Parks & Recreation Commission · 2012
Parks & Recreation Commission Special meeting
· recording 2 hr 53 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
361 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:00 If they want an extra 652 or whatever it is.
0:31 Thank you.
1:02 Thank you. Thank you.
1:32 The agenda is set to you, and I'm like, well, I don't know what we're supposed to do. I don't have students know what we're supposed to do. He calls students.
2:00 Thank you. Thank you.
2:42 It's your fault, Teri. It's all my fault? Is it talking to you? Between talking to you on the phone, and you know my house is, you know, only 900 square feet. It's probably stuck in here somewhere, but we were in a rush, so you didn't. I should have brought my house to you with me.
3:18 This barn is surrounded by two roses, too. I love that. Is that a big holiday? Yeah, it was alright. I had family, huh? Which is always nice.
4:10 Wow. In general, this goes through that box. You know, I always do this to myself.
4:52 Okay, just juggling lots of stuff as usual. Do you need one?
5:27 Okay, I will call this meeting of the Town of Mammoth Lakes Recreation Commission to order. Roll call, please. Here. Present. Public comments. This is the time any member of the public wishing to speak on anything that doesn't otherwise appear on the agenda.
6:07 Post public comments. If no one says anything, do I ever have to open it. And the only thing on is the applicant presentations. Applicant number one, the Whitmore Recreation Area Operation Maintenance. Good afternoon. I was, hopefully, Elaine was going to jump up during public comment and talk about the fabulous ribbon cutting. I thought that was a...
6:38 Fabulous event, really well attended. I mean, Bill was there, I mean, the mess, Barry Crusty, I mean, it was a really, really good event. If you weren't there, you missed a T-shirt. But congratulations, we thought that was a really, really well done event, so I didn't want to publicly say that. Oh, you're going to jump in when you do your little thing. Okay, sorry, I might have taken away her... Okay. But yeah, we did want to thank you for a terrific event. Good. So, I'm here to...
7:10 Present the Whitmore Recreation Area and Parks Maintenance Position Application. I'm going to essentially summarize the executive summary, which is in your packet. As you know, the town submitted four applications. These were presented to town council and then again presented to the Recreation Commission on October 9th. So the four applications the town will be presenting this afternoon. I'll do the first one here for Whitmore Recreation and then we have Peter and Ray here. I believe Ray's here until 2 o'clock.
7:40 Sorry, 3 o'clock, Ray? Yeah, till 3 to follow up any of these questions that we might have about the application. So we'll try and be succinct and as brief as possible. I don't know if you can on this first one. So essentially the town submitted this urgent application to the 2012 Measure R Fall Award to fund the operations and maintenance, as we discussed, of the Whitmore Recreation Area and the full-time parks maintenance position, which is currently under Dennis.
8:09 for a period of two years. This funding request, as you know, is the result of the proposed restructuring plan to reduce the department's full-time equivalent staff from 6.15 to 5.8 and to eliminate that one full-time position to fund the settlement agreement. So the funding request is presented in the packet. It's $117,000 currently to fund the 50% cost of the annual Whitmore Recreation Area expenditures.
8:39 As you know, the county reimburses 50% or 50 cents for every dollar that we spend at that facility. And the other amount is the $66,485 to fund the full-time parks maintenance position. So I'm going to just jump in and just briefly kind of walk through some of the impacts and the benefit that we have. It'll be very brief. And then we'll try and finish off with, as we did briefly at the meeting on the other night, that
9:07 Staff is working and continues to work with a lot of the community members and advocates for the pool and the recreation area. We're continuing to work through that funding strategies and tactics document. And then subsequent to that is the resolution. And I don't know if we want to spend any time on it today. I think we'll look at that probably on Thursday. But feel free to ask any questions on those two documents that I have here as well because they do cover this application as well.
9:35 So the Whitmore Pool is the only public pool in Mona County. As we know, it operates from June through September and serves over 14,000 Mona County residents. This season, over 70 swimmers utilize the pool each day. The closure of this facility will eliminate many community-based and needed programs, much as we've talked about before, including learn-to-swim lessons, public lap swim, adult stroke improvement classes, along with the popular recreation swimming.
10:01 The Whitmore Pool is also home to 19 members of the Mammoth Lakes Swim Team. They've indicated that they're on their way. And for over 15 years, the Sharks have called the Whitmore Pool home. Recently, the team finished third out of 11 teams at the Regional Championships. And as you know, many of those teams swim year-round. So it's a great effort and a much-needed facility for that team. Across or adjacent to the pool at Benton Crossing Road,
10:30 The Whitmore Recreation Area includes one regulation baseball diamond, two softball fields, restrooms and considerable parking. It is also the location of the new multi-million dollar track, as we've just commenced, and the synthetic field that is nearing completion, we think about two to three weeks away until we can hopefully accept that facility. The closure of this facility, not obviously the synthetic field and the track, but the three baseball...
10:58 Fields and the softball field there will impact many organisations upwards of when I did the count of about a thousand children, including Monon County Little League that we've discussed, AYSO Soccer, High School Soccer, want to get on that field now, we're kind of telling them we might have to wait until January, Eastern Sierra Dog Agility as you know, Mammoth Unified School Juristict as we discussed, and the Sierra Cycling Foundation which is host to the annual High Sierra Fall Century.
11:24 Finally, the loss of a Recreation Supervisor, which is also budgeted in this reduction and this application, would reduce the many value-driven and customer-centric programs currently being offered by the Recreation Department. As you know, a lot of the programs that we offer are very affordable and really targeted towards our socioeconomic demographics here in town, and they include open gym basketball and many summer camps, hot shots.
11:51 Little Sluggers and the very popular youth theatre. So a lot of those programs would be affected as well. Briefly in summary, the proposed restructuring plan and the loss of the Whitmore Recreation Area and Pool would have an adverse effect on the community's quality of life. It will negatively impact the health and social wellbeing of our residents. It will restrict opportunities for a local youth to pursue their dreams. As one child said, his career at eight could be potentially over.
12:21 And finally, it would reduce recreational amenities and programs that are critical to the success of our tourism-based economy. So I think we've talked about this item enough. Hopefully there was enough information in the application. As we said, the Town's working through our many funding strategies and tactics. We do have members of the team in the audience this evening and also High Sierra Triathlon who are also good users of that facility.
12:51 At that time, that's my presentation. And any questions we may answer for you. Want to jump right out and start us? Nothing that I haven't said already. Nothing I haven't said already. Okay, well I have some questions. In your financial summary, Stu, one of the things you hear me harp on a lot is true cost accounting and all that other stuff which adds costs on to what the actual cost of the job is.
13:25 And the garage vehicle services, can you explain that one to me? Because that's a pretty big number. And the vehicle equipment depreciation charges, I'm assuming that that goes into the vehicle replacement fund. Ray, you may be able to answer, he's better than him. And in these times, are those things, well, firstly, garage services, what are they doing on what equipment that's $16,000 worth? Because somehow that seems like a lot of money to me.
13:55 and the depreciation charges, is that just on the equipment that's used at Whitmore or does that cover all the vehicles that the Rec Department has or how do these, because that's a lot of money between those two items. You can start. Good questions. The depreciation portion for Whitmore should be just the depreciation of vehicles used at Whitmore. So it's probably getting there and back.
14:26 On-site doing the work down there, whether it's trucks or lawnmowers or whatever, it should be a proportionate amount to Whitmore. Then we also have the budget for the rest of the parks, which is just parks maintenance. There should be a similar line item in that budget to cover the rest of the parks. Yes? I was told at one point that it was 25% of the 12 costs of the recreation vehicle replacement and maintenance costs. Yeah.
14:57 Could be. This is what I'm suggesting is that's how it should be structured. Now, to get a firm answer, you've got a different answer, and if you got that from Cindy, then she's the one that's doing the work. So, Dennis? That's not Cindy, that's Dennis. Well, Dennis, he knows. I mean, he's into this budget. So, I guess what I'm suggesting is the way it should be structured.
15:24 You should have a proportionate or a prorated amount for each budget. So since we have a Whitmore budget and we have a parks maintenance budget for all other, and the percentage may actually work out that way. I don't know. We could, probably what I'd suggest, I kind of wrote that question down on Thursday. We can come back and present that to you or either have Cindy come and get those details for you. We can get clarified. No, I'm sorry, what was the other? Garage and Vehicle Services.
15:54 The next budget that's put in at $15,807, that's a lot of mechanics. Yeah, and again, it should be a proportionate share to that fund. So all departments pay into that fund. And again, it should be based on number of vehicles, service hours, that kind of thing. Even if that's somehow... And again, we're going to be asking the other question. We'll get clarification on both of those.
16:26 So your concern is the $16,000 just seems on the high side. If it's 25%, that's $64,000 for vehicle maintenance. For the recreational vehicles. And somehow that seems a bit much to me. And then the second question is, are these things, since what we're trying to do here is to give enough money to keep the level of service down there what it is, are those numbers that really should be added into this? I mean, we're running on a shoestring, you know, budget.
16:58 Are those things that really belong in this application? Got it. So we're going to find out where that number came up for, for the vehicles and the garage? Yeah, we'll get a calculation on that and then pose the question about what do we really need, you know, to continue to maintain and provide the level of service down there. Of the total budget for Whitmore. We're trying to decide where the numbers came that's assigned to Whitmore altogether, right?
17:34 Yeah, how did they get assigned to Whitmerer? Are they true cost of operating the pool full of season or is this replacement cost? Is this stuff that could be delayed for a year or two? Should it be Measure R expense? Because some of these, I believe, is just taking money out of Measure R and putting it into a vehicle replacement funder. Yeah. Any other questions for those who are mine? Has the town attorney reviewed the draft resolution yet? He has the resolution, he hasn't.
18:06 Provided any comments yet, so I'm trying to get those comments for Thursday. Thank you. Does everybody up here have that resolution? Yeah, we've revised one, the latest version. I know Sean and I do, but I didn't see that. I don't know if we got forwarded. I don't have any one. Yeah, so Stu, could we get that latest one that, uh. Yep, I can email it this afternoon. To everybody so that we can deal with it at 1 o'clock on Thursday, right? We're all here at 1 o'clock. Yeah, 1 o'clock. Yep. To deal with that issue. Okay, thank you. And, you know, I appreciate you bringing up those questions.
18:38 The questions that I had brought up before, but you know, I think that we just need to make sure, and I haven't read the new resolution, I haven't read what it says, I just think that if we're moving forward with this, that it needs to be very clear that any income that is dropped from the pool is going to be offsetting the expense. We're in savings.
19:04 And that all of this is just, that it's still going to be invoiced just as any other application, that it's not just that we're handing you $185,000. Any other questions on the, how to resist the, or as you call it, on this application? If I may share, we did have Lindsay, swim coach, if Lindsay wanted to say anything before we finish this. Are you okay? I don't want to put you on the spot, but.
19:37 Okay. Or Alana. If you'd like to speak to it, yeah. Because they helped us write that application as well, so I did want to make sure that if you wanted to, you were able to provide any other additional information. My name is Lindsay Barksdale, head coach of the Mammoth Lakes Swim Team.
20:10 I guess I just would love to reiterate the importance of the pool to the town, to the community, and really for me most importantly to the children in our community. I think that, yeah, I think the pool, I think the sports complex in general, the ball fields, as I drive back and forth to the pool twice a day from May until the end of August, I see a lot of youths down there by different groups.
20:38 That utilize it. And I haven't said this before. I don't know if this is now the time to say it, but as a member of the community. Oh, perfect. Okay, we can go through that as well. But something that hasn't come up yet for me that I haven't said as a member of the community and with regards to Measure R, I feel differently than some people I've heard who've expressed feelings up here when I voted on Measure R.
21:07 I simply voted for recreation. I didn't vote knowing really any of the fine print other than what was on the ballot. I didn't really research it. And yeah, I just saw recreation. I like to recreate. I moved here because of recreation. So I guess for me, Measure R is to support any type of recreation in any way. And for me right now, this is a pretty important...
21:34 Recreational Facility that needs to be saved. So yeah, Alana Levin, myself, one of our swim team board members, Lisa Okamoto, and then Bruce Torrance. We got together last week just to see if there was anything more we could come up with. And I think this is in the new version, but it sounds like you guys haven't gotten the new proposal. So some of the things, we came up with quite a few different fundraisers.
22:02 that we were willing to put together with our groups to help the pool, help the Whitmore facilities. The swim team can host a swim meet. All of our proceeds could go toward the pool. There's different ways that we could have triathlons in conjunction with using the pool, using the track. We also use when we host our Whitmore triathlon.
22:29 Currently, we use the dirt road that goes around the ball fields, the kids bike on it, so that we can keep them off the paved road and away from traffic. You know, we talked about different community fundraisers where we could get matching of funds in the community if the swim team raises a certain amount. Maybe individuals could match. Maybe we could host a track meet that could raise money. A baseball tournament. Maybe the dog agility could have some sort of competition where they donated money.
22:57 We talked about a pentathlon. I think the list of fundraisers are so, Commissioner Stalick, when you say about any proceeds going toward the pool and offsetting things, I think as well fundraising could be toward that. We're looking into grants last, two weeks ago, Lisa Okamoto talked about the USA SWIM grant for $5,000 that would come in. We're looking into renewable energy grants, trying to think about that. Elan 11 is looking into USA Triathlon for any grants they may have.
23:27 We had some ideas to generate more revenue as well. In talking to people who are lap swimmers, we could raise lap swimmer usage fees. Maybe there's a way that we could keep county residents paying the current fees for the pool, but maybe out of county residents pay a little bit more to use the pool. Again, you'd have to really clarify non-resident and things like that, but I think that could be done.
23:56 We can host special events, you know, renting the pool for parties for different things. Maybe the pool could sell food down there. I don't know if that's, I'm sure there are different problems and more hassle with that, but I know for me I'm down there a lot. It'd be great if I could get a sandwich and do my work in the office and not have to drive back to town.
