Town Council
· recording 3 hr 32 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
368 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
7:16 Very quickly, I think I mentioned the discussion paper that was produced by Diat and Bacha, which you've received. That provides some of the background and, as I mentioned, those key questions to be looking at. Just a little bit of background on Diat and Bacha. I think I mentioned that already. And that will be the workshop content. So just very briefly, the legal authority for community benefits is well established in state law and in U.S. law. Many cities have these types of programs.
7:46 It's part of the overall police powers of the city, within the realm of the city to impose these kind of regulations, and particularly to request that projects provide public benefits when they are receiving density bonuses and incentives for that development. So it's that relationship and that balance that can be negotiated through a community benefits program.
8:11 The origin of our community benefits policy is in the general plan. A couple of really significant policies that were adopted and placed in that document, including policy L3F, which sets up the idea of a framework to ensure that the town gets community benefits when it approves development projects and sets up some parameters for that as a series of actions, which are listed in this slide.
8:34 One of those important ideas being that of a formula-based method to calculate, to evaluate those projects and that trade. And then the second policy, which is really significant, is policy L5G, which is the one that, in the previous iteration of the general plan, allowed for double density for hotel projects, for hotel and transit lodging projects, from 40 up to 80 rooms per acre.
9:00 And all you had to do was provide understructure parking. Many of the projects that we see in town, the Econa Lodge, I think is one of them, there's a number of hotel projects that were approved with additional density under this provision. When we updated the general plan, there was significant desire to raise the bar on that expectation. And so this policy was drafted to frame up that higher expectation of what the town might receive in exchange for the community benefits that, or development incentives that it was offering in the form of this hotel density.
9:29 And so these are some of the key points of that policy. It applies to the commercial zones, it applies to lodging projects, and it allows for that double density to be awarded. In 2008 and 2009, following the general plan adoption, staff worked extensively with the council, with the planning commission, with stakeholders to formulate what was really thought of as a bridge policy that would take us from the broader framework of the general plan to something that would more
9:59 Officially guide staff's implementation of that policy, particularly evaluation of community benefits, a methodology for that, providing a definition of what community benefits are. And I think the key thing to note here is that community benefits under the general plan are things that the town wouldn't ordinarily get. So they're extras. These are things that aren't development impact mitigations. They aren't the ordinary infrastructure that's normally needed. They aren't the normal fees.
10:28 Improvements that a project typically has to provide. These are over and above what the town would ordinarily expect to get. And that bar is very well defined in the interim policy. And then secondly, it defines incentives in three ways. One is changes to the building envelope, allowing different setbacks, height limits potentially, allowing financial incentives, things like rebate fees, and finally, density increases as well.
10:56 And those are laid out. The copy of that policy is attached to your packet. And then finally, as I mentioned, a framework for evaluating those projects. Noting here that it's really kind of a case-by-case framework. You take a project, they are able to come forward with a proposal, have an early review or input from the council, and then work with staff to really bring that back and do...
11:21 Often quite detailed financial analysis which may require a second economic peer review to make sure that it meets the financial balance. Is the town getting enough for what it's offering in exchange for the benefits that it's receiving? A couple of projects have gone through that process. Some of you were involved with those approvals with Old Mammoth Place and Clearwater. It was also an idea that was included in the North Village specific plan amendment associated with Mammoth Crossing and with the Mammoth View Project.
11:50 And then the other thing that we've done, which is relevant here, is we've completed neighborhood district planning for most of the areas of town that are important and relevant to community benefits. And that's important because the policy says look to district planning to tell you what the right benefits are and where they should go. And so we've done a tremendous amount of work in 2010 and 2011 to work through those different district plans. And each of them includes
12:19 A list or some indication of what the right set of community benefits is for each district. And the interim policy reflects that and directs us to look there to find out what we should be getting in exchange for these incentives. So I am going to turn it over to Michael. Now there's a set of five questions and then I think there's two optional questions. The five are really kind of the key.
12:44 Ones that we'd like to get some direction on tonight. The others are time-permitting. So, Michael, I'll turn it over to you unless the group has any questions. I have a question. I think in 2007, it was resolution in 2009. Should any benefit have to be a capital improvement or can it be something like ? That will be, that's one of the discussion questions that will be asked is if we come up with a finite list, could you propose something else different?
13:16 Instead of one of those physical improvements. But generally, I think they are thought of as physical improvements for the most part. Yes. If I could, I think that's part of the process to develop this formula and this framework is to have that conversation about priorities and weighting and value of those things. And so part of developing the formula is having that conversation beforehand.
20:03 I think Matthew was saying, rather than doing it every time with every project at the dais. So you've come to sort of an agreement about what you want and what it's worth, and then you can then approve projects. Maybe if I could add something really quickly. We are, as well as doing this, working with Dait and Bhatia on our commercial zoning standards. And one of the things that they're helping us do is have a much better articulated zoning framework that's about design expectations, about building envelope,
33:39 You know, buildings fitting into the street and being compatible with our local context and design. And so the two things go together. The zoning for commercial sets the design expectation and the non-negotiable elements of that design. And then this is really about how does it fit into that established framework in terms of the, you know, what does a building look like? I think that's a great direction. I'm sorry, Jo. Thank you, Michael. I guess we'll hang up now and move on to our next item. So appreciate your...
39:51 Thank you very much. Appreciate the input on this, and I'll be talking with you soon. Now for something completely different, as they say. So hopefully we can get this done fairly quickly. I know there's a lot of people here for this item. So the second part of the workshop relates to the question of single-family transit rental, well, transit rental in our single-family zones.
41:00 This was brought up as part of the restructuring discussion. There was a lot of public comment. There continues to be a lot of public comment and input on this question. And so we wanted to have this workshop as an opportunity for an initial framing of really two key things. What are the key issues that we should be looking at as we work with our stakeholders, with the Planning Commission, with the Town Council to review and vet these issues?
41:28 Excuse me. What should a work program look like for doing this? What are the most important steps? What are the most important opportunities for input from the public, from stakeholders, and from the Planning Commission and Town Council as we bring that program forward? And then related to that, if we do have a focus group or committee, what should that group look like? What should that composition be? What would be the most useful formulation of that group? So we have posed a series of
41:57 of questions, which hopefully we can get through fairly quickly. One of the first attachments to your packet, I think it's three, is a table of issues. And we put this together based on all of the handouts, the discussion that we've had with different stakeholders, emails that we've received, conversations that we've had, things that we've heard in public meetings, to try and capture really the breadth of the issues that we've heard.
42:25 We've sorted them into a set of four different categories. I'm not going to go through all of the issues because there's quite a few of them. But those categories are legal and regulatory issues. Those are things that relate to relationships to CC&Rs that has come up, to the general plan. Sorry, it's not on the screen. The second category is neighborhood impacts, what I would call quality of life type of issues, noise, traffic, parking, nuisance, neighbor complaints, that sort of thing, as well as public services impacts, police and fire and so on.
42:54 Fiscal and economic impacts, and this is a broad topic that addresses really the question of what is the effect of this on the town finances, also what is the effect of this on the existing rental market, and then what are the costs to the town to potentially enforce a program? So those are all types of questions that go into that category, and finally, and related to that is enforcement. How can the town effectively enforce a program? What resources would be needed? What would be the key concerns in having an enforcement program?
43:24 So we would like to get your input on the first question, which is really, does the initial issues list that you've been provided adequately capture, at least as a starting point, kind of the discussion and the research that we need to do and need to have and the topics that we need to be looking at going forward? Or have we missed anything?
43:55 So to that question, I think that's a really important one, and obviously...
44:14 One of the key pieces of feedback that we got from the stakeholders group when we met with them on the 25th was there's a couple of questions we really need to answer and look at first before we go too far down the road of making decisions about whether to implement a program or not. There's a lot of work to be done to answer some of those initial questions, and those are exactly, as you say, John, the geographic scope. Where do CCNRs, how do the CCNRs relate to town policies?
44:42 Andy might have some comment on that. And, you know, the town typically does not enforce CCNRs. And it's, you know, it's not as cut and dried, I think, as we might hope in terms of being able to make those decisions based on the CCNRs that exist. So, right, so in terms of having a process, answering that question first, coming back to this group is part of the process to say, let's look at those questions first, return, and get more direction.
45:16 And it was basically, you have a question of, I'll say it the same way, by the time you take out those areas that have a CCMR says left, would you really want to do this in the family?
45:40 I was troubled when I read this because the whole process was just driving us.
46:04 And when I read this...
46:24 All kinds of claims and, you know, lots of reasons why we should do this, but no specifics. I mean, really, I didn't get out of this what I needed to get out of it. And so that would be my very first basic question.
46:36 Why are we doing this? Because at what cost are we doing this to the people in the hospital? You think of the impacts of the neighborhoods? I think something like this requires a job. I don't know if that's number one to the first, number two, highest quality of life for residents. I don't see this as a minor zone to change. I think this is absolutely huge. And I wonder why we're going forward. I realize we're looking for revenue because two second homeowners.
47:02 I think that's part of the analysis.
47:29 Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
47:59 And I think very easily we need to analyze and look at all the facts out there. In one way or another, I think we need to at least address it. My personal opinion.
48:09 I think it's a second issue. I just don't think there's too much out there for me to know for me to happen this quickly. Do I think we need to have a discussion?
48:32 Right, and there's many dimensions to the argument, and what I'm coming to realize as I think about these issues is, in some cases, it might be about the program, the nature of the program.
48:47 It may help to solve some of the problems or it may not, but until you think about the program, you can't fully understand whether or not it's something that you want to do or not. So it's a bit of a chicken and egg because you need to think about the program as well as the issues, and until you know the issues, you can't think about the program. And so we've tried to define at least to put some sideboards on the range of questions, the research topics, and I think as Joe was suggesting, there are some high-level questions that are really important to say, is there enough in it to...
49:16 to even be worth moving forward, but we still have, that's still going to take some work to address that particular question.
49:30 I want to talk about this a little bit, but I have looked at some of the CCNRs, and they're massive, because some of them are available at 50 years old.
49:58 Not really drafted this in mind. So it's not as clear as we want it to be. Just looking at CCRs is not going to be a very good indication of whether they'll do a lot of transparency or not. In some cases, you're going to be able to look at it. I'd like to see the analysis. Absolutely. I think that that's what our discussion took about. We had some discussions. There were so many questions that came up.
50:24 So there's benefits and there's huge costs on each side, but really what we need to know how it works.
50:48 So there's a few deal breakers at the beginning of the process.
51:16 So what we're working with staff on through the planning commission and through the town manager is let's get those questions out there. Let's get them answered.
51:35 And it's not driving an opinion right now, but it is, here's the question, yes, we can do that any further down, because who knows, we may kind of go out of the program, because that means what's happening, but it's not something we do perfect. I would not say that we'd be able to do this thing for six months.
52:04 One of the benefits of this, or my suggestion, would be to have them continue down that path and train forward towards both sides so we can at least see without no verses.
52:18 We put it on.
52:47 We put it on a discussion. Well, it just is a discussion. But, and I agree, it's not one of the things that we decided, you know, I doubt that it would be decided by August 2015 because the amount of resources. And I also, since our community has been involved, I don't necessarily want them until we've got those basic questions, those kind of questions answered. You know, I love the fact that they're a community that we're talking to them.
53:17 So that's, I think, a really good segue to this just made, and hopefully we can cover this briefly, is that phased work effort. What we've proposed in your packet is exactly that, is to work over the next, you know, approximately two months to do that research on regarding the CC&Rs, get to work with our attorney to have, you know, having the town's legal opinion on this is important too.
53:47 As well as from the outside stakeholders. And then bringing that back early next year with some options to the Town Council Planning Commission and deciding whether or not at that point to proceed with more in-depth work to develop a program. So that's our current proposal and I want to see if that seemed like a good approach to the group sounds like it is.
54:15 And then finally, just we have talked a lot about working with our stakeholders. We have some really great, enthusiastic, energetic people that are really engaged with this question on both sides. You know, there is an effect interest for those groups to continue to come together. We had a very positive meeting a couple of weeks ago where, you know, we were able to just talk through some of these things. So I wanted to ask this group.
54:41 If we should continue to meet with those stakeholders as part of the process, if there was any desire in particular to have representation from either the Planning Commission or Town Council on that group, and if there was a desire to have potentially some other people who are maybe a little more neutral in the process if they're willing to step forward and do that to help to be part of the discussion as well.
55:16 We're fitting it in.
55:46 Thank you.
56:09 Thank you very much. Okay, we'll go ahead and get started with our regular meeting Wednesday, November 7th.
1:03:40 There was nothing to report out of our closed session meeting. And with that, we'll go ahead and start with the roll call, please. Jamie. Here. Here. Here. Here. Okay, thank you. With that, we'll do the Pledge of Allegiance. Rick, would you like to lead us in the pledge? Certainly. Please rise and join me in the pledge. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands.
1:04:13 One nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Okay, thank you. With that, we'll move on to public comments. Is there anybody in the audience that would like to make public comment on anything that is not on tonight's agenda? Please come up at the podium, state your name, and we'd like to hear what you have to say. Joe? My name is Joe Pernoma. I've been back from town about 15 years now.
1:04:51 Just pretty much everybody knows I'm a big motocross guy. That's where Russell knows that. And really my big fight was trying to get the track back open. But unfortunately, I've been watching the meetings the last few months. And I think it's just time for maybe my opinion as a personal person in town, what I'm seeing on my level, what I call kind of the under-50 club. First of all, of course,
1:05:22 All the, do I get five minutes? Yeah. You know, all these things, it's cuts, it's a pool, it's a big opportunity for the kids, it's a big, you know, it's really good for our athletes, it's a really good something for the young, for them something to do, because a lot of the young from 12 and under are really being left behind. They haven't got much. I work at a store, these kids come in.
