Town Council
· recording 3 hr 56 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
382 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
55:48 And so, yeah, those two, correct, correct. And so, and then my suggestion is that we just, sorry, I think I accidentally made you up, that we refer that back to staff before the discussion that we don't, you know, the staff hasn't had a chance to inform us it wasn't even really discussed. Yeah, that's the next thing.
56:30 Okay, guys. I am wearing my... You're not paying the propane bill. I'm wearing knee-high wool socks. I'm wearing some of my snowboarding socks. This is what I call them because they're knee-high wool because it's so cold in here. I don't know. Can you get into your settings? Oh. And it's going to be interesting because one guy that asked me, he wants to speak on a single family home, but the decision tonight isn't really...
57:18 Deciding the issue, it's deciding whether we're going forward to decide the issue. Right, just to continue the work, to get the facts. Yeah. I think a lot of people thought we were voting on it today. Yeah, and it was really interesting, and I will speak to it, because I listened to the Planning Commission meeting, and the reason it was a 3-2 vote was because the staff report from the Planning Commission said...
57:41 Move forward and, you know, move forward with research and go ahead and implement. Well, those are, and what Rhonda and Elizabeth were saying while they were the no-hers on it is you get your information first, then you decide if you're going forward. You don't make a motion that says you're going to get the information and go forward. Right. That's deciding before, you know. Right. So we'll see. Yeah. But I think we'll get to listen to people's thinking of your preference and that's now part of the film.
58:11 Oh, well. Unless, unless it's a consensus. I'm just hoping that we get to a consensus of everybody up here saying what, you know, what should we do with it. So we don't continue to have things like that. To me, staff had already...
58:47 You can't afford a propane bill, John. You're shaking. Yes, sir. Are we off? Yeah. So she says your wife's your wife. God, thank you.
59:14 Thank you.
59:29 Thank you.
59:59 Thank you.
1:00:28 Thank you.
1:01:04 Okay. We're going to go ahead and get started with our regularly scheduled council meeting for December 19th. We have nothing to report from closed session. And we did have a meeting just a little bit earlier with the Recreation Commission. That will be discussed a little later in tonight's agenda. So with that,
1:01:38 We'll go ahead and get a roll call, please, Jamie. Here. Here. Here. Here. Okay, with that, John, would you like to lead us in the pledge, please? I'd be happy to. Please join me. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
1:02:14 Okay. At this time, we'll go ahead and open it up to public comments. So if there's anything anybody in the audience would like to comment on that is not on tonight's agenda, please come up to the podium, state your name, and let us know what's on your mind. Thank you. Hello, Mayor and Councilmembers. My name is Jesse Baldwin, President of the Mammoth Lakes Contractors Association, and I'm also a small business owner and homeowner.
1:02:47 I'm here again tonight to remind you of our position regarding the permit technician position that has been proposed and approved to only fund for half the time. I know we've talked about this a lot. I just wanted to reiterate because I spoke with our members last Thursday, December 13th, at our monthly meeting. We have about 43 members right now of the Mammoth Lakes Contractors Association. We all agree that this position must be fully funded and occupied every day. This position is the first communication
1:03:17 That the majority of the community and visitors speak with when they enter the town's offices. We are not sure you fully understand the importance of this position for everyone. Us contractors rely heavily on this position to not only issue permits but help with research on old building plans that enable us to provide our clients with accurate information. We pay for this service through the permit fees that the town collects and when we submit an application. Simply say that we don't have the money is unacceptable for that reason.
1:03:46 We understand the town's financial issues. However, this is a service that we pay for. Therefore, we plead that you do not ignore us. We will work with the town staff in any way we can, but we must be assured that this position is fully funded and occupied. It makes no sense to not have a permit tech or even rotate existing staff to such a critical position. I can assure you that it will only drive up illegal building activity if people don't know what they are doing. It will cause delays and therefore people will just not pull permits.
1:04:15 Two things come out of this. One is lost revenue for the town, and two, the town will have to enforce something that was completely avoidable. Who is going to enforce it as your staff is already stretched to the limit? This is not something you want Johnny spending his time enforcing when he can be doing what he always does, inspections, research, code research, etc. We don't know the codes like he does, so we are all asking him important questions that we need to have answered. If he is enforcing a surge in illegal activity,
1:04:42 Then we contractors that go by the book will suffer. Johnny already does too much and is always willing to do weekend inspections, nighttime inspections, and I don't think creating the possibility of illegal activity is something we want to add to his list of things that he does. We respectfully state that you fully fund the permit tech position as this has been stated at every council meeting by myself and other contractors. And I did express, you know, that delay that happened.
1:05:08 Before with my permit for the ceiling fan, it was kind of a silly whole thing, but, you know, I can tell you that every permit that I've submitted since that Elena has handled, I've gotten it back the same day. It's been awesome, you know, and we really need that. Today I did an exhaust fan in town that had illegal wiring up behind the exhaust fan, and had I not pulled a permit for that and had a legal person doing it, it may have ended up being that same way, you know, when they were done. Somebody did that to extend the wire, and, you know, a licensed electrician knows better.
1:05:38 That's all I have. Thank you. Thank you, Jesse. Hi, Tim Flynn, Mammoth Lakes resident and also board member of the Mammoth Lakes Contractors Association, currently serving as secretary. I compare with Jesse. I think that, you know, the permanent tech position needs to be, you know, fully funded. But I do think there is some fat in there that you could cut. You know, but I would recommend that it would be done in-house.
1:06:12 You know, and let, you know, let the supervisors and so on and so forth find out, you know, what are the needs, you know, of the community immediately and then, you know, make cuts accordingly, you know, but I mean, I feel like, you know, you know, not to offend anybody, I mean, I like everybody in there, you know, there's nothing personal.
1:06:37 You know, but I believe that the town should operate more on like a real business level, something that's more financially sustainable, you know, and so, you know, I would really look into, you know, the needs of the community first, you know, like these, you know, we have a lot of these like smaller little permits, you know, so we need, you know, kind of the littler guys in there to, you know, process these little minutiae type of issues and then, you know, like...
1:07:05 The bigger issues, you know, where there's people just kind of like waiting around for something to happen, you know, maybe they need to, you know, either come down the ladder or, you know, take a vacation or something, you know, so anyway, that's my views. Thank you. Thanks, Tim. Donna Hustleton. I wanted to talk about the shooting at Connecticut.
1:07:36 And talk about our situation here. I just, I don't know if everybody knows, but our kids go to other schools for sports. And when my son was 17, now he's 30, we went to Le Sur, which is by Big Bear. And when we pulled up, there were shots fired. And we put the kids back on the bus, and the coaches spoke to the school, and they end up playing. And then our girls went into the bathroom.
1:08:05 And they were there an awful long time, so I walked in and one of the girls came out crying because the other girls were going to beat them up and was pushing them around. So everybody was restricted to the bleachers and no one was allowed to go to the restroom or buy food without an adult. Well, the sad thing is halfway through the game, their girls spoke about what their goals were and what they wanted to do. And one of the things, several of the girls spoke about how
1:08:34 They wanted to kick our butts and win, and that was the most important thing, and the way they said it was not great. Well, for me, when I thought about that at that time, it's us parents that kind of need to make sure our children aren't acting that way, and we need to step up to it. So as all of us parents in our school district, by the way, the girls did win that game.
1:09:03 As us go to other schools, we also have to be very open and have chaperones for our sports and make sure that this doesn't happen to any of our children. So I just wanted to speak about that. Thank you, Donette. Donette, if I may, just while you're there and since you brought it up, and I think you and I talked last week or the week before, what this lady is saying is reality, unfortunately, and
1:09:32 I have two more examples that I wanted to share with the community. One is that it's my understanding that the Mammoth soccer teams do not play against one of the local communities that they used to play against because every time they'd play them in soccer, there was a threat of fights from the other players. So we just don't play them anymore.
1:10:03 My son, a number of years ago in high school, went to an event actually at the same location and was accosted afterwards in the parking lot at Bonds and was pummeled by four other men and the only reason that he's alive today is because a lady who was waiting for a friend of hers in a car saw what was going on and moved her car forward with her lights on. It was at night.
1:10:32 And the four people, the four other guys left, and my son was taken to the hospital with a concussion, but he credits the only reason being alive is the way this lady reacted. The reason for telling these stories is that they do happen, they happen locally, and I think it is up to the parents to have the influence on their children to teach them that sports is a sport and not something that...
1:11:01 Should involve fighting or anything about life threatening. So thank you for bringing it up. I think it's our responsibility as parents to not say to our own children, say, kick their butt, do this. If my son ever said that, he'd be toast. But we as parents have to set the example. And I think that's really important. And just because it hasn't happened.
1:11:25 And we have great police here. We have great schools here. We have great superintendents. But we also travel just like other schools travel. And we, as when coaches ask for chaperones, please step up to the plate. It makes a big difference to make sure our kids are protected. That's all I'm asking. Thank you. Good evening, Mr. Mayor, staff, council, community, Rich Boccia, superintendent of schools. We're all horrified by the tragic events that occurred this last Friday in Connecticut.
1:11:59 You know, I think it's a system of the world. The world is in distress, and this is just what the symptom we begin to see. You think about what happened in Aurora, you think about Oregon, you think about the school shootings. It's just unbelievable these days the things that are going on. It's inherent upon us in this small, cozy town I call paradise to be aware of the distress that this community has to share. Our schools are safe. I'm not going to build prisons. I'm not going to build walls around our schools that kids can't get in.
1:12:27 We want parents and students to feel welcome. We're going to do what we need to do to protect our kids and the community at large. We're reviewing our safety plans at this point. I'm very grateful to the chief. We started Friday afternoon, Saturday, Sunday, Monday. We're on the radio today talking about what we're up to at this point in time. You know, get into sports. You know, we don't play one school anymore. You know, it's just it's not appropriate. And I was down at a volleyball game at School X.
1:12:53 And we were getting heckled, booed, hissed. And I went to the administrator. I said, you either get your people under control or I'm pulling my people off the court. And we need to be bold enough and courageous enough to say, you know, this is not how we're going to raise our children. It's about respect, support. And one small community takes a village. And we've got a great village here, so let's make this work. Good evening. Happy holidays. Merry Christmas. Thank you for the time. Thank you, Rich.
1:13:20 Are there any other members of the public who'd like to come up and speak on anything that's not on the agenda? Okay. Seeing none, we'll go ahead and move on to council member reports. We'll go ahead and start with John. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Last week, I'll try to make it real quick. Last week, I went to Bishop for two meetings. One was the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments at that meeting.
1:13:48 It was expressed that Caltrans is tightening their permitting process for events that are held on their highway system. Fortunately, they used Mammoth as an example and said how well that we, through Ray and Public Works, already work with Caltrans on permitting like the 4th of July parade on our streets. But it was addressed more to other communities, Bridgeport.
1:14:17 City of Bishop and how those communities are going to have to start working more closely and getting their permits to do their events on the highway system before they actually have the event. So that was brought forward. I thought there was one more item on that. Excuse me for not being organized on that. The Linda Archularious, Daniel County Supervisor, brought forward.
1:14:52 What is called a legislative platform. This is a legislative platform that the Mono County supervisors have at the state level. It's not necessarily directly pertinent to Mammoth Lakes as a city as it would be to a county in the state. But each member of the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments was asked to bring this back to their body.
1:15:18 And I'll give it to staff, and we'll agendize it at a future meeting, go through the platform, and see if there's anything on this legislative platform that we would, as a council, would approve, not necessarily for the council, but to sign off for on ESCOG. So it's a formality, if you will. Also attended the Eastern Sierra Transit Authority, ESTA.
1:15:46 And there was nothing of relevance to report on that meeting. Also attended in Independence. Last week, a meeting of the Great Basin Unified Air Pollution Control District. That meeting had a public hearing that lasted for, I think, six hours with the City of Los Angeles there.
1:16:15 The main issue on that was the origin and the development of what's referred to as the Keeler Dunes, the Keeler Sand Dunes down at the Owens Dry Lake and how those dunes originated and whose responsibility, if anybody, it is for the creation of those dunes and also for the remediation of those dunes because currently on a windy day, the dunes is one of the highest, if not the single highest.
1:16:45 That was addressed. There was no resolution. There were arguments both by the APCD staff and the City of Los Angeles as well. And at our next meeting, I believe it's in March, we'll come back and have further discussion and the board will make a determination at that time as to how the dunes were originated and whose responsibility it is. That's all I have. Thank you.
1:17:15 Thank you, John. Michael? And then Jill? Just a few items. The Mayor and I attended the Local Transportation Commission meeting a week ago Monday, and the good news was the number of projects that are going to go forward in this town next summer due to grants and state and federal money that comes through that Local Transportation Commission. There's going to be work on Lower Canyon Boulevard, sidewalk on Sierra Nevada, part of the Meridian Boulevard.
1:17:44 Reworking the Meadow Creek Connector and the Library College Connector Path. All those are going forward for construction next summer. I also attended a meeting this afternoon with staff to review the Casa Diablo for draft environmental statements since there will be a town letter in response to the draft EISEIR that we'll have on the next meeting's agenda.
1:18:12 And then I just want to remind everyone, if you haven't had a chance, that the Repertory Theater is doing a wonderful version of Dickens' Christmas Carol Gone Wrong this weekend. In fact, Thursday through Sunday, if you get a chance to see it, it's great. Great. Thank you, Jill. Mayor Pro Temwood. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. I attended the Mammoth Lakes Housing meeting on behalf of the Council last Monday, the 10th.
1:18:39 Two items. One is we had a presentation from the Rural Community Assistance Corporation, which is a state-funded entity that was intended to and designed to and did tell us how if we wish to qualify for additional state funds as it relates to the development of housing as well as the management of existing housing.
1:19:08 At the same time, we also had a discussion, and I wanted to bring it to the attention of the Council, about an agenda item that was on last Council's, or last meeting's agenda, and that was related to the public meetings that we're going to be holding in January, February, and March related to Phase 2 of our restructuring plan. And it was pointed out, we had some discussion about it, that
1:19:38 Many of the partners as well as departments are going to be essentially having a discussion with us about ways to improve efficiencies and perhaps additional restructuring in order to meet the objectives that we've already outlined that we intend to meet with respect to this restructuring.
1:20:07 That, of course, will go on for quite some time. There are four phases. We've only been through the first phase. And what appears to be missing, what's included, of course, is a review of community development as well as housing, which is appropriate. What is not there is a review of tourism and transit and specifically the contracts with tourism and transit.
1:20:32 I have a request that those be added as areas, if you will, for discussion in February or March as we go forward. And if that's not something that can be done without having some discussion about it, and I certainly understand that may be the case, then I'd like to have it agendized for discussion so that we can talk about whether we have included everything that we do or contribute to as a government in
1:21:01 The discussion about how we're going to do it differently. And that's all I have. Okay, thank you. Just a couple items from me. I wanted to announce I attended Campo, the grand opening for that new restaurant in the village. I thought it was wonderful. Great Italian food up there, so it was kind of a nice experience. I met with the young professionals group on the 12th.
