gov and improving the TOT collection and tax return. And then penalties, that's already gone through the attorney as to what the penalties are out there. It's been clarified and that's already been taken care of as well. And then enforcement is the next step.

18:06 But first it's the educational step, getting that letter out to everybody so everybody knows what's expected of them. We're not looking to go out and set an enforcement prior to that letter going out. So that's the first step. Terry, can I ask a question before you go on? Can you just remind us of the status of single-family residents' nightly rentals? Single-family rentals can happen in an R1.

18:34 Single family. I'm sorry, in a resort zoned area only, not single family. Sorry. Yeah, okay. And that is still the case. That hasn't changed. And so condominiums may be rented on a nightly basis and homes within the resort zoning, as long as their CC&Rs don't state that they can't. So there is some...

19:03 Issues with that, and that, I know there are some housing areas that are dealing with that as well, because they are in a legally zoned area, but their CCNR say they cannot rent, so they're dealing with that internally. Okay. And, any other questions? I'll wait until the end, because you may cover it. T.O.T., how it affects everyone.

19:24 Town services, which affects everybody from our community members to our guests. So police, roads, snow removal, events, parks and recreation, marketing, transportation. This is a resort community. And close to 70% of our budget comes from TOT and tourism. So it's key to the health of our community. And so marketing.

19:50 Those, you know, for us to be able to have an effective marketing program, we need those, we rely on those TOT dollars to bring those folks here so that we have the money for everybody to live the way they want to live up here. The guest experience, guest experience goes to those folks that are coming up here and, number one, the town is not kept in the manner that it should be.

20:15 Or we're not offering what it needs to have offered. But also when a guest comes up here and they're locked out of wherever they're staying, who do they call? Whatever they rented is not up to par to what they thought they were going to rent. Who do they call? And those things are all going to be looked at as well. So hopefully improve that communication and who people go to and that type of thing. That's part of the educational process and hopefully some ordinance changes.

20:45 And the local job market. You'll hear people in our community that say, you know, my job doesn't rely on tourism. Well, every single job in this community relies on tourism because that's our industry. And so it doesn't matter whether you directly ever touch that guest, but you're there because we have the capacity and the guests here. And if we didn't have that, then your job may not be there.

21:14 So every job in this community, it's the trickle-down theory, is touched in some manner by tourism. Biggest concerns reported, in 2009 estimated $800,000 of unreported income due to owners renting illegally. 2011, the Mammoth Lakes Lodging Association reported that the number today is closer to $3.1 million. That's in two years.

21:43 This is just the Mammoth Lakes Lodging Association, 16 properties tracked in February, which is also a short month, owner-guest usage and what that calculated out to be. And this is just condominiums. It doesn't take into anything else, into account anything else. So just condominiums. And we came up with, and then took that number from February and multiplied it by five.

22:09 Because we are not full, you know, 12 months out of the year. So we felt it was a pretty conservative number. And came up with $3.1 million. And that calculates out to just under $400,000 in TFT. So the experience, the other concern, the experience for those that are visiting Mammoth and the importance of bringing people back to Mammoth Lakes, which is part of what I already went over. You know, it's great to get people here. We want them to have a good experience and want to come back.

22:39 Loss of service or limited service back to the local job market. Mammoth Lakes Tourism and their ability to do their job with a budget largely based on TOT dollars. Proposed immediate action. In 2009, the town approved a letter that was to be mailed out as soon as possible to all property owners through the following channels. HOA accounting firms, real estate contact list, which would be all property owners, rental management companies, HOA managers, local papers. That letter didn't go out.

23:10 This is kind of where we had that lag. Things were done, but we didn't quite get that next step of moving forward. The letter's been revised once again with working with our new team and will be going out, it looks like, once we get the supplies the first week in September. The TOT team has expanded, as we said. So the TOT committee consists of myself, Terry Stelick, Tom Smith.

23:37 Matthew Lehman, John Urdi, and Cheryl Witherall, and then the Community Development Department of Pam Kobylarz, Sandra Moberly, and Mark Ordlaw. And I do have to appreciate that they have jumped into this, and we've hit the ground running since then. Calendar, we're having weekly meetings right now, so every Thursday we're meeting in the morning.

24:02 So we have just an update what we're doing, what's moving forward, and just so we can keep that momentum going and deal with any issues that might have popped up with any step that we haven't moved forward. The letter stuffing party will be the first week of September, and so we're looking for volunteers. We've sent notice out to the lodging association and any other business person that would like to come help stuff on envelopes, get a hold of Cheryl or myself.

24:31 We'll let you know when we're going to do that, but it'll be the first week in September. What we have accomplished. We finalized the letter to go to all 8,000, I think it's 8,000 plus property owners. Press release approved by the team for local papers. That will be coming out in this next week's paper. Sample letters to attorney for review. That's already been accomplished.

24:55 Mailing to 8,000 property owners on calendar, creation of hotline, phone number as well as an online component for use by community. All of those would be anonymous. Separate website for the TOT issues, questions, et cetera. So there will be a Q&A page on that website as well. So people will be able to go on there if they're not quite sure of something. There'll be some direction as to some basic questions or who they can contact.

25:23 Review of the process matrix by attorney. And so we put a matrix together. What's the first step? Letter goes out. What's the next step? What's the next step? And so that's been put together as well. And that's been reviewed by the attorney as well. Set up meeting with attorney for questions. And that's happening tomorrow morning at our meeting. And we'll be having a conference with the attorney for any final questions that might have came up. What's next?

25:49 Getting property owner letters out the first week of September, confirm the process and matrix as well as the draft communication letter with the attorney that will happen tomorrow morning, have staff follow through on leads to determine our matrix is complete, publish press release, continue to meet weekly to keep momentum going, continue to communicate with council and Mammoth Lakes Lodging on progress,

26:14 Goal of an ordinance change to change to a monthly reporting cycle. That's for the TOT collection. Right now, any business that collects $10,000 or more in TOT pays on a monthly basis. If they do not collect $10,000 or more of TOT, they collect on a quarterly basis. Well, for those folks that are going on a quarterly basis, right now, it's putting any information that we get for TOT, which is key for marketing.

26:43 It's key for planning. It's key for anything we do here. It's putting it six to eight months out before we actually have a true figure because of that. And so we're asking that everybody reporting on a monthly basis. And that would be an ordinance change. Continue communication with property owners, real estate community, management companies, et cetera, on compliance. Publishing papers are success. So we've had the idea of kind of doing what the library did is we can have our little thermometer and, you know.

27:12 Say what money has been collected. And so wrap-up is $400,000 is a ton of money. It's a lot of money, and that was based on a year ago, and I'll tell you daily, it just kind of compiles and gets worse. This number has increased by 2.3 million in two years. TOT committee members are available to talk to the community member.

27:38 To any community member, council, and the finance department to hear ideas and to assist wherever possible, Mammoth Lakes Lodging continues to support these efforts and will assist council in any way needed. And then there's a full list of the team as it stands right now, the TOT community team. That's it. Questions? Yes, Terry, how can we, the community members, help?

28:11 What do we have to see or hear? The community members, you know, it kind of starts with an educational process that, you know, if somebody's doing something in an area that's not legal, whether it be a condo, or if they're doing something that's not legal, I talk to the person first if you're comfortable doing that. Let them know what they need to do, where they can find where they're doing it. Otherwise, it should go to the hotline.

28:37 So if there are many cars parked in, for instance, my neighborhood, which is obviously single family, and I've not seen them before ever, then that might be something that would be indicative of a weekend rental maybe? A lot of that, a lot of times that is the case if you continually see, you know, 10, 12 cars in a parking area.

29:00 You know, but there are times that a family will bring up that many, but it definitely, if it's something that kind of continues, it's kind of a... Well, I have attempted on occasion to talk to some of these people, but it's kind of direct to say, do you own this house? You know, so is there a phrase that would be good to say to a visitor? I mean, I... You can just, you know, kind of in general conversation, you know. How long have you lived here? How long have you been here? What have you been doing? You know, do you come up often? You know.

29:29 Just kind of general conversation. Because we are not looking to attack our guests. We really aren't. They're coming up. Most of them don't realize if they're doing something wrong. And so that's not what we're looking to do. It's just something that this community needs to understand and our property owners need to understand what TOT means to this community. And that by doing something...

29:55 That is taking away from that TOT. You're taking away from the community that you have came to, you know, enjoy, whether you're living here, whether you're a second homeowner, whether you're a part-time resident. So anyways, as well as our guests. So it's just extremely important. And so I think the first part is that education. And, you know, just in general conversation, like I say, most people have no idea if they're renting, that they're doing anything that's illegal.

30:23 And so... And it may not be. Yeah, and it may not be. So, yeah. You talked about owner-guest. I think there probably are lots of instances, because I've seen on, you know, BRBO, Vacation Rental by Owner, no TOT charged. Can the owner just say, oh, they're my friends, or they're my guests, and then what do you do? Do you do a sting operation? How do you find that out? It would come down to a sting operation at some point. So, you know, if people have...

30:53 A guest there. We used to have 15 guests there in one month. You know, most likely there's some money that came across hands, whether it's a cleaning fee, whether it's a utility fee, whether it's rent. But any cleaning fee, utility fee, or any of those things is rent. For anything that you are paying to stay within that property, that's rent. That is the definition of rent. Okay.

31:16 In our single-family neighborhood in Old Mammoth, there are several residences that are nightly rentals all the time and have been for years. I think this is probably a question more for council than for us, but are they feeling a lot of pressure to legalize nightly rentals in single-family zones because of the revenue they're losing?

31:37 Well, the council did bring that up, and it's something that the Community Development Department and council are talking about, and it's a conversation that's going to take place at some point. What we've been very concerned about is that we need to get the enforcement part of this down prior to ever even talking about opening something up, whether you're for it or whether you're against it. Because if you don't have that, then the experience for everybody, whether you're the person living next door to that house that's renting or...

32:06 Condo complex, or whether you're the tenant. We need to get all of those things down. And it goes to how many parking spaces can you have? How many people can occupy that place? There's a lot of things that, even if that goes forward, there's a lot to be done as far as that goes. But that conversation will take place.

32:28 We feel it's really important to get this done prior to ever even looking at opening anything else up. If you can't enforce something and you don't have something that's effective there, how do you ever open something, open up that other camera? Yeah, I know what you're saying. Thank you. Rodney? No, any questions? Terry, does the committee have any, have they made any forecast or...

32:51 Expectation or goal as to how much of that $400,000 they hope to get in the first year of enforcement, second year, third year of this program? Any ideas? No. I would say that, you know, quite possibly we could get the $400,000 plus. Maybe that's being too optimistic, but I don't think so. I think that if those folks out there that are renting, actually that are renting legally even comply, then you're going to be hitting that number.

33:21 Well, and one more question. Elizabeth talked about the possibility of applying this to single-family residences, and Planning Commission, I'm sure, could be, likely would be a part of the process if that was decided to change the ordinance. Are there any other things the committee can think of that you want us to do as a Planning Commission?

33:47 Yes, a couple of points. There's two different aspects of this. First, it's the law. It's required on the books that if you're renting that you pay TOT. So it's important for us to enforce and collect. But it's also important for us to welcome and acknowledge our visitors. So our approach is going to be very educational first.

34:13 The letter that will be going out shortly, it's a two-page letter, and it's almost a zoning code definitions letter, if you will. There's an awful lot of information in it, and we will follow up with persistent and consistent messages through press releases. We're building the website to include fact sheets so people have the information. And, you know, as many issues we face in the town.

34:42 Unclear information, ambiguous information, it doesn't help anybody. And so as we did with the zoning code, we want to make sure everybody understands what is the definition of rent. So getting the information out in a positive and constructive way is very useful for us. And yet we must be firm in abiding to the law. So by the way, our anonymous tip line.

35:11 I'd like to report that phone number for you. It's 760-934-8989, extension 275. This is also a partnership, and I think this committee has done, as I've already said, an awful lot of work. John Urdi is partnering with us. We all have a vested stake in...

35:36 In collecting this revenue. It's the bread and butter in the community. And as Terry's already said, it is the essence of how we provide services and facilities. So it's a very important issue. And any business should collect the revenues due first. In terms of the single-family rental discussion, as you recall, about two years ago, we started that work effort and we tabled it at council direction so other priorities could move ahead.

36:03 And in the work program discussion, the council agreed with the TOT committee that we need to, you know, first perfect our enforcement program so that we have institutionalized our staffing and our systems to make this painless and efficient. Right now our methods are, it takes four data entries to collect TOT.

