Town Council
· recording 4 hr 15 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
538 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:08 Sure. What I used to do, I'd say yes with an extension on number or whatever.
0:35 Joe, do you want to report on our liaison meeting today? Yeah, I'll be glad to. Just saying, you know, we're just starting.
1:05 Thank you.
1:08 Whichever number it is. Abstention? Abstention, yeah. It's, you know, one of those legal terms, they make it as impossible as possible.
1:38 Okay, we're going to go ahead and get started on our
2:05 Regular meeting for Thursday, October 18th. With that, we'll go ahead and start with roll call. So we have Pam helping tonight instead of Jamie, so we're going to be a little patient with her. She's new at it. So anyway, Kim? Here. Here. Here. Here. Here. Okay. With that, Jo, would you like to lead us in the pledge, please? Please join me.
2:37 I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Okay, with that, we'll go ahead and start with public comment. So if there's anybody in the audience that has anything they'd like to comment on that's not on the regularly scheduled agenda tonight,
3:10 Please step to the podium. Please state your names for the people at home. And that's it. Thank you. Elaine Smith, the High Sierra Striders. Andrew Castro with the High Sierra Striders and Mammoth Track Club. And today we'd like to extend an invitation to everyone here, everyone listening, to the grand opening of the Mammoth Track Project. I hope everybody knows about the Mammoth Track Project. After five years of effort, we're bringing a...
3:41 All-weather, high-performance polyurethane running track and synthetic infield to Mammoth Lakes down at the Benton Crossing near the Whitmore Animal Shelter. The grand opening will be on November 17th. That's a Saturday at noon. We'll have some fun. Please wear comfortable clothing if you come. It might be a little cool that day.
4:05 And wear nice soft shoes, rubber shoes to go on the track. Come down and see who will be making the first inaugural lap on the track. Thank you. Do we have a challenge for the council members? We do have a challenge for the council members. Not all have had the opportunity to accept, but we know that they will. And we'll be putting them to the test with the first town council 100-yard dash.
4:34 I'm in. We may have some other celebrities out there performing tricks and showing us their wares, so come down, take a look, and join us with the grand opening. Are we looking at a completed project at that time as far as the track itself?
4:54 The track itself will be done. We're in the middle. We're at the final phases of completing the track portion of the project. We just have the striping left that will go pretty soon. This weekend, I think, is when we'll be doing that. The infield will be worked on then, and there'll be about five days left of work by the time on that Saturday, so it will be...
5:18 Not fully complete, but well on its way. So the infield, there'll be still a little bit of work to do and a little bit around the perimeter of the track itself. So mostly completed. Good. Last question. Is there any kind of cover to protect it from the winter elements or is it just open all the time? It'll be open all the time. In actuality, if it snows and gets snowed down there, it actually protects the surfaces from UV rays. So it's actually a good thing.
5:48 Or prolong the life of it. Congratulations. Thank you very much. Hope to see you there. All right. Good job. Thank you. Anybody else for public comment? Hi, John Wentworth with MLTPA. I guess it's a grand opening season. You guys will be looking forward to what we're going through in a couple weeks here. Mammoth Lake Stress System grand openings on Saturday. Three big events. The first is 8 o'clock in the morning. We're going to be doing some very important trail construction work.
6:20 All of you mountain bikers who want to get out, we're working on the Sharp, one of the Sherman's Working Group projects to enhance that, the Forest Service, the timber operation is finished up there, so now work's going to happen on that. Two o'clock, the grand opening ceremony is over here at the Visitor Center. The MLTPA is having a fundraiser on Saturday night, so just a quick update. Hope to see you all there, and it's grand opening season. Thank you. Was it eight o'clock, John, up there? For the fundraiser, seven o'clock. No, you meant eight o'clock. Eight o'clock in the morning, sorry. Eight o'clock in the morning is for trail building.
6:50 Okay. Thank you. Yeah, thank you. All right. Anyone else for public comment? Good evening. My name is Lee Gosh. Tonight is Jamin's last night in town. She's been recalled back to San Rafael. So she'll be going through extensive training for the next four to eight months. I had a really hard time at the supervisor meeting when I brought her there to say goodbye. And I've been doing a lot of soul searching lately to understand why it's so hard to get the dog back.
7:35 I read a thing on the internet about a lady from Ohio who says when you give your dog back, do not cry when you hand him over to the puppy truck. I need him down in the Mojave Desert when I hand her over because then he'll stress your dog out. The best thing you can do for your dog is to be your dog's best friend and give it encouragement and confidence.
7:56 Another one that I read was a lady was saying, you think you're the only one that can love this dog as much as you do, but there's one other person that can love this dog more, and that's the person that's going to be getting this dog. When I was at the supervisor meeting, it really made me think. And what I came up with was, it's not about me and how sad I am to give up Jamin. It's about the person who's going to be getting Jamin and how they're going to have their life to continue. And I'm very proud of Jamin.
8:25 And it's really hard because I've never given up one before, but I am damn proud of this dog and she's going to be a good one. No guarantee she's going to make it though because it's very hard for a dog to make it. And then tomorrow I'll be getting a new puppy also. It's a two-month-old puppy and when it's old enough I'll bring it in so you guys can meet it. But there are a few people in town that do have service dogs and I know they appreciate everything that these service dogs do. Thank you. Thank you, Lee. I'd like to say one more thing too. I thank the whole town.
8:54 For everybody who helped me raise Jayman, it wasn't just me. It was all the businesses and everybody in Bishop. It was a town that helped raise Jayman. It wasn't just me. So I thank everybody. Thanks. Thank you, Lee. Anybody else for public comment? Okay. Seeing none, we'll go ahead and move on to Councilmember Reports. I'll go ahead and start this in. So, Jo? Thank you.
9:33 On Monday, the Mayor and I attended the Local Transportation Commission meeting. The most important thing coming out of that was that there's a little bit more money to put into some of the public works projects that we have going on, so there'll be a slight bit more that public works can get accomplished for us. Also today, Rick and I attended as the MLTPA liaisons,
9:58 A meeting with staff and members of the MLTPA board to start talking about how that group can help in our restructuring as is noted in our plan. So we've had our preliminary meeting on that. I'm sorry, was that with you? With MLTPA and staff. Thank you. Mr. Mayor, I just had a couple of items not to report on but heads up on. Michael and I are going tomorrow to Bishop for two meetings.
10:30 The first is the Eastern Sierra Transit Authority, ESTA. That's at 10 o'clock in the Council Chambers in Bishop, and at 1 o'clock in the afternoon is the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments, which is Inyo County, Mono County, Town of Mammoth Lakes, and City of Bishop. And then next Thursday, a week from today, here in Mammoth, is the Mono County Collaborative Planning Team Meeting. And if anyone is interested in attending
10:59 That's a group of agencies within Mono County Forest Service, Bureau of Land Management, Town of Mammoth Lakes, Mono County, and so forth. And some of the agenda items, if you're interested, is the Inyo Mono Integrated Regional Water Management Program. That's Mark Drew. The Inyo National Forest Plan update. Susan Joyce of the Forest Service will be there out of the Bishop office.
11:30 Another item is the Inyo National Forest Alternative Transportation Systems Feasibility Study Update, and that's Deborah Lyons, which most of us know Deborah in the time that she spent on transit in both Inyo and Mono County. And the last item is the Digital 395 and the Last Mile Provider Plan Update by Nate Greenberg of Mono County. So if anyone wants to attend on any of those items, that's next Thursday at 9 o'clock in the morning.
11:58 At the town county conference room above Giovanni's. Thank you. Okay. Thank you, John. Michael. One matter for the benefit of the public and the council, the mayor and I attended a conference put on by the Urban Land Institute in Denver the last few days of this week, or actually the first few days of this week.
12:26 In fact, I think you got back about 45 minutes ago. And we, that is, the mayor, myself, Rusty Gregory, and Chuck Landy, presented to several hundred developers, financiers, the thinkers in the development community in the United States, particularly the resort development community, the story of Mammoth. And our story was entitled Mammoth on the Brink.
12:54 And it was designed to tell the story of what has occurred over the last 15 years with respect to the airport development, its litigation, the bankruptcy, the settlement, and the ultimate dismissal. What we found is that most people in the room knew that Mammoth Lakes was in bankruptcy, that it had lost a lawsuit.
13:22 And we got really good, strong feedback, not just for the interesting story from a storytelling point of view that we presented, but also because we have presented what may become a model for other governments as many cities face similar crises. If they aren't now, they will. Different circumstances, but same problem.
13:49 Very, very productive conference to let the development community, the capital markets know that Mammoth is once again open for business. Very productive and the mayor may have some additional comments as well. Thank you, Rick. Yeah, actually I would like to just add on a few things to that. I agree, it went really well. Interesting group. There was actually...
14:14 It was broken off into a couple different factions of the seminar. I think there was about 6,000 people in all that had attended up there. This was specifically related to resorts, and Vail was there, Aspen was there, Park City, a lot of others, and Mammoth did have a good presence there overall. As Mayor Pro Tem Wood had mentioned, some other cities were very interested. There were other staff members there.
14:43 Listening to what we had to say. And what I found to be interesting more than anything else was they came up to us and said, we're going to probably be calling you because we need some help and really want to understand what's going on with this bankruptcy situation. What did it take? What were you really faced with? And what is it that we're going through right now? A lot of cities are going through what we are right now as far as these discussions, cuts, and everything else. And they're in a very challenging...
15:13 Challenging place as well. So in an interesting way where we started off a little bit behind the ball, we may end up being in front of the curve sooner than we know it. With that, on a little bit lighter note, I went to the play The Marvelous Wonderettes at the Edison Theater and have to say it was absolutely wonderful. Pretty much a full house there. For those of you that went to the play, I got to be Mr. Lee. Pulled up on stage. Very fun.
15:42 But I'd highly encourage everybody to go. It adds a very light mood to what's going on. And just highly encourage everybody to go there. Real good time. And then I want to touch briefly on, jump ahead just for a second, on our restructuring discussion later. I would like, I'm going to want to just remind myself to bring it up to council, a discussion about possibly forming a committee or not. So I just want to get feedback from the rest of council and the public.
16:11 With that, I don't have any additional comments. We'll go ahead and move on to commission updates. Sorry, one interruption for those in the back. It's really full. If you guys can speak really loudly. Sure. And make sure you're talking into your mic. It's really hard to hear in the back. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. All righty. So we'll go ahead and move with commission updates. I'm Mickey Brown. I'm the vice chair of the planning commission.
16:42 Good evening, Mayor, Council. Per your instructions from the last Council meeting, Planning Commission met on October the 10th, and we had a very lengthy discussion on what we felt should be the recommended work priorities for the Community and Economic Development Department. In your packet, I believe it's page 41, you'll see a summary of that work program.
17:12 The schedule is divided into three sections. One section is current future projects. One is ongoing and one's almost completed. It's a two-sided piece of paper that should look something like this. Yes? No? Is it in this big packet? It's in your big packet. Okay. And I believe it's page 41. Okay. Okay. Okay. Got it.
17:43 When Commission developed the priorities for this particular work program, we took into consideration revenue generation, we took into consideration projects that were already funded, for example, if we received grants, and then we took into consideration projects that we considered legal mandates. And, of course, any project that's on our almost completed list, which is
18:12 The Mammoth Gateway sign, the Whitmore Track, and Municipal Wayfair Master Plan that are almost completed. If those projects obviously need some additional work, they would take priority. So what I'd like to do is I'd like to just go briefly through this with you and then give you some additional comments. Our number one priority is the zoning code update.
18:40 Our number two priority is the special events market feasibility study. And the number three priority is the capital facilities and diff update. Air quality management plan update, we actually have a grant for that. We recommended that an outside consultant be hired to complete that. It would be revenue neutral, but it would allow that project to be completed.
19:10 Subsequently, there's the Main Street Corridor Project. We also have a grant for that, but that grant we have until February 2014 to complete. In the current scenario, that's like a lifetime, so we made that a B priority. And then we have our solid waste and materials facility, which is obviously a legal mandate, and that's why that rate's high on the list. And our last
19:39 Future project then is the completion of the Southgate neighborhood district plan and while we would very much like to do that now we felt that as the private group of citizens that are working on the high altitude training center gain momentum that it might be a little bit more efficient for us to work on that in the future versus the current so those were the priorities as
20:10 Commission established them. Of course, there's the ongoing ones of TOT, enforcement, special event permits, economic business development, and then this air service and airport facilities planning is a little different than the private group that's actually working on the expanded plan for the airport. So after Commission worked on this, Ellen Clark, Rhonda Dugan, and myself went to the Economic Stimulus Council
20:38 And while I walked in really proud of my schedule here, the feedback was, well, how long is it going to take you to do it underneath the current work program that we have? And the reality is, is to complete all the work on here, we're probably looking between a year to two years to complete, which I know is really difficult.
21:05 And so we brainstormed some ways that we possibly could expedite the work. The reason this economic development, and I know I'm preaching to the choir, is just so important, but last year we had an economic forecast study completed. It was just a year ago. And it was pretty interesting. I don't know if you remember, there was scenario one, two, and three. So the median scenario, scenario number two,
21:34 said, if we reach this kind of development in a period of time, it would increase retail sales tax by 2.7 million, it would increase measure our money by 1.3 million, it would double TOT tax, and measure you funds would increase 37%. So being the person that likes to look at the glass half full, I mean, I think we...
21:58 This is really a two-road approach we have to take here. We have to really look at what we can do to increase our revenue, as the mayor has often said, and obviously how to cut our expenses. The problem with our development is in the past it was always a game of rules of play. Every developer would pretty well come in and have to negotiate what their developer rights were.
22:27 And what we would really like to be is developer ready, not almost ready. And to do that, we really need then to complete our zoning code update, complete our building and permit fees update, and complete our development impact fees update. And probably to finish the whole package, we do need to complete the Southgate neighborhood district plan.
22:54 The Economic Stimulus Council, I thought, had some pretty interesting ideas. One, we could hire a consulting firm. We'd probably have to go out and raise the money to do that or try to find grant money to, for example, complete the building and permit part of our project fee update. We can move our zoning code update
23:21 Project along to the part where then it goes to legal review and CEQA review and then start working on the development impact fee update. So the two of them would overlap. One of the things that we'll talk to council about is when we talk about incentive zoning, are you going to make policy or is it going to be part of the code? Where policy would be a very different situation, it would really just
23:50 be something that you would do on an annual basis saying okay for this year this is what our incentive zoning is going to be to encourage somebody to come to town so I think we have done a really good job of outlining the really key elements of the work program now the question is is how fast can we get it done and Ellen later on this evening is going to really talk about the net effect
24:16 of the restructuring of her department, and they are absolutely a great team, and they are willing to do whatever it takes to really help us move forward. And we do have, I believe, scheduled next month a joint workshop between council and commission to work on the zoning code update. So is there any additional questions on that? Any questions? Yes, John. Just clarification, Mickey, if I could.
24:41 The grant you were talking about under air quality management plan update? Correct. I believe that's the grant from Great Basin? Correct. Okay. And what's the amount of that grant? Do we know roughly? The town was awarded $50,000 in competitive funding, and then we are also going to apply some block grant funding to that for a total of about $70,000. And that's sufficient?
25:07 That should be sufficient to do the scope of work that we've discussed with the district what their expectations for that project is. We had a more ambitious scope that we'd pare back quite a bit. And, you know, I think it is the sort of project that would be fairly easy to outsource to, you know, really it's a lot of just data updating analysis. I think we can do that quite efficiently out of the office and get that done. At this point, do we know when that contract might be let and after it's let what the time frame on that might be? Well, we're,
25:37 Supposed to finish the work by the end of next year. So I would hope that we would get that contract underway the next month, you know, month essentially and get that work going. Great. Thank you. Any other council members? Just a comment, Mickey. So Matthew and I very boldly. You said we're getting, right? Yeah, we laid out a timeline that might be a little bit ahead of yours. So hurry. Right. Well, and you know, there's some, you know, other things.
26:07 That we talked about that are a little bit more out of the box. And one of the things is that we have a very senior planner who's working on TOT compliance, which is a really good thing. But I think it's a lot easier to train a TOT compliance person and maybe even have an organization outside of the town and to have that senior planner then come back and work on some of those projects.
26:33 Obviously, a senior planner requires a very specific skill set. And if you do bring in some developers, trust me, we'll talk a good story for you. Well, we just want to get those updates done. And I know that you're on the right track. So good for you. Any other questions? I just want to say thank you, Mickey. I know you guys have been working hard on that. And also,
26:58 Ellen, I appreciate the attitude you guys are carrying forward with the cuts and everything. Really good to hear that. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, Mickey. Anyone else? Any other commissions? Sandy Hogan with the Mobility Commission. This is just a brief announcement more than anything. Our regularly scheduled meeting for next week has actually been postponed. It's the public traffic management workshop. We hold two of those a year.
27:30 We will probably hold it in the first week of December. We're trying to coordinate our calendars right at this point. But that's one of two that we have transit management in January and, again, usually in June. So that's just basically an update. Okay. Great. Any questions? Any questions? Thank you, Sandy. Are there any other commission updates?
27:58 Okay, we'll go ahead and move on to department reports and emerging issues. Since Mickey gave me a good segue, very briefly, we, staff has published the most recent update on our DOT revenue collection. There's a flyer available at the back of the room outlining the current revenue collections that we've accomplished, now standing at about $187,000 in revenue this year.
28:27 This fiscal year, which includes $143,000 in new taxes and $44,000 in penalties and interest. So that work is proceeding. The second item is more of a business matter regarding a joint workshop that we'd like to schedule with the Town Council on November 7th with the Planning Commission precisely to advance some of these critical work program items. In particular, the topics that we'd like to focus on at that joint workshop are
28:57 An initial discussion for the Community Benefits and Incentive Zoning Program, particularly really focused on giving our consultants some guidance as they move ahead to develop that ordinance, make sure they're proceeding along the right track, answer some of, I think, some of the high-level questions that are really necessary to guide them so they're not, you know, working towards the wrong end.
29:18 And then the second topic that it would likely make sense to discuss is the single-family transient rental issue. It's been obviously raised in this forum. We're continuing to hear about it as something that the community would like to engage in as a discussion, and I feel that it would be a good opportunity to have a work program discussion, vet some of the, I think, the key issues, make sure then that we're on the right track in bringing that program forward if that's something that the council wants to direct us to pursue.
29:48 So those two topics, and definitely welcome any input from the Council for this time on that workshop and those two pieces. Any input this time? I'm very supportive, yeah. Supportive of the workshop, for sure. Is there an input on the specific items? No. November 7th? November 7th at 5 p.m. Before our regular scheduled meeting. Right, immediate before your regular meeting.
30:16 And then finally, just a quick update on one of the items that Commissioner Brown mentioned, which is the building permit fee update. We are actually making some progress on that, working with one of our outside plan checkers who's quite expert and works for a number of cities in Southern California as their building official and has agreed to do really a pro bono review of our existing fee program.
30:38 Processing the results of that, feedback we've gotten from him, and we expect to bring a report back to Council in the December meeting. Great. Thank you, Alan. Appreciate it. Good evening, Mayor, Council. Stuart Brown, Recreation Manager. I want to just do some shameless promotion here while we've got a packed audience. The Recreation Department is hosting the Haunted, actually, the Halloween Carnival and Haunted Rink, Friday, October 26, from 6 to 9 p.m.
31:10 $5 gets you in for all the carnival games, fun, skating, we'll have food, lots of fun, and hopefully the weather will accommodate as well. So that's Friday, October 26th at the multi-use facility right next door. So the skates will still be on the racks. Hopefully some people will come along and help us celebrate Halloween. There you go. Great. Any questions, Stuart? When is the opening of the rink? Scheduled right now is 23rd of November.
31:39 So it's the end of that. I think Thanksgiving is Thursday, so we're trying to open that Friday. So that's something we've always tried to do to get that open for Thanksgiving week. So we're going to try that this year, see how the weather holds out for us, and this will be a great season. So we'll open November 23rd and run through the typical time in February, February, March again. Thank you. You're welcome. Thank you, Sue. Good evening, Council Mayor. Just a couple of quick updates on some of our projects.
32:08 Lakeview Road, fondly referred to as a voodoo chute, is in the final stages of completion. We're just in the process of connecting our heat source to the tubing in the roads, or in the roads, so we'll be wrapping that up shortly. Sierra Park Boulevard, which you may have noticed, we've got the first lift of asphalt down today, and we'll finish that up tomorrow, so we'll be coming back to do striping.
32:36 Some of the pickup work next week. So that's just about completed. The contractor from there is moving down to the Trails End Park project. That project's going to run about six weeks, so that's going to take us into end of November, 1st of December. While we're all hoping for a big winter, I think the work that's included in that project can be conducted despite potential weather.
33:03 That's good. We'll get that project done. Elaine Smith mentioned earlier the track. The track itself is in place. The contractor will be applying a polyurethane sealant, essentially, this weekend, I believe, and the next week they'll be striping the track, and then following that we'll be coming in with the turf, and that's about 15 days to get that done.
33:27 So it's pretty close. If you haven't been out there, it's pretty impressive. It's a nice facility, and I think it's going to be a great amenity for the community. So I just wanted to give you a quick update on some of our projects. One last thing. About this time every year, at least for the last couple of years, we have to consider colder temperatures and weather as it relates to the Lakes Basin Path and when we close it. Council a couple of years ago...
