TransparentMammoth

Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2010

Planning & Economic Development Commission Continued meeting

· recording 2 hr 44 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

353 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 So this is coming out. Up there. Yeah.

0:33 Just because I think this is the reason that's the work to see, is Tom. Yeah, he doesn't. He doesn't have plenty of credit. So we haven't seen this picture for shows. I said, I just want a story. Well, as long as they're navigating. Yeah. They knew it. They knew it. You got to go previous first two times? Maybe because I was under pressure? Sure.

1:03 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

1:21 You know what, now it's under argument. I'll be leaving, so thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

1:51 Did we start talking?

1:52 Yeah.

1:53 Yeah.

1:53 I didn't need to hear it.

1:54 Yeah.

1:54 Yeah.

1:55 Yeah.

1:55 Yeah.

1:56 All right.

1:57 Thanks.

1:58 Bye.

1:59 Thank you.

2:00 Take it off.

2:01 Take it off.

2:02 Yeah.

2:03 All right.

2:04 All right.

2:05 All right.

2:06 I'll say goodbye.

2:07 Good seeing you at all.

2:08 And, you know.

2:09 OK.

2:10 I'll say goodbye.

2:11 Yeah.

2:12 Yeah.

2:13 Yeah.

2:14 Yeah.

2:15 Yeah.

2:16 Yeah.

2:17 Yeah.

2:18 Yeah.

2:21 What'd you do? Operated on it? I lowered the cone of silos. We were talking about some stuff in Israel. Oh. You just yanked that? Oh, that one over here. You just like a car thing? Yes. Ah.

3:01 What's left? I have to be gone. Are we going to turn these lights on? Lights? Be gone.

3:51 Not these. It's easy to share. Hey, if you can't carry on to the house, I was going to say, what is this? You just can't run even across the house. You guys will get together. Sorry. These are the conditions. Yeah, these are the conditions.

4:52 What time did y'all last night, lady? Oh, dear. Oh, dear. Oh, dear. Um, if you were required to, uh, perform field exceptions to implement weather, I can arrange that. Thank you. So it's kind of... Here, please. It is. It's like a... Yeah, we need, like, some... You are representing the town. Yeah.

5:31 From last night,

8:21 At this point, so according to our agenda, Mark, that you could help me with the protocol. It feels like we never went home, but I know there was actually a break. We were able to reconvene, or is there any other housekeeping business that you take care of, roll call, and should continue with that? It doesn't hurt to take roll call, but you are reconvened. This is a continuation of yesterday's, Karen. Thank you. We will do that. Let's take the roll call this morning. Karen?

8:57 Here. Here. Here. Yesterday we did have reports from the commission and we have opened and closed the public comments section yesterday. If there is anything new that comes to life today that needs further discussion or there's further questions, we will be entertaining those as well.

9:23 So at this point we are in our process. We are beginning to deliberate and arrive at a final decision regarding the project. And at this time I'd like Mark to present the draft revised conditions of approval that we discussed yesterday. We just got those compiled with strikeouts. So if we can review those first and see what other action we need to take. Thank you. Thank you, Chair.

9:51 New handouts today. One is a six-page, seven-page document showing revised conditions of approval. The other is a revision to the findings as requested by MLTPA. Both are dated March 11th. So if you don't mind, I'll review them first with the conditions.

10:14 There are two types of information shown on this, and it's organized substantially to the major headings of your now conditions. Revised text, text that's modifying an existing condition, is shown in strikeout underlined, so it's red underlined, and you can see any strikeouts there. And it's in the consistent numbering as shown in your existing conditions. We also have new language that you discussed.

10:44 And that language is shown underlined, but it's black and white only. And it's bulleted because it's going to change the numbering in the final conditions. So we didn't bother to do numbers for you. So I'm just going to read this to you. Some of the underlined stuff that appears to be additions is in red also, right?

11:06 I don't, I don't, well it's, if it's new information within an existing condition, it's read underlined. Right. So that's new, but if it's a completely new item, completely new condition, it's got some bullet underlined. So if I could do a brief summary, the first item on this page is an errata, it's a deletion to a duplicative condition, and so condition number 58 is struck.

11:35 The next is under planning general conditions, and this is language that our town attorney Peter Tracy has suggested, and he has recommended that we include this in all of our conditions of approval and master plans as we go forward. The purpose of this is just to provide financial protection to the town if we have to defend actions. Occasionally the towns and municipalities are sued.

12:04 Under CEQA, Administrative Law. So this is a harmless item. It doesn't affect the document at all. It's just protection to the town. The next items modify conditions number three and conditions number 97. These were provided by legal counsel, and they implement the subsequent modifications to ordinances.

12:32 That allows CBiz policies to not be in conflict with housing policies or impact fee policies or public art policies. So this is a technical legal correction and it doesn't affect your policy decisions, whatever you choose to make in the end. So these are legal items that have the town adopting ordinance revisions.

12:58 Prior to building permits or certificates of occupancy. And I'll pause to give you a moment to read them. So any questions on that? We discussed that earlier yesterday, and I think that language describes it. Correct. Whichever prevails. May I go on to page two? Next subject. These are a series of revisions.

13:34 that are speaking to valet parking requirements, on-street parking. They're pretty minor. We've also captured on page three some ideas. You mentioned melting the garage lamps. That's shown as a new condition. We've inserted new language about a delivery management plan, making sure that we're capturing your concerns about

14:04 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

14:32 It has to be able to accommodate a bus going under it. So there's a little height revision here. And then the final new addition on page three under mobility is the two-way concept. So it allows us to consider a two-way access flow in the future. So it just requires some future analysis. May I move on to design? These were specific comments that flowed from some of the ADP meetings.

15:14 Discussed in general and some comments provided by Elizabeth. We've added three new sub-items to this design. They're shown on page four. And these are really consistent with our design guidelines, making sure that boulders have natural. Our design guidelines actually say boulders should appear to be buried two-thirds underground. So this is in those tones.

15:45 Before you get off of that, just a minor question. Is there a possibility of conflict with public art there? And just for example, I'm thinking of the representation of Devil's Post file in the lobby of the Weston where it's more angular than in the real.

16:05 For me, the way staff will view this, these are landscape plans. Anything coming from a public art side will be specifically. Wouldn't come under this. Okay. Should we say excluding public art? Because I know that fountain was a potential public art piece, wasn't it? You could. Maybe include that. If you think that adds more clarity, that's fine. Okay, excluding. Are you okay with that, Jay? Sure. And I have a question about E as well.

16:32 Talking about making the landscaping more natural in appearance, the curvature of the waterway goes through it, goes around one of the plazas in a very geometric way. Is that the only way it can work? Do you know what I'm saying? The landscaping there with Ross is actually, we can make that much more loose and formal, particularly the edges. Yeah, okay, that's what I was concerned about on the plan.

16:58 You know, I also had a concern I didn't bring up yesterday. Can I insert it here under design, even though... If you have the consensus of the commission. Okay. Mother, may I, yes. Okay. The space between the River Terrace and the restaurant and the corner of the hotel, how wide is that space? It looks a little bit like a slot, you know, on the plot plan, but of course the scale is very, very small. The space between the columns and the...

17:25 Where you go from the river terrace and then does it just naturally flow for human traffic or does it look like you've got to slip through a narrow slot to... Well, right here it is about 25 feet. Oh, 25? That's fine. Okay, good. Yeah. So may I... Thank you. Thank you, Mark. Wayfinding number 69.

17:57 This is not specifying the kiosk. It's specifying the plan shall include information similar to the trails way of finding type 2 kiosk. If you have any questions about that, Peter Bernstein has his specifications. Peter, is that the map sign? That's correct. It's got the map sign as well as the destinations and trail types for the whole system. Okay. And there's provisions for handouts, little brochures that may be available.

18:28 For each of the routes. Would it be possible to ensure with that that it shows how you get there from here? In other words, if this is the center of town, how you get to these places, does it have a you are here component on the map? It does. Okay. And I think that's what is inherited in these things. Okay. Okay. And I'm not quite sure how kiosk is used here because I think of that as a cylindrical thing, you know, on a street corner.

18:56 With ads for events on it. Isn't that term defined in the... That just defines the sign type. Okay. So the type 2 sign kiosk actually has a little bit of a roof on it. But what we're asking is that the map, the wayfinding system, include that information. Okay. Because that sign might not be appropriate if it's in the lobby of the hotel. Oh, exactly, yeah. But this would be... How many locations would this be? Would this map be available on site?

19:26 That's what the plan would show. So if the commission wants it to be in more than one location, you might... Oh, at least two, I would think. Find that in the plan. Ah, in the wayfinding plan. Okay, okay, thank you. Yeah, I think we should define it, not specify a number now. Okay. You might think one would be enough, or you might think three needed. Okay, okay, but that's good. But that's the plan will illustrate. Right. Good. Does this language ensure that the wayfinding signage...

19:56 On the project is, conforms to the standards, you know, is the same as the rest of the trails and wayfinding system, it's going to be a part of that? This condition would need to be modified to ensure that we're using the, maybe we could add something that says the exterior signage would be similar to the, our sign standards. I'm just thinking of the desire to have that overall system be integrated.

20:24 Does that make sense to have it within the project the same as the rest of around town? I certainly think there should be some elements of it that, you know, coordinate with the rest of the sign system. I thought that's what Type 2 Keown system did. Well, we said there was information, should include information on that sign plan and include the sign taps similar to the... That's the substance, and I'm kind of talking about the form. Yes, that's what, to include the sign.

20:52 So I guess the question is, is it our intent to have this particular level of signage be a part of the trail system signage? If it is, it would need to be the same, regardless of the design elements that maybe the project is incorporated because of just this. Now, they may have other design elements and signage on their property, but this is...

21:19 is showing the connectivity, and if that's what we're talking about, it would be the same, and it might need a little bit more language, because it could be completely different than the design elements of the properties project. I think we ought to get the applicant's input on that, too. I just want to clarify what we're asking. How do you...

21:39 So the town is developing a consistent template, first for a trail system wayfinding program, and then we'll move on to some similar family design for directionals on streets and roads. And so as we develop a program, there'll be design consistency, and the question to you is, how much consistency do you want to incorporate in an on-site program that will be a condition of your future plans?

22:21 So I think we're excited about that consistency, and I think it's a wonderful step in creating a consistent look and feel throughout all of the community. We want to work with the town to make sure that we support it, but I think we want to have a little variation within the development itself to have some characterization and some uniqueness that makes it unique to the environment.

22:47 We're willing to and absolutely interested in working with you to support your initiative, but we want to be able to be compatible, but maybe have some variation for uniqueness of location. So with that, I might suggest that we look at number 69 and say a wayfinding plan insert that is complementary to the town's

23:17 Design, Wayfinding and Design System, comma, shall be submitted to and approved by. Do you have consensus that it gives us the freedom? I'm fine with that. I want to accomplish the objective, and complimentary I think is fine, but I want it to be the level of the type 2 wayfinding sign. I mean, I want it to be not just a little out of the way.

23:46 map someplace, but I want it to be something. You weren't deleting this, the added sentence that was already there, were you, Mark? No. Oh, you're leaving that one. We're leaving that one. Okay. That's being left. Okay. That's being left. That's great. Are you okay with that? Mm-hmm. Okay. Thank you. Okay. Thank you. Are there any other questions on that page? I have a question on page one, but I can wait until the end to go back to that. You got through that too fast, and I didn't get my question in, so I'll wait until the end. Okay, so we'll go back to one.

24:24 At the end. So no questions on that page. Page 5, at the top, under the landscaping section, some specific modifications to landscaping specifications are proposed. And also on item 80, just reinforcing special care to be taken to preview the existing trees through and during construction.

24:52 I might add to B, height requirement, or height required, or height specified, to B at the top of that page. Saying you want to decide a height now, or? No, it'll be on the plans, and they were talking about eight feet, but the height required or specified? Sure. So you want to say tree sizes shall include container or gallon size in addition to height of tree? Or height specified?

25:26 Rather than just 8 foot tree. In addition to specified height. Yeah, that's better. Got it. A little bit belt suspenders. Under signs, this is just a, it's just more specific to who approves, so this requires both ADP review, and I think the intent under this is to make sure that the master sign plan and the architecture and some of the design comments that were made during the ADP process are knitted together.

