TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2012

Town Council

· recording 3 hr 50 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

468 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:07 Okay, we're going to go ahead and get started. I want to thank everybody for coming out tonight to our December 5th regular meeting for Town Council. I'll start by saying there's nothing to report out of closed session. And with that, Jamie, can we get a roll call, please? Here. Here.

7:41 Here. Here. Here. Rick, would you like to lead us and pledge, please? Certainly. If you'll please rise and join me in the Pledge of Allegiance. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Okay. At this time, we'll go ahead and do public comments.

8:14 If there's anything that anybody would like to speak to that is not on the agenda for tonight's meeting, please come up to the podium, state your name, and let us know your thoughts. Mr. Mayor, Council, John Urdi, Mammoth Lakes Tourism. I just want to remind people of a couple of things. We've got the Alaska Airlines snow packs that are on sale right now, six and ten packs. The ten pack is down to $66 per route, so you have basically five round trip tickets. They can be booked 24 hours in advance.

8:50 We're going to be selling those through the 15th of December until they sell out. So we've got about 10 days left for those. That's valid on just the LAX Mammoth Yosemite segment. The other thing is on Friday night at the tree lighting, we'll be selling all of our new logo gear. So if people want to come out and purchase hats, T-shirts, hoodies, I think we'll have convenies by then as well, we'll be selling those out at the tree lighting. So just an update. And John, did you mention those are fully transferable?

9:17 They are fully transferable. I didn't mention that, but yes, that's a good point. So people can buy those and use them for their families, use them with their friends. You can go in and buy them with another person. So definitely a great deal and something that we want to kick off. Tried to do it this past summer. Couldn't get it figured out, but we got it figured out for the winter, which hopefully leads us to have them available all year round. John, can you share with us?

9:40 When we'll be going to full flights and what the flights will be in cities? Sure. Actually, we just started going seven days a week this past Saturday with Alaska Airlines. So we're seven days a week, one flight a day still. The second LA flight starts December 14th. That's five days earlier than it was supposed to. It was supposed to start the 19th. They scheduled it the 14th, so that's actually helping us at this point. And all the other flights from San Francisco, Orange County, and San Diego start on the 19th.

10:07 Can you tell us as far as the bookings of those flights as compared to previous years? Yeah, previous years we were up. Right now we're behind actually last year. We had a lot of pre-bookings last year because of the prior winter. We're behind slightly. We're actually up in San Diego pretty substantially. And the other markets are recovering nicely with the new snow. The phones are definitely ringing off the hook and getting us some bookings for the holidays now. Thank you.

10:36 Ticket packs, they don't expire. Those tickets don't expire. They will expire April 14th. Of 2013. Correct. They're basically for the winter segment. Okay. So that's the LA winter segment. And then what we'll do is we will work to put something in place so when the spring, summer, fall service starts for next year, we'll have another product in place. But I'm hoping that we can actually start selling during February vacation week next year so that we can get folks pre-purchasing for the summer. And those likely will be valid.

11:03 Depending on if we can negotiate the year-round LA flight to be one contract, so that it's spring, summer, fall, and winter, as opposed to having two separate contracts, it would be nice that we have those valid the whole time. The only difference might be the yield on the ticket. The winter flight may be more expensive than the summer flight, so we need to figure that piece out, but that would be the way to do it, is we can make them good for a calendar year for purchase. And also, what time is the tree lighting, Friday night? Tree lighting is at 5.30.

11:31 Stu can handle it. I'll follow you. Okay. Thanks. Anybody else from the public? Lee? Hi, my name is Lee Gosh. I'm happy to announce an hour ago I got a phone call on Jane and the guide dog that I was raising, and she has officially been pulled as a breeder, so she made it. And what a breeder is, is the guide dogs like to keep their own stock and try to keep it going, and they pick the cream of the crop, that's how they explained it to me.

12:03 And it's the ultimate honor for a puppy raiser to have your dog picked. She'll be living within 50 to 75 miles on campus with the family, and they'll be breeding her once a year, so there'll be a lot more jamies out there to help people with their lives. And I get to raise one of her puppies when she has a puppy. So probably within the next month I'll be flying up to San Rafael at graduation, and I'll be handing her over. And I'm really proud of her.

12:27 And I'll bring Flana up here probably at the next meeting. I just thought this was just not the right time to bring her, but my new puppy, I'll bring her to introduce you to her. Thanks. Thank you, Lee. Congratulations on that. Anybody else from the public like to speak? Anything not on the agenda? Okay. Seeing none, we'll go ahead and move on to council member reports.

12:53 Joe, I'll start with you. Nothing to report. Okay, great. Nothing to report. John? Real quick, I just wanted to share that I had the privilege last week and then again last night to attend the Mammoth High School basketball, both men's and women's basketball games, where the Mammoth men's team won both of their games against Big Pine by substantial margins. The women's, even though they didn't win, showed improvement.

13:23 Game last night. And just wanted to mention also that this Thursday, tomorrow night, both high school varsity basketball teams will be playing Lee Vining High School here in Mammoth. The women's varsity starts at 5 and the men's start at 7. In particular, the men's team has been playing together. Now they're mainly juniors and seniors, but they've been playing together.

13:51 For three years in the high school level and additional years prior to that. So some of them have been playing together for six years. And this squad of men basketball players in the past two years, I think, have won only two or three games in those two seasons. And this year they've won their first two games. So big improvement for the men's basketball program this year. Thank you. Thank you, John. Michael? No. Nothing. Okay. Nothing today.

14:21 I'll just go through a couple quick things. I had an opportunity to meet with Bill Cockroft and Michelle Tamer regarding the Mammoth Kamikaze Bike Games, which are scheduled currently for September 4th through the 8th. So we're really trying to get another event going at the end of the season to bookend that.

14:44 Also, John and a number of other people in the community are working with the San Diego Half Marathon to bring that up here. So if you haven't done it already, you're a runner or just want to participate, that's going to take place at the beginning of April, I believe. And all the proceeds from that will go to local charities, so keep that in mind.

15:10 Throwing out an idea of a winter carnival. They're working with John Urdi, Brent Truax, and David Page actually brought this forward and worked with Councilmember Raimondo as well. Coming up with some ideas of how some people can champion a bunch of different ideas so not one person has to be burdened with the task of putting on a giant event. But we're playing with the idea right now. We might be approaching some members of the community to ask them to take a leadership role in taking on one task.

15:39 Just to give you an example of something we've thrown out there was maybe going to the Contractors Association and taking that upper pad next to the ice rink and doing something like build concrete forms to put in a giant snow maze to let the kids do that. And that's something that can last throughout the following months into the spring. And that's one of maybe 20 or 30 things that we could be doing around here.

16:04 It doesn't cost a lot of money, and it's ice sculpting in front of major businesses, key points throughout town. So something new to look at, and we're going to keep kicking that around, so we might be calling on various people in the community. And then I got an email earlier from Michael Vanderhurst from Mammoth Lakes Tourism saying that Mammoth and Mono County and really the eastern Sierra got named the top ten best destinations to visit.

16:34 And Lonely Planet, which for those of you who aren't familiar with, it's a great tourism and people that are out there looking where to travel, that's a pretty big deal for us. So I wanted to let people know about that. And then finally, Council, what I'd like to see is we're going to probably try to open up a better line of communication here with the community.

16:58 I know there's a lot of stuff going on out there. We've been pumping a lot of information towards everybody and it's not easy to grasp all of it. So we're going to toy with the idea of doing a newsletter or something along those lines and maybe even a quick media workshop after, you know, council meetings. We might even do something before council meetings, let everybody come in so we can just sit down and have a conversation and people can do it in a less formal environment.

17:27 If you guys have any thoughts, throw them at us, and we're going to start working on that. So with that, we'll go ahead and move on to commission updates. So any commissions have anything that they would like to report? No, Terry? I was chair of the rep commission, and we didn't really talk about having a report today, and Stu may be reporting on this, but I just wanted to let you know that...

18:03 Pat Agnich and myself did meet with Ray and Stuart on Monday to talk about just kind of the process as starting our CIP and a CIP discussion, I guess, and the PFFP or whatever it's called now, the Community Capital Improvement Forecast for Long-Term Plans. And so basically what we've came up with, and it's going to be finalized in January, and we'll come out with a schedule.

18:35 Timeline and what we're talking about at each of our meetings. But we'll have our regular commission meeting at the first Tuesday of each month as we normally do. And then two weeks after that, we'll have a workshop. And we're basically going to take each of our plans, rec strats, Parks and Rec Master Plan, Trails Master Plan, Dr. Seds, take all of the adoptive plans, and we're going to take one to two of those at each of those workshops.

19:02 Kind of our homework beforehand is for each of the commissioners to go through that, make an executive summary of our own, and then come together at that workshop, have that discussion, include any public comments, and then we're hoping, you know, we were originally looking at kind of a six-month schedule, and we're looking at kind of trying to condense it to about three months if possible. At the end of that, coming out with something that we can...

19:28 Start working with all of those summaries to make a master plan to bring back to the council. So we're trying to be pretty aggressive in moving that forward. Great. Thank you, Terry. I wanted to correct something. So the Mammoth Half Marathon is June 23rd. So I apologize for that. Any other commission updates? OK. Seeing none, we'll go on to department reports and emerging issues.

20:02 Mr. Mayor, City Council, just a quick reminder to our community. As most of you probably know, we maybe have six or seven bears that are still circulating around town. I get calls every morning about the footprints that everybody sees in the snow. Some people this time of year, they assume that the bears are all in den. The bear's a little confused with the weather patterns that we've been having. And these large bears...

20:32 I've been active every night. People have been, the last several nights have been leaving dumpsters open not knowing that the bears were still busy and the bears are getting into that food. To answer the question a lot of people ask every day about, you know, shouldn't the bears be in bed by now when I show up to deal with an open dumpster?

20:55 The shortness of the days, the cold weather, the snow burying their natural food sources is what pushes the bears into den this time of year or even earlier. As long as we have an artificial food source available for them, then it perpetuates that and it just extends the length of time before they go into den. Unfortunately, the other night, three bears got into a grease bin behind a restaurant. That, you know, extends their being up for probably a couple weeks.

21:23 So I just ask the community to keep doing a great job. Lock the dumpsters. If you have issues, don't hesitate to call me, 937-BEAR. You've seen all the ravens around town. They're dragging a lot of trash around. Lock the dumpsters for the same reason. Also, the coyote population this time of year gets very busy. And so if you have the small dogs, outdoor cats, I'd be aware of the local coyotes that you're seeing on the streets. Even midday, we're seeing coyotes in our neighborhood.

21:50 Be aware of that. Also, I'm proud to say that on two different calls we've been responding to, there's two bobcats that are circulating in neighborhoods. Thank you, Joe. And pretty neat thing. Nothing to be afraid of. They don't want to eat your cats or dogs. But for people to be able to observe that in our community, what a great indicator of one of the things that's going really right in our town is to have local bobcats being observed multiple times a day. So that's something that we should

22:19 Really be proud of and celebrate. That's all I had. If there's any questions by council, I'd be glad to answer them if I can. Any questions? Yeah. Thank you for your time. Thanks, Steve. Appreciate it. Any other department reports? Just a couple of quick items for the Community Economic Development Department. Update on the TOT enforcement efforts. Still continue to make good progress. Currently at a total of about $228,000 for this fiscal year.

22:52 We think we have another $20,000 or so waiting to be receded into our system, which will bring us close to the $250,000 halfway point for our TRT target this whole year, so that's great news. We're working actively with our logging community and others to do outreach. One of those major efforts is doing some direct outreach to the TRT remitters.

23:18 Thank you.

23:46 The second topic I wanted to update you on was some efforts regarding single-family transient rental. We're continuing to get a lot of communication and just sort of feedback on both sides of the debate about that.

24:11 Following the joint workshop that we held with the Planning Commission on the 7th, the Planning Commission discussed sort of follow-up items from that, particularly the issue of the CC&Rs for HOAs and how that might relate to a transient rental situation in single-family neighborhoods.

24:31 Based on that, we've asked the Town Attorney to develop some additional information for the Planning Commission, which they'll be reviewing at their meeting next week. And based on that, providing a recommendation to the Town Council on really whether and how we might be able to proceed on this question. So bringing it forward is really as a should we move ahead with this thing to get a more definitive direction based on some additional information from the Town Attorney. And that will happen on the Planning Commission meeting next week on the 12th.

25:01 I'm pretty sensitive on spending staff time on this issue because on the last issue that you mentioned, single family rentals, because I'm not sure that there are any neighborhoods in the town and the community that would

25:24 Have CC&Rs that would even allow this. I know that there are some areas of town that do allow it, but those are ones that we've already identified and that we're aware of, and it's either one or two neighborhoods, and they're very, very small. So I just heard this evening that that was on the Planning Commission's agenda, and so I'm concerned that we don't spend too much time on it. I'm concerned.

25:50 That hopefully at that meeting itself we will have the answer as to whether or not which neighborhoods, if any, do allow it in the community. Right. The town attorney has not let Nate speak to this if he wants to, but has provided some advice to us as to how we might deal with that. And one of the issues is really whether or not the town should put itself in a position of attempting to interpret CC&Rs.

26:14 Which, as you know, are really the domain of the Homeowners Association to both interpret and to enforce. And so the intent of this discussion on the Planning Commission is to daylight that issue a little bit more, provide some options to say, if the town did decide to move ahead with a program, how CC&RF might be handled in some form or fashion, and use that as a basis for decisions. Because right now we've had a lot of discussion about

26:42 You know, what do the CCNRs tell us? Can we interpret them? Can we decide based on whether or not we should allow transient mental in certain neighborhoods? And the answer is it will be difficult. And so we wanted to just provide more information on that topic and on the basis of that information to decide whether or not that's something we wanted to move forward. So it's likely that we'll have clear direction at the end of that meeting? Absolutely. Thank you. Anybody else? Any questions for Ellen? Okay. Thank you, Ellen. Appreciate it.

27:15 Evening, Madam Mayor, members of council, staff and community. So the highlight of the holiday period is the official Town of Mammoth Lakes tree lighting ceremony, as John alluded to, jump the gun. So Mammoth Lakes Tourism will be there selling their logo wear, but really the purpose of the evening is really just to bring the community together, hopefully bring some nice weather. I don't know if it'll snow that evening, but we can certainly try. So 5.30 on Friday, it's December 7th, so it's two days away.

27:45 5.30, Footloose Sports Parking Lot. Scheduled to be in attendance is our Mayor, Lehman, who's going to officially flip the switch, do a little bit of a countdown. Compliments of Long Valley Fire Department. Santa will make his arrival. Woolly is also going to be in attendance for all the big kids and little kids. And local organisations selling scrumptious food and beverage will also be there as well. So that's this Friday, 5.30, Footloose Sports Parking Lot. Everybody's welcome. It's a free event.

28:13 A little update on the Mammoth Ice Rink. It's also scheduled to open Friday, but due to circumstances really outside our control, due to equipment, pipes, weather, etc., we're probably delaying that opening, or actually are delaying that opening until the week of December 10. It's more than likely going to be next Friday, December 14th. So we do apologise for not being able to get that facility open, but again, we've had some hurdles that we'd need to overcome.

28:43 And just to wrap up, Commissioner Stellick did mention the, it's the Recreation, I think we're calling it, I don't know, we haven't got an acronym yet, but hopefully we'll stay away from that, but it's the Recreation Facilities Investment Program for Recreation and the Arts, that's kind of what we're calling it, and that is due to the Council by June 14, 2014, but obviously the timeline will be a little bit more compressed, we'll have to get something to you at that time.

29:11 And certainly in the near future. And just to quickly follow up, the Mammoth Half Marathon folks are back on December 17th, and at that time we're going to finalise the route, basically the town route. So town staff came up with three alternatives. We presented to that group and they're coming up on Monday, December 17th to at least review them. Hopefully they can walk them, maybe run them, see what the weather does, or snowshoe them, one or the other. But we'll try and get that route finalised so they can start promoting as well.

29:41 Stu, are they doing a 5K as well? They are. That's correct. Yep. Any other questions from Council? Any questions for Stu? No. Thank you. Thank you, Stu. Okay. We've got Cindy. Cindy Myron, Finance Department. I just want to remind Council and update the community that business tax renewals will be going out next week. They're due January 1st.

30:09 Delinquent after January 31st. That revenue source, just to let everybody know, does get dedicated to our tourism department in full. That's it. Thank you, Cindy. Chief. I'd like to give you an update on what's happening in the police department. As I think you're all aware, we've had five people are going to be retiring or leaving by the end of this month to actually two of them have already left to other departments. Another five or so are processing elsewhere.

30:43 And that means, I believe, that by the time we get to July, we'll be down to seven positions that are being eliminated. I've had preliminary discussions with our Navy law enforcement partners in Inyo County and Mono County about the feasibility of developing some kind of system where we can use them to backfill vacancies we can't fill on a particular day. It's going to be a little more complicated than we thought, but we're trying to move forward on that.

31:11 I'll be coming to you probably the next meeting with a report that will explain what the impact's going to be on the service reductions. Probably in January, early January, I'll come to you with a plan on developing a reserve program and how we're going to move forward on that. As of today, retired Sergeant Karen Smart has informed me that she's accepted my offer to be a volunteer coordinator. So that's going to be very important as we move forward on developing a volunteer program.

31:41 We're going to need somebody to manage it, and Karen will be really good in that position. So she'll be working with the rest of the town staff on a town-wide volunteer program as well as one specific for the police department. So those are some of the things that are going on right now. Any questions for Chief? Chief, a real quick question. I know I was unable to attend, but you had a Hispanic advisory public meeting on Friday up in the village.

32:08 I wasn't able to attend because of doing snow removal at that time. That was when we had a pretty good storm on Friday. And did we have a decent attendance? For the same reasons you were unavailable, a lot of our attendees that would normally have been there were unavailable because of the heavy snow that was going on at the time. One of our presenters drove from Fresno, and he arrived after it started but was able to give his presentation.

32:38 Three presentations from Mono County Health Department, the Highway Patrol, and then we had an Immigration Rights Attorney. We're well-received. The information was very informative. And other than the turnout, we feel it was a very successful meeting. Curiosity, was there any of that fine food left over? Yes. Yes? Okay. I didn't ask for one. I did not go back to the police station. I don't know where it left. But thanks to Marancia Villa, one of our...