24:16 I see a lot of people during our swim practice who use the public restrooms down there when they're going for bike rides. I think there's probably a way you could get some revenue from people wanting to donate to use the restroom. Contract swim lessons. I know of a lot of people in town who come to me who teach swim lessons and they could do private swim lessons and be a private contractor through the pool and give some of their proceeds that way.
24:46 I don't know if this, is this what you want to just go through and kind of talk about? Okay, since you guys haven't heard or been able to read it. We talked a little bit about the efficiency of the way that we see the pool being run and we talked about maybe changing the schedule a little bit. It came up to maybe close the pool on a Sunday and Monday. That works for me because our swim team doesn't practice on a Sunday and a Monday. But again, days could be changed, I'm sure.
25:14 Talking about when I talk to people in town, some people don't come to Whitmore because the hours that it's open for public swim don't work for them. So talking about maybe the swim team could switch our practices up, try to open a little bit earlier in the day. My friends with kids, their children take naps right in the middle of the day, so 12 to 4 doesn't ever work for them. So maybe the pool could get open earlier in the day to allow for some morning public swimming. It's really warm and pleasant down there. Lap swimming.
25:43 You know, during swim lessons or during swim team, we could try to offer a lap swimming lane so there's a lot more time in the day for lap swimmers. Maybe starting lap swimming earlier, but now it starts at 6.30, you could open at 6, because really right now people are knocking on the door at 6 o'clock. They help pull the covers to get it going earlier, so maybe we could just have that available. And then enforcement of payments. It seems like the system now could be changed to really better,
26:13 Make sure, I know for my swim team, kids come in early to go to swim team. They want to hop in the water and public swim. We can figure out a better way to make sure the pool makes a little bit of money when people are using it outside of swim lesson time or swim team time. We spoke about sponsorships and donations. I know Stan is here. He's talked in the past about having a product that he could donate for fixing the pool.
26:38 We can look into more. I have a swim team parent who looked into solar water heating. He was on track to get a company to donate product for that. So there are things we can go that way. Stan mentioned briefly as well at the last meeting about talking to different swim corporations, seeing if people would donate. I'm sure they need something that they could donate to for tax write-offs.
27:00 And then marketing. We talked about for the pool, or Whitmore in general, a sign on 395. The kiosk has their big sign when you go down south of Bishop. Getting better, not better, but maybe different signage at the visitor's center. Ads in the papers, making sure that all the visitor guides are targeted. In the post office, even just putting things up there. If there was a way to get some sort of email blast, different from Stu's News or Recreation this week.
27:28 Web sites. And then, not sure if this works, but at the post office as well, just putting something out to every PO box person, because a lot of things that I talk to people about, they just don't know when the pool is open, when it's available. And unfortunately, I think it's laziness that they're not willing to look it up. And I think if we can really spoon feed it to them, there might be a better way to get more usage. And then, just going through the last page here, it's maybe not.
28:03 I think that's probably about it from that. I don't know, Alana, if you have anything else you want to bring up. Are there any questions of that going over? Yeah, maybe. I just want to ask, Lindsay, you've said some great things here, and you bet, you know, probably take all your suggestions. I'm glad you guys are meaning to try and come up with ideas, whether it's fundraising or reducing costs. And definitely, you know, some of the things you wrote down,
28:32 There's going to be some, you know, challenges to be sure. I guess my question would be more, you know, how would we try and work some of these compromises into any kind of resolution we pass here? And do they need to be worked into any kind of resolution that we pass here? Because the way the resolution currently states, essentially, is that
28:57 We're looking to fund the Whitmore Pool and the position for two years for maximum of two years and once that happens, you know, I don't mean to say it like this, but there's no more real pressure on anyone to try and do these kind of either fundraising or cost benefits. Stu, one of the questions I was going to have for you that's not necessarily directly to Lindsay here is
29:23 How do we even begin discussions with the county to ask if they can pay more? And of course their initial reaction is going to be no. But how do you even bring them to the table to discuss this if we in the next week or two need to make a decision, sorry, next week and a half, that we need to make a recommendation here that goes forward that says, well, not unless the county steps up to
29:53 75% or the swim team is able to generate X amount of dollars. So I'll answer the first question. So we did draft and include in the resolution language that says whereas the town will pursue viable and sustainable partnerships, public, private, and non-profit to improve operating efficiencies and to reduce operating maintenance expenditures at the Whitmore Recreation Area slash pools. I mean, we're writing that in. I don't know if any other language you want to add and include that.
30:21 The other and the second question there was I briefly did talk to the Town Manager about that and we would suggest that the Recreation Commission draft a letter requesting that and present it to the Board of Supervisors to see if they would consider additional funding for that Whitmore Recreation Area. I think that would, from an advocacy body and a recommending body of Town Council, we think that would be probably a good first step to kind of broach that discussion and see if they're willing to
30:50 Engage a conversation with us about that. Although, frankly, from my standpoint, if we're going to engage the county, let's engage them not just at Whitmore. Maybe 50% is fine at Whitmore. Let's engage them with the fact that we provide all the recreation for all the South County kids here in Mammoth, and maybe they could help pick up part of that ticket, which would put money back into the recreation fund. So I think that's a conversation that needs to happen. But it's not just about Whitmore. It's about recreation costs.
31:21 Yeah. Any other questions? I have one last comment that I just thought about while you guys were talking as well. As you are going through all of the Measure R applications, I guess one thing that I would love to see is rather than a straight no answer to this application, is there a way to say, you know, look, all of these groups in town are trying to compromise and help raise money. Measure R is willing to...
31:53 Could compromise a bit, give a portion of it, and then is the town willing to also give a portion? You know, is there still, I don't know, I can't get quite a grasp at the town council meetings, is there hope of the town still coming in and saying, yeah, we can find the money? But even if, so, you know, maybe it's not, I would certainly love to see, instead of a no answer, some sort of compromise of we'll kick in half if you kick in half or something.
32:21 Thank you for saying that. I think that that's actually a big, that's the question here. I don't think any of us want to see Whitmore Pool closed. Yeah, I get that. I certainly have gotten that from you guys, from the Town Council, not quite so much for sure. But yeah, I guess any way we can go about it. I hate to just have to be a citizen and keep saying, save it, but I have no constructive ways to help. But yeah, the mower that we can just get.
32:49 A little bit here and there from every group and make it work. I just have to say that I appreciate the groups staying together and seeing how they can help the situation out, understanding that, you know, kind of everybody's put in an awkward position in this one. Yeah. You know, so I guess in diversity and in bad times there are, you know, benefits. People are coming together and coming up with solutions. Yeah, definitely. Thank you very much.
33:17 Go. I think that last point was really what I was going to mention because I have to go to people that it's not that I don't support using measure or funds for the pool, but I just support that we do it within the confines and I'm still not really clear about the language. I've tried to look it up, but I'd be happy if somebody could point me in the right direction to find Alana Levin. And I certainly would, I think I support
33:48 In your recommendation, I support responsibility back to the town council for rather than deleting that item from the budget, having some responsibility toward it and then perhaps asking for matching funds. I know that Measure R even is rooted in the idea of what can you bring to the table. So if there are certain items in the Whitmore pool or Whitmore recreation area budget that can be
34:18 woven into Measure R's language, then those are the items that Measure R works to fund, and the items that are not part of the Measure R original language that we voted on are matched by the town or by the county. And the last thing I would add is really another kudos to Lane and the High Service Triders and everybody who was involved in bringing that facility.
34:46 Because I think it ups what we're trying to develop here. And to take away the projects around that seems, you know, here this group just, it shows, raised funds, brought it together, and it is going to bring a different level to that recreation area. And then finally that the county, just a reminder that it is the only pool facility of that that we can use.
35:17 And then one last step is Hydera Triathlon Club certainly does use the pool and we've had designated times for the club to use. I've said it in the past about lots of user fees being increased. This is a very small help on it, but certainly the Tri Club too having some element of support with that. So just reiterating that the community is behind it and certainly would stay behind it even if in the language or the recommendation it said these clubs have committed to X amount of dollars or these three fundraisers.
35:46 That you can rely on us to follow through on that if you wanted to touch base with us about specifics on that. Thank you. Stan, Celine. I realize this two-year budget is really kind of do or die. The council isn't going to matter if we donate or fundraise or anything else. That's speculative. But I've got some things here on the budget I was looking at. Pool supplies for fiscal year is $3,600.
36:23 I've been in the pool business for 31 years, and I look at $3,600 as pool supplies is pretty outrageous, depending on what it is that's inexpensive pool supplies. Obviously, motors, filters, and stuff like that can't add up. And again, I'm going to tell Stu and the rest of you that I have contacts in the industry. Whatever the facility needs, at the very least, I'll get it to you at cost. In some cases, I'll get it to you for free.
36:56 Public Utilities, $20,000. What was that? Whitmore last week. I'm taking some pictures. Contradictory to the Mammoth Times, it's not a dump. The spring is still alive and well. Our cisterns there that we've been drawing water from aren't filled. So yeah, there is a situation there. But I come up with 91 degree water in about 400 gallons a minute that's going on.
37:27 Wasted down the meadow. That's not LABWP's water, by the way. That's BLM. And I've had dialogue with Colman and Bishop. I believe that 28,000 can be cut in half. So I don't know if this dialogue helps you at all with the city council. But I think that those numbers are real. The same thing with solar. The roof space on there is enough to heat that pool just in itself.
38:02 Those are just a few things that I came up with. The other thing, too, on this is that the structure of the fiscal year isn't really fair on programs. Now, you take Brian. His is in the wintertime. His is right in the middle of the fiscal year. He needs money. Ours is at the very end. He gets split in half. So what you're saying is, okay, we're going to make a finite budget here based on certain things when Brian's budget could be used
38:33 Exclusively in the wintertime. God knows last year we didn't have any snow, so maybe his budget's lean that year. Whitmore's going to be pretty much consistent. But I don't think that when you evaluate everything, when the money's funded for each one of those things is important. And then the last thing I want to ask is, again, let's just say that we get Mr. Moneybags who wants to throw in
39:07 A half a million dollars into the Whitmore Program. How does that affect the budget? I mean, if they've already made the commitment for a two-year budget, and then all of a sudden we say, hey, you know what, we can fund this all in-house, then what happens? I mean, where does that money go? It goes back to Measure R. It goes back to Measure R, and that would be a great thing. And I think it would actually depend on how Moneybags decided to tell the town that he wanted to allocate that money.
39:40 That money could go to the water in the spring to be used to heat the pool. It could go to the solar. Anytime you make a donation to a non-profit, which is what the town is, you can earmark that donation for however you want to spend. So if it was earmarked that he couldn't be used to repay Measure R, then you couldn't repay Measure R with it. That is the domain of the donator.
40:03 Really has nothing to do with this particular request. But you follow my point in this is that certain programs are funded at certain times and it could be important how that money is... And I was just going to make a clarification that none of this money actually is just taken and placed somewhere else. It's actually invoiced back to Measure R.
40:28 And then the money comes out of Measure R's account. So it actually doesn't go there and then come back. It just doesn't go anywhere if they don't need it. So if there's monies that came from fundraising or from our wonderful Mr. Money Dads or whoever. All right. Thank you for your time. Thank you.
40:49 Can I just ask Dennis? Can I just ask Dennis to answer the two questions that Stan brought up with regard to the pool supplies being a high number and the water at 91 degrees? I know that you've given us some discussion about why we can't use the water, but we asked that question last meeting and you weren't here, and we'd love to have you just kind of speak to that on the record, those two items. Pool supplies is chlorine. Okay.
41:19 Things like that. Water treatment items, filter parts, miscellaneous parts. Anything that has anything to do with the pool is pool supplies. Brushes to scrub the pool, nets, skimmer baskets, covers, all types of things. But chlorine is our biggest purchase. We spend about $7,000 a year just on chlorine. Okay, well, the number here is actually...
41:49 What was it? Because that's only 50% of the cost. I see. Okay. No, actually, it's not. No, it's the whole cost. Well, the way the budget works, it rolls over from, we run it all summer, starts in July, and then in the spring, we start back up. But still, that's the annual amount. Yeah, it is. Yeah, regardless of whether it's split between two budgets. Right. Which it isn't. It is kind of. It is partially, yeah.
42:20 You have a couple months that are in. Right, in the previous. So that pool supplies is anything to do with the pool separate from the ball fields. So any supplies, anything that operates the pool. Okay. Bump motors. Stan was saying that that number seems a little bit high, but. You know what, Sean, let me clarify that.
42:49 Sanitizers and stuff like that. If this is including all of that, pumps, filters, maintenance stuff, pool covers, brushes, and all that, I'd say that's a quite fair number, and it might even be a lot lean, depending on what happens in a year. Okay, thank you for clarifying. If we lose one pump, and you could spend $1,500. Okay. You know, we have circulation pumps, we have irrigation pumps, we have pumps that run the water to the...
43:18 Showers. We have small pool circulation pump. So we have about five different pump motors down there that all, because everything is drawn from the well. Okay. We don't have a water system down there. We are our own water system down there. So really, it's quite lean. Okay. With regard to the water that is coming out of the ground at 91 degrees, there was an issue, and if you could just speak to that. We used to pump years ago.
43:48 We would constantly pull water out of the ground to heat the pool. Well, the health department came in and told us, no, you can't do that anymore. You need to make this a closed-loop system. Contain that water and treat that water constantly. So we only pull water in for a couple hours every day to replace what we lost to evaporation or we probably have a few cracks in that pool that we're losing water underneath.
44:19 And that's from a freshwater well? That's from our well. And that water is about 91 degrees. And years ago, we used to always consistently pulling water out of there. But you can't control the pH or the chlorine levels when you're constantly dumping fresh water in there. Okay. That's it for now. I know that there's discussion, at least that I have.