1:21:28 And this is a group that I believe started to emerge a little bit through the Chamber of Commerce. And what it is is just a group of young professional people that are really looking for an environment in which they can expand their thoughts and ideas and really get together and move their thoughts forward in our community. But the attendance was great. It was held at Blue Handcrafted Foods. And I wasn't sure what to expect when I got there because it is a relatively new group.
1:21:57 It's probably one of the most well-attended meetings that I've been to in a long time. So real fun, good, energetic group of young folks there. That's about it. Actually, I did meet with David Page, John Erdi, Michael Raimondo, and a few others regarding a winter carnival that we're trying to get together probably in the second week of February. And we're making some strides there. We've had a number of people from the community.
1:22:27 Jump in to participate on how we can really get something moving forward. We'll have different nodes throughout town and just a real fun, energetic event going on throughout the weekend, maybe three, four days. But I think it's a good way for us as a community to come together and everybody participate and start looking forward to some more of the positive things we have coming forward here next year or so.
1:22:54 With that, I don't have anything else. Excuse me, if I may just say one more thing. Sorry. I wanted to add one more thing, and that's for staff. When I parked for this evening's meeting, I realized that we, the town, and probably Mono County, have vehicles parked in the Vons parking lot, and I think the town's going to be pretty much full by Friday. We've got...
1:23:20 Snowstorms this weekend, maybe next week. I just want to make sure that both the town and the county are able to move all or as many as we can of the vehicles out of the Vons parking lot. 21st? Friday? Great. Thank you. Okay. Thank you, John. With that, we'll go ahead and move on to commission updates. So are there any commissioners out there, commissions that have anything you'd like to report on? Okay.
1:23:49 Seeing none, we'll go ahead and move to department reports on emerging issues. Mayor, Councilmember, staff, we actually have some good news to report tonight, and that is we received the phone call earlier today from Standard & Poor's, their bond rating agency, advising us that thanks to a lot of work that we all have done, and I'll list all the accomplishments in a few seconds, S&P upgraded our bond rating from C.
1:24:24 To double B plus. Double B plus is a better rating than this town had before bankruptcy. It's a better rating than we had in 08. It's a better rating than we had in 06. We have ways to go. And we are going to be working very hard with standards and poorest to upgrade our rating even higher. I tell individuals that
1:24:46 A bond credit rating shows credit worthiness of a town, of a city, of a municipality. It's very similar to credit score for an individual. And in the world of municipal finance, it matters. This is probably the most important factor that matters.
1:25:05 The reason S&P upgraded our rating is first because we're very, very persistent. When we called them initially after the settlement, they told us that it would take at least six months for them to evaluate before they're willing to accept our request to upgrade our rating. However, they have looked at the fact that we had mediation before bankruptcy and negotiated some major concessions in that mediation. They looked at the settlement itself.
1:25:34 And I think they were impressed. Finally, they looked at the restructuring plan that the council just approved. And all of those factors combined, which of course reflect the hard work by this council, by staff, and our various partners, including the employee unions. So that hard work resulted in this amazing, quite amazing accomplishment for the town.
1:25:56 Last but not least, when I asked S&P earlier today what it would take for us to upgrade the weighting, they mentioned two specific things. One is increasing our reserves. They're not happy that our reserves are only at 1.2 million going to 1.5. They need to be much higher. And it has to do with volatility of our revenues that sometimes we don't have the snow, we don't have the TOT, and that's the largest revenue for us.
1:26:21 The second factor is really sticking to our budget decisions that we recently made. They know, they realize, and they spoke to me about this, that decisions that we made were very, very, very difficult decisions, and they just want to see us implement those decisions. So I want to report those good news to you. Thank you. Thank you, Marianna. Are there any other department reports? Okay. Seeing none, we'll go ahead and move on to item number one.
1:26:53 It's the introduction of new Assistant Fire Chief. We'll have Chief Harper come on up. Mayor Lehman and members of the Council, it's with great pleasure I get to introduce our new Assistant Fire Chief, Chief Freevault. Chief Freevault comes with over 35 years of experience in all forms of fire protection, including state, federal, and local. He recently retired from Sparks as a Division Chief with over 24 years of service to Sparks.
1:27:34 He has a bachelor's in fire administration and a master's in fire and emergency management. He's working on his doctorate in public policy and administration. I worked with Chief Frival when I was with the academy up in Reno. He has a background as a professional instructor. He has a background also in emergency management, consulting, and wildland fire ground leadership. He has an extensive background in mentoring.
1:28:04 He's married 25 years to his wife, Debbie, who also served as a wildland firefighter. He has two kids, Kyle, who just finished a tour in northern Iraq as a specialist in the Army, and Miranda, who's finishing high school up in Reno and competes in martial arts and recently won an amateur competition. So Chief Revolk, we interviewed a total of, or we had a total of 14 applicants.
1:28:32 And we hired him obviously just because of looks. Anyway, it's a real pleasure to welcome him to the community. Well, yes, he did tell me I have a face for radio, and so that's... I'm honored to be here in the community. My wife and family and I have been here several times. We're kind of a hockey family, so we can see the rink up again. It's just a gorgeous area, so when did we saw the opportunity come up?
1:29:09 We took a shot at it. My goal is to help protect the lives and property here, get everybody home safe, and just contribute. Thank you. Thank you. Okay. Thank you. And we'll move on to agenda item number two, which is a 10-year anniversary award to Senior Information Systems Specialist Dan Dennis. Robin? Good evening, Town Council, staff, and members of the public. Dan Dennis is a great guy.
1:29:46 He is also our Senior Information System Specialist. He is also the man behind the scenes, making sure all of our IIT needs are met. Throughout the years, he has helped each and every staff member, from the PD to the town yard to our offices here, and all of our IIT needs. Unfortunately, Dan is unable to join us this evening.
1:30:09 So it will be my honor to present him with the Certificate of Appreciation for 10 years of service on behalf of the Town Council when I see him next. So Danny, if you're out there watching us on Granicus or Channel 51, on behalf of the Town Council staff and me, we want to thank you for your 10 years of dedicated service to the Town of Mammoth Lakes and for keeping our IT systems up and running. Thank you.
1:30:39 Dan, if you're watching, we do thank you very much for your service. We appreciate it. Okay, we're going to move on to a consent agenda. And so is there any items that the council would like pulled from the consent agenda? Okay, seeing none, any members of the public that want an item pulled? Okay, with that... Mr. Mayor, I'd like to make a motion to approve items 3 through 5. Okay, we have a motion to approve items 3 through 5. Second.
1:31:14 And we have a motion in a second. Okay, Jamie? Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Okay. Motion passes 5-0. We'll go ahead now and move into policy matters. Item number 6, which is a resolution canceling development agreement for the development of the Mammoth Lakes Airport by mutual consent of all parties to the agreement. Andy Morristown Attorney, I'll present this one.
1:31:44 You may recall that as a part of the settlement agreement, everyone who had any rights in the development agreement waived those rights and agreed that the town could terminate the DA. At this point, this item is just a matter of housekeeping. State law allows the town to terminate a development agreement with the consent of the developer, which we now have. It's in the settlement agreement. So this is really just tying up a loose end. Nothing controversial. Not a surprise to any of the people that had rights under the DA or have them.
1:32:12 Because they've already agreed that the town could do this. If anybody has any questions, I'd be happy to answer them. Does anybody have any questions, Andy? No. Okay. Call for motion. Oh, first of all, it's a pretty important housekeeping. Yes. Yes. We are canceling the Hot Creek Development Agreement in 55 years or so. All right. I move that the town council adopt option one, which cancels the development agreement.
1:32:39 For the development of Mammoth Lakes Airport by mutual consent of all parties to the agreement. And before anyone votes on that, we can just see if there's any public comment. Okay, do you want a second? Yeah. Second. Okay, we have a motion and a second. Are there any comments or questions from the public? Okay. Seeing none, we'll go ahead and ask for roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes.
1:33:08 Motion passes 5-0. Okay, we'll move on to item number... I'm sorry? I'm sorry, yippee! Yeah. I'm tired at this point. I know, but as Rick said, it is so important to be cancelling that. Mentally, he's already behind me, so... All right, item number 7. To approve the 2012 measure are fall funding recommendations proposed by the Recreation Commission.
1:33:37 So with this item number seven, we'll go ahead and Dave, are you going to present? Just briefly, to the point, right, I'm not going to stand up and do it. We had an earlier meeting this afternoon with the Town Council and the Rec Commission regarding this item. As you recall, Measure R is funded in two parts during the course of the year, spring and fall. This application is coming up. It's a larger one. It has several items. I'd be happy to go through those if the council desires.
1:34:07 It's available for the public as well. The total funding request is going to be, let me just get to the right page here, $164,431 for a list of projects that include college connector path, Waterford Trail design, tennis court rehab, multi-use facility in Haspin, special events barricades, Whitworth track equipment, Whitworth track maintenance, trails and parks maintenance, special events generator, and measure our administration.
1:34:35 The funds are available. Recreation Commission reviewed the project list as well as all the other applications that came forward and forwarded this recommendation with a resolution to the council tonight for approval. Okay. Thank you, Dave. Are there any questions of council? No. Are there any questions of the public on this item?
1:34:58 Okay, seeing that, I do have one question. We have 164 as our number, but if we look at the table, it's 177, 821. The difference is based upon previous funding and portions of funding for the overall project. Some previous funds were already allocated. So the 164 is the actual allocation request. There was a question earlier as well about the fund balance. At the end of the process, there still is a...
1:35:28 Remainder of $222,026 in the Measure R Fund account. Okay, great. Thank you, Dave. Okay. Well, if we don't have any other questions, we'll go ahead and ask for the public. Yeah, I did. Any other questions from the public? No? Okay. Yes? I move we approve option one, which is approve the measure, 2012 Measure R Fund, fall funding recommendations in table one.
1:35:58 And adopt the resolution appropriating the $164 of $431 and measure our funds for fiscal year 2012-13. Second. Okay. We have a motion and a second. Roll call, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Okay. Motion passes 5-0. So we'll move on to item number 8, resolution to review.
1:36:25 Accept pre-audit actual financial results for fiscal year 2011-2012. Mayor, Councilmembers, good evening again. This presentation is on pre-audit year-end results. Cindy Myrell, the finance manager, and I are going to co-present. I'll go through a few slides. The presentation is not long, and Cindy will cover a couple of slides as well. I will mainly talk about the actual year-end results and revenues expenditures.
1:36:53 And funds, and Cindy will talk in more detail about the loans outstanding and staff's recommendations to write off or forgive a couple of loans. So here's a summary of what's in the report. The financial audit, which happens every year, it's done by an independent auditor.
1:37:31 So that audit for the last fiscal year that ended on June 30th of 2012 is expected to be completed at the end of this month, which is typical. And this report presents pre-audit year-end financial results. A number of financial summaries are included in the attachments, including general fund revenues and expenditures, as well as revenues and expenditures for all funds.
1:37:57 So the entirety of the town's financials are before you in summary format in this report. Attachment C is an interesting attachment, or I should say worthy of mentioning. It's something that we introduced to the council for the first time last year at the end of the year. And it shows not only fund by fund summary of revenues and expenditures, but also shows fund balances, which is very important to look at.
1:38:27 In addition, it does show fund balances by type, and I'll talk about that in a minute. So let me highlight some of the major differences that happened between the amended budget for last fiscal year and year-end results. There are no differences from what we reported to you as expected year-end results just at the last meeting, so we're not looking at any new financials.
1:38:57 But we do have to highlight budget versus actual differences in order for the council to approve them for the audit. So the actual general fund revenues as compared to the budget were higher because A, the payment of the loan that came from the airport for the terminal building has been recognized as a revenue. Previously, we were sending it directly to the reserve. A partial loan repayment from a dip fund has been recorded.
1:39:27 You may recall that millions and millions of dollars have been loaned by the general fund to the diff funds and finally one of the diff funds had some money to pay us back. In addition, a 4.3 million dollar loan from a vehicle fund has been reported as revenue and then offset by expenditures and that loan was spent on additional loans to the diff funds of 1.4 million to cover additional negatives.
1:39:56 A loan was about $3 million worth of legal fees. And these increases in revenues were offset by a delay in a payment from the hospital pursuant to a hospital land exchange. The expenditures, that's appropriate.
1:40:26 The expenditures were also higher because the payment of MLA-related legal fees that I just mentioned and additional transfers to the general fund to the DIF funds, that's the additional loan of 1.4 million that I mentioned. Advancement C, again, as I mentioned, shows funds by type because as you look at a fund balance, the fund balance is not necessarily cash.
1:40:55 An important category of fund balance is non-spendable, it's non-cash, and a good example of that would be in a vehicle fund, we assess the value of our vehicles and parts, and that becomes part of the fund balance, but obviously it's not something that we could go ahead and spend. Some other portions of the fund balance could be restricted generally by law.
1:41:20 Committed to assigned or unassigned. An unassigned portion is what is generally available to be spent. Now I'm going to stop here and turn it over to Cindy. This slide is a little difficult to see, but this table that's before you is also on page 3 of the agenda bill, and it shows loans that are on the books. Good evening, Council. Cindy Mayro. I'm first going to just go down what receivables are actually on our books.
1:41:54 And kind of open a discussion and receive direction on your pleasure. So first, you have the general fund. We loan development impact fees, $3.9 million developing projects over time. A lot of it, you know, Lake Mary Road, the skate park, many projects that are on that. It was assumed that we would have some large development.
1:42:20 The second loan is a fractional use note that is owed to the general fund from our fractional district and that was for the formation costs of the district. These funds could be paid back if there's additional development that is fractional use.
1:42:49 Down the road, we don't know whether that development will happen at this time. The next note is an airport note receivable. We had put in that it was really for operations, but it wasn't. It was for capital improvement in environmental and legal costs. Over time, from 2000 to 2008, these loans were recorded. There's a recreation note also due from the fractional district, and this has to do with
1:43:18 Ice rink operations. The fractional district can fund additional increased level of police, increased level of parks maintenance, and increased parks and recreation facilities. Workforce housing, there's a $900,000 note receivable that was reported for an Aspen Village housing project and development. They needed additional funding to complete the project.
1:43:49 The next note is a Hot Creek Aviation accounts receivable. It was revenues that were recorded in the airport and Hot Creek was not paying these lease payments and with the end of the settlement it is not expected that we will receive any funding from that source. The Vehicle Service Fund has loaned
1:44:16 The development impact fees, $1,275,000 also for the projects that we're continuing. And then there's $4.3 million that is due from the general fund to the vehicle services fund for the legal costs and giving cash back to the diff funds and making them whole.