33:07 Committee members, she's always able to get us plenty of food, and thanks to the several restaurants, all of them I can't remember, that donated food to the event. Good. Thank you, sir. Thank you. Thanks, Chief. Any other department heads or emerging issue comments? Okay. Seeing none, we'll go ahead and move on to our council presentations, and we'll start with the Chief. Thank you. It's my pleasure to...

33:37 I recognize two of our police department employees for milestone years and with the award that goes with it. The first one is Officer Jesse Gorham. I would ask him to come forward. He is just completing 15 years with the MLPD. Jesse started his career in San Diego in 1989 and decided to move north in 1997. So he's been with us 15 years this month. He's had a very distinguished career with us.

34:04 He's worked a variety of really important jobs. They've included being our department armorer and range master. He does a tremendous amount of training for people in town as well as our officers. He was on the MONET task force. He worked detectives a couple of times. He was on the mountage unit. He was a crime scene investigator. And I'm sorry to say that he's retiring after 23 years in law enforcement, 15 here. And he's moving with his family to Clendenin, West Virginia.

34:34 With his wife Valerie and three of his four children. His oldest child is Laura. She's a Marine and is currently going to school in San Diego. We're going to miss Jesse. He's been a real stalwart. He's had quite a presence in the village in the evenings at times with his departure and Marty Thompson's yesterday or earlier this week. That now makes me the largest member of the police department. I'm not sure that's a good thing.

35:00 But Jesse's had a very honorable career, and we're sorry to see him move on, but we wish him the very best of luck as he moves on to the next chapter in his life. But he's here for his 15-year award, not for a retirement ceremony. I just want to thank the council and the people of Mammoth Lakes in town for the opportunity to work here and to have a good career and to raise my family away from the perils of the city.

35:35 Which is what I was trying to escape for my children. I've had a good career. I've got some cases. This town, although a lot of you believe it's a sleepy little town where you can leave your keys in your car and your door's unlocked, not so much. And I'm very proud. I put a serial rapist in prison, 25 years to life, who was operating between Santa Barbara and here.

35:58 And injected a woman on Mammoth Mountain, and our case was the case that broke that one open. We was instrumental in a woman who called 911, all we have a first name, and the call was hung up, and we actually saved her life. We interrupted her murder over on Mono Street, or actually it was Lupin Street.

36:21 And she was unconscious when we got in there and her boyfriend was in the process of strangling her to death. So, you know, those things will always be with me and I know that I've touched people's lives. So, anyway, I thank you for the opportunity and it's time to move on to a new chapter. Thank you. Thank you, Jesse. You know, I want to say something real quick, too.

37:01 Jesse was the first officer that I met when I moved back up here. Under good terms or not? I got to see Jesse in action and how he handled a pretty interesting situation. It was with a guy with an eye that had actually followed me down from the lake space. He was kind of a self-appointed vigilante.

37:25 But Jesse handled the situation real well, and I appreciate it, and I think the neighbors in the neighborhood have been taken to a very interesting situation. So, Jesse, thank you again. I appreciate it. And good luck. The second presentation is to Officer David Scobie for achieving 10 years with the Mammoth Lakes Police Department. David couldn't be here tonight, so I'll be accepting the award for him.

37:55 David is well known in town. He was our traffic officer for a number of years. He wrote the grant that got us the position in the vehicle. He's also well known because he and his wife Martha and his son William are residents of town. I think Martha is as much in the police department as David is. She is at everything. And they're just great residents and he's a great officer. They all volunteer for just about everything in town.

38:22 When I first got here, I met with every one of the members of the police department, and I asked all of the officers, tell me who's the best officer besides yourself, of course, and why. And David led that list. And having watched him for the last two and a half years, I understand why. He was selected as the Officer of the Year for 2011, both by the Police Officers Association, who picked the peer officer, and I did the same thing. He was my Officer of the Year last year.

38:48 I regret that David couldn't be here, but it's my pleasure to accept his award for him. I'd like to make a comment about David as well. I don't know David real well, but like the Chief said, even amongst his peers, one thing I've heard consistently throughout the community when you hear about police officers is that

39:15 People really like David Scobie. I mean, even the people that have been pulled over by him, I mean, they almost enjoyed the experience. Anyway, I think he's the epitome of a great officer, and I just want to say thank you. With that, we'll go ahead and move on to the consent agenda. Mr. Mayor, I would like to remove number six. Okay. Joe is pulling item number six.

39:44 Any other council members pulling any items? Are there any members of the public that want to pull any consent agenda items? Okay. We move to approve agenda items 3, 4, 5, and 7. Okay. Second. All right. We have a motion and a second. Can I get a roll call, Jamie? Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Okay. Motion passes 5-0.

40:13 We'll go ahead and move on then, Joe, to item six. For the benefit of those who don't have agendas, this is about the Measure U Spring Award timeline, and I did have some questions from staff. Stu, if you wouldn't mind coming up. First, I wanted to clarify, and it's kind of part of page two and page three, that no cap was placed on the amount. Rather, there are some specific funding areas.

40:46 Special Events, Emergency or Previously Awarded Projects that Require Additional Funding and Town Council Recommended Town of Mammoth Lakes Projects. That's correct. So are there people who applied last year and didn't get funded that are essentially being excluded by this? I'll just show how to answer that. I think this is aligned with the spring funding priorities.

41:19 And I know the members of the committee here this evening they can speak to as well. But overall they're very cognisant of the limited funds available. You know, it's less than $250,000. I don't believe they're in a position to spend it all. I think the goal is to synchronise those two funds that measure R and measure U in the fall. So the decision to move forward from instead of a funding cap to a category was to really prioritise those funds to existing special events or new special events.

41:50 That do want to come forward. And as we've identified here, two and three. So they're going to combine those two, those three funding categories with the funding priorities that for the benefit of the public here this evening are still the same and has been the same since council adopted these for the test award. And they were economic stimulus being number one, high impact, ready to go, leverage and then plan for the future. So really, if you look at the categories, they're really looking at one, two and three.

42:19 So I think with the limited funds available, they thought it was the best interest just to go after those categories they could give or reach those funding priorities identified. Okay, then my second part... Sorry, it's this microphone. It's that microphone? Okay. Then my second question was about the available funding because I know in the agenda bill you say plus or minus $260,000.

42:47 But it appears in Attachment B that that includes an estimate of funds that come in through the end of March, yet it then also says in here that at the time the awards are being made, the amount received is going to be determined, and that's all that will be available, right? That's what we've done in the past, exactly. So it's the funds on hand at the time of the award. So on March 19th, we'll be able to kind of pool the available funds at that time.

43:16 That would be the award amount. So it could very well be far less than that amount, which typically what's happened. Recently in Measure R, it actually went over the available funds just for the last remittance from the state of California. So I think that was the decision we've made previously about that funding amount. So we don't award it based on what we anticipate. We award on what we have available. OK. And then just for the benefit of the community who might be listening or is in the room,

43:45 Can you tell them the application opening and deadline so they've got some planning time? Yeah, we can. So, again, it's on page two of the agenda bill if you had a chance to review it. It's also online. January 7th is when the 2003 Measure U Spring Award will open. It'll be open through February 1st. And then we move through a number of special meetings beginning on February 26th, which is the first special hearing, the second special hearing, if needed.

44:14 It's March 5th, and we're back here in front of Council on March 20th. So we did want to, as much as we can, expedite this process and get those funds available to the community at that time. The Measure R award will be following that, so that award will probably be May or June. For the Measure R spring? For the Measure R spring, right. So they're not running concurrently. They're still somewhat staggered. There we go. That is the timeline as it's presented. Okay.

44:44 All right. Yeah. Then in that case, I will move approval of option one. Second. Okay. We have a motion in a second. Roll call, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Okay. Motion passes 5-0. Thank you. Okay. So with that, we're going to move on to policy matters.

45:20 And we're going to start with the adoption or consider the adoption of the restructuring plan. And Dave will go ahead and walk us through this. So, yeah, Dave, please. I'll just take a few steps. Okay. So first I want to just, you know, thank the council and the community for all the difficult and hard work that has gone into this, particularly as well, Marianna and our staff.

45:44 You know, this is kind of a closing of a really important, difficult, and somewhat dark chapter for the town. We've made through it. We've made our first payment in November. We're scheduled to make our next payment in July. Those payments have been funded. But there's many more payments to come. And so tonight's restructuring plan really is the stage for those future payments. I don't want to have anybody think that somehow this is an easy...

46:12 Next step. This restructuring plan has many, many elements to it that have to be considered. You're going to do that tonight, and then we're going to implement based upon your direction to us. There are some things that I think it's important to talk about relative to what we need to do. First off, I think we need to have a long vision. This can't be short. This needs to be long. The plan you have in front of you is a five-year plan. Every year after this, you'll get five-year plans.

46:40 There may be things that happen in the meantime. I don't know about those things, which could make this payment schedule shorter or change it in some fashion, but right now we have a plan that we're going to implement. So we need to stay the course. It's really important that the community stay the course and be disciplined in its approach. From my point of view, I think the work that I do, we certainly are going to look at and maintain a very compact and efficient government. There's always a sense.

47:08 An interest in growing the government as new revenues come in or programs or ideas come forward. We're very, very fortunate in this community to have measure R and measure U to take care of a lot of issues and ideas that come forward. There are many, many, many other things that require attention from your road maintenance to other areas of facilities management and maintenance and responding to the development community. We're going to need to work on ways to be efficient and effective and reduce and maintain cost structure.

47:37 So we'll be bringing those proposals to you. I think there's going to be a need over time, and we're going to be working on them as immediately as tomorrow, that we need to get a sense and recognition eventually that salaries and wages and benefits for our employees are in alignment. People understand what they are, they're comfortable with where they are, and the argument about that is diminished. We should be focusing on the future of Mammoth, auditing these other kinds of things that distract us.

48:04 So we're going to be working very hard to bring those into a place where that is achieved. I think along with that, the Council will be working on, we'll be working on with you, some very clear goals and objectives this spring. You can't have a myriad of goals. You need to have some very concise goals and objectives. We need to do that work, and we'll help you do that. And I think, and Marianna will talk a bit more about it, we certainly need to continue our public-private partnerships. The town staff.

48:30 Can't do this alone. We've had some great partnerships. You've heard about them tonight with Measure UNR and so forth. We need to continue that effort, and I'm very pleased to have a chance to do that. We've got a couple of things we need to talk to you about before you get into the details. We had some decisions that came out of the rec commission that applied to tonight's conversation. I'm going to ask Stuart to come back and talk about those things. When he's completed, I'm going to ask Mariana to come up and finish the walkthrough as you started to talk about it and bring this thing to a conclusion.

49:00 And we look forward to your discussion and debate, the community's input, and then whatever direction you give us, we'll go to work on it. Thank you. Thank you, Dave. And real quick, before you start, Stuart, I'd like to ask council, a member of the community asked if they could come up and they had a question on transit as it related, I think, to some financing. And I told them to bring it up at some point during item number eight versus public comment.

49:36 If Council doesn't mind, I'd like to allow them to come up after Stuart and discuss that. So go ahead, Stuart. Stuart Brown, Recreation Manager. So this topic, as you know, is very much related to the restructuring plan. In the proposed restructuring plan is the elimination of the Whitmore Recreation Area Pool and the use of the ball fields. And it also includes the elimination of a parks maintenance position.

50:05 So the Recreation Commission has been wrestling with this topic for quite a number of months. And more recently, we've scheduled four meetings in the last nine days to try and get some closure on this topic for the council this evening. So the Recreation Commission met this afternoon at 4 o'clock in a special meeting. The present was the town attorney to firstly finalise a resolution. And we apologise that we haven't been able to get that to you.

50:34 Prior to this evening, but as you can understand, it's been, well, it's a very concise resolution, so we obviously need a little bit of time to walk you through that document. The commission also acted on a statement that they'd like to precede that resolution, and with the mayor's permission, I'll go ahead and read that. I've also given it to you this evening. Essentially, on December 5th,

51:03 In 2012, the Recreation Commission approved the following motion, which was unanimous, so 4-0. Commissioner Agnich was absent. And the statement is as follows. We believe the intent of Measure R was to improve and enhance recreation parks and trails and not to replace general fund monies dedicated to those uses. So while the Recreation Commission has recommended Town Council adoption of the proposed resolution, we feel strongly that the Council will only adopt the resolution

51:32 If there are no other general fund monies that could be realised to fund the Whitmore Recreation Area and the park's maintenance position for a period of two years, beginning January 1, 2013. So that was the statement I've read. I also previously presented the resolution. It's here before you. It's quite in-depth. There is three pages of the resolution, and the final page is the amended Measure Hour Expenditure Plan.

52:00 Town Attorney can speak more closely to a couple of citations that we'd like to reference, but essentially what it does is identify that the funds being used to fund that operation is supplanting. Supplanting doesn't appear in the Measure R Ordinance, but it does appear in the Measure R Expenditure Plan.

52:27 And the Measure Hour Expandage Plan can be modified and amended with a majority vote of Town Council. So that's the seventh paragraph down the seventh whereas. The Commission also identified six statements, which you can kind of read through them with you. But essentially what it does is to commit Measure Hour funds for a period of two years for the very specific use of those funds.

52:57 To fund the Whitmore Recreation, to only fund the Whitmore Recreation Area and Pool and Parks Maintenance position beginning January 1, 2013 through December 31, 2014. That was point number one. Point number two, it just identifies that it is short-term supplanting of general fund expenditures. Point number three, the Town Council hereby directs town staff to work on, present for consideration prior to June 30, 2014, a comprehensive revenue enhancement and cost containment.

53:28 Program. And we're also directing staff to bring forward that program or updates to that program as frequently as possible under the direction of council. And then number four speaks to what Commissioner Stellick talked to before and what I briefly talked about was a long-term five-year capital investment program for recreation of the arts. So that was number four.

53:52 Number five is more to do with the annual accounting of those funds, budget, and as it states here, the budget shall be approved by the Town Council prior to any use of those funds. And it does clearly say that any portion of the Measure R funds, the expenditure of which is authorized hereby, which is not spent for the authorized use, shall remain in the Measure R account. And for the benefit of the public, as you know, Measure R is not

54:21 A cheque that's handed over to any organisation or project of an applicant, it remains in the measure hour account with the town and funds are billed against that. So those funds would remain in that account if they're not used. And then point number six is the area that we probably had the most discussion with at the Commission this afternoon. But basically really what it says is all revenues collected for use at the Whitmore Recreation and Pool

54:48 And this is excluding funds collected for the use of the Mammoth Track. We haven't set that program in place or any fee structure for that facility, so it's a little premature to include that in this resolution. So those revenues that are collected outside that Mammoth Track in that field shall be used to support its operation and maintenance and be deducted from the Measure R contribution, which is actually similar to how it's processed right now. So those revenues are a net amount that can come off the gross.

55:18 And then should the town identify additional revenue sources, either one, directly related to the Whitmore Recreation Area and Pool, or two, generally available for recreational purposes, those funds shall be used only to support the Whitmore Recreation Area and Pool in position instead of Measure R funds, and the incumbent Measure R funds shall remain in the Measure R account for reallocation in accordance with the expenditure plan. So, I don't know.

55:46 Town Attorney wants to speak to that directly, but that probably is a point that we need to kind of clarify with the Council. Thanks, Stu. Andy Morris, Town Attorney. The last version of the resolution that I suggested to the Recreation Commission had some additional language in it, intended to capture the idea that the Town Council is not obligated to send every spare new dollar that you find to the Recreation Department budget to offset measure our revenues.

56:15 And the Recreation Commission, I don't want to entirely speak to them. At least one or two of them are here tonight. They can speak. But the commission felt that that's exactly what they do want. They do want that if the town ever finds a spare dollar, that it go first before it goes to reserves. And by the way, I think Marianna is working on a reserve policy that she can discuss. But if you ever find a dollar, it first has to go to the rec department to reduce the measure or expenditures before being used for anything else you might want to use it for.

56:44 So the commission felt that they did not want to include the clarification that I had included in the draft resolution that captures that. So the version that Stu has described and that you now have that they approved omits a sentence that I had included at the very end that says essentially the intent of this paragraph is that the town council is not obligated to increase the general fund budget for recreation as a means of reducing measure or expenditures.

57:12 So I think that with the version that the Recreation Commission has forwarded to you, arguably you do have to use any money you find, any additional TOT, any other revenue that may come in. First, you have to use to pay down the measure or expenditures. If that's the Council's pleasure, then the resolution that they gave you would be the right one to adopt. If, on the other hand, you'd like to have more flexibility in deciding what to do with additional revenue that may come in that's not rec-related.

57:41 Then you might want to request some amendments to the resolution before you adopt it. And I see the two commissioners are here and they can perhaps explain better. And actually before we get from the commissioners, there's one more part, Andy, that is not really clear to me and it's the third, the paragraph number three where it talks about we're going to present a comprehensive revenue enhancement and cost containment program. How is that different from the budgeting?

58:13 That we've been doing or the restructuring that we're doing. That was the Recreation Commission's request and I don't know entirely what they mean. Okay. I can certainly help. So we began this process, as you know, several months ago and where we are now with that is we have a funding strategies and tactics document that's identified specifically for Whitmore Recreation Area and Pool and the Parks Maintenance Position. We've presented that to the Recreation Commission and with our partnerships,

58:43 With Mammoth Unified School District, Mammoth Lake Swim Team, we're working through a number of strategies and tactics that we'll be able to provide either additional revenue, visitation, or some programs to reduce operating expenditures. I mean, the obvious one out there is the geothermal heating. It's also the solar heating. You know, what opportunities available there? We can look at scheduling. We can look at times, operations. We can look at fees. So there's a whole multitude of options available that the commissions

59:10 Identifying and working through. So that is kind of a... So that number three is this is the Comprehensive Revenue and Enhancement and Cost Containment Program for the Whitmore Park. Specifically for the Whitmore Park. Okay, because this makes it sound like its entire department, you know, county town budget. Okay. A little bit clearer. Other questions for Stu? Just as a note, you know, I know everybody's working hard on this stuff. I just, I mean, it's hard to...

59:51 I have a decision ready to make right here at the last second. I mean, we can't even have time to read this. Right. And actually, I did have one more question I forgot to ask. Since Dave and Marianna were in a closed session with us, neither of them have had a chance to review this. Is that correct? Yeah. Yeah, just a little bothersome. It's hard to... Well, I'm not willing to work on it until I've had a chance to read it and get some more input. But I think maybe if there are some concepts we can discover or discuss as a group...