25:59 We received a comment about affordable housing and the recreation area could be. Excuse me. I'm sorry. This is going faster than I'm keeping up with. What I was expressing a preference for is to have the master sign plan submitted at the 50% design development stage. That was included on page 4 under item G, signage design including retail signs should be integrated into the project design.

26:29 And we can add at that point in time. We can add it to either one and say... We're going faster than I can keep up. I'm a speed reader, but I can't keep up with all these details today. Just to be clear then, on this 91, we should say I'm submitted at the design development level, which correlates to other criteria in the ADP and revisions. Do you want to take a few minutes for yourself to go through the rest of that so that you...

26:59 I haven't, it's going faster than I'm ready, so I'm ready word for word. On 80, can we go back to 80? Second red line to ensure that their root zones and trunks are protected. There's a typo there. Okay, now we're at 90, we're at 100. Is that right? I'm up to speed now. Yeah, affordable housing. So I just want to clarify on that point so that it's consistent with condition number 64.

27:45 We'll say at, so revised drugs will be submitted at design development stage. Good. That's good. Instead of no later than. Yes. Portable housing? Question? Any questions on that? No. Page six.

28:46 This is a new condition, trash recycling. Prior to the issuance of a building permit, the applicant shall submit a trash and recycling management plan that ensures efficient, convenient, and unobtrusive removal of trash, restaurant waste, shipping materials, and disposable recyclables. I have a question, please, if I could, for Mr. Ashworth. In the design, and I'm sorry for bringing this up now, it just kind of came to me, but up in the village, one of the main problems with

29:22 Trash recycling is the grease traps of the restaurant and the cleaning out of them and how they're maintained. Have you, in your whole design, is that something, are we going to see these trucks parked on Old Mammoth Road with hoses going across the sidewalks or is there a more defined area?

29:47 This is an issue that often comes up, particularly in resort areas. It's a good question. What we've done in other resort locations and what we've proposed here is to locate those grease traps in the garage. Okay, great. That's a great solution. Thank you. Continue storm water management. Any issues with that? No. And Peter, is this going to the storm water management plan? Is that going to be able to tie into the town system so we don't have problems, downside or upside of town or the project?

30:23 Yeah, correct. It came to light with some issues with the village related to overflows into our storm system when they didn't really know what they had. Thank you. Next is the 10-foot promise condition, and I hope we captured your thoughts. But how about the fence? How about the attractive fence with a mural on it or peepholes, you know, on Little Mammoth Roadside. We don't need it anywhere else, but an attractive fence. It's there.

30:56 Oh, I don't see fence. Or is it someplace else? Well, it doesn't say that. Yeah, it doesn't use the word fence. If you would like to add that, we should specifically place it here and say that construction fence, old fate fronting old Mammoth Road, shall be attractive and interesting. Yeah, because it's not called a fence, correct? There's another term. They had a good fence around Grand Sierra when that was...

31:28 Built, and this one can do even better. Dana, sorry. Just on that same point yesterday, I thought... You should come to the mic. Are we still on TV? Yes. Thank you. Good morning to you all. Just on that point, I thought, if I recollect the conversation correctly yesterday when we discussed this item, it was a hardscaping, i.e. a sidewalk, and a fencing component.

31:58 But this includes language that is a little more expansive in that it references landscaping. And I would think landscaping, that's kind of going to be problematic. I mean, you've got all this construction going on. Where does the water come from to do the landscaping? Because you're not going to have an irrigation system there.

32:20 So I think yesterday, just the landscaping was not, we didn't discuss yesterday, so this is new, and I think it's just, you know, practically speaking, a little problematic. Would you be okay with adding something in about working with the public art to perhaps do, as Elizabeth mentioned, a mural on the, in place of landscaping? Yeah, I think it's a great idea. But the last thing we want are utility lights with plywood overhead and, you know, warp plywood walkway.

32:46 You know, for three years, you know what I'm, like you see in the city. You know what I'm saying, you know, like you see in the city. So what we're looking at is replacing the word landscaping with arcade fencing, which allows you to see a representation of the finished project. That'd be great. You know, even rather than looking through to see their building, I'd rather look through and see the diorama of what it's going to look like. That's a good idea, too. But it's replacing the arcade fence.

33:15 The landscape. Perfect. Even though most construction activity is going to be beyond the fence, I appreciate what Dana's saying about the problems of maintaining the landscaping. Yes, that's, we don't want to. I hadn't even thought about that. Yeah, I think we'd be very interested in doing something specifically or the representative of the project along the fence line. It would be very attractive and help people understand what's going on. That'd be great.

33:39 Good. Thank you. So we just delete in landscaping? Yeah, arcade fencing. Arcade fencing. Arcade fencing. It's to show. That's a new word. Okay. Well, it's to show. Barricade or arcade? Do you want arcade or barricade? Why don't we give them a choice and let them work with it a little bit? Fencing. Fencing. Okay, good. I still think there's another term we use in the village, like hoarding. Thank you, hoarding.

34:04 It's actually what it's called, it's construction hoarding, and that's the fence that goes around the property. Hoarding? That's not the chain link? No, it's not chain link, it's the wood, and that's the term for it. H-O-A-R-D-I-N-G. Thank you, Peter, I knew I just couldn't get it out of my head. Okay. Thank you. You might want to put that in quotes. Yeah, so it actually is hoarding. I thought that was saving old newspapers. Yeah, exactly. You're familiar with that term too, right? The hoarding?

34:34 Okay. I got it. Okay. Thank you. The next items are water resources, and these are verbatim from the water district letter with one exception, which is, I think on number C, we added, no, I think it's D. Yeah, we put evaluate in front of all of them. Thank you. Right. Just because some of them said evaluate and consider and others said install. Okay. Can we insert and consider?

35:04 Can we insert and consider? What's going on? If you would like to finish, evaluate the feasibility and consider for each one is what I would like to see. Evaluate and consider throughout. Thank you. Any other questions on page six? No. So is E, evaluate and consider? Yes.

35:55 For the four of them. Yeah. Okay. Well, and also on page seven. On seven. Oh, yes. Very tall. Yeah, where it just says considered. Moving on to easements, we noted that we didn't have this standard language in our condition, and we caught that after our discussion. And then finally, the last revision I had, you had a discussion about encouraging the highest level possible, but not requiring it. So this is just a...

36:34 Can we change in the second line A minimum to at minimum? That's stronger. But doesn't California 2010 green building code? That's LEED certified. That brings them to LEED certified. Yes. No, no, no, I'm saying the project applicant shall seek at minimum LEED silver, and I certainly hope it's going to be more than that. Then you need at minimum A LEED silver if you want to be really correct. Well, that's better. Yeah. Thank you.

37:05 We have several grammarians up here. Commissioner Tenney would go back to page one. Okay, I've really tried to get my head around this one. This is 97. Would you speak, Mark, to the letter from Mammoth Lakes Housing and how requiring what's in the Clearwater-specific plan with the option of going back to do an alternative housing mitigation proposal, why that's different than what...

37:34 The CBiz policy, which postdates the Clearwater Specific Plan. I'm having problems with the CBiz policy anyway, but can you talk about this a little bit? I didn't follow. Sure, I want to refer to, so this is only a legal time in question. I just want you to be sure that you understand that. Yeah, I don't. Okay, I need this. And I'll quote from the March 9th memorandum from...

37:59 C-Biz is intended as a bridge framework to be further implemented through conforming changes to the town's municipal code. So the policy does not trump the code. So where there is conflict, we have to correct the conflict in order for it to be implemented. So C-Biz is a policy adopted by resolution pursuant to general principles of municipal law, does not have the effect of amending or superseding ordinances.

38:28 Codified into the town's municipal code. Therefore, to implement the intent of the policy and any incentive proposal approved for Old Mammoth Place or other developments, the town will need to draft and adopt by ordinance amendments to the development impact fee ordinance, public arts program ordinance, and the workforce housing ordinance to expressly exempt incentive densities from the calculation of development impact fees, art requirements, and housing requirements.

38:58 These amendments would need to be adopted prior to the date that applications for building permits are submitted to the town for projects such as Old Mammoth Place that seek incentive density. So the issue is only one of internal consistency between municipal code requirements and policies that are adopted by resolution. So the council has adopted the incentive zoning policy and we're adhering to that. And to avoid the...

39:27 Technical legal issues raised in the Mammoth Housing letter. This is the thing to do. So basically adding this language, if the incentive density approved as part of CBIS is excluded? Correct. And then I have a question, and we're not in public comment, and I'm fully aware of that, but since Pam is here as the director of MLH, could we hear from her possibly on this? Are you satisfied with this?

39:59 Because I have a feeling you may not be. Good morning. Pam Hennerty with Mammoth Lakes Housing. Thank you for the opportunity to speak on this. And just to answer the question, I think that Mammoth Lakes Housing concern, in the letter, we asked for compliance with 1736. If, as Mark says, 1736 is modified to adopt the ramifications of the CBIS policy and that affordable housing is then waived,

40:29 In the density bonus units, then asking for compliance with 1736 isn't out of line because 1736 will in theory be amended to reflect those changes. I am in awe of your ability to go through all of these conditions of approval so quickly because while you've been doing this, I've just been reading 97 and trying to evaluate the language. I do think that

40:58 Based on the letter from Kevin Ennis and the information that Mark Ordlaw just gave to you, I think that if the zoning code amendment goes through and 1736 is modified to implement SEVIS, then simplifying this condition of approval to say that the project will comply with 1736 that's in effect at the time of grading permit, or they may come and ask for an alternative housing mitigation plan, would simplify that altogether.

41:28 I do think that if the condition is to stay as it's written, I think there are some potential conflicts in it, and so I'm not sure if you want to deliberate on what I've just said or not, but I do think that on page one, after the red language speaking to if the CBIS density is excluded, it does say this shall be mitigated through construction of units on site. Then if you turn the page,

41:57 And you go to the next red language, it does say an alternative housing mitigation plan and amendment to 1736 shall be proposed. It's either in compliance with 1736 or it's an alternative housing mitigation plan and I think that both those shalls are in conflict. If the language were to stay as it is, I would also ask that you would include in that sentence

42:27 Shall be proposed for review by Mammoth Lakes Housing and approval by the Town of Mammoth Lakes. Additionally, at the end, I would request that this alternative housing mitigation plan, if it were to be required, include any changes made to 1736, not just those.

42:53 that are adopted to implement the SEVIS policy. As you know, we've been talking about significant changes to the 1736, and while it references livability and other issues that we may be working on in the coming months, I just want to make sure it's clear that it's not just those changes that are required to implement SEVIS, but any changes to 1736. So Pam, on that point, if I can suggest some language, and you tell me if this implements what you're asking.

43:21 Starting with the red line, red underlined, any revisions to chapter 1736, that revision? Yes. If it said, any revisions to chapter 1736 of the town code, including those that change mitigation rates or fees, would that do what you're asking? If you add in there, including those before that change? I think so, and then I would also say at the end, yeah, I think if you put any changes, any change to mitigation rates, fees,

43:56 Provisions, livability. And then at the very end that are adopted, including those to implement the CBIS policy. I think you'll have to hear from the applicant on this because they are requesting a testing map. Right. And I just, you know, I think that the whole thing could just be in accordance with Netflix Housing's letter if they were required to comply with 1736 at the time of grading permit.

44:22 Is this something that we could do possibly, as we've done with Snow Creek in the past, where the applicant, Pam, and staff, you work on this language to satisfy all three parties? I think I'd rather not do that in that this is the public hearing and I don't want to have a resultant document that's not conformed with what you said.

44:48 What this strikeout language says in its full context is that an alternative housing mitigation plan and amendment to Chapter 17, et cetera, shall be proposed for review and approval by the town. We're not opposed to review by an LH and Planning Commission.

45:09 Prior to the issues of the grading permit, by which the incentive density is proposed to be excluded from the workforce housing. So this is written this way to have the belts and suspenders to make sure that the policy is consistent with the law. So that's why it's written that way. This is not trying to skirt something. It's trying to just maybe tie the policy.

45:32 existing and future changes to implement. I'd like to hear from Elizabeth, but I think, you know, the changes that Pam were mentioning myself, I think, are relevant to have here, so, but Elizabeth. Before we hear from the applicant, I've got some questions. What we approved in the Clearwater Specific Plan was it would be subject to the requirements of 1736, as we all agree on that. And yet, that is under consideration, under evaluation, it's going to be revised.