1:44:43 And that has a repayment plan already in our current restructuring plan of 11 years. So I'm first going to talk about the airport loan and the $3.2 million that is on there. It represents the capital matches, as I said, environmental and legal costs plus interest.
1:45:13 It was intended to be repaid with development that was anticipated to happen with the development agreement. We assumed that the airport would have additional revenues generated from the Hot Creek development, and that is no longer happening. The FAA entitlement money cannot be used to repay this money.
1:45:41 The portion that is on the books is really for the matching funds for the development or projects that were done down there. You can't use new entitlement money. It's really for the match going with that, so you cannot use the FAA million dollars a year to repay any part of this loan. We do have PFC revenue. A portion of that can be used to repay a small portion of this $3.2 million. What's PFC?
1:46:09 Passenger facility fees. There's $4.50 per employment that the airlines pay us. And that money can, it has to, it is earmarked for capital and it can be used as matching funds. We have a ACIP that had to be submitted to the FAA. It's our capital improvement plan for the airport. Part of that plan included the runway.
1:46:37 Expansion, equipment purchases, and the terminal. So we have $96,000 sitting in that fund as cash that could be used to fund, pay back a portion of this $3.2 million. It's staff's recommendation to use that $96,000 to pay back the general fund and possibly fund the permit tech position for the remainder of this fiscal year.
1:47:06 Keeping a little bit more than $200,000 on the books for a future discussion for the PFCs. As I said, we have a CIP plan that plans on using all of our PFC revenues to cover the matches. As we get the million dollars a year for capital improvements, we have to have that matching funds and the PFCs are intended to be used for that purpose. Where does the PFC currently go?
1:47:33 It is in the airport. It's held in a fund, in the airport capital improvement fund, and we currently have $96,000 as of June 30, 2012, and we anticipate about $126,000 in the next fiscal year. Okay, thank you. Cindy, while you're on that, so does that mean that money in that fund has been used for other things because we've been running, the airport's been up with the seven flights a day for
1:48:00 Couple years now. The PFC's revenue just started about a year and a half, two years ago. Okay. So we, that was a, and that's why we didn't, we haven't had this revenue source for a really long period of time. And to get the PFC revenue had to be approved by the FAA, and like I said, we had to submit our capital improvement plan to them as to how we intend on spending that money. Okay.
1:48:28 So the recommendation is to write off the just under $3 million, not the $295,750, using the $96,000 that we currently have in cash to repay the general fund, and our recommendation is to help fund the permit tech position for the rest of this fiscal year and deal with ongoing funding of the permit technician in our next budget cycle.
1:48:57 Do we get any kind of credit, financial credit for writing that amount off? No. No, I didn't think so. It's just really cleaning up our books and our auditor, you know, it is not reasonably expected that there will be revenues available to pay this money back. Thank you. So if we were to take those...
1:49:20 PFC funds and payment. Yeah, and payment funds and put it towards the note. When it comes to the note, does it go back in general fund anyway? It goes back to the general fund, yes. You can just put it in the general fund. You can put it in reserves. It still goes into the general fund. The staff is just recommending that you fund the permit. Just because you don't want to go through the accounting nightmare of having to process it here and then again? Okay, got it. Why would you not?
1:49:47 Okay. And because it came up earlier,
1:50:19 Cindy, is if I remember what Jesse and Tim were saying is that they pay fees for the permits to be processed, but I don't remember us seeing any kind of a study on whether those fees were covering the cost, so I just have to presume that whatever they are paying for their permits is not covering the full cost of the permit technician? It's not covering the full cost of the building department, no. Okay.
1:50:47 And our last one that we're recommending we write off is the $367,500 Hot Creek Aviation accounts receivable. We have just settled and we are not going to be receiving this revenue. It's part of the settlement. It's part of the settlement. So if you would like, those are our recommendations. And then if you wanted to go back to look at the previous loans.
1:51:30 If you have questions for me on any of the other loans that are on here that I just kind of went down the list for, I'm willing to answer your questions. Okay. Any questions from the council? I have one. Jo, do you want to go first? No, go ahead. Well, we have on the dais, each of us, some communication from Mammoth Lakes Housing specifically.
1:51:57 Director, and she may wish to speak to it. And that relates to the write-off of the Workforce Housing Loan in light of the fact that that entity is really an extension of the town, at least in my mind. I realize that it's a separate non-profit entity, but we are its primary sponsor. And in light of the resolution that was passed in May of 2006, I actually see my signature on it.
1:52:27 That suggests that if the funds are properly used and the project is completed, the loan would be written off. I'm wondering why that would not be under consideration now. That is at Council's, if you want to direct us to write that off, that is Council's discretion to do so. I guess the reason is that since we fund the entity with the funds that if it were to repay the loan would be coming from us,
1:52:56 There doesn't seem to me to be any reason to have the loan from us remain outstanding unless, and certainly we can hear from Pam, we can hear from you, unless there is some other source of revenue that we might expect to receive that should go toward that loan. But it seems to me, as I understand it, that's a workforce housing project that has now sold out and there isn't going to be any additional revenue.
1:53:20 I'd certainly like to have a discussion about it. Council members, exactly. The item is before you is for a discussion and to receive the direction from the full council.
1:53:31 For the majority of the council, the resolution was adopted quite some time ago. It gave direction to the town manager. We have a different town manager. We have different council members now. We also have taken into consideration that MLH, while you're absolutely right, their major source of funding is the town, they do have assets.
1:53:50 And so one of the ways to repay the loan perhaps is to allow participation by the town in one of those housing assets. But again, it's something that invites a discussion by the council and we're here to take your direction. So Cindy, so there's no collateral then on that? No, there's no collateral. It was used to fund the Aspen Village Apartments for the construction in that project.
1:54:21 And when they sold the units, there was no residual funding left after they sold it, and they used some of their reserves to cover the difference when they sold the units at a loss from what the construction costs were. So if all the units are sold, how do we get paid back? That's really the point. For context, we're now in 2012, but as everybody knows, that project came on.
1:54:50 When the housing market not only was collapsing, but it collapsed. And so the revenues or the prices that were expected to be paid were obviously not realized because it was no different from any other housing in Mammoth or for that matter anywhere in the country and the world. It simply declined and that's the reason why the shortfall occurred as I understand it.
1:55:13 It's simply a matter of timing. But my point is really not related to that. It is that if we're the ones that are financing, why would we carry a loan? I think because it's a separate entity. Jo, do you have? Well, yeah, what I was going to suggest is since this one is just coming to us and rather than try and go into the details from here is that this particular one be brought back to us separately because it's not actually part of the resolution tonight.
1:55:44 Yeah. As I understand it. Could you add it if you... Well, we could, but I'm not willing to add it until I really understand all of the ramifications and have a little more information, so I was going to suggest that we ask that one to be brought back separately so that we can better understand where we are and then at that point decide whether or not there's a repayment plan or a write-off. I agree with that.
1:56:08 So are you suggesting that we still address these two items here? Correct. Yeah, I would suggest, right. Okay. That because the resolution that we would be adopting doesn't say that we're accepting, you know, that we were doing anything other than writing the two off, I would suggest we have that one come back separately when we can focus on it. So you're suggesting workforce housing by itself comes back?
1:56:36 Yes. Okay. So do you know what assets are available that we may be able to attach? That's why I want it to come back so we can actually see anything that might be there. I do have a list of their assets. They're not in front of me, but I do have a list of what they do have on the books and what we funded for them. Okay. John, did you have any other comments? No, sir. Thank you. Okay.
1:57:05 The only comments I have, probably along the lines with Joe, I would be in favor of seeing this come back versus trying to discuss it tonight. I'd also like to, since it's on here, maybe bring up, since we have Pam and Rick here, maybe inciting a discussion for a different direction of housing. It just seems that we've talked about different loans that we've had to pay back, and there's a lot of
1:57:34 Now we have a $900,000. Last week it was a $750,000 loan. Before that it was a housing product that we ended up having to pay for because it was going back to the market. It seems to me that maybe this would be a good time to talk about how we might want to change the direction of housing. And for the last couple of months we've been talking about how we can keep some of our employees.
1:58:00 How we can maintain our police department, how we can do all these different things. And I'm wondering if there's not a vehicle somewhere inside of housing here where we might be able to find a benefit to the employees and maybe instead of having a very broad workforce housing element out there, let's narrow it to somewhere that we actually truly need it. I think part of the problem that I've been vocal about before with the housing is that it's so broad that we're actually inviting people in from out of our community.
1:58:29 To compete with the workforce that we're trying to support. And I have a real tough time with that. I was talking to somebody about Aspen, and instead of having a six-month period of time where you have to live and work in the community for six months before you qualify, I think they have like a five-year period where you truly have to prove that you're living here and you're from here. And I'm sure there's some legal requirements for all of that. But I would be interested if we bring this item back to also bring that up for discussion.
1:58:59 And maybe it's a separate time, but have a workshop with affordable housing so we can maybe try to look at a new direction for this entity and see if we can't start reining in some of this debt and some of these, because this is going to go on and on. There's, I mean, this loan here eventually is going to turn into something like the one last month where they can't pay for it and the town's going to have to cough it up because we owe that money and we're ultimately obligated for it.
1:59:24 So I'd like to see us take that in a new direction, new avenue, and maybe see if there's not a way we can work with our employees, our employee unions and whatnot, and see if there's not a way to perhaps find some benefit there and solve some of the other problems we have. So that's all I have, and I'd be in favor of hearing this item again.
1:59:45 Council Members, Mayor, if I may ask and perhaps suggest, Council Member Wood, you mentioned earlier that in the next few months, the next couple of months, we're going to be discussing each department and each area of the town, including their budget and performance. Housing is on that list. I can't recall specifically when they're scheduled to be discussed, perhaps...
2:00:08 We have that in front of you, but would it be your pleasure to bring housing discussion at that time, which may happen in February or March? It's set for February 6th. So is that the timing for you? I think that'd be fine to have a workshop type of discussion myself if everybody else is in favor of it. I think that would be only an opener because this is a big policy discussion with
2:00:36 A lot of facets to it. One of the things that I think that it's important to state tonight, and, you know, I absolutely respect the position of the mayor, and I think he respects Martin as well, and it is well known that we're on opposite sides of the fence on housing issues. But I think it's important that we recognize that the housing entity is not our enemy.
2:01:04 We are the housing entity, and it is us. In other words, the voters voted to spend a portion of the TOT on housing. And that's why I say it's a much bigger, broader policy discussion that must involve the community, because if we take it in a direction that is different from that which was suggested 10 years ago, and it may be appropriate to do that under the time, it certainly may be...
2:01:31 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
2:02:01 And I'm very much in favor of doing that early next year. So if it is such pleasure of the council, what we will do is bring the information, revenues, expenditures, performance measures, similar to all other departments, to you on housing on February the 6th. And at that time, you can determine if you would like to proceed with future discussions, which you probably will, and or workshop. Yeah, and if we could have assets and if there's been any audits.
2:02:29 Anything of that nature, any results, something like that, I'd like to see those as well. Yes, Jill. Cindy, could you go back to the other slide where you were essentially changing the resolution, if I understand what you were talking about in the staff recommendation? So that would change the dollar amount that would be written off, correct, for the airport note receivable?
2:02:55 I just wanted to speak against necessarily identifying tonight when it's just coming to us that the $96,000 would be used for the unfunded permit technician. I'd like to suggest that we, if we decide to reduce the amount we're writing off by that amount, that staff comes back to us with a little bit more information about how to spend it.
2:03:19 Not that I'm saying that we don't need the permit technician, but I don't necessarily. I have trouble with a nexus of saying you're taking passenger facility stuff and giving it to permits. I think that there may be a more sophisticated way of doing it. Correct. Correct. But I think that Rick's suggestion of reducing the general fund contribution in the one place, making it a cleaner step through, might be the way that we would go.
2:03:48 And then if I understand it, the $200,000 that we would quote keep on the books would be because we expect to see more of the PFC money come in, but that money does not necessarily have to be spent on terminal match? It does have to be spent on the match to the million dollar employment money that we get, entitlement money.
2:04:12 So any time that we're receiving money as a capital project is moving forward, depending on the timing of those capital projects, we do have to have matching dollars available to do that. Okay, but even though it's, quote, the match, it can still come back to the general fund. Only for this amount because of the projects that were included, the only amounts outstanding were the airport runway, some equipment, and one other item. Terminal remodeling.
2:04:42 And the terminal. Okay. All right. So that is match we've already earned. And the rest would stay there until we can earn some more. We've done something else and can get the money back. And you would make a decision in the future as to whether to use the PFCs to pay back the general fund or continue to use it as matching dollars for airport improvements. Okay. All right. So I don't know if there's any other...
2:05:10 Okay, I don't know if there's any other comments before I make a motion on my idea of not necessarily saying it would be spent on the permit tech tonight. I'd like to ask the public first. Sure. See if there's any comments from the public on this particular item. Yes, John. John Baruch. I have a comment on the Mammoth Lakes Housing forgiveness request. I was just a four-page sheet in the back there.
2:05:44 I agree with staff that it should not be forgiven, but I don't know really what this means because if it isn't forgiven, if it is forgiven or isn't forgiven, what's a grant? But I am in favor, definitely, of discussing where housing is going, what it's doing. Last month, this month, there's $900,000 that housing wants forgiven. Great. Last month, $750,000. I heard that there's a $500,000 yearly debt service that we're paying.
2:06:14 Plus, of course, housing has defaulted on a couple mortgages and loans in the past. I'd like to see a complete audit or a complete list of all these items. And it should be, I think, by an independent auditor. I don't think the board should do it. Evidently, when it comes to money, I don't know. I guess I'm going to say the board's inept based on some of these numbers here. We also, I would assume, you're going to have income.
2:06:42 I mean, I've got a couple pieces of property, and I have income, and I take the income and the expenses, and sometimes the income is higher than the expenses. But what happens to the income from the housing? This is such a great program. We've got all this income. Where does it go? And why doesn't that go to debt service? Why is the town of Mammoth Lakes paying for the debt? And where's the income going? So, you know, to me, from what I've seen in these numbers, $750,000, $900,000, $500,000, a couple loans that then defaults upon.
2:07:10 I think there should be a complete, not restructuring, but there should be a complete audit and to see where the money's going and how we're doing this particular program. So those are my comments. It'd be a shame to wait until February 6th and start a program without all this information. Maybe the information, I'm sure it exists, but as a taxpayer, I'd like to see it in written form. Okay. As a board member, John, I...