1:00:23 As part of number eight, then maybe it can come back to us because as far as I understand, nothing would, if we approve the plan as it stands tonight, nothing actually happens with the Whitmore Pool and Park things immediately. Am I correct on that? No, but not necessarily. The position that is identified in Parks Maintenance would be notified of a layoff. Even if we continued it over for two weeks? If you continued it, certainly we would.

1:00:53 Defer it until then. But if you were to approve the plan tonight as proposed, we would take action. Okay. And I think the broad scope of what we want to do, I think, can be painted at some point once we get into number eight. But I think the particulars of the resolution where I'm running into just... Yeah. I know Stuart may have said this is concise, but it's three pages. And I'd like to read it and understand it before I vote on it.

1:01:22 Mr. Mayor, I have the luxury of not needing this resolution, if you will, to be finalized tonight simply because I don't support using this proposed money to fund recreation. I think that we should take it out of the general fund. So I think we can still address this issue as a council and find out at some point this evening if there's support.

1:01:52 If there's three votes on the council to pay for the Whitmore pool and the facility down there at a general fund as opposed to a loan. Okay, well, as we go down through the table here, let's bring this back and address it once we get down to recreation of Whitmore, if that's okay with everybody. And then, yeah, we'll go ahead, Donette.

1:02:23 I just want to say I was at the 4 o'clock meeting and our attorney, your attorney, your town attorney, is the attorney for everything in your town. He did this whole resolution and it was a beautiful resolution and then it's being been picked away. And I just find that what I'm seeing is

1:02:53 Having the town attorney constantly having to change stuff to meet the commissions how they desire. And that's what you pay this town attorney is to make the recommendations and to keep you all out of trouble. Because in the past, we've seen what happened by not listening to your attorney or doing other things. And I just, I think Andy has done a great job.

1:03:22 In his language that he had put in, that was taken out, I don't find that, I can't believe that that would go back to Measure R. I think that you should use the money as the purpose. It's gone through its process. The money's there. I know, John, you don't agree with that. But just let the process go through. And if you get extra money,

1:03:49 The point was... Donette, we're going to go through this specifically as we go down, and once we start talking about Whitmore Pool and Measure R, so we will have that time... Can we wait for that comment? Yeah, if you would, please, because I think we just really wanted to understand the resolution first, and then we're going to get into the table here and go through the process of just discussing each item, and I'll explain that in a second, so if you could wait until we get there, that would be real helpful. Okay, thank you. Thank you.

1:04:18 Can you speak just to that resolution? Sure. It'll be just really quick. Yeah. You know, as Andy had said on the item number six, that we're looking for any penny that comes into the town to come back to this, that isn't actually what we were looking at, that if there was extra revenue and the TOTs came up, that we would ask that the town council put monies back into that.

1:04:44 And so the way it had read is that without increasing the general fund budget for recreation, and we felt that if there's extra money that comes in, that it should be able to go into that if that's what the council chooses. We're not saying that every single penny that's realized has to come back into here, but we're trying to make the point that this is supplanting, that if there's money that comes in and the general fund realizes the extra funds and they're able to...

1:05:12 And one of the council meetings in one of our discussions,

1:05:39 The council, some of you had indicated that you would be open to it if there was a surplus to putting back into R. And I do want to thank Andy very much for going back and forth with us on this and meeting us this afternoon. That was great. Thank you, guys. And we'll probably call you back up for questions when we hit that item, so thank you. Okay, and before we jump into the table here and going down these items, I wanted to...

1:06:07 Ask Bill if you wanted to come up and speak now, because I think I probably should ask you to come up in public comment, but my mistake. Mr. Mayor and Council, normally I would be in public comment, but this is very relative now, so I'll just speak on it as quickly as I can. So I realized a couple weeks ago that the late night transportation was taken away. I heard some rumors about it, but it wasn't until someone from 1849, the manager,

1:06:34 I called and said, you know, what are you going to do about this? And there's no transportation in this part of the community, et cetera, from the hours of 10 until 2 p.m. That was the original, or last year's late night transportation, as you recall. So in a couple of weeks, we're putting on a big festival right now, Lights. It's about 17 days from now. We'll take about 12,000 people and transport them up by gondola and by buses to Canyon Lodge and put on a great show, a show for our guests and for the town, et cetera.

1:07:05 And then we'll bus them back down and they'll go into the community at the Village and Whiskey Creek and restaurants and places down farther and they'll continue celebrating. And then at 10 o'clock the bus service will stop and they'll be walking. You know, our reserve community is about friends taking care of friends, right? It's about our guests and it's really on a 24-7 basis. We're promoting feet first. We're promoting responsible driving. We're trying to regain market share.

1:07:35 You know, that was the, you know, I know in the town that's one of the biggest issues is really trying to get more dollars, TLT dollars in it. So that to the ski area and other people in the community, that's trying to regain market share, grow visits. We want to be the most visited ski resort in the U.S. Ski Magazine gives a rating out. And we always rate high in lifts, terrain, parks, challenge, snow.

1:08:07 And we rate low, although it's improving, in access, operate ski, off-heel activities, including dining. Compared to other resorts, Vail, Beaver Creek, Aspen, Summit County, specifically Breckenridge, Frisco area, Steamboat Springs, Park City, Whistler, they run hours, lead nine hours, they end from 1.30 to 3.30. 1.30 being the Breckenridge area, Frisco is one.

1:08:35 The others are all in the 2 o'clock or 2.20 region for late night bus transit. And the latest one is Whistler at 3.30 in the morning as a closing time for their transit. I also looked at another one to try and find something that was a little bit lower, which Crested Butte was 12 p.m. And then I found something that was a little bit lower yet, and it was Big Bear. Their transit service stops at 5.30. So Mammoth would be somewhere right between Crested Butte and Big Bear.

1:09:04 Oh, by the way, Big Bear, they're closed on Christmas and they're closed on New Year's also. So I guess my question is, will this really affect the guests that we're asking to come back for one or two or maybe even three more visits? It was experience. Isn't that what he would expect at a resort with services that could allow him to do something other than just recreate on the hill during the day time? To recreate last year's

1:09:34 Services, I understand that it would be around $40,000. So that's my point, and I hope you'll take it into consideration. Thank you, Bill. And that $40,000, that was to operate from the 10 to 2, that's what you're saying? That's the 10 to 2 service, right, with those four hours. Okay. I was just going to ask that of someone else. Are there any questions with Bill?

1:10:03 That $40,000 pays from when to when? Well, like I said on 120 days, John's here and he could, you know, give you the exact amount, but it's right in that $40,000 target because we've already lost some days now going into winter and it was taking that basic 120 days for Christmas vacation. Thank you. Thank you, Bill. So you're asking not just for that one event, you're asking for the entire winter?

1:10:33 No, I'm not asking for the event of Night of Lights. Night of Lights is, you know, that's going to happen. If there is no bus service, there's no bus service and everyone's going to be walking around town. And that's just a reputation that we'll have to suffer with. When is that event? December 22nd. No, but when is it over? It's over, well, the last condole and last bus that we're providing specifically for the event is at 10 o'clock. It is at 10. Right. And that's also concurrently when the night time.

1:11:02 Services would stop the trolleys. So as a compromise, would it be acceptable to provide bus transportation that night until one or two and take it as an isolated evening as opposed to the evening? Well, given a specific case, that would be an important one and that would be something to consider also. That's still funding for a single night. But then starting then, it's Christmas vacation. Every single night is an event night to the visitors that come to recreate.

1:11:32 You know, we sit around that town, and we probably don't use it, and we probably call that the, you know, the drunks bus. Those that go to the bars, but those people are the people that come and spend, when they're on vacation, you stay out late at night. As workers here in the town, we, you know, we don't use that bus service, and we're not out that late. But go to dinner and have it be past 10 o'clock, and if you took a bus to get to dinner, you're going to walk home. Or you're going to take a taxi, and yes, taxi services are available. Thank you. Thank you, Bill.

1:12:01 I've also asked John Helm, Director of ESDA, if he could maybe address a couple of questions. Are there any of these concerns if there's possibly a way that we might be able to work around scheduling or something of that nature? You know, we're just on, as we all know, we're all on this limited budget, the mountain, the town, everybody, you know, ESDA. So I'm just wondering if there's anything we can do or what will it take cost-wise? And I just want to be able to address that since we're going to be talking about that.

1:12:31 Tonight's discussion. Right. My name is John Henlon with Eastern Sierra Transit Authority. As has been pointed out, our service this winter is reduced to ending at 10 p.m. We have historically the last couple of years operated until 2 a.m. seven days a week. This is a direct result of the financial challenges faced by the town and town staff being advised that there was basically a 10% reduction that was required for this current year's fiscal budget.

1:12:59 Town staff involved in the transportation program and ESTA staff discussed a number of different alternatives looking at the various services that we operate. We operate the trolley year-round. It's daytime trolley in the summer months and the night trolley in the winter. The purple and gray lines, community circulator routes. We operate dial ride service and we operate the lakes basin trolley in the height of the summer in July and August. All of those routes were looked at and modifications to all of those were looked at.

1:13:27 And what we ended up with was a reduction of an hour. We started an hour later in the Lakes Basin Trolley this past summer. We've paired back an hour a day. We've ended the dial ride service an hour earlier each day, seven days a week, through the course of the year. And we've paired back the night trolley service from 2 a.m. to 10 p.m. We were able, by doing those things, to leave the community circulator rides purple and gray lines intact and unchanged.

1:13:56 And again, we looked at a lot of different options. There were pros and cons to each of the options, but felt that this would probably have the least impact, although I will recognize that's a subjective determination. Was Bill pretty accurate, you think, on the $40,000 for the winter season? Yeah, to give council a little clearer picture, our hourly rate, we have a contract with the town of Mammoth Lakes for the transit service we are.

1:14:25 Our hourly rate this year is right at $40 an hour. So the additional four hours a night, there are two trolleys in service to provide 20-minute frequency. So that would be eight hours per evening and $40 an hour is $320 an hour. For pretty much the full season would be about 150 days. That would be $48,000. But we're already into December. If something wasn't implemented until...

1:14:51 Closer to Christmas. As Bill pointed out, it could be closer to a 120-day period that would be looked at for that. Okay. John, what's the number of new buses that we have this year? We have 11 new buses. Is it going to be 12? It will be, but probably not until winter's nearly over. All right. Okay. Thank you. Do you have numbers, John, on the ridership from 10 to 2 and from 12 to 2?

1:15:23 I don't have definitive numbers. I was just looking at some statistics from last year, just looking at trip sheets to kind of get up and the drivers make tally marks. The last run is typically, particularly on weekend nights, a big run. The ridership will tail off from 10 p.m. each of the runs until the last run. And we noticed, I think it was two years ago, we went from 1 a.m. to 2 a.m.

1:15:51 We expanded from 1 a.m. to 2 a.m. And the last run before 1 a.m. was a big run. And the last run before 1 a.m. the next year was a very low ridership run, and the run right before 2 a.m. So it's whatever's the last run. But it typically ratchets down from 10 p.m. until the last run, and that's a big ridership run. Just one comment. I think cutting four hours is a lot.

1:16:22 You know, Bill made some good points. I mean, just using that license example, I mean, 10 o'clock, the event's over, everyone's got no way to get around. And the bar crowd is going pretty strong, especially on weekends and holidays. So, I mean, if anything, I think some way to find a median, you know, cutting four hours is quite a big cut, personally, I think. And I missed the last test of the median. You guys probably talked about this.

1:16:50 Well, and actually, the decision, as I mentioned, was made last summer in response to the town's staff's direction to find a 10% reduction. Those four hours were made last summer then. That decision was made at that time. Got it. Thank you. Okay. Do you have the ability, the capability, does ESCA have the capability of doing a one-night run for this event on the mountain?

1:17:18 Just for those four hours? We do. We would have that capability, yes. Thank you. So, you know, we went out prior to the bankruptcy filing and essentially asked everybody that works for the town or everybody who has a contract with the town to take a 10% cut. That was, one could argue, arbitrary because it was across the board.

1:17:47 And so a lot of people who work for the town directly took a 10% salary cut. It sounds to me like what happened here is a 10% service cut as opposed to a compensation cut. Is that what happened there? Yes, it is. And that is the means that the Eastern Sierra Transit Authority had to achieve that cost savings reduction that was requested or mandated by the town.

1:18:16 To put it in another perspective, and I don't want to get myself in trouble and speak for the ESTA board, but it's, I do not believe that the ESTA board would want to operate the service in just the Mammoth Lakes community at a loss when the other communities are, our challenge and our goal for our system-wide is for each of our services to operate, to generate revenues to cover their costs.

1:18:46 I'm sorry, go ahead. I know it's jumping ahead, but within the attachment A2 that we're going to be looking at in detail, isn't there an increase in the estimated revenue for transit? Or is that not effective? Not really. Okay. All right. Well, I think when we get down into the meat and potatoes of talking about this,

1:19:16 I'd like to keep this somewhere on the surface so we can continue talking about it. I think as Bill mentioned, the area where we cut just seems so critical. I mean, if there was a different part even of the day or the season or something where we could make different, the scheduling of this is just, it's odd that we cut like the most important time of the day. We have drunk drivers on the road and we have, so hopefully we can readdress that later. If you're here, we might have a question or two.

1:19:45 Absolutely. I'll be here. And I would just point out that also in reference to Councilmember Eastman's question, there is a lot of flexibility. It wouldn't have to be an all or nothing. There could be different levels of service on different days, for instance, weekends or something like that. Right. And I guess that's what I was getting at. So thank you. Okay. Thank you, John. Okay. Oh, sorry, Stu. I did want to point out as it relates to the Night of Lights, the Town Council did award a special event transit fund.

1:20:15 Out of Measure U last spring. So those funds have been used for Bluesapalooza, Jazz Jubilee, and in the application that came for was the Night of Lights. So we've been working with the mountains. So we're looking at a supplemental trolley application for that evening for both the trolleys and the town buses and the mountain buses to staff that through those hours required. So once we get that application in, Measure U application committee is just going to review that application next week.

1:20:42 But, you know, there's sufficient funds viable, you know, for that to cover the Night of Lights event. So I just did want to bring that to your attention. Thank you, Stuart. Welcome. Okay. I'm sorry, did you bring to any question? No, I have a thought. I'll hold it for the discussion. Okay. I don't have a question. All right. Thank you. So what I'm thinking here, we have a pretty long summary of general fund financials that we need to go through.

1:21:13 And initially, I talked with town managers on a good way we could walk through this process, and I wanted to run it by council and see what they thought, but the initial thought was to go down by this line by line and take a vote on it as we go. But the only concern I have with that is that if we get down near the end and we do start making some changes, if we come up with a

1:21:41 With the shortfall, we're going to have to go back and vote on everything again, or a bunch of other items. So I wanted to see if council would be okay with maybe going down, noting the changes, taking just a base, I don't want to say a full-on vote, but get a consensus from everybody if that's what they're comfortable with, whatever the decision is, and then once we get to the end, vote on the whole

1:22:08 Plan, basically, at the end. I want to get to the thoughts of the council, and if that's a good procedure, or if you had some other thoughts. I'm okay with that. You're okay, Michael? Jo? Yeah, I'm okay with that. Yeah, all right. We'll go ahead and do that then, and start. So, Mariana, did you want to have anything you wanted to say here? It's up to you, Mayor. I think it's going to be more productive if you start going through attachment 1A. We did have a presentation, but the presentation simply walked.

1:22:37 Through the supplemental report. So the only point that I would make is there is a supplemental report was the updated plan that did not change significantly. The only significant change in the plan is the recognition of the two housing loans that are due back to the state in the years 2015 and 2017. So that's the only major change. But other than that,

1:23:02 We agree with your suggestion to go through attachment A1, which is the restructuring plan. And I also would recommend that if it's a pleasure of the council to go through the plan, line item by line item, or department by department perhaps, which is pretty much page by page, and if there's disagreement by the majority of the council with a particular measure, perhaps if that majority offers.

1:23:28 A replacement measure, that might work, so that you're not losing savings, you're replacing them with something else. Okay, and I don't know if we could just kind of keep a general tally of where we're at with this. I imagine this could become interesting. Matthew, though, I think, though, that one of the things we need to do before we talk about that side is make sure that everyone understands.

1:23:48 The recommended changes in the revenues because that's an important piece of it. That'll be the first item that we go through. Which is really A2. Okay. Oh, okay. Yeah. Yeah. But we have it, we still have it on A1 here. Correct. But I mean, we've got, yeah, there's. Yeah. And just one last comment so that we are on the same page. I assume that you wish us to look at the attachment A1.

1:24:14 From or that is part of the supplemental report because those are the most current numbers as opposed to that which is in the agenda. That is correct. Let me actually do this. Mayor, Council, I think to help you and the community. So yes, there is a supplemental report. It's relatively thin this time and it has involved in the very beginning the title of supplemental report regarding adoption and so on.

1:24:44 And I think what's important, and we attempted to outline this in the report, is on page four, handwritten page four, on the recommendation for the council and the community to understand that the council would be voting tonight on the resolution that is the same resolution that was attached to the regular report, so the resolution itself hasn't changed.

1:25:11 And the resolution, a summary of the resolution, if you would, is presented on page 4. The resolution would approve the restructuring plan, which is attachment A1. The resolution also would approve changes to the town's budget, and those are attachments A2 and A3.

1:25:30 And I think I should walk you through them in a few moments before you return to A1. So I suggest we go through A2 and A3 because that sets the context for A1. It also authorizes this plan to serve as the foundation for future budgets. And basically you authorize the five-year plan even though you only have a one-year budget. And lastly, and this is important, we would like to be able to return to you on a regular basis.

1:25:59 was reporting on how we adhere to both the financial and non-financial initiatives in this plan. For example, this plan, every department is charged with a number of tasks, everything from studying a volunteer program to using technology, and we would like to be able to report to you and the community progress of those tasks. Lastly, we also would like to get your direction.

1:26:27 And this was not my presentation, but I'm doing somewhat a concise version of this. If you go back to page three in the report, what we also would like to do, as Dave mentioned before, and I think this is important for the community to understand, this restructuring plan is only phase one. It is a very difficult phase. We're making some very drastic decisions.

