Parks & Recreation Commission · 2012
Parks & Recreation Commission
· recording 1 hr 52 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
197 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
20:37 I think you know my work, Terry does. I've been working on this problem with Whitmore Pool and a few other things since August, actually even before then. A couple of questions, a couple answers. What does it cost for a 50-meter pool? It costs a million dollars. That's $12 a square foot for concrete, demo, and port. Filtration system, like Dennis said, depends on the size, what you want to do. If you want to put in solar, all the rest of that stuff.
21:10 You're already on a three-phase system. That system is efficient. You're going to get, except when you start to replace it with new equipment, you'll probably get a little bit more efficient pump just because of technology. Demo the pool, probably about 20 grand. I just demoed two pools in the last two years. One was 15, one was 18. One was up at Courchevel, and the other one was Sierra Manners this year.
21:34 Sarah Manners with 17 grand. When you say demo a pool, you mean rip it out and fill it back in? No, we actually built a new pool. I see. Beautiful pool. You should go take a look. I believe the lot that we have right now from LADWP is 200 by 440. Am I correct on that, Stu? We'd have to verify that lease. I know it's in that agreement.
22:01 So you want to put in a 50-meter pool, 184 by 50. So depending on what you got, you got 75 feet on both sides of the pool for decking and stuff, and the length, whatever. But you guys have some Quonset huts and other situations there. I've had dialogue with LADWP. Their culture is like talking to a brick wall. So what I would recommend that you guys do,
22:32 is not spend serious money on Whitmore. Let's keep it going as long as we can and push that money into something that's a better project, closer here, it's more user-friendly. I've been working on this for a long time. My roots in the swimming pool industry are 30 some odd years and they're very, very deep. I just finished the business plan and I'm going to submit to an organization that I've known these guys for a long time. They have just created a university caliber
23:04 Education Program that brings in the AIA, Landscape Industry, a whole bunch of all your professional entities into one big program. I'm going to try to access all that. It's a game plan that I figure I can't lose at. If we come up with zero from them, we end up with zero. Some of the guys who do this work, you think about the most obscure pools that you could ever think about. Vanishing Edges.
23:34 Whatever. These guys do it. One of the contacts I have just did the, what do they call that, the, was it the Lincoln Memorial with the big lawn? They just did a three-year renovation on it. That's the caliber of work these guys do. I'm trying to get them all together to see what they can do for us. If you guys have any questions about pools, direct them to me. I've been trying to get stuff going with Stu and Dennis over the years. You guys need a filter?
24:05 Give it to you at my cost. I've done this stuff with you guys before. Dennis has called me for a few things. I've got it in my truck. Just drop it by. You guys never get a bill. Some of this stuff I can get donated. I'm starting a non-profit. That's even more incentive for. So, if you have any more questions regarding this stuff, a lot of the stuff I have off the top of my head. So, along with you guys, I'm also working on this with you, just in kind of a different direction.
24:39 Thank you. What was your name again? I'm sorry. Stan. Okay. Most people know me in town by Z. Yeah. And I think that begs the question is we need to look at all of the different facilities that we have and where is that facility going to go? What does it look like, you know, long term? So. Yep. We need to get there. Yeah. Thank you. Okay, thank you. I like that a lot of stuff. Like I said, this thing has just been a whirlwind.
25:11 It started out with Hot Creek. In August, it was a letter. I went to the Forest Service. I've got a dialogue with them about Hot Creek. That place is nice for it. It doesn't have to be. That's a gem for us. And it can be made into a hot spring facility, swimming pool. It would be a big draw. That went from that into Whitmore Pool. A couple weeks later, all of a sudden, this debacle came up with Whitmore Pool.
25:42 I've done a lot of research. I've got an appointment tomorrow in Reno with warming. You guys are using half of the geothermal that's available right now just off of what we have. That well is 440 gallons a minute, 95 degrees. We've calculated it out. New technology now. We could probably heat that pool with what we've got. And I don't know whether any of you know this. Peppermill just did a huge renovation. They ripped out all their gas and electric.
26:11 They've got geothermal there. They've got a huge pool. The whole concept is done by geothermal. I was supposed to have a tour with the people from Oromatic, except for now we're scared just to make it. There's a lot of information that I've dug up, pieces of paper I've got in a pile on my desk, but there's just a ton of stuff that we have here that we can use. The technology that's available from the pepper mill.
26:39 They have a heat exchanger the size of a pickup truck that handles the entire complex. It's phenomenal. So before you guys start dumping into a lot of money or spinning the wheels on stuff, let's get together. And the solar is a great idea. Thank you. Moving on. 2A. 2A. Review and provide direction to staff on proposed funding strategies and tactics for Whitmer Fools' operation and maintenance.
27:18 See if I may share. I'll just give you a quick preface. So this item was added late to your agenda, but we did get it out on Friday. Hopefully you had a chance to review it. It really came at the direction of council who are in here this evening talking about a lot of these things. So they are looking for consensus recommendations regarding the items that are in this staff report here this afternoon for you.
27:44 What I'll basically do is just give you a brief preface and then probably seek your direction on how we want to tackle and discuss a lot of these items. But essentially what staff did was work with our Mammoth Lakes swim team board members, coach, Commissioner Truax, Commissioner Turner of our Recreation Program and Committee to develop several funding strategies and tactics related to the Whitmore Pool operations and maintenance. The challenge that we're facing, the items before
28:15 For you can be considered as singular alternatives or as a combination to improve and enhance the operations at the Whitmore Pool while at the same time reduce operational expenditures and ultimately reliance upon the general fund. Funding strategies and tactics include additional sources of revenue, which we've listed, operating efficiencies, and C was long-term facility planning. So we've identified, I believe there's six
28:43 Additional sources of revenue items, so I've listed the strategy and just some tactical discussions that have taken place currently. Operating efficiencies, we've identified five operating efficiencies, and then C was long-term planning, which has kind of been discussed at this time, just in a brief discussion. So, Chair, I believe we can kind of walk through each one, if you wish, each one of those strategies, just to kind of, you know,
29:13 Provide any direction to staff. Really what we're looking for here is twofold. So one would be this evening with direction to council on what items you'd like staff to pursue. And then ultimately we can work or continue to work on these items to get this funding and to get the Whitmore Pool continually funded and operating, hopefully in a more efficient and productive manner.
29:41 So in that I'll turn it over to the chair and then whatever direction you'd like to proceed. Well let's go through it one by one. Now Stu, the number one strategy, Secure Measure R funds, that pertains to the proposed or draft resolution number 12 that comes after that, right? Just so that everybody's on the same page.
30:05 That is correct. There's two attachments to this staff report. Attachment A was that draft resolution that was worked on. Originally, the discussion started, if you're wondering how this got to a resolution or a draft resolution, was originally meeting just with members of the MLTPA board to discuss trails and measure R funding, and then it worked into a discussion about Whitmore. So that's that document before you staff drafted.
30:33 This first version, this is subsequently updated by that group that's been working together, and I know Commissioner Turner and I know Chair Sousa was in that group too, so they can speak more to that as well. But this would be a draft resolution utilizing Measure R funds for a period of two years for a very specific purpose, and it would have a sunset on it as well, and you can see a lot of those details in that draft resolution. This would be something that
31:01 Would have to, if Commission felt that this was one of the options that they wanted to consider, would have to be essentially finalised by December 5th. So it would have to be part of the restructuring plan that Council would need to implement at that time. So obviously it's difficult to work through all the details here, so in the staff report, staff suggested if this was one of the strategies you wanted to pursue, you may have to consider scheduling additional meeting just to work through this item particularly.
31:29 As I don't think we've got sufficient time this afternoon, but we'll see how we get on. So what the resolution does is not just the pool. The funding and the resolution is the pool and one FTE position that is not related to the pool. It amends the expenditure plan to allow the council to use Measure R funds for this purpose, even though it is acknowledged that this purpose is probably supplanting for a period of no more than two years.
