TransparentMammoth

Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2010

Planning & Economic Development Commission

· recording 1 hr 53 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

242 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

0:36 I don't, you know, I didn't read it for word, but I did, I think I would have caught it. I didn't see it. Because I haven't seen it, so I want to make sure that it was out. I didn't see it in there. That doesn't guarantee it. Yeah.

1:04 Before we start, because I've been trying to find a few, did they take out those two homes, the Juniper Ridge and the Plus Home, that would be part of the equation? Is that a scene?

1:54 Have a great time working on this program. Aha! So, Colin, my reporter, is saying, like, yeah, you're skiing over on a dragon's tail, and, you know, there's just some random guy staring off in the distance, you know. Contemplating.

2:16 Thank you.

2:36 Be bold, be bold. Be bold? This is nice, Mr. Chair.

3:01 Hopefully you say all your quotable stuff in the first 10 minutes and I will... You can go home and watch my computer.

3:37 Let's call the meeting to order, and if I could have Elizabeth Legas in the meeting today. Please join me in the Pledge of Allegiance. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you. Karen, could you provide the roll call for us, please? Commissioner Clark. Here.

4:07 Commissioner Duncan. Here. Commissioner Tenney. Here. Vice Chair Barrett. Here. And Chair Dugan. Here. Next I'm going to go to reports from the commission and let me have a report that they'd like to share. Jay. Friday I went to the Main Street Neighborhood District Plan Open House and then last night went to the Main Street Neighborhood District Plan Workshop.

4:38 Sharon was there, Rhonda was there, Elizabeth was there. Very good attendance. I thought there was a lot of good information shared, both by the audience and by the staff. It's a good presentation. Sure. Walk her through, or however it was called, on Monday afternoon. I attended with Jay last night, and Elizabeth, and I guess you were there, Rhonda. And I thought the last 15 minutes were by far varied.

5:07 Productive. But I thought it was an excellent presentation. Well done. I was sorry we didn't talk a little bit about anything but roads and streets. But we'll get there. I thought it was well done. Yesterday at noon, I attended the Chamber of Commerce meeting to hear Dana Cervi speak about O'Mammoth Place. I'll just add something to that. It was really gratifying, both the public comments from two open houses and last night at the workshop.

5:39 To hear such thoughtful questions and really constructive suggestions instead of people saying, no, I don't want it, you know, all that negative stuff. I mean, people were really constructive and really thoughtful. In fact, I found some resources. I wish I'd gotten their names in this town, people who really know the right questions to ask, and I wish I knew who they were. So it was a very good workshop. Thank you. You mean Campbell? No, I wasn't referring to him. I was referring to the man who referenced the Urban Land Institute, someone I'd never seen before.

6:09 But it was good. It was gratifying. Thank you. No meetings, but I just wanted to send out our thoughts and prayers to Tracy Kelly and the loss of Patrick last night and to their family and their children. Thank you.

6:29 I did attend. I was standing in the back observing the end last night as well, but it was very gratifying to see such engagement and constructive and really working towards some really exciting conclusions there. That was very good. Thanks, Mark, and thanks again to all that were involved. That was quite an effort to pull off. Thank you.

6:54 This time, we're moving on to the public comments section, and we are going to give a new sheet of shot here, which is a request to speak that if anyone would like to come forward, we'd like to record your information for the record, and if anyone would like to address in the public comments section, this is a new time that there is a matter that is not on the agenda.

7:23 Please step forward, stay tuned, and turn in one of the sheets to anyone here. Since we have two members of the committee, we can invite you up if you'd like at this time. Thank you. That's a good point. We are streaming live on the internet right now, so if you happen to have that technology available, you can see it right now. So we have both cameras and we're streaming live. Great.

7:53 Pretty scary. Excuse me, can I ask a question about that? I understand that they have some way to communicate or to at least send in something while, during the... No, there's been some misinformation about that. There is a public e-comment link, but we're cutting it off 24 hours before the meeting. It's nothing live during the meeting where you can go to the agenda and click on the item you care about and comment.

8:21 Opposed or support and make your comments, but it's not, nothing's live, I found that call, nothing's live. Okay, so we don't have a check. Clarification, thank you. And then Jamie, then we'll get those comments in before the meeting starts. Yes, we'll generate the report and then we can give you the report. So when, you know, we have a whole homeowners association, for instance, you know, sending in.

8:44 Thank you. Then I will close the public comment section for now. We do have another one available at the end of our meeting. Next on our agenda are presentations. We have none. Consent agenda, also none. Public hearings, none. And that brings us to business matters. First business matter is a discussion of the U.S. Forest Service in town of Mammoth Lakes cooperative projects.

9:14 In the Mammoth Lakes area, that includes the Lake Mary Bike Path Completion Project, the Mammoth Lakes Trails and Wayfinding Signage Project, and the Lower Twin Lakes Trail Head Improvement Project. And there is a recommendation to adopt an addendum for the Lake Mary Road Bicycle Lanes and Off-Street Bicycle Path Mitigated Negative Declaration. More to follow on that at this point. Staff contact will be Peter Brascone.

9:44 Chair Dugan, Commissioners, as many of you know, we've been working on the Lake Mary Bykath Project for some time, and fortunately, the main project is fully funded, and then the Forest Service received grant funds, which enabled us to complete all the sections which were originally intended to be included, but were not included due to budget constraints. The new project, the overall, what we're calling, the

10:17 Well, let's talk a little bit about the history, about the existing project. The existing project is the one that Speece Construction has been working on for the last two summers and will complete their work this summer. And that's the path that begins at Whiskey Creek intersection there. Goes up to Twin Lakes. At that point it went on street and then through the parking lot at Tamarack. Reconstructed the path along the lake front.

10:44 And then began a new path that's off street that went from the Tamarack store all the way up to Horseshoe Lake. And so that, there was a couple of gaps in there that I'll be talking about shortly, but that's what I call the base contract that was awarded in 2007 for SPIECE and the mitigating aid debt that we're doing the addendum for for this other work. The Lake Mammoth bike plash completion project.

11:14 Includes a new bridge at Twin Lakes, the lower Twin Lake, so there'll be an 80 foot span bridge, pedestrian bridge adjacent to the road bridge. The path continues off street and will go with an underpass just beyond Lake Mary Loop or Twin Lakes Loop Road. There'll be a concrete culvert box structure for an undercrossing for the bike path. And then the path will continue off street between

11:44 Tamarack and Lake Mary Road connecting to the path up at Tamarack Store. Other components that are included in the completion project are a spur at Old Mammoth Road. It would take you up to that intersection on Lake Mary and Old Mammoth Road. The trail is actually down about 40 feet below the road. And then at that point there's a bid option for a bus turnout.

12:15 And these will be turnouts where the buses are able to get off the street, similar to what we have in town on Old Mammoth Road. The next component is up at the PAC station. The same thing, there'll be a bus turnout at that location. Going up further, another gap was at Poconoby Lodge, bus turnouts at that location as well. We already had a connector path there, but it'd be constructing a bus turnout.

12:45 And then at Mamie Overlook, enhancing the Overlook experience so that you can actually get to the edge. There's a pretty good photograph opportunity there and some interpretive opportunities there. And then a turnout as well on either side of the road at that location. And then the path was going to end at the restroom as you enter Horseshoe Lake. It will now continue.

13:13 to where the bus stop is at Horseshoe Lake. And so basically the overall project, you know, it's very much, you know, we don't want to use the term enhanced, but it will be a complete project and provide complete off-street access to Horseshoe Lake from town. So it's a pretty big project. The other project,

13:42 In the Lakes Basin is the Twin Lakes parking lot staging area. We'll be reconstructing that with marked spaces. There'll be a turnaround there for a bus and a significantly more efficient parking lot so that it's the same area but it's more efficient because it'll be striped and designated for large vehicles as well as small vehicles. And then there's also the opportunity there for

14:11 Bus shelter and interpretive signage. The third project is the Mammoth Lakes Wayfinding and signage project and we had the subcommittee that reviewed the colors, the sign types. Essentially the sign types are out of the draft trails master plan. There's been some tweaking but essentially it's the same ideas, the same layout.

14:39 From that sign type. And we do have the two boards and the color chips of the colors that are used on the signs. Essentially, this is all on Forest Service land. And so it's the red-green, I mean the brown-green. And the blue isn't really used for the mountain. We are constructing a prototype sign that should be completed in the next couple of months.

15:10 And we can bring that for the commission to review or the subcommittee to look at. So, you know, it's a big component. We're doing about $400,000 worth of signage for that project, which that's a lot of signs. It really made the experience to use the trail system much more usable and user-friendly to, you know, allow people that don't know the area to get around the trail system and understand where they're at. Includes maps.

15:41 of the vicinity and then where the bigger signs are, the map of the whole system. Staff did review the project and prepared an addendum and found that it was consistent with the previously adopted mitigating NAGDEC and we're asking the commission to recommend that council adopt that when it goes before them in two weeks. With that, any questions? Any questions?

16:13 Okay, I've got a few here. Looking at these boards here, Peter, I see there are four choices for the Mammoth sign. Is that anything we recommend on, or is that what they're considering, or there are four color combinations? The Mammoth signs, I think what we really found is that Mammoth has a whole bunch of different colors they're using, and we're really not dictating their colors for their signage, and we're not actually constructing any of their signs as part of this project.