1:26:49 We're going to be handicapped as the town to provide services. So the only way for us out of this handicapped position is to continue talking about how we're going to do things differently. In order to start talking about outsourcing, volunteers, discussions with unions and so on, we need to spend more time looking at every single department and their deliverables, their costs. And so on page three,

1:27:17 We provided to you the proposed schedule of meetings that will look at every single department and look at them in the context set on page 2. And page 2, the last paragraph on page 2 suggests areas that, or a template, so to speak, to view each department. So for each department you would look at programs, budget costs, positions, deliverables.

1:27:44 And comparisons of costs and deliverables to other jurisdictions or the private sector. So as part of your decision tonight, we would like to get your direction on what else, if anything, to include in the discussion of departments as we go forward with this process. So basically, your input or your reaction, if you would, a direction to us.

1:28:11 To the list on page two, items one through five. So with that, I could either take time right now to walk you through revenues and expenditures, or we could take a little bit of time and talk about the list on page two of the report. With your pleasure. Joe, did you say you wanted to go through A2 first? Well, yes, and I don't have any problem with the steps or the schedule.

1:28:41 That's in the agenda bill. Okay. I think steps might be a little easier. This is a supplemental report, so obviously not many of you had a chance to review the detail, but are there any immediate concerns or questions or comments on the items that we included on page two to be brought forward for each departmental discussion?

1:29:06 You're talking about A2, right? No, this is page 2 of the report itself. There's a list of items on page 2 of the report on the next steps that we would like to use as a template to review each department. It's the actual report, the cover report. I've got three different reports here. That's it. No, that's all right. I guess I've got so many.

1:29:45 All right, well, I guess, let's see. I don't have anything to add to the next steps. Okay. It seems thorough. Yeah, I'm fine with them. Anybody else have any comments or questions on that? Okay. So, all right, and then we have phase two, and I think Marianna explained that. So, after this, we're going to end up going through, we're going to have a number of different meetings where,

1:30:18 We'll be able to engage the community and really start digging in on how the restructuring will take place. So why don't we go ahead and did you want to go through what A2 first? Let me do A2 and A3 and I think that's going to set the context for A1 because A1 is based upon the numbers in A2 and A3. A2 shows a schedule of the general fund revenues.

1:30:46 It's comprehensive. It starts with your actuals for the last few years. It also, on the right-hand side, includes assumptions on the revenue growth for the next five years. And previously you approved the budget for the current fiscal year, fiscal year 12-13. That budget included revenue projections for the general fund.

1:31:15 In column labeled recommended changes to the fiscal year 12-13 revenue projections, the column that has bolded numbers and also shaded numbers, that's the column that we recommend changing from the approved budget, which is the column right before it. So for example, transit occupancy tax total. In the approved budget, you have the transit occupancy tax at 10.5 million.

1:31:44 10, 5, 7, 8, 7, 7, 4. We're proposing to increase that number to 11.2. Now, it seems like a large increase. We actually have done it incrementally. And we continue monitoring the numbers. We just had a strong summer in July and September where we received 400,000 more than what we projected. Your year-end estimate also includes 500,000.

1:32:12 Revenue from Enforcement. So that's going to be the largest increase of 700,000, almost 700,000, just on DOT alone. And not the entire 700,000 would go to your general fund because a portion will be recognized under MLT. We also recommended a slight change to the business license tax, again, based on the

1:32:41 So the actuals on TOT for last year,

1:33:10 A bad year, we're 9.8, and we're going to go up a million five to 11.2. 500 of which comes from TOT enforcement, so we're projecting a million dollars more, correct? Of actual TOT, other than the incremental TOT from enforcement. And it actually is, so just to say the same numbers, perhaps slightly different numbers, so yes, if you look at the column, this is a good column to look at.

1:33:36 Labeled November 2012 pre-audit actuals. These are actuals for last fiscal year. Yes, last fiscal year you ended almost at $9.9, almost at $10 million. Bad year, $9.9 million in TOT collection. Add to that $500,000 for TOT, you are at $10.2. Rounded, $10.2. Right. So we're proposing to go to $11.2, which is $1 million in true growth. So the best recent year,

1:34:06 Was 10-11 at $11.1 million. That's correct. And the, I mean, I don't see this as conservative projecting because the best year that I see on the page is 11, of actual, is 11.1, but we're projecting 11.2 in this upcoming year based upon the two items. One is a strong summer.

1:34:33 And two is the collection of incremental revenue that we otherwise have not collected in the past, right? It's not a conservative projection. It's a projection that we're comfortable with, but it's not a conservative projection. You're right. Marianna, I have one question to Joe's point on transit here, this $40,000 shortfall. On June 20th on the budget, it's $813,000. It goes up to $865,000, so there's $52,000. Is that...

1:35:02 Am I reading that wrong? So while with MLT, their contract actually requires us to send them a percentage of TOT and a full revenue from business license tax, so that's what we do. With MLH and ESTA, the contract is for a specified amount. So anything, any extra amount that we receive in TOT,

1:35:27 It stays in the general fund. And it's something that was determined based on FCI's and Fulbright's work. And we just continued that practice and all projections. But we do have the option to say that they are 1% they should receive it all. You have that option. It will impact you by balance. Yeah. So then to ask Rick's question a different way, previously our growth assumption for TOT for the current year

1:35:58 Was 5%. 5% plus 500,000. Right. And now we're looking at 14.1. Which includes 500,000. Right. So previously it was 5% plus 500,000 that would have put you was 9.9 at about a million. So now you're at a million three. Okay. The only problem I have with it is, and it's kind of along the lines of what Councilmember Wood was saying,

1:36:31 I looked back 10 years and looked at our revenues. I'm looking at our total revenues, and that's really, we can get into the details of it, but I think only three times in 10 years have we gone over $18 million. And the problem with that, I see, is that we're going to put a five-year budget out here, and then if we don't meet our revenues, we're going to end up right back here again, tweaking these things and going right back. And I personally,

1:36:59 I think we should be budgeting off of a very conservative budget just to plan for the worst case. And I think it's better that we end up having a few extra dollars than not having enough again and having to go back and, you know, try to talk with, you know, whomever to try to make cuts. And so that's just my opinion. I don't know what the rest of council thinks on that. Just make the cutting job harder. Yeah. We can get there. It's just, I think the town...

1:37:30 You know, any municipality, I think, has a history. You know, as soon as you get a nickel, you spend a dime. And it's, we tend to spend money that we don't have. And I just, I want to try to change that if we can. And perhaps the way to change that, there are two concerns. One is, TOT obviously is the largest revenue source, so we need to spend time talking about it. Previously, the projection, as Councilmember Bacon indicated, was,

1:38:00 5% growth on a bad year plus 500,000 on COT enforcement. We're quite comfortable with the 500,000 enforcement estimate. We think that we're doing a good job and we'll hit that mark. The 5% increase was something that we worked extensively with John Ernie on, so we were comfortable with that estimate. What changed between that estimate...

1:38:24 And today is the additional $400,000. So that's really a delta. But that's question number one. Well, let me add to that. So what changed is the $400,000 delta. Why $400,000? Because that's what you achieved in the first three months of the year. The first three months of the year. So if you assume that the remainder of the year is still going to stick with 5% increase plus enforcement, you're going to make your budget. So that's issue number one. Second issue is

1:38:54 If you get any other revenue, whether it's COT or let's say property tax or sales tax, I really would not expect anything on the property tax side. We just talked to the county and they think it's actually going to go down. But let's say sales tax. We believe that the way to keep us financially solvent and disciplined is to have a number of financial policies.

1:39:18 And we're going to be working on those and bringing those to you very soon. And those policies would address decisions such as if you have an unexpected revenue, do you spend it or do you bank it? And our recommendation is going to be you bank it.

1:39:33 When you say bank, you mean put it into a reserve account? Put it into a reserve, up until a certain point. Once you reach a certain point, then it starts. Which we're not anywhere near close to that. No, you're currently at about 5.5 percent. In five years, we are trying to get you to 8 percent. Your target is 25. Marianna, if I can, since we're still on TOT so that I'm clear, in the recommended changes column in the middle of the page for transit and housing,

1:40:02 The 865, 157 for each of those, is that a reflection of just 1% of the projected revenue overall? That's correct. So the result is that if we give housing and transit less than $865,000, which the voters have indicated they're entitled to, or at least the voters have indicated we're going to spend on the designated activities,

1:40:32 Transit and Housing. The difference between the 865-157 which you're projecting and what we actually give them goes into the general fund to fund other things perhaps related or not to those two areas. That's how currently the model works and that's how your structuring plan works right now. Your structuring plan assumes that you do not give to MLH or to ESPED.

1:41:00 Any increase in COT because they have contracts that are based on amounts as opposed to percentages of revenue. But we don't do that for tourism. Because their contract is based on percentage of revenue or full revenue. And all of those contracts, if I remember correctly, have 30-day termination clauses.

1:41:22 That's correct. So, and then, so back to transit, since we started with that, what are we giving ESTA, or what are we spending on transit as a whole, including what we give ESTA from the 865 that you projected? I don't have an answer. I'm not sure if Ray has, knows what a concert with ESTA is. John? John would.

1:41:48 We can get an answer to it very quickly. I believe that our contract for this fiscal year amounts to $680,000 to $690,000 that's in right in that range. All right, just under $700,000? Yes. Okay, and does the town, do we have, part of that is our administration fee, administrative fee, 4% or something like that?

1:42:17 That we keep in-house in order to do whatever we do related to transit? Well, so ASDA gets their contract apportionment and the 690 or 680 is after the 10% reduction, then we spend a portion on our staff and whatever is left goes back to the chair on front. Okay. All right. Thank you. Should I move on to other revenues? Yes. Sorry, Mariana. Okay. So business license tax, small change.

1:42:47 Just to make it equal to last year, we do not believe that there's going to be any drop-off from last year's actual property tax is actually going back to the budget or slight change from the budget, if you would. But if you look at the actuals for last year, there is a decrease and the assessments have gone down.

1:43:11 Again, we talked to the county just two days ago, hoping that there's something happening that will drive our numbers up. And no, the opposite is happening. The assessments continue to go down. So that's why you see almost no change from the budget, but a change from last year's actuals. Sales tax continues to decrease, but only slightly. It's only $30,000 on the actual sales tax and a slight decrease on the triple flip.

1:43:40 The analysis here is mainly done in consultation with HDL. It's a consultant that looks at our sales stacks at a business level, so the actual individual businesses, closures, openings, and so on, so we trust their numbers. Utilist user stacks, as you measure you, it used to be in the general fund, it's no longer there. No changes to franchise fees or interest, and interest is...

1:44:07 Almost non-existent. Can I go back to, sorry, to sales tax? Of course. Why would that not increase if TOT increased, based upon a strong summer? You would think that the actuals would go up, but the only response that I would have, almost a guesstimate, but perhaps educated guesstimate, is it depends on what the tourists spend money on, whether it's taxable or not, and whether it stays here in town or not. A lot of visitors to bonds.

1:44:39 Okay, non-taxable groceries. I think another thing that's happening a lot more is, I mean, hearing is, you know, retail people walking into the stores, trying everything on, then they get their iPhone, they take a picture of the tag, order it right there and walk out. So, I don't want that happening. So, anyway, okay. Admin services fee, not a large amount. The increase there actually has to do, it's a, the category doesn't.

1:45:06 Quite sound right, but that's where we place reimbursements, and we see the reimbursement related to a legal case, and that money actually paid for work done by BBK, so it's almost passed through, it's one-time money. Intergovernmental revenues, I am not, I think I'm 99% sure that this amount,

1:45:28 Which is similar to prior years, has to do with a very, very small portion related to more vehicle in lieu fees that we still receive after a substantial cut. So we thought the state would take that small amount. They didn't. It came in, so that's what stayed.

1:45:46 On the miscellaneous revenues, the payment from the airport, which is our last payment on the airport debt, the amount is slightly higher than what we anticipated in the budget. The hospital land exchange, so we initially in the budget assumed one payment and the payment is about $350,000, $400,000.

1:46:07 But last fiscal year, the two payments that they owed us did not come in because we're still working on the agreement. So those two payments now are added to the one payment. So now you're looking at three payments in one fiscal year. So that's why the amount went up, but it's just really a fiscal year difference. So those are the only changes, and really the major changes are in the transit occupancy tax that went up, and property tax continues to go down.

1:46:36 Okay. If you'd like, I can just very quickly walk through attachment A3. There are almost no changes. Attachment A3 has also some historicals but also five-year projection for the expenditure side. And this is only the general fund because that's the only fund where changes take place. And if you look at the second column, actually it's the third column, labeled June 2012 approved budget, that's what you approved.

1:47:04 In comparison to the next call, recommended changes, the only change that we're recommending is to MLT to pass through that additional TOT amount and everything else stays the same. Okay, any, Council members, do you have any questions on the expenditures? No, but I'd like to ask just one more question on the TOT. So of these increased projections, what's the actual increase that would be applicable to the general fund?

1:47:38 Not the piece is going anyplace else. So the TOT piece went up by $130,000 from the approved budget to the amended budget, if you would. The total TOT was increased by about $400,000. So that gain on TOT was $270,000.

1:48:01 Okay. And then it's already built into your structuring plan, so the numbers are already in your structuring plan, so it's not new money that we just found. Right. And then you said approximately 100,000 going forward, right, Mariana? Excuse me, 100,000? You said approximately 100,000 annually going forward in future years? For the future years, correct. From what you saw previously. Right. From the previous version. Thank you.

1:48:25 On attachment A1, before you start going through it, if I could mention something that I meant to mention in my presentation. If you look at page 8 of the restructuring plan, we are making a change here as it relates to the IT items. The previous version of the restructuring plan, the version that you have before you of page 8,

1:48:50 Includes the recommendation to basically outsource the IT position and we are currently unable to do that. We have been researching and have been hoping to reach a different conclusion and as of 3 o'clock today we were not able to do that. So the conclusion is we're not able to outsource for legal reasons.

1:49:16 And therefore, we are asking to amend the restructuring plan to eliminate the two line items that have to do with the IT specialist elimination and replacement with the IT contract. And to offset the loss of the savings, we're going to reduce the amount of money that we are going to send to IT in the highlighted line item.

1:49:43 Labeled Fund IT. So elimination of the line items labeled IT specialist and funding for IT contract which results in some deficit and that deficit is going to be taking out of the line item that is shown as a negative meaning that in addition to the budget labeled Fund IT placement repairs and improvements. So that's the only amendment that I wanted to make.

1:50:10 And we're available to answer your questions as you start going through attachment A1. Okay. Thank you, Mariana. Okay. So, with that, we'll go ahead and start with attachment A1, the amended attachment A1. And did we have any copies for the public back there? There are copies of this appointment. Okay. Okay. So, everybody wants to...

1:50:38 Follow along. We can do that. But we'll start with the general fund expenditures and kind of an important piece because this is the baseline of our revenues coming into the town. What page of the supplemental are you on? I'm sorry. Page one of eight. For me, it's one of eight. One of nine. Of the supplemental. One of nine. One of nine. One of nine. I think so. That's the old one. Hold on just a second. We've got three different.

1:51:15 Need to turn that iPad on. Got it. I got it right here. Well, the iPad doesn't have the electronic version of it. Sure does. Okay. Okay, so we'll go ahead and start with general fund expenditures and just to make sure we have the right one here. 1.847 million? For 12-13 projected surplus, yes. Okay. Got it. Okay, so with that, are there any questions?

1:51:44 That Council has on revenue or any concerns that they have. My only question, my only question, Marianna, is on the REU going down from 11.7 to 8. Is that accurate? That's correct. And the main reason, so previously, just to kind of keep everyone with us, the previous version of the restructuring plan,

1:52:06 Had us building up our EU reserves to almost 12% in five years. We're not able to do that because of the change that we made two years.

1:52:17 4 and 5 by recognizing the housing loans that have to be paid because that money has to come from somewhere. It comes from your RU. So therefore, you go down from 12 to 8 percent. Now, the money that will be paid on the housing loans eventually is going to return to the town. How many years that's going to take to sell those units, we don't know. 5, 10, 15, I don't even know what the terms of the loans are. Now, the...

1:52:45 The 218, that and the 100,000 going forward, I mean, that theoretically could go back to the REU? That amount has always been built in your numbers. That is calculated? Okay. Thank you. Well, so that for this year, for 12-13, we're expecting that we can put 250,000 into the REU? That's correct. Which really means that if we don't meet our revenue projection of the 218, then...

1:53:14 We're not going to be able to put anything into the REU. That's correct, but you do start with one million, a little over one million in the REU. Correct, we have some there. But if we go with the more optimistic revenue for TOT, what falls out, I have to look at what things would fall out if we don't meet those projections. That's an easy, well it's not an easy decision, but it's easier than eliminating yet another position.

1:53:47 So going back to the revenues, did anybody have a question on these? Everybody's comfortable with the $19 million, $215 million? Well, I think it's just important to make sure the public knows that the reason for that is the extraordinary receipt of money from the hospital this year. Right. That's correct. The $1.3 million?

1:54:15 I don't have that in front of me. And that's why it's so much higher than it otherwise would be. Correct. That is absolutely correct. Your budget was $300,000. You're going to get $1.3, but it's not extra money. It's just money that is delayed, that wasn't received the year before. No, I understand. Yes. But I think it's very important for the public to understand that. Right. And so going into future years, we're bringing it back down to what I think is a more reasonable level.

1:54:46 Which is more consistent, I think, with where we've been in the past. Quite honestly, I still think it's a little bit high, but I just really wanted to get everybody's feedback and see if they were comfortable moving forward with the general revenues as they've been laid out here. I am.

1:55:05 I am because I think there's a couple of things in here that we can delay a little bit, such as the IT, that we don't make the expenditure until we've seen what the February, you know, December, January, February numbers look like. We could always delay it, or we could recognize that we'd end up putting less into the REU this year. Okay. And, okay, well, let's go on down the line then. And I guess we can address...