1:05:50 I ask them every time, and they come in and buy candy and buy potato chips, and like I said, what are you doing today? We're bored. We have nothing to do. I go, what about the skate park? Yeah, I'll go to the skate park. They only did that for a couple hours. But from then on, they're just really, they're bored. And all we're doing is actually making these kids obese. When I went to school here, back in the day, the town was growing to be like an extreme recreational town back in my days. You're Dave McCoy's and a lot of your athletes.
1:06:18 We have some top athletes in this town, and we're not really getting much recognition, and the reason they are top athletes is because of what we have to provide. Now I'll just kind of go on this thing. I just thought, this is my opinion, and I'm sure a lot of the people in TV land, I don't know about some of the people in here, but a lot of the people in TV land will definitely agree with me out there. First of all, like David Wilbeck said, stop funding the U.S. Forestry. U.S. Forestry screwed us. I'm a big motocross guy, I'm a big OHV guy.
1:06:46 And they destroyed our OHV in this town. We at one time had a Disneyland of OHV. And as it increased, what they did was they shut it down. Now the Mammoth Mountain, when their business increased, they were able to improve and expand and add runs and add lifts and the whole deal. So to me, OHV is being discriminated in this area. And it's one of our big money sources. This year,
1:07:15 The motocross race, we had a kid who came, he was 14, 13 years old. The kid was a ripper. That kid is ripped on everybody. Any bike you put this kid on, he ripped. Kawasaki pulled that kid over. He signed a $400,000 contract with Kawasaki. $400,000. I don't see any runners at 13 years old being signed on to any kind of contract for any money. That kid's already out to a great, great future.
1:07:44 Stop funding John Wentworth, an MLTPA. And why I say that is because he's a non-profit and he can go ahead and get some grant writers and start, go ahead and find his own money at this point. Especially when they want to close the pool. I feel our Chamber of Commerce is really not giving them zero. When it comes to that, the reason why I say that is because my field, anytime I call organizations, call manufacturers, I call other areas,
1:08:12 They ask about the Chamber of Commerce, what they do for our town. They really don't do anything. Businesses are bad. The service in businesses are bad. Everybody's not on board in the same way. And our visitors just kind of go, why bother going in there? Stop funding the Castor, Smith, Wood running track. That's something that's out of the area, something you can't really get to. What a lot of people don't know is Snow Creek offered to build a track, help pay for it, and dome it. And they said no.
1:08:42 So, again, we're dealing with daily DWP. They're suing us. For the rec commission, get a younger generation in the rec commission, rec rate, not condo managers and locksmiths. So this way here, we can go ahead and really start focusing on getting the people that are driving, you know, all the millions of cars that are driving on 35, that are going to Tahoe for paddleboard events.
1:09:09 I mean, everything. Those guys are doing everything right now. Tahoe is killing us. I mean, we're just a joke. We're a retirement home compared to them. And again, stop stealing the Measure R or Measure U money. It's not what I voted for. I voted for that stuff to go into recreationals and building stuff, and that would be like a BMX track for the kids. Maybe go into the industrial park, put in a BMX park of some kind. So that way it's year-round.
1:09:36 Give back to the kids, because the kids are getting ripped off. Again, the whole deal, too, a lot of people don't understand. What's happening is the younger Jim... Thank you. Joe? Did you have a couple other comments? No. Okay. Anybody else from the public? Yes. Jim Smith. I'm one of the Wood Smith Caster folks on the track.
1:10:09 We're actually having the grand opening, and we've been coming with the track on the 17th at noon. You're all welcome. We were trying to get the five of you guys to do a little race, but I don't know where that's at. And then, Matt, were you going to do a pole vault?
1:10:24 You're going to be in town? What are you going to do for it? I'm not going to be in town. I want to do it. If it was a different day, I could do it, but I misplanned, and I'm not going to be in town that day. All right, so we'll schedule something else for you. Make sure everybody's out there. I'll be out. I'll try to get in shape. Okay, so just a bunch of small events. We'll do a novel run, but noon on the 17th. Okay? Thanks, Jim. Anybody else from the public have any comments?
1:10:51 Okay. With that, we'll go on to Councilmember Reports. Jo, do you have any? No. John. I have no, Mr. Mayor. Michael. Yeah, I just have a couple. Mayor Lehman, I attended a monthly MLT meeting today and just a couple of quick updates on air service. Our October inbound load from LAX, in fact, was very strong at 54% versus 39% from last year, so it was up considerably.
1:11:20 Even since we had less flights at four a week versus seven, so our cost decreased on the subsidy. December 14th, Alaska starts their second daily flight from LAX, which is a morning flight, which is about a week ahead of the other flights coming in. On December 19th, we get all the United flights, which are from San Diego, Orange County, and San Francisco.
1:11:45 And then there's a pretty solid rumor out there of something exciting coming soon regarding a discounted air pack program that's going to benefit the community. And that hopefully will be announced shortly. Stay tuned. And do you want to explain the air pack, how it might work? I don't know if I can go in. Okay. I'll hold off on that. Okay. Anything else? No. That's it. All right. Mayor Pro Tem, Wood. I attended the Man Flakes Housing monthly meeting Monday, actually.
1:12:14 And the item on the agenda that I want to discuss with the council is before us later on, so I'll keep my, I'll reserve my comments to them. That's all I have. Okay. Thank you. Next we'll move on to department reports and emerging issues. Were there any departments, emerging issues, Dave? Commission updates. No, I'm sorry. We went right past it. Sorry about that. Commission updates. Any commissioners out there?
1:12:46 Okay. We'll move on then to department reports and emerging issues. Any department heads? Nope. Wow. Okay. We'll move right along. With that, we will – did you have something, Steve? Okay. We'll go ahead and move on then to the consent agenda. Was there any items that council wanted to pull? Mr. Mayor, I'd like to pull item 7 for discussion, please. Okay. Michael.
1:13:17 Anybody else on council? Anybody from the public want to pull any items? Yes. Okay, that one's pulled. Okay, so we have item number seven pulled by Michael and a member of the public. So, Michael, do you want to go ahead and... Do you want to do the motion first on the other ones? Oh, sure. Okay, let's go ahead. I will move that we approve consent agenda items one, two, three, four, five, six, and eight. I'll second it. Okay, we have a motion and a second.
1:13:46 We'll call Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Okay. Motion passes 5-0. And then we have item number 7 pulled by Michael and a member of the public who wanted to speak on that as well. Yeah, go ahead. I'm going to speak first. Okay. Donette, did you want to speak first? Donette Hustleton. I have a question on the website, manual maintenance.
1:14:16 Do you have a budget for that whole breakout of the $40,000? And if not, can you tell me anything where that money's going, how much of it's going to MLTPA, how much of it's going to the town? It seems like a lot of money possibly should go out to bid to see what kind of lower amounts that we could get on that maintenance part of it. I just think that it's a lot of money, and I think we could maybe get that cost down. Okay.
1:14:44 So I don't know if anyone can answer the budget part of it. There is a budget breakdown in the packet here, and it's $34,700 total for the maintenance, and basically $28,500 of that goes to MLTPA annual CMS contract, $3,700 basically goes to MLTPA for a one-time hard launch expense, and then $24,500
1:15:12 50 goes to the Town of Mammoth Lakes for annual site hosting maintenance. Okay, so the 24 is an annual thing. I got that whole thing. But the 28, what is that going to be consist of? Is that like, you know, when people call in, there's a problem? You know, is it just the website maintaining? I think that maybe for $38,000 or $34,000, maybe we should consider going out to bed on that when we go out to bed on other things similar to that.
1:15:42 And see what we can get for that amount of money. I think it's a lot of money. Okay. Thank you, Donette. I'll ask John to come up and see if he can answer it, but I wanted to ask Michael first. My only comments for discussion was that, you know, I'd like to start to see on this and other, you know, other payables we're doing a little bit more accountability as far as breakdowns on the receivables, on the payables, a little more detail.
1:16:10 Breakdowns coming our way for us to review so we can really get a clear idea of what we're paying for and then making sure that we're getting exactly that on the other end. It's a little bit more detail. Okay. That was my comment on it. Okay. And the only comment I had, and I was actually going to pull it, but Michael had pulled it as well. It was just a little bit along the same lines as Donette, and I just wanted to know.
1:16:39 The 28-5 really entailed a little bit of what both of you said was what was entailed in that 28-5. And, John, I know you're here, and I just thought if I could ask you if you were available to answer that. Matthew, can I ask it in just a slightly different way? Is the major portion of the 28-5 that goes to MLTPA says daily operations, 19,500. So what are daily operations?
1:17:06 Well, thanks for all your questions. I think that this has been kind of a long and interesting process, and I would really suggest that the council find a way to work efficiently with your staff because we provided a multi-page, very detailed, hourly breakdown of every cost associated with this two months ago. This document was prepared by staff thinking that the council didn't want to have a certain level of detail. They sent this to me last week and said, we're going to send them this nice
1:17:35 High-level roll-up documents so you guys can understand it. I would defer you to Dave and to Ray for the documents we submitted a couple months ago to try to get the detail that went into this. A couple things to keep in mind. You have a website now that's been live for two months with no maintenance. Nobody is maintaining that website. Right now that website, which is articulating your recreation opportunities, is telling everybody that it's this beautiful summer experience here in Mammoth Lakes.
1:18:03 The transition to fall never happened because this management contract was never in place. The transition to winter, I hope it can happen, but unless there's a management contract in place, it's not going to happen. If you guys really want to start drilling down into this, you might want to maybe come back to MLTPA. We put up about $5,000 to convene the Forest Service, town staff, to get the technical team and the content team together so that there would be a partnered, engaged,
1:18:30 Functioning Management Plan for this website at our own expense. $4,500 we put into that to get the partners together, to get the team in place, and to get the site launched. If you think that that's not a good idea, I would suggest you may want to take the site down until you get this stuff figured out. I would defer you today for the details of where the dollars are being spent. I can certainly come back and provide you that information. But again, this document was prepared by staff because they didn't think you guys wanted to see the detail.
1:18:58 So I can answer any other questions you have, but again, you've got a site that's live, that's sitting out there. If you do a Google search for the Mammoth Lakes Trail System, you get to that trail system. John Urdi is very patiently waiting to get the management contract in place so we can start tying it in with Mammoth Lakes Tourism and all the rest of it. So I kind of defer to you guys just how you want to go. So back to my question, the 28-5, what
1:19:27 What are you guys doing for that? Just real quick, quick. I'm not asking for the overall details. Is it putting in pictures? I don't know. I just want to know what I'm getting for $25. Sure. So I wasn't prepared to speak to this night. Again, maybe the staff could go back to the detail we provided them. But essentially, about an hour, you get an hour's worth a day of someone looking at all the analytics, looking at all the things that are happening with the site, dealing with...
1:19:52 You get responses and reviews from the public who are engaging with the site to make sure everything is working properly. You get a quarterly transition of the site from its recreation season from summer to fall, from fall to winter, from winter to spring, winter to summer. You get the coordination of the forest service, the town staff, Mammoth Lakes Tourism to make all this stuff happen. The town has been going back and forth with us whether things are lump sum contracts, whether they're time of material contracts. Certainly this is a
1:20:20 This was reviewed by the town staff. This was reviewed by the MLTSCC. All of them proceed reasonable at that time. We can do it on time and materialist basis. If not that much time is needed, that's not a problem. But you get a managed website between three different agencies articulating recreation opportunities over four different seasons and articulating all the great recreational opportunities here in Mammoth Lakes.
1:20:44 Okay. So, John, then the 19.5 on the daily operations works out to about $66 a day for somebody to do that, daily updates. Right. I didn't do that math, but something like that. That's kind of what I was getting at. Okay, so we just went through a thing where the site, again, was live. It was spammed by trolling some web presence out there. Started sending all kinds of weird, gibberey, garbages, messages through the review thing back to the website. We dealt with that at our own expense with the web programmers dealing with it. We took care of that problem.
1:21:12 Again, the sites didn't arrive, and it's, yeah, it's about $66 today for someone to look at that stuff. Okay, that's it? Okay, fine. Good, thank you. Okay. Your question answered? Yep. Okay. With that, yeah, Dave? So in response to the question about the contract, early on in the measure of our process, the council approved a resolution that allows the
1:21:42 The staff to bypass bidding and RFP requirements on behalf of the trail system. So we've been using that all along. There hasn't been competition requests for proposals and those kinds of things for certain work that has been accomplished. We've been using that format. So if that's something the council would like us to look at, we certainly can do that. But we have not really taken an active role in doing requests and so forth under that previous decision by previous council. Okay.
1:22:12 Me personally, I just wanted to get a general breakdown. I hadn't seen that comprehensive breakdown. I think John answered it. It's somebody going on there. It makes sense. $68 an hour or whatever to go on there for a day to check it and do all this stuff. That was really the question I had. That's it. That's all. Anybody else have any other questions, comments?
1:22:39 I know John Urdi's pretty excited to get the same thing. I need to explain that. I love the site. I think it's great. Not a question on that. Matthew, then I would move that we approve option one. Second. Okay. All in favor of... Jamie, we will call. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Going from commissions to the council. Okay.
1:23:08 With that, we will move on to our policy item number nine. And Mariano. Mayor, Councilmembers, community staff, I am before you tonight with some repeated information on the proposed restructuring plan as well as some new information concerning the results of the recent online survey. So let me walk you through the slides that contains that information and then...