16:42 So no recommendation from us on that? Yes, so we're not really acting on the mountain signs or their logo for this project. There is a color palette that are registered logo palettes, so just find the ones that are most compatible. And certain ones have certain uses as well, so this would be the recommendation. Okay, you used Twin Lake Store and Tamarack Store sort of interchangeably here. You're referring to the store past Tamarack Lodge, right? Well, there's actually the Tamaracks,

17:12 Door, right, the campground store? So it's just beyond the Tamarack Lodge. Uh-huh. Okay, but you're not talking about the store at Poconoby? No, there would be a turnout. There is a connection at Poconoby, and then part of this project would build a bus turnout at the locations where the bus stops now on that loop. Currently, the transit stop goes up around the Lake Mary Loop Road.

17:39 And it comes back into Lake Mary Road at Poconoby. And so there'd be a bus stop at that location. I didn't see any reference to picnic tables as any of the amenities. No picnic tables are planned? Not as part of this project. There's signage and benches at the locations. There's also a smaller version of our bus stop that is included in the bid package.

18:08 And that's Exhibit 2. Is that Exhibit 2? The one that has peeler logs, because it wasn't labeled, and I wasn't sure if it was a bus stop or a different sign structure. But it's the bus stop. Yeah, that's a bus stop. Okay. Okay, that was one of my questions. You jumped ahead. On page 5, you talk about the Measure R grant cycle is providing $60,000 for signs on townhome property and easements.

18:38 Is that beyond the Lake Mary bike path project? Other town signs? So this is the beginning of, you know, signage and wayfinding in the town? It's the beginning of a signage and wayfinding. If you look at Exhibit 3, this is an index sheet for the signage project. And essentially, it covers all of Lake Mary bike path, which is the funding that's coming out of that. They've got, the Forest Service received two separate grants.

19:08 One was about $3 million for the Lake Mary Bike Path Project, and then $300,000 for townwide signage, which really can only be used on their land. So the $60,000 measure of our money would be to build what signs we can build with that amount of money, at least for this phase, within the town limits of the easements that we own. So if you look at the graphic,

19:39 Essentially it covers the entire town system where the MUP is now, so the paved MUP. And there's a couple of signs that are a little bit unattached, like the Mammoth Rock Trail or some signage at that trailhead and some outlying areas. But generally it's the MUP, our existing main loop. And in which area do you plan to start? In the center of town where I'll be most visible and work out? Or what's your plan with that 60,000?

20:11 Yeah, actually, it's the section from the Welcome Center, because the Welcome Center itself is on Forest Service land, but then we get into some disjointed areas that are on town land, and so it'd be to try to keep that lower loop completed, and then so that people can feel the whole experience of what the signage program, wayfinding program will be. Okay. Excuse me, Elizabeth. We actually, you know, we're doing the

20:40 Designed for almost all of the signs within the town system, but we're kind of limited on funding. There is another measure, our cycle coming up in June, I believe, and so we'll be asking for additional funding at that time. While we're on that, Peter, Exhibit 3, you've got those rectangles, squares from 1 to 21. Can you kind of outline which ones of them will have signage added in this phase?

21:10 Well, essentially, all of those squares would have signage within those boundaries. The town-wide ones that probably would not be included on this first round of $60,000, the signs are, you know, they range from about $1,000 each to $5,000 or $6,000 each. So they're relatively expensive, but they're really durable.

21:39 So doing that lower loop, you know, around the Commerce section and then, but you know, like the Lodestar Trail, maybe that doesn't have a lot of signs yet. You know, trying to get the section from the Welcome Center, kind of that trailhead point, which has a lot of main signs and the big map sign. And then that connection around through the forest. Essentially all of the signage within the forest in town.

22:05 will be completed with this project because since their funding was limited to just their property, it really made an opportunity to replace all those signs. Do you have anything else? I have two more, yes. On page 13 of the packet, the oval sign, the one that looks like this, I don't see it exhibited up there from here, but I don't know why I didn't notice this before, but the lettering is rotated 90 degrees where it says Lakes Basin,

22:39 Path, and I don't know how the other commissioners feel about that, but I find that very disorienting. I wondered why the letters weren't put one over the other in a vertical column rather than sideways. I mean, that's what Corbin design did. Maybe you don't find it easier to read if it's in a vertical column, but having it rotated 90 degrees I found strange. This is a relatively narrow sign? Yeah. And basically, and it...

23:08 All of the trails will have their name on it, and some of them are relatively long, with the connector and stuff, so you end up with more space along the vertical. No, I'm putting the letters over each other, L and then A underneath, and then K underneath the A and E underneath. So reversal from what it, instead of reading top to bottom. Oh, reading top to bottom. Yeah, I don't know. I mean, does that trouble any of the other commissioners?

23:34 Yes. First time that jumped out at me and I thought, why do I have to turn my head to read this sign? So you'd rather see it go... In a column. The other way. Okay. Would you make a note of that? That's just my personal preference for ease of reading. I think design-wise, I think it looked better, but I'm not a professional designer. Yeah, I think if we were...

24:00 Going to recommend changing that. I'd want to know what the Corbin people said first. They may have studies to show this is more reliable. I don't know. That's a good point. So, but maybe we could ask them about why they rotated it as opposed to doing it one over the other. And then my last comment, on page 30, the traffic and circulation impacts, and you're saying you're going to construct these paths to the Caltrans standards. I've already talked to Ray Jarvis about this, but I haven't had a chance to talk to you. Are you considering striping this path?

24:28 With a nice yellow stripe down the middle like they've done in Santa Barbara. Solid stripe down the middle because it's, people are going to be coming pell-mell, two or three of breasts coming down the hill and I pity the visitor with a baby in a stroller. Yeah, actually, you know, most of the path was already striped and I think what we were thinking was we just go ahead and stripe the whole thing. The whole thing. But much of it was already striped on the original contract. And it doesn't do anything, you know, to enforce it, but at least it shows there's...

24:57 Two sides to the path, so that's good, because that's a public safety issue as far as I'm concerned. Those are all my questions, thank you. The other thing just to point out is, you know, the bid package that's going out next week to the Forest Service, and then they're going to actually advertise this work, but there'll be a shop drawing that comes back to the town for the review and approval of coordination with the Forest Service. The actual detailed drawings of every sign that will be produced. Okay.

25:29 And so we will hear a follow-up from Corbin Design on why they rotated that? Yeah, I can bring that up and we can meet as a subcommittee if you want. That's a good suggestion, Jake. Anything else a little bit? Nope, that's all I have. Thank you. Jay, do you have some questions? Peter, the $200,000 in the wayfinding project that is going to provide wayfinding and interpretive information on the Lake Murray bike path, is that going to cover that whole path? Or is this just a portion of what will eventually be there for?

26:00 Wayfinding and interpretive. Yeah, what we were able to do is, so the Forest Service received like $3.03 million. $450,000 of that was awarded to the town last year to assist with paving that lower section when we were having some financial tight problems. Since then, we received additional funding from Caltrans, the state. We re-juggled a few projects that we had with the state.

26:29 Moved the money to this project. So $200,000 of the Lake Mary completion, the $3 million, is going to the wayfinding project. So there's one contractor producing all the signs for that project. They're all the same. And that will be enough to build basically all the signs in the lakes basin. The interpretive, there's about 12 interpretive signs.

27:01 There'll be a separate RFP that goes out to help prepare those descriptions and the message for those signs. And those are actually part of the $300,000 for the kind of town-wide system. I have a follow-up question to that. Speaking of interpretive signs, I understood there was a subcommittee of interested locals who were, you know, familiar with the area about possible sites that would...

27:31 Benefit from an interpretive sign, and they were going to, you know, write draft text and stuff. You're saying that's going out to some other organization? Or some consultant? What the force are, you know, it's really their money, and so that direction. And so what they directed us to do was prepare a RFP that will go out, force people to provide proposals to assist with the preparation and getting those

28:00 That committee together to develop those messages. But the committee will still be formed. It would be within that scope of work that the consultant would be, I don't know if we're going to end up calling it a committee or not. The forest was having some issues with that. But it's certainly a user group of individuals knowledgeable within the area. Yeah, I think that would be useful. I think that's what we kind of ended up.

28:30 Thank you. The Exhibit 2, which is page 10 in the packet, showing the bus stop plans, shows a light. Are you running power to all the bus stops? No, this is actually an earlier version of that. The bus transit system actually stops at dusk, and so there's no need for lights within the bus stops, and so they won't be lit.

29:02 Essentially, we took the existing bus shelter design and knocked the wings off it, so to speak, since we know that up there we shouldn't need quite the size of the facility, and it cuts about $25,000 off the price. The tunnel, though, will have lights. And then one last, kind of a minor thing, it's just kind of interesting to me because I noticed it, the plan for the modifications to the turnout at Lower Twin Lakes.

29:34 There's a note about installing a sand oil interceptor, and that just piqued my interest. I assume that's something to trap oil that accidentally gets spilled. Is that something that you commonly do in drains around here? Yeah, our new general plan, that is a requirement for all commercial properties, and so we comply with our general plan. Okay, thank you. And when do you hope to have this completed? This summer?

30:03 Now both projects will end up taking two summers. We expect construction to start in June. All of the town wayfinding within the town main proper should be completed this summer. And then the trail won't be actually completed until the end of the summer, so the signs won't be installed until the following summer on the upper lake space. Did you say just the signs won't be, the rest of it will be completed?