32:00 That could be one year. The problem that I have with it and I think Sean and I both have struggled with is is there other room in the budget that this isn't necessary and we don't know the answer to that and that's kind of frustrating. Although we do have a meeting with the council after this to deal with this specific issue. So at that I would take your input. I would say Sean and I disagree in one area on the second page of the
32:30 Proposed thing. The sentence was added and Bill Taylor did this for us and he did a great job on this for us. I want to thank him for his work. I don't see him here. This funding shall be structured as a loan to be replayed from general fund revenues. And the way I look at that is taking money out of my left pocket and putting it in my right pocket. If we have to use these funds for this, this is an emergency. Admit to the people that this is an emergency. Take the money and move on.
32:59 And that's just my take, and Sean can speak for himself. I will turn it over to, you want to start with Sean, since you were the other person. Start with Sean. Go, baby. Yeah, boy, where do I start? Let me turn off my mic so they don't have my grumbling. Okay. Well, and I guess my big issue is that, and I've spoken to this numerous times before,
33:23 is that I am highly adverse to using Measure R funds just for supplanting ongoing the operation of Whitmore Pool. But in the same breath, I want to say that I do not want to see Whitmore Pool closed and that I think that the funds should be found within the general fund. I believe, and I'm saying this as an armchair observer,
33:49 That there's got to be room in the general fund for $117,000 to fund Whitmore Pool, and it shouldn't be coming from Measure R. There are a couple of things that, since I'm going to start down this road, that I would like to go ahead and just have entered into the record. The first thing I'd like to say is that the question number five that was part of the survey, and I said this at town council last week, is very misleading.
34:16 There are three questions, and if I can turn to it quickly. You're talking about number five on these strategies to raise? No, I'm actually referring to, and I want to bring this up, and the reason why I want to talk about it first and have entered into the record that I feel that that question... The percentage is misleading that they're saying. The percentage is misleading, and I want to say that outright because that gives me some basis for some of my...
34:46 comments. If you oppose the proposed elimination of the town share for the Whitmore Pool and Park to save nearly $120,000 annually, would you support using Measure R funds to help fund these programs? And then it's got three answers that you're allowed to give. And the question that was referred to was that 58.4% said yes, I would support using an estimated $120,000
35:12 in annual Measure R funds to fully fund Whitmore Pool and Park. But the next question says, no, I would not support. And it's two sentences, this could lead to the closure of these facilities. And as I said at town council last week, well, I'd vote for it too. I would say I will use Measure R funds, especially if I don't understand that. So just the straight question of 58.4% saying, yes, use Measure R. This question doesn't say anything about imperp...
35:42 Or is it just short term? It just says using Measure R funds to continue funding Whitmore Pool. I believe it is misleading. Then you get into the responses, the detailed responses if you want to leave comments. And there's a total of, what is it, 130, 129 responses. Now, I read through those and more than half of them, in my opinion,
36:09 And there's a lot that it's kind of unclear, and I don't want to claim any hanging chads with what people are trying to say here. But more than half of them are pretty adamant about not using Measure R. And again, everyone can have their own interpretations into this. A lot of people don't understand what Measure R, you can see in some of the responses. There's a couple things that I want to say with regard to those comments as well. I was surprised how many people didn't know that we had a pool.
36:37 That must be second homeowners. That kind of surprises me. A lot of people said that they would like to see the county contribute more funds, and a lot of people said that they would like to see user groups pay more. And then a lot of the comments also said specifically this question is confusing.
36:59 That's not the only way to fund Whitmore Pool, or you're not being entirely truthful. And this is in the comments section. So if you really dive into the comments, I think that the public gets that that question is fairly misleading. And the reason why I am so opposed to Measure R funds, and depending on how you read the law as it stands right now, the way that it was, in my opinion, sold to us five years ago,
37:27 was to improve and enhance facilities, and it was a special uses tax, required two-thirds, and in the very near future, if we bond Measure R, Measure U, fortunately there is talk coming around that is saying it's time to bond these measures, and maybe it is time, we may need to do a parcel tax to pay ourselves out of this debt that the town faces itself in right now. If we take Measure R and we just
37:55 Shifted over to paying for Whitmore Pool. I promise you that the 50% of the people who wrote in these comments aren't going to want to vote for a special use tax again. That's my biggest concern, is not just even the interpretation of what you may have voted for on five years ago, but even looking in the future. The next opportunity to vote on a bond or any kind of revenue is in June of 2014, I believe, unless we do a special election.
38:21 And we've even got to be prepping ourselves and our electorate to be willing to vote for another special use tax or parcel tax or whatever may come of this going forward in the future. And if we just turn measure our dollars over to something that has previously been paid out of the general fund, it just scares me with regard to a precedent and what we want to build and what Rich Boccio was just talking about at the podium. So that's why I'm so highly opposed to that.
38:50 This resolution, this draft resolution, and I helped write it, and there were two sentences in there that I did insist Bill Taylor put into that, which are somewhat controversial. One is as a loan, and we didn't put in any of the comments that you and I are talking about. I understand, Bill, where you're coming from with the point of, you know, do we say this as a loan or just call it what it is? We're just paying for it with Measure R.
39:19 I guess the reason why I want it as a loan is that, look, if future town councils want to forgive the loan, that's up to them. But what I want to make sure that is in place right now is the integrity of the spirit of the election with regard to Measure R is that it is used to improve and enhance. If we are going to bond it, build a recreation facility, a rec center, redo the Whitmore Pool, whatever the case may be,
39:48 I want to see that go forward and that the monies that we use right now, I'm aware that we're in a fiscal challenge right now, a little bit of a crisis situation, but there is opportunity in this chaos and I want to make sure that we are taking that money and setting it aside for future improvements and enhancements. So I guess that's the big point that I want to make with regard to saying that
40:16 If we're going to use Measure R, and I am so opposed to it, and this is why, this is my concession, this is, or I guess, this is my compromise that I'm willing to offer, is that, yeah, we, in the same breath, I will say, I don't want to see, I don't want to see Measure R funds used, but I also don't want to see Whitmore Pool go away. And if town staff is really telling us that we have squeezed every single dime out and we just cannot fund,
40:42 $117,000 for Whitmore Pool out of the general fund, which I find hard to believe, but again, I'm not that far into the numbers, and we have to use Measure R. dollars, then I want to see it in the form of a loan, and I guess that's where I'm coming from. Thank you. I've spoken. And I have some comments on that, but I'll tell you what I suppose. And I've said a lot there. Well, thank you, Sean. It's kind of a tough act to follow, and I'm kind of in between. I think Bill makes a very good point in terms of
41:12 This is our money, whether we call it a loan or it's coming out of our one way or another. I think every member of the commission does not want to see Whitmore closed. We are all disappointed that this was the cut made from the general fund from an already very lean recreation budget. My feeling is that we've all formally and informally counseled to reconsider.
41:43 Finding the money from the general fund. And my sense is at this point that that's not going to happen. That cuts to housing are difficult because of loans that need to be repaid. Cuts to transit are difficult because of environmental commitments. And I'm not confident at this point in time that the council
42:06 is willing to re-look at that. I think they've given every indication that it's R or nothing, which I think is unfortunate, but being a strong advocate for the pool, I am in favor of the resolution primarily because it addresses, it forces the council to commit to a long-term recreational capital facilities.
42:31 Discussion and plan, and I really think that's where we need to go. So I think Sean's making great points, and I agree with everything that he said about the use of R, and I've talked to so many people in terms of my feeling that R was, that supplanting language was a commitment to not cut recreation from the general fund, but I recognize that we are in a crisis situation. So I think that we need to move forward.
43:01 With the draft resolution, whether we change the language to a loan or not, I'm on the fence. I could go either way, but I'm leaning a little bit more toward what Bill is saying about it's our money, meaning Measure R. And I think that's really all of my comments for now. And if anyone has any questions, I do think that there are some really good strategies coming out of the discussion that we had in terms of anything we can do to make the pool run more efficiently. I think they're...
43:29 I think there's some really productive, really creative things that we're looking at there, and obviously any savings that we realize there would go back into R, which makes me a little more comfortable with going with just a R grant versus a loan. I did want to ask staff in terms of one of the...
43:47 Things that we discussed in terms of cost savings was looking at closing the pool for one or two days a week. And have we come up with a number on what that would save us, just considering that the bulk of costs at the pool are utilities, which we'll have? We haven't, no. So I think our intent today was to really just try and present them as we did at those meetings and then provide staff with direction. And if you wanted to pursue a particular strategy and tactic, we would then go ahead and start running those numbers for you. Okay.