1:23:49 We'll be available for any questions. What we're going to discuss with you tonight in the agenda report as well as in this presentation are the following. One is a summary of the restructuring plan that has not changed since October 18th, results of the online survey which is new information, responses to questions which I will briefly mention
1:24:21 Won't really spend time going through them. Future public meetings are also included in the agenda bill. And as a reminder, we're now talking about what we call phase one of restructuring that focuses on the immediate financial needs and proposes a number of cuts. But there are going to be additional phases, mainly focusing on the analysis of the alternative service delivery models, including
1:24:50 Using volunteers, outsourcing, joint provision of services and so on. There's also going to be additional information that will be presented by Community and Economic Development. There are some slides from Public Works, but unfortunately our Public Works Director is out sick, so we will not be going through the slides, but the information is there and I'll mention that.
1:25:17 The proposed restructuring plan, again, has not changed since we presented it or re-presented on October the 18th. The details of the plan are included in attachment A. It's a multi-page document that includes the detailed reductions that are proposed. On this slide, what we showed is a summary of those proposed reductions.
1:25:43 In the Police Department, the elimination of up to seven sworn positions effective July 1st. So in conjunction with the next budget cycle. And the rest of the reductions are slated for January 1st of this next calendar year. And that of 1.5 positions in the Community and Economic Development Department.
1:26:08 Public Works and Transit would consolidate road and parks maintenance to eliminate the position. In parks and rec, the town would discontinue funding with more facilities and also eliminate some positions related to that. In administration, the vacancies for the budget manager and IT specialist would go away and be assumed by either contract or the existing employees.
1:26:35 And town-wide, we will have a number of initiatives that are spelled out in the detailed attachment A, but one of the most important ones is establishing a volunteer program. So these are the recommended measures that get us funding-wise where we need to be, and that is save approximately $500,000 in the current fiscal year and almost $2 million on an ongoing basis after that.
1:27:04 What I present here, and we discussed this in great detail on October 18th in our report, are the alternatives, possible alternatives. This is not an exclusive list, but it is a list of some of the alternatives that we discussed with the Council. These are the alternatives that we also sought input on in the resident survey. These alternatives are not factored in our plan. The savings that you see here
1:27:33 Or estimated savings, but they're not recommendations, they're simply alternatives that you may or may not want to consider. Among those alternatives are further cuts to MLT, MLH, or ASTA to replace some of the cuts in the previous slide to police, community development, and so on. Also among alternatives are the use of Measure R funds to keep the Whitmore facilities operational.
1:28:01 And a number of tax-raising alternatives. It is important to point out that on the taxes, if there is an initiative or a decision or direction to place any of the taxes on the ballot, all of these taxes require voter approval, everything from 50% to 2 thirds, depending on the tax. So if there is a decision to pursue these taxes and place them on the ballot, the council would have to give direction to staff.
1:28:31 Through legislation no later than January or February of this year in order for us to start generating revenue in July of next year. So there's going to be a significant lag in the collection of the taxes. And last but not least, we have talked to you about enhancing the collection of COT by allowing nightly rentals of single-family residences. But again, none of these alternatives are part of your structuring plan.
1:29:01 What I will discuss next are the results of the online survey that we recently conducted. I would point out to you, Council, and the community that there are exhibits that contain a lot of information that came out from the survey, a lot of the comments that we received, a lot of the qualitative, so to speak, descriptive information, and all of them are in the following exhibits.
1:29:24 3A, 3B, 3C, and 3D. What we have done in Exhibits 3A, 3C is categorized responses based on the residents. So, for example, Exhibit 3A contains all of the responses from everyone who responded. Exhibit 3B contains responses only for those who identify themselves as full-time residents and or business owners. Exhibit 3C.
1:29:52 3C contains responses for full-time or part-time residents and or business owners and 3D shows all the responses again by residency status. We have done an analysis at two levels. One is just the basic quantitative analysis which basically just came from the SurveyMonkey tool. It's something that that website, that service does for you based on the yes-no responses.
1:30:22 Because you can categorize them in quantitative, i.e. numerical terms. Qualitative analysis was performed by looking at the open-ended questions and comments because you can't really categorize them in yes, no, one, two, numerical categories. So the qualitative analysis, and again, qualitative analysis is very subjective, very individual, and we would invite the council.
1:30:48 The comments themselves suggest that the following
1:31:16 Seem to be priorities for those in 27 that provided comments. Leadership and accountability, financial stability and sustainability, quality of life, public safety, and that the community is willing to unite and help the town get past this lawsuit. On the quantitative side, there are so many ways to look at the responses again. What we have done here on these slides,
1:31:45 is looked at responses from the residents, full-time or part-time, and or business owners. So in other words, we eliminated responses from those who do not live here and simply visit. The great majority of responders are of 678, 603 identify themselves as residents or business owners, so you're looking at the great majority of responses. So if you look at these responses,
1:32:14 With regards to a question on taxes as an alternative to police tax, almost 36% indicated that they are not opposed to the cuts in police, and for those who are opposed, less than each of the taxes that were listed as a possible tax, which I included in the previous slide, everything from the admissions tax to the utility tax, each of those taxes received less than 36% support.
1:32:44 Very low support for the utility tax, 16%, and a higher support for an admissions tax, 35.3%. If you look at cuts to measures A and C, i.e. tourism, housing, and transit, as alternatives to police cuts, in response to this question, 33.5% of respondents indicated that they're not opposed to cuts in police.
1:33:10 And when given options to cut elsewhere in measures A and C, 31.5% favored cuts in tourism and 43.7% cuts to housing. When asked the question as to whether respondents would support other ways to seek reductions in costs in collaboration with the Police Officers Association, basically looking at restructuring the salaries, benefits, and any other costs that
1:33:44 are subject to the current union contract. In response to that question, 58.1% support us seeking those ways to reduce costs instead of making cuts in the police department. 25.4% support seeking those savings in addition to the cuts. As far as Measure R is concerned, and using Measure R funding,
1:34:12 To support the Whitmore Pool and Field, 59.5% indicated that they support using Measure R funds to place the town's commitment to those facilities to the tune of $120,000 per year. So that concludes the results of the survey. I could take questions or continue with the presentation. We can take questions at the end.
1:34:45 Why do we keep going? Let's keep going. Okay. The additional information that we included in the agenda packet, as I mentioned before, contains responses to questions that we found to be relevant to your deliberations tonight and on December the 5th. There are some questions with regards to revenues, with regards to the police department and so on, and responses to those questions can be found in attachment too.
1:35:15 I mentioned future public meetings. They're listed in the agenda bill. So with that, we have a few slides for community and economic development. You may recall that in the past few meetings, we talked very specifically about police. The police chief was here before you. Was his response to the proposed cuts and how changes in the police department would take place?
1:35:42 We also talked a little bit about the Whitmore Pool Cuts. We have not had a chance to discuss community and economic development or public works in transit. In public works in transit, the majority of the cuts have to do with the Whitmore Pool and Park. And again, unfortunately, Ray Jarvis is not here tonight to address them. But Ellen is here, and she's going to walk you through the community and economic development. Thank you. Thank you, Marianna. Good evening, Mayor, Members of the Council. Ellen Clark, Principal Planner.
1:36:19 This is just a brief presentation that we developed in response to the restructuring plan regarding our service delivery work program. We've prepared a couple of slides that provide some additional information and background on that. Just as an introductory statement, one thing we've heard recently from our planning commission, from the economic stimulus council, from various other places is
1:36:46 Really the importance and the need now more than ever for the town to focus on programs that can drive revenue, can increase visitation, can engage partnerships, can encourage your investment, and community development is really the department that's doing much of that work for the town through our various programs. We've been doing it and we'll continue to do it and we recognize and acknowledge the importance of doing that. As Mariana mentioned, in terms of the budgetary
1:37:15 Impact. We are looking at a cut of approximately 1.5 FTE. But it's important to note that there's other movement of staff in the organization that's actually going to have a somewhat more significant impact on the department, for example, moving our analyst into more of a role of finance department, having our permit technician services shared.
1:37:40 Among other departments, that makes that impact a little bit more significant than just 1.5 FTE. And these are cuts that come after a series of cuts like many other departments in the town over the last few years, reducing our staff from 15 in 2008 to where we are right now, which is about 10 and a half, and less than that with the restructuring.
1:38:04 Despite that, we continue to provide a high level of service, clean our core services, building services like permit processing, plan checking, inspections, helping out with airport planning, permitting, public outreach, and assistance with the airport commission, providing assistance for capital projects and to the public works department in a pretty significant way in terms of planning, CEQA, various other aspects, and as well as the economic development strategic planning items I mentioned.
1:38:33 And many of those things are really what we call cross-departmental support, the things that we do to support and assist other functions of the town, TOT collection being one of the notable programs that we've engaged in recently, airport, as I mentioned, is another one, and providing that assistance throughout the organization rather than in a contained way, just community development per se. This is just a slide that illustrates a little bit, I think pretty vividly,
1:39:02 What we've experienced in terms of permit volume and permit valuation over the past 10 years, 10 to 12 years, what you can see in this picture is a high volume of permits and a relatively steady volume of permits, which is the blue line at the top hovering at around 700, 600 to 700 permits a year.
1:39:23 An evaluation that, despite that huge spike in 2004-2005 with construction of the village, is flat or declining slightly. And what this means is we have a large volume of small permits. We have a lot of reroutes, we have a lot of additions, remodels, bathroom changes, you know, water heater changeouts, and all of those require processing and handling, perhaps not to the same extent as a huge permit, but...
1:39:47 It's a volume that certainly adds to our workload. The same is through our planning permits as well. We see a similar picture, a fairly high volume, just the value and the size when it's small, which means the net effect of which is our cost of recovery suffers because we don't tend to recover as much cost on small permits as large permits. This slide illustrates what we think the effect of restructuring is going to be with the left-hand bars in each case in different categories reflecting our current staffing.
1:40:17 The red bars on the right showing where we may be able to allocate resources with our reductions. And so as you can see, our resource goes down to every department. We tried our hardest to keep the TOT staffing at a high level. We know that's an important priority. We currently have close to two full-time people working on that, and that's going to go down somewhat just by necessity.
1:40:42 As a service in all other areas, and it's just a factor of fewer people, fewer man hours, person hours to do that work. Ellen, what's the difference between the blue and the red? The blue is the current, and the red is the proposed with restructuring. Okay, thank you. And the numbers on top of it are the FTEs for each category. So we did an analysis based on our actual, we looked at our hours, we tracked this stuff, and are able to report where we actually spend our time.
1:41:09 And it's like this, and it's going to be made with something like this. So it's really a reduction in level of service that we're going to see. And the effects of that are really things like a slowdown in permit processing. We just can't handle as many permits. It's going to take longer to get permits approved. And timelines on projects are likely to be extended. And we can do our best to keep things on track, but in the end, you can only use so much work with the amount of people that you have. I will speak to ways that we might seek to...
1:41:38 Be more efficient, but it's inevitable to see some reduction in all the service. We talked a lot about, or the restructuring plan talks a lot about how we can change the way we do business to be more efficient, to bring more resources to the department, to find ways to streamline, to cut costs, and the simple fact and statement is we're doing many of those things already. We're probably one of the most
1:42:05 Accountable departments in terms of how we document and spend our time. We have a time tracking system that we use extensively that we use for our cost recovery and billing. We're able to report information. We've done a lot to increase efficiency working with our commissions to reduce the amount of paper and process that's involved in that work and improve efficiency there. And we've also implemented many technology improvements, particularly the basic gov system. We're continuing to work to improve.
1:42:34 That technology and looking at ways to automate the TRT collection system there. We've talked about that in the past. To allow for self-serve permits potentially so that if you have a very simple permit that doesn't require a plan check like a water heater replacement, you can just go online, pay your fee and issue a permit within a day with minimal process and minimal paper handling on the staff part. So those are both things that we're trying to do to improve efficiency.
1:43:04 And then also having better records management so that we can access and gain information and share that information with the public as well rather than to always deliver information through a phone call or through an email. We're always looking at ways to find your funding through grants and other opportunities, particularly obviously those ones that are aligned with our work program. Permit streamlining, as I mentioned. And finally, volunteer services, although it's likely that those are going to be
1:43:32 Confined, I think, to some discrete purposes just because of the nature of the work that we do. And as Marianna's mentioned in the past, having a very well-defined program where we can bring in volunteer resources to assist with fairly limited tasks, maybe an option. The other thing I don't think is listed here is outsourcing. We work a lot with consultants where we need to to handle overflow of work. We use CEQA consultants, professional consultants like the zoning code consultants to help us provide technical assistance that we don't have in-house.
1:44:02 And so continuing to look at those options and potentially for some of the day-to-day functions of the department will be a strategy as well. That's it. Thank you. Okay. Thank you, Ellen. Any questions for Ellen from the council? No. Okay. Thank you, Ellen. Dave, do you have a question? Well, I just wanted to ask, why don't you address some of the things on the slide that Public Works has? It's a pretty solid commentary, but I'm happy to talk about some of those things.
1:44:34 This was, well, maybe at a high level, because it was in our packet last meeting, wasn't it? Okay. Yeah, if we could just have a quick, if we could just go for the public. So as a slide will point out, there's been obviously changes to the street and parks maintenance division from 10 to 5. Certainly that's an impact, and we're concerned about that for the winter.
1:45:02 There are constraints that we're working with on top of that, which includes limiting hours for our seasonal road maintenance workers to 1,000. And if they go over 1,000, then they're required to participate in the PERS program, which makes it an expensive operation to have those employees. So we're kind of working through a different delivery on some of our winter street maintenance staffing. We've added some new facilities to the system. You can see the Lakes Basin Trail.
1:45:31 Whitmore Tracks, Sidewalks. Some of that's going to be funded through the Measure R and U relative to the tracks, and we're very happy about that additional funding that's coming forward. One of the things that we're doing as a result of trying to prove efficiencies is consolidating the operations. So you have a consolidation that occurred last spring, which is when Bill Manning left, we consolidated the airport into Public Works. They were separate operations. Within that, then, we're now consolidating.
