TransparentMammoth

Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2010

Planning & Economic Development Commission

· recording 3 hr 6 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

410 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:07 Thank you.

1:29 We learn. Good afternoon. I think at this time we will call our meeting to order. And if you, those of you that are here would please rise and join me in the Pledge of Allegiance. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

2:01 Thank you. Karen, could you call the roll, please? Commissioner Clark, here. Commissioner Duncan, here. Commissioner Tenney, here. Vice Chair Barrett, here. Chair Dugan, here. At this time, we'll have reports from the Commission, anything that they'd like to share, and to start off.

2:24 Elizabeth. I was pleased to see that Rite Aid, or the Rite Aid Do It Center Mall is really cleaned up there, what should be back of the house, but at the side of the house, and that's at Old Manus Road, and that's nicely cleaned up, that looked good. The other thing I think we should just be thinking about long term when we talk about what it's going to cost to take back 203. There are many, many factors involved, and one of them I don't think we count in, what it costs to clean up all those cinders.

2:52 I mean, not only the mess, you know, how bad Main Street looks for our visitors, but what it costs in the spring to clean up all the landscaping and all the cinders because the snow hasn't been removed, it's just been plowed and all the cinders. So, something to think about. That occurred to me this morning when I got my mail. Thank you. Thank you. Anyone else? Sharon? I attended on March 16th a group of concerned citizens.

3:20 who are called the Future of Mammoth Group. Did you hear what they had to say? Thank you. Yeah, I'd just like to inform the Commission that during the Mammoth Place hearings two weeks ago, I had made a request that the fly-around that they did, the fly-by, be put onto our local station.

3:47 And I just want to know, Sandra has worked very diligently at that, but we found out today, I've got my phone turned off, so I just can't read the email, but basically Mike Grossblad has stated that the town cannot do that. I don't know if it's a financial issue or a contract issue with Channel 51. Yeah, he just stated that it's typically just the Planning Commission meetings and Council meetings, and we don't typically put anything other than those items on there.

4:17 So we did ask about that, and that was his determination. And we did discuss it with Dan McConnell as well about possibilities. So they both discussed it and determined that we wouldn't be able to put that on there. So in light of developing technologies and the interest of keeping everyone forward, is that something that we need to develop policy in order to allow them to come?

4:47 The technology didn't exist. Now it does. Is there any type of position that we have? Or is that something that needs to be crafted by staff? We could discuss it with Mike Grossblatt. That fly-around video is available on our website. If you just click on it, you can watch it on YouTube. So it is available to the general public. If you have...

5:09 Internet access in a high enough resolution to accept that. Right, right. I mean, it's something if you wanted to agendize to discuss, we could do that. Yeah, if I could just further discuss that, Madam Chair, and that is, I believe my thoughts would be that it would come down to a council issue, because council does have the last say on that channel.

5:33 But I think it might be good for us to agendize it or if we're able to at this time make a recommendation to council to consider it. You know, it would certainly be a community benefit to have it on that channel. I did speak to the other owner of the other channel in town, town of 33, who was more than happy to put it on for Mr. Demetriotis if he chose to, but it would have to be done as an infomercial, so there'd be a great cost to that.

6:03 You know, I just think for the future for us, this is the new technology as the Chair stated. It's very disappointing that the Town's position is just very strictly known. So whatever we can do, I'd appreciate. Sandra, can you clarify for me what can go on the website? Or excuse me, what does go on the website? Only staff reports?

6:24 On the website or on the town's website? We put all the information, so all the pertinent information on the website, so the staff reports there, all the attachments, including the fly around, are on our website. Tony's asking about the... This is channel 51. ...channel 51, the TV station, that's our community TV station. Oh, I see, okay. There's a huge viewership on channel 51. Right, I thought we were talking about the website. Much more than the website. Yeah, okay, I see the problem. I missed that.

6:54 So, obviously, that it's not our decision, but I think that if we're going to bring this forward, the Town Council would like recommendation because is it reasonable to expect that every bit of paper that we get is going to be available for the viewership at home? And now you're talking resolution equality.

7:20 As well. So what is reasonable? And I think that that's probably what we would have to come up with some recommendation on what you can have available, what is just not going to be properly represented, and then give that, this is our recommendation, and let them proceed from there. And so that sounds like an item. Do you have consensus that we could agendize this for later on? Do you have some thoughts?

7:48 The other thing I was thinking was in the meantime, someone who doesn't have access because all they've got is a TV, we can always direct them to the library and they can see it via the town website through one of the computers at the library. I think the discussion is what's reasonable now if technologies are available, but they are not available to every person at all levels and when you start to have a representation.

8:17 It could be misrepresented just because of the resolution and the clarity. So what's reasonable? And since there are no guidelines right now, the town is saying, we haven't done that, so we're not going to continue to do that. And that could be fine, but is it reasonable to expect them to do that? And if you could also add in there also, Sandra, that when you bring that back,

8:48 The viewership that day of our meeting, those watching TV, watching the meetings at later dates, none of that fly-around was available to them on TV. They only saw this body and staff, so that's another concern, too. Madam Shagan, one more thing, if everybody else has had a turn. Yes. Okay. During director's report, I guess that would be the time to do it, to talk about the

9:19 Wisdom and effectiveness of a Planning Commission response to this recent letter to the editor that I just saw on the paper. I'd like to bring that up during director's report. Okay. Is that an appropriate time? I believe so. Okay. Are you here asking for staff response, whether there are sort of clarity on who should respond? Or if it's even... Or if we should respond. Even if we should, because it's so much inaccuracy in that letter, and I wonder if it should...

9:49 Dictive value to the response? I don't know. If you, um, we can do that. Okay, let's do it during director's report. A director's report, absolutely. Okay, um, moving on then, this is the public comment time. This is the portion of the agenda provided to the public with an opportunity to address the planning commission on matters that may not otherwise be listed on the agenda today. Um, under California law.

10:17 Planning Commission is prohibited from generally discussing or taking any actions on the agenda, however, we may briefly respond to this. Therefore, if anyone has any comments at this time, there are speaker cards that we'd like you to fill out for the benefit of our audience at home. And please come up, state your name. We're looking at you. We're looking at you, Pete. And that would be you. I'm good. Okay, thank you. There are no public comments at this time. There is a public comment.

10:46 opportunity again at the end of the meeting. And moving on, there will, there's no presentations for today. The consent agenda has two items on it, the annual report for the last year and the Planning Commission letter of support for the grants from the, for Caltrans community-based grant program. And if anybody would like to poll these items, otherwise I will enter.

11:15 entertain a motion to accept the consent agenda. I do have one correction, I think it is. On page 22. Of which report? The first one. Okay. Page 22, the process, O Mammoth Pace, this is a vesting tract. Speaking of 22 as hand-lettered or? Hand-lettered. Okay. And it says that several more places, but that's the one that

11:52 The tenant where it's this tentative tract map? Yes. Old Mammoth Place asked for a vesting. And I might try to get something done with my speaker, which every time I touch it, it makes a noise. It's a vesting tentative tract map. That's just a correction. That's a good point. And it's listed elsewhere. We found another place, Sandra and I.

12:15 Maybe toward the end, but at any rate, I think maybe I just suggest that wherever it's listed as a tentative tract map, be corrected to a vesting tract map. Thank you. That's a good point. I just noticed something on that same page, Sharon, after you pointed out that correction. It's a Mono County Courthouse, isn't it? The Superior Court is not Mono County Courthouse, not Mammoth Lakes Courthouse.

12:40 It's located in Mammoth Lakes. I wondered about that too. It's a Mono County courthouse. It's in Mammoth Lakes. It's in Mammoth Lakes. Mammoth County courthouse in Mammoth Lakes. Yeah, I think that should be rephrased so it's clear that it's Mono County courthouse. I think court is two words too when it's the courthouse in Mammoth Lakes. Madam Chair, I'll make a motion. Can we do any questions on this? Yes. Continue. Is that all you've had to share at this time?

13:14 Thank you. We're not going to discuss what we have now. Well, we have to pull it first, I think, if we're going to do that. Now it's been pulled. Okay. So both of them have been pulled or just? Oh, it's on the consent agenda. It's on the consent agenda. Oh, no, I'm ready to talk about it. So Sharon has pulled number one. Thank you. For clarity. I just jumped right in. It's okay. I assume by talking about it, that's pulling it. Okay. For the record, it was pulled by Sharon. We had discussion.

13:44 corrections there. Does anyone else have any items that they would like to discuss on the annual planning report? Okay, Jay, why don't you go ahead? Oh, okay. Page 12, the resource management and conservation element. The next to the last paragraph talks about the town continues to require...

14:04 All new development projects and facade improvements to be consistent with our lighting requirements, but we also require all outdoor lighting to be consistent and as code enforcement permits, that's happening. In fact, I just had a call about an hour before I got here about a business on Main Street that is trying to figure out how to comply with the code. So I think that should be clarified. It's not just new development, but everything has to comply with that ordinance and as code enforcement permits, that's happening.

14:34 So would you then advise, requires all development, just take out the word new? All project. All outdoor lighting. I mean, it's the lighting ordinance for the town of Mammoth Lakes. All outdoor lighting. Residential, commercial. We focused on commercial because that's what our visitors see most, but all outdoor lighting. That's what the lighting ordinance is. I can clarify that in the report. Thank you, Jen. And there's one more thing on page 15. The doctor says,

15:03 Next to the last paragraph, what is the time frame on Dr. Sedts? I know we're really low on staff and they've been just, you know, drowning with all the stuff that's coming in, but what's the time frame on making Dr. Sedts a reality? Can you give me some idea? It's been pushed back due to other programs that the council has that are superseding that.

15:30 I think that in the director's report we should ask Mark for a new timeline. So are you amenable to the language as it is here, but you just wanted to know where Dr. Seth's timeline is now? Yeah, I think we should include that in this because it's a planning report for 2009. I think we should have some language that includes where it is now.

15:56 Otherwise, the description is exactly what it is, but it sounds like it's on the shelf. It's not on the shelf. It's still out there and we want to make it happen. You were interpreting that language and say it was on the shelf. Oh, absolutely, I forget. Absolutely, that's my interpretation. It does not say that, but it's my interpretation, the way it's written, instead of being, you know, a strategy, an economic development strategy.

16:20 It doesn't sound like it's an ongoing strategy. Exactly. Exactly. What page are you looking at? Page 15 in the packet, 13 or 21. And just for the benefit of the viewing public to Dr. Seds, as we refer to it as not a doctor, it's destination resort community economic development strategy. Very good. Right. Very good. Did you have that written? Never mind. No, that wasn't.

16:47 Excellent piece of work and it sums up everything we're dealing with and everything we need to deal with and we want to make sure it happens. And I can imagine getting a phone call, who's Dr. Seth? What's his email address? I'm sorry. Okay. That's all from me, Rhonda. Okay, thank you. I think this is a question for Jen. On the first page of the report, in giving the background, you talk about the California code that requires

17:15 Local agencies to investigate and make recommendations to the legislative body regarding reasonable and practical means for implementing the general plan. And then you go on to mention the requirement for a report, which is this report. My question is one of procedure. As long as we're making this report every year because we have to, why not fold that first requirement in and do a little bit of forward thinking about

17:45 Other ways we might do things instead of just reporting on the progress we've made. Is there some other place that we satisfy that requirement about investigating and making recommendations? Well, I think the report serves as our status check and report back on the last year and how we've progressed. And in that we can say what we've been doing successfully and what hasn't quite worked so well. And we tried in this report actually to get in an actual

18:13 The action table of the general plan can actually detail out the status of the progress of all those items, as well as what Dr. said. Time being as it is, we happen to run out of time to not be able to do that, but we are hoping for next year that we can include a much more detailed action progress report for this, and then we can make more directive recommendations and suggestions for next year in order to prioritize and focus on.

18:42 I think that would be good. I mean, as long as we're spending the time, why not make it a tool for us as well as just reporting on what we've done. I mean, when I was reading this, I started thinking about other things you could do, and I got a little bit, a lot further out. For example, when I was looking at the mobility segment, I started thinking about what about segues for people that aren't going to walk.

19:09 And then I don't know if any of you have ever read about something that's called personal rapid transit, but it's a, I'll just read the definition, I think that's the best way to define it. A public transportation concept in which small automated vehicles travel on a network of specially built guideways. The vehicles do not stop at every station, instead they are designed to make a non-stop journey to the destination individual users have selected and bypass intermediate stations.

19:38 It's kind of like an on-demand taxi service. I started thinking about things like that and thought, well, you know, if we had another part of this that was more forward thinking, we could, what if we had the money and the time to do that kind of stuff, we could do a little bit of future thinking here? I think I'd like to hold that type of discussion for

20:01 Later on on our agenda, which is the preparation for the town council study session. I just meant to give that an example and say why not in the future have this kind of a... And I think that we probably want to address this in the director's report is what is the level of detail because if you put your aspirations on here or suddenly are you held to them when you don't have a level of control. So I see...

20:25 This report, I'm interpreting this report as a recap of what we did. Now, it doesn't say too much why we did what we did because sometimes we were directed to do something instead of what we had intended to do. Is that pertinent here or is it just this is what happened? Do you need to put in, you know, is it implied that because of the economy and the flexing resources and

20:51 And priorities, this is what we did. And that's the way I kind of looked at this. But I don't know what the requirements of the report are. Yeah, that's correct. The state really uses this report to assess local trends and planning, understand kind of where the local jurisdictions are going and if they need to make any adjustments in their regulations, like with the general plan guidelines, maybe how they need to react as well. So they're using it as...

21:19 A meter as well to kind of see where the local jurisdictions are. And then the housing information is used strictly by HCD, which does relate to our progress in meeting our regional housing needs, as well as with grant distribution. Okay. So I don't think we're held with our feet to the fire by the state and specific guidance in here. Just wanted to clear that one up before we tell them we're going to do something.

21:48 I was going to call staff on this, but this is Paul. I'll go ahead and ask. We are on track for March for the ordinance on the marijuana cooperative, so the community is informed before the June 8th ballot. That will be brought to you at your next meeting. So it's one meeting late, but yeah, it will be on the April 14th meeting. So instead of this today, it's going to be April 14th. Okay. And then

22:16 That has to come back for a second? Or is that only at council? It'll have to be a second reading? Only council. So the Planning Commission would make a recommendation to town council. Town council will consider it and then conduct a second hearing. And the schedule works out that it'll all be completed prior to the vote. Okay. And so for those in the public asking about that, so they could review it before the vote, it'll be available on the town website a week prior to our April 14th meeting then? Correct. Right. The reports are distributed typically the Thursday before the meeting.

22:46 Thank you. So did anyone have any further questions or clarifications on the annual planning report at this time? Madam Chair, I'll make a motion to accept the consent agenda as amended. Second. Second. Any further discussion meeting? All in favor? Aye. Thank you. The next item then is the Planning Commission letter of support for application.

23:15 For grant funds from the Caltrans community-based transportation planning grant program. I'm sorry, you know, I made the motion to accept the whole consent agenda. Do you want me to resend it? It would only be necessary if somebody has concern about the letter. Any concerns? Well, I heard it just for that one item. Oh, you did? Oh, okay. I thought it was for one item. Oh, okay. I said approved the consent agenda, so that was my... I thought you pulled that one item. Yeah, okay.