30:35 The speech contract will be completed this summer and we expect that almost all the work for this completion project should also be completed. So it's virtually done. Yeah. Thank you. Anyone else? I just have one question. This is Peter. Regarding this committee that you were talking with Elizabeth about putting, is there a reason that we move John here that MLTPA wasn't doing that for us or are they going to bid on it perhaps? I don't know.

31:06 Well, I'm sure they're certainly going to be part of the process of helping develop the messages. I'm not sure if they can bid on or not. That's a good question for service. I can ask that. Any other questions? Any further discussion? This isn't a formalized public hearing. We have discussion at this point. Mark, it's appropriate at this time if there are any other public comments on this, is it? Yes. To contribute? So I'm going to open that up if there's any public comment.

31:38 to please come up to the podium. Thank you. Have you filled out a card first? I certainly can. The germs I have right now, I don't know if anyone wants to. I will trust you to do it afterwards, so we make sure we know who you are. Okay. Thank you, John Wentworth. Thank you very much. My name is John Wentworth, and I wanted to just make sure that everybody understands how hard the Public Works Department and the Forest Service have been doing

32:10 How hard they've been working the last couple months to get this project done. It's a critical and key and very important thing. And these guys have been working their tailings off. So everything about this, there are opportunities coming out of this in all directions. MLTPA has been involved all kinds of different ways and aspects of this. And we are actually, we are working on some other projects to build on the momentum of this project to really get to a build out of the signs and wave finding system for the trail system.

32:39 But we've tried to be very sure to not distract from any of the efforts that Public Works is doing to get this bid back in on Sunday. So for now I think it's just important to say how much we support this and their hard work and their efforts and good luck getting that thing out on Sunday. Thank you. And thanks to Peter for sticking with it for going on 15 years now. That's very impressive. Like a dog with a bone.

33:07 Tom Moody. Thank you. I just came as an interested person today. And I'm interested, Peter, about the metal tunnel that goes under Chair 15 bridge. Is that going to be covered with any particular thing eventually or material? Yeah, actually, there's an additional retaining wall that goes parallel to the road. And so it'll actually be covered with dirt that exposed steel. And there's a head wall that is placed up against the compacted dirt.

33:37 Similar to the headwall we have down on the Meridian Undercrossing. It would be just like that one. I don't think it was completed yet. Yeah. It's not going to be just steel. All right. Thank you. Thank you. Anyone else? Thank you. Is there any further discussion about this? Any other questions? I think it is maybe we look a little for some clarity from the foreign group on the signs. When I looked at the signs, it immediately triggered.

34:08 The ones that were the vertical as opposed to the horizontal. Where they were used is appropriate with a horizontal sign because of its width. So they look like they're trail markers within. That's what I interpreted it to be as a trail marker. It's not the primary sign, but it's to keep you in line of where you are. So that's why it didn't trigger consistently.

34:33 Since I'd seen the wording before, I didn't have to turn my head to read it, I immediately looked at it. That may be a little clarity there along that way because it's not usually because you see a vertical sign. But if they could provide that level of clarity, I think that that would probably help. Not to assume that, but it didn't trigger me as off, even though I did. And essentially the type 4, 6s, that's what their intent is really as a trail marker.

35:04 And the sixes, or I mean the fours, provide that little blow up of the locale with a small map to help guide you where you want to go. Thank you. Just before you leave, can you remind us again what the graffiti proofing measure is on this material? It's got a clear coat acrylic finish over the overall completed sign, and that's supposed to be able to.

35:36 I move we approve option one, items one and two of option one. I'll second.

36:14 Is the request for clarification on that sign separate from this? Well, I think that that's the next question was discussion because if you're pending the outcome of that discussion or do we want to accept it regardless of what their explanation is for those vertical signs? I thought it was going to go to the sign committees.

36:37 Is that alright with you? Yes, and I'm not as worried about that as I am about a stripe down the middle of the path. I really want that to be a condition of the use permit or whatever it takes, a stripe down the middle of that path for public safety. And actually we're... Okay, because I didn't see it listed anywhere. No, because that's part of the design standard for the path. Oh, okay. So that doesn't need to be called out. Okay. Okay. And we're good to go. No further discussion? No.

37:05 Call for the vote. All in favor? Aye. Aye. Thank you. Thank you very much. Thanks, Peter. The next item in our business matters is the discussion and eventual naming of a new street initially serving the Civic Center parcels, including the new courthouse and existing community church. And, Peter, that is you as well. Thank you.

37:32 As you know, the Civic Center site is an approximately 11-acre site across from McDonald's that includes the community church site and is bound by the hospital to the south and the RV park to the east. As part of the new courthouse, which begins construction this summer, they'll be constructing a piece of the new road that'll go north-south adjacent to the RV park.

38:01 That'll serve this parcel and could, it'll eventually tie into tavern, but it also could be extended to into the school district's property if they choose to access the new high school or new facilities at that location. And so staff's asking that the commission discuss options for a name and select a name for the new street.

38:29 Essentially the timeline is that the AOC, the courthouse, will take access off of this new street and so their address will be off of this new street. The sooner they have an address, the easier it will be for them. As construction progresses, it's always nice to have an address as you start versus changing it halfway through the project. Communities do have various ways to name streets.

38:59 The town really doesn't have a specific method other than we don't want to copy an existing name or have a street name that's similar to another name. It could be a person, it could be a notable event, it could be a certain place in the community or a thing, it could be numeric or a letter. So with that, I'll let the commission... Questions or...

39:29 Yeah, I have a question, Peter. Part of what I'm going to propose here shortly, there's a plaza that's also going to be involved in the Civic Center area. Would we be able to make a recommendation on the naming of that today as well? I know it's not a part of this agenda bill, but could we include it as a recommendation that could maybe come back, or could we include it today? Maybe Mark's better for that. I think you can make that as a...

40:03 If you develop consensus as a recommendation to the council as a future activity, it's not there yet, but it'd be a future consideration to something that was to be built. Okay, good, thank you. I guess I have a problem with that because we don't know what the downtown, if Civic Center moves across the street, then it won't be there, as I understand it.

40:33 That would be true. I mean... That could be true, yes. I think what you can do, though, is you can certainly discuss what you're going to talk about in terms of the hierarchy of places and importance of how it relates to your concepts. Okay. And not necessarily make a binding...

40:56 Recommendation at this point in time to the second item you're suggesting. It's the consensus of the commission. Yes. If it comes to consensus. Yeah. You know, and just to, I don't think I actually said it in the agenda bill, but currently the church is addressed off of Main Street and we will be coming back and there's still a few outstanding address issues that have cropped up since the last address change that we made last year.

41:25 And so we'll include a resolution for the commission with the church parcel and then also that would do the official naming of the street from a record standpoint. And the church is going to have a different address? Well, yeah, because right now they're addressed off of Main Street and their new driveway is going to come off of this new street. Oh, I see. Yes. Okay. I missed that hard. Jay, you have a question I can see. Yeah. In our package, the

41:58 August 20, 2008, Town Council agenda item regarding the proposal to change Meridian Boulevard to Dave's Drive and Asma Street to Romas Road was attached, but it wasn't really clear what happened from that. I looked up the minutes, and it's still not too clear. The minutes from that meeting say Mr. Bernasconi outlined the information in the staff report. There was discussion among members of council, and that's it. I guess it's in limbo.

42:27 Well, actually, the main discussion was that it's pretty expensive to re-address. I believe it was 1,200 plus properties when you rename a street. So the consensus really was not to rename the street because of the cost. And one other question. I was going through my mind trying to think of some of the types of names we apply to streets.

42:56 Just off the top of my head, streets, boulevards, ways, drives, circles. And my question is, what limitations do we have on that part of the street naming? And specifically, could we name a street with the word run? With the word run? Uh-huh. Or like a Meridian run? Yeah, I don't know. Essentially, we wouldn't want it to be something that thinks it's a cul-de-sac, like a place, a circle, one of those.

43:33 Yeah. So I don't, I don't think run. Places. I think we might have to look up some state law about, from the vehicle code. There might be something about that. And I just don't know. It's really not a boulevard, because it's not that, it's not an arterial. It will be a collector. So it's a commercial collector street. So, you know, a boulevard or avenue, probably,

44:05 Those are more like materials, normally. Although we do have, you know, we do have Waterford Avenue and a few others, but town has a lot of exceptions, but. I mean, the entire length of this eventually will be what? Well, initially it'll be 300 feet, but in the long term, it could actually go all the way to Murray, and the school district wanted to use it for access to the property. Okay. Any other comments, questions?

44:37 Questions? Are we ready to move into comments? Okay, I'd like to just throw this out here. I've been... She's laughing. I've been thinking hard on this for the past week since we got this packet, and, you know, you mentioned in here about with Dave and Roma, and, you know, frankly, I think if we're going to do anything with Dave and Roma's name, it needs to be something really connected to the mountain. Absolutely. Because, you know, to me it was always, Minaret should be Dave's Way, Dave, whatever, McCoy Boulevard, something that connects because, you know, Dave's legacy is not the town, it's the mountain.

45:10 And then the college also. So I kind of got rid of that and started thinking after all these years being in town and with past leaders of town that have passed away, one of our just incredible town managers we had was Glenn Thompson. And he just did an incredible work for this town and his son Marty is now in our police department and Glenn was just a wonderful man. He did incredible things here. And then we had Helen Thompson.

