Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2010
Planning & Economic Development Commission
· recording 7 hr 24 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
914 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:00 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
0:30 Thank you.
0:52 Hi. This is the... Huh? Oh, okay. Are there some on the back table for the public? And the people in the room, I'm sure, will want to know. So I think they should be out before one. Is there... I mean, this morning, I think, when I refer to it, I think they'll be able to get it. Did they bring enough of these coffees to put out in the back, too? I can ask a mark. Did you bring enough coffees to put in the back of the room with this? Just this here? No.
1:22 Good morning. Good morning. And well, this is the, uh, this is just, you're going to see this. This is our one.
1:44 It took me 20 minutes just to pack up my stuff and make sure it was ordered. Yeah. What's the stuff we just got this evening? What's all good? Good morning. No, it's in the car. I just didn't think to take my... Oh, okay. Okay. Okay. Okay.
2:08 Hello, Jim. Nice to see you. Well, no, I thought we had to do that, so, good, good.
2:47 Good morning. We're going to call our meeting to order. This is the
3:18 A regularly scheduled Planning Commission meeting of Wednesday, March 10th, and at this time I'd like to ask Vice Chair Barrett to lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance. If you'd all stand to join us. Please join me. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you. Karen, could you...
3:50 Call the roll, please. Here. Here. Here. Here. Here. At this time, I will take in reports from the commission. Elizabeth. Yes. I found my Albert Einstein card. I think Professor Einstein, I don't know if he turned over in his grave or be amused that he not only appears in the general plan of Mammoth Lakes, California,
4:18 Where Gordon Alper suggested we include on our community vision page, vision without execution is a hallucination. And then he also appears at Trader Joe's where there's now selling cards with a quote from Albert Einstein on the front, which I think is very relevant for today. We cannot solve our problems with the same thinking we used when we created them. I like that. Okay. My next thing is...
4:47 Last week, no, I'm very glad with the zoning code update and the, you know, just the whole code update that's going to be taking place this year, that signage is at the very top of the list because our sign ordinance needs updating for sure. And I would just like to report to the commission that I took a cursory cruise from the stove to the village and there are 44 canvas signs out there. Some for permanent businesses, some
5:15 Signs stuck in snow banks, there's sandwich boards, it's just all kinds of stuff. And I thought that was pretty bad until I went to Reno, and their approach to dealing with the recession is if I put up more signs, I'll have more business. And it has gotten so out of control, and there's one place I have to tell you about, it's a commercial center that was built in an old residential neighborhood, but not old, half commercial, half residential, I mean, a very nice neighborhood.
5:43 And it's a cluster of buildings with internal parking, and it belongs in the residential neighborhood. Well, what they have done, because business is so bad, is in the snow banks they have signs, they have sandwich boards, and at the corner where Starbucks is, which is really beautifully landscaped, very nicely done, they have three huge signs for the businesses, including a trailer with a 4x8 sheet of plywood on it across the corner, saying, Napa Sonoma Grocery and Wine Shop coming soon.
6:11 And the trailer's on blocks. I mean, that's, you know, that's how bad, that's not how you compete. People think more signs, you know, that's how I'm going to compete, that's how I'm going to bring in the customers, and that's not how you do it. I was recently in Scottsdale where my husband had a medical appointment, and Scottsdale has the same policy that I've seen in Westlake Village where the signs are very small and they're low, but they don't, they're not in your face, they're perfectly visible, perfectly clear, but
6:39 More is better is not necessarily the case. More and bigger is better is not necessarily the case with signs. So I just wanted to put that out there. And we've got 44 canvas ones out there that are out of compliance right now. So thank you. That's all I have. I have a little response to that. I was there last week. In Reno? Yes. Okay. Last weekend. And since that particular street that that's on might be what we would call a level C.
7:11 Anyway, the point is that they come through that street about 50 miles an hour. Do you know the corner I'm talking about? I know exactly. If you're sitting at the restaurant across the street, but if you were coming through 50 miles an hour, the only way I knew that that Napa Sonoma was coming to town was because of that sign. So, there's a lot of, I think what you have is the ability when you do address to your mobility and traffic flow is to have
7:40 Smaller size, because now you're changing the patterns there, but when you're racing by for your life at that particular corner, something's got to slow you down, and though that sign just about caused an accident, and I do realize that they have changed the, there used to be a signal that you could turn and yield on green, which now has been, you cannot do that anymore, which we found out the hard way. So,
8:09 I think there's a lot of options and the points are, but it's not just the signage, it is the traffic flow along those areas and as we look to improve other areas through town.
8:18 Those are the options that we, the signage, you can only see a smaller sign if you're there long enough to see the sign, and that's one of the areas that we want to look going forward, so I think there's validity on both parts, and that's the stuff that we're going to have to work towards. But I was thinking, I'm sure the architect would just, you know, be appalled with what had happened to a very nice project. It was appalling, but I didn't know it was there, and I was looking for it, but it's not there yet. Thanks. Thanks, Elizabeth. Yeah, and Elizabeth, I'd just like to add into, I know we're not...
8:44 Debating comments from commissioners, but if I could just add in another perspective, and that is, if you account for the number of businesses that have closed in our town over the last year and a half, it's far more in a ratio to the signs you're seeing right now. I'll use Cuppies as an example. Cuppies went through a lot of process to open. They are signed very low. Had to conform. People couldn't see it from 203. That business is out of business now.
9:11 There are other businesses on Old Mammoth Road and two or three that have opened and to do a new sign that's under our current ordinance costs you $10,000 or more. So if we really want our business community to succeed right now in economic times we are in, I really think we need to kind of turn a blind eye to those type of banners right now until the economy comes back and we can actually adopt a sign ordinance that works for everyone.
9:36 But my original comment was, I'm glad it's the first thing on the agenda for the code update, because it needs to be updated. And we need to, you know, it all has to do with cumulative impact of what does our community look like. And it's not a standalone issue. Exactly. Exactly. Very good point. Thank you. I appreciate everyone's comments. Jay, do you have anything else? And Sharon. Yes, I attended the Mammoth Community Water District meeting on February 25th. Thank you.
10:05 There are no other reports from the commission. We'll move on to comments from the public. This is a time set aside for the public to comment on anything that is not otherwise on the agenda. We have one major item on that. So you can address one thing I do want to make clear today. We will be utilizing our speaking slips. We don't have a name for these exactly. But they are available at the back of the room. There are pens at the back of the room.
10:36 I will require these today to make sure that everyone is on record and that we recognize for the public and those that are viewing at home that you fill out one of the sheets there. I appreciate that. So if anyone has any public comments that are not related to the items on the agenda today, please come forward and state your name and hand-carrying your slip. Nope.
11:00 We will move on to the next portions of our agenda, which are the presentations. There are none. We have no consent agenda today. And that brings us to the public hearing. And our public hearing today is regarding Old Mammoth Place. We're going to be considering a vested tentative map 09-003, a use permit application.
11:26 Design review, adjustment, and district zoning amendment. Along that line, this project has got quite a history and when Commissioner Tenney graciously requested some time to speak to bring everybody up to speed on what the history was and that sounded like a great idea and hopefully the comments that she has today bring you up to speed with where we are. So I would like to defer to
11:54 Commissioner Tenney first before we have the staff presentation because I think it has a great segue into the staff presentation. Good. Staff, are there copies in the back table? Good. You'll see on the back table a brief two-page history of this whole process that's been going on for five years. It started out as Clearwater and then Old Mammoth Place. I put this together from my memory, from my notes, from my Planning Commission documents, from talking to Mark Wardlaw, talking to Mark Carney.
12:23 Talking to our mayor, Neil McCarroll, trying to get a chronology because today is the 55th meeting in five years related to this project. So we've had a lot of public input and what I did was I traced the sequence and how things happened. This is sort of the first one through the gate since the CBIS policy was adopted and a number of other policies that implement our general plan, the specific policies and so
12:52 It's a little bit of a careful process for us just as it's been a careful process for the applicant. But this is brief and I urge you to pick up a copy. I'll remind the public again when the public comment portion at 1 o'clock happens so they can see this as well because it really clears up a lot of misconceptions that you read in the paper and, you know, hear in public comment letters where people aren't fully informed. So it's on the back table if you'd like to read it. Thank you. Okay. Thank you.
13:22 If we do have some time constraints today, or I don't think there are challenges that we can't meet, Town Council has, if you've seen the notice, is reconvening at 6 o'clock tonight here, and that was not on the schedule when we planned this, so we will be adjourning at 5 p.m. today. And we do have time allotted for tomorrow morning should we need to continue or...
13:46 Just depending on what our particular situation is at that time. We will be taking public comment at 1 o'clock for time certain, and we will do it earlier if the time allows. And the Planning Commission will break at noon for one hour to hopefully grab lunch and recon...
14:08 You know, reassess where we are at that time. So once again, if you want, when the time comes, I'll be announcing, you know, what particular level we're discussing at this time. Everyone will get a chance to speak and if, and to, you know, make sure that we're respectful of everybody here. There's a lot of passion and there's a lot of opinions and we want to hear it all. At this point, if Mark, if you're ready, I will continue to the staff presentation.
14:36 Great, thank you. Good morning, Chair and members of the Commission, members of the community and applicant team. Today we're going to do a slightly different kind of presentation for you, a staff presentation for this item. This Old Mammoth Place project has been underway substantially for nearly five years. You've had anywhere between 36 to 55 different public meetings on this.
15:05 or some policy matter that's related to the determination of this use permit application today. We are working within a regulatory and policy framework. So staff is looking at this project and evaluating this project and making recommendations to you based on the general plan, which was adopted in August of 2007, the North Old Mammoth Road District Study,
15:31 The ERA, market, real estate, market outlook, and development strategy project that was completed with that program are condo hotel policies that were formulated and have been embodied in all of the specific plans and master plans that you've recently acted on. The population at one time model, our build out model, as well as the project impact evaluation criteria that flowed out of that population at one time.
16:01 Program, the community benefits and incentive zoning policy, the discussions of height and density is directed by Town Council and considered by the Planning Commission, and this very specific Clearwater Specific Plan, which we refer to as the CSP. And with that CSP, you'll recall in March of 2008, part of that evaluation included a market analysis prepared by PKF.
16:27 And evaluated in peer review by ERA. Staff's evaluation of this project is through this approved regulatory and policy framework. We are evaluating the merits of this project, how it meets the intent and the purpose of all of these documents, and its measure of goal attainment. How is it meeting and to what degree is it meeting goals and objectives and policies set forth in those documents? And then finally, the evaluation of impacts.
16:58 As you know, when we look at some of the more subjective criteria of design guidelines, that is, in a sense, an impact evaluation. What the Planning Commission is asked to consider today, based on this evaluation that we've presented in the staff report, that you'll receive public presentation on today by both staff and the applicant team, are six actions. Determining that the project is consistent with the Clearwater Specific Plan EIR,
17:27 that you'll review and approve a proposed design review, 09-005, which looks specifically at architecture site design and exterior materials. Adjustment 09-004, which is approving a 10%, which is 3.5 feet adjustment to the building height for up to 28% of the three-story buildings that are along Old Mammoth Road.
17:53 and 6% of the buildings fronting Laurel Mountain Road. Use permit application 09003 and the vesting tentative map 09003, those documents establish the program, the overall development standards, operations, and are substantially implemented through the conditions of approval. Those two actions are contingent upon approval of the DZA, the District Zoning Amendment.
18:21 The zoning amendment 09001 is a recommendation to council by the planning commission whether or not to modify the definition of the measurement of height that's now in the Clearwater specific plan, measuring building height from the top of a podium of underground parking. Those are your actions. The staff recommendation is contingent, too.
18:48 The Planning Commission should determine whether or not the proposed zoning amendment, this definition of height measurement, meets the intent of the general plan and the specific plan and helps to achieve the goals for the site and this district, and if so, staff recommends that you approve those six actions that I've just described. Our public hearing presentation to you today is first by staff, this project overview. I'm not going to read the staff report. It is extensive and it's very well organized and well done.
19:17 Literally, we don't have any more information to add to what we've provided you in the report. RBF, Eddie Torres, will review CEQA. He'll speak to water analysis requirements. And also, he'll review the third-party peer review of the visual simulations. And then EPS, Walter Kieser, will present our peer review of the community benefits and incentive zoning analysis.
19:47 The applicant team, Mr. Jim Dimitriotis, will introduce his project and team. Mark Carney will speak to specifics of the amendment. John Ashforth with BSA will speak to the details of the architectural and design program. Les Card will speak to their evaluation of circulation and parking. And then Jerry Kaiser conducted the detailed CBIS analysis, and he will present that.
20:14 During this presentation, you have the option of taking some questions after staff and then following the applicant team. You can do that at each segment, and you can close at the end with closing your questions, and then you'll be taking public testimony. There's an opportunity for rebuttal by the applicant, and then there will be deliberation and decision by the Planning Commission.
20:42 The staff report content includes a summary and background of the history of this project and its setting, the subject property and surrounding land uses, the related policy background and studies. Much of this you've reviewed and considered through the specific plans. There's some more additional detailed information relative to this project in your report. There's a detailed issues analysis, a discussion of conformance with the general plan and vision statement.
21:08 CEQA compliance options analysis, which is somewhat new for us in this report, project alternatives, and then a recommendation. The staff report also includes attachments, the Planning Commission resolution, CEQA compliance document, the project impact evaluation analysis, the traditional land use analysis for general plan conformance, the DZA and adjustment request in detail, the RBF 3D
21:37 Model third party review, the Nelson Nygaard report, our EPS report, ADP notes, public comments, comments from other agencies including the water district and town response, and then a project narrative from the applicant project plan. And then finally, new information, it's not actually new, it's just recently provided to you. Over in the first part of this week on March 9th and March 10th, we have provided you with a synopsis of
22:08 All of the public comments that we received in writing to date and in our tradition, we note the comment and then we note the staff response and identify where information is contained and how that item will be addressed. We have an additional memorandum from Walter Kieser speaking specifically to three questions that were raised in the community benefits incentive zoning analysis.
22:33 We have communication from the Water District by General Manager Greg Norby speaking to water supply and assessment. And then finally we have a memorandum from Richard Watson Gershon, special legal counsel to the town, speaking to implementation of CBIS policy. That too in response to questions. In summary, this project requests a use permit and all of the other related actions for up to 488 lodging rooms.
23:02 On-site workforce housing, outdoor public events, plazas and associated amenities, 19,500 square feet of retail and 17,000 square feet of restaurant space, 9,500 square feet of conference space, 4,500 square feet of quality spa and wellness center, and underground parking. And underground parking, I'll note, although it appears to be partially below grade and above grade,
23:29 In the definition of the Municipal Code, it is defined as underground parking. The issues analysis contained in your report covers these items, density and population at one time, the project impact evaluation criteria, community benefits incentive zoning setbacks and lot coverage, design review, height and mass, development program use and operations, feet first mobility, which includes our sections on parking.
23:55 Energy conservation and sustainability, construction staging and phasing, dumpsters, loading and service areas, and agency comments. I'm not going to speak to all of the issues that are described in your report. We find that the project conforms, hence our recommendations, to most if not all of the criteria. But what I will do is speak to some of the common topics that people are most concerned with and point out those that you should, as a
24:26 Planning Commission deliberate on. And remembering that we're working with existing policy context and framework. In terms of density in the population at one time analysis, or population at one time criteria, the proposed project is consistent with the density within the specific plan and the GP. Remember that this specific plan sets different development standards than the former commercial general of CTE loans. Those do not now apply. Only the
24:55 Clearwater Specific Plan. The project would generate a maximum population of one time of 882 units, and of course how we formulate the population at one time, number and estimate range, it's based on the numbers of rooms and units on site. The result of this project, if built, would be a town-wide population that is the same as previously reported, between 52,000
25:22 258 and 55,955. That information is consistent with the actions you took in discussing Mammoth Crossings and Snow Creek as well as the Clearwater Specific Plan. So we're still within our criteria. In the project impact evaluation criteria, it's a rather detailed chart where we qualitatively and quantitatively where we can describe specifics.
25:51 The subject headings are Traffic and Mobility, Water Supply and Capacity, Air Quality, Green Technology and Energy, Economic Stability, Social Capacity, Housing, Recreation, Leisure Capacity, and Community Character and Aesthetics. The project overall ranks highly in meeting all of these specific objectives and review criteria. There are a few places where it doesn't rank as highly as others. That's identified in your report.
26:20 But all in all, when we look at this project in terms of this broad range of evaluation criteria, it ranks very highly. One point that we'll talk about later in our project impact evaluation criteria is water supply and capacity. The town views water supply as in the envelope of the general plan. The general plan build-out estimates and the final environmental impact evaluation of that
26:48 identified a maximum number of units to be built out over the 20-year period of the time, and this project fits within that envelope. We can have different discussions about modeling and site-specific conditions, but this project fits within the water supply assessments completed for the general plan. RBF will speak to that in more detail, as will Ellen Clark and perhaps Greg Norby.
27:13 Community benefits incentive zoning has been a very controversial aspect of this project. I think the methodology is very important. The Planning Commission discussed and accepted analysis about how we would analyze this project on December 16th. We reported a residual land value analysis method, and Kaiser Marston was retained by the applicant.
27:41 Walter Kieser was retained by the town to conduct peer review, and that analysis has been completed. It was reported to you in a workshop session on January 13th, and because this is new information to you, new procedures, we wanted to give you plenty of time to digest this information, and we do have some questions that we've received recently that we'll discuss in just a moment. The reports are part of your package.
28:09 And the reports have not changed since they were presented to you on January 13th. In sum, Mr. Kieser will speak to this as well as Mr. Kaiser, this analysis considered a partial valuation of components of the project. So not the full dollar amounts of the items that were identified as benefits. There were six items identified. The outdoor plazas and public open space, mid-block connector, retail restaurant space.
28:37 meeting and conference space, underground parking, and the evaluation of those benefits, and only a portion of the costs of those benefits, was determined to be approximately $26 million to the community, which is something like a 10 to 1 ratio of incentive density to the value of the amenity. The amenities were defined first through the general plan.
29:03 Somewhat refined through the North Old Mammoth Road District Special Study, and then more discreetly refined when the Town Council adopted, and you recommended, the Clearwater Specific Plan. So the policy framework of what amenities are appropriate to the district have been formed, and these comply with those, and the evaluation has been conducted consistent with the CBIS policy. Your decision, of course, will be to
29:32 weigh in on the merits of those amenities and try to determine if indeed they complement the site and the district and you perceive that to be a reasonable value to the community. Questions we have received regarding the incentive zoning program include suggestions that the development impact fees should be paid and as you know the final adopted policy exempted the incentivized programs so
30:01 That square footage above 40 rooms per acre and the retail components, they're exempted from the payment of fees as well as the housing mitigation requirements. And the question was posed that impact fees should be provided and that on-site affordable housing should be provided. We posed those questions to Mr. Kieser and he provided us with the following responses in...
30:27 In short, that adding additional program to the project will make it even more financially infeasible, and adding additional fees to the project will make it even more financially infeasible. And as you'll hear, it's on the very cusp of feasibility in relationship to density, cost of amenities, and return to the investor. We also received a question about
30:56 And this team discussed this throughout the process and we asked
31:25 And only under pain and duress did Walter agree to respond again. And the pragmatic answer is there is not a linear relationship to program density and financial feasibility, meaning that it's very difficult to say we'll take out a spa and therefore reduce 10 units. That is simply not how it works. And your financial team can review that with you in detail.
31:52 We also received questions about the regulatory context of the incentive zoning policy in relationship to adopted codes. Kevin Ennis, our special legal counsel, reviewed that and he recommended this. There is not a conflict until the timing of a building permit or final certificate of occupancy is required related to the item. So, for example, the payment of diff fees.
32:17 They are paid a building permit. So the issue is one of timing, not necessarily hierarchy. He recommends that the town, at completion of this process, and before we go forward with other permits, that we modify the ordinances that adopt DIF, Housing and Public Arts, in order to allow that flexibility and avoid any future conflict between incentive zoning policies and
32:44 Code required obligations. The codes that are in effect at the time the permit was deemed complete are indeed effective. The application was deemed complete some time ago. And through the vesting map, they will have to confirm their consent, the applicant, to pursuing the benefits that would be granted through this kind of approval process.
33:12 Thereby eliminating any conflict with zoning and policy standards. So essentially it's a timing issue. It is not a – the policy issues have already been laid out and again you, the Planning Commission, will weigh the merits of the program in your considerations. Housing, again, it's the same issue. In this question whether you should place more affordable housing on site versus some other component is really your –
33:43 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
34:08 The staff report and the conditions of approval identify refinements to be made. You may have additional refinements to suggest at this meeting. Those refinements have been described as refining the entrance to the project, defining materials and designs of some of the column posts and pillar features, and additional refinements to the south elevation of the hotel building, as well as windows, fenestrations, and bays. Height and mass.
34:36 Evaluation is very controversial as well. I would expect you to spend a lot of time on this. Our building and height and mass evaluation, which was a successor to the story poll policy, the town council requires the planning commission to set a method to determine the impacts of height and mass. You did so on January 13th, and you required a physical model. There it is.
35:02 It was actually prepared earlier, but it exists in space and time, and you have seen it on a number of occasions. We have included, through the architectural team, a 3D computer animated fly around of the site to model a digital context of its conditions. There is a detailed line of site analysis of the proposed project, as well as alternatives to the project in your packet.
35:28 We've also included a height zone analysis in the RBF study as well as the applicant's submittal. We provided you in our comment package specific responses to your questions about where exactly does the building not conform to the current standards of the CSP. We conducted a tree survey that was about two years ago, so a couple of inches might be on top of those trees now, but that has been record information for some time. And then finally,
35:57 The third party review of the 3D computer simulations was conducted. The intent of the third party review is to verify the accuracy and reliability of those images so that you're not in a place of hoping the applicant's information was correct. And the conclusion was, yes, indeed, it is a correct simulation.
36:20 By way of example, our detailed analysis includes the line of sight from all aspects of the building in order to see scale, relationships, and view surrounding the site. And those views and vistas are providing just open sky as well as views to the surrounding mountains and the site.
36:44 This is the example of the height zone diagram. You know where it conforms and where it does not conform. This is the existing tree survey mapped to the site. This is an example of the RBF third-party review in diagram and in computer models. And then finally, we've provided photos to you that demonstrate the condition of onsite.
37:10 and your ability to see beyond any building that is there now. This is rafters. Obviously, it's difficult to see beyond, literally, a building when it is up close and in the forefront of your perspective view. The impacts from our height analysis are that the visual impacts are not more than under the current zoning, so this is consistent to the specific plan, and we don't
37:38 See that there will be an impact if you decide to change your definition of height. We also find that overall in the siting of the project that it is well-sited in terms of its relationship to the surrounding neighbors to allowing sun and access, light access into the site, into the surroundings. And by way of ancient history, these boards down here on the floor with the big X's through them.
38:05 We recycle everything. These were some of the original site plans provided for the specific plan discussions approximately three years ago. And you can see that the site is now much more open than is shown to you on that left site plan. Mobility is a very important subject of the general plan. The specific plan provides for reductions in parking.
38:31 If a shared parking study is completed, the developer requests and is annexed into a parking district, and any fees are paid if required. We conducted a very detailed study of shared parking through Nelson Nygaard working on behalf of the town, funded by the applicant, and their analysis determined that they actually recommended a lower number of parking than is actually on site.
38:59 The applicant's team will speak to you about parking, and I think that we've determined that the parking layout and conditions of operation meet the requirements of not only the specific plan, the general plan, but also our public work standards. Construction staging and phasing is frequently an important issue. The plan and the conditions of approval require a construction plan to be provided prior to building permits.
39:29 With the intent of protecting surrounding neighbors, condition of approval 126, and mitigation measures, AES 1 through 4, page 82, provide details and specifics to that plan. That would be a future implementation item. And then, let's see, almost finally, project alternatives. The town council recently asked us to provide somewhat more in-depth analysis of project alternatives.
39:56 for consideration to the public and also Planning Commission and Town Council when appropriate. We did that in this evaluation and it's somewhat hypothetical because we're not actually detailing and drawing out a series of different plan options. But in this case we developed four. One is called the base case and that is more well developed in your financial analysis and it anticipates simply leaving the existing facilities there and making some small addition to the number of
40:26 of units that can actually be fit on the site and still meet parking requirements and other conditions of the code. So it's just a slight addition to what's there, maintaining the existing facilities. The second alternative, we just assumed we'd demolish everything and build per the code, but at the base density of 40 rooms per acre. Alternative three is the same
40:51 Program concept just forced to fit within the existing height limitations. And then alternative four is the proposed project itself. These are slightly different than the options that are provided to you. This is the alternative. In your staff report, you'll see a table in which we've taken the major objectives from the specific plan and arrayed them to these four alternatives. And we simply measure them to goal attainment.
41:17 As well as feasibility. Because if it's not feasible, it's a moot point and it's only paper. Our conclusion is that Alternative 4 has the highest level of goal attainment with the highest level of project feasibility in terms of financial analysis. And then again, our staff recommendation is to determine whether or not that proposed zoning amendment meets the intent of the general plan and the specific plan and helps achieve the goals for this site and district. And then if so,
41:48 approve the six actions. That concludes my portion of this staff report. I want to thank staff for putting together this very thorough report. And I also want to note that over these 55 meetings and these five years that we've been in this, our applicant team has been very receptive and responsive and flexible in working with staff. So with that, I would like to pass the presentation to Eddie Torres.
42:16 to discuss CEQA and height analysis. Mark, there is a couple of questions. Mark, can you just clarify for the audience, people at home, that, you know, we talked about the completion deemed complete on this application, means we've been in it for five years, that actually the application was deemed complete in 2009 and not before, so the current general plan does apply. That's correct. It was deemed complete on November 4, 2009. Thank you.
42:47 So one thing I'll say about you, you have a lot of staff here. We have Ellen and Jessica and Peter and Sandra and Ham and myself. And this is such a complex project with many different moving parts. We will be fielding your questions and passing them to the best staff person that knows that most detailed bit of information. Any other questions before I step away? Not at this point. Thank you. Excuse me.
43:18 We're doing staff questions after all the presentations, correct? Yes. Good morning. My name is Eddie Torres, the RVF Consultant. We were retained by town staff to act as an extension of town staff and to serve as an independent reviewer of the old mammoth waste concept. We prepared the Clearwater Specific Plan EIR and the conformance analysis we prepared, looked at the development concept to see if the impacts from the proposed development were consistent with the impacts identified within the
43:55 Final EIR. As you can see, the conformance analysis prepared was quite extensive and had technical appendices, consistent with almost a level of detail as a mitigated neck deck. To provide you with a summary of the development comparisons, the first column is the specific plan draft EIR. The second column is the scenario analyzed within the final EIR. And the third column is the old name of the place development concept.
44:29 Joining me through the comparisons, this is the site concept for the original concept under the draft EIR, the concept under the final EIR, and the current Old Mammoth Place concept. This is a breakdown of the summary for the proposed development under the Old Mammoth Place. As you can see, the proposed development is consistent with the specifications allowed under the specific plan.
45:03 In our review, we looked at the topical areas that were addressed within the draft and final EIR. These issue areas looked at land use and planning, aesthetics, light and glare, air quality, noise, traffic and circulation, and utilities and service systems. The findings for land use and planning summary show that the development concept is similar to the final EIR and the project would not produce any new significant land use impacts. Land uses are consistent with the specific plan.
45:35 Densities are consistent with the specific plan, and the project would construct onsite workforce housing. I apologize that the text is a little difficult to read. I have a copy if you'd like to see it. A specific plan amendment proposed in order to clarify the definition of building heights. This is what Mr. Wardlow previously discussed as far as the adjustments along Old Mammoth Road and Lower Mountain Road, as well as the...
46:03 The measurement of the building height above the podium level. Under aesthetics, light, and glare, the aesthetics and light impacts resulting from the project would be similar to the proposed or the analysis under the draft and final EIR. The proposed specific plan amendment, the draft EIR considered building heights of up to 65 feet and the specific plan would allow up to 55 feet. The project did not introduce any new view impacts and view pluggage was slightly reduced.
46:44 Compared to the draft EIR. Additionally, no icons are proposed in this development concept. The next topical area is air quality and noise. We ran the numbers based upon the revised traffic generation rates and the building allowances, and we found that air quality and noise impacts have remained consistent with the issues analyzed under the draft and final for both short-term and long-term effects.
47:14 Under Traffic and Circulation, we presented a table here as far as the matrix that shows the three primary intersections that were analyzed under the traffic impact analysis. Compared to the draft ER, the LeBenz Place project would not result in a greater impact in level of service and would not require new mitigation. The change in daily volumes is an increase of 1,093 vehicles. The proposed internal intersections are forecast to analyze an acceptable level of service.
47:48 Additionally, the valet parking plan provides a capacity to 619 spaces with a demand of 619 spaces. Utility and service systems, what we looked at is each of the service areas that would be serving the projects, sewer, water, and so on. Utility and service systems under the old man-of-the-place concept would be adequately mitigated under the mitigation required under the draft and final EIR.
48:15 The old man-of-the-place concept is forecast to demand 27,023 gallons per day. There are multiple conditions that have been imposed on the project, and with the LEED silver certification, the water demand would actually drop down to 17,866 gallons. It's important to note that the draft ER looked at a demand of 28,000 gallons per day. In short, based upon each of the issues we identified and we looked at, we have found that
48:48 Each of the topical areas addressed are there's no greater impacts and most importantly there are no requirements for additional mitigation or modifications to the mitigation specified under the final EIR. The next step goes into our review of the 3D files for the building heights. It's important to note that this basically gives the specific plan amendment language. It's a bit difficult to read but you have it in your packet and it's basically the
49:23 specific plan amendment language for the amendments to building heights and the requirements. It's important to note that the methodology we utilized in the fire review is consistent with methodologies used by other lead agencies in lieu of story polls, particularly in instances where you have developments proposed over underground parking garages and developments where you already have existing on-site buildings.
49:46 A lot of agencies use the 3D file review that we've ran through to determine if the building massing setbacks and heights are within the recommendations allowed. The next couple of steps I'll walk you through are the major three steps we took to review the files. The first is we developed a 3D building envelope based upon the setbacks and height limitations. The yellow zone is the 35-foot zone, the teal is the 45-foot, and the blue is the 55-foot.
50:16 As you can see, it also accommodated all the setbacks under the specific plan amendment. The next, this is a model provided by the applicant team. It's a 3D file, and what we did is we took the file and deconstructed it and looked at how it was constructed and reconstructed it. It was constructed appropriately the first time around, and the tolerances were within limitations. The next step is we take that building model and we stick it into our building envelopes.
50:48 We look at areas that exceed the height envelopes. As you can see, the areas that have a slight exceedance are along Old Mammoth Road and Laurel Mountain Road. But these exceedances are within the limitations required under the specific plan amendment. They're all within the percentages allowed, 28% and 6% and all below 3.5 feet. Other small exceedances you'll note are elevator shafts or parapets or mechanical equipment.
51:16 Which are also allowed under the specific plan amendment. The following is just a walkthrough of the views, the comparison of the before and after. This view is the view along Old Mammoth Road looking north. The top view is the existing. The bottom is the proposed. These views are also similar to the views that were selected for the draft and final EIRs. This view is Old Mammoth Road looking south, before and after. This is Laurel Mountain Road looking south. And this is Sierra Nevada Road.
51:56 It's also important to note that we looked at the way that the applicant team merged the model with the photograph. We looked at all the camera settings, all the GPS points, all the survey markers, the field of view of the cameras, and each important criteria involved with depicting a valid and accurate simulation. Each of the parameters that were selected and identified by the applicant team were within the standard industry practices and within the standard tolerances.
52:24 As I mentioned before, this criteria is typically used by agencies in low-story poles when you have existing on-site buildings where you can easily erect story poles or scaffolding, and also, most importantly, where you have buildings that are erected over podiums or underground parking structures. That concludes the presentation and I'm available with any questions that you may have. Does anyone have any particular questions?
52:50 Could you go back to the slide that was a three-dimensional perspective of the height analysis that listed a number of spots? That's it. Yeah, I don't think that was in our package. Could you maybe talk a little bit more about that? For example, one question I have is when you have a particular point on there, how big is the area that that particular height applies to?
53:17 The way we pick the points is we set up a randomized grid pattern and the randomization pattern of the model picked points. We don't want to pick points to pick the best spots. And so we looked at in particular areas that were along Old Mammoth Road to determine if any of the allowances were within the 28% and below 3.5 feet and they all fit that criteria. We also looked at this area right here which was in the
53:44 percent allowable and also below the three and a half foot limit. The highest exceedance was 3.42 feet and that was within this zone right here and that's due to the architectural features that have a slant roof to improve the variety of visual character on the frontage right there on Mammoth Road. What was the size of your grid that you broke it up into?
54:12 The size of the grid, we broke the entire grid was the entire project boundary, and the grid pattern was three by three. Three feet by three feet. So these points, you said these are randomly selected? Yes. Okay. And these are actually spot points that measure that particular spot. Got it. Thank you. I have follow-up questions on that slide, which is really hard to read with the colors. The hotel roof is shown in this...
54:42 This model as exceeding the entire roof, as exceeding the height. Can you tell me if the points at the southernmost end of the west wing of the hotel, I see red there, but I can't read the numbers. Yes, how much does that exceed? That is three feet and three feet. Those two points are actually the parapet with the rooftop access. Parapet.
55:09 Do you mean the design element that's timber slanted upward toward the south? Yes. That's what you mean by parapet. And then is it number 15 or, no, 10, I think that is. But it's hard to see. Is that a point on the roof or is that a point in the gallery of the marketplace? I think that's 10. It's right there. Yeah. And that is paying the parapet also, so that's two feet.
55:41 Two feet there. Two feet there and then three feet on the other side. Yes. Okay. Thank you. So is it fair to say that if you look at point six and five and then you go over to point seven and eight and nine, there's basically, it goes from zero to two to three feet grade for a variance between them? And that's based upon the allowances within the area with structures that are over the podium and then also as it's measured from the ground level.
56:09 And the transition within that too. Any other questions of the presentation at this point? Thank you to the player. Appreciate that. Thank you. Mark, do we have any other presentations for the staff? That's right. Yes. Walter. I'll give you a moment to sit here. Good morning, Madam Chairman and members of the Commission. My name is Walter Kieser. I'm a principal with the firm Economic and Planning Systems.
56:50 As Mark introduced earlier, we are involved in this case in a peer review of work that has been done on behalf of the applicant by Kaiser Marston Associates. I'd like to give a little background for the viewing audience and the audience in general since they haven't had an opportunity to hear earlier remarks about our background and our firm and then go into the details of our presentation.
