TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2011

Town Council

· recording 4 hr 8 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

451 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

30:16 Which is a huge newspaper, also ranks for men's health. We'll have him coming over this year. Met with Runners World UK, which was fantastic. They're very interested in doing an article on what we have in our tiny little town here. And on the running side, again, if people didn't see, we had two great finishes last weekend. Actually, three great finishes. Congratulations, Rick. Finishing in the San Jose Half Marathon, we had Matt DeFlesden and Dina Kasker.

30:53 Take their first place in their respective fields. So, fantastic stuff. Got to keep us in the press. What was the third one you mentioned, John? I'm sorry? What was the third great finish or great time? Councilmember Wood, I believe, second place in his age group. Oh, I'm sorry. Thank you. Among a number of other locals that went over and raced in that event, so that was fantastic. I think there were about 10,000 people in there. Mev finished at 102, which was minute office time last year, which was still...

31:25 Much better than I can run a 10K. And then Dina had a 112, which again is a fantastic time. So I don't think she was pushing the baby on the way, but probably could have. John, did you hear any snow total numbers from the mountain today? You know, early this morning I heard near foot up in the mountain, but I haven't heard anything since then. Okay, thank you. Looks nice out there, though. Thank you. All right, thank you, John.

31:52 Jim, did you catch up? I forgot to hand out a piece of bulldog. Okay, just hand it out without telling us. Okay, Jim? Jim Smith, Mammoth Mountain. We are not opening tomorrow. That's my first comment. We've got about two feet, about mid-Chilea. Plenty of snow is a good starter, though. It's going to get pretty warm pretty quickly, unfortunately. Although, that's not the reason why I'm standing here. So, I'm here to kind of remind...

32:22 Staff, Council, the public that the Maiden Lodge land trade, which has been hanging around forever and a day, many people thought it would never happen, has actually kicked off. It started last Thursday. There was an open house here, and it actually wasn't very well attended. It was only about six folks. So I'm here to remind everybody that the Forest Service, who, although there's been some dispute as to what they've done, they've actually provided notice to all the right folks, all the right times, but based on, there was,

32:52 We were hoping for more people and more comments, so I'm going to remind everybody that the process has started off. It is a public scoping for the NEPA process. It's going to be an EA. All the information for the land trade is actually on the Inyo Forest website, so go there. Unfortunately, I don't know the information. There's also a comment section there. Feel free to call them out and talk to me or Ron Cohen, but the best thing to do is consolidate comments.

33:22 Through the website at the Pino National Forest. We'll also be having more public workshops. This is really just kicking it off, but I want to let everybody know that it's going, and I want to make sure we get all the comments we can. Okay? All right. Thank you, Jim. Lee, since we have such a long agenda, could you pass out the rest of the ones after your time? Thank you. Okay. I was here just before summer, and I talked about some emergency cards that I wanted to do.

34:12 The main reason I wanted to do it was back in December when we had the power outages and all the snow. I had a lot of people call me, what do I do, what do I do? And I had some people tell me that if their power was out to have them put their wood burners on. I remember calling the fire department up and I said, if their chimney's plugged up, can't carbon monoxide come back in the chimney? I don't want to be responsible for giving out any information that's not right. So I made up some emergency rat cards. They're finally done.

34:41 The Fire State Council backed this up. They got a grant from State Farm, and out of their grant, they gave me money to make up 10,000 of these. We would be passing them out all over town. I'll be working with Brent Harper on this, the Fire Chief. I want to put out a special thank to Brent Harper. He helped Aaron of Bluebird Imaging, and I have to stay extremely focused doing this. It took a while to get this done. I'm very proud of it. It has the Mammoth Lakes...

35:11 Public Information Number, a lot of people don't know about that. 934-8054, an event of an emergency, call it and it will explain to you what to do. It has Caltrans Number on it, Mammoth Mountain Ski Area Emergency Hotline, if you get hurt on the mountain, you can call that number. The Edison Emergency Service, if you have a power outage or problems with the electricity, you can call them. It has the radio stations, the weather report, Mammoth Mountain, and the tourism department.

35:39 I've already passed them out around town. The police department's got some, and I've asked them if they could put them in the cars also so the officers can pass them out. You can find them at the fire department, the post office. Steve Schwinn from Central Reservation of Mammoth, he's going to be putting it on his website. Anybody that has a reservation service, it would be a good idea to put it on your website. This is for the people, and it's good to get the information out there. There's one other person I'd like to thank, and it's Stuart Brown.

36:08 Stuart Brown came in at the end and helped us to come up with this, and I would like to thank you, Stuart. Stuart and I have a common theme of believing in the political process, listening to the people, and working together, so thank you. And these will be passed out all over town, and there's some in the back, some of you would like to pick them up. Thank you. Thank you, Lee. Lee, you should be proud of this. You should be very proud, and thank you for doing it. Thank you very much.

36:40 Okay, is there anyone else for public comment? Seeing none, we will move on to Councilmember Reports. Skip? Thank you. I will start off. I just wanted to let everyone know that the farmer's market is officially over as far as kind of having our space blocked off. However, if you drove down Main Street today, being

37:11 Because of the late start of the season, we still have some farmers that have crops coming in, and they are interested in trying to get them to the public up here. We had two hardy souls out there selling their product today, this afternoon, and they will be out there for the next few weeks at least in front of the outlet mall on Main Street. We have taken down the one-way street closure that we had up there for the time being, but they're going to occupy the parking spaces.

37:41 On the north side of the service road there. So they will still be out there as long as the crops keep coming in and weather allows them to be out there. Overall, I would say they were extremely happy about their newest location.

38:02 Main Street, if you recall, last year, and they were down in front of the P3 Mall, the Main Street Center, and this year we moved them up back on to town property just on the frontage road there in front of the outlet mall, and the farmers, the other vendors that we were able to attract felt it was a really worthwhile move. They continue to comment on how many different languages they now have at the farmer's market, which tells us that the tourists are seeing it.

38:29 Thank you. Thank you.

38:56 Just sort of tells me that we have a venue, you know, and we have venues in some of the places that we don't even think we have venues, but with a little bit of imagination, a little bit of work, you can make something happen, and I think we're committed, the certified farmers, myself, Sandra DiDomizio from Green Fox Events who helps coordinate all of the other vendors other than farmers there.

39:23 We're all committed, and I want to thank the town of Mammoth Lakes, particularly the Public Works staff, Dave and his staff, and everyone who kind of helped us pull the whole farmer's market thing together. So it was definitely a success this year. On the 28th, I did, as Joe mentioned, go for a ride with Randy Gillespie from Golden State Honda.

39:49 And Ed Amonto of the Forest Service, Bill Sauser was with us, John Regabugle was there, and several other folks that helped drive the rhinos around. We went out to Glass Creek and did a little drive, and I'll be the first one to admit that I fully support and still did support and still support the Wilderness Act that is helping to preserve a lot of our wilderness. But with anything of that size and that scale,

40:17 Once it's enacted, you're going to go back and take a look at it and you're going to say, hey, maybe this didn't really work. It wasn't exactly as we had planned. Maybe we can do it a little bit better. And what we did is we looked at some of the areas where roads have been closed that maybe created a loop that allowed people to have a continuous ride and kept traffic flow moving. And instead, you have to go straight up to a point.

40:43 Where there isn't anything. You just stop in the woods and there's barely room to turn your vehicle around and still stay on a paved road. Or there's another spot where maybe you get within 300 yards of a beautiful campsite where people and their families used to take their fifth wheels and be able to introduce their kids to the edge of the wilderness or be able to take their elderly parents there and have a nice weekend or something and let them.

41:12 Kind of enjoy that front country experience of the wilderness and that has been blocked off. So it's my understanding that we do have the ability working with our regional forest offices and directors that we have the ability to make some adjustments in these routes and make it work. And one of the things that I think we need to really focus on is this is a revenue source for both for the entire eastern Sierra and Bishop is well on its way.

41:42 To creating what they call the Adventure Trail System where you can get into Rhino and you can drive your Rhino from Lone Pine all the way up into Bishop and have routes that you can take and when you get to different locations you can have your choice of maybe doing wilderness camping or if you want to get into a hotel or you want to stop in and get groceries at a market.

42:05 Get gas for your vehicle, something of that nature. You have the ability to safely access all of these areas, and I think that is a program that we need to seriously consider adopting and moving throughout Mono County, because as you look at North County particularly, the revenue up there, they need a good solid revenue source and properly maintained, properly enforced, and with the proper education.

42:32 This could really go a long way for bringing a whole new element of revenue resource into our area. So it was a very interesting, eye-opening tour that I took with them, and I want to thank all of them for inviting me to go along with that. I haven't reported for the past couple meetings, so I've got quite a few things. I can just go on and on and on. I was lucky enough, and I have gotten, I think, somehow onto the list for the Eastern Sierra California

43:03 Transportation Planning Group. And what that is, is it is really just Caltrans, Inyo, Mono County, Kern County, Sandbag, which is kind of the San Bernardino Transportation Group. And they get together quarterly. And whatever the meetings are here in Mammoth, I'd like to attend them because they talk a lot about projects that are going on throughout that area. And personally,

43:29 I know there is such a value to 395 becoming four lane out of LA in all directions, whether you're going to Mojave or you're going out to the Victorville area. When we see that four laning happening, the easier it gets to drive up here, the more people that are going to come. It's like opening up an artery, you know, doing a bypass and getting that artery open and making the body healthier when 395 becomes four lane all the way through.

43:58 We're going to continue. We're getting healthier, and we're going to get a lot healthier when all that happens. So just so people know, as we look at projects down the road, if you're going down 395 to the south, you're going to see Olantia project that is still in the works. It's been partially funded for planning, but they're waiting for more funding to finish it off, but still looks like possibly in the year 2017.

44:26 We could see that bypass done. Once you get on to 14, there's a little place called the Homestead, and that's where the four lane goes into two lane until you get to Red Rock Canyon. They divided that into three sections, and so they now have the funding to look towards doing section one, probably within the next three or four years, about a five mile section, and each section is approximately five miles long.

44:54 Again, within probably the next six to eight years, that will all be four-lane. There is also, they are looking very seriously and very soon at the, as you go down 395 and you get to Kramer Junction, it's one of those intersections where things just back up immensely, particularly on holiday weekends. They're looking at doing an interchange there because they have a project linking Kern County over to the 15 and the 40.

45:24 And that project will actually create an interchange there that will get rid of the stoplight and the cross traffic and at least help traffic flow more smoothly through there. And as you get down towards the bottom of 15, towards the Atalanto area, there's always been a big question of how to get people through Atalanto and all that area a lot easier. The folks in Atalanto are opposed to a bypass through there because of the way it...

45:51 It cuts into some of the properties that are on there in development, and it cuts them into two small sections. They want to just improve that four-lane highway from 15 over to the 395, make it a minimum impact, what am I trying to say here, limited access highway as you move across there, but even better, it appears LA Metro wants to get trucks out of the

46:21 The 10 and the 15 freeways down there. So they have proposed and are working on the funding for what they call the High Desert Corridor, which will be an expressway running from Palmdale over to the 15 through Atalanto, which means that as you're going down to 395, instead of having to do that last section of 395 down to the 15, they will begin to direct people down this expressway.

46:48 Over to the 15. So it will help us in a small way also. But it's a fairly major project and that looks like it's definitely a reality. So I found that to be quite interesting. And I think I did attend a school, unified school district liaison meeting, but I think since Rich is here and is going to speak to Major S in a little bit, I will leave that to Rich. So thank you. Thanks, Skip. Rick?

47:20 I'm not going to go on and on. It's been a month, and we have had a whole lot of meetings. See if I can do this in one minute. Town County Liaison Committee meeting wanted to simply report that the county has committed to, maybe they've already done it, I haven't been out there in the last couple of weeks, basically paving the airport road. Those of you who have been out there know that it's been pretty rough, and so they've got the funding and the wherewithal to do that.

47:49 I attended a couple of meetings on behalf of the Recreation Subcommittee with respect to the MLTPA effort or lead effort to forge a relationship with the United States Forest Service, including a kickoff meeting with the Forest Service. I just got to tell Councilmembers this just continues to be extremely productive, and I emphasize that. Forest Service philosophically is on board with...

48:18 I know that everybody thinks that the federal government is broke, but it does print money, and money does come our way here and there, and so I see that as very productive. And the other thing, of course, is that they're looking to us as well as a source of funding for projects that might be essentially within our sphere of influence, but outside the...

48:48 Limits of the Town of Mammoth Lakes. And as we know, when a visitor comes up here, I don't know whether the visitor knows where the limits of the Town of Mammoth Lakes are. I don't think they care, so long as they're having a good and important recreational experience. Last but not least, a couple of Mammoth Lakes housing meetings in this last month. I just want to share two things. One is...

49:12 That we have received, I've not yet reviewed because it's 170 pages, the draft community housing needs assessment, some pretty fascinating stuff upon first glance in there. I'm going to present or put together a summary and get it to council. Community will be pretty interested, I think, to see what the needs assessment is projecting as current and future needs for housing in the community.

49:39 And secondly, there is a vacancy on the Board of Directors for Mammoth Lakes Housing. We are looking to fill it. The bylaws provide the Board can fill it. And we're hoping to find a person within the community that we serve, specifically the workforce and or the Hispanic community.

50:04 To serve on that committee. So if there's anybody that's interested or anyone who knows somebody who might be interested, you might let me know and I'll certainly make contact. That's it. Thanks. Thank you, Rick. John? Joe, I'm in deference to the length of our agenda tonight. I'm going to defer any reports. No reports. Okay. Well, since I was on vacation, I don't have many reports, but I would like to let my fellow

50:31 Councilmembers and the community know that the American Planning Association California Chapter awarded a first place to the town of Mammoth Lakes for our downtown concept for Main Street document, so it was recognized at the California state level. Do we have any additions to the agenda? Seeing none, we will move on to commission updates.

51:03 Okay, then we will move on to department reports and emerging issues. Good evening, Mayor, members of the Council. I'd like to let you know that we have posted for public review the draft initial study for the Town of Mammoth Lakes Parks and Recreation Master Plan Project. That is located on our website, if you care to view it and comment, in our Parks and Recreation Master Plan update file. Also, we will publish on Monday

51:34 The draft general plan mobility element and begin the workshops with the town commissions on this very important document. It's rather extensive. We have about a four inch technical summary that goes with this document and we intend to hold our workshops and cheer before the town council on this draft document in December or January. It's a very progressive document and is focused on

52:04 Our feet first principles in the general plan. And also we will post tomorrow our final report that we have received from EPS, the Mammoth Lakes Economic Forecast and Revitalization Strategies. This is the work that Walter Kieser was doing for us in regards to our economic development and market-based forecast of projects for the town. So that information is all coming.

52:32 Some of it's posted. Some will be posted tomorrow and the rest on Monday. Thank you. Mark, what was the deadline for comments on the draft? This is a 30-day public review period, and comments can be received in writing no later than November 4th, 2011. Giving counsel, Dave Wilpert, Town Manager. Just a couple things. I want to introduce Mike Dang to you. He's our new budget manager, IT manager. Mike, stand up.

53:06 So he's been with us a couple weeks and he hasn't left yet, so that's good news for us. And we're hoping that as time passes he has a chance to work with each of you and if you have any questions for us he can help answer, please let us know. And I also want to report to you and the community that we're continuing to work with our creditor, MLLA. We had meetings this week. We've transitioned from providing information, and I think I've reported to you in the past that they have been diligent in their requests for information.

53:35 I've provided literally reams and reams and reams, and they now are satisfied that they've received everything they've asked for, and we're now moving into negotiations, and we had meetings with them this week, about three days worth, three hours a day, so about nine full hours, and we're moving, I think, over the next few months to make some progress in that area, so I just wanted to report that we're now in the negotiation stage. Thank you, Dave. Any other departments?

54:07 In that case, I will ask if there are any council members or members of the public who wanted to remove items from the consent agenda? Nope. Madam Mayor, I'll move for adoption of consent agenda items 1 through 9. I'll second that. We have a motion and a second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Council Member Eastman? Yes. Council Member Harvey? Yes. Council Member Wood? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Laney? Yes. Mayor Bacon? Yes. Motion passes 5-0.

54:36 We will now move on to our policy matters, and the first one is a presentation from Suzy Baines of Wild Iris. Good evening. I am Suzy Baines. I'm from Wild Iris. I'm the program director, and I am mostly these days stationed here in Mammoth working out of Mono County. But I'm here this evening to ask the town council to proclaim October as Domestic Violence Awareness Month. This year marks our 30th year.

55:09 Anniversary of Wild Iris serving victims of domestic violence. Our agency began in 1981 with a telephone in the living room of one of our founding mothers, Anne Bishop, and that first year they received two phone calls. Back then domestic violence was seen as a lesser offense. It was treated more as a private family matter. Victims were often sent home from the hospital without intervention.