1:46:00 Within Public Works, Parks Maintenance Division into with the road division. So we have more people doing more things, we hope. Obviously, some of it's specialized, but we think by consolidating, we're able to maybe move employees around a little more efficiently for various purposes, particularly in the times when there isn't activities, either in the winter road maintenance, we can move them into sidewalk maintenance, which was typically parks maintenance activities.
1:46:28 One of the things that we really focus on, and I think it's pretty consistent throughout the kind of work that we do, is health, safety, and risk management. In the past years, we've had some high levels of problems relative to big snow equipment causing damage in the winter, throwing snow through windows,
1:46:51 Coming on cars that have been parked illegally, so we're being much more aggressive with the police department ticketing cars that are parked illegally in the right-of-way so we can reduce some of that risk of management. So we're trying to take a little bit longer look at how we can save some money on that side. And then, of course, there's just going to be some deferred maintenance that has to occur as a result of some of these discussions and downsizing. Thank you. So right now, the plan includes eliminating the park's maintenance positions.
1:47:19 Work load includes the night shift operator for sidewalk snow removal. And you'll know from your worker who are driving around town, we have those small little blowers that move on the sidewalk, so we're going to see less of that kind of activity. There's going to be some snow removal required in assessment districts. We need to maintain those because it's a priority that we get paid for. Certainly, there's going to be some effect on ice rink operations, particularly after storms. Right now, the ice rink
1:47:49 It shuts down during the storm. Then it takes a day or two to bring it back online. That could take a bit longer just because we have less people doing it. That employee also supervises summer seasonal employees. We'll have to do some work with our road maintenance workers to pick up some of that work. I think there's going to be just a general overarching issue with just general maintenance in the park system.
1:48:18 And these kinds of jobs, like any job, people get to know their jobs. These jobs are often based upon the geography and the infrastructure of the city. So a person gets familiar with Shady Rest Park, for example, they're out there every day, they don't have to be trained, they know what they're doing. When that person leaves, all that kind of corporate knowledge goes with them. So then you wind up bringing seasonal employees in, which you're good employees, they just don't have the knowledge base. So everything takes a little bit longer or doesn't get done to the standard that we expect it to happen.
1:48:47 We're very fortunate to have Dennis Rotner, who all of you know. One of the things that we had talked about, I think, and we're concerned about now is some kind of a succession planning for him. Going back to that knowledge base, you know, he is probably, knows more about the park system than any person here. So that is something that we're going to have to look forward to in the future is figuring out how to transition. You know, Dennis at some point will be leaving us. So we've only got 25 years in. So, we'll get the fly. Oops.
1:49:18 So right now, just to give you a sense of the Whitmore Pool, we just renewed a 30-year lease, expires in 2041. That includes the new track. The pool lease expired in 2007. We're currently working to update that. So there's been a question about if we close the pool down, does that put us in default for the lease? And that does not happen. There is a certain level of minimum or standard requirement in the lease that we have to maintain. Obviously, it's a
1:49:48 The facility where people may or not go, we have to maintain some level of safety there. We'll do some inspections. If we were to terminate the lease, then we would probably need to pull the infrastructure out, but that's not uncommon. Almost every lease that anybody has ever pulled, when you start to terminate the lease, you're pulling your stuff out. So we don't plan to do that, but I don't think we're planning to terminate that because this is a short-term problem, we hope.
1:50:15 I'll take any questions. I'm not Ray Jarvis, but I have a little bit of knowledge about it. Are there any questions from Council? No. Thank you. Okay. All right. Well, with that, we have the two presentations, and what we... Dave, Mario, did you guys have anything else this time? No? Okay. What I was hoping, what I was thinking we could do...
1:50:47 Because tonight's focus was really to deliberate on this plan, get some input from council and from the public and various commissions. And at the end, after everybody's had their questions and comments, have council deliberate on this and come up with a plan after the weeks we've had of discussion, all the feedback and whatnot. So initially I'd like to ask council if there's any
1:51:16 General questions right now before I turn it over to the public and commissions to see if they have any questions or comments. I'd like to hear what else they have to say. Okay. And with that, what I'd like to do as part of trying to work through this restructuring is look at page number four, which is attachment 1A. It's really a summary of the areas that are being impacted.
1:51:46 And I'm going to work off of that, and I would ask that the public maybe take a look at that, and if there are your comments or questions, by all means come up, and let's go ahead and start hearing from you. I know there's some folks from Rec Commission, I think we're going to come up and speak. Mariana, could we put that slide back up? Yes. Let's do three minutes on this, because I think it could go a while. Just depending on, we'll play it by ear.
1:52:18 Lining up for this. Okay, so is there anybody from the public that has any comments or questions on what Dave Mariana said or any of the items that are on the restructuring plan? Donette Hustleton. A couple things. The first thing I want to say is on all the three taxes that possibly will be in front of the people, I would suggest if you restricted it to paying off the lawsuit instead of using it for your budget, pay down your lawsuit quicker.
1:52:57 If you did those three taxes, it could be as much as $4 million a year, maybe more, but at least $2 million. Instead of 24 years, pay it down by 10 years. And then once those, you know how everybody hates taxes, once that's done, and part of your language is that goes away unless you want to bring it back to the public and use it for something else. I think you'd have a better shot than just saying,
1:53:26 Use it for your town budget. And this way you don't have to touch your town budget. Just use those taxes just to pay off your lawsuit. I would suggest that. I don't know how anybody else feels about that. But this way it would get paid down. I know there was a big comment about that. My next question or comment would be on Whitmore. Taking the measure, our money, to backfill Whitmore of 220, I believe. And I think it would be up to you as council.
1:53:55 To direct to Park and Rec's commission instead of suggesting that they put that in their budget for this Measure R application and just take it out of there so it gets funded as you heard what 59 point something percent of the people want to use Measure R. And it only is a temporary so maybe a year maybe two years. The problem I see is you've got close to 800, not quite 800,000.
1:54:21 $300,000 of that's going to the trails because that was deferred to this budget. So that drops it down to $5,000 or less than $5,000. What's in front of them is another $300,000. And then if you take Whitmore of $200,000, that doesn't leave you anything for anything else. So my suggestion would be put Whitmore in there. Tell them that it has to be funded through there. Not a loan, but funded. And figure out the rest, but do not defer again for next year.
1:54:50 Figure out what's in your budget now, stick with your budget, and stop deferring money so we don't have to be in this position every time. That would be my suggestion. Thank you, Donette. Any other members of the public? Mayor, Town Council, Jesse Baldwin, business owner, president of the Mammoth Lakes Contractors Association, member of the Building Advisory Committee. I'm here to speak as I have been the last several meetings on the...
1:55:25 Primarily the permit technician staffing. Basically what I'd like to ask since tomorrow we have the monthly Mammoth Lakes Contractors Association meeting which we've invited Dave and Matthew to that we postpone making a decision on the permit technician until we've had an opportunity to discuss in detail how that's affecting us at the Mammoth Lakes Contractors Association meeting tomorrow. Okay. Thank you, Jesse.
1:55:56 Anybody else? Yes, Chuck. Good evening, Chuck Landy. I just wanted to speak a quick second on the proposed reduction in planning staff. You know, we, meaning the whole town staff, private sector has worked hard planning for the future. And we've spent hundreds of thousands of dollars on district plans, Main Street plan. Zoning needs to be updated. Those plans need to be codified so that when...
1:56:30 People do come in to develop in the future. They have a set of zoning standards and guidelines that they can work from, and I worry about the great momentum that we've built towards this effort falling apart if we don't have the staff to support it. So your consideration there towards our future growth. To get out of this mess, we really need to grow out of this mess, and I think that's a very key element to pay attention to. Thank you. Thank you, Chuck.
1:57:00 Anybody else? Yes, Kirk. Good evening, Mayor, members of Council, Public. This is a statement that comes from the Mammoth Lake Housing Board, so I'll read it into the records. The Board of Directors of Mammoth Lake Housing recognized the town's economic crisis and understand it's imperative to address the settlement with MLLA. Mammoth Lake Housing further acknowledges that the town
1:57:31 has diverted $482,000 per year of voter-approved housing funds to non-housing uses. That equates to 60% of the housing funds and 24% of the annual settlement payment. While housing values have declined, wages and jobs have also declined. The need for workforce housing continues and will grow as the local economy improves.
1:57:55 In partnership with the town, Mammoth Lake Housing has brought over $40 million to the local economy. An active housing program will continue to bring millions to the town through grants and other mechanisms, leveraging the small amount it costs each year, the MLA Mammoth Lake Housing's contract. Maintaining and growing workforce housing in Mammoth also addresses multiple objectives in the general plan.
1:58:24 From social stability to economic growth to greenhouse gas reduction, that's part of our general plan. The town has made commitments through grants and policies that must be honored or we can pay those grants back fully.
1:58:39 The program cannot be totally eliminated without significant expenses. Mammoth Lake Housing contracts with the town have been cut $55,000 already. We used to be at almost $400,000. We're now down to $329,000, resulting in lost services and reduced personnel costs. Mammoth Lake Housing is the most...
1:59:02 Cost efficient, sorry, Mammoth Lake is the most cost effective option for meeting the town's housing commitments and objectives.
1:59:13 And this is the most important paragraph, I think, because we are trying to figure out a way to work with the town in its economic crisis. The Mammoth Lake Housing Board of Directors requests the council cap the taking from housing at the current level of $482,000 until the council can implement revenue generating measures to pay for the settlement.
1:59:38 This compromise of housing funds will contribute to the short-term solution that the town is facing.
1:59:44 Notwithstanding, the board further requests that the council develop a plan to reinstate the 1% commitment to housing within the next five years, while continues to fund Mammoth Lake Housing at the current level of $329,000 per year. So we recognize it, and we recognize that there is a political commitment, but we also want to step forward and work with the council to try to get through this. That is the statement from the board. I'd like to add a few things.
2:00:13 In 2002, when Measure A was passed, we expanded quite rapidly, but partly because of the development that was going on. We had five staff members at that time, and right now we have two staff members. Since 2007, neither of these staff members have had a COLA or a merit pay, and they have assumed more responsibility for their health insurance.
2:00:36 So we saw what was coming, partly because of the graphs that were up here, and partly because we began to shift our focus from developing property to homebuyers assistant programs. We currently have done 57 homebuyers assistant programs. A lot of those are outside of Mammoth Lakes, the town of Mammoth Lakes, because our workers
2:01:01 The other thing that I think is a historical element to this whole thing, when Mammoth Lake Housing began its process of going forward, one of the major discussions was that Mammoth Lake Housing was going to take over
2:01:30 Because we could get grants for it, the people that their average medium income was less than 60% or 60% and less. So one of the focuses has been, you know, to try to get either construction grants or grants that deal with that. Because we...
2:01:49 accepted that responsibility at Mammoth Lake Housing. That was taken off the table when developers came in. So they began to look at 80% and higher when they are trying to address their housing needs or, you know, whatever the development agreement, that was the parameters.
2:02:09 I can't say enough about our two staff members that continue to accept more work levels in monitoring the recent contract that we have accepted more responsibilities from the community development department and monitoring being a major one. So we have, in our contract, have actually taken more responsibility from the town or it's been outsourced to Mammoth Lake Housing.
2:02:35 I don't have anything further to say. I'm certainly open to any questions that you might have. And Pam is here if I don't have a direct response or there's a technical aspect of it. Are there any questions of council members? No. Kirk, I want to follow up on something because it was clear to me as it was discussed in the board meeting. And as you know, I was present for that as the town's representative.
2:03:05 And that is to further explain who it is that Mammoth Lakes Housing serves and has served. And what I heard you say is that it is essentially assumed responsibility for providing housing to families whose income is only 60% of the median family income of the community. Is that a fair statement?
2:03:33 It's a part of it, but it is initially a major part of it because of the grants that we receive. So, yes, we are focused on providing for those. Yes. So, the question that I have is, that I'd like to have you elaborate on a little bit is, is that a segment of the community that is otherwise served or is not served by private development?
2:04:02 With our rent rates the way they are, I would say that these people fall below them because we're talking about minimum wage people. So you're going to, if these people go into the private sector out there, then you're going to find that they're going to be doubling up families and units and that sort of thing because they aren't. They're an important, I think the real issue is they're an important part of our community. And so these people that are working here,
2:04:30 Where are they going to go? They can't go into or they're going to, you know, do stacking in some of the private rentals. That was one of the major focus. That was what we focused on initially at Mammoth Lake Housing. And we took that off the table when developers came in. We said no.
2:04:49 We're going to, this, the 80% of AMI, average medium income, is something the developers, 80 to 120% to 200% is something the developers. So Mammoth Lakes Housing's focus was at the other end of the continuum. And yeah, I believe, I think it's apparent because we do get complaints periodically of people stacking.
2:05:14 So the other question I have, it's unrelated, but I also want to have you discuss it because we're going to be debating numbers. What the board in its position statement has requested is that in essence the $329,000 be the firewall. That is, that the funding not be reduced to any level less than $329,000. That's correct. So my question is, has the board
2:05:44 Examined whether or not by continuing to outsource, meaning not bringing the function back into town, has it examined whether that 329, one, is adequate to maintain the programs that we have, and two, whether it could be done more cheaply or less expensively if it were brought back into the town. Well, the first issue, there's several problems there, and one is the real estate that we own.
2:06:13 That's worth about $125,000 for our offices, but we've borrowed $150,000. So I'm not too sure who's going to assume that if Mammoth Lake Housing is pulled into the town office. Then you have the different grants that also are coming due, and I didn't address those, but they are in the letter to the council that these will have to be paid for.