57:18 EPS is an urban economics firm. We have a lot of experience with resort development around the western United States in places like Mammoth and all over in the competing resorts, and we bring that to bear. Over the last five years, we have worked here in Mammoth for both public and private sector clients, working on Mammoth Crossing, and more recently, as some of you know,
57:42 on the development impact fee and housing program review last year, and that's work that we're continuing to do. Regarding the peer review, this work that we've done is it was a collaborative effort. From the beginning, we worked with KMA and the applicant to determine the appropriate assumptions to be made, methods to be used, and the assumptions, et cetera, et cetera. During the course of the review, we had several discussions to
58:12 solve problems and address different issues and then of course we finished by reviewing the work on its face and arriving at our conclusions about its quality and precision. In summary, we find the work that's been done by KME to be an accurate and appropriate reflection of the CBIS policy in this case, entirely consistent with professional standards.
58:38 that we're accustomed to and we're basically in full agreement with its results. That being said, this analysis does raise, has raised and will raise any number of questions, some involving how certain things are done or why they were done, some referring back to the project and its merits and some of these other topics and those are all of course valid.
59:03 Valid topics to be concerned about and why we have these discussions. I'd like to make a few specific comments about the analysis in that regard because I think it will help illuminate the work that's been done and perhaps answer some questions that may be raised along the way. First, an important point was that we are in this analysis comparing the project to a base case. You must do that. You must have a compared to what.
59:30 scenario, very, very important part of the analysis and we worked with staff and the applicant and KMA to develop that base case. We're entirely comfortable with both the concept of using the base case and the base case that was articulated as a point of comparison for the analysis.
59:49 The second piece is that the work relied a lot on what we'll call foundational documents, the CBiz policy and other expressions of town policy that are integrated into the analysis to make a determination of, for example, what precisely is a community benefit.
1:00:10 And while there is going to be and has been and will probably continue to be a lot of discussion about what constitutes a community benefit, I think the analysis, and I believe Mark mentioned this already, is consistent with written policy as best as anybody or we can determine, and we agree with that. Regarding the community benefits in this case, they are largely on-site
1:00:34 It's also important to point out that the project generates a number of other benefits that are not considered quote unquote community benefits tightly under the policy, not the least of which are fiscal and economic benefits. If you look at the generation of
1:01:05 of fiscal flows, transient occupancy taxes, sales taxes and these things, you'll find that the analysis of the project will generate something on the order of $2 million annually to the town's budget, a substantial sum and hopefully benefiting the town going forward for the services and investments that it needs to sustain itself. There's also the contribution to the various public improvements, the diff.
1:01:34 Program and other physical improvements that are needed to both mitigate the impacts of the project itself but provide broader community benefits and improvement to the town's overall infrastructure. I'd like to make a few comments about the financial analysis itself, again because it's important to just make note of this. First,
1:01:57 The analysis form is a residual value analysis. We're looking at how these different development programs influence the value of the land. There are many forms of financial analysis done at different stages of development to inform investment decisions. We are fully supportive of the use of this residual value analysis approach.
1:02:21 A more detailed analysis that is often done that we've done many times as well as KMA has done is a so-called pro forma time series analysis becomes possible when you have a project at a higher level of development and precision than we have at this present time. And so we're not, that's why we did this residual, recommended this residual value approach. The analysis
1:02:49 does reveal some important financial topics. Not only does it reveal the project's ability to generate and support community benefits, but it also makes the point that at the present time, the project is not really feasible given the market position right now. And that's not a surprise to anybody to get the numbers to work, so to speak.
1:03:11 There was a, we had to, the KMA had to make assumptions about quote unquote market recovery, price points recovering to a point where investments would be justified. So it's very important to make that point. Beyond that, it's important to point out that these projects, and we've worked on lots of them at all stages of development, are always difficult financially. In the best of times, they're difficult financially.
1:03:33 As you are aware here in town from watching a number of them go through trials and tribulations. So this is not an easy process. And we have to, if we're in pursuit of redevelopment of these sorts of projects, it's important that we recognize those financial difficulties. And as a town, while making sure that policies are met and impacts are mitigated,
1:03:56 That we want to be careful to make sure that we're not doing anything that makes an already difficult financial situation worse. In conclusion on our remarks, I'll just say that another topic that has come up and we've responded to in various ways is this topic of density, mix, scale, and these sorts of things. Mark made reference to this.
1:04:18 We certainly don't believe that there is any way of sort of deconstructing the project piece by piece and saying, well, we can trade this and get fewer units or one less floor. Very, very difficult to do that. In fact, impossible in our view. There isn't a linear relationship that can be drawn. We think that the project as it is does represent, based on our experience with many other projects of this type elsewhere in the western United States,
1:04:46 A good balance between program elements, the lodging, the retail, the community amenities that are included, these are the kinds of elements that are incorporated into projects and their relationships are quite important and we think that this project, as far as we can say, reflects a reasonable balance in all of those regards.
1:05:11 The final thing I would say is that regarding back to this community benefit thing and the broader benefits that may occur is that we think that this project needs to be looked at from the viewpoint of the broader perspective of where you're going from the resort and community standpoint. Obviously, there's a recognized need for stimulating and proceeding with redevelopment, revitalization of the resort and the community.
1:05:39 And this project in this location, again, at least in my view from what I know, does represent something that moves you in that direction. And I think that's an important merit to keep in mind and place the other questions and topics in the context of. So with that, I'd be happy to answer any questions that you may have. Thank you. Anyone have any questions of Walter at this time? I'm not sure, Walter, if I should ask you or Mr. Kaiser this or both of you this.
1:06:07 What was the rationale for including the underground parking for the hotel component in your financial analysis as a community benefit? I believe that's really a staff question. I think that's a policy. That's a staff question? You're asking a differential. And I'll save the question if it's complicated. Save the question for Mr. Conner, please. Okay. Then I have another question. Could you speak a little bit about how we can know, how we can...
1:06:43 expect that this retail is going to work. I know it's a good location, the marketplace is great, you know, it's got terrific potential, but we've got a lot of empty storefronts, and how do we know it's going to work? Well, that's an excellent question, and if I could answer that question with absolute precision, that would be really good. But I'll do my best. First of all, I think in answering that question, it's important to know what we're talking about here.
1:07:09 The numbers have been shown up on the team today, variously, but roughly speaking, there's about 38,000 square feet of retail, as I understand it, when you include both the food and beverage and the specialty retail. That will replace approximately 12,000 square feet that there's today, so there's a little bit of a net out, just keep in mind, that is important to point out. The balance between in that 38,000 is about...
1:07:36 60% food and beverage, 40% specialty. Just by the way, if somebody just asked me off the street what that balance ought to be, I would say 60-40. So again, they're following form that we see in other resort developments like this. So that roughly breaks down to 23,000, 24,000 square feet of food and beverage, 15,000 or so of specialty retail. So that just gives a sense of scale. That scale,
1:08:05 The second thing is that the retail component is integral to the success of the project. One of the ideas here is you create a pedestrian-oriented place in which people that are lodging there can have access to the retail services they need and at the same time provide a place with enough scale so that it can be an attraction to the broader community and other visitors to Mammoth Lakes.
1:08:35 So we think the scale, just looking at the project, and we're not answering your question right totally, but I just want to put it in context. We think that as the project goes, it's definitely balanced and appropriate. The question about its performance vis-a-vis existing retail is a very interesting question. In fact, it's an essential question, and it's much broader than this particular topic. There's no doubt that
1:08:59 The existing Mammoth Lakes Retail is underperforming in various ways. I was just in Sierra Center last night looking at it and I went, wow! And that is a problem that's caused by a number of different circumstances, not only the current economic downturn. You've got a scattered pattern of, frankly, so-called strip commercial retail that is largely unanchored.
1:09:24 and not really coordinated or programmed in any particular way that has evolved over 40 or 50 years. Much of that space is antiquated from even modern retailing circumstances. This isn't uncommon for communities all over California. This isn't particular to Mammoth Lakes all over California in the West and the whole country. There are examples of this particular problem. Here, it's particularly acute because there hasn't been
1:09:53 The amount of normal, quote-unquote, normal amount of revitalization, redevelopment that would have occurred and has occurred in many other locales for various reasons, which you probably know more about than I do. So we think that the fact that you've got an economic downturn, you've got a scattered pattern of stripped commercial development, and you've got a lot of antiquated formatting leads to the problem. It isn't necessarily a demand problem.
1:10:20 It's a supply problem. That is to say the supply is not up to par. It's not the kind of space that attracts retail expenditures in the way that we would expect and hope in retail. Another point is that for all of this to work for the retail, whether it's the existing or new or as it's revitalized, you have a demand problem.
1:10:46 A little bit of a demand problem that will hopefully improve over time. When we worked on the Mammoth Crossing projects about five years ago, we did a full-scale market report that looked at this retail question. And I think that work is largely valid today, and I would refer you to that, and I'm sure staff can provide you with a copy of that. But in that analysis, we looked at the existing retail, we looked at the typical fashion of supply-demand relationships over time.
1:11:11 And basically determine what I've just told you, that you've got a lot of antiquated space, and at the same time, there is existing pent-up demand for retail that isn't being captured for various reasons. And also, over time, as you build out the community, both in terms of the lodging sector as well as the second home and resident community, that there'll be additional demand that can be realized.
1:11:38 Topic of figuring out how to manage and grow and improve the retail sector is a big question that you face. And while it's true that you've got a situation here of increasing retail while you've got underperforming, it doesn't follow that you shouldn't do this because you've got underperforming because they're not equal. They're totally not equal. They're not in the same universe. In fact, the retail that's like we have expressed in this project is where you need to go. What you need to do is replace.
1:12:07 And over time, revitalize those existing underperforming retails with different forms of retail, different uses, et cetera, et cetera, consistent with redevelopment that I think you've all been talking about for a good long while. So then following on that, because it didn't quite answer my question, I'm unfamiliar with this sort of thing. Once this project is underway, who determines, who's in charge? Yeah, who determines this?
1:12:31 Price per square foot. Who determines the mix? Who determines what tenants are going to have? Who's in charge of making sure that it works like you say it should work? Okay. Yes, I'm sorry for not catching that nuance of your question, but that's a very, very good question. The answer is that one thing about this retail, and Jerry Kaiser can speak about this in a moment, is that in these contexts, it's typical that the retail requires subsidy.
1:12:59 In other words, it in fact is an amenity that is being subsidized, cross-subsidized by other aspects of the development. And that's simply because the cost to create the space and park it and all that is not matchable by typical retail rents. Because you are going to have to attract tenants that can only pay a certain amount. And when you compare that certain amount to what it costs to create that space, in this case, there's a subsidy indicator. And that didn't surprise me at all. We see that all the time in these circumstances.
1:13:27 So that raises the question, well why if the developer is providing a subsidy are they doing this? And the answer is they're adding value to the overall project by creating a mix of uses and services that make the whole project work. So they will be making decisions about tenants to basically to have appropriate mix of tenants to serve the retail needs, the convenience needs of the lodging guests as well as the community at large.
1:13:56 They have, since this will all be under, hopefully, one developer control or one organization's control, they will be making decisions over time to balance the retail so that you don't just have t-shirt shops because that's what results in underperforming retail where everybody's competing for t-shirt sales. And like in a mall, you don't have 15 t-shirt shops. You may have one. So they will be working.
1:14:23 very carefully to, because it's in their economic interest, to maximize those retail rents, and they won't do that if they just, if they don't manage the space properly and get the best tenants they can possibly have to serve the guests and the community at large. Thank you. Following up on that, if we assume that the applicant is making rational business decisions,
1:14:50 Is it a good indicator of the likelihood of success of the retail that they're choosing to go ahead, assuming they do? How good evidence is that for us? Well, if I understand your question again, the reason why retail is mixed into these projects is because it's a necessary element of their success. And the fact that it has to be subsidized is a purely rational decision. It's done all the time.
1:15:19 Even in shopping centers, you have cross subsidies going on. If, for example, I work with a lot of shopping center companies around the country, and if they want to have, say, a newspaper shop in there that can only pay $2 of rent, you know, they're going to be cross subsidizing. So that's a rational decision because they're playing for the whole and not for the part. And that's what they're doing there. And by the way, playing for the whole is precisely what I think.
1:15:46 Do we have another situation in town that might be similar to this one? Did we not, with the North Village, attempt to have
1:16:17 critical mass so that it worked? Yes. And I haven't studied that project. I wasn't involved directly, although I have reviewed it. And I do think that life affords us these opportunities to look at what has happened in the past and decide how this may compare to that. And I think there are a couple of observations about that that may be useful in your deliberations. One of the issues, of course,
1:16:47 When I first looked at that site five or six years ago as it was developed, my first conclusion, sorry, Dana, was how is this thing parked? So there's a parking issue, I think. So that's one difference, I think. In this project, hopefully, you won't have that parking constraint, particularly related to the
1:17:13 The person driving, accessing the site by car and finding the place to park so they can visit the retail. The mix of parking is very, very important to getting the retail to work, and I think that's one thing that may distinguish, hopefully, from a North Village. The other is that, just in terms of location, there may be advantages to this location being slightly more central.
1:17:36 And having some more opportunities to gather and capture sales from surrounding residential and retail a little more in context. But it's an interesting point, and I definitely think that looking at a project like this one is very helpful to look at what happened in the past and to not repeat whatever mistakes may have been made at that point. As an economist, you're telling us that if we make almost any change,
1:18:06 to what is presented to us, it won't, it will become infeasible. Did I hear you correctly? What I, what we're saying is that the project, this is a, from a feasibility standpoint, this project is, is, it's going to take a market improvement to make it feasible in the first instance. And that even when we look at it with all its parts in scale,
1:18:34 Adding costs of any sort or removing revenue will basically weaken that. Yes, that's basically what we're saying. But it does not follow that you can't do anything because it's all about trade-offs. Theoretically, if you could reduce costs, for example, if you could reduce parking costs, which are very expensive, you could have the opportunity to do some sort of trade.
1:19:02 What we've said in our earlier remarks is it's very difficult to predict that. I think it has to be done in the context of very, very specific this-for-that kind of discussion. But generally speaking, we don't think that you can basically make major revisions to the project and expect it to have either the community benefits or the possibility of being feasible as we see right now.
1:19:30 But that's not an absolute answer. I hope you're understanding. Can I just want to be able to give a little follow-up regarding the North Village project? Yeah, Walter, I just wanted to follow up on, you're absolutely right about the parking with North Village, and I think this project presents the parking that is needed to make subsidized retail and the restaurants feasible, and following up on Sharon's comment regarding critical mass, I think that is the key word.
1:19:58 This project does present that critical mass, whereas the village is at less than 25% build out and does not have that critical mass. So sharing your comment about critical mass is correct. It's just the village has not attained it yet. That's correct. Thank you. Are there any other questions of Walter at this time?
1:20:18 Thank you. Thank you very much. I'm going to stick this out with you, and so if any questions arise, I'll be here. Madam Chair, could I call back the CEQA person, possibly, real quickly, if you don't mind? I neglected to ask a question. Are we under compliance today with air quality in Mammoth Lakes? Air quality compliance in Mammoth Lakes today.
1:20:50 I believe with the vehicle miles traveled limit, there is an exceedance under the general plan build out. The project with the design features is within the relative comparison of what was analyzed within the draft EIR and the final EIR, and the conclusions reached in the draft and final was that the air quality impacts were significant. Is the air quality. I'm sorry, they slammed a door and I did not hear you.
1:21:19 The last three or four words. It's relative to the way that you look at the air quality. I believe that the basin is non-attainment for particulate matter. Correct. And that's based upon monitoring data. I believe that there's a monitoring station close by and it's showing exceedances of both the national and state standard. And I was curious, you do not have the Mammoth Community Water District letter in your report?
1:21:46 We have a water supply, a pseudo water supply assessment which was prepared to acknowledge the comments raised by the Mammoth Community Water District and that's an attachment within the CEQA conformance analysis and that addressed revisions to the water supply calculations and demands and the associated reductions associated with the LEED silver measures. There seems to be some discrepancy between the two.
1:22:17 Sharon, which letter are you referring to the letter that came at 10 o'clock? At the back of this report, there are two letters or reports from consultants, water demand memorandum, but there is no letter here from the Mammoth Community Water District. Can you speak to that? Yeah, we received this morning a follow-up letter from the water district, which should have been distributed to the commission.
1:22:49 Well, we had a letter from them, well, not us, but the department on December 9th. Correct. And it is not included in here. Attachment 12? Yes. So Sandra is saying attachment 12 includes that letter from December the 9th? It's here, but it's not in the CEQA report. It's the CEQA report. So I just was curious as to whether or not he had seen that letter. Yes. Yes. RBF's analysis was
1:23:19 Explicitly in response to that December the 9th letter. RBF. In the conformance analysis, the follow-up analysis they provided in response to MCWD's December 9th letter. And even between RBF and Bowden-Gans, there seems to be some discrepancy. One says there's an 18% less water requirement, and the next one says 10 to 15% increase.
1:23:48 So I'm just bewildered by all these numbers. We asked RBF to essentially peer review information that was provided by the applicant's engineer with regard to water conservation. Eddie, you probably have more detail in your head about those two reports, but that was the way that the process worked. In the discrepancy, we looked at the bounding gowns letter and addressed that within our water supply calculations, and we looked at the...
1:24:15 Efficiency measures and the reductions associated with those based upon our own independent analysis of how much that would reduce the water supply by and based upon our own conclusions. The water supply was reduced by, I believe, 10,000 gallons per day. So with the resultant implementation of the measures, it came out to just about 17,000 gallons per day. Okay. I understand that, but my concern is the last one. Thank you.
1:24:46 Ronnie, can I just go for a moment? Going back to air quality, have I been under a misapprehension that the reason we can't, what's the word I'm looking for, comply with the PM10 is because of the air that comes through from Fresno through the pass? I've been told that. Isn't that our problem? And speaking to the local air district, a majority of the air pollution within this basin, it's captured and entrained within here. It's a conveyance of the wind transport systems and the valleys that
1:25:16 Push it here, but it can't be exported from here at the rate that it comes in. So it isn't Mammoth Lakes generating it? No. Okay, thank you. But just clarify there too, from being on the past board of directors with the Air Quality Board, it is the ag, you know, work from the South Valley. Oh, yeah, I wasn't, I wasn't criticizing residents of Fresno. No, no, no, no, no, no, also, but it's, it's also, it's from the road centers that we use. That creates. Yes, I've heard that as well. So the primary generation of it is entering dust from the roads.
1:25:45 But not all the PM10 is coming to maintain roads. Okay, that's good. Thank you. So those issues you'll have one in the summer and one in the winter appears to give us a consistent non-compliant quality. Pardon me? It gives us a year-round consistent non-compliance quality between those two factors. And the air quality factors and measurements have been fairly stable. There have been reductions associated with
1:26:10 Some of the measures implemented by the town on reducing the wood-burning fireplaces and so on, which have showed increased improved results. Thank you. And we comply federally. It's the state compliance that we have the issues with. And this year that we've had from January 1 to current, we've had about 16 days that we have not complied with the state. And that's also due to the fact that the California ambient air quality standard is more stringent than the national. Exactly.
1:26:39 Considerably, yes. Thank you. Any other questions at this time? Thank you. I think we move on to Jerry. Is that the next presentation? Jim. Good morning, everybody. It is with great excitement and pleasure that today, March 10, 2010, we present to the Planning Commission and the Mammoth community for their consideration to hold Mammoth Place. This presentation
1:27:43 has been created as a result of over 50 public meetings, thousands of business meetings, and literally tens of thousands of hours of effort from many professionals and members of the Mammoth community. I'd like to thank all of you for your effort. I especially want to thank Mark Wardlaw, Pam, and the town staff.
1:28:12 For their tremendous effort over the last five years to bring to Mammoth what I believe is one of the most amazing projects in Mammoth's history. In addition, over the last five years, we have literally heard from and I have met personally with hundreds of our citizens about this project. This has, in my opinion, significantly improved and changed this project as the next.
1:28:44 Couple of slides will illustrate. Five years ago, this is what was proposed. It was basically a series of boxes with very, very poor light quality, very poor thought given to the retail and other types of requirements that I think the community had talked about since we first presented. And this next slide shows
1:29:12 Basically what we've ended up with, which is a nice pool area, lots of open meeting spaces, retail, outdoor dining facilities, and many more amenities of which you'll hear a lot more details in the first few minutes, in the next few minutes. I think there is no comparison between what we had created five years ago and what we have today. Now by now you all know that I deeply care for Mammoth.
1:29:42 Even our newest daughter, who is due in one week, is tied to Mammoth. We will name her Calista Sierra Dimitriatus, which means most beautiful Sierra. Now, we did think about calling her Calista Mammoth Dimitriatus, but then calling her, you know, that might have had some implications for her socially. For the rest of her life, she would be known as the most beautiful Mammoth.
1:30:11 So I think that the improvements that you've seen, what we've done to the Sierra Nevada Lodge, what we've done to Rafters, shows that we are here for the long haul. We believe in making Mammoth a beautiful place that we and our guests can enjoy. Since we've done the renovations, I am very, very proud to say that many people have come by.
1:30:35 Have been pleased to have dinner there at Rafters and enjoy their stays at the Sierra Nevada Lodge. But I think what's interesting in my mind is that we will have an even more significant impact to Mammoth with this project. While many feel that five years is a ridiculous amount of time that has been invested in building and creating and designing this current project, I think it was time well spent.
1:31:06 And I am the person that paid for all of this. I am happy to have done it, because what we have come up with truly reflects not everybody's happiness, but it does reflect what everybody has been asking for. And it's taken a lot of time and effort to come up with what we are presenting today. For example, let's just round out some of the firsts that we represent here. We are the first project after the new town general plan.
1:31:36 We are the first project to go through the district planning process. We are the first project that has gone through PAOT. We are the first project that has gone through SEBIS. I hope there are no more firsts. These firsts, though, were important because somebody had to set the stage and work out the challenges to bring a project like this to market.
1:32:06 It is my considered opinion that projects like this are essential to the future of man and its citizens' well-being. Our employment, for example, on our current property has gone from 30 people to over 70 people. And over the next year, I expect us to reach over 100 people. We have taken 45-year-old buildings and turned them into something that we can all enjoy and be proud of.
1:32:38 But we can't keep improving 45-year-old buildings. There comes a point in time when they must be put to rest. So while I am proud of our efforts and what it has produced, it pales in comparison to what this new project will do for Mammoth. It will bring 378 jobs to the community, full-time jobs.
1:33:09 It'll bring $8.5 million in wages paid to the citizens of Mammoth. It will bring $1.9 million in direct tax revenue to the town. The budget crisis of Mammoth would be solved in one fell swoop. Not to mention there would be another $3.2 million in related tax revenue.
1:33:43 Generated by this project that would impact our community. I haven't even talked about the amenities that we're beginning to propose or proposing as part of this project. In addition, just the construction over the three-year period would inject 100 plus million dollars into our community. That's 30 million dollars a year over the course of three years. Now how many people would benefit from that?
1:34:18 This project by itself, from a financial perspective, will have a tremendous positive effect on all of us that live and work in Mammoth. But let's not focus on the purely financial benefits for our community. Let's focus instead on the community benefits that this project brings to us all. A state-of-the-art meeting area which will support hundreds of peoples,
1:34:51 And parties in an enclosed environment. It's something that the Departments of Recreation have, for example, suggested would have a tremendous impact on having business meetings come and groups come to have business meetings in this community for the very first time. You'd have an enclosed glass mall for small local artisans, something that does not exist here.
1:35:20 Something that is not costly and out and prohibitive for these artisans to display their wares. You would have new state-of-the-art retail space, and as we've heard from the experts, that would bring tremendous opportunity and efficiency to our retailers. It would have open-air plazas for events and activities like ice skating or concerts.
1:35:50 My goal is also to make this one of the nation's first geothermal resorts in a ski resort. I have found in my research now that two blocks away we have water at 166 degrees. This could be the nation's very first, if not the world's, resort that is supported by geothermal. New restaurant space.
1:36:23 Imagine what you've seen at Rafters. Now imagine what we could do with something new and state-of-the-art. Outdoor dining space, one of the things that confuses me. Why don't we have more of it? This project has lots of outdoor dining space so we can enjoy the beauty of Mammoth. How about a new state-of-the-art spa? How can we be a world-class resort and destination when we can't even offer amenities, like a spa, to our guests and visitors?
1:36:56 And how about the most important thing to me from an amenity perspective? Our first dedicated, new, pure hotel that offers five-star amenities. Mammoth doesn't have it. You don't have a property. We don't have. I don't have the opportunity to present not only the most beautiful geography and natural resources, but to give people
1:37:29 A beautiful state-of-the-art hotel to stay at. It doesn't exist. That has all of these amenities built into it. No property has that here. And this would be the first property to offer that. These would be the community benefits that Mammoth needs. In fact, these are the community benefits that our guests and citizens deserve. In conclusion, this is an important and very special inflection point.
1:38:05 Mammoth's future. This commission has the future of our town in its hands. The financial benefits are clear and irrefutable. Huge revenue for the town, its employees, and citizens. The amenities which Mammoth does not offer as a town will become available to our citizens and our visitors.
1:38:37 and will help us become a world-class destination and resort. Partial adoption of these amenities is not an option because the economy and real estate markets and buyers want a project that offers and fulfills the needs of a world-class destination and resort. Now questions about height have also come up again.
1:39:13 While I know and understand this is an important issue, today you will see full 3D models that are accurate to an inch that will demonstrate to you that this height that we are talking about represents an increase of one foot over the entire 55 foot building envelope. One foot, let me repeat this, one foot difference over the 55 foot building envelope.
1:39:43 So I'm looking forward to your now having the opportunity to hear from
1:40:22 Our team, we'll start off with Mark Carney, and get into the details of all of the years of effort and what they offer this wonderful community of Mammoth. Thank you very much. Thank you, Jim. Good morning, Madam Chair. Good morning, Vice Chair Barrett. And good morning, Commissioners. Good morning, members of the public. My name is Mark Carney. I'm the legal counsel for Mr. Demetriatus.
1:41:08 And I have been asked by Jim to present and explain the application for the specific plan amendment. In large part because I was the only member of Jim's planning team that was actually on site at the time. It was around and involved when those things happened. In fact, I may be, along with Pam Kobylarz, one of the few members of the community that actually attended all of those 55 meetings that you alluded to.
1:41:37 And so I have particular, I think, credibility in terms of discussing the history. But I could not have done a better job than Commissioner Tenning has done in discussing the history, and I want to express our appreciation for that. It's really important when we discuss the height amendment to discuss it in the context of where we've been so we can discern whether or not we're heading in the right direction. And what I mean by that is the context of the height discussion goes all the way back to that first hearing in December of 2005.
1:42:05 Because you'll recall, as you said in your summary, Commissioner Tang, that that project that was proposed by Jim's development manager, Jim and his development manager, Rick Rosenberg at the time, was entirely compliant with existing code. It was 45 feet of buildings across most of the site with one plasma. The reason for that is that was what was allowed throughout the C1 and C2 zones before the specific plan amendment was approved.
1:42:35 And there was a provision that said that if you are able to provide understructure parking, then you can go up to 45 feet. And it's important to recall what the planners at the time were thinking when they said 45 feet. I wasn't involved at that time. I wasn't at the December meeting. I only got involved when I, after that meeting, the Planning Commissioner said, no, we don't want 45 feet across the site. At that time, it was four stories, essentially, throughout the site.
1:43:05 And the metric was 10 feet per story and then 5 feet more just to add some space between the floors. And so whenever we talked about 45 feet at that time, we're talking about 4 stories. And so what was presented to you in December of 2005 was a 4-story concept. And the planning commissioners just didn't like it. And they were right not to like it because at that time there was a new vision evolving in town.
1:43:34 Through the general plan update. And no longer did we want to have two things, no more strip malls and no more height across the entire site of the project. And so what the Planning Commission in its wisdom did is said, wait a minute, I know our code says that, but we're going past our code now. We're going beyond our code to better things. So what we want you to do is scale it down in the streetscape so we can have some active commercial. And if you need to go up taller in the middle, that's okay.
1:44:04 Because what we understand is you won't be able to see it anyway. So essentially what happened was that there was a concept of swapping two floors from the entire site, reducing the space on the streetscape to two stories, 25 feet, raising the middle area to 65 feet. So when the client came to me in March of 2006 and said, hey, we had a bad day at the Planning Commission,
1:44:30 We were totally in compliance with existing code, but they just didn't like it, and they told us to direct our attention in another way. I said, well, you can't do that under existing code. And Rick said, well, what can I do? And I said, the only choice for you is to go through a specific plan. And so from the very beginning, we started talking about two stories at 25, four stories at 45, six stories at 65.
1:44:56 And there was also a concept for architectural interest and for flexibility that we might have three stories, we might have five stories as well. But it was always a range of two stories to six stories, 25 feet to 65 feet. And within six weeks of my being hired to help process the specific plan, we presented an application for the specific plan.
1:45:23 And in that application, we sought exactly those heights. Scale down on the streetscape, not necessarily all 25, because what you also said is you wanted some up and down, you wanted some architectural interest on the streetscape. So we even considered 15 feet, one story, two stories, 25, three stories on the streetscape. And that idea of 10 feet per floor carried through the entire process of the old Mammoth Road District study,
1:45:54 And the specific plan, and it carries forward until today with the use permit application. So during that entire process, when people would ask me what the height of the building was, I would say, five stories, 55 feet, or six stories, 65 feet. And when it got around to Planning Commission action on the specific planning movement in, I believe, July of 2008, over two years after we had applied,
1:46:24 We proposed up to 65 feet in the center and the Planning Commission approved that request. They recommended approval to the Town Council of a specific plan. They would have heights ranging from 25 feet to 65 feet, two floors to six floors. And when we talked about that, we talked about six stories 65 feet, four stories 45 feet. We never talked, no one ever asked me, what's the elevation?
1:46:55 of that building. What's the altitude at the top of that building? That wasn't part of our parlance then. What people cared about was what is, how tall is that building? How many stories is that building? Now, even though you recommended approval of 65 feet to the Planning Commission, we know very well that the Town Council said, that's a little much. We'd like you to scale it down to 55 feet. And so thus we went forward with a new team after the specific plan amendment. Mr. Rosenberg was no longer involved.
1:47:27 Mr. Landau, the architect, was no longer involved. And we got a new team to process the use permit, which is where Dana Severy came in and where VSA Architects, led by John Ashworth, came in. And so what we got approved was 55 feet. And we didn't, at the time, we thought everything was just fine. We got our 55 feet. After the new team got involved, they took a look at the situation and said, whoa.
1:48:00 We've got a problem here with the way that the height is defined in the specific plan. There's no mention in the specific plan as to how you calculate heights when your project is going to be atop a parking structure. And at that time, if you recall, every building was atop a parking structure. We were chided, in fact, a couple of times by the staff with the six-acre parking garage that was proposed at that time. So even though every single building was intended to be on top of a parking structure,
1:48:31 We didn't have a statement in the specific plan as to how one should calculate height if that building's on top of the parking structure. So what we're left with is what you see before you, is the complete definition, the complete summary of how we are left to calculate height under the specific plan. And as you see, all it says is the vertical distance from existing grade adjacent to the structure, the topmost point of the building.
1:48:59 So when Dana and John got involved, I said, what about when it's above a parking garage? And I said, oops, that's a problem. And we've been working to, John and Dana and Jim have been working to solve that problem ever since. And the problems that they brought to our attention were really threefold. There's no guidance on how the building height is calculated for buildings and top apartment structure.
1:49:26 There's no guidance on how building height is calculated on a slope site with multiple adjacent graves. It's very easy not to really reflect upon the notion that there's a 19-foot difference in grade from the northwest corner of this site to the southwest corner. I would think that most of the community up until now would have thought that that site is relatively flat. So, frankly, I'm one of those people who maybe didn't have a clear understanding of the implications of the 19 feet.
1:49:57 Across the site. And the third problem that they brought to our attention was there's no guidance regarding the necessary elevator or stairway overruns. And so they brought this to our attention and said, okay, we've got to fix this problem. Now, what guidance do we look towards in order to fix this problem? Well, interestingly enough, even though we had 2009 zoning, which in many ways is the most advanced zoning document this view has ever seen,
1:50:26 It wasn't as thorough as what we call the archaic existing zoning at the time, which I understand was drafted sometime between 1985 and 1986. What I mean by that is, this is the definition from the existing code, the code that the specific plan supplanted for this site. And it actually addresses those very issues which we discovered our own specific plan did not. The first one talks about average slope along the grave.
1:50:53 The second one talks about what you do if you've got a sloped trite. The third one talks about that as well. The fourth one actually says, how do you measure height, or how is height impacted if you've got buildings upon a parking structure? And you see right there, ten feet more if you have buildings upon a parking structure. So ironically, the existing code that we were supplanting was more thorough in this particular area than our specific claim was.
1:51:22 Which was regrettable. So, there's still flaws, however, there were still flaws in this analysis, in this way to calculate height back in 1986, because if you look at number four, and in particular with parking, it really doesn't talk about underground parking. There wasn't the cognizance at that time, I suspect, that there would be so many buildings that would actually be built upon underground parking. So if you see, it talks about the ground floor of the building devoted to parking. Well,
1:51:52 I don't think that's ever happened and we never really want it. In other words, a parking structure on the first floor and then some residences on top. So it really doesn't articulate what you do if you're talking about parking that is largely underground. So we look for guidance elsewhere. And what we learned is the developers of the proponents of the Lodestar Master Planning apparently saw the problem.
1:52:21 and addressed it because they knew in their master plan that buildings would be up top parking structures. So if you look at how the way height is handled in the Lodestar master plan, the first sentence talks about buildings on the natural grade. Now that's where the, that was the beginning and the end of the discussion for the Clearwater specific plan. But importantly, if you look at C there, it talks about what happens if you've got buildings up top parking structure. How do you calculate?
1:52:48 Well, it says that in that instance, you measure from the ceiling of the garage. As long as the ceiling, as long as the building height is not increased any more than eight feet as a consequence. Okay, so that was the first iteration of a more sophisticated approach to analyzing or to calculating height in our community. That was the first precedent, if you will, for what we're seeking today. And then,
1:53:16 Several years later, in 2000, the developers of the North Coast Pacific Plan ended the same issue. They knew that they were going to be building on a parking garage. They didn't miss it, they had it. And the first sentence, again, talks about what do you do with natural gray. The second sentence, the second paragraph here, talks about, in the instance of buildings at top of a parking garage, here's what you do. And what it says is, buildings at top of a parking garage is two.