45:36 Who was the chair of our Planning Commission. She had been a previous council member. Very civic-minded. She did a lot of work with the Arts Council. Business owner. Business owner in town for many years. And I thought, wow, you know, their names both are spelled the same way, Thompson. But they're not related. They're not related. So what if we called it Thompson Way? They both had their ways about how they did things in the government and working with the town. It's a way to memorialize both of them with one street.

46:04 And then I started thinking further, and that's when I came up with this plaza, because I thought, you know, we had Roy, who played an incredible role in this town, was an Olympian. So if there's the plaza that's connected there, why couldn't we do, you know, Roy's Sari Memorial Plaza? Or I first thought, you know, the Sari Olympic Plaza, but, you know, you have to get permission for that. And because my thought about the Olympics is that Roy was an Olympian too, so if you're going to do the plaza,

46:30 Get public art involved, and we can do little markers where all of our past Olympians from town, Andrea, Nancy, Cass, Stacy now, Mason and Gary, you would have a little marker that talks about their Olympic history. So it would give some kind of a story in this plaza off Thompson Way, which is our civic center. But that could just be a recommendation on the plaza part, but for the naming of the street, I just think we could...

46:59 Name, take two incredible individuals that were great leaders of this town and memorialize them with this, you know, the street that's part of the Civic Center, which is what they were part of in this town. Tony and I discussed this at length, and I have to say, Tony, you came up with the Thompson, but I came up with the Way. Yes, you did. Because it's a little pun there, because, you know, they just knew how to do things right, and they were two great people, and what a coincidence they had the same name.

47:28 I really like the idea of the Sari Plaza. I don't think we have to call it Memorial Plaza, just the Sari Plaza. But we need a place in this town. And I keep meaning to go to the Public Arts Commission during public comment and say, when are you going to start talking about, you know, public art to honor all our Olympians? Because there are so many in Mammoth. And so I think that's a wonderful idea. And if the plaza doesn't end up being between the police station, the court,

47:54 And the county offices, if it ends up across the street with a new Main Street plan, well, just take the name and the concept and the location for the public art and move it there. And that's a very good idea about having the art not be three-dimensional, but having it be stones in the plaza with the information like, you know, the Walk of the Stars in Hollywood because it doesn't take up any space and yet it gives them all that recognition. I like that. Comments? Did you know the Thompsons? I didn't.

48:26 I replaced Helen Thompson. I would want to hear your thoughts before mine. Because I just, I will go along with this based on the experience of the people that knew them, because I didn't know them. So it sounds good to me, but I just don't have any personal experience. Absolutely, I knew both of them. I served with them for a while on the Arts Council as well.

48:52 But I think that to connect them with a civic area in town I think is appropriate. I would just call it Thompson's, I would make it plural because it's a story of two people there in the set that says two people. But they were very important to the community at the time and I think it's important to carry on those legacies because there will be a time that people won't know who David McCoy is if we don't tell them. And there will be a time that people don't remember

49:21 Who the Thompsons were, but they were integral part of this community and helped build what it is today, so, and I think it's appropriate there in those areas, so that would be my opinion about it. I like your comment around it to have it be plural, but it's important that it not have an apostrophe in it, because it belongs to both of them. That's what she, Elizabeth and I went over about. Yeah. We had said, I said, Thomson to BS, plural, because it's both of them, and then we went back to you. Yeah.

49:48 That's good. Singular works. I'm not particularly tied to either of them like that. That's my comment. Do you have any input, Sharon? I didn't. You didn't? I don't know them either, so I'm not terribly in favor of names, but you obviously know about the history and the contribution for both of them, so.

50:15 I would have no objection. And this goes on to council, does it not? I mean, this isn't, oh, this is our, this is our call? This is our decision. Oh, good. Yeah, it's our decision. It doesn't have to go to council. Wow. Their contributions to the community were significant, very significant. Yeah, Helen, actually, her and her husband, they had one of the first...

50:35 Sporting Goods stores here along with Kittredge, and it was right down below where the theater is now. The Outfitter. Yeah, the Outfitter, and they went through many, many years here of seasons of serving our visitors, and then in the late 80s when we had the downturn like we're experiencing now, they weren't able to keep it open, but they stayed in town, and then George passed away early 90s, and Helen.

51:01 Stayed very involved civically. You know, the town council, she was appointed actually to the town council, and then she served on Planning Commission all the way through her death. And along with serving on the Arts Council, Sierra Summer Festival boards, and you know, with the Campbells. Well, it won't make any difference whether the Civic Center is there or not, really. Right. Right? I mean, even if that's moved.

51:29 Still is an appropriate... Oh, absolutely. Well, there are a variety of streets in town that are named after, you know, port citizens or folklore around there. That's what gives a community character. And every community has a main street that they decide to either leave as main street or change the name for whatever reasons. And there's a lot of oak streets and maple streets, but...

51:52 You know, there's just, that's what makes the community unique, is something that has somebody ask, why is it named Thompson's place? And hopefully it'll be somebody around that'll tell them. That's good.

52:08 There's no problem with it intersecting Tavern Road, is there? Not at all. Not to any of our knowledges. Well, I mean, apparently there was an old tavern. There was a tavern on Tavern Road. An institution. Yes, exactly. We have friends in Florida who live in an old...

52:29 Community around the golf course, and so they named every street, you know, after some aspect of the golf course, and they live on Dog Leg Way, and I'm just really glad that's not my address. We're going to leave it right there because it could go so... No, we can be more original and more appropriate. Thank you. Yes, Jeff. One more thing I thought about, Tony talking about the plaza and some public art. Would it be appropriate to think about...

53:00 It wouldn't necessarily have to be public art, but at least some kind of a sign or monument associated with the street to provide a little bit about those two people. And maybe that's something to suggest to the Public Arts Commission if it could be public art. Oh, that's wonderful. And it's at the beginning of Mammoth, you know, people coming to Mammoth and this is what we're about. Right. I think we saw actually that in one of the many peer resort tours, that there was examples of that.

53:29 I kind of think it's Breckenridge, but it made you feel connected to the place. That's a great idea. Would the commission be okay entertaining the plaza in this recommendation as well? That's a great recommendation. This is different. Yeah, the street is different. The naming of the street with a recommendation. Okay. You know, in terms of your plaza discussions, you know, as we bring the main street neighborhood district plan study,

53:57 That would be the best place for you to have your conversations about that ceremonial civic space. Maybe we could couch the recommendation in terms of suggesting it be part of the consideration in the Main Street neighborhood district plan. Yes, that you'll be seeing. Can you agendize that as one of the items we have to consider when we look at that? Absolutely. Good. We'll put it in our report with everything else that you'll be on. Good.

54:26 You'll look for it, though. Absolutely. Any further discussion? Nope. Sure, I'll make a motion that we adopt the name of Thompson's Way, plural, not apostrophe, for the new connector road for our Civic Center.

54:53 So we don't have it written down here, so I'm kind of searching for some words for it. Does that cover it for you, Peter, or do you need something more? Nope. That's perfect. Do we need to add to it about the recommending there be some kind of explanatory, you know, a little monument or something to say who these people were? Is that appropriate to add here? We'll put it in your minutes, but we'll also, this sounds like...

55:19 After you've acted, something that you want to refer to the Arts Commission. Yes. Yes. Yeah, so it shouldn't be part of the motion. It's just more of a recommendation for the Arts Commission. Part of your delivery. Yeah, and could you just be sure that we know it's for Glenn Thompson, ex-town manager, and for Helen Thompson from the Planning Commission? Well, apparently she served town council. Oh, yeah. Not yet, not snowshoe. They already have theirs. Exactly.

55:49 Exactly. Any other discussion? Did we ever get a second? Difference, I seconded. Okay. I thought so, yeah. Difference. And then just to clarify, it really doesn't go to council directly, but it will go to them indirectly via the address changing, and the staff report will point out that that resolution will actually come back to you for approval, and they'll just confirm your approval on that final address changes. Okay.

56:17 Good. Thank you. Can you do your vote? Oh, yes. Oh, roll call vote? Let's do that. All right. Commissioner Clark? Yes. Commissioner Duncan? Yes. Commissioner Tenney? Yes. Vice Chair Barrett? Yes. And Chair Dugan? Yes. Thank you. Could we also, I'm sorry, Peter, can you, like, do a little notification to the Thompson families, both of them? Sure. Good idea. Thank you.

56:49 And then on our item three of business matters is the draft 2007-2014 housing element update introductory workshop. And Ellen, you're going to start us off with that? Thank you, Chair and Commission. As you mentioned, this is an introductory workshop to review the first public draft of the 2007-2014 housing element update.

57:19 The housing element is one of the components of the general plan. It's subject to stringent requirements set forth by the state, including a regular periodic update. In this case, the last housing element was adopted in 2003, so we're due for our update and actually slightly behind schedule.

57:44 As I mentioned, the state takes a great interest in the community's housing element. There is a required process for the state to both review and to certify the element as in compliance with state law. And that certainly adds complexity to both the document itself, it explains some of its heft, and also a great deal of the content that's in there is there because the state requires it.

58:12 In terms of this draft, we did bring this forward for review to a subcommittee, which included two members of the Planning Commission, Commissioner Dykens and Commissioner Barrett, as well as members of the Mammoth Lakes Housing Board. We had our consultant also review the document to advise us on its consistency with state law in particular, and we had Walter Kieser review it in light of the recent changes to the housing fee.