46:01 So why, and this is what's troubled me from the beginning, is why are we putting in eight three-bedroom units or equivalent on site? Why are we specifying when the policy hasn't been changed? I know that's related to the CDIS. That's completely wrong. I just want to be sure that you understand. I don't, so explain it to me. The specific plan ties the project to the housing ordinance. The specific plan also says it shall conform to the incentive zoning program.

46:31 And as you know, the conflict that we've already discussed in great detail is that the policy has slightly different requirements and allowances than does the ordinance. It's the policy that has looked at the...

46:48 The entire program, not just housing, not just diff payments. And so to implement that policy, whatever you choose to act on through the program, you need to make sure that it's consistent with law and not in conflict with law. So this language isn't setting up 8 or 16 or 30 units. It's just making sure that if there is a conflict between policy...

47:10 and between the ordinance, we've reconciled it and we've included the language in the conditions of approval so that you're not on the face of it taking something that appears to have a conflict with it. So don't, in this subject, don't talk about how many units are on site. This is only a mechanism to make sure that the policy implementation is consistent with future amendments to the codes.

47:36 But Council Kevin Ennis says that the ordinance trumps the policy. And that's what these revisions correct. It lets you act on this permit, and the town council will act on their actions, whatever their decisions are. And then before the project pulls a building permit, the town will have had to correct the ordinances to make it internally consistent. That's all this is.

48:03 And then it also specifies, as the Clearwater Specific Plan, which was based on the original concept proposal, which had a block of workforce housing at the north end of the property, all units were on site, does it still have to be on site, since it appears to me that we're sort of adjusting to the specific plan. No, we talked about this yesterday in the public hearing, that the specific plan allows on site or an alternative housing mitigation program. Okay, okay, the proposal.

48:33 Hmm. So Mark, can I ask, based on what you just said, and I think this sort of, Elizabeth and I are sort of having some of the same trouble in the language in this condition, and I understand that you're, the reconciliation that needs to take place, but this condition does say this shall be mitigated through eight units on site, and then a couple sentences later is say there shall be an alternative housing mitigation plan. I think that's the concern that I have, is if

49:03 1736 is amended to reflect CBiz, then would that reduction in affordable housing requirement be required as an alternative housing mitigation plan or would it just be in compliance with 1736? I think the idea is to allow the alternative affordable housing plan to be, the findings to be changed so that that is the tool.

49:33 That allows its conformance to the basic requirement to be met. So, Mark, then why can we not just delete this shall be mitigated through the construction of it to eight three-bedroom units? If the plan is going to solve it and it's going to be mitigated that way, then why do we need both languages? That's what's causing all my confusion.

49:59 Yeah, whichever way it comes out, well, the language will specify how it has to be. So we should strike that language and just leave it in with the mitigated housing plan. Yeah, it's probably appropriate to hear from the opposite. Thank you. Mark Carney, good morning. We understand Pam's concern and it's a valid concern. And I think what Pam is saying is if the language just said

50:28 That we would be subject to the affordable housing mitigation rules that are in place when we pull the grading permit. That seems fair to us. And it's less complicated than what we're doing right now. As long as it also allows us to go from the affordable housing mitigation plan. And as long as there's a mandate that the town will actually process this change to the ordinance.

50:58 The way it's phrased right now is that the problem with the language on the second page is it doesn't have the subject in the sentence and there's two different things going on and you don't know who's required to do what and it actually mandates us as a consequence. When you read the sentence in the middle of the page it says an alternate housing mitigation plan and amendment to chapter 1736 shall be proposed for review. Well, there's two different parties here.

51:26 One is going to propose the amendment to review, and the other may propose the alternative housing mitigation plan. We need the town to be mandated to agree that they're going to pursue this amendment to the ordinance, but we want to have the ability and not the requirement to seek an affordable housing mitigation plan. So I think that these two separate subjects need to be broken down in separate sentences. How would you rewrite it? I would have one sentence that says that

51:54 The town shall process an amendment to Chapter 1736 for review and approval by the town, etc. In other words, the town agrees that it will pursue this amendment to the housing ordinance to reconcile it with cedars. See, if it doesn't happen, it puts Mr. Dimitri at a great risk. Oh, of course. And that's what we've got to avoid.

52:22 By the same token, we don't want to be told that we must come forward with an affordable housing mitigation plan because 1736 at the time of green permit just might be just fine for us and we may not need to see that. So I think it needs to be broken into two sentences and each of us with a talent with a requirement and also an opportunity. Now, I mean, I don't want to blur out language right now. I'll be happy to work on language and submit it to you later on this morning.

52:55 Maybe we take a 10-minute break at some point. I do want to talk about another issue that's related, which is even more important to us. Mark, before you go off, can I close on a response to this? Sure. Yes, I think we can delete that sentence that says, this shall be mitigated. So we're going to delete the entire sentence? Yes. Beginning with this shall, ending with workforce housing units.

53:24 Right. And then we should also specify at the top of page two, the first sentence that keeps running on, and then it ends, and approved by town of town and Mammoth Lakes Housing prior to each instance of grading permit, you should change grading to building.

53:51 Building permit? Throughout. Throughout the document. It's tied to the building permit. It was just an error. Are you hearing anyone? Dana? You've heard that. Okay. Do you want to take a break now to craft this, or do you want to come back? I mean, now that we're on this, because it seems to be, you might want to take this all in context, but it's up to you. Right, so let's make sure we all understand what we're talking about. Exactly.

54:20 The purpose of 3 and 97 conditions is to create the legal tie that says, that acknowledges that we need to have the policy consistent with the code and vice versa. And so this is allowing the project to be acted on by you now, recognizing that it needs to be reconciled, and if it does, everything's fine. It sets up a process and a method.

54:50 If through the reconciliation it isn't modified, then it's also saying that the applicant has to abide by whatever rules are in place at that time and or if there is no change to what's being applied for in this vesting. So it's protecting both the town and the applicant, but it's not committing anybody to determine what it will be saying it must be reconciled. So we would never

55:20 State in a condition like this, that the town shall do this, and we would bind the commission and the council to a future action. So that's the concept. And by taking out the specificity of the number of units here, it allows that program to be resolved later. I agree essentially with everything Mark just said. And in terms of the process, how I would propose that we proceed is...

55:43 We have a number of responses to the various comments you've made to these revisions. I think the most efficient procedure would be to let us just tell you what our comments are, and then to the extent we need to have a 10-minute break to revise, we can just do it once and don't have to revise. So let's go through the rest of it first. I've got a couple of comments, and then we can break and write some language.

56:10 The condition that causes us the most concern. Mark, I think we're about finished with our end of it, and then I would love to give it back to you. Oh, I beg your pardon. Yeah, I think we just have a couple other issues and then keep the continuity of it. Okay, so we went back to issues regarding 97 on number one, and...

56:37 Did we, we were back, yeah, I thought we were almost done. On page seven. On seven, we were at easements and sustainability. Yeah, we finished, we finished that. We have an at a, on page seven. So, if you don't have any other comments to these, we can speak to this. I just want to make a comment that, you know, yesterday I asked about the ice rink.

57:03 And all that. And I understand that there's probably a legal issue with us that we can't include that as a condition. Can you just fill us in on that? Is there an issue with, you know, putting in that he would work with, that the applicant would work with the town? I think that, so what your comments were yesterday is in looking at the plaza space, summer events plaza, proposed to be a winter ice rink, a temporary type fixture,

57:34 You saw benefit to that and you thought that that was a valuable amenity to the town and to the district and to the site. So if you wanted to affect that and if you could either leave the program as described or you could add more detail that says the applicant shall provide a temporary ice rink and then if your thoughts were also as to operating and maintaining that, you could do that. As to

58:04 Some other larger relationship to what the town's doing, I think that you shouldn't put those comments into the conditions of approval. If you wanted to forward thoughts and comments as you did to the Public Arts Commission, you could certainly do that to the Recreation Commission or to the Town Council, whatever body you thought appropriate. So I think what I'd like to do is just, depending what the commission bills, is make a recommendation to Parks and Rec to

58:35 begin those discussions themselves with the applicant and not tie it to these conditions at this time? Absolutely. That's a good idea. They may not know anything about that, but I don't think it would be a condition of approval at this point. So if we can just make a recommendation actually that council sees to pursue it and that the applicant and the council can pursue that with Parks and Rec. Sharon, you're fine with that? Good.

59:01 So am I noting something that the Planning Commission is recommending the Tourism and Recreation Commission to discuss and pursue this as some broader town purpose with the applicant directly? And the purpose of that is really Tourism Rec is in charge of that ice rink, so let's have them make those decisions and take it forward just with our recommendation. Can I note consensus? Yes. Thank you. One more addition.

59:30 And 174, I really want to emphasize, at a minimum. So can we say, shall seek, comma, at a minimum, underlined, comma, a lead silver certification. Shall seek, comma, at a, underlined, at a minimum, underlined, at a minimum, three words, at a minimum, comma.

59:54 Should we add italics for added emphasis? And bold face and 16 point type. Because I think it's going to happen. You don't want to change it to platinum? Of course I want to change it to platinum, but you know, who knows when the economy will turn around, who knows how long I'm going to live, and I just got to get my emphasis on the... You don't know what you get until they award it. Exactly. Any other comments to this?

1:00:18 Not from us. Just the Mammoth Lakes Housing issue that we're going to resolve. I had more trouble with the housing language than any other single word in all this stuff. It's very conceptual. The last attachment, the second attachment we have is the one page. This was finding number three in the packet and the MLTPA.

1:00:44 Specifically requested that you add a finding that is stating that the project that you're discussing, whatever it is you approve, that you're making the broadest finding that it's meeting all of the goals of the town. So we added, as a last sentence to this paragraph,

1:01:03 That the Planning Commission would be making this finding. Further, the benefits accruing to the community from the project's proposed features and amenities have been determined to achieve relevant community goals to a greater extent than would be achieved through the payment of impact fees and other exaction that may be forgone pursuant to the community benefits and incentive zoning policy. Why do you use the word relevant? Because they should be relevant. And, you know, the town's goals... Relevant to what?

1:01:33 When we go to the general plan, we have a host of goals that include, you know, all of those that are captured in the triple bottom line. We have specific goals, policies, and objectives to recreation and trails, to social stability, to retail, to animation. So by speaking relevant goals, that captures everything. And I don't think, I think it's,

1:02:02 Less graceful to try to specify individual goals. No, how about just deleting relevant? Well, how about if you delete relevant and say community goals, comma, as defined in the general plan, comma. Oh, I like that. Relevant makes it sound sort of cherry picking. To achieve community goals as defined in the general plan, comma. Thank you. And they're per se relevant because the general plan tells us what's relevant. I like that better.

1:02:34 Why are we using foregone instead of lost? Because it's a better word. If you want to change it, you may. I prefer lost. I don't. Foregone. Because that's subjective. I'm okay with foregone. Foregone isn't? I don't think it's as subjective as lost. Ah, okay. Just one more comment on that. I don't know. I don't think it implies I need to change this language any further.

1:03:15 In the letter from MLTPA, where they requested this, they said, should you choose to approve the applications for Old Mammoth Place without any requirement for recreation and trails mitigation or fees, MLTPA requests that the project findings include language. I just want to note that what they're referring to, our approval, would not be without any requirement for recreation and trails mitigation. It's only that the portion of the mitigation

1:03:45 And fees that would come from the incentive portions of the project is foregone. Not all of it. There's still fees paid on the other parts of the project, just for clarification. That's how I read it and understood it. Does it need more language? I don't think it needs more language. I think you've thoroughly considered those factors in all of your deliberations. Could we maybe send a reply back to MLTPA after this by the Chair?

1:04:15 Defining that more for them as to what our decision was just so it actually gives a reply back to them that they could use. I'm willing to work with staff on that. That would be. I absolutely support that. Okay. Mark's going to talk to us. Okay. Do we have any other discussion on these before we hear from the applicant, Mark? Well, have we captured, did we capture your thoughts on your deliberation? Do you have anything to add?

1:04:51 I just wanted to make mention that of all the years that we've all been working together and trying to achieve things, that

1:05:22 It gave me a very good feeling to have you state yesterday that you had a good feeling from all of the meetings and working with this applicant, and I really appreciate that. I sincerely do. And I'm very happy that today that you do have that feeling and we can move forward in our town. So I wanted to thank you. Okay. Mark, please, identify what we have issues. Thank you. I'd just like to pick up, really, if I may, on the point that Tony just made.