2:06:43 Unless another different funding source comes in. I think it's really important to recognize that Mammoth Lake Housing is not just functioning in the town. They're functioning in the county, and they're functioning down in Bishop. So a lot of our different activities, and we do get some revenue from those different activities, working with the Bishop City and things like this, but some of our workers are down there. So I don't know if I'm completely addressing your...
2:07:13 Your question, and maybe I should ask Pam to come up. Ultimately the question is going to be whether or not the proposal that is on the chart now, which is to continue to fund it at 329, ultimately the question is going to be whether we should do that or whether we should further cut or whether we should enhance or increase.
2:07:40 Pam Hennerty, Executive Director of Mammoth Lakes Housing. To answer your question,
2:08:12 Councilmember Wood. I believe that 329 is the bottom line. I think for the services that we provide, you will not be able to bring those services in-house and provide them for less than what it would cost the town to employ two people. Jennifer and I have been with Mammoth Lakes Housing for a lot of years. We have a lot of knowledge and expertise, and it would be hard-pressed to find somebody to...
2:08:37 To fill that knowledge base. It also seems to me contradictory to be thinking about bringing back in the housing function when a majority of Phase II or many of this restructuring plan is looking at outsourcing. Mammoth Lakes Housing was developed by the town as a private separate non-profit and it was really the first example of the town doing outsourcing. Mammoth Lakes Tourism was then set up in a very similar fashion.
2:09:05 I think that at the end of the day, based on the grant writing skills, the dollars we bring into the town, the programs we operate, the units that we manage, delivering that level of service for less than $320,000 would be very difficult. If it were to be reduced, the level of service would obviously be dropped.
2:09:32 Including opportunities to apply for grants, which we've been so successful at in leveraging the town's commitment and the contract amount. Thanks. I would like to add one more thing. There is a real skill to writing grants to get these dollars to come into the community. And right now I think our Mammoth Lake Housing staff is just about the only one in the community, the only two people in the community.
2:10:02 When we talk about these grants, we're not talking about filling out a page. We're talking about two inches of paperwork, and that has to go back and forth to the town and a coordination between the town. But the Mammoth Lake Housing staff does take the lead on that. If you have any other questions, I'll try to field them. Members of Council have questions? I have one. I got the letter from Housing.
2:10:28 There are a couple things I'll address later in it, but one that really stuck out with me was on the second page, basically saying that in December, and I think this was a question I was prying on at the last council meeting, in December of 2015 and 17, loans due to the town from California Housing Finance Agency will become due. Those loans are $396,000 and $343,000 respectively and must be repaid to the state.
2:10:57 This equates 20% of our homebuyer assistance portfolio. The remaining 80% of funds came from state and federal grants, the grants you were talking about. And then it goes on to say the loans may be repaid by the homeowners if they chose to sell, which they may or may not do. Regardless, it says the town should consider budgeting a payback program to the state from 2002A funds in respective fiscal years.
2:11:24 And I guess my question is why should the town budget to pay those back? It's your loan. It's almost $750,000 that we have not programmed. And I'm just wondering how it's going to get paid. It's coming due in three years and five years respectively. Well, there's sort of two.
2:11:46 Levels to answering that question. So those loans were loans made to the town that were passed through to Mammoth Lakes Housing. Some of those units have already been resold and the funds have been paid back. So by 2015 and 2017, those debts could remain the same or they could be drastically reduced by, you know, a person who received a large down payment assistance loan, repaying the loan.
2:12:12 There is that potential. I do think that as you're looking at this and you're looking at how you're going to restructure and how you're going to continue to fund housing and how you're going to continue to operate housing, obviously there is some discussion of cutting funding to Mammoth Lakes Housing, bringing the organization in-house and dealing with that. And if Mammoth Lakes Housing were to be eliminated or Stafford would be brought in-house, those deaths would continue to exist and the town would be liable for them.
2:12:40 That's just a reality. So if Mammoth Lakes Housing were to continue to be funded and continue to exist and continue to go on the way we've operated since 2003 when the town started funding us and we knew that we were secure in that, then Mammoth Lakes Housing would certainly be working on a repayment plan and potentially in conjunction with 2002A funds, perhaps a loan from 2002A.
2:13:05 Until the homeowner repaid the loan. And there's a variety of options that are out there. But while you're considering how to deal with this housing program, we brought these loans before the town to the town staff to say, you need to remember these and realize that these ultimately are town obligations that will have to be dealt with in the event that Mammoth Lakes Housing is no longer an entity. But if you are an entity,
2:13:32 I mean, basically, it's almost like we co-signed on a loan, and if you default on it, or you can't pay it, then we have to pick up the tab. Well, ultimately, it was a loan from the California Housing Finance Agency to the town of Mammoth Lakes, and then the town lent those funds to Mammoth Lakes Housing. Okay. Well, it was lent for a purpose, though. I mean, I... I understand that. I mean, I understand that it was lent for a purpose. My point is...
2:14:00 Is that in this discussion of what do we do with housing, it's not necessarily a this is your problem, figure it out kind of a statement. It's more of a problem of as you think about how to move forward, you have made obligations, these two loans being part of those obligations, and as we go forward, we need to come up with a plan of how to address those, whether Mammoth Lakes Housing exists or does not. Okay.
2:14:22 Second question, who's the loan with at your office? Do you guys have a loan with the bank? We have a loan with Eastern Sierra Community Bank. Okay. Okay, I don't have any other questions now. Matthew, could I go back to your first question? Just ask staff, have we recognized those loans within our FTI study or anything? You know, if I may, since you're on that subject, instead of putting it into the debate portion,
2:14:53 If you are running an operation which has been running since 2003 under a practice whereby the funds that are collected, approximately $800,000 a year, are expected to be received, then you go out and you get grants and you get loans and you do what's necessary in order to establish and then maintain programs. In this instance, we borrowed some of the money, we the town borrowed some of the money and then loaned it to housing.
2:15:22 In order to create a fund to provide down payment assistance to low income households so that they could actually buy a house and be part of the community and be invested. The problem is that those loans are not to be repaid until the units sell, which could be forever, theoretically. Not forever, but a long time. But the loans that were made were shorter term loans and so those simply don't match.
2:15:52 The fact is that it was not an unreasonable decision for the town or for the housing to do those things in order to generate the funds for the 57 families that have received the assistance. The problem is that the town has taken $428,000, $482,000 away from the 800 that the housing entity used to receive and always expected to receive.
2:16:17 The problem's not the housing entity's problem. The problem is that the town has cut its budget. And I think that Rick makes a good point. These loans were made to the town in Mammoth Lakes Housing in 2005 and 2007. The world was an entirely different place in 2005 and 2007. Mammoth Lakes Housing had a...
2:16:36 Much different purpose in 2005 and 2007. And we knew in 2005 and 2007 that the land debt service that currently takes $242,000 from the 2002 Measure A funds would be paid off in 2013. So in anticipating continued growth in TOT, you know, everyone was on cloud nine. We were on top of the world. Repayment of those loans didn't seem like it would be a concern. I realize that's not where we are now.
2:17:05 And I realize that these are a concern and they need to be dealt with. But we've all been facing the changes. To Rick's point, the money was coming in from 2002 until recent years. Money wasn't programmed to pay this back though, right? I mean, there was no money, there wasn't a contingency being taken out every year to pay it back. Actually, that's not true. The housing fund has always built a reserve. We've never been...
2:17:34 Fully expended the reserve. There's a huge misconception out there that of the about $800,000, the 1% of TOT, that those funds have come to Mammoth Lakes Housing. That's not true. Our contract sort of maxed out at $385,000 a few years ago, and we've since been cut to about $329,000. Some of those funds paid the $242,000 in debt service that will be paid off in the next fiscal year.
2:17:56 Some funds paid for town staff and their housing operations, but there was always housing funds that went into a reserve account. And whether that was to be paid this debt or, you know, maybe perhaps we had other options, but housing has never fully expended the 1% of TOT. And that fiscal responsibility has now sort of come back to bite us because that savings is gone. So there was that amount of savings to spend that money, but it's not there anymore.
2:18:26 Okay. Thank you. And the reason that the savings is gone is that the town took the savings. Yeah. There's two – when you look at your budget, you have developer fees. There's about $400,000 in that pool of money right now. And we've used some of that money for different programs out there and everything else. And then you have the political commitment for Measure 2002A, which was 1% was –
2:18:54 Was tracked, basically, by the Finance Department. And so every year we were informed of how much money we had utilized of that, $257,000 for, you know, land payment, the $385,000 for that. But there was always money left over, and that money was basically rolled over on an annual basis, and all that money is gone now because of the need to trust the settlement.
2:19:21 Just to make, on 2002A, that was a 2% TOT increase. 1% went to Mammoth Lake Housing, 1% went to, or half a percent went to Capital Projects, which went down to the airport and never seemed to have come back, and a half a percent went to marketing. So on 2002A, it's not just housing. That was a political commitment to three different items at that time. Okay. Thank you, Kirk.
2:19:50 I just wanted to make some comments on the housing. I pulled it. Last time you guys all spoke about it, you had a lot of questions about, you know, how much things cost and whatever. I pulled a tax return, and it's public comment, public knowledge. You can pull any tax return that's a nonprofit. And what was startling to me is the salary range. Your executive director makes $100. This was a year ago tax return. The current one is not out yet.
2:20:21 It's $113,000 a year and your assistant makes $85,000 a year. That's not really comparable to Mono and Inyo County. It may be comparable to Mammoth Lakes itself, but as far as executive directors, that's pretty high range. You also had a lot of rent and such. The $329,000 is coming from the town to pay those salaries and the rent and the utilities and all of that. That was my understanding.
2:20:49 My suggestion would be, you know, you're going to have to, since you took the loan out and you lent it to the non-profit, the non-profit technically, yeah, is responsible, but you are ultimately responsible. If you take that back, maybe it goes out to bid to the person at a lower rate to management or to a management company to oversee all of that, then when you need to pull grants, you hire people to write those grants.
2:21:17 I just thought that there was a lot of money that showed up on the tax return that was being spent that the town could absorb some of that telephone, whatever, in part of their own budget if they had that position there. Okay. Thank you, Donna. That's the cost of employment, not the salaries. There's a difference. That's the cost of employment. Rick said that was the cost of employment, not their salaries. Well, on the tax return it says salary. It's the cost of employment.
2:21:48 Mayor, if I may, before the next speaker speaks, going back to the previous comment on the housing reserve, Cindy has reminded me that the reserve that has been established was recently used to purchase a housing unit. Is that correct? Yes. So we did not use the reserve for balancing. The council recently authorized the purchase of a housing unit. Thank you. Good evening, council. I'm Martin Kleinbart, resident of Matt Phillips. A couple observations. One regarding...
2:22:21 Police Department cuts. If that's the proposed plan and it goes through, you've got an effective date of next fiscal year to terminate seven sworn officers. That alone probably will have an effect of reducing officers now because they'll immediately go looking for new employment and when that new employment comes through, they'll leave and then you won't fill those positions.
2:22:51 Second, if I heard correctly, Mammoth Lakes Housing, they're supporting people and items outside of Mammoth Lakes. I mean, we're collecting the TOT for Mammoth Lakes. That money's supposed to go to Mammoth Lakes. I know that there may be other grant monies, but it seems kind of odd that we're going beyond town limits and funding or servicing.
2:23:20 People outside. I mean, I understand there are people that work here. I understand that. But it's public money. And it's public money for Mammoth Lakes, not for Mono County, and definitely not for Inyo County. Thank you. Thank you, Martin. Good evening, Mr. Mayor and Council. You're probably pleased they didn't bring a chart. Let me respond quickly. The money.
2:23:57 Some of these loans that go to units outside of Mammoth, those are supported by other agencies who rely upon Mammoth Lakes Housing to administer them. So it's not town money. It's grant money that the county or the city of Bishop has managed to acquire. And so we utilize Mammoth Lakes Housing.
2:24:28 And it actually is an income source for Mammoth Lakes Housing. So it's a good thing for everybody. And while those houses in the county, you know, that's where some of your workers live. So it's a good thing. And just to kind of restate what Rick was saying, you know, the voters said 800,000 to housing. So what do we have left? 329. If the voters said,
2:25:08 800,000 Measure R, and you took 60% of it, people will be yelling and stamping their feet out here. But you already did it, you didn't even ask. So just keep that in mind as you go along here. And that comes to the survey. So if you say cut Mammoth Housing, you want to cut Mammoth Housing. Well, you didn't tell them you already cut it by 60%.
2:25:40 He might have had a lot of different responses. And you didn't tell him he brought 40 million in construction and so on or thereabouts into the town over the last years. So these are important points. My graph would show you if you go below, you're going to go up. It's going to cost you a lot of money. So we're bare bones. Good program. Thanks. Thank you, Larry.
2:26:17 Any other members or commissioners want to speak? Okay. Oh, sorry. See you. Rusty. Rusty. Rusty Gregory, Chairman and CEO of Mammoth Mountain. And I'm an impediment to growth and prosperity of our resort community. I came here 34 years ago, learned how to ski. Like many, I stayed around maybe too long. And I stayed.
2:26:55 Because Mammoth was a place that I could do what I wanted, when I wanted, how I wanted, for the purposes that I wanted. And we have a gene pool that's made up of a lot of those kinds of people, which is what makes Mammoth, to me anyway, a great, very interesting place to live. It also makes it a very difficult community to lead. Because when you're full of a gene pool that wants to do things when they want to do it, how they want to do it, and have very strong opinions,
2:27:26 At least the council TV sessions are pretty interesting. So a lot of people that stay where they grew up, not that they're followers, they do radically idiosyncratic things as well, but come to a difficult, harsh environment like Mammoth, do your business, raise your kids, try to build institutions that are strong and stable, and that's one hell of a challenge. The kind of people that it takes to do that are people like us that have very strong opinions. But I can tell you that as I've gotten older,
2:27:57 And have more responsibility. You know, I came here to have fun and to pay for it by being a lift operator. And, you know, I'm where I am today, rightly or wrongly. But I still hold to those kind of basic ideas. And holding to that is part of what's contributed, particularly considering the influence as a leader in the community that I have and the company that I run.