36:31 Enforcement can be a time burden, and so as we turn it into a really effective system and move forward with revenue collection, then we can consider the best ways to conduct the single family rental discussion. Council was interested in holding the discussion, not a conclusion, they want to have the debate and the analysis so that it can be discussed in the community.

36:59 And we would expect to pick that up in this fiscal year, but certainly after the holiday season. So our first priority is to be focused on this. And I do think that having updates with the Planning Commission are helpful because this is a pretty good way to get information out. And it's certainly broadcast on the system, which is a useful tool to us.

37:24 So at some point in time, not only will we be enforcing, but we'll be tracking performance. And so through the Basic Gov program, or whatever program I choose, we'll start to be able to say in the third quarter of the year, revenues are this compared to the last revenues. And, you know, most people want to abide by the law. And I think this article that you just passed out indicates that if people knew that they had certain requirements, they could

37:54 Terry, are you emphasizing in the educational material the fact we don't have

38:21 Big manufacturing plants here and all these other businesses paying taxes, which is why visitors like to come, and therefore this tax is to support all these visitor amenities that they're enjoying, so it doesn't look so much like an onerous burden, but like instead of paying for what we're offering them? Absolutely. Good, so it's a positive approach? Yeah, it's basically, it starts out, you know, that tourism is our industry and lists.

38:46 All the things that TOT benefits this community. Oh, good. And that's the start of the letter. And then it goes into, you know, what you need to do to comply and, you know, what the rules and regulations are. That's great. And you say that letter's going to everybody in town. Every property owner. Yeah. Thank you, Terry. All right, thank you. Thank you. Appreciate your effort and staff's efforts as well.

39:15 We have nothing on the consent agenda today, so that moves us to public hearings. And our first item under public hearings is the use permit application 11-002 and design review 11-002, which concerns a request to construct a new bowling center within a new building that is at 3029 Chateau Road to be known as Mammoth Rock and Bowl.

39:43 I will start by opening the public hearing, and the first part of this hearing will be the statement of presentation by staff. Thank you. Good afternoon, commissioners. The project before you today is a request for a new bowling center that would include 12 new bowling lanes as well as billiards tables, darts, three golf simulation machines, and also a new bar and restaurant. The project would also include a new parking lot with 37 parking surface spaces.

40:14 The proposed project is consistent with all applicable zoning requirements of the commercial general zone within which the project is located. I'm just going to give you a very brief summary of the majority of the compliance with the development standards. Bowling alleys are permitted use within this zone as are restaurants and bars with the approval of a use permit, which is what you'll be considering today.

40:39 For the height of the project, the proposed building is approximately 33 feet tall at its tallest point, and our code allows up to 35 feet, so the project is consistent with that. No new density is proposed as part of the project due to its commercial nature. Parking is required to be provided for all uses within commercial zones. However, the municipal code does allow for shared parking to be considered where there is more than one use on the same site.

41:07 In this case, the bowling lanes are the primary use on the site and staff has determined that the majority of the other uses on the site will function as accessory uses to the primary use and therefore will not require additional parking. Staff has discussed this concept with the Planning Commission Design Committee who had consensus that all of the uses on the same level as the bowling lanes, including the bar, billiards, tables and darts, would be accessory to the bowling lanes, as well as the golf simulators and a portion of the restaurant on the upper floor of the building.

41:37 Based on that consensus, staff has provided a parking analysis that breaks down the total parking requirement, including the accessory uses and 25% of the restaurant being considered as an accessory use. Given those considerations, staff has determined that 54 total parking spaces would be required for this project. Since the project only contains 37 parking spaces on the site, the additional 17 spaces will need to be provided off-site somewhere.

42:05 Our municipal code does allow several options for providing required parking off-site, including providing parking on another parcel within 300 feet of the use, given a recorded shared parking document between the two property owners, providing off-site parking via a joint parking facility or municipal parking lot that is established and approved by the Planning Commission, or establishing a parking district and payment of in-lieu fees.

42:34 The applicant has stated that it intends to enter into a parking agreement with a neighboring property, however, details of that agreement aren't required at this time and have not been finalized. Staff has included condition of approval number 36 that allows the applicant to provide the additional parking by either of these three options. And additionally, the project applicant will be providing five on-street parking spaces that will help supplement the parking for guests of the project.

43:03 However, these parking spaces can't be counted toward the parking requirement pursuant to code. For lot coverage, the commercial zone allows a maximum of 70% lot coverage, and this project just meets that at 69.8% lot coverage. The building and all of the parking lot and parking spaces are consistent with the required setbacks in this zone. Just to know that the commercial zone has a front yard setback of 20 feet, but the side yard and rear yard setbacks are zero feet.

43:37 The commercial general zone requires that snow storage be provided at an area equal to 60% of all parking and driveway areas. The project complies with this requirement, however, it appears that some of the snow storage areas may be difficult to access, and therefore in heavy snow years, snow storage could become an issue. Staff has included condition of approval number 28 to help address this issue that would require the property owner to enter into an agreement to have snow hauled off-site in the event that

44:06 The snow can't be kept on site. Plan Sheet A 4.1 of your plan set includes a proposed monument sign for the project. Typically, Planning Commission doesn't approve signs. However, since the detailed information has been provided at this time, staff is recommending that Planning Commission consider approving the sign as part of the use permit application.

44:29 Staff has reviewed the sign proposal with the sign committee and the sign committee was supportive of staff's recommendation and also of Planning Commission considering the monument sign as part of the use permit. The sign would be located at the northwest corner of the site near the parking lot entrance. The sign frame would be composed of raw steel and stained wood with brick metal siding background to complement the building colors and design. And the letters would be halo lit letters, which is permitted under the new sign ordinance that was recently approved.

45:00 There's three items that I wanted to bring to your attention regarding the sign. The first item is that the current proposal in your packet includes a sign square footage of approximately 31.5 square feet, but the sign ordinance limits signage to 30 square feet. The applicant has agreed to reduce the sign size to approximately 29.5 square feet. The sign ordinance limits sign height for monument signs to a maximum of 8 feet.

45:28 And the proposed sign frame exceeds 8 feet by 2.5 feet, although the sign itself is within the 8 foot height limit. The sign ordinance allows sign frames to exceed the height limit provided that they are necessary structural elements. Finally, the sign base proposed to be made of cast-in-place concrete meets the requirements of the sign ordinance. However, the Planning Commission may wish to consider a more detailed or attractive base as part of the sign approval.

45:55 Staff has included condition of approval number 34 to address these three items and allow planning commission to approve the sign if so desired. This project is subject to the town's interim housing policy regarding mitigation of workforce housing. This policy exempts retail and restaurant uses from all housing mitigation requirements but does require non-lodging commercial uses to pay in lieu fees to satisfy workforce housing requirements.

46:25 Based on the proposed uses, the policy is clear that restaurant and bar portions of the project would be exempt and therefore would not be required to pay any fees. However, it is unclear how the remaining uses, including the bowling lanes, golf simulators, restrooms, circulation areas, and other utilitarian areas would apply. The applicant has submitted the following request regarding interpretation of the interim housing policy.

46:53 Retail and restaurant uses are exempt from affordable housing requirements in this zone pursuant to the interim housing policy. A bowling center such as the proposed project is similar to and incorporates these uses. As a proposed development project with a small variety of very mixed uses, there is no way to separate the areas of restaurant, bar, and retail from the bowling and golf uses. Restaurant and bar wait staff will be serving all areas.

47:20 including the bowling alleys, just as they would within the restaurant and bar areas. Therefore, the applicant has requested that the entire building be exempt from affordable housing requirements. Staff has reviewed this request and due to the unique nature of this project, agrees that the bar and restaurant uses would be intermingled with the remaining uses. Staff also believes that the employee generation rate of the project would be similar to that of a retailer restaurant project of similar square footage.

47:50 For these reasons, it may be appropriate for the Planning Commission to consider and determine the entire project to be exempt from all housing mitigation requirements. The Planning Commission should discuss this request and determine if an exemption to affordable workforce housing requirements is appropriate or if some other alternative may be appropriate. Staff has conducted a design review analysis for this project, and due to the unique nature of the building, there are some unique design constraints that apply.

48:20 For example, no windows can be installed around the bowling lanes since lighting within that area needs to be consistent at all time for bowlers. Given these restraints, staff has determined that the project complies with the town's design guidelines to the extent possible. Staff has also reviewed this with the design committee and one item that they expressed some concerns about were the colors and materials for the project. The applicant has supplied me with these material samples that I can pass around.

48:50 Since it was somewhat difficult to tell the exact colors on the printed color renderings in your packets. And in regards to those colors, we have included condition of approval number 35 that would require a color mock-up on site prior to construction of the building.

49:10 In regards to off-site improvements, as I mentioned, the project applicant will be installing five on-street parking spaces to help activate the site and surrounding commercial uses. This isn't a requirement of the code, but it is recommended in the South District's NDP. And the project will also be installing a sidewalk along the project frontage, and this is a requirement of our sidewalk master plan. The town has received minimal agency comments regarding this project and has not received any public comments.

49:39 to date regarding the project. The project is consistent with the general plan and vision, and staff has determined that the project is exempt from CEQA pursuant to the infill development project exemption. Prior to this meeting, I received some comments and questions from Commissioners Duncan and Clark, and I've made minor changes to the conditions of approval as a result of those comments. I believe that those commissioners may also have some recommended changes to the conditions during their...

50:09 Deliberation later on, but the two changes that I wanted to bring to your attention at this time are on condition of approval number 33. That's on page 2-20 of your packet. And we would like to revise this condition on the first line, replace the words final map with grading permit, since there is no map associated with this project. And then in the middle of the condition where it talks about which streets the public improvements would occur on,

50:40 We should delete Mountain Boulevard, Alpine Circle and Main Street and replace that with Chateau Road. The second condition that I wanted to discuss with you right now is condition number 37 on page 2-21. The applicant has requested that I change the language to this condition so we would replace the entire condition with language that would read, to ease parking demand during bowling league play times.

51:13 The applicant shall add a requirement to the rules for league play that league members carpool, take public transit, bike or walk to the bowling center. The purpose of this condition and also of the changes to help mitigate the limited parking on the site and the applicant was concerned with the currently proposed language that due to

51:36 The inability to control the time that league play happens, when games start and stop might not always be at the same time. It would be difficult to regulate the time in between league play. This condition satisfies the same intent by helping to mitigate and alleviate the parking demand, but is something that would be easier for the applicant to regulate. With that, staff recommends that the Planning Commission adopt the attached resolution.

52:04 Finding the project to be categorically exempt from CEQA, approving use permit 11-002, and design review 11-002, and including the findings listed in the resolution and all conditions of approval. That concludes my presentation. I'm happy to answer any questions you have. Ellen Clark and Peter Bernasconi are also here, and the applicant has a PowerPoint presentation that he wishes to present. Okay. First, does anyone have questions specific for staff?

52:34 Pam, we're at the bike racks. Sure. If you go to page A1-1, the first page in your plan set, near the entrance to the building, so where the sidewalk leads up to the building, you'll see a note that says summer bicycle racks. And then right within the entrance, there's another note that says two bicycle racks. Okay, thank you. I have a couple more staff questions.

53:10 You already covered a couple of things I picked up in conditions. The samples that were just passed around, those are stock colors from the company. So there's a condition here that the color committee will look at the colors prior to building permit or prior to, what was it? Yeah, prior to application on the building, but the building isn't being painted. It comes from the factory like this, right?

53:39 The metal comes from the factory that way, but the metal is just individual long sheets that are three feet wide. So we will put up a sample board on site that can be turned so that you can see it in the sunlight, you can see it in shade also on site. Because I had asked Pam in an email if we could go outside today. It's just like a rock. You don't paint the rock. You buy the material and you put it up. And it's the same thing with the metal.

54:08 And that will happen on site prior to any metal being shipped to be put on the building. So there's no need, as I asked in an email, Pam, for us to go outside today and look at these samples. I thought there'd be a materials board and we'd look at it in the sunlight, but it would be better to see a big mock-up than to see a materials board. I think it would be better to wait. Okay, okay, then I won't be concerned about that. Yeah, that was condition 35 that I was wondering about.

54:36 Number 24, this is just a clarification. It says a CFO is required for all future tenant improvements, and this is a case where you have an owner. Are you talking about concessionaires? Are you going to have concessionaires inside the business operating the bar and the restaurant? And then those are the tenant improvements? What does that mean on Condition 24?