1:53:46 Second sentence, when all or a portion of the building sits above a parking garage or when a building is front in a plaza in the plaza resort district, building height should be measured from the garage loop elevation or the plaza elevation at the perimeter of the building. That's the second instance where the top of the garage was the determination point for how you calculate height of the building, not the podium. Now, the next instance of this
1:54:16 came up in the Snow Creek Master Plan, which was just last year. And the Snow Creek folks got it right as well. What they've said is that in order to calculate building height, you measure from the average finished grade, as determined by the average grade along the building's perimeter to the top of the ridge line.
1:54:43 What I understood the understanding, learning about this, the genesis of that was, is that there's going to be a lot of building out in Snow Creek, which is essentially in a bowl, and what you need to do in order to get buildings leveled is you need to fill that bowl, and you can fill that bowl with filler, you can fill that bowl with underground parking, but whatever you fill that bowl with, once you get to the finished grade, the uppermost point of the filler, the uppermost point of the parking garage, that's where you start calculating height.
1:55:13 Now, I understand that all five Planning Commissioners sitting before me today actually voted in favor of that specific, of that master plan. And if so, then you voted in favor of this definition of height. And what we're trying to do is get to that, or something like that. To get to where Lodestar is, to get to where Northwest Pacific Plan is, and to get to where Snowflake Master Plan is. And this is the language that we propose in order to accomplish that.
1:55:44 Now, I'm not going to go through it. It's part of your staff report. But basically, you can see we're trying to use the same concept as Lodestar did, the same concept as Snowflake did, but instead of saying that the maximum building height, or excuse me, the building height could be increased up to 8 feet at Lodestar, or up to 20 feet is set forth in North Coast Pacific plan, we're saying up to 9.9.5 feet would be the maximum. Now,
1:56:17 So we're asking you essentially to follow your established precedence within the mountain, and in particular the one that you were responsible for last year. And we're really focusing on trying to overcome this omission on our part and get back to a sense of fairness. Now, is it fair for the hike calculation for Old Mammoth Place to be the same or similar as it was for Low Star?
1:56:47 As it was for North Village. As it was for Snow Creek. We believe it is. We hope that you will agree. Now, you'll recall that on February 3rd, I made a very similar presentation at a workshop where we laid out the terms of the specific plan amendment. And I actually thought that that went okay. I thought, at least from my perspective, I said what...
1:57:18 I was supposed to say what I intended to say. It came out the way we intended it to. But a couple days later, we read the newspaper, and it said we were proposing buildings at 65 feet. It's like, wow, not everybody understood what we were saying. We've got another chance. Let's try to get it right. So what I said to Dana and John is, look, I'm the one who really doesn't know engineering and architecture. You guys do. You're trained as architects. You understand this stuff. We've got to make it simple enough for me to understand.
1:57:46 And if it's simple enough for me to understand, then it's clearly going to be simple enough for the rest of the community to understand. So what they did is develop a series of graphics which is intended to demonstrate the issue and demonstrate the solution to the issue. And the question of this building is really how tall is this building?
1:58:09 You could look at it and you could say, I could make a pretty good estimate on how tall that building is based upon the number of floors. If we use the same equation we've been using for the past two years, most people might say, it's about 25 feet. Two floors plus five. But the calculus in determining that height is very simple. To determine the height of a building, you measure from its base to its top. Now the question then becomes, does the building height itself change?
1:58:44 Depending on what's beneath it, the answer is clearly no. Because as is seen, on a flat side, natural gray, the height of the building is still 25 feet, from the base of the building to the top of the building. And when it's above a parking garage, the height, as it is in the North Coast Pacific plan, the height of the building is still measured from the base of the building to the top of the building. Similarly with Lowe's Tower, the height of the building is still.
1:59:19 The base of the building, the top of the building. And in the Snow Creek example, what this shows is there's fill on either side of that garage. Whether that was all fill, or whether that was filled with a parking garage underneath, the finished grade is the base of that building, and that's where you begin to measure the height. But what happens if you have a building on a slope? You can't do this. That'd be dangerous and unsightly.
1:59:54 And it becomes particularly more dangerous unsightly if you add a parking garage to it. You not only ruin your furniture, you ruin your car. So, but you're still at 25 feet from the base of the building to the top. What do you do? You've got to balance out the base of that building. How do you do it? Is this an option? Measuring from the highest adjacent grade?
2:00:22 Again, on the right side, you see from that point to the top of the building, it's still 25 feet. But that's precarious. There's got to be some way to fill in that area where that building falls down. The other way to look at it would be to measure from the adjacent low grade. And in that instance, you take the base of the building, be the part on the left, the lower part of the slope, as opposed to the other way, the upper part of the slope, and you measure 25 feet.
2:00:53 But that has problems inherent in it as well. In this example, you won't be able to open that door. You won't be able to see out some of that window. And this is the issue that we're focused on in the northwest corner of the site. This is the issue we're focused on in the lobby. We can't have that result. We can't have high-end hotel rooms that are looking into dirt. We won't do it. We can't do it.
2:01:25 We can't have a lobby where you step down into a basement to enter the hotel. So there's got to be another way to accomplish this. What do we revert back to? The way it was done at the other master plans. And what we have here is the solution. And the solution is really, as John Ashworth has said, finding that sweet spot. Being able to have the parking garage.
2:01:54 Being able to make sure the slope, the upper slope on the right doesn't intrude upon the door and the window, and making certain that there is no visual impairment or impediment on the down slope side by coming up with some kind of creative design solution. Whether that's a berm, which is what you'd probably do in a single-family home, or whether the thing that they did at the North Village specific plan is have kind of a wall and face it with rock work.
2:02:24 Or in this instance at the North Coast Pacific Plain, you don't even see that because that portion of the building is covered by the three-story street fronts. So if you do that, the question is, what are the implications? And really, in terms of calculating height, if you look on the right side where the question mark is, how do you respond to that question mark? If that's a 25-foot building, because it's buried in,
2:02:54 A foot or two or three to the right, would you not call that a 22 foot building? Of course not. It's still a 25 foot building. By the same token, if you look on the other side and see that other question mark on the down slope side, would you call that higher than a 25 foot building? No. It's still being measured from the base of the building to the top. So that's where we're trying to get to. That's what we're trying to ask, that's what we're seeking. A reasonable, rational,
2:03:25 approach to this, which is consistent with the precedents that your predecessors and you, in fact, yourselves have set. Now, in closing, I want to say one other thing. I understand that this issue of height coming up to you at this point has been very disconcerting for all of you and for members of the community. And, you know, we often forget that you folks are volunteers.
2:03:54 And it's easy to criticize you and your role. You very rarely would receive thanks. We recognize that you are volunteers. We recognize that you work at least as hard as we have to go forward with it. And I want to apologize to you personally for my role in missing this issue at the time. Now, you might wonder, how could something like this happen? And it's quite simple. When we...
2:04:24 presented the specific plan application, we actually presented a draft specific plan. And that draft specific plan is something we carried forward for two years until, more than two years until it was actually acted upon. A couple of three months before the specific plan was actually acted upon by you, the relationship, the Jim's relationship with the architect ended. And so we did not have an architect actually on our team when you
2:04:54 Recommended approval of a specific plan. And the language that we are struggling with here today was added a month or two prior to the hearing. It was the glossary. We had been reading the text for two years. We had been revising the text for two years. We had been refining the text for two years. The glossary was added within 60 days before the hearing. Now, I regret it happened.
2:05:25 I'm confident if we had an architect on staff at that time, he or she would have looked at it and said the same thing that John saw. We've got, this is a problem, we have to revise it. And if we would have caught it at that point, we wouldn't be here today. Because the reasonable solution would have been, oh, that's right, we don't have a way to calculate how it's in a park garage. What should we do? Well, let's look to establish town precedents. And we have asked to do exactly the same thing. So, I understand that this has added additional stress.
2:05:54 To your deliberations. And I want to express our regret that we had to put you through this. Having said that, we think we've got a great solution. We think it's consistent with everything that you've done in the past. And we ask for your support of the amendment. I'm here to answer your questions. Just a quick clarification, Mark. The initial proposal back in 2005.
2:06:19 Was nearly compliant with existing code, but there were some issues about lot coverage and, you know, some minor. So it wasn't, you stated it was totally consistent, but it wasn't totally consistent. I beg your pardon. I'm hearing what I heard at the time. I'm repeating what I heard. As I said, I wasn't on the site. I think it, let me amend that statement based upon your counsel there. I think it would be safe to say it was entirely compliant with the height of the applicable zoning at the time.
2:06:49 Which is the topic of this discussion. Okay. Thank you. Tom? There's a clarification also, Mark. Out in the community, we keep hearing about, of course, the height, as you mentioned, and the concern. And we have two different terminologies. We're saying underground and we're saying understructure. So as the legal counsel for Mr. Demetriotis, what term are you looking for us to use? Is it underground or is it understructure? My understanding of the town code says if your structure is...
2:07:19 If it would be 70% underground, then it is an underground structure, and we are compliant with that. So it's your... It's underground. So it's underground, and it's... It's 50%. I beg your pardon. 50%. Right. We're way underground. Yeah, so it's underground. Good. Thank you. I believe that was also clarified earlier in the Stanford site as well. Thank you. Any other questions at this time, Jay? Mark, I don't know if you're the right person to ask this, but the question mark on the right in the figure that you've got up there, the increment...
2:07:48 For the Old Mammoth Place plan, excuse me, as it's proposed, at the point where the podium is adjacent to the highest natural elevation, which I presume is the northwest corner, what is that increment as you've proposed? John Ashwick will follow me and he'll give you the precise number, but my understanding is it's 53 feet, so 2 feet. Okay, so at that corner, your podium will actually be 2 feet below natural grade? Correct. Okay.
2:08:19 Okay, good. Now, the three existing standards that you referenced from other projects in town, first of all, the Lodestar Master Plan definition of height. Does the Old Mammoth Place project as it's proposed meet that definition of height? With one exception. If you change the reference to eight feet at the maximum additional height to nine and a half feet, it would be entirely...
2:08:48 Consistent with that. So, and I take that to mean that the point at which adjacent grade is lowest relative to the podium is nine and a half feet. Correct. And that is a result of a lot of very creative and elegant work by the architect. What I mean by that is that John and his team didn't just take the high point and run the parking garage all the way to the end of the site. If he would have done that, we'd be talking about 19 feet, right?
2:09:17 What he did in SEPT is elegantly, frankly, step down the parking garage at three intervals in order to conform with the lay of the land. And that's why he was able to accomplish this at nine and a half feet. And same question with the North Village specific plan definition of building heights. Does the Old Mammoth Place project meet that definition? It meets it with...
2:09:47 Ten and a half feet to spare. Okay. Because the North Village specific plan allows for additional height of up to 20 feet as a consequence of the podium. Okay. And same question with the Snow Creek definition. Right. Yes, exactly. If we change the definition to calculate height from the final grade, what's the word name? Finish grade. Finish grade. Finish grade. Then we would be...
2:10:16 In that case, finish grade equals podium height. Correct. Okay. Thank you. Maybe I misunderstood. Somebody said, and it may have been Jim, that we went from 9 1⁄2 feet today and we're only up one foot. Well, I'll let Jim respond to that. Well, there's a lot of kind of fun facts that John is going to reveal in terms of the impacts of this issue on the community.
2:10:44 And one of the most compelling for me, and I don't want to skirt your question, I'd like John to answer that question. That's fine. But one of the most compelling conclusions that this process has led to is a study and the realization from that study that the average height of the buildings within the 55-foot zone of this project, when measured from natural grade, is 35 feet. Let me say that again.
2:11:13 The average height of buildings within the 55-foot zone when measured from natural grade is 35 feet. What's even more interesting is the average height of the buildings in the 55-foot zone when measured from the top of the podium is 36 feet. That's the level of significance that we are discussing today. That's the overall impact. One foot.
2:11:42 In terms of the average height in that zone, I suspect that's what Mr. Demetriaz was alluding to. I'll leave it to John Ashworth to explore that further. Anything else to do right now? Did you have another question? No. Okay. Thank you. You probably don't want to. I'll just run out. Okay. Go ahead. Thank you.
2:12:08 Yes. So while I was with these from, I want to, Sandra, a question for you, please. We're using, you know, North Village, we're using Lodestar, Snow Creek, as quote precedent setting, which I agree they are. But we also do the calculations, because I know at the Village, you have canyon and you have hillside, and then you have the great coming down the midratt, and the purpose of that podium and the top of that podium was because of the difference.
2:12:38 So in ratio to the village and to Old Mammoth Place, is it the same ratio to allow for that? You mean the same grade change? Yeah, well the 20% that was allowed at the village was because of the grade change. So what we're looking at for Old Mammoth Place, is it in context with what the grade change is? You know, we can look into that question. I mean, we have all the plans here, so I can take a look at that and compare. That's a good question. Thank you.
2:13:06 Very quickly, maybe you can answer this, Mark, maybe not. What sort of change is that grade? What is that grade? It looks rather severe. I don't know the answer to that question, I apologize to you. Do you know what estimate of the grade change you would make on that? That's used in the pictures. It looks like more than a 10%. I think that's true.
2:13:37 Yeah, it's quite a bit more than actually we have on our site. And our buildings are obviously taller than that as well. So this was meant for a luster purpose in order to make it as simple as possible for me to understand. And if I understood it, I thought I could communicate. Thank you. And Mark, if I may, weren't you just trying to demonstrate the fact that at the north end of your property, if you were to...
2:14:03 To do this, then the whole Old Mammoth Road site would be below grade and underground basically. It would be almost a moat around it. The whole northwest corner of the site and the lobby would be underground, right? Then we would be in a situation where we would have to step down into the front door of the hotel, which is...
2:14:24 Not anything a hotel operator wanted to do here. Much, much like Lincoln House was at the village before Grand Sierra was built. Correct. And you had to come down off the road and down the stairs and no one could find it. Not the kind of entry statement that you want to attract a hotel here. On Laurel Mountain, I'm learning that they would also be underground.
2:14:48 Any other questions at this point? Just a comment. So I'm following up on what Tony was asking. As I understand it, the total differential in natural grade from the highest to the lowest point across the podium is 11 1⁄2 feet because it's that negative 2 plus 1 1⁄2. So all we need to know is that the distance across the lot to know what that percentage changes. Thank you. It sounds like algebra class. Well, it's engineering. That's the thing.
2:15:18 Thank you as an owner of a, quote, flat lot. To find out it wasn't flat, I completely sympathize. And our house is on a 45 degree angle. I thought I was buying a flat. Let me share this real fast history while we're waiting for Elizabeth. No, we dug in. When we took years ago, a number of years ago, the 4th of July parade, as many of you all know, it used to start at Chateau and it would come up Old Mammoth Road and up 203.
2:15:48 And then we decided we wanted to change that and start it up on 203 and bring it down to this area of town that we're here. And now, well, we lost all the dressage of the horses and all these folks. They didn't want to participate because it was easy for them to participate in the parade coming up Old Mammoth Road, but because of the grade on Old Mammoth Road that none of us realized, they couldn't do that coming down.
2:16:12 That was the first time in over 20 years living here that I realized the grade that really was on Old Mammoth Road. Okay. We will be breaking at noon, but it's, you know, we may have encouraged people to feel free as long as we can participate if they have to leave, myself included. At this point, next, I wanted to still have the applicant still available. Is anyone else in this? John?
2:16:44 Thank you, Madam Chair, Vice Chair, Commissioners, Town Staff, members of the community. My name is John Ashworth. I'm a principal with Bull Stockwell Allen Architects and Planners out of San Francisco. I'm very excited to be here to talk about what I feel is an incredibly exciting project, one that I think is a real high mark of my career. We really specialize, have a number of specialties that I think bode very well for our work here.
2:17:14 In Mammoth and at Old Mammoth Place. We are really very well known for our environmental credentials. Many of our buildings are LEED accredited projects. And this project, as we all know, is slated to be, at a minimum, a LEED silver project. We're also known for our mixed use and hospitality understanding. We have a number of very successful hospitality and mixed use projects under our belt.
2:17:43 We have a real understanding of the needs of a hotel operation and the goal is really to be able to create that first class five star hotel and the related amenities that would really serve this town very well. And thirdly, we're known as snow country experts. We have designed mountain projects in pretty much every major resort throughout North America. You'll see many of our buildings there.
2:18:10 My firm was at the very beginnings of Beaver Creek in terms of the evolution of that village. We have master planned villages in Park City, in Crested Butte, Colorado. We've been very heavily active in the current new villages at Stowe. And the reason I bring those up is not just to kind of note the experience, but I think it's important to really talk about those projects and how they compare to this project.
2:18:38 Because I'm here to really talk about this project and to share my enthusiasm for this project. Because this project really does differ in many respects from, I would say, the majority, if not all, of the other projects that I've worked on in all these other resorts. How do they differ? Some of those other projects that I mentioned, not all of those, for example, are LEED certified projects. While they are typically mixed-use projects,
2:19:07 They don't necessarily have the level of amenity and plaza space and park space and the level of thought and care that has gone into this plan to really make this a huge boon to the community. And I think that's the very kind of major point here, is this project really has the opportunity to become the heart and soul of a mixed-use downtown mammoth.
2:19:37 And that's a very exciting thing for me because it gives all of us an opportunity to work and contribute to creating a real there here in terms of the downtown, to move away from the strip mall prototypes, to really begin to retain, to create a street wall and to create meaningful pedestrian retail, to create synergy and to really create a there there so that Mammoth can continue to be the first class, world class.
2:20:07 And I think that's a very exciting thing and I've not ever worked on a project where there's been this level of commitment to public spaces and to really creating a heart and soul as part of a major community and I'm very proud to be associated with this particular project. I'd like to
2:20:39 Kind of height has been a big issue and so I'd like to hit that head on and I'm going to talk about that throughout the presentation and just to kind of follow up with what Mark talked about to kind of describe some of the implications that some of the questions we're getting at in terms of the project. Eddie Torres pointed out and I think it's pretty well known that the Clearwater Specific Plan really works to envelope the entire site with low story buildings, 35 height zone, three story buildings around the perimeter.
2:21:08 of the project. There's a transition zone, which is a 45 foot zone, with the higher portion of the massing located in the center portion of the site. And again, the idea was to really mask, if you will, with the lower scale components along the street, as we all know, and basically place the higher portion of the building where you can't see it. And I'll show you some analysis, both in terms of the fly-throughs and all of our site section analysis.
2:21:39 That shows that you absolutely cannot see this taller portion of the building from the majority of the streets. In fact, an interesting statistic is from only 2% of the site, as you walk around, can you even see a portion of the 55 foot high buildings. Our 55 foot high building is located here. There's a large portion of that 55 foot high area that we did not build in.
2:22:08 And I'll get to that a little bit more. We really wanted to maximize sunlight and those kinds of things in, again, the plaza spaces. So within that, and that's been alluded to, our average height within that 55-foot height zone, if you measure by adjacent grade, is 35 feet. If you measure by the top of the podium, is 36 feet. So a difference of one foot. The parking garage starts here and basically comes along, steps down, and then ultimately steps down again to the grove.
2:22:40 At this location here, the garage is minus two relative to average grade. The worst case component is right here, and that's where we're nine foot six inches above adjacent grade. Now, what does that mean? Over 70% of our garage is underground. The rest of the garage is fronted by the 35 foot high buildings, or in this case, a one and a half story building.
2:23:11 Essentially, the garage is absolutely invisible. It steps down. In this location, you're also fronted by the 35-foot high components and the lower story buildings. So this is an area, again, that you really can't even see. From that 9.5 to the negative 2, the site basically slopes and you get that gradation range across that. So I would argue, and again, as you look at the fly-through analysis, as you look through our site analysis,
2:23:41 The height issue is really one of essentially something you can't see, taste or smell because it's basically on top of the podium, it's basically shielded by the lower scale elements and it's essentially a negative number in this location and again is consistent with other specific plans and master plans that have been part of the town of Mammoth Lakes.
2:24:10 So I'd like to move away from that and really talk about what is very exciting about this project and I think really underscores why this is a very important project. We didn't start as an architect. I like to consider myself an architect and planner and I was really given the marching orders to not design architecture to start with. It was to really think about the site first and to think about what really would create a meaningful series of public spaces, essentially the spaces
2:24:40 So as you can see, of course, and I think as you can see in the model, we really
2:25:09 We developed very little there. The goal was to really create as much open space to let as much sun in as possible and to have very low scale buildings. We've got a restaurant component here that basically, and then the ground floor retail along Old Mammoth Road, and a nice plaza here that again catches the sun and could be used for seasonal events, ice skating, antique car shows in the summertime, a variety of different events.
2:25:38 So we really tried to put the, again, to use the Clearwater Specific Plan to locate the taller portions, but even allow that to have sunlight penetrate through and to really create a very porous, a very nice site plan that had a lot of public open space associated with it. And you can see the different kinds of components that ultimately then resulted from that. And these are, I think, part of that public benefit package that I think is, I think,
2:26:08 Very exciting in this project and beyond what I have seen typically in my other resort projects. We start here with the grove, which is taking advantage of the existing trees, really highlighting those and creating a major gateway to the development, a place of repose. You basically then climb a few steps into what we call the commons, which is a public space where you could have the farmer's market in the summertime, the Christmas tree during the wintertime.
2:26:38 Really a very kind of intimate space. These spaces have all been thought of from a programmatic standpoint so that they're not just, you know, open pieces of concrete with some cement, you know. They've got rock features, water features that ultimately culminate in what we call the river runs through it that takes advantage of the natural slope across the site as a series of cascades and water pools. We have a semi-public space associated with the hotel that includes its pool areas.
2:27:07 And that's really the source of the river runs through it, where the water features continue to run through and cascade through with a series of rock, landscape, and water features. We've got Old Mammoth Square, which again is this terrific opportunity for all sorts of public events, where you could set up tents for a gala or an antique car show. We imagine that you could have a miniature golf, the Frosty's miniature golf. You could have the seasonal ice skating rink.
2:27:36 A whole variety of things could occur on this particular place. And again, it's also not just a lot of pavement. It's articulated with very nice design elements, with water features and fountains or a rock climbing wall, stepped seating that is landscaped and very nicely integrated into the overall site. The connector road. The connector road is not just a connector road. We actually went
2:28:05 Above and beyond what was required by the town to really make that a true amenity, public amenity benefit to the town. It's wider than what was required. It's 24 feet so that it could accommodate two-way traffic, which is actually what we would prefer for this particular connector, so that it really becomes a real road. We created extra-wide sidewalks so that we could have streetscape and landscaping along those sidewalks on both sides.
2:28:35 And then we created a pocket park, which we call Cascade Park, which again is another public amenity that is being contributed by the project as part of the benefits package. And this again would be a place for some recreation and respite, and ultimately as the town continues to develop, we see this as being a real meaningful benefit as opposed to just a simple mid-block connector. So to quickly summarize,
2:29:05 You've got one, two, three, four major public spaces that are being contributed by the project that are rock, landscape, water features, have a series of programmed events associated with them. You've got the connector road with its additional landscape. You've got very nicely designed streetscape and streetscape elements including bicycle racks and lighting along old Mammoth Road where we have the ground floor retail.
2:29:33 We've got this, what we think is an incredible mountain market, the festival marketplace, that provides a really wonderful circular racetrack, if you will, of retail that circulates the site and provides a meaningful synergistic experience for pedestrians where you can have a variety of retail from the small artisan shop that Jim mentioned to about a 45...
2:30:01 100 square foot anchor in really recreating a really wonderful landmark gateway market element on the corner at this location. We think that the project really has a number of benefits that are remarkable. And those are really in addition to some of the other secondary public spaces and landscaped elements that are all a part of this overall design. This project then very much is about these community benefits.
2:30:35 And again, much more so than projects that I've worked on in the past. It's about the rock work. It's about the paving. It's about the water features. It's about a variety of public spaces. And it's about really creating a there-there for this community. And here's an image along Old Mammoth Road where we really do have a very different prototype from the strip mall type of retail that we have in town today.
2:31:08 Walter talked about the need to really reinvent the retail in town, and I think that's been the desire of the general plan and the desire to really, from everyone's perspective in town, to really try to bring a street wall and pedestrian scale retail along Old Mammoth Road and really invigorate the downtown area. And I'm excited because I really think this project will do that.
2:31:34 And again, we have this wonderful mountain marketplace which gives us covered market events for a variety of food and beverage, small scale retail components in conjunction with some larger retail opportunities. I'd like to talk a little bit about site coverage because I think that's another interesting statistic. The site coverage allowed within the Clearwater Specific Plan is 70%. We're currently at 42%.
2:32:04 I think that, again, underscores the level of commitment that Jim has brought to this project and this proposed development to really try to give back to the town, create a place that has synergy and energy and will certainly work from an economic standpoint, but also that is going to work for the town and for keeping Mammoth in the limelight and as a major destination resort, really creating a place that people will come to.
2:32:33 And it's not a function of just trying to maximize density. It's been a function of really trying to find that sweet spot, using the term that Mark said I like to use, of development and the public spaces and the way this whole plan knits itself together. So these areas represent the coverage elements that we've talked about. Again, low scale elements. We've got a two-story element here, one-and-a-half-story element here and here.
2:32:59 All flanked by the lower scale development all the way around the site. And these series of really wonderful spaces. If you look at that worst space that we're talking about in terms of where we're nine and a half feet, again, we're on the parking garage, so it's invisible. You don't see that we're above adjacent grade in that one location. You really see all these public squares and plazas. This is over 230 feet from Sierra Nevada Road. It's over 170 feet from Old Mammoth Road.
2:33:29 And again, it's fully blocked by these lower scale elements. It's really next to invisible. And this just shows the overall programmatic. I think again, we have a very rich program that really is part of that synergistic approach to this particular site. We've got obviously the hotel. We've got the conference space. We've got the spa. We've got the festival market hall. We've got retail along Old Mammoth Road.
2:34:04 We have two restaurants that are very flexible in terms of their use and could also have some rooftop dining opportunities for different kinds of opportunities. We've got the public plazas, we've got workforce housing. It's a very dynamic, rich mix of program. All over parking, which again is 70% underground and the portions that wouldn't be underground are all fronted by the lower scale buildings.
2:34:36 We have now rejiggered the loading, so it is all through the garage and from the Laurel Mountain loading dock, so there's no longer any loading dock at all on Sierra Nevada Road. It's all through the parking component. And again, getting into this parking I think was an important breakthrough to come off of a connector road, so we minimize any curb cuts around the site as much as possible with the exception of the loading dock on Laurel Mountain.
2:35:05 And again, the goal to really be a good neighbor to the overall community. This is a diagram that shows the analysis of the parking garage and illustrates that it is 70% underground. Again, this is the point of existing adjacent grade here and here on which the parking garage podium was based on. And that was based on so we didn't have underground entries to the hotel or...
2:35:35 Buildings below grade on Laurel Mountain. We needed to have a set of datum for the garage that we could get into, and we wanted to do that off of the connector road. So these are the points of existing adjacent grade that established that podium height. And again, there's a 19-foot change in grade, so rather than just run the podium all the way across, we really tried to get that parking underground as much as possible and to be knit into the site as best as possible.
2:36:05 And we did that by sloping the ground of the garage 4%, which is the maximum you really can slope a garage so that we could follow the natural contour. And then stepping the garage so that, again, we just didn't have one constant plinth. And that also is very nice, in my opinion, because it follows the natural contours of the site. You've got the high component up here on the northeast side, sorry, the northwest side. And you've got the low component.
2:36:34 Down here is the side slope. So our garage and the underground component basically steps with that as you get down back to the grove at natural grade. And these are again the points of existing adjacent grade where we establish the podium height for the garage, which again was the sweet spot. We're actually two feet in the ground here. That gives us nine and a half feet higher here.
2:37:07 The kind of the average across through here. Again, that distance is over 271 feet from Sierra Nevada and 163 feet over to Old Mammoth Road from this point that again is shielded by all these lower building elements. Architecturally, very excited about the architecture too. We've really tried to create something that is very unique, that is not something that you see everywhere else. And I think this has been a terrific collaborative effort.
2:37:37 between ourselves, staff, the ADP, really working to develop something that we can all be very excited about. This is showing that new corner retail at the northwest corner, a one and two story building that really welcomes you from when you're driving from the north.
2:37:58 Really working hard to incorporate a lot of the heavy timber components and to really try to bring this to a much more of a mountain look and feel in conjunction with a number of the comments we received. I think architecturally it's important to see this work in three dimensions and so I'd like to go to the fly-throughs right now because I think that's the best way to see it and I'd like to ask you to take a look at two kind of key things that I think are important is one how
2:38:26 Which the facade development is in three dimensions. That was really where we put a lot of our intention was to really try to create a sculptural three-dimensional facade to really create variety because we had some height limitations on this project. And secondly, I want to play a little bit of a case of where's Waldo to see if you look for the 55 foot high portion of the building site, it's difficult to find.
2:38:53 And so I think you'll see pretty clearly as we fly around, and this is a car height driving around the roads, you cannot see those taller portions of the site from the perimeter of the site. Okay, so here we're starting at the Grove, which is on the southwest corner. So you're seeing these heavy timber elements for the three-story buildings as you're coming down Old Mammoth Road. You see again the articulation of the facades.
2:39:39 Ground Floor Retail, which would be enhanced with outdoor dining, signage, some of the heavy timber elements announcing the entrances, the corner element, Old Mammoth Place, Lantern, Retail Lantern, that introduces you into the marketplace. Here, coming down to connect the road, seeing the entrance to the hotel and looking towards Laurel Mountain Road.
2:40:12 And again, you'll see, again, you really are not able to see the 55-foot-high portions of the project, not because they're not modeled here. They are. It's just that the streetscape itself is defining the view corridor so that the taller portions of the site in the middle are following the desire that had been developed to basically put it in the center where it would not be seen. And here we're turning the corner at Sierra Nevada.
2:40:47 And we're coming around to Old Mammon Square, where the seasonal ice skating rink would be. In this location, you're about 270 feet from the taller portions where you do get a view of the hotel components. The lower scale restaurant components, we've now got rid of this loading up. And we're back to the grove in this location. So again, I think, and I think you can see this in Eddie Torres' visuals as well.
2:41:22 There's very limited impact relative to height that's located in the center of this project. It really is defined by what's around the perimeter. We go the other direction. We're now starting at the northwest corner and moving down Mammoth Road. You see, again, the articulation trying to get some real variety both horizontally and vertically to really create a very rich, dynamic retail street front.
2:42:00 Based on commentary, really using heavy timber in conjunction with cedar look, cement-titious fiberboard to create a very mountain, rugged architecture coming along where we have the terraced seating, seasonal ice skating rink element here at the southwest. And moving down Laurel Mountain, again, you can see
2:42:51 The facade is defined by a variety of articulation, heavy timber elements, bays projecting in and out, as well as no visibility of the taller portion of the hotel beyond. And then moving down the connector road towards the hotel entry, where you see the scallop bays articulating the views towards the mountains. There's the festival market hall, the entrance off the connector road and through this space.
2:43:32 Again, back to this iconic corner retail lantern, lower scale element that brings you both along Old Mammoth Road and in and around through the marketplace. And the materials I talked about, again, really working to create a variety of very mountainous, rustic mountain materials that range from the heavy timber to a wood-look cement board.
2:44:06 Some metal accents, and some granite, and the overall massing of the project. The height analysis, we did two different ways. Again, this shows the analysis based on the height above the parking plinth, which basically shows there are a couple of areas which include the elevator overruns and stair overruns that are required for code and for roof access that would be beyond the height.
2:44:38 And then these areas right along here, along Old Mammoth Road, and this little portion right here along Sierra Nevada, where we're asking for the accommodation to create some additional variety in the 35-foot height zones to give additional articulation and improve the overall mass of the project. John, before you leave that, can you clarify something? This corner you keep referring to as being 9 1⁄2 feet higher, higher than what? Adjacent grade. Okay.
2:45:05 Because I don't think that's clear for the public. It's not that the building is 64 1⁄2 feet high. No. Okay, you should clarify that. That's a good point. Thank you, Commissioner Tenney. When I say that it's 9 1⁄2 feet taller, what I mean is that it's 9 1⁄2 feet above existing adjacent grade. And when I say that it's minus 2 here, it's minus 2 based on existing adjacent grade.
2:45:34 All of the buildings are sitting on the parking podium and are 55-foot buildings. And because you're on the parking podium and because of all the landscaping and terraces and the stepping, you don't see anything but a 55-foot story building. Now, it's nine feet above adjacent grade in that location, but it's shielded and sitting on top of the parking podium. So then why, is Eddie Torres still here? I don't know if he's here.
2:46:02 Oh. In your diagram, you had some random points where you measured the height above 55 feet, and I think you said 3 feet for that point. I'm trying to, it was 3 feet higher. I'm trying to reconcile these two. And those weren't really for the building and rooftop, it was for the impertinence structures that were exempted by the code. We just wanted to show that. So those randomized points were below the impertinence levels. Thank you. Okay, thank you. And John, while you're on that slide and talking about height,
2:46:31 Can I ask a couple more questions? This relates to the request in the adjustment for the architectural features on the roofline along, I think that's B there, is it, that you've got along Old Mammoth Road? Yes. And the two eaves that are at the southeast and southwest corners, the, as I understand it for the latter, those two roof eaves, the total
2:47:02 That adjustment request includes is 3 1⁄2 feet above 35 feet plus 2 feet for appurtenances. Correct. And you're calling that eve there in appurtenance. So that would actually be a total of 40 1⁄2 feet. Correct. Now, on the ones along Old Mammoth Road, is it the same thing or are they just up to 38 1⁄2 feet? I believe they're up to 38 1⁄2 feet.
2:47:26 Okay. I would need to check that, but that's my understanding is that it's really here where we wanted to get some additional slope and get some additional overhang that we got up to that full movement. Okay. Thank you. And this is the analysis that if we measured this based on adjacent grade, you can see then this portion of the garage would then be technically above that adjacent grade number. They're still 55-foot buildings. They're sitting on top of the parking garage.
2:47:58 But that shows you the portion that would be above that. Again, when you average it all out, we're talking any difference of a foot. And this diagram illustrates the areas that we were just talking about, those areas of request. You can see this is kind of the tallest piece because we wanted to get some slope here with those heavy timber elements to create some additional variety. These are lower and I believe are within that 3.5 feet range when we just wanted to have a little bit of additional.
2:48:28 Variety and Articulation from a massing component, which is something that was anticipated, as you know, within the Clearwater Specific Plan, that that would be something that we could come back and request if we all felt it collectively, you know, enhanced the overall streetscape and created some variety along critical facade areas. The view analysis is in the documentation. I'll go through this very quickly.