58:39 That were adopted as an interim policy. We were scheduled to have our housing element certified by August 2009, so we are somewhat behind schedule with that. We are currently out of compliance with state law, meaning that we are ineligible or much less competitive for certain housing grants, so it's quite important to make this review process as expeditious as possible.

59:05 To help with that, we've requested both an expedited review from HCD, and we're conducting this initial review simultaneously with HCD's review in order to streamline the process to the extent that we can. In terms of the content of the element, it consists of five chapters. Many of the components of the plan are there because the state requires that we analyze and include that data.

59:30 These are the things that helps us to analyze our existing policies, programs, and our community housing need in order to develop the program of goals, policies, and actions, which really set the stage for our housing policy for the next five years. There are some significant changes from our previous housing element, including

59:52 Obviously a relationship to the recently adopted interim housing policies and the expectation that a new housing ordinance will be adopted that revises quite considerably our housing mitigation requirements. Direction to, as a key action to complete a community housing strategy in partnership with Mammoth Lakes Housing, which will essentially direct Mammoth Lakes Housing's own work program and dedication of resources to housing.

1:00:20 The incorporation of livability concepts, which was an idea that came out very strongly in some of the preliminary meetings that we had with the Memphis Housing Board, with the Planning Commission and with the Town Council. Livability being the idea that units are sized and include the amenities and are located and have an affordability level that meets the needs of the community as much as we can.

1:00:49 So that's a strong theme throughout the housing element. And just in terms of land use changes, as we looked at our inventory of available sites for housing, this is something that the state is very concerned about, that we have sufficient land, sufficient sites to meet our housing need. Looking at opportunities to reuse existing properties, to infill, to provide mixed use development that can provide additional housing units in addition to simply developing new

1:01:19 Delping vacant properties with new housing projects. And then finally, as we reviewed our zoning code with regard to state law, there are a number of places where we are not necessarily completely in sync with what state law requires that we allow for in terms of certain types of housing. And so there are a number of actions in here to make amendments to our zoning code to bring our code more closely into line with those legal requirements.

1:01:47 And those types of things will happen in conjunction with the zoning code update. So with that, I would open it to you for any questions that you might have about the element. And just to add, as I mentioned, this is the first draft.

1:02:04 We will be getting comments from HCD and comments from you from the Town Council and from the Mammoth Lakes Housing Board and hopefully also from the public as well, which we will incorporate into a public review draft which will be brought forward for hearings, public hearings and adoption. So there will be additional opportunity to review, comment and change this element as we move forward. Go ahead. I just want you to know, Alan, first, thank you for all your work on this. Sure. We talked about during the committee also just the work that's gone into this is pretty incredible.

1:02:36 Having to put it all together was just, we thank you for that. You know, I'd asked you during the committee meeting, and I think I found it here, I was trying to go through, we talked about the fact that we had some of these million-dollar-plus homes figured into the equations, and it looks like it's gone from the one part, but, you know, it's still, of course, under Cable 2-28, page 57. So are we still including, like, you know, the homes in the bluff and Starwood in our equations for

1:03:08 For affordable housing? I mean, I know we had to do it for the comparison, but it still kind of bothers me that it's not affordable housing, so if we really want to have a true feel for it. I'm sorry, Pam and I were going to talk and I didn't get a chance to ask her about that. So this was, these two tables, 228 and 229 were,

1:03:30 An effort to really, we prepared this housing needs assessment portion of the element really a couple of years ago now and obviously a lot has changed in the housing market since that time and this was an effort really to document how those housing prices have changed so wanted to include sort of the complete inventory and it's difficult in looking and sort of deciding where to cut that off because there's a lot of exceptions. We found things like for example the sale of the San Joaquin Villas units really affected the

1:03:59 Median sales price for large or for I think four bedroom plus homes in the town because there were 24 units and it really skewed the data and so it was just a question of not wanting to get into a slippery slope of omitting data and so we just included it all. So you're talking about when San Joaquin Villas went off of their affordable and they were able to sell at market rates? When those went on the market they were considerably lower priced than most equivalent four bedroom condo units in town and so it did modify the...

1:04:28 But do you realize, I mean, there was that chart in here, and I don't see it now. And I asked Jay, I don't think he found it either. So maybe Pam. I just wanted to add that this housing element is that housing, it looks at housing of all needs, not just low income. And so in some of those charts, we need to be looking at what some of the million-dollar houses are selling for and comparing those.

1:04:53 What the regional housing needs allocation says is we have different income groups we have to meet and some are considered above moderate or market rate housing. And so we have to include those into the calculation because we're really, you know, so often we think about the housing element, we think about low income housing or workforce housing, affordable housing, whatever term you want to use, but this element is really looking at the housing needs of the community as a whole, not just the lower income groups. So including or excluding those numbers would

1:05:23 Would not give a holistic picture. There's certain chapters that focus on the low income, but we need to include those higher numbers in the charts of the holistic. So does that give us more latitude in allowing for 180, 220% of median then by using those numbers? I mean, does that help us then? Well, the state really wants to look at how we provide housing in their income category. So they look at extremely low, very low, low, and moderate, which at the state level is...

1:05:53 30% is extremely low, 50%, 80%, 120%. Then anything above 120%, they just can call above moderate and it's all grouped into one. The state doesn't offer any programs above 120%, so if we want to offer those programs, that's something we can look at within our own housing element and our own data, but the state really looks at those five categories. Thank you. Any other questions at this time? Jay, you have a couple questions and then...

1:06:24 There's a couple questions in the public. I have questions, too, after Jake. Okay. First, I just, well, no, it's a comment, so I'll make it later. But a couple of things that, on page, Ellen, on page 45, about midway through that first paragraph, under 2.5, states, given that about

1:06:55 Given that about half of all rental vacation units are occupied in the winter months and the typical occupancy of transient units is four persons per unit, the town's population increases by approximately 9,200 persons. I'm not sure, can you kind of explain that? I'm not sure what that meant. I'm not sure I can reproduce that math off the top of my head, but what they're saying is I gave, I provided the consultant with

1:07:21 Our average occupancy data over the whole winter, which is I think somewhere in the range of 40 to 50 percent occupancy on average over time. They were looking at a time. So you're not talking about rental vacation units that are occupied full time. This is just on average. These are to say that of all of the vacation units about this number are typically occupied on a winter weekend. Based on our TOT receipts, of course.

1:07:52 Okay, and one more like that. On page 48, in the middle of the first paragraph under occupancy, counting for approximately 4,600 units of Mammoth Lakes total housing supply, vacation homes nearly doubled the amount of homes occupied by full-time residents. I'm not sure, again, exactly what that means. I think it means that it was more than double the amount occupied by.

1:08:23 I think it's just a poorly phrased sentence. Again, not talking about full-time residents. No, I think it's saying there's twice as many vacation homes as there are permanently occupied units in town. So I can, we can make that edit to clarify. Thank you. Any questions? Any other questions? Yes. Ellen, I need some clarifying. First, you did a great job with this housing element. It's very easy to read and easy to understand. I'm really impressed with the work effort.

1:08:54 It's about the community benefits incentive zoning policy, and I wasn't at the council meeting where council adopted that in August, but it's come to my attention in the last two weeks that it's dramatically different from what the Planning Commission reviewed, and I just wasn't aware of that. You know, it's sort of, the other stuff gets piled on and it fell through the cracks. Could you clarify for us how are, what the, how,

1:09:19 The workforce housing policy is, it used to be very clearly spelled out, number of FTEs, amount of square footage, this is what you had to do. What it is now for developers who come to town, what is required of them? Because the way it's spelled out in the amended and adopted, revised, not amended, revised and adopted CBIS, Community Benefits Incentive Zoning Policy,

1:09:48 I'm not clear. I mean, what kinds of recommendations are we supposed to be making to Council about community benefits according to this policy? About, like, housing, you know? There's two big things, two big policies were adopted. One was with regard just to the housing mitigation requirements. So the Council adopted an interim housing fee policy that adopts new...

1:10:12 standards for housing mitigation based on an inclusionary requirement of 10% rather than the FTE-based method. So first, this was the resultant work from the Community Facilities Funding Committee that was established by the Town Council. That grew at both the development impact fee rates and also the way we now calculate

1:10:41 Housing Mitigation Impacts. Walter Kieser with EPS provided critique and support to that group and the recommendation of that committee to the council was to modify the development impact fee rates and to modify the housing mitigation fee rates or the calculations of mitigations required.

1:11:07 And so that's the first fundamental change. And frankly, that was one of the work efforts that delayed the production of this housing element. So those housing requirements are now incorporated in this draft document. And then further, the incentive zoning program, the community benefits program, that was almost a year-long work, well, more than a year-long work effort.

