Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2011
Planning & Economic Development Commission
· recording 2 hr 54 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
384 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:00 Call the meeting to order. We'll start with the pleasure of allegiance. Please join us. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. That's close enough. We'll give her a minute to take her seat.
0:45 Roll call, please. Commissioner Brown? Here. Commissioner Hart? Here. Commissioner Duggan? Here. Commissioner Tenney? Here. Vice Chair Duggan? Here. Thank you. Oh, I see we're doing election of officers before reports from the commission. Okay. So we'll start with agenda item one. Agenda item one is the Planning Commission's annual selection of officers in committee appointments. This is usually done at the...
1:18 First regular meeting in July. This year we're doing it later because of a recent appointment filling vacancies at the commission. We now have a complete roster of commissions. Welcome, Mickey Brown. So with that, the planning commission is first to elect your chair and your vice chair.
1:41 And then after you have done that, we can roll into standing and ad hoc committee discussion and appointments. Are you calling for nominations? Yes. I nominate Jay Duncan as chair. I second. Move nomination, cease. Pardon me? Move nominations, cease. Should I ask for any more nominations first? She said, yeah. Okay.
2:14 Is there a second to the motion that nominations be seen? Second. I second that as well. Okay. So, call for a vote? Please vote. Does this need to be a roll call vote? It need not be. Okay. All those in favor? Aye. I'll abstain. I'm already involved. You're one of the best chairs we have ever had. I agree.
2:44 We'll see. Oh yeah, that's right, you've only been filling in. Moving on to Vice Chair, we have nominations for Vice Chair. I nominate Elizabeth Tenney. You second? I'll second that. More nominations? I'll accept a motion to close nomination. So move. I'll second. All those in favor of Elizabeth Tenney as Vice Chair? In favor?
3:21 I'm fine. I believe that is unanimous. Okay, good. Thank you. The next item is a discussion of standing committees and ad hoc committees that were made within the Planning Commission, and I want to make sure that you understand the difference between the two. An ad hoc committee is a committee that is generally a short-term nature. It has irregular meetings, and there's a beginning and an end to it.
3:49 A standing committee is a committee appointed by the body. You're known in the Brown Act as a legislative body. And that is an ongoing committee. And it may or may not have a regular meeting schedule. We've listed in your agenda packet the standing committees. They are the design committee who serves with the advisory design panel. Can we meet with regularly to discuss the design?
4:17 Site plan issues associated with various projects. You have a color committee, which is a standing committee of two members who advise on exterior color and materials as required with minor permits. The design committee meets on major permits. You have a signed committee of two members who advise on the design review of signed permit applications. According to the Brown Act, standing committees
4:46 that are appointed by the body require posting of an agenda and we will be very thorough now in posting agendas of this group and so you should consider that because a 72-hour notice is required to post that agenda. That means for us to process our permits, our applications and to meet with the committees. They're not on an informal, ad hoc basis.
5:11 So we have to know in advance that it is a required meeting and we'll post the agenda and then we'll conduct the business of that standing committee. We do not have to post agendas for ad hoc committees per the Brown Act. With that, I'll move to ad hoc committees. There are a number of committees now appointed by the Commission. One is the Resort Investment Committee, which I believe that work is substantially completed. We have a draft resort.
5:41 Investment Element of the General Plan, and we'll process that now separately. The Zoning Code Committee is an ongoing ad hoc committee, but we expect it to end somewhat shortly. You recently appointed members Clark and Dyken to that group at one of your last meetings. We have the Five-Year Capital Improvement and Public Facilities Committee.
6:07 That's the group that will work on the public facilities plan, and you appointed one member, Member Duncan. We have a wayfinding and community messaging committee that will participate with other members of the commissions and a stakeholders group. One appointment, Commissioner Tenney, and you have an economic development committee, which the...
6:31 Planning Commission appointed Commissioner Dugan, and I'll note for the record that we have an informal body known as the Economic Stimulus Council that has included now Commissioner Mickey Brown. So if Mickey Brown wishes to participate in that effort, she should be also then an appointment of the Planning Commission, because you can't be there as a commissioner and not be a commissioner. There is...
6:58 A maximum of two people you can appoint to any committee. Otherwise, it becomes a quorum of the board, and then it becomes a regular planning commission meeting or special meeting. So you have an option of appointing one or two members to these. And the reason you might consider one or two members is the amount of work that is spread amongst all of the commissioners, but also the complexity of the issue that you're working on.
7:26 Some issues are more complex than others. You might also review the standing committees and not ad hoc committees to determine whether any of them can be consolidated or if any of them can be eliminated because of progress made in your zoning code update and other matters. So with that, I'll turn it to the Chair for the appointment of standing committees and ad hoc committees.
7:53 I'll just start with them as they're listed. First, with respect to the design committee, I want to say that I've been on that committee since I was appointed a commissioner, so it's been a little bit over three years now. It's a very valuable experience. Because of that, I think it is important, if we can, to share that committee experience among as many of the...
8:23 Commissioners as possible. I would like to turn my position on that over to somebody else for that reason, and I would suggest that if she's amenable to it, it might be best for Ms. Brown to be on there. I found it a very good experience when I was new on the commission. I'll need one. Okay.
8:47 Consensus? Any other discussion on that? Elizabeth? However, I would like very much to continue on that committee. Mark just made a suggestion about consolidating the standing committees. I wonder if it would be efficient to consolidate design and color. Would that be more efficient? Certainly on the related subject matter. I would agree. I think that with the publishing of the color book is the primary guidelines.
9:14 I see more and more that there's less need for that particular definition of the color committee. Here's the book, follow that, contact staff. If you see something that falls outside of the guidelines and do their presentation, but with the consolidation of staff time, our time, and for the applicant's time as well, I would be well amenable, because now the new color book says choose from that.
9:44 And I don't think we should type anything else with it. I'd be fine with that. That sounds good. Any more discussion with that? Well, if we're going to combine the committees, and did Commissioner Clark want to remain on the new committee? Excuse me? I'm sorry. She's saying since you're on one of the committees that's being combined. No, that's fine with me that you get the experience. Okay. So I think we have consensus to combine the...
10:16 Color Committee. Can it just be called the Design Committee? Yes, it can. And that would be Mickey and me? Yes. Okay, good. We'll note in our record that the standing Color Committee is now deceased. Reinvented. Recycled. Yes. Okay, moving to the Sign Committee. Our current Sign Committee includes Sharon Clark and Ronda Dugan.
10:46 Both have a desire to continue? I'm fine continuing. I'm also fine relinquishing that to someone else. I think it's important with the signed committee that since we have such new guidelines that we continue it as a separate committee for the time being because even though it is directly related to design and you want to incorporate the two.
11:11 It does have a little bit different guidelines. So I'm happy to stay. I'm happy if anybody else wants to be part of it as well. I'm happy to stay or go. Anybody else wish to? Well, let's see. Okay. Okay. Moving on to the ad hoc committees. I think, Mark, from what you said, it may be appropriate at this point to dissolve the Resort Investment Committee. Yes. Since that's in any discussion of that.
11:41 I think we're done. Okay, good. Zoning code committee, I've put in a lot to that, and since there's not much left, I just can keep going. Sharon, are you? Fine. Okay, so we'll leave that one as it is. Any further discussion? Okay. The five-year capital improvement committee, I'm okay with being appointed and keeping that. I don't think we have a need for a second planning commissioner on that. I would not think so. Okay.
12:14 Any discussion? That's fine. Okay. Wayfinding and community messaging. Lisbeth, you're the expert. You obviously have a big interest in that. Well, I'm happy to do that because it goes along with my volunteer project, so I'm happy to do that one. Okay. Do you perceive any need for another commissioner on that? Unless someone wants to join me. No, I'm fine. It's almost done, too, though, I mean, in the sense that you've put a lot of things in place.
12:43 Well, the wayfinding and community messaging part isn't done. It's going to be the whole town, but we're sort of in the middle of it. And that process will include a public arts commissioner, a mobility commissioner, and a recreation commissioner. Oh, good. So it's a very... So I think we have consensus on Ms. Tenney remaining as the one planning commissioner on that committee. Okay.
13:09 Economic Development Committee, as Mr. Wardlaw mentioned, new Commissioner Brown has an obvious interest and investment in that. I think it would make sense, as he suggested, to add her. Yes, I'd very much like to stay on that committee. Good. Okay. How is the Economic Development Committee separate from the Economic Stimulus Group? Or do they have to be separate? The Economic Stimulus Council.
13:37 Thank you.
14:04 So then those two can't be consolidated. No. They are not. Right. Okay, good. I think that wraps up item one. Yes. Okay, the next section of the meeting is reports from the commission. I'm going to start out today, and I want to welcome to the commission and introduce our newest commissioner, Mickey Brown.
14:33 She has been visiting Mammoth since the 1960s and has since that time recreated here and has lived in Mammoth full time for about the past 10 years. She has a bachelor's degree in business economics from the University of California at Santa Barbara. She has extensive work experience as a certified public accountant and in the real estate field. When she first moved to Mammoth, she served as the chief financial officer for Snow Creek Investments.
15:03 She is currently a co-owner of Resort Property Realty. And she also, as we were just discussing, is a member of the Economic Stimulus Council. And in her application, it really resonated with me when she said that she was an outdoor enthusiast who, quote, said, for me there is no greater sight than the first view of the minarets while driving up the Sherwin grade when returning from a trip. I hear you. Thank you very much.
15:32 And I have one other thing I want to mention. On September 9th of this year, the California Chapter of the American Planning Association, the 2011 Central Section Neighborhood Planning Award, first place was presented to the town of Mammoth Lakes for the downtown concept for Main Street. And big thanks and congratulations to the staff for all the good work you did that led up to that. Absolutely. Thank you.
16:05 I just want to reemphasize that, you know, this was truly a community effort. And in the work of the commission, everybody on the focus groups in the town council led to its success. It was very successful. Okay. Other commission reports? Sharon? Hi. Thank you, Jay. I attended the Mammoth Community Water District meeting on the 15th of September. I have an article from the Wall Street Journal, September 1st.
16:35 discussing metropolitan problems with parking, which seems to me that we have dealt with that on occasion, that parking spaces are beginning to be almost as expensive square foot wise as apartments. So I thought that was curious. But some officials, city planning officials, are saying that lower minimum parking requirements at residential buildings.
17:02 And help us use mass transit and that otherwise we have more traffic in the densely populated areas than we need. And I was particularly interested in the San Francisco, that was Manhattan and Boston, and particularly San Francisco in 2006 required that developers unbundle parking from the prices of the condos.
17:31 And they're pricing the parking places separately. And so that buyers are more likely to take public transit. So I just think that is apropos for Mammoth, that we are trying to encourage leave your car at home and take public transit. And then the final thing I want to compliment and thank the Mammoth Lakes Lodging Association and our staff.
18:01 for this marvelous letter concerning T.O.T. I just think getting this letter out is critical and thank you so much to both groups. And that's it. Thank you. Just real quickly, I had just a little insight. Yesterday I had to make an unexpected trip up to Lake Tahoe and looking at that from the different perspectives and it's very interesting on what
18:30 How traffic patterns and things are flowing there. Most of you know that they have a major convention center site that is in bankruptcy, and so there's a huge hole in the ground right in the middle on State Line, this street, and how that's impacting the community, and there's some places where it's impacting them tremendously, and others are not.
18:54 And it's just interesting to see how the evolution of how they're going after business at that time as they switch from traditional casino business to more recreation and adventure. And also their events and concerts are what are bringing them the revenues that they did not have before by doing more contemporary acts that have a bigger draw.
19:19 You know, how transportation affected one of the disappointing things was is that with their economic troubles, they have abandoned pretty much their public transit. And how much it's suffering in that area because, yes, it's under construction. Only the major hotels have transit there, but there is no more transit to Heavenly or whatever it is. That was really key to that community.
19:49 There's a lot of economic issues going there that are similar but different from us, but really the key is getting those people to move around easily. So here we are in town as we look at things like parking and how do you encourage people to use public transit there as you show them the benefit of it as a verse to, I can afford to live here if I don't need to bring my car.
20:16 If you can get around easily, you don't need to bring your car. And how much a community that was known for its pedestrian traffic doesn't really work as well when they start to cut back on what they consider to be non-essential things and how they will take care of themselves, it hurts the community and how essential that is going forward. So it was interesting to see it. And I've been there several times, but not looked for this thing and saw it was making an impact in that community.
20:44 Even more than the big hole in the ground. Interesting. Thank you. Ms. Brown? I have no report. Ms. Tennant? I've been thinking about what Commissioner Dugan said at our August 28th meeting about our parking requirements when we had the Rock and Bowl project before us. I've been thinking about that ever since, and it has affected how I will think about future applications and the parking requirements. So you make a very good point.
21:12 A couple things. I attended at the invitation of the court, the dedication of the new courthouse in Thompson's Way. And Glenn Thompson, our former town manager, his widow was there, as were his grandsons. And Stan Eller spoke very movingly about Glenn. It was very nice. And then I made a few comments about Helen. I didn't know her well, but I liked her so much. And, of course, I'm sitting in her chair. I didn't take her place, but I'm sitting in her chair.
21:38 And I was really glad I was able to mention Tony because it was Tony's brilliant idea that we have Thompson's Way instead of, you know, Lodgepole Lane or some other ordinary name we could have given it. That was really very nice and so it was well received. By the way, I notice you have a little work to do. In our packet, Thompson's Way was written two ways both wrong. One with an apostrophe and one as Thompson Way.
22:04 In our packet? I missed that. It's part of the gateway sign. I think that's where I saw it. Oh, I missed that. We have to work on keeping understanding what that is. Yeah, autocorrect is just playing havoc with it. Exactly, but that's so interesting because I was the one who called the executive officer of the court, Hector Gonzalez, after they had the announcement in the paper saying that they were moving and it was Thompson's Way with an apostrophe. And I said, do you know why it's called Thompson's Way? And I told him.
