TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2013

Town Council

· recording 2 hr 15 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

271 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:01 It at least sounds like you've shot someone. I know. Does Rick even know we have a meeting today? I know it. Maybe he doesn't realize this. I don't know. One million is a workshop, okay. You know.

0:21 Hey, Ray, you want me to start with you? Can you keep going? Sure.

0:48 Okay. We're going to go ahead and get started with our agendized 5 o'clock workshop meeting for discussion and direction concerning the review and budget proposed performance measures for public works and transportation, including the airport and contract with Eastern Sierra Transit Authority. So with that, I'll go ahead and turn the podium over to Ray. Thank you, Mr. Mayor, council members.

1:19 Tonight I'll be playing the role of Mariana Marysheva-Martinez and myself. She is unfortunately not here and I think stuck with some jury duty issues. What I'd like to do is just start off with a real brief introduction on the department, a little bit of background on what each division or each of the divisions and a brief synopsis of what each division is responsible for.

1:48 The Public Works and Transportation Department is comprised of five operating divisions. They are engineering, maintenance, fleet services, airport, and transportation, which is really transit. Engineering is responsible for providing development and review services. They manage the town's capital improvement program, which is principally funded through state and federal grants. In fact, in the last three to four years,

2:16 We have successfully applied for and received about $16.7 million in state and federal grants, which required a match of about $622,000, which is 3.7%. Not bad. Street maintenance is responsible for, obviously, street repair, traffic signals, street light maintenance, sign removal and replacement, storm drain maintenance, and snow removal, as well as facilities management.

2:44 Our Fleet Services Division maintains all of our town vehicles and equipment. They're also responsible for replacement and sale of surplus vehicles. We also have contracts with Mammoth Unified School District, the Fire District, as well as ESTA to provide service for their vehicles. Then we have the Airport Division. Their principal responsibility includes conducting safe and efficient day-to-day operations at the airport.

3:14 They collaborate effectively with other town departments to implement the airport capital improvement program and the ALP. They're also responsible for the ongoing and continued development of airport facilities to support regional commercial air service and general aviation. And then last but not least, transit, which we've been working on for

3:41 Quite a few years now and has been a very successful program. We operate a year-round free public system for our visitors and residents and that's done through a contract with Eastern Sierra Transit Authority. We also maintain the transit facility and the system signage. These divisions have budgeted revenues, which we'll get into here in just a second, and expenditures in 10 different funds.

4:09 Which include parks maintenance, engineering, gas tax, local transportation planning, Long Valley Mineral and Materials Site, Mellow Roos, Vehicle Service Fund, Airport Enterprise and Operations Fund, Airport Capital and Debt Service Fund, and the Transportation and Transit Fund. In addition, the department administers eight assessment districts that include North Village, Old Mammoth Road, Juniper Ridge, and the Bluffs.

4:36 So I just wanted to give you a quick little synopsis of the department, which as you know has expanded as of July 1st. I'd like to get into Marianna's PowerPoint, talk a little bit about the financials related to the department and the proposed performance measures. And if you look at your attachment A, which is...

5:08 Page 1 of 7, I believe, is where it starts. You'll see a revenue summary. This provides budget for FY 12-13, the current fiscal year as well as next, and prior year actuals for the Public Works Department and assessment districts, which are actually on the, actually it's not on that page. The assessment districts are in there as well. But you'll see a revenue summary.

5:38 The only thing that's really changed since the June 20th budget was approved is we've taken about $89,000 out of the department's general fund support, which went to Whitmore to keep the park and pool open for the balance of this year and maintain that one parks maintenance position. On page 2 of 7, you'll see a summary of...

6:08 Expenditures. Again, street maintenance was reduced by $89,000 to cover those costs that I just mentioned. And then on page 3 of 7, you'll see expenditures by category. There's a lot of numbers here, obviously, so if you have specific questions about numbers, I will try to answer those, or our finance manager's not here, but we'll get you answers if I can't answer them.

6:38 And then on page 5 of 7, you'll see, oh, assessment districts, page 4 of 7. So there's a revenues and expenditure summaries there for all of our assessment districts. And an outline of all of the positions in public works are on page 5 of 7. And you will note, I mean, I know you're already aware of this, but if you looked at maintenance worker under streets,

7:09 Going back to the very first call in 2008-09, we had 10 full-time equivalent maintenance workers. Today it says five and a half. It's five, five and a half. But we've essentially cut that group in half since 2008-2009. I think we've had a similar impact on parks maintenance. We started with a lower number, but basically I've reduced them by about half.

7:38 But having saved that one position this year, we're sort of status quo for the last couple years. And then last, for Public Works, Attachment A, page 6 of 7, are all the proposed performance measures. We've got seven programs, eight programs, excuse me, that we've listed performance measures for. And then there's two performance measures.

8:09 Two programs on the next page, Transportation Planning and Vehicle Services. Basically, there's a total of 21 proposed measures for all of these programs. You know, frankly, I'm a supporter of performance measures. And at the same time, when you're talking about 21 performance measures over all of these programs, that's a lot of time that it takes to actually collect data, analyze the data, present the data, monitoring, et cetera.

8:38 I think that these are reasonably good measures. Obviously, you don't want to implement performance measures that don't tell you anything. I think that these are good measures. But I guess what I'm saying is I would, you know, in starting in our next budget year, you know, we'll begin to measure these things and report out on them. But there may be some, you know, fluctuation from what's proposed tonight or what you suggest.

9:08 Performance measures that would be useful or informational for you going forward. And, you know, where we end up. I think over the next couple of years we'll get a pretty good sense for what are reasonable performance measures and, you know, what are measures that are going to give us useful, meaningful information. Hopefully that made sense. Let's see. If you go to attachment B1, which starts...

9:41 Well, it's typed page 104 on attachment B1, handwritten page 11. Again, you're going to see the same information repeated for airport and transportation. On the next page, you've got revenue summaries and expenditure summaries. And then on page 404, attachment B1, you'll see performance measures again for airport and for transportation.

10:11 These are our suggested performance measures. And again, those are the measures that we intend to begin working on in the next budget. I'm going through this pretty quickly. I just want to try to reserve as much time as possible for discussion. And then attachment B2, there's a breakdown of the Eastern Sierra Transit Authority budget. Among other things, you'll see revenue to ESTA of $677,000.

10:39 In bold in the top section there, that's the contract that the town has with ESTA. And then below that you'll see a breakdown of their expenses to give you a sense of what their costs are. So that's, in a nutshell, Public Works and Transportation. Her next slide really just addresses the next budget review and sort of scheduling matters.

11:12 I went through that pretty quickly. I'd love to answer questions and talk about the department to the extent that you want to. And with that, I'll end my presentation. Okay. Okay. Thanks, Ray. With that, I'll go ahead and open it up to any council members that have questions or comments, concerns regarding public works.

11:40 And then I'll go ahead and go out to the public and see if they have any comments or questions. So we'll start. Go ahead, Jo. Yeah, I had a couple, Ray, before you get too far away, or if you want to sit down and sit over there. Okay. I think you're right that this may be more measures than it's feasible for you to look at. And I think you've got some good ideas. And there were a couple that...

12:06 I kind of thought, well, do we really need that? And so one that I would suggest that maybe we don't need, or let me tell you what I think it says and then you can correct me. Yes. Under engineering, the second one. Which page, Jo? It's handwritten page nine, the public works department measurements. Page six or seven. Yes. Yeah.

12:29 Under the number two one where it says percent increase in the overall project cost during the fiscal year due to contract change orders, don't you have like a 10% contingency that you build into everything that would be, so would you do change orders that are within your total contract amount or are you talking about change orders that take you over a contract amount? So we typically build a contingency amount into the contract. The change orders would come after the contract is awarded.

13:00 Typically if you run into unforeseen circumstances in the field or, you know, something comes up where the design intent isn't exactly what you had imagined and you want to make a change, then you can negotiate a contract change with the contractor. Typically you want to keep those to a minimum because, frankly, you know, you always encounter unforeseen circumstances, but you want to minimize the amount of contract change orders just to control cost.

13:28 So would it be an example of the Lake Mary bike path posts being farther apart? That's one of the examples? Sure. That would be a situation where you need to change something in the field that you didn't anticipate. And because of that, I was just wondering, since they're unforeseen, I understand the idea of keeping the cost down.

13:54 But on the other hand, if they were unforeseen, is that really a measure that we want to? Well, you know, minimizing or measuring contract change orders is pretty standard. Okay. You know, whether it's 5% or 10%. 10% is a number I definitely would not want to exceed, so that's why I suggest starting at less than 10% for contract change orders. And, you know, what will happen is we've got data that we can review.

14:22 Going forward, we'll continue to collect data, and you'll see a trend with a type of project. And the idea is that it should help us tighten up some of the design work, depending if we see a change that occurs regularly, then that's going to tell us something. Okay. And then just a general comment, and I'm glad you mentioned design, because right now we contract some of that design out. Is that correct?

14:50 Most of our design work is contracted out. Most of our design is contracted out. And we also have contracts for a lot of the small strips of landscaping around town. So you've already contracted out certain services. Exactly. Public Works already follows sort of a public-private model in that we do mostly manage contracts.

15:14 And we contract a lot of work out. We contract, frankly, probably all of our design work. There may be some minor design that we do in-house, but it's mostly contracted out. As you know, we contract out assessment district work for Juniper, the bluffs. You know, snow removal is contracted out. So, yeah. Okay.

15:36 Mostly contract that out. Because that was the one thing that I didn't really see it spelled out in here anywhere is how much you are already contracting out. And I think that's an important thing maybe in next year's budget to have that in some way quantified. Sure. Yeah. Yeah. And, you know, I mentioned the dollars that we get in grants. You know, we're really proficient at writing grants and being awarded mostly transportation-related grants. But that work,

16:06 From the design through the construction is all contracted out. We do project management essentially and construction management. Thank you. Thank you, Joe. John, did you have any comments or questions for Ray? One comment and question. Ray, I just wanted to mention in general for council and staff, I think a lot of staff already realize it, but it's come up.

16:37 This winter, in December, we had a couple of small storms, and then we had no snow, essentially, like less than an inch of snow on the pavement, and yet the town crews went around and followed the roads, and I just wanted to state for council that the reason that they did that is so that they knew that it was going to be sunny. They knew we were in for some good weather, and it was still during the holiday time period.

17:06 So they go around and they scrape, even though it's only a quarter of an inch of snow or a half an inch of snow, they scrape that off, and they're also scraping any snow that had been compacted on the road, so that they create dark spots in the asphalt, and the more dark spots you create, then when the sun does come out, then it gets rid of the ice in the road, it's quicker. So most people, including my life,

17:32 I don't understand that and think it's crazy for the town to go out on the roads when there's no snow on the road, essentially. But it wasn't going to clear snow. It was done to get the roads clearer sooner. I have a question. I want to take advantage of Brian. I don't see him that often. But we've got four and a half positions at the airport with the airline service that we have.

18:01 You obviously made it through the two-week storm period just before Christmas. Is that, did that work okay with four and a half people? Well, you know, we actually have four and a half staff and we have two seasonal winter temporaries. And I think what this allowed us to do is actually for our record, we removed the snow a much earlier hour. And one of the things that we used to not start coming to school at 7.30.