54:59 This is just a standard condition that we always include, and it's basically to allow for any future improvements somewhere down the line after the building's built, just to clarify that, you know, future improvements would require a certificate of occupancy as well as owner improvement, not tenant. In this case, right.

55:17 It refers to the interior improvements to a building, so TI's are the nomenclature of interior improvement. Okay, that's new to me. I think if a tenant is like a concessionaire, so. And your previous question is condition 35 regarding the final mock-up. Thank you. Those of us who forget our glasses, okay. The last question was the top of the building, and I think I have an old elevation here.

55:45 The highest point is to this rim around the roof, and I don't know what you call the rim around a flat roof. I mean, it's obviously a parapet. What do you call that? The what? You said it. The rim? No, a parapet. Oh, it is it? Even though it's continuous, it is a parapet. Okay. It's actually the definition of a parapet. That's what it is. Okay, that's good. So it's finished on the inside as well with the same siding, because that's how it looks on the elevation. Yes. Okay.

56:15 That's the definition of a parapet. Good. I just learned that. Those are all my questions. Thank you. Oh, staff. Thank you. Rhonda? I have a couple. The property, the SCE property to the south of this site. East. North, south. Okay. Behind the property. What is that used for right now?

56:50 It includes a substation. It includes a maintenance facility. They park their vehicles there. It has a building office. Okay, I guess I'm talking about the property that is directly behind the building. What is on the south side? Park. Back here. Park. That's Mammoth Creek Park East. Mammoth Creek Park. Okay.

57:25 So that comes up to Mammoth Creek Park? Yes. Okay. And there's no other, there's just easements there, there's no other use for that, there's no other ownership in between that and Mammoth Creek Park? That's correct. Mammoth Creek Park, what we refer to that area, it's owned by the United States Forest Service in the town as a permit on that particular site. So it's public lands and it's, if it has them, it's recreational.

57:57 Okay, so this is one of the sites we've looked. Is this portion of it one of the sites that we've looked at for recreational purposes? No. Okay. Not this private property. But, okay, this is private. No, I'm sorry, the Mammoth, the property adjacent, the Mammoth Creek Park area. Yeah, so Mammoth Creek, this is part of the area described in the South District's neighborhood area that could be used for a variety of flexible recreation space.

58:26 And event activity. And it's now currently adjacent to it. It's relatively undisturbed. It's natural. It has pines. It hasn't been substantially graded or built upon. Okay. That's the only question right now. Thank you. Chair? Yes. COA-19 talks about grading plan. It shall include tree protection.

59:09 Measures, since there are no trees, I wonder if we could maybe talk about that the land could be, this is, grading plans should include erosion control measures instead of talking about protecting trees. Grading operations shall not commence until erosion control measures are in place as shown on the approved plans and is required by the town.

59:41 Look at condition 20, isn't that what that does? 20 is compliant with the local guidelines for erosion control in Mammoth area, and so the grading plan, I think it's fine to make that change. There isn't any trees on the site, so making the change from tree protection measures to erosion control is fine. I just, since there aren't any trees, I didn't know what we should do, and that was my recommendation that we...

1:00:16 Control measures. But if it's already said in 20, then maybe just drop 19? I think they're a little bit different because 19 requires that information to be shown on the grading plan itself. Okay. Whereas 20 requires compliance with the erosion control guidelines for the district. So just... So I think those recommendations you made are good and we can incorporate those. Okay. And then COA number 27.

1:00:45 Public trails and bike lines, there are none. So maybe if we just take out. Essentially what this condition does is makes the applicant keep open the, there essentially is a bike lane along the shoulder there, it's just not striped. There is the public trail that ties into the end of the street and then so people access Old Mammoth Road from that way. So this condition would require them to keep the.

1:01:16 Access open to the public in front of the property during construction. Well, should we get rid of that second sentence? We can get rid of the relocation. Well, they could actually have a traffic control plan that would relocate the pedestrian way. It's a standard condition that's included, really comes out of the Talitz Project problem. So you think you need both? Since there are no trails to be relocated, but... It's trails or bike lanes, so the trails can certainly go away.

1:01:49 The bike lanes are really what's there, even though they're not marked. So we could get rid of the trails. As a general issue, though, these are standard conditions. Does it make sense to where parts of a standard condition that don't apply, so it has no effect, does it make sense to each time we go through these, take it out if it doesn't apply? Because it doesn't make a difference.

1:02:19 It doesn't hurt to have the standard condition. In the future, we could make it more precise as long as we don't creep away from our standard condition. If we find a problem with the condition, we change the standard condition, but if it's only an issue with whether it applies to a particular project, why not just leave the standard condition? Well, it just didn't make any sense, but now that you've explained it, perhaps since it's standard, it needs to be there, but since there weren't any trees and there weren't bike trails, it...

1:02:49 Didn't think so. Okay. And the final one, just a question of the petitioner. Is there going to be a place for winter clothing, I presume, in maybe the entryway there? Hanging or lockers or something? There will be lockers on site. They're not shown on the plan right now. That's something that came up going into the bowling centers. But there will be lockers.

1:03:17 And there will be a place to hang clothes and things. People tend to, in this sort of environment, put them out where they are and keep them out because otherwise your jacket that's really nice goes home with someone else. Thank you. But there are lockers. Have you considered coat check? I mean like you do in museums, you know? It's possible, but we haven't. No. We'll see whether that becomes a function of need or not. And that's all I had. Okay, thank you.

1:03:47 A couple of things, Pam. First, with respect to the sign on that page that you referenced, A4.1, the figure on the left middle illustration shows the dimensions. The vertical standards on the left and right of the sign are, what do you say, a total of 10 and a half feet.

1:04:14 Eight foot height that's allowed goes to the top of the horizontal support, the upper horizontal support for the sign itself. So the two and a half feet of those vertical columns above that is the part that's an issue with respect to height. And as you said, it's allowed to, that frame is allowed to exceed the height limit provided that it is a, quote, necessary structural design feature. And I'm still not clear, is it staff's position that that,

1:04:44 Two and a half feet is a necessary structural design feature. Let's ask the applicant if it's required or not. Technically, no. Aesthetically, yes. Aesthetically, structural. Structural, yes. You're right. You're right. Okay. Okay. I just wanted to get that clear. In housing, reiterating what you said, Pam,

1:05:14 About the housing policy that exempts restaurant and retail uses from affordable housing requirements. Can we, maybe Mark, you can help, can we kind of collect the various types of uses that come under the housing policy? We know that restaurant and retail are exempt, specifically. We know that lodging residential, except for single-family residential, are included.

1:05:44 What else is there that's included or isn't included? Well, one example would be office uses in a commercial zone that would not be exempt. That's really probably the principle one category of use. And this is a use that's a little bit unusual, I think, in terms of classifying it as a retail use. So we're doing our best to try to figure out which box it fits into. And I ask that because...

1:06:14 Taken in a vacuum where it says retail and restaurant, how do you decide if it comports with the council's intent in exempting those to include this or not if you don't know the others that are, so that's what I needed to know. Thank you. Okay, any more questions specifically of staff? Okay, then we will move on to the applicant's presentation. Thank you. So, for the most part, I've just got some more images to show what the room looks like.

1:06:46 And then I would like to go through some of the comments. So this is... Did you get the lights, Pam? It's a little tough with the lights, but that's... Yeah, these lights. And this one. So this is the entrance to the building on the right. And the...

1:07:16 Although the comment was made that there aren't windows into the bowling area, we have windows around the perimeter of the building on the really visible sides of the building, that being the north side, which you see here, and the west side that open into the windows that are up high on this elevation are into a mechanical space and they are just to break up the facade. They're not functional.

1:07:43 We don't need windows there. We've put windows there at the request of the design review committee. There are also windows. There's a long entry corridor along the west side of the building. And the reason for the long corridor on the building is that the pleasant space in the building is going to be at the back of the building. That's where the view is. That's where the parkland behind it will be.

1:08:11 That necessitated getting back to the back of the building. And in the middle of winter, the sidewalk on the outside would just be a nightmare. So we have a long sort of indoor corridor. We also have a long area for walk-off mats because this is a synthetic floor or potentially a hardwood floor for the bowling area. And you rent shoes or you bring your own shoes. And tracking cinders in, which we spread all over the roads,

1:08:39 It's a real problem for the floor. So we have a long area to hopefully get most of that off people's feet before they get into the building. So that functions that way also. But we have windows all along. We have windows along that side. We have some clear glass windows, and we have some that are just for light coming into that side to kind of create a different environment as you walk through that space and make it a pleasant experience getting back into the building.

1:09:07 We feel that this has created a pretty clear and straightforward way to find your way to the front door. This on the right is certainly more like the front door than what's on the left because on the left is we have an enclosed trash room for a trash recycling so it's part of the building as opposed to being out in the parking lot where it's done almost everywhere else in town and there's

1:09:37 The little opening on the side, next to that, there's a little slot in the opening, and that goes back in, and there's access in there for the electrical meters, so SCE can come and read them without them being on the outside of the building, and for fire, and it's also would be the deliveries for the building for food and such. So, there's that opening that's on the left there in the brick red color. Down the side, between our

1:10:13 This is the back of the building from the west, southwest corner of the property.

1:10:48 Looking at a rear deck and a deck up off the restaurant area that's semi-covered. At the end, there's the green plaid area on the far right. Downstairs is what's called a party room, so it can be segregated off from birthday parties and things like that for kids. That's where the cake gets scraped off the floor kind of room. Upstairs is building office.

1:11:24 This is then looking down on that, showing how the roofs work. You know, it's a relatively large building because of what's inside it with rolling lanes, and it needs to be relatively boxy. We've tried to really break that up so it doesn't come across as being very boxy, but a large flat roof is by far the most economical way to do this. The building is larger than you can really do a...

1:12:05 A pitched roof unless you have a lot more land. Fire station is an example of a building that is not as large as this, square footage-wise inside, but they have a lot of land on both sides so they can deal with the snow as the snow comes off the roof. We are going to just hold it and let it melt or it will blow off as it drifts. Here's a couple little close-ups of, on the right is the entry and the steel and the wood.

1:12:39 Concrete, and on the left is a little bit of the same, and then the trellis element that's over that north wall, breaking up that north wall. And here we are looking back up along the east property line from the back of the project, showing that we're away from the property line, they're away from the property line, there is a bit of space in between there. The trees that you see, there actually are a couple trees.

1:13:12 in this pocket in the wall on the right on the SCE side that will be maintained. They have a couple trees on their property but there are none on this. There's nothing growing on this property at all. I mean it's like there's almost no scrub. This is up on the right is up on the patio deck and how the roof is cantilevered out. I've got a rendering program I'm trying to figure out how to use and I can't. So the glass at the end there looks like it's opaque but it's actually clear.

1:13:47 Same thing on the left. You get a reflection, which makes it look a little bit better. But that's just some detail on it. Around those windows is all steel. It's laid up in kind of a shiplap style. It's using a material that will work very well that way. It's not typically used that way, but it brings in a little bit of that. A little warmer, a little more...

1:14:15 Something you want to get a little closer to look at type of thing. And we have panels of that around the building. This just shows overall how the first floor sort of sits on the site, and you can see that long corridor on the bottom of the building that leads back into. It also ramps up gently as you go in. The bowling lanes, whole bowling lane area is actually almost 18 inches above the slab, and then you raise the slab in the back of the structure.

1:14:47 That's where all the ball return and all that sort of stuff is. So we need to get up, gently up into the building. And so we're kind of slowly going up on a ramp in the front. There are no stairs, of course, there. And then it's bar area towards the back and billiards. And on the top end is sort of the back of house stuff where the elevator is and the bathrooms are. There's some kitchen storage. There's a boiler room. There's a maintenance room for the...

1:15:16 Bowling lanes, some other back of the house things. And this is upstairs above the bowling lanes. It's a little odd the way it looks because it's cut straight through and it's hard to make out what's going on there. But we actually have some drop elements on the ceiling trying to create an interesting ceiling and to baffle the sound to try to help cut down on the sound level that you get from.

1:15:46 The bowling. On the left of that, there's a long, skinny space that's actually an attic space, and all of our mechanical, our air handler units and such will be inside the building and not set up on the roof, as some other large buildings in town that have flat roofs do. We've got them fit into the building. Going from the bowling area, which is sort of in the middle left side of it, then we're into an area where there's these golf simulators.