23:46 So do we need another mention? For the consent agenda? For item 2. For item 2. Anyone have any changes on item 2? Okay. I move we approve the Planning Commission letter of support for application for grant funds from the Caltrans Community-Based Transportation Planning Grant Program. In a second. Okay. No further discussion, Paul, for the vote. All in favor? Aye. I have signed my draft coffee already, but I will sign that one.

24:17 Mine's in red. Thank you. Okay, moving on then to our public hearing. There are none at this time, but the next item, they are the business matters, and it is item number three, the Planning Commission, small wind turbines. And Sandra, you have this item. Thank you. The purpose of this item is to present a potential Planning Commission interpretation for small wind turbine installations.

24:46 We received a request late 2009 from Mr. Pete Moeller to install a small wind turbine, which is proposed to be 30 feet high. And staff analyzed the code and determined that there wasn't any requirements in the code that would permit this, either through any type of permit. However, we did meet with the advisory design panel committee.

25:12 and discuss this proposal and they recommended that staff look into possibly an interpretation of the code to allow this type of small wind turbine installation. Staff reviewed the code and found that the closest item in the code would be a satellite antenna or an antenna, which is...

25:32 Somewhat similar to a small wind turbine installation. So in order to allow this type of an installation without an amendment to the zoning code to allow wind turbine installations, the Planning Commission would need to interpret the code to say that these small wind turbine installations are not more detrimental than a typical large antenna or antenna installation.

25:57 So staff included that information in the report and additionally we did do some research on the Assembly Bill 1207 which actually has already sunsetted so it's not currently in effect however we did include those regulations in here for you to review and we did review

26:18 An American Planning Association publication called Practice Renewable Energy that details small wind installations and we did include that as attachment to of this agenda bill, I'm sorry, of this report. And basically the article goes through kind of the typical impacts and discusses how to deal with the different impacts. So staff reviewed that and determined that

26:46 Basically, these small wind installations probably aren't likely to generate major impacts based on our research on this article. And so staff made a recommendation that the commission find that this use is similar to and no more detrimental than existing permitted uses within the residential, commercial, industrial districts and to allow this type of an installation with an administrative permit, which is a permit that's approved by the community development director but does not come before the planning commission.

27:16 So I'm available for any questions. I'd be happy to talk about any of this information in more detail. Tony, you had a question. I have numerous questions for you, Sandra. First, let me just, well, I won't editorialize, let me just ask the questions. So you are, so it's staff's recommendation and staff's interpretation that a satellite dish on a side of a home is no different than a 30-foot by 4-foot tower.

27:44 Well, the code calls out satellite dishes and antennas. So that would be the closest thing in the code to a wind turbine that is a metal structure standing up. So staff was looking for something that would be the closest thing, and that was what we found.

28:00 Two-foot dish is what we're talking about on the side, or are you talking about a large or an antenna that could be four, which normally aren't used any longer. Yeah, this code is an older code, and so yeah, I think the intent was to cover those types of installations as well. And then I noticed there were no analysis at all of are there wind speed calculations for the town of Mammoth Lakes? Is this a viable option? There's nothing in our packet, and I know over the years, I know that Dan Dawson

28:29 Has done these calculations. So I just wanted to be sure that the town has done no analysis of other calculations except for the AV's bill and also from this company, Mariah. Right. We didn't conduct any wind speed analysis of what's in the town. Mr. Moeller may be able to speak to the research that he's done in town, but we didn't conduct any wind speed analysis to determine where in town this would be beneficial. It would likely be the applicant would...

28:59 Would look into that information in order to purchase this unit. I mean, I doubt that they would be purchasing it if it wasn't going to be a viable option. So I would assume that the applicants would be looking into that information. But Mr. Moeller may be able to elaborate on that. And then I noticed that, you know, the information here is from a company called Mariah. I've done a lot of, you know, work on the internet looking at a lot of things. They have a very well-informed website. But we are...

29:28 Basically doing an interpretation that would be specific to this company's product. And there's many other products available on the market, such as spires that go on top of buildings and other ones that are actually up to 80 foot tall and even larger. So would it be staff's opinion that by approving this interpretation, we are basically locking in one company to a monopoly on what could be put in the town of Mammoth Lakes?

29:58 I don't think that would be the case. I think that we would look at each project as it came in on a case-by-case basis, and if there are similar installations to this, we could bring it before the Planning Commission if we have something that's different. Obviously, this would only cover something that would meet the current height standards, so it wouldn't be anything that could exceed the 35-foot maximum height and residential. So if someone did come in with a taller or something that was...

30:24 Very different from what you're seeing here. I think that would be something we would bring back to the Planning Commission. So our intent was just to kind of look at what was presented to us. However, ultimately, when we update the zoning code, we will be including regulations for all types. Well, and that's my next question, too, is that Jay and I sit on that committee, and this is something that over the next two months and that when we're meeting, that we could actually place as a priority along with

30:49 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

31:13 So, is that something that staff really looked at and felt, I mean, because you kind of mentioned it here, but didn't take a position on that, so. On whether or not we're going to include all. Well, whether it should be, I mean, it was more, it's kind of a gray area that staff left in this packet, from what I could read. I think it definitely will be included in the zoning code. Well, I understand that, but.

31:34 More of why we're taking this up as an interpretation instead of waiting the two months to get it as a full public hearing. It's just the interim period, right, to allow if someone wants to pursue this type of installation now, the Planning Commission has the opportunity to allow this type of installation. I don't know the timing on the zoning code update. That was part of the reason why we pushed this ahead was to allow the Planning Commission to make a decision on these types of installations.

31:59 Whereas it could be two months, it could be longer. It just depends on staff's workload right now. So that was the reason why we did bring it forward. But we are planning on including it in the code update. Thank you. Chair. Following up on Tony's question about satellite dishes and antennas, is that part of our code, would that apply to a ham radio type antenna?

32:25 It would apply to all different types of antennas. Okay. Because that, to me, made a lot more sense than a satellite dish, which is typically attached to a structure and, as Tony mentioned, very different. But I can see the analogy to a, you know, some of these ham radio antennas do the same thing. They stand up vertically out separate from a structure. Yeah, just the code simply says satellite dish slash antenna, which is why we referenced it that way in this.

32:49 Assembly Bill 1207, that was really interesting to me, and I researched that a bit, but one thing I couldn't find was, well, the facts first, that bill was signed into law in either 2001 or 2002, and it had a sunset provision in it. That's why it expired in 2005. And I kept searching, trying to figure out why it was sunsetted and why no other legislation came afterward, and I couldn't find any answer to that. Did you?

33:19 Do you have any? No, I didn't. I found that kind of curious. It is odd. I can kind of fill you in if you want a little. My interpretation of it in research and what we've done on our geothermal side is that the base load factor of wind is very minimal compared to what solar and geothermal can do. Thus the buyback from the utility companies is very low. So I think it was just kind of left that solar kind of picked up the solar farms.

33:48 Have gone on, and SCE has really put, and PG&E both, a lot into the solar instead of the other aspects of wind. It's interesting that they put a sunset right in the law. Yeah. Anyway, and a follow-up to that, Sandra, that's the law we know about with respect to wind energy. Is there anything similar in California law with respect to solar, with respect to geothermal, that's a mandate from the state restricting what...

34:18 Local municipalities can do with respect to prohibiting these sorts of installations. I'm aware of solar, that cities can't prohibit people from installing solar. I think it's just on roofs. Homeowners associations can't prohibit that. I'm not aware of anything on geothermal, though. Geothermal is governed by Department of Land Management. There's mineral rights and water rights involved, and it's a state agency. Yeah, so it's all state agencies that regulate it in a local municipality.

34:47 Would have to go through those state agencies. There's royalties that need to be paid back. So there's many layers of government to get those two things done. Okay. Okay. I think that's all I've got for the moment. So are there any other questions? No questions, but lots of comments. The staff, okay. Because what we're here today is to see if we find this consistent with your definition. Is that correct? Mm-hmm. Okay.

35:18 It's going to come. There's not a public hearing on this, but the applicant is here. Is there anything at this time that you wanted to address the Planning Commission? Do we have your proposal in the packet as well? I would just enhance that. In terms of podium. You come forward. Dean Moberly, Moberly Architects, members of the Commission and staff, thank you very much for your time.

35:45 The application that you have is basically complete. My intention was to introduce this product before I brought a specific location, and I have a couple of locations pending in the wings once we get past this point, but I want to know if we need to do this full process to bring those, or is this something we can do with an administrative permit, and that's my goal today, to pass that step. Thank you.

36:12 Okay, if there's no more questions of staff for the end, I'm going to open this up to discussion. And some questions, I know Elizabeth, you said that you had some items you wanted to say. Well, I think when it comes time for the vote, I'm going to vote for option three, which is recommend that wind turbines be included in the zoning code update and don't allow them until the zoning code is adopted. But because you have come forward, I think this is a relatively small item and it should be updated.

36:44 A theme throughout the general plan is that the man-made shouldn't detract from the natural, you know, our spectacular natural surroundings. And the visual blight aspect of something I absolutely believe in. Of course, it's alternative energy. We should use this. We have the wind through the pass. I absolutely should be using this. But if you look at the wind turbines in Tehachapi on those bare hills,

37:07 I mean, that's public art. Those are sculptures like we saw here, and this didn't come out very well in the copy, but I mean, they're gorgeous, absolutely gorgeous. But this is something akin to a TV antenna, even though it's cylindrical and smaller, it's akin to a TV antenna. And just because they paint them gray doesn't mean this startup company can't get some different colors of paint. There's a problem with reflectivity, which you'll see on this picture in the top, and there's another picture.

37:37 Here, showing how reflective it is. It's not unlike looking at a cell phone tower. That's why they disguise cell phone towers in places where their visual impact would be significant. Here, one of the colors that was suggested actually when Commissioner Duncan and I talked about it was dark green, but this roof is one of my pet peeves about standing seam sheet metal roofs. It's in Denali green, which is not the color of any vegetation I've ever seen.

38:07 So what it needs to do, in my view, is have its visual impact significantly mitigated, and just as I learned when I first moved here 15 years ago, Dave McCoy said you can paint the lift towers any color you want as long as they're black, because he just wanted them to disappear. And it's the same thing, a dark matte finish, whether it's olive drab, you know, just some dark color that won't stand out.

38:36 Would be fine. And if this is, I mean, I would think there'd be a demand for this. I'm surprised it hasn't occurred to Mariah Energy to start offering them in colors. I saw one photograph here showing it in dark brown against the desert. Right here it was dark brown. No, against the desert, that isn't the color I would have chosen. But one of the rationales in the other zoning information that staff listed in the staff report

39:03 was the gray is considered to be the color that's most least visible against the sky. Well, that's the same reasoning that lets people put blue metal roofs on top of their buildings, you know, because it's the color of the sky. That's not how you see it. This will only be 30 feet high or whatever the ultimate height is, but it needs to be a dark matte finish that blends in so completely minimize its visual impact because like this, it's just like looking at a

39:32 TV antenna, and aren't we glad we don't have to look at those anymore? So I would go for option three, and I would add to that option a recommendation that this be addressed right away. So that's where I stand. Thank you. Jake? I'll go. My biggest concern is with making sure, well, I'll back up a minute. I'm a big...

40:02 I'm a proponent of alternative energy. I've kind of followed wind energy for a long time. I would love to see this kind of technology succeed here. The worry I have is with the aesthetic concerns that the town is going to have, that the people in town are going to have, that we allow something but put

40:29 Aesthetic constraints on it which almost ensure that it won't practically work and thereby killing future prospects because the first time it's tried it doesn't work. And mainly what I'm concerned with is the amount of height and the amount of separation of the turbine from other structures and trees that may be necessary for it to be able to capture a practical amount of wind energy.

40:58 If you look in the APA article that was included in our packet, there's a couple of quotes I want to read on page 65, which is not the actual page of the article, but it's page in our packet. The statement, a small wind turbine can produce impressive amounts of power, but only with access to good wind, which is largely a function of proper siding and adequate height, factors that zoning regulations impact mildly. And then a quote,

41:27 Further down on that page, variations in topography and obstructions such as buildings and trees slow the wind and add turbulence near the ground. Therefore, adequate height is a critical factor in effectiveness. In order to function well, the lowest part of the rotor blades must be a minimum of 25 to 35 feet higher than surrounding obstructions.

41:47 Height regulations that do not achieve such separation eliminate the benefits of investing in a wind turbine system. Now a little bit of a caveat there, I suspect that article they're talking about horizontal axis wind turbines and not vertical. So that height probably will vary a bit. But going on, small wind turbines must be mounted at least 25 to 35 feet above surrounding objects, between 50 to 120 feet per end, the higher the better close per end, in order to perform well.

42:16 At lower heights, even if there is a lot of wind, it will be so turbulent that the turbine will wear out quickly before installation costs can be recouped. So as I mentioned, those heights may well vary for the vertical axis turbine, but I'm still concerned that the kind of height that may be necessary in a particular location in town for this to be a practical device in terms of generating energy may be more than

42:46 the town is willing to grant. And I want it to be successful, so I'm concerned with how we deal with that trade-off. Just to point a clarification, you weren't referring to a different color as being something that would interfere with a wind turbine. No. You're just talking about would it be practical because it wouldn't be tall enough. Yeah, functionality. Yeah, yeah.

43:10 In a point on noise, if you look at the figures and what some of these other limits have been placed on noise and you look at these particular turbines, I suspect that's a non-issue. This is very quiet, particularly compared to those big horizontal axis turbines. And I know some of these newer ones are, I believe they're even using magnetic bearings.

43:36 which make them even take some of the sound, get it even lower and make them even more reliable in terms of not having to worry about the bearings wearing out. As to size, there's a reference in the APA article talking about small wind. There's two kinds of, quote, small wind, close quote. One is residential, and they say that that's turbines rated at 10 kilowatts or less, and for commercial installations, I think it's 100 kilowatts.

44:05 10 kilowatts, compare that to the wind spire, it's 1.2 kilowatts. So we're talking about a pretty small installation relatively. Again, I'm arguing in favor of this being a pretty reasonable size. Oh, and I worry about the setback requirements. I know this isn't necessarily the requirement that will be imposed, but on page 40, which was a listing of the requirements in AB 1207,

44:36 There was a, let's find my place here, height was limited to 65 feet on one to five acre parcels, but there was nothing said about parcels less than one acre. If we stuck to something like that, you couldn't have one most places, residentially at least, most places within town. So I'm just, I've got a lot of concern because I want this to be successful and I want to figure out a way for it to allow it to be functionally successful and still.

45:04 It really is going to be very site-specific.

45:36 The microclimate of any particular lot is going to have to have a little observation and analysis to see if it's appropriate or not. Mostly it's going to be on the ridge lines or bluffs where this is or in open meadow areas. Also, this particular unit that I'm proposing actually performs very well even at the lower height.

46:01 In lower winds and in open, as long as it's open areas, in areas that are heavily wooded or that are on the lee sides of bluffs or ridges, they wouldn't be candidates. Yeah, yeah. And can I respond to one other thing also while I'm here? The changing of the color, the factory finishes not any paint at all. The tower shaft itself is galvanized. It's all recycled steel.