1:05:55 We also want to thank Ms. Eckerd for her openness to what we've been trying to accomplish for the past four years. And the same goes through for Ms. Gesford in particular, because you may recall that Ms. Gesford was among the people who spearheaded the attempt to overthrow the specific plan through a referendum.

1:06:22 And to hear her come out yesterday and actually say that she was in awe of what we have accomplished was an incredible statement, I think, and reflects really well on her. And I was kind of in awe of her being able to say that under those circumstances. So we were very impressed with the graciousness that she and Ms. Eckert showed. Now, to the point.

1:06:50 that we're most concerned about is Condition 3. And I want to make it clear that we understand what Condition 3 is intended to accomplish. And we, although it's problematic because it creates great vulnerability to Mr. Demetriatus in terms of what may happen

1:07:14 In that ordinance update process. Anytime there's more discretion by the town council, especially if it's a new town council, we just don't know whether the town council's ordinance will proceed in a manner which is consistent with the SEVIS policy. So you can imagine that that vulnerability is something that's of great concern to us. Bluntly stated, what happens if the town council changes its mind and says that it doesn't want to exempt the incentivized density?

1:07:44 from the DIF ordinance or the affordable housing mitigation ordinance. That's a $6 million cost right back to the developer, which would not have been anticipated at this stage. So the setup is problematic, but I haven't been able to think of anything that we could do to overcome it, because I think that Mr. Ennis' opinion...

1:08:11 is a reasonable, rational opinion, and it's fundamentally based upon the acknowledgement that a policy adopted by a resolution doesn't have the effect of amending an ordinance, and I don't disagree with that legal opinion at all. Having said that, the language that is proposed in paragraph 3 goes way beyond that concept. It actually makes the approval of the TTM, the use permit, and the use permit,

1:08:41 Contingent upon the town actually amending those ordinances. And we can't have that. What I think the intent would be is that the application of the CBIS policies, in other words, the reduction of the fees or the foregone fees being applied is contingent upon.

1:09:06 The ordinance is being adopted, but not the approval of the tentative tract map and the use permit, right? The consequence of losing, of having to pay another $6 million more would be bad enough. The consequence of not having your TTM and use permit approved would be drastic and dramatic and would never have been intended by this language. So, I think, because if you read it, what it says is that the approval of the best tentative tract map and the use permit is contingent

1:09:35 upon the Town Council approval of the district going on it. Absolutely true. We agree. But it's not contingent and shouldn't be contingent upon the Town's further action with respect to those ordinances. Now, the application of foregone fees is contingent upon further action by the Town Council and amending the ordinances.

1:10:04 But not the approval of the tentative tract map of use permit. Now that's setting up the problem. Is everybody in sync on that? So we need to fix that. And the first sentence before the redlining stands as is, we accept. That's the reality. You're still talking about three, condition three. And then you want period after district zoning amendment? Exactly. And then we need to draft another sentence that says where's the effect that

1:10:34 The waiver of the fees is contingent upon approval of an ordinance. So, do you agree with that, Mark? I don't know if waiver of the fees isn't the right words. I mean, if they had a break, we can pick a better way to say it. Because we can't wait, because basically what we'd be doing is waiting until the town...

1:11:05 Got around to amending its diff ordinances and its affordable housing mitigation ordinances, the RFI ordinance, until we get an approval. Yeah, you still want to have an approval. Until we have a use permit. No matter what we're doing. Yeah, I understand the issues. The approval's tied up. I think that's correct. Okay. So I think when we get into the working session here, I think it'll be easy for Mark and me to separate this out into two sentences and really reflect the intention of the...

1:11:30 of the legal council. Do we have consensus on that? I'm not sure what you're asking, Mark. You're asking that when you do, in other words, you're tying the town to these fees being wavered? No. I'm trying to make sure that our approval of the TTM and use permit isn't tied to future action by the council beyond the DZA. We all know that whatever you do, if you approve this today,

1:12:00 That the approval is going to be contingent upon the DZA. Everybody agrees with that, and that's absolutely right. There's another concept, however, and that is this concept of reconciling the CEDIS policy with the three other ordinances. Now, whether or not that happens should not affect whether we get our use permit approval or TTM approval.

1:12:29 What it should affect is whether we benefit from the policy, from the CBIS policy in terms of the foregone fees. That's what I'm focused on. Okay. So I'm just trying to separate the concepts. Okay. And it's actually the opposite of your statement. It says they can't waive the fees. I'm sorry, they can't? The fees cannot be waived unless there's a subsequent amendment. So it's actually...

1:12:57 I think that the application of foregone fees is contingent upon future action by the Town Council in amending its ordinances. That would be, in effect, the wording of the second sentence. Okay. I think we've...

1:13:24 made our points with respect to 97. All that really is left to do is to sit down with Mark and craft that language. Right. And with that, I'm going to turn it over to Chapman for some more topics. Thank you. All right. Thank you. Let me pull up one side plan because I think it will help explain one of the questions that we want to bring up. Sure. Okay. Let's get into this. I think folks know that maybe Margaret, where are you a pointer? Yes.

1:14:05 It would be nice to get the lights. I can barely see it, even though I feel like I know it by heart now. One of the items we wanted to ask for a slight reconsideration on is one of the new conditions. It's the third one that basically requests that the Port Cochere be designed to accommodate a 40-foot vehicle at the check-in area. And we assume that that is really for a tour bus drop-off.

1:14:34 And we'd like to propose an alternate there. We had always, one of the things that we would hate to see happen would be to have a tour bus, for example, disrupt the regular day-to-day flow back and forth between the lobby. What we had always anticipated is right here, and this came up yesterday, there's a location here where we had designed for a tour bus to be able to come, pull in, and be able to drop off in a very nice league.

1:15:01 landscaped area that's out of the way of the right of way but isn't necessarily affecting the port cocher and the hotel entry. So we'd like to propose to change the word port cocher to project and after vehicle at at the hotel. So the language would read the project shall be designed to accommodate a 40 foot vehicle at the hotel check-in area.

1:15:30 And that should be designed, you know, and the rest is consistent with what's written. Isn't that too tight a turn? Is a 40-foot, like a regular coach, you know, a tour bus, a nice tour bus? Yes. Yes, it is. That's 40 feet. And isn't that too tight to be able to pull in? No, we have actually, we may have to, for example, redesign these trees a little bit. They may be kind of placed improperly. But there's actually plenty of room to pull off and into this slot.

1:15:57 Right in here in order to accommodate that tour bus. I think this issue is not about tour buses. Yeah, the tour bus turning radius would be significantly bigger. It would be like a WB-62. Stop 42 feet. No, it's bigger. They're about 55 feet long, a tour bus. Oh, okay. And they have a WB-62 radius, which is significantly bigger than the 40. This is really about getting the little buses, the little buses, meaning the mid-range buses, the luxury buses that the mountain uses.

1:16:26 From the airport, those kinds of shuttle buses, or the YARCH type bus, so they're not the bigger buses, but they're the ones that have about a 30 to 32 foot wheelbase. In addition, it's the nuisance, you know, we know, or the fire district knows from experience that projects like this have somewhere between, you know, 5 and 10 calls a month that are not nuisance calls, but they're alarm calls activated by burnt toast, basically.

1:16:55 And so the main panel for the panel activation, you know, they're going to be wanting to pull into this driveway or they'll block the street off for an hour or so to actually identify what the problem is. And so that's the concern. So it's those two uses. But wouldn't you want them also to maybe pull into this area as opposed to block the port co-chair? Well, the port co-chair is wide enough so that you've got, you know, you've got multiple stacking there. So they're not going to block the whole thing up. It's just enough so they can actually drive through.

1:17:24 We don't want the fire trucks cooling up five times a month. Actually, we could change the condition and say it'll just be per the fire district's requirements and then it could be resolved later, but they don't prefer to actually block the street.

1:17:43 Every time they come in, because the road isn't wide enough for them to actually just pull off on the side. To be clear, we do have the Port Cochere height, and we do have the turning radius that would allow for that. We calculated that yesterday with less car. Again, our concern is more that we don't want to have emergency vehicles or those kinds of things necessarily interrupting the day-to-day flow of the hotel lobby and the guests. Yeah, and I can just, you know, I'll bring up the village just very briefly.

1:18:12 Having been a retailer there for six years, weekly sometimes, the fire alarms were going off exactly from what Peter just said, burnt toast. People upstairs, it would be burnt toast in the units. The alarms would go off. They would be going off for a half hour at a time, disrupting service, and the apartment had to come out, and an hour later, they'd finally go off. So it is an issue that will disrupt service.

1:18:39 And your guess, actually, at the same time. So this is something we need to solve, is my point. I mean, again, that's why we had set aside this area. But I think Peter's suggestion was a good one as well, that clearly we need to be able to accommodate for emergency situations as well. But I think the concern, as Jim mentioned, is we just don't want that to be kind of a regular occurrence as panels are being reset or what have you. I wonder if you could explore with the fire department. I mean, they'd be the ones that have to determine this.

1:19:09 Could they pull up to the port clocher, unload their guys, and then back up into that other space so that it's just a very temporary stop there? I can't speak for the fire department. I know based on past experience they tend not to like to have to back up. I'm also a fire captain. It's a three-man crew, and no, that wouldn't be realistic. So all three of them need to get out? If it's a high-rise, which this is going to be a mid-rise, all three.

1:19:36 Go inside to investigate the call and reset the alarm panel. John, this is one of the many reasons why I wanted to pull out spaces for tour buses and the fire truck there on the north side or the south side, whichever was easier, but they just keep going the same direction. I don't see how, and of course I know the scale is much larger than that, but how is a fire truck or a regular motor coach with European tourists on it going to turn around in that space?

1:20:04 I mean, how are they going to get out? We assume that they would basically be using the connector road and go all the way through. No, no, but they're pulling off next to the Zen garden and parking. Yes. They pull in and they're going to turn around like you put in a hammerhead. No, they can't. They can't. No, it would be a back out. That's right. They would have to back out. And why is that better than condensing your landscaping some, maybe with like vines on a trellis instead of shrubs and trees, and having them pull out in the line of travel to the north?

1:20:33 Or possibly to the south if that's easier for even for electrical hookups and have them even park there. Well, you couldn't do that with the fire department. It just seems so much easier to have a pullout slot going in the line of travel than that complicated tucking them. And I know what you're saying. You don't want a fire truck at the front door, you know, four or five times a month. That's just not good for business. But that just seems so obvious to me. But I'm just a layperson and, you know, I don't know. So I'm confused.

1:21:03 It looks like we're talking about two different things. Yeah, we are. One is a safety issue. I did not read this to be the language to be addressing the safety issue. I read this to be language addressing for large buses or transportation vehicles. And it sounds like we have, if there's a safety issue, we need to address that. And we need to address industry standard.

1:21:33 for what is happening with buses. You don't bring them to the front. They don't unload up front with everywhere else. They get into the extremely tight spaces. They don't watch while they do it because it scares you. But it is a completely separate operation. They're designed to do it that way. And I can see how this happens in that space there. But if we're talking about safety,

1:22:01 And the fire lane, that is a different issue, and I think that they shouldn't be rolled into one. Because I didn't see this was addressing the fire lane at all. I thought it was where you want to put the buses to load and unload and to store overnight. You don't want them anywhere near the front of your hotel. And so do we have to, if we could have staff work with them on addressing those two separate issues, because the fire...

1:22:30 Truck is going to come where the fire is. And if it is in the front of the building, he will be parked there. But you don't want to have bus parking blocking the potential access, and that's why it needs to be far away. And working with the fire department, we had set aside again this area for that pull-off for the fire truck. And that was acceptable. Okay. So what happens when you've got two at once?

1:22:57 Two fire trucks. The bus is there. And fire truck. And so, you know, because the burnt test. Well, again, this is a wide enough area. Again, we probably have to redesign it, I think, as a condition. It could be stated that. To accommodate. To accommodate to a dedicated emergency pull-off as well as a bus drop-off. Well, you have another emergency entrance in Sierra Nevada. That's correct. Yes, that's correct. There's emergency access, I think, all along. There's emergency access here.

1:23:26 Crossing this little bridge here, obviously around the perimeter, and the request was also that this would be available. So Peter, are you? Do we make sure that we just define what this condition is? So Rhonda, you're saying the industry standard is to have loading and unloading of tour buses and how far away is another location?