18:31 We started at 6, and we actually have the runway and partial program open by 7 o'clock, and we actually are receiving planes at an earlier hour than we've done before. We worked out fine, and I think it's in a way it's like a business opportunity to look at in the future. We don't still have to hear the remainder of the ramp, but I mean, having enough people get in there early, and peeing off is actually what we need the airport out. Earlier, we had the earliest commercial flight ever

18:59 I would just add that we do have four full-time and two seasonals, as Brian said. The way it appears in the budget is a little bit different because some of their time is allocated to transit. So we're working airport and transit with the same folks.

19:29 With the same full-time folks. In wintertime, those people, those acquisitions. The two seasonals go, well, the two seasonals, oh yeah, yeah, right, in the wintertime. Exactly, yeah. No, it's worked out pretty well. I think it gave us a cover of that. The last thing that we want to do is not have the airport open for commercial service. And what we're finding out is we're not only having to go for commercial service, but with GA, we're open for GA.

19:57 It's working out really well, and I think it's a good model. It's something that we should be doing, because we want to be able to accommodate these people. And it's very likely that we'll have commercial flights as early as 8.30 next year. And so we're ready to go at 9 o'clock, and that can be a challenge. Yeah. Are there airlines? There's two airlines. There's United and what's it? Yeah, United and Alaska.

20:26 Four flights, going up to six flights, you know, on Thursday Friday Sunday. And we are getting all those, there's never been a flight missed due to the airport operations. We missed some views of weather, some views of mechanical. John Ernie probably found out on this, is that since those storms, we have just been very, very successful in getting all the flights in. And they are doing very well, and numbers are doing very well.

20:54 So the airlines are happy? The airlines are very happy. I think we work really well. One of the things we do at our airports is we work very well with the airlines, CSA, MBO. We really try to work as a cooperative and all pull together. And we do a lot of things that are very unusual with any other commercial airport, but we do them at our airport in terms of how we work staff, where CSA is allowed to go, and the responsibilities are.

21:21 What the airlines do is because we're small and we're able to do these things, we really work very closely together. I won't go into it, but I mean, it's just nice to say that we have some unique relationships here between PSA and the airlines and ourselves. We'll take both. And I can give you an update now, or if you're not going to talk about it.

21:47 Probably tonight a little more people will be watching it. Anything else, John? Michael. I just got a question on the entities comparing the cost and performance. Yeah. You have the cost compared on the performance but not on the cost at other peer resorts. Is that needed or not needed? Are you looking at page 707? Yeah, then on the airport's the same.

22:16 Yeah, and since you mentioned that, well, let me answer your question. The reason that the cost comparisons say no next to the out-of-state resorts or communities is because they are out-of-state. And we want to have, you know, we've got laws that are different between California and Colorado, for instance, that would skew the numbers. Okay. So we're going to do cost comparisons just for comparable towns or resorts in California.

22:46 And then we'll do performance comparisons on all of these. So it's the same with both. I just wanted to also let you know that under transportation, I failed to add Sun Valley, Idaho. So I would like to add that back in just to keep it consistent across the board for which places we're looking at. Ray, you talked about the reduction in personnel.

23:13 Maybe not reduction at the airport, but certainly the reduction of personnel in public works as opposed to snow removal and having fewer drivers running equipment. Is it fair to say that we have plenty of equipment to plow our roads, but we're short on drivers? And if that's the case, how did we get through the pre-Christmas and Christmas snowstorms with the limited number of drivers? Sure.

23:42 Yes, we have more than adequate equipment. The equipment we have is top-notch, honestly. The council has always been very supportive of that, you know, since I've been here, and I've been here a little over eight years now. But the fact is, is that each operator represents a piece of equipment, and if you don't have an operator, that equipment sits idle in the yard.

24:09 We do have five winter seasonals this year. I believe three of those, I can't remember if it's two or three of them are brand new and then the others are repeat, which is good because they know the neighborhoods and it really takes a couple years even for a good operator to learn how to remove snow here. So with our permanent staff and our seasonals, we have just enough operators to cover what we would consider a normal storm.

24:38 And meet what, you know, our policy for, you know, plowing every 12 hours and blowing every 20 hours. The potential problem comes is if somebody's sick or is off duty for some other reason, family, personal, whatever it is, we don't have any wiggle room with staff right now. So that's the only risk that we have right now. But, you know, between the seasonal folks we have and the permanent folks we have,

25:07 If everybody's healthy in here, then we're okay. And I also understood, or thought that I understood that during the heaviest part of that stormy period, that some of the mechanics, some of the shop personnel actually drove for a while, and of course if they're driving.

25:25 They don't have time to do the maintenance for their other job. Yeah, and the mechanics will typically get out in plow trucks. You know, when a storm is coming in and it just starts snowing, they'll get out. Usually they're the first ones out, particularly if we're not staffed and ready and in town, we're not, you know, on a split shift, for instance. Those guys will usually come in first and get in the plow trucks and get out there, start plowing, putting cinder down. Then the crew comes in. Yeah, sure. Okay.

25:55 Michael. That's all you have. Okay. I mean, I'll just comment one thing that I think that the Snowmobile guys do a great job. I mean, they're out there at 2, 3 in the morning, whatever time they start, and I mean, they do a really good job. Okay. I just had a couple things. One was starting off with just that, the great job that they have done.

26:19 Certainly was a little concerned with all the cuts we've made of what was going to happen, especially when we had these big storms coming. We were excited about it, but certainly want your roads clear, and I think they did a wonderful job. I want to say thanks to ESTA for also doing a good job at night with bringing back, when we brought back that bus service. I think had we not done that, that was certainly a good call, and I'm glad Bill Cockroft brought that up.

26:47 Those buses were just absolutely packed. I can only imagine what a nightmare it would have been had we not had that in place. So thanks to everybody who made that happen. Also, I think, Michael, you called up Mammoth Mountain Ski Area and got some of the additional funding for that in addition to what the town found. So I want to thank them for that. Same with the airport. I've flown out a few times, done a good job. Certainly have our mechanical issues. Wish those didn't happen.

27:16 Probably hate it worse if I was on the plane and we had a mechanical issue. Brian, you become a mechanic. Fix those planes. I had a couple questions. Obviously, we're looking in every nook and cranny to save every dollar. Has Public Works considered insourcing at all? For example, other loaders in town bringing in, doing mechanic work on, I don't know, private industries.

27:46 Loaders or other heavy equipment or counties or somebody else's while in town or do we already do that? I don't know. We do insource not on heavy equipment at this point, but, you know, we do Mammoth Unified School District buses and obviously work on S2 buses. We work on Mono County Schools and a fire district. So we are insourcing that work now. Okay. But, yeah.

28:15 All right. So you're looking at that, obviously. Yeah, and we've done that for a while, and at the moment we have one vacant mechanic position. We're working on replacing that person, so we have really three full-time folks down there, but we'll get that one back in there, which will give us, you know, the ability to consider more of that kind of work. But we stay pretty busy, as it is, with the insourcing that we do. Okay. And then what about, you know, I noticed,

28:45 Vesta has an area where they park their buses and the school has an area where they park their buses and we keep our equipment somewhere. It seems like we have quite a bit of land out there. I'm wondering, is there any way of consolidating some of those different resources or areas into perhaps putting everything on the town's sites, maybe leasing that space out to them if we have room or something along those lines? Yeah. As you know, we have the transit facility, which is essentially across the street from our building.

29:15 And we're actually working with ESTA now to improve that site. So where the impound yard was, we've now moved that out onto Commerce Drive right out in front. And we're in the process now of doing sort of a master layout of that piece of property. I think it's about an acre. So that we can provide covered parking for the ESTA buses, block heaters.

29:42 In the future, what we'll do initially is pave it, put drainage in and pave it, but we're putting a plan together to provide covered parking, some office space, wash bay, that kind of thing, for ESTA buses. Because right now, they don't have a place to put all our buses. There's not enough room there currently. Yeah, they leased that from us, but we're improving the site through this project. The town yard and the school district

30:12 Bus Barn is actually right next to the town yard, which you probably know that. Right. But typically what happens in our yard is we have space reserved for stockpiling materials for road work and, you know, that kind of stuff. And when we have a stockpile there, there's not much room left over. And then you add to that all of the equipment we have that's parked outside, there's actually very little extra room. At one point in time there was discussion.

30:39 This is one of those projects we had talked about years ago. It just never quite happened. But we were going to build additional indoor storage space for equipment, vehicles, and that kind of thing, which was going to kind of go, I guess, would be at the west end of our site. But that just didn't pan out. So, you know, to answer your question, the space, while sometimes it may look like there's a lot of space down there, it's pretty limited when we've got all of our equipment and materials in the yard.

31:09 Okay. So I throw it out there because it does look taken sometimes, but just see if there's a way to consolidate somehow or vehicles wherever we can. There was some extra space, Mr. Mayor, originally, and we sold that to the school district. Was that where the bus barn is? I'm not sure. I think that was done before I came. Oh, for a buck? All right. Okay. A hundred bucks? And it was a half acre?

31:40 I think it is something like... That was a former council, a prior council. Yeah. Okay. Great. All right. Okay, well then, we'll move on to the next question, I guess. Landscaping, we seem to hire the same people over and over for that, for the landscaping out on the streets.

32:09 I'm wondering, assuming that goes through the typical bidding process, and I'm wondering, when we look at the various companies we're hiring, are we comparing apples to apples? The only reason I ask that question, and I don't know the answer, is I've heard people say, well, they're not playing on the same playing field. And I'm assuming we are, but do we actually contract that out every year? Do we do like a five-year contract? How do we do that?

32:36 We changed this a couple years ago. I think we have a two-year contract. And we can actually, if we choose to, we can, you know, go out to bid every year. But a two-year contract gives us a little bit of flexibility. But it is, it's opened up, it goes through a public process. So, you know, anybody that's qualified to do that kind of work is able to submit a bid. Is it based solely on price or?

33:03 For the most part? Well, I mean, you know, we're a public agency, so I mean, that's really sort of what's required. It's the lowest responsive and responsible bidder that we're obligated to accept. Okay. A couple weeks. Peter just said we're going out to bid in a couple weeks on that. Okay. I think that, I have actually one last question. I noticed, so our S to bus is we do obviously advertising on the sides and whatnot. We don't do anything on the inside.

33:34 And I'm wondering, is there a reason we don't? Or do we? I don't typically see any kind of marketing inside the bus. We actually can do it, but I think any revenue generated on the inside would be put back into our, to lower our hourly rate that we pay. So I think what ESTA has is the rear of the buses and the inside of the buses. And that, whatever they generate for revenue, that goes into them.

34:01 Okay. Okay. Got it. All right. I came up with one more comment is having been down in Southern California over the holidays and you mentioned the covered parking.

34:26 There were several places I saw new installations of an angled covered parking that had solar panels on it. And that hopefully our design staff would be looking at that for any possibilities where we have it. Because I'm sure over time that the solar energy might pay for the installation of the panels. No, I think that's a great suggestion. And when we do get to that point where we're installing those covered parking areas, there's actually quite a bit of surface area up there where you could place.