1:16:17 There's some odd bits of storage space in there, partly because the bowling lanes are a certain width and golf simulators are a certain width and they don't really jive and one's above the other and structurally that's kind of the way it lays out. So it actually gives us a little bit of space in there, it's a little bit of elbow room for it, but it's in there. It's just maybe not the most efficient of use.

1:16:43 And then to the right of that is the restaurant area, the seating area. Above that in the plan is the kitchen. And there's other back-of-house stuff, staff bathrooms or staff, one above, you know, bathrooms above bathrooms. Then this is the monument sign. To let you know, to get that square footage down from 31 and a half square feet to just under 30 square feet, we're...

1:17:14 We're taking an inch off the sign all the way around. That's all it takes. So we're going from 9 foot long to 10 foot 8. And instead of being 3 foot 6, we're going to 3 foot 4. And so actually the lettering will stay basically the same. It'll just be what's behind it changes slightly. Material choice here is to have elements that then match and go with the building. The steel and the ends of the steel are cut as steel is cut on the building.

1:17:45 So it has a similar detail. The wood, instead, is similar to on the building. It also will hide the means of getting power into the sign, up and into the sign. And the concrete base is similar to the concrete base elements that we have on the building itself. Same taper on the end. Wintertime, it'll be buried. Summertime, landscape grows. This is an area that doesn't get snow and roll around it other than enough to get the sign clear.

1:18:14 Or it doesn't have snow, it has snow removal around it, but it doesn't have snow storage around it. And obviously it's a sign and we don't want a pot of snow in front of a sign. This sign, the sign ordinance is that your signage is based on the linear frontage of your building. Based on the linear frontage of this building, we're allowed 84, over 84 square feet of sign. This is the only sign that we're asking for.

1:18:44 Because it's back-to-back sign, you only count one face of it. That's also in the ordinance. So we have 30 square feet. We have 54 square feet that we're letting go of, basically, in this. So with the orientation of where this building sits and how it sits back on the property and where people can see this from the road, we feel this sign is critically important to be seen from.

1:19:11 From Old Mammoth Road. But a sign back on the building, you already know where you are once you're there. You're in the parking lot before you'd see the sign, so there's no point putting the sign there. Bruce, what does it say under rock and bowl? It says fun food and games for everyone, because that's kind of what it is. And which parts of that lettering would be halo lighting? The mammoth rock and bowl. Just that part? Yeah, the bottom part wouldn't be. It would get some light on it. There's no other light source on it, just the...

1:19:41 Halo lighting. Halo light on the east face of the sign as well or just on the west face? It's just on the west. I think we're only allowed on the west side. Makes sense. But there's, there's, anybody that's coming from SCE to come here knows that we're there. Anybody that's coming from the Blue Roof Condos knows we're there because you've got to go buy us to get there. And Bursa from Apartments across the street, same kind of thing. So, we think we'll be found. So, that's...

1:20:14 That's really my presentation. I have some other slides that would be the plans and such, but you have those in front of you. If you have any questions. Yes, you said that was glass around the deck on the second floor? Yes, glass. It's not plex, it's glass. It's glass, yes. It's half inch. It'll be similar to what's, in fact, very similar to what's on the deck at Canyon Lodge. I did that, so it's worked really nice.

1:20:42 Is the reason you chose to put the sign in the, what I think of as the corner, the northwest corner, rather than in the central landscaped area off Chateau, is it because that's a snow storage area? Is that why you made that decision? Well, I didn't want to. There's a couple reasons. It's not in the center because I want to put the sign by where the people can walk to it, and they walk to the sign, and I want to get the sign.

1:21:06 That's one. Two, I want the sign as close to Old Mammoth Road as I can get it. That's this location. And three, if I put it on the other side of the driveway, I'm going to then want to put snow storage on this side, and now I'm potentially piling snow up, and my line of sight is right through a pile of snow to try and see my sign. It doesn't work very well. Is there a drain in the roof?

1:21:32 Lots of drains. Lots of drains. I would think so. The textured concrete, not textured concrete, the concrete, what is the finish for that? It's not going to be just like concrete that's poured for a foundation. Is it going to be a polished or smooth finish? How are you finishing? There's a lot of concrete. How are you finishing the surface of that? I don't believe, one, I don't believe there's a lot of concrete. There is some concrete.

1:21:59 Well, the concrete that's holding up the sign, the concrete that's holding up the pillars, I mean, the concrete is an element, just straight toward concrete? But it'll be, you know, smooth and finished. It won't have holes and it won't have air pockets or any of that sort of thing showing in it. Did you consider doing any textured surface for the concrete with various types of forms? Yeah, it could be like a board form.

1:22:29 Or even something better than that. I mean, there are things you can do. It depends on what the board is that forms it. Right. I certainly don't want to make the concrete, pour the concrete, try to make it look like rock, like they're doing on the bridge as you come into town. No, no, I'm not talking about that. I always talk about the Haas School of Business in Berkeley. That's such a good example of textured concrete, all different kinds of texture, and just add some, but the whole building is concrete. Right.

1:22:59 Less than, probably less than 1% of the building is this material. Okay. So what do you see? What we've got proposed is just a smooth finish concrete. It would be, that's really what we've got proposed. Is it possible to mix in tiny pea gravel or anything like that to be more interesting? It could be an exposed aggregate concrete. That doesn't hold up very well.

1:23:30 Not as real. You know, Schrager's office is looking, their wall is not too bad. Okay, I don't think I remember that. How high is the support for the post as you walk in the entrance? Yeah, that's right up there where you're looking at it. Yep. No, but as you walk in the entrance, there's those concrete supports. Okay, that's all for questions. We can talk about that in discussion. While we're on the base of the sign, have you considered?

1:24:02 Some sort of facing? Or will it be hidden with landscaping? Part of it will be hidden by landscaping. It's only this tall. And in the wintertime, certainly that tall is kind of in the snow. We don't have any rock on the building, and I don't like putting just a teeny little bit of rock on the building. And so to put a little teeny bit of rock on the sign, I don't know. That's a fit. Doesn't work. But it will be pretty much camouflaged by the landscape? It should, yes.

1:24:31 By the landscaping? Yes. Okay, because I had some concern about the plainness of it, the base. We kind of want the base to be plain because the focus is the sign part of it. Okay, just as long as you have some bushes, that'll be fine. Along the side, the west side, and the south side? Yes. Is that grass? Is it paver? What is that? The landscape? On the ground. On the ground, if you look at the landscape plan, there's ground covers.

1:25:00 All sorts of stuff on there. Oh, but I thought that was snow storage, so you're going to... You can drive a loader... Yeah, but are you just going to drive over that? Sure. That's why there's no trees there, but there are lots of things that you can drive a loader over that come back in the spring. Okay. Okay. I saw the little bushes, but I... Okay. Thank you. I think I just have one question, because I can't read it on this, but is your loading dock in the front?

1:25:32 Entrance. The loading is, it's just, yes, there's a doorway that goes in. Is it, that's from the cover here is the, the garage, the raised garage looking door? No, that's trash. That's trash. That's just trash. So we have trash pickup and loading and in the very front entrance off of the parking lot, is that correct? Yes, we do. Okay. Yeah. Yeah. That's it.

1:26:03 The two and a half feet I mentioned of those verticals on the sign, give us your argument for that, the necessity for that two and a half feet for design. It's, it's, we wanted something that kind of raised to the sky and kind of stood up and like, you know, as opposed to something that at the eight foot, if we stop everything at the eight foot line, then we have what appears to be a short spot sign. And we didn't want to have that appearance of a short spot.

1:26:39 More difficult to do the extension and doing a nice detailed end on the steel if it only goes up to the eight foot height, then it's not going to have that on there because it doesn't work to then have a sign do this to a flat. What could you do with a foot, say, as opposed to two and a half feet? Well, I mean, I can do something in a foot. I could do more in a foot and a half and I can do what I think looks really great in between.

1:27:14 So, that's just my thought. To try to have something that you can see and you can find and you'll see from moving down the street towards this, that's all I, I mean, it's considerably shorter than most older designs in town, so. This is just a curiosity thing, the drains in the roof, do you have to heat those at all, or is that designed as long as things are cold enough, it just stays?

1:27:51 All that collects and stays at that. They work from, there'll be a bit of heat tape in them just for when it gets really cold and the building gets cold inside. Generally that won't be on. There's enough latent heat of the building, even though you insulate everything really well. You've got a pipe that's penetrating through and the pipe gets warm. And it's not just a drain in each location. And there's more than a dozen drains on the roof.

1:28:21 It's a drain, an overflow drain. They're together. So that's what the pair was. Okay. That's what the pair was. And one is, one is, they're stuck down in kind of a recess, and one is down at the bottom of the recess, and one has a two-inch lip line. So when this one gets clogged, that one then starts to work. Got it. Thank you. Can you follow up on this? Okay. Bruce, just help me out here, because I don't have my glasses. What is the height of the sign from the bottom of the base to the top of the I-beam?

1:28:51 To the top of the I-beam? Eight feet. Only eight feet? That's eight feet. And the bottom of this? Oh, to the top of the... I don't know if you're pointing at it, because I can't see what you're pointing at. Yeah, from the bottom of the base to the top of the I-beam. To the top of the horizontal is eight feet. And then it's here. Oh, I see. The other... Okay. The vertical I-beam is what I'm talking about. I'm sorry. The vertical one is then ten and a half feet. Okay, so if you're standing on the base, if you're a kid standing on the base, there's no way you can reach the top of the... You can't. Vertical. Okay. Because the base is two feet?

1:29:23 It's two feet. It shows us two feet. Two feet, okay. Thank you. I have a letter here from the Mammoth Hospital Auxiliary that we just got today, having to do with the parking next door, and that they, just as a letter stating how, it says, it's from Ellie Randall, President of the Hospital Auxiliary. The Mammoth Hospital Auxiliary Board has

1:29:56 Met with Dan O'Connor, who's the proponent of this, on two different occasions to discuss common interests regarding parking and snow removal between the cast-off and the proposed bowling center. The auxiliar is willing to share parking, snow removal, and parking lot maintenance between the bowling center and cast-off in designated areas subject to presentation by respective attorneys. There's a lot of insurance stuff and things like that that have to get worked out on that, but that's what this is.

1:30:23 So please give that to the clerk so it can be part of the record. I'll give it back. We can make a copy. Chair, did you have another question? No. We didn't. No, right now. Okay. Thank you, Bruce. Okay. We will now have a call for testimony from those persons who wish to speak in support of the project. So anyone who wishes to speak in support? I would like to thank Bruce very, very much for doing this.

1:31:11 We have been asking for this ever since I moved here in the 70s, asking for the whole reality forever and ever and ever. I'm happy with what he's doing, and I'm in support of it. I just have a question for Bruce. Is there going to be like handicap parking, handicap stalls, and room for wheelchairs to get around inside of it and everything? I'm very happy with it. Thanks. Thank you, Lee. Hello. Dave Harvey, Mammoth Citizen.

1:31:47 I am fully in favor of this project. I think, as Lee just said, there's many of us in town that have been waiting for this project to come along. And in this economic environment, we have somebody willing to take the risk and step out and to do something nobody else is willing to do. And I think this needs to be, number one, recognized and commended.

1:32:14 Any issues, I understand that at one time there was some discussion about parking. You know, if we're going to walk the walk, talk the talk, we've got to do it in unison. And if we're going to be a feet first community, well let's act like it. The people have arrived here, this is not like their final destination.

1:32:42 This is just one of the activities that they're going to visit while they're in town. We have a wonderful park and ride. We have a wonderful bus system and trolley system. Let's bring that into the equation. And maybe that becomes part of the marketing of the bowling alley. Park your car at the park and ride. Take the trolley and enjoy a day of bowling and having fun. So your recommendations weigh very strongly, very heavily.

1:33:12 on the Council. So I just want to remind Commission of the very powerful nature that you have in getting these things achieved for the community. Thank you so very much. Thank you, Dave. Anyone else in support? My name is Robin Schmidt. I'm the manager of Forest Meadows Condominiums directly across the street. And the Forest Meadows Board of Directors asked me to come forward and say that we are not opposing the Bowling Center.

1:33:47 And we are in favor of it, but we do have concerns. We have eight condominiums that face directly at where the bowling center is going to be, and four of those condominiums are occupied by full-time residents. And our main concern is parking, because it'll be me who goes and makes sure that the bowling center patrons aren't parked in our lot, and it'll be me towing them.