1:23:54 It is, it's about where they have it because they're set in a separate area of those particular guests. But there was a misunderstanding as to bus size, right? You're not talking about the bigger size. No, I'm talking about the bigger size as well. But then the smaller shuttle buses? Shuttle, that's good, thank you. It is transient on the shuttle that can have access. They're much, they're much smaller than the other.

1:24:21 Your portaget will accommodate them in the check-in because they're part of the transient check-in process. Part of the group process is oftentimes at other check-in locations of the hotel that enable the hotel to work with a large group at one time. They don't come through. They don't access. At the Mammoth Mountain Inn, they don't even let them off the bus. They move them directly to the building.

1:24:46 So my idea of having two pull-out spaces at the end of the connector row close to Laurel Mountain actually isn't far enough away in this configuration? You know, it's fine, you know, for what they have here, this excesses it because you actually, it puts them within the project instead of the people on Laurel Mountain saying this. So I think this is a very considerate

1:25:14 Solution there. Okay. Because it's within the project instead of parking in front of somebody else's condom. And then, John, what's your resistance, you know, design-wise to that suggestion of having a pull-out space at the west end? We had originally looked at down, you're thinking down here? No, west end. Top. Yeah. Up here.

1:25:43 We had originally looked at that, Commissioner Tenney, and given the desire for sidewalks and the width for the 24 feet, we just didn't feel we had the room for that, and that's again why we came up with this idea of creating this zone where you could basically pull vehicles in and drop off in an area that was off the street. We also like this better too, because if you drop off here, your guests are basically getting out on the...

1:26:09 Wrong side of the road, so to speak. If they were to pull in here, they would be able to get off of the bus on the right side and be able to just circle around behind the bus and come in on the right on the entry side of the hotel. So we thought that would actually be a very nice entry sequence for people getting off the bus. Or immediately access their rooms. Or immediately access their rooms. Which is, that's even better, especially for your service, that they're immediately taking bags to the rooms.

1:26:37 They don't mix with the transit just because the bulk. And it's on the conference center side of the hotel. And just with the luggage and everything else, getting luggage off the curbs and across the connector road, particularly if that really is being used as a connector road, we felt getting the...

1:26:53 The guests out of the line of traffic was the way to go. And the tour director usually checks everyone in. Yeah, I know. Am I hearing that we're in accord with the applicant accepting the emergency safety issues? I understand the applicant's offering on that. And then Peter addressing the fire issue, that which...

1:27:17 But the tour bus has to back up to get back on the connector road to exit onto Laurel Mountain, correct? That's correct. Or they may choose to pull up and back in. That's usually what they do. And we would have to modify this clearly, I think, to accommodate all those components to get that radius in. But we've looked at that. There's space to modify. There's space to modify. And how many buses can it accommodate?

1:27:45 Well, again, I think what would make sense, based on the concern about fire safety as well as the bus, would be to accommodate a dedicated emergency drop-off area as well as a dedicated bus. But if two buses should arrive within 10 or 15 minutes of each other, what are they going to do? Because that's sort of how the travel schedule can work, you know, they get here just before supper? Yeah, that's programming you to the hotel. It's their challenge.

1:28:14 This is very common in urban settings where they're taking tour buses. It's hard to believe, but they do it, yeah. That's kind of the onus that the hotel, that's what they do. So what if we included some language like we've done with these other items such as you develop a plan, a programming plan for tour buses? I think that'd be fine. But I just want to be sure that we're not building in an obstacle.

1:28:40 I don't want to think that with the approval of a plan that would only accommodate one, are we building in an obstacle to, can the program and community even solve? Because it takes a certain amount of time to get here from Yosemite and, you know. And just to make it clear that the quarter share that's currently with the radius in there will accommodate the small shuttle buses. It will not accommodate the luxury bus that the mountain has or the arts buses, which are the mid-level, they're 30 foot. Right.

1:29:09 Basically a 30-foot wheelbase, it does not meet that radius. Would it accommodate them if they went out on Laurel Mountain? Well, Laurel Mountain's a public street and it does. It's just a matter of we wouldn't want them to have the stopping area in the middle of the street. They can't. I can see the design is to have them stop there in the first place. Am I missing that? No, we did look with Les Card yesterday about a 40-foot vehicle and we felt that we would need a 42-foot vehicle.

1:29:36 Turning radius. Right, so the standard is. And it did look like we could get that to work with the Port Cochere. Assuming the vehicle was turning from the right-hand lane with some minor modification here, it looked like we could get that to work. That was assuming that from the right-hand lane and swinging over right up against the entry to the hotel. So then you would be comfortable with this condition as suggested, knowing that it's intended to accommodate the...

1:30:06 What Keith was talking about, which is different than a tour bus. Yes. Yeah, this wasn't intended to do a tour bus. Right. We have a tour, a condition 61 that requires a bus loading and drop-off facility and overnight parking with plug-ins for at least two buses on site. So that may cover the tour bus issues that you were discussing. And then the fire,

1:30:30 Questions. So we had basically three issues that I heard. We have several life safety conditions starting with 103 that requires the applicant to work with a fire district on all their plans. So I think that might cover the questions that came up. So we wouldn't be making any changes to the condition regarding the port of a share based on our understanding now that it's for these yards buses and mountain buses.

1:30:59 Is that, I want to make sure I heard everybody correctly. Are we overlooking something? Why do these shuttle buses need to turn around? Why don't they exit on Laurel Mountain? They need to pull the traffic light. We have a traffic light. Yeah, pull into the drop-off and then just go right out, continuing to the west, onto Laurel Mountain, because they're going to go around the block, new traffic light, make a left turn onto Old Mammoth Road. And that's the radius, that's that, that's that vehicle that meets that 30 foot radius. So that's the difference between.

1:31:35 Okay, I thought the radius issue was doing a 180 so they could go back out on Old Mammoth Road, which we didn't want to do anyway. If they come in on Old Mammoth Road and the exits on the right side of the bus, they pull into the porticocher so they can exit at the door side of the hotel. Oh, I see. They do the 180. So they do need to do a full revolution.

1:32:02 And with this radius, it would accommodate that. Basically, it adjusts the curb returns on the driveway. We felt that looking at it yesterday, we could accommodate a 42-foot radius. And that's what that is. That makes sense. I see what you're saying now. So I have a question. Maybe Peter from the Yards bus? Why would that not be kicking up and down at the bus stop? Not at the property, but down on the street? No, I'm just, that's the size of the bus. The luxury type.

1:32:32 Okay. Transportation that some of the hotels provide. But public transportation is down on. No, this would be public transportation. Absolutely. Okay. That'll be clear. Thank you. Okay. Okay. I'm sorry. Continue. Okay. The next comments are on item number 64, design. And we have a number of comments here. There are a number of sub-conditions.

1:32:55 Thank you.

1:33:24 With all due respect, some of the language is based on a misunderstanding of the design, and I can go through that specifically, or what we feel are personal preference that, again, might end up being too limiting, and we'd like to propose some minor modifications to some of this language. So, for example, to be specific on item, sub-item number B, this is a discussion regarding the design of posts and columns and pillars.

1:33:54 In the last sentence, it reads, refine column materials through the use and composition of steel and native stone versus board formed concrete. What we'd like to suggest, again, we think that there might be some nice variety that might be possible in concert with native stone and some board formed concrete. This is a big project. It'd be nice to have some, potentially, some variety.

1:34:20 So what we would like to propose is that we would consider native stone versus board form concrete, or if that's not acceptable, suggest that there might be some combination. So you're saying consider column materials through the use of, instead of refining them to be? Would be to say, and consider native stone versus board form concrete, or some combination thereof. There might be something else at the time. Or there might be something else as well.

1:34:52 I mean, our feeling is, so, of such materials as steel and native stone. Right. But not to necessarily limit us to have to use native stone in all cases. There might be something else, or given the size of the project, it might be nice to have some variety in different locations. Jay, I don't know your recollection, but I know when I looked at this, there were just so many columns and so many, you know, bases of board formed concrete, and it was...

1:35:22 It just didn't look as good as the design of the project. It was like a... Well, and I'm thinking that both on their side and our side, we're talking about variation. Right. More than the number of columns. So maybe if we put in there such as steel, native stone, and board form concrete so that they have a choice among a variety of materials.

1:35:43 Were we talking about wood with metal strapping and heavy bolts? Yes, we've actually. Because that's a really nice detail. As those things develop, we see huge opportunities with all the metal strappings, the metal shoes. Oh, it looks great. And in some cases we feel that, again, that could be done successfully with native stone. It could be done successfully with board from concrete. Or some other material. I like Jay's suggestion of listing the options as commas, with commas, and include.

1:36:12 Timbers with metal, what do you call it, metal shoe? Metal shoe and the metal strapping and the big bolts, you know, a good massive. We do have quite a bit of that on the building already, for example, at the lantern at the north, and I was messing up the directions yesterday, but at the northeast.

1:36:34 We do have those big heavy timber columns coming down. They need to come off the ground a little bit just so they don't soak up the water. But those, I think, are the perfect opportunity for the big heavy timbers with the metal shoes and strapping and those kinds of things. So I think we're just looking for variety so that our hands aren't held. So I think if it could say...

1:36:57 to refine column materials for the use and composition of steel, heavy timber, native stone, and or board form concrete, just so we have some variety and some options. Elizabeth, what if we just said in other materials approved by ADP or something? Well, I'm fine with what John just said, though. Well, the easiest way to do that would be to add after the concrete at the end of the sentence, comma, heavy timber, and similar materials.

1:37:28 Did you take out steel and stone? No. Let me read the whole thing. It would say, refine column materials through the use and composition of materials such as, wait a minute, now we've got materials twice. Let's try it this way. Through the use and composition of materials such as steel, native stone, formed concrete, heavy timber, and similar materials. That puts materials in there twice, but it's... And similar.

1:37:59 Just say, just say, and similar. And similar. Yeah. And similar. And product. Similar product? Yeah, and similar product. All right. Sandra, did that get that? I got that, yeah. Yeah, another place that there was a problem was the southeast corner of the east hotel wing with that tall, tall column, remember? Right. That just didn't work, so.

1:38:20 Yeah. So does that... I like the idea of variety. Absolutely. Because I think then we can really explore some exciting ideas as the design develops, bring those back and... And this is all within the context, just to make sure that it's going back to ADP and version of ADP. Exactly. Because this is just the refinery. Mm-hmm. Got to polish it up a little bit. Thank you. And Sandra, do we have that? Yes. We have consensus on that?

1:38:44 Not hearing anything, so great. Great. Perfect. Okay, now on number C, that condition currently reads, refine the design and materials of the south elevation of the hotel building, minimize or change the heavy horizontal of granite slab, and changing board form concrete to a different pattern of material. That's missing use, isn't it? Yeah. Yeah, I use use of. So there were a couple words that were missing, but then again, we felt in some cases this was...

1:39:13 Perhaps too limiting and in some degree arbitrary. For example, if you would look at page six of your booklet, you'll see our current proposed elevation of the hotel. And it's here. So this is the granite components with the heavy timber component on the top. We feel that horizontal use of stone, for example, one of the greatest pieces of architecture ever is the Parthenon, which uses horizontal stone. And we feel that this...

1:39:50 is perhaps a little too limiting and arbitrary because we feel that again as we look at the design and continue to develop it using a granite facade which is traditionally particularly rough hewn and is quite a rich material and we would prefer to soften this language a little bit to potentially say something like refine the design materials of the south elevation of the hotel building consider

1:40:19 Alternatives to the horizontal granite would be acceptable, but we feel that the way it's currently written is quite negative in connotation and kind of rules out the use of the granite in the horizontal configuration.

1:40:38 I'm almost inclined to suggest just deleting the second sentence and letting them work with ADP. This is so specific. I don't think it needs to be. That's why I was going to ask, Sandra, is there a reason that we, at this stage, that we have something this specific? We captured the ADP's comments. Yeah, that's absolutely what ADP said.

1:40:54 We're happy with striking the sentence. But it's going back to ADP, and it's going to be refined, so, yeah, let's just strike it. Let's strike it. And there's currently no board form concrete on the hotel facade now anyway, so we eliminated all that, so that didn't make sense to us either. Okay. So are we striking the entire C? No, just the second sentence. Oh, no, not the entire one. Just the second. That's fine. And I propose you strike the last sentence, too, because, again, there is no board form concrete.