33:53 Approved November 10th as sort of the late date to close the path, which means we'll be pulling that seasonal railing that's in the avalanche zone out prior to the 10th or at the latest by the 10th. I met with Roy Moyer at Tamarack yesterday and discussed some of the issues up in the lake space itself and helping them, you know, manage their season up in the...
34:20 Tamarack for cross-country skiing and how that relates to our path and so forth. So we'll be looking at that and just monitoring weather and at the appropriate time we'll move to close the path. So it'll be posted and everybody will be well aware of it. We'll make it known so it won't be an issue hopefully. Yeah. Always questions. Thank you, Ray. First of all, congratulations on the Sierra Parker Boulevard project because
34:48 You know, you have to have certain temperatures to put down the asphalt, and I stopped and talked to the guy today, and he said that they're going to be done tomorrow, which means that all the asphalt is laid with good temperatures, so it's nice to have that project done. Also talked with the guys doing the rock work on the two entrance monument signs, and they said that they were going to work on the sign by the courthouse first.
35:17 And get that done first. And they thought that they would have the rock work done on that about by the end of November. It does take a while. And I said, so are you going to leave the second side, the Forest Service side, until next year? And he said, no. He said that their instructions from their boss, which is Danny Whitmore, and thank you, Danny Whitmore, for having your crew do this work, that they're going to go ahead and work on the other side as well.
35:45 And they indicated that, John, could you speak up? Oh, I'm sorry. Yeah. When the cold weather comes, which it will at some point, that they just build a, like a tent over the, where they're working to keep the heat on the inside. So they indicated that they thought that they, at some point, they would be able to finish the rock work on both of those signs sometime this late fall or winter time. So that's great. Yeah. Oh, goodness.
36:15 Oh, real quick, Ray, one final question on road opens and closures. Is there a specific date that the road down to Devil's Post Pile, Red's Meadow is scheduled to close, or is that weather-related? I think it is weather-related, and I think the Forest Service wants to keep that open as long as possible. As you know, they're removing timber out of Red's Meadow.
36:39 I think they were scheduled to start helicopter operations next week, and there's a little bit of weather potentially moving in, I think, next week. That may kind of slow that down. If that happens, then they probably won't get to that this year is my understanding. But yes, to answer your question, I think it's weather-related. Okay. Thank you. I'm pretty sure. Ray had one quick question. I'm sorry. So on the voodoo shoe, we have that little shed that's over there.
37:08 Are you guys going to cover that up? Any trees or anything like that? It's just a little bit of an eyesore. I don't know if that was in the plan. Well, that all depends. There isn't, honestly, right now a plan to put any trees or anything out there. We can certainly look at doing that to screen it a little bit better.
37:28 Okay. It's not in the budget right now, but as I said, we can certainly look at doing something like that. Doing a little bit of landscaping is, you know, not a huge cost, so we can take a look at that. I guess we can look at that then. If it's not in the plan, we'll look at it as funds come available. Sure. Okay. Thank you, Ray. Sure. All right. Any other department reports? Okay. We'll go ahead and move on to consent agenda.
37:58 So with that, we have six items tonight. And are there any comments or questions from Council on any items on the consent agenda? Mr. Mayor, I'll abstain on number five as I have a conflict. I represent the party that's impacted by the subpoena. Okay. Mr. Mayor, I'll move for Council adoption of... I need to abstain on item one. I'll move for Council adoption of consent agenda items.
38:27 One through six with the two stated abstentions. Second. Okay, I have a motion and a second with two abstentions. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes on one through four and number six abstain on five. Yes. Okay.
38:57 So we've got all those items taken care of there. Okay. Great. Thank you. We'll go ahead and move on to policy matters. And first item is item number seven. And we'll go ahead and I'd like to get a presentation from Susie Baines, please. Good evening. Susie Baines, Director of Programs for Wild Iris. I'm suffering from a little bit of laryngitis, so I'll try to get through this kind of quickly for your sake and mine.
39:30 So as you know, October is Domestic Violence Awareness Month. It's a national event that strives to bring awareness to a national epidemic. The purple ribbons that have come to be known as a symbol of domestic violence awareness are going to recognize and honor victims of domestic violence and to celebrate survivors. It's also a symbol of hope that the stigma and the silence surrounding domestic violence will one day be broken. Nationally, one in four women
40:00 And one in 32 men will be directly affected by domestic violence in their lifetime. In fiscal 2011 and 12, 159 Mono County victims received services from Wild Iris. Nine victims and their children were sheltered from an abusive partner. And additionally, three victims and their children received emergency transportation out of the area due to the volatility of the situation that they were in.
40:29 I'd like to take this opportunity to urge all citizens in Mono County and Mammoth Lakes to support Wild Iris' efforts to end domestic violence in our community because when even one man, woman, or child is a victim of domestic violence, it's too many. Our hope is that the members of our communities will take the initiative to educate themselves.
40:56 About the impact of domestic violence and to become familiar with the resources and the programs that are available in our community. So with that, I'm going to cut it short. And thank you very much for your support. Okay, Suzy, we'd like to, if you could come up, we'd like to give you this proclamation, please. Go to item number eight, which is the Mammoth Lakes MLTSCC. So, Stu, shorten that up a little bit.
41:45 Stuart Brown, Recreation Manager. Evening, Mayor, Council, members of the public. So the item before you this evening is to approve the priority trail projects list for fiscal year 2012-13, presented by the Mammoth Lakes Trail System Coordinating Committee, or in Mammoth as the MLTSCC, and recommended by the Recreation Commission. So I'll try and keep this brief.
42:09 The Committee with help from MLTPA compile their comprehensive list of trail projects in and around Mammoth Lakes for the past several months. The Committee has worked to prioritise this list and identify projects for funding from the 300,000 annual Measure R allocation approved by Council. On June 12, 2012, the MLTSCC submitted a recommended project list to both the Recreation Commission and Town Council, and that is attachment B in your packet.
42:39 Since that time, the committee has been refining the list and on October 9th, the MLTSCCC met to review and prioritise the fiscal year 12-13 project recommendations and these prioritised projects are identified in Attachment A. Total funding recommendations are $292,652. On October 9th, the Recreation Commission recommended that Attachment A be presented to Town Council this evening.
43:09 For funding consideration. So the next step after this action before you is for staff and the committee to develop a scope of work and level of effort for each of the projects, including a more detailed analysis of the cost, as many of the projects are kind of estimates only, and finally determine which organisation is best suited to deliver on the projects, and then commence contracting obligations at that time.
43:37 So the recommendation for you this evening is to approve the priority list for the fiscal year 12-13 presented by the Mammoth Lakes Trial System Coordinating Committee and recommended by the Recreation Commission. That concludes my presentation. Okay. Thank you, Stu. Are there any questions of Council? Yes, I have one. Stuart, at the end there you said that MLTSCC would be determining who was going to get the contracts. Don't you mean recommending?
44:05 Yeah, recommending, sorry, that's their body right now to recommend. So there was still quite a bit of work to do with this list, so we just want to get it to the point that council can approve that committee moving forward with that prioritized list, and then the committee can move forward with further detailed analysis. Okay. Michael, do you have any questions? No. I had a few questions, and I appreciate you clarifying that these were estimates, because the one question I had was where the numbers were coming from.
44:34 So we're going to narrow that down, and I'm guessing that, you know, for example, if we were to take any one of these, there's going to be a breakdown of how many hours or at least a, like you said, a more detailed outline of what we're paying for. Right. Okay. Yeah, that's great. And then I have a question, and maybe you or John or somebody can bring this back, but this is something that's come up to me before. We're paying, it looks like, an estimate for $30,000 for the Friends of the India to do Lakes, Basin Stewards.
45:03 Program Management. And to clarify, is that in wilderness, or not wilderness, but forest service area? That was, yes, I believe so. And I guess the question that I'm going to present, and again, I've heard this from a number of folks, is why we're paying for that. And so if we could bring that forward and then just some better clarification on, you know, website operations. You know, we've got almost $40,000 for operations and maintenance.
45:32 I'm not saying it doesn't cost that. Maybe it does, but it would be nice to have those kind of details. So that's all. Maybe you would let me make a comment about that. The Mammoth Lakes Trails Plan has approximately 320 miles of trail. 300 of those miles are in the forest. So the majority of the work that's being recommended through this process is forest lands and forest trails. So nearly everything on the list.
46:02 Is in the forest. Okay. But can I, but Dave, it's all within either the municipal boundary or our planning area as outlined in the general plan? Yeah, it's all within the planning element, including the trails plan, but most of the requests for funds will be in the forest because that's where the trail system mostly is. Okay, yeah, and I guess I just want to know what that's going to be because there was some trail maintenance that was done last time I was very opposed to.
46:31 And I just want to see what that's going to be moving forward, if we're going to end up doing the same thing, if this trail maintenance means closing more trails. I mean, I just would like to know that as we move forward. So just to clarify, so you would expect staff to bring back a more detailed level of effort and estimate and cost to council? Please. Okay. And then, so, where are we at with this one? Are we doing just approval on this?
47:02 Yeah, information. Matthew, can I ask you for a little bit of a clarification on which ones need to come back to us? Are you talking about the higher money ones that we would see in awarding a contract? Because some of these are pretty small amounts that would be administratively handled. Sure, yeah. The larger ones more specifically, but I think everything else, they may be small, but they add up to $300,000. And I guess I just...
47:28 Stuart said they're going to give a detail on it, that's fine, if they're doing that anyway, I just specifically on some of these larger ones, I would like to get just a better outline of what we're going to be doing too. I do want to point out that one you identified there, number 451 website operations, so that website is actually live, mammothtrails.org.
47:50 So this is really the content management of that site. So this is one of those priority projects that we need to kind of move forward on. Right. No, I understand. With some expediency. Yeah, no, I understand that. And I'm supportive of the project for sure. I just want to make sure that we're getting for $40,000. It's very detailed. We can do that. Okay. Thank you. I'm sorry. Oh, yeah. Please. Donette Hustleton. I had a concern about the website that was brought up.
48:28 We're almost at a quarter, not quite a quarter million dollars on that website. And it went from 10 to 17 to close to 40,000 to maintain it. And my suggestion was to send it out to bid to see what kind of best price and what kind of work can be done and possibly be able to save some funds in that area towards another project. Okay. Thank you, Donna.
48:55 I think if we can at least get back the scope of work on it, then maybe we can consider that. But I'd like to see what we're getting first. If it's pretty obvious, then yeah. Okay. Are there any other questions from members of the public on this? Okay. So we've given direction, and with that, we can move on. No, we need to make a motion.
49:17 I move we approve option one, which is to approve the priority trails projects for fiscal year 12-13 presented by MLT SCC and recommended by the Recreation Commission. Second. Okay, I have a motion in a second. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Okay, we have a motion passing 5-0. Okay.
49:50 Okay, with that, we're going to move on to policy item number nine. And before we start this, I want to go over a couple of things. One, how we're going to handle this tonight is going to be slightly different. But before we get into it, before I turn the podium over to Dave, I just want to say I acknowledge a lot of frustration out there and confusion with folks. This is a very challenging process, a lot of change going on.
50:21 Change is always difficult. It's never easy. But what we're doing is part of a plan. It is part of a process, and we're working through it. I know it may seem confusing, and there's a lot of detail in what we're doing, and that's why we're encouraging everybody to be here and write your emails and ask the questions that you're asking because we do want you to be as informed and educated as possible.
50:51 With that, we have received a lot of emails, a lot of phone calls, and we're trying to just gather as much input as possible. So with that, Dave, I'm going to go ahead and turn it over to Town Manager Dave Wilbrecht. As you guys come up and ask questions, I think instead of getting into long discussions on each department and having them come up and give you a presentation, what we'll do, if you have specific questions relating to a specific department, we'll let that department head come up and answer your question as best they can.
51:21 But I'll turn the podium over to Dave at this time. Thank you, Mayor and Council. Just to report, after the council meeting tonight, I'm headed to Sacramento. Tomorrow we have our hearing with the federal judge on the bankruptcy plan that we've forwarded to you. So hopefully tomorrow the judge will approve the ability for the town and our attorneys to go back to state court and revise the writ to match the settlement amount when that occurs.
51:49 Within 30 days after the process, the bankruptcy will be completed in an automatic fashion. So tomorrow is an important hearing date, so I'll be reporting back as soon as I learn that outcome to you. Just a couple of comments. I appreciate the fact that, and you mentioned it too, this is a very difficult process. We certainly want to encourage everybody to participate.
52:15 Tonight, Marianna is going to provide some more information, particularly in terms of a calendar to let people know what we're doing and how we're doing it, go through some more details. Obviously, there's very, very much information that's now on the webpage, our webpage, as well as things that we've handed out. To the point, I think maybe it's getting confusing, but I think it's important to continue to move forward with it. We have department heads and managers here that can answer questions. I've asked them if they need to make a presentation to do it in about two minutes.
52:45 And so, you know, Ellen Clark, Ray Jarvis, Stu Brown, Dan Watson's here. I think, of course, I'm here as well to provide information. So I'll turn it over to Marianna. She's got some slides. And then feel free to ask us to come up and answer any questions you might have. Thank you. Thank you, Dave. So we'll go ahead and let Marianna give the presentation. Did you want to give it first, Marianna, before we turn it over to the various? Sure. Yeah. Okay.
53:15 Mayor, Councilmembers, good evening. As Dave has mentioned, we have presented a wealth of information to you and the community. There is a lot of information on the town's website. If you go to the main webpage on the left-hand side, there is a link to settlement, and that's where a lot of the restructuring plan information is. What we decided to do tonight is...
53:41 As opposed to going through every line item and every single department again because I think we're beginning to confuse people. We don't allow enough time for the people to speak and to ask questions. We will try to be as brief as possible and really highlight the most important points. I don't have too many slides so I will try to be brief. What I'm going to be mainly focusing on is a summary of the plan.
54:06 And the alternatives that we were able to fit on one page. There should be handouts out there. The summary also went out with the press release, and it's going to be on the slides. So that's what I plan to focus on mainly tonight. I am also going to remind the community that, again, there's a lot of information on the website. We update on a regular basis the frequently asked questions document. So as you ask us questions,
54:33 And we provide responses. That document is available online as well. And everything that we present to the Council, the agenda packets, the attachments, the presentation, everything is available online. So with that, there continues to be an opportunity, multiple opportunities, multiple ways for the public to provide input to the Council, staff, all of us.
55:00 You can respond. We encourage you to respond to an online survey that is available. A link to the survey is available through the town's website. The deadline to respond is October 21st. We have received a lot of responses, and we're not going to analyze them until after that date. We encourage you to continue attending town council meetings. In the agenda report itself, we continue, and we've done this since September,
55:29 Presenting specific dates of when the Town Council meetings will take place. So specifically on pages 2 and 3 of the agenda, we noted that after tonight's meeting, there is going to be a meeting on November the 7th, when the Town Council will begin deliberations on the restructuring plan. On December the 5th, the Town Council will continue discussions and will cast a vote on the plan.
55:56 After that, after we approve the first phase of the restructuring, i.e. cuts, we will move to the future stages of the restructuring plan that mainly will have to do with the alternative service delivery models, including volunteer programs, outsourcing programs, and so on. So we encourage you to attend those meetings, and the list of those is available in the agenda bill as well as on the website.
56:23 We encourage you to call the town manager's office, send us emails to the MLLA settlement inbox, the town floor, the town council, and so on. All the emails as well as the letters that we receive are included in the agenda packet for tonight. It's attachment E as well as anything that we receive after the print deadline is also available. Copies are available.
56:51 We also included in the agenda packet itself additional information on the restructuring plan based on some questions that have been raised, the same information as available in the frequently asked questions. For example, a question was asked as to how the reduction figures or the deficit figures were calculated, how they relate to the settlement amounts so that question is answered, as well as what additional measures are needed.
57:19 To rebuild fiscal stability of the town. So that is addressed. And in general, and I'll speak about this in a few minutes, the restructuring plan really provides only a base, the first step towards recreating fiscal stability in the town. We do need to do a lot more. We're very low in cash. We're very low in reserves. So we'll talk a little more about that tonight.
57:48 Now, I did want to spend just really maybe perhaps a minute or so on the context for the proposed plan because I think it's something that perhaps we did not clearly articulate in previous presentations. The structuring plan, as you know, currently proposes a deduction of a number of positions to be exact 13 of those 13, 7 are police officers. Obviously, those are extremely difficult cuts.
58:16 To propose, so why did we keep particular reductions? Well, the context in which we made those recommendations for the community and the council to consider was threefold. One is we could not propose any taxes because any tax has to be approved by voters and we can't balance the budget on a tax that hasn't been approved. But it's something that we engage in discussion with you. And tonight we'll talk a little more about possible taxes.
58:45 We also need voter consent, not voter approval, but voter consent on further making reductions to tourism, housing and transit. We had to make some reductions to those three areas. They are not special taxes, they are not legally restricted taxes, but they are taxes that are protected by what we call political commitments made by voters years ago.
59:13 And lastly, there are also measures R and U which are legally restricted. And we cannot take money from those measures to balance the budget. So those are some of the constraints that we had to operate within. And all of those constraints are up for discussion with the community. Now, the proposed plan, again, what I'm going to do is just follow this handout, the one-page handout. What I'm going to do is spend just really a few moments...
59:39 On the proposed reductions, the handout includes the reductions and then the alternatives. So the proposed reductions again develop in the context that I just mentioned. Can't raise taxes, can't touch measures A and C, can't touch measures R and U. At this point the reductions include the elimination of up to seven positions if no other options are available.
1:00:03 In the Police Department, the date has been moved to July 1st, 2013, from January 1st, 2013, and that would save about a million dollars. The rest of the departments would have to eliminate positions in absence of other alternatives on January 1st. Community and Economic Development could see the elimination of 1.5 positions. Public Works and Transit could lose one position in Parks Maintenance.
1:00:31 Parks and Recreation would lose, I believe, 0.75 recreation specialists if the town's funding for the Whitmore or Pullen Park is discontinued. In administration, the budget position has been eliminated and the IT specialist position would be contracted out. Town-wide, we actually set aside some money for the volunteer program that we plan to establish.
1:00:58 So those are the recommended measures. In the first year, in the current year, they barely balance us. We're very, very short on cash. In addition to budget balancing, which is what we see before you, we also need to keep in mind our cash flow fluctuations during the year. So to make the first payment to MLA,
1:01:20 We're going to be borrowing from some of the funds internally within the town. So these are the proposed measures, again, developed in the context that I mentioned twice. Now, what possible alternatives exist? Now, these are some possibilities. Obviously, it's not a list that is all-inclusive, exhaustive, but these are some of the possibilities that we would like to discuss with the community and the council before December 5th.
1:01:52 We could raise taxes. And again, all of these tax increases would require voter approval. Actually, before I get to the taxes, I'm getting ahead of myself. We could seek voter consent. Again, not voter approval, but voter consent in whatever form we decide to seek it to further decrease funding to tourism, housing, and transit. What I listed on the slide are the full amounts that those organizations receive.
1:02:20 The reason fiscal year 12, 13 amounts are about half of the annual is because I listed only half the year, assuming that the cuts need to take place by January 1st. So if you look at the last column, those are the representative full amounts that those organizations receive, about 2.2 million for MLT, about 329,000 for MLH, and about 700,000 for EST. Again, those are full contract amounts.
1:02:49 And if we decided to cut some of those amounts, we would like to make sure that it's dealt with proper consent for the community. Mariana, can I interrupt you really quick? On MLH, can you explain how we got to the 329? Because a question that's come up is if it's 1%, how do we get to that number? Absolutely. And I did provide a detailed response and a frequently asked questions in the doc and the staff report for those who would like to take a look at it.
1:03:18 Basically, yes, both the transit and the housing functions receive 1% of TOT, which is about 733 in the case of ESTA. However, approximately 280,000 on the housing side is currently spent on debt, debt that pays for one of the affordable housing complexes.
1:03:42 That debt is going to be paid off at the end of fiscal year 13-14 because that money is not legally restricted. FTI, when they did analysis for us in consultation with bankruptcy attorneys, had to include that savings of $280,000 beginning in fiscal year 14-15 in the general cash flow.
1:04:07 So those savings are now basically going to be part of the equation that is used to calculate how much money the town has. At the time the FTI had prepared their analysis, those savings were part of the annual surplus that they calculated.
1:04:30 There's also a little bit of money left after you subtract MLH's contract of 329 and the debt service of 280. There's some money left that pays for town staff and there's also a structural surplus in that fund. So both the surplus and the money that becomes available from the debt service are already part of the...
1:04:53 Town surplus equation, which is not something we absolutely have to do, it's just part of the financials that were developed for us within the legal boundaries. Once we get to those fiscal years, we could make a decision how we want to spend those amounts. Thank you. Moving on to Measure R, we could apply...
1:05:14 For the use of Measure R funds to continue the town's funding of the Whitmore, Pullen and Park and that's on an annual basis just under $120,000. Now let's talk a little bit about new taxes and again all of these require actual voter approval and the timelines that we presented assume that the council if there's direction from the community to seek voter approval
1:05:41 The Council would make a decision in December or January to put something on the ballot. It takes about four months for us to prepare, about a month for us to prepare legislation and about three months deadline that the county has, or three months timeline that the county has for us to submit information to that. So there's at least a four month lag between our decision.