1:34:15 That is a huge concern for us. And actually, Marvin, the manager of Bristlecone Apartments, he couldn't be here, but that's also a major concern of his as well. And it sounds like with the park and ride and the cast-off, the things are trying to get resolved in that manner. The cast-off parking, though, on a big, big cast-off day, cast-off people park in that dirt of the vacant lot.

1:34:40 All the overflow. So I'm not sure on a big cast-off day, big bowling center day, and a big Christmas vacation day, how that's all going to come into play. It'll be interesting, but I think it can be worked out. Another one of our concerns is noise, because it is a bar, and a lot of my residents that live there are afraid that there's just going to be a lot of...

1:35:06 After hours noise. I don't know what the hours of the bowling center even are, but if it's two in the morning and you've got drunks out in the parking lot, that's something that won't be acceptable to us. And another issue that we have is lighting. We want to make sure that the lighting is all night sky compliant and not shining into the windows of our residents. It sounds like if the sign is shining out towards Old Mammoth, that won't really affect us. It might affect...

1:35:34 Thank you.

1:36:01 Mark, would it be appropriate to address a couple of those things now before we... Sure, go ahead. Okay. With the parking issue, is there anything else we can do in terms of conditions that help with avoiding that problem of parking spilling over across the street? I think we should ask the applicant to pay for two signs, one for each parking lot, and say no parking for the, you know, Mammoth Rock and Bowl. You know, two attractive signs.

1:36:32 You know, the intent of zoning and conditions and parking analyses is to say that and to determine that you're providing adequate parking. I think if the applicant was amenable to working with a neighborhood like that, that could be something that you might request and you might agree to. You know, typically,

1:36:59 When we go through our analysis and we're making the determination that the system of increased transit, walking and outside parking, and the condition that they secure parking, because that condition must be satisfied, that's bundled together to say there is adequate parking. And I think in a normal condition, we would not require, in this case,

1:37:24 in the applicant to post those signs, but the applicant may well be amenable to agreeing to that because you're only anticipating that there's a problem and we don't actually expect to see a parking problem through our analysis. And connected to that, as I see this, the potential shared parking arrangement with the castoff is a very good one because it seems to me that almost all the time you're going to have

1:37:53 My client has also had negotiations with other

1:38:23 Adjacent or nearby properties, we haven't had as much, there hasn't been as much discussion yet with those, but there's the, where Skeetown Blicker is, and that, that area for the ability to work out something with them, and to maybe to work out something even across the street at Bergs, property in the corner. And the client is amenable to, if a need arises, that a sign needs to be, needs to go up to tell people.

1:38:53 To not park in the Bristlecone parking lots. Or the, I always call them blue groups, sorry. In their parking, that they'll procure signs to be put up and work with those two groups of people to make sure it's done and what would work. But we want to, I don't think we want to say that, yeah, we're going to put signs up right now. If there isn't a problem, I don't want my client to have to.

1:39:21 Put up signs that aren't necessary. And staff would agree with that. Give it a chance to work. And also, you know, it would remind us that we already have provisions in the code that would allow satisfying parking through an assessment district through a shared parking program. We didn't take that approach because there are procedures associated with that. And your new zoning code, your parking requirements, could be satisfied in many different ways.

1:39:49 Ultimately, on the feet first issues, there can be situations where there could be no on-site parking required because they've been satisfied in other reasonable ways. Noise, the municipal code has noise regulations and we enforce those. And so for folks that are violating those noise standards, which are decibel and also, I think, time of day, we call the police.

1:40:20 One of the other things about this is that if noise is generated by anyone, it would be when they're leaving. When the building is occupied and there's music downstairs in the barn area, that's all on the back side of the building and you've got to go through a number of doors to get out. We don't believe that we'll have any kind of noise leakage out of the building to the north. We may have some.

1:40:49 To the east, if someone goes out the door, you're going to hear a bit of noise, or to the south, but that's away from where people live. Bruce, what... I'm sorry, I was going to say that if there was noise leakage, they need to turn down the south. The hours? Not positive right now, but weekend nights till 1 and probably opening 11 o'clock.

1:41:18 Not expecting a lot of business during the days unless, you know, Saturday where it's really stormy weather in the middle of winter or any of the days this past or more of the weekend would have been good days for people to use the bowling center because the weather was so miserable. So, but that's sort of the way we envision it.

1:41:46 In terms of lighting, condition 17 requires compliance with their municipal code. They're required anyway, but we state that as a condition. And it might be worth a one-minute tutorial on what that means, because if people don't know about that ordinance, there are a lot of lights around time that are not in compliance, but they should understand that this will be in compliance, and what does that mean? Right, sure, I can summarize that for you. Basically, our lighting ordinance is a dark sky lighting ordinance, and

1:42:14 It limits the wattage of bulbs, you know, to the minimum necessary to light whatever area is being lit and it also requires all lighting to be downward directed and shielded so that the source of the light is not visible from off of the property. So light doesn't fall on any property other than the property? Right. And also I just wanted to point out to you we do include a finding on page 2-14.

1:42:39 For the use permit, the finding states that the proposed use would be operated in a way that's compatible to surrounding uses and it requires the project to comply with all noise lighting and other requirements of the municipal code. Thank you, Pam. Any others wishing to speak in support? I'm an owner and resident at Forest Matters, a.k.a. Blue Roofs. I have no qualms about...

1:43:15 The bowling alley in town, I don't even have any qualms about a bowling alley at this location, but I find that 37 parking spaces for a facility that has 12 lanes and a bar and a restaurant is wholly inadequate. The idea of five spaces on the street when we can't park anywhere on the street in the winter makes those spaces a moot point.

1:43:45 I mean, I don't want to flog a dead horse, but there are less parking spaces at the cast-off during the day than they can use. They use half of that lot and they use street parking. The idea of having off-site parking for another 17 spaces, if it's not the cast-off, anything, as you said, up to 300 feet away,

1:44:15 Well, our parking lot is 50 feet away. And I've got to tell you that a few years ago there was a bar over where the bicycle store is now, and we couldn't get any parking in our lot. If we came up on Friday night after 9 p.m., there was not a space to be found for our cars in our lot. If we went to dinner on a Friday night and came home, there were no spaces left.

1:44:45 If you don't require enough parking spaces close enough, then the whole issue falls on Robin's shoulders to go out there and police a parking lot for a corporate entity across the street. It's about all I've got to say. Thank you. Anyone else in support? Okay, we've seen no motion. Anyone wish to speak in opposition? Okay, and then I think we have another category.

1:45:20 Just general testimony, anybody who wants to say anything about the project. Okay. Rebuttal of the previous testimony by the applicant. Anything else, Bruce, that you would like to add? I think we have in the process of submitting this and what we've done in our planning and all the discussions we've had with the staff and with the design review committee of the planning commission prior, so on the parking issue.

1:45:57 And it's, so that's, I don't think that I need to rebut that. And it's not a corporate entity. It's a local resident who's building this. Thank you. I have a quick response, too, just to clarify. The five on-street parking spaces would be available for use for parking in the winter months because it's a part of a commercial district. The only time those spaces wouldn't be available is temporarily when they're being used for snow storage after large snowstorms. Thank you.

1:46:28 Question. I have a question to you. Go ahead, Jen. Would there be parking in front of the Bristlecone's and Forest Meadows, thank you. Is there parking, street parking there? They have parking there for their units. Oh, for their units. Okay. Yeah, that was approved previous to the town. And they can park there in the winter, too? Yes.

1:46:55 Thank you. The parking in front of this project would be signed, no parking from, say, 2 a.m. to 7 a.m. So we can do snow removal during the morning hours. Peter, that street is a dead end still. That's correct. Is there any possibility of having head-end parking at the end of the street? I know I've turned around there a number of times. And who would rule on that?

1:47:25 Well, we stored a lot of snow at that end, so it wouldn't be conducive to our snow removal operation. But if it were not between the hours at 2 a.m. and 7 a.m., would it work? Something we could study. Because it seems like, what, eight parking places may be there headed in? Probably, but it's really a significant, I think the condom also stores snow in that area, so it's really a, you know, we put a mountain of snow at that end. Okay.

1:47:58 It's something that we would need to study. Robin, can you come to the microphone so people at home can hear? And while you approach it, you know, we're most interested in having, you know, making sure we have identified the number of spaces to be satisfied and then do so through an off-site parking situation. So whether it's satisfied by transit service or we've calculated a walking demand or there is a particular lot. And you'll note that...

1:48:25 In the reference to on-street parking, that's only referenced. It's not counting towards the demand. So that would be a similar situation for other heading parking if they're ever running. Okay. Okay, the way Chateau Road goes is there's the lot that's in question. And then there's Southern California Edison. So there's that whole length. There's no really real parking there. And at the end, there's the bike trail.

1:48:52 Which they keep clear for the kids. And that's right at the very far corner. And then there's a small easement that goes in between our property and the bike trails. Very small. They're probably, if you've tried to get parking in there, you might get one or two cars. But the way that when the town removes the snow, they push all of that snow from Chateau Road all the way to the very end. And then last winter, there was just a giant snow mountain. Oh, I can imagine.

1:49:21 But what I was thinking is, because a lot of people do park on the street, or they would like to park on the street where Sierra Manor Road dead ends down in Duvon's, if you made that parking, daytime parking only, although you would have a hard time enforcing that, not just getting the bristlecone people parking in there too, that might just fill up like that between, I don't know if it would work or not if you made the Sierra Manor Road daytime or

1:49:50 Or Bowling Center parking. But that might mess up snow removal as well because even in a good winter, that road gets very, very narrow. I don't know. One of the many reasons why we're trying to get people out of their cars. Oh, yeah. Robin, do you know how much parking is in Southern California Edison, SCE? They have about four spots, five spots.

1:50:22 Because most of their front is a landscaped area. Their parking area that they have is mostly for people to run in and out and pay their electric bill. But it's usually empty after 5 p.m. when they close? So that might be an option, too. And Condition 36 really gives the applicant several options to meet the parking requirement. I think we're ready to close the public hearing and deliberate.

1:51:03 Sure. First of all, I'm in complete support of this project. I want to see it successful. And there's a few things here that I have questions about that we maybe need to look at. I think probably one of the most successful places that I've seen for this project in a resort area is in Vail. It has no parking. It's on the shuttle route.

1:51:35 It is off of a plaza. And I would seriously consider the coat check is an amazing revenue source there. Good point. And this is not a place that people bring their own equipment usually, so they do have, they travel a lot lighter than most activities I have seen because they're on vacation and a destination and nobody wants to pay for bowling ball on a plane.

1:52:04 So, how we look at it, making it successful, is one of the things that we want to emulate in this community. I have a problem with the parking, but I have an opposite problem with it. I think there's too much, and here's why. Is that, to Dave's point there, we need to talk the talk. And I'm a major concern, not about the height of your sign, that anybody's going to know you're there. Because I drove this...

1:52:33 During the day, in that area, and I looked where your sign was going to be, and going at the posted speed limit, I'm going to have to strain to know it's there. So I am very concerned, and what I don't want to see is that the only alternative is that you have to put a banner on Old Mammoth Road to say Park and Ride, Rock and Bowl, whatever it's going to be for the day, is there. And we have a building set so far back that

1:53:03 It's going to, it will be an issue, especially when mountains of snow are piled around here. I think snow storage could be an issue if you, that you could help solve if you paved one side of it to where you can push snow back to Mammoth Creek Park to keep this area open because eventually I'd like to see that parking lot gone because that's a great place for a convention center.

1:53:26 with all of the things that you have there that people actually ride to. So it's a very hard philosophy to get people going to give up their cars, but once you are in town and if it is accessible to everything, they give up their cars. And one of the best ways is that your parking spots there, is that where you're going to put the bus stop or does the bus go right up to the front door?

1:53:50 There's other things to think about, the traffic flow and keeping people out of that area there. And I think your deck is too small. I think that's where you should shift the building a little bit there because that is the best view in town. I think that your area where you have it backed right up to the edge of the property line is where your terrace would be to be Mammoth Creek Park.

1:54:18 That being said, the project is going to work. I think that we're going to have to look at this project in the upkeep a little differently to make it successful because the mountains of snow are going to hide you. The mountains of snow are going to jeopardize the existing parking that you have. And the mountains of snow are going to put your neighbors into issues as well.

1:54:45 I think that having to remove the snow from that area, if we're pushing it to another area, might be an option just to look at. Your business plan is definitely going to have to be offset where your neighbors are for the park. This, what is successful in resort communities is not necessarily during the day. It's they open up around 3 and they go till 11 or 12. Even in Aspen doesn't go to 1 because people just wear out.