22:32 And he found that so interesting. They made it part of the courthouse ceremony, dedicating our new street. So, oh, interesting. Okay. A couple sign issues. I don't know if I should save this for director's report, but we've got a flashing neon sign across the street. The same banner on Main Street for the grand opening that was there when they opened, I think, three years ago is still there. What is our procedure for sign complaints? You should as a citizen.
22:58 Or Planning Commissioner, contact us separately, and you do not need to bring those to this forum. No, I just was asking the procedure. Email staff, any of the planners can accept a signed code complaint, so whether it's Ms. Daugherty, Morris, Kobalartz, Clark, Moberly, or Wardlaw, please send that information and we'll put it into our system. I shall do that.
23:21 And then the last thing, I know we've been focused when we talk about customer service on hospitality training for our seasonal workers, but a friend of mine who's trying to find a caterer for a fundraiser dinner at the end of the month, end of October, spent over a week trying to contact local caterers and got no response. He finally had to find a caterer in Lee Vining for this event. And I think it behooves us all to remember to leave those auto-replies on our emails, so if we're out of town or...
23:51 Whatever. It's not just the seasonal workers who need the training. It's some of our business owners who are getting maybe a little bit too relaxed in shoulder season. And if we want to be a true four-season resort, I think we've got to keep up with that stuff. Because my friend is used to doing business in the big city, and so he says, I can't adjust to this. He's feeling a little pressure because he's got to have this event, and he doesn't know how to cook. That's all. Thank you. Thank you. Next section is our first.
24:22 Opportunity for comments from the public. This portion of the agenda is to provide the public with an opportunity to address the commission on matters not otherwise listed on the agenda. So at this time, anyone who has a topic like that they'd like to address, please come forward. I see no movement, so we will move on. We have no presentations today. There is nothing on our consent agenda. That brings us to the public hearing.
24:51 portion of the meeting. Just a brief overview of our public hearing procedure. We will open the public hearing and then first have a statement and presentation by the staff, followed by a statement and presentation by the property owner or other advocate for the item. That will be followed by questions from the Planning Commission, then a call for testimony from persons wishing to speak in support.
25:20 Then persons wishing to speak in opposition, followed by a call for general testimony. Then an opportunity to rebut previous testimony by the property owner or the proponent. At that point, the public hearing is closed, terminating public testimony, and the commission will deliberate the matter and arrive at a decision. So on our public hearing today is Agenda Item 2, the Trail System Master Plan and Environmental Impact Report.
25:48 And as I mentioned, we'll start, we'll whack the gamble to open the public hearing and start with a presentation by staff. Ms. Clark, where are you going to start? Chair, I will be leaving to staff the Airport Commission at 3 o'clock, so if you see me depart during this matter or subsequent, it is for that reason. Thank you. Good afternoon, and thank you, Chair and Commissioners. The item before you today is the public hearing.
26:21 for recommendation to adopt the Trail System Master Plan and certify the Environmental Impact Report for that project. The Trail System Master Plan is a project that's been many years in germination. This is the culmination of an extensive multi-year effort to develop a comprehensive plan that will replace and supersede the existing
26:48 Trail System Plan, which was adopted in 1991. The Trail System Plan is truly comprehensive in its scope, looking at the complete system of trails, paved pathways, hard and soft surface trails, signage and wayfinding, and various amenities associated with that trail network within the town's municipal boundary. It's a significant expansion of the scope of the 1991 Trail System Master Plan, which really focused
27:15 on the town's main loop system and various connector trails, focusing on areas principally or in proximity to the town's urban growth boundary. And the trail system master plan goes beyond that, looking at the entire town from the urban growth boundary all the way out to the edges and connecting to the broader system of regional trails that extend beyond the town limits. I won't
27:44 I'll give you extensive detail about the content of the Trail System Master Plan. As I mentioned, this has been through an extensive process starting in 2007 and initiated by Mammoth Lakes Trails and Public Access to comprehensively update that plan. That process involved numerous public workshops, focus groups, study sessions, meetings with various agencies and interested parties, receiving comments, processing them.
28:10 Surveying existing conditions and identifying needs for the trail system that were all brought into a draft published in February of 2009 or initially in August of 2008 to which comments were received and responded to and then presented in a revised draft in early 2009. Since that time,
28:33 Following that publication, after a hiatus due to some funding constraints, work began on the environmental impact report for the project, which allowed the project to move forward to this stage of public hearings and ultimately to adoption. Because of the amount of time that had elapsed since the publication of that first draft,
28:56 We worked, staff worked with Mammoth Lakes Travels and Public Access to consider any RADA and changes that might be needed to that draft to bring it up to date to reflect changes in progress since 2009. Those RADA were presented to this commission and to other commissions in June and brought back again last month to really get you to introduce them to get your sign-off on those changes.
29:25 Included in your packet is this document, which is what we're calling the redline draft, which shows all of those erotic changes as redline strikeout folded into the February 2009 draft so you can see where those changes are made. Following adoption of this plan, we will go back, accept all of those changes and produce a sort of final consolidated draft that will reflect all of those changes and have all of its pagination and various other
29:54 elements corrected. I didn't mention, I mentioned a little bit about the comprehensive scope of this plan. It's important to note that this does include, in addition to this, Trails System Master Plan document does encompass a series of attachments. Perhaps the most important of those is the Sherwin's area planning documentation, which reflects more detailed planning for the Sherwin area.
30:22 and more detailed planning recommendations, and that's incorporated by reference and as a component of the Trail System Master Plan that will be adopted. Briefly, on the CEQA, we did complete an environmental impact report for this project that was prepared and circulated in July of this year for public review.
30:48 The draft DIR is a program level analysis looking at a fairly high level across the broad range of connected and long range actions of the trail system plan. And the intent of the program level at CEQA analysis is to pave the way really for implementation of those future projects to minimize the future CEQA review that will be needed by looking at things in this program manner.
31:18 And we also, the intent of that CEPA document is to inform future NEPA analysis that might be required for projects on forest service land. The EIR also looks in some additional detail at a series of what are described as priority projects, but really a set of projects that are more likely to be implemented in the short term with the goal of really making that review of those projects very minimal.
31:45 As an EIR, the public review period resulted in only four comment letters, two from the public, one from one state agency and one from Mammoth Lakes Trails and Public Access. All of those comments were non-substantive. They generally were technical in nature, small changes and corrections to the text. All of those comments have been...
32:07 are reflected and have been responded to in the final EIR that's included as an attachment to this packet. As I mentioned, just very minor technical corrections and changes. The EIR did not, although it did identify a number of potentially significant impacts of the project, found that with implementation of various mitigation measures, all of those could be reduced to a less than significant level.
32:34 So in addition to recommending adoption of the Trust System Master Plan and certification of the EIR, the Commission will also be considering recommending adoption of the Mitigation Monitoring Plan, which sets forth all of those mitigation measures, timing, and responsibilities for their implementation. And adoption of that Mitigation Monitoring Plan is a component of the CEQA certification.
33:04 Because no significant unavoidable impacts were found to resolve the project, there is no need to adopt a statement of overriding considerations in the case of this project. So with that, it is staff's recommendation that the Planning Commission recommend that the Town Council, the Planning Commission recommend that the Town Council certify the Trail System Master Plan EIR and adopt by resolution the Trail System Master Plan. Thank you. Questions of staff?
33:33 Alan, I have a couple of questions. First off, this is a very comprehensive job. It's really an impressive plan. On page 2-3, the handwritten 2-3 in our staff report, it talks in the second paragraph under project summary about implementing the master plan, including development and adoption of design management and maintenance standards. I wondered about adoption of or development of design standards since Chapter 6 is very thorough.
34:03 There are additional standards that will be developed. What does that refer to? Chapter 6 is design guidance, and so there are recommendations at this point. The goal is ultimately for there to be something called a standards manual to be adopted. Like Caltrans has where it's signed? Similar to that. So it's similar to the town's public work standards, maybe actually incorporated as a component of the public work standards that would really set out all of the much more detailed specifications and guidelines.
34:33 for any future physical facility. So it would say the trail needs to be eight feet wide, have this type of shoulder, this material, much more detailed than the guidance in here. This is really, gives direction, but ultimately it will be really engineering standards in many cases that will be developed and adopted. Yeah, that makes sense. And I had one more question on 2-5.
34:57 I've been sort of confused, and mostly it's what I read in the paper, where I find out about the Rec Commission prioritizing projects. How does what the Rec Commission is doing, or as I understand it from the press, what they're doing coordinates with this in terms of prioritizing projects? I would like some straight info from that because I'm really confused.
35:23 This master plan document, like many master plans, give us a breadth of the network of a trail system, both in the town's urban growth units and outside of the town's urban growth units. It also gives us design standards, specifications that will implement separately. Once a document like this is established, then the town, and you'll know what your subsequent agenda is,
35:50 We are undertaking a five-year capital improvement program and public facilities finance plan. So each commission through this process will be asked to review the priorities for those subjects that fall within their purview. So mobility will be asked to look at sidewalks, at bikeways that are with our streets and our roads, with our traffic signals and traffic control devices, and also with wave funding.
36:19 The Recreation Commission will be asked to review their facilities and standards. Trails are part of that. And this master plan and the work of MLTPA will flow into that effort. In the CIP, the program, it includes two key subjects. An asset management plan that identifies the existing facilities, including trails, streets, and buildings.
36:45 And their expected maintenance and repair and rehabilitation costs over time. And we'll also identify the capital projects plan for five years. So what segments of a trail, for example, should be included in the first year, the second year, the third or the fifth year. And when we look at projects, we now think of them from the idea of design all the way through construction completion.
37:14 And then along going operations. So the master plan establishes the biggest picture. It includes some priorities, but through the CIP program, the five-year program, and then the adoption of actual budgets. It's the annual budget that allocates the money to fund any project using the town's public monies. There are a number of different processes underway, but the revenues...
37:41 Some will be Measure U, some will be Measure R, some will be unrestricted TOT funds, some will be state and federal grant funds. So these processes are actually merging together, you know, rather nicely with the time frame resources we have. So, in fact, on the 5th,
38:04 We're going to Council with our scope of work for that five-year CIP program, and the Recreation Commission, for example, is already starting their work to consider both asset management and capital projects. So there is a process, and the end result will be by this time next year, we have a reconciled CIP process. We don't have a very good one right now, but this five-year program will get us there.
38:32 Okay. Thank you. Thank you. Other questions? No questions. Go ahead. I apologize. I'm really Johnny-come-lately on this project. So I just want to make sure I understand that there was really no formal opposition to the EIR? Correct. The four comments that we received were
38:57 Delivered really technical changes and corrections for points of fact in some of the information provided in the EIR, but did not challenge or oppose the EIR based on any of the basis of analysis and any of the mitigation measures or the required components of it. So procedurally and substantively, there was no opposition to the EIR as it was drafted. And then because this is certainly a
39:23 A document that's going to be living for a long time and there'll be different segments of it over different years. Can anybody come forward and protest the EIR in the future? There's a statute of limitations in terms of challenges to the EIR, which I believe is, I want to say 60 days from the filing of the notice of, what's called the notice of determination. Okay. So the law does dictate a period within which any challenge to the EIR must be received.
39:53 The challenge to an environmental impact report, though, should be based on environmental impacts, and it should be focused on the inadequacy of the evaluation or new information or missing information for this process. So the certification is simply the action that says we, the body, certifies that this is a complete and accurate document. Okay. Thank you.
40:23 One of the proponents for this project is the town itself. Do we have any representative from the town to speak as a proponent as opposed to staff report? This is a partnership project, and so staff is both the proponent and also the...
40:42 I think Mr. Wentworth is here and he'll wish to speak as an MLTPA person. Right. That was going to be my next step is to mention that MLTPA really is a partner in this and if there is a representative of MLTPA present who would like to speak as a proponent, please come forward. Please give us your name and your town of residence. My name is John Wentworth. I live in the town of Mammoth Lakes. Now cover your ears just for a second.
41:17 That's a plan. I'm humbled to be associated as being a proponent for this project. I was planning only to speak as someone in support of the matter, but I could perhaps give a little bit of background. If any of the commission has any questions, I can certainly try to answer them. We start back to March of 2007. That's when MLTPA, a newly incorporated non-profit here in Mammoth Lakes, convened a group of stakeholders and agency.
41:44 Folks, get together to start doing an update for the 1991 Trail System Master Plan. In June of that year, MLTPA secured a commitment from Rusty Gregory and Mammoth Mount Ski Area for $100,000, $100,000, towards, and I quote, master planning of a comprehensive trail system for the town of Mammoth Lakes and the surrounding area, subject only to an equal $100,000 matching commitment from the town of Mammoth Lakes. Mammoth Mount Ski Area's commitment catalyzed,
42:14 Ongoing efforts between the Town's Tourism and Recreation Department elected members of the Town Council and MLTPA to update the Town's Trust System Master Plan. On October 3, 2007, just about four years ago, the Town Council voted to allocate $100,000 to effectively leverage Mammoth Mountain's $100,000 commitment, and the concept of Master Plan process for new Trust System Master Plan, a camp process, was underway. So four years and many tens of thousands of hours of effort later,
42:45 Efforts by citizen volunteers, agency staffs, outside consultants, and interested parties from all over the country, literally, the Town of Mammoth Lakes Trail System Master Plan is ready, finally, for the adoption by the Town of Mammoth Lakes. And there's some folks that just need to have some acknowledgement as being part of this really significant effort. And to start first with the jurisdictional partners. That was the Town of Mammoth Lakes, the United States Forest Service, who are truly partners in this effort. The funding partners have made the funding for this process possible.
43:15 Mammoth Mount Ski Area, the Town of Mammoth Lakes, the developers for them, including Cardinal Investments and Mammoth Crossing, and members of the 100 original founders of MLTPA. The Sierra Nevada Conservancy provided critical grants, both to MLTPA for the camp outreach effort, as well as to the Town of Mammoth Lakes for the CEQA process. The entire EIR CEQA process was funded by a grant from the Sierra Nevada Conservancy. The planning partners, which is the agency staffs from the Town of Mammoth Lakes, the International Forest, Mammoth Mount Ski Area, and MLTPA,
43:44 The consultant team out of planning and design, trail solutions, corporate design, the signage and wayfinding group out of Michigan, beneficial designs and PCR services corporation that did the EIR. And finally, the volunteer, the citizen engagement with this effort, which is really kind of astounding. And there are thousands of documented hours of volunteer time that went into this plan, certainly the Sherwin working group and the...