1:55:35 The highlighted areas here. So we've got the repayment of Measure U subsidy. Everybody okay with that? Oh, yeah. Where are you? What's that? In the projected funding needs. I'm sorry. The 325? Okay, thanks. The settlement payment, I guess, we get that. We're done. Dallas, we're done. Reserve for RU, we're talking about putting in $250,000. And

1:56:11 Actually, before we go there, I wanted to bring forward this situation with housing here again. So in years four and five, just so the public knows, we've been presented with two payments that are going to be due. One is $396,000, another one is $343,709. And for whatever reason, as a result of cuts,

1:56:42 Whatever. The town is now being obligated to pay these. And this is a new basically 700 and some thousand dollars that we learned about a few weeks ago. Just so everybody keep that in mind. If we end up paying this, I want to make sure that it's a loan. And it's not something we're going to pay for because eventually when those houses are sold and if they get the money that goes back to reimburse the state where they got the money from,

1:57:12 I want to make sure the town gets that money if we end up paying for it. It doesn't go back to housing after we paid the bill. So I just wanted to clarify that and make sure that that's where we're going. It makes full sense to us, and we will record it as a loan. And just to add to what you said, Mayor, these loans are loans that the state of California gave to the town.

1:57:34 We didn't pass them on to MLH. MLH gave them to individuals, but the loans to individuals are for, I believe, a 30-year period, while the loan from the state to us was for a much shorter period. So our loan back to them is due now, but individuals are going to pay us back when their properties are sold.

1:57:54 Or at the end of that 30-year period. So MLH will have the money to pay us. And if we record these amounts as loans, then it should work for us and it should work for them. Okay, I just want to clarify that and make sure everybody's on the same page. And if I may, Mr. Mayor, because I don't want there to be a misperception. Let's be clear. This wasn't something that was just suddenly discovered. The town borrowed money from the state.

1:58:22 The purpose of the loan from the state was to loan money to individuals for down payment assistance. Those loans by the individuals will be repaid as they sell their units. It could be 30 years or it could be three years. Some of it has actually already come back. But since the town doesn't operate housing, instead it has formed an entity that it is nearly the sole funder of.

1:58:50 We, in turn, passed through, as Marianna indicated, the funds that we borrowed from the state to Mammoth Lakes Housing. And so it's appropriate for it to be categorized as a loan, but I think the important point that I want to make, which is important to me, is that this isn't a surprise, it's a timing issue. We borrowed, essentially, short-term money from the state, but we then loaned it...

1:59:20 Or gave it to Mammoth Lakes Housing to loan to individuals for long-term loans. And so the gap between the two is as a result of not all of those loans being repaid by the individuals. And so it's appropriately in our budget. I'm glad to see it there. It's not only we're being transparent, meaning it's an obligation of the town. And it happens in these later years as these two loans become due.

1:59:49 So the structure as you propose it, Mr. Mayor, seems fine to me. It seems appropriate. If money comes back to Mammoth Lakes Housing from individuals, that money ought to come back to the entity that loaned it the money. Okay. All right. Okay. Thank you. So we'll go ahead and move on down here. So let's look at the REU. We have $250,000 projected going in, and then we're taking some out.

2:00:18 Year two and putting some back in year three and then we have our shortages here. Is everybody comfortable with these? Yeah. I personally would like to see more money going there and maybe along these lines we have to go with these projections just to keep us on track but maybe just as a I don't know where we're going to be who's going to be up here in four years but it might be appropriate that as we get surplus monies I think one of our first

2:00:47 The priority should be refunding this REU or funding it just because if we have another year like last year and we're projecting and we're not being conservative with our projections, we better have a fallback plan. So I would just propose that that be a priority for us is refunding that REU. And I actually think when we approved the budget, we said that that was a priority, also getting more money back into road rehab. Yes. Because we have kind of set our priorities already.

2:01:17 Okay. All right. So let's move on down. So we don't have any other changes on page one. Is everybody comfortable then? Yeah. Okay. So on page two of eight. But supplemental, for the audience has the supplemental, it's two of nine. Yeah. Right. Sorry. I got two different versions. One I wrote on. Just want to make sure. One that I apologize for that.

2:01:46 We have three different versions of this. So, okay, so two of nine, we're going to go down to annual fund, stipends, uniform training. So basically we've set aside $25,000 to try to get some volunteer programs and others set aside. Is everyone comfortable with that? Yes. Okay. And while you're on that page... I'm not in light of... No, I wouldn't fund that. Okay. I heard today...

2:02:14 A very important funding shortfall for transit and I would take that $25,000 in very simplistic terms and defer it at least for this year and fund transit.

2:02:31 I agree with that, actually. And again, that's very specific, and we haven't talked about other things, but I simply throw that out as something of a discussion emergency. I'd like to find another 15 to fund all 40 of it, if we could. I guess we'll get on the list. If we get on the list, we might. Okay. John, what's your thinking? I'm comfortable with spending the 25 on researching volunteer programs. We've started that process. It has a...

2:02:58 And the only other comment I have since we're on that line just for clarification is that

2:03:25 It appears to me that the suggestion for the $25,000 expenditure is for stipends, uniform, training, and so on, as opposed to research and programs, which is what we're doing now. Right. And that caught my eye a few times as well. And so since we're literally within... No uniforms, you're saying? Well, yeah. Well, we're three weeks from being 50% through the year and still in the research stage. And again, I'm not... Oh, I see what you're saying. So that the reality is we...

2:03:54 We'll revisit that when we get to the end of the list. Yeah, we'll come back.

2:04:22 All right. Let's go to page three of nine. Any questions on this page? And by the way, if there are any members of the public that want to come up here, please come up. Raise your hand, speak up, and feel free to speak up as we go through it. And if there's something we already passed over that you wanted to talk to, I apologize for not stating that earlier. Okay.

2:04:55 Then I want to, let's go back, because I want to address these as we go down the list. Okay. Which page? On page 2 of 9 on the volunteer. Oh, done. Okay. 2 of 9 volunteers. And Jo will probably know this, because she volunteers a lot, but it actually doesn't cost you $25,000. We do that volunteer program at the Mono Lake Committee, that someone could come and talk to the people in charge.

2:05:18 of how much it actually costs, because I deal with all those costs, and Joe is one of our volunteers, and there's a lot of volunteer for interpretive programs, so I would say that money is kind of high. Okay. I don't think that you will be spending that kind of money, because there's a lot of programs you could follow that you could reduce that. Okay. So I just want to point that out. All right. Thank you. Chief Harper. Members of the Council, if I could just take a minute.

2:05:51 Obviously, we're opposed in the fire department to the big cuts for the law enforcement. My understanding is that we're going to have a period of time from 3 to 7 in the morning where we're not going to have any police protection, and that's just not good for all of us. We're going to be out on calls without backup, paramedics. We maintain a staff between the paramedics and us of six people on duty 24 hours.

2:06:20 We're on duty the whole night. Now we're going to have a period of time when we don't have any law enforcement backup. And there's still a lot of stuff that goes on. So we're opposed to that. We recommend that you find a way to partially fund the police department some of that 1.1 to keep 24-hour coverage. Okay. Thank you, Chief. One last thing. Rick, you had said this.

2:06:49 I had asked Cindy the question, is the money for the housing that you said that was paid back, you didn't say that it actually was paid back to the state, and I had asked Cindy if she said it was, so would that mean that as money comes in from repayment, would that be paid back to the state at that time and would lower these amounts? You mean the money that comes back from those that we lend it to? Yeah, yeah. No, it would come back to the town.

2:07:14 The town is responsible to pay the state the $300,000 or $400,000 that becomes due in years four and five. So as that money comes in from the people that sell their units, you're holding on to that money and it doesn't get paid? That's the suggestion, yes. Yeah, basically, so it's due and typically affordable housing would pay that money, but because there's budget variances here, they're short of money and we budgeted it in our budget. We pay it.

2:07:44 And then as they receive the money back from, let's say a house sells, I believe that's how it works, they'll get the money and have to pay it back to us. Right, so then you hold on to it with that potential. We'll pay the state as soon as we get the money. Yes, it would be a revenue item, but we don't know when it's coming in, don't it? Let me clarify. Some of these loans have been ongoing for several years, and some of them have sold. As soon as that money comes back, it comes directly to the town.

2:08:11 And it gets paid back to the state. So if any time up before these loans are due, any monies come in from a house being sold, we will return that to the state at that time. Yeah, that's a great point. Thanks. I guess the key is saying before the loans are due, after the loans are due. We have to pay the loans when the loans are due, period. But any monies that have come in for other loans that have been paid have been repaid to the state already. These loans were larger.

2:08:37 Earlier. So if a property sells and housing gets the money back, they pay the state, this number will be reduced? Yes. Yeah, sorry. I was thinking after the loan, so. So real quick, what about the, as a practical matter, as money comes in, is it re-loaned on?

2:08:57 No. They are not using this program anymore. It wasn't one of their best beneficial programs, so they are not using this funding source any longer. Thank you. Okay. And if we could, I want to stick to pages 1, 2, and 3 of 9, since those are the only ones we've gone through so far. Hi. I have a question on attachment A2, if we could step back there, because we didn't ask any questions on the general fund revenues by revenue type.

2:09:28 I just wanted to clarify which of these line items represents the fees that we as contractors pay, for example, permit fees, stuff like that. They're not here. Cindy, correct me if I'm wrong, your fees are not shown in the general fund, they're actually shown in the community development department's budget.

2:09:51 And so what happens is they hold on to all those fees and whatever is the gap between their expenditures and the revenues and there's always a gap, then we supplement that with general funds. So the fees are not shown here, but you would find it in their budget, which is online. Thank you. Thank you, Jesse. Rich McIntyre, I'm a community member. I would like to just state that I'm opposed to the concept of using a placeholder to reduce our police department.

2:10:24 Your function as a council was to provide public safety for us. In 1970s and 80s when I was here we had a deputy resident and he may have been on duty or may not have been, but we only had 2,500 people. We now have 7,000 or whatever and more than that in the wintertime plus our visitors. So I disagree with this method. I realize that the budget is unsustainable the way it is. I just disagree with...

2:10:52 Slashing the number of people we have to accomplish that. So I disagree with how you're doing it and just wanted that to be stated. Thank you, Rich. Okay, on pages 1 of 9, 2, 9, and 3 of 9, are there any other comments from the public? Okay. Then, Council, if we could come back to page 3 of 9, are there any questions so far? Anyone? No questions for me. I think it's well stated on here.

2:11:26 Okay. Is this appropriate at this time to make the clarification that we're not necessarily asking for the reduction of seven officers? We're asking for 1.1 million from that department, and there are other ways other than cutting seven positions to get to that 1.1 million? Yeah, I think this is a good time to mention that. I think it's appropriate, and if anybody else has any comments on that.

2:11:54 That is a good clarification. I think there's been some misinformation that we're demanding cuts of certain positions. I think there are other alternatives out there. Some within our control, some that are not. But basically, what's happened here is every department's been given a budget. This department's been given a budget to work within. There's a box to work within. And my opinion, it's...

2:12:24 Department has to come up with that solution. And I'm not an expert in this area. And I'm looking forward to seeing one. And I don't know what any other council members believe on this. But that's my opinion. I have a comment real quick, too. You know, there was a news media headline that recently stated that safety is not a priority to the town council. And I think, I can speak on all our behalf, that's the farthest from the truth.

2:12:54 We know many of the officers. We appreciate everything they've done for the community, past and future, and safety is definitely the highest priority. I think that, as Mayor just stated, that there's an opportunity in the crisis that's a different structure with the additional changes that our restructured budget can afford, and I think it can and will work in the community, and personally, I urge the POA to continue to dialogue with our managers. Thank you.

2:13:24 So while we're on the subject, just a couple of additional comments that I would like to add to Council. My view is that we are providing or we are providing funding for a department and charging that department with coming up with a plan to deliver

2:13:51 Not a lower level of service, but a different level of service. And I think there's a difference. And what I'd like to do, and I've tried briefly in the past and have not been successful in the last couple of months, is move the debate and the discussion away from the emotional argument, which is in part based upon people's view.

2:14:15 That if we don't leave the organizational structure exactly as it is, that we're going to suffer in some calamitous way. From that approach to what is obvious, and that is this is a budget discussion, and we're trying to approach the cuts that we must make in a rational way. One could argue that we're picking on the police department.

2:14:42 Well, one of the reasons for that is that we picked on every other department over the last three years, not hearing a whimper, as much as a whimper from the other departments. They accepted that which we presented, and levels of service either changed, they were different, or in some instances were lower. And this is a very tough problem. So let's talk about the numbers. I have the numbers for 2012.

2:15:10 With respect to what it costs for the personnel in the police department, it's $3.45 million. We are asking for a pretty dramatic cut. That $3.45 million, that's for the uniformed personnel, amounts to the least expensive compensation package, that is for the least tenured officer of $146,000. The most expensive,

2:15:41 At $289,000. And an average of $192,000. So in very rough terms, it costs $200,000 per police officer. That's what it costs the town. Now, one could argue, and I've heard in a recent very vitriolic email that it is I who approved this in the first place and how could I possibly

2:16:09 Take this away. Well, the truth is that I didn't because the last contract was approved before I became a member of this council two and a half years ago. That's really not the point. I'm not looking back because every time a contract negotiation came forward over the last 15 years, in fact, since the inception of our town's existence, those who were

2:16:35 Negotiating on behalf of the council, and those councils who approved those contracts did so in good faith with an eye toward getting the best personnel, being competitive, and fitting whatever the compensation package was within the budget based upon the community's priorities. We're still doing that. And the problem is that although the community's priorities haven't changed,

2:17:06 A huge part of this town's operating budget goes toward public safety. And it therefore has to, at least in my judgment, participate in a way maybe not exactly the same, maybe more, maybe less, as all of the other departments. I'm not happy about this. But it is not for me to say to the police chief,

2:17:31 My solution, Chief, is for you to not have an officer on duty from 3 in the morning to 7 in the morning. That's not my duty. It's not this council's duty. It is the duty of the department to determine how it wishes to organize itself, and that's the responsibility of our staff, our paid staff. The question about who should bear the brunt of this is interesting because what has effectively happened is that we've got a demoralized police department,

2:18:03 Who believes, rightly so, that they've given a lot. And by the way, the police department received in that last contract, which was done in May of 10, two and a half years ago, and I think Cindy will correct me if I'm wrong on the date, there were some substantial increases that were given, and the reason for that, as I now understand it, is that concessions prior to

2:18:35 Whatever date they got big increases had been made. And at the same time, what apparently the studies found was that we were underpaying our police officers from a competitive standpoint. And that their contracts were brought up quickly in order to make them competitive, which is the appropriate thing to do. I don't question the wisdom. I don't question the motive.

2:19:04 Of either the police officers or the town in entering into contracts at a time when the town could afford it. It's an affordability question and it relates to what priorities we have as a council for public safety among all the other priorities that we have to deal with. And so this isn't happy as a placeholder, but I'm not telling the police department to cut five positions.

2:19:34 At $200,000 apiece. Or seven positions. I'm not telling a police officer to retire, to resign, to go to another department. And I'm also not telling the police department how to organize itself internally in order to provide what it thinks is the appropriate coverage at the appropriate times in the seasonal economy. And seasonality happens within each week, not just within each quarter.

2:20:00 This is a heck of a problem. The other problem that I see, and then I'll shut up, but I was going to make these comments at the end, is this. Because I want to make sure that we're talking about facts. I don't begrudge a police officer costing the town $200,000. I don't believe the town can afford it today. Any more than I think that a public works officer who drives a snowplow, who costs the town $80,000,

2:20:29 I don't know that the town can afford the $80,000. And we've taken measures to reduce the budgets in that department, and that has been done, and I know, I know from clients that their salaries have been cut in order to save people, in order to not reduce staff. The police department itself, the police union itself, has as an opportunity the ability to restructure among their own. I'm not telling them to do it.

2:21:00 And I'm not judging them for not doing it, but I haven't seen it yet. We know that our last police chief, Chief Shinley, who retired out a couple of years ago, we know that this town pays Mr. Shinley, who's 51 years old, $159,000 a year and will for the rest of his life. He cut a great deal. Maybe he doesn't think it's a great deal. I think it's a deal that the town can't afford

2:21:33 To give to its entire police department. If we had $24 million to spend instead of $18 million, I wouldn't be saying this because we would be able financially to afford something. And so that's what this council is really struggling with. And unfortunately, in that struggle and in the decisions that are made by the chief, by the staff, in how to resolve this budget shortfall, human lives and families are impacted.

2:22:03 The community is potentially impacted. I'm looking for the police department to do what it can and deliver what it needs to deliver differently than it has before because quite frankly, I don't know where else to go in this budget other than where we've been. Enough of that. And just one quick comment too, Rick. You know, after the proposed reduction, we're still at $3.6 million, which is 23% of our budget. So it's no small pocket change.

2:22:34 Yeah, 23% of our budget, in my opinion. Jill? Matthew, I just noticed that under number three on this page, I think that we need to strike one word because it's my understanding that the direction from council is hoping that the Police Officer Association will participate in the solution, but I don't believe that we were saying that it would be limited to new officers. Yes, we are talking about

2:23:03 Implementing what is called the two-tier system, but I don't think that that precludes other changes that would be affecting current officers, so I'd just like to strike the word new. I believe our discussions have been the other. Okay. Yeah, please. Yeah, you've got the numbers. I got them from you. I hope I got them right. It's okay. The contracts that the employees have currently began in 2006 and 2007, and

2:23:40 At that time, there was a study done, and the reason, and Rick did try to speak to this, at that time, there was a study done and found that town employees' benefits salaries were below market by anywhere from 15 to 30 percent. So that contract came about to try to, because the town couldn't afford to increase salaries 15 to 30 percent all at once, they approved a four-year contract with salary increases over a period of time.

2:24:07 And then the extensions over time and concessions over time have come into play because of the market and revenues not needing what they should. And the other thing I wanted to clarify was we pay our employees PERS as we go. We do not pay them once they leave. Other than the PARS benefit enhancement, that is something that we will continue to pay any

2:24:35 Police Officer, as they leave, they've currently suspended that program, so their benefits are frozen to the current year, saving us 5% in what we pay on an annual basis. But just to clarify, the PERS is paid as the employees are working, and once they leave, we do not continue to pay for retired officers or any other staff.

2:25:02 Right, but yeah, and I appreciate that because that is so. We're not actually writing a check to Mr. Shinley. What we're doing, however, is we're funding a very, very large current retirement cost based upon what CalPERS tells us. That is correct. What we need to pay in order to meet the. In order to meet those obligations in the future. Thank you. Yeah, coming down, Mark. Good evening, Councilman Martin-Clapper. I just have one quick question.