55:36 And children were often left to suffer in silence. And as a consequence, the abuse would go on for years and in many cases the violence would only end with the death of a woman or a child. We've come an incredibly long way since that time. We know a lot more and we're much more knowledgeable than we were 30 years ago. We've changed the laws and we've made progress in changing the way that people think about domestic violence. But our work isn't finished.

56:03 Today, one in four women will experience domestic violence in her lifetime. Almost one-third of female homicide victims that are reported in police records are killed by an intimate partner. Nationally, the cost of intimate partner violence exceeds $5.8 billion each year, $4.1 billion of which is for direct medical and mental health services. Locally, during the 2010-11 fiscal year,

56:30 Wild Iris received nearly 300 domestic violence-related hotline calls, provided 121 safe haven bed nights to victims and their children, and helped 42 families establish new homes because they were displaced due to domestic violence. During the month of October, Wild Iris is promoting awareness about domestic violence through a traveling exhibit of life-size silhouettes.

56:54 The exhibit will move from Cerro Coso, where it is today, to the Mammoth Courthouse, the Library, Mammoth Hospital, and will end its tour at the Bridgeport Clinic. The exhibit serves to honor the transformation of victim to survivor, for that is our ultimate goal, to transform lives. We work not only to help break the cycle of violence, but to help victims overcome the financial and legal barriers that they face, and to connect them to the community resources.

57:23 Thank you so much.

57:51 I thank you for giving me a little time this evening to say my spiel and to bring the awareness to this forum as well as to the community at large. Thank you, Susie. Are there questions? You will notice that what we have done is put the presentation and the proclamation together as an agenda item. So if there are no questions or discussion, I would entertain a motion to approve a proclamation for claiming October's Domestic Violence Awareness Month. I'll make a motion. Second.

58:20 We have a motion to second. Can we have a roll call vote, please, Jamie? Councilmember Eisman? Yes. Councilmember Harvey? Yes. Councilmember Wood? Yes. Mayor Porton-Laymond? Yes. Mayor Bacon? Yes. Motion passes 5-0. And through the miracles of modern technology. We're pre-planning. Thank you so much.

58:58 Next, we have a presentation regarding Measure S, and I will point out to Councilmembers that there is a revised resolution that you should have received. Good evening, Madam Mayor, Councilmembers, staff, and members of the community. My name is Rich Bacci, and I am proud to be the Superintendent of Schools for the Managed Unified School District. I'm joined tonight in this short presentation by Board Member Gloria Vasquez and Parent Teacher Stacy Posey.

59:30 We all know that great schools have great communities and that great communities have great schools and thus our vision, schools as great as the mountains. We all know that this is not an easy task. We can celebrate that both our elementary and middle schools crossed the 800 mark on the state academic performance index this past spring, which is a measure of success for California public schools. We can take great pride that our high school was named a California Distinguished School this past spring.

59:57 What we all know, there is much more work to be done. We have some serious challenges as a community, and they can only be addressed through the development of a collaborative, cooperative among all of the stakeholders of this community. We're too small, they're not standing together. I believe that over these past 18 months, if this school district has exhibited their desire to be an active player at the table, we are only as strong as all of us together. My main goal tonight over these next few minutes, I know we have a long agenda,

1:00:27 It is to provide the council with a school district update and to ask for your support of a resolution supporting Measure S. This past September, we began to look at our spring data. We began to look at our vision statement. We began to revise our plans, looking three to five years out. Our vision, schools as great as our mountains. We had a broad group of stakeholders joined together for a long day and a half, members of the community, business, schools, public and private sectors.

1:00:56 We went through the SWOT process, strength, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats. We came up with six major themes that will lead to strategies, and our next step is to meet on November 4th to process those action plans. First, achieving and sustaining financial stability. Establish and maintain the financial resources necessary to accomplish our vision. Culture and values. Develop a transparent, collaborative, performance-based culture. Communication and leadership.

1:01:24 Improve communication with key stakeholders, teachers, students, parents, and the larger community. Programming. Create and implement programming consistent with the variety and quality stated in our vision statement. Leveraging resources. Creatively seek out and utilize underused resources, both physical and intellectual, to best support excellence in education. And technology. Embrace technology. Develop and maintain a technological platform.

1:01:52 And educate our stakeholders as to what will be effectively used by all constituents. So based on those big ideas, we stepped back as a governing board on a board study session on September 8th and came up with five district priorities for this school year. Number one, preserve and strengthen our district's fiscal health. As you knew, California public schools have been reducing funding by $18 billion over the last three years.

1:02:17 Mammoth Unified reduced their operating budget by $911,000 for this school year. My team members will talk more about Measure S and the implications. Number two, improved student achievement for all students, narrowed the gap for underperforming subgroups by implementing a comprehensive data-driven approach to continuous improvement. We're using something called an online assessment center, instructional maps, backward mapping, target instruction for students who need acceleration.

1:02:46 Number three, increase rigor and pathway options and track the progress of our graduates in order to evaluate the effectiveness of our programs in our public schools. Number four, begin to adopt the common core standards. Common core standards are the new national standards coming out of the race at the top in the Obama administration. We're looking at initial assessments in the spring of 2014, so we're trying to get out in front of that in the areas of English, language, arts, and math. And number five, enhance the public image of the district.

1:03:15 Through transparent, consistent communication to all stakeholders. As I shared, Measure S is an important part of our number one priority in the district, which is to maintain our fiscal stability. So with that, I'd like to introduce Gloria and Stacey to speak a little bit to that. Ladies, please. Hi, good evening. My name is Stacey Posey. I've lived in Mammoth for 16 years, and I've been teaching at the elementary school for 12 years. And I'm here to talk tonight about Measure S.

1:03:46 I'm really, I'm proud to live in such an amazing, beautiful town, and I'm even more blessed to work at such an amazing school, the elementary school. I have three children in the district. Next year I'll actually have one at each school site, but right now my oldest is in high school, so I've actually, he's gone through all the school sites, and as a parent, I'm not just a teacher, I've experienced the hardworking staff that we have at all school sites.

1:04:15 If we don't commit to passing Measure S, we will lose half the staff. They will lose their jobs. So that's a concern for me as a parent because it will affect my child's education, all three children's education. Those staff members are also members of the community, so it will affect our community as well.

1:04:38 I've taught for 12 years at the elementary school. Currently I teach third grade. I have 24 students in my class. Very manageable amount of students with various levels of learning. And as Mr. Bacha has said, we surpassed our 800 mark at the elementary school. Very difficult task. But we did it. Yay! But without Measure S, those class sizes will increase.

1:05:03 Possibly double. So the 24 kids, the manageable number I have right now could surpass 40. As a teacher, I'm worried because the education of the students is very important. As a parent, I'm very concerned for my own children. The students currently have access to newer textbooks, technology, wonderful libraries in each school site with incredible librarians running all of those libraries. If Measure S doesn't pass,

1:05:35 Students will lose access to all of those things plus more. Measure S, if it doesn't pass, it will affect the students, it will affect the families, it will affect the teachers and staff, all of who are members of our community. So our school needs your support, just like the town needs great schools. So we work together, and I need us to work together so that we can pass Measure S on November 8th. So, thank you. Thank you, Stacey.

1:06:06 Good evening, Council, Mayor Bacon and Councilmembers. I'm Gloria Vasquez. I'm the retired principal of the middle school and now on the school board. And I am here tonight also to urge you to pass the resolution in favor of the parcel tax measure on the ballot, November 8th, Measure S. Measure S is a renewal of a parcel tax that's been in place for the last eight years and has been supported.

1:06:37 By our town and by our voters for these last eight years. It's up for renewal at $59 per parcel for an owner of a parcel within the limits of the school district. That works out to about $1.13 per week that parcel owners would be contributing towards the success of our schools.

1:07:05 The parcel tax generates $660,000 per year to support the school programs that Stacey just mentioned. And we have budget assumptions as we begin to plan for the 2012-2013 year that include a possible reduction through the proposed budget cuts that might be coming from the state in January of this year of a reduction of $1.2 million.

1:07:35 We need to plan for the worst-case scenario, and the worst-case scenario would be that the members of our community, the voters, would not pass Measure S by the two-thirds majority that it needs. If it's not successful on November 8th, and the state of California pulls both triggers in their mid-year cuts, that would be $1.2 million in reductions for our next school year.

1:08:03 We are in the process of crafting what those budget cuts could look like. It will definitely affect programs, services, the students and staff. And so we are hoping, we are praying that the continued support will come from the voters of our community to renew this parcel tax for the schools on November 8th.

1:08:31 One of the things that I have always loved and cherished about the town of Mammoth Lakes in the nine years that I've been able to live here full time is how we come together as a community whenever there is someone who has been injured, been ill, suffered grief, or had some kind of financial instability or financial crisis.

1:08:58 And we come together as a family and as a community to rally around and to support when that happens. And that's what's getting ready to happen if the parcel tax would not pass on November 8th. The students of our community are our most precious resource, but they're also our most vulnerable. And so I hope that we can rally the support of the community and you as our

1:09:25 As representatives of our leaders of the community in passing the resolution in favor of Measure Ask tonight. Thank you. Thank you, Gloria. We appreciate your continued support of our journey towards greatness. Any questions for me, I'd be more than happy to answer. John? One is a statement and then two quick questions. The need is clearly present for this funding and for...

1:09:57 Okay. My final question this evening is,

1:10:27 It says that there's an exemption for property owners over 59 years of age, or 65. 65, correct. I think that there's a number of people in that category who would choose to pay that amount. What do they need to do to not take advantage of an exemption? Anything? Just don't apply for it. Just don't apply. Every June in the paper, our business manager puts the exemption in, just don't apply for it. Okay, thank you. Thank you, John.

1:10:56 All right. Are there any other questions? All right. We again at this time have in front of us consideration of a resolution endorsing and in support of Measure S. So we take comments and or a motion. I'm just going to make a quick comment if I could. Rich originally came to me and talked to me about this, and it was largely because I'm pretty heavily opposed to taxes.

1:11:27 Obviously, like many of us are, but especially in these hard times. And I've always felt that our school system needs a lot of work on a federal level and a state level and whatnot. So I really needed some convincing. And when I spoke with Superintendent Bocce, I think he, understanding who he is and who we have there, I felt pretty good and pretty solid about the fact that this was going to a good place. And I think that our superintendent is, in fact,

1:11:56 Coming up with some good deliverables and some good action items, I think, to help our schools locally. I wouldn't support it on a very long term, only because I think we need to fix some of the root of our problems, but I certainly do support it, and Superintendent Pacha, I thank you for helping educate me on it. Thank you, Matthew.

1:12:18 Madam Mayor, as the only council member with children in the school district, I would move to adopt resolution number 11-57, which is the revised resolution for us tonight, supporting Mammoth Unified School District Measure S. I'll second. We have a motion and a second. Can we have a roll call vote, please, Jamie? Council Member Eisman? Council Member Harvey? Council Member Harvey? Council Member Boyd? Council Member Boyd? Council Member Boyd? Council Member Boyd?

1:12:44 Yes, motion passes 5-0, and again, in anticipation, we have coffee for you. Thank you very much. We appreciate your continued support. Thank you, Madam Mayor. Thank you very much. Thank you very much. Okay. Our next item is presentation and adoption of rest strats to recreation implementation strategy. Thank you. Madam Mayor, City Council.

1:13:32 Town Council, excuse me. Carl, before you get started, could we get some of the lights down so that everyone can see the PowerPoint well? Sure. Thank you for having me here today. Glad the weather cooperated to get down here. And I'm here tonight to present to you an overview of Rex Stratt's process and some of the recommendations. I know your agenda is very, very crowded, and that will be as prompt and as quick as I possibly can.

1:14:02 Sir, you didn't have any difficulty on the highway getting down here? No, it was more, I live in South Lake Tahoe, and so it was snowing there, and I thought, oh my God, I've got to drive. But once I got over Kingsbury grade, it was spitting snow, it was fine. Okay, thank you. Real quickly, rec strats, I know, has been a very popular topic for a number of months within the community.

1:14:30 Our team from SMG were facilitators for the project, and the team included myself, Austin McInery, who's had a lot of experience in public meeting facilitation here, and Dana Stroud, who provided significant on-the-ground support, arranging meetings, and making sure we all sort of met and got the correct information out at the right times.

1:14:57 Additionally, there's a significant amount of people within your community that deserve thanks. The folks that were part of the original rec strats meeting, they put in a ton of time. Several of the town council put in time. And all the people that came to these meetings from the community put in a lot of time, as well as the rec commission put in a lot of time.

1:15:22 We were mere facilitators of a very fluid process that involved a lot of members within the community. Real quickly, the project goal was to develop and implement a strategy for the elements that were originally identified in rec strats one. Project objectives included to produce a community-based categorized and prioritized list of recreation projects, programs, and services.

1:15:51 Identify responsible partners, organizations, and so forth. Identify potential funding sources. Identify transportation mobility issues. Identify proposed timeline for overall implementation. There were three phases to this project. The first phase was pretty exhaustive information collection. And that consisted of a number of different components. First, we had public comment stations at various locations.

1:16:19 I want to thank Stuart for helping. He was a tremendous help in a lot of this information, but he was a guy who gave us some insight on where to put these stations. We had an online survey, which was both in Spanish and in English, and I want to thank Rich and his assistants with helping arrange for the translations. Again, it was a lot of people working on this project. And then finally, we had a number of community workshops.

1:16:47 Starting in March and going through June, and we had many, many people attending. Overall, just to give you a sense of that, we had roughly 85 online comment forms completed surveys. We had 227 attendees at the various workshops, of which there were 95 individual people, so a significant amount of folks from the town.

1:17:15 There was a website that had over 1,100 visitors to the site from the community. So we had significant amount of community participation throughout this entire process. And we met individually. We met whoever wanted a meeting. We met with as many folks who had an interest in meeting. And so I felt we got a very good sense of input from the community. The second phase was developing a draft plan, which

1:17:44 We reviewed all the input that we got from everywhere. Sheets that were filled out at the community workshops, notes that were put on the flip charts. We went through everything and worked them into a cohesive strategy and plan, which you have. I don't want to go through that too much in detail. There's a lot of detailed work there. And we presented the draft plan to the rec commission on July 12th.

1:18:13 We took their input as well as community input and reprocessed it through the, you know, integrated into the plan and then provided copies back. Phase three is the final plan which you have in front of you or in your packets and again that represents the compilation of a lot of work. Getting through the recommendations because I think those were the key elements here.

1:18:42 First recommendation was develop short to long term view. We look at funding potential for measure R and measure U and what we wanted to do or what the recommendations that came out of this were don't look at it all to be spent in one year. Look at a long term strategy. What could be spent this year? What could be spent on capital projects over the long term? Don't just sort of spend the pot of money. Look at it as

1:19:11 We've got to spend it all on these five projects this year, but look at a long-term horizon and how you can create an asset base or increase your asset base. Secondly, undertake project feasibility. At the end of the report, you will find a huge consolidated list of projects, both capital and non-capital projects. Additionally, there's a separate list, what we call unlinked. These were projects that didn't quite fit anywhere but still have very strong merit.

1:19:42 And need for the community. Things like fish stocking, upgrading municipal recreation and so forth. And all of these are important projects. But one of the things that we consistently saw throughout the process was a need for undertaking project feasibility. In the past, part of the comments were that the town had embarked on investing in projects without a full feasibility study.

1:20:08 And that is one of the things that came across in a lot of the comments and whatnot. And again, not just including construction costs, but what's the market potential for projects? And again, we have specific recommendations on what should be included in a feasibility study. And again, I'm sure there's more you could add, but at least that's the basics that we felt comfortable recommending, particularly with capital projects. They really do need a strong feasibility component.

1:20:37 Third, I further refine the publicly identified project elements. There are short-term projects that are low-hanging fruit that can be done in a very short order. Adoption of the trail system master plan, which I think is in your short-term future here. There's some very low-hanging fruit. Increased coordination with the Inyo National Forest. Councilmember Wood spoke to that issue. These are all things that can be done.

1:21:05 In a short, fairly short term, but, you know, portend huge benefit. And so we want to refine that and get these things implemented as quickly and as efficiently as we possibly can. Capital projects, there were significant numbers of capital projects, including field house, multi-outdoor use facility, indoor performing arts, aquatic facilities, high altitude training.

1:21:36 And so forth. And part of the need is to look at your other community partners out there and find how dollars can be leveraged. Not just with your money. I know the school district, hopefully their measure will pass. They might be an excellent partner for some of this. Or somebody else might be an excellent partner. There's real need to look at leverage in how you bring these together. Both other public organizations as well as private organizations.

1:22:03 Could be leveraged partners in some of these major capital projects. Clearly a need to undertake an annual review and update and see where you're moving, how fast you're moving through, what projects can get done, what projects are still in the hopper, and where opportunities may lie. Some of these may take a little while to get done. There's a lot of pre-planning, especially the capital projects take a long time.