46:30 The cylinder turbine itself is made of aluminum, and the fins are actually airfoils. They're shaped like airplane wings, and I'm not sure what the effect of painting them would do. I've seen shafts painted, but I've never seen the foils painted in any installations, and they have them all over the world now from this company. Even powder-coated? It might be possible, and I'm going to go back to the engineers, and we're going to talk about that.

46:56 So that I can respond to these things further, but right off the top of my head, I don't know. And especially, you were concerned about glare, and one of those issues, probably on the airfoils, is that you've got to have a pretty smooth surface, or you interfere with the... Yes, it's a very small foil. It's only about four inches wide. I just want to follow up on one thing Mr. Moeller said. You mentioned ridgelines, and that reminded me of one thought I had, and everybody's going to have different opinions, but

47:27 When I look at Mammoth Mountain and see lift towers, I see towers for wind turbines as less intrusive than lift towers. Neither one of them bother me. We've got some great ridge lines up there, which to me would be an ideal place to consider putting these things. Of course, that's a different concept than a lot and power generated on the lot for the use on that lot. But it's something to think about because we've got the wind energy.

47:58 Sharon? No. Did you have any? Okay, thanks. Tony? Well, Pete, I just want to say I want to thank you for, like, putting your foot forward and bringing this up, and it pains me because I am going to also go with option three. And what pains me is that I know you and I know what you want to do here, and the fact that you could bring jobs to this community by way of training, you know, kids and younger people, our construction guys, giving them work to do these installations.

48:29 It's something that we need. And it's sad it's going to have to wait for a while, but I want to get more into the scientific part of this and not the aesthetics because I think that will all come through public hearings if it goes through the process. And, you know, right now, and this is more for staff and also for you, Pete, because you may want to contact them. I served on the Great Basin Air Pollution Quality Control District Court for four years as a director.

48:58 And one of the things we did is we installed equipment on the top of the Rite Aid building. And on top of that building is an odometer that measures wind speed. And it would be very easy for the town staff and for you, Pete, to contact Ted Shady. And you could get that information of the wind speeds that are collected. And, you know, basically how it works is you have a bend, which is a graph, and you have these different bends that measures all your wind speeds. I can tell you that for the town of Mammoth Lakes,

49:28 From past studies that have been done, that then is going to have a zero in it in most of them. And there's going to be some that have higher, you know, numbers. Frankly, you know, if you look at the town of Mammoth Lakes, there might be some places up in the knolls that are at a position to where a wind spire could work, but not very few other places in town other than out of the Snow Creek Meadow.

49:52 I think it's something that we need to look at in our update. We need to have it included because we need to have all renewable energy resources viewed as a possibility for our town for our future. You know, I kind of went back and forth with this, Pete, and then I went on the Mariah website and I found words, and I'll read this. It says, how much wind do you need? It says, in general, you want average wind speeds of around 12 miles per hour.

50:18 Although in some places, wind spire makes sense with lesser wind resources. For example, if you have high electricity rates, which we all know we do, or substantial rebates or incentives available to you, it may make sense to place a wind spire in a zone with an average wind speed of only 10 miles per hour. And they say, note, average wind speed means the average 24 hours a day, 365 days a year for an average year.

50:47 And we have to remember that year to year that averages can change quite a bit. So my point is from the studies that Dan Dawson has done over the last 20 years, a constant wind speed of even 10 miles per hour has never been documented within the town of Mammoth Lakes. So I would encourage you to contact Dan and work with him on the statistics that he's done because he's really looked at for down at Snarl and for the town.

51:15 To actually have these types of product in our town for renewable. And for that reason, and also I just, I can't accept that an interpretation could be that satellite dish or an antenna is comparable. And I really feel that this needs to go through a public process because it's a very heated issue. There's also

51:42 Possibility of wildlife damage. Now these, it's very minimum. And as the products become more on the market, they're getting better products that don't do that, that, you know, the aesthetics of it. So it's something for our future, but it really needs to go through the process. And I also would like added in the number three that we make renewable energy a priority in our committee for the zoning code ordinance.

52:14 Madam Chair. Could I make a suggestion? Would it be appropriate, what does the Commission feel and what does staff feel, that there be a temporary subcommittee consisting of Jay and me? Because we looked at this initially. I really want to see how to make this work. I really, really do. And I know the public outcry that will happen. It's consistent with our general plan, but how do we minimize visual impact? How do we make it maximally effective? Would it be useful?

52:41 For there to be a Planning Commission subcommittee to do further research with the applicant and with staff. I think you need to wait for a zoning code because you need to have it in the code, Elizabeth. Oh, no, for that one aspect of the code. Then it should be all renewable energies, not just one. It should be... Not just the language about wind? No, it should be solar. It should be, I mean, if we're going to do that. Okay. I mean, that's my opinion on what the best the commission feels like.

53:09 And I just think that we need to, you know, Jay and I, you know, our meeting, we... Yeah, I know you're already doing the update. Well, we pushed for meetings and then we got put off, and I think council needs to have a message that we need this as a priority. We asked that in our past meeting, and I know our next meeting won't be until this coming month, but I think we need to, whatever we can do, Sandra, to expedite that, get our meetings sooner. I know our committee is ready, willing, and able to get this done, so...

53:38 And for the rest of the Commission, we've just been asked to wait, and that was not what our committee wanted to do. But it came down as a directive from the Town Council, so. I thought your target date was December. For complete all the ordinances. We're talking, we're taking a section at a time. And you're going to present that individually?

54:01 I don't know how it's going to be presented. I think that our committee was going to take a section at a time and then it would come forward. Our choice is to take a section, have it ratified, go through the public process. That becomes part of what our, to coincide with our general plan. If we wait until December and then we go through 2011, we're a year away from having to amend again our general plan. Okay, I just didn't realize it was going to be done piecemeal. I thought it was, you know, going to be ready for our public by August, September.

54:30 No, I think the finalized portion of it, but I know we've discussed in our committee meetings that, you know, we are taking a section at a time. We're not doing, we're not taking the whole apple, we're taking a bite at a time. Didn't realize that. And this is something that we could recommend that our committee takes up as a priority in the first meeting. I think these could be complementary. I think the kind of information we could learn by allowing one of these at least to start work on going ahead would inform

54:58 The zoning ordinance. Just for example, like you're talking about the question of whether there is adequate wind, that's something that as this went to a particular site, we'd find out. And those are the kind of things we'd need to know in crafting the zoning code that applied to this. I really would like to make this work. And I don't have enough information. I don't know enough about it. And we don't know enough about local conditions. And we have to anticipate the public outcry and address it.

55:27 Be able to address, you know, in an informed way their issues. I would suggest you allow one. Let people see it. Oh, you want to be a pilot project? Why not? Yeah, okay. We're planning to put one in at the fire station first. That's an interesting idea. Every other jurisdiction in Inyo and Mono County signed off months ago. I'm not quite sure why we need to make this so hard. Are there any other caveats we could put on, Tony, that would make you?

56:03 More comfortable with allowing, you know, at least one or a few of these to go ahead now? No, I just think we need the public's input and we don't have that. I think do an interpretation. I've never been comfortable with this body or even council doing an interpretation without the public. So, but what you're also talking about, though, is that option three, it reads until the zoning code is adopted. That's uncertain. And to Sharon's point is, and what you're actually talking about today is till this portion.

56:34 that would be affected by the zoning code is now you're talking about a zoning code amendment not the entire code and that's the only that would be the only condition that I could look at is that if that's possible that you're pulling this particular portion fast tracking in but you still need to have these particular things available there because otherwise it could be

57:01 We could have another priority come to light. That pushes it even further. And, you know, the message is this was, this we, we have a lot of priorities in the zoning code in general is one of them. But now this is something that we see within that priority. It's a double, triple A priority here. And we would like to see if we could mitigate this. I think that you're looking at, you know, with,

57:29 It's hard to envision within the suburban landscape, you know, how that affects for most people. You're talking about having within the urban area, and it's very intriguing. It's hard to visualize. I personally have a place where I'd love to see it, you know, but I'm within the county because I think I have the conditions. Unfortunately, I have the conditions that would make this, I think, what they say most effective there.

57:57 But that's, it doesn't apply, you know, to me. So I'm more than happy to let somebody else be the guinea pig there. But how that, you know, option three would then need to be reworded to allow this to come up, because that's not how I see it now. It would have to move. It would have to be part of everything. Well, I think that's what we're saying is that it should be made a priority in the first round of the zoning code committee.

58:24 But let's get back to Mr. Moeckler's suggestion. Is this something that the Fire Protection District is paying for? Have they asked you to do this? No, I'm making the investment to introduce it to the town. They've agreed to host it. Okay. And where are you going to install it there? That's a whole different thing. But no, but we would be able to see the actual product as opposed to pictures. People actually would drive by it every day. They would stop. They would look. They would listen. They would look at the...

58:53 In the window there would be a small display showing the electronic performance display showing graphs of where the wind is at, what the power it is producing, kilowatt hours that it's producing over time, and it would be creating interest and perhaps some acceptance to the product. And Sandra, that would then fall under a temporary installation that would not have to go through this body or?

59:23 Any type of code adjustment? Well, I'm not sure about that. We would have to look into the proposal for it just to be, if you're speaking of just a temporary installation for a certain short period of time, or is it a permanent installation? It is permanent. I'm sorry. I retract that. I'm sorry. Would this be, it's on a corner, would this be on Forest Trail, in front of the station, next to the... It would be on the west side of the station, adjacent to Forest Trail. Well, you know, unfortunately, that's not what we have in front of us right now.

59:53 Which is, you know, we're looking for here that this is, is this use similar and no more detrimental than the existing permitted uses. And that's what we're being asked today. And I think you would have to make that determination in order to allow, before you provide anything. And that's where is, and I think if you read option three in that context, it is saying,

1:00:23 It would be saying, no it is not, and we must define within the zoning code what its impact is. So that's where option three looks a little, it actually, it feels like it steers us down another path to make it the way it's written here, and we would probably want to redefine it. That's right, perhaps in the future, I know we've said this before, it's always nice to have an option that allows us to make

1:00:52 Changes to the options presented. Well, what can we not do that? I think that's applied. You know what? It's never stopped us. I certainly hope so. The language there has never stopped us. Option four? We rewrite. They're all on that as well. So option one says it's finding the use is similar or no more detrimental if you adopt that.

1:01:18 Use within the residential, commercial, industrial zones of permit them with the approval of an administrative permit. And option two is that it is not similar. And then option three recommends that it takes this up within the zoning code. I suspect all five of us can agree with that part of option three that we recommend it be included in the zoning code update. I think we have consensus on that. Just going beyond that is the issue.

1:01:48 Well, and I have a question for Sandra, if I may, too, before we get to a motion in that that, sorry, I should have asked earlier, because it's been running in my head. If this was to be approved, which doesn't seem like it will at this point on interpretation, but, you know, it's got industrial and commercial, so does that mean that developer A, who has their use permit sitting in the wings, could come back and say, I want to amend my use permit, I want to put wind spires, and because I'm doing that, I now am providing...

1:02:14 Such of a community benefit, and they can start that argument to where they can try to get something changed. I mean, there's no definition. We've left it wide open here, and I don't want to open that door right now myself. Do we have, can we make a recommendation to staff that they limit this to one demonstration?

1:02:33 Installation, can we, can we, do we have the power to limit that? See, again, I have an issue with that for us doing it on interpretation because there may be another company out there, and I know there is in Reno. But that's why this would be a good thing. We'd learn from it. Well, but then you're eliminated to only one, and I don't think you, I think you need a full spectrum. I mean, this is very scientific and you need, there's other products out there. Well, this would be a start. You know, and I just. Tony, I have to disagree. Here we have.

1:03:00 Here we have a proposal that's completely consistent with our general plan. Here we have an applicant who's willing at his own expense to put up a demonstration turbine at our fire district. That's not the most... I know, I know. So... That should be part of the discussion, Elizabeth. Well, yeah, no, I can... I'm back to differ. Yeah, I can express my opinion. It is... Before us is the recommendation that this doesn't pose any more...

1:03:29 Impact, or is consistent with the same impact of what you've compared this to. And I have to get back to that. If that is true, and you know, you can, we can argue that yes it does, you know, or no it does not. Is it the same as an antenna? It's not the same as we've established that it is similar to an antenna or even, you know, a cell tower. It has less impact as a cell tower.

1:03:57 Because it's not as tall. But it's on the top of the, these are not attached to a building yet. You know, and that's what we're looking at there. Should you find that it has no more impact, and that's all we're, then it looks like it's the next step. Because it can't be where, unless you're saying, if you put it here, it has no more impact. If you put it there, it does have an impact. And I don't see that that's the way it's written.

1:04:24 No, the intent is that then it would have to meet the requirements for a satellite dish slash antenna, which is the standard requirements. They have to meet the setbacks for all different zones and the height requirements. So that's how we would measure it through the administrative permit process. So that would, if the commission found, determined it was similar and no more detrimental than, then Mr. Moeller could submit for an administrative permit for the fire district project, which would not come before the planning commission. It would be a...

1:04:53 Director level review. Okay. It would be what, Sandra? Director's level review. Right. Administrative. Correct. But to finish my comment, what I'm trying to figure out is how can we make this work and have it benefit everybody. I mean, I really, I think the idea of seeing one on the ground so we can figure out more intelligently exactly what the zoning code should say is a really good idea. I'm just not clear, even listening to your explanation, Rhonda, I'm still not completely clear on how the other two options would...

1:05:22 The option one, actually, would apply just to this one case. Well, can't we word it so that it does? I need some help with that. I'm not quite sure how to do that. Because we're being asked if it's consistent with existing code, which is outdated. It's from 1987. But that doesn't... I know, but it's... So the answer is yes. Is it consistent with existing code? If we agree. If we agree that that is there. Yeah.

1:05:53 And the code being outdated isn't the issue. Now we're updating it and it would not be existing coded when you change it, but you've agreed at the time that this was part of the existing code. So isn't the answer to your question is in order to make that happen to where it's a test case or whatever, you would have to find for option one in order to make it happen.

1:06:24 And then it's not just Mr. Moeller. I know. I feel like I'm in a vice here. I'm trying to figure out how to accomplish the objective and not get unintended consequences. That's what I'm concerned about. Well, that's pretty much impossible. I think that's the problem. That's exactly what I'm talking about. Since March has shown up, our next committee meeting for our zoning code update is going to be in the next month by March, I think, or by April.

1:06:54 Okay, so if we were to suggest in a motion here that it be a priority of that zoning code update to address the renewable energy resource part of our zoning code update, are we then able to address it at that meeting, come forward with a ordinance for it, which we could do in that meeting with the group that we have, and bring it forward to this body for an amendment to our zoning code over the next two to three months maximum.

1:07:29 I think we'd be hard-pressed to take this on as a new work item immediately starting now and bring it to the committee. Could you do it with help from a subcommittee? Since I've missed your discussion, a couple things you could do. One, as a new item, something that's introduced to you, one choice that you have is you could say that this is appropriate to a certain zone.

