Town Council
· recording 2 hr 13 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
283 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:14 For that? This is yours, young fella? No, that's good. Call to order the regular meeting of the Town Council of Mammoth Lakes for September 7, 2011. I would first like to report that there are no actions to announce from the closed session that we had earlier this evening. Roll call please, Robin. Councilmember Eastman? Here. Councilmember Harvey? Here.
2:18 Councilmember Wood, here. Mayor Pro Tem, Layman, here. Mayor Bacon, here. Rick, would you lead us in the salute, please? Certainly. If you would please rise and join me in the Pledge of Allegiance. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
2:49 The next item on our agenda is public comments, and I'd like everyone to take a quick moment to notice that there is now a little timer on the edge of the town clerk's desk that will count down the time, so when you see it go to red, your time is up. I'm sorry, what was it? I think the rest of the room will probably let you know.
3:19 So, if there's anyone who wishes to comment on items that are not part of tonight's agenda, please come forward, and the timer is set for five minutes. Good evening, council, staff, and public. My name is Joe Perino here from MammothMotocross.org, that's not .com, and .com is the mountains, races, and events. I'm here just to share with the community.
3:53 And the OHV people in our area, that Transworld Motocross Magazine has our motocross race in it. I brought this up before, just let everybody know that September edition does have the motocross race in it. We did get a five-page spread out of it. And this magazine is international. So I think it's a great disclosure to us.
4:23 And then I wanted to thank John Urdi for this little event thing here. He also put the motocross in here in this event, which is great. The problem is now is I'm getting a lot of phone calls and emails from people from all over wanting to come ride the track. And I have to let them know that, I'm sorry, that our track is closed. There's a gate there, and the only time you can go to a race, it would be in June. And it's kind of sad that I have to turn these people away.
4:53 But one thing I did do, what was really good, was over the weekend, I put on an event. I had 20 people come from San Diego and took them out on dirt bike tours. They were going to stay for five days. They dropped a lot of money in town. They brought a lot of money to our town, gas taxes, food supplies, restaurants, which was another revenue builder for our area.
5:25 Another thing, too, another reason why I'm up here is what I'm trying to find out is on 395, you have these little icon signs of what our areas offer. You have tents, fishing, bicycles, you know. One thing that thing is missing is motorcycles. And I'd like to see whatever you take. Maybe I'll talk to John Urdi. Maybe I'll talk to Skip Harvey about this.
5:54 I talked to Dave Wilberg about this. What it would take for us to be able to get icons, a motorcycle icon on that 395. So people know that we have OHV in this area. I've had so many people at the campgrounds come up to me and ask me, you have OHV in there? You can ride a motorcycle here? I had CTUC maps, I gave them maps, I gave them a lot of information, gave them my business cards. Anytime that you need information, call me.
6:22 I'd be more than happy to take you out, give you some tours, guide you around so you don't get lost, and to enhance our OHV. Right now it's perfect timing. We've got clouds. We're going to be fall. Clouds are coming in. It's cooling down. The sun's in a little different position. Perfect time for OHV. And unfortunately our town is dead. And I'd like to see if it's possible we can start marketing these months.
6:51 Pretty much from now until November, December. Get that marketing going to show that we really enhance our OHV in this area. That's with rhinos, quads, group bikes, whatever it takes to get those people up here. To get the gas taxes, to get the lodging, get the TOT, to get the restaurants, get the retail stores. Everybody wins with OHVs in the neighborhood. Any questions? I have a question for you, Joe.
7:22 Have you thought of maybe starting some sort of an event or a ride or something to have that grow in the fall season? I mean, a lot of times, especially during the fall, we're really looking for people to step forward and step up to kind of create these things. That's a great question. That's a great question, Matt. You know, I'm kind of still working on that. I'm still kind of new to the trail stuff because, like I said, I'm more of a motocross guy.
7:50 And due to, I really have another choice, because I don't have a tractor, I do have to ride the trails. I am getting together with other agencies. Dick Allen does an event in October. He brings probably close to 100 people here. He comes out of Sierra Nevada, which is the Sierra Safari Race ride, which is great. Jerry Counts has actually brought another ride back to Mammoth. He's got a very good network of these guys, of a lot of your dual sport riders.
8:19 Which are dirt bikes with plates on them, so they can go on the street too, which makes it real convenient. Okay, Joe, it's now on the red light. Oh, okay. Thank you. Thank you, Matt. We don't have a buzzer, but we might add that. Thank you. Good evening. My name is John Wentworth with MLTPA. And a couple of quick announcements. The final Summer of Stewardship event will be this Sunday in Convict Lake, September 11th.
8:49 Appreciate there's this very significant golf tournament. That day you guys might not be able to make that. But for you all, for the public, it's the final event. There's a knockout barbecue lunch that the Convict Lake Resort puts on at noon. It's probably the best meal you get this summer, but if you can make it, great. But there will be some events happening in the fall. Very excited to announce, I think we're going to be building a trail on September 24th, National Public Lands Day.
9:17 From where the tunnel goes underneath Lake Murray Road up to the Panorama Dome Trail. This is one of the recommendations from the SHRM, the SHRM Area Recreation Plan. The SHRM Working Group put this idea together. It's a modest effort but a very important connector. So if there's time on your calendar that day, you can come out and throw some dirt around and get a very important piece of trail built on that weekend. And there's also going to be an event for the mountain bike community for the Mountain View Trail. We're getting some dates firmed up with Frenzadino and their stewardship crew to take up.
9:46 Maintenance pass on that trail. So important, interesting things are happening. I'll be back when you guys have your next meeting in October to give you an update on the Mammoth Lakes Tourism inaugural documents of authority, and I look forward to that. Thank you. John, the mountain bike trail, where is that going to be at? That's the Mountain View Trail. Mountain View. And we're splitting it up. We're going to do the actual event will be during the week because a lot of people in the mountain bike community work in shops and stuff over the weekend. So we're going to try to like a Wednesday afternoon between about 3 and 6.
10:15 Friends of the NU has a student corps coming out of Stanford University, I think, that will do a full sweep of the entire trail probably sometime next week. And then we'll have some specific projects, some bridge building and specific kind of heavy lifting maintenance chores to do. And we'll make an announcement on that when that's going to happen. Thank you. Any other questions? Thank you, John. Thank you very much. Oh, wait. John, just the Mountain View Trail you're referring to, is that the one up on the mountain?
10:44 It's the one that goes from, you know, the overlook up past Main Lodge. The beach. It runs north of 203 all the way down to the earthquake fault. Okay. Okay. It's very popular. Yeah, so you're on the north side of 203, the mountain view that's over there, the extension. Exactly. The public non-bike park. Yeah. Okay. Thank you. All right. Thank you, John.
11:08 Good evening, Elizabeth Tenney, volunteer organizer for the Mammoth Gateway Community Project. I understand you'll be talking about wayfinding, community messaging in the gateway at your October 5th meeting, and I can't be there, and I haven't seen you since March to talk about this, so I thought I'd give you a quick update tonight. The project is going so well. I mean, the support that's coming forward is just phenomenal, and I'm very, very encouraged by it.
11:32 After I talked to you, it was either March 12th or March 15th, I met with Rusty at the mountain because I knew I couldn't make this project happen without a lot of in-kind support. And Rusty said, oh, this is great, Elizabeth, but it's not grand enough. We need to do it on both sides. So the workload and the time doubled right there. But we're working together, and it's really going to be good.
11:54 The conceptual design is done for the north side. In fact, I'm going to give you a copy of our fundraising brochure. These are the first five off the press, realizing, of course, this is conceptual. It goes before the Planning Commission for a sign permit and design review on the 28th of September, and then it will come to you at your next meeting. But we have a lot of plans for fundraising beyond direct contribution. There will be a band of...
12:22 Bronze plaques are on the base of the sign, which is going to be a design element, and the major donors will have a bronze plaque. There will be personal papers. We're getting engraved bricks. This was Chief Watson's suggestion. It was really a good one, so we'll be able to pave a path up to the monument on the south side. The Water District has volunteered with a little encouragement.
12:46 To install and maintain a demonstration garden of native plants, the courthouse is going to supply the water through their irrigation meter, which will be a huge savings. And, of course, this entire project is private donations and in-kind support. So, you know, that really, really made a difference. Another thing we've come up with, there'll be several fundraisers, including, there'll be several at the Bluffs in October.
13:09 And then Jim Demetriatus has agreed when he has the grand opening of his new restaurant, Red Lantern, it will be a big fundraiser for the Gateway. So there will be a lot of other events throughout the winter. We're also encouraging people who want to help out, to invite friends for dinner, and then give them a bill for dinner, which would be a tax-deductible donation to the Gateway. So we think there will be all kinds of stuff. Larry Walker, who designed the monument, is going to do a poster.
13:37 And of course, since Larry's doing it, you know it's going to be great, but a promotional poster that we're going to put all over town, the mountain, everywhere, in time for the Christmas holidays with all kinds of information on how you can donate. We have a website, we have email, we have a brochure, and the permit, building permit application went in today for the South Monument. The signed permit application has gone in, and we're just...
14:03 Going along, just gangbusters. It's just wonderful. I'm really, really pleased. So I'd like to give you the first copies and realize this is conceptual because the north side we have to apply to the Forest Service and, you know, the things that have to be done. But give you some idea of what we're after. Thank you, Elizabeth. Are there questions for Elizabeth? No. Thank you. Thank you, Elizabeth. Thank you, Elizabeth. All right.
14:46 I think we have some more people wanting to speak. Madam Mayor, members, John Urdi from Mammoth Lakes Tourism. I just wanted to give you a little quick update on where we're at. And just mentioned to Joe, we'll chat about the signs on the highway as it being a Caltrans challenge. But I just wanted to bring up a couple things. As we all know, it is getting into the slower season here now that we're past Labor Day. And one of the big things that we've done to really try and...
15:18 Keep the business coming as we put together the Eastern Sierra Fishing Coalition. And the idea behind that was to bring back the Eastern Sierra to where it should be from a fishing standpoint. And with the coalition, we met about a month ago and talked about having what we're calling the second summer. Seeing as that from opening day of fishing season to 4th of July, we really didn't have a first summer. So we're calling Labor Day, don't know, November 15th, the second summer. And with that, we're putting together a tagged fish derby.
15:46 Here in the Eastern Sierra, not only Mammoth Lakes, but throughout the region. And in partnership with Western Outdoors News, we just put together a 20-page supplement that's being distributed through their entire network. And as you can see, we've got the back page for Mammoth Lakes. Interior front page is Mono County. And this is very much in conjunction with Mono County to make this happen.
16:10 Western Outdoors News went out and solicited their partners to get prizes. We've got about 1,800 prizes for people to catch fish, and it could be something as little as a lure. And the grand prize is actually a 15-foot Greger boat with a mercury outboard on it and a trailer. So we've got some great stuff, and the boat will be in town next week. We're going to kind of parade it around from shop to shop and make sure folks know it's out there. It can be won via the tag derby, or it can also be won via a raffle. So we're actually selling tickets.
16:38 With the idea that the funds from that will go towards fish stocking within the eastern Sierra. So exciting stuff there. Last week I attended a U.S. travel event in Salt Lake City and had the great opportunity to sit down with folks from U.S. travel and American Express, and we've contracted with them to do a quarterly report for us. Moving forward here, every quarter we'll get a report, and basically what it is is it's where American Express holders have spent their money in town.