1:22:32 I think it's important for the rec commission as well as the council to aggressively look at this on an annual basis or twice a year at least in terms of getting through some of the projects and what's the status and so forth. I know you have a process with Measure R. There's also a process with Measure U that can look at how to develop funding systems and mechanisms and again that should be compared against

1:23:02 The recommendation and the project list. Arts and culture is a huge supporter. There's a lot of interest in arts and culture, but we really need to bring forward some champions within the community to help support this on a much bigger playing field. And arts and culture can be all-encompassing.

1:23:26 And it's the one thing that can very helpfully differentiate a destination, a community, as well as provide local residents with the benefit of arts and culture in their lives. But it really needs the ability to come together, all these elements come together and be a force within the community. I think a lot of opportunity exists if more and more people in this area have a keen interest.

1:23:53 Would work together and create a vision and a strategic plan and so forth. Funding sources, again, I talked briefly, but we identify a lot. Everything from the town of Mammoth Lakes, school district, non-government organizations, grants, user groups, private sector, businesses, Inyo National Forest, Mono County.

1:24:19 LA Department of Water and Power, membership, user fees. There's lots of places to find partnership dollars. One of my favorite sayings is money finds a good idea. You know, if you've got a good idea, money will find it. And the key is putting together good ideas, letting people know, identifying partners, and when they see a good idea, the money will flow. It's amazing how that little thing works.

1:24:46 And again, we think that you guys have a huge opportunity with R&U working in seed capital, starting capital to again sit down with other partners throughout the community as well as partners outside. Transportation mobility, there are a number of opportunities identified in the workshops and these are a summary of them, you know, emphasize access to trails.

1:25:17 Feet first as somebody earlier, Mark spoke to earlier, free public transit, all these elements speak to an integrated recreation experience and mobility is a key piece to that. And if you look at the communities that have solved this, places like Vail, places like Whistler, they really provide a comprehensive package.

1:25:43 And ability to access the amenities, I think it makes your destination and your community a lot stronger. I happen to live in South Lake Tahoe where we have a $14 million need but a $4 million budget. And it's very challenging, but I think, again, there's some opportunities out there and mobility is sort of the glue that sort of makes it all fit well together.

1:26:14 So where it leads us today is to your adoption. I will tell you on a personal note, it's one of the best, most funnest projects I've ever worked on, one of the most unique projects. I don't know of another town that has identified recreation in a strategic way and is willing to take the steps to put together relationships like with the Inyo National Forest and others and to really make recreation an integral part.

1:26:43 Thank you, Carl. Are there questions of Carl?

1:27:14 I don't have a question, but I was just, as I often do, writing a couple of notes down of comments that I was going to make, and you just took the words out of my mouth in the last couple of paragraphs. I appreciate the work that you've done and can't say it any differently or better than you have. Thank you. Again, a lot of people worked on this. And actually, it's going to sound like I somehow channeled your PowerPoint beforehand, but there were a few things. First of all, I wanted to thank the community and everyone that was involved in it.

1:27:46 It was a lot of work. It was a lot of meetings, but we have some very good results. We have an implementation strategy. In particular, I think that having a projects list is very important to us. The concept of looking short to long term is very important as we're going forward. I especially like the feasibility section, especially identifying that there's both a demand analysis and a cost analysis that has to be completed.

1:28:15 And I will also reiterate, because it's a concern of mine, that we are still lacking in the arts and culture area, and it's an area that I, as one member, want to help the community trying to figure out how to come together and get those champions going. It does not mean that rec strats is not a good document. In fact, I think, though, that it's going to lead into some of the other discussions we have when we consider the later agenda items.

1:28:45 We do need to figure out how, as a government, we can support getting some kind of an art and culture group moving together. One last comment, Madam Mayor. I think if Red Strats did nothing else, it exposes that, that there is a need and it's fragmented, but there's huge upside, and so that's a good thing. The other last comment I'll make.

1:29:17 I know there's a lot of different processes going on in town, and the list that comes out of here at some point can be married with some of these other processes. You're going to have a really good view of a lot of things, and I think the more this can be integrated into the other processes that are going on, I think it benefits the community. Is there any member of the public who wishes to comment on this?

1:29:46 Recreation Strategy and Implementation. More questions? Okay. In that case, I will either deliberation or I'd entertain a motion. Madam Mayor, I just want to say that I think you hit it on the head. It's been said a couple times that this really incorporates an implementation plan, and that is so critical because this community is full of great ideas, and we've had them one after another, and we always get to a certain point.

1:30:20 To where we can't quite get over that hump to get them implemented and get them moving on to where they become something tangible that we can actually see in action. And I think the work that has gone into this with community input is fantastic. You've done a great job. And I would make a motion. A second. We have options. I will.

1:30:50 Get to my right page here. I'd like to make a motion that we adopt direct stress to recreation implementation strategy recommended by the Recreation Commission and presented by staff and B, provide direction to the commission and staff on implementing any of the recommendations identified in the document. Okay. Now, Matthew? I will second. Point of order? Yes. Do we need in our motion to indicate the adoption of resolution?

1:31:21 As well. Or is that understood? See what I mean, David? Yes. Okay. I will amend my motion to include the adoption of the resolution as written. And will the seconder also agree to that amendment? Okay. We have a motion and a second. Can we have a roll to call vote, please? I want to address part B.

1:31:48 Because it suggests that tonight we're going to provide direction, and I would suggest that the direction comes actually in a couple of the agenda items that we have and will come from time to time. Just a couple of things that sort of hang in the way of providing specific direction. One is the litigation that overhangs everything here.

1:32:16 In the town it makes it difficult for us to plan. We're trying to run a government as if we don't have a judgment, recognizing that we do have a judgment over hanging and are doing the best that we can. But I will say that the measures RNU provide opportunities for funding of specific projects. There are processes in place to fund identified priorities.

1:32:46 In addition, we've got the CIP before us, which obviously includes projects that are part of or come out of rec strats. I think the important part of this document is actually not tonight having to come up with a list of what it is that we're going to do next and how we're going to finance it or fund it. It is instead

1:33:13 Just one more piece along the road toward establishing the priorities that we have maybe assumed to exist but have not actually put into a structured presentation. This really sort of becomes a guiding document. It's not one that's going to go up on a shelf. It's also a living document, and we would expect to change as

1:33:40 Priorities change as opportunities arise and so on. Most importantly, and I've seen it in particular in the kickoff meeting with the folks from the international forest, it is an expression of our commitment as a community to recreation-oriented activities, both as they relate to quality of life or impact it, and two, as they drive tourism.

1:34:06 And with that, we have a renewed and enthusiastic interest in collaboration and cooperation from that entity, and I'm sure others as well. So, very important document in and of itself, and I don't think that we have to specifically identify tonight what it is that we're going to do to implement it or to...

1:34:34 Spend money that we have consistent with the priorities that are there. So, those are my comments. Okay, any other ones? Okay, roll call vote, please, Jamie. Councilmember Houston? Yes. Councilmember Harvey? Yes. Councilmember Wood? Mayor Pro Tem, Landon? Yes. Mayor Bacon? Yes. Mayor Bacon? Yes. Motion passes 5-0 through the recreation strat. Implementation strategy is adopted. Thank you.

1:35:00 I'm going to ask Council whether you feel you're ready for a break or want to continue another item before we take a break. Do one more? Okay. We will now move on to agenda item number 13, which is receive and accept the town attorney's memo regarding supplanting as it relates to measures R and U. Thank you, Madam Mayor. I don't know how much of a presentation you'd like. You do have the memo. You've had a chance to review it. I'd be happy to.

1:35:32 Explain it briefly for the benefit of the audience, for those watching at home, and be happy to answer questions, whatever your pleasure is. I would think a short summary, and then there might be, as public comments, there may be further questions that come from there as well as from Council. Okay, fair enough. The first question that we needed to address in the memo was whether Measure R, Measure U can establish a minimum spending level for the town. That's an idea that has been kicked around.

1:36:02 Some people have been under the impression that the two measures do commit the town to maintaining existing levels of funding. California law is pretty clear in saying that voter initiative measures cannot bind public agencies to spending any minimum amount of money for anything. It's considered to be an infringement on a public agency's police power. As you know, the police power has nothing to do with law enforcement. It's just sort of general authority.

1:36:26 Because the courts have said that voters cannot establish minimum spending requirements for the town, the only interpretation that there can be of the two measures is that they don't do that. You can't interpret them in a way that makes them contrary to the law. So neither measure requires the town to establish a minimum level of spending in the areas that the measures cover. So that's the first point, and that serves as sort of the foundation for the rest of the analysis.

1:36:54 With that out of the way, then the question becomes, if there can't be a minimum spending requirement, then what does the anti-supplanting language mean? And Sandy Hogan did point out one aspect of the memo that I do need to clarify, and that is that the anti-supplanting language in Measure R doesn't apply to everything. It only applies to maintenance funding specifically. So the conclusion that we've reached is that

1:37:21 The anti-supplanting language that's in the Measure R Expenditure Plan and in Measure U means that the Council cannot keep its level of spending constant but simply shift money away from the areas that are covered by R and U and then backfill with Measure R and U. What you can do, I think, is that if you need to reduce your overall level of spending, you can do that. It's a corollary of that idea that the measures can't bind you and force you to spend a minimum amount of money. So, for example,

1:37:50 If you have $16 million to spend in the general fund, and in one year you partially fund recreation, parks, trails, arts and culture with it, and the next year you want to keep spending $16 million but not fund any of those things and make up for that lack of funding with Measure R, Measure U, that I think you cannot do. However, if you need to go from spending $16 million and spending some on areas covered by R and U, and the next year you need to go and spend $14 million,

1:38:19 I think that you can have those cuts come partially or entirely from areas that are covered by Measure R and Measure U. And again, that's the only conclusion that you can reach from the firm fixed point of no minimum funding requirement. So that's my interpretation. And with Measure U, it's very clear that it is what it is. The voters have adopted it. Only the voters can change it. Measure R is a little bit different.

1:38:45 Because Measure R's anti-supplanting language is not in the text of the ordinance itself. It's in the expenditure plan. The initiative adopted the ordinance but also established the initial expenditure plan. But the language of the expenditure plan of Measure R says that the council can amend the expenditure plan. So if the council were so inclined, you could amend the current Measure R expenditure plan to completely remove any reference to supplanting.

1:39:13 The short way of saying all that is that the Council could do away with any restrictions on supplanting the measure R, then you would simply be forced to use the money for the things the measure R says that you can use it for, but without any question about backfilling.

1:39:27 And Measure U, you don't have that ability to take away this planting language. So I presented basically the same information to the Recreation Commission by phone last night. There were a number of questions, which I did my best to answer. If you have any questions, I'd be happy to tackle them. Or if you think that anyone from the public might want to weigh in during public comment, I'd be happy to address questions from the floor. Okay, let's start. Are there any questions from Council?

1:39:55 Is there anyone from the public wishing to speak on this issue, please come up to the podium, and again, I'll remind everyone that you have the five-minute limit. Hi, I'm Dunnett Hustleton. I have a couple questions. On the maintenance part of this and the administration part of this, so does this mean that, say, there are some needs for some park improvements or other improvements, and that's a maintenance issue for pre-existing, can that

1:40:23 Can the money be used out of Measure R to pay for that? Well, I think it can. I think it absolutely can. I don't think that there's anything in Measure R that would support the idea that it has to be used only for new facilities or construction facilities. I mean, the text of the expenditure plan, which I happen to have, says it shall be used only for the planning, construction, operation, maintenance, programming, and administration of all trails, parks, and recreation facilities managed by the town.

1:40:50 There's no reference to only new facilities, and the fact that it can be used for maintenance suggests to me that it can be used for maintaining anything. And what about staff? Is staff able to tap into that money if they need to hire an extra person and to fulfill those public works or parking reps?

1:41:08 To bring up things that, you know, need to be repaired, they can also use that as well? Yes, I think so. I mean, it may or may not be possible to justify an entire staff position. I mean, you might have the staff position that's partially funded by this. But again, because it allows for the operation, programming, and administration of facilities, to me, operation, programming, and administration means staff. So I think it is fair game to fund at least some staff time with this. And if a person wants to apply for the Measure R money,

1:41:37 Are they allowed to use any of that money for their own benefit as far as utilities, rent, administration type of stuff, or not? You know, the intricacies of the measure are funding and award structure are perhaps a discussion for another day. Because the town council ultimately has the authority to decide how it's going to be done, I guess the council could perhaps decide to program some of that money to cover.

1:42:06 Private Party staff. Whether the council would want to or would want to continue doing that is another question. Okay, thank you. I think my five minutes is up. Good evening. My name is John Wentworth. Nice to meet you. I served as basically the campaign manager for Measure R and also for Measure U. So I'm also serving the Measure U committee right now, advising the council on a variety of different things. The questions come up about the date, establishing a level of service,

1:42:39 at the date when these measures were passed and whether that date has any validity. It's been represented to the measure committee that it doesn't, that the questions of planning is kind of a real-time phenomenon and that trying to establish a baseline or a floor level of service at any date is not appropriate. I wonder if you could...

1:43:00 Advise myself, maybe the committee on that. I think that's generally correct. And the reason is that if you establish a baseline date and say that funding has to be maintained or services have to be maintained as of that date, that's a bit inconsistent with the first premise that I discussed, which is that the voters cannot require the town to spend any minimum amount of money and, by extension, provide any minimum level of service simply because the courts have said the state law doesn't allow it. So that idea of a baseline date, to me,

1:43:29 I don't think that's really the right way to look at it. I'm not sure that it's a valid method of analysis. Okay. With all due respect, anybody that may have... Well, it's helpful working with the measure of your committee. This question's come up. It'd be helpful to get... I mean, we understand that you're the town's attorney. You're hired and engaged and paid for by the town. But, you know, at this point, opinions coming from anywhere is helpful to help clarify this. And I have to say, in response to some comments that I understand were made last night,

1:43:58 That nobody from the Council and nobody from staff directed me to any particular response, any particular way of looking at this, or even told me that they hoped that it would come out a certain way. The analysis that we undertook, both of state law and the text of Measure R and Measure U, was made completely independently.

1:44:16 And there may be people on staff or on the council that disagree or chagrin by it, but it's certainly not a conclusion that was directed or requested by anybody. Okay. A couple other questions. In putting together this analysis, did you have an opportunity to review the campaign materials that were used both in Measure R and Measure U as testaments, perhaps, or statements to voter intent with respect to these measures? No, I didn't take a look at that, and I'll tell you why. Because the key...

1:44:43 To it is going to be the language ultimately. If the language is not clear, then you have to look at the voter intent. But I understand that some of the voters may have had the intention of establishing a minimum level of service or a minimum spending level, but because that can't be done, that part of the intent, I think you just can't take into consideration. So I didn't look at the intent, but if you think there's anything in the intent or in the...

1:45:08 In the campaign language that might bear on this, given that there can't be minimum service requirements or spending requirements, I'd be happy to take a look at it. Yeah, all those materials have been archived and they're available if that's something you'd like to take a look at. Just a couple other quick questions. Are you aware of sort of the nature of the political climate when both of these measures are brought forward in terms of the public's perception of raising revenue and the necessary

1:45:34 Articulation of level of trust between the community and public funds and its relationship to the town. I'm sort of vaguely aware of it. It was before my time with the town. So I'm not aware of all the details. And certainly the little that I know didn't really affect the analysis one way or another. Okay. And also, and finally, my final question, but it was a good one. Madam Mayor, if I could recover from my...

1:46:06 Brain, flatulence, perhaps I could come back and ask a question. Thank you. I just want to ask for a comment. Just accept the dang thing and move on. Anyway, I'm Bill Sauser. Was that your five minutes' worth? No. Thank you. I'm done. One interesting point is in Measure R, when those of us that worked on that, and several of you up there worked on it with us, and we asked the then-town attorney,

1:46:36 Where the supplanting should be and how we could make this strong so that the town couldn't backfill. It was the previous attorney's opinion that it needed to go in the expenditure plan. I can't tell you why, but that's how it got there. So I do think we have to look at what the voter intent is. And Andrew, I think you did a great job. It's a great report on what the town legally can do. It doesn't speak to morally what they should do.

1:47:02 Can't set a floor for what the town can spend, but certainly the town council has it within their rights to say, we should have stepped up to the plate and funded stuff we didn't even spend, and we're not going to take the gift the people has given us and backfill what we should have been spending with it. They can. And with your reported legally being in those states, I think that you would certainly have a disgruntled public.

1:47:31 If we took Measure R and just backfilled without guarantees that we would be able to do what the voter's intent was originally. And I think most of you sitting there know what the intent was. But I wanted to, I don't know that you knew that. We asked how to make this strong enough so that the bookkeeping game couldn't be played. And that was the recommendation that came forward, unless I'm wrong. I think most of the audience have worked on it even closer than I did. So it was one attorney's opinion that that's where it needed to be.