2:07:38 I will be, I look forward to enlightening you. Thank you very much, Rick. In addition, I'd be very happy, I'm sure housing would be very happy to provide you with each year's audited financial statement, happen to have it, and I'm sure that if you would like to discuss the details with either a board member or the staff, or for that matter, the auditor, who is independent, not an inept board,
2:08:07 They'd be happy to discuss that with you and look forward again to enlightening you as to what it is that housing does and what it spend its money on. I understand the audit, but we're 1.6 million, 2.5 million in the whole. That's all I'm saying. I understand that. I look forward to enlightening you. And then also one other point, which I've said before, which I think is a conflict of interest, in the board packet there's two resolutions, 2006-2004.
2:08:36 That were signed by Rick Wood, the then mayor of Mammoth Lakes, and he's also on the town council, or on the housing. I think it's a conflict of interest. Our attorney has said it's not. And maybe it is an illegal conflict, but it doesn't feel right, and it sure doesn't smell right. So those are my comments. Just another comment. I don't want to have a debate with you. The council is a representative on tourism, transit, and housing. I haven't seen too many things signed by those.
2:09:06 Thank you very much for your time. Thank you, John. Thank you, Rick. Any other comments from the public? Mayor, Councilmembers, Tim Flynn, Mammoth Lakes resident, past president of the Contractors Association, past dip fee elimination proponent. So I'm pretty versed in...
2:09:36 The DIFF fee discussions and so I just had some questions I guess for Cindy. She mentioned that DIFF monies were expended for projects. My question is which projects were funded and were they in direct correlation to the projects that the monies were collected from? Second question, how many times can DIFF borrow from general fund and vice versa?
2:10:05 And also on the housing. Have all the monies from DIF that were obligated for housing been expended? And I guess this is probably a better question for the workshop, but I'll just throw it out there for the community. Maybe we as a community need to resubmit to the community for a vote and see how we all feel about it now. See how we all feel about the housing issue now. Thanks. Thank you, Tim.
2:10:37 Are there any other comments or questions from the public? Mayor, Town Council, I just have a comment. Maybe I could get a little bit of insight. Just with regards to the comment about the permit technician, obviously, I didn't expect anyone to be under the impression that the permit fees fully covered the cost of the entire building department. Honestly, I don't even understand.
2:11:07 Fully, you know, what all fees or, sorry, costs are associated with the building department. Mostly what I was stating was that the permit fees seem to be more than adequate to cover the permit technician that collects those fees. And it is just my brief opinion that it seems only obvious common sense to me, and perhaps someone else can enlighten me differently.
2:11:34 That reducing the staffing of a revenue collecting position will reduce the revenue collected. Right now we don't, you know, we've talked about possibly, and I'm not saying that to be rude, I apologize if it came across that way, but we talked about possibly an online permitting thing, you know, component to their software, and that's fine, but that's not in place right now. And I haven't heard any definite plans that that's going to be in place anytime soon. So, you know, basically what we're talking about is a gap in collecting those fees.
2:12:05 You know, regardless of the enforcement and all the other stuff that I've talked about. And I don't know, you know, that it would be directly proportional to the percentage decrease in staffing, but we haven't seen any of that math presented. And at the last town council meeting, when we talked about income and expenditures and everything, all the permit fee income and everything was missing from all of that. And I asked about that, and Marianna, I don't remember verbatim what you said, but basically it was that that's all internal to the department.
2:12:33 If we don't see any of that math, you know, I don't know exactly where to access all that stuff, and, you know, I'm sure that's a discussion to have offline and everything, but, you know, if we're not looking at all the math and we don't know, you know, how much money's coming in and how much that affects, you know, the, you know, being able to pay for, you know, the whole permitting process, then I don't, like I said, I just don't see how it makes sense to cut a revenue collecting position.
2:13:00 Jesse, I think what we were talking about earlier was an attempt to not do that. And Joe was just, I think, trying to say, instead of, the proposal was from staff to say if we had those funds coming in to use them to pay a permit technician, I think the discussion was, well, can we just separate that it's going from the airport to the permit somehow. So that gap you're talking about, I think staff has proposed a way to try to bridge that gap. Okay.
2:13:29 Is that right, Dave? So just a couple of comments. First off, you know, we're doing things very quickly, which, you know, at times then lends itself not to be as accurate as we'd like to be. So tonight's discussion about the savings, the $94,000 or so, really came out of an earlier conversation and meeting we had and kind of discovered we had that available to us. And we had heard you many times and we recognize and agree with that importance of that job.
2:13:56 The fact is we're looking in every little corner for every little nickel and dime we can find to do things. So the plan, which I appreciate the comment by Councilmember Bacon, we do need to bring back a more complete plan for that use of those dollars. So what we talked about earlier today is to fund the position. Now we do have a problem with that because this is one-time money and the permit tech position is an ongoing expense. We need to reconcile that.
2:14:23 We also know that there's some software that could really improve the delivery of that position's needs and functions. And you've spoken about it, that you could do a permit from your office, pay for it online, have it printed out in your printer, and never have to take a moment to come to the office. There's a huge savings in time for us to do that. So our plan was to come back and at least get a sense that the council would like us to go in that direction. And then we're working internally.
2:14:53 And Marianna made a point tonight about it, which is we have improved our standing with standardism pours. And we want to maintain that. So we have to be very disciplined and compact. So we're looking at internal staffing changes, restructuring how we do some of our business. The problem, of course, is in terms of the building side of it, is that if the town actually charged the full cost of permits, there would be many permits that wouldn't be issued because they're just too...
2:15:21 Difficult for some people to get their small and their problematic. So the larger permits actually offset some costs for the smaller permits. The overall program doesn't pay for itself. So you can do some kind of a cost analysis and revenue analysis and you could place it wherever you want. You can say, well, we need to really fund building permits. So we need to fund plan check. We need to fund the inspections. All of that needs to be paid for and general fund subsidizes it. So you could put the subsidy anywhere you want. It just happens to be at the permit tech.
2:15:50 Level now. And that just was kind of the way the cards came out when we did all restructuring. So I think the idea of bringing it back is a good one. We're also going to be looking at the building department along with community development as part of our overall review of all of our department's functions. So you're going to get a much greater detail of what the expenses and revenues look like, what the delivery of services are, what performance standards we're looking at for those positions and deliverables. So I think this is a good opportunity to look at it. We know there's a need, though, that is a need today.
2:16:19 So we're looking at trying to resolve it as quickly as we can. Thank you. Thank you, Jessie. Good evening. Pam Hennerty, Executive Director of Mammoth Lakes Housing. I just wanted to extend an invitation to all of the council and any of the public, for that matter, in advance of the workshop to come and talk with us at Mammoth Lakes Housing about what we do. I think that there are a lot of misconceptions in the community about housing and the need.
2:16:51 And there's a lot of different opinions, and I'd like to discuss them. I look forward to an open discussion with the board and the council and the community. And I just really want to point out that, you know, Mammoth Lakes Housing is a private not-for-profit. All of our books are public record. We do have an independent audit each year that I'm happy to share with the community. And I also want to just point out that the loans that we're talking about, the lowest $700 and so thousand that we talked about, the $900,000.
2:17:19 That's on your agenda tonight. These are not new loans that are coming out of the woodworks. These loans were made and approved by town council in public hearings in 2005, 2006, and 2007. They've not been hidden. They've been on the books. They're just something we've needed to deal with as the town examined its finances related to the settlement with MLLA.
2:17:45 We have been forthcoming with where we are and how those may or may not be repaid and our plans for those. But again, I just want to remind the community that in 2005, 2006, 2007, we were in an entirely different place. The world was in a different place. The economics of the town was in a different place. And if we would have seen coming what we would have done, all of us probably would have made different decisions.
2:18:13 In 2005, 2006, 2007, John Farouk was an advocate for housing and nearly a partner in workforce housing deals. And so, you know, this isn't something that's been hidden. Things have changed. Mammoth Lakes Housing has changed and will continue to change. And we look forward to an open discussion and invite any of all of you and the public to our office to discuss housing and what it is we do. Pam, real quick.
2:18:39 And in the end, even today, even though the downturn, the amount of those loans, those were productive loans. Those did good things and provided housing opportunities for people in the community today. I believe that they did. I think you're right. So thank you for saying that. Thank you, Pam. Any other members of the public? Okay. Well, seeing none, then I'll ask... Okay. Shall I try to get through this one? Okay.
2:19:10 I would move that we approve the attached resolution accepting the fiscal year 2011-12 pre-audited financial results, approving fund balance designations, and accepting staff's recommendations on loan write-offs, noting that the amount of the airport note receivable is going to be reduced to something that's just under $3 million.
2:19:33 The difference between the 3.290.041 and the 2.95. Right, but I'll let you worry about the number. Then further that, how the $96,000 in PFC fund is to be allocated, be brought back to us at a separate date, and that the MLH loan for Aspen Village apartments for $900,000 be brought back to us at a separate date.
2:20:01 Did I get it all? Okay. A second. We have a motion and a second. Okay. Roll call, Jamie. Councilmember Bates. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Okay. We have a motion. Councilman 5-0. And we'll go ahead and move on to item number nine. So, Jessica.
2:20:24 Jessica Morris, Associate Transportation Planner. The purpose of the item before this evening is to provide information to the Council regarding the Main Strait Project, which will be coming forward early next year, and to request that the Council consider appointing a member to the working group that will be supporting the project.
2:20:41 Staff has recently had a kickoff meeting with the consultant, Winner & Company to discuss the scope and schedule in more detail and talk about how the Main Street Project relates to the zoning code update. The intent of the Main Street Project is to move forward with the implementation of the preferred alternative from the downtown concept for Main Street.
2:21:01 And look more closely at the design of the corridor and the logistical and incremental steps that would be necessary to implement the project as well as look at the financial aspects. As I have mentioned, an important component of the project is the coordination with the effort to update the zoning code, in particular the commercial zoning chapter. To assist with this, staff has developed a working group which we are calling the downtown working group.
2:21:28 And this group will support both the Main Street Project and the zoning code update. The working group, which will have our first meeting tomorrow, consists of various property and business stakeholders as well as the members of the Planning Commission Zoning Code Committee. And as I mentioned, we are asking that the council consider appointing a member to the working group as well. Do you have any questions? Okay. Any questions from council? No?
2:21:56 Okay. I'll open up and see if the public has any questions on this item or comments. Okay. Mr. Mayor, I would like to volunteer myself for the downtown working group. Okay. So we have one person volunteering. Are there any other council members that want to volunteer? Mr. Mayor, I'll make a motion that the council appoint Joe Bacon as our town council representative to the downtown working group.
2:22:23 Okay, I have a motion. Second. I have a second, Michael. I guess, well, if we need a roll call on this, but let's do it anyway. We'll get a roll call, Jane. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Okay. Thank you, Joe. All righty. So with that, we'll go ahead and move on to item number 10. I think this is what everybody's been waiting for.
2:22:53 Which is the zoning code update and the status of a work program and schedule, including consideration of work program options for single family, transient rental, commercial zoning, and community benefit incentivized zoning. Thank you, Mayor and members of the Council. Ellen Clark, Principal Planner. The purposes of this agenda item is to provide an update on the work program and schedule for completion of the zoning code update and in particular to see more specific direction on to
2:23:21 Work program items that relate to the completion of that broader work program for the zoning code update. As you're aware, we've been working on this project on the update since about 2010, including what we're describing as two phases of work. The first of those represents work that was completed in 2010 and 11, primarily as an in-house staff effort to draft.
2:23:45 And review with our planning commission in the zoning code users group, approximately 35 zoning code chapters with a lot of work during that time. In 2011, we received a significant grant from the state of California, over $300,000 to complete remaining work in the zoning code update. And that grant is enabling us to tackle some of the more complex and difficult topics for the zoning code, to engage consultant services to assist with this effort, to work with our town attorneys to complete legal review.
2:24:14 And also some additional work, including development of an indicators framework as well. The deadline for expenditure of the grant funds is August of 2013. We began work on Phase 2 early in 2012, and mostly working behind the scenes to begin to examine and look at some of those additional chapters. We've outlined some of the steps that we've completed to date, as well as the work that remains to be done.
2:24:42 As well as the timeline and schedule that we anticipate to complete that work to allow it to be wrapped up in the summer of this year. As we began that work, a number of issues or a couple of issues really have arisen that are under discussion have been somewhat controversial. So we're coming to you at this time to seek additional guidance on the extent to which we should engage with those and integrate those into that zone and code update work program and determine how it's best to move forward.
2:25:12 The first of those I'll do because it's a little easier, I think, relates to completion of the commercial zones chapter. We held a joint workshop with the Planning Commission and Town Council in November, asking some really high-level questions, particularly about the community benefits and incentive zoning ordinance, which relates to that zoning piece. And that really initiated a discussion about the timing, the necessity of those CBIS standards.
2:25:40 And how they relate really to the overall framework of commercial zones, the standards that we have, and the importance of getting those standards right so that we can accomplish what we intend and what we've stated we want to do in the downtown concept for Main Street and other district plans that are written over the past couple of years. And that's really a question of feasibility, whether or not the standards that we have can get us there. Staff took this question to the Planning Commission on December the 12th. There was a unanimous recommendation from the Commission.
2:26:10 That that question, a really close examination of those standards be looked at through the zoning code update. As Jessica mentioned in her presentation a moment ago, we've suggested this idea of a downtown working group that would really tackle both the commercial zoning issues and the broader Main Street project as well as a unified effort looking together at those development standards, physical development and implementation that's necessary. The second topic, which I think many of the audience are here to...
2:26:39 To listen to is really with regard to single-family transient rental. That was also discussed at the joint workshop. As you're aware, it's a controversial and difficult topic that's come forward a number of times in the past without resolution. And we're hearing, I think, a range of strong opinions on both sides suggesting that this is something that we should move forward on and those who are concerned with the impacts of that decision. Following the joint workshop,
2:27:08 Staff reported the outcomes back to the Planning Commission. There was agreement from the Commission that some additional work by our Town Attorney to daylight the issue of CC&Rs and how those might relate to single-family transient rental might come forward. And staff also asked the Planning Commission to provide a recommendation on how staff should move forward to be provided to the Town Council at this meeting. So that's what we're doing for tonight.
2:27:37 The staff report does note the recommendation made by the Planning Commission, which was approved by a 3-2 vote. The recommendation was to move forward in some form or fashion to continue to investigate the issues and options for civil family transient rental, to do that investigation and some additional analysis, and based on that, to return to the Town Council to determine if staff should move forward in a more formal way to develop an ordinance or...
2:28:04 Regulations that would allow for single-family transit rental. If that program were to move forward, there's a series of three bullet point recommendations, one of which rose from the town attorney's, or two of which rose from the town attorney's recommendations, and one is really about working with stakeholders and all those interested parties to make sure we fully engage in all of those issues. There has been some discussion about the recommendation and what it really meant, and I wanted to emphasize that really
2:28:33 That staff sees this as a phased approach. It's something that needs to allow for the full consideration of all of the issues, if not something that anybody wants to rush into. I don't think anybody agrees that.