17:04 And it'll break it out from lodging to dining to activities to services, the whole nine yards. And what we've done is we've actually commissioned two of those reports, one domestic and one international, so we can figure out our top markets, where they're spending money, how much they're spending, the whole nine yards. So we'll get that on a quarterly basis. And we also commissioned them to do a report on air service. And what they'll do is they'll track folks that use their American Express card to purchase an airline ticket from LAX2.
17:28 Mammoth. We'll track back to what their origination airport was, and we'll be able to track exactly where they spent their money when they came here throughout the county, so not just Mammoth. And it's a pretty amazing tool that we have, and I was concerned that we wouldn't have a great sample size, but this summer we've had over 2,600 people that have purchased their flight with an American Express card, so we'll follow those people, whether they're at the one alley deli or they're up at the mountains, so we'll be able to tell where they've spent the money, so that'll be a great tool for us moving forward.
17:56 On the research side also, we've been doing surveys throughout town. We've got a lodging survey that's out there that the lodging properties are issuing to their guests. I've been getting a number of those back in the mail. People that don't fill them out right in front of them, they actually mail them back to us. We've been doing them at the major events. We've got them at the airport. We've got them in the rental car envelopes when people pick up their cars. And then we've also got the taxis doing exit interviews. So when they pick someone up and they're taking them to the airport, they've got clipboards and pencils.
18:26 In the taxis to be able to get people's feedback as to where they went, what they did, how long they were here, what they spent, the whole nine yards. We are still in the process of finishing our guidebooks for next year, the four-season guidebooks. We had a great meeting today, a great envelope-stuffing event for the TOT this morning. Thanks to everybody who participated in that. And then just lastly, the World Championships last week in Daegu, South Korea.
18:53 We had six athletes that went. All six of our athletes made it to the finals in their respective field, which was phenomenal. Unfortunately, Morgan Yuseni, who should have been the 1,500-meter world champion after the running that she's been doing lately, she was tripped up in the start. So very proud of the team. They're all due back here in the next few weeks, but great accomplishments. Thank you. Any questions of John? Thank you. Okay. Anyone else?
19:24 Leslie, I think we're going to have to ask you to move that camera someplace else. Good evening. My name is Lee Gosh. I'm here this evening. I live in Sierra Valley Sites. Sierra Valley Sites is a very complex area. We need a town code enforcer. I know staff keeps telling me they're doing an excellent job and we don't need one. I disagree. We need a town code enforcer. For the last two weeks, I am completely focused on Sierra Valley Sites.
20:01 I have taken a lot of pictures of dumpster spills all over our whole area for the two weeks. People leaving couches out. There's one here where a cushion was burned yesterday. Our town could have burned down if that would have really caught a fire. That is the second one at Sierra Valley sites that's happened. The other one was on Joaquin. This one was on Lupin Street. The side of affordable housing on the front each road.
20:24 All the signs were twisted and bent over sideways, and there was cars parked on the town easement. That is right beside their bedroom windows. I am not for affordable housing in town, but I'm protecting them because they're in Sierra Valley sites. Cars are parking right beside their bedroom windows. I asked the town to put these signs up, and they put one up that says, three of them says, no stopping any time. There's cars parked right beside their bedroom windows. They were unable to fix the signs for about a week because they were doing Meridian Street.
20:53 But the sad thing is we want to be a destination resort. Our guests saw all those signs bent up backwards sideways. Then there are some other things. I've given it to the fire department. I'll give them the cushion that was burned. They're pushing those yellow things over with the cement out of the ground around the fire hydrants now. So now the fire department has to go around and fix those. And Sierra Valley Sites needs help. You ask us to call for compliance only. Now you're pinning neighbors against neighbors doing that.
21:23 We need somebody out driving around watching compliance. We have pouches everywhere right now. We have furniture everywhere. It is where the working people went, and we'd like to have some respect in this area and have the town show us that we are valued in this town. When it comes to our wildlife, I was looking through the paper. There is no information whatsoever of educating people about wildlife and about the dumpster spills and protecting our wildlife in this town.
21:52 Labor Day show, what happened to the guy last year, and the bear that got into the dumpster at the courthouse. I would like to see an outrage of education in this town to protect our wildlife. It's not just the bear. They get in too much trouble in this town. There's coyotes out there. There's raccoons. There's all kinds of animals out there. And I'd like to see, what does the town do? How do we know when you find somebody or when you contact somebody?
22:17 Can you have a thing in the paper saying where you've been notifying people so that people will know that you're actually on top of this and these people know they have to start picking up because they're going to be put in the paper? There is absolutely nothing in the paper. And then, if I may, please, I'm not going to be able to stay at 10 o'clock. May I speak on Consent Agenda 11?
22:38 That is not a consent agenda item. That is a policy matter. No, I'm sorry. We will probably not be that late tonight, but no, you cannot speak on something that's on the agenda. Can you mark that? Minutes, please. And I'll give you the paper and the pictures that I have. Thanks. Thank you for the segue, Lee. A quick report on wildlife and issues. In regards to one year ago at the Labor Day Arts Festival,
23:27 There was the issue with gentlemen and the people feeding the young bear. I certainly do want to have deja vu. The arts festival went off without a hitch this year. I was really well attended. A great event. I spent a bunch of time over there. On Saturday, with a full crowd, I looked up in the tree above me, and there was a sow and two baby cubs sleeping in the tree. They seemed to be watching the kettle corn, is what I think.
23:53 You guys know me. I spent the whole day there. And not one of our guests, the whole theme of the arts festival this year was the bear. And so the three bears left the festival, spent the whole day in the tree above them. Not one person saw them.
24:09 I waited until the late evening when everyone had left and all the vendors had left. The bears came down. We didn't give them the kettle corn and they left the area. The place was well policed. The vendors did a good job. There was no food or baiting to the bears. And so a huge success compared to last year and what we went through. But how ironic that the bears would feel comfortable sleeping there in the forest while the event was going on. In regards to the situation that's going on with the bears right now, it's really going really good.
24:38 Is there always room for improvement? You bet. The other day, out of 450 dumpsters, we had four that were hit in town. Four too many. Each one of them, you know, we follow up on, respond to those calls, and take whatever measures are needed to correct that. But all of us have lived here a long time. We remember what it used to be. My congratulations and thanks to the whole community for all the effort and really the huge amount of voluntary compliance that's going on on the streets.
25:07 We do have an active bear, a three-year-old little brown-on-brown bear. If you live out on the Red Fur Hill Street in that area adjacent to Valentine Reserve, the bear's pretty active. Leave your door open and leave for a few hours.
25:24 A lot of people are leaving their doors open or sliding glass doors open, go in and steal an apple, went in and stole a bag of peanuts off of a table and left the building. We take it in stride, but it's not good. It's not a funny thing. And so by Halloween, our bears are about 22 hours in the den.
25:43 And so we just have a short window of time. It's been a fantastic year. More bears than ever, less problems than ever. And so I would just encourage everybody to keep it up, keep doing the right thing. To answer some of these questions, my phone rings constantly. We follow up on every single call, whether it's a perceived call or a perceived threat, or if it's a real situation when it's still trash, every single call is followed up on without exception.
26:12 So 937 Bayer, everybody knows my phone number, will continue to do that work, and I just want to thank everybody for their help and cooperation with all the animals in our community. Last thing, out of the seven deer that were in the bucks, the massive bucks that were in the herd that enjoy the bell-shaped parcel, over to the golf course, out of seven, the fourth out of seven was killed Saturday night.
26:37 On Meridian Boulevard, all four of those magnificent breeding bucks have been killed on Meridian Boulevard. So we don't have a lot of tourists left. It's just locals. It was local that hit the deer the other night. It was very regretful, but it did happen. So just a word to the wise. It's very, very dark out there. A lot of animals. And if we have guests or family coming up, you know, just keep encouraging people to slow down and watch out for that wildlife. Any questions, Ms. Mayor?
27:05 Steve, is there any way we can highlight that area on Meridian to educate people, highlight it in the way of signs so that we educate people to know that because there is a traffic pattern there. I want to spray the road with six-foot ladders like they do in the Tour de France. The chief has advised me to knock it off and not do that.
27:30 They're accidents. So we've done a great job. We've got great signage out there. Will accidents continue to happen in life? Yeah, bad things happen to good people. But I just, gosh, if we hadn't done those preemptive measures, how many more animals would have been killed? So it's hard to judge the successes. I'm relating to a failure.
27:53 I think we're doing fantastic. These were accidents. But just a word to the wise, I don't want anybody getting hurt and certainly try to spare our wildlife. So I don't know what other measures we could take this year, but maybe for next year we've got some more signage.
28:07 Any other questions? Yes, sir. You know, Steve, why don't you get a decoy and just kind of move it around out there alongside the road so when they're driving down they see it and they stop real quick and they go, oh, okay, and they keep on going. That's a great idea. I meet with a group every week and they've got some other funny ideas. We want to chalk the outline of the dead animals. There you go. But we don't want to put our guests off. It's funny and I appreciate the humor, but again, we don't want to see anybody get hurt or anything like that.
28:36 I'll use good judgment. Steve, is that area west of Minaret? It is. West of Minaret is correct. The last of the bucks were this side of Minaret on Saturday night and got T-Bone crossing over to the golf course. The 5x8 is still alive. The 4x3 is alive. It was the big, magnificent 3x3 bowl that was destroyed. I'm sorry I ended on a negative note. Thank you for your time. We all need to know that. Thank you.
29:05 Okay. Is there anyone else wishing to speak during public comment? In that case, we will move on to Councilmember Reports. John? I have none. Thank you. Okay. Skip? I have none. Rick? I'll defer to you for the meeting that we attended. Okay. Matthew? I just have a couple quick ones. Two of them I'm actually going to defer off to Mark Wardlaw, which will be...
29:33 A little discussion on T.O.T. enforcement and then the other on the Economic Stimulus Council. Some progress we've made there. Two areas I would like to discuss are just the events. It sounds to me, just from what I've been hearing around town, talking to restaurateurs, hoteliers and whatnot, that this summer has been phenomenal as far as attendance to these various events and I think everybody getting behind it has been a proven success.
30:00 I was fortunate to work with the Chamber of Commerce specifically on the Mammoth Rocks event. They've taken that event over, taken charge of that with the help of Mark D's number of other volunteers and team captains, and they just, they did a great job of driving folks to that. Also wanted to thank Mammoth Mountain Ski Area for their first inaugural mud run event, which turned out to be another tremendous success, real exciting, seems like it really energized a lot of people.
30:30 It was a four-mile run. You walked up. When you finally got up to Canyon Lodge, started in the village, it just looked like the Baton Death March with people trying to get up the hill. It was tough, but I think people really enjoyed it. If you get on Facebook or the Internet now, you're starting to see a lot more of Mammoth all over there with some of these summer events. I wanted to thank them for putting that together. That was a great success.
30:56 There's been a number of other groups coming to town, specifically some auto groups and the Goldwing group and a few others, and they've been coming to town for a long time, and there's a wide variety of these groups coming and growing up here, and I'd like to see if there's not a way as we move forward that we can't encourage them to keep coming here.