1:06:05 And the special election if we decide to hold a special election. So at this point, the timelines that you have on the taxes assume that there could be a special election if we decide to raise taxes in April. So among possible taxes, and again, opportunities are endless, but these are some of the possibilities, is new admissions tax. If we decided to seek voter approval on a 3%, as an example,
1:06:31 Admission tax, admissions tax that basically would apply to the lift tickets as well as any other admission tickets within the town. We would raise on annual basis, beginning next fiscal year, $2 million. And that's the earliest that the money will come in. The problem with any of the taxes is there's such a lag, not only between our approval and the actual election, but also then between the election and when the money comes in.
1:06:59 The next possible tax is the utility tax. We have Measure U, which is the utility tax. It's currently 2.5%. If we raise that tax to 5%, which still would be low compared to other cities, but high enough here, given the utility costs, you could collect a million dollars from that particular increase a year, a million dollars a year, again, beginning next fiscal year.
1:07:23 If you have a new sales transaction tax, I'm going to call it sales tax, that's the easiest, very similar to what measure R is, measure R is a sales tax. So currently our sales tax rate in Mammoth Lakes, including the measure R add-on is 7.75. If we increase that rate by 0.5% to 8.25, we would raise a million annually.
1:07:50 But it won't come in until March of 2014 because there are requirements at the state level for a lag. So we would collect $750 next year but then a million a year after that. Now I did provide some rate comparables. $825 would be higher than Monroe County but would be much lower than many other California cities.
1:08:14 We also could seek voter approval on a parcel tax of about $100 a year per parcel, and that revenue would come in in time for next fiscal year. It actually would come in December, but it only comes twice a year, so we would collect a million a year. And lastly, we could seek, and this does not require voter approval, but does require community consent,
1:08:42 We could seek an enhancement of the TOT collection by allowing additional nightly rentals of single family housing units. We don't have a good revenue estimate, and that's why I said to be determined, but a guesstimate at this point, based on what we know, is it could be close to $500,000. I frankly did not even want to put the number out there because it is a guesstimate, but that's the best that we can produce.
1:09:12 I have two questions on the taxes for the public's sake. So just for clarification, even if we passed, we decided in December that we wanted to move forward with a tax, and in March it passed, it would still be a long time before we would have revenues coming in. So in the short term, there are still going to be cuts necessary, and I kind of want to emphasize that because some people are thinking if a tax were to pass immediately in March,
1:09:42 That we would be able to avoid cuts, and that's not necessarily true. We're still going to probably have to make cuts unless we can find some other way around that, but it's not looking that way, just for clarification. And the other thing on the sales tax, I had a question. Does that apply to only sold items or is it rental items as well? So if you rented a pair of skis or something like that, do you know?
1:10:06 I don't think it applies to rental, but I'm not. I don't know either. Yeah, whatever is taxable, whatever is taxable. Restaurants, all that tax, sales tax, you get that percent. Yeah, okay. I'm curious, okay. But very quickly on the timing, you're absolutely right, and I think that's very important to emphasize that currently, if we go back to the previous slide,
1:10:32 All the non-public safety cuts would still have to take place unless we find a different source of revenue or different deductions, which still would be deductions. Public safety cuts at this point are assumed to not begin until July 1st. So to the extent that we have new revenues, those with public safety cuts would not be necessary and some of the non-safety positions could be restored.
1:11:03 As I pointed out before, and I'm going to mention briefly, that our restructuring plan is not perfect. It does create a good foundation, but we do need strong reserves because we currently have barely enough cash to make payments to MLA. If there's another bad snow year, we do need cash to avoid future cuts.
1:11:27 There are some other alternatives for us to consider and we would seek Council direction on when and how to consider those alternatives. For example, rezoning the bell-shaped parcel to either sell or make available under a long-term lease for development so we could generate some TOT revenue. You may recall in the community may or may not know that currently that parcel is zoned as parkland so it's not developable.
1:11:53 We could also generate long-term revenues to the sale of town assets. We would not recommend selling any assets right now. It's really not a good market, but it's something that we need to consider. And to clarify on the bell parcel, we would have to go through CEQA again too, right? That's my understanding. If Andy Morris is here... I believe we would. That's right.
1:12:18 This is the last slide. And really, my point here is to remind the Council and the community, because I think I've said enough, we've said enough in the last four meetings. But I want to remind the Council and the community that there are a number of exhibits included with this agenda packet. Exhibit A is a detailed plan, which is summarized on this one page. There's nothing else in it. Exhibits B1 through B4.
1:12:43 Discuss impacts as well as proposed organizational structures for the departments impacted by the proposed plan, including admin services, community and economic development, public works and transit and recreation. And those department directors are here to answer any questions or provide any additional information. Exhibit C includes yet additional information from the police chief and the police department
1:13:10 With regards to the plan of deployment, if staffing goes down, as well as a plan to develop the reserve and the volunteer program, the police chief is here to provide that information or answer any questions. Exhibit D, we discuss in the report housing, transit, and tourism as areas where reductions have already been made in prior months and years.
1:13:35 But where further reductions could take place was the community consent. As part of that discussion in prior meetings, questions came up and staff was requested to supply information on what exactly Mammoth Lakes Housing does for the town through their contract as well as what housing units they own and what loans they owe to the town and what is the timeline to repay those loans. That information is in Exhibit D.
1:14:04 And Pam Kennedy is here to respond to any questions. And lastly, as I mentioned previously, Exhibit E contains communication received from the community to date on any of these matters. Against the last slide, I'm going to sit down and see if there are any questions from you and the community. Thank you. Thank you, Marianna. So are there any questions to start with for council? Any questions from the public initially? Yes.
1:14:37 Go on up to the podium. State your name if you would, please. And again, what we'd like to do is we'll have the various department heads, if you're asking about a specific question within the department, have them come up and answer your question. Thank you real quick. Yes. I wanted to offer anyone in the audience, I've got 20 copies of the frequently asked questions that are printed out. And if someone doesn't want to go online or if someone would like a hard copy,
1:15:07 We'd like to distribute those 20 copies throughout the audience. Thank you, John. Okay, go ahead, John. Good evening, Councilors Mayor. My name is Sean Turner. I'm a Recreation Commissioner, Vice Chair of the Mammoth Lakes Trails System Coordinating Committee. I'm a business owner, a soccer coach, pretty active here in town. And I guess what I would like to do is I just want to speak briefly because there was some confusion initially the meeting on November 7th.
1:15:35 I was going to invite the public to talk specifically about recreation issues. It sounds like that got moved up to this meeting tonight. So what I want to speak to just briefly is with regard to Measure R and my understanding from my seat on the Recreation Commission about Measure R being used to pay for Whitmore, to keep Whitmore pool funded. A couple frustrations I just want to express briefly is that what we've heard from the Recreation Commission, or at least what I have heard,
1:16:05 Is that the public, a large portion of the public, feels like Measure R is the only avenue to keep Whitmore Pool. And I don't believe that that's the case. The other frustration that I hear is that they feel that the Recreation Commission is the gatekeeper to making this decision. And as you know, that's not the case. We only make recommendations to you, the Town Council. You are in a very difficult position with this MLA settlement.
1:16:33 The reason why I highly advocate against Measure R funds being used to take care of Whitmore Pool is twofold. First of all, my understanding of Measure R, and I know that this is a topic of big discussion, is with regard to the S-words, planting. But Whitmore Pool has been paid for for years by the general fund. And if Measure R is now used to pay for
1:17:02 Funds that were previously paid for out of general fund, then Measure 1 was only a tax increase to there pay for that part of the general fund. The second comment I want to make is that businesses here in town, all of us as a business owner myself, Mammoth Brewing Company, we just had to go through some cuts that I was not
1:17:24 I'm happy with. I had to let go of some employees going into the fall just because, as every business in this town goes through, it's very difficult in fall. But for the company to survive, we had to make some cuts. And if you're talking about $117,000 to keep Whitmore Pool, which is just such a valuable asset that this town has, as well as an additional $65,000 to $80,000
1:17:52 For personnel in the Recreation Department, I would like to say to Town Council, please find that money elsewhere. The Recreation Department has already taken bigger cuts than most other departments until the proposed cuts that are happening right now. And if you need to take a loan from Measure R, which my understanding is that can happen, I would like to make sure that Town Council really makes that clear that it is a loan from Measure R.
1:18:22 I guess in closing I just want to say that recreation is the product that we sell here in this town. Recreation is the one product that we offer, outdoor recreation specifically, that gets our tourists coming up here. And I think that if you start to cut things like the Whitmore Pool from General Fund with the expectation that Measure R is going to cover that, when in my mind Measure R is for the improvement and the enhancement of the recreation programs in this town,
1:18:52 I think that's a mistake. So again, I know it's not a question specifically, but because the November 17th Recreation Department specific comments got pushed up to tonight, I really wanted to make that comment. Thank you for your time. Thank you, Sean. We got you. Thank you, sir. You guys speaking in the mic. Yeah. You opened the door somewhat on a
1:19:23 potentiality of a loan to keep Whitmore open for this next year. I think that it is likely that the council and or the community will want to generate additional revenues in some form over the next year. What form that will take, we have yet to determine. But
1:19:49 There are things happening in the proposed cuts that none of us want. And if there was a commitment by the council to take an amount of money, let's say $200,000 from Measure Our Funding to keep Whitmore Pool and recreation programs going for the next year in anticipation of generating a new revenue source to pay that back.
1:20:16 Is something like that been discussed by the commission and do you think the commission is supportive of something like that? Right. Great question. Privately that has been discussed, I think, in actual commission, not directly. I will say this, that for years, since I've been on the Recreation Commission, we are at a point, in my opinion, that Measure R and Measure U should be used for bonding large projects going forward.
1:20:46 For years, we have been debating not to take that up because the MLL settlement's coming, the lawsuit's coming. Now that the settlement has happened, I think it is time to move on. I think that Measure R and Measure U are, and I'm speaking Measure R as a commissioner and just Measure U as a citizen. I think the time is ripe for bonding those measures so that we can look at these large projects.
1:21:16 Like a community center that we've talked about for years and years, where's it going to be? I think it's time to seriously look at bonding that money so that we can make a major investment like that. You just asked me about $200,000 perhaps in the form of a loan from Measure R. Look, if that's what it takes to keep Whitmore Pool open, then yes, I will probably personally support it. I'm not in favor of it, but these are difficult times. When Measure R passed, I think it was meant
1:21:46 The improvement and the enhancement, not the supplanting of the existing recreation department. Times have changed. You've got difficult decisions in front of you. But what I would like to say to you is that out of a $17 million budget, if you're looking at it for $185,000, we've got a lot of staff in this town. And again, I know and Facebook friends with many of them. But at the same time, there are cuts that have to be made. And I had to make some cuts.
1:22:15 In my professional life with regard to my business, it's not fun decisions, but you've got to make the decisions and you've got to make those cuts. So I would highly recommend that you, I would say that you can find money elsewhere. I'm not seated where you are. You've got to make those decisions. Thank you. Anyone else? So, Sean, I'd like to put you on the spot and I'll put others as well. Okay. First of all, I share your concern about
1:22:45 Opening that door on R&U in particular. If we were not to approve a loan, based upon what you saw on the screen tonight, where would you come? That was going to be my question. Well, you don't have to answer it, but we do at some point. Yeah, I know you do. And actually, again, going out there in, sure, I'll take a little bit of a stab at that.
1:23:17 You know, you do have a lot of departments that are out there that have got some pretty big salaries. And while that's the going rate, sometimes you have to get lean. And I think that Whitmore Pool is more important than some of the positions that I know are out there.
1:23:41 I'm not going to go into any more detail than that, Rick Wood. Thank you very much for putting me on the spot. Thank you, Sean. But at the same time, you know, if we're talking about, you know, and I hate to say only $185,000, Whitmore Pool, the value of that is so great considering the type of budget that you've got. So I hope I dodged that question. Thank you. And I just had one quick comment. I appreciate you pointing out that that is not, that R is not the only place to pull the funds from.
1:24:12 There are other places we can look and, you know, I personally am thinking of other areas as well. So, thank you. And regarding November 7th, you still can discuss this on November 7th. That's just the day we're going to be having deliberation. So, there will be some time, I believe, for some final comments. Probably December 5th, too. Okay. Well, I know that there was quite a few emails that were sent around throughout the public that were saying, got to get there on the 18th because everything's been moved up.
1:24:41 There was a little bit of confusion on that, and I specifically wanted to address it. No, I'm glad you did come tonight, though, to talk about it, because it's better we get it out there now and start discussing it and airing it out and getting all this out there. So thank you. Thank you for your time. And Pam, do you know how to work that thing? Okay, we're going to... Three minutes? Limit time? Yeah. I don't know how to work that thing. Shall I? Three. Three minutes. Can I go? Since I have three minutes? Go ahead. Donate Hassleton.
1:25:10 A couple things I want to bring up is the Measure R that was on the cut Whitmore pool, but then you had Measure R using. So that was a little confusing, like you can use Measure R, I feel. One thing that Sean said or neglected to say is also in that Measure R is that you also have administration and maintenance as part of that award that comes out of the taxes. And I strongly feel there was, like Lisa said last time,
1:25:38 90 swimmers and 454 people that learned how to swim. And there was, I think, 7,000 hits of going to that pool. The other part I want to talk about is I also do agility. And we have an event that brought in around 90 dogs, about 100 people with families that brought revenue to the town in TOT for bed tax.
1:26:07 And also about sales tax. We also had catering and that also generated quite a bit of money. We also paid the town for having this event, so that generated money. We can only grow the event to so much because you can only have so many dogs. That's generating money and that's fundraising and that helps with that. It's not a lot of money, but it helps. The other thing that's really concerning is that baseball field.
1:26:33 Was built by the high school or by Reagan Green oversaw it. It's a beautiful field that is used all the time by the baseball kids out of the high school and other people. And Rick, you know that because you've been out there. And that's really sad if you let that go as well as the pool. And I disagree a little bit with Sean. It would be great to do the loan. And if we can increase the sales tax and part of that could come out to pay that loan off, that would be wonderful. But in the meantime,
1:27:03 What are these 90 kids? What are these other people going to do when there's no pool? They're going to be bored, getting into trouble. I don't know. I know my kid would get in trouble. And sports was a big thing for him that kept him out of trouble. So if the pool keeps these kids out of trouble and they have something to do in the summer, I think it's really important. Same with the baseball, the agility, and anything else that's out there. It's used more than you think. And I really strongly urge
1:27:32 Maybe taking the loan from Measure R or using the money. I don't agree that we should be doing new projects and then we still have maintenance. We still have everything that goes along with it and you're putting the old stuff in the back. If you continue cutting your programs, you're cutting your staff, that means you're cutting your programs. You can't cut any more staff. You are down to the bare bones. There's going to be sacrifices by doing that.
1:28:00 By not collecting your TOT, by not overseeing stuff. But I do agree with Sean. Maybe there is a little bit high salary that should be leaned out. So quick question for you. You're saying to preserve these things. I heard taxes, I heard measure R, and I heard cut salaries. Those are the three things I suggest. I know that taxes, like Marianna said, would take a while. But in the meantime, maybe you can loan that money out and then pay it back with that tax if people approve it.
1:28:30 And I appreciate a solution. Don't go yet. You speak early, you get cross-examined. You and I sat on the little lean board for quite a while. Yeah, we did. So I have two questions, and they are, what do you think about increasing user fees for the use of the pool? I think a lot of people that don't have a lot of money use that pool. And I think that you would...
1:29:02 Those children would suffer is my personal opinion. You also know that I volunteer for the swim team and I do their books, so I see a lot of that stuff. And I think there's a lot of hard times for people out there, so I would not in favor of that. I would try something else.
1:29:22 One other question. So that operation out there is financed or funded 50% by the town. We have three supervisors representing this town. Do you think that the, meaning representing districts which include the town, do you think that the county should play a role in any way? And if so, what is that? If you look at how many kids come out of, that use that pool, majority of the population comes from Mammoth.
1:29:53 There is some population that comes from the county, but not as much from the population from Mammoth. You've got your Crowley, that's Mono County. You've got, I think, a few Swan Meadow people, and you have some June Lake people. But Mammoth residents are also county residents. I understand that. But I'm looking at, you're asking, I'm looking at what the supervisors say, and I'm thinking possibly that maybe we should ask them for some additional funding towards that.
1:30:22 Also, you have the shelter out there. Now, you also have to pay some of that. Am I correct? That is correct. Shouldn't you be asking for some of that funding to help support that? Well, I'm asking you what you think. I think you should. Personally, I think you should ask for more funding. I think you should keep the animal shelter going, keep these other things going. Yeah, I do. I think you should ask for the money. I don't know if you'll get it, but I think you should ask. Okay. Thank you. Appreciate it.
1:30:51 I'm going to reset that. Please. Good evening. Hi, everybody. My name's Lynn Almeida, and I actually live and own a business in Bishop, but I'm here as well as Dinah speaking on behalf of the Eastern Sierra Agility Group, of which I'm also a member. I'll try not to duplicate too much of what she said, but I have a couple of other things, points to bring up. Our membership, it really is comprised of people from both Inyo and Mono counties and Town of Mammoth.
1:31:19 We're split about evenly between the two counties. We also offer classes to people in the summertime, mostly people from Mammoth Lakes, anywhere depending on the year from 50 to 40 people or 15 to 40 people and their dogs so they can come and have a safe, positive, healthy way to interact with their pets and train their dogs. A tired dog is a good dog. Our club, in addition to the trial that we host, we're starting to
1:31:47 Gain some renown in the area is a great place to come and just train with our club, not during the trial. So we're starting to see people come to this area and of course bring their dollars for a longer time period than just that special event that we have every year. I expect that to only get more so as agility gets more popular and our group gets better known. The other thing is that the Whitmore ball fields are really the only facility
1:32:16 Thank you for your time and energy and participation. Thanks.
1:32:49 Hi, my name is Ken Coleman, and I've worked in a service sector job here in Mammoth for almost nine years now, and just very recently, Pam and Jen at Mammoth Lakes Housing helped me purchase my first home through facilitating down payment assistance, and I never thought that would be possible, so it's kind of like more than a
1:33:19 Dream come true because I never even dreamed of it. And I just want to say thank you and give them a plug that I definitely would like to see that possibility remain in place for my friends and other community members. So it's a program that worked for you personally? Yes. Thank you. Thank you. Good evening.
1:33:50 My name is Elizabeth Truax. I'm a resident of Mammoth Lakes, a parent, increasingly these days a recreation advocate, and I'm also the newest recreation commissioner, though the following views are my own. Like many people, I'm disappointed by the proposed cuts to recreation funding, specifically the Whitmore Pool and Park. According to the CDC, drowning is the leading cause of death for children ages 1 to 4, who, according to the American Red Cross, represent 75% of drowning fatalities.
1:34:18 The CDC indicates that drowning is also the second leading cause of death just after automobile accidents for all children from ages 1 to 14. We are the town of Mammoth Lakes, a resort community surrounded by lakes and filled with unsupervised private pools. Teaching kids to swim and be water safe is critical to both the health and safety in this community. Whitmore is also the only public pool and also the only full-size pool in the county, which is an important distinction for both the NICA kids on the Mammoth Swim Team and other recreational lap swimmers like me.
1:34:50 Whitmore is used by both visitors and locals alike. On many occasions, I've heard the pool staff giving directions and local information to visitors to the facility. With school budgets in California being cut, kids in Mammoth will be in school just 175 days this year, possibly only 165 next year. This is the wrong time to be cutting funding to recreation and closing facilities. It also sends a poor message to the athletes we are trying to attract for high-altitude training with the construction of our new track.
1:35:19 I realize we are in for very tough times with this settlement, especially over the next 10 months as we pay out over $4.5 million by July 1st. The community has been presented with the option of using Measure R funds to supplant recreation funding and save the pool. It has been presented as an all-or-nothing choice in some venues. Some people I respect very much do see it that way, but I am personally wary of using the existence of Measure R to justify cuts in recreation spending.
1:35:45 From the general fund when recreation is already one of the smallest general fund expenditures. If we spend our funds in this manner, I fear a slippery slope where the entire recreation budget could be cut from the general fund in the coming mean years. Now, I love the Whitmore pool, and I'm probably one of the last people here who wants it to close. But it is an aging facility, and it is 10 miles outside of town, so we do need to be planning for the future. This settlement's a 23-year deal, and that's a very long time.
1:36:13 Both the Parks and Recreation Master Plan and Rec Strats list short and long-term goals for recreation in this community, including a permanent year-round aquatic facility. Even the restructuring plan itself lists pursuing grant funding for recreation as a goal. But without being able to leverage those Measure R monies as I believe they were intended, those goals are going to be difficult, if not impossible, to achieve. And I don't think our residents or visitors are going to be willing to wait 23 years for needed recreation infrastructure.
1:36:42 In a time necessitating shared sacrifice, the operative word must be shared, and I'm going to come to some solutions. If I personally can find ways to use our recreation funding yet more efficiently, or if I need to become a volunteer swim instructor, I will. I actually sit with Sean on the recreation programming committee, and we have discussed increases to pool fees as part of our discussions, particularly for our seasonal passes that are used heavily by lap swimmers.