2:48:58 But the general analysis shows very clearly that again it's the 35 foot height elements that govern so that you really don't see any of the 55 foot high buildings regardless of whether you measure them from adjacent grade or from the podium height. I may go through these not completely because they seem to be taking their sweet time to show up but you can see again both from across
2:49:33 The road, this is Old Mammoth Road, so here's Old Mammoth Road here. This is taken through this location here, both from across the sidewalk or adjacent to the project. It's the low story buildings that are defining your view corridor. It has nothing to do with the buildings that are in the middle of the site, again, whether they're based on adjacent grade or based on whether they're measured from the podium height.
2:49:59 So you can, you basically see right over the top of all of those. And that's why you don't see any of the taller portions of the buildings within any of the fly-throughs. This is taken from Sierra Nevada Road through the restaurant here, obviously. Taken again from Sierra Nevada Road looking in this location. John, if you could hold that one for just a second, because why it's loading, because on my version there's a...
2:50:36 Very large existing, that's the one, it's there, correct? Correct. Okay, I think that's important too because that's my main question of how much that was shielding that open space now and it apparently is shielding it. Thank you. The tree? The tree. Yeah, that's an existing tree. Right. Again, these are additional views along, we really went all the way around so that we could really demonstrate how little visual impact there are.
2:51:07 Again, I think the Clearwater Pacific Plane did a very good job of locating the mass in the middle, so you didn't see it. Thank you. So again, this is now taken from Laurel Mountain. And, you know, again, it's really interesting because it's these low-scale elements that are defining this. So again, our request to measure from the top of the parking podium, which again is based on an adjacent grade,
2:51:40 I think really shows that there's no visual impact. In fact, you could even add, not that we're suggesting this, but you could even add an additional floor and not even see it. This is from the connector road. Again, the lower scale elements are shielding the higher portions of the site. And we took the oblique corners because we were concerned that would be where you would see some of the higher portions. And again, these are taking some time to load, but we were again very pleasantly surprised how very little impact.
2:52:16 There is. You just don't see that taller portion, the 55 foot portion in the center is so well shielded by all of these elements, you just don't see it. So this is the oblique corner view from the location of Old Mammoth Road and the connector road. This is from the grove, which does a pretty good job of getting shielded just because of all the existing wonderful trees that are there. These are all huge files.
2:53:02 And I'll end with this one. Again, there are more, but it basically all shows the same conclusion that, again, whether you measure from adjacent grade or from the podium, which we're requesting, we're still talking about a 55-foot high building. We're talking about a case where it's actually below grade here, existing adjacent grade, where it would be measured from above existing grade in this location, but it's really a moot point because you just don't see it. And these show those corner views. Tony, you have a question. Yeah, I just have one question for you, John.
2:53:34 2002, when I served on town council, one of my first votes was the West End Hotel. And after it was built, coming in on 395 and driving around town, going up Minaret, well, you could see the top floor of it. And it was something that we didn't realize when we approved it. And I thought to myself at that time after seeing it, well, we probably could have gone down the floor because 20 years from now, maybe the trees will cover it.
2:54:00 Yesterday afternoon, as a passenger, I went driving around town, went down to 395, up 203, up all the way up to the village, came back around town, old Mammoth, and I couldn't find any point from any of those places that we could actually, we will be able to actually see that highest point of your building. So, I'm not an engineer, I'm not an architect, but my question to you is,
2:54:22 Are there any points outside? I mean, it's great to say we're at site level on the street, but any other points in town that you think we're going to see at the top of that building? Given the tree, given the, kind of to use the analogy that's been used about the village and the trees, the existing trees on the site average about 65 feet, but there are some trees that are considerably taller. Some go up to about 85 feet. And given the tree cover in the area and given kind of that you're down in the flatland, I think the answer is a pretty definitive no.
2:54:52 Thank you. I guess I'm curious about that statement because this is one of the highest points along that Old Mammoth Road. Yes, except you're still down in the flat. You're right in that Old Mammoth Road does rise from Main Street. It has, you know, again, people tend to think of it as flat, but it actually has a rise there. And it pretty much kind of flattens out there. But because it's, in greater context, a flat,
2:55:26 If you will. I mean, we all kind of think of it as a flatter area, given that we're surrounded by hills and mountains. And then given the trees that basically exist around, there's not a high point where you would actually be able to come down and really see this development very easily, particularly since so many of the trees are up above that 65-foot height, and we're only talking about a 55-foot height maximum building. And also just to maybe...
2:55:56 One more step on that. On 203, coming up 203 by Old Mammoth Road, what I notice is the viewpoint going down Old Mammoth Road, you have Mammoth Mall that actually gets in the way of it. So is that your understanding also? That's my understanding as well, yes. You believe that with Mammoth Mall sitting there, it still does not exceed that height of it? Correct. Well, my concern is view sheds, not so much.
2:56:18 Seeing the buildings, because of the step back, obviously they're not going to be shown, but the view shed is what I want to protect. Right. And based on our analysis, there would be, we feel it's a pretty definitive no, there would be no impact on the view shed. Are there any other questions of John at this time? We're going to break in a few minutes, but. Just very quickly. John, when did you realize that we had a discrepancy and needed to do something
2:56:48 Commissioner Clark, I knew it the first few days that I worked on the project. And that was? I believe it was last June, roughly June, July. July.
2:57:06 Ms. Sharon, I think Mark Carney had stated it was after the town council meeting when the policy was established. As soon as I got into the project and really looked at how you would get a parking garage in, get access to the parking garage, not put buildings underwater, so to speak, find the sweet spot, it became very clear, and particularly looking at the other precedents in town, it became very clear that there needed to be a means to measure
2:57:33 Like in the other master plans from the podium height, because otherwise you get into so many complications and pushing things where they don't want to go. And that was last June? Correct, yes. Thank you. Any other questions at this time? Jay, do you have anything? Elizabeth, do you have anything at this time? I have a lot of questions, but I think I'll wait for the staff questions and they'll be able to respond. And Tony, do you have anything else? I file a sale after public comment. Mark?
2:58:01 Thank you, Madam Chair. Our intention was to have Les Card come up and speak for, you know, five minutes or so with respect to circulation and parking, followed by Jerry Kaiser, who will take up to between 10 and 15 minutes. We're conscious of the fact that that would bring up to 12.15 or 12.20. What's Madam Chair's practice? Well, and we do have a commitment to the public at 1 o'clock, so our additional questions, we've allowed for those to happen during the presentations.
2:58:31 I believe to keeping that commitment at the 1 o'clock. So it's up to you that we can... If you can give us until 12.15, I think we can wrap it up. And I think we'll start with the CBIS. I have my lunch in the car. That's fine. All right, we're going to start with Mr. Kaiser first, a little out of order, just in case he takes the full 15 minutes. Okay. And then Mr. Carr will be here to answer questions in the afternoon if that's the case. Okay. No pressure there.
2:59:06 Madam Chair, Commissioners, and member of the public, Jerry Kaiser, I will commit to not taking the full 15 minutes. Just a way of a brief introduction so you know who is speaking to you. I'm the founding principal of Kaiser Marston Associates, often known as KMA. We do real estate and financial analysis. I thought I would just cite three quick projects in San Francisco that I think you'll have some.
2:59:34 Familiarity with. When the National Park Service, so you understand the way, when the National Park Service needed a leasing and finance strategy for the Presidio to demonstrate that to Congress that this could eventually become self-sustaining, we did that work. Two other projects that you'll be familiar with are the Ferry Building in San Francisco and Bloomingdale, the new Bloomingdale store and shopping center.
3:00:04 I am familiar with Mammoth. We've been working here off and on for about 10 years. My specific assignment in this case was to undertake the CBIS analysis. You've heard from Walter a peer review of our analysis. You've heard Jim cite some of the really significant findings from that analysis. I will just kind of go over it in keeping with my commitment to not take the full 15 minutes.
3:00:34 Fairly quickly. Essentially, as you heard, so this slide just tells you what my purpose was, and this slide tells you what our finding was, is the key finding to be that the value of the community benefit
3:01:15 It's in the $26 million range, and the potential benefit to the landowner density upgrade that is being requested is in the $2.5 million range. It's a multiplier, and to the positive side for the community, about a 10-time multiplier. Just so you're aware, one reason that the benefit to the landowner is not greater is because of the amount of benefit that he's providing to the community.
3:01:45 in these community benefits and the costs that are associated with that, so we understand that. Now, I think a key, whoops, too fast, I'll go back. I think an absolutely critical, in my own mind, maybe the most important finding that we're going to come to, not that that significant multiplier is not important, but in my mind,
3:02:17 It's the responsiveness of this project to the town's work. It is the need to further to town as a destination resort and sustainable year-round economy, to improve the pedestrian activity and gathering spaces, to create a there-there and not the outmoded strip mall that tends to prevail. It's to provide instead a compact retail place.
3:02:46 with good parking that can provide criticalance. And those kind of essential ingredients that you've heard about, I think for the last couple of hours this morning, really will be responsive to the recommendation of Economic Research Associates when they did their document a couple of years ago and said there has to be a project in this town that is of sufficient scale to move Mammoth up
3:03:14 The global competitive ladder, to quote that. In my words, in my words, and I say this both as a professional and also as a skier who's debated with his buddies where to go skiing, everybody says this is a great mountain, it's a great setting, it is not the village and the ambiance that we want to come to. And the decision we tend to make, frankly, is to go to another location that has those ingredients. I believe...
3:03:43 That this community desperately needs this project that's before you this morning. That it will do untold wonders for this community and will really make people come here instead of making the decision to go elsewhere. Just very quickly, in the interest of time, I think Walter really spoke to the fact that in terms of looking at the methodology for the benefit to the landowner of the density upgrade that we use the residual analysis.
3:04:15 I won't dwell on that since Walter, I think, covered that quite well. What I would like to spend a little more time on is that, and I believe, Commissioner Tenney, if I understood your question earlier, I'll try to speak to that with regard to how we treated the parking. The methodology with regard to the identification of community benefit components was either to look at development cost or development cost in relationship.
3:04:43 To any value that was being created for the private property owner. Because as we have talked about, a number of the benefits, you know, the essential elements of this project, the kind of reinvented retail that's really needed, the public spaces that will add so much to the community, and the lodging, of course, itself, they will also be a benefit to the project. We all agree with that.
3:05:12 So the question is, how do you look at those projects in relation to the specific components that are being provided? And the way we looked at it is, we took on the outdoor pauses and the public gathering spaces. We did not count those spaces that were going to be a primary benefit to the hotel. We just took them out. We just looked at the cost that was going to be provided.
3:05:36 for those spaces that are really being provided in what we think is clearly over and above and to the primary benefit of the community. Same with the mid-block connector and the widening of Old Mounted Road. And again, here we did not include the value of the easements. It'd be conservative in our estimate in terms of this community value would be. We looked at what the actual cost of construction will be. We did the same thing with regard to the
3:06:05 The meeting and the conference based in what is in excess of what we believe a prudent investor would do in this particular community and situation. In the retail restaurant component, number three in the chart that's before you, there will be income generated and value generated to the property. But as Walter said in his presentation, it's not going to be sufficient to cover the cost. So there's going to be a subsidy required. And what we've estimated with our $2.6 million dollars.
3:06:36 of community benefit is that differential, that subsidy requirement that will be there. With regard to underground parking, and I think this, hopefully I'm speaking to your question, Commissioner McKenney, what we said here was that the great bulk of the retail restaurant space that we believe would be provided in this project, we believe a prudent investor would be
3:07:01 We approach very carefully and would only build a really prudent investor, would only build a small component of that. The great bulk of this law will have benefit and will create a synergy, will be a benefit to the community. So that space we have included as part of our community benefit. We have also said that the underground parking that's associated...
3:07:28 with that great bulk of retail and restaurant space should really be viewed as community benefit as well because if you don't do the bulk of the space, you don't need to provide that parking. So we saw the two together and that's why we have included full cost of the underground parking for the retail and restaurant. By contrast, we said the underground parking for all the other uses.
3:07:57 That parking does need to be provided somewhere. It would be provided and certainly could be provided in a structure, above grade structure. And therefore, in fairness to and keeping our estimate low for what the community benefit would be, we said we really need to deduct from the cost of providing that underground parking the alternative cost that would be associated with providing an above ground structure.
3:08:24 I believe that that was the question you were asking. That's the reason we've done it that way. You add up all those community benefits, and we are at the $26 million mark. With respect to the fact that we don't want to lose sight of the other benefits to the town from the zoning increase, and Jim spoke very eloquently to this chart, the direct fiscal benefit from the project itself.
3:08:52 We're estimating at nearly $2 million a year, the primary, both from the transient occupancy tax, which is the largest producer of the property and the sales tax. But I want to speak for just a moment to the next bullet that's on that chart, which is the induced sales tax and transient occupancy tax. This is what ERA spoke to when they did their work and what I feel so passionate about, which is the ripple effect.
3:09:20 that will create, that will result from this outstanding project, that will result from creating the there-there and the synergy and begin to turn the direction of the town so that other projects will result and even those projects that are in place will do better because more people will be making the decision to come here rather than the decision to go elsewhere because of the lack of ambiance and those very factors.
3:09:50 The jobs Jim spoke to, permanent jobs, the wages, and I think maybe the last bullet here I also find to be a very important bullet in my thinking. It's not just the new jobs that are going to be created, it's the new wages that are going to be created, but it's work for the towns underemployed. To me, that is a very significant benefit that will result in the project. With that, I think I met that a minute last, so I think you did that by. Thank you very much. I have one question for you.
3:10:19 And it's regarding your, maybe this is covered in the induced sales tax where you were talking in a previous slide where you were talking about the incremental meeting space there. So, and you had a value of that, I believe it was 2.8, 2.3 to 2.8 on that. Was that including the additional occupancy and TOT from the surrounding
3:10:50 Properties? No, the way we estimated the median conference space in excess of the prudent investor was to take, we used the Weston as kind of our prototype example and said a prudent investor would build about that. It's about adjusted for the size of this facility, about the total of
3:11:11 About 9,500 to 10,000 square feet that's proposed to be built of conference space. About 3,100 of that would be what a prudent investor would do, and the balance would be community benefit, and we multiplied that by the cost of construction, and that's all that's included in that number. So if would that be induced as an additional number. So would it be fair to
3:11:34 Surmise that there would be additional T.O.T. from other areas from surrounding adjacent properties because you could not possibly house enough people on that side there. Absolutely. That would be incorrect. Thank you. Good question. Excuse me. One more question. And we'll give you your time. What percentage did you use for occupancy? 60.
3:12:01 And that's what your question is then. You think because the average occupancy in this town is much less than that, under 40 percent. So the reason you're asking... Because if they only built enough for the hotel to use that everybody could possibly use or stay at that hotel...
3:12:23 Then the Westin is actually fine because nobody's, it's not, they can't have a bigger conference with people staying in other surrounding areas. But now with more conference space, they can have a bigger conference there and that could drive occupancy and rentals into the adjacent rental properties as well. And that's where you got your 60% as opposed to under 40%. That's correct. Thank you. Thank you for your patience, Chair. Thank you for the opportunity, Chairman, Vice Chairman, members of the Commission.
3:12:59 Thank you for the opportunity to present to you. My name is Les Card. I'm with LSA Associates. No, nothing. Just out of order and I continue. Thank you. I've had the opportunity to work here on many projects over the years. I'm a registered civil and traffic engineer. I've been practicing traffic engineering and transportation planning for about 35 years. For the last 13 years, I've had the opportunity to work on all of your major projects up here.
3:13:29 Starting with North Village with Dana Severy back in the late 90s, the Snow Creek Project, Mammoth Crossings, Ski Back Trail, your airport work, all of your major projects, I've had an opportunity. So I do know the resort business and the traffic, special traffic issues and parking issues that you have. We'll briefly cover, since many of the points I wanted to make have been covered, is one,
3:13:58 The major change from the previous specific plan. As has been described, the current project takes all of its access off of Old Mammoth into the new connector road, either into the structure or the Port de Croce with access on the Laurel Mountain. That compared to the previous specific plan, which had major access down at the corner of Sierra Nevada and Old Mammoth really congesting that corner, this is just a much superior plan and the technical work we've done supports that.
3:14:28 This exhibit here, the parking program, this is in your staff report, it's been addressed and touched on briefly. It's really one of the major mixed-use parking programs that you have. The specific plan allows for the sharing of parking between the retail and the restaurant. It actually precludes the calculation of the residential component into a sharing program. And what I mean by that is this program, we've had to
3:14:55 provide parking for the residential component, those 534 spaces, those 534 spaces, completely separate and independent, just like every one of those residents was going to drive in and park in an assigned space. That's what the specific plan, in effect, required us to do. However,
3:15:16 Once we go through the program, we add the component of the restaurant and retail. That's explained in our report in your packet, how we come up with those numbers. We come up with a total of 619 spaces. However, as you're aware, we can operate this as a ballet program. Once we do that, that whole residential component becomes a pool for us to work with. They are not individually assigned.
3:15:43 What that all boils down to is really a very conservative program that you have recommended to you. You saw that in the presentations by Jason Schreiber from Nelson Nygaard where he spoke about the calculations that he made. He would have recommended somewhere between 513 and 570 spaces as the demand for this project. We're recommending and the staff has agreed we're providing 619 spaces. That's how we're calculating it.
3:16:13 The way that that's being done, the garage itself is designed for standard 450 car parking based on all of your typical design standards, aisle widths and all of those things. The valet parking program, obviously we're taking advantage and we're really stacking the cars in there. We're doubling up vehicles in the banks, we're putting vehicles in the aisles. This is a conceptual program that we've developed.
3:16:43 where we show 619 capacity. How a valet operator will do it, they'll decide. We've increased the capacity about 38% from the standard design. They tell us that they go anywhere from 50 to 70% above a standard capacity. We don't need that. Again, this is just an illustration, one concept on how to achieve that. This does maintain the aisle widths that the
3:17:09 Public Works Department has requested that we maintain, but we believe that we've got a very sound program, that we're not utilizing any of the parking that can occur along Old Mammoth in any of this count, so it's all provided within the structure. It's also interesting to note that you don't even need to consider the concept of a valet program until you go over 75% occupancy.
3:17:36 In other words, the 450 spaces completely covers all of the residential retail restaurant uses until you go above 75%. That's really when it becomes necessary. In the interest of time, that's really all I wanted to cover while I'll be here this afternoon for questions. Yes, sir. Just one fast question. The connector road, is that two-way or is it one-way only? Under the current...
3:17:58 Recommendation is it's two-way between the entrance to the garage and to Laurel Mountain. It's one-way inbound, in other words, from Old Mammoth into the site under the current conditions. It's wide enough to be two lanes. We've had some discussions about that might be a preferred option. It does not cause a significant impact if you did go eastbound on the connector road out to Old Mammoth. That's something we'd like to maybe work with the staff in the future, but it's not precluded. Thank you.
3:18:28 You'll be here this afternoon? Yes. Good, because I have a number of questions. I do too, so do you want to do it now or later? I want my lunch. You might like the questions better after lunch, too. Exactly. So at this point, thank you very much if you can be available. We're going to reconvene at 1 o'clock. We will reconvene with the public comment section at that time because we've made that commitment to the public. So hopefully a lot of your...
3:18:58 We got our questions answered, a lot of them this morning, and we will then get down to the final questions this afternoon. Thank you. We'll see you at 1 o'clock. Let's go. Thank you. We'd like to reconvene at this time. And just for those of you that have weren't here this morning, there's not many yet, but there will be. I anticipate soon is that this is a public hearing regarding Old Mammoth Place.
3:19:27 Listen to the staff and the applicant this morning as well as Elizabeth generously provided us with a history of the project starting five years ago and 55 meetings. I think those, I didn't get much past that particular level without some shock there but how much detail it is and I believe that we have
3:19:50 Copies available? These are on the back table, and this is based on my memory, my notes, my Planning Commission packets, conversations with staff, with Mark, conversations with Mark, a conversation with Mark Carney, and with Neal McCarroll, our mayor. So this is a recap, two pages of the history of this whole project, and if you haven't seen it, it's back there and available. Thank you. Chair, for the record, I note that you called in
3:20:17 Public, you opened the public hearing at 915. Yes, I did. Thank you. So at this time, there are, we have not covered all of our questions from the Planning Commission, but we did make a commitment to the public that we would begin the public
3:20:35 Hearing portion of this in public comments section, so the rest of the Planning Commission has been asking some questions throughout the presentation, but we will be coming back to that later on, but right now, we would like to turn this over to questions, and we'll call for testimony from those.
3:20:55 In a particular order I'd like to carry with this, those that like to speak in support of the project, there's also some parties here that are neutral as far that for informational purposes that would actually like to speak. I'll have those in between and then we will have those in public that need to speak in opposition. I request again that you fill out the speaking slips. They are
3:21:23 Located at the back of the room, and when you come to the podium, please give those to Karen. We are streaming live on the computer. This is being taped, so it is important for the public to know who's participating, and we time stamp, and so everyone knows who's up there in case the camera isn't capturing directly your comments there in person. We can't see your faces.
3:21:46 All the time. So at this point, I would like to call for testimony from those persons wishing to speak in support. Give your card to Karen. Please be respectful of everyone's time. Limit your comments to five minutes. If you would like to say I concur with what's happened, please feel free as well. Anyone would like to speak? I don't know if she's here. She submitted a card before lunch. Sally Guessboard said she was in favor. At this point? Okay.
3:22:15 Knowing that this time would like to come forward, I will, as others come in, and if they would like to speak and we have time, I'll absolutely allow that. Now I'd like to call on Earl Henderson with the Water District and had some items of clarity you'd like to bring forward. Earl Henderson, Mammoth Community Water District. A couple of comments this morning that were covered or not covered.
3:22:50 Clear enough, perhaps, in the letter from the Director of the Water District, Greg Norbury. Commissioner Clark referred to them. Your CEQA presentation had a slight presentation in there that concerned water. So it's the substance of that letter from the Water District that I'd just like to bring forward. I'm not speaking in favor of or against the project as it stands. The CEQA presentation made the sort of all-covering statement.
3:23:19 That the projected water use of the project was well within the general plan estimated water use for the town as a whole. I sort of felt that was a little bit misleading because if you take, I guess, the total amount of water left to be used in the general plan, definitely we have not built out yet and the water consumption or use for this specific project indeed fits within that emblem.
3:23:48 As was stated. The letter addresses some issues that perhaps just need to be brought to the forefront. It's not new. Last month in your commission meetings concerning the Holiday House, two other commissioners on the Water District Board, Commissioner Cage and Commissioner Albert, were quoted. And it was basically trying to forward the idea that we need to pay attention to the fact that we're building an infrastructure and capacity at the Water District.
3:24:17 To meet the needs of the general plan. And that if we continue on with density increases, which is fine. I mean, it's up to you to decide land use. It's just come to a recognition of the fact that somewhere at the end of the line, there may not be capacity for the last people in line. And, you know, how you handle it is up to you.
3:24:42 But it's just, we want, I guess, some recognition for the fact that you have to acknowledge that we're just somewhat forewarning, that we need to move ahead as a town, we need to build these projects that are necessary for the community to benefit, we need to take projects like this that are willing to step up and get in the fray and work with them, absolutely. But we just need to keep in mind that if you're handing out increased densities again.
3:25:12 There may come a gap at the end. And then the water district will become the bad guys. We'll be the ones that will be told, hey, your job is to supply the water and the wastewater treatment that we need. And we'll have to say, you're absolutely right, and here's what it's going to cost to do the additional work. And then somebody's going to have to figure out who's going to pay for it.
3:25:37 So, in essence, I think the consensus is we just don't want to be left at the end of the line. So, please, consider these things in your deliberations. Work it into your plans as a planning commission. It's just not an endless goal out there. The moving target of the general plan is created enough to work for the water district to try and keep up as those numbers change and the land use changes and projections of population and densities.
3:26:07 So if anything, it's just please keep us in mind and acknowledge the fact that what you're doing may generate problems for those down the road. It's somewhat disingenuous, not only to those people applying for the process, but those that will follow. So that's about all I have to say. Thank you. Earl, if I could, you and I have discussed this, so more for the public and the public that's here and those watching and streaming on the Internet.
3:26:37 Page 5 of the letter that we received last night from Mr. Narby and the board. And there's recommendations here, A through E. And then numbers 2 through 5 talk more about working with the town to establish guidelines. So if we were to use these today with the Old Manly Place project and look at future use for future developments, does that satisfy, in your opinion, the board that we would be meeting those?
3:27:02 Issues regarding infrastructure and that for the future. Or coming close to it, not just meeting. It's a positive step that direction, yes. Earl, has there been any partial update or complete update of the 2005 Urban Water Management Plan? It's in the process to be done every five years, and that's one of the projects online this year. So then the general plan update came right in the middle of your update cycle. Okay, so we're a little out of sync there. Yes.
3:27:32 Excuse me. This may be in those recommendations. I haven't had a chance to read through all of this letter yet, but one question I have is can you project that if all of the projects that come online from here forward incorporate, I don't know if I want to say maximum, but water-saving features both for domestic water-efficient fixtures, all that sort of thing, as well as landscaping,
3:28:00 Is that enough water savings to project that there won't be a shortage or is it too hard to produce that? We just completed a multi-year study of the groundwater under Mammoth Lakes to give us a better idea of what's there. That's just been finished up the last few months and it's under close scrutiny and analysis to see how it fits into the bigger picture.
3:28:22 We are like every other city and county and state of California under the governor's mandate to reduce water consumption by 20% by the year 2020. The water district is already implementing help rebates on older projects and encouraging the installation, as that letter addresses, of water conserving figures. We're unique, though, in the sense that if you take the charts and graphs and so forth that we've got and get every month on water production.
3:28:52 We peek out at water use during the summer. We peek out at sanitation water going the opposite direction in the winter. So we've got reclaimed water online for the golf courses, trying to find out how much more we can conserve and save and use in landscapes. So we've got two sets of pipes, basically, that we're trying to meet your demands, your request for this moving target of the general plan.
3:29:21 And we're not like the cities down south where it's all on the same level or just, you know, peaks in July perhaps. So, I mean, it's the size of the wastewater pipes as well as wastewater treatment. So it's not necessarily so much even conserving water. That we feel we can do. The water district, through its ordinances, restricting the amount of water that's used and when we can water and so forth helps that summer peak.
3:29:51 But we're still dealing with, and if any of you happen to drive out of town during our biggest weekends, towards the end of January, you realize that the wastewater treatment was having trouble keeping up. So it's a totally different issue. So it's not like we can lump it all together. And it's not necessarily, I would say, that water itself is the issue, but it's the entire infrastructure. We'll get water to and from.
3:30:19 All these projects as they go online. If densities increase in any given area, perhaps that would overshoot the infrastructure that's there. And so we would have to start upsizing pipes, probably more so for wastewater than even for the water itself. So it's just a general idea, I guess, that we've been working hard with staff, with town staff. Their way of calculating water connections was different than the water districts.
3:30:48 This last year they got their heads together and actually agreed, well, we need to find some common ground on the way we execute these numbers for what's going to be needed. But I'm sorry, it's just, it's an overall picture that's not new. And more and more you're hearing about it from the district directors as well as the general manager because we work it into this groundwater management plan.
3:31:16 Our rate structures. It's just an issue for us to deal with. Okay. Sharon, did you have a question? I just wanted to thank you so much for coming and talking to us. Thank you for putting up. Do you have the capacity to store green water? I'm thinking of all that water going the opposite direction in the wintertime. Is law upon green water? Yes, it is. And we're dealing with issues now.
3:31:40 With the NEPA process and Forest Service because we'll be reducing perhaps the size of what's there because it's overexpanded beyond we haven't been using the great water. But now this next year it's going to go online for Sierra Star. The T is already in the line to put Snow Creek Golf Course online. We've got large condominium projects that want it. CDRES Park is in the mix for a grant to get the reclaim water out there.
3:32:08 So now we're looking and trying to figure out where and how we can most effectively put that as a water source. But during the winter, at this point in time, there's just no effective way to store it. You can't make another reservoir or another, you know, pond or something? Possibly, but to get it down low enough that it wouldn't freeze and then pump it all the way back up. And then where would you use it in the winter? Possibly snowmaking, snow park out in...
3:32:37 The vetters, it's clean enough to put on the play fields for children, so these are options, but it would just actually just be a minor enhancement to the winter, Commissioner Tenney, to be able to do as much as we can, but I guarantee it's being looked at. We're trying to make every drop count twice when it comes out of the world. So I want to go back to the recommendations one more time, and that is...
3:33:05 A number of a few years ago, the district had increased the DIF or your fees and then you reduced them. Yes. And can you just historically for the commission as to what the fees were going to be used for and then what happened when you reduced them? Well, as we began dealing with the largest PAOT number that the town had come forward with, we were looking for all the ability to gather water to meet the demands. We had
3:33:34 A sizable amount of money to go into drawing water out of an adjacent watershed. And it was decided that if the number, when it got adjusted, that we could pull that out for now. And so that gave us enough leeway to reduce our fees, connection fees. But then again, our connection fees are back up for re-evaluation.
3:34:01 As well as our rate studies now to figure out how we're going to pay for what's necessary at this point in time. So again, like I said, it's just a plaintive cry, I guess, to keep us in mind, get it out there, acknowledge it, and at least start looking at it. It would appear the efforts have been put in by this team, that they're looking for conservation ways and so forth, but it's just a piece of the big picture.
3:34:27 Town build out, I don't expect to happen within my lifetime or within my tenure on the water district, but I'd like to be able to leave the water district whenever I do and say that I know things are pretty well on track and online. We've all been made aware and we're working in the same conflict. I do have one more thing, Rhonda. In the December 9th letter, the district believes the proposed project now meets the requirements for completion of the
3:34:56 Water Assessment, Supply Assessment. If that needs to be done, would that be on your dollar or the project's dollar? How much comes back to us? Oh, really? You would have to... But, you know, there's issues here. The larger the project gets, the more footprint envelopes, I mean, the less water it needs because now, all of a sudden, the highest water use, the landscape, is diminishing in size. So, you know, there's...
3:35:23 Definitely a swap-off in the assessments of how much water will be needed for the sites because, like I said, just the more hardscape and building footprint you have, the less they're going to plant. So the water needs are down in the summertime. It helps them to fit within what's needed. For the technical record, I'd just like to state that we received correspondence from the water district and they wanted to make sure that
3:35:50 A water assessment study was or was not required, and RBF prepared a detailed study to document whether a study was legally required or not, according to Senate Bill 1610, and the determination that both parties agreed to is that we don't have to do a legally required now water assessment study.
3:36:18 One is not required and we're not doing one. And it's just a matter of law. I guess I tend to prefer to listen to my own water district as far as the legalities go. The district told you that in the letter they sent you? In the one we got this morning? Yeah, the one that was not required. I didn't get it last night at 10. I got it this morning. Again, we're not...
3:36:49 For or against the project in itself, it's just the idea that we're worried about capacity and where we will stand in the general scheme of things as the Planning Commission moves forward. Thank you. Thank you. Appreciate it. Thank you. For those of you that have just joined us, we are in the public comments section and we are using our speaker slips today. We are streaming live and we are also...
3:37:15 being recorded for the news, and so if you'd like to speak and have not already filled out one, please, there's slips at the very back with pens available to any of those to Karen when you come to the podium. Right now we're at a time where we have neutral session, and those that would give some points of information or things to be considered, and we did open up the, right at one o'clock, we opened up the time for those to speak in.
3:37:44 supported the project, and no one came forward at that time, but I do see we have a lot of other people, so if there's others that wish to speak, I will allow them. Tom. I'm neutral. You can speak. Tom Moody, representing Sierra Park Village. I appreciate your history, Elizabeth. I feel like you've been part of this history, because I've only missed three meetings the whole time, and one of them...
3:38:14 It was just several weeks ago on the CBAS thing, but I'm up to date on it now, don't worry. And it's really been a very positive experience getting to know the Planning Commissioners better and the staff particularly better, as well as the applicant and his team, his new team. And over this time, there is absolutely no doubt this project has improved immensely, particularly in terms of architectural design, the overall quality of the project, the materials used.
3:38:43 And I really appreciate the sensitivity of the developer and his team to particular concerns that we've had over Sierra Park Goals. He's been very responsive to those concerns. But unfortunately, we do have a complication that makes it more difficult to totally bless the project at the moment, the zone change. First of all, I want to emphasize that we were never concerned about heights in an abstract sense.
3:39:11 25 feet or 35 feet or 45 feet, 55 feet, but more in the context of what the view impact would be. Now I saw the drawings that the applicant presented and I realized the little guy sitting down in front of the building there, standing down in front of the building, and the guy going up the middle of Old Mammoth Road is not going to see the 55 foot building, but people coming down Old Mammoth Road will, to some extent.
3:39:35 And particularly people that live in second floor rooms in Sierra Park villas that will have the view of the knolls obscured somewhat. And people in Timberline that won't be able to look at the White Mountains as much. And as well, certain views of the Sherwins. So there is a view impact. But I think more than anything right now, I need to get a few things clarified.
3:40:04 in terms of this view situation. I need to know exactly what the podium level is at above natural grade. You may have that, Sandra.
3:40:21 The podium level, or Pam, either one of you, the podium level above natural grade. Yeah, John had a couple slides in his presentation that showed that, and if we need, we can have him put those back up again, but because the natural or existing grade is sloped, the podium height above that does vary across the site, and so as he pointed out on the northwest corner of the site, the podium level is actually two feet below the existing grade.
3:40:51 However, on the southeast corner of that building, the top of the podium is nine and a half feet above the existing grade, and so it will vary between two feet below to nine and a half feet above as the slope changes across that site. Okay. So the structure of the building, the hotel, and the 45-foot buildings, particularly the 45-foot and the 55-foot buildings, will be on that podium.
3:41:19 Which is above natural grade. In some cases, yes. In some cases, nine feet above natural grade. That means that the actual buildings will not just be 35 and 45 and 55 feet high, but in some cases will be as high as 64 feet high. Isn't that correct? The roof of the building would be, as you're saying, however tall above existing grade.
3:41:45 However, the building itself would only be 55 feet from the top of the podium. To really appreciate this problem, I think what the commission and the public should have received was some drawings that indicated the natural grade as it exists now, the amount of grading that will be done so we know how far down this parking structure is going to go, and where the podium will be or the top of that parking structure where that will be.
3:42:12 In terms of actual elevations compared to the national grade, and then some drawings showing exactly where those buildings were being. I realize you gave us one that showed the buildings being totally in compliance, but that was on top of the podium, as they have to be, according to the zone change. But we don't really have information and drawings to appreciate the reality.
3:42:38 of these buildings on top of the podium. As you mentioned, somewhere it's going to be over 64 feet high. That's a major impact, particularly considering what the council went through, what we went through. The council struggled on this. They really struggled. We had Skip at 45 feet, Wendy at 50 feet, one evening, and then Stevie changed her mind back to 55 and then...