31:18 And specifically, one thing I did last year with this Minnie Cooper group that came up was went there and spoke to these folks and later had heard that they just really appreciate the fact that a council member had gone in there. And I know Joe's been doing the same thing and a lot of other council members have done the same in the past.
31:38 And I'm just wondering if moving forward if we can't come up with some sort of certificate of appreciation that we regularly hand out without having to come to council each time and maybe something from council or from the mayor to regularly do that. I'm not exactly sure what the protocol is, but I've spoken with Dave a little bit about it and just hoping that we can work with Mammoth Lakes Tourism to know when they're coming and perhaps just try to meet these folks and give them a thank you. And that's about it.
32:07 Thank you, Matthew. Just a few items to report. On the 19th, Matthew and I attended another planning session for a countywide group that is planning a Veterans Day celebration on November 11th to actually honor our veterans, as we say on the signs, entering our county. There's another meeting, I believe, on the 16th? Something like that.
32:35 On the 30th, Rick and I attended a planning meeting as the recreation subcommittee with the recreation commission and staff to work through the recreation strats, implementation strategy, and the Measure R timeline and all of that that we'll be seeing in October and working it around so that hopefully by next year
33:02 We have that all completely lined up with the capital improvement plan and the facilities, whatever we're going to call the facilities plan. I did meet with the Gold Wing Road Riders this weekend, and I would like to thank Mammoth Lakes Tourism and their staff.
33:21 And the Chamber of Commerce for all the things they did to make that group feel welcome. This is the second year they've been here, and sorry I didn't have a new ride for them, so Skip, they took your ride again. It was called the Mayor Skip's Ride. And I've never seen so many nice smiling faces, and that is two years in a row that this group has come here and loved our town.
33:43 And then also I would like Chief Watson to pass on to Sergeant Smart my thanks for the wonderful safety presentation that she gave to them that I was able to witness. Are there any additions to the agenda? Joe, how many people were in that Goldwing group? There were over 400 who came. And this is the second year they have come.
34:10 Because of the Chamber's involvement and Mammoth Lakes Tourism involvement, they had coupons, they had a special tag they wore that got them discounts in almost every store. It was really nicely put together. Speaking of numbers, Rusty Grady reported 720 people participated in the mud run. About 300 of them signed up the day of. It was amazing. It was a great turnout. Excuse me, Madam Mayor. We need to do an emerging...
34:42 Department report for just a minute. Okay. I was going to say, I was looking, we had commission updates, but we can do it out of order. Thank you. Good evening. We're going to talk a little bit more about bears, follow up on some of Steve's comments. And I really want to give you an update on the status of the efforts to get Steve Searles, the ability to use lethal weapons in the forest serviced area portion of the town. And as you know, he can't currently do so because of
35:14 A federal law that prohibits the use of firearms by anyone other than a law enforcement officer within 150 yards of developed property within the U.S. Forest Service area. Our latest approach was to develop a firearms training and qualification program that would be approved by the Forest Service, and that would allow, Steve, an exception. Last time I reported to you, we were waiting on a response from the Forest Service that had gone to their legal department.
35:42 We got a preliminary response back. Two weeks ago, I hosted a meeting with John Armenta, the new U.S. Forest Service District Supervisor for the Indian National Forest, and some of his staff, and along with the Fish and Game law enforcement personnel. We had a real productive meeting. We talked about a lot of things, including what we can do and what Steve can do in public education and how to improve communications. But what did come out of the meeting was a preliminary report that...
36:09 We will be officially notified by the Forest Service that they are not going to grant that exception. We had considerable discussion about it, and I haven't gotten a letter yet that will go into more detail, but I interpreted their primary concern as being two. One was potential for liability to the Forest Service and the federal government if they had any formal agreement that granted this authority. And the other one was simply they're a really huge bureaucracy, a big agency.
36:38 They don't like making exceptions. It makes it difficult to make an exception for one place, so it's sort of an organizational mentality that they're opposed to. My impression was that's coming from the legal department. We continue to have, I believe, a good working relationship and an open dialogue with the local Forest Service people, but that's the latest response.
37:04 I'm frustrated because we're running out of options. We've tried a number of different things. We discussed options in that meeting. One of them, which the Forest Service liked, along with Fish and Game, was reserve police officer status. If Steve were to be a reserve or we were to have someone else as a reserve police officer, that grants that individual the authority to carry a firearm and use lethal weapons. It sounds like a simple solution, but the state...
37:32 The post, the certification agency, certifies what it takes to become a peace officer to have that legal authority. And it takes hundreds of hours of training. There's no academy here. Steve and I have talked about it. It's not a viable alternative. As Steve has accurately pointed out, it would mean he would go through several hundred hours of training that he would never use in his capacity as a wildlife specialist.
37:59 We are going to be looking at reactivating our reserve program. We did have one at one time, I understand. We will be looking for retired officers that live in the area. If they've been retired for less than three years, then they would have the legal authority to become a reserve officer without having to go back through to Canada. That would only be something, if we were able to find somebody to do that, they would be there to work with Steve, certainly not to replace him.
38:26 Decades of experience in someone who's working this time of day a good 12 hours a day. Another approach that we're going to be pursuing is to seek legislative support or some type of support from our local congressman, Buck McCune. Steve and I are working on, actually Steve with the assistance of Rusty Gregory hopefully we'll be working on establishing a meeting soon with Bob Howder, the Chief of Staff, to Congressman McCune. And the idea is we'll see
38:56 What we can get from the Congressional Office, either in the form of some form of exemption or exception, or if necessary, legislative relief that would provide an exception under limited circumstances that would apply to Mammoth Lakes. So I wish I had good news on that. We've only got a couple of months until the end of the season.
39:19 As I'm sure you're all aware, the last couple of months is when the bears get most active in their feeding to get ready to hibernate. And I don't know that we're going to have anything in place by the end of this season. But we're going to work on that. On another matter that sort of addresses some of the comments that Lee Gosch made about trash and dumpsters, Steve came up with a good idea, and he's done some of the groundwork, and that's to work with Mammoth Disposal.
39:44 He goes out every morning and checks the dumpsters, and that's where he gets those numbers of four. The other day he told me there were seven. And Mammoth Disposal has the ability to go out. If we call them, if Steve calls them, they'll send out a truck, clean up the mess, secure the dumpster, and then they have the ability to charge the property manager or the property owner for that service.
40:11 And that is a pretty simple way of providing a financial motivation for property managers, property owners to make sure their dumpsters are secure and that the residents are aware of the requirements to make sure that they secure the dumpster. So that's the latest in where we are with bear management. Okay, let's continue with any other departmental reports or emerging issues.
40:44 Mayor, members of the Council, I have a few items for you. First, to follow on a couple of speakers and follow up on Chief Watson's comment, we have started developing our code enforcement program that you authorized in our work program this year. We held a meeting about two weeks ago with Chief Harper, with Chief Watson, Ray Jarvis, myself, and...
41:09 Staff of our department, and we're fleshing out how we can develop a sustainable and supportable program, and we expect to, in the next month, call on some of the key people who expressed interest in the Sierra Valley sites to join us in a strategy session about how we go through a process that involves community engagement to develop something along the lines of a neighborhood care program.
41:37 So we've started that work program, and in that we've talked extensively about Steve's work and the work that our building folks and great engineering folks are conducting in that neighborhood. Also, related but separate, you have at your seats the letter dated September 8th regarding the rental enforcement notice.
42:00 A couple of people have mentioned the stuffing party. 8,000 letters were stuffed, folded and stuffed, and placed into envelopes today, and they're going out in the mail tomorrow. Our program is one of public information first. We continue to update our website, so that becomes the first line of accurate information. We have issued a public service advisory, and we'll continue to do that.
42:28 More will be printed in our local press. And this week we're teaming up with the finance department to develop a fact sheet and resource what we hope will be a lot of phone calls and email messages about how folks can comply with our TRT requirements. So this is our startup of this program and it's taking a lot of our staff resources and time. And I'd like to note that there were an awful lot of volunteers to help stuff.
42:57 Those letters today. It was done here in this room, and we really appreciate their volunteer help, largely from the lodging partners that we work with and the TOT committee. We, over the last few weeks, have held now four meetings with the Economic Stimulus Council. This was a group that was called together by Mayor Pro Tem.
43:21 We're using this group as a focus group to help flesh out the issues that we'll bring to you in a scope of work on October 5th about proceeding with an economic development plan. The group has held facilitated meetings, identified a host of actions that look like short-term, high-gain things to follow up on. Some are town-oriented and some are business-to-business, chamber of commerce type of subjects.
43:50 The headings that they have focused on include business assistance, retention, and diversification. How do we help our local businesses? How do we attract investment? Marketing and promotion. MLT is a partner in this effort. Market-focused government. How are our fees and our processes and procedures? Very focused on our clients. And finally, special events and cultural arts programs.
44:18 So it's been very productive for us. Like any focus group, we're learning a lot from them about local issues and what the local business groups are concerned with. And this is, frankly, the first time that we've had a lot of participation directly from businesses, lodging association, board of realtors, major renters of space, as well as property owners.
44:45 And all of our associations, including the Contractors Association. So it's a very, very productive and useful effort for us. Finally, following up on Commissioner Tenney's report to you, we are holding, in a similar vein, some workshops on municipal wayfinding and community messaging. This to vet the ideas of the wayfinding program, the gateway design, and community monumentation.
45:13 And the first workshop will be Thursday, September 15th from 11 to 1. We're using this information to help form that scope of work and also work with our United States Forest Service partners and the Mountain and other people that are involved and interested in community-wide messaging. The scope of work...
45:34 Our workshop will also be held with the full Planning Commission on September 28th and then will appear before you on October 5th with that scope of work to receive your direction. Thank you. Thank you, Mark. Stu? Sandra, is someone trying to tell us this is running long? I'll be brief. Madam Mayor, Councilmembers, staff, I'm just here before you to just report very briefly and if there has any questions from the Council on the Measure U Steering Committee process.
46:05 Steering Committee met on August 19th for their first of many meetings. All committee members were in attendance with only one apology, but the alternate was in attendance. The committee started to tackle the approved scope of work that the council authorised, which includes the role of the committee, the composition of the committee, the reconciliation of the ordinance and the ballot measure, and began the supplanting discussion and have a draft supplanting policy.
46:35 That they're working through that they're going to review at their next meeting this Friday, September 9th. Also this Friday, September 9th, for their second meeting, they will be reviewing or kind of discussing the five-year goal of Measure U, the SWOT, the Strength, Weakness, Opportunities and Threats of the current Measure R cycle, and they'll also be looking at just an overall review of Measure R.
47:02 With the ultimate goal of coming before Council on October 19th with that supplanting language and that policy discussion for review and consideration. So that's kind of the timeline. Recreation Commission is involved and they'll review that in their October meeting. So the timeline for the October 5th wasn't just going to make it. We were doing to take our time. The facilitator perceives that the process will be complete by November, December.
47:31 So we're going to try and do this in phases, bring policy items to Council as we move through the process and hopefully get some direction from Council if they need to be steered in a particular direction. Okay, thank you. You're welcome. I just have a couple short ones. Just as a follow-up and let the community know, on September 14th we're cleaning up City Hall. Oops. And so on your desk in front of you I put a notice.