1:47:59 I think that's your opinion that because it's there, we can limit it. I'm just interpreting the language on the page, and that's just how it's set up. Thank you. John, did you get it back now? I gave you John. Thanks very much. Bill Sauser, through the miracle of modern science, successfully channeled my question, which is exactly that, which is when these measures were being put together. Obviously, the town had a previous attorney who advised a variety of people working on the language for this that was going to be before the voters.

1:48:29 This was the recommendation. None of us as lay citizens are experts and that kind of thing. That's what went to the voters. Now we're hearing a slightly modified. It should maybe kind of been that. And I'm just wondering if you're aware of that. Obviously, there's two different... I'm aware that my predecessor did weigh in on that. It's not that putting it in the expenditure plan itself makes it vulnerable. It's that there's language in Measure R that says that the council can amend the expenditure plan. Okay. That entire mechanism was perhaps we were...

1:48:58 I don't want to say naive, but now we have maybe two different ways of looking at it. So I appreciate it. Well, and not to beat a dead horse, but if the idea was to make sure that the town had to provide a certain minimum level of funding or services, as I've said, I don't think the law allows that. There's just not a way to really bind the town council's hands in that way. So if that was the intent, I don't think that there was a way to get there. No, I don't think that was the intent. But I think that the council certainly appreciates...

1:49:25 And Council Member Wood has talked about political commitments and the need that the Council has a bond of trust with the community. And that, you know, measure R certainly is available to the Council if there's perhaps an emergency, if there's some unforeseen circumstance. But the whole debate of putting these measures together was the nature of how strong is this trust between the political commitment from the Council and the community. That's one of the reasons.

1:49:52 For better or worse, these had to be, we were brought forward as two-thirds plus one vote amendment. Thank you, Mr. Sauser. Thank you. I'm sure if the Council forgets those political commitments, the community will happily remind us of them. Swiftly. Thank you, Tom Cage. Question, is Measure R and Measure U money protected from the judgment or any part of the judgment that may be negotiated?

1:50:22 In regards to the airport. Yes, sir. Because these were special tax measures, it means that the money is earmarked for only the purposes laid out in the two ordinances cannot legally be spent for any purpose other than those. Are there any other comments from the public? I thought you were coming up too, sir. Okay. You can. All right. Okay. John, I'm going to start with you. Any comments?

1:51:07 Yeah, I had some statements that I was going to make, but they were brought forward with a public comment this evening, but I'll just restate them a little bit so that it's clear where I stand. Anti-supplanting language could do away with supplanting and backfilling technically or legally. We've been told that, so that's clear, but the call-up question would be, even though it's technically legal,

1:51:36 What was the intent of the voters and also the organizers when they passed both of those measures? And I think maybe not everybody, but I think the majority of people and hopefully the majority of council realizes what the intent was when both of those measures were passed. Having said that, if the council at some point under severe distress decides to use money from either R or U for the town,

1:52:05 To either supplant or backfill, the funding at that time should be limited in duration and be accompanied by a formal written Town Council resolution stating that a definitive time frame, after a definitive time frame, those monies will revert back and not be used further for backfilling or supplanting. Okay, that's it. Done? Yes. Okay, Skip. Thank you.

1:52:38 I think John's got a great idea there about being clear about what happens if we happen to use it. But just kind of chronologically speaking, and it was brought up at the podium that I'm looking first at the campaign material, which I believe created the spirit with which the voters passed the measure. And it's been said that they expected us to use this funding for recreation over and above what we already had.

1:53:07 There isn't any way that we could have anticipated losing, but we had higher hopes back then that we were not going to lose some of the things that were coming forward financially, be it shortfalls in our budget or the lawsuit or anything else. But I think one of the things that I feel would help ease the concerns of a lot of people is that at the time this measure passed,

1:53:35 There was a dollar amount that we were spending for maintenance on these facilities, and we simply need to establish that as a baseline. We understand that we can go below that if we need to. I think that's pretty clear. You can't foresee that. But we need to have that amount brought forward and put out somewhere for all of our commissions and committees.

1:53:59 to use as a guide for when they begin to fund things with the Measure R or the Measure U. Are we taking a lot of money out and is this project all of a sudden something that we shouldn't be using Measure R or Measure U money for?

1:54:16 In the future, or is it something that is such a valuable project that these committees are going to say, we need to keep this at this level, we need to keep moving forward, we need to really support this project. So one of the first things I think we need to do is get that number. I believe Dave is that number, it's out there somewhere, that we could get that. We need to establish what the baseline is so that future...

1:54:40 Nick? You know, my comment's pretty simple. As long as I'm here, given the...

1:55:14 Commitments that have been made. I won't spend Measure R or Measure U money on what I consider to be general fund expenditures unless a bankruptcy judge tells me to do so. Matthew? I really don't have anything new to add. I think that we've all pretty clearly understood what the intent of this is. I would like to be clear.

1:55:49 Don't really recall back when R was going through. We've heard a lot about that R was supposed to be used just for new facilities and whatnot. I just don't recall the campaign language on that personally, but I'd like to talk to John and some of the others on that just to better educate myself on that back when that was going on. And then finally, I guess I just wanted to make clear, I think there's a misconception as to why this

1:56:19 This measure R&U language came up, and it's actually just something that's been floating out there for a long time, and we need to clarify it. I think the timing with what's going on with the creditor and whatnot brings to question as to why this was done. It's actually been something that's been in the works, I think, for quite some time. So that's all. Okay. And, John, I am ignoring you because we're in deliberation, and that's something that you can talk with Matthew separately on.

1:56:47 I did want to clarify one comment, make sure that everyone understands that it is the council who hires the town attorney. The two employees sitting at the table right now are the two that we are responsible for and we hire. That said, I accept the definition that has been brought forward by our town attorney as it is written. I believe it is the correct interpretation.

1:57:13 I'm also going to agree with what Bill Sauser said. There's a legal definition, which we have tonight to accept, and then there is the moral issue. And as has been said by some of the other council members, I do not have an intention of using R or U for existing services unless we are forced to do so by a bankruptcy judge.

1:57:40 Madam Mayor, I'd like to move that the council approve option number one and receive and accept the memorandum this evening. Point of order, if I could. I agree. I'm willing to accept that. We need a second before discussion. I do think that we need to get this. We've been talking about this for a long time, and we go around and around and around. We need to give staff some direction to get that baseline number for us.

1:58:08 So that we have some idea of what we were spending. Because that seems to be the big point of contention. It's why this keeps coming back to us quite often, is no one knows what that number is, and we just need to see if we can't get that baseline number as a reference point. It doesn't affect how we are going to spend it, but we need that reference point so that we know what we need to build. If we have to go below, we need to know what we need to get back up to.

1:58:32 My suggestion, rather than to cloud this particular agenda item, is to just write up an agenda item for our next council meeting and put it under consent, just for what you're saying. That would be fine. Just have it approved under consent. That would be fine. And I would suggest that maybe, yes, I believe the Recreation Commission has been already starting to do some work on that, of identifying facilities in the inventory and things. Got it.

1:58:57 Okay, we have a motion and a second. A roll call, please, Jamie. Councilmember Marysheva? Yes. Councilmember Wood? Yes. Councilmember Wood? Mayor Parts of Layman? Yes. Mayor Bacon? Yes. Motion passes 5-0. Let's take a five-minute break. Thank goodness.

1:59:40 I will call the meeting back to order. Could we please end the discussions? Thank you. And we will go on to agenda item number 14, which is to approve the measure fall application award and evaluation materials, methodology timeline, etc. Staff report, please.

2:00:45 Good evening, Madam Mayor, members of Council, staff, and our community. So, this evening, we're going to discuss the Measure I-4 Award, as the Mayor indicated. And, at this time, the Measure I-4 Award application period is scheduled to open on Monday, October 10th, and close on Friday, November 4th, at 12pm. At the close of applications, the Recreation Commission has the responsibility, as stated in the ordinance, that we've discussed this evening,

2:01:14 To receive public input and provide recommendations to Town Council regarding the appropriate use and award of Measure R funds. Prior to the commencement of the annual Measure R Fall Award cycle, the Recreation Commission mixed to review and establish the timeline, Measure R Fall Award application form, and annual Measure R funding priorities and principles for Town Council approval. The Recreation Commission began preparing for the Fall Award cycle of their June 7, 2011 meeting.

2:01:42 During this extensive process, the Recreation Commission also identified maintenance, as in operation and replacement funds, that will be set aside for previously awarded Measure Hour projects in this funding cycle. The Commission also adopted a policy for the allocation of future maintenance funds. This evening, staff is seeking Town of Council review, approval and direction on three parts of the Agenda Bill. Part 1 is the approval or amendment of the 2001 Measure Hour 4 Award Application Form.

2:02:13 The Measure R Priorities and Principles document and the 2011 Measure R Fall Award project filter and checklist as submitted by the Recreation Commission and included in your packet this evening. Secondly, staff is seeking Town Council review or approval or amendment of the Measure R Fall Award timeline, also as presented by the Recreation Commission this evening. And then thirdly, review and then provide priority recommendations to staff and ultimately the Recreation Commission for the

2:02:43 The proposed 2011 Town of Mammoth Lakes Measure Art Fall Award applications. Included in this Agenda Bill is also an estimated amount of funding available for the 2011 Measure Art Fall Award. The 2011 Measure Art Fall Award incorporates the use of the following documents. The Fall Award timeline, as we discussed, the application form, the priorities and principles, the project filter and checklist, and also in this packet, as we discussed, the proposed Town Measure Art Fall Award.

2:03:13 Applications in a very simplistic format. At this time, I would ask direction from the Mayor and Town Council on how you would like to proceed with this agenda or item. I would suggest that we deal with each of the issues separately so we can focus and take public comment on each if there is. Is that acceptable to Council? In that case, first, are there any questions of Stuart? I have a question of the Mayor, if I may. Okay. At the risk of stepping out,

2:03:48 On the end of a limb and getting in trouble. I'm wondering if considering the current discussions and situations that we're in with the settlement of the lawsuit, if rather than going through this exercise this evening or at any time in the near future, it might not be time for the council and the community to pause on the Measure R funding process until after there's an agreement on the settlement of the lawsuit.

2:04:22 No. No? Sorry. Okay. I can tell you why, but the bottom line is no. It's very important to me that we move forward. These are restricted funds. They are intended by the public to be either allocated or spent or both. And so I recognize why, John, and I don't mean to...

2:04:47 You're not. To suggest that's not a reasonable request, I just don't want to stall this process. Okay, I'd like to start with number two, which is the application form. Is there anyone from the public who would like to speak on the application form? Come up to the podium, please. Hi, I'm Donna Hustleton. Thanks for listening. Like I said previously,

2:05:23 Last night there was a Park and Rec Commission meeting, and on September 19th, Terry did a whole lot of work on getting the feasibility in order to present to the Town Council tonight, and it was supposed to have come back last night for the Park and Rec Commission to review to make sure all the language was correct. That did not happen, so I'm asking if that part of your application

2:05:48 goes back to park and recs to make sure that that is that language is correct before you approve that part of it. I also like to just say a couple things is because that bypass that part of the commission, I also want to talk about the application part of when people submit their applications instead of bypassing the staff in the town when they do fill out that feasibility if park and recs commission

2:06:18 Say they would like certain ones to be approved, those I would suggest go back to the town staff to make sure all those numbers are correct and then if they have any comment go back to park and recs and then when the final should go to town council for approval. I also have one last suggestion is if there's any monies over $100,000 possibly requesting an independent audit of whoever gets that.

2:06:45 Money that's over $100,000 since this is public money. Thank you. Terry, yes, start recognition. I can only speak for myself. This was supposed to come back to us last night. It did not make our agenda. Stu actually did provide the committee that was working on the application a copy and went through it, and it appears that all of the comments that were added or revised have been sufficiently put in the application.

2:07:25 So I don't know, you know, if the commission would like it to go back to us, then that would be fine. We are going to have a meeting on the 12th. But just looking through it, it looks like all the comments were put in. Thank you, Terry. I saw the chairperson back there shaking his head. No, no. The committee, that she looks at it, is satisfied that the content is indeed what the commission asked for.

2:08:06 More than comfortable with you accepting the applications and having us move forward. I hope you've had a chance to look at that. That whole section on feasibility was added as a direct result of the work of the SMG group in rec stress. A direct result coming out of that was a great idea. It helped us with the verbiage. Originally, we had asked that maybe a $100,000 limit, anything over that would require one. And we decided there's no reason.

2:08:35 That each applicant couldn't fill out to their own ability a feasibility study. Then if we decide it requires more than what they've given us, we can ask them then and perhaps even fund a professional feasibility study and ask them to bring the application back. I think it's an important piece that somehow we didn't get in in the first place and it improves the whole process. Thank you. Thank you, Bill. Is there anyone else who would like to speak on the application form?

2:09:05 Are there any council comments on the form before we move on to the next part? Okay, that would be moving on to the priorities and principles, which are actually on page four of our agenda bill. And for the benefit of those of you who do not have copies, the priorities are to finish parks, trails, and recreation projects that remain incomplete.

2:09:28 Plan for the future, face completion of Trails End Park, and provide noted grooming of cross-country trails in Mammoth Lakes at the same level or comparable to the 2009-10 program. The principles are emphasis on visitor-driven driving projects, emphasis on cooperative efforts that significantly measure our funds, and projects must cite recommendations from the Draft Parks and Recreation Master Plan, the Draft Trail System Master Plan, and the Rec Strats 2 Recreation.

2:09:57 Implementation Strategy. Is there anyone from the public wishing to speak on this one? Comments from Council? It's very broad. I don't have any comments. If I may, it's broad, I think. Bill, please come up so they can hear you at home. We talked about that in committee earlier. It's broad because we're in the process of developing a prioritization list that includes all of those things. It is not quite done yet.

2:10:32 But we believe that that broad definition fits within the rec strats and the parks plan and brings home the projects that are consistent with all of those. Okay. The next portion would be the project filter and checklist. Oh, sure. I agree with Bill on the park. They just started that process. My only concern is we'll be able to get that process done.

2:11:06 Prior to the end of the application so that the town can put their own applications in for what they need out of the measure R, that would be my only concern, the time limit of that. And they've just started that process to figure out what needs to be done and put it in priority. So I just want to make that comment about that. Okay. Okay. Project filter and checklist. Is there anyone wishing to speak to that? Okay. Any comments?

2:11:38 Council? All right. The next section is the proposed town measure fall, measure all. Okay. I give up. Town applications. What's in that water? It's water, but... Do you have any coffee left there? Really? Is there anyone in the audience wishing to speak on this section? Okay. Council members?

2:12:13 Oh, go ahead. No, go ahead, Rick. Sorry. You know, I, there's a whole lot of work that goes into this. And one of the things that council members can do or council can do as a body is to influence the process at varying levels and to varying degrees. One of the things that I try to do

2:12:43 And I'm actually pretty successful at it is not interfere with the process as it's coming up. And the reason for that is that although I may have very strongly held views about something, I recognize that there's a place, there's a forum within which to express those views. And so consistent with that, I'm really reluctant to get in the way of the work that the subcommittee

2:13:12 The applicant, the staff, and the commission are expected to do with respect to the prioritization because inevitably everything that we do gets politicized. And my view is that although I think it's important for us as a council to put stuff on the list that we think is important, either as a body, collectively, or as individuals, in the end,

2:13:40 There's a process to go through to really identify, well, after looking at the merits of each, looking at feasibility, looking at available funds, looking at the associated maintenance costs, all the things that go into deciding where it should fall on the list of priorities, it should go through that process without having the council, in effect, rate that which is on the list or add things to the list.

2:14:10 I've said in a long way what could be said in a short way, and that is that I wouldn't mess with it and wouldn't have the council provide input unless the commission wanted it. I concur. I disagree with that a little bit. I agree with it to the extent that we've asked a lot of folks to look this over, and I'm sure they've done an excellent job of it.

2:14:38 But I think it's our responsibility to be asking the questions. I mean, not asking questions has gotten us in trouble before. One area I do have some question on here is more of a breakdown on some of our applications. What exactly? I mean, is there a further breakdown, for example, on special event venues feasibility study, 60,000?

2:15:08 I mean, is that going to one person? How is that broken down? I mean, I'm curious. If that's going to one person for a feasibility study, I'd almost, I'd like to question that. But then, you know, we have some other expenditures in here, $331,000, $331,000, $100,000 flat for a trail project. I'm just curious if there's a little bit further breakdown on that. Probably I'm not the one to be answering that. Probably Mark is ready to answer it better. I think the list you have in front of you.