2:28:48 Releasing a flood of unregulated single-family rental onto the market is in anybody's best interest, and so proceeding with due caution, considering all of the issues, the options, and the benefits, potential benefits of a program need to be considered and weighed before deciding if we move ahead. With that, really the recommended approach would look something like this, which is to, based on the recommendation, which is in spring of 2013,
2:29:18 To complete additional analysis, investigate some of these issues, determine really the feasibility of bringing forward a program to allow single family transit rentals, and then bringing that back to the town council for a direction on whether to move forward. The analysis that I mentioned would be somewhat high level, but would address some of those critical issues and topics that have been raised, things like the need for general plan amendment, neighborhood quality impacts and how those might be addressed.
2:29:44 Potential revenues and costs are just some of the things I think we'd look at in that initial analysis. And then at that time, if directed to move forward, potentially as part of the 2013-14 work program, then there could be some timing considerations in there to move forward to that work program, to draft the ordinance for review and consideration. So really a stepped and phased approach.
2:30:08 Allowing for input, allowing for full vetting of all of the issues, and allowing for the right decision points to be made by the Town Council with proper input and information to make a decision at the point. At this time, and in the staff report, staff does not make a recommendation, but does suggest that the Town Council could either simply affirm the Planning Commission's recommendation as it's presented and made on December the 12th, with regard to both the Transient Rental and Commercial Zones work programs.
2:30:37 Or, alternatively, to make modifications to some or all components of that recommendation and providing alternate direction in any way that the council sees fit. Or thirdly, simply directing staff to come back for attention with additional information and deferring this discussion to a later date. Okay. Thank you, Ellen. Okay, so kind of an important...
2:31:02 I just had a couple questions of Ellen, so I didn't know if you were about to go in there. No, I was going to ask everybody, so go ahead. Thank you for this timeline, because I think it will now meet. I believe Rick and Matthew made some kind of a commitment of getting this done, and I think we've got a timeline that'll get us there, since you're on the hook for that. I was just kind of wondering, I'm puzzled, but...
2:31:25 In a good way that for CEQA it will only take a negative declaration. It's not like having to do a general plan EIR. Because the zoning code implements the general plan, provided that the zoning code ordinance is consistent with the general plan, we are hopeful that we will be able to process it through a negative declaration.
2:31:51 Really rely on the general interior to allow. Okay, so we'd be relying on the 2007 EIR. Okay. Then if I understand the options essentially on the single family transient rental issue, even though in the document you have essentially what would be several steps is you're only recommending that we
2:32:20 Get more information and bring it back for a decision. You're not, because the other, the second bullet on page six goes ahead and proceeds to draft it, so it kind of presumes a particular answer. It's suggesting that if, at that time, if there is a recommendation to move forward with the ordinance, that those three considerations should be part of that. Okay, but that's not really part of the motion that you're asking for tonight. You're just asking for direction to review it.
2:32:48 In essence, that's the most important recommendation tonight is the way in which staff should move forward to work on this. All right. Okay. Okay. Yes, John. I need clarification still, and I know that there's some verbiage that has been put out there. Is my understanding correct or not in that currently there are no major subdivisions in the community?
2:33:18 Are there any large subdivisions that the CC&Rs currently would allow rental of single-family rentals on a nightly basis? Based on the dozen or so CC&Rs that the Town Attorney will be, and Andy, of course, you can add to this, is that...
2:33:36 They say different things about what isn't allowed with regard to different sorts of commercial uses and different sorts of transient uses. And I think the conclusion really is that many of those regulations are not crystal clear. And so this is really why we asked Andy for his opinion on how or if or whether we could really get into trying to interpret these CC&Rs to make that decision on that basis.
2:34:03 And Andy provided a suggestion for how essentially putting the decision in the hands of the homeowners associations for those subdivisions to affirm and really interpret their own rules, which is really as it should be as to whether or not transient rental of that nature is explicitly allowed. So if we put that decision in the hands of the individual homeowners associations saying whether they wanted or did not want.
2:34:31 Nightly, single family nightly rentals. To date, have we had any of those associations come forward with an application to allow or requesting to allow nightly rentals? We have not. And, you know, I think it's a, I think the difference perhaps in the way we've talked about this, we're talking about this now as compared to the past is that this, in this framework.
2:34:56 The town potentially would actually develop a set of rules that said, if a homeowners association wanted to come forward, a firm that their subdivision permitted single family rental, we would have the system of rules in place to regulate and to allow for and to permit or to really control those uses in the way that the town saw fit, rather than putting all of the burden onto the homeowners associations who come and have to.
2:35:20 Write those rules themselves, bring that forward through a process. So it's taking away a barrier to some extent, but it still is putting most of the responsibility for the homeless association to come forward and then say, yes, we want to do this. We want to participate in the program. And I should point out, there's some developments that don't have an active HOA. We understand that. We got an email today from someone who pointed out that his association doesn't really exist. They just have CC&Rs.
2:35:46 State law has a procedure where even if you don't really have an association as such, the owners of the property can amend their CC&Rs. So when we say the HOA would have to amend CC&Rs, the HOA would have to make the decision. Really, if there's no HOA, it can be done by the residents. There is a way for them to get there if that's the direction the council wants to go. I'm just wondering if there hasn't been a request if we're not putting the cart before the horse and why we're prioritizing this.
2:36:15 Just in case a homeowner association wants to allow nightly rentals. Well, I think that at this point we haven't told any of the HOAs or any of the residents that that is an option that the HOA or the residents would be able to decide. It's one policy option, but...
2:36:32 I don't think the council's given us any direction to do that yet, which is probably why we haven't. No, and I'm going to disagree with you, Andy. It was before your time, but we did say that any neighborhood that wanted to come forward would let us know when we'd consider it at that point, and that was about three years ago? I'd stand corrected. Before your time, yes. Yeah. Thank you. Okay. Rick, do you have any comments? Questions? You know, I just want, I go back a long way on this.
2:37:04 And I must, there are two points that I would make. One is, I'm actually thrilled to see that there is a dialogue going. Because for about 14 years now, I've been asking for one. I think that what occurred, and so, and by the way, the dialogue,
2:37:24 is in part emotional, as we see from the emails and letters and so on, but it's also in part fact-based, and this is exactly what I have looked forward to seeing as a precondition or prelude to a public discussion about this, because it's just high time. Irrespective of which side of the issue you're on, the second
2:37:53 The point that I would make actually goes, Joe, to your comment, which was the action that was taken three years ago. I interpreted that three years ago as a punt, meaning we're not going to touch it, but if an association comes forward, then maybe it's something that ought to come forward. I may be wrong. It was not in the council at that time, but if an association comes forward, then maybe that's the opportunity for us to discuss it. Well, the opportunities...
2:38:19 Now, and I think what's before us now, as far as I can tell from what came out of the Planning Commission, is whether we do it sooner than later, meaning have that debate sooner or later. And so my view is that it's so important, it's so emotionally laden, that is, the positions of the parties, and
2:38:46 In particular because there's so much information from other communities. Maybe they're not exactly the same as us, but they are resort communities nonetheless, and we can draw upon the experiences that they have had. And by the way, I've had some extensive discussion with Mike Vance from Whistler. As many of you know, he was our community development director for many years. They went through a very painful process. They didn't just get to it.
2:39:13 And their process is worth looking at. The process, the arguments, and the outcome are really worth looking at. And I don't know whether they're directly comparable or not. But my point is that there's just a lot of data out there. And I don't think we should ignore it. I don't think that we should just assume that we take some of it and reject the rest of it.
2:39:40 The downside is that that takes time because the public process can't be done quickly. And as much as I would like to see this move forward in a way that's constructive, on a timeline that seems realistic, I recognize what the reality is, and that is that we need to make sure that whatever decision is made, or even if no decision is made, that will be done after we have all of the facts and all of the legitimate arguments are heard. Yes, John?
2:40:13 I have huge respect for Rick, and we agree on a lot of things, but he just mentioned that the community of Whistler up in Canada just went through a very painful process to address this issue. I would submit that our community has gone through a very painful process over the last few years, both in reducing our staff essentially in half.
2:40:44 In settling an airport lawsuit where we have to pay $2 million a year for the next 23 years. Personally, I consider that to be enough pain for our community. I also question that since we have reduced our staff and since our, I mean, you just look around at our staff. We've got a gentleman here, Jesse, tonight talking about a permit technician.
2:41:14 We know what we're facing with the reduction of our number of officers in our police department, reduce snow removal services. Our staff, in my mind, has better priorities, particularly in this department, community development, with updating our zoning code, amongst others.
2:41:39 So that we are prepared when and if the next round of uptick happens in our construction. So whether Rick says we punted three years ago or whether we punt today, I just think we have higher priorities for our staff to be working on than this particular issue at this time. Thank you. Thank you, John. Michael, do you have any comments? Yeah. Just a couple comments. I agree with Rick. I think that
2:42:10 You know, there's a lot of comments and concerns and a lot of factual data. And personally, I mean, I'm interested in the factual data. There's a lot of emotions on whether it's a good thing to do, not a good thing to do for the town, for the community. I look forward to receiving more factual data, and I agree with the Planning Commission's recommendation that we move forward with their continued research. Okay.
2:42:42 If there are any other questions or comments from Council, I know there's a lot of people in the public that would like to weigh in on this, so I'd like to go ahead and ask some of you folks if you want to come up, if you have a comment. If somebody before you has made the comment, just say I agree with them and maybe add anything new. That way we don't hear the same thing a bunch of times. There's a lot of folks, it looks like, that may want to speak to it, so if we could just keep it coming in an orderly fashion, that'd be great.
2:43:12 Mickey. Good evening, Council. Mickey Brown, I am Vice Chair of the Planning Commission, and I just really wanted to re-emphasize a point was while we did have a lot of discussion on this, the one thing that everybody in commission was agreed upon is that we really do thoroughly need to address the issue. I don't think anybody just agreed with that on commission, so the only issue was then really when were we going to put that into the work program and in what facet.
2:43:41 You don't have to have any questions. I haven't seen that. No? Thank you very much. Thank you, Mickey. Evening Council, community, David Page. Just really quickly, I wanted to just say a couple of things. First of all, thanks for once again considering this seriously. I know it's a tough, tough thing to try and resolve. But I also, I'm not sure that some of the emotions that have come out in some of these meetings are actually representative of a broader swath of the community.
2:44:15 A lot was made of the fact that there weren't any proponents of changing the ordinance at the Planning Commission meeting last week. And just to say personally, 2 p.m. on a Wednesday afternoon is a little tough for those of us who have kids or who are working. Obviously, there are a lot of second homeowners who can't make it up. There were some people on the planes today. Both Horizon flights, both Alaska flights were canceled today because of mechanical difficulties.
2:44:43 Those were full flights, people that aren't here. I don't know what we pay our $250,000 for exactly. That's another issue. But I think you've seen, I hope you've seen, there have been hundreds of letters. We've got a petition with 300 people on it, hundreds of property, taxpayers, some who live here, some who live down south, hundreds of visitors who've...
2:45:10 Who are not here this week precisely because they can't rent a house. And I think that's something that I understand the public process takes time, but there is a certain amount of urgency here because I think, I mean I was talking with one of the checkers at Bonds today and he was saying that he was kind of shocked at how few people were in town here the week before Christmas. He said that in his 20 years here he's never seen it like that. And here we are with, you know, the most outstanding snow I've seen in a long time and why there aren't.
2:45:39 A lot of people here, obviously, some of it has to do with the economy. There are lots of other factors. But I would say that if you just think of the numbers, if based on the TOT Enforcement Committee's numbers, there are 100 to 200 homes, and if those homes aren't being rented this week, that's upwards of 1,000 people that aren't here because of that. And so they're not eating out at restaurants, and they're not shopping at barns, and they're not supporting local businesses.
2:46:08 So, just really quickly on the quality of life issues, we've heard a litany of problems that people either fear or have experienced with what they are perceiving as nightly rental problems. So I'm just going to read from somebody who wasn't able to be here tonight. This is something that Deb Pierrell wrote in. She's been on several commissions. She used to own Mammoth Creek Inn. She's a local homeowner.
2:46:36 And she's answering a specific letter that she received saying, you know, we live next to a property that's been renting nightly and it's a problem. And it's a lot of what we heard last week at the Planning Commission, you know, 11 cars in the driveway, things like this. And I share those concerns. I don't want to live in a neighborhood where people are partying all night long. I think Deb's point is well taken, so I'm just going to read it.
2:47:04 If your example was a short-term nightly rental, it was illegal, which is why I want to make it legal and oversee it. There are no short-term rentals allowed in Mammoth currently, thus it could not have been overseen by a management company. So a lot of the complaints that we've heard are people who are doing it illegally. So I think the question is, how can we improve the situation that we're in? How can we enforce the quality of life?
2:47:30 The way that a lot of communities have decided to do it, given the market pressures, given the fact that it's already going on, is to codify it, is to approach it with specific standards, with specific licensing requirements, with the requirement that there has to be a local manager listed on the license so that we can actually go to these homeowners and say, this is how you do it. Here's how you get your license. Here's how you pay your taxes.
2:47:57 And then there's actually teeth to the enforcement rather than just having them do this black market thing, which is problematic in certain cases. And then I'll just read her last paragraph and then I'm done. My home is also just that, my home. And I love that I live in a town where people want to come visit and create jobs for others. I do see all sides, clearly, which is why I'm an advocate of truth, unbiased facts, and a solution, without fear-mongering. I hear how upset you are.
2:48:25 And I respect you have an opinion. I only ask that you see both sides and remain open also. I have rented homes in other areas for vacation with my parents and grandparents. Vacationers are not disrespectful people. Discourteous people are the same anywhere. I suggest we manage the 98% of great vacationing visitors Mammoth has versus the 2% of rude ones. We are a resort town. And then just in closing, I want to reiterate my willingness to work on a...
2:48:53 Committee. If it should come, if you guys were going to recommend that this be studied, I'd love to work on that. So far we had a committee that was formed and it was supposedly a work committee, but there were nine or seven or eight people on it who didn't really want to have a discussion about this and myself, so it kind of went nowhere. So I'm hoping that we could get to a place where we can really look at the neighborhoods and figure out a way to do this practically in a way that works for everybody. Thanks.
2:49:23 Thank you, Dave. Good evening, Mayor Lehman, Councilmembers. I'm John Morris, Chairman of the Mammoth Lakes Lodging Association. And this is a tough issue. As the Chairman of the Lodging Association, I think that the most prudent thing to do to tackle this issue is certainly to take, as Mayor Pro Tem Wood said, take some time. This is going to take a long time to vet out. And my question is,
2:49:59 Is this the right time to do this? As Councilmember Eastman said, we have a lot of other things going on. We've been through a lot of painful things. I would recommend that this be put on hold for a while. And my condition on it would be the Council asked the Lodging Association to get involved with the T.O.T. enforcement issue a while back.