1:55:14 At that point. So it's very rare. Maybe in the afternoon or in the summertime they can do that. But there is a pattern that works that could be compatible because your facility has the ability for shared parking for events if we put it in the right spot. And looking at all the parking on the corner there, places that...

1:55:35 May be able to share parking during the day. You're going to provide parking during the day in the morning for others there and looking at when your business model works when those places are closed. So I really want to stress that let's make it to where people will walk and shuttle because you stated here that everything is a quarter of a mile, that the shuttle stops are a quarter of a mile.

1:56:01 It's not excessive in the summer and it's not excessive in the winter. How do we capitalize on that to make that work there? And to make sure that people see each business is there. I have no problem with the height of this sign. I think it's too low. I think it's, you know, it's too discreet in my opinion there. So I think we'll be looking further down the line for alternatives to make sure that people can see it there because they're going to be driving around. They drive around and look for my place of business.

1:56:30 And they look at the bears and think, isn't that great? They don't see that that's where they're going. So, you know, how you get across, you know, the marketing, I think would be the biggest challenges, but we have a great opportunity to do something current, something now, and not ride the end of the way. So, you know, I just want to make sure that we keep those options open to look at a little different to solve those issues because we build too many buildings in this town that the loading dock is in the front.

1:57:00 Have a real problem with that. And why is that? It's because that's where the access is the front. And I just want to make sure that if that's where it has to go, then that's where it has to go. But let's keep the access open to either side because I can see in a few years you would tear out that landscape on the side, put a paved driveway through there, but it's a paved area to make a plaza to Mammoth Creek Park to enlarge your space right there because it's a feet first.

1:57:29 Type of venue. You have a great venue there, and let's see if we can, you know, open that up to get that started. Some things I was seeing. Thank you. Next. Go ahead, Sharon. Well, I don't have any problems. I'm in total support, so. I agree with you, though. I think we may have to do some things in the future to be certain that it. The site can evolve to where we're looking for, and that's where I want to make sure.

1:58:00 That that site that we're looking at now, that if we'd only done this. So I want to make sure it can evolve for the needs of the community later on and to improve the neighbors' experience there as well. Thank you. Following on Rhonda's comment about the loading dock in the front, that's very unsuccessful at Weston. It was really a shame that that worked out that way. But I'm not sure it's going to be so bad here because

1:58:31 It's recessed and there's a door and it's over to the side and I hope that the parking area is wide enough that it won't be like it is driving up to the west end, but that is a concern. I would say probably the where that works is because of the timing of deliveries or when you are going to be closed. Yeah, it has to do a lot with trucks delivering, you know, in the morning, midday, basically we're not open so we don't have a conflict.

1:58:58 There's, I mean, we can't get to any other side of the building. There's certain, I mean, there's certainly, we're hemmed in, kind of, and they're really, this is one of the biggest vacant pieces of land in the Town of Mammoth Lakes, and it's not big. It's kind of like, it's either here, it's nowhere. Yeah. That's fair. That's fair. But in your particular situation, I have no problem with the loading dock in front, because I can see it's going to work, whereas it didn't work at Weston.

1:59:28 Shall I go ahead? Okay. I've got some questions, but first I want to talk about the good stuff. I'm just so impressed with this project and we so need this and thank you for bringing this to Mammoth. The fact that your architect was able to take a big box of space, you know, that could have looked like Costco and make it into a contemporary design, but a contemporary design that's going to be classic. It's just going to, you know, wear so well.

1:59:55 I like the rafter tails on a flat roof. I mean, they're not coming from the flat roof, but those details around the edge, the way they're exposed. If you see them exposed on a conventional 4 and 12 roof, it just looks so 70s. But on this design, it doesn't look that way at all. I like the addition of that eyebrow sort of pergola roof across the front to break up that expanse. I'm not sure if I used the right words. I just learned how to use parapet correctly.

2:00:22 Anyway, that really helps the front of the building. I think your full cutoff lighting is excellent. I like the way the windows are recessed. Very much like the sign design, and I don't think it's too high. I think it's too low. I wish the sign could be bigger and higher because your awful Mammoth Road, I share Ronda's concern about that. I don't know if you can have variances for signs. Can have variances for signs? What can we condition you just stated?

2:00:52 You should change the ordinance. That would require changing the ordinance, and we just adopted a really good ordinance, too. I believe the ordinance does allow a slight increase in height for signs if they would be blocked by snow. Oh. So if there's an inability to remove snow from in front of the sign, is that correct? That's, yeah, it's because those snow storage areas, they concern.

2:01:20 Is there any options that keep them from having to remove the snow in order to do that and put them in other areas? I'm just concerned and we may work it out. If we could raise the sign, you know, make the base higher or something, I think that would be a good thing to do. Not bigger, just higher. Yeah, higher. My three big concerns are, number one, the roof color. And I've been...

2:01:42 Considered unrealistic about roof colors, but this is so visible from Mammoth Rock Trail, and when I know the cool roof concept, and this is, is it the law of the land now in California? I'm not sure, but when I look at the solar reflectance index, appliance white, kitchen appliance white is 0.79, and almond, which is the color of, you know, the scrub, the desert, is 0.76, so I wonder why we can't consider something that's not a white roof.

2:02:12 So, that's, I mean, a light color, but not a white roof. It really... If I could, we just did that for the SARS building. I know, and that's where people considered me being unrealistic and, you know, gets kind of that whole color Nazi thing, which I don't want to bring up, but I just did anyway. But, so it doesn't have to be a white roof? Is that right, Mark? No, the efficiency coefficient is...

2:02:39 Pretty close for an almond color. Yeah, it's .03. That's just what we did on the SARS billing permit process. Okay, that's good. That's one concern. Next concern is this concrete. I love the fact that the bases are trapezoidal, but it's three right angles, and you just have one, you know, line that's slanted. I mean, that looks great. I like the fact they're tall, but I'm concerned about how the surface of that concrete is going.

2:03:09 I don't know what you can do with concrete. I don't know if you can burnish it or polish it or do something, but there is concrete, not at eye level, but up around where you're going to see it, and it's a lot of it. And I know it's a small percentage in terms of the total volume of the building, but it's conspicuous. That's the word I want to say. So I wish there was something you could do with the concrete. And then my last thing is the landscaping.

2:03:35 It's going to be totally trashed in those snow storage areas and you're spending a lot of money for shrubs and trees that I don't see how they're going to make it. I know a snow storage area is between you and Edison and it would be nice to set off the building if you could have more trees there but then you're not going to have enough snow storage. So I might suggest that you follow the inspiration of Roberto's which then inspired the post office which has inspired other places and do perennials and wildflowers.

2:04:03 Which die down to the ground in the winter, and then they'll be under the snow, and then they come back like gangbusters in our, you know, high solar climate. I'm just really concerned about all those shrubs. They will be completely trashed. And then they'll look sort of like, oh, they tried to recover, you know, but you can do a lot with perennials. So I'm concerned about that. Obviously you can do what you want with that because your plan is perfectly acceptable. It's just not going to survive. That's what I'm worried about.

2:04:33 So those are my issues. Thank you, Elizabeth. Your last one first. I've got to reply to that because we've got all last winter we had 12 and 13 feet of snow on either side of our driveway. We're piling up on the driveway and it always amazes me every year. We have bushes, we have plants that come back just fine. No problem. So do I. It's amazing to see. Every year I think it's not going to happen, but it does. Wow.

2:04:57 I had like four inch aspens just broken over. Our neighbor has aspens, they're all dying because of aspens, but not the bushes. Not the blooming potentella, which is gorgeous. So I respectfully disagree. That's fine, that's fine. Bushes don't do so well where we are, but we're out in Old Mammoth, and you know, that's a whole different universe out there. Let's see, parking, I...

2:05:22 I acknowledge the concern of people across the street. You can see why that's a worry. But I'm confident that it's going to work well. And I think it's going to work well. And it's not like if it doesn't work, there's nothing we can do about it. The way the condition is worded, we have ways to address that if it doesn't work. So I'm confident that that will work out. I had one little suggestion to make on the snow storage.

2:05:50 Condition, which was, let me turn to the page, condition number 5. 17. 17, thank you. And I had sent this to Pam. I thought it would be a little more clear. If you look on... I think it's condition 28. Oh, I'm sorry. Which condition? I'm getting condition numbers. On page numbers, condition numbers confused. 19. It's condition 28. Yeah.

2:06:27 And right now, Pam, I'm getting... Thank you. The bottom of page 2-19. I'm trying to find the right place. And I think... Okay. In the second line where it says that the project will remove excess snow from on-site parking and walkways, I have suggested we add it and move such snow to an off-site location because it doesn't say that there. It's just... Wait, are you at 28? Yes. Uh-huh. Oh. Yeah.

2:06:57 It implies it because it says in the event on-site snow storage is unavailable, but I just thought it might be a little better. So what are we adding? After parking and walkways and move such snow to an off-site location, comma, and then continue within the event. No, I agree because that area was a little confused. It's like, well, kind of read like last resorts were going to have to put it in the parking lot. I'm like, no. Yeah, right. It's not the sort.

2:07:26 What if it said, Covenant for Snow hauling to an off-site location shall be? That's more concise. Pam, is that okay with you? Okay. Yeah, that's fine. So we're just putting off-site right after hauling? Yeah. Okay. To an off-site location. The sign, I agree with everything that Elizabeth and Rhonda said about height and so on.

2:07:59 I just want our ordinance to reflect reality, and if it doesn't fit these sort of things, we already need to think about changing it, but maybe it does fit. Mark, do you remember, we just had this concern with the new sign for the new restaurant on Old Mammoth, what's the name, CJ's, and

2:08:22 There's an allowance for it to show up above snow, and I can't remember what the height limit was for that. I don't recall that actual dimension, but it is there, and I might suggest that you consider an amendment, a minor amendment that says something to the effect, the sign may be, modifications to the sign may be approved by the Community Development Director consistent with the sign ordinance to ensure adequate visibility related to snow management.

2:08:52 Yes. Is that an illustration or? Yeah, we would add that. At the end of the condition probably? To which one? Number 34. 34. Yeah. Because maybe we also pay a little close attention to our wayfinding areas because we've thought, I've traditionally thought of wayfinding as things that were

2:09:18 Natural areas or just regions of town, but, you know, we may want to open wayfinding to particular areas of interest that do have commercial value because, you know, wayfinding to the top of Mammoth Mound ski area is pretty limited.

2:09:39 Right now and throughout town. So maybe it's looking that your wayfinding includes the golf course, includes recreational activity signs that also have commercial districts there. Because if you look at other communities, when they have a lot of wayfinding signs, but they do say that there's a mall here, that there's restaurants and retail along this way. And maybe we address it through our wayfinding signs as well as the commercial entity itself.

2:10:08 I like that. Yeah, we might carry that over to our wayfinding topic. Right. And then the last thing I had a concern with initially was the affordable housing, the rationale of where this use fits in with whether on the side of the uses that are not exempt or the uses that are. With the discussion we had today, I just want to make it a matter of record. It seems pretty clear to me that logically the types of uses we're talking about here

2:10:41 It makes sense for those logically to be included as exempt as analogous to retail and restaurant uses. So overall, I think it's a great project. I think it's going to be exciting to see this get implemented. It's just turned out very well. I think we're at the point of interfering the motion. Could we review some of the revised conditions? Okay.

2:11:09 One, the applicant was amenable to having a condition, something to be effective. If project patrons or employees park in surrounding residential properties, applicant is agreeable to cooperating to provide appropriate parking siteage to control. And that's where it's conditioned on experience.

2:11:35 Right. Yeah. And it was, if the need arises, and we described what the need is, almond color roof material. Mm-hmm. Yes. My client is amenable to doing that, but if it goes the other way around, if they start parking in our lot, then they get to put signs in. I mean, it seems fair. If we had to put signs in their parking lot, because our patrons are parking there, if they start to park in our parking lots,

2:12:06 Without an agreement to do that, that something has to be worked out. What patrons do you expect to park? If people that are coming and visiting the Bristlecone Apartments across the street start parking in our parking lot, and we've had to put a sign up in there saying we can't, our patrons can't park there. That's a good point. I don't think we can actually catch them to this condition.

2:12:35 You know, there's certainly good will. Say your name again, please. Andrea O'Connell, my husband, they're building this project. As far as the parking, you know, we're working with Castoff. Castoff says they have a problem with people parking overnight already in their belongings, what they told us. I'm concerned about that also.