1:37:10 I can only speak for myself, but I know I'd be willing to pay a little more to make sure kids learn to swim in our community. That being said, it's certainly no reflection on the capable individuals or their performance, but in tough times, I do urge the council to look first to the top of the town's organizational chart to help balance our budget rather than starting with a seasonal facility and the people cutting the grass. As far as asking the county, I think we should certainly ask. I've heard the county commissioners say they understand the
1:37:39 Challenges Mammoth is facing, and, you know, they're, at least say they're willing to help, so it's definitely worth the question. Elizabeth, we're at three minutes there. Thank you. Thanks. So, quickly, it sounded like volunteer programs, increased pool fees, and over time, use Measure R perhaps to incorporate into a larger facility somewhere, maybe as we think of long-term programs like Sean was talking about. Yeah, my concern for Measure R is just planning in the long term. Okay, thank you very much.
1:38:13 Evening, Mayor, Members of the Council. My name is Kirk Stapp. I'm a resident citizen and a voter. And I'm going to try to read this because I'm probably getting in a lot of trouble. For the record, the single issue before the council this evening is should the council put before the voters a revenue tax measure. If the council chooses not to put before the voters a tax measure, the consequence will be first
1:38:44 Funding from measures A, T, 2002, A, R, and U will be permanently shifted to either programs outside the political commitments of previous councils or to the town's general fund to fund MLLA ballast settlement. And secondly, without a revenue tax measure, the town's municipal service levels will be drastically reduced. Public safety, parks and rec, housing, transit, marketing.
1:39:13 However you want to cut it, those programs will take hits. In the alternative, if the town chooses to put before the voters a revenue tax measure, the first question the public will ask is, will the political commitments of previous councils be restored? Without this council making a commitment to restore previous political commitments, the chances of passing a new revenue tax measure will be slim and none.
1:39:42 As a voter in Mammoth Lake, I would strongly urge a 3% lift tax to restore municipal services to residents and visitors, but only if the Council commits to restoring the funding previously committed to Measure A, T, 2002A, R, and U. The Council, I don't know if the public knows this, but I've read the Best, Best, and Krieger legal opinion. It sounds like you can use Measure R and U monies.
1:40:12 So we say to the backfield cuts. My support for a lift tax is predicated on the fact that Mammoth Mountain was initially sued by Hot Creek but negotiated or purchased a tolling agreement pending the outcome of the case against the town. It is my personal belief that Mammoth Mountain is partially responsible for the litigation and is ethically responsible for addressing part of this settlement.
1:40:40 As an aside, a 3% lift tax would cost a day skier the price of a half a beer up on the mountain, not exactly a detriment to skier visitation. Thank you for your time and consideration. Thank you, Kirk. Any questions? The council have any questions of Kirk? No. I think you were clear. Thank you. I do have one question of your town attorney. If we put on a vote that goes to the general fund,
1:41:12 The revenue is going to the general fund in April. Is that a two-thirds vote or a 50% vote because it's a general fund revenue source? You can adopt taxes in two ways. You can adopt what's called a general tax, which means it's not legally earmarked for anything, not restricted in any way, although you can have an advisory measure where the voters get to say, this is what we would kind of like if you'd use it for it. That kind of tax requires only majority approval.
1:41:37 On the other hand, if you're going to do a special tax where the funds are legally restricted and can only be used for the specific purposes that the voters approve, that's a special tax. That takes two-thirds approval. Thank you very much. Thank you, Kirk. David Page. I'd like to speak on the solutions front really briefly. I just want to touch on a couple things about the single-family rentals proposal.
1:42:11 I think as expected, it's been contentious already and I've read several very emotional letters this week. And I just want to start off by trying to allay some of the fears that I've seen in those letters. First of all, there's the contention that by legalizing single-family rentals in certain areas, it would ruin our neighborhoods. And I want to just first...
1:42:37 Lay out that as I understand it, the discussion so far has been to only allow this within certain resort corridors and not to put it out as a town-wide overlay. So I should have a big one, but as I understand it, the idea for the proposal is to go just within those neighborhoods that are already impacted by condominiums, by transient rentals of other sorts. So we're looking at
1:43:07 From the village up to Canyon and from Canyon over to Eagle. And I don't know, you probably can't see this, but we're talking about these very small neighborhood communities that are basically surrounded by resort zoning already or by multifamily residents which are allowed to rent on a transient basis. So it's not going to affect, as I understand, it wouldn't affect
1:43:36 It wouldn't affect the trails, it wouldn't affect the knolls, it wouldn't affect the neighborhoods that have high density full-time residents like Snowcrest, Pinecrest, behind the post office, Old Mammoth. And Jeff Weinhuff is going to speak to some specific numbers of what the inventory is in those areas. And we're talking about areas that, from the studies that we've looked at, have up to 70 to 80 percent vacancy.
1:44:05 So we're not talking about neighborhoods that are full of full-time residents. The other major fear that I'm seeing, and that I think that I'm hoping that we can work together to show how this is, that the fear is really groundless, and that is that by allowing this, it's going to dilute the market and a lot of our smaller motels and a lot of people who are renting condos are going to suffer.
1:44:34 We've been able to see in various different studies how a lot of the peer resorts that have approached this issue and changed their zoning, that in fact it hasn't had any impact at all on the existing lodging, that it's an entirely different product. We're talking about those families that are coming with 10, 13 people who are not going to be renting.
1:45:01 Six hotel rooms and they're not going to be renting two or three condos. If they can't find the houses that they want, they're going to go somewhere else. So I guess that's my three minutes already. That's it. Yeah, I just, I wanted to say that I did, I had a meeting with Cheryl Weatherill of the TOT Enforcement Committee and I think it was a very positive meeting and I think that we're going to present some numbers tonight, some hard numbers and I think that, and I really look forward to, I want to reiterate that I'm
1:45:29 Open to volunteering and working on whatever committee that we can put together to really look at how this can be realistically done. Okay, appreciate it. So you guys are going to continue conversations with that other group? Yes. Okay. I think that's valuable because I think just based on what I've seen from the emails coming out of it, everybody's learning quite a bit.
1:45:51 The falsism and truisms. Yeah, I feel like the next step is to really start to put stuff on the ground so that we can see, you know, these are the neighborhoods that will be impacted. These are the neighborhoods that won't be. How the enforcement strategies have worked in other towns, the real brass tats of it. Okay, thank you, Dave. Appreciate it. Hello, my name is Jeffrey Weinhuff. I'm a part-time resident at Mammoth. We've owned a home here for almost 10 years, and I've been a fan of Mammoth since I first started skiing here in 1970.
1:46:34 That just means I'm enthusiastic about the town and its prospects. But the reason I'm here today is because in my professional life, I've spent my life advising companies that are either growing or restructuring. And when I was here, when the town announced the bankruptcy proceeding, the first thing I did was realize that there was a lot of work to do that would engender some pain and it would also have to find some additional revenue going forward. So every time we look at a corporate situation,
1:47:03 That requires dramatic change. And this is something that has happened here. It's a completely different environment now than it was before. And it's time to really look carefully at how you cut deep, how you cut effectively, and then how you move forward to find revenue. And I don't want to make any comments today on how you guys have chosen to cut or will choose to cut going forward. That's not the basis of this discussion. But what I did do was look out into the ski community
1:47:32 And see if there was any guidance for the precedent of using single family overnight rentals to collect TOT successfully and whether or not that had a real negative impact on the communities. Because it's been done here in Mammoth for a number of years, although not officially. So what I'd like to do is take you through a quick presentation. I'll give this presentation to staff so that it can be included in the materials. But for the council today, basically the idea is to...
1:48:00 Get an idea of scope of what one could do by legalizing single-family rentals in town, either town-wide or in the limited resort corridor that David has just described. Now, since I wanted to look broadly at what the opportunities are, I'm going to show you two different opportunities that will be here and what they might look like. If you turn to the second page here, what I'd like to concentrate on here is that this is not a new precedent.
1:48:28 Aspen was actually the most recent town that put in place single family rentals and they did so more for a quality of life aspect and the ability to add more housing stock to the town than they did to make money. Their TOT rates are actually quite low. But if you look at the Colorado Association of Ski Towns, 95% of those towns both embrace and actively promote the use of single family rentals.
1:48:56 of overnight homes. And what I did was reach out and talk to the finance directors of seven of those ski towns. I actually made calls directly to those people, asked them whether they thought, and one of the obvious issues here is, is this competitive with other housing product in town? Does it compete with the hotels? Does it compete with the condos? And all I can tell you is the experience of five of the larger players in the finance departments in those areas said,
1:49:26 Everybody saw this as a completely different asset class. It was not relevant and not part of the real thing. So they had seen no impact on competitive products. You know, I'd ask, because you have a lot of information here. Yes. I'm wondering if, as you guys, well, it sounds like you've already done a lot of work. I have. Yeah. And a lot of valuable work, especially for an important topic.
1:49:54 I'm almost wondering if this isn't a whole meeting somewhere, I mean, where the public can show up to it versus, I mean, I feel like a lot of folks. I'm at your disposal. I would just, I would like you to turn, though, if we're going to do that to what I would consider a conclusion back on page, page nine. So,
1:50:17 You can look at all of the dollars that there are here, but I think the most important thing that I found when I studied Mammoth is that Mammoth has a lot of very interesting research that's on the town website. And in 2010, there was a report called the Mammoth Lakes Housing Element that was used to describe the housing stock in town and what it did and how it operated. And what we found in that case was that there, according to the town report, were a little over 9,000 homes available in the town.
1:50:47 And then of those, slightly more than 3,000 were used for primary residences where people actually lived there, which meant that you had 6,000 homes that were either vacant or being used for rentals. That means two-thirds of the entire housing stock of the town is not being used. Are you talking about condos too? Yeah. Condos, we have 105 plus condos.
1:51:10 Hold on. Just let me look at the numbers. This is the town report. We'll let the people at the podium speak. Thank you. So if one were to look at that, that means you've got about a two-thirds vacancy rate in terms of what happens in town system-wide. And if you look at the tourism department, there's about a 36% utilization of the available stuff that actually gets used. So if you look just at the resort corridor homes that...
1:51:38 It's in the area that are adjacent now to what David had described from the village up to Canyon, over to Eagle, out of the real neighborhood parts of the town. That's about 600 homes. It's a little over 600 homes. Okay. And on page 9, this just kind of lays out how the math would work on that. Okay. If you only use two-thirds of those homes, not all of them, but two-thirds of them. I'm sorry. If I let you go on, I'm going to let everybody do it. Okay. I apologize. 36% occupancy.
1:52:07 That's going to give you $3.5 million of incremental TOT. Happy to take up the rest of it at another time. There will be that opportunity, Jeff, and there are a couple of things that I want to note. One is many years ago, prior councils, planning commission staff, town staff, and in some instances members of the public participated in peer resort tours. In every tour that we took,
1:52:35 The issue of single family residential rentals was addressed as one of the things that we spoke with people including people in municipalities about. And what I'll tell you.
1:52:52 This is probably a $25,000 study if we were to have hired a consultant. At the discount rate. So I'm glad to have it for free because we have no money. But I'm very pleased to see this comparative analysis because, and I'm not taking a position. Sometimes when I make a statement about something, I see it next week in the paper as a position. This is not a position. This is a fact-gathering session.
1:53:22 But my point is this. There's a lot of either misinformation or no information out there. And what is so significant about what you have presented is data, real data from comparative resorts. And so I appreciate that because we can analyze that data, we can think about that data. And what this data doesn't tell us is something about the impact on the quality of life. That's one of the arguments. But we'll have that discussion as well. The second point is,
1:53:51 Whistler's not included in the study, I see, and Whistler does allow, and has always allowed, single-family residential rentals. Mike Vance, when he was here a dozen years ago, was a proponent of that. Third point, which I find actually very interesting, is that other than Aspen, which just two weeks ago passed an ordinance allowing single-family residences, virtually all of these peer resorts have a long history of that.
1:54:21 I'm really interested in looking at this data very carefully. Last point, I don't see any reason. If you're including all these neighborhoods, I would also include the neighborhood for at least an analysis south of Little Eagle, the Majestic Pines area south of Little Eagle, because I will tell you, I live in that neighborhood, and there's a whole lot of rental activity going on for people who want to be close to Chair 15. Sure. And therefore, it seems...
1:54:49 To me, and in particular, there are a lot of large homes in that area that could accommodate large groups of people. So, again, it's not a position. I'm just really happy to have the facts all in one place. I look forward to looking at this. I'm pleased that you're encouraged by this study. There is a lot of money available here. I think that there are two to three million dollars available in a limited availability. And the thing I think is particularly important is this is revenue that if you act quickly and come on the town's books,
1:55:18 Very quickly. You don't have to wait to come on. And if you act now, you'll be in line for the holiday season for ski bookings. And the revenue numbers that we put in here were based on a study that I did of people who had quietly rented homes in Mammoth. And I think they're very conservative. So I'd be happy to participate another time. Hold on, you guys. Let's not do that. We're going to go to the podium. Okay. Thank you. All right. Thank you. Thank you. All right. Hi. Good evening.
1:55:47 I'll keep this very brief. My name is Mike Braun. I'm a full-time resident and homeowner in the town. And I just have a quick comment and observation and then a question for you. You know, I notice that the police department is the number one thing on the cutting board here, so to speak. And I'm kind of shocked that in a town like this where we thrive on tourism, I would think public safety would be the number one concern. I know it's a touchy subject. There's a lot that's going into this, but I just wanted to view my feelings.
1:56:17 Secondly, I mean no disrespect to anyone in the room by this, and this is more out of curiosity than driven by anger or frustration. I think some other people have the same feeling and danced around the question, and I'll just ask it, why does a town this small have a manager and assistant manager where we pay a ton of money? In my feeling, Mr. Wilbrack could handle this town more than adequately, and there's a huge resource of money, and I do not mean this disrespectfully at all. I'm sorry, it's more of a business question.
1:56:47 But that's my question to you and anybody who would like to answer it. Thank you. I'll go ahead and address it right now. So at this time, Dave is the town manager. We don't have two town managers. We have a town manager and we have Marianna who's an administrative assistant. And what the jobs they're handling right now... I think she just got a demotion. Sorry. Administrative assistant town manager.
1:57:16 And so what's happening right now, Marianna is not only helping with this restructuring process, all this was done, okay, Marianna, Dave did this stuff, but she's also handling the finance part. We don't have a finance director anymore, okay? Dave, we don't have a community development director either. Dave is handling that piece as well. If we were to rehire somebody with the benefits and the salary, we'd almost be back to where we're at with her now.
1:57:45 Now, could that change in the future? Yeah, it could. Right now, we need somebody. We have very good quality management to help us get through this process. Okay, thank you. I've got a point that I wanted to make. It might be timely at this point, and that is I heard from a number of people throughout town that we should look to Pismo Beach as an example of or what we would pay a town manager, and in particular the
1:58:13 The rumor, if you will, or the talk is that the cost of Pismo Beach of their town manager is $160,000. And so I asked our staff to do a little research and just as a point of information because I think that it's important. I don't know whether Pismo Beach is exactly comparable to Mammoth. Certainly it isn't as far as the weather is concerned, but it is a tourist town and small.
1:58:38 The public information there shows that the town manager has a base salary of $165,000 with a total cost including benefits of $245,000. I just point that out because I know a lot of people are talking about that as a comparative example of what we should be paying. And your comments, I've heard a lot of them, and they don't fall on deaf ears. It's something we do have to address longer term.
1:59:05 And as we restructure, we have to look and see how is it that we want our government to look. Do we want to keep the structure we have now? Do we want to go back to department heads or not? As of right now, this is the structure we're looking at. It could change, and we're certainly having the same conversations with our town managers that we're having with other departments. Thank you. Yeah. Hi, my name is Erin Kittle-Lafrancois. I've been a committee member of Monon County Mammoth since 1976.
1:59:39 And actually I learned how to swim in Whitmore Pool. I see Whitmore Pool, I see swimming, I'm sorry, as a life skill. And if you have community members who can't afford to go to Snow Creek Athletic Club, which is the only other place that offers swim lessons in Mammoth or Monon County, to my knowledge, at least South County, then you're denying so many community members a life skill. There's a couple of points I'd like to make before I, my own three children,
2:00:09 I'll go to bed at 7 o'clock on a school night, or else I would have brought them with me. But they've each written you a letter, and I'd like to somehow submit that, because they don't have an email address. They're only 6, 7, and 9. I think your cut should be shared across all the departments equally, and as well as not just cutting the lowest members of your staff, but also administration levels. When your tax measures were passed, and I'm referring to RU, all of the ones, I don't remember all the letters.
2:00:38 Town of Mammoth Lakes was not facing the massive settlement that we are today. And the Town of Mammoth Lakes should not be building new facilities if we can't even maintain what we currently have. If we have to supplant funding for existing facilities and our programs, then that's what we should be doing. And my husband and I personally, if we had to pay more for current programs, we would be interested in doing that. My three children, basically, I'm just going to summarize their letters.
2:01:06 You know, Madeline's only in first grade, so there's spelling errors. I'll bet you're going to correct me. Especially if she couldn't spell the breaststroke. Yes, I could spell that. I could correct him. But I didn't want to. She says she loves to swim, and please do not take the pool. She doesn't want it to close because she loves the breaststroke. Please don't close with my pool because I love, love, love, love swimming. That's from Madeline. She's six. Quentin says I love swimming. I don't want my career to end.
2:01:36 I've only been on the team a few years. I'm only seven. Please don't close the pool. And then my oldest is Aiden. He's nine. Hi, my name is Aiden. I'm nine. I love the swim team. I don't want to end my career. So please don't close the pool. I really love swimming. My favorite stroke is the breast stroke. I have almost earned a junior Olympic time in that stroke. I want to swim for my swim team, not in Bishop. I just like swimming for my home team.
2:02:04 So if there's any way that you could submit these, because I saw in the minutes that you had copies of letters. Can I get these? Absolutely, yeah. And then the other thing I wanted to say, I've been teaching at the high school for the last 15 years, and of the last nine valedictorians, seven were on the swim team. And I'd just like to echo that or reiterate the fact that there's a lot to be said about athletics, being an athlete myself.
2:02:32 You learn how to win and lose. You learn how to practice. You learn how to struggle through injuries. And that's a life skill that is hard to teach in the classroom. I know that just beeped. So my time's up. But I think that there's so many more things to be doing for kids these days and that athletics is one of them that's being cut at the school a lot. And it would be great if the town continued supporting what they already have, not cut it. Thank you. Thank you, Erin. Any questions from council? Council members, my name is Donna.
2:03:07 And I would like to talk about Mammoth Lakes Housing and how it has benefited me and the community. I noticed that your proposed cuts are $164,000 for the year 2013 and $329,000 for the year 2013-14. That's a lot of money for an organization that has helped hundreds of people here in town, including myself, and hundreds of families.
2:03:37 That's a lot of money. I wish a lot of people would come up and speak for Mammoth Lakes Housing and how they have benefited from it because I personally have, and let me tell you the ways that it has benefited me. When I sold my property, it was a high market in Mammoth. I didn't get much money for my place because I bought in a high market also. My home was very high maintenance and I ended up getting divorced to where I needed a place that I could handle.
2:04:11 To where it was lower maintenance, and the only option at that point was to buy through Mammoth Lakes Housing. I looked for several months, and I'm telling you, the money that I had, the down payment that I had to put on my place, the places were just absolutely broken down and very bad shape. Mammoth Lakes Housing was brought to my attention, and I went and I talked to Pam and Jennifer.
2:04:36 And in the long run, it worked for me. They gave me a second down payment, and I was able to afford to live here. It has benefited my son. It has benefited me. I can't even think of what would happen if I wasn't able to keep my son in school here and make it stable. If I had to move him from his friends and out of town, I don't know where his life would be right now. He has now graduated from high school. He is off to college, and it is a good result.
2:05:05 I can't imagine if it was any different if I had to move out of town and we had to get new friendships and build new relationships. Mammoth Lakes Housing offered this opportunity to me. And I'm sure it has offered opportunities for many people in town here. One is also a benefit. It is a benefit for employers here in town. When people have lower mortgage rates, the employers can hire people at a lower wage.
2:05:33 If you have a higher mortgage rate, employers have to pay a higher pay for their employees. So in the long run, it benefits everybody here in town. It benefits the people, it benefits families, it benefits employees. So I just want to kind of put that out there forward to you and try to make the organization work. I know you're in a tough position, you have a lot of cuts, but I'm just telling you, it's...
2:06:01 It'll work. It'll work. And I know you guys will do a good job of deciding what the end result is. Okay? That's it. Thank you. Thank you, Your Honor. Thank you. Mayor, if I may correct the misstatement by the Speaker, currently no cuts are proposed to Mammoth Lakes Housing, and the numbers that were mentioned, 164 and 329, is the total amount of the contract. So cuts to housing, along with taxes and everything else, are options, but they're not in the plan.
2:06:31 Correct. Thank you for addressing that, Marianna. My name is Brian Martino. I'm a resident of Mammoth. I've talked before. The council has a lot of emails, a lot of letters from various residents regarding nightly rentals of single-family homes. I think you've probably seen the website by the opposing party, which I represent as well, against single-family nightly rentals. And I think the – so I'm not going to go into a lot of detail, but I think the issue is obviously revenue. However,
2:07:00 While I haven't seen the study that he presented tonight, I find it very hard to believe you're going to talk about $2 to $3 million of additional revenue. First of all, I don't think the people that are illegally renting their homes are all of a sudden going to now sign up with a management company or send in the reports or get their permits or whatever. I've also did a little bit of study and called other cities, including Park City, which was in the original website said, allowed single-family rentals in single-family zones, and it does not.