1:08:01 And so you could say that, for example, you might want to test this out in the commercial zone or in an industrial zone where you would typically have more intensive uses. And so you could limit your interpretation to those kind of zoning districts. Another option is you could say that instead of having an administrative permit at this time, because this is a brand new thing,

1:08:27 And so if that's a concern, you could

1:08:58 Say, yes, let's test it out. Let's have a higher level of review for this first case and make sure that we're going to be protected. And then you satisfy your design issues, screening, adjacency, all of those issues, and then come to the zoning code update and work it out more there. And the reason I answered your question where I think it might be a little difficult for us to come to the committee is that

1:09:25 Our first works on zoning code, which were delayed on because of our other work insertions, were going to be the signage program, and so we'd have to delay the signage program to be able to work on this, which we can do. What does changing that requirement to a design review do for the applicant in terms of cost and time? It increases both, their cost and their time. I don't have exact figures on the...

1:10:01 There's no way to take option one and be very clear that this is a demonstration project? Or as you said, Mark, in that one specific zone? If you make a determination that says this is consistent with, let's say, the commercial general zone, because that's what that would be, it would apply to all the commercial general zone. And once we...

1:10:31 Decide that something is a permitted use. You can't regulate how many of them unless it's very specific that way in the code, much like what you did with the medical dispensaries. I think that, you know, another thing that we could do if you're concerned about the design review process, you can treat this much like you do a sign, and you can say, please refer it to a committee.

1:11:01 Since you entered, my concern is the public and no public participation in it. Even if it's a demonstration? Excuse me? Do you mean public participation in the review and approval of the? Of the ordinance. I mean, this is an ordinance change that we would be doing. We're saying it's an interpretation, so it's going to skip over the ordinance change that we're doing in the coming months. If this body decides the interpretation is that it's acceptable, then it's code then.

1:11:31 That's correct. Yeah, so it's code then. I mean, there's no public process for it. And ultimately, though, we would still include this in the zoning code update. This would be just the interim period between now and when. I understand. At this point, there's no public participation. Right. But how about Sharon's suggestion that why can't we amend option one to say this is for this particular case as a demonstration wind turbine? I mean, why can't we be specific to this particular proposal?

1:11:58 Why does this mean that everybody's going to be able to do this in their front yards? Because of the law. Yeah, you're saying, commercial general, you can't pick and choose what company can come. But we can't change the wording to say, as a demonstration project, I mean, this almost seems red tape-like. Give me an example of why that's not right. That would be like saying a retail shoe store will only permit one in this zone because you want to see if it works. Yeah.

1:12:28 So what zoning is doing is it's categorizing uses, building, and accoutrement appropriate to those different districts for land use compatibility and all the factors that you consider when you're doing zoning code. Let me add, Elizabeth.

1:12:49 I mean, I'm not against doing this. I mean, very clearly. No, I know that. And it's not at all. But you have to have all of the information. We talked about earlier, 55 meetings on Mammoth Place. Well, that gave us all of the necessary information, regardless of what somebody thinks about the meetings, to make the best possible outcome happen.

1:13:08 And we did that. And it was general plan stuff. And we need that on this also with our renewables. And I want to see it happen. But in the time that we're waiting with the zoning code, I don't think anybody sitting at this table could say that we don't think it's going to be in our new zoning code amendments to allow it. So what Mr. Moeller and others would be able to do is do their analysis. It does not stop them from doing wind studies.

1:13:36 From going around town and doing wind studies in different locations to establish for themselves where they would be available. That's supplying us with the necessary information that we need when it comes to use permit time. So it doesn't stop him from moving forward with what he needs to do to find out if it's viable. What is the height limit and setback requirement within Commercial General for the antenna?

1:14:04 Type of installation that we're deciding about? It's a 35-foot height limit, and then the setbacks are 20 feet for the front yard. There's actually a street side yard is 20 feet, so along that corner it would be a 20-foot setback from the street and 20-foot setback from the front. How many places in Commercial General could you fit one of these within that setback? A lot or few? Well, there's a zero side setback for properties that are, you know, that are not corner, so...

1:14:34 You know, you could, the fire station may be difficult. I'm not sure if Mr. Moberly looked into the locations or not, but there are probably locations that you could put it because of that zero side yard setback. It could be, you know, close to a property line if it was to be considered similar to an antenna. I just thought of a public safety issue. How tall is this base shaft before you get to the turbine part? Twelve feet. Twelve feet.

1:15:05 Okay, so there's no way anybody can get at it to vandalize it. Unless they buy a little bit of snow around it and start climbing up into it. There actually are potential dangers to it. Yeah. Yeah. Nice thing to vandalize it, get a cut and sue, you know, that sort of thing. There are actually pole extensions that will take this up to 50 feet, but I don't want to go there yet. Yeah. That opens up a hole. I understand. I'm just trying to get the door open. And, you know, we've been dancing around all morning. Okay.

1:15:34 Don't go there. I think the door is open for you to do your analysis and to continue this. I don't think that there's any, you're hearing any objection that will come forward in the update of the general plan. The zoning code. The zoning code, I'm sorry. You don't have to wait there. Excuse me, zoning code.

1:15:56 And to make it successful, you need the public to buy into it, too. So a test pilot would be good. That's the best way to do it. But, you know, we need to go through a process, and that's not what this agenda bill is today. The turban is worth a thousand words. I'm getting there. Well, could he come back with a simple use permit for one at the fire station? Only if we find that it's, we'd have to say that it's the same. I mean, we'd have to approve this today.

1:16:27 For that to happen. That's considerable expense, too. Yeah. Is it possible to require today at this stage that the shaft that can be painted be painted a color other than light gray? Yes. You know, I read there was one word I took out in the background where it says I took out low contrast. No, I said low contrast color.

1:16:58 Instead of dark color, because there might be another color that provides the contrast there. Depending on the site. Because that one just struck me as, you know, it might actually be a lighter color if it does have low contrast on there. And that allows, because I saw in the pictures, the one next to the Capitol building was white. It looked like a flagpole. You never saw the blades around it.

1:17:24 And that's, so that showed that it had a variety of uses there. So the shaft looks like a flagpole or whatever. That blends in, it's the blades that don't, that are supposed to visually disappear. There, so I would be looking at that because that would be a discretionary that comes along. The design review would be saying in this particular application you might not be doing this color. Which I think you'd probably want to do anyway to.

1:17:52 Sell the concept. You know? That it's not unattractive. I think that when people see this thing working, and they're absolutely fascinating to watch because they're absolutely quiet. And even in the lightest winds, they're spinning. And they're fun. It will attract its own attention. As far as the colors, I would suggest that the fire station, we would probably paint the shaft the same color as the station building. I was just thinking that one. And leave the fins themselves in raw aluminum, which they'll perform best in.

1:18:21 And at that point, let's see what's lost. Literally, yeah. Okay. And I personally haven't, I don't have an issue of trying to hide these. I want everyone to know that this community is, you know, coming up, is on this, for this cutting-edge technology because they definitely are a statement of the commitment to renewable energy and wherever it is.

1:18:49 As a community, I want people to know that now, do I want, would I want as my, you know, my neighbor having one as long as it doesn't obstruct my view or, you know, it becomes something along there. Those are the issues that we're going to have to deal with there because, and unfortunately, you don't have much to compare them to around here to say, you know, how that impact is. Two things. I think you'll find a very substantial public support when they see this.

1:19:17 And I also think that you shouldn't be too worried about 2,000 of them rolling into town next week. Nobody's spending money and it's not going to happen. Unfortunately, we're well aware of it. I wasn't trying to make them disappear, but I just thought I didn't want them to look like TV antennas, which I remember so well from my childhood. Think of it as a kinetic sculpture. That should help. A mobile. I could handle you.

1:19:47 Option one, if I strike residential. So that's just where I am. I'm the only one, I think. Oh, okay. So if I could, I want to be very specific and address your comment about public participation. So if you want to have, if one of your concerns is to allow

1:20:10 Public participation and awareness of the issue. I think there's two ways to do it. One is a zoning code amendment which would specifically consider making this a permitted use within whatever specific zones you thought would be appropriate. And another approach would be through this interpretation if you find that it's consistent but that a use permit is required because the use permit versus the administrative review.

1:20:37 So those would be the two mechanisms to allow public participation in the process. So are you then saying it's possible to reword option one to find that the use is similar to and no more detrimental than the existing permitted uses within the

1:21:15 Strike residential, commercial, industrial zones and permit them with a, and require a use permit? Yes. So, Vice Chair Barrett, does that take care of, address your concerns about public involvement? I can't support taking that residential. If we're going to do this, it has to be for our entire town. It has to benefit our residents as well as commercial.

1:22:04 The developers, if you want to call it that. I just, I have an issue that this, that we're doing an interpretation and what we're using to do the interpretation, I can't find factual to make that decision. I'm fully supportive of Windspire's renewable energy and having it within our code and allowing it to go forward. I just don't feel that we are making the correct decision. We don't have the correct information.

1:22:30 To say that a windspire is comparable to a satellite dish, I cannot accept that. I can't even a TV antenna that's on top of your house that could be hit, I can't accept that either. I believe we should have them, and I think that we should go forward, but I think that this agenda bill does not address the way that it should happen. And to take residential out, you're knocking out everyone.

1:22:55 In residential use that could actually attempt to have one to save money on their energy bill. And where it should be is in residential, just like solar is used in residential. So just to cut residential out to make something happen, I just don't think it's appropriate. I know we're grasping at straws to try to make this work, and I appreciate that. I'm sensitive to it. I want to see it, but I think that something can come back from staff that gives us the ability to approve this in a timely manner.

1:23:21 Where we're not giving an interpretation with the satellite dish. I guess I view it as a interim step. And I believe that the zoning code update will and should include residential and all other forms. So I see it more as an interim step. I don't know if that is helpful to you or not. My ultimate goal is to be able to provide these for any zone in town.

1:23:51 Sure, and we would support that. Ultimately, I think that's going to happen through what process, it's not for me to say, but I kept the scope in this particular product specifically because it, from my point of view, does fall within the range of current zoning, and I don't see why it needs all this extra review.

1:24:18 If that's what the Commission's decision is, then we'll have to go that route. My goal is to get them in here and bring as many as possible as soon as possible. That's my goal. I don't think it would give you another option. I think it would be appropriate for you to refer this to your zoning code committee and perhaps you can talk in that update group about the information you would need to

1:24:56 Make a different kind of decision. And so you could either go that group or you could have it with the regional committee that discuss this. And so what I'm hearing from the Planning Commission is that you're interested and you're supportive and you certainly want to see some greater public participation. And you're not comfortable saying it's like a satellite dish. And so it's not a clear and simple...

1:25:27 determination of consistency for you. The comparison isn't holding up. I agree. I'm not comfortable seeing it's like a satellite dish, but I am comfortable in seeing it's like other types of antenna that also fit within that same category, like a ham radio antenna, for example. Does our coat permit like a 30-foot ham radio tower to be placed on?

1:25:55 Residential or commercial problem? That's what this section is. It's salad, dishes, and antennas. So it does allow the 30 foot. They just have to meet the setback requirements. So you can refer it back to one of your committees and do a little more work to come back more quickly to the Planning Commission. Or you can take the zoning code update approach, which, you know, if it was filed as a zoning code update,

1:26:30 Take it on immediately. So, you know, either way, we'd have to staff it. So it'd be a little less timely in the referral to the committee. Those would be two options in addition to those presented. So you're saying the output went to the committee that it could come back to this body for an amendment in a timely manner? You know, in a way, it's six one way and a half dozen another because if the applicant files for a zoning code amendment, we're going to process that.

1:27:02 If we did option one with the amendments or the wording change and zoning code update, wouldn't they address that or couldn't they at the time if this turns out not to be as we hoped it would be? If you did option one and modified the areas, then you have a use permit, an administrative use permit that we'd probably place conditions on, thinking that it...

1:27:33 We'll be testing out as we go. And then the zoning code update process would be separated in such a way. But it could amend whatever, if we find we don't like something that we've done? It could establish new different standards, but it wouldn't establish retroactive standards. No, no, it would not come back to this one, but when we have looked at this as an example and there are changes that we decide need to be made, then we could do it with the update.

1:28:06 I want to see it happen, but this is just a weird decision to have to make. I mean, the way it's worded, I just... Can we have staff reword us and listen to the comments we've made and bring this back to our next meeting? Yes. Listening to our comments and bring us back something that can work for us for a demonstration project, to get it going, still involving the code update, addressing what each commissioner has stated?

1:28:41 And with some options that give us the ability to do it? Yes. That's actually a better word than temporary. Why not demonstration project? That's, you know, because it will be there, I'm sure, permanently, but it would be a demonstration project. There would be lots of measurements and, you know, all the things you're planning and doing. If we did a demonstration project in the wording of the agenda bill, it would strictly address that. It wouldn't be an interpretation.

1:29:10 We could then limit it to whatever Mr. Moberly is doing. It would be up to him to do that demo project, furnish us. It would be a help to us for defining our zoning code update because you would have the materials to give us to show it. And thus it goes across all barriers and we get it done without having it blanketed across the zone. I support that. We can certainly do that. And it could come back.

1:29:41 to our next meeting so we're not delaying him any longer. I think we would request from Mr. Moeller some plans and information on the specific project to bring back so that you could look at the specific installation and determine that that proposal is no more detrimental then and similar to. And it would just be specific to that proposal as a demo project.

1:30:02 Perhaps we could have Jay and Elizabeth as the design review committee work with Mr. Moeller in bringing that back to us at our next meeting also. Sure. We could do that. So it would just depend on Mr. Moeller's timing on submitting that information. Is that something you could work with, Pete? Yes, yeah. I'm enthused to continue and pursue this. My question would be, what does success look like to me? What are my parameters? Where is my goalpost? Is this a performance curve in electricity that you're chasing, or is this some sort of public acceptance of a visual?

1:30:31 I have, personally, is that what you're asking me, I have no issue with aesthetics with these at all. I want to see them happen. Again, it's a public issue. There's no members of the public to speak for or against to have their issues. I want to see that or give them more opportunity to be here for it, and interpretation doesn't allow that. I also want you to be successful, and a demonstration project will allow that. If we put it into general commercial,

1:30:58 There are companies that I know in Reno and down in Ridgecrest. I happen to know a woman that's the representative down there that when I spoke to her about this, she wanted to come up today to say that she wanted to put one in. So that opens a door and it could be a floodgate. I don't want to see that because I want to see it be successful. I want the public to support it. And basically you are going to have the opportunity to show the public how it works by a demo project. So for me, you're looking at a goalpost for two weeks from now at our next meeting.

1:31:27 To bring it back, and you would have approval, and you would go to the administrative use permit stage. Okay, but I'm still confused. I don't know what success looks like. I have no clue what I'm chasing now. Well, your success is going to be your implementation of this product and showing the public how they work on aesthetics that are concerns of people, the sound issue, the wildlife issue. Can it really work? Is it sustainable with the winds that we have on an average daily basis?

1:31:57 You have that ability to be the rock star here and show these can work in the town of Mammoth Lakes. I want to see it in residential because I think it could be huge savings for our residential. I think that's my market. Exactly. That is your market. So, I mean, to me, you're going to do a demo project as you've stated you would do. It's going to be up to you in two weeks to come back once that's approved, which I don't think it would not be approved at that point.