44:10 The Sherwin Area Recreation Plan. Two members of the Sherwin Working Group are actually here today, signatories to that effort. Thank you for the Sherwin Working Group, the Sherwin Area Recreation Plan Technical Committee, the Camp Summer Participants, the Camp Winter Participants, and all those who submitted comments to the draft of the plan back in 2008. Ellen commented there are very few comments in the EIR that may have something to do with the fact that the public comment period of the draft plan itself was so thorough. There were hundreds of comments that really helped make this a comprehensive, very excellent document that it is today.
44:40 This master document, this plan is really the master development plan for the Mammoth Lakes Trail System. And in meetings with the Forest Service that are going on right now to bring the Forest Service and the town into a very effective and efficient partnership for this Mammoth Lakes Trail System, the Forest Service has called out and identified it as such. This is your master development plan. Anybody in the real estate community knows what a master development plan, that's what this document really is.
45:04 This plan and the implementation of this plan is a direct investment in the recreation infrastructure of this community, which is a direct investment in our economy. This trail system, should it come to fruition with the adoption of this plan, is going to enhance visitation and enhance the quality of life. I'm very much looking forward to working with Mickey and members of that economic stimulus group to connect businesses and economic activity to these unique recreation opportunities that this plan is going to represent.
45:33 And finally, to the Measure R process, which has been the Recreation Commission, which has been using the draft of this plan as a guiding principle for the allocation of Measure R funds over the last couple of years. Significant components of this plan have already been implemented and adopted, absent some of the physical and capital process, which have to have this EIR certified before that can happen. So this great big plan is on track for adoption. I want to thank the Planning Commission.
46:01 For your help and support making this thing happen, and if there's any questions you have, I'd be more than happy to answer them. It's heavy, it's good. Thank you. Thank you. Does anyone have questions for Mr. Whitmer? Okay. Let's move on to testimony from those persons wishing to speak in support of this. On behalf of the Mammoth Lakes Trails and Public Access Foundation, we strongly support adoption of this plan and certification of the EIR. Thank you.
46:35 Thank you. Well, my name is Steve Searles. I'm a resident of Mammoth Lakes. I hope it's appropriate time that I speak. I'm not against the plan, what's going on in Mammoth. I don't want to be disruptive to the meeting or all the thousands of hours that people have put in to the project. But in real time, what's going on in the forest surrounding Mammoth, which it gets kind of convoluted, which plan is which and which group is doing which.
47:12 The lay people of the community that don't go to these long meetings like you folks do get confused. They're all at work right now and I got a chance to slip in. But the amount of roads that have been closed that surround our community is astonishing. From June Lake down to Coyote, all the forests, everywhere you go is road closures. I have lived here for 35 years.
47:42 25 years or longer ago I participated in this process and in the mapping for off-road vehicles for going around town. Here we are decades later and they pulled the trigger this summer and people went out. I don't think that some of the closures were mapped to be closed. People maybe with their own agenda that were a little bit too zealous that have closed.
48:11 Gosh, roads that have been there before any of us were born aren't able to go on right now. Everywhere you go in the forest is road closures and where they put the logs and the rocks. The people that are avid outdoorsmen like myself, I'm not encouraging this, but a lot of people are tearing them down. A lot of people are roosting around the closure to get back on the part of the road that...
48:39 Doesn't have logs and brush and rocks on it. I think there's going to be unintended consequences from closing so many roads that people use so often and creating more damage that nobody wants, laying what they call single track on motorcycles, roosting through the forest in a group. The jeep trails are super fun to ride on, super adequate for quads, those rhinos.
49:07 Motorcycles, all the above, Jeeps, they're super neat, everyone knows where they are, and now everywhere you go has closures, and so people feel disappointed, maybe they didn't attend the meetings and put out the amount of work that you folks did, and that's not good, but they just know what they know and they're used to it, and so they're ripping into the forest and maybe causing more damage than the road being there and not being closed.
49:35 I just was in the June length meeting. It was an agendized item. All the roads, even roads that were improved this year by volunteers for little camping areas or day spots where you could have lunch. Groups of people have come in and closed the ones that volunteers went to make better. And so as we go through the possible bankruptcy of our town, one of the few things that the courts isn't going to take from us.
50:04 It's the forest and the woods and all that we enjoy. I think it's extremely marketable. People want to come here and enjoy themselves. For what these folks have done, and especially inside the town limits, I just think it's wonderful. Again, I'm not the smartest guy in having attended all these meetings, and I don't want to be disruptive with the process.
50:28 But right outside the town limits, and some of it's in the town limits, even designated bicycle trails have been camouflaged and closed. It's just silly as could be. And so we were on a motoring tour yesterday for encouraging motorsports and snowmobile use in the forest. All of us were just stunned by how many closures and how many boulders have been rolled into the roads. Again, I sincerely believe that people that
50:58 mean really well, probably took it upon themselves to do extra work and close stuff that probably wasn't ever intended to be closed. Steve, have you talked to the Forest Service about this? I was with Schloffman, Rugerberger, Kaczynski, we're all there. Yeah, and some of it, they, oh, sorry you feel that way, or, you know, we've approached the Friends of the Inyo. Gosh, those are super nice people, but holy mackerel, I mean, it's just...
51:27 The silliest thing, and when I was on the committee and we worked on this, we came to a conclusion of 11 miles of redundant roads that needed to be closed. It was really appropriate and probably more were found out over the last couple of decades. But some of these spur roads that are a dead end with beautiful vistas where people have walked their dogs or enjoyed their privacy or meditated or prayed or whatever they do out there in the forest are now closed.
51:55 Again, I mean, no disrespect to anybody, but this is out of control. It's going to have a kickback effect, and the folks aren't here today, but all of my friends are calling me, what the heck, Searles, why are all the trails closed? What I'm trying to understand, though, is did the Forest Service close these roads, or were they closed by...
52:15 Well-meaning, misguided people or arbitrarily? I mean, who closed the roads? It's my understanding that the Green Sticker Fund, we actually funded the closure of our own trail system. That was a grant that was given to the Forest Service with a tune of millions of dollars. It's my understanding that they sublet out that hands-on work to volunteers or friends of the Inyo.
52:42 No disrespect to Stacy or anybody like that, but I think they got a little bit overzealous, and gosh, roads that I've used for 35 years, I can't get on right now, the giant boulders they've rolled in the roads where snowmobiling is, we normally wait until the snow's deep enough so you don't bang up your sleds, but there's going to be all kinds of people hitting logs and, you know, they put up the two posts with the log across, there's going to be people hooking that stuff everywhere because they...
53:11 They've used those roads for decades. And so I would, again, you said to speak, if you're in favor of the program, I'm sure in favor of what's going on in the scope of Mammoth, the Sherwins, the Lakes Basin, all the stuff within our town, but right outside of our town, it's just...
53:30 Hundreds of roads have been closed, not 11 miles, not a few, not a dozen. All the trails and camps are offshoots around Gene Lake closed. I have a property down by Coyote. All of that up on Coyote Flats has all been closed. And so as you go through this process and everybody does their good hard work and means well.
53:55 Man, man, I think maybe we need some oversight on what's really happening on the ground real time. You know, just a mile from here, people rolling logs and putting all these boulders in really great trails, and it's causing other illegal trails today. People are roosting through the forest because they're frustrated that the main routes are closed. More questions? Thank you for your time.
54:24 Thank you. The Trail System Master Plan, part of its operation that's very important to it is having a detailed inventory of what's out there. So obviously if the closures are different than what has been planned, that's something important to know and to take a look at. And Mr. Seals mentioned, it sounds like...
54:54 Primarily what he's talking about are activities on forest service land, but also some within the town limits as well. In the county as well. In the county. So maybe staff can pursue just some inquiry to the appropriate people at each agency and ask that they may want to make themselves aware or do some more surveying or something and see what's going on out there. Comments? Yeah, just for a point of clarification, I think what Steve is talking about
55:23 It's the implementation of the Inyo National Forest Travel Management Plan. That's specifically what this is about. This Trail System Master Plan has no direct relationship. It's happening forest-wide. This is a national mandate from Congress for every forest in the country to inventory their roads and then make decisions about once a decision is made to then go out and close the roads that are consistent with that decision. And that's the effort that Steve's referring to.
55:49 But it sounds like what he's saying is that perhaps the closures that are happening don't match what was mandated. That's what doesn't seem to be clear. And I have no knowledge about that. That's something I'm sure that the – if anybody – I would really encourage Steve to go to the Forest Service. Friends of the Inyo is under contract to do a lot of that work, but that's between Friends of the Inyo and the decision that the Inyo National Forest has made, and that's – it's definitely happening, but that's the appropriate body to be talking to for the stuff. Yeah. Thank you.
56:18 So, I agree, I don't think this, it doesn't affect our decision today, but it's something that's worthwhile to be aired. I think he stated it more accurately and articulately than I did, and I think that's absolutely correct, but again, with the folks on the streets, they kind of lumped together that MLTPA, the Friends, the Forest Service, and that is...
56:44 Helping a good cause that's within our town. And we appreciate you helping the public and getting the message across is where, you know, the difference between things there. I think that's really important. Thank you. Thank you. Anyone else wishing to speak in support? And we'll go on to anyone wishing to speak in opposition. And next, anyone who just wants to give general testimony about this project. Okay?
57:16 Any rebuttal to the previous testimony by the proponents? I think we've covered that. At that point, I think we're ready to close the public hearing and terminate public testimony and deliberate. Anybody would like to start with their thoughts? A couple of things if you want. If you look at when you're dealing with the environmental impact report, it's less than significant or no significant things.
57:46 And that's the way it's designed to read. How does it affect something? Well, it doesn't have any effect. Or it does have an effect. But when you look at it versus a positive, maybe a negative, or something that's an added benefit, you'd have to look at this particular plan. And what it gives you is, you know, increase access to things that are around the area, especially wildlife access to people who may not go off trail but would definitely...
58:16 Want to know that where they're going is taking to them, you know, they want to know where they're going and how to get there, where their destination is. When you look at how it affects the schools, it's only positive how it affects the schools. It takes some of the burden of them to produce like services and it takes them away from this controlled school environment out into...
58:39 The wilderness for a lot of people, you know, may not be for some, but it is definitely an environment that changes, so it's only beneficial there. Yes, it impacts them, but I think that's quite a positive, you know, and now if you're looking at negative, there will be a time that while these things are under construction that it affects.
59:00 Anything being under construction. And temporarily affects mobility and drainage issues because that's when anything that you're building does. Yes, it adds the police, looking at here, the impact is police will be required to be in this area more often as it becomes more popular. And then it's increased, you know, we will have increased funds and personnel for maintenance and upkeep.
59:28 But what do you get from that over and above? And that is, what you get is vastly improved mobility around town. You get vastly improved wayfinding because it becomes part of the experience. And it's an additional community asset. And we can argue whether this is the one asset that drives everybody to come or whether it's a value-added benefit. I tend to look at being a value-added benefit.
59:57 Because what that does is it gives you better mobility, better recreation, comprehensive wayfinding, but what it does in the bottom line is all these things add up to allow your business owners to charge a little bit more for their rooms and the restaurant owners to have a different, an ability to offer more fare longer times of the year and things allows us to do more business.
1:00:26 Which puts money back into the coffer, and that's, it's not the direct driver, but it allows us to upgrade our product all the way around. And so when you look at a comprehensive trail program, yes, there are some communities that it absolutely, that's the reason you go to that community. That's a long-term goal. But in the meantime...
1:00:47 It allows us to have a better presentation in our community and provide revenue sources and things that completely enhance the experience. And that's why the book is so thick because it really connects a lot of things. It isn't just about a paved path or a trail. It's about how you present your community. And that's why it's so comprehensive. And it really does have environmental impacts.
1:01:15 Which, in the long run, it improves your environment, and that improves environment for the guests and everyone, as well as those that live here. Thank you. Mr. President, are you ready to come? I concur with Rhonda, because she reminds us repeatedly that it's all about economics, because we wouldn't be here unless we had a sustainable economy, and this is a good step toward that. It really is about economic development, even though you don't look at it that way. This is the experience we offer guests.
1:01:43 I'm just really impressed with the whole effort. I followed it from the beginning and the outcome is very good. I'm very satisfied with it. Thank you. Sharon? I go back to 2007 when my husband and I were part of the inventory of our trails. So it's been a long time coming. We happen to live in almost a paradise and this simply enables all our
1:02:13 people, community, our visitors alike to access and that our environment. So I'm just thrilled that it's finally here and thank you so much for the community and John and staff and whoever did it. Thank you.
1:02:40 I would just like to comment on the Lake Basin Trail System. Even though it's not 100% completed, it's absolutely fabulous. It's supposed to be a bike trail system, but you see people regularly walking it, you see people on there with their strollers, you see families, big kids, little kids, and I think it's just a really great indication of what the whole master plan is going to do. We've been through portions of this before. We've had a lot of material to go through.
1:03:13 It's evident to me with this additional review I made in preparation for today's meeting that this is a remarkably thorough package, both the master plan itself as well as the environmental documents to measure the impacts. I think it's very thoroughly and very well done.
1:03:36 With that, I'm fully in support of it. I think also, when looking at this as a triple bottom line, because I think it involves all those three lakes, this covers largely the natural resources we have. As evident from Rhonda's comments, it's tied very closer to the economic aspect of the triple bottom line because it's such a valuable resource.
1:04:04 And it even relates to our social leg. I think back to Mickey, the quote I read from Mickey, what we all, I think, feel this is our social activity a lot, is being out there close to nature. So it covers everything. Okay. With that, are we ready for a motion or is there any more discussion?
1:04:35 I recommend that the Town Council's, that the Planning Commission recommends to the Town Council to certify the Master Trail System Master Plan, Environmental Impact Report, and adopt by resolution the Trail System Master Plan. Second. We call for a roll call vote. Commissioner Brown? Aye. Commissioner Dinney? Yes, aye. Chair Deakin? Yes. Commissioner Dugan? Aye.