48:05 We've also noticed the newspaper goes out tomorrow. So the offices are going to be open relative to things that need to be accomplished. Our primary focus, though, is to clean things up. The police department is fully open and they're doing their work, public works in the field and so forth, but the town offices are going to be cleaned up that day. Just want to let you know that. And the second thing is I just want to let you know we're also scheduling a follow-up to the airport commission meeting that occurred last week for next week, and we'll get that information out as soon as we get that meeting scheduled.
48:35 Thank you. Thank you. Madam Mayor. Yes. I'm sorry. If I could go back. You asked about additions to the agenda. Yes. And at that time I missed it. I would like to pull consent agenda. Oh, we haven't gotten the consent agenda yet. Oh. Yeah. Okay. So they just said in there that that's part of that. Right.
48:52 I know. The language in the two pieces don't miss because I have something to pull also. No, but before the Moberly family gets more impatient with us, I think we'd better move on to our council presentation of a five-year anniversary award to Sandra Moberly. They can come back in or no? Okay.
49:16 Thank you, members of the council. I'm very pleased to present Sandra Moberly, senior planner for her five years. Sandra has obviously been here for five years, and she has been one of our key staff members who's been involved in almost every major land use permit application we've had. She provides senior experience and oversight to all of our programs, and she's truly instrumental.
49:46 And we couldn't do it without both of them, Sandra and her baby moverly. You know, most recently, she took the initiative and applied for the Sustainable Communities Grant that the town received, the $318,000 program. And she did that.
50:05 In addition to her regular work program, so it was really quite a challenge to get that done and everything else. At the same time, she has been the lead project manager for our zoning code update. She has drafted or reviewed every single chapter of that zoning code, and it's a challenge, a little tedious, but also exciting. And her experience working in our public counter.
50:33 Handling use permits administrative and discretionary has made her invaluable in helping clean up this zoning code. We're very, very happy to have her. We're very lucky. You have a staff represented by Sandra that is equal to or better than, I think, any other organization you'll find in this state. So thank you very much, Sandra. It's very nice to have you part of our team.
51:03 Sandra, I'd just like to present you to the certificate. It's been wonderful in the time I was planning commission to have worked with you. Thank you so much for the first five years. Thank you. Thank you. Okay, and you are right, Skip. We're going to back up because we kind of skipped over commission updates. I presume there were no commission updates, so we're moving.
51:41 Backwards in time. Are there any items that anyone would like pulled from the consent agenda? Item number eight, please. Item number eight. I would like to pull number four. Are there any other items? I need to abstain from number four. Okay.
51:58 That will be noted. So then in that case we'll move on to our public presentations. The first is from Deanna Dillon, Superintendent of Devil's Postpile National Monument regarding the general management plan. Good evening everyone and thank you very much for this opportunity to tell you about where we're at with our general management plan and our preliminary alternatives and hopefully you all have easy access to our newsletter that I put on your desk.
52:36 And to our general public, there are some of these in the back of the room. So I have a slideshow with pretty slides, too. I need light, though, so I can read my notes. Thank you. Well, the purpose of this presentation is, first of all, to provide an update on our general management plan and its progress, and then to discuss the range of preliminary alternatives for our general management plan.
53:21 And the initial ideas that the interagency planning team has developed. Our NPS team has been gathering public feedback on these initial ideas and alternatives so we can complete the details in the next phase. And what's really exciting is this is an extra step in the process. So we do not have a preferred alternative. So it's a really neat thing. Some parks do it.
53:45 And we really wanted to be able to bring some of our preliminary ideas to our stakeholders, our partners, the public, our visitors, so they can help us develop or help us give feedback on what some of the preliminary ideas are. So it's really exciting to be able to present that option to people. In this presentation, I'll highlight and discuss the major actions and issues that our plan will address.
54:12 And as you all know, really fortunate this year, Devil's Postpital National Monument, we celebrated our centennial, 100 years old, and want to give a lot of appreciation to the Town Council and Mayor Joe Bacon, who was at many of our ceremonies, and Skip Harvey, who sure gave me some really sound business advice on how to coordinate our logistics for meals and buses.
54:34 And Don Eastman, I know, attended some of the events. And I'm sure some of you others were there, too. And I probably just didn't notice you and all the flurry of activity. So thank you again for the town support of this very important year for us. And as this is our centennial, we celebrated the last century. And so with our general management plan, we're looking to the next 15 to 20 years in the starting of the second century.
54:59 As you all know, the Devil's Postpile National Monument was established to protect Devil's Postpile and Rainbow Falls and also recognizing the value of the wildlife scenery of the upper middle fork of the San Joaquin River. I think you've probably heard the story about stopping the dam a number of times, so I'll tell it to you on a walk to the postpile someday if you haven't heard it. Also, Devil's Postpile National Monument, I tend to think of it as being in the heart of the valley, but it is surrounded. We are the rectangle.
55:29 Outlined in the slide, surrounded by the Inyo National Forest. And we are both within the Ansel Adams Wilderness and surrounded by it in John Muir Wilderness and the John Muir Pacific Crest Trails to traverse the monument. So now for the exciting part of this presentation is, so Devil's Postpile National Monument, this is a National Park Service unit. And we are able to, because of the long history we have working with the Inyo National Forest,
56:00 In collaborating our operations, we're able to collaborate our planning. So it's a very natural step for the two agencies to work together because operationally we're surrounded by the INYO. We're really dependent on them for our transit system and road. And the visitor experience is integrated between both agencies. And so this ongoing collaboration and the plan will help us to make better decisions in this planning process.
56:25 So we did all the formal requirements to request the Forest Service to be a cooperating agency in our plan and MOU is signed. But it's important to note that this plan is very specifically a National Park Service record of decision. We won't be making decisions for the Forest Service. We will be making recommendations collaboratively developed with them. So if you go to page two of our newsletter, you'll see that there's three scales of planning.
56:55 And the scale, number three, the monument, that is the one that will be the formal record of decision listed in the Federal Register. Alongside that, though, throughout our plan, and you'll see these as you go to the alternatives, the number three, the monument, will be denoted with the NPS logo. The valley-wide plan, the 5,000 acres of Reds Meadow Valley, number two, where all the roads, the campgrounds, the trails, the
57:24 We will also be collaboratively presenting some of the options in that area. And then the watershed scales, looking at the whole Upper Middle Fork of the San Joaquin. And for most of those issues, most of our actions are really focused on the monument in the valley. And the only one that really looks at the watershed scale is when we'll talk about wild and scenic river designation possibilities, and it's currently eligible.
57:53 So we're looking for a broader scale to integrate both immediate monument, larger or medium-sized valley and larger watershed scale. So some of you may remember we did start this process in 2009 and we did do scoping with our foundation plan. I mean our foundation statements that identified the purpose of the monument and our significance and our fundamental resources and values.
58:24 And we did do public scoping on that. This is the year we're doing our preliminary alternatives. In 2012, next year, we're going to come out with our draft, and we hope to finalize the plan by 2013. Just a quick summary of what we heard during scoping of what people value most is definitely the beauty and the preservation and protection of the resources and features of post-pile, Rainbow Falls, clean air, clean water, the river, and the beautiful scenery.
58:55 People really like the idea and the broader preservation concepts of watershed protection and protecting the wilderness values. And they really like that rustic experience, the quality of the experience and setting, like stepping back into time and you get a sense of the ancient. They value the low level of development and scale of what is there, and we heard a lot of just keep it the same and don't overbuild. So there's not demand for additional modern services or conveniences.
59:22 The new idea is mostly called for additional linkages and connectivity via trails and transit up to town and linking additional local destinations and also on connecting and partnering on how and where information is delivered in Mammoth Lakes. So these comments help to set the stage for what is really driving our alternatives and what is similar among the alternatives.
59:45 So you will see that there are subtle differences between the alternatives and many of these ideas could fit under multiple concepts. There's not any dramatic differences in our natural and cultural resource management. And most of our alternatives and the variations have to do with facilities. And some alternatives also vary in how they address commercial stock use in the wilderness.
1:00:08 So several of these recommendations also include actions, as I mentioned, that would take place on the Forest Service land, so we are collaborating in the presentation of those ideas. So some of the elements common to all alternatives, we do have listed in the newsletter, so you can browse through those. Those are the topics there. Our natural and cultural resource management, our climate change, and our commitment to be a climate-friendly park and do what we can to contribute to sustainability.
1:00:39 The range of visitor activities, our shuttle bus system, and access, the importance of science and research and interagency coordination and collaboration. So as in all management plans, we have the no action alternative, and then we have our three action alternatives. And what we thought would work really well is to give a name to each of these alternatives, and that a name would be a concept statement and an overall philosophy that affects zoning.
1:01:07 So the three alternatives that we've identified thus far are the watershed alternative, the connecting people to wild nature, and special destination and focus on key attractions. So the watershed emphasis proposes greater emphasis on managing and promoting visitor understanding of the broader Upper Middle Fork of the San Joaquin River watershed and the role of the monument within that watershed and some special things at Minaret Vista that I'll be telling you about.
1:01:35 And the connecting people emphasize the monument and the corridor from Minaret Vista down through Red's Meadow as a gateway to a greater wilderness and a place for visitors to experience and connect with nature in a wild setting. And special destination is really focused on place-based that would be primarily around Minaret Vista, Devil's Post Pile, Red's Meadow, and Rainbow Falls. Something that the National Park Service does in all of its general management plan is called zoning.
1:02:07 So we've developed five management zones for the plan, and we apply these management zones to the different alternatives. A quick summary, I'm not going to read the text, you can look at it, but the five management zones are the front country, the sensitive resource management zone, the natural wild, the portal and transition zone, and the key attraction focused interpretation zone.
1:02:32 And how this plays out in kind of just a quick little thumbnail is how those colors are kind of dispersed through the alternatives. So you can take your magnifying glass to that later and see how we try to sync those zones with the different alternatives. And we will be talking specifically about the implications of those zones as we talk about these specific areas as we move forward.
1:03:00 And so first, I want to talk about the doubles post pile ranger station. It's a very charming, quaint ranger station. It's really small. It's about 400 square feet, so it can get a little crowded in there. Just last Monday, we had 2,200 people. So in a small little section like that through the day, it can be cozy, especially if it's raining and people don't want to be outside. But we love it. It's charming. It's got the rustic character.
1:03:26 It's a small structure, and it's trying to serve many functions, both visitors and office space, and it's not very ADA friendly. We've tried to do what we can, but it's pretty hard to turn a wheelchair around in that office. We've got a ramp, but I know we can do better. So we're looking on the range of alternatives of an adaptive use of an existing ranger station, where we probably move just a couple of those computer deaths out of there.
1:03:52 In the connecting people, we do know on the 1997 flood, the rain on snow, the ranger station did flood two or three feet deep. So we know we got a ranger station on a floodplain. So we recognize in two of the alternatives, we have to move it out of the floodplain. In the special destination, not only would we move the ranger station, we would build a slightly larger ranger station. And throughout all these, we would improve the shuttle bus stop and turn around and parking.