34:56 Yeah. These are great. They're all angled to whichever way. You know, you just design it so it's getting the maximum sun. Yeah. I've seen them too. That's a really good point, yeah. Actually, that brings up another point. Councilmember Raimondo and I went and met with Greg Norby at the Water District and had a conversation with them about their solar field down there. I think, what, they have three acres or something along those lines, but it was shocking what it was actually producing down there as far as power.

35:26 After talking with him, and he said there was a couple different types of avenues you could go down to make as efficient as possible for us if we ever considered that. But in speaking with some other cities, other municipalities, it sounds as though a lot of them are doing this at their airports if they have the additional space. We have some space. We got some space. I think we have a little space back, and I'm just wondering if that isn't something we shouldn't consider maybe.

35:53 Just at least looking into, it might be something if we do have legitimate space down there and if the costs aren't such that, you know, it would be imperative to us if it would actually create a benefit and we can get grants back from the state and look into all those different avenues, it might be something to look into, at least might help offset some of our airport or transit costs. Sure. Yeah, and in the coming months, we are going to be updating our airport business plan.

36:21 As you're well aware, the 25 acres down there is now back under the control of the town. And so we want to look at it very objectively, obviously working with the FAA early on, and consider the highest and best uses for the airport. And I don't know what that is, but as I said, the next couple of months, we're going to start working on updating that airport business plan. I'm sure we'll be coming back to the council with that at some point.

36:51 A draft, you know, for conversation, as well as, you know, probably the Planning Commission and some other folks. So, yeah, I mean, that's another idea that I think should be considered in terms of how we go forward with that land in the future. Okay. Yeah, something we could at least consider. I just had one other quick question. I mentioned about looking at, with Caltrans, additional

37:18 Street poles down Main Street, a really dark area, do you have solar, solar, has there been any conversation with that yet? No, at this point we haven't contacted, or made contact with Caltrans, but it's on our radar. Okay. Yeah, and there's actually a couple other locations in town that are of concern to us. Obviously the intersection right out here by the school, although with that new sign out there, it's pre-will lit it. Yeah, it's pre-right.

37:44 Although I think Rich turned it down a little bit. And then at Commerce Drive and Minaret, that intersection also is really dark and I've had other folks ask me about that. So, you know, we're looking at all of these things and, you know, I'd like to put together a project where we can, you know, fill in those gaps in the lighting. Yeah, and I think the solar idea runs are great. I mean, they run for free. Yeah.

38:13 Oh, sorry. It's the other M Street, Meridian. It's a new extension. I was just going to follow up on that, Michael, is that the lighting for the college connector path, the one that goes from the library down to the schools and all that, that's solar. And it's a perfect, you know, it'll be a perfect test for us. In fact, there have been a couple of, has it been about four years that a couple of those light standards have been up there and they're

38:42 Totally saw their power. Yeah. Great. Okay. More to come. Yeah. Any other comments or questions of council? Anybody in the public have any comments? Yes, Sandy. Come on up. Yeah. Please. Sandy Hogan. I was just wondering about, this is a question, I guess, for Ray. On page 12, concerning the town contract with ESTA, it wasn't originally, of course, all the contracts took a 10% hit.

39:17 And as a result, we had the issue of the 10 p.m. to 2 a.m. service in the village, and of course we had to do a one-time fix, and Mammoth Mountain also stepped up to do that. In the outgoing years of the restructuring plan, has that 10% been built back in, or are we going to have to look at one-term fixes every year? I think at this point that the $25,000 that the council put back into transit is this year only.

39:46 So when we start talking about next year's budget, that same conversation is going to come up. So it'll be a $40,000 plus, actually. Yeah, well, there's the other $15,000. Yes, it will. We're going to have to look at it again, and we're going to have to try to come up with a solution, one of many. But we're narrowing them down. Right, but that's an important one to keep in mind because it actually cost quite a bit this year to change schedules and information.

40:13 You know, for transit, you just want to keep it steady and keep going on and not make quick reductions, which, of course, is what this was. And so keep that in mind. I think when you're going through, I know that we'd like to hold to the restructuring plan, but that 10% cut, again, is going to have to be made up somewhere or services are reduced.

40:41 Just want to be sure it is not included in there. It wasn't clear to me that a five-year plan if it had been added back in. Thank you for bringing that up. Oh, sorry. The other thing to consider along those lines is it may or may not be $25,000 or $40,000. You know, the cost of service hours right now is pretty low. I think it's like less than $40. Yeah, just less than $40 an hour. I don't know that it's going to stay that way because this is as low as it's been.

41:09 You know, so we'll have to consider all of those factors and what the total budget looks like. I just don't want to get that, have that get lost again and all of a sudden in the midst of the holiday season we're looking again, oh my goodness, what are we going to do? You know, I think, I know that it's very difficult to think about moving back up, putting that 10% back in, but it's service reductions, maybe there, maybe one year, yeah, maybe there's a second year fix, but be thinking five years out. You know, do we want to keep our services as they are?

41:37 Well, I think looking at what we saw over the holidays, I mean, it made us all pay attention to the importance of needing that transportation during those hours. I mean, even with the buses running just 100%, there were lines out there. I mean, and I understand we have some tracking systems now going in on the ESTA buses, and Councilmember Raimondo can probably touch on that tonight, but interesting stuff. I think it will help people.

42:04 For the record, it was actually Cheryl Witherell at 1849 that brought everything to our attention about the fact, because she wanted to know what to advise her customers, and so I forwarded to that John Helm, and Bill Cockroft was made aware of it, and of course he's the one that brought it to your attention, but she wanted to know what to advise her customers, and that was, you know, an advance of it, so it came from the public noticing, like, whoops, buses aren't running.

42:30 You're right. I actually stand corrected on that. I do remember Cheryl writing that initially. Absolutely. Right there. All right. Thank you, Sandy. Anybody else from the public have any comments or questions? Okay. Well, then, thank you, Ray, and everybody else. And we'll go ahead and adjourn the workshop until our regular schedule at 6 o'clock. Sorry, Mr. Mayor, prior to that, is there any other direction that the council would offer at this point, or does everything look satisfactory?

42:58 I think it looks fine. I don't have any additional comments or questions on this direction. No. Other than I think in the future in the budget that whole business of I like the word insourcing, how much of the insourcing you're doing and how much of the outsourcing you're doing. Sure. Okay. Thank you. Michael, did you, looking at the cost comparisons, did you want to have them go through the cost comparisons for out of state? No. I mean, I just want to know if

43:28 There was reason to do it or not to do it. Okay. It's fine. I also think it's consistent with what we discussed last time for public safety. Right. Okay. That's fine. All righty. Well, then, we're good. Thank you, Ray. Sure. Appreciate it. Thank you. Okay. We'll be back at 6 o'clock. Meeting for January 20th. Much better. We're going to go ahead and get started with our regularly scheduled council meeting for January 23rd. I'll go ahead and announce that there was nothing to report out of closed session. With that,

49:53 We'll go ahead and start with the roll call, please, Jamie. Here. Here. Here. Here. Here. Okay. With that, we'll go ahead and start with the Pledge of Allegiance. John, would you like to lead us? I'd be happy to. Please join me. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation,

50:26 Under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. With that, we'll go ahead and I'll ask the public if there's anything that's not on the agenda currently. If anybody wants to come up and speak, please feel free to. Good evening, Mr. Mayor, Councilmembers, John Urdi, Mammoth Lakes Tourism.

50:58 Just wanted to give you a little bit of an update. While I have only anecdotal information regarding our business levels throughout the holiday period and through this past holiday weekend, the feedback has been very strong across the board. I heard over the holiday weeks, retailers, restaurants, lodging properties talking about breaking records. That's fantastic. That's a great opportunity for us. As you'll remember last year,

51:19 December was strong because we had people locked in because of the huge snows of the year before. So we didn't die on the vine in December. We died on the vine in January, February, March. So our opportunity this year is now that we have momentum is to really continue that momentum. The snowstorms prior to the Christmas holiday were fantastic. We had really a 14-day period where we had a number of lodging properties that were sold out for that 14-day period, which is really the best opportunity we have during the holiday.

51:49 Right now we're looking at the recovery and the momentum that we have. Last year, because the holiday season wasn't great, people went back and said, we're not going to go back. We can tell our friends that it was not a great experience, and we really suffered for the remainder of the year. The opposite of that this year is happening. So we have people that are coming back sooner. We have people that are telling their friends to come here, and I think that we're really poised for the remainder of the year. Bookings continue to be strong. Properties are reporting that they're seeing the bookings.

52:16 Even into March right now. So on the air side, again, last December was not a complete disaster because people were committed. But going forward to this December, we actually saw the Los Angeles market with about 900 additional passengers for the month of December. The San Francisco market was up about 6% in load, which is a great number. San Diego was up 12% and Orange County was up 7%.

52:41 Now, moving forward, I'm comparing the next few months to the month-end number. So the January numbers right now in Los Angeles, as of my report yesterday, were up 900 passengers in Los Angeles to the end of January number. So this is the report from earlier this week. So we still have a nine-day booking window for the remainder of the month. We booked 1,800 people this week across the network. So if we're booking a couple thousand people,

53:09 We're going to see these numbers continue to increase. So that's about a 12% increase to the final month-end load last year out of Los Angeles. In San Francisco, it's even better. We're up 1,231 passengers and a 20% growth in load. San Diego's up 30% in load and almost 1,200 passengers as well. And then Orange County has really rebounded. It's up about 18% in load, and it's doubled the January number from last year already. So anything we move on with this is going to be a growth.

53:39 February, we have a couple of the markets that are actually already, as of January 22, which is the report from yesterday, that were already booked what we had at the end of February last year. So you think about that, we've got a month and a week, and we're already ahead of where we were at the end of February last year. So that momentum is there, and it's something that we'll continue to have. It is snowing out there now. I think that that's the sort of thing that's just going to keep us moving in the right direction.

54:04 I'm sure some of you saw the graphs that we put out prior to Christmas, prior to the rest of the country getting snow. We wanted to take advantage of the fact that we had 100% of our acreage open when places in Colorado were at 20%, 30%, even some at 15%, and even our friends up in Tahoe that were so far behind us that we needed to take advantage of that. We work with an occupancy tracking company called MTRIP, and we pay to actually see what one of our competitive markets is compared to us.

54:34 And that momentum and that reach that we did in December to show how much snow we had, it put us ahead of a place like North Lake Tahoe, where we're typically behind those places in the months of January and February. Right now we're even with them because of this momentum that we had. We let the world know that we had all this snow when they didn't, and I think it really did influence people's behavior. We sent those graphs to all of our tour operators around the world.

55:04 We had reservations out of Brazil that were slated to go to Colorado, but because we were showing we were 100% open and Vail was 30% open, they rebooked with us, and the Brazilian market is a pretty lucrative market, so those reservations could be anywhere from $10,000 to $20,000 each, so that's the sort of thing we needed to take advantage of when we had that competitive advantage, and we did. So, momentum's there. Okay. John, real quick, you mentioned that the, I think it was the San Diego market.