3:43:05 John Eastman eventually supported the compromise, you know, and here we are now with this unfortunate situation. I'd like to have your response to the question. I really do appreciate the problem the applicant has in terms of his grading and his construction. He's definitely got a problem. But we've got to have some kind of compromise on this somewhere so that the view impact is not as extravagant in some areas as it really is.
3:43:33 Pam, could you also add in the percentage of the building itself of mass that is at the height that Tom is now speaking about? You know, we talk about the grade and above natural grade and from 9 to minus 2, but that doesn't encompass the entire building. So what is the percentage of land coverage that that height is there at at the 9, 9 1⁄2 feet over? I think John Ashford would be the best person to answer that technical question.
3:44:04 Through the commission, there is a drawing C6.0, does have some cross sections of the project, and really what it indicates, if you look at section BB, is the center of the project and the podium are about at the grade, and then as Pam indicated, on the northwest side, the project's actually just below grade, and along Sierra Park Road where the buildings are lower,
3:44:33 That way you can follow while Peter's talking. The podium's above grade by the 9th. And additionally, there's also sheet HA.23 in your packet that does show a 3D view of the entire site with only the podium that shows which portions of the podium are underground and then kind of going across the side how much of the podium is sticking out of the ground. Which page was in? This is HA.23. If I could add to the view analysis, sheets also show natural grade.
3:45:05 But none of these showed what Tom was asking. If you could give us the bottom line, how high are those buildings going to be above the existing natural grade? The maximum that they would be above existing natural grade is that one corner where the podium is 9.5. So the roof of the building would be 64.5 feet above existing grade. I can't tell you what percentage of the building that is for, but that would be the highest point. That's a substantial change.
3:45:38 We have now in terms of the zoning, unfortunately. The compromise I presented was to allow the applicant to have the zoning change so he can measure from an average point, two places on the building, on the average grade, but limiting the building itself to somewhere below 50 feet.
3:46:21 Whatever we have to do, in other words, whatever we have to do to accomplish a building that is 55 feet high from the present natural grade. In the case of the 45 foot building, the same thing. In the case of any part of the 35 foot building, the same thing. What we want to end up with is our structures that are at the same elevation that they were at when they were approved at 35, 45, and 55 feet high.
3:46:53 Whatever we need to do to do that. Can you ask a question? Sure. Let's ask a question, Tom. So currently, if you're standing in front of the current Sierra Nevada Roadway Inn, the hotel portion, and you're in the middle of Old Mammoth Road, there's about a 20-foot difference, correct, from the road to the natural grade of where the building is built. And then you have another 35 feet. So you're at 55 feet.
3:47:22 From the center of Old Mammoth Road to the top of the roof of the current hotel. So if you were going to go by that natural grade with 55 feet, you would then be, what, 75 feet is what you're saying if we went by without excavating? I'm accepting the concept that you need to average the slower points. That's what I'm used to. That's the only reasonable way to do it.
3:47:51 The measurements would be from those points up, 55 feet, 35 feet, whatever. But you're saying from the current natural grade that they have to excavate that property to begin, so you're going to get rid of that grade and you're going to have a different natural grade to start with. But we know the elevation now. I'm not sure I'm answering your question. I'm just trying to get clear that you're saying from the current natural grade, so are you looking at the top slope where you're here at the north end?
3:48:25 Here at the south end? Is that what you're saying? Because then 55 feet on top of that is 70 feet. What I feel should be done is normally done in a situation like this. You average the points below the buildings. Not the entire plot. You average the points below the building. Take the hotel building, the 55 foot building, and...
3:48:50 Find two points there at one end and one at the other and average those. That would be your average existing grade. Same thing with the 35 and 40. Can I add something to that? We did do an analysis of each building from average existing grade and that was included in your supplemental memo that we sent out yesterday. And the hotel building that is in question is 59.5 feet above the average existing grade below that building.
3:49:20 So that doesn't represent the highest point, but it represents the average. And that is the building in the southeast point? That's the hotel building in the center of the site. In the center of the site. So it's 4 1⁄2 feet above the 55 feet. Tom, as I understand what you're saying, in practical terms, to measure height the way you're proposing to do it, first of all, I don't think there, it doesn't appear, any alternative that involves
3:49:50 Practically being able to lower the garage lower because of that northwest corner. That, if you take that assumption, the only way that this can be addressed with your requirement would be to take a one story off of the building. I understand that. Okay. And you mentioned, you're referring to your average elevation method as the normal way it's done, but I think you were here this morning that in
3:50:17 In Mammoth, we have three examples from Snow Creek, from Sierra, Lodestar, and from the North Village District Plan of a different way that we normally do it here, where this has been done, where this has come up in the past. Okay, in terms of measuring the height. In terms of the height standard, we have those. What I was talking about in terms of averaging was establishing a beginning base point by averaging two points. I understand. You're building 55.
3:50:48 Okay. All right, if you can work on that, consider that. Thank you. In terms of CBAS, there's no question that there's some amenities here. Initially, I did not agree, or the group did not agree, that things like conference centers and plazas constituted amenities, because I've seen nice hotels that establish those without a problem. But apparently, staff and commission, maybe the council,
3:51:19 has established a concept that they want for this area, or a dream for this area, and so they're going to promote it through this zoning and this sea best policy. So these things do fit that. Those are listed in the general plan, they're listed in your clear water specific plan, so we respect that.
3:51:45 Also some other items like wider sidewalks, enhanced landscaping, the interconnector road, which also does serve the project, and the parking structure, which to some degree is apparently underground according to the applicant's own analysis. But the real question here is how much of a density bonus is ripe in this instance. And I question the study to some extent.
3:52:14 The study tried to separate out in an almost scientific manner the benefits for the applicant as opposed to the benefits for the community. And he gave a pretty precise dollar value to those. And I think that's kind of, I think it's questionable. When you get right down to it, almost all the amenities are part of the project. They're nice amenities. And they do fit into your...
3:52:42 to your Clearwater Specific Plan. So I think that the applicant definitely does deserve some level of a density bonus, but I don't think it's up to the level of a double density bonus. Consider also that this is the first project that's coming before you, and you're going to send a message to other applicants. Is this applicant going above and beyond the project? Is he doing something that really benefits the entire community?
3:53:10 I hope you'll weigh that when you consider the use permit and the actual density bonus. In terms of the vesting tract map, we have no problem to approve that, but when you approve it, be sure that it has a condition that limits the actual maximum pipe from existing grade to achieve the 55-foot building or the 45-foot building that I discussed.
3:53:38 In terms of the adjustment, I think these are things are, this kind of adjustment is usually normal at a site plan stage, except in this case, three and a half feet is a little bit high. It would have been better if we had some drawings to demonstrate this appurtenance so we could really appreciate it and maybe have no problem with it if it may really add to the architectural design of the building, but we don't have that.
3:54:06 At least I never really saw it, except in a drawing, and you really, you really couldn't see it, what that looks like. Is it on there? It's not on there. It's in the dictionary. All right, thank you. Thank you. I do have a question for the applicant. On your presentation, I think probably John could tell this, on page HA5, where it shows
3:54:35 What is the depth between Sierra Nevada Road and that first building? According to your scale, it looks like it's somewhere between 100 to 120 feet between Old Mammoth Road and that first 55 building. From Old Mammoth Road? No, from Sierra Nevada Road. That's 170 feet to the middle of the road. Okay. That's 120 something from Old Mammoth Road. Right, 120 from Old Mammoth Road. Okay.
3:55:06 So it is set back, not quite, yeah, it's my point that it is set back quite a way. I actually went out and drove the site again today for a lot of these issues, and I'll give my observations later for what I saw and things, but I just wanted to clarify that, 120 to 275 on the, as far as the, it's probably. The other thing is, it's blocked by the smaller buildings.
3:55:33 in general also, so not only do you have the 270 foot setback, but you also have the buildings in front. Well, now with the plaza, it overlooked, the plaza's open between there, so it's not blocked by all the buildings, but that open space, it is set back substantially, which will give a different perspective as well. Okay, thank you. That's all I need.
3:55:55 Just a note that this plan set is available on our website and has been since February 24th. So all of these plans that you have, your impact has been online since the 24th. Right, and we have not, this has not changed since. Thank you. Any other questions at this time regarding this issue? I know we have lots of questions, but I want to make sure that the next person comes in. Yeah, I think I'll wait until public comments. Okay. Anyone else?
3:56:25 Clarity of Neutral Positions. A neutral position? Yes. And I believe you had turned in a sheet. Come on. Come forward. You're Sally. Okay, thank you. Thank you. Good afternoon. I'm Sally, guest board. And I don't know how you got back from lunch in time because I walked right by the site because I live.
3:56:52 Adjacent to the proposed site. And I fixed myself lunch and I was late getting back and my name was called. I apologize. And I am odd by how much work the commission is putting in and the hours and also by the principles in developing it. I am odd at your work and amazed. I am convinced after this morning that the motive
3:57:24 behind this new project is, embraces the community and I do feel embraced by it and I want you to know that and I didn't feel that way with the previous development ideas. I think you will be true to your word about developing this according to what you have stated this morning.
3:57:56 I loved the presentation of the visuals, the moving around the property. The only thing missing was the viewpoint from my condo, my townhouse. And I'll give you my address and I would like to see how much my view overlooking the project will be disturbed by this project. What goes along
3:58:25 Laurel Mountain Road is important to me. I know there's going to be a landing there for a lot of the movement trucks and stuff going in and out of the hotel and so on. That concerns me. I, along with I know one other person in this room, walks that street every day. I do. I go to the post office. I go to the amenities of our little...
3:58:57 I care about my view from my level, not ground level, from up above on the second story at Timberline. I really, really care about that. I care about the natural materials. I'm not an engineer. I'm an artist. I care about the rocks going in. That's really important to me. Very important. I care about the amenities.
3:59:28 I have two points. One is, of course, about the height. I think that if a certain height has been determined previously that governs this project here, that's the height that has been established. The height has changed somehow from when I started listening to all this.
4:00:00 Perplexed about that. I know the ground, there's one area that slopes up. Is that reason enough to put the whole project 10 feet higher? I'm not clear about that. If one area slopes up and there's a landing for the whole project, the height already was agreed on, so why does that have to affect how high it is? It affects me.
4:00:29 Because I'm going to be looking out into the high part. Because I fortunately have a condo, a townhome, that looks out high. I love that. So I care about that a lot. Amenities. I'm not an engineer, but I would like to know what the amenities are compared to for this new project compared with the old cold water project. What are the differences of amenities? I know the...
4:00:58 From what somebody's told me, the underground is going to be less expensive, so maybe not as many amenities will be given forth. I'm not clear about that. I'd like to have a comparison of amenities between these two areas because I was familiar with the last one and not as much as this one. So that's basically what I have to say. The height, important to me, the amenities.
4:01:27 I know without a shadow of a doubt after this morning that the developers and all the staff people working towards this project will do their highest sense of right. I'm really interested in that. I am not neutral. I approve the project. And I'm really grateful I have that feeling too. And thank you very much for all of your hard work. Appreciate it. Well, thank you. We don't often hear public comment like that.
4:01:57 And Sally, thank you for using our sidewalks. I remember a number of years ago getting a letter from you about that when we put them in, and I do see you out there using them, and it's good. Hi, my name is Lee Gosch. I'm apprehensive about a few things. The first thing is affordable housing. The first people that have learned to change in this town are Sierra Valley sites. We've all been crammed in there very tight, and we have a general plan that I would like.
4:02:38 To be stuck to. I don't understand how. It's always changing all the time. You can give somebody this if you do that and everything. Why can't we stick to what we've done? They should have, what, 27 on the project and they're asking for eight because they're doing a lot more amenities. Is that proper? The project is proposing to conform with the CBIS policy, which exempts their incentives density from mitigating their housing requirements.
4:03:10 They conform with the policy under which they apply. So 27 units on the project then? They're currently proposing 8 units on the project. Okay, I think they ought to stick to 27. You guys, I really think these places need to have more affordable housing on the project. I've mentioned to you before, when I worked in Alaska, I would have done anything to stay in a place. I could find one and reselect them calls, which is not a good thing to do. There's a lot of people that are just here for 4 months out of the year and they need to go overseas for people.
4:03:39 We need to put more on the project. We have hardly any land left for affordable housing anymore. I was told that back in 2006, we only had 25% of land to build on. Where are you going to put all these places when they go forward? They need to have more on the project.
4:03:55 Truthfully, the working people are an asset to this town, and if I had a project, I would want these people on my project. They are an asset. They don't have to drive there. It's less people on the street. You've got people there to work at the time. If the snow's really bad and everything, they are an asset, and they need to be treated with respect, the working people. Another thing is I worry about the people that are going to be around the project because they're going to have, like, is there enough parking everywhere?
4:04:26 Sierra Valley sites, they park everywhere. It is a safety issue. It's a fire issue. There's a lot of drugs in the area. There's alcohol. If they're going to have bars on the site, they're going to be walking to all the projects around them, and they're going to be affected by Sierra Manors and all the projects around at the condos. How are they going to solve all the beer problems, alcohol problems, and drug problems, and parking problems? How are they going to stop affecting those people? Sometimes, you know, when you
4:04:59 People want to build more. This is Mammoth Lakes. We have a good product to sell here. And the developers know it. They want to get in now before the general plan changes. And it saddens me to see the town selling their souls so they can get something built in this town. Why don't you hang on to what we have and value what we have and wait until, you know, something really good comes along. This could be really good, but there's issues that have to be thought about. What about the parking problems?
4:05:25 When the bars come in, what are they going to do with people? Look at North Village. They have problems there, and it affects the whole town at night when they come home. Sierra Valley sites, we have a lot of issues there from people coming home from North Village. And it's not just us. It's a lot of other areas. So those are things that I'm really concerned about, and I would like to see them addressed. And please stick to the general plan and help the people and listen to the people.
4:05:51 Because this is a good town, and the town's going to take off, and the developers know it, and they want to get in cheap right now before it takes off, and then the town has to pay for it afterwards, and I don't want to see that. We want to go forward. Thanks. Staff, do you have any response? And Lee, I'm sorry you weren't available this morning because there were a lot of those issues were covered as well as far as the parking. I think probably the parking.
4:06:17 How that level is mitigated there just to refresh those that missed it this morning? The number of parking spots and the intended use for that and how that differs from other examples we have in the community. And that it's underground also, Peter. The parking for the project is fully provided for under the structure and so right now it's including 619 spaces of which there's a little over 80 spaces that are actually self-parked.
4:06:47 for the commercial areas. In addition to that, there's some public parking spaces along the street that will be provided, but also provide for storm removal operational areas. And that it's dual use, it's not just for the residents, it's available for retail and restaurants. Right, retail and the affordable housing units. In comparison with the village, which didn't provide any parking for the commercial areas as part of the project itself, only for residential parking underneath the structure.
4:07:18 Because there's some places I know where the parking's being abused and you can't find a place to park whenever you go there. How can you guarantee this place is going to be abused and everybody go there and say it's a good place to park and, you know, I can catch the bus and go there? It's ballet. It's ballet. It's ballet.
4:07:36 It's valet. So they can't go underneath it. Then it might affect the condos around it then. I mean, you see that everywhere. They go parking in the condos. How are the condos now going to deal with it? Like Sierra Manor's, and then I don't know the other place on the other side of the round buildings, the condos. They're going to start parking over there. Lee, the parking underground is specifically for the residents, the guests of the hotel, and the guests of all the shopping and restaurants on the project.
4:08:00 But you cannot guarantee me when they go shopping, they're going to park someplace else. Why would they do that if they could park on site? Then tell me why in our village they park underneath where 850 is. Because there's no parking at the village, because there is no parking for that. But people sneak in there all the time and people that live there can't get into their condos. I mean, these are things that have to be thought of. I believe it's a different situation, but we agree that those issues...
4:08:23 Need to be mitigated Those issues need to be mitigated and I think that that's what we would be working with the applicant on. Thank you. One of the other things that this project also has a condition for a parking management monitoring program and so that they can monitor and we can understand what the demand is and how it fluctuates through the project. It does require, you know, a 24-7 valet operation and then there's that other area that provides for self-making.
4:08:52 Just curious, did the Westin also require 24-7 valet service? The Westin did not require valet service. So we do learn. We do learn. However, they do have that. But they do have valet parking. Are we coming back to parking? I guess we will. Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah. Okay. I will save my questions. Exactly. Okay. If there anyone else we've talked, we've listened to people from our neutral position, from positive position.
4:09:22 And now, Pat, and then I was going to open it to an opposition, but it doesn't matter at this point, but you have a slip for us? Yay. Thank you. I thank you for everyone complying. This is a new process, and it's working the kinks out. In fact, I didn't know exactly what to fill in until I marked all three. That's true.
4:09:46 That's an open mind. Thank you. I was very strong. I've been in the beginning. Yes, you have. And actually, I wasn't going to even speak today. But what got me here was all those emails I got last night, mostly this morning, and I decided instead of coming this morning, I'd read all those emails and letters. And what brought me here was what got me involved in politics in the first place, and that's why.
4:10:16 I was really glad to hear Earl speak to it because I read those letters and the response from Mark and it reminded me of all the battles I went through back during the drought years in 1994 through 98 and I felt I needed to come to emphasize how important what Mr. Norby wrote how this is so often ignored
4:10:46 Because it's easy to set aside because the future is way out there. And I remember back sitting with one of the first vice presidents of InterWest when I was elected to the water board and telling him in a few minutes my view of what it means to live at the top of a watershed. When I was done in a couple of minutes, he looked at me and he said what I heard again and again after that.
4:11:16 was, well, in so many words, we'll have to think about whether we're going to stay and do anything. And I heard that again and again over the years. It's something that is set aside. It's not considered as important. Development is more important in the future. And when people forget, I don't know how many people here were here during the seven years of drought. I almost, I dug out my charts that I used to get elected to the water for that are from 1988.
4:11:46 to 1994, the seven years, and those charts show the well history during that time period, and a picture is worth a thousand years, because they go down one year, then they go up a little with recharge, then they go down further, then they go up a little, and they continue to do that until they go all the way down, maybe 160 feet.
4:12:14 Or 120 feet, or in some cases only 10 feet. And in one case, 10 feet from the pump at the bottom. Okay. This is something that's never mentioned drought years. One, the water district is incredible. I have incredible confidence with the management, with the board. I don't have to go to meetings, but I do get their agendas every month.
4:12:42 I don't have to monitor it anymore. I have incredible confidence. And I came here simply to emphasize that listen to the water board. Listen to them and educate yourself because it's, well, it's complex. Our whole water system here is complex. And I know when I was on the water board, the mountain wanted to use 300 acre feet of water for snowmaking. 300 acre feet of water for Mammoth is...
4:13:12 I forget, it's 9 and 11 percent of the total allotment, at least in those days, of our annual water allotment from Lake Mary, 10 percent for only 300 acres. So, you know, you have to be informed, the community has to be informed, the developers have to respect the idea that we live at the top of the watershed, and there are circumstances that
4:13:42 What do you do when you run out of water? Then we have the environmental one, which isn't even mentioned. The fact we're getting more water and rain than we are, you know, in town, and it's getting warmer, higher up. So these are concerns, and it's the main reason I came. I still have concerns. I'm sorry I wasn't here this morning. But reading the comments and so forth, I see that they're really blessed. I do want to stay right up front. The last meeting I did attend, I went away with a really good feeling.
4:14:13 Okay? So, along with others, I do have a lot of hope that things can be worked out. There are concerns still, but I see a lot of other people have responded to them, and I don't need to. Thank you. Thank you, Beth. At this time, we can move forward. We're going to, I'll go ahead and entertain any public comments and oppositions. We'll, I'll make sure, our, our group is.
4:14:45 Orderly size today. I think everybody who wants to will get a chance to speak. If somebody would like to come forward and speak or if they have any questions, you know, if you still have questions that we have not addressed this morning, as we said, the commission has not had a chance to ask all their questions and if someone would like to wait until afterwards, that's fine because then we will move on to those areas and might get your questions answered as well. Anyone else like to come forward at this time? Madam Chair.
4:15:16 We received two letters of public comment that asked to be read into the record. One was from Andy Ott, and it was, I think, a third letter reiterating his desire for story polls. What is our policy on reading into the record? The other one was from Amy Cutter, who wanted it read into the record. The commission discussed this before. You generally said that you do not read letters into the record. It's the commission's pleasure. We can submit them to the clerk to include in the record, but we don't read them full. Okay.
4:15:46 And the person. So we'll just acknowledge that they asked to have them written the record? Yes, in fact, Sandra has communicated with Mr. Ott that they're formally part of the record. We've included those comments in the staff response and comment letter as well, so they're well documented. I also remember addressing his concerns a couple meetings ago, the exact same concerns. Yes, we've addressed those concerns a number of times. Okay, good. Please be assured that...
4:16:14 No matter what time you get it into us, we're reading these letters, and they are considered, and staff does respond if there's some issues that you have questions about, too, and they do go in the public record as well. Okay, Mark, is it all right that I leave the public comment open, or should I go ahead and close it? I mean, we did announce that it would be 1 o'clock for everyone, but I do want to make sure that everyone feels that it's available.
4:16:43 To speak, and everyone has spoken at this point that it's here. Do you have any? Are we allowed to keep it open if we're going to start deliberating? We're not deliberating. We're not deliberating. We haven't asked our questions. We're answering questions. You should have a reasonable period of time where you close the public. Okay. So at this point, at 2 o'clock, since we told everybody we'd be able to listen to them as well, I'm going to go ahead and close the public comment section. Okay? There we go.
4:17:14 Now, we're going to move on to questions from the commission that they had from this morning's session as well as now. And I would like to call on Elizabeth first. I know that you had a lot of questions. Okay. I'll try and be quick. I've got one giant one and then a lot of little ones. Questions for all of us as well, but everyone will get your seat. Okay. Are we going to do this just sort of kind of scattered or can we do it in some sort of... Category? I'd like to do that. I'd like to start out with parking.
4:17:42 Can I start out with parking? Fine. I'd like to kind of, because we'll all have questions on parking, if that's okay, Madam Chair. Been able to keep this in context, I agree, that's probably a great place to start, and so I'll start with Elizabeth, and our topic right now is parking, and the questions of staff and questions of the applicant, too. Okay, so my question is going to be, with this idea that I've been hatching since last Friday, when I really got into this and have done nothing else since last Friday, would this work?
4:18:11 Okay, so that's, it's going to be a question, would this work? Now let me tell you what it is. Mark is about to leave the room. Okay, this gives me terrific heartburn in the resource conservation sense, and I put dollar signs in place of the S's in resource conservation. If underground parking costs $40,000 a place minimum, and I was so, I found the Nelson Nygaard study so compelling, I mean, I just couldn't believe.
4:18:40 What you can do with valet parking, and of course I've seen the lots in San Francisco next to restaurants where they have 900 cars, you know, and 10 square feet, I don't know how they do it, but yeah, valet parking is very, very efficient, and to spend all this money to put these cars underground when that money might be used for something else, that's part of the issue. Then the other issue is, and I'll tell you where I think the parking can go,
4:19:10 The other issue is if we didn't have all this parking underground, we wouldn't have to have such a big parking podium. And if we didn't have such a big parking podium, is there a point at which we could drop the height and, you know, address this issue, which is the single greatest concern from the public? They feel a little bit betrayed, you know, like we've read on 55 feet and, you know, we've heard lots of letters and lots of comments. Is there some way we could drop the height towards Sierra Nevada Road? Now, what we would do with this parking,
4:19:39 If it costs $20,000 a place to, and we're talking 9 by 18 place, to build structured parking and $5,000 surface parking, we don't want surface parking. The town has across the street and half a block away a parking lot where a wonderful project was planned. In fact, I want to ask Pam the status of that project. Mixed use, workforce housing, understructure, underground parking. And all we have there now is a surface parking lot.
4:20:08 Why wouldn't it be possible to reduce the cost to the developer, work out some kind of public-private partnership, although I'm thinking big, but you could start out with just build some parking with the ability to be able to add on to it with retail on Old Mammoth Road and then build above it, but the parking places for residential and for retail and for restaurants and build them across the street at half the price for
4:20:36 The project. I mean, it's a half block away. That's all it would be. Then we could take the money that was saved and address something which gives me great concern to achieve the base density. And we've been using this chart. You've seen this on big pieces of foam core, you know, this enlarged chart. It talks about what you have to do to get density incentives or discretionary density. But for the base density, the thing that hasn't been addressed is trails and access to public parks and surrounding public lands.
4:21:06 I mean, MLTPA points that out in their letter very much to the point. And so I'm thinking, how could we get some money to address wayfinding, trails, clearing sidewalks, you know, our whole feet first philosophy, which is what the general plan is all about. How could we get some money without making it too onerous for the applicant in order to do that? And so that's why I'm thinking about this parking. I'm really, really distressed that we're spending all that money.
4:21:35 To put cars underground. I just am very troubled by that. And I wonder if it would be possible to reduce the size of the podium, possibly step the components of the project. In fact, I was even thinking, looking at the hotel, these two ends of the hotel here, the north wing, excuse me, the west wing and the east wing, if the top floor were stepped down one unit, you'd end up with two penthouse units, which would market for more money. Can you picture what I'm saying?
4:22:05 Take off the top floor at the end, that unit, or however many units are facing south. Can you picture what I'm saying? I see blank stairs. Okay, I'm not making myself very clear. Anyway, then you would have a penthouse unit with a deck above, and then the next level, the third floor, would also be a penthouse unit with the same timber details. It would help to address this problem of the nine and a half feet over height in that corner.
4:22:34 It would help to address height concern. And if you didn't have to have the podium extend as far as it does in this diagram, or in this plan, this isn't a diagram, it's a plan, it just seems like we might be able to solve a lot of problems and we'd have some money left to do the kinds of things that, you know, we're all about here, which is recreation on foot. So that's my thing. Is there any way that would work? And you don't need to address it now.
4:23:00 You can think about it while we ask our other parking questions. But I've been hatching this idea all weekend. Did that make sense? Well, you're saying that the surface parking lot, you're saying a parking stall at 20,000. That's for surface. Structure, structure parking. 5,000. I got the figures out of the staff report. 20,000 for structure. But how many floors of structure? I think we need 86 places.
4:23:30 Because we have that now on that parking, on the parking right. Right, right. Which we have to keep due to the ground. So if you put, what, one law, I'm just trying to figure out what you said about housing. But I'm thinking 86 places, well, that's what should ultimately happen, and that's what was planned for that parcel. I mean, Pam had a great design that came forward. So you're saying excavate that parking? No, no, no, I'm saying. I think that we really have staff. But we need to hear from staff. I don't know. Let me paraphrase what question has been asked. Because it's a question at this point. Is it possible?
4:23:59 practical and desirable to move a portion of the parking now provided underground to another lot such as the Tavern Road lot with the idea that there is some cost savings. If there were cost savings, those funds could be applied to something else like trails or snow removal. I got a million seven is what I got. And then the related question with
4:24:25 Reduced amount of parking on site, there would be a smaller subterranean garage allowing some portion of the building to be stepped down. Exactly. That's the question. Exactly. So if I could, I'd like to ask the team, perhaps Mark or Les Card, to talk about the parking demand from their perspective, and then we can talk about our...
4:24:49 Staff ideas about parking demand and how it's satisfied. And because of the Nelson Night Guard study for valet parking, the subterranean garage could be much smaller is what I was thinking. I mean, I really, that report was excellent. We always appreciate your creative mind and your spirit, no doubt about that. We're struggling here, and why you saw the blank stairs is we're struggling with the notion of solving a problem that we don't think really exists.
4:25:15 Now, I understand that we've asked for a different height calculation, a different way to calculate height, but just because we've done that doesn't mean that we have a height problem. Height, problems of height are judged by impacts of height, visual impacts, and I think that John has been able to show through the line of science drawings earlier this morning and the fly around.
4:25:35 that there's no visual impacts associated with the additional 9.5 feet on that particular spot. So we're loath to try to solve a problem that we don't believe exists in terms of visual impacts of the specific plan amendment. Now, and the way that you've proposed to solve the problem creates its own set of concerns for us. First, I think we would have to do a new EIR.
4:26:01 Because we would have to judge the circulation aspects associated with parking across the street. Additionally, I do not, because we, the whole circulation element of our, of our specific plan would be different than it is right now. We would have to have some analysis of the, of that corner over near Century 21 because we'd be a lot of people coming in and out of there. In addition, I think it would be, now this is, this is Dana's and Jerry's expertise, not my own.
4:26:30 But I do know enough to say that I do not think that we could tenant that property, the commercial spaces in that property, if we had parking to service those commercial spaces down the street. I've negotiated a lot of leases in my career, and one of the first things that comes up from the tenant is where am I going to park, where are my spaces, how many do I have? And can you imagine the negotiation that we would have with an anchor tenant?
4:26:56 Where they say, okay, where am I going to park? And say, oh, down the street, across the street. No, one half block, really? Oh, yes. Oh, yes. Now, we're loathe also to get anywhere close to recreating the problems at the village. We couldn't be happier that we can say with a straight face and with all sincerity that we will not create that problem for you, that we've got that problem solved. The direction that you're heading, I think, would lead us closer to creating a problem.
4:27:23 We think we've solved that problem. We've checked that one off our list, and we're not encouraged about going back there. And that prime motivation, though, is the money. Right. It's to spend all that money underground. I understand that you have some concern about it, and I know that MLTPA wrote a letter, and that they wanted to basically urge you to charge the full amount of DIF because that's where they get some of their revenues through the recreation element of the DIF ordinance.
4:27:53 We've tried to show how cooperative we have been with respect to MLTPA's suggestions in the past, and I think it's demonstrably true when you look at our plans and our programming. We have underground parking for bicycles at this location. We have an area to encourage people to ride their bicycles so that we were required in the specific plan to put in
4:28:21 A changing area so that people who ride their bicycles can get cleaned up before they go to work. We have created a pedestrian environment on this site, which has got to be what MLTPA likes to see, and we are intending to induce that pedestrian environment throughout Old Mammoth Road and the community. And moreover, MLTPA is about recreation. Jim has strived to make this the center of recreation in Old Mammoth.
4:28:51 The recreation dollars that are being spent on this site are a large percentage of that $26 million. Those plazas are focused on recreation, all of them. The pedestrian walkways, the streetfront commercial, that's all recreation. It may not be trails to the backcountry, but it is no less valuable in terms of recreation. And on this site, at this location, keep in mind your general plan says this site is...
4:29:20 Within the mixed-use district of this community. And we do not have a mixed-use project thus far in our mixed-use district. This would be the first. So we're focused on all of the general plan goals that we're trying to meet. We think we've done everything we possibly can to meet all of those goals. And we think we're at a pretty good place right now. And we're a little bit concerned about
4:29:47 Any kind of wholesale revision at this late stage, it would essentially force us to go back to the drawing board completely. Not only with the design, but with the programming. And I can't speak for Jen on this topic, but I would be surprised if he would be willing to scrap what we've worked for for the past year. Well, you may not... I'm not saying you're saying the word scrap. No, no. But effectively, if we were to say...
4:30:16 John, let's reduce the size of this parking garage. I can just imagine the ripple effects that it would have on his planning efforts. So I'll let him speak to that. But I think we're, first of all, we don't see the problem, because the problem is visual impacts. And they're not visual impacts from private residences. There's no right to private views under California law.
4:30:46 The general plan speaks to public views, and we've shown that we've maintained those throughout this effort. And so, you know, we're happy and I think we've proven ourselves eager to solve problems and to improve the project along the way. We just don't see this measurement of the height from the podium as creating visual impacts that would be fairly characterized as a problem.
4:31:13 Okay. But that was the secondary issue for me, but it's a big issue out there. But in terms of, but if your primary goal would be to put, I'll let Les talk to what would, what he thinks would happen if we decided to move some of the parking down. Okay. A couple comments about your questions, Commissioner Denning. The recommended plan has 619 space, the demand. You're correct. Some of,
4:31:46 Jason's work from Nelson Nygaard had ranges below that. They had a range somewhere between 513 and 570. That's somewhere between 50 and 100 spaces less. And the way he got there was consideration of more walk-in demand, being satisfied by walk-in rather than parking, and again, the full sharing of the residential units.
4:32:14 in terms of the program. But let's just say for discussion's sake that we've pulled out 100 spaces out of that demand and we only need, let's say, 519. And it's possible down at the tavern site, as I understand it, talking to Peter, that 100 public spaces could be achieved there. They wouldn't be exclusive to
4:32:40 this Old Mammoth Place project, they would be public spaces, and certainly not as convenient, not likely that residents that are staying in the hotel would park down there, so that would be the retail or restaurant uses. It's within a reasonable walking distance, and I'm not saying it isn't. One of the key aspects of the specific plan is to have the retail parking be able to be self-parked.
4:33:09 Why is that important? That's a holdover from the specific plan and I think along the lines of thinking that those desiring to go to the retail establishments would some reason or other desire to be able to self-park. That's built into the plan that we have now. An area is in effect blocked off that we will be able to continually provide self-parking somewhere in the neighborhood of 80 spaces for the retail users.
4:33:38 That's a specific plan requirement. But stopping from there, I'm just saying let's say we could get 100 spaces down at the tavern lot. Again, those are public. I don't think that solves the problem, but I'll let John say if he had a parking garage that only had a 519 demand, would he be able to do anything with that? Commissioner, in response to your question, I think one fundamental question is if you were to take that garage and take 100 cars out of it, where would you take those cars?
4:34:15 In a way that would make sense, and what effect would that have? And assuming we want to continue to enter from the connector road and enter from the north, that's what's setting that, that's what's using that adjacent grade is what's setting that ramp and the entry to those elements, and that's where you would enter the garage. So even assuming we could or it was desirable to eliminate those hundred spaces,
4:34:44 You would then eliminate those naturally from the areas that are essentially away from that ramp and that entry point, which is essentially on the area from the south. You would contract the garage from the nether from the furthest points, if you will, in order to keep a continuous garage. And so that would mean basically pulling back along the south side of the site where we don't have any kind of height or...
4:35:13 issue, even a theoretical height issue. If we were to take 100 spaces out, you'd basically be taking two rows out in that direction, which would only get you back about halfway in the plaza area where we're talking about, for example, the temporary ice rink. So if you were to contract that garage back, it would be logically done in an area that wouldn't really change the podium height where the question of the height issue has come up.
4:35:40 And it would then, in my opinion, not allow us to really gain any additional stepping because all of the parameters are being driven by the adjacent grades along the connector road. So we're taking out 100 spaces, save you $4 million? I can't, the money issue, underground parking is incredibly expensive. I know. It's $40,000 installed. So that's $4 million. Did you have some other questions regarding parking?