1:11:35 That was adopted in August. And so as we proceed forward with both the zoning code update, community benefits incentive programs, the implementation of the housing element, and then the housing ordinance section, we're going to have to adjust and correlate to make sure they're now all in sync with one another. So the first change is

1:12:01 The more significant reduction in housing mitigation requirements that are embodied in that. That's the first thing to understand. And then with the community benefits and incentive zoning policy, after the Planning Commission recommended that policy to the Town Council, a number of workshops were held, and a number of interested parties were concerned about the cumulative

1:12:30 addition of density as we go through the incentive zoning program and I met with Mr. Dan Dawson and Mr. Jim Smith and we worked on those issues that are resulting to height and density and one of the policy recommendations that they made was that for the portion of a project component

1:12:56 that is within the incentive zoning community benefits policy application that those programs and those uses in the square footage that is being sought after and incentivized through that kind of a program should not also have to bear the burden of the additional burden of the incentive or the development impact fee and the housing because

1:13:25 The thought rationale is that as you keep adding fees and exactions to what you're trying to place the incentive on, the financial equation keeps requiring more and more density to fund that. And so that's why that policy change was made and it was presented to the council, it was in their staff report, and they acted on it.

1:13:50 So there isn't a direct correlation then between the number of units generating a certain number of employees, therefore you have to have a certain amount of housing. There's not a direct correlation now? Not in those limited areas where there's an incentive zoning program. However, with that said, the incentive zoning program also allows additional housing to be an item that could be granted for incentive zoning calculation. And it's all certainly a discretionary action.

1:14:16 Which is not on your agenda today, but when you consider those items, you're now looking at a much larger menu of program and facility that you are evaluating to that particular location and that particular district, and you will have to make those decisions.

1:14:39 Is this an appropriate amount of retail? Is this an appropriate amount of parking? Is this an appropriate amount of affordable workforce housing? And so you'll have to look broadly at all of those aspects of a project. Okay, so that leads me to my next question, the chart or table on page 127, where it lists six major projects and then what the estimated potential of workforce housing units is.

1:15:07 And not knowing the formula for how you calculate how much housing is required, well, I guess there's not a formula, it's discretionary now, is that what you're saying, Mark? The inclusionary housing requirement has a formula that says one out of every ten market rate units needs to be a workforce housing unit. Okay, so how were these numbers of units determined?

1:15:29 If you can answer me briefly because I can't correlate it with the maximum unit potential. I can't correlate the number of workforce housing units with the maximum unit potential. Those are the actual number of units that are in the approved use permit in most cases or in the master plan in the case of some of these projects that are required to be affordable housing units. So these are actual required units essentially of these projects. And the reason why we included these was because

1:15:59 These are, HCD likes to see the most certainty that there is in your projection of building future affordable or workforce housing units, and so we chose to use either master planned affordable housing units or entitled units as our basis for calculating our projected future supply among, in addition to any vacant redevelopment type.

1:16:27 So that's why I couldn't look at these numbers and figure out a correlation, because it goes back to other documents. And these were also based on the previous code, so, you know, there wouldn't be that same 1 in 10, it would be the, they would have been based on the FTE requirement or some other requirement. Okay, so the policy is 1 in 10, the units in any development have to be deed restricted? Did I hear you say that? In a 100 unit project, 90 market rate units and 10.

1:16:56 Workforce Housing Units. Okay. Okay. Any other questions? I'm still trying to get my arms around that. Okay. I would like to just defer a second to Enlantek if you've got a question for me. Actually, I'd like to follow up with what Elizabeth's talking about, which I really believe is related to the relevancy of the document. And I guess that's my question. You know,

1:17:28 Things have changed so much since 2007, 2008 when a lot of these statistics or all these tables were compiled. So I guess my question to staff is how is anyone actually going to look at this document and believe that it's remotely usable or has any utility? Well, I hope that the state, when they review this, looks at it and finds it credible and reasonable, and I hope that this Planning Commission or Town Council can make the same determination.

1:17:58 I mean, how much of the information here is based on data collected from the 2000 census? The majority of the data here, with the exception of data that simply doesn't exist for this community for more recent years, was taken from the 2000 census but updated to 2008 or 2009. What do you mean by who updated it?

1:18:22 Hired has access to a data vendor basically that provides based on other projected indicators can extrapolate essentially 2000 census data to. Right. So in other words, so then we get it updated to 2007, which is completely irrelevant compared to what's happening in 2010. I'm just getting to the point. It seems like I don't think this thing, it shouldn't be dated to 2014.

1:18:48 At minimum. Well, that's sort of the statutory period for which this housing element is valid, so that's why it extends that long. I mean, I think to some extent there needs to be a benchmark, otherwise data conditions always change, and we made our best effort to make this the most up-to-date information that we could, given the length of time to prepare the element. And I understand the work that went into it. I just don't.

1:19:15 I don't think that anyone's ever going to look at this and think that this data is remotely reflects what's happening now. And so in other words, you have your element and you've fulfilled your legal requirement and it means very little. If I could respond to Mr. Carlton. Among the policies and actions of this housing element is

1:19:38 I think a number of measures that will help to keep our housing policy, our housing ordinance and our housing strategy relevant to current market conditions. And I think we all understand that this is a document that's written at a fixed point in time and can only be benchmarked off of the data that's available at that time. In particular for the housing strategy, which is I think a much more, will be a much more of a living document.

1:20:02 In terms of being updated, being responsive to changing conditions, that's the point of the housing strategy is it's much more flexible. We don't have the state telling us when and how often we can and have to update it and with what information. And so it's a tremendous opportunity, I think, to have a document that can be updated on a more frequent basis and can gather data and update strategy and direct strategy to fulfill the housing need as possible.

1:20:29 Conditions change over time because obviously they are going to change. So I think that they're perhaps not directly in this housing element but in the actions that it will produce will enable the town to be current and responsive to our housing needs in future years. I think you just answered a question I was going to ask but maybe you can expand on it a little bit. I was going to ask you to compare the housing element to the housing strategy. What do we, the town,

1:20:57 I mean, obviously the housing element we do because it's a legal requirement, but in addition to that, what do we do with it, how do we use it, versus what do we do with the housing strategy? Well, the housing element, as you mentioned also,

1:21:13 Commissioner Deichen is, it does have a lot of stuff in there that the state wants us to do and to include, and includes a lot of action programs, some of which will affect zoning and therefore will simply be incorporated into future projects as they come forward. For example, this housing element does direct changes and update to the existing housing ordinance, which will become then the standard by which all future housing proposals are evaluated.

1:21:41 It will continue to live as a regulatory document through the zoning ordinance like other elements of the general plan do. And there's also a number of policy requirements as well that I hope would be brought to bear when you consider housing proposals. As far as the housing strategy, as I mentioned, it really is a much more flexible document.

1:22:03 We'll be working with Mammoth Lakes Housing very closely to develop. In fact, I think Mammoth Lakes Housing will really be the primary author of that strategy with some input from the town. And that's a, I would call it a strategy as far as directing their programs. It's a program document that says we have these tools at our disposal and these are our priorities and this is the particular housing gaps and needs that we're trying to meet through our work as the town's.

1:22:31 Housing, essentially housing authority. So it's a slightly different focus, I think, than the more policy and regulatory based things that the housing element does. It's more of an implementation document as opposed to a policy document, which the housing element is. I'm just going to throw this out there, maybe make it more simplified and follow up on what Ted is saying. This document, state required, and what it really does.

1:22:57 Is it gets us our money from the state for housing, correct? I mean, that's the intent. This is, I mean, I'm just being very blunt about it and to the point, this is all about how much money we get from the state. So in reference to what Ted is saying, you know, this is the requirements and there are, most of the tables in here, Ted, aren't 2007, they're 2008, 2009. I mean, sure, granted, it's still a few years back. Right, using 2000 data. So basically,

1:23:23 This is just, I mean, it's not our housing mitigation and it's not our strategy for the town itself. This is what we do to get our money from the state. I mean, to put it very bluntly. Well, here's what I'm really getting at. What I'm really getting at is we hired an expensive consultant to do this work. And if really the conditions on the ground are constantly changing and in flux, perhaps our staff would be better off taking this in-house all the time and maybe we should...

1:23:53 Approach it that way. If it really is a living document and our staff knows this information and has the tools to do this, why are we hiring expensive consultants to do this for us? Hi, I think, Mark, would you like to address that? A couple things, and I want to follow up on your two comments and speak to Ted's comment. Housing elements have some level of technical specificity and documentation that you need to know, and we can do that in-house.

1:24:23 And actually, Ellen has done the bulk of this work now. We started with a contract for services with E-Doc, which is they were competitively selected. And as our budget began to decline, we decided to take much of the work back and do it in-house. And the reason that, you know, one hires consultants is that you need a special level of expertise.

1:24:50 You don't have the staff resources to do that particular work or some other political reason. And so in this case, we started at a point where because of our workload and the permit activity, we couldn't do it in a timely way. And then when our budget resources declined, we ate a bunch of that contract money. So in the future, the next time it's time to do a housing element.

1:25:19 If our workload permits and we can meet the time frame, it would be a reasonable thing for us to do in-house. In terms of what this document is, it's a pure document to the general plan itself. It's an element of the general plan. And when you look at the programs in section 5.2 on page 157, you'll see that it's at the same level generally as the general plan. So it establishes policy and it identifies specific actions.

1:25:48 So it is literally a state requirement, and states do this to make sure that municipalities are providing reasonable, affordable housing alternatives and options within the community. We certainly do relate to this document to obtain funding for our housing programs. That is important, but that's not the only reason we do this. We do this to make sure that we are on game and we can provide reasonable housing alternatives to the community.

1:26:17 The relationship of this to a more detailed strategy, that's much what you're doing in district planning. It's a more detailed strategy to the very broad land use element sections, goals and policies in that general plan. So unfortunately we are tied and limited to data and with the 2010 census going on, you know, we hope to always have more and more.