55:32 You were up maybe 1,200 passengers for the month. That translates to maybe around 35 passengers per flight, but you have to figure out that per flight is here and there, so maybe 20 in one direction and 15 in another direction, but still that's a substantial increase. Right, and you're looking at the average per person spend at almost $600. So to add that number, it's a sizable number. Good.

55:58 So Alaska and the United are happy right now? Yeah, everybody's happy with the numbers. I think we had, you know, we've been very fortunate with the weather that we haven't had a number of cancellations. We've had some issues with some mechanical, but not too many. But we want to definitely keep an eye on that and make sure that that continues to not be a problem. The challenge when we have mechanical issues, if they're on the ground here or they're on the ground in L.A., is that they don't have a number of, there aren't a lot of people flying a Q400 out of there.

56:26 And they're not really hubbed there. So if an alternator goes out on a plane, they can't just walk into a storeroom, grab another one, put it in. It's probably coming from Seattle to fly down there. So that's part of the challenge that we have. When they have issues here, it's very similar. They don't have any supplies here. And even in L.A., there aren't a lot of other people flying the Q400. So they can't even walk over to the United guys and say, hey, we need an alternator. So it becomes a little bit more of a challenge when that happens. And that does bung up the system a lot because you do have people that are flying internationally that are trying to get from here to L.A. to make connections to Sydney.

56:55 Or, you know, the U.K. So that's a bit of a challenge. We're still working with Alaska on that. And we're planning on heading up to Seattle probably the end of February to start talking about summer and beyond with Alaska. Thank you. Anyone else? Yeah, I just had one member of the public I was talking to prior to the meeting, and one thing you do notice out there, maybe everybody else is listening too, is the mood's a little different.

57:22 There's certainly a different mood than there has been in prior years, and hopefully this is a change for the better looking for several years. Yeah, and we've got a lot of good stories to tell. You know, you look at just the new restaurants in town between Campo and Jimmy's and, you know, just looking around town and looking at what's going on with development and infrastructure change, it's a great thing. Yeah. Okay, thank you, John. Anybody else from the public have any comments or questions? Yes, Jack. Thank you.

57:54 Council, nice to see you all. Know most of you. I'm Jack Copeland, and formerly 39 years with Mammoth Mountain Ski Area. Retired now. But I am now the recently elected president of the Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce. And I thought I'd come by and introduce myself and let you know I'm in that position. And as part of that position, I'll be attending more council meetings and commission meetings and probably local agency meetings.

58:24 Bringing myself up to speed about issues in the community that might be of interest to our membership. And I thought maybe I'd talk just briefly about some things that the Chamber's looking at and things that are important as we look towards the future. One of the first is, it's kind of paradoxical. Clearly the Chamber is

58:51 Is interested, is pro-development, interested in the growth of the business community in the future. But on the other hand, we're not interested in that growth at any expense. And we think that growth needs to be reasonable, needs to be responsible, and it needs to be sustainable. An example, and I use this only because it's rushing everyone's mind, is that it's very clear that Vons needs to expand.

59:20 God knows it could use a facelift. And anybody who's gone shopping in Bishop and enjoyed these spacious aisles and the broader selection of products down there understands the difference between bonds here and down there. So everybody is in favor of having bonds expand. But along with the positive elements and the obvious business case for that expansion,

59:47 There are some unintended consequences to members of our business community. And I'm speaking about the Java joint. And I'm speaking about our friends, Lynn and Karen. They're not big business people. But they have and they're going to suffer some business setback because of this change in development. Now, fortunately, they are entrepreneurs enough to have gone out to solve their problem.

1:00:16 And that, but not everyone's going to be able to do that. And I really appreciate that. I have so much admiration and respect for them going out and taking bull by the horns and taking the initiative to change their business model. I bring that up because even though we all know business expansion is good within certain reasonable limits, there will be unintended consequences.

1:00:46 And what's good for, although the small business community of Mammoth, clearly, you know, we all know that the more salmon that fish, that swim upstream, the better the fishing is for everybody. And so we're not fighting that. And generally speaking, what's good for the big businesses of the community are good for the small businesses as well, but not all of us. And we hope that during the discussion, there's going to be a lot of pressure on council. There's going to be a lot of...

1:01:15 Maybe pressure is not the right word. Let's say enthusiasm for future growth. And with that enthusiasm, it's important that we, the council and the planning commission, consider the impacts largely unintended on the existing business community. If we were to, let's just say it's easier for me to exaggerate to make my point.

1:01:37 But let's say we double the number of lodging rooms in town over three years during the next spurt of growth. That's going to be great over the Christmas holidays and over presidents and over Martin Luther King. But it's not going to be very good Monday through Thursday midweek non-holiday. And it's going to put a lot of our existing lodging communities out of business. And if every development comes into town and in the name of providing

1:02:07 Better service on site puts in two restaurants and three retail shops and a rental demo center on property. What is that going to do to the existing businesses in town? And what impact is that going to have on the sustainability of businesses and employment in town? And I don't want to paint a picture of not being anti-growth because we're not anti-growth.

1:02:35 But we recognize that as a period of growth comes up, we need to have everyone at the table. We need to consider the unintended consequences. We need to include the smaller businesses in the dialogue about what is the impact to the greater community at large of expanding everything. That's one of my concerns. And I think that's a concern for all of our business members in the community. But we are pro-business.

1:03:05 We are pro-development. We hope that the council and the community will be development ready when capital comes back into the community. And I look forward to chatting with you and working with you on various projects in the future. So, boy, it was good skiing this morning. Jack, real quick, thank you personally for making your commitment to being the president of the chamber. My pleasure. That's wonderful. You're a fine, fine man, and they're fortunate to have you. Thanks, Jack. Thank you.

1:03:33 I second that, Jack. You know, looking back, I look when the Mammoth Rocks thing started, you know, a lot of people get credit for that. But ultimately, I remember when it started, and it was you that actually brought it up in there. What do we need to do different today and now? And I think, you know, I need to say thank you for what you've done in the past with the Chamber and moving forward. And I think we're fortunate to have you there. You're welcome. Thank you. Any other comments, questions from Council or the public?

1:04:03 Okay. Thank you, Jack. Any other folks in the audience have anything that's not on the agenda they'd like to talk about? Yes, Eric. Hi, my name's Eric Wasserman. I'm speaking as a mobility commissioner and a private citizen. I just want to address my concerns to council. A little bit of history. A few years back, we reduced our seats on mobility commission, and I lost my agency seat as the chamber. I originally was on there as a representative of the chamber.

1:04:35 We were told at the time that the only difference in the ordinance was to reduce the number of seats on the commission. And after it was voted on, I looked back at the ordinance and lo and behold, I'm now on there as an individual and I'd given up my chamber seat. Long story short, eight months went by, council was busy with other things, obviously the lawsuit, no need to go through the history, but too busy to bring it back up. When it was brought back up again, it was to merge the airport commission.

1:05:05 With Mobility Commission, we were told at the time that the airport commission was just too busy. There was too much going on. We can't possibly do that. There's so much going on. Okay, we lost that one. A couple of weeks later, what happened was, well, now we need some money for the airport subsidy. Guess what? All of a sudden, transportation has something to do with air. And we agreed as a commission to support that.

1:05:32 And it was the right thing to do at the time. I did vote for that, and I do support it. But as a commission, then, I got an email on December 26th saying there was going to be a meeting on January 2nd to disband the commission. I find that to be pretty insulting because December 26th, either A, too busy with your own business to be dealing with anything, or B, you're out of town enjoying vacation and spending time with your family. I had emailed a response.

1:05:59 To ask if that meeting could be pushed to the next Town Council meeting, as I was unable to attend on January 2nd, as I'm sure many of the other commissioners affected were, didn't even get the courtesy of a response, and this is the next Town Council meeting since then, so I'm here to say my piece. I think it's wrong. I think it's unethical to put that through that fast, quite frankly, and not give people a chance to respond. I can understand the need to merge. As a commission, just so you know the history, I know Chair Hogan had emailed you guys.

1:06:28 Some notes from our meetings. We had agreed prior to Councilman Harvey suggesting to reduce meetings. We took that upon ourselves about a year before that. We also had suggested joint meetings so that when there's something new and staff has to present it to mobility and air and planning and everybody else, we were the commission that initiated that and said there should be one meeting for everybody. Let's save staff time. You can look back at the minutes. There's issues that we as a commission had voted on where we're coming up with a

1:06:57 A quote, free grant, a free project that we question and say, how much is this free project going to cost us? And oh yeah, there's $80,000 in staff time. Guess what? It's not free. We don't need someone to tell us that there's traffic on Saturday when people are getting off the hill. We've been a responsible commission. I could understand clearly why this is being done, but I just wanted to make it public. I think it was wrong that we got an email on the 26th, scheduling a meeting on January 2nd, and it's not right.

1:07:23 Furthermore, I think we're moving in the wrong direction by putting this on planning commissions table. Let's look around ourselves. The facts are clear. The economy is improving. Unemployment is below 8%. It peaked over 10%. The GDP was revised upward to where it's going to be about 3%. Europe is stabilizing. Italian debt was 4%. Back in the fall, it's now under 2% for their three-year treasury. Europe is stabilizing. Guess what? Money is going to be coming back into this town.

1:07:49 Planning Commission does not need the burden of taking care of traffic issues and other issues with the airport. I think that the decision is wrong. I think it needs to be readdressed. And I'd be curious to see a financial study of how much money we actually cost people. We were being a very effective commission. And what Chair Hogan supplied, she did. We had asked to reduce our meetings. And we were told that, no, we shouldn't change the ordinance. We're supposed to meet monthly.

1:08:16 Let's schedule the monthly but strive to only be quarterly when there's pressing business. And we acted responsibly as a commission. And as I'm speaking as for my fellow commissioners, we didn't feel too well respected when we came off as flakes in that staff report that was inaccurate. So I just wanted to read that to council. And it just doesn't make you feel very good to serve for that many years with the big bucks that we get and then be treated that way.

1:08:42 Okay. Thank you, Eric. Are there any comments or questions with Council? I don't have any. I just have a couple. Michael, do you have any comments? The one regarding the notice and regarding any implications, I guess, that the commissioners weren't respected, anything along those lines, I would like to just say, you know, ultimately,

1:09:11 The agenda comes before me. And if you guys feel that way, I, one, would like to apologize for that. I don't want you guys to feel that way because our commissions are the backbone. They are our voice and eyes that are out there really researching and doing the work for a lot of this information that we can't do. So if you feel that way, if any other commissioners feel that way, I apologize to you for that.

1:09:40 Certainly not intended. You guys have done a lot of heavy lifting for us. And as a matter of fact, I'd like to say thank you for it. The economy does appear to be stabilizing out there. Unfortunately, we're still in a position where we're not stable yet. And we have to really be looking down the line. And we're just looking at every dollar we can right now. And hopefully we can bring that back in the future. And I guess if anything,

1:10:11 It comes out of what I'm trying to say is we absolutely do respect what you and other commissioners have done and to apologize for any implication if we've given that. So as things improve, hopefully it will be improving here. It sounds as though they are. Hopefully we'll be able to bring that back and seek the advice of people like yourself and Chair Hogan who have given us valuable input.