2:15:37 is asking you what projects you would like to have town staff bring forward for this fall award cycle. Right. What my suggestion would be is that you allow the committee and or the entire commission to work with staff on what we feel are the appropriate ones, bring that back at your next meeting for your approval for those to go forward, and then have you either approve or not approve those so we're not working with the whole thing. Obviously,

2:16:05 We have $305,000 remaining in the fall cycle to give out, and those potential awards are $900,000 by themselves. We may get some from the public as well, so I don't want to speak for them, but for me as the chair of the commission, I think that's the way I would bring it forward. So you want to refine it down to ones? Refine it down to those that at least have a chance without prejudicing ourselves without having seen.

2:16:35 Those specific applications are others. Staff time is valuable. And I don't think as a commission or as a council, we want them working to prepare applications. And we've increased the time on the application considerably with the additions. I don't think we want to see them spending a lot of time working on applications that aren't even going to be considered. And I'd be correct that once we get to application, we're going to have a lot of detail about everything we need to know and more.

2:17:03 I also agree with that. You know, one of the reasons for bringing it forward was that there wouldn't be surprises from Council. And so at this point we know what the range is, but I am very concerned with the amount of staff time that would be put in to filling out applications that are in three times, not counting everything that will come in from the community. So I would like to suggest that we ask the Recreation Commission

2:17:31 Or your subcommittee to work with staff to better identify these and bring back those, especially with our fiscal situation in mind, those which we might want to say yes, go ahead and apply on these at our next meeting. Do we have consensus on that? I agree. My only question is would that process include our Town Council Park and Recreation Commission?

2:18:01 Committee? Or not? I would think it would be better. I agree with Rick on not being too involved in the process at the early point. Okay. I just want to clarify. Yes. And I would think that any one of us who had questions about individual ones could email those to staff and ask them to be a part of the discussion. With that in mind, there was a method to my madness of skipping over the timeline.

2:18:31 There are some concerns that I have with the timeline as it was. And if we are in consensus to send back and have the town projects come forward on the October 19th meeting, I would suggest that then the applications would not open up until after that. So that would result in a shuffling of the timeline. I have also

2:19:00 Suggested that we polled the council, I think, that the December 31st, a few days before Christmas, to have such an important issue might be a problem, not just from the standpoint of us, but the fact that we have to remember that we have staff agreed to take furloughs to help cut our expenditures, and they have to take a number of eight days, and many of them may take them around the holidays, and staff might not be available.

2:19:28 So I would suggest that

2:19:54 In addition to reviewing the projects is that it's somehow we review the timeline with the idea that the applications would open after the October 19th meeting, which would shuffle everything into January, presumably. Yeah. If I may, Madam Mayor, so we've scheduled a special meeting in the Recreation Commission to do exactly that. So they're going to review, prioritize, and work with staff on those applications. We'll also bring back the revised timeline, once again, to your October 19th meeting.

2:20:31 So I hope that they'll kind of give you some introduction and will not be obviously scheduling December 21 for the final review and approval. Obviously right now we really can't make that timeline. It was very compressed. So we might even be in the second meeting in January, I think, at this time. But we'll have that. And just a clarification, since the question was raised, this would also give the full commission a chance to look at the feasibility section. That's great. Yes. It's quite detailed.

2:21:03 Do we want to approve parts of this or do we want it to come back? My fellow council members. Well, I'm looking at option one. It doesn't sound like approving any of it will move it forward any more than it already is being moved forward by the direction we're giving. Bill, do you disagree? Yes. Just stay there. For staff considerations,

2:21:42 I think that since we have buy-in on the application, that approving that so that they can tweak it and get them printed up and get them ready for people to pick up and people can go online and look at them so they know it's going to be expected of them would probably be appropriate. So A of option one, you would like us to move forward on? Yeah. Yeah. Okay. And the timeline they'll bring back. So B would be deferred.

2:22:13 C we could probably go forward on because it sounds like we agree that direction should be given to staff to work with the committee and the commission to prioritize the town's applications for submission. So A&C. So was that a motion for A&C? Yep. So moved. Do we have a second?

2:22:43 Second. We have a motion and a second for portions A and C of option two. Could we have a roll call vote, please? Jamie. Council Member Houston? Yes. Council Member Harvey? Yes. Council Member Wood? Yes. Mayor Pro Temleyman? Yes. Mayor Baker? Yes. Motion passes 5-0. Thank you. Do you intend to indicate option one, item A? No, option two. At this point, we will move on to number 15.

2:23:21 The sprung structure, and I do want to point out that there is an updated agenda, so Peter will ask you to walk us through all of it, focusing on the updates. Thank you, Madam Mayor, Councilmembers. Could we please take the conversations outside? Thank you. In front of you, you have an updated agenda, and I would point out that all of the changes have been italicized to assist with seeing what those changes were. And just briefly,

2:23:53 You know, we've had an increase in air service, currently planned to have seven flights a day beginning in the middle of December. With that increase in traffic, there is a need for the additional holding space, and this facility would provide that space. The project doesn't add any new capacity to the airport, but simply provides space to keep the passengers out of the weather. The purpose of the agenda is to ward the sprung structure tent improvements and erection to

2:24:25 Louis' Responsive Bidder. And then to provide the council information regarding the chronology, the town attorney's interpretation of the discussions that he's had with the FAA and the Department of Justice. And then review some of the cost-cutting measures of staffs recommending in the report. So with that, there's some reference documents attached.

2:24:54 And if you have questions regarding the attorney's memo, you can answer those. So staff did begin advertising for contractors September 16th. We opened bids yesterday. We received only one bid from Spees Construction at $156,200. That bid was about $46,000 over what we expected. So...

2:25:18 We're proposing a few cost-cut saving measures to keep the project within the $430,000 current budget appropriation. That includes elimination of a women's and men's restroom and just having a unisex restroom in the building. And then eliminating some concrete work around the perimeter of the building that's in the current contract for the site work that hasn't been completed yet.

2:25:48 Between those two, that's a $15,000 each project reduction. And then if you look in the finance section, there's some additional cost cutting measures that we identified to obtain the $46,000 cost savings. The existing terminal does have two men's restroom and a women's restroom, and then it does have a unisex restroom in the secured passenger holding area. So...

2:26:18 Essentially, there will still be plenty of restroom capacity, we believe, with the adjacent buildings. It's only really 30 feet away. The foundation would be completed with the facility so we could add another restroom in the future, but just not connected at this time. With that, attached also is a schematic showing the...

2:26:55 The facility and the tenant improvements inside the building. And the unisex restroom would be, it would include a water closet and a urinal. So it's the larger of the two restrooms and show them the details. With that, if there's no other questions, staff would recommend. Yeah, questions. Peter, just to kind of remind me, if I didn't see it, I mean, we're looking at...

2:27:26 It's phrased as the current project estimate is $430,000. Is that the total cost of the entire project or just for the, so the structure itself, all the work and everything that's being done, total cost $430,000? That's correct. And that's the, at the last meeting, at the August 17th meeting, Council, there's a budget resolution that appropriated the additional money for the project.

2:27:53 But then we're talking about a lease payment of $30,000, and we have, it comes back again in the second year, I think, we have a second lease payment. How long do we, we're only making two lease payments? No, there's a five year, so this, so just to kind of go back and review on page four, the project budget, the first year lease payment, which is included in this capital budget for this fiscal year, is $30,000, and that includes

2:28:23 The lease payments, shipping, sales tax, and delivery of the sprung structure. The structure itself is currently at the airport for you to be installed. The Marzano work, which was awarded at the August 17th meeting, that work is underway. Utility work is almost complete. They'll be doing the foundation in about a week and a half. And so that contract with the reduced scope.

2:28:51 Is about $205,000. The building, tenant improvements and putting up the building with the scope reduction to this bid would be $141,200. Then we've already done the environmental work and that was about $5,000. The architect design and project specifications estimate was about $15,000 and we've reduced that to some from the original budgeted amount based on where we're at.

2:29:21 There was a legal review related to the sprung structure purchase agreement, and so that was about $2,500 in legal review time. And then the contract administration, which is survey, soils testing, special inspection, is $10,000. Permits, which are outside permits, I think it is about $5,000 in the county, the Air Quality Board. And then internally we'll do Costa County.

2:29:51 So that's $13,700. And then the inside the building will be some tables and chairs. That was reduced from $15,000 to $6,000. Bill identified some other furniture that might be adequate, at least for this year. And then we've got a small contingency still of $10,300. So total project budget is $40,000 to $30,000. So when you talk about $28,000 60-month lease payment, that's the total of the 60 months.

2:30:19 Of lease payments, $28,000. On the last page, on page 14, the last page of the agenda. Yeah, that was, right. So for five years we'll have a lease payment and then there's a residual payment. And they totaled $28,000. Right. Okay. I guess, can I go to Andy for a question on this, the court case and the rulings and all that.

2:30:45 Why wouldn't we want to go straight to the judge that made the ruling on us and ask for his approval on this or get clearance from him to be sure that it's not going to come back and bite us? Well, I suppose it could, but subsequent to the date of this memo, I've talked to the Attorney General's office and...

2:31:09 Previously, as of the date that I wrote the memo, they had said, well, you know, we're not too sure. We don't really see a problem. We think it's going to be okay. Since then, the Attorney General's Office has said, we're not going to take any action. There's nothing here. We don't have any concerns. And the woman I talked to at the Attorney General's Office is the woman who handled the litigation against the town on behalf of the Attorney General's Office. So, to me, the fact that she is convinced that we've done this correctly and that nothing we're doing implicates...

2:31:36 The order from the 2003 case, that suggests to me that we actually did do it correctly. So I don't see a need to talk to the judge. I don't even know if that judge is still on the bench. Maybe, may not be. But we've talked to every regulatory agency that has any jurisdiction, and everybody seems convinced that we've done it correctly. And the Attorney General's office, they don't usually go out of their way to sort of be nice to local agencies. I mean, they're paid to be skeptical and to make sure that we're doing things correctly.

2:32:06 And I haven't gotten the official letter yet that she promised to send me confirming they're not going to take any action because they think we've done it right. But that was what she told me two weeks ago. But if the judge, say, gets wind of this and he is still on the bench, could he then require them to take an action? I don't see how he could because the order issued in that 2003 case said the town could not...

2:32:36 Complete certain improvements without doing an EIS, without doing NEPA compliance, but this is not one of those improvements. The town has complied with the order from the 2003 case, and although the judge did reserve to himself jurisdiction to enforce his order, nothing we're doing really falls under the order. So even if somebody were to talk to the judge, I think once all the facts were explained to him, presumably with the Attorney General's office's help,

2:33:03 I don't see what action he can take, truthfully. And would your law firm defend us for free if he does take action? Every day, low prices on me. Thank you. Are there other questions to staff? I have a couple. Peter, what's the capacity of the town? It'll have a posted capacity of 116 people. 116. Okay. The seating will be by 85.

2:33:34 And this is for people either, this is outside the secure area. So this is people either who haven't gotten checked in yet or are waiting for their bags when we have some of the backups. That's correct. So the people that maybe they're early for their flight or there's a delayed flight, they'll be able to wait in this area, maybe buy some food, some drinks and be out of the weather.

2:34:03 I'm not sure they're going to want to buy drinks if there's only one bathroom. In the ticketing area, how many stalls are there? In the ticketing area, there are three women's stalls, and one men's and one year old. Okay. Any other questions? The staff will go into... Okay. That reminds me of a question.

2:34:36 So is this, what about passengers who arrive? This isn't really a holding area for them. It's only for passengers who are departing, correct? For both. That's correct. Bill can actually talk a little more about the operational aspects. Operationally, what we plan on doing is we've got two periods during the day when the flights are very tight. They're about almost less than an hour apart.

2:35:05 So as people come in and are ticketed or get their, check their baggage, get their boarding pass, excuse me, they, if they're on the first flight, we'll send them through TSA and into the holding area. The follow-on flight will stage those people in the tent. And as the people are boarding out through, then we'll bring those people through TSA. There's simply not room in the current sterile area to have two flights.

2:35:37 Actually, Rick, I don't think that's giving the complete picture because there was an occasion when I was picking up family members on one of these Friday or Saturday evening flights where we had to wait more than half an hour for the Horizon flights

2:35:50 Carry on luggage because of some backup problems. And so there was a whole flight of people trying to stand in the ticketing area. And that was one of the reasons for going forward with the strong structure. So there will be people coming off of the plane who would make use of this while they're waiting for their baggage to be delivered. Is that where you would expect people to go as opposed to the secured? We won't process them through the secure area until the brief is there.

2:36:19 The first flight is boarded. If someone's coming off the plane, they're not going back into security. They're off the plane. So it will work for a little bit. Hopefully this year we're going to have more ground support equipment and we won't have the baggage clues that we had last year. I mean, look, I guess the concern, I don't want to micromanage this, but you wonder whether the savings that you are proposing, which is to eliminate a restroom,

2:36:47 When you've got the capacity and the numbers that you expect is the right place to achieve the savings in order to bring it in under or at budget. That's the issue that I'm having and I don't know anything about the operations of an airport other than traveling through it and so I can't tell but I'm concerned about it. I'd say we brought our project team together today and looked at all the different options and that was one that we felt we could make.

2:37:16 Given the restrooms and the short walk away. We could add one later, couldn't we? We'll probably end up with some port-a-potties. So I just wonder if there's an opportunity to go back to the loan bidder and ask that person to reduce the bid. You're smiling at me, I guess.

2:37:45 We deal with fees regularly, so you can't answer that. Well, essentially, you know, it's a low bid project even though we only have one bidder. But we did identify bid items within the schedule so we can delete, just basically not award certain things. And in this case, we wouldn't be awarding the bathrooms and we'll negotiate the difference.

2:38:15 To grind them would mean a lot before we actually award it. It really isn't part of the public contract process. We can grind it after it's awarded, but I don't know that we're going to get a lot more than $15,000. I did speak to them about what we were thinking of doing just to make sure that they would accept a contract or not because then we may have a different recommendation. I'd like to just make a comment. We're committed to work within the budget that the council approves.

2:38:49 And so the options we looked at today were the most minimally impacting. But if we can find the $15,000 to add the second bathroom in, we'll do that. But we're committed to, once we hit a number, to stay with it so that the council and the public believes we have integrity in our work that we do. So our goal is to build this thing within the budget. And if we can work around that relative to other elements in the project.

2:39:16 To make something happen, we will. One of the discussions we had was to remove or eliminate the concession area. So trading concession, which is a revenue area, for restrooms, that didn't make sense to us because there is a possibility of making some additional funds. So it is a toss-up. We just want to stay within our budget. That understood, what would be the...

2:39:42 Ticklers or targets that would tell you that, well, you're going to have to bring in a port-a-potty or something. Well, I think it's what's going to happen, and I just practiced, I was going to ask Bill to talk about the layout, but as people get off the airplane, there's going to be two points of people wanting to use the restroom, right? Media when offloading, and there's restrooms, I think, in the main terminal that people have used in the past. Those are still going to be available for first-off passengers on the airplane.

2:40:08 Then there's going to be folks who want to go just before they get on the airplane, and they're going to be in the terminal for that purpose as well. So we'll have to watch carefully, I suppose, and if it becomes problematic, we did ask Peter to make sure that the facilities were available to install restrooms if we needed to. So all the plumbing, the mechanical, water, all of those connections will be there if we need to do that. And we won't know that until we give it a try for the season.

2:40:37 And it's a $9,000 cost, which we could, if it's required, we could certainly put it in later. Okay, any other questions? Any discussion? I'll go ahead and make a motion that we approve option one. Hang on. Wait, wait, wait. I remember back when I was a young council member that our legal council at the time told us that

2:41:11 The decision that we were making, we were on solid ground, no problem, go forward. We also had the support of the FAA. The FAA said, oh yeah, looking pretty good. Keep going the direction you're going. Well, both of them were dead wrong, and we're paying for it now in a big way. I just, I find it a little bit frustrating that we are basically kind of here at the 11th hour.

2:41:40 Having to make this decision on this structure, because if we don't get started on it right away, we need it for this season. That's obvious. But we should have. This is a big issue. It's a huge issue. We've already suffered a great loss because of not following the right process. Why didn't we go to the judge in the beginning?

2:42:07 When we first decided we wanted to do this project or that we wanted to do some kind of work down at the airport and just seal the deal and get the answer straight away that would assure us that nothing's going to come back and bite us, you know, to wait until now to have to make a decision to me is kind of a, it's putting us in a position.

2:42:33 I would submit that

2:43:01 We have as a staff and as a council crossed every T and dotted every I. This whole issue arose from a private citizen or two who created their own view of the situation down there. And as a responsible council member, I'm going to base my decision tonight not upon what one or two individuals from the public sector

2:43:30 Private sector made an observation. I think that we have crossed our T's and dotted our I's in the sense that we have checked with, and correct me if I'm wrong, we've checked with our own town staff, including legal counsel. We have checked with the Attorney General's Office for the State of California. We've checked with the FAA. We've gotten clearance from all these people.