2:50:25 Members of the Lodging Association have been working with members of the council and the town and so forth to work on this enforcement issue for the last couple of years. And to be quite frank, we've just barely scratched the surface of a revenue source which is there. It's not a question of whether or not this is a net positive for the town. It's not a question of whether or not we might make some money out of it. That is a question with the single-family home issue.
2:50:52 And I'm certainly open to looking at both sides. I think it should be vetted out, gone through thoroughly. If it turns out that it's a net positive to the town, it comes down to quality of life, and it does come down to money, right? The bottom line is, if by opening up single-family homes, it is a net positive to the town, who is the lodging association to stand in the way of something like that, if it's good for all of us? No questions asked. If it's good for everybody, great. Problem is, it takes time.
2:51:20 It takes a lot of staff, a lot of staff hours, a lot of staff money. Do we have that money right now to be spending the money on that when we have, you know, the issue comes up, well, we need to get this done now. We need to talk about single-family rentals right now because we're losing money because people are not coming to town because we can't rent this and that and the other thing. We're losing money because people are renting their homes illegally and the TOT, there's no enforcement. The enforcement effort has been
2:51:49 A good start, but it's just the start. This has been going on for a long, long time, and we've really just scratched the surface on this whole issue. So my recommendation, my ask would be that please devote the town staff, more town staff, many more town staff, hire people. It will give you an ROI, a positive ROI. We are to work on the TOT enforcement issue because
2:52:16 There is money there. We all know there are legal activities going on. If we can reel that in, we can bring in the TOT and get that under control and show that the town can enforce the rules as they are written right now before we open anything up that gets more complicated to enforce, I think that that's the prudent step at this point. Let's do that first.
2:52:40 And make sure we're good at doing that and see how much money that brings in. And if at the same time we can also start working on the studies and the issues that are involved with single family home rentals, great, let's do both concurrently. But I don't know the inner workings of the town, you guys are the experts on that. I just don't see with everything we've just gone through that there's enough town staff and money to do both. And really I think it's only fair.
2:53:06 To the community and especially to the folks in the Lodging Association who have devoted a heck of a lot of their personal time to this effort to continue to work on that aspect where, again, it's a known revenue source. And simply, it's law. And so let's get that done first. I'm certainly willing to be a participant in the discussion of single family rentals when that time comes. You really have to ask yourself, is this really the right time to do this?
2:53:34 Even pushing it off to the spring, you know, we need to be working on the enforcement issue. We need to be adding more staff to that as much as we possibly can to bring that money back in. That's only going to further allow other studies to happen, first of all. So that would be my ask from the Lodging Association. Let's focus on that issue first. And then once we get that under control and really are good at doing that, then we can move on.
2:54:02 Thank you guys for your time. Thank you, John. Appreciate that. Real quick question, actually, for Alan. I read in here, there's a grant that we're using to get through at least the zoning code piece. Would that grant be paying for this portion of it? I think it could reasonably pay for...
2:54:25 You know, a portion of the work that was completed before August of next year. Okay. It's a zoning issue. The scope of our zoning code update is quite broad, and so I think we could tackle this through that grant. Would it, okay, so it wouldn't be cutting you short or cutting you short of the other two, other items, CBiz and, and, uh. I think there's enough money in the grant. Okay. Thank you. Do you like Rob and Peter to pay Paul? No, I don't think so.
2:54:55 Oh, sorry, Lainey. Go ahead. Sorry. Good evening. My name is Lainey Summers, thank you so much for all your time, and I would like to thank staff. They've gone out of their way to be helpful and informative as we move through this process. I'd also like to let you know that a number of our folks are unable to be here tonight because they're actually at our elementary school tonight listening to our children play their instruments and sing their songs, and I believe those children are all part of this wonderful community.
2:55:23 We have here, and they would like to go ahead and extend their apologies for not being here. In my opinion, we continue to put the cart before the horse. We're contemplating time-consuming work and spending a lot of money on a relatively small segment of our community. Developers, as they come forward, pay for the right to develop in our community, and I think at this point, should we have an HOA?
2:55:47 Amend their CC&Rs or a specific person come forward with a specific project request that we might go ahead and do this analysis and jump through these hoops, but we should make them pay for it. We don't have the money at this time. You know, there's a million ways that we can slice this particular apple, and I would encourage you to take a look at what other communities have done. Mono County just approved.
2:56:12 A pathway for approval for home rentals. It's very restrictive. It brings forward the people who are legitimate operators, the people that we want to be renting their homes, the big lodges and those types of things. That's what we want. We don't want the 1972 house up on Jahan that is in need of repairs and has taco beds and some of the problems that we associate with our condos at this point. Basically, I would like to see
2:56:43 Some of the fighting stuff. I think that it's very clear that the lodging association, the homeowners, and our neighborhoods, we're all here to work with the people who would want this, but it's not a black or white, all or nothing issue. We need to have some, there just needs to be some control about what it is that we're bringing into our community. We're trying to be a world-class resort. We don't need more garbage. We need to go ahead and continue.
2:57:10 To find ways to reinvest in our community and just bringing on 600 homes just for the heck of it isn't going to be doing it because you're going to see reinvestment stop in the other places you want to see it happen now. So I would encourage you to perhaps look at who it is that should be paying for this.
2:57:31 When it is that we have the time and how it is that we should be moving forward with this based on what sister communities such as Whistler are doing. And quite frankly, folks, we're your experts. I've been renting for 20 years. I've been writing TOT checks to you every single month for 20 years. I started out as six units. I'm now your second largest property management rental agency in this community. If you have questions, please come ask me. Thank you. Thank you, Laney. Hi, my name is Christopher Kimmerle. I'm a homeowner.
2:58:04 Here in Mammoth Lakes have been a homeowner since 2005. I came today to strongly urge the council to please pass an ordinance that will allow single-family homeowners to rent their home on a nightly basis and to do so sooner rather than later. We've been, myself and the co-owner of the house, which is close to Mammoth Lakes, close to the town, have been renting our home on a monthly basis since 2005, and we have been advertising monthly rentals only.
2:58:35 And the far majority of applicants that we get are for people that want to rent nightly rentals or weekend rentals or week rentals or two-week rentals. The majority of people that we have making inquiries are not able to rent the home for a month at a time. We do have occasional ones that do and we do make agreements with them, but the majority, the vast majority are those that want short-term rentals. Those people that apply are mostly honeymoon couples.
2:59:03 Europeans that want to do a two-week vacation here, seniors celebrating their anniversaries, fishermen in the summertime, they really are not the kind of people that have been portrayed in the media as partiers, etc. We haven't had that experience at all. So I'd just like to voice my opinion, explain my experience as a homeowner here. We've never had any problems with vandalism or parties or any issues like that. In fact, it's quality of life issues.
2:59:37 We have a homeowner next door that resides there full time and she has no problems with any of the people that we've had there for these long term rentals. In fact, she says that she approves and appreciates their presence because without their presence, our neighborhood would be a dark corner because the other homes in the neighborhood don't rent their homes on a monthly basis and the homeowners are hardly ever there. So I just want to express these opinions and again urge you to please pass this ordinance as soon as possible.
3:00:07 Thank you, Christopher. Good evening. My name is Cindy Gates, and I and my husband are second homeowners here in Mammoth Lakes. We had owned a condo before the home, and we actually had more problems there than we do with the homes in our neighborhood as far as rowdy neighbors that are renting for wood ends, trying to cram in as many people.
3:00:39 We pay a high-end property tax here in Mono County and we all enjoy the quality of life here.
3:01:04 With 7,800 full-time residents and a population that swells to 28,000 on busy weekends, it is the second homeowners that are underwriting the quality of life that everyone in Mammoth enjoys. It would never exist on the tax base of 7,800 full-time residents. So let's stop pretending that it does. Our voice deserves to be heard, and we pay that right every year when we pay our property taxes. My husband's company hosts an annual ski trip every year.
3:01:33 We avoid Mammoth Lakes because we cannot rent a home that will provide the amount of beds that we need and the privacy that we desire. We go to places like Park City and other Utah resorts for this. We would like to bring people into Mammoth Lakes. We want to bring that quality that mammoth has to families and to generations of people that will keep coming here.
3:02:01 So I think, like the other people have said, you know, it's time to rethink this. Open up the vast amount of money that we have to bring to the community, especially in light of what has happened with the airport. So if the council can give us their time and attention, the other homeowners, if we can go ahead and put a community group together to investigate this further that would help alleviate
3:02:31 The expense that some of the other people thought that this could bring, we're all for that, and we'll gladly, gladly help. So thank you for your time, and we appreciate it. Thank you, Cindy. John Baruch, homeowner. Been in Mammoth for an excess of 30 years, unfortunately, or fortunately. At this point, I'm going to speak against single-family residence rentals.
3:03:01 And one of the reasons I'm going to speak against it, and I have no emotions here, by the way, because no one was next to me, is, first of all, why are we talking about it? And what are we looking at as far as, we need information, and we've known this for 10, 15 years now. So why are we here? Why are we even talking about this? I think it needs to be vetted. It needs the pros and cons to be there. I assume from what I've heard and what I've read, what people are looking for are large units.
3:03:31 I don't know, say you've got 5,000 or 4,000 houses, whatever houses we have, so you take that and say, okay, how many of those are really large units, and I'm assuming that's going to be over 4,000 square feet. I'm just picking a number. So then you narrow that down, because why would you want to run a single family home as opposed to a condo if you want less than that? That's what I'm reading from the papers. So how many large homes do you have that are actually going to be rented?
3:03:56 And then when you look at that, I think it was brought up at Planning Commission, you have large. Now you have Stonegate. You've got Timbers. You've got some units out at Snow Creek. You've got Talus at 5,000 square feet. We just did a survey at Stonegate. And, you know, there's 14 units there, which half of them are in a rental program. Those are 3,500 square foot houses. And they are houses. They're not detached. They're detached.
3:04:26 If the person wanted to come up, they could easily get two of those or three of those. The other thing as far as taxation is concerned, don't forget, homeowners, second homeowners who bought condominiums were taxed heavily for that to begin with. We paid diff fees. They paid transportation fees. There should be a survey as to how much it is, $23,000 per unit. Do you realize that the units that were built after 2007,
3:04:55 Are paying a transportation fee of $341 a year. So there are roughly 500, 400 condos right now paying that transportation fee. And that goes up on a yearly basis based on CIP. So we also, as condominium owners, also are paying solar removal. They're paying for management fee.
3:05:20 They make sure that there's not overstaffing of cars, over parking of cars. If there are, they find other places to park them. So it is a business. And if you want to try something, why not take some of the houses that I think are legal, I'm not positive, but I think there are certain areas that are legal to rent single-family homes, and try that for an example, I believe.
3:05:44 Chair 15, for instance, I think you can remember, I'm not positive, so I won't say that, but if there are any legal places, do it. On what I saw in the back of the 12 or 14 CCNRs of houses, there were only two that specifically included single-family rentals for nightly rentals, and the other 10, kind of iffy or no. And you've got to remember, when people bought these,
3:06:07 There's an exclusion. And it was against the law to rent. So when you buy a single-family home, you knew this forever. And if we do do this, I think it should be vented. It should be figured out what we're doing. And at that point, there should be a fee if we're going to put housing into it. In the meantime, if you want to do something for income, and also, I don't really know if they're going to have a decrease in income. I'm hearing a thousand million bucks, two million bucks. When you've got condos at 35% and 30% rental,
3:06:36 I have a tough time believing you're going to pick up any more TOT. I think this is going to be a swap. But if you want to pick up, if you're looking for dollars, if that's the why, how about enforcing single-family homes that are being rented and enforce that and find the people that are renting illegally. In the meantime, while we're having this discussion. Those are my comments. Thank you. Thanks, John. Hello, Council.
3:07:09 I just want, I'm not a property owner here. I'm sorry, can you state your name for the public? Oh, okay, I'm sorry. Yeah, my name is Jared Kimmerle. I'm not a property owner here. I'm a vacationer. I'm a person of modest means. I'm a software engineer, roughly 60,000 a year. You know, I can't necessarily afford to come here and rent for
3:07:38 A month at a time. But I would like to come up for a week at a time. And I think that's, I love this community. I've been to Devil's Postpile. I've been to Rainbow Falls. I've been, you know, mountain biking at the mountains. I love to come here and vacation and enjoy the wonderful goodness that is Mammoth Lakes.
3:08:07 By not allowing nightly rentals, you are somewhat, in a sense, you know, not allowing people like me to come up here and do that. And I just wanted to put in a word for that, you know, that you would consider nightly rentals. You know, me and my wife, we're not riffraff. We, you know, we want to, you know, come in here and abide the rules of the community.
3:08:36 And have a good time. So I would appreciate it if you would allow nightly rentals. Thank you. Thank you, Jerry. Greg Martino. I've been up here before. I'm a homeowner. I think one of the things everybody's saying is that the town council should allow the nightly rentals. I think as Councilman Eastman pointed out, and I think as the attorney's memo points out, even if the council changes the zoning, 75%, maybe more than that,
3:09:11 of the subdivisions will still prohibit it based upon their CC&Rs. Whether you're going to get the homeowners association or individuals to get the necessary percentages, some of them are 75%, some of them are as high as 90% to amend their CC&Rs to change that, I think it's unlikely. So the fact, the two points about what we want to do here is to get revenue and supposedly open up homes tonight, the rentals, I think that's changing the zoning, it's very unlikely that either of those things are going to happen.
3:09:39 You have certain areas where there aren't CC&Rs. That will happen. You'll then be able to allow those nightly rentals. But my guess is most of those areas are not the trophy homes, are not the homes where you want 10 and 12 people or multi-generational families, two or three families to stay there. They're in the older areas. They're smaller homes. They're situations where they don't have the CC&Rs.
3:10:02 So I don't think you're going to get trophy homes. I don't think you're going to get these big homes that people want to rent and therefore get these people that are supposedly, which I don't believe is the fact anyway, that are supposedly not coming here because they don't have homes to rent. You're still going to have the CCNRs that are going to prohibit it. But what you're going to have is a problem where the homeowners association or individual residents are now going to have more of a problem because my belief is once you take away the zoning requirement or prohibition, the people are going to ignore the CCNRs.
3:10:31 And then the homeowner associations are going to be putting the burden, it's going to be put up on the burden of the homeowner associations and the individuals to enforce their CC&Rs, which is very difficult. They're not going to have the town to be able to call up and say, hey, they're violating the zoning, we need to investigate this. The town attorney's third option that he proposes is, that doesn't really solve the problem unless his zoning, his proposal, which is unclear in his memo,
3:10:58 Is that you're going to change the zoning ordinance that says we allow single family rentals provided the homeowners association adopts the following language allowing transient rentals, then is the town going to enforce that? If that means then if my homeowners association doesn't allow it and somebody's illegally renting, that should be then a violation of the zoning as it is now. Can I call up and say, hey, they're violating the zoning. Is the town going to then look to enforce that?