4:36:10 I don't think so. Yes, I did. I remember. Just a follow-up. Peter, yes. Thank you. Essentially, the garage that actually you're proposing is a 450 space garage, not a 619 space garage. The additional spaces are achieved through the valet parking problem. The reason that the specific plan was laid out like it was was just to make sure that it's not under parked.
4:36:36 And they don't want to be under parked either. And we agreed that the 619 spaces that they proposed was a reasonable parking with the shared parking program. Without the shared parking program, the project would have demanded 729 spaces. So there is a fair reduction from what would be required without any sharing through our existing ordinances in the specific plan that allowed the 619 number. But the actual garage is only, if you're looking at 40 or 50 or...
4:37:05 Whatever the number is, dollars per space, it's a 450 space garage, not a 619. But the comment that troubled me in the staff report was that Mammoth isn't ready for this at this time, and I'm thinking to myself, two years after the general plan is adopted, which absolutely focuses on feet first, and that's what we're trying to do, and for a project that maybe in five years, market conditions will indicate you can make a go of it, but a vesting tentative tract map can be renewed up to ten years.
4:37:33 And so to put this kind of plan in, already there are things in the specific plan, that if I had seen this project as it's designed, I think, you know, I would have looked at the specific plan differently. And I just wonder if we're thinking far enough ahead, getting outside the box, and I'm also very concerned about the money being spent on parking cars. And that just, that really troubles me. Part of the issue, you know, is the development agreement, the village provided no parking.
4:38:00 That no parking was required for the commercial space up there or any skiing. So, you know, we don't want to have a case. That was the reason for having enough space in the parking garage for all of the units because we want people to come to town and stay there and then use transit, not drive around. So there's limited, you know, there should be hopefully a limited number of people that use their car during the day and aren't using transit.
4:38:26 So those cars will be there throughout the period that they're at their stay. Now there is airline service that's going to change maybe the mix over time, but the investing tentative map approval is today, not... Well, based on what I read, I thought valet parking for the whole thing was a great idea, but apparently, since it says that in a specific plan, it has to be self-parked, and I just, I'm not so much in favor of that now. One last comment. We should also remember the two of us with the construction costs today.
4:38:57 It's going to be a lot different 10 years from now. I know. Approvals today are one thing. So things can change when they come back for extensions or for the use permit stage. Maybe they won't want such a big parking garage. One last comment in regards to parking. The concept of moving parking off-site is really an in lieu of fee contribution, and that's one of the mechanisms that is allowed through the code and the specific plan. And traditionally, when you move parking off,
4:39:25 You accept a lower fee because the developer doesn't have the secured rights and investment, if you will, from building that parking. The parking is not exclusive to that developer any longer. It becomes a public space and a public pool. And so the idea is that it might cost $40,000 on site, but you only take a portion of those construction costs and put them off site because you're sharing it with others. So if it did occur,
4:39:55 There might not be residual monies that flow from that to some for some other purpose. Okay. So my only other parking question is, is the ramp heated so that snow will melt off tires coming in? Yes. The ramp is heated. Okay. Thank you. That's my only other parking. And that will be noted for the record. Thank you. Sharon, you had some questions and then go to Jen. Just a couple of questions. 748 is required.
4:40:24 Peter, by code. Peter. 748 parking spaces are required by code. 7, if you, well our code does allow shared parking analysis, but if you did, if there was a non-shared parking analysis, it would be 728. 728. Yeah. Page 33 of your staff report.
4:40:51 So it's 728. 728. And then with sharing, 619 is what is required for the project, since they have a shared use project. And these are under structure parking at 20,000? Under structure parking, the numbers that we use in engineering is about 40,000 in space. Under structure parking might be 20. I'd actually...
4:41:23 According to what I read in here, underground was 40, under structure was 20. And then surface lot's about half of that, so about 10,000 spaces. Okay, and I thought surface was 5. I got this out of here. What have we saved? And this would go then to the project, what have we saved because we are not doing underground? When this project started, I thought we were going to carve out
4:41:53 The corner that was high, and so that it would all be at, you know, underground. The parking is underground. By definition. The code defines underground parking. It is underground. But in fact, it is not. I mean, it is not that costly, is it? What you're doing now, is that not a change? This is what is considered to be at the very high end of what the underground parking would cost. We're talking about
4:42:24 What we've proposed is fully underground parking. We've carved out the whole corner. You've carved out two feet? No, no, no. That is the area where the podium is minus two feet. The garage then goes down another, with the structure, another about 11 1⁄2, 12 feet from there. So we're carving out about 14, 15 feet from that. That whole corner is excavated by 15 feet. In fact, the excavation continues.
4:42:53 All the way out through as we continue to slope down. It would have to continue to excavate? I thought the other end was only, the variation was 15. The worst point relative to natural grade is 9 foot 6 below the parking podium or roof. The parking section is about 12 to 13 feet. So even in that kind of worst
4:43:23 So the parking is 70% underground. It is $40,000 per stall.
4:43:54 Type of design and layout, definitely. So it's H-A-20. But if the variation is 15, I've heard 15 to 18 to 20, now today it's 19, variation between the corner, north, west corner, and south, east corner. The variation of the 19 foot is from the very far corner of the site to the low corner of the site, which is actually here on the parking garage.
4:44:32 The Delta is slightly less because the parking garage is not at the extreme corners of the site. So on the parking garage, the parking garage clinic, or podium, you've set an elevation of 58. And that is based on the adjacent grade that occurs at Laurel Mountain and adjacent to the hotel entry. Set at 58? 68, 58. The elevation is... Okay. Or 78. And for example, along...
4:45:03 Old Namath Road, for example, the grades range from 41 roughly up to about 48, 49. I keep comparing this to when we built our house, and our grade was 45, so we had quite a bit to do to get it to code in this town, which is 35 feet on each corner. So that, of course, is what I thought you were going to do with this project, but that didn't happen, and now I'm trying to
4:45:35 Understand what we're doing. We are doing exactly that. We're completely compressing the podiums into the ground at the north and west. It's fully underground. And then because of the site slopes, that podium in theory would begin to daylight because of the natural slopes across the grave.
4:46:03 I think, you know, maybe I can try to help clarify this. It's a very large site, and typically in development, because this site is so large, you don't see a lot of parking structures that are this large in there. And on the west and north sites,
4:46:26 North edges of the site, there's extensive excavation and grading that has to occur, and there's less extensive excavation that has to occur on the east and then the southeast corners. But in all cases, there's some level of excavation. And, you know, I think one of the ideas out there is that because this garage is not being, you know, dug to some fantastic depth, that we're being cheated.
4:46:54 And, you know, it's not completely underground. Our code does describe what is an underground or what isn't an underground structure. And from the financial aspect of it, there is a tremendous amount of grading to go on. And not only uniquely to this particular site plan, but if we had an alternate site plan, there would be extensive grading. And so when we look at it from the...
4:47:18 The definition of our zoning code, it is underground, and we make that determination because the laws and the rules tell us that. From the aspect of the incentive zoning picture, we ask ourselves that same question, but we ask it in a slightly different way. Yes, indeed, it's underground. And then the secondary question through the incentive zoning analysis is to what extent does the magnitude of that underground parking
4:47:48 Deserve some valuation to giving of an incentive, whether it's density or some other form. And I think in the composite look, which is the appropriate way to look at the whole project, we're able to say that the scope of the cost, the magnitude of the project, not only by parking, but the other amenities, that this looks like a reasonable incentive package.
4:48:18 I think you have a couple of questions on the table about, you know, one, what really is underground parking, and then two, how does it relate to incentive zoning? And embedded in, I think, your discussions in the Commissioners and Tunney's ideas about how we view this and are we getting reasonable or even the best alternative out of this design? We've worked a lot on this project, as you know.
4:48:47 As has the applicant and everybody else. And I think a very good way for us as staff to explain what you have in front of you is a careful design. This is a large site with extensive grain change across the site. And the architectural team has had to balance a number of competing objectives. Story height.
4:49:15 Is the intent of this project meeting the number of the levels of stories that were anticipated? And you well know that the zoning envelope was pyramidal, so we wanted lower levels of development on the edges with moving density up towards the middle. And we asked ourselves, did they do that? And we said yes.
4:49:40 You also, through that zoning envelope, said you didn't want a flat box. One of the fundamental issues discussed throughout this entire process from the very first presentations is you didn't want the flat pancake that was allowed through the C2 zone. A 35 foot with a 10 foot exception flat and not volumetric. They have done that.
4:50:08 The aspect of putting building height, the lower mass along the edges, was to be respectful of neighbors and to allow as much sun access, view corridor, and vista as possible, and they have done that. A challenge in looking at different siting options is when you look at the hotel element, it is a larger building, and it's designed as an integral building, so it's one building, and it's in a U shape.
4:50:38 And we all know that form follows parking. And so this whole project is designed to integrate the buildings. And you'll note that there's, in a sense, three different buildings. The hotel, the eastern building elements, and then the western building elements. They're all separate. So they've had to deal with building separation and also having a hotel.
4:51:01 that functions vertically and horizontally and is structurally integrated with the parking structure design. So they've had to contend with that. The compatibility with neighbors is important in that it would be difficult to shift the hotel elements to one other side or the other. That, one, it would be in conflict with the building envelopes and we'd start to see
4:51:29 A more dramatically stepped hotel component, which would start to suggest there would be multiple different separated elevator vertical equipment rooms and simply not efficient construction. In terms of the architectural design, you've already seen and heard the presentations about that design review and you have your own opinions about that. The site circulation.
4:51:58 When we look at different garage configurations, one alternative is this, a large podium of parking. Another alternative would be to break the block up into either two halves, either an east-west circulation system or a north-south circulation system, which would tend to cause parking to go farther and farther underground.
4:52:21 which is just more cost, and it would be less effective because we'd have more and different circulation points, and we'd also have more curb cuts. One of the compelling aspects of this design from this design is that the buildings have been massed to the center and massed to the northern portions of the site where there are dramatically lower impacts on surrounding neighbors.
4:52:46 With the open areas to the southern aspect, it's more open, it's more sunny, and as a result of the last presentation, I believe the loading lamps to the restaurant have been modified as well. So this is pretty graceful in terms of how it responds to its adjacent surrounding residential neighborhood uses. That includes delivery and access to the commercial portions of this building.
4:53:18 So, thinking of all of that, which is an awful lot, and composing it to something that actually fits the regulations as well, is somewhat of an artful process. That's why they're architects. There's somehow arts in there. And we've thought about this. We've asked ourselves, in fact, our very first conversations with this early applicant was, no, you should carve this up into four discrete building paths.
4:53:47 And the blocks would be actually pretty small and difficult to build on, about 230 feet by 230 feet or so, which is much smaller than most urbanized downtown grids. And so our response to that was to include and incorporate the mid-block connectors. And this design is much more graceful, much more effective and efficient and pleasing than this first design that you all saw.
4:54:17 I think it's a very difficult challenge for you as a commission to put all of those things together and then adjudicate that composite piece of architecture and program that remains financially feasible. As we've said before, the challenge in dealing with the program and cost implications is that there's a finite amount of cost.
4:54:47 That a project can bear. And you've got two financial analysts telling you that this is right at the edge in the threshold if and when the market returns. So, you know, on the staff side, we're not suggesting that, you know, you can't make changes, but it would be very difficult for us to make significant improvements upon this because of all the factors that have had to be weighed to get to this particular.
4:55:14 Model, Diagram, and Program. One thing I want to bring out for the commission's benefit for those of you, sorry, if you have not looked at this online, Sharon, I think I found the best, one of the best illustrations of this was in HA 16. It shows the, it shows the entire cross section from Old Mammoth Road to Laurel Mountain Road. It shows the grade.
4:55:45 It shows underground parking there, and that one probably illustrates issues that others have looked at, and the next three pages are good, but it's HA-16. That helps to see where the natural grade starts, how much you have to excavate by the time you get to Laurel Mountain Road, and then the subsequent pages also show underground parking.
4:56:14 And where the existing grade is and where the podiums and how that changes. Go back up, yeah, the 16, I think. With the volumes of information, it's hard to remember where you saw all of this, but you do remember seeing it, just identifying it quickly. Especially this computer, for whatever reason, is very slow to upload these. It's a lot. It's a lot, but... That's mammoth time.
4:56:48 Does that help, Sharon? Oh, yeah, it does. Thanks. It's just finding them again after we've seen them once. You begin to think you dreamt it, but I knew it was there for seeing it. That's it. So at that point, you see that on the right is, excuse me, on the left is Old Mammoth Road, and there is, for those of the audience that can't see, there is a green line.
4:57:49 That represents the grade and I don't have a point. Thank you. You're close enough to actually see that green line as well. That represents the grade and crossing that grade is the underground parking. It's that block. Helen, if you could highlight that block that they're seeing there is the underground parking. And the building actually sits on top of that to where it is just two feet below.
4:58:17 The existing grade when you get all the way to the right on Laurel Mountain Road. That helps to illustrate what you're talking about. That is number... It's HA16. That one's 16. The one that I guess I'm more curious in is HA14. Uh-huh. Because I wanted to see it from Old Mammoth Road. So now if you look at Old Mammoth Road and from the page of HA16,
4:58:47 You would be able to see that part of it starts, the parking building would start just behind those buildings and then it graduates down as the great shifts and the excavations all the way to Sierra Nevada. To Sierra Nevada. Yeah. It's a little bit more. There was, according to the HA-16 parking under the retail?
4:59:20 I don't think it's actually, under, it just backs right up to the retail. So they're at a different level. The retail is at a different level. That's correct. It just backs up to it. It backs up to it. So we don't park under retail. Under the retail. You do park under the market retail, but the market, the retail is fronting Old Manic Road. So the retail is really at grade, which is...
4:59:51 Point of information, since this is streaming, what is the public seeing on their computers? Are they seeing that image or are they looking at that with all the heads? They're seeing you as well as the staff. But when they look at things on the screen, are they seeing what's up there on the monitor?
5:00:19 They should see everybody in the screen behind them, but they probably not see it very well because you have a light on them. So they don't see this image on them. There's no dedicated window for the screen. So they're not seeing that image on them. No, there's no dedicated window there now for the screen. Oh, okay. That's the next level of technology. That's the next round of public comment letters. As soon as we figure out how to do this one, we'll upgrade as soon as we can learn something. John, if you could take us to AHA's...
5:00:49 14, I think that's where we were, yes, the connector road, is that the, I think you said you were taking out 15 feet? Yes, what you can see, the blue line is representing the podium height, the green line is representing the existing grade. Now that's a different section cut.
5:01:14 And so you can see that basically where you have the connector road, where you're seeing the dark gray, you see we've excavated all the way down for that. And you can also see that our garage floor slopes because we wanted to be sensitive to the gray and be able to then step the garage down again to really mitigate the impact. Our goal, and I think we've been successful, has been to make the parking garage absolutely invisible.
5:01:41 Well, but you don't step, it's not in HA14, it's not step down. Maybe it is. The green line is. Yes, you actually do, where you see that series of vertical dimensions, you actually will see a step down. This is the garage itself, the garage floor. Yeah. Thank you. So, Commissioner Clark, right here is where that, you see the parking podium comes along. The podium, yes. And then it steps.
5:02:12 So that it's following the natural slope of the property. The bottom of the garage, though, is that bottom line. Correct. And it is also sloping at 4%. And this slope's right here. Absolutely. Right. The garage. Do we have any other questions on parking at this time? I was going to ask about surface parking by retail. How many spaces, Peter? Do we know that yet?
5:02:42 I think there's about 10 spaces, and then there's also the transit stop that also stays there. So 10 spaces. On the front. On O'Mammoth. On O'Mammoth. And there's nothing else anywhere. Yeah, there's some additional parking on Sierra Nevada. Oh, there is. It just didn't show anywhere, and so they'll all be parallel, not tow-in. They're all parallel. I think there's a total of, isn't there, 29 spaces all the way around?
5:03:14 The project. So there'll be on Sierra Nevada and? Correct. Oh, Mammoth. So Peter, you're recommending 619 spaces underground. Yeah, underground. Underground. And those, so that actually parks the project and the spaces that are along the street are public parking. In addition to that, they serve as the operational snow storage when we're going to be trucking snow in this vicinity. So it's a dual purpose.
5:03:43 And the benefit is that there's some additional public parking in the vicinity that's not 24-hour parking, just daytime parking. Will they be metered? Currently they wouldn't be metered in the long term. The town could have a paid parking system. Well, if they're not metered, they'll be used all day. Yeah, yeah.
5:04:07 We could act, you know, there could be a time limit, a time limit, a time limit, a time limit, somewhere like the village houses, a two hour parking, and that takes human, that takes, labor, that takes our parking enforcement officers to enforce that. Was there any interest in a district, a parking district, annexed into a parking district for the hundred, little over a hundred spaces we're not having by code?
5:04:37 Well, there isn't because we were able to meet the demand within the structure. With the valet parking. Right. But the one thing that is needed in this area is parking. And in our sticky dot survey that we did, the one thing the community wanted was parking. And that's why I would be very, very interested in...
5:05:03 Some sort of district annexed into a parking district. There is a condition for if they end up being short their parking demand. So the parking requirement is 619 for the project. But that's dependent on valet parking. On valet parking, which is, you know, the parking code allows that for this district, for this specific plan area. So they're meeting the demand on site. If, for instance,
5:05:32 Long term, they're able to show that they can actually provide 700 plus spaces. Then actually there's an opportunity maybe for the town to participate in that facility to provide additional public parking within their facility through a district. But their project is meeting the parking demand. According to the specific plan. Yes. But not the general plan. No, that's not correct. So the general plan gives us.
5:06:00 Rod standards, but it relies on the zoning code to set the parking requirements for each specific area. So this study documents that we feel that they meet the zoning code, in this case established by the specific plan, they meet the demand on site. To the extent that they or some other future owner wants to join an assessment district to pay for parking, they could do that, but we're not suggesting that that is tied to the approval.
5:06:28 of this particular project. In the event, in the future, that they wish to reduce their on-site parking demand further, they could enter into an in-lieu of fee program to participate in an off-site structure. I think the tool that you're speaking to is either an assessment district or an in-lieu of fee option, but the in-lieu of fee option is an alternative to satisfying parking on-site.
5:06:57 And we feel through these studies they satisfy their on-site parking demand. Thank you. No further questions. Thanks, Sarah. Jay, do you have any additional questions? Some of you have any additional questions regarding parking. Thank you. Next, let's, if we can move on to, if anyone has any questions regarding
5:07:21 Design or functionality. Let's look at that. We'll kind of take some of the high-end points that we've looked at and then if we've missed anything, anybody's questions, then we'll obviously go back. Elizabeth, do you have to start? I was pleased to hear that good news about geothermal. When are you going to drill a test well? Well, actually, we have done some research in that and there is a lot of brick paperwork and I've talked to the...
5:07:50 Members of the Water Department and things like that to hear about what's been happening in the vicinity. So I think that my goal actually is going to be interesting because, you know, the economy, we're not sure the timeline for moving forward with the larger project, but I've always toyed with the idea, wouldn't it be fun to build a spa on the current property? So, you know, it might be much sooner and I'd love to be able to use natural hot spring water underneath the property to provide some...
5:08:19 Some nice soaking tubs. So, you know, sooner rather than later. Good, okay. What we need to do actually is come up with an ordinance that will allow for it to happen in the town of Mammoth Lakes. Drilling for geothermal? We do have to. An ordinance? Yeah. Add that to the list. That's a good point. The connector street, I've got real problems about. Where's John? Is he here?
5:08:48 Oh, okay. But this is a John question, I think. I'll skip that for a second. Well, the next one's a John question. Oh, the delivery trucks. I'll ask you this one. The last thing we want is what we have at the village, which is, you know, parking out in the middle of Minaret Road while you make the deliveries, and the loading dock is gathering dust, which, you know, was carefully planned. How do the delivery trucks that deliver...
5:09:17 You know, goods to the retail, how do they exit the garage? Exit the garage right up the ramp. They just make a full circle? That's how it would be? I think there's some height clearance limitations. That's only limited height vehicles, obviously. You're talking about the loading dock. I think I have to turn around to come out. You're talking about the loading dock over on Lorraine. No, I'm talking about delivery trucks that go in behind the old Mammoth Road retail through the parking garage entrance. How do they get out?
5:09:49 We're going to need John Nancy, of course. Okay. Because I'm not, the loading dock, there's one loading area over our floor mountain. Yeah, I know about that. They've moved over there, so you're not referring to that one. No, I'm referring to that. And the vertical clearance. UPS, delivering to the retail. Right. The parking garage doesn't have any excessive vertical clearance. It's got like a nine-foot clearance, I think it is.
5:10:12 Nothing like that. John's here now. John's here now. We'll leave your vehicle. Sure. Thank you. We have, based on, based on some of the comments that had come up previously, we really rethought and reworked the loading altogether. And we, what we, what we've done in a nutshell is we've basically been able to tie all of the parking through the park, or sorry, all of the delivery through the loading dock on Laurel Mountain and then down through the parking.
5:10:41 Garage. So for a large scale truck, obviously like a Cisco truck or even a UPS truck that has extra height to it, they would be using the loading dock at Laurel Mountain. Now say they are trying to get the package to one of the retailers or one of the restaurants. We have now set it up so that there's a lift that would take you from that loading dock level directly down to the garage so that things could be very easily transferred over.
5:11:10 For the restaurant that is facing Sierra Nevada, we've eliminated that loading dock location and eliminated that curb cut. The small vans that primarily can service restaurants would come in through the parking garage. That would just be a regular van size. We've created a dedicated, and I can show you those slides. I do have them with me if folks are interested. No, just in general. I'm just curious. So folks would be able to come in, and we've set up a dedicated loading dock.
5:11:40 For that restaurant in the garage with its own vertical circulation so that smaller goods and things could come in at that location and the trash would come out at that location as well. Anything larger again could come in at the Laurel Mountain Dock and drop down to the garage and be transferred over. Okay, because the current two problems we have in Mammoth, we have lots of problems, but these are two problems, is we have semis parking in the middle of the street.
5:12:07 Across, right across. Which we don't want to have happen. With forklifts making deliveries. And then we also have on Minaret by the village, we have the semis, they don't want to bother to drive around to the loading dock and reverse, you know, to back up. And so they park in the street and it's the driver in the hand truck and it's horrible. And so I just wanted to be sure we were avoiding that. So our general strategy is for semis and bigger trucks, we have got the two loading dock locations off of Laurel Mountain. For smaller vans and smaller deliveries, they can use the parking garage. Okay, that answers those questions. One more thing, Elizabeth.
5:12:36 We're also proposing a new condition which would be consistent with the specific plan that they would need to prepare a delivery management plan. Oh, good. And also trash management in terms of trash pickup? Yeah, there's another separate condition for that. Oh, okay. The other thing about the project and the current configuration of Old Mammoth Place is it is a...
5:13:01 So it's a two-lane road, the full distance, but part of it's one way. That short section that's about 80 to 90 feet long would provide additional space for a loading zone for those trucks that occur like at the village or across the street at... You mean if they're too big to go in the garage? Yeah, because we don't have that many deliveries that are made with smaller vans. Most of the trucks are more like the UPS size or bigger. And a five-star hotel is okay with that at their gateway entrance?
5:13:30 That's just one configuration that I saw. Okay. We don't want them in the middle of the old mammoth road. Exactly. So the condition also would include, in no case, shelves, delivery vehicles, NP traffic flow. Okay. Okay, another issue, now that you're back, John, I still have trouble with this connector street, specifically with reference to tour buses. We used to have lots of tour buses filled with Europeans spending money, and they would come from Yosemite, come over here, go to Grand Canyon.
5:13:57 And the loading and unloading, and you have the two lanes and the beautiful landscaping, but there's no pullouts for those tour buses while they're loading and unloading. And I think that's a critical issue that needs to be addressed. So you don't have to address it now. I'm just telling you that's an issue I have. I thought I saw that on Royal Mountain Road. No, that's the loading. I'm talking about loading and unloading people. Yeah, that's what it is. I interpret that to be as well as that.
5:14:25 That would be like access to the bus entrance. No, what we had proposed off of Lower Mount was overnight bus parking using the loading dock spaces as part of that delivery management plan. And that's where we were also proposing to put the recharging stations for the buses. In terms of the pull-off, we've talked about two concepts. One is kind of, it's a little hard to see in this diagram, but there's a space between the
5:14:53 The buildings facing Laurel Mountain and the hotel. And that was the area where we felt the tour bus could pull off out of the way for unloading. Describe that location again, facing Laurel Mountain. Right here. So the bus would be able to pull right into there. I thought that was a Zen garden.
5:15:16 Zen Garden is up in three years. Those guests would appreciate it. Okay, but you understand the issue because I would hope that conferences will be put together and buses will come from Reno filled with participants or from LA and they get here and it's going to be a really nice motor coach, a really nice arrival and you don't want them at the loading dock. And John, the UPS truck will be able to get in from the
5:15:45 Old Mammoth Road entrance to the garage or not? A UPS truck is probably a little tall. We have nine foot clear, which is... Oh, only nine foot. Nine foot clear. So I think a UPS truck is probably realistically... It's going to come in the other one. Okay. Okay, continuing with design and functionality, and needless to say, these are most of my questions. I notice that the convention center is two levels high because on the floor plan you show open to below. Why are you using that space for conventions when, I mean, we have nice...
5:16:14 Grand Sierra is very successful, although it's too small, but for a conference center, why is it two stories high? A conference center, a traditional conference center is typically about 5,000 square feet and is typically unencumbered with any columns because you want to have a large space that has a lot of flexibility and particularly that has state-of-the-art AV and ability for lighting and a variety of different components. A 5,000 square foot ballroom
5:16:41 If you can think about it in plan, it's roughly 50 by 100. So if you think of a ceiling, that's a very big room. If you had a ceiling that is one story, say 10 or 12 feet, it feels incredibly compressed like a pancake. And it also doesn't allow for state-of-the-art AV presentations, for conferences to come in and set up booths with their requirements for booth heights and lightings.
5:17:11 So the standard within the industry for any kind of conference size, for any conference facility of any size is 22 feet, typically of ceiling space. And it's a function of not only the AV and the requirements for exhibits and different kinds of events, but it's also the proportion of the room, is to have enough height to go along with the giant size. How wide is the 100 feet? Again, a 5,000 square foot ballroom is 50 by 100. Okay.
5:17:39 So, you know, if you had a 10-foot ceiling in a 100-foot long room, you really feel like you're in a pancake. Call it a bowling alley. A bowling alley. So, it's essentially that you really need that for AV, for HVAC, to get your additional girders in to get the column-free space, as well as displays, as well as just the visual proportion of the room. And column-free space, you can't hold up the floor above it, so there you are. Okay. Next question, Peter.
5:18:08 It said that public works can't require sidewalks, widening, transit stops, etc. Didn't we require that for the village on canyon? What was the deal there? Can you remind me of that? That was years ago when they did the canyon reorientation. Where does it say that? No, for widening the right-of-way. It says public works can't require sidewalks. Oh, as far as community benefit. Yeah, generally, you know,
5:18:39 We've got adopted standards for projects. And so in the village, actually, they built the sidewalks to the standard at the time, which was six feet. And that's currently our standard, except for Main Street. So the sidewalks that are actually public sidewalks in the village area are just six feet. And the remainder are really part of the plaza easement. And some of those become encumbered with different seating for the restaurants and that kind of thing. So the public space is really just that six feet.
5:19:07 That answers it. In this case, it's going to be wider, you know, 10 to 12 feet. Okay. Okay. I'm so glad you got rid of that loading dock door at the front of your project, and I hope you'll take advantage of that unobstructed southern exposure and not just make that a wall. I mean, it's got all kinds of potential there, so that was a good thing to do. Let's see here. Oh, the master sign plan, are you planning on...
5:19:33 Well, usually we wait for a master sign plan after the project, but it's such an important, as we discussed at ADP, such an important design element. Are you planning on coming back when you come back to ADP with your sign plan? Let me ask you to ask Jim. Or ask Dana. Hadn't planned on coming back with a sign plan at a design development stage? Yeah. No, that's one of the requirements. You know, the 50% design development, you come back to ADP.
5:20:04 Design should be part of that. Okay. Again, we agree that signage is really important to this project to create that icon component, so yes, we would be bringing that. Okay, good. And I think we've already talked about more natural appearing landscape and hardscape, which I think is really, really important that what you have there is too urban. And my last thing in the staff report, it says you've already got 62 points toward LEED Gold, and why are we even talking about silver? Why don't we just say LEED Gold? I mean...
5:20:33 You know, LEED certified is the California Green Building Code, so why not say gold? Because you've already got, you've just got everything lined up. The, the, kind of the fortunate or unfortunate thing about the LEED process is, you know, I know it's problems. You never really know what you got until it is. You got it. You're done. So even though we're scoring that right now, they, they could, for example, disagree with some of the scoring, or they could change the rules, which is actually happening quite regularly. Okay.
5:21:03 It's sort of the concept, you know, it isn't so much the rating as it is the concept of it. Yes, Commissioner, one thing that's interesting to me about this particular opportunity, and some of you have heard me talk about it before, but if we do indeed find water under the property that is of an appropriate temperature, we can go straight to Platinum. I know you can, I can't wait. And that would be, I think, great for Mammoth, great for the country, and great for the
5:21:34 Occupants, everybody involved. So that's actually the goal, just so you know. And that's part of the intent is to move forward with the process that we can actually do some drilling underground and see what we find. I have a question. Excuse me, just to follow up on that. There's a condition of approval that requires them to get LEED Silver. I know. Why don't we, in addition to that,
5:22:02 Strongly encourage them to pursue lead platinum. Yeah, why gold? Let's go for platinum. Okay. We don't want high. Doesn't make it a requirement, just lets our sentence. Yeah, the highest possible. Okay, my last functionality question is construction management, and this is condition 136. Would it be possible, and I don't see why it wouldn't, since you're going to be under construction for three years, to put in about 10 feet of your streetscape on Old Mammoth Road and then have
5:22:30 A really nice fence, you know, with a mural or something, a little peephole and that kind of stuff, but not just have it be what's existing in your construction fence, have that 10 feet be the promise for what we're going to get. On the rest of the site, you know, Chainlink or whatever, but there on Old Mammoth Road, where we're getting a lot of foot traffic, a lot of bicycle traffic, it'd be really nice to have that first 10 feet. I can't see how that would get damaged in construction because everything would be happening behind the fence. That seems reasonable. Yeah, I mean, I think it would be nice.
5:22:59 Okay, all my functionality questions. Thank you. Thank you. Jay, do you have any questions along this line? I guess I do have a couple of questions. How much would it hurt if you actually built to the height that we started with 35 feet along Old Mammoth and Laurel Mountain? What would it do to the project? I guess that's John since they're architectural. Sure.
5:23:29 Well, Commissioner Clark, I think the rationale for the request for accommodation along Old Mammoth Road is that we've really been trying to create, as part of the Clearwater Specific Plan, as you know, there's an allowance for a request for an accommodation if collectively everyone feels that it enriches the visual
5:23:57 Peel of the architecture, creates additional variety, improves the overall mass and relationships. We felt given the length of that facade and our desire to really give it as much depth and character and variety as possible, we wanted to really give the town as much variety and as great architecture as we could within that 35 foot height limit in the allowable accommodation.
5:24:24 We've got the two-story piece at the corner. We've got a lot of ins and outs. We've got as much up and downs as we can get. In order to get a little bit more variety, we wanted to come back and ask for that accommodation because we thought it was a win-win for everybody. So along those sites, could we accommodate the strict 35-foot level? The answer is yes. We would end up with a much flatter, more continuous,
5:24:52 And if I dare say monotonous facade. But could it be accomplished? Yes, it could be accomplished. So because it was available, you asked for it. Is that what I'm hearing you say? I mean, you knew that 35 feet was what you were supposed to do. It was not because we wanted to. It was because it was available. It was because we felt that it was something that was allowable for consideration if it...
5:25:24 improved the aesthetic and massing, the aesthetics and the massing of the architecture, which we feel it does. But you were asked to do that and the ADP asked you to come up with some of these things. In conjunction, I mean, we really worked hard through our own internal works as well as with ADP and with staff to really try to create as much richness and variety to those facades as possible through a combination of massing shifts.
5:25:52 Yes, that's what I said. Could you do it within 35 years? No, that might not have been acceptable because it was
5:26:22 Boring. Right. But could you have done the architectural appurtenances in the 35 feet? We couldn't have done the variety. You would have pretty much ended up with just a flat roof. Well, that's not very architecturally inviting. No, it's not. But I guess what I'm saying is I wish you could have done it in the 35 feet, the architectural design.
5:26:45 Right. But once you consider a 15-foot floor retail, which is what you need for retail, and the three levels of... I'm not an architect. I just think it's possible to do it within the 35 feet. That was one of the problems, Sharon. When 50 feet was proposed, it was like, on what floor do you put little people? You know, there is aluminum for the floor and the space between the floor for the, you know, all the heating, you know, HVAC stuff, and you'd have 15 feet for retail to start, so you just end up...
5:27:17 Chopping off a floor or having like a little space. Any other questions regarding design and functionality? No, that was kind of moving to the, she's talking about the adjustments, so. Okay. That was my next thing. Continue with your questions. Okay, so we're under height and mass. We can do that. Okay. Okay, I want to talk about the adjustment request a little bit, and the first thing I want to refer to is the plan sheet, HA,
5:27:47 25. And there's two parts to the adjustment request, or well, you could say three, but the architectural features that we were just talking about are these that you see in the top drawing there, they're on, that face the middle of Old Mammoth Road. And those, the adjustment request, I believe I'm correct, is for a maximum of 38 and a half feet.
5:28:19 Then in addition to that, the other two areas that apply to the adjustment request are at the southeast and southwest corners of the southeast corner of the project, Old Mammoth Road and Sierra, and the southwest corner, Laurel Mountain Road and Sierra. And so the first one of those is the roof you see at the left in that top drawing, and then the other one is at the bottom on the right.
5:28:47 Those two, if I understand this correctly, involve the, under the adjustment, would have a three and a half foot increase from 35 feet plus a two foot extension, assuming that those qualify as an impertinence. So for the first part of the adjustment, the middle part of old mammoth road, I think that's acceptable.