2:44:01 Because of a judgment against us on a much bigger and an unrelated situation, I'm not going to be gun shy to make responsible decisions in the future. So I'm comfortable in moving forward with this tonight. I can't prevent an individual, whether it's one of these two people or someone else, from raising this issue, but we have checked with everybody that you would responsibly check with, and they said, not a problem, move forward.

2:44:29 So I think that's being responsible. Motion? Is it already done? No. I would make a motion that we approve option one. Would you like me to read all three items? Well, actually, there's eight, so I don't think you're going to need two. Okay. I'll second the motion. We have a motion and a second. Roll call phone, please, Jamie. Council Member Eastman? Yes. Council Member Harvey? I know how much we need this structure to have good air service and provide good.

2:45:12 Customer Service this winter, so I will vote yes. Councilmember Wood? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Layman? Yes. Mayor Bacon? Yes. Motion passes 5-0. We will now move on to number 16, which is a resolution increasing expenditure authority for Mammoth Lakes Housing. Mayor and members of the council, this item is a request for supplemental funding for the Star Apartments Rehabilitation Project.

2:45:44 That is funded substantially through a CDBG loan. In 2008, a town in Mammoth Lakes applied for and received a grant for $1 million through the CDBG program to acquire and rehabilitate a four-plex apartment building at 1829 Old Mammoth Road. This is known as the Star Apartment, and it is intended to provide affordable rental housing.

2:46:09 The town provided a match of $37,000 with that grant, which has been used to pay for planning permit fees and a few other costs. As work has proceeded on this project, Mammoth Lakes Housing has, through their construction efforts, discovered some unanticipated costs primarily related to asbestos abatement. Oftentimes those types of costs are difficult to identify early on.

2:46:38 And additional funding is now needed to continue with this project. Pam Hennerty is here if you have detailed questions you'd like to ask her. The staff recommendation is that the Town Council approve the attached resolution adding $40,000 in funding to Mammoth Lakes Housing to supplement this grant funding to complete this project. And that funding should come from

2:47:08 We recommend the Workforce Housing Fund, which has a balance at this point of approximately $679,000. That concludes my report. I'd be happy to answer questions or refer them to Pam Hennerty. Are there any questions, comments? Just a comment.

2:47:35 Mammoth Lakes Housing Board obviously is supportive of this. This is what these funds really are used for. This is a really worthwhile project, and obviously it's with leveraged money. Okay, thank you, Rick. Any other comments? Madam Mayor, I'd like to make a motion that the council approve option number one. I'll second that. We have a motion and a second. Will I call vote please, Jeremy?

2:47:59 Councilmember Reisman? Yes. Councilmember Harvey? Yes. Councilmember Wood? Yes. Mayor Portem-Lehman? Yes. Mayor Baker? Yes. Motion passes 5-0. We are now moving on to item number 17, draft scope of work for municipal wayfinding and community messaging program. Thank you very much. We have provided for you a very, I think, complete and comprehensive staff report. The intent of this program is to...

2:48:34 Establish a consistent pattern of design to guide the signage and monumentation in the town of Mammoth Lakes. It's not to preordain any one particular design, but to improve consistency, imageability, and understandability, as well as to eliminate signage clutter, particularly in our right-of-way when talking about directional signage. Rather than walking through this fairly detailed report,

2:49:02 I think I'd rather ask the Council if you have specific questions that you can answer. Jessica Morris is the principal author of this, and we're happy to field your questions if you have them. Our recommendation is that you review the scope of work, provide any adjustments or modifications to it.

2:49:27 And then approve it and direct us to issue a request for proposals. Once the request for proposals is received, we'll have a better understanding of the budget for this. And we do have substantial funding to lead into the design phase of this. Additional funding would be necessary, but we want to see the scope of work and the competitive submittals that we would receive through the RFP process. Thank you.

2:49:57 Any questions of staff? I don't have any questions. Go ahead. Well, no, go ahead. You know, I just want to clarify. So as I understand it, this was within your scope of work that was identified in the budget process. Yes. And so that is why it fits within the budget now. And what isn't in the budget is the next phase, I guess. Does it make sense to...

2:50:27 Start and spend staff time if we don't know how we're going to fund the next phase once phase one is completed? I think so. This effort is one of those early momentum projects. It's very high visibility and relatively low cost. This is the type of project that is fundable through a pay-as-you-go program. It's not $60 million. It's a manageable program that once we had a plan and specifications in effect,

2:50:57 We could implement over time. The funding that we would expect to receive, that we already have, to implement the design work is through our community-based transportation planning grants. We have phase one, which we now receive, and we'll have another $165,000 we expect to receive in January, February next year, which will fund this effort. In fact, this is very similar to the Mammoth Lakes Trails.

2:51:26 Signage Program. Once you have the specifications, then you can implement them through grants and through whatever other reasonable funding sources you have. We're also doing this to actually establish the palette because you see that there are private efforts, such as the Gateway Project that we'll discuss, that have some relationship and bearing to this. And much of our signage has been ad hoc, it's antiquated. I cannot see the...

2:51:54 Street signs at night. They're just not reflective. And this is recommended in the mobility plan draft. It's recommended indirectly through the rec stretch program and through the trail system master plan. And it's also one of the early recommendations for implementation through the district planning process. So in order to achieve a rational program that we can afford with, the design specs are required.

2:52:25 And we might also add that some signage programs may be required as a condition of approval with projects because wayfinding is very helpful in terms of traffic management and directing traffic to its destinations. So what is it that the consultant is going to do? That's a good question. I guess really that's probably what I should have asked because what I see is

2:52:57 You have it in your work plan, so it's budgeted. This is kind of the first part of phase one, and then phase two is actually putting something in the ground or putting something up, and then we've got this little in-between area that involves a consultant, and so I'd just like to have a little more detail on what that is. And frankly, I can't tell from the specifics of the proposed scope of work. Okay, so I think it's the third page of the staff report. I have a brief summary of the task.

2:53:26 Most of which would be performed by the consultant. And again, it would be very similar to a process that the town and MLTPA and the Forest Service went through with Corbin that came up with the design specifications and different concept designs for the trail system program. So this would be a similar process. And a lot of it also has to do with coming up with criteria.

2:53:53 So that's part of it. They would also help us put together the

2:54:22 Cost estimates for everything, an implementation plan, recommendations for phasing, recommendations for which pods, if you will, of signs would go in first. So it's basically kind of a master plan for the overall program. And staff doesn't really have the capability to do sign design. And also part of it has to do with transportation engineering standards. So you need certain...

2:54:53 Sign designs for if you're traveling a certain mile per hour down the road, what they need to be, how big they need to be, and how big the fonts should be, colors, so on and so forth. And then the consultant, a big part of it, I think, too, would be helping us work with Caltrans and Forest Service to make sure that we comply with all their regulations and work through their separate processes. Thank you. I see. Are there other questions of staff?

2:55:24 How does this work in with MLTPA and all of the wayfinding on our trail systems and everything? How is this connected? It's connected in that we want to build from that program. We certainly don't want to reinvent the wheel on that, so we're going to pull from that in terms of design so that everything complements each other and works together.

2:55:50 But they serve different purposes. The trail system signage serves a different purpose than what a vehicular-based program and a pedestrian and bicyclist-based program would be. So it's intended to complement that system. This is obviously an independent effort, but as Jessica has alluded to, a significant amount of work has gone into the identification of naming conventions for destinations and places and all this kind of stuff.

2:56:24 That was an enormous amount of work, and I think there's no need to repeat that, and I think we're all in agreement that those consensus naming conventions that have already been established as part of the trail system process, that goes to Jessica, goes to that team, so these guys don't have to reinvent the wheel of doing all that stuff all over again. That's a significant sort of head start for that stuff. And I'll just add, you know, we will definitely utilize the naming conventions that were used for the MLTS system.

2:56:55 But part of this process would be coming up with additional naming conventions for other destinations that aren't trail related. So, you know, a ski area and the library and different public and private destinations that our visitors, well, mostly our visitors, but our residents too, need to get to. So we'll build on that, we'll take from that, and we'll be consistent with the MLTS.

2:57:25 Do we – okay, never mind, just answered my own question. Thank you. Okay, comments? Madam Mayor, I move – Wait, I want to make some comments. Oh, sorry. I agree with what Rick has to say about how far do we want to get into this before we have any idea of how we would pay for it. Just because it's in the work plan, the scope of it or the size of it or the scalability of it is not necessarily outlined in the work program.

2:58:01 And I am concerned that a lot of these things we've been told verbally, but it's not in the agenda, that, oh, yeah, we're going to look at what's already been done. I'm really concerned about redoing work when our only resource we have left at this point is our staff. And I'm concerned that, oh, yeah, we're going to integrate with the Terrell System Master Plan, Red Strats, et cetera. Well, why doesn't it say that in here? I'm just really concerned, and you've heard me say it before, we need the Impala version, not the Cadillac.

2:58:31 And I would like to see it have a clearer scope within the scope part about what really needs to be done in phase one within the realization that I will continue to say if we can put more money into enforcement at TOT, which brings us revenue, redirecting staff into some of those areas is important to me.

2:58:57 The other thing that it was important to me to point out is under financial considerations there is a comment about potential use of Measure U, but I want to make it clear to the community that that is not any kind of presupposition or allocation of Measure U funds before that committee is done with their work. So to your point, I'll tell you, it seems like this is self-limiting, and that's why I'm okay with it, because it's so important.

2:59:35 to me to move along the signage and wayfinding efforts that have already begun with respect to trails. But I do share your concern that this is a dead end or that it's going to go nowhere depending upon what the RFP produces if bids for consulting services are extraordinary.

3:00:05 I imagine what staff can infer from our comments and previous comments of council members is that we don't have any money, much less a whole lot of money for consultants. And I think that's, you know, I'm okay because it's in the work plan, provided it doesn't interfere with other work that is in the plan.

3:00:33 But I'll scrutinize very carefully that which we're going to be requested to come up with money for in order to move it forward, even though I think it's very, very important. So obviously you can see the conflict there in my mind. If I could address a couple of issues. This effort, both the staffing work for it and the consultancy work, we see that principally funded through the grants that we've received.

3:01:03 We're not expecting or hoping or intending to apply general fund funds to this. So you think that we're estimating a contract to go to be in the range of $30,000 to $40,000. The challenge, as you've just seen with the spread structure, is we don't, after we've written a detailed scope, we'll get back what we get. We have already

3:01:30 We've done a significant amount of work. We build on that. And through the adoption of the programs, staff will soon be acting on the trail system master plan. And so we rely on what's already been approved and adopted. And the structure that we would work within will ensure consistency. We're not trying to redo work. We're not trying to create a different palette. We're actually trying to create

3:01:57 A complementary palette and build on what has been done with, of course, the MLTPA work. So the challenge we have is that it primarily looks like it's a grant-funded program, both the staff work and consultant work. And the staff, whether it's Public Works or us, we don't have the experience to give you the laminate detail and specification that would go on.

3:02:24 A sign that would be placed in Caltrans right-of-way, which must also conform to Caltrans signage standards. In the process that we've described, we've already established a stakeholders group where we have MLT, we have airport staff involved, we have public works staff, we have a lot of commission representation, and we're driving to consensus.

3:02:49 You know, staff understands our plans. We understand your overall direction. Without having a set of guidelines and a plan, when you do have that opportunity for funding, whether it's a town funding source or a grant funding source or an agreement or a condition imposed on the project, if you don't have the specifications, we're simply back to the ad hoc process that we've been in. And there are a host of signs out there that, you know.

3:03:19 They're just all different. And to establish a graphic pattern of design intent, which is what the trail system signage is doing, and to expand that throughout the town for all of our directional programs, it sets you up and prepares you for development activity and future funding sources. So some things seem to be momentum projects.

3:03:45 That we should be prepared to take advantage of the opportunities when they arise. Mark, could you repeat the part about which grant is funding this? They are the community-based transportation grants, one, that we are currently using, and two, which we've already been awarded and we expect to receive the funds in January or February. We also have LTC funding that's directed to this effort. So, you know, we don't have any general fund.

3:04:15 Okay, well, if that had been included in the financial considerations, I would not have made. I'm still concerned about using the money efficiently, but if it's not general fund, then some of those comments I would withdraw. Public comment, please come on up. I know you've been waiting back there. I was just taking a breath. Jim Smith, Mammoth Mountain, get that out of the way.

3:04:54 I think this is really important. I really encourage you guys to support this. I think Mark's done a great job explaining this and his team. We all know the economic issues that we're dealing with, and there's a bunch of what Mark's used to term some low-cost, high-impact things that we can do. This is one of them, and getting this teed up and ready to go is going to be very important, and we're going to see that in the next agenda item.

3:05:21 I'll also add that Mammoth Mountain is doing the same exact thing. We're going to start this process on all of our buildings. So we all live them drastically, but as we get new folks coming to the main lodge and they don't know where to go, or they go to Canyon Lodge and they don't know where to go. So we're doing the exact same thing starting this winter where we're just going to find a third party signage.

3:05:46 The company is going to do the same thing, get into naming conventions, consistent messaging with everything from color and how it's stated and what it's said. And we're trying to take each one of our portals and try to change them into a way that is consistent with different market segments. One's going to be very family-oriented. One may be more oriented to youth action.

3:06:09 How you name those, how you say all those things, and then how you present all those is absolutely a very important part of the guest experience, and we're recognizing that too, and we're going to take the same thing that Mark's asking you guys for today for the town, Mammoth Mountain's going to take that same approach for all of our portals. So we're going to kind of piggyback, you've got the trail system master plan that's done it, you're going to piggyback that with what's going on with the town, and then Mammoth Mountain's going to add to that as well.

3:06:38 Look at Mammoth, and we provide signage and communication to all of our guests. It's totally going to change the guest experience. I really encourage you to approve this. Jim, can I, Jim, can I, Jim? Yes. Quick question here. I mean, you're bringing in a third party. Yeah. To do this, we're bringing in a third party. Right.

3:06:57 Town, Mountain, working together, would it have we had any discussions about using the same person so that there is some consistency throughout? Absolutely. The answer is we have not talked about it. This is something that we've been talking about internally, and, you know, I think, I don't know if Howard has announced this yet or not, but we're going to be announcing a very large capital plan. I'm sure you've heard some police scuttlebutt that, you know, we have a significant directive to go ahead and remodel Canyon Lodge.

3:07:27 And Main Lodge is going to fall right behind it. And we all know about Eagle, and we're pushing that as hard as we can. So this is something we just kind of kicked off in the last few weeks, last few months, I should say, as we put our five-year capital plan together and our five-year business plan. So I've not talked to Mark about this at all, but happy to sit down and work with him and pull it all together. And that will include, we haven't really decided, but we at least discussed it. Even the trail naming and how we present that is actually on the table for us as well, besides just how we...

3:07:54 Direct guests to the portals and how we direct guests within each one of the lodges as well. Okay. Okay. Thank you. So I still call facelift chair three. Me too. Bruce Woodward. This seems to fit in very much with the doing the district plans, redoing the zoning plan.

3:08:21 The zoning code and all of that. It seems to be in the same vein and that was very important to get that done so that we're ready to do things. And I think you ought to put somebody else's money where your mouth is on this one. And just, it doesn't seem to... Are you suggesting that the mountain should cover it? It's a grant money, the money that's already there. So that's, I mean, I think it fits in with that and I think that you guys pushed hard that that had to get done.

3:08:51 This is part of that. Any further public comment? I'm ready to make a motion, which is the council. John, do you have something to say? No. Approve option one, the draft scope of work for the municipal wayfinding and community messaging program and direct staff to issue a request for proposals. I'll second the motion.

3:09:17 We have a motion and a second. A roll call vote, please, Jamie. Council Member Houston? Yes. Council Member Harvey? Yes. Council Member Wood? Yes. Council Member Clarkson-Laymond? Yes. Mayor Bacon? Yes. Motion passes 5-0. We are now moving on to Southgate Wayside and Northgate Wayside.

3:09:40 Thank you. The purpose of this item is to provide the Town Council with an update on the Mammoth Gateway Community Project and request direction from the Council on several items related to this project. The project includes two gateway monument signs on both sides of Highway 2 and 3 adjacent to the Courthouse building. The south monument sign is a volunteer-private-public partnership and is intended to be built with money from donations for the project as well as volunteer services.

3:10:09 From various parties. The location of the South Monument sign is within the town's land use jurisdiction. Therefore, the Planning Commission reviewed and approved a sign permit for it at the September 28th Planning Commission meeting. The next steps for this sign would include issuance of a building permit and construction of the sign, which is anticipated to occur next year. The South sign is proposed on land that is owned by the County of Mono, and the Board of Supervisors voted 5-0 on March 15th.

3:10:38 To support the project and to allow the county's land to be used for the project. The county is currently working on an easement that would allow the town to own and maintain the sign in the future if it's determined that the town should retain final ownership of the sign. As outlined in the agenda bill, the town council has not formally discussed the ownership and maintenance of the South Gateway sign. Staff is recommending that the council discuss the ownership and maintenance of the sign, which will allow staff to move forward with the maintenance and ownership agreements as necessary.