44:16 Thanks, Stu. Beth? I appreciate the sides of what has been mentioned. And I keep going back to the Measure R and the resolution and what was the language on the ballot that people voted for. And the ballot language is very simple. It just says to fund the purpose of funding recreation trails and parks. It doesn't really talk about supplanting until you get into the expenditure plan, and then it details it. But the detail,
44:53 references more facility maintenance. And the numbers that are listed in this draft resolution indicate Whitmore Recreation Area, so it's pool and the athletic facilities as well. I am a little uncomfortable with the loan language in this document.
45:20 It mentions sunsetting at a certain time in two years. Maybe that's just the language, that it will sunset in two years and not reference alone because I think as Bill has mentioned, you're just taking money from one pot and putting it into another pot. And maybe that's the way to bring it to an ending point so it doesn't go on in perpetuity. Put a sunset date on it and
45:52 And go from there. And I'm not sure if it's feasible to put dollar amounts in a resolution like this. I don't know how council will feel about that. But, I mean, overall, I think you put a lot of effort into it. The way I look at Measure R is that it can be used on programs and operations. So I think this dollar amount that we're looking at includes staffing and facility maintenance. Maybe that needs to be extracted out because...
46:22 That maybe gets back to Sean's concerns about the supplanting. The supplanting doesn't really refer to the way I read the expenditure plan to the programs. It's just more facility maintenance, so maybe that would make things feel a little bit more comfortable. But overall, I think it's a good approach and a good compromise, and hopefully it'll get us...
46:48 Short-term solution, knowing that there are longer-term solutions that we need to look at, and it gets us moving, and it does keep the pool open, and I think, as Betsy mentioned, I think, and Sean, that's what we're all interested in doing. I agree with everything that's been said, and so I absolutely wholeheartedly agree with Sean that it should be alone, but I think as much as we've been kind of
47:21 As far as I'm concerned, backed into this corner as to that this is the option that we have to take. I think that also backs us into the corner that there's really no way to pay it back as well. And so I don't know if we're making the concession that we're using Measure R. I guess it would be nice to leave the languages alone in there if we have the ability to come up with a resolution or a way to pay it back, if there's that means.
47:47 If there's not that means, then I would say that it should go forward without the language of being repaid. It has language in there as far as sun setting goes. I would really like to make that clear. It says it's going through December 31, 2014. I would like to say that it is done, ended, and put a January 1, 2015 date in there as opposed to just a sun setting language. And that may be overkill.
48:16 I guess I'm looking at protecting this and making this as a short term and without any type of out and that if it was going to be used again that we would have to actually revisit it and maybe sunsetting does that. I kind of would like to see a date in there. The other thing that I don't know if we need this in there or not, it states that, you know, that there's going to be a counting at the end of each calendar year.
48:43 And any portion of Measure R funds authorized hereby spent for the authorization person shall be returned to Measure R. I don't know if that's clear enough stating that any incomes that might be seen through whatever programs or anything else, I want to make sure that that is offset, offsets any expense prior to anything coming out of Measure R. And that we need to make sure that that's very, very clear.
49:12 Any income that's derived. This is a tough one for me because I absolutely agree. This is not what the voters voted for. It could absolutely kill any potential of voting anything to benefit this community and move it forward in the future. But we're in a time that, you know, if this went through bankruptcy, Measure R probably would have been used within bankruptcy.
49:42 Because the, you know, we went into Measure R thinking that it was very protected, and unfortunately the language is loose enough that it leaves some loopholes in there, which is really unfortunate, and it's unfortunate we have to use it because it makes it really hard to argue that point in the future to say, hey, that's okay, because I've sat there and argued that point with many friends, family, and constituents out there saying, oh no, we've got this covered, it's okay.
50:12 It's, you know, not going to be used, and, you know, here we are. And it is a very unfortunate place to be in. Because the only way we are going to move forward, because we have a huge infrastructure of facilities that are falling apart, is that we're going to be looking to our constituents, to donors, to sponsors, and that's the way we're going to be able to get facilities in the future. So how we act and how we deal with things right now is key.
50:42 And Sean, I appreciate you bringing up the point on the survey because it was a joke. And so anyways, I do appreciate that. And I appreciate the fact that the information is in here that we need to move forward because, you know, I'm on the CIP committee and we sat, and I know there's been a lot going on, but sat in emergency meetings trying to get last year's budget put together and there's been no more meetings since then. And we need to get that going because we can't move forward with anything. We keep bringing...
51:12 Measure our applications forward and things forward, but we don't have that vision of what our future looks like. And we need to have that vision, we need to prioritize, and we need to start moving through that process. So now that we've gone through this resolution, allow me to muddy the waters some more. Okay. Because we're going to have a workshop with council, and perhaps I shouldn't bring this up, but I'm going to. One of the reasons that I don't like the idea of a loan, the town council has borrowed from...
51:39 Measure 2 for airport subsidies. They have borrowed to pay legal fees out of all of the reserve funds, including the Reserve for Economic Uncertainty and the Vehicle Replacement Fund. One of the reasons that there's no money to pay for Whitmore Pool and the General Fund is they're repaying in the next budget literally hundreds of thousands of dollars into those bank accounts, because that's what they are, bank accounts. They're savings accounts.
52:06 From my standpoint, after looking at what numbers, and I don't understand their budget very well, if your wife is here, she could help me with that. She's my pro. Me too. I mentioned to one of the council members at lunch today that before I put any more money in my savings account, I pay the electric bill. And maybe as a town, and maybe as a commission, we should be asking them to pay that electric bill.
52:32 Before they put money back in the savings accounts that they borrowed out of to pay legal fees. From what I was able to garner from the little sheet of budget that they gave us, we're talking, you know, $400,000 or $500,000 in the next fiscal year going back into reserve funds. $189,000 for this is not... So something else for you to think about, and I'd love to hear your thoughts on that before we go forward with a unified front.
53:00 Absolutely, we have to do this resolution, and I appreciate Bill's work, and I like the resolution if it's what we have to do. I'm still operating as a mushroom. You know, they kept me in the dark, and I won't take that any further. You've all heard that before. So my problem with just going forward right now and saying to council tonight that we approve this resolution, Mr. Wood told me today, well, Bill, we need for somebody to stand up and say,
53:29 Don't put money in savings. Pay the electric bill first. Boy, I really didn't think we would need to hear that, but maybe as a commission we need to say that if that's the way we feel. So I would ask that question of each of you so that as we move into this workshop that we're going to next, we would have a clearer thought there. What's the question? You want to prephrase that question?
53:56 Should they be hitting up Measure R for this amount when they're putting far more money than this amount back into their reserve funds? And repay. They plan in the next fiscal year, they plan to completely repay $329,000 or whatever it is to Measure U that they borrowed from Measure U because they borrowed it and they want to live up to that commitment. More important to me, if we don't have to go down the road of setting the precedent that they can come in anytime they feel a need and change
54:28 The resolution for the expenditure plan, even though that's in their purview, they're allowed to do that. Until there are no other options, I would like to not see this happen. And if they are indeed putting that much money in, we have to ask the question, I don't know at all, all I'm doing is looking at their sheet and knowing what some of the expenses are, I have a little advantage over the other mushrooms out there in the audience, but not much. I think the money is there.
54:57 By just not putting it back in the reserves this year. So you're saying money, you think the money is in the general fund, it can be found. I think it can be found if we don't fund the reserves back to the amount that they're asking to put in this next year. And for the next five years, in their five year expenditure plan, the amount going back into these reserves out of what they have in their budget as a legal fund goes up by another five or ten percent every year.
55:24 Well, you see, that's the side that I would fall back into, is that, you know, I'm stepping up to this, I guess, with a compromise, I guess. And something I want to say is that, you know, I'm aware of and I appreciate the history of where this conversation started.
55:36 But, you know, sat in a meeting with Stu and Ray and Dave Wilbrick, what, two weeks ago, and my comment coming out of that meeting was that we do need some kind of compromise. And I remember turning to Dave and saying, Dave, you find the money in the, and referring to you, the town, you find the money to fund the, in the general fund, for the $117,000 to fund Whitmore Pool on an annual basis.