1:26:43 Accurate and timely data, but that is truly a constraint. We do have the specific vendor information that Ellen has mentioned, and we also have a lot more current Department of Finance information. So we use the best data that we can to get to this kind of a document. But it's, you know, it's not just a make-work activity. There are social reasons to do it. There are legal requirements to do it. And, you know, whether the information is, you know...

1:27:11 Supercurrent or not, you know, the information that went into the entire general plan is also akin to this. And this is the kind of document that sets up the very broad framework for everything else. So it's consistent with the general plan in terms of the level of information, and it does have the added scrutiny of HCD that we have to respond to.

1:27:38 Ellen, would it be possible, I hope it would, and I'd like it in the next week if possible, this table on 127, which is our six outstanding projects, either pending or anticipated, could you reference in that last column where those numbers came from, how they were arrived at, I don't need any long treatise, just a short memo, how the workforce housing units were calculated.

1:28:03 Sure. What they reference back to, and if I could have that in the next week before, so I have time to study it for our next meeting. I've really been at sea with this, and that will help me. Yep. Thank you. Do you have any further discussion of this?

1:28:26 So, Mark, this has to be, we update this, what, every four years? Every five to seven. There's a sort of a weird thing where the housing element periods overlap, and so it gets confusing, but it's about every five to seven years. And we are at what year? Five? Seven? We're at seven. Well, we're late. So, I mean, we have to do this. So, we have no way of even waiting until the 2010 census comes in to do it, because we're already overdue. Yeah, I mean, the 2010, is what we've done, and there'll be probably a

1:28:56 Period of several months before even the most basic data becomes available from that census. And you have no reason to do that because in terms of how we and Mammoth Lakes Housing deal with our more current situations, that's really for the strategy. You know, this should be a long-lived document and the state recommends that the general plan be reviewed every five to seven weeks as well. So, you know, that just should be our manner of business.

1:29:26 But you should also expect your staff to be smart and nimble and tracking and watching and changing conditions in the community. They're significant and noting those as well. So this is like a funding tool also. If we come in, which, not some lizard that's going to make a projection, but if you've been around town, that kind of looks like our full-time population has declined some over the last 10 years. Demographics have changed.

1:29:54 So that's not going to affect this for us with the state for funding. It's only going to affect the strategy and how we implement it. I mean, the state is willing to accept data from the 2000 census from now because they understand that not every community has the ability to generate a whole series of updated data points. And the 2000 census is a...

1:30:18 Community-wide survey, it surveys a tremendous depth of issues and different components and tabulates them, and so it really is the best available base source for this information. So we're working with the best information we have. Pam, did you want to have some other comment? Yeah, I told Ted on his way out the door that, you know, we worked on the Alpine County housing element, which is a much smaller document, much less in-depth, and, you know,

1:30:47 There's a lot of updated information, as Mark had said, from Department of Finance, and even the Census Bureau had updated information, and the consultants had great updated information, and I'd look through their stuff going, man, I wish I had Claridos and all these other sources that they pay to get information from, because in doing the Alpine County housing element, it was like, 2000 Census was it, and I'd call the guys in HCD and say,

1:31:14 I've got nothing new. Every table is the same table because there is nothing new for Alpine County. Granted, Alpine County has, you know, like five people that live there. But, you know, so this data is, you know, it's a lot better than, it's not as great as what some, you know, very urban jurisdictions have, but it's really good and I think it'll be really useful for what we have and what we'll use this document for. And I do, you know, I'm...

1:31:43 The first one to leave the charge is this really does help us get funding, but in reviewing this and reviewing the last housing element, in Chapter 5 specifically, talking about what we're trying to do and what we've achieved, that's what the state wants to know. There's plenty of jurisdictions out there that go through their checklists and do this and they can't say that they've made any housing progress.

1:32:06 The state's not going to certify that. They're not going to be eligible for those funding sources if they're not making progress. And so to be able to compare what we've done since the last housing element update to now and then planning those strategies and looking forward of what we want to do between now and 2014, for me, is exciting because we've made great progress. We have a lot of work to do. I did some telling this morning. We still have 88 households on our low-income rental waiting list. We have 78 units in place, and we still have 88 households that...

1:32:35 That need decent, affordable rental housing in this community. We've got a lot of work to do. And this is one piece that we can stand up to the naysayers out there, and there are certainly some out there right now that say, you know, look, we have needs and we have programs and we're going to fill them. And so, you know, I know that Ellen and the town staff worked hard on this and we appreciate the work and look forward to implementing these strategies in the future. Thank you. I think this kind of follows up on that.

1:33:08 Out of all this wealth of data here, on page 32, table 211, median household income, really stood out to me. Between 1999 and 2008, median household income in Mammoth declined almost 10%. You put on top of that, I saw a reference somewhere else in the housing element to using an average 3% annual cost of living. You put that on top of that,

1:33:38 And you're talking about really big negative change. I'm amazed we can make any progress with that kind of, you know, situation. And it's much worse here even in the rest of Mono County and even in the state of California. The median income over that time increased a little bit. So that's the situation we're dealing with. That just is really impressive in a negative way that it's that bad. So making any progress is pretty amazing.

1:34:10 This is a really good picture of where we are. I mean, in words. In words and charts, you've made a picture and it's good. Yeah, and I found great relevance. Yes, there are places I would challenge if that really exists today, but, you know, it did exist a couple of years ago and there was, and it may exist tomorrow, the way that things are going up and down. We would hope that those issues would maybe right themselves, but, yeah, that would happen.

1:34:39 I would have to agree with you. Overall, the data is relevant and allows you to build your strategy. That's what I would say. May I ask Pam one more question? I'm sorry. Sure. I apologize. I was going to call it. We were going to meet, and we didn't. The other question I have is, you in here, you talk about the mortgage and the loans and the loan programs and that. I'm hearing from folks that...

1:35:08 You know, we're looking at, well, it's even in here, I think there's like pre-foreclosures are at like 39 as of February 1st. But I'm hearing from people in the financial market that we're probably going to hit 20% of our market in foreclosure by this summer, which is a huge number for us. And you consider we have 4,800, 4,600 homes and 20% of those going into foreclosure. Is there anything that strategy-wise you're going to be doing to try to help do buyer assistance? Because a lot of these homes in foreclosure, sadly,

1:35:38 People lose them, but they also come back on the market at a very low price through the REO process or short sale. So are you able to assist buyers with your programs in those foreclosures and REOs? We are. You know, we hear a lot that Mammoth sort of follows behind the market, and I don't think we've seen the crux of the foreclosures in town yet. Through the federal stimulus,

1:36:04 There was a program released called the Neighborhood Stabilization Program. We joined a consortium of other rural housing geeks to apply for funds for that, which specifically helps buy foreclosed properties. We haven't heard back on that yet, but it was led through the...

1:36:25 RCAC, the Rural Community Assistance Corporation, and so there's about 20 jurisdictions that applied for over $25 million to help buy foreclosed properties. Additionally, we will be, we constantly are applying for down payment assistance through all the programs that are available, and we can use those funds to help buy short sale and foreclosed properties. And so those are coming through. We're working on one right now.

1:36:50 The down payment assistance programs we offer have been huge in the last, we started in 2003, or 2006, I'm sorry, 2006 we started down payment assistance. In that time, we've done 60 down payment assistance loans, totaling over three and a half million dollars. So, you know, helping people get into deed restricted market rate homes and the foreclosures are really picking up and we're seeing a lot of interest in those. Short sales are a little bit tougher because the banks don't want to deal.

1:37:19 with added layers, but short sales are taking a turn to foreclosures much more quickly than we'd like to see. And are you getting any assistance from the banks, like on your current market housing that you have for sale? Yeah, you know, we actually, I was on a conference call yesterday where we were working with the

1:37:41 CalHFA, the California Housing Finance Agency, and we're going to work to get two lenders approved in town to do their loans, which they can do 95% loan value, which sounds like the loans that got people into trouble, but when you work through low, you know, with the low income programs, we can work to make sure that they're not paying more than they should be paying. And then the units that we have for sale right now, Oak Valley or Eastern Sierra Community Bank, they're the same bank.

1:38:10 Fannie Mae came up with some really crazy rules, and it's going to impact Mammoth a lot on condo sales. Fannie Mae says that if a condo complex isn't 51% owner-occupied, that they won't underwrite the loan. That's right. So all these condo complexes that are not owner-occupied that are being rented, people selling those condos are going to have a really tough time. It's been frustrating and difficult for us because we just finished the Aspen Village condos and

1:38:37 We had tons of buyers, but Fannie Mae wouldn't underwrite, so nobody would lend on them. Eastern Sierra Community Bank didn't traditionally do 30-year fixed traditional mortgage packages, but they agreed to step in and do those loans, at least until we get to the 51% on your occupancy rate so that Fannie Mae will then underwrite those loans. So that's going to be a huge issue in Mammoth as, you know, the condo markets we have.

1:39:03 Oak Valley Community Bank has really stepped up and we really appreciate their help. And those units are selling like hotcakes at the moment. Thank you. Mark, what is our action today? You have no action. This is an introductory workshop and giving it to you today so you understand it in this context. And then you have...

1:39:27 Thank you.

1:39:55 Thank you very much for the work on this. Thank you, Ellen. Mind-boggling, but thank you for making it palatable. I really appreciate that. Back to my agenda here. I'm just covering it up.