1:05:06 Commissioner Craig. Aye. Passes unanimously. Thank you. And that one is option one, correct? Option one. Yes. Yeah, I did mention. Did you want a picture? Mr. Chair, I'm wondering if it's possible to have a photograph of the commission. It's just an informal thing so that we can advise folks if this action has happened and also advise let them know that it's going to the town council in an appropriate date. Sure. Is there anybody here who knows how to work a camera? Oh, yeah, there's one guy back there. Okay, thank you very much. That camera, I don't know.
1:05:44 Should we all hold our books?
1:06:13 Are we close enough? Do you get John? Don't make John head less.
1:06:42 Thank you all very much. That concludes our public hearing for this meeting. The next section of the meeting, business matters, and our agenda item three is municipal wayfinding and community messaging program with scope of work.
1:07:16 Is that you, Ms. Marlon? It is. I'm handling this. You're everyone today. I am. Thank you, Chair and Commissioners. The purpose of this agenda item is to allow the Planning Commission to consider the draft scope of work for the Municipal Wayfinding and Community Messaging Program and to make a recommendation to the Town Council. This item is scheduled for Town Council consideration next Wednesday, October 5th. This program is also intended...
1:07:42 presented to provide context for consideration of the following agenda item, which is the Mammoth Gateway Community Project Sign Permit. The project is intended to implement goals, policies, and actions, which are cited on page 3-1 and 3-2 of your report. The purpose of the Municipal Wayfinding and Community Messaging Program is to move forward with the immediate and short-term actions.
1:08:09 that are referenced in the goals and policies and actions with a goal of establishing a consistent design that employs a hierarchy of monumentation, directional signage, and informational guidance, which will achieve a comprehensive, user-friendly, and attractive wayfinding and community messaging system. The components of this system are looking to complement and build on
1:08:37 existing design references that we have here such as the Mammoth Lakes Trail System signage program, the Ski Back Bridge in the North Village, the proposed Gateway Community Project and our new branding that the town has adopted. The draft scope of work is included as an attachment to the report. There are two major phases of the draft scope of work. The first phase
1:09:03 It's described on page 3-4 of your report, and it's basically including, it includes the development of the plans and specs for the signage program. Phase 2 is the physical installation of signage for the program, and that's all included as attachment 2 of your staff report. If you have any questions on the details, I'd be happy to go through them.
1:09:26 Thank you. As the Planning Commission
1:09:54 Member on the signage and wayfinding committee, Elizabeth, would you like to add anything to that before we have questions? I wouldn't add anything to the report, but I have a question, and I think I've already talked to Commissioner Brown about it, so she will probably ask the question that we have already discussed. Do you want any questions? Yeah. Okay. So on page 3.4, when it talks about phase 1,
1:10:24 And it talks about it will require the assistance of a design consultant. I was wondering if you could expand on that point. Well, it would be a we would have to do a proposal, a request for proposals to obtain a consultant who would basically help us prepare all of those tasks, tasks three through nine. So I'm not sure if Hayes, if you want to elaborate on anything.
1:10:54 On that, this is Haislip Hayes. He's with our engineering department. He's working on this project as well. So the idea would be to hire a consultant to help us with our design concepts and to help locate where the signage will go and what the message of the signs will be. Presumably this is somebody similar to Corbin Designs, the kind of work they do. There are a number of consulting firms that specialize in this type of work. I would follow on Mickey's question.
1:11:27 Why do we need a consultant? We have you, we have Jessica, we have, you know, we have a finite amount of money for this grant and why we're spending it on a consultant that almost seems like a middleman. Why don't we just get someone to design the signs? You guys have determined where they go. Sure. The designer would do a theme. Why do we need this?
1:11:48 Extra consultant. We're not planning to reinvent the wheel. We're going to build upon a lot of the design efforts that have already occurred with the Gateway Monument and the messaging for the bike trail. But the consultant is really going to bring an unbiased third-party opinion to what messages go where with the ranking and how we categorize the sign and the hierarchy of the signs. And we don't want to, you know...
1:12:12 Have a biased opinion from staff or retailers or merchants or any of the different stakeholders. We really want a third-party opinion on how these things should be categorized in the hierarchy of science. I appreciate what you're saying about third-party objectivity, but how, I mean, we know the territory. How can we collectively not do that ourselves? I think that's why I would... Snicker, snicker. Because it hasn't been done. It hasn't been achievable.
1:12:41 I understand the question, but, and I would look at it from a little different standpoint. You have all the right components here, but that doesn't mean it's going to be done right. Because one of the things that, when you're trying to direct people around town, you have to give them a sense of how big and where it is. So when I'm trying to explain people all their signs there, the signs can be very overwhelming. If you don't be expressing...
1:13:06 The town of Mammoth is four square miles. That's something that a guest can get their head around, or we can get our head around. And what that actually gives them a picture of connectivity. Well, everything is very close, yes. And we need to make sure that we're guiding our guest into a sense of where you need to go, because it's just like being on the freeway on 395.
1:13:31 You can go for a very long time and never know you're heading towards Mammoth because the signage doesn't say anything. And you can go off and decide that maybe you've missed it because there's nothing about a new Mammoth. Well, the reality is everybody's done the right thing is because Mammoth is not on 395, it's on 203. So where this will come in technically is the right, but you still can't get away with your way around.
1:13:58 I would hope that the consult, if we're using a consultant, it is to, how do we connect everything so you have an idea of, I only have to walk this far to get where I am. That you're up in the village, but it says, downtown is a half a mile. And knowing how these, so you get perspective, because once people know how far they have to go to get to certain things, then they judge whether they will walk or not.
1:14:26 And if they don't have this connectivity there, they're going to get in their car and they're going to be looking for little signs. And that's what I know we want to avoid there. We want to make it to where the city flows. They have an idea of how far they're going to go and where we start to look for things because this is all, this is great. These are the components there. But how do you make it feel like, well, if we're only four square miles, this should feel like a nice, compact, tight pedestrian community.
1:14:55 And how do we make it feel like it's a square? And how do you get around there? That's what I would hope that this particular wayfinding includes not just, you know, you're five miles from here, but you're also another two miles back from somewhere else. And putting all of those components together, that's where I hope that the money for a consultant would be, because I concur with you. We know what all the pieces look like. I would expect somebody to put the pieces together in a way that flows. And I appreciate that we're all too close to the material.
1:15:25 To be objective. But how do you tell somebody where you live? Down the 4th Street on the right in Old Mammoth. Because very few people can see the signs. That's where I live. And that's it. So they cannot imagine that you wouldn't know what street number is on your house. Can't even tell them that half the time that they don't have street numbers there. So how we're moving around, how we're getting people to move around there gives them a sense of this is bigger than I know. No, this is, it feels.
1:15:54 Like I can maneuver that. That's where I'm hoping this goes, because that I think is really key to that whole situation. I think my frustration is, and of course if I didn't believe in planning I wouldn't be sitting here for 10 years plus, but we have what, $165,000 in this grant? And how much of it will go for the consultant?
1:16:14 And I really want to focus on results, and I don't want to go off, you know, half-cocked and not have a good plan, but I look at this, I look at the caliber of the staff we have, I look at the quality of our commissioners, I look at the kind of support we have, and I just think, why do we need a middleman? But maybe Rhonda makes a good point, and maybe I should listen to that, but I'm really focused on results, and it troubles me. But I think if we need something else, that's what they've...
1:16:41 Pull it all together. Because right now, I agree, it's not pulled together. Some may feel that it is, but I can see it still doesn't tell me, you know, it tells me where I am right now, but how far is that where I want to go? How do you know where you want to go if you don't see the perspective? That's what I would expect that to deliver. Because if it doesn't, then we haven't gotten the result of what you need. So then what percentage of the grant is going to go for the consultant and what percentage will go for signs on the ground?
1:17:10 Or in the air or wherever. Hopefully as much as possible will go towards actually implementation of the program. But until we actually complete the RFP process, we won't know exactly where we stand with that. So the request for proposals, since it includes bids to do the job, then you'll get some idea of how much a consultant is going to take out of this. Okay, I really want to see signs. Maybe the takeaway from the Planning Commission is to...
1:17:35 Request that staff take an extra close look at the statement of work that they come up with for the consultant and make sure it's only the things that we really can't do ourselves. That's a very good point. I guess I'm tip, what's a typical cost for, and will it come in the RFP or no? A typical cost for? The consultant to do what we're asking. The trail system master plan wayfinding.
1:18:05 The standard manual was, initially it was $20,000, and then we had an additional $15,000 scope of work for them to do. But they provide, they really provided some facilitation. They helped identify the nose, get some common terminology, and get a graphic that was easy to read and comprehensive for people to see as they're going through the system. So this will provide the same thing except for the cars and people around the community, not the trail.
1:18:35 Peter, what was it that Jessica already did, identifying, what, 37 locations where we needed significant directional signs? What was the name of that task? I think Jessica could do that. Yeah, there it is. And then what's this intern doing with the GIS points? What's that intern doing? The intern is actually working on task.
1:19:03 Task number two, the existing conditions and needs. We've sent out, we've, well, the work has been completed by the intern, but they went out with the GPS device and cataloged all the existing signage and all the arterials and collector roads throughout town. And that effort included every little bit of information you could ever imagine about the signs, from the dimensions of the post to the height to the color to the condition, and then photographed.
1:19:30 All these signs. And then we have it in a database that's easily accessible to anybody who's actually online. And you can go and see all the signs right now. Then who would be preparing this owner's manual? That would be an effort between us and the consultant. But the town couldn't do that once the consultant had figured out how to make it all work, as Rhonda has described, how to make it all clear to the guests. And that isn't something staff could do.
1:20:00 No, the staff will work on that. That's part of this program. Okay. You understand my concern about the chunk that, you know, the consultant will take out of this. Well, I appreciate that you're having to pay, but somebody's got to have to do it. And right now, you don't have staff to do it either. No. We can't, like I said, we're not reinventing the wheel. We're really going to build upon all the work that's been done. This is, the consultant is really just bringing things together and giving us that third-party insight and specialty. Okay. Because you don't have enough manpower to do it.
1:20:32 Bill, which is what troubles me about consultants, and we've seen such a parade of them before Planning Commission, is they sum up what staff has already done, and then they walk away with a check, you know, and so that's very frustrating. And that's not our intent. Okay. You appreciate my concern. And it's not our desire. And I think it goes back to what Jay said. I think the RFP has to be clear, concise, specific about what we want, and...
1:20:59 I agree with Elizabeth. I sure want some signs in there. Yeah, I think we're on the same page. Yeah, very much so. I believe this grant, the funds are really for planning grants, they're not for sticks in the ground. These funds cannot be used for construction. Oh, really? They're planning grants, right? Oh, how do you get a grant for construction? Well, I mean, it's great to have good plans, but, you know, well, that's distressing.
1:21:30 So is that going to have to be a budget item for 12-13? That's right. We absolutely need them to use that. We need them to use that. We need them to use some other problems. And not the other. Well, then maybe we should enlarge the consultant's role and get more out of them. If this can only be used for planning, maybe we should enlarge the consultant's role and get more bang for our buck. We'll have to see how the RFPs come in. Okay. More questions?
1:22:03 No. That kind of blew me away. Yeah, that just, you know. Did I hear a comment that we should have the Planning Commission sign committee review the RF, or the final proposal? Was that? I don't think we heard that. No, okay. It was, I think that's that. That the commission, oh, no, that we would, okay. Now that we, now that we know what the scope of what it would be entailing, I think staff is, we've expressed our intent. Okay. Just to make sure that we're.
1:22:30 Utilizing the funds the best we can, that's what's appropriate to the grant. A couple other comments I wanted to make. One, having to do with design references. In the staff report on page 3-3, there is a paragraph about components of the system creating a pattern of design and complement build on existing design references, such as
1:22:57 The Mammoth Lakes Trail System, Signage Program, Ski Back Bridge in North Village, the Gateway Project, et cetera. And our attachment one shows, has a graphic showing those. I would assume, although it doesn't say it specifically there, that those are just examples, not the only references we're going to use. Okay. And my other comment has to do with phasing.
1:23:24 Phase 1, in a word, is planning, and Phase 2 is implementation. And it's apparent that by the time we get to implementation, and even the implementation phase itself may be spread over a considerable period of time before we get this whole system done. And I looked, but I couldn't find anything in Phase 1 that dealt with what I would think could be an issue there, and that is...
1:23:54 If this system is going to be implemented over a long period of time, do you need some planning to make sure that when you start implementing, you implement in chunks that are unified, that don't create something that directs you somewhere that hasn't been implemented yet? I don't think it specifically states it, but I think that would be part of task three, which is identifying signage, kind of identifying the overall signage.
1:24:24 And identifying which signs kind of should be added or replaced, consolidated, removed with the sign hierarchy. We can add that in there. I think that's a good point. Think about a perk chart where you look at all the things that have to be done here before you can move on to this part and make sure that everything's phased in a way that's sensible. Yes. That's my comments. Good point. Anything else? I just have one.
1:24:53 Additional question. I heard within the last couple of months that there's actually a federal statute that says that the street signs need to be able to be readable at night by the average 60-year-old. Yeah. What does that mean, and what does that... That was new guidelines from the manual on uniform traffic full-drive devices on retro reflectivity, and unfortunately that was squashed, so we no longer have to worry about that.
1:25:25 I was afraid you were going to parade me around town at night, see if I could read the signs. There was a point where we were actually going to start looking for volunteers. Thank you. Are we ready for a motion?
1:25:53 I move that we approve with any modifications the draft scope of work for the Municipal Wayfinding and Community Messaging Program and forward to the Town Council for review and direction. I guess the only modification is that the RFP would come back to the Planning Commission, maybe a tighter version or a version that accomplishes or addresses our concerns. As well as the adding the phasing and implementation. Yes. Yes. Good.