44:49 I know that there was discussion of whether we use a heat exchanger to keep that water constantly heating the water inside the pool or solar, but that sounds like a completely separate measure to our application. The problem today is we don't have enough way to run the pool, let alone by the heat exchanger. It's sort of a catch-22. Okay. Well, I was going to ask a question about contractual services. You know, $6,000.
45:16 What does that consist of? Do you have to hire someone else to do some work out there? Yeah, we do. So we have a water main that breaks down there that's a four-inch water main. I think I talked to you guys about the four-inch water main that I'd like to replace someday. It broke on us, well, once during the construction of the track, twice during the construction of the track, and we discovered a leak out there when we were working on that. We don't have time to work on it. We hire a contractor. They come in, dig it out, and repair it.
45:46 Things like that that's above and beyond. We run one guy down at Whitmore three days a week. If he runs into a situation where we have issues, the whole crew goes down there, all four of us. So we're running very lean down there, extremely lean. That facility needs five people full-time to make it something special. Right now, three days a week, that's it. Thank you. Further questions?
46:18 Next on the list is the grant matches, the trails grant matches. Hase isn't back yet, but I can give you a brief discussion on these projects, two projects. Essentially, these projects are in the trails system master plan. One of them is a connection between
46:48 The intersection at Meridian and Sierra Park Road at the library goes to the college, continues past the dorms and then connects down to the main loop. That particular project has got several other funding sources including a BTA grant for $538,200, an EEM grant which is $343,000,
47:18 And the friends of the library have also donated $34,800. And for that project, we're asking for a $25,000 match, which will fill out the budget. Currently, the project has been designed. It's ready to go to bid once we get this particular grant. Measure R is approved. So it would be constructed next summer. Both projects or just? That was the BTA. That's the college connector path. The other Waterford Gap.
47:49 Closure Project. That project also has received a BTA grant. We did do the CEQA document some time ago, a few years ago, with Measure R money, at least part of it. And that project will need to be final designed, so that would be designed this summer and then constructed the following summer and build the two bridges across the creek at Waterford, between the Waterford Gap.
48:19 Area. And the BTA grant does require a 10% match, which is an amount of $66,930. Any questions? Yeah, I just wanted to ask, with regard to the grants, what's the long-term impact on Measure R in the sense of ongoing annual fundings? I get the impression that once these two trails are built, they're built. Is there anything, and correct me if I'm wrong, but is there anything in the grants?
48:53 It might come back at a later date if we don't fund, we have to give back grant money, something like that. You know, essentially the trails do require maintenance, some maintenance, you know, we plow, or I don't know, I don't think, part of this we're actually thinking about plowing in cooperation with the college, but the, you know, you do have to sweep the pests, you know, at least monthly, that's our current protocol, and I don't,
49:22 We're not looking for Measure R impact for maintenance. Okay, so there's no Measure R impact for maintenance. It's not with this grant application. All right. Thank you. This was also discussed at the MLTCC meeting in April. No, I remember it. No? Any questions? Bill? When we took our field trip, you had said that there's an opportunity to split these amounts and that part of this needs to be funded this year and part of it can go into next year. Can you break that out if that's the case?
49:56 For the connector path, that particular project, we would need all the funding this cycle to move that project forward. For the Waterford Gap project, the design cost is really what would need to be done this fiscal year, which is the 69-30. The remainder could be in the following fiscal year as far as construction goes.
50:26 It would be $69,000 for the 2012-13 fiscal year and $13,000. And for the 2013-14 year we'd need $60,000. And if that came back, if you had the $60,000 would that need to be in the spring or could that go in the fall of next year? Could go in the fall because we would bid it in the winter. Okay. We would need the funding in place before we could go to bid. Okay.
50:53 Is there any type of contract with the college as far as the maintenance or usage of that trail since that is the college connector path? You know, their environmental impact report suggested that the path be constructed. It didn't require it. They did, you know, they did pass a resolution, the school of MCOE and the college as well as the foundation agreeing to provide the right of way needed for the trail as required.
51:23 and to assist with maintenance as they could afford to. So essentially they're not on the hook for it. But I think for the winter snow removal aspect, there certainly should be some discussion about that. And the town's currently not committing to clear the snow year-round on that path. So it only says that they would help maintain it if they can afford it? Yeah, essentially there was no obligation other than support.
51:54 All right. Okay. The reason, so the EEM grant, which is an environmental enhancement grant, essentially that's for, to mitigate other projects that have been approved and constructed, and essentially the reason the funding was available was because that particular path was listed as a possible mitigation but not a required mitigation. Any further questions on this one? Thank you.
52:27 Let's move on to the community center tennis courts, RIA. Okay. So this is our annual, we're trying to actually combine it into a multi-year cycle. Kind of re, basically fixing the cracks and resurfacing as needed the tennis courts up at the community center park.
52:58 You know, 7,000 is what we've used in the past. Last year the bid came in at 6,000. So it does vary a little bit. And essentially this is, you know, the asphalt that's up there is, I think we figured out it's about 40 years old. So it's on the downhill cycle as far as the shrinkage goes. And so we're getting, you know, maybe two to three inches of shrinkage each year, which is the width of the cracks.
53:27 In order to make it safe and usable, they really need to be filled every year. And I don't know if there's anybody from the tennis room. Questions? Questions? Why are you asking for five years? That was something that I believe we discussed on October 9th, and that was a recommendation we received from the commission to submit something that's of a five-year term instead of coming back year after year. I mean, we're happy to do it either way. It's just something that, as we know with Measure R, if it's not used, it's not used.
53:59 So there's a commitment for maintenance for that court for that five-year period of time. I understand multiple years, but five years, it just seems like, okay, so it gives the perception that there will be no improvements to that facility. You're just going to continue to band-aid it for five years. Yeah, I was getting the same thing as well. Is this the first year it's been asked for for a multiple year? Yes. One of the things we did talk about early on when the tennis club was...
54:37 She's not here today, but was to basically start to look at a replacement plan, basically build two new courts to make it so we have eight, and then a replacement plan over the next several years after that to do one court a year for like four years. And essentially that would be a $200,000 a year commitment. Right, and they put that in an application at one point that we turned down. The question we've never dealt with as a commission yet.
55:02 Is if we're going to completely build brand new tennis courts, which is what we're talking about, and you and I have had the discussion personally, is that the place the tennis courts need to go? Before I want to put out that kind of money there, I want us to do that master planning that needs to be done and make that long-term decision. Because it's going to cost us the same for a court. Because I keep getting courted and I forgot, what's the exact age of those tennis courts?
55:32 They were built prior to incorporation. So we've been incorporated 30 years since 84. And the county built one of them themselves, which is the one that has the heaving problem, which I think we figured out it's a root. There's some pine trees that need to be taken down before we reconstruct these. And the other ones were before that. So they're pretty old. They're over 30 to 40 years old. Because they're over 30. 30 plus.
56:02 Okay. I've been saying 35, but I'd like to narrow it down as best as possible so I sound like I know what I'm talking about. But we think it's about 35? Yes. Okay. And what's the lifespan on a tennis court? 30. Well, you know, usually, yeah, for asphalt, you know, you're going to, normally you get, for the new asphalts in a configuration like this, you'd get maybe 20 years without it's tracking very much. The asphalt, we similar to what we have at the parking right lot, which is, if you go look there, there's really,
56:33 Minimal or no cracks. Okay. So it's much more plastic than the asphalt that was used up there. Okay. And since I'm asking questions, I just want to ask my last question, if that's okay. So this seven gram that is being requested on an annual basis, it's just patch cracks. There's nothing new that's being going in there. Okay. Because I know we've dealt with this year after year and just want to make sure there's nothing new. And it touches up the surface texture.
57:01 Where the cracks are patched. Any painting? Is there any painting that comes into that? Or only if you, do you need to do any repainting after you patch the cracks? Yeah, the polymer goes back down. Similar to what they did this year if you were up there. Yep. Thank you. Were the tennis courts resurfaced like in the last two years or so? Three years ago we resurfaced them all. And that year we used, there was a $7,500
57:29 $8,000 Measure R Grant, and we used about $8,000 of general fund. Do we have usage numbers for the tennis courts? Not directly. We did from a tennis probe, we could get some type of metrics. I did receive a call from the lady out there that when we put the tennis backboard, basically we requested to move it because it's being used all the time.
58:00 So we're going to need to move that further away from where it is located. But basically she's saying from dawn to dusk, there's somebody on that backboard all the time. So I think that's... Is that a noise complaint? Anecdotally, yeah, it's a noise complaint. Anecdotally, I think there's some pretty good usage numbers there. Thanks for putting that in a positive light there. That's right. So I think directly, Commissioner Stehlik, no. We do track those numbers when we do have a tennis professional. So that's something we've obviously got to seek, but otherwise, no.
58:30 But I've actually participated in the Sunday social or whatever, and sometimes you can have as many as, you know, looks like 25, 30 people playing on a Sunday morning. So you're still having those Sunday socials even though we don't have a pro out there? That's correct. Is there any, are you going to be looking for a pro to?
58:55 Be out there this next year? Absolutely. We were informed a little too late from Tom's departure previously, so that was our impact. It's a great service for the community, so we really want to make sure we can utilize that a lot. I just have one quick question. Terry covered most of what I wanted to ask, but at what point does filling in the cracks just become untenable? I mean, is this a realistic option for the next five years?
59:29 Really, I think as long as the tennis courts are going to use and we're able to patch them, we can certainly do that. The optimum solution really is to build a new surface, which I think, you know, we did some studies. It looks like a post-tension slab really would be the ultimate long-term solution, which is in that $150,000 to $200,000 range. The $200,000 release for the new court and a little bit less for just...
59:55 for the two courts that don't have a heaving problem, and then the court that has a heaving problem will need to basically excavate that out, pull the roots out, in these sets we think they are, the roots, and take down numerous trees. So $200,000 a court. Yeah. Okay. My only issue with going five years on the $7,000 is that this is a perfect example of what we didn't want to happen to measure R in the first place.
1:00:26 This was a maintenance fund that was in the general budget every year until they told us they could not fund it, and it came to us for a one-year fix, and it has resided at Measure R ever since. It was an emergency item that came in, so once we supplant once, then the issue becomes it stays on the docket. If we could find a way to ensure that these maintenance dollars can go back to where they originally lived.
1:00:54 And as the budget gets reconfigured, it wouldn't be shoveled someplace else because we've hit the easy button, and I would have no problem with this. You know, I've made a commitment to the tennis folks that there's important facilities, and yes, from my standpoint, probably going to keep funding them, but this is the perfect example of why I'm so leery about the pool, because the easy button's been pushed once.
1:01:17 Does that now become the ongoing maintenance responsibility of Measure R? And if we keep going down this road, eventually, is Measure R just the maintenance and operation of what was the traditional park fund, now that I've done my politicking? I think that the pro is hugely important. I, myself, go by the tennis courts several times a year. I was told by the people in charge of the tennis that the reason I'm not seeing anybody is I'm showing up at the wrong times.
1:01:46 But year to year, this year, I saw far fewer people there. And I think it's a direct result of not having the program we've had in the past. Although I don't know that. You know, sports tend to do this a lot. I talked to another gentleman who chases bears around town, who's there all the time, and he concurred that he's seeing far fewer people there. So I don't know if we need to step up our advertising or our whatever. But it would appear, anecdotally anyway, that the youth has fallen off considerably this year.
1:02:16 Over what traditionally happens there. That's just my... Well, there's a strong program at Snow Creek, the athletic facility. So maybe, as Stu mentioned, if there was a tennis pro back at the community courts, probably a trend. Are we just brought away from Snow Creek, or do we create more interest and more... You know, those are things that I haven't seen. But that's all part of master planning. And where do we put the new ones, and how many do we build when we build them? Now our audience on this.
1:02:45 Also the courts are used with the town-wide tournament that's in the spring as well. There's also a group of pickleball players that have been in Mammoth for the last several years that have been dragging me over there several times to see their group. So maybe that's something we need to look at to enhance the usage up there as well because that's becoming a huge sport nationwide. Alana and I have the same comment to make. Well, one of the same comments. My name is Lynn Sparksdale.
1:03:14 We heard you mention about maybe a new location for the tennis courts. I just want to put it in your head about the Whitmore Sports Complex. That might be a great place for it. Also because of weather, it doesn't get as much snow. People could play all year. I know during swim times, kids could swim, adults could play tennis, vice versa. Could be a great place to put it. And then also, Commissioner Sauser, with you just talking about Measure R being
1:03:44 Sort of the easy way out for the town with general funding. I guess, and I'm not sure if this is really the time to say it, but I would hope that you, all of you as the Recreation Commission could go in and really talk to the town. When I look at the budget and I see that the recreation budget is the smallest budget that we have in our town.
1:04:08 Something like that needs to change. And this is a town based on recreation. And so I guess I would ask of you to go in and say with a very loud, strong voice, you know, we can't keep pushing recreation aside. It has to take a bigger part in our town budget, in the general fund, in the importance of the town council members as well.
1:04:33 And I've been sort of thinking this for the last few weeks going to meetings and you kind of said it right there, something has to change. So I don't know how you guys do that, what your interaction with the council is, if it's outside of meetings or just during meetings, but I would love to hear some pretty strong language with them in support of recreation.
1:05:00 And we actually have done that many times in the past. I have verbally been told by the council that we shouldn't worry. They understand that recreation is the engine that pushes onto the bus along, but still we can hit the profits three times as often as we can do. Money where their mouth is, I guess. Thank you very much for saying that. It might not hurt if it's heard from many different sources, too, such as yourself and other people in the community. Certainly. And that, I guess, is another good question. What is our best way as community members?