1:10:35 Great. I just don't want to see all the hard work get lost. Again, we had our ducks in a row. The reason we didn't have meetings is we were efficient. We took care of money. We expanded routes. And one of the things that was introduced was expanding the trolley service to 2 a.m. because if our workers can't get home from work on public transportation, guess what? They're not going to take it to work. So there's a lot of things that I think I haven't talked to any planning commissioners, but I would guess they probably don't want to get down to that level of detail with what hopefully happens with the economy getting better. Another thing I should mention is

1:11:04 The Chamber did have an agency seat there. If the Planning Commission is going to take over that scope, I think some discussion should be talked about. I know our Chamber President is here and I don't want to speak for the Chamber, but really representing the business community, I would think a seat on a commission would be essential to get that point of view because that's essentially what I was representing originally. Even though my seat was me personally once the ordinance was changed, I always voted and took the stance of what the Chamber would do. Okay.

1:11:33 Thank you, Eric. Appreciate it. You weren't here during that meeting, of course. You may have seen the recording. But really what you've spoken to is what I spoke to, even though I voted for it and I wasn't dragged along. I voted for it because I thought it was the right thing for the town to do. But one of the things that I observed from my years up here and also my years of being on a commission is that a pretty important role is played.

1:12:02 By people who choose to become part of the political process, the government process. And the downside of getting rid of commissions is that we lose folks like you and others on the commission. And I made the comment that as strange as it might seem to many people, this job here can be very isolating. You look to...

1:12:27 We each look to perhaps the same people over and over again or receive information from the same people. And so the commissions provide great value to me, not just on the issues that are presented, not just on the heavy lifting, but because they provide additional perspective and come up to the podium and provide us with reports.

1:12:52 We're going to miss that. I will miss that. And I'm sorry for that because I see basically what we're saying to the community is, look, we're here and we can't afford to have other people in the government because we don't have enough staff or we don't have the money to pay staff to manage the various commissions. So that's the downside. Tough decision. I'm hopeful that in better times we'll be looking at these things differently than we are now. I just wanted to let you know that. I appreciate that. Thank you.

1:13:21 Anybody else? Okay. Thank you, Eric. We do appreciate you coming up. Thanks. Anybody else from the public have anything they'd like to speak on that's not on the agenda? Okay. Moving on, we'll go to Councilmember Reports and any additions to the agenda. So I'll start with you, John. Oh, I have none, Mr. Mayor. Oh, wow. Okay. Joe? Nothing. All right. Michael? Sure. I just have a couple. I attended our monthly estimating.

1:13:49 Happy to report that the transition in taking over the winter bus lines from Mammoth Ski Area so far went real well. A little bit more exciting news is to report in last week's paper. A new bus tracking device called NextBus has been installed in the red line initially so far, which basically provides real-time estimates for bus arrivals to the stop by simply calling the number posted.

1:14:14 Entering the stop ID or receiving a text and it'll let you know when the bus is going to arrive. Further enhancements are already in the works to have a QR code to scan at the stop. It'll let you know exactly when the bus is going to arrive. Trolleys are being discussed as the next lines to have the technology put on and then follow up with the rest of the lines in the future. I think it's a great benefit for residents who depend on the buses to get to and from work and also the visitors. I think it improves our transit system.

1:14:44 And I've officially attested it myself. It works really well. Also, Mayor Lehman and I attended the League of Cities convention for new mayors and council members, and that was very informative and appreciate having the opportunity to go to that. Okay. Thank you. Mayor Pro Tem, Wood. I attended the town-county liaison committee meeting last week, and we, as a town, made a request of the county that they

1:15:11 Share with us in the form of loan allocations from Southern California Electric that are granted to the town and the county specifically to accomplish the undergrounding of utilities and specifically the utilities to be undergrounded are the lines in front of what will be the Mammoth View project on Main Street up there where all those railroad ties are. A pretty important project for us. We met with two of the supervisors

1:15:41 Tim Fesco and Tim Alpers, and the response was positive, and that's something that the developer is going to be contributing to as well in the event that we can get this done, so that's the status on that. Secondly, I wasn't present, but I understood that Dina Castor yesterday, I think, announced from the Mammoth Mountain Skiria Tusk Bar deck

1:16:07 That she will compete in the LA Marathon on March 17th of this year. And this is, as we all know, our Olympian. She will turn 40 in February and still holds and has held for over 10 years the American Marathon record, which...

1:16:35 It's just simply an extraordinary feat in and of itself, and to have held onto it for so long makes it even that much more special. So, good publicity for Mammoth Mountain, good publicity for the town, and we look forward to her doing well in L.A. Mr. Mayor, I had a couple things real quick, if I may. I just wanted to thank Michael for his attendance at the ESTA meeting. I had a heavy, heavy business day that day. It was Monday this past week, and I wasn't...

1:17:04 Friday, excuse me, Friday of last week. Wasn't able to attend. But Michael, to his credit, had just gotten back the night before, late the night before from your trip and made an extra effort and went to that meeting even though he had indicated that he probably wouldn't be able to attend. So I appreciate it, Michael. The other thing I wanted to mention was just informational to the council and that is that it's my understanding that the MLTPA board

1:17:34 It has been working on, it is working on a proposal and they plan to present that to our Park and Recreation Commission at the Park and Rec Commission this coming week, next week. Okay. Thank you, John. I have a couple of comments. I think Council Member Raimondo mentioned it. We went to the League of Cities Conference for new mayors and new council members.

1:18:01 Pretty informative stuff out there, not just because we get to learn some of the legalities and protocol items over a three-day period, but also you get to learn a lot about other cities and what's happening in their municipalities and coming to find out that while we have a lot of problems, so do other municipalities. We talk a lot about TOT enforcement and issues like that and how we may have

1:18:30 Been behind the curve. Come to find out we're now, I believe, ahead of the curve and probably setting the way for what a lot of other municipalities. I mean, I had more people asking questions about how we can enforce their TOT, and interestingly enough, I had more answers than questions. So I found it interesting, and there were many other areas. Clearly, having gone through the bankruptcy process was of great interest to other municipalities.

1:18:59 A lot of them would pull you aside and say, you know, we're having an issue here and here and we may be faced with X, Y, or Z problem that we had to address. So very interesting stuff and I think it was educational just on multiple levels. On another topic, the Rotary Club, the Noon Rotary Club is going to be holding a winter carnival on February 9th at 630 at Canyon Lodge.

1:19:28 That I announced that, particularly to the council members, hope that they are able to attend, and also members of the public, I think a lot of the auction raffling they'll be doing there will be going to charity, so I wanted to make that announcement. Aside from that, I don't have any other items, and we'll go ahead and move on to commission updates. So any other commissioners? Sandy Hogan, and this will be the last update for the Mobility Commission.

1:20:01 We had several topics. We had our transit workshop at our last meeting, and one of the things I wanted to bring up right now so the public is well aware is what I brought up during the workshop, that this year, because of the fact that we had one-time money, we were able to restore part of the cuts as a result of the 10% cut that was delivered to the ESTA contract, and that was the

1:20:28 The village service from 10 p.m. to 2 a.m., and of course Mammoth Mountain stepped up also, and the town gave 25,000, Mammoth Mountain gave up another almost 15,000 to restore that service. However, that 10% cut is still envisioned, from what we understand, to be in place for the next two to four or five years in the restructuring plan.

1:20:53 And so I want to be sure that the council has this in mind, even though maybe this year right now operating costs are down. Transit doesn't function well, nor does the public have a lot of trust in it if we change a schedule as we had to this year and then change it again. So ideally, in budget deliberations, as hard as it is, I know, please reconsider making sure that we don't have these

1:21:22 Cuts happening, interrupted service, then you put it back in, because it's not good for anybody. And transit is built slowly but surely over the years into a successful operation as this one has done. And it doesn't mean that our winter service would be interrupted totally, because obviously we have a contract also with Mammoth Mountain, but the town contract is the one where we continue that service at night or our other routes.

1:21:49 So anyway, that was one thing that we did talk about. We did not have suggestions for cuts, didn't have from the public, whatever. And I know that right now we're looking at lowering operating costs, but still, for the next five years, we want to keep it on a steady course and not shake it up. Second thing we talked about was the transition. In other words, how to transition our duties to, whether it's the town council, to the planning commission, or whatever.

1:22:18 And all three of us, Linda Salcido, Vice Chair Wasserman, Eric Wasserman, and I all said, hey, we understand the decision. It's a business decision. And we know that staff is overloaded. But we would like to be able to continue to offer any help or expertise or corporate memory to whether it's the council or the planning commission or whatever. If you can call it ex-official members of a

1:22:48 Of a subcommittee that maybe they'll set up or whatever, but whatever you come up with, we are willing to serve however we can. So that was the main thing. I think Ray went away with a lot of ideas, and I'm sure we'll come up with more. So any other questions? Questions to council? Just a comment, Sandy. Thank you.

1:23:13 And thank you for offering to come and assist Planning Commission. They do have a lot on their plate, as we have historically as a council. And just greatly appreciate you offering to step forward and help with that. I know you guys do have a wealth of knowledge, so thank you. Thank you. We felt it was a privilege to serve, so thank you. Okay. Any other commission reports?

1:23:41 Okay, seeing none, we'll go ahead and move on to department reports and emerging issues. Is there any department heads? Okay, move, Ellen. Just a couple of items briefly. A report from today's planning commission meeting. The planning commission considered an application for an extension of the special event permit for the event occurring across the street at Sierra Center Mall.

1:24:11 Continuation of that for a number of weeks with the movie theater or movie showing and large graphic on the wall. The planning commission found that that did not meet the definition of a special event under the zoning code and therefore staff will not be issuing the permit for that special event to continue. We are working with the applicant to

1:24:35 To issue an administrative permit for the snow plate area that's there and also for an additional weekend rail jam event, which clearly fits within the definition as a one or two day event in that location. Staff will be continuing enforcement of sign and banner issues at Sierra Center Mall. And on that note, there was a number of emails about that over the past couple of weeks.

1:25:01 We will be returning to the Planning Commission at their meeting on February 13th with some additional information regarding really what sort of resources would be required to do a more vigorous enforcement program for science in particular since it seems to be kind of a, it's an ongoing issue but there's been a spate I think of problems that we would like to see addressed and asking the Planning Commission if that's an effort they would like to undertake.

1:25:29 Making a priority and how that would fit in with our work program. So that will be under discussion on the 13th. Just to let you know, on February the 12th, we will be holding the first public workshop for the Main Street. This is the Phase II grant that we got from Caltrans to continue the downtown concept for Main Street planning effort. Our consultants will be coming to town, doing sort of a public kickoff, looking at issues.

1:25:58 And also providing a recap of the work we're doing right now with the Downtown Working Group, which is really our focus group or stakeholder group for the Downtown Project and for our commercial zoning update effort and presenting that information on the 12th. So that's a public meeting. I think, like, starting at 5 in Sweezy for everyone to attend if possible. And then finally, I heard today from...

1:26:23 Sandra, Patricia, our staff involved in the TNT enforcement effort that they estimate were about 70% towards our $500,000 goal for the year. So we're more than halfway through the year and well on our way to reaching our financial target. Okay. Great. Any questions at Ellen? Okay. Thank you. Any other department heads want to speak? Okay. Seeing none, we're going to go ahead and move on to council presentations.