2:28:27 That has contributed to the circumstances of Mammoth Lakes today. The only way that we can deal with a problem in the long run that we're facing tonight is to grow out of the problem. When you have a significant obligation that's going to last for a long time, one that probably doesn't make the sense to pay off early if you do the time value of money calculation from a finance standpoint,
2:28:55 That obligation is only going to feel like a lesser obligation if we can create the resources to minimize it. The only way to create those resources to minimize it is to bring more people to the town of Mammoth Lakes because whether we like it or not, whether we want to diversify or not, the business of the town of Mammoth Lakes, economics of the town of Mammoth Lakes are dramatically influenced by tourism. So therefore,
2:29:24 The only way that I believe that we can solve this problem in the long run and to not just survive but to prosper because I'm not sure how many of us here just want to survive. Now just surviving is no small feat here given what we've faced the last several years but I don't think that that's our objective even though that may seem out of reach to many of us these days after a few years of drought, after financial meltdown, after all the things that we've faced.
2:29:52 Survival seems like a pretty lofty goal at this point, but I can tell you that, and I won't say people like me, I'll just say me, employing 3,000 people in town, a company that's supposed to bring in $150 million a year in revenue, do it profitably, create a lot of jobs, that the way that I'm thinking and the way that I've acted and the way that I've been running the company has been an impediment.
2:30:19 To the very things that we need to do to fix the problem, which is to grow. We need to ask ourselves why you can go to North Star and see what you see in North Star when, you know, it's a great place, but, you know, in terms of the Mother Nature they have in North Star, we have so much more here. Why on earth do they have the things that they have and we don't have those things? I get facility envy every time I go to that place, right?
2:30:44 Why do other places have the things that they do and that we still seem to be working on making our flush toilets work? Right? We just somehow, I don't know what it is, but I can tell you that I'm part of that problem. And that's because, you know, I want to do it my way, when I want to do it, how I want to do it, and now I run a big company and I have a lot of clout to back up that attitude. And I need to change that attitude. And I covet to you tonight.
2:31:13 As the town council and the community, that I will. And I'll do that in a very big way, and I'll talk about that in ways that I think that other people can get behind. I think that we can, without huge sacrifice, but with some sacrifice, how we can raise $5 million, maybe as much as $6 million, and use that to market our community. And I don't mean ads in Sunset Magazine, I mean real marketing. I mean to decide, yeah, that's right.
2:31:42 To buy the sheep? To get him the hell out of town? That'll be the first start. Are you on the public relief program, Ted? The orange? That's like a prisoner outfit working on the highway. But I promised I'd be serious, not make any jokes, but it's hard to make jokes, Ted, without you speaking. So I think that, I think, I don't think I know. If you take the
2:32:09 Revenue-based, and I won't go into great detail tonight because we have so much more to do tonight, but to do more than survive, but to prosper, to take the obligation that today seems insurmountable and to minimize that by having more resources, we need to bring more people to town. To bring more people to town, I can't just do it the way that I want to do it, when I want to do it, how I want to do it, for the purposes that I want to do it.
2:32:35 I need to understand that even though Mammoth is a big place compared to our competition, compared to Tahoe, compared to Vail, compared to, I don't know, whoever our competition is, you know, staying home and hanging out with AYSO Soccer, whatever keeps people at home, that we need to have a much bigger impact in the marketplace. To do that, we need to understand, I need to understand that I need to subordinate my view.
2:33:03 To the view of a whole. Now for a capitalist and a right-wing guy like me who's much more liberal than most people realize, that's like, you know, the antichrist, what I just said. But the facts are that we are so much bigger together agreeing on a brand, agreeing on a future, agreeing on aspirations that we can collectively hold than we'll ever be if we just pursue the ones that we hold individually.
2:33:30 We just like to elect you so that we can shoot at you because God
2:33:59 Who on earth would be stupid enough to try to lead a community like this? It's like flunking the IQ test, I think, running for a job like that because it's impossible. So I don't just believe, I know that if I think about it differently, that we can figure out a way to pool our vision by creating it together.
2:34:23 But I mean really working through it. There's no free lunch. We're going to have to argue through the politics and without having the government as a proxy doing it and then beating them up for doing it when we can't figure out how to do it as a group. So I think that I know that tourism and the people that are in the tourism business can come together to figure out how best to market the place. And again, not arguing about ads, but how to come up with real resources so that we can compete with the competition that have so much less
2:34:52 And that's the only way we're going to get beyond where we are today. But before we can even talk about growth and prospering, even though I've spoken about that for a few minutes, we have to first survive. And to survive, we have some very difficult things to do. Actually, you have some very difficult things to do. And that is that you,
2:35:22 You need to decide the limited budget that the town has now compared to at least what it was before. You've got to decide out of that meat and bone what to cut. I have been uncharacteristically quiet and absent from these meetings that's been commented on and it's not been accidental. Part of it is because of the well-publicized personal stuff that I'm going through and it's given me a chance to kind of stand outside of Mammoth for my own health and safety.
2:35:50 And to be out of town and kind of look back at the life that I have here, the life that we all have, and at the opportunity that we have and what's required to get there. And, you know, I've come to this conclusion that I'm like, you know, really the biggest obstacle because I have the most resources behind me. But I think a lot of us that are in business have the possibility to rise above that and change it. But to get to there, we've got to survive. To survive, we've got to cut some meat.
2:36:19 And I have very strong opinions of what you should and shouldn't do. Very strong. And you don't need to hear it. Because you're already getting a lot of very strong opinions about what you should do and what you shouldn't do and the choices that face you are impossible. They're politically impossible. They're financially impossible. They're very painful. And you have to do it anyway. And people in the audience and people in the town, we all know that. But we're going to beat the crap out of you anyway.
2:36:49 Right? Because it goes with the territory, and unfortunately, that's the position that our country seems to be in. I don't know why the heck we're there. I'm part of that as well, but it's a fact. So I strongly support whatever it is that you need to do. I'm not going to express the opinion of my rather significant company in our small town for that, other than to also covet to you tonight that whatever decision you make,
2:37:19 We will not criticize. We will not have an opinion on, but we'll go to work to make sure that it works out as well as we can. And then I'll follow up on the comments that I made tonight and the promises that I made tonight that the mountain will be different. I mean very different. We won't compete with the rest of you so that we can get our employees because we can give them free passes. We'll figure out a way that other employers that do the things that we ought to do collectively to come together to create a great experience.
2:37:49 So that more people will come here. We'll somehow have the same advantage that we have on those passes. We'll stop competing with the hospitality operations in town to think that that's competition and that somehow that makes things better when all we're doing is just eating a bigger piece of the pie that we get one year and somebody else gets the next year and never grows. We'll figure out how to do that
2:38:10 To follow behind the collective. It sounds so communistic. Ted, I know it's the kind of stuff you learned about in Dartmouth. This is like the proletariat rising up and taking over the means of production. Right? But I can tell you that the collective, with vision, with commitment, with resources committed to it, that we can do it much better than we're doing it now. And it starts tonight with the survival that we need to achieve tonight and the decisions that you have to make.
2:38:40 My company, me personally, we're behind whatever that decision will be, and then we're behind the discussion, the dialogue that we need to have with the rest of you to figure this out, because we cannot solve our problems, and we've got so many, and every time there's a little downtick in the economy, and I've been through so many of them now, with this always happens. So much worse here than in other small rural communities.
2:39:06 We cannot keep doing the same thing harder and faster and expect a different outcome. We've got to fundamentally change. And the mountain will fundamentally change. I promise you that. Thank you. Thank you, Rusty. Rich McIntyre, community member. I guess I'd want to boil it down into simple things. I agree with Rusty. He said we've got to grow and do things differently. But you have to solve the problem.
2:39:42 I think you need to go to what the basic needs of the community are, not what they want or what we have to have. And one of them is public safety. And I've thought long and hard about contracting with Monon County sheriffs and looking at the choices. And I don't think any of them are to the benefit of the town. And I think the comment that if you say you're going to cut police, some of them are going to leave and you're going to have that. I think the salaries are unsustainable.
2:40:12 Salaries and Benefits. So you've got to solve that problem, but not by cutting police officers. And then you have to look at your public works and what's necessary. Now, I don't think there's anybody in this room that doesn't think that they're not paid enough and that the town employees have already taken some haircuts. Maybe the police haven't taken as many as you think they should. I don't know that because we don't have all the information.
2:40:40 I don't know if I'm in the mainstream because I just got that packet over the survey. So I'm going to read all that and see if I'm in the mainstream or I'm some wacko out there. I don't know if I'm becoming a communist or not, but I kind of agree that we need to collectively solve the problem. But I think in the short term, you have to look at what we have to have and then say no. And I'm not advocating cutting.
2:41:08 Programs, I'm advocating slowing them down within the reason that you can afford until you get to the point that you can do other great things. So I would just hope that you would solve the problem with the police department before they all leave, because I can tell you that the deputies that live in New Yorkton and Colville that get assigned to them won't be the police officers we have. So I would just encourage you to hang in there and be tough, and like you say, we're going to take shots.
2:41:38 Thank you, Rich. Anybody else? Johnny. So again, Johnny Gates as a private citizen. Just to touch on a couple things, I appreciate Rich for coming up before me after Rusty, but I think Rusty made some pretty interesting comments. One, attitude.
2:42:08 The team he talked about, the community, but attitude, you know, whether it's the mountain or the town employees, dare to soar. Attitude almost always determines altitude in life. So we have to change our attitude. We have to change our thinking. What that is, I don't know. I'm intrigued by Rusty's comment about changing an attitude. I can tell you from my personal experience with the mountain.
2:42:38 They are always adapting. They are always changing. Jim Smith, Tom Hodges, Karen, they are amazing people to work with. And Rusty brought up an opportunity for everyone to possibly go through. You know, what's the opportunity? Change, flush the toilets, be North Star, what have you, whatever that is. If an opportunity is knocking, build a door. The mountain knows how to build that door.
2:43:06 They are always changing. They are always adapting. And the last thing that Rusty said, and I think everyone else somewhat agrees with, is, you know, be a team. Be a community. We can get this done. You know, we can agree to disagree. I'm not allowed to shoot the bullets that way because of my employment, but, you know.
2:43:31 It takes a lot of courage sitting on that dais. I mean, it takes a lot of courage listening to people like me and people like Rusty and people like John Wentworth to listen and take that all in. And sometimes decisions are hard to make, but there's opportunity. There's an opportunity for us to be a huge team, and there's an opportunity for us to change our attitude. And I'm not saying our attitude as a community is a bad one, but...
2:43:58 Attitude almost always determines altitude in life. And I think that's, you know, one last thing. I appreciate George for writing that little piece, but I don't mean to get corny again with the quotes, but I think attitude that Rusty alluded to is an important topic. Thank you, Johnny. Sean Turner, business owner, recreation commissioner, vice chair, MLTS, DC.
2:44:32 Great stuff said here tonight. Since we're throwing out analogies, opportunity and chaos. I've always loved that. And right now we've got a lot of chaos and frankly quite a few opportunities in front of us. It's not exactly what we want, but at the same time what's going on here is making us all reconsider what we're having to go through. Competition, I just want to say that, makes us all sharper.
2:45:01 As a business owner, competition makes me focus, makes me realize what I have to do. Two weeks ago I was in front of you and I said that as a business owner, this fall, this year, my sales have been up, so have my expenses dramatically. I had to let it go of some employees and some managers who I really consider friends. Sorry, the company can't support you right now.
2:45:26 In looking at these questions that were put before us, I think it's interesting, and I actually want to go through the one question with regard to Whitmore Pool here in just a second. But if you really dive deep into the comments that are left on the pages and pages of this, a lot of detailed comments that I don't think truly reflect the way this question is asked. I'm going to talk specifically about Whitmore Pool and Measure R for a minute.
2:45:53 Just because the supplanting issue keeps coming up time and time again. This question is asked number five if you oppose the proposed elimination of the town sheriff. Fifty percent of the Whitmore pool save 120 grand annually, which is a little high, but that's okay without talking about the actual funds. Twenty-five percent says, no, I'm not opposed to cutting the...
2:46:14 Pool, or I'm not opposed to the proposed cuts for Whitmore Pool. That's too bad, but that also tells me 75% want to keep the pool somehow, someway. That's a good thing. I like that. The way the next two questions are asked, though, kind of troubles me. Yes, I would support using an estimated $120,000 out of the annual measure our funds to fully fund the Whitmore Pool and Park. 58.4% say yes. Next question.
2:46:40 No, I would not support using an estimated 120 in annual measure arm funds to fully fund the Whitmore Pooler Park. This could lead to the closure of these facilities. So if I'm reading the survey, that tells me that if I don't vote on this survey monkey to use measure arm funds to go to Whitmore Pool, that Whitmore Pool is going to be closed? Wow.
2:47:04 Probably vote in that 58.4 category as well. Now I'm familiar with the way my interpretation of Measure R and supplanting is all about. If you dive into, and I'm going to ask you to look into the comments that follow this specific question, and I would say about half of them say, is Measure R really the only way to go here? And thank God for those people asking that question, because I'm going to go back to the opportunity in chaos.
2:47:34 Measure R is not the only way to fund Whitmore Pool. There are other opportunities. I'm not going to go into detail, but I'm also going to tell you to read a lot of the comments that are left there, and a lot of them do point a possible solution with regard to the salaries that are paid. And I don't believe yet, and maybe I'm wrong because I'm not as involved as you all are with the actual budget, that this town is as lean and as mean as it can be.