1:04:22 Next one, this is one of the probably more emotional issues for our visitors, is the Devil's Postpile Campground. And so we're looking at a range of alternatives from removing the campground and converting it to a day-use area along the river bank in the watershed alternative. And we would lose those camping sites in the valley there. Whereas in the connecting people, we would move the most sensitive sites away from the river and we would try to find replacement sites.
1:04:53 And we still would try to develop a day-use area near the riverbank where the parking lot and the campground currently is. And then in the focus on special destinations, we would downscale the existing campground. And this is where a lot of new stuff starts happening. If you see the picture on the left there, that is kind of like a, I used to tell my superiors at our regional office that
1:05:22 We live in Shangri-La, but we are living in Stone Age conditions because that right there is the wash basin, the sink to do your morning toiletry, the little camp stove used to be next to that, and then there's a shower next to it where you walk out with ice spills in your hair, and it's also the maintenance shop. So we realize that we really need to, we are improving the employee facility, we're building that, but our maintenance shop is still
1:05:49 Very substandard. We're not in OSHA compliance. Mice and wood rats, although they're cute, they're not appropriate in that building. And we also know it's too small. Our table saw is out in the rain. And so we know we need to have a slightly larger facility in order to meet the maintenance needs. So I was actually given the money to rebuild it, but I said, wait a second, we've got a really great opportunity to work with the INYO. They have maintenance needs too. Let's explore doing a joint facility.
1:06:16 That's probably going to be considered, well, we're considering locating it at Promise Valley. And that facility would be a maintenance facility, but it would still be relatively small, very modest, but also multipurpose. So if we had to evacuate people during a fire or bring them to a safe staging area, we could have a place to bring them. We could make a defensible space. We could make sure we had good communications.
1:06:40 We could put in a little access area for the Mona County Star so when they do rescues they can have some equipment down in the valley. And so that is one of the alternatives that we're looking at in the connecting people to wild nature. And throughout the alternatives, just a question of scale. So in the watershed it would just be using an old cabin that they have there right now with a gaping hole in the roof that we would repair.
1:07:09 So anyway, so that's an exciting one and one that would potentially give us opportunities to partner with the town is we also realize our administrative facilities, we kind of had, at one point I had 12 people in an 80 square foot space for office space. So it's a little crowded down there and it is a computer age. We know we need to have some additional office space. So we're going to be looking to the town of Mammoth Lakes for some possible considerations of additional office space that we could potentially.
1:07:39 Work out a partnership agreement. So take a close look at those and the alternatives and we can talk quite a bit more on that. One of the really exciting ideas is Minaret Vista. As we all know and love, Minaret Vista is one of the best views in the Sierra, if not the best.
1:07:56 And so many of our visitors miss that opportunity, and this whole experience really isn't integrated into the Devil's Post Power Reds Meadow experience. So we see we have this tremendous opportunity to improve this experience, redesign the parking area, move the parking area away from the beautiful viewpoint, and integrate the location into the rest of the experience, and make it a better destination. And we could also have a shuttle bus stop up there, too, and that could really be a major enhancement.
1:08:25 To that area and to our visitors. And in the watershed alternative, we're looking at having it be a destination along the shuttle bus road. And then the opportunity for people to go into Reds Meadow Valley and Devil's Postpail if they like to. But this could become an experience. And then in that case, we would have a small seasonal staff visitor contact station there. And we also would be looking at putting new trails along the rim, an ADA accessible trail and a trail connection to the Pacific Crest Trail.
1:08:55 On the connecting people one, it would be a smaller facility, a kiosk, which still would be a transit stop in connection. And on the special destination, again, we would really put some emphasis into this area and put the interpretive and ADA trail in and do a better job of showcasing this for our visitors. And it would be a real benefit to our local community and give people more of an experience and enhance the attractiveness of the gateway community.
1:09:28 Devil's Postpile Viewing Area. Since it's a Devil's Postpile General Management Plan, we have to see how we can make that a better experience, and we are always striving to make it ever more accessible. It's right next to the river, so we can't be 100% ADA compliant, but we're always making improvements, so we just put in a really nice ramp down to the base of the postpile so people don't have to kind of stumble down the stairs and slip on the pumice anymore.
1:09:55 And so we would continue to improve that access and also up on the top to make sure there's glacial polish that people can see into the future and still experience while they're there. Then the more complicated ones we're looking at is Rainbow Falls is in Ansel Adams Wilderness, 0.2 miles in from Boundary Creek. And it's a very unusual wilderness area because we get 100,000 people down there in the months of July and August and September. So it's very crowded.
1:10:26 So managing congestion down there and providing for some type of threshold wilderness experience and some of the qualities of wilderness character. Before it was designated wilderness, my predecessor did a great job of making it easier for visitors and put the large stairs in and the overlooks and the stairs down to the bottom. So we are exploring if we should look at realigning the trail away from the edge where I'm always afraid people are going to fall off and down.
1:10:54 Down the river and over the falls. It hasn't happened yet, thank goodness. But we are looking at moving that trail a little bit away from the edge and removing the log stairs and creating more of a wilderness quality trail in a sense of discovery. Also looking, there's another alternative, maybe soften the edges of those log stairs. And in the watershed alternative, we are actually proposing to remove the rock stairs to the base of the falls.
1:11:22 The commercial activities in the wilderness is potentially our most controversial issue we'll be dealing with, including the day rides to Rainbow Falls. We have approximately 1,200 day-use rides to Rainbow Falls each July, August, and into Labor Day weekend. And so we are required by law to determine what's the extent necessary to provide this commercial service to provide for a wilderness experience for people.
1:11:49 So no matter what, through rides, in all alternatives, we'll continue in all these alternatives, and of course tied to the limits set by the Forest Service injunction. But through our alternatives, we are looking for two alternatives, continue the use to Rainbow Falls, that would be the no action in connecting people to nature, and two alternatives discontinue the use. However, we do realize that
1:12:16 Just continuing the use, we can just relocate it just on the boundary of the wilderness at Boundary Creek and just there, so many people ask me for toilets out there, you probably give a thousand comments a year on that one, but we could potentially put a composting toilet there on the other side of Boundary Creek and kind of a nice rest area for people. It's kind of hot and dry and exposed because it's in the burn area. So no matter what alternative we ultimately select for our draft preferred, we know that we are required by law
1:12:46 To meet the criteria of extent necessary for wilderness of the Wilderness Act. And we will try to complete this analysis in the GMP. Other commercial activities that occur in the wilderness are fishing and some guided photography. So just a couple more slides. Another thing that we're going to be looking at is wild and scenic rivers. And it was determined eligible as a wild and scenic river in 1992 in a study done.
1:13:18 By the Sierra and Inyo National Forests. And in this step of the planning process, we're going to look at determining suitability for that designation and seeking comments from our stakeholders, partners, and the public. The outstanding and remarkable values, including the geology, the scenery, the recreation, and the wildlife. And then the last big thing we're going to look at in this plan.
1:13:45 Is boundaries and other designations to this area. We are required by law on 1978 National Parks and Recreation Act to evaluate the adequacy of boundaries in the GMP. So we are proposing an administrative cleanup of the trail connecting the two features. So it's kind of interesting. You get to the pulse pile, you walk another 10 minutes, you're out of the monument for two miles, and then you get to Rainbow Falls.
1:14:12 So it's kind of very confusing to people because the laws and the regulations are different about dogs off leash and hunters next to the trail. And I said no smoking on the trail, but then they get out of the monument. And so anyway, but in the original designation, the 1911 map, those two features were completely within the monument as well as the whole river. So we are looking at that. So we are both encompassing both of the geologic features within the monument boundary and the river.
1:14:41 And looking at potentially extending from Merritt Falls Campground to Lower Rainbow Falls, bringing that boundary out to the east to the road. So it's really clear in people's minds where is the National Park Service unit. And many people come there for a family-friendly experience. And it's easier to know what the regulations are when you're not going back and forth between the two different sets of missions and rules and regulations.
1:15:07 Which isn't to say that we don't completely value our partners at Inyo National Forest. We've done a great, amazing job working together for almost a century. And so we recognize that the two agencies can do the best job by working together side by side. And what could be a really great potential benefit for both our communities, our visitors, our stakeholders is look at other designations. So one of the ideas that we kind of are floating around is perhaps designating.
1:15:35 The entire watershed is a minaret and Devil's Postpile National Monument area. The minarets encompassing the land currently managed by the Forest Service in the wilderness and getting that special prestigious designation and Devil's Postpile National Monument just being slightly expanded. So that could potentially be a really nice draw for visitors to the community to know there's a nationally designated monument, but maybe people don't like that idea either.
1:16:05 Essentially, you know, we would keep the two agencies completely working together and collaborating. There's many Park Service units like Grand Canyon Parashant that work together, National Park Service and BLM. So it's not an unprecedented idea, but we definitely want to hear people's feedback, see if it's something that appeals to our visitors, our partners, and our stakeholders. So where are we now? Next week on Thursday at the library.
1:16:35 September 15th, 3 to 6 p.m., we'll have an open house, we'll have posters, flip charts, people can comment, we'll write everything down on the flip charts, and we are taking public comments all the way to September 30th, so if you have some, please get those in. I have been this summer going out to our visitors in the bus stops in Rainbow Falls, and they are really excited about being engaged in this process, and it's just been really inspirational.
1:17:02 To see the amount of interest our public has in preserving these jewels and these special places when they come to the town of Mammoth Lakes and they know Devil's Pulse Pile and Red's Meadow and that beautiful view is just on the other side of town. And this is the only way they can get there. So we're really appreciative of the time you've given me here to kind of give you an overview. It might have taken a little longer than it should have, but if you have any comments or questions, please let me know.
1:17:32 Thank you, Dan. And I have one question. Is there an online way for people to respond? Absolutely. Yes. And we have that described in our newsletter. And then if you just go to our website, too, nps.gov slash depo. And then every newsletter, we also have a form if you want to mail that in. And something to just kind of emphasize is
1:17:56 We're really not asking which alternative do you prefer. You could mix and match. You can say, I really like this out of the watershed. I really like this out of special destinations. I really like this out of connecting people to nature. So we're kind of right at that time where there's nothing set in stone. We really have a really neat opportunity to look at a blend of different options for the future. Questions of Deanna? All right, great. Thank you very much.
1:18:28 My pleasure. Thank you. Okay. We have a second presentation from High Sierra Energy Foundation. You know, I'm Rick Phelps, and I'm Executive Director of the High Sierra Energy Foundation. And thank you for the opportunity to bring you up to date on the changes and progress of the foundation, including the board, the mission, financial situation, work activities, accomplishments, and long-term prospects.
1:19:08 As I have just a few minutes on your agenda, I prepared my remarks in the interest of time and focus. As all of you know, our board resigned in July after naming me to the board. It was a surprise to me, and there is, as Sam Walker was quoted in the sheet, no dirt there. Or as Charlie Eddie said in an email to the media, almost the entire board has been in place for six years, following two years, serving as the core of the town's renewable energy task force.
1:19:37 We reached a consensus that after eight years, it's a good time for fresh faces and ideas on the board. Several other members and I had stated a year ago that we would be leaving the board this year. Each of us has expressed a willingness to continue to assist and support High Sierra Energy Foundation. I think Sam and Charlie's explanations say it all, and no further discussion is necessary. The challenge now, however, is to form a new board that will help lead the foundation to a productive future.