3:11:25 So again, just changing the zoning is not going to solve your problem. There's a much bigger complicated issue because of the CC&Rs that everybody seems to just ignore. You can do more study, you can get more facts, you can bring up more information about whether you're going to get TOTs, what the vacancy factor is, etc. But the bottom line is when all of that's done, you still have the CC&Rs in the majority of the communities that are going to prohibit it regardless of what the Town Council does. We're going to waste time, staff, money, and energy.
3:11:55 Thank you. Thank you, Greg. Hi, my name's Frank Moore. I'm a part-time resident here, pretty much 50-55% of the year I'm up here. I've owned a house here now for over 10 years. I've rented a condo here prior to that. Anyway, I'm also a real estate broker, been a broker for 20 years, pretty much retired now. He did hear from over here that the town's looking for every nickel and dime has helped pay this huge debt for the next 20 years.
3:12:31 I don't know how we got into that situation. I mean, that's past history. But you've got single-family homes that are considered somehow separate from condominiums. I don't get this, having sold real estate. Why do condos allow nightly rentals in single-family houses? Can't do it. That's something I don't understand. Other towns, other places you go, that you can rent a house. If you go to Europe, I'm from Europe, I stay in Europe.
3:13:00 You could contact a company in Europe. You could rent a house if that's what you needed to do. If you had eight, ten people in your party, you got a house usually. If you want to stay a month in Europe, you got a house. You didn't rent a condo. I've rented apartments in Europe. I've rented houses in Europe. You go to Lake Tao. I was in Lake Tao two years ago. Friends of mine rented a house. They had a big group. They wanted to play music. They were musicians.
3:13:26 They were skiers. They want to play music at night. You can't do that at a condo. You can't do that at a hotel. You can do it at a house. You people, they're saying the lodging association said, oh, you've got to enforce the rules because you've got to get these people into the lodges. Well, shut the condos down and you get more people in the lodges. My point is that I do have some people that stay seasonal rentals. You know where they are? They're the parents of the kids in the ski program. There are different types of people that come here.
3:13:56 They don't necessarily fit into a condo or a hotel. They want to leave their stuff here. They're commuting from LA, wherever. They're commuting up that room every week, every second week. The kids are winning races here. And they're a different crowd. There's a different crowd that comes here that does not fit into condos, does not fit into the hotels and motels. Anyway, and the point that the lady made about
3:14:25 Paying the property tax here. I pay property tax here. I'd like to be treated as equal to the condo owners. Thank you. Thank you, Frank. Mr. Mayor, I just, real quickly, I want a clarification from staff. Single-family homes, three neighborhoods were mentioned earlier. I believe it was Tallis, the Timbers, and Stonegate. Do, how many,
3:14:53 How many single family homes do we have that are allowed to be rented? Those are condos. Those are all condos. All those are condominiums. Mostly in the resorts zone or in the North Carolina specific plan. What about Crooked Pines? Crooked Pines. Crooked Pines has single family. Their townhomes are something that's also in Sierra Star. There's some single family homes in...
3:15:21 Crooked Meadows. I just wondered if we have a number of the number of houses that are available for rentals. I think that Mr. Brown had done some research on this and she thought there were like 106, 110 of those newer townhome condo type product that was in town right now. 106? I think he's talking about homes. Homes. Single family homes that are allowed to rent in resort corridors. Do you know Mickey?
3:15:50 Commission was that since 1999 there was 117 luxury townhomes that were four bedrooms or larger, but I don't know how many legal single family residents we are, but you are right on Crooked Pine, which is resort. Crooked, what's it, is it Crooked Pines? Right. Right past the cabins, there's that little street of homes that's legal to do short terms. Just a handful? Right. But I don't know how many for sure. But that's it. Right. Okay.
3:16:18 I just want a clarification. Yeah, just a handful. Thank you. Good evening. My name is Barbara Hadley, and I've been in some aspect of real estate since the 70s. In the mid-1990s, I spent considerable time up in Mammoth, lived here pretty full-time working in the real estate field.
3:16:50 Now I live in Montecito in Santa Barbara and I still work part-time, mostly retired, in real estate. I am here this week visiting family and I'm just amazed at this whole conversation. Every aspect of real estate since I started has changed and I think anybody who's been
3:17:16 Around very long would agree that technology, the internet, and all the rest of it, including the banks, the loans, etc. Families and businesses now, and I'm coming up here as a tenant, are looking for where they want to go in a very different way than when I was selling Mammoth just a few years ago.
3:17:41 You don't really go out and get brochures anymore. You go online, you see what you can get in Aspen, you see what you can get in Utah, and you look at Mammoth. I have friends in Southern California who ask me frequently about Mammoth and why Mammoth hasn't kept up with all the rest of the resorts that we all attend.
3:18:09 There isn't a place to come and get a single family dwelling. In today's market, tenants are looking for easy access. Manly finally has an airport. And I was here through all that struggle. Terrific. Get on the plane. If it's full, it gets here. If it's not, it has mechanical difficulties. Once you get here,
3:18:39 You're looking for quality lodging. And quality lodging is not necessarily 3,000 square feet. It happens to be what you see online and what's interesting to you. And that might be by owner. Most likely it is because there develops a rapport. It's something to seriously consider. People in my age group are looking for the multi-generation vacations.
3:19:09 We want quiet. I don't want to go rent a condo with a bunch of noisy people. I think you're missing the boat on that part. And I think people are willing to pay for a five-star experience. And that five-star experience does not have to be the Westin. It can be anything that's available. So I would just like to say that currently, in my opinion,
3:19:37 From the south as a tenant, Mammoth is not competing for the upper income families. We can get here, but we need a place to stay. Thank you. Thank you, Barbara. Good evening. I'm Mark Lehman. No relation, I don't think, that close. I bought a place in the ghetto three or four years ago.
3:20:12 Single family cabin. We can sleep 10 people in there. I'm up here probably three months out of the year. It would be nice to have a legal option to be able to put it up for nightly rentals. I think it cost me about over $20,000 in mortgage payment and everything else to keep the place up here. I have no intention in selling it right now, but
3:20:44 The arguments against it seemed like they're just putting their head in the ground. I read the staff reports. It looked like there were three different options, putting your feet in the water a little bit, going all full bore on the process. If you start small and say where it's allowed, open it up.
3:21:12 Have some sort of a process. Obviously, you're going to need to in the planning department as far as getting permits, paying fees. I'm sure there's probably 30, 40 percent of homeowners in town that would certainly take a serious look at it. And from the standpoint of whether or not single family homes are a draw, we've
3:21:43 Rented houses in Santa Fe and Laguna Beach in San Francisco. It is very nice to pull up to a house and feel like you're at a home, not in a sanitized hotel room or a condo that's been thrashed. And quite frankly, it's definitely a draw for the town. Will it offset some of the condo income? Who knows?
3:22:11 You know, if the TOT tax goes down after a year instead of going up, then you revisit it. But looking at it from the standpoint of, well, let's wait and, you know, we don't want to get that extra income. Let's shoot everybody that's doing it legally now. I don't think it's productive. So thank you very much. Thank you, Mark.
3:22:48 Thanks, Terry. These are facts. These are from a study that was done, and actually a couple studies, in South Lake Tahoe. Thank you. It was kind of interesting because it's kind of a timeline. So back in 2004, 2005, there was just kind of an informational piece that was put together.
3:23:26 An Economy in Transition. This is for South Lake Tahoe. 1999, school enrollment started to slide and four years decreased by 700 students. 2004 to 5 lost another 261 students. This drop was proportionate to the local population. With low interest rates, the sale of homes was dominated by second home buyers, with local residents couldn't borrow against the equity on their own.
3:23:50 2003-04 single-family homes sales increased 33% with 75% of those going to second home buyers. Many of those homes are being converted from year-round single-family to seasonal, long-term, and vacation rental properties. Then there's just a little bit of information in the change of that tourism picture at that time. The fundamental premise is that there will be a smaller, more upscale community based upon the following changes we see occurring. This is still based on the 2004 model.
3:24:19 Second, home ownership, vacation rentals, hotels, motels, and timeshare house. Most of the visitors, but vacation rentals of houses has been very active over the past few years. Where do homeowners go when their home is rented out? The last eight years has seen a marked upswing in single-family rentals. Streets that had numerous year-round residents in the 80s may now have one or two. With profits made, they have little to no incentive to rent out to year-round residents.
3:24:45 With this, desirable employees are hard to find. Non-professionals often have two jobs, and professionals find their wages reduced from comparable big city physicians. The fundamental role of the police will not change. The manner in which they operate will change dramatically. As rent increases, the forces lower and middle class workers force the middle class workers off the hill.
3:25:08 And it does decrease domestic violence, but will be met with an increase in vandalism, burglary, and burglary, and noise violations brought on by weekend revelers. Primary and secondary schools will continue to have reductions. This brings it into the current year. This is a report, and I pulled it off the internet, from South Lake Tunnel that was just finished in October 2012.
3:25:34 And they didn't use 2011-2012 for their figures because of that poor ski conditions, that snow conditions we had last year. So demand for lodging decreased 30% since 2001-2 to 2010-11. Where is that single family rental benefit? That's my comment. 25% TOT decrease 2005-06 to 2010-11 until they had a tax increase in 10-11.
3:26:03 Despite decrease in lodging, skier days increased 22% from 2008 to 2010. Where's that compliance? California retail increased 19% between 2002 and 2005, mostly due to Heavenly Village. Properties that have reinvested, this is really important, properties that have reinvested have seen the most growth. Those that haven't fared the worse.
3:26:30 With a surplus of rental properties, rental rates are such that reinvestment is nearly impossible. So their property inventory is kind of interesting. Only 9% of their property lodging inventory is through a management company. The highest percentage of their inventory for the casino hotels is 15%, but the number of people is at 36%. So it definitely goes by what's around them and what the...
3:27:01 Opportunity is, whether it's a lake, whether it's a key scene, or there has to be something to draw those folks. Single-family rentals weren't even mentioned in this whole October 2012 discussion. South Lake Tahoe has more inventory than its competitors, clearly has an oversupply of lodging units. South Lake Tahoe's ADR is $102 a night. A little hard to reinvest at $102 a night. Wow.
3:27:28 Mammoth Lakes continually compares ourselves to other resorts while we want to make sure we're offering what our guests are looking for. We don't want to be a cookie cutter. We need to excel in what we have to offer above and beyond the other resorts. Looking at the information provided in 2003-04 to today with South Lake Tahoe was very eye-opening.
3:27:55 Where is the enormous benefit of the single family rentals? Lodging is now down 30% with TOT down 25%. This report was just done in October 2013. They didn't use that. I already told you that. South Lake Tahoe is going back to the basics with the key elements they're focusing on being diversify into more recreation, hiking trails, et cetera, something that we have to offer in spades.
3:28:16 Leverage history and entertainment and unique environment. Upgrade the visitor's experience and provide shopping and retail. Those are all things that we've discussed and that we're looking at with our Economic Stimulus Council and we've done with our special events. Let's not follow in someone else's footsteps. Let's keep our sense of community and neighborhoods. Maybe that's something Mammoth Lakes did well in the past that has saved our community for our future. If someone's CC&Rs allows nightly rentals,
3:28:45 Let those that want to benefit go through the legal process to open their neighborhood zoning plan and general amendment plan. I keep hearing time and time again that we don't have homes to rent. We have, this comes from the white paper that we had through Mammoth Lakes. We have 106 homes in the resort quarter plus many other townhomes, standalone homes within an association and large condos that will accommodate large groups. We obviously need to work together to educate those within the rental industry and our guests as to what's out there to rent.
3:29:13 This will be accomplished with the information that the town is now collecting. We don't even have an inventory of what we have to rent out in this town, which just amazes me that we even discuss this when we don't even know what we have to rent. So this is being discussed through our TOT committee, and there's things that are being adjusted, and hopefully we'll have an inventory by January. Our condo inventory is higher than any other peer resort because single-family rental in the majority of Mammoth Lakes is not legal.
3:29:41 So condos of different sizes, some more upscale than others to diversify what we have to offer to our rental pool were built. There are many that purchased a condo over a home so they could offset their investment through nightly rentals because that's what was legal to do so. And do we really need another lawsuit? I know there was one letter here that stated that nightly rentals is not a business of a single family home. And I just have to say that I beg to differ. You have to have a business license. You have to have a TOT license.
3:30:09 And it should be a business. And to my knowledge, unfortunately, in California, you cannot say that somebody has to go through any type of property management company in California real estate law. I don't know. That would be something that would be discussed because I know that's something that Whistler requires, that they had to have a front desk and that they had to go through a company to keep the quality that they were looking at and keep the control. So I just wanted to give this to you because the study's quite large. The 2-2012, I have it.
3:30:39 I found it on the Internet if anybody would like to read it, but it was kind of eye-opening looking at that timeline. Thank you, Terry. I'm really, really terrible speaking in public, so hopefully I'll get through it. Diane Stilwell, 101 Great Escapes. I don't completely agree with the Laws Association on every last point. I do think that if I were a homeowner, I think it's a bit un-American that it's not comparable to own a condo and a home that you...
3:31:18 One has one law, one has another. I do, I do, I read every letter that everyone wrote. It seemed like 80% of them were for doing this, but many, many of them were almost complete copies of the other letter, so it seemed like an email that just went around and people changed the sentence. My disagreements with the points, there's a few points. The first gentleman spoke, said we aren't busy this week because we,
3:31:46 Don't rent homes. We aren't as busy this week because Christmas is on Wednesday, and that is a fact. And Laney Summers is completely right that if you want to ask, you know, what's up, you do need to ask rental agencies. Now, our company is all high-end. I have 120 condos. I have maybe 20 that we would call standard. I get 20 or 30.
3:32:14 Requests a week for places that hold 12 to 20 people. That's every week. I could rent them like pancakes. It would happen. My whole issue is, and we have these issues in condos, is parking. People will not carpool. That is not true. So that was in a lot of the letters points that people or families are going to carpool.
3:32:39 People are families, and the whole reason people want homes is because they do want to stay together. There are friends that want to get together once a year. There are families that want to get together. They are not noisier than anybody else, and it is true that that probably would not disturb the neighborhood to a great level any more than the 1% that always disturbed the people. That is a good point as well. But they won't carpool. I mean, we have a lot of large condos. We have a lot of the big snow creeks. We have a lot of condos that sleep 10 or 12.