1:05:29 Do we write letters? Do we stand at council meetings? You know, I work on this all the time. From my standpoint, the best thing you can do is call your councilman, have lunch with them, meet with them face to face.
1:05:42 A letter is easy to look at and read and push aside even when you read it into the public record. Nothing is as strong as you going one-on-one with each one of those individuals with your concerns. Okay, excellent. I like that. That's just my opinion. It may differ among my peers here. Taking a little more of your time. Anyhow.
1:06:01 Thank you. By the way, I've heard those comments expressed to me directly by counselors in one-on-one meetings like that, that really we can find it. There's other places besides Measure R. So thank you for saying that. Yeah, it's to be found. Okay, let's move on to the Multi-Use Facility Enhancement version. Looks like we have Peter again. Commissioners.
1:06:28 This application's got three parts. Multi-use facility, as you know, has become quite popular in skating, and this summer we had roller skating and some roller hockey, but probably can be promoted more as well. The first part is adding, basically relocating the existing trailer the town owns from the airport area.
1:06:57 and located on site as a dressing and storage room. Basically, that would, there's two locations that we have to work out, which is the best with the school district, but essentially it would be having a contractor move the trailer, we'd permanently anchor it and construct a ramp so that it's accessible and run electricity to it. It would not have any other
1:07:26 Utilities other than Electricity. And that portion is $12,000. That would be constructed next summer. The other, the second portion is the hockey barrier fence. And this component consists of a chain leak fence that would replace the netting currently around the perimeter of the rake on the ends only. The hockey group is one that really requested this change.
1:07:57 When they use the facility with the netting, actually they get caught occasionally within the netting or the puck sometimes gets caught. Occasionally a puck might go through, although that's pretty, I don't know that we've seen that many, but it does happen. And so that essentially would be replaced with a chain link fence, black in color, and which would match the chain link fence around the perimeter.
1:08:26 And that request is for $23,000. The third one is to continue working with the shade structure. In January we should have a presentation with the architect to the commission outlining a couple of alternatives for the structure itself and then discussing how much shade and where the shade needs to end around the perimeter of the facility. The current estimate,
1:08:57 Essentially, this would be putting together the bid documents so that it would be ready to go to bid once there's construction funds. And the current estimate that I put together without the architect's input very much was a little over $250,000. And so this request is for $25,000, which is about 10% of the construction cost for the facility. And this would be a netting type facility, not a hard cap, one that was retractable.
1:09:27 During the daytime, it could be retracted so that it's shaded. The ice should be in much better shape by having shaded ice. A day like today, you know, it would be nice to make ice tonight, but if it's going to be sunny tomorrow, we really have to wait until there's a little bit of cloud cover. The $25,000 you're asking, though, for that would be the engineering? That would be, yes, the architect fees and the structural analysis so we can get a building permit.
1:09:59 Go to bed for the project. Okay. Any questions? So that's the design plans. Okay. Could you prioritize these? I mean, what is the most important? I think in that order. So the moving the trailer and then the hockey barrier fencing and then the shade structure or the way you have it listed in the document? I think that really the dressing storage trailer currently, you know, we did buy roller skates this summer.
1:10:33 And we have the ice skates, and so we really don't have a good place to store the extra skates from season to season. So we really need the storage first. And then I would say the shade structure and then the barrier fence. And that trailer that we talked about on our little field trip, the goal there too is to kind of create that little changing room, locker space, something that's a little bit more accommodating.
1:11:02 Than changing out in the weather. So I think that's a great enhancement to that facility. The trailer itself is partitions. It was a construction trailer is what it was. And it's partitioned in the middle. It's about half and half. So it's easily accommodating into a storage unit and a dressing room. Thank you. Terry? Okay, so we're not even going to get a presentation from the architect until January.
1:11:31 And our spring awards come up in March. And if this was to go to March, would that give us enough time to get everything put together that we could actually have construction and everything done prior to the following morning? I think so. I can talk to him and put together a schedule and give you that on Thursday. And as far as the fencing goes, if we were able to...
1:12:02 You know, I understand that that's something that somebody would like. I guess, is it a like or is it a need? You know, is it, you know, where does that fall? And with it being number three, I guess it's kind of more of a like, and so... Dennis may have a different order. Talking to the hockey guys, they despise the netting we have there. Our glass being outdoors and the high winds that we have, it's safe.
1:12:33 They want the net. They want the chain link. And we've got quite a few numbers and we've got quite a few in Bishop that, you know, kick this league off and get some more people out there. That's my goal is to get more users out there, get that program. Would these folks be willing to get themselves together and come up with some type of matching funds to put up a fence if that's what they really would like? Possibly. I was trying to get some of them here tonight and Jeff was back east.
1:13:03 I think he might be here tomorrow. He'll be back Thursday. I can get him to show up Thursday and see if he can rally the troops. It's a lot of safety issue too as well. The guys were getting hit and basically collapsing over the boards. So from a public safety point of view, it's big. The other thing too, just talk on programming. We're going to commit to...
1:13:26 League night every Monday night as well and that will run through the entire season. So traditionally we've stopped hockey in the winter time but we really want to kind of create a draw, some animation at the rink. So hockey night is every Monday night and we're also having the Wednesday and the Tuesday nights as well. So there's more hockey on the schedule than we've done before. So something that we're committing to and we've met with them numerous times. So far we've met with them three times. They're very, very eager to get involved and provide us more help.
1:13:56 Either that's financially, I'm not too sure, it's difficult, everyone struggles, but I know from a volunteer point of view, they've always committed to. Anyway, but I think from a point of view, from public safety, I think is key, and then certainly from a programming point of view, it's something that we're very supportive of. Just trying to figure out where we're at, because we have a whole lot more money that's being asked for than we have here, so.
1:14:21 No, I was just going to add, it sounds to me like maybe the fencing is not necessarily number three if it's a public safety issue. Have for now. Boy, I've got an employee who's a big-time hockey fan who's said how important the fence is, so I get it on that from public safety as well as just enjoyment type perspective, but I think that's a great part of maybe asking if they can contribute, you know, rally.
1:14:51 To, you know, help in some way. Absolutely. Whether it's, because he happens to be a contractor, so it might work out. I just want to confirm, though, that in all of these cases, the storage trailer, the hockey barrier fence wouldn't be able to be installed until next summer, so they won't even be able to use it this winter, correct? Correct. No way it could be sped up? Just can't move that fast. Well, by the time the measure, our
1:15:20 It's awarded by Council, which is December 19th. Yeah, okay. This hockey season is over, what, February, right? End of February. End of February? Okay. And just one last question. The trailer and the hockey fence, there's not much, well, actually, I'll ask you, is there much maintenance or is there any measure of dollars that need to be coming out of that? I've kind of read the report here.
1:15:49 Doesn't really say much for those two. That's pretty much got a lifespan of 20 years, I think I read in there, and can't imagine there's much that needs to happen. The fence really shouldn't have any, I mean, it's going to have kind of the normal maintenance as dentist does every single day. You know, make the ties, but that's really not measure or dollars. The trailer itself, you know, essentially we're going to paint it and it really shouldn't require.
1:16:17 Any new maintenance? It'll need painted once in a while, but so does the existing trailer, so it'll be painted at the same time as the other facilities out there. No specific majeure dollars for those two. For the shade cover, same thing, it'll have a long-term life, but in the end, if we don't have a hardcover, we need to replace the netting in 15 years or something. This may be way, way out there, but I was just curious.
1:16:47 What happens to the shade structure from the Whitmore pool in the winter? It just goes into storage, right? Right. Is there any way we could use it to shade part of the ice to save ourselves a little bit on utility costs in the winter? I mean, it's probably come up before, but it's not as worth it. It's really a lot smaller. So this one is going to be the full width of the ice. It's 120 feet by 210 feet long. And the Whitmore facility is 30 by 40?
1:17:17 Somewhere. So you'd actually have posts that are in the middle of the ice, which wouldn't. That obviously wouldn't work. I was just curious, since we talked before about maybe doing something in, you know, in three phases. Yeah, so that would be all the way across, though, so if we did a third of it. That wouldn't work. Yeah, that would just, that would be a 120 foot width, and then we just wouldn't make this long. Whatever we're talking about for the ice rink, it needs to be retractable. Yeah, and this is just, this 25 grand is just the, it's to.
1:17:44 To do the bid specs. Bid specs. So it's not even really to get it in the drawings so that we can hire a contractor to. It's a good idea. Maybe we should do the bid specs for both and move them up and down. I like that idea, though. So a couple of questions. The shape structure that he's drawing up for us, did he go and look at other areas? I know we saw one on our peer resort tour, and I can't bring the resort up at the moment that I thought was just.
1:18:15 Perfect for us because it was a series of panels that swung open so when it was snowing it didn't get destroyed and shut to provide shade and protection. Have we looked at that? Because the engineering on that already had to be done. Is that something that we can bring in here? He is looking at other examples and that discussion was what we'll have at the January meeting. But there's a couple of different alternatives. One is that basically
1:18:45 Turned in vertical. The other type really is just to keep them permanently vertical and kind of the modeling helps look at that where you've got a certain height of your shade and with the sun angle that gives you the shade on the facility and those could stay out. The other is really a retractable type that goes into a little box on the side of the rink and has a mechanical device. It seems to me that some of you, I have seen other rinks with similar structures.
1:19:13 And if we can avoid reinventing the wheel, it seems to me that some of these things, expenses could be saved. We don't need to re-engineer it if it's already been done. So as Teri said earlier, I have a little concern about funding something where we haven't even heard any of the recommendations from the architect and what the research has shown us. On the hockey fence, the steel versus the steel,
1:19:44 Because I've used steel fence as sort of hazard as well. If it's standard chain link and a kid's out there and his hand goes through that chain link, it's not nearly as forgiving as the netting. For this season and maybe for another season or two, I know one of the complaints was that the puck is hitting the netting and dropping down actually behind the boards. Can we remount that netting in a way so that it's flush with the face mounted on the top rather than behind so that if it hits the netting it comes down?
1:20:11 In the field of play instead of behind it, I understand, because $23,000 for a chain of defense to go around two ends of an ice rink. Pretty expensive. So can that be done, and can we find a way to make it more taut so that things don't go through it or off of it? It acts as a pitch back. Right. No. That's what they don't like. The puck hits it, and it actually flings back. They don't lose it.
1:20:42 It's mounted on the outside. You can't mount it on the inside of the ring because then you have screws and brackets and hangers. So we mount it on the outside of the board. But the tighter we make it, the springier it gets. So it's actually flinging the puck. Right. It's more natural with the chain link is what the guys have done. The size of the chain link then, is that standard? Standard size.
1:21:12 Yeah. So do we not run a risk of little kids' hands going through that and getting stuck in it? Well, it's a four-foot board and a chain link would be above the four-foot board. I'm sort of a little kid and I had to hang on to the board when I went around. It'll be on the outside. I'm assuming there's others that have the same issue. And we're looking at a rubber-coated, vinyl-coated chain link. Okay. So my other question on that one was for Thursday.
1:21:39 Could I again see, and I know I've got it in my paper somewhere, but finding it would be tough, the hockey numbers going over the last several years, what it looked like when it was at the RV park and what it looks like now, are we increasing, decreasing? Okay. It's increasing, what gets you those numbers? Yeah. Any other questions on that application?
1:22:01 I just wondered, you know, Sean actually asked that question, is none of this would be able to affect this winter season. The trailer wouldn't even be able to be moved so that it could be here for this winter season? You know, maybe I'll remove it. I don't know that we certainly wouldn't get it painted and probably not the power hooked up, but it could be puzzled when we get it moved. We'd have to get and then get the screw jacks to hold it down from the wind. But without power, it's not really functional on that in storage, correct? Well,
1:22:30 In the daytime, it's got windows, it's not, we have storage needs. Well, I understand that, so I guess I'm looking at this whole thing, it was a little disappointing to hear Sean, so none of this could happen. So that one is a possible, yeah. Yeah, so that could at least help in the short term when we funded it. Certainly in the summer, too, when we switch over from ice rink back to hockey again, the summer. Yeah. Could the skates be, or the roller skates be stored currently?
1:23:00 In the trailer? The trailer. So the current location, there's really no supervision of it. I don't think we'd want to store anything in the shelf right now. They're in a shop. But the trailer itself isn't. It's at the airport pit. And so we don't go out there on a daily basis if there's some vandalism or theft. They're safe to keep them in the yard. Since we just had a member need a break,
1:23:38 Shall we take a five-minute break to get some water until she returns, or do you want to keep going with that? No, let's bring it more like two, two minutes, three minutes? I'm just saying. We'll take a two-minute break.
1:24:07 Thank you.
1:24:36 Thank you.
1:25:04 I know. I'm going to drink it too much.
1:25:31 Thank you.
1:26:00 Thank you.
1:26:12 Well, I've already scored, and I'll go back and review my scoring from what I've learned today, and then we'll have any other questions that we asked answered on Thursday.
1:26:42 I don't know. We'll talk about it, I guess, later. Okay. Okay. I will call this meeting back to order. Man, I hate this thing sticking here. That's why I keep pushing it away. If it would lay down down here, it would be much better.
1:27:12 So we will move on to the special event enhancement. My name is Alana Levin and I recognize this application on behalf of Mammoth Trails and we're a group of recreational groups.
1:27:43 Organized Recreation Groups, the High Sierra Striders, the High Sierra Triathlon Club, the Velo Club, Mammoth Nordic, Eastern Sierra Nordic Ski Association, the Eastside Velo, these groups like that? I'm kidding, I'm giving you our time, they're at the end, but Mammoth Track Clubs.
1:28:03 Oh, sorry, Nammoth Track Club. I keep calling you my serious riders. Nammoth Track Club. And the application is for barricades that we have been using for special events for most of these clubs. And the reason to apply for more of them is twofold, possibly threefold. The first reason is we could use more of them for certain events. And I'm speaking in that we have the triathlon.