1:41:23 There's only two sentences. There's only two sentences. Sorry, the last portion of the last sentence. Sorry. We're just checking all the last sentences. Yeah, we're going to take all the sentences out. Great. John, can you? But is that with leaving in his suggestion of considering? Can you bring the materials board around to the front of the podium? No. Okay. Just right there in the front of where you're standing so we can see it. Okay. Yeah. I didn't get to ask you yesterday, but that material, the silver material, is that what you refer to as metallic silver in your materials? Yes. And where is

1:41:53 How is that used? It's used in some of the metallic bays on Laurel Mountain. There are a few of the bay components that are accents. Okay. Okay. Reflectivity is a consideration. Yeah. Because that won't oxidize, will it? No. And it's not currently reflective and it comes in other colors. But I think we would not want it to be reflective either. Because our sun is so intense. Absolutely. That's ADP though. Yeah, but that would be ADP. But I just, I never got to ask you what was metallic silvers. I wanted where that went. Thank you.

1:42:23 Let's see. Item D. Again, this is an area where we felt there was perhaps something that is too limiting. And again, from our point of view, we felt there was a bit of a misunderstanding of the design. And let me pull the model over.

1:42:44 So, get rid of the other sentence. Second sentence. Get rid of the second sentence. Let's get rid of the second sentence. Let's just get rid of the second sentence and then leave, refine the design of windows, fenestration, building bays and columns. That'd be fine. Let's do that. Let's just do that. I never understood the second sentence anyway. You were there. I thought that was your sentence. No, it was not my sentence. I wasn't there when it was, I was there when it was stated and I wasn't sure what was said, so.

1:43:11 But I'm just a layperson. I thought it would be some big architectural thing I don't understand. Okay. And that would be terrific because, again, slots can be viewed as clear stories. And from our point of view, they were actually very carefully considered relative to creating a screening as a counterpoint to the glaze components. And they were actually set, for example, if you sat in a chair, you'd get a nice framed horizontal view. I wondered about that.

1:43:36 Developed very successfully by, for example, Joe Esherick, Bill Turnbull, some really great architects, Charles Moore, where there can be the use of very nicely framed windows, and our intent was not for it to be arbitrary or slottish by any means. That brings up something. Are the utilities being undergrounded on Laurel Mountain? Because that view there is just gorgeous. Are you going to... I believe they are, yeah. That's part of the... Peter?

1:44:05 How about the utilities across the street? Are the guests at this hotel going to have to look at the wires and phone poles? The guests across, yeah, for the poles across the street, they will be, they're not including the underground. They're including everything associated with their project and the poles that serve their project. So the guests will have to look at the poles across the street? Yeah. Because that is a spectacular view, which I didn't realize until I walked the property. It's just, that's a shame. It's a great view.

1:44:29 I'm sure that the residents across the street would be happy to have the project underdone the utilities if it's interested. Yeah, okay. Pretty expensive. Pretty expensive. Okay. Oh, that's too bad. That's too bad. Huh. Yeah, okay. Our next comment, ironically, has to do with views. It's item number F, and this has to do with the proposed use of glass railings.

1:44:55 Again, from our point of view, we felt that this is a large enough project that it would be nice to have some variety and to have both metal railings and in some cases some glass railings, primarily because glass railings are actually very much a fixture in the resort industry because they allow for view. Basically, they allow you from within your room to be able to look through and capture the view as opposed to having that being blocked. John, you're saying railing, but you mean panel.

1:45:24 Who do you mean railing? Well, I mean the rail, the panel. Safety barrier. Safety barrier, guardrail. We again feel that this is maybe too limiting. We think that from a maintenance standpoint, ironically, glass is oftentimes better than metal railings because they don't rust, you don't have to come back and repaint them, they don't get a lot of dirt and those kinds of things in them. So we would love to be able to have the option, particularly since this is such a larger project.

1:45:52 To have some variety. So we would, you know, propose some softening of this language to allow us the option to perhaps re-evaluate it, but not to limit it altogether. I think that was the intent of this language, is just to reassess, but not to remove. It's just the way it's written, it sort of puts a negative spin on glass panels, which in fact are oftentimes better from a maintenance standpoint. But it's going to be far enough above the balcony so a shovel can get underneath. But that's in code, so why is this in there?

1:46:22 I'm asking if it's... This was in response to an issue that was raised yesterday at the Planning Commission meeting. And as Rada said, the code defines what the railing is. Shovel. I mean, that's implied. So that's kind of where... And glass railings could be designed to do that. You just hold them off. Absolutely. That's what you do. But at Solstice, they didn't do that, and it's a problem. And the maid will be cleaning the glass? Just as they would a window. But again, you'd have to clean the metal railings, too, because they fill up with your...

1:46:50 So that's more of an ADP issue also, to where we could just strike it, is it not? I think so. Yeah, so we should just strike it. Strike the condition? F is down? Yeah. That's an ADP issue. It's in the code and it's ADP. I don't see that you need to call it out. How about review instead of reassess? But that's something ADP is going to be doing. It's in your design review. They're not coming back for a while, though, with the economy.

1:47:19 Well, and at that time when they come back, then you'll be able to review it. Oh, shit. What do you think, Jay? What are we doing? I'm thinking it could just be deleted. Okay, I'll go with Jay. My fellow ADP person. And those are all of my comments. Thank you. Okay. That's it? Is it going to be straight for health? Break? While we wait? The break while we wait for health. I think Mark and Mark have been burying it out in there. Are they ready?

1:47:47 I don't know. Oh, are they talking? Let me see. Oh, yeah, they've been working on it. Let's see if we need to break. Well, we will. Let's take a five-minute break at this point, and then we can assess. Okay. At this point, well, we can reconvene at 10 till the hour. Okay.

1:48:19 I have 11. Oh, I thought it was 10. I thought it was 5 of 10. But I'm so glad we didn't rush these conditions last night. The stability matters. Have your martini early today, Sharon? I don't do martinis. Oh. No, I've got to go to cast-off at 9 o'clock this morning. Yeah. Whips through 97.

1:55:00 That are described on page one of your revised conditions paper. And I think we have a much more simple and straightforward bit of language for you. Can I get real close to your microphone? Yeah, it's hard to hear. Please. No human's neck is long as you stand from the edge to where these are placed. Suck it up, Mark. You can do it. Okay, you ready?

1:55:30 So I'm going to read what this will be as a proposal. So first, condition number three should read the first sentence modified to this form. Approval of vesting tentative tract map 09003, use permit 09003, adjustment 09004, and design review 09005 is contingent upon town council approval.

1:56:00 of District Zoning Amendment 09001, period. Mark. No, approval is contingent. Approval is contingent. Never mind. You've got some real grammarians up here. Mark was attacking the prepositions. Just defer. So, the next sentence is extracted from

1:56:30 97. So we're going to pull it out and we're going to modify it. So sentence number two for this condition number three should read, the waiver of certain municipal code requirements contemplated with this project to implement the CBIS policy is contingent upon amendments to chapters 1516, 1518 and 1736.

1:57:00 period of the municipal code. Okay, would you read the first part of that is contingent upon, read the first half of the sentence again. You said the waiver, starting. The waiver of certain municipal code requirements contemplated with this project to implement the CBiz policy is contingent upon amendments to chapters 15.16

1:57:30 15.18 and 17.36 of the municipal code. Understood. The waiver of certain municipal code requirements contemplated with this project to implement the CBIS policies contingent upon amendments to chapters 1516, 1518, and 1736 of the municipal code.

1:58:01 And Mark Carney, can you say why that doesn't put a burden of uncertainty on the applicant? Well, it does. It sort of does. That's the concern that I expressed last time I was up to the lectern. I know. That's a big concern. You have no choice. Jim was just in the back room saying to me, we spent months and months and months and more money than you could imagine trying to comply with a CBIS policy, and essentially what this means is we don't have anything.

1:58:32 Yet. Any benefits associated with that. We're still contingent upon further action by the town council. And that's a problem. But I don't know any way to get around that right now. But they do have their approval of the VTTM use permit. Right. That we do today. It's just the tying up of the fees. We do have one more sentence to this one. Did you say you picked that sentence up in and out of 97?

1:58:57 The risk really is very simple. If the town doesn't amend those ordinances to reconcile them with a seat of its policy, then there just won't be a project. It's just that simple. Because that's another $6 million or so to you. Okay. Thank you. I'm sorry. I was wrong about that. The next sentence is being extracted from that section. Is that a number three?

1:59:21 Yeah, so there's going to be a third sentence, so they're still on number three. And let me finish these sentences and describe to you again what this does. So the third sentence to this condition, number three, is these amendments shall be prepared for review and approval by town council prior to application for a grading permit, and grading permit is here because of the timing, an earlier timing, rather than a building permit, so it's actually desired.

1:59:50 for a grading permit by which the incentive density is proposed to be excluded from these municipal code requirements. So, what this condition does, it meets the intent of what we were trying to build through these two conditions. It acknowledges that the vesting tentative map is contingent on the zoning amendment. It also acknowledges that the incentive zoning policies

2:00:20 The amendments require waiver of the fees that have been described to you through and program requirements. So they're either fees or a program by principally housing and the other elements that we've already talked about. So it says they have to be amended and then it says that there's a timing for the amendments. So the amendments have to be prepared and

2:00:51 Delivered to the Town Council before a grading permit is filed. So we've now acknowledged that the policy and ordinance conflicts need to be resolved. So that's what condition number three does. These amendments shall be prepared for review and approval by town prior to application for a grading permit by which the incentive density is proposed to be excluded from these municipal code requirements.

2:01:21 Yes, we can say that. The incentive density and community benefits. And what are the consequences if for some reason those amendments are not prepared by the time of the grading permit and don't meet that third sentence?

2:01:50 They can't proceed with the grading permit. So they just can't proceed, so they're stopped. And the result, if the codes, if the municipal code amendments are not approved, the project will be subject to housing. And housing, which we'll get to in just a minute, they'll have to meet the housing requirements either on-site, off-site, or through fee, the provisions of the housing ordinance.

2:02:19 For that incentive zoning, which they're now not calculated to. And the same with ART and the same with diff fees. And it may mean that, you know, in the financial condition, it may stop the project, require additional modifications or what have you, but they're not released unless the codes are amended. Mark, Dana just reminded me that Jim will be spending hundreds of thousands of dollars in anticipation of the grading permit.

2:02:50 And so we would like to see if we can push the commitment for the town up sooner so we know well in advance of whether or not Jim's going to spend money pursuing the grading permit. So what we would propose is language to the effect that the town will pursue these amendments as soon as practicable, as soon as possible, in due course. Some language that says you'll do it now or right away.

2:03:19 Whenever you decide when it feels helpful to do it, but in no event later than, and then insert the greater kind of language. You know, Mark, when we did DIF a number of years ago when I was on council and we were modifying, we had a hard date. You know, it was by June 1st, whatever it was, 2005. We'd love to see that, whatever. You know, so why can't we put a hard date in there? I thought we had consensus that we wanted that before we had the break.

2:03:49 Oh, great. We missed that. Can you talk about that with us gone? No, no, no. Before the break, I thought there was consensus that we needed to get this decided expeditiously. We would love to have a hard date. Is there a hard date that you guys could come up with that we can put in here? Yeah. Can you pick a date that you feel comfortable with, Mark, to pursue these amendments? If the project isn't going to be built for, you said, at least several years, I don't understand the reason for that.

2:04:18 Because they have to do work, Sharon. I can't predict when the project will be. Well, they're not doing any grading now. Well, but Sharon, they have to do work with engineers. There's a lot to go. I understand all of that, but it's still not something that needs to be done in the next 30 days. Oh, no, no, no. No, no, no. That's why I'm suggesting that Mark pick the time. We're not proposing. How long is it going to take is the question. One item is, you know, the housing ordinance is going to be amended soon. Right.

2:04:45 The housing element is under review, and then as soon as that's done, we're working immediately on the housing ordinance so we could include that. And so, you know, we don't want to link it to the vesting, that's for sure. And then, you know, maybe you want to just emphasize in your comments that this is a high-priority work program. You could, establishing a hard date for the town.

2:05:15 You could, but... You know, with all due respect, I think this commission has in the past placed high priorities on recommendations to council and they've just been overlooked by council. So I'm not comfortable just saying it's a high priority for this current council, to be very blunt. The zoning code is supposed to be done by December, which is just a superhuman amount of work facing you guys, but that's the deadline for updating Chapter 17. You want to say then what's within one year of the date of this approval?