2:12:59 I think it's, I'm not sure the condition needs to be in there. I would, I personally am very amenable to speaking directly, but I don't think it needs to be in the conference. That's my personal view, because I may have exactly the same problem the other way, and I don't think it's appropriate to discuss the conference across the street with reference to this. So it's the Commission's pleasure.

2:13:24 Is this area posted as no parking between two and when you're not supposed to park there? Yeah, no, I'm sure we will put signs up that say there's no parking from this hour. I will take the cast off. The ladies have told me that people go park there right under their sign. So they have a problem with enforcement. We'll be there a little bit later so we can enforce that nobody's parking there. That's not either. Rolling Alley.

2:13:50 Or that's still there, you know, after you've cleaned up, shut everything down, and their car is still out there. We'll see them. So, and I am concerned about that. I'm concerned about the, you know, what they're concerned about, I'm concerned about. It's a turn. Yeah, the option is, you know, you put something in to acknowledge the applicant's amenability to doing this, or you do not, and then...

2:14:16 The issue becomes one of good faith between the parties and or co-compliance. We plan on being good neighbors, so it's not, you know, we want them happy. I want the bully, for goodness sakes. I want their money. I have a question. When it comes to co-compliance, we don't have a co-compliance officer. Through the chair, the public hearing's closed, and typically when we close the public hearing, yeah.

2:14:55 Public comments are not, there's a period of public comment at the end of the meeting? But you can't talk about it because it's not, it's part of the agenda. If you have a comment about code compliance, you can raise that at the public comment period at the end of the meeting. Well, I was just concerned about them because, I mean, we have phones all over town, and if you have to call on something, you know it's going to be wrong. Why don't you make your comment in the second public comment and make it, generalize it to code compliance?

2:15:25 But you understand the procedure, Lee. Okay. I thought she was addressing what they had addressed, so I thought it was all. But public comment has closed. That's the way the procedure works. If we don't have this kind of a provision added, how does that reduce?

2:15:53 The options of what can be done. Does it change things, really? No, it does not. In any use permit that you review, can you review the parking requirements and the parking plan and approve them? If there's a problem in the neighborhood that's impacting the area, it's traditionally a code compliance effort. Okay. Well, I think that makes it a little more clear than we have the parameters. I would agree. It doesn't preclude you from doing anything in the future. Okay.

2:16:22 So we covered the sign, we scratched the offsite parking issue. You made the modification to Commission 28 regarding haul to an offsite location. Was the Commission satisfied with the landscaping or did you want to modify from shrubs to flowers? I'm satisfied.

2:16:53 He'll do what he needs to do. Right. I would just encourage you to plant lots of perennials. You'll be so happy. You'll do what survives. I know that. We'll come back. I mean, we've got to get approval for the landscape plan, actually, as part of our building. And we'll come back in then, and if it's perennials on the plan at that time, it'll be perennials. But we'll keep up whatever is there. It's to the advantage of the building to count it nicely from the landscape.

2:17:26 Bruce, our potentiel has come back beautifully every year, and they're covered under 10, 20 feet of snow. No, no, there's some shrubs that do. I have nothing against shrubs, it's just, it's a lot of money for that. Yeah, the one additional change was the change that Commissioner Clark suggested to condition 19 take out the reference to tree protection and only reference erosion control measures.

2:17:53 And then the two additional changes that I mentioned during my report at the beginning of the presentation. And I believe the applicant indicated there are some trees adjacent to the property that we would want to be protected. So maybe it stays as a standard condition. Okay. I move that we find the project to be categorically exempt from CEQA and approve use permit 11-002.

2:18:29 and design review 11-002 with conditions as recommended by staff and the changes that Mark just outlined for us. Second. We have a motion and a second. Yes. Vice Chair Dyke? Yes. Smiths or Tenney? Yes. Mr. Clark? Yes. Motion passes. Boarding zero. Can you get it opened by Christmas?

2:19:00 Yeah. Which is, which is, which one? By Christmas. Feel pressure. We're moving on to business matters. We have agenda item three, which is public comments on the trail system master plan draft environmental impact report. It's to be presented by Ellen Clark. Thank you. Should be extra wisdom.

2:20:22 Thank you. I put the extra ones over on the table. So this agenda item is a public comment meeting for the Trust and Master Plan Draft EIR. We're currently in the public review period for the document. And CEQA encourages various opportunities for the public and interested parties to provide input on the CEQA document.

2:21:04 Holding this is an opportunity for public comment. I'm not sure we have any members of the public here, so I'll try to get my presentation brief. Very briefly, as I know, this is the environmental review, the CEQA documentation for the draft trail system master plan that was published in February 2009. The trail system master plan is a comprehensive trail system plan for the entire Mammoth Lakes area, the entire Mammoth Lakes trail system.

2:21:35 Covering the entire area within the town's municipal boundary. It includes numerous components, hard and soft surface trails, bike facilities, projects within the Sherman area and outside of the urban growth boundary, as well as management, maintenance and implementation policies and guidelines. Just a couple of graphics showing the project area, the town's boundary and planning area. Some detail on the

2:22:08 Components that are within the growth boundary and within the Sherland area. VEIR itself has been written at a program level, meaning it's relatively high level. It covers a broad project area series of related actions that are expected to take place over a long period of time. And in addition to that program level analysis, also focuses on a series of nine near-term projects that were looked at in more detail.

2:22:40 to facilitate their near-term implementation to really minimize the amount of additional CEQA review that would be required. The program level analysis is intended to be used in conjunction with future project-specific review for individual components of the trail system to simplify and focus that review to minimize that subsequent CEQA review that may be required. It's also written to facilitate future NEPA review, which will be required for projects, components on four ships.

2:23:11 The process to prepare the CIR began in the middle of last year and resulted in the publication of a notice of preparation of an initial study which looked at broadly the range of issues that might be of interest in the EIR. There was a public scoping period of about a month held in November, of course there was a public scoping meeting in November.

2:23:36 As a result of that, various issues and concerns were identified which are looked at in the draft EIR. This is a list of topic areas that are covered by the EIR. It includes most of the CEQA required topics with the exception of a few items such as utilities, mineral resources, agricultural resources that aren't really of concern.

2:24:01 As well as cumulative effects of this project in conjunction with other projects in the area, and as well as a series of alternatives. Very briefly, these are the major impact areas that we're studying and where impacts were identified. I won't repeat them here. I can read them off the slide. But there were a number of impacts identified in various areas, as you can see.

2:24:30 And in all cases, mitigation measures were identified in the EIR that could reduce those to a less than significant level. Because of the program level, programmatic nature of the document, most of those mitigation measures relate to looking at means that can be incorporated into future projects when they are developed. Some of those do rely on additional studies that will be conducted when more specific alignments are developed as part of future project implementation.

2:25:00 And importantly, the EIR did not find any impacts that were significant and unavoidable. So all impacts that were identified can be mitigated through the mitigation measures specified in the EIR. Three alternatives were looked at as CEQA requires, including a no project, no development alternative, meaning no more trails would be developed in town.

2:25:23 or in the municipal boundary, an alternative that considered just the complete implementation of the 1991 Trail System Master Plan, a much more limited trail network, and finally, a reduced trails network alternative that considered only projects within the UGB and not outside of that area, so a much reduced trails network. And although alternative C, being confined to the town's urbanized area, was environmentally superior in terms of the

2:25:52 level and extent of impacts that were associated with it, it was found to fail to meet most of the project objectives and goals, which, as you can imagine, are to implement a comprehensive and much more extensive town-wide trail network than we have today. In terms of process, this meeting and the public comment period is an opportunity to comment on the adequacy of the draft DIR.

2:26:16 Whether it was consistent with the requirements of CEQA, were the impacts reviewed properly and analyzed appropriately, are the mitigation measures identified sufficient and adequate to mitigate the impacts that have been identified, and were the range of alternatives discussed sufficient and appropriate. We will be receiving comments during the public comment period, both verbally, if anyone cares to speak at this meeting, or

2:26:45 Through written comments. And all of those comments will be responded to in full in the final EIR that will be coming for the Planning Commission and Town Council as part of the adoption hearings for the Trust and Master Plan. Just as a note, if people watching this on television do have comments, that's my contact information to provide written comments. Next steps, the comment period is due to end at the end of next week on September the 2nd.

2:27:17 We're going to provide an update to the Recreation Commission that they're meeting in September, probably to the Mobility Commission later in September. We're targeting the lease of the final EIR, the actual document, around September 19th, with the Planning Commission public hearing tentatively scheduled for September 28th, followed by Town Council public hearings in October.

2:27:43 And that is somewhat contingent on the number of comments that we get. So far, I haven't received really any comments of significance. We'll see what happens next week, but assuming that we do get limited comments, that schedule should be achievable. There's, I know, a desire to move this thing forward and to get it adopted after many years, really, of moving through the process and developing this plan.

2:28:11 A somewhat aggressive schedule, but one that we hope to be able to meet. So with that, I'll have to answer your questions. And for this, for the Commission, you know, you will be reviewing the Trail System Master Plan and the final EIR at that public hearing at the end of September. So this is really, if you have any specific comments or questions on the EIR, ask your review. Question, Elizabeth?

2:28:41 Alan, I don't know whether this fits in under air quality because we want people to be using the trail system, but what can we do to get people onto it? And I'm not just talking about the Lake Mary bike path, and maybe this doesn't count where it goes by Starwood and Minaret or the trail sidewalk that was put in along the Aspen Village townhomes so that people would be out of Old Mammoth Road. I have seen repeatedly this summer people riding their bicycles or walking or pushing strollers.

2:29:11 In the street, parallel to the trail, where the trail is like 10 feet away. And I know yesterday on our 203 signage strategy tour, Hayes talked about the bike trail signs that are going to go along 203 and he said there's going to be 26 of them. He said, well, they're very small and, you know, they're just adequate there for bicyclists. Is there some way we can have a bicycle logo with an arrow pointing to these trails so visitors who

2:29:40 Don't have the trail map in front of them. And, of course, we also have got the gaps to talk about, too, for the bicyclists, which is another issue. But how can we get people onto these trails, which seems so obvious to us who live here, and it hasn't occurred to them that they can ride their bikes over there and be safer? I think there's really two parts to that question. One is completing the trail network. So right now, as you know, on Old Mammoth Road, there's a significant gap of trail just sort of dead ends in Mammoth Creek Park.

2:30:07 Tossed out onto some what here may or may not be a trail. And then it starts up again. And I see so many confused people at that Bigger End Road, Old Mammoth Road intersection wondering what happened to the trail and why does it stop and start like that. So I think closing the gaps is a huge part of it and that's recognized very explicitly in the master plan.

2:30:27 And the other major piece is the signage and wayfinding program. And you've seen those signs start to go up now along the Lake Mary bike path. There's now a trailhead sign at Mammoth Creek Park, which both orients visitors and locals as well. Many locals don't know where all the trails are. I didn't know for a long time until I was looking for them where all the trails were in town. And to help much people understand.

2:30:52 What their destinations are, what their options are, how far along the trail they are before they get to the next waypoint, and working with them on TPA and on public work staff, we have a very well-developed plan for that signage wayfinding program that we've started to implement and will continue to implement in the next year or two as funding allows. So those I think are really the major...

2:31:16 That's a good one. I've just been surprised this is even a problem, but then when I think about it from the point of view of somebody just visiting for the first time or hasn't come here often, of course it's a problem. Yeah, exactly. Chair, I want to clarify, do you believe that that is a CEQA-related issue or is that just a question? No, just because we're commenting on the draft EIR, so that's why I didn't know where to put it, but maybe it'll be dealt with in wayfinding and it doesn't even have to come up in the EIR.

2:31:42 better identification of where the trail is. Any other questions about the draft EIR? No. Yes.

2:31:54 Page ES-5. Ellen, I just need to understand this comment. Alternative C would fail to meet any of the goals for the Sharp Project. Is that just because it's outside the urban boundary? It's saying that in that alternative, because it would exclude the Sharp area and therefore the Sharp Project, there wouldn't be any goals to be implemented with which it would or wouldn't conform. Does that make sense?