1:28:33 But I did come forward thinking that that was a good reason to apply for more, just because we needed more. And I've tried to find other resources. I've been able to use some from the mountain, but it's usually scrambling enough barricades, and we usually don't get enough for that event in particular. But last year we had three events on the weekend following 4th of July.
1:29:01 or close to the weekend, which was Freedom Mile, the June Lake Triathlon, and then the Jazz Jubilee was the following weekend, but we had to get those barricades, the special event signs, a lot of these materials to all of those sites, so we were scrambling to go from one site to the next. And this year coming up, in many of the years, events are going to be on the same weekend, so it would require events to use all of those barricades.
1:29:29 And so I think it's potentially making it a... In other words, some events aren't going to be able to have the barricades. So I noticed last year I brought them to the Jazz Jubilee site, and this year we're on the same weekend. We're usually on the same weekend. I try to bring it to Fourth of July weekend as much as the town or the community will allow, including the Forest Service and that sort of thing. So I'm using the triathlon, the Jazz Jubilee, and the Freedom Mile as an example, but certainly what I...
1:29:59 What I'm seeing, and I think is a great thing, is that we have more special events coming to the area, and so the need for more barricades is there because we're using them simultaneously. Some people are using them for crowd control or for course marking, and that was the third full reason that I didn't realize until we put the application together was that the fire commissioner, Tom Heller,
1:30:25 Requires that we have a certain kind of barricade for crowd control. The triathlon, for example, doesn't use the barricades as much for crowd control. There can be an element of that. It's generally for a course, whereas the jazz jubile amount. So when we put the application together, we compared the different vendors who sold them, the ones we were looking for, and then he did, which is what we put in here and we priced out was the kind of barricade.
1:30:53 that is more weighted, that can't take over as much for cloud control. One last thing I'd like to add, not to throw my application out, but these events happen this summer. But I thought that the fall application is the time used to come in. It is. You've done it right. Any questions? Yeah, so these are different from the barricades that you currently have? They're different.
1:31:21 Very similar in look and the idea of the plastic barricades that link up to one another, but they are, I believe, heavier and lower to the ground. Yeah, and the distance is less, so you can't, you know, Tom was worried about feet going through the barricade, someone falling over and breaking ankles or injuries that way, so he basically, you know, came in and selected something that was for that type of view, so that's...
1:31:50 Okay. I know we awarded some money a couple of years back for barricades. How many did we buy last time? How many do you? I guess my question is going to be, how many did we acquire? Have we lost any? Have we broken any? I can't remember the exact number, but they're probably the most highly used piece, as you know. They are. We've used them. Exactly. So multiple organizers are really seeking those barricades.
1:32:19 I think they serve that purpose really well. Right. All of those mortgages, as far as I know, we still have. None of them have broken. They've been great for us. I mean, we have to transport them. It's difficult to transport in the back of the truck, but I think it's... I think there were 50, as far as the number. I think that's the amount. I didn't remember that. Okay, so you... ...based this amount basically on how many feet this would, these units would put in its...
1:32:49 It's actually not for me enough, even the two combined, but for that particular event, but I also felt like, hey, you know, we'll try to put in a reasonable application. No, and I'm, you know, I'm supportive of this because they sure do come in handy for events and as an event organizer. I know that these six groups have priority in using those
1:33:17 These with regard to applications. And as I recall, I think Bluza Palooza, there was something on the Sunday morning after the event. I don't remember specifically. It is the first weekend in August. So that was a Mammoth Track Club event. Okay.
1:33:49 No, and that's why I'm, that's one of the reasons why I'm supportive of it, but I mean, just as far as supporting special events, and I guess what I just wanted to make a comment is thank you very much to the six groups here who have put together this application both several years ago and even now, and your willingness to share them with Jazz Jubilee and Bluesapalooza who are not.
1:34:16 Signatures to this group. I mean, it's just very, I think it is very appreciative. So, that's all I have to say. And I guess I would, you know, for matching the argument that I would put forth, maybe not argument, but is that as special events, I personally put on the special event because I love that sport and it's great seeing people do it.
1:34:45 It's been wonderful, certainly special events to bring that to the community. So I guess we've always seen these types of requests that what we're matching is bringing in over 1,000 room nights to an event, from an event, things like that. So I was just mentioning the matching aspect of the Measure R application. Any other questions? I just have a question. The application is for $15,000, but on the request on our Measure R...
1:35:14 Grid, says it's $16,101. Is that because you guys changed the type of barricade, or why is that number different? I think that was just my error when we got the email, which I just printed here on October 24th at 2.23. I think I'd already processed that application. And the bids were coming in late, right? So we just went through a longer process to try and find the right barricade. So I think at the end of your packet, there is that. If it's not in there, I've got copies of them here.
1:35:43 The quote from Traffic Safety Warehouse that actually has the 56 barricades at $195 each, plus there's a custom logo that we want to put on, so we actually want to identify these with the Measure R logo as well. So that was kind of the cost and the shipping. So that was the $16,100.32. That actually brings something up. Would we be able to possibly look for funding if we're putting logos on these from businesses in town that want to put logos that put their advertising?
1:36:13 on some of these barricades. It's town property. Would it be possible to purchase them with the Measure R logo and then to, once they're purchased, to raise money, you know, have sponsors pay for their logo to be on them permanently and then put that money back into? You know, I would say more, because this still isn't going to be enough as we move into this world of special events.
1:36:43 I would be in favor probably of buying these and then setting up a donation program where if somebody wanted to send along another barricade with their logo on it, they purchased a barricade. And then we increase our barricade numbers through that program. Because 106 barricades sounds like a lot, and when it's in the back of her little truck, it looks like a lot. I saw them moving them once last year, and I was thinking something of O'Keezer. Anyway.
1:37:12 It really is nothing in the scheme of things. If two events run the same weekend, 106 barricades is nothing. I would agree, and I guess I'm listening to this, and when this came forward, it's for sporting events, which is why it's going to all these folks. So maybe it goes back to maybe a Measure R, I mean Measure U special events application as well, since it's going into the special events world, and that's sounding like where...
1:37:40 You know, there's more and more need for some of these. And so I think that we need to look at that as well. But I think your idea is great as far as that goes. Go ahead. Along the lines of logo, I was wondering, do you, how much is it for logo per barricade? It's $195 each plus logo, or sorry, plus a logo cost, plus a shipping cost. And $195 is not taxed. That's correct, yeah. So I would say possibly $250 each, something around there.
1:38:11 It's 267. But that includes the shipping. So I was just wondering, do you have to have a logo on each and every one? Maybe it could be a third of them or something like that to save a little bit of money. But I like the idea of sponsorship, putting logos on.
1:38:32 I could feel the heat. But I guess I would have to say the same thing. I can't see that we would need a logo on each and every single one of them. Especially because they're heavy, right? We just wanted to identify them, I think is what we said. Measure our work is just, you know, what we're trying to do here. Do you know what each of those decals costs? It says $65 for custom, for each barricade.
1:39:01 I think that's what it had here, yeah, 65 times 56 was, yeah, 3640. We could probably check on that, Alana, if you wanted to, but it seems like a lot. And sales tax does go up on January 1st again, too, so half a percent will increase that cost when you get it out there. Let's get it done before then. Okay. Okay, any other questions? Moving along then. Thank you.
1:39:34 Thank you. And you're not going to the Mammoth Track Project. I carry this wherever I go. It looks better in person. I know it was fun. Elaine Smith, High Sarah Strider's Mammoth Track Club, High Sarah Strider, somewhere in there. It was fun taking this out again after not seeing it for a while, maybe a few days, and after having the track and field there.
1:40:11 For real. But yes, it actually looks like that, and as you said, even better. So we were really excited on November 17th on Saturday to celebrate the ribbon cutting. It was a stormy day, but the clouds parted just as we were for the celebration. About a little under 200 folks came to the event.
1:40:37 We had T-shirts out, so I know we gave out 150 T-shirts and still had people asking for some. So I know we had a real big crowd. We had many luminaries speaking to the crowd, including Bill.
1:40:52 We ended the event with an inaugural lap around the track, and that was one of the greatest things ever, to see all those people running around the track and being really excited, so it was really fun. I smiled the whole day, kept smiling all night, and I'm still smiling from the event, so it was a great milestone to celebrate, and we were very appreciative of all the folks who came.
1:41:21 and Brave the Weather, although that's nothing for Mammoth folks, Brave the Weather there. So a great accomplishment for the town after five years of work on that. A little news about, and I think people have heard about, the merging of the High Sierra Striders, so it's a group that's been coming to you for five years, and you've seen most of you have had to endure our presentations over the last five years.
1:41:50 Merging with the Mammoth Track Club. So the Mammoth Track Club is the elite group that was a continuation of the work started by Coach Vigil and Coach Larson up here and bringing the elite athletes to train at altitude, producing countless world championships and two Olympic medals, a world record, on and on and on.
1:42:18 That club and the High Sierra Striders are now one. We've merged and so we're looking to bring running and excellence in running to the full breadth of athlete from the recreational athlete to the elite athlete. Terrence, you may know, left to go to the UK and he'll be the head of the distance running team for the UK.
1:42:47 And so now Andrew Castor will be the coach for the Mammoth Track Club. We'll have Coach Vigil and Coach Larson on the board of advisors, an elite advisory board. And so we'll be continuing with their efforts together with Andrew's. Dina Castor will be the president of the board of that organization. And so we are really excited about what that's going to bring to Mammoth.
1:43:16 We've already had through press at the New York City Marathon and what was supposed to be the New York City Marathon and with our opening had lots of interest in athletes from all over the country talking about moving up here. We're going through a process of recruitment right now to look at what athletes we can bring and start.
1:43:40 Another crop, if you will, looking at the horizon being the Olympics in 2016. So we're really excited about that. I actually have three athletes coming during December to visit us, to visit Mammoth, to take a look around to talk about how we might work with them. We have Terrence looking at bringing the UK distance team here to train in April and May.
1:44:10 As part of the new club, we're working on developing a concierge, if you will. So we'll be their one point to stop and say, we want this kind of running package or these kind of facilities or this. We want to know how to get accommodations, et cetera. So we're going to work to do that with those teams and be the one stop shop that they can come to. We have the Oregon Track Club. Oregon Track Club, two of their runners.
1:44:40 We're here before the Olympics. The two women who represented us in the marathon, or two of the three women who represented us in the marathon in London, Cara Goucher and Shalane Flanagan. Their team, their whole team this time, though, is coming in February, March to train for about six weeks. So already we're seeing a lot of folks.
1:45:06 As they said they would, they said we'd come and visit you and stay here and train here if you had a track. And now that we do have a facility, they're starting to come. So we're really, really excited about that. We also are, just so you know, in a year typically the High Sierra Striders was
1:45:30 Putting on two events traditionally, the mile and the 10K, the charted out 10K. We're moving up to six to seven events next year. So we're adding a relay meet down at the track in April, in May actually. Then we'll continue with our two traditional races. We want to have a race up in the mountain, so ascent to the top. We're adding a
1:45:59 Clinic before the half marathon, so it'll actually be several days of clinics where people can sign up, people who are running the race, the half marathon can sign up for three days prior to that and work with us on the course. We're scheduling a running camp in September, so one of the times during our low season, bring a group of folks up to train with us at Altitude, learn, meet Dina.
1:46:27 Have the experience of running. So a lot of new events for next year, tripling what we've done in the past. So those are a lot of exciting things that are going on. So what we learned, though, from the past five years of getting to this point is that as we went through our fundraising, and we hope because now the facility is here. So finally,
1:46:55 Everyone can see what we've seen for five years. There's excitement generated about it. We want to build on that. And we're hoping that the time frame in which it takes to raise the kinds of funds that we need, and the funds for the second phase is very comparable to the first phase. It's about 2.4 as we estimate right now.
1:47:19 We're hoping that that time frame can be shortened, but maybe not. But we're looking at it as a five-year window. A five-year window to raise the same amount of funds to support the project. The second phase includes the looped parking that you see on there. It includes the lighting, which is a big cost that goes around the field.
1:47:47 One of the other big costs is the building, the new building that's right here next to the existing bathrooms. A picnic pavilion, a DG path that goes around there, and then the terrace seating on the visitor side. That still needs to be done. So that's the second phase.
1:48:16 What we wanted to do with this application is to start the process and look at requesting an amount that was more comparable year to year than we were in the first phase. So in the first phase we had submissions that were large amounts at certain times and what we wanted to try to do this time in order to help with the decision making process is generally bring to the commission an amount that was equivalent time and time again.
1:48:46 That amount is about $250. It'll vary a little bit from time to time depending as to how the project evolved, but we really wanted to keep it within that ballpark moving forward. So that's what we're making the request today. We do have some immediate costs that this would go to. We need to design the building. That was not done as far as the designing of the first phase. What was laid out was a footprint of where
1:49:15 The building would go. A little bit of the concept by the architect was done, but it really needs to be done by an architect, not a landscape architect, but a...
1:49:26 Architect that would do buildings, so we would need to design that facility. That's the remaining portion of the design. We also have the loan that needs to be paid back. That's a upfront cost to, or a cost right now that this amount would go to. And then the rest of the budget would be, as we have done before, we talked about phasing when we could build things if we decided that
1:49:53 For example, the lighting. We wanted to do the lighting before the five years because we had demand for those services. We might say, okay, let's fundraise and put the money towards lighting that we'll do in year two or three. So that still can happen, but right now we'll just look at a window of five years and doing everything and hopefully doing everything in a second phase. So that's our approach with this.
1:50:21 is to come to you periodically with about the same amount. Questions? Pat, let's start with you, Ms. Dunn. So the loan amount is $300,000, is that? $300,000, right. That's the contribution, part of the contribution from Dave McCoy, part of it, $300,000 was a gift, a donation to the project, and $300,000 was a loan to the project. And that allowed us to build the project now.