56:02 And I'll help write the application for Measure R to put in solar panels or a heat exchanger for geothermal to reduce that $28,000 annual line item that is using propane to heat Whitmore Pool when it's sitting on top of a volcano. So, you know, in my feeling is that, and that's a long-term solution. I'm aware that that's a long-term solution. But my frustration is that let's use Measure R dollars.
56:30 to build an Olympic swimming pool for the Olympic down there next to the track so that we really can attract high altitude training or an aquatic center that's closer to town. Now granted, the soonest we're going to be able to have that is five years away.
56:45 So how are we going to continue to do any kind of aquatic programming in this town until that actually happens? It's got to come out of the general fund. Or, as some of these other strategies, which we haven't really touched on yet, is asking the county to pay for more, increasing user fees, although we're going to have a tough time squeezing the swim team on that. I mean, there's only so much we're going to be able to do with some of these other strategies, but at the same time, there is some that we can do.
57:13 And my feeling is that, you know, as part of the CIP process, as part of the Park Master Review Plan goes, let's pull, let's save our Measure R dollars. I've had more than two town counselors tell me that with regard to Measure R application process, and this is kind of timely because that's our next subject that we're going to go into.
57:36 I've had two different town counselors tell me, I would like to see you guys on the Recreation Commission not recommending using all that money. Save some back. It's time to start holding some back. And for the four and a half years I've been on this commission, we've been told, hold off on bonding, measure R until the settlement comes. Well, the settlement's happened. So it's time to really, with regard to the CIP process, with regard to this crisis that we've got with
58:02 Whitmore Pool facing being shut down because we can't find $117,000 to fund it, that we need to really push through this opportunity, which is whether it's bonding, whether it's a parcel tax, whatever the case is, let's get better swim programming, better swim program, and that can be not only a program but a better facility, whether it's down there or whether it's closer into town, let's actually get that. And Bill, what I'm going to say then in answering to your question is that
58:32 And I'm aware that a loan is just moving money from one pocket to the other pocket. But at the same time, I guess that's the compromise that I'm willing to offer. And it's not just me. Because if that doesn't happen, then I want to fall back and say, let's find the money in the general fund. It's got to be there. So are you saying, because we made the commitment out of Measure U that that was a loan, that it is so important to repay that loan right now because it was a loan.
59:02 That we should take Measure R for the Whitmore. And remember, it's the Whitmore Recreation Area. It's not just the pool. This is the ball fields and everything, too, because a lot of the maintenance that goes on down there is for the maintenance on those fields. Or should we delay paying that loan back in order to not use Measure R for that facility? Well, I don't know what the structure of the Measure U loan was, but if it can be delayed, it makes sense to delay that instead of taking out another loan to do this. Or the...
59:30 Economic Uncertainty, or the Vehicle Replacement Fund, or the Reserves for Police, and the Reserves for Public Works, and the Reserves for, these are all the places where money has been borrowed out of, and they have monies going back into each of these funds each year, and I don't know how much, this is just, so, and I'm not fully, we need to get through this so that we can have public, thanks. I'll keep my comment short. I think that's a great strategy, and I think that we should approach the council with it.
59:56 However, I am concerned because I've certainly been at council and heard Sean and heard Terry and I myself, and Pat as well, and I know that you have informally, we have all asked the council to find what's a relatively small amount of money to fund the Whitmore Recreation Area out of the general fund, and their answer seems to be RRR. So perhaps we're asking them their own question. Maybe we should be focused on asking them, can we delay repaying these loans? But I am leery that council may say,
1:00:25 But they're not willing to look at anything else. Well, but then we've done our due diligence. Maybe we need a plan, because I agree, you know, we are just advisory to the council, and they can do whatever they would like to do. I agree with what you're saying, Bill. I think that it seems logical that it could be pushed back, those loans, and funded the funding, and I, too, agree that it's a small amount of money.
1:00:54 In the scheme of the entire town budget, and knowing that recreation has been cut significantly in the last several years, it just seems a little inflexible. But as Betsy mentioned, I think the focus seems to be, for some reason, a little bit more recreation facility pool. And I think if we say no, you know, we don't want to go forward with this resolution, then what?
1:01:26 And it feels like there is a time pressure because I think Stu mentioned by December 5th this all has to be. And I want to ask a question about the timeline. Before we go there, let's get Chad's comments on this last piece. I think Pat's idea about plan A and plan B are great. As far as paying back any, you know, this has been one of the issues that I have with this whole thing is we don't have the budget information, we don't have the numbers in back of us, we don't know where these
1:01:56 Things are coming from. So unfortunately without, you know, we have some high level numbers and that's about it. So without that, I would agree. I think that they probably could hold off on paying back the reserves. Measure U, I actually think that Measure U should probably be paid back because it's in the same boat. It was a special tax that was used under an emergency situation.
1:02:22 That was explained that it would be paid back. There's people that are actually in Measure U Committee are probably already planning for some of those funds. And I don't think that that should be put back. I know that there's, you know, I don't know where our vehicles are. I don't know where all these other things are as far as the need, the immediate need. You know, could they be put off for two years to start repaying those?
1:02:48 Reserves. I think that questions probably should be asked. And so I think that's a great point to have an A and have a B and that we go forward with A that says, hey, this isn't okay, but I guess if you have that fallback of B and everybody knows that, that makes the A kind of mute. You didn't hear that. So anyways, I think that because, you know, one way or another, we need to move forward.
1:03:18 Yeah, okay. So what is your pleasure? Do you want to hear public comment now on strategy one, or do you want to go through all the strategies real quick and then go to public comment? We could go through so everybody kind of has the... Yeah, let's go through the strategies real quick. ...so that they can make comment on all of the above. Right. Can I just ask one question that you guys are talking about? You know you were talking about paying back those reserves. If you remember what Marianna and Cindy and even Ray said,
1:03:48 That money that has to be paid back is restricted to that snow removal tax for vehicle replacement and to refund back. That has to be refunded, correct me if I'm wrong, Ray, within the year, or you lose your chances of receiving more money to do your road maintenance. Is that correct, Ray? Are we talking about gas tax or are we talking about Measure U? Well, we're talking about all of these. Oh, okay. That's just one.
1:04:15 That's just one piece of it. Right. And so when they say that, when you guys keep saying that don't pay back some of the reserves, you have to pay back some of the reserves. No, and that's understood. Yeah, so you may not have that money. Out of that particular reserve, yes. Okay. Yeah, you have to have the, basically we get 50% from the state for gas tax. Right. We have to have our 50% in the same budget. So I think what you're saying is correct, yeah.
1:04:46 I guess my point was, I know you guys, it would be nice to say, well, we want to take that money out of those reserves, $200,000. The problem is that's what the town's been up against, is they have to pay back those reserves immediately before they see where I'm coming from. They have to pay back for, and we're not going to get into the argument now, but that one particular fund, you're right, the money that's going into many different funds, not all of them are restricted dollar funds. We don't know.
1:05:16 We don't know. I don't know. All I know is what the numbers that they gave me in the packet. Strategy 2, request additional Mono County funding. I don't know how realistic that is, but at the same time there were a lot of comments in the comments section about that the county needs to, you know, pay more. And I don't know how realistic that is in getting the county to step up, but it sure doesn't hurt to ask. Yeah, you can always ask, but having been to...
1:05:49 Supervisors recently and asking them for money. Their fiscal boat is really not sitting much higher in the water than ours. Fair enough. And we're also about to have a new board sit with three different supervisors, so. Okay. Any other comments on strategy number two? Nope. I think you can ask. I don't know how far you'll get, but. Yeah. Enhanced programming. Any particular comments?
1:06:16 Something we discovered there in Stu, correct me if I'm wrong, is our total gross revenue was $22,000 last year? At the pool was, yeah, just $18,000. I'm referring to the pool, but it's $18,000. Yeah. And I want to say that in the sense of, you know, can we maybe increase a little bit here and there? Yeah, that was something that Betsy and I in Stu kind of explored, Lindsay and, you know, a couple of others as well, but, you know, we might be able to get another five or ten
1:06:47 Grand, 5 or 10 percent. We can knock it out of the park and make another 2,000. Yeah. So it'd be at 20. I think we decided that our rates were already high. We'll talk about user fees here shortly, but just as far as, you know, do we build soaking tubs, do we have a TO style, you know, not without quite a bit of investment. So I don't know how much that's, opportunity that provides. I don't know, we used to have parties under the floorboards at Whitmore Pool.