2:05:45 We could meet that time frame. Okay. Does that satisfy you, Mark? Okay. Okay, that's good. Mark, could you get this one written out and at least email us so we'll have the actual wording? Yes. I'm writing down the note if you can read it. And then just repeat back to us, maybe read it back so Sharon's clear on it, if you would. Well, you don't need to go back to it for me. If I can just get it. I mean, are you clear on it, though?

2:06:19 The intent? Because it's going to be part of the motion. Oh, absolutely. But I just would like to have it. I mean, I've made all sorts of notes here, but I'd rather have it for sure. I've added a phrase to this to capture your thought. I don't know where to put it yet, but it'll be completion of these code amendments within one year of action by the town council on the project. Okay. And the applicants, okay. You're fine with that then?

2:06:49 One year of action by the town council. Yes. So, if I could move on to condition number 97. This one is now made much, much, much, much, much more simple. And the applicant, or Mark, speaking of the applicant, has agreed to waive their vesting to the housing ordinance. And so this becomes very simple. 97 would now be one sentence.

2:07:16 The project shall be subject to the housing ordinance in effect at time of grading permit and as contemplated by condition number three. And so it'll just be effective to the current ordinance at that time. And we inserted condition number three so that you'll know this is 97, so it's really far down in the document. And by reading number three, it makes you go all the way back.

2:07:45 It's just a link. Okay, and why is this at time of grading permit rather than in one year when the code's updated? Why is it at time of grading permit? Because you said that was too far out to be able to plan. Why isn't it the same deadline as the previous one? That's a building. We started changing our language in terms of timing of building. Pam and I remembered why we did this. When projects come in at building permit,

2:08:20 They've gone too far in the design, development, and construction drawings to actually catch things that they should have, so the 70 square foot bedroom, so it puts us in a reactionary period, and so what we're, I don't know that it's, Mark, we have a revision to ask you that might supplant this. What we're really trying to get at is, we know that the ordinance is in the process of being amended, and we want to be able to comply with that ordinance.

2:08:51 We don't want to run the risk that that ordinance is only in place for another year, and then we haven't gone forward yet, and then the fees go up again. So essentially what we do want to do is, Mark, is invest in the revised ordinance, whatever it is. So we'd like to make a reference to the fact that this ordinance is going to be revised, and we will agree to comply with that ordinance, and we want to invest in whatever that says.

2:09:19 What that does is protect us from the risk. It does two things. We don't benefit if mitigation rates go down further later on, but we're not hampered or hurt if mitigation rates go up later on. Because Jim knows what he's spending. Once he learns what the new ordinance says, that's what we will comply with, period. We can't have this contingent liability of additional units out there in the future.

2:09:51 So how do you say that? Yeah, how are you going to say this then? I don't know. How would you like to say that? We can say the horrible, as revised, we will comply with the horrible housing mitigation ordinance. That is, we can say that's in place one year from the date of the town council approval. It says we know that it will be approved. That's what it says, isn't it?

2:10:20 Because you're saying it will be revised within the next year, right? That's our hope. I can never promise when it's done. Then let's acknowledge in the condition that the Town is in the process of amending the ordinance, and we will comply with the amended ordinance. Period. And Mark, does it make any sense to say that we won't comply? That doesn't sound right.

2:10:50 I don't see how that accomplishes their objective. Yeah, I don't see how that accomplishes. Not putting it off to grading. No, no, we're getting rid of grading. We're just saying is we're acknowledging the fact that you folks are in the middle of revising this ordinance. Right, right. Whatever comes out of that process, we will comply with it. That's what we're trying to say.

2:11:21 I think the challenge is you can't vest something that doesn't exist. Oh. And so the, because that's what you're asking for. And so the question, it needs to have some kind of performance something like you'll comply with the housing ordinance in effect as of X date. So I'm not sure what to advise you. Well, if you continue on that, you'll comply with the housing ordinance.

2:11:55 That is in effect of the date of the application for the grading permit? No, see, that could be three, four years from now, and the ordinance could have changed three or four times between now and then. That's what we're trying to avoid. Oh, exactly. Well, does that raise the same issue that you're concerned about, investing in something that doesn't exist yet? No, I think...

2:12:21 Setting the time is fine. Okay, let's set the same, let's set one year from the Town Council action then, then we don't have to tickle our fellows twice. Is staff okay with that? Yeah. Any thoughts? The likelihood that it's going to get changed in the next year and then it changed again seems really remote. I think we're willing to take that risk. I think the year is going to be...

2:12:45 Once you check that box, you're not going to go back. Would you concur with that, Pam? So it has a similar phraseology as the last one, town council action. Pam does not concur? I don't know. I thought that was exactly what Mammoth Lakes Housing wanted, what Mark just said. I don't think it is. I think there's an issue there still. What?

2:13:17 Mark's tall. What the Mammoth Lakes Housing Board requests is that the project comply with the municipal code in effect at the time of the grade permit. That's why I'm having trouble with the date. You understand our concern. I do understand. I understand your concerns. I'm just trying to think through.

2:13:48 You know, I don't know if the board would agree to setting a date, you know, based on history. I think that, you know, these policies don't change very often, but if this is 10 years down the road before they pull a grading permit, I think that that, you know, we may not be getting the housing that is required at that time. You know, I also think...

2:14:16 I guess if I can chime in for a second. So when the applicant asking for the vesting tentative map is seeking to vest the rules that are in place at that time. And Mammoth Lakes Housing has said, please don't do that. So you get to decide. You get to recommend either the language which we had first drafted in effect at the time of grading permit or building permit, you pick. The other choice is

2:14:44 Which Mark has just suggested, which is one year. A one year is substantially the same concept as vesting the current rules. They're hopeful that the rules change and there's a lower codified requirement. So it's really a pretty straightforward question. A future ordinance or one that's in existence within one year from now? So if they want an extension, which they're going to come back for extensions to us, I would assume.

2:15:14 That's in two years. Correct? Well, they can apply for an extension. At any time. But it's going to be two years from now. Normally, that's what we see. I think we owe it to our future as a town, as a successful resort community, to get these rules in place. And one year, since they're in the process of being revised, does not seem unreasonable to me. You know, people come to town with projects and they're very frustrated because they don't know what the rules are. And I think that...

2:15:47 A year, we're in the process of thinking about this. I mean, how can we talk about preparing for when the capital comes back. When the capital comes back, they want to know what the rules are. So let's get on the stick and, you know, decide. And this project may come forward in sooner than five years. Who knows? Well, that's the first part of the concern. But then there's the concern Pam has expressed that we get the amendment. We fix that date at which you're going to accept the terms of the amendment.

2:16:17 Then is there an unlimited period for the grading permit after that? Can there be some reasonable limit on that proviso that the terms of the amendment within one year vest provided that you apply for a grading permit within some reasonable period? We would have the vested right to proceed as long as the tentative tract map had life, as long as it were still alive, whether it were...

2:16:46 Extended or not. And that's what we'd like. Now see, the way it's set up right now, we've applied for vested tenant map. We could vest in the existing code, affordable housing mitigation code, right now. That's easy. But we see that it's changing, and so we don't want to vest to that code. We want to get the same benefit to the revision as somebody else coming after us. So that's really all we're asking for. And we want to have the vested right would give us the

2:17:16 benefits of that new ordinance for the life of the project, not any artificial limit of when we pull grading permit. I don't think we can connect it to the grading permit. Your concern is addressed by your ability to accept or deny an extension request of the tentative tract map.

2:17:37 There are other people who would like to know what the housing requirements are. I think we should get it done. It should be a reasonable expectation with the housing element done, the policy formulation, Walter Kieser's assisting in the housing program, that the staff should be able to complete the housing element or the housing ordinance update within a year. I mean, that's reasonable. Can we promise it? No, I can't promise it.

2:18:02 You're certainly directing us to do certain things, and if this condition were approved, you know, we'd be moving to that degree. You had a question, Tony? Well, I'm just going back because Elizabeth was bringing vesting up again. You had said earlier we cannot connect the vesting to that one item, correct? Did I hear you wrong? No, I think you can't vest a future ordinance without any type of time or condition to it. And so by setting a time, I think that is a reasonable condition.

2:18:32 Okay. Because it's, the intent is that the housing policies and concepts that were recommended by the CFFC, reviewed by the Housing Board, adopted by policy through the Town Council's action, now incorporated in the housing element, have some reasonable expectation to be implemented in a similar housing ordinance. That's why that's reasonable. If the Town doesn't get it done in a year, are we liable for breach of promise?

2:19:02 Yeah. You have to be fall back on. What we'd like to do is the same protection, we'd like to ask for the same protection with this condition as we asked for before, which is getting a commitment from the town to pursue this ordinance amendment. The same language. But we're not going to set the town up to be sued if we don't get it done. No, no, but in the prior condition, condition three, you've already agreed that the town is going to pursue

2:19:30 amendments to the three ordinances to comply with CBIS, to conform to CBIS, all we would ask in this circumstance is for the town to commit to acting good faith to change the housing ordinance. I mean, they're already in the process of doing it. Okay. I support that request. That's fine. Good. Okay. That concludes our revised conditions. Okay.

2:20:06 Can you read that back, please? No, we've got people streaming, we have people watching. No, we understand. That's a good point. Yeah, and, you know, we need to keep this moving along before we lose focus on this, so if you can, if you can, state it, and then we will see it later. One second, please. Sure. And this is not going to be sound, right?

2:20:46 Or is this 93? I mean, number three or 97? This is 97. Do you want 97 or do you want both of them? No, just 97. I think we're clear on three. Three, we're okay. The project shall be subject to the housing ordinance in effect within one year of town council action on this project. And then it should go on to say the town of Mammoth Lakes will initiate a...

2:21:22 Amendment to this section 1736 within one year of action of Town Council action on this project. Initiate and complete, not just initiate. I think we'll only say initiate. I cannot promise when it will be done, but I can certainly suggest an initiation date. Staff would not recommend... Yeah, but you need to put something stronger and they're just initiating something. We could be five years from now. Could you agree to making a good faith effort to complete?

2:21:56 Yes. I think I could do that. But if there is an earthquake and all town resources are diverted someplace else or there is a fire or there's some other thing that would reasonably... I think the good faith effort is... And I would also propose in the first sentence to replace the word within with the word on because you said... Read the first sentence again. It should be a date certain that you're talking about. Yeah, on, right, and not within. Yeah. Read the first sentence again, please.

2:22:24 I can't. Let's see. The town of Mammoth Lakes will initiate... No, no, the first sentence of the convention. Project shall be... The project shall be subject to the housing ordinance in effect... Right here. On. On. You have within. On effect. No, in effect on. In effect. On. One year.

2:22:52 Or in effect, in effect, one year from the date of council. That's right. Okay. Yes. Thank you. Is that set, Pam? Is that... Okay. Okay. So that was affirmative from Pam. Yes. For the time being.

2:23:21 Now we're going to move on to the required actions. You'll find those in your staff report on page four. There's six actions required in order for us to enact the Old Manless Place project. And we've discussed these quite a bit. So if anyone has any further issues regarding these six, we can poll those or we can see if we have satisfied these requirements.

2:23:49 I'm satisfied. I'm satisfied. We're going to do them individually, correct? No. I'm asking if we can discuss them at the time that we've, at the time we're going to then entertain a motion and then we'll have discussion. Okay. If that is, if that's, I think that's what you're asking. I guess.

2:24:17 But have we covered issues because they are determined that the project, so have we got enough information with a motion on the floor to have discussion deliberation about the consistency of the Clearwater Specific Plan, the design review, the height of adjustments, the use permit, the vesting tentative tract map, and the district zoning amendment. So that's at this point.

2:24:46 If there's anybody that thinks that they want to discuss more, we can pull that, but you will have an opportunity with a motion on the floor. Madam Chair, I'll make a motion that we recommend that the Town Council determine that the project is consistent with the Clearwater Specific Plan Environmental Impact Report pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act Guidelines and approved district zoning amendment DZA09-001 approved vesting tentative tract map.

2:25:16 09-003, use permit, 09-003, adjustment, 09-004, and design review, 09-005, with modifications as discussed, contingent upon town council's approval of DZA 09-001. Second that motion. Second. We have a motion and second. It's on option two in the analysis, and now I will...