3:33:08 Everyone brings too many cars. Our biggest issue is having a place to tell the people to bring those third and fourth and fifth cars because they'll bring them. And unless the city addresses another place for people to park, they will stick out on the road and then you won't be able to plow. And it is very important on some of these streets that that plow can get by or your help can't get out, you can't get to work. It's a big, huge problem. I see that as the biggest problem.
3:33:37 Biggest problem is that you're taking tax from a company that you know is largely paying the tax or at least trying to be legal. We have all known for years we're going to get audited. We all know that we're going to continue to get audited. Private individuals do not get audited at the rate we get audited as companies. That is unfair. This town settled, I heard, in Lodging Associates, for 20 cents on the dollar for people renting illegally. When I get audited, I'm going to get to the...
3:34:06 The opportunity to pay probably 120 cents on the dollar. So that's a bit unfair. I think that the second biggest thing that the town needs to figure out is how to make absolutely sure that these people pay the tax on the money they collect. Now, I as a company, I could print out a two-page report with my tax return that would be really a pain to
3:34:29 Fake. And I think people that are individuals could also be expected. I mean, we don't do that. We just write it down and when we get audited, you'll catch us if we do things illegally. But private individuals are not going to get audited at our rate. They will not comply because people, you know, it's human nature. So that needs to be addressed, that making sure that the proper amount of money gets paid, taxed, etc. The third enormous problem is that
3:34:59 People don't hire legal help. And I don't mean illegal aliens. I mean that when you rent privately, you get person X or person Y to do all kinds of labor to make it happen. These people need to have business licenses and the town needs to make sure of it. Because if you get person X that will clean a home for $200, but Laney Summer's company has to because she's paying workers' comp and she's paying
3:35:28 You know, health care pretty soon and all the things that companies have to pay. She has to charge $300 for the exact same thing because that person is not paying taxes because they do not have a business license. So we need to make sure that people rent, renting on their own higher legal businesses because then that keeps it at a fair and balanced, it's competitive. Like you could hire me to clean your place, which we don't do that by
3:35:56 You know, I'm not trying to get more cleaning. I'm just saying that I would have to charge more because all of my people are, you know, they're paying taxes. And that is a huge problem here. People are renting on their own condos right now. They're getting their cleanings for 50, 60, 70 bucks. That is impossible for a legal company to provide with linen. Impossible. It's only done because these people are not filing tax returns. So that is another thing. And that's X number of more.
3:36:24 A lot more money going into this city in a different way on taxes. I had a quick question on something. Forget it. Who's talking? I am. Oh. I thought it was over there. I have an ear issue. Who's talking? I am. When you have people calling for 10, 20 people and you can't put them in a condo, what do they end up doing? I have no idea. A lot of people rent, too.
3:36:52 But we do run out. Do they get multiple condos from you, or do they just leave? They do until we're out, and I assume they call everywhere in town. And people constantly tell me, oh, we'd like to rent a home, but we couldn't find one, or whatever. And our constant response is, it's illegal to rent a home in Mammoth. And people always tell me, oh, no, it's not. And I say, oh, yes, it is. You can rent out, but your money's at risk these days. It didn't used to be, but it is now, because, you know, you are going after people.
3:37:21 I personally think, I mean, this is going to be legal. I mean, it's just a fact. The mountain wants it, and when the mountain wants it, it is going to happen. We just have to address all the really hard issues to make sure you're not taking money you're already getting and getting less money and diluting the market from legal things to illegal things. And that can be done, but you do have to think about it. The other thing about people in homes, they don't have their children. When they say they have 16 or 20, they usually have 25. And, you know, I mean, it's true.
3:37:50 So, you know, you really need a way of making sure that the neighborhoods aren't impacted, and I think that that will happen. I have to go to Europe, and we always rent homes, but we have never gone anywhere without a caretaker. I mean, there is a caretaker that you can call, and this whole thing that we have to have a 24-7 person on the business license, I mean, those are just words. Nobody's enforcing that, and until you've enforced all the things that are already on the books,
3:38:18 We can't add this thing. I think we will add it, but those are the issues. And my company will probably make a fortune when you make homes legal because high-end people are terrified their home's going to get trashed and they're going to hire a company like mine or other companies. There might be a bunch of people in the middle that do it themselves. And again, I urge you to make sure that they hire people that have to charge the service at a competitive rate or you're losing even more money.
3:38:46 Again, I have to cut you off. We've gone over the three minutes like twice. But thank you. Yeah, we appreciate it. Council, would just mind maybe let me make a comment. Yes, sir. So our presentation tonight was really about asking the council for direction on whether you want us to do a feasibility study. This is a project like any project. Someone's floated an idea out.
3:39:16 And then the question is, does the idea have enough merit to do some feasibility work? We could do that work and then come back with some results on that. And then you could decide whether you want us to then really actually go and build the project or whatever that term might be that you're looking at. So that's what we're looking for, some direction on a feasibility study. And I think, too, the time to really dive into these questions and concerns would be if we decide to go down the line further. It'll happen in a workshop or in a... So...
3:39:46 With that, Dave, you're up here, but if we could reserve more comments and questions for assuming we move forward. Sure. I'll just take David Harvey, and I'm speaking as a resident of Mammoth. Dave, you looked at my notes. Excellent points. Excellent points. I'll just touch on a couple of things here, and it won't take much time. HOA versus Municipal Code.
3:40:17 That's something we can deal with. I'm sure we have the legal minds to get through that and be able to work that out. The body of work, it falls well within the scope of the zoning work plan that is currently underway. It's not an oddball kind of thing. It's exactly the type of issue that you would want to discuss.
3:40:46 The one thing that I did want to touch on was we have spent a lot of money and time and effort with TOT enforcement. Obviously, there are people here renting single-family homes, and they are generating income, quite a bit of income. And the more and more I hear about our TOT collection from illegal rentals,
3:41:17 It shocks me, quite frankly. Now, the one thing, and this is something that is not new, is that I always felt that if we're going to go after these people, well, and we're now finding that, yes, indeed, there are many, many successful folks out there doing this, why don't we want to bring them into the fold? Why do we not?
3:41:45 I want to show them a clear, concise path to get on the TOT train, ASAP. That's the kind of money. I'm not talking about 600 units out there being rented and a gazillion billion dollars coming in in TOT. I'm talking about what we are uncovering that already exists in our community. And instead of being maybe the...
3:42:16 The heavy-handed enforcer, maybe we become enforcers that also show a way for these people to continue on with their single-family rentals, because there's obviously a market for it, and assist them in that process. And I have other points, but I'll leave them. Thank you very much. Thank you, Dave.
3:42:45 I am one of those people that rent my homes. I've been through the enforcement process, and I am paying my DOT penalties and interest and enforcement fees. I do have a proposal. I think you shouldn't give everybody a green light to rent their house, but why don't you have a special use permit? If somebody wants to rent their house,
3:43:11 They apply for the permit. They pay for it. There's rules and regulations. And every year they have to get this permit again. If they have too many rules that have been broken, if they have too many complaints, they don't get another permit. It gets revoked. That's all I have to say. Thanks, Jeannie. Okay. Yeah, Celia. My name is Celia Stewart, and I...
3:43:41 I was watching the Town Council meeting on television, and I wanted to just come in and talk. Sorry, I just got graced, so it's hard to speak. I live near Eagle Lodge, and some of the people in my neighborhood do rent their homes out. And it hasn't been a huge problem because there aren't that many homes doing it. But when you think about it multiplying, I think it could be a really big problem because
3:44:11 You know, just last month a guy had a bear in his garage because he left the garage door open and he said, what, you have bears here? And we had to help him with that. And, you know, at one point I went across the street at 4 in the morning and said, you guys, I think you're probably on a different time zone, but I'm trying to sleep.
3:44:32 Because it was summertime. And they said, no, we're just having a bachelor party. And they were really nice people. And as I said, it hasn't been a huge problem because it's not legal yet. But I just think that, you know, I heard someone tonight say, hey, let's face it, that, you know, the town is supported by tourists. And we are supported by tourists. But those tourists are served by the people in this town.
3:44:59 And we have people with children who want a quality of life where they want to live and not have to deal with the craziness of rentals in their neighborhood. And so I would like you to just consider that as well. Thank you, Celia. Okay, I think we went there, buddy. With that, I guess I'll bring it back to council and see if we can come up and give staff some direction.
3:45:29 Mr. Mayor, if I may, just to get it started, I wanted to further clarify. I asked earlier tonight how many single-family homes we had in town that were in an area that allowed nightly rentals. And it's a handful. And then the number of townhomes was mentioned. I think it was 106 or 109 that people could rent. They had the large units. And just for perspective, I wanted to mention to the council,
3:45:59 In particular, out at Snow Creek Phase 4, and most of you are aware of that project, Snow Creek 4 has 40 townhomes that are not only 4 bedroom units and sleep 10 people or more, but they're also equipped with a 2 car garage, so they're essentially a house, it's a duplex, and I know some of the other Snow Creeks have the same type of units.
3:46:29 These are big units and if a family or if a group wants to come to Mammoth and rent a unit like that, which is essentially a house, they're already available in what is arguably the most beautiful setting that we have in the community. So in that, John, correct me if I'm wrong, but on an annualized basis, I would suspect that those units are
3:47:00 Close to about 30% occupied. So lots of room for, you know, additional rentals on the big units. So I'm not, personally I'm not sold that there's a need in the community that's not being provided for people. We have, periodically, not often, but periodically we'll have a wedding group come up and they'll rent five units. We had the, when the UCLA
3:47:28 Women's Volleyball Team was practicing at the Snow Creek Athletic Club. They would come up, and they would rent five units. So big groups, if big groups want to come up, the availability is there for those sized units, and yet they're maybe 30% occupied on an annualized basis. Okay. Jo, do you have any comments? I do.
3:47:56 It is also not a priority for me at this time while we're trying to survive and restructure ourselves. And I will still go back to the statement we made a few years back is that if a neighborhood came to us and asked for it, that was the time to start to implement a project. I object to the idea that we're going to develop this whole set of regulations and then see if anybody is interested.
3:48:20 John, I think your number on the product was a little bit understated because you didn't count Sierra Star where we have definitely trophy homes that are and can be available for rent. I also look back to the statement that John Morris made about we started this project with the idea that we would get the enforcement of the legal rentals up to speed first and at some point move on to the other discussion.
3:48:48 I don't think we're there yet. And I also appreciated all the comments from everyone, but we do have the product. We have the product right now in the resort corridors. And diluting the product across more units concerns me because we did not plan those areas for that kind of a...
3:49:14 I heard comments about, you know, getting roads plowed and things like that. I think we have to realize that this community has been very, very careful in defining the general plan to plan for higher density and increased usages in the areas that are close to the resort portals, etc. And I just can't see that this is the time to move forward with this. Okay. Michael?
3:49:44 I think that, as Dave mentioned, I mean, we're not going to vote on this tonight. I mean, this is simply our direction to affirm the Planning Commission's recommendations. And I support the recommendation, and I'm prepared to make a motion for it. Okay. Well, let me ask Rick if he has comments, and I'll make a few, and then...
3:50:10 Be ready for a motion. My comment is, you know, I'm sitting here as a council member who was on the council for eight years and then not for four, and it's just stunning to me that it's deja vu. It's amazing. I can recall a discussion, what I can't recall is the exact year. That's called age. Yeah, I know that.
3:50:38 But it's exactly this discussion. And the discussion was whether we were going to vote to have a feasibility study. And so instead what we've had tonight is what we had about six or seven years ago, which was a debate or at least a public statement. I haven't heard one new thing tonight. I'm not suggesting that the comments are not important because this is, for me personally, fascinating.
3:51:06 A lot of different arguments, complex subject. Nobody here, except for one person who said it's inevitable, is in the middle. People on one side or the other. Great political debate. However, it's not yet fact-based. And so what I called for some years ago, and the council said no, I think it was about the fourth or fifth time I tried, so I finally gave up.
3:51:35 was to have the debate. And in having that debate, to have staff work up the, or obtain the facts from peer resorts, whether they're the same or not, doesn't matter to me, but work up the facts nonetheless to see what the experiences of others have been. This is not uncharted territory. We know from other experience what communities
3:52:02 Have done and not done and how it's worked or can know how it's worked or how it has not worked. Instead what we have tonight is a public presentation by people who have a position when we're there. And by the way, I appreciate the comment, but that's not what I thought we were going to be doing tonight. I actually said to Matthew on the way in, well this isn't going to be a very long meeting. I actually had a party to go to about two and a half hours ago.
3:52:27 I'll get out of here pretty early. And Matthew said, oh, no, all these people are going to be here. And I'm thinking to myself, wait a minute. The only thing we're discussing tonight is whether we move forward. So with respect to that issue and not the issue of whether I'm supportive or not supportive, I'm in favor of moving forward and moving forward now and prepared to give staff the direction that whatever direction it needs in order to do so and am prepared to fund it from
3:52:55 The $318,000 grant that we received to finish the zoning code update. After all, this is a zoning question. It is appropriate for this to happen now. There you go. That's my... I don't know how I can say it anymore emphatically. Thank you. Well, I've read everybody's letters. And I think, Rick, you're either in favor of this thing or you're not. There's not a lot of in the middle.
3:53:21 I have created my own list of pros and cons, and they're just about the same on either side. It's really fascinating to me, and I think at the end of the day, whatever direction we end up going, the facts need to be brought forward, because as Rick said, this was brought forward six years ago. I bet six years from now, if it didn't at least get vetted out, it's going to come up again. So at the very least, I'm interested in hearing the facts.
3:53:49 I'm interested in seeing where it is part of zoning. We have money allocated for them to go through the process. So I'm certainly interested in hearing that. A lot of concerns I do have are the impacts for our neighborhoods, our quality of life. Diff fees were not paid, as John Avruka appropriately mentioned. And I'm just assuming as we go through this process, hopefully all these questions and concerns will be written down by staff and be addressed.
3:54:18 So without going too far into it, I mean, I could go on for a while on this, but I'm in favor of learning more about it. And I think that's where I stand right now in making it part of the zoning code update. I would definitely say this. If we start running short of time or money, I want to make sure that the zoning code and CBIS components are made of primary priority.
3:54:45 Don't want it also, I do not want it to have an impact on the current enforcement. So if it starts pulling away from our current enforcement procedures, I for one don't want to see that impacted not one bit. So with that I'd be in favor of learning more. Mr. Mayor, I'd like to make a motion to approve option one as presented by staff. Okay, we'll second that motion. And we have a second. Jamie, roll call please. Discussion.
3:55:11 Yeah, I just wanted to publicly state that doing a feasibility study on this issue is personally not a priority for me whatsoever. Okay. Thank you. Thank you, John. Roll call, please. No. No. No. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes. 3-2 to have some more information gathered on this topic.
3:55:43 Okay. That's it. With that, we adjourn. Yes. No.