1:26:54 With that, I'll go ahead and turn it over to Chief Watson. Thank you. It's a pleasure to lead the discussion to recognize Doug Hornbeck for 15 years of service with Mammoth Lakes Police Department. Besides the 15 years he spent here before coming to Mammoth Lakes, Doug spent six years as a police officer at Signal Hill, and before that he was a reserve deputy sheriff for Los Angeles County for three years.

1:27:28 He had all that up, and he's got about 25, 24, 25 years of law enforcement experience. With us, he's worked a whole bunch of different assignments. Up until fairly recently, he was our detective, worked on a number of very many, very significant cases over many years. He's probably going to be going back to detectives soon because of vacancy that's going to be created there. I think Doug's a really good example of what's good about small town police departments. Doug lives in town.

1:27:57 Very few people in town that don't know Doug that haven't crossed paths with him, either professionally or personally. And that helps him do his job and it helps build a relationship and a bridge between the police department and the community. So, you know, he's one of those senior, seasoned officers that I think makes any police department better and we really value the service he's provided to us. Doug's got one daughter and three grandchildren and I know he coaches baseball, football.

1:28:25 Both. Both time as a coach. So with that, I'd just like to introduce Doug Longbeck. Okay, we'll go ahead and move on to the consent agenda item. Is there any items that council would like to pull from the consent? No? Anybody in the public? How many items they'd like to pull from the consent agenda? Okay. Seeing none. Mr. Mayor, I'd like to make a motion to approve.

1:29:37 Items 3 through 7 on the agenda. Okay, we have a motion. Second. And a second. Roll call, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Okay, motion passes 5-0. With that, we'll move on to item number 8 under policy matters, which is really discussing the seeded proposal for Mammoth Creek Inn expansion project. Okay.

1:30:11 Sorry, go ahead, Jen. Thank you, Mayor, members of the council, Jen Daugherty, associate planner. The purpose of this item is for council to evaluate and discuss the proposed community benefits, incentive zoning, or CBIS proposal for the Mammoth Creek Inn expansion project. A concept review application was submitted for this project, which allows us to review preliminary information for a project before they spend the time and cost to develop detailed plans.

1:30:38 It provides us a great opportunity to provide feedback at the initial stage of project development. As you probably know, over the past few years, the owner of the Mammoth Creek Inn has done renovations to revitalize the site, both interior improvements for the rooms and exterior façade upgrade as well. Now the owner is proposing to expand the existing hotel by adding 12 rooms in nine condo hotel units.

1:31:04 These units would be contained in three buildings of the same design. These buildings would be located towards the rear of the site. The buildings are proposed to be about 43 feet in height, which would include under-structure parking and four floors. The unit configuration would be three studio units, three one-bedroom units, and three two-bedroom units. The proposal would result in the hotel being seven rooms over the maximum allowable density of 40 rooms per acre.

1:31:32 Therefore, the applicant is proposing to utilize CBIS and provide in-lieu fees towards a transit stop or shelter in the vicinity of the project. This proposal would be consistent with the current CBIS policy, which was adopted in 2009, and the South District's Neighborhood District Plan, which is the district in which the hotel is located. The Planning and Economic Development Commission reviewed this concept review earlier this month.

1:31:59 And identified and discussed potential concerns related to parking, site and building design, and snow storage. The commission also discussed the preliminary CBIS proposal, and there were some concerns about the amount of the in-loop fee proposed. However, the financial analysis that was prepared for this project by a third-party EPS identified that 5% of the net return would be a sufficient margin to request as a community benefit, which equates to about $6,000.

1:32:29 The financial analysis found the net return for this project to be lower than typical, and therefore the suggested in lieu fee is a smaller amount. The project would also generate town revenues through TOT, property and utility tax, and sales tax as well. Therefore, staff is requesting non-binding input as required in the CBIS policy from Council on the CBIS proposal to determine if it is

1:32:56 Worthy of consideration by the Planning Commission when the formal application is submitted. And with that, the owner and applicant for the Mammoth Creek Inn project, Mr. Stephen Hakeem, is here as well if you have any questions for him. And with that, I'd just be happy to take any questions. Okay. Thank you, Jen. Does Council have any questions of Jen? I have one. I just want to make sure I understand this, is that the new units are hotel-condo, which means they'll be individually sold, but

1:33:25 They will be part of, they'll kind of be blended into the existing hotel front desk and all of that? Yes, they will function as hotbeds under our current definition of condo hotel, so they would be on the reservation program. The owner is just looking at providing flexibility in the future if they would like to sell those units, but they don't have any plans on selling those units in the near term. Okay. So they're going to be built that way but not sold? But they would be able to be sold. Okay. Okay.

1:33:57 Joe, do you have any other questions? No, that's... Any other council members have questions? I just have a comment. Sure. Well, I'd like to see a little bit more of community benefit. I'm happy to see someone bringing a project forward. My only question is, our local licensed contractor is going to be doing the work, and has any bidding been done yet? Maybe you can answer that for me. Hi. Steven Hakeem, one of the owners of the Mammoth Creek Inn. I'd like to thank...

1:34:29 Council for hearing this as well as staff for putting together such a detailed report. At this point, no, we haven't gotten any bids. We've gotten preliminary bids and have done work with various GCs in town. Our intention is to employ GCs in town mostly because of the relationships we built with them but also because of the vicinity of the supplies and the resources that they have in the area.

1:34:57 The reason why we haven't put together definitive bids is because we haven't gotten to the point to which we know exactly what we're going to be building. So part of this, and we also discussed this with the Planning Commission about a few weeks ago, our main intention in building this is because unfortunately the way that the setup of the Mammoth Creek Inn is, a lot of the units that we currently have are studios.

1:35:25 And one bedrooms that are very small and it's made it a very difficult market for us in order to bring in families of larger scales. So even though on paper and EPS's analysis shows that we're not going to be netting such a return that is typical in the development, we feel that it would as a whole bring life to the hotel.

1:35:52 And that's our main goal here as well as to hear sort of, I mean obviously this isn't binding but we're hoping to get some sort of support one way or another from you before we spend any more time debating on whether or not this makes any sense for us to build. Okay, thank you. Sure. Okay. I'll go ahead and bring it to the public and see if there's any questions out there before bringing it back to Council. So is there anybody in the public that has any comments or questions on this item? Okay.

1:36:24 Then with that, I'll go ahead and bring it back at least for a little bit further discussion from Council if anybody has any comments. I have a few. First of all, in the, and I know we can't speak of one specific agency or one specific concerns, right, of occupancy, but when it comes back to Planning Commission,

1:36:53 I'd like to see that there's some way of validating whether or not that 60% occupancy rate is a true occupancy rate if it's going to be considered as part of the benefits that relate from TOT. I'd also like to see that there be some kind of a discussion of this. It does concern me that there's some benefit from having additional rooms from TOT, but if those later become sale units, there's a huge benefit.

1:37:23 to the builder of the condos and no payback to the community for allowing the density to get sold. And that's the sticking point for me. I'm not sure how we can deal with that. And that was my first thought when I looked at this is, well, obviously as a hotel room, yes, there's some additional TOT, but if you can sell the units, there's a huge benefit to you having built them that how we can wrap that in.

1:37:50 If it's not on the table right now or if it has to come back, if they want to sell them, I don't know how you figure that out, but that's a concern to me. Sure, let me just say one more thing. And then I like the idea of being able to use it within the district, but I'm a little bit concerned about having it be a transit shelter or pullout on that part of Old Mammoth Road where we don't even have a bike lane that's more than this wide.

1:38:18 And so I don't know if it's the appropriate benefit. I would also be concerned about the amount, but mostly because of the amount, because of the sale. So if you want to answer that, please do. It's actually interesting that you brought that up because at the Planning Commission hearing that we had a few weeks ago, the same concern was brought up in terms of the condo sales. Why we have continuously stated that our intention isn't to sell the condos is because

1:38:50 First of all, even if we were to sell them, it wouldn't be your traditional condo where the owner would own it outright and could do what they would want with it. It would be treated as a hotbed, which is under the definition that staff can provide to you in which we would still provide room service, we would still provide the same amenities, the rooms would be cleaned on a daily basis, it would still function as a hotel. Secondly,

1:39:16 In lieu of the conversation that we had with the Planning Commission and the ambiguity of whether or not the condo sales actually benefit us, we went back to EPS and had them do another additional professional analysis on the condo sales and where that brings us to in terms of revenue compared to the added cost. And I don't know if you've been provided with that. I think it was sent out about a week ago.

1:39:46 So you might not have had a chance to review it, but it actually shows a negative return compared to the cost of what we would be selling those units for. So again, our intention isn't to sell the units, it's only that because we're building brand new units, it would be prudent for us to have the flexibility if in the future, when the market hopefully does pick up, or if there is a demand for it, that we would have the ability to do that.

1:40:15 Alright, so then I presume that would be flushed out more before it comes back to Planning Commission. Yeah, absolutely. It's unfortunate that you didn't have it in front of you now, but it's only because our Planning Commission hearing was about two weeks ago, so we weren't able to get that in front of you. And also about the occupancy rate that you mentioned, that's based on our standards going back the last three years on an average scale. So we can...

1:40:43 Provide further analysis or we base it off of our own. And that's good to know and should be some way more clearly stated without getting into anything that's proprietary because that is higher than our total average. And so, and I understand you are a unique type of a property, but I think it's one of the concerns is to ask, is that a realistic occupancy rate? Right. And when it comes back to planning commission. Okay, thank you, Jill. John?

1:41:14 I just had two things. I just wanted to state that the underground parking feature is very, very important to me, and I appreciate you going underground for parking. The other thing is I have had actually relatives and other people that I've talked to who stayed at your facility, and they're very complimentary with their stay there, which is an indication to me that you run a very professional business there, so I appreciate that as well.

1:41:43 I just also wanted to add, sorry, about the understructure parking. Because of the hardship and the way that the layout of the site is, the only way that we can make this feasible for us is to do understructure parking, which also in turn makes this a much more costly construction job. And I'm sure you're aware construction in Mammoth isn't particularly cheap.

1:42:12 Just because there aren't as many supplies readily available, or this is what I've been told at least. So this is part of the reason why the margins are so slim for us, especially as a mom and pop ownership. It's just my brother and my father and I who's running this, and thank you for your complimentary comments. If there is good news on the underground parking, it's the location because it's essentially filled dirt.

1:42:41 In there as opposed to some of the more rocky areas in town. Oh, they'll still find plenty of rocks. Hopefully you'll be okay. Our goal is to bring some more light to that end of Old Mammoth Road and instead of making it end, have it be more of a pit stop. Will your focus of the new buildings be to the south, to the Sherwins? Yes, yes. We're going to try to...

1:43:08 Provide as complimentary views as possible to the Shirtland Mountains, as well as have it tie in really nicely with what Rock and Bull is doing. Oh, good. And Matthew, I thought of one more thing, is that it's an intangible benefit, but I applaud the fact that you're using this plan to make up for the fact that you've never really had adequate parking for what you have right now. Yeah, well, it's unfortunate because the land that we own,

1:43:35 That we would like to build this on is sort of a dirt lot in which we've been using mostly for snow storage. But with the help of our architect as well as staff, which I can't thank enough, we've been able to sort of put this plan together without really asking for any variances at all and having this be feasible all on our own site. So we're hoping for your support in order to make this work.