1:20:07 Helping us put that board together on an interim advisory basis are Mammoth Hospital CEO Gary Boyd, Mammoth Mountains Jack Copeland, and retired Mono County presiding judge Ed Forstensor. I think each of you will agree that these three individuals have the depth of experience and community presence that are unmatched. I look forward to their counsel, insight, and creativity. Our goal is to have a new board in place by the end of the year.
1:20:36 In that new board, we'll review our mission that has been in place since 2005. The mission of the foundation is to develop and showcase energy efficiency and renewable resources in Mammoth Lakes and the eastern Sierra. Unfortunately, this mission has been a source of confusion, as efficiency is essentially invisible, while renewable projects are much more photogenic.
1:21:04 I've heard the comment many times that we have to get beyond light bulbs. And I agree with that to some degree, but the importance of energy efficiency cannot be overemphasized. As stated in the January 2011 update of the California Energy Efficiency Strategic Plan, quote, the state's loading order, and the loading order is what kind of generation resources are needed, whether it's natural gas, nuclear, solar, etc.
1:21:34 But that loading order identifies energy efficiency as California's top priority resource. Under the Public Utilities Code, utilities are requested first to meet their, quote, unmet resource needs through all available energy efficiency and demand reduction resources that are cost effective, reliable, and feasible. The last few words of the code, the Utilities Code, is the challenge with developing renewables.
1:22:04 Cost-effective, reliable, and feasible. And it's how new projects are judged. Cost-effective, reliable, and feasible. Our mission remains the same. Curiously, some people thought that our recent unsuccessful proposal to the Air Pollution Control District did not fit with our mission and asked, what did energy have to do with air pollution? The answer is pretty straightforward. A lot. Think coal. Think green outcasts. Think non-carbon renewables.
1:22:35 So, how are we doing? Well, we're surviving in these times, but we have had a very good run. Since we started in the spring of 2005, we've raised more than $1.2 million, including $195,000 or 16% from the town. The SCE partnership provided $570,000 or 46%. CEC grants just under $200,000 or 15%.
1:23:02 Iceland, America, nearly 100,000, 70%, and the remaining 272,000 came largest to smallest from foundation directors and employees, Mammoth Community Water District, Flex Your Power, Mammoth Mountain, Mono County, Mammoth Pacific Geothermal, and miscellaneous contributions from corporations and individuals. It's important to realize, however, that two-thirds of the funds received historically are for fee-for-service activities.
1:23:32 We do something under an agreement and charge per hour for our services. This is the way many nonprofits are going today as the normal sources of philanthropy, individual or corporate, are shrinking. Our annual budgets have been as high as $300,000, but we have severely cut back since early 2009, and our budget this year totals $116,000, including $14,500 or about 12% from the town.
1:23:58 The remaining 88% is all fee-for-service revenue from the SCE partnership. We have about $190,000 remaining in our partnership budget with SCE through the end of next year. But that is all fee-for-service and is very dependent on the energy efficiency activities of the jurisdictions of the partnership. If government efficiency retrofits aren't completed due to budgetary concerns, that directly impacts our fee-for-service revenue.
1:24:30 A little more on us. We have a 130-square-foot office above the outlet malls with two work areas with borrowed furniture. My current salary is $20,000, way down from the boom days of 2008. I am the only employee, and we obtain additional services on a contract basis. Pamela Staden, Energy Efficiency, and Lesla O'Vary, when she's not pregnant and doing other things, helps us with the Living Wise Education Program.
1:24:57 And as far as I know, everyone has a comfortable cloth coat. Extra credit on that. And from all our activities over the last six years, how is the town of Mammoth Lakes benefited, which is also how I spend my days. According to SCE, about 4.3 million kilowatt hours of community energy savings, valued at more than $650,000, it goes to residents and business owners in this community.
1:25:27 Just on that alone, the town is getting more than a three-to-one payoff in its investment. Two booklets published for homeowners and businesses, Mammoth Energy Smart and Energy Answers for Today. Two educational energy summits in partnership with Cerro Coastal Community College. Several Title 24 classes, as well as a Green Building Code class last December, co-sponsored with Mono County. Five years of the Living Wise Energy Water class for 6th grade earth science students.
1:25:57 Over 500 students and their parents have participated, co-sponsored by the Water District. Two small business direct and solid sweeps, 60 businesses five years ago. The second is occurring right now, and as of this morning, over 150 businesses in Mammoth are signed up for lighting and refrigeration retrofits. That's real value for the town and for energy efficiency and the environment. And I might add this.
1:26:26 This would not have been happening without our direct negotiation with SCE. We are a long way from their core area, and there are people in Edison, having been there a long time ago, that refer to Mammoth Lakes as the Pluto of the service territory. So we have to work to get attention. We've been successful at that. We're also coordinating right now outreach for the free upcoming comprehensive mobile home and manufactured.
1:26:55 Retrofit Program. More value. We've connected homeowners with solar contractors and geothermal heat pump providers. The first ground source heat pump installation in Bono County was in June Lake last year. We were instrumental in working with Britannia Pacific on the first geothermal space heating project in Mammoth Lakes, the Mammoth View project off Alpine Circle. We facilitated and made our geothermal data available.
1:27:24 The developer told us, Hector told me, that the geothermal would not have happened without our input. Co-inceded Town Tree Lighting since 2006 and exchanged old-style incandescent Christmas lights for LEDs. We're currently working with both Mammoth Hospital, Mammoth Unified School District on their facilities planning to ensure that renewables and efficiency that are cost-effective, reliable, and feasible are included.
1:27:54 What does the future hold? Our activities will be heavily focused on efficiency and connecting local residents and businesses with SCE programs. They are promoted heavily down south, but often invisible up here. In fact, we're very successful at that, and we were recognized at the recent Statewide Energy Efficiency Best Practices Forum in San Jose.
1:28:18 That was sponsored by the Local Government Commission. We were recognized as a best practice in marketing and outreach. The Eastern Sierra Initiative, the local government partnership with SCE, continues to the end of next year and will likely be extended to the end of 2013, beginning California Public Utilities Commission adoption of an extension of the year. We will also continue to facilitate development of renewable resources.
1:28:47 With emphasis on geothermal for spacing and providing input on other renewable options. Education initiatives will continue, including Title 24 updates and the Green Building Code. Significantly, we will look forward to working with MCWD to co-sponsor a six-year of the Living Wide Sixth Grade Program. In conclusion, and on a personal note, I'd like to say that my six years here in Mammoth Lakes have been the most fulfilling and interesting in my career.
1:29:17 Despite not being the most profitable and despite the sometimes baffling sensitivities and politics of a small town. But ultimately, there is one defining question to ask. Did the High Sierra Foundation, with the support of the town, develop and showcase energy efficiency and renewable resources in Mammoth Lakes and the eastern Sierra, as is our mission? Clearly,
1:29:47 The answer is yes. Questions? Any questions? I don't have any. John? Yeah. First of all, thank you, Rick. I was a council member that asked Rick to give a presentation to the council and to the public this evening. I'll also be making similar presentations to Bishop and Monoanio counties. Great. Back next month. I have four questions, if I could. The first one is, without doing a...
1:30:17 Financial Audit. Can you share with us the current financial condition of High Sierra Energy Foundation? Well, we have the contract from Southern California Edison, which we bill for services. We receive money from the town every month into the renewed contract for $14,500. We have a credit card bill that we have to pay off. We pay a middle amount for rent.
1:30:45 An office space. The money from Edison that we get goes to pay for advertising, pays for contract labor, and goes to help absorb overhead. So our situation is, like many nonprofits, on the edge, but that's why we've cut costs, cut salaries, and everything else. Would it be appropriate to know what the credit card payoff is? It's about $14,000.
1:31:17 14, okay. Which is actually underwritten by me, so certainly there's an incentive to want to pay that off. So financially we're at $14,000 from the town, $14,000 credit card pay off, so those zero each other out, and then we get 88% of the fee for service from Southern California Edison. At this time, yeah. Okay. Given the current economics.
1:31:46 I think you answered my question when you said that the Edison money should continue to the end of 2012 and with a one-year extension to the end of 2013. What the CPUC, California Public Utility Commission, is thinking about doing is extending the energy efficiency rate case one or two years. That just evens out their workload and makes it go better. Okay.
1:32:18 So is it fair to say that that funding from Edison at this point appears to be a stable source of funding? It's stable, but as I explained in the future service, we have to have work to do. And the partnership looks at retrofits for the government jurisdictions and everybody's budget have been so tight, there hasn't been a lot of activity. So we've not had a lot of input on that.
1:32:45 I'll be writing some things up both for Ray Jarvis and the other jurisdictions about what all is involved. It's not a lot of money to do all of this, but it's a lot of money given the current times. The jurisdictions that would be funding projects would be Mono County, Inyo County, City of Bishop, and Town of Mammoth Lakes, those four. And I would guess that neither Inyo County nor City of Bishop nor Mono County
1:33:14 Are budgeting much money, and I don't know if we've discussed that as a town at this point? No, it's, they're not budgeted items at this time, and I think for the town and Mono County is a total of about $30,000 worth of work with a two-plus year payback, but it's just not.
1:33:36 Not available right now. Right. Ineo has some stimulus money or a project. They're doing some work there. Monroe County has some stimulus money that we helped them apply for a couple years ago, but that's still in the approval process. The two other questions I had, and I'll mention them just because I had them, but I think that they're not relevant at this point. I was going to ask the future financial condition, how do you see it?
1:34:12 How do you see us getting there financially? And with what you've said, the way to get there is to get programs from the four entities so that we can have programs and then get reimbursed from Edison. Well, but, you know, we want to stay busy and that's how we generate revenue. Right, okay. We had actually, a good example of that is last year we had a contract in Mono County for
1:34:40 Provide them with energy efficient systems, outreach, and we weren't able to do anything except help them with their green and building code seminar. Thank you. Any other questions? I don't really have a question, but I just want to say that I think the work you're doing is very significant and really under-recognized.
1:35:03 Throughout the community, particularly the direction it is going. I have been a recipient of some of your programs, and it's greatly appreciated the way you do it and the way that it has helped my business to be more efficient.
1:35:16 And I think the work you did with Britannia particularly is probably just a small chip into something that's going to be much, much bigger in the future. Unfortunately, until the project gets moving and is up to speed and people see it actually in action, I don't think it's going to be recognized, but eventually it will. And I want to thank you for all your time and effort in sticking to it through what is sometimes a very tough situation. So thank you.
1:35:45 Thank you for your support. Thanks, Rick. Any other comments? All right. Thank you, Rick. Thank you. We will now move on to the consent agenda, and I notice that numbers 4 and 8 have been pulled. Could I have a motion for the remaining items? Madam Mayor, move to approve 5, 6, 7, 9, and 10. Second. I have a motion and a second. Could we have a roll call vote, please, Robin? Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes.
1:36:17 Yes, motion passes 5-0. I asked for item number 4 to be pulled specifically because in the public comments on the first page, we had the discussion where Brent Harper had requested waiving of the $10 tree cutting permit while they were doing the
1:36:39 Fire suppression. And I know that later in the meeting, we were informed that that would be handled administratively by our town manager, but I thought the minutes should reflect that because this just looks like he asked and we did nothing. So I would ask that some wording be added at Jamie's and the staff's discretion after they've reviewed the video.