2:25:45 Open for further discussion before we have a vote. I'd like to open with Elizabeth. At this point, do you have further discussion? Just very briefly, I didn't think I could spend more time on a project than I spent on Snow Creek, but I found I've spent more time on this project than I spent on Snow Creek, and not just because of the 55 meetings. I was so determined to be sure we got it right, because it is going to be the center of Mammoth, and it's such an important project.

2:26:15 They've been through every page, every document, you know, three and four times to be sure we hadn't overlooked anything. I've been heavily lobbied by many people, as you can imagine. But I'm at a point now where the project isn't just okay, the project's excellent. I'm really, really enthusiastic about it. I have a wonderful level of comfort with the fact that the final refinement of the design will go before ADA again before, you know, we go further, because there's still a few issues, but they can be worked out.

2:26:44 I have no problem with the height now that it's been so clearly spelled out where the height comes from, and I would remind the public that one of the reasons that the applicant is asking for these height adjustments is because ADA said they should in order to get more architectural interest, in order to make it more mammoth, more rugged mountain architecture, and so those minor changes that have affected the height in a small way were requested.

2:27:13 As far as building, calculating the height from the podium, of course that makes sense, since it's what was done with Snow Creek, with the village, and with Lodestar Master Plan, and so I have no issue there. I'm very enthusiastic about the conference space. It's been wonderful to see, especially at the rafters and the Sierra Lodge now, how many happy, smiling people are enjoying our resort. You know, they're just really pleased with the amenity. That's good. I feel that we have...

2:27:41 We're getting a real bonus with the open space for events and especially with the conference center also for events, not just conferences. And I think we've really addressed recreation because this is going to be the center of town and because of the conditions we've added with wayfinding and the other things for showing people how to connect to what surrounds us, you know, these spectacular surroundings, as well as the recreation opportunities that are provided on site. So I'm very enthusiastic about the project. May the economy turn around swiftly.

2:28:12 Thank you, Elizabeth. Sharon, are you, do you have comments or anything you'd like to discuss at this time? I, with all of them together, it's very difficult for me to vote because I supported some and not others, but I will have to vote no. And the reason being that I feel very firmly that once a commitment is made to various heights, 55, 45, and 35,

2:28:42 With a talented and competent team that we have, the architect would be able to comply with those findings. I have problems with the water resources not established. There very clearly says in our general plan that they should be. I have problems with the workforce housing. And when we get to the vesting,

2:29:12 That one is so far out in the future that I think it leaves us in not knowing what we're doing. Design review, again, goes back to the height and mass. I think, again, general plan C2V is very clear that this is height and mass that is inappropriate for the adjoining neighbors. And then, of course,

2:29:41 findings for community benefit. My big problem there is the price tag that will be for the town of the $6 million. So I have to vote no on this project. Let's see. I'll just do them in kind of a random order here. The community benefits analysis, I have a concern with the way that amendment is proposed, but I understand that's

2:30:12 That's not an issue here. I'm satisfied. I hope we get a chance to address that before the Town Council amends that policy, but that's not an issue here. I'm quite satisfied with the way we've worked those conditions to satisfy the community benefits analysis. As to height, the only thing I can sum up there is that I feel sure that if the Town Council had

2:30:40 Had the proper definition of height at hand, they would still have set that at 55 feet and this project would be in compliance. We've got plenty of precedent to show that was simply a mistake. I don't think there was anything intentional on anybody's part and I'm hopeful the council will remedy that by recognizing, as we did, how that situation came about.

2:31:09 The ADP issues, I'm confident that some excellent solutions will be worked out because I've been a part of that and the applicant has been fully cooperative and done a huge amount of work in the past and I'm confident they'll continue to do that on those remaining issues. Water resources, that was really a concern early on with the battle of the letters back and forth, but I think we've all recognized that there's a need for the

2:31:39 the town and the water district to work those issues out and I'm confident that with that cooperation there will be a satisfactory solution to that. So I'm no longer concerned about that. Overall the project has come a long way from the start. It's an excellent project. I'm excited about the possibilities, those amenities that they're providing for the community. I look forward to

2:32:06 Seeing it happen hopefully sooner rather than later, although I know, you know, that data is a little bit indefinite. One particular thing I'm really excited about, just because from my kind of techie side, is the commitment to pursue some geothermal resources. Boy, we need that around here. And Jim talking about doing that as one of the first parts of the project I think is really neat, and I'm really looking forward to seeing that, hopefully seeing that happen. So overall, I support it.

2:32:36 I concur with Elizabeth and Jay and all the statements they've made, so I'm not going to go through those again, except to state on the height, because that was a major issue coming up from the community, not the height, but the measurement of height. And I am confident we've satisfied that that is, and I think, Jay, you're correct, the council, I think that was an overlooked part of their...

2:33:00 decision and we've learned from that and I think the fact that Sierra Center Mall across the street from us here and also the Shiloh are both built upon podiums and the measurements were used at those times along with the other specific plans and the fact that really what we're talking about in that measurement is a foot and a half. It's not 10 feet through the entire property. It's also on some corners of the building that are not visible.

2:33:26 Basically from anywhere in town or even around the project. So I am comfortable with what we've discussed. John Ashworth, you're an incredible architect. I believe that when you tell us that this is how it has to be, that is the solution. To do anything else with that podium, you lose half the building all the way around. We lose entirely the perspective of what this project is. I'm not going to go through all of our different points at this time because I think they've all been covered.

2:33:56 With housing and I think I'm confident with that now. The water issue, I'm very happy that you are acceptable to adding the key conditions from the water district. I think that opens up new territory for us to move forward with the water district and future projects. You know, I think it's also important to know that this project, it's my belief, this project, you know, it's going to bring new customers along with the local clientele we have, our residents and new customers.

2:34:26 You're not going after a market share and stealing from other properties. This project, I think, is going to be the first to show that you will bring new people to Mammoth to enjoy, and not just the mountain, but our town that we have. And the benefits that you've already started providing currently are to be commended for. The fact, you know, when we look at some of the issues, Sharon, that you brought up, you know, the fact that in this economy, and even if it's five years from now,

2:34:55 To bring 300 plus, 370 new jobs to this community, that's approximately half of what Mammoth Mountain employs. That's probably equal to what Vons does. This project will be one of the top employers for our community in the years to come. And to be able to revitalize our local families with these job opportunities is an incredible thing. And I really thank you for that. It's what we need in this town. It's what we need to keep our quality of life.

2:35:22 And our sense of families here working. But it's also on your shoulders, Jim. It's, you know, you are here, you've been doing a lot, and I'm taking you at value that you're going to do what you say, and we're going to hold you to it, too, because, you know, you're setting, it's on your shoulders to set the tone for future developers, because you have now set the bar at a point that they're going to have to comply with also. And if you fail us,

2:35:51 You fail the future of our town. And I don't think you're going to do that. In fact, I know you won't. So it's on your shoulders. This process has been incredible. I think the fact, as I mentioned earlier, for Pat Eckert and Sally Jessford and our other folks, to have that feeling, that does, it gives me a good thought inside because for so many years we've been at odds with different groups in town and people. And you've brought us together and I thank you for that. So I'm a positive on this vote.

2:36:19 Staff, you've done an incredible job over the years working with it and so has this commission and I just hope our town council has the foresight to see what is going to happen in the future and that they move this project along as well. So thank you. There's not much to add at this point other than one of the things that I needed to look at is how a project like this

2:36:47 How it reinforces the general plan and the triple bottom line in there, which is the economic, environmental, social aspects of it. And what I found to be economic, it's obvious to me.

2:37:02 Being that this is part of the industry that I come from, is that it's hotbeds with viable restaurants and retail, and I think some of the statistics I provided for new incremental guests yesterday, this is the type of project that they're looking for, and I have to concur with Tony, is that this is bringing incremental business, it's not coming from another sector, it's not...

2:37:27 A trade up or trade down, whatever it is, it is options of people that had want to come to Mammoth and are now there's viable ways and the timing of this project will support that. I have my particular insight of what works as far as the community benefits and what truly are benefits. We know that we would have a conference space if it was economically viable for the host house to build it. It's not.

2:37:57 And a cooperative effort is the only thing that would support it. And others in town benefit from that as well. Environmental, it's feet first. It is good design and it preserves. It preserves the trees. You have done an amazing job of trying to preserve sidelines and views from those areas. I stood.

2:38:22 I walked it off. I looked at what you're going to see from now, and it's as minimal as it can possibly be. I understand the height calculation on the podium. We're consistent with what we've done with others. And socially, I hear that the community is saying you are respectful of your neighbors, and just the fact that the project has changed so much.

2:38:49 Due to the input and will continue to be enhanced as we go forward there, that you're open to the community input of what's necessary at this property. And the right project can enhance all of our quality of life, and we look forward to that as well. So at this point, I have to say that I am also supportive of the project, and I don't go to many hotels.

2:39:19 Where the, excuse me, the owner, the general manager has a picture in it. That means you're on the line. And, you know, it really caught me. It's that you're willing to tell everyone who you are. And that's important to this community because you know that we're going to find you. And we've all said that, you know, we have very high expectations. And we've all worked very hard. We're very tired on it.

2:39:49 Steph has done an amazing job. And I didn't think we could work more than we did on Snow Creek. And there's different issues, but I think that in both cases, it's coming to the best plan that we can for the time we don't have a crystal ball. If we did, we wouldn't be doing this. We'd be picking six good numbers in Vegas and all taking care of our issues. But we're doing the best that we can with what we know and where we proceed.

2:40:18 I thank you for your time and your input in that. I'm sorry, one more question for me. Sure. Staff, are we able to, and I think this would be if the applicant agrees to this because of copyright laws and that, but would you be agreeable to your fly around that you did of the building, that the project, I mean, that perhaps staff can get that on channel 33 so that the public sees that over time so people that haven't seen this can have that ability to actually

2:40:46 That visual was incredible to show how, of the podium, the height, and what this project actually does. So any way that we could assist them in getting this out to the public, I think, would be very good for us. It's all public record.

2:41:00 Okay. So there's no copyright. Okay. It is on our web. I wish there were a copyright. Yeah. Didn't think of that, did you? Well, no, a lot of times I know I've gone back to the town and we've asked, like, for the village. Currently we're talking about doing some awnings, but there's copyright laws on the plans and the architect doesn't sign off, he can't use them. But just if we can, I don't mean to take time, but if we can get it, work out something, they get it on TV on 33 or 51, I mean, that would be wonderful. Figure something out.

2:41:29 with a readable screen that says what the context is. No high def required. Okay, but whoever does the technology, I don't know who that is, but make sure that you can read the text.

2:41:40 That's on the screen to say what the project is. I'm just talking about the flyer. No, no, no. We have a very good technology station. I'm sure they can help us do what you're asking. Mark, we trust that there'll be a representation available for any of those that want it. And if there isn't, you will hear about it. I just forgot to thank Sandra and Ellen and Pam. You have...

2:42:02 Answered emails more than once, answered questions more than once. Thank you so much for your time, energy, and effort putting up with me. And staff in general, I thought this book was just fantastic. So I appreciate that. Thank you so much. I forgot that's it. It's always implied, but it doesn't hurt to say to begin. The easy stuff is done. Now everything is at Herculean efforts, so we really appreciate that.

2:42:30 If there's no further discussion, I'd like, excuse me, to call for, while I can still talk, to call for a vote on this, and if you could take a roll call vote, please. Mr. Tenney? Aye. Yes. Yay. Vice Chair Barrett? Yes. Chair Eugen? Yes. Mr. Leighton? Yes. Mr. Clark? Nay. So, um,

2:43:01 The motion passes 4-1. Now this will be going with recommendations to the town council. There's not a date scheduled for that, do I understand? Or is there a certain amount of time that it would be going for? April 7th. April 7th? That date's really important to us because John Ashwood will not be available two weeks later, so we'd like to hit that April 7th date if possible. We'll do our best.

2:43:29 And also Pam from Mammoth Lakes Housing and also for MLTPA. We thank them for their input as well. And all of the people that spoke and the community that brought forward all of the emails and comments to us. You guys did a great job. Thank you. So if we have no other business, we adjourn to our next meeting of, and Mark, could you remind me the date? I don't have a calendar. March 24th at 2 p.m. At 2 p.m. Thank you very much for your participation. We're adjourned.

2:44:01 Yeah, very good job. Well, you know about these dogs. I mean, I don't.