1:50:53 Summer? Almost winter? Instead of waiting for another year or two. As Teri mentioned, the requests for funding far exceed the amount of money that we have. Absolutely. So could some of this be, I mean, you're talking about phase two, but can some of it be phased? It can all be phased. I mean, yeah, it can all be phased.
1:51:25 The two costs that I mentioned are things that we would do immediately. And in order to build for the second phase, we have to go through the design that comes first for the building. I guess if you were to say, you know, we could pick something else and do that first before we did the design, but that does have to be part of the second phase. And then how many members are in your...
1:51:56 organization. The organization that belonged to the running club? Yes. The combined grouping, I guess. It fluctuates between, say, 75 and 100 right now. We actually have opened that up to the general public beyond our borders here in Mammoth.
1:52:17 And we do have folks from other areas joining the club. We've added things to entice them, one of which is a newsletter that we'll produce quarterly that will go out to the membership. We're working on several things that are still in the works right now. This all happened really quickly. We got word of Terrence leaving and just a few.
1:52:41 weeks ago. It's been a whirlwind. So we're working on different things to attract folks from not only in Mammoth, our general membership here, but beyond our borders. So it'll be attractive to join the club. And we do...
1:52:58 Currently have a new website that we're working on where there's applications on the website and we do have folks coming from beyond the area joining the club. They'll get t-shirts, they'll be members of the Mammoth Track Club which features the elites. They'll get information from the coaches and share training tips with the athletes, etc. And anytime they come here we'll take care of them too. Congratulations, it's a beautiful facility and thank you.
1:53:26 Sorry I wasn't able to go there. Yeah, well, I know you had seen it right before you had your tour, and I was trying to get down there for it while you were there, but I'm glad you did get to see it because it is impressive when it's beyond the board. So, thank you. I'll start by saying congratulations because it is a beautiful facility, and I know how much work you guys have put into that and everything else. And then I'm going to go to, I'm a little...
1:53:54 Disappointed to hear that we're looking at the $300,000 loan because we were kind of assured time and time again that that was being worked on on fundraisers and that type of thing and that that money was being paid back in that manner. Well, it still will be. I mean, it is part of the cost for the second phase. It's don't take this as
1:54:17 Saying this is only coming to Measure R. It's not. It's going. We're continuing to fundraise, and we've actually have had a nice donation since Phase 1 isn't quite close, but almost. We're getting close to that. And Phase 2 has started. We continue. We're not looking just to Measure R or Measure U for the funding. We're continuing the way we have in the past.
1:54:46 Where we hope that it's pretty much divided 50-50 as it was for this portion. So, no, don't mistake this for saying it's just on Measure R. That is one of the costs that are now that we would address right away, but that's, we're not looking just to Measure R or Measure U to pay that back. I guess a question to, thank you. A question to you then is,
1:55:13 As a commission, we really need to look at all of our facilities as a whole, and we need to start prioritizing, and we need to look at how we can be putting monies aside to fund all of our facilities. And so I guess this is, I understand that this is going, there's momentum going right here. How would you see that affect you if we put this off for right now and in this next year, had those conversations with the commissions and bringing people in?
1:55:42 from different facilities so that we can master plan each of these facilities and then put that priority list together and then look at all of the different funding opportunities, whether it's a bond, whether it's grants, whether it's just setting money aside and straight out funding it, whether it's sponsorships. I guess if we're taking a large chunk like $250,000 each year out of Measure R, I don't see us being able to get anywhere with any of the rest of this.
1:56:10 I think it needs to be kind of in the grand and the master plan as the rest of phase two of the track. And I think that there may be, you know, like I say, sponsorships or funding opportunities that we need to look at it as a whole as opposed to continually just focusing on one project. We need to see how we can do all of the projects and how we can fund those.
1:56:36 And move forward. I don't know if that makes sense. I don't know if there's a question. Well, I guess I see. If we were to do that, my question is, is if we were to put that off and say, no, we're not doing this right now, or is there a portion that you have to have right now so that we can have that conversation for the whole master plan? So does that make more sense? I think I understand that there are lots of priorities.
1:57:05 Master Plan and where the Mammoth Track Project fits in that Master Plan is a conversation we need to have. And that can be, of course, we're going to decide whether to spend money here or other places. Of course, we want to make a commitment to the second phase. The idea that we've brought forward is to
1:57:34 Is to, in a way, commit funds more timely so that we're not asking for $2 million in five years. We're asking for a little bit over time. I think we as an organization from the very beginning have been supportive of bonding the Measure R and Measure U funds so that we could have a larger pool where you can dedicate a certain amount.
1:58:01 towards the track and then a certain amount to other projects that could also be done. So we would be supportive of that discussion. So yeah, I know that there's lots of priorities. We're going to be pushing for this one. We can, if we need to say what, you know, what we need to do right now is to plan the design of the building.
1:58:28 That's one of the first priorities, and the second priority is to secure funds to pay back the loans. So those are the two top goals that we have right now with respect to this project. And so if you were asking for just those monies to move forward right now, what would you be asking for? I would be asking for the – I see them as part of the bigger plan, so it would be –
1:59:00 We think that the planning, the design could be $50,000 to $60,000 for the building. The loan you know is $300,000. So I'm not asking for that full amount there. We're not asking for that full amount there. But those are the two immediate costs that we would have with the project. And we can talk about if there are certain things that
1:59:32 We would want to have in place at this facility versus others. And my example, you know, arbitrarily taking the lighting or we could talk about how that might be phased in. And that could be a subject, that could be how we present it for the next time. So it would be good to have guidance with respect to how you want to hear about this. And maybe that's what the discussion today will lead us to.
2:00:04 Well, congratulations. It is a stunning facility, and I've just been encouraging people to go and look at it because it really has to be seen in person. It was just phenomenal. But to follow up on what Teri said, I appreciate what you're trying to do by, you know, asking for the $250,000, you know, for consistently over five years. Unfortunately, it's just not great timing with all the other existing priorities, and I think that
2:00:32 What you've outlined a little bit for us this afternoon, and I just, I'm a little cautious in that it's not outlined well in the application is, what I hear you saying is that you're looking for the $250,000 from us, and that the two priorities for this year, this immediate need would be the $50,000 to $60,000 for design work for the building, and looking towards paying back.
2:01:00 A portion of the $300,000 loan. And I just want to make sure that because you've asked us for the biggest amount out of all of our requests and given us sort of the least detail in the application about where the money would need to go. So are those the only two things that the $250,000 would go toward? Well, the costs of the project are detailed in the project conception plan.
2:01:25 And that's pretty much how it breaks down among the different elements of the second phase. And the design costs do probably, I have to see whether that's identified in there separately. But the design costs are part of the cost for the lump sum of the building, I think. Yeah. Okay, so it's in that amount.
2:01:55 And again, this approach, and so this is as much detail as we had previously in the first phase of how we presented our budget. And this was taking a little different tact in terms of trying to look long term and just trying to divide it up over those five years and having the amounts accrued go to
2:02:21 An amount at the end of that time period that would be sufficient to help to pay for the project. So that's the approach. And the detail has been presented this way in the past. But the design, I think, I can pull that out. And that wasn't specified. But of that amount for the building, that's about what the design would be, 50 to 60. Thank you. Sean?
2:02:52 No, no other questions that haven't been asked, but I will jump on the bandwagon and say congratulations. Beautiful track. Thank you. I'll re-give my entire speech. Wow. I'd like to hear that. It is a great facility. However, the difference between what you've done here and moving along with Phase 2 is this could not be structured any other way than what you did. It had to all be done at once. But when I look at Phase 2, there are several things here.
2:03:22 that I would love to see prioritized. There are things that jump out at me. You've got a great fitness facility down there now. We could dress it up, which doesn't make it any more usable, which is about what the building does. But there are other things. A fitness loop station, I can see that as being a huge bonus for what is already there. Not a lot of money for Big Bang.
2:03:49 The covered picnic pavilion, I've spent a lot of afternoons down at Whitmore through my years in town and it can be pretty impressive if you're just sitting there without the shade structure. So I would actually love to see an approach more like that from my standpoint in terms of prioritizing where we get the biggest bang. So far I don't see the building as being a big bang.
2:04:15 You know, that's one of those things you can get around, the change rooms and the showers and the rest of that. Maybe that can be part of the pool facility and maybe we can even work out, people can pay to go over and shower and change at the pool. It's across the street and they're athletes, they probably can make that without, you know, a big job. So I would love to see us look at it from that standpoint. The other thing that I do caution of is that the $300,000 loan is something that I viewed that
2:04:44 The High Sierra Striders would be taking care of and raising funds for and definitely not to be repaid out of a Measure R fund. So maybe we're seeing that different and you can speak to that differently than you did with Terry because I'm seeing that as the fundraising obligations of the group going forward as their part of the original construction because that's Phase 1, it's not Phase 2. And I'm not seeing that as part of the Phase 2 expense that Measure R would help pay for.
2:05:10 Well, I think, again, and I may be repeating what I told Teri, so I apologize if it's just repetitive. The $300,000 loan is absent of the interest. The high share striders is taking on interest charges for that. It's not included anywhere in here. We're going to take that on ourselves. The $300,000 went to build
2:05:37 The facility. So the $300,000 went into money is in this field, is in the track, wherever you want to put it. That went to cover the cost of the construction. So it's merely a timing issue. It allowed us to build now versus later. And to gain the
2:06:04 I think we've seen and really in the responses that we've gotten, you know, Runner's World, I've neglected to mention, Runner's World came up for the opening and they put it on their newswire. So this is getting a lot of attention that even more than perhaps we anticipated. So this is doing a lot of good now. So we need to take advantage of that. And we wanted to do it.
2:06:31 sooner rather than later because it will help our fundraising in the future. But those, the $300,000, so to me when I look at it, it's a timing issue. It allowed us to do it now. It went to the cost. It didn't go to anything but building this facility. And it's still, it's a cost of the, of the, of phase one that is unpaid and is now part of the cost of phase two. So, you're right. We couldn't,
2:07:00 We didn't want to do this so that a quarter of the field was left out, if you will, or a quarter of the track wasn't completed. We trimmed this thing down to the barest bones in order to get the most bang for your buck in terms of having the track, seeing that track and seeing that grass down there completed so people could start using it. It was really, it's been interesting to see how
2:07:30 Difficult it's been for people to really envision it. And once they see it, then I know what it meant to me after seeing it on this board and then seeing it there. It is wow. And that's what we wanted to do. And that's why we wanted to go ahead with the loan, not wait longer. We wanted to go ahead, build this facility, and then gain the benefits from that. Okay, thank you. Any other questions before we move on? Go ahead.
2:08:01 Just one more question. I know this is further down the line, but you mentioned $290,000 for fundraising. That's if we need it. So that's to have people that it would include some staff work to make sure the project goes forward. It would also...
2:08:26 We kept the fundraising that we'd done to a minimal shoestring budget, and we anticipate perhaps needing to spend a little more to get a little more. But again, that's an amount that if we don't have to spend it, we won't. But it is there as, and it's based on a project of this size, this is a typical amount that you would spend.
2:08:56 Recommendations from fundraising organizations or work by fundraisers. It's a percentage of the project, and that goes to that. But I think this is a joint venture between a town and your club, right? So wouldn't the town, or is town staff covered in that? Town staff could be covered in that. They managed the project. There were staff hours that were paid to manage the construction.
2:09:25 Initially, the town did donate many hours of work, and then that changed, and throughout, and I don't know at the point, but throughout the management of the project construction, those hours were paid for out of the funds raised for the project. So it would be included, that type of service would be included in that amount. So one last question, is there a way to kind of
2:09:54 I know that this is still conceptual, but is there a percentage of that money that goes to fundraising versus project management? We could work on that. I don't have it. I have it more. I guess what I'm wondering is fundraising a fraction of it or is it a majority? No, it's a fraction of it. Thank you. I guess I have a question and I can clarify because
2:10:22 Bill was, you know, making some priorities, and it would be wonderful if you guys made those priorities and brought those back to us, because I guess I would see that the building with the locker rooms and if there's going to be a weight room in there, that that would actually be something that would make the facility much more usable and could attract more folks there. Is that? That could be one of the reasons I would say.
2:10:52 If we do have a lot of teams coming to train down there, that could be a real asset to having that facility. And then with games, there's a concessions area planned for that building. And I know a lot of the...
2:11:08 Football League and Soccer Leagues. They would have an opportunity to sell concessions through that, and I know that generates revenue for them. So those are the kinds of things that may put it as to be higher on the list, although it's a bigger capital expense. One of the things that may move it to the front, but also then make it take a little longer, is that we've had some interest in a sponsor coming
2:11:37 to join our team, and what they were looking at was a facility, and so helping us build a facility. So it's conceivable that having a sponsor in there could maybe elevate it, but maybe it makes it more doable because they're contributing to it. So there's a lot of different factors that would go into prioritization.
2:12:02 You know, some of the things that can be done, as Bill mentioned, can be done relatively simply. Have to check with, you know, Peter to see how easily those could be done. But their lower costs could be done sooner. Those are the kinds of things we could take a look at.
2:12:18 Would you be able to, I know it's really short notice, would you be able to bring that kind of prioritization back to us on Thursday? We can sure try. Yeah, we can try it. I'll do the best we can. And, you know, I know you've dedicated five years of your life to this. You know, thank you because you have given us an incredible project. Thank you. Thank you very much. Okay, next is the equipment.
2:12:46 Equipment, Mammoth Track Project. Okay, so I'm here for Andrew, not quite as tall as he is. Again, Coach, you look different from the last I tried. I lost a few feet of height. We're asking for the steeple barrier. In a steeple chase race, there's actually five barriers, solid barriers, that they go over. We're asking for one for the water pit.