1:26:23 Second. We have a motion and a second. Ms. Moberly, does this need to be a, can this be a voice? All those in favor? Aye. Thank you. Moving on to item four, which is the sign permit for the Mammoth Community Gateway sign. Before we have staff's presentation, I'll note that
1:26:57 Because of Elizabeth Kinney's involvement with this, central to it, there was some concern whether there was an issue with respect to a conflict of interest. The town attorney was contacted and found that there was no legal conflict of interest, but Elizabeth and I discussed this and agreed that for the sake of appearance, avoiding the appearance of any proprietor, that she would step down.
1:27:27 from the commission for this item and speak however you want to as a private citizen from the audience. I think that's very appropriate. I have no conflict of interest legally because I have no financial interest or remuneration for this. I'm doing it as a volunteer, but I'm doing it as a private citizen, not as a planning commissioner. So I think your direction is very appropriate and I will step down. Thank you.
1:27:53 And with that, Ms. Moberly, would you like to present the staff report? Thank you. The item before you today is Sign Permit 2011-00015, which is the Mammoth Community Gateway sign. It's a new gateway entry monument sign on the south side of State Route 203, just west of Thompson's Way. The project includes a monument sign, associated structural elements, which include a pilaster retaining wall.
1:28:21 As well as associated lighting. We've included the plans for the sinus attachment beadier staff report. The sign is proposed to be 20 feet high at the tallest point, which is the top of the pilaster, 16 feet tall at the top of the steel beam, and 34 feet wide with approximately 144 square feet of sign area. The sign will include the text Mammoth Lakes on the east-facing elevation and the text
1:28:49 Thanks for visiting. See you again soon. Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce on the west-facing elevation. Just as a note, the text reading Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce is smaller in font than the other remaining text. And the signed copy is not final at this time. It's close to final, but not quite final and may be revised prior to installation. So we've included condition of approval 13.
1:29:15 which requires that the final signed copy be reviewed by the Planning Commission's signed committee prior to its installation. As a quick background, the Mammoth Community Gateway Project is a citizen-initiated project which grew from a joint Planning Commission Town Council meeting in November of last year. The project is a volunteer-slash-private-slash-public partnership which is intended to implement the concepts
1:29:44 That were described in the downtown concept for Main Street as well as the general plan. Since that time last November, the project has been expanded to include a similar monument site on the north side of 203. That location is outside of the town's jurisdiction, so we will not be issuing a permit for it. However, we did include information on that sign as part of your packet, which is the last page of attachment B for your reference.
1:30:13 This sign permit isn't a typical sign permit in that most sign permits are all approved at the administrative level. We brought this before the Planning Commission because of its exposure and to allow the Planning Commission to consider it. We have outlined all pertinent sign requirements in the staff report on pages 4-3 and 4-4. The project complies with town's sign ordinance as described.
1:30:39 I won't go into details unless you have any questions on any of those items. The new sign will help to implement the general plan and vision specifically by creating an ambiance that attracts visitors using exceptional standards for design and development that complement and are appropriate to our eastern Sierra Nevada mountain setting.
1:31:00 And additionally, Appendix C of the general plan, which is the physical development diagram, specifically identifies the proposed sign location as a primary gateway to town. With that, I would recommend that the Planning Commission choose option one, which is to approve the sign permit 11-0015, as shown or as modified by the commission. And that concludes my report, and I'm available for any questions that you have. Questions?
1:31:35 It's not a staff. It would be a presenter. It would be a presenter's staff. Questions? No, I have a question. I have just... I think Sharon has a question. Pardon me? I think Sharon has a question. Sharon, go ahead. I just believe we're supposed to have apostrophes in Thompson's way. No.
1:31:58 Well, we need to be consistent. We talked about that earlier. I was out to lunch? Is that what you said? It was actually, you did come up earlier about the inconsistencies there. Okay. It's Thompson's with an S with no apostrophe. No apostrophe. It isn't consistent, but some other. Two Thompson's. So the road is incorrectly? In this. In the side. Okay. The other question I have is, I thought it was the other way, so.
1:32:26 At any rate, the text on this sign, I didn't see it and perhaps didn't read closely enough, may be changed, it's not permanent, or is it permanent on the sign? It's permanent. Once it's there, it's permanent. Correct. But in between now and when it's actually installed, the language change. That decision hasn't been made, but once it's on, it stays. Correct. Okay, I just...
1:32:55 Perhaps somebody who knows more about signs could answer that question. I just wonder if, is it terribly expensive to change if we decide to change at some point in time? Does any, I don't know anything about. I'm not sure I think I can refer that question. The construction. I'd like to refer that question to the applicant. Okay. Or to somebody, maybe Bruce would know. I don't know. Let's wait just a second until we get there.
1:33:22 Staff work, or staff questions. Okay. Thank you. Those are all I had. Okay. I had a couple of questions. The, you, on page 4-3 in the staff report, you cite the section of the sign ordinance that establishes limitations and permits signs to be up to 12 feet in height. And then note that this one is 20 feet 5 inches in height.
1:33:50 Sign area you note is community information signs are exempt from the sign area limit, and this sign area is approximately 144 square feet. Refresh my recollection for signs that aren't exempt. What's the square footage? Maximum is 30. It's 30. Okay, so this is quite a bit above that. And on the next page, 4-4, the sign setback.
1:34:14 The normal setback required is five feet from the right of way, but a smaller setback is allowed in order to meet the intent of the chapter. And this one doesn't have a setback. It's just kind of a general frustration. We just did the sign ordinance and we're still doing exceptions. I have no problem with any of these exceptions. I think they're imminently necessary to the...
1:34:37 Okay. I guess we can ask...
1:35:07 Proponents, comments from the audience at this point? If you will, state your name. Elizabeth Tenney, private citizen and community organizer of the Mammoth Gateway Community Project. And the first thing I'd like to do is to give you a photo rendering of the project that was done on a color printer that has truer colors than the muddy version. This is just a different time of day.
1:35:48 What? That's just the evening shop, the toilet shop. That's a very smoggy day in Pasadena as far as I'm concerned. This is a very unique project. It's called out in the general plan. I can't quote the action item that it is, but it's definitely an action item in our general plan. It's a one-shot deal. We only have one gateway into town, and that's on 203. The monuments are designed to be there for 100 years or more.
1:36:15 We do have restrictions from Caltrans on what kind of information we can put on the opposing side of the road. So that's why the Mammoth Lakes is on the other side of the road. We can't really have any message there. Welcome to the top of California because we are the highest elevation incorporated community in California is proposed for the north side, but we haven't even filed the application and the town will be doing that for a permit from the Forest Service.
1:36:43 Can you generalize what their restrictions are? As to what you can say there? With Caltrans? Well, I know we couldn't have events on that side, because we did talk about that at one point. Is one of the things you can't have a changing? Yes. No, we can't have any information other than Mammoth Lakes, you know, on the other side. They're okay with that. And it is out of the right-of-way. We've allowed one foot, I'm hoping.
1:37:10 One foot is going to be enough. Yeah, right, but out of the right-of-way so we won't have a problem with the plow hitting it. The letters, and Bruce has explained to me how, but maybe Bruce, you want to speak to how the letters will be attached. They're anodized aluminum. The font was chosen to be compatible with the California and our brand, but it isn't necessarily final.
1:37:38 That's the one I've seen in all the photo renderings and the one that Larry Walker called out when he originally designed it. But there has been some question about that. I don't know if the font will change or not. I know it won't be script because it's too hard to read at 35 or 40 miles an hour, so it needs to be clear. But the letters are very securely, they're not just nailed on or screwed on, they're an integral part of the raw steel grid.
1:38:04 that forms the sign itself, and then there are wood timbers between the sections of steel, so they're very, very permanent. As far as welcome to the top of California, I don't know if in 50 or 75 years people are going to want the sign to still say that, but it pretty much, I think, involved taking the sign apart to change that. Would you agree, Bruce, if that message were to be changed on the north side?
1:38:32 We also have included the town's brand in anodized aluminum. I'm not exactly sure what the color is going to be. I thought originally it was going to be bronze, but I was told bronze will blend in too much with the wood and it won't show up. But there would be four renditions of the town's brand on either side of that outer column. So Bruce can say a few things about the scientists.
1:38:59 He's the one who's figured out how to build various great ideas, so he really knows this inside and out. The letters will be mounted in such a manner that they're very difficult to be removed, and very difficult to be removed, so that they won't be removed by somebody we don't want. You mean like welded, kind of? No, they won't be welded. They're aluminum, they're anodized, and you can't weld that.
1:39:26 But they will be attached securely. There are ways to do that. And getting back to Sharon's comment about changing the letters, the letters will be, they're fairly expensive. And so to change the letters later, and since this is being built on contributions only, I don't know who's going to come up with the money to try and change it. I doubt that we need to come up with something.
1:39:51 I think the Mammoth Lakes, the conundrum of this sign is that it says Mammoth Lakes, it will say Mammoth Lakes on the left-hand side. And the main reason for that and the design of that is that's the photo opportunity of that sign and with the mountain in the background and such.
1:40:17 And we wanted to say Mammoth Lakes. If you're taking that picture and you're taking it home and you're saving it and, you know, it's in your slide show or on the computer, I guess so much right now, in 10 years, people are saying, oh, and it was Mammoth. And that's important and very important. But unfortunately, that's on the left-hand side of the road, not the right-hand side of the road. And if you put it on the right-hand side, just on the right-hand side of the road, there's no good photo opportunity from the right-hand side of the road.
1:40:45 There's a bit of a trickiness there to figure out what's the best thing to put on the sign. The back side of the south side monument has just a departing statement which is in there, which seems to be a very nice way to put it. We were trying to stay away from come again. We don't want to get into any sort of innuendos or that sort of thing. So that's why it says what that says. As a sentiment.
1:41:16 That is appropriate and again can be easily read as you're driving by. And while the speed limit in this area is 35, you get run over if you're going 35 at this point. So the reality is that the size of things are the size because of the speed of the vehicles. The color of the lettering is something that will be
1:41:43 Final approval on that, that's noted as being, I think it was more the color of the letters, I think, than the font itself. There was some talk about the Mammoth Lakes that's used, the script font that's used, and that's very difficult to read from the distance. And if it blends in at all with its background, kind of like it does behind you, it's very hard to read. So that's why, and it makes the sign.
1:42:10 If it's one word like that to look just like the logo, the town's new logo, it becomes a very long sign and it's not really doable. So this was, you know, there's a balance between the color of the letter, the color of the background, its readability, whether it's too bright or whether it's too dark. There's a fine balance you have to play in there to get it just right because it is meant to be seen.
1:42:39 It is a sign. That is the point. So it needs to be enough that you can see it. So there has to be some contrast. And it's like the Forest Service signs. They're brown and yellow. And it's a bright yellow. Pretty bright yellow. And you can see and read all of those. They're very legible. They're also rather large. Those signs are well beyond the 30-foot square foot of a typical sign that we would have in our community. So I feel that from the size standpoint, we're good.
1:43:08 The north side, what it says there, you know, feeling that it needs to be something that is catchy, needs to be something that is relatively short, because you don't want to write a book on a sign, because nobody will read it. And it's true, we are, we're about 200 feet higher than Kirkwood, so we are. Well, then you can prove it. And so... Because they'll be asked to prove it. And even if we...
1:43:40 Even if we weren't, in Big Bear, there's Rim of the World, there's Rim of the World High School, they're certainly not the Rim of the World, they're just, that's the name, and it's a great name, and it fits down there, and I think this would be a good name for here, so, but that's kind of going to be up to the Forest Service. And, okay, that's it. Thank you. Another comment about the letters, it isn't just the rock work that's going to last for a hundred years, we really want the sign to last for a hundred years, therefore it has to be very classic.
1:44:12 And it has to be distinctive, and yet it's still going to look pleasing and be a real landmark. Here are just a few of the National Park entrance signs, and some of these are classic, and some of these aren't. And I've got another 20 I could have checked on you, but I think you've probably seen enough. And I'll make one last comment in the staff report. The retaining wall on the South Monument has been eliminated. The North Monument, excuse me? Uh-oh. It's going to be...
1:44:51 Ripwrap, I believe. Okay, Bruce, it's been added back. The rock wall that's on there, there's a small, it's a curving rock wall, it's only about, at the highest point, it's almost three feet above ground. It's on a slope, and basically it's going to be just, the concrete is, the reinforcing's laid on the angle, and the stone is then set into it, so it's not technically a retaining wall.
1:45:18 But it will hold back the slope. But there is a rock, curving rock wall there, but it's going to be at about a 60 degree angle. But it's not loose, still on the rig back. So we want enough squirrels in us. I've learned so much about building since I started this project. The north side, however, will require a real retaining wall because the grade drops off quite a bit, and that's the north entrance to the bike tunnel. But that isn't an issue for you today.
1:45:48 I'm glad to know that. Thank you. Are there any questions of me? I guess I had a question. What about the snow, height, and will our sign still be visible as Caltrans plows? I don't remember how high it gets there. This year, I believe, there was probably eight feet of snow, but this sign, it would still be above that. Okay. Okay. It's on a four-foot mound.
1:46:20 which will help, and also there are bollards in front of the sign, between the sign and the road, and those bollards are going to incorporate the lighting for the sign, so there won't be any off-site, you know, glare or anything like that, but they're going to incorporate the lighting, and they have been designed to be two feet more than the width of a plow blade, and the way the mounding is designed, the plow will be able to get in there and scoop the snow out, so.
1:46:47 And I believe once all the MOUs and everything are worked out, that will be a town responsibility to scoop out the snow from the town sign. I had visions of somebody going and pushing the snow back on both sides. I can see people maybe out there shoveling if it gets hidden. If it does. Okay. Did you want to add something? Elizabeth, I did have a question. Regarding the West Face,
1:47:17 Of the South Monument where it says thanks for visiting, see you again soon. It has Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce, are they a contributor to this? A financial contributor? What Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce is doing is really huge. They are going to be the pass-through organization. They have a non-profit, it's a 501c3 that's an arm of the chamber. The Mammoth Community Foundation, we have a number of foundations, but this is the Chamber of Commerce's 501c3. They are going to
1:47:46 Process all the donations. The donations are thereby tax deductible, which is a big hook for, you know, pulling in contributions. And they're going to pay the invoices. And they will be, since this is on county property, the deputy county council who's been assigned to work with me on this was insistent that someone has to, quote, own the sign while it's under construction. So they will be the project sponsor slash owner while it's under construction. And then it will be donated.