2:48:05 I think that we can operate a lot leaner to keep $117,000 to fund Whitmore Pool out of a $17 million budget. So what I actually, and in saying that, I just want to say with regard to this planting issue, there are those that feel that Measure Art was passed for the intention of improving and enhancing public parks. I fall into that category.
2:48:31 And then there's the other camp on the other end of the spectrum that says, sure, just use Measure R funds to go straight to paying for Whitmore Pool. Well, I view that as just, that was just a tax increase that was slid under. If that Measure R was really just going to replace the general fund, then I got a tax increase forced on me. And so that's where I'm coming from with regard to the supplanting issue. The point that I want to say, and what you don't necessarily want to hear is,
2:49:00 Don't take it from me. Take it from somebody else. I know you don't want to hear that. You want to hear solutions. The Recreation Commission, this coming Tuesday, November 13th, and frankly, I want to invite...
2:49:12 Anyone and everyone to come to that commission meeting because I really appreciate the public input that comes into the recreation commission meetings so that we can then make recommendations to you. We will have the opportunity to review the Measure R applications for the first time this coming Tuesday. Please attend the meeting 3 to 5 right here in this very room.
2:49:31 So, I guess, in saying that, I just want to say that
2:50:01 I would like to recommend to you a compromise that is a win-win, that does not only pull from Measure R. Without speaking to the details on that, we're working on that, and I invite the public to come to Recreation Commission this coming Tuesday. Thank you, Sean. Any questions? Thanks, Sean. Sandy Hogan, 17-year resident here and a very strong supporter of Municipal Recreation. Sean, you kind of gave me that opening as one of the others.
2:50:36 That holds a different opinion. I also voted for Measure R, was a strong supporter, and I understood it, as did most residents, Measure R meant R for recreation, period. And I think that's why almost 60% of the people are saying, Measure R, I voted for it, it's for recreation. Use it for recreation. The supplanting language has been a little battle that's been going on for a long time. We keep going back and forth.
2:51:06 Our town attorney has given us a very clear memo on, given the council, a very clear memo on the fact that as a matter of fact, this planting language in the first place really is not able to limit your powers. That money is approved by the town council. The only thing that would make it really illegal is if you use it for other things other than recreation. One of the things that I proposed was
2:51:36 Since that is so, and I believe Andy would, if you asked him tonight, would pretty much verify that. It's not the same as Measure U, which policy language says enhance and what's the other word? Improve. That's Measure U, policy language. I serve on that committee. But Measure R, the supplanting language, only applied to one little itty-bitty portion if you want to consider the supplanting language, and that was
2:52:06 Recreation Facilities Maintenance Funding. So it's far overblown. One, you have the power to remove supplanting language and just clean that and use that money for recreation. And I've said don't just use it for Whitmore. You can free up a little bit more in this crisis period, which I see is the next two years. Use it for recreation, period. That's what it's for. Fund the recreation department. Recognize.
2:52:35 You know that we need to keep our recreation going. It is the core, the heart of our community, for our residents, for our kids. My mom was fond of saying it kept me out of trouble when I was a teenager, and I'm a firm believer in municipal recreation. I don't have any kids, but I know it's important for our community. So don't be afraid to be bold at a time when we have to be bold. The next two years, I'm going to be a supporter of these tax measures.
2:53:03 I will volunteer, as I said, to work on a committee, especially for the parcel tax. That's probably more appropriate for me. But that's going to take a while to take effect. So right now, in these next two years, you need to make these first payments. Free up some general fund money, just fund recreation out of Measure R. You can do that. You have the power. You don't have to go apply for Measure R and have the recreation. You appointed them, you know, down deep.
2:53:33 Let's face it, you can do that. There are times when it's wonderful to follow the process. Once in a while you're in crisis periods and it's time to act. So that's all I'm coming from and I'm part of that other part. Okay, questions? Any questions to Sandy? No questions. Thank you, Sandy. Okay. Do you have another one here? My name is Mark Davis. I'm a 30-year resident of Mammoth Lakes.
2:54:05 And have been, for a long time, a supporter of improving our trail system. I've put a lot of personal effort into that over the years, and only small increments have come to it until recently. We have been working on saving our trails, which is a major reason people come here. And I can't stand still and see Measure R usurp.
2:54:34 The trails efforts. It's one of the reasons that market the town. You can market all you want, but this is solid. Trails are a big part of what brings people here repeat business. And a disappointment in maintaining these trails. People have made some somewhat inaccurate comments that we're giving money to the Forest Service. No, we're giving money back to the public who comes and uses these trails.
2:55:02 And I feel that you are forced to make some very hard decisions here, but trails are not an expense, they're an investment. I'm not saying that Whitmore Pool is unimportant, but it doesn't bring millions of people and dollars to this town like trails will. And the trails are very much in need. They are not being maintained if we don't maintain this program. And I think that it's an important part of growing out of this.
2:55:31 The problem is the investment in trails. Thank you. Thank you, Mark. Okay. Are there any other questions or comments from the public? No? I'm Terry Stelick. I'm the condo manager on the rec commission. Actually, I'm not the manager. My husband is. But anyways, I just want to say that, you know, there was a process put in place for Measure R. The commission has put forth an emergency item.
2:56:08 Thank you, Terry.
2:56:40 Are there any other questions or comments from the public? Okay. Jeremy Goico, owner of Black Tie Ski Rental Small Business, owner of town local, and I wanted to speak to what Rusty said. Thank you. I think that's something that we all need to hear. It's uplifting. My business partner, Colin, and I, we came from Steamboat Springs, Colorado. We work for the original Black Tie.
2:57:13 We know a lot of other mountain resorts very well. We've gotten to know them well. We've been to Vail, Telluride, Steamboat, Crested Butte, North and South Lake Tahoe, all over the place. I agree with you. North Star, they've done a tremendous thing up there. Their mountain sucks. We have a way better mountain. But they do have some things there that we don't that bring high dollars, and we should be getting those customers.
2:57:43 And it was just really nice to hear those words from Rusty because my business partner Colin and I have noticed since we got here, nowhere else, no other, in ski resort towns you do have this kind of mountain versus local little thing going on. Nowhere else have we felt it as
2:58:05 Divided as Mammoth, which is unfortunate. And we've felt that way for the first couple years that we've been here. And to hear, you know, this want to change, this paradigm shift that the mountain would like to put on is just very comforting and uplifting. And we look forward to working with you. Thank you. The other thing, these proposed plans, I don't like the sound of cutting any of this stuff.
2:58:38 I'm wondering where the talks are of what are we going to be investing in? Where are we going to make our money? You know, I look at that constantly with my business. Where is my money coming from? I need to make this much amount. These are my marketing plans. This is how I'm going to use my money to get a return and make those things happen. And I don't hear any of that talk going on here.
2:59:07 Frustrating and concerning to me. And I think there's some things we can be doing. When I hear that we're cutting more dollars from Mammoth Lakes Tourism, I feel like we could almost increase our... It's not necessarily here right now. Matt, I'm sorry. But, you know, I know that they have had cuts already made and stuff like that. You know, if we put more money into...
2:59:36 The institutions that we have here, instead of continuing to cut them back, maybe that will enhance our budget. And I just don't hear any of that going on. Whitmore Pool is one of the coolest pools in this country. Where else could you have a view of those gorgeous Sherwin Lakes from a public pool? You guys keep getting bashed by a lot of people-first decisions you're making.
3:00:02 Our town council is one of the strengths of our town. I want to say that. When you guys came up with the money from Measure U to save our airport subsidies, to be honest, I thought I was going to have to leave Mammoth for a little while because if that airport goes, so does our business. And you came up big and you made a decision and you kept us moving forward. And that moment, I knew we had a strong town council. And I know you'll make the right decisions.
3:00:32 And I'm just not satisfied with this proposed plan right now because it's just getting rid of everything we need, you know, to survive, you know, and it'd be interesting to hear a little more discussion, how can we raise more money, you know, and that's what I would like to hear more and would be interested to hear what other people have to say. Thank you. Thank you, Jeremy. I'll try to touch on that as we...
3:01:02 Move on into our deliberation. Are there any other comments from public? Okay. Seeing none, we'll go ahead and move into the deliberation part of this discussion. And what I'd like to do is just, with Council's approval, I guess we can just go look at page four and any other comments, items you may have brought with you, go through.
3:01:32 Either item by item, one at a time, and lay out your thoughts, your proposal, your plans, and we can discuss it from there. If anybody wants to start, go ahead, otherwise I will. Take the lead. Okay. Okay, so looking at page four, basically we've looked at all the proposed reductions, possible alternatives.
3:02:02 I'll offer my thoughts and ask my fellow council members to weigh in and give me theirs, give the rest of the council theirs. I am relatively comfortable with the proposed reductions as they are. Regarding the police department, I'm hoping the town council cannot open up their contract. That's something that's up to the police officers association. I personally hope that we do
3:02:33 Go through some discussions and have those meetings. We have a good police force. And I think with all that's happened over time, when you get into these discussions of cuts and whatnot, it becomes an us versus them thing. And that's not the case. We're one town. We're one community. And our police force is part of that. They have been doing a great job. We brought the chief on. And I think under his leadership, there's just been some great things happening over at the police department.
3:03:02 So I'm hoping that I'm going to stick with the cuts as proposed, but I'm very hopeful that we can work with our Police Officers Association to come up with some alternatives. Regarding community and economic development, I understand we have to keep our cuts where they are in the immediate term. One thing I have to say, I think Rusty said it, Jeremy touched on it, growing out of this.
3:03:28 This is a very, very important piece of what we're going to have to do. And part of growing out of that, you know, community and economic development is not just planning and permitting. There's a lot that goes on there. Our revenue collections is being done by this department largely. We have a lot of money that's sitting out there that we are missing out on just for the simple fact that we have not had a good enforcement process in place since this town has been in existence.
3:03:56 That is being created, it's being generated, it's being computerized. We need the people there right now to get that done. It may cost us in the long run to have that, but I think in the long term it's going to benefit us. Also, as far as being development ready, as Rusty touched on, that's very important. We've put our planning department in a process to make sure that we are development ready and that we have
3:04:25 Our zoning code update fixed. We have our CBiz in place. We just spoke about it at our workshop earlier. We need to make sure these things are in place before the turn of this market. I work in the real estate market. I see changes happening. I see the distressed properties are getting absorbed. About 60% or more of the transactions out there are all cash right now. So that's a big indicator of what's coming.
3:04:48 So we do have to be prepared for that. We don't want to be doing this stuff in the middle of the cycle. Otherwise, we're not going to be a year or two behind. We're going to be 10 years behind. Public Works and Transit, I'm comfortable with the cuts as proposed. Parks and Recreation, specifically as we relate to Whitmore Pool, I would like...
3:05:13 I do respect what the rec commission has to say, and I would like to see what they come up with between now and December. Tonight, we said that we'd be coming up with a plan. I'm going to offer my opinion on it. I'm in favor of using measure our monies to keep the pool open for a period of time, maybe for two years, to keep the pool open. I think we need to find an alternative program. I know there's some discussion out there.
3:05:39 With regard to bigger recreation programs, Measure R, that's what its intent has been for a long time. Rich Boccia, the Recreation Commission, had been working on some thoughts of using school lands for recreational components, whether it be the pool, whether it be things that the school can use as well as the public. Longer term, I'd like to see Whitmore brought into town, and I'd like to see it incorporated with a bigger recreation program. And I think Measure R funds can be used to build that.
3:06:08 Along with others. And I think we can bond those funds long term and have that built out. Administration, I'm comfortable where we – well, actually, I take that back. Administration, one of the areas we're cutting pretty heavily is IT. IT is a very important component. We've cut, I think, a little bit too much. I would like to see us fund that back in some manner, if not in the short term, in the longer term.
3:06:35 Technology will allow us to advance, as I mentioned earlier, just something as simple as TOT. Having computerization in place, having all these departments have the capability of talking to one another, which we don't have right now. It's very weak. Having security measures in place, we need to improve those things, not only to be a more efficient government, but also to be compliant with...
3:06:59 Legalities that are out there, so I think we need to be paying more attention to that. I think for minimal dollar amounts, we can make leaps and strides with technology. Volunteer programs, very much in favor of it. I think Marianna and Dave spoke about it a little bit at previous workshops. We aren't to levels that other municipalities are. I went up to Colorado. I got off the airplane up there, and every time I get off,
3:07:25 I see hosts that are out there. There's people in the airport. There's people around town ready to answer questions. These are volunteers that are there to answer these questions and make you feel welcome. That's just one element of where we can be using these volunteer programs, but I'd like to see us move forward in growing that type of program. Economic development is very, very important to our community as well.
3:07:50 That goes back to the Community and Economic Development Department and why I think longer term we're going to need a person in there and we have to finish the programs we've started. A couple other areas. Chamber of Commerce. We have not cut the Chamber of Commerce. Reason being, personally I think that there's a lot of benefit there. I know that somebody spoke earlier and said there wasn't. The Chamber of Commerce runs one of our bigger events in town and the money that we provide to them, they bring back.
3:08:20 Probably two or three times just off that one event. But events aside, I would like to ask the Chamber of Commerce, even put them to a challenge, to work with MLT. As we move forward in uniting our community and in uniting our business community in particular, I would like to ask them if they would work with the restaurant community and do as the lodging association has and form a restaurant association. We used to have it in the past. It was a very strong voice in this town.
3:08:48 But I think it's very important that those folks get together, and I would like to ask the Chamber of Commerce to help work on that. I'd be happy to work with them since I am a liaison with the Chamber. I see Brent in the back nodding his head, and we'll talk about that a little further later. Let's see. That's about it. I did have some comments. I think I made them with regard to Mammoth Lakes Housing.