2:07:29 There's only one specific area that allows it. The rest of the areas are definitely not allowed. Big Bear allows it, but they have a lot more single-family homes, and they have condos. It's not like Mammoth. They have three people that are there for enforcement 24-7. You can call it any time at night. One of them will come out if there's a problem. We wouldn't have that here. I live next door to someone that's been illegally renting, and believe me, it does affect the quality of life. You have people coming in at 12 o'clock.
2:07:58 Ten people, you have three different cars, they come away, three days later you get three more cars. So if the council is looking for a revenue source, I think it's better for a tax, whether it's a 3% tax, whether it's a sales tax, whether it's a parcel tax, something like that's going to give you a certain amount of revenue. Changing the zoning to allow nightly rentals on the chance that you might get additional revenue, I think is a disservice to the residents.
2:08:24 That live here permanently. I think it changes the quality of life. And based upon one of the cases that was on the earlier website, once you do it, you may not be able to undo it. Because at least the case in Florida determined that once you're allowed to do it and you get revenue, when the town then changes the zoning to prevent you from doing that, that's considered a taking, at least under Florida law. How it be in California, I don't know. But do we really want to open up to that problem again?
2:08:52 So it's a quality of life issue, and the town simply for a short sighted to get some additional revenue that it might get, which I don't believe it will, and while I, again, I haven't seen the study, there's already resort corridor allow single family homes. Those aren't fully rented consistently. Why add, why do you think you add more residences to that pool, you'll all of a sudden get more people renting them?
2:09:17 It doesn't make sense. I don't see any evidence of that. So I'd ask the council to move very carefully. And I think it's a general plan amendment. So whether you can just do it by an ordinance or not, I'm not certain that's true. Greg, if I can, a couple of comments that I have heard from very longstanding residents here just this last week. I don't know whether you can address this or not, but...
2:09:41 It seems that the discussion both publicly and also in the emails and communication that we're getting is focused on revenue versus quality of life. But nobody seems to be talking about the customer, our customer. And the question that I have is, do you think that there is a segment, can you imagine that there's a segment of the visiting community that would not rent a condo?
2:10:08 Or a hotel room for a large group if they had the option, well, I guess putting it differently, do you think that there's a segment of the market out there that simply doesn't want to be an existing product and therefore is looking for another product? Well, you change the question. Is there a group out there that would rather rent a single family home than a condo or a hotel room? I'd say yes.
2:10:35 But you already have those available in the resort quarter areas. You've got the Timbers. You've got Stonegate. You've got others. Those aren't fully rented. So I don't see that there's any evidence that shows that there's market that these people want to rent single-family homes, but they can't find them here, so they're going elsewhere. But those aren't single-family residences. Those are condominiums or attached residences. The difference between an attached home, if you're asking that question, I'd say no.
2:11:03 I don't think there's any reason why you'd want a single-family attached home versus a Timbers house, which is just as nice, or a Stonegate house, just as nice. Well, I ask the question only because it seems to me that the debate needs to include discussion about whether or not we are reaching out or offering a product to all segments of the visiting... Well, I would think that tourism...
2:11:26 The department could say, do they get calls where people are saying, oh my gosh, I can't find a single family home to rent. I have never seen any evidence of that, either from the staff, from the resort communities, from the lodging association, whatever. So I don't think there's any evidence that that's the case. Thank you. Thanks, Greg. Greg, you're working with the other group as well, right? Correct. Okay. And are you going to come up with some of these studies too? I'm assuming you guys are working on a lot of that. Well, we're talking about getting locations, et cetera, yes. Okay. Thanks, Greg.
2:12:00 Good evening. Cheryl Witherell. I'm here tonight to talk about the subject of single-family homes, and I'm going to try to avoid some of the conversation that we just had with Greg. But I'm encouraging you to give the direction to staff to create a focus group made up of our community to look at all sides of this issue. I'm going to back up a little bit to some of the conversation earlier from Mr. Page and Mr. Weintraff that I just do not think this is something we want to do quickly.
2:12:29 I believe this is a general plan change, not simply a zoning issue. There just are far too many unanswered questions right now, I believe. Too much data being thrown around. I don't think we have the answers to the questions. I'm in a research stage, really, in this issue. I spent many hours over the last couple weeks meeting with people on both sides, trying to get input so that I can understand it fully. I've been in Mammoth for 10 years.
2:12:55 We've heard from the Mammoth Vacation Home Rental. They have a website that has a lot of information. Just a week ago, Mammoth Neighborhoods website was created, and this is a website really supporting the protection of our neighborhoods, which has reached 156, I think it was at 160 signatures in just one week, of people very against single-family home rentals. Various reasons. Many of the letters that are included in the packet today share a lot of those reasons, some of them very well written.
2:13:25 I brought some cards today for those of you in the audience that don't know about this website that has the link of how to find out and research this on your own. As stated, some questions are unanswered and I think essential to this topic. What is our inventory? We don't know. Of that inventory, how many are homes? How many are legal homes? Of those that are legal, how many have business licenses? What's the occupancy of those homes?
2:13:53 What truly would be a guess is the TOT displacement versus new TOT that could be collected. Really, my list goes on. I've not seen this data report. If there's an extra copy, I'd love to take one with me. And my thoughts really after a lot of research, and I will continue my communications with David. I've met with Planning Commission asking some questions. The town staff has been very helpful answering some of my questions.
2:14:19 But I just don't think this is a change to make in Mammoth Lakes now when our occupancy rate is less than 40% annual. I don't believe that there is a way to pick and choose areas that can be opened up without having a battle from others that are not going to be included. I think there's illegal renting going on all over Mammoth Lakes. I do not believe that anyone who bought a home in a non-zoned area that has a mortgage commitment
2:14:49 We'll take this lightly. Regardless of where you buy a home, it's a neighborhood, whether it's Canyon, whether it's the Knolls. I believe we don't have the enforcement capabilities now to open this up at any level, especially when we're looking at cutting staff, police, etc. I don't envy your decision. I'm at my three minutes. Quickly is not the way to handle this, but I'm willing to participate. I'm willing to continue my research.
2:15:16 And willing to serve on any type of committee that you allow to happen on the subject to do this the right way. Okay. Thank you, Cheryl. Are there any comments or questions from staff? Cheryl, would it be helpful, since this is going to be a big topic and there's a lot of research and whatnot needed, I mean, would it be helpful, what are you looking for in a focus group if we were to do one? Would it be something if we made Suite Z available that you guys could come in here and work with that other group on?
2:15:46 Are you looking for a facilitator? You know, I think that's a question. I think it's a question maybe even for the Planning Commission as far as what work they have. I think there has to be direction of what you want to see out of the committee, or I think it's going to be a back and forth. That's what I'm concerned about. And it could be a long conversation. The Mammoth Neighborhood Group has met a condo complex recreation area. You know, I think there's places we can meet.
2:16:13 But I think we need a general scope of what needs to come out of this. I think that we've got to have some of these questions answered. Maybe some of them are in this report. But I think with direction from planning, possibly with staff, really what the questions are. Well, what I'm wondering is maybe instead of going through this, if we ask each group to bring forward their best effort is why they think it should.
2:16:39 Go forward. Well, I'll tell you what I'm concerned, and I think Cheryl raises a good point. You know, we're in, in all of these things, we're in a fact finding and, you know, opinion soliciting stage. And this is something, because it's not a new concept, there are facts out there. We just don't know what they are. And you can argue, it's very difficult to quantify.
2:17:08 The quality of life issues. You either know them or you don't or you can feel them or you can't. But you can quantify from other resorts that keep this data that have been doing it for a long time. And I just have got to believe that the solution in bringing these facts forward is to have both sides on this issue trust the facts that are being put forth by each side.
2:17:33 And it seems to me that if we get there, we're going to be able to have, you know, that will frame the debate and we'll be able to have a debate about what we ought to be doing because either way, I mean, there are views. We've seen them on both sides and this is not new and it's just that it's now come to the fore. So my view is that if you simply have two competing sides presenting, making a presentation, it's going to be very, very difficult for us because we certainly can't.
2:18:00 Corroborate or determine the validity of the studies that have been done. We need, I would love to see a group come together and they're either going to agree or disagree or agree to disagree. But if they're working with the same fact base, that would be helpful to me. So would it be fair then to have these two groups get together and do just that, have a fact-finding session? I think that's a start if they're willing to talk to one another. Yeah, and I think there's a second part of that. If I remember what Ellen said earlier correctly, the planning commission is planning,
2:18:30 Part of the workshop on November 7th would be a general discussion because putting my planning commissioner hat back on, I agree that it's probably a general plan amendment, which means it would go through the planning commission and all of that first. I'm really listening to what Cheryl is saying here about it may be possible, you're right, Rick, it's been out there for years, it's been debated before, but I don't think it's a short-term solution. It's nothing we would do quickly.
2:18:58 And I would almost want to see what the Planning Commission has to say and then send it through them to work on it as time is available for a while and not consider it something that's going to help us with our plan in the short term. Because it's going to, we're going to lose focus on making the decisions that we have to make. Maybe I could suggest that both groups put together maybe their top five points, maybe their top five questions, and getting that to planning to help.
2:19:27 Create a scope work. Maybe there's one person from each side that would be willing to work along with planning to help create a scope and what they wanted to get out of the committee. But I agree. I just don't think it could be a quick decision. Okay. Thank you, Cheryl. Just to remind everyone, we only have six weeks to get this all finalized this time. Well, we got to the seventh before we're deliberating. Right. Two weeks? Yeah.
2:19:56 I mean, staff is very willing to sit down and meet with both sides, I think, to have that discussion, initiate. You know, I know Cheryl mentioned her list of questions. We're more than happy also to contribute some research and maybe more of a neutral position in terms of weighing the facts from both sides. Okay. All right. That sounds great. If you could reach out to them or if you folks could get a hold of them.
2:20:25 Ellen, while you're here, would you like to take my copy and you can make copies for people and then just put one back in my box? That way some of the people who've asked for it can request one. One other question to David. Is this on a website? Is this on your guys' website? Thank you. Sandy Hogan, and I want to start off speaking as the president of the Mammoth Knowles Homeowners Association, and I want to call attention to how wonderful this effort has been.
2:20:56 I know that our members have been so excited. This is the TOT collection, the task force that's been going on. I know there's a lot of the property managers working with town staff, and it's been a huge effort, and it's really paying some dividends right now. And I think it is very definitely proof that we can do something right. My big fear, and I think I can speak for my board as well as myself, is that expanding this willy-nilly, when you still haven't gotten this down,
2:21:25 Totally and completely would be a mistake, especially at a time when I hear that some of the staff that's really making this a success could be either assigned to another department or have additional work to them. And I don't know that, but I have heard that. So my advice, I think, from our board would be continue with this effort. Do not dilute it. Whatever you do, tonight on the agenda, for those that maybe didn't see the consent agenda,
2:21:53 I think item four was it's a subpoena from the town council to one of our illegal renters before it was illegal. They're trying to make this person legal and they're going through the process, which is a very difficult process. They did the appeal, the owners did the appeal, but they would not produce documents. And so now the council has to subpoena them.
2:22:19 To produce the documents, to come before, so in other words, it's an evolving process. It is not completed yet. It's not perfected. I think once it is, it could be one of those that might be outsourced later or considered in year second, in other words, after the new year. But I do think that we really want to talk about, in other words, this is very important. So keep it going. All right, but before, okay. I wanted to just speak.
2:22:49 Just personally, okay, now, not for my association or anything, just a moment. Anyway, the second thing is... You just cut the line, Ken. Sandy, I have a quick question of you. I'm not finished, actually. Yeah, let's let Sandy finish. Okay, I learned a lot of things. I personally...
2:23:20 From just what I've learned this week, I do not believe that you would be creating new customers. I think you'd be just shifting. And that's doing our condo owners and property managers a real disservice. Because there's a limited property base. I just think I heard 40% is the average occupancy. If we've got that going, throwing more product on the market is not good business for our condo owners. Those condo owners right now...
2:23:48 If they're trying to refinance or if they're trying to sell, they have to get financing. Okay. And they're looked at very carefully at occupancy. Sandy, quick question. So others can speak on that a lot better than I can, but there's a whole bunch of points that I think need to be brought up. I'm very pleased to hear that actually we're looking at putting together a group to really research this because this isn't something you want to hurry through. Sandy, real quick, question.
2:24:15 Can you, as the president of the Knowles Homeowners Association, can you clarify for me, or do you know or not, if the Knowles Homeowners Association does have existing CC&Rs against, that prohibit it? Yes, exactly. And I think, and actually Greg would tell you that the renter next to him, he has tried to put in some requests.
2:24:44 Entirely true. The CC&Rs prevent, our CC&Rs, which are very old, prevent operation of a business, boarding house, lodging, etc. So it doesn't specifically say or prohibit nightly rentals of single family homes. We've got a couple of attorneys here. Part of my position is that if you rent it consistently on a single nightly basis and getting paying transit occupancy tax, that's a business, so it's prohibited.
2:25:11 If you get a business license, which would be required, then by definition isn't it a business? It should be. But again, that would be under the umbrage of business as opposed to does not specifically prohibit nightly rentals. But it's not a commercial zone either, right? Correct. No, it's not a business. So kind of my point is if it is as we think it is, then at least for that particular neighborhood,
2:25:39 Rentals of single-family homes would not be allowed. Ideally, if the ordinance stayed in place, that's true. But enforcement of CC&Rs is a pretty tough thing. You know, enforcement of an ordinance, it seems to be a pretty tough thing because Greg, as a matter of fact, has called many times to report that person next to him. And at this point, it sounds like there's a log jam. You know, and so that's one reason why I'm saying, let's finish this effort. Let's keep it going. Get it up polished and go through the whole process when they come to you guys.
2:26:06 You know, because that's the next step after their appeal. They're going to appeal to the council and collect that money. That'll be your job. Thank you. Don't let them walk. 30 seconds. I've been a member of the board of directors on Mammoth Knolls for 33 years. Can you set your name for the record, please, sir? My name is Kenny Colter, and I've been in town and in real estate and a whole bunch of other businesses for 33 years.
2:26:37 And the only thing I would like to tell you is that prior to incorporation, some of us had to go to the, and John, you will remember this, we had to go to the County Board of Supervisors to get the buses, the reconstruction of houses to eight bedrooms and ski clubs coming into the Knolls, and that's how this code got into, or yeah, the code got into
2:27:06 And it took us a long time to do it, but I don't want to see that happen again. And it could, because cheaters are cheaters. Thank you. Thank you. Sorry about that, Terry. Terry, was that okay? Yeah, you did fine, yeah, thanks. Terry Stelick, here as a citizen, and actually I'd like to maybe speak as a commissioner as well, but start as a citizen.
2:27:36 I'd like to see two task force put together. You know, sometimes we can study things to death. But, you know, we have, as a community, kind of just swallowed what's been given to us is that this is what needs to be cut and this is what needs to be restructured. And, you know what, I don't think there's been enough information that's been given to us that we can actually take that as an informed decision that this is truly the restructuring process and the items that need to be cut. And so I would love to have, we've had this committee before, none of their,
2:28:06 Information or none of their suggestions were taken, but I would really like to see that move forward. You know, what are the goals? What are the level of services that we're trying to provide within those service areas? What are the top priorities? And what can we contract out, if anything? And this goes for the general fund that goes for the pool, and my comments come for the pool too. What are our cost recovery? We need a cost recovery. What's the cost recovery for our police sitting up there at the village?
2:28:35 Is there an opportunity to charge for their services out there? This isn't popular within the recreation and it didn't go over well the other night, but what is the cost recovery for the pool? The pool's open 13 and a half hours a day. Once the school is, once it's open permanently for everybody, it's occupied eight hours a day for swim team and lap swim.
2:29:00 And so, you know, should they pay higher fees? The pool swim team paid $1,800 last year. Unlimited lap swim pass was $100. It's being raised to $125. But is that satisfactory? I don't know. I don't know what the charges are for the Whitmore fields. So I would love to, as a commissioner, sit with coaches, staff. You know, what can we do with this department to try to gain some income?
2:29:28 to offset some of these expenses to maybe save the facilities from being cut or completely consuming measure R. So that's one part. Where's the $500,000 that was budgeted already? Where'd that go? So Bill Taylor wrote that in a letter to the sheet, and I think that's a really good question. Where did that $500,000 go?
2:29:52 What's the true timeline? It's my understanding that you have $2.5 million through vehicle replacement funds. And so if we have that to pay off the initial debt when we sign all this off come December, then doesn't that give us a little bit more time instead of trying to rush into something and make rash decisions that could affect our entire community for a very long time to come? In reading the suggestions on how to increase revenues, I found it interesting on
2:30:22 How they were presented, especially the one about enhancing collection of TOT revenues through single premium rentals. I would argue that this can be accomplished in a three to four month period that, or it'll be an enhancement of TOTs because I seriously feel that it'll just be a displacement of fees. The discussion is obviously not going away, so instead of leading questions on a survey, I would like this task force to be put together.
2:30:52 I have one more point that I would really like to make if I could. We need to take all factors into consideration, including the future. I just learned this new wording. Pipeline projects. You have 14 pipeline projects in total. Residential units account for 1,346 new coming up sometime in the future. 24 of those are homes that are from the Altus program that just came before the council.
2:31:21 And it will be able to be rented. Hotel units total 1,675. These have already been improved and waiting, I would assume, for the economy to improve before something comes forward. If the demand is so large for homes, then maybe some of these projects should be built as homes as opposed to condos. Thank you, Terry. My time is up. Yeah, thank you.
2:31:50 On the $500,000, I wanted to ask Mariana to address that because I think she did a good job of addressing it in Bill's letter when she responded to him. So if you could, it was referring, I think, to the $500,000 that was initially budgeted. That's correct. And I actually provided quite a long response in both the frequently asked questions and the actual documents, the agenda report for tonight. It's on the first four pages or so.
2:32:16 But in general, without going into all the detail, and I would be happy to talk to you once you take a look at the detailed response, the $500,000 per FTI model was an average annual surplus. Once you take into the account the surplus from last fiscal year, which they projected to be over a million dollars, and that's what we think we will have.
2:32:39 But then for the next few years, the actual annual surpluses were lower, because once you take into account that large surplus, then it was lower, and then it grew to something like 500,000. So it was an average amount, and it's in our numbers. Secondly, what we also include in our numbers is a little bit of a buildup of the vehicle, of the reserve, of the general fund reserve, which is something that we absolutely need to do.
2:33:09 FTI took into consideration is you made a call, and I'm going to get to your second question, but it's related. You made a call that a few months ago we took a loan from the vehicle fund of about $4 million. We spent $3 million of that on attorney fees, and we spent about $1 million to cover negatives in the development impact fee funds. So that $4 million now is being repaid back to the general fund.
2:33:37 Or he paid back to the vehicle fund. FTI assumed that that repayment will not take place, that that $4 million will stay in the general fund as cash. We decided to reverse that decision and pay the vehicle fund back so in 11 years you'll have that $4 million in that fund. So that's kind of somewhat of a lengthy response, but the response in the report is even more detailed with tables. Your second question, if I may, Mayor, is
2:34:05 On taking a loan, yet an additional loan from the vehicle fund to pay the first installment of $2.5 million, after we took a loan of $4 million that I just referenced, which was unrestricted money, the only money that we have left now in the vehicle fund is restricted gas stock money. We cannot take a loan against that money. It's against the law. So we frankly don't have too much unrestricted cash to play with.
2:34:33 Yeah, your vehicle replacement fund, boy, wouldn't it be nice that we did that for all our facilities because just for the Whitmore facility alone, it's over $27,000 in one year that goes to that vehicle replacement fund and maintenance fund. I absolutely agree. And just on that note, if I may very quickly, I think what this underscores in this discussion and the questions is that
2:34:55 We are insufficient in setting aside money. Not only we don't have a general fund reserve, but we don't have a reserve for deferred maintenance. We don't have a reserve for IT. We only have a reserve for vehicles. That's the only reserve that we have, unfortunately. And I think you make a really good point there, Terry, because it's something that I've seen since I've been on council. I want to express this to the community. You know, we build things over time. We want things, and we end up building them.
2:35:25 And we've been finding money or we find a location to build them, but what we don't ever build in, or rarely, and Measure R is a rare example, as is you, we don't build in the depreciation, we don't build in the sinking fund, we don't build in all these things, at least not adequately. And that's a problem. And even if our population has grown,
2:35:45 Police, for example. As populations grow, we need more police. It's not growing as fast as the need or the expense for that particular department or any other department is growing. So, like Measure R, when we want something, we have to have that vehicle in place to take care of it from the day we build it to the day it's gone. And I think that's just the new way of thinking. We're going to have to do with everything. And if this tax comes forward...
2:36:11 I think a lot of that has to start going to build in and replace a lot of these things, whether it be the pool or whatever, we need to build those mechanisms in place because they haven't been there for a long time, decades. And so, you know, that kind of comes to, you know, this part that I'm just going to go ahead and say it. Remember, we wanted to be a resort community, not just a resort.
2:36:33 And we all want to keep a quality of life. Let's look at long-term solutions, not just what's going to happen and help us out today. And so I would be okay with a parcel tax, whatever tax that would have to come forward to help us out. If you look at $100 in the scheme of things, that's not a whole lot of money for us to keep our town whole so this community isn't fitted against each other as to who needs to be cut and what needs to be cut.