1:48:16 To whatever entity will accept it, and all that's being worked out this month. I think they will help with fundraising as well, but there was some comment in the beginning, why should the Chamber of Commerce be recognized? That's a valid comment, but we couldn't make this happen without that kind of tax deductibility and them agreeing to process all the money and all the contributions. So that was where that came from. Any further comments from the public?
1:48:52 Reminded me, they will of course pay for those letters on the back side of the side. Well, that's financial contributor, yeah. Well, absolutely, as well as I hope have fundraisers and, by the way, our fundraising deadline is March 31st, which is five months, no, six months away, we still have six months, because Chuck Landy, we're still here, good.
1:49:15 He pointed out we've got to have all the money in the bank before we start this. Would be a good idea. Absolutely. Everything's got to be in the bank, so we're under a lot of pressure. I've started fundraising already. I stuff envelopes and write notes and all this kind of stuff, and our fundraiser's planned in October.
1:49:30 In November, Jim Demetriatus is going to have a grand opening of the Red Lantern fundraiser on November 12th, which is the opening weekend at the Mountain. We've got all kinds of stuff coming up, so we're working very hard to raise the money to do this, and we're getting huge in-kind support from the Mountain, from Snow Creek, and others. So the in-kind support, I mean, all I've spent money on is for paper and postage so far. It's just the in-kind support's been amazing to date, so it's great. Any more questions?
1:50:01 Okay, we've got more comments from the audience here. Thank you. Dave Harvey, Mammoth Lake Citizen. I wanted to take this opportunity to thank Elizabeth and all the folks that she has helping her going forward on this project. I and my family believe that this is the right sign at the right time in the right place. It has the possibility of...
1:50:35 Having the same notoriety as the Las Vegas sign, which is internationally known. And I feel within a very short period of time, we're going to start seeing this monument, this sign into Mammoth, show up all around the world. Thank you. Thank you. Any further comments? Discussion? You want to start? Just a couple of things that I'll contribute.
1:51:07 So, by definition, it is a monument sign, which means that it doesn't change. It is reflecting a point in time that we wanted to recognize things. So, as far as the changeable messaging, this is not that type of thing. It's the message we want to adopt. This will be our Nike swoosh because what you need to make sure is we have to say if we were going to be the top of California,
1:51:33 That is something that we probably will have opportunity to promote in other areas. It's great to throw something like that out there because just the notoriety of people trying to find out if that's true or not puts you on the map. I'm not so concerned about the snow getting over it. I think that's an amazing photo opportunity to have the snow halfway covering the sign. I don't know of anything that says more that this is the real deal than something like that.
1:52:01 Make sure that the snow completely surrounds it, whatever, but we can see what it is. It is, you know, it's the sense of place, and I think with, this ties in so much with the wayfinding is, where am I, and how does that relate to where I want to be? And the fact that you finally know that you're there, we've all visited the communities where Jackson Hole has the antlers in the town square, so you know that you're there.
1:52:31 And with the sign, with the vistas behind it, enhancing those, we have vistas that not many places in the U.S. have. I mean, there's that sense of place when you come around.
1:52:46 Round the corner on 395 and you go, wow, that's it. And nobody in Colorado has that. I don't care what they say. So, I mean, the fact that this is something here. The font, I only feel like it's extremely bold and it's very vertical. Okay, so it is a bold statement, which is fine. It's just realizing it doesn't...
1:53:12 It doesn't give me the warm friendliness that the other thing does, but that's not necessarily a bad thing. It's very vertical font, but it's really strong. That may be, you know, that may be just fine. You know, we're not, the other one feels warm and cuddly next to it. We're not cuddly, we're the big stone mountain is what it feels like, which, you know, I can see that that's the way it hits me there. But you won't forget seeing that.
1:53:41 Seeing, knowing you're here, it's an amazing photo opportunity. I think you probably need to be prepared, though, for people to pull a U in the middle of the street to get their picture taken. And so either how we mitigate that or whatever it is around there, that's what will happen because it happens in front of my establishment with the bears. So that is something, what a, it's an unintended consequence, but that's exactly where, you know, this is a postcard waiting to happen.
1:54:10 Could I make a comment about that? Sure. We've already addressed that situation. We're hoping it's adjacent to the bike trail, so people walking and biking will be able to access it easily. But we need to have, and I've talked to John Urdi about this, we've got to have some kind of signage at the visitor center showing people the trail that goes to the tunnel so they know how to get there. We have to work that out. There are two times, and I'm thinking ahead to 2013, and may I live that long with how much work this has been,
1:54:39 But when the project's completed in 2012 and then the Water District Board of Directors has agreed to install and maintain a demonstration garden and I would like that garden to look very much like the post office. That'll be its landscaping. So on a bright sunny day in August, people come to town and it looks like the post office in front of the sign. That's experience number one. And experience number two is coming to Mammoth on a Friday night when it's snowing.
1:55:05 And you see the lights on that sign through the snowflakes and you see the lights of the cats up on the mountain and you go, wow, I'm here. You know, it's just, it's just, I just had a little chill. As we're guiding them into town. It'll be so exciting. This is so overdue. We've needed something like this, you know, something worthy of this place for the longest time. So I just am really enjoying working on the project and I can't believe how much I've learned about building the things. Thank you.
1:55:37 Elizabeth, I love your passion. And I think, you know, we've talked so much about Main Street having a sense of town presence, welcoming, and the monument really does that. So I'm very supportive of it. My only comment to staff, and I know this isn't really all in your jurisdiction, but we just need to do whatever we can in our powers to remove all those other signs.
1:56:06 From 203 and 395, as somebody has referred to as the Viking Village signs, and there's a, and I've noticed when you drive into 203, I mean, there's a lot of signs, so whatever can be removed from the street to really give this the focus would be just terrific. There's a group right now, including the Forest Service, in fact, actually the Forest Service's request,
1:56:36 They are studying the signage from the airport all the way to Old Mammoth Road with the thought to eliminating, consolidating and clustering because it's just that problem. I had the same reaction from the county when I went and asked permission to use their land for this monument sign. We already got all these signs and why do we need more signs and we need to get rid of some of them. I think there are 40 between 395 and Old Mammoth Road which is way too many. So people are aware of that and working on it.
1:57:04 That's part of the wayfinding program. My concern was the back of the north sign. There's nothing on it at this point. I'm assuming that's still coming. And that's why I was concerned. In the picture that it has a blank one, right? Yeah. And that's why I was asking my question about. At this point, the back of that sign is blank and it's not lit. It's, we want to have one statement as you're leaving town.
1:57:38 On the side that you're driving out on, and that's the south monument, west side, and so on the north side, right now, there is nothing on the back side. So that was purposeful? Yes, very purposeful. Okay. Well, that had to do with my question about changing these messages, so now I understand. Thank you. Okay. I support it. I think it's the right design. It's the right plate. Well, Dave Harvey said it. Yeah.
1:58:09 So I support it. Later comments? I think we're ready for a motion. I move that we approve sign permit 11-00015 as shown or modify. Actually, we didn't modify. No. As shown. Second. Yes, including the findings in the list of the resolution of all conditions of approval. I second. We have a will call vote, please.
1:58:46 Yes, Ms. Chair Pickens.
1:58:48 Yes.
1:58:49 Ms. Chair Pickens.
1:58:50 Yes.
1:58:50 Ms. Clerk.
1:58:51 Yes.
1:58:52 Motion carries.
1:58:54 Four to zero with Elizabeth abstaining, recusing.
1:58:59 I don't know what the proper term is for the record.
1:59:02 She recused herself.
1:59:03 Yeah.
1:59:04 Or she recused herself.
1:59:07 Welcome back.
1:59:16 and item number five is next this is the draft scope of work for the economic development program
1:59:28 Ms. Moberly. Thank you. The purpose of this agenda item is to allow the Planning Commission to consider the and make a recommendation of Town Council regarding the draft scope of work for our economic development program. This program will build upon and update the destination resort community and economic development strategy, which I'll call Dr. Seds for the remainder of my...
1:59:52 presentation, its acronym. This will also continue to advance a more formalized community-based economic development program. The majority of our work in this program is to implement actions and deploy programs that have been identified in the general plan and Dr. Seds and to update Dr. Seds and implement additional actions as determined necessary. The economy element of our general plan has served as our starting point for our economic strategy.
2:00:22 of the town and our Dr. Sets process. Dr. Sets was adopted by the town council in April of 2009. It established a three-year strategic and operational plan, which is intended to strengthen Mammoth's economy and our position as a destination resort.
2:00:45 which includes goals, strategies, and objectives for facilities programs and planning, and Dr. Sedd's also incorporated measurable outcomes and objectives. As a part of this program, in building upon work on the Dr. Sedd's, the Economic Stimulus Council was recently established, and the intent was to engage the business community.
2:01:12 In discussions of economics and a stimulus of our economy. The ESC includes a wide range of members and they've held five meetings where they've discussed a variety of topics and have really served as our focus group for the preparation of this scope of work. The ESC has agreed to continue their efforts to support the development and implementation of the overall economic development program. We've included
2:01:42 A fiscal strategy, town fiscal strategy on page 5-4. It's basically a starting point for the development of a fiscal strategy, and the intent is to respond to some of the issues that have been raised. The recession, comments by the CFFC committee, the town budget, as well as discussions regarding the name of the feed reductions have raised.
2:02:06 A lot of questions regarding our fiscal strategy. You know, what are our fiscal goals and objectives relative to transient occupancy, sales and property tax? What strategies can we use to achieve these goals and what tactics implement these strategies? And these all seem like things that we kind of already know, but these we'll kind of use as the base in developing our economic development plan. And so that's included on page 5-4 and 5-5 of your report.
2:02:35 And so we've included the draft scope of work for the Economic Development Program. It includes continuing our priority actions, both actions that were cited in Dr. Sedd's and actions that were recommended by the Town Council. We will be updating Dr. Sedd's and we will be implementing new actions as needed. Attachment A includes the scope of work.
2:03:04 On pages 5-6 and 5-7, we walk through phase 1, phase 2, and phase 3 of the scope of work. After publication of the staff report, we review the scope of work, and we'd like to propose to combine phases 1 and 2 to all just be one phase. This would allow us to streamline our process a little bit and to update Dr. Sedd's concurrently.
2:03:28 As part of the other tasks as well. So that was one change we'd like to propose. And so then Phase 3 would then become Phase 2, which would be implementing the new Dr. Setz actions. So with that, we'd like to recommend that the Planning Commission review the draft scope of work for the Economic Development Program and forward a recommendation to the Town Council for consideration.
2:03:56 As written or with modifications as suggested by staff. And I'm available for any questions that you have. Questions or comments? Do you have questions first? I have a question. Go ahead. Okay. I question why you're preparing an update to Dr. Seds. This is really an impressive document, and I wonder why staff time has to be spent.
2:04:21 It would be tidy, of course, but why you have to do an update, why you can't just continue to check things off as they get done and not spend staff time on actually preparing an update, you know, writing a new Dr. Seds. Well, we'll be doing both. We'll be checking off things that need to be done or we're doing, and we'll also be identifying new things that might need to be done, kind of describing the things that we have done that have helped our economy.
2:04:47 And, like I said, outlining new things. So it's not really a wholesale change of Dr. Seds, it's really just an update, saying this is what we've done, this is what we've identified to be new items that need to be done, and here's our timeline for doing those items. So Dr. Seds is a three-year kind of snapshot, so really every three years you should be updating. Okay, that's a different...
2:05:10 The conception of update than what I thought when I read this. So it's just adding things to this and then sort of seeing how things that were recommended went and just sort of more an assessment than an update even and adding to it. That's the intent. I mean, the intent of this program is really to focus on the actions and to implement as many actions as we can.
2:05:31 And the update of Dr. SIDS would allow us to identify new actions for implementation. Okay. I'm just so aware of the limitations with staff time and, you know, numbers of staff, and I hate to see you redoing a document where we could be focused on the doing. That's my only question. Thank you. To Elizabeth's point, this is a living document to where it's not one of those documents is that we've completed that, this is what we're going to do, you execute that.
2:06:00 Move on because the goals don't change, but how you get to those goals or what we may have to change because they may no longer be pertinent in the marketplace. And looking back at what even the 18 months, almost two years ago, when we were looking at some particular actions or even tactics for how we're going to address some of these, they're no longer available to you or they're just not the right thing to do in the particular economic.
2:06:30 Climate, other things come forward. And as an update is, those will be noted. And that's what I think part of even through our minutes process of the meetings there. So it's constantly changing. And because that industry, you know, tourism is constantly changing, there's constantly different things that are affecting it. And that's where we're
2:06:53 Supporting how this thing is going as well. Just a background of where the ESC comes from is what that really was. It's a brainstorming think tank of people that we're doing business in spite of whatever else is happening with the town, whether it's litigation or whatever. Our doors are open. And we need to provide the
2:07:18 To our guests and to ourselves, the stability that no matter what happens is that we have an action that we can take. And some of that stuff is immediate today. Some of it is long term. But we're not completely at the mercy of something we have no control over. There are certain things that we need to be responsible in taking actions for as business people.
2:07:43 and not relying on the government to do these things, especially when they don't know if they'd ever be able to fulfill it. And what we found was there was a lot of interest, talent, and ability to execute some of these things there as regarding data finding, as educating ourselves on what was happening within the industries, things that we could do to support each other.
2:08:12 And then knowing where were the right tactics to take from the positions we're in today. And that's where I found the Economic Stimulus Committee to be helpful because they all were coming from a different position as in a commission or even a standing committee would be. And that's why it's coming forward now is because that group cannot take any action.