2:32:23 Well, confining it to the UGB would only apply policies, include policies applicable to the UGB and not to SHARP, so it's kind of a moot point. You know, right at the very beginning, proposed project, the TSMP will integrate and adopt the SHARP, you know, that's right at the beginning, as a component, and then it turns around and says we can't, so I was just kind of disappointed, I guess. This is looking at considering the,

2:32:53 The alternative C, which is only implement a trail system within the town's urban growth boundary, which would preclude the SHARP project. So there are objectives in the SHARP project that wouldn't be adopted or implemented, and so they wouldn't have any, they wouldn't exist. Well, I'm just disappointed. Yeah, I'm just disappointed. That's all. Okay, and then some more questions. Paige.

2:33:22 And maybe comments, positive. On ES-43, I was just real pleased that it shall be designed. This is 4.H-6, designed to an extent to avoid wet areas, springs, wetlands, lower portions of slopes. I'm very positive about that. And the next one, a maintenance plan. I've mentioned this to you earlier that I'm real pleased. That's in there.

2:33:52 And then finally a question on 2-2. Can you explain about the intersection improvements, for instance on Lake Mary? There's some at Davison, some at Lee Road, at Juniper Ridge, and...

2:34:12 Lakeview, what sort of intersection improvement? Principally, those are improved pedestrian crossings. Okay. So it's saying there's a trail there and we want people to be able to get back and forth. But we're not talking anything major. Right. And this document does not design those intersection improvements. It says there's a need for them.

2:34:33 Okay. It's just pointing out that the trail is there. Correct. Okay. And there may be a need for an additional pedestrian improvement too. Those were all my questions. Thank you. No more questions. We should ask the public if they have any comments. Thank you for no comments from the public. So if I could just close by saying that the comment period is open through the end of next week. If people want to submit written comments, the EIR is posted on the website.

2:35:04 We have a copy at the town offices and at the library. Thank you for your good work on this. This is one of our nicest amenities. Thank you. It's very exciting. Yeah. Okay, agenda item four, which is appointing ad hoc committees to support community development, excuse me, community development and public works, FY 2011-2012 work programs.

2:35:33 Thank you, Chair, members of the Commission. On August 17th, the Town Council approved our fiscal year work program and made some modifications to it and emphasized a couple of priority projects. One of them was TOT enforcement, and as you've already seen, we're shifting staff resources to move into that arena. Another is the subject heading that's described in our budget called completion of master plans and

2:36:03 The public facilities financing plan. That effort is substantially a joint public works and community development effort wherein we are evaluating the master plans that have been drafted, those that are old and have been completed, and identifying five-year capital improvement program priorities as well as the long-term facilities priorities.

2:36:30 And developing with that the financing plan and strategy of those facilities. So it's actually a lot of work. We expect to present to the Town Council the idea of having a very representative committee to work with us on that with a very well-developed scope of work. You'll see this year we will bring forward with all of our projects, our major projects, detailed scopes like we have on district planning.

2:36:59 Those are called frameworks, but they're really scopes of work so that the commission and the town council can review the work before we start. How are we going to approach it? What are the steps and milestones? Have we identified the appropriate deliverables? And do we have an appropriate process that's seeking appropriate community involvement? The ad hoc committee for this effort, we'd recommend perhaps one planning commissioner.

2:37:28 And it will be very methodical. It will not be like the zoning code update at such a fast pace. But it will seek to evaluate the facilities, the list of facilities, identify which should be removed from that list or which should be resized and which should stay as proposed.

2:37:48 We'll be integrating rec strats, trail system, park and recreation master plan. It will include the neighborhood district planning inputs as well as the existing facilities that are identified. So this is an important and complicated program. One of the results will be to make specific financing recommendations for those facilities, which will include development impact fees and incentive zoning.

2:38:16 Things that we've already talked about. So Diff discussions have been going on in the community and the council has placed a high priority on resolving the amount of Diff in its uses. So this is, again, a very important committee. We would represent to the council that it should include probably the chairs of the city's commission's town council representation.

2:38:44 Representation from the Capital Facilities Funding Committee, that group that have started this and made specific recommendations for how we conduct this effort. So we'd like to follow through with that. And perhaps various members at large which might pull from some of the groups that are now joined in the economic stimulus group. So we want to make sure it's broad and representative.

2:39:10 But an early Planning Commission appointment will help us. We'll actually review the scope and bring that back to this commission and then go on to town council. The second is, the second program item is completion of an economic development plan. This town has not had an economic development plan. This will essentially build on the general plan and the work of the destination, resort, community, and economic development strategy.

2:39:40 In a way, kick this off by forming the Economic Stimulus Council. We would want to have broad community participation in this, particularly from the commercial interests of town, businesses, lodging association and chambers. So we may draw from the work of the Economic Stimulus Council to do this work. Typically, economic development activities seek to provide

2:40:07 Assistance to businesses in the form of education and resources. It seeks to make sure that our fee structure and process is appropriate and it's not an obstruction or cost to businesses. And it seeks to identify resources that might be brought to bear financially to assist in business startup, property improvements, including signs, building and facade improvements.

2:40:35 And then finally, it includes the idea of business attraction and retention programs. A good example of attraction programs are when we have a developer who's ready to go or we have existing landowners who have vacant space, town representatives may well go to leasing conferences and participate in attracting and communicating to those potential tenants.

2:41:03 Another item that's pending and will come very quickly is the completion of the draft mobility element, the circulation element of the general plan. We have a draft document in preparation and here because it's going to update the general plan and essentially replace the mobility element with an updated mobility element.

2:41:25 We would recommend a Planning Commissioner join with a Mobility Commissioner to work on this before we bring it out to the public, much like we did with the resort investment element. And then finally, we would recommend that you appoint a member to Municipal Wayfinding and Community Messaging Committee. This committee was mentioned during Planning Commission reports. We've started this process.

2:41:54 By gathering up the stakeholders who are involved in our directional sign program and also community messaging such as banners across the street that speak to special events. Our stakeholders now include the Forest Service, Caltrans, Mammoth Lakes Tourism, and we would expect to have maybe one or two other commissioners, perhaps mobility because of the wayfinding program.

2:42:21 and move through a comprehensive program so that we can stop implementing ad hoc designs and making disjointed decisions. With that, those are four new ad hoc committees. Ad hoc means they have a start and an end that won't go on. I want to remind you that you have a zoning code update committee, which are members Dyken and Clark, and we'll be meeting with you, I hope, in September.

2:42:50 to pick up and close on building height and incentive zoning. Commissioner Clark is also our forecast committee and is a liaison, if you will, with the water district. We have work that's coming out now on development forecast process. You also have other standing committees.

2:43:12 That we might suggest you wait until the appointment of the Planning Commissioner, which is now scheduled for September 7th. That concludes my report. If I'll kind of go out of order here and first give my thoughts. The Master's Plan and Facility Financing Plan Committee, I agree with the recommendation of staff that that be Commission Chair. Obviously, we don't have a chair right now, but I could.

2:43:42 As Vice Chair, I could fill in for that until we do, presumably. Can't we go ahead and elect you? Well, I think it makes sense to wait until we have a fifth member. Okay. Because it will be fairly shortly and that person can participate in that decision. You said that person will be here on the 7th? The appointed on the 7th. 14th is a week after that. Oh, did you say the 14th is going to be canceled? I have not said that yet, but I would like to under Director's Report. Okay.

2:44:11 So we wouldn't have a chair until September 28th. Okay. But nevertheless. We won't be here, so, you know. Sorry, I didn't mean to step on here. I concur. Okay. What do you say with that one? The economic development plan completion, I think it would be very logical for Rhonda to do that, continuing. I'd like to continue with the work that she's done.

2:44:39 Got the ball rolling in. I want to see it through. Thank you. The mobility element, we need one member for that. I'm not sure who that would be. Does anybody here have a desire to be on that committee? Member four is the one I want. Well, if it's between mobility and wayfinding, I prefer mobility. You got it.

2:45:02 Okay. I prefer wayfinding. Okay. Well, I guess that worked. It only makes sense for Elizabeth to continue what she's been doing with wayfinding and messaging, so. Well, if our new appointee is all into mobility, then. That could change. Yes. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. So that's that, I think. Thank you. Okay. Briefing matters. We have none scheduled today. That brings us to the director's report.

2:45:35 The first item I've already mentioned is the Council is scheduled to appoint a Planning Commissioner on September 7th, and we've been asked by Town Manager to present to the Town Council a status report on the Town Gateway Project, which is the project that Commissioner Teddy has been volunteering her time to support.

2:46:05 So that will be an item coming forward. And I think that item will proceed, a Planning Commission item will proceed the Town Council item. So we will start quickly with a scope of work on the wayfinding program and the design concept that's tying all of these things together. So you'll see some fast action on that. And then the public hearing is...

2:46:30 Ellen mentioned for the Trail System Master Planning Certification of the EIR scheduled for September 28th. In terms of the Planning Commission meetings and schedules, at this point in time, we don't have any items set for September 14th, and we would recommend that await the BI. I would recommend that you cancel that meeting and hold the meeting on the 28th.

2:46:59 That completes my report. That completes my report. Thank you. Question? I did hear cancel the 14th. Yes. You have consensus? That's no coverage. That's fine. Okay. Announcement of special future meetings? None yet. We do plan to schedule a meeting, a tour to Kings Beach and to Martis Valley. We haven't completed that yet. We'll let you know.

2:47:30 It might be on the 14th. Are you serious? I don't know. I mean, it would really, I've already got an irreconcilable conflict coming up, and so as soon as you know a date, or dates, then I can rearrange. It might be useful just now to poll when we have conflicts while you're here.

2:47:59 That's tough for me to do without my calendar. Yeah. Yeah. Same thing. Yeah. Okay. We'll send you emails. Karen will coordinate a meeting time. Okay. Okay. Special meetings. Second. Public comment. My first question is... Just for the record, Lee. Thank you. When you guys did the zoning code update, when does it go to council so the public can weigh in? Because you have them at 9 in the morning and then we can come.

2:48:36 So the zoning code update's not done, is it doesn't go to the council so that... It goes in part, so it'll go at a lot of different times. Okay, so that's not done yet. Right. And when I was speaking earlier, I did raise my hand and I was acknowledged to come up. I have a request to ask the Planning Commission. I would like to have an agenda that teaches about the Roberts Rules. I'd like one that teaches about the Browns Act and when it's appropriate to speak and when it's not.

2:49:02 Because we all need to be on the same wavelength and understand everything so that people don't get put on the spot when they raise their hand in their knowledge to come up. So I would like to see an agenda of educating people about the Roberts Rules, Browns Acts, and when it's appropriate speaking when it's not. Thanks. Sorry for any embarrassment. We do make mistakes. I know. That's why I was asking. I think those two things of educating people would be good and make up a list so people will know exactly what's going on, and I think it would be a good idea. Thanks. Thank you.

2:49:33 Any more comments? I think we're ready to adjourn. Do you wish to agendize an item? I have a question about that. Isn't that something that we go through our training, the ethics training, and we cover that? How often does that happen? I know I've attended it a couple of times. Fair Political Practices Act training, I believe, occurs every two years. Okay. It felt like every two years. It would be appropriate to be a part of that. It's not specifically that.

2:50:03 That's a good place. And so all that material is posted. I mean, it's available and the things there. So, you know, I think that we'd make it, you know, where those things are available. We're certainly happy to check our information and share with the public, you know, our rules and how we proceed.

2:50:25 Something, though, I don't understand is on every agenda, whether it's council or one of the commissions, if there's a public hearing, there's a certain legal format we have to follow, and that is clearly laid out on the agenda, so it's not anything we're keeping secret, and that's why the vice chair said the public comment period was over. He didn't hit the gavel, but the public comment period was over.

2:50:49 Well, her point was that even though we did that, I let her start, and that was my mistake. Jay acknowledged her. Oh, I see what you're saying. Excuse me. I did miss that, Lee. I'm sorry. I would like to see the town work with the people with a political process where people are working together to educate the people. I am so tired. Go on the Internet if you want to learn. If you want to learn, go read the book. We need to work together to educate the people. It doesn't need to be a long agenda. Just work with them.

2:51:16 Educate them so when they come they'll understand. I know you don't like this one, but what are the people? Lee, I'd appreciate it if you wouldn't presume what I like or don't like. I'm happy to provide information to the process and I will review our procedures and see our procedures manual and if there's a way that we can provide information that's useful.

2:51:41 I'll work with the Chair and we'll publish. Yeah, I think we understand the concern and can address it. Yeah. Thank you. We'll respond through the Chair and then set an appropriate means of sharing that with the public. Thank you. That will adjourn. Okay, thank you. Mark, when does the Resort Investment Committee meet?