2:25:29 Where do the police salaries sit in relationship to other California cities? And if there's any difference because of our location, what would that be? I have an answer. Does anybody else want to answer? Well, I was going to say it looks like Dave has an answer. Just in general, very general terms, not into detail, we did just an overall study between the cost per officer, between the town and the county, and my recollection is that

2:25:59 A deputy sheriff in general, including management and all sectors, is about $37,000 less per unit per officer than the town. At the county? At the county. What about the rest of the state? We didn't do the rest of the state. We just looked at the counties just as a neighbor who's in the same market, same set of voters, more or less, same conditions, and so forth.

2:26:26 But that's a good study. We are planning to do a study. And I'd add to that, Martin, in my opinion, it doesn't matter. We can't afford it. The other side of it is, you know, we have, well, I'll just wait. I'll wait until later on this one. I can quickly say, I mean, I understand that we can't afford it, but the net effect is they'll take jobs elsewhere. And it will cost us to bring people in.

2:26:56 That aren't already here available to fit the requirements. And in the past, that cost us money through housing stipends and all kinds of other deals. I agree, and there's a lot of impacts to it, you're right. And, you know, it stinks. I mean, I'm not agreeing that the dollar figures are, I think they're exorbitant, but, you know, I wasn't a proponent of the escalating rate back, you know, five, ten years ago.

2:27:28 Yeah. Well, I think another thing to mention, too, is a lot of other municipalities are failing for this very reason. And I'm not saying the police. I'm just saying because of their contracts, their structures with their organizations. And, you know, they're running into problems, and they can face it like we are, or they're going to end up probably facing bankruptcy, as you're hearing in the news. In other cities, their problem with bankruptcy is problems like this.

2:27:57 But as you guys are aware, my biggest concern is getting us involved into another litigation because we make a cut that violates a contract agreement. Well, we think about a lot too now. Thank you. Okay. There aren't any other comments. Yeah, come on up, Lee. Yeah, we're still talking on page three of nine, which is the police department. I would like to say that I am extremely involved with our council members at this time.

2:28:31 I feel like your heads are in the sand, you're in a bubble looking through your rose-colored glasses. Our police department are valued people, and your tone of your voices don't show any respect towards them at all. How can you want to work for somebody that has no respect in you? And you just, people like to feel valued. You don't understand these guys go out and they put their lives on the line every day. Like I told you, I had an officer tell me every night before he goes out, he says a prayer, hoping he comes back.

2:29:00 Jesse Gorman told you about the person on Lupin Street. That was just down the street from me that they tried to attempt to murder the lady and the police had the sense to know what to do. I mean, and then like what, two, three months ago there was two drug busts just down the street from me. Sierra Valley Sites, I'm very focused on it. They could live in Sierra Valley Sites. And our officers, my heart goes out to them. How you are treating them right now is when they go out to work,

2:29:29 How can they be concentrating on their jobs and doing it properly without doing a mistake thinking, do I have a job? What about this? And I got kids and I have home payments and I got a wife. I mean, you are putting so much stress on these officers and their health and everything. You're not thinking about the people. And my heart goes out to them and I just wish you would just, I mean, I can really explode tonight and I'm trying not to because

2:29:53 I don't think you're respecting them enough. You are cutting them back so much and not doing everything in every other department. It's like they don't even exist. You know, why aren't you finding a little extra money for them? People in town have been telling me, well, get rid of them. They all make too much money. You know what? You guys picked the price for them. You didn't have to. You guys are the ones who picked the pay for them, and now you're being Indian givers and asking for it back? When these guys put their lives on the line, our town needs public safety.

2:30:22 Without public safety, we're in big trouble in this town. I hope you guys stop to think about that because look at Rick Scholl. He was saying he didn't want an officer to come here if there's only two on the street because he doesn't want his officers to be in jeopardy. Does that mean anything to you, what Rick Scholl said? Or anything that the district attorney said is, please don't do this? Are you guys just like have cotton in your ears, not listening to people? People have told me too that you have insulted the people of this town with the survey that you did.

2:30:52 When 65% of you ask to keep our police officers anything before keep the officer, it's like our officers don't exist. Let's just get rid of them. Please, please, please think of the public safety of the town and our guests when they come here because I think you're going to be looking for a lot of lawsuits happening here pretty soon. Thanks. Thank you, Lee. Anybody else? Okay. Seeing none, I'm going to move on to page four of nine, no, five of nine.

2:31:24 Floor's a blank, right? Yeah, floor's blank. I wanted to make sure it was blank. Yeah. Okay, any comments on page five of nine? Anybody? Can we cut through with the page? Anybody from the public have a comment on page five of nine? Jesse? So, I want to thank you, Mayor Lehman, and also Dave, for attending our Mammoth Lakes Contractors Association meeting last month, wherein we did discuss

2:31:59 This permit technician vacancy as well as some possible proposed ways to accommodate that cut and also provide the same level of service. And basically I think we're on the same page at the end of that discussion that the contractor association will support whatever changes you make as long as we can still expect to receive the same level of service both in terms of somebody being at the desk for us to go there and meet with as well as

2:32:28 Permit turnaround time. And I don't want to beat this dead horse too much, but I do want to, I just want to give you a small example of what I just experienced with trying to get a permit myself. I'm an electrical contractor. I submitted a permit application on November 21st for a ceiling fan. I returned on Friday 11-23 to pick that permit up as I normally should be able to. Now, the only thing that was different

2:32:55 In this permit application than any other one that I've done, because I do a lot of them, was instead of Elena being at the desk, there was some other lady I didn't recognize. She obviously had no idea what she was doing. Somebody else came up to assist her. I gave them my application and my check, and I left. Like I said, I came back Friday to get it. They said, it'll be ready Monday. We came back. Actually, I paid somebody to go there Monday. They said it'll be ready in a half an hour.

2:33:26 Basically, we sent somebody else again on Friday because it still wasn't ready and they weren't able to get it on Friday, November 30th. I sent somebody on Monday, December 3rd to get it. They told me that they didn't have it, that they had given it to an elderly gentleman. And I asked the only gray-haired guy on my staff and he had never been to the town offices. Long story short is I got that permit today myself. I went there and Elena went and pulled all the permit apps until she finally found.

2:33:56 My permit for a ceiling fan. So it took 14 calendar days to get a permit for a ceiling fan that cost over $80. I have over an hour and a half of payroll out on sending employees there. That's not counting my time stopping what I was doing to go there and get it. And like I said, the only thing that was different here was the person I gave my permit application to. So Johnny has pictures and stuff of

2:34:23 Obviously, unpermitted work that was done at the Java Joint, which is right outside the doors of this and the town offices. There was a sofa there that people sit on that was burning from a receptacle that was melted and burned behind it because it was installed by somebody who didn't know that they had to ground the box. On that same job, inside the panel was an electrical breaker that somebody had taken and cut and hacked to make it fit inside the panel in there. And that's the kind of stuff that...

2:34:54 I see in this town when unlicensed, unpermitted work goes on. And my concern that I expressed before and that I, you know, hold now is that if it's expensive and it's difficult to get permits, people are just not going to get permits. The owners don't want to pay for it. The contractors don't have time to go through that whole process. And it's the small jobs like that receptacle behind the couch or that circuit breaker that was added in the panel that

2:35:22 People are going to say, well, you know what, I'm just adding a circuit breaker, or I'm just adding a receptacle right here. Why bother getting a permit if it's going to take me 14 days to get a permit to do something as stupid as CCC in the bank? So, like I said, I do support the fact that the town needs to make cuts, and like I said, I thought we were on the same page about service and stuff like that, and I hope that this was an isolated incident.

2:35:47 But it is what my concern is. If somebody doesn't have ownership of that position and I don't have a go-to person that I can go and say, yeah, you know, where's my permit and chase it through the process, then, you know, this is what happened, in my experience at least. Thank you, Jesse. And I think your comments are heard. I mean, it's not acceptable to wait two weeks for a permit, and you're right, it needs to improve.

2:36:13 I think as we go through these changes, there's going to be some hiccups, some hurdles, and just keep letting us know what the problems are, and we'll try to resolve them as we go through. And as you and I have discussed before, we'll try to get a lot of this computerized as well, so a lot of it can be done quickly and it won't require a person to oversee so much of it, but the feedback's very helpful. So thank you. Anybody else have comments on this page? Nope.

2:36:43 Okay. We'll go ahead and move on to age six of nine. Public Works and Transit. There's Transit. All right. Any comments here? Anyone? Changes? No? Okay. Anybody in the public have comments? Yep. Absolutely.

2:37:13 Elizabeth Truax, Recreation Commissioner. I just wanted to reiterate what you heard from the commission and from a number of members of the public regarding the proposed closure of the Whitmore Recreation Area. Recreation is a very small portion of our overall budget. You've seen the document that Stuart prepared showing the impacts of the proposed cut on our recreation program.

2:37:40 The park is utilized by our high school softball and baseball teams. You've heard from the 90 kids on the swim team. You've heard from the 7,000 visits to the pool and also about public safety. So again, I'd just like to reiterate that we would really like you to find a way to restore that funding. So thank you. Thank you. Donette Hustleton. I actually want to say thank you for all your hard work. You've actually...

2:38:13 Asked a lot of hard questions. And usually in the past that hasn't happened. And Cindy has come up a few times and gone over a lot of things. So I think that you're doing a great job with this whole budget process and how you have to restructure because you're thinking about it. And that's really important. I also have to agree with Rick. Usually we don't agree. But the whole spiel about the police department and that whole thing.

2:38:42 I have to agree with them. I mean, it's tough. And I have to say, I'm one of those whiners about park and recs. The staff might not be whining, but I'm whining that we need it. And so, you know, they've taken huge cuts. And to ask other departments to take it now, I think, is really important. So I want to point out that park and recs is taking huge cuts. And so thank you for all your...

2:39:09 And staff for all your hard work because I know this is very difficult because I do this for a living. To go back to Whitmore, I was a little disappointed at four because our town attorney, or not mine, but your town attorney spoke about the resolution. And one of the sections of that was talking about

2:39:28 That money going, not binding you in a sense. And you can correct me if I'm wrong, Andy, but it sounded to me like he was trying to put the language in that it doesn't bind you to put the money back to measure R for Whitmore Pool and the fields if you got that money in. And the examples that were brought up was, you know, last year you had a big snowblower go down. You've got to use that money for that. Some of it's got to go back into reserve. It's got to pay back vehicle stuff. There's a whole big picture.

2:39:56 Out there that you have to look at and to bind yourself to say to put that money back, it doesn't make sense to me. And I thought the language was great. Whatever your attorney decides that you need to do, that's what you pay him for. And he's a great attorney, so I think that's really important. John Eastman, you said that you don't want that money to come out of Measure R. You want it to come out of General Fund. But I went through your budget when it came out.

2:40:25 There's no money there. I don't see any money there. I'll show you where it is. Okay. If you can find it, great. But I was looking through this and I'm not finding any money and we're just asking you, you know, I'm asking that you use some of that measure our money until we can figure this out. And great if you can find the money and wonderful. But I couldn't find it. You have a really tight budget. That's what I just wanted to say. Thank you. Thank you, Donna.

2:40:57 Any other members of the public have comment? Okay, sorry. So Amy Cutter, local homeowner. So it's difficult when you keep moving through that people bring up things and then I want to make a comment on a page prior. So under the, okay, it took me a long time to find it, page two of nine, sorry, back under Dave Wilbrick's section.

2:41:31 You talk about the technology changes. So to emphasize, I think, Matthew, what you were talking about was computerizing the permit process so that regardless of who walks up to the desk and wants to look at the status of their permits, it's not like you have to go back to the original person that the contractor came and gave the document to. It's on the computer. It's automated. It may be a more streamlined way of doing the permit process.

2:42:01 If the Town Council is serious about that, then you probably should add that to item number three for types of projects you want to pursue in the IT department. So there's sort of this checks and balances, right? If you're saying in this department you want to automate, then over in the IT area, which is on page two of nine, you would then want to put that as a priority. That way you have a fighting chance of actually executing on something like that. And Mayor, if I could point out, on page two,

2:42:32 On page two, we did list a number of town-wide IT improvements, but on page five, under community and economic development, there is an initiative, a task number five, to research technology enhancements that are specific to community and economic development. So I think we've captured on page five. Just not on page five. So I don't know whether you want to just enhance that and say the permit

2:43:01 Automating the permit process so it doesn't get lost. Something like that. So that if the town is serious about automating the permit process, that there's a placeholder that hopefully it doesn't get lost. Okay. No, I appreciate that. And we're going to revisit it too in the next phase. So we're kind of just figuring out the numbers now. And then we're going to start going into some of the details of it in our next phase. Okay. All right. Thank you. Thank you.

2:43:31 I have a comment regarding Measure R and the pool. And, you know, I've stated numerous times I'm a strong supporter of keeping it open. I don't think there's any other money here. I think that if there's any other money here, we need to find 15 more thousand for the bus and buses. And then the rest of it we need to put back to the REU. I'm a supporter of utilizing R for a couple of years while we're working for a long-term solution.

2:44:00 I think that's the key. And that's, you know, that's my opinion on R. And I think that we should debate it tonight and make a decision and not come back to it. Okay. Jo, did you have a comment? Well, actually, I wanted to hear what John's proposal was. My magic proposal. The magician. John the magician. We currently have how much in road maintenance? 500,000. 500,000. That 500,000 isn't spent.

2:44:31 Until the summer months after it's been generated. So in my mind that is a pool of money that has some financial flexibility. The dollar amount that we're looking for the pool is...

2:44:48 Well, if you include the maintenance position, it's just under $190,000 for the current year and a little over $180,000 per year for future years. So it's around $200,000 a year. What I would propose is to use $200,000 of the $500,000 in the road maintenance fund.

2:45:14 With the anticipation, which I fully anticipate that we will have a surplus this year, just as the town has had a surplus, I believe, almost every other year in its existence. Last year in the down year, we had a surplus of a million dollars, in excess of a million dollars, I believe. We've already established

2:45:41 In this year's budget that we had a surplus just for the two months of July and August of $400,000. We had that surplus of $400,000 from July and August this summer because of the efforts of John Urdi and his organization. I recognize that and I appreciate that and acknowledge their efforts. And we're factoring that $400,000 in additional revenues into this year's budget.

2:46:12 I would anticipate and again you have to go back to last year and understand what went on last year. At this time last year from I believe it was November 20th to January 21st, a period of two months, we had zero snowfall for two months in the middle of winter. And yet from our budget

2:46:44 Our conservative budget revenue projections, we had an excess of over a million dollars last year. So I'm pretty comfortable, I'm assuming that with the early snowfall this year, the base on the mountain as we see it today, particularly the upper part of the mountain, and the fact that we had no snowfall last year for two months in that same time frame already, and we're only about two weeks into that time frame.

2:47:13 In that two weeks, we've already had four storms. And the forecast is for additional storms and colder storms at the end of this month. So I'm pretty comfortable that we're going to have an excess of, if not a million dollars, something in the hundreds of thousands of dollars in TOT revenues this year. So I would propose taking the approximate $200,000 out of our

2:47:44 Either out of our REU or out of our, not out of our REU, excuse me, out of our road maintenance fund, because we don't need it today, we don't need it in the next five months, and then in anticipation of a couple hundred thousand dollars or more in revenues, TOT revenues this year, making it a priority to replenish that road maintenance fund with the money that comes in from that.

2:48:14 Okay, but John, hasn't the road maintenance fund for this year's budget already been spent this last summer? No, it's spent after it's collected. No, no, no, no. What I'm saying is that you're saying borrow from next year's road money because it's spent in the summertime? This year's budget didn't we spend the road maintenance money over the summer? Yeah, I'd like to hear from Ray. I understand what you're saying, but I don't think there's any money there.

2:48:45 Yeah, and that's the issue. We did quite a bit of work this summer, and in fact, we're just finishing up some of that work. I would certainly want to check the balance in that fund before we committed $200,000. I think the balance in that fund might be right about that at this point in time, or slightly less. So, yeah, I would just suggest that we verify that balance, and I can certainly do that with Cindy.

2:49:12 And then the second part of it is presume that there would be more than the 14% increase in T.O.T. that we've just discussed earlier that would cover this? Absolutely. I'm not comfortable with that. Michael? The option for me is to either do it this way and the only other option is to do it the way where you're going to borrow the money from a tax measure that was not intended to use for that.

2:49:43 And considering those two options, I'm not willing to go down the road to prostitute the intent of what the voters did when they voted for that tax payment. You could split the deal and just fund the remainder of this fiscal year at about $90,000. And then our budget is analyzed and provided more information for next budget year, which is really the $181.

2:50:13 And what happens if things go south this winter and we don't have a great year? I'm not saying that we're, you know, I hope we do. Where are we at? Just so I understand. Yeah. I think one of the problems... I'm splitting the 90s, what my question is. Well, I think one of the problems is that we do this a lot. We plan for, you know, a good year, and next year we start shuffling. We spend all of our time shuffling money.

2:50:43 And it seems to me that if we plan... Because we're going to have bad years. This is one of many more to come. We had a bad year last year. I know. And we're going to have another one. Not this year. You don't know that. I don't know that. But my point is, if it's three years from now, it doesn't matter. The point is...

2:51:00 If we're planning for a great year here, we're going to end up pulling all this stuff back later. I think we have to plan for the worst year, and then if there's additional funding, we can go from there. I don't think you have to plan for the worst year if the indicators are indicating a good year, a normal year. We just got into December. I mean, anything can happen. We had a great year, I can imagine, a couple of years ago, where we started four feet of powder in October.

2:51:29 Come December, we had been snow again, nearly. So... I would love to elevate you to put more in the RU because we already depleted it all for the lawsuit. So I would like to put some money back in. I hope we have a tremendous year. You want to do that over operating the Whitmore pool? No, I'd like to operate it with R. That's the difference. Okay. Well... I have a comment. Yeah, we're here. So...