2:08:39 They can make recommendations. They can help open us up to ideas and solutions. But now, coming forward is where we need to decide is there recommendations that we have to bring to council to take actions if it's involved, or is it purely citizen-driven? I think some things, you know, we'd like to be able to close the book on today, but you can't. You know, we can't get, you can't just say do away with DIF. You have to go through the process to address that. And that's where the consensus is there.
2:09:08 The benefits don't outweigh the issues that it brings to there, then you start the process to do that. And that would be where this provides valuable information to it to make sure that we have the priorities there because it's not just visitation, increasing visitation, it's getting more money in front of the people that are coming here.
2:09:32 How do you do that? Through the programs and the wayfinding and the trail system, you have enhanced value-added items there instead of just the same thing and, you know, charging more for it. Because those particular, we don't have that ability to do that anymore anywhere in the country, not just in Mammoth. That gives a little background on why people like Chuck and Dave are participating in their time to see where...
2:10:01 Things, you know, what can we contribute to that that isn't reliant on others? Questions? Question, page 5-2, a destination resort, all right, down at the bottom, Dr. Seds is where I am, and the last, or maybe it's a second sentence, three-year strategic plan, our position as a destination resort,
2:10:32 I wonder if community was left out, destination resort community with goals, strategies, objectives. I'm sorry, because I see community, so I must be on a different line in your... Where are you? 5-2 under Dr. Seds, the heavy Dr. Seds, the fifth line strengthening Mammoth's economy in our position as the destination resort community.
2:11:05 Which is in the title of Dr. Said, so that would be a good idea. I just think we are a resort community. We are not just a resort. I just think it's critical that we not change. And the same thing on page 5-4 under Town of Mammoth Lakes Fiscal Strategy. The first thing is key resort community goals.
2:11:44 Same thing on page 5-5, key resort community strategies. I actually think you can take out resort or community's key goals and strategies. Because looking at the fiscal objectives, key strategy, key goals there. Because that's a heading for any particular study. Absolutely. That's true. That makes sense.
2:12:13 So we'll just do key goals and key strategies. Thank you. And attachment B, I have questions. This is page 512. These are handwritten numbers. Under strengths, I think we have more strengths. And the blue is suggested by the economic...
2:12:52 ECS. ECS, thank you. Where it says broad range of recreational opportunities, I just wondered if we could expand on that a tad, because I think we have incredible recreation opportunities. Maybe we don't need it, but I just wish we could do some more with our recreational opportunities as strengths in our community, because I think we have them.
2:13:23 Well this is just reporting on what the Economic Stimulus Council
2:13:28 No, excuse me, it isn't, I'm sorry. Yes, it is. You're right. No, it's a string. What this is, it's just listing, it's not talking, it's not getting into the details of what those are. I think when you say a broad range, that means... A broad range. What it is, is that we have such a wide variety that there's an appeal. That's what it implies to me. So, you know, so that's what it's saying, and this isn't really the place that you need to...
2:13:53 Renumerate it. When you get into the tactics and actions, you're going to be, that's where it enhances these strengths. And that, because we're going to need to say that you have, let's take trails for example, is that because you have trails, these are how you can build them into economic factors, which, you know, a lot of those recreation things, it's a little muddy on where you can.
2:14:19 Let's be honest, make money about it. But you can by having them as an added on value and you being close to a trail for your restaurant or your particular other activity. That is an enhancement there. And we will see some things more defined. All right. So you think that that's the place to expand? Yes. Okay. So what does that mean to you? I think that's what you're looking for is tell us what that means. Why is it a strength there? Because we can do this with that. Okay. Thank you.
2:14:49 I just, I want it somewhere that we have a broad range. Attachment. Do you have questions? Or I'll be sure instead. Oh, excuse me. Attachment C, page 5-16. I was number 13 under create new events. And it's just a typo perhaps. Running event with runners village put on by, what? No, that's actually,
2:15:25 There are particular events to where that would be more in quotes of a runner's village because it is a sponsorship and a retail opportunity that they have a trade show or a retail opportunity. They're called runner's villages. Thank you. That's just lack of knowledge on my part. This is an IE. It should be within there. That's an example. Okay, well.
2:15:48 Thank you. Clarification is what I'm looking for. Yeah, I would put in IE with that because that's an example, that's not where the main focus was, but you have that at a bit chair two, I'm sorry, I still call it chair two, but when we do the
2:16:09 Trade Show for the ski vendor's trade show. They do a vendor's village right there. Just so long as everybody understands, I didn't. What did they call it this summer? They had a unit at Snow Creek, I think, called a runner's crib, and they could stay there. It's not the same thing. But that's an example of certain things. Okay. That's just clarification. It's a little too much insider lingo. All right. And I obviously didn't know. Thank you. Those were my only questions.
2:16:38 Did we get any questions first? I have comments. Oh, these are questions. Okay. Sandra, who will be managing this when you're out on leave? Will that be Jen? Likely Jen. And how does staff define sustainable tourism? Tourism that can be continued all through the year. So year-round, shoulder seasons, midweek. Okay.
2:17:07 Thank you. I'd like just to share a little bit of my viewpoint of the Economic Stimulus Council. I really believe it was a private, with the emphasis private slash public council, and my sense is that the inclusion of the minute notes and the comments was somewhat premature in this document because
2:17:39 Especially the private section has a very definitive action item list that they want to take. And so because that is not neat and tidy yet, it wasn't included in the document. So for example, the Chamber of Commerce had a strategic workshop where they really defined what they felt their future role was in event development.
2:18:07 and event coordination and how they want to handle that. So in the future, what you will see is some very defined actions coming from the Stimulus Council and it will be action really truly from the business community where we always rely on staff support. It will not necessarily be staff driven. But my problem with the way this is currently laid out is the scope of work.
2:18:37 And I really feel that the scope needs to be more detailed because while, for example, TOT is certainly at the top of staff's action item list and people are working very hard on it, we still have a huge fundamental problem with our TOT reporting. And the reason I know that is because if you go down to task 6 from the private sector,
2:19:07 It is my lead with the Chamber of Commerce to develop the indicators report. And we could present an indicators report through the second quarter next week to, for example, to council. But the reason we can't do that is because we still have no current TOT numbers.
2:19:29 So it'd be my really strong recommendation that we say that the scope, especially regarding TOT, should be very specific, that it should be the number one priority, that it should, that number one priority really needs to have the funds and resources dedicated to it to upgrade the software system, that there needs to be monthly reporting both from all of the
2:19:58 People that collect TOT and then back to the community and that we need an online payment system. So that's my first comment about scope. My second comment about scope is that in the Dr. Seds document, original document, you know, air service was one of the number one items and even in the Economic Stimulus Council we talked
2:20:26 extensively about air service. And so now we're in a situation where we are very fortunate that we're increasing our number of flights from, you know, one flight during the summer to seven flights, but I just feel that there should be a task about making sure that the whole guest experience is really a positive one. This is my fear, is what happens if you have
2:20:54 Three planes that can't take off and you have, you know, 100, between 100 and 200 visitors all sitting at our current airport in some spring structure. I mean, how are we going to accommodate them and how are we going to make that a positive experience? I'll give you a little example. I flew out of our airport last week and while I was standing at the counter, somebody came up and said,
2:21:23 Can I have wheelchair assistance? And they said, well, we only have one wheelchair. So there was some poor gentleman that appeared maybe to have, you know, cerebral palsy or some sort of ailment like that. So they had to take him out of the wheelchair, put him in a chair in the security lounge, and then use that wheelchair to go get the gentleman that also needed wheelchair access. So, I mean, which we won't even talk about.
2:21:54 ADD issues with that. So I really think that as part of our economic development, and Rhonda you can add to this, we talked a lot about, remember initially about what happens when flights cancel, what can we do as a group to provide alternative transportations, how do we make it positive, and now we've gone from one to seven flights. I just think that should be part of the scope of the economic development.
2:22:22 Well, I see it is here. It's actually on 21 has created a backup plan for canceled flights. I would expect that to be here. And what I'm seeing here is... But wait, sorry, 21 where? 21 on page 5-19. What this is, is this is not, again, this is a scope of work that we, it's not presenting the entire scope of work. It's where we're moving for. These are the goals and strategies.
2:22:45 That you have to supply tactics. I don't think that by any way this is comprehensive. And I am sorry, I apologize, I missed the meeting if we had, if there was consensus in that that TOT was the primary objective there in enforcement of that and that we were asking for funds to do that and setting that priority above everything else. And if that's where it was, I think then I would probably have to look at this a little closer because that's not where I would be.
2:23:11 personally voting for it. I think there's amazing work been done on the T.O.T. collection, but how if that I have different feelings on it as an individual and as a planning commissioner there I would have be presenting it as well, but if that's what the scope of the group believed that that's where it is we would find a way and would have to have tactics in there because now we're talking about funding.
2:23:36 These things directly from town, and that's where the recommendation would come from. I don't see that that particular document in any way said that we are ready to make those. I see this as this is the scope of work it's working on. These are the things that you expect to see delivery on at this time. And where we are moving forward then is absolutely addressing how we do these. But there's in no way do I see anything as fully developed.
2:24:05 But these are things that we brought forward that need addressing. And that's what we plan to do is get them addressed and come up with tactics and actions for these because these are the strategies. You know, improving the guest experience everywhere in town is...
2:24:22 It's a never-ending thing, and one particular action begets another one. You know, two wheelchairs sound simple. Evidently, it's not. I've been there for that very same issue there, and I'm thinking, hmm, I better get a wheelchair. I better get a wheelchair. But it's contributing that, yes, we better see what we have to do to get that wheelchair there. So where this is designed to be is that this is the agenda that we continue on this and we move it up to a more comprehensive level.
2:24:52 There's a lot of work to be done because some of these are really, you know, they're really big objectives here, but how do we make this pay off economically and provide the biggest bang for whatever buck, virtual or us, you know, actually putting dollars into that, and that's where we as a commission will then be making recommendations is here's where you can get the most for it. We do that.
2:25:21 I'm sorry, I'm not 100% sure that we're both talking about the same thing because my last comments were referring to page 5.6 which was the staff scope for their economic development program and that's what I just felt that because the economic development program has laid out these tasks and I just felt that those were the tasks.
2:25:49 That needed to have a little bit more detail to it. So I'm not sure if we're commenting on the same thing. Well, they don't have any detail at this point, and that's not what they were designed to do at this point. So my question, I mean, I hear a little bit of confusion about how best to meld the Economic Stemidus Council's work with the past work. How do we improve on that? Well, as being, you know, part of the, Dr. Seth's,
2:26:22 group there, I would be taking the goals and strategies that the economic stimulus group would bring forward and apply those to more definite actions within the Dr. SIDS because they were very large and now you're getting down to some real things that you can say these are the things that we need to address here.
2:26:50 As far as because a lot of it says there is we have visitor attracting events and things that you have in here which would include marketing, securing event sites, securing convention facilities, how the guest experiences these things and pulling them together in these categories that really allow you to take specific actions instead of
2:27:18 Instead of a shotgun approach, bringing them down to these things really matter, and that's where they belong in this. And you can execute them. Well, and you're both now in that committee, so presumably you'll both be working on... That's what it sounds like. Okay. It's, you know, it's taking all this material and funneling it. That's, that's where it really needs to be. Taking all the material and funneling it into the appropriate area so we can have an action on, a definite action on it.
2:27:48 Because I see, because these are a lot of, there are a lot of notes, but pulling it together, here's the right place for, you know, it's marketing and it's conventions, and it is the creation all along together in this particular area of Dr. Sed's, which supports, number four, support visitor attracting events. And it doesn't mean that we have to put them all on. It means that we have to have an environment that you can have those.
2:28:20 Would it be appropriate, after hearing this horror story from Mickey, and then thinking about my friend who couldn't find a caterer, and then the weather problems we have with flights being delayed or even canceled, to have one of these tasks as a question, how does this enhance the guest experience? Because Dr. Seds is all about ED, economic development, and if we don't have a positive guest experience, we don't have the economic development, and the return visitors are so much cheaper to bring here than the new visitors.
2:28:48 Should that be added as a task? As a task. Or just as a theme? Or should that be incorporated here in a very general sense? So are you talking about, you know, identifying the effects things like that have on certain things? Do you think that that's something that needs to be brought forward to people? You know, do they, you think, does the community realize those little things? How broad that effect is on that? So can't find a caterer.
2:29:17 Tells everyone that nobody returns calls here, that we actually don't have a work ethic. Do you think that that... No, I'm not saying that. I'm just thinking about things that we maybe haven't thought through, like only having one wheelchair. I mean, things that affect how the guest experiences their vacation in Mammoth, their time in Mammoth. And should we be keeping that in mind as we go through all these things? Absolutely.
2:29:45 Wow. I don't know if you write it down as a task? Well, I don't know. I mean, it's a full-on example. You can put that on the board, and you can see how far the effect of something like that goes. Yeah. And some may blow it off, and others just go, how far reaching does do things like that go? And maybe that task is identifying that even the smallest interaction
2:30:10 Or what you may think is a small interaction has the ripple effect. And that's maybe identifying the ripple effect in the community. And I think that's valid from the standpoint of the economic stimulus group is addressing the ripple effect of how everything is connected. And I think that's what's come out of this with the contributions from
2:30:38 From Chuck and from Mickey there, realizing that, oh my goodness, didn't realize that touched you. The decision that was made over here touched over here. And now we're seeing that had an economic effect as well. So I think if anything coming out of this is that it puts you all there together and you can't do one thing that doesn't affect everyone else. That makes you much more cognizant to what you're doing and asking is it the right thing.
2:31:07 Okay. It's a very good point. I think that's what we found, getting everybody in the room going, I didn't even think of that, but now it's glaring me in the face. And then, you know, going back to the ambassador program and the hospitality training and all those things. Well, is there some way with maybe community indicators report that we could have something to do? I thought the most exciting thing that I read back in the back with the...
2:31:32 from the Economic Stimulus Council was the better guest experience, page 518 and 19. There were things that have never been mentioned before, but I agree with Elizabeth that making our visitors happy, making them feel welcome, I mean, to me, that's just a, maybe it should be a task somehow. Those were exciting things that were...