2:13:15 For the other four, we'll use hurdles to signify where they would be and the height that they would be at. That's sufficient for training for this particular event. We have a member of the, as I mentioned, the Oregon Track Club's coming to train here. One of the folks on there who actually went to the Olympics.
2:13:40 is with that team. In order for them to train, we would like to have the one barrier up, and that's one thing we can't use. We have hurdles where we can place on the other four, but we can't place hurdles on the water pit. So a cart is in there, too, a cart to shuttle the hurdles around so we don't damage the track, and then a screen mesh, which I've never done.
2:14:09 Steeplechase, so, but apparently the water can reflect in your eyes and be distracting, if not causing harm to somebody who can't see that. So that's our request for that. This will allow teams to travel as a whole, and one of the problems without having the track is we had those marathoners here before the Olympics, but their whole team couldn't come, and then they couldn't stay a longer time without the rest of their team.
2:14:37 So this will enable the teams to come all together and use our facility. Stu, one housekeeping real quick. The numbers in the plan that I see here are actually $2,348 or $3,000, is that? Yeah, I think what he didn't put down there is there is about a $600 shipping cost, and that's how it got to the $300. So that's not in there, okay. So it is actually $3,000 then? Yeah. Okay.
2:15:09 Questions? Sean, we'll start with you this time. Okay, so it's just one barrier, and the barrier is the pit that you fill with water, is that? Yeah, the barrier goes right in front of the water jump, and then you can see it when you went down there. The rest of the water pit is coming, it's on its way. But yeah, it goes right before that. Okay, so we just have one? We're just having for the one. The other four, we will make do with hurdles we have.
2:15:39 Okay. And if we were to have a competition, we couldn't use the hurdles, but we're not going to have a competition that we know of soon. You know, since you don't have a building, where are you storing this now? There is one container down there that is right near the track, and you probably saw it. It's in between the two terrace seatings, and we have...
2:16:01 I don't know if the right word is a permission, but we have permission to leave those there. We can actually have two. So the equipment, that's an empty one, and that's where the equipment will go. Okay. So this will be kept there? This will be kept there when not in use. What's the lifespan on a... I think almost forever. Okay. Can we hold you to that? I would have an exact number for you. Longer than a hockey chain link fence? Okay. Yes. That's all the questions I have right now.
2:16:31 That covered all my questions as well. I'm good. Being a non-runner. Yes. And a non-steeplechaser. Yeah, now. Now. It's right. After this track is in place, you might become one. Coach Callister can work miracles. Never say never.
2:16:53 Oh, boy. To give you a real good answer, probably we'd have to, there are a number, you know, when Anna Pierce was one of the mammoth track athletes who came up here, she came as a steeplechase runner. So it's not as highly followed as the rest of them, but there are quite a number of steeplechasers. I can't give you, I can't give you without looking it up. I'll have to come back on Thursday with that number. So when it's, would it only be
2:17:21 Filled with water when you're using it, or how does that work? When it's not in use, then? You can drain it. You could drain it, or you could keep it full, but we probably would, I don't know what the best approach is, whether it stays full of water. There's actually a cover that goes over it, so we probably can keep the water, cover it, so people don't fall in there, and then remove it when it's being used.
2:17:50 I don't know exactly whether or not they, you know. Well, the conserved water, you'd want to just fill it once, but I don't know if that's how they actually do it. I believe that they would drain it after each use, because if you don't drain it with the temperatures that are down there and with well water, which does not contain chlorine, you end up spending more money cleaning it, the greens, out of it than you do, that's why all the even impromptu hot tubs in the Eastern Sierras have.
2:18:18 Drains in them so that that water doesn't stay. I'm just assuming this is one more piece of the puzzle to make that project complete, more useful for more people to come up. Yes, especially, I mean, given the team perspective of that's why we didn't, before the track was here, see the Oregon Track Club down here because they couldn't travel as a team. And that's even true for
2:18:42 You know, they're runners of the 800 and the 1500. The long distance folks could get away with not running on the track frequently. They'll go down, you know, they used to go down to San Diego. But teams, you know, other teams coming here, it sort of doesn't work if they can't get all their whole team here and stay, they can't stay for a long time. Anything else? Okay, thank you. Thank you. Thanks, Mike. Moving on to Man of Nordic.
2:19:19 We will give Mammoth Nordic a moment. Stu, on the special event enhancement, where it said $15,000 in the application, but you said actually with other costs that is $16,000? That's correct. $16,101. And it depends when you buy it too, right? So if you can get it before the year. And that revised amount is actually in your fundering application grid, which was...
2:19:59 Hopefully part of the packet that you received. Yeah. Yeah. How many changes were there? Because, you know, unfortunately I did not print up all the applications again. Well, I think you'll get, there'll be another change coming up in a sec. I think you'll see a revised amount being requested. That's the only one that was received. Yeah, because I didn't realize that there was any revisions. I assume that the original application was the application. Brian, you're up.
2:20:30 I didn't look that far. You have a microphone. Testing, yes. Good afternoon, members of the commission. My pleasure to come before you and present our revised request for funding for our fall 2012 Measure R application. Thank you, Brian. The application we submitted several weeks ago for the fall
2:21:58 funding process essentially represented our original request to the Mammoth Lakes Trail System Coordinating Committee. So that number is revised down to reflect two things. One is the fact that through the MLTSCC funding process, we were awarded $20,000, which we're grateful for. And we've also...
2:22:25 Found ways to wring a little bit more efficiency out of what we do. So the document you have in front of you essentially represents the revised request for funding down from the original $66,400 to $34,200. And I can walk you through those changes if you'd like. I don't know if you guys are actually looking at your original R application from us. It had a budget page included. In that budget,
2:22:56 We essentially had two components that we were trying to establish a funding source for. And based on the fact that we did receive the $20,000 reward from MLTSCC, that leaves a balance unfunded of $46,400. We've got some concerns about that process, and it's strictly a process thing. We're not.
2:23:36 We're certain that things will work out to everyone's advantage ultimately, but given the nature of the budget discussions that are continuing to be grinding through the sausage mill in town government, everybody I think would be less than wise to think that fundings that hasn't been billed for at this point will likely be available in the spring of 2013. I think that's a reasonable concern to have.
2:24:06 Another thing that we're still working on with town staff, and again I'm certain we'll be able to find language that's acceptable to all parties, we don't have a signed letter of agreement for the MLTSCC award just yet either, and again I'm working with Stuart and Dave on that and I'm certain we'll be able to arrive at that. But that's essentially the reason we're coming before Measure R and the Recreation Commission is to try to find some way to assure that as we go down the road and
2:24:35 and invest not only our equipment and our dollars and our time into this program, but we have a likelihood of seeing some funding on the other end. So from that $66,400 reward, we'll just take that $20,000 from NLTSC off the top, so we've got $46,400. Essentially that leaves about $16,400 in unfunded program manager hours.
2:25:05 And we've decided as a club we can arrive at an additional 234 volunteer hours, or approximately $8,200 from our club to fund that position. We did not see enough of a disbursement from the MLTSCC award to fund our Nordic Trail Steward Program. Based on that, we have decided to provide an additional 134 volunteer hours.
2:25:32 Or $4,000 to apply towards the Nordic Trail Steward Program. So in essence, starting from the $66,400 minus the $20,000 that I know Perfect World will see dispersed in the spring, that leaves a balance. And then again, I'm sorry, and then subtracting out the additional volunteer hours willing to commit to the program and make it successful.
2:25:58 We're left with a balance of $34,200. So that's our final number for the fall request for this cycle. Any questions? Questions? Let me start with you. So I believe from the Mammoth... MLTSCC. Yeah, right. It's called the CCs. The CCs, okay. I think most of that...
2:26:28 Not to exceed $20,000 was for the actual grooming, is that correct? Well, it was based on a lot of other components to administering and providing the entire program, so that's what that $20,000 is ultimately to be dispersed for. And it would only, it's based upon billable hours, correct? So if for some reason, I hate to say this, but if we don't have a great snow season again.
2:26:59 Then those costs would not be occurred. Is that correct? To a large extent, if that was the case, yeah. But there's, you know, significant administrative time to put together the program in any case, whether we're grooming every morning, which we intend to do at this point, or whether we're not. So, you know, again, those are the things that Bill, I'm sorry, Stuart and Dave and I are working on right now in regard to the letter of agreement. And there is a question.
2:27:27 Between that committee, I believe, is to exactly the sideboards we did or didn't put on that. And I don't believe that committee is in agreement on what those sideboards were. We're having a meeting this Wednesday. I think we had asked to get some answers for that, which was with regard to the not to exceed $20,000, which I don't think you have a problem with. No, that was because you awarded $20,000 to fund the administration of the program.
2:27:57 We don't have any concerns about it. I guess that would be a concern is that it keeps coming up as administration because it was actually for the grooming. I don't know. I'm sorry. I'll ask my questions. That's why Wednesday's meeting becomes important. My memory of that meeting was that we said we would fund at the high rate of $35 an hour, which is a program manager rate, any hours that were spent actually grooming the trail system. My memory can be faulty.
2:28:24 And I was told that it is faulty, and that's not what we did. We awarded a $20,000 award. You were at the original meeting. I remember there was discussion about it, and I think that what was actually decided upon was pretty, not to exceed amount. I don't think you itemized where that money was going to. Okay. That's what I, my recollection. But, so, so the 34th.
2:28:51 1,200 would be kind of spread throughout your entire program. Is that correct? In essence, yes. You know, at some point, the application you have in front of you, you know, was relatively explicit in describing all of the things we do to make certain that the program is a high-caliber program that we're proud to provide on behalf of our community. So those are the things we're trying to work with town staff to make certain that those are addressed in the letter of agreement.
2:29:21 I think it's great that you're adding volunteer hours and time to offset some of the costs. As we've asked some of the other groups, are you able to prioritize some of these things? I mean, if the funding, if the $34,000 was not awarded, are there any priorities that you would establish? The only priorities that we establish as a club is that we'll do the job regardless.
2:29:49 Where the Chips Fall. Because the program isn't of value unless it's delivered at a caliber that we as a club are proud to provide. So I'm really terrible at having cars held close to my vest. So, you know, you can interpret that how you like. I hope you can interpret that meaning that we are sincere and genuine and have worked relatively hard over a relatively long period of time to put forward something that we want to continue to do. So we will do everything we promise to do with that.
2:30:19 Essentially where I think this is going to sit down. You're welcome. You're going to go back to this. This started out as a volunteer program. You guys did an incredible job without snow last year. And there were issues the previous year. So it's been a couple years that the Forest Service has just been grooming.
2:30:45 and doing their thing. I don't think you've done a grooming program for the last two years, am I correct? No, we actually did about three weeks last year, about three and a half, actually. And the year before, we actually did a fair amount of work. Okay. So, quite frankly, the year before, we did 120 days' work. Okay. So, you know, last year was difficult in a lot of cases, mostly so, but, you know, we were prepared to answer the bell, and unfortunately, we didn't get that chance.
2:31:11 So maybe it was last year that there was no funding that went out. Because I know we funded your program in the past. In the fall of 2009. Okay. Thank you. And, you know, you're stepping up this program. This kind of falls in with our commission needing to get priorities put together. Because I guess I'm looking at each of these things coming forward, and we're looking to fund a manager. We're looking to fund...
2:31:39 You know, a steward. We're doing this with the trails. Somewhere we have to pull all of this together because I think there's a lot of money that's going out that should be consolidated because one person could possibly do all of these different things in that coordination. I don't know if that goes to the Mammoth Lakes Recreation discussion. I don't know where it goes, but I just see that these programs, you know, when we started out with something being voluntary.
2:32:06 And now we're paying an administrator, we're paying a steward. With this one, I have a little bit of a concern with a steward. Since it starts at the Visit Welcome Center, you know, to me, there should be some type of ability at the Welcome Center to help those folks with whatever information that it might need for that trail. Or is there a map with some of the signage that we've done that can help them with these things? I don't know.
2:32:35 So I guess I'm looking at, and I truly have a little bit of a hard time with the $20,000 that's going out with you telling me that that could be spent whether there's snow or no snow. You know, there's got to be a program, and I guess that would need to be spelled out to me if that's going to be spent no matter what. What does that program entail that means that that money is going to be spent prior to there ever being any grooming on the snow?
2:33:05 So why does that have to be spent prior to that happening? So, you know, we have the Eastern Sierra Nordic, we have the Mammoth Nordic, we have Mammoth Lakes Trails. We need to bring everybody together somehow and so that we can, you know, have a cohesive program all the way around because I see that we're paying a lot of different folks for managing programs where we need to have a trails, I don't know, maybe whether it's a trails manager or I don't know how we do that.
2:33:35 So anyhow, grooming I see as, you know, if we're doing special events and stuff like that, then that brings in a whole other thing. If we're just doing grooming, then I would like to see us kind of just put that grooming program together. Okay. More questions? Are you looking for an answer for that? I, you know, I don't know. I would like to respond to that. Okay. Because I don't see this request any different than MLTPA.
2:34:04 Well, I guess what I'm saying is I think all of those need to come together. Well, but we've already awarded over a million dollars to MLTPA, and a lot of what they've done has been administered. Okay? So I don't see this being too far different. And it may be a great idea in the future to have a trails coordinator who can do it all, but I, you know, I see this as more of a...
2:34:28 These are more immediate needs, and that's maybe something that we can talk about during our prioritization and park master planning discussions. I think it has to. We can't keep fragmenting like this. Well, but is now the time to do that when we have a winter season that we're here? And so maybe that is something to discuss for the future. Let's get the comments from the other commissioners. I'm just expressing my concern.