1:07:16 In the hot spring that runs through there, maybe we could do that again and charge, you know, wine and teas. Maybe we should. The enhanced programming from my standpoint, I love the idea of any enhanced programming. Usually the first year costs us money on enhanced programming does not make us money. These are great things to consider. Whitmore Pool is hugely underused. Great things to consider. However, in terms of the current...
1:07:43 Need, I don't see any of these enhanced strategies helping much. Would these be offered like through a contract instructor, so not staff? Some could, yeah. I mean, Zumba obviously does right now. And the pool party, private dinner, that could be something that the swim team could take on and do some fundraising. You know, July 4th would be a great venue to watch the fireworks and do the whole thing.
1:08:06 And these other ones here, InterCupola, these were the things that we were investigating when we were looking at a lot of our research. So it just could be enhanced program just to increase visitation just through, you know, more usage. Yeah, and I think all of these are great ideas that we should pursue. I don't think looking at them as a saving. Yeah, as a saving. If nothing else on that, I'm going to go to strategy four, secure grants.
1:08:34 What type of grants are these? Are they something that is it for programming or is it for improving facilities or is it? We've got two. We've got the SPLASH grant and the PACSWIM grant. I know we talked about the SPLASH grant. I can't draw my memory on those swim teams. Lisa, did you want to jump up and quickly talk about those? These were being researched through a swim team, so they came forward and recommended that we kind of submit a joint application. The SPLASH grant is actually something that's set up because so many children don't know how to swim.
1:09:03 I don't know the exact numbers. I know it was 40% of Caucasian kids don't know how to swim, and it's even higher for other minorities. So you become a splash partner with U.S. Swim, and because we are a swim team that's affiliated with Pacific Swimming, we would qualify for the grant, although Steph's not sure with the amount of lessons that we offer, if we can qualify or not. That's what we're trying to find out. Once you become a splash partner, they give you a bunch of literature.
1:09:31 So that you can start splash events and try and get more awareness about the need for people to learn how to swim and then you can apply for the grant. And the grant gives funding for swim lessons and would be another source of income in that regard. So you would actually have to have the increased lessons up front before you could? Well, we're trying to apply to become a splash membership so she's thinking, she's not sure, she's going to send them the information anyway because we're such a small rural community.
1:10:01 We probably won't fit exactly what they're looking for, but hopefully they can make an exception for us because we don't have that many year-round occupants, you know, to be able to have, I think it was eight lesson sessions and we had six. And so she's thinking that it still might work and that she could send in the information. I don't know if she sent in the information yet or not. Oh, there you are. Yeah, we talked, remember? Yeah, we met and we filled out the pavement.
1:10:32 We filled out the paper to be able to mail it off for the splash grant. And then after that, if we get approved as a partner, then we can apply for the grant. And the grant, I think we have to make a partnership by the 13th of January, I believe, on that. What kind of revenue would that bring in? Wasn't it like $1,500 or something from lessons?
1:10:56 It's not a huge amount. It's not a huge amount, no. Does it basically help provide lessons for system-managed children? Yeah. It all helps. It all helps. It's something we should be looking to do. Yeah. Well, it's definite goodwill. I mean, we need to get the kids around this area, you know, water safe. So, it would be for that. And it's a lot of outreach.
1:11:21 And one thing that's happened is that our community is not unique in terms of the fact that pools are very expensive to operate, and no one that I'm aware of makes up in revenue what it costs to operate a pool facility. And because a lot of communities are looking at cutting their pools because of that expense, a lot of national swimming organizations are realizing that there is a need, and so there have been some efforts that grant monies for...
1:11:47 Other communities in our situation, so we need to be, I think, involved in that. Absolutely, thank you. Thanks, Elise. Any other thing on grants? Raise user fees. Raise, and then you see what they are there, Stu. The graph we have of fees, is that current fees or is that what you're proposing? That's, we're at $4.50 right now. This is what we're currently charging? Correct. Okay, so I...
1:12:21 I'm sorry with you guys, but I don't see any room. We're already at the ceiling. Yeah. I mean, maybe we can raise it a dollar or two. Yeah. And there was also some other ideas that we had as far as being able to combine some of the sessions. But, you know, and asked the swim team to pay a little bit more.
1:12:46 There's, you know, and every little bit helps. I don't mean to say it's not a lot there, but, because every little bit helps, but, um, We just asked them to do so much already, they volunteer to help clean you. Well, that's right. They stepped up with regard to offering volunteer hours in there, so. Yeah, absolutely. And I feel very strongly that we cannot raise our lesson fees. They're very much, you know, in line, if not a little bit higher than what other places are doing.
1:13:11 I have had some lap swimmers say to me they would be willing to pay a little bit more either for their pass or maybe through some type of a donation option just to help keep the facility open. How many kids do we get for lessons down there on a weekly basis? Swim lessons. Staff? For the summer. It's cumulative.
1:13:43 We have two time slots that we do. We have at least two to three classes going on per time slot. And we try to work within the appropriate ratio, so no more than six kids per class. So if you had three classes going on at the same time, you have at least 18 to 20 kids in the water, up to 18 to 20 kids in the water per time slot. And it just, you know, it varies. That's why we offer seven weeks, eight weeks of lessons so everybody has an opportunity.
1:14:12 I do have a couple comments on this actually before we move on. Lindsay, did you have direct answer? Yeah, I just have the information from our meeting before. Yeah, if you've just got that real quick statistic, excuse me, Bill. This year, this came from Stephanie, that last year there were 449 kids who took group lessons.
1:14:40 Two people took stroke improvement classes and 34 kids in privates. 449 broke out over how many days? How many kids a day is that? It's like eight weeks, isn't it? Is that what we do? Eight weeks. Each session is a five-day session. So is that person counted for each five days? Yes. The report that Lindsay has is strictly attendance. That's why sometimes when you guys look at each.
1:15:09 Revenue numbers versus, you know, attendance. Attendance is always going to be really a lot because we've got people that will come, they book for a five-day, you know, people on session, they come in five days. So we count that person for five days before they just won. So all that strictly attendance.
1:15:27 And that was one quick comment is that we certainly could improve attendance, you know, and
1:15:40 Is that a Measure U transportation grant or, you know, application? I don't know. How do we get kids down there to the pool? I heard two different town counselors at the last town council meeting say that ultimately they'd like to see the pool move closer to town so it would have greater attendance. And I think that everyone would agree that you bet we'd have a lot greater attendance. But as we discussed on our tour this afternoon, it's only 10 minutes away. So it's kind of give and take there. Yeah, it's not that big. And I think anecdotally that.
1:16:10 I learned how to swim there back when we were all riding horses still. Well, almost, anyway. So back when Mammoth had a thousand people or fewer in it, three days a week, there were at least 50 kids there each day for swim lessons. We should be able to produce more with 7,000 people in Mammoth and a couple thousand more in Crowley than what we did in the 60s. So there's room there for a whole lot of improvement.
1:16:40 And it's 10 minutes. It's, you know, at any rate. I just looked up the splash grant again, and I just want to clarify, it's $5,000. I was wrong. A municipality with one pool is $5,000, so better than we thought. Okay. Thank you. And you had another comment on user fees. I would like some other information on here, especially if we're moving down this path. You've gathered a lot of information here, Stu, but I would like to know what each of these municipal communities are subsidizing.
1:17:10 What percentage are subsidizing their pool? So we have what the rates are, but I'd like to know what the actual subsidy is and what their user numbers are. Now, since I just got that email this morning, I did get some responses back from the people that I reached out to. I just had, you know, I had an interview this morning. I understand that. I just sent out the email, so. We've already started down that path. Okay.
1:17:38 Okay. It is a question that I ask because I think that's important. And then the other thing that I'd like to say is, you know, I agree that, you know, in some cases maybe some of these fees are at a max, but I don't know that. And I'm looking at, you know, we're looking at either closing our pool or we need to raise the revenue. And so I guess I'm looking at, you know, we're going to have to raise the cost of the pool usage. Are we ever going to be able to pay for it?