2:31:57 I think that they hadn't been mentioned outside the particular scope of people who work with it every day. You know, it kind of was lingo to where insiders knew about it, but now that they're sharing it with others and realizing it had an effect. You know, working with Mickey's, we had...
2:32:14 Realizing how TOT affects the real estate industry, how occupancy and ADR have an effect on the real estate market. If you have a low ADR coming to town, are they potential buyers? And if we don't know if they're potential buyers, do we even have the right product for that buyer? And if we're not sharing a level of information, we're all making decisions that are not really important. I agree with you. Where can we?
2:32:45 Mr. Landy, do you have anything you'd like to contribute? I encourage you to vote on this, pass it through, encourage council to hear it as quickly as possible, because what this sort of evolved in, we had a zillion meetings, and it did come up with the staff report the center put together that was great, but it is...
2:33:10 You know, it's more policy. It says, okay, here are a bunch of things. Now let's go get in the detail. Quite frankly, a bunch of us thought when we started we were going to get in the detail, but it had to be apparently broken in two different spots. So, you know, we've been at it for two months. I think a lot of us hope that we would be finished by now because we don't want to have the results after we've come out of the recession. We want to have all the tools from monetary things to things that you're talking about.
2:33:38 As we come out to make sure that we maximize our position. So coming out of your approval would hopefully mean a quick one from the town council, which would hopefully mean CFFC starting up again, some of these other little small groups starting up again so we can tackle it quickly, get results quickly, and come back and have tools and policies to work with. So, you know me, the epitome of patience. I think all the things you talked about are great, but we need that.
2:34:07 We need to get it on and get it approved so we can get into all that detail because we were kind of included from doing that. Thanks. Is this for the council on the 5th? Yes. Good. And just a comment on the guest experience topic. You know, of course, the guest experience is important, very important to economic development, economic stimulus, and I think it's kind of interwoven in all of these tasks.
2:34:31 And the intent in providing the ESC's comments is to let the group know, let the Planning Commission and Council know what they came up with, which there's a lot of great ideas in there, a lot of new things, and a lot of things we can build on. And those could be things that we either build into the future, Dr. said, the update, or things that we tell, you know.
2:34:51 Direct other people to do at this point. I mean, the ESC is committed to doing some of these tasks on their own. They've committed to preparing the community indicators report. There may be other tasks that won't be done by the town that would be done by the chamber or some other group that's part of the ESC. So I think that these tasks hopefully will all be accomplished in time. And so I think that it's just kind of a broad
2:35:20 Broad, you know, group of comments, and we will incorporate them as needed into the Dr. Sett's program, so. Where I think that we, I think that the outline and detail, you know, it's very, it's very direct, very specific, and to Sharon's point, it doesn't have a lot of commentary about, you know, what you're supposed to do with this. Maybe if we look at the background paragraph and add a few things to that, I think that one of the biggest things that came out of it is this over,
2:35:49 Arching effect of certain areas are now working together and realize their decisions are, their particular actions are affecting other areas that they didn't even know about. And I think that is so important. And that's how we've come to, you know, that's where it came from, the economic indicators report, where that came from, because that's something that had been a
2:36:14 A goal of mine for probably 15 years, but it was being addressed only through the tourism and the lodging end of it, and it had a completely different focus there as what it does to the rest of the community, to where, you know, retail and restaurant staff, according to the occupancies report, then, you know, the real estate communities just...
2:36:38 Determines when is the best time for a target-rich environment based on the occupancy. And if that is three days late and, you know, is past history, it does nobody any good. And what we discovered, it wasn't just lodging to fill those rooms, it's how the rest of the town operates. And it takes this from...
2:36:59 You know, taking us out of a reactive mode all the time. And we're great firefighters, but maybe we took a little bit about fire prevention, you know, plan ahead and we wouldn't be running, we wouldn't be running around doing these things, catch up all the time. So if you look at background, I would, you know, be happy to work with you or Mark because working on this a long time, and this is what I see walking into it.
2:37:24 Was a lot of valuable information of how these things are affecting each other. And that's what I, that would be the, why are we bothering with this? Because we've done a lot of this work before, but now we're connecting it. I think that would be something that council would need to know. What's the value of it? Is it helping Mickey's industry? Is it helping, you know, John Morris? Is it helping the Chamber of Commerce? Because if it's not helping, we're wasting our time.
2:37:53 Very quickly, you said economic indicators report. Should it be, should that be there instead of community? No, no, I think community is fine because there's a variety of things. It's not just even us. It broadened. Okay. It broadened, you know, there was things that I was looking at specifically and we added to that, which were, you know, community things that knowing how many, you know, if you ask five people, you're going to get five different answers on how many hotbeds we have in town. Okay.
2:38:23 What is full? We all think we know what full is, but it's different on July 4th as it is on December 28th. But to answer your question explicitly, the report includes unemployment, it includes transit ridership, so it includes bank deposits. Okay, so it's community. She said something about economic indicators. That's not what this is. That was something that I was looking for when it was through tourism.
2:38:50 And we added that we came together, those included certain things, now it's even broader in community. Okay. I guess one of my questions is, this is so similar to me, and maybe it's because I'm outside the real estate industry and the business community, they are so similar, five and six, where am I missing something?
2:39:18 Both of these are scopes of work. This is the CIP. Why don't we go through six and then talk about that if you're still... To me, they have a lot to do with each other and I just wondered if there's some way we could combine, I don't know. At any rate, okay. The other thing I just wanted to say, this recession is sort of a double-edged sword because we would not have been able to do any of this had we had projects coming.
2:39:48 And this is so necessary, so long awaited, that, you know, I almost want to say, thank God we have a recreation so we can get our ducks in a row. Now we're ready for time. I mean, am I missing something? Or, I mean, we really couldn't have done any of this, could we? I mean, you people know.
2:40:08 Kind of. Sharon, I'm looking forward to the day when we can have a secondary town brand or logo, which would be a ketchup bottle inside a red circle with a red line through it. No more ketchup, you know. We're moving out. That's what I look forward to. I just think this is great, and I've just been glad we're finally getting here. That's all I do. Then are we ready to move it forward? Absolutely. Well, I want to just
2:40:37 The staff really want us to say we just have two phases. I mean, that was the one kind of big. Yes. That makes sense to me. To me, too. So I would, with that modification, I would send this along to council with all due speed. Well, I'm all excited about getting it done. So moved.
2:41:07 Option 1. Option 1. Is that close enough? Yes. Yes, that's fine. All those in favor? Aye. If we can get a second. I'll second that. Thank you. Oh, I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'll second that. Thank you. All those in favor? Aye. Aye. All those opposed? Motion carries unanimous. Gend item 6 is the 5-year capital improvement program and public facilities and finance plan work program and scope of work.
2:41:40 Yes. Ms. Daugherty. Thank you, Chair. The purpose of this agenda bill is for the Planning Commission to review the scope of work for the five-year CIP and PFFP work program. This, again, as the other scopes of work you've looked at today, will go to Council on October 5th, and we'll report out any comments you have verbally to the Council at that meeting.
2:42:04 The purpose of the PFFP is to adopt an integrated and reconciled plan for the town's prioritization, funding, construction, operation and maintenance of all existing and future public facilities. The PFFP will allow the town to make more deliberate and well-informed decisions about financing public facilities, the cost for maintaining and operating those facilities into the future.
2:42:33 and how to prioritize those facilities based on strategic funding opportunities and available maintenance capacity as well. This strategy will allow the town to avoid financial missteps, reduce lost opportunities, be adaptive to changing conditions and to attract investment. The PFFP program builds on the CFFC or the Capital Facilities Finance Committee which
2:43:03 completed work in 2009 and 2010. The PFFP really will focus on compiling numerous public facilities that we have identified in various policy documents, district studies, rec strats, the general plan, masters and specific plans, and looking at forecasting these facilities over a long range, over a 20-year period.
2:43:31 The PFFP for this work program is running in parallel with the five-year CIP. The five-year CIP is looking at a more short-term approach and strategy to public facilities, looking at those near-term facilities identified in the PFFP document, looking at both asset management in terms of maintenance and operations of existing facilities, as well as
2:44:00 funding and constructing new capital facilities. Both the PFFP and CIP program this year will include a transparent process involving the public as well as all commissions. Specifically, we will be bringing facilities focused to each commission to that commission. For instance, the recreation commission will look specifically at recreation facilities listed in both the PFFP and the CIP.
2:44:31 We will also be, or the council will also be appointing a committee for this process, which we expect will include representatives from council, from all the commissions, and as well as representation from the previous CFFC committee and the Blue Ribbon Diff committee. Those committees have all already done extensive work and are familiar with some of the financing opportunities and strategies with the methods of funding.
2:44:59 Public facilities and it would be important and desirable to keep some of that consistency with that group. The draft work program, the scope of work is laid out in detail in your attachment one. It is laid out on a time frame based on broken down by months and will track with the annual budget process. The CFP or PFFP is different than the CIP in that it is an upfront one time effort.
2:45:31 that will be revisited less frequently than the annual CIP, which is reviewed annually, adopted by council annually, to decide how to appropriate funds for public facilities in the upcoming fiscal year. As part of this process, it's also important that we revisit development impact fees, which I've heard mentioned today already. We'll be looking at updating the five-year DIF study.
2:46:01 As well as addressing the issues and considerations related to the Nexus study and other considerations that have been brought up in the past related to DIF so that DIF can be adjusted as appropriate after we complete this PFFP and CIP work program. With that, if you have any questions, I'd be happy to answer them.
2:46:28 Mr. Bertasconi is here and he has extensive experience with the CIP process as well. And we would recommend that you recommend the scope of work be adopted with any modifications by the Council. Jen, on page handwritten 6-3, under Commission and Public Involvement, why did you feel the need to use the word transparent? Isn't that implied? It's implied. We want to make sure that this is
2:47:00 A very open, welcoming process for comments to make sure that we aren't missing anything, that we're incorporating all our facilities. And I think it's going to be important to be very transparent when we get to options for funding of the facilities and how those are prioritized. I think that's going to be a very lively debate and it'll be very important to be...
2:47:25 Clear and open with the public and all the commissions on how that will be done. I take issue with that word. It's sort of weighted. Could you possibly use inclusive or open or some other word than transparent? Because by definition, using it there implies what we have been doing. Here to four is not transparent and that would not be good. So that's my only question. More questions, comments? I like inclusive, Elizabeth. Inclusive, community-based.
2:47:59 If that, yeah, I kind of agree, transparent makes it sound like we haven't been. That wasn't my intention. I know it was. Oh, no, we know that. We know that. How it'll be taken. But interpretation may sound different. I like inclusive too. Jen, do you see that there would be any, would we be following the process any differently? Just, you know, public involvement. We would be looking at it doing the very same way, is that? Right. Okay.
2:48:32 And anyone can approach staff with questions and input at any time. At any time. So maybe we don't need either one of those. That may have been Elizabeth's point. Do we really need it? Since it says public involvement at the end. You know, I think it relates back to some of the discussion previously with the measure art process and that so that this process is fully open to the public and some people don't feel like they're left out. So I think that's...
2:49:04 Part of the reason for that. That's why I like the word inclusive. That works much better for me. Maybe community-based is quite sufficient. Do you think? I'll hold up or have a strong feeling of Cedar Way. I think the intent's clear, whichever one you use. More questions, comments? Page 6-1, Joint Commission Workshop on the Draft Resort.
2:49:40 Investment Element. Again, did we leave out community? Resort Community Investment Element? Surely it's a community investment. Where did that end up, Rhonda, the title of that element? I'm trying to remember. I thought it was Director Rozier. We're not just going to. We can confirm the title of that with Mark. It had three initiatives. Okay. Well, maybe that should have come up before, but we definitely are.
2:50:13 Community. I can check that with Mark. Make sure we get the title correct. It's the SEDS without the PhD. Definitely. So from my benefit, so my understanding, the reason we're doing this scope of work now with the improvement and the facilities and finance plan is because you're going to take all these documents that you have out there.
2:50:44 Basically update them, put them in a comprehensive new document, update? Well, we're taking our existing documents and compiling the facilities from those documents into one document. And it's really replacing our master's facilities plan, which has done that in the past. However, we have had a lot of new master plans and updates. We just had the trail system master plan update. So we're looking at having a comprehensive
2:51:14 Catalog, essentially, of all our public facilities and ensure that they're scoped consistently and described consistently in one place. And then that can help us build annually and update our CIP every year. Okay. Which you're mandated to do, because doesn't this help streamline that process as well? Yes. Thank you. And again, this is something that we needed, just a plain capital investment program for a while.
2:51:43 It's important to make informed decisions, understanding the scope of public facilities that are programmed or anticipated in the future, understanding where the funding is for each of those so we can make strategic and well-informed decisions so we aren't... Yeah, so they aren't isolated decisions. Exactly. Comments, questions? No.
2:52:09 I just want to say that I really appreciate the dates, the doc, you know, that we have here, that it does put it in a benchmark, continual benchmarks. I really like that. It's very clear and concise. I'm sorry, Elizabeth, I want to call you again. I'm just, again, so glad that we're finally getting things in black and white. I'll be quiet now.
2:52:36 And it's amazing we're doing that with, you know, such limited staff time. It's really incredible. I move that we approve, were there any modifications? Yes, there were, eliminating transparent, although was there consensus to eliminate transparent and substitute inclusive? Substitute inclusive? It's clear to me. Anyway, option one, the draft work program scope of work for the capital improvement program, public facilities and finance plan, and forward to the town council for review and direction.
2:53:05 Second. We do. All those in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Mission carries 5-0. Okay. Briefing matters is next. We have none. Director's report. Work program status, no materials or report. Was that written before Mark knew he wouldn't be here, or when are you going to get that? I don't have a report for you today. Okay. Okay. Future agenda items?
2:53:37 Nothing there. Announcement of future special meetings. The only comment I have is that your next meeting will be a joint meeting with the other commissions, and it's actually on this topic, CIP PFFP. Okay. So that will be October 12th. Okay. Second comment from the public session. We have no public here, so we will adjourn to the next regular, well, the next meeting, which will be a joint meeting for October 12th.