5:29:13 And one of the reasons that I do is if you refer to, get my numbers right here, HA2, you can see that the sight line with that 38.5 feet also goes right past the next building feature over the, is that the Paseo route? The marketplace. The marketplace. If you cut down that,
5:29:54 38 and a half feet to 35, it wouldn't make much difference in the sight line, because it goes right over that anyway. If you compare that to a sight line for the other one, which is HA5, on sheet HA5, there you see in the lower drawing the sight line for 4B, which is for the structure at the corner of Laurel Mountain in Sierra Nevada. And that one, at that 40 and a half feet, that is the defining structure that
5:30:26 raises that sight line. So however much you can lower that roof there, you're lowering that sight line a bit. There's nothing behind it that comes up that high. So there's two things that I would suggest you might want to work on that. One is that sight line, and the other is calling that roof or that even an impertinent bothers me a little bit too. I'm not sure if it's that definition. Let me explain why we're
5:30:55 We're proposing that as an appurtenance. It's really a function of two reasons. And I can also, I think, answer the aesthetic, because I think on balance our feeling was the aesthetic richness of a latticed heavy timber structure in that location outweighed another foot or foot and a half of height. Let me explain that. What we've proposed to do there is to, and this came,
5:31:18 from the comments and the collaborative working or relationship with staff and ADP was a real desire to really augment the heavy timber aspects that we had on the project and to add them in new locations as well. We already had some heavy timber at these locations, but we had to be kind of skimpy with it or modest with it, if you will, because of the height requirement. And so we basically had a very simple beam.
5:31:47 And then a column support, supporting that beam. As part of the language that we've proposed to develop, and you can see that as a series of kind of latticed and tiered heavy timber, we felt it was going to be much more architecturally interesting and rich to do what was traditionally done by Japanese architects was to really layer up or create a lattice work of heavy timber.
5:32:26 So in addition to your beam, you end up also with purlins and outriggers. And so by the time you add those additional purlins and outriggers, which adds that level of richness and that scalloped edge and really creates the filigree work against the skyline there, it raises the roof up that extra little bit. And we felt that because that was the equivalent of additional elements,
5:32:56 That related to the type of appurtenance or parapet type of element that would qualify as an appurtenance. So we were doing it for the aesthetics and the richness and the consistency overall and it was that layering that kind of pushed that height up. Now we can push it back down but we'd end up back where we started from which was a less rich architectural solution. Thank you. Yes.
5:33:28 Yes. A follow-up on Jay. Jay, also, when we did the village, the clock tower was considered an appurtenance because it was the architectural feature. And I think long, many, many years past, we've always looked at architectural features as being part of the appurtenances that we agree with. If it's structural, that doesn't disqualify it? No. No. It's more of, and Bill Taylor could you probably speak to if we wanted him to. We've always looked at architectural features as being appurtenances.
5:33:56 For the aesthetics of it. I had a question for staff, and with all due respect, I had passed a note earlier for them to find out. As we sat here, we've had these packets that we're going through in the past week or so, 10 days maybe, having all the questions about the way that we're measuring, and we've kept using Lodestar and Snow Creek and the Village. And it occurred to me while we were going through this process today that we actually have another place, and Bill, you may even be able to answer this.
5:34:25 And that's across the street at Sierra Center Mall. Sierra Center Mall starts at an elevation here on Meridian. It drops down to where we have that vacant lot next to it. And it has an underground parking structure. And the buildings are 35-foot buildings. So my question was, did we already set the precedents, as you're asking for, for measuring from the top of the podium? Because that's exactly what they have there. Because they have the understructure parking, the podium, and the two floors going up.
5:34:53 So, you know, we've been using Lode Star and everything else, and actually three floors going up. So I really think that, you know, if we can find that answer, we're going to find that we've actually done that same type of measurement in the past that you're asking for today. So I know we're still waiting for it. So that was my question for Rhonda, if we could come back to it when they have that answer from staff. Do we have any idea how far that podium is above ground at that?
5:35:18 Southern End? You know, and that's what we need to find out. I know if you've been in, I mean, most of the time you only go to Sierra Center Mall if you go into the court, so. Yeah. When you, except for the hot chicks. So when you pull into that underground structure, you're at a level and you drive down, you know, halfway through, you go to a lower area. So I really think that could actually give us the answer that we're looking for as to the measurement of top of podium.
5:35:45 Did you know, I had an image in my mind anyway that that building was built prior to the Townsend Corporation? It was, yeah. Okay. So it would be under county code? Yeah, we're going to find out. That's what they're searching for now. I guess my point is for everyone is that the measurement, that seems to be the rub of how we're going to measure and maybe just focus on what that looks like and how we're measuring and that would give you an idea of what we would be doing from top of the podium.
5:36:13 And if I could just point out that the nice thing about this is the podium never shows itself anywhere. So we had a lot of questions this morning, I believe we were able to ask those regarding height and things. So do we have anything else at this point? I can respond to your question earlier regarding the North Village Pacific plan and the 20-foot parking level. So we looked at the North Village Pacific plans and along
5:36:44 Canyon, it's about a 440 foot distance and a 20 foot grade differential, so it's about an 8% grade, and then compared to this project along the Connector Road, it's about a 460 foot distance with a 10 foot grade differential, which is about a 4% grade change, so they're requesting a 10 foot, about 10 feet height above grade for the parking, 9 feet, 9 and a half feet, so it is kind of comparable to the North Village Pacific Plan grade change.
5:37:14 For those of you that did not hear, we have a hard stop at 5 o'clock because the town council is reconvening tonight at 6 and they will pick this out to set up. So I want to make sure that we get to our questions. We have some time to deliberate. So these were some ones that people want to specifically look at. Sharon, do you have some other questions at this time that we have not covered? Well, when are we going to get to CBiz?
5:37:44 We can do that right now. And housing. And housing. And the trails. We're going to do it now. So you're up. Okay. I'm giving you the leeway to do that. I need to find a map that shows me the east-west and north-south pedestrian corridors through the site. I haven't seen that. Is there a... It is the site plan. I'll go ahead and put that up and I can explain that. Okay. I want to see that.
5:38:19 That's the first one. And should I go ahead and describe that now, Commissioner Clark? That'd be super. Okay. Boy, this is hard to see. Do I have that somewhere? Yes. That is the site plan. Oh, okay. It's L1.0. Say it again. L1.0.
5:38:48 Okay, there are all sorts of ways to be able to move through the site. Of course, just starting from the north side, we have this east-west connector in this location where we have the landscaped sidewalks, actually on both sides of the street. From the south side, you're able, of course, to walk north-south along Old North Road, of course.
5:39:16 You've got the Grove component here, which allows you to come up into the Commons and to move through the Marketplace and back out to the Connector Road. Or you can actually move through as a pedestrian and come out through the Paseo as well. You can actually do all sorts of figure eights or anything you'd like through here. Also from the Grove, you can move up to the Commons and move across.
5:39:43 This direction, so you can actually move north-south, you can move east-west along this plaza here, or let's say you're coming from the intersection of Laurel Mountain, Sierra Nevada, you can basically move through the site through this way, through the marketplace, or you can move through the site along this way, so there are a variety of ways you can move through the site diagonally, north-south, as well as east-west.
5:40:14 The hotel lobby circulation, which obviously is not fully public. Well, I guess it's public, but it's, you know, it's a hotel lobby. There is also, of course, the flowway all the way through the lobby, which occurs at this location, through the pool plaza, the river runs through it, out through the commons, and either towards the southwest or towards the southeast.
5:40:38 I guess when I read the Clearwater Specific Plan, it said any site plan that will utilize pathways and streamline pedestrian connectivity, at least one east-west and one north-south pedestrian connector is required to be included in the site design, and I just didn't ever see it, and I still don't. I mean, you're kind of diagonally in and out and under, you know, in buildings, but I guess I don't.
5:41:08 Think of those as connectors, but maybe they are. Did you want a straight sidewalk, like the connector road, which has a sidewalk on either side? I guess I didn't think about the edges. I somehow or another thought it would be through, but that takes care of my question. Thank you. Do you have anything else that you want to say? Oh, yeah. I, of course, I agree with Elizabeth that I have problems with the connector road being one way, but you say you're talking about that, thinking about it.
5:41:43 We would actually prefer it to be 2A. It's been designed so that it can be 2A. It would be much more useful to the community. Yes. Thank you. And housing, of course, I, even though you are only going, well, that gets into CBiz, so we're not ready for that yet. Thank you. Jay, do you have any other questions? Okay. Any other questions on this issue? Housing is my question.
5:42:17 Okay, then we'll take housing next and then we'll go to CVS. And if we haven't covered everything, we will find out. Housing, would you have to start? Okay, great. Ellen, I do not understand the condition in the staff report, how it relates to the Mammoth Lakes housing, both letters from them, how it relates to Walter Kieser's letter. I'm really confused because it sounds like units and rooms are being used interchangeably.
5:42:47 And the letter from the Housing Foundation refers to 27 units, and yet we talk about 28 FTEs fitting in 8 units. I'm really confused, perplexed by this. I need a lot of explanation. There's a couple of layers here, I guess. The staff report provides an analysis, both of the housing requirement relative to the existing municipal code,
5:43:18 Which is, as you know, is calculated in FTEs, and those FTEs are absorbed by a certain ratio of units and bedrooms, basically. So ultimately the FTE calculation is derived actually from commercial space as well as the hotel rooms.
5:43:40 And that's a square footage calculation. It has nothing to do with the number of hotel rooms or units if it's an FTEE base. If you're looking at the calculation basis for the recently adopted interim housing policy, which is an inclusionary requirement that says a percentage of the total units in the project need to be workforce housing units, that does rely on units.
5:44:08 And rooms as a calculation. The difficulty with the hotel project is it's rooms, however, the workforce housing is provided in terms of units. And so what we did was create an equivalence of unit equivalence to translate between units and rooms, similar to what we did in the POT analysis, and also looked at a total number of bedrooms. So based on the inclusionary housing requirement, you need to satisfy both the number of units and the total number of bedrooms.
5:44:38 In order to meet that requirement, if that makes sense. So in this case, I have to look at the tables, but both conditions need to be satisfied in terms of total bedrooms relating to total number of hotel rooms and units. But the inclusionary policy wasn't adopted until after 11-4, right, when the application was deemed complete? So what applies?
5:45:04 Well, in the staff report, what we say, and it's quite clear in the specific plan, that the code that applies is the code that was in place at the time that the application was received, which in this case was the existing municipal code, obviously well before the inclusionary housing policy was adopted. What we wanted to do, and I believe that Mammoth Lakes Housing agreed with this approach, is to say that yes, although by the letter of the specific plan they are required to
5:45:33 Comply with the Municipal Code. The Municipal Code permits, through submittal of an alternative housing mitigation plan, an alternate way to calculate your units, to satisfy your mitigation requirement, and so what we proposed was that at the discretion of the town that
5:45:52 An alternate housing mitigation plan could be proposed that would rely on those inclusionary housing standards because it's really a progressive thinking of the town on what those requirements ought to be. And the Mammoth Lakes Housing is in agreement with that approach, as I understand it. Okay. Somebody else have a question? Any questions? Any questions? How many people is that you're talking about housing? Well, eight three-bedroom units. Three-bedroom units.
5:46:23 That is the current proposal. You know, that might shift somewhat, but that's to generate, to satisfy 23 FTEs. Exactly. You would need to provide at least that or some other configuration of units and bedrooms. Okay. Thank you. So for the public, it's, you know, when we're talking about eight, we just have to remember that we're not talking about single units of living space. Eight. To put it very simply. Eight housing units with multiple bedrooms. Exactly. With multiple bedrooms. Yes. Thank you. And does it, excuse me. That would satisfy the 27 or 28.
5:46:52 At the FTE. Correct. 23 is required, and it satisfies 28, yes. And the project needs 378 employees, and you're going to put them in 8 bedrooms? That's not exactly how it works. There's a netting out of the existing uses on the site, so there is a relationship between that FTE calculation and employees, but it's not quite the way that you're suggesting.
5:47:19 I think in your packet you described which units, you know, there's a manager unit, there's on-site and things like that is required. Right. I've never seen any packet. Well, and it's part of our housing mitigation plans, which we have one of the strongest housing mitigation plans in the state of California and requirements. Okay. Thank you. How does that fit with the opinion from our special land use counsel, Kevin Ennis?
5:47:43 That CBiz is only a policy and it's not an ordinance yet and until the ordinance is changed then the municipal code is what applies. Correct. I got a lot of conflicting information on this. Dates of application, what applies, ordinance versus policy. It's pretty clear both through the specific plan and through the determination of our legal counsel that until such a time as the town makes amendments to our housing ordinance and our other fee.
5:48:11 fee ordinances that that that that ordinance does take precedence over the CBIS policy and so for that reason Mr. Ennis suggested a couple of amendments to the conditions that you see in your current staff report and I think I'm not sure which reflect that which which essentially
5:48:34 Add a condition relative to that change because in his opinion it's really the point at which the fees are determined and pay that is the timing by which he needs to satisfy and change that, sort of tie up that loose end in the code to bring those two things into consistency with one another. So right now there's an inconsistency between the CBIS policy and the municipal code because the municipal code hasn't been updated to reflect the CBIS policy. He says that needs to be amended.
5:49:02 And providing that that happens before the fees are calculated and paid for this project, that you as a body can approve this project with that understanding. What is the downside of requiring housing, you know, workforce housing in compliance with the code with the option that everybody has to come back with an alternate housing mitigation proposal at a later time?
5:49:28 If the policy's changed, if the applicant wants to be reconsidered, what's the downside of that? It doesn't preclude ultimately, if the council decides not to amend the municipal code to reflect the CBIS policy, then the applicant would be subject to the current municipal code requirement. And compare those side by side again in terms of what will be required, you know, the workforce housing units and so on.
5:49:54 The applicant has to comply with current code as compared to if the code is amended to coordinate with the policy change in the CBIS. So the worst case of the housing requirement would be that they would need to provide approximately 27 to 28 units on site? Regardless of how many rooms in the units.
5:50:21 Well, yeah, that could vary somewhat. That's assuming three-bedroom units as they propose now. That might change again depending on the configuration. The leased case is, I believe, five units. Page 32 was based on the inclusionary housing requirement and incorporating the CBiz exemption.
5:50:52 From the incentive density, five units, and then a small, an increment to be paid for in fees as a partial unit. And then there's under the inclusionary requirement and counting, sorry, not having the CBIS waiver, 12 units and then eight as we currently have. So depending on what
5:51:22 Whether or not you count the Inclusionary Housing Waiver for the CBIS policy, I'm sorry, the waiver for the CBIS policy, the FTE calculation or the Inclusionary Housing, it varies quite a bit from anywhere from 5 to 27 or 28 units. I'm getting more confused. She's giving you the range, so whatever happens with the ordinance, it's going to be within that range. And at that time, that's what we'll apply.
5:51:50 Has Peter Tracy seen this letter? We have copied Peter Tracy on all of this communication with Kevin Ennis, who is the town's legal counsel, so he's aware of these things and concurs with him. I guess I'd like to hear from Peter Tracy. You are hearing from Peter Tracy, because Peter Tracy authorizes us to work with Kevin Ennis, and so that's your legal opinion right there. Peter Tracy is our town attorney, but if we go out, he sends outs.
5:52:19 He farms out questions to other attorneys that specialize in that field. So he asked Kevin Namath to do this? Yes. Thank you. So he obviously concurs? Correct. Right. So let me add a different kind of answer to your question. The numbers and the choices are shown on Table 6, your type-written page 32 in the report. In the big book. Yeah, in your binders. In the staff report.
5:52:46 And ultimately, the net result of this, because what you see is some different outcomes that are contingent on future actions by the Council. And so the situation is the application was made when, you know, during the current housing ordinance, the Council has approved a policy direction to change our housing ordinance, and the CBIS policy
5:53:16 further modifies the ultimate program. So it includes housing modifications and it includes impact fee modifications as a result to the site plan. So the language that Kevin Ennis has suggested to make sure that all of these contingent issues are tied together and we modify some conditions specifying that
5:53:40 Like the DZA, the use permit, et cetera, and the investing tentative map would be contingent on these changes. Ultimately then, when we're looking into the future, if the housing ordinance remains the same and for whatever reason we don't change, then the site plan is what you see. It's a WYSIWYG. What you see is what you get.
5:54:03 Those units will either have to be incorporated on site within that envelope, within that parking program, or an alternative housing mitigation plan will have to be submitted that's providing some amount off site or through a fee. It could be some or all. And so that would be a future action for the Planning Commission, reviewed by Mammoth Lakes Housing, approved by the Planning Commission. And then to the extent that the
5:54:32 Codification of changes tying together the housing, the death, and the incentive zoning program occurs, as documented in this report, then what you see is really what you get. So you're not at risk in terms of policy. The policy decision that you have to make is when you're evaluating the total program, are you getting what you want?
5:54:57 And so the legal issues have been resolved, they've been identified, and they just need to occur. And that's the language that Covenant has provided you. And our recommendation will be subject to what prevails at the time. Right. So it takes, you know, for example, the council would have to approve the zoning amendment to achieve the height. If they didn't, something else will have to happen. The council will have to ultimately...
5:55:25 And regardless of this project, the council is going to have to amend the housing ordinance to implement the new housing policy. Is it appropriate for us to make a recommendation to council whether or not they should approve those changes to the policy? I think you could schedule that as a separate agenda item and it's not the subject of this permit. Okay. I have a question. Is on-site
5:55:55 Critical here? And the reason I ask that is I'm thinking once again about the blank stair site with the parking lot. A wonderful project was planned there. It's only half a block away. Is there any reason why the applicant couldn't participate in that project at a future date and not do the housing on site? I would say that that would be too specific of a condition. That site has a lot of baggage with it. It's purchased through federal money, through a Caltrans grant.
5:56:24 It may or may not work for housing. You saw one program you saw and you approved a use permit for the Tavern Road project. Was it perfect? No. Was it good? Yes, it seemed to work at the time. And I think that some of the work that you see coming down the pike through the downtown neighborhood district plan is it's showing you different housing sites, it's showing you a lot of different situations. And so if you had that kind of an interest, I don't think I'd tie it to a specific site.
5:56:54 Okay, but is on-site critical in our condition here? Does it have to be on-site? On-site housing? Yeah. No. Okay. This goes back to your policy change. The biggest thing you're doing is, first, you're looking at the overall program, you're looking at its design, its function, its composition, and all of its program elements, and the applicant and staff have made recommendations to you. They're requesting. We've advised you.
5:57:21 And you need to make a decision and say you like that program and you're willing to support the actions that go with that. Or you'd like to modify that program and then the same result in actions. What we're suggesting through the incentive zoning policy is that it is a policy that allows you to evaluate each site that seeks to employ it.
5:57:48 At a particular time in the evolution of the town and thinking uniquely of its location. In this case, what we've recommended to you is that this is a good program. So the balance of retail, of open space, of conference space, and the mixture of housing, hotel rooms, and affordable housing is a reasonable program for this site.
5:58:17 You'll have to decide whether that's true or not. And some of the variables you're dealing with are program. If you choose to put on more housing, then you'll have a lower goal attainment through retail or open space and recreation, for example. Could you also feel, as within, if you remember, on the parking right lot, I'm sensitive to what you're trying to get to, but doesn't John Farouk still have some type of, not ownership, but he has first right of refusal?
5:58:45 I was on council when we did that sale, and part of it was that it had to stay park and ride. If something was built, he was the one that was able to. If it was going to be sold, it had to be sold back to him. I don't... In my recollection, I'm not sure that that is true, because I'm vaguely remembering when we went through the exclusive negotiating agreement process. I don't remember seeing that condition, but the thought...
5:59:13 If you have that kind of programmatic idea, there are a number of different sites where it might be employed, so I wouldn't tie it specifically to that particular site. Everything I'm doing today, I'm trying to come up with solutions, and I'm batting zero so far, so I'm really focused on solutions. So that might be a useful site, some might the Civic Center, some might Shady Rest, some might other sites that a private party might wish to participate in. So that's why I wouldn't try to tie it to something that may or may not be achievable. Okay.
5:59:42 Did you have other questions? I do. I just remember at the very beginning, one of the things that I liked was the employee housing along Old Mammoth Road because it would show vitality, people, lights, always. And apparently that is not happening. I no longer see employee housing above the retail. I'm going to defer that question to John, but if I may,
6:00:13 Add one comment to respond to your question. I'm going to ask for some confirmation here from Pam. My recollection of a specific plan is that there is a specific requirement that we mitigate our affordable housing on-site. Yeah, there is. And if that were the case, then I don't know that we, I don't think we could mitigate at the park and ride site unless we have another specific plan. Oh, on-site. Oh, I see what you're saying. We would not, we'd have to come back here for another specific plan.
6:00:43 Yeah, the specific plan does require it to be on site, but just like the municipal code, if an applicant wanted to apply for an alternative housing mitigation plan, one of the things they could propose is off-site housing. And that would not require a specific plan amendment? No. It's permissible within the existing specific plan. Right. Oh, good. Good. Let's just all remember, I mean, 10 years from now, if this goes forward, seven years, there's going to be times when...
6:01:12 Things may change for us, for the developers to come back. So it's not set in stone as we may think it is right now. They may even come back requesting a smaller parking garage. Yeah, you never know. We're talking to the fact that there's a question remaining by Commissioner Clark. Right. John. Is that you? Yeah, so, Commissioner Clark, we really have always wanted to have the opportunity to provide on-site housing.
6:01:44 And I think it's an important thing. And originally I wanted to have it above Old Mammoth Road. We've actually looked at two or three different locations. And it's come back to us several times now that it would be nice for people to have some flexibility about where they chose to live as opposed to us dictating to them where their housing would be. So I think while there might be areas that are better than others from everybody's perspective, right now I believe we're really...
6:02:11 focused on giving people flexibility. The goal of having permanent on-site housing for, you know, say 24 to 30 people is nice because that's almost 10%, right, of the total occupancy, right, so about 8% or something. So the goal now, I think, is to really provide people the opportunity to have a little more flexibility about where their housing is and not putting them all in one location. So right now you're
6:02:39 Eight units that you're proposing would be scattered throughout the project? Correct. I think that's current thinking, but we're really listening to a lot of the guidance that the town staff is providing about where they think people should be.
6:02:53 We've now moved two or three different times, and the current thinking is to give people flexibility so they can be integrated with residents. I liked the idea that it would look like it was always alive. That was the original plan. That was very positive. Thank you. I think you had planned to always have it alive through increased occupancy there, but we did see a lot of examples of dispersed housing on our peer resort tours, and what that gave people was a sense of
6:03:21 It was a sense of community and there were some very vibrant spots and there were some that were quiet and private and it did not provide the concentrated workforce housing block there and a lot of communities definitely opted for that to have it dispersed through the community so it provided a lot more vibrancy throughout the entire project.
6:03:45 Just a quick comment. I think what Commissioner Clark was referring to where the workforce housing was aggregated along Old Mammoth is working with staff and ADP. The whole northeast corner, as John described with some graphics, has kind of evolved where we have that two-story retail pavilion out at the corner. And when we went to that two-story volume,
6:04:09 That floor above that previously was workforce housing went away. So, you know, that just kind of describes how things have been moving. Do we have any other questions on housing right now? No. I don't think Tony had any as well. I'd like to move to community benefits. Who would like to start? I have more discussion than questions on that one.
6:04:39 Okay, so I would like to see if we could leave approximately an hour to 45 minutes for our discussion at this time, so if it's not, and we're looking at questions right now, if anybody needs clarity, and then we'll move on to our discussions. If you have some community benefits questions.
6:04:59 Oh, so we're going to, when we deliberate, that's when we balance community benefits. Well, I don't know whether now is the place or not, but, well, we'll wait for that. So you have no other questions of clarity of staff at this time? No. Oh, perfect, thank you. I don't think that... I do actually have a question.
6:05:23 Tony Hannity, do you have a question? On community benefits, yeah. Okay, go ahead ahead. This has to do with some of the MLTPA issues, and I wonder if staff could talk a little bit about conditions 46, 48, 50, 69, and about 52, let's see, no, not 52, 62, no, excuse me, I'm sorry, I'm getting a little bleary here. Yeah, 58,
6:05:57 46, and 48. If staff could discuss that a little bit. Could you repeat those questions? The numbers? 46, 48, and 58. What did staff have in mind when they wrote these conditions? And while you're thinking about that, with the comments that have been made, when do we see the language of the revised conditions? When are we going to see that language? I can start, and Mark may have something to add.
6:06:27 We're going to go through all of the revised language on the conditions before you make a decision. So we can do that before you start your deliberation if you want. So we'll see the revised or hear the revised language? Okay. So it's 46, 48, and 58. If you could just discuss what your thinking was. Both 46 and 48 and actually also 47 came directly from letters from MLTPA during the specific plan public hearing process.
6:06:54 These provisions were incorporated verbatim into the text of the specific plan from those letters and these conditions are also verbatim from the specific plan. I believe that 58 is actually a duplicate of 46, so we can delete that one. And then... You see that as a duplicate? Yeah, it's the same language. Because I actually see 48 as much more comprehensive than 46. 46 and 58.
6:07:27 Oh, delete 46. Delete 58 is the same as 46. Delete 58. One more time for the record. 58 is a dupe to 46. Got it. Okay. Okay. And then on 69, this refers to a wayfinding plan needs to be submitted to the town, and this just refers to the timing of submittal and approval of that plan. And as you know, we'll have our wayfinding graphic program fully adopted, you know,
6:07:59 Within a timely period. So you see trails, wayfinding signage moving forward. You've recommended approval of that. We have traffic directional program already contemplated for design. And then we have transit packages that are actually developed already as well. And how do you see them participating in that, just having signage on their property? We'll see a signage plan. And then in terms of print media, they have that at their lobby and they pass that out.
6:08:30 So it might be similar to the type 2 plan that we just, that you just, sorry Peter, I didn't hear, so it might be similar to like the type 2 sign, right, plan for the way finding system that you just saw last meeting on the way finding project. Okay, I remember, it's part of the marketing and, you know, and advertising hotels would provide, this would be the type of information they would, they look for, provide, so definitely. Well, what I was thinking of, and I was thinking of it when,
6:09:01 We talked about how I didn't like the retaining wall on Sierra Nevada Road, not just because of the way the retaining wall looked, it was sort of clunky. This goes back to when I talked about the retaining wall on Sierra Nevada Road, I thought it was sort of clunky, but I also didn't like the idea that it separated the project from the neighborhood, and I really envision this project as the center, and I want it to reach out to the circumference, you know, our four square miles, and so when I talk about
6:09:31 Wayfinding and connecting to trails and connecting interpretive signage and connecting to what's around us, which is what people come for. It's all that stuff around our four square miles. I was concerned the language in these conditions, including 69, weren't, you know, strong enough, wouldn't accomplish that objective. So that's why I was asking for some comment from staff, but I still don't think they're going to accomplish that objective, so I have concerns about that.
6:10:04 Don't know that it's an issue to say what's in the content of the plan. If the plan is not acceptable, then it needs to be broader, but all you're asking for is the plan, not the details of the plan. You know what I really like are those big billboards on the mountain, and you know where you are, and you know how to get to where you want to go, you know which trail you're going to take, which run, and I just wish there were a place for something like that that would really connect people here, not just going to the lobby and getting a brochure, but
6:10:32 And hopefully by the time the plan can include that. I'll get you a cost on those. Oh, they're really expensive. You'd be surprised. I love those billboards. They're great. It's crazy. Okay. Any other? Pam, I'm sorry if we interrupted you. Did you have anything? I was not. Okay. That's all. Do you have anything else? It's fine. Okay.
6:11:01 I think we've covered all the highlights as far as questions. Does anybody have specific questions in any area that we have not covered at this time? No, I've got them all covered. Okay. I can't believe it. I'll just add in that. Staff did the research on Sierra Center Mall, and we've got the plans. You know, and it was correctly, it was during the county time, as was the Shiloh Hotel, both of which are on podiums, underground parking.
6:11:26 Curious, if they cross the street at Sierra Center Mall, they're parking, and the Shiloh was reduced because of that. So, we don't want to go there with you. But, it appears that the measurement was done from the podium. So, even though it was another time, you know, that has been done before. So, just for the early 80s. In the early 80s. Okay. So. Okay. And Shiloh is 55 feet. I guess I do have one more. Shiloh is 55 feet. Shiloh is 55 feet. Okay, that's interesting.
6:11:57 You had another question? I'm looking at the fee waiver provision. Is it correct that then the town leases for almost $4 million in diff funds, and if so, who pays that? I'm sorry, that was consulting with Walter. I'm sorry, page 18 of our developer benefits from CBIS fee waiver, borne by somebody.
6:12:37 Other than the developer. And I guess that's the town. Correct. And as this section of the staff report acknowledges, pursuant to the SEVIS policy provision, yes, the town would forego that increment of DIF and potentially of housing fees, amounting to as much as, you know, three and a half, I'm sorry, six and a half million dollars.
6:13:06 So to the extent that those DIF fees would pay for incremental service demands and so on and so forth across the general categories that DIF helps to fund, then that funding would have to be sought from other places. And the town has done this in other instances, for example, with waiver of housing fees for affordable housing projects. It says, you know, that exchange is fair. Walter, did you have something? Yes. Yes, I would like to respond a little bit.
6:13:35 Of course, the DIF policy itself and program is under review at this time. And so we, there's a lot of moving parts with respect to that. But one part that is not moving is the relationship of DIF to development. The cost base of development is figured on a build-out scenario that does not include the incremental density.
6:14:01 It's a very important point to make here. And so part of the rationale, and help me if I'm not mistaken here, Mark, that the fact is, the reason why the sea business constructed it like that recognizes that fact. We're not underfunding anything because the funding is already provided by the base amount of development for those improvements that are the basis of the DIFF fee. The DIFF fee is not just, you know, money. It's money related to specific projects.
6:14:31 Need for which was generated by a specific development program which is exclusive of these density bonuses that would be available through CBIS. It's a very, very important point. We're not underfunding anything. Because the project is providing. That is correct. Does that same rationale apply to the housing mitigation? No.
6:14:53 Not in the same fashion. Again, I would say, though, excellent question, with respect to the housing, that is also under review. And so we're, even the staff worked with her, did their very best to try and reflect the implications of what, excuse me, where we're moving or where we have moved a little bit on this. And at the end of the day, it may be a bit different. I would say that in respect to housing, that it's,
6:15:22 You need to look at fundamentally what the housing need is, how many of those jobs are going to be taken by existing workers, all this other stuff that is a little bit more nuanced and complicated. I would hope that's where the housing policy is going. That being said, the notion of inclusionary, that is, in these kinds of commercial projects, maximizing inclusionary housing is a good idea because
6:15:48 Simply of the limited number of sites you have available to you. So I would hope and I imagine that going forward with the housing program, there's still going to be an emphasis on this inclusionary concept, which I think is very important given the land supply issue. So that's a couple of points on the CBIS related to DIP and housing. Thank you.
6:16:14 One other, this is an important fact that led to the formation of the policy. We told you this when we came to you in, whatever that was, February 3rd. The reason for the policy instrument in the incentive zoning program was that there is a direct relationship between fee or program, which is the cost, and what's generating the revenue to pay for the cost.
6:16:43 And with each increment of fee or housing program or retail or parking, whatever that cost is, more square footage in rent or sale is required to support that. And one of the hurdles that was overcome in incentive zoning policy was taking out one of those factors that kept leading to higher and higher and higher on-site densities.
6:17:10 So this was a subtle balance between achieving the appropriate program contribution at the right place and time, but also not pushing the density and building height envelope in every situation to achieve that program. So the relationship of income and revenue to program and cost is very important. Thank you. Any further questions?
6:17:42 I have a question. Well, it's a question I have for Bill Taylor. Bill, I just have a question before we start to go into our deliberations. If you don't mind. Because we had received a letter from MLTPA, of course, with the signature and then yours on the housing. Are you satisfied on both ends, MLTPA and housing, of what you've heard today? Is there anything that you'd like to tell us before we go into the deliberations? I think what I really would say is I'd like to hear...
6:18:15 the deliberations and see the outcome is. I mean, I don't think that there was anything that was specifically said today. Certainly the conditions of approval as I commented before and as I included in MLTPA's letter reflect the basic analysis that we had asked for. I think the findings that we requested in our final paragraph in the MLTPA letter would be important. Those are
6:18:45 I believe the findings that are required by CBiz. So we're, you know, I think at this point I'd just like to see how the deliberations go. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. I finally found it. Great. Page three, vesting map. It says that right to proceed with development that is in substantial compliance with the development standards. Now, who makes that decision?
6:19:15 Well, first, when you approve, when you recommend approval or act on the items you approve, and then the council acts on their zoning instruments, that sets the standards, so these conditions are tied to the existing rules and regulations in effect, and then when the next step, which would be design development drawings, in this case, and then building permits, staff checks for conformance.
6:19:44 And, you know, for example, if the setbacks at 10 feet and they're at 10 feet, they're at substantial conformance. If the setbacks at 10 feet and they were at 5 feet, they're not. So they need to be, you know, a couple of inches. We don't, you know, inches aren't that important, but we are pretty rigorous in deciding
6:20:08 As I said, what you see is what you get when you approve this kind of a plan. And so if this looks different, we're coming back to the appropriate body for confirmation or interpretation. But you make the substantial compliance, yay or nay? Yes. Thank you. Any further questions? So I think we're ready to deliberate. Is there any more information that we need, Mark, at this point?
6:20:41 Not from staff's perspective. I do want you to know that I have a running list of some of the concepts that you've talked about as things that you might want to see as conditions. Exactly. And that's really important because we have discussed quite a bit there and we'll be able to incorporate any of those within our conditions there. I'd like to open up the deliberations right now and discussion. Elizabeth, can I call on you first?
6:21:10 Okay. I know we discussed some changes, Pam. Are there anything else that would need to be brought to attention? I know they were in our packet, but there was... About CBiz? Are we on CBiz now? We're on deliberation. We're on deliberation, so it's really required actions. Are we going to go by these, or are we going to... Well, we want... Because we haven't talked about community benefits.
6:21:37 Yes, we have. I thought we had. No, we had questions. So now we want to. Questions, okay. So as far as discussion and deliberation, that's what I'm asking for you now, is that I think we're through with our questions. Is everyone in concurrence that we're through with our questions and now it's time for discussion? Okay, good. Okay, we'll start. Our charge as planning commissioners is to make sure that whatever comes before us is consistent with the general plan.
6:22:06 And we have policy L5G which says that community benefits must be above and beyond those required to meet the incremental demands of the project. And that above and beyond phrase has been in my head since last Friday when I really got into this and just read the whole thing three times. I look at the community benefits that are being offered.
6:22:34 And the amount of retail is just wonderful. It's great. And that's definitely above and beyond. But that's the single most, to my way of thinking, significant community benefit. The plaza, the outdoor spaces, that's a nice amenity. It's also the roof of the parking garage. So can that be taken as the entire benefit, you know, or as part of that, a benefit to the developer if you've got to put a roof on the garage?
6:23:03 I've lost the piece of that. Here we go. I was asking Peter about the Old Mammoth Road widening because I read in the staff report that that wasn't required, the widening, the bus stop, the sidewalk, and that's being listed as a community benefit. I'm still not completely sure about that.