1:18:07 Through those usage fees? No. Absolutely not. But, you know, what does that subsidy look like? What is it reasonable? And then, you know, do we have sponsorship programs for folks that might not be able to pay those increased fees? I mean, I'm sorry, Swim Team, but I look at Swim Team at $1,800 for the amount of time that's being used down there, and I just think that that needs to be upped. Lap Swim, I think, could definitely be up.
1:18:35 Now, like I say, once again, it's not going to pay for it, but every bit that we can increase our revenues for that pool is going to help in the long run. Terian, I just want to add that there were a lot of comments specifically in answer to that question that did say specifically raise user fees. But that's kind of easy to say.
1:18:58 It is. It's going to be talking about it. It really is going to be minuscule. And as you look at it, we're already at the higher end now. One thing, it's hard to compare. I don't know the hours of operation. So, for example, the season pass, for here, it's $100. But for lap solving in Bishop, it's $180. So it seems like, oh, there's room for increase. But maybe they're offering them more hours per week or per day than we're able to offer.
1:19:27 So it's, in a way, apples and oranges. But maybe there could be more cost-effective methods of doing things, as I think you guys have touched on before. And maybe, I think even Stephanie mentioned, maybe group lessons should be a shorter duration, you know, 30 minutes instead of an hour or 40, but whatever it happens to be, that would save some stout.
1:19:47 And I think that's where the subsidy question comes in because that's going to give us a better idea of what we're actually comparing as well if we know what each of these communities are subsidizing. We're running out of time, so I'm going to move this to the public comment portion of this. Please keep brief, and if somebody else has already made your comment, just nod and we'll see you. A couple things I want to touch on is what Sean was talking about.
1:20:16 Five years ago when they voted on all this money for Measure R, I've gone to two Measure R, actually three Measure R, and not one time have you guys put any money away. In the previous years before the economy taint, you had all this money coming in, but it was all being used for trails and whatever. I don't understand why you can't put some of that money away.
1:20:44 Like last time, you deferred $300,000 for this budget for trails, and you've done it, and you're going to continue doing that. Well, I think you need to re-look at that and see what's really important. Do we need more trails? Do we need to help with Whitmore this year or next year? Maybe there's other things, but if you can put away some of this money towards this big project that we're all talking about, if they do these taxes, and once this lawsuit's done,
1:21:13 Then you could go back to the people and ask them to pay or do another tax to do a big complex that you all were talking about. But in the meantime, it's not going to happen for 10 years. And you need to start putting some of that money away and bank some interest off of it. I also think that the town will never pay back the loan.
1:21:41 If you borrow this money from Measure R, they don't have the money to pay it back. There's too much out there at this point, maybe down the future. But they're only asking for two years. It may continue. We don't know that. But you guys have obligated yourself for $300,000 for the next five years for trails. And now my question is, if you're going to do Whitmore and we're going to do our trails, there's not much money left.
1:22:11 for any other project that's coming up in front of you. So maybe we need to look at do we use, send that 300,000 to Trails or do we scale it back this year or next year? I don't know what that answer is, but maybe we need to look a real hard look at that. As far as the accounting for Whitmore Pool with the income and the expenses, Teri, I'd be glad to make sure that happens.
1:22:37 And I can get all that information, and I'm pretty good at that detailed part of it. I'd be glad to work on that as a volunteer to present that to all of you, if that would help. As far as raising the fees, I think the swim team has talked about helping out in a lot of ways. But I'll tell you, I think you all know that all those kids on swim team, they're out there fundraising to keep this program going, and they're the ones that kept this swim team in the black because of their fundraising.
1:23:07 It's not the money that we got for their fees to swim. It's all their fundraising efforts that these children have done, and they were willing to even do more. And if you ask us to pay more, I'm sure it depends on the amount that you're asking, but then if we have to raise the fees to cover it because we don't have it, then who does that hurt, and do we get less kids, and then those kids can't swim because they can't afford it. So we've got to think about that as well. Thanks.
1:23:37 Thank you. I have one question. No, and actually it's of the board, and if you guys could help me out. In our youth sports funding, didn't we give swim team $3,000? We gave them money, I'm not sure. Because remember there was a reduction this year. There was a reduction, so we may have cut it back 10% because our whole funding was cut back 10% because that is the fee that they used to have to pay. So it was actually given.
1:24:05 It was given, well, that's, it's just, so if there's money given, so that is a Measure R thing. No, it isn't. That is a sports youth funding. Youth sports funding. Yes, that was general funds. So, anyways. We turned back the $3,000 except for last year that was reduced. I think it was to $18,000. Okay, that's just a question. Rich. I'm sorry, Rich.
1:24:28 Comment and clarification. Keep connecting those dots. We've got great schools in this community that need some work. We've got lands. We've taught facilities. The schools have to be in the middle of this mix. Clarification. The $117,000 we're talking about, if this doesn't go through, do we lose the match from the county? So really we're losing two cents on it. Or losing...
1:24:48 Twice as much than we anticipate. And number two, if the parks are closed or Whitmore has closed the ball fields, do I contact CIF and say I'm canceling my baseball and softball programs at this point? Yeah, I don't think you're going to see them closed, so I don't think that's going to get an issue. Okay, do we lose the match though from the county on this if this doesn't go through? If we close and have no expenses, then we have nothing to bill them for. They pay 50% of...
1:25:17 What it costs us. So they'll match the 117 if this is approved tonight. And it comes to actually more than that, but yes. Yes, thank you. His point, though, that if we close Whitmore Pool, or close Whitmore Recreation Facility, that he's losing a large portion of your athletic season, is that correct? Baseball and softball season is done. Right. You contact CIF, number one and number two. If we don't do this, we lose the county match in funding, which I thought I heard about last week.
1:25:49 Yeah. And it gets a whole lot more complicated than what we're even talking about here because there's leases and everything else. We can't just abandon the project, believe me. I just have a couple questions. The 117 that we're talking about, does that include the Whitmore and the ball fields and the track?
1:26:07 So, so there is... I think it's only the pool. It's not just the Whitmore pool. It's everything. It's the Whitmore recreation area. Okay. It's half of 232. That's another person. That's an employee. Oh, that's right. So Whitmore is, what, is it half? 230? Well, of the 232,000, we believe 100,000 is the Whitmore pool, and the 130 is the Whitmore recreation area, as in the ball fields. So it's 230.
1:26:34 $2.30 is the total, less the revenue, so it's $2.14. So you're saying it's specifically $1.17 goes to Whitmore Pool? No. No, it's the Whitmore Recreation Area. Okay. About half of that would be the pool. Yeah. It's actually the full amount is $2.32, I think, is what it comes to. Correct. And because the county pays for half of that, with the income that we bring in, that reduces it as well.
1:27:02 Our actual cost is $117 just because that's our portion that we have to fund. Okay, so most of this is aimed at Whitmore Pool, but that $117 isn't the entire program for Whitmore Pool. Do I get that correct? That's right. That's half of it because it counterpays the other half. But this is actually having to fund the entire Whitmore Recreation Facility, not just the pool. Right. So in my...
1:27:30 Do I understand is correct that I could be logical in saying Whitmore Pool itself could be $50,000, $60,000 instead of the whole $117,000? I think Stu says about $100,000. Yeah, so the operations at the pool is about $70,000 a year plus the maintenance. Now the maintenance is a joint fund. Okay, I got it. Yeah, gotcha. How does the Parks and Recreation Town handle donations? Welcomely.
1:28:01 Okay, let's just say, I imagine we came up with $117,000 out of my back pocket and it covered your budget, then what happens? Okay, I understand. I don't want to get into cross conversations because we have time constraints. What I'm saying is that I just want to know, if it covered the entire budget, then whatever you have budgeted goes back in the next year, goes into a coffer, goes somewhere else, right?
1:28:30 Well, there's no money that's budgeted. This is coming out of the Measure R funds. So, anyways. And I think it would get more complicated than that. If the money was donated for Whitmore, I think then the county would come and say, well, we want ours reduced by the same that yours is getting reduced. The town only collects back from the county 50 cents of every dollar that the town actually spends. Okay. But it might be worth the conversation. Maybe we could do that later. Okay, so now how does...
1:28:59 How do you handle a subcontract? What would happen if the town said, we want to subcontract out Whitmore Court to somebody and let them bid on it? Bid on the operations and maintenance of it? Yeah. I think that's actually going to be explored in the next phase after the restructuring. I don't know specifically regarding this item, but I think the town's going to work through that question. Okay.