2:37:02 Terry, as a Recreation Commissioner, what do you think about the use of Measure R to make up the $185,000 that the pool lose? As Sean said, I think that the amount of money that you're asking for is pretty minimal in the scheme of things. I would be okay with it as a loan. And I truly feel that we need to look. I mean, if I looked at the Whitmore budget for...
2:37:32 A few minutes and kind of started shotgunning questions to Stuart and, you know, didn't get a lot of questions answered. There's, I got some answered but ran out of time. So, you know, there's a lot of efficiencies that I think that we can do and, you know, your programs, I'm sorry, but your programs are, there's no staff or there's no facility that's built into those program costs.
2:37:56 And so what is the council, you know, willing to subsidize? What is a reasonable subsidized amount for each of those programs for them to happen? You know, so I think that we need to look at all of those things and see if there's any efficiencies that we can actually kind of, you know, we all have to step up and pay for what we're going to use. And can they, will we ever be able to completely pay for a pool? No. I mean, that's unrealistic. Could we a program? Quite possibly.
2:38:24 And so, you know, does that save us, you know, some money in that? You know, maybe then we'll have to have sponsorships. I don't know. I don't even know if we're still going to have any money coming for the youth sports program. Maybe we can look at more sponsorships through the youth sports program if we have to raise fees for some of these, you know. So I think there's opportunity out there. You know, we can adopt a park. I mean, there's opportunities out there. And as a commission, I think our commission would be willing to sit down and go through.
2:38:54 The recreation budget. And maybe that's how instead of having a whole task board, maybe we take small areas and we look at, you know, are there some efficiencies that we can look at and agree to within each area? And we're going to look at that in phase two of what we're doing in this process too. So that will happen next, after December 5th. Matthew, can I make a comment? It relates to Terry's and to other people. Yes, the three minutes makes it short, but please send your comments in to us if you didn't get a chance to get through them all the way.
2:39:24 Yeah, thank you, Joe. To what Terry's saying, I wanted to bring up this to Council before I forget. So I'd spoken with Dave a little bit about this committee and maybe getting a committee together, and Dave references a blue ribbon committee where we can get a lot of these ideas together and sit down and maybe we sit down for half a day for two or three days and really try to crunch through this just to get some additional feedback from people. And I really wanted to talk to Council about it.
2:39:54 It's kind of a two-way to sort. I think it can help, but it can hurt as well. And I wanted to see what you guys thought about. Are you talking about something that happens within the next six weeks or something that happens within Phase 2? Before we make a decision. My feeling is, and as you can see tonight and by the letters and things we've gotten, is our community is not shy about giving out their opinions. And I think that we get to a point where we've got to make the tough decisions.
2:40:20 It's going to take us the next six weeks to work through with additional input in these meetings. And I think that's the way to handle it because it is really our responsibility to figure it out. And that's why I haven't said much is I'm still in the listening mode. But I think that at the next meeting we have to start being in the deliberation mode. Okay. Do the other council members feel the same way? I'm with Joe unless I hear otherwise. I am as well. Yeah. I agree. Okay. Now that doesn't mean that in phase two we're not going to be looking for help. Yeah.
2:40:50 Okay. And I did. Well, we're getting the help tonight. Yes. Yeah, I think we're getting a lot of it. I think the emails, too, that's, you know, some thoughts, some thinking that I didn't expect. I've seen definitely come forward in the last three weeks, so there's no doubt. I'm hearing things I didn't expect to hear, so let's go ahead and carry on. Thank you. Good evening. I'm Chris Powell. I'm the Athletic Director at Mammoth High School, so I'm here to speak on behalf of Mammoth Unifying. First, I'd like to thank the generous
2:41:22 I thank the private citizens of Mammoth Lakes for propping up our athletics department for the last year or so. I know that's been a huge burden in fundraising and such. I want to speak to what the closure of Whitmore will mean to the district. Obviously, we play our softball and baseball down there. If we close it in January, it will be no baseball and softball this year.
2:41:49 We cannot afford to, one, pay for it, and two, we can't afford to drive down to Bishop to practice every day and such. And, you know, it's an hour and a half drive down there. We would have to pay the park down there. We would end up getting an hour of practice before the sunset. So it would be the end of baseball and softball for this year.
2:42:19 Another crushing blow to high school athletics that has continued for the last year and a half here in town and in the state and in the country as state budgets cut education funding and things like that and athletics is always a first go. So I just plead for that small money to keep those fields open as we share facilities and I'm grateful for that. Thank you. Thank you, Chris. Appreciate it. Any other comments or questions?
2:42:49 Okay. I'm Mel Cedar, and I'm a resident of Mammoth Lakes, even though I speak with a Kiwi accent. I have a daughter here, 10 years old, and I'm not here to do the bleeding heart parent, my kid loves swimming story. I wanted to thank council and the people on the recreation committee.
2:43:11 Staff for the quick response and the positive response to the email that I sent. And I was really pleased to see that on handwritten page 20, some of the suggestions for finding grants and sponsorships to keep our recreational facilities open being one of those areas that you're willing to explore. So I'm here tonight to say thank you. I'm here to say at this point we need to pull together as a community. I heard Matt saying that
2:43:39 Everybody's looking at us to see how we handle and how we rise from the situation. And this is our opportunity to shine as a community and as a town and to make the right decisions and put our community first. So again, I'd like to say thank you. Thank you very much. Couldn't have said that better. Thank you for that comment about pulling together. Good evening, council and members of the community. My name is Marvin Oreck. I'm the current manager of a majority of the low-income housing in Mammoth.
2:44:11 Specifically, Aspen Village, the Jefferies, Manzanita, and also Brissacone Apartments. I came here in 2002 and initially was just managing Brissacone Apartments. I immediately saw the need for more low-income housing. I had no idea that the town of Mammoth Lakes was entertaining the possibility of opening some more sites. I was quite pleased when they did. So Mammoth Lakes Housing has been an integral part in
2:44:40 Getting our low-income housing together here in Mammoth. A couple quick stories. I've had people come to me and just literally cry on my shoulder when they were able to obtain low-income housing. Not just getting low-income housing, but quality housing. We take very good care of our apartments, and people are quite pleased. The majority of the people here have homes. For those of us who are renters, low-income housing is very much needed.
2:45:09 There is still a need for more low-income housing, not only specifically one and four-bedroom units. All of our units are two and three-bedroom units. Now as a member of the community, I've been listening to all the comments back and forth for the last month or so. I apologize for my ignorance in this respect, but a lot of things have come to light just this evening. First of all, I want to let you know that I will put you in my prayers.
2:45:38 I envy your situation. It's got to be tough. I'd like to know where Mammoth Mountain is in all this. Is there a representative here? From what I understand, again, my ignorance, I know nothing about the mountain's involvement, but it appears they have some concerns here. Closing of Whitmore.
2:46:07 This is a community. You can't get rid of Whitmore. It's just that simple. The dollar values I'm looking at, we're talking tens of thousands as opposed to millions. Let's get real. That wouldn't even be a consideration. Some of the salaries, I think, at some levels of local government should probably be cut. Not eliminate the position, but just cut the salaries. I'm sure that would take care of the little costs that Whitmore is. I just learned this evening that that included, I always thought it was a swimming pool. Now I understand it's baseball.
2:46:37 I've got three kids that will be playing high school baseball next year. I'm not driving to Bishop, okay? Lastly, what guides to all this trouble to begin with is our liability. If you decrease the police department staff, I think the potential liability there is just going to just tear up whatever effort you make now, the potential liabilities from civil cases in the future, but just squash all that. Thank you for your time.
2:47:08 Quick comment for the benefit of the public. The mayor and I are members of the Mammoth Mountain Ski Area Town Liaison Committee. We have a meeting tomorrow morning with Rusty Gregor at 830, as well as a couple of staff members. We've had meetings. My expectation is that the mountain will be a participant in whatever the solution is that we are going to come up with to find balance in all of this. Thank you for letting me know that. Is there a consideration of a 50% commitment? LAUGHTER
2:47:37 I can ask for a yes. Good evening. My name is Pam Hennerty. I'm the Executive Director of Mammoth Lakes Housing. I like it, Pam. I want to start off by thanking those who came here tonight to speak in support of our organization and what we do, as well as thanking all those who have written letters and emails speaking about the programs and how we've impacted people's lives. The people we help are...
2:48:09 Members of this community. They help make up the fabric that creates a diverse economy in this town. They serve our community, and they're vital members, and their voices deserve to be heard, and I'm glad that they're expressing their opinions. In 2002A, the voters voted to have 1% of TOT funding directed towards housing. In the last six years, that's averaged $811,000 a year.
2:48:37 And you'll see in your packet tonight, and I'm pleased to see that it's starting to be addressed more clearly, that if you take that $811,000 average, and all that remains is Mammoth Lakes Housing Contract of $329,000, approximately $482,000 a year has been redirected from housing to some other purpose in these balancing measures.
2:49:00 That $482,000 does not show up on the spreadsheets of the summary proposed balancing measures, but they have been taken and redirected from housing to other purposes to help make the town whole. That equates to approximately 60% of the housing funding being redirected from housing to other sources to help solve this problem. So I'm here tonight to tell you that housing has contributed to the problem.
2:49:28 But it's essential that we maintain the commitment that was made. Mammoth Lakes Housing was started by the town because there was a need for housing. And yes, we're in a different place than we were then, but we will be in a different place again. And it is very important to maintain the organization, maintain the investments that have been made. Not only has the community invested in the 1% TOT since 2002,
2:49:55 But the Town of Mammoth Lakes has received over $21 million in state and federal funding for our housing programs. With that money, we have created 85 rental units, we have 51 deed-restricted homes in this community, and we have done 62 down payment assistance loans. All of those units and loans and homes require ongoing reporting.
2:50:22 We deal with maintenance. We deal with the homeowners. We deal with the people we've lent money to. We deal with the renters. And it's important that those people who we've made this commitment to have someone to go to when they have questions about their home potentially being in trouble or underwater or having issues with their homeowners association. They have renters' needs. So I'm here to ask you, I'm here to...
2:50:48 I just wanted to ask, how do you respond to the...
2:51:09 The question that you know is out there, which is that the government's building and making available housing competes with the private sector either inappropriately or competes at all. I would say that it's probably true that our rentals do compete with market-rate housing, but our rentals that we have developed and upgraded in the last several years are safe and decent homes for people.
2:51:39 They're energy efficient, and they are at a rent that is affordable for the incomes that these people make. Some will say that rents have come down and are affordable in this town, and I think that the 85 renters we have in our units and the 35 households we have on our waiting list would argue that point. I would hope that the units we've developed would put pressure on some of those other landlords to fix up their units, to make improvements.
2:52:09 To become more competitive with the units that we've been able to generate. Every one of our renters pays a proportionate share of their income towards rent. And if they were forced to be out in the open market, that portion of their income that's dedicated towards housing.
2:52:27 Would be out of proportion and they'd be overpaying. They'd be probably living in substandard conditions and they would probably go back to the conditions that we found in 2004 where there are multiple families living in a unit because they can't afford the rents. Thank you, Pam. Pam, obviously we have accepted money from, excuse me, we've accepted money from both the state and federal governments for our housing to date.
2:52:54 What strings or what financial obligations, maintenance obligations do we have to either of those, the state or the federal government, based upon the funding, the grant money that we have taken from them? Well, there's two answers to that. The rental projects that we've developed that we received both state and federal funding for have 55-year affordability requirements. Those units have to be maintained at their affordability levels for 55 years.
2:53:23 So Mammoth Lakes Housing is a partner in those units, and so we've committed to that. If the units were to lose that affordability, the millions and millions of dollars that were borrowed or that were loaned from the state or granted from the state, in addition to the tax credits and bonds, would have to be repaid back. So in the rental units, that equates to probably about $40 million for the units we've developed.
2:53:47 For the home ownership units and down payment assistance programs that we have accepted about $5 million from, those loans have, and again with the rentals as well, all of those programs have commitments that we report on how much money we're taking in, how much money is loaning out, when people are paying back their loans, and then when people do repay their loans.
2:54:12 We have to re-lend those funds out under the same terms of the program. If we were to collect a loan and not have an ongoing down payment assistance plan, those funds would have to be returned to the state. So I guess my point is that the funding for Mammoth Lakes Housing as it stands today is $329,000, and that's for staffing and administration.
2:54:40 to basically to tread water to perpetuate the housing program that we have today. And if we defunded an additional $329,000, we would be defaulting both to the state and possibly federal government for housing grants that we've already received and performed on. And so we have a certain level of maintenance that we have to
2:55:05 The town made a commitment when they accepted those funds and Mammoth Lakes Housing was and has been the organization to fulfill that commitment. If Mammoth Lakes Housing was no longer funded, the town would still have that commitment. There would still be a tremendous amount of work to be done in order to maintain those commitments. And if the commitments and the grant reporting and the follow-through weren't done, then the state would come after those funds. Thank you.
2:55:33 So let me get this straight. We borrowed a bunch of grant money. We didn't borrow grant money. It was granted to us in a promise of continuing programs. So we took money from the state. And if we do not maintain these affordable housing programs, we will have to pay the money back. Yes. And...
2:55:58 Let me get this straight. Do we have a down payment assistance program? Do we owe any money back currently? No, we don't ever owe money back on the down payment assistance program as long as we continue the program. So if a household was lent $100,000 to help buy their home,
2:56:17 When they repay that money, it needs to be used in accordance with the grant program, so it has to be used for affordable housing purposes and relent to another household. Recycled. Recycled, exactly. It's called the income reuse plan, and the town council adopted the income reuse plan that said that those down payment assistance loans would continue to be relent in our community.
2:56:40 And if those funds come back and the town does not operate those programs, the funds have to be returned. They're not up to the town now to use for whatever they'd like. Okay. That's great. It's a really great program, Matthew. I understand that you're... It sounds wonderful. I'm sorry I'm not trying to be a jerk here, but you know what? I'm not sure that's true. You know, are you sure we don't owe money from the down payment assistance program?
2:57:10 We don't owe money back to the state on that. Well, let me, so there are two down payment assistance programs that were loans, and they're outlined in your packet. Yep. Those loans are due back to the state in 2015 and 2017. Those loans are due from Mammoth Lakes Housing to the town at that time. So Mammoth Lakes, the town borrowed money and then lent it to Mammoth Lakes Housing. All right, I'll leave it there. Can I have a quick question?
2:57:38 What did you say it costs annually to run MLH? I mean, what is the annual cost, just administrative, just to run the program? Our operating budget is about $410,000 a year. What does that all go through? Can you give me just a quick breakdown real fast? I'm sorry, you said that? Can you give me just a quick breakdown on that cost? It covers our overhead, so it includes our office space.
2:58:10 It covers utilities, it covers the staff, insurance, basic operation of a non-profit organization. Thank you. Pam, I apologize. I wasn't trying to belittle the situation at all. It's just frustrating to me. So, thank you. Good evening. I'm Larry Johnston. I'm the vice chairman of Mammoth Lakes Housing Incorporated. Jim.
2:58:43 Jennifer and Pam really are exceptional, and we are so lucky to have them doing what they're doing. Mammoth Lakes Housing is more than just a place to find affordable workforce housing. It's an economic machine. It's created jobs, construction jobs, and it allows other businesses
2:59:23 To function. And so, you know, they've generated, I think the staff report says $60 million or so, $30 million in grants. And you know what $30 million is? It's two and a half years first year, $2 million for 23 years. That's a lot of money that we're liable for, that somebody has to manage, and they have to manage as well.
3:00:02 I don't usually go anyplace without a graph, so I just wanted to graph what John was saying. So this is the $800,000, the top line. That's the 1%. It looks like you're going to take, we are going to take $400,000 to $500,000 of that without voter consent. And I think Mammoth Lakes Housing is okay with that. I think we understand that. But if you go below
3:00:36 This line, which is about 329,000, you see what happens. You're going to start having to pay back things if you don't manage it properly. So this is my geometry. Y equals X squared plus 329,000 K. That's what it looks like. So I just want to say, hey, Mammoth Lakes Housing contributed 60% to this problem.
3:01:09 That's up to solving this MLLA problem. And then as a closing note, thank you very much for your very hard work on this. It's not easy to go through what you've gone through and have to go through. I'm glad I'm not on that side. Yet. But thank you. Thank you very much. Thank you, Larry.
3:01:44 Larry, a couple of comments, one related to what you said and another not. As you know, I sit on that board as well as the council representative. I missed you the other night. He was out of town. Where was I? East of here. You know, I think what I'm hearing you say is that this investment in the community is no different from any other investment in infrastructure and otherwise.
3:02:13 And requires funds to continue to maintain. Is that a fair statement? Yes. I think that's reflected in the graph. Well, you know, I didn't do well. John stated it. John stated it clearly. I have no idea what that graph was intended to be. You know, I went to law school because I couldn't read graphs. So the second question I have is really unrelated.
3:02:41 Can you, and I'm going to put you on the spot, but you're a public official. Can you, can you tell me whether the county should play a role in assisting the town, helping the town out on this Whitmore problem that we have, this 185, 117, 185,000. It's actually Whitmore's 117. I think the others are two staff members. We're already helping out to 10 of the 120, I believe. And just,
3:03:10 Just the other day we gave $3,000 to the swim team and we're eating the $65,000 for the animal shelter. So yeah, we did. Now, you want to ask for more? Yes. While you're here. The position of the board is that if you want to do a formal request for any particular item, we would be happy to consider it.
3:03:42 But we have a safety net that the county maintains. And we've worked hard to be as frugal and efficient as we can be. And we're working hard. We're still going to do some things in the future. And we are not ourselves much above water. So I think there are things that can be done, efficiency kinds of consolidations that are possible.
3:04:21 And we're willing to consider those things. Thank you. Thank you, Larry. Appreciate it. I have a request, real quick, Bill, if I may, of Mariana. I wanted to, for the public's benefit, to break out the, I believe it's the $482,000 that's been talked about that we've taken out of their budgeting.
3:04:46 It's my understanding that a portion of that, a large portion of that is a repayment of a loan that the town made to MLH. So I want to be fair as to what that $482,000 represents. Thank you, Councilmember Eastman. It's actually around $400,000 right now because the 1% COT, I believe, is around $730,000, maybe $740,000.
3:05:14 Once you deduct MLH's contract of $329,000, your luck was a little over $400,000. Of that, approximately $280,000 is an annual debt service payment that continues through June of 2014. So it's a debt service payment that has been here for years and years and is going to continue through that date. As of June 2014, the debt is going to be fully paid off.
3:05:42 And that 280,000 FTI's calculations was put back in the general fund because measure A is not a special tax, it's a general tax, and legally FTI could only do one thing with that available money, and that is put it back in the general fund. So that's what happens with 280,000 beginning June of 2014.
3:06:09 That leaves approximately $120,000, maybe $140,000. Well, gradually, we built a structural surplus in the housing fund, and the same thing happens with that structural surplus, as does with the debt service, $280,000, because it's not a legally restricted money. It was put back in the general fund and FTI's model, because legally, that's the only thing that they could do. Thank you. Thank you, Bill.
3:06:39 I'm Bill Taylor. I'm also a board member of Mammoth Lakes Housing. And a couple things. I think you saw my letter from last week, and I just wanted to thank Ms. Marysheva-Martinez for a prompt reply. I think she answered the $500,000 question very well, and I understood what happened. I still have one point I'd like to bring up, and that's on page 5, under the possible alternatives.
3:07:07 Page 5 of today's staff report. And just to point out that the baseline, 700,000, or 7 tenths of a million as it's presented here, 0.07 million, represents actually a 10% reduction from the receipts. Projected receipts are actually 814,000. FTI and your, what did you call it, operational restructuring plan.
3:07:34 Took 10% off the top, and that has become a new baseline. In fact, at this level, transit and housing are already contributing $80,000 a year. So that's just a minor point, but it does adjust the figures so that currently with the outstanding loan on the apartments that you're paying on now, there's $265,000.
3:08:02 Being redirected to unrestricted funds. That will be $594 in future years. So anyway, we've talked about that before. I've mentioned to a few of you that I think revenue enhancement is an important part of the program and growing our program. I think you need to be looking at Mammoth Lakes Housing as a resource, not expense. When you look at the money that has come in that they have managed,
3:08:30 The units that have been built and sold during a fairly severe economic downturn, the rehabilitation of the star apartments, that was money that wasn't being spent in this town, in this economy. The opportunity to do more rehabilitation, to create more workforce units out of the existing stock that we have is actually fairly substantial, and I don't want you to overlook that.
3:08:59 We know our construction economy is really hurting. This is one way to funnel money into those jobs and into that part of our economy. It's been said that one of the comment letters that was said that we don't need new construction. This has been pointed out that may not be true for rental units. It's probably true for sale units, probably not for affordable rental units. And I'm going to run through these quickly before the lights change on me.
3:09:30 Remember why you formed Mammoth Lakes Housing as opposed to Housing Authority. And there's two of you up there that were part of this. You did not want housing to be part of this government. So think about that. Let's see. There's a sense that all Mammoth Lakes Housing does is kind of sit over there and maybe talk to a few people and manage the existing units. But as Pam pointed out,
3:09:59 We have rental and home buyer counseling, down payment assistance grants and loans, CDBG loan, grants for acquisition and rehab, USDA rural development loans. This is all money coming into our community that's helping even the down payment assistance loans that you were concerned about. Those help people buy units. They pay real estate commissions. They keep property values up.