2:34:53 Okay, well, first of all, Brian, I want to say I'm very fond of your organization. I think you guys do a really good job. There wasn't a lot of snow last winter, but, you know, one of the days that there was snow, you guys were out there grooming, and you did a nice job. I was down there skiing. I like your utilization of volunteer resources. I think that's all great. I think maybe what Terry's getting at is the way that you wrote the application. First of all,
2:35:22 In our priorities that we set when we did the 2012 Measure Our Fall Award priorities, number three was to provide Nordic grooming of cross-country trails and Mammoth Lakes at the same level or comparable to the 2009-2010 program. I was really surprised not to see that in your application. Maybe I missed it. But I think that what she's getting at is because the way you set up your application was to use these funds toward salaries,
2:35:49 versus programming. I'm just curious about what will these positions that are now paid positions allow us to get now that we weren't getting previously? Well, you'll be getting the same level of service that you got for nothing in 2009 and 2010. So, you know, in essence, you know, I apologize if it wasn't explicitly mentioned in our application that what we were looking to do was duplicate and exceed what we've done in the past.
2:36:18 So in 2009-2010, we had all the ingredients that we needed to have a killer season. We had early snow, we had excellent conditions, we had late snow. So we took advantage of that and we groomed 120 days out of a 365 day year. So that's a reasonable percentage of days to put down Nordic trails in the town of Mammoth Lakes for free for the public. So in essence, every time we've come before the community,
2:36:46 The committee or the commission or the council to describe our program, we've described it as a high caliber program that takes a lot of resources. And the resources are the close to $85,000 or $90,000 in equipment that we've invested in through contributions both locally and out of town visitors, business community, that sort of stuff.
2:37:07 All of the expenses associated with running the program, like our insurance costs, which are egregious and getting more egregious by the day, based on the programs that we're adding, which you're aware of, the snow school program we're going to be adding at the school district this year, came at an expense to the club, but it was one that we were willing to meet. And none of the funding that we're asking for today from Measure R has anything whatsoever to do with the projects that we're rolling out for the school district. So please don't misconstrue the fact that...
2:37:37 While we have other things we're doing in the community, we're coming to the town to fund those things. We're not doing that. So the quality of the programming is based on the amount of resources you apply to it, and those are manpower and equipment. So the application does in fact reflect that there is a manpower commitment that we would like to see some offset in being funded. And as Pat mentioned, it's really remarkably similar to a lot of the applications you've already funded.
2:38:05 Be they Friends of the MEOs, Summer Stewardship Program, the bulk of MLTPAs work over the years, and, you know, we're just asking for some consideration to be viewed as a comparable applicant for funding. Thanks. And just out of curiosity, so you guys are all set up with your insurance for the school program? Button up, ready to go? Super. Yeah, just...
2:38:29 Actually, I didn't have any questions for you, only a comment, but I do have a question for you. Do you have any idea how many people are using your trails? I know it's tough to guesstimate, especially with the slow snow year last year, but is there any way you can estimate? You know, I'd be happy to quantify that for you after this year because I'm going to be there every day, all day. There's really no accurate way to register how many people cross over a trail system.
2:38:58 Underground snow counters, clickers. But, you know, I would cheerfully tell you a hell of a lot of people enjoyed our program in 2009 and 2010, and hopefully a hell of a lot and then some will enjoy it this year. And I'll give you a firm under in the spring of 2013. Well, and I think that that's actually a good segue, thank you, into just my comment, which is, you know, you guys do a great job. Thank you very much for the work that you do. You know, I obviously was part of the MLTSCC recommendation that gave you guys 20 grand.
2:39:28 And frankly, I think that that was appropriate this year. I'm not to say that for future years, you know, maybe it comes strictly from Measure R, but certainly this year, in my understanding of the work that you guys do, I think it was appropriate that that money came from the MLTSCC annual budget of $300,000. Obviously, you know, we're looking at a request here of you of $34,000, and thank you for decreasing that amount.
2:39:58 But, you know, of over $600,000 total for an award of $330,000, and, you know, we're having to decide, is it going to be the swimming pool or is it going to be Mammoth Nordic? And I hate to be so blunt like that. That's the chair you guys regrettably assigned yourselves for this, not only this year, but many years. I know your job was a tough one.
2:40:22 Well, and, you know, ours isn't as tough as the council because we only make the recommendations. So they're the ones that really get beat up, sort of, usually, not always. But in any case, I just want to say that, you know, thank you very much for the work that you guys are doing and are committed to doing this coming winter. And, you know, it's just a tough year, this year. Okay, that's all I have to say. I sure hope I don't feel it in my bones.
2:40:51 You need to get new bones, Bill. Well, I do need to get new bones. You're right. One of the problems, and I've talked with John at MLTPA about this as well, is both of you want to bring in the top tier program. I understand that. I appreciate that. When I worked on trails here, that's the program I wanted to bring in as well. The problem is the town of Mammoth Lakes can't even afford a Hyundai program, let alone a Cadillac. So at some point we have to look at
2:41:19 Perhaps lowering our expectations to the point of affordability just right up front. I appreciate that that's what we all want to do. You know, I would love a huge 50-meter pool down at Whitmore and another covered one here in town. Is that a reality? It's not going to happen. So that's just off the top. There is a difference in the MLTPA previous grants.
2:41:49 And in this one, in that we were billed hourly for what was supposed to be specifically called out in a contract. Perhaps those contracts were not written to the point where the end result was named enough. The deliverables were not called out as they should have been. I can't blame MLTPA for that, but frankly they had a billable rate.
2:42:16 And they only billed us for hours that they worked on that project for the town. So I do see them as different. We covered their billable rate. We didn't cover their manager. Did his fee come out of that? Maybe. I don't know. But I see that as a difference. And what they brought to the table was huge in the first place. Without them, there is no R. There is no U. So I see them as being two different kinds of programs. You can't pay back somebody.
2:42:45 No, I understand that. And because of the public's concerns, we have already, a year ago, altered the way in which that whole system works and how those contracts are awarded, and that's what the MLTSCC was put together for. My questions on this one are, one, I don't see that we can afford a $66,000 program.
2:43:14 I thought the $20,000 award was a reasonable amount. The questions that I had left in my mind were, we had talked at that meeting, and the minutes of that meeting are nowhere clear enough, for me at any rate, about whether if money was awarded for this from Measure R, whether that money would then pay back the money that MLTSCC had awarded.
2:43:44 And while I can't go and talk to the other MLTSCC because of Brown Act violations, I still think that that needs to be worked out there as well. So I have several questions, which I'm hoping we have some answers for by Thursday. And that's it. Other than that, you've done a great job. A non-profit group that has provided a good product, which is why we added it as a priority for this year. Any other questions for Brian or comments? Well, I guess I have one.
2:44:14 A couple of questions. So anyways, and I would like to say, I'm sorry, you have provided an incredible program over the years. But I guess what I would like to see, and I'm sure that's going to be within the contract that's coming forward for the $20,000 and then for any of this that would come forward because Measure R has never been paid out just in a lump sum.
2:44:38 You know, without something being billed back, that this is what was done, this is the hours that were spent, and this is what was provided. So I have a concern that there's a possibility that that might happen. I'm not certain why you would assume that, because nothing in our application asks you to hand us a big pile of money. We're going to do the same thing that every other applicant's always done, which is bill for the time we spend providing the services we've been asked to provide. Okay, I guess I didn't hear that earlier. I heard that you were receiving the money.
2:45:05 And, you know, whether the services were provided because there are a lot of administrative costs. I guess I would love to see it broken down a little bit more as to what exactly, you know, would be provided because I guess I'm still looking at a lot of the steward programs.
2:45:23 things that you're saying here is the same thing that a manager would be doing and why that steward is... I'm sorry, I missed what you just said there because I'm not certain... I guess I'm reading your job description here and I'm seeing a lot of the things that the steward could do and it's the same thing that your manager position is doing or could do and so I guess I would like to see why there would need to be both positions. I would just ask you to give some consideration of the fact that sometimes when you add
2:45:52 A resource like skilled and passionate people to solving problems like making a program better over time, it's better to have somebody that you can count on to delegate some of those things to when your plate is being consumed by a lot of the operational things that usually happen with providing a groomed trail system like fixing broken things, buying stuff to fix broken things, using those things you just bought to go fix broken things that won't get fixed even though you just bought new things to fix it.
2:46:21 Those are just, that's a semi-sarcastic way of saying there's a lot of things going on, a lot of moving parts, and I apologize if that came off a little snide. But, you know, we're just looking to try to find enough people that have a sincere interest in doing a great job to put together a great program. And to Bill's comment earlier about, you know, the town not being able to afford a Cadillac program, well, unfortunately, that's the seat you sit in, being in...
2:46:48 Dealing with the constraints of the funding that the pound has to distribute for all of the folks out here and the public are trying to put together, I'm not going to say Cadillac program. I don't drive a Cadillac. But it's going to be a kick-ass program if we're involved in it in any way. So, you know, I understand you've got a lot of difficulty and a lot of hard decisions to make, but, you know, you're going to be faced with this with shocking regularity. People are going to bring forward big ideas to you guys.
2:47:15 And, you know, it's your job to digest those and determine which ones are deemed a priority. And that's, quite frankly, all we're doing here today is asking you to consider us as a priority. And if it doesn't work out, you'll probably see us next year. And so that brings up, because that's kind of the challenge that I would bring to this commission and this community is, you know what, having a volunteer program is always hard to sustain because volunteers, that is their passion.
2:47:42 But unfortunately, time constraints and personal constraints make it difficult for those people to continue to doing the volunteer work at the level that they would like to do. So I think that we need to look at the programs as a whole because, once again, I don't think for every program that comes out here that we think is worthy, we can afford to pay an administrative position. So we need to look at it. So I guess that's kind of where I was coming at.
2:48:12 From the beginning, and it needs to be, and that goes to MLTPA, that goes to Nordic, that goes to, you know, Eastern Sierra Nordic. It's just, there's a lot of, it goes, you know, to the trails, maybe that, you know, the person to the, or the track. Maybe there is that one coordinating person that we can get that can work on all of this. I don't know. That's just something that I'm bringing forth. It doesn't mean that, I mean, this is probably not have to do with what this is in front of us right now, but it's something that we need to consider. Wouldn't that be a recreation director? Well.
2:48:41 Anyhow. Any other questions for Brian? Brian, thank you very much. Thank you. So with that, we will meet on Thursday at 1 o'clock and you'll get us that.
2:49:05 Resolution as Bill has redone it. Probably everybody would have it by now. He's waiting for Sean and I to both reply. I don't know, Sean, if you have a reply. I did reply. I will do that and then he will pass that along. Could you just describe what some of the changes are? I might be able to pull it up real quick. It was... I guess I would rather read it. Yeah, let me forward it to you. I'm sorry, Pat, only just because I think trying to surmise it right now could be...
2:49:37 We added things that the commission talked about last time in the minutes. If it makes more money, that money goes into the pot first, reducing the amount of R to come out. Still in it that we need to determine or not is the clause on whether this is a loan or whether this is a... Although the council made very plain that they would not move it forward as a loan. The two years, and I think that that's pretty much it, just that one paragraph at the end to...
2:50:05 Delineate the fact that if we can't enhance that, then more money can be brought in. Because I think that's the one thing we all agreed on in our last condition meeting. Stu, we have other things for our regular meeting agenda other than this. So we still have the regular meeting if we finish on Thursday? Well, the only, yeah, the only item at this time that I can recollect was the recommendations on December 4th. Okay, well, we need to discuss that because we have, you know, parks planning and...
2:50:35 We've got measures, rec straps we need to get going on. And if we meet at that meeting to do nothing more than to lay out a calendar of how by the end of next year we come up with what we need to do to make a determination whether the pool stays there, whether it moves, whether the tennis courts, the master planning of the other parks, the implementation of the finish of Trails End Park. I mean, there's a whole lot on our plate. As much as I would like to go without a meeting,
2:51:04 I think that we've got an awful lot of things to deal with that probably we should have that meeting anyway. I would ask the rest of the commissioners how they feel on that or whether you want to cancel that meeting for lack of agenda items because I see a lot of things I can put on the agenda. My only concern is that I am going to be driving back from San Francisco on that day, so... Leave early. Well, I will. I believe it's currently scheduled for 4 p.m. At least that's where I've got my calendar.
2:51:32 No, it would have been a regular time. The other thing that we've added that I think Ray sent out a meeting request was a Recreation CIP meeting. I believe Commissioner Agnich and Stehlik were invited. I think that's on the 3rd. So that's really kind of that discussion that we talked about last time to kind of set, you know, some type of timeline with that committee. Right. So I think there are things that while maybe we can make it a short meeting, I think that is still a needed meeting with your permission and approval.
2:52:01 Commissioner? I think it's key. You know, we keep putting this whole discussion off. We have to have this RecStrats and Master Planning meeting because there's just, I mean, just kind of where I spoke with Elaine or, you know, with Brian or with any other facility or program that's coming forward, we have to have that whole discussion. And that's what the council is looking for us to do. I mean, we're actually looking for us to do it a lot sooner than now. And so...
2:52:30 I guess I would agree, even if it's just to set what we're going to do and what that timeline is and what our process is going to be in moving forward. I think that that has to be a priority that we set for ourselves this next year, and I think that would be a great meeting to kind of have that discussion. And if we put that or one other thing on the table, at least we have time to actually discuss that and ferret out what our options are.
2:52:56 and moving down from there because I think they will probably include a spring measure fall application from us to have that facilitated discussion. I think that's a good idea. As you know, I'm not able to be at that meeting and that's why I'm very appreciative of the meeting today and then on Thursday to come and do some of the training and the boarding recommendations. So thank you. But I agree with what's been said that at least to calendarize
2:53:25 Reviews of the master plan, and the RecStrats, and a couple of things. Okay. With that, we'll move adjourn. I don't even think we need a motion. Thank you. Thank you all. Thank you guys.