1:32:23 You'll be able to get your use permit and you're on the road going and getting it done. Where do I go to start pulling permits? You'll go back to the town staff with application for a use permit that's administrative. That's what we're talking about. When do we reach that point? In two weeks from now when it comes back to us for us to say this is the demo project we want to approve. Okay, so you want me to bring a specific project to you? That's what we're talking about, correct.

1:32:50 I think I heard you say administrative, and I don't think you meant that. Actually, I think that's what they said. It would be a use permit. It would be a administrative use permit. Right. This is what I think you all have said. You've all expressed some various issues and some concerns, and you're not quite ready to take action and make a decision today, so you'd like the applicant to work with staff and also the design committee, and we'll review the notes, which will speak to.

1:33:18 Design and whatever your other notes were. And with Mr. Moberly's conceptual project, we'll be able to address those specifically in that application and then make the determination of whether it's an administrative permit and that the Planning Commission has the comfort that your issues and design criteria and safety and operational criteria have been met through that interpretation. And so staff, applicant.

1:33:47 And committee will report back to you at either your next meeting or whichever meeting we work to come back to you in at. And then I think from the, and that will allow staff to look at the specific site as well. And I don't recall exactly if that's a public, quasi-public site because it's the fire station. So turning this into a demonstration project will allow you to make more

1:34:17 informed zoning code decisions later. And so I think what we're trying to do is take your issues, refine them, be able to address them with your specific project proposal, and then determine then whether it's an administrative permit or use permit or what the final action is. You know, and Pete, for myself, I'd love to see you put one in residential also. I mean, I'd like to see you not limited to just one, maybe up to three, to show the various areas of town. We live in a very...

1:34:46 Different kind of situation in our town with the ridges around us and how the wind generation is. And, you know, it's your expense, so I don't want to make you spend money and tell you to do three. But I have no problem if you chose to do that, of doing it, because residential is going to be your market. And, you know, you look down in the trails, you look at over an old mammoth and up in the knolls. It could be very, very just incredible for this town to do something of what you want to do.

1:35:14 I want you to be successful. I'm six months into the effort right now, so it's not lost on me. I think it will certainly be useful for the public and useful for us as well if you can do a photographic simulation. I assume you were going to do that as part of your presentation, showing the firehouse and, you know. I was going to pour some concrete and put up a turbine. Yeah, but there seems to be this little bump in the road here that we've got to get past.

1:35:41 And I have no problem with you even, I know the other commissioners, I mean, 30 foot, I think that's very, you know, honorable of you trying to go by our heights, but you may find by analysis that it needs to be 45 foot or 55 foot. So I think you really need to look at that so that we have that information because you want it to be successful and the best possible outcome, and if it is higher than 30 feet.

1:36:05 Then you've established that and you have the scientific data to back it up. So it gives us the ability to say, yes, we should do this because these are the benefits. I'm not arguing with you. I'm just trying to give you more information of this. I understand all the science. I'm not arguing with you. I just think it's a great idea for what you're doing. So let's just do the best thing we can do with it. I'm trying to keep it a simple installation that conforms and move forward quickly. That's my goal.

1:36:34 Well, I actually think that we have consensus on that. I think with staff's help that we'll get this to the next level and get the community involved at the appropriate level and let them know that we're pursuing these things. And I think that's very important for them to know, that we are moving on renewable energy and this is one of the first steps.

1:36:58 Don't have any, we don't have anything to compare it to in this, so this is groundbreaking for us and we appreciate your patience. Let's break it together. There you go. And I would be fine if staff felt that they could get this done in a time before our next meeting to request a special meeting. I don't know how the other commissioners feel, but I would have no issue with having this as a one-item agenda to allow Pete to get forward on it. I think it's technically three weeks before our next meeting.

1:37:29 At that point, and should you be able to move along at that speed that you can pull everything together, I think that's fine, but I think three weeks is going to, we should be able to have it available for the next meeting. We'll do our best. That's great. I would suggest I'll work with staff and we'll return as soon as we can. Absolutely. And we actually meet on the 7th at 5, and so if he had something ready, we could meet that day at 4.

1:37:55 If that were... If you could have something ready by next Wednesday, you... I think we'll have meeting conflicts on the 7th. Okay. Okay. Well, let me ask you this. Legally, would the committee be able to, like our sign committee does, to make that determination, means it's a pilot project? Not an interpretation. But you're still going to do an interpretation. You have to do an interpretation, even though it's a...

1:38:17 Even though it's a pilot project? You would have to make an interpretation that that pilot project is similar to no more Dutch riding band. Find something comparable. Correct. That's what may take three weeks to find that. So it's an ambitious schedule. It sounds like a long time, but it's not. But I appreciate that. So Mark, do you want to recap? What we have consensus from you is Planning Commission is continuing this item to the next meeting or sooner.

1:38:44 And you're referring it to staff to work out temporary installation details with the applicant and to meet and confer with the design committee? Yes. And Pete, I would be more than happy, I'm still a hearing board officer with Gray Faison, and I'd be more than happy to assist you in getting all the documentation on the wind speeds. I know that Ted would not have an issue.

1:39:07 Yeah, I've seen them from areas in the Owens Valley and others, but in looking for them around here, I didn't find them. Yes, I'd be very happy. I've lived here for 30 years. There's a lot of wind here. Yeah. As we can attest right now, outside. Wish we had one right now. Also, Dan Dawson, the snarl, has all of the 20-year reports. You've all spent a lot of time, and we're going to spend more. Thank you so much. Thank you. Thank you. Okay, now that I've...

1:39:35 This placed my agenda. Thank you. That's the wind. We've been watching the wind outside. The thing is with that. The irony is not lost on us. It's consistency, though. You have to have consistency. That's it. Okay.

1:40:11 So the next item is item number four, which is preparation for the joint town council study session. That will be held at 5 p.m. on April 7th. And Mark, you have met with staff and I think got some directive of what we're looking for in this particular meeting. And this is an annual meeting that we have, correct? Yes, this is your...

1:40:40 You actually have a couple, like two meetings with council and the council this year is asking commissions to address the bullet point items that we've prepared in your report and for your information we gave you the attached work program so that it reminds you of what we're working on this year and then I just passed out to you just a list of the accomplishments of the planning commission to date.

1:41:10 Broken it down into this fiscal year, your development projects, policy development, public participation and meeting effectiveness. We've also noted on page two the modifications to our approved work program, which I'll mention. When we developed our work program,

1:41:32 We didn't anticipate working on the DIF program, the Capital Facilities Funding Committee, and that has taken an awful lot of time. What we've completed is a review of approximately 15 documents and identified policy linkage or low-level policy linkage back to the DIF program. We've reviewed, I think it's 26 environmental impact reports.

1:41:58 to try to identify what programs would have been implemented through DEF. And we've also prepared a report, it's called a report, the Resort Investment and Public Facilities Report, that speaks to a methodology of how the town can establish more effective priorities within its capital facilities and investment programs. So that's been an extensive amount of time.

1:42:26 We didn't anticipate working on the medical marijuana programs and we're engaged. You've already completed and the council has acted on placing one item on the ballot for June and then Sandra's hard at work on coming forward to you with the development regulations and I believe that's the next planning commission. Whitmore track facility is a public project.

1:42:55 That includes both CEQA analysis and project analysis and then a permitting process that we're handling through the county. It's Department of Water and Power on land leased by the town and it's within the jurisdiction of the county. So that's a challenge and we're supporting public works on that.

1:43:17 Various trails-related programs we're supporting, and then finally we're working on the new website development. Jessica Morris, who our staff is leading that effort. So those are important priorities, and so they've slowed down or delayed some of our other planned work. And then we're still focused on...

1:43:40 Preparing for reinvestment in our next fiscal year. So this is just to tantalize your discussion about what you have done and what you've focused on. And that concludes my report. Yes. Question for you, Mark. So after 12 years from the Tourism Commission up to this day in joint meetings with Council, this is a lot to go through in an hour. Are we going to just pick out a few items? Is Council being furnished this beforehand so they can see all of this?

1:44:11 There's a lot to go through in one hour with them and I would hope that we could have a discussion here about some highlights like Old Mammoth Place should be a huge highlight and I think Elizabeth wants to address that. I think we've provided this to you so that you guys, you the commission, I think what you want to do is focus on what's meaty and timely.

1:44:32 To actually discuss with the council, you know, we can pass out whatever information you want, but I don't think you have to rehash what you've already done. And I think looking forward and focusing on effectiveness is great. But can this be sent to council like now so they see this before, so they kind of have the time to review all this? We'll put it in their agenda packet. Okay. Right. Okay, good. Because, as we discussed, they have like the development of accomplishments.

1:45:00 They have that already. And what you're looking at is just highlighting to reintroduce, you know, in case you've forgotten, this is what we've done. And what we've done in policy development. I think it is important to note the modifications that we have because...

1:45:20 That may not come through that these were, you know, you asked us to do a work program, here's the modifications that we did in addition to that. And they could have affected the work program because I think where we probably want to spend our time is on what is the anticipated work program. And these are the things that we believe are important for preparing for investment.

1:45:48 You all can read that because we shouldn't have to defend any of these issues, I guess. It's done. There it is. This is what you gave us. I think Commissioner Baer's comment about Old Mammoth Place, you know, you've done a lot of new work on that. You know, you're kind of groundbreaking work for the community. Something just came to my mind, though. Council on the 7th also that evening, they're taking up Old Mammoth Place, correct? So we have to be very careful that we're not lobbying them.

1:46:17 On what we're doing, so maybe we should have that discussion. Maybe it's that Elizabeth's presentation. I'm going to speak for you, but maybe there's something that is given to them, the presentation she did, something that, you know, I don't want us to get in a position where we lobby them. You mean the chronology of all the meetings? Or something like that. You know, we don't want to lobby them. That's a real bad area for us to get into. Well, I also would look at this as, you know,

1:46:46 If you want to, you could use that as an example of getting this done. But I don't see that it's specific in the outline that you have here that specifically looks at Old Mammoth Place. It could be you're talking about you're bringing it forward here and we've brought it to you to this next level.

1:47:12 That's the extent of what you have because I'm available for that meeting as well and had planned to be available for any questions that come along with Old Mammoth Place and how we came to our decisions because CBIS is a sensitive policy at this point and how are we really determining if they're getting their money's worth.

1:47:34 At that point, and building heights are sensitive. We have precedents in what we did at that point, but, you know, we're establishing good building practices by measuring, by that determination of the building height, and addressing the placemaking that this particular project will bring forward, that is exactly what's outlined, and Dr. said so.

1:48:01 I think that we address this as a body of work. And yes, there are certain things they have questions for us, that's great, but looking for preparing, you know, preparing for reinvestment is where we want to be focusing our time. Can I jump in? Oh, go ahead. I'll be real fast. I have a completely different take on this. Could we also add into this, I don't know how the commission feels, but, you know, I feel that the letter that we received from Mammoth Community Water District on Old Mammoth Place and the fact that we included

1:48:30 Their recommendations. I think that something needs to be said there about that because it really set a precedence for all future development for us. And I think we need to make council aware of that somewhere in here. I think that would be under what you've got as policy development. Okay, so if we can add that in with Mammoth Community Water District, I'd like to see that. And because that is not just pertaining to Old Mammoth Place. No, it's for all future developments. And that way it brings it out forward is that those are the standards.

1:49:00 And the issues that are coming up of their infrastructure for increased, you know, for all development. Elizabeth Yedda. This is completely different from what I thought we were doing in our joint session. You mentioned something at our last meeting, Mark, and I've been in transit a lot the last 10 days, so I've been thinking about it a lot, that we would be talking about what we were really happy with the outcomes and things that just had really worked well and why they worked well.

1:49:30 Okay. Okay. Okay.

1:49:57 It's easy to describe what you've done. It's listed and you don't need to read the list. That's what this is. Unless you wanted to read the list, you could. And so I think your themes, the water district input and our working with them in the urban water management plan, that's a significant change to how we've done business before. And I think that's worth knowing. And I think what's worked well and what hasn't worked well, that's a significant discussion with the council.

1:50:27 to the Council policies. And, you know, they act on them, and then you implement the Council policies. And so your discussions about how you are, you know, conducting your work, the analysis you used, I think the height analysis that you've used in Old Mammoth Place and in Mammoth Crossings is a significant improvement. You're much more methodical now than we were. You've got your...

1:50:55 And I'm not speaking to the outcome, I'm talking about the method of analysis and your scrutiny of these projects is quite significant. You're comparable to any west side Los Angeles community than you were not before. So that's a pretty high level of significance. So how you make sure that you're working with the council, those are all great discussions. So you guys should talk about that. You know, and also you have...

1:51:25 Speaking of the future in that, there are three seats up on council, so this will be the last meeting with the current council, and maybe that's something more appropriate for the next meeting with the next council coming in, and then you have Chair Dugan and I are actually, I think our terms are up on commission this time, so maybe it's something that you want to add into the next meeting of the first quarter coming up with your new council, because they may have an entirely different direction that...

1:51:53 They're looking, I mean, I'm just putting it out. Well, this has been put off for many months, this joint session. So, I mean, this is a council with three seats leaving, so maybe just doing as Rhonda said and going through, you know, this part and sharing, I don't know how you feel about that, but, you know, talking about the accomplishments, but you've been pinpointing Old Mammoth Place and the fact of those very differing issues that we took care of and how we took care of them is important. Well, I...

1:52:19 I'm looking at that as, yes, Old Mammoth Place is the one we just did, so it's fresh in our mind. You could apply those very same things to the process we used for Snow Creek. Oh, exactly. So I think that... Yeah, I'm sorry, I didn't mean just... Yeah, well, and because I think there's a level of concern that because we just finished this project, we all are very close to whatever your decisions were, and now they haven't even decided it, and it could all come back to us. But...

1:52:49 Those were processes that we adopted with Snow Creek. And because we went through that process, we were able to apply what we learned to the Old Mammoth Place project, and we planned to apply them again to the Main Street Development Project. And I would assume that you would apply that to Mammoth Crossings as well. So in that context, I think it's appropriate to talk about it.

1:53:18 I'm more than happy to give them the big, impressive, long list. You know, the longer, the better, so we don't read it. But, you know, at that point of what we've done, because you all have seen what we've done, and there were, we could point out some modifications that are significant if they change the directive, because they're going to be sensitive to what they told us to do.

1:53:41 And have you accomplished that or have you not accomplished it? And do you feel that those were valid? Should we have done something else to that point of what works and what doesn't work? But to where also these, I think it's important to tell them that this is what we think is important through what the community is telling us and these issues that have arisen. We know that we have to address this. This is where we think we're going to be spending our time.

1:54:10 An appointed body of the committee, this is the heavy lifting we see that's going to help you make your decisions. Are you on board with this? Are we on the right track? Which is what we're really trying to determine because if our priorities have nothing to do with their priorities, whose time is being wasted? Everybody's time is being wasted then. Well, we have to also be sensitive that we have minority opinions on some things too that need to be out there so we can't just...

1:54:39 Speak in general terms of something. I can't be there on the 7th. My husband's having surgery, so I can't be there. But I really would like to say something. Should I write, you know, a couple paragraphs about what worked and why it worked or even not being specific with specific projects and then what I still have concerns about? That's what I was suggesting for you to do is to write your...