3:09:17 I've made enough comments on that. I don't think I need to beat that dead horse anymore. People know how I feel, but I also respect the fact that I have fellow council members that have strong opinions that are different. With regard to taxes, this is one way. It is a revenue source. It's a possibility. We've heard a lot of folks out there discuss taxes. Town council, I suppose, could bring it up, but...
3:09:46 I almost think that if it is brought up, I would like to see a member of the community step forward and get that petition going if that's the direction we're going to go. Or ask us to do it and back it somehow. But I think with where we're at the cuts now, we have service levels and I think we need to find out if the public's willing to live with those or not. And finally, to Rusty's comments, to Jeremy's comments, I really...
3:10:16 Like and respect what you guys are saying. And Johnny, you said the same thing at previous meetings as did Jim Lynch. Our community needs to be bonding together in these very challenging times. We've been divided, and a lot of it's been over silly stuff. I appreciate Rusty coming up and saying what he said. I don't place all the blame on the mountain. I place some of the blame on us as a community as well. We've divided ourselves.
3:10:44 We don't need to be doing that anymore. As we bring this town together, you know, Mammoth's always been ranked somewhere in the top three of resorts in North America, and I know this year we got ranked a little lower. Last year we came up with a concept that was the best summer ever. I'd like to look forward to a new concept that we as a community, we with Mammoth Mountain Ski Area come up with, that we strive to become the number one ski resort in the next couple of years.
3:11:15 Breckenridge is always up top. Maybe our slogan is going to be Beat Breck. But I'd like to see us do that and see us come together as that community. And we've got a great marketing team to do that. And hopefully that's the direction we can head. I look forward to being part of it. So those are my thoughts. And I'd like to turn to the next council member and hear theirs. So, Jo? Okay.
3:11:43 I don't have anything else to add on the police department. I think you covered that well, Matthew. On community development, there's a couple more items I'd like to bring up. Within the work plan that is within the budget that's not being cut, we have the staff to finish up those things we need to have done to be ready for development, and we've been very fortunate that staff has gotten grants to help us with that. As far as when the upswing happens,
3:12:10 Community development is one of the areas where it's very easy to bring on additional resources and not just necessarily hire another full-time staff person immediately as the permits are coming in because, as our developers in the room know, we ask for money up front. And so you do have a way to fund getting those services done in a timely manner. So that one does not concern me. I think we will have the resources to do that.
3:12:37 I am a little bit concerned about the reduction in the TOT and the permit, but I think that the changes we're making in information technology will counteract that. Our staff have been working with some really antiquated systems. They don't talk to each other. The people get up and walk from desk to desk. That's where some of our information technology is.
3:12:59 I am supportive of changing it. If you could look at the detailed plan, you'll see that in the IT area, we're looking at approaching it from different ways and doing part of it through outsourcing, which is a reasonable thing for us to do. On Whitmore Pool, I want to reserve judgment until we hear what the Recreation Commission has to say.
3:13:22 But I want to make it clear that I've heard it said a number of times tonight, oh, well, this is only, you know, well, we'll bridge it for two years, or we'll do a loan or something. We've got 23 years here to think about. We can't just kick it down a couple of years, so I hope that whatever is coming back to us with the community input to the Recreation Commission is realistic about how we can fund some of those things because just...
3:13:47 Grabbing some of Measure R because it's available and saying, oh, well, you know, we'll do that for, and I've heard, you know, one year, two years, three years, but if you don't have the plan of how you're going to fund it, why would you do that? I think you all know I am an extremely active volunteer in town, and I know it's one of the things that I take pride in in our community, that we have so many people that are willing to volunteer and to
3:14:14 Be involved. And so I definitely support a volunteer program in any way that we can make that work. Okay. Okay. Michael? So I agree with a lot that's been said by Mayor Lehman, Councilwoman Bacon. In addition to the cuts, I mean, I still think that we need to look at raising revenue. And as Rusty stated, you know, growing out of this is
3:14:47 It's critical for us and critical for the town's future. I think that, you know, I'd like to ask Rusty a point-blank question, and would you and the Mountain support an admissions tax? And if not, why not? We'll fall behind the council. A better way to do that is to pay the same money or more through a business improvement district.
3:15:20 So it's not that I'm against the tax
3:15:50 It's that I'm for doing this differently than we would do it. We should ask the government to do too many things for us and then to beat you up because you didn't do it as well as we think that we can do it. So it's not about the money. It's not that I'm against the tax. It's that I want to pay that money on all of our businesses in a manner commensurate with whatever the logging community should do, whatever the restaurant community should do.
3:16:20 Whatever retail, rental, whatever, right? Whatever newspaper should pay. So, just kidding about newspapers, but tourism business, not all businesses, tourism business. So, so that amount of money on the missions, the tickets, I want to pay that, but I want to do it the way that I just said, not through the, not through the inefficient for this purpose.
3:16:50 Inefficient mechanism to get in the way of the end result. And I'd like to take one point, because Mark touched on it. When I say marketing, and it's not, I don't mean just ads and sunset things. I mean marketing like Apple markets. Apple starts with the products. Don't talk about the ads. They talk about...
3:17:15 The product, the iPhone, the iPad, and stuff that they sell, and we sell experiences, right? We bring people to Mammoth and enrich their lives. Those of us that are lucky enough to live here enrich our lives forever if we can get past this stuff. And those products, whether it's trails or other things, that money needs to be available for that kind of marketing, not just ads, at least in my opinion. That's just my opinion.
3:17:41 I will say it, be quiet, and throw in with the group so the people can express theirs, and that's how we, that's my answer, and I will hope that's a straight answer. Thank you. And then as far as on the pool, I mean, I'm supportive of a two-year loan of some sort for Measure R as a band-aid. I agree with Matthew. I think we need to think bigger. I think we need to look to bring a rec center to town. We need to...
3:18:11 To be able to bond R&U and provide, again, something that will benefit our residents and our visitors alike. But I think, you know, the answer to shut it down over a small amount of money is not the way to go. So I think that that's kind of all I have. Okay. Rick or John? Rick?
3:18:39 My approach is going to be a little different, and I'll begin with saying that I wanted to give a soaring speech, but Rusty already did, and I watched Obama's speech last night, and I'm sure I wouldn't measure up, so you'll only get my comments. You know, I'm not going to take a specific position on the first half of page four on any of these items, and there's a reason for that. We're going to make a decision on December 5th. I have asked...
3:19:09 Sometimes as a devil's advocate and sometimes not, a number of questions of the community because I intended to listen. The purpose of this was to listen and I don't want to effectively prejudge that which is before us. But I also want to give you my thoughts on what I think we're dealing with. Leadership requires that we make tough decisions and we will. In crisis, we have got to act and we're in one.
3:19:40 So, from my perspective, what we're really doing is examining the function of government. What is it that we want to be? How big? How do we do it? And I've come to the conclusion over these last months that we have to do it differently. We have to do it differently because we can't afford to continue to do it the way we have. People want everything, but they don't necessarily want to pay for it, or even if they do, we can't necessarily afford it. And so, as has been stated, we've got...
3:20:08 Tough decisions, limited options, not a lot of money to spend. What I find fascinating about the process, as somebody who's been in it for a long time, is that this has generated more public input, more comment, more email, more Vons discussions, almost to the point of exhaustion of all of us, quite frankly. And I should also mention more closed sessions.
3:20:37 Thank you.
3:21:03 As divided as some people say we are, I think we've got a whole lot more in common than we might think. So for me, all of this really comes down to affordability. What's the balance? Where do we find it? And I think we are going to find it. And it isn't going to be pleasant. It's going to be painful. What's on the board is painful. But one of the things I think that's important to point out, and it hasn't been stated yet, and that is that there are a lot of cuts up there.
3:21:33 The reason that we have targeted, if you will, those specific areas can be seen by having watched the PowerPoint presentation of the various departments which have shown that over the last four years we've made dramatic cuts. Those cuts don't show because they're already in place. We're pretty close to the bone, if not there, on this town based upon what this
3:22:01 What the folks here in this community expect this government to provide for it. And I understand that you can look around and, you know, find a way to buy fewer pencils and erasers, but the truth of the matter is that we're not buying hardly any pencils or erasers right now. And we're going to see impacts on the community, and we're going to live with those impacts. And this council is going to decide, based upon the values and the priorities that have been stated to us,
3:22:28 What we think is best for the community. One thing that we haven't done is we haven't cut out the investments that we make. Jeremy, you spoke about investing. You want to see investment. Well, we do invest. We invest in housing. We invest in housing for the people who live here and who work here so that they can stay here. We invest in marketing. We, as a government, invest in the business or in the
3:22:56 The mechanism to bring people here to support the businesses who support the employees and to obviously pay the TOT which runs the government. We invest in transit. We own a fleet of buses and we do that because we want to make the visitor experience better. We do so, by the way, by leveraging money. And that is not by accident, by the way. This is because the voters, time and time and time again,
3:23:25 Have been asked to make investments in this community, and they've stepped up and they've said, this is what we want you to do. As a result of those, we've got Measure R, we've got Measure U, we've got Measure T, and we've got two Measures A, which provide a total of $6 million to this community that this council said to staff when we went into this restructuring process, do not cut. So you don't see cuts.
3:23:55 Other than those that have already been made to those things that we think are investments in this community. And I would expect that from my position that we're going to continue to do that. Which takes me to my last point, and that is taxes. So it's really easy, I think, and what I've heard from a lot of people, I've heard a lot of wild ideas about taxing ourselves, and it's been very interesting. Some of them are good and some of them are just crazy, but it doesn't really matter. There's a segment of the community that is saying, I will step up.
3:24:24 And pay something in order to get us out of this mess. And my response is I'm not supportive of a tax increase of any kind. I'm not supportive of a parcel tax. I'm not supportive of an admissions tax. I'm not supportive of a sales tax. And I'm not supportive of a utility tax because I think we have taxed ourselves enough. We have taxed our visitors enough. And I also believe
3:24:52 That if we're going to have that genuine discussion and then decisions that flow from that about what this government ought to be, what it ought to do, what the limits of government ought to be, that we need to focus on what we can afford without simply going out and raising more money. Taxes are not the way to grow ourselves out of this. Investment in the community is. Rusty Gregory has presented a plan in very vague terms.
3:25:21 And specifically, we've made a public commitment of the mountain to participate with the town and its business and other communities and constituents and segments to grow our economy, to grow the visitorship. That's the way that we get out of this. And this $2 million a year is going to seem less and less onerous as we do that. I don't think the way to do that is to add an additional burden to the town, so I'm not supportive of taxes. Thank you, Rick. John.
3:25:51 The town's restructuring process that we're going through and have been for several weeks, if not months, to me has been a once-in-a-lifetime sobering experience. The town of Mammoth Lakes in the last year filed for municipal bankruptcy. Additionally, the town of Mammoth Lakes balanced our budget for this year. So we have a balanced budget for this year.
3:26:22 We have the money currently to make the initial down payment once we get out of bankruptcy on the settlement, yet we still have the additional $2 million that we have to come up with July of 2013. It's because we have to come up with that $2 million July 1st that we have proposed the cuts that we have proposed, the additional cuts, the tough cuts with the police, the tough cuts at Whitmore Pool.
3:26:52 So until something changes, whether we change the areas that we're proposing to cut or whether there's a revenue source identified, we don't have too much latitude on making the $2 million in the cuts. That's what the settlement, that's what we bought onto in the settlement. I personally like
3:27:30 My fellow Councilmember, Mayor Pro Tem, Rick Wood, do not support any taxes unless, I do have a qualifier, unless that tax proposal, whatever it may be, is brought forward by the public. I also do not support taking money from any of the measures that we have passed. Measures, I do not support.
3:28:00 I'm interested in the intent of measures R and U as they were passed by those who voted for them. And also finally I do not support
3:28:31 Any funding decrease in tourism, housing, or transit in any of those three areas. Thank you. Okay. Thank you, John. Okay. Well, I think we've covered most of these areas. Jo? Just a comment. Since we just got the idea thrown out and would not...
3:28:58 Thank you. Thank you.
3:29:26 And I know that we, earlier in the meeting on the consent agenda, we canceled the day before Thanksgiving as a meeting, but I'm wondering if we might want to ask to have something set up for next week to give people a chance to think about, provide more information, provide feedback for us to hear whatever it is the Recreation Commission is thinking about. So you want to hear from the Rec Commission prior to, let me look at the dates here.
3:29:57 I was just saying, what's next Wednesday, the 14th? We actually have a BID meeting tomorrow, too. So we may be able to shed some light on that. And the Recreation Commission is Tuesday, so if we had another meeting next Wednesday, you would have input. Plus anyone else who might want to add more input. Okay. I personally
3:30:29 I think those comments can be made on the 21st, but I'm open to whatever the rest of council wants to do. Well, we already canceled the 21st. Do you want to put, yeah, the 14th? I'm sorry. Oh, the 5th? Yeah. I'm comfortable with the 5th, but if you want to have another meeting so people can think about it longer, I'll leave that up for the rest of council. John? I'm available. I'm available. On which date? Wednesday the 14th. The 14th? Okay. So. Yeah.
3:31:02 Three. Okay. So then... Either way is fine with me. Okay. Then the 14th, we'll go ahead and schedule a meeting for the 14th to ask the various commissions to report back on... And this would be the only item on the agenda? Sure. Okay. Five or six? Community out there, five or six? Six? Six. Okay. Six o'clock. Okay, then.
3:31:34 With that, staff, did you get enough direction? Well, I guess we're going to have another meeting, so it doesn't matter now. Okay. Well, if there are any other questions or comments from the public. Okay, then. With that, we'll go ahead and adjourn and move on, and we'll get to our next meeting.