3:10:29 These are funds that are helping our economy stay solid. Finally, there's been an implication that moving the housing function into the town is simple. I'd suggest you that it's not that simple. And I think a lot of the reasons why it's not have been pointed out. Mammoth Lakes Housing on the units that it actually manages puts a liability firewall between you and those units. That goes away if you take the management over directly.
3:11:00 And finally, I'm skipping over some things. General plan. Your adopted housing element says, and this is action H2A1, dedicate one percentage point of all revenues from transit occupancy tax to fund affordable and workforce housing programs and the work of Mammoth Lakes Housing. There's a risk to not following a general plan. Certain grant funds are not available to you. Quite frankly,
3:11:31 Zoning actions, development approvals can all be challenged. The town is not following its general plan. Keep that in mind as you go forward. I don't know how large that risk is, but I know communities have been sued over in the past. So thinking about how you integrate your actions, you have to make a finding of general plan consistency, how you integrate these actions with the adopted plan in this community. Thank you. Any questions?
3:12:01 Bill, I just had one. You know, this grant thing has kind of got to me now. It sounds like that liability firewall really isn't a firewall because the town's on the hook for it. Well, I was thinking more in terms of if there's a problem with, let's say tenant, there's an issue with the housing, we are now the end of the place where that stops. We're not here.
3:12:30 It goes on to you. Okay. And you have insurance coverage for that? Correct. Yeah. Thank you, Bill. Thank you. Bruce Woodward, local citizen. I got up at the last meeting and talked about the need for raising, I guess, basically a parcel tax was my thought at that time. So I'm not going to go into that. I don't need to go over what I went over last time. I think you heard it.
3:13:03 It's out there and it's like, I think it's still a valid idea. But I'm now, last week I also said, you know, you're going to get the stream of people coming up here and saying, you can't cut this because my, whatever. It's, it's, it has to be here for the Town of Mammoth Lakes. And they're basically down the line, everybody's right. So I'm here to be that person for something that is important. And I think it's not just important for
3:13:30 It's important for me because I deal with it a lot, but that's in the community development department or the community and economic development department, which is that economic development part of it that's in there now, that's what's going to get us out of this problem. And it's been that department, we've been through it over the years. We've kind of whittled down and people have gone and we haven't replaced and we've cut down. But we've talked and talked and talked about how we have to be ready.
3:14:00 For when things do turn around. And it seems that if we can continue to cut, we're going to get to the point where things may turn around around us, but they're not going to be able to turn around here because people will come here and find out they can't get anything done. And that's what I'm really concerned about. And it starts on the little teeny things. It starts with someone going in and wanting to get a permit. And they're getting, they want a deck. And it takes them a really long time to get a deck.
3:14:28 Or they want to follow the letter of the law and they're going to replace their water heater. And it's, I don't deal with these things in my business, but it occurs and it happens in the town, it happens a lot. If it's not, if it becomes a real pain in the neck for the people to do this or it takes a long time, they're still going to replace their water heater. But we're going to start having things that aren't being done properly and you're going to start having all sorts of problems and you're going to have a code enforcement issue down the road and you're just creating
3:14:58 Thank you, Bruce.
3:15:29 Mariana, would it be fair to say, too, I mean, we're, as of today, we're really not cutting. We're just maintaining the level of service we're at now. And we're holding vacant spots. There's vacancies there. Yeah. As it's outlined on here. Well, we're making cuts. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. We are. So, no. All right. We'll just leave it there. Good try, though. No.
3:16:00 Well, I'm just with, we have bacon, bacon, bacon on here. Go ahead. Hi, I'm Flossie Coulter. I've been a resident here for 33 years, and many of you know me with a variety of hats. But the first thing I want to ask are a couple questions about your summary sheet. The way I read it is that you will have the money for this first year except for $483,000 or $480,000. Is that what this means?
3:16:33 The proposed cuts. I don't think we got that summary. That's correct. Yeah. Okay. So I then would like to jump to the bottom half. Terry brought up about parcel tax. Other people brought up about the 3% tax on the ski ticket. And then it also says about other additions. Doing an event in town
3:17:03 Any of us that sell tickets would just add it on to the price. We might not like that. Bookkeeping will be a nightmare, but it is something that can be done. Instead of these top portions, which affect everybody in a variety of ways, I suggest for the long run that you really look at your voter approval raising taxes.
3:17:28 You've got a variety. What does a 2.5% utility tax increase mean? That means $2.50 for every 100. But my question is, that's Measure U. Am I correct? Would that Measure U money then still be under the umbrella of what was voted in, or would that 2.5%
3:17:54 Be allocated to help pay off the debt or do whatever. Depends upon what you, how the ballot measure is drafted. You can do what you want. Okay. But if I'm looking down here now, I don't know how $2 million came out of emissions tax unless that was really taken off of mountain numbers. I really don't know. But the utility tax, the sales tax, the parcel tax, that's two points.
3:18:23 $75 million a year. That would get you out of the red a whole lot sooner. And it really spreads it over everybody and nobody in the town position of police or recreation or whatever that we all use would have to take that cut. We would all share. We can put the blame wherever we want for this lawsuit, but we're all in this together. Flossie, Flossie.
3:18:54 So for somebody who sells tickets, it's a pretty bold statement, pretty brave statement for you to make. Do you think, as you're out in the community, you know a lot of people, everybody's talking about this. And that's why I'm not so sure it's a smart idea for me to have just said what I said. So do you think that given what you see, what you saw on the board tonight, what you see in the sheet, what you, in the paper before you,
3:19:27 As well as what you've heard tonight and read in the papers and so on. Do you think that this community would support that which you have just suggested we do and that is to raise taxes? It's going to take a lot of work, guys. It's going to take a lot of work. And it will take a lot of us to do it. But I really don't see a better alternative. I mean, you might have other...
3:19:54 There are things that are viable.
3:20:23 A viable community needs. As far as tickets work, badges, there's only one other event of our type that I know of that charges people tax, and that's the Sun Valley Jamboree, which is going on right now in Sun Valley. And they very plainly say on their badge prices, it's a hundred and some dollars plus tax. And you could indicate, we might even make some money out of this. If we have a $90 ticket, we say, yep.
3:20:54 It's $3 tax. Only $2.70 of that goes to you. Yeah, sure. I don't know if that's legal. I don't know if that's legal, but I like the idea. Cassie, I just have another question. So are you suggesting multiple taxes? Yes, I am. Okay. You know, all of us would share, all of us use utilities. Anybody that comes to town would have a sales tax.
3:21:27 Most of us do some shopping in Reno, Carson City, LA, wherever you go. Seven and three quarters sales tax is lower than Costco, lower than anybody to the north. And, you know, that might only hurt on really big ticket items, but you're not talking very much money in any one of these situations. And it would spread it across the board.
3:21:58 Thank you. Thank you, Flossie. Is everybody in the back going to come up and speak as well? We've got three people? Yeah. I'm just trying to decide if we should take a break real quick or not. No, let's keep going. Let's go. Okay. Come on up. Good evening. Flossie's a hard app to follow, but my name is Pat Agnich, and I'm a Recreation Commissioner, but tonight I'm speaking as an individual.
3:22:26 Who has worked in the recreation profession for over 32 years. I'm going to speak to the benefits of recreation, which I think you all know. We are a recreation town, but I think we are quick to think about people coming into the community, and we have to because that's a good balance. It brings a lot of money into the community. But we need to think about our residents as well, why people will come to this community.
3:22:50 For work, but for schools, recreation, you know, it's the whole gamut of services that are provided. So not only does recreation provide, you know, physical health benefits, those are kind of the obvious things. There's also mental health that can be enhanced, you know, but through recreation can really
3:23:16 Getting nervous here. It can relieve stress, of course, which I have right now. And, of course, there are a lot of social benefits involved with it as well. You talked about building communities. Certainly, recreation does do that. It builds individuals. It builds communities. And I think at this point, this community can benefit from something like that with all that it's gone through. And as Commissioner Truax even pointed out,
3:23:45 Can help prevent and help with safety issues as well. The recreation budget is less than 3% of the town's overall budget. When you think about that, there are only three staff. I don't know how Stuart Brown and his team do all that they do, because I know that Stu is also involved with other responsibilities as well. So the way I look at it is that we need to
3:24:16 Make sure that recreation benefits the community and that it is a very inexpensive necessity. Thank you. Pat, real quick, and thank you for coming and speaking. We've asked every other commissioner except the one that's not here this evening, but would you agree with some of your fellow commissioners that there's a possibility of a consideration for a short-term
3:24:45 Use of Measure R funds to support, to keep the pool open. Have you thought about it? We haven't spoken at, you know, as a commission. Individually, you know, some of us have different opinions about things. I think bottom line, we need to provide recreation services and facilities. And I know that gets back to the whole issue of supplanting, which Sean mentioned earlier.
3:25:18 I think bottom line we need to do what it takes to keep facilities open and programs going. Thank you. And I know that the expenditure plan does allow and measure on for the council to modify some of the language with respect to supplanting. And I think if it is perhaps on a short-term basis, that would be beneficial to the entire community. Thank you. Thank you, Pat. So Johnny Gates, private citizen, Mono County.
3:25:51 Pat and I were laughing on who was more nervous to get up here. She went first, so I appreciate it. The lady in the yellow earthworm sweater, she got me to get up here. So, Matt, if you can turn off Rick's microphone, because I don't have solutions. I just have complaints that I think are important. Like I said, I do live in the community, but my wife was born and raised in this town.
3:26:19 My in-laws have been here since the 50s. The stories that I hear at the family parties about what the community did for the community all the time is really important. And Terry and Flossie both said, and I'm ad-libbing here, and I don't mean to get corny with some quotes that I'm going to say, but I think they're important. Terry said, pull together, don't pit each other.
3:26:46 And on that, it's okay to have opinions. It's okay to speak your mind. But be a team. If we're all a team, we're all a community. The team is together, everyone achieves more. This community, which was unbelievable in their turnout tonight, this council who hasn't wavered from any criticism, any goodwill, anything, the town staff,
3:27:17 We can make all this happen. We can make it happen if we're a team. Every one of us have personal goals, business goals, whatever it is in life. And goals, here's another quote, and I don't mean to be corny, but goals means go out and locate success. How do we do that as a community? We do it as a team. We figure it out. Matt, you made the comment about
3:27:43 You were amazed or something like that about all the community voice and the community input. And I know, Rick, you said it. Let's figure it out. This community, this council, this staff loves this town. It's this town. It's not about me. It's not about Dave. It's not about Bruce or Matt or Michael, whomever. It's about this town. We love this town. If we do it as a team, we'll get it done.
3:28:14 The last little corny thing, you know, a bend in the road is not the end of the road unless you fail to make the turn. So we've got a bend in the road. We've got a 29.5 bend in the road. So there's opportunity. And 29.5 million, and I mean no disrespect to any of this, is a lot of money. But opportunity, nothing is more expensive than a missed opportunity.
3:28:43 I don't know what that opportunity is, but whether it's development, TOT, I mean, there's been amazing ideas, but my point is nothing is more expensive than a missed opportunity. And again, you all know who I am. I beg you that I'm talking as a private citizen and nothing more than that, but I think there's a chance here for
3:29:11 To us to have the greatest team in history. If we all come together, all bring out our opinions, which is fine, and, you know, we can agree, we can disagree, we can agree to disagree, but we as a whole can get this done. Thank you. Thank you, Johnny. Johnny, it's not corny, by the way. I appreciate your comments and your leadership. You've always demonstrated it. Thank you very much. Hi. Amy Cutter.
3:29:45 Local Citizen. So I have a few comments, and then I have a few questions for Dave and Mariana, as well as to Pat, or Pam, sorry, and Bill Taylor. So don't leave while I'm talking. So, and then I have a couple of suggestions from, depending upon the answers to the questions.
3:30:15 So first, of course, there's a lot of frustration with this situation. There's a lot of suggestions or cuts being made or cuts being suggested, taxes being suggested. And I think part of the frustration comes from not understanding all the unintended consequences. And I think part of the discussion or things that have come out tonight, new information has come available or has been put forth.
3:30:45 So that we understand better when certain line items are discussed, certain cuts are being presented, that there is an unintended consequence. We don't all know what the impact is. And I think that goes to part of the frustration. It's just not understanding the full impact of each of these line items. I know the staff has done a lot of work, and that doesn't go unnoticed, but I think it's just...
3:31:13 A huge job trying to uncover, unravel all these unintended consequences. So with that, I have a couple questions about the Mammoth Lake Housing. So on page 7 of the packet, at the top, it talks about if you do bring the housing in-house, that there, I think I'm reading this right, there's a $329,190 savings.
3:31:43 Now, I appreciate Bill talking about that firewall. I appreciate that because it sort of goes to, well, why wouldn't you do it? If there is going to be a savings, what would be the impact to Mammoth Lakes Housing? So I don't know who would like to answer that question. Mayor, if I may, I wanted to correct you right away. Sure. $329,000 is the total amount of the contract between the town and MLH.
3:32:10 So if you brought the housing function in-house, it's going to cost us more than zero, so there's going to be some cost. So the savings are going to be between $329,000 and that cost. But that cost is going to be, we haven't frankly looked at it yet. Okay, so there's not a full $329,000? Absolutely not. Okay, then the other thing on that point is what would the services be if you brought it in-house? So let's say it's not a $329,000 savings.
3:32:38 Let's say it's $150,000 savings. What would the service delta be? Would the service be the same? So absolutely not. We're minimizing a lot of things. And so we would certainly do a lot to reduce the cost to that to its basic minimum to maintain some standard that we have to oversee and to manage those millions of dollars you've talked about. Okay, so you wouldn't shift those people?
3:33:07 from Mammoth Lakes Housing in-house and make some adjustments. Well, we might. Okay. In some case, but the level of service, your question is, would drop. Okay. The other thing is, I don't know if we can keep going. You're fine. Go ahead. Okay. I know I gave you the carrot of the suggestion. So the firewall, how many issues have there been in the last 10 years that we're concerned about that would expose the town?
3:33:35 That is not exposed today because of this firewall. None today. I mean, there's concern about an exposure to the town, so I'm just curious. Pam could probably answer that better than us. I'm not sure I can speak to the exact number. I mean, we have 85 tenants and, what did I say, 62 down payments in six months. So by us taking on that responsibility, you know, if a tenant has a doorknob broken,
3:34:08 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
3:34:33 So I wasn't talking about the service level because I would consider that service level as opposed to an actual issue. Somebody having a doorknob, that's like a property management role. That's part of your service. But the impression was that there's a legal exposure to the town that would cause a big issue as opposed to the typical services that you provide. Are you asking have they ever been sued? Whatever that definition of an issue is that would expose the town.
3:35:02 Since I was the one who brought it up, I don't know that we've had any issues like that yet, but almost every landlord does at some point, and they're usually not minor issues, and it's not that we can quantify the data based on past experience, but it's simply knowing that if there is an issue that stops with us, we're not going to do anything.
3:35:30 Okay, so I'm going to move to my other question. Sorry, is the taxing side of it. So on page nine, the last bullet point above E, it talks about the timing of getting a tax measure on the special election.
3:35:50 So the question is, it says that if the town makes a decision, town council makes a decision in December, or let's see, wait, be made by January, that the earliest special election could occur is in April. So my question is, can you, before the town makes a decision, start doing the legwork for, let's say you assume that you're going to have a special election, can you start the legwork of preparing for a special election?
3:36:18 Any earlier, like say the town council says, all right, direct staff to start working on preparing for a special election, that would then allow you to have the special election earlier than April.
3:36:33 Most likely not, and I'm sure that Mr. Morris might add to this, but the bottom line is the county requires 88 days by law. It's not something that they establish. By law, they require that 88 days prior to the election that we submit all the approved resolutions, ordinances, and so on to them. So that's three months. So then that leaves us a month to go through the process of
3:37:01 Placing resolutions and ordinances in the public view, so to speak, going through the process. So there's not much that we can do to really minimize that process because that month, frankly, is probably insufficient for the public discussion and the vote. Okay, so you couldn't start, say, doing... I realize no decision has been made about the tax versus the cuts, but I think to Flossie's point...
3:37:29 That when you look at all the, you know, the pool, the Mammoth Lake Housing, some of these, they're really small items in the big scheme of things in that it does target particular groups, whether I'm in favor of them or against them, but that the tax, if you do a suite of taxes, that it does, everyone sort of bears the brunt. And so the only question I have is whether we can start working on some of that paperwork, like work signatures, what have you.
3:37:58 Say in November to move up that election date. My response is as soon as the council gives us direction, we start. We wouldn't start before that. I think the community itself would be very upset if we began using staff time and resources in an area that has been undecided. And so I think just for good public practices, we would look to the council to give us direction when they would do that and we would start working on those things.
3:38:28 I would just add one point of clarification if you don't mind. A tax measure can either go on the ballot at the council's direction, which doesn't take any signatures from the community, or it can be put on the ballot if enough signatures are gathered. The thing about that is, though, that if you're going to gather signatures, you have to have the exact language of the ballot measure available when you start.
3:38:50 So there's not a way to start collecting signatures in advance of getting it fully fleshed out. Okay. But let me go back, if I may, to your question on the timing. So regardless of what we do, and we'll have to do a lot of work before we start drafting ordinances and resolutions, but once the council makes a decision on specifically which taxes to pursue, you need to have at least four months from that decision to the election because there's simply...
3:39:19 We simply can't make it work any other way. Sure. And the suggestion or what I was alluding to of town council directing staff was under the assumption you start doing some of the legwork but you actually don't throw the switch of doing the formal action of putting the or preparing for the tax until the council makes a decision. If the decision is
3:39:48 Okay, no, we're not going to go that way. Then you cut the cord on the work that is done earlier in the process. All I'm suggesting is you sort of run in parallel. It may not be something that you guys can do. It may be a bad perception. It was just a suggestion on how to move up the election date since it is going to be a special election. You still can't reduce the four months period. Sure. So that's just the bottom line. Sure. Okay.
3:40:18 There's one final comment. One of the things I think I've heard criticism for over the past year so that I've been here is that staff drives decisions. So can you imagine what would happen if staff started drafting and crafting the language for a tax measure? And we deliver it to the council. Is it the council's direction to us? Or is it us driving the council to a conclusion? And I think we're very sensitive to allowing this process to play it out completely.
3:40:46 And let the council direct us about what they'd like to do. I was not suggesting that you guys go off and do it. It was town council actually directing staff to do the work. The idea behind it, the spirit behind it was just run in peril, start the timing earlier, and if you guys decide not to do the tax. We're going to stay on the air of caution. Sure, no problem. That was my suggestion.
3:41:15 The other thing about the Mammoth Lake Housing is just in the pool is, again, they're small taxes and that you may be better off doing the taxing side of the solution. Amy, you know a lot of people, you're outspoken. Do you think a tax measure would be successful if we were to propose one? I'm not convinced.
3:41:45 That it would, notwithstanding that we've heard from eight or ten people who are saying, consider the alternative, which of course, we are, it was on the board, but what do you think, what's your intuition? It's a tough climate for people being in favor of a tax. I think one of the biggest challenges for the town is that there's been so many taxes that have been, or measures that have put taxes aside.
3:42:15 The response has always been, oh, no, no, no, don't worry, don't worry, it's protected money, it's only going to be spent on X. This money is only going to be spent on Y. And I think one of the concerns in the community is that there's a perception that the money is being raided for these different funds. And so I think the big uphill battle for the town is if you do go down the road of these tax measures, how do you reassure the community that you're not going to rate it for something else?
3:42:44 You could restrict it if you went that level. Agreed. If you want to risk a two-thirds vote. But again, I think there's a different ballot measure for each type of tax. Is that not correct? Yeah. So, you know, maybe you go with putting all of the ballots on for each of the different taxes and you see which ones pass, if any of them pass. Just a thought. You're looking for suggestions. Yeah, no, I'm asking. Any other questions?
3:43:17 No, I was just going to say, and Amy, I do appreciate your suggestions line out as well, and we have the benefit that the next meeting on November 7th, we will know how the tax measures on the November ballot went. That will be more information to tell us on whether those two passed or not. Got it. Okay. Thank you. Council, my name is Jesse Baldwin. I'm a homeowner, a small business owner, an electrical contractor, and I'm also here to represent the Mammoth Lakes Contractors Association as their elected president.
3:43:55 And I'm also a member of the Appeals Board Building Advisory Committee. I don't want to repeat what I already went over at the last Town Council meeting with regards to the permit technician, but I do want to expand on it a little bit. First of all, I do want to thank you for the revisions that I saw with regards to maintaining that position. That's great. What I do have a problem with is the clause in there that says possibly it is a part-time.
3:44:24 And possibly reallocating some of that position's duties. Also, I know we spoke about this at length at the last Town Council meeting, so I don't want to take up too much time with it, but I do want to mention that since that meeting and this meeting, I have been approached by business owners, contractors, and by virtue of my job, a service job where I perform electrical work inside people's homes, customers have expressed to me a unanimous concern.