1:29:27 There's other programs and grants available through the swimming pool industry too. And I know of several. NSPF has the same type of program with swimming lessons, but they also have world and other programs. There's also some avenues of crowdfunding that anybody can do. Could be the town, could be a whole group of us that could help in all this.
1:29:56 You answered my questions. Thanks. Thank you. Thanks, Dan. Good afternoon, everyone. My name is Sasha Mueller, and I am on the Mammoth Shark Swim Team. I have been doing it for two years, and in those two years, I have met new people and become more active. To start off, I'd like to say that before I was on Swim Team, I would just sit there bored to death. But swimming has given me something to do. It has kept me in shape for skiing and has kept me on top of my game.
1:30:32 Here's a coincidence. Lindsay Barksdale is my swimming coach and is now my ski coach. She has helped me become the best swimmer that I could ever think of. Yes, I understand we are in a lawsuit and I get it. We need money. But please don't take away our pull. It is the only team sport available to us kids in the summer. So, in conclusion, us kids, we need Whitmore to stay open so we don't get weak and bored. Thank you. Thank you, Sasha. Okay, Alana, top 10.
1:31:09 My name is Alana Levin, and I actually came for a different portion of the agenda. I'm sorry to be honest, and this is being talked about. So I just wanted to pass on my comments as an individual in the community. I can't represent my club, but I certainly can say that I am a user, and I'm responsible for bringing, you know, through our platform club other users to the pool.
1:31:37 and that I would support raising the user fees for lap swimmers. And I also actually would just say that I wouldn't support raising the swim team fees, but I would support seeing an encouraging increased participation in the community, helping to get more kids there, because I do agree that you would lose, potentially lose the numbers that you have if you increase the fees on those families. And then also I
1:32:07 I thought the strategies were great and I'm hoping that they'll be combined so that we're looking at all of them together, the grants. We are a member of USA Triathlon and we could look, I'm horrible at talking in public, but we are a member of USA Triathlon and we have looked at grants before so I'm happy to come together and see if we can come up with some small but money to help.
1:32:37 Bring some support for the pool, including even in our annual membership, very little money that it would bring, but even adding a certain amount of money to our annual membership and saying that that includes a pass or that includes a punch card, you know, something like that to help encourage participation for lap swimmers to bring more people there. Also, as a user of the Whitmore pool, I...
1:33:05 Use it myself. We use it for triathlon club training, for junior triathlon training. I, and again, just speaking as an individual, I do not support using Measure R funds for the pool. I do agree with Sean, and I don't know the ins and outs of the loans, so I'm not commenting on that. But I do support being sure that everybody's looking at what is written in that measure and
1:33:33 What are the restrictions? And just that we take care in following any rules or matching funds restrictions. And I know that we all feel like we're on this deadline of the pool closing next summer, but I don't think that we should buy into a fear and a panic about we have to grab from here and here or the fear of having to
1:34:00 Try to take money from other programs that are valid. I personally think the Trail System is a very valid program and I see people using the Trail System. I see people on a lot and a lot of visitors. So I think we have a lot of wonderful things about it. I hate to see us start to pit against each other and try to take money from others. I'd rather see us collaborate and really try to
1:34:27 Be creative and see if we can bring matching funds as a community and fundraising to something like this. And I do support continuing to speak to the Town Council about what really are the numbers and what really can we do for the general, what can they do for the general. Thank you. Thank you. You know, very well said, Alana, because I have to say that we're being asked right now to make this decision because this is being cut as of the fifth.
1:34:56 As far as Whitmore Recreation goes, we actually have some time that we can sit down with folks in our community and try to figure this out. Now, as far as the staff member goes, that isn't the case. But anyway, so...
1:35:12 Right, so we've got... Well, but we could have a couple months that... Okay, Stu, do we actually need to pass a resolution on any of this, or can we just use the knowledge we have given each other and move that forward into our meeting with council? Because that would be my preference. Well, I think two things. So, you know, part of this process is the restructuring plan, and they're trying to find savings. They're obviously trying to find, you know, a couple million dollars to pay.
1:35:41 Our loan, sorry, our debt. So, I mean, December 5th is really a hard time and we need to find that money. It's actually cash. So, in the other discussion about delaying loans, you're just delaying funding. There's no real savings, right? So, actually, we need to find this money and I think that's why this is a critical time. So, I think from that point of view, December 5th is a hard time. So, if we really want to pursue this resolution,
1:36:06 We've got December 5th to work with. There's no other meeting scheduled apart from our applicant presentations with our Measure R applicants from the 26th and the 29th of November. There's an opportunity there to come in maybe an hour before that applicant presentation and maybe walk through the resolution and firm up this language. We'd also like to get it to the town attorney. So, you know, I think we do need to kind of move that along. I think in regards to tonight, I don't think a...
1:36:33 A motion is really needed because we haven't really finalized any. I think it's just a consensus recommendation. You're going to continue to pursue these strategies and tactics, work with staff and then bring something forward. But I think council are very interested here tonight if a resolution is part of one of those strategies that you want to work towards. Yeah, and I think they'll hear that as a commission and as individuals. So unless somebody...
1:36:58 feels that we need to pass a resolution on this. No, and I actually would like to say that I think that if this is going to be part of a Measure R, that it at the very least needs to go through the Measure R process. So it does mean that we're really just considering input tonight, correct, with the intent to make a recommendation by December 5th. You know, I've had several people actually tell me that, you know, they want to see this go back before the voters.
1:37:27 I don't think that's entirely realistic, but at the very least, it definitely, in my opinion, needs to go through the measure of our application process. Council's going to make the decision before December 5th. And as an advisory board, I think the best we can give them today is our advice on how we think this should move forward and tell them pretty much what we have just said. So if you're good with that, we have about 15 minutes left maximum to go through our last agenda item, the 2000 and...
1:37:57 How would that? I don't think we have consensus on whether it should be alone. So how would you phrase that? I think the council just needs to hear each of our opinions on that, and they need to be the ones to make that decision. Well, unfortunately, two of us can't be there tonight because we weren't anticipating this happening. Well, that makes it a lot easier. So I just want to point that out. I think that if, yeah.
1:38:25 There's somebody that's, you know, Bill, if you're going to present this, you could present it. Yeah, I will. We have option A is that, you know, reserve funds aren't paid back and that we, that the council please try to find funding. There might be opportunities within the community with partnerships, with grants, with things like that that we would need more time to pursue. And that B would be that, you know, the resolution would come forward. There is.
1:38:55 kind of dissension, whether it would be a loan or whether it would be just an outright supplanting or in moving that forward. But that one, you know, we would like to see Whitmore Pool funded in some manner, whether it's coming from general fund, whether it's coming from partnerships and grants, or whether it's coming from a resolution, being either a loan or not. Is that fair enough?
1:39:22 I think that Jenny could take that and play it. Yeah, and we will. I will make sure that both sides of that are heard. And I think I heard from all of us that if it's possible not to repay the loans right away, that we would prefer that funding mechanism be used for the pool. And if that is not possible, then they have the closed sessions. They know more than us that we would then move forward with the resolution. And the dissent on the resolution is whether it should be a loan or whether it should just be.
1:39:52 A theft. I mean, I mean, just used in that method. Perfect. Okay, we're good? Yeah. So let's move on to review the measured RFs, revise the timeline if necessary, and the presentation. Remember, we're not actually looking at the individual applications unless you have specific questions about one that you need to ask.
1:40:21 More importantly is what order do you want them presented in and does the timeline still work for you? That is correct, yeah, so just briefly, just for the members of the audience too, so the measure R fall application period closed October 24th. We received eight funding applications for a total request of just under $680,000.
1:40:49 All the applications can be reviewed online. It's on a home page, some quick links under Measure R. You can click into the 2012 fall applications. The estimated available funds for a ward are around $325,000. That's in your packet as well. And that's really due to the encumbrance of the $300,000 from trails and the maintenance items that we've previously discussed.
1:41:16 So this evening, what really staff is requesting, we had revised the timeline due to the fact that we're compressing everything to December 19. So what staff has done is put the two applicant presentations in the same week on November 26 and November 29. So that's Monday and Thursday, both at 2 o'clock in Suite Z. So it's after Thanksgiving, it's before December.