1:55:06 Right, right, something, sorry, yeah, but I didn't understand that was with respect to this, because that's what I thought we were talking about this session, because I can just see the session not being productive. My opinion would be that it's most useful for you to talk as a commission, as a body, and so one, and you know, I can certainly look at the schedule and see if we can move the Planning Commission Joint Council to another evening.

1:55:37 So that you all can be there. So that's one option. And I think what you should do, if you have things that you're concerned with that didn't work well, you guys should be talking about those. About it right now. Yeah, get into it.

1:55:54 And then maybe that would summarize what your concerns are, Elizabeth, and we'll put it maybe on paper or at least get it addressed. Whatever we do, we'll write a report. You just mentioned, though, that possibly we could still move this to maybe the following meeting. Is that something we should discuss first right now to make sure that Elizabeth could be part of that? I mean, I have no issue with that. That's not his call. I didn't look into it.

1:56:19 We do have flexibility. I just can't promise that. I take advantage of the moment now and have your decision. No, but I'm saying for the meeting, though, it's really up to... Rhonda, as the chair, runs that meeting for the council. It's not the council running us, so...

1:56:35 You know, if we had an opportunity to change it to the next two weeks for Elizabeth to be there. I don't actually think that's the way it works. I think Neil's in charge of the meeting. Yeah, this is our session there. Their calendar will need to be open to the next available time for their calendar. So maybe instead of a speculating, Mark, at this point, you tell us what our options are with that.

1:57:01 But I do, in the next hour, I would like to take some time in anticipation of what, you know, of what we want to talk about at that meeting, because I agree, Elizabeth, this needs to be productive. I don't feel that they have been as productive, and we need to be in control of this. But also is, we want to be very specific on what worked, what didn't work to be constructive and lead them into...

1:57:29 Where we believe these things should go instead of it degenerating into I have one thing on this list that I have an issue with, that somebody has a personal issue, that's why things should be general and that your work can apply to a lot more than one project anytime that you can point that out, it's much more beneficial. Instead of getting...

1:57:54 You know, narrow in your focus and that we've had to spend a lot of time on an issue that we shouldn't have had to. Here's where the work with the general plan or implying that is coming along. So if you do have things that you believe the work is doing, this is the time to talk about it. And if you want, you know. Right now in our meeting. This is the time to talk about it. Oh, okay, okay. And to where if you are not able, if it turns out to be the 7th and you are not here.

1:58:22 Fine, if you'd like to write them up, if they're, you know, if we have consensus on those issues and things like that. Well, I didn't even write it up for the commission, I just, in my opinion, like I was there, you know. Okay, okay. Let's think about, let's think about Snow Creek and Old Mammoth Place, our two big projects. When they first came to us, we didn't like them, staff didn't like them, the public didn't like them in the first iteration, remember? And the reason they were successful was because the process was collaborative.

1:58:51 We worked with the designer, in the case of Snow Creek with Hart Howerton, and then in the case of Old Mammoth Place with BSA, whatever BSA is, Tim Bull something, whatever it stands for, I can't remember, and the applicant, and with this dialogue, back and forth and back and forth, and all those meetings we had that were sort of belittled in a letter to the editor, those had to do with

1:59:17 Policy to implement the general plan to make sure we got this project right. But the reason that the final outcome was so much better than the initial presentation is because, as I've seen over and over, going on nine years doing this job, that the whole is greater than the sum of the parts. I mean, there's a synergy. There really is. Working back and forth.

1:59:37 Rather than having somebody come in from outside and say, this is what I want to do and it fits the rules, therefore I should be able to do it. If we work together, we get a good outcome for the community and a good outcome for the applicant. And really, that's been absolutely proven to be very successful. Do we dare compare it to another project? Oh, of course. The courthouse? Well, that's, yes. Well, that's a very good example because of constraints posed on us from the outside. That's a perfect example, Jay.

2:00:07 It was not a collaborative process. We did everything we could to make it a collaborative process. But there was no collaboration because of the requirements of the state and the way that it had been set up to have that outcome no matter what we said. And that was fully unfortunate. Then the thing that's not working so well is the public process. And golly, I don't know what more we can do. We changed the date of our meetings. Time. That time, excuse me, not the date. The time of our meetings.

2:00:34 We have put all this stuff on the web. Our meetings are now being streamed as well as being broadcast on Channel 51. We announced specifically with the last project a more convenient time for public comment. We've added times for public comment. Even with streaming on the web, I was really distressed to get back in town and read this letter and last week's sheet with all these errors in it because the entire meeting wasn't viewed.

2:01:02 They didn't see the whole thing. I mean, what more can we do? I'm very, very frustrated with the public process. This letter politicizes what we did. It's untrue. I'm really distressed about it. And one thing I want to talk about during director's report, which I'll just give you a preview, is is it worth our time to respond to it? That's what I want to talk about in director's report. But that's what's not working.

2:01:28 So, are you, so are you fine with Rhonda, I mean, this is Rhonda's meeting, and with all due respect, it's not meals, it is the Planning Commission's, and all my years there, the Planning Commission Chair, or the Tourism Rec Chair ran the meeting. Okay. So are we, I mean, I am fine with Rhonda moving forward on Dr. Seds and what she's doing. I want you all to be there.

2:01:48 No, we're there, but I'm just saying that it's the... And none out there. Yeah, go ahead. No, but the chair is always... You know when you were on Tourism Commission, Rhonda, it was the same thing. In fact, I remember I had to run one once. Yeah, you had to run one once. It's just the way when I was on council, we gave the floor to the commissions and it was their meetings. So, I mean, I am comfortable with Rhonda as the chair, you know, running this and bringing up the issues that we've all discussed myself.

2:02:14 You know, in our accomplishments and how we're looking forward and keeping it concise and not letting it churn and getting across what, you know, we need to get across. Well, I think that if you look at, if we've got these development projects and since those are things that happened, it can be a great note of what worked and what didn't.

2:02:42 At the conclusion of that. And I think your point of, you know, collaboration brings all to consensus. That it is, that's it in those examples right there of Snow Creek Gate, you know, Old Mammoth Place, and what you get from that being a better outcome for the projects, the synergy. And, you know, community acceptance of

2:03:05 Things that change, can they live with the change, and knowing where they can't. And those projects changed dramatically from what it was because everyone was involved.

2:03:19 We've addressed that, so I think that's where that would live at the end of the presentation of the projects. Now, whether that be the handout, you know, is that, here it is, if it's in advance, and, you know, what we would like to say is this is a long list, and we'd like to reiterate our experiences through that, what works and what didn't there. And then when you look at

2:03:44 Oh, that's true, that's true.

2:04:15 I kind of look at it differently. The only way I can possibly interpret this is that we have a certain number of people that are coming out and being vocal. And we appreciate when they're here that we actually get to address those. And when you write a letter, it's a level of protection that you didn't want to come here and speak it. But I am surprised at the number of people that are watching this.

2:04:44 And if they're not here telling me that we're doing the wrong thing, then we are doing the right thing. That's a good point. I have no other way to look at this because there are people telling us when we're doing the wrong thing, but they certainly know, you know, when I'm wearing the wrong color because I hear that too and things as well. So it means that we're not just talking to ourselves.

2:05:12 And we assume that there's nobody here that we are. That is not true. We would never talk to more people. No, I didn't think that. So that's part of what's changing. And we need to recognize that this is a very public process now. And we're reaching more people than we ever have before. And because they're not here...

2:05:32 You know, expressing their feelings in a very high tone of voice is not to say that they may be sitting at home waving their fists at us, but that this process is moving along because that's what's working because you're getting these much more collaborative efforts. So I have no other choice to look at than this way. You know, I might add in that I watched the council meeting after our last Planning Commission meeting, streaming it.

2:06:01 Much better reception sound than I've ever seen on the TV channel of the meetings. So I'm very impressed with the streaming that's going on and the ability to respond by comment. So I think that's great. That's just kind of a little caveat there. I'd also like to know if we could add in somehow it's been difficult for us over these past years since we've updated our general plan.

2:06:27 And our decision making because our ordinance are not in compliance with the general plan. I know. And the council took that as not being a priority. And I think, I don't want to say scold them or slap their hands, but we need to make them aware that. You mean the code, this size? The code, I'm sorry, I keep saying that to you. I think we want to emphasize that the fact that we haven't been able to, they haven't made the updating of the code a priority has somewhat tied our hands in many ways. And I don't know how you want to phrase that. Well, I actually think.

2:06:56 I may not get to. Somebody else may. But actually, what that is, that's very important that if this is, if it's turning out to be that our hands are tied and we cannot complete their work program that they've given us because of these issues, that can be one of the things that we express is, you know, what we have learned is that

2:07:19 They may not have seemed like a priority at a time, but now we have taken care of all those issues and is moving them up the priority ladder as natural as you complete a work program there. So we are finding that that is becoming more and more of a priority if we're to complete the work program that you've given us. Well, an example I'll give you is the measurement from the podium. If that had already been completed in our zoning code update, it would not have been.

2:07:48 An issue for us because it would have been in the code. We're using outdated code. And so we're using, thank you, yeah, outdated code and then we're having to make interpretations and amendments that cause the community, they say, what's going on? And they have a right to say that. So I think we just need to really emphasize to the council that that's very important and they need to really consider bringing that up, you know, in our work program. Fortunately, it's here.

2:08:14 Yeah, it is. It's number two. But we need to emphasize it is my point, Sharon. This is two pages of things that in one hour you'll never get through every hour. Well, and as these, we're not going line by line, I think that if this is amenable to the commission, I'll work with staff on trying to develop these accomplishments. They're the top ones, the top eight.

2:08:41 with the other eight subcategories in here, but just that we have, we've accomplished these things and there's more, I think they've got the more detailed list, don't they, of the plan, the, they have the, they've actually looked at the annual plan, this recaps the highlights of the annual plan, so that's where we're talking about, we're not covering this, and, you know, other than,

2:09:10 You can read it, but we're not discussing it because they have the annual plan. I think that that's important. I don't see that there's any need for discussion, especially on things that we've reviewed, the height and mass of the Old Mammoth Project. They're going to be talking about that tonight. So we just list them here as Old Mammoth Place. It's coming before you tonight. Could we do something where if Rhonda sends it to you, staff, that you're able to...

2:09:37 Copy us on it and then we won't hit reply all if we have any questions on it. In other words, Rhonda's saying she's going to put together something with you for the discussion so if we could get that sent to us so we see what it is before the meeting and we just have to make sure we don't hit reply all if we have any comments. I just thought we were going to be talking about

2:10:02 I think we are. I just don't see any need to get into any of the rest of it very, I mean, they can read. That's what I thought we are. That's what we're saying. And that we, you know, we have the list of development projects that you've seen here and some observation, the only thing we might put in is based on their observations of what works and what doesn't work, but it seems to me that your statement about excessive...

2:10:32 There is no such thing as excessive public comment. And working together in a collaborative, I think that wraps up the whole thing. Where do we go with excessive public comment? Maybe there's not a lot of folks out here giving us public comment. Oh, I see what they're talking about. Excessive meetings. To your point in the letter that 55 meetings is a waste. Any time that you have the opportunity for the public to come and speak.

2:11:01 You know, that, and to, this is collaborative, and that is actually, that's a great wrap up to all of this. I think I was thinking about the public comment, and it just, this is wanting an ideal world, how to make it more informed. You know, wish the public could be as informed as we are, because we have these packets and we, you know, trudge through them. I think the point there is that we're never going to reach that point, but we need to keep trying to reach that point. You never stop, you're never going to make everyone happy, and someone always has the ability.

2:11:30 When we talk about it later here, to write a letter that may not be factual, but it's their perception. It's what they believe to be factual. So you just have to deal with it. And we will, and now that technology has been given many more opportunities to read or to discuss and to get into detail of this than they had before.

2:11:51 It will never be enough for everyone, but it's out there and it is available. Okay. Well, if you're going to be rearranging this a little bit, Rhonda, with staff, could you add considered to 1, 2, 3, and 8 on Part B? No, 1, 2, 3, and 10 considered and provided input. I think provided input is... Wait, wait, wait. Where are you? On Part 3. 1B, 1, 2, 3, and number 10.

2:12:21 We considered those and then provided input at the end. So we considered whatever the item is and then we provided input at the end because we did a lot more than I think that would be good. I think to your point, everything else says reviewed, blah, blah, blah. Yeah, reviewed and recommended. Exactly. And that isn't just to add words, it's to show that we really did think about it. Okay. Should we provide?

2:12:48 Far input on what we think the priority, the order of the priority should be for the anticipated work program? Sure. Absolutely. Why not? Because, you know, this is not any specific. Go ahead. When you do that, you know, the zoning code is huge, and you've already had some conversations. There's a reason you want to do the sign code first. And so if you want to add character and flavor to some of those items about, you know, why it's important and what is important about it, that'd be a useful conversation.

2:13:17 So, i.e., the sign code update is to enhance our business environment, to revitalize it, to bring folks to town, and to encourage them to shop, things like that that we need to say. Make the community more attractive and memorable. And economic sustainability. To improve our economy. And along the same thing with renewable energy and adding that into the program. So, at these meetings, we've done it a variety of ways that we've split up.

2:13:47 You know, among commissioners, we've all taken a certain topic to either discuss or a couple of areas to where you feel that those are your areas. We've had it to where there's one level of presentation. We've had it to where council, you know, fires questions immediately and we never get to our program. So, you know, I think that we'd like to find some happy medium between all of this and to set up a format to where

2:14:16 I particularly like a format to where everyone gets to, and especially when we're talking about our anticipated work program, to where everyone gets a couple of topics to do exactly what you just did. And no more, you know, doesn't need any more detail than that, but pick them and I take them and, but, you know, I kick it off and I bring it home. And as far as

2:14:44 Pulling it all together because this is definitely a joint effort. It is not me getting up and lecturing to them what we've done, see what we've done. It is how we've learned and have achieved the results we have that we don't even talk about there. So I'd love to divide this up and have people

2:15:08 You know, address and give a few sentences about this in the context of where we believe these are the important priorities to improving investments, if you're comfortable with that, if we have consensus of that. I think that's a good idea. Can I make a suggestion? Certainly. So where it says complete, you know, like 1, 2, 3, 6, and 7, and 10,

2:15:32 Could we perhaps have the Chair, when she does her opening, address those issues because they have been completed? They're very simple to the point. Well, they're not completed. Like, as our, to prepare for investment, we have to complete the zone and code update. No, that's true. Okay, I take that back. Unless I missed something. No, that's very true. You know, Rhonda, that's exactly the right preposition and the way to do the sentence. To prepare for reinvestment, comma, we have to. To, yeah.

2:16:02 Yeah, we must. We must. Absolutely, that's exactly the way to express it. And if maybe Jay and I, you know, we've worked on the housing element, we're working on the zoning code. I would expect you to want to take those and, you know, and if you'd like to address them together because I think that shows, it shows that this is not one person's particular.

2:16:27 Agenda, this is the subcommittees pulled together and this is how we've worked on those things. That works for me. The district planning and zoning code are hand in hand. Well, that's what I was saying about, you know, they just go right together. Yeah, they go right together. I mean, if you have no issues, I wouldn't mind doing the marijuana development update. So if we do reschedule, maybe what you want to do, maybe Elizabeth does the district planning just because she happens beyond the mainstream program.