1:37:09 Madam Mayor, I would agree, and I would move to adopt the consent agenda item number four as amended. I'll second that. Can we do an all those in favor? No, we'll do a roll call vote, please, Robin. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Matthew, were you not going to abstain on the... Oh, it's four. I'm sorry. I'm looking at eight here. Yes. Motion passes 4-0 with one abstention.
1:37:42 That's correct. We'll move on to item number eight. Skip? Thank you, Madam Mayor. I think if we could, I'd like to get a staff report on this as to how we came about identifying this position and the salaries that we're offering. Good evening, Council. I'd like to just do a brief report and answer any questions you might have regarding this agenda item. And we certainly could have put it in the regular agenda. And so...
1:38:12 Thank you for the questions. We're certainly happy to talk about this. We had a recruitment that was held recently. This is a result of some of the work that was done early on when Marianna came on board. As you recall, the council at the time was looking at hiring an administrative services director, which was a high-level position to oversee finance, HR, and several other functions within the town. Marianna came on and had a chance to analyze staffing levels, service levels, delivery, and so forth.
1:38:40 And felt strongly that although the administrative position probably was valuable and certainly important, there was so much just plain old work that needed to get done that she recommended to the council and the council agreed to move that position from a singular position to two positions. One is an analyst position level and one is more of a clerk level. So we went through the process of looking at the job descriptions and looking at the workload that needed to be done. I think the position was...
1:39:09 It was divided into two pieces. One is the TOT compliance and budget analyst position. The other one was more of a clerk and payroll support tech position. Both of those are finance-related positions. We went through a recruitment process based on the job description that we developed. Recruitment resulted in 10 applications. In the 10 applications, we had two good candidates.
1:39:30 People that had some experience, but we had two people that had very good experience. We interviewed two people, and at the end of the interview process, we realized that one candidate really had a lot of experience and capacity that not only met the basis needed the job that we had posted, but far exceeded that in many ways, so including many of the concerns and problems that we're dealing with today, economic development, analyzing economics of projects and so forth, in addition to the...
1:40:00 Budget Analyst to kind of work in TOT. So we went through a process of looking, first of all, within the current structure of whether or not we could make an offer to the employee or potential employee. We had conversations, and there were two things that came up relative to this. One was, or maybe three things, I think. One of the maybe important things is, like many people in Mammoth, he wanted to be here. You know, his position in the past, past positions, was a much higher level position. We were happy to...
1:40:28 Share his resume with you if you'd like. But he came recently. He has his own consulting business. He has a law degree as well as an MBA from the University of Promo, Utah, and also has worked extensively in finance in many capacities, and most recently as the real estate director for the largest private school district in the state of Hawaii. In the state of Hawaii, they've allocated public lands into private use.
1:40:56 To fund school district operations at a private level. And that structure is different than mainland school districts. So we felt very strongly that this was a very positive interview. A lot of the background check that we began doing with that individual showed great competencies, capacities, the ability to bring really a full toolbox of financial skills to the town. So unlike what we may have done in the past where
1:41:22 We didn't feel strongly about a candidate. We certainly feel strongly about this candidate. And it's really driven by several things. First off, as you know, we have a very, very thin organization. And we ask people to do many things. And to be able to bring someone to the town with a huge toolbox of capacity, to me, is just a very positive action that we could take.
1:41:45 Unfortunately, as much as we've come to respect and enjoy working with Marianna, she does have other plans in life, and eventually she will be a city manager in a city and will be knocking on her door with questions about how to do things, but realistically, she has other plans in life and will eventually be doing those kinds of things. So she has become such an asset, not only to me, but far longer than me with you. So when you ask questions about things financially related, she's your go-to person.
1:42:15 We need to have somebody with similar capacities because we have many, many, many, many, many, many, many financial problems that we're dealing with, not only in dealing with the lawsuit that we'll eventually have to work through over a matter of time, but we have many problems relative to just working through issues. So, for example, who is working through and managing Measure U and Measure R? Those are questions and concerns we have. We have minimal capacities to manage those dollars. We're not misspending the dollars. We're not making mistakes.
1:42:45 That I'm aware of, but there's a lot of financial work that needs to go into those things. We need to analyze those budgets, we need to follow the resources that are being allocated and spent. So from my perspective, we had a candidate come up that had just wonderful credentials, excellent references, a great background, who in other terms, had we flown the finance position that was originally allocated, probably would have been a number one candidate for that higher level position.
1:43:12 For us, I think we're looking at a kind of a home run relative to this. I think there were some concerns when we talked about making sure we didn't offer the highest salary, so we looked at that structure. I recommended moving this position from a position that was allocated to a little bit higher level, which is very equivalent to the assistant airport manager level position, some of those things. We're trying to keep it within the framework of our structure as it exists today. It's not at the top of the pay range.
1:43:41 It's an at-will position at the executive level, so there'll be eventually when we work through the contract processes, an at-will contract is not part of the collective bargaining. So to me there's just upside. It's a $5,000 more than what the job description and job advertisement allocated for the position, and as a result of that we got a great candidate, and I think we're recommending certainly that the council approve the change to the salary.
1:44:08 And to the job title to allow us to move forward with the recruitment and selection. So answer any questions you have specifically about it here. The one question I have is I was well aware of our need for a financial analyst. That's been clear for a while. But I also thought that we had a strong need to improve our...
1:44:35 H.R. position and to work on getting our employee manuals, job descriptions, employee handbooks and things of that nature in order. Have we completed that task? Have we fulfilled that position? And are those jobs being taken care of at this time? Well, we have Noreen Wilbert, who's been with the town for many, many years. She is serving in a capacity that isn't at a director level, but she certainly is working towards some of those goals.
1:45:03 Or probably knowing that we're working through the personnel manual, for example. But I think by default I'm the personnel director, so a lot of the work that is being done has been done by me. And Marianna certainly has done a tremendous amount of that work, initiating the personnel manual and some of those things. Frankly, as I mentioned early on in my discussion, we're short. And so a lot of the things that we want to accomplish, we have to prioritize and determine what's going to get done, what's not going to get done. So in terms of the financials, to me,
1:45:31 That is the most critical thing that we've got to be concerned about. A lot of the other things may not be fully broken, and the wheels aren't falling off, and they're important, but there's just so much resource to go around to accomplish it. So we are making progress on those things you just discussed, but they're not as high a priority in my mind as the financial. Okay, and then this is the first time I've ever heard of a need for an IT manager.
1:45:55 When did we determine that that was something that we needed to recruit for? Well, I think one of the reasons we put that in the report is that we do have certainly IT needs, and one of the skill sets this person has in addition to the financials, you know, technology skills. We have one person who is our technology person, and that person goes away. We often rely upon a, you know, a private sector business, which is perfectly okay for the...
1:46:23 Short-term, but we don't necessarily have anybody who's looking at the system as an overall system. The technologies that we have are, frankly, antiquated in many ways. We have old financial software. We have technologies. My PC, for example, I left the county with Windows 7, and now I'm working back on the original Windows XP with 2003 Windows Exchange. So that's just the nature of where we've spent our resources and capacity.
1:46:53 Having somebody in-house who understands those technologies will save us a tremendous amount of money over the future when we have to eventually upgrade our technologies. There's no doubt about that. I mean, we rely heavily on technology. The fewer people you have in this kind of work, the more technology becomes critical. So we're spending nearly $100,000 with, you know, the IE group to help us with our budget work. With that budget work, they're still using those technologies to back down or back load.
1:47:20 Data into a software application that the council approved to be developed. So we're kind of jerry-meandering and fixing technologies. That's going to have to change eventually when resources either become available or under crisis. So that's a need that's out there. I can tell you there's many, many needs that the town has that the council isn't necessarily aware of because they're not percolating to the top as priorities. There's just not the capacity for us to bring you problems.
1:47:48 Expect solutions when there's no money to do it. So we're figuring out how to do those things ourselves or we don't get them done. We just hope they don't fall into a crisis mode. So we've got somebody who has those technology skills who can help us oversee that. So that would be one of the duties that we would allow or expect that person to be involved with. If there's more, for example, you've had a lot of discussions about the economics of the development community. What does it mean to the town relative to a new project?
1:48:17 What are the economics of those projects? And we often rely upon the consultants that are working for us to look at those numbers and analyze the data. This person could do that for you. They can look at projects, new future projects. They can work with the Economic Development Committee that's being formed on. I talked earlier today with a real estate person who's been collecting data for years and years and years and has that available for us to begin utilizing to help new developers or contractors understand the economics of...
1:48:46 Grill Estate in Mono County and in Mammoth Lakes in particular. Who can do that here? This person can do that for us. Or do it for the chamber, for example. So we're expanding the capacity of the town in all kinds of ways by bringing higher skill sets to the table.
1:49:02 But we talked quite a bit during budget discussions about outsourcing a lot of the work that we do here in town, which it sounds like we're doing a little bit of that when our IT guy is not available. Have we looked into the comparison of whether or not we could save more money by continuing to outsource and still? It sounds like our problem in our IT department is more outdated.
1:49:27 equipment and outdated systems than necessarily the knowledge of someone to keep them running. So between outsourcing the work and only having to pay for it when we actually need it and the need to save our money and purchase the updated equipment seems like something that we should be looking into before we start investing in a position to do that work.
1:49:57 Well, you know, I was in the meeting when Avery and Associates made their presentation on outsourcing, and I, my sense during that presentation that the council, you know, was unhappy with the report overall, but also felt in that report that there, although there was opportunities for outsourcing, there isn't a tremendous amount of opportunities for outsourcing. We certainly would look at it, we certainly need to do it. We allocated dollars for this position.
1:50:23 John? John?
1:50:50 Hopefully a little different change of direction. Personally, I have no concerns, and I'm very supportive of making these changes tonight. I'm personally excited about being able to hire this very qualified employee. And without doing this, in my mind, we would continue to be exposed and vulnerable. And for just an additional $5,000 a year, I'm fully supportive of doing this hire.
1:51:21 Thank you, John. Any other comments? I have a comment. I really can't appreciate where Skip's coming from as far as the HR comment. I know we had looked at that as a dual position. So certainly I think some we need to keep in the forefront of our minds. As far as this person and their qualifications, you know, one thing I've heard in a number of committees and commissions and all this that I've been working on is
1:51:50 A number of a growing need for higher technology. I know we've all spoken about it just to create the efficiency. We've talked about month-to-month reporting is a growing need. TOT enforcement, obviously. I know there's some software hurdles there. There's some software hurdles in accounting in general that we're obviously working with. Rick and I have been working with IE Group and whatnot.
1:52:17 The Economic Stimulus Council, we've been talking about working with the Chamber on various trending from various sectors of the community. So I do see a strong growing need for this, and I too would support it, but I do want to make note that I do recognize what Skip has mentioned. Excuse me just for a moment. My understanding was that at some point that the discussion about splitting the position
1:52:43 was to make that there was a discussion early on about hiring an administrative services director. That position was finance and HR directly oriented, that they were going to do that broader scope of work, and that based upon the workload and need in the organization, that we decided not to go that direction, but instead take that position and split it into two positions. One position is more financial TOT oriented, which we're talking about tonight. The other one was more clerical.