3:11:08 As a complement to the South Gateway sign, a similar sign on the north side of 203 is planned. The north monument sign will be located on land owned by the U.S. Forest Service. Staff has had some preliminary discussions with the Forest Service regarding this monument sign, and the Forest Service has expressed support for this concept. Due to their budget and staffing constraints, though, they've asked staff to submit a preliminary concept application sometime this month.

3:11:34 In order to ensure that permits are received by spring of next year. The Town Council has not formally discussed the Town's role in the North Gateway sign, and staff is requesting that the Council discuss the Town's role with regards to the major tasks for the sign, which includes securing funding for the sign, developing plans for the project, obtaining permits, and the construction, maintenance, and ownership of the sign.

3:12:01 Staff has provided the Council with discussion options for both the North and the South Whitehead sides within the options analysis section of your agenda bill. And at this point, I'd like to ask Bruce Woodward, who's one of the project coordinators, to give you a brief PowerPoint presentation regarding the Mammoth Gateway Community Project. So this first view is just the overall, with both sides of the road. This is the North Monument, and down below you can see the...

3:12:36 How the two relate to each other. This monument is a little bit, this one's larger than the one on the south side of the road. There's some interesting sort of issues with the messages on the signs that has to be, because the photo opportunity, which we feel that this is a really strong element, is of the south side.

3:13:08 But it's the north side that's sort of the one that's welcoming you to town. So they're kind of pulling. So that's why the south side says Mammoth Lakes as we're coming to town, and the north side says welcome to the top of California. So that's the north side and the south. Bruce, just a question. And you're saying this is the photo op because they see the mountain and the forest and everything, right? Yes. Okay.

3:13:43 If you look back, this is not the background. They're lovely trees, but it's really not the photo opportunity that people want. The mountain in the background is what people are going to take a picture of. And we want people taking, you know, they're going to stop and take pictures of that because it has the mountain there. That is the major draw here. We want the words Mammoth Lakes in their picture with the mountain that they have for years to come.

3:14:12 And they remember it and they send it to friends and such. So that's the south side. This, it's a little hard to see, but this is the, where the two monuments are. You can just barely see Thompson's Way there to the right of the one, the south one. So they're just directly straight across from each other. This next, this is a little bit,

3:14:44 That's the curve there in the upper right hand corner is the corner of Thompson's Way. There's a mound and some rock work on the west side. There's a sloping, somewhat retaining wall. It's not technically a retaining wall. On the west or the east side in front of the sign. And it'll be, both of these signs are lit. Both monuments are lit.

3:15:14 With a lantern on the top and with ballards that are tall, ballards with a light that's a very focused light that will light just the sign. The east face of those signs are lit with two ballards and two lights. The west face of the south sign is lit with one ballard. It's not as important a message. And there is no lighting on the west face of the north.

3:15:44 And again, this is the south monument and the earthwork being done mounding. There is some earthwork on the other side. We're just not as far along with that. These plans are in for the building permit. We've got corrections letters back. All the corrections have been made at this point. So we're at the point of being able to pull a permit for the south side. North side, the architectural plans are about...

3:16:20 85% done. Structural plans haven't started. We're waiting on Forest Service on that. But for the submittal for the Forest Service, we needed to have my plans far enough along. And the grading on the north side, there's a bit of grading for that. That hasn't been done either. This is just some images that show some of the materials. And they're all just all natural materials.

3:16:55 With the possible exception of the lettering being a finish on it because they're a cut letter and they need to be in a contrast to the background. We have that fine line between having everything blend in and go away and the need for it to actually be able to be read and seen. So we think we've replaced what the message is and gives you a sense of the scale. That's a six foot tall man standing in the lower left.

3:17:34 They're mammoth. The backside of the North Monument, South Monument, departure statement. Bruce, well, you've got that there, and it's small print, and it's late, but does the bottom say Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce? Yes, it does. And the Chamber of Commerce is a contributor in this. There are, on the bottom of this sign, across the bottom, there's a band of bronze plaques that are,

3:18:23 Contributors to this. This, again, is a primarily a publicly or privately funded by donations project. And the Chamber of Commerce is a contributor to this also. There's about 26 individuals and corporations that are contributing to this at this point. So, yes, that does say that. And they're paying for their letters and all the other letters on this side of the sign.

3:19:07 At least. Okay? Questions? I had one. So when people stop for the photo op, they've got to pull into the court on Thompson Way, they've got to pull into the court house parking lot area and walk over? Or they can come across from the visitor center also. Because this is right at the bike tunnel. Is the visitor center about a quarter mile of the road though? No. No? No.

3:19:45 Yeah. We have a healthy, visiting crowd. Okay. I'll answer my question, I guess. They've got to park there. This is on the shoulder. On the shoulder in the summer. Let's not go to it. Okay. Thank you, Bruce. Okay. Okay. So if I could specifically...

3:20:20 I know people wish to address the council in this matter. What we're seeking direction from the council is, one, we have more work to do at the staff level to determine what the appropriate agreements are and memorandums of understanding are with the different parties. So we have agreement works to do with the county, with the water district who's working on this. And we have yet to determine, in the end,

3:20:50 Who is the best entity to actually own and maintain this? It could be that it's the foundation. It could be some other group. So we haven't resolved that. But any comments that you can, questions and directions you might give us, that could be helpful. And also, for the north, we saw this some time ago. We were working on the south feature.

3:21:20 And you can see that it has grown, and the project proponents are very supportive of this, and they're recommending that the North be implemented and added to this. And I think all of the parties involved, the significant donors, the Forest Service, are seeking some form of direction and commitment from the Town Council. So that is what we're seeking from you.

3:21:48 Today some sense of direction. Where do you want us to go with this? Are you supportive? And we don't have all the information to bring to you, so this is an early touchdown on the newest component as well. Thank you. Don't go too far. Are there questions of staff? I do have one question. It's a question that really is being asked.

3:22:11 By other people, and I don't know if I have the right answer, but we're talking a monument sign here coming into town, which I think is great. I mean, the trees look, the trees in the mountain always just still get me excited when I drive through that area. I think this complements those things. But the question is, we have another sign that we have talked about in the past. What is the status of this other sign down?

3:22:36 On 203. The Forest Service has rejected the current signage proposal. We had a meeting last month in which we had our stakeholder group actually touring all of the facilities. We went to the airport, we drove through town, and we saw a number of different sites. And that stakeholder group includes Caltrans because they...

3:23:00 Have some fairly strict regulations, and they also manage the right-of-way, and it included the Forest Service. So the Forest Service representative, John Kazmierski, informed this group, which included two arts commissioners, that the current design of the art project is rejected. The Forest Service has given us, the town, and the arts commission,

3:23:26 Fairly consistent input now on some of the previously proposed art projects. One example was the kinetic pieces, it's hard to remember their name, that had been proposed and suggested to be placed in front of the visitor center. The Forest Service also considered a proposal to place the trout up by the lakes areas.

3:23:55 And their consistent information is that they're very concerned and they're very sensitive to the design context. There should be a reason that a particular piece of art, or whatever feature we want to call it, is being placed somewhere on Forest Service land versus privately held land. So they see a difference between the public land and private land. They see the main lodge, for example, as...

3:24:25 Although it's forest service land, it's built in an urbanized way, and so they see a different context. For those areas that are generally natural in the forest, they're expecting to see something that has an appropriate design, so it's probably not bright, flashy chrome. It's far more related to the natural materials and the natural colors.

3:24:47 And it also has a reason for being there that's telling a story. And some, I think, of the more abstract pieces don't fit with the Forest Service concept of public art in the Forest Service lands. And they're very protective because they have such a huge area and we can all imagine how many requests for stuff.

3:25:10 Okay. I don't mean to cut you off, Mark, but just to kind of go back to my point would be is that does this open up any funding that might be moved over towards this project by not having to sign down on 203? It could. And we've talked about this before. The Public Art Commission recommends expenditures to you, but it's the Town Council's decision on how to make those expenditures.

3:25:40 So in, and I think one of the things that we'll do through this other, through this process, this wayfinding process and gateway monumentation process is consider where are the main gateways? Are there some minor gateways? If this is the main one, it should be considered and perhaps there's another location that the Kabbalah design could be placed. The town council could also

3:26:07 Which we've mentioned here in financial considerations. If the town wishes to fund some or all of this, you can so direct. Or you can ask for more information for consideration. But yes, it could do that. Okay. Thank you. Mark, I have some input on possible ownership of the south sign and maintenance.

3:26:39 Monroe County Board of Supervisors on a 5-0 vote were gracious enough to allow us to place the sign on their property. I'm a believer and a proponent that three of the five Board of Supervisors, members of the Board of Supervisors, represent the community of Mammoth Lakes, which is the majority of the Board of Supervisors, and that the town of Mammoth Lakes is part of Monroe County.

3:27:06 That's what I would propose, a 50-50 ownership.

3:27:38 Maintenance of that sign between the town and Mono County so that it's not all in one agency or the other. Do you think we can include the state on that? Do you mean Caltrans? You know, I would be satisfied with the town in Mono County. Also, I really appreciate Skip bringing up the concept that you just brought up on the sign and the discussion whether we need a sign.

3:28:10 Further east on 203 and what money that may or may not free up for the north side signage. That's a really great possibility to think about. Having said that, I'm not prepared tonight. I don't think that the council input on the north side sign is urgent tonight. And I would like to give our process.

3:28:42 Let it work itself through and maybe address the north side sign sometime after the first of the year. John, I just thought it was important to you. A lot of people think we're building two signs right now. And I want to get that out to the public. That is not our intention at this point. As one of the two liaisons of the Public Arts Commission, along with Skip, I know they are already discussing whether or not the, do we call it the Kabbalah sign?

3:29:11 Whether or not, since many people said it had the industrial look, it could somehow be on Meridian, either near Commerce Drive or near Trails End Park, since money has already been spent on it. And I think that's a separate issue that we need to think about. Can it be reused because money's been spent, staff time has been spent, et cetera, on it?

3:29:37 Does it make sense to have that discussion after the first year? Yeah, it does not have to happen now because first of all I'd like to have the Public Art Commission discuss it and make a recommendation to us and that was just a sparkle in a couple of their eyes. It was not a full commission discussion. Okay, good. I have one point of clarification in the agenda bill is it

3:30:05 Yes, I attended the last M.M.S.A. liaison committee meeting, but because of another commitment, I left before this was discussed, and I do not feel it is in the least bit appropriate to use public art money for a monument sign. And I would like to have, that's another reason for delaying the north side, is for us to really consider it. I don't see how it in any way fits.

3:30:32 The ordinance or the plan that we just approved in June as far as what public art money should go for as far as art and the story and all of that. Wasn't the sign we used before a monument sign? No, it's considered, that one is artistic. That's why we all, that's why I had trouble with it because it was art. It's all right. Yeah, I support having that discussion after you've had a chance to vet it.

3:31:03 Okay, so that is direction. Anna? I think your direction was continue with the south gateway feature and explore different ownership and maintenance possibilities, including a 50-50 with the town and county so we can explore those and allow the

3:31:34 Wayfinding Program and the Arts Commission who is taking a tour next week to see if they can come up with art concepts and strategies. So work with the Arts Commission on the Kabbalah sign and through this also merged with this Wayfinding Program. And I think you may be supportive of the North Gateway, but you're holding off on the concept of funding discussions.

3:32:04 Tell? I think that's all right. Well, I think it's more than fun. Well, I guess so, because if you can't fund it, you're not going to build it. I think we can live with one sign for a while. I do know that you have members of the public that wish to address it before you. Okay. Okay. In talking about this project, obviously, I held my comments from number 17 on the agenda.

3:32:40 To really tie it into here. The Gateway Monument, the whole point of it is to have an arrival area and really have a presence when you come into town. And I think that the combination of the Gateway as well as the wayfinding signage throughout town and the consistency of that is critical. And this Gateway is something that if you go into, I came through Yosemite right before we had to close everything the other day. And it's amazing, the signage going into the park.

3:33:09 It's probably one of the most photographed pieces because people want to have that memory of the recognition of where they were. And I think that's critical for us. I think the consistency also is something that the line between art and signage and wayfinding is a tough one because I think that the challenge that the original sign presented, the Kabbalah sign down by 395,

3:33:39 Is that if you were to see that and then come into town, it doesn't have the consistency, whether it's the materials, whether it's the messaging, whether it's the fonts, whether it's the size, whether it's the shapes. So I think that there's something that we need to look at there as well as combining signs and doing different pieces. But the gateway sign, I think, is one that is really an arrival piece for us that really hasn't been here. You know, the sign that we have down there right now that's probably three foot by five foot, not really an arrival sign.

3:34:08 This is something that definitely, definitely lets you know you're here. And I also wanted to read for the public's knowledge here an email that was sent to the council members today from Chuck Landy of Chadmar Group, which is, Dear Mayor and council members, given the weather conditions, I'm unable to get to Mammoth Lakes this afternoon and attend the council meeting tonight as I had hoped. He talks about items 18 and 19, and he says they're very important to the rebirth of Mammoth as a town as it comes out of the recession.

3:34:38 I urge you to approve item 18 and participate to any extent possible. The entry monuments provide a sense of arrival to Mammoth, which is critical. I think that's the same consistency with where we feel we're coming from. So I encourage you guys to focus on that as an opportunity for us. John, quick question while I have you. I wasn't overly whelmed with welcome to the top of California.

3:35:08 To me personally it doesn't say anything, and I know that that's open for discussion. And then looking at the materials, I see something like welcome, and then we have the quote from John Muir, people coming into Mammoth, and if it says going to the mountains is going home, then particularly people that have second homes here or people that live here, I think they can relate to the...

3:35:36 You know, hey, we're coming to the mountains, we're coming home. Anyway, just a thought. Right, and there's still discussion points on that as to what they should say, even the back of the sign for the Chamber of Commerce as far as thanks for coming, please visit again soon. Things like that. I think we still have some work to do as far as the branding of the sign so that it's tied into where we're headed with the overall brand of Mammoth Lakes as well. Right now, in my opinion, it's a little too corporate, a little too hard.

3:36:05 But I think that's something that all of those things are kind of placeholders for right now. Yeah, absolutely. Thank you. Bruce will probably kick me. John, before you go, so I'm unclear from your message how important the north side sign is to you as opposed to...

3:36:31 Just the south side sign at this time. You know, I think you could get away with the south side sign being the sole piece, but I think when you add the north side sign, it does give you a true sense of arrival. Graceland doesn't have one post on the side of the gate. I think those are the sort of things that when you are coming in, it is a sense of arrival, whether it's the standards of an old west going to a rancher.

3:37:00 The monuments come into a lot of different parts and cities. I think it's just a nice bookend to the entrance into the town. Thank you. Anything else? Jim, did you want to speak? I'm going to disagree with John, actually, because I actually think the north side is as important as the south, and the south is as important to the north.

3:37:33 This is a gateway into an entry statement. It's a guest experience. It is, welcome to Mammoth. You're here. We're different. We're exciting. We're moving forward. I think it's a metaphor for where we're going and where we want to go. And I truly believe that we need both. Now, we can certainly argue whether it's art or not, and we can certainly argue...

3:38:00 How it should be funded. And I think that is a discussion that will probably bear itself out as we move forward with this. And, you know, look, I mean, we all know, I mean, Elizabeth Tenney, as we all know, has been an absolute bulldog. In fact, I would say to you, just help us out so she can stop calling me as a favor. We all love Elizabeth and she is great at this. And I want to give her...

3:38:28 Kudos to the Nth degree. She's been absolutely fantastic. Mammoth Mountain is super supportive of this, as you can tell. We think this is actually a great statement. It goes back to the signage of weight mining. It goes back to those low-cost, high-impact things that we can do. I think this really makes a true statement. And I actually think...

3:38:48 We would be selling ourselves short, and we would be selling our guest experience short by having an online sign. And I'm not trying to be dramatic, I truly believe it. And I think Larry and Bruce would tell you the same, and these signs are...

3:39:03 Beautiful. These guys are super talented. We love them. From an architectural point of view, and to me it's art, but the same thing, I won't get into that discussion, but when you look at some of the best architecture in town, this absolutely mimics it and makes a statement. It's part of all the placemaking that we're trying to shoot for. I can't...

3:39:24 Thank you. Thank you.

3:39:53 You know, Rusty's having a fundraiser at his house on Saturday. Steve Horman's actually doing the same thing. There's a couple houses at the block that's going to be open and try to push that off. Jim's going to have a kickoff at the new restaurant, Red Lantern, when that opens. So there's a huge amount of support for this.

3:40:11 And we're going to fundraise for it. Mammoth Mountain's going to provide, at a minimum, just like-kind services. We'll provide materials. If we can provide actual cash, we're going to try to do that, too, as we move forward. I think everybody else is going to do the same thing. So I encourage you to not discount the north side. I believe them to be one and the same. And if we work towards those, plan those, get everybody on board, we'll be fundraising for both of them.