2:16:56 Oh, I could talk about that for an hour. No, you're not going to get an hour. You're going to get seven minutes. Yes. But the chair will decide how many minutes you get. To bring me a bell. I think, actually, we should strike six because we hope to be done with medical. Yeah, because I was thinking, as I said that, there's not much. I mean, we have the ordinance. Sandra, we sent it to Sandra. She's been re-going over it. Well, it shows up in number two.

2:17:20 Yeah, these are modifications of things that we couldn't complete because we're doing those instead. And I looked at number two as those had to get done. Yeah, right. And we're hopeful that Snow Creek Development Agreement's done as well. In this heading of looking forward to the next facility here. So we're striking number six. Six to number four. And four. And the list gets shorter.

2:17:44 So are we going to do, I'm sorry, just a process point here, we're going to come up with two different plans in case Elizabeth, in case the meeting has changed and she participates so that if it is done on the 7th. Do I have to, I mean, can't the four of you do it? Well, of course. It would be better if you could be there. I mean, no, it won't, I don't really have to be there.

2:18:05 Okay. I'm sorry, I can't be, I've got a good excuse. Yeah. It's okay. Okay. Don't worry about it. But I hate to, I'm sorry, you know, we plan things around second and fourth Wednesdays and then bingo, there's a, you know. That's why we're doing this now. Okay. Because we only have an hour. I'm sorry, I was just trying to accommodate you. Oh, no. No, that's because I've made my comments now and Rhonda's got them down. It's duly noted. Good, that's great. And you will get credit.

2:18:31 So then on the district planning, then with Elizabeth, that would be Rhonda? Uh-huh. Yeah? I can do that. I can talk to you about it on the phone, Rhonda. Sure. It's really been a good process. Probably a couple hours. It's been a great process. Okay. And then Jay and I would use zoning code. And... So CFSC and mobility. Right. CEQAs.

2:19:07 Sharon, is there something that you would like to bring, you know, and this is very general, we're not getting into high level on this because first of all, there's not time and it is, you know, I'm happy to work with you on certain things but, you know, and if you don't want to, that's fine, you know, because some of this is, we may not even get to touch on it. Some of this predates me.

2:19:32 Exactly, exactly, and that's fine, because we may not even get to touch on it in a more specific tone, and maybe not all of this needs to be addressed, you know, because when I'm looking at CEQA for Parks and Recreation Plan, the Trails System, those there, to mention that those are going to have to happen is pretty much, oh, gotta happen, okay, fine, you don't need to tell me.

2:19:58 Well, you know, Sharon, you've had some issues about CEQA and how it's been conducted. Is that something you'd want to address to the council? No, I had another concern, and we're not there yet looking for anything else, but I'm concerned about how we analyze projects, and that obviously was my concern with both Mammoth Crossing and Old Mammoth Place.

2:20:20 That we didn't look at the reduced impact alternative that the, you know, our general plan EIR required. And I wanted to see what council thought about that, that we haven't used that. We've looked only at one more project as opposed to looking long term. And I didn't know if that would be something they were concerned about or not. And I don't know where it, you know, whether we need to put it on the docket or not. But that was an issue I had.

2:20:49 that I thought needed to be discussed. I think technically, you know, to see what your question is, when the town acts and certifies an EIR, you know, we're just, we certify the report and the actions, it was completed to the best abilities and best information that the town and decision makers had, so that points down. And so if your question is about more like alternative

2:21:18 Development Projects, so pick Project X, Mammoth Crossings itself. You might be suggesting that maybe we should look at lower or a different, let's just call it lower height and lower density because that's what everybody's concerned with. So when a project is coming forward, if you're suggesting that we should look at a different alternative for that project, that's useful. I think going back to the CEQA document,

2:21:46 That's so broad and high, it doesn't help you because the CEQA part's done. And so I think the question is, for me, are you asking, should we have a more rigorous evaluation of lower density projects when they come forward?

2:22:03 Actually, I put it down under Promote Resource Conservation, which was part of the work program that we didn't, or maybe we won't do in September 10, by September 10. And that's where I was hoping to look further into the water situation. And it's on page 2 of our handwritten 75. That's really where I had it, Mark. Oh, that's on the other.

2:22:32 And that is, maybe that's when I need to look at that as opposed to putting it on the town council conversation because it's, I think it fits there. Well, why would that not be some part of the anticipated work program? Is that what you're asking? Yes, it is. And, oh, I see what you, because it's... It wasn't on this list. It wasn't on this list. But we'd look to, I, since I...

2:22:58 We have started looking at this list. Wouldn't we look to combine the two and make sure that we have all the issues there? And along the same idea, we had target dates, and they didn't happen, and I wondered if we now have new dates for things like general plan housing, but that is on here. And the North O'Mammoth Road, I was curious about why we're codifying that one, and wouldn't that fall under zoning?

2:23:26 Code, would that be there or not? Which one I'm sorry? The zoning code update. It says we're going to do it in 2009, which we didn't do. So would we be doing that? And a new date? Don't we need a new date for that? Would you just go with the zoning code update? So one of the caveats that we have, and one of the reasons we gave you this sheet, is we're not spending time and detail updating our work program.

2:23:55 Thank you.

2:24:25 and hit some of the things that are actually delayed but we really want to try to complete this next fiscal year. So we didn't try to cover everything, just the highlights. I think Commissioner Duncan started a question about are the ones under Roman numeral 3, are they actually listed in your priorities? And so you might want to have that.

2:24:48 You know, like, if it's really important to get the zoning code updated under you, you think it is, but if it's for you, you know, maybe you want to push that up. Question on number 10. Yes. There is a public art plan that they've adopted, so is this something new, or you're included? No, this is adding a little more detail to the strategy of what they're trying to do. To the existing one? Yes. Okay, so they'll end up, so we have the ordinance, and then they have one that I think is adopted.

2:25:19 I don't think, it might not have actually been formally adopted by the council, but we're using that as a benchmark, and so we're trying to get a little more pointed to it. Well, something I'll offer you that I, if you don't have, I did furnish a copy to the department that was handling public arts about a year ago, and Rhonda and I served on the arts council board some years ago, and we spent about $25,000 for the Moskens report on cultural tourism.

2:25:49 Which was a report that was done for the entire Eastern Sierra Corridor. It's about 190 pages long. And I did furnish it to that department. I do have a copy of it packed away that I can, I think, Peter's shaking his head. I think he remembers that report. But it was done by the Arts Council. We spent the money to do it. So I'd be happy to furnish you guys with that report to use. And it's an extremely good document. Inyo County's been using it as well. That would be helpful. Okay.

2:26:18 And Rhonda, if you want me to, why don't I, I need to do my fair share, why don't I contact mobility people and enhance that little bit there? That'd be great. Okay? Okay. I can do something here. Okay. Thank you, Sharon. So, like a lot, so what you just said on number 10 is actually, it's, we're looking to work with the Public Arts Commission, develop a strategy for implementation.

2:26:45 We just put this on so you can know what we're working on. So, in fact, let me just review. I'll go backwards. So Jessica's got that project. So Jessica is working with Dan Dennis and other internal staff, and they are driving. It's just a schedule, and it's relentless. We're going to have a new website, and it relates to the grant as a program. And so that took at least 5% of her time.

2:27:12 But it's going to be a significant improvement for us. So that's just something internally staff is working on. Sandra's leading the cultural arts plan strategy, and she's held a series of workshops, and they're really moving forward so that their work, we hope, will be more related to the biggest picture of the strategy of the town and work of the planning commission. So that's moving forward. It's going to be a little bit delay, but good progress.

2:27:39 On number nine, CEQA for Trails System Master Plan, we have a grant from Southern Sierra Nevada Conservancy, and it got placed on hold. The money was frozen last year between budget issues, so we have a draft Trails Master Plan. Ellen is leading the CEQA effort, restarting that. The grant has been re-released, and we'll be issuing an RFQ and RFP for consultants to prepare the CEQA document.

2:28:09 Also, in the context, though, of our own budget. So we have to see what a budget looks like and figure out who's doing what. And as a CEQA document, because it's looking at physical locations for trails, for example, we'd expect this to be in the time frame of a regular EIR, which is, you know, 8 to 11 months. And then after that part's done, we reconcile and finally the trails master plan, and it comes through the bodies, including the planning commission, as a master plan.

2:28:37 Similar situation for Parks and Recreation, except that the CEQA is not completely funded, or not substantially funded, because we don't have a grant for that one. And then Mobility Plan, Ellen and Jessica are working together to support Peter in Public Works and Ray on the Mobility Plan itself, and we're working through a grant right now that we received from Caltrans.

2:29:07 That's overlapping the downtown neighborhood district plan and some of our data work that we need to have done to complete the mobility plan. And then one of your items was to support a subsequent grant. And so we hope to continue that process so that we can completely mesh the land use recommendations with the transportation recommendations. Because transportation only supports

2:29:36 activities and uses. So that work's going on, and it will come to you. Some of the detailed work is done by staff and other commissions, and then it certainly relates to the DNDP program. So some of the highlights on this work program for you, and the zoning code, as the time collapses, the burden to Sandra.

2:30:03 It's huge. Yeah, it's huge. And so we're parsing out individual sections to different staff members who are also quite busy. District planning is significant, and that sets up the programming character that leads to the zoning code itself. And then the community capital facilities funding work also relates to our neighborhood district planning. So it kind of sounds to me...

2:30:32 Maybe one through five is what we're really looking at for discussion. If you allotted ten minutes for the opening by the chair to do, and then ten minutes for each item, you're at 60 minutes. That includes questions from council. And really, it should just be one through five that we focus on. Well, and there are only four, really, because you've already eliminated four.

2:30:51 And like what? Snow Creek, yes, so there's really only four. Exactly. How about the mobility? And what you just said in mobility was exactly what you wanted. Say it is, where did I write this down? You're working with these collaborative grants to mesh the land use and mobility in the example of what we just passed today. I have a couple questions. On number 10,

2:31:19 When you do this strategy, can you clarify in that strategy what the role of Planning Commission is and what the role of Public Arts Commission is? There have been some kerfuffles, and I just think it would be really useful. I mean, I know that we have to determine if anything that comes before us is consistent with the general plan. That's our charge by the state of California. If I may, I think Liz was referring to the town sign that is going on 203 that because it's county property, this commission had no jurisdiction over.

2:31:48 So it never came to us. Well, and also the art for Snow Creek 6. So that was another situation. What's Planning Commission jurisdiction? What's Public Art Commission jurisdiction? And I think this goes all the way back to the clampers with the big monument on the corner of Mammoth and 203 that never came through the Planning Commission. It just was erected. Sure, we can clarify that. Yeah, that would be good. And then on number one, I just want to...

2:32:18 Confirm with you, Mark, that all that input that came in from that last workshop on Main Street is going to go back to the focus group before it comes to Planning Commission, right? You were going to synthesize all that stuff and it was going to go back to the focus group, right? I believe I have Jim's nose right here. Okay. Okay, but I just want to be sure it's going back to the focus group first because I think

2:32:48 I wouldn't want to leapfrog over them because they put in a lot of effort and a lot of thought, you know. The focus group is great. Yes, they're wonderful. So our next step on that is to, and we haven't done any work on that since those February meetings because of these other incidents. So we're going to the focus group with what we think is a sketched out synthesis plan. Good. So they'll get the meeting notes from the two-day walk-arounds and from the public meetings.

2:33:17 We're hopeful to get one major concept, and there could be different ideas to it, and then that becomes the document or the subject that gets reported out through the downtown neighborhood district study. And then we'll have to figure out to what extent does the body read the study, because ultimately we'll be coming to the Planning Commission and then on to the town council as a study, and we're very anxious. We'd like to complete that by this chamber.

2:33:47 Good. Okay. I just noticed, Elizabeth, the interesting thing, after all these years, this is one of the first joint annual meetings that we haven't taken to drive around town to look at projects that were built that we had worked on the year previous. That's true. Because nothing's been built. I think I've got a good sense. I think the chair might make notes. Minimal will meet and...

2:34:13 If the hour goes so fast and, you know, as long as we can kick it off and be in control of what we need to express and where we need directive from them and that they're adopting, this is what we're working on, is that amenable to you? Because these are our priorities and keep in mind if you have another priority, it will greatly affect some of these other projects that you've set for priorities to begin with.

2:34:43 So, we're getting down to it. All the easy stuff is getting done, and now it's the tough stuff that we really have to, it doesn't feel easy, but that we really have to hold firm to it. Can you put in, we're going to put an order in so that we'll know when we're coming forward? Yes, it is informal, you know, things, and I don't think we're going to do A-B this time. We'll just...

2:35:06 This is the discussion of where we are. And then Jay and I can just talk about what we'll. Absolutely. And I'll work with Sharon and I'll work with Elizabeth as well. If I could, you know, I just, we don't have any briefing items on Director's Report today. I know you have some questions, but I ask Peter to come to you today through Director's Report and to give you a very brief presentation about the Capital Improvement Program in Public Works.

2:35:32 Because you soon will be asked to review the capital improvement program. And it's, you know, it's a process. This is making a sausage. Oh, it's going to be on the screen. Yeah, do you mind receiving this through director's report? I have to leave at 5 of 5. He will be brief. Flip quick, is that what it says? Very quick.

2:36:06 Mark, when are we going to get the Old Mammoth Place conditions of approval? That we, sometime, okay, just email it? Okay, thanks. You'll email all of us? Yes. Good, yeah, it's hard to follow all that. But we did a lot of revisions. It was a lot of work, yeah. Thanks, Minnie. We're looking at all the broken things that need to be fixed.

2:36:56 So essentially this is how project development process and capital project delivery for town projects. And those are projects that the town has money and may also be projects that are funded by private parties that they've just made a donation to build something similar to what we did with the Welcome Center Plaza.

2:37:29 We essentially got a $70,000 donor that gave the town that money, and then ECA gave us another $20,000, and so that was constructed as a public project using private funds. ECA, what's ECA? ECA is the East Street Sierra. Oh, ECA. Oh, I said ECA. ECA, yeah. So this will go through quickly. Projects are delivered from conception through design, development, and construction.

2:37:58 It also briefly will go through what is it, how the California contracting law works, what defines a public project, and the town purchasing requirements. Town purchasing requirements, this is something that's not a public project, we're going to go buy a loader, a piece of art, or something that's manufactured elsewhere. Things that are over $25,000, basically a bid process.

2:38:33 Where we're advertising and soliciting bids or proposals from a vendor. Purchase is less than $225,000. It's an informal bidding process where we get three quotes typically and then analyze those quotes to see which one meets our needs. And if it's, the specs may be slightly different from each of the vendors so that, you know, it gives us a little bit of leeway on whether or not it's actually loaded or not.

2:39:01 Is that saying, Peter, you have to get a bid from $10 up to $125,000? I mean, a $10 purchase? Where's the floor? Where's the floor? Generally less than $1,000. So if we're buying pencils, we're buying it from a supplier that we've typically used, or we're buying it from access downstairs for convenience. Right, okay. But like $1,000 or over, you've got to get bids. Okay, that's good.