1:53:13 More oriented toward payroll. Right. A much lesser kind of role. So the result then was HR had to be kind of retooled into a different solution. And so that solution kind of emerged with Noreen willing to step up and do some of the work. And then I think for a long time prior to me getting here, Marianna took that role and responsibility. Yeah. So that has carried forward. And I'm assuming that that's what the council direction was and is. And that's what we're doing.
1:53:42 So I don't disregard it. I think that's just how I understood it to be. Is Noreen, do you feel comfortable with what's happening, I mean, as far as her? That's a personality. Let me answer your question differently than what you've asked it, though. One of the things that's happened, and you should be aware of it, is that when all of the administrative changes occurred over the past few months, a lot of staff stepped up, not just Noreen.
1:54:12 But, you know, Cindy has stepped up. Stu has stepped up. There's been a number of our employees who worked at different levels in the organization have stepped up. All of those employees are capable, qualified individuals. They need support and help. It's not a criticism, but we're asking them to do a whole lot of things that I think maybe a year ago they probably didn't know they were going to be doing today.
1:54:35 So to answer your question, we're working with that situation. They're very willing to step forward and do the hard, heavy lifting, and I really appreciate their efforts and work. Just like you said, I mean, Mariana is going to be leaving at some point, and the load that she has carried while she's been here, you talk about not recognized, we'll be lucky if we can get one person that can do what she has done for us.
1:55:03 We're on very thin ice in my mind and I'm tickled to death that we were able to get someone to apply for this position this well qualified and that we have an opportunity to bring them in. Before I get back to you, Skip, let me see if Rick has anything to say. No. Okay, let's go. Well, I think, Dave, you brought up a good point. The current staff has stepped up. The current staff also took a pay reduction and they lost benefits or both, one or the other. It's really hard for me to swallow.
1:55:32 I have asked my current staff, who have been loyal to us for a long time, to take pay reductions, and we're not just paying this person $5,000 more. We are going to the top of the pay scale that we allotted for this position and going $5,000 above that. If I was an employee of this town, I'd find that really hard to swallow, to be quite honest with you. And let's not forget,
1:56:00 That we do have a bit of a debt ahead of us, $42 million, I believe it is, and I think everybody in this town is going to end up paying in some way for that, whether they lose property, they lose parks, they lose services, whether they've given up some of their wages, we're all paying for it. And now we have a new person coming into town, and I just want to make it clear.
1:56:23 My concerns are about the hiring practices of the town. I know nothing about the individual, so it is not about the individual. It's about the hiring practices of this town. In the private sector, you identify the needs of your business, you create a position, and you hire an individual to fill that position. Financial incentives are given based on performance. It appears in our town and in government, you find an individual with skill.
1:56:52 And you create a position that fits the needs of that individual. You don't even have to prove your skills. You just have to tell a good story. And as a council member, on my first year in council, I was part of a hiring process where a person told a really good story. And we brought them in. And now, as described by yourself, it was a gift that keeps on giving. And that was not a complimentary comment.
1:57:19 about the problems that we had with that. For myself, fooled you once, shame on me, shame on you, fooled you twice, shame on me. I'm not going to be fooled twice. You know, we have to create a system when we bring people into this community, into our employment, that requires them to prove that they can handle not only the job that we have advertised for, but
1:57:48 Thank you very much.
1:58:17 Town salaries and wages get so out of control. How did they get so high? Why are we paying so much? We're going to go back and ask everybody to take another hit. And we may be asking some of our employees to do that again, depending on where this lawsuit flies. You never know. It could go that way, but yet someone who is not part of collective bargaining
1:58:37 May not be affected by that. It's a pretty cool way to come into the town at this stage of the game, to come in as a consultant whose pay may not be affected. Yeah, we could get rid of them if we can deem that position, if we can do without it, which doesn't seem likely, but to bring somebody in that would be exempt from any future agreements that we might make with other employees.
1:59:04 Again, as an employee of the town, I would have trouble with that. I think when you sit somebody down, when you advertise for a job and you sit somebody down and you start to interview them, the very first question you should ask them is, are you willing to work for the amount that we published? Point blank period. If they say no, they shouldn't be wasting your time with the interview. If for some reason this person you spent all this time interviewing and doing this competitive...
1:59:31 The other thing is that I think
2:00:04 All of us work here and live here and we know that if we went to a big city or we went someplace else and did the same job or had the same business that we have here, we would be making a lot less. We have all sacrificed in a big way to be able to stay in Mammoth and enjoy the beauty that we have here, the low crime rates.
2:00:26 The activities, everything that we have here, and to bring someone in and just give them everything they want, allow them to think that they can continue the same lifestyle they might have somewhere else, again, I don't think it's fair to the community to spend taxpayer dollars that way. So I think we need to rethink how we do it.
2:00:49 You know, if staff wants to spend all, if you want to offer somebody the top dollar of the amount that we have allotted for a position, right off the bat, go ahead, you know, but I just don't think that's a wise choice. I think we've been burned before, you know, all of us have in this hiring process. We have hired people, we've been told how great it is, what a wonderful job they're going to do.
2:01:14 And it doesn't pan out. It's happened repeatedly in this town. You can look at some of the other town manager positions, you know, people that have held that position. It just goes over and over again. You know, my position is if someone wants to fill this position as advertised, then it should be done within the guidelines the council originally set forth. I don't think we should be putting any more money forward on this, especially in these economic times.
2:01:42 And just as a, not to be argumentative, and I apologize for that, I think it's my job and duty to bring you the very best possible I can bring. We have a person who probably qualifies for that administrator position that you originally had talked about clear back in the fall, winter. This person will come as close to that as you'll find. You're probably saving, if you look at it from that point of view, $40,000 or $50,000 a year for a skill set. I think if you were to talk to individual employees,
2:02:10 They certainly have taken sacrifices and cuts. I think they've also had an incredibly large workload change, and they're looking for some relief in some capacities, not only in terms of what this person could do for them. For example, Stu is our main guy in the recreation division. He's also managing measure even our dollars. So, you know, Stu is a great guy. His job, his plate is full.
2:02:37 We need some support to his office to help manage those dollars in a way that the council expects us to manage them. It's not a criticism to Stu, it's not a criticism to Cindy. The fact is, the work is there and needs to be done. Now, if it's the council's desire, we talk to this individual, and if the council desires not to move forward with this, then the deal's off. We'll go back probably to the number two candidate, which you're going to find somebody who will work for the structured salary that we offered.
2:03:04 And we're going to get a product and outcome that's going to be okay. I think this is probably a fine person. We might decide to go back and recruit again, depending upon our conversations. I don't want to make a commitment over TV about that particular thing. But obviously, you have a difference of opinion about the duties and responsibilities relative to...
2:03:27 And we'll go forward, whatever that is. So I appreciate the comments.
2:03:56 And I appreciate the frank dialogue about that. Okay, Rick? Madam Mayor, call for the question. I would like to make a comment first, if you don't mind, since I get to go last. Getting back to the job description and having been involved in this, I see that it is an important step in the right direction. I see a complete distinction between...
2:04:19 What our current information technology staff is doing as far as technical support and doing it well and calling for backup from an outside company for technical support when he's gone, I have no problem with. I think that some of Dave's comments about
2:04:36 How abysmal the state of our computer systems are is an indication of the fact that there hasn't been anybody managing bringing the technology along. We have spent all of this money with IE
2:04:50 Consulting to get us a new budget and get us these templates and we have to be able to continue to support that. I also agree with the comments Matthew made about technology becoming more and more important, not less important. And based on that, I see that the description does outline very high priority duties that we need to have accomplished. Based on that and on Councilmember
2:05:18 Woods call for the question. Do we have a motion? Madam Mayor, I would move to approve the resolution adding the position of a budget and information technology manager to the unrepresentative executive category and authorize the salary range for the said position. I'll second it. We have a motion and a second. We have a roll call vote, please, Robin. Yes. No. Yes. Yes.
2:05:52 Yes. Motion passes 4-1. And we will move on to policy item number 11, which is appointment of an expired term on the Planning Commission. I was thinking, if it is the Council's pleasure, that we would first just name our top candidate and see how the votes fall from that. I'm not seeing anybody.
2:06:25 Matthew, did you want to make any kind of a comment? Yeah, I did. I had to recuse myself from the interview process with candidate John Verru, because I just wanted to make that known, so I have to excuse myself from that candidate. All right. Let's start with you, Skip. Your top candidate? Anita Hatter. Rick?
2:06:57 Mickey Brown. John? I had Robert Calvert. Matthew? Mickey Brown. And my first choice would be Tom Moody. Okay, so we do not... Madam Mayor, if I may. First of all, I wanted to make a general comment. We interviewed five people this afternoon. Those five people that were interviewed, I had...
2:07:34 Grouped all with very high and closely rated. I had one six, excuse me, I had two sevens and three eights. So, I mean, we had a really comparable group and qualified group. Mickey Brown was in, actually she was number two in my voting, so I would be at this time
2:08:02 Amenable to moving my first place vote to Mickey Brown as well. Okay, that would give three votes for Mickey, one for Anita and one for Tom. That is enough for an appointment. I'm just looking to see if anybody else has any comments.
2:08:26 I'll just comment that all the candidates were exceptional. I would have to agree with that. I only went with Anita because I felt her experience both with government and with the government process and her time in the community working within the town. I kind of wanted to make sure that we had...
2:08:48 Someone that represented the community with the question I asked. I was looking for someone that wasn't just focused on the development and growth aspect of the town, but that could clearly assist us in making sure that we get the needs of the citizens in the town. But with that said, Anita and Tom Moody and Mickey were all kind of the three I was tossing around, so I'm satisfied with it.
2:09:18 Skip real quick, and it's just a question maybe of legal counsel. It's my understanding, because Anita was in my top three as well. She'd had an excellent interview under trying circumstances for her. It's my understanding that she lives in the county as opposed to in the town, and I thought we had an ordinance that on Planning Commission we could only have one out-of-town commissioner, and we already have one. We already have one.
2:09:47 So I don't think we could have two. I was not aware of that. She lists her physical address in Mammoth. And registered to vote in the county. I just brought that up as a side note. I wasn't sure. I would also make the comment that I had the opportunity to watch Tom through the project that he mentioned during the interview, which was the old Mammoth place.
2:10:13 And the reason he had my top vote was that I saw him advocate for a position, but then when it got to the point where compromise was needed, I saw him work towards compromise, and I thought that that was extremely important. However, seeing that the majority of the council is in favor of
2:10:43 Mickey, I think that what we could do here is just have a motion. I'll move to appoint Mickey Brown as the applicant, or I should say, to fill the vacancy on the Planning Commission with the term of appointment to expire on July 31, 2014. I'd second that. We have a motion and a second. Could we have a roll call vote, please, Robin? Yes. Yes. Yes.
2:11:15 Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. Congratulations, Mickey. And I believe we are going to return to closed session to continue the discussion from earlier.
2:12:05 Thank you.
2:12:26 Okay, back to John, part of this was because we wanted you to be part of the discussion and how we'll bring you forward on.