2:51:58 You know, first of all, where's Donette? It is true that we don't, you and I just, no, no, I'm not calling you up, it's okay. I appreciate your comments because, and I'm going to return one to you, and that is that each time you get up, you call yourself a whiner, but you have a suggestion. You have a proposed solution. I have said publicly, and it's going to seem, I'm sure, very derogatory to some people,

2:52:25 I'm not much interested in having people tell me what it is that we shouldn't do. I'm getting that in emails. God knows we are getting that in emails. But I am very interested in having somebody tell me how not to do it but then propose an alternative. Sometimes I agree with your alternatives. Sometimes I don't. But I applaud you because every time you get up there, you tell us there's a nugget there somewhere. So I do. I do recall. So

2:52:57 You know, fundamentally for me, I guess as a foundation, I am not in favor of rating tax measures for general fund expenditures. Now that's different from the philosophical argument about whether the language of a measure says that we can or can't supplant or should or shouldn't supplant. For me,

2:53:28 And I've been involved in a number of tax measures over the years. If you make a commitment, you need to keep it. The other side of that coin or argument is, no, no, we're in crisis and you do what you have to in crisis and we're going to stay alive. Well, I don't think that we have to do that in order to retain or to keep the spending for a very important program or programs.

2:53:59 As Dawnette knows, I came up through Parks and Recreation. I chaired that commission for five years, a long time ago. I know the importance to the community, and I respect it. What we did with staff when we said come up with a plan of restructuring, we did this as a council. We said there's two things that must guide you. One, there will not be revenue increases, meaning

2:54:25 We're not going to go out to the public and say we're going to maybe pay for this with a tax measure that we cannot control the outcome of because it has to be voted upon. And two, that we're not going to invade, or you, the staff, can't invade measures A, A, R, T, and U. That's what we said. That's why this is so difficult. Because we have money. We've got $2 million in U and R. And it's so easy for us to say, and the

2:54:54 Park to Recreation Commission capitulated. They said, if you have to, invade it, but only do it for two years, but try to find it somewhere else. So what John Eastman has said is, I've got a way to find it somewhere else. And frankly, John, I'm with you. Because I can't violate, I'm not going to violate, except to the extent where we have already violated by taking 10% away from everybody. I'm not going to violate that principle. I think it's that important.

2:55:21 My view is I would sort of tack on to or tag on to your point and say, well, if you and Dave, I like your suggestion about the $90,000, one could argue that it's a punt. I believe that it's more appropriate to punt than it is to invade the principle. And what could be done is to reduce the, you know, find the $90,000 from the

2:55:50 Road fund. Now understand all the maintenance for the road work has been done. We're coming into the biggest TOT collection months beginning right now, beginning this month for the next four months. So the cash flow is going to be there. It's going to regenerate that. Of course it will. So it's not a question of whether the money is going to be there. The question is whether you want to pull it for something that has a high priority. We've already reduced that down significantly. And my thought is

2:56:19 That if you were to do that with the understanding that we would revisit, obviously as we will, this again in this next budget discussion for next year, and at that point if we determine that the crisis is big enough and we do not have another place to draw it from, then consider the proposal that Parks and Recreation came up with today, which is to draw it on an interim basis against the Measure R fund.

2:56:47 That, it seems to me, is a pragmatic solution to a problem without violating the principles that many of us have been adhering to for a long time and without closing the pool and without laying off the person who takes care of all of our parks. That's the way I would go. Matthew, can I ask Jo a question? Yeah. Well, actually, let me ask Rick if I understand what you're saying.

2:57:15 Focus on meeting the this year cost, the $90,000 from the road rehab, not going over to next year's, just whatever didn't get spent this year. Right. And actually, I think I can live with that one because I agree with you that we should not be going into Measure R. I think that we would know by March or April whether or not John's

2:57:44 Spectacular snow year shows up or not. You know, I'm looking at my house is still getting rained on, not snowed on. I think that that might be... Fortunately, we don't ski at your house. Fortunately not. Nobody skis at my house, yes. I think that that gets us to a point where, yes, it is a stopgap, but I'm not willing to commit to the general fund that's not coming yet in new revenues, but I would be willing if...

2:58:14 The amount that we set aside for Road Hub this summer turned out to be more than was actually needed. Joe, I have a quick question, and you know the budget as well as anyone. I mentioned as a source of funding

2:58:30 The road maintenance fund. There's another fund, and I wondered if you think that that's viable for consideration, and that's our vehicle replacement fund. I don't know if there's any money in the vehicle replacement fund. I think we've already rated everything we can there. So there's nothing there. There's no unrestricted portion, and even if you touch the unrestricted portion, you can only take it as a loan, and that's what we did. And we're going to be paying back that loan for the next 11 years. Yeah. Thank you.

2:59:02 I think we're all kind of saying the same thing. I'm wondering if the only problem I think with relying on the general fund is if the monies don't come in and we don't make a decision that we can fall back on, for example, Measure R, we've got a problem. You know, because they're going to be wanting to plan on that. There's going to be applications in the future and whatnot. So, I mean, for me, I think as a placeholder, I would

2:59:33 I would say have the measure there in case we need it, but as a first priority, let's go after... That's what they're saying. Yeah. But what they're also saying, though, is that we must pay back if we use it immediately. You know, I don't want to tie our hands anymore. We've done so much of that.

2:59:49 I just don't even want to go down that road anymore. I think if we use it, we use it. We'll pay it back if we can type of thing. We can't do loans. I don't think we have to decide that. No, I don't think we do. And I think that the time when we would decide that is getting more information about what money might be available in that one piece of our budget versus knowing how much when they come to us with the measure our spring, our award process is to have at that point whether or not

3:00:18 We needed to reserve any funds. And another concern that Michael hit on is, you know, we have taken a lot of money on this RU. And, you know, now we're looking at, you know, we've had a few other things pop up, but we're not funding RU like we hoped we would. I remember when we got elected, one of the priorities was to fund this to 25% or something of our budget or more.

3:00:42 So you're going to be up for about four terms to get there. We had to deplete our REU basically because we had to pay attorney's fees. No, I understand. I get why. It's not that we spent it on anything else. Right. That's my point, too. I mean, it's been depleted and rated, so I'd like to try to fill it back up. We all would. And I think that's top priority. So just something to keep in our heads. You know, I wanted to mention as well on

3:01:11 On the REU is, you know, as much as I don't want to look back, Matthew, I know that you will agree, because you and I were in the same election cycle, prior councils were perhaps not told as forthrightly as they could have been about what was in that REU, because I remember when Mariana came and she said, oh, by the way, your REU isn't $4.3 million, which is what your budget shows, it's $1.1 or $1.3 million.

3:01:40 And three million just disappeared. It was just gone because there was a node in there. And so it certainly remains a priority for me. And when I was on the council some years ago was this huge priority as we were ramping it up in good times. So I'm with you, Michael, on the importance of the REU, but I'm also not willing to close a pool.

3:02:10 Okay, well, so I guess let's just come to some sort of concept. Oh, we got more people. I'm sorry. Yeah. Donna, I just, I actually helped figure the numbers out with Stu. I did all the calculations. And what they did is they took, they actually had excess of $54,519 that they're putting in the savings. And if you decide to go down that path and then you have to fall back on it,

3:02:39 Possibly you could suggest that you take that $185,000 and also bank it in case you need to fall back on it. And if you don't use it by a certain time, then you can release it back into the spring award, possibly. Because what they did is they did defer $60,000 over to the spring for a raise, stuff happening for next year so they could put some money in the bank, which is a good sign because that means you're trying to save towards a bondable for your multi-purpose. Hi, Amy Cutter.

3:03:13 So a couple things. One, I appreciate the fact that some of you are concerned about barring against future funds or rating accounts too far out into the future. I appreciate that. Obviously, though, if there's road work where you're not going to use that money. So, Jo, when you were talking about this year, did you mean...

3:03:36 City year through June 30th or end of December? No, fiscal year because they already had an allocation this past summer for all the road rehab projects, which I guess summer includes November. Well, right now it includes December. Okay, so that's the one comment I want to make. Second comment I'd like to make is, I think Matthew and maybe Michael have mentioned it, is in terms of the revenues, I think it would be good to

3:04:06 Drop the projections. This whole notion that, you know, this year's a bad year, so next year's going to be, or sorry, last year was a bad year, so this year's going to be a great year, I think is a little too optimistic, and that we should be planning based on a more average year, not a super great year, not a horrible year, but maybe, you know, 60% or 40% somewhere in there of a great year.

3:04:35 Something like that. That way there is a philosophy out there is wherever you look is where you're going to go. So if you're riding a bike and you look off to the edge of the road, that's the route you're going to take. So if you set your sights on revenues in terms of a budget at a lower number, that at least if you go past that, you're going to have extra. And I think Matthew has mentioned that more than once this evening. And that gives you a little more buffer.

3:05:05 That would be the other recommendation I would make. Thank you. Thank you very much. Elizabeth Truex, Recreation Commissioner. I just wanted to bring it to the council's attention that it's counterintuitive as it may seem. The decision about the Whitmore area is, in fact, time is of the essence because we have been told by Rich Bacha, the school superintendent, that essentially the softball and baseball seasons would need to be canceled by February. They're already.

3:05:37 Trying to move forward with those. And I also just wanted to say that if it is not the pleasure of the council to find this money in the general fund, that is why the commission included that language in number six in terms of if we do have a surplus, if we do have a good year, we know we just came off a very good summer, that if the council does end up voting to use our funds, that money could be restored to those funds if there is a surplus. Okay. Thank you, Elizabeth.

3:06:08 Okay. So I guess I want to come up with some sort of decision as we give staff direction on this item. I think what I heard the summary was to determine if there is remaining funds from this year's road rehab that could be transferred over. Okay. And I don't know whether that is something that...

3:06:35 I think we can say come back to us if that doesn't balance out this year's. But I also heard us saying that after we get through our big TOT months that we still know we've got to make a decision about the pool's funding for next year. Well, yeah, but you've got to remember there's an ARCS maintenance person in here too. Correct, but I'm saying I think that what we would be doing is saying that we would be

3:07:02 Because in reality, if I understand it, the park maintenance person, you know, if there's only 30-some thousand, we can at least bring that person along for a while because we won't actually do the pool operations until the summer. Councilmember Bacon, if I may suggest, I think you said it just a minute ago, and that is...

3:07:27 If your direction to us, just on this year, I still would like for you to give us more direction on future years, but for fiscal year 12-13, if you give us direction to take 89-830, which pays for the pool and the maintenance person out of road rehab budget, if that's your direction, and then add to that, if the money is not there in the road rehab, then we return to you. So if the money is there, we don't return to you, and we continue with this decision.

3:07:56 Yeah, that's what I was trying to say. Thank you for being so succinct. So you want them to come back to Council for additional funding later? No, I think that we could solve this year's problems apparently with what was left and not expended in road rehab. On the other hand, road rehab in future years, I'm not willing to say we would continue to take it from road rehab to the pool. But it gives us time in future years.

3:08:25 To work on that because there are certain things in this resolution that I would not be willing to sign at this point and one of those was that number six is because we've already said we have certain priorities. We'd already talked about increasing road rehab because in the long term it costs you more if you don't do it. We talked about increasing the REU and so I can't be comfortable with saying that money that comes is going to be used only for Whitmore Pool.

3:08:53 So I think we can, and it is a little bit of a delay. It's kicking the can down the road a couple of months saying we still have to figure out how Whitmore Pool gets funded in the future, and it's my feeling we have to decide that before the Measure R spring award allocation is determined of whether or not we need to hold some back. We'll know in January what our...

3:09:18 Our projections are going to be on TOT. Yeah. But do we want to add that if we do take this money from road maintenance to fund Whitmore Pool, that when and if the revenues for December or January come in above projected that that money be spent to replenish that $90,000 that were taken from road maintenance?

3:09:44 I'd rather say that we revisit it when we do our mid-year budget adjustments in February. I agree. Which timing will be the same anyway. Or we use it from R and then put the money back in R if we have much success money. I'm not willing to violate the principle. I mean, I personally think recreation and R, I mean, I understand you guys' political commitment, but personally, I mean, I'd rather take the conservative road considering our...

3:10:12 The school. Well, and in a way, it is a conservative road, because what we're saying is, tell us how much money was left that was already budgeted in a different department, and instead of, quote, wordy the year, and it's saying, oh, goody, they had a surplus, it's saying, apply it now. And also, the option that you've described remains open. Because there may be a point where the crisis is so large,

3:10:37 That we, that the political commitment, that it is appropriate to violate that commitment. I'm just not, I'm just not willing to, this council may, may decide to do that, but the point is that the option, the option's still there. I'm just saying, I mean, we could put it to bed now, and I mean, I understand everyone's point, but. Yeah, and I tend to agree with you on this, Michael. I just think that, you know, we're trying to put together a five-year plan here and stick to it.

3:11:06 And for me, I just assume make a decision one way or another. Personally, I would feel comfortable saying we'll use R as a placeholder. If there is additional funds in the general fund, then we'll use those or replace R, whatever the timing is on that. But I just think that why do we have to keep shuffling all this money around? It just seems silly to me. It's whether you're going to do it or we're not.

3:11:34 At some point, there's going to be a shortfall. There's not going to be a shortfall on anything. You can just take it from the general fund as we need it if it's there. So I personally agree with Michael on this one. But Joe, you said you were comfortable just using general fund money. I was comfortable if there's a look at...

3:12:03 Starting the direction with saying if there is excess general fund from the road rehab for the current year to pull it over while we work this out a little bit further. And yes, I see that R might be on the table in the future, but I don't think we're quite there yet. It also gives an opportunity for some of those other, I can't remember the words right now, you know, some of the other options, grants, et cetera, to be pursued a little bit further.

3:12:31 And it would be great if the community could come back and say, hey, you know, the number's a little bit lower because we've found another funding. And so it sounds like you're essentially in agreement with John and Rick on this, basically use the general fund, forget about R. For right now. For now. I agree with you, though, that long run, even, well, even for me, two years out of measure R was not a solution either. Because if you don't have something that makes it sustainable, it just can't go.

3:13:00 I just hope that we don't have to constantly revisit this thing. I want to just get it done, make a decision, let's move forward, and we can let staff work on all these other things that we need to work on over the next year. Because otherwise, we're just going to keep coming back and take a computer to pay Paul, and we just spend many hours going around. But this is one item, so if there's a consensus, it sounds like, to go forward with yours and John's.

3:13:25 Do you need a consensus or do you need an actual motion and a vote? Well, we'll come back and do all of it at once, I think. Once we outline exactly what it is we want, we can do it in one vote if everybody's okay with that. But it would be helpful for us to know where you are right now. We heard clearly that on 12-13 we use 89-830 from road maintenance unless it's not there and then we return to you, but the decision is to use it from road maintenance. For future years, I think what I'm hearing is

3:13:54 We will defer that decision and what would be helpful for us to know is until when. Is it next meeting? Is it the first meeting in January? When are we going to revisit the decision? I think we're trying to mid-year budget. Yeah, which is February? Which I believe would be February because by that time we'll have a better idea of the TOT. And the mid-year budget is going to be for the current year? Correct. We still will have to deal with how we're going to fund it in future years.

3:14:19 So how does she plug it in, though, if there's no general fund monies there? I mean, how does she plug this in right now? Well, in reality, it would show balanced, it would be funded this year, and it would essentially be an additional liability that we don't have covered for the following year. That's correct. So the direction that I'm getting is for 12-13, we'll reduce your road maintenance budget.

3:14:48 And the remaining amount by 89-830. We would reallocate that amount to public works and recreation for the maintenance position and the Whitmore pool, therefore retaining the maintenance position and keeping the Whitmore facilities open. For future years, for which you don't still have the budget, but we still need to have the five-year plan, we will return to you at the time of the mid-year review for the current year in February and make that decision.

3:15:14 Correct. And that's also presuming that the measure, our fall award would not come, excuse me, spring award would not come before the mid-year budget because they kind of go together. Well, the other thing is, you know, the bigger potential problem is that if we have, in fact, overstated revenue projections, the mid-year budget review is going to be focused on that and we're going to have a lot more difficult.

3:15:42 Additional difficult decisions to make if we're not meeting those budget projections. We're going to know by February what happened in December and January and can project what's going to happen in February in those next months. I think that's why we should project for lower revenues. Well, I'm happy to do that, Matthew, but tell me where to come. Well, and Ashley, Matthew, I have a comment when we get a couple of more pages down of something that I think we can...

3:16:11 Fund, but delay actually spending the money on. I guess my point is, Rick, I don't want to assume, I am optimistic like John is, but I don't want to budget for it, because I just assume budget for a mediocre to bad year. Philosophically, I'm with you. And we produced...

3:16:34 In the eight years that I was on council some years ago, eight surpluses. Because we budgeted conservatively. But that's not the case now. And so I'm certainly with you philosophically. But a budget is just a budget. It's just a projection. And it's dynamic. And living is going to change from time to time, maybe month to month. And this is just something because it's so tight that we're going to have to continue to

3:17:00 To live with. And so while we want to project out a year and two and three and five, it's not terribly useful. It's inaccurate. We can't attain the degree of accuracy that I would like. Okay. Well, we've got, it sounds like, three people that are in favor of doing this. So, Marianna, I think you know where to go with it. Okay. So let's look at page seven of nine.

3:17:31 I think we really already discussed all that. So on page 8, I would ask you to keep in mind the revisions that we made to the IT specialist position, basically not outsourcing it, and that will impact your IT placement line item. Instead of having 85,000 added each year, you will have

3:18:00 64,000 added in the current year and 28 going down to 19 added in future years to the baseline of 65. Okay. Any comments to the council members? None. Anybody from the public have comments on page 8 and 9? Okay. Seeing none. Oh, yeah, I did. This is my comment is that on the IT replacement repairs and improvements,

3:18:31 We recognize that we need to do it, but I'm wondering if this is one of those items that we could say, yes, we want it in here, but not actually make any of the purchases until we see the December and January TOT. So you'd still spend the money this year, but instead of spending it in January, you might not start purchasing things until March. Okay. Just as a...

3:18:59 It's small, but that plus knowing that we may or may not be able to put money into the REU helps us with offsetting those more optimistic TOT revenues. Maybe we need to spend it on a new microphone. That too. Right now. Yeah. I think RIT needs some help, and I think... And I'm just suggesting a couple months delay. I'm not saying, oh, it definitely needs help. It definitely needs help. Well, I think, again, this is probably a philosophical question. Actually, maybe not.

3:19:31 The money, I think, longer term that we spend here is going to save us five times what we spend on it. Having spoke to someone that came here and looked at it, I mean, it's not a matter of buying a lot more computers and wires, it's buying great software. And it's teaching people how to use that software. We just talked about planning a minute ago. We were paying employees to be there, and these folks could be getting online and doing this from their offices, coming in and the permit's ready, let's sign it and move forward.