1:44:05 So thank you. Councilmember Romney, do you have any other questions? I'm supportive of moving forward. No other comments. I'm supportive of the project, though. Okay. I just had a couple quick comments, questions. One, I wanted to say thank you for stepping forward with something new and sticking your neck out there a little bit. I know it's tough right now. And certainly appreciate it.

1:44:32 A couple concerns I have. One, timeline for construction. Did we address that there, Jen? Is there actually a timeline of when they propose to start? Assuming, I mean, would it be a year or two or looking? The reason I ask the question is this. One of my concerns would, would this be completed by yourselves, the owners, current owners, or is this something that would be sold off?

1:44:59 And the reason I ask that question is because if it gets sold off as a higher density project, the crisis obviously goes up and it makes it more challenging for that to actually be accomplished longer term. So a concern of mine would be, one, that it be completed by the current owners versus sold off. Two, that we hopefully, assuming this goes through planning commission and council, I'd like to see some sort of proposed timeline.

1:45:29 The hotel versus condo thing that Joe spoke about I think is a concern of mine as well. When you build a condo, obviously it goes to a fee simple ownership type product. They don't have to rent it. I think you can try to put stipulations on there, but I don't think that you can actually put a stipulation on there that it has to be rented.

1:45:51 In either case, I think if we're going to look at CBiz and community benefits, I think one of the benefits to this community is the fact that there would be TOT coming back into the community. So for me, that's a bit of a sticking point for me, is that there is some sort of TOT benefit that's predictable as far as it actually being a rentable unit versus something that could be taken out of the pool. Another concern of mine, we're talking about seven units of density.

1:46:19 Seven density units for a cost of about $6,000. So basically we're talking about a developer paying $800 to get seven additional density units. Pretty good deal. I'm not saying I'm for or against it. It's just something to think about. It concerns me in the sense of the precedent we're going to be creating. What about future developments? Are we going to be doing 22% over current density on every single project?

1:46:47 I'm just going to be looking to plan a commission for some sort of justification as to why we're doing it. And then my question, and I didn't really catch this, but it looks like you're doing about three units per building. You just said three buildings? Or there's two additional buildings, is that right? It's three buildings. They're all of the same configuration. Each building has three units.

1:47:13 Okay. It's resulting in 12 total rooms, but only seven rooms would be over the density cap. Okay. Okay, so about four per. All right. And those are my only real concerns. I mean, I'm really – it sounds great. I like the idea of somebody moving forward with a project, but those are a couple concerns. I'd like the Planning Commission to at least ask those questions and perhaps address them a little bit further because –

1:47:42 Those are the only things I see right now. With that, I think we have some, I guess, direction for staff. Does any council have any, is there a motion on any one of the options? Just give direction as we've stated. I'd say we... Well, I presume if we just provided input, do we have to do a motion? Well, we have an option, one or two, but just, okay. So it sounds like we have some direction then.

1:48:12 As far as thoughts of council. So just to help us out and help the applicant out, it sounds like the direction is that the preliminary proposal is worthy of consideration by Planning Commission. We just have some discussion points that we'll have to talk about with Planning Commission. I think that's how I'm seeing it. I don't think we want to make a decision right now as far as whether it's something obviously we put a stamp of approval on.

1:48:41 I think we've all pointed out areas of concern, and certainly would be, we want to see something move forward somewhere, but builder items of... I think what we're talking about is option one, isn't it? Yeah. So I'll move for council adoption of option number one. Okay. So we have a motion for option number one to provide non-binding input as to whether Mammoth Creek, in expansion, see if his proposal is worthy. We have a motion. We have a second. Second. Okay, we have a motion and a second.

1:49:10 So, let's just go ahead and do roll call, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Okay. Motion passes 5-0. Thank you, Ms. Joaquin. We appreciate it. Let's go ahead and move on to item number 9, transient occupancy update. So we'll go ahead and turn to Cindy on that. Cindy, my role.

1:49:41 So the item before you tonight is to seek some direction on a few TOT items that are kind of hanging out there. So in 2009, we began a TOT enforcement effort. And part of that effort was some educational classes that we held, several classes over the summer. And anybody that attended those classes could request an audit.

1:50:08 Any period prior to when those classes were held, they would have had TOT taxes, penalties and interest waived. So the Lodging Association, there was 23 remitters that signed up for those audits and we had staffing reductions and didn't proceed with the program. So those, Lodging Association is requesting that those 23 remitters that signed up for those audits

1:50:36 Be able to have their penalties and interest waived for the period of time that we're auditing now, which is January of 2010 through December of 2012. That's one of the items. The next item is currently the ordinance does not allow the tax collector to waive any portion of TOT regardless of the amount. And we wanted to bring forward, there's some cities that do allow the tax collector to waive

1:51:05 Negligible amounts. For example, the city of San Diego will waive an amount plus or minus $25. Mono County will waive plus or minus $100. And so we want to find out if council would want to consider a policy of this nature. The other thing we have on this is a long agenda with a lot of decisions.

1:51:29 TOT certificates, right now we're in the middle of upgrading our software program for the collection of TOT, which is allowing us to collect more data to provide to our lodging partners and John Urdi. Part of that software upgrade, we're upgrading and including more information in our TOT certificates.

1:51:55 And we need to reprint all of our certificates. We're gathering information from all of our remitters that have so we can tie every single unit that we have to our property database to figure out exactly how many units are out there being rented. So we are requesting that council waive the $23 fee for the reprint of the certificates for each of the units.

1:52:23 And lastly, the Lodging Association has requested that we bring forward and ask Council to consider waiving the collection of TOT for the donation of rooms for our local events. For example, they donate rooms to Jazz Jubilee, and our current code requires that TOT is collected on any amount of rent, and rent includes

1:52:54 A value of service, money, goods, anything. So if they receive in exchange for a donated room, a space in an advertisement, they feel that that's difficult to measure the value of that and to pay the TOT on it. So they're requesting that the donations of rooms for our local events be waived. Does anybody have any questions for Cindy?

1:53:26 Yeah, I have one, and Cindy, it's on that final part, and in the financial considerations, you say that the cost impacts for these local events will vary, but there's no estimate of how much we would, quote, be losing if we didn't have it. I don't really have a way to measure it. Okay. We can measure it without the event, it would be zero. Well, yes, I know. Good point, John.

1:53:58 Any other comments, questions? Just what is the total amount? Do we have that? The total amount? So there's 23 people that you would be waiving there? They're requesting that we waive any penalties or interest that would be discovered in the current audit program that we're doing right now. Okay. Previously, the waiver of tax penalties and interest was only for the period of time.

1:54:29 That was prior to the class being held should they be audited. They weren't anything after they had actually taken the class and learned about how you're supposed to collect and remit TOT. That was not part of the original waiving of tax penalties and interest. Nothing would be waived after they had taken the class, only prior to. Got it. Thank you. And we don't have a number on those either, right, because we probably haven't done the full audit process.

1:54:58 It would, first they would be put into a, they're in the pool of people that are, we're auditing, you know, several people now. They, we've got quite an audit program going on with our existing remitters. Okay. So they're still just in that pool and we're only asking that the penalties and interest portion be waived, not the tax itself. Okay, got it. Got it. Okay.

1:55:23 And the reason, I'm sorry, the reason for that is that we didn't get to the audits as we had planned to when this was originally adopted. Yes, we hadn't gone, and they want the educational type audit. They want to, you know, if they're doing something wrong, they want it pointed out to them. Okay. All right. Any other comments or questions? Okay, what I'll do, I'll go ahead and turn it to the public, see if there's any comments or questions out there, and then bring it back to council. So, this time, is there anybody in the public that wanted to,

1:55:54 Make a comment or ask any questions on this item. Okay. Seeing none, I'll go ahead and bring it back to council for further discussion. Yes, John. On the first section, the educational audit amnesty, I'm supportive of that. Okay. On the tax collector waiver of negligible debt, I would recommend that we follow the Mono County current policy and not refund taxes that are

1:56:25 That waives and does not refund taxes that are less than $100. And on the waiver of TOT certificate fee, I support the waiving of the $23 for the TOT certificate reprint. And I also support waiving of TOT for donations of room for local events. Okay. So you're saying item number one, you would put a number to it of $100? Is that what you're saying? Yes. Okay. All right.

1:56:52 Okay. Any other comments? Just like Jo, you have something? Yeah, I would agree with John on all of those. I think that the one area, though, when it comes back to us on the local events is that there's got to be some kind of a way to determine what falls in that and what doesn't. You know, that it's clear what a local event is. Local meaning in, I believe. Yeah, well, you know, whatever it is, yeah, that it be a little bit clearer so that then

1:57:21 When you set it up, you don't have then people arguing, well, mine's a local event, and mine's not. So you kind of raised the question that I've been thinking a bit about too, which has to do with comp rooms. And I don't, you know, John, maybe you can help us a bit with this. But one of the things that we do regularly is comp rooms for, you know, writers' workshops and various interests that we want to come to town to do things for us. And oftentimes our...

1:57:46 Lodging community is very generous and willing to provide rooms for them. This ordinance requires TOT to be paid on those rooms, don't they? No, it doesn't. So that is an exemption. If any value received, TOT is due on any value received. So if there is a true comp room and there is no value received by the remitter, there is no taxes due. So what's the difference between a comp room and a room given to a musician?

1:58:14 If they receive value, like tickets to Jazz Jubilee or advertisements, the value of those tickets or the value of that advertisement, TOT, is owed on them. Okay, so I'm just trying to get this clear because there are other... So let's say, for example, this coming fall we have the big bike race and there's going to be, you know, potential comp rooms.

1:58:38 And rooms that are going to be provided for lodging for pros, for example, that might do endorsements or other kinds of things. The lodging industry needs to know which rooms are going to be TOT required because it sounds like it can get very confusing. We want to be able to have events that are successful and not discourage those kinds of activities. I just want the council to understand there's a little... That's kind of why I said make sure it's real clear. Yeah, there's a little twist here.

1:59:08 How would you like us to handle those kinds of rooms? Yeah, that's actually a concern I had on here as well. I like the idea of it, and I think we should be very supportive of having comped rooms, but my concern is creating a loophole somewhere. And, you know, at what point, how many rooms do you comp? I mean, if they invite every single pro up here, maybe we want that, I don't know, but at what point... We do.

1:59:34 Yeah, exactly. I don't know at what point can they get out of control. Other communities must have faced this. Yeah. Can we check with some other communities on what they do on this item? We'll do some research on that and come back with something clearly stated that you can make a decision on. Thank you. Well, it has to do, I mean, while we're on the side, it has to do with the receipt, with a trade. That is the receipt of something of value. In exchange for. So, for example, I mean, look.

2:00:02 If a hotelier who could otherwise rent a room comps it, there's no revenue to that hotelier at all. And so if the hotelier happens to get, you know, a couple of tickets to an event that might be worth $50, what the current ordinance requires that $50, the value, which is $50. The value, the $50. The TOT is owed on the $50. I just, I think that, I don't see an opportunity actually for much of a loophole. I don't see the loophole here.