2:39:29 There are exceptions for sole source, but we do have to go to council to get that exception approved. I'd like for, for instance, equipment, a Caterpillar, we're buying it from CAT. We have all of our spare parts from CAT. We don't want to have 10 different vendor spare parts. We go to council, we make that $350,000 purchase as a sole source. And then there's...

2:39:57 Except for consulting services where we're looking for a specific level of expertise. Process, and we'll kind of go through each of these in detail a little bit, but somewhere you have to start from a specialty plan. That might be the master plan, you know, trails master plan, parks master plan, a facilities plan, which is, you know, some of that's developed from the general plan.

2:40:27 Identify the project need through that process. Townsville needs to weigh in on that, and that's our master facility plan. We develop a cost and what the specs might be, how big it is, where it's going to be located, those kinds of things. Funding options, whether or not it's grants available, general funds, another special fund supported by fees.

2:40:52 Times before the Planning Commission and Town Council make findings that's consistent with the General Plan, other comments. If it's not in the Master Facilities Plan, we incorporate it into the Master Facilities Plan. The Master Facilities Plan is also run through the Planning Commission. It's incorporated into the CIP, and that process is where the Planning Commission each year reviews the CIP, makes findings that it's consistent with the General Plan.

2:41:20 Eventually, Council adopts the CIP for the current year. It also looks at out years. Maybe not everything's funded, but it's kind of the things that are in priority that are included within that five-year plan. From there, the project's funded for staff level, so we can go out and hire a consultant, prepare the preliminary engineering and schematic design.

2:41:50 From that, we can start the environmental studies, secure project approvals, which that might be if there's a use permit involved, if there's Caltrans approvals, for instance, if it's in the Caltrans right-of-way. Caltrans approvals might include, if it's funded by Caltrans, but not in there right-of-way, they have some approvals that go along the way. We finish the, and these kind of go in parallel, we finish the design details, specifications.

2:42:21 Require a right-of-way if we need to buy the land or an easement for the facility like a trail. Those all pretty much go in parallel. There are some funding restrictions depending on what type of funding we have. We can't do a final design before we've actually got the right-of-way, those kinds of things for Caltrans funding. And then we prepare and advertise the contract. The council awards the contract. At that time, we also have them approve the plans and specs.

2:42:50 Complete the project and eventually have a ribbon cutting and close out. A ribbon cutting. I'll go through some of those in more detail. Strategic plan are really to develop the objectives, the goals, prioritize the project. So if it's a master plan, hopefully the master plan has looked at some of those and help prioritize that in conjunction with the plan. Develop a schedule so when we think, you know, they might be built, what funding might be available to find and develop the budget.

2:43:21 As you saw before, we're really looking at the budget all the way through every step to make sure that when we think we can build it, we have the money to do it. Project NEED is, like I said, I actually first presented this to the Art Commission. We need to tell how to build a project like this. A sign is determined to be a project, not necessarily an auto sculpture or something, so that one will be a publicly good project.

2:43:50 But review alternatives, look at different locations, if there are different locations, define developed budget, prepare preliminary processing. At that point, we'd incorporate it into the five-year CIP and develop the specifications, so that's kind of the spin section or the black trail, those kinds of things. Incorporate the MFP, define and develop the budget, so we're looking at the budget again.

2:44:20 Some of the places that could incorporate public art in conjunction with a project that maybe is grant-funded through streets or something like that is like we did on Main Street where we have the artwork that's within the sidewalk area. And so the capital project itself can't pay for the artist to actually do the design of the pavers, but it couldn't pay for the installation.

2:44:51 of the hard face escaping of the project. So there's a balance there of how that integration works. Other things that could incorporate are the roundabouts where you've got the center median area that's landscaped. There's certainly available area there for some type of artwork that might not need the close eye view of it. That's something you can see where you drive by or across the street. Obviously, you don't want a lot of pedestrians.

2:45:19 Out on the street looking at the specifics. That's been done very well with large bighorn sheep at the roundabout in Reno. Oh, yeah. Yeah, worked very well. Yeah. Welcome Center to our office, you know, those kinds of fixed police station, bus shelters, is areas that also include artwork, art projects. So next year's project, and like I said, you'll be seeing the CIP next month, probably your second meeting next month.

2:45:50 Meridian Boulevard Reconstruction, we are in line for our money, Stimulus II project, which is Jobs for America, if that comes to fruition, Meridian Boulevard's project is really, plans are like 95% complete, and we will be able to award that project in 90 days, if we got the money. That is one of the requirements of that funding. Currently estimated is $8.2 million. Lower Canyon is 2012-13.

2:46:20 Year is when that one would be constructed currently. Twin Lakes Trailhead Project is a project at Twin Lakes, Lower Twin Lake, where the parking lot is, reconstructing that, and you saw that when we did the Yara update, or no, I guess you haven't seen that yet. So you'll see that at CIP, and I can provide some details of that if you'd like. All these will be coming to us, right? Yeah. Lake Mary Bike Path completion, that's the segment completing.

2:46:48 The bike path in the areas that were not included in our original contractless piece. Sherman Street Bridge, that's a bridge at the end of Sherman Street, and that'll be this summer. I'm designing right now. St. Frost's School is a project in front of the police station, so you saw a piece of that with the police station, you saw a piece of that with the court facility, and the town will be designing that, finishing the design of that, it'll be...

2:47:18 Completed late this summer is our target for that work. Safe Rout to School is a sidewalk project on Tavern and we'll be designing that next year and constructing the following year. Another grant project. The first one is a federal project and the second one is a state funded project. Lakeview Road is where we're going to do the heated street section.

2:47:45 Right now, that one is in design, and our alternative at this point is a ground source heat pump system to heat that section, and not a geothermal well. We're confident we can make that work. And then the Town Shop boiler upgrade is another stimulus project where we're going to replace the existing boiler that gets about 52% efficient with a 95% boiler. Excellent.

2:48:16 I always thought that Lakeview Road thing was called the luge. I didn't know it was voodoo shoot. With the state and the funding, federal projects that we run through Caltrans, essentially this is a schedule of all the activities that have to occur to complete the project. So there's a lot of detail. You don't want to miss a step. A fatal flaw means you give the money back. So that's a two page. A lot of things can be done at the same time.

2:48:46 That turned out so well.

2:49:19 The railing on Lake Mary Bike Path is similar to the railing there. Oh, really? That would be nice. Two-day expansion, which we do for years now. It's primarily our building base, the rock work, and the Lake Mary Conclusion Project for the Andrew Castle have that same type of artwork, or the rock-facing, sculpted rock-facing, incorporated with the head walls. Oh, good. That was another very successful outcome.

2:49:53 Thank you. Thank you. Good. No, that's... So, the airport project. So, is it... Are we at its limit of functionality with the four flights coming in today? One? Okay. At the existing terminal.

2:50:22 to show them another clear journal.

2:50:25 Right.

2:50:25 to show parking.

2:50:30 and

2:50:30 you think of the

2:50:32 DEFA's

2:50:33 which

2:50:34 is actually

2:50:35 that's one of the

2:50:36 Okay.

2:50:38 the airport

2:50:39 access road

2:50:40 which I think was also

2:50:42 was there

2:50:43 is

2:50:43 right now

2:50:45 we're basically done

2:50:46 in the

2:50:46 right away

2:50:48 by the

2:50:49 right away

2:50:51 Department of Health.

2:50:53 and then get us a use permit from the Forest Service. And we're updating the environmental EIR that was done for the airport, which we certified to include state graphs that will be done in the next month. And then on the cow transfer, we'll make sure with our environmental report. So that

2:51:22 Environment Report will actually be burning to the Commission. Is the new report that's been coming out on the sage-grouse going to affect anything? I mean, the analysis shows, we don't think that there's any nesting grounds within the, there wasn't before. Right, right, and I don't think any, that's my concern, I read what was going on with it, that seems to be a concern. Plus, we need to stop hunting licenses also on them.

2:51:53 Thank you. Mark, do you have other items? Do we even get to your director's report yet? I don't have anything else. Okay. Elizabeth, you had an item that you talked about earlier. Well, I'm thinking with respect to this letter that maybe I'll just write a letter myself, you know, sign it myself. I'm not sure I can do that as a planning commissioner. I think it would be useful.

2:52:25 And maybe we can discuss this just briefly. If we can clarify what our job is here, because we're here to represent the community and make sure that every project that comes before us or every request is consistent with our community's general plan. And this particular letter, just one aspect of it, complained for the fifth time, this is the fifth letter about this, about the fact that we didn't require story polls when we've said repeatedly,

2:52:53 We have much better technology now. I've just visited my mother, who still doesn't, at 89, still won't get a microwave, and I just wanted to tell her, it's like, mother, you could have a campfire instead of using the stove, you know, I mean, really, and it just, the thing with the story poles, all the simulations we had were so much more accurate for what this project's going to look like than putting a stick up in the air, and some people you can't persuade of that, but that's something that I would

2:53:22 I would comment on in a letter of reply. Now, I don't know if I can do that as a planning commissioner. Maybe I can't get out there and rebut errors and things. Maybe I shouldn't even do that. What does the commission think and what does staff recommend? There were so many inaccuracies in the letter. Mark, did you have? Yeah, I think that when the planning commission as a body chooses to respond, you can discuss.

2:53:54 This kind of stuff. And it's appropriate to assign a commissioner. Thanks, Peter. Because factually, what you're saying is, in this case, the role of the Planning Commission is to make recommendations or take actions as delegated by the council. And you're doing it to the consistency of general plan, the zoning codes, all of our other standards. And in this particular case,

2:54:19 There is a policy procedure, which is the height and mass evaluation policy that's been considered by council and was delegated to the Planning Commission, and you considered it and you set up an approach. And so you followed the policy, you acted in the context of how you're supposed to act, and you used your discretion and you voted. Not all votes are 5-0, not all votes are 0-5. That's why you sit as a body.

2:54:49 Because you're acting and you're adjudicating on a project. And so much of this does have discretion. You know, it's not black or white. And so you had a ton of information. You used a very extensive public process. There you go. So if you felt it was appropriate to delegate a response to one commissioner, you could, I think, Commissioner Dyken.

2:55:17 Responded last year to some similar kind of comment. Oh, yes, that was good. And you can also, you can respond as an individual yourself. You are a citizen. You haven't given up that right yet. Well, how would I sign it, though? Elizabeth Tenney, Planning Commissioner, or just Elizabeth Tenney? If you respond as a citizen, it would be Elizabeth Tenney.

2:55:40 Okay. If you are acting on behalf of the commission, you can say you're a commissioner. Well, and I think that, you know, to your point, not that we're defending ourselves, but it's the non-factual elements that were in there are disturbing, the use of the word town, that the town is against all the meetings, the town was against the process. I think that, you know, when that's read, there was another comment in the letter that a planning commissioner was attacked.

2:56:10 And I've had a couple of people ask me. I was very distressed by that. What paper? Have I missed something? It was in the sheet. Sharon, it said that we attacked you. Attacked you. It said you were attacked. I guess I didn't read the letter. I must have been napping then because I don't remember that we did that. If I knew that it was not factual and that, I would have called you and said, are you okay? I had people asking me what happened and I'm like, what? So I read the letter and it's like, whoa. So it's things like that.

2:56:39 You know, it gets into, I think, Elizabeth, if you start responding. Yeah, it's right here if you want to see it. No, thank you. I'll go find it. If you start responding to each and every letter all the time, sometimes silence is better. Generally, that's my policy, but this one really bugged me. And I think that, you know, we've gone through the process ourselves. I mean, you know.

2:57:04 It perpetuates it. You keep getting into it. I know. Unlike a lot of our community members, this specific gentleman, like the publisher of a paper, buys ink by the barrel. So, you know, I think that we went through this process and we know Sharon wasn't attacked. We know the entire town's not against us. So I think leaving it alone, really, at this point, is probably the best policy.

2:57:28 However, when people see it in print, they think it's true. And I just can't let this go by. I don't want to let it go by. What should we do? Because really it comes to us defending ourselves, and we shouldn't be defending ourselves. Well, I see two options. One, we can decide that we want to or don't want to reply as a commission. If we don't want to reply as a commission, you can reply as a...

2:57:58 Private citizen. And is your advice to me? Tony's saying just ignore it. I think that's his advice. I'm saying you can. You need to weigh those things. I mean, I would be fine with you and the chair drafting a letter if that was the consensus of the commission. You know, my point about ignoring it is we have had 50, well, actually 60 meetings, 62 when it hits council.

2:58:25 We've gone through this. To me, it's going back to that churning. Are we churning over it? But not all those meetings were about Old Mammoth Place. They were about policy related to it. I understand that, but if there wasn't any subsequent, if there are any subsequent letters perhaps, it was the only one in the paper, in either paper, really about it. That was surprising. Perhaps we kind of take a coastal mode on it right now.

2:58:54 See how it goes and if it perpetuates something that we feel we need to respond to then, then, you know, perhaps have Rhonda draft something with your help if you feel... That's a good suggestion. You know, just kind of see how it goes. I mean, this is something that it may not come up again in the paper and individually we can correct the facts when people talk to us and, you know, by putting another letter you may...

2:59:19 You may incite and get another one in response. And then how do you... Yeah, I know that syndrome very well. How do you stop that ball from rolling? Exactly. Yeah. Okay. But I think, yeah, but I do agree with you. It was very, especially the part about Sharon, I was like... Oh, there were so many things in it that we just... I thought that our meeting was very respectful and that we were, you know, we...

2:59:43 We had a good debate and good dialogue and it was long and it's important to also point out that last Tuesday that person was at the Future of Mammoth meeting. They wrote the letter and I had a little discussion with him before knowing this letter was out. And knowing that he watched it via the internet, I was like, how was it? Because I was interested to know from down south how it came off for him. And he was very irritated and upset and said his computer, you know, went out at 4 o'clock or something like that.

3:00:11 And I said, and then he went on about us not having discussion, and I said, well, did you watch the meeting? All the discussion was on Thursday. Did you watch the meeting all day Thursday? We spent quite a few hours. It was a very good, lively discussion. And he said, no, I didn't see that. So I was like, oh, well, you know. I said, gee, I'm sorry, because a lot of what you're saying was answered in that meeting. So, anyway. I'm going to follow the advice of if this doesn't die down, then maybe subsequently.

3:00:40 To set the record straight, excuse me, I have to leave, I'm sorry. At this point, if there's no other items then that we can adjourn to, this talks about our regular meeting on the 14th, but are we adjourning to the special joint meeting? How is that protocol? There is a meeting in between, I don't want anyone to miss. Yes, you'll be adjourning to the special meeting. Okay, so to the...

3:01:09 Town Council Planning Commission joint meeting of April 7th at 5 p.m. here in Sweet Z. We are adjourned. Thank you. I'm curious, when we had the information from Peter, was it on the, did the people see that too? Did that go home? It wasn't on. Okay. So they got to see everything. Okay. Are you speaking of the TV sharing or the screening?

3:01:42 Streaming. It's not on the stream, is it? Yes, it is. That's what I heard you say. Oh, you are doing it now, streaming? Yes, and just, well, I stopped it now, but just to let you know, you had about 164 people watching the March 11th meeting. We have reports that we can do. I can't do it from here, I can do it. Oh. But you had a lot of people watch your decision. Yeah. So, because, because, I mean, I just have to say one thing. Oh, yeah, it's an atrocious letter.