3:19:59 You know, the efficiencies we would gain from it, I think, are exponential. So I really think that we need to consider funding this far more heavily than we are if we can. And when I say far more, it's probably doubling it, which is, you know, $25,000 or $50,000. And what that will do, that will probably gain us the ability, you know, in TOT enforcement to gain hundreds of thousands of dollars possibly.

3:20:28 And I totally agree with you is that, you know, we have floundered and fallen behind for so many years that technology will be one of the ways that gets us out of this. I was just saying a couple of months delay so that we're sure the revenue showed up. Because, well, gee, $85,000, isn't that just about what you were hoping to spend on the pool? You know. Okay.

3:21:00 Yeah, I just wanted to come back around on that topic. So if you bring up the permit situation that Jesse was talking about, if you end up having three employees trying to find one permit, the labor spent trying to find it, I mean, we all know about automation, and so I think as your, I get the point about delaying the dollars, the spend of the dollars, until later in the year, but then you need to offset it and look at

3:21:29 Okay, what labor is consumed, meaning you're spending labor dollars looking for something that if you automated you wouldn't have to spend those labor dollars. So it's just a thought. And also making it self-service. I mean, that's a great idea. That if you can do that sooner rather than later, then you save all the contractors and as well the employees in town, the town offices looking for these permits. And that's just one example. Thank you.

3:22:02 John Urdi, Mammoth Lakes Tourism. Just a word of caution, when you're talking about the projections for winter, keep in mind that December, we won't even have those numbers really until about February 15th for December, so January, March 15th. So it's going to be hard to really get that other than some of the tea leaves that we can get out there talking to some of the bigger properties and how they did during certain months, but to get the true numbers and then also when you start to look at the quarterly true-ups, that changes things as well.

3:22:30 Just keeping track of that. Yeah, but the majority of the big remitters are on the monthly basis. Correct, but they're not due until the following month. So December isn't due until the end of January. So we don't really get the numbers until about mid-February. And I think most of them hold on to their money as long as they can. So it's not like they – we're trying to push that back. We are trying to change the remittance times so that we can actually get the data because it helps us just like it will help you to know what's coming in.

3:22:59 Efficiencies, John. Efficiencies. And the projections. Well, in the computerization, we can track the pacing so we can actually look out six months and say, okay, we're looking good here. It's just going to help fix those problems. Well, with the TOT software that we're working with, we should be able to get real-time 70% reporting. We have X number of dollars in pacing. So I think we've got some good opportunities, but just a word of caution. Thank you. Okay. Moving on.

3:23:33 We're on page 9 of 9. Are there any other questions here on the final page? I think that one's just a repeat of stuff we saw up above. I'd like to go back to 2 of 9 where we were talking about finding the money for transit. And I realized when Bill Cockcroft was making his initial estimates of the 40 or 48,000,

3:24:03 I think that I would want to ask John Helm if there's a way to creatively staff having the night trolley be during our peak times in our weekends and fit it within that 25,000 that had been put there for uniforms, et cetera, that we may not realize this year. You know, in other words, they're saying is if you had 25,000,

3:24:31 Would you have a way that you could increase the night trolley hours on peak times, which is all of Christmas and big weekends and things like that? Do you think you could work out something? Would you be able to staff something like that? Yes to both questions. We could staff that. That's what I mentioned earlier. There is flexibility. A solution can be worked out. So that is a possibility. And 25,000 in quick mental math would be.

3:25:05 Okay. Sufficient to cover holiday and weekend periods. I don't know if we need an inconsistent trolley system. Well, my only thought is we didn't find any other place to find the rest of the money. Well, I propose if we take 20, you know, if we get 25,000 out here to go to Mount Skier with 15,000. He's still here. Mike. I mean, they need it. We need it.

3:25:37 I mean, we're pulling out $25,000 that we didn't have. So, I mean, it's worth having a discussion. Well, I think this kind of goes back to the problem, though, with the measure money. If there's extra additional monies here, we can stick to our plan we're trying to create, what we've been talking about for two months. Well, and it sounded like the Night of Lights in particular was potentially Measure U. So we're really just talking about a way...

3:26:04 To deal with the trolley service. Because I can't see adding the trolley service back on on a quiet Tuesday just to have it. And I think that's a good point. You know, it's mobility. Yeah. It is mobility. I think if it's going to have that strict of an impact on our visitors here, let's take it from an appropriate source or at least apply for it. But it's a timing issue, too. John's going to need some lead time. Yeah. Yeah.

3:26:34 The inconsistency, I mean, I made the mention, too, of the holidays and weekends, but, I mean, as I think about it more, I mean, are we open for business? Are we not? Are we open for business seven days a week? Well, and I can see us committing to 25, and, yeah, you can go ask Rusty for the rest. I mean, I agree. I agree? Yeah. So is that... So we have 25, we need 15, I mean, right? You may not need 15 because, as John said, the 40 was for...

3:27:04 The entire season, and we're partially into that season, so, you know, is the number, is it 30,000? But what about future years, though? I mean, we have to consider the year after. We're not planning just for this year. We're doing a five-year budget now. At this date, will you take the first year of that five-year? What do you anticipate, then, since we already started? What are you anticipating not being the 40? What do you think is the number to go?

3:27:32 Well, and again, the estimate of 40, that's 125 service nights. If you, the thing I just calculated is if you started the Friday night before on the 21st of December before the holiday weeks really start and ran through April 21st when they project Canyon May Close, that's 122 nights. So that's roughly that. Except that we know that on a Tuesday,

3:28:03 Other than in a holiday, the mountain's got 1,500 skiers on it instead of 20,000. Is it that important to find $15,000 that we don't have in order to have service seven days a week and five days a week for those four months, you're down to maybe 90 days, I don't know.

3:28:29 Okay, so essentially what we're saying is take the $25,000 on A1 in the 12-13 budget and apply it to night trolley service.

3:28:56 And then Michael's, that's what our direction is, and then separately Michael's going to go with his hand out. And one thing, I have a problem with this is that, you know, we have this volunteer program we're trying to get into effect, and it's gone now. No, no, this is annual funding for stipends, uniforms, training, etc. So how are we going to train them? Well, because we're going to have to figure it out over the next six months, it goes into effect the future year, and yes,

3:29:25 That means that we don't have night trolley service funded next year, but we can still look at some options for that. And then just to make a comment is that I'm hoping as our years get better that we can get to the point of making sure that all of the money out of measure T and A

3:29:51 The 1%, whether it's things staff is doing or going through to ESTA or Maniflex Housing, that hopefully we'll get back to that someday. Even though that's a little farther off. We were just having a private conversation trying to figure this out for you. Do you have a solution? Yeah, we do. We have a solution. You know, if you say you're going to be open certain times and not open certain times, no one's ever going to know when you're open, right? So if you advertise that you're only open from Thursday,

3:30:20 To Monday, and you're closed on Tuesdays and Wednesdays, and you let the public know, then it's always consistent, and you're saving money. At least two days out of the week. Well, I think it's good for the local, but the problem is the visitor. We've got to advertise that. Somehow we've got to advertise that. It gives an experience different for a visitor that comes on Tuesday than it comes on Saturday. I mean... It's a thought, you know, I mean...

3:30:47 It's a way of saving them. It sounds like we have direction for staff on that. And then, John, you're in favor of taking from R. Okay, so...

3:31:16 Do we have to approve? You need to approve the resolution. Okay. Okay. Hold on a second. Oops, I'm on the wrong one. Jo, do you want to read it off? Well, okay, you mean reiterate the changes and then do the motion? Sure. Okay. So what I have gotten down in my notes is... Let's do it by page again. Yeah. It is on page two of nine. We...

3:31:49 Deleted the annual funding in this year for the volunteer stipend uniforms, etc. And somewhere there's going to be another line that adds that into ESTA for night trolley service. On page 3 of 9, on number 3, striking the word new in front of officers. Correct. On page, well, I don't know if it's 6 of 9 or 7 of 9.

3:32:19 But essentially that as Mariana previously stated better than I that we would find the 89,830 for this year from road rehab or come back to us and that we will also revisit it at mid-year and we recognize that we do not have it funded in future years.

3:32:45 I think that's the same, and I guess I should say that we recognize that we do not have night trolley service funded in future years at this point. Okay. So, based on all of that, if I can find the right page here. And then the measure... Yeah, because we did not... Wait a minute, I'm trying to find the page that's got the motion. Number three, I think. Oh, I'm reading page four. Yeah, I was getting there. So, okay. So, I think we ought to... Well, okay, so then the...

3:33:22 The resolution approves the restructuring plan as amended in attachment 1, approve changes to the town's fiscal year 12-13 budget as amended to reflect the recommendation recommended in A1, 2, and 3, authorize the restructuring plan to serve as a basis for future budgets beginning with I think we're okay on that.

3:33:45 And then direct the staff to provide regular reporting on initiatives listed in the restructuring plan and adherence to the new fiscal plan outlined in the restructuring plan. I think that's it. I'll second that motion. So how do we vote for discussion and not support what I'm not supporting? Yeah, you would have to say...

3:34:19 Okay, so, Matthew, under discussion, if I may? Sure. I wanted to make a general comment this evening as it relates to our restructuring plan for the town. My comments are saddled with the federal court's mandate to pay Terry Ballas, et al., an unjustified amount of tens of millions of dollars. So it stopped rattling. Get the electrical contractor to help us.

3:35:00 Yes, thank you. I'll start again. Saddled with a federal court's mandate to pay Terry Ballas et al an unjustified amount of tens of millions of dollars, the town council not only just paid the Terry Ballas group a down payment of $2.8 million, plus an additional $50,000 to Terry Ballas directly, but the town must also come up with an additional $2 million by July 1, 2013.

3:35:34 And yet an additional $2 million every July 1st for the next 23 years. Unlike our federally elected officials of both parties, including 100 senators and 450 members of the House of Representatives and the President of the United States, the Town of Mammoth Lakes elected officials are unable to print and or borrow money that is not theirs. Mammoth Lakes elected officials must spend only the money

3:36:02 Only the revenues that duly flow into the town coffers. It's very simple. If the town does not possess enough revenues to cover expected expenditures, then the council must make the cuts to its expenditures to match its revenues. This is exactly what is happening with the town council, not only currently, but for the past several years.

3:36:27 In recent years, the Town Council has acted responsibly by making deep cuts to town staff and to town programs, but now there is this new challenge to pay a group of investors $2 million every year for the next 23 years. I submit that it is this new financial challenge which has thrown the huge monkey wrench into the normal operations and the town's ability

3:36:57 To provide municipal services to the citizens and visitors of our community. This council has done its best to provide expenditure reduction options to our community to get the community's feedback on what its financial expenditure priorities and service level priorities are for this coming year's budget. Yet there is no consensus. There is no clear pathway to make the necessary

3:37:26 Budgetary cuts to the services the town supplies. A few examples, the swim team doesn't want Whitmore pool cut. The school kids don't want the closure of the Whitmore ball fields where literally hundreds of school-aged children and an equal number of adults use the ball fields during the spring and summer months to play baseball, softball, football, and soccer. Whitmore pool and the fields are a great facility.

3:37:55 That gets great usage by our citizenry, but today we can't afford it. Our community members and our guests have become accustomed, some would say spoiled, by the high level of officers and public safety that we have enjoyed over the past 20 plus years, but today we can't afford that same level. It was mentioned tonight that late night transit services has a constituency as well.

3:38:25 Contractors have enjoyed getting their house plans or their construction permits processed in a timely manner, but today we can't afford it. We have all cherished the absolutely great snow removal service and road maintenance, but today we can't afford it. I could continue with other examples, yet the point is that because of this unjustified, most would say ridiculous judgment against the town and the consequential $2 million a year payment,

3:38:58 This council has no choice but to make the cuts necessary to generate the $2 million each year. Every area of the budget that the council proposes to cut, there is a constituency that is opposed to making cuts in those areas. Really, the only other option to the cuts is if there is a sufficient community support to pass a new revenue measure.

3:39:26 Like an admissions tax or a lift ticket tax or something else. Otherwise, and without some new form of revenue enhancement, budgetary cuts will be made that most will not like. Thank you. Thank you, John. I have a comment that's not related to the cuts, but I've got an anecdote to share, to put out there. As I stated earlier, we put sideboards around this by telling

3:40:01 The staff to come up with a restructuring plan and the public can't possibly know what kind of work this staff has put into getting this thing done. They can only imagine. And in part is because we were not willing to sponsor and promote tax increases.

3:40:25 So my anecdote is that I was in Anaheim yesterday and last night and stayed in a hotel. And I looked at the bill this morning. And on the bill was a – and I was happy to be at the hotel because I was at the Bruce Springsteen concert, so it didn't matter.

3:40:51 I looked at the bill, and the TOT in Anaheim was 15%. Ours is 13%. In addition to the 15%, there was a 2% bid, which in this instance was entitled Tourist Improvement District. I think it's Anaheim Tourist Improvement District. And that was 2%.

3:41:23 And in addition to the 2%, there was a fee that was, it was $1 entitled a resort fee. And I don't know what that was. I didn't ask anybody. I just looked at it. Now, I don't know whether that would be $2 if it were two nights or whether it was, I don't know what that is. My point is this. We are taxed heavily.

3:41:51 If this community, if there's a segment or segments of the community, the constituencies that Councilmember Eastman has spoken about come forward and organize to put a measure on the ballot and if the voters approve it, we'll have higher taxes. By way of comparison, I wasn't offended by those taxes. I doubt that most people even look at them.

3:42:19 I mean, they just see the number. And I don't know that for a fact, but I pointed out just for comparison purposes. I'm personally not prepared to sponsor a revenue measure. I felt it was very important for this council to live within the means that exist today. But if the community decides to do that, I'm sure there are plenty of examples of other communities that have

3:42:46 Gone out and solved or at least ameliorated their financial problems by raising more revenue and that's always an option, it's just not one that's considered tonight. Thank you, Rick. Michael Jo? No, Rick said what I would have said. I thought Rick would stay at the village for a minute. Before we move on to the next item, I want to say thank you to the community.

3:43:20 There's been a lot of people that have been engaged on this process, and I think Rick said it well. It was really nice to see the last meeting, a lot of folks coming up, and let me start over. Earlier on, people came out. Obviously, there was anger and venting, and probably still going to be a little bit of anger, but near the latter part of it, a lot of folks came back, and you guys were presenting solutions, and that was very helpful for us, all the emails we got.

3:43:50 The staff got a lot of emails and whatnot. So it was helpful. And I just want to say thanks. And we've gone through some of the hard cuts here. I think now the next step is to make sure Mammoth is not a $17 or $18 million general fund town. It's a $25 million general fund town. And so now we've done the hard work. We're going to go make sure John Urdi gets it in gear, and we're going to get behind him.

3:44:18 Get some folks here and get them back to town because that's what's going to help us get out of the problem, restore our services the way they need to be. And I'm looking forward to that. So that's all I have to say. By the way, there was a $16 parking fee on that bill too. It's better than the $20 in San Francisco. So Rick, how many more times was the hotel bill than your Bruce Springsteen tickets? So do we, Joe, did you have a motion then?

3:44:47 We already made the motion in a second. Okay, then I'll do a roll call. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Okay. 5-0. And we'll move on to item number nine, which is adopt an ordinance renaming the Planning Commission and recognizing new duties of the commission with regard to economic development and public art. Is that worth it? Okay. Yeah. Okay.

3:45:22 So I will keep my staff report very brief. It's already been a long night. Very simply, this agenda bill presents for the town council an ordinance that would make amendments to the municipal code recognizing duties of the planning commission related to economic development by renaming the commission from the planning commission to the planning and economic development commission and also proposes to

3:45:52 Make a really a clerical recognition of the fact that the Public Art Commission is now the body, I'm sorry, the Planning Commission is the body which has handled matters that were previously handled by the, by the Public Art Commission, really to clean up the references in the zoning, in the municipal code. With that, I'll just take any questions. Any questions, Bill? Well, I don't have a question, but I do want to make a proposed change to the ordinance. Okay. All right.

3:46:20 If you look in Section 3, it's the third bullet down. It's the bullet that's like a circle where it's talking about advice and make recommendations. And it goes on to talk about referring work plans, applications, et cetera. I believe it is incorrect to have the mayor listed there. I believe it needs to be the entire town council so that it would read,

3:46:46 That may be specifically referred to the commission by the town council. And also, because one of us cannot do that. That's the requirement of the entire, you know, or a majority of the council. And also, in the first line after the and, there's an extra appropriate. Okay. So you want to be taken out? Yeah. Not appropriate? But the first appropriate taken out, because it, yes. And then also the mayor or taken out. Okay.

3:47:17 Any other council members have comment? And we're getting, if we, what, sorry, and he was just clarifying that this is actually introducing the ordinance, you cannot adopt it tonight, it'll be second. Oh, excuse me, yes, but I'd rather introduce an amended ordinance. Okay, well, we have some changes, do I have a motion? Public comment, yeah. I'm sorry. Anybody from the public have comment on item number nine?

3:47:48 Okay. Okay, then I will move that we approve option one to adopt the attached ordinance as amended, renaming the planning commission and the community development department and assigning the new duties. Actually, if I may, the agenda bill is confusingly awarded. Okay. The motion might be to introduce way first reading, read by title only. Thank you. Amended ordinance. Amended ordinance, yes. Second. Okay. You got that, Jamie.

3:48:20 Okay. Okay. All right. We have a motion and a second. Go call. Sorry. Go call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Okay. Motion passes. 5-0. And then finally, we're going to reschedule the January 16th meeting. It doesn't look like we need to. So, anybody have any comments on here?

3:48:53 Be okay. Mr. Mayor, I've moved that the council rescheduled a regular meeting of January 16th of 2013. Yeah. To the following Wednesday, January 23rd, 2013. Okay. I'll second. Okay. I have a motion and a second. Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Okay. Motion passes. All right, zero.

3:49:26 And we expect a full report. Did anybody, is there any other comments or questions? Nope. Okay, we'll go ahead and adjourn. Thank you. Matthew, on something like that, you don't have to do a roll call? I just want to make sure you do. No. All right. You can do a roll call. I was going to say, it's nice to see someone else. I'm tired other than myself. I'm just kidding. I really do.