3:44:55 About the cuts proposed to the police department and how they're willing to do whatever it takes, whether it be paying a sales tax or eliminating non-essential services to maintain those police services that we currently have and the protection that those services offer. And I just felt that I was obligated to express that. With regards to the permanent technician position, I made the analogy at the last meeting that
3:45:22 Getting rid of that position would be similar to firing the tax collector. I've heard some things tonight like we should do equal cuts across all areas, stuff like that. I think as a business owner, and this is my perspective, I need to focus on areas that generate revenue and I need to cut costs in areas where
3:45:48 I'm spending revenue, and it's not generating revenue when I'm in a position like this. You know, it's been a very difficult climate for me, personally, business-wise, and so I've had to, you know, just like I heard tonight, I've had to cut employees, I've had to cut, you know, benefits. There's a lot of things I've had to do to slim down and streamline to stay in business. But what I don't do is I don't get rid of those portions of my business, like my licensed journeyman that goes out and makes me money.
3:46:13 You know, I might have to cut his hours if I don't have work for him, but I can't get rid of him completely because otherwise, you know, he's not going to be able to bring that revenue in. So with the permit technician, you know, essentially that's a revenue collecting and generating position. You know, I go to that person this week, for example, I turn in six permits just this week. And, you know, I pay money as far as I know, and anyone can correct me if I'm wrong, but that that...
3:46:43 You know, that entity is basically self-sustaining on permit fees. And I think that there can be more effort made, not necessarily in cutting back in that, you know, collecting and revenue generating position, but instead focusing on how we can encourage permit compliance. And, you know, one of the things I read, I don't know exactly where in the materials tonight, because there was so much paper, was imposing stiffer fines for non-compliance.
3:47:13 And, you know, I can just tell you, you know, if somebody is caught not pulling a building permit and they only have to pay double that permit fee, you know, that's not a prohibitive penalty. But, like, all of you know, probably OSHA, if they come in and they find you with a violation, they hit you with a big fee, $5,000, $10,000, $20,000. And, you know, I'm not trying to say that we should try and pull people out of business with fees like that, but we definitely need to discourage.
3:47:39 The homeowners and business owners that are going to go ahead and permit unlicensed, unpermitted work because there's not much of a penalty for it. And I see, just by, you know, I'm not an expert in, you know, any area other than electricity and electronics. And I can tell you I've seen some really, really scary stuff in town here.
3:48:00 It's not been done maliciously. It's just been done by people who didn't really know what they were doing. It was allowed to be done because the people who authorized the work weren't aware of the safety hazards with allowing that type of work to be done by unlicensed professionals. And because there was no permit, there was no inspection, and there was no second set of eyes that could have caught it. I know I went over the three minutes, and I don't want to waste a lot of time, and I've had a lot of information, and I've heard a lot of good things.
3:48:28 I just wanted to briefly say that I don't have really good ideas, and I haven't heard really good suggestions for the short-term solutions. I think we're in a, you know, for repaying the debt, I think we're in a, you know, a tough situation where now, okay, here's the judgment, and you've got to start making payments right away. And like we all talked about, you know, with the sales tax, it's more of a long-term thing. It has to be approved.
3:48:58 From my experience recently filling out my State Board of Equalization sales tax returns, looking at the different district taxes, I have to look at, you know, what is the tax rate? And, you know, I have the state and then the district tax for performing, you know, business that's taxable in the city of Mammoth Lakes or town of Mammoth Lakes. It only added .05 percent. And there's a lot of other districts on there with much higher percentages. I don't know why, but I know that, you know, being in a tourist town like Mammoth,
3:49:28 I don't expect to have the lowest sales tax rate. I don't expect to buy goods and services at the lowest price. And I don't think our, you know, our visitors coming up expect to either. So I think that that's a good opportunity going forward for, you know, maintaining our police services and filling these budget gaps because basically anyone who is paying sales tax is pretty much benefiting from the police service and coverage, you know, whether they're a guest.
3:49:56 Coming here and buying stuff or whether they're a resident who lives here and has to pay that tax or business doing that. Jesse, I hate to cut you off. Thank you. No, we got some good information from me. I appreciate it. Some new stuff, too. Thank you. Thank you. Hey, Mr. Marion, Town Council. Brent Truax, Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce. I keep my comments fairly short tonight. The Chamber of Commerce really feels, from the standpoint of supplanting, is my first comment.
3:50:31 Is that we cannot support that. We were part of the organizations that helped get that approved, allows the public, and sold that as a, you know, recognizing that there's always things that happen in the world, but sold it for a particular use, and that's what those were supposed to be used for. In that way, we cannot support, and hopefully, Town Council can find ways to not supplant funds from those acts. Secondarily, just as a second point, it's just interesting when I look at the, my brief amortization schedule.
3:50:59 Which says that over the next seven years we're going to pay about $9 million in interest and $5 million in principal. And I see it phase two and I don't know, I just want to make sure I understand. It's part of the discussion after this first portion to figure out how to pay this off sooner because we're paying a lot of interest here for 23 years. I don't see this as a $30 million issue, I see this as a $50 million issue. What's the plan to cut that down because $9 million of interest in seven years is a lot of money.
3:51:26 And we're paying a lot to get to this stage. And I know we're going through a lot of deliberations and hard decisions to make this stage. But it's a lot of interest we're paying, particularly in the first 10, 15 years of this note, that are a substantial amount of the monies we're paying. Thank you. On your first comment. Yes. And maybe I'll ask Rick's question, but don't believe it's supplanting.
3:51:54 But would you be in favor of a short-term loan under the assumption that a tax were passed? From a loan standpoint, it would be more acceptable from the standpoint that it wouldn't, the way we view it, that would not be supplanting, that you are paying that back. I see from the standpoint of, even with the airport and the Measure U, that it's scheduled to be paid back as planned. But that would not be supplanting as per the...
3:52:21 What we see that as. If you're taking the money right from there to put into the general budget to pay for items that have been paid for, we would view that as planting. And you look at just from the standpoint of long-term trust, you know, we all go around this in many different ways. We talk about sales tax, what's going to happen, is Prop 30 going to pass this year or not? That's going to raise sales tax. There's certain businesses in town that already pay more sales tax in other places because of where they are in town. There's a lot of sub-issues. There's no easy answer. I'm not coming with any great answer for you as well.
3:52:50 But I just look at the standpoint of we've got to get this resolved and we need to pay it off sooner rather than later. I think 23 years. My daughter's five. That means she's 27 when we're done with this. That's a lot of money we're paying out over 23 years. You're right. And that interest, as we mentioned before, a lot of it's up front, just like a mortgage payment. So, yeah. So what's the Chamber's position if it has one on taxes? See, as I was waiting for this late in the evening, I hope you knew somebody else.
3:53:20 Right now, we have not discussed it as a formal resolution. In some ways, sales tax is a regressive tax when you look at that from across property. So it's really not, in my opinion, and more of a personal opinion, the best tax maybe. Maybe there is latitude with some property tax that could take place. And I throw this out only from listening to discussion tonight, and I'm not saying I'm endorsing either way. Maybe you're looking the wrong ways. Maybe $100 is in the right way. Maybe $200 is the right way to retire this earlier.
3:53:48 But I do think, and I think there was comments made earlier, there is a little bit of communication in town about the trust. If it's taken, will it expire, will it be used for other things? There's a lot of comments around town of how people make sure. We talked just a few minutes ago about putting certain language and acts. People thought that that's what they had for Measure U and Measure R, and they're finding that's not the case. So there always seems to be this kind of little door that's left open at the end of the day.
3:54:15 What do you think the business community would, or how do you think it would react to the formation of a business improvement district that participates, if you will, in marketing and tourism along with the town to relieve some of the pressure on the town? And I realize I haven't, you know, previewed you with that question at all, but I'm curious about what you might think about that.
3:54:45 You don't have to answer it, but it would be great to hear from the chamber on that issue as well. I'll give you my quick reaction to that standpoint is I think it has some legs to stand on. I think the challenge there is how do you make it broad enough so you aren't just, because what's been discussed so far is particularly attached to the lodging industry. I think it has to be a broader base whereby it would impact all those people impacted by tourism. And if you're talking about a fairly small portion at that point in time that's realistic, it's an option I think that one has to look at. Okay.
3:55:15 Thanks. Okay. Thank you. Hi. Good evening, Council. I'm Martin Kleinbert, businessman, electrical contractor. I'm out there in the field, and I deal directly with customers. I have customer base that are out of town and, of course, locals. And a lot of times, you know, we discuss, you know, the current things that are going on. And lately, there's been quite a few customers that are very concerned about
3:55:52 What's going on with town? I try to encourage them to go online and look at what's going on. And the biggest consensus I get is we need to get it over with. We need to do what's necessary to not decimate the public services, whether it be snow removal, whether it be police department, whether it be town services.
3:56:22 They feel that that's very, very important to themselves. And if they have rental units, I think they are very concerned for their renters, that they have a good time and they enjoy spending their money here. You know, town is in the business, I mean, this community is in the business, you know, mostly for providing a product for...
3:56:46 For the public, for the visitors. I mean, yes, we have people that live here and we respect everybody that does. So I had an email conversation really quick with Marianna today. You know, I told her in my support of, you know, if we can do the multiple small taxes to spread it around that I think that...
3:57:12 Maybe that, I'm suggesting that's probably the best thing because the alternatives seem so out there as far as it's going to hurt this group of people, that cut's going to hurt that group of people. If we lose police officers, what is it going to cost to get those police officers back? And we're going to be in the same predicament. We're going to have to provide incentives, which are going to cost, incentives for housing, which is going to cost.
3:57:40 You know, in order to get people to restaff when the time comes to restaff. So as far as that goes, and then one of my questions that wasn't answered, and I don't know if it can be tonight, is that we did, because I know it's on the table to charge for some of the transportation. My only question is, is just like all the other little cuts, some big, some little, what's the impact?
3:58:09 If we start charging, because I know that the whole purpose for getting the trolley going and getting the transportation and not charging was to get people out of the cars and into the trolley or into whatever, you know, the lift or any of the public transportation systems we have. If the impact is reduced ridership, what is that impact as far as the particulate matters that we have to comply with? It's another...
3:58:39 You know, regulation that we have to deal with. Great, great point. Let me try to address that a little bit. Excuse me. Two things. One is that they have, we don't need to reinvent the wheel. There have been studies done on the impact of charging a fee as it relates to the number of riders and transportation.
3:59:06 And we've had those mentioned to us before with John Helm, actually to the entire council. And real quickly, when you charge a fee for transportation, your ridership will go down between a certain level. So then you're self-defeating what you're trying to do is to generate revenues where it's going to cost you more.
3:59:32 Putting a fee on transportation has been proven through studies to not be an effective way to fund the transportation. On the second part, help me here, what was the last part you were talking about? Well, I think you just answered the last part. The first part was my suggestion as far as multiple small taxes. Okay. I think you had one. Okay. Thank you.
4:00:02 Just a point of information. I talked to a guy yesterday, seems like an eternity ago when we were in Denver, but it was only yesterday, a senior executive at Vail Resorts, and specifically about transit, because they've got an extraordinary system. It's not just town-wide, but goes way down valley as well to bring people in.
4:00:27 I asked them a question specifically about whether they've ever addressed the issue because it's very expensive of actually charging and the short answer was they wouldn't even think of it because of the expected or perceived impact on ridership. Just point that out because I happened to be asking that question yesterday. I support it being free because I think that it's the only way to get people to use it. I remember to the point you were making that registered with me and that is
4:00:56 That we do have an air pollution control district for both Inua and Mono counties. And part of our compliance with that is to get people off the roads. And you get people off the roads in the wintertime because we have to use cinders on the road and the vehicles pick up the cinders and so forth. That's correct. And that is a requirement of us to match that. Thank you, Martin. One more person.
4:01:31 My name is Jim Lynch. I'm a 26-year resident of Mammoth Lakes and a 11-and-a-half-year business member of this community. I wasn't going to speak tonight, but my friend Johnny Guest just totally got me motivated to try to bring some positive vibe over this whole situation because this has been, it's going to, I don't envy the position you guys are in because this has just totally brought a total down spirit to this whole community and we need to get out. I'm not a key step. We need to form as a team. So what I'm bringing up is to try to resurrect an idea that was brought up.
4:02:01 Two and a half to three years ago from my good friend that I worked with on ski patrol, like 23 years ago I worked with him and it was a member, a friend of mine that grew up here, his name was Chris Lietza. Councilmember Bacon, I hope you remember this because he clearly was, I remember you were on the council and I think John Eastman was as well when he spoke. But what he talked about was trying, thought it would be a great idea to finally honor Dave McCoy.
4:02:28 So many towns give keys to cities to famous people and this and that and do amazing things. And one thing, you go anywhere. How many MLK, Martin Luther King street signs are there? I mean, I just remember being down at Staples Center and the Laker and the whole state community down there honored Chick Hearn. Chick Hearn Court is from Figueroa on 11th Street has now been renamed. And I just started thinking about when he said, like, an opportunity missed.
4:02:56 Dave McCoy is going to be 98 years old, and I know he's going to make it to 98. That man is amazing. We all came to this town because of that one man. He is the one that created the mountain. If you guys remember, the town became incorporated because of the growth of the mountain. I personally think we need to get back to the spirit and have people. I challenge you, Mayor Lehman, and Mayor Pro Tem, Rick Wood, because you guys are going to take us into the future.
4:03:25 To try to come up with a way, and the best thing to do would be, his idea was to rename Meridian Boulevard as McCoy Boulevard and rename Azimuth as Roma because they intersect and they came together as one. And I just could not think of a better opportunity than on August 24th, summer 2013, to have a community
4:03:50 And I just cannot.
4:04:19 You know, mention, like, what a better opportunity to maybe bundle an event like that, get, have something for this community to have, and not, and another way to actually get, you know, John Urdi, amazing marketer now for this town, to get behind this, my wife up at the ski area, Johnny Lynch Marketing, get ski industry personnel and all these people to get together to have a great, great, you know, because as my fellow swim team member lady that got up here and spoke,
4:04:49 Mel, she said, you know, everyone's looking at you, how we're going to come out of this, and I just think it'd be a great event to do that. And so I totally champion you guys, Town Manager Dave, we've got to lead us out of this total pit of despair, really. And even though, like I said, it's probably not the right time to do this, but...
4:05:12 I think it's a great opportunity to do this. I know, because I called Chris Lee today to ask him if it was appropriate for me to bring this up, and he said, I don't think it's the best setting, but go for it if you want. And I remember Joe Bacon, and Councilmember Bacon's concern was, you know, it was a bad economy two, two and a half, three years ago. It'd be tough for, you know, business members on Meridian to have to do things, but I look at it, the main business on that street is Stacey Barfield in a real estate. I'm sure she can afford some business.
4:05:40 New business cars and stuff like that. And personally, if I owned a business on that, I don't mean to be, I don't mean to, you know, despair, you know, but I just, seriously, I mean, what a great idea. And the main concern that I remember that was brought up, though, was to Ray Jarvis, and he said it would be more expensive for the town changing everything. But, and that's my, so my question to you, if you guys think this is a great idea, you know.
4:06:05 Jim, I couldn't think of... Actually, Jim, my concern was all of the residences on Meridian because there's so much of a multifamily. I mean, why not you take the... What condo complex is a residence on Meridian Boulevard? That's what I... There's 13 within one block, including, you know, including... You've been to my place, yeah. No, I worked at your place, but you're saying as a... So, I think it's a nice idea, but I think you might pick another street...
4:06:33 Another section that doesn't have quite so many businesses and residences on it. Well, now here's another take on this whole thing. He brought, obviously, in my opinion, he went to the wrong, he should have went to the Planning Commission, because it seems like everything Elizabeth Tenney does touches gold, right? That sign is going in. Chris's idea got totally swept under the mat, you know? I mean, now it's, now, I mean, it's personal now on me. I've lived here for 26 years, and this is a real bummer thing.
4:07:00 That was your concern. But the main concern was raised about more of the town having to change things. But personally, that sign got put in. How much money would have been eight street signs for the two main intersections? So much could have come together with how many wood carving artists, I mean, chainsaw artists are in town to do the other wood signs. There could have been so many things. But that got stuck under the thing, and we've got a massive sign going on that cost a lot of money.
4:07:29 Chris obviously just went to the wrong commission. Because I clearly remember him getting up, and you were the, I mean, not to be personal attack here, but you were, it was the main person that kind of shot him down on this, saying, great idea, but it's going to be, you know, real expensive. Joe, I personally, you know, I just personally didn't think, how would Jim be swept under the side, and now we have that signed?
4:07:55 What I'm saying, Jim, is I'm not against the idea. I just thought that wasn't the appropriate street. I think it's a great idea, and I think we need to find a street for it. Yeah. I think the timing may not be bad. Okay, sometimes, like you said, when things are really bad, it might be a great idea. Opportunities arise, right? Huh? Opportunities arise. And Johnny just said it, and so that's why I came up here and challenged myself to do it. I like the first thought. I love it.
4:08:27 I think it's great. That's what I want. Get some positive vibe back into this community. It's pretty draining right now. You're right. All right, thank you. Thanks, Jim. Thank you. You'd be a hard act to follow, Jim. No disrespect to Jimmy, but Dave just told me I'm going to be changing all the signs. So I would like to actually follow that, but get back to the
4:09:08 Yeah. Main topic. Yeah. So I've got a couple comments if you don't mind. Absolutely. And the first one really is about supplanting. So if this – if Whitmore Park – this is how everyone's been asking, well, how could this park be on the cut list? And, you know, I've thought a lot about this. I was your old parks and rec director back in 2000. And so I've got a lot of affinities and a lot of, you know, strong feelings about it. If Whitmore Park and Pool –
4:09:36 If it were on forest land and it were called a trail, you'd be funding it. So we've spent more than a million dollars in the forest since Measure R has been approved on lands that we don't own, we don't control, and we freely spend money in the forest that is managed by some other entity. So in my mind, we own the land or we have the land. I don't see the supplanting in the same sense of
4:10:07 Because we're supplanting the federal government. In my mind, we're supplanting now, if that's the rule, that we're spending money on existing infrastructure. 300 miles of trails is part of our trail system plan. And so it's all built. It's there. We spend money. We've spent over a million dollars in planning money without really turning dirt in the past three years. So for us to spend $168,000 or $200,000, whatever that might be, to me was kind of pocket change.
4:10:37 Relative to the idea that if it were on the forest land and it was called a trail, we would have just spent $300,000 a day where you approved a list of projects for $300,000 because it's on federal land and it's in our trail system and it's part of that system. So I don't have any heartburn at all. Why not spend money on town stuff? So let's get kind of a personal view on it. I think it's a paradigm that we've kind of created for ourselves.
4:11:08 The other thing I want to mention is these are very, very difficult and complex problems. And there's no doubt in my mind you wouldn't be here today dealing with these things in the way you have without Marianna. There's been a lot of concern and criticism about how much money she makes, how much time she spends, and who is she and what is she doing. But it's been really an invaluable resource for us. We don't really talk about this very much. We maybe should.
4:11:36 But the fact is, between the work that Andrew's firm did, Andy himself, myself, Marianna, all the other folks, we probably have saved the town, and this is a bad context, this is all bad stuff, probably more than $60 million. We reduced the RITA mandate from $43 million down to $29.5 million. Over time, that RITA mandate, if we hadn't paid it,
4:12:01 Would have been at least $60 million over a 10-year period. If we had financed the $43 million, it would have been close to $85 or $90, which were some of our rigid calculations. We knew we had problems with the ballast, Hot Creek deals through the development agreement. There was at least $20 million sitting on the table with potential lawsuits over those things. So you start adding all these numbers together, it becomes a very, very large deal that we were dealing with. Without Marianna,
4:12:29 With her capacities to analyze, deliver, speak to complex issues in simplistic forms, not that she's simplistic, but we are, and I think it's been very, very, very helpful, and I would defend that as long as I would need to. I think we've got huge value out of that expense. She's been loyal, capable, and I think she's done a great service for us. I just want to make that clear. In my mind, I'm very supportive of that, and I know that the council is. Couldn't agree with you more, Dave.
4:13:00 And I can't tell the public. I mean, there are so many e-mails and there's so much information that all of us have seen go back and forth. I mean, it's crazy. I mean, when I came on to council, I remember talking with Neil McCarroll about it and saying, you know, how long should I expect to be spending on this? And I think he told me, well, you know, if you're going to do more than most council, you probably need to be spending more than 15 hours a week on it.
4:13:28 And I'll tell you what, it's become a full-time job. And I see the emails coming from Marianna and Dave. I mean, I'm talking all hours of the night. When I wake up in the morning, there's emails. I mean, these guys are up working at ridiculous hours. And I don't think people really, really understand that. It's hard. And as hard as the situation is, the hours we're putting in.
4:13:52 I know it would only have been far more complex, and we would have a lot more issues we'd be facing if we didn't have both of those people over there, including Andy, too, who I know we can call, and he calls right back if he doesn't answer the phone. So we have some excellent people here, and I think we have excellent people all the way through our entire staff, our police force, everywhere, and they do need to be given credit, and I know that's a feel-good statement I'm making, but...
4:14:19 I'll tell you, I've worked with them now a long time, and it's all true, and everybody's working really, really hard, so I appreciate both of you, and Andy, thank you, and the rest of staff and police. I do appreciate all you guys. Thank you. All right. Anybody else have anything they want to add tonight? Okay, well then, with that, we're going to move into closed session. Yeah. We'll keep going.