2:00:32 I think because I can't imagine that in exchange for the comp there would be a significant trade value or a value of services or something else received. Well, I think the concern for me is that if somebody comes in, they can say they comped the room, but perhaps it wasn't truly comped. Oh, different issue, yeah. And I think that's the problem I see is, oh, we comped that room and, you know, or we traded for $50 for the tickets.

2:01:00 I mean, I just think that they can get a little fuzzy there, and I'm just, that's my only concern is... Part of the audit process is tracing, you know, deposits to the room rents, and there's a trace, it's traceable to see where the income comes in, what their reservations are to their tickets, to their deposits. Right. Was that person they comped it truly associated with the event, or, you know, I'm just trying to be the devil's advocate on it. I like all of this. I think as John presented it, I think it's great.

2:01:30 I just want, hopefully we can narrow that piece down as we move forward. So. John Urdi, Mammoth Lakes Tourism. Let me confuse it a little bit more with a couple of other examples. You know, for us, we have an opportunity. We have a great opportunity to bring in writers, for example. We don't know if the property is going to be listed in an article. We don't know the value of an article. Yes, we can say, okay, they were listed in one inch by one inch square, and to buy that in the New York Times, it would cost X.

2:01:59 The other piece that we have is we do promotions. We're doing a promotion with a restaurant called The Counter right now. We've developed a mammoth hamburger that's all over the state of California, and they're doing this great promotion where we're doing a giveaway with the Westin, and that's exposure for the Westin. We needed the promotional room, so how does that get treated? Because I don't know what the exact value of that promotion is. So I think those are some of the, not necessarily loopholes, but I think some of the areas that we need to look at when we're talking about writers, when we're talking about

2:02:27 Wholesale tour operators from Brazil. We have somebody come in that's staying in a property because we want them to sell the property. You know, there is a benefit or a projected benefit or a potential benefit, but we don't know necessarily what that's going to be, when it's going to be, how much it's going to be. Same thing with a writer. You know, we had the Boston Globe in here over the Christmas holiday. They wrote a great article. They talked about Petrus. They talked about, you know, their experience in lodging.

2:02:51 You know, that was a comp room. How do we assess the value of that? So that's, I think there are some of those places that are going to be hard to truly define outside of an event. It's easy to say if Jazz Jubilee says we'll give you a quarter page ad and a quarter page ad is worth $250 and they gave them three rooms, then you have a $250 value. But with an article, it's a little bit more difficult, especially when it's a, you know, we stayed at the Westin. You know, how much is that piece of an article worth?

2:03:19 If the whole article could be worth $20,000, how much is that one line worth? And, you know, I think it just gets down to splitting hairs. Okay. So just to confuse these a little more. Well, going back to your example, then, why would the lodging partner that provided that room be willing or wanting to pay the full cost of that $20,000 TOT debt? Exactly. And it really benefits the entire community. Okay. So, you know, so I think it gets back to what Cindy mentioned, which is the audit.

2:03:46 You know, the audit itself requires us to look at the room, if it's vacant or if it's filled, then tracking back what was the purpose of it and where's the money resulting from the deposit and so forth. So I think the audit will take care of a lot of these questions. And we'd be happy, if you'd like, in some future meeting to go through the audit process. If you've not or don't know much about that, I know some of our council members have been involved in some of our TOT committee meetings.

2:04:15 We're happy to come back and show you what the audit looks like to answer some of those questions you might have. And while we may have some properties in town that are willing to donate rooms just for the good of the cause, most of them are looking at it from the exposure standpoint. So if there are point of sale in every counter restaurant across the state of California, and it says that you're going to enter to win a chance to come to Mammoth Lakes and stay at the Westin and ski at Mammoth Mountain and go snowmobiling and do all these other great things, that's the exposure for the partner to give us the room to be part of that exposure.

2:04:44 So, agreed. Okay, thank you, John. If there aren't any other questions of counsel, I'll go ahead and ask for a motion. John, did you want to make this? Oh, I'm too busy making jokes. Excuse me. I'm too busy laughing at his jokes. He's not that funny. Joe? What? Are you prepared? Oh, excuse me. Okay, well, um,

2:05:15 Okay, let's see if we can get through this. I move that we approve the extension of the educational audit amnesty approved by the town council resolution 0932 for all remitters who signed up for that program by October 30, 2009. This will waive penalties and interest only. Past due taxes will still be required to be paid. And we direct staff to prepare an amendment to the municipal code to allow the tax collector to waive debts of $100, right?

2:05:44 Up to $100.00. And approve a one-time waiver of the TOT certificate printing fee associated with the implementation of TOT software and data collection upgrades. And finally, that staff return to Town Council with a resolution and further explanation of waiving TOT for donations of rooms that support local events. Second. Okay.

2:06:13 We have a motion and a second. Can you roll call, please, Jamie? Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Okay, great. Thank you. Motion passed by zero. One question. I just want clarity on the 23 remitters in the amnesty period. That's for January of 2010 through December of 2012. And it was there. If that's your amnesty period, yeah. Okay. Thank you.

2:06:43 Okay, we'll move on to item number 10, and we'll turn to Town Manager Dave Wilbrack, please. So this is a fairly simple presentation. I'll just make it from the chair here. In the past year, we've been putting together a log of actions that the council has taken where there's further action necessary by staff. So I think it was at the time Mayor Bacon asked for this to be done, and we've continued to follow through with it. So this is our...

2:07:08 An update report to you. There's no action that you need to take, although we're interested in any input or comments that you might have. We're planning to produce this on a regular basis to keep the council up to date on what we're doing and what you're doing as well. Okay. Jo? Well, I have one suggestion is that with everything else that we have going on, the very first one about writing a legislative platform to me seems to be something that would be such a priority that it ought to just come off the list.

2:07:39 I say that because that implies that we're lobbying and we're moving forward and we're not doing any of that and won't be for a while. I think that the way we've been handling things like the Casa Diablo issue or some of the other ones is writing a letter when it's appropriate rather than taking the time to work through setting up a legislative platform when we're not going to be proactively pushing for any legislation is something we can't afford the staff time to do.

2:08:08 Okay. Any other council members have a comment on that? No? Okay. Dave, did you have a comment on that? Okay. Okay. That's the letter I saw you over there. Okay. Any other comments or questions on items on this? Okay. Yeah, I think it's fine, Joe. I like having this personally. I know I had, I think, two people from the public.

2:08:34 Asked if we could have something like this just as a snapshot so we could see what all is happening out there and the progress. I remember when we first came on council, Mayor Pro Tem Wood had mentioned one of the actions I think we asked of the Community Development Department was to ask for a timeline. I think timelines are so important to ask for only because some things can just sit out there and loom forever. I appreciate it. I think this is good as it is.

2:09:03 There's kind of a big one on there, too. Bankruptcy. Yes. It should be the whole thing. We have larger font on the done for that one. So was there consensus to remove the legislative platform? Well, if you want to, I'm fine with that. We don't need to make any more work than we need to for staff, so I'm fine with that. So yeah, we'll go ahead and remove the legislative platform.

2:09:32 One item comes off. One item. Well, actually, several will come off because those that have been reported as done will come off. Sure. Like the bankruptcy. Yeah. Okay. Good enough. With that, we'll move on to item number 11, which is also the town manager, and it's relating to the airport commission and mobility commission. Mayor of council and community, I do also want to apologize for perhaps moving into this thing in the way that we did.

2:10:10 We certainly were doing a lot of things last year, and I think what happened on December 26th was one of those moments when I actually was elucid and realized that we had not contacted any of the commissioners. We were just going through so much so fast that I sent that email out, and I really probably could have and should have called people, and I apologize for that. On behalf of the council, I think that's the right thing for me to do, so I do apologize to Sandy.

2:10:40 Eric and all these other folks that were frustrated about this and we'll try not to let that happen again. One of the things that's come up a couple of times, which I think is important to talk a bit about, is the workload of the commissions that exist now that they've been working on and future things. What's going to happen to that work? My thinking is, and we can talk more about it, you can give us some direction, is those people that are engaged in it would probably like to continue to be engaged.

2:11:08 The difference would be, from our point of view, is that we could use it on a more ad hoc basis. Sandy Hogan would be my go-to person when it had to do with mobility issues, and I fully expect her, knowing who she is and what she's interested in, to come to us when she has mobility issues. She's not going to give up on the subject. I'd be surprised if she decided that I'm not interested in mobility. She's going to come to us. So that would be a person I would want to talk to and keep engaged in this process. The intention is not to dump the entire workload onto the Planning Commission.

2:11:37 They're busy people. They've got their own work responsibilities. On the other hand, if there are things that they could do on behalf of the council within the work plan, we could utilize that. So I think there's a sense of being dynamic going forward. So I would, for example, if an issue came up and the council wanted something done with it, where we have naturally just gone to the Mobility Commission or the Airport Commission, we would probably call it the Airport Commissioners.

2:12:04 Or the Mobility Commissioners and say, do you have some time to work on this issue with us? It's a task force. It's an ad hoc committee. It's going to take a couple of hours to do it or may take a couple of meetings. We would work with you on it. Some of them may be willing to do that, but I hope that they would. Some of them may have their feelings hurt and they may not want to do anything with us, but we certainly hope that they would be our first go-to folks. In fact, I can see situations where they may make recommendations just as they have.

2:12:34 To the Planning Commission if they need to or directly to the Council. There may be other items where the Council just feels they want staff to do it and come back with a recommendation instead of going through multiple steps that we've done in the past. So again, this is a different approach. Are there going to be errors and mistakes? Probably. The Council may want to come back and revisit it as things change or as the workload increases. Or yourself, you may get complaints or...

2:13:02 We have discussions with citizens who may motivate you to come back and reinstate the commission. So this is not a hard line for us at all. It's really more of a way to try to expedite some of the work that we've been doing. We really just frankly did a quick analysis. I think Eric did a wonderful job of describing some of the changes that their commission has made. But we just looked at the workload. We looked at the calendar of scheduling and participation. We thought,

2:13:31 Maybe we could expedite some of this stuff a bit. So it's really at the discretion of the council if you want to maintain those conditions. We're happy to do that. We can look at different schedules, or if you want to continue with our recommendation, we're pleased with that as well. So we'll let you decide what you'd like for us to do, and we'll take your direction. Okay. Thank you, Dave. I'll go ahead and bring it back to council and see if there's any input from the council members.

2:14:00 I'm prepared to make a motion, Mr. Mayor. Okay, I'd just like to ask the public really quick. Anybody in the public have any comments or questions on this? Okay, sorry. Yeah, sorry. I would move to approve option one, which is to waive the first reading and introduce by title only the ordinance to leading chapter 2.38 Airport Commission and chapter 2.43 Mobility Commission of the Town of Mammoth Lakes Municipal Code.

2:14:28 Okay. Second. I have a motion, and I have a second. Can I get a roll call, please, Jim? Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. And with that, we don't have any other items on the agenda for this evening, so I'll go ahead and adjourn the meeting. So thank you, everybody, for coming tonight.