1:41:44 As we've stated before, December 4th is actually when you make your funding recommendations and it goes towards Council on the 19th for your workshop and for Council to review and potentially approve those recommendations. So that's what we have. The applicant presentations are presented to you. It's in the order. Usually this is a process that we go through each of these meetings if there's another order. Typically it's from the applicants, so if the applicants come forward at this time that wish to move their order around.
1:42:12 You can also change that order at the meeting as well if a group's prepared or they have a presentation and so forth. So the opportunity is here to kind of review that applicant presentations because we'll go ahead and obviously contact the applicants after this meeting and present that schedule to them. And then also in this packet is just your Measure R application checklist that you'll use when you do grade these applications in December. And remember that he says we have two meetings in one week.
1:42:42 That is only if the Thursday meeting is needed. In the past, a couple of times we have managed to do the whole job in one night rather than break it into two. That is just there in case we need to break it into two. In this case, I don't think that's going to be necessary. I have a conflict on December 4th, it's personal conflict, so I'm not just one person, but I'm wondering if we could meet any of it earlier that week on a Monday. If not, I will then...
1:43:13 Listen to all the presentations and then provide my written ratings. The 4th is our regular meeting, isn't it? Yeah. Right. So by then, they're graded. We should have that by the 2nd meeting. Right. Typically by the 29th. Yeah, hopefully by that time our recommendations are pretty firm. I don't have a problem moving Monday. And I don't have to. Monday the 4th?
1:43:49 3rd. 3rd. I mean, I don't see any particular problem with that. I'm fine. Unless you, there's another option, you can leave November 29 and actually do your recommendations on that date and leave the 4th. If that works, we can do that as well. And then just go back to regular rec things on the 4th. Yeah. Be done. I have no problem with that. So it's the 27th and 29th that we're talking about?
1:44:16 Yeah, that's correct. So we would use both of those meetings. Although it's still, it may not, both meetings still may not be necessary. We may be able to still hammer it out in one night. It just means that both of those nights we need the scoring board and everything in case we get to that point. And then typically as the commission had is for any follow-up questions to the applicants, they have those three days to kind of prepare an answer. They have that opportunity again on their Thursday. Maybe it takes, you know, an hour, 30 minutes to get through those questions and then you can kind of proceed with your recommendations.
1:44:46 And I wanted to comment. I think Mammoth Nordic received $20,000 from the trails, right? So wouldn't their request, I know that there was a conflict overlapping time-wise, so maybe their request is for $20,000 less than $60,000? I have asked Stu to give you guys the portion of the minutes from the MLTSCC meeting where we dealt with that because we put parameters on it. It's an NTE. It's not an absolute amount, not to exceed.
1:45:15 Because that committee thought that that was the fair amount to pay for grooming for the season. And I would like you guys to all see that and be aware with that. I don't want to just tell you, as Sean and I are both on that committee, but I'd rather you saw what was decided there. The $60,000 is the same thing he asked for at the MLTSCC, and we decided we needed to at least guarantee him that money up front so that he knew he was going to run the season, whether he got the Measure R award or not.
1:45:45 And then I believe it was decided, and we have Sandy here as well with us, that if they passed Measure R muster, then Measure R would backfill the MLTSCC. I know we talked about that. Is that the way we finally concluded on that? Yes, it is. That's what I thought. But at the same time, you know, that's, you know, we pay them out of this pocket or this pocket. That's exactly right. Yeah, I understand. It really wasn't. Yeah, yeah. Well, but my concern was that it,
1:46:15 Yeah, which is fine. I think what Bill's trying to get to is that it was agreed upon that the $20,000 was a sufficient amount. Was the amount. Yeah. So, anyway. And we can certainly ask it later. Yeah, that'll be asked at a later time. But I would like that verbiage for you to all see that. Yeah. You know, I asked this earlier, and there's just one question that I have since this is being dealt with right now, is the contract for Whitmore Pool.
1:46:44 I know you said they're just cleaning up language, but if we're being tied into that for five years, if we're looking at our master facility plan, if something changes and the pool changes from point A to point B, you know, I guess I would love to make sure that we're looking at that when we're putting a new contract together, so. We'll make sure we consider that, and there are provisions in that lease agreement where you can
1:47:11 You know, you can amend the lease, just like we did with the ball fields. That lease had not expired, and we amended it and updated it to include a larger land area so that we could fit the track in there. So the same provisions would be in the pool lease, but we'll definitely keep that in mind going forward. As the lease holders, I would also be interested in knowing what is the end game if we decided that pool was no longer in our future.
1:47:39 What do we have to do? Is it in our lease that we have to remove it or does it, because it was LA's before it was ours, we've expanded, it would be interested in knowing what it would cost us. Well, I just had this conversation with DWP a couple weeks ago with regard to the ball fields and the track and there's a couple things. One is we could stay in the lease, this is not what you're asking, but if you did, then there's a minimal amount of maintenance that would have to take place just to keep the facility
1:48:07 you know in a state of good repair so it's not falling apart or the town could choose to get out of the lease and what I was told basically if we made that decision then they want the the land reclaimed so you'd have to go out and demo all the improvements and restore it you know to their satisfaction now the issue that you just pointed out with regard to the fact that that was LEDWP facilities before
1:48:35 That's a bit of a nuance, and I'm not sure, you know, what, I'd have to go back and look at the current lease and see what it says about that, but I'm 90% certain there's language even in the current lease that would require us to restore the site. Right. And that was my question at the beginning of the night. Right, the cost associated with that. But restore it to what? Because I can tell you photographic evidence that there has been a hot...
1:49:01 Well, we're going back into the teens. We can argue that. We'll just tell them we'll restore it to what it was when we took it over. Right. Or something close to that. Yeah. Okay. Thank you. Any other questions? On that specifically? Yeah, because I'm to measure our application. Because I'm moving on really quick. We have five more minutes. I'm going once, twice, manager's report.
1:49:28 I believe I've put everything in here. I think the first version, I missed the day of the tree lighting ceremony, so that's Friday, December 7th. That will once again beat the footloose sports parking lot. In here also is the little comments from the community centre and the Hornet house up there. We're also planning moving the gymnastics program to the middle school. We're securing that insurance, so as you know, it's a very laborious process, but we're getting there. And then Hot Shots Basketball.
1:49:58 Has, well, begins tomorrow. How about that? That's going to be the Mammoth Middle School Gym. And then the only other one that we had here, we obviously did our tour at the ice rink today, so it's scheduled for Friday 23rd. That's weather permitting. Depends on what happens outside with the weather. And finally, the ribbon cutting ceremony for the Mammoth Track Project slash field is this Saturday at 12 o'clock.
1:50:25 And as you know, we're not really scheduled to open that facility until April 1st at this time. So council commissions are all invited. Should be a great affair. Bring your running shoes. Prepare to eat some cake. Maybe after the running, I'm thinking. Probably not before. That's all I had unless there's any other questions on the management support. Questions? I just had a quick question. How many people attended the Honda?
1:50:55 We took $260, which adds $2 for a visit, so we figure that's about $130. That was this year. Last year probably doubled that one, I would say, just because of the size that we had and the age group. This year it was really just elementary age, so I think for elementary age, I think it was great. Last year we actually accommodated the older kids and the Hornets and the Arsenal were separate, and then we did the trick-or-treat around the village.
1:51:25 And it was a long period of time. That was a three-hour, four-hour event. So in two hours, we did, I think, a pretty good number. You're welcome. Commissioner's report. We can start with you all night, John. Yeah, just that Town Council meeting is tonight, but if you're not going then, Chamber of Commerce Mixer is at the newest business in town, which is right next door to the Mammoth Brain Tasting Room. But anyway, Chamber of Commerce Mixer is tonight, 5 to 7. That's it.
1:51:56 I have nothing to report. Well, I must make a shameless plug. Oh, do it. That's right. You've got a good point as well. I believe there's bluesy bluesy tickets there in the auction, isn't there? That's right. You're so welcome. Good reason to go right there. I don't have anything. Me neither.
1:52:24 I'll entertain a motion in that case. I so move. Second. I have a motion and two seconds. Good job. Thank you. All those in favor? All those in favor?