6:23:34 And the sidewalks are wider on Old Mammoth Road? Okay. And also on Sierra Nevada Road and Royal Mountain Road. We've done some studies on Royal Mountain Road for future sidewalks. And with that study, it really put it on the other side of the street.
6:24:03 That's an awkward head-in parking thing. Yeah, okay. The mid-block connector is a real benefit to the town, but it's also a benefit to the developer, because that's how the hotel works out best. I mean, it really works out well.
6:24:33 So when I look at this and I read the MLTPA letter and I rack my brain and come up with my scheme to make a million seven by condensing the parking garage so we could use that for trails and more sidewalks and more feet first amenities. And that didn't work out. And so I'm really still tussling with this community benefits that are above and beyond what would be required. And I'd like to hear from the rest of the commissioners. That's my...
6:25:02 That's my issue. I'd like to address the plaza. Sure. I think what we're missing on the plaza. I wasn't dismissing it. I wasn't just saying it was a roof. I guess what I'm trying to say is that it's not just the plaza, but it's what's going to happen at that plaza is the community benefit from the ice rink to all the functions that happen and the maintenance, the management, and the cost of doing such things and events on that plaza is what make up that whole community benefit.
6:25:32 I think just to say that, you know, is the plaza really a benefit? Well, it is because of what can happen there and what's going to happen there. If it was simply going to be a roof over the garage, you have to question that, but it's not. Right. So I think that, you know, for the community benefit portion, it's, you know, from outdoor weddings to the ice rink to, you know, whatever else happens there. There's a plethora of things that will be going on there. This is the first time we've had to address this policy in conjunction with the project.
6:25:59 And we also have to be consistent with L5G in the general plan. So it's above and beyond that I just want to hear from you. Well, I think that is because if you take the village and you look at the plaza of the village, which is supposed to be a public plaza, but the town has no control over what goes on there. It's a private entity. It's the village neighborhood company. And the programming of it, we have no say in that. And so we've provided this plaza and an amenity there that means nothing to us, really.
6:26:27 Whereas this is something that would be programmed and the town would be working with, with the developer, with the property owner of that, in the management, the program, I mean, what happens? Okay, and I'll also add... Excuse me, before you go on, Tony, help me understand how this one's going to be different than the one at the village. The one at the village is not, it's basically privately ran by the neighborhood company.
6:26:49 It is not a public closet. It is called a public closet, but we did not put programming or anything into it. So the town has the ability to do four events there a year with no financial help from it. It's basically there. So we have to come up with all the funds in order to do the events.
6:27:10 And there's only four years that we can do. Whereas with Mr. Demetriatus and this project, it's a joint effort that, as you know, we've been working with Dana Stroud and we've been hearing all these past couple years now of what can be programmed there and how they're going to be directly working with the town to do that. And I'll also, I still don't see the difference. That's a huge difference because we'll have control. We could actually program. We are going to control this project. We are going to work with him in the programming of it. And if the programming doesn't happen,
6:27:41 Why would it not happen? Well, I don't know. Why wouldn't, I mean... I think you have a good example of this at the villages. Previously, it was not programmed. And so it became a space that was not utilized and not to the benefit. They have recently started programming, and there's a huge difference to the community and surrounding by having events there. But it is expensive, and they had to actually include infrastructure.
6:28:09 Part of this proposal is to start out with the infrastructure like the ice rink or something that is, you know, the Rockefeller Center concept that we use dual times a year, but the programming there that we are involved in instead of
6:28:26 Buying into it as a certain participant. So it is a community. It absolutely is a community benefit when it's programmed. And what we're asking is that, yes, it'd be programmed. Otherwise it becomes the top of a parking garage, I think to your point, which could very easily be private space there. And by them allowing that to be space there that the...
6:28:51 Community has access to not just the hotel guests because there's several areas of the village that are not open to everyone. They've created a snow park next to the pool, but that's for their hotel guests, and that's not what you're talking about. It is a different level of programming that enhances
6:29:11 It enhances the surrounding area, not just his property there. That's what we're requiring. So there are restrooms and fountains and PA systems, all electronics. Everything is there. To be used for those type of things to allow that to be there instead of if you want to do it, you bring it in completely. So that's where this has the ability to perform as a community benefit.
6:29:40 Take our ice rink, for example, that we have now. The ice rink runs, is running the town into the hall on revenues of what it costs. You go out there, sometimes there's more staff inside the warming hut than there is on the ice. If Mr. Demetriatus decided that he could work with the town, which I know he can, perhaps we can move that ice rink over to his property in that plaza. He manages it for us. It drops the revenue. The revenue, of course, would be, you know, that has to be decided, but the cost was something he could be bearing.
6:30:09 So that's how you can get that benefit. And that's so interesting because I thought the ice rink was a very detriment to the town in the sense that it competed immediately with our own ice rink. So what you're saying is get rid of one. Yeah, I've always, I mean, the ice rink that we have currently, it's a money hole. It is a money hole. So here's a benefit that the developer can provide as a community benefit by doing something like that.
6:30:36 I don't know if he wants to, but that's something he may be able to do with the town in the coming years. Can I add one more thing before I relinquish my time? No, I'm trying to talk to you. You regain your time? No, not actually the top of a parking garage. It was a little bit of a cheap shot, so I will retract that one. The conference space is excellent. I just think that's wonderful. That's going to bring people here. I can just, if it's marketed along with the events, that's very, very good. I'm very happy about that.
6:31:03 But I think we owe it to MLTPA. Excuse me, do we want to talk about each of these as you bring them up? No, I'm just bringing up my issues. But I think we definitely owe it to MLTPA to respond to their letter about in our findings, including language expressly stating the tradeoffs made and how the benefits that accrue to the community achieve the community's goals better.
6:31:25 And providing enhanced recreational and trails experiences. Right now a spa and wellness center is far better than a trail, the way I feel after sitting here all day. But, you know, trails and getting out into the backcountry, that's, you know, just enjoying, you know, everything we have here, what brings the people here. I'd like us to respond to MLTPA in our, in our, what will be our final thing? Well, don't you feel that, anyway, that's.
6:31:53 Those are all my issues. Don't you feel that actually what they're doing though is they're providing a center for recreation. People are coming there, they're staying there, they're going out into the areas to the backcountry, they'll be going fishing in the summer, you know, winter sports in the winter. So what they're doing is providing a center base for recreation. But I want to beef up those conditions. No, I understand that. But I mean, I think we have to also acknowledge that this property in the center of town is going to be a center for recreation. And it's how it's dispersed through the rest of town. Okay.
6:32:23 You may also wish to note that there's a broad range of activities that fit the term recreation and why people choose to go places. I mean, where can you go in town now and have family that sit there and play back on a wintery night, let's say? We really don't have that. I think they're going to provide that. And that, to me, is recreation, too. It's an activity. Do you have anything else at this time? Those are all my issues about community benefits. I look forward to what you guys have to say.
6:32:53 Chair, do you have anything else as far as information? I disagree, Elizabeth, totally with the conference space. I think that's purely for the hotel itself to fill beds. I disagree with you then. Okay, we just disagree. We'll have to disagree to disagree. And especially, again, getting back to the sticky dot survey that our community did, the one thing that they definitely did not want.
6:33:23 At that, in our town center, or this place, was convention conference facilities, because they didn't obviously think it was a community need. How many respondents was that? That would be an interpretation of that, but I think you're fine to say that it is, they did not want it there. That was a conference center? No, it was a convention conference facility that I think
6:33:51 Perhaps the community just at the sticky dot survey did not think it was necessary there. And again, as I said, the one thing that they did want and it stood out of all the things that that sticky dot survey showed was parking, parking, parking in every location. And so
6:34:16 The, um, back to the underground parking, I would have problems giving it for a benefit as well because, first of all, as soon as you do underground parking, you get your 10 feet on your building, which would take you up to 45 feet. That's, oh, that's not? It's not subject to it. Oh, this, it's, that's in our general plan, but that makes no, no.
6:34:45 It's in our municipal code. It's in our codes, okay. And we're not subject to that because we have a specific plan. Right, okay. It's a deviation then from our own municipal codes. May I correct another misapprehension that we've heard that we just want to make sure for the record that it isn't perpetuated. John has pointed out to me that two of the plazas are not on top of the parking garage, and so they do not come from the roof of the parking garage. One of them does.
6:35:10 And in addition, I'd like to... Two of them. Two of them. Two of them. Two of them. Two of them. Two of them. Okay, great part. So, I'm sorry. It's my job to make sure that that is not perpetuated to the public and to the council. And you do a very good job of it. And if I may, I apologize for intruding on your deliberation, but...
6:35:32 Your question is very apt, and that is, how do we distinguish above and beyond the incremental demands of the project? That was a wording that I worked very hard on, that Bo Taylor participated, and that Dan Dawson participated, and that Mark Worla did as well. And I think a tool that you might consider using to assess what is demanded by the project, what is the incremental demand of the project, what is above and beyond that, is to look at the West End. And if you look at the West End, you will see what is required.
6:36:00 By code, so to speak, of a condo hotel. You are required to have essentially one bar and restaurant. You're required to have a small conference space. I think if the town had to do over again, they would up that requirement because they think that's small, a little bigger than the Westin. And you're required to have nightly check-in and check-out service. You're required to be part of some larger marketing service.
6:36:30 And your nightly living service. And essentially, that's it. That's what's required by the code. No prazzas are required at the West End. If you went anywhere on the West End and you were not a guest, they could politely ask you to leave unless you were in the lobby or you were in the bar or if you were in the restaurant. And they could say, excuse me, are you a guest? If you were in the pool, for example, if you were anywhere else. On this property,
6:36:57 So there are no plazas required, no street front commercial, no mid-block connectors, and so that is above and beyond, everything that we just mentioned is above and beyond the incremental demand of the project because we have evidence of what this type of condo hotel would require in terms of the demands of the project. That's a very apt example. Thank you.
6:37:23 Continue, Sharon. I would disagree with you because I think some of these things are required in a specific plan. Well, I think what the specific plan says is identifies these things as community benefits. Keep in mind there has been a progression of the community benefits identification. It started out on page 26 of the general plan. And there was a list, a specific list of community benefits in the general plan. That list was carried forward in the North Old Mammoth Road District study.
6:37:52 Another list, a refined list, and then after that, that list was carried forward into the specific plan. So if you want to know what a community benefit is, you've got those three resources to see. And they specifically say plazas, conference spaces, mid-block connectors, underground parking, all community benefits. So it would be hard to imagine anybody deciding otherwise when the three governing documents that preceded this effort all say that they are.
6:38:22 Community practice. Page 14 in the plan says two east-west connectors shall be constructed, north-south pedestrian, so I guess maybe I'm not reading the specific plan as you are. It very definitely says these things shall be there. That's in response to the mobility plan that the town pushed forward.
6:38:53 What we have done with respect to that is we have created a complete street, way beyond any concept of just a midlock network. We have a complete street on the North Road. So that's beyond that. And keep in mind, we have the expert financial consultants who have already done this analysis for you. You have a consultant who has given you his professional opinion about what the...
6:39:17 demands of the project for TIPP and what is above and beyond that and considered to be a community benefit based upon their reading of the same documents that guide you. Well, those are economists dealing with purely dollars. I have to look at more than that. That's just one part of the area that I have to look at for my...
6:39:39 Decisions. Well, specifically, I respect that, and specifically with respect to plazas, the development agreement between Interwest and the town of Mammoth Lakes called out the pedestrian plaza and the village as an amenity and as a community benefit, and there was a requirement of a public easement over that property to essentially perfect that right to walk on the property. Thank you.
6:40:10 Connector Road, I think is very definitely necessary for the project and until it's a two-way street, I'm not sure it's a community benefit. I've already said something about the ice rink and the conference center and now I've lost my community benefits list so that I can respond. Sharon, can I ask you a question about the two-way street? There was objection to
6:40:39 traffic pulling out on Old Mammoth Road and adding to congestion there and there's going to be a traffic light at the intersection of Old Mammoth Road and Sierra Nevada and so the idea is that when people exit they'll pull out onto Laurel Mountain and go around the block to the light and that will reduce congestion that was done even though it's two lanes going in that was done intentionally so do you still object to it well the
6:41:07 One of the consultants in the back said that it did not encourage, you know, the flexibility wasn't there for community travel, and it's going to put traffic, more traffic, on Laurel Mountain. I guess I'm just, when I hear a connector road, I expect it to be available as a connector. In other words, to get from one east-west both ways. And Laurel Mountain, I don't know what the LOS is, but it has a lot less.
6:41:35 What else did I miss? We've talked about the connector, the plaza, the conference, the parking. I still believe we need more parking. I disagree with you on that, Elizabeth. And if we can't put it on site, if we don't have enough in the future, I guess I would like something that since more was
6:42:05 Necessary according to our codes that that would be done by the developer to provide those parking places in an annex in a district and an assessment district of some sort. So you want more parking if but off-site? If they're not putting it on site so if we need it in the future that that would be assessed to the developer to provide because it is part of our code. Okay, that's interesting. Okay.
6:42:36 How does that fit with our feet first? Yeah. I mean, I don't understand how more parking follows to a feet first mobility plan, which is what we're trying to achieve. We are trying to achieve that, Tony, but apparently the community wants parking. And as long as they want parking, that's what I represent. Well, and I think that we're going to disagree on how much is enough to them because, you know, based on
6:43:06 what was the sites there providing not only parking but a management plan as well because I think that's very important whenever we develop parking sites whether they be surface or buildings that we also incorporate management plans not just the spaces because in order to have efficient parking in the area that we have limited to is we've got to utilize it the best and
6:43:34 This is the first example of not only the spaces but a management plan. They did not have a management plan at the village. I'm there every day and it breaks my heart that people can't come to shop or go to restaurants because there's not a convenient place to park and they're sitting empty all during the day. So the first thought was this management plan.
6:43:59 Is it be exactly what it needs, you know, to make that much more functional? The Weston figured it out pretty fast as well that they needed to. So I don't think, I think that their, the request that I read in the Sticky Dot was solve our parking issues. And going with not only space, surface, underground, but management, and this is our first step into management as well, and I'm encouraged to see that.
6:44:28 Should we develop more, need more, and I don't think it'd be exactly for his site, but it might be for adjacent sites that you have to have a management plan to. And I'd be very interested to see how this works, if that helps develop this in to provide that traffic flow, and I wouldn't meter the spaces out there too. Yeah, I agree that the public is demanding parking, but I think we have to interpret that reasonably as the public wants adequate parking. And if we give...
6:44:58 Any credence to our experts, what they're telling us is the amount of parking provided here is conservative. It's on the high end of what's needed. And if anything, we might want to go a little bit lower and still have adequate parking, but even encourage feet first more. And make it easier. I think it's important to remember how many people participated in the Sticky Dot exercise. Do you know who was in charge of that? Was it Jen?
6:45:25 Mark, how many people participated in that? I think we had like 75, but we emphasized in our report to council on the adoption of this policy that that was not a statistical survey. It was a self-selecting group of people, whoever they were, that came to participate, and that's why we didn't try to prioritize. We actually recommended that we didn't establish those polling results as preference because at the end of that we came to the...
6:45:55 realization that the best way to figure out the amenities per district is to actually go through the neighborhood district planning process. So although that's useful information, there's other, probably more useful information that's germane to each local district. So keep it in perspective, less than 1% of our total population, full-time residents, participated and non-empirical. Non-statistical.
6:46:28 And I found my list. And I think I've addressed everything. That's even better. Can we go back to first principles a little bit? Absolutely. I'm trying to constrain myself to the specified CBIS procedure. And the first step is to look at the benefits that are offered under CBIS.
6:46:59 First of all, they have to be benefits that are within the policy defined as eligible to be benefits. And I guess we're quibbling about that somewhat. But that first step is to assess the value of those benefits relative to the incentives being sought. And as I understand it, what we have to find is that the value of the benefits to the public outweighs value to the developer.
6:47:28 Am I stating that correctly? Well, we've got double density to think about, too. But that's the next step, I think. And that's a crucial point here. Say that again, Jay, please. As I understand it, our first step involves comparing the value of the benefits, the value that will be attained by the public versus value that's going to accrue to the developer.
6:47:54 And as I understand it's separate from that then is if we come out with a positive assessment, which isn't necessarily financial but is value in a broader sense, then the next step is decide how much benefit they are entitled to. How much benefit? Yes. Do we give them double density? Do we give them...
6:48:17 One and a half times density. And that step, I think, needs to be kept separate from that first step. The first step being purely financial? No. No, being valued in a broader sense than financial. Okay, because I cannot accept just... Are we intermingling that originacy? Yeah, are we intermingling that first and second step? That's what I'm trying to understand here. So based on our expert...
6:48:45 Analysis saying that these benefits benefit the community tenfold of what they benefit the builder. Right. Is that something that you still feel is in debate? No, I don't think so. I don't think it is. I have no problem with that finding showing that there's sufficient benefit to the public here. But what guidance do we have to decide how much we provide in incentives?
6:49:17 So how it equates to the density. Yes. Because it's tenfold enough to get you double. Yeah, it's tenfold enough. Well, now you're taking it back to the finances again. And I heard Jay say he was talking about value. Well, finances are part of value. It's just part. But it's not the major part. And isn't this setting a precedent? Or is this for this? When you use the word precedent, that's a pretty significant word.
6:49:45 Each and every case you have will be a different combination of events. And I think what you're struggling with is that you have a program of amenities and you're concerned about the increases incrementally and to the total of resulting density that get there. One way to think about it is if you take this plan, you know,
6:50:13 What are the alternatives? An alternative is to significantly reduce density and don't expect to have a hotel and don't expect to have a conference center. Don't expect to have the mid-block connector. And a very fine art is to determine, although the specific plants as it is required, what is its financial relationship to actual feasibility?
6:50:42 If we put a specific plan amendment item, the site shall provide an aquatic, an Olympic designed aquatic center for the community. Does that make it so? It does not make it so because it's not financially feasible. And so if you want to reduce density, acknowledge that you won't accept those other program elements because they're not financially feasible.
6:51:09 If you want to reduce density, you're also making implicit decisions that say you're not going to implement many of the aspects of the general plan nor the specific plan in the studies that led up to it because there's not an ability to achieve them. There's nothing materially different about a plaza built on top of a structure or on top of dirt. It's a plaza. And the alternative to the plaza is
6:51:39 Build a program. So put some triplexes on that space, and you'll diminish the critical mass in the animation to the project as well as the district. You won't have a plaza, and you won't have the open space. So there is some sense of nexus and connection to the program, to the design, and to its financial feasibility.
6:52:08 And to think that it all exclusively...
6:52:38 Falls to the benefit of the applicant or the property owner is not correct. Any place you wish to go, whether it's Aspen or Telluride or Santa Barbara or West Los Angeles, the connection of placemaking is design from the private side, the public side, the joint investment and leveraging of program and character, and it really is an integrated soup.
6:53:07 You know, when you start reaching in and pulling out lumps of potato and lumps of stew meat, you're fairly soon left with a thin broth. And if your thin broth was what you wanted... You must be hungry, Mark. Many of us didn't get lunch. And so you really have some fundamental choices, and I think they're very clear and obvious. If you reduce density, which you could decide is appropriate, you should think that you won't.
6:53:35 Receive, you won't realize those benefits. That's just the way it is. And if you want to have a low-intensity cold bed project, that's an alternative. If you want to have the existing facility with a new coat of paint in, say, five years, and maybe some infill marginal units, a triplex placed on some of the surface parking, there you go. That's an alternative for you.
6:54:01 So those are the pragmatic things. And as you try to parse out, well, I don't think a portion in that closet, take out 10 bricks and say he has to pay for that, that's what your advisors have said, it doesn't work that way. It's not a linear relationship. I'll trade you a broom closet for a unit. It doesn't work that way. There's a reason that Westin has the program that does. The way I look at it is density is the foundation of the project.
6:54:30 When you start removing the foundation, you lose everything else from it. Then why are we here? And to elaborate on what Mark basically said is, you know, Mr. Demetriotis and his wife have done a great job right now, excuse us putting lipstick on a pig, but that's what you've done. You've done a great job with it. You've added things. It's wonderful. You know, he can simply go and add 80 units to that place and call it a day. We get no community benefits. We get nothing else from it.
6:54:57 He's been able to now move his occupancy up in what he's doing without stealing from other properties, without doing anything else. He can do that right now, put 80 units, make his money, be happy, and we have nothing other than 80 more units on the property. That he could do right now, we couldn't say no to. So I think we have to keep that in perspective. You think he could do that under the Clearwater Specific Plan? I don't...
6:55:26 I think the town would allow people to incrementally add. And if, let's say, we had some space, we'll take out 20 parking spaces and build a triplex there, that would not reasonably trigger that. And I don't think it's in the town's ability to say you can't do anything without complete demolition of your site. Yeah, we couldn't do that. I don't think you'd do that. And the reason you're here, and the discussion you're having...
6:55:53 Wait, wait, wait. I want to go back to the fact that he can't just incrementally retrofit the site. I thought we had a specific plan that said specifically what had to happen at that site. Yes, but there are non-conforming use considerations. Can he make, can a property owner reasonably make minor modifications to his project? And I think the answer would be yes.
6:56:22 And I don't think the town is saying, you cannot do anything other than paint your building. So he wouldn't be building the Clearwater specific plan. Right, he would. So one of your alternatives is... He would be retrofitting what's there. The base case. So the challenge you have, Commissioner Clark, is you as a body are adjudicating the program.
6:56:45 The design and the facilities and density, but you should do it with realistic expectations. If you choose to say, for example, you can have, I'll make it up, 50 units per acre, we will advise you and say you cannot reasonably now require all of these other components because it's not feasible.
6:57:13 So that's your challenge. Yes, commissioners, let me offer some insights into my thinking here. We met with the experts on financial planning in terms of community benefits, value of those benefits, etc. And the economics came back $26 million for the town, $2.5 million for you. They even asked me, why would you do this, Jim? It's not a good deal.
6:57:42 And the reason I would do it is because I think this model is better for the community than taking my base case scenario, which I gave them, which you have, which is to build 240 units total. We have about 160 rooms now. We go up to 240 rooms, keep the property as is. It will have the same look and feel that it has today. There are those that would like that, that would prefer that.
6:58:13 But is that good for the community? Absolutely not. It costs $2 million a year and lost tax revenue. It costs $8 million a year and lost income and wages for all of the citizens of Mammoth. It costs those things that I described this morning. This brings the community tremendous benefits. And from my perspective, it is your choice and your ability to say, we like this or we don't. If we don't like this, Jim,
6:58:43 We want to thank you for your five years of effort working with us all. This is not what we want. And you have every right to say that, and I will go back to our property and build the 80 units in a year or two. And that's it. And we lose 300 jobs for potential jobs, full-time jobs for our community. And it's not by choice. These are just the numbers that are coming out based off of all of the reality of our economy today. Okay? So just so you know how I'm looking at it.
6:59:13 Do you have anything else, Jay? I don't think so. And wait, I have to say this one thing. You know, we only live within policy and regulations. And on page 12 of your staff report, we've exerted what your policy guidance is, which is a quote from Section 523 of this specific plan. For the purposes of considering increased density up to 80 units per acre, this specific plan contemplates
6:59:43 The community benefits listed below to be among those that may be determined to be desired by the town of Mammoth Lakes and may be appropriate for this site. The final community benefits will be determined pursuant to the future policy which has been completed and will be applied during the use permit application for which we were in. And they go on to list specifically
7:00:08 Indoor meeting and conference space, there's another program, outdoor public events plaza, commercial retail and restaurant uses along Mammoth Road, which we've also noted is we're not talking solely about in-line space, we're talking about a much larger massive space, like you would think of a Trader Joe's, that kind of square footage, which is really beyond the pale of in-line space that might be required in any downtown area.
7:00:36 Underground parking, pedestrian and vehicular mid-block connectors, dedication of property for the purpose of improving the public rights of whites, et cetera, and then public access to the events. So what you're looking at is within the policy envelope. There certainly could be others, and you could certainly pick and choose. But the relationship, I think you need to be very thoughtful and wise, and not just arbitrarily hope that if you reduce density, you still get that candy.
7:01:06 Because, you know, that was deserved to the stew. Well, it's our job to follow the policies that have been set forth in the past. Right. And interpret it. And interpret it and go forward. And if we don't like those, then we have to start making recommendations to change them. But we can't arbitrarily change them in this process. I guess policy is what I'm interested in. In the actual SEVIS policy under B2, it talks about
7:01:34 How we shall have a developed list by town council. We have a list. Is that the only list we have? Is it only for the specific plan? We don't have a list developed for the town? That list, remember that the general plan has a larger list. Right. And through the neighborhood district planning process for North Old Mammoth Road.
7:02:00 The Town Council reviewed that list specific to this study area and refined it to that small list. So we're getting the actual list each time per district plan. Right. And the Council... So we don't have one townwide? No. And the Council's action was determining that an equestrian facility in the North Old Mammoth Road area was probably not appropriate. That's why they took it out. But we do have one townwide. It's in the general plans. Yeah.
7:02:30 No, I'm saying it's been refined to each specific. Oh, of course, of course, but there is a town-wide list and then what fits each district with a neighborhood district plan. Correct. Yeah, right. I have, my feeling is that the list of benefits provided and the valuation, as we've discussed, and as the financials, in a qualitative sense, to me,
7:02:56 Qualifies them for double density. My question is the process and how do we, I mean, is that enough or do we have to provide more than that as a rationale on how we get to double density as opposed to any other density? I think it's, there's a couple things if, you know, obviously if you don't agree with this list that those are community benefits and you're not going to have an issue and that's what the question is.
7:03:25 And you're going to have to make that decision for yourself if it does. I think we've beat a lot of these issues, but I'm going to beat one more. And that is the conference space. And I respectfully disagree with Sharon that this is only for the hotel. If it was, we would have a lot more conference space than we did. And my 20 years experience in this particular industry shows that they will, hotels,
7:03:55 Projects will build just enough to satisfy that because they are huge money losers. I'm sorry, but they are. And where you do, and there's no greater example than the Keystone Project, which a beautiful conference center that was built not near hotels, and they wondered why it was not successful because you had to go across town.
7:04:18 to your hotel and that completely defeats the purpose of a functioning conference center and conference centers must have not only host hotels but satellite properties to feed off of those in order to make them viable and to actually pay for themselves and where communities benefit from these much more than the individual hotel.
7:04:43 Because primarily conference visitors are paying a lower rate than the transient visitors, but you make it up in their recreation and amenities and all the other ways that they spend money. And the fact that we have not been conference accessible Monday through Friday is why we have our, we're totally dependent on our occupancy levels for the weekend to offset everything else. And if
7:05:10 This has been a big issue and I'm not advocating just building a huge conference center because we have plenty of places to supply hotels, but we definitely, with you building more than you need, is a community benefit because it certainly is going to cost this property a lot to maintain it, but it can definitely pull other revenues from other areas.
7:05:37 And I also want to share some information that was compiled by Tourism Recreation regarding airport. A survey for the one month from January 13th to February 16th, there was a total of 192 deplaning passengers that were surveyed. And we all have some sort of gut feeling about who we think these people are.
7:06:02 And it was very encouraging to see who they really are. People getting up in Mammoth. These people that were taking advantage of air service. And 77% of them were visitors to Mammoth. Only 4% of these people were value pass holders. We tend to think that our value pass holder of the 40,000 of them are going to be on the plane. They're not. These are brand new people that don't have loyalty to Mammoth through a pass.
7:06:29 That is incremental business right there. 59% of them visited because of air service and 65% of those people visited Mammoth for the first time. 51% of them traveled with families. 83% of them came to recreate. Only 6% of them came for business conference because we don't have a place for them to come. And if you want keys to your occupancy Monday through Friday, they come by plane.
7:06:57 They will drive five hours on their own, but for their company to take them to a conference, they want to fly. Shopping, 74% said it was the most popular activity other than skiing or snowboarding in Mammoth. It was followed by other recreations, but the second thing that you do...
7:07:15 When you go to other places, unfortunately my credit card tells me, is I have to spend money in other places. 40% of them stayed in hotel and 26% in a rented condo, 66% of them stayed in transient occupancy places. 57% of them stayed three or four nights. That's more than just a weekend. And only 17% stayed one to two nights.
7:07:41 94% of them stayed in Mammoth, 42% listed that friends and family told them about them, about the air service there. 51% were female, the decision makers, as if you're in tourism, you know who says, I don't have to check with friends. It's the women. 36% of them have children. And 17% listed their annual household income.
7:08:10 of over 250,000, and 55% said they would be interested in summer service to Mammoth. These people fit the mall to feet first because they are going to be here, and they are incremental visitors, and we had always wondered if that was really true, who was going to use this? Was it new people? New people come to us for various reasons.
7:08:36 Community benefits of things like shopping, you can debate if we have a lot of shopping. Evidently, they're going to want to find every bit and they will continue. They do come for conferences and they do stay in the hotels and the condominiums that we have available. So looking at are these things, or what are the things that draw them? It is conference space for business, somebody else is paying for that trip.
7:09:04 The outdoor events in Plaza and the commercial real estate, underground parking that is programmed is really essential and those are my comments about that you're not using this just for the hotel guests, it is, you're turning that parking space I would say three to four times a day. And the connectivity, the mid-block connectors, I personally have issues regarding putting more trapping on Old Mammoth Road and I like to see how we keep that circular and moving there.
7:09:34 And the public access to these events and working with the town of programming, I think, does that qualify these as viable community benefits that are paying ten times over? I don't think that there's that big of an argument on it. Yeah, and Jay, you know, this first sentence to CSP includes a list of community benefits to be among those that may be considered.
7:10:00 They've done every one of them that are on the list. I agree. So I think that gives us the ability to look at double density. But I would like to add one more thing in that, and I see it's almost 5. I'm assuming we're going to have to come back in the morning now. You know, the letter from the water district, you all received this, I think? You know, I'd like to hear from you in the morning about being able to, you know, you're a trailblazer, you're a maverick.
7:10:28 You've stated it basically yourself this morning, and we appreciate that. And some firsts, you hope there wasn't another, but I think maybe this might have to be a first, and that is that we're able to put A through E, somehow incorporating them into your project, so that you are the first one, I'm sorry to do it, but for us to protect our water in the future and the infrastructure as it comes forward, I'd like you to look at these and see how you can help us to start that process.
7:10:56 So that all future developments follow what the water district is asking us for. Mark, is that a policy issue? Is that a policy issue? Because I've looked at this, and there are great recommendations, but there's no reason I would see that this project is the only way that's held to that. I think those would be issues throughout the rest of the community. And we need to establish that first? No, I think the water district has, you know, we met with them, Rob Clark, Ellen Clark, Mark Clark.
7:11:26 We met with Greg and his staff, and we've talked about we're going to participate in the urban water management plan with them so that we have far more integrated growth projections and such. And we also, they're committing to participate with us in application review and joining our development review committee, our internal staff, the fire district review, so that's very helpful. And I think
7:11:52 What I would suggest with these recommendations is we include them as a new condition of approval. And with each one, so A, evaluate the feasibility of, they should all be, instead of just saying install, we should evaluate the installation of so that there's truly a system. And then we should, on D, evaluate installation of. And with those two additions, these would be reasonable conditions of approval to apply. And
7:12:20 And I think, you know, as Mark Twain said, you know, risk is for drinking and water is for fighting, and that's what we're going to start to see in the future. That it's truly a finite resource that we need to be very thoughtful of as we manage projects, improvements, and growth. Thank you for refining that, because that's what I was trying to get to. And I'd further like to ask you, Mark, on number two through five, where they talk about in this letter about us working more together with them.
7:12:48 That we can maybe agendize for our next meeting that we decide to commissioners that with the council liaison committee that can take part in these discussions as we move further through the processes in the future. Right. I think those are... And that's not for Mr. Demetriotis. That would be more for Planning Commission. This is a town and district issue. Right. And a work program issue. But I just wanted to get that in the record that we could do that. And Tony, I think I can respond just even now to these requirements.
7:13:16 Because really what they're asking for is to evaluate, work with them, and the answer is yes to every single one of these. We will work with the Department of Water to really work on making sure that we're as efficient as possible because our goal is not just to be a lead, silver, but really to be the best we can be because that's what I think we have the opportunity of doing here. So we have our commitment to work with the town to make this happen.
7:13:45 I'm very glad we're coming back in the morning, so I want to hear the revised conditions when I'm fresh. Well, I was just going to suggest that we're not out of here until we're kicked out of here. If you want to continue until 530, you certainly can. I have to leave. There you go. 5 o'clock. Are you able to meet in the morning? Can we meet at 8? I can.
7:14:06 I mean, would eight work? It'll be a short meeting. Sure, I'll still be up, I guess. We are noticed for tomorrow's meeting. Time doesn't matter. We're noticed for it. You're adjourned, so it doesn't matter. And you've already opened and closed the public hearing, so that portion won't be complete. And so if that's the desire of the Planning Commission, we'll reconcile these notes and have a freestanding sheet that shows you strike out
7:14:35 And we'll be presenting comments from Pete Tracy, from Kevin Ennis, from the Water District, from your comments, which we believe you have consensus on. And then we'll also be adding a finding that you and MLTPA requested.
7:14:54 And Pam, you said there was always some changes you have. I'm going to work on that myself, too. Are you able to email those to us this evening so we have those at least to start with? Those changes will be what Mark's talking about. Oh, are those the same ones? Yeah. So we'll see a strikeout version of revised conditions. And I can try to send that to you tonight after we get them all put together. You can sleep next week, Pam. Sure. Have you had any sleep this week, any of you? Oh, okay, good. So we come back tomorrow. We have to clear the decks there, don't we? And we will...
7:15:25 Pull adjourn for today, but we can continue our meeting until tomorrow morning. At what time? And we have agreed at 8 o'clock. 8's great. Who should I email tonight if I get some thoughts on how to beef up those conditions related to wayfinding and recreation? Should I email you, Pam? Who should I email? Pam. Pam. Can I ask staff?
7:15:53 Is that unrealistic to meet at 8 o'clock if you're pulling an all-night on this? Yeah, it would be better for 9. Yeah, maybe we should do 9. Let's do 9. You guys are going to be burning the candle tonight. What's better for you guys? The commission's choice. You know, an hour in the morning doesn't help us. Let's do it at 9. That's not fair. We're working to go. Oh, okay. 9. 9? Okay. The chairman said. It means I have to ring the call. Is that it?
7:16:23 We will reconvene tomorrow morning at nine. I thank all of you that participated today. Your comments, we do take these under consideration. It's been a long day, but I think very fruitful. And if any of you have any questions, the staff or us, please feel free to forward them on. And those of you can join us and see you tomorrow morning at nine. Thank you.
7:16:51 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.