1:40:13 Please bear with me. We have next on the agenda would be briefing matters if we have them. We do not. So we're moving to the Director's Report. I just want to report out some pending future Planning Commission items. On March 10th, you will have the public hearing for the Old Man Place project. And we also...

1:40:36 We'll be bringing to you an interpretation, a seven-coded interpretation, that would allow or not allow wind turbines in the town. I'm sorry, what did you say? Wind turbines? Wind turbines. Wind turbines. Wind turbines. Yes, yes. Smallish towers. Yes, I know what that is. It was in the shape of that. People. People. People.

1:41:01 And then also, on April 7th, you should note your calendars that you'll be having a joint study session with the Town Council. That was April 7th? April 7th. And the Town Council has changed the format for all of the commissions and they want to focus on accomplishments and looking ahead for each commission. And so on the 24th of March,

1:41:27 We'd like to place an agenda item for you to prepare and we'll give you information documenting your accomplishments. On March 10th, isn't that a morning meeting because it's going to be a long day? Yes. So on March 10th, it's your regular meeting and we'll just have a start time at 9 o'clock. 9. And we expect to have a rather lengthy presentation now for the Old Men and Place Project.

1:41:54 And we want to make sure that even though you have held a series of workshops, that you're receiving in the record, written in the long testimony, the information for all the major parts of this project so you can understand them. And you know that the community benefits policies will be weighty. You know that the design issues will be weighty. You know that parking and

1:42:22 And, of course, density will be weighted. So we want to make sure that you have all of that information. And when we look at a scripted time, kind of mini agenda for those presentations, we think that the best time to make a time-certain declaration for public testimony is at 1 p.m. Because I don't think we'll be able to complete all the presentations. And in those presentations,

1:42:50 We would really like and encourage the Planning Commission to ask the presenters questions and comments to make sure that you understand the details you need so that when you deliberate, you have everything you need to form some kind of action. So you're going to advertise that public comment will be at 1 p.m.? Yes. Okay. Rhonda has asked me to do a brief recap of the history of the project.

1:43:16 Does the commission think it appropriate that I would do that before the public comment, when the public's there? Because it's really for public information, just to recap the history, rather than in the morning before the presentation? Yeah, the only, our only challenge is, is that since this could be non-continuous, is that when you're coming back at 1 o'clock, if you don't know,

1:43:47 If you haven't been there since 9, you're not going to be up to speed. And Elizabeth had just expressed that since she was the only one, I think I may have been here but not know what's going on at that point, the only one that was really working with this, that just could give a little progress, a statement of where we were when this progress started to where we are now. And we were thinking about that being part of the...

1:44:15 The presentation, but maybe it would be better as a recap. Or how do you feel about that? Because what I don't want at 1 o'clock, I don't think anyone does, is that we have to, that we're going over issues that we went over this morning. And with streaming on the computer, then we're able to have people keep up, which is, that's a, that's a huge help there, keep up where we've been. So I'll just talk, thinking for status. You have a comment? Oh, I'm sorry.

1:44:44 So we're going to break at 12, come back at 1. So why can't we just have public comment at 12 and not break until 1? Because we've already noticed the paper. It's done. Okay. Oh, but I think we'll have more public comment than 12. Oh, I don't think one hour will take care of it. No, I think start at 1. And we may go to the 11th, right? We may go to the next hour. No, I meant for the people here in the morning, starting at 12. You can always break and come back. Oh.

1:45:15 I mean, if the concern is about the people being in the morning not coming back or being able to speak at 1 o'clock, then accommodate the people in the morning. Well, you certainly have in your agenda, you have a point for public comment. So if you want to take public comment at the outset of your meeting for those people who only can be here in the morning, you have that part. And then in terms of recapping, if it is your intent to be able to advise the most

1:45:45 Members of the audience. I think that you'll be able to see in the morning that body of people, and you can do it then. Or you can wait until after the close of the public comment at the 1 o'clock, so following the 1 o'clock close, you can do it then. Well, the intent was sort of to edify the public on the history of this thing, because it's been going on since December 2005. Earlier. Let's leave it as we plan.

1:46:14 Part of these. That we could put on the webpage, it could go in the packet, it could go in the back of the room. Oh, you want me to write it? Well, I mean... I was just going to chat. You were going to wing it. Oh, you want me to write it? Well, I'm just saying, if you wrote it out, it could go on the web, it could, yeah, it could go in the back of the room. Okay. If you would like staff to go through our notes and show you what we know to be the chronology of events, we could certainly produce that and post that if we'd like.

1:46:45 I was going to be a little more informal about it. Yeah, I think the intent of it was just to show where we are, you know, where we are at the project in context of where we come from. And I think in the morning is fine as well because should everything be succinct, we will have time to take some public comment in the morning and then continue it at 1 o'clock. I forgot about the streaming.

1:47:10 Are there two cameras set up so everything is going on the web? We're seeing the commission and staff. They see all of us. That's great. They see all of you. The only people they can't see is who comes to the podium. That's why it's important. Right. And I think you're entering this information into the computer so they'll know who's talking.

1:47:32 I don't think they're seeing that. They're only seeing the agenda and the Jamie Wizard time stamping things and kind of taking little notes than I was taking notes. That's a very interesting point, Karen, because now that we've gone really high tech and this is a wonderful service for the community, why can't we put the podium over there so the public would be on camera too? Is there any reason why we can't put the podium over there? I don't know about your wiring. What, Mark? It's not wiring.

1:47:58 I don't know how long the wire is. Okay. And then you'll have people. Yeah. But it is, I mean, now that we can have everything on camera and on the web, it's just, it's fantastic. Well, we may find other ways to enhance our performance. There, but. Performance enhancing. Don't even. You know.

1:48:23 Okay. I have an issue before we move on. Okay, thank you. A director's issue. Mark, I've got an issue with this CBIS policy. We're supposed to evaluate projects as they come forward and decide whether the community benefits, you know, read the financial stuff, all that sort of stuff, and say, is this adequate, you know, and make recommendations to council. And for me to find out,

1:48:51 Accidentally, incidentally, all these changes that have been made because I've been in and out of town and I missed this meeting. I think if a policy that we have to use as reference in our deliberations changes so dramatically, it ought to go back on our agenda for a workshop or a briefing matter, a briefing matter where it is reviewed for us what happened since we saw it.

1:49:15 I saw the, I went online and saw it on the website and saw the final document and then I contacted Ellen and Ellen sent me the document, a working document with the strikeouts and the added language which was very, very helpful. How do you do that in the future? That would be really, really helpful because I didn't realize how much it had been revised and

1:49:41 You know, finding out about it just sort of by accident, and I felt sort of foolish. But it wasn't pride. It has nothing to do with that. It has to be trying to do your job as a commissioner. You've got to be informed. And when it's dramatically revised, it seems like it ought to come back to us as a briefing matter. Well, now I'm very confused. I didn't know that I was so out of the loop. What have you discovered, incidentally, that I have not? Oh,

1:50:08 I just got this at 11 this morning and I haven't had a chance to go through everything, but there are many strikeouts and additions and revisions. What did you get at 11 this morning that I don't have? No, I asked Ellen for it specifically. I provided Commissioner Tenney with a copy of the staff report from the August 5th town council meeting that documented a series of changes that were added to the policy. Because I had asked her questions about it. So she sent this to me. We'll send that to all of you. Yeah.

1:50:34 Well, maybe it's something I could pick out. And do we get our packets today for the 10th? We were getting them two weeks in advance. Thursday. Tomorrow. What time tomorrow? When it's done. No, but I mean... Before 5. But only before 5. Okay, so come in at 4.30 and it'll be there. Yeah, it's just not completed. Okay, that's fine. Okay. We were busy last night. Oh, yeah. Last night was... And you got the room cleared out. I'm amazed.

1:51:05 Were you still here? Yeah. Did you just spend the night? It felt like that, I'm sure. Thank you. Thank you. We've discussed that since there are no further comments from the public, they've all abandoned us because now they can do it from home, which is great. Thank you. Let's see how this goes. Then our next meeting will be March 10th, starting at 9 a.m.

1:51:34 And we will then see from the agenda what our basic schedule looks like. Then you said that on 4-7 that that is when the town council is scheduled our joint meeting with them and looking at accomplishments and looking forward. And our 3-24 meeting we would like to discuss the agenda for that and our prep meeting. Okay. Do I have those correct? And then March 11th we're supposed to reserve for the morning as a carryover?

1:52:03 Is that right? If needed? If needed. Okay. Yeah, if needed. One of the reasons the meeting was posted at 9 a.m. was so that you had a reasonable amount of time in the morning and in the afternoon so that you would reduce the probability of the RCA meeting.

1:52:26 Those have usually, when we've had to go that far, they've usually been very short, working on a few items and things, so hopefully. And which is also the reason why we hold these special workshops for you, so that you can at least hear and have time to digest the information. Thank you. For the commission, I think that was very good advice to write out a recap rather than just...

1:52:49 Chat, because, you know, I can sort of start cracking jokes or whatever, you know, just, it would not be good. No, I always have a very succinct and just, you know, my recollection. Well, then it could be in the back of the room. That's a good idea. It's a very good idea. Thank you. Okay. With that, we'll adjourn to our meeting of March 10th at 9 a.m. Thank you.