3:40:40 We're not trying to distinguish one from the other because, like I said, it's absolutely the same. So please consider going after both. And, you know, look, if we fundraise for enough for the south side, great, we'll get it, we'll get it in, and then we're going to keep fundraising so we can get enough money to do the north side as well.

3:40:57 Plan them both. Let's talk about them both. Let's treat them as one entry statement, and we'll get them both. And maybe it's phased, maybe it's not. Just depends on how successful we are at fundraising, but we'll end up with both of them. I absolutely believe it's imperative to do that. Jim, real quick, your point's well taken, obviously. The point I was trying to make was that on the north side, it was unfunded, and to me, unfunded meant

3:41:24 That they were looking to the town to fund it. We can't fund it. I don't think that was the intent. When I say we, specifically all of us together, being led by Elizabeth, we're looking at this together as one project. And we'll fundraise until both have been funded and then both can be built. Thank you. And not that we wouldn't, we'll still continue to seek.

3:41:49 You know, help from council. In fact, one of the things I would at least ask of you today is because of trying to treat them as one, if you guys could at least maybe give, throw in some staff support and time so we can continue to process the plans and kind of work with them. So they've been a super help but they've been very limited. So I'd ask you to give some staff direction to allow us to kind of use their time as we continue to move forward as well as part of that.

3:42:16 Totally agree with you. And like I said, we're actually trying to fundraise for both at the same time. Thank you. Okay. Anybody? I would need to have Mark come back to the microphone if you could and explain to council what our options are, if any, and what staff time we'd be looking at for you to help facilitate both sides.

3:42:40 The south side, you've already acted on that and authorized us to allocate staff time to the signed permit, which we've now completed, and also limited building permit review, which is underway, and we'll complete that shortly. The work on the north side, you can see that the architectural plans, the concept is very similar, so the design time is way down for us. And I think the critical path would be to file...

3:43:06 Direct staff to file a special use permit with the Forest Service because the Forest Service prefers to work with the town as the holder of the special use permit. And so we would use this information and submit it to the Forest Service so that they would be able to consider it in a way that if it does move forward, they'd be prepared to do work potentially as early as spring funding.

3:43:35 Dependent, of course. But right now, with Council, it's all about money. It's all about how staff spends their time and what monkey wrench would this throw into your staff's time? I don't think it would be a significant process to file the permit. It's a standard transportation and utility permit. It's like S-205 or something. And it just requires some simple language. I might even print it and have...

3:44:03 The applicant team fill it out and then we submit it to the Forest Service. So I don't see a significant time on our behalf to support the north side. Thank you. De minimis. So I would change my recommendation based upon the input that both Jim Smith and yourself gave us, seeing that the continuation of the process to permit the sign on the north side would not be a...

3:44:42 Significant financial impact or workload impact on your staff. I'd second that. Any other comments? Yeah, well, I fully agree that both sides are equally important. It's a statement coming in. It's a gateway. That is what it is. You've got to have two sides to your gateway. So I think that is important. And I also think that with the right verbiage on that north side, it will be equally as...

3:45:19 Photogenic as desirable place to have your photo taken as the south side and we may save some people the life-threatening rush across the street trying to get that picture on the other side. Hey, we've got a tunnel underneath the road.

3:45:34 We could put antlers on, they could put them on and run across the street, slow down for the deer, you know, that might work, I don't know. But I do think that that is important, you know, the verbiage will make that sign, you know, very photogenic over there on that side, particularly with the big trees behind it. I'm not particularly hung up on whether the county is going to, we'll ask them, we'll see if they want to be part of this, but I think the fundraising that we do, the pride of ownership that will be taken if the town,

3:46:04 goes into this on its own and says, look what we did for our community. We are proud of our town. It makes a huge statement. So, you know, I want to continue on with both sides and continue looking at funding sources, be it private, be it public art, whatever we can do to get these things moving forward and get them both built as soon as possible. Yes, starting with one, getting it completed is probably the best way to

3:46:33 Program it, but we need to make sure we got the finished product in mind and get both sides done. Mark, do you need a council motion or do you just need a direction? Well, it's my understanding of saying it's within budget. We've already allocated those funds, haven't we? For the south side? No, I think you were saying for the north for the special use permit. You would get it done within existing resources.

3:47:03 Slightly higher. We'll find our own staff time and make that happen. What we're really seeking is direction, your direction, to work on this effort. We don't initiate projects and just do them. For the town manager, for you. Okay. I have no problem proceeding with the special use permit, and I'm going to hold Jim to raising the funds.

3:47:32 I'm supportive of the project, I'm supportive of owning it, I'm supportive of maintaining it, and I'm supportive of finding money to assist in the fundraising effort, including transferring money from, it's already been allocated toward the sign that is now no longer approved down at the bottom of the hill. Okay.

3:48:01 Any other comments on this that you were just asking for direction, right? Consensus is adequate. Thank you. Then we will move on to item number 19, which is the draft scope of work for the capital improvement program and public facilities financing plans. Thank you very much. The purpose of this agenda item, both Ray and I are prepared to answer your questions.

3:48:34 Is to seek your review and approval of the draft scope of work for the five-year capital improvement program, CIP, and the public facilities and finance plan. By way of background, this work is building on the work of the capital facilities financing committee. That committee met a number of years ago and recommended that the town revamp its... Excuse me just a second, Mark. Could you please take that discussion outside? Thank you.

3:49:04 That the town revamp its CIP process and also revamp the master facilities list and how the town approaches the funding and financing and establishment of that master facilities list. The five-year CIP program and

3:49:27 PFFP are related substantially, and so we have prepared in this report an overview of the scope and the intent of this effort and are seeking your direction. So I won't go through this in detail, and I'd rather try to respond, myself or Ray, to your questions and comments. Questions of Mark or Ray?

3:49:59 Mark, I have one that is kind of a timing and sequencing question. I noticed that you have us approving a committee tonight, presumably after we've talked about scope of work, et cetera, but it has some unfilled positions. Yet you've already scheduled a joint commission workshop for next week, and I just made the presumption that that would include your committee.

3:50:28 It would. If you wish to consider this further and not appoint your committee, we would hold on that joint workshop. The point of the joint workshop is to have that committee and all of the commissions in the same room so they can hear the scope of work in the process because this effort is both a committee effort, but it's also a full commission effort.

3:50:53 We will ask the commissions to individually review in detail their own CIP program. And this is what the Recreation Commission has been talking about to us extensively. And so Ray is nearing production of a draft CIP that would include an asset management program. So it lists the existing facilities we have and identifies the rehabilitation and repair requirements.

3:51:22 And then in the capital projects program, it describes those facilities, and there's a cost threshold that makes it more than just routine maintenance. And so, for example, the rec commission will get a fairly extensive list of what more pool, you know, paint that needs to be done, maybe roof repair, and the more substantial projects, such as fixing the pump system. And so the commissions will get to

3:51:51 Chew and weigh in in detail about what the priorities are, but they'll have extensive information in front of them so they can have a really thoughtful, reasoned discussion and so that it will help them figure out what's truly important and what their recommendations are.

3:52:10 So the PFFP is really the committee-level work. The commissions will work in detail on the CIP. And then there's a much more long-term program where staff is focused on carrying out the recommendations that the town council would accept from that PFFP about redoing the sidewalk master plan, for example. But that's not a critical path item, and that would extend over.

3:52:39 A much longer period of time. Okay, then there's a second timing question. Is that if in Phase 1 you're getting this list and you're starting to talk about going through and doing some priorities, why is the resizing, re-scoping in the following year, why is that not included at the same time? In the very first phase, our objective would be about December, January to work through the PFFP.

3:53:08 And with that committee group, present the information that we've already had. We don't want to reinvent the wheel. I think the strategies are largely finished. You just adopted rec strats, you have district planning, you have a host of master plans, and you have the general plan. And the work that was done through the CFFC group has already identified a structure so that that master facilities list can be discussed.

3:53:36 The various criteria that would be used to figure out, you know, should a given project stay on the list? Should the Civic Center project in this current fiscal environment stay on the 20-year master facilities plan? I don't know. So we would walk through that process and the expected recommendation from the committee to the council would be what facilities stay on the list? What facilities should be specifically studied to be resized?

3:54:04 I don't think it's possible for us to re-scope a, you pick a facility, whatever it is, to re-scope that in a three-month period of time. And so we would want to come to the Council with recommendations. And then the third one, which is really key, is of those facilities that should stay on the list and should be re-scoped and considered, what are the best funding tools to achieve them? Because we already know that development impact fees.

3:54:33 Have a host of problems associated with them. And so having some sense of what should be funded through assessment districts, whether it's facility maintenance or even a business improvement district, what should be left for some future bond issue, what should the people decide to vote on, and the structure of the financing, whether it's pay-as-you-go, short-term bond instrument, or a long-term bond instrument.

3:55:01 And then, of course, we also have other tools. It may be that some of the facilities should be implemented as a condition of approval on certain projects, and they're just simply not executed through a public funding source. Traffic signals, very common for a project that's causing a major impact to install the traffic signal. So that's what we would hope to achieve in the short term.

3:55:26 Come to you with a recommendation, seek your direction, and then we would carry on to implement those short-term tasks. Okay, and maybe I didn't ask it quite right, but the CIP is the five years. Yes. And presumably everything that is on there has been reviewed for scale, size, or at least, you know, see what I'm saying is, you know,

3:55:51 I forget what the total was for the Civic Center, but I hear $60 million. Well, no, if it's $60 million, it isn't happening anytime soon, but what if it's really only $23 million? One of the issues with the $5 million of CIP program is that if there's not money for it, it shouldn't be on the CIP list. Okay, so that's the first go-around of the feasibility is what we have funding for at this point. Right. Mark, I apologize, but I need to be reminded

3:56:21 Why we're doing this, why this is even on the agenda, when in my mind we would be wasting staff time, commission time, council time on prioritizing CIP projects that in my mind we don't have any development projects, we don't have any money.

3:56:52 To perform any of the items on the CIP list, why is this a priority to do this work? There's two answers to that. I'll answer the first, and then I'll ask Ray to talk about the CIP. One of the critical path items that is embedded in this program is resolving DIF. Is what? Resolving the development impact fees.

3:57:16 We have a couple of projects that have come our way that are exposing to us some of the issues with development impact fees and our flexibility in dealing with them. The Mammoth View project is a project that is perhaps suggesting that it's ready to move forward. Except for the impact fees, they're suggesting that they're too high. So we're cleaning up something that isn't appropriate today.

3:57:41 Right. And, you know, figuring out the right form of flexibility, right-knit, you know, DIF used to be that high, and the CFFC work reduced it. We still have 10 buckets of funding. There are small increments. And perhaps, I don't know what the answer is yet, which is part of the process, perhaps DIF should be that big, and there should be fewer buckets.

3:58:07 I'll bet it doesn't match.

3:58:36 On a critical path item is how do we then fund what we need? And this is essentially the community and this representative group being able to say and separate what do we need from what do we want. Bill Sauser coined that term in the CFFC work. So one huge priority, in my opinion, my professional opinion to you,

3:59:00 Is that making sure that we're not only prepared for reinvestment, but we're actually attracting investment, the appropriate investment to this community is important. And I think that DIF and how we partner with development is a crux issue. The CIP issue, I'll turn to Ray. Mark, just real quick. So this is part of the entire path that we've been on for preparing for reinvestment.

3:59:30 Yes. Okay. Thank you. Actually, John, I think it's the final step. I'm good now, Ray. I'm good. Yeah. Seriously. Thank you. Thank you, Mark. Okay. Does anyone else have questions? Did you need that clarity? No? Okay. So anyone in the public wishing to speak on this? Sorry.

3:59:59 I like staff planning. So, Jim Smith, Mammoth, I want to make sure I get that in. So, John, I think you asked a great question, and I, so from my perspective, or Mammoth's perspective, this, and Joe, you've already said, this ties it all together. So, we've got the neighborhood district plans done, rec strats, right, the trail system master plan, we have all these things that were essentially capital items, right? So now we get them all in a bucket, then we say to ourselves, well, what do we do with, like, how do I pick you project over your project, and vice versa? Well,

4:00:29 Bringing all this together, this hopefully lays that path of groundwork for us. I think this is a great thing, so I encourage you to support it. Thank you. And the other piece of that is the makeup of the committee. I understand you're looking for council members to participate along with, it looks like, a number of commission members.

4:00:53 Yes, please. We would recommend that this is a very high-level subject, and council leadership would be invaluable. Before we get to that, I'd like to propose, following up on my comments earlier, that under the bullet that says others as appointed by town council, I do not have someone picked out, but I think this is an opportunity to bring someone from the art and culture community.

4:01:21 into all of this. You know, Public Arts Commission has previously said, no, they're art, they're not, they're public art, they're not art and culture, when we try to expand them, because our general plan says we're going to support art and culture, and it didn't really get covered in rec strats, and when I look at this, I see that having representation and reference of potential

4:01:47 Capital projects that are in the art and culture area is nowhere in here at this point. So, as I said, I do not have anyone in mind, but I think it would be important to start giving that part of our community a voice in one of the, or maybe the only, others as appointed by town council. And that would be separate than public arts? Yes. I see that there is a difference between our art and culture. Sounds like you've thought of that already. No?

4:02:21 I think that that would be a useful voice to the table, and we've really left it up to you. Perhaps somebody from the Foundation would be appropriate. I have in mind Evan Russell. I would think, well, I don't know that he's enough of a detailed person. Pardon me, Evan, but...

4:02:43 I would think that maybe we'd leave that up to staff to look because I know there's also been, there were some people who were involved in the rec strats process in the art and culture sessions and in the wrap-up ones that might also be considered. You can certainly leave it to staff and we'll invite a decent representative.

4:03:08 For those commissions that have a TBD, we would actually ask the commission to appoint their own body. And those that have a name have already done so. On the council, would it be the mayor? Well, the mayor was going to volunteer because if you notice, way back when I was on planning commission, I was in at the beginning of this. I'm interested as well. Okay. So we have two. Those are my plan to not argue, Skip.

4:03:40 Get the straws out. Do you need direction from Council tonight on an individual? It's your pleasure. If you felt that you wanted, if you were happy with one ad for arts and culture, we could vet a few names and leave it to the mayor, or you could just ask us to do so.

4:04:08 Is there any reason we couldn't have two council representatives? I was thinking two would be appropriate. It's in a way it's like a liaison. And, for example, right when I first came on council, Neil and I were on the community development fee, which is kind of related to all of this as well. The two of us sat on that committee. Okay. Two is good. I would support two council members. At this hour, I can't. I can't think about how to solve.

4:04:43 Can we come back to this? Can we come back at the next meeting? Would you give us opportunity to have the other commissions chime in and to figure out who might be a good art and culture person? That is why I'll continue this. One caveat I'll say is Ray's staff, they're burning midnight oil to produce the five-year program.

4:05:12 All of the commissions, REC, Airport, Public Art, can have really accurate information to chew on. And so this is the schedule that we're really able to support. So after you've approved it, this is how we'll deploy it. I think I'm hearing consensus with the scope of work.

4:05:35 And actually, I was going to make a comment, so I'm glad you said that, is I think it's a really important step to essentially say that each segment of it is reviewed by a commission. I think that's a really important piece so that the community has a chance to review it. But I'm hearing that you could go forward with the scope of work.

4:06:01 But I think we're asking to bring the committee appointment back, which would also mean, I guess, delaying that workshop on the 12th. Or would you appreciate the two council appointees to be done tonight? If you would, I'm ready to make a motion. Sooner is always better. Does any council member have a problem with wrapping it up right now?

4:06:27 Nope. Nope. If you've got a way to wrap it up. I'll make a motion that the council approve option number one as stated by staff and that the mayor, Joe Bacon, and councilmember Rick Wood be appointed as the two council representatives. I'll second that. And was that also to add an arts and culture person? And to add an arts and culture person.

4:06:56 As appointed by Town Council and with names recommended by staff. I'll amend my second to include that. Okay. Before we go to a vote, is there any further discussion? Okay. We have a motion and a second. Could we have a roll call vote, please, Jamie? Councilmember Reeson? Yes. Councilmember Harvey? Yes. Councilmember Wood? Yes. Mayor Wilton Lehman? Yeah. Mayor Bacon? Yes. Motion passes 5-0.

4:07:22 Madam Chair, with the 10 minutes left that we have, I might suggest that we maybe carry over this last item to our next meeting. I was just going to make that same suggestion since we still have some closed session issues and we have been at this since 5 o'clock, so we will defer number 20, which is draft scope of work for the Economic Development Program. I will suggest that if there's any council members who have questions for staff that they...

4:07:50 Deal with that next two weeks if there's any additions to the agenda item. That said, we will adjourn into closed session